Backup Documents 04/26/2011 Item #10G
10 G
~
~ I- . I- .
<(u: <(u:
ci 0 ci 0
o:::(/) o:::(/)
a D:: <(w D:: <(w
<( (/)o-l <( (/)O-l
W J Wille... w Wille...
::E: - <( ::E: - <( 0::
cwz cwZ
. C> > I - C> > I _ <(
z ~ i=1-~ . Z i=1-~ ::E:
jjj 00<( C. jjj 00<( 0
D:: m <(1-0::: L D:: m <(1-0::: w
W I- ~:::.:::1- w I- ~:::.:::1- ::E:
m 0 ZO:::- ~ m 0 zO:::- I-
-w~ -w~
::E w >--l<( ::E w >--l<( >-
::::) .., ~u~ ::::) .., ~u~
m m ...J
Z ::::) 1 OW~ . Z ::::) OW~ z
::E tn -lI C ::E tn -lI 0
W W >-1-1- ( w w >-1-1- tn
.!:: ::E: ZI(/) ( .!:: ::E: ZI(/) tn
I- <(1-<( L I- <(1-<( w
<( 0 z~w , <( 0 z~w D::
0 I- - ...... , 0 I- - ...... 0
z ~ ~o:::a , z ~o:::a 0
w D:: ~ zw(") < w D:: zw(") <(
1~ 0 -1-(") C> 0 -1-(")
D:: ~ ~ - ( <( D:: ~ ~ - 0
a.. ~~~ t- o.. ~~~ I-
::E zw~ IJ ::E zWZ w
wO:::o wO:::Ci
0 --l l: 0 --l D::
0 W(/)- < ~ W(/)- <(
D:: 0:: 0:::0::::J . . 0:::0::::J
o will I: D:: o will 0
.,j 0 w u.zo::: :;j 0 w u.zo::: Z
>- D:: 0 ::E: WOw < >- D:: ::E: WOw <(
<( I- COu;Z <( I- COu;Z
...J 0 (j ...J 0 tn
D:: 0 VJ -I(/) 0::: .. D:: 0 -I(/) 0::: I-
0J <( m -l ~ :J, :;j <( m -l-:J z
W w ::2~1- u w w <(~1- w
I ...J ::E: ::r (/)Oz III ...J ::E: I~Z ::E
0 . 0 (/)00
I- (/)u~ III I- ::E
t-J . (/)u~
I- Z ....-. C I- Z 0
Z 1->-0::: z 1->-0:::
~ it: ~ ~I-<( <- it: ~ ~I-<( 0
>-ZI c >-ZI D::
c.. C tn CO:J c.. C tn CO:J ::::)
co 0 . c co 0 .
w W tn ouS W W tn ouS ~
P- ~ ::E: W -l _ > tn ::E: W -l _
D:: -lu.o::: <( D:: -lu.o:::
W I- 0 -lOa c w I- 0 -lOa D::
.-}2 ...J II.. 0 <(00 C ...J II.. 0 <(00 0
c.. 0 <( I-o:::-l U. c.. 0 <( I-o:::-l LL
~ I- <(<(u. U I- <(<(u. tn
II.. I 0:1: U II.. I 0:1: W
W I-Ill~ !: W I-Ill~ I-
...J (/) W - ...J (/) W - ::::)
W WII- :2 W WII- Z
a ...J O:::I-Z = ...J O:::I-d] :E
- W
m :J~~ m :J~~
t2 <( OZI- - ~ OZI- -
I- W-o::: ~ W-o::: C")
0 ~ 0:::(/)<( - ~ 0::: (/) -
w u w >-'<;f"~~ W
::E: '<;f"(/)e... ::E:
\} NWW U W
I- ,0:::0 D: I- \I ONo:::W D::
~ Z 1'-0 ::I Z &C.~oo ::E:
