Loading...
Agenda 03/22/2011 Item #17A 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. <-~- EXECUTIVE SUMMARY SV-2006-AR-9400 - relating to an after-the-fact Sign Variance for the Swamp Buggy RacesIFlorida Sports Park. The Sign Variance requested is to allow an cxisting non-conforming, off-premises directional sign to remain at its existing location until the Rattlesnake-Hammock/Collier Boulevard bridge is expanded or an adjacent property owner allows the sign to be moved onto tbeir property. Tbe subject property is located at the southeast corner of Collier Boulevard and Rattlesnake- Hammock Road on property hereinafter described in Collie.. County, Florida. OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) finally approve an existing, nonconforming, off-premises directional sign to remain at its existing location until either a new bridge is constructed at the location or new property owncr approves the re-Iocation of sign, whichever occurs first. CONSIDERATIONS: At the BCC's December 14, 2010 meeting, the BCC heard a Public Petition by Randy Johns requesting a twelve month extension for a Variance for the Swamp Buggy Sign that was previously approved with a three year time limit. The sign is an off-premise directional sign for ~. the Swamp Buggy 1acility. The Swamp Buggy sign is located at the Florida Sports Park entrance at the southeast intersection of Collier Boulevard and Rattlesnake Hammock Road. At that meeting, the BCC directed that a Variance extension be approved to allow the sign to remain subject to the following terminating events, whichever occurs first: 1. The Rattlesnake Hammock/Collier Boulevard bridge is expanded. 2. The adjacent property owner allows the sign to be relocated on their property. Please note the following additional information regarding the history of the subject sign: I) A Variance (Resolution 07-22) was passed on January 23, 2007 that allowed the "'original sign" to remain in place for a period of up to 3 years up to January 23,2010. See attachment A: Resolution 07-22. 2) On December 1, 2009, the BCC previously approved a one-year extension until Dccember 1, 2010. 3) A new sign face, slightly larger than the "'original sign lace" was erected without a rcquircd sign pennit. A Sign Permit was granted preliminary approval on January 14,2011, subjcct to the approval of this Sign Variance Extension. - 4) As a result of a complaint that the sign was altercd without a sign pennit, a Code Enforcement Case was opened on March 6, 2009, Codc Case number CES20090002361. The Packet Page -1328- 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. Code Case will remain open until the proposed Sign Variance Extension is granted and the sign receives a Certificate of Completion. Please see attachment B, entitled "Code Case Details." FISCAL IMPACT: None. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN IMPACT: This request will have no impacts on the Growth Management Plan. ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES: There are no environmental issues associated with this request. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC was not required to hear this item. