The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 02/23/2010 Item # 7B Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 1 of 167 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY CU-2008-AR-14085, FLO TV, Inc., represented by Kimberly J. Madison, Esq., of Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A., is requesting a Conditional Use for a communications tower and the installation of related shelter and equipment in the Estates (E) Zoning District, as specified in Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). The approximately 4.77-acre subject property is located at 5860 Crews Road, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, in Collier County, Florida (Companion item to V A-PL2009-037). OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) consider an application for Conditional Use Number 3 in the Estates (E) Zoning District for a communications tower and related mechanical equipment shelter, as specified in Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC); and to insure that the community's interests are maintained. CONSIDERATIONS: On May 25, ]993, a Conditional Use was approved for the subject property (Reso]ution No. 93- 219, see Appendix I to the staff report) to allow the replacement of an existing 438-foot guyed communications tower and its associated mechanical equipment structures with a 430-foot guyed communications tower and a 2,400 square-foot building. Six years later, due to a federally mandated frequency and power change that could not be accommodated on the site's existing tower and antenna, the approved site development plan (SOP) was amended to allow the replacement of the communications tower with a much stronger 394-foot tower. However, instead of removing the old tower and erecting the newly approved one per the approved SOP, the applicants simply erected the new tower approximately 50 feet away from the old tower, thereby expanding the use on the site. Not only was this additional tower in violation of the approved SOP, it also contravened Resolution No. 93-219, which permitted only one communications tower, and further stipulated that any "expansion of the uses... or major changes to the site plan submitted... require the submittal of a new conditional use application..." It was not until the applicants attempted to co-locate an antenna on the supposedly dismantled tower that the County became aware of this violation. In order to redress the infraction and comply with the terms of the approved resolution, the applicant has submitted the subject Conditional Use application, which if approved, would legitimize the existence of the additional communications towers on the site and allow the co-location of the new antennae. As shown on the Conceptual Site Plan contained within the Collier County Planning Commission Staff Report entitled, "Overall Site P]an," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28, 2007, as revised through April 9, 2009, the unmanned facility is somewhat centrally located on the site, allowing the E Zoning District's required 75-foot front and rear yard setbacks and 30-foot side yard setbacks to be well exceeded. The two communications towers and accessory equipment shelters are shown enclosed within a chain-link fence. The towers are spaced 50 feet apart and linked by elevated walkways labeled as "coax bridges." The walkways connect the towers to a newly proposed 224 square-foot equipment shelter, which would house a CU-2008-AR-14085, FiO TV, Februmy II. 2010 Page I 0/4 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 2 of 167 generator and transformer, and would be mounted by two new dish antennae and a GPS antenna. Two existing parking spaces for the facility are also shown within the facility's gates. The facility is accessible via a private drive ITom Crews Road. A dead-end, dirt spur road at the entrance provides access for maintenance vehicles to the tower-supporting guy lines and anchors adjacent to the eastern boundary of the site (these guy lines and anchors, as well as others on the western boundary of the property, are the subject of the companion Variance application). Along the northern boundary of the site, a 20,786 square-foot conservation easement is proposed. Because the site is heavily wooded, as shown in the aerial photograph on the preceding page, the existing vegetation would serve to satisfy the project's perimeter buffer requirements; and because of the limited nature of the proposed change, 79.3 percent of the site would remain as open space. FISCAL IMPACT: Approval ofthe Conditional Use, in and of itself, would have no fiscal impact on Collier County. There is no guarantee that the project, at build out, would maximize its authorized level of development, however, if the use were approved, a portion of the existing land would be developed and the new development would result in an impact on Collier County public facilities. The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of building permits to help offset the impacts of each new development on public facilities. These impact fees are used to fund projects identified in the Capital Improvement Element of the Growth Management Plan as needed to maintain adopted Level of Service (LOS) for public facilities. Additionally, in order to meet the requirements of concurrency management, the developer of every local development order approved by Collier County is required to pay a portion of the estimated Transportation Impact Fees associated with the project in accordance with Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Other fees collected prior to issuance of a building permit include building permit review fees. Finally, additional revenue is generated by application of ad valorem tax rates, and that revenue is directly related to the value of the improvements. Please note that impact fees and taxes collected were not included in the criteria used by staff and the Planning Commission to analyze this petition. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMPl IMPACT: Future Land Use Element (FLUE): The subject property is designated Urban-Mixed Use District, Urban Residential Subdistrict on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP. Relevant to this petition, the designation permits non-residential uses, including utility and communication facilities. FLUE Policy 5.4 requires new land uses to be compatible with and complementary to the surrounding land uses as set forth in the LDC. It is the responsibility of the Zoning and Land Development Review staff as part of their review of the petition in its entirety to perform this compatibility analysis. CU-2008-AR-14085. FLO TV, FebruQlY 11,2010 Page 2 of4 Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 Page 3 of 167 Based upon the above analysis, staff concludes that the proposed Conditional Use may be deemed consistent with the Future Land Use Element. (Please note that the complete GMP analysis is contained in the staff report.) AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMP ACT: The applicant has not made any provision for the affordable or workforce housing needs that approval ofthis application might generate. ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES: All environmental issues have been addressed, The applicant was not required to submit an Environment Impact Statement (EIS) for this project. ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION: Pursuant to LDC Section 8.06.03 0.1 Powers and Duties, the EAC did not review this petition because the site is less than ten acres and is not in a Special Treat;ment (ST) area or an Area of Critical State Concern (ACSC). COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: This item was continued from the October ]5,2009, CCPC hearing, pending further information as discussed in the attached Supplemental Staff Report, The CCPC heard this petition again on January 7, 20]0, and believing that approving the Conditional Use would not be injurious to the neighborhood or detrimental to the public welfare, voted 6-2 to forward this petition to the BCC with a recommendation of approval, subject to the following conditions: ]. The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the Conceptual Site Plan, identified as "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28,2007, as revised through April 9, 2009. The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for Conditional Use approval only. The final design must be compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations. 2. Development on the site shall be restricted to 3,359 square feet of impervious area. 3. Maximum height of the two towers on the site shall be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances. 4. Both towers on the site shall be equipped with either solid red beacon or dual mode lights unless a waiver of this requirement is granted by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). 5. All guy line anchors shall be fenced pursuant to LDC 5.05.09.G.12. 6. One tower on the site shall be owned by or leased to a governmental entity for government-related, essential service purposes. Should this entity remove its antenna(e) CU-2008-AR-14085. FLO TV, February II. 2010 Pagel of 4 Agenda item No. 76 February 23, 2010 Page 4 of 167 from the tower, the property owner shall immediately notifY the County and replace the antennae e) with another essential service user within six months. Two commissioners did not support the petition because the applicant failed to meet the conditions of approval from the first Conditional Use. They expressed that the applicant could not be trusted with the conditions of the second Conditional Use. Staff has received one letter of objection from the community, which is attached to the Staff Report as Appendix 2. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: Before you is a recommendation by the Planning Commission for approval of a conditional use authorizing communication towers in the Estates (E) zoning district. A conditional use is a use that is permitted in a particular zoning district subject to certain restrictions. The attached report and recommendations of the Planning Commission required are advisory only and are not binding on you. Petitioner has the burden of demonstrating that the necessary requirements have been met, and you may question Petitioner, or staff, to satisfY yourself that the necessary criteria has been satisfied. In addition to meeting the necessary criteria, you may place such conditions and safeguards as you deem appropriate to allow the use, provided that there is competent, substantial evidence that these additional conditions and safeguards are necessary to promote the public health, safety, welfare, morals, order, comfort, convenience, appearance, or the general welfare of the neighborhood. As a further condition of approval of the conditional use, you may require that suitable areas for streets, public rights-of-way, schools, parks, and other public facilities be set aside, improved, and/or dedicated for public use, subject to appropriate impact fee credits. Approval or denial of the petition is by Resolution, with approval of the conditional use requiring four affirmative votes of the Board (supermajority vote). The proposed Resolution was prepared by the County Attorney's Office and is legally sufficient for Board action. (STW) RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the BCC approve CU-2008-AR-14085, subject to the conditions of approval recommended by staff and the CCPC, which have been incorporated into the attached Resolution. PREPARED BY: Nancy Gundlach, AICP, Principal Planner Department of Engineering, Environmental, Comprehensive Planning and Zoning Services CU.2008.AR.14085, FIO TV, February II. 2010 Page 40f4 Item Number: Item Summary: Meeting Date: Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 5 of 167 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS 7B This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Petition: CU-2008-AR-14085 FLO TV, Inc., represented by Kimberiy J. Madison, Esq., of Ruden, McCiosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, PA, is requesting a Conditional Use for a communications tower in the Estates (E) Zoning District, as specified in Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Deveiopment Code (LDC). The approximately 4.77-acre subject property is located at 5860 Crews Road, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, in Collier County, Florida. (Companion itern to VA-PL2009-037) CTS 2/23/2010 9:00:00 AM Prepared By John.David Moss Community Development & Environmental Services Planner, Principal Date Zoning & Land Development Review 1/27120104:25:28 PM Approved By Judy Puig Community Development & Environmental Services Operations Analyst Community Development & Environmental Services Date 1/28120103:54 PM Approved By Ray Bellows Community Development & Environmental Services Manager - Planning Date Zoning & Land Development Review 1/30/20101:38 PM Approved By Steven Williams County Attorney Assistant County Attorney Date County Attorney 211120102:20 PM Approved By William D. LorenzI Jr., P.E. Community Development & Environmental Services Director - coes Engineering Services Date Engineering & Environmental Services 2/212010 2:50 PM Approved By Nick Casalanguida Transportation Division Director. Transportation Planning Date Transportation Planning 213120108:46 AM Approved By Norm E. Feder, AICP Transportation Division Administrator ~ Transportation Date Transportation Administration 2191201010:22 AM Approved By OMS Coordinator Date Agenda Item No. 76 February 23,2010 Page 6 of 167 County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 219/20102:36 PM Approved By Jeff Klatzkow County Attorney Date 219120102:59 PM Approved By Leo E. Ochs, Jr. County Manager Date County Managers Office County Managers Office 2113120101 :43 PM AGE~~~~~Ne. 78 Fetiruary"23, 2010 Page 7 of 167 Co~r County .... """"'-..- ~ ~ SUPPLEMENTAL STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMlSSION DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION FROM: HEARING: JANUARY 7, 2010 SUBJECT: PETITION CU-2008-AR-14085, FLO TV INCORPORATED (COMPANION ITEM V A-PL-2009-037) PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: FLO TV, Inc. 5775 Morehouse Drive San Diego, CA 92121 Agent: James J. Porter, Esq./Kimberly J. Madison, Esq. Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A 401 East Jackson Street, Ste. 2700 Tampa, FL 33602 REQUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider an application for Conditional Use Number 3 of the Estates (E) Zoning District, as specified in Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC), for a communications tower and related mechanical equipment shelters. PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: This item and its companion Variance petition were heard by the CCPC at their October 15, 2009 public hearing. However, due to issues raised by CCPC members necessitating further research, the applicant requested a continuance of the hearing, which was ultimately rescheduled for January 7, 2010. The specific questions raised by the CCPC are listed below, with staff s responses highlighted in bold font: CU-2008-AR-14085 12/17/09 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 8 of 167 1. Was a certificate of occupancy ever issued for the new tower and, if so, why wasn't the old tower dismantled as required by the approving Conditional Use Resolution (No. 93- 219)? Tbe new tower was properly inspected and did receive tbe required certificate of occupancy prior to becoming operational. However, because the Building Department inspectors do not refer to the approved resolution to verify tbat the conditions of approval attached to tbem, if any, have been fulfilled, they did not know of the condition of approval attacbed to Resolution No. 93-219 that required the old tower to be dismantled. Nevertbeless, ensuring compliance witb sucb conditions of approval is normally under the purview of Zoning and Land Development Review staff, and occurs at the time of site development plan (SDP) review and approval. However, in this instance, the applicant needed to maintain tbe old tower on the site until after the new tower was erected so that the existing antennae could be transferred from tbe old tower to tbe new one without an interruption in service. Because of tbls unique circumstance, Zoning and Land Development Review staff should have required a note on the SDP stating that tbe old tower had to be removed after the transfer took place, so that it might have been clear to the building inspector that it needed to be dismantled. However, it should be noted that the approved SDP did not depict the old tower-only its concrete pad- and referred to the new tower as the "replacement tower." The application submitted with tbat SDP was also unambiguous about tbe applicants' intent to dismantle tbe old tower, stating "This SDP amendment is only to replace the existing communications tower structure" and "aU the antennas on the existing tower [will beJ moved to the new tower...and the existing tower removed." 2. LDC Section 5.05.09. G.3 allows standalone communications towers with Conditional Use approval, provided the tower is owned by, or leased to, an essential service that is the primary user. What is the difference between an essential service "tower" versus an essential service "antelUla"? CU-2008-AR-14085 12/17/09 2 The LDC defines a tower as "a structure whose primary purpose is to raise the beight of an antenna." No defmition is provided for an antenna or for tbe "primary user." Nevertbeless, staff bas historically defined a primary user as a governmental entity whose antenna must remain on the tower for as long as the tower exists; so while other commercial users are free to Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 9 of 167 use a particular tower and then relocate their antennae to other towers as needed, the governmental entity's antenna is obligated to remain. As such, it is stafrs opinion that any tower with an essential service's antenna(e) mounted on it is an essential service tower. 3. Can the essential service user be a leasee? If so, what happens to the other antennae on the tower if the essential service user decides not renew their lease? Does the tower have to come down? According to LDC Subsection 5.05.09.G.3, towers may indeed be leased to a governmental entity. The LDC is silent I as to what would happen to the non-essential service users' antennae on a tower should the essential service user decide not renew bis lease and move his antennae elsewhere. (For a list of the commercial tenants on the site's towers, see Appendix 1.) However, pursuant to a policy memo by the Zoning Director, an essential service tower in the E zoning district may not be without a replacement essential service user for a period of more than six months, or else a Code Enforcement violation would be initiated to have the tower dismantled. 4. What is the required "collapse zone" for the tower? Normally, the required collapse zone for towers over 185 feet is 2.5 times the tower's height from any adjoining residential zoning districts. However, essential service towers are exempted from this requirement. Nevertheless, the applicant has provided staff with a certified letter from a Florida-licensed engineer (Appendix 2) testifying that, in his opinion, due to the design of tbe guy lines on the subject towers, "it is virtually impossible for the tower[s) to fall in a straight line the way a tree might." Rather, if a tower were to collapse, it would "fall in upon itself in an accordion-type fashion, with the debris contained within the anchor radius of the guy cables." 5. Are lights required for the subject towers since they are in excess of 150 feet? CU-2008-AR-/4085 12/17/09 3 Agenda Item No. 76 February 23,2010 Page 10 of 167 Yes. The project was reviewed and approved by the Collier Mosquito Control District, who determined that only one of the towers needed to maintain either a solid red beacon or a dual mode light since the towers are a mere 50 feet apart. However, as noted in the letter from the agency provided to the applicant (see Appendix 3), this exemption is strictly limited to the subject site only and would not automatically apply to other sites in the County. Mosquito Control also informed staff that, due to the towers' heights, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) might still require both towers to maintain lights. As such, a condition of approval has been incorporated into the attached resolution requiring that both towers be equipped with lights unless a waiver of this requirement is granted by the FAA. 6. Are communications towers routinely inspected by the County? According to LDC 5.05.09.G.14, guyed towers exceeding 185 feet are to be inspected every two years by an engineer or other qualified professional, and any recommended repairs are to be made without delay. The report of this inspection is required to be filed with the County Manager no later than December 1 of the applicable inspection year, and if snch report recommends repairs, a letter verifying that the repairs have been made is also required to be submitted to the County Manager following to their completion. To ensure that this requirement is fulfilled, staff is mailing notification letters to each of the affected tower owners informing them of this biannual requirement. The reports subsequently submitted by these owners wilI then be reviewed by County Engineering staff and maintained on file with the repair reports, if any. Staff will be following up with the CCPC on this new protocol after the N ew Year in order to apprise them of its status. 7. What happened to communications tower on Tower Road? Why did it collapse? This tower collapsed under usual circumstances in that its failure was not caused by a hurricane, tornado or other violent wind, but rather by a propane fire that was ignited while the tower was being welded. The heat from the gas-fuelled fire actually melted the steel lattice, provoking its collapse. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney's Office reviewed this staff report on December 10,2009. RECOMMENDATION: Zoning and Land Development Review staff recommends that the CCPC forward Petition CU- 2008-AR-14085 to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval, subject to the following stipulations: ' CU-2008-AR-/4085 12//7/09 4 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 11 of 167 1. The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the Conceptual Site Plan, identified as "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28,2007, as revised through April 9, 2009. The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for Conditional Use approval only. The final design must be compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations. 2. Development on the site shall be restricted to 3,359 square feet of impervious area. 3. Maximum height of the two towers on the site shall be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances. 4. Both towers on the site shall be equipped with either solid red beacon or dual mode lights unless a waiver of this requirement is granted by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). 5. All guy line anchors shall be fenced pursuant to LDC 5.05.09.G.12. 6. One tower on the site shall be owned by or leased to a governmental entity for government-related, essential service purposes. Should this entity remove its antenna(e) from the tower, the property owner shall immediately notify the County and replace the antennae e) with another essential service user within sixty days. C(J-2008-AR-14085 12/17/09 5 PREPARED BY: .~ JO -DAVID MOSS, AICP, PRlNCIP AL PLANNER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW REVIEWED BY: ~ RAYMO V. BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW ~II} r..rh.~ ./SUSAN M. ISTENES, AICP, DIRECTOR DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW APPROVED BY: H K. SCHMITT, DMINISTRA OR MUNITY DEVELOPMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL VICES DIVISION Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 12 of 167 Ivi vI J D( ATE' /2-/7.' (fJ r I ATE I~J.,).~ 'j DA /.2./.:ItIM I r DATE Tentatively scheduled for the February 23, 2009 Board of County Commissioners Meeting CU-2008-AR-/4085 /2//7/09 6 {-fj- /0 DATE AG~W-~&-~O;~ Page 13 of 167 Co~r County ~ ~~..- - STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION HEARING: OCTOBER 15, 2009 SUBJECT: PETITION CU-2008-AR-14085, FLO TV INCORPORATED (COMPANION TO VARIANCE PETITION V A-PL-2009-037) PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: FLO TV, Inc. 5775 Morehouse Drive San Diego, CA 92121 Agent: James J. Porter, Esq./Kimberly J. Madison, Esq. Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P.A 401 East Jackson Street, Ste. 2700 Tampa, FL 33602 REOUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider an application for Conditional Use Number 3 for communications towers and related mechanical equipment shelter in the Estates (E) Zoning District, as specified in Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: . The approximately 4.77-acre subject property is located at 5860 Crews Road, which is south of Davis Boulevard and east of County Barn Road, in Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, of Collier County, Florida (see the location map on the following page). PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: On May 25, 1993, Resolution No. 93-219 (see Appendix 1) was approved for a Conditional Use on the subject property to allow the replacement of an existing 438-foot guyed communications tower and its associated mechanical equipment structures with a 430-foot guyed communications tower and a 2,400 square-foot building. Six years later, due to a federally mandated frequency and power change that could not be accommodated on the site's tower and antenna, the owner of CU-2008-AR-14085 September 24, 2009 Page lof8 ~ g ~ "L! <C <C ~~~ t; ~, ~ ~ , d - I Iii c ~ - - ~ I, Q~ E O!JIOI ::I~ -I. ::I OK Z II. CO II. _ --, WQ , . , o-!;( ... I~ 1"1 ;;;0 ~ ::; 0.. 3 ex: -, <( ~~ I ~ w I ;~ ,I Q~ ~ IOllL ::I. I, i ...~ -"'- . w <.? ~ ,I l_"-""il Z - in - J Z ~ 0 BW'N30OlHS I - I N II ~" I. co w ;~ :;;I~ , m i R ... ...._~- " Ii ::; g~ I- - ex: ...~ ~ ~ . ~ 01 ~ ~~ '" w '" ~ ~ 0 0 / E- ~ ""''''''' u - .. z 0 0- P I 0- g. .i! w ~ Q. ~l . II ' · ili I ~ J!! 0.. t1i ~ <( ~- z () ~I I . :2: 9 ~ 0 ii " Z . tli ~ 0 . - I- ~i <( M~ I 0 i 0 a " I ......I ~ ! ~ ~ iD . .1 . ~llOa(lNWl ~ i · UK . " . ':>"'''c.o=,,...,~...r=~.r~,_... :,.,.."',.."..".,...''','''..;;c'""''..............~_._- ~, :c ~~~ '1.% (.) 2: -, ~i ~ ~ ! ~i ;~ ~ 'gl ~ ~e ; ~ ; :2, OIl .I~ Iii ~I :: Q 3 i ii!!!. Q ~ ~ 1'1 I Z I i~ ~~~~5 ~ ~ I 9 i ! !ill ~55~~ i:: i <( HHmt! EzU8 ;! .i. ::l llil !:t =1' . 0 H.HUO! , .-~ ~" A-" , I I I I I ;1 d . i I: I I ~ I I I 'i I I I I I ~ . . . . . . . ~ I V b II!I ~;~~Iifii~ I .'15! I I I IIs9.~~II'I'1 ; I i il i i! III!~ h i! Ii ;~ ;;. II I I I Hili !I II!! fi ili:!' t ~1'3tt ~. I'g~;g f Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 16 of 167 the property, Renda Broadcasting, amended the SDP to allow for another replacement communications tower with a much stronger 394-foot tower. However, instead of removing the tower and erecting a new one, as per the approved SDP, the new tower was simply erected approximately 50 feet away from the existing tower, thereby expanding the use on the site, Not only was this additional tower in violation of the approved SDP, it also contravened Resolution No. 93-219, which permitted only one communications tower, and further stipulated that any "expansion of the uses... or ml\ior changes to the site plan submitted... require the submittal of a new conditional use application..." It was not until the applicants, who lease tower space from the owners, attempted to permit an antenna on what was supposed to be a dismantled tower that the County became aware of this violation. In order to redress the infraction and comply with the terms of the approved resolution, the applicant has submitted the subject Conditional Use application, which if approved, would legitimize the existence of the additional communications tower and allow for the expansion of the use on the site. As shown on the Conceptual Site Plan on the preceding page, entitled, "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28, 2007, as revised through April 9, 2009, the unmanned facility is somewhat centrally located on the site, allowing the E Zoning District's required 75-foot front and rear yard setbacks and 30-foot side yard setbacks to be well exceeded. The two existing communicatious towers and their accessory equipment shelters are shown enclosed within a chain-link fence. The towers are spaced 50 feet apart and linked by elevated walkways labeled as "coax bridges." The walkways connect the towers to a newly proposed 224 Aerial View square-foot equipment shelter, which would house a generator and transformer, and would be mounted by two new dish antennae and a GPS antenna. Two existing parking spaces for the facility are also shown within the facility's gates, accessible via a private drive from Crews Road. A dead-end, dirt spur road provides access for maintenance vehicles to the tower- CU-2008-AR-14085 Seprember 24, 2009 Page 2 of 8 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23,2010 Page 17 of 167 supporting guy lines and anchors adjacent to the eastern boundary of the site (these guy lines and anchors, as well as others on the western boundary of the property, are the subject of the companion Variance application). Along the northern boundary of the site, a 20,786 square-foot conservation easement is proposed, Because the site is heavily wooded, as shown in the aerial photograph on the preceding page, the existing vegetation would serve to satisfY the project's perimeter buffer requirements. Because of the limited nature of the proposed change, 79.3 percent of the site would remain as open space. SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: East: South: West: Vacant land, zoned FaIling Waters pun Vacant land, zoned Falling Waters pun Crews Road, then vacant land, zoned E Vacant land, zoned Falling Waters POO GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY: The subject property is designated Urban-Mixed Use District, Urban Residential Subdistrict on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP. Relevant to this petition, the designation permits non-residential uses, including utility and communication facilities. FLUE Policy 5.4 requires new land uses to be compatible with and complementary to the surrounding land uses as set forth in the LDC. It is the responsibility of the Zoning and Land Development Review staff as part of their review of the petition in its entirety to perfonn this compatibility analysis. Based upon the above analysis, staff concludes that the proposed Conditional Use may be deemed consistent with the Future Land Use Element. CU-2008-AR-/4085 September 24. 2009 Page 3 018 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 18 of 167 ANALYSIS: A Conditional Use is defmed in the LDC as, "A use that due to special circumstances is not permissible in a zoning district, but may be appropriate if controlled as to number, area, location, or relation to the neighborhood." Per LDC Section 1O.07.02.D, before any Conditional Use can be recommended for approval to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA), the Planning Commission must make a finding that: I) approval of the Conditional Use will not adversely affect the public interest; 2) all specific requirements for the individual Conditional Use have been met by the petitioner; and 3) satisfactory provisions have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable: I. Consistency with the Land Development Code and the Growth Management Plan. As noted above, the existing communications towers are consistent with the provisions of the Urban Residential Subdistrict of the GMP. The LDC also permits communications towers as a Conditional Use in the E Zoning District provided that they are owned by or leased to an essential service, which is also the primary user. Pursuant to LDC subsection 5.05.09.G.3, "essential services" are governmental uses that include, but are not limited to, safety service facilities, such as fire stations, sheriff's substations or facilities; emergency medical service facilities; or any other similar use where a communications tower could be considered a logically associated use. It should be noted that while there is no definition in the LDC, staff has historically construed a "primary user" to be any approved governmental entity which must remain on the tower for as long as the tower exists. Therefore, while other commercial users' are free to use the tower and then relocate their antennae to other towers as needed, the governmental entity is obligated to remain. As noted in the applicant's narrative statement (Exhibit D to the application), the new tower would meet this provision as the primary user would be the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), an agency of the US Department of Justice. Since Resolution No. 93-219 was approved for a Conditional Use to allow the replacement of a tower that was never actually removed, staff determined on April 3, 2008 via a zoning verification letter (ZLTR 2007-AR-12825) that the old tower was an illegal use. As such, the purpose of the subject Conditional Use is to seek approval of the expansion of the use, .pursuant to Resolution No. 93-219, and legitimize the old tower's existence alongside the newer tower. ,Both the GMP and LDC subsection 5.05.09.G.9 encourage the placement of more than one tower on a site, provided that all setbacks, design and landscape requirements are met and the structures are only located as close to each other as technically feasible so that the failure of one tower would not cause the failure of (or present an unacceptable risk to) any other tower on the site. Although staff would normally insist that this tower comply with the aforementioned E zoning district's provision to have an essential service as the primary user, in this instance, staff would consider the subject property to be an essential service site since the other tower would already have a governmental entity as its primary user. CU-2008-AR-14085 September 24, 2009 Page 4 aJ8 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 19 of 167 The LDC permits essential services towers to be up to any height as required for the particular use at its specific location. According to the applicant, the height of the towers proposed would be approximately 450 feet, which measurement includes the tower and the pole-mounted antennae at the top. (It should be noted that Resolution No. 93-219 did not have any height restriction for the tower on the site.) However, because the towers are in excess of 150 feet, the project was required to be reviewed by the Collier Mosquito Control District, who determined that the towers would need to maintain either solid red beacon or dual mode lights, pursuant to Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) standards and as required by LDCd m.. . ... . .... ..