The URL can be used to link to this page

VAB Agenda 08-06-2018 Item 8 08/06/2018 Item 8 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation to authorize the VAB Legal Counsel and the Board Clerk to seek alternative special magistrates to serve during the 2018 Value Adjustment Board (VAB) Tax Cycle, if necessary OBJECTIVE: To authorize the VAB Legal Counsel and Board Clerk to seek additional special magistrates, if petition filings deem necessary. CONSIDERATIONS: Per Florida Statute (F.S.), Chapter 194.035 (1) ... "In counties having a population of more than 75,000, the board shall appoint special magistrates for the purpose of taking testimony and making recommendations to the board, which recommendations the board may act upon without further hearing. These special magistrates may not be elected or appointed officials or employees of the county but shall be selected from a list of those qualified individuals who are willing to serve as special magistrates. Employees and elected or appointed officials of a taxing jurisdiction or of the state may not serve as special magistrates." "The Department of Revenue shall provide a list of qualified special magistrates to any county with a population of 75,000 or less". RECOMMENDATION: To authorize VAB Legal Counsel and the Board Clerk, ONLY if deemed necessary, to seek additional magistrates to fulfill the requirements of F.S. 194.035 (1). Attachments • SAMPLE: DOR Special Magistrates List for 2017 Petitions (Previous Year) • SAMPLE: DOR List of Persons Who Have Taken/Completed the 2017 Training (Previous Year) SPECIAL MAGISTRATES LIST for 2017 PETITIONS As described in section 194.035(1), Florida Statutes. Prepared as of November 30, 2017. NOTE: This list contains and relies on magistrates' credential information from the clerks of the value adjustment boards. The clerks supplied this information in response to a November 2017 survey on special magistrates who are contracted to hear 2017 petitions. The Property Tax Oversight Technical Assistance unit keeps this list up-to-date. Special magistrates' addresses and some phone numbers are available by request through VAB@floridarevenue.com. The Department of Revenue does not certify or approve special magistrates as qualified to hear cases on behalf of county value adjustment boards. The Department of Revenue has not validated the information on this list and makes no assurances as to whether any magistrate has any of the indicated credentials. tip.. _ .. �.. Mag& 7. `a,' X.:4,Z1:A,4 !..,I1011` '. cgs`^ 11';' m, � gdlIkwcithz Last Name FirSt Name CoUnty , County County I County , County Abrams I Perla Miami-Dade Bedsole James Flagler Nassau Birnholz Standford Broward Bombino Isabel P. Miami-Dade _ Bruner, Esq. James ? Leon Carlin Lee Alachua Duval St.Johns Ceasar Mitchell Broward Chadwell Ellen Charlotte