The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 01/12/2010 Item # 7A Agenda Item NO.7 A January 12, 2010 Page 1 of 52 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY VA-PL2009-1162, Elke Remmlinger-Behnke, as Trustee of the Bernd Schoenherr 1998 Irrevocable Trust, represented by Karen Bishop of PMS, Inc. of Naples, is requesting two after-the-fact variances for an existing screened pool enclosure that is an accessory structure to a single-family dwelling. The first request is for a variance of 2.5 feet from the required rear yard setback of 15 feet as provided for in Section 8.16 of the Kings Lake Planned Unit Development (Ordinance Number: 82-52) to allow the existing accessory structure to remain at 12.5 feet from the rear property line. The second request is for a variance of 2.41 feet from the required side yard setback of 7.5 feet as provided for in Section 8.16 of the Kings Lake Planned Unit Development (Ordinance Number: 82-52) to allow the existing accessory structure to remain at 5.09 feet from the side property line. The subject .26" acre property is located at 2454 King's Lake Boulevard, in the King's Lake Unit 3, in Plat Book 13, Pages 33 and 34 of the Public Records of Collier County, in Section 7, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. OBJECTIVE: ~ To have the Board of Zoning and Appeals (BZA) review staff's findings and recommendations along with the recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) regarding the above referenced petition and render a decision regarding the petition; and ensure the project is in hannony with all the applicable codes and regulations in order to ensure that the community's interests are maintained. CONSIDERATIONS: In 1983, the .26" acre property was developed with a single-family home. In 1991, a previous owner had applied for a pool and screen enclosure permit. In 1993, the pool and screen enclosure were constructed and received a certificate of occupancy from Collier County. In 1994, the present owner purchased the property. In 2005, the screen enclosure was damaged by a hurricane. In 2007, the owner attempted to replace the damaged screen enclosure in the same location and was infomled by Collier County permitting staff that the screen enclosure is encroaching into the required side and rear yard setbacks. Building Department records show that the owner hired a different contractor from the original contractor who had applied for the building permit. The new contractor installed the encroaching screen enclosure without obtaining the required building permits. An anonymous complaint was filed with Code Enforcement; the case number is 2007060321. (Please see attached Code Case Detail Report and Building Permit Listing Report at the end of the Staff Report.) The minimum rear yard setback as provided for in Section 5.4.4.C. of the Kings Lake PUD is 15 feet. The minimum side yard setback as provided for in Section 5.4.4.B. of the Kings Lake PUD is 7.5 feet. This variance request seeks two (2) after-the-fact variances as follows: - VA-Pl2009.] 162 12.14-09 Page 1 on Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 2 of 52 1. A 2.5-foot reduction from a required rear yard setback of 15 feet to allow a 12.5-foot rear yard setback. 2. A 2.4I-foot reduction from a required side yard setback of 7.5 feet to allow a 5.09-foot side yard setback. The site plan entitled "Specific Purpose Survey" dated September 29, 2009, and prepared by BBLS Surveyors & Mappers Inc., illustrates the location of the screened concrete pool deck along with the existing 12.50 and 5.09 setbacks. (See the Site Plan in the Staff Report.) There have been no other variances granted within the King's Lake PUD. As previously stated, this screen enclosure along with the encroachment has been in existence since 1993. To date, no known complaints have been received from any neighboring properties. FISCAL IMPACT: The Variance request by and of itself will have no fiscal impact on Collier County. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) IMPACT: The subject property is located in the Urban Mixed Use Residential land use classification on the County's Future Land Use Map (FLUM). This land use category is designed to accommodate a variety of residential uses including single-family, multi-family, duplex, mobile home and mixed-use projects. As previously noted, the subject petition seeks a variance for a single-family home that is located within a single-family subdivision, which is an authorized use in this land use designation, therefore, the single-family home use is consistent with the FLUM. The Growth Management Plan (GMP) does not address individual variance requests; the Plan deals with the larger issue of the actual use. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPe) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC heard petition V A-PL2009-1l62 on November ] 9, 2009, and by a vote of 6 to 3 recommended to forward this petition to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval. Three of the Commissioners recommended denial of the variance for the following reasons: """." There are no special conditions and circumstances related to the land and structure involved. A literal interpretation of the Code will not result in hardship to the property owner. The property owner could afford to rebuild the screen cage enclosure correctly. - The variance is not the minimum variance. - Granting the variance would be granting special privilege to the property owner. VA-PU009-1162 12-14-09 Page 2 of3 Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 3 of 52 - Granting the variance is not in harmony with the LDC, as it is not a legally permitted structure. - One Commissioner stated that they knew this was a setback issue. "1 cannot reward them for bullying ahead because it punishes the people who do it right." Two of the Commissioners who recommended approval expressed the following: - 1 do not see this as a problem.....These things happen. It is not the fault of the homeowner that it (the screen enclosure) carne down. It is a huge expense to replace these enclosures...... they are replacing something that is already in existence. This (screen enclosure) is not a big issue." - This house and pool have been here since 1993. No neighbors are complaining. The pool cage is not harming anybody. The pool cage carne down as a result or an act of God, we should not be penalizing the property owner. The CCPC also commented on the status of the unlicensed contractor. Staff has researched the issue, and has found that in 2007 Contractor Licensing investigated the unlicensed contractor who performed the unpermitted work at the subject site. The unlicensed contractor was subsequently penalized and was issued 5 citations totaling $ 1,500. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This Executive Summary has been reviewed for legal sufficiency and is legally sufficient for Board action. (STW) RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals approve the request for V A-PL2009-1162. PREPARED BY: Nancy Gundlach, Principal Planner Department of Zoning & Land Development Review ."""'- Page 3 of3 V A-PL2009-] ] 62 12.14-09 Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 4 of 52 ,- COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Item Number: Item Summary: 7A This item requires that all participants be sworn in and ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. VA-PL2009-1162, Elke Remmlinger-Behnke, as Trustee of the Bernd Schoenherr 1998 Irrevocable Trust, represented by Karen Bishop of PMS, Inc, of Naples, is requesting two after-the-fact variances for an existing screened pool enclosure that is an accessory structure to a single family dwelling. The first request is for a variance of 2.5 feet from the required rear yard setback of 15 feet as provided for in Section 8,16 of the Kings Lake Planned Unit Deveiopment (Ordinance Number: 82-52) to allow the existing accessory structure to remain at 12,5 feetlrom the rear property line. The second request is for a variance of 2,4 1 feet from the required side yard setback of 7,5 feet as provided for in Section 8.16 of the Kings Lake Planned Unit Development (Ordinance Number: 82-52) to allow the exisling accessory structure to remain at 5,09 feet from the side property line. The subject ,26 acre property is located at 2454 Kings Lake Boulevard, in the Kings Lake Unit 3, in Plat Book 13, Pages 33 and 34 of the Public Records of Collier County, in Section 7, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, 1/12/20109:00:00 AM Meeting Date: Prepared By Nancy Gundlach Planner, Principal Date - Community Development & Environmental Services Zoning & Land Development Review 12/14/20093:05:04 PM Approved By Judy Puig Operations Analyst Date Community Development & Community Development & Environmental Services Environmental Services 12/16/2009 3:43 PM Approved By Steven Williams Assistant County Attorney Date County Attorney County Attorney 12/16/2009 4:05 PM Approved By Ray Bellows Manager M Planning Date Community Development & Environmental Services Zoning & Land Development Review 12/16/2009 5:02 PM Approved By Jeff Klatzkow County Attorney Date 12/23/2009 8:20 AM Approved By Nick Casalanguida Director ~ Transportation Planning Date ,- Transportation Division Transportation Planning 12/31/20097:42 AM --,~~-~-- ..."-_. --. -._._----_.-...-.. .__....~~-~ Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 5 of 52 Approved By OMS Coordinator Date County Manager's Office Office of Management & Budget 12/31/20099:23 AM Approved By Mark Isackson ManagemenUBudget Analyst, Senior Date Office of Management & Budget Office of Management & Budget 12/31/20092:32 PM Approved By Leo E. Ochs, Jr. County Manager Date County Managers Office County Managers Office 12/31/20094:53 PM Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 6 of 52 - TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION .~ .- FROM: DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION HEARING DATE: NOVEMBER 19, 2009 SUBJECT: V A-PL2009-1162, KING'S LAKE UNIT 3 LOT 26 PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner: Elke Remmlinger-Behnke, as Trustee of the Bernd Schoenherr 1998 Irrevocable Trust 2454 Kings Lake Boulevard Naples, FL 34112-5400 Agent: Karen Bishop PMS, Inc. of NapJes 2335 Tamiami Trail North Suite 408 Naples, FL 34103 ...- REQUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider an application for two (2) after-the-fact variances to allow for a screened pool enclosure for a single family home. The first variance is to reduce a required rear yard setback of 15 feet to 12.5 feet. The second variance is to reduce a required side yard setback of 7.5 to 5.09 feet as provided for in Section 8.]6 of Ordinance Number 82-52, King's Lake Planned Unit Development. The requested action would allow a screened pool enclosure at ]2.5 feet from the rear yard property line and 5.09 feet from the side yard property line. GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The subject .26* acre property is located at 2454 King's Lake Boulevard, in the King's Lake Unit 3, Block R, Lot 26, in Plat Book 13, Pages 33 and 34 of the Public Records of Collier County, in Section 7, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida. (c'iee the location map on the following page.) V A.PL2009-1162 Date: 12-16~09 Page 1 of 8 w ,- l.=-~ (.-_~",i I _~ j\;-,)- _~~~::'l.~{:~~~' ]:~)9 \__,;~.1< / ,'..I"~!.I':jH!j i J I :TL/< I~/ ..[-----.1;, ',', .\ --__':/ ' :;!. I; ..--.............., '. ...~- - 1,- ' "-... ;.!- ',- ,,' \. /". -~-~ w i!; ~'GJ c,) . <'/:1JI:n I I 0/,~!~ ;~ ~:~/i: ,/~'l" i i i I II i rT\_> i / I z I, , o " . o " u c " ~ . , . . --'- ~--_.~- ,,' ! . , . , Q:l"xnrv.;E ~1lI()" ~'- ,...",~CJ;: . " JI131'JS'<'3 , , I -----. I i-------< I , I /1 \ ." . _.~_ ,,_! ~~ I C ,.//' I '-, -~.......'--. ~('J '-;:~\---r"'\~ ~~. :. -- f L<'{C]_I , I~ i ---7/ / d [-- . -----C;i--II- '\. __ ,:l?~ ) ~~ i ,\~. ~ ~ ~I f-i~,"'"'Y ~ '.;--.\ '-::~.,-> I'--'L --I{"'^''- ! // - \. "^</ 5 ___I ~ " Q" '>... '< I ,ml I ~ .< / ."i;;'", ! 1/' '" . -~, I =~ ';./ I"':> "" - ~ I I . - Z ','..... ~ " / d i__-II"1 '- ~ f-<' <::-J<ij%"- ! / ~l : .: 1 vJ~~ <5~./, , 1=--=1 H = \,J Y y-\ ~---- "..--.--; 1,. ,I 'i - '. ~._-' .';.1 l.i i!' (' - \ "-----~_-~..'" I L. ,e \/TTl I I I n-:-"- '" "' _:., J.'~" , \ ii~d \j I J ,"", ':.:! I-liT"". l__Llc,--<:.\ ,",V ., , Clcl'h\)ln08 J~"" S~NI)< " '4\' c;;>- ~'- , " , ..:>-' . .--" , '~' , I I .. ~ ::'5 "- _ Y' '--... " " <:Lin J u>< ~ ~ ----...: I ^ / 1" ~11?)1 ;'~"../ '>\ "L-L---.t " ' ", //:~>;:\T:'\ < ,;x~~~- j .e;; ~ y'~----" r-1J-----., \,,:, I ~'-i I Y l' ~J\ --1 .-..