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This Executive Summary has been reviewed by the County Attorney's Office and is legally sufficient. A majority vote is required. STW RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Board of County Commissioners approve the request for Swamp Buggy Sign Variance subject to the following terminating events, whichever occurs first: a. The Rattlesnake Hammock/Collier Boulcvard bridge is expanded. b. The adjacent property owncr allows thc sign to be relocated on their property. PREPARED BY: Nancy Gundlach, AICP, Principal Planner. Dcpartment of Land Development Services Gro\\th management Division/Planning and Regulation Attachments: I) Resolution 07-22 2) Code Casc Detail s 3) Current Resolution Packet Page -1329- 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 17.A. Item Summary: SV-2006-AR-9400 - relating to an after-the-fact Sign Variance for the Swamp Buggy Races/Florida Sports Park. The Sign Variance requested is to allow an existing non-conforming, off-premises directional sign to remain at its existing location until the Rattlesnake-Hammock/Collier Boulevard bridge is expanded or an adjacent property owner allows the sign to be moved onto their property. The subject property is located at the southeast corner of Collier Boulevard and Rattlesnake-Hammock Road on property hereinafter described in Collier County, Florida. Meeting Date: 3/22/2011 Prepared By Name: GundlachNancy Title: Planner, Principal,Comprehensive Planning 2/22/2011 2: 13:25 PM Approved By Name: LorenzWilliam Title: Director - CDES Engineering Services,Comprehensive Date: 2/22/2011 3:08:50 PM Name: BellowsRay Title: Manager - Planning, Comprehensive Planning Date: 2/22/2011 3:09:50 PM Name: PuigJudy Title: Operations Analyst, CDES Date: 2/23/20113:30:51 PM Name: FederNorm Title: Administrator - Grmvth Management Div,Transportati Date: 2/23/2011 5: 18:46 PM Name: WilliamsSteven Title: Assistant County Attorney.County Attorney Packet Page -1330- 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. Date: 2/24/20112:16:31 PM Name: MarcellaJeanne Title: Executive Secretary, Transportation Planning Date: 2/24/201 1 4:25:42 PM Name: KlatzkowJeff Title: County Attorney, Date: 3/11/20113:21 :53 PM Name: lsacksonMark Title: Director-Corp Financial and Mgmt Svs.CMO Date: 3/14/20 II 4:02:44 PM Name: OchsLeo Title: County Manager Date: 3/14/2011 4:41 :53 PM Packet Page -1331- 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. RESOLlITION NO. 07-.13.....- RELATING TO PETIl10N NUMBER SV-2006-AR-9400. FOR AN AFTER-THE-FACT SIGN VARIANCE FOR TIlE SWAMP BUGGY RACES/FLORIDA SPORTS PARK. TIlE SIGN V ARlANCE REQUESTED IS TO ALLOW AN EXISTING NON-CONFORMING. OFF-PREMISES DIRECITONAL SIGN TO REMAIN AT ITS EXISTING LOCATION FOR A PERIOD OF NOT MORE THAN THREE YEARS. TIlE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF COU.IER BOULEVARD AND RATTLESNAKE-HAMMOCK ROAD ON PROPERTY HEREINAFfER DESCRIBED IN COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA. WHEREAS. the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125. Florida Statutes. has conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 04-41) which establishes regulations for the zoning of panicular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of variances; and WHEREAS, the Board of z"ning Appeals (BZA) has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided. and has considered the advisability of an after-the-fact sign variance to allow an ex:isting, non--confonning off-premises directional sign (hereinafter referred to as the "Sign") to remain at its existing location for a