___ 5.05.09.G.13. As an essential service, the towers would also be exempt from the collapse zone requirements for towers over 185 feet (which is 2.5 times the tower's height from any adjoining residential zoning districts). Therefore, with the conditions of approval recommended by staff and the Board of Zoning Appeals' (BZA) approval of companion item V A-PL- 2009-037, the facility would be consistent with all of the applicable provisions of the LDC. 2. Ingress and egress to the property and proposed structures thereon, with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe. Transportation Planning staff has reviewed the application and has determined that no transportation issues are associated with the project. As previously noted, the facility is unmanned, and the site is only occasionally visited by a service crew member to perform routine maintenance. The facility is accessible to these vehicles via Crews Road, and two on- site parking spaces have been provided on the site, as required pursuant to LDC subsection 5.05.09.G.l1. 3. The effect the Conditional Use would have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects. As previously noted, the two communications towers and accessory structures are surrounded by vacant and wooded E-zoned properties. As the subject property is similarly vegetated, existing flora on the site would serve as a buffer between the facility and adjacent properties, as permitted by LDC subsection 5.05.09.G.21. Presently no offending noise or glare is generated by the facility. Although if the surrounding properties were to eventually develop, CU-2008-AR-14085 September 24, 2009 Page 5 of8 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23,2010 Page 20 of 167 these buffers, combined with the site's enhanced setback yards, would effectively mitigate potential impacts. 4. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district. As noted in the application, the site has been the location of a single communications tower and its mechanical equipment shelters for nearly 30 years (for which Resolution No. 93-219 authorized replacement); and the two existing towers have been in continuous operation on the site since 1999, During this time, there have been no recorded complaints from adjacent property owners. Moreover the facility is separated from the closest single-family home by a distance of over 300 feet, and further buffered by 75 feet of vegetation. Due to this plant material, the facility's somewhat isolated location on the site, and the limited nature of the proposal (to legitimize an existing tower and add a 224 square-foot equipment shelter) any impacts on the surrounding neighbors would be minimized. ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAc) RECOMMENDATION: Pursuant to LDC Section 8,06.03 0.1 Powers and Duties, the EAC did not review this petition because the site is less than ten acres and is not in a Special Treatment CST) area or an Area of Critical State Concern (ACSC). NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (NIM): (provided by Cheri RoIlins, Administrative Assistant) The applicant duly noticed and held the required NIM at the Fairfield Inn by Marriott on April 15, 2008 at 5:30 p.m. No one from the community attended, and the meeting was officially ended at 5:45 p.m. One letter of objection to the construction of a new tower (which the application does not propose) was received from the community. However, staff later received a call from this property owner, who asked that the letter be rescinded once he understood the application was to legitimize the two existing towers. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney's Office has reviewed this staff report, revised on September 30, 2009. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the CCPC forward Petition CU-2008-AR-14085 to the BZA with a recommendation of approval, subject to the following conditions: 1. The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the Conceptual Site Plan, identified as "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28, 2007, as revised through April 9, 2009. The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for Conditional Use approval only. The final design must be compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations. CU-2008-AR-14085 September 24, 2009 Page 60[8 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 21 of 167 2. The southernmost tower shaH be owned by or leased to a governmental entity as the primary user of the tower and shaH be for this entity's government-related purposes. 3. Maximwn height of the two towers on the site shaH be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances. 4. Development on the site shall be restricted to 3,359 square feet of impervious area. 5. Maximum height of the towers on the site shaH be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances. 6. All guy line anchors on the site shaH be fenced. ATTACHMENTS: Appendix I: Resolution No. 93-219 CU-2008-AR-/4085 September 24, 2009 Page 70f8 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 22 of 167 PREPAREDB~ ~~ ,--f Iv- 2- J () JOHN-~ID MOSS, ICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER tiTE 7 1 DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW REVIEWED BY: /2. a:: ~ .1/ 10 ~ 1-0'1 AA Y~D v: BELL'bW~,-ZONING MANAGER DATE DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW I)~""", /~ IOft/o9 ".sUSAN M. ISTENES, AICP, DIRECTOR DATE DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW /o/~~ . DATE Collier County Planning Commission: J ( - 1 ~ to DATE MA Tentatively scheduled for the December I, 2009 Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting. - CU-200B-AR-140B5 September 24, 2009 Page 80f8 mOr- r-~'" o~ "":N_ .0 '" 'N $~CJ.) -Cll'" Cll"'Cll -o~!L ".0 ",OJ ",ll.. <( ~ ... ';j 09!._ ~ I <( ~.~ .. <( " ~ ~'" ..; 0 ~ 5 ,~ I gj . ~ - - ~ Ii " I " ~ c~I-", I .-- 0" ::>0 ;:I" -Ii .!:~- , I z c..~ CO Q.;J; _ 0 J.. g I~ l;:;-,-, w- ~'< ~ ::;; I. "- ",0 a: "I 0 ~, ~u ~ "< , \ ' W I ~~ ~l c ~ i . ::>0 L/ "l- I c..~ ift -iiOi;1 <0.- W I. ~ -'-.T" ~ I. J.O B~ " I)} >~! ~ou . 'itl u . > JNV'NJOOJI-IS I - i II W ~ 10 "I 0 lIil~ ~ I .. " . u. 0' ....--- I' ~l~ ::;; - --- 0 a: ::>' Q.~ ~ ~ g ~ . ~ o~ ~ ::>' ~' c..~ W g ~ l'lr.l5011ON / -.... - ~ ~ i, ~l ~i . , !; . "Iii I II I w II , a.. ~ U i ., ~ ,1: .1 .! !, <( !I .s . . ~! . I z N(3 !l ., I , , " ~ w ". j .1 I 0 s ~ 0 " " Z ,. " 0 11- , 11 , . ..~ N ~ . - ].",,.r;r;s I- ><<lU.Vl...... Ii <( I u f 0 < " . i .....J i , , ~ .'! ~ , f~ 5 n . . . " . II !D ' ! . I I . , . a...c~ H01S'tltl1Jll1 ,I , . ~U: . " I " a.. <( ~ (9 Z Z o N '" '" o ... do 'f '" o o N ::i Cl .. zl 0, f- f- UJ !L I. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 24 of 167 ~~ Ruden ~II McClosky 401 EAST JACKSON STREET SUITE 2700 TAMPA, f'LORIOA 33602 (813)314-6709 FAX, (813)314.6809 KlMBERL Y.MADlSON@RUDEN.COM December 16, 2008 John David Moss, Principal Planner Collier County Zoning & Land Development Review 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 CU-2008-AR-14085 REV: 1 RENDA BROADCASTING Project: 2008070019 Date: 12/24/08 DUE: 1/27/09 Re: Application for Conditional Use - Collier County (the "Application") 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (the "Property") Applicant: MediaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Our File No. 60479-0001 Dear John David: The Applicant seeks approval of its Application for Conditional Use to permit the co- location of broadcast equipment on an existing wireless tower located at 5860 Crews Road, in Collier County, Florida (the "Project"). The Project will essentially entail the addition of a cellular antenna and broadcast equipment to an already existing, functioning tower and as such will require only minor alterations, at best, to the site as it presently exists. There will be no additional employees stationed at or accessing the site due to the installation, and no additional building square footage will be associated with the Project. Applicant's request is consistent with the County's desire to "maximize the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites," as set forth in Section 5.05.09(A) of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). The Project is consistent with LDC provisions goyerning the standards for design, vegetation screening, construction and facilities setting for communications towers. . In connection with the above-referenced Application, and on behalf of the Applicant, MediaFLO USA, Inc., enclosed please find the following documentation for your review and consideration: I. Twenty (20) copies of the signed Application for Conditional Use; 2. One (I) check for the Application Fee, in the amount of$7,073.00; 3. One (I) original, signed and notarized Agent Affidavit; ~ TPA,663997:1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSEll, P.A. BOCARA10N . CAJtAW' H.LAUDfROAU. MIMtI . NAPLES. OILANDO. I"OITST.lUClf. SAMSOTA. ST.'HmBUltG . TALLAHASSEE:' TAMPA' WfST PALM BEACH John David Moss December 16, 2008 Page 2 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 25 of 167 4. One (I) original, signed and notarized Owner Affidavit; 5. One (I) copy of the Addressing Checklist signed by Addressing; 6. Twenty (20) copies of the Pre-Application Meeting Notes and Submittal Checklist; 7. Twenty (20) Conceptual Site Plans (24" x 36"), plus one (1) 8 Y, x 11 copy; 8. Two (2) copies of the warranty deeds; 9. Five (5) copies of aerial photographs showing FLUCCS Codes, Legend, and project boundary; 10. Five (5) copies of the Listed Species Survey for the Property; II. Five (5) copies of the Wetlands Jurisdictional Determination for the Property; 12. One (I) copy of the Statement of Utility Provision; 13. One (I) CDROM containing an electronic copy of all documents and plans; and, 14. Two (2) signed and sealed Boundary Surveys. Please do not hesitate to contact me should you require additional copies of any of the above-referenced documents, or to address any questions regarding this Application. Sincerely, p-~ Kimberly J. Madison u KJM!kcw Enclosures cc: Thomas Voltero, Esq. (w/o enclosures) TPA,663997,1 RUDEN, McCLOSKY, SMITH, SCHUSTER & RUSSEll, P.A. BOCA !tATON . CARACAS. FT,lAUDERDAU . MIAMI. NAPUS . ClalANDO . PORT ST. LUCIE. MRASOTA . ST. mERYule; . rM.lAHASSEf: . TAMPA. WBl PALM "fACH ,. , COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT ,DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET (j) Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE'EiM~ of 167 NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252.2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 PETITION NO (AR) PROJECT NAME PROJECT NUMBER DATE PROCESSED ASSIGNED PLANNER CU_2008-AR-14085 REV: 2 RENDA BROADCASTING Project: 2008070019 Date: 3/18/09 DUE: 4/15/09 ABOVE TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF 'F"'+,'!~~1~1{';<;Z:':-,,~;,-, l~~! ""''''" '" ~."~",,,~1~' r-""/--C'). --;-1 ,0" ".~L._G~~hi~~~ j ,.L r!;:~I' I I { , ~1:1o 'c ,It'' :,.'~/~ NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) MEDIAFLO USA, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION ADDRESS 5775 MOREHOUSE DRIVE CITY SAN DIEGO STATE CA ZIP 92121 TELEPHONE # (858) 651-3244 CELL # FAX # E-MAIL NAME OF AGENT JAMES J. PORTER. ESO . FIRM RUDEN MCCLOSKY ADDRESS 401 E. JACKSON ST., SUITE 2700 CITY TAMPA STATE FL ZIP 33602 TELEPHONE # (813) 222-66?0 CELL # FAX # (813) 314-6920 E-MAIL ADDRESSJIM.PORTER@RUDEN.COM - APPLICA TION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDlnONAL USE - 4//4/03. rev S/20I2ooS. rev 2//2/0B. rev. 1//4.0B - ~+iaillnfi:i'}~~mil~1~tjjJ:',~I~t~'l;".!~~1;~r;5,,~i~ '''l~~'''i ;~t';;l' . I~?' ,1('- :", ~ ;-; U~.' ~~IWi~~~I;!;':II~;; \'tb~~~: ~~ .," ~<; ,~~ ~~~A1f~'7~~~~'b...u.~1f.:";H .t"''<~'''JY.kZ:;,Uitil1'.v'1r,''-''''", r~ "'._ _ ~ t'.~\~,'\t, ,,-,:.~NSj ~(.."...~,..',_~..;" _=-_.,."., '1'.\, Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 27 of 167 Complete the following for all registered Assoclatlon(s) that could be affected by this petition. Provide additional sheets If necessary. Infonnatlon can be found on the Board of County Commissioner's webalte at httD:llwww.collleraov.netllndllX.8aDx7.........n4 Please see Exhibit "A", attached. NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAlUNG ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAlUNG ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIAnON: I. i' MAlUNG ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP '. . NAME OF MASTER ASSOCIAnON: MAlUNG ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF CIVIC ASSOCIAnON: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP I." . . ;OJSCl.OStJAEOF'IN1'iRm1NFC:m""T10N-;;,;X, l a. If the property Is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety, tenancy In common, or Joint tenancy, 1181 all part1e8 with an ownership Interest as well 88 the percentage of such Interest. (Use additional sheets If necessary). Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable, b. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stOCkholders and the percentage of stock owned by each. APPL/CAnON FOR PtJ61./C HEAR/NG FOR CONDfTIONAL I.I5E - 4//4/~J, rev S/2~/200S. rev2/12/08, rev. 7//4.08 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 28 of 167 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Existing Address) 5864 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Proposed Address) Applicant: MedlaFLO USA, Inc., a Delaware corporation Exhibit A List of Surroundine: Ree:istered Homeowners and Master Associations I. Falling Waters Beach Resort, Phase II Mr. Thomas Powers, President 6660 Beach Resort Drive, #6 Naples, FL 34114 2. Falling Waters Condominium Owners Association I Mr. Tom Lee, President 2202 Hidden Lake Drive, #7 Naples, FL 34112 3. Falling Waters Homeowners Association II Mr. Tim Boyle, President 2274 Hidden Lake Drive, #9 Naples, FL 34112 4. Magnolia Cove of Falling Waters Mr. Raymond C. McCabe, President 2338 Magnolia Lane, #2 Naples, FL 34112 5. Cascades of Falling Waters Condo Association Mr. George W. Baker, President 1972 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 6. Cascades at Falling Waters Mr. Robert Hinklin, President 2004 Cascades Drive, #1 Naples, FL 34112 7. Falling Waters Beach Resort Master Association Mr. Donald K. Bassett, President 6580 Beach Resort Drive, #3 Naples, FL 34112 TPA:642048,1 Name and Address Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 Percentage of Ownersft'iJse 29 of 167 See attached listing of officers for Renda Broadcasting Corporation, attached as Exhibit "8". c. If the property Is In the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the percentage of Interest. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. d. if the property Is In the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the general and/or limited partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. APPLICA nON FOR PU8L1C HEARING FOR CONOlnONAL USE - 4/14/03. rev S/20/200S, rev 2/ / 2/08. rev. 7//4.08 " . I www.sunbiz.org- Department of State Agenda Item No. 7B FebRag, :tl)~10 Page 30 of 167 Home Contact Us E-Flling Services Document Searches Fonns H Previous on List Next on List Return To List L--------~: No Events No Name History Detail by Entity Name Foreign Profit Corporation RENDA BROADCASTING CORPORATION Filing Information Document Number P30305 FEI Number 251259502 Date Filed 07126/1990 State PA Smtus ACTIVE Principal Address 10915 K-NINE DR BONITA SPRINGS Fl34135 . Changed 07/02/2007 Mailing Address 900 PARRISH ST 4TH FLOOR PITTSBURGH PA 15220 Changed 0412612000 Registered Agent Name & Address RENDA, ANTHONY F RENDA BROADCASTING CORP 10915 K-NINE DRIVE BONITA SPRINGS FL 34135-6602 US Name Changed: 07/0212007 Address Changed: 07/0212007 Officer/Director Detail Name & Address Title DPT RENDA, ANTHONY MERRIMAN RD. SEWlCKLEY PA 15143 I EXHIBIT B http://sunbiz.org/scripts/cordet.exe?action=DETFIL&in<L dOC_Dumber=P30305&in<L cam... 1212/2008 .! Www.sunbiz.org - Department of State AgerWilJ1El91~~ 7B Fe~~i'010 Page 31 of 167 Title DVS RENDA, CATHERINE R. MERRIMAN ROAD SEWlCKLEY PA 15143 Tit/eV SERENA, ALAN C 3111 CHESTNUT RIDGE DR PITTSBURGH PA 15205 Title DV KELLY, MARYANN 114 ALPINE CIR BELLE VERNON PA 15012 Title V REICH, JUDY 506 COVENl'Y TRAIL LANE MARYLAND HEIGHTS MO 63043 Annual Reports Report Year FIled Date 2006 07/1712006 2007 07/0212007 2008 0212812008 Document Images 0212812008 - ANNUAL REPORT 07/0212007 - ANNUAL REPORT 0711712006 - ANNUAL REPORT 03/1412005 - ANNUAL REPORT 03/0112004 ANNUAL REPORT 04122/2003 ANNUAL REPORT 0312412002 -- ANNUAL REPORT 05/15/2001 ANNUAL REPORT 04/26/2000 - ANNUAL REPORT 03/16/1999 - ANNUAL REPORT 04/14/1998 ANNUAL REPORT 04/21/1997 ANNUAL REPORT 05/01/1996 - ANNUAL REPORT 05/01/1995-ANNUAlREPORT~-6' .. ;). Note: This Is not official record. See documents If question or conflict. http://sunbiz.org/scriptslcordet.exe?action''''DETFIL&inlLdoc _number-P30305&inlL earn... 121212008 ,! . 'www.sunbiz.org - Department of State Age'lAA.tt6fl1~1lI"t. 7B Fe~fflP!IY~ :!01 0 Page 32 of 167 Previous on List Next on List Return To List ; L_____..___ No Events No Name History Home Contact us Document Searches E-Fillng Services FOmlS Help Copyrfght and Privacy Policies Copyright @ 2007 State of Florid., Department of State. http://sunbiz.orglscriptslcordet.exe?action=DETFIL&inCLdoc_numbet=P30305&inCL earn... 121212008 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 e. If there Is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or In8MdiRiH1l67 a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners. Name and Address Percentage of Ownership Not applicable. Date of Contract: f. If any contingency clause or contract terms Involve additional parties, list all Individuals or officers, If a corporation, partnership, or trust. Name and Address Not applicable. g. Date subject property acquired l8J Owner acquired property on January 13, 1999. leased 0 Term of lease yrsJmos. If, Petitioner has option to buy, Indicate the following: Date of option: Not applicable. Date option terminates: , or Anticipated closing date: h. Should any changes of ownership or changes In contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, It is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form. APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDITIONAL U5E - 4/14/03, rev 5/20/2005, rev 2/12/0B, rev. 7/14.08 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 34 of 167 Detailed leaal description of the prooertyeovered bv the BDollcatlon: (If space Is inadequate, attach on separate page.) If request involves chaA9tt to more than one zoni"9 district, Includtt ..parate legal description for propartylnvolved Intl8ch dl$trlot. APplicant liIhallsubmlt four (4) copies ofa reQeot survey (completeq within the la.st six months, maximum 1 ~ to 400' scale) If requi",c1 to do.o ~ t.he p~ application mtl8tlng. NOTE: The applicant Is rellponsJblefor supplyl~th6corrfCtleSaJ des:criptlon. If questions arise conQernlng tbelegaldescrlptlon, an engineer's certtflc.atlonorl$ealed 'survey may be required. Section/TownshlpIRange 08/50/26 Lot: B.lock: SUbdlvlslon: Also ktiOWl1e.s Lot2(). Encl:1anted Ac~ Plat Book Pagtt #: PropertY I.D.#: 00405160008 MliJtes & Bounds Description: SIZE OF PROPERTY: ft. X ft. _Total Sq. Ft. Acres 4.n ac (207,781.20 s.f. m.o.l.) ADDRESS/GENERAL LOCATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 5860 Crews Rd., Naples, FL (existing address), 58.64 Crews Rd., Naples. .FL (proposed ~ss) 1"'~I!!""i/,!:"''''.iiiJ''.'','.:'''"1!.'''''''~.,....,''(_. "'" ........."... .,. ...'..'.'.....,;iir',.,.'..~. \'J... ...'.!: '~r l'-"" ..,~. ',:.', _<"~ii'i';;:).,,.,.,~,..,..,..,.~~,~. . .. . .,..'':,_ J. :".'." ..i ",'hi; ''''~,'i!;'..:..,-;.. ~.. ~ - Zoning N PUD S E E PUD W PUO Land use Non-agricultural acreage I vlilOant Non-agricultural acreage / vacant Non-agricultural aoreage / vacant Non-agricultural acreage I Vacant Does the owner of the subject property own property contiguous to the subject property? If 80, gIve complete legal description of entire cOIltlguous property. (If space is Inadequate, attach on separate page). Not applicable. Section/TownshlplRange / / Lot: Block: Subdivision: Not applicable. Plat Book Page #: Property 1.0.#: - APPlICA T/ON FOR PUBLIC HEAIIING FOR CONDlT/ONAl USE-11M/OJ, rev S/20/Z(JiJS, av 2/ [2/0B. rev. 7/ /1.08 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 35 of 167 LEGAL DESCRIPTION Property located in Collier, FL The West one-half(W Yo) of the Northwest one-quarter (NW V.) of the Southeast one- quarter (SE v.) of the Southeast one-quarter (SE V.) of Section 8, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County Florida, also known as Tract No. 20, Enchanted Acres, less the South 30 feet for road right-of-way purposes. AND BEING the same property conveyed to Renda Broadcasting Corpomtion, a Pennsylvania corporation from Sterling Communication Corpomtion, a Florida corpomtion by Warranty Deed dated January 13, 1999 and recorded January 20, 1999 in Deed Book 2503, Page 1624. Tax Parcel No. 00405160008 EXHIBIT I G Metes &: Bounds Description: Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 36 of 167 .',j:DISJAlL: TVDe of Conditional Use: This application is requesting a conditional use allowed per LDC Section 2.04.03 of the J; zoning district for installation of broadcastina eauioment and antenna to exlstina tower (type of use). Present Use of the Property: Existing communication tower. I. ,;i.-.-..,:,_.", '", ..'--'. " ....,.." '-','Iol'l~",;:'li."",~~j',li:l!lM"'"-""""'-"''':''>''''''""'r~i" 'W'" ., ,,'-, :.:, , ::"\:, ,:"'~:i::,:~;?:~;:~:~.~tm~~',- :~:r~~,,'.;~;:;~C~:)~:.:':,~" ,':5>;,~'~:~-:,:,~:t.':'>i~,:::;." :":;,;:'~i.. ' Evaluation Criteria: Provide a narrative statement describing this request for conditional use. See Exhibit "0", attached. NOTE: Pursuant to Section 10.08.00. of the Collier County Land Development Code, staffs recommendation to the Planning Commission and the Planning Commission's recommendation to the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be based upon a finding that the granting of the conditional use will not adversely affect the public Interast and that the specific requirements governing the indMdual conditional use, If any, have been met, and that further, satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable. Please provide detailed response to each of the criterion listed below. Specify how and why the request Is consistent with each. (Attach additional page. a. may be necessary). a. Describe how the project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan (include Information on how the request is consistent with the applicable section or portions of the More land use element): b. Describe the existing or planned means of ingress and egress to the property and proposed structura thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: C. Describe the effect the conditional use will have on neighboring properties In relation to noise, glare, economic impact and odor: d. Describe the site's and the proposed use's compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district: APPUCAnON FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDmONAl US. - 4//4/01, rev 5/20/200$, nv 2/12/08. nv. 7/14.08 Agenda Item No. 7B Fe=: 23,2010 e. Please provide any additional information which you may feel is relevant to this re .37 of 167 " Deed Restrictions: The County Is legally precluded from enforcing deed restrictions, however, many communities have adopted such restrictions. You may wish to contact the civic or property owners association in the area for which this use Is being requested In order to ascertain whether or not the request is affected by existing deed restrictions. Previous land use Detltlon8 on the 8ublect D1'0Dertv: To your knowledge, has a public hearing been held on this property within the last year? If so, what was the nature of that hearing? No. . OUI~lal Interoretatlons or Zonlna Verifications: To your knowledge, has there been an . otfIclallnterpretatlon or zoning verification rendered on this property within the last year? 1:81 Yes 0 No If so, please provide copies. See Exhibit "En, attached. Additional Submlttll reaulrementa: In addition to this completed application, the follOWing must be submitted In order for your application to be deemed sufficient, unless otherwise waived during the pre-application meeting. a. A copy of the pre-application meeting notes; See Exhibit "F", attached. b. Twenty (20) copies of a 24" x 36" conceptual site plan [and one reduced 8~" x 11" copy of site plan], drawn to a maximum scale of 1 Inch equals 400 feet, depicting the following [Additional copies of the plan may be requested upon completion of staff evaluation for distribution to the Board and various advisory boards such as the Environmental Advisory Board (EAB), or CCPC]; · all existing and proposed structures and the dimensions thereof, · provisions for existing and/or proposed Ingress and egress (including pedestrian Ingress and egress to the site and the structure(s) on site), · all existing and/or proposed parking and loading areas [Include matrix Indicating required and provided parking and loading, Including required parking for the disabled], · locations of solid waste (refuse) containers and service function areas, · required yards, open space and preserve areas, · proposed locations for utHltles (as well as location of existing utility services to the site), · proposed and/or existing landscaping and buffering as may be required by the County, · location of all signs and lighting Including a narrative statement as to the type, character, and dimensions (such as height, area, etc.); APPLlCAnON FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR CONDmoNAL USE - 4/14/03, ,,",5/20/2ooS, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7/14.08 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 38 of 167 c, An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), as required by Section 3.8. of the Land Development Code (LDC). Not required. d. Whether or not an EIS is required, two copies of a recent aerial photograph, (taken within the previous twelve months), minimum scale of one inch equals 400 feet, shall be submitted. Said aerial shall Identify plant and/or wildlife habitats and their boundaries. Such identifICation shall be consistent with Florida Department of Transportation Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System. See Exhibit "G", attached. , e. Statement of utility provisions (with all required attachments and sketches); See Exhibit "H", ! attached. f. A Traffic Impact Statement (TIS), unless waived at the pre-application meeting; Not required. g. A historical and archeological surveyor waiver application If property Is located within an area of historical or archaeological probability (as Identified at pre-application meeting); Not required. h. Any additional requirements as may be applicable to specific conditional uses and identified during the pre-application meeting, Including but not limited to any required state or federal permits. BE ADVISED THAT SECTION 10.03.05.B.3 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIRES AN APPUCANT TO REMOVE THEIR PUBUC HEARING SIGN (S) AFTER FINAL ACTION IS TAKEN BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. BASED ON THE BOARD'S FINAL ACTION ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE REMOVE ALL PUBUC HEARING ADVERnSING SIGN(S) IMMEDIATELY. Within 30 days of adoption of the Ordinance, the owner or developer (specify name) at Its expense shall record in the Public Records of Collier County a Memorandum of Understanding of Developer Commitments or Notice of Developer Commitments that contains the legal description of the property that Is the subject of the land use petition and contains each and every commitment of the owner or developer specified In the Ordinance. The Memorandum or Notlceshall be in form acceptable to the County and shall comply with the recording requirements of Chapter 695, FS. A recorded copy of the Memorandum or Notice shall be provided to the assigned Principal Planner, Collier County Zoning Department, within 15 days of recording of said Memorandum or Notice. APPLlCAnoN FOR PU8LlCHEARlNGFORCONO/OONAL llSE-4/14/03, rw5/20/2005, rev2/12/08, rev. 1/14.08 I . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 39 of 167 Application for Conditional Use 5860 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Existing Address) 5864 Crews Road, Naples, Florida (Proposed Address) Applicant: MediaFLO USA, IDe., a Delaware corporation Exhibit D Narrative Statement The Applicant seeks approval of a conditional use request to permit the co-location of broadcast equipment on an existing wireless tower located at 5860 Crews Road (existing address), in Collier County, Florida (the "Project"). The Project will essentially entail the addition of cellular antenna and broadcast equipment to an already existing, functioning tower and as such will require only minor alterations, at best, to the site as it presently exists. There will be no additional employees stationed at or accessing the site due to the installation, and no additional building square footage will be assoeiated with the Project. a. The Project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC) and Growth Management Plan. The Project is consistent with the County's desire to "maximize the shared use of specified tower sites to minimize the need for additional tower sites," as set forth in Section 5.05.09(A) of the LOC. The essential service provider for the Project is the U.S. Department of Justice, FBI, an agency of the Federal Government, in compliance with Section 5,05.09(G)(3) of the LOC. The Project is consistent with the LDC provisions governing the standards for design, vegetation screening, construction and facilities setting for communications toWCl'S. b. Means of ingress and egress to the Property and proposed structure; automotive and pedestrian safety; traffic flow and control; access in case of fire or catastrophe. The Property features an existing private access road from Crews Road as a means of ingress and egress to the Property for maintenance vehicles and in the event of frre or catastrophe. There are existing parking spaces on the Property for maintenance vehicles. As the faeility is an un-manned site, no alterations to the existing parking or to the existing means of ingress and egress on the Property are required. Pedestrians and the general public will not have access to the site. c. The Project will have a minimal effect on neighboring properties with regard to noise, glare, economic impact and odor. The Project involves the installation of an additional antenna to an already existing communication tower and will require the addition of an enclosed generator. Notwithstanding, the Projcct will have only a minimal effect, if any. with regard to noise and glare to neighboring properties given (i) the tower already exists and (it) the Project involves only the addition of equipment to the existing tower. The Project will have no known effect on neighboring properties with regard to odor or economic impact. d. CompatibDity with adjacent properties and other properties in the district. The compatibility of the site with adjacent properties will not be affected by the co-location of broadcast equipment on the existing communications tower. Given (i) the tower already exists and (ii) the Project involves only the addition of equipment to the existing tower, the existing compatibility of the site with adjacent properties and other properties in the district will not be disturbed. TPA,639135,1 .1 (i) Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 40 of 167 STATEMENT OF UTILITY PROVISIONS FOR CONDITIONAL USE REQUEST a. b. COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM CITY UTILITY SYSTEM FRANCHISED UTILITY SYSTEM PROVIDE NAME PACKAGE TREATMENT PLANT (GPO capacity) SEPTIC SYSTEM r',".1I"",~'1!"JI'i~>~"~~~_m';"i:'~ '6\'W'!;i".,;A,~.{,1;;,.r"',r;!d;jfr:,,,;>c,~ ,,",',,.!( .':' . -, ,',,,,,,,' ,.i"",,:~"""'_'l'U;-' , " ~"' ',. NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) MEDIAFLO USA., INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION ADDRESS 5775 MOREHOUSE DRIVE CITY SAN DIEGO STATE CA ZIP 92121 TELEPHONE # (858) 651-3244 CELL # FAX # E-MAIL ADDRESS: ADDRESS OF SUBJECT PROPERTY (IF AVAILABLE): 5860 Crews Rd. (existing address), 5864 Crews Rd. (proposed address) 1"r''''l:i:''(:''liI'.<ii;.~''IIlI.ii1.' '.;""'II\r""~E"'~~'::"'~':"1 '~-:1~P'\;' -,~:,'! ' ",~Yi~~' " ,~~)i~;€>~'.,~~~ ,,~~~'~'~,"~',''m_!,~~,,~:'~-'.'~,:~ .. SectlonfTownshiplRange 08/50/26 Lot: Block: Subdivision: aiWa Tract 20, Enchanted Acres Plat Book Page #: Property 1.0.#: 00405160008 Metes & Bounds Description: I::'~: "',~:;,:;..'~~~""", :'~"',:iJt&i"" ::i ":-:~~:""-"",.,~,1;,~.>.,~.\~..~1tr;1~:',";, '," -;",'. '\' ,',',',. "',;',.., ; "'-"."":"'" ,. (Check appllcsble system): o o o o o ..,.......,......".... ...".-, .."...... me".-AW!$EiilIIB"_' !...~~~..,.~..>,...' .....". ",,'..", . .",... 'PE:.w" 0 ' 'linE......",,' ." > ":: ::":',,:' ,'". . ':'."',,,,' :' fl.1- ".."~,,,,;,- ",,' -';,-':~-' '.~-,-'"",',.,"','~ ";::,,,,-,,:,, o o o o c. d. e. a. b. c. COUNTY UTILITY SYSTEM CITY UTILITY SYSTEM FRANCHISED UTILITY SYSTEM PROVIDE NAME PRIVATE SYSTEM (WELL) d. ..~ .-. APPLICATION FOR PU8L1C HEARING FOR CONO/nONAL USE - 4/14/03, rev 5110/200S, rev 2/12/08, rev. 7//4,08 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 A. WATER-PEAK AVERAGE DAILY Page41 of 167 B. SEWER-PEAK AVERAGE DAILY IF PROPOSING TO BE CONNECTED TO COLLIER COUNTY REGIONAL WATER SYSTEM, PLEASE PROVIDE THE DATE SERVICE IS EXPECTED TO BE REQUIRED Not applicable. 1Il~:" ," Provide a brief and concise narrative statement and schematic drawing of sewage treatment process to be used as well as a specific statement regarding the method of affluent and sludge disposal. If percolation ponds are to be used, then percolation data and soli involved shall be provided from tests prepared and certified by a professional engineer. I' I'"~ . ' '~"',,' , :' , , :.t.., )' ~ 8IIi If the project is located within the services boundaries of Collier County's utility service system, written notarized statement shall be provided agreeing to dedicate to Collier County Utilities the water distribution and sewage collection facilities Within the project area upon completion of the construction of these facilities in accordance with all applicable County ordinances in effect at the at time. This statement shall also include an agreement that the applicable system development charges and connection fees will be paid to the County Utilities Division prior to the issuance of building permits by the County. If applicable, the statement shall contain shall contain an agreement to dedicate the appropriate utility easements for serving the water and sewer systems. .:::r ' . 