-----j I~'_J'!I_II ~ )~"l~l~:-+-\~. I """', ,/ "~/'''! ':-) \ \ \ // \.... , .~ /'- ..----.. ,- I, I /,'" ;' -~-~-<' \ //--1 -'-, , ~ -- , ,,~ /'~. \ \, , J" ~~I /(JJ~~~J [ i " '-" 1f1 , /~ ------., r / "~I! , I " I! __ __-1---\_.0/ I , " , ," c ~---' " " I , , , ,---...; " ,:'1 . . I,,, , .~-,- , " '" , , y-",")-: . . ~ -'-jl00 --- I ,I ,':'0t /: I~ ;., i~ -,,, ,.., I~' lJ'l u_ ____ ;; "~'",l :i,'!l ~ l~_iUI-:_,_ ""C-;;;;;'1~--'!.~rh\N-:-'''J'' I ,.J ", ,----~. ~;i-~ ; ~~ ~~;: I "~'~ _' -....-, """"~.l l.l...+'1 I ~'~ .- ,~ ,,~ , I- Z " ~ ~~~! !JT ~ 0 t~ ~~ ~ l~ "J~'-:~ \ ~ L:<\ /) ~ _L ,', 3'< -";f - ;, 1,\, ~ /;\.. >../. ~ :~~-rrlf!~ if g -.----- 1 ,----" I i ;.~ ..;>"~,'.L) n ~ E~~ l""":~~~ _J 1""'-'" '''''''' ""'-'"'' I .~J .,.;:-' i ~i "'..- I -,-- I , I' 'I ,~"". ~. r -,.!_'~.-~~~~ - -. --- .._\ L/<fj ~~ {i i ~ /- ~.;",j,.,.", I' ! -? -,> '-------------..,-_-4_____ ~~~ ,-- _nr_"j~:'~ I i->-'! - ::~~: f c'J~,"/A' 1---1 '. \ - -,;'o-''';T1I.~~. "'~""O,...2,__~=-.:..J :;si' ...--- '" nl/ ; ---- -...." - _ fj--.,' -1:----.-.1 7/:" 5!, ~:~ ' '---', ' ~ --' .~'" " '-- .' ~:', ~.~, !..' .." ., l i:>< r '- ~~ , .'/ / 'J' . --..----" -~ 1'/ ":;-'-" ',.,' LE___ I;r ;I,J 1, . ~: '.- Ii].' " :!I I :1 _._';11_, ~ . k. :'1.__ -, ~'_~_~"" __"~._____~._.,w___~.__._.,_ - ----,,~. -~ ~ .:~, "!- ,'" " , ?,', /'1 , . '" , , , .. " . - ___u__' "i.- ,." , .. . J}' , , . ." , ;-11 /-l I--~L__._ . , , ,'- . i ~' , , I V' ,.~ .-"" , 1 t I .--: IF / ~ : , , /1 p~ , ';11E t",- . , , ,.. " " , , . '. ""'"T."" : . , .. ,-_r-- ., , , ~. ,- ~--...r f___.______________.. ." .:,\ f.________ J.v>, "',,,~"j;.-", ';:-1lli~1 : ~. ~ ~> ;;.:; ".-, ....0: J 'r) ~ .,' ,I,,; . ! I"., ", " F 1- 1 , , I , < l :~ , , -, '.;'1> ,./ ,Y. .....) !'_\. ,-,~~" , , , ,. 1 i \ . ! c. _ . , .. -~~ , . .. ,':-, I. . !-:-:i! , .. , ,. . " " . ,- I , , ".'. I --~. 1 "".."". j' ,,--~--.-- --. -I 'j-- . ,. , ~ , I ".. , ~'. p, ;I' n iJ- " I'., ::' "..-n , " .; I , , , , , , 1 :.i . ",' I, , , , ,,, "-, i. ,: <C...,.... ':.".v..:.~"','~..~"'"'''"'''''. . . . , ,..=,~~,.._,..---.".,."'~._""=",""'.;"-''''-.:.:'--'''''. ,.-~.~''''_.'''~'.~~-''''''"."'''' _.~~"""7-'U~.'=,."...,,..._,--'.......;~"'=:,.,,.'-'_"""-",-'.' ,..;', '''''.~-..-;~~.~~__..-' 0.. <( ~ (9 Z - z o N N '" - - a> o o N ...J 0. ~ ,. Z o f- f- W 0. 0.. <( ~ z o - I- <( o o ...J -- , ... ~ 8 '" i3 tjl ... 251 ----',-. ~i I I I " . January 12, 2010 Page 8 of 52 \- . .f () 1M>: TR...::;IC rtmMWAG!: r"_;;[;,IEN'U , f'ROi";:rcrv..1 UN~ -/ v -. , ~" \ / \ ~ a-f" /" \ / / CONCfltTI. \~ /_>!.l'9 DECK ~__~/-;:../ .--.-- \ -,--. \ ,# ,\ , rD?[ n ,;",lC[N-' =~r.r - ., J ,,~. /",,'- , '\ I 1tlO' (4.84' ; , ~.; '. -.Sl:[ \ / I~')r ../ ~/$ / TJR /' . APP~OX1MA1t.J Tal:' Of 13AIolK ;0',[;.1';...., , P,R_Y.,- C2 L2 Ii." .'"' rZ',11"'-- o:,r'- / .' , !:JX',( 'x PIX:, ';C,\L~ I" ~ 30' . Dr~^IL 1-] t.._ " \ , J[r lO-sY " ., ,",,' " , , . '" \' ,,; .// \ \ . POOL SCRE[N~D ,00\. CONCRET[~ OECK o " .. --- '" \ -- r..\ttJ'u'. _~\>.tO \ ,n CD' . \ \ '" '-". ;,'1.~ ~ '\ ',... ~ \~1;\ \....---"/" , / '(_97' 11,." DETAIL 1,t.~T 27 t..-DT 26 w;,- ri.' "c.'<U;: I..en 2.5 , ,. ~ ~8 ?~ g- >: / \ t,F'''I1'O~ "~l'f.'lON r'YSl'N" I :iWP.Y 'lI'llI:HoJr, (~~5~ 1~1f.lr;S ..I\~.- 9: I/O) lo.n'p.U.f , .x \ (". '" , ',...-:;.0 , , ,// .' 10,0' PtJ,( \ ~o./- . . " - , \ , BLOCK "R'" !j.o_1 , I I __~___I , / F/ "'"~ 1'/' ._;'....\:t). ,/~ /:, ./ ." N4.1,'J'~'::IY'VI IJ~ 1'5' ,:XIST1NG DRMS, WALrS P'ir. U ftc,1 '!I~ N::,)1 $lHOW"J -fO ~ ,e - - , - - " 10,0' P,U,E, I r - \ , \ , ;')1.,.)0 ,/ .-- C!l - . n,R --'---'----''l! "'If;'. , , . L1 / PX,l'. I ."'1 ~'Ib ..,.'0 EI:;' ~I , . 'P,C,P. i!-- .// . . , , . ------ '( '; .,... . \ , \ , , , , \ \ .-"' -...-' /" \ \ \ \ \ LOT 5- - - -- NI:\"'5~:4t"f. ;'1~.7?' (p) ;74 7~. IJJ) , f' (IlAStS!Y ntt.l<INC,S) . -. .- KtNGS LAKE BOULevARD 94' RICHT. O~-w,\Y ('W~,)Wt."( f.{r;' SI~OWN) - " " .- ,." - - LOT 3 ~- , \ 3LOC:'< 0>0" , ;.,0- .... lL)T 21', R' ,8:::r. R, ~INGS :.AK[ L"'T Ny .:l ACCDRDING TO T-l[ PI.AT TI'C:PE:)F f;'ECOPJ[!, IN PLAT 808K 13 AT ;.'/',cr:S 33 ~,ND J~ or lHr ;Ot'21.1C R[CDlms Of COLU(R rOUi-JTY, F: OR:DA tf.OTES: 1.) TH!~ '>URvrv WAS "'REPARED c-PCCWICAILY MiD rxc:"JS'l/tL Y '0 '01-10'-" ,HE R":I.A':ON~,+F m- I1-il FIELD LOCATED POOL Mia FOOL DECK TO THF rwu; ,;)("I,T[') 8nUNGARY:iF LOT 76. Blr'CK R, "'Ne" u".!<L UN;T He. 3' LEGAL DESCRIPTION LEGEND p" M 0 PC.P, FIR Pl,C. ,<0 P<:iM. ,'-c. (r') (>1\ ClRIIE - , . o :i ~ " g '-..~ ......,l<:, IJ\ I:>.... o i 3L~ .., :0.'- , "" "" ~J", o . . ?[I,MANLN- RC'l:r,,"l~:! VmIU~'ENT '(ll,Nr_~ 4".L- ~l1qCRc7'[ MONUW..ln r8ROI'~EN) If]:)'!!) f'E'<MA'>JFN' C0NT":Ol Po;r.JT (5/8" iR:JN RIJU wm-I A.IJM;NU~I ;;"p) rcum ~/e" IRON rwe, (010 ID) f'UBI C LnliTY [AS[,ENT IW;OI"'ORr,T[D PIIOf-f'S310!,AL StrNcyor: AND MAPPER L1Ctt.SEPSU3'NCSS r~or'ID', ~.c'~IN:'3'1':A"'IVf CO'lf PRINTED 2 i fJEt.PI~~C;., <;I OWN 1"- fir..:;" RE,fY -') 71-1: C[NTLRU~I[ ~l~~I.'.{;S 1,\K1: ElL'll). >:;ljGS L,'I'[ '-mn .~c ;, ACCe,I':)ING TO THE r"LAT --:-H~RLOr r,s R[(()'-:[.Et IN I'~,\- 3D~)" 1:; AT P'>'C[,.?, 3.3 AI~D _':4 OFTHl. r~UE'UC RCCC"J$ UF ,;OLUFP. C~:l)t;:" '_CP [A, - .. J) HI;; 1"O'~lR!Y ,~', ,,:JFJFCT TO :ASU"nITS, Ri:SER'-;,IT:'Y,,-, OR ,\[ST!<iCnUNS Dr RECORD '. o 4) L'n/[NSIONS SHO'.VN f',,:,CY', ^.RE iN "~l'l Mj~) mTIMAL,: TH,,.Tor .'; 5-1, T~.W, ,';:JflV[" IS No)" V/,,-i8 \\l"'j:)l;~ THE SI:.;r~^TUR;:: ,\NO WL ,W::';IN"L r~I\,SE:> :';[A', 8" ,4 Fl("JR~A UClNsm :',~J~'vtYOR l\'1D MAFPER b) rO',_+~["ATOh~~ 8ENEA~'-1 nit SI:RlACL. I' ',Wf >-IPiF ~:()T '1FFN ,,::,\TFD :'Li\T M'OASU"ED CERTIFIED TO: ,,-,',', ,',':"r "'!'I;Q " 1 FM~': 1,( 8~ I<,'PL,.s LINE TABLE BBLS SURVEYORS & MAPPERS, INC. LINE BEARING DIS"!'ANCf L1 '189.55'41"[ 22:.73 l2 S89.S5'4'"'\,/ :n fJ '. CERTIFICA TION: -- --.-,- CURVE TABLE I 'Il-.THY ::~:nl-Y ThOT ,:"~: :;f'E(JFC -~URPC;';f Sl.'RVCY ~,.:,s SURvtyeD UiDCR :,,. '''~SI'~)~IS.-i:-l~: ';-'A_ifGt ON O!'l/2.[,/Cl"l Tf-:IS SiJR",lY 1,[L.b ".~c I,AINII,,jU~ F,>-lt;:~A'_ 'ic:'Hr.;,t:D~ SL~ FUR-'-I BY THl "lOFI!);' :",:f-!i.O (11 PPOr-:S',lc'I.IAI I ~,:'I[) :)?\f';YOG:, IN :;~I,\P-r'? C,,(;1,'-S. , ~,~ 1">~~;lAI'i'T '(' ':::.J',r-~: .,-" ,.,,-, ~,-,,",r,h 'CT" - 'TFe ,. __"C, , ,,",-,-_h~"'_ "'v"' .,.^'..~, ., ---~- ...:.:;:> . -=..::.~- "'/=/~ ~ c ';::,-J r BU,"" ,-,T':'-,[ i''jf ;-",)RiD!., (" _.s, {i5~9€) :;GLS :~~lRV;ycrl:: {; I ;4;.Pr:R:; I"C (l,a I!U,,}) " C:;' C3 RADIUS 272,OQ 9500 23000 '.lllTA 44"'::;0'00" CHORD 205,"8 4:'5S lC301 LENi;;W 7112'> 4291 10:J.B9 25.~;2'51' 25'<,2',)1" CH01~O 8U>8ING Nli7"/.'Y"C"E N7,:c,Q'ic, ~,"F N~C:;9'15'T o o " . " " . < . c. a> b w " c SPE~RCPURPOSESURVEY BBLS SURVEYORS & MAPPERS INC. 1502.A RAILHEAD BLVD. NAPLES, FLORIDA 34110 (239) 597-1315 , LOT 26, BLOCK R, KINGS LAKE UNIT No.3, PLAT BOOK 13, PAGES 33 & 34, A PORTION OF SECTION 7, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA . . i " " < ':. [~ .'-"~--" ,,'.,. '''"''.''N''_.'''~'_4'M_'',.,__,' , Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 9 of 52 PURPOSEffiESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: In 1983, the .26clc acre property was developed with a single family home. In 1991, a previous owner had applied for a pool and screen enclosure pem1it. In 1993, the pool and screen enclosure were constructed and received a certificate of occupancy from Collier County. In 1994, the present owner purchased the property. In 2005, the screen enclosure was damaged by a hurricane. In 2007, the owner attempted to replace the damaged screen enclosure in the same location and was informed by Collier County pennitting staff that the scr~en enclosure is encroaching into the required side and rear yard setbacks. Building Department Records show that the owner hired a different contractor from the original contractor who had applied for the building pennit. The new contractor installed the encroaching screen enclosure without obtaining the required building pennits. An anonymous complaint was filed with Code Enforcement; the case number is 2007060321. (Please see attached Code Case Detail Report and Building Permit Listing Report at the end of this Staff Report.) The minimum rear yard setback as provided for in Section 5.4.4.C. of the Kings Lake PUD is 15 feet. The minimum side yard setback as provided for in Section 5.4.4.B. of the Kings Lake PUD is 7.5 feet. This variance request seeks two (2) after-the-fact variances as follows: 1. A 2.5-foot reduction from a required rear yard setback of 15 feet to allow a 12.5-foot rear yard setback. 2. A 2.4 I-foot reduction from a required side yard setback of 7.5 feet to allow a 5.09-foot side yard setback. The site plan entitled "Specific Purpose Survey" dated September 29, 2009, and prepared by BBLS Surveyors & Mappers Inc., illustrates the location of the screened concrete pool deck along with the existing] 2.50 and 5.09 setbacks. (See the Site Plan on the previous page.) There have been no other variances granted within the King's Lake PUD. As previously stated, this screen enclosure along with the encroachment has been in existence since 1993. To date, no known complaints have been received from any neighboring properties. SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: A lake/drainage easement, with a zoning designation of King's Lake Planned Unit Development (PUD) -' East: Single-family residences on Lot 27, with a zoning designation of King's Lake Planned Unit Development (PUD) South: King's Lake Boulevard, an 84-foot right-of-way, then single-family residences with a zoning designation of King's Lake Planned Unit Development (PUD) West: Single-family residence on Lot 25, with a zoning designation of King's Lake Planned Unit Development (PUD) VA-PL2009-1162 Date: 12w16-09 Page 4 of 8 ,,-,--- Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 10 of 52 - _. I"" .~,k<_ . ------.....,-.-----.--.-- AERIAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY: The subject property is located in the Urban Mixed Use Residential land use classification on the County's Future Land Use Map (FLUM). This land use category is designed to accommodate a variety of residential uses including single family, multi-family, duplex, mobile home and mixed-use projects. As previously noted, the subject petition seeks a variance for a single family home that is located within a single-family subdivision, which is an authorized use in this land usc designation, therefore, the single family home use is consistent with the FLUM. The Orov,,1h Management Plan (OMP) does not address individual variance requests; the Plan deals with the larger issue of the actual use. ANALYSIS: - Section 9.04.01 of the Land Development Code gives the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) the authority to grant Variances. The Planning Commission is advisory to the BZA and utilizes the provisions of Section 9.04.03 A. through H. (in bold font below), as general guidelines to assist VA.PL2009.1162 Date: 12-16-09 Page 5 of 8 ..-.-^.. ~"--'-""',"" Agenda Item No, 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 11 of 52 in making their recommendation of approval or denial. Staff has analyzed this petition relative to these provisions and offers the following responses: a. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing, which are peculiar to the location, size and characteristics of the land, structure or building involved? Yes. The subject property is slightly pie shaped with the narrowest piece located to the rear of the property where the existing screened pool enclosure is located. b. Are there special conditions and circumstances, which do not result from the action of the applicant such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property, which are th" subject of the Variance request? --.- Yes. The current homeowner purchased the home in ]994, The original home has a swimming pool and screen enclosure which was reviewed and permitted in ] 991. The certificate of occupancy was granted in 1993 by Collier County. When a hurricane blew the screen enclosure over in 2005, the homeowner had expectations that it could be replaced in the same location, c. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this zoning code work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties for the applicant? Yes. A portion of the screen enclosure would have to be removed if a literal interpretation of the zoning code were applied. d. Will the Variance, if granted, be the minimum Variance tbat will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure and which promote standards of hcalth, safety and welfare? No. The Variance proposed would not be the minimum Variance to allow reasonable use of the existing screen enclosure. The screen enclosure has existed on the site for at least 12 years without complaint or issue. Approval of this Variance would not have a negative impact on standards of health. safety and welfare. -' e. Will granting the Variance confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied by these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district? Yes. A Variance by definition confers some dimensional relief from the zoning regulations specific to a site. Howcver. no similar Variances have been granted in this immediate nei gh borhood. f. Will granting the Variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this Land Development Code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare? Yes. As previously stated, the encroachment by the existing screen enclosure has been in existence from 1993 until a hurricane blew the screen enclosure over in 2005, There have v A-PL2009-1162 Date: 12-16-09 Page 6 of 8 - _ ,""_",,_,,,_"h Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 12 of 52 - been no complaints from the neighbors regarding the 14 year location of the screen enclosure. g. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives of the regulation such as natural preserves, lakes, golf c.ou."ses, etc.? Yes. There is lake located to the rear of the property. The existing location of the screen enclosure within 2.5 feet of the rear setback and 2.41 feet of the side setback does not obscure the lake view of the other neighboring properties. In addition, there is a dense landscape buffer between the screen enclosure and nearest neighbor, mitigating for the encroachment. h. Will granting the Variance be consistent with the Growth Management Plan? Approval of this variance will not affect or change the requirements of the Growth Management Plan. ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL (EAC) RECOMMENDATION: The EAC does not normally hear Variance petitions. Since the subject variance doesn't impact any preserve area, the EAC did not hear this petition. '.'-, COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney Office has reviewed the staff report V A-PL2009-1 162, revised October 27, 2009. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) forward Petition V A"" PL2009-1162 Kings Lake Unit 3 Lot 26 to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval. -- - VA.PL2009-1162 Date: 12-16.09 Page 7 of 8 _'. _ ..._Wm...._______~ '__"__,~_' Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 13 of 52 PREPARED BY: , l 'rt'\, NANCY G 1:A H, AICP, PRINCIPAL PLANNER DA T DEP ART/o, T OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW , y , Ctt, v\ REVIEWED BY: I ({, 10 Zi.f 0' RA YM D V. BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER DJ TE DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW '-{n. S SAN M. ISTENES, AICP. DIRECTOR DAT DEPARTMENT OF ZONING AND LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW APPROVED BY: /' ,rr:.c-~ ;:;~/ J9S~PH K. SCHMITT, ADMINISTRATOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & ENvIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION /d/::',/Iu;1 / DATE Collier County Planning Commission: ! .. n \ ' ! ! I .J ~~- . \(l<./\'\ ~~\~ MARM, P. STRAIN; CHAIRMAN , II III 'I I,.,' . ..v I DATE Attachment: A. Pool Permit B. Pool Screen Permit C. Code Case Detail Report D. Building Permit Listing Report Tentatively scheduled for the January 12, 2010 Board of County Commissioners Meeting VA.PL2009.1162 Dale: 10-26-09 Page 8 of 8 .."...,._._,,,.....,.,~;,'""'"...., '.. ,..'..,.......- ~...,., . Agenda Item No. 7 A .. January 12, 2010 ATTACHMENT A3ge 14 0152 ..I." PLICATION DATE 11/01/91 PERMIT NUMBER 910011611 WNER- ITTMAN 454 KINGS LAKE BLVD. APLES FL 339620000 CONTRACTOR- NASSAU POOLS CONSTRUCTION. INC. 3420 WESTVIEW DRIVE NAPLES FL 339420000 . ROJECT NAME-~~T POOL DB ADDRESS- 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD. 643-0990 EN LOCATION-EAST UBDI~ISION-KINGS ECTION- HJP- EGAL NAPL ES LAkE RANGE- MAP/AREA- GEO-CODE- TRACT-OOO BLK- LDT/PARCEL- UNIT- ERMIT TYPE- SWIMMING POOLS 1&2 FAMILY OST OF CONSTRUCTION- $22,000 APPROVAL DATE-ll/01/91 - CONTACT PERSON-CONT CONTACT PHONE #- 643-0990 The above application has been examined and is hereby approved subject to the payment of $ provided by the Collier County Building Code and Ordinances. Payment Received by: Date Issued: L{- A.I Receipt No. ../ 6\) (jOII Z 7 . ,as All work under the approved build n permit shall comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinances and additional stipulations and/or Conditions of Permit. The approved permit expires if work authorized is not commenced within six (6) months from date of issue. The permit fee will be doubled, plus a maximum daily penalty of $500.00 if work is started without an approved permit. The permittee furtherunderstandsthatonIy licensed contractors may be employed and that the structure h n r i until a Certificate of Occupancy is issued. Signature of Contractor ~. (' /"-...1 '" / /,:} I ;".. /F/-"/P "I __ - NOTICE: In addition to the requirements of this permi~ there may be additional restrictions applicable to this property thaI may be found in the public records of this county, and there may be additional pennits required from other governmental entities such as water management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies. ~c ~ Customer ow - Records Room : ~ Property Appraiser I . Lobby Fil. S-In WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER ORANATTORNEYBEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. ,- ''''~~~''''~'~~'--''''.'. -.. Agenda Item No. 7A ..:!anuary 12, 2(J10 Page 1'5 of 52 , -.... .. .. J COLLIER COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION NO-910011611 CONTRACTOR-THRELKELD, THOMAS L. OWNER- PITTMAN JOB ADDR-2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD. TRACT- LOT- BLOCK- UNIT- FOLIO 1I- SU8DIVISION-KINGS LAKE TYPE OF OCCUPANCY-R/STRUC OTHER THAN BUILDINGS PROJECT NAME-PVT POOL WORK DESCRIPTION- THIS CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED AS PROOF THAT SCOPE AS DESCRIBED ON THE PERMIT. DATE-06/24/93 Tf .. , Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 16 of 52 ~ _.~- ,. ~"i INSPECTION HISTORY - JOB LOCATION-004-EAST NAPLES -fJ3DIVISION-KINGS LAKE ,B ADDRESS- 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD. JOB NAME- DWELLING UNITS-OOOOO CONTRACTOR-NASSAU POOLS CONSTRUCTION,INC. PHONE- 643-0990 NO- PERMIT NO-910011611 MAIN PERMIT NO- OWNER-PITTMAN DATE ISSUED- 11/04/91 DATE APPROVED- 11/01/91 SECTION TOWNSHIP RANGE MAP/AREA S.D.C. RECEIPT- WATER- BLOCK LOT/PARCEL UNIT TRACT SEWER- 000 COASTAL ZONE USE/OCC-R/STRUC OTHER THAN FLOOD EL- STRUCTURE-PVT POOL BENCH MARK- COMMENTS-. LOCATION- CONTACT PERSON-CONT PHONE- 643-0990 ~******************************************************************************* ******** INSPECTION HISTORY ********* ~INE # NOTE LINE 910011611 DATE TYPE 99-NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT 70 - OL STEE & GROUND 01-FINAL POOL - 00/00 INSP-MOORE, KERM INSP-MOORE, KERM .00 .00 11/07/91 PASS 11/07/91 PASS TOTAL FEES- .00 t. - ;;> ']-'1'3 /.): ;, 67 - 01< --;/0/ 0;:: Screel1 . . .~. \ ~ L/ /<. ( f') ! 1\--- r, ,\ I ~ ~.. - c\ 0" /) I l..../ ...,'- .- _..,".~-.._,~~"...~-"~_.,-_._._----." ' _'_".M__~'_~_' _.""'_ -----'_. COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS , }S Page 17 of 52 PERMIT PERMIT . , ISSUED: MASTER ~: 910011613 11-01-91 BY: LOAD o COA #: PERM:IT TYPE: APPLIED DATE: SCCG 11-01-91 V1\LID .: APPROVAL DATE: 11-01-91 JOB ADDRESS: 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD NB JOB DESCRIPTION, CPOOi:~ SCREEN :) JOB PHONE: SUBDIVISION ~: FLOOD MAP: ZONE: FOLIO~: 0000000000000000 BLOCK: ELEVATION: SECTION-TOWNSHIP-RANGE LOT: om,ER INFORMATION: PITTMAN 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD KING LAKES NAPLES, FL 33962 CONTRACTOR INFORMATION: TRELKELD. THOMAS L. 3420 WESTVIEW DRIVE NAPLES,FL 34104 CERTIFICATE #: 10865 PHONE: r 941) 643-0990 FCC CODE: 329 CONSTRUCTION CODE: JOB VALUE: - STROCT OTH THAN BLDG-POOL/SEAWALL/DOCK/F 10 I OTHER TOTAL SQFT: SETBACKS FRONT: REAR: SEWER: SEPTIC CONTACT NAME: CONT CONTACT PHONE: (941) 643-0990 LEFT: WATER: RIGHT: WELL Per Collier COlmly Q-dirumceNo. 2002-01, as it may be amended, all \\OeX must comply with all applicable laws, codes, ordinance~ and any additional stipulations or conditions of this permit This permit expires if\\Ork authorized by the permit is not commenced within six (6) rnonthsfrom the date of issuance of the permit Additional fees for failing to obtain permits prior to the commencement of construction may be imposed Permittee(s) further understands that any contractor that may be employed must be a licensed contractor and that the structure must not be used or ocwpied until a Certificate of Occupancy is issued. NOTICE: PRIOR TO THE REMOVAL OF ASBESTOS PRODUCTS OR THE DEMOLITIO~ OF A STRUCTURE, FEDERAL ,\Nl) STATE LAWS REQUIRE THE PERMIlTEE (EITHER THE OWNER OR CONlRACTOR) TO SUBMIT A NOTICE OF fHE INTENDEO WORK TO THE STATEOEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION (OEP). FOR MORE lNFORMATION, CONTACT OEP AT (239) 332-6975. In addition to tbe conditions of tbis permit, tbere may be additional restrictions applicable to tbio; property that may be found in Ihe public records of tbis county, and tbere may be additional permits required from otber governmental entities such as water management districts, state agencies, or federal agencies. WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PA YING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WIm YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT. _'..... ,-,. ,.""..0.;',-'.__''-,''."','.,_,;",.,_".__",,, .. Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 18 of 52 .~.> .' ~ """\." ,-".. .. ".m]2!.l -llc E:dt v"., ~ ------..-...-.--.-----...-....- ,._...,-_.__...._~_._.~---..-,--- --_._.".....-._..._-~_. _.._.~_.- -..'-..-.... ~- -....-..-...-----.-.... CD~PlusThl ~ ~ ~ t,,_,'M8IN! . lL ~ i!I 1 fJ: ~.... ~ I ;,<r.;J .-. ..., ~ -I' $1 Add...,;"gJf',op,,", I Code E""cemon! Pemilt;.,g I Dov. Re""" I c..n Me_me'" I Quo5fi... Cetlilicatea Permits Itl:l;Jjled~ C8II,Ooo,-' 13I -"'- :i'Startl j ~' ]..I.sI :J ! Desktop N- 1 MY Documents >> j; ~ 1 r;~:-~-,~.i~--~-;-:~..._-~ p J My Documents , >>f.'.. ) """"I'"' ..;";j :."""",- '::)0' "IJ.'V;. .'''iI 9:20AM ,--. Thursday, Oct 29, 2009 09:20 AM -_...._._^-"--~,,-,,-".- CDPR2025 COLLIER COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY Agenda Item No.7 A January 12. 2010 Page 19 of 52 This Certificate is issued persuant to the certifying that at the time of issuance this ordinances of the county regulating building requirments of the Florida Building Code structure was in compliance with the various construction or use. For the following: PERMIT NBR: 910011613 CO NBR: 22490 STATUS: ISSUED CO TYPE: FINAL ISSUED DATE: June 24, 1993 ADDRESS: 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD NB SUBDIVISION: LOT: BLOCK: T.R.S. : SLUC CODE: UTILITY COMPA1JY: ELECTRIC JOB DESC: POOL SCREEN N~rnER OF METERS: OWNER: PITTMAN 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD KING LAKES NAPLES FL 33962 LEGAL DESCRIPTION Note: A new certificate is required if the use of changed. or if alterations are made to ~he buildi:1Q certificate voids any certificate of prior date. the building or premises is or property deser ibed. A new Collier County Board of County Commissioners CD-Plus for Windows 95/NT Printed on: Page 10129/200' 1 of 9:20:03AM 1 Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 20 of 52 .- , t-PIM11D8 H'Jtl'IIl09 HP1M.IUO __ _._i HPIMllll ______.-J ---_._----- '-~-"- -. .-----..-, ,"",IMll1Z t-P1M't180 t-f'1M1161 ",-~, . ; ;, t - , ~ -." '" ~ 'XA C-t-A LCl/VO ,(otvArl\c+ Go "3. 0 . ~ 5fl~[tOtf Sql - 00 <0 L .-~" Monday, Aug 13, 2007 09:13 AM ,... ~"._~._------,._,._. Code Case Detail Report CASE NBR: 2007060321 STATUS: OPEN CASE TYPE: ZONING AD DR NBR: 137942 LOCATION: FOLIO: 0000053003680005 AO NBR: INSPECTOR: 308306 MARIOBONO Agenda Item No. 7 A ATTACHM~eY 12, 2010 ~.. ~age 21 of 52 CDPR4204 - Code Case Detail Report LEVEL: NOV 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD KINGS LAKE UNIT 3 BLK R LOT 26 LOT: TAZ: 26 137 BLOCK: R PLANNING COMM: SUBDIV: (988)-Kings Lake Onit 3 EN ZIP: 341120000 OPEN DATE: DIRECTIONS: 06/13/2007 OPEN OSER:DELICIAPOLSE SEE Notes for ATF CLOSE DATE: DISPOSITION:CEB CLOSE CATEGORY: SWIMMING PRIORITY: 0 HEARING DATE: DESCRIPTION: NO POOL CAGE POOL ENCLOSURES LAST VISIT: 1015144 CONTACT?: PHYSICAL FILE 10: OR PERMANENT FENCE IN PLACE SINCE HORRRICANE WILMA 10/24/05. CONTACT INFORMATION: REMMLINGER-BEHNKE TR, ELKE PHONE: FAX OWNER INFORMATION: REMMLINGER-BEHNKE TR. ELKE THE BERNARD SCHOENHERR REV/TR OTD 1/13/98 NAPLES, FL 341120000 PHONE: FAX: TENANT INFORMATION: REMMLINGER-BEHNKE TR. PHONE: ELKE FAX: VIOLATOR INFORMATION: REMMLINGER-BEHNKE TR, ELKE THE BERNARD SCHOENHERR REV/TR OTD 1/13/98 NAPLES, FL 341120000 PHONE: FAX: COMPLAINANT INFORMATION: NAME/ADDRESS: PHONE: (239)597-2711 FAX: 2425 KINGS LAKE BLVDRAY MONNOT VISITS: VISIT NBR INSPECTOR 997340 MARIOBONO SCHEDULED DATE 06/13/2007 VISIT DATE 06/13/2007 REMARKS 155--205 ON SITE KNOCKED ON DOOR, NOH. HOOSE APPEARS VACANT. OBS POOL W/O PERMANENT PROTECTIVE BARRIER. TEMP BARRIER IS NOT SECURED. PHOTOS TAKEN PREPARE NOV. RESEARCH PERMITS. PERMIT ATTACHED HOWEVER CONTACT INFO ON PERMIT INDICATES CONTRACTOR HAS NUMBER DIS CONNECTED OTHER NOMBER IS ASSOCIATED W/INCORRECT PARTY. MAIL NOV CERTIFIED MAIL ALONG W/ORDINANCE. MP.IL ANOTHER NOV W/ORDINANCE FIRST CLASS MP.IL. MBS5 R/C 7-14-07 DSP ;ollier County :D-Plus for Windows 95/NT Printed on: Page 10/20/2009 1 of 2:33:34PM 3 , ,,~ . MS COWLES HAS ALREADY OBTAINED A GC/ENGINEER TO OBTAIN PERMITS. 