period of not more than three years. The Sign is located on the southeast comer of Collier Boulevard and Rattlesnake- Hammock Road, as shown on a sire plan attached as Exhibit "A:' The BZA has found as a matter of fact that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Section 9.04.00 of the Zoning Regulations of said Land Development Code for the unincorporated area of Collier County; and WHEREAS, all interested panies have been given the opportunity to be heard by this Board in public meeting assembled and the Board baving considered all matters presented. NOW. THEREFORE. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COU.IER COUNTY. FLORIDA. that: The Petition SV-2006-AR-9400. filed by Robert J. Mulhere of RWA, Inc.. representing Mr. David Torres of ToU.Rattlesnake, LLC, with respect to the property hereinafter described 115: Parcel 17 of Section 14, Township 50 South, Range 26 East of Collier County. Florida, be and the same hereby is approved for an after.th::-fact sign variance for the Swamp Buggy Races/Florida Sports Park. The Sign may remain at its existing location ns shown on Exhibit "A," subject to the following conditions: 1. The Sign shaH be allowed to remain in place until the earlier of the permanent relocation of the Swamp Buggy venue or upon written request by the Collier County Transportation Division to accommodate improvements to Collier Bouievard or Rattlesnake-Hammock 10f2 Packet Page -1332- 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. Road. In any event, unless otherwise extended by this Board, the Sign must be removed no later than three years from the date of this Resolution. All costs associates with the removal or relocation of the Sign shall be borne by the applicant; 2. A right-<lf-way permit, if required, shall be secured within four months from the date of this Resolution~ 3. A building permit application shall be submitted to Collier County within four months of the date of this Resolution; and 4. Required landscaping shall be planted around the base of the Sign. A planting plan shall be submitted to Collier County with the building permit application. The Applicant may utilize manual irrigating techniques if the planting plans include xeric or drought tolerant plants. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to Petition Number SV- 2006-AR-9400. Swamp Buggy Sign Variance. be recorded in the minutes of this Board. TIlls Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote. Donethis vOai day of J!2.liU~_.2007. ~ . ~ ':'::. !."!TEST: ,> ,1JWlGHT E. BR:E>CK, CLERK ~tJ~~~ .~ ~,'to CtfRFU>>' perk s IgnltlKt vn I. . BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLlERCOt;~ /;#, tf By: ~______ JAMES COLEITA, CHAIRMAN .leffr(' A. ' ow Mann. mg ssistant COUnf) Anorncy 20f2 Packet Page -1333- 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. , 0 ~ 8 z :1 0 c:= c:= ii- w 0.. w :~ - u z <( <; '" 0 <( i~ > 0 c , z ~1G to " v; I' !U i~ \1 . !R v J.I8IHXa: ~.T t:J.rl f...- .::.1. en z. I co. co ..L ;< '" "'<( 00.. O?<J) o~ -'''' l..i..-O 0.. In ~ ~S ~1IIl ~1Ii ~ ) , \ "' .,; ?- m I x w I z'" "'''' <J)~ I..... ("~ 011 0..> oj i-W '" a-. 0- Z II 0' 08 / "'-, to..; 0 CD ~ I x vi w '" '" w U I Z >-- 0 <t '" O? to '" > -' .oJ Z 0 '-' >-- v; ~ so, i1 ~ d ~ ;', w U Z <( Ct:: <( > co -~$~ 3' z u en I \ 112 , <( \ D-:i ~ t ),"\n ~~ll~':;"" I Ulo I" " \, \ \1--0:: ",- .., ,,)t ., ,gs 1.~ ,J" '1 -I In. 