Collier Hendry Lee Davis, Esq. Joseph Haynes Brevard Hillsborough Leon Marion Orange Osceola Pasco Polk Sumter Volusia Eskuchen Martha Jackson Garcia Raul I Miami-Dade Gossett,Jr. Gary R. Highlands Grace-Jones Dawn E. Broward Gruskin David 3 Pinellas Hoepker Todd Citrus I Lake Orange Hood Adam Bay Johns Dianne M. 1 Hillsborough Johnson Andrea Citrus Manatee Lasa Fiorella Miami-Dade Matthews Larry A. Escambia _._ Mazur Davia O. ; Broward Miami-Dade Palm Beach Meade Michael Walton Miller Glenn Miami-Dade Parwani Rinky Brevard Manatee Seminole Pelletier Claudette Brevard Miami-Dade Sumter PribellKevin Volusia Rutland Lori L. Hillsborough Lee Pasco Pinellas Sarasota Samaha Charles Hillsborough Pasco Pinellas Sanders Paul Clay Schmidt David I Martin Palm Beach St. Lucie Stump Daniel St. Lucie Taylor Matthew Palm Beach Trentelman John C. Marion 1 Last Name First Name County County County C aflty = ,,,„,„„county .,` coop, Tukdarian Thomas Orange Van Loon David Monroe Violette Mark ' Okaloosaf Willner Robin I. Broward Miami-Dade Wonsetler Karen Brevard Indian River Orange Yerkes Darden Duval Youn: Elizabeth Hernando Polk Sumter rT Last Name First Name County Coin County County Couri Y _,_ County Andrea Pamela Duval Hernando Indian River Leon Nassau Orange Palm Beach Pasco Seminole St. Lucie Volusia Broome Robert Bay Leon Carter Reginald Alachua Duval Flagler Marion St.Johns Crepeau Jeanne _ Hernando _ Pasco De La Guardia Mario Broward Miami Dade -- Gray Harvel W. Broward Lee Palm Beach Holman Carolyn Pinellas Nystrom Steven Hendry Lee Pasco Pelletier Mark Collier Martin Regina Corcoran Monroe Robinson John Citrus Pasco Pinellas Sarasota Sumter Ruden Alexander 1 Clay Salas Marcos Osceola Sarasota Sutte Robert Lake Orange Volusia Walton Tatro Steven Polk Sumter Tippett Thomas A. Lee Weinert Ed Broward Charlotte Martin Orange St. Lucie „ .„tate.Certified Real Estate App; � w �j�� s"��ipyn� ' r Valuation Petitions r � Last Name First Name County County County- County County county Akers S.James Palm Beach Albright,Jr. Stephen J. Marion Allen Stephen Sarasota Alvarez Pedro M. Miami Dade Miami Dade Amoedo III Andres Armada Albert , Miami Dade Atkinson William Pinellas Autrey Terry L Broward Palm Beach Barfield Edwin Citrus Orange Osceola Bass Richard Sarasota Behm Jim Hillsborough Pasco Polk Seminole Bertelle Charles Broward Miami-Dade Black Dennis Lee Brown Gregg A. Broward Carlson C William Lee Carter Reginald Brevard Duval Flagler St.Johns Chapin David Palm Beach Checkai Robert D. Leon Conway David G. Broward Palm Beach Crepeau Jeanne Manatee de Laurier Edward Duval 2 Last Name First Name County County County„,„ County County County DeLeon Timothy -_ Pinellas , Delgado,Jr. Leonardo Miami Dade Dodier Leo J. Broward Palm Beach Donald Terrana Pinellas Dube Lorriane L Broward Collier Hillsborough Sarasota Edmundson