09/12/2007 10'00-11'05: - MET WITH ALEXANDRA COWLES, OWNER'S DAUGHTER, ALSO IN ATTENDANCE WAS KAREN BISHOP OF PMS (435-9080 X 3 AND 825-7230) AND IAN JACKSON OF CONTRACTOR LICENSING. DISCUSSED POOL ENCLOSURE THAT EXCEEDED SIDE SETBACKS. MS. BISHOP ALLUDED TO THE FACT THAT THIS ENCLOSURE WAS A REPLACEMENT THAT MIRRORED THE INITIAL POOL ~NCLOSURE. NO FOOT PRINT WAS CHANGED OR SLAB EXTENDED. MS. BISHOP IS REQUESTING A MEETING WITH MICHELLE ARNOLD TO DISCUSS CASE, TENTATIVELY PLANNED FOR MONDAY SEPT 17~H. WENT ON SITE VIEW ENCLOSURE WITH ALL IN ATTENDENCE. MS. BISHOP BELIEVES THAT NO SETBACKS WERE COMPROMISED BASED ON A POOL ENCLOSURE THAT WAS COED BY THE COUNTY IN 1991. BEFORE SETTING FOR CEB, I SUGGEST WE AWAIT MICHELLE'S RULING. - R/C 9/18/07 - MB#55 - IR 997587 MARIOBONO 07/20/2007 07/20/2007 1002419 MARIOBONO 07/30/2007 07/31/2007 1003348 MARIOBONO 08/09/2007 08/09/2007 -, 1004447 MARIOBONO 09/12/2007 -, :ollier County :D-P1us for Windows 95/NT 1'05-1'15: - PE~~~ - ~ANC~LED _ SEE ATTACHED _~n~~Tte~o, 7A CONFIRM TEMP BARRI~ ~\lL ,~g_ PLACE. DISCOVERED POO 2N ORE ERECTED W/O PERMITS - RESIDENT/CONTRACTOR CANCELLED PERMIT DUE TO ENCLOSURE NOT MEETING SET BACK REQUIREMENTS . OWNER THEN HIRED NEW CONTRACTOR AND HAD POOL CAGE BUILT WITHOUT PERMITS. PHOTOS TAKEN ~ RETURN CASE FOR CEB PREP. ATTEMPTS TO CONTACT MS. CONVES (SIGNER OF GREEN CARD) UNSUCCESSFUL AFTER SEVERAL TRIES. LEFT CARD AT FRONT DOOR. . R/C 7/30/07 - MB#55 - IR 450--455 ON SITE LEFT BUSINESS CARD. RESPONDENT LEFT MESSAGE ON MY PHONE WHILE I WAS ON VACATION. EXCHANGED MULTIPLE VMS. AWAITING RETURN CALL AND EXPLANATION OF POOL ENCLOSURE. MB55 R/C 8-6-07 DSP 11'00 - 11'20: MET W/OWNER ON 8/8/07 - FURNISHED COPY OF PROPOSAL OF CONTRACTOR - PROPOSAL STATES PERMIT WOULD BE OBTAINED - CONTRACTOR APPEARS UNLIC. IN COLLIER COUNTY - IAN JACKSON HAD MEETING W/OWNER TODAY ( (ALEXANDRA COWLES) AND IS BEGINNING CASE- CONTRACTOR HAS YET TO RESPOND TO OWNER. R/C 9/10/07 - MB#55 - IR Printed on: Page 10/20/2009 2 of 2:33:34PM 3 .--.-....,-- --.-,,,,,-,,- 1008798 MARIOBONO 10/11/2006 09/11/2007 1010296 MARIOEONO 09/28/2007 09/28/2007 1011863 MARIOBONO 10/15/2007 10/23/2007 1015144 MARIOBONO 11/08/2007 11/09/2007 1017500 MARIOBONO 11/30/2007 LETTERS: REF TYPE CC VIOLATIONS: STATUS VIOLATION LETTER NAME 1ST PAGE NOV/ST RQST DATE 06/14/2007 PRINT DATE SEND DATE STATUS 06/14/2007 06/14/2007 SENT RECV DATE 6/19/2007 GROUP CODE 8721 VIOL. DATE 6/13/2007 DESCRIPTION/REMARKS SWIMMING POOL ENCLOSURE SPOKE TO MS. COW4ES, ,SHE HAS RETAINED ALL PAP~R I~NO. 7A ENLISTED THE AID O?~R~~~I~~ OF COMPANY PMS. MEE!~~~ ~~ FOR lOAM WED. 9-12-07 MB 1:00-1:15 R/C9-12 10'00-10'30: - CEB PACKET PREPARED. R/C 10/15/07 - MB#55 - IR 10'55-11'00: - CEE PACKET ALREADY PREPARED/OWNER PROVIDED NEW SITE SURVEY AND CONTINUES TO ATTEMPT TO RESOLVE ISSUE PRIOR TO HEARING. OWNER AND I EXCHANGED VOICE MAILS TO UNDERSTAND LATEST DEVELOPMENT. R/C 11/8/07 - MB#55 - IR 1'50-1'55: - VIOL. REMAINS - CORRECTED CEB DOCS. SUBMITTED TODAY. R/C 11/30/07 - MB#55-IR IMAGE S : IMAGE DATE IMAGE DESCRIPTION 6/13/2007 pool w/o barrier and unsecured temp barrier mb55 6/13/2007 pool w/o barrier and unsecured temp barrier mb55 6/13/2007 id property mb55 6/13/2007 id property mb55 7/20/2007 pool cage w/o permits mb55 7/20/2007 pool cage w/o permits mb55 7/20/2007 pool cage w/o perrni ts mb55 COMENTS: ORIG DATETIME STATUS ORIG USER COMMENT: NOTES: :ollier County :D-Plus for Windows 95/NT Printed on: Page 10/20/2009 3 of 2:33:34PM 3 Comment Listing Report :D~R1007 - Comment Listing Report ATTAC~>>~~~~~ Page 24 of 52 REF TYPE REF KEY AD 137942 STATUS WARN ORIGINAL USER PETRULLIPATTI ORIGINAL DATE/TIM 7/20/2007 r COMMENT On 7/20/07 it erected after (Peter Bell). setback issues. another company LAST UPDATE USE LAST UPDATE DATE PETRULLIPATTI 7/20/2007 was discovered that this property had ascreen enclosure resident canceled a permit through JC Marshall Construction The owner was told that she needed redo application due to Instead of reapplying for the permit the resident had do the screen enclosure without permits. ,,-'- ,- ''',.- :ollier County :D-Plus for Windows 95/9B/NT Printed on 2:29:43PM 10/20/2009 Page 1 of 1 . ,._-~'.-_. .-. '...4_....._,..."..,.__.._...". ". .0:0"1 I'-~U) .0_ 0"10 Z 'U) E~N OJ >- OJ _~O> -COCO "'=>o. 'Oc "CO OJ., 0> .0: t"- ~ I- YA '/8'1 Ivy ~~ ~ '" " .. " . ,. , " .- " .- ! , . . , , . . , . . . " . , '1- .M . . 1 K O^lB .lMl~"" , . " , " " , ! . . 0 . c . . 0 , " I , . -_. avo~ NOL~DHIN' Q~ ~ ~J;1.. ~~ il,--<= ~tllj ; (""U:>I avo>< """n"<tHfOd~" d l,! .," ~~~ 0.,. . 1; ~ .., L!! . z " . Cl ~ ;:) 0 a. ~ . . ~ ~V^31n08 3lNIOd NMO~;) lS~ lN31'13SIf] '1 'i'd-~ @ o~"'^:OJln08 :1>1\/1 SC>NI)I @ w O~ ;:). o..~ ~ . /'^~'<,@ / '<, A,,, 4~~Z\ '\ ~\ , ~ . . . w ~ @>> ~ 8 7 \ '\ / ,. 11 , 'I" . ~~,~~~ ~ :'~ . , ......l'I .. "i~~ "'~1Il '-!~ ~ad . . l""''''''gvs , 9' ., Ii Ii 1)(30^'G ~"~R\<""_..lN.!S M:lu.,......... .~.... 0-2 Uo w - '\< Ou "'0 <L~ ,,~ , ,"- ~~~ " . . , ,.- ~ ~ ~ i~- <3)"" ~- i'i3"' "><lEI"lll_ .. .'" --,;;;;0.;- "',,- ~; "';;(lX""{31 ..J~ "''''"''' ., ,. c' , ! . lH.Od "'o.~ -J" "0' ~-~-" _" 81:; \:I n ~~ 2g "' ~ "'- !. ~ l!' , . ,. -. il . > . o " '- , I jl . , .,- , . " <<"! , .. , li- . >, . ". ,. 0 ! I t, - 1':1- ,. IJ 11 . 'I' l.1 " . . " . " co H " ~w ~~ >;!i ~j ~j "- .' . , . . . ! . a.. <( . ~ , , , Z 0 - I- <( U . 0 . .....I . . , . ~~ ,'\Q /... ....< \.. a~V^31n08 3N:J\I'I'l31!:l'lfHQ ..<' ^ 310!:lI03lS13ll38 u (Cl :r :;: '&-' < I~ . . 2 o Wo- 0-<( <nU o ~ .. G. '~.o'tl ;: /1 /' \ .~. n~lIl. \ ~ ,~ ~'> r " - r " " \/ . . . . . ,(\ y '. ~ --1f' Ie )} '/ > Cl~~~ ::)~ x)l o..~ ~ /:u& a ;<., J::.~"1 if . ! AXI>I ii~ - Ss ! / >"" / "o^,~ ~( '( . " o > 1:JSS3H:Jna /@ ~ > w w w . . w . o o . < > w w " o . i . w . < w o o __---1 ?; . ); 8 . " . . I \./ I I I I I I I J'W:>SOl'or.r / --- z-- Iii rls !, '"0 r-~_ ~::: , , " - , ^ , . ; ,- N . -, . I'. " , ~ . , . . ! [ , . < .. " ~~ " , ^ II . 0 .. , "I , . " . ~ ~- . ~f~- c;j~~s ~au_ "l'.: \ fl . ! - " , , . .. " ," -' O~O~ N~~' A1NllOO I ~ - i c:: ~'tC/\, _;:::.:;:-8 ~~~~ ~dt; .. . . . -- ~!-l , I I . . , ( ^ , , 0 , . , D ! . . . , , l . . . . " . , , . ^ ., ., , . " . .. " ,. . I i , I r ]^,~,,- ,,~O~"^"" - . " . . , II " !I .. .. .. ,. ^ ., " . , . , ~ 1 I ~ 0... <( ~ <.9 z - z o N N '" - - '" o o N ~ 0.. ;; " 2 o f-- f-- UJ 0.. - . eomr County .. - ~ - Agenda Item NO.7 A January 12, 2010 Page 26 of 52 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 {239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 . . .... ... ..... VARIANCE PETITION APPLlCA TION PROJECT NUMBER PROJECT NAME DATE PROCESSED " .. -' -- " , . (VARIANCE FROM SETBACK{s) REQUIRFOI'OIlA D..,T....... aft ---..... DISTRICT) . ... .. .... VA-PL2009-1162 REV: 1 . . KINGS LAKE UNIT 3 LOT 26 DATE: 8/31/09 DUE: 9/15/09 I APPLICANT/AGENT INFORMATION I NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) aKE REMM"NG~HNKE ADDRESS 2454 KINGS LAKE BL VO.. NAPLES. FL 3411 2 TELEPHONE # 239-775-0455 CELL # E-MAIL ADDRESS: FAX # - NAME OF AGENT KAREN BISHOP WITH PMS. INC. OF NAPLE.s ADDRESS 2335 TAMIAMI TRAIL N. #408. NAPLES. FL 34103 TElEPHONE # 239-435-908Q..EXT 3 CELL # E-MAIL ADDRESS.KARENBISHOP@PMSNAPLES.COM FAX # 239-435-9082 I PROPERTY DESCRIPTION I Legal Oe5cription of Subjed Property: lot 26. Block R. KinQs lake Unit No, 3 Section/Township/Range Z/~/2M Property I.D.#: 53003680005 Subdivision, KinQ' Lake e\JO IDRI Unit;> LoI, 2b. Black: R Metes & Bounds Description: ].ot 26, BI()clLR, King, Lak~ Unit No.3 Acreage: Address of Subject Property (If different from Petitioner's address): BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOB8YIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESE REGULATIONS. - ,"_,._,._."____.."-....__.'~,,_,,~..~._..~. "'._'" ..._.,,_.._,_.~.,.~...".._. .._.....h.." . . CotMr County ,., -- Agenda Ilem No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 27 of 52 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 I ASSOCIATIONS I Complete the following for all registered Association(s} that could be aHected by this petition. Provide additional sheets if necessary. Information can be found on the Board of County Commissioner's website at http://www.colliergov.net/lndex.asPx?Doge=77 4 . NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: .I<;INGS lAKE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION MAILING ADDRESS 2296 ROYAL lANE CITY ~ ST ATE tl ZIP 34112 NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP I ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE I Zoning Land Use N ,PUD i Drainaqe Lake , - S PUD 'ROW I . E PUD ! Sinqle Family I . I W ; PUD ! Sino Ie Family I Minimvm Yard-Bequiremenh f.!)J Subject Property: Front: .lQ Corner lot: Ye.D Ye. [ZI N. [ZI N.D Side: LS. Rear. 12 Waterfront lot: I BE ADVISED THAT SECTION 10.03.05.B.3 OF THE lAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIRES AN APPLICANT TO REMOVE THEIR PUBLIC HEARING SIGN IS) AFTER FINAL ACTION 15 TAKEN BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. BASED ON THE BOARD'S FINAL ACTION ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE REMOVE All PUBLIC HEARING ADVERTISING SIGN{S) IMMEDIATelY. ,.'".;' . Co~\ ~unty - Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 28 of 52 . ,,~~, COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 I NATURE OF PETITION I Provide 0 detailed explanation of the request including what structures ore existing and what is proposed; the amount of encroachment proposed using numbers, i.e. reduce front setback from 25' to 18'; when property owner purchased property; when existing principal structure was built (include building perm;' number (s) if possible); why encroachment is necessary; how existing encroachment came to be; etc. For projects authorized under LDC Section 9.04.02, provide detailed description of site olterations, including any dredging ond filling. Se,;tion 9.04.02 of the Collier County land Development Code [LDClpermit.s variQnces to dimensionol standards. incuding setbacks. The agplicont purchased 0 single family home with 0 pool and enclosure in 1994. The subject site of this varignce ~etition. located or 2454 Kings lake Blvd [folio Number 530036800051. aiso known as Kings Lake Unit 3 Block R. Lot 26. was develQlled with 0 single-fQmily home in 1983. A pool and screen enclosure was permitted and constructed in '991 by the previous owner. The screen enclosure wos d,amaged by a Hvrricone in 2005 and when the j;)resent owner tried to get it !!tl2laced in 2008. Collier County informed them that the existing pool deck and screen enclosure was encroaching over the allowed setback line. The minimum side yard setback allowed for the Kings Lake ~~- PUD is 7.5 feet which the existing lonoi encroaches by o.QProximately 2.5 feet. The minimum rear yord. ;;etbock is 15 feet which the existing lanai encroaches by agproximotely 5 fe.et. This variance request seeks to legitimize the legally constructed non-conformities and permit 1y.to minor encroachments as follows: ReQr yard 15 fee! to 10 reet Side yard 7.5 feet to 5 feet Please note that staff and the Collier County Planning Commission shall be guided in their recommendotion to the Board of zoning Appeals, and that the Boord of zoning appeals sholl be guided in its determination to approve or deny 0 variance petition by the below listed criteria (1-8). (Please oddress these criteria using additional pages jf necessa ry.) 1. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing which ore pecvlior to the location, size and characteristics of the land, structvre, or building involved. -- The origin!:ll RLQperty owner received bvilding permits for both the pool anp ",,,odQted deck Qnd I' pool enclos!,lre screen. These permits we"re further issued certificates of occupcmcy bosed on the plot I2.klO llWreseootions made at the time of bvildirJg p~rmit application. Those approvals based 00 glgn submissions were th~ b9~~S for the current owner assuming thot they meet 011 zoning requirements relotive to setbacks. The error comes to light only as 0 result of stor!!1 damage necessitating 0 replo<;ement of th~ pool enclosure screen and thus r~resents the spec:iol condition and d,n;um.stonces that ore peculiar to this .Q!.QPertv. If it were not for the storm nothing would hove surfaced to indicate thQt there were violqtion~ of Slltbacks. CleQrly vn9C!r svch circumstQnces an ofter the foct varianCe cp-provol is w!:lrrCOled. -_......--...._---~- ...~- .-.-- . ._,_~._"._.w.,_ , . eo1$tt <;Ounty - Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 29 of 52 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 2. Are there special conditions and circumstances which do not result from the oction of the applicant such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property which is the subject of the variance request. y~s. 1JllLpool enclosure screen was I~gally Rermitted in 1991. three years prior to the exi~tjng oW!:ters purchase of the home. A few Years ogo the screen was irreparably damaged by a storm condifion one;! glJe to the overwhelming amo~mt of local repairs. were ungble to get the repairs done in a timely manne~l The issue was further compounded by a contrQctor who failed to obtain 0 valid buildinQ permit.,! Nonetheless. that contractor plQced the screen enclosure in the some location that it was originally ggproved in 1991. The current owner was unaware of these conditions and assumed that c-permit to ~ICJce the scr~en would be legal based on historical facts. These are soedel conditions for which the current (llQperty owner should not be penalized. 3. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this zoning code work unnecessary and undue hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties on the applicant. DeniQI of this variance request would create an unnecessary hardshjp on the current own~r becaus~ they would be reguired to undertake a costly removal of the area of encroachment which would. substantially reduce the area of the pool and deck which was 0 part of their originolj2urchase resultina in o loss of valve to their home. The necessity for strict application of the reor setobck moreover is ameliorated iry large part by the fact thl;]f this RIQperty enjoys a relationship to a lake in the rear and thus does not adversely impact another residence by 0 diminished rear yar~. By this account 0 litero\ inter.,pretion will indeed work unnecesspry and undue hardship on the oPJilicant. 4. Will the variance, if granted, be the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the land, building or structure and which promote standards of health, safety or welfare. The voricmce. if grant~d, will be the minimum variance required to make possiQle the reosonabl~ v~e of the '\In\! and ,tructure and Rromate standards af health. safety or welfare. It shaold forther I2.!l r~coQni~ed that th~ r~g.uested variances do impact the ~ntire lot line od[~c:ent to other QLQPerty because of the angle of the lot lin~s resvltinliJ in encroahments that apply to Dort of the adjacent lot lines Oi ~i!;ted on the ollQched plot plan.. 5. Will granting the variance requested confer on the petitioner any special privilege that is denied by these zoning regufations to other lands, buildings, or structures in the some zoning district. The requested variance will only allow the pool deck end existing screen enclosure to encrooch into thj! sid.e and rear yard. It does not Qront any sQ.~k9f use or privilege to the owner that W9$ not otherwise legally permitted many years ClQO. 6. Will granting the variance be in harmony with the intent and purpose of this zoning code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. ..- ,-'-'-"~'-""""-"-''''- ., . Co~r County + '-- - Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 30 of 52 -,.~~ COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 The zoninQ code intE:nds to regulate develop-ment standards. including s~tbcJ(;ks. to avoid conflicts between structvres. The home meets all other apclicoble codes and regulations. The pool deck and screeJl litnclosvre II in hormony with th~ chorocteristic of the neigh!:>orhood Clod Ol2ProvOI of the vorionce will not Cllt~r thgt fact. It presents no conflict with neighboring ~tructures and will not be detrimental to the publi~ welfare considering tho fact that it replicates 0 condition thot had been in effect for many years. - ".- H_'p' _ _.. _._.____~_.~_~.... __ - -,_..~.~'"'-_.~~, ;~.~--'.._-'. .' . ..~_._,~___,w.._'__ ..-....-,...--. - Co~r County .. - - - - Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 31 of 52 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 7. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives of the regulation such 05 natural preserves, lakes, golf course, etc. I2.1he rear of the \vbie~t 2.[Qperty is (l toke thul omelioroting the 0irpose for which setba,ks ore gesign~ inlorQe port ond will not illJpa<;t the IQke in any WaY, 8. Will granting the variance be consistent with the growth management plan. The re..Qve.stt3d variance does not alter any allowable US~, increase density or otherwis~ alter any .mpect of developm~nt Jhot is regulated by the growth monagement plan. Legol provisions are mode for the granting of variances. The action of granting th~ variance would result in a condition of consistency with the growth management pion. 9. Officiallnferpretations or Zoning Verifications: To your knowledge, has there been an official interpretation or zoning verification rendered on this property within the last year? 0 Yes r8J No If so, please provide copies. - . eomy County ... 1:.._- - Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 32 of 52 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 V AR/ANCE PETITION (VA) APPLICATION ,-, ',' . i, ....;"... SUBMITT ALCHECKLIST . , THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. ,.'.- . REQUIREMENTS. #OF COPIES lS 1S 1 1S I 1 3 1 5 REQUIRED NOT REQUIRED ',i ~ Com feted A lketion (download from website for curren' form Pre-A lication meetin notes Com leted Addressin Checklist, Si oed b Addressin De ortment Conce tuol Site Pion 24" l( 36" and one 8 Y:z .. x 11 ,. co Survey of ropert showln the encroachment (measured in feet) Owner/Agent Affidavit 51 ned & notorized Deeds legal's Location mo Aerial photographs {taken within the previous 12 months min. scaled } ":::200' , showin FlUCCS Codesl Le end, and ro'ed boundar Electronic copy of 011 docvments and pIons (COR OM or Diskette) ~jstorical Surve or waiver reauest Environmentcllmpcct Statement (E1S) and digita1jelectronic copy of EIS or exem tion iustification Within 30 cloys after receiot of the first review comment letter, provide Pro ert Owner Advisor Letter and Cer1ificalion x X o fEJ o o o o o o fEJ I 1 (gJ (gJ 3 1 F.ES: ['gI Pre~application Fee $500.00 (Applications 5ubmi"ed 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting will be required.) Review Fees: (gJ $2,000.00 Residential o $5,000.00 Nan.Residential o $2,000.00 Sign Voriance o $100.00 Fire Review [8] After-The-Fact Zoning/land Use Petitions 2x the normal petition fee fEJ $925.00 Estimated legal Advertising Fee - CCPC Meeting ~ $500.00 Estimated legal Advertising Fee ~ Bee Meeting (any over- or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Doily News). o $2,500.00 EIS Review o $1,000.00 listed Species Survey Ilf EIS is nal required) OTHER REQUIREMENTS, o o /- ,0 / II / .' r-- ~ ( I,:'J .. ~f'" > ,tt'/'c/ Agent/Owner Signa;u" -- 2.X(Y::; Date '---_.." ..., ,-~.,..." , . . I COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVelOPMENT REVIEW WWW.COLLlERGOV.NU 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 (239) 403-2400 FAX (239) 643-6968 Agenda Item No. 7A January 12. 2010 Page 33 of 52 I ]gL Dimensional VA-PL2009-1162 REV: 1 KINGS LAKE UNIT 3 LOT 26 DATE: 8/31/09 DUE: 9/15/09 VARIANCE PETITION Dale: ~/J?7/~;me: J l/s;.,m / l 2.'-fS-,,/ ?..'-f5''1 /A IrJ:&-s t-A/'-,;::<, hft1?PI) f];sh6j2 Phone: (j,YJ:: 9!Yfi"') ~iYJS, :h~cz. r1Tili-fd-1 r"'. $"__ C.'_Lai1F"::> 12i.2u Owner Name: E 1- v..C' i2R.mr+':\L.,/~F ~ - B~ Owner Address: Zti57f 0if1'f" i.. A-v.f---::<> J?/ye1J Phone: Meeting Attendees: (atta,h Sign In Sheet) PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES * & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Assigned Planner: rY7pJ I_S~,^-_ 7 (~""e Project Addr/locatian: ;/;; ~ 1-11~c5bjueL h/,teL . Project Name: Applicant Name: Firm: Current Zoning: NOTES: . . . t. a "'17) I.{f'-r(/R~ (Sf,L'''''h-R..,.,..... R,("'('-.'>.!"-OI._/) ~ 1 (- .;T F--i'Vl f' h1('lTY"V": r,"'t- . [.2), (~ - tt; -cJ;?~ . If telephone pre-application meeting is held, direct the petitioner to coordinate with Linda concerning the requiremenT for the peliTioner to 5end the notice letter to The 5urrounding property owners or to give them that information that Lindo typically provides them 1 - -- -".-.-. "_"C"o_,.4='-''"''''M ."'0_.....,.,....,.,,-.,.....,_.". . ~"__"N'___""___",_""__",,,_,~_,_,,,,_,, O'..O'.... . , J - .- Agenda Ilem No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 34 of 52 VARIANCE PETITION (V A) APPLICA TlON SUSMlnAL CHECKLIST THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW WjCOVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTAlS WILL NOT SE ACCEPTED. -. . - # OF NOT REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED Completed Application (download from web5it!..f~ curr~!,,!_!~rm) 15 ~- Pre~Appticotion meeting notes 15 Co'!'E!eled Addressing Cheddls!, Sianed by Addressing Depart~,,-nr I -::::t.- 15 Conceptual SHe PIon 24" x 36" and _~~B_Y2 " xli" cOPL ~ . ,. . Survey of property showing the encroachment (meosured in feei) 1 i,,__..__ -...-- - --.._--_..~. .. Owner/Agent Affidavit signed &.. notariz.ed 1 .2S Deeds/legal's 2 ^ location map I ---^ -1 Aeriel photograp"s {token within the previous 1 2 months min, scaled 5 1 "=200'}, showing FlUCCS Code~!.t~~enp!-.~ndJ?roiect ~~n_~or~_ I --;.... -'--- I Electronic copy of all documenh ond plolU {CDROM or Diskette) I '.'- I -l _O'_-------<~-- , Historical Surveyor waiver request . ____ I I I ;A-.. -..-.-O'-- _..._O'_.._O'___ ^ ----_.._-------- Environmentollmpoct Stotemel'Tt (EIS) and digital/electronlc copy of , .7--. i ~~~!.~_~ptjon _i.!:J~!~J_~'?tjo~ 3 _. . -^--._O'_~~_.-.__..._-~~ _~ , Within 30 doys ofter receipt of the fir~f review comme'lt letter, rovide Pro. erty Owner Advisor letter cnd Certification Proiect Narrafive 15 X-- Send copy of review packoge to Robin Singer, Plonnin9 DirecfOrt Oty of Naples 295 Riverside Cirde, Naples, FL 34102 1 x FEES: f54 Pre-application Fee $500.00 (Applications submiHed 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting shall not be credited towards application fees and (:I new pre-application meeting will be required.) Review F~~~; f,.tt"'=.dD _ 1ll 2000.00 Re,idenriol - AFnf2- lifE. Fftc-r o $5000.00 Non.Residential I&) After-The-Fact Zoning/land Use Petitions 2)( the normal petitIon fee ~ $760.00 Estimated legal Adverlistng Fee - cepc Meeting gJ., $363.00 Estimoted Legal Advertising Fee. 8CC Meeting (over- or uflder-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Doily News)_ o $2500.00 EIS Review OTHER REQUIREMENTS, o 0._ 0_ Agent/Owner Signature Date 2 -'--O'-'---..O'.-- _.--... . PUBLIC PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS LDC 10.03.05 F.3. Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 35 of 52 ':4ny applicant requesting variance approval or parking exemption approval must provide documentation to the planning services department indicating that property owners within 150 feet of the subject site have been advised of the extent and nature of the variance or parking exemption requested within 30 days of receipt of a letter indicating that the application is sufficient." Applicant must submit a Property Owner Advisory Letter certifying that the property owners within 150 feet of the subject site were notified. Letter must have property owners list attached. Property owners list must be submitted after initial staff review and comment on the application and before the Public Hearing is scheduled with the Collier County Planning Commission. 3 - _'<'~""'_'~'<""''''''.'''''''"''_" ."____..,,.,._..o.~;..,_..._.,..._ . , -, ~ = ..... - di (l;j ~ == Q .:piiIiif ... ~ <.J ......, .,....... ~ Q., ~ ~ ~ ~ f-.' ~ W;;l .:t: en Z ~ Z " tii 00 o o N r- r--- N - rI.l = ~ = < l-' Z - .... w w ::E ... o w !( Q ~ p ~ <:u ...!:d w eo:! ::E ~ <l: Z rI.l .... ~ u w - =: ., ~ 0 '" .... ~ Gl "> Gl a::: - c: Gl E a. o - Gl > Gl o "0 c: IJ ..... ell IJl c: .