The URL can be used to link to this page

Ex-parte - Fiala 05/09/2017 Ex Parte Items - Commissioner Fiala COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AGENDA MAY 9, 2017 ADVERTISED PUBLIC HEARINGS - NONE CONSENT AGENDA 16.A.1. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the minor final plat of Triangle Plaza at Lely Resort Tract "A" Replat, Application Number PL20160003092. I, NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE I 'Meetings Correspondence e-mails ❑Calls 16.A.2. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the minor final plat of Naftal Acres, Application Number PL20160003115. NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM SEE FILE Meetings ❑Correspondence e-mails Calls 16.A.3. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Vincent Acres, (PL20150002012) approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM X SEE FILE ®Meetings ®Correspondence E e-mails ❑Calls Meeting w/ Ashley Caserta, Patrick VanNess, Nick Kouloheras of Habitat for Humanity (9/21/16), Attended NIM (March 2016), Emails from residents in neighboring communities, Meetings w/ Planning Commissioners & Staff 16.A.4. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Esplanade Golf and Country Club of Naples Phase 3 Blocks "K1", "K2" and "H3", (Application Number PL20160003679) approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM n SEE FILE ❑Meetings ❑Correspondence De-mails ❑Calls 16.A.5. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve for recording the final plat of Del Webb Naples Parcel 102, Phase 2, (Application Number PL20160003169) approval of the standard form Construction and Maintenance Agreement and approval of the amount of the performance security. 171 NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM n SEE FILE ❑Meetings ❑Correspondence ❑e-mails ❑Calls SUMMARY AGENDA 17.A. This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve amending Ordinance Number 92-10, as amended, the Tollgate Commercial Center Planned Unit Development (PUD), by amending the PUD document to add specific institutional uses as permitted uses on Tracts 7, 8 and 9 of the commercial use areas, "A" parcels, as shown on the PUD Master Plan; by amending the PUD document to add specific institutional uses as permitted uses on Tracts 16-20 and 24-25 of the commercial/light industrial uses area, "B" parcels, as shown on the PUD Master Plan; and by providing an effective date. The subject property is located at the intersection of Collier Boulevard (CR-951) and Beck Boulevard in Section 35, Township 49 South, Range 26 East, and Section 2, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. [PUDA-PL20150002280] NO DISCLOSURE FOR THIS ITEM M SEE FILE ❑Meetings ❑Correspondence ®e-mails ❑Calls Staff Report, email from residents of Forest Glen Co ier County GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT Gik TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING DIVISION MEETING MEMORANDUM Date: April 26, 2017 Location: Commissioner Fiala's Conference Room Subject: To discuss Saint Andrews Blvd. issues and potential solutions In attendance: Donna Fiala, Commissioner District 1 Leo Ochs, County Manager Nick Casalanguida, Deputy County Manager James French, Growth Management Deputy Department Head Jay Ahmad, Transportation Anthony Khawaja, Chief Engineer of Traffic Operations Lt. Jeff Boyd, CCSO Jaques Pankita, CCSO William Douglass, LCCPOA President Dudley Chism, LCCPOA Vice President Linda R. Jorgensen, Lely Golf Estates President Amy McGoewan, Lely Golf Estates Tony Branco, Lely MSTU Verna Lutz, CAM, Sandcastle Management Items discussed and determinations made: County Staff, Commissioner Fiala and representatives from the Lely community met to discuss the various suggestions that were communicated through Commissioner Fiala's office. Topics that were discussed but found to be nonviable included: • A pork chop median; • Gating of Warren Street; • Posting of`Local Traffic Only" signs; • Posting of"No Through Traffic" signs; • Use of cameras; and • Use of additional speed tables. Memorandum April 26, 2017 Page 2 of 2 After discussion, consensus was reached on enacting the following solutions: 1. Speed limit reductions to 25 MPH on St. Andrews and on Augusta Blvd. (June 13 BCC); 2. Installation of Lely Resort directional signs on Santa Barbara Blvd. approaching Rattlesnake Hammock Road that will be installed by June 1; 3. Installation of a multi-way stop sign on Warren St. (June 13 BCC); 4. Installation of delineators approaching Wildflower Way to keep drivers out of the bike path that will be installed by June 1; 5. Installation of delineators approaching Warren St. to keep drivers out of the bike path. This item will be installed by July 1 after BCC approval of the multi-way stop installations; 6. Addition of red flashers to St. Andrews Blvd. approaches at Wildflower Way and Warren Street that will be installed by June 1; 7. Addition of red flashers to Augusta Blvd approaching Forest Hills Blvd. that will be installed by June 1; 8. Refreshing of bike lane pavement markings by Road Maintenance will be completed by June 1; 9. Selective speed and stop sign enforcement by CCSO; 10. Creation of a project to design and construct the Saint Andrews approaches to Wildflower Way and to Warren St. and identification of funds in the 2018 budget. The project will start by creating design concepts that will be developed with the help of the community landscaping committee (or its equivalent). The design concepts developed will then be presented in a public information meeting to the community, as a whole, and further community input solicited. Design elements to be included in the design are: • Curb extensions • Brick pavers approaching intersection • Landscaping, • Crosswalks • ADA Ramps • Evaluation and the removal/relocation of speed humps approaching these intersections. Schedule: • Project start October 2017, with the start of the 2018 budget. • Preliminary design and public input, January 2018 (during season). • Final design June 2018. • Construction fall 2018. dlais teptesents the undetstandLrn of the attendees at this amain,. 2f thete any disctepancat, please tepott within 7 dale of the tepott. 691 From: Linda Coyner fruitnflowers@gmail.com B Subject: map for GERRPST*AR Date: April 24,2017 at 12:13 PM To: Rita Pyrdol cioiacenturylink.net i put gate to allow the parking on the Warren sideake sense? r : : .m4 T_t te,* „,„. ., .4‘s , ,::....re t--.4,, r, , _ E .. - -ti.... -,-1 ., itt,„' - af " _ fir+ q, ...d wgE . 1 \s,,,,......1,1 - ' t — , -I ' -- '-' r 0 ,i, iY E � 4 r 'ted 4 ' 3 w. yo- .,--- I 3 Ski" CT.• 2 ' ' A '' , _ , . . 2 r 4, .,.,_ ,,,, ,,,...,i,,,..::: 0 oc5,..),,,,,.co ..i--cr,DJ 140,10 ,,,,, . „frti ,s,....0,,,,,_74,,,,,r''''''":" ' ''';..t...:6', :: :1-77- 14 • - -; 4 41zv '. k" - w 7. -"‘ ; , - Y- *. t .. near Naples — Collier i 00 j CD LLL..L ; I CI 7.7 i m j _ C I 10 0 6366�P B PdC I CI,. 0 Gulf Coast Little League Park Dixie Dr' /y��a 41 confederate Dr {t f�oh, f (ti. c. C.;2 SN C2 c\t (�` " � o1i Ct \-1`(' C3 �2 2p (er \\() SZ d b �y2 0 Napoli Ln -0 ", NAPLES MANOR �� `�r o Raintree Ln \-1\2 C .-..\ o o Maple Ln 4 �,\ a5 O` L Cypress Ln o� q"' O 44. \K\ ). t, Myrtle Ln 9: ,\''''ro„ ` r, F <s,e 41 f Q se r 0 0.25 0.5 miless�, sr Eagle Lake ' �sp h� Community f 1 r r �. 1 of 1 ., go bing maps Notes — ).r iPLEWOf1L VLELVI LAKLS East Naples Davis Blvd rIAPLtt S VetS1 CROWN POLM1t NAHHONAL GOLF CLUB g Fa La Kt AVALON lAL-•� WOOL., d )I -ALN O 964 v Lely - ROCKEDGE 951 Naples Manor Lely Resort t,r_-0,,,,,-,I fi f i.S 90 l dna Belle Meade brei REGAL ACRES 14-1- b ; bind y 2:17 1.lcrosoft Corporation 0 207 HERE co V 3 WATERFORD s U ESTATES O� Cr Y C o, Riviera E m Golf Club e O RIVIERA GOLF v The lords Way ESTATES Polly Ave Marsetie° ROYAL WOODS GOLD& Everett St COUNTRY CLUB SHADOW WOOD Royal Wood Golf Course HUNTiNGTON WOODS WINDSONG Naples Motor Rattlesnake Hammock Rd e64 SIERRA Speedwa' Lay PALMS OF NAPLES COLLEGE PARK MEADOWS Ph -ons Royal Palm Country Club d Reponal-Collier o- Blvd y `' LFL✓CDUrv'TR'/CLUB C'` Rondo ySouthwestern 'p rB v Stare Collier 9 `7 c 'Pon' ROCKEOGE cc Hibiscus Coif Club , t7 .. E" O J ss Andre`e $1.40 `a,r.gC'c Classics Country Club v T ArM, ai � Sabal Palm Rd 4ti `ec 9c• C�3N l't'ridflower ly- ` oy r 31 i' 'o R hKgh 6- LELY RESORT CI. to R UT r pNates M a o e.hoot . Grand Lely o y Si C a Shr>nL'�o, Ley Resarr ltav a o . Golf&Country er/o r ao Club Cr ti� 0 WINDING 5' t',.., ° CYPRESS TREE TOPS Ley ' '-/ Eagle Lakes a t°' Community Pork n n 2500 feet 500 m re' 0,- 02017 HERE r Anyone who worries that the traffic would then be a problem on Augusta or Grand Lely if these plans were executed, removable Jersey barriers could be put down first and traffic counts taken. Lets have stats tell us what to do,not conjecture. I am sure you all are aware that at the Collier County website under "Transportation Planning Section" there is a part called"Traffic Calming". Here it states that a "problem" exists if in a residential area, there is "Daily traffic volumes greater than 2,000 vehicles per day." St. Andrews has almost 4 times that volume. And that count was taken in April when most seasonal visitors have left. Surely, this situation requires immediate and drastic action. We propose the gating of Warren Street at St. Andrews, allowing only emergency vehicular traffic. As a group we feel that much of the traffic volume generated on St. Andrews is due to vehicles exiting and entering Warren street. Warren Street was opened to St. Andrews because of the fire station. The building is no longer a fire station but is a storage unit. At one time, Warren Street was closed for months for repairs and there were no problems because St. Andrews does not supply the most efficient route for Warren Street area residents. From Warren Street, by using one of the 8 exits onto 41, residents can travel at 45 or 55 mph to their destinations, north or south respectively. Then by accessing Rattlesnake, they can travel 45mph east and pick up Santa Barbara. They should not be speeding on St. Andrews which has a speed limit of 30mph. Please execute this plan and stop the bloodshed. Foxfire community faced the same problem and gating the street solved it. We cannot wait for heavy-duty engineering in the future. It will be too late and stop signs are producing accidents not preventing them. The motorists who speed were not deterred by the speed limit signs and won't be deterred by lowering the speed limit. If we reduce the total numbers of motorists, we will also be reducing the numbers of reckless motorists on a street that, because of the proximity of the houses to the street, presents a situation that allows little room for driving errors. We are neighbors . . . out there,close to traffic,vulnerable. Please save us. f Thank you for letting us petition the Board.. The obvious root c se of our probl= is the failure of Planning and Zoning. Now you and I have to deal th it. Please excuse me III sound angry to you. It is displ ed anger. I am not . gry with you. I am angry with myself. I have blood on my hands Gerri Jennings died on our street, St. Andre Blvd. on March 28 017. She was hit by a car that jumped the curb, knocked dow94 mailbox/lamppost . , still had enough forward momentum to kill a person walking ow the sidewalk and two • a er people had to jump out of the way. We remember Gerri. We are Gerri's ST*AR. Star st., ds for ST. Andrews Rescue. We are 50 neighbors in the greater St. Andrews Blvc1 area. Will the members of Gerri's ST*AR please stand. Thank you. ,� At this time of day many of our members wor have left for the North and could not join us but I have 9 pages of their emails Wishing us success. Each page contains many emails from differendividnals. New stop signs were installed after Gerri's death and two cars have been rear-ended at the stop signs while stopped. One was sent to the hospital and then released, thank God. He's here today. I saw the danger years ago and asked and trusted people who promised me they would end the speeding, the passing on the right in the bicycle lanes, the road-rage fueled tailgating, the endless stream of cars and huge trucks. But I failed to follow through; to make sure everything was being done to prevent what was so obviously an-accident-waiting-to-happen. And s, it did. And I am sorry. We are asking you to help disperse the huge v: ume of traffic that travels St. Andrews. Ours is residential street only two miles lon_ , 'th 200 homes, each situated less than three car-lengths, some only two car-lengths,,,.;om the onslaught of what it seems are many uncaring and reckless motorists. That number of houses does not include the people from the many complexes, such as Four Fountains. Our street provides homes for many souls. This is my mailbox which can only easily be accessed from standing in the rain gutter of the street. Reckless drivers passing cars on the right in the bike lanes could easily strike an innocent neighbor getting her/his mail. r Streets that flank us, Augusta Blvd. and Grand Lel do not have houses situated as close to the street nor do they have anywhere near the ount of traffic. As measured in April by the Collier Co • Transportation Department in a 24 hour period, St. Andrews had almost 7, 500 v- cies pass through, almost 2,000 of which were trucks. Trucks were not cars with trailer:. One-ton trucks are restricted by a s': on St. Andrews but 18-wheelers, cement mixers, car carriers, huge flat bed trucks • d other heavy commercial vehicles daily travel the Boulevard. Trucks require more feet of ro•d to stop and therefore present an even greater danger than cars. In comparison, on the same day, only about 2,800 vehicles drove Augusta Blvd. 340 being trucks. That means that St. Andrews handles almost 3 times the vehicles that Augusta does. I think some cars coming from Santa Barbara with drivers texting or otherwise distracted, hit the light and enter St. Andrews and think they are still on a six-lane major thoroughfare. They are lost and angry and react by speeding their way out. I amt trying to explain the truly life-threatening actions of motorists my neighbo and I have witnessed. On Halloween, our street is very popular. Hundreds of chili fill the Boulevard until midnight. It is truly a delight! But children can be unmins . of danger, especially on that night. I fear for them. Commissioner Fiala wisely recognized the probly in 2007. In this email to a resident dated February 5, 2007, she wrote, "We hav- always planned ahead to extend Santa Barbara, and then through a cement "pork c direct the traffic at Rattlesnake to the left or right and make it difficult for people to •ccess St. Andrews or Augusta Blvd." I have here plans drawn up by . engineering company in 2006 that illustrate how dispersal of Santa Barbara's traffic was to be accomplished. As can be seen in both plans, NO access is provided to Saint Andrews from Santa Barbara. All that was needed was cement barriers to prevent traffic from Santa Barbara going straight ahead to St. Andrews, instead traffic was to be directed left or right onto Rattlesnake, a six-laned road, widened for the purpose. I imagine our taxes paid for these plans but unfortunately they were never realized. .) ..1"-,. i ..4., ,, . C:i VSY—_',,ma�yy � 4 �p �6N��u} •�� ir : ' €�' ''4. i de*,... i:. v4' tttt* ,. -- 1 ' ,,,,•:;a3, .` „I, _,' - .41. . "'� ;- x 1. t ai ' ' z' es' 4 I .� g�q n. r,�;•: , .. p r" g. :„. r 3 ew J ;' : '7.' P wg 1.x f" ' 4 . ,_ • ' i$� p�. ,'. i y yt $ ' UG.. :.�f�n ti I "4 j qt o From: Rita Pyrdol �i@centurylink.net 8 Subject: Fwd:final draft Date: May 1,2017 at 5:24 PM To: Stephen G. Erickson,DDS PC phen_g_erikson_dds_pcm sr@ e.smilereminder.corn t iia ✓a c*a 4 R.'4p''S icw� 1 ty` =.- ' ii4.,ck. , - \-*'- I4.`1,-'''''.4 :,-,•,,,,f--,,,,,-.:'-.',. - ..'— .----...,,,15,:-.3/4.:5,1,1-..,:i *.....,. - - S , -'_ ,-.:*--,;.;,7";.-,::,:7:-- ./''' -';',.. ..i.1! t ` . .�'sf'.r '` y^' �/{�� ,eta' . �i�¢,: rte .. �' A Y.? �y s_ SgT�l i t sa o 41 y .: b' gig'r t ) �1, �°�r ;fit ; .• t� yr�yyy S§} _ '1 i 'T 1 S 'Y7, If.-;-.]:i 1k x t'` 3t t i i I $; w . ,1, t:.t.,:,:iii.,..-., i'l 1 ir,.... -:...--*-.:_ :i......„*...)7.:..,--is.. 0- li 4 t _ . 4 � ¢ a^ , ,, '". `E _ _ i ` '{f __ 'v's. �� ",. sem^ 1 1 o r } ccnn � � f,'.;:3-:.1 1 ---} O "NN N:Nrrt+'r++r'r1Y}+r000ao.Poo:'o0 s p iR N O t0-00 f(Otl'A X41 N 71,4 0 tO U y t%ii,.) UL:A W NY o 3 ° 0:-.,,O'----- ''''',C,',O o'O:O 0 ci D O O:O::6.6 O 0 ti.,:,.O O O O-O "6 N o w O O o 0 0 0 Q 0-.0..,;.0 0 iO'0 Q 0 0 0 O:o F.!..::o 0-O f N IC Ca. 02 Di $ X A m OND i r 'Ft#N i'4. 1.4 iJ r .Y t+,r'I-s' y � C 4 n m r :,:-.,:,.-:,.4 k,-,,. N'r W-W#+ t0UI.V.4' v r '.• v L) m 3 A rortw•rvto00)I-'0VbrOD1.m 0}V,Nmowvto i- c m rt m Mm }n Q N t r W _i I`c m m v a n n G Ih . f r- $ 3 m ro _ /\ I OD ry ID :-1 O s f '4-5-_-----:-.-1.:•'D f O O O A to 3 N Ot P O O';O,: •:::.:.,<D'o:O O-O Ei-O 'r A!r'.(�.0 0 O‘.-4'-',.::,.:',',..:c) Y 0 0.0 uF , e i } # 0v 3 '.1;;.' .. i ) • N 3 ti)til A 0 c .. f S' N VI j� o O U O N*-4:-'0 N N T7 N 00 A:1.4--,.,0.,741,;171){I!Y 0 r O'O-O O 0.0 O r } d f,.. i - O N ,... C r N k is _Ig kill. to .a N O t0 r�+N 1)�JI'•N'Imp M 1+ r' Z`N r�'+�'r}, N O a a s :}a p r .A .l Jk A 0% V 111;',1,:t.*! U 11-;t0 SIF N(W.:is)`O CO f6thr it.,':!-••i..--0 O 0:N to , 3 tri...-,':: — 3 ; n .p A Y {_ r A N Q N #alt f. -.....':,--'---;:ii.. 7 �."' tD `jpC c N .K.Y Or'IO OD 0D'.[O .FOpC1 UI Op__Ina V W r ` �} o V E+:U m U 7D r'0k-N•fi,1'_Ot SA N t0 W:U OD ut r N W.ut O r (D o I n �' it w au X W Yo F I A w --I 3 o :1' V) 0t N N' r 74A W:,..(44E1,1,1.','"?,.; 0)V UI U :U ,�0%'vtN r W O 0 CD K A U •• o A A iE M tI2;(7t M.:.]..- .[V jOJ'a M(ID M M'UI A M':14-_:::i A VI , U 2" 3 t ' §Y O N d "4 t € r 3 -N n: �}y i a x a) 5 3 W t0 '.° O N s A W d ( N } In O V t r)4.--,.. .,,," W N' r r+'r r-r-r -0 ,p Si-' U V A W al tA;Of `+ to Q W 15-,-....., Y N A 0% t0 t0 N N :r O ,.:T O r 9 r , O g otD (D W rrr 0} i ' f i I . r A `�` '-c-' F }S 1 CI O IO '-5.P.;,:"'fit:O.0 W.W„M-rl N'Di N Q N'O'r 4 M O O 0 O-O VI 4 t t r } a } } { F 7 A ? ". - ut NU OOr000I+;000Y 0 O.'0F+O 00x00'000 O . (p 0 3 D) tri. P r•r �::: [tl o O 0!2'•O ll:o � O �.=0 73;::0 iO;O!i!:�O:Q�O��O�#O;O�o�Q='0�GY OF to to _ f }- 1 , s.,,, E•�_ _ 3 Np }g VF } F A O . O : F f } - of In t,, 0 0 va s-,o oo-oDo.0 o0000O:o iii;',':',40.,.',0 p o o r b A r- i to _ -':.• g. i .ii.,...-:-. N o a Q-oa,o •o -oo.PbobocaoY000000o cn , t }� oaoo_ oE 0 A rnom ;y r , f 000 oV r cr'0O0 000o a GSoR'0000m tt V s: in' `" o O Qoo:;a. 'o`0;0}00 j0O.0.0000-0Y}000C'.O O , Y jo V } r } -I r O • O N -6''''''' N-N N N -W iii:_W N N N N ".N W:W W m +-'` I(I W .H.-:•.-.O 41-W'9,-...;--t0 g'O O'-O W l0 10 W 9:,...to O.. }�O O ,, r,,Y.4 , Y} N O V 7.A O 0% V N co10'NJ NO.t0 41 N Ot N W W'.r,V is, W A t0 V n 0 O t - .-..- - -_ ,--.. -< v Oµ 1 i I I 1 n r,,T, ..1 b 9 o z g.4 0*.8 (71 .. .. .. , i,,,, 9..,,,,,fk.ce iL4:-.P•hi ;-% sr ,, $4,..g.-.*N,,.„-,., ,,, ,..i..,,.. w 6 Ecg ja is 4 ..,e., ..4.-,-...,-1Z.r.,o,.1-.:!•.'-V.-- 8,::z gg z,%0 i-5: z (n ›. c > o , Is) N '.1s) r.,•::x0.1.co Pt T i,...-:,E5 .;5S0 68 ic;ik c' r- C rn m 414 -• i.....;..6 fi=LID a 0 000', cr, 2 - 0 ..---,,,e,rx40 b.,,,,015?,--0 - t:-..?,..--, t,",-, t.,,,,,,,. 4-fi:,-,:, i.,,,,,•:: .. --I , › Et a c)tP.t.!i'° p..% ,.„-..,.;;! .:.,,.....-:,.. 0 o — r,'-s.-,, :..f,...,. qi.....,. tr...,.,"-: * fai., 4-../;`,14,,...:CA!191z,'1•6- c,J pt) — o• a t-Tg, iW,,J:`:igii,'.*-•:=1,--ki.:1 i;tizzi, 441:!.J'Y4c° ..•1-i;. i'.i'j:::eg .7,-'..t::': 1•) Pk:'.. tg2i;3'''Ilit.s2 (4 (.4.14.6i.--),9 ".1': :::--:.:i 1-.24-1:::' i':::';?-•':.!. gt: k;.:•:.. =''...--:''.-.::, r.x > .:,.. ',:.*:13 itigi Id ecil Fp! '.:_,:-.tA ,-,0 I 4 51 i'M Ete', ,-gi: gg: ii:;,.E--:, ....,-:, v, i-:;'4.1.; KAI Ifit Eli i'v,-ZR L'ig -g::::,,:;i! -.:11.:N„,„,'4..,.-t'...*-c.k5k°k-.? 1 tti' ;-..',,.. 4':,.'-,-. 19,--'- ,...,ka.,,o 19 oil): 411_,:t,.. 1;00 eli- 11 .t. .-- 'q `"• i,:i..-.. ...:.:_:,,_„ Ili) go W.-. o .'u,ef.-. ,,'.,N*:.i:." {. , 4i-.ta.`"i:441S,'ix-I,.(4 4i 0 1.,..i..-...17"1 ligi 1...!re'.'ON Xik;LI:4511 cr,iCk t-,1,1 F-.,..-.7.:r: 'r.i.';.,...i' '..1.-.,'.."•-:. ,..2,4,:.1-'1-. OD'*C.k-1;-,-e 0 0t."- ',,,. '-q;'.,,',, 0.:-:',4 ,ts:!'. -'. kif;4' :::-::::.• iv Iii'l W t4 41 2-f!X -.Leil tiTgl !i-M ET> n in I D Ill U Iq4i .!',•: .r.:....::.: = r)1 0 •-7 2:i';:j: iiN ip:'4,... :.:Fs, ,..o....-,- .9.:',:Ld . fi 44.-:f... .i.4.:!;"iFk.41 P);!'-' !".'..-.. Is)'-.-..-'...1-:] 1 , -$.0.,,J,.::.04;co;,P,::P. i.;.:.1:-;•:-.; r:..;.... ., !.:::.--.:;-"--, !--:,,,--: t--• w i34-'.:-', V:4:1-` ,.::‘Nol Ui 0) 1,?-"' n 0 N 41, .:',,, 14 ID.!i-6:j.,.0'' ': I) C ;•-• 0 :Y!:::- ---,..-::-. fl) i',':.,:.! f:---;.-.1i..-:- l'..:-::::::,- ;:,.....,* igk- (.f,,Y:', irei3, ti::•±.:r.i i:,.p::::,': :-..-', „.. i-,,„'----''''_-Jo ittj,:ci ``) 11) ,•,' j .::-.,_.,,,-i.., ::::-::::]:,-,::: -:,::-:.1- -'-P-.-:-. f.-.:Z.:-';':-].-• t'-'4;t:.' i?.?.,'.Vf: ',:-,-,::-- -L''''..,'F...4>;.;'' N n ....0.< i --l' 4,..-'-i,----: tv-i-• NI ..::.., ,--;:i.,-; ::-4V 0-T-a5:,I."';:,-:--..• ),:. n P. -I --.:5r'- ,1::.:. ::-.•,. !:-----.., 6,ii-•tlf P.' k5.'.tR r'af'-f- i'--a- P'.4.•: e,'.i.:-$ t',-.'g i:: x 9 ii. IIP 0 .;65 0 04:0 It 0 W kV `CM Pir3J (ii.