Kathyrn B. ; Hillsborough Marion Palm Beach Polk Sarasota Seminole Volusia Elam James Nassau Evans Kenneth Pasco Fernandez Angel Miami Dade Fleri Edgar Citrus Hernando Lee Orange Volusia Fox John Duval Friedman Wendy Broward Gallion Robert M. Broward Geurin Shawn Pasco Giles Don 1 Bay Golicz Lawrence Pinellas NI Gonce Bruce B. Lee Gonzalez,Jr. G. Adrian Broward Miami-Dade Gray Harvel W. Miami Dade Lee Palm Beach Greenberg Joel B. Broward Harris Richard L. Hillsborough Pasco Hearn Joy Broward Lee Pasco Hemingway William Miami Dade Hicks Robert HillsboroughPasco Sarasota Hollis Caleb Duval Holman Carolyn M. Hillsborough Humphrey David Bay Hunter Robert Martin Hunter,Jr. Robert Broward Palm Beach Jackson Michelle Palm Beach Jacobs Michael P. Broward Jamir Stephen Hillsborough Jane Ena Broward Miami-Dade Jim Behm Pinellas Johnson Steven Miami Dade Johnson Kelly Orange ! ....... Jourdan Herbert L. Marion Joy 1 Hearn Pinellas Katsikos Jack Miami Dade Kern Michael P. Broward Kevin Talbott Monroe Krabec I Bradley Martin Krasinski Raymond H. Broward Manatee Pinellas Krueger Kyle Duval Nassau _____ Lawson Douglas B. Martin Miami Dade Broward Palm Beach Lemonde David Lee Lleonart Luis Miami Dade Lloyd Philicia Broward Lopez Pedro A. Miami Dade Loraine Dube Pinellas Marder Sherry Palm Beach Marino John Duval 3 r: last Name First Name County County mm_m County A County County : County Marshall Steven Escambia Marshall William Lake i Martin Michael Broward Palm Beach McDaniel Robert Broward McQueen John Charlotte Sarasota Mesner Robert L. Broward Palm Beach Michael Ezekiel Jeff Miami Dade Mikolsky Julie , Brevard Mullen,Jr. Henry Duval Mutrux Charles Broward Lee Palm Beach Neil Stephen Indian River St. Lucie Newell Billie Lee Norris J Lee Lee Nystrom Steven CharlotteHendry HillsboroughPinellas Pasco Polk Sumter O'Donnell Judith F. Broward Ortega Jose A. Miami Dade Parham L.James Leon Pelletier Mark Martin Collier Peltier Terrie Martin Brevard Broward HillsboroughOrange Pasco St. Lucie Petrick Kalle Miami Dade Petrole Joseph Miami Dade Porcaro Steven A. Hillsborough Pinellas Rascati Gina Martin Palm Beach MI= Richard Davis Pinellas Pinellas Riddle Thomas Orange Robertson Cassandra Volusia Robinson John Citrus Hillsborough Pasco Polk Sarasota Seminole Sumter Volusia Salas Marcos E. Martin Broward Hillsborough Indian River Pinellas Polk Sarasota Sumter Pasco Sarley Donald Palm Beach Schmidt Stephen Palm Beach Sehr Scott Broward Shawn Geurin Pinellas Smalley Lee Miami Dade Smith I Janice M. Hillsborough Spool Philip G. Miami Dade Steeves Richard L. Broward Orange Osceola IIIE Stein Daniel Duval Stevely John Brevard € III Stocking 11111 Maria E. Broward 3 .