- c: o N ... o - c: Gl E - ~ o a. Gl o G> c: o N D lJ) lJ) .- - G> :E a::: w Z Z <( ..... ~ o w Z C> - V) V) <( Qj r:: . > o m .. CD .- - - o u @) CD C o N C III III .- - CD E ., ., Gl ~ "0 'tJ <( - .- IJ :E . w co lot') 0- C"l I C"l lot') C"l I 0- M C"l ~ III ..Q E :;) Z Gl c: o ..c Q.. ,""",'j'.t~ . -,..."....,.."., ':'~""'r ,. '.t;:;2< :;,~..,.>j.\ "),',~y;: ", q,,', .,.'....~., ,.'., :.' ,........~.., .. ....... ,~.. :::::~':'.':; ...11),,,,., '''',' '<.VI'..'.;. ".' .;" S'~"" "'0~" , "'". ., ',',,- J~ Z_j.~ ""'f""':'F', .,.. ....... '~~~'~~ r,~1:c;.,';;"", ...... ""'~~ '. "':.'""..,.~ C::'X'''I,,);'~ -:/r,>:~::::,~; r- If:; '0 1--. Iz !Q~ <4t I~ _I t\ ~ ILI~, :0 '-' '0 I: :0 ,>- \ I- II ,,, Z "/ I:J\(~ (' .0 . '- ~ . ; <", V IL II' I I I . lA VI iw a::: o o <( I..... - '<( :E ! ,I ,W Iffi Ill:I ':E I:J z w IZ ,0 1::1: ~ w .:E <( z i ~ J '. C-1. 14- '<l I i I I , , I I , I v Q '" N - 0> > " ~ , N Q '" - '" .. '0 " "' '> " ~ 0 0 '0 f- W I W , I , I (J) z - I Z , (') I (/) - I " c I 0 N , :2 , - - C " ~ ~ ~ 0 - (') -.... ---".~._'-' . . ., " C ~~ ::r ~ <to -l I , i (~_ . ., s~ ~ .s ;::::) ~ VI - f <:l . . - - .... "--~,--- Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 37 of 52 AFFJDA VIT Well, Elke Remmlinger-Behnke as Trustee of the Bernard Schoenherr Trust being first duly sworn, depose and say that well am/are the owners of the property described herein and which is Ihe subject matter of Ihe proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest Q/1d true to the best of our knowledge and belief Well understand that Ihe information requested on this application musl be complete and accurate and thaI the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted. As property owner WelIfurther authorize Karen Bishop, PMS Inc. of Naples to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this Petition. {h L.: ~ SilJhature of Property Owner Signature of Property Owner Elke Remmlinger-Behnke as Trustee of the Bernard Schoenherr Trust Typed or Printed Name of Owner The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 00 day of ~ ,ole,r"'7 ~ 20Ql, by who is personally known to me or has produced - as identification. State of Florida County of Collier 'da) Notlry Stamp .n..'u."........."....................u_ i CHRISTINA J. FRIDLEY . ! ~~.~ Comm# 000887n& ! i ~ ExpIros5l7/2()13 I . .:i~Iot;fj7j.~ . : ~l'DI"f\: ~ Florida Ncltery Alan" Ino i . . .....".n...............................,I...I. II..... ~'1 LVU,;;JI 1 U. "'.:11"1"1 ""I'"I~ !!3S-455-030S ,..1 Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 38 of 52 r CoK~ .- COWER COUNTY OOVl!RNMINT ADDRIlIIIINCI DEPMTMENT - NORTH HORIIeItlOE DRIVe HAI'L.&8, FLOIUDA U104 (Ut) 10-2400 FlUe 1m) 10-1724 PIIW. aamlllello tIw foftowlng - ,. tD .. Addl8lllllg DlIpartmenl et 23ll-.2S2~.. or ...bmJt In p.o, """ ta IhII AcldmIIIlI lleDarI:rnent It lIle IbclYe aIreIl. . Hal .1 ..... lIlII apPI7 Il:l .veIY prajoIcl ltan.. In ...... type ... requllWd. FOLIO NUIIBI!IQ MUST BE I'ROYIllBo. I'IIIrM aIlIet lItan B month. wi' tl!t!U;,. 8CIdfIfcrlaI ........ lUId apP/'lMll j)f !he Add....I"" Oell8ltmlml - 1"ETITI0Il TYPE (''''' type below. aomt>Ivtct .-PII/8lII ArIdtvwIrrt1 CheddI<<"" fIfIdI PetitiDn CIiIII) 8L (lIaldng Perml) SOP (SllI!I Devetoprl\l>,1l PIM) liD ~ 0Dck ex.m.;"n) SOP" (SOP Amltllllmlntj Ca~ P...,e SOP' (lllIUllItlInllll Chlllge to SOp) CU (CondIllan8l Use) SIP (SlhIlmprlMIlT.u,1 Plan) EXP (ii-.tian ParrM) SIP! (lnlu1lal8ntla1 Chlnge to SIP) FP (Flnll I"fIt SNR (8lreet N1me Chlnge) UA(l.al Una Ad~rlll ~ &NC cs- Neme O"""lIe _ unp/8bd) PNC (project Name Oha"lle) Tl)R (Tr1Il1SI'er of DcMeIaprnent "lglrts) PPI. (Pllnl & PIe! AevIow) VA (VIrlIIncII) PaP (PNRmInaty Subdiwioion PIlI) 0 \/Il.P (V\IIllllatillll Rem""" Perrnitl PUD ~ B IIRSFP {Vellelellon ".InDVlll & SIa F1II P-ll RZ (8tlndard _one) OTHER . .- FOUO (pre""", IDI NUIII8ER(a) of _ove (11t1lCl1 to, or 11$0_ wlIIl, ., demlpUo~ If _ trip one) 53Q038llDQ2i STREET AOORESS or ADDRESSES (..~. IffllrHdyl~ ~ KJ/{qe lAKE. QLVQ . LOCATION MAP mUll be IIlt8eI\8d lhowI~g _1ace\llm 01 projectIIl~ 'n I8lalIon 1<> neBI'I6l public I'OIId rtllhl. tiI_ . SURVEY (capy - needed only Iar unplatted proptr1!el) PROPOSED PROJECT NAMIi (ff IIppJit:tlble) l1la PROPOSED STREET NAMES (If app/jeel*) ~ SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER (lor .lCleting pro/Etailltn only) SO/" . or A''''' - VA-PL2009-1162 REV: 1 KINGS LAKE UNIT 3 LOT 26 DATE: 8/31/09 DUE: 9/15/09 - ----_.._,,-_.~ ------ . u__'.._________." '_..... - ..... "3B-~55-030S ".2 Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 39 of 52 Ccntnty COLLER COUNTY COYERNMENT ADDItISIlNIIIlEPAlUMENT 1- NOR.TH HORlIelHOll DIIlMi NAPU!a, FLO"IDA 34tH (13" 2112-2410 FAX (n., 251-4724 praJ-ct or ....Iopo- d nem.. P/DPOI8d lor, or 81,_dy _lIring In, condlllnln/~m a_ (ll' applioatloll; irldlC8te .....0 . ~ or .......,) Ple_ CIlock One, I!lI C~eclclIsl15 11:1 be F8x.cl b8ck o P""Ollllft~ Piok.d Up AI'PI.ICANT NAME: ""ONE 23 FAX 239-435-g~ Signlllure on Addresclng Cheokflst does not constJtute Project anet/or Street NIme Ilpproval .nd is SUbject to furhr review by the Addl'888ing Department. FOIt ITj\fF USE ONLY A.N N........(Pltlll8')', 5'2..00 ~'lSOoo 5 Fon.. NIIlnIIer Folio NumIMr Folio NumIMr ~by: Upcl.... br: . t'\..-~ ~ 0... ""'" DM: O~ - C-7-o'i . DeW: IF OLDER THAN 8 "ONTHS. FORM MUST BE UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED ,{J M ~-:':~~~~9 .,.,~o;.,..~~., . -. -' ." .- ....,... ...'~-' Zi ,'-.-.... ", . ~~ . ._...'.~J .., w o 4 ~ ,.-- "' ~ '" 8 o ~ .. J ~ f"l'\ . ~ - .- ;; ;;; - f4( ii$f -< f:pt ~ ~ I-r4 ii$l .' .l ~ ~. ~ ~. .. . . ' ..;:0. 1 . , . tt;: , " - ", . . ,. t . . .. /.. 1"" i ~ i.'~ z ,.: z o - .. '" ... III II. o ~ .. III ... ~ :z: .. ::J o III ... :z: .. II. o .. !oi "- II. o Z o - III > - o m ::J III '" ..---iI,-..... ...O"'r',- g,v.)",- , ,.... ---:.;:</ ,- ; <; I -f.::!_.,,Af \~ 11~ I: If'~ ;:2 c....(i'~ /;0' -"-____ -C\!;;~ -- c. ~-, ,~ .'~,i -. ,. " ", " 1;>.1\ ,....:. - - . e.. . ! .. .. .t .1 '" ',. 1",..... t .. ._ l- ,t t ," ~.!l It ~l ,j i~. ,'.ro" .r-H. ',1 ; .~,l ., I .Ii..' I .: ~ ,I. -,' g~~ kll~t ~-:: i ':~....J, 'Ilit~~~ .:-:::~:~ 8~::.~h1it:i '8:::~ "a;;:Ji lids: !~i,h,,~,~ 'g~l:.IJ' \f~i:~ i ~~ "3~~ 'e~=a; ll;:k~ llj;:8rt '&;.~"i 8i.~; 2iJ:~~ t:fal !..~! :':!~~! :::'!i ! e!~!~ ~~~~ tt'i~ :il'~::~ d~! :::~l!~ ~':"I~ ~~~t~ ::;~,~ 8~;:.~ :::~~ !r:;,"~ ~~~~ :t~~ ::?Ii~ ;.:;":'~~ J:r:~~ ':;~:! ~;~!!~ ,;;";ot i~*;!- ..~., "~'. ".'. ..,." ..,,, ..... ..~.. ...... ....., --.-... ..,., ...., ...., ....., ..... ..... ..,., ",". ..,., ..,....,., "," ,,' .. ..... -... ...~... .....~"." ,,,.. ." ..~,,, ..,,,.~ ....~h ..w....~ ''''''" ...~w ....~. ....", ..~". ...."h .....,........ ... '''''' .. .. '''' . ...... ......~ .......... . ~ . .. .. ~ ~ .: .. 11\ <l '" .. .. ..- '" .. .: . 01 III '" ~ . ~ ~ ~.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .... ... . , . . - . . . - , " o , Q ~ ~ ~ 4 ~ ~ .. ," l' .. .. t l' ., · -, ,l -,\ . \ . -, -I ._,.~,_ .~.,. .1I1...'l. _.~r .-.~il'.._~..._.11 .. :~~ .-,.:;li:'i h=l .IIM, 1.::% -i~~;i t:h; a;;t..i ,':;2'; ~~! ==~i! :"'~t~ !~! .::~i! :::~~"il! h~":'! ~t'l!;.! l!t~J~ . ~", -.... w ""'.. ..,... ..,., . ... '" ..,... ..,.. ....., ..., ..,..,,,...,,'......,....... ...",........"...........". .' 1J31.lVl-d 10N , ~ o " , , . - , ,- ;>=l . ~, . . , - , . . . . , . w- oo. ~. -" " . >, ., '..c-';) W. . u - <~ u. 0_ . . ... . , ~........ - 1-- . , . . , "'I~ '- o ~ ~ ~ . J ~ 5 " . , . . . . . , . , . , . . " . .'11 to. , 1l1l.^'J1no. :I".' lJ .......n.../11 . ,,- .. . . . . "ij. . . ... , fD 1\I . a: , . ... i!l "' . J ..'.. ..."'.,......". m - o III . o III , .. . , , - I.""'''''' :.......-........"'. -- . I '" . , . . . ! , .. .........,.. . ! ..:::: ~ . '" o - a: o ..J II. '. ...... " .. '" ' .,. .,. ~ " ~.. ,- .,.~ ) ~ . ,"...-- . . , :!: :: , . . . . i~ .' , , , . l~ If '81. i if. . '.' , . . - . . >- .. Z ::J o '" a: ... - ..J ..J o '" i . .. . ~ 4 .. .'. . - . , , , , " . . . , . "" .. , . .' ~~ {~~~~ ,...~' . . . , .', ~ II' . " = 1.>:, ., 0, "'_ D . .. .. ",.. . ~ ::,. .'. , ,. ~;~ ~ 1:',8, ,.. ;' l~\ '. " . . u . . , . ...',....< '",,''''' - . . 0- ," ~;; . . _...... - .,"'," N" .' ., -:1 , .. , T. .....,,..'..." ~""or ....::...., .- . . . -l ~'R . . . -ala - , ........'..... , ,- . . ....,.-....~ .,. . . , , . . . o , , . . . . J o W ~ ~ < ~ " . m , , . - . . , >, . 0 ;1 . . , -......., -;:;;''''.'''If , ", I. , _'u .. . . " o z . - 'tttt. ri~~! . -~'.. -'.'.. ,",,'U. , _.W'''';''''' . . . . . . , . . ~ r~ '. . . . ~ . . . " . . . . , U"UO ~,'" "-,<> j- ~I _._~- -"-", 11'!'lI " - - - .......,""... ", .~ j_<>4 ~~"":t~~t""-)! 0;"'0 ;"'Qt-""~;": .. . ... .. .. .. .. .~.. e - .. . - .~ :_~ ~. _... ""... ""'.... """" ""... H_" ........ . . . , . , - . , . -. M/~ ,tool Olln:ilnOI ;IN." ,"OHIN ",u,-",.o'.,...-..o," , , . -: -....l-~ '-t:I.. .. '; ~ I "".... ....- -- (: -~ -- -.- . . , . .'. , o . .' .;;:1 <<".. '" ....... -.. ...... ........ . , .. n__.......+.____..,.., _..-_""'.,ul..--.----- r-.~l'j";i::"~-~~i; i;;.t:H,-~-'; C'l i 61 : ,: :.1.1 PI':;;I. tool , " 1 , . , 'I ~:: :' I' ~: ",/.-' : 1 ' :: .,ri., f.'>.....'..., : ! : I'" tI . " <l '::l 11 "'; I ':)1( lINn C:ltl""3);Y~ . . , ...1___..'-_.....1___._.__. , .. 1 , ' , ,'..u_.L..___,_____c__ , I' ,~,,---_..,,-~-- L_....__.. __......~__'..__'._~__ - . , - . ,---'-----..... ",,'r.. --. -.".._-_.~-~....,,--- ---","~---" "-,-- , January 12, 2010 Page 4 of 52 , c:I [ LAKE TRACTD (DRAINAGE EASEMENT) - -<;'l\:: -, PROPERTY / UNE----" , ,s' :><;' -, I 10.503' I 11i21 I APPROXIMA1t] TOP or 3ANI<: pu,E-l . F R ~ - C2 II I . L - - - \ \ I , lOCO , 17.!l7' ~ \ ~, " \ . .,-su: , \ roGE or CONCReTE POOL DECK -~- \ ,\ \ o. \ \ - 1/ \1 , Stl<;J;.: .". Xl' - . , ~ET...tl SCREENED CDNORElE~ POOl DECK I - - . _..- ,..p.t.J...... '^'<><" ~ (,0,' -,~. )1- EDGE or SCREEN CAGE '''''- I ~... l' .. \ \ '{l. , ~. - ~ '<>-\ . - '>>.... "'. I , U:)T 27 DETAIL NOiTOSCALE p'J,r---J I I LOT 26 .l.Pr'ROX LOC,oTlON EXISTING 1 STORY BUILDING (2454 KINGS I.AKE BLVD) \ e\ \~ \~ BLOCK "R" '. ;0 " 8 - L,OT Z5 ~ i!i 0 , ~ - 10.0' \ , 1C:.D'p.l},E. I \ \ .....-50 I ' / ~ / \ / (EXISTING DRIVES. WALKS AND UllUTlES fJOT SHOWN) "j, , , / / ./ !l.D--.J , I I I I ~s_o I I , / / - / 274.73" (I') 274.73' (M) I 11 o. -10 . a . . cIN C .,. gl I 'co " M - - - - - - c3 \ I \ N04.4'J4'2ttw "'00 / \ ~ ~ 37 _ 16' \ C' ~ - --------- - - - - .. ~I :z ~! .. => Q P.CP. f.l.Il. 10 G' P.u E..., '- L 1 - ~FI..- \ - - - - - ---.---...: 1'89"55'41"[ (BASIS or BEARINGS) -- . :'-. ,./" -- KINGS LAKE BOULEVARD B"" RIGHT-OF-WAY (RO~DWAY NOT S~OWN) - - ~--- -- - - \ :""CT S - - T - - - \ LOT 4 I LOT 3 BLOCK "0" , LEGAL DESCRIPTION NOTES: LOT 26, BLOCt( P, KINGS LAKE UNIT No. 3 ACCORDING TO THE 1:> lFIS SURVEY WAS PREPARED SPEClrlCALLY AND EXC~USIVELY TO SHOW PLAT THEREOF RECORDED IN PLAT BOOl< 1.3 AT PACES 33 AND D1E RLLATtQN$HIP OF TI1( FIELD LOCATED POOL AND POOL DECK TO TI-lE 3~ or THE PUBUC "tCORDS or COLLIER COUNTY, ,LORin.... FIE_O LOCATED BOUNDARY or LOT 25. BLOCK R. KIi'jGS LAKE UNiT No J 2) BEARINGS SHOWN HEREON P(rEl< TO THE CENTERLINE or KINGS LAKE LEGEND BLVD. KINGS '.ME UNIT No .3 ACCORDING TO THE PLAT T>-1ER[Or A5 PtCORDED IN PLAT BOOlf 13 AT PAGES 33 Il.ND 34 or ~E PUBUC: "'ECORDS - 0 !'RU, 0 PER~ANDJT R[FERENCE MONUMENT or :::OLLlER COUNTY, FLORIDA, w FOUND 4",,,- CONCRETE MONUMENT (SROKEN) < pcp, . rOUND PERMANENT CONffiOL POINT :.\) THIS PRO"(FH" IS SUBJ(CT TO EASEMENTS. RESERVATIONS OR e (5/B" IRON ROD WoTM "'LUMINUM CAP) 'i:ESTRICTIONS OF RECORD N . , , 0 FOUND 5/11- IRON ROD (NO 10) o ! PUE.. "'U8U: UnU7Y EAS[I.-1[NT " ) DI"~NSIONS SHOWN HERroN ARE IN ""En AND OECI~ALS THEREOF. . '" INCORPO!;:ATrO g '" "" PROfESSIONAl. SUIiV[YOR "NO MAPPER 5.) THiS SURVEY IS NOT \lALlD I',Ol"HOUl THE SIGNATURE At_O THE ORIGINAL '" " LB, LlCfNSED BUSINESS RAISED SEAL or A FLORIDA UC[NSEO SURII(YOR AND IotApoER. N , FJ,C. FLORIDA A.OMINiSTRAT1\IE COOt . (P) PLAT PRINTED 6} FOUNDA.TI01,S BENEATH THE SUR> ACE. IF ANY, Ht> \IE ~,OT BEEN LOC/lTEO" , (hA) ME"SURED , CERTIF1ED TO: . '" '-f '.j' .. 200.g , ',),-- . 1) "'Me; I"'C, Of" NAPlts 0 . , LINE TABLE BBLS SURVEYORS & MAPPERS, INC, 7 , LINE BEARlr-IG DISTANCE CERnFICAnON: wi ~I " N89055'~1.E 22 7~ HEREBY r::::RTiFY ~HA7 il"'IS SPE.CIFIC PURPOSE SURVEY WAS SURVEYED ., " S9S'55'~I"W 2273 " UNDER MY R[SPGNSIi3L[ CHAPG( ON 09/28/09 THIS SlIRV(Y ;,IEETS lHE. " MII~lhIIU.. TECH>.:ICAL ~T~NDA"DS SET FORn; BY THE FLORIDA 80ARD OF . 0 " CURVE TABLE PROF<:SSIDNI\l LAND 3URV[YO,"S IN CHAPTER 61GI7-5. ,A,C PURSUANT "' TO S~.D~jj~77 n?'7 >1 ~I\ STHtJTES , " CURvt RADIUS DELTA CHORD CHORD SEARING ~ENGn; . "' ~-::. ,,;I-."/~ - " 2nOO 44':\O'00~ 20598 N67'40'4-0"E 2112.'\ c .~ C2 9500 25'52'51. 