-5:.;'• Otill. tg:: j .•?: r.::',;' -i( 2_ E i,, 0, -,-. •,:-:,,,5::-, ,.•,' -..:i.. .t:..:., k.,•-::J ,...1::_:t ,, R 048 1.;:zi.,:::: li-.375,., -"i'--. i-,i,j -.-----::o -'':'--- . ,.- ,:-.--.,-,.--0 ro0 ?..., . /-Pp 0 EZE 1%.:i'I- .q- l'-,. ::,,„i-,4-11 b.)*11-" .-.-C•.-ii''. . :-': -; 0. ET ..a: 00 ti.% d:fi. t, *) 14 !? --0.:i'fr t,.,1i.:;' i:.',* 1:sai• .N.:fi (n 0-, 9 "A -,5•Z'r -1.:'1 to 14.''',i 0 t,;:1--IU ::. e:-.:4 7i g c'o' O '4 'i....:-,..4" Ng;'' g. P). fe ..M RI kts-j:, k:RI --',::;14;,.. titi fit P1R tg 00,0 0i-:f,.° ID — 0 En , = — 0 • ki414,:: ;.§.4.: },---m-:-.. 1:,.- , pA 0 6g 0!,C,; ,'(:1 kig K .i. fel o 2 -.:-.....-S fft. VA ift 0 t45 0'?:,.. tA '0 i'--,g. fat 0 ki.1,.0 Pi-I0 ,n5: P.:e, tfffl',.. t-',4:: t--:-,g!'.i irgA 1.•-_k:',.'_.::: im.' I > w 60 ,_, ':-.....680 r?,. t...t.,,,.;1.--:- ,, '.. -:.'...:..::•.,.']. F..'.„,'. :.-I Ii1tt1I 0c) - :.vpi..,.-g.,'-'FP.,....:':-:-..a,..-U..gn.,-.A5i-,g:...zf:i..a.t,.-.,-,-.,i:.tii..:.-f;--.!:,!. i7.1-ig-ff,_1,i-'i,.-,-.:,E.j::--1,i-;7:-4.,:,.:.g-:,1:k.)7.,:-:.4E!iv:.'Az-,,--.,-:!;-:..3-':,-.Ei.---,:-;.i: ,1r,,,L'i,'..-.:.-.-,-'::,-!-::l:':-ia-._':::...g:-.r,-'i:.:I,:..i,..,,'!.k:-.--'.N--:-g:..-,-:-.-,-.;:..::: ';t-1i.pk;rf-,:,.-.,-,,..;.g-i5,:-,i•-:.;'.i:.t:-,'::zI:iN:-:,,,1'i-:i1.,'_:1:..,.:,-,-:,,,.-?:':H,::-:,.:: . . . -:-.ri?S:i-i:..-.'.•.•. kktmok:,'F,LFi-N!-..i'M-*e,.3--"-.i..:.*';:'1-,:.,iE4:'i...li.;',:,iii,. tr;:iKt!RKr':,,:--,.'-:,-;-:r-.:.:2g,'--75_,-:i:',:,-K:,.:.,i,.:t.:'..:s.-.,:::-.-,J:,_..',,'4:--s:,;•:-;l1::,;-':i.,-:'.?'i-.,':-:..;sr:-:::i!:.. 1-Fs'i,1rvt1,'i-±--:4I--C-:?-?::-,Z7i".:-'',.:,'.df.:-;::..iE:-'.-4i:;.-..:s..,::'--':.,.....'.--- 00gca020• x b 0 0: 0-0 0 0 P.0 0.. 0.0;0v 4 0 W° 90 : 0 p iti R , , 1i- ), ID 0% °' $:o 90 -6 0 0N '5,D 4 ^) i "Va 1 '00:0ek0 s-pii 6 0 p ;, iv P'° , 0 10 01"I0. ,..iko 70 t0610 p0 p 0 = 76 (5 i1 .. l'..-A VE kii Igi fgt. kit Pit NA iii; ji 4:4 0 01(:) CD CD ti-ggi rit,-i ill KI ['ill: go 40#:i.c:1 ° V4 •,.'il'''': ::::. A i9.3- .,3,f14 go O °Ric)2$ iii.i.S. listg tt filit: f----Z.--.:". C) f.;--'0 5),,,,i,°k..*. i-':'i',. r:Vit!- tjti P.'ic, i...',.,.''.Er: c x cj• 0 pg :42.;r4 t ,:i3..y i-,.-;t,, . ..1. vg i.,-iii .„.,,.,-,.:.:,..,,, Er:(IT ,...= f4;.]Yr.,' a;-:i ,::,.-, '-':: 1.,:, ?;....-iie 0 ItE::0 ....-'' "'.'a Wiif ..", 0.-,....r, '':',:: --':;-1.--, -.' .::.'; kti:',"0 i;.:.•! Jae *...:.,..y t .;. .r.•:-,:. i ,.:; !:, .--.--40_.,6 ::) 5? c) ::::','f':.!.. •.,•-•:.:--:.:.:,•:.:- !,:::,,-,:-J. ,'•-:.'-.-E.! i '.,i,J,; ff-ap 01.raf,0 i....qc) ?: T b0 -ii.g c,WY:o-i,95 -f-,:-.,:.:1 R;j:'.::-:. (;-,-;:b k:::-:,,'._ .;::-..:-::•:s-:,-:: T,:T'a .,':.]-:-:•?:. Li:-.:;-1,,,--;. 1,:,::).t ''><- in 0 r*--; 1,..-" E:.:: i....:..: i::i..::.•.: ,...-.::-.-,._:_ '::::,,.:„:,.-:: i:::-.;,g., i,:fi- .j.5-..::',....,:, i.i.±:-iit iNft,-, F.:e7 --,, m i - f;4:: PIP..,!6'.0;..0. •-• i i...i-i.,,: k-......f wo .*.-...f.,:— I :i!,::-__ -5,--,-• vg.4.2,0 00 „..,.1-..,t, im t:,,.-::-, ,,7„,,,0 4,,,.,..;.0 5 a, - ---"--o 0,-.:-- ,--,,,:, ;.--.:.,------- ,..----., ;•:;.,:f -:::-..-:,,-.-.-- 1..-,,:.,--. ,.,!.;--:.-.--ii !::-..-..--..•:.: ',-,,,,-.-r-: x> , ,i bo o c' &0 9 E?. -I ” c. i - . - - --::.o P::: in " P a 0 _: -_..-" 4-:::.-,f-I -'.--:',--g ]:"-'::::::::i. '-i•a: . ,::::,',,,...4.ii...co CI C)C) 9'.. 0. 0 I.,. .-:::-.:: .--cr.:.c):C4f.::•-••• W 0 " - 'o 0--: -- -< v ,..-„,.... _, „.--.,,-0 jtx;o-._.....- o -,,,,i.0 p-, 6 ° ''!.1 I i , 1 i ! 0. I n n r •N rt (n 0 CO -1 z a_ I+I..W.I.i+W.W'1+00000 00 OO 0000 0 00000000 0 00 00 00 O 00 0 0000000 (n r I+00001fl 10 VD ED CO CO CO 00 V V V V 0101 CA 0101 un to N A A A A W W W W N N N NI' h.o-,OOOO 1-I A W 1-.O A W I-•O A W.-'O A W I-'O A w r O A W t+0 A W N O A WµO A W 1-'O A W e-•0 A W r O A W r 0 d, 1 .n 0 In 0 0)01n 0 In 0 to 0 to O N 0 0 to 0 In 0 co O to 0 ut 0 N O to 01n O N 000 to 0 to 00100001 O rY jS NI'4 I-•N N).J ci)N I•N i+N N N N N N I)'.4 Z 0 C 3 W N V A 01 A.W N V 0 W.0 V V 01 N V OI VI V t0 m 0)V 01 I'A A W N N W V O o N 1+O O O N O N W F+O N Z mT C m Z L) D r 01 CO V .O W A N r m A w 1n 10 o m (0 A N w In rn r r- 0 0 0 Cl M N Al N I-•W N N N N N I.N N N r D CO CO a W W N 00*'W A/n A 1+V 1-•10 W A V h+I-•.0 A A A W N 0 1-`0 N 0 1..1-.O Al I+0 0 0 Al H 1-.0 A I+0 A (j) E W g# in F I W A no 01 00 O W O W A Y A A f n 0 I W A A W W A W 0 W A A A A A A A co A A W 'N I .- I 41 0µV ID Cl.0 A CO 1-•W V 0 A CO V1 10 1+W O+in m N 0 t+'D W A to r-.A N A to 0 N to 1+0 0 N N 1-.N V N 0 In 3 E 7 § Q 1 N Y N A V 01V to 01 N OD co .0 V be co V N Co W V A up 1, G t 1 n a fp (o < Z.. . f N Al N N N N N Al N N Al N N N N to I'I'++1-•I•H I.1-'N 1-.I'N I-'H 1-.F.t+H Y N 1-'I•I-•1-.Y N I'1-.-Y 1+N () A W W W CO NNNNn•01-'I.0 CD0010.D.D•000Co03CoV V V V 01010101cn00En44.A 4.to W W W NNN N = n t A W I.O A W I.O A W N O A W I+O A W 1-.O A W N O A W I.O A W I.O A W H O A co H O A W I.O A6µO rt d o V I 0 En O I n 0.n 0 VI 0 V f 0 t n 0 t n 0 V S 0 01 0 t n 0 t n O t n 0 I n 0 1 n 0 I n 0 t n 0 t n 0 t n 001 0 t n 0 V i 0 t n 0(n 0 O 3 < r m O c N N r N.-.N r to..N N 1JµN r I'N N>'N N I'N O to Co TY' a W I-•N N 1-.A N V N.D an In to.0 01 V ul O 01 W O CO W CA N to O W A A 01 I•W.O t0 O CD Cn W In 0]N 1D to V A N O Z ,--1- W OD 3 no c = o_ Wv o � A O 0oo +W V CO cn In CO N ¢ '0 C OD 3 7 N Yr W.+N W N N W W Co A U W A A W A A CO N N N N N N N N N N N W N N 3 .O k'V 010+.w I'corn to V V 03/to InO cocna W 01 W NCO 01 A A V 0•NN W A.0 to 0 00 V 01Mr V to.0N W m 0 U) 1 CP m 33 I' I. • rt' 3 W N In W Oo W O. 0. W O CO O W co 01 O. N .D to w J .0 N N ) i. n 4 N N N W N W N A N N N W A A A O1 D1 A 01 01 A V Tri A 0 01 to A A A A A VI W A W co A W W A 0 N ICO W J co J co 0 W O N IJ W N N U to 0 1'0(I-•W A CO 10 A 1D 0 Of CO A V 00 W CO 01 W 10 W O UST A A N J to W 6 1 to 0. µ N N N N 1' H N A W N rN• I' W W N 10 4.4 V 0 V W 01 O CO 0 N O. V T < (I) 'n < (t) A N 0 1 n o arr. o w E c 0 3 m -4 3 m o o CD 1 0 a N aC A N W O .n 5-4 µ O CD 0 O O N .+ ( ID 01 0 Z 000 00 0 ? 0 03 'I' o SC) li)oN O W v o c x 3 I i Ixm r o 0 0 A (00 "'( 1 O µ 01 O µ t 1 .Ch I„1 F• µ+ Os? R tn m VI 01 0 w w uI y H w o o a 0 N -- W 00 w A 0 O 0 0 0 V 3 3 o 3 `c C Iµ.. o µ Q O Q` 0 CPI INTI -. 3 O µ -- 3 CO 0 10 7 0.O 0 I• 0 N N 0. CO' 00 to a A. 0 T a V o1.-` w B € Ut D T t z °z Ni:N L.N izi L r`}+t 24.C.r r •r 1 F,r• Q d . p}b O $ __ WNW.,"ib O`V'01'J IA W N r:o1•19 ?-) Ot SIF?L'-N Wo 3 C Y O-:a O a .O• o O..:5.• o d-o O O,e,:38 7,O'O.O O-D'O a S N o OO Q'O fit,=O}Ce;O't „,.o 0 0 00 0 o7q[o q;Oo� o tO 7 m m .� } t NO. t NIp C s CV-ii f S -5., t _ .. .. .. - J X n fo A r Et-_--.,1W:sr;:w w irt�ut A •A W.A W A•A W t 0 g ni p} 7 i n ip CO Main �r- .O w WO, i!'1 •P O b w`V O W.,,x N,w v m 3 m !a w b';;0 `s.r,_n:'yO,;t.r w it4 Ns_v a ;w rw�kfra:f'4 1"..::n r " z tv a d c>_: Vis_ t:; m F aa't m xl74 N Wil t.;;- .as ,V==: ,..: 61 m co m m N 1F+::w GAN b A r F7rN 5+`r A lik'O�GFFo b ifigqo Q o us ,e.,4; -t.]gt.i ty....z:f Ill pit,-; vi.,:::,..:, r p, ii rt mat ks-r P4'.-0-• / Z �N y)� y� r, ' }�'' �.y; iF:.�< ' :=: FES: i:� k_:',. _ • f` 4,1-.--1,i i. sad: i'�,: _ ��J�/ }u A i'4°) 1`r N V,::n Wiry,.til'V 4[;W E:.- N O u b o r N v crE:N I:CN V r is>LO w}g A t��V Gt r W VI L @@@@ ate..-'--._. ?:P,.'. ^ r. }: �'�' fi"^` i W 1i'�.>Ni ii f�i�N �cY'-N `r 1!•+'=��..aa'4,4,:,,.... --: 14 N is, w ,OD m 14,H.'154.-44%-..-to-L.01414 ar-;w iii yv.o rA a 1!;Ott 10 P.4" Y-•'+ w i' a N 0,;tic+ - 'b .!:A alt o 1t+.0 u>E;w A A Uk W8.:::,::i'" rU,'i v o : 1q t.. }A d N N _ >:?y = i":-. Y:"^s F?;s L:v" 7. ,...f,-,1:: C w 4o X f- <x` ar r r s r r{ r x`r t: ; 5< : :. W •I 3 �_ e N to OD N GSW! i?<A 1,'1`4q�.,r `NA�Y`w A XXdtlsw if:o L� t:-z :�> w p O ear ,( L in o •A zn -WI"' V` 0 £0 MI;;Ci?r,';', 3tliN T1 b op_ti MN V:'::}O ui : n .0 'v 0 NJ 4 t - ":• ``' _ ^=id 's i.-?, f_ S '� - P-33. ms:- E^:; ,,,,,•:, :i» _ - _ 4;': n (1 El tal ' �'' f:'t':. y isi:; A n +'S A _ ft r p.4ti ,3: r tT Da l:;:s Y? 5 p W int - P...!! � -' ��= w N t Q To C o13 W .i O V 1 = r r't/D W(�`A ;W IV r ,Nr `a '^ r ` A m is FbA�.(O N F :N 4k r N ;� O :w .:'.N{ilito o n (D p ._, ` : 1 t O • _ _ `='• #'a:,< ... -..'.: n p �... to 01 a1 ~=N O 1G 'w r W -�W tocsW t, S • ,..„.._,: . ... p",:',:i ='-'-'i F.' I"'i Kr.l''.4:: '1':-.Z.,-,- Ki.;'.,,S 1-7A Pke e? i'',�w: Ill 0y� - i t..,-.i., r.f ti r::: n A 0 A .,-. ...-..-'z'O RS3o i7Ei0 CL O x'%N f: .•o,'_'A.i'�,:0 =0 O O �0 1.:*.i.`.�r a e el ‹-.,...5, i '`,+":1 "_ Ems, - k.§1! - l Y. , € O 2, , Fes= _ {_ 11.4 _ r }}F�:{EX�'' €i` _ H? f:: nN �¢ - 3:�' Si" t 4::'_,_ 111 x x• O O 0'O::q ,0 'O O Y "O O `.0 5i,4 YY,::O •'�..,-�O to to s >» a; N >:: cA _ s -` ..s`: r em. '��::;. ill tit c, w 0 0 "0 '0' O fo _ f'▪i; .�'5=;' s�!p-t=-:}4 R� !,a 0 t11 w o 0 aEo o o o R%o o o,,P..!o o `o Ck:q v- N 674 _ ' _ E'C�== - -:m, =; Imo' - _ A0 ,w 0 i k�` - V to ,) ) \.' V • o 0 0 o fro+a.:o 0 0 0 o ao'o W0Yo', ,-.::..0'o 0 0''0 0 r:.:n: g : t,:-...4..„! `-.':. G' Lam... kms=: �,- 1 4 r • 0 0 :b'o b-a o o'rssd 0 0'0 0 0`o*:*._...,c, O Q;OboO-:o o A • .>'. p ` } �r oo \ N 1•J N N N NN N N N w N NN all}�f Ni i3 N Ii1 N N N y 1Aq�r CD O6-V 0104 V V:V at CO,COAO b-b b-OD:alp10 go-,.•O1Fb b.iO cl V 0 N W-a}a�.u,Y- V[-H'a1-A 111 tr OD,N:Tti..A .:r;0b--- V 1410 . q - _ < V A .• P.- n 2 s 0 Q tf, -,, iii,t,t .,,.,•,,,:,.':: _, t„r:.,:,.i a, .ti (.:...,,I,:t ,-:iti i,y,r4q. sf.,i. : . .. ,:go 1,,,in ,,:tp; yks „vm iigt LA,...ao mg If•J:.•--: ,10LLw'LR.. a....'8 4 z ...-1 > 0 > .f:'!.ii,. 'al EA ik:1! 4-7,-.4, ...0.6-ajb 4: ? ...gr6'ell;pt.:,t:•-•Lsi,': ,:g.ri.li ?::4:1 W I-,1,17-..53..;01 1.4:1.. 61 c)ga 8 s,.•‘.1t. ki,."%ri ki.47, ISif.l?': '-';.V:. m g ,''.'-'.1 N.1 k tcji MI P?Pzia kiti8 ta. ° ,:-4•, i'''t! itl ki2 k'it, ki-T1 Z1, 33 * a, ,„ t ii KR ttu .e.i--..it ,::t.i mit, g z t,,I.:,.,.?..,. .,._.,,,__.,...75.- k.-.i.'7.;g ticil 4...i, i;-kii tn c° ._,,, g •.:ics ,.,,,'.1 V.,,t=3: P:''' k"4.44. k4S.i ?.i:.'kz:i 'F.* '.'-'4") -I r- a• - tiiza! L'i-.... MA iT,',:.1:-•: Fixi ik,,,i ...,..1, !6ti.,,A; ,i.,.,.,: z•-.:1-- iii.W; :1-', ;','.'`:.; ' .! te...'....i;4'`0410 arj:.ft`n Mi. f* ,,ti.,. ,....,,; uku%Ifillita` m5:0 4*.:• ,...,.i7g, Efol:•?-4 5$.r,,:.: , m o !.k..;!! 1.,..9,.,*in .--,,g,i te.....?, r.,,-.:: I •••1 701- c..- 4:-...4•:i -....$A k.... F4 .,,,,.% i-.LA,.i '4:1-A iN ir-4 i 0, mt tq. v,:t.:, c,4.,,,,,, Pf,',i'.-! 'i,.:•-i.i,. ,.4-;<•".' tf'i:-.! Pao t,..40-,:::1 r i ff..,..?....i:-.i ta..c.--..- tizi,-3, ..:.,,,..-f," .c-,.,,,,.,,, .';.F.T..,,,i. t.;74- OP':' .111-.7;0..,„:,..-Ei t's,Zi;,;• t.,:-.:41 Daiii -I C-) i .''if; mti t$T..:.1 EV Mic; ij 0) .,.-.3k,...,: ,..,.... ..! ..-, ,",1.-... fr.5., '....,.,...,; ="•" I ....f:_s.. >,..--'t. ...,..:‘,. ,,,•:•.,,.-, i...93.:.:-.4 ..:..5......:-! 'ESS., F.!:,::7'...5:' !.•,.::',.-. M - ,.,'-41, 4., i.iTitl 'At i!iiS N ataj C4° o §-• t-,-'7.:-:.0?Wit -ej.4 Kt ON Or4:". lSf.?"'• u,,,q''..;ta 41,41'4 iiki--; 1 i1/41 I.4 •;-::. .! !..:::-A!, ,: RI .,,nst IA iwt•I..„,,,.....)_...to i4 iii;k-ts•V.,:: f-.,n k-1t.,..,4 VA e...,..t.§ tt.4,:t n ,,,A•74.0 119-A - .ii: 144 On! c;4 o f, 14.4 ."1 0.7.77, t?-.'4 ?.:--1 Ftt .7. 1 tn ,,.-z,;.. -•--- :.1:.F4*.Pt t.tf4 :.:.. .:t-3..- .:1-k4; .r. . la,?gt E:...;'.-g If-;:;S:.:i- IL7-f.rTi ,...- .,..„,ti ,f.p,.,1 ,. .A.„,". .V:, .„.....„ „.:„..„, -:-,.-:.A --,:z: . .! -.'f,tr.:ri: -,filf 0 ,S }-.E,4;1•: r.1,,..; ',.', ..-,*'?.. Z1-37,-,"•. 2."• ,,,"""'1:i *..-."''',-! '.'- ra-z IIT:','4 -I t ;-• It tT Zig_,PD M lak 'tli'z lit tit. st,.: tit ,.., IP, CD i I.) in ,*.NJ -.,.- .*T..,• ..,.....„,:, •-itr. V.:,-;:.--f:i -.,,..7. 1-'7--,A l' ' Oz:•-• 0 --I 1 VO LT-ti‘. V-A -4.Y iic?.t:----.t 1?-.1,:; -,-al i*--kim. et:a. ,--,*, NI - j:-1C-'2. V36:igR! '-i-ff: ''' '..,1z ,.-3i '•:.:!-k: r-31!.,R .,tZi W 1...• ';- 5: ,S1'::, m NJ cl .t.. o•--1 ,..1 i 4;3:it gy,.:ii -.':R gif441 grz. .t ,,ift; 4-i g w e-F, oti3 Eliz > -'.'=V :51.1.: Rt.:1:- 'A '''''s-:KI k:/-"ift tft ;: "'''.4 x 3 0 •- Fi 3 cu ...41:g t-'4,---, [-6*-S 3- -.. z-Wl•:±0 tti ffik LK:+ 1-44Z., 1-.'4'-; !RI kjf..:: ? 0 16 -'is•L' I% tko Pi-,2)-`1 N !. . git: i-lor% fr,:i.;':3 oxl tx :.-,.1 aN 5 E?;i-,; Ike..0 F.„..„ u.:.;-,,,. k _ k-,,;:i tizfi.c, - ti) n 0 0 I-. At°W11.! Vfni '-tli git ke i. ;4 .•:'•gi '':-4':7':- P ... 0-'-'1*•1°'''''''.5'4 a.. Cir I NJ -I, ,„•:,.: . iM4 '...fir.. ''if•a, - .,...--, F• ,...: ,„,,, F.,...., ---,.`•,-,...•1,-.1-•.=.,-4 op NW...4 ..: i"E!,-,-,, t""4Z, n fT) ;,.',,,, r: a-':?•7 . (j)4, . 5; -I 5 r-t g, ..,..T., .7,..,y, IT,1- i'?,:.:',5, )> n f,..,' , j 0 C ul = ,.... p. ''''' ''''',,, ,W.,.?.-.".I.'4*-•44 i...,...Z: r21 t,,,:.:, ,,,, ::.,. .:„.„..,,,,, , ,.....:, . _ ,.. ..,.. ,,.:7-... k.t... h.-a irgA ..,:,:f k....4...' iL,.,....',::a 6 (1) T- I-- .-,.-,....-4,; fi.i..5•-•,..'•!:si,..!.• z•....-.-.0... E*-.14 42t:ii!i ..:3?...i ,,z.i.i.; f,?..........iti" re:•,:::::0.....•!.-..' (II = - V 5 m P../ 00 il'•..;,;NI,,,.:-atiZ iwk Kw i-:-.3.v; ..-..z...,- k.a.,V fr,,,...Ei 0;Ck.i. If.:..?.:::,. ELR .i•-,1.,..,„ t:7,! W-,,, Lt rit., t.41.,. .wo_fr, tim ,;.-4 .0 '4g r...,2 ,,ift, k:i3 1,-.:-0*,..-,1.-fjg_f..':',i EI45 ..;7; ff)A A. .Q i':::-.:-Z."* 2.."7:1-: t,.._",.:....4 1 0 r4 ._.i.,k ki-Ar: r. ji', -5T':-7.": 5> .1.354.. ff..s.Z. ''''.:?i:' fit*-z co,W"re ,:-..ft E4.:;g, ....6 •• x -it ?,:r.:.-- 610 tit.1- .-;-.--zt, [-54-1. :[!'z-.=,: . ':-.:' ni FE CD 0 tlis 0 kt:0 4 tATI ri• P.41 Re gtA 1,-44 g 4. %- , j•••• •4 .,..It V.S;,.! Fit 41 kti {at ift A 1. trA R4t-; kg tit°.ft a- 3- 3 fift t* kft ?tn,_ ,,.-„,,,,, ,..---,:.„0 ip..-i.:0 Sv,,,..5 p3,1 t,5.: fa:Fiii;, :,,ff:;K4 Etiz1: C - if--it w,o,_._.,, .,: F.,kt..,,,...1 k.-3..A, Km ,i-.,,,,, r.:.,,,, .:-,.,.z,. _ii- .. ,,L-., f.% M. f- ',. k-;.E$-,, 14 1: ,t ki3 LLSf'• 0 o ra, fi7;f-.2i c5...-g. Fe:4 41,1! '-ta f',..*: b c) ..% SI [-..t..Ri til kV 1..-.=.,yri: 4i tn 4.'-'t'pl 6 ,a-,..-,:::4,. tl-f., p-4 lit-1. E:?tt-zi kgitn „, 1,.,„. } : ,...4.1 II,i*tn RI M lit 'et 11.4 MI Fr?<' ..7..,., t_;i!...-5,?: 'eft„,,,,,,-• F.4.:-.1-- fig...3 :'.,.,:,..il iri.,&a ,,‘.:-:.,3.7.: V.,...1-2,•.; 1.-g4.. pli -at -,'''''': fr.;:1:4g gist :-.6g;0 0 o to g5li .:0 ko mi., 1 in 4" ggio R-. Fero_A*°F-4 c.% ia...=:21.1 '.i.it C7 CA 1 11. MI g re a.wx 0 m ttt VrRi.: M la kti; 2 :-„,,, ,,,...f., - 0 - .4,„ ,, ,. .F,,,, r, (TX ,--,..41, E.,..,_:g ,41,0 6)„....,.. t.;,-gt; 6k.,:z.. p..k ...,3,,,,,it --c-r.:i,,, •'K iii-ar a W.cag: °iil titl t.4.. tfi. IN itt ri11 Mt ci-.-'10 kk.io b 0 t.4.i „-,1 ifo Plv rt 64''' reA0 4;:° A -.,... j-.. ..?. tr:g1 ti,:::,..:' • ti•i---1 igi ilr4 WI tI.Vi fatt 0,%,°tiTit civ Ki-: ;:-:i °' , 0 0' #:0 t5--:-A t-,f'.. ,,T.if !'j..,.E.,:': 3 D LT:1-ii- g''4‘0 0,2 C.M ::::.:: F--4 2 L- a iii.0 0, RI izTi,1 rag -:-E:;-I-:' b c) IS.4 ii4 tit: `4.!:? im: t;;-,-4:.;,, i-..i„'-'::: -,,,,-,:::-i. ko iR.;0. __::.i.: •:::-,:g in 'Vii '-''''''-.-;.: ti.--N 11*4 obi e#:-k°f9.:': :--:-:':',-:-,'•':': 1X-!ff,:;: fi% iir.•-•_;•:•-:.i:-:::i _",':::''-':::''- '',.:':;:i.it-', x ,-;.- • 1 -1.til kll 46.:f!:0:57A7- 1-P: ''.01.,':' .:-i,' 6;..?,i'., kig:. •i•t;:, i4.--g W.: ;-7.(T. -O0 Oc) b r ..... i„::•...A ,f8.1.: -. ,;:;:,'it.-:: i.:',..--:-.,-,.., 1::-:.-,..:,--: ;,,-::,-F-2:::: 1.3...i. gf•+,,,0 eki 0 iir.,P D:ti, v 0 ..".,--:,...-:. `,..z.F.ir, t.,14,-. i:'.y;6. '----. ,...:••-•:,: f..-,.„-,.. :„;,..„0 IA..., )63 ••• .--:':-0,... ::: .fi.V.,. t,,:r.'..4E g5.::::;,..t q"?:•-!:•• °•.‘ 4% ....1 .....0 Ilk f.E;7:1•*, R-':",t1 1: :-.,:.:- ti,„•:.,.::-::1 b-ji 0 R•--; t::::',..,-.'l'.'• ?,:"'4 i..%.1 P.a: N'.-S X 1. :0 IP::::0 . ti-7..* ;..-f f.',...:, c 5.< 6" . ,0 7:9,.,: ., k".kif, ....f...fE: i':,1a:.:: , ,0;97. ,.-.; i;,..1-z.;64 1.,.:..,,F: t:-F- : o 0 0., 0 ......;;-0 0.... P,.....,i .:!al 1.--:::".•-: a c) • 0 . ..,:'. .t6.:.:r: •„:':• :Frr.r.',. :.,...•0,"•:',-, v o r •,..-.I. 1,.t.:1i :, trI.,. i'..":,•rr-i vo.-....ia...4',11 .< Eil;z f.',.s.:*k:J:i , ..... ,.-......,s,. ..,..k,, --.,-, ,, ,.: •::.,ki:,:. ,.,,:,- ti.,;f0 R.e.gEi, a • co - co i 1 ,-• • F nno m o .-•.•.• a �`0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ,, F p Y F..Y00001010 0 41 W W fD W V V V V TOt13100 of In tnA A A A W W W W NNNit, 0000 A W Y O A W Y O A W Y O A W Y O A toO A W N A W O .O A W.O A W O A W..:• 4,C...4-.04,4,1-.0 O d In 0 In 0 VI 0 U 0 in O to O N 0 to 0 W O In 0 In 0 to 0 In 0 VI 0 to 0 N 0 to 0 01 0 Ill 0 In 0 in O In O In 0 N 0 ra 4 A A A A of W to In to A A A A In A OI W In V a.,1 In to W WNY Z ITI 01 co InA W V 030)4.14.14.101r NInW NW WNW10,10,41,-,AID Vt01001AANY 00 NYYNN W W01NNto rn > O --I i 0p n -n z $ N DQ P N Y N N I. 21 m P. IWi1 m ta cu 01 10 I--' 10 W A 0 to rn 1 z IA i IP 133< 1 A A in to In A A In A W co a1 v of A 01014,co told Al 0 0101v W In 4,A Y W a1 0Y0101O N Of 4,V NA 4,I0001 W at W A NYO CO NY h.h.NOYNOA V 4,tn4 V CO i4 N Ah)Co 0 µ ....0 . N V v V A W O i 0 10 0 0 0 Y CO 0 O V 0 0 0 Y N ID N A 0 0 N Y CO a A A W N Y Y Y I. A .N N N 4,a1 10 In Al N A V A CO V 10 O W Y 10 W V O V1 O W Y V A V A N N Y A Y N A N V 0 0 V W N 3 S N 1 0. to N. V O N of V A fil 0 0, N to Vf U CO W co In n 0 -1 0 0 C to 2m D- 1`G N --t 0) i Al N N N N N N N 1 V N N N N Al Al N Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 0 Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 1,0 r 0 Y Y 0 Y Y Y N A .,� W W W W N N N N Y Y Ni Y o o 0 010 010 10 CO W CO W V V V V 01 W W a,co W 1n to A A A A W W W W N N N N rt 6 A Wt'OA WYOA WYOA WYO�PI2JYOA WYOA WHOA W YOA W YOA W YOA WYOAWYO N X d V I CI VI O V I O t o 0 l n O l n O t n O I n 0 L.0 t o O 0/I O In o V t O t n 0 In Qin 0(n O of C IA C N O I n O In Cl I n O W 0 r� O n O 1-1 MI 1 0 (0 0 $ € r NYW WNN W AW A A A In OIa1010,Ot 010101.4 V V CO VOt V CO 0,01 V 01 V 0,0101In In to Alam 0 In CO �' @ W 10 N ID V 0 V O Y V N la N W Y Y O 10 V 0 W 13 to ANO W Y W CO CO A I-+Y to O A 01 Y N to O N W I0 A 10 W 10 C rt � o 1n 3 _. WW V. VI W A 10 V ONi A tT W V O W ttn o CI iiid �Oi Y N W W co AAµW A W W W In A V In 01 CA V V CO 01 V in in W V W V W N V U301 W A In A Cp1 VI VI ^" @ WID CO a1 Nal to W WNW 1D01 TONCO OW WYUA I rt co 0V W0CO W IDN W W,I)r.W W 010 W V AN 7 ID Y Y N N N N N N N rt 4Of W IV+ In ol A Al tW+ 01 W coa co at 0Iv W Y M Y Y Y Y Ni Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 0 W N Al W W to 01 01 01 W W V V W V 10 N Y A NNW W A to A C.N Ni W W N W W N A N Y N O O O Y 3 I W Co 0 0 0 01 N CO W ID O CO V A V V V V Cn N O O Co Y Y T W O N Co N 0 O V W V to Na N co N Y N a1 W VIA a. FI CO i 0. CO In V IW. N O W In In N 11 p PIO of W 10 V 0 W Y ID 01 W W t O011 0 r�r N < rr V) A NJ O 4 C o 3 W C 3 or I O 0 0 ID n o 0 In O to r r O Y 0 O W N 1 P r . O N -4CO m3A0 OAO O] O In 111 CX) V 4 m o 01 n 01 0 n 0 0 111 CO W X(0 vV Al 0 C 10 0 ID C x 3 I I0Wo 10Vr 0 '1 O OO coCA • O ° UN N CC oI-,W Ncc r' 30 t0 o * ID N W N I' o V o A Z d N NI CO 0 W W ID 0 ID V N 03 0 A r 0 0 o 0 A 3 3 3 ,r".. o r w O O. V 17.A Al Y Q In 01 7 O a V 7 A CO 01 7 o.O O r w COO0 0. Co w (Ail 0. CO A A -< V A a . ,, i s nnr- tn 1 si 1 z fARNTIN F+r 'i-w.A.- +:•Y wt-r..'..-Qp...0 ,O:0ppY7`0 00 -'I 4C::N .'.:0;-I 00 {P 1AcA.?Gik:N O+Oi,W zGtt U(:'A N O E ,t,..-'-':ao;;o;c o'C o o-o b o goi. 8 igto' .�.o •`.o i-.o a I 4 n * - o'o_ o O;.0 o;:0 Q 0 Cf.:.:0 t,*: `.�9�-�=o o b:}o�_;o a-o zi a n k: a, I. m s . X n ro V ., f €--:Y -1 z z w rn ra.t:w lil Ai/�wuiN w w41A � yg vK,Y iR t ifl Ol �4 so v s r Six'i44-!,,4,1- W w v O z pp AAA..]] VVV -i N t0 i/t;01 ill UI yY,N�Ol Vl` A O Y = UhAO- Y r '1 { iiiD 1 3 m rn t � s Ag:li r in coi O Y•t--. .•.-.A...-W TiC:W SO4 a O N til A -O MO.b;N Cl-,O O.o ut H 11G �R it' :51.1! rid II 3 S kN.. N O! w N G n W Ol .=`•; 'f�','.;Y W W II W ltzr• " v�Y m Y 9Y- N •O o Ut ,O W t V Q b UR W 41 f0 Q1;10 F W f_�'Ul'�fiF Y W O r,-•.-: �+.Y-r o , ti) k-' O .44 n'Y�+.Y ic'r mit F F_ Y '+ N i'''') W OF g O itf,0 m.O/ 10 i- i t fir .Ui Ai"v�l N O Til-iD F� N O o O A O 1?A`f iiN blO A4+ N'A•Ui .1-_:. N.,,,,}N.Ul:'Ol Ulw A N,10 10 VI , I Cl i ~ o * -I' W '14.•;,,Jn 0 f V Ati'_Y Ss'N N`N.IOW 0 Ut 0;..4-:;:-,1,1‘, N:NN 1 N a1 O r U V W 01 -i UI.o. :r r 1Y O U1.0:54:...._ �(:A O�Y i.1.-,--:..:.:: ,. 'N GF N V s0 VI U!A O';O b V Ot_A OD r W 51.::::!..'" Q N:_-.7"‘..' OD.-,N}+NW E0.V O . (Q , '7 j 3i. p ! o d r Y .. ' w H o �ODn X N w►N-35 w Ar t. � 'a so ao yo Co; a '-,n w r.)1.:::::::'-5.':. i t'“:' n et. bb� ` A N �K W ;W ht r-{><-O r*co"OF F+ UI.W dl=r N N N w A Fn , m �"C o g rii o N N s 3 [l fa 1 w • l',...-:-.; Po ts o j n 7 w o o /. La ! S # .itA w 0- iw O 0 v p U N O N W.43,..m QR.0) UN►r .Yp 1-,,,,_,!..1:-, i.:.--.::,, Vl,W.KA 9 Y '+:O O 7 cl =N O 1 3Etitt 0 V O 51 � N rt DI o :fl VE NI o. H o rr 3 'i-o' 0 -.4:.--;):3 o to r 4• O�.O O a,r�O O O,,:o.........,:.:.:., 4+ 0.P.....:.:0 O_N O Y U O br0 lli o 0 1 'U I m I F O - - 4 '41. V.--.:,.; k.�s D` A N 0 0 0 0 0 0-,9,-;,:m a mon: #.o!i$`o i00 C1O 'O Q o O o o 3 pli ` eso o oce0G;ow ,i 21 oo -fro0.0oo aro :;s: .cn 0 € o o o0At # op oo=OOoOo.bo000 o 00..b,.to. o 3 a na O a+o O O IO O O O O O O'.O O O'O'-to 0 O-.0 O.O .(.o:-.,,o O O OO U7 , #r:_. {_ ' �`:� OR < - - Ea Y'';' E'R's - x 3 h_ b Ep Cl O O O O.:-:-'o O O O.O 0 0 0 O OO O 0 O�O.O O Cl O O O O , 1 N i OF s co n _ ti O O .0:::0' .:.:-•1(:' Y O Q,O O 0 0 0 O':'.0 O 0 0;0„.5.?„-„,O 4 0 k*:-:,,,, O 0 ,: A ` .---------',"::--:-;::j- t., -i r 0 I E c ~ a N N N N'N N'N-N N-N N N N.-.5-'"-:''' :N yd;N q.N t�..N Yp/ at}�,I�,Os D �� r 01 01 101'UI i/i w ih'Ui OL.OI wI V �:V.OD-V�E,V'b0;'10}. 1:01 < r/ N O �D�',D�ih'A GF-:CO q6-V A ip N=_w N-N i+_.Dl iJ�.A :O ijc;.GD a oY o 3 F.