____ Sutte Robert Citrus Brevard Lake Okaloosa Pinellas Polk Volusia Walton IIIIIIIIIIMMIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIMIMMIIIINI Tarkoe Zillah L. Broward Miami Dade Taylor David Brevard Tippett Thomas A Lee Toro, II James Clay Valentich Michael Sarasota Ward Mel Brevard Duval St.Johns Watson Scott Broward Collier Wells Alfred Duval ._ 4 Last Name First Name County County County County County County Wilson Shawn Highlands Hillsborough Polk Wong Jose Broward Yeargin,Jr. Harry"Al" Duval Young Juliana i Indian River 5 Q °' co ' n n nn N. n 4 nT n n n n n n n n!- n T n n nTT ,N-7 n n N. T T T 1A_ y > T 6) TTT6) TY 6) T 6) w w oT T 6) IQ r Vo57 7 0 7 7 7 U 7 o U U o 7 7 7 7 7 G) 3 3 O ZO ? ? QQ ? OQ7QOOQ - 777 ? cn7 N ,t 0 n t0 N n Cig )A M T M co t0 n n t0 p M O M M N n nN NNN O T T T T TM T N N T N c, T • T T eq (N C) as 0 01 C C) E o y a) U) U y N a a7 ca V 0' h. a) ` a) d L N E Vi V) E E N O a) w a) a) a) N a) d CD R :: w w c'' O U.. co R Q R R L E R R L Q R 2 R R R R 2 Q L Q E 05 •ts M Vy VR y N N 12 y R y N N co 2 'O N Ro) R C) of C) U C) O) C) R C) '3 _) o .0o) OR OR .0 Y d a) R 0 R R R yR R R 0 R 0 oR aR aR R y aaoR O y LV g L ci) L w L L V4 L V) r E y R C R R R L R R R C N L N R n' R L N C A C L U R U U U 0 Uan 0 U U R U a) U ' U . U U , ' R U R d L '° a u) a a a R a a a L Q '° R a f0 a '° a a R '6 14 L Q i R G) P4[ ° v) m N v) v) a v) v) v) a) v) 2 a v) 2 v) 2 v) cn a 2 m v) m Q. L L L L L L L L L L L L L tV N '° a) E d a) a) °- a) a) a) E m .'° °- a) .� a) .� a) a) Q m m E y 0. O Y U u) a, _ y U < Cl) a u) y U) U < v) U a) U U) v) < 'U 'U y ° y Q 0. 1- d 'R 2 'R '° 'R > 'R 'R 'R 2 '16 a) >+ .2 a 'R O R R >, o a) g .2 A a L L L L L Y L L a �' L L a L L t-' a Q L �+ . Cl) a -o a a a y Q a a -o a v) a, a fn a cn a a a' CO v) -O 0.°- -2 0 Ce � 0 a f, < < < o < < < '° < 0 o Q 0 Q m Q Q o a) m p a o 0 ._ ~ E >, m° >, A >, a` T >. >, CO° > E aL > E T E T T aL E E m >, m a` = y ° g : as Q ° a co waaaac a) a) CD pOaaOaaO • yQ a) 9 C 7 ' O E O O O p O O O E O a E O E 0 ~L d y d d d i a ay ada di y i y C R To Ts a RRR o RC ° m m m m mvm ai 0 Rm R a ia R a) i3mQ Ce fY Ce m CL CC IY Q W m ce ix ce• Ce a) Q ce Q Cl) "3 a) .° a) s a) a) a L 0) o c Cca TO c C c 7 G) V3 7 CL i- as as > F- ~ > ~ o 0) E allz N (3 0m C3 — r > J N N O R OT o da) illC C L L d a 6. > R R E E o, c 2 N ° ° ao ° t . C . y a w aaC � N sQ > .E r m C Ed 0 L R RR coy O dN Q a Q m mm mm " tO " .0 a a Qa mmm J U) --I— _ a (.) r ° v c.) o E •° d a) 42 ti) .E co rn E t m a .a y = iC i .72 e am >, c 76 tt CL CL a E ` RR C R L J ?. aaU U ° ° Q y a' a = R1- W 0 g a2CD i a) a) - wap 2 a L vvvQ d U rt W ii N V Q n N. r- r. r- ti ti N- ti r` ti r- N. N n r` N. N- N. r- ti r- N. N r N- n r• n i n r` r, N- r r r r rr r r r r r r r r Z:5) a) rn a C) rn a� t > > c a) a) C) cr w a) :) 0o a) u a a a a) U a) 7 O 7 7 7 3 7 3 U O O 7 7 3 c,) 7 U 7 7 co 3 Q Q a N o ' Q ? a Q ? O z z ? ? a Q C 0 0 0 < 0 < a 9 co N 9 < 9 Q N N N N T- a- N- N ,- M 4. N N co N N M M N N CO N O r� N ,,,i:, r N O N CO CO 2 