4255 1<76'59'15 5"~ ~2.91 c 51EP"E,~ E. BE:P.PY, ",T.:..rr QF ,LORIOA, (P L S 1I~296) "' '.:':\ 23000 25"52'51" 10.301 N7fo59'15"[ 10.389 c BelS S~j;>V!:YC;;:S & Mf...?"[RS INC" (L,B #6753) .. . b SPECIRCPURPOSESURVEY BBLS SURVEYORS & "' ~ . "- w "' . a "' MAPPERS INC. e ,. 0 , LOT 26, BLOCK R, KINGS LAKE UNff No.3, PLAT BOOK 13, N "' w 1502-A RAILHEAD BL VD. , ., , , , "' g, . 0 PAGES 33 & 34, A PORTION OF SECTION 7, , ! "' ." . , NAPLES. FLORIDA 34110 i , ~ . ~ TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, " 9~ i " ~ . (239) 597-1315 < IE" . 0 COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA I Q Q "' Current Ownership Property Address 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD Property Record ., I Sketches I ~ ~ Parcel No. 53003680005 - Owner Name REMMLlNGER-BEHNKE TR, ELKE Addresses BERNARD SCHOENHERR REVITRUST UTD 1113198 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD City NAPLES State FL Le9.1~ KINGS LAKE UNIT 3 BLK R LOT 26 Section Township Range 7 50 26 Acres 0.26 Sub No. "'" u Use~~...t KINGS LAKE UNIT 3 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL 436900 1 2007 Final Certified Tax Roll (Subject to Change) If all Values shown below equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll Land Value S 241,718.00 (+) Improved Value $ 226,595.00 (=) Just Value $ 468,313.00 (-) SOH Exempt Value $ 0.00 (=) Assessed Value $ 468.313.00 (.) Homestead and other Exempt Value $ 0.00 (=) Taxable Value $ 468,313.00 --'" .-t == 'Save Our Homes. exempl value due 10 cap on assessment increases. Date 11/2000 07/1994 I The Information Is Updated Weekly. .~-. Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 ,:i Page 42 of 52 Zip 34112.5400 Map No. 5B07 Strap No. 436900 R 265607 I _ -,- .....-._-q- --,--_..'~ - ".,._-~.,,'._-._.." ,....--.-- .I'll MIII.I"' Are. 124 ~ M!I!P9t 11.5734 latest Sales History Book - Page 2740 - 2611 1969 ~. 665 Amount $0.00 $ 200,000.00 YA-PL2009-1162 REY'1 OKINGS LAKE UNIT 3 LOT 26 ATE: 8131/09 DUE: 9/15/09 ""'Cloooo," COWER , a...~ florf~. 'II'Ulor, ... ....Ilcb../Ir lid IIkIlltmmIllIpr 1IU_b. Tl!llulc I. allumoa each It 10 aft .ndltl~ec1 Q 0 !OI1oIfntI, :v ~ tD~ - "_IoMlp...ZeDarRla'IdI<648CtoPllh,lIeIllo,Ca""a., g 0\ ;:J;Ul ""'o,..1laiI1 , "-"r~ c.n..., ,,....Ift, ~ ...6t0lANrD..........- .\......DlI..." ....................................... .. ................ ......TEN' I: NO/l00($JO'OO}............ ...... ................... DOUAKI, ............."'llh- ....~It OMHroa .....,pIU.,. D~ .........,II..n"r.,. ~.. "....,...... r............ GIAHI'eI aM! ORAHn!Bt ..bI.I4.......r."'~....'V\11'-l,tlJ1IIM. lOt.......,Io..._.. COLUl!:a ...... florIda ''''t !<It 25, 81oolt., k11l9' Lalcl Unit No, " accordinlJ to plat rlcorded 1n Pllt 'oole U, p09" 33 .od 34, Publio Rlcordl ct C01111' County, rlorida, . o 18~3723 COlliER COUNTY , arr&nty Deed INT . - . : 53003&.OD05 IND -. III 'lit t!>>J,(f/IJ. f!J 'NI~ lIaIolWI I~ u,oI VIqIaJa r. PIl .... .nll'tlllnled wftlow, Benr.e. 9~,.." , , RECORDED JII, ,1'~A.D., . Bubjlot to r'"tr!otionl, rlllrvatioOI .nd ......nts of rlcord, it any, and tax.. .ub"'lIIsnt to 1993. . .r-. ~ :~ ~ I\-.:tl,':.: i'/'~9:9"\'~"l:fLI.'rJ' :U"I' 1':1: R~'th;,.~ S ',::,':; T l"'hl\qlUt dk....I',n,..t'l rrt'prrl1 h, PiJ" ", tl.Oft., elm: Or (JUIIIT eMf . I L~ /k"l , ([-It.. ",,, ,19J4 It July - n1Jr\ '''. I"Dr. lIMIIN.r ,,\... \. ..,." 'DIIl "161. UN~_I........ 114".111I1 Iff"" a" t.""tl.llt1'''f\~lfII, "'11J/ t":'.:I<'., eltli 11I1 . __ '._~ .__ ._ "."" ........ ocr... .... HOTAaV1UlUC ilM~ "aUlD--" _IW. 1l "-_1.1..6 e.,.ital II. . (4......10.. _8U .1. ::':t rot! ,......".. Agenda Item No. 7A January 12,2010 Page 43 of 52 . . . . , . . o o ~o QCO 1'I1Cl\ (II . . . n. .........,..-r 1:>......,...... ....._ .,.... .- ,.... ~'l..a "" lie: ....... 10: 2710675 (I: mo JIG: 2617 .. II' IIIIaI& ., f ., .1. -f R 11/1f/1ttl1l1l:'18 _I. _, lUll lit III 1I.1f .'.11 .11 Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 44 of 52 ",...;U_ ,r#'. .... D. Goodmaa 000-" -..t. 8nat illl Rid&cwoocI Dri.., s.~ 405 N.... Florida )4101 TeIepao..: 9011.514-4900 -: 11II I - . 1111__11II IUIII" 111I1 W.-\RIlANTY DEED (Ramal (01 Itccordwa laiOf1AaltGll) TIllS 1NDENI'IJu, -..h dW l:!.~" day of J........,.. J99I, bc:&wcea 81l'.aND 8CIIODiBI!IUI, 011<I. IIEIIND SCBONIIEIUl, . ...... "'_, OnnIor., UllI ELK/! 1lEMMLINGIal.-rBND, . 1r-, of IIlo IIEIIND SCBOII:NHEU 19911 ~TIIVST""I--'"" 1:>'~199ll, wbooe.....olf'lCC~i&:uS4K;"i. Ub 1IouJcnnI, N..., I'Iarida )4112, 0Iula:.. WlINaSaTB, nw. dill: Gndor. (0( aDd AD CO!I&IdcraIioo or lbc 5WD or TEN DOll.ARS, ODd odIcr ""'" ODd V_Ie tDDSidendoas 10 said 0nnI0r, ill hind paid by ..id o,."-.lbo ................., Is.....". ~ bu .......... harpiDed UllI sold IOI1x: ..id an..e. u4 QpI'll_'1 ftoo:. TtQn la fNIt aDd au'" rDreYer. the rouowin,a dt:seribcd land. .rt...~. I,lat ..., ....... ill CaIUet r-n....ty. Florida. ID-wit; An uadlricIod lIflJ p....... (-J, ....... .. 01 C,....-'. IDr<raIII Lot 26, lIIock R, KIop LaIto Unil No.3, a<:cordioi 10 pial mcordcd ill Pial hoot 13. ...... 33 UllI )4. Public Iloc:onl. of Collier Counry. Florida. .- suamcr TO .104b;,.n'''''. laCfVatiODl, AId ""--"IU of record, and lUes. ror year 1991 UllI ___ y..... Prior """'...- '. .........., ill a.R. Boot 1969, Paae 865. Folio 5300]680005, Asld said Gsaaror ~ hc<.:by tully w..... Ibc IilIc 10 sold lu>d. ond will c1cfcnd tl1c ...... .-phu!r die lawful dabu of aU pcnoaa wbomsoc-w:r. Tr'~<c hcn:iIl (or dlo a~"Olllm...) Is j!laIIltd lidl POwer Illd Illlhority 10 P"",,,'. c:o=-..'C, d. 1"'IIr'. --~. or ~o{nooise 10 manaae and tfil:pOK or me real propeny dc:aibcd h...~ .. ICI ford1lD AoricIi St_htl_ Sc:aioJa 689.071. Upoa . deadJ of die Dvlt.cc. lbe p..... ~"QI' IJ'!tiH(lC' u-..vl~ tJx: trua IIrecmeAl referred 10 ....... sboII he ALEXANDRA IlEMMLlNGER, UllI upoa . l<CClnlaIlOD ill UIl: Public P rordt of ~11a l""~t...,.. Plorida of a ......t\ cadlica&c of Ibe )"hi'" I:nldet. Lide 10 me land dacdbcd IadD IbaII be d .-t bdd by Ibe a~tIOf' U.ld~ wilhnl.&t Ihc need for rcconfina AIQ' IiddiIioIaI dIv...._ ..1_. -- .-. .......~...- n_...._"W' _.._--~---',._~,_. -,-'- """---~-'~"'''-- ...._-_..,,--~ Address Information Report CDPRIOOl - Address Information Report Agenda Item No. 7A January 12. 2010 Page 45 of 52 ~DR NBR STATUS 137942 ACTIVE HOUSE NBR PREFI: STREET 2454 KINGS LAKE TYPE BLVD SUFFIX UNIT PRIMARY OWNER INFORMATION NAME REMMLINGER-BEHNKE TR, ELKE PREVIOUS OWNER PITTMAN, VIRGINIA L LINE1 THE BERNARD SCHOENHERR REV/TR SUBDIVISION 988 - Kings Lake Unit 3 LINE2 UTD 1/13/98 BLOCK R LOT 26 LINE3 2454 KINGS LAKE BLVD SUB LEGAL LINE4 CITY '-"'PLES STATE FL ZIP 341120000 SLUC 1 DESCRIPTION SINGLE FAMILY FLUE ZONING PUD PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT, MIXED USES _ ..-.. --..-- PUD TAZ 137 FLOOD MAP 0392 FLOOD ZONE X FLOOD ELEV. CENSUS TRACT CENSUS BLOCK NONE NONE Collier County CD-Plus for Windows 95/98/NT Printed On, 8/13/2007 9:07:07AM Page 1 of 1 ---- ._,-_. . .~, --~_.._~.-,. . , I -..... I , I , II _m_,.__ _.<.<-_. Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 47 of 52 RESOLUTION 10- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY RELATING TO PETITION NUMBER VA- PL2009-1162, FOR TWO AFTER-THE-FACT VARIANCES: FROM THE REQUIRED 15-FOOT REAR SETBACK AND FROM THE 7,5-FOOT SIDE YARD SETBACK FOR A SCREEN ENCLOSURE OVER AN EXISTING POOL AND PATIO AT 2454 KING'S LAKE BLVD., WITHIN THE KINGS LAKE SUBDIVISION POO IN SECTION 7, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (LDC) (Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which establishes regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of tho County, among which is the granting of variances; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals, being the duly elected constituted Board of the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of a variance from the required IS-foot rear setback to a 12.5-foot setback for a screen enclosure resulting in a rear setback variance of 2.5 feet for an existing pool and patio and a variance from the required 7.5-foot side yard setback to a 5.09 foot setback resulting in a side yard setback variance of 2.4 I feet, in the Kings Lake Subdivision PUD (Ordinance No. 82-52) at 2454 King's Lake Blvd., also referred to as Lot 26, Block R, Kings Lake Unit No.3, Scction 7, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, and has found as a matter of fact that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been madc concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordancc with Section 9.04.00 of the Zoning Regulations of said Land Development Code for the unincorporated area of Collier County; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered all matters presented. V A-PL2009-1162 Rev. 12117109 I of2 '_ ..M....___._,"_..~.._.",'"." Agenda Item No. 7 A January 12, 2010 Page 48 of 52 _. NOW, 1HEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY TIIE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNlY, FLORIDA, that: Petition V A.PL2009-1162 filed by Karen Bishop of PMS, Inc. of Naples representing Elke Remmlinger-Behnke, as Trustee of the Bernd Schoenherr 1998 Irrevocable Trust, with respect to the real property hereinafter described as: Lot 26, Block R, Kings Lake Unit No.3, according to the plat recorded in Plat Book 13, Pages 33 and 34, Public Records of Collier County, Florida be and the same hereby is approved for a variance from the required 15-foot rear setback to a 12.5- foot setback for a screen enclosure resulting in a rear setback variance of 2.5 feet for an existing pool and patio and a variance from the required 7.5-foot side yard setback to a 5.09 foot setback resulting in a side yard setback variance of 2.41 feet, as depicted on Exhibit "A" attached hereto, of the Kings Lake Subdivision PUD Zoning District wherein said property is located. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to Petition Number V A-PL2009- 1162 be recorded in the minutes of this Board. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote, this _ day of ,2010. .- ATTEST: DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNlY, FLORlDA By: By: , Deputy Clerk , Chairman Approved as to fonn And legal sufficiency: Steven T. Williams s...-.... Assistant County Attorney It ./1.01 Attachment: Exhibit "A" - Survey CPI09-CPS-00982\27 VA-PL2009-1162 Rev. 12117/09 -- 2of2 ^ -. _._,- ..~'-_._~._- ",-'._~,- .-., ____ '''4'_~ .. ,,___.."~.__ ._J"" \ - " .-- /J<(I'>...... ..to r;P>/i..",',JJ \ \ ,~- -:,'~~' \ '. , \ M''''I![)Y .rl:;,\'ION \ r ~,~~ ~.N(: . ST ,Jj;' Y HOTi.DII~C 12~54 ~",IG~.' \.AK, tit ','0) \ ,,--,.-,--,"\ \ ./~~\ \ 1----- , ~" c:I '." V , }- I'" -, , " S S':AL( ,. . .30' 1 J , '5' ,AI':[ Tr,ACTO (ClRA'I~A.Gr [r.SEMENT) AF"'ROXII""TI:l 10"l)< 11"'''''' 'O,C" ,. ~-' E - i ,....-~.~ L2 ,2,".- u" , , " :'1 ~1-L.... - - ,), I , 31;' 1O.::'~' '00<. SCR~DJED PI'JOt cor.C~[j(..-J' (}(CK .> ~ '. \,!H ,!",:r LO; 25 " ?2 8 ~ '" p ~ g - " , \ , \ \ \ , l_Or 26 1(;0' "U'O;-" , BLOCK "R" ~o-'--'_. (;::X:;.''1ICfiPI"~. MJc' lHIIIf:', NC- 50 !I~.\~'- , .~.L-, "- !!il 8 "'I f:l 1i' 5[ c. --f\ I 'II' c " "r - ., Ll ] ,<I "'I' ,:;,g OIN .~ -... :'~t :'74 7~' (p) ,"'.Ci> , - -.--------- NSS'''5o'.tI"T ;,,"<;1;; Dr "i/."I"(:'>; ~71, 7J" (101; . KfNGS LAKE: BOULEVARD '\4' PICHT-O>-WA" :RCj!,~WAY I:OT SHOWN) b. fA January 12, 2010 Page 4, of 52 , / _,c/ _'\ \ PPDi'un"', ~INT -/ - - /"/ . I...g~' / \ / - /' \ _Cl':/" ./ , t::'...';:: "" r\p .' c ...-r'--.e.e.' ,. " ~'-srL ['~TA!~ - .' eDGE O. CONCRETE ~ r:>l)'X DECK '\_-----=:;;: ~------ ./ \ '\\:' \y,_ J: ','./ \ \ .-",/' P'.J,( " " '. EDGE , Df SCR[EN--- CAGE , , '~.79' \ LO--r '2.7 DETAIL Nl)TW"CALE . . ,. , -'00' pU.E. \ \ \ ~-5,O \ - , . , / .- f / / - / / // I"CP~'c-o :/ "'~~~ >~ /' /" .. /' '-. N44'~\4':W"W 137,16" ",.),: ~ WAU'.1:O r,1'n~.,.) / . - - f .. _f , c' \ \ , c\ .. \ \ .~~ un , \ '\" ~\ / ./' / -------- - , \ \ / , \ \ , .-I' /- '\" \ \ , \ . , 1_0-' 5 /.-;-- . .. -' .. -.- .. .. -- f- .. \ , :"OT <l. \ c:-:- .1 C3,--OCe< "C/' LIOGAL DIOSCRIPT!OI!. LOT 26, bLOCK R, I(I~;:;':". tAKE v.r N". 3 ~,CCOROINC TO THE PLAT 11-l~'lED' Pu'ormEll IN Pl.A' BOOK 1~ A: P~GES 33 AND 3-' OF TH[ "jR'_IC f<r(:C\RDS or CC;UER COUNTY. "Le'?IDA LIOGIOND PFHA 0 PCP * FLRMN~EN7 :~r;t:W:W:T '}(JIJL~;NT '--OU~,[; 4"x4- ,~OI,CflrTt l.'OMWHH (8Rl1"nn F';JlHlt; F[PM'v4,TJ' :OIHRClL C')If.;T (5/6"' :F;Cl" ,wo wm' ALL.~AI~~'J" C,~"') F':JUfj[} ,,/5" !p-:)r, P()[j U,K: I~) F"~BlIC ~;,ILlTY ::"Sr:J![~T 1~'-::QPf'OR.'TLD PPGI'E':"SO~~L SCI"V["OR Mol,! MAPFER LCil;src, []U::::f JESS F,C!R!QA t,[lMIN'~;Tf'P"iVECODE PRINTED I,IR 0 RUE t~,C .~ S M, eR C',\C- {P) (>.i) "LA" MfJ~'-!",O LINE 'C :)[, 200g L/NIO TABLE eeLS SURVEYORS. MAPPERS, INC !lEAPING DISTANCE NB9'5~:t.1'E :;273 se9'~0> 41"-'" 22 73 l: CURVIO TABLIO CURVE RAQiUS C' 27:::00 C' 9500 "' co 23(1(:0 DELTA 44'30'00" CHORD l1URi'1C '-67'40'4:;)"'': N"'G'5~'\'J S"[ ~E:~GTH :'::1'25 4?gl 10:;[19 ~<'C~"' ,- "~.'