Backup Documents 01/11/2011 Item #12A12�
ARBITRATOR
Our county attorney explained to the landowners well over three
months ago that there is a legal remedy, through the courts, to resolve
this. Instead, Commissioners Coyle & Colleta supported a motion by
Commissioner Fialla to go to arbitration. This was and is a
circumvention of existing law to benefit a group of rural lands receiving
area developers.
Currently, zoning variances are determined by a Super Majority vote.
This has resulted in a relatively well thought out community with a
quality ambiance for over 350,000 residents. A Super Majority
requirement would extend that same opportunity to the 300,000+
future residents of the receiving area.
Change this and you could destroy not only part of that ambiance but
certainly abandon the residents of Ave Maria to the whims of the
Barron Collier Corporation. The special act that created Ave Maria
allows the developer to have control of local decision making that
affects the pocket books and quality of life of the residents until the
majority of the property is sold to others. This could take decades. The
citizen's only protection is a supermajority vote on zoning changes.
You have a decision to make. Decide if it is your duty to protect the
present and future residents of Collier County or help fatten the wallets
of the developers and further indenture the residents of Ave Maria.
V
m
n
3
V
r
--i
m
a
O
X
O
z
2
m
a
r
m
r
m
m
a
z
m
W
a
v
O
3
V
H
X
O
m
C
V
m
W
m
w
z
2
m
X
a
0D0
�zz
m
3 61
3�rn
cD
m z
V)WX
0O
M
a
0 T
O
rt
7
w
m
C
� Z�
f(D
w
rn D
X
r
G) C0
0
m
L,zD
o� °
m�z
z n
�zz
-1 0 CD
m W ��
r) Ln
D
0�3
rn
z
M.4
(�
?
£
o� °
a
0Z0
°
z
rn�z
ao 0o rn
°�
D� No
°OC
-j o
�3z
�
Lr) M
°
m
D C)
zoo
00 N
a
mo-
O 70 rn
X MO
G
U)
°zrn
M
m
3
rn0OD
>
-zl
O
O
co
o °
o m
C:
7
m
z
m
C
n
n
c�
J m
rt
m
m
r ..
G`
of
.O
cD
n
ai
O
O
a
`t
U
Ma
r
m
m
Ma
H
Z
n
r
m
X
m<
u
m
CL
Im
T
A
m
A
3
V
r
m
m
In
7D
O
z
_
m
a
r
m
r
m
_
m
a
z
m
W
X
O
3
V
X
X
-I
O
_
m
C
V
m
m
m
z
G)
_
a
X
v
O
X
r
3
m
v
O
_
m
m
w
z
C
m
m
X
O
C
A
3
3
m
z
z
v
m
O
v
m
3
_
m
A
_
n cn (')
3DO
3rr-�
Nm
MX
-n0
rn ;z
rn
;arn:�
zO
MDrn R
C) G)
D
_z