O CO O 2 R >, >, >• ca ca T fa CO L CV a) a) L L a) L L U E c i Y Y w NNY _ L Y _ w , O g O a) a) a) a) .2 w O r O .2 O _0 _) O O OO YO YO O O O a) w 0) YO a) O O YY Caa Ya Y YY2 E a L a a aa a aa a s aE * a 1Zi a s L a L g a E a tas V) 7, A Y TA YN Y 'O Y M a N a No fa Y Y 12 Y YN NY Y YY Y N N y NjV) Y :ii-, y 0) .0 a) a, _) a7 a a rn 'En co aa b) 'U U a) a) ca an a) a) a) a) 0) U a 'U a) En rn a) C y co co ca a CO O ca CO O ca 0 CO O 0 CO CO 0 CO CO CO O CO ca CO O a CO O R as ca a E E E E E 2 m E 2 m 2 m 2 2 2 03 2 2 2 is 2 2 5 N 5 0- 5555 5 5 5 5 c C a a a a(a L ca a s CO Ca a s C a C a L L a a CO COCa Ca a a a L a N U a) U U U .0 U ca .0 U Ca -U cc U O O U U to U c. U 0) U U U O U O U U U U a) c0 a) O w O a) a) O .- a) a) y CO' O a) O O O 0 Oa a •,- 2,..) •F, ,0):,. Oa O aa a a a a a a i a aa I- a s 2 a „c3- Oaata5n ) afUN N /)co fl U) u) u) N U e N N O U) U N Q. Q. (1) L E L 0- O. L L0Lcli LLd 16 E 'a-) L L00y L 'CB OL L ' LOLLOL O < CO v) v) 0 00 y 0 O .0 a a 'v 'vA 'w '0 U 'V .CO 'v < '0 U < .y2 .0 .(/c 'CO 'R >, a .R 'a 'a '(a 5 .A 'R g5 2 Ca >, >, a R2 R Ca R a a a m a ca , L a a a a -O LaLsLa La La -p L s -0a -a La �O Ya L -0 a a a o La Ls La y a <A 0 a a a a o aoao ooa wa o a a aaaaaaaaoa aoaaaaaaoa > n' . m >+ >, a >, m T a a >+ >+ m >, >, T i T T A t 'tta T E a >, >, T T tttt O ja O O O O O C O a) C O tt C a) a a a) O a O a) a)ttt w O O O a O ja O O O O a C a a a a a O a a O a O a C C a a y a a a a s a C a O a a a a O O O O O O O E O O E O E O O O O O E O O O a O 0 O 0 O a O O O O O a aL a a a aL y a a y aL ; a = L a. a` N a a a aL a aL aL L a a a a` as a a a a a co m a R Ca Ca n a TvCa Ca �a �v Ca �a a �a a �a Ca iv Ca a) a) a) a) a) a) 'o a) O �C a) 'C a) O CO .0 CO O O O O a) a) a) O a) a) sd a) a) s s a) -Ta 7a 7 7 7 a) a) 3 a) a) Ca fa a C C Tts C C I- > >> F- I- I- I- C L i C O 01 CO as 0 co '' R 0 0 a) a V w cA O O .0 aama O N U U U 0 >, T S C > L a) C a E r rL. O O O .= O -0 _ i O . C ( i ` C `a-.) ` a J • V 0 7 a 7 3 0 C C L L E LL LL 0 is a O 0 0 0 O L7 Vr O 3 a • CD D 0 a a -0 w w w U. ri ri ri ii C� C7 C7 C7 (7 El.' cp 2 a LU 0 O 0 d O ›" 't3 3 a 0 -P- ` 0 O Z _ yt NNR v 0 > > aRo v a o z a 3 C C 0 O E R t O E t O y E E 0) N C -0 a a C L L 3 co L L O a t J J J J J N' n r ti ti r- n ti N- r-. n r r- r-- ti r N- r N- N- r— n N- N- r n N- N r- ti r.. •e- r T T r T T T r T T T T r T , I T T T 1 r 1 r 1 r T r T 1 1 T r 7 S 7 7 a 7 V 7 7 7 7 tn O 7 0 7 7 7 a) V C U a) 7) 7 7 to Q 7 7 7 7 Q Q d 7 O 7 7 7 Q 7 Q v) ? Z 7 Q ? Q - 9 0 7 0 N Q -7 7 Q fD - Q - co a1 Cn , 1.0 In N N N N N (O N N CA N ,- C 01 T , N T T N GD N N N M N T � T M N N T N T N ,— N ,- T N T N v) ) N (n to N a.. o A C)) COC) a CC) w L N E L E E y a) a) .O a) a) a) tv a) .2 C) O a) cu .O C) C) O .O w a) yO a) o o a) ) 0 o a) C)Cc6 w CC E Q CC (a CC 2 12 < E E E E Q R E E Q E R Q ra (a (a R E E 2 R A 2 ra