'r ~ ~, _, _. ~ ~ ... , , ..' =" I~ -, I ., " \::.. 1':~ i "" ~. I ,;, j -1 ':'! '~, .,., ~ \." , I . : -:", Unless waived or otherwise provided for at the pre-application meeting, if the project is to receive sewer or potable water services from any provider other than the County, a statement from that provider indicating that there is adequate capacity to serve the project shall be provided. APPLlCAnON FOR PUBLIC HEARINC FOR CONDlnONAL USE - 4/14/03, rev S/ZO/Z005, rev Z/IZ/OB, rev. 7/14,08 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 42 of 167 COLLffiRCOUNTYGOVERNMENT April 3, 2008 Margaret Smith MediaFLO USA c/o Redna Broadcasting 2 Larkspur Ct Greenfield, NY 12833 Community Development and Environmental Services Division Department of Zoning and Land Development Review 2800 North Horseshoe Drive' Naples, Florida 341 04 RE: ZoniDg Verification Letter ZLTR.2007-AR-12825, zoning verification for property addressed as 5860 Crews Road, legally described as the West Y, of Northwest V. of Southeast V. of Southeast V. Less the South 30-foot right-of-way. in Section 8, Township SO South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. Property ID No: 00405160008 Dear Ms. Smith: In your application dated January 23, 2008 you request a zoning determination regarding the two existing communication towers and your desire to co-Iocate antennas on the lower that was to be dismantled on the subject property. The zoning for the subject properly is Estates with an approved conditional use (Resolution 93-219). As provided below, an expansion of the original approved conditional USe cannot be granted; furthennore, the tower designated to be dismantled remains and must be removed in order to comply with the terms of approval of the original conditional use. The conditional use, referenced above, was approved on May 25, 1993 for the subject property to allow the replacement of the existing 438-foot guyed communications tower and accessory structures with a 430-foot guyed communications tower and a new 2,400 square foot building. Site Development Plan (SDP) 93-62 was approved July 23, 1993 showing the new 430-foot guyed communications tower and accessory buih.ling. An amendment to SDP 93-62 was approved July 19, 1999, proposing the replacement of the. existing 430-fool guyed communications tower with a stronger 394-fool communications tower. Several insubstantial changes to SDP 93-62 have been approved to add generators or co-locate antennas on onto an existing tower on the site, Your application states you would like to co.locate antennas Ofi the tower that was to be dismantled. A current aerial shows two towers existing on the subject property. The approved conditional use provided for the replacement of an existing communications tower; not an expansion of use by adding an additional tower. Section 10.08.00, of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC), provides for conditional use procedures and requires any additional uses or expansion of pennitted uses not shown on the conceptual site development plan or otherwise specifically provided for in the c , Phone (239) 403-2400 j ~ EXHIBIT E c c) u " " or (239) 213-2913 www.co1liergov.net Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 43 of 167 conditional use application to undergo submittal, review and approval of a new conditional use application. LDC Section 5.05.09,G states no new tower of any height shall be permitted in the Estates zoning district exccpt for essential serviccs listed in subsection 5.05.09.G.3, thereby prohibiting the expansion of the approved conditiOnal use. Please be advised that the information presented in this verification letter is based on the Land Development Code and/or Growth Management Plan in effect as of this date. It is possible that subsequent amendment(s) to either of these documents could affect the validity of this verification letter. It is also possible that development of the subject property could be affected by other issues not addressed in this letter, such as, but not limited to, concurrency related to the provision of adequate public facilities, environmental impact, and other requirements of the Collier County Land Development Code or related ordinances. Should you require further information please do not hesitate to call me at (239) 252- 5748. Researched and prepared by: Reviewed by: ~- ss oc ur, Planning Manager Department of Zoning and Land Development Review ~~ ~h~ (!? 'stine Willoughby, P~er Department of Zoning and Land Development Review Cc: Conespondence File, ZLTR-2008-AR-12825 Mike Sawyer, Senior Planner Peggy Jarrell, Addressing Section EXHIBIT I F Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 44 of 167 . < OLUER COUNTY GOVERNMENT EPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPM WW.COLllERGOV.NET 0.,,68 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRM NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643- (i) CONDITIONAL USE PETITION I I 1 i I' I I I , 1 PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Project Name: I. Applicant Name'~ Firmt J.n.;. +t.- / 14~ Current Zoning' f. ~~ ~Nkath~ Owner Name: Owner Addressl Phone, Meeting Attendeesl (attach Sign In Sheet) NOnS: Cb"'~'1it. vb'" \ ~\ , , '.10 .. ... ...ro~' Jon WI'l;{A 0 "1lZM.\s ATI!)N <f>1A,."A./,.-Jt- S>JB.l'flr I"f L.efrT6!-. "$~Tn.Ir. "'~""7 ~ ,4PD/7~.o..c..... "'Tt.1P "=~""r~.lU. A-U:- ?~e:>~SGl> .+c;. ~~ oF- n/l90 C6,v'J>IT..'I/""'- us.e. . - lls.h;r; SJliW,,:S SVf/.I;IJ't 11////1 FvCi/j 0;11 !MtJ'(ocMIP.tJ w"""~f.1.~ (/< (lV,) ANn ~/6 Ct"J1,.e~ rfJ)' J'1J1/~rrlS'. - WIj-l{M/J .)1I;t'J/lI(.;ta1/,4( ~-fEIUtw'Mr"# - P~-Sl (.#A-t/i /!2/;-j'i/Ul.::: A-/lIi;9 off/ C() .J' /1$ jJlA4/. (/0/0 Q F ill~ G+l.ffw( .AlAfrv/; VIi(~t'AkLW O"v..f/#;) J.r;s.(}7 'K. , Agenda Item No. 7B Februaly 23, 2010 Page 45 of 167 ,. CONDmeNAL USE (CU) APPLlCAnON SUBMITTAL CHI!CKUST " THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. REQUIREMENTS ro ect o EDt "Fest Trock" must submk opproved copy of official oppllcotton o Affordable HousIng ''expedited" must submit copy of signed Certiffc:are of A reet'rfOnt. PLANNER MARK IF NEEDED TO BE ROUTED TO REVIEWERS BELOW: I b th d i' f OF COPIES REQUIRED 20 20 1 I 20 20 2 1 2 1 5 1 7 3 4 4 1 2 2 NOT REQUIRED I ~.- .)(" ~ Comm...." shou d e forwarded to the Planner Drier to e due ate SCHOOL DISTRICT (lJ lARKS & lEe ",Murdo $mIIh- (I) SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS (IJ UTILITIES ENGINEERING - Zamlra Delloro (1) COMMUNITY PLANNING SA YSHORE/GATEWA Y TRIANGLE COORDINATOR - LInda Bed/e/yon (I) REDEVELOPMENT Executive Director (I) Communications Towers Onl MOSQUITO CONTROL NAPLES AIRPORT AUTHORITY 1 COLLIER CO. AIRPORT AUTHORITY 1) 1 CITY OF NAPLES, Robin Sin or, Plannln Dlr. 2 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 46 of 167 FEES! .. ~ Pre-applleatlon Fee $500.00 (Applications submllled 9 monlhs or more after the dale 01 the las! pr....pp meellng shall nol be credited Iowards application fees and a new pre- applieallon meellng will be required.) .~ Appllcallon Fee / $1500 if flied in conjuncllon with a rezone petitIon Fire Code Review Comprehensive PlaMlng Conslslency Review EsIImated Legal Advertising Fee - CCPC Mealin; EsIImaled Legal Advertising Fee - BCC Meeting (any over- or under-payment wUl be reconciled upon recelpt of Invoice from Noples Dally News). $2,500.00 EIS Review, II required AlIA $1000.00 Usted or Protetled Speclet sGivey review fe. (when an E1S Is nol required) $4,000.00 $150.00 $300.00 $760.00 $363.00 Transportation Fee., If required. ~ o $500.00 Methodology Review Fee, If required o $750.00 Minor Study Review Fee, If required ^, I!Jr .fl o $1 ,500.00 Malor Study Review Fee, If required J V I r OTHER REQUIREMENTS: o n n n AppllcanJlAgertI SignaIure Dale 3 !. i I I , I i !" I - , - Agenda Item No. 78 February 23,2010 Page 47 of 167 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS LDC 10.03.05 F. Applicant must conduct at least one Nelghbomood Infonnatlonal Meeting [NIM) after Initial staff review and comment an the application and before the Public Hearing Is scheduled with the Plamlng Commission. r I. I I I , Written notice of the meeting shall be sent to 011 property owners who are required to receive legal notification from the County pursuant 10 Section 1 0.03.05.8.8. Notification shall also be sent to property owners, condominIum and civic ClssocJatlons whose members are Impacted by the proposed land use change and who have fonnally requested the County to be notified. i I I I' A copy of the list of all parties noticed, and the date, time, and location of the meeting, . must be furnished to the Zoning Department and the Office of the Board of County CommIssioners no less than ten (10) days prior to the scheduled date of the NIM. The applicant must make arrangements for the location of the meeting. The location must be reasonably convenient to those property owners who are required to receive notice and the facilitIes must be of sufficient size to accommodate e.xpected attendance. . The applicant must place on advertisement of the meeting In that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and classified advertisements appear stating the purpose, location, time of the meeting and legible sife location map of the property for which the %OIlIng change Is being requested. The display advertisement must be one-fourth page, In type no smaller rhan 12 point and must be placed within a newspaper of general circulation In the County at /east seven (7) days prior to, but no sooner rhan five (5) days before, the NIM. The Collier County staff planner assigned to the prafect must attend the NIM and shall serve as the facilitator of the meeting; however, the applicant Is expected to make a presentation of how It Intends to develop the sublect property. The applicant is required to audio or video tape the proceedings of the meeting and provide a copy to the Zoning Department. As a result of mandated meetIngs with the pUblic, any COIl1mltments made by Ifte applicant shall be reduced to writing and made a part of the record of the proceedIngs provided to Ifte ZonIng Department. These written commllmenls will be made a part of the staff report of Ifte County's ClU'lew and apP~al boclJesand mad.. a part of -.the consideration for inclusIon In the conditions of approval. ,1'''~ a:M-v ~~ arf~'d'Jv, . 4 ~ ~ z 5 :E l!) ... ~ Q ~ II ;S 1 a. ~ 1 > .; ,! 0 "'CS (:!l 'C .! II = ... 0 it c 0 ~ .g - "; o II C "'CS .~ ~ 'I: "- lJ "" j it ... ;; Ii :i o _ :e "e 3! :e > W lJ Q .!: i .... .... t'). l:'C ~ 'i III l:'C Z ~ Z ('C <( &: ... II a.. ..II Q E III ;) Z Z (!) II 2l Ii 4'{ if I ~ .., 2 A. 1ii m ~ ... :c( ~ I ~ a.. t ~ ~:e I.! ~ Q.. ~ 0 !i \~, 8 1 .. ~ z .. , ! t ! I~ ~ ~ i i .~ o oS i a:; z Cl ~ t Ci T , .' Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 49 of 167 COlUER COUNTY GOVERNMENT ADDRESSING DEPARTMENT (i) 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 ADDRESSING CHECKLIST Please oomplete the following and fax to the Addressing Department at 239-252-5724 or submft in person to the Addressing Department at the above address. Form must be signed by Addressing personnel prior to pre-application meeting. Not allltems wUl apply to eveJY project. Items in bold type are required. Forms older than e months will require eddlUonel review and approval by the Addressing Department PETlnON TYPE (Gh9Ck petition type balow, complete a separafll Addres8/ng Checklist for ellGh Petition Type) o BL (Blasting Permit) 0 SOP (Slle Development Plan) o BD (Boat Dock Extension) 0 SDPA (SOP Amendment) g,CemlvllflClrcus Permit 0 SDPI Onsubstantlal ChlUlge to SDP) J/!liI CU (CondlUonal Use) 0 SIP (She Improvement Plan) o EXP (Excavation Permit) 0 SIP I (Insubstantial Change to SIP) o FP (Final Plat 0 SNR (Street Name Change) o LLA (Lot Une Adjustment) 0 SNC (Street Name Change - Unplatted) o PNC (Projeol Name Change) 0 TOR (Transfer of Development Rights) o PPL (Plans & Plat Review) 0 VA (Valiance) o PSP (preliminary Subdivision Plat) 0 VRP (VegetaUon Removal Permit) o PUD Rezone 0 VRSFP (Vegetation Removal & She FlU Permit) o RZ (Standard Rezone) 0 OTHER LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subject property or properties (copy of lengthy description may be ettached) 00 -at." -'8 . ~~C:L G...3 FOLIO (Property (0) NUMBER(s) of above (attach to, or associate wi/h, legal description if more than Dna) o~ ~\(.,O~ STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES (as applicable, if already assigned) ese<oo ~80S 'i<.t::-;. . LOCATION MAP must be attached showing exeat location of projecVslte in relation to nearest public road rtght-of-way . SURVEY (oopy - needed only for unplatted properties) PROPOSED PROJECT NAME (if appJlcablIJ) PROPOSED STREET NAMES (if app/iceb/e) SITE DEVElOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (for exlsling projectsls/1es only) SDP orAR# I EXHIBIT I Page 1 of2 C9 I Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 50 of 167 ADDRESSING CHECKLIST - PAGE TWO Project or development names proposed for, or already appearing In, condominium documents (If application; Indlcata wIlether proposed or existing) Please Check One: 0 Chacklislls to be Faxed back B4'ersonally Picked Up APPUCANT NAME: \~LbLA. ~Q&1M<a-> / t:iWl1"lJ2."i i1x f\tp\ 1CMt- PHONE FAX Signature on Addressing Checklist does not constitute Project and/or Street Name approval and is subject to further review by the Addressing Department. FOR STAFF USE ONL V Primary Number --9 '3 4-'?\ Address Number Address Number AddreSll Number Approved bc;:;;?~1UU1 f Updated by: Date: &-~-o~ Date: IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST BE UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED Page 2 of2 G:\Current\AppUcatlon t::orms\AddressJng Ch&ckllst rev 042908.doe. -'" _ D. ..IIIAl1lUl QUllLES . _ SlIm3llO f501 T_,M. T1AlL -. -.IS. fLllIIlIl MIOJ Tho. inctNmenl PfWo1IW by: Agenda Item No. 7B February , 2010 Page 5 of 167 2422539 OR: 2503 PG: 1624 IICOUII it ''''CIlL WitS tI CDUIII CDIIn, u 11/11/11 It 0:111I "111I1. IIDCI, CIRI call UI3l1." II( m 11.11 1OC.,11 llUI ,John O. Hum"hmvi~. EWlUlft' QlW'11!S & 8r.lf.ly .4501 TilfTuanu TrAil North Sui~ 300 Naplfi,. Flomia J4 toJ leU, QGlILU IIWI IllllUlW" lUll J.l/L11 fl 11I11 111I WARRANTY DEED This Indenlur.. madelhi, /3 '_I! day of Ja flUe. 01 1999, between Slerlins Communication COlporation, a Florida corporation, aRANTOR. and Renda Broadcasti"S Corporation a Pennsylvania Corporation, whose federal employer identifICation number is , and whose post office address i, 14S9 Crane Avenue, Pimburgh, Penn.ylvania 15220, GRANTEE. Witnesseth that said Granlor, lor and in consideration of Ihe sum of TfN DOLLARS, and other sood and valuoble considemion, to said Granlor In hand paid by said Grantee. the I'K8ipt whereof is hereby acknowledged, Iw sranled, bargained and sold to the said Grantee and Gran....', heirs and asslsn' forever, lhe following described land. ,lluale. lying and being in Collier County. Florida, ./~.RCO'0. ~'v~ vA"~ The West One-ha~f t!J <If the North er (NW 1/4) 01 the SouI'-sI on....... ~SOUthe.ut on or (SE 1/4) of 5odion 8, Township 50 h.' ...~. Ea Coun F. Ido, also known as Tract No. 20, &lc:lfant t h\r road npt-of-way purposes. I! ~ I ~ \ \r-:i u. ;...,/ Subjecllo reslrictl~ ~ese"'ation a eo\Sl!01. e 'blr;y:./' Ill, if any: and real estale t.... for the\~1999. and all 'u~Je. nr ' . bearing Propeny Identification Number,' . 5160008. ~ ',J / c': '\. r. /~~ y and said Grdntor does hereby fu~~tfQ'~ land, and will defend Ihe ",me apn_t the lawful claims of all perso~;'~"'" In Witness When>of. the Grantor ha, hereun.o 'el Granlor'_ hand and seal the day and year first above written, Slsned, sealed and delivered in our presence: STERLING COMMUNICATIOI1!irr CORf'()RATlON,a rlarid" ~llon ..-t:r'~ . .~ ~ B. TI , ._ president 2500 Airpon Road, South Naples. Florida 34 I 12 ~.aqA'm...) W s'l 'J:M 'g Tl'w-.hU Print name . " 'f. . .'....?. : 'J1W4,"ofJ)~"":" Witness '2 (LK,.~; C,. wal:i.."Oh Print name . .,.,: .' ..' f QMU\~"C1tst.l j EXHIBIT V Agenda Item No. 7B ,2010 Page 52 of 167 ttt OR: 2503 PG: 1625 ttt ST....TEOF r LOi!./J),J. COUNTY OF l ~ o/'( The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this I j'~ day of , J~""" 'J ' 1999, by Bruce B. Timm. a. President of Sterlins Communications Corporati , (rf who i, pe..onally known to me or I I who produced as identification. I "'nlaAl/\<-, W. X.'iI'J NOT....RY PUBLIC (SW) Inl"r iZSJtA Ill. f dA(- N_me of Notary, Printed, Typed or Stamped My Commis$ion Expires: ...-....---- _.~.,~ ,/\f;.R CO,,:,,, ":>. \"'>"'-~"'!I\r:-" /. 0\ ,;.--" '. Maor.IIO W, Laog /.i..'-/ ~ ': ,.'~~'ca'''''...... f / 1-1' 0.:.... .' / \____ .. .. '.. ;.""IIfotAHClf': /. ~;Y;~o:;::-'!\\V/ . \ \ r.l\\....Y\'J) :u J ,~I I-I .. ~J \'..,'\ ) /, \.~\ _~ ,.."-'J 'IA,-" ''V\,J/,O/ ~l .. /,~I ..... r"'''''''' /."'" / .,-.-;!/.,. .:'-..., .--/"'. \\ ~.... <.~!zg Cj\~~->'" --- ~l'JCllnl Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 53 of 167 (i) AFFIDAVIT Deborah Barret.t MediaFLO USA, Ine, is an Applicant tor a w1reless inStallation on the Wel" ".....' '~9 being first duly sworn, depose and say that ~ property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, Including the disclosure of Interest information, all sketches. data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief. We/I understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted. the Applicant Kimberly J. Madison, Esq. As ~ Well further authorize _ to act as ourlmy representative in any matters regarding this Petition. ~~ Signature of Applicant \"I1UUUl tTu:l Deborah Barrett Sr. Oirector, Operations Signature of Property Owner Typed or Printed Name of Owner t:e1'liel: Si'e.a Be..e.lephu!!'l.'e- Hall..A~cJ:: E<16hloU RegieR Typed or Printed Name of ~ Applicant The foregoing instrument was acknowledged belore me this ?..v,';J . day of t7(],kPt1 20k'b., by if)/;Jr1VJ 1&1/71itt who Is personally known to me or has produced as identification. - - ~ ~ - - - - - - - - ~ l@ ~~= l j.; NoIary I\bk: . C<IIlfomIo ~ .. san :>>go CWlIy - - - - ~~~~~~ ,. .;;." / <-"..~-_.___.,~~-L.,~ (Signatlfl'e of Notary Public) c../ '6'lIJIlt'- 3c:06Z fnl/$IZt1r0 (Prin, Type, or Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public) I ""'-,',~<,. . I ,.",." APPllCAnON FOR PUBLIC HlARING FOR CONDIOONAL USE - 4/14.'03, r~v 5/20/2005, rev:?;12/0S Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 54 of 167 (i) AFFIDAVIT Well, Bill Mueller on behalf of Renda Broadcastino Corp being first duly swom, depose and say that well am/are the owners of the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief. Well understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurete and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered, Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted, As property owner Well further authorize Kimberlv Madison of Ruden McCloskv to represent Renda Broadcastin in relation to the conditional use etltion and. to act as ourlmy representatil,< I an aft regarding this Petition. ----;7 '" () )q Signature of Property Owner Signature of Property Owner Bill Mueller Typed or Printed Name of Owner Typed or Printed Name of Owner The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 02-'i~ay of ~~ . ~// //./. /J 20%, by ~ :7~/i(L--L'" Uu who is personally known to me or has produced as identification. (Notary Stamp) {Print, Type, or Stamp page 10 of 10 conditional Use Extension Application - Feb, 2008 ~~. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 55 of 167 Collfer Mosquito Control District 600 North Road, Naples, FL 34104-3464 AdmInistration: (Z39) 436-1000 / (239) 436-1005 (fax) Hangar: (239) 436-1008 / (239) 436-1007 (fax) www l':DIller-nm~DUft:o.Of'Q November 13, 2009 Dear Mr, Heckerman, The Collier Mosquito Control District endorses your request that an exemption to the local code requirements be granted with respect to the property at 5860 Crews Road, Naples, FL with FAA registration number 1056659. Sincerely, Kelly Huff Director of Operations ')<. ,,"col'd of c."mmJ$SJon~n!, EJc~Mlt1e Olrector; Fronk Vtm Esse-n. Ph.D. Spray S<h.dufe: (Z39) 435-1010 ~cquf!lyn D. Fres~nju4 Chair 1m F. JOhnson, Secretrny Robe-t o. Geroy, Tr~trSurer J~annlt e. Stook., Und(f M. Hartman APPENDIX 3 Immoka1ee Substation; J65 Altpf1'* Blvd, IJfdg A.IX 'mmo1mte~ R. 341.4Z (Z39) 867-3ZOO Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 56 of 167 Renda Broadcasting - Naples towers Tenant Roll as of 11-25-2009 Property Name Tenant Name Naples Renda (New) Wireless One Network, Lp, A Delaware limited Part (AT&T) Naples Renda (New) Nextel South Corp" a Georgia Corporation Naples Renda (New) MetroPCS California/Florida, Inc. Naples Renda (New) T-Moblle Naples Renda (New) Verlzon Wireless Personal Communications LP Naples Renda (New) Sprint Spectrum L,P. a Delaware limited Partnership Naples Renda (New) Alltell Communications Naples Renda (New) WSGL -FM Renda Broadcasting Naples Renda (New) Florida Power & Light Company, A Florida Corporatl Naples Renda (Old) Lojack Corporation Naples Renda (Old) Verizon Wireless Messaging Services (inactive) Naples Renda (Old) US Department of Justice Naples Renda (Old) Reach Communications - APPENDIX 1 - ., ,/ Agenda Item No. /l::l February 23, 2010 Page 57 of 167 ;~ Structural a~ ~~!T'e~~nts Structural Components, LlC '617 PeeM Street. Unit A Boulder, CO 60302 Voice: 866-386-7622 Fax: 303-962.3577 November 16, 2009 Jerry Heckerman Renda Broadcasllng of SW Florida 10915 K-Nlne Drive Bonita Springs. Fl 34135 Re: Structural Review - Fall Radius Assessmant Structures: (1) 454' ERI Guyed Tower. (1) 454' Allied Guyed Tower Site Add.ress: 5860 Crews Road', Naples. FL 33942 Site Name (#): Renda Broadcasting (Naples) SC Number: 090339 Dear Mr. Heckerman: I am writing this letter in reference to YOllr requesl for Structural Components, LlC to provide our opinion of the expecled mode of collapse for the (2) guyed lattice steel communications lower located in Naples. Collier County, Florida. The two towers stand approximately 50 ft apart from one another whh a maximum outer guy radii of 210 fl, The towers are designed in sllie! accordence with the Electronics Industry Association Standard E1NT1A- 222-F. 1996 Code as well es local codes. Due to the safety factors InCOllJOlllted Into the deslgn standard, we would not expect the tower to fall the moment that the designed winO spaed has been exceeded. Although h is extremely rare for a guyed tower to collapse, most failures OCCUr during catastrophic natural disasters such as hurricanes or tornadoes in Which tolal devastaUon to the surrounding area would also occur. Because of tha various levels of guy cables designed to support the towers, and having Innar and outer guy anchors at boftt lower slteo, it Is virtually Impossible for the tower to fall in . otrelght line like II tree might. The expected mod. of collapse would ba to fall in upon itself in an accordion-type fashton with the debris contained within the anchor radius of the guy cables. Since there are many facto", that will affect the failure of a communication tower. we would like to pOint out that the mode of tower fallure mentioned above Is just an estime\!!. We trust that this information confirms 10 you that towers are designed to survive rarher than collapse. Please feel free to contact us If you should have any questions or require further Informaflon. Best Regards, Structural Components LLC ~~ ,-.d--, --. /,rVr ~); ?~- Michael T. DeBoer. PE Florida License # 49140 Expiration 0312812011 Brad Cook, P .Eng. VP Engineering //,1::;/" ~ f APPENDIX 2 eno I'-~ .0 ON Z01 EN m =::m "'''' 'O~ c.D m<D ",LL <( <1:\ till ::>' . 0" -,. ..... 109 .-. "0' <Dl :iE, . J ! . i . t ti! ili <Ci cn4- ::J~ o 00 ..J2 LL2 ca~ .- J -04- Q)6 :E4- is~ ~nl ~.I~ !;r iii , ! . ili::~ I. ~1.3~:l " I~!~ig f ~ 6 i ~ n~~ II ! ~ " ~ I P ~ hHih~ nhnli Nli Iii !~!~ dl,! IIII~ · ~il ~ z '~!~;lllln ~ ~ q~~. ;UI ~ ~ i !P,'i 'filli 8 o!h'~I' ~ I ~~~~ ilU ~ . N ~ o~ o a:::~ 1--' "<t <!u-(f]"l n.. . ~ --' =:!:(f]wu.. <!wo:: f- --' U . In.. (f] (f]<!Ow f-ZlO--' u.. 00D- =:!: t11<! Z III ! Ill'll !I. I III !I HHm' ... --'. I N e :> 00 we> ~ 0::= :or I- Ui ",..", ~'5~o "0" ~<t~ ,oco<n o::"g~ cf.tON~ ~<tiM 000" ~zo13 :;)w.... t)~Q.,O ! '7 I 8 l- . II. ~ ~;I =~ I '" 'i'...~...."" 'I <~ ~~ 4..ol!f .<0( ~ ~1II01n g " ~~OO:;~:j hi I ~h~8 ji~R t:z~% ~.. '2 ~ _I> 0 ., u ~< ~ ~~ we w Z~ 13 ",t;] !' ~3 -<< ~. ~ Il I ! << - I · ~ Ii i"- ~ h! !,np'l l ~ i~! Iii Sii Ii I! i ; g: II tl .. . :; ~ I I ~~!~ ilf I H .. I 1:1; ~ <Iii . III .. ~; ~ !i ~ .. ~.. g !~ i i c !. - l " ~'!8.~P i~"~~ II~II ; ~ ~ ~ i ~I :Ii nld i n ~ ~ ; ~ L, . 'd mi, I i;H~I~11 i;[ ~!tl! ! ; IsO!! ~ ~Itl~ ~ a _l~~ . ~ l!(q L ;ti I UI",! _IIII! n ",I I ~ I! i 8 ! I R I ':l "I ' 5 II I ~ II I · lie !I ! IIi :1 .~ 'I~ II: lill ~ ~II . II!I ;il~ tl.: 1_; , :1 - (1)0 r--~ .0 -"! , <l>>' =::rn rn::> 'O~ CD Q)Q) OJU, <( <(' (1)1 ::ll . 0' -', ,,-, ..8 -, 'OJ Cl. :;:. ~ . o!m ! It = S i! III ri, ! illI" 11 1i/lllli ~ I i ~ ~ i Hi! I ~#.! III -. .. -.. I :1' ~ = ~ 3 'T-,~......... Il,. .c.... "'1- ~ ! lI....old..c ~ -, :lilll (flU - - ~~~j~ l;i ~ ~ <( J.~>-~8 ~;z ; t~~Z ei ~ z > ~ 0 u ~ ill ii Ir, ~ a i:i ~ ill I .o-K I Ill! I~ ~llll ----~-T--~- ~-.,J!I;'I;.C~--) ~ - . /" j_':'::\JL_~ ~~--V~- 'v~ I '''''''I/'''--- 'I nll;~ I I II r ~ I : . 8 I : . I I I !i I l '- . i I ! ~__ _______' I,I__.-.-J I n__L_-17-",! - ~ 7c.;~o"! l ~ I: i Ii II i I I I I I ~ .o-.K I 1 ;1 if i i; . i I , ~ ~ ~ . . . i ~ i ; ~ I!! ~ I ! J . . . ! i r~ ~ ! ; ; . - I .ilf I ,I !! 1 i II sin d \J ud 'UI I~ ~ -wit.. ... <. I i I ~. "I' i i i II II !I r Ii iji I I III ni I J HI h .I i J. V h . ~.o l. H' i ~$:I I. · lt~~a ." t!3~;~ f <t; :z: ~ l , )11 !~l ~ en' (,) . . ~ :::>\ ~ Ii 11111. ~ ~ ~ . i~ o ~ alO O' I! I "I 11 j....llll-ll.ol z i ": I'-~ -" ~.. i~ :~oIiJ....:c ~ g .0 lL' I III. ~gft~~ . . Q ON ell' ! ~ ~ .;: I z - -\ ti ir ~ .. i !a! e~E~E O? 'tl' ~imHI ~ EN Gl~ :5 - nl . z ~ 2c :r ~ :;, 0 " -ro lD - .. .. .. .. ~ . II u ro ::> 'tl~ cD ",'" (DLL <( ~ a I I J 1 I I I II I i ' I III . l , B B " , < I Ii u i I di H~ ....-J ;It-,~- ffi J "1'; mIllD~IJ. ..'r . . ;'. ii~~;! I. I .~I' " I ;S~ig f ~ <tt ~ . " ~ . III 1Il1 ! . ::II ; ~I t;; . I f I - O' l'llid I ~ ~ ....I' r;J .. I:~ ..\:~Vl~~ n i ~ u..' I II II Q. .~ .-c: Ill' ~~~~g ~ ~ , ._1 l:f 1- h "C. Q ~ . HJHiI !~! Ill.. 11.--1 i 4: 2i':' 4ll :$ -r I I , ~~~~8 . -co ::iE. m :t ~ " ..----., 0 ro'" u 'O~ C:"" <D<D ",LL <{ r'~ , f ~ ~ ~ i I - ~ I '--"-'-- , '-'-l I I , I f I I ~L. , I I f I I , ~ i; , I I I I . , , I . ,~ I ! II U f , , I i-,-. I 13 , !; > , I I I ~ . , I P I I . I~ 01 ! i B , I . ..,j lil~!~ I.! ~ elf! " !iS~i~ f V Ii <(I is = l , III ~ tn' ii~ ! t;; :::ll S ~ z . 111118 ; 5 j al'" 0' Jc~t11c:~ ~ i ~ r-~ ...J' ;~ I!~ 1'1 Ii! i~, ll...<Ill ..0( ~ ~ '" 1.1..' 11111 ~~fig~ i ; ON ..I i <( z - -" ill! !;' I . . iHiml III! ~~~ ~8 C'l "0' 5 " EN .,l I i I .I. ~ 'Z . ~ ~ ~ 2c :iE, :t 0 III --.----1 ~ -ro ro :> "'~ c-" ",'" O)LL i ~ <{ i i~;~ I. ~J.!~~ .- ~Ig~ig f ,.,.. // // yo "----- "-..... "-..... r . . . . - .. -! . I I i I ! I ~Ili." Ih,lidli",dl bi:~ Iii ~ l~!llll~!~l! ~I;;ilil ~!ill <C is ' ' a ~ I" rb t;; VI .... Ii :! ;: ~ 8 ::3 ;!~ lilli, , J o ~ , 000 0 'II 'I' ..\:riVl~~ . i M r- ~ ...), m, II. .<loI .cj ~ ~z I Ill, ~~~~~ i wj . , .0 LL' . <C -"'l .!!; ,~ s' , :c - i ~ ii ~-<>-..c8 . U !f HBm, t:z~z 0 'C. ~ , mj ~ - i I I ~ ~ OJ>- :E, :1' 0 ~ - ~ -" -. -0 I 0 -ro ro" 'O~ c.o ,," ","- <( ./ r - T /' - )\ /' I /' . \ /' . I I \. y . 1\ i i 1 \ I r \ i \ '"....., I \ I \ I , I I I I I I . l~ - I 0 I I I I I I 1 n. . _____ m.._ di Iii H ;0l!~~ ~ HI <tt :J: . ! , III . I;; en' y ~i 1 . :::>\ ~ Pill, % ;; , 08 I~ , . ~ i a:JO I! I "I < ~ ::; ~. . . < "t r-..~ ...I' ~; I II" ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 lL.' ~ ~ <t ON 01' ! !f. , ~ 0 Z ' ._9 ~i' ~ . HH,HI . ~ ~ C"l -01 I : ~ ~ % EN .., ~ , :1' 0 "'>, :;:, g ~ ... -... I u - ~ -ro ro:l 'O~ c.o ",'" i ~~!! t ",u.. <{ ~I~t .' liST ." = " I MJoIG> 1I/U1Il(] J~ Ol .o-Dl;~ _......~QL.l)-~lttll __~g_OI..lI-_(3l _....1' -'UIIQ:l _~:I. ,,-_lJ) _toIUSlQD1.,<-.MIl:(3l ...WllWJll..lIDlIlP!ll<llJ1OOl.Jl-.Otll:ll ___..000 _l_.Ill_'~llL;oOIl -- ,-. _tIIOdI>1Q1.......~~'l Ii Pi !' I _",_M!_ ~- ! .lI'.UIDI><~_lO ~ q; ~ Ii ~ 5 ~ III " ~ en ! = ~ :;) i I nli o ~ (1)0 0 ; il~ III III ~t::IrI.:~ ~ . I'-~ ...I' [ .. It! I III. ~";~(I;g ~ ::;: .0 u.' ~~~~:j ~ i ci: ~'" ",' ~ <" i~! ~~~~8 ._1 f - ~ HUL I '0' :sf iiI ..i ~ % ~ .)!;c :;:, =1' 0 III ""0__1 0 -m m::> 'OL ; ! e..o OlOl i ~~!~ I. 'V ""LL <( ~ < ,t~~~ ,. l! ~lS~r f ~ Ii ~ w p,il, ~ . g w I; qll ~ r 0 Ii "' .11 ., i 11'!lp: !ll HI' If i!I~'I'i lill;1I !I s fllln!1 ~ ;1 n I ! U II II I , I , . I . I I '" a I; ; ., ;, U II Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 66 of 167 Global Broadcast Services, LLC 2614 N Tamiami TrI #507, Naples, F134103 Office; 239-963.5434 EmaU; d.EUioll@2bs.R.com we; GB5-FL.COM Tower Inspection Report Prepared For: Renda Broadcasting Location: Naples Florida Contact: Jerry Heckerman, Chief Engineer Date: December 18, 09 GBS was contracted to do a Tower Inspection plus plumb and tension on an existing Allied guy tower located in South Naples off of County Barn Road. Listed below are the results of the plumb and tension plus the visual inspection of the structure, Visual Inspection of the structure Item Good Fair Fail Notes 1. Anchors (6) X 2. Anchor Heads (6) X 3, Turn Buckles (15) X Nofie:ure 8s 4. Vera Grips (6) X 5, Tower Sections X Tower Members and legs are in good shape Some light surface rust Needs wire brushing and cold lZalv (20%) 6, Tower Bolts X . All bolts are in good shape, light surface rust on 30% or more 7. Tower Paint X Tower Paint is flaking And verv faded 8, Tower lighting NA Power 9, Antennas and lines X Some of the coax needs to be secured better 10. Tower GroundinO' X 11. Guy Wire Grounding X Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 67 of 167 Global Broadcast Services, LLC 2614 N TamIamI Trl #507, Naples, FI 34103 Office: 239-'j5434 Email: rWOlt@2bs-i.comwe:Gis-FL.COM " Estimated Old Tension Vert Vert New Tension Vert Vert Correct A.B CB A-B C.B Tensions Avg Avg Avg Avg And sizes Le1l2" Le1!2" Le1l2" leI! 2" 1. 3/8" t.54O 860 2toB 1.5toC 1,550 'h"to B ~ toB 2. 7/16" 2.080 1.560 1.5 toC ltoC 2.100 l.4"t08 lA"toB 3. 9116" 3.500 2.150 2,75 to C 2 toC 3,500 113" to B IA" taB 4. 'nt' 2.690 1.670 3,75 to A 3toC 2,700 1""toB In"toB 5. 5/8" 4,420 2,860 3,5toC 3.25 to C 4,450 IA" taB 'A" lOB 6, 13116" 6.830 3.650 4 toC 4,5toA 6,800 W'toB W'toB 7. 13/16" 6.830 2.975 3,75 to C 2.75 to A 6.800 Yz'''toB W'toA Corrected Plumb Transits were set up 90% apart and shot of leg A. Transit cross lines were set up on Center of leg to compensate for any leg size variance. c: . I Tn. h r G;J a lr.:':' ;!,;~~~~~~~'1,,~:tlmn!fi~~* ., "Jiik'if,::,>'~;,<:,':c~;a~~~tw<~I: ,A~ '~:~;:~. ~:~~.~' dl~!,11'j Notes: 1. Existing guy wire on the first level A anchors had been spliced previously using two preforms that were hand shake tower with no thimble. The tension caused the preforms to fold and break over time. 2. When proper tension was applied to the splice performs broke. GBS repaired the splice using cable clamps. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 68 of 167 Global Broadcast Services, LLC 2614 N TamIami Trl #507, Naples, Fl34103 Omce: 239-963-5434 EmaU: d.EUiotl@l!bs.o.com we: GBS-FL.COM This particular ( A I) guy wire should be replaced, the splice repair is only a temp measure and GBS does not guarantee the splice. Tower has light surface rust that needs to be wire brushed and cold galvanizing compound applied to those areas. After the plumb and tension was done to the tower on the Dee 17, 09 the tower now passes inspection. Regards, Darryl Elliott,EE GBS ~ Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 69 of 167 Due Diligence Inspection Report ", 'J ' "", e ' Naples, FL FL-4031 Presented to: Jer!)' Heckerman CE, Renda Broadcasting of SW Florida 10915 K-Nine Drive Bonija Springs, FL 34135 S2 Structural as ~~I!1~~nts 11I17 Peerl, Unit A I kU'der, CO I (80015114-11838 November 17, 2009 Completed by: Wes Culver Field Engineer Manager Structural Components. llC Agenda Item No. 7B February 23. 2010 Page 70 of 167 DUE DILIGENCE INSPECTION Naples, FL Technical Information: Site Location: 5860 Crews Road Naples, FL 33942 Coordinates: Latitude: Longitude: N 26.1258330 W-81.7213890 Structure: Support Type: Connection Type: Height: Face Width: Guyed All-Weld 448 fl. 57" C-C Manufacturer: ERI Design: Unknown Insoection Details: Dates of Inspection: August 19th, 2009 November 18th, 2009 I nspected By: Ryan Beach, Field Eng., Structural Components LLC Darryl Elliot, C.E" Global Broadcast Services Inspected In Accordance With: Collier County, FL Guyed Tower 2 Year Inspection Requirements Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 71 of 167 Introduction At the request of Renda Broadcasting, Structural Components, llC and Global Broadcast Services have completed an acceptance site review of this tower in conformance w~h Collier County's Tower Inspection Requirements. The scope of worn included but not Iim~ed to the visual inspection of the structural members and connections, in add~ion to the appurtenances and transmission lines. The tensions and alignment of the tower were measured in accordance w~h TIA-222-G Annex J "Maintenance and Cond~ion Assessment". Measurements of the tower alignment and guy tensions can be found attached. Structural Components has also created a 'Priority Rating System and Rust Classification' to assign a value to the condition and priority, which needs to be addressed. This is to help the Owner allocate funds and resources to address maintenance issues now and/or in the future. A full list and description of these ratings can be found in the section ent~led "Priority Rating System and Rust Classification" sheet, followed w~h an overall summary of the tower with recommendations. It is important to note that this report does not comment on the structural adequacy of the tower, only its physical condition that can be reasonably ascertained by visual inspection. For a list of all specific work preformed while on site, please refer to the Collier County, Fl Guyed Tower Inspection Requirements. Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 72 of 167 Priority Rating System and Rust Classification A priority is placed on each conclusion or recommendation made in this report to help the Owner in allocating funds for remedial work or future ettention. Conclusions and recommendations are assigned a priority rating of A. B, C, D. or E. These ratings are related to safety, structural integrity, system performance, and proper maintenance of the tower and attachments. Priorities are assigned based on safety standards as well as the experience and knowledge of our engineering staff. In all cases, safety is of paramount importance. Priority categories are defined as follows: Priority A - Safety Criteria: This includes items or faults which, if not corrected. may lead to collapse or failure of the structural system or antenna or pose a threat to the safety of personnel that might be on the site, Priority B - Performance Criteria: This includes items or faulls which have or will impact on the quality of transmission signals received or transmitted, These faults are generally related to faulls in antennas and transmission lines, their mounting, connectors, and grounding. Priority C - Maintenance Criteria: This includes items or faults which do not have an immediate effect on the tower but rather items and faults that, if not corrected. will in time shorten the service life of the tower or its elements. Priority 0 - Future Attentlon: This includes Items or faults which require ellher attention by a Professional Engineer qualified to work with Communication Structures or attention on a regular basis by qualified tower inspection personnel. Priority E - Housekeeping Criteria This includes lIems or faults related to ease of access to the tower, the ladder condition, anti-climb condition, fencing, gates, locks, access roads, etc. RUST CLASSIFICATION: level I Initial surface rusting that can be easily removed (Priority C) level II Initial surface rusting that cannot be easily removed by sanding (Priority C) Level IV Surface rusting with initial pitting of steel (Priority A) Significant rusting of steel with up to 10% area of steel loss (Priority A) Level III LavelV Significant rusting of steel with area of steel loss exceeding 10% (no longer safe to climb, PriorityA+) Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 73 of 167 Overall Summary and Recommendations During our s~e vis~, we noted the following deficiencies. Following each deficiency is a recommendation for the remedial action to bring the tower inlo compliance: Item Priority A - Safety Criteria Section Recommendations" ... j.:':"".'. >"",.". - No problems noled - - Item Priority B- Performance Criteria Section . .. ... Recommendations .. . "::,"','-'-. - No problems noted - - Item Priority C - Maintenance Criteria Section . . Recbrillri~ndatlons - No problems noted - - Item ., , Priority D - Future Attention Section Recommend~tlons - No problems noted - - Item . . Priority E - Housekeeping Criteria Section ., Recommendations"::,,,", - No problems noled - . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23. 2010 Page 74 of 167 Maintenance and Condition Assessment 1 Damaged members (legs and bracing) ConditionsINotes No bent or damaged members were found durin ins ection. No loose members were found during inspection. Bolts were checked visualiy on entire tower and s t-<:hecked with wrench. No problems noted No problems noted No problems noted A. Structure Condition 2 loose members 3 Missing members 4 Loose and/or missing bolts/nut locking device 5 Visible cracks in welded connections Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 75 of 167 B. Finish CondltionsINotes 1 Paint and/or galvanizing No problems noted Level I rust on some structural members (approximately 3%-5%). This will not affect Rust and/or corrosion condition including structure condition, but should be mon~ored. If 2 rusting increases ~ should be removed w~h a mounts and accessories wire brush or similar and affected areas should be cold-galvanized with a minimum of (2) coats of 95% ZRC. 3 FAA or ICAO color marking conditions No problems noted 4 Water collection in members (to be remedied, No problems noted e.g" unplug drain holes, etc, " Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 76 of 167 c. Lighting Conditions/Notes 1 ~onduit. junction boxes. and fasteners No problems noted weather-tiaht and secure) 2 Drain and vent openings (unobstructed) No problems noted 3 Wiring condttion All cables are secure and showing no signs of deterioration. 4 light lenses No problems noted 5 Bulb condition No problems noted Strobe lighting was Inspected and appears to be 6 Controllers (functioning) functioning at the proper intensity for day and nioht modes. a. Flasher No problems noted b. Photo control No problems noted c. Alarms No problems noted Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 77 of 167 D. Grounding .'. ................ Condltlons/Notes . 1 Connections All connections and Cad Welds were found to be in cood condition. 2 Corrosion No problems noted Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 78 of 167 E. Antennas and Lines ,." Conditions~~tes' 1 Antenna Condition No problems noted 2 Mount and/or ice shield condition (bent/loose, No problems noted and/or missino members \ 3 Feed line condition No problems noted 4 Hanger condition (snap-ins. bolt on, kellum No problems noted orips, etc.\ 5 Secured to structure All antennas, mounts and coax lines were found to be orooerlv secured to structure. ~ Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 79 of 167 '..F. Other Appurtenances Conditions/Notes. (welkweys,. pletforms, sensors, ..."i .. Ooodllghts, etc.) 1 Cond~ion No problems noted 2 Secured to structure No problems noted Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 Page 80 of 167 G. Insulator Condition Conditions/Notes 1 Cracking and chipping No insulators present. 2 Cleanliness of insulators 3 Spark gaps set properly 4 Isolation transformer cond~ion Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 81 of167 ,::.,,,',., H. Guys CondltionsINotes . 1 Strand condition (corrosion, breaks, nicks, No problems noted kinks, etc.) 2 Guy hardware condnion No problems noted a. Tumbuckles or equivalent No problems noted (secure and properly applied) b. Cable thimbles properly in place (if required) No problems noted c. Service sleeves properly in place (if No problems noted reQuired) d. Cable connectors (end fittings) No problems noted (i) Cable clamps applied properly and No problems noted boltsti~ht (ii) Wire serving properly applied No problems noted (iii) No signs of slippage or damaged No problems noted strands (iv) Preformed wraps properly applied, full wrapped, and sleeve in No problems noted place (v) Poured sockets secure and howing No problems noted no separation Some cotter pins are beginning to rust. These (vi) Shackles, bolts, pins, and cotter will not affect the structures cond~ion, but pins secu re and in good condnion should be monitored and replaced in the future if necessary . 3 Guy tensions Satisfactory, see attached charts 4 Record temperature, wind speed and direction 85F; sunny; calm ., , Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 Page 82 of 167 I~Concrete Foundations . CondltionslNotes , Ground cond~ions No problems noted a. Settlement, movement or earth cracks No problems noted b, Erosion No problems noted c. S~e Condition (standing water, drainage, No problems noted trees etc. 2 Anchorage cond~ions No problems noted a. Nuts and/or nut locking device (tightened) No problems noted b. Grout cond~ion No problems noted c. Anchorages and/or anchor rod condition No problems noted 3 Concrete condition No problems noted a. Cracking, spalling or splitting No problems noted b. Chipped or broken concrete No problems noted c. Honeycombing No problems noted d. Low spots to collect moisture No problems noted ., , Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 83 of 167 J. Guyed Mast Anchors Condltions/Notes 1 Settlement, movement or earth cracks No problems noted 2 Backfill heaped over concrete for water No problems noted sheddinc 3 Anchor rod condition for water shedding No problems noted Corrosion control measures (galvanizing, 4 coating, concrete encasement, cathodic No problems noted protection systems etc.) 5 Anchor heads clear of earth No problems noted Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 84 of 167 K. Tower Alignment 1 Tower Verticality 2 Tower Twisl 3 Guy Tensions Conditions/Notes Satisfactory, see attached chart Satisfactory, see attached chart Satisfactory, see attached chart .~ ~ . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 85 of 167 Naples, FL Verticality and Stralghtriess . Vertlcall Suai htness Resultant Allowable Result8n(':;i\ ;; Allowable Deviation Resultant Deviation' Deviation ne;;filt/on b1wEI~l: bIw Elev. . . .;;;i'~III,',:' , ' I inches inches inches 12,00 Reference Elevation o 0.00 0.00 0.00 0,00 . Denotes outside allowable ran e, otherwise satisfacto COMMENTS: from TIAlEIA-222-G 1. Seelion 13,3.3 recommends that the horizontal distance between the vertical centertines at any two elevetions shall not exceed 0,25 percent of the vertical distance between the two elevations, l. , Agenda Item No. 78 February 23,2010 Page 86 of 167 . Naples, FL Twist Measurements . Reference Twist with Allowable TwIst Relative TwIst Allowable Twist Elevation respect to with respect to between reference belween reference ./ft.\ 10 ft. elev. ~~ ft e/ev. . points points ;d""reesl deoreesJ fdeareesl (deareesJ 400 0.87 5.00 0.29 1.00 380 0.58 5,00 0.00 4,00 299 0.58 5.00 0.58 5.00 199 0.00 5.00 0.29 3,00 137 -0,29 5,00 0,00 2.00 99 -0.29 5.00 -0.29 5.00 0 0,00 0.00 0.00 0,00 . Denotes outside allowable range, otherwise satisfactory. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 87 of 167 '.' ,'". ..i'.: ."", "", I:'~'I', -., ',_,:-;,,: " i,i!"'>:i . Naples, FL ,i"". Guy Tension Measurements ;" ;'''':'.'' ",;,. :)i::: "'''',''- MeasJ~, Guy To Guy,qiam. Recommended Tensions Elevatio~, Anchor " an? Type . Tension :,Design I.T. (AllOWable) "'"", i;~~ al60 Deg:iF lrt!30 Deg. F [kiDS) (ft.) '.,' ""c (kips) , ..: (kiDS) .' . 392 A6 1" B.S. 12.83 12.20 9.76 10 18.30 380 A5 1'B.S. 11.53 12.20 9.76 to 18.30 299 A4 1-3/8" B.S. 23.70 23.20 18,56 10 34,80 199 A3 1-3/8'B.S, 24.25 23.20 18.56 to 34.80 137 A2 1'B.S 12.87 12,20 9.76 to 18.30 99 A1 1-1/8' B.S. 14,92 15.60 12.48 to 17.94 392 B6 1"B,S. 12.33 12,20 9.76 to 18.30 380 B5 l' B.S. 13.08 12.20 9.76 to 18.30 299 B4 1-3/8" B.S. 22.49 23.20 18.56 to 34.80 199 B3 1-3/8" B.S. 24,95 23.20 18,56 to 34.80 137 B2 l' B.S 12.63 12.20 9.76 to 18.30 99 B1 1-1/8' B.S. 14,53 15,60 12.48 to 17.94 392 C6 1"B,S. 12,98 12.20 9.76 to 18.30 380 C5 1'B.S, 11.38 12,20 9.76 to 18.30 299 C4 1-3/8' B.S. 21.90 23.20 18.56 to 34.80 199 C3 1-3/8" B.S. 24.91 23,20 18,56 to 34.80 137 C2 1"B.S 12.18 12.20 9,76 to 18.30 99 C1 1-1/8'B.$, 16.51 15.60 12.48 to 17.94 " Denotes outside allowable range, otherwise satisfactory, COMMENTS: from TIAlEIA-222-G 1. Section 7,6.1 recommends that initial tensions (I.T.) in the guys, for design purposes, is normally 10% of the published breaking strength of the strand, wtth upper and lower limits of 15% and 8%, respectively. 2. When using initial tension values greater than 15%, consideration should be given to the possible effects of aolian vibration. likewise, when using initial tension values less than 8%, consideration should be given to the effects of galloping and slack-taut pounding. 3. Design guy inttial tensions at 600F are assumed to be 10% of the breaking strength of the steel cable and applicable at the anchor. 4. 1 kip = 1000 Ibs. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 88 of 167 RESOLUTION NO. 10- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW TWO COMMUNICATIONS TOWERS WITHIN THE ESTATES ZONING DISTRICT PURSUANT TO SECTION 5.05.09 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATED IN SECTION 8, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 67-1246, Laws of Florida, and Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on Collier County the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which includes a Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of Conditional Uses; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals (Board), being the duly appointed and constituted planning board for the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of a Conditional Use of two communications towers within the Estates Zoning District pursuant to Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code on the property hereinafter described, and the Collier County Planning Commission has made findings that the granting of the Conditional Use will not adversely affect the public interest and the specific requirements governing the Conditional Use have been met and that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 10.08.00.D. of the Land Development Code; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented. Mediaflo USA, Inc. CU-2008-AR-14085 REV. 01/13110 ] of2 Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 Page 89 of 167 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: Petition Number CU-2008-AR-14085 filed by Kimberly J. Madison, Esquire of Ruden, McClosky, Smith, Schuster and Russell, P,A., representing FLO TV Incorporated, with respect to the property hereinafter described in Exhibit "A", be and the same is hereby approved for a Conditional Use for two communications towers within the Estates Zoning District pursuant to Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County Land Development Code, in accordance with the Conceptual Site Plan described in Exhibit "B" and subject to the Conditions found in Exhibit "C". Exhibits "A", "B" and "C" are attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this Board. This Resolution adopted after motion, second, and super-majority vote, this _ day of ,2010. ATTEST: DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA By: By: , Deputy Clerk FRED W. COYLE, Chairman Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: Steven T. Williams 0.:> Assistant County Attorney ..~~ \3 .,0 Attachments: Exhibit "A" -Legal Description Exhibit "B" - Conceptual Site Plan Exhibit "C" - Conditions CPIOS-CPS-0091S142 Mediaflo USA, Inc. CU-2008-AR-14085 REV. 01113/10 20[2 Agenda Item No, 7B February 23, 2010 Page 90 of 167 Exhibit A '. , LEGAL DESCRIP1'10N Property located in Collier, FL TIIIl- West one-half (W 'h) of the Northwest one-quarter (NW \4) of the Southeast one-quarler {SE \4) oflhe Southeast olle-q1lllrter (SE 1') of Section 8, Township' SO Soath, Range U East, Collier County Florida, also known as 'Tract No. 20. Enchanted Acres, leas the Soutl130 fellt for road right-of-way purposes. AND BEING the san)C property conveyed to Itenda Broadcasting CcIporatilln. a Pennsy1venia corporation from Sterling Colnmmrlcatlon Cotporation, a P10rida cotporation by WlIfl1Inty Deed. dated lanulII")I13. 1999 and recorded January 20, 1999 In Dood Book 2503, Pllge. 1 624: Tax Parcel No. 00405160008 RMal342H6:1 , ~\ :;:,1 01 -', I.L.' .!!!! -g, :a: . a ~ ~ '10. ';'1 r,'" l5 .i ;.. ! i II II III ~ .. .. .. .. .. ~ . . ; Jiillll~ i=Q - :E ~ !r !~ Iii I Ii @R II i - ," . . . . . . ~ = ft I Iii ~I . i. Ii I I ~ I i . I I I 1 I I I I ~ 7 I III . I . . · II!; ~;~!11Ja~l 1."lfi i I I II .II II ~ I I~III I I UII I II ~!~ II iqq! illllllsllllll! II If Ii 11!;!d~ ! 1'!~;i' f Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 92 of 167 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL CU-2008-AR-14085 January 12,2010 1. The Conditional Use is limited to what is shown on the Conceptual Site Plan, identified as "Overall Site Plan," prepared by Black and Veatch, and dated September 28, 2007, as revised through April 9, 2009. The site plan noted is conceptual in nature for Conditional Use approval only. The final design must be compliance with all applicable federal, state, and county laws and regulations. 2. Development on the site shall be restricted to 3,359 square feet of impervious area, 3. Maximum height of the two towers on the site shall be limited to 455 feet, including antennae, lightening rods and other appurtenances. 4, Both towers on the site shall be equipped with either solid red beacon or dual mode lights unless a waiver of this requirement is granted by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), 5. All guy line anchors shall be fenced pursuant to LDC 5.05.09,G.12. 6. One tower on the site shall be owned by or leased to a governmental entity for government-related, essential service purposes. Should this entity remove its antennae e) from the tower, the property owner shall immediately notify the County and replace the antennae e) with another essential service user within six months. Exhibit C <00.... ....~<O o~ '",~ _0 '0') 'II: ~ Ii ",Ii! ! i ,., ~ "',I I ~ 'en >- OJ ~OJ ~l , ::!:::ctle>> H. I ''fl!' ~11\l' " "'::>'" . 'O~CL 0::' li!I! ilIm'l I "!!f 1'1 ~ en ij\!! I, ,I ". !i:.lj! .!ill U il., :i!1 OJ OJ ~ ","- L ~ ldm l~ iil!e;l! U!'II !rsUj 11!lill! <( f- 'i~ !i'ip~~'i !ll~ht Ilh -1rt+1 511' OJ' hu' IiLll 1:1 lL .11..'. ... _.' Ii / v). . '. III ~ <( imi 1'1 , II! , I!! limn r " i iil 11 Ii! "' $ I ."" ~~~ 11'1 ! I II II . ~ Ii! II . I iii ,i I :n!rk!1 ~ ! II ill'I!'llll !~ 11>1 lI11,h! ~ ! I IIIIIIII!!!I ~i ij " I ~ ...11.',; .. , jj.11. r ' --II i , . .! - I! IL ~! I II~ . ,ko I, I .~~ , 511 11 ~ ."11 I ii \ l 'c \ l . \ l . ~ '\ , II 'I ,i I~ I" lr " " l~ ,I< II In, "j 1~1 . b, i ~I . \ \.... ---~ " jl t. -Ii 1111 Ii I I , ~ I 1'1' ill,1 I '::~ I 'i .~ . ~ Ii I!~ I, I I!~I I II lill i!! i ~I II ~ . n .. I. I _II I i~!!II llll~!: Ii, il :11 ':I i'II!!,. ~~JI~li 111111:1, ~I!b!ffi, .;. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 94 of 167 Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management, Pennitting, Septic Evaluations . ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Ramsey Inc. ~.~f'~~~ .-- "'-"_.""~' ...':'.:.:: .,'" . . LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP ~_......-- ,.,_._,--'-;,;,~ . , ~"=-IT . '."." .~,. - LEP . Licen~d Environmental Professional CWB . Certified Wildlife Biologist CFEA . Ct!nified Florida EnvironmentaJ Assessor REPA . R~gjstered Environmental Property Assessor CEHP - Certified Environmental Health Professional OSHA 5 - HQZardous Materials Incident Conllmmder E-mllil: RamseyJnc@embarqmai!.com Office> 239.564.1660, Fa.. 866.334.1496 26314> SI. NW. Naples, FL 34120 www.ramscyinc.net REV' 1 CU_2008-AR-14085 ' RENDA BROADCASTING Project: 200/0880700~UE: 1/27/09 Date: 12/24 _ _ _ _ _ 08 October 2008 Ms. Jody Lima Black & Veatch Corp. 60 I Walnut Street Suite 550 W Philadelphia, PA 19106 PROJECT: Renda Broadcasting Corp., Black & Veatch Tampa 011; PID 00405160008; Street Address: 5860 Crews Rd.; Cily: Naples ; State: Fl.; County: Collier; Sec 08 Twn 50 Rge 26; Road Frontage: 330 feet; Acres: 5.0 Ms, Lima, Please find attached a Listed Species and Wildlife Survey Repon for the Renda Broadcasing Corp., site in Naples, Florida, Collier County. Tampa OJ L Please call if you have any questions. Best regards ~ Michael R. Ramsey ~ . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 95 of 167 Ecological, Environmental, Agricultural Land Management. Permitting, Septic Evaluations ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Ramsey Inc. LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP '~'''-- ,~'.'___~""_~~~-_'h"'"",;...~_:;.>:__ -~r:.~"- .~:=,~.r._'''''''''' .on ''''"''---" . -, - ,,- '~"''''' LEP - Licensed Environmenlal Professional E-mail: Ramscy.lnc@embarqmail.com CWB . Certified Wildlife Biologist Office: 239.564.1660. Fax: 866.334.1496 CFEA - Certified Florida Environmental Assessor' 263l4,h S1. NW, Naples. R. 34120 REPA . Registered Environmental Property Assessor www.ramseyinc.net CEHP . Certified Environmental Health Professional OSHA 5 - Hazardous Materials Incident Commander LISTED SPECIES WILDLIFE SURVEY REPORT 2008 PROJECT: Renda Broadcasting Corp., Black & Veatch Tampa 011 DATE: 10.08.08 BY: Michael R. Ramsey Ramsey Inc. Owner: Renda Broadcasting Corp County: Collier City: Naples Size: 4.77 acres Legal Descriptions: PID 00405160008 5860 Crews Road; Section 08; Township 50. Range 26 INTRODUCfION The applicant Renda Broadcasting Corp. has applied to the for the necessary permits to expand its existing operation of communication towers and broadcasting in Collier Co, (Figure J and 2). The following protected species/wildlife survey report was done to meet the submission requirements for each agency involved. This report evaluates if the above described project property is utilized by any wildlife, and any species listed by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) and the US Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS). METIlODS First, the project properties were surveyed and a map prepared of the habitat types on sire. Second, the official lists of protected species were obtained from each of the agencies (FWC & FWS). The FWC list all species classified as protected by the state of Florida government. The FWS list all species that are classified as protected in the state of Florida by the United States government. Third. each species on each list was researched a. to county of occurrence and required habitat in the literature. Last, all species that were indicated as being found in Collier Co. and having a habitat type that occurred on the project propenies were searched for by surveys on the project properties. RESULTS Survev Dates. For this survey period the property was visited on 09/24, 09/26, 09/27, 09130, 10103 and 10/04 in 2008. Surveys were done in the morning (AM) 2-3 hours after sunrise and in the evening (PM) 2-3 hours before Sunset, Survey routes are shown in Figure 3. ~ .. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 96 of 167 Renda Broadcasting Corp. Bladt &: Veatcn Tampa 011 PIO 0IJ.W5160008, 5860 Crews Rd. Lislt.'lf Species Wildlife Survey 08 (ktOOer 2008 Page 2 Habitat. The Florida Land Use. Cover and Forms Classification System (FLUCFCS) was utilized to produce the habitat maps for the project propenies. The habitat or FLUCFCS maps are depicted in Figure 4 for the Yahl Mulching project. Table 1 below indicates the acres for each habitat type. Table I. FLUCFCS acres for the Yahl Mulching and Recycling property. 10# Acres FLUCCS # Habitat Tvpe I 2 3 4 5 6 7 3.73 0,06 0.15 0,38 0.22 0,15 0.08 624 624 740/310 740/8212 740/8145 419 419 Pine/Cypress/Palm Pine/Cypress/Palm Disturbed Land/Grass Prairie Disturbed Land/Communication Towers Disturbed Land/Access Driveway Other Pine Other Pine The Renda Broadcasting Corp (Tampa 011) propeny presently has a communication tower broadcasting operation in place on 0.60 acres. This propeny has been impacted by road construction on the north, south, east and west sides of the property. This construction has effectively cut off sheet flow across the propeny, except for unusually high rainfall events. Impacted hydrology appears to be the cause of the pine trees and melaleuca being present with present in cypress transition areas in the 624 habitats, It is also the reason for the heavy meJaleuca infestation in the general area. This area has been slowly drying out over time. The property appears to have been "enhanced" for melaleuca more than 4-5 years ago. There are no melaleuca in the canopy or sub-canopy. There are also dead melaleuca stumps and piles of cut canopy and sub-canopy trees that have been cut and treated all around the area. The enhancement of the area removing melaleuca has been very effective. It appears that there is 0.5% or less melaleuca in the groundcover and the area is doing well. On the east and west sides of the Renda parcel there is active enhancement activates for melaleuca taking place. The adjacent properties have canopy and sub canopy trees is various stages of post herbicide lreaunent. Overall, the general area around Renda is undergoing a lot of changes in the vegetation due to the herbicide enhancement treaunems. StatelFederal Protected Soccies Listed. The FWC list was published in November 2007 and lists 118 animals as protected in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix A. Based on general habilat requirements, historic distributions and actual sightings, the FWC lists 52 animal species that may occur in Collier County. There are 51 species that are vertebrates and 1 invertebrate. The 52 species are listed in Figure 4. The FWS list is updated daily on their website. The October 2008 list totals 113 animal and plant species as protected in the State of Florida and is attached as Appendix B. Based on general habitat requirements. histone distributions and actual sightings, the FWS lists 19 species (19 animals and no plants) that may occur in Collier County, Species for Collier Co. are listed in Figure 4 also. Site Survev Results. Figure 5 indicates the cumulative total of all species observed over 10 survey events. Daily field sheelS are located in Appendix C. Overall, 15 species were noted, 14 bird species, 1 mammal and 2 reptiles, The most frequent bird species observed was eastern blue bird with 27 observations. No listed species were observed or indicators aoted on the propeny, ~ . ~ Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 Page 97 of 167 ~ Renda Broadcasling em'p. Black & Veatch Tampa 011 Pro 0040~ 160008. 5R60 Crews Rd. Listoo Species Wildtifl'" Survey OS October 2008 Page 3 Listed Seecies Results. Gopher Prog/Rana capito: Prefers dry sandy. upland habitats adjacent to wetland areas. This type habitat is not present onsite, or adjacent properties and no individuals were observed on site. Changes in the project property will have no effect on this species. Cape Sable seaside sparrowlAmmodramus maritimu., mirabi/is; Currently inhabits seasonally inundated freshwater interior marshes within Eve'glades National Park and Big Cypress National Preserve in Monroe and Dade County. Last documented in Collier Co. in 1979. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property. Florida Grasshopper sparrowlAmmodramus savannarumjloridallus: Prefers large areas of frequently burned dry prairie habitat. with patchy open areas sufficient for foraging. This habitat type is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property. In addition, this species has not been observed since 1955 in Collier Co, Changes in the project property will have no effect on this species, Florida scrub jayl Aphe/ocoma coeru/escens: Prefers low growing scrub oak plants. This babitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in the project property will have no effect on this species. LimpkinlAramus gaaraana: Inhabits mangroves. freshwater marshes. swamps, springs and spring runs, and pond and river margins. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were ohserved on the properties. Otanges in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida burrowing owVAthene cunicu/ariafloridana: Prefers habitats of high, sparsely vegetated, sandy ground. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species, Ivory-billed woodpeckerl Campephi/us principa/is: This species is considered to be extinct but is still listed. Known to prefer swampy forests, especially large bottomland river swamps of coastal plain and Mississippi Delta and cypress swamps of Florida. This habitat is present onsite. but no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species, Cuban-isnowy plover, Charadrius a/exandrinus: Prefers dry, sandy beaches. where they nest in shallow depressions, usually near some vegetation or debris. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Piping plover/Charadrius me/odus; Prefers open, sandy beaches and on tidal mudflats and sandflats along the coasts. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Kirtland's warbler IDendroica kirt/andU; Nests in nearly homogeneous stands of usually 30 ha or more of dense scrubby jack pine. Florida maybe a migration stop between Michigan and the Bahamas. Individuals may flay straight through. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Little blue heronlEgretta caeru/ea: Peeds in shallow freshwater. brackish. and saltwater habitats. Nesting colonies usuaIly occur in coastal areas, but prefers foraging in freshwater lakes. marshes. swamps, and streams. Nests in a variety of woody vegetation types. including cypress, willow, maple, black mangrove, and cabbage palm. Usually breeds in mixed-species colonies in flooded vegetation or on islands. Nesting habitat is present onsite, but no other nesting of other wading bird species has been observed. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year . /: Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 98 of 167 - Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Vealcn Tampa 01 I PID 00405160008, 58()() Crews Rd. Lisled Species Wild[jf~ Survey OS Dclober 2008 Page 4 which removes all prey species. No individuals or nests were observed on the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Reddish egretlEgretta rufescens: Typically prefers coastal mangrove islands, or in Brazilian pepper on manmade dredge spoil islands, near suitable foraging habitat. Generally forages in shallow water of variable salinity. Broad, open, marine tidal flats and shorelines with little vegetation are ideal feeding areas. Also important are salt evaporation pools and lagoons, often located inside mangrove keys or just inside shoreline on mainland. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. SnowyegretlEgretta thula: Nests both inland and in coastal wetlands with nests placed in many types of woody shrubs, especially mangroves and willows; usually over shallow waters. Almost all nesting is over shallow waters or on islands that are separated from shoreline by extensive open water. Feeds in many types of permanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, streams, lakes. and swamps, and in manmade impoundments and ditches. Breeding success is tied to water-level fluctuations, Preferred nesting habitat is not prescnt ons;te. TheJe are 110 permanently inundated areas on site. Seasonally flooded areas are very short in duration. Because of drainage. the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. No individuals or nesting were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Tricolored heron/Egretta tricolor: Most nesting colonies occur on mangrove islands or in willow thickets in fresh water, but nesting sites include other woody thickets on islands or over standing water. Prefers coastal environments. Feeds in a variety of permanently and seasonally flooded wetlands, mangrove swamps, tidal creeks, ditches, and edges of ponds and lakes. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. Preferred nesting and feeding habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. White ibis/Eudocimus albus: Found in a wide variety of habitats, including freshwater and brackish marshes, salt flats and salt marsh meadows. many types of forested wetlands, wet prairies, swales, seasonally inundated fields. and man-made ditches. The forested wetland habitat is present onsite and targeted to be preserved and enhanccd. Because of drainage, the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. No individuals or nests were observed in the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Peregrine falcon/Falco peregrinus: The Peregrine Falcon frequents open areas like IIlaT1ihes, fields, swamps, and tidal areas. Since its reintroduction into the eastern United States. however, the Peregrine Falcon has colonized many urban areas because of increased nesting sites (and nesting ledges being created on buildings), This species is considered to be recovered and is wailing for delisling. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species, Southeastern American kestrel/Falco sparverill., pall/ll," Found in open pioe habitats. woodland edges. prairies, and pastures throughout much of Florida. Nest sites are tall dead trees or utility poles generally with an unobstructed view of surroundings. Kestrels are not known to nest in Collier County. Most individuals are migrants from the north. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have linle to no effect on this species. Florida sandhill crane/Grus canadensis pralensis: Habitat: Prairies, freshwater marshes, and pasture lands. A voids forests and deep marshes but uses transition zones and edges between these and prairies or pasture lands. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were obscrved on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species, American oystercatcherlHaemalopus plll/iates: Habitat: Coastal waters. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 99 of 167 Renda Broadcasling Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PlD 0040516000&, :'1860 Crews Rd. LiSlcd Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 5 Bald eagle/Haliaeems leucocephalus: According to the FWC eagle website. the closest eagle nest (CO 023) is 2,30 miles to the north west, A map of this nest location is presented in Figure 6. he proposed project is not in the primary or secondary zone. No individuals or nests were observed on or utilizing the property. Any proposed changes in this property will have little to no effect on this species. On a larger scale the FWS has delisted the Bald Eagle. Wood stork/Myeteria Americana: Nests colonially in a variety of inundated forested wetlands. including cypress strands and domes, mixed hardwood swamps, sloughs, and mangroves. Forages in 6-15 inches of surface water. The preferred nesting habitat is present onsite, but the surface water does not get very deep on the property during the year due to the impacts of road building changing the hydrology, Because of drainage, the area dries out every year which removes all prey species. No individuals or nests were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Brown pelican/Pelecanus ocridp.n1n.lis. Habitat Mainly coastal, feeding in shallow estuarine waters, and (l\jss often) far offshore, . This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Red-cockaded woodpeckerlPicoides borealis: Habitat: Inhabits open. mature pine woodlands that have a diversity of grass. forb, and shrub species. Prefers mature slash pine trees that are generally larger than 12 inches in diameter, a wide spacing of trees, no subcanopy and relatively dry conditions. The preferred habitat is not present onsite. No individuals were observed on the property. Again for this survey all pine trees were inspected for nest cavities or stan holes and none were found, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Roseate spoonbill/Platalea ajaja (Ajaia ajaja): Habitat: Primarily nests in mixed-species colonies on coastal mangrove islands or in Brazilian pepper on man-made dredge spoil islands near suitable foraging habitat. Does feed in forested wetland habitats with slow moving water. Although forested wetland type habitat present, hydrology has been so impacted it is very low quality, Because of drainage. the area dries out every year which removes all prey species, No individuals or indications of this species were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Crested caracaralPolyborus planeus audubonU (Caracara cheriway): Open country, including dry prairie and pasture lands with cabbage palm, cabbage palm/live oak hammocks. and shallow ponds and sloughs. Preferred nestlrees are cabbage palms, followed by live oaks. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Everglades snail kitelRostrhamus sociabilis plumbeus: Habitat: Large open freshwater marshes and lakes with shallow water. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Black skimmerlRynchops niger: Habitat: Coastal waters, including beaches, bays. estuaries, sandbars, tidal creeks (foraging), and also inland waters of large Jakes. phosphate pits. and tlooded agricultural fields, This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species, Least tem/Sterna antil/arum: Habitat: Coastal areas throughout Florida, including beaches. lagoons, bays and estuaries. Increasingly use artificial nesting sites, including gravel rooftops. dredge spoil islands or other dredged material deposits, construction sites. causeways. and mining lands. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 100 of 167 Renda Broadcasting Corp. Black &. Veafch Tampa 011 PTD 00405 I 6000R. 5860 Crews Rd. li.~ted Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 6 Roseate tern/Sterna dougalli (Sterna dOllgallii dOllgallii): Habitat: Nest sites include bare limestone, shell-sand beaches, newly deposited rock and marl fill. dredge material, and heaps of broken coral deposited by storms, This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Bachman's warbler/Vermivora hachmanii: Historic records indicate the Bachman's warbler nested in low, wet forested areas containing variable amounts of water. but usually with some Water that was pennanent. This species is considered extinct in Florida. This preferred habitat is present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Smalltooth sawfish/Pristis peetinata: Habitat: Shallow coastal. estuarine, and fresh waters: often in brackish water near river mouths and large embayments, in deeper holes on bottoms of mud or muddy sand. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Rivulus (mangrove rivuJus)/Rivulus marmoratus: Habitat: coastal, appears to prefer red mangrove (Rhizophora mangle). This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Sei whalelBalaenoptera borealis: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Generally. in deep water; along edge of continental shelf and in open ocean. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Fin whale (finback whale)/Balaenoptera physalus: Habitat: Pelagic, marine. Usually found in largest numbers 25 miles or more from shore. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species North Atlantic right whalelEuhalaena giaeialis (Balaena glacialis [incl. austrolis]): Habitat: Inhabits near shore and offshore waters. Mainly coastal in the North Atlantic. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Florida mastiffbatlEunwps glaucinusfloridanus: Habitat: Roosts in palms and hollow trees and in buildings. Forages high in air over natural as well as human-altered landscapes, Minimal preferred roosting habitat is present onsite. No individuals were observed on the properties or surrounding areas during surveys. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Humpback whalelMegaptera novaeangliae: Habitat: Pelagic and coastal waters. sometimes frequenting inshore areas such as bays, This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Caribbean monk seallMonachus tropicaUs: Habitat: Marine area~. Shallow lagoons and reefs, sandy beaches, and permanent islets or beaches above high tide. Mainly west coast of Florida and Caribbean. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Everglades mink/Mustela vison everglooensis: Habitat: A variety of wetland communities, including salt marsh, freshwater marsh, cypress swamp, and hardwood swamp. The preferred habitat is onsite. However, no individuals were observed or. indicators of the presence was noted on the property. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23. 2010 Page 101 of 167 Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa 01 ] PID 00405160008, 5860 Crews Rd. L.is1oo Species Wildlife Survey 08 Oct_ 2008 Pllge7 Sperm whalelPhyseter macrocephalus: Habitat: Pelagic, prefers deep water, sometimes around islands or in shallow shelf waters, This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida pantherlPuma (Felis) concolor coryi: Habitat: Requires extensive blocks of mostly forested conununities. Tbe FWC panther telemetry database form 1981-2007 indicates no utilization of this property (Figure 7). From 1981 to 1995 the closest telemetry activity was 1.5 miles away. From 1996 to 2007 there has been no telemetry activity within 2.5 miles of the site. The forested habitat panthers utilize is present onsite. No individuals or indicators were observed on the property. Planned changes in this property should have no effect on this species. However. this property is not in the Focus Area or Primary or Secondary Panther Habitat Zones articulated by FWS, but it is within the area of Consultation (Figure 7). Big Cypress fox squirreVSciul1Is niger avicennia: Habitat: Sandhills (high pine), pine flatwoods, and pastures and other open, ruderal habitats with scattered pines and oaks. Depends on a variety of oak trees for seasonal food and nest material. Longleaf pine cnne~ and seeds are important foods. This habitat type is not present onsite, due to little to no oak trees being present. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species, FloridalWest Indian manateelTrichechus manams latirostris (Trichechus manatus): Habitat: Coastal waters, bays, rivers. and (occasionally) lakes. Requires WanD-water refugia such as springs or cooling effluent during cold weather. Sheltered coves are important for feeding, resting, and calving. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida black bearlVrsus american us flnridanus: Habitat: A wide variety of forested communities is needed to support the varied seasonal diet of black bears, Forested wetlands are particularly important for diurnal cover. This habitat is present onsite. Figure 8 indicates black bear telemetry locations form 1983-2000 as collected by the FWC. The closest bear location was approximately I mile to the east of the property. Figure 9 indicates the locatiuns of nuisance issues from 1980-2006 according to the FWe. There has not been any nuisance issues on this parcel. This is an unmanned unoccupied site that produces no waste or trash for weekly pickup. This general area has had no nuisance call since 2005 based on data form FWC. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species and planned activities should not generate nuisance issues. American alligatorlAlligator mississippiensis: Habitat: Most permanent bodies of fresh water, including marshes, swamps, lakes, and rivers. Occasionally wanders into brackish and salt water but rarely remains there, Protected classification is primarily due to similarity of appearance with the American Crocodile, This Species is considered recovered in Florida. Habitat is not present onsi(e. No individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Loggerhead seaturtlelCaretta Cllrettll~ Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic water~; nest on coastal sand heachc~. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Green seaturtlellChetonia mydas: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches, This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. American crocodilellCrocodylus acutus: Habitat: Coastal estuarine marshes, tidal swamp', and creeks along edges of mainland and islands. Usually associated with mangroves. Nests on beaches, stream banks. and levees. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 102 of 167 Renda BrooJcasling Cnrp. Black & VC;lIcb Tampa all Pin 0040516000K, .5860 Crews Rd. Li~led Species Wildlife Survey 08 Oclobcr 2008 Pllge 8 Leatherback seaturtlelDennoehelys cariaeea: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest nn coastal sand beaches, This habitat is not present onsitc and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have nO effect on this species. Eastern indigo snakel/Drymareholl eon.is couperi: Habitat: Broad range of habitats, from scrub and sandhill to wet prairies and mangrove swamps. In northern part of range, often winters in gopher tortoise burrows ili sandy uplands but forages in more hydric habitats. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the property. Also, no gopher tortoise burrows were discovered, Changes in this property will have no effect on this species Hawksbill seaturtJe/lEretmocheiys imbr/cata: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches, This habitat is not present onsile and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Gopher tortoise/Gopherus poiyphemu<: Habitat: Typically found in dry upland habitats, including sandhill., scrub, xeric oak hannnock, and dry pine flatwoods; also commonly uses disturbed habitats such as pastures. old fields, and road shoulders. Typical habitat not present onsite and area is generally to wet. No burrows or individuals observed on site. Changes in tbis property will have no effect on this species. Kemp's ridley seaturtJe/lLepidocheiys kemp/I: Habitat: Marine coastal and oceanic waters; nest on coastal sand beaches. Tbis habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species. Florida tree snaiUIUguus lase/ams: Habitat: Tropical hardwood hammock (rockland hammock). This species prefers smooth-barked trees. This habitat is not present onsite and no individuals were observed on the properties. Changes in this property will have no effect on this species CONCLUSIONS The majority of habitat on site is 624 pine, cypress, palm. This habitat type appears to be the result of a hydrology impacts over a long period of time, which dried the area out and allowed slash pine and meJaleuca to invade in cypress transition areas in the dry years. Melaleuca enhancement onsile has improved the vegetative associations on site, The surrounding properties melaleuca enhancement activities that are currently ongoing are causing a lot of changes in the vegetative structure in the general area. The wildlife utilization of the area is primarily passerines, and raccoons. No listed species were observed utilizing the area. The area has generally a low utilization by wildlife and is not expected to increa,e because of its fragmentation of habitat caused by the roads and drainage of the surrounding residential area. This area is not expected to have a high increase in wildlife utilization in the future with or without changes to this parcel. and a continuing problem with rnelaleuca Overall, changes in this property will have little to no effect on any wildlife in the general area including any listed species that may occasionally use the site. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23.2010 Page 103 of 167 Renda Broadca~ting Corp. Black.. & Vealch Tampa 011 PID 00405160008, 5860 Crews Rd. Listed Species Wildlife Survey Olil October 2008 Page 9 REFERENCES Ashton. R. E.. Jr.. and P, S. Ashton. 1988a, Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida. part 3: The amphibians. Windww-d Pub!.. Inc" Miami, Florida. _' 1988b. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part I: The snakes. 2nd ed. Windward Pub!., Inc.. Miami. Florida. _' 1991. Handbook of reptiles and amphibians of Florida, part 2: Li7.ards. turtles & crocodilians, 2nd ed, Windward Publ.. Inc., Miami. Florida, Barbour, D, B,. and S. R. Humphrey. 1982, Slatus and habilat of the Key Largo woodrat and cotton mouse (Neotoma floridana smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus allapaticola). J Mammal. 63:144-148. Barnwell, M, E.. P. A. Meylan, and T. Walsh. 1997. The spotted turtle (Clemmys gutlata) in central Florida, Chelonian Cons. BioI. 2:405-408. Bartlett, R. D.. and P. P. Bartlett. 1999. A field guide to Florida reptiles and amphibians. Gulf Publ. Co.. Houston, Texas. Berner, L., and M. L. Pescador. 1988. The mayflies of Florida, Univ. Presses of Florida. Gainesville. Dirkellholz, D. E. 1963. A study of the lite history and ecology of the round-tailed muskrat (Neofiber alieni). Ecolog. Monogr. 33:225-280. Bortone, S. A. 1989. Notropis melanostomus. a new species of cyprinid fish from the B]ackwater- Yellow River drainage of northwest Florida. Copeia 3:737-74I.story. habitat assessmen~ and systematics of Ihe blaclanouth shiner (Notropis sp,). Blackwater River drainage. Final Rep. Nongame Wildl. Prog.. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Bouchard. R. W, 1978, Taxonomy. ecology and phylogeny of the subgenus Depressicambarus, with the description of a new species from Florida and redescriptions of Cambarus graysoni, Cambarus latimanus, and Cambarus striatus (Decapoda: Cambaridae). Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 3:27-60. Bowen. P. J, 2000. Demographic, distribution. and metapopulation analyses of the burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia) in Florida. M.S. thesis, Univ. Central Florida, Orlando. Brady, J. T" T, H. Kunz, M. D. TuttIe, and D. E, Wilson, 1982. Gray bat recovery plan. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv., Denver, Colorado. Brim Box, J.. and J. D, Williams. 2000, Unionid mollusks of the Apalachicola Basin in Alabama, Florida, and Georgia. Bull. Alabama Mus. Nat. Hist. 2]:],143. Brody, R, W. 1990, Status of habilat and populations of Procambarus pictus in the North Fork of Black Creek, Clay County, Florida. S~ Johns River Water Management District, Palatka, Florida. Brown, L. N. 1997. A guide to the mammals of the southeastern Vnited Slates, Vniv. Tennessee Press. Knoxville. Brown, W. S. 1993. Biology, status, and management of the timber ratOesnake (Crotalus honidus): a guide for conservation. Soc. Stud, Amphib. Rept. Herp, Cire. 22. Carle, F, L., and M. L. May. 1987. Gomphus (Phanogomphus) westfalli spec. novo from the Gulf coast of Florida (Anisoptenc Gomphidae). Odonatologica 16:67- 75. Chace, F. A.. Jr. 1954. Two subterranean shrimps (Decapoda: Caridea) from Florida and the West Indies. with a revised key to the American species. J, Washington Acad. Sci. 44:318-324. Chafin. L 2000. Field guide to the rare plants of Florida, Florida Natural Areas Inventory. Tallahassee, Chase, C. A" and J. A. Gore. 1989. Snowy plover breeding distribution. Unpubl.linal rept., Florida Fish and Wildl.Conserv. Comm" Tallahassee. Choate. P. M. 1984. A new species of Cicinde]a Linnaeus (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae) from Florida, and elcvation of C. abdominalis scabrosa Schaupp to species level. Entomol. News 95:73-82. Conant. R., and J. T. Collins. 1991. A field guide to reptiles and amphibians: eastern and central North America, 3rd ed. Houghton Mifflin, Boslon. Cox, J., D. Inkley, and R. Kautz. 1987. Ecology and habitat protection needs of gupher tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus) populations found on lands slated for large-scale development in Florida. Nongame Wildlife Pmg. Tech. Rep. no. 4, Florida Game and Fresh Waler Fish Comm,. Tallahassee. Crance, J. H. 1986. Habitat suitability index models and instream flow suitability curves: shorlnose sturgeon. V, S. Fish Wildl. Servo BioI. Rep. 82(10.]29). Deitz, D, c.. and T. C. Hines. ]980. Alligator nesting in north".entral Florida. Copeia 1980:249-258, Delany. M. E, and C. L. Abercrombie. j 986, American alligator food habit., in north-cenlral Florida, J. Wildl. Manag. 50:348-353. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 104 of 167 Renda Broadca.c;tlng Corp, Black & Vealch Tampa OJ I PID 00405 J 60008. 5860 Crews Rd. Listed. Species Wildlife Survey 08 Oclobn 2008 Page 10 Delany. M. F.. P.B. Walsh, B. Pranty, and D. W, Perkins. 1999, A previously unknown population of Rorida grasshopper sparrow on Avon Park Air Force Range, Florida Field Nat. 27(2):52-56. Deyrup. M.. and R. Franz (eds.), 1994. Rare and endangered biota of Horida. vol. N: Invertebrates. Univ. Press of Rorida, Gainesville. Dodd. C. K.. Jr. 1988. Synopsis of the biological data on the loggerhead sea turtle Caretta caretta (Linnaeus 1758), U.S. Fish Wildl. Servo BioI. Rep.88(14). Duggins. C. F., Jr.. A. A. Karlin. K. Relyea. and R, W, Yerger. 1986. Systematics of the key silverside, Menid!a conchorum. with conunents on other Menidia species (Pisces: Atherinidae). Tulane Stud. Zool. Bot. 25(2): 133- 150. Dunkle, S, W. 1989. Dragonflies of the Horida Peninsula, Bennuda and the Bahamas. Scientific Publishers. Gainesville. Horida, _.2000. Dragonflies through binoculars: A tield guide to the dragonflies of North America. Oxford Univ. Press. New York. Dunn. J. 1999. National Geographic Society fieJd guide to the birds of North America. 3rd ed. National Geographic Soc., Washington, D.C, Emmd. T. C.. and M. C. Minno. 1988. Habitat requirements and status of the endemic Schaus swallowtail in the Horida Keys. Final report, Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Conun.. Tallahassee. Enge. K. M.. M. M. Bentzien. and F. Percival. 1986. Florida scrub lizard status survey. Tech. Rept. No. 26 to U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv.. Jacksonville End, Sp. Office, Florida. Ernst, C, H., and R. W. Barbour. ] 989, Snakes of eastern North America. George Mason Univ. Press. Fairfax. Virginia. Ernst, C. H., J. E. Lovich, and R. W, Barbour. 1994. Turtles of the United States and Canada, Smithsooian Inst. Press, Washington, D.C, Ewert. M, A.. and D. R. Jackson. 1994. Nesting ecology of the alligator snapping turtle (Macroclemys temminekii) along the lower Apalaehicola River, Horida. Final Rep. NG89-020, Nongame Wildlife Prog, Rorida Game and Fresh Water Fish Conun., Tallahassee. Fitzpatrick, J. W" G. E. Woolfenden, and M. T. Kopeny. 1991. Ecology and development-related habitat requirements of the Horida scrub jay (Aphelocoma coerulescens coerulesceas), Nongame Wildlife Prog. Tech. Rep, no, 8, Horida Game and Fresh Water Fish Conun., Tallahassee. Horida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission, 2003. Management Plan Red-Cockaded Woodpecker Picoides borealis. Tallahassee. A. 78 pp. Horida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2003. October 8. Horida's Waterbird Colony Locator. http://www.myfwc.com/waders. Horida Fish & Wildlife Conservation Commission. 2006. Eagle nest locator. http://wldJwc.state.fl.usleaglelenglenests. Florida Natural Areas Inventory. 1990. Guide to the natural conununities of Horida, Horida Natural Areas Inventory and Florida Depl. Natural Resources. Tallahassee, Franz. R. 1986. The Florida gopher frog and the Florida pine snake as burrow associates of the gopher tonoise in northern Horida. Pp. 16-20 in D. R, Jackson and R. J. Bryant (eds.). The gopher tortoise and its conununity. Proc. 5 th Ann, Mtg. Gopber Tortoise Council, Gainesville, Horida. Franz, R.. and L. M, Franz, 1979. Distribution. habitat preference and status of populations of the Black Creek crayfish. Procambarus (Ortmannicus) pictus (Decapoda: Cambaridae), Horida Sci. 42:13-17. Franz, R.. and L. L. Smith. J 999. Distribution and status of the striped newt and Florida gopher frog in peninsular Florida. Final Rep. Horida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm, Tallahassee. Gaby. R,. M. P. McMahon. F. 1. Mazzotti. W. N. Gillies. and J. R. Wilcox, 1985. Ecology and status of a population of Crocodylus acutus (Reptilia: Crocodilidae) at a power plant site in Florida. J, Herpeto!. 19:189-198. Georgia Department of Natural Resources. 1999. Protected animals of Georgia. Nongame, Endangered Wildlife Program, Wildlife Res. Div.. Georgia Dept. Nat. Res,. Social Circle. Gilbert, C, R. (ed.). 1978. Rare and endangered biota of Horida. vol. 4: Fishes. Univ, Presses of Florida. Gainesville. _(ed.). ] 992. Rare and endangered biota of Rorida, vol. II: Fishes. Univ. Press of Horida. Gainesville. GI."berg, J., M. C. Minna. and J. V. Calhoun. 2000. Butterflies through binoculars: a field, finding. and gardening guide to butterflies in Horida. Oxford Univ. Press, New York. Gordon. M. E.. and W. R. Hoeh. 1993. Anodonta heardi,a new species of freshwater mussel (Bivalvia: Unionidae) from the Apa1achicola River system of the southeastern United States. Walkerana 7:265-273. Gore. J. A,. and M. J. Kinnison, 1991. Hatching success in roof and ground coloni... of least terns. The Condor 93:759- 762. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 105 of 167 Renda Broadcasting Corp. Black & Veatch Tampa 011 PID 0040~ 160008. 5860 Crews Rd, Listed Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Pnge ] ) Guillory, V. 1979, Lake Eustis puplhh investigations. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission 1977-1979 Final Report: Study I-N. Tallahussee. Guillory. V,. and W, E, Johnson. 1986, Habitat, conservation status. and zoogeography of the cyprinodont fish, Cyprinodon variegatus hubbsi (Carr), The Southwestern Nat. 31(1):95-100, Hall, E, R. 1981. Mammals of North America. 2 nd ed, John Wiley and Sons, New York. Harvey. M. J. 1992, Bats of the eastern United States. Arkansas Game and Fish Comm., Little Rock. Hersh, S.L. 1981. Ecology oUhe Key Largo woodrat (Neostoma floridana smalli), J. Mammal. 62:201-206. Hipes, D.. D. R. Jackson, K. NeSmith, D, Printiss and K. Brandt. 2001. Field guide to the rare animals of Florida. Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee. Hirth, H. F. 1971. Synopsis of the biological data on the green turtle Chelonia mydas (Linnaeus) 1758. FAa Fish. Synopsis 85. Hobbs, H, H,. Jr. 1942, The crayfishes of Florida. Univ. Florida Publ., BioI. ScL Ser, 3(2):1-179. Hoehn, T, S. 1998, Rare and imperiled fish species of Florida: a watershed perspective. Office Envir. Serv.. Florida Game and Fresb Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Hovis, J, A.. and M, S. Robson, 1989, Breeding status and distribution of the least tern in the Florida Keys. Florida Field Nat. 17(3):61-66, Humphrey. S. R, (ed.). 1992, Rare and endangered biota of Florida, vol. I: Mammals. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville Humphrey, S. R. 1988. Density estimates of the endangered Key Largo woodrat and cotton mouse (Neotoma floridana smalli and Peromyscus gossypinus a11apaticola) using the nested-grid approach, J, Mammal. 69(3):524,531. Humphrey, S. R.. and H. W. Setzer. 1989. Geographic variation and taxonomic revision of mink (Mustela vison) in Florida, J. Mammal, 17:382-392. Hurst, H. N., G. Bass. and C, Hubbs. 1975. The biology of the Guadalupe, Suwannee. and redeye basses. Pp. 47-53 in R, H. Stroud and H. Clepper (eds.). Black bass biology and management, Sport Fishing Institute.Washington. D,C. Jackson. D, R., and R, Franz, 1999, Survey for the fire-back crayfish in the Apalachicola ravine system, northern Florida, Final report to The Nature Conservancy, Florida Natural Areas Inventory, Tallahassee. Jackson. D. R.. and E. G, Milstrey. 1989, The fauna of gopher tortoise burrows. Pp, 86-98 inJ. E. Diemer, D, R. Jackson, J. L. Landers. J. N, Layne, and D. A, Wood. eds. Gopher Tortoise Relocation Symposium Proceedings. Nongame Wild\. Program Tech. Rep, no, 5. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Jackson. D. R.. and R. N. Walker. 1997, Reproduction in Ihe Suwannee cooter. Pseudemys condnna suwanniensis. Bull. Florida Mus. Nat. Hist. 41:69-167. Jackson. J. F, 1973, Distribution and population phenetics of the Florida scrub lizard. Scelopotus woodL Copeia 1973:746-761. Jackson, J. F.. and S, R. Telford, 1974, Reproductive ecology of the AOOda scrub lizard. Sceloporus woodi, Copeia 1974:689-694. James. F. C. 1991. Signs of trouble in the largest remaining population of red-cockaded woodpeckers. Auk 108:419- 423. Johnson. S. A. 2001. Autecology of the striped newt (Notophthalmus perstriatus): life-history, upland-habitat use. paedomorphosis. and conservation genetics. Ph.D. diss.. Univ, Aorida, Gainesville. Kale, H, W" II. (cd.), 1978. Rare Wld endWlgered biota of Florida, Vol. 2. Birds. Univ. Presses of Florida, Gainesville. Kale, H, W"II., B. Pranty, B. Stith, and W. Biggs, 1992. An atlas of Aorida's breeding birds. Final Rep. Nongame Wildlife Prog.. Horida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm., Tallahassee. Keppner. E. J.. and L, A. Keppner. 2000, A preliminary search for the Panama City crayfish. Procambarus (Leconticambarus) econrmae, Hobbs, 1942, in Bay County, Aorida, Reporllo U.S. Fish Wildl, Serv.. Panama City. Horida. Knisley. C. B., and J. M, Hill. 1994. Studies of the Flurida Highlands tiger beetle, Cicindela highlandensis: distribution. abundance. habitat characteristics and biology. Report 10 U.S. Fish Wildt. Serv., Jacksonville, Aorida. _' 1996, The Florida Highlands tiger beelle, Cicindela highlandcnsis: habitat requirements. remaining range, life histol)'. and management, Final Rep. Florida Nongame Wildlife Prog. NG91-012, Horida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm.. Tallahassee, Kulhavey, D. L.. R. G, Hooper, and R, Costa (cds,), 19')5. Red-cockaded woodpecker: recovery. ecology. and management. Center for Applied Studies in Forests. CoJlege of Forestry, Stephen f'. Austin State Univ., Nacogdoches, Texas. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23. 2010 Page 106 of 167 Renda Broadcasting Corp, Black & Velll(;h Tampa 011 PID 00405160008, 5860 Crews Rd. liSled Species Wildlife Survey OR October 2008 Page 12 Kushlan. J. A. 1974, Observalions on the role of the American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) in the southern Florida wetlands. Copeia 1974:993-996. _' and F. J. Mazzotti. 1989. Population biology of the American crocodile. J. Herpetol. 23:7-21. Lazell, J, D.. Jr. 1989. Wildlife of the Florida Keys: a natural history. Island Press. Washington, D,C. Layne. J. N. 1990. The Florida mouse. pp. 1-21 in C, K. Dodd. Jr., R. E. Ashton. Jr.. R. Franz, and E. Wester (eds.). BulTOw Associates of the Gopher Tortoise. Proc. 8 th Ann. Mtg. Gopher Tortoise Council. Florida Mus. Nat Hist., Gainesville. Loftin, R. W. 1992. Use of nest boxes by the Florida kestrel. Florida Field Nat. 20(3):57-64. McMillian. M. 2001. Florida Important Bird Areas Program, site nomination fonn -Lake ISlOkpoga, Audubon of Florida, Tampa Bay Sanctuaries. McNair, D. B., and J. A. Gore. 1999. Recent breeding status of royal and sandwich terns in northwest Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(3):117-120. Maehr. D, S. 1987, Florida panther movements, social organization. and habitat utilization. E-I-II annual perfonnant'O report, Florida Fish and Wildl. Cons. Comm.. Tallahassee, Martin. W. H., and D. B. Means. 1998. Distribution and habitat relationships of the eastern diamondback rattlesnake (Crotalus adamanteus). Herpetological Nat. Hist. 7:9-34. Means. D, B. 1975. Competitive exclusion along a habitat gradient between two species of salamanders (Desmognathus) in western Florida. J. Biogeog. 2;253- 263. Means, D, 8., and A, A. Karlan. 1989. A new species of Desmognathus from the eastern Gulf Coastal Plain, Hetpelologica 45;37-46. Means. D, B.. and C, J. Longden. 1970. Observations on the occurrence of Desmognathus monticola in Florida. Herpetologica 26;396-399. -' 1976. Aspects of the biology and zoogeography of the pine barrens lreefrog. Hyla andersonii. in northern Florida. Herpetologica 32; 117-130. Means. D. B.. and P. E. Moler. 1979. The pine barrens treefrog: fIre. seepage bogs. and management implications. Pp. 77-83 in R. R. Odom and L. Landers (eds.), Proc. rare and endangered wildlife symposium. Georgia Dept. Nat. Res., Game and Fish Div. Tech. Bull. WL-4. Meylan. A. B. 1999. Status of the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) in the Caribbean region, Chelonian Cons, BioI. 3:177-184. _' and M. Donnelly. 1999. Status justifIcation for listing the hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) as Critically Endangered on the 1996 mCN Red List of Threatened Animals. Chelonian Cons. BioI. 3:200-224. Mettee. M, F.. P, E. O'Neil, and J, M. Pierson. 1996. Fishes of Alabama and tbe Mobile Basin. Oxmoor House. Inc.. Birmingham, Alabama. Minno. M. C., and D. Pierce. 1999. Florida butterfly gardening: A complete guide to attracting, identifying, and enjoying butterflies of the lower south. Univ. Press of Florida. Gainesville, Mitchell, J. C. 1977. Geographic variation of Elaphe guttato (Reptilia: Serpentes) in the Atlantic coastal plain. Copeia 1977:33-41. Moler, P. E, 1981. Notes on Hyla andersonii in Florida and Alahama. J. Hcrpeto1. 15:441-444. _.1985. A new species of frog (Ranidae: Rana) from northwestern Florida. Copeia 1985:379-383. _(ed.). 1992. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. vol. ill: Amphibians and reptiles. Univ, Press of Florida, Gainesville. -' 1996. Alligator snapping turtle: distribution and relative abundance. Final report 7544. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm,. Tallahassee. Moun~ R. H. 1975. The reptiles and amphibians of Alabama. Auburn Univ. Agric. E<p, Station, Auburn. Alabama. Myers, R. L, and J. J. Ewel (eds,) 1990, Ecosystems of Florida. Univ, Central RoridaPress, Orlando. NatureServe. 2006. NatureServe Explorer: An online encyclopedia of life [web application]. Version 5.0. NatureServe. Arlington. Virginia. http://www.natureserve,org/explorer. Neill. W, T. 1971. The last of the ruling reptiles: alligators. crocodiles, and their kin. Columbia Univ. Press, New York. Page, L M.. and B. M. Burr. 1998, A fIeld guide to freshwater fIshes: North America north of Mexico. 2nd ed, Houghton Mimin, Roston. Paul. R. T, 1991. Status report.- Egretta rufescens (Gmelin) reddish egrel. V,S. Fish Wild1. Serv., Houston, Texas. -. and A, F, Schnapf. 2000, Florida Important Bird Areas Program. site nomina-tion fonn _ Passage Key National Wildlife Refuge, Audubon of Florida, Tampa Bay Sancluaries. Pennak, R. W, 1978, Fresh-water invenebrates of the United States. 2nd ed. John Wiiey and Sons. New York. f\qe noa Item No _ 18 -February 23. 20 '1 0 Page 107 of 16"1 Renda Brondca~tulgCOrp, Black & V'~alch Tampa 011 PID 00405 16000R, 511.60 Crt'w~ Rd Li~ted Speci~s Wildlife Survl:Y 08 O(lnbcr 2008 Page ]J Peterson. R.T 1998. Peterson field guide to eastern birds. 4th ed. Houghton Mifflin, Boslon. Pctranka, j. W. 1998. Salamanders of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian lnst. Press. Washington, D.C. Pilsbry, H. A. 1946. Land Mollusca of North America, Vol. 2. part 1. Monograph of the Academy of Natural Sciences. Philadelphia. Pimm. S. (cd.). 2000. The 2000 Cape Sahle sparrow annual report. Accessed 2001 May 8. Poole. A., and F. Gill (eds.). 1992-2000. The birds of North America. The Academy of Natural Sciences. Philadelphia, and The American Ornitbologists' Union. Washington. D.C. Post, W., and J. S. Greenlaw. 2000. The present and future of the Cape Sable seaside sparrow. Florida Field Nat. 28(3):93-110. Pranty, B. 1996. A birder's guide to Florida. American Birding Association, Inc,. Colorado Springs. Colorado. Prinliss, D. J.. and D. L. Hipes. 1999. Rare amphibian and reptile survey of Eglin Air Force Base, Florida. Final report to U,S. Dept. of Defense. Florida Natural Areas Inventory. Tallahassee. Prilchard. P. C. H. 1989. The alligator snapping turtle: biology and conservation. Milwaukee Pub!. Mus., Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Quay, T. L., J, B. Funderburg. Jr.. D. S. Lee. E. F. Potter. and C. S. Robbins (eds.). 1983. The seaside sparrow, its bioiogy and management. Occ. Papers, North arolina BioI. SUrY, North Carolina State Mus. Nat. Hist., Raleigh. Relyea, K.. and B. Sutton. 1975, A new trogJobitic crayfish of the genus Procambarus from Florida. (Decapoda: Astacidae). Tulane Stud. Zoo!. Bot. 19(1,2):8-16. Rice. D. W. 1957. Life history and ecology of Myotis austroriparius in Florida. J. Mammal. 38:15-32. Robbins. C. S., B. Bruun. and H. S. Zim. 2001. Birds of North America: a guide to field identification, St. Martin's Press. New York. Rodgers. J. A.. and H. T. Smith. 1995. Set,back distances to protect nesting bird colonies from human disturbance in Florida. Conserv. BioI. 9:89-99. Rodgers, I. A,. Ir,. H. W. Kale II, and H. T. Smith (eds.). 1996. Rare and endangered biota of Florida. vol. V: Birds. Univ. Press of Florida. Gainesville. Robertson. W, B.. Jr.. and G. E, Woolfenden. 1992. Florida bird species: an annotated list. Florida Ornithol. Soc. Spec. Pub. no. 6: ix + 260. Roosenburg, W. M. 2000. Impact of a bycatch reduction device on diamondback terrapin and blue cmb capture in crab pots. Beol. Applic. 10:882-889. Ross. 1. P.. S. Beavers, D, Mundell, and M. Airth-Kindree, 1989. The status of Kemp's ridley. Center Marine Conserv.. Washington, D.C. Runde, D., J. Gore, I. Hovis. M. Robson, and P. Southall. 199]. Florida atlas of breeding sites for herons and their allies: update 1986 - 1989, Nongame Wildlife Prugmm Tech. Rep. no. 10. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm.. Tallahassee. Semlitsch. R. D. 1983, Structure and dynamics of two breeding populations of the eastern tiger salamander, Ambystoma ligrinum. Copeia 1983:608-616. Shealy, R. M. 1976. The natural history of the Alabama map turtle. Graptemys pulchra Baur. in Alabama, Bull. Florida State Mus" BioI. Sci. 21:47-11. Shriver. G. W.. P. D. Vickery. and S. A. Hedges. 1996, Effects of summer bums on Florida grasshopper sparrows. Florida Field Nat. 24(3):68-73. Sibley. D. A. 2000. The Sibley guide to birds, Alfred A, Knopf. New York. Spotila. J. R.. A. E. Dunham, A. J. Leslie. A. C. Steyerrnark, P. T. Plotkin, and F. V. Paladino. 1996. Worldwide population decline of Dennochelys coriacea: arc leatherback turtles going extinct? Chelonian Cons, Bioi. 2:209,222. Sprandel, G, L.. J. A. Gore. and D. T. Cobb. 1997. Winter shorebird survey, Flurida Game and Fresb Water Fish Comm. Final Perf. Rep, Tallahassee. Stevenson, H. M, 1970. Occurrence of the carpenter frog in Florida. Quart. J, Florida Acad, Sci, 32;233-235, ~. and B. H. Anderson. 1994. The birdlife of Ronda. Univ. Press of Florida, Gainesville. Stys, B. 1993. Ecology and habitat protection needs of the southeastern American kestrel (Palco sparvcrius paulus) on large-scale development sites in Florida. Nongame Wildl. Prog. Tech. Rep. no. 13. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fisb Comm,. Tallabassee. Telford. S. R. 1959. A study of the sand skink, Neoseps reynoldsi. Copeia 1959: 100- 119. Tenant. A. 1997. A lield guide 10 .snakes of rlorida. GuJfPubl. Co., Houston, Texas. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 108 of 167 Renda Bm.:u:lcasling Corp, Black & Veatch Tampa OJ I Pro 0040316000R. 51160 Crews Rd, U!lted Species Wildlife Survey 08 October 2008 Page 14 Timmennan, W. W. 1989. Home range. habitat use and behavior of the eastern diamondback raltlesnake. M. S. Ihesis. Univ. Horida, Gainesville. Thaxton, J. E.. and T. M. Hingtgen. 1996. Effects of suburbanizalion and habitat fragmentation on Florida scrub-jay dispersal. Florida Field Na!. 24(2):25-37. Toland, B. I 999a. Nesting success and productivity of Florida sandhill cranes on natural and developed sites in southeastern Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(1): 10, )3, _' I 999b. Nest site characteristics, breeding phenology, and nesling success of American oys\ercatchers in Indian River County, Florida. Florida Field Nat. 27(3):112-116, Tuberville, T D" J, R. Bodie. J. B. Jensen, L. LaClaire, and J, W. Gibbons. 2000, Apparent decline of the southern hog- nosed snake, Heterodon simus. J. Elisha Mitchell Soc. 116: 19-40. V.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 1982, Slock Island tree snail recovery plan. V.S. Fish WildL Serv., Atlanta, Georgia. _' 1984, American crocodile recovery plan (revised). V,S. Fish WildL Serv., Atlanta. Georgia _' 1987. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; proposed threatened stalus for two Florida li1.ards. Fed. Reg. 52(13):2242-2246. _' 1998.. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; 90-day finding for a pelition to delist the Squirrel Chimney cave shrimp. Ped. Reg. 63:67618-67619. _' I 998b. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; detennination of endangered stalus for five freshwater mussels and threatened status for two freshwater mussels from the eastern Gulf Slope drainages of Alabama. Florida, and Georgia. Fed, Reg. 63(50):12664-12687, _' I 998c. Okaloosa darter (Elheostoma okaloosae) recovery plan (revised). U.S. Fish Wildt. Servo Atlanta, Georgia. _' 1999. Endangered and threatened wildlife and plants; final rule to list the f1atwoods salamander as a threatened species. Fed. Reg. 64:1569]-15704. _' 1999, South Florida Multi-Species Recovery Plan V.S. Fish Wildt. Serv.. Atlanta, Georgia. 2172 pp. _' 2000. Candidate and listing priority assignment fonn: Cicindela highlandensls. _' 2006. V.S. Fish & Wildlife Service The Endangered Species Program [web application]. VS Fish & Wildlife Service. Washington. D.C. http://www.fws,gov/endlUlgered V,S. Fish lUld Wildlife Service lUld Gulf States Marine Fisheries Commission. 1995.Gulf Sturgeon Recovery Plan, Atlanta, Georgia. Walls. J. G, 1976. Fishes of the northern Gulf of Mexico. T. F. H. Publications. Inc., Ltd., Hong Kong. Whitaker, J. O. 1996. National Audubon Society field guide to North American mammals. Alfred A. Knopf, New York, Williams, J. D.. and G. H. Burgess. 1999. A new species of bass. Micropterus cataractae (Teleostei: Centrarchidae), from the Apalachicola River basin in Alabama, Florida. and Georgia. Bull. Florida Mus. Nat. His!. 42(2):81, 114. Witzell, W, N. 1983. Synopsis of the biological data on the hawksbill turtle Eretmochelys imbricata (Linnaeus. 1766). FAO Fish. Synopsis 137. Wood. P. B.. M. L. Hoffman. M. W. Collopy, and J. M. Schaefer. 1988. Southeastern American kestrel (Falco sparverius paulus) natural history. life requirements, and habitat protection guidelines. Final report to Office of Envir, Services. Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Comm" Tallahassee, Woods, C. A., W. Post, and C. W. Kilpalrick, 1982. Microtus pennsylvanicus (Rodentia; Mundae) in Florida: a Pleistocene relict in a coastal saltmarsh, Bull. Florida State Mus. BioI. Sci. 28:25-52, Wooley. C. M., and E. J. Crateau. 1985. Movement. microhabitat, exploitation. and management 01' Gulf of Mexico sturgeon, Apalachicola River. Florida, North American 1. Fisheries Manag. 5:590-605. Wunderlin. R.P. 1998. Guide to the vascular pllUlts of Florida. Universily Presses of Florida. Gainesville. Honda Zambraoo. R.. M. S, Robson. D. Y, Chametzky, and H. T, Smith. 1997. Distribution and slatus of leas I tern nesting colonies in southeast Florida. Florida Field Nat. 25(3):85-91, Zambrano. R.. R,. H. T. Smilh, and M, Robson. 2()()(}, Summary of breeding roseate terns in the Florida Keys: 1974- 1998. Horida Field Nat. 28(2):64-68. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 109 of 167 PROJECT LOCATION MAP ~-~-, COLLIER COUNTY, FL 5 , 10 15 Miles , o 5 PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 REND B OADCA TING Figure 1. Project Location Map; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rga 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. + , Ramsev Inc. Envlronmedtal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple~ FL 34120 239.564.1660 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 110 of 167 emPRO~ECT LOC~~I~N - DETAIL ~APIj~ rlliJ. ~_.~ I., ~ 1-. c-- [ r-= ">J "'- ___--=:1': ~ ~ ^I / IF ~ ~ ~/ if IEJJ -'1 k r< ~_ r- C ::: :::: == - - "11 tEmIJ ~ W I I - I j---_ I FlI co ~ I 11I1 ~~ ~ Ilf.I~l ~ ~ fHrt" ~\~-~~<" \ I jfij .. J L fo- ::!< 0=0 I C::J 0:} = o f--- x I "l If' 1---- ~~ l f--- f-. _J ~ (,5,) \: ''. '( i---- Tc~~ -jf~ M .~ ~~ = - i I '~ @~ .. I I ~ I I = --=1f- I .. elliE' . lID. I I I I III11II I m l ii a ~l\\~ ~ ~ ~0t m I \jF ~ '<'==0-J I-- /--'v ~ \ -- I " ~ :/.~~~D !L--=-~ .=rl..--rrr--=I l ~tf~ "'- ~ I IB := I I - '" PRO.JECT:BL CK VEATCH TAMPA 011 r , - V<:E ~J )~ r S ~. \ ~~~ \=:i y I( u n::r N + Ramsev Inc. Envlronmen'al Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!,FL 34120 239.5.....1660 Figure 2. Project Location Detail Map; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn SO, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. FLUCFCS HABITAT MAP & WILDLIFE SURVEY ROUTES 330FT \ x ~ x ><~~><~>S& >< ><:x" 6<'" x x '-- x:X><X x :.< >< X >;> x >x...x >< ~ XXx~ >Q?' >< ><:5>< ~x ~ x ><::x>' x ><,;>< >< ><,;>< >< >0< >< X' :>< I>< X>'}< ><x '-- ><:x"'" >< ...?' >< :X::X x ~ :x x:::x ~ x::x ><:'x x ~ ;>< p;>< :x>;;: X' :x >< X':S< 'XX '>< ...?' >< >< ""x'>< >< :x ~ I><:xx :x" ~ x ><:x >::> <.., ~XX:xx J<;x :x>< y~ '-- '. ><: ~ ~ s:; >< ? ><;(::x;:: '>S; >< x..- >< "'~ '>l x:X ><> "":x X X ~ ^'" :xxx xX x. x><~ ""x'><x vx :x ~ :x:::x X X ;,.x 'J< ;>< I ~ X . ~' x~ 4 ":x 'x X" :xl'-~""x ~"'~'? ~ 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEP/SFWMD JURIS. WETLAND USACOE JURIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.06 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC .740310 DISTURBED LAND I GRASS PRAIRIE DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE UPLAND #30.15 AC O 740 8212 DISTURBED LAND I COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE UPLAND #4 0.38 AC r:0J 740 8145 t..::::J DISTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE UPLAND #5 0.22 AC Ii: Q l'l CD 419 ~ OTHER PINE ~ DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE "URIS. WETLAND #6 0.15 AC #7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY . TOWER # # SURVEY TRANSECT # \ Ii. 1\ 1:1" -- -l'l: - ><x><!;.o ~ x ><x X"X< X ,>< >< "-" X>< >< ~x>< _ >S>< :oS: ""x x x xx ~x "'" xx >< s:; x ~ ><~5>>< :x ~ >< ex Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 111 of 167 "'- 'x >< . J Xx ~~y :'\.' ::?\'- '1 ~ ~ ~P< :><)- "'- ~ ~ 'Ix '- 0::.: ~ ><~ . I - I I I I _,CREWS ROAD ROW . +, Figure 3. FLUCFCS habitat and wildlife survey routes map. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmen"i:al Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple!"FL 34120 239.5_.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Roed, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. I 1 r I i , , Agenda Item No. 7B February 23.2010 Page 112 of 167 LIST OF USFWS AND FWC PROTECTED SPECIES FOR COLLIER CO., FL. AS OF 10/08/08 E.~"~~__ ~.~H.~--!..._ DqU."'AiTD lIT.". 'iON --ijtfi- "'" ... , $.~C (1.2) ~IPHJ8IANS ~\",b!r fmtl ll:~~_..___ HnM,'''pi/n , --_.,_.,~'" -~._"~-"'-'~--_"'__""m ('''pl'S~;'''''~''.Ie~"rn'''' ;1;-: I .!:.~~'l!~~,_~~,~L~~:,'~""I1IIJI&!..~~~_,___~_,.__ FkriI~ ~1\tI j~~ ApI...m.......... "PI'ndr;lMl,l IT T J""u AnmlUjt~'':''"'''' .~SC(l) Alh~"'('Wlll-""ktrid (Arlr..... !. ~."b\ng'4'ill:llwl clHlio!u....../I"rid(llttl) ISSC(') ,~ul)'.hIIedWOUtJp.."."" (a,!,~"IIiIu~,.m...'ipallT ;E f-~l?'~- .'",~"!'driu.t~:~'!~~~,_ IT p.~~, Ch"'1l(/nllS"",/n(I,." .'if..-.-----:r--- K.~nd"~a- Drndmll'..,iinl<lnJJI i.i:. E' IiIllI:bilelann Eg,../t" ,'llrrulnJ !SSCll,4) ~1.h~1lI'<<. ~:g,!.rruru!~~~,,!, ,isscn,4) IIImI?cp F.vrrtlnthllla iSSCm: ~.~ f:"rrrldtr1r'i!.~ ':S.'K'(1.4)" ~~fakon -- ~::;;;:K~~ ._~ -, ~~f.(2) ;' ,"- 8011lhloal<lem ,......rr.n ~~<m'l Fah':'l.;w:n'crt::; ,"'~"I". iT 1'I11.lrnlSar.ihi!'...... (;~"a~;j,~~""'r..JUj.f i1 AnIlrrIQ~Ilml' HtImt"'Of/"'.~/J;QtJIII IT""- V,~l but_gk lmlirn-tlu~'~""""ph,IIUJ ~~~_,.__ MW:""j..~ Ie browppd.:... PftffatIW,,,'Citk"'tllis -'rssE(~ rtId~~'kadm~l:CI Pi<.'lli4r,'bfJrPQIi~ [sse' malle~ilI PlultlMtla}nju/A.jtJiDoi"M 1'~SC(I.4) Ptl!Jl1r>rwrP}S""IIf"wJ..bmI# /ClInll:amwriwnv} iT T Nn.flrlwrlK.<~m~p/ulrtb"" iE .E -:::::::/~t':M ..._~-"~--*,~.(~~~ '''rn .....'.... "'" (,5/t'"",d""gal/ii I' . roMllelem ""..,,1I11i) T D.,....n'lwarhlot ._Ym""'MlI.bm:hmtlllii E fISH,. IJlIIlItooll...wlilh Pri."/"flt'crina/tl 1'6 gg;::,-;:;;;;;;:,-tl="".(I~E-:- &'bo>"- Ihriall. (BoIama NnnhAIlII~,..,,1U ,lflCilIl~ JIllcl.....""'lkJ) II:! E I'IoRIoomcWll"bIf E"""",Jt/fI...;,,,u}1nriJanu~ If. ' ;~=.\ClI.__..."'~=:'~/~?T;~~II!'t' ',,__~~ 1.~_.~~.. E.~,,**.,,__~~~t,g/<id...~_.__,_ ~__,_,._ speM...tII~ Phymrrm<IrmI:Tplmllt., :1< FUiblJl11Illtr P~mQ(FIlIIJlTNIC"""t'",; If:. E "C>>""'",m~ Sdll",-u1ttrllvwNlkl IT rrid'tdtw,"...lJIt(I/uskllimlllrl,l I (r~..,'"_,,,~) il! _~~....,,_tJlr>~.. .._..,.p.L_ - -, -. -.kc-~,~._ -,. AIj;~~;>rllliJsil~ipPw"Ii.J ' ISSC,o.J) ;..,H/A. C""/lncur"'" . iT' T iEi F~cl n. II! T IE H "r" -~'-l' . 'r;-' ..'-E' 'T 'E , Am"''''/''''''',um"ril'''',,'''mlrobJ/j,t E " E -n-' E l'n:l;lIOdel\f1lC.... ~,KlliI::R h>>ek~ -.;;;-~--.....- f},rKlafWesfJmim!rl\lllllH Fklrila"'~dr.be.- RFn1LFS ~~~ollpl~"'-' il~_flne a:reeOIlC.lIUltle ~."croood"" lI:~~_~a.~. ~"h:m'klj,>o',,~'uL: ,_. ~~~I~ il''l'herlOl'lniN: Kcrql'~lillry<o:lla~'li: . CIW....in"'I'f/lU C,.,I(.I'Id,oI........"'... .____fk.r"'!...._~/;!,.tv>r!.'''-.:'.'!.. I.h -"""'" 'I"",~, ",,,,,,-,. """!":'" ---Fl'rlmt1rlJrl:t,,';mbricnJ~ .-.. (;""h<<N~ pcAwM_.t lL"""..-h;/,'~b,,,p# iN\'F.R~R~'rES MOJJ.lJSKS }-lcr-idlo I"'" <tJ.l~ U,......Jtl--td'IlUll I isSe(!) IUNTS (,NQJ;I!L_,. Project: Figure 4. List of USFWS and FWC protected species for Collier Co., Fl. RENDA BROADCASTING CORP, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 RENDA, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA OIl, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08. Twn 50. Rge 26. totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsey Inc. Environmc-nt.t1l COnllullll'lij: Z6Jt ...Sl. NW N;lfII('~,fT. 14120 ,":,W.$64.1660 Agenda Item No. 76 February 23,2010 Page 113 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES/WILDLlFE FIELD SURVEY SHEET CUMLA TIVE TOTALS PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLI ER OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: 09/24,10/04/2008 All SURVEYS AM & PM TOTAL COUNT MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0630 AM 1945 PM 0'15 69-83 F NONE 10-80 % DATE: BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BlUEJAY CARDINAL PllEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK MAMMALS RACCOON REPTilE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE TOTAL COUNT 1 14 7 11 2 27 1 23 3 15 15 2 4 1 1 Project: RENDA BROADCASTING CORP, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 0111 Figure 5. Cumulative totals for Protected Species / Wildlife Survey. Daily field sheets in Appendix C. RENDA, BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA Oil, 5860 Crews Road, pm 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsey Inc. Environmental Consulting 2631 4'h St. NW Naples, FL 34120 239.564.1660 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Pa e 114 of 167 EAGLE NEST MAP OCTOBER 2008 . 2008 EAGLE N..t Lo".t1oftS Collier _ Rend. P."," N-. ~ \. N Figllre 6. Location of Eagl.. Nests in Coller Co. as of October 2008.; SOlWCe FWC ellllle website. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmen"ial Con.lllting 2631 4th St. NW Nar.le.. FL 34120 23 .564.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Agenda Item No, 7B February 23, 2010 PANTHER TELEMETRY 1981-2007 '_-'.;;-1'.';" . ,":;- ~';t',.~'" N Roads . Panther telemetry data 1981 2002 . Panther telemetry data 2003 2006 . Panther telemetry data 2007 _ RENDA PARCEL N. Panther Habitat FocUII Area 2006 Dec , '~/ Original Panther Consultation Area i'i;.. ... ... Panther secondary zone _ Panther primary zone <- " ., N Ramsev Inc. Environmental Consulting 2631 4th at. NW Nar.le!~ FL 34120 23 .5_1660 - Figure 7 Panther telemetry fo..... 1981-2007 In Coller Co. 80urce FWC. BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews R_d, PID 00405160008, Sac 08, Twn 50, Kge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 BEAR TELEMETRY 1983-2000 "~ Wlm I e . e . . e .: . . . .. . . . Black bear tel em fI 1983 2000 _ RENDA PARCEL /\I ROADS N Figure 8. Black Bear Telemetry in Coller Co. 1983-2000. Source FWC. Ramsev Inc. Envlronme'*-I Consulting 2631 4th 8t. NW Nar.'81.\ FL 34120 23. .1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Agenda Item No. 76 February 23, 2010 BEAR NUSIANCE LOCATIONS 1980-2006 '~ Wlill . . . \. . Bear_nuisance_1980-2006 _ RENDA PARCEL /\/ ROADS Figure 9. Black B..r Nuslanee LaClltions in Coller Co. 198D-2008. Source FWC. . + BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmerllal Consulting 2831 4th st. NW NaplelS, FL 34120 239.5_.1680 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Pa\l.<;.118 of 167 APPENDIA A. FLORIDA'S ENDANGERED SPECIES, THREATENED SPECIES, AND SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN ... .. November 2007 FLORIDA FISH AND WILDLlPE CONSERV ATJON COMMISSION - Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 119 of 167 APPENDIX A. CONTENTS PREFACE..............................................................,........................................................... ii NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN.... I OFFICIAL LISTS ..................................................,.....................'...............'.............. I FISH ..............'...............'.........................................................'...................................... 2 AMPHIBIANS............................................................................................................... 2 REPTILES....",...........,................................................................,................................. 2 BIRDS .................................................................................. ..................'....................... 3 MAMMALS....................................................................................,......,.......................4 INVERTEBRATES .................................................................,..,............'.................... 6 CORALS ............................................'......................................................,.............,..6 CRUSTACEANS....................................................................................................... 6 INSECTS ...................................................., .............................................................. 6 MOLLUSKS ...............................................'.......................................................,...... 6 KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATIONS........................................................ 7 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 120 of 167 APPENDIX A. PREFACE This document consolidates the ofticial state of Florida list of endangcrcd species, threatened species, and species of special concern. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) maintains the state list of animals designated as endangered, threatened, or species of special concern, in accordance with Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and 68A-27.005, respectively, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.) bttp://fac.dos.state.l1.us/. The state lists of plants, which are designated endangered, threatened, and commercially exploited, are administered and maintained by the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (DOACS) via Chapter 5B-40, F.A,C. This list of plants can be obtained at htto://www.tl- dof.com/torest manacement/plant conserve Iist.html. The federal agencies that share the authority to list species as Endangered and Threatened are the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration-National Marine Fisheries Service (NOAA-NMFS) and U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service (lISFWS), The NOA,A-NMFS is responsible for listing most marine species. The federal list of animals and plants is administered by the USFWS, and this list is published in 50 CFR 17 (animals) and 50 CFR 23 (plants). Additional information regarding federal listings can be located at the following websites; NOAA-NMFS http://www.nmfs.noaa.covandUSFWS-httD://endancered.fws.cov/wildJife.html#Snecies. Please note that while the FWC has published a consolidated list of state and federally listed species in the past, we now only publish a list of species listed within the state of Florida. This list will be maintained and available at our agency website: httD://www.mvt...c.com. Lists of federally listed species can still be viewed at the USFWS and NOAA-NMFS websites mentioned above. It is our intent by providing the list in this manner that we will be able to maintain a current list that is more readily available to the public. I would like to thank the following people who assisted in revising this list; Tom Logan, Jeff Gore, Paul Vincent, Paul Moler, George Wallace, Jim Rodgers, Karl Miller, Ted Hoehn, Darrell Scovell, Gray Bass, Kelly Donnelly, Elsa Haubold, Kipp Frohlich, Bill Brooks and the USFWS staff. Special appreciation is eKpressed to Ms. Angela T. Williams, Ms. Christine Yannett and Ms. Kat Diersen for their assistance with preparation of this document. . Commoo aod sclentln. names listed Itrst are as they appear In the FWC "Florida Wildlife Code Title 68A" (F.A.C). Commoo aod/or sdentlll. oames followlog this and located withio pareoth.... () contaio oames as used.by USFWS, or other commonly used names. Bradley J. Gruver, Ph. D Endangered Species Coordinator Species Conservation Planning Section Cover Photos by FWC Staff: Key Largo Woodrat, Burrowing Owls, Okaloosa Darter, Schaus' swallowtail butterfly, Short-tailed Snake. ii Agenda Item No. 78 February 23,2010 Page 121 of 167 APPENDIX A. NUMERICAL SUMMARY OF SPECIES LISTED BY THE STATE OF FLORIDA AS ENDANGERED, THREATENED, OR SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN STATUS DESIGNATION FISH AMPIIIBIANS REPTILES BIRDS MAMMALS INVERTEBRATES TOTAl. E 3 0 6 8 20 4 41 T 2 0 II ]0 4 0 1.7 SSC to 5 7 18 6 4 50 TOTAL 15 5 24 36 30 8 118 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 122 of 167 APPENDIX A. OFFICIAL LISTS Common Name Scientific Name Status FISH Atlantic sturgeon Acipenser oxyrinchus sse (I) (Gulfsturlreon) (AciDenser oxvrinchus des%i) shorlnose storaeon Aciuenser breviros/rum E shoal bass Micron/erus ca/arac/ae SSC II 2) Suwannee bass Micron/erus no/ius sse II) rivulus Rimlus marmora/us sse (I) (man"rove rivulus) J,ake Eustisooofish CVDrinodon varier!atus huMs; sser!1 blackmouth shiner No/ronis melanos/omus E bluenose shiner Pteronotronis we/aka sse 11,2) saltmarsh tonminnow Fundulus ienkinsi ssem keY silverside Menidia conchorum T crvstal darter ervs/allaria asnrella T harleouin darter E/heos/oma histrio ssem okaloosa darter Etheos/oma oka/ossae E Southern tessellated darter Etheos/oma olms/edi sse (I) (tessellated iohnnv darter) macula/icens key blennv Starksia s/arcki SSerl) AMPHIBIANS tlatwoods salamander Ambvs/oma cimm/a/um sse Georaia blind salamander Haideotriton wallacei sse (1,2) nine barrens treefrol! Hv/a andersonii sse (I) Florida bOIl fro!! Rana okaloosae sse (2) !!onher fro" . Rana canito sse fl ,2) REPTILES American allir!ator Alliga/or mi..sis,';ppiensi.. sse fl,3) American crocodile Crocodvlus aculus E key rin"neck snake Diadonhis nunctatus acricus T Eastern indiuo snake Drvmarchon corais couDeri T red rat snake E/aphe gut/ata sse' (l) Atlantic salt marsh water snake Nerodia clarkii taenia/a T (Atlantic salt marsh snake) 2 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 123 of 167 Common Name Scientific Name APPENDIX A. Status Florida pine snake Piluophis melanoleucus sse (2) mUf{itus short-tailed snake Stilosoma extenuatum T Florida brown snake Storeria dekayi victa T' rim rock crowned snake Tantilla oolitica T Florida ribbon snake Thamnophis sauritus saekeni T' bluetail mole skink Eumeees ewef{ius lividus T Florida Kev mole skink Eumeces egref{ius ef!rerdus sse (1) sand skink Neoseps reynoldsi T gooher tortoise Gopherus polyphemus T Barbour's man turtle GraJJ/emys barbouri sse (\ 2) alligator snaDoing turtle Maeroc/emys lemminckii ssem striped mud turtle Kinosternon baurii H' Suwannee cooter Pseudemys coneinna sse (1,2) s/Mlanniensis loggerhead seaturtle Carella carella T (Iol>I>erhead sea turtle) green seaturtle Chelonia mydas E (green sea turtle) leatherback seaturtle Dennoehelys coriacea E (leatherback sea turtle) hawksbill seaturtle Eretmoehelys imbrieata E (hawksbill sea turtle) Kemp's ridley seaturtle Lepidochelys kempii E (Kemp's ridlev sea turtle) BIRDS oioinf! olover Charadrius melodus T snowy plover Charadrius alexandrinus T (Cuban snowv olover) American ovstercatcher Haematonus nallialus SSC71,2\ brown oelican Pelecanus oecidentalis SSC(]) black skimmer Rynehops niger SSC (]) least tern Sleinu unlillurum T roseate tern Sterna dougalli T (Sterna dougallii dougal/ill limpkin Aramus flUarauna sse (I) reddish egret Er!rella rufescens sse (1,4) snoWY ef!ret [,i!rella Ihula sse (I) little blue heron Egretta eaerulea sse (1,4) tricolored heron Erzrella tricolor 55C(I,4\ 3 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 124 of 167 Common Name Scientific Name APPENDIX A. Status white ibis Eudocimus albus SSC(2) Florida sandhill crane Grus canadensis pratensis T whOODing crane Gru.\' americana sse (5) wood stork }vfveteria americana E roseate sooonbill Plalalea aiaia SSC (1,4) burrowing owl Alhene cunicularia SSC (I) (Florida burrowin!!' ow]) (Alhene eunieularia tloridana) crested caracara Caraeara eheriway T (Audubon's crested caracara) (Polyborus olaneus auduboniI) I perel!rine falcon Falco oereflrinus E Southeastern American kestrel Falco soarverius oaulu,~ T bald eal!le Haliaeetus leueocenhalus T osprey Pandion haliaelus sse2 (1,2) snail kite Rostrhamus soeiabilis E plumbeus lEverl!lades snail kite) Florida scrub iav Aohelocoma eoeruleseens T Cape Sable seaside sparrow Ammodramus marilimus E mirabilis Florida grasshopper sparrow Ammodramus savannarum E floridanus Scott's seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus sse (I) neninsulae Wakulla seaside sparrow Ammodramus maritimus SSC (I) iuncicolus white-crowned pigeon Columba leueoceohala T Kirtland's warbler Dendroica kirllandii E Bachman's warbler Vermivora baehmanii E ivorv-billed woodpecker Camoenhilus Drincioalis E red-cockaded woodpecker Picoides borealis sse Marian's marsh wren Cislothorus naluslris marianae sse (I ) Worthinll'ton's marsh wren Cistothorus oalustris griseus SSC (\) MAMMALS . Florida panther Puma eoncolor coryi E ! (Puma f =Felisl coneolor eoryl) Florida black bear Ursus amerieanus floridanus T3 Everl!lades mink Mustela vison everrzladensis T key deer Odoeoileus virginiam,s E clavium 4 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 125 of 167 APPENDIX A. Common Name Scientific Name Status Lower Keys marsh rabbit Svlvilae-us paluslris h~f;,eri E Bilo! Cvpress fox squirrel Seiurus nir!er avieennia T Sherman's fox squirrel Sciurus niger shermani sse 11,2) Eastern chipmunk Tamia, strialus sse (J) Sanibellsland rice rat Orvzomys oalustris sanibeli sse (1.2) silver rice rat Oryzomys argentalus E (rice rat, lower FL Kevs) (Oryzomys paluslris nalator) Kev Lano woodrat Neotoma tloridana smalli E Key Largo Cotton Mouse Peromysells gossypinus E allaoalieola Choctawhatchee beach mouse Peromyscus polionolus E allonhrvs Southeastern beach mouse Peromyseu., polionolus T niveiventris Anastasia Island beach mouse Peromyseus polionolus E ohasma St. Andrews beach mouse Peromyseus polionotus E peninsular;s Perdido Key beach mouse Peromyseus polionorus E Irissvlleosis Florida mouse Podomvs tloridanus SSC (1) Florida mastiff bat Eumops glaueinus tloridanus E grav bat Myotis ra-iseseens E Indiana bat Mvotis sodalis E Florida saltmarsh vole Microtus penmylvanieus E (Florida salt marsh vole) dukeeampbelli Sherman's short-tailed shrew Blarina earolonensis sse (2) r =brevicauda 1 shermani Homosassa shrew Sorex lonfliroslris eionis SSC(2) sei whale Balaenootera borealis E fin whale . Balaenoptera physalus E -ffinback whale) -- -_...,,--- North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena glacialis E (right whale) (Balaenaglacian,[incl auslralis n humpback whale Mef{aotera novaeanJ!liae E sperm whale Physeler maeroceohalus E Florida manatee Trieheehus manurus laliroslris E (West Indian manatee) (Tricheehus manatus) 5 Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 126 of 167 eommon Name Scientific Name APPENDIX A. Sta tus INVERTEBRATES eORALS I pillar coral Dendrogyra cylindrus E CRUSTACEANS Panama City crayfish Proeambants eeo'!finae SSC (I) (econfina crayfish) sims sink crayfish Proeambarus erythrops sse (I) (Santa Fe cave cravfish) black creek cr;rlish Proeamharu.. pic/us sse (I) IN~FrTS Miami blue butterfly Cyclargus [=Hermiargus] E Ihomasi bethunebakeri Schaus' swallowtail butterfly Heraclides arislodemus E nonceanus MOLLUSKS Florida tree snail LiflUusfaseiatus sse (I) Stock Island tree snail Orlhalieus reses E Orthalieus reses [not incl, nesodrvasl 6 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 127 of 167 APPENDIX A. KEY TO ABBREVIATIONS AND NOTATIONS List Abbreviations Fwe = E= T= sse= Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Endangered Threatcned Species of Special Concern Reasons for sse listings prior to January I. 200 I are indicated by the number in parenthesis under the following criteria: (I) has a significant vulnembility to habitat modification, environmental alteration, human disturbance, or human exploitation which, in the foreseeable future, may result in its becoming a threatened species unless appropriate protective or management techniques are initiated or maintained; (2) may already meet certain criteria for designation as a threatened species but for which conclusive data are limited or lacking; (3) may occupy such an unusually vital or essential ""ulugical niche that should it decline signitlcantly in numbers or distribution other species would be adversely affected to a significant degree; (4) has not sufficiently recovered from past population depletion, and (5) occurs as a population either intentionally introduced or being experimentally managed to attain specific objectives, and the species of special concern prohibitions in Rule 68A-27.002, F.A.C., shall not apply to species so designated, provided that the intentional killing, attempting to kill, possession or sale of such species is prohibited, {FWCl I Lower keys population only, 2 Monroe County population only, , Other than those found in Baker and Columbia Counties or in Apa!achicola National Forest. 7 TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System Agenda Item No. 78 Febj;!Jary 23, ,2010 PKgliq ;!aQ!f4167 APPENDIX A. 1,,-,;.~'tI'" u.s. Fish $ Wildlife Service ..1 ~J Threatened & Endangered Species System "~~.,' ';,"~..:..';ii .........._..-.. ": . Florida Notes: . This report shows the species listed in this state according to the Federal Register IIsrlng c18scription. . This list does not incfude experimental populations and similarity of appearance IIsllngs. . This list incftJdes species or poPfJlatlons IJndBf the sole jurisdiction of the National Marine Fisheries Service. . Click on the highlighted scientific names below to \f;ewa Species Profile for each listing. StfJtu, Specl8s1./:;tlng Name Listed specie. (based on published population dllt.) -114 listings ".NOTE: The. ~tm sea /ul"lJe is Ii.vled 2 limes under anlmal3. So the actual number irstea IS- 58 Animals and 1 J 3 Total. Animals - 59 T Bankclimber, purple (mussel) (t=IIiDtoidem~ <;Joati..'mlf~) E Bat, gray (MlIotis nri~Ascens) E Beetle, American burying (NlcroDhorJIs americanLJs) E Butterfly, Schaus swallowtail (lj~r~g!i0s aristodBmus Donceanus) T Catacara, Audubon's crested FL pop. (Po.!Y/;J9t'IJ$pf(ftnQjJjL~J1.r;!JIt?Qn/~ T Coral, elkhorn (Acrooora Dafmat~) T Coral, staghom (,AcroDora cervicornis) T Crocodile, American FL pop, (CrPQQffyJus "fQU1l.J,:?) E Curlew, Eskimo (NvmcniJ)s _QOl'!1..af~) E Darter, Okaloosa (E(hI;,9stQ!11~P.Jsff/Q()S<l!2) E Deer, key (QQtJCOi/911f; v/mi"ianus clavil1m) T Jay, Florida scrub (Aphelpco,ma t;Of!r.U~e.~~-'lj) E Kite, Everglade snail Fl pop. (RQ~trfJan.Jf}.!J.~~Dlumbeus) E Manatee, West Indian CUichec:hus m~) E Moccaslnshell, Gulf (Mediollidus DenicilltJtu~) E MoccaslnsheJl, Ochlockonee (Medionidlls slmDsollianus) E Mouse. Anastasia Island beach (Pen)lll}'sCU:"iPi2{onotusJJt!.tlliiill) E Mouse, Choctawhatchee beach (PoromY$(;M!i.pQf/onotlJs Rlloaf1.ty~) E Mouse, Key Largo cotton (fqro~ni'~\-({.$_!)Qfi~.YJ2lll1m~lmQ) E Mouse, Perdido Key beach (E..eroIJ1EcUs DofionotlJs Irissv!lJmg!~) T Mouse, souttleasrem beach (e.Q.romvscu~.P-Q1jgJ1Q/J!ill.lllll.Y..~lllr:i~) E Mouse, St. Andrew beach (Pcromyscu_s po/io,,-ot!l~Qgfl!fJ.~Jll1!ijjJ E Panther, Florida (Puma (=Felis).cO.r1<;QIQf.cgOO) E Pelican, brown except U,S, Atlantic coast. FL, AL (PefeCfllltl$ Decider/tails) http://ecos.fws.gov Itess_publicllpub/stateL isting,jsp?state=FL&status=1 istcd 10/8/2008 TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 p~~ ~t4167 APPENDIX A. E PigIOEl. oval (Plourob(~m,l pYrlforma) T Plover. piping except Greal Lakes watershed CC.";lmc1rius meloc!lIs) E Pocketbook, shinyrayed (J.-,<Jmpsi/is SUo.J/lgLilal.3j E Rabbit, Lower Keys marsh (Sy!yi(iJSWS p~l.lI$lri$ t.Jefnefl) E Rice rat lower FL Keys (Ory?QIJ1Ys Qalustris n~W1ior) T Salamander. f1alWoods (~r:nbystDrna 9inG)!J!iJtum) E Sawfish, smalltoo'h (~.Q;)jjiI)>ll11) E Sea turtle, green FL. Mexico nesting paps. (Cllq{Qni~L'nxdas) T Sea turtle, green except where endangered CClHtlQ.Qia.m$1[ls) E Sea turtle, hawksbill (Eretmochelvn Imbricara) E Sea turtle, Kemp's ridley (Lenidoche/vs kemWI) f Sea turtle. leatherback ([2Qrmccnclv:; coria;;;zjj) T Sea turtte, loggerhead (GfJlQtta c.arQ!ta) E Seal, Caribbean monk (M(Jrach.vs troplc;a1is) T Shrimp, Squirrel Chimney Cave (Palae.m.Qf7JUep3:UJJlmioSl1) T Skink, bluetall mole (Eumeces eareaius fividus) T Skink. sand (NeoS8D$ rRvnokim) T Slabshell, Chipola (EJiiR1io ank>ol@nsis) T Snail, S'ock Island lroe (Q1I!J~~Yil~LiIJJ;Ln~J:iI:Y;W) T Snake, Atlantic salt marsh (fjgI~ 1Mniata) T Snake, eastern indigo (Qty-'!l<<rphon corais cotJDe'-~ E: Sparrow. Cape Sable seaside (fVJlmW1Bllli&.mari1!mus mirRb(li~) E Sparrow, Florida grasshopper (Ammodramus savann~nJm flnn'danu$) E Stork, wood AL. FL, GA, se (Mvcteria 8mer~) T Sturgeon, gulf (Ac{aenssr oxvrinchus d(J~tDf) E Sturgeon, shortnosB (Ar:ipenser brevirostlllm) T Tern, roseate Western Hemisphete except NE U.S. (Sli2!lJi1.1&lgaJJii QQugiYU/} E Three-ridge, fat (mussel) (Amblema ne;sleriJ) E Vole, Florida sail marsh (Mir;rctL:!! pcnn5yf...:mil";,':s dlil,('C.dnlrb(l!i) E Whale, flnback (BalilftfWP.tf:ra. physallls) E Whale, humpback (MQgflplora novaean91if/g) E Whale, right (Balaf!f1luJ1{f~ia!Ls....{lL1GL.1iJl~1) E Wolf, gray Lower 48 States, except where delisted and where- EXPN. Mexico. {(2a[li~ /Vpu.~) E Woodpecker, red-cock.aded (Pj~Qj!1.e.flPorealis) E Woodrat, Key Largo (N~Qtoma floridana sma/II) PI_"t. _ .;;.. http;//ecos.fws.gov/tess_public//pub/slateListi ng.jsp '!state= FI,&status=listed lO/8/2008 TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System Agenda Item No. 78 February 23, 2010 ptllJct1 Ja:%i4167 APPENDIX A. Status Sper:JeSIL/sling Nsm. E ASler I Florida. golden (ChIYSDPt,;IS f/ofJddfla) E Beargrass, Britton's (Nolina.Jwrtpnianfj) E Beauty, Harper's (Harpqrqr.:[l/1ijJJlpv..4J E Bellflower, BrooksviJle (.c<J""fla(1./,1I~ rObinfiiaq) T Birds-in-a-nesl, white (M(Jc.tlJi.rtfiJJ(baj E Blazlngslar, scrub (Lialris, Q'Jjjng(lr~el T Bonamfa, Florida ([tQf]i1.mi.fl.SJr!1!1f!jflora) T Buckwheat, scrub (Erioaonum !Dnaifo/ium Vlfr anaDhaJifoliur'{J) T Butterwon, Godfrey's (f'ingulclJ.fa,ionfJn.J!1~) E Cactus. Key tree (eJ.}Qsocereus rabinil) E Campion, fringed (Silene MlvaetnJIJ) E Cha1fseed, American (,C;ChWR/btM 8rnm1!;aDa) E elsdonla, Florida perforate (ClimPJlia Pf3rtor~(a) E Fringe-tree, pygmy (Chic:m:1nthus oygrnafJlI.s) T Gooseberry, Miccosukee (Ribe!; echinellum) E Gourd, Okeechobee (C/lc/JrbitR nkeF~hnhp.p.nsis SSD okeec/1oD~sjs) E Harebells, Avon Park (Q(Qlgllllia a.Vf::Jnli'1$is) E Hypericum, highlands scrub (Hvoericum cumulic.ola) E Jacquemontia, beach (J.{Jg!JJLe.lJ1onlia rea/inata) E Lead-plant, Grenulate (AmQ/'PhEl.ae..nuJsta) E Lupine, scrub (LJJwm..lS../lr.idorflrr:/) E Meadowrue, Corney's (l11aJjr;l[I.llJ.1. CDolerl) E Milkpea. Small's (~!a..$maJ1ib E Mint, Garrett's (Dic~.!iJndra christmani!) E Mint, Lakela's (Dicerandra immawlata) E Mint, longspurred (Qjr;f!Lll!1Qra comutissiml!) E Mint, scrub (Diceranrlra frureSS;tms) E Mustard, Carter's (~art~rl) E Pawpaw, beautliul (fJfJ.illif}gothnmnus p.uJf:...hg.l!l!s) E Pawpaw, four-petal (Asil?7ina tetr(lrn~rij) E Pawpaw, Rugel's (Deerinaothamnus.WQcfiil T Pigeon wings (9!iUld~J[p.$JlJJ.m;) E Pinkroot, gentian (Spig,.eJl.{t~Q..ftfj) E Plum, scrub (PfL!l!V$..!lwj(aJjata) E Polygala, Lewton's (Po.lygal.alew.tQf]il) http://ecos.fws.gov ltess _publicllpub/stateListing.jsp?state=FL&status=listcd IO/S/200S TESS: Threatened & Endangered Species System Agenda Item No. 7B F~~~:~?J~~~ APPENDIX A. Potygala, tiny (PQI:i{Jd/R ~m':ifl.i(l E Pondberry (Lindera n'clissifolit''1) E Prickly-apple, fragrant ((.,~e[~.u$ eriophon,ls WJ'. fr,1(Jr8(ls) E Rhododendron, Chapman (RhododcndfQDc.hflnmQ[!iI) E Rosemary, Apalachicola (C-QwslciLf/ilfJ1alJral E Rosemary, Etonia (Conradina eloJ1La) E Rosemary, shon-leaved (ConmdlJ1fl.Qr.1iyjfpJiIj) E Sandlace tPolygQ(l~!Ja_IJ)Y.riQ{Jj]y.!1a) T Seagrass. Johnson's (!:1moJ2l1ila..j.alw.Ofli!) T Skullcap, Florida (~aMJIQ[it!.".) E Snakeroot (fr'ioolvm 9un~o.~fym) E Spurge. deltoid (s:tJam$.JJ.<'Y_f1P. rlRltt;li1.eJ1 <:<:0 d1'Jlt"'il"i"'J!~) T Spurge, Garber's (ChamBesvce.JJa[bJt[f) T Spurge, telephus (Euc'JhOrbin te/sohioidBS) E Torreya, Florida ((Qlreya ({Jxifglig) E Warea. wide-leaf (Warea amDlexlfoJia) E Water-willow. Cooley's (./.wcia cDo/evll T Whitlow-wort, papery (Paronvchia charlaCeft) E Wireweecl (PJJ]YfJPfJeIl8 p~mrM1iil) E Ziziphu$, Florida (zgjph1JS ceJata) FWS EndanoArAd Soecis.$J:lome I ECOS Home 1.QQn.Ut.ctECqg; I P..rivag 1 Disclaimer http;llecos. fws.gov/tess_publicl/pub/stateListing .jsp?state=FL&status=listed I 0/812008 APPENDIX C. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 132 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09/24-10/04/2008 ALL SURVEYS AM & PM TOTAL COUNT MICHAEL R, RAMSEY 0630 AM 1945 PM 0-15 69-83 F NONE 10-80 % BIROS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJA Y CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE TOTAL COUNT 1 14 7 11 2 27 1 23 3 15 15 2 4 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 133 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09.24.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0645 AM 0930 AM NONE 76 F NONE 10-20 % COUNT 3 2 2 2 5 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 134 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 01 1 COLLIER DATE: 09.24,08 PM OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1730 PM 1945 PM 10-15N 81 F NONE 40-50 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJA Y CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 2 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 135 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER DATE: 09.26.08 AM OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0630 AM 1000 AM NONE 71 F NONE <5 1% BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 1 2 1 2 5 1 2 2 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 136 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER DATE: 09.26.08 PM OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1715 PM 1930 PM 0-5 N 83 F NONE 10-20 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 1 1 t 1 2 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 137 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 09.27.