• --. -_- G V O1 1 4 1 .., n 2 ' ,,,-s ;), 9 in I WC) -1 •,-:-• CD ...... • -,--. - I I ------ •••••••- ---- ------- ---- ----• -r-------- --- ,-----:: ...,.., i,„...1,_,:. .;:.-:,,„.„.., ..•:•-• •:..,,..,2.] •:,":,:--..•v.-•:: im. f-,.al kg;:;I: ,.'...',:-„---,:::: '...•.--•;:; •:.•:.,-.....,•:.!: co f:r.,A--,-,:.!.. tRI ••-'•-•:r:',:• -•] --:--......,.„ ...,_:,•.•:,.:..].„-:::,-.., i••;:fi•-•„,,,i.i.i r::.t,'-..] iL,:i•-e:, f;:m .:I••:::::-,•:? -J-&-..o !•0::-::: .- ..-.' ,..-•••:.", ••--- ,-_,-„,- :•,. :- --.-'' --I -.,..,. i.,„:,.. ,.„.,:„. , ,::---,--, •"•::,,, •I ii -0-I 6:;:I-:t„4.ivi,„.::;:•,,":."•0- 0,::,:,,-:4.'::-,, ?1•4.1'.:•:,,.-;1-4.-.,fg.,.,-..:.,„-q.;.1:::1.,•-':I-::;i.:-l•::.•-,....-,.:•::-,A:7::,3.--:-I-;!.,t,4....,,7:'...". ;4-,i,.,;,::4.---,,-e,,.„,--.::,•-• }t.1;':kI„.A•.-s-„.!..'.)':q.--'1.'-&.''a:.:.I.R.,g.'.'.::-m0•• •t0-fi:P.(..•:-:•I.:;I.'0* iII',..gI.I...-i..:'-',r::.,r',I,„',;,'.2__ fit*-v.5,t:-:'.r'!'-:--.-.I..,I::--I.-•. t..'-Ii..•••••.I:.•.•'•j••.•':.''.:•.:'- R in w °afo 0a ., i :g)0 '°3, if ,a•3,mio , -6 •0 0 !. : p:0 ',, a?o 9f°g:0 10 0.00 40;6c0 3 0 c) 0 T z-,.>, cH ::,',1 73▪ rn Aff,. ,:::.3i% '.•:-.-,-::_ i---H,---.',:. 'f:.-,-A •-,.,.,-:- -!•'-,-?, '-•-•:-.':•.! f.,•,. .,-,f, • ••• • • g ,A.-,i-i.z .-.;.,:l.1:: ::.,.;'-;.•-.,,,: -,,,,•:.'r.,:,-; E--:.,;:,..,:-.,-:- w:::,,.,. . .f. ,1,4,, (ii-.1 itk L„., ••.>•:.I-. 1•.)....,__L4. 9_. .-- . -ii..!to tii.Y.;1'4,i4:::1.-• '.0:W :,,,,"';'_F, :.o. 0 •,'-'•••••• 0 IT1 Ul C7 tP ...,ji Vie.'cn*/4, ,.V',4;':4) (ii''''-'1.-` Cl' '1 ....1'''''. ''.1.•::. '..g-i la,ii.PY "N v..:'.a%-1.:'....I'°tit•j A io:',,I a 7!77-.---- ,,-,•'• -- I-..§•-•.:-.• ,••••••,:••-•••••• :---.••': cn •.:-'11.1!'"^,,-4.if$•••W4 up tw NJ Pt....14 .,,,•,••.,••••: ;••,',•'•:•,' !-:::,•--•-: •••-•,• -•j P3i,:.•:•'.: •:.•:•:• :: ,...... o ID n 6 0 a A lye 0)Vt,(J.1 1,,f,;:i- •,:*:-)-: i..,:.3i,ii:,; .,.';'i,', :.':-:.:--.: i-:---;i:-:'-: ',:-..4,.'. is.:::::., il-.:z-..,,R 0 3 x ,;:'-'.i:;::5': Ma ;".4-4;t: V5.1 fig% .1-.';;....i.! f.!-.if..!R: 1.'•;,..iii . il.'i:, .. ''...i !.. 1-' 4' 9, -''''', ":"..•.' g..c7, k;.g.,5; .: :....=.cF:. 'T.-'-:', :.,:-,,----:, 0:.,- 1:,.:'CD...,„4 §fia•I' 1;fi,.1,.; k.•:!-•.7 '•--,-,-,,, -k.ir..;-, r"-•,,,-4.• 1•1:,--,...:i, ;7:,:-:•': `;',.,,, z:',A;', z.,.. '; '' ii,-;,if, Wit 1-•4.i...k,0 Fki. -4 io .q t..:i°g.4.,:..'i ER i,I.f.,-- •:•_-•.I .: I-•:::--:::;•.-- 0..-a .,-.-:',r, i:•.,•-!• -. c.--.::„.• „•:'•-,. .•..•-•••••..,.•••••• ,-,., ••.•-,Lr.gc ,',-..--,7;.,•:-..i ;i.,•:,.,•••.::::-, i,-:.-Li.,..,.. :•••,,: ..it,.j.-: .,::.-•.,„,, ...•.:_,•:•,...,•(A.,•.,.,.6 ‘,., .-,1,:i,...,ts),...-:,to ....a'...k f.:.Z.-,..1'. qi.',•.. ...:,-A .:.:,''.,,"_..taha-i0 ,3- A,:.5.. .4!'- A.':4-4.:..'i"iritt 43 it•N`° CD '4 0, .. .:.. Y.-*•.,.',.t.. t.u,:.- -.& 4..CI' ..-cri-::i•(Ti :.•••.f:.•(A C) Ui oo , Wi,.,-",1-.1:,1,4;.•in 3-,CD -,S,„... '•q CO 91-tri :-.--: '''': ,::-:::-,•,':..... t'-;;;.:§. i'.'T:;'4,.;:,. ,:•.,:i. :'-; 1--' tn 4*'9 Ai at t!...- -7:at;,..„,-. ii:•-,:ifi:g- i..:::i•-•.• •••••••••:••: -.-..... „.,,..,.:. ,-•:•'.,4--. l'II:..4':I.. F,::•':-.X " • b op 'iPlil i- ,4 :.:,. ..:„:„ L:,:.,:r....,.. ,,:,-„,, ..:::„._,..:,.:, r-> n-;:lia..-... -f:F.-.:-'7, ,i,i:Y4 rs"...,3 17:::,-!,,,: ''',.':'.•-•-'-''' ,--- ' ' ' :... ,..':', ° X 0 1 i --:-::,,,-. ife'.0 :P.... :: =-: .,,,,, • ...., ,at.,,...4.--&:,...I 0% ta :jak-..P & . e.ui,1 -107',0 ,„-,-,•:. ''''... :.,:1_,..',.f.: 1":-.5. .:.''''''':.:-'-, --'-'::'„'-' -.... ' . .•-• Ca n i,., . 0 I 0 0 '.5:1;i:.:-. 3.".: :":*i K•'.'!:1 ife.4's.":;!. ..'?-.•,:t -.4...:i! ,,.7.::g .-',..,,.-- ;.:,-;-. ii.V. 0.c) P.,..f., -I n er 44..)i*i%4° il, r:e, -... ,..A.',.41;"iiiii,T:0 g:5:44 i,,,: ..-...• i:1-::;:f,..ii Fi4.:' .-.'..• :.:•.:.. n A 3. -, $ 7 0 f-• ,.dck at 0 4° ,f•X3-', 0.1 ii'l',.Q i. .:- ;;. -: Iggi i-.•••:•:::::::- •••-•••••,•• ,''' 0 I F.)* A,. ;61 IJ co •••;.v. - Wg kit aiig Og. fi.:gR krgiR tgli.:.: .!...W.'4 tgi Ir•-,-.:.-k I.'„,,..... -I FE, 3 0 ii n liv i.. :1 R1., !. ff.,;.,.!•;•, ••:-2.1•0. -2:::::•••,'•-; !.,:Ni:.:.,-, ;&',i it ...,-2.5.--4 ',-••:::••J. :;„; 0' SF. 0 vi ..-,i,„•?,..-. -.....,„•4•T ,•,„-•:•,'.. ,--...,...,t,-. „,:----, -----•:-. :.:-,...:" :-":--."•,-• I .1.,p 0!;e:k 0§-1'.° i?, CD -0 .... ,.., :,-:', :,-, k::::,:'-E i•-•'SI A vc.'A-..:... ..?. pg4 iIj-:7•I?::•2:: 0_ . , li-- •:-.--R -'1'--.:1:- rif-:0 01 s4'C!.----''0'6M kgi g:..05. i!Ii:-..:;7 rI•::7 (-) I" , 4 1-• (a :-1. • i..i':-- 1,4 6W.I:co 1..!-:--• 4---••:- -.:-:,•i': " •".-:-::•• r-iT-:.: 1:!,"St Z'f].t.:','";-! Z.-?::F.f ,'.-E.•• VI c° IQ. (7).514 a U) o3 ....,,." tk:,,-- ,,,,, ,,:''''-- - ,---:::, i.,.,,,,:,: Nr-t. ',.,,-,:-, kz,,,,, •:').",-:'::, 5' -, D 3 I - ''''"" '„•"'"' ''''''-:: --T --•---- I.::•-,E..-::::: !••••.t.;-•, 1;7-%.,-:..k i•Oifs. Pa-.. 1:::.4'i.;:- -- '''':--- .'rr-'"'-'-'-' 'I-:-•'•':: - ;- - --- -•--, 0.-F, 4..f. E::,....r. ".-.7.'.-:-..r4:.:: Fii-ii," c in = . ._-':1:- 1,:i.,;f; ,,,E'N'0 13',;::0 M c' cD - Cl) 0 ---. .,:--] ,-.--iF::' , 4':::-*-.gki°M .....-::.,'i fk:%-.5 ti.---:.r '..-:1':', )-• 04,:-.-0 Fir-.- -',.''--n: -:'-'::::.:•4'. 14: 1.e.,::::•.":- 'i:;.::P;-?,..': D - o V ID ci ;Si.§ ca 1/4t*ii Cr , °5% viii.::::' ,-,,i:-:-:1-: ::-:.,-::,.,:j.3.: -_,-:]:,0. .;.:._,7,•::: ,.,,,:E.E..:,.. ,,:.:...-,E...:;:::. w 4,,. i i... 0 tif 0 :....:.... m > (11 3,.......,::::, ..,.-. ...•:: ;.,.,...:,:z.• :-....:. ,,. ,....,,...i. 1-,.., .0--,,;:32.: •,.-:,....c.:. ,...•:-... . i•:•••:..,. r,-,..-..0,0,..:0 re) 3 ..- --,-,...., :•.:2-..., F?:::.],. t....nv 1.,:•• -5,,,,,,-: 13§•.,.,,,, ,,, ,0.....-o 0., ....„,,,:. Lif..V. 1:---i•.g.:. 5......lt ..z W-.,,, Feo gx..zz,0 0.47..,... P-Dg, (D ...; ... re i',..K;',-;': .'.','.0*.i.','0 01F.:-.-:_?a A 0 'gV fA 0*14:0 1$ft-:".°M p-iii- KA gg. 1•!• 4..: i3:g2 42.:.''''::', tfg F'-' ,... b 0 •-a:0 I-n .1-i:'A 101 ii--I4'.II II,•--17g *I-S&.':. .-i:-.I:t Vi.1.•V flif: k.i.;$ vg5-: c › .,,o: ;,,,,,-„,. ,;,:..„,,, ,..„,,...„ i„.„,„ pg.-.:,.. ,..,:i,,.,,,,,. t•,,t.,--:,,. c.....,...,13.,,, ,;b:-Y.. ,z.-,..•:-....,•-•• cr x ..g,,,,,-.7z. 1,,:-::::;,,- Rff;Eq 1,'6:1:,.., :.':;.',.:.: 'z',R)..4-;:, E..:3..c,y. Fii;ffif) Y.--.•,, i*,i.:i 0,--.:76' 0 FC, n7 i •-•41-•;* ta-:3.--: i•IgII:- lea'i Ikt .q.k.:', 4,,K.'-',II-,,,J rial;6),9_,Ir'',-,,..1., ra tg.14, -,•.I.,•.1k *1,:i. rff•;•:fil a',k-7,•.• 4I.'.,-L..,Wr4',T.--.1',:-: - 5'4.* OA 1-*:-,,<:i .L7-:-,;,'* ''-'„ 11 c) IQ 35.g.i !al 0 R31:a Mi:"itt," ai7 i:iii:.i.. if5t0 titg. I-;•••'-IiII. I'''•!:'::•:.. •••••••• F ul 4, U) :P3i'-`1.,:v: 4'::::.f.T"; -:1,-...; 00:.- -,.-.•:i.g i,;',43-.1 :-1iii5: m: •,:::::i..:! ::-•::..'._:.. ,."*J.-..:.: c > --:,.,-74. i'-.fi- .fAr4 i:'AI:4 :....g.,.. fi.4Z 11.-.i....f•YE.e. i'ag. I ,R•1,4-'-1-K,..-jt.f.,.,1s,i--;;.: fp/si!,gg•,•,i7:,.-: --ii".•,...,i-.•:s:-,4 5,, iirs.sgj.r.•.':.-.,-.. g,.t.:a,.,i'4tl5i E'V•!c'',o;-.R.,::l..-:J. i,-!r.-rtz,-A,].`.-'-,T:,.i-;,Zf -ti-..-:§.-.,,-,),;4---•.77):,,.; DtM o ; 1q$ t-.:gA4r-z.•::i:ii:!00 0*000evok0e000,0.004°6P.,i-.t•:F:•:,..,1'5'".',f-..i]5-'::,':.,i.s..i;-..,.":..0 IfW'i:if.•i:-.iZ7.•.-".?-,'.i.;f!7:I..:..i'c.-:.•°1ktr(-,49•:*4•.'•••..-;-*''f--.•'74•iV-••ii.•:ii.••:i1 .;'• ' c00r cXVr, ts...-.•,),-_-... 1.;;•-7,-7- ,-:-f,..k.,,,,- Eiji,N f';',,,, -,,,, <'',..2 ?:,,,-- e....., ,,-. -.....:.,. c > -,,.c5i,- r-.Z.?;"Z,-, 0:-.];:.,1 -:,,:,.,:'g R:f;i!,- a-7E::':; Cgi'al l'a'::::.,,, .:7,-1:z..41 •,..W.:7: ,.„,:- : -i ..:-:. .. .... -iii• 0 45;:i,0...9. '0' .-...• .. .•••••.:,-• ••-.".,,•••• I'-'020- ,,."g. I. --Ii;0 6 1- 05 0 a ka:.-.-=, ,••;:•:.::•••. '•-••••:::::••I• •"--•-, --:-...,•,-,-E •.-'::-I- *0 X:f..0 Ct I',.'-:g '--Z.g :;..4.f.i•.',i.-. iM "......'.. ir.--.. : A i --ev.0 ,,,,, I. O 1-- -,,,,,... .-5.e,!: '--Y,,T,..:1,.: ,A,..:.v. ..,..,;i?-,. if,ia,. 1,::-.:::,.- -m .i..,.,,-, i,i•:,., :',..,;,,-1,1 •;..c,,...,:q 0 _7.i-D- 1 ;:.-..i?..-4., .F:'•::A..z. i;.-...:--....:2 i:,..,;,.: c....s4::::. -..,,:,;., !:..::±:,,..:-. r,,, ,,„:4,y..-.,,, ,,..,..._ -.6..i e 0...., ": 3,,,..".•:•:.F:i z,,,I•f:. ge,.:.,-;. ii1:.:p2.•-: kf.ig.,- ',i.:-#--,-'• .-:•.,:-2-s--- 6,-;,..0:.0-i,0•a'I vii. In ••••.-:.,.., 1.,p:i klii..... Iii.v.; &-0,--,ce.:••---o 0.-.--•° CD -"-•--, i:•••:.. - !&-.,0 0,..•...,-.E ,-,-,."-:,-• -•..--.-;::-E. .5.•;•,:,;1 ::.-i-f...‘;: :,:". Ki:1,..-:: ,, ,E'f• CD : !;CA ,....,... .„---.• :•.......-.„ ,,,.-••-•., ,:•,....,:•:, ...,...3.-.;;?:: -p.:,••-:. F.§..:.q: f......,,. ...., b 0 80•.-•••-•••••• •i:•;i5-,.7.: •.':•;••, ;.•-•,-,--,,•-: 1-:::.:•,:-• -------- ',...--,-"- .•,,,,,,-.•-.-2,. tr:.• ,,,..4.Q .r.i,F?....; ,-..:•::...-•!, -.,> U) „...•...„. -.::.':.§k: •:_,:f:2::i.z -,,,•;•-:',:-•-:.,-, .i•,.E.:.•-,---.. -=;.:.:-.-..::,..-:_. •_,-••!--•.., ,..-,-,:•.-::!'., if* E-j.f..,".i.::, f.rs,...:7:„. !..,". :: x Fi .i.:.. ficii. i,,,-,* .!&C) ,iti,r:1 0 L':ID n) . • ,:',±-, ION'0'i-:$3:'.:0)!;!/..4.'° 0. •,,,:".., i'3,,, .%':', ,-,',---,-:: ----- 6-:::.o ;: ---..:D-.,9:i ig.-.3 FAA': !Zi.'k ..:1-,•-,li-.' v 01 0 ••:-:1..0 ei o P,•.-I-:°••,„„ • •--•'••-:--•'• -•„-„:„ ..--•-,:;-i., --:::-.:• :: 1---:,--7,,, i_q:71,3:i '-.'':'.-5•:-.:_ ',..--",•:.-:.-: 1 b o ...„.,.,:, --- a 1 F.:,,...z pia t-4% lig.3 I'--I:g',:-., I"'-'-',- F---•,:. I-•-:•'-'l.-q IIT;5:_if igi i':-;'-...4-i:I -'-•.--:c) 57 6 •-•-•:::I;-:.-.! -,...,7f.-g:::- I..4,..:.T, i*.-...;1. i-,i-s!.:•,-.: ,-•-'•::::- :„.„--. .-.:,-...•••, .4„, ........ .0,0.g., --I 1-' 0 .- ,... m 0 (A " ''Z.i. i..'1::::,::: :6?-',..5i. 1:::::i'E ':-:•;,--•':-: '.-::t-:-:::.,, i'::::::±--.I ,- ca!tO.,::.a:pr,a,---- ).-• a i.a:if,- 0:871: 6,-,0 p.,?a... a 0/ 0, -< --J I a F-"II o-44.-0--,- 6 0 02 -....- I I ,-, I i 1 git g Inn i m -'iz 01 L r 0 0 0 0 I D 100 t 0 000,03 W 0 O 0 0 0 St a 01 0 W cm A A 0 A W la W W N 0 0 NJ 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Ft l' A W r 0 A W 1+0 A W C)A W r O A W I-'O A W 1+O a W r O a W r O A W V.O A U r Cl A W r O A W r O 01 Win W 0 In O W 0 Vl 0 in 0 In 0 01 0 W 0 to O W 0 W 0 W O W 0 In O In O In 0 In O In 0 In O W 0 W 0 W 0 W O rt E E Z Z to k W'D IO W W W W o1 a W A 01 A A W A A 01 CO V 00 IW W N N O CO 01 to 0 0 V W a OIr 0 0 0 V Cl 0 W IO O 10 I-'r 00 10 0 N01 COCO01 a 0 01 a N I-'I-'t-'N1N NJ NJ' W In DOI 0 N W Z > D W m n 2 g N C A 9 r N v, 1N+ W W NW mC co NJ V W 00 N r F'fl 1 CO O V OI IO CO N V CO 0, N r m s r 0 CO r Q < I W A W A A W A A A A A A A to A A 0 A A CO 1'A N N 1+ 70 % In W Df A A.0 0 V r A N V IO ID NJ 01 NJ 14 A A N W ID 0 01 0 V N W 1'Y O N W I'N F'NJ 0 1'NJ I'A 01 W In VI V V) 1 W t N N 0 44 m 0 A 0% I 44 N' 0 UI V 0 a tn 0 i R n f. r I' F.I-..r rr r r 0 W 10 V 10 0 CO 0 0 CO CO IO W CO N tD O A 1'W V IO F.CO W A W N r 3 W NJ in A NJ A W NJ a NJ W 01 In I''D 1-'I'W W W W CO 0 CO NJ V CO W IO V In 01 W NJ W N A 1'W a W V W IO In V 0 U f. D a € Ct 0 UI 0 a in A o N. n 1 o al n 0 (0 H 7 It < j--i`t 0 NJ £ N N NJ N N N NJ N NJ NJ NJ NN'N N NJ N I'r r r r F'F'r 1+r 1+r I'N.a.•r r i-4 I-4 F'r F'F'r 1'r r F'F'r r1' (n -4. ' ��1 W W W t"N NNNr rr 00001010 IOID CO 00 CO COV V V VOI010101 in Ino InA A A A W W W W NNNN N S n 'YI�( WNOA WFOA WI+ g AOA WrCA WrOA Wra1 Wr0A WroA La v.OA W1-0A WUOA W r0 In O W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W Oto 001 O W O W O W0 W 0 W O W 0 In 0 In 0000 0 In O W Oto 0 0 0 W 0 W O 3 0 03 tu 0 0^in £ -' L 13 I < � (oo ' 4. r r Or NJ r N NJ r N OI A W ANA W W A W W ClOI O 01 V 03 J J V W V 01 J D NI V W W Of A A W A In „.- '0 (1) N OA 0 W ID 001 Cl W 40 V 0 NJ W T V CO W ID a CO N r 01 W CO 0 5 01 N tO CO for N r r 0 W CO 0 T NI W 00 O Ip r Z el. W 3d K N 2'ut o A W 03 N A O W V O 41 O tT r 0 O O V O 0 CO A V A 01 W N W CO tli t TJ F r r-r r N r N A 0 OJ A W W A W W AAO 0 W 001 O0 01 V IO V V W W V 01 01 V W W 01 W W 0 W W A W A W a $ W r V A 0 0 W A Y 0 N i...,-•CO A in r In ON 0 V V 01 CO r CO tT W NJ 0 CO V 0 CD r A W CO V W ID CO CO V W r W ID (/13 a Ito rt W 0' A 44 61 10 4.11 N in J NJ W V L W 0 OI CO I+ CO t0 V W W O 01 r rrr.r F.r r r rr r O 1 N.N W N N A W W OI A W O 0 N.IO 0,V tO O r N r r W A W A 01 41 W W W A 01 W W N A t0 W 0 r 0 IO O t11,03 i V r 0 A 10 0 0 0 A 10 1.0W W -•O N 10 CO W W W 10 V A A V W V Co N V In W tD W W A CO 0 W 10 5 CO N r N.N 0 CJ ID O. C 10 A V r 10 ID 0 0% V 0 A V N 'D VI 01 W W W N 01 W W A 1 'ti < U1 -ft < U) N 1-4 O 3 n d CU C A N o ST OS T O O Ort 3 ID O O O f0 a N a _ I VI (n (J) O to r IO co :P O co OD O N A O V N O V O1 O Z W W O Z o N o t0 O o to 0 2 f A N 0 CO W tO 0 W ..i Co v 0 v W CO f 10 O 0 0) c x 3 1 Z A A A I, 1-+ O 0 • coN•V 03 -A r O N 00 GO W r (n co• I-' O 01 01 0D co V1 H u 00 u V n r (A — ID • 01 IO O W A In 0 W v V v 01 N W (0 •• A r O n n n A v 1 3 3 3 c; 0 O co1:7.. 7 0 01 0•1 7 01 OAD NJ 7 0.O 0 ID O W (p CO r 1J m O O W ry 01 1-• O F' O N 0 O. 0 A 0 p O In In y '< V 0' On May 4, 2017, at 8:19 PM, JoAnn Clark <joclark2842@gmail.com> wrote: Rita I plan to be with y'all on Tuesday. I would stress only the volume. Because if there are too many options, they may"throw us a bone" but we still will have the the #1 problem... volume! Sent from my iPhone On May 4, 2017, at 6:17 PM, Kathleen Barney <kabnaples@yahoo.com> wrote: To whom it may concern As a resident of Lely golf estates I feel I must join in with many many neighbors to voice my thoughts on the current intolerable dangerous situation that has evolved. I feel we the residents know better than anyone what will and will not work. Flashing lights and stop signs are causing terrible traffic backup and more accidents! All of the items that are supposed to be initiated per your last meeting are expensive time consuming and will not help our major problem. Volume which is growing exponentially with growth in the east corridor. The pork cho on Rattlesnake may help but I strongly feel an electronic bar on 41 and one on Rattlesnake and definitely closing off Warren which is very problematic to our community are the only sustainable and logical remedies. I walk St Andrews nightly and my neighbor and I each and every nite have counted over 40 cars in a 2 -3 min. Period in and out of Warren speeding loud mufflers no turn signals etc. please remember the houses in Lely resort are set much farther back and I don't feel any community should take preference over ours as they really will not suffer the problems we have. Please ! No convoluted band aid fixes. Close off Warren to our community and at minimum a porkchop better still a gate on each end. Please listen to the residents and put politics aside! Kathleen Barney Sent from my iPhone On May 4, 2017, at 2:32 PM, Andre Bouquet<nfn20091 @gmail.com> wrote: Rita: I will be unable to attend the meeting on MY 9, however, I did send an e-mail to Donna Fiala on TU, outlining my views. This is my text: With respect to: Speed limit reduction Delineators at Wildflower Way and St Andrews Stop sign at Warren St Stop sign at Wildflower Way Reduction of roadway width Installation of crosswalk pavers Additional signage at Rattlesnake Hammock will be ignored as has been the sign prohibiting trucks in excess of 1 ton capacity, resulting in traffic by dump trucks, concrete mixers, flat beds, 18 wheel cargo trucks, etc. This continues to this day. No mention has been made of heavy duty truck traffic! These are feeble and costly attempts to satisfy occupants of St Andrews Blvd. None of these proposals will do anything to solve the problem The outstanding problems are: A large volume of traffic emanating from Warren St going north and traffic from Santa Barbara going south. Lack of sufficient police presence on St Andrews. Future volume will increase from additional housing developments on Santa Barbara and from "The Isles" The solutions must come from: Warren St traffic to St Andrews must be stopped Santa Barbara Traffic (south) must be directed to Grand Lely (four lanes) with a traffic signal at Rt 41 Consideration should be given to a "Gated Community" for Lely Country Club as was done in Foxfire several years ago. If "band aid" solutions are to be instituted, then accidents will continue to occur with more property damage and possible additional loss of life. Andre Bouquet 681 St Andrews Blvd On May 4, 2017, at 10:50 AM, SHELLY SMITH <pinkshe110523@yahoo.com>wrote: Rita, I will try to make it and lend my support, but I have to work that morning. This is a very important issue and I will see if I may come in later to work. My only suggestion is that we close off Warren Street permanently and/or with a gate that ONLY emergency personnel can use. We can slow down the traffic with stop signs and speed limits, but that does not eliminate the obvious problem. I will do my best to attend the meeting, but I believe we all know what the best solution is to keep our neighborhood safe and thus create less vandalism,theft,traffic accidents and destruction to our landscaping. Thank you, Shelly A. Ficarra On May 4, 2017, at 10:08 AM, Jane Troeger <Janetroeger@gmail.com>wrote: Hi Rita, I am in agreement with Theresa's suggestions. You can put me on the list indicating support, however, I will try to attend the meeting. Thank you. Jane Troeger Sent from my iPad On May 4, 2017, at 9:05 AM, Beverly Bragiel <beverlygri@comcast.neb wrote: Good Morning Rita Norb had another good idea, which is where the high school empties onto Wildflower, make it a right turn only, then no turn at first turn around which will funnel them into Lely Resort Blvd. Simple and inexpensive see the map below for a clearer understanding. hups://www.google.comimaps/@26.0876604.-81.7158806.15z I am sorry I cannot attend I have out of town buyers scheduled for Tues and Wed starting at 9:30 both days. Norb will try to come on Tuesday. We won't know his schedule for sure until the day before. Let me know if there is anything else I can do. On May 4, 2017, at 9:02 AM, Kathleen Barney <kabnaples@yahoo.com> wrote: Rita I must work that day and can't get off. I t Truly wish I could be there to support you but I will definitely email you. What will you be suggesting to them ? Sent from my iPhone On May 4, 2017, at 9:02 AM, Kathleen Barney <kabnaples@yahoo.com>wrote: Rita I must work that day and can't get off. I t Truly wish I could be there to support you but I will definitely email you. What will you be suggesting to them ? Sent from my iPhone On May 4, 2017, at 7:50 AM, n kling <n_kling@yahoo.com>wrote: Please express our great concern about the significant increase in traffic on St Andrews. We are so disappointed the county promised one thing and delivered another. They did not predict the volume we now have. Law enforcement is a deterrent that is NOT effective although well intended. I know as I walk my dog 4 times a day. Early ie: 6-7am is worst then 5-6 pm is next. Please ask council to visit at these times. Sit 2 houses before a speed bump and observe. Close Warren St, make Wild Flower 1 way, add 3 more stop signs as they slow traffic more than speed bumps. Trust me this would greatly reduce volume. Tks Nick and Jeannette Kling On May 4, 2017, at 7:01 AM, Kathryn Winters <klwinters56@yahoo.com> wrote: Rita, Because of a commitment I have on Tues.and Thurs, mornings I will not beable to attend Tuesday's meeting. Kathy winters 503 At. Andrews n May 3, 2017, at 11 :07 PM, Christine Posedel <christineposedel@yahoo.com>wrote: Rita, I cannot attend and pray one of the strong voiced, politically active previously for our street men, will attend and speak with you, as well as a large number of our neighbors, as a show of solidarity and determination that the right thing be done! Good luck everyone! Prayers and crossed fingers you can drive the point home for a long term volume solution. Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android On May 3, 2017, at 10:55 PM, Denise Miller <millde6@gmail.com> wrote: I will not be able to attend. I am still in the working field as a teacher and we are in the middle of state testing. I fully support that the county needs to find a way to limit the VOLUME of traffic in our residential neighborhood to areas that were designed for that volume. Denise Miller On May 3, 2017, at 10:30 PM, Jerry Greene <yankees.jerry@gmail.com>wrote: I agree and support you 100 percent Jerry Greene Sent from my iPad On May 3, 2017, at 10:02 PM, Mary jo agrusa <maryjoagrusa@yahoo.com> wrote: I am unable to attend the meeting Tuesday sal n mary jo agrusa Rita, Marcia and I are headed back to Michigan so we will not be attending the meeting. However, you can use this e-mail as a indication of our commitment to this mission on safety of Saint Andrew Blvd. (our residence is 109 Tanglewood Ct.) Thanks for all your doing- Marcia & Robert Sack Sent from my iPhone On May 6, 2017, at 11 :58 AM, susmatth@aol.com wrote: I will be out of town that day . Looking forward to hearing what will if anything happen following this meeting. Sent from AOL Mobile Mail Get t On May 6, 2017, at 12:37 PM, Jan Anemaet <Jananemaet@xplornet.ca> wrote: Hi Rita, I am seasonal and back home unfortunately so cannot attend. On May 6, 2017, at 1 :27 PM, John@NN <john@naplesnavigators.com> wrote: Rita, I have a must do doctor's appointment Tuesday morning and will unable to attend, feel free to use my name. I sent 'MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net', Donna's go between a message yesterday afternoon regarding this matter I am enclosing it here for your use. Good luck. Warmest Regards, John Grice John Grice REALTOR® Cell: 239.269.4514 Land Line: 239.963.9182 E-Mail: John@NaplesNavigators.com Web Site: NaplesNavigators.com Downing-Frye Realty, Inc 3411 Tamiami Trl. N. Suite 100 Naples, FL 34103 We appreciate your effort to resolve the dangerous traffic conditions on St. Andrews Blvd, thank you. This week I have observed police cruising up and down the street, on several occasions, stopping vehicles to write up violations. I reside at 432 and walk, usually in the mornings, between 5:30 and 7:00, and by doing so I believe I have a valuable assessment of the situation of road conditions between Forest Hills Blvd and Lely Palms Dr. Generally the CCSO patrols between 10 and 2, the least busy and not a good example of the issues, especially since many snow birds have departed. I will list the issues in no specific order and I have not observed any driver involved in all of these infractions. 