L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L V) (n T2 ti) c N_ N_ �a11) 12 N_ _N V_) N N_ N_ N_ v7 N -43 V) N y y y N v7 N U) R N 0) 0) ca C) CS) '(j CC C) 0) to O) 06 O) 0) (C O) a) (a O) 0) 0) Q) O) rn C) O) o) V cs) R co 0 (C c6 c6 d cC O O co (C CC O w co a) cC al O al co O ca as co CC cC (C (C CO (C d R 2 2 m 2 2 2 a 2 m 5 2 2 2 m R 5 as 2 2 m 2 5 m 2 2 5 5 2 2 2 5 2 a 2 u) v R (C C C a a L R C a C a ca C yC —cC ca C ca a c ca 0 m ca cC a a (C C (a C) tco U ) U O U as ) U tU C .0 ' t) U ca ) U (a t) .) C) U U U U C) U a) U C) 0 y C) o a) .0 C) w C) C) C) C) N 0 a) R a) a) y C) C) y a) a) a) o a) a) a) C) a) ,T a) a a L a a a ,v a L a a a a L a a a L a a L a a a a a a a a a 0 a En cn W V) v) Cl) o. v) 0 N v) v) v) m 2 (n 2 N v) m v) N m V) v) v) v) v) v) v) v) cn a v) L L _a L L L L L L L L L L L L L 'Q L L L L L L L L L a L 0 0 E d d 0 a a, E 0 0 d 0 E To m .3 0 a) E 0 0 E d 0 0 m m m m m d d y N y N N V) Q CO 0 .(n (0 0 CO 0 c) V) O V) CO y CO N a) ) CO ti N N N th N N Q c) CC 'CC 5 CC 'm '(a >, '(a g CC 'm '(e '(a 5 m 'R m .E 'R E R 'm E (a cC (a a) cC m (a (a (a >, 'ca L L L L L i"� L L L L L a L a t L a a - a a a E. E. a a a a -0 N a cn a s -o a a - a a a a a a a a a 0 a Q Q o Q Q Q o Q o Q Q Q Q o m Q aa, Q Q o Q Q o Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q o Q T T m > > > a >, m > > > > m C >, C > T Ca > > m > >, > > > > > > > a > t 2 a.. t t t . �, t t . t .r O t O t t ., t t t t t t t t t t t t aaC aaaa aaj aaaa0Y a � aaas aaas aaaaaaaaaC a 00 E 0 0 0 0 o E 0 0 0 o E ;....,1 o a 00 E 0 o E o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L L a s y a a a E a y a a a. a y a a s y a a y a. a a a. a a a a a. i s iC is a) a)7 is is an d m 7 a f6 is 7) 7 a R R 7 is m .= (C (C m m (a (a as m ca d m da) '0 a) a) O a) 'aa) C) 'D a) a) o 'a a) a) 'o C) o C) C) C) C) C) C) a) a) a: a! Q W a_ ce 0 W ¢ a: a: cea! a a: a! a! a a: a: Q a_ a: a: a! a! a: a: a! a! w a: a) a) 7 •07 • 7 7 7 7 'a) > (6 > > > > C H I- L c C L c u! y i C C C C Y L c •"O •U O O 01 CO CO C 0) y 0) R CO y O 0 .O -0 d ' C N N N 'O t . 0) A C 0) 0 c (.) C)) C_ d L t t IV U d O y E E C N Y 0 O C y . C C C L 7 C) C (n •- 0) 3 0 a •L co"6. i V) i 0 0 7 (a (a -� O t t t 7 Y Y O (v � m E 13 o (a (a CC (a 2 2 o 2 0 2 2 2 -) —oi -) -, Y Y Y J J o f 2 2 2 2 I 2 -J c c c c °) 0 E a) CC c 'C y c T2c R -o (a o c 0 c c E > C) 'O y ;-, >, >, O a) y (a ca (C CC C >, ` 0 C) 'a (a .0 R O C) -as '> 'V L t rn O O ca o .0 in o 0 a L r .C .0 C _ C d 0 > m s a s E >, F. a L > > -� o ff tj 7 (`a R O Y . c) V W = co Y C -. 0 2 •v ar ) > Y 0 p a a 0 -) Y) �% a a c) E 2 2 5 o Q cn 2 2 w a: f2 p N cn N- N- N- N- N- N. r- N. N. rN. n c- n r•-• r- N. r ti n ti 1. n n rs r r- r r r r r r r r ar r a y r r a d 5 Q a 0- C7 O a5a- a) V 65C. Q- a V j a) p V j V a a 7 7w 7N Q7y ? z N O Q y Q Q 0 ? -? Q Q a 7 0 ? O cn 7 7 ' M CO N r r N N N CA N 52 � ,- N ,_ ,- c- N N N r a- N cicsiN M ',- O— e- a- w y y U) y a) y y .a), t/1 to aa+ CU A >' a) a) tYLa a) d L d 0 w CO C) a) a) U) C C C C y C C y C C y L L L L _ L L L L I.