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0700 AM 1000 AM 0-5 N 72 F NONE 70-80 % COUNT 4 1 2 1 3 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 138 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER DATE: 09.27.08 PM OBSERVER: TIME START: TItME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MICHAEL R RAMSEY 1715 PM 1930 PM 0-5S 81 F NONE SO.60 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 1 4 5 1 2 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 139 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 01 1 COLLIER 09.30.08 PM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1700 PM 1930 PM 0-5N 80 F NONE 70-80 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK MAMMALS RACCOON REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE COUNT 1 2 1 1 3 2 2 . . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 140 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLIER 10.03.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0645 AM 0930 AM 0-5 N 69 F NONE 10-20 % COUNT 2 2 4 3 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 141 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK PROJECT: COUNTY: DATE: OBSERVER: TIME START: TIIME END: WIND: TEMP: RAIN: CLOUD COV: WATER: COMMENTS: MAMMALS RACCOON BLACK :& VEATCH TAMPA 01 t COLLIER 10.04.08 AM MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 0645 AM 0945 AM 00-5N 83 F NONE 10-20 % COUNT 2 2 1 5 2 2 2 3 REPTILE SLENDER GLASS LIZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE , , Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 142 of 167 PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY FIELD SHEETS PROJECT: COUNTY: BLACK:& VEATCH TAMPA 011 COLLiER DATE: 10.03.08 PM OBSERVER: TIME START; TIIME END: WIND: TEMP; RAIN; CLOUD COV; WATER; COMMENTS: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY 1730 PM 1745 PM NONE 83 F NONE 10-20 % BIRDS RED SHOULDERED HAWK BLUEJAY CARDINAL PILEATED WOODPECKER CAT BIRD EASTERN BLUEBIRD GREAT EGRET MOCKING BIRD HAIRY WOODPECKER RED BELLIED WOODPECKER MOURNING DOVE VULTURE BLACK COUNT 1 1 2 2 3 2 2 MAMMALS RACCOON REPTilE SLENDER GLASS LiZARD BLACK RATE SNAKE _., or"" ; ~" Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 143 of 167 Ecological, Environmental, Agric:ultural Land Management, Permitting, Septic Evaluations - _'.""H ~a_IIl.~ey In~. -'-'..~'" LEP, CWB, CFEA, REPA, CEHP ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING LEP - Licensed Environmental Professional CWB - Certified WiJdlife Biologist l."FEA - Certified Florida Environmental Assessor REPA - Registered Environmental Property Assessor CEHP p Certified Environmental Health Professional OSHA S - Hazardous MateriaJs Incident Commandet E.mail: Ramsey.lnc@cmbarqrnail.com Offi",,: 239.564.1660, Pax: 866.334.1496 26314" St. NW, Naples, FL 34120 www.ramseyinc.net 08 October 2008 CU.2008.AR.14085 REV: 1 RENDA BROADCASTING Project: 2008070019 Date: 12/24108 DUE: 1/27/09 Ms. Jady Lima Black & Veatch Corp. 60 1 Walnut Street Suite 550 W Philadelphia, P A 19106 PROJECT: Renda Broadc...ting Corp" Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Pill 00405160008 ; Street Addre..: 5860 Crews Rd.; City: Naples ; State: FL; County: Collier; Sec 08 Twn 50 Rge 26: Road Frontage: 330 feet; Acres: 5.0 Ms. Lima, This letter is in response 10 your request for a review of the project property as described above per the rules of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD), and/or the U.S, Anny Corps of Engineers (USACOE) for lbe presence of jurisdictional wetlands and/or surface waters and the need for p~ts (Figures I and 2). To determine if jurisdictional wetlands are present 3 components (soils, vegetation, and hydrology) of a parcel of property are investigated for wetland characteristics, If any 2 of the components have wetland characteristics then DEP/SFWMD claim jurisdictional wetlands, If all 3 components have wetland characteristics then the USACOE claims jurisdictional wetlands also. Depending on the situation permits could be required from DEP/SFWMD and USACOE prior to commencement of any type of construction activity in jurisdictional wetlands. DEP and USACOE claims Old Farm field Ditches as jurisdictional surface water areas if they are generally 2 feet or wider, have a side slope greater than 3: I, supply water to a wetland, and there is no current permit in effect on the property. SOILS. The soils are mapped by the Natural Resource Conservation Service (NRCS) for Collier Co. The soils present are 1114 Pineda (H), and #21 Boca. The 1114 soil is considered to he a wetland soil type by NRCS (Figure 3). Soil sampling onsite did reveal wetland characterislcs in the 624, and 419 areas. VEGETATION. The vegetation on the property is defined by the Florida Land Use, Cover and Fonns Classification System (FLUCFCS, Figure 4.5,6) as: #1 & #2 624 Cypress Pine Palmi DEP,USACOE Jurisdictional Wetland 3,79 acres; #3 740/310 Disturbed Land/Grass Prairie DEP/SFWMD, USACOE Upland 0.15 acres; #4 74018212 Disttubed LandlCommunication Towerrs DEP/SFWMD,USACOE Upland 0.38 acres; #5740/8145 Distrubed Land/Access Driveway DEPISFWMD,USACOE Upland 0.22 acres; #tj & #7 419 Other Pine DEPISFWMD,USACOE Jurisdictiom~ Wctland 0.23 acres; HYDROLOGY. Last, for DEP/SFWMD there were indications of hydrology on the property in the 624 areas, For USACOE, there were indications of hydrology on the property in the 624 areas. However, USACOE can assume there is hydrology when wetland vegetation and NRCS hydric mapped soils are present. Therefore, the 419 areas are assumed 10 have hydrology present. CONCLUSION, This review of lbe property indicates that there are jurisdIctional wetlauds on the properly as delineated by the by the 624 and 419 areas. Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 144 of 167 Renda Broadca...ting Corp. Black & Veatch Tampa all Pid 0040~ 160008,5860 Crew! Rd. Initial Evalu.lIion 08 October 2008 Page 2 Construction or land clearing activities on this parcel will require an Environmental Resource Pennit (ERP) from DEP/SFWMD fur impacts to jurisdictional wetlands and/or surface waters if any part of the 624 areas are impacted, It will also require a US Army Corps of Engineers (USACOE) pennit for impacts to wetlands, and a review by US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) for impacts to Hotida panther and/or wood stork habitat if any of the 624 and/or 419 areas are impaCled. This property would be considered "connected to a TNW" by USACOE, Please note that this review was done prior to you having a Surveyor mark the comers of your selected lot and the boundaries were estimated, Indicaled wetland lines may change due to the DEP permitting process and closer investigation. If this evaluation is more than I year old, the property needs to be revisited to note any changes. Please call if you have any questions. ~ Michael R. Ramsey President ~- .' . .., Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 145 of 167 PROJECT LOCATION MAP COLLIER COUNTY, FL 5 , o 5 15 Miles , 10 N Figure 1. Project Lacation Map; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acrea. Ramsev Inc. Environment.1 Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Nap'e!" FL 34120 239.5-.1660 - ~ .' . . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 146 of 167 ~R9..""~~~C..T L.'.--i\Q,~ATION. DETAIL ~AI~P I : lirJ. ~f=j'- \~~ ~ ILL k 1~ II I J ~~--'0-.~]1 r4 ~ 1/ n l -~iE! c>~A@r f 'j r- ( fW'iF~ ~~ .. I ") ~ L _ . \ I ". "VIR BLVII. _ Lt h I J.."': ~" 8~ !! fJ Iii 1 I ~ ~~ = 011 If" I <i ~J ( L, J! i !! . I (" ~ Iii ~l!1 - ~ It ~I'~ I I 'b._~~ -+- l= V ~ c fj\ 'FJIL I ~~~ ,~-'" ~' &m"SI-V [1' ~ I ~- mTIDl -~~'-\C,,-I- JJ ~~~ h jplIIDl1IIIII\l :J. TTI ~. --Ip ._~ \DmII LJJ L ~ =I-UL___~J . l rTr ~~~=~__~1.1 J I;, ~~ ~ ~ \ I iliJ 1-- a~ lv PROJECT: BLACK & VEATC TAMPA 011 l luf + Figure 2. Project Location Detail Map; Ramsev Inc. Environmedtal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple~.FL 34120 239.5_.1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 28, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. '... .' Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 147 of 167 SOIL MAP ~ #14 PINEDA FS (H) c Figure 3. 5011 Map of project location. Source US Dept. of Agriculture, Naturel Resource Conservation Service, '1990, SOli Surveys, FloIrida; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. N + Ramsev Inc. Envlronmetftal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naples, FL 34120 239.56...1660 , .' Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 148 of 167 FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP JJO FT g}3 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEPISFWMD .lURIS. WETLAND USACOE .lURIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.08 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC IEE"l'I 740 310 Il;tl;!I DIflURBED LAND I gEPI1UJW~\FLAND USACOE' ULAND #30.15 AC O 740 8212 DISTURBED LAND ( COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEPISFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #4 0.38 AC r:01 740 8145 ~ DiSTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY Bl~c!&r'll~Vd-"ND #5 0.22 AC 419 . ~ OTHER PINE ~ DEPlSFWMD UPLAND ~SACOE .lURIS. WETLAND 6 0.15 AC 7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY . TOWER Ii: Ii! '" 1'\ V' Y >< $;;: x'>< >< /' Ix;>< f>< )< ~ .x.: x ",'> >< ~:x x ;x V' :xX: 9 )< x., '-- )< :S:< '" ><:x,> >- '-- x <:9' >< ~;x '-- ><~ ;x,. "-- ><>< >: 'x >< >< ~ x. 0<>< x >: x ;X X<X>;y"~:s: ;x x., ~ >< '-- ~ ;x ~ ;:: x~ t"' --------------------~\ - 40 0 40 L JECT:B Figure 4. FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; 1III '1 . '- '" ><.,~ ><> >s; ><~ Xx "" X>< '>< >< >< '-- .? ~ '-- 0. 'x ;? ~ >< )< ><::~ >< Y'> .,?< '" 6< ><;>< "" V' "- Y ><:8: ?S:xA> (> ><.>< ~l.> "'><> e "->< '" x X>< "-x . N x Y":x 8:." 4 >> ..'>< >< I ~ >Ox: ~>< r" x: ~~~ ,. '\~ :x 0' s>~ X I I CRE..WS ROAD ROW H TAMPA 11 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 28, totaling approx. 4.77 aeres. N E Ramsev Inc. Environmental Consulting .- 2631 4th SL NW N.ple!~FL 34120 239.5_.1660 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 AERIAL FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP Figure 5. Aerial I FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Age 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. Ramsev Inc. Envlronmedial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple~LFL 34120 239.5-.1660 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 ZOOM OUT AERIAL . . ~ + Figure 6. Zoom Out Aerial; Ramsev Inc. Environmenial Consulting 2631 4th St. NW NaPI:~L 34120 239. 1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn SO, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. SITE PHOTOS Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Figure 12. Site Photos; DATE 10.03.08 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5880 Crews Road, PID 00405180008, See 08, Twn 50, Rga 28, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. . Ramsev Inc. Environman'b.l Consulting 2831 4th St. NW Napl.!5~FL 34120 239.5-.1880 Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 152 of 167 DEP!WMJ WETLANDS DETERr.tNATlOfo' FIELD WORK SHEET _~~_~ ,,-. .!'~"'!LR.""lIIJIy.R~~INC Cl.'El>IT..U.CK6vu.TC"!T}.;MP"oln,~AOC"'STNQ MAPFlUCCilCOOI~ l.40DlllIr~!!"I!DlAND !O ____, "AOf'{"'TVI.E(lAL.~11GOGI ~.CAII..!!'~.._ U12COf111MUNICATIOffTOWP ".....CCI!UDR AV 1lI1OU"'ll'IIIPltDALCI\1t'QllIIII'I'IJIllMDllI'. nn'-J<<ll'wtl\.APDt.lIlJI".o.or.~ll[CAUII!n<<~"'" ___~lIllllfllO_OHl,),N)>Hl!"'Wcl'CotKIl~ACll..,.CQN;bNIClIHE'" ~""lIOl(ftf\H;;1'(:N llIlC_......J_Cnow.JI(c.o.uE~N'fliCTIUl'AC~W~T!"dlIllQl;:llIJ:PI:5M1E..lftll)~,.'IU~"'~AJ'lI;..~~n7'fS-101tl!'~- DITCH68 fltlIl!tlfHT: Y&S NO xx liE I'IG . VECET A1IOM: \ftTUNlf C""Ol"I "'A .",FAe ,,'11f.,S !lLOTTI V ceNBA(~l -'!4SAIW."''''-Y;:~'' -".,.".ICAC.llIFEIIA(F} --"SCHlNJIlTl1lll:BlI'ffi1IFOllUS(1') =='IIoUELAtEl.OloOONOl.l!IIEFlVlAtA .__ 'l\.,l\:ACIA AlIltcll.IFORMe$~) liUBCANOPY No" "'-fAG 'lIoPIHU!lt:t.O.OTTIVDEH!L'041'1 -"SAlW..PN.MITTOjf) -"t.MlICAefRlFERAlI'J =,.SQIN.,Ili1J.PlUINTHlFOUUSll'J _"MELAl.ElJCAWIll()!1HeRVI...,) "WEl<<MIlt:PIi_) ==,..,ICASAlJAE"IF) _"4M'/t11$frll!QUIANEN5IIlI__.....,.,....~F) %DI08f"'(flO5....JRGlN...fIMl'l -,,!UOl!N!ACLMNlIl'l -"'AelCIAAl,IUCI..I.IFOfIMESll"1 ""'--- O"OUNDCOVl!R frt'A 'Jl.fAC _",PINL$EUOTTIVDINSoIl(F) "WALPAU.IETTO(l'I -'l\."""'IOACl!R1FERilIFI -'ll.SQ04IMJ8'l1!.REBlNTl'Ill'Ol.tU$(F) -'lloMELALl~QUlNCllENliRVIAlF) =""llEftE~RIPIf4Il'l _'4,"lCAS~1 __ "" 1NIl1l1... (lI.MH!tfilll--........,.....cF1 ~._'II.DlOllP\"A06VlFIGI~(F1 -'.'Il.I!~H1"'ClIMINI~ -""foC,o\Oj......t.AIC\l.lfQAMI!!liIF) t2:R'...ld'IOJ'OOONllIAOINICUS(I') !;1.IJ__""AAISTlQAtTIII1CT"'(Fj %AXONOP\JS8Pl"l --,8AO(l~RI8MA1.MII"(ll.""IF) .1::1L 'lloIIDlNSI'I~OSA(Fj _'IIolltllEl.l"'lI'l 'lloCMO,I'I'ARl...Sf:R011NAlI'l ""DlClflCOJiI!A!ll.III!'l!iR"'I'" -'IIoEfWJRQIIlTl'''IF) -""fIllOERONOUiiFlClFOLIUS(f} -"",RYN)IlJ.lIW.DWINIll'1 =='Il.P",TQlIIIUMSI'lfl %i!lITHolMIA8l':(F} -'!l.F1lo11RlsnLlSSf'ATHACCA(fIl -'IIo'OfIESTIEAAI(~MATAlFl -,,'u!XOI'ACAVOPACo\I'1 -=t:.IIII'I.....rO\CVLIIoIlRICA{"COQON) 'RoLA~.CAAO(.lA~(f} -'IIolYONl",FeflRUOI~CF) -'IIoWl!lOOHl"'CORC~lllfOU,l,(F) -""MIIWIIIAaoANDENlI'l "J.-llL'1oP!'M.ASI'lFl - 'Jl.PSYcIOTfllASI'.{f) --"""IIUl1USllPtf'l -""IlANllUOUSC"'NADlN$l8{Fj "~__""&El8ANlASPCF) YoBl!TaI'I1A(lEHlCULAT"'ff'l -""SIIII,.AXSI'(fl -'II.TOXIC(lIl)IHMONFWllCAH$l.1'} .!:!L'II.VITISAOTI.NIIIIQ.I,I,{l') 'IIoWECEUA1lllOBollTA HYlJROLOGtc INDICATORS: """ ""'QA1.Ml.T8 W",TEAw.FItal M"1.06 RAFTINGOI'DEflA!& SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: ,__, AtJI.U:k_.... "TNckOMlS<.olK. ",Q- ....H)IIllOP"WlldtI_ ...~SInilIl~rll.,.... "'6010-1,,,,B_ A1Sc/Jll.Ul\yu.... S,s.ndy~_. S5Sa/lltfAt<i>l< f;6S~M"l ~TC"""",,_ F'I.AIlIft~~"'l F~D.plI""'''''' '13~",","'. tlI.l'l!lr:wMO ......", -- -, -, AI.,",_ VII_NO ~ loll.... Q_ Y!I_ NO __. FUNCTIONAL NlA ti 'I'd NO JlI-.......,.ION...L. IilIAltal:' WATER N:llOATOII.,.IIATA, ctIUIAC:TlllDINO WanATIOttIlMTO.llKOIIIIOM Of' A&llAl.eoYllW)a , , , , "OW aurAC~LAlJljFOl.IAll'Wj .r.cEflRlA~'W. CEl-TISWVlGAU . . , . -, -' , ..---~ .... ro\llOOIIJt,lOISTICHIlJM.Ol PER9l!"'P"'~l./5T""&_",,,.,{OI ILEXCASSINI101 S.t.LIll.CAAOllANA(O) FR.u.INUSCAAOI-INI_101 .___...0lI'.0 QI'- YES_NO xx.. yES 0.' NlIC"TOII",IIAUI ~VIGnAT"'''''''TO'110'll00ll~Ol'.ulULCO'IIIWII , ~ -' , , -' ,ACW Ql1i.IlCUllLAURI'OI.~fWl ACIIl~~ CELTISL..'IVIOA'''' (;(lAft.JSFOC;:M1......P'Wl , . -' , --. -, -' , OBL TiO.XDDlUlIfDlSTlCl'4lUUlO1 PIRSI!AI'ALUBTAIS_.,lO) llEICCASSllCtOI $AtlXCNlCl.I,o,w.,{OI "FlAXINU8CAROlINI"'~ CEP~HU5OCClCENT...~I'tOl . ...... 'lIoAl.8IlJA.MJII'I$$1fj =~~$l:IlASlt.WWII"'M_"'" ._'lIoOOllRCUI!I~!IIQINo\Nol\flJl ...... 'lloAUlIZlAJUlIIlA1SS1N ='lIoIl~AA$llWIU!!A(U)_(1<<I 'lIoOOfRClAVIRa......K'(I'lJ. =-.c:.RHlSCOPilU-INLUM . ---'"', jo.:ao",,1)l'I. -.c:.ALBI21...JULIBRISSlN ='lIo...MMOSI.....um:M51I~"M ,.~~S.w.IWlloII(Vj_..... =,..CA~llCAl'lI'AAl.IEflICA....lUl 'lIoCEtolAU8$1'lUl =''lIoO'rf<<)l)CJHo.o.cn'lON(lJl__ _ 'lIoOl.CTYl.ItClLOMERATAIUl 'll.DACT'flOCTlNlIMAI!trrPTltNlM_ ::='lIoOl!9U)llIUMSPM _'Il.lUiilOl.AllI'IAlUl __...._'Il.L'W'........cl'l,l) _'Il.OXllLlSSTIII1CTAlUl _""PANlCl&IloWl1M!,M1UJ_ .R..-""'....LUMNOTA1'\.-..uJ _,,"PIl.OIlll'HiSIl.IGIOAlUI _..~_""l'm'CII'8l..._GRAMlNl'OI..Io\{U) "I'TE"IDILNGl.IDrrSCH(UI_"'I~ =='RoPTll'ICJCAI.LONP'l'CH08TACHV\JM1Ul _'lIocueACtllCll1"'YAHlI(U) 'lIoOUERCUllVIAGl*""'!Ul -='lIoIlHl&OOI'AlUNJI,IM "'1'IH~VTlIlUMflE.PEMSlU'__ ioiO:""SPEfMOtOOCI....lut _ "f.STENOT~UMIl!Cl.H)ATUM(U)""""'.... !:1!....'I'olNNALOllAY"tut .!I....- "f.IlAREGAOOND ilCWlT1CPI.AHlll ....co.. -'" -1MlRCX.OGICDATA --"8EOlIolENTOIPOGlTION -...ouo,TICF-AUNA lOll. pQClPTlONIl 10Y11 DEPTItI'" SOllSA.UPli13 "" "" n' m m "" '" "" '" "" "" "" '" "'. '" ". "" "" "'. OO_~Qj""",,,w_3Q.....c....mal...."tWt1e-"""- NO_"._ll._""'.~O,"_hIlr..&ll1C._ctron"2ar"".<IIlI'Il!'(l_lr"t""'~ NO_'-"I...,W......otl...........l\lllltOwAn'.OIsur!.... NO .....n3Qoontu1... "",,"-~_rq_",,,,"'I... "'""""M1IIn t>or.!......"~~ ","n,""om.1 ...".........1.. '"""" HlJ.-.l1%ar'..,..,r..j.muciIh......._III.........11in6.'U<t"'. NO=2"1.,.,lMlI'Ilnij'oI".,urI.,. 'lO_gioI~'"...~ICCloIPn&O'll.Of......ol'~lIlInijlnath.,..t- NO .~_ .,..1IlItle Iftol "",,_1hol:'-GINII4In"""''' I'M _weO%m tnQnllnc....m.2 NO_~~_.....'.ll".I...._:I~aI.... NO_.''''_4.1I>c:I<'1aoIIrq_'......L'"......_3D'......~M1"' 1 ".lHI;10%p".,...c....""D~""".....,"'.._I.. NO.__IJItr11o''''_\llhChllCCUpluBO'I'o'''.....oll.'~~''.OIW.....- NO_.II..'..,..,~-..IId_.INI,..'O'I'o...""""Ci'fo"'.~OO"_.WVQ_'a.D'.....fICf HO~....NtIC_""_ol~.....IIII<lWlnldlo""'_""11,...'-ll1donnro"IMILPl*6';Y#'IIliN3o.I.H'Cf'rlH...1 "'~ N01!!..IlREALEXT'NTOIlL>lPL;""",*,5Clilo;~ NOU NlUlLElCTENTOIIL,'.r.ew>~'O'llo~p,o~'ACI NO,IIl!_IoIJCI(SClII.& ~;-:~...,..,...,.... ... INIllO"TOI'IIITM1"A: OWIIl:fIi~VlQEfATICItHMTOlI!lI1'1loOllIlltOlUiO''--'''COVIJWII: ""'" ,.". -' . , BI::' , -, , =, . ~ no'!l. " .!:!L'lIo , -. ~ -' , =, -' ~ -~ ~ -.""'lIo =, , . , . -' . , -, , -~ =, -' ~w RCUlIVJJR!FOL~ IlCIRRlAlMo4fFWI CORNJS'OI!MNIl.(FWI AMPHlCNlPUMMUIl.ENBEROANlI"fol{rN) llLECl+ANSERmII1:.!!-.____ ~N1I1LLA.....lATlCAlPw) CHmIl)pI.A~ICAC011'WJ CIRSILNNJTTolLI.lll'Wj ~INA9PlFWl CCNX;IW'1J!IEReCTUStl'Wj CORIOPSlSSf"lfW) CYnRUIl ~rol..l.MlS(FWl CYP'ERUIlODOl\ATU&lFW) DlCHlLIOt.IENo\COi.OI'AT'11'Wl DlOOl"V1IL101N11<NAlFWI EU8T~OLAUCA1FW. "l.llIRISTY\.ISANNU'oll'Wl GLIOlf&IATRlACANTl<<llIll'Wl HEllAK1'1'UlI'f!'W) HVDIIOOOTYL.I$fI'{I'W) l'fI'I'IIll.lOllM8t'lFWI IM'TlSoIlU.TA(FW) JUNC\J5J.W1l)lPMTU5IFWj LACHNXAlI.ClN $1'{IIOQ1lunONllOot'Wl LIfoI)!ANlAQFl,l,N)t'lOl'IA{fWj IlE.ANl'HEMHABTo\TA(I'W) p~lIII!l'ENS(FW) PASPAl.l.NLIOI.LAI'IIS(FW) PLl.(:tEASP(FW) FM.X1A1I'{FW) RUMlICllt.I'IT10lUATUS ll'Wl SCLiiRlA$'IP'W) BOLIDAOO{f'W) SI'/\IlTINIo_IRltl'Wl THI!I.Vl'TERI6IP(f'W)lP1l!l.OfERN woocw1dml'" VIRGll'lCA 1l'WIVCt<<fERN llVJIIlllCArIOLlN.'INIo(l"W) .wYINTITOUSflOOTli -HVPEfmIlOl"HICl!NTICI~il Ac::TIVECYI'ftINKfrEEB 'LOWCHA~L6 NO , ~ , , ....-,., -, ~ . . -, -' , -. -. =. . --, _n_,., -, , -. . . . , , . . . 08L T...llODn,IIIIDISTlCH\NIOl PERSTI.....AWSTIlIS_..IO) Il../(t.:_'....IUl a"'UllCAROtI.0.N4lOl fAAlUNU8CAROllf'lllNAl0l CIPHALNlTHU8OCClD&HT...U${O! ...NNONA m...IlFI"'lOl """""0' CLAOILNJAWoICENSEIOl [)ICHl'l~,"v.TlroLlAIOl ELEOCHAFlIIlep101 EFlIOCAlLON $PlP'I"IWORTS) (OII'WJ FUlIlE* SClRPOOIAtOl JUNCUSSp.lOl LUDWIG.....PIOl LVTHflIAISP(OI 1MolI'~IABPlOl WH.E~CN'ILlLAflIS{Ol P...,..ClNloEtRTOI<<JHtOl I"Ol~BI'(OJ PONfIDllU.l.COIWATlllOl PROSEfIP~OP IOl I'lIi'l'NCOSPOR"IO) S...GITTAA!ALANC1FOl.I"COJ lSelA_IIIIAGr<OA{ll1 THill.lA~PlICI.LIlTAiOl """'[01 - ~-~!~ 6\JRI'~WA1'!"'I'flE9ENT AQIJI\YIC MOfiSI5!UVEIIWORTll DRIFT LINES IIEaETATECTUIl~K8 ILlvllrl!DLlCHENLINES lI_rqW___Gn~~~....rt"...'old,""""nc.bKM II50LATID YU NO lQL "''' ST"TlOFFL: DB' Sl'WMD WETLAND; WliTlAND VII NO ~ JURlBDlCTlONAL DIftRMNATlON uPLAND Vii xx . NO _..,)"""_""'..'""___.__.~,~'""",__'".. ....,~_....... ...'....~,-;M__...lO'''"'-,.,_-",-... COfMCTIU YU NO,!LltA .\I.U ... llf.lSANDWIFIOOK JJ. JIOCl<REFUSAl SOIL$o\..l.EI-' 0.0.'.0 A m.FINES~NtI ~....a ~ !!I3S"'NO .D.10 .u S1o.NOWIROCKI .().10.0 A4113SANO BOIL1Yl'Ih n''''''' SOILDI~IJI'll.~DHOYNATURAL. EXOTIC INFEST" noN LevELS EO. ~AREAL COVl!R....Q!. E1.1""'2Ii'%ARIEAl.COVI!RAIIE lE2. 2e"11rWfoAAEAL l;OYERAO! E3 _ ~1.".1S"""""EAL COVeRAGE f!.4 .1"","1~AREALCOVeRAQl!; SUR.....CE WATBII: JUl'IlSDICTICJNAL VB NO. NlA.!!..._.__ OI11lRMlNATlON ..1I..am:tIU____ ~...._-,,-- .":",,,,~~"'II'.... ''''_.".....~''''''','''.~~".....,.,:..:;::''l''_~~'<........~.,v".._:..:",=~''..........~'...' ,,,..;,<<:,,.w......,,...,,,u.. 4OUlTlONAl_0: L:illI _. " . 0.: 19.&JAL. I'\ooc:.UOI w,,, F\.tx;CS COOl! 4111 OTHI!JII PI"' Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 153 of 167 DEPfWM) WETLANDS DETER18NATION FIELD WORK SHEET _MlCI:!AI!l. II. RAMIg~MSliY r4C CL,Elfl. .LL.A.CK" VEATCH 1"."01", RCHC. IROAOCA.ST..O !1 _ ffiOl"l:RTY\.EGM. PIDOlM06I_IMOCMWIROAD JURISDICTIONAL wii~ - - orrcHUPREaNT: 1Iln:>eS.9E'IV'{Ci.IILCA'!UXIIft'P'OOn15.W. 'I\~_IoI;lfW'n>>GlI,IIU'f""".I1.ASOICTIOON.lt.coo.a '....,_ _,,_ OI,Dl'IlOntClllCUll/'lO"'Y(lCarHiJlt~AClMI'OCJC1.INNQTI€lJlt OPtMlIOI~1'\H;1UIl OITCIO_JlJ'tP$(ltCllaw.lILc.o\a:~.,Arf[tT_..eIow"lSflt. "'ot~S"""-'d'\Ilaoll"'~"'''oINlAII:_O_la'(7_IO~Of_ VEGETATION: wEl'LNI) CANOPY W.. ~"AC ~"'INl,.6ELLOTTIVDfooM1F) .4........~S...lIAL,.ALMETTO(Pt "~Cf:l'ltFERAfJ'J -"'SCHINJIT!IU:IlIHTHII'O'.IUllfl'l -'Il,MIil,f.l.~uc::...()UJNOUENlI'lVl"'iI"l =""ACACIA,I,l.fIICI.LIFOIUoEGl11 SUICANOP'f' If A ~I'AC 1~ 'll.PINU5 ~u.om V DENSAtrl 4'JC.SAlIAlPAl.MIl1'TO(F) -,.WYlIIICACERlF&AAll'/ -'ll.SCI-GNIJ6TE11EBtHllft,-ouU$(F) -...ME1..,I,lEiUCAQUINQlENERYI"'(lI1 -- 'lIoSERENOA RIpt'N$(I'] -'llo~ICAS...UAE""1 -..........$lNl!OOIANENS"__....-..~1'l "-"'OIOSPT'IOSWIOI_II'1 --""f:l.Ii3CNACUMlN(P'1 -1l;...CACIA...LflICU..lFOIIMl!S(F) -. '''' OFlOUNOCOYI!Fl If" 'lloFAC lY. ""PI1'fJI5lLOnl II IlEhI8I\lf'l :!.-'ll.SA_PA\.MI!.TTOIFl :!L-'lIoM'lR!CACI!"',lUo(fl _%'Cl-lINU6TEREBIM'HlI'O\.IUS(f) 5-101l;NlfL.Al.lUOAOUI~YIA(F) J!:!t"'SEJlIiNOA".~ "'ICAI.I~ HlL'll.M'I'FUI'NIQUlANENSI8__.........~Fl ~DIOllPYROl5I\/I~INI_!tIl1l'1 ='I\.EOOENlACIJMINI11'1 ....1\C~ClAAI.-"lC\A."QII~ 1:lL.'Il...~'llAQlNICt.61f'l .!t;B.'llo~""li1TltlAllTllIOTA(J'l _""~llONOPU5S"I'J .!:!!....'I\.IACCIWIlSHAl.M1FOLIA(Fl _'IIo.IOllNl~ILOBA{F) "'BlUI~""1l'1 ='Il.DlOlTAAIA't,llOTINA(f1 _'110 DlO.'K".OREA......II'eRA(F1) _'I\.fl'lAOl\OBTIlIlIP lI'J "" ERIGmOHQLl!AOlFOLIUS If} ='Il.ERVNlIIUMMl.t/WlNlIIFl ~_'I\.EUP"'TOIIIUM$l"\1'j _'lI.EUTftoIM_Sl"lPl _'Il.FIMlJRIIIT"llJSISIPA~IF) 'IIoI'OfleSflI!MSEBRlGAlll(f'l -- 'Il.ILEXOPACA V~ACA(FJ -=1i.tlolPPATAO'l'UftoDR!Cr\[f'?COOONI 'Il. LAC.-rnHQCAAOLI~lfl ="'~'l'QNIAI'ERAl.K)Ir.eAIF) 'llo~OOflCIiQlIIIFOllAfFl -'llo~SQAN)fNStl"l liii'llopIfVl.ASI'[f') !!!::'ll.P8VCl<lTP;IAS~.Cl'J 'Il."l.8UBSI'II'l -'lloSAM800USCNlllDel\lllIIl(1') ~%SESBAMA8I'CI'I ~'l'oSl!!TI!fIII_GEHIC~..TA(Fl ~~~%SMlLAXSI'lI'l :INO'lI.TQ)(ICOD~iIIADICA"64FJ .!:.1IL'lI.\/Il1SIlOTLNDIFOI.IAfI") 'lloWl!!Dl!!U_TRlO8ATA HYDROLOGtC INDICATORS: uu ALGAL MIlTS WA11!RIMRj($ =AUl'WUCH5 flAnlNGOI' DURIS SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: Ird_' ;:=='e':_ FIC_ M~ndklotodi>' "5 Sltll'lllllM:lL""'II ....Orgaric~ AT 5cmM.,Uqru...... S4S*""'YC>>-l'MI..... S5SordrA.dtt. ,,-- S7~"""". F~lo....O/IlYMl"" F!OepooI$d_' FI31..1mb1lc"""_ OI!~D - ..w -, -, .-.. "s Y!S.!L. NO NO~"II'I4. NI'" ,0 VO NO fUNCTIONAl. N1A Xi"V!S ....-,.0- .nJAIRDICTDNAL' SURFACE wATut 1lDlCAT0000nllATA: (lIWW:T1:_YIlCllfTAnDHHdTOH10'l.0fIMONOI'APUlCovalUoOl . . -' . . I'ACW QU(1lCu&~Al,IIN'OLIA(FW) ~JlI'I\.IaRLM;f'WJ CUTIIH.AEVIQ,O.TA , ..... 'Il. TAXODI!JMDISTlCHlUMlOl .... PERBEAP.l.\.LIliMlS_1I10l % ILUCASSllEtol "4 MlLI_CAROCI"'NfIIOI ....,.''''IlIHUSC~LINlANA(O) ,,_~!i" .2!.'!:!..-~.__,..u , . . . . -' '~Il! OUt. I,Sl..Al,IllFOLIAtrWl ACf;flRIJII~ OI!lTISlAEVIQATA. CQRM,lS FOEIoIIHA IFW) ...,ATOftaTMTA: atU\lGTlfIZJIlO VlGUATJOM_TQ .lllI'lloOJl....OI' MllALeGVlIIIAQII -. ~I .. . < d . --. . .' 00' TAllQDllMDlSTI()H~ PlfI$IAJOALUSTRlS_IO) lLEXGMBINlilOl 8AU:.l CAFlOl.waIOI PfIAIllNJll CAACUfIlIANAtQl Cli:f'HALANTHU!lOCClDENTAUS(OI ....... . . . _~L'" d . -'. --. < . . < ... . ;MO'llo -'.'llo . . . --. -. < -. . . . . '-. . . --. . . . . . . . . ,... QlA:f\CIAoL.AUJllfQ.IAlfWt ~'''-- GOfIHUSF(Je""""'IFWl Ml'H1CAFlPtNMl..H.fNlll!P'lGAMUMIFWI Ill.ltMtIMlISIfIU"ll CEHTELLAASlATI0A1FW) C>Ifl'l'$OIIALANL8ICACO(PW) CtIllll\Jlol~ALLI(FWI c:,QW,4EI.lNASl"(I'W) (l(J,II()()AftPUSER!CTLBIFWl COIlIKlP9lISPI'W) cY1'1!IW&UOULNlI$fl'Wl GYI'IOI\.$OOCll'lATUll(J'W} DICH'lOlllENACCLOfI\ATA1FW) D1ODlAV1JIQlf\II..,.,[f'W) JU$'I'ACHY&Gi.A~/f'W} I'1l,1lAlSTYLI&JJoM.II.t'WI Q~EDml",TRIAOANTHO&\FW) HELlAHTKJSSPll'Wl HVDJlQOO'N\..ESP(l'Wl Hl'P'EflIC\.NSI'(PW1 1ffPTlS.o\I.I.TAlI'Wl JUHCUS~fUll(PWl LACHNOCN.I.CII\IISP1I1OOSOTT~OII'WI L1t.11EI'ItIAGfWOFLOIlACl'WI ~AHrf1l!AAHA.!lTATAlJ'WJ PAHlCUMRlI'tHI~ PM!"ALI,NLlGlA.AIll8!l'W1 PLUCHEAl!II'(l'WJ ft1I!XlASP11'Wl ALlt.EXVERTlC1Ll.ATUS lI'W) 9CL.I'I....8J'lfWl BOUP.olGOlP'W1 SP~TIHAIAIlEAI(FW) THELVPTl:fllt~(rw)$HELllFERN WOODwAIlOIA VIRGIf\IICA lFWl v r;:..o FERN lIVf1ISCAJlI1/NAllAIPWI NllCATOliISTMTk l:~tIlllZlNCllVllMlTA'T1ONtWrTO.t:'",ORlHJlIlIorlllllllU.CO'YMACII _ClIt.- VES VES ~_ NO 0IllIr. ~ NO XX . . . < . -' . . . < . . . . . . . =. . . -. . '--'1\. . . . -. . . .... TAltODILIolOIITICHl.Al(Oj PERSIAPALLl!ITRIS_1Ol lLEIlC....lllNl!(Ul SAUltCAAOl.loIIo*lOl PAAlfINUSCAAClINlANA(OI CI~ClCClOIN'fAl!S(Ol ~lIL.ABl'IAlOJ """"''''' Gl.olOIWJAAlAlCENSE(Ql OlCflflOMINAU.TIFOU,,(Ol ELEOCHAAl'''''lOl EJlIOOAlUJHBf'lP"'!WOfl1ll11CM"Wl FUll'IlNtoSCtflf'ODliAIOl JI..INOUllSP.lO) LI.()WjQlAsPlOJ Ll'TIfIIWSP(Oj ...........'" III.H.ENnRQIAOAPILLLARIIIO) PANlCUilI'lEMlTOUON(Ol Jl'QI.TaoN.N3f'lOI POHTEOE,,"^(lON)ATA(Ol PROllEIIPI/'lACA$P'lOl _lOI SAOIrrfoRfAlN<:ll'OUAJO) lll!TARlAaMf3N',.[Ol TM.It".ENlOllAT"'(O) ,,,..,,.."" ...... '\I.ALllIZIAJIJI.IPIS&tH 'Il.llJR$l!fIJISIUAAUaAIUl_lMIO ....OUII'1CUSVII'IIlIMNAlPl,I) Q* AOVENTlT0t.6IlOOTS -JofYPeI'l1AOl'ItCLENtICU ACT1VllCW'AQIilltN;E8 FLOWCHoVN::15 Irclgj"*"'W_b.....""..._SU..IIiIloJ""""""...~___ IIJ(lI..4TED YA NO"'A lOL,-=---- Q., SlJ""ACEW"'TERpf!!S1!HT AOUATlCl.06SI&1.lVeIllWORTS -~IP'TLINI!S "'EQETATEOf1J8~ !LEVATEOL!CI1IHUHfS ...... %......IZlAMIBAIIl$IN -'lloBl.RllERASlWIlt8AM_l_ -%oAIlICuaVIROINIloNPo(flJ) -"'RH\J$COMlLIMAtM - JlNO"'Uf'L 'lloALl!WAJULllIRlS$IN -'lloAMlll106lAARRUI$lll'OLlAr\Jl ""isuII5oE","~_ALJIIAIl;J_"" -'II.c.r.LuCNIP~.wEfIfCANO\lUl -~'Il.CEN;;",IJ$IUtM -"'CYNXlONDI<CTV1..OHM_1 -'II.DACfVl.I$Ql.OAoIEflAT~M -- 'IloDAC'NLOCTlMUMAEaypnl.MM_ -'lloDl!8MOOIWBPtUl -'II. 11,.11I OiLABfIA(IJl ='II.LAN1'ANAlFU) "Olt......$STIllCTA(LII -"PANCLUw.u.MJMlUl_ -"'PA"'AWolItOTA1LNlUl -"'PILl>>LII'HISRIGIDoIll\.l} --"PIT'l'OPII'~GfU,MI..mtJ~(UI L""PTEAlOIlAlGl.1l0lTSOHIUlllUCl<fflON 'lI.P1'I!IlIOCALl..QHI"I'CNOlITAGMNM "'-'l(,0I..IlPCIJS0lW0WI1(UJ -"Ol.l&AC~vIMIW.NAlIJ) -'II.......OOJ'ALL.lN.NfUJ =:'II.IUtWClHl!LYIlIUIllRIP2PC!lM_..._ JI::t!l 'll.5P1IWMOOOEBP, IUl _ %.IRNOT.vHI'ItlflISEClNJATLUlUJ......_ M!......UfIeJt'I.08o\TAM ~",IL\MQIIOI,ICl """ ~CTliD STATE,OI'I'1.: Da". SIfWMD WETLAND VIES NO .!.JL AQUI'-Y1r;:PL.ANTS IIUIoHILINl) HVD1'lOl.OQICOA1'A $EDlMEHTDVOSlTlON =ACUA1'IC''''1..tlA IOL~ 1m """R LSA/olPU!'1 .H.o Of L(A~"I1'TEA .n.2,5 A 1lI1SNlD .5.50 II r.lATAI_:l!JISAICI t.IOn~ES:9I2SANll !.D.ll.o E2 YA1MIX:l!J4flANO MOnl..l1s,e/2SAND ~, "" m ~, ~, ~, ~, '" ". VIIS Ll!.. '" ~, '" ". '" '" '" '" '" NO _u...,..... ofIool:llWl'Illlll3o,!wMc'--l OlllSlwlnr wrt_ ~_..",...._8'__.dII~__lIa...8lI..........C"""""201.....tIJIIlr4IDo....lt.\II$l,lll.... NO_I..,...GI_........"'5"'_..~_4.....""_ NO ~311Qlll__ PK'i-llII\iro;l""'\IllIl"S-;I.""'."I'I""'I'WI-"'~~ _..........., ",,:.....IDr~1o """" NO :l'%.Df........O.I.'_~_III1&P11""".;;6......-=. NO-,~.~rallr....... NO=~\IO'll''''''WIlloI:~ell'll.''''''''oll.''''''eln<lllDo'kIll&I NO ."""eln"'IVII......I.._4"'_a...m_wBlnl...._lnc""'....~ NO=UlPlllld_..-.fl'.I".,<i...:lll'llogl_. NO_..'""4.lNc~.IiIlIlI9"""rg!"""If"........3orltn..lYOm'fII'_:T1l%lI!Itdt.o"..nlb)I"""....,m- NO ._~.\IIIl'td"'....~oc:cupioI.801loGr__or.I_~_lr"'..__ NO_ '-..._''''''''~",..u.t....1IlnIo0l_..nv....1Dl_.-.ro....,,10''OIIlUll... NO_on""""_~OIlrUlnMr1o~.~.....6.\I'W;;I<--.,'fIIln""""'e.__3"'1.....l:ff\I"'.,or... NO.!!..A"EALElITEHTc.t.~I?L;lr)dr\GIl<I..;~ 1fJ.IS!.... ""EAL EltTE.HHJIlI.. ,.AOW ~~ DO'I'.l-"I.AN) 1...."'"'9 FAC) NOD,~$OlL$ NOLi-IIllralollY"",,l\jdI'csolt "''''- WET.....ND: ,lURI9DICTONAl PETERMfUt-TDN UPLAND 'fE8 ~ NO ".i"iI'M....,."'-....."..-:",......."....,__"'."..~""'",.,..".,.,~ SURFACE WATiA: ,lURIiDICT~ DIiT&RMt<lATIOH .... ."-,,,,-,..,<<-p.",.~, .",..~"",,-<-,' NO NlA.~__ ..0>......-......".___ ___..100..11I....101I.__ ,;.X__"IQ;.~I*""~1t ,,"=,,,,.,.h~.'.;,>' ,'"~.-.:;-M''''.'-,.''' Agglf'I(\No\~I""D, - ''':J",,:.',~;''''_.;'''''''' YU.. .'-'_..'.""'~..'.'- ND~;;;-lcr-' EllOTIO INFEST "TON LEV&L8 I!O. O%AAEAL COV&llAGEl; E1 .1%-Z1~.f.REAL COYw!R.IQI: E2 . :zn..5O% AREAL COVERAGE Q-5,,,,,1nARIiALCOvY"'aE f" .1~100%.f.AUL COVERAGe -~,'-'-- 8OILS_Lin .$...,.0 Of LEAFtlTrlfIl .O.J.ll " 1II11lAND :Jr.lFSMlDSTflEAMS o.!Jl WlTIlIX,SIl!SAND IlCITll.ES:II2SNoIl $Jl-IJl E2 ~TIlIX:6I2SAI<<I I.IOrrL&S:8I2SAM:! 501LTYJ'"!.: 14 PHfDA (HI " . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 154 of 167 DEPfWM) WETLANDS DETERMINATION FIELD WORK SHEET _0.... ~.URL "-_ "ICHAB- fl. .....MlIf,'(J!!..MSeY He Cl.llo;1': BLACK & VIEAT(;!U.....,.. Dt".1!!.!!OA IIlOADCAantQ MO.PFU;CCSCODE !_~D8TU"'BI!DLANO ._.._.--!O~~._~._ "I'I(JPtRTYc.f.l:W.: f"II)OO40S'-lI!I!!I.-!!!!!P".'!"J!JIOAD 310 DAY PRA" DnCMflI; PM!RHT; PlICHI:S.vl:A!IKClAl.Co\~,o,.M~ T11iV_N:lf_IVII'Ol,IuT"""J_CIIO<W.-IIIlCALM...y&"i1KY_lIW""'O,..~.IHlllOVl!l<IonM~..-ISACTM:~~R llI't....tIQ'ICflf'...flCf<. Dllt:~_......'WCl>(Nt.l.IGCo\..._Y_.G1l1l.ft'l\CIi....1Ult.SIDt~IlAIE.'......,all'!tt:K"'IlH)~~fflCN1Ol'0'-TO'fOl'.:s- VEGETATION: "'""'" CANOPY ,..... ""40 .....IN,ISfUQnlvOE~') -'!'.Il~IJAl.P"'.Ml!"OII'I =% MVRKl,lCERIFIl'AA(P') "-SCHlNJllTEREII1NTt\lI'Ol.lU5{l'1 -... ~t..ALEUCAOOINOl.E/IoEAVI.l'l =-=..."c,""ClAIIVl'!rcu..1FooMES(f) SUICANOP'V If" ",,1oC ..PINU8E"LOnlV~~ ==",$A5AL PWlETTOlI"t _,~.~"'~Ic.-.ClftlJlAA\l') 'lIollCHlNJ5TEFU:III",""I'(lI..I1J$IF) ='YoUl!U1U!UCAQUI~lEHlAVI"l"1 _%5~R..NO.loIIII!PENS{F) %FICIo8"'1JIU!"l"J -'-'-''''~INEGI,II\JCNSlS,_''''''''>AI\l'J - 'lloDIOIlP'fA08VllICltNANoIIlfl -,.r.L.GeNACl..NlNl{Fl -"lI,.ACACIAMI\IeU,JfOfU.ES(F) ~ a.ROUNDCOVEA It'A ""file _.",'tNUSELLOTTI'Iom5All'I 'l.SAII.....,.ALt.ETTOfFl _"IoIoMlICACEIUFERA(F) 'lloS(:lollNJ$1'l!I'IE8INTHlFOl.ILSl"I -'ll.MEl....LEUG4OU1NOl,ENE"...IA(F1 -'lloS:EfIE~REPINS(lfl -<4FICASAVM:"'''1 -'lI.r.Ml8INEClUAf\lt/l6IS,_0IJ0CI0T'l(l') ~~ - '!l.DIOSPVROSVlFlGtNI~ If} -%llXIIUUC\JAINI1Fl - '!l....CAC'" .o.uJIIU::U.IFORWEB(Fl ij)..jO'lIo-'NOFIOf"OOONVI.."N1ctJB(Fl BL'lI.~ISTIDASTRICf"'lFl .....XCWOl"\.8P{l'} :::='lI.iACCKlIIIIl$HALMlFOLI"'lF} J!b1I.'lI.8to1iHS..IL.QSo\'1 ___'lI.BI.IIE~I...rr) 'lI,DfBlTARl...SEfIOTllUll") -,.plO$COIIIl!A!t)I.BlFEAA(F7) - % EIlAGAOSTI$.'~ Ifl '--'lIoERlIlERONOl.EflCI~H,IS(P} ~-'lI.I!.IIt'Yl6IMII,It,LOWIMlIYl -'lI.luP...TOI'Ilur.iUIF} =:'11. EUfM,It,NIASPII'l %Flt.IIRISrYtl$sPATH,It,CEJ.(F) -.,.fOllESTIERAIiGlltGATACI'} - ,,1lJ!XOPACA VOP"-C"fI'1 -%IMPIiRAT...cYLOOPllC"'lF?COlJOllIl -=='Il.~ICA1tOUAHA(f} . 'lioLYOM"'FERftl.IlJII'E...~ -"" ".~COHt...COPlOHORIFOLI...l"l -='lI.MlK.UII...~NSlF} 2(I..tt,"PHV!.A5Pl") w"'lI.PSV(:HOTRlASP.(Fj =:,.PlL8USIll'P'l 'lI.5_UOU!lct.Nl.OENSlSIfl .L-'lI.SI!SBANlASP(F} 5-JL'lI.SIT!.PllAGt;IiICULAT"'lFl ~'lI.StMLAXSPIFl D::J!!. ,. lOXlCOD!.NORON AADIC"'HS(f] ~a_%VlTIlfl;(JTtHlI'OLI,It,(F} 'lI.WEDE.LI...TRLou.TA HYDROLOGIC INDICATORS: !\I.G.'lLWors WATERWJlK8 -- -RAFTlrCOFOE8AI9 SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: --. M_P"AI'I;" fSTlI/:IlOllllS..._ FlOMlfot """HJdrolil"l-- A~ i>b"IfIrIilI<lLI\VflIf; AtiOlgancllockl "t!.cmIUllyMrlIlII s.~~_ S!~RMla~ 5IlS\tlppld_. S7OPIW1_ F2LDwnG~lIIIIII' fJOopNl8ll~ F13~__. ........ ~, .- c_: ....., -- YU_NO -!:!..Sf.11'Ilt4 NI...q Vl!1II_ NO _. FUNCTIClNJ4. HIA xx YES HO JUflISOI:TIDNAl' llUAUt'..Ii WATEA YES___NO A NIlCAI"OR.lTMTA: ctWIACTlJOItG VllIIlTATICMtKM TO I" Ih, OIlMOICOf AJiIaIt. COVflWM , "Ao ~ACW .. OUl!II.CUSI..AUlIFOlIAl~1 -...ACfFll'll)ll.lll.JWlFW) ___... CELfl5l,loWlCl/IlTA .91""' o 'Ilo OBL 'Il. lAl1ODlUUOISTlCHUMlOl ~ PtR$P.PA~i,IlTAIa_!Ol -OC'Il.EIlCA6ll....I(OI ---.... SA~IIlCAAOlIANAlO) 'lI,'AAAlNUllQl,RO\.INI_lOl ~ NlICAT"OIIITMTA; ~VECllTIU1OHIUllITO'11(l'l1.0JlIIOIlli0l''''IUI.CO'II.''''''' o 'lI, . -. -. --. ~Aew OUEACl.lSLAlIIUtQl.IA(I'W) M:f.II.IUJBPI~ CELTISLA'VIQAT... CORNJSroI1,IINAllfW} , . . . -. -. -' . om. TAltOOIUMDI5TICI't~ PEII.BEAPALUSTAl:S_",(O) IU!XCol$$INflO) SALlXCAfIOlI_<Ol 'AAXlNJIlCAAOlffoltAlUllOt C~PHAl..NllTHUSDCCIDENT""'I$IO) YES YES Q!.t4'!.. 111-20% . . . I:-IL"" . . . -. . -. . -. "",. -. -. . . . . . . ==.. . =. . . -. -. . -' . -. -'-'llo . -. . . 'KW tu:IlCUSI..AUlIPOL"'IFW) ACl!!1I.Rl.BAU1l<<FWl COl'INJllRlE~fFWl .....H1CARPUMIoILIH..EIoIIIEAtWlU..fl'W1 I!l.ECM!'diISEIIlUJI1-16 CENTELlA...."'''CAll'W)- Ct<<tSOMl>>IJlilCACO(FW) ClRBIIM -.rrrAUllFWI ~8PtrNl CQHO(IAIIlI'L8Ef1ECTUI(F'IfI 00I'I1OI'81S8P(f'Wl C'fPEAU9L~FW) ~US()l)(lR,f,1U1Io(I'Wl DIC~COLOFlAT""IFWI OIOl;l!l",vll'OltM/tI.lFWl IUSTA(;Wt$Cll..AlJCA.IFW) FIIolIA'STY\.I$~fI'W1 QLEOlT81"'~~ "'LIAN'fIU;SPII'WI ffI'tllIOC01'YI.ESP(fW) H't'I'EIlICl"""SPf1W1 tflf'TISMAT...(fW) .,lJNCI"Ij;MAAClMTlB(FW) lACl'NXlo\U..ONSptB008UTTONIlOVWl llN:l~RNIA QfW()1'1..ClAA FWI MElANfi'EAAHoI.$TATAlP'Wl PAIfOUMIlEPIiHS(f'W) P.r.$PALUMlIGU.AFl18(FW) PLUCHEA8PIPWI PlI-Elll",SPlFWI 1luutJ<.~CllLAT1JSlFW) SCl.IAIA$P<I'W) SOLIDAGO 1l'WJ SP,v\TiftIllNC,PlI!I'W) TI"IEl."'TEA188P(FWlI/MBLDPEI'IN wOOOW"RDIA VIAGINlQl, (fW1 V CI*I "All X'tAIBCAAOI.INllNIIl'W) ..-::ATOIlSTIU.TA: C....'VCUII2IlGYIIlInATIDMtwr.T08ll\l"loOftMOMOf'AlJUl.COftMOl 01"", , ."" 'llo.....alZl...JULI8FUSSp.j = % BURSlPlA SIMAIIlUBA (lJ)w.ol_ ___,,..QUEflCUSVIROINIIlNAlP'lll _,,9'!'!It.- QlhII _ ~.. NO lQL ADVENlrfOlJ9ROOn I'IVI"EATROf'HICLtiNTIClLS ACTlVECVPPlBIIKHEE8 FL.OWC_ElS NO 1I'"......~W.8tI_~....""__&.:Ioo'..nc:JuclgII..It,~~btIow:_ 1&Ol..iIlTI.1I Yl!1 JOOXlt ""A ...... . -. -. . . . -' . ~..~,. -' . . . -. -' . . -' . . . -. =. . . -. -. .... TAXOOIUM!;llI!iTICItiVWlOl P!'IUIVl P...lUSTFllS-",,,, lOl '~"Aew;.;.I..EM $A&.IX(lAIIIOl1Ntt.(()! rnAXlNUllCAAOLINIANoI.\OI CEPIW.A~OCCtOEtnAlIS(O) ,It,NNO......OlAllflAlO) &iIlCOPAfOl ClADM.NJAtolAl(;IN$J!(D) OICHl'lOM'IUlLATlFOlJol(Q) i~I~$8'!O\ ERlOCAU.ON~"'EWOATS) j(WW) f\JIR~SCIRI'CIInAIOl JI.H:lUSSl'.(O) llOWJOlASP(O) lvTt41I,NSPI01 H'I'IIIPWolollSPlOl wtLENIIEAQ",,<:AI'1I.U_A'US (0) ..AHlOt,lolH:I.ITOMJNIOl PO\..'\'OOM,MSf'lO! PONTEDEAlACOIlDATAIOl Pl'IDSeIllPINI\CoI\5P1Ol FlHVI'COSI"OII"'lOI s.-GllTARlillL>>IClfOL"'iOj StiTAAlAlMONf<tDl T*UAGENlC\.I.A1ol (01 ~.IOJ o ""lPl %.....BIZIA.lJI.I~I$$I'" =""llJlIlSl!lIASlMillRUBAM_...o ~_~OUEFIGIJ8V!flGlNI\NAfFUl _'l'IIfJSc:OPAU-II'fJMM "'" SO-oUl...UPL 'lI.......BIZI.....u.llIfll9SIN =:'lIo.......QSlAAflTEMlBl.,OlI...!Ul ;o..UAS....SIIoU<.RUiIA,UI_'..;. =-=,.. CAl~IC""..o\ AWEAIC...Ni'l (lJl lIoCENC..u.ISSI'lUl 1:1L'lIoCI'KXlONOACTYlONM_ _ %(l,olCTY\.ISOLOWElIATAM .!::!!-'lloDACTYI.OC'I1INlWA&l""TIIMM__ _'4OE$WOll1U101SP(\Jl _.,_"'H.lXGl.AIlI\A(U) _...I...olHT~(I'UI _'lI.OXALI!iSTAICT"'IUl _",PANI(;W"",,)(IIoUolM_ ._"'PASPo\UMN)T"TUI.I(Ul _ %PIUJ8I.li.....S RIOIOA tu) _~_ _ % PI"""'8ID I............. QAiIlMNlFOI.l... (Ul ..PTERlOIlA4OlEOITlCI1llJ1_...... -...~PVCN05TACIoM,N(lI) ~-="'~CtWIo'lNIllUl ,.ooeRC1.8Vlf1OlNANA/1.I) :::='lIo -.$COfIALLIH..UM _...RH"l'HOHlLVTRUMR!PEN!l(Ul__ ,2!!:M..'lIoSl'l:RIMCOCI:SP-1Ul _'ll.9TENOT~lJM&lIClNJA'l.IoI(lJ)F\.aIOT*IO j.ig'lloUAEHiIllOllATiIllU\ ~...8AAEGROlJIoV "'" MXJATICPLJoNTG ......"" IoMJIIO~OQJCDATA "'~-Sil)lfolENtOIftO$lTlON '-'.AQlJ,I.TlCFAl.I'liIl II01LDUC~10Tft M""" LSAMPliiU O.ll-6.0 A V,I$A'-ICWIROCK U. AOC~ 1I~i'USAL ". ," '" '" '" '" '" ". '" '" '" '" '" ,,' '" '" '" '" '" fIO .,.. ..,.,.oI.,..p..._301"_c""'m.,Of.........