;azrn
D Z
O
=rN
=W °o
mcow
�Ln
rnzw
�yV)
Oa3
�<z
= v
W En
v
>z�
vr) O
>0�
~z
rn, G) z
n
rn
o
vzO4
3--�6
z "'
C3z
rn rn v
z -I °o
� O V
N
O rn
m AO
L��
ozm
m M
-�I m
3 po -I
Zoe
� r
�O
000
03
o
z
�D
'a
m
O
c
z
3
m
r ^\
m
z
a
3
m
E4-
m
z
G)
m
v
X
J
c
O `
rr �
r.�
r
�r\ I
� n
c�
�3
v
R X
1 tC
e �
U)
n
0
0
v
CL
rt
Ma
m
a
m
Ma
M
H
z
n
r
m
a
X
a
U2
tD
CL
lu
(D
0
r�
v
X
J
c
O `
rr �
r.�
r
�r\ I
� n
c�
�3
v
R X
1 tC
e �
U)
n
0
0
v
CL
rt
Ma
m
a
m
Ma
M
H
z
n
r
m
a
X
a
U2
tD
CL
lu
(D
T
n
m
n
3
M
r
m
m
v
m
X
O
z
_
m
a
W
r
m
r
m
In
O
_
m
v
a
z
m
W
a
X
O
3
V
X
X
O
_
m
C
V
m
W
m
m
z
G)
a
X
O
m
r
m
v
O
_
m
m
.%
w
z
C
m
U)
T
X
O
a
n
O
3
3
m
z
z
v
X
O
v
m
W
O
z
_
m
n
w
70
n cn (-)
3D0
� rn
0 -n0
rn ;z
rn
Ln m
z0
MDR
M�o
0 z
D
Z
�zm
�zz
=moo
r N
=Wo
rn W W
<
zw
rn
M D
T�DN
0�3
'J' z
x
OLf) 0
;a Z
0�0
X00
2zD
rn�z
n
03 03
D—IN
O
00-°4
3 --� o
C3z
m
LO 0 N
O
Z
O
OP V
N
mo-
00rn
���
0zrn
-M G) En
3m
rnW
z >�
0 0
Ow
rn co
n�
O�Z
cF
M
I
rp
U2
V
0
z
3
m
a
G)
z
a°
_1
- 3
r
rn
3
m
z
rn
ma
m
m
H
z
n
r
m
X
rm
m<
a
m
CL
m
ml
ml
�lr
T
S;
m
A
3
V
r
m
m
rn
O
z
m
a
W
r
m
r
m
zi
O
In
_
m
a
W
Z
m
W
a
v
O
3
V
X
X
O
_
m
C
V
m
W
m
m
z
G)
_
m
a
v
0
m
r
w
m
v
O
X
w
Z
C
m
m
X
O
C
n
O
3
m
z
z
v
m
O
v
m
U)
U)
Z
m
n
_
w
7D
C) cn n
3D0
3rr-�
� m
0T0
0
MPOz
�m
z0
j°D�
rn
Z
�C) D
_z
�zm
�Dz
o
=rN
=M °O
mco W
Ln
r;
A D
7� D cn
OCz
z o
op
;a Z
0�0
z
rn,z
rn
> Zo Nj
00-04
3-�6
Z
3>
D
m
Ln 0 N
Z -I
O
�pV
rnO�
O0rn
,O
Ln
�zm
M��
3rn
�
rn W
zpD
>rr-
�O
000
O
z
I
X
cD
�a
T
(D
3
r
z
z
m
ol .
� v
� v
X
U)
O
S
O
0
a
G)
z
a
rn
r
rn
N
•
3
m
z
v
rn
I�
1
1 011%
L� A
cD
3
y�
u
fD
ie
c
a�
V
n
�i
1 �
S
0
o �
c�
W
c
a
m
m
rt
r
m
m
H
z
n
r
m
X
u
Q
m
CL
a)
IMMI
rop
m
�J
Q�
I'r
A
m
n
3
r
m
v
m
0
Z
m
a
00
r
rn
r
m
m
v
a
Z
m
00
a
v
O
3
H
70
O
S
m
C
V
m
W
m
N
Z
G1
S
m
a
v
O
c
rn
r
w
m
v
O
S
m
m
w
M
Z
C
m
m
0
C
n
O
3
m
Z
m
z
v
m
v
v
m
Z
S
m
n
S
w
ncnn
3D0
3rr-�
� m
U)
n
Z 0 rn z
V) m
z�
M D
C) G0
Z
D
M Z
�zrn
�Dz
z
�<O
= r N
=ED °o
m ag w
rnzw Ln
;D�
0�3
-I 'C� z
m o
Up (/)
�
z-<
oC)o
z
rn,z
rn
> o
moo°
3
--16
z "'
C3z
EnM
N
Z --I o
0 V
XD�
0;0 M
m A
U)
ozm
v G7 cn
3m>
for-
�O
Om co
O�
zZA
m a iG) m
13
m Z
a G)
m v
� 3 m
r
rn
O
Z
r
�.1
a
v°
X
m
�v
n
fD.