. :'J1 CI-jOCfC 20535 47.55 'CUOl N 7 r '~i~;'l ::''[ 2 :..~,:::' 51" NOTES: ~i TI"IS SUP"":Y WAS "'RtF'AR:::D SP['::I"'ICM.LY AND rXCLUS1\/rLV TO SI.I:,JY! H[ f<EllI":ONS'-!IF' 0"- TI" F'['J) LOC/,"TSC' DOOL M,JD "OOL D[Ck r" T''1E FIELD :.JC,\~E:;J BC-~JI';DAf<Y at LOT 2G, BLOCK R, ".I,<CS LAKE UNf- Me 3' 2, 8[ARIIJGS SHOWN --I[R~0r~ R[Fi:R TDIHE:[t\'lT.R~lolf Of KII'.G5 '-ME f';\/D" K'i1,JGS_;,KF UNIT No 3ACCOIi:f1"N[;WTHEP"ATTHEfi[OFAS ~~C:()RCED I'~ "'~Al 8::l0K 1_' AT ""FeE;, 3:, ,",ND 3.1 or TYE F'L'8~'C ;','cop,s iy-:-OLl'[;,/ ::OIJNTY. FLJRIDA, . ~ 3:, HilS ~"O"LiiTY 10. SJB,ilCC- ,(' FAS'::MF:NTS, R;:S[R'It--IO~IS OR P;:STPI~T~'~'HS N R~CCRD. -, J DI\'EHSIO',S SflOWN HEREON ARE IN [[[- AND DECIMA:"S ,H[2:':OF :,,) TYISS,iRVEY 1S NOT VAliD 'NiHOU, ,YO: SIGN^l:JRE At,Q THL DRIG'NAL P'I,SF.D "EA~ 0"- A FLORIDA lICt'-!SE[) c;JRVE"'OR AN(: MA?I-'EIl L ) FOL,\~Cf,"C'I". SF'-JEI,lH ,II[ SJR"AC[, iF ,~NY, HI\\/[ l,nT DED,J ~JC;ln:) , CERTfFllOD TO, I'I"/SINC; :Jr,,,,.,'"'L[5 CIORTIFICA TfON: IJ"RF[lY ;:i-i'iFY "'--.1" ;'i"',S Sf'[CiFle =':JRPOSS SU'<VEY WAS 9'::1\1--\,"''' lll,['ER ',IY ~CSPC:'tJS"Ll c:~",,,~[ Of- 09/;:S/0.. T-JIS S'';R'/fY I/~[TS Tf"'l 1.j,I.Jlf,I.'M ~'[.:f",,:^L ,;,~N)AP.;)S SET F:JRW t:!Y T'-1t F"l8R!')f. 80,'F,j or . -'i>Of-''':S,ONfll : "'~,[; :;,!P"/::TC"Z II, :f'^P'CR ;;lC~;-6, ,A. C '"'IJ"C:UANT '0 "';:"""1 ':".'J.["2,.C...rL:;g" SrAll.m:s .::... =- _f" ~ I _.,.,._.!!l '~~k r~~~;-c" ~ o<i;:"W'" .o~;'>[ f)F ~-L::81~iA, (r" L S 1;578[>) ~FL:: '",I'tI\'?"l'"'' ~ MP.,,,r'l'3 NO _ (L S 1!67':D) , . ~ SPECIFIC PURPOSE SURVEY BBLS SURVEYORS & " . ~ < W . 0 ~ C ,< 0 , MAPPERS INC. , LOT 26, BLOCK R, KINGS LAKE UN" No, 3, PLAT BOOK 13, '- 0 0 "' - " !~ > ~ PAGES 33 & 34, A PORTION OF SIOCTfOIV 7. 1S02-A RAILHEAD BL VD, m 0 '- , ~ . ~ NAPLIOS, FLORIDA 34110 ~ 9' TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGIO 26 IOAST, ~:;i ~ . 1 < 'J" COLL/IOR COUNTY, FLORIDA (239) 597-1315 . " EXHIBIT A ."., ',' ';"~., " "'-. , r/ ~-' ; , , ) Ie\. '", L-"KE WAC' G (tjRAIl;lAGf C"SEMtNT) APPf.::::WIJAn:J TOrJ or SA"': IO,O'I'W.!::."" rr i 1"''-\1.,- C2 I I ./ :21.2\ 1-. - - OJ; ,( I - . ::-eAl;:!;; " . 30' r-L~..E-I o 1~' , , .W 10.53' , PiJOL Agenda Item NO.7 A January 12, 2010 Page 50 of 52 - PROr,ryr" , LlI.;rJ - - / / l)['U,"- " J . SCREENED CDNCRE1E~ ;>00'.- DECK -- . ..--" ~t."v'_ _.,0 .to ~O"v' " < ,.... 1'1.-"' '" .. 'l.-'t-'" I 11.97- \ , \ \ L.OT 25 /lPilROlL ~QCt.. 'lrlN [X.S1INC' STOflY f1U\tD,N(> i' ~I! ?;i ~ -, , I 1110' P.U.L-1 _-J LOT 25 ~o-' 1-5.0 I ([~SllN(: DRIVES, WN.K5 AI.lD Ul1l'-'E'!> Nor SHOWM) ,. BLOCK "R'" - ltlO~'-~.t1-,_ L1 F:P, \ , , , :;eol . ""9 ,-!,., . . OIN o' g, I "~,, 4-"'=::'':- ..- ~ Cl: ~I ill n1 gl f.I,R L01' 27 DETAIL .~--- NO~ ~( :;,.,\lE SL\IO) ....LI.E, '" / // / , f.l,R /' "p~< ~"'C>r<S"<<" / /'( /' W4~",~~,'2r:~w ',3'7 Hi' , .- - ,- -- .- . . c' \ \ -, ~ "'A.OO \ '( ~\ \ \ \ \ LeT " / - ----- r_c.". NB~"i5'41"t ~Hn' (P~, -- --- /./ ;61\;;'15 tY !J[ARIi'iGS: ;:7~ ;;:' {M) ,_. . .- KrNGS LAKE 80ULEVAFUJ !ll' P1l;I'IT__'Y-WA'I' /P.~'P0''''A'' Wl' 3'1tlW'.> /' - - - .- ---' - - T 1 ~- \ \ OCK "c!" I ----- --' - LOT 3 3.. LEGAL DESCRIPTION '_OT 26, 8LOCK P. KINGS LAKE UNIT No. J ACCORDINC TO ,HE PLAT ,Hm::QF RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 1.5 AT PACES :>3 AND 34 Of THE PUBLIC RECORDS or COLLIEP COllNn. FLORIDA, LEGEND '" RM. 0 pCP . ;,Ifl. 0 p,u.L INC. P S.M. , " F .ft"C. (P) I") P[RMANCN1 REFERHJCE MONUMENT FOUND ",,,,..":ONCR[T[ u()NUI,lENT (8ROKEN) FOUND f'ERMANENT Co'l1FlOl POINT (5/8" IRON ROD W'TH ALUMINUM CAP) FOUND 5/6~ IRON ROD (t>Jo 10) PUlOlIC UTILITY ::t.,SEMENT I'lCQI'PORATfD PROFr::SSIONAL SURVLYOR t,NO ;';,APPER L1Cn~SEC BUSINESS ~~~~IOA AO'AINI$lRATlVE CODE PRINTED I.IEASUREO SEP ." 1009 LINE TABLE 6BLS SURVEYORS' MAPPERS, INC. flfl,'W.G DISTANCE '169.':;:;'1,1"[ 7.2:3 SSY'S541'W 2zn LlN[ " " CURVE TABLE CURVE RADIUS DELTA CHORD CHORU BEARING l(NG11-I " 272.00 4-4.,50'00' 205.>l6 t-l67.M)'40"E 21',25 C2 95.00 25.52'51" 4-255 tHE'S9'\Sc."t ~ 2,9' c, 13IJOQ 2~,.~;~'51" 'O:Y01 N75.~9'15"[ 10."'>-89 - LOT 4 NOTES: -"--- 1) THiS SURVEY WAS I'REf-ARCD SPECIFICAllY ANO rXCLWSII/Ei..Y -C):S>C'.\J 1HE R[LAT,Qr,SHiP OF THe FIELD LOC:ATEt:' POOL ,Hm POOL DECK 10 1d[ fiELD lDUTET) S(YJNDARY 0, .01 21..', BLOC~, R, ..!I,GS LAKE \IN'7 Ne, :: ~', O"rnp,rIC,S ,,"':.)1'>1'1 Htf\:EO'; FlI;->rJ" TO T4( Cf'I-r,;f'LiNi 0' .,1:(;" c,\,.r P'YC. V.'hIC5 .i>-KE r"'~ ~<>. } .o.;;CC-Rl'"I-Ir. m nit "I.A~ h'tIU:O' !.c; 1,;:C<:'/''')[l'' ,~ p,./>' H:"lO~. ::3 <11 pi<,rs..D ^IW J~ -')I"'\.. HJfI,lc '~~C(,F!PS '.:'0[' ca'_~!;::R C.CiIY;T~, '1.0RII1A ..i) TH'$ rR:Y'[RlY IS SUBJECT TO C."SCMENTS. RCSEf1VPIONS DR Rr:$1RIClV,~I::, 0' "[CORD '..) QI'AEN'iIO"i:; ShOI'lN ~:CREO~ ARE :N ~[E': A~iD DECIMA:..::; 1H(PiOf, :;.) -,,'is SUJ<VEY IS N(;.T VALID V~THOUT ~W. SICNATURE AND ,HI, ORiGiN,~L Pft.lSET SU'l 0' ^ F:"ORIDA UCENS(;) SJ'lV"VOR ,\ND MJ>PP;::R G) rc-uPC,o.Tl0t,,; PENEATI-l THE SURFACE. 17 AN'f, H"VE NO~ ;<E:N L(l~AT;::CL CERTIFIED TO: ) ?,I": i"lC 01' '-.lM'LCS CERTIFICATiON: -------.- '-'::'(1:8' rt:111~r TH,,~ ,"IS ~;PL:;;:nC ;)l)RPOS., '-0"','':"( '/'I"c ~,.'.''.TYI't ~ICr" ,.I, 10[5l"O',:,:"I.; ::>IM,::;C ('/( ('':l/:mfCq !H!S 5\,'I'VE- '''i,C., 'Hi., '~!NiMUM 1,:t;HN:::A', '.;1f'rJGf,?,D:i: SET rO"'TH RY ~,.t[ c'_lill'DII.. Hi....,'" U' C1"r:<P~S'>,,:N"l ".ri~; ~;ijR~"C;~S 1" CI1<1.P,!:": ".lGl,;-r" r t, C ''',<>'-Hh''';' ,r'. :;(,.",....' ,'.'::-.L1.~ "" (';'IO~ ,,~,'~II rEs. ..-' -- .-.':;> - . - ---- ,- sf ~ --,. ~ _ . - _ ~.=__~..z.. _ ''''_''''[ , ",__"_". _.'..., ". - "''''') 'r>'" ,'c-'S) ,,~, " .... d'-.' r, c' ,,,: '<'. .,...," '. ;.- ,,'.'':'. 'ml.:-; ~i,"".,,-','r:~~:, '" ,~!\--,,,U,: i'lt: I._!' >".75::) BBLS SURVEYORS & MAPPERS INC. 1502-A RAILHEAD BLVD. NAPLES. FLORIDA 34110 (239) 597-1315 SPECIFIC PURPOSE SURVEY - , . . m ~ "- . 0 ~ 0 ,. 0 , " .~ . , .' - m ~~ iii ~ 0 , ~ ~ I ~ " ~~ " . ~~ . 0 0 0 . LOT 26, BLOCK R, KINGS LAKE UNrTNa. 3, PLAT BOOK 13, PAGES 33 & 34, A PORTION OF SECTION 7, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA '-.....-....------.....- , ._,-,-.. , I I I , I I \ I I I , I , , , . I I i I -I ~ I ." I ."1 :c ':.1 " ~' , ::i ., ,-- ~ ' , 1. L.:lIS m'. ~ Agenda Item No. 7A 1\.tng S Hat: RomeobJuers .a.SSonHtton, ;BUt.January 12, 2010 Page 51 of 52 1044 CASTELLO DRIVE, SUITE 1/206 NAPLES, FLORIDA 34103.1900 (239) 261.3440 + FAX: (239) 261-2013 Emcll: Swllllcms@Swpropmgl.com November 11, 2009 Ms. Nancy Gundlach Collier County Community Development & Environmental Services Division 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 RE: Petition VA.Pl2009-1162 Remmlinger-Behnke, as Trustee of the Bernd Schoenherr 1998 Irrevocable Trust 2424 Kings lake Blvd. Dear Ms. Gundlach: Please be advised the Board of Directors of the King's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. objects to the above referenced petition regarding a setback variance. The reasons for the objection are as follows: 1. The variance request is in violation of the setback requirements as stated in the King's Lake PUO; 2. Any improvements to property in King's Lake must be reviewed and approved by the King's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. Architectural Review Committee prior to construction. These improvements have not been approved by the King's Lake Architectural Review Committee. If you have any questions, please contact me at 261-3440 (ext. 17). Very truly yours, Cc: Board of Directors ..-..-(' :._" '-- > ,--' '( f .-'--) 'I-t /i-', o. f-' -..., .__,' "f ' . --, ''',r.., "1"'" _ ~_ .. ,',,,.. "." ,'~ . 'v"" ",~ ';--"""'H' r"'-'-',.r _. '" ~.... "', . -" ,."'.--., '-"', ">'-,,", ""....,.."."...._..n..._".....,._ . Agenda Item No. 7A January 12, 2010 Page 52 of 52 , Naples DaDy News. Sunda" December 27, 2009 . 2tD ~""~'''_~,__,,_w_...._,^_...,..~, .-......,. ~,.. "'_'~,__""_~B.. -'~'''~'''-''(''''-''''_''''.'''''__"''~''~''~'''''_"''''''''_'.."....,..-,._~'-~~~,.",._,~_.,..,'_~".'_.N_ ~_m~.-.-...,"_,...,.,~_>O..,"P,,_.., '. ..,..~_.....,..~,_,."'.,.,.,"~_, ,,,,,,,..,,~.,,,_~.,..'N',,,,".~~_,.~._._.,>.<._,,~_~.,,,.,,..~,,,,,,.,~'''_''_~''''''''''''''''''''',"~."_,~,,,,.,..,,,, "__'_'~''''_',,~.v~.~,^.___.,",. ,",m.' """"_'"'^~N'_'_=~~'""""_~~,~"""",,,~ ~,~~-,.,,".' ".~W.'.'.'_ '~Y"'''~.-.W_~''_,',^_''_'~ __"w,w.. ".,~_.^~,." 'M___."~,,_,,_,,~ .~'", NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Notice is hereby given that the Soard of County Commissioners, as the Board of Zoning Appeals, of Collier County will hold a public hearing on Tuesday, January 12, 2010, In the Boardroom, 3rd Floor, Administration Building, Collier County Government Center, 3301 East Tamiaml Trail, Naples, Florida. The meeting will begin at 9:00 A.M. The title of the pro- posed resolution is as follows: A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, RELATING TO PETITION NUMBER VA.Pl2009-1162, FOR TWO. AFTER.THE.FACT VARIANCES: FROM THE REQUIRED IS.FOOT REAR SETBACK AND FROM THE 70S-FOOT SIDE Y ARO SETBACK FOR A SCREEN ENCLOSURE OVER AN EXISTING POOL AND PATIO AT 2454 KING'S LAKE BLVD, WITHIN THE KINGS LAKE SUBDIVISION PUD IN SECTION 7, TOWNSHIP 50 SOUTH, RANGE 26 EAST. COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. .. .. ., Petition: VA-Pl20og-U62. Elke Remmlinger-Behnke, as Trustee of the Bernd" Schoenherr 1998 Irrevocable Trust, represented by Karen "Bishop of PMS, Inc_, of Naples, Is requesting two after~the.fact variances tor an existing screened pool enclosure that Is an accessory structure to a single family dwelJlng. The first request is a variance of 2.5 feet from the required rear yard setback of 15 feet as 8rovided tor in Section 8.16 of the Kings lake Planned Unit Development ( rdinance Number: 82-52) to allow the existing accessory structure to remain at 125 feet from the rear prope~ line, The, second request is for a variance of 2.41 feet from the "required side yard" setback of 75 leet as provided for in Section 8.16 of the Kings Lake Planned Unit, Development (Ordinance Number: 82-52) to allow the existing acces~ sory structure to remain at 5.09 feet from the side property line. The sub- ject ,26+/. acre property is rocated at 2454 King's Lake Boulevard. in the King's Lake Unit 3, in Plat Book 13, Pages 33 and 34 at the Public Records of Collier County, in Section 7, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier .county, Florida. .. ".. ", ' , '. '''', ','" ." ~ ','.. '. ". ' . '.,.., copy of,th~,pr~p~secl Resgiution is on file with. the Clerk.tothl},SOanl. ' and is available for~mspectlon'-:' AfI interested parties are'lnvlted to attend ""and be heard ",_, '" "_ '=_"'"~" ' _, ,., ,.,. .. , ,",\.:" . ".' ." ',"- ," "-":, '~',".-",";'~":, ,'" '- "~:NOTE: All Persons wIshing to speaJ.: on any aperiCla: 'fte'7rfmust register' with the County ,Administrator prior to presentatIon of the agenda item to be addres~ed. Individl;lal,speakers will be liml~ed to 5' minutes on;an~ftem., The selection of an lndlvlduar to speak on behalf of an organization or" group is encouraQed. If recognized by the Chair, a spokesperson for a group or organization may be allotted 10 minutes to speak on an item. ' , "" .. Persons Wishing to have written or graphic materials included'ln the Board agenda packets must submit said material a minimum of 3 weeks prior to toe respectiVe]UbliC hearing. In any case,' written materials intended to be considered y the Board shall be submitted to the aPl?ropriate County staff a minim of seven days prIor to the public heaTing_ All material used in presentations. before the ,Board will become a permanent part of the record., . ': , . . Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the Board will n'eed a: re- . cord of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need to en- " sure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made. which record in- cludes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal Is based." ", ' If you are a person with disability "who neecJs any accommodation in order to partiCipate in this proceeding, r,0l! are entitled, at no cost to you, to the.. provision of certain assistance. P ease contact the Collier County Facilities .. Management Department, located at 3301 Tam/ami Trail Eastl Building W. Naples, Florida 34112, (239)252.B3B0; Assisted listening deVIces for the' .. , hearing impaired are available in the County Commissioners' Office. , - BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. DONNA FIAlA, CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E. BROCK. CLERK .By; Teresa Polaski. Deputy Clerk (SEAL) .. . J)ecpmper 17. 2Q09 ~ <.~. . .. ,". ._~v~~_~ .., .....~~~--,-_...".,,~ -