0 ao(/) I- 0 ao(/) l-
. <( 0 cJ .<(0
~ ::E o -0::: C ::E o - 0::: 0
D:: 0:: ZOO I- D:: D:: ZOO I-
0 W wl-O C 0 W wl-O 0
II.. Z oOW U II.. Z oOW w
0 0 zwa:::: I- 0 0 zwa:::: I-
w i= <(Co ~ w i= <(Co :i
I- ~~z I- z~z
W w i= O-l<( .. w i= i:5:::::i<( ..:::i
...J W W ...J W
...J a.. c.. O:::I-(/) L1 ...J a.. c.. O:::I-(/) W
I- ::E OOW D: I- ::E OOW D::
~ 0 >-zl- <I ~ 0 >-ZI- <(
C) I-I-:J C> I-I-:J
::E 0 Z Z:J~ C ::E 0 Z Z:=J~ ::::)
W w i= :=JCO~ W w i= :=JCO~ 0
.!:: 0 0<50 > 1:: 0 0<50 >-
<( z z
<( w Uzo::: <( <( w ozo:::
...J ...J
0 c.. tn 0:::-<( C c.. tn 0:::-<(
Z W W WoO z w w WoO
w ::E D:: :::::i31ll W ::E D:: :::::i31ll
C) <( a.. -lOw C) <( a.. -lOw
w W
<( Z 0:: OZI <( Z 0::: OZI
Uc-I- Uc-I-
:.~.~
10 G ff,_
-I~O ;;tI Z )> -I~O ;;tI Z )>
:r:zo m (j) :r:zo m (j)
mOr "'C )> m mOr "'C )> m
OJrr :;0 3: z OJrr :;0 3: z
oCm m m -0 c oCm m m -0 c
)>Q;:o (J) ~ )> )>Q;:o (J) r- )>
;:OZo m ::r ;:OZo m )> ::r
0_G>0 z 0 0_G>0 Z 0
-< :::f m m c:: :::f m m
S:ooC 3: S:ooC 3:
0 -cz z 0 ) -cz z 0
C Z-l-l (j) 0 -I . Z-l-l (j) 0 -I
)> Cz-< 3: =i > Cz-< 3: =i
:;0 r:rloo -0 "'C r- J r:rloo -0 "'C r-
m en-l;:o m r- m 1 en-l;:o m r- m
)>cQ -f m )>rO -f m
C -f -f
zs:z =i m j zs:z =i m
3: o=i)> 0 C . o=i)> 0 C
=i ::;Omz z ." i ::;omz z ."
m moO m 0 I moO m 0
C o-lm ~ :;0 I o-lm ~ :;0
-I OoZ 3: of OoZ 3:
0 ;:0- 0 0 I ;:0- 0
o )> . o )> . 0
-f enoo Z ~ enoo Z 1-,
:::I: 00'""'" -f 00'""'" -f \ .
:;0 m;:O", :::I: J m;:O", ::I: V\
m -om.J:>. m I -om.J:>. m
m )>(1);:0 ~ I )>(1);:0 ~
- ;:O-m ; ;:O-m
W -IZo -IZO
- S:G>c m . S:G>c m S:
~ r- r-
m-l- m m-l- m
z:r:;:O z:r:;:O C,
z _-I m m -' r- _-Imm r- o .
C .J:>.OJ-I ~ m .J:>.OJ-I m -..,
-f ." ."
m :i 0 :r: -f :i 0 :r: -f
(J) "TJ)>)> )> 0 -0 "TJ)>)> )> 0 -0
r;:O-l ,-. r;:O-l
"T1 00)> C ." r- oo)> C ." r-
0 C -f m C -f m
:;0 Oor :;0 )> Oor :;0 )>
;:O"TJr " m ::I: (J) ;:O"TJr m ::I: en
-< - r m m - r m m
~()o en ~()o en
0 000 en c -0 000 en c -0
C ICOO )> ;!! ICOO )> ;!!