3
m
n
ai
G
b o
3
'G
Ma
rm
m
m
m
H
z
n
r
m
X
U3
�D
CL
a)
rop
m
'v () cn ( )
n ODo
3rr
m 3 r rn
3 a zoo
V m �rm„z
m
v 3 m >�
N rn
0
G) G)
C Sq G)D
3 rn n
? _ �zo
m m = r N
m rn W o
r " r) Lrl
z.
m Z �n�
m
-Ci 0�3
cmn =<z
O Wmm
m D W
P or)o
n moo
O -� z z
-I 3 rn�z
rr, co co
W -Z4 Duo
O ;zo
il
M Z 3 O 6 Lri
O � �3z
O m m
yoo
V O zoo
v ;oD4�h
-4 m Oporn
O 0 o rn �O
= O v'
r^ z -M G) Ln
-XirnD
V
M m rn W -�
OD
5.
W r-
m ~ O
G) p Oco
m 0� Ln
X
X Z
m a
m
O
yy
�1
a
U
O
rr
ti �
\ 1�
k
a
rn
Z
a
m
r
m
3
m
m
z
G)
m
L
m
� y
n
4 �
o
Z
O
a
W
a
c�
rt
Ma
I"
m
m
H
Z
n
r
m
ro
a
U2
m
C.
(D
n
m
C)
3
V
r
m
m
TI
X
O
z
m
a
W
r
m
r
m
ZI
O
mn
m
v
z
2
m
00
a
X
O
3
M
X
X
O
2
m
C
m
W
m
m
z
G)
m
a
X
O
M
m
r
N
w
m
v
O
2
m
m
..
w
..0
z
C
m
O
c
A
O
3
m
z
z
v
m
O
v
m
z
2
m
A
2
w
ncnn
3DO
3��
P-4, m
cn
U)0
OTO
0
rnrnz
;a M.
zo
MDR
C G
Z
D
rn z
�
�Zm
ADZ
=Z
�0
r N
=co °o
mcoW
rnzw Ln
a D
�Dcn
0�3
�<z
z o
Co Lo
z
0n0
moo
rn�z
ca co
n
rn
> o
moo°
3-�0
Z
mM
N
Z -I O
p0�
mo-
N
O rn
L (n A
0 z rn
Mc)Ln
3 co m
�
�>
" � r
�0
003
Co
o Ln
LO
z
D,
m a
m m
C a
3
O
Z
n
,l
IS
C
i
i
v
m
U)
c
Mq
a
m
z
a
m
r
rn
7�
A
3
m
z
G)
m
i
A
t A
-� lD
m
(DD
(D
_
ul
V
fD
n
ra
0
s
0
10
a
tQ
(D
rt
Ma
ro
m
m
Ma
H
z
n
r
m
X
rm
�D
CL
a)
�D
H
n3DO � 3 rn r^ ^
m arm y m G
A O �rnn 70 Z
3 a
C OTO rr rn
rn -1 (f) m V m
r
m p = —
v 3 rn D rt r
O rn z = rn
v, z
3 ° M
O p z ,n,., H
rn m n
a � mmy
G0 � n�� r
w
m z 7C D U)
m
G m O <m %p
-n
rn m
m 7o WO o
^ _
m �
>z� °v o
O ono
C A
Z 3 =z>
-� 3 rn�z
o -z-� °moo
0
zo
z 396 _Pk CD
° v z r- Ln -`
G c3D O
O m m Z
N � N
3 O z � C) r'F
V
a oo
°v n °�
O 0 o L A
Ln L�
2 O �zrn
m Z M��, n
-< D
m m m co
A z O
m y ��0 3,
z j0
000 a
n-<
m o� _
a Z U) a CL