'b' ~\ I Ul ''''''.;./ ,r r" , t ~~l 'i'~ It M '"'I' ~i!'''' 1- ,Ii f :'::)~ -~, ~ ~i'.:.>~f;,- =- ='= = =~====---::: ~--"'-;;"-,- "-= - ~ ='-- ----~ ~" II hijll ~ilOli ~.!!~ Ilh i c -';07 f ril~ ~>~i \~tl 'l~i=;:! ~~~ I~~ /-~'?-_----~------------ I =.; ~'! .~~~. W~ /' 8 ~'14~i ~ '" 0 I ~ . i -;;T. .1, "v,/ .la "'"'I_ =< ~ II. ~ 0 I ~I'" II. ... VIV' ~~ r- -I wGI hi 'I' I .\ ;:: "ii --' I I .- ,.; .. ,. ;2r\ 3~~ I I, lVNVJ 8NI1SIX3 -l'.Y2-__ q~ -. " ---'-:ro~_._----/ I I 1<;6 OVOiJ )"lNnOJ <f(n \ Packet Page -1334- ~ '" M N 0 0 0 en 0 0 N tJ) UJ U (i) (/) .n :J CO Z ...... '" Q) "' ell 0 C! Q) (/) CO 0 Q) -0 0 0 Q ~ l- , ...... - 0 0... (l) :;;: 0::: <( '" <:'! '" ":': .... I 0 ~ ~ , 0 - - 1 ~ g~ 0 N c:c ~ ~ ...- N "" ~( ~ :;;: <( 0 ~ 1:- 0 ~ en .... III l: .r::. 0 lJ) 'tl ~ l: l: en 0 III 0 lJ) a. l: 0 ~ N III III III - lJ) c:c - .~ a. '" '" 0 M a. U E > ~ ~ D III (I) m " a. ell 2 D .~ 'tl 7j (I) if, III C g ~ !JJ ~ :J 9! .~ C' !JJ 0 III CJ ~ f-- - "' :J oj ell 0 (I) U .r::. co - 0 .~ l: en 'iij ..!!! 0 a. , ,., en - en l: :J III III E III a. OJ E ~ '" .E ;: l: tJ) UJ 0 III - 'tl l: ~ 0 0 'tl '" 1:- u :;:; ~ M ,., '" N ~ ~ III III - 0 l: III .r::. '" ~ 0 lJ) :J - .!!1 0 l: 0 C '" en 0 U ..!!! '0 <:> '" 0 Iii lJ) ~ a. .0 u N lJ) E ~ ~ 'iij tJ) l: III E 0 ~ - '0 lJ) N UJ en 0 - 0 0 Cii '" '" u Z a. U U a. ., ~ '" ~ .2 .2 c r !lJ "- - " >. 0 " - - r f-- " "0 5 9! :J .- Q) Q.. C[j -' :; Z if, <,2 Ul '" " = :J ~) c5 "' C! -0 ~ ro = C! -~ 0 ~ :1) :u 0 " " -,.........,................. ..................... ...J "- <Ii U U III ...J a. Z ...J '" >- UJ Z <( ~ 0 0 <( Z > >- tJ) ...J e> w III e> ...J ~ :J I- '" .!!1 0 I- " III '0 <:> <( 0 <:> a. 0:: U <:> :;;: ..J (ij .... <:> N <( ...J en N .... ~ 0 D '" ~ :J ., .... tJ) ?- m "' p ~ 9! 0-;. "' (I) ~ ~ s C D Q 0 0 ~ D < 0: 2:: ~ 0 (i) ~ en ro :J 0 c Q ro 0: 0: 2 "' "' (I) 2 <( It) N It) '<t o ~ o ~ o N - CD ~ - N ~ Q} - 'U ) c: o :;::; :J <.:J Q} X W J) .co - OJ o OJ (f) m () Ul ;: ., E E o <.:J ., E o " '5 o 'C ., a; i5. E o <.:J co 'C 0 ., 0 ~ N "5 (0 g M c:: 'C ., c: Cl 'iij Ul <( c: .Q 16 E o .2 ::J c: o " "' '" U <ii .. .c c: " '" " .- -" '::lI)~~ c: ctI .- 0 ctI J:: > 0 .- C Q.l~O -EO. .!? (j5 a> c::! "' "N oQ.l:tico"- ~oEa.-o m 0. Q:5 c: ~ ';'::;>'0.<1)'- Cf) en ..x:J "'C 0)"'0 ctI 0- Q.l:JW-ID > (II': (/J ..... .- :J co..c Wo.o-.cU ~ E ~ Q) ro rcClJ......O>Q) ~ :J C (Il o CI) 0 mc::" N J::J:: N ro'-:: u CI) ..--.c~(/)O cn-~-oEI- 9~~J::O Ll(E~gI ("')Q.)oouCl. " ;; i5. E o (,) co o o N <a '" " ;; Ci. E o " E co o o N <a '" co o o N <a '" ~ ~ J:: "' c: o "' 2 16 0. >> ~ " J:: "' c: o "' 2 16 0. >> c: .Q " " 0. "' c: cri E :g (3 is 0....2 Q. 'C ",""z~U) C:o:: "' .... ro..:.::..... "C lO :;::; ro 'E::: 0 Q) l{) ~$:oQ).s-1;);: 000 u"'O:2: Q) - ~ C W:::J:J""': C cr: ro...... C'" ctI OJ >..- C . Q) > ._C"Eroctl~.....o en ~ :J > 3: ctI ...: a. "'0 Q) 0 c ..... QJ Q.l 0. Q)-ucna>>.Cctl -5 ~o'U) ~(") ~ OJ ro.2:2esofija:g ~~:S:'"C<ci:S>"~ Q) LLOOQJcro 0::.8$:::;::;0....=> lOrnCl);;::;NOOCJ') v ro -- ~.!:: E () .!: ~ ;:~"E ro"O g.c""EM m c.. Q.l ~ ~ .... ~ ~~ 9 ctl E co'-E.2=a ~C'? ..,......c:;wu cc ...-ClUl13..cOl:J=u M US ~ ,c ~ 'U) (') 5 ~ " ;; Ci. E o (,) co o o f::' - '" co o o N <a '" ~ ~ J:: "' c: o "' 2 16 c.>> J:: " it; " "' " c:: " "' ..JI L.L./ L.V..L..L ''-'-111 ..1..1 or-\. c: -0 ,9 Q)...... I./l'- "'0 ~_o" E " ro "'0 :> .- "Cl ~ Ow>, .~E Q) :J .Q '5...c >..... 16 ~ 0.. ~ U .~ '::0. 