Bayshore Beautification MSTU Minutes 06/06/2018
1
Agenda item 4a– June 6, 2018 meeting minutes
BAYSHORE BEAUTIFICATION MSTU MINUTES OF THE JUNE 6, 2018 MEETING
The meeting of the Bayshore Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee was called to order
by CRA Operations Coordinator, Shirley Garcia, at 5:00 p.m. at the CRA Office, 3750
Bayshore Drive, Unit 102, Naples, FL 34112
I. Roll Call: Advisory Board Members Present: Maurice Gutierrez, George Douglas,
Robert Messmer, and Sandra Arafet. Excused Absence: Sheila DiMarco
MSTU Staff Present: Shirley Garcia, Operations Coordinator; Tami Scott, Senior
Project Mgr.; Debrah Forester, CRA Director; Naomi Hutcheson, Administrative
Assistant.
II. Elections for Chair and Vice Chair: George Douglas nominated Maurice Gutierrez
for Committee Chair. Second by Robert Messmer. Sandra Arafet Third. Maurice
Gutierrez will assume the responsibilities of Bayshore Beautification MSTU Chair.
Sheila DiMarco will retain her position as Bayshore Beautification MSTU Vice-Chair
III. Pledge of Allegiance: Led by Chairman Maurice Gutierrez
IV. Adoption of Agenda: Motion to accept Agenda as written by Robert Messmer. Second
by Sandra Arafet. Passed Unanimously
V. Adoption of Minutes: Motion to accept May 2, 2018 Minutes as written by George
Douglas. Second by Robert Messmer. Passed Unanimously.
VI. Community/ Business Presentations:
A. Update on Landscaping—Aaron Gross, Ground Zero Landscaping—With
summer here they are very busy keeping up with weeds and pruning, as well as
working with the rain. Spraying is about half done. A foxtail was mowed over near
the Real McCaw. Aaron will look into whether it can be replanted or if a new plant
is needed. Maurice Gutierrez made a directive for staff to make the best decision
regarding the foxtail, so long as it does not exceed $700. Shirley Garcia, turns the
irrigation system on twice a week for 20 minute intervals.
VII. Old Business:
A. Relocation of Irrigation Pump Becca and Bayshore: Renegotiations on the
Irrigation Pump in the easement of the Food Truck Park development have resulted
in a deduction of MSTU funds towards the project from approximately $13k to
2
$10k. Initially, there were a few wiring issues, which resulted in the pump flooding
the area. All technicalities have been addressed, and Aaron has informed staff that
everything is up and running appropriately. The next hurdle is the reimbursement.
Sandra Herrera in Procurement Services recommends addressing it as a Settlement
Agreement between the MSTU and the property owner for tracking and record
keeping purposes. A modified map of the easement should be obtained and included
in the records of the transaction. Staff will reach out to Jennifer Belpedio in the
County Attorney’s Office to have the appropriate documents drawn up. Hopefully
before the Board of County Commissioners break for their summer recess.
B. Thomasson Drive-Staff Update: Good news: Staff has met with Procurement and
the CEI services and Contract have been put out to bid. Bad news: time line a few
months behind original anticipation. CEI’s are on site every day, all day and integral
to project. The current dates should work well with the school schedule. Staff has
specifically requested that contractors have roundabout experience, high MOT
training, and experience working with Florida Power & Lighting (FPL). The project
will not just be judged by the final product, but by the process and effect on the
community. The MSTU wants things to go as smoothly as possible so that the
community is more receptive to future endeavors. FPL will do their schedule
underground work in coordination with construction contractors. FPL hardening
project is missing a link and must verify existing conditions. Both Windstar and
Mattamay have received the projected timeline. ROW agreements to be determined.
Appropriate timing to install a Coming Soon sign (possibly recycling the Fire
Suppression Sign) with images of the project were discussed. There will be a kick-
off meeting for the community. Past community meetings dealing with concerns
about the roundabout have been successful and more have been suggested as the
roundabout completion nears.
C. Redevelopment Plan: The Redevelopment Plan schedule was included in the
Agenda Packet. The contract with Tindal Oliver has been extended 60 days. There
will be a Community Workshop Forum on September 6, 2018 at the Naples
Botanical Gardens, to look over the Draft Plans and refine the goals and visions of
the CRA. October 11, 2018 will be a Special CRA Meeting to Recommend the
Adoption of the document. A map was included for Committee members to see the
outcome of the Community Workshops in April 2018.
VIII. New Business: None.
IX. Staff Report:
A. Project List Update: Tami Scott, Senior Project Manager, highlighted a few points
from the Project Managers Report. The Food Truck Park is under construction and
scheduled for completion in September 2018. The Microbrewery is under
construction and scheduled for completion in October 2018. Harborside Animal
Clinic had its groundbreaking on May 15, 2018 and is estimated to be a one year
3
project. Woodsprings Suites site is cleared. A cement dump from past US 41
construction was discovered causing delays in infrastructure work. Starbucks shell
site work is completed. A separate contractor will be coming in to fill the store.
Opening scheduled for October 2018. Racetrac has had no movement since the pre-
app in March. The old Racetrac site has been sold to William Hicks, who owns
other properties in the Mini Triangle. Compass Pointe is back on the market. Cirrus
Pointe has been sold. The CRA has reached out to the new owners and anticipates
a July meeting. Mattamay homes has not provided any updates. Sabal Bay’s fencing
has been put up and the site cleared. Courthouse Shadows has been put on hold. The
site that used to be the Greyhound station on Davis Blvd had a site approval a year
ago. The site is now starting work on a commercial business mixed use building.
Phase III of Porsche construction—accessory use with power washer—has been put
on hold. Holmes Oil is moving to Radio Rd but there have been technical problems
with moving the gas tanks and DAP. This is delaying their move, which is delaying
the move of Porsche onto the Holmes Oil property. Sunbelt Rentals are building a
new building. Sara Bay Marina has torn down the building that used to be boat
storage. Este/Airport C5 parcel just outside district is available. Naples Classic Car
on Davis is putting in a new building. The relocation of the Cell tower will require
approximately $750k from the CRA. Once the tower is moved than closing on the
property can start. Trio recently sold for $4M. Staff has not heard anything about
zoning changes. Staff looking into a design workshop with consultants reaching out
to corporations in the Bayshore Area to incentives site changes and uses. Arno with
the 17 Acres has requested $2.4M from the CRA to assist in funding the project.
The CRA Advisory Board has rejected his request. Arno responded to CRA Staff
on June 6, 2018 that they would revert to the original deal, but would like to change
the planned apartments into condos and remove the parking garage due to steel
tariffs and increasing construction cost. The 17 Acres go to the BCC on June 26,
2018. Should negotiations with Arno not pan out, the CRA will have to come up
with a new plan. The MSTU Committee suggest the CRA look in to extending
Sugden Park.
B. Financials: An updated Actuals was distributed to the Committee for review.
X. Correspondence and Communications:
A. MSTU Member Vacancies: There are currently two open Committee Member
position. They are advertised on the County Website, as well as the MSTU Agenda.
The Committee request that staff include advertisement of the vacancies in the CRA
monthly Agenda and Communication. Suggestion of adding to Old Business, so
that it is addressed earlier in the meeting. Steve Rigsbee, soon to be appointed CRA
Advisory Board Member, will be reaching out to Gateway Triangle Residents to see
if they are interested in extending the Bayshore MSTU boundaries to include their
neighborhood.