:;0 Z-< (J) Z-< (J)
(') )>-1- Z Z )>-1- Z
;:O-<~ -f ;:O-<~ Z -f
0 S:()en r\J -f (') S:oen -f (')
3: Ooen ::I: r- Ooen ::I: r-
3: zs::r: m m zs::r: m m
m -ls:)> m )> ,-l s: ~ m )>
z 'c _ r .- 0 :;0 c(j)r 0 :;0
~ ;:0 (I).! 0 )> r- ;:0 - 0 )> r-
Z~oo -f "J :;0 -< Z~oo -f :;0 -<
)> mOm :::I: (\ C mOm :::I: C
Z ;:OZ"TJ m ;:OZ"TJ m
c OJmo :;0 IV :;0 OJmO :;0 :;0
c;:O;:O . . 0 c;:O;:O .. 0
)> -(I)m 0 -(I)m 0
r- r-
:;0 o;:om ) 3: o;:om 3:
m -mz "'C -mz "'C
-f zG>G> :;0 )> zG>G> :;0 )>
G>_)> (j) G>_)> (j)
0 - (I) G> 0 - enG> 0 d
)> W-I- :;0 m W-I- :;0 m
WmZ Z wmZ Z
C O;:oG> -f C O;:oG> ~ -f C r
C -":;Ez 0 )> -":;Ez 0 )> cJ
:;0 m=i)> -f ::r m=i)> -f ::r
m ::I: ::I:
(J) 6;:r:z m m 6;:r:z m m
(J) -1-1-< (J) 3: -1-1-< (J) 3: "2
0 -l:r:r c Z -l:r:r c Z co
Z )>mo m c )>mo m c -I
r- S:OOO c.. 3: S:()OO c.. 3:
-rOO m -rOO m
-< )>m-< 0 m )>m-< 0 m
-f ~;:oz -f m ~;:oz -f m
::I: -lAG> m :;0 -lAG> m :;0 J)
m ;:0-1)> !!! ;:0-1)> ~ !!!
(') )>00 )>00 -=:::::::.
z ") z ~
::I: r-l:j (j) r-l:j (j) -
~ - :3:< - :3:< e)"
zm=i :I: Zm=i ::I: r"
?J )>OJm m ~ )>OJm m
-oOen )> -00 en )> ({\
r)> :;0 ~ r)> :;0
m;:o C m;:o C . ......J
_en 0 _en 0 ,~
"Tl)> "Tl)>
!-I !-I
lOG
11
Agenda Item #:
io(,
Meeting Date : ~
Presented by:
LA lTL-lN
W eS e<2.
Clam Bay Site Specific Alternative Criteria Proposal
This proposal is premature for the following reasons:
Currently under Florida Administrative Code 62-302.800(7)d:
A deviation process (called site specific alternative criteria, 55AC) cannot
be proposed for nutrients at this time.
The recent state Water Quality Reclassification Rule
(FAC 62-302.400(12)) provides a process for alternative
criteria for nutrients; however, it has NOT yet been
approved by EPA so it cannot be implemented yet.
Any state or federal alternative criteria must be
approved by EPA.
5T A TE 55AC
FEDERAL SSAC
EPA cannot approve any nutrient state 55AC
until they have approved the Water Quality
Reclassification Rule or state numeric
standards are set.
EPA cannot approve a federal nutrient
SSAC until they have finalized federal
estuarine numeric nutrient criteria and
have developed a federal SSAC process.
Therefore,
~
It is Dremature for the County to develoD the Clam Bay SSAC before the aDDroval of
the Water Quality Reclassification Rule or aDDroval of the estuary numeric nutrient
criteria by EPA.
Completing such an expensive process ($77,148) prematurely would be an inefficient use of Coastal
Zone Management Funds and may not result in the desired outcome of a SSAC for Clam Bay.
~
CoNSERVANCY
Of Southwest Florida
-
Prepared for the Collier County Board of County Commissioners 4-26-11 Meeting