0 -0 OJ Q) -0 ..c _ C')> ...J >UQ.l ....c..EU"OC ...Ja> 9l~"""'C N (/) Q) - '"C woO '- '-"'S Q) N'- 0 C "'0 -0 Q.l..x 0 "'C~ C'".o~fi..; Q.l"O'o > co_ ~:J ~ 00-5 ~ irl co > EO 55> u c.. lI) 0'- ro .... Vl -0 Q) 0 roc~~z~Q)oQ)ffi~:;z :::::::Cl:> -o>._c Q.lro ctl.- N C C W C") CLl ro >-..0""'" tV I !!!....- c;.Q C _::I o...:=: '"'; en en ..c CLl N U5 'S "m 0 u :: E ,g = '> 9 uU)N -E..-....Q).... Our--- roroocgwOCLlcS:~l-ro..- wur---ow....N5;-crouoth U),g 0:;:; 0:: wC"i:: c8..cro- ~ U)~.2u >N o.Qlc >-"E:v52 LO ~ ~ g"~ 2 ~..c ~ 0 ~ 8 r; 0:: "'>t .... ~ Q) o...u ro c..c c"_ > LO c:o"C E..t:: 0-::1 0- O'l>.,g Oeo en ~ .... Q) ~ 0::1 C:.;::: 0 c ro _ >-a.. .... Q) U ro ::I -'C E 0. t (f) 91i:;a.~a;u~oCLlW EWLO ~ ~ C'C = 5,:':=; U) -g:E C.$! g-...,. thU)"~~tiCf.i 5~ E2'~ro c.~ N " ;; Ci. E o (,) co o o N '" - '" co o o N '" - '" ~ ~ J:: "' c: o "' 2 16 0. >> " u 6 Q) Ol U ::l to oil C <D E <D Ol ro c ro ::2: " " Q) J:: " it; " "' " c:: " "' :2; <l: en c:'! en '<l: o ~ ID , mom E m ~ w a> ro ,V).c >.- vi C:::l ...... ..CI U U ~~V)uuu~ 0 ~ ~~D~O ~ g roOUIDc~_ ID~~~ 0- Eo~ .~ o~~~'ffi~ro~O~E2=u ~O~~ID > ~=-~~uV)U~~~V)gID~2 ~~~IDwgOm _O~O~'~~~$ID~V) ..cWv>= ro~~Ugz9 U~..CIU'rororo~.c>g~E~wo~=CCrol~~ 2~ro~~ouuo-rouro:::lV):::l~C_~V)-VID' c>5~~co>-~goC.cCIDgu~Eo~5~..CIv 80 EIDO-E~V)~roU0.c~~O wrou,EO cmw~occ~'_o~~ro~~'->-~.c~-~~~ SCJ)w~ooe~g~~~~.~iE~~~~g~=~~w~ -0 N l:J 0.-- ro...... Vl...... (/) 0 . x () 0""" 'E'" 2Vl'ID-~~~~l:J~~WU~~ID.Q~t~~: _ c..wM=c..c LC'-'- .cuONl:J>wro-o~roroVl E~cro~'~-om:::lro-owVlc~row~~c..crn_Vlo WOOUroVl~~OVl~~l:J:::l 1=c..EVlro:::l~OM =~u~,-o'-'_~~..CIVl'ffi~2NBVlW=c..Vl>ON <:{-o Q)"O c..co 0 C '-rI).ctO co u....Q)_"'C"I"""" .-j..CIrorn~"">-o>-~w~-~Vl~wWOI>-cU ~~wEg.~~~~~g.....c~~~~w~EU .~~~ NO~:::l ~ :::lw:::lWOO ....mo~ro:::l....w....c "'--roCID~a3~CD2CO.c >'0 'I-CO -~:;:J>c mCcOlO-w-.co.. o.",oIDEI-......'-c~~..D(/}2 0 OctlVlCO ID E' wU "'C~VlwwEo Cu Ig~~~ciI~ ~E.~~E~m~~~~IDU~2m ~~~~>0~~;g;~'~3~~~~~~oo~~~~ ~~~~~g~~oo~oo<~~OU~~~~B~ooo.oo o ~ o N ~ <0 ~ ~ N ~ <II C '" E E o u Ql ~ <1l o c o ::; U Ql X UJ '" E w '" 0 " " " g- "- '5 " 0 0 0 U U en en '0 0 0 '" 0 0 ;; N N iD iD Q. ;;r ;;r E 0 u en en '0 0 0 '" 0 0 ~ N N ':; ;::: ;0 0' ;;r '" ?; l>: ~ ~ '0 ~ Q; .c '" '" "' c: c c Ol 0 0 'iij "' "' <II 2 2 <( rn rn 0->- 0- >> CJ) 'm " ~ Ql <II '" 0 0 Ql rn rn CJ) <1l U U () '" '" c: C m 0 0 oJl '"'"I ,"V..I....1.. IL.'-III..I..I .r1.. I ui Q).~ ..... C") ..Q ..c :5 Q) -ci ..Q 010Q) roo -5 ~ "0 ,-C")-.:ru==:5"';:;cri Q;Q)O'-Q.) Q)coc:;:-OE(/):;:>..c=.E::J ..0 00 m----c..... g! Q).......O 0001 E (/) I '- --ro ro.=: ~ $: c::-g.!:Qcr Q.)c;nro>~,,,o..(/) OOO:.:Q.)LO E..c ....... ~ E ::J ro .c. 0.. c 0...0 ..... o -.:r -0"0 C Q.)..o 0) ~::J 0..- I EJ---:Q)'- Q.)cc>.(/)m=-.:r o >. ro ~ rn.~ ~ :5 :.i2 .9:0 ; Q) $: U ~-gu::J(/)CC1_.....Q)a.rn ..o>(i: =roEuc>~o~O~~(l)O rsa::.3~..co$:;>Q.) c>CUZtl? Q)..... <D"O'-rornrornc co -o"E'-O')Jc....::J..c ......-rn-oo. Q) rn 0 '- rn ro.......~.::&:. ro'~ <D (/) ,~ 0 '"0 , ::2: rn 0 C (/) co> ~.!:Q 0 <D co 2 ~ . ~ cc C 'm ..Q ro ~ N u>.gj'<tc.....Q)1?..ct::.....o..-"_~ro . <DO) _O~..c.......OQ) "" ~ 0) ~ ro :.;:; 'E = 0 J U C .!: c >. g o::JQ)u.!!:!..oc.......'-ffJ>. ......- Li.l en .... -0 .9 ::l Q) <D 2: .- ro ~ rn 2 ~ ..... o.~ Q) > (/):2::l"O Q.) E......s.mo 01 __cc>......umu (/) "0'- o E...J ::;'-c.51:.~~"E ~~ E'" ~ c.b; . a:; &E u.~~.;:: ~ O'(i) 0) ..d-oo~n::'(ij'(ij.ffJD..