~."""Q NO_lI\<tIll....'.__..d~"'_I~'-&O%_d"''''.~OI"..II...''Gbolowl2''Dl"'"'- NO_I_oI_W...... 01 I lIf_lI1lIftri\I ""'n,(. lll...._ NO _;IOI:IIl__ 1<IO---=-.~.'ll_""'*ti.'l_..,..."'""JIl..~a~"""'....I.'>:~t...,......"" NO l"IoOl"......,1.I...I,OCII/IfIUdIJh'___S"aurl"'" NO - 2"'1.,.t....6'cl""...._ Jor)=\lIt)'MI"'IIIl.wiIhc~.lO'lI.ilO'.....IlI.lolfl'''''''elnotl!llJ...ha NO.". _lIpr"""e..0I......r.I.._I'lr>~a..............su'llo<><_Intm>....2 J<<)_I~.......-,5"1.lnd\llll110'l1001-"1 HO _).,..,....'.tnc:lINI\lngwAn8"ofl.-1_w........3ti1.....ctwo"" llf....;70%~11._IdIll'_f1<~ NO,____gllylOm....~'____lIIl'll.or.......cl..aW\Irov_li.Ollllll.I.Il""" NO_..._."IIido;...Cl_"'_..._lO'lI.lIf'"""'~_ior..._rgotlnIO.ct....... NO .,__a~conc:_JIO........c'I_."dl....~AkII11.....A"lI1ck.'IrffO-lIPlIefli"~J"'_&~_........ HO!!.-AIllAL~XTENlOBL.UPLi '1)IIlIlc....,,~1IIlClIl)' NO !I2l.._AflEAl.ll!'T!NTOBL' FolCW ..110% IJPI,AoND"~ FAa) NOd I.lLlCKSOILS IoI.JU-ItfI"'<l~y"""Ill'drio~. 1oI.J_~_ Oh' SURF,t,Cl!iW...fIPlPRESENT olOUolTlClr.lDSSEllI\.IVI!IIWORTS MIPTllHES vt:OI!T"'TI!OTUSIlOCKMUIlIQCKS ELlEvATIl.bUCHE.IILINES ~CTI.1I"1'-I NOFC_,..A NO HIAXX SOIL~l.IP~E',( 11-2,1) A .tnF1NliSoOND ,04.0 iIlZ ~rJ s.-.ND '.0_1.0 -'J SANOWIf\OCI\S 7.o.l0.C ..... 7I3S"'OO SOll,1"" l'PllEDAlloll ISQILOISTURllEDNOfNATU!l.iI\l STATEOfFl: De SfWMP WETl.AND: WETLAND YES. NO ~ JURISDICTION"'L DETERMIIl...TION UPLAND YU XX NO ..,..___.....,.,.~._..o> ._.,.x."...'-'\".........~_.. _...~._---"',..."'"',<-....~_.....>,.''',,,,."'''''',.. EXOTIC INPSBTATION LliVELS EO.~AREALCOVERAGE Ef. f'llr25%ARUL COVER"'GE 52. 2rJr5(nl....REAL covl!RAOS E3" ln~7G'lI.AREAL COVER"'GI! M .1''''''00'l'. ...REAI-COVERAGE SUA'...CEWATEA: JUFIISDlCTlOHAl DETeRMIN...TION "'" _.,..~----- -~..-._- ~~""".,...~.'l'."""'......,.,...,..'....-..'''''-'- r'....__,~__........',.....,.""~,,,.'I.,;,rl'.----.,.,"'.... ,"l'i,~('l'.~..,'O,';:"". AODinoMAL INI'O: tllIII " ' Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 155 of 167 .P~ 10.a3.ot ""'''FLLCCSCO!ll. DEP/WII) WETLANDS DETERMINATION AELD WORK SHEET ,""-,,,,,,, _MICHAEL R. RAMIIV, A~MSE" we CliENT:8yCK It VlATctl TANN a111. R~D" INtOADCAIT"Q 112tCY".USHfIfPAl!l 1S1 __ . ~QPEATVU;QAL_~~~_I8Ill(;RfW'JtOAO - - JLlR1lll)CTIONAI. WfTl.AND orreMu MISEi'll: OITt.1'U~AlP"~CI.....c.o.1'l'<:lCIlWffJInc:Dt' ~....,. oor....,I'I..AtOI, II\1I"AIt.....SlIlC"aw.lEO.~ 1K~.tJ'E 11I:VN'EDL(I'''IPl\l[a/DHlorN)'''W;lClmeIIrufoOlS.oC1ly(OCH:~nG'' OPli.....llCJlaolr!Hlnat D1.C_..~,/UFt'lllllCT1lN'll.IIE""""" _v~r!upO(:l,wAll:AII ..oc~~~."'., i~'''I~~Tt:(l'l''''OJ'iC>J.IlI;~f_l(I>OF_1On;f'($_ -- .... Y.I_HO.M.._JlWJ. HI/I. D. VB NO fUNCTIONAL. 1'111. XX'fl!lI- NO'~ JUAIBDICTIONAL' SUAFACEWATIiA VEGETATION: c..."'" If" """At J!!::!2......'Nl,$ELLOTfIVOf"l$4I") .:d....-'II.5.........."LIoETIOIf) 'IIoIoMUC"'C'"I"JIlA~ -'''--'lloSCHlI'MlTEfl'''''''H1I'Ol.IUS(fl -''''~LM.EUCAauw:MlNt''VI^t~ -....AC...CI"_ICl..JF~81~ VIi8M-NO _ ~fOftITIIIlTk C~IIIaIDYEQl!T"'TIQflIHAllITOIE1K(lIOIIlOIll0l'4lIM.c;ovIAAQtI G "" 'AC W III-H'" 0Bl "" Ol.EACWlAIJAI'Ol.IAII'WI .1\l;I!'llo lAllOOllJlolOISTlCllllM!Ol '" ACI!JIlRlllRU"lfWl _'110 Pf.Il$lA MlUSTRIS ..-..101 '110 CELTlSLAl!V1GAlA ... l\.fillC'-MIMiPI -~ 'II. SALlXCNlOl.IANA(O! -.....'WClNJllC...AOI.IN"'ICA(O) 9"-' 91'" lIC*;IlTOIIIn'UTAJ. QWIIIlCT__VllI&T.IlfiOllIWlTOHlftOlllIllOfll!G'MIIAl..COVII'IAQI. !RJICANOPY 1OI0 N1'A ..,Ae 10.10 '!I.PlfUl ElLOTTI V DlOOiArF) .!!.-%!lAIlAlP""-I.l!TTClCI'I 'llo......RICIICI!fllR;M(F) -"'IIC1-1!H.>>l'lllll!IIINTHlFOlIUSIFl '.-'IIoMELAlIlJCIlQU!IIIOIJI!NEAVI....CF) - -"""SEftENOARlPINflII'l _n",'ICA&AtJIlEA(FJ -"lI!YAI;IHI!GUlANi.N11IS___..,rrl --'!\OIOSP'It'IOlJ\III'l(II~CF} _._"Ji,l!lOl!N1....CtMM(f1 -:= ""....CAClA .......1C\.I.IFOfM.SI"J """ . % . -. . =. PACW OU&RCLeL.AUIIIlfOLlA(FWJ AC~RRUJAUM.f'w} Cl!LTIIIL.JoEV1GATA ~Jrl.lSFCll!lIIINIi(FWl 10.20... i-l0"'" -. ""-' , ~...-.... . COl. T-"llOOllMOI$TICt1ILM(01 'ERSEAPA\.I,.I$TRI$_..lOl I\IiXCASSIJlfElOj SAllXCAAQLIAN-'{OI FRAXINL&CAROLINI~) CEPHAlANTMl.GOC(XlI!NfAlllIlOl Ol~ ~, 1NDlClItl'000STIUlTAJ. CM'R" ,_waEUTIOIIIlASTOIIE1",0RIIORI~MIUl.~ QROUNDCDVEA "" "",Ae Jl!:It.'lIoP1,..El.LOTTIV PliIlSA(l'1 ~"8A8Al"Al~TTO(Fl d 'll.I.M'IICiIIC.....,I!.I1,AIFl r 'IIoSCHRlS Tl::RUINTH"'OLtU!l(f) !12.-"'~QUIN;lUI""'Vl~ l'.1!...'IIoSlERtNOAIl,EPENll/Fl 'lI.FlCiIIllillUlIIIA(') :f.tl..'IIoll'tR8INEGU......""'18_---TA/lF) 'IIoOlO5PYF1OSVlfI(JI"'iIIHA~ ,..II!UCWlIAClUINIl') 'IIoACACIiIIAl.FIIClLI~5[Pl s:i"iI'II.AI'Il~VlRGIMC~F) .!tiR-'IIoA"'lIlT1DA$Tl'lICt,o,(f) 'IIoAl(QNOPUlIBf'CfI} .!:lL'IIo~aH"UllfOLIAI'" ""SIDINl"lLOSA.{f1 ___'lI.SLAELIiII(I'"J -.'IIoDlCllTAI'l/ASEAOTItu.(PJ ""DlO$CO'II!AElt.UI.IAA('~ -"EMaROITI$ $'If) -~",I!IIIIQEl'lONQlERCIl'()LlU$lfl ""'ilWNCllLlolSAlDWINI/F) -"'i!uPATQA.llMS'(Fl -.,.eUTMoUB"lI'J -'IIoFIUllRlSnLIlISPATw.cu.(F) -'IIo1'(llllll!6TIE""SEGAlo..T~ -""JLfll(llPoI,CAVOP'AOA(I'J ---::'llollllPERATACYl.INJ"'CA(F"10000Hj -"'lloLACHtrWmIIi8CAIIOLIANAIf) -..LVONIA'lliIUIUCJINfAlVl -"'MfLCOl1IAOOfICHOfIIFOL....fl'l --:--"'hIIKAN1AaeAAOENJ!Fl ~,"PtM....SPfI'l ~""PS'fCloDT'Ill...$P.(I'"} 'IIoRl.8USSPlFl -="'~....OA~DEH8ISCl'} ... 'IIoltsIAMASPP') -:;r-""SETl!RIAQf:NKlI.l..ATA(F} ~'llo$MILAllM'{F) twlI%TOlCIClODENClRONRAOIC.'INS(fJ a""VITlgAa'1\NlIPOUA(F} "",WEDELtATRlO8ATA HYDROLOGIC INDICATORS: xx ALG.IILw.-.TS ~WATERMloRK!l -AUFWLCI-IS AAFTINOrlOl!1IRIS SOILS: HYDRIC INDICATORS: 1__: M""'*P_.... F6TNt1lu.l<!lul.. FIO",,", M~""lQIIl_ ,o,~st"ilfdloro" ..s o.u...~ 1!kJd... A75c;<n~MnI.. s.6WIIIyGloojWd.... SllS""",,,__ SIls~~, S'tDlfll........ ,1I......Q.~_ F3Pl1.,...,w.lI F'9~""_ ........ ...., ....... ...." -- -- ~.. VES~NO YES M",NO ,...% "'- . . . "-'. "'- . -' s,jL'" . , , . -' "'- . .1P:::IA-'" . -. -' , - -~"" -. , -. -. -, . -. =. . '-. _.~-", -. , , . . . -, _._'lIo 'ACW OUEftCU8LJl,UAlI'OLI~ "C:~RIIl.8A1..lMlFWl OORtfJ$~OE"Mlo(FW1 AM'tiICNlP\,.U M.H...EreEl'IGANIUM fFWl IIlll!OI'N.N8IRRUI.I::!!......-.. ClfIlTf.LLAASlil.TlCo\jl'W) C~1GiIIOOll'W1 CIRSlLlol~,I,lU(1'Wl OOIoIYElI~"'(I'VfJ C:ONOCAf\I'USIIII!ClLS(f'W) OOf\EOf'9IIIIIP/FWl CVJII'II!IIUSllGU..ARlIIII'WI CVPIllliAOOOF\,I\TUll(I'Wl OlOlA:>MlNillcc:LOAAfA(FWI DlOOIAVIAGlNlAMlo(FW} lulTAOHV!IBU.lI:lAlf'WI Fr~ISTVU$AHNlJ,J,lFWI I3LEDITlI/ATRlACAHTH':l61fW) I4!UANTHUSIlPIf'WI M'l'PROCQTYI.E!IP(FW) Ift'l'ERlCUMIlP(l'W} HTPTISALATAjFWI ,/Up,(:t,$w.AalNltTUSIFWI lACHNl;lC.ll.l.ON8Pf8OOI~O"'lCI)Il'W) lIMlEflNIil.Ol'WOII'lDRAjFW) t.El..AHflERAHASTATArMl P...MCl,NIliEPENSlFW) PA8PAUJIoIlltJl.l..NllIS{fWI PllCHEil.llPll'Wl RI1ElU....SPfFWI ~lt\IEATICIUATU& (NIl SCl.I......8PtFW) SOLIClAGO(l'W) SPNlTINA.....,1N1fWI THELT'I'TERIS8P(I'W)5tELDFERN WOOOWAfilDIA V!M1NCA (FW)VOfolFERN ll'\''''8CAROlI~(I'Wl ..... "'- , -' ,,'O'll. "'- . , -.-"" , -, ""-' , , ". , -' OIL' . --''110 . " . =, , . "'- , . , -' COl. TA.llOOlUMDISTlC"'~ PliRM'"P"UJSTRIS_.,(01 ILl:.ll~_1UJ SALJllCAAOlI-'Ol 'R.vr.1NtJSC"'ROl.IHI~1 CEPHAI.AH1"HlJ8 OCCIOEKTAUS (01 ~QV"Rlt.lOI I,I,OOPAlOl C!.ADlUMJAU,o,ICI<NSf/OJ OU;:....Cl'ENA lATIFOLIA (01 E,IOClWWlSPIOl ERlOCAlLQH5f'CI"IPEWORT.ln (OIl'wI FLlRENiIISClRlIOOtAIO) JI,NlUIiiS".lOJ ,lCWlGl,I,PIOI LYTIoAMSPlOl """""'."" lIoIJI1..!NllEAOlACAP\l.U..uUSlOl P....C\.NHtMlTOMlN(Ol """"""'- PONT.I!tlI!iIIIACOROATAlOI PR06I!RI'lPMCASP(Ol RH'11'fCOSPOIIIilllOl SAGtTTA'ItA~ANCll'Ql.lA(Ol $l!TAI'lIAw,al'MflJ) T~1.I.oeMC\A.ATAlOl T'l'PH,I,SP(OI .._~..- ft' ". ". ". ft. '"~ ". '" '"~ ft' .!!i.. ft. "'. ". '" '" lL "'. "- "" 'U ... "'. l<<l_..ol.....cll........'......ct.v....l<11__S....,..., f'lO_.....MlMIlrlNcil""".dIIpioolirll......rn.I.-800l.""""c_20/1......,'llIboolowr1:ror.<OI.,. NO_I_ol.........""....o.._'1I........OI....._ NO ..lIIIn300llfl_ NO -:--lnIlJ1\ro;t......\CIIf.. ~.. 1 M""'... ~~.........?~ _r.lY'''.~' or ~.""''''''~II> ,.""" NO :l%or_li.l.mut"'''-"'"''',.....I._VIIlh.h~__ NO:--......._l'oIl1w.<OI_ NO=~...-....,OOOuplMB~.._.I~iIIl'lIr....'&ln"'1lII....""" NO ..,..""".lrfofMIII__I.Il_.."'noklhD.........en"'-"'_mc....""2 NO=AIJlIMfI__.S..l.on......:10%ol.... NO. ....._..,..._..flIotlIlWIlrQ....'.oI......,........)ot... ~,_ \ orle..,70"4!*1"..'coo.nlb1olll_m..... NO_OlIo)Wd...-'"'"""~.e'""or_OI.'-""..,.....nl,.dhllJll_ HO_....W_ll"1lic1o......,..,.,..._.hII_llOlI."''''''..c.......~...IH._"''_lO"ol_.,. NO.__o._pa_lIli_..._l...p........,...S.\IOdO.WHQrol._I.~3..._ldwmilllo'l_ NO_ARliillLlIltllENT09l.uPl,hjUri:._:~ NO __AREAlEllT&Hf OIIL I ~ADW .a_lJIILANJ!-"'"", FAC) ND.ll M.lCKSOll8 NO-~_II,od*,""" M:/O- ADVENTlTOUlilflOOT6 ~HVPERTROf'ltoClINllCILS .!ll.--"C:TIVECNPAE96KI\MIS FLOW C-..S ""*mirQW__....A.....-SOIJ'IIfIe~...pnnldo!~.___ . lllOLAno YU lID ~ "A COfNiCr"Sii. - '"u WETlAND: .lURl&PlCTIONAl DI!TI!RMlNA TION UPLt.ND ,..-..---..".0<..........."."1 STAT!! OF FL: DEP. SFWMD WETLAND Yd.'g.. "10_ Oh!._ 6URFACEWATERPIllfS!HT -AQUO.,1ICMOSSESlLIVliRWOlllTS ORI"LINU VEOl<TilTEgTU$$OOICSH.JUMOCKli I!.LEVIlTEDLICt'ENLINI!S MD_lL"... va NO XX .. l~ ._,___".....,..,,"~~_."""'~.f"".,,' "..~,,..,......_,.,.,... EXOTIC IMI'UT AnoN ll!VBLI FJ). O%oAREAL CQWRAOE. 1l'.1~AREAl.COVE:""OE ea. 2t""'SO'lloA"EAl COVEM!JE EJ.51%o-7PoAREAlCOVEAAGE e.. 7O"",'OlMIoARIiAI.OOVERACU SURFACE W.."'I!R: .lUA18OlCTIONAL m NO WAY-......___. DE11!:R.......TION ~...______ ~_.._M._ -',."""''',.,,-! ...,,,.":....,,"~,_...""...~.!.".__....#_._,,""....c>!!l.""'~,,,,..~.~',... ADOlTIONtoLINl'O; t!lI -,.,....'"'\"....,'".:.,...~..,...',.,.,.,,_. ...... l\.AL81lJAJUL.IBRIIlSIN '--"!\IIUASERASIMl\l\UBA(Ul_~ =:'''4OUl''IDJSVlflGlNI\NAjFU) ...... "4A1.IIZIAJUUllRlllSIN --.-"481.R!R11U.$lMAAlIlAlUl_~ -''''-QUERCUSV~FLll ="RttlACOPAllIM,Jl,lfUl 01... ao4ll'll.UI'L 'IIoIlLI'IIZ,AJJlIIRIBSIN -"4AM1F1OSI"',l,RTEMlSIIJ1OLt,l,M -","I,,1H1i.EAA';;~M_"-' ="4CALLICAR'AAUl:IlICAH,o,M 'IIoCEN:lIftJS8f'M :="4C'tl<<lOONDACmOrlfi\.ll_ __ "4 OACHLII (lLClWAATAM ... OACNlQCTI"'lM .u!Q't'PTILM M............ =:'IIoCESMODlU~9P(Ul 'IIoILEllGl.AllFWU) -""LANTIlN'FlIl -'IIoOltAlI$STlIlCTAM =="PiIIMCJ,.alWlXMMM_.. '110 PIlSI'AlUMI'IOUTL.MltJ) -'lloPILOBLEPHSRIOlu,o,fU) -..P!NOP$lS_GfWlIIM'OLIAM -"'PTERIDlI.AlOU!DITSCHIUlMOCll_ -'.-... PTEROCALUlH I"fQQTACH'f'UMM -== 'lIo QI.II!lIlC1Jll OHNMNI"Ul _'4Cl11FlMVlMI~ 'IIoIIHlScoPALLIPf..UM -...AIoIYNClleLVfRUMIIIEPlNSM....._ J:Hl."'SPEI'NACOCESP.ll1I "'-STENOT~UMS~Ct.NOATLM(UI.......... o:"10'll.URE~L.OIl,I,TilllUl ~"'II_GROL..W<<J ou., IlClUATICFUH'fS ......".. 1MJII00000COAT,I, ~SI!l*IlHTDEI'091TlOI\I --,I,QUI,TICF..""'" "OQC~ WtR ........ SOILIlAMPl.l!"" O.$.(lJI 01 LEAFLlTTIiR 0.0.2,5 A M8.IlNO .!i&:D E IMITR1;1.:lIlllN&l IolCI'ITlES:IlI2S-"'ID ,~'11.0 E2 MATRlll,liilSAJ'C) KrrTl.ES:MS"'NO IlSfoW'lt.n 0.5.0.0 01 LEIl'LITTER tJ.3.0 A llf1l>AND 3I.2FSANDS1'JI!il.KS 3.0.5.0 E ~TRIX:Ms.-~ ~LEs:ens~ .Il9.o to2 .LIiIITAlll,II2SiUCl ~1'I.!S:8/l!SN.O SOIL T'Il'E; 14PNE~ll1l N180CA '. . Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 156 of 167 Sample Point 1 74082128145 Black & Veatch Tempe 011; Rende Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 1 ........ _n" "......._...,..,.,. , ''-~'.~_'~' .~_',-'T~;'-_'_" '~"'''''''''''''',.'". . Project Name: Black & Veatch Tampa 011 Date: 10(07/2008 , Sample Point Number: 1 County: Collier ,Investigators: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC, Roll No: 7408212/ I Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? Lat./Long.: . No Is the site signijicantly disturbed (Atypical Situation)? North: 25' 39' 48" t No~ _I~,~_h: sil(l ~_p~!~n~~~,,~.':oblem~!~2__ ___~~__~ __ __~,~~~_._n_=_Y"e~t~ 80' 5T_1r;~_-~~ -- ~"~- VEGETATION I No. - Scientific Ne;e , i1-i SPERMACOCE FLORI6ANA i 2 I URENA LOBATA--- i31 ANDROPOGON VIRGINICUSn n__'_ ~ 4! VITIS ROTUND~~OLlA ._ __ _ . i i._ ______ L__: ------ .--.--- I. L__ n -- .------- i I ~i--I-- - T----==-:...------- _.1 Time: State: FL Photo No: Datum: NAD83 Indicator Pe-icent Strata Status Cover ", 1 UPL 7,00! Yes ,FACU3 .7.~_Yes FAC- 15_00 1 Yes FAC_~:OO 1 Yes- - 1 ..1 ' _=_J I _._ ; ._ _____. 1__..1...... n--.-J I __..__.._.L I ___~=-#= . 4=< __ --r----=E ----r==.J 'DOmlnent Sptlcles 'Herb .----;-Herb -- .---.-. : Herb il-ieib I i Total Number of Species: 4 Total Dominants: 4 : Percent of Dominants that are Wetland Species: 50/20: 50.00 I Lre~al~nce Ind~x: 3.58__=~~___ .___. HYDROLOGY II Recorded Data:' . 1_ Stream, Lake, or Tide Gauge _ Aerial Photographs Other X No Recorded Data Available FAc(mlnus)- applied: 25.00 FAC Neutral: No Ii .1 JI .,-'~ Fieid Observations: Depth of Surface Water: Depth to Free Water in Pit; Depth to Saturated Soil: ___(in.) (in.) (in.) Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary Indicators: ___ Inundated __ Saturated in Upper 12 inches __ Water Marks __ Drift Lines __ Sediment Deposits Drainage Patterns in Wellands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): Oxidized Root Channeis in Upper 12 inches 'I Water-Stained Leaves i --~~ Local Soil Survey Data i FAC.Neutral Test ~.~ O~~':':_(E><plaln in RelT1~k~) "-----.. _._-~----_.,' . ------.-. . .....-.-.---.; Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 157 of 167 Sample Point 1 74082128145 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Randa Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 2 SOILS . Map Unit Name: #21 BOCA DISTURBED' - - '-Drainage Class: '(Series and Phase): Field Observations Ta~~n_o.my (~u~roup): ____ __n_____C~nflrm~apped T)'Pe? No ____ ____~ pr~~~t~~!l.CrIPtiO?'-MatrixColor " Te~t;;;;;~60~c;etions,---" Redox Feature ,Redox Color-- -~, ii~~c~.~~~ ;:z !(M~~~~~~Oi~!___ -s~~~~~:y-- _ __-.Al!unda.!'c~/<:;ontra.sl_ , (Munsell MOlst)~i it- 6_dR6C-;-'A---<- -"1OYF!l --"'t-----m--S~.. ------r-- -------:---- - -~I '- _~".. J_ -_--4. ______ ____ .. ~---.- -- ~ -. . I :i . : i i !: i t~+--f- -1- ----~~~-~=t=-~~~ 11_.___1- I ____.-- ' ___~___-L-___ .. .,jl " ,; I i I I ,r--- +---+-- ----t- .------<---- . . --+----~' ii' : ...j-------I -- .--)--- . I :: Hydnc SOli Indicators: I' Hlstosoi Concretions I ,I -Histic Eplpedon -- High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Solis 'I' Ii -Sulfidic Odor - -- Organic Streaking In Sandy Soils II == Aquic Moisture Regime Listed on Local Hydric Soils List ' ,I _ Reducing Conditions Listed on National Hydric Soils List II 1'1_ - - Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors Organic Pan 'I' I NRGS Field Indicators: __ _Other (Explain in Remarks) [, !~-'-"'-_::=:-- . ----:C'7"-=--,,---=--=--,-- . ____----'-===--. _ . .. __. J WETLAND DETERMINATION ~ Is this Sampling Point Within a Wetland? ~I! No Is this Sampling Point a Waters of the US? I No . Have the ~e~erlT1inatio~_re~ults b~en _~verri~en by the user? J :1'-- . NC!.. HydrophYti~ Vegetati~ Present? . No Wetland Hydrology Present? l:~()- ~YdriCSoils_present~_ _ . REMARKS -- -- ;1 Ii 11 II I: ----. .---- _~__n " ,. ~=_,,"~il ] Wetland Yes X No WoUS Yes X No 4 Species Richness Prevalence Index 3_58 !\g(,nda Itm" No. 78 February 23, 2010 Page 158 of 167 Sample Point 2 419 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 3 Project Name: Black&Vea~i~htampaOT1 Sample Point Number: 2 Investigators: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC. i Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? ',:f',JO Is the site significantly disturbed (Atypical Situation)? 'U'!Q,,,~~~~~~t~~a P~~l'~~:~~bl:~_~,::~~~__~c~ VEGETATION Dat;;: 10107'/2008" County: Collier Roll No: 419 Lat./Long.: NOl1h: 25. 39' 48" West: 80'57' 17" Time: State: FL Photo No: Datum: NAD83 :! .. .. ..__'__ "..._"'",.___m_.____._____ _.._._-_._._--_._-~----_...~-------- ----- I No. Scientific Name Strata Indicator Percent Dominant' .~~~__ ~~_~_ Status Cover Species _ J It ~f~~g~~~~~:,:~o=":~===: ,~:~~! ~~gw 3~:~~ ~ ~~s I~:-{~j ~~~~t~~~r,4o ~~--"---:-===-~-~- ,~~~~ i :~gw ~_1;:~~ I ~~s-~ I 5 i ILEX CASSINE ' Herb I FACW I ~-.. 2.00-r Nn 1 ! 6iSPERMACOCEFLORIDANA --~------- !Herb fUPl ~-r-25.00 I Yes 1 f -n7f~HYLA N_()DIFLQR~--==--__ ._.___~_jHerbi-FACW I 25,00 Y;'s _oj ____ ____LHerb i FAC~ I 25.00 i Yes . I '. -H~~~~~ESJ;k%TNARAbiCANS IHerb I FAC , 25.00' Yes "I I~~~~~~^ = - .. i:?J;:r=~ ;~t-0:j i- ...L--:------=-~-:.~--- .J ~ -- --~--:::=--i=-~--=:--~ ~j , ... .__ ._-~ l L I I. I II i Total Number of Species: 11 Total Dominants: [' Percent of Dominants that are Wetland Species: 50/20: 83.30 Prevalence Index: 2,84 , 6 FAC(minus). applied: FAC Neutral: 66.70 Yes HYDROLOGY II Re~orded Data: i I .. _ _ Stream, lake, or Tide Gauge 1'1' - Aerial Photographs Other ,x~ No Recorded Data Available il I Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary Indicators: Inundated __ _ Saturated in Upper 12 inches Water Marks Drift Lines Sediment Deposits ___ Drainage Patterns in Wetlands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): Ii ____ Oxidized Root Channels in Upper 12 inches I, Water.Stained leaves I .. X. Local Soil Survey Data i! _...1<._ FAC.Neutral Test II ,~,..~~~ .pther (E~plain in Remarks) _, il II Field Observations: i Depth of Surface Water: Depth to Free Water in Pit: Depth to Saturated SoU: (in.) _____ (in.) (in.) ,,'.,_,...___.__n_____ ____________.,__ -.-...-- -..-..------------------------.----.-..--------.---.--..-....-.- .-- ~, i I Ii 11 II I II :1 1: il ii I! " Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 159 of 167 Sample Point 2 419 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 4 SOILS Map U~ltiii~m~~-#2tB06A I (Series and Phase): Taxonomy (Subgroup): l~r~jlle Descri[liion:__~_-::~~~:=_:' Ii Depth I I Matrix Color ' il (inches) I Hz i. (Munsell Moist) , Co.O:2:~]= lOYR6Il-':- r . i. . 2.5-5.0 i A . I 10YR6Il :1- -5.0-11.0 ,,_. I 10YRB/4-- ![~~--~- " I I Ii i-. I!--+ I ,r------ -j , r 1--=4--- I! HydriC ~OlllnOlc~tors: I Histosol [i --=Histic Epipedon Sulfidic Odor , -.- Aquic Moisture Regime II -Reducing Conditions I -Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors NRCS Field Indicators: S6 Stripped Matrix Drainage Class: Field Observations Confirm MapPEKl.:rype_~_ No_ Texture, Concretions, Structure --- Sand .. -Sand Sand Redox Feature ; Abu.nda~cElLContrasl -Tt:ledox(;olor-- ~ I (Munsell Mois:~__ I -I- I j--WVR812 . - - n.____. j(jYFfill2- _,~ _____...J' I I I ._--~...., =t= --" 1 r- ,....L... i I_~_- - . ----+--- - . --.-, I __I Concretiona High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Soils Organic Streaking in Sandy Soils Listed on Local Hydric Solis List .. Listed on National Hydrfc Solis List Organic Pan ...2L.. Other (Explain in Remarks) t__ _. _n._ WETLAND DETERMINATION II Yes - Hydrophylic V~g;;~tion Present? - Yes Wetland Hydrology Present? _-'!'.es Hydric Solis Present? 1 - _ - -.: ___ :i I, ---.---==:.:.:::! Yes_Is this Sampling Point'Within a Wetland? '1 ~Is this Sampling Point a Waters of the US? 1'1 .~. Have the_ deterrnl.n~tion results~een_ overridden ~~~~J REMARKS rF I, I ii I' I I: .",i Ii I. ii ~ I !i II L_ Wetland X Yes No Ii ______=-~)J WoUS Yes X No 11 2.84 Species Richness Prevalence Index Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 160 of 167 Sample Point 3 740 310 Black & Vaatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS paga 5 Project Name; Black&VeatchTampaOl1 , Sample Point Number: 3 Investigators; MICHAEL R, RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC. Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? ,'Nj> Is the site slgn~icantly disturbed (Atypical Situation)? ;~P~. IS_ t~_e_~~_~p~~~!ial~~"~lem,!-~ea?_~~. ____ VEGETATION Date; 1 0107/2006''''- Time; County: Collier State; FL Roll No; 740310 Photo No: LatJLong.; Datum; NAD83 North: 25039' 48" ,j West: 80'57'17" 'I ._",~~.._.=.=~."".,."__== ~~ ._~~_,..._d i ~- ..-J.=--==:"~---':'-=-==- -----=---- i I ____.n-. .-" --- L J----.---..- Indicator percent'- Dominant I Strata . Stallls Covar.~!es...J , Herti...JUp.~t..' 25.OQ .~' Yes i .__ . :Herb~Ac;~., 25,ooH~S_......J _ .._--. ,Herb . i FAC)'Y__25.oo -f- Yes ... .~i __._' i,Herb. I FAC -+----,?!?-2--+.~ ____._m iHerb_iFAC i 25.00 I Yes_ :=_-. m~= iHe~fc=:i=~.7'OO :J. NO~1 _ ..--1-__1.. _1 ..1......-._1 . ----1. _!__L._.....L.. -I -:-..:.=~.=r=~.~.-r.~ '--.=--t=~. . --+----. L .1. . .....- ~. ; No. Solentlflo Name ~~,.~=, I 1 I SPERMACOCE FLORIDANA "2 ' ANDFIOPOGoNVfRGfNiCOS--- ~ ~l ~~TL~/~~~~Z~~ ..---- "5 i TOXIC6i5EiiiDi=lON RADiCANS to. 6 i vrfis ROTUNDIFOLIA I '---1- ..__....~.__.. ~__ ....L- -"y. ,~.. , . ! u---+-._. 1..---1- . ! : ~-' FAC(mlnus)- applied; FAC Neutral: 1 50.00 J' TBD .--- .....,-------'--- , Ii I rotal Nu~~er of SP~cles;'6 . . Total Dominants: I Percent of Dominants that are Wetland Species: 50/20; 75.00 I Prevalence Index: 3.23 L._ 4 HYDROLOGY r-;;~orded' D~ta: . Stream, Lake, or Tide Gauge i ..' ..- Aerial Photographs ! =---.: Other 1 X No Recorded Data Available ,- I , : Field Observations: Depth of Surface Water: Depth to Free Water in Pit: Depth to Saturated Soil; (in.) .___ (in.) (in.) .. . Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary indicators; Inundated ._ Saturated in Upper 12 inches Water Marks Drift Lines _. . Sediment Depos~s .~ Drainage Patterns in Wetlands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): _ Oxidized Root Channels In Upper 12 inches II Water. Stained Leaves " =__- Local Soil Survey Data ,I -:: 6~~r~~:;i~~~tRE!~~r~~~,_ _~~!I 1 ,I I :i " p ,. l~~_. ..~=". -~_. .--,---" .---- .--- "-----.-.--..--.. --------- Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 161 of 167 Sample Point 3 740 310 SOILS .. ~.""". ._...- '-=--.,....-.. -.----... Map Unit Name: Drainage Class: (Series and Phase): Field Observations T~onomYJSubgrour:>t____-_-~~nflr"! Ma~.:rype? No _ ___._ F:'b:I=t~e:crIPtiEf'MatriX-COlor'" Texture, Concretl~~~~--- Red~;;-F~~~;---I Redox COlOr:":"~J ,. (inches) ~, (Munsell Moist) I Structure ! Abundance/Contrast I (Munsell MOist) I' :: ~:~~~~ I ~ t --:~~~- --- ;:~-~-------d+-l .:~- '---T"_'__~I ru>-7.0 I A --' I 10YR5Ir-r-=----::=- SimdlStoney- .. I 1:-7__0-10.01 ~_ i 10YR~_i____~arnj__-.._ ;-==~ .1 - ---} H ,I . ! --+- I ----- -- ---r-- - r-:=---I----+--:c:----- =$ J--!-+- -I ---- ,-- ........ J---~T ."--r-- .-;------ r:c ~J:~:=--=---T~~--=--~- -- .. i~-=--=r= .- 'I __ Hlstosol Concretions 11___ Hlstlc Epipedon High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Soils 'I Sullidic Odor Organic Streaking in Sandy Soils ! = Aqulc Moisture Regime Usted on Local Hydric Solis List II __ Reducing Condnions Listed on National Hydric Soils List :! _ Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors Organic Pan II NRCS Field Indicators: - 11=_ Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Randa Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 6 -:1 -11 - I --I I Ii :1 Ii Ii I _'_ Other (Explain in Remarks) --".. :1 _....=:==:J WETLAND DETERMINATION r. N. 0 .HYdr~Phytic- Vegetation Prese~l? , No' Wetland Hydrology Present? I - NO- Hydric Solis Present? ~....,-~--=:-::-:-:==-~-_...;..~. No Is this Sampling Point Within'a Wetland? i] No Is this Sampiing Point a Waters of the US? II .'NO Have th~ determination results_been overridden by the user!JI ,- _.._-,-,'~' -::::::..:...:.. REMARKS :r----- - y,-----.'.-- ,I Ii " II 1 Ii I' II ,. " ii --_...'-._-" .-. .--. -_.- .--- Weiland WoUS Yes Yes 6 Species Richness X No X No 3.23 Prevalence Index i Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 162 of 167 Sample Point 4 624 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Randa Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 7 prOject NalTle:"Slac"k"i. Veatcl1T~mpa 011 Sample Point Number: 4 , Investigators: MICHAEL R. RAMSEY, RAMSEY INC. ! Yes Do Normal Circumstances exist on the site? . No . Is the site significantly disturbed (Atypical Situation)? (No.~s...!!'~site a 1'l()~,,!i~IProblem Ar.ea? ..' l._....._ ..___,----'--.:..'_______". ., .-,---'---..... ' -. .-------------'--..". -.,-=.=,::,~,:","~+'....' VEGETATION - .---- ! NO, Scientific Name 1.-__ . ['1 ! TAXODIUMDISTICHUM l~PINUSELLlOTTII-' . L!l SABACPALMETTO .. - L-~. ,1' AXODIUMDI~TTCHUM I 5' ILEX CASSINE 16 'i'>TNUS ELLiOTI" n' .-- r~...I~~~~~g.....~~i~~~RID~N.-A ~_~ ~.. . 9 ARISTIDA STRICTA -- . . 01 0 SMILAX SbNA-NOX . . .- 11 ! TOXiCoDENDRON RADICANS 1~ VITIS Rb!UIIIDIFOLlA __ r- j-- L---I--..- ~~---. L- T-"-"..'''' _......~",.."..,-. Date: 1 0/0712008 County: Collier Roll No: 624 Lat./Long.: North: 250 39' 48" West: 80057' 17" Time: State: FL Photo No: Datum: NAD83 .._."':"=~ -.- S;r~i; Indicate,; PetcenC" Dominant' -1 Statu._ Cover.._ Species! iHerb..~ OBL ~_~15~_ No ---, ! Herb _I FACW I ._~5.00 i Y~~ !Her.b I FAC .L~t No ~hrub ! OB_L._ ...L._7.00_, Yes ! ! Herb : FACW -----r- 7.00' No'1 ..'~ ~:~b '~~fwT ~;:~~; ~::-i I Herb FAQitj I 25,00' .~ Yes ! ____iHerb I FAC:.._ I 25.00.!_ Yes ..J .. i Herb ' FA9_ ! 2.00 1. No __ I -I::: ~~-I~::l~:' J ..t_.n_~ I Tot~~~m:r of Species: . 12 --" Tot~1 Domina~ts: 7 Percent of Dominants that are Wetland Species: 50/20: 85,70 i . Prev~ence In~:~: .~___=:60 O~__ .. _.______ . HYDROLOGY Ii R;corded D~ta:'- ~.. ii' .~ Stream, Lake, or Tide Gauge ! Aerial Photographs I --- Other !!-'3(- No Recorded Data Available p-- FAC(minus)- applied: FAC Neutral: I -. '--li I 7.1.40 Ii Y~ Wetland Hydrology Indicators: Primary Indicators: _ Inundated ._ Saturated in Upper 12 inches Water Marks _ Drift Lines _.!<... Sediment Deposits _ _ Drainage Patterns in Wetlands Secondary Indicators (2 or more required): " _ Oxidized Root Channels In Upper 12 inches Ii ._ Water-Stained Leaves I Local Soil Survey Data !, _2<_ F AC-NeutralT est I: Other (E~aln in Remarks) . II . -.'. .---.--- .' '-'-''''--'--- - .."-,---.. ,...-- ,.. .--..-------- i I Field Observations: I'i Depth of Surface Water: I. Depth to Free Water in Pit: ,j Depth to Saturated Soil: lb.~~=..~~ ..-.._._=~~"..".,.~~,="-- (in.) ____(in.) .. (in.) ... ~ i Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 Page 163 of 167 Semple Point 4 Black & Veatch Tampa 011; Renda Broadcasting USACOE WETLAND DETERMINATION FIELD SHEETS Page 8 624 SOILS Map U~it Name:#i4"PINEDA(H) AND #2i-aOCA (Series and Phase): T axono~y (SubQrCl'P2: Profile Description: . Depth:-' - Mai,ix Color . : (inches) i Hz I (Munaell Moist) , "O:(f-2~5'-TA----:--" 10YR6I1"'.'- .'---. 2~s:s:or'i: 10YR6I1-.-.---- 5.0-11.0' "E 10vRei4----r L__ _..._ ..--..1- ----t- -----:--1. -----.- I r-------..---:=-----=-"_~_ Drainage Class: Field Observations Co~f~~Mapped Typ'~? No Texture, Concretions, ,Redox Feature Structure .______1. Ab!,lndance/C_ ontrast Sand - Saiif..----- ...-+-----. Saiid-----t-- --- Reeiox-c6ior-' I (Munsell Moist): I ..-- J_ _ ___' I 10YR812 .1 ----r--:--fOYFi8/2 _I ....----.- I -...."--.-- .... .-.----. , -.--.-.------'1 ! ._... _-il I .--il In. i - -----=----r----- ---=::r::---:-- I 1 _~~_----I=_.:.__ ._~. 1 ' , I ---I :] -'I .--.--....: " .. ~I I :1 ,---- , 1 j-~~_...l I I i: HydriC ~Olllndlcators: I Histosol I' '-:=Histic Epipedon I Sulfidic Odor :; - Aquic Moisture Regime --- Reducing Conditions , - Gleyed or Low-Chroma Colors II ._. .U ,I NRCS Field Indicators: $6 Stripped Matrix :1 :i IL--__ I ---r - Concretions High Organic Content in Surface Layer in Sandy Solis Organic Streaking in Sandy Soils Listed on Local Hydric Soils List X- Listed on National Hydric Soils List --- - - Organic Pan I I 1 " I' 11 .- J ~ Other (Explain in Remarks) WETLAND DETERMINATION r;:::-"'-' --. - -- Ii Yes Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? " ---ves Wetland Hydrology presant? I! ~ Yel!. Hydric Soils Present? I 1.-- .--..- Y/!!_IS this Sampling Point Within -a Wetland? --1 _NQ_ls this Sampling Point a Waters of the US? 'I _.N..9_ Have t~e ~!~mlnationresults been_overridtten b~~he user? J REMARKS 'I --.---- L . ---. ------- '__.___00_' ------..---".- Ii 'I I I :1 I I "."-=--==--:::-~.:::.~-=='-I " ,I " Wetland X Yes No WoUS Yes X No 12 2.60 Species Richness Prevalence Index I ' Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 AERIAL FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP ~. ." . CU_200S-AR-140S5 REV: 1 RENDA BROADCASTING ~Project: 200S070019 > ~ Date: 12l24l0S DUE: 1/27/09 il. . "I . PROJECT: BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 RENDA B ADCASTIN CORP. Figure 5. Aerial I FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; Ramsev Inc. Envlronmenial Consulting 2631 4th st. NW Naple!~FL 34120 239.5.....1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011,5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, See 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. _ r Agenda Item No. 7B February 23, 2010 FLUCFCSI VEGETATION MAP 624 PINE CYPRESS PALM DEP/SFWMD .JURIS. WETLAND USACOE .JURIS. WETLAND #1 3.73 AC #2 0.06 AC TOTAL 3.79 AC om 740 310 IliW DISTURBED LAND I GRASS PRAIRIE DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #30.15 AC BE O 740 8212 DISTURBED LAND I COMMUNICATION TOWERS DEP/SFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #4 0.38 AC ~ 740 8145 ~ DISTURBED LAND I ACCESS DRIVEWAY DEPISFWMD UPLAND USACOE ULAND #5 0.22 AC 419 ~ OTHER PINE ~ DEPISFWMD UPLAND USACOE .JURIS. WETLAND #6 0.15 AC #7 0.08 AC TOTAL 0.23 AC . BUILDING . ELECTIRICAL UTILITY . TOWER t: o l'l III \ Ii. 0, -I't - - 40 L 40 80 120 Feet -, o 330l'T '- I" ~~ ~~X<<~ ~ x XX9<" x Z x ~ x X ;?<, x ~"'--' x x X >< X><x '> x x :> X>< :x>><: x XXx x >X ;><"'(9<x >< x x~ y ;x><x':> x:>< x.-~ x x X 'X,?< X x :x :>< :>< :> v X:: ><;x:?< x x>Q< ;><,., v x >C x,.; >< x x X:; x "'--' v x"",><^, x 'Xx X x.- XXx x :x Q Z Xx x ~ :& x ;x><.<)~ ><9<<<X ><':: :x ><::xx""x ~ x Xx ::; ~:x~X~y;;~ ;x 9 x :x >v<:xx ~ ':x x I>< :> x:x X;x x;>: ':x x s:: ;?< XX x. x x x V xxx x~ x X'X':x:xx xx x x.- XX :>< x x x 'x,(x./<>X T:x -><x x :x ~ ~ X 'x x X x,;xxX'X x ~ x>:x x x.- xx v V (>< x ? x "',.'1. CX;x x :x x x,. x v XX ><.;> >: :x x 9<>01 ~~>S: . N~:x ~ xx :>< :x~ x x 4" x x i ...~ ~ x&xx 4~ 0x I'-.. x :: x:; ~~_ :;~ :; ;< X>9O ~ xs:~~ SS S ~ ~ ~~;;; ~, -7 ~" ~ x ><-z' XX'X '><X'X .".." ..<:i rx x>x~ '>< ~ ~ Y<..-'X' ~ ~:-z :x x X'Y" S:: s ::: ~ x:: I I I I TIl" II I I __~EWS RQ~~_~OW -,'--- N f' LACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011 Figure 4. FLUCFCSI Vegetation Map; Ramsev Inc. Environmen'tal Consulting 2631 4th St. NW Naple.!'~ FL 34120 239.5.....1660 BLACK & VEATCH TAMPA 011, 5860 Crews Road, PID 00405160008, Sec 08, Twn 50, Rge 26, totaling approx. 4.77 acres. If"" Agenda Item No. 7B February 23,2010 Page 16601 167 Sept 29,2009 John David Moss _ Principal Planner/Zoning.& Land Dev.elopment 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Naples, Florida 34104 Dear Mr. Moss, I am currently out of state and will be unable to attend the public hearing, Oct. 15,2009, in reference to petition CU-2008-AR-14085, I am strongly opposed to allowing a tower built within 500 feet of my property. I own a 5 acre parcel on the south side of Crews Road. My family and 1 have owned this property since approximately 1968. With the extension of Santa Barbara, I finally have a good possibility to sell this properly. Who would want my 5 acres with a huge tower across the street? In regard to petition: V A-P12009-37, I ask that the variances be denied. Laws are put in place to protect the general population from being taken advantage of, When I remodeled my home on Tarpon Road, the contractor made a 6" mistake. I was required to take down the east wall for 6" and another home owner was required to do the same for 8'. How can you even think of considering this size variance? I would hope county property owners would have the same protection under our laws. Please add this correspondence to the public hearing October 15,2009 of the Collier eounty Planning Commission of Collier County, Florida at 8:30 am. Would you also forward my letter to the Honorable County Commissioners of Collier County. ~~\tful. lYf'. jilted, ~LdLs) Dan Quinn \ 1895 Tarpon Road Naples, Florida 34102 RECEIVED Cc:emailedtojohn-davidmoss@colliergov.net ; (; G ZONING DEPARTMENT - ~nda I~m No. 7B NOTIC' OF PUBUC HEAR brua 23 2010 TO CONSIDER RaDLUTI , . Page 167 of 167 Notice is Rereby given that the Boam of COUllty CommIssioners. as the Board. Of Zoning Appeals, of Collier County WJIl !lold a publk hearing on Tuesday, February 23, 2010, in the Boardroom. 3rd. Floor, Administration Building. Collier County Govemment Center, 3301 East Tamlllml -Trail, Naples" Florida. The meeting will be-- ,'"' I ..., ;3i ,; Ii Ii I! ~jl II ,Q oj r: II ...1. II L . I' 1,1 fill 1"1 'i5.11 ;Ill . d 11 gin at 9:00 A.M. The title .of the pro- Jio:sed resolution Is as follows: A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEAlS OF .COLUER ,"COUN- TV; FLOfUOA,. PROVIDING FOR 'THE ES- -TABUSHMENTOF A _ CONDITIONAl USE TO ALLOW lWO' COMMUNICA- TION TOWERS WITHIN THE ESTATES ZONING DISTIlICT PURSUANT TO SEC- TION 5.05.09 OF THE COWER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATEDJN SECTION. 8. TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COWER COUNTY. FLORIDA. The Board will consider Petition: CU- 2OOS-AR.14085, FLO TV, Inc., repre- sented by. Kimberly J. Madison, Esq., of Ruden. McClOSky, Smith, Schuster and RusselL P.A., IsrequestlnA a Con- ditional Use for a ,communication tow- er and the Instenatlon of relatedshej. ter and equipment in the Estates,(E) Zoning District. as specified In Section 5.05.09 of the Collier County land. [)e.. veJopment Code (LDQ. The approxl. rnately 4.n-acre subject property Is lo- cated at SB60 Crews Road, In Section 8. "Township 50 South, Range 26 East." In Cotller County, Fforida. (Companion item to VA-PLlOO9-037) NOTE: All Persons wishing to speak on any. .."enda .Iter.n must r~ister with. the County Admmlstrator pnor to pre- sentation of the agenda ..ttem to be addressed: Individual spa,oll'wllI be limited to 5 minutes on any.ltem, :The sefectjon of an Individual to. speak on behalf of 'an orgilin,lzatfon or group Is encouraged.. If,. recognized by. the Chair, a spokesperson for I group. or organization may be allotted 10 mIn. utes to speak.on an'!tam. Persons wishing to have written or graphic. materials Induded in. the Board agenda packets must, submit said material -a minimum of 3 weeks prior to the respective public hearing; In anY case, written materials Intended to be considered by'the Board-shall be submitted to the ApprOpI'ine County staff a minimum of seven days prior to the public hearing.. . All material uied I In presentatlcms before the Board wRl beCome :a . permanent part. Of 'the .re- ~rd, .. . Any person - vv:ho decides to appeal a deds~on :of the Board wlllnefJd a, r~- carde of:: the proceedings pertainIng thel'frtO and therefore, may n~d to ensure _that a verbatim record of. the proceedings is made, which record In- cludes the testimony and evidence upon which the appear 15 based. If you. are a person" with a disability Who needs any tccominodatlon in or~ der to' participate In this proce~in9, you ate entitled, at "9 cost to you, to the 'provIslon of certain' assistance, Please contact the CoHier- County' f. cili1les Management Department. _lo- cated at 3301 Tamiaml Trail East, Building W, .,Naples, Florida 34112, (239)252~80. Assisted listening' . de- vices for the "hearing Impaired are avallableln the County Commission- ers' Office. SOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS SOARD Of ZONING APPEAlS COLUER COUNTY, FLORIDA FRED COYLE, CHAIRMAN OIMGHT E. BROCK. CLERK By: .1 eresa Polaski, Deputy Clerk ~~ '. . FPhnJIII'V 7' 'n10 Nn'A~7':174