1. Failing to come to a complete stop at any of the stop signs, especially at Warren and Wildflower, one driver didn't even slow down. 2. Stop signs are being seen as Yield Right of Ways. 3. Speeding, some I would estimate to be at 50mph or higher. This has subsided some probably due to fewer cars using the road after season. 4. Truck over the weight limit, perhaps due to signs being hidden and no enforcement. 5. Drivers moving into the bike lane, at almost anywhere on the street, especially when speeding. 6. I cannot say most, darkened windows prevent it, many drivers are distracted by talking or texting on mobile devices. 7. The new stop sign has caused one new hazard, yesterday, there were 17 cars and trucks backed up towards Rattlesnake Rd, I estimate it took 2 minutes to clear. 8. The amount of traffic, especially in season causes unnecessary delays in residents from backing or pulling out onto St. Andrews. The amount of traffic also creates other undesirable situation, trash and glass items thrown from vehicles, tires screeching and loud music and exhausts disrupting the peace in the neighborhood, diesel engines making so much noise they can be heard through closed doors and windows, especially when they are floored. I know you are responsive to all citizens as you should be, but this community can no longer enjoy our properties or peace with this situation continuing. Whatever the solution(s) the commissioners come up with, they should not penalize the residents of this community. Thank you for your attention and action. On May 6, 2017, at 2:25 PM, Jane Troeger<Janetroeger@gmail.com> wrote: As I am struggling with a stomach flu, I am not sure that I will be able to attend the meeting, but I am in support of reducing the volume of traffic on St Andrews Blvd. Sincerely, Jane Troeger Sent from my iPad On May 6, 2017, at 3:20 PM, brian sedey <usa4evr@hotmail.com> wrote: Hi Rita, We will be unable to attend the Tuesday, May 9th meeting. Please convey the fact that we are in agreement with the " gating" of St Andrews Blvd and that you are acting as our spokesperson on all matters re: St Andrews Blvd. Thank You, Margy & Brian Sedey 788 St Andrews Blvd 440-339-6870 On May 6, 2017, at 6:30 PM, Maureen.brehm <maureen.brehm@comcast.net> wrote: Hi Rita, We fully support your position that traffic volumes along Saint Andrews Blvd need to be reduced due to safety concerns, the rising number of accidents and heavy truck traffic volumes. We are sorry we cannot attend Tuesday's meeting in person. Regards, Andrew and Maureen Brehm 693 Saint Andrews Blvd. Sent from my iPhone On May 6, 2017, at 7:26 PM, Kathleen Barney <kabnaples@yahoo.com> wrote: I hope they are brought to realize that the stop signs flashers taking out a sped bump altering the road is not cost effective and will just glut traffic and cause more accidents. None of us will be able to get out of our drives! It's a problem now. Also on google maps you can see how many other ways there are to get into the manor from 41 . Good luck at the meeting Rita . I really tried to get off work that day but I have 2 girls out of town and it was impossible Sent from my iPhone On May 7, 2017, at 8:19 AM, Lori Radliff<loriradliff@yahoo.com>wrote: Have to work will not be able to be there good luck get it done !!!! Bob Radliff Sent from my iPhone On May 8, 2017, at 9:48 AM, Joyce Cashin <jnc456122@gmail.com> wrote: I will not be able to attended the Mtg on Tues. But you have my permission to use this email to represent strength in Numbers. On May 8, 2017, at 9:44 AM, Gerd Berndt<berndt741 @aol.com>wrote: Hi Rita, We cannot be there at the meeting unfortunately. We know you will represent us well. Thank you Gerd & Martha On May 7, 2017, at 10:46 PM, Todd Schilling <toddschillingservices@yahoo.com> wrote: Hello Rita, I will be working. Please use this email as confirmation of my on going concern with excess traffic, speeds, and the many unfortunate yet avoidable accidents and tragedies Saint Andrews Blvd. has incurred. Please Lee me in the loop on further developments. Thank you! Todd Schilling 225 Saint Andrews Blvd. Sent from my iPhone On May 8, 2017, at 11 :42 AM, Jwesthaus <jwesthaus@yahoo.com>wrote: Hello Rita, I will not be able to attend. We are out of state at this time. Good luck at the meeting. John Sent from my iPad Hi Rita My name is dava hirsch and I am the president for fairway villas. Gabby told me about the meeting Tuesday but unfortunately I will not be able to attend. I did want to give you my email address and let you know that whatever help you need to please let me know Hopefully something can be done on are street. I have almost gotten hit twice at the stop sign on wildflower It is amazing that people just blow right threw it. Thanks Dava Hirsch 510 Saint Andrews Blvd Sent from my iPhone On May 8, 2017, at 9:01 PM, Wajda Family <wajda2nd@comcast.neb wrote: I cannot be present for the Commissioners' board meeting but as an owner of a home on St Andrews Blvd I support any action that will decrease traffic and increase safety on this residential street. Sincerely , Mary Wajda Sent from my iPhone 'I cz.. _ �a w, i Vii» r � '2`'r ate ' . hA 42 ' F i' }r, 4.0 li . 1 -it el ,.... „.-,,f,,,:',',,,,,,,::-,:-.:,y,3,,,,,,.. ----..,-A!::,,,,,,„: -,,,,,,,_ ,,,_ 9 „,:.--„,:::„.„..„.,,,„,,,..,..„,n.„,„ „„..„,,..„„ ,,.;.....„,„,, •' -r ...., . , ,, •ii,„,4fr _it. ohnge.org Libertarian Party of Collier County Florida )fso Recipient: Bill McDaniel Letter: Greetings, Please provide safe access to Medical Cannabis in Collier County by ending the Moratorium. Comments Name Location Date Comment Jo Vaccarino Naples,FL 2017-02-19 When you block safe and legal access you create (answer: Illegal activity). This isn't rocket science. NINA MARTINEZ CAPEL CORAL,FL 2017-02-19 The people of Collier voted over 60 to have dispensaries Michael Faust Fort Myers,FL 2017-02-19 Is ridiculous that you would subvert the will of the people. The law passed, find reasonable accommodation Jennifer Small Naples,FL 2017-02-19 The Collier county residents voted.And that vote should be upheld Jamie Cain Naples,FL 2017-02-19 I have 20 signatures on a hard copy so we are up to almost 40 signatures! Keep sharing.Let's get legal and safe access to medical marijuana in Collier County! Laura Walker Naples,FL 2017-02-19 I have seen the positive effects of cannabis. Carly Gabbard Naples,FL 2017-02-19 People need the opportunity for easy access to all life saving and life enabling medicine. Donna Wolf Naples,FL 2017-02-19 The people have voted to provide medical cannabis to those who need it to improve their quality of life.Please do what you were elected to do&carry out the will of the people.Thank you for doing your job. patricia boutilier Naples,FL 2017-02-19 Medical marijuana helps people Jamie Walker Naples,FL 2017-02-19 The people need to be heard and their wishes respected.This is not up to government,the people have spoken,do your jobs. Benjamin Walker Naples,FL 2017-02-19 I'm a veteran with PTSD and have a hard time sleeping insomnia and hardly .44. eat this helps us maintain healthy eating weight if ur stressed comes you down Lewis Attardo Lutz,FL 2017-02-19 I suffer from Epilepsy Tita Arends Naples,FL 2017-02-19 It is needed for many health issues and it was made illegal knowing the benefits.People should be able to chose which way they wanna go medically. With FDA or the natural way. R Kupcs Naples, FL 2017-02-19 The cannabis plant is a life saving plant that every human needs full access to use. Kenneth Jones Rock Hill,SC 2017-02-19 People need relief NOW! Rebecca Conway Marco Island,FL 2017-02-19 Cannabis IS medicine.It is a safe alturnative to very dangerous pharmaceuticals.The people voted for legal cannabis and should have safe and easy acces to their medicine D Strom Naples,FL 2017-02-19 I believe this could help a lot of people in pain. Jason Doe Naples,FL 2017-02-20 Marijuana is medicine Judith Parris Naples,FL 2017-02-20 I have needed medical cannabis for quite awhile and was pleased when the voters passed this back in Nov.2016. Here we are,3-1/2 months later and now this happens? Scott Neff Naples, FL 2017-02-20 FL voted and the people said yes.Thats how our democracy works. Michelle Guthrie Naples,FL 2017-02-20 We need this pasted,people like me needs this thank u Christopher Santos Naples,FL 2017-02-20 It's our right to have a choice on traditional medication.Have family members who suffer extremelly pain due cancer... Laire Lightner Naples,FL 2017-02-20 : It matters! Name Location Date Comment andy casas Bonita Springs, FL 2017-02-20 I have epilepsy and they got me in all kinda meds.I need this instead of my meds.This can help me in a big way along with many other people with what i have Alex Roldan Naples,FL 2017-02-20 Everyone in need of medical cannibis should be allowed that access. Jon Levin Naples,FL 2017-02-20 It is a proven fact that cannabis has healing properties. Please don't let your personal bias get in the way of your constituent's(don't forget,we do vote) health and welfare. Thank you. Cherrie Cecil Naples,FL 2017-02-21 This is medically necessary not only for my son but many other sick people! This moratorium is a disgrace to the voting system and voters voice!! Vicki Boyd Naples, FL 2017-02-21 I disagree with the Collier County Commissioners actions as they are contrary to the voters. Jean-Pierre Gregoire Naples,FL 2017-02-21 Many people need medical marijuana for health reasons.Why are you going against the Amendment 2? MARILYN SAINZ Naples,FL 2017-02-21 6 months is more thsn enough time,there is no need to extend to 12 months. Would you extend and hold off treatment to an ill person? Enough said! Karma Hamilton Naples,FL 2017-02-21 I have a masters degree in mental health counseling. I have worked with those in our community with dual diagnosis substance abuse and mental health problems.Their addiction and dependence on the pharmaceutical companies #bigpharma is only making their problems worse while benefiting the corporations and those that let people out of touch with the needs of those who would benefit from medical marijuana deny access to what has already been deemed legalized by the majority.Mortality,crime,overdose,our tax dollars going to narcan&funding inpatient 30 day stays at"rehab"facilities that are just pharmaceutical dispensaries,will all drastically decrease once legal access is not inhibited by those who are trying to abuse their power and deny fair democratic process.If you find it socially acceptable to take ambien, antidepressants,zanex,muscle relaxers for a long plane ride etc.but want to deny our citizens their right to access safe,natural medicinal marijuana you work for#bigpharma-I'd like to research who on that board that is denying collier county access has prescription cocktail regimens of their own,popping pills like candy,uppers with their venlafaxine in the morning and an ambien cocktail at bed-I'd be curious and bet that the majority do-holier than thou right?Hypocrites! mark higgins naples,FL 2017-02-21 Cannabis can help so many sufferers of different ailments,some of which can not be treated with anything else!My son has aspergers&seizures. Kelly Cobb Cape Coral,FL 2017-02-21 The county has no right to act against the people's choice. Their personal opinions are null and void on all issues and should be reminded that they work for the public Eric Daly Naples,FL 2017-02-21 People that are destroying their bodies with opioids because of their a debilitating pain should have easy access to this totally natural alternative. Shawn Hilkowski Naples,FL 2017-02-22 I feel that cannibus can help many people with health issue and mental illness... Vanessa Franklin Naples,FL 2017-02-22 Commissioners should stop messing about with we the people. We voted and the commissioners should respect the outcome. Elsa Brightmon Naples,FL 2017-02-22 I have MS and feel that this benefit me. • Austin BI!tch Naples,FL 2017-02-22 In Defiance of tyranny Name Location Date Comment Veda Porreca Naples,FL 2017-02-22 This is a very critical matter for Cancer,Mental Health and Chronic Pain Patients. I happen to be one and if this is not passed as promised it will make life a whole lot harder. How can they go back on something that has already been passed. Synthia LaFontaine Naples,FL 2017-02-22 The illegalization of medical marijuana is cruel to people who are suffering and need it. Michelle Taranto-Qualls Naples,FL 2017-02-23 This should be a no Brainerd.Why would you not want people that need medical Marijuana which is much safer and more effective than toxic prescriptions available to those that need it?!? Nathan Wall Naples,FL 2017-02-23 The people have majority vote and the state shall not attempt to stop our votes.! elizabeth kostuk Naples,FL 2017-02-23 It's an obvious choice over narcotics/opioids. Amanda Mihalik Naples,FL 2017-02-23 I've seen how great this helps the economy with out negative effects in Oregon Michael Spencer Naples,FL 2017-02-23 How many times do we need to vote on this? Joyce DeMartino Naples,FL 2017-02-24 I have Transverse Myelitis which is like MS.I would very much like the opportunity to try Medical cannabis. Joan Ginsberg Naples,FL 2017-02-24 I was lied to about this issue by Commissioner Andy Solis on February 21. Edward Tucker Naples,FL 2017-02-24 Your decision in no way reflects what the MAJORITY of voters have chosen! Get a grip and get with the times! Thomas Yeaw Naples, FL 2017-02-24 This is why citizens distrust their elected officials.We the people vote and then you ignore this is very typical of government ignoring the people Jessica Thompson Naples,FL 2017-02-24 Freedom. Sheila Taylor Naples,FL 2017-02-24 The county needs to respect our vote. Andrew Seijas Naples,FL 2017-02-24 I am signing because the delayed response in New York resulted in the undue pain and suffering of a family member. Delaying this in Collier will do the same. Janet Mitchell Naples,FL 2017-02-24 Science has shown that cannibas has several medicinal uses and it is time to look to natural rather rhan manufactured healings. Jan Falkum Fort Myers Beach,FL 2017-02-24 I believe medical marijuana is necessary to help patients with conditions that have few other options. Stefanie Sanders Naples,FL 2017-02-24 The voters have spoken,and are overwhelmingly in favor of access to medical cannabis. It is not the purview of the Commissioners to thwart the populace. This moratorium contravenes the wishes of the citizenry.Do your jobs,and enact Amendment 2 immediately. Kathleen Hendrix Fort Myers,FL 2017-02-24 It is safer than many drugs.People should have every option for treatment.We voted for this.What's the hold up? Norman Dolinic Naples,FL 2017-02-24 Voters vetoed for it. Kathryn Augustin Naples,FL 2017-02-24 The voters have spoken. Anyone supporting the moratorium should be recalled.People are suffering. Heather Bladich Naples,FL 2017-02-24 I believe people with illness should have access to medical marijuana,and regulations will help keep it away from children. E.Thomas Costello Naples,FL 2017-02-24 Two of my sisters died of cancer&the medical treatment they received.They both suffered terribly.Anyone who votes to allow more suffering is inhumane and possibly worse. Name Location Date Comment Elizabeth Julian Naples,FL 2017-02-24 I believe in the use of cannibis over narcotics!There are so many uses for medical cannabis,please get rid of this"reefer madness"stigma and let sick people feel better and maybe ever get better,naturally.Why wait? Patricia French Naples,FL 2017-02-24 I had a hip replacement a few years ago and I was put on the available pain medicines. E.g.opiates.I seriously almost died of them.My blood pressure went sky high.We should allow people to Use medical marijuana which you cannot die of. There are lots of us baby boomers now and we're getting a lot of • aches and pains! Dolores Lynch Naples,FL 2017-02-24 I believe easy access is critical for debilitated patients who may not find it easy to travel to distributors in town and cities over 2 hours away! We need to act on behalf of those who are hurting. The voters have spoken regarding medical marijuana! denise petersen naples,FL 2017-02-24 I'm signing because I have MS and I hope to use medical Marijuana to help with pain,spasticity and sleep.And because the voters agree! Karen Price Naples,FL 2017-02-25 I already voted for this and I am still in favor of legalizing the use of marijuana for medical purposes. Mary Sanders Naples,FL 2017-02-25 If regulated it will be a beneficial service to those prescribed cannibus for medical needs Jessy L Guffey Naples,FL 2017-02-25 Adding ANY Moratoium should be illegal. The Voters spoke up,,,and should proceed as stated. People are suffering„waiting for the Medical Marijuana,„,Sick and VOTERS in extreme pain should not be suffering any more time„, Please please go ahead with the original dates. Jennifer Marchionda Naples,FL 2017-02-25 Of the help and freedom from symptoms.., Lisa Pedro Bonita Springs, FL 2017-02-25 I have a freind with MS and I have cancer! Chris Burns Naples,FL 2017-02-25 we voted Danielle Rachel Naples,FL 2017-02-25 I'm with you Denise! Becky Lang Fort Myers,FL 2017-02-25 I have friends with cancer who need this! Bonnie Rae Bonita Springs,FL 2017-02-25 The absurdity of considering cannibis more harmful than any of the other prescription drugs readily available is beyond reason.Which side effects are the government protecting us from?Rational minds must prevail. James Morrissy Naples,FL 2017-02-25 Need for my older brother Deborah Bushen Naples,FL 2017-02-25 My husband was severely injured in 2001 when a steel pallet weighing 146lbs fell striking him on the head,causing a concussion and spinal injuries. Since that time,he has been on opioid medication.This medication effects his personality and his internal organs. Julie Boyan Naples,FL 2017-02-25 I am a cancer survivor and have anxiety. Chuck Schanne Naples,FL 2017-02-25 I believe it should be the right of the patient to elect his/her right to medication. Or the Doctor and certainly NOT the Commissioners or Board or any other individual. Medicinal marijuana is a very effective way to overcome pain and misery for many patients and is not harming the general public in any way. Thank you ! nancy dunn bonita springs,FL 2017-02-25 its important for people who are suffering without it Name Location Date Comment maureen burns Naples,FL 2017-02-25 I am apalled that elected officials would disregard the voters wishes. Furthermore,I work in the healthcare setting with doctors I respect and understand clearly their desire and need,as well as the patients to have access to the drug of their choice often times at much less of a cost and with less impairing side effects. I am the parent of a highschool senior and have had some very open discussions about drug use and availability. What I have been told is that by the seventh grade most kids know who to contact if they want to buy drugs.A sad,scary,sobering fact.It almost makes the commissioners attempts laughable.Seventh graders have illegal access. Cheap.Easy.The most devastating drug to society statistically is alcohol. Desperate people will do desperate things.If I were in enough pain,I might just contact a seventh grader. ....._.....__. Karen Karlonas Naples,FL 2017-02-25 People need options for medical treatments tracy gunn Naples,FL 2017-02-25 This is legislation passed by vote in our country,you have no right to block it. Christopher Halaschak Naples,FL 2017-02-25 We,the majority of people of Florida(over 70%)voted in favor of this amendment.We did not vote for delays,studies and political mumbojumbo,just action.This should not be a big deal folks,and yes,Collier County is compromised in the brain,thinking that we are different that all our other counties,we are just as human as other people throughout the state.Come on folks,get it done! Cynthia Downing Naples,FL 2017-02-25 I live with severe pain 2417 and I'm forced to depend on opiates that are addictive. .. _ ............ ...... Denny Phillips Naples,FL 2017-02-26 The Collier County Commission's proposal to implement a 12 month moratorium under the guise of safety is an outrage and flies in the face of "common sense and good judgement"! Missy Cowan Chelsea,MI 2017-02-26 Voters have already made our voice clear when we voted for access to medical cannabis and we have no intention of allowing further discrimination against this medication that has proven helpful for so many different diseases.It is up to us to protect the Amen Ilene Ewy Naples,FL 2017-02-26 I agree! Arden Bess Naples,FL 2017-02-26 Its the right thing to do. Marsha Rubin Naples,FL 2017-02-26 Legal Medical Marijuana can help people in terrible pain-we voted for this amendment to be passed and it is important to implement it sooner than later. . ._. .. .. ..._.... ... _. . ....... .... ....._.. .._...__.. ......... . AMAnda Norton Naples,FL 2017-02-26 For my father who is in constant pain! Moya Lewis Naples,FL 2017-02-26 Is beneficial Frank Comeriato Naples,FL 2017-02-27 It is unfair to deny a SAFE alternative to the drugs people are taking to treat the debilitating diseases they fight daily. ........ ......._.. .. ....... .... ........._.. Karen Swift Naples,FL 2017-03-01 I am in pain every day. Tracy Acuff Naples,FL 2017-03-02 I'm signing because I support the need for some patients to have safe access to this medicine,such as the vote was passed last November. ..........._.___........................._ ....._... ._... ...... ... _.__... _._.....__._.. Millie Harvey Naples,FL 2017-03-05 The voters spoke.It would appear the council works for the big pharmaceutical industries?Who ever approved the moratorium should be cast off of the council. ...._......_. _.._._..........___...... maureen burns Naples,FL 2017-03-08 Collier county commissioners are helping to support local illegal drug dealer's business by encouraging desperate people to purchase drugs from a street dealer. Kind of makes me wonder if some of them are benefitting from the illegal trade and don't want legal dispensaries cutting into the business?? ..... ._....... ._.... .. ..... Victor Espinosa Naples,FL 2017-03-08 I want access to medical cannabis in Collier county.That is what I voted for. Name Location Date Comment Roshelle Perry Naples,FL 2017-03-08 It's the right thing to do... I'm for medical use Kurt Hoenig Naples,FL 2017-03-31 It passed because we voted for it. Now it needs to happen without more beauracratic b.s. Richard Ritterbusch Naples,FL 2017-04-06 I believe that our county's elected officials should not interfere with the obvious will of the statewide electorate.I also believe that marijuana is unjustly vilified by some well meaning individuals and groups. eric plessinger naples,FL 2017-04-09 Because I believe marijuana had many medicinal uses Peter Haljean New Lenox,IL 2017-04-09 America needs safe access to THC products. Gloria Aparicio Cape Coral,FL 2017-04-25 I want a better quality of life for my husband,he was diagnosed with Epilepsy more than 10 years ago,it is about time for him to tried an alternative option that is already available in many estates of our nation with positive results. My question is,why is the delay for? We have spoken with our votes and it is our right to have this amendment in effect immediately. Sickness do not have a moratorium. Richard Conover Naples,FL 2017-04-25 The citizens of Florida have spoken.We want marijuana legalized.Do not defy the electorate. Freedom Evolving Naples,FL 2017-04-25 Time to let Amendment 2 and the peoples choice for legal,available dispensaries move forward Shannon Livingston Naples,FL 2017-04-26 Patients need access and citizens shouldn't fund lawsuits that are imminent if the county denies this constitutional right. Thomas DeMaio Boca Raton,FL 2017-04-26 I'm signing because the people spoke in November and it is time that our representatives listened. Gail Hayton naples,FL 2017-04-26 My daughter suffers from severe epilepsy Carl-Betteanne Camagna Thornton, PA 2017-04-26 medicinal reasons White Kristin Naples,FL 2017-04-27 We voted,we counted,we won,we want it,we need it;without interference and injector.Florida commissioners need to get out of the way of medical, physician recommended use of what WE the people voted for. People are suffering and dying while you prostrate yourselves along with the pharmaceutical companies.We will remember come election time. Diana Daily Mount Olive,AL 2017-04-27 My husband just passed away from cancer this past 2/28/17 . I'm sorry but God forbid to take business away pharmacies. Lift the moratorium you have no right. HAS ANY OF YOUR FAMILY MEMBERS SUFFERED OR PASSED FROM CANCER Or ANY TERMINAL ILLINESS. Watching and caring for the terminally is a terrible thing. People are dying while you scratch you heads. A. Joanne Morris Naples,FL 2017-04-27 I feel that medical marijuana is a safe and effective medication for patients whose doctors feel it a viable alternative to other meds. Probably much less likely to cause addiction than other,narcotic,meds. Carl-Betteanne Camagna Thornton,PA 2017-04-30 we need safe pain medication.WE VOTED for it! Jack Bills Naples,FL 2017-05-01 Carter County residents need to have local access Valerie Mercurio Naples,FL 2017-05-01 This naturally grown plant has the most healing power of the big drug companies pills. There should not be a a law against using this effective drug Barb Senkevich Naples,FL 2017-05-01 I feel it's one's right to have access to this if it can help ease the nausea and pain of whatever they are going through. Nancy Kasian Naples,FL 2017-05-01 I would like to have access. Name Location Date Comment Brad Mathews Naples,FL 2017-05-02 It's needed Debra Laux Naples,FL 2017-05-02 As a RN,I am more than aware of the benefits of medical marijuana for those that would benefit from it.I find it unconstitutional that you would even consider a moratorium. In addition,I also find this proposed moratorium inhumane to those that would benefit from it. Deborah Dittmann Naples,FL 2017-05-02 Medical marijuana is a potential pain remedy which has far fewer problems than the opioids currently being prescribed,particularly addiction. Maggie Cody Punta Gorda,FL 2017-05-03 It is the only medically indicated humane thing to do Laurie Von Dollen Naples,FL 2017-05-03 You have had 6 months to figure this out-Time is up! A handful of people do not get to dictate our health care. Jason Hartgrave Naples,FL 2017-05-04 Preventing access to medicine of any kind is barbaric and inhumane regardless of your personal feelings towards the medicine in question. Colleen Gill Naples,FL 2017-05-04 Pm signing because prior to moving to Naples, I was a medicinal marijuana patient in the state of Maine.I had emergency spinal surgery after an accident and had nerve damage that cause consistent twitching and intermediate bouts of paralysis in my right leg.Thanks to medical oils and edibles, I was able to control my spasms and reduce the nerve pain.And most importantly,I was able to avoid taking addictive opiates by using a natural medicine. I have fully recovered since,but this should be allowed for patients to obtain close to home. If we can subscribe opiates out of hundreds of pharmacies,then we should be able to provide them with a healthier,natural,and much more sustainable alternative. Rebecca Conway Marco Island,FL 2017-05-04 Pharmaceuticals nearly cost me my life and left me riddled with health issues and blindness.Cannabis is the ONLY safe option for me. Stevens Johnson Syndrome can happen to anyone,it does not discriminate.Nearly all drugs, RX and OTC,can leave you fighting for your life.Cannabis IS medicine! Gloria Aparicio Cape Coral,FL 2017-05-05 Last November passed with high majority amendment 2.There is no excuse to delay medical marijuana to be available to those who desperately need it. Follow the example of states that have already approved it. Name Location Date Comment Ernest Zuccarelli Marco Island,FL 2017-05-05 At 64 years of age I have never used drugs or alcohol.After a lifetime of construction work I have a medical condition that required pain medication. After many tests my primary care physician sent me to pain management where I was given opioids as treatment.The side effects were many and unmanageable so I took it upon myself to find another solution. I obtained some cannabis legally on my own and started self medicating using it in tiny amounts.The CLINICAL effects were amazing.All my vital signs including A1C improved dramatically with none of the opioid side effects.My pain diminished considerably to a manageable amount and my weight even dropped by 30lbs. I now feel I'd like to work instead of retiring but many companies have drug testing.So instead of paying into the system for a few more years your actions are keeping me unemployed. When used responsibly I proved,in my case,that cannabis has a place in medicine.My physicians agreed. I feel my government is keeping me from helping myself and improving my physical condition for the sake of special interests that have no concern for my health but only for the enrichment of a few. I recently took a lifetime of savings and built my own house in Collier County. love where I live!I gave myself and my wife the reward we deserved for the diligent efforts we made over the years to be responsible law abiding citizens. Now YOU have turned me into a criminal unless I go to another state. SHAME ON YOU PEOPLE!The constitution says"by the people,for the people".Well a majority of the"people"HAVE spoken and you've chosen instead to redefined my civil rights.Your job was to make it happen-nothing • more!What's been proven is that American politics is true to form only for the few! Shame On You! Ms. Fiala-I voted for you.Now that I see you in action I feel my support for you was misguided. Ernie Zuccarelli • Marci Seamples Naples,FL 2017-05-08 71%of Florida voters voted in favor of Amendment 2. Elaine Malone Naples,FL 2017-05-08 It has been scientifically been proven to help conditions of MS and Parkinsons we also voted for this Meredith Wiacek Naples,FL 2017-05-08 I am a Registered Nurse who has taken care of patients and family members who suffer from severe,sometimes terminal,pain. I would like to medical marijuana be an option,as I voted for this in November. Mily Cancio Naples,FL 2017-05-09 Medical cannabis helps Parkinson's patients, cancer patients and pain management. Octavio Alvarez Norfolk,VA 2017-05-09 The science and evidence proves that it helps!! 1 Name City State Postal Code Country Signed On Jamie Cain Naples Florida United States 2/18/2017 Greg Cain Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/19/2017 James Westvold Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/19/2017 Jo Vaccarino Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/19/2017 Kristin Miceli Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Carrie Freeland Bonita Springs Florida 34135-5030 United States 2/19/2017 Vickie Harrison Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/19/2017 Alicia Panas Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/19/2017 Peter Richter Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/19/2017 Elsa Grifoni Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 2/19/2017 Dennis Bosher Naples Florida 34113 United States 2/19/2017 joseph cassano vero beach Florida 32966 United States 2/19/2017 NINA MARTINEZ CAPEL CORAL Florida 33991 United States 2/19/2017 Karrie Weaver Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Kristina Luscan Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/19/2017 Jennifer Small Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/19/2017 Cindy Kemp Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Robert A Enright III Fort Myers Florida 33907 United States 2/19/2017 Chelsea Fowler Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/19/2017 Laura Walker Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Carly Gabbard Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Tania Rocha Naples Florida 34113 United States 2/19/2017 Kim Durston Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/19/2017 Carin DeRossett Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/19/2017 Donna Wolf Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/19/2017 patricia boutilier Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/19/2017 Millie Harvey Naples Florida 34114 United States 2/19/2017 Jessica Van Ord Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/19/2017 Wendy selman Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/19/2017 Colleen Messina Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/19/2017 Kandyce Kelley Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/19/2017 Jeanette Lynn Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/19/2017 Cory Gabbard Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Jamie Walker Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Karen north Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/19/2017 Kathleen Traynor Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/19/2017 brittany blanco Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/19/2017 Bev McCann Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/19/2017 Benjamin Walker Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/19/2017 Lou tinel Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/19/2017 Lewis Attardo Lutz Florida 33548 United States 2/19/2017 Alexia Anastasia Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/19/2017 Tita Arends Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/19/2017 Amanda Barton Fort Myers Florida 33908 United States 2/19/2017 Nicole Figley Bellevue Washingto 98004 United States 2/19/2017 R Kupcs Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/19/2017 Stephanie Bowen Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/19/2017 Jared Jones Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/19/2017 Michaelle Smith Tampa Florida 33619 United States 2/19/2017 Andrew Norris Anchorage Alaska 99503 United States 2/19/2017 LaVeeda Krumm Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/19/2017 Leilani McCoy Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/19/2017 Rebecca Conway Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 2/19/2017 Margaret DeSear Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 Michael Schneider Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/19/2017 D Strom Naples Florida 34114 United States 2/19/2017 Julie Martin Frederic Wisconsin 54837-8918 United States 2/20/2017 Victoria walton Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/20/2017 Jennifer Breen Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/20/2017 Donna Dawley Fort Myers Florida 33901 United States 2/20/2017 Ashley Stroeter Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/20/2017 Wiliam Tolp Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/20/2017 Jennifer Blanco Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/20/2017 Jason Dorris Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/20/2017 Judith Parris Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/20/2017 Anthony Carucci Glens Falls New York 12801 United States 2/20/2017 James Luscan Naples Florida 43104 United States 2/20/2017 Meagan Perkins Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/20/2017 Alicia Craig Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/20/2017 Christine Foster Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 2/20/2017 Paul Harper Naples Florida 34103 United States 2/20/2017 Scott Neff Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/20/2017 Michelle Guthrie Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/20/2017 Jessie Lloyd Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/20/2017 Crystal Wilson Naples Florida 34103 United States 2/20/2017 Summer Strom Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/20/2017 Jill Dixon Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/20/2017 Mary Hernandez Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/20/2017 Christopher Santos Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/20/2017 Laire Lightner Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/20/2017 Andres Casas Bonita Springs Florida 34135 United States 2/20/2017 Rachel Parnell Murfreesboro Tennessee 37127 United States 2/20/2017 Alex Roldan Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/20/2017 Cathy Stevens Fort Myers Florida 33967 United States 2/20/2017 Jonathan Levin Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/20/2017 Arianne Levin Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/20/2017 Jameson Connors Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/20/2017 Amanda Catalano Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/20/2017 Jeffery Pratus Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 2/20/2017 Alexandra Dixon Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/21/2017 Cherrie Cecil Naples Florida 34103 United States 2/21/2017 Vicki Boyd Naples Florida 34120-2912 United States 2/21/2017 Jean-Pierre Gregoire Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 Nevin Hoefert Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/21/2017 MARILYN SAINZ Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 P. Eisa Lindner Naples Florida 34113 United States 2/21/2017 Cathy Young Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/21/2017 Karma Hamilton Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 Heather Thompson Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 Donna Algier Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 mark higgins naples Florida 34117 United States 2/21/2017 Julie Granese Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 Marne Gleason naples Florida 34109 United States 2/21/2017 Edward Laurson Denver Colorado 80235 United States 2/21/2017 ileana ramos naples Florida 34105 United States 2/21/2017 Kelly Cobb Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 Jeffrey Smith Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/21/2017 Bob Costa Venice Florida 34293 United States 2/21/2017 Ray Martinez Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/21/2017 Eric Perry Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/21/2017 Eric Daly Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/21/2017 Brian Griffith Vero Beach Florida 32965 United States 2/22/2017 Shawn Hilkowski Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/22/2017 Lisa Clark Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/22/2017 Vanessa Franklin Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Georgie Cooper Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 James Cooper Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Dawn McConnell Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Edward Larsen Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Barbara Quinn Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Elsa Brightmon Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Austin Mitch Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/22/2017 Veda Porreca Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Raquel Duck Naples Florida 34120-2383 United States 2/22/2017 Alison Whiting Spring Hill Florida 34608 United States 2/22/2017 Synthia LaFontaine Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Tara Sokolich Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/22/2017 Ronni Novak Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/23/2017 justin miller Fort Myers Florida 33905 United States 2/23/2017 Michelle Taranto-Qualls Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/23/2017 Michael Sullivan Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 John Morton Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 Mike Falcone Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 Tim Grey Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 Heather Grey Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 Nathan Wall Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/23/2017 William Crowley Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/23/2017 Janet Weisberg Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Linda Hardy Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/23/2017 Craig Chandler Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Darrell Brown Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 Tessa Tilden-Smith Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 elizabeth kostuk Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/23/2017 Sarah Haacke Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/23/2017 Amanda Mihalik Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Gherri Wheaton Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/23/2017 Kim Hubscher Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/23/2017 John Costello Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 Michael Spencer Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Jon Calderon Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Mike Vance Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Maria Threlkeld Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Sheldon Starman Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/23/2017 Tonia Dwyer Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/23/2017 Kristen Mclaughlin Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 kimberly