< ~co ~<.E'w '" Q) '-' :5 iil en " ::J co . c Q) E Q) (J) m c m :;;; Ul Ul Q) ~ <C LO N LO ~ o ~ o ~ o N - CO ~ - N ~ Q} - Il J c o *" ::J () Q} X W JJ CIl Q) o Q} Ul CIl U III 'E .. E E o () ci..!:2 C1> (j) c: ~ :0:5 . ~ "E .. =' --..c. 0" "C tJ) >-:!:o..~a5~ <(:CO -groctl-N'Q .2:-0 CO O')"'C ro == 0 0>..... 0::02 ro..s-~o ..s...... I w_...... W-C' E~C1>C3oE~orng> O"\t ::J -0 _ Q.).- ...... 0)'- .; c gUm 5 g-i:5 ~ E Cijo..........(/):o:::uE....ct1 u c:-g ~ c: ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ ~~:~~~ ~~~J2 Q) Q)..c. E en 0 C/j"ro 0.. C/) C) ~"'C E ctI u .!a E ro Cf) ~/D ~ o~-c E 0).g.0 c...>o_~EO'luo g E "C E ~ -03 8 .~ 'E = octl~E"Cu -gCL&i .....s:c-Q)~EoECIl Q')U).cc"'5 EO-a- OC/')OO1:l .-(/)....~ 6.E~~~~..i-~;E "'7o~~uocOc:::::l -.:t".,..::......Cf.lNOurotll .. E o " 'S o '" Q; a. E o II 0> o o N 25 ~ ~ '0 .. Qi a. E o () 0> '0 0 .. 0 ~ N 'S i?5 0' ~ '" ~ 0: '0 '" " .~ III III <( ~ i; -" "' " o "' 2 rn a. >- " III '" Cl rn II '" " o '" .9-" o~ "' ....... 0 .... N ....:;:::; >,...... ~ N 0:';:::::-0)(":::::"- ';~c......C:ai "C ('IJ..... 0 E c:.S::!o::......:;: ro ~::cuq:J U) rn~i9~o~ u C r.n (f)_ U g 8 @)~ ID CO-o"O ~::l .c:c:Q)U'OOO" U::l1ij~()~ ro..Qo~Eo ffi ol>.><..3~O') &'E ~'c ~99 U?ctI::J~"CU;~ .....~CD..c:2"\t..J. NO') 0..0.. ID=o ..... 0 E ~'::l Q)_ cnoro~o-On:: 9N3:U)~U)l!) ~:5~.E:2.EOJ ,coOo_oQ.Ul VN_-,...J--:l '" Q; a. E o II 0> o o N ;: N ~ 0> o o N ;: ~ ~ ~ i; -" "' c: o "' 2 rn a.>- -" " ro '" "' '" 0:: '" "' " o ~ Q; a. ,~ :0 ::l 0- " o '" " " '" '0 " o a. "' ~ E o ~ "oE '0 ;: '" '" 2 c: "''0 " " (/)", '" Q; a. E o II 0> o o N 25 N ~ 0> o o N 25 N ~ i!! '0 " 1" '" -~ ;: '" ';; '" 0:: '!;; .J/L..LI'"V..I..L '1.'-111 .L1.r\.. .8 " ~ Q; a. ,~ :0 ::l a. " o '" " " '" ~ -g, 00> a.o ~o "C:J 0" " " '00 '" '" " > c "C "''0 JlCl >.- "'0 co .- ~.E (1)....._ ""S2 Ea.", :::l > .~ t/) .... E co 0>.... 'm ctI Q.l Q) ro >'a..S:2: u", r/l 5-~ E s: ID 'OEro"'C....oQ)..DEU)= C Q)Q) .c....::Jo _ 2~.cr::~~00..u~~ ....:> .... ...............Q.l..... Ecng].3-o~:t: 0...._ ai "CoQ.l(l)Eo-~uw e Q)Nc::.~..c.... Q...o,$s - w ~ . > U Q) '-" ro r::-o ~.5..c0'l-gcn::: 0.0 0 roO'l ''''-0-0 Q)Q.l-OUoo U rotOo (l) 0.0 r:: 0.0-' -0 NN..c,(l)ro -w'f (l)::2::c ~O'l c.o=~.~ wI.!) .~:J~~9.E~a; 6 (l)E~ ~ci E ~g-o.g=~..c (l)~ c::90:2..J.<(.orou:gEtO o~~.... C'~ e ~u rn-o g- o I"OOOOa..Uc:::l(l)....1.!) ",-V(l)-_E"OCWIro "'-ca..(l)m 3,~ro o~ O'l 0 E -5 () e 0 Cti c >.m ...- OW::3WW:::~>oro>-. en c.o cb Cm >-~~ ~ 85~ ~-50.....g U (l) (l)a;~::3 g v, Cl.W, ro= co.. rom~ ... '" Q; a. E o II 0> o o N 25 N ~ '" Q; a. E o II 0> o o f::J ~ "' 0> o o N 25 N ~ 0> o o N ;: N ~ i!! '0 " 1" '" .~ ~ i; -" "' " o "' ~ $ rn a.>- o U; OJ D ::l o:l oj Q) !,l ;: '" ';; '" 0:: '!;; c '" E '" OJ rn c: '" :2: on '" " rn II '" <:: o :2: <( L() c:'! L() ~ o ~ o ~ o N ~ <.0 ~ ~ N ~ (J) - C1l o C o :;:; :J <.) (J) >< W en 'co a; o (J) en C1l U '" 'E .. E E o <.) c CIJ '- CD o o.w~ ,:Q-a>ro"u'cE N.....m ~~gg1ii.~(l)O "l""""COO 1.!)Q.l:::COIDo....;S..... ~Q.lm ..... :::I :::::l >... '" u...- (tjI Q) c Ci.c-5..U ~~ c: I CIl .0..:..:: ~ u c:..... E '" en CD u c: CIJ 0 CD CIJ :::::l U c 16 .- 0 0 - ..... 0)"0 0 c:-- .c ::Ou-uE.....a......-.... ~R::J ro"O 5--::J ::J';CI.D >. ::I 0.. '- ~ rn .c '0 u > 8 cg,. -0 '-'-0 '-.- -g &U -- '0 Z CD -0 -g -5 2 (/) ctJ "(ij U -g ~ -0 ~ .~ 'C '- 'c ~ 0:: CD~ Q.lCIJ>Wctl;;:::N -0 wQ)-o ~-oa.OQ)..- -g2~ro~s.E<("oQ)-o-' =CIJ....."o-coc .w:2.!:Ul CIJ Q) cv c: .....