- .7, a) y YO a) a) a) a O YO d a) a) a) a) •� a) 0 0 0 w w •C) to Y Y Y Y t6 Y . . . Y Ca 2 m < < c6 ca m '0 < < ca co Ca to Ca 2 Cas Q Q m 2 Ca a Q E ca E to Ca g E1 L L L L L L L L L L L R Y a "a '''y Yy Y Yy D 12 y y y y y ja :in' 'a '0 Y Y Y Y yY - 8 .y y y Y yY 'U a) R Ca a) C) O) 5) Ca ca a) C) C) 65 U O) a CaC) V ) CaCa5 a) C) a) a) U a) to a) 0 0 ca Ca Ca ca 0 0 to Ca co co co O co a, 0 O a) a) a) a O 0 co o Ca a) a a a) a 2 m m 2 g 2 2 m m 2 g g g 2 a 2 m m 2 a 2 m CO 2 g 2 R 2 g a- 0- (/) "a a _ -a -a -a a r N -a a L cn L R y C C o R to R C C A to R ra ca L fa yC C y R L tQ C c Ca Ca ca y C 6 L a) U a ca CU U U ca ca U U U U U aU ' ca ca RU aw) U it o U Ud UC) U U) y) CA a) A CC) a) 0 a) a) a) a) a) y a) R'ta a y y a a a. a. y y a. a a. a a .aa y y a tQ a Lo y a a a a s .a ▪ cn 2 m a) cn cn cn cn a) a) cn co co Cl) Cl) L co E a) a) 2 co a cn a) a) co cn cn 2 cn cn a a L -a -a L L L L .a -0 a. -a Q L L Q L L L 'c L a d `a E m a) 0 0 d 0 WW m a a) .R E E .m d a a) E E a) a! a) .� a) d a- Q y U a, a) .v) v) y v) d a, v) 0 y y 0 Q u) c) y a U 0 Q cn y a) y _y y U y 0 Q T .1 m 2 2 C .R E7R 2 2 Ca C C C Ca > C d 2 2 m .0 �. 'ta 2 2 Ca to ca 0 Ca Ca > a, a -0 -0 Q Q Q Q �' a a C �' L L L L a L L d 13 a a a a a a y a to a "a > a y Oa. 'a 'O a a a a a a) o Q 0 o o a a 0 Q o o < < < < < o a m o o W < o < 0 0 < Q < m < < o CI >, c m m >, T >, co m >+ A >' T >, a >' L m m C >' a >t m m >, > > C T > a To a) O C C a) a) a) a) C a) a) a) a) a) R a) YO C C 0 a) is d C C a) a) a) a)tt a fa C a y y a a a a y y a a a a a C a C7 a) a C a C) 0 a a a a a C O o a E E 0 0 0 o E E o 0 0 0 0 0 0 a E E a 2 0 a E E o 0 0 a o 0 0 o 12 a y y d aL a s y y a a a a a. a w y a i a y y a` a` a` a` a` d 7 •7 A R cv R C ca to co co R d m 7 R d 7 7 ca is is is fa d 0w aareCeeeCeaaCeWCCWCe Ore as as °' CeQaCeCLCL CLCL .Ti a) m m mLE m m 21 d m s a) 7 3 O 7 'rn O '0) 7 O '0) Cis is To fa C> os fa A C m to C _ L L _y ...7.L L L ca C " C y 'E y a) L y •i n 7 m y 0 o C C a) .O Y Y Y y E ` c) O 0 L ca a s y �' N Y O ca a 0 •C) = L 0 r 3 •i .L+ L C 0CY) d N a) ' .0 d r w �_ 3 0CT" o d ca 2 2 o as a U Q g 2 2 2 0 2 z z >, >, ° O a to m m a) a 0 a a a a a W Q: 2 .e 2 g 2 z z 0 a a a a. a SI E a) R = a >, >' n L d a) aC) as Y t`o .0 T y Y Y a) .` d y a- a) _ C a0 a,= O fa ' 'i y a) L' a) C s C i _ a) Y L L C L a) > > C L a) 9 0 -0 0 R la d to a) d a) a 3 E C = ca t0 d y R y t4 L Cn d w r 2 ° ° c7 W ~ a = v m J c"n -) cn w m F- Y ° a cn cn U n n N- n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n N- n n 1"._ n n n N n n n n n n n T T T T T r. T T T 7 T T T r T T r T T T T T T r T T T T r. T o. 7 7 3 7 c 7 U U 7 3 a 7 5 U a7 a) a) 7 a) a) 7 7 7 o U o c7 a) Q Q ? 