Bruge Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/23/2017 Hilda Umpierre Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/23/2017 Matt Rebmanm Palmetto Florida 34220 United States 2/24/2017 Maria Rivas Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/24/2017 Christine Cargnoni Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Joyce DeMartino Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/24/2017 Teralyn Siller Arlington Texas 76018 United States 2/24/2017 Joan Ginsberg Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/24/2017 Michelle Tucker Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/24/2017 Edward Tucker Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/24/2017 Michael Stephenson Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/24/2017 Thomas Yeaw Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/24/2017 Jessica Thompson Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/24/2017 Tobias Simmons Naples Florida 34114 United States 2/24/2017 Sheila Taylor Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/24/2017 Andrew Seijas Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Janet Mitchell Naples Florida 34103 United States 2/24/2017 Jan Falkum Fort Myers Beach Florida 33931 United States 2/24/2017 Stefanie Sanders Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Kathryn Garra Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/24/2017 Kathleen Hendrix Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 2/24/2017 Amanda Conforto Naples Florida 34114 United States 2/24/2017 Joelle Canglin Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/24/2017 mark Lorenz Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/24/2017 Erin Howlett Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Beth Carr Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/24/2017 Cori Craciun Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/24/2017 Norman Dolinic Naples Florida 34114 United States 2/24/2017 Abby Yetter Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 2/24/2017 Kathryn Augustin Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/24/2017 Bret Baker Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/24/2017 JoAnn Hillebrand Cape Coral Florida 33914 United States 2/24/2017 Heather Bladich Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Courtney Lehmann Naples Florida 34103 United States 2/24/2017 E.Thomas Costello Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Loretta Merchant Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Mary Parkman Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Elizabeth Julian Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/24/2017 Kevin Dwyer Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/24/2017 Patricia French Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/24/2017 Kazel Morgan Austin Texas 78745 United States 2/24/2017 Dolores Lynch Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Timothy Mansberger Naples Florida 34103 United States 2/24/2017 Lee Fagan Cape Coral Florida 33914 United States 2/24/2017 denise petersen naples Florida 34108 United States 2/24/2017 Mari-Lynn Hoffman Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/24/2017 Conny Kennedy Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/24/2017 Kenneth Frazier Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/24/2017 Gabriella Deponte Marco Island Florida 34145-4727 United States 2/24/2017 Abieser Rodriguez Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/25/2017 Tony Myers Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/25/2017 Susan Limpitlaw Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/25/2017 Renee Messina Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/25/2017 Isaac Morris Waldorf Alabama 20603 United States 2/25/2017 David Nourse Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/25/2017 Karen Price Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 DONNA AYDELOTT NAPLES Florida 34112 United States 2/25/2017 Mary Sanders Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/25/2017 Jessy L Guffey Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/25/2017 Tina Le Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/25/2017 Jennifer Marchionda Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Lisa Pedro Bonita Springs Florida 34135 United States 2/25/2017 Peter Ridley Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Richawn Cranor Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/25/2017 Lisa Rice Atwater California 95301 United States 2/25/2017 Rosa Martinez Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/25/2017 Chris Burns Naples Florida 34106 United States 2/25/2017 Rob White Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/25/2017 Ruth Couture Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 godelieve hm ANTWERPEN 2018 Belgium 2/25/2017 Peggy Kass Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Danielle Rachel Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/25/2017 Becky Lang Fort Myers Florida 33919 United States 2/25/2017 Bonnie Rae Bonita Springs Florida 34135 United States 2/25/2017 Kim Spies Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/25/2017 James Morrissy Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Alicia Browner Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/25/2017 Deborah Bushen Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/25/2017 Julie Boyan Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/25/2017 Ellen Mendez Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/25/2017 Mary Lewis Sheehan Saint James City Florida 33956 United States 2/25/2017 Brandon Todd Cape Coral Florida 33909 United States 2/25/2017 Jeanine Edwards Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Chuck Schanne Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 nancy dunn bonita springs Florida 34135 United States 2/25/2017 Janet Pinto Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/25/2017 maureen burns Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/25/2017 Jeff Walters Bonita Springs Florida 34135 United States 2/25/2017 Ruby Troiano Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/25/2017 Kristin Burgess Naples Florida 34114 United States 2/25/2017 Mike Edwards Mt.Juliet Tennessee 37122 United States 2/25/2017 Lou DiGiacomo Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Gianna Timo Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/25/2017 Caroline Pate Miami Beach Florida 33139 United States 2/25/2017 Thomas Bowman Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/25/2017 Diane Johnson Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Ashley Lang Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/25/2017 Karen Karlonas Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/25/2017 Kristi Remy Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/25/2017 Craig Fox Deerfield New Ham 3037 United States 2/25/2017 Geri Rosenman Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/25/2017 Robin Currence Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/25/2017 Tracy Gunn Naples Florida 34101 United States 2/25/2017 Kevin Campanella Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/25/2017 Pam Halaschak Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/25/2017 Christoff Spies Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/25/2017 Christopher Halaschak Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/25/2017 Cynthia Downing Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/25/2017 Nick Borders Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/25/2017 Denny Phillips Naples Florida 34109-7850 United States 2/26/2017 Missy Cowan Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/26/2017 Ilene Ewy Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/26/2017 Richard Murphy Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/26/2017 Marita lepson Immokalee Florida 34142 United States 2/26/2017 Victor Rudowski Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/26/2017 Shari Perkins Saint James City Florida 33956 United States 2/26/2017 Jessica Anderson Covington Louisiana 70433 United States 2/26/2017 Victoria DeRoy Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/26/2017 Kara Lawrence Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/26/2017 Andrew Mendez Hesperia California 92345 United States 2/26/2017 D.J. Lyles Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/26/2017 Arden Bess Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/26/2017 Amy O'Malley Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/26/2017 Michael Clarke Naples Florida 34102 United States 2/26/2017 Marsha Rubin Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/26/2017 Judy Dempsey Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/26/2017 paul Mcfarquhar Tampa Florida 33606 United States 2/26/2017 Jessica Wolff Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/26/2017 JERRY LANG NAPLES Florida 34110 United States 2/26/2017 Katrina Borders Naples Florida 34108 United States 2/26/2017 Cheryl McPherson Naples Florida 34119 United States 2/26/2017 AMAnda Norton Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/26/2017 Moya Lewis Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/26/2017 Di French galloway New Jerse) 8401 United States 2/26/2017 Linda Sexton Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/26/2017 Laura Bensman Naples Florida 34113 United States 2/27/2017 Stephen Sullivan New York New York 11105 United States 2/27/2017 Gabriel Tamayo Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/27/2017 I Sammie Patino Naples Florida 34120 United States 2/27/2017 Chloe Cafiero Naples Florida 34105 United States 2/27/2017 Michelle Blake Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/27/2017 Frank Comeriato Naples Florida 34117 United States 2/27/2017 Samuel Comeriato Naples Florida 34104 United States 2/27/2017 Ryan Donato Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 2/27/2017 Dara Goren Fort Myers Florida 33967 United States 2/27/2017 Sam Velazquez Naples Florida 34114 United States 2/27/2017 Jason Levin Naples Florida 34110 United States 2/27/2017 Chris Smendra Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/28/2017 Nicolas Nixen Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/28/2017 Mark Dennis Naples Florida 34116 United States 2/28/2017 Sophia Brasher Naples Florida 34112 United States 2/28/2017 nick james Naples Florida 34109 United States 2/28/2017 David Nickols 3/1/2017 Mike deluca Naples Florida 34119 United States 3/1/2017 Karen Swift Naples Florida 34104 United States 3/1/2017 Michelle Church Naples Florida 34116 United States 3/1/2017 Chris Bellor Naples Florida 34116 United States 3/1/2017 marlies santoro naples Florida 34112 United States 3/1/2017 Aaron Monteverde Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/1/2017 james ford Naples Florida 34103 United States 3/1/2017 Martin Sotelo Naples Florida 34116 United States 3/2/2017 Tracy Acuff Naples Florida 34108 United States 3/2/2017 Stacey Campbell Naples Florida 34112 United States 3/4/2017 Jason Mersereau Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/4/2017 Crystal Torres Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/5/2017 Ashley Gilbert Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/8/2017 Victor Espinosa Naples Florida 34116 United States 3/8/2017 Irashema Hernandez Estero Florida 33929 United States 3/8/2017 Roshelle Perry Naples Florida 34113 United States 3/8/2017 Carmine Biello Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/9/2017 Megan Henry Naples Florida 34103 United States 3/9/2017 Susan Banta Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/10/2017 Joe Walton Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/10/2017 Eric Schoen Naples Florida 34120 United States 3/10/2017 Marta Campanella Naples Florida 34110 United States 3/11/2017 VIVI STATHOPOULOU LAMIA Greece 3/18/2017 Kurt Hoenig Naples Florida 34102 United States 3/31/2017 Richard Ritterbusch Naples Florida 34120 United States 4/6/2017 David Darwish Naples Florida 34109 United States 4/8/2017 Matt Fahnestock Naples Florida 34112 United States 4/8/2017 Greg Christensen Naples Florida 34102 United States 4/8/2017 Eric Plessinger Naples Florida 34104 United States 4/9/2017 Peter Haljean New Lenox Illinois 60451 United States 4/9/2017 Michelle Karlen Naples Florida 34104 United States 4/15/2017 Toshia Diabate Daleville Alabama 36322 United States 4/20/2017 Gloria Aparicio Cape Coral Florida 33991 United States 4/25/2017 Richard Conover Naples Florida 34119 United States 4/25/2017 Cindy Kemp Naples Florida 34116 United States 4/25/2017 Jana Greer Naples Florida 34120 United States 4/26/2017 Shannon Mende Naples Florida 34120 United States 4/26/2017 Crystal Patterson Naples Florida 34102 United States 4/26/2017 Sandra Hagedorn Naples Florida 34114 United States 4/26/2017 Constantin Verdes Naples Florida 34120 United States 4/26/2017 Shannon Livingston Naples Florida 34105 United States 4/26/2017 Lori Yashko Naples Florida 34109 United States 4/26/2017 Thomas DeMaio Boca Raton Florida 33432 United States 4/26/2017 Jill Dixon Naples Florida 34103 United States 4/26/2017 Mara Bugarin Naples Florida 34104 United States 4/26/2017 Gail Hayton naples Florida 34108 United States 4/26/2017 Carl-Betteanne Camagna Fort Myers Florida 33967 United States 4/26/2017 Susan Dunn Naples Florida 34116 United States 4/27/2017 Kathy Macaluso naples Florida 34104 United States 4/27/2017 Claire DeMauro Naples Florida 34108 United States 4/27/2017 Kristin White Naples Florida 34119 United States 4/27/2017 Diana Daily Mount Olive Alabama 35117 United States 4/27/2017 Jennifer Chadwick Naples Florida 34104 United States 4/27/2017 Joanne Morris Naples Florida 34112 United States 4/27/2017 David Burke Naples Florida 34103 United States 5/1/2017 Jack Bills Naples Florida 34106 United States 5/1/2017 Valerie Mercurio Naples Florida 34108 United States 5/1/2017 Barb Senkevich Naples Florida 34109 United States 5/1/2017 Yvonne Hernandez Naples Florida 34108 United.States 5/2/2017 Brad Mathews Naples Florida 34110-1160 United States 5/2/2017 susannah McDonough aa Florida 34038 United States 5/2/2017 Charles Albright Naples Florida 34108 United States 5/2/2017 Debra Laux Naples Florida 34108 United States 5/2/2017 Deborah Dittmann Naples Florida 34108 United States 5/2/2017 Maggie Cody Punta Gorda Florida 33950 United States 5/3/2017 Margie Nissenbaum Naples Florida 34109 United States 5/3/2017 Laurie Von Dollen Naples Florida 34108 United States 5/3/2017 Stephanie EArnhart Naples Florida 34113 United States 5/3/2017 Jason Hartgrave Naples Florida 34108 United States 5/4/2017 Colleen Gill Naples Florida 34114 United States 5/4/2017 Marley Hagerstrom Naples Florida 34112 United States 5/4/2017 randy moffett Naples Florida 34116 United States 5/5/2017 Ernest Zuccarelli Marco Island Florida 34145 United States 5/5/2017 Marci Seamples Naples Florida 34104 United States 5/8/2017 Elaine Malone Naples Florida 34112 United States 5/8/2017 Meredith Wiacek Naples Florida 34120 United States 5/8/2017 Petition for Safe Access to Medical Cannabis Dispensaries • in Collier County Petition We the citizens of Collier County hold that licensed Medical Cannabis access is summary and background critical to the letter and spirit of Amendment 2. Florida voters made very clear our intent when we voiced our agreement to Legal Medical Marijuana by an overwhelming vote of 71.3% in favor of Florida's Amendment 2. This vote amended Article X, Section 29, to allow the"Use of Marijuana for Debilitating Medical Conditions,"with a physician's recommendation and stands aside from limited "Compassionate Use" law, 381.986, Florida Statutes, and chapter 2016- 123, Laws of Florida. We further hold that the moratorium proposed in Collier County places local patients' access to this legal medication at undue risk. On February 14, 2017 the Collier County Board of Commissioners convened their regular meeting. One of the last minute agenda items was to vote on a 6 month moratorium on safe patient access to cannabis within the county. During the meeting the Board of Commissioners upped their original intent and voted on a 12 MONTH moratorium instead; effectively blocking safe and local access to legal medical cannabis. This action is in blatant disregard to the 64.3% of Collier citizens who voted to have safe access to medical cannabis. In addition, the moratorium presents an unjust and unsafe proposition for all patients in Collier County and unilaterally removes our citizens' rights to safe local access to cannabis medication. This initiative comes up again on February 28th for a final vote. Please attend this meeting prepared to speak and to voice your opposition to this unnecessary prohibition of dispensaries. Board of County Commissioners • Date: 02/28/2017 9:00 AM • Location: Board of County Commissioners chambers,third floor, Collier County Government Center 299 Tamiami Trail E., Naples, Florida 34112 In this county we have no problem allowing pharmacies housing far more dangerous medications on every street corner to provide ease of access to medications for our ill or elderly patients. It makes no sense we would deny ready and convenient access of medical cannabis to these same ill or elderly patients. By signing this petition you are letting your Commissioners know the citizens of Collier have already made our voice clear when we voted for access to medical cannabis and we have no intention of allowing further discrimination against this medication that has proven helpful for so many different diseases. It is up to us to protect the Amendments we put in place, therefore we must demand our Board of County Commissioners allow licensed dispensaries to begin to operate in Collier County at the earliest opportunity. Additional ways you can be involved: 1.Voice your concern in email to: Donna Fiala, District 1 Email: DonnaFiala@colliergov.net Andy Solis, Esq. Vice Chairman, District 2 Email:AndySolis@colliergov.net Burt L. Saunders, District 3 Email: BurtSaunders@colliergov.net Penny Taylor, Chairman, District 4 Email: PennyTavlor@colliergov.net William L. McDaniel, Jr., District 5 Email: BillMcDaniel@colliergov.net 2: Consider attending one or both of these two town halls: Commissioner Fiala Town Hall Gathering Date:02/23/2017 6:00 PM Location:Rose Hall Auditorium, adjacent to the Marco Island Historical Museum 180 S. Heathwood Drive. Marco Island, Florida 34145 and Commissioner Andy Solis`s Town Hall Gathering Date:02/21/2017 6:00 PM Location:North Collier Regional Park 15000 Livingston Road, Naples, Florida 34109 Action petitioned We,the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to allow for for safe access to Medical Cannabis Dispensaries in Collier County without delay and to vote down any moratorium on the Medical Cannabis Businesses that may seek to begin operation in the county. 2 ' Page Petition for Medical Cannabis Dispensaries in Collier Printed Name Signature Address Comment Date OJ a.6.1. ma-ie ntid, ej Xin,e. eii, 4L „ e.1 91',9 1 A y 4l?/t7 ei s A cc sS G(eucw- h1Ivu� J-e'. - eny/ 6 A-(°r. hr p y 4;i. r}'1 �� p-e��1e r„ �j� *�i7 P,1L1 K part f),,, 2, • / /1--F-5- (hf et,04S ?K ox . _66 ilf r' ii4 I- "f - L/' 74) Yoe S / 330g-buckiss Vit. l 'a ,il / �t//M(�1,iL 37111- a Nem 1V I�l I �'{ �t`��L'� ,,,._ lora t?»P.61�5� c.r�tki�4i7i 1L1��`t ►o C;,►3IP -. ,. � . f i l �q Pt�S� F►-341) dint c�w,1 too 1. AN: a r1 I rna�U� l J < 3u27 Sacraor4° ct1a.9 ?leap_ wtoiVA_ e.Q;c,.( 7 17 12-oar', c t.Q �-- -- 1J a ce s, R. 3- /OS �,c�v-v,c.6 s es.s�( accc ss�.b k' / 5 � �L441 /55- 9/1.6icoolr c!/1C1. c: rTqc2/7/7 � P /30ANV 5/424/1✓GS�L 94/13 f SSE .✓Alae- d 0/1. CApd / 4.t- 6906240604Pef610(De4t kA,�-//7.7 lbar/ s 34 34- d4n/f/ I fr 6 %3 mbeqo ec 074 /14/074/-11-1 71i 2 v-11-7- Lis -1`t7 74:6- Dw L-/nom j __,40 1y.3- 7-Eillet GkicD pil re 9-see i •dPt.e 2/1/17 flicliAti 01,61, E - U Ld Vii „wv W ,Y i,h 2/17/1'7 I 3L'hO1 G3.:4% A ‘69141 -- ?•, a iw71 7 Ma«► 5e2v151e. .4 , 57421.asy V:11 ,�o Wei w aSom4v 4*g -'Vk 4401, .1.1.-.- t old..r�s 644..\)- Mec9L4'0 a1 a 1 .15-Pal 4it . I, ►" lb V1693NO �� S bAfbA(ic. . 17 )Lrcl sCe------ 2F2360 ; e, D6t1 fl i r,— 16._- (:).,/'I/ i,,d1 r 1M Lc/,., Aj/o, 64e,-01, UL fv(e_ a4�� P 5 ri t ,, ` K t:t -6S - ,,, cc 0.9 fov_t,c> i F a 2`4 4 /7 50,0?-x coBesec j .--1/4----... ---------- c ., .--c-t.e_, cx,if,-(5e4- ,..,_9(kplkirvii,k_ dr V-,6 • re_ ti- Cii- ‘ 't Vi IAO\c-Ai ( -------"-- t1($\& )11 '41' LI tip u rkA ov, s o D j ape,�. S _ 46r.v� A) AUa ci 5 P 33 r�� l ?/1 -7 1 ain 221 Atc(qb Trh S+ t ok'1 � N E- YiD,.pA i-L 34120 2 HI ' 7 $ �a t� r �aSS J/Icil 7(Yrki.N.) 6 C.--"---' ---- LI.,,\et ,� TI CS R-Iiii0 jllei\ .4,1",...