- a.1ii > Q) u E}.... ctl iD'o..t) o..wo"8:::l o ~~O)o:5 Q)~ %@-oEg ("')..0 U C Q) III '- '- N"- 0 "C C 0 a..o:: ;,;::; fJ) "'-~c":5i.~~a. -g5~ ~ x ~N'> to Q):J'E:: U c I ;>,,--o>c-rowm-o N ...... >. >. ro ':> c Q) ~ 'S: :E .,-..-WCIJQ)>rol/lcQ)o..... u?o;:S~I~(L.9.8cr:~~ .. E o <.> :; o " 1ii a. E o u m o o N "' ~ "' "C .. - .. a. E o <.) m "C 0 '" 0 ~ N "5 l?:i C' '" "' ~ "C '" c Cl 'iij '" <( m .c '" c o '" $ m "->- <.> '" '" o <ii u " c o _ >- c ,.....: =cO o 5:"'''' J,-, .:= ~ ~~-~2~ """..... 0 C ro ro c is Cl.. co "'0 C ~u~'~g-.g'l C Q) (/) > .... (/) -c..cz"OSo OtoQ) - -'::J...,:J!2-c0'l >,_ C/J '- Q) 0 -oo~:Sc::J~ ~ z Cl.. 0 en..- ^' ...c >.-o.!G ' u..=:!:a>cQ)oo ..... ro $: ..c co.o u .2u..:.:::..........J_l::: :2Eo~06~l() __:::1$:>,01 co ...J'Q) Ole> CL o .... ,g 0)'- 0 If) 0-0 ::Jczo OQl"OWNo - ..--"'" Q.l -0 0)~2o.t5~..- o ::J:':::: E CIJ I !2 I c:r c ro C 0,- f';-Q)o$:o~c rotYO(f)UCOO " 1ii a. E o u '" o o N ;;:: 03 m o o N 0; - "' ~ m .c i'? o '" $ m "->- ro u " c o c co cV Q)-OO ::J ro ~ "Ou...Q lii :g a> > -- E 0Q):;::; "'-- .- 0 0 c c c g &.Q ~~c c.. .2 '" '" x oS: 0) Q) '" '" " ~""- t >. ~ ("') o...c.- 0) c.."'O~ (fj Q)Q)-g~ ~ ~-- Q) Q) Q) Q) U ~ -:;: ~ ~ u ~ 0;= C Q) U c.. CD (fj n. E c.. ctl '-' 0 o u IlJ u '" 1ii a. E o U m o o N 0; N iD m o o N 0; N iD " o c -'" <ii .c -" '" " " " " a: '!;; ..JI L..L../ L..V..L.L 11.'-111 ..LI .r-\. ",o/l 0"'0 0 ctl OJ> ~ g 2';; >._!: 0 0 ~~CD~CZ~ O)=E::J~ .~ 9g;,;:;CD_~~ J'--rvCc..U,c '~oE"'oO oo<j)U c"";"c 0)0 '~oooo o t U :> U >.:;::; ~Lf1!lU);:;;;c~ cboo5os:ctl2 I-cuc.._~ro ,..... 0 CD Q) CD .....(fjm~U_C o c .c (fj c {g .Q> a... J:: t::: c.~ c.. en wO=.c~::J~o) o:::'-octl 00 >.o....,>~- I w"'Oz~"O...Q"O~ (/)~ .~~u~"";" <(O:::ro-=~-'::12oo U u -- ::J C ._ U Z (s c :s:: c.. 0 Q)-':: w-~..::.:::>."O..ol.() a....:2:.3(sCDc=OO O:J~3:-=j-~g- " 1ii a. E o <.) m o o N ;;:: 03 m o o N ;;:: 03 ~ m .c '" c o '" $ m "->- " '" "" " ~ '!;; ~en __ 0 ~ E:;: (f) .~,..; 0 caE.....o cctlwN o I- .~ ~ ~ W 0 lii Q) 0) c c c..oo C ::> ~ 0 ctl :> ...QL()~ ~ >C~t:: OO~Q) Z2("jg. 0) "Octl~~ 0 Q.)U~ c.. en .t (f) .q- u .J... ~ co ("') c ,., o E....J - C OLL>' Q) g..c ,~g; .:L 01-05::::10) 2 ~ 0 CiIlJ 0 r..f) 0) "Q; ctl c....n 0 9uZEol- L().2:....J ctl..-- 0 C';J Q) 0::: 5: u I co (/) I- en -.:: 0.... " 1ii a. E o U m o o N "' N 03 m o o N ;;:: 03 ~ m .c '" c o '" $ ro "->- c .Q m o '> '0 '" " :g z " m '" 1ii a. E o U m o o N "' N 03 m o o N ;;:: 03 ~ m .c '" c o '" $ m "- >- "' Q) 5 (3 ii: 1() J) ~ o C;; '" D ::; OJ ii3 E '" CD S2 ro ::< "' "' OJ ~ <( L{) N L{) ~ o ~ o ~ o N - CD ~ - N ~ Q) ~ 'J J c o :;:; :J () Q) X W .fJ .cu ~ Q) o Q) CJ) Cll U ", '" - C Ql E E o () Ql E o () - " o 'C Ql - Ql is. E o () en 'C 0 Ql 0 _ N .S 23 <:T ~ Ql 05 c:: 'C Ql C '" ';;; '" ..: () '" Ql C "' Q) 's 13 0:: en o , .,. ~ 00 c '" "" J!l o t- O I CL .>< () c"'", 00l", w""!::i c.. () '" '" .~ ~ ~ ~U,,"": -<no "'<no c: Q.l" ocN tIl .- .... - <n Ql "'''", 0..0 '" "0-0- 2.92 O-E 0..- E~2 26co ~c:ID c - ~(1J:=o:l ~()S:o (J) U'l . J, OroON J,E?cb NON ,-C......U rol-ro'";::: Ql a; is. E o U en o o N in N 05 '" a; C. E o () c en o o N in N co en o o N in N 05 - Q; .c <n c o <n $ ro 0.:>- - Q; .c <n c o '" $ ro 0.:>- eo is. E .ill ~ '" () .~ Ql (J) ~ o 0", :>- ~ ro 0l0) en E...J g'o 9~u.."C00 1.0 I- Vl 0.0 N 0.92 E..... cO""" c.. ro u (j) ~ co 3:~ 0'- Z C/) Lt) J,2::..J....OO NIDet::Oc.. I U) I- '+- CIl CO-ro.-<CO I-c:Eo::~ 0:: g.!:2 .