7 7 Q -? O 7 ? O Q 7 -7 co 7 7 O Q 9 U) Q Q v) 9 7 7 7 ? O -? Q to O O N cr C M N co T . T n N It) N aA aA 0a CO n T M M O M n (0 M N NN T T N T N T M N N T C) N N T T CO T T ('y LO T N N N T M N T T I- li a) y y y « :: a) a) a ca T T T ` a i y a) a) L y U E E E _N . w 0 . R0Oa .. aa0 a1 a) a) a) O) a) a) Cr) a) a) Y Y Y .+ R a R R ^ Q R R CO < R R QL L L L L L RY a)R R L L 2 R ayg R R R R L L L 'ow 73 Y 173 -E Yy Y Y 13 Ii; Y 'd Ti; ca 0 Y N M �a R Y y fY Y N y NN C) 'V C .0) co O) C) C) R C) Cco . .0 . C � . .- 0) Q) v VO) C) Cco •_ _ O O) C) co a) a) co a) 0 a) R R co 0 R R O a) R a) R y R R a) a) a) co co y co a) co R co a) R g a a2 a CO a2 2 2 m 2 2 CO a 2 a g a 2 2 a a a 2 2 a 2 R 5 a 2 a 2 (- L (n 73 W _ _ Y (I. L CO L V) V) L L co L y A L y R R CO = R R c y R L CO y R R L N L R R L R N R R R y R U y U y R U U U R U U ',7., U y U U U 0 ' 0 U U y U ' U U U ' U E ,ow O) y .m 5 y a) a) a) y 6) y .0 y a) y y N D7 0 a) a) 0 a) a) a) a) F,',' a) a R 0 a f6 i R coa a i a a i R a R a R a a R R Ti V) V)a „c.1' /� U) L 0 co L a) .e ) U) U) a) U) (/) a) V) '- V) V) CO Q 'a V) V) 'a U) (I) V) U) V) L a a - L L L -0 L L L a L 'a-) L L L L L L L L y a :2-) a E !3 a) a) a) E a) a) E .'a a) a y .� y y a �v a '6 a) a a) .2 y E y .2 y U) Q 'U N Q y U Un in a y ,() a y u N Q y U )n w < 'U Q v) )n Q w U U) v) v) U )n .R > y .R >' 2 y ..6 "R t6 2 E )6 2 y R >, '17' a 1°. R T a > .2 2 > .0 y 2 2 .2 a R I.. t' a L t a L L L L L a L 'L" L L .g L L .E L a L L L L a U) CI- O (n a a a 'O a s -O V) a y a N a a y U) y a a y a U) a a a V) a a a, >' a. a L a Cl a L a a L >, a a a >, a a a >, a a a a a >, a a a > 0. Q o a) Q O o m Q Q Q `a Q Q `a a) Q o Q y Q Q o y o Q Q o Q a, Q Q Q y Q ›. a c yT+ a m E yT > .>+, m y>, > m E y>1 a >1 E y>, T a E a. . '• T a . , L .T+ y>, , ` T L L Y o L t L L L Y o L t o L 0 ` L o L L L o t a a y a a 0 a) a a y a O acl) ''' a s m C a a C a a a O. " a O O Q O O E Q O O O E O O E O 0 O Q O o O Q O 0 0 O 0 Q O O o Q 2 aL ,_ aL y a` a` a` a a` a y a i a` n` a` L n a L a a a` a a To a) fa d ' R R is O fa is ' m a) R is is d d R m d is is is is as a) a) I a) a) a) =a a) a) 1E a) a) a) a) a) a) a) a) a) a) a) a! a' ce 0 Q ce ce ce Q Ce ce Q cG 0 ce re cc a) 0 ce ct O ce ce Ce ce cc 13 n y a) y s a Z as C > > > co C C as I- co � t- 1- V) V) Ce CL Ce i L wN 0 a a 0 a o o '� a n � ,- ' L 30 C owCyo) C C w (ET) a--1. - (7) Qy7RA R y O O 00 % QCtL aN JdN '2 (O (n m aaY § § Ca); (n in v) n Nn - - If= = R o ce a: CD (I) F- > CO roTo R cn coL C c .L 0 0 3 L y 2- E CD R 0 a) ca t R E E E o R 3 ,R y d L t t O 2 L R > a O :C L C C C .Q -0 _ .Y-. C o O O L y U >i Q O 'a L O R 'a J 2 2 a 8 in (n a > E o c° o co ro N 2 o I- F- a w °° ' Y = n n n - m N '- 00 T d L o Q L c3 O) O , )C 03 2C IIn O1ml Ci U cn L E . el)y Uti) 2 y . Q N O O Q m i a+ O d O Q O L 7/1 a 3 •6 d O � d 3 R Y• C C y 3 3 = R . 16 N R) N 0 W 7