- C,� � � l7 3IPage Petition for Medical Cannabis Dispensaries in Collier Printed Name Sig re Address Comment Date ‘,06 /0-24±cr\ if/ /' CI 3 a 4w 5a) /3c-i -r/ech ,r ,i,..5---14- l ,c)) n-= :5 33 ►ti tit ti--# 0"-- ----- ii&U. crrYillAc (t_ qrgAti 4jPage Petition for Medical Cannabis Dispensaries in Collier C 0 O U \ O EQ O O •N U U � , 43 a)o a) O c N. 0 U Q) Q O CI_ o A A A AC) Z SZ 01(7) N J W N < I U < 0 o 0 Z zo OE U z O O C U w < a) u) � a) C � F- U a � c L--- ' I BrownleeMichael Subject: Habitat NIM Meeting for Vincent Project Location: New Hope Ministries - 7675 Davis Blvd 40 Start: Mon 3/21/2016 5:30 PM fc End: Mon 3/21/2016 6:00 PM M Recurrence: (none) 1 (0 40 Organizer: FialaDonna 1 BrownleeMichael Subject: Ashley Caserta, Patrick VanNess, Nick Kouloheras re: Vincent Acres Location: DF Office Start: Wed 9/21/2016 3:30 PM End: Wed 9/21/2016 4:00 PM Recurrence: (none) Organizer: FialaDonna 1 BrownleeMichael From: Lenore Meurer[lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 2:37 PM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: Re: BCC Agenda THANKS! LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT Lely Landings of-Southwest Florida LelyLandings@aol.com 239-234-6236 Original Message From: BrownleeMichael <MichaelBrownleea,colliergov.net> To: Lenore Meurer<lenorem(a).aol.com> Sent: Thu, Sep 1, 2016 2:03 pm Subject: RE: BCC Agendas It appears the Vincent Acres item will be on the 9/27 agenda. From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 1:26 PM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: Re: BCC Agendas Thanks I was on the calendar and hoped to see the agenda already LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of-Southwest Florida LelyLandings@aol.com 239-234-6236 Original Message From: BrownleeMichael <MichaelBrownleecolliergov.net> To: Lenore Meurer<lenorem@aol.com> Sent: Thu, Sep 1, 2016 11:00 am Subject: RE: BCC Agendas Lenore, The BCC agendas are typically not available until the Thursday before the meeting and can be viewed/downloaded from the County Website http://colliergov.net. If you have any troubles finding it after September 8th (for the 9/13 meeting),just let me know and I will try to help. Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net Career Coup Under Florida law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a pubLic records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 8:01 AM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: BCC Agendas Hi Michael, Do you have any of the agendas for the BCC meetings in September? I'm looking for the Vincent Acres due to be scheduled this month. LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings of Southwest Florida LelyLandi ngsOaol.com 239-234-6236 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 BrownleeMichael From: Lenore Meurer[lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Sunday, September 25, 2016 11:11 AM To: donnafiala@gmail.com; BrownleeMichael Subject: Cedar Hammock folks Donna, I've called the residents at Cedar Hammock, too many to count, and got hold of Heritage general manager and sent him information on Vincent Acres, and he put iit in their news bulletin. Cedar people just aren't around, they're not here yet. Dwight wrote the many of them and directed them to contact your office so you may hear from them. Let us know since I am at a loss as to what else we can do. The Guy Michael had that complained is a renter at Cedar Hammock and doesn't know anyone there but has been trying to get to people. I'm heading over now for brunch there, are you hungry??? Talk later, LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT Lely Landings of-Southwest Florida LelyLandings0aol.com 239-234-6236 1 BrownleeMichael From: Dwight Kehoe [dwight@vakdwk.com] Sent: Monday, September 26, 2016 7:57 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: Copies of Letters I Sent Attachments: J. Reckford HFH -Sept. 24 2016.doc; Cedar Hammock Sent.doc; NDN Affordable Housing.doc Donna, Thank you for spending time with us (Lenore Meurer's ad hoc committee) Thursday evening. I hope your knee procedure went well on Friday and that you had a restful weedend. Whenever I mention a person's name in a letter sent to another person, I believe the person mentioned should have a copy of the letter sent. Therefore, attached are copies of three letters I sent this weekend. One is addressed to Mr. Jonathan Reckford, CEO, Habitat For Humanity International in Atlanta. The second I sent to 15 residents of Cedar Hammock whom I believe could be full time Naples residents. Hopefully, they will contact your office with regard to Vincent Acres. The third letter I sent to the Naples Daily News "Letters to the Editor" section. In it you will see that Riviera Golf Estates may again be under the gun to prevent Riviera Golf Club from becoming anything other than a golf course. Thank you for your dedicated service to our County and its residents. Dwight (Kehoe) BrownleeMichael From: DeaneConnie Sent: Monday, July 18, 2016 3:15 PM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: FW: Vincent Acres RPUD (HFH project on Market Street) Hi Michael: In regard to the Aug. 2 meeting. It is for a project called New Hope Ministries PUD and info can be found in the City View portal under PL20150002519. Connie From: DeaneConnie Sent: Monday, July 18, 2016 2:45 PM To: BrownleeMichael Cc: GundlachNancy Subject: RE: Vincent Acres RPUD (HFH project on Market Street) Hi Michael: The applicant is required to hold one Neighborhood Information Meeting (NIM) and that was held on March 21. A public information meeting (PIM) is not required. The Aug. 2 meeting that I found on the NIM tracking chart did not have a planner's name nor a number listed so I am trying to track down what that one is. When I do, I'll let you know. Connie From: BrownleeMichael Sent: Monday, July 18, 2016 2:37 PM To: DeaneConnie Subject: RE: Vincent Acres RPUD (HFH project on Market Street) Thanks Connie! So is there a hearing or PIM scheduled in the future? Is the one you mentioned on the phone (August 2nd at New Hope) regarding this project? Appreciate your help, Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net 1 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-mail address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: DeaneConnie Sent: Monday, July 18, 2016 2:31 PM To: BrownleeMichael Cc: GundlachNancy Subject: FW: Vincent Acres RPUD (HFH project on Market Street) Hi Michael: Principal Planner Nancy Gundlach has provided the attached items in regard to your call to me today asking about the Habitat for Humanity housing project on Market Street. The attachments are: 1. Advertisement for the NIM which was held on 3-21-16; and 2. Synopsis of the meeting. If you need any additional information, please let us know. Kind regards, Connie Deane Communiy Liaison Communiy and Media Relations Section Collier County Growth Management Department 2885 S. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 conniedeana,colliergov.net 239.252.8192 (main) 239.252.8365 (desk) From: GundlachNancy Sent: Monday, July 18, 2016 2:25 PM To: DeaneConnie Subject: Vincent Acres RPUD (HFH project on Market Street) Hi Connie, Attached please find a copy of the Vincent Acres RPUD NIM Synopsis and NDN ad for the NIM . Sincerely, Nancy Gundlach,AICP, PLA# 1244 Principal Planner, Zoning Services 2 Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 (239)252-2484 nancygundlach@'colliergov.net ATTENTION: Be advised that under Florida's Government-in-the-Sunshine law,information contained within this email becomes public record,unless protected by specific exemption. The law provides a right of access to governmental proceedings and documents at both the state and local levels. There is also a constitutionally guaranteed right of access. For more information on this law,visit: Florida's Sunshine Law Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 3 BrownleeMichael From: Lenore Meurer[lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 11:13 AM To: FialaDonna; orschks@comcast.net; shel42@gmail.com Subject: Fwd: Trail Acres resident response She and suzie sold and left Trail Acres, you have Greg's contact info? LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of Southwest FIoric{a LelyLandings0aoLcom 239-234-6236 Original Message From: LAURIE MILLER JENKINS <MILLER.LAURIE(a�hotmail.com> To: Lenore Meurer<lenorem(cr�aol.com> Sent: Tue, Sep 13, 2016 10:43 am Subject: Re: Trail Acres Hello Lenore, thank you for thinking of me in regards to the concerns for East Naples. Unfortunately, I have sold my beautiful home in Trail Acres, primarily because of these issues. It was not something I wanted to do, but felt my home was only going to depreciate more if I stayed. I wish you the best, but I feel there is not much that can be done to stop it. Sincerely, Laurie Miller Jenkins From: Lenore Meurer<lenorem@aol.com> Sent:Sunday, September 11, 2016 10:07 AM To: ieremy.dene@vahoo.com; miller.laurie@hotmail.com; suzifree@comcast.net Cc:shel42@gmail.com Subject:Trail Acres Hi everyone, I was given your email addresses to reach out to you regarding your grave concerns over Habitat for Humanity's buying the properties in your neighborhood and the resulting conditions you are faced with now. I represent the East Naples Community Associaitons who are opposing Habitat's large scale projects planned in our communities, and would like to include you. Do you have any pictures of before and now of your community homes? We are preparing to present to the Board of County Comissioners on 9/27 (HFH Vincent Acres) and I will be returning to town to meet with our group and prepare for this. Please call me as I am interested in what happened, my group will want to know as well. My number is 718-720-6716 home and will be here tomorrow, Monday if you can call then? Or if you like I can call you if you provide a number. Thank you, and hope to hear from you. LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT 1 Lely Landings Of Southwest Florid LelyLandingsc aol.com 239-234-6236 2 BrownleeMichael From: Lenore Meurer[lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 08, 2016 10:50 AM Subject: Fwd: Vincent acres 9/27 Attachments: Staff report-PUDZ-PL20150001945-Vincent Acres RPUD.pdf; Executive Summary in Accela 1849 8-23-16.rtf; Ordinance - 082316.pdf Categories: PRINTED Here is the information from the Project Coordinator, Nancy Gundlach, on Vincent Acres. Vincent is scheduled to be presented on 9/27 to the Board of County Commissioners. I will be back in town 9/21 for it. The transcripts are not yet available and won't be by the BCC, not sure if this is customary procedure since the packet will be incomplete. LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings O(Southwest Florida LelyLandings0aol.com 239-234-6236 Original Message From: GundlachNancy <NancyGundlach@colliergov.net> To: Lenore Meurer<lenorem@aol.com> Sent: Tue, Sep 6, 2016 1:20 pm Subject: RE: Vincent acres Hi Lenore, The CCPC Transcript is not available yet. They are typically available approximately 6 weeks after the CCPC(Collier County Planning Commission) hearing. Attached please find a copy of the Staff Report and Executive Summary. Sincerely, Nancy Gundlach, AICP, PLA# 1244 Principal Planner, Zoning Services Growth Management Department 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 (239)252-2484 nancygundlach@colliergov.net ATTENTION: Be advised that under Florida's Government-in-the-Sunshine law,information contained within this email becomes public record,unless protected by specific exemption. The law provides a right of access to governmental proceedings and documents at both the state and local levels. There is also a constitutionally guaranteed right of access. For more information on this law,visit: Florida's Sunshine Law 1 From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem@aol.com] Sent:Thursday, September 01, 2016 1:33 PM To: GundlachNancy<NancyGundlach@colliergov.net> Subject:Vincent acres Hi Nancy CAN YOU FORWARD ME THE CCPC TRANSCRIPTS AND DOCUMENTS PERTAINING TO THE VINCENT ACRES PROJECT? THANK YOU. LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings O(Southwest Florida LelyLandi ngsOaol.com 239-234-6236 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 BrownleeMichael From: Lenore Meurer[lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Friday, August 05, 2016 4:01 PM Subject: HFH Vincent Acres CCPC scheduled 8/18 @Collier County Attachments: 8-18-2016 CCPC AGENDA Vincent Acres.docx Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged Hi Everyone! Attached please find the Agenda for the CCPC review of HFH Vincent Acres project beng held on August 18th in the Board Room at Collier County. Any objections you have should be sent into Nancy Gundlach, Project Coordinator or Eric Johnson at Collier County. Any who can attend this meeting and object would help greatly! I want to share Collier County's website with you all so you can sign up for email notifications for just about anything happening here in Naples including ALL NIM notifications! You can also watch all BCC meeting broadcasts while you are out of town to keep in touch with whats going on, all in real time. Here is the website just copy and paste into your browser: http://www.colliergov.net/your-government/divisions-a-e/communication-customer-relations-division/sign-up-for-e- notices/ LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings OfSouthwest Florida LenoreMOaol.com 239-234-6236718-720-6716 1 BrownleeMichael From: BrownleeMichael Sent: Friday, September 23, 2016 2:42 PM To: 'gertonw@outlook.com'; 'generalmanager@cedarhammockcc.com' Subject: Vincent Acres Agenda Item for Tuesday Commissioner's Meeting Attachments: 17B Vincent Acres.docx Commissioner Fiala wanted to make the you aware that Board of County Commissioners will be hearing an item on Tuesday September 27th that may have impact on your Community. Below is the Executive Summary and the entire agenda item is attached. Recommendation to approve Vincent Acres RPUD, PUDZ-PL20150001945- An Ordinance amending Ordinance Number 2004-41, as amended, the Collier County Land Development Code, which established the comprehensive zoning regulations for the unincorporated area of Collier County, Florida, by amending the appropriate zoning atlas map or maps by changing the zoning classification of the herein described real property from a residential multi-family- 12 district (RMF-12 (10)) zoning district to a Residential Planned Unit Development (RPUD) zoning district for the project to be known as the Vincent Acres RPUD, to allow construction of a maximum of 85 single-family residential dwelling units or 118 townhouse residential dwelling units on property located west of Collier Boulevard at the southwest corner of Davis Boulevard and Market Street. The meeting is open to the public. Regards, Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net Coder County Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-mail address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. 1 BrownleeMichael From: Lenore Meurer[lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 1:26 PM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: Re: BCC Agendas Thanks I was on the calendar and hoped to see the agenda already LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of Southwest Florida LelyLanclings0aol.com 239-234-6236 Original Message From: BrownleeMichael <MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net> To: Lenore Meurer <lenorem@aol.com> Sent: Thu, Sep 1, 2016 11:00 am Subject: RE: BCC Agendas Lenore, The BCC agendas are typically not available until the Thursday before the meeting and can be viewed/downloaded from the County Website http://colliergov.net. If you have any troubles finding it after September 8th (for the 9/13 meeting), just let me know and I will try to help. Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net Co r County Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 8:01 AM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: BCC Agendas Hi Michael, Do you have any of the agendas for the BCC meetings in September? I'm looking for the Vincent Acres due to be scheduled this month. LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of Southwest Florida LelyLandi ngs0aol.com 239-234-6236 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 BrownleeMichael From: BrownleeMichael Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 10:59 AM To: 'Lenore Meurer' Subject: RE: BCC Agendas Lenore, The BCC agendas are typically not available until the Thursday before the meeting and can be viewed/downloaded from the County Website http://colliergov.net. If you have any troubles finding it after September Bch (for the 9/13 meeting), just let me know and I will try to help. Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East,Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net CA* r C:iruyy Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 8:01 AM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: BCC Agendas Hi Michael, Do you have any of the agendas for the BCC meetings in September? I'm looking for the Vincent Acres due to be scheduled this month. LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings of Southwest Florid LelyLandings0aol.com 239-234-6236 1 BrownleeMichael From: BrownleeMichael Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 2:03 PM To: 'Lenore Meurer' Subject: RE: BCC Agendas It appears the Vincent Acres item will be on the 9/27 agenda. From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem@aol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 1:26 PM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: Re: BCC Agendas Thanks I was on the calendar and hoped to see the agenda already LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of Southwest Florida LelyLandings0aol.com 239-234-6236 Original Message From: BrownleeMichael <MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net> To: Lenore Meurer<Ienorem(a aol.com> Sent: Thu, Sep 1, 2016 11:00 am Subject: RE: BCC Agendas Lenore, The BCC agendas are typically not available until the Thursday before the meeting and can be viewed/downloaded from the County Website http://colliergov.net. If you have any troubles finding it after September 8th (for the 9/13 meeting), just let me know and I will try to help. Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem(aaol.com] Sent: Thursday, September 01, 2016 8:01 AM To: BrownleeMichael Subject: BCC Agendas Hi Michael, Do you have any of the agendas for the BCC meetings in September? I'm looking for the Vincent Acres due to be scheduled this month. LENORE MEVRER PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of Southwest Florida LelyLa ndi ngs@aol.com 239-234-6236 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 BrownleeMichael From: BrownleeMichael on behalf of FialaDonna Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 1:23 PM To: 'Lenore Meurer' Subject: RE: Trail Acres resident response Greg Westgate 825-0441 From: Lenore Meurer [mailto:lenorem@aaol.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 13, 2016 11:13 AM To: FialaDonna; orschks@comcast.net; she142©gmail.com Subject: Fwd: Trail Acres resident response She and suzie sold and left Trail Acres, you have Greg's contact info? LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings Of-Southwest Florida LelyLandings0aol.com 239-234-6236 Original Message From: LAURIE MILLER JENKINS <MILLER.LAURIE(a hotmail.com> To: Lenore Meurer<lenorem(c�aol.com> Sent: Tue, Sep 13, 2016 10:43 am Subject: Re: Trail Acres Hello Lenore, thank you for thinking of me in regards to the concerns for East Naples. Unfortunately, I have sold my beautiful home in Trail Acres, primarily because of these issues. It was not something I wanted to do, but felt my home was only going to depreciate more if I stayed. I wish you the best, but I feel there is not much that can be done to stop it. Sincerely, Laurie Miller Jenkins From: Lenore Meurer<lenorem@aol.com> Sent: Sunday, September 11, 2016 10:07 AM To: jeremy.dene@yahoo.com; miller.laurie@hotmail.com; suzifree@comcast.net Cc: shel42@gmail.com Subject:Trail Acres Hi everyone, I was given your email addresses to reach out to you regarding your grave concerns over Habitat for Humanity's buying the properties in your neighborhood and the resulting conditions you are faced with now. I represent the East Naples Community Associaitons who are opposing Habitat's large scale projects planned in our communities, and would like to include you. Do you have any pictures of before and now of your community homes? We are preparing to present to the Board of County Comissioners on 9/27 (HFH Vincent Acres) and I will be returning to town to meet with our group and prepare for this. Please call me as I am interested in what happened, my group will want to know as well. 1 My number is 718-720-6716 home and will be here tomorrow, Monday if you can call then? Or if you like I can call you if you provide a number. Thank you, and hope to hear from you. LENORE MEURER PRESIDENT Lely Landings OfSouthwest Florida LelyLandingsOaol.com 239-234-6236 2 BrownleeMichael From: BrownleeMichael Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2016 3:35 PM To: 'lenorem@aol.com' Subject: Vincent Acres Agenda Item/Counts by District Attachments: 17B_Vincent Acres.docx; Residential Units under 126000a.pdf; Habitat Homes in E Naples Boundary 061616.pdf Lenore, Per our discussion, here is the information you requested. Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg"F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net Cott Colinty Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. 1 s a` -1+' rT sy•,•t.�+: ` �'i "i S:ii lop a"L ro _ a`; >< N rP ` �� i i• i S . !lata Z If; l.,0—.� yaar.. .., a ivis. . a as .cl . �«sc wi PROJECT 1 G�. ss.?� 28 S i S ii sa xma-7• L#'L: i I r/l�Rl6/�/G�r1 ce`y 12 iss� '''''#`-''''''''' Ha (L`. jar w esu -4„,..i V # a'3s V4 az i LOCATION IiffiII! wa 77 !K n N•e n ?' .41.1,. e y Iw r • a Z K- i �UM`Y r •i-+r�� ti.�M.\ __ ie4• ••a,Of N•.a l� I !•✓M M N tY YNM! 1 , +✓1,u . \\ } 1 -1� I 1 $ AAA`l k X' i 41 jr: ,...�_�...�......e_r,--a IY D 1NTER5TATE -75 I * 36 yy— k' ,fi r# \'''T � -: .` , s114 ti tem . SUFI - i a!tiu .mss ti► :+x��• +{-.�1. r1 q4s-.INIC PI �3 - ar i/a+Aiio,rata-. If V 0, -�-:�7 fV'R+RD s •. • 1_i E 4�'��iI�•i� � ��_ i ROAD rr I 3 _ i `� 1 -Lr I1 15 1 1 2 .,, -7,1 1 .-i i I tST J ..� i s , !y f-1 s . I t 7 to t '''s•---,--;..-:-.- ec `4 ( l ai 1 a /W i _ I .. _ ��.."-. :fid'`l - ` .�-, t � PROJECT LOCATION NOT TO SCALE��...—�..._._...__...�...._ 1 BrownleeMichael From: BrownleeMichael on behalf of FialaDonna Sent: Friday, April 29, 2016 10:07 AM To: Fugow6@aol.com Subject: RE: NO CHANGE PLEASE Dear Cpt. MgGrath, di • PC11116 Thank you for your email. Commissioner Fiala values your thoughts. Regards, Michael Brownlee Executive Coordinator to Commissioner Donna Fiala, District#1 W. Harmon Turner Building- Bldg "F" 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#303 Naples, FL 34112 P: (239) 252-8601 F: (239) 252-6578 MichaelBrownlee@colliergov.net Cotter iter CvuvitV Under FLorida Law, e-mail addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send eLectronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Fugow6( aol.com [mailto:Fugow6@aol.com] Sent: Friday, April 29, 2016 9:51 AM To: FialaDonna Subject: NO CHANGE PLEASE DEAR COMMISSIONER FIALA AFTER READING THE PROPOSAL BY TOLLGATE COMMERCIAL CENTER TO CHANGE PUD ORDINANCE 92-10 FROM IT'S PRESENT STRUCTURE TO CHANGE IT TO PERMIT EVERYTHING FROM AMUSEMENT RIDES,RIDING STABLES,GO CART RENTALS AND AN ADDITIONAL ONE HUNDRED FIFTY OTHER USES WAS NOT THE ORIGANAL INTENT OF THE ORDINANCE. ANY CHANGE TO THIS DEGREE WILL HAVE A SEVERE IMPACT TO THE TRANQUILITY AND ATMOSPHERE OF OUR AREA AND MAY CAUSE A DROP IN THE VALUE OF OUR HOMES IN FOREST GLEN. WE ARE ASKING OF YOU. AND YOUR FELLOW COMMISSIONERS TO LEAVE THE ORDINANCE TO IT'S ORIGANAL FORM. WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR HARD WORK AND AND FOR BEING OUR COMMISSIONER HERE AT FOREST GLEN WHICH ABUTS BECK BLVD. SINCERELY CAPTAIN TERRENCE McGRATH (RET.) 3646 PERIWINKLE WAY NAPLES, FL 34114 354-3323 2 S&9rty STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: ZONING DIVISION—ZONING SERVICES SECTION GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT HEARING DATE: JANUARY 5,2017 SUBJECT: PUDA-PL20150002280: TOLLGATE COMMERCIAL CENTER PUD PROPERTY OWNER,APPLICANT&AGENT: Owner/Applicant: Agents: Sky Angel Center,LLC Richard D.Yovanovich,Esq. 1300 Goodlette Road North Coleman,Yovanovich&Koester,P.A. Naples,FL 34102 4001 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 300 Naples,FL 34103 Toll Gate Naples,LLC 3845 Beck Boulevard, Suite 807 Robert L.Duane,AICP Naples,FL 34114 Robert L.Duane&Associates 4880 Tamarind Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34119 REQUESTED ACTION: The Tollgate Commercial Center Planned Unit Development (PUD) currently permits various uses as shown in Ordinance 92-10. The Applicant requests amending the PUD document to add specific institutional uses as permitted uses on Tracts 7-10, and 15 of the commercial use areas, "A" parcels, as shown on the PUD Master Plan; by amending the PUD document to add specific institutional uses as permitted uses on tracts 16-20 and 24-25 of the commercial/light industrial uses area,"B"parcels,as shown on the PUD Master Plan;and by adding Exhibit B to further define the areas that allow the institutional uses as permitted uses GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The subject property is 100.23±acres in size and is located in the northeast quadrant of the intersection of Collier Boulevard and Davis/Beck Boulevard.The site is within the boundaries of Activity Center Number 9.The site is partially developed.(See location map on the following page). Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 1 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC I PINE MOE ROAD 1011.Sao '> CalFlt G 15 w A � _ ,5COWER pop ... A16� a eOUM WC RIM a18 wM1,ES P °'a s .Pm mtaeaum m COM. Wirr 15 ' mt�.a.� i J� .61,51E APY5 v 9 amt MAX PLO Y am BOO.PM .rw�"I! I• A pp ..w Pme AD 10 32 33 24 19 ` 1 MOO i i -,o,t,,,,GOLDEN GATE W 11161 l 1 E uv AGE - 1 - j r';p" �w.en sAt+rc na,nxu• Gmha Nail me e i 27 26 25 30 Mohr �eaGa + � PROJECT ��• AWE.kµP � ..4 917E r LOCATION cPw; \ LOCATION win a 8 nr. .- ° < j 1 .... m a.. IL a:,. ...NINE -Nwaint5 .�� = ,f a a D t til s: .- atwf,. .f G.wax w e I r 'i�` ice, Ho I Y atn,FS,pitta 7---41I ' PUD 1111 tw tp caEFZ nta PUD L.1 warm wam 4.a 4:fr.I 1 Ili .,q,..i'.9 -- �+ a. � 10 naxn1. 11t > r: PUD ' I _ i te. .atElt I 6i• twm wtmrvrtnox a7mar i�.. ✓.ar1 . 1 C •-:•:AS:\NPW ^_ PIO i> I It LAWS wirer161 .- te 5 t 14IonD r t] ROYAL to sae Wilk ''''acx LOCATION MAP ZONING MAP # PETITION PUDA-PL-2015-2280 ACTIVITY CENTER #9 �61.13� ?u'��iulunn :t ilia:.S . u . __. I c <,...r+..a.I+.,M. Is ' R 961 INTERSTATE 716 �1� �.. r/tifi u p1y/i cc 1 A . $11111111PRIMItILIMP..1f11/1H W t111p,ini CI It I Iuuhtl pnj kt! 1`7 t 1 .aA 11 yiuc1111t•n\ .� _ _ I 1 — . ,. wr„�• a. . !.....1......L ^+__.3_i rra 4a! 47.7 J r r��h�� r�.tw°.� LI . . ;1,61,;;_„,A v4''''kk, ..,. \i a ' ..� `_. • .mom N+Nula 111. wm 0 1 An A , '," �' 1111,1114,4 no — qll� .J,fi i mi sl 1 i—*1., -_-/ig...,......., .._ f, ....e . no }' NV mm I$ !� alai a .,4 no ar :VAT i I P. AMENDED - SEPiENIBER 13.ZDII i g ..,' 11��!{ F �L mesa .ro. I uv (Ord No 3011-26) INAD 0\" g 1 ' \ i /I -,:.,V-., ,..-, ef .uo (' '4.'Lay"... �'rtr ) ---., I. LEGEND ` J —,7...-4ClJ1..,,? .envy.CENTER BOUNDARY '"' 1` � r = A RYJ EMSnNG ZONING Abs.-- .. ♦ + = S✓` ! h Q of noPm UK/DSE ~ = - i 5 ;�►EXISTING BUILDINGS AND STRUCTURES z ,. PURPOSE AND DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: The Tollgate PUD was originally approved on January 17, 1984, as a commercial/light industrial project. It has been amended several times over the years. The proposed amendment would add institutional uses and would not affect the maximum square footage or development standards. SURROUNDING LAND USE AND ZONING: North: Interstate- 75 ROW, across which is the White Lake Industrial Corporate Park PUD; intensity: 136.5 acres of industrial and 7.8 acres of commercial. East: State offices and a communication tower,zoned Rural Agricultural(A). South: Beck Boulevard ROW, across which is the residential and (undeveloped) commercial Forest Glen of Naples PUD; intensity: 100,000 SF of commercial uses. West: Collier Boulevard ROW, across which are developed and undeveloped parcels; zoned I- 75/Alligator Alley CPUD; intensity: 265,000 SF of commercial uses; and General Commercial(C-4); intensity: per LDC Section 2.03.03.D. r , J ;ire 4. 9111 4'1t,, Alt*�1��^i a.� 4: t if s 0sdCR a. s Elis - Subfil- ject . �. ' ..3 . Site i-liPs:r J r' Aerial Photo(CCPA) GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP)CONSISTENCY: The Tollgate Commercial Center PUD was determined to be consistent with the GMP at the time of the original rezone.Staff reviewed the proposed amendment to determine if the petition can be found consistent with the goals, objectives,and policies of the overall GMP. CONSERVATION AND COASTAL MANAGEMENT ELEMENT (CCME): The proposed amendment to the PUD will have no effect on the requirements of the CCME. FUTURE LAND USE ELEMENT (FLUE): The subject property is designated Urban, Urban Commercial District,Interchange Activity Center(IAC)Subdistrict#9,as depicted on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) and in the Future Land Use Element (FLUE) of the Collier County Growth Management Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 4 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC Plan(GMP). The proposed PUDA may be deemed consistent with the FLUE of the Growth Management Plan. TRANSPORTATION ELEMENT: Transportation Planning staff has reviewed the proposed amendment and has found it consistent with the Transportation Element. ANALYSIS: Staff has completed a comprehensive evaluation of this land use petition including the criteria upon which a recommendation must be based, specifically noted in LDC Subsection 10.02.13 B.5, Planning Commission Hearing and Recommendation (commonly referred to as the "PUD Findings"), and Subsection, 10.02.08 F.,Nature of Requirements of Planning Commission Report(referred to as"Rezone Findings"),which establish the legal basis to support the Collier County Planning Commission's(CCPC) recommendation. The CCPC uses these same criteria as the basis for their recommendation to the Board, who in turn use the criteria to support their action on the rezoning request.An evaluation relative to these subsections is discussed below. In addition,staff offers the following analyses. Environmental Review: Environmental Planning staff has reviewed the petition and the PUD Document for environmental sufficiency. This project does not require review by the Environmental Advisory Council (EAC) since the project did not meet the EAC scope of land development project reviews as identified in Section 2-1193 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Transportation Review: Transportation staff reviewed the PUDA and found the Level of Service continues to be acceptable. Zoning Review: The Applicant wishes to add institutional uses to the existing PUD. The subject site is within an Interstate Activity Center(Number 9). FINDINGS OF FACT: This PUD Amendment qualifies as a Substantial Change under LDC Section 10.02.13.E.1.b,"a proposed increase in the total number of dwelling units or intensity of land use or height of buildings within the development." PUD Findings: LDC Subsection 10.02.13.B.5 states that, "In support of its recommendation, the CCPC shall make findings as to the PUD Master Plan's compliance with the following criteria"(Staffs responses to these criteria are provided in bold font): 1. The suitability of the area for the type and pattern of development proposed in relation to physical characteristics of the land, surrounding areas, traffic and access, drainage, sewer, water, and other utilities. Staff has reviewed the proposed PUD Amendment and believes that the addition of certain institutional uses are compatible within an Interstate Activity Center. The addition will not have a major effect on traffic and other infrastructure. 2.Adequacy of evidence of unified control and suitability of any proposed agreements, contracts, or other instruments, or for amendments in those proposed, particularly as they may relate to arrangements or provisions to be made for the continuing operation and maintenance of such areas and facilities that are not to be provided or maintained at public expense. Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 5 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC Unified control was established at the time of rezoning and continues through the present ownership. 3. Conformity of the proposed Planned Unit Development with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Growth Management Plan (GMP). Staff has reviewed this petition and has determined that this amendment to add institutional uses does not affect the PUD's consistency with the GMP,therefore,staff is of the opinion that this petition may be found consistent with the overall GMP. 4. The internal and external compatibility of proposed uses, which conditions may include restrictions on location of improvements, restrictions on design, and buffering and screening requirements. The proposed change is the addition of uses.Staff believes that the approval of this amendment will not cause any compatibility issues. S. The adequacy of usable open space areas in existence and as proposed to serve the development. The Applicant proposes to add uses. Open space will not be affected. 6. The timing or sequence of development for the purpose of assuring the adequacy of available improvements and facilities, both public and private. It is staff's opinion that the addition of new permitted uses will not affect public or private facilities beyond what was approved in the existing PUD. 7. The ability of the subject property and of surrounding areas to accommodate expansion. The current PUD was found consistent with the GMP and compatible with the neighborhood. The addition of the proposed permitted uses is consistent with the uses in an Interstate Activity Center. 8. Conformity with PUD regulations, or as to desirable modifications of such regulations in the particular case, based on determination that such modifications are justified as meeting public purposes to a degree at least equivalent to literal application of such regulations. The proposed amendment is consistent with the uses in an Interstate Activity Center. Rezone Findings:LDC Subsection 10.02.08.F.states,"When pertaining to the rezoning of land,the report and recommendations from the Planning Commission to the Board of County Commissioners...shall show that the Planning Commission has studied and considered proposed change in relation to the following when applicable"(Staff's responses to these criteria are provided in bold font): 1. Whether the proposed change will be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Future Land Use Map and the elements of the Growth Management Plan. The proposed use is consistent with the uses in an Interstate Activity Center. Staff recommends that this petition be deemed consistent with the GMP. 2. The existing land use pattern. The existing land use pattern was reviewed and approved at the time of the original rezone. The proposed amendment will not substantially alter that pattern. Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 6 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC 3. The possible creation of an isolated district unrelated to adjacent and nearby districts. No new districts will be created through this amendment. 4. Whether existing district boundaries are illogically drawn in relation to existing conditions on the property proposed for change. This amendment will not affect existing district boundaries. S. Whether changed or changing conditions make the passage of the proposed rezoning necessary. Staff believes that this location is appropriate for institutional uses in addition to the approved commercial and light industrial uses. 6. Whether the proposed change will adversely influence living conditions in the neighborhood. Religious institutions and other institutional uses are generally compatible with both residential and non-residential uses. 7. Whether the proposed change will create or excessively increase traffic congestion or create types of traffic deemed incompatible with surrounding land uses, because of peak volumes or projected types of vehicular traffic, including activity during construction phases of the development, or otherwise affect public safety. Transportation staff reviewed the PUD and found the Level of Service acceptable. 8. Whether the proposed change will create u drainage problem. The PUD is required to meet South Florida Water Management District standards and therefore, will not create a drainage issue. 9. Whether the proposed change will seriously reduce light and air to adjacent areas. The site planning process,PUD dimensional standards,and LDC requirements will ensure that light and air circulation are not seriously affected. 10. Whether the proposed change will adversely affect property values in the adjacent area. This is a subjective determination based upon anticipated results,which may be internal or external to the subject property. Property valuation is affected by many factors including zoning; however, zoning by itself may or may not affect values, since value determination is driven by market conditions. 11. Whether the proposed change will be a deterrent to the improvement or development of adjacent property in accordance with existing regulations. Since the Tollgate Commercial Center PUD is existing, the proposed amendment should not be a deterrent to the improvement of adjacent properties. 12. Whether the proposed change will constitute a grant of special privilege to an individual owner as contrasting with the public welfare. Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 7 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC The proposed development complies with the GMP which is a public policy statement supporting zoning actions when they are consistent with said Comprehensive Plan. In light of this fact, the proposed change does not constitute a grant of special privilege. Consistency with the FLUE is further determined to be a public welfare relationship because actions consistent with plans are in the public interest. 13. Whether there are substantial reasons why the property cannot be used in accordance with existing zoning. The subject property has been developed within the parameters of the existing land-uses; however, the addition of institutional uses to the current permitted uses will be consistent with the uses in an Interstate Activity Center. 14. Whether the change suggested is out of scale with the needs of the neighborhood or the County. The subject PUD was evaluated at the rezoning stage and was deemed consistent with the GMP. The GMP is a policy statement which has evaluated the scale,density,and intensity of land uses deemed to be acceptable throughout the urban-designated areas of Collier County. Staff is of the opinion that the development standards and the developer commitments will ensure that the project is not out of scale with the needs of the community. 15. Whether is it impossible to find other adequate sites in the County for the proposed use in districts already permitting such use. There are other parcels in the County suitable for institutional uses.However,an Interstate Activity Center is deemed to be a place for diverse uses. 16. The physical characteristics of the property and the degree of site alteration, which would be required to make the property usable for any of the range of potential uses under the proposed zoning classification. This project will undergo evaluation relative to all federal,state,and local development regulations during the site development plan approval process and again as part of the building permit process. However,since the site is partially developed,this process will be minimal. 17. The impact of development on the availability of adequate public facilities and services consistent with the levels of service adopted in the Collier County Growth Management Plan and as defined and implemented through the Collier CountyAdequate Public Facilities Ordinance, as amended This petition has been reviewed by County staff who is responsible for jurisdictional elements of the GMP as part of the PUD process and staff has concluded that no Level of Service will be adversely impacted with the commitments contained in the PUD Document. 18. Such other factors, standards, or criteria that the Board of County Commissioners (Board)shall deem important in the protection of the public health, safety, and welfare. To be determined by the Board during its advertised public hearing. Deviation Discussion: The petitioner is not seeking approval of any deviations from the requirements of the LDC. Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 8 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL(EAC)REVIEW: This project does not require review by the EAC since the project did not meet the EAC scope of land development project reviews. NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING(NIM): A NIM was held on April 21,2016 at 5:30 PM at the Tollgate Commercial Center. Questions were asked, but no objections were voiced. The NIM summary is attached as part of the back-up. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney's office reviewed this Staff Report on December 20,2016. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the CCPC forward Petition PUDA-PL20150002280 to the Board with a recommendation of approval. Attachments: Draft Ordinance Application& Support Material Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 9 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC PREPARED BY: e-4-2 -/4, FRE I FSCHL,AICP,PRINCIPAL PLANNER DATE ZONING DIVISION REVIEWED BY: l RAYMOI'V. ELLOWS,ZONING MANAGER DATE ZONING DIVISION ( z -Z t' - i MIKE BOSI,AICP,DIRECTOR DATE ZONING DIVISION APPROVED BY: � / / 1 LP • • FRE CH, DEPUTY DEPARTMENT HEAD DATE • r TH MAN GEMENT DEPARTMENT DAVID S.WILKISON,DEPARTMENT HEAD DATE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT Tentatively scheduled for the February 14,2017 BCC Meeting. Tollgate Commercial Center PUD,PUDA-PL20150002280 Page 10 of 10 January 5,2017 CCPC