~~ Om E c: a.. a. co 0 <ri W ....1- c c: O::EW~~ ~>a2()>- <(~~~l () "0 C . 0 Z2g~Ci W ro C..... . a.....rovu 000("1)1:: '" a:; C. E o U en o o N in N 05 en o o N in N 05 ~ Q; .c <n C o <n $ ro 0.:>- ~ '" ." '" 0:: ';;; c ~ ~ . o C 0 '- Q.l .Ql U -8 "'0(/):::0 (tI-oE- E c.o Q) (/) ro :::I (J) ro-o~rg ==2=0) ~ lt~-e: "E 8 cri-o Q;lco9c.9 ~>C)lo rooo""" S z,,:""". ~ ~ c (])"c ~gC6~ c" () l!')eoQ,)CI) MugOL[) (j)l@~;:;~ 9 E D..E (J) <n ~oouo cb~u.9~ '" a:; C. E o U en o o N ;::: N co en o o N in N 05 ~ Q; .c <n C o '" $ ro 0.:>- is. E .ill ~ Ql () .~ '" (J) ~ >...:, O"'N 'C , -ZOO '" -~ .S2~ Q.l u C:c(ljl:::: Q.l Ol ro LO en'ii) () co __O)e. o o.~ (f) :::: >.-00 > 0. '" ctlo(9v -0 u 0 . ~'"O-$ <(~~~ "'2;'.:"2 0 ......>c- -ctIro- ctl -0 () (tI 0...... ctl (J) C I;t: .... "6> 0<( 0 .~ o - 0 "=t-g(/)-o m;::::Cf)Q) 0'- 0 .c mEet) N..Q......ro ob~.9~~ '" a:; C. E o U en o o N ;::: N co en o o N ;::: N 05 ~ Q; .c <n C o <n $ ro 0.:>- ~ '" ." '" 0:: "" o en W 0 :J N (J) 0. ' C/)E~ - '" l!') 3:". .....w2 ~ '" .....0-0 en-", 9<ig N o::.~ cO c" ~ I-goQ) O::cUo o co . I a..uml!( w(/)9o 0:: coco"'" wE":J~ (/)OCO'" c3~g::2 0- 0. z...... >. 11l w> 010 a.. 0 g>~ OZCO...... '" a:; C. E o U en o o N ;::: N co en o o N ;::: N 05 ~ Q; .c <n C o '" $ ro 0.:>- ~ '" ." Ql 0:: "" -'I L..L../ 4'-'..1. 1"''-1'1 oLl or-1.o '" a:; C. E o U en o o N iD 23 ~ en o o N ;::: 05 ~ Q; .c <n c o <n $ ro 0.:>- "' Q) 's 13 0:: " CD "'=='" e ~ e. o~...:g _Nctl_ ID ..... ID <0 U) t >-...!::: co 0 ctl ..... (.) a. ...... (.) B~.2~ .951""2(j; ""2~g~ (I) C C'.c: .- Q) 0- ~a.E5 coOIDE ~lO.o<o s:~.9o o U).!!2:: "::toQ)u "'lO(jjID ","'ctl.c: o ...: (.) U ~ ~C'? ~ M N::J9hw~ .....(f)XI/l..:::t:. '" a:; C. E o U en o o N N ~ c: .~ c. i: E o 0 ZU en o o N N N ~ en o o N ;::: 05 en o o N ;::: 05 - Q; .c ~ <n 0 C C o !!! <n OJ 2 .c: co .B 0.. >- ~ <ll .g o Q) OJ U :J o:l 015 co <ll E <ll OJ g> ro :;:; <J) <n <ll ~ '" ." '" 0:: "" c .Q 13 '" 0. 2 <l: l!) N l!) "<I: o ~ o ~ o N - <D ~ - N ~ Ql - Cll o c o :;::; :J o Ql >< ill (/) Cll a:; o Ql (/) Cll U ^' Ul " '" E E o o ~55ai """,0 ~(j N CC-d"";" "-,,,0 Em~ ",.0 0 (/)~ ~"C o ~ }Ecgs m5CI:l >:= w "''''-0 ~ooO) 'U5509 'S: . 0 N \1)~'<-"";" ~"m a3 0 {f) E Co::; o (l) 0.-- "-"-Q)"- C'? C ..... L!) 0> D'l Cl..o;) 9 "(Ii w g- L.C(~:::o ~ g~~ " E o " '5 o C .!'J Ci. C: E o 0 zo '" o o N <D 25 ~ -0 " " Ci. E o o -0 '" ~ '5 0- " 0: '" o o N "' 25 ~ -0 " " Ol 'iji Ul <( ~ :;; .c: YO " o YO $ rn "->- " Ul '" o " .12 U '" q. , Q)"OC( -0"0 o"'~ ut3~ ~ '" ~ O.c:U'> -,,", <D '" "- Co '- {/} "-~o Q).2N ~ - ~ "-<D~ o Ul . ......=(]) .92~9 .0 '" ctlcr)"-- coo ::)N"'- U'>~" ;::60 ~~ "- ",,,<D ooa. .J."E'E '7 \'tl co 0000) ....(00)0 '" Qi Ci. E o o '" o o N ~ ~ 25 ~ '" o o N N 25 ~ ~ ~ '" " o YO $ rn "->- " '" .'O '" 0:: '" YO ~ .~ 'S .... u'" '" '" 0:: I '" o o N 25 N 25 ~ " '" E '" ~"2~~ ~ E ~"fij E OC(DWQ UW......I U '" '" o 0 o 0 N '" 25 '" N N 25 23 ~ ~ '" o o N 25 N 25 ~ ~ m ~ -5i ~ 25 (5 YO YO 2 2 ro CD a. >. a. >. e .Q U '" "- (J) o o N 25 N 25 ~ '" "- >- f- "" e "fa " I (J) o o N 25 N 25 ~ " o e .!!! a; .c: "' '" w 8 " " > " 0:: o YO .~ " "- <D 0 >z '" . .c: Ul ::l Ul- -"- .Eo :;;0 "-0 0-; "eM DUO') ~~YO -00.:: ~00 "'- ~...... t....N 00- ,,-- "' "'-0- ~ ",0 ~~OC '" "- . u '" >- c c "3 IDW:,::; "-",u 0.0 '" -'/L..L../L..o..J.......... ."''-111 .....,.r-t.. o ~ -g ,..!. II) a. '- ro ..- (f)~~~~ ~~ a3>.'~ "0 ""C"""-o Q):::J C:UQ;~ ~~~.~ 0 ~ ~:2 c~~ ~ ~~ :s ~ ro ro;;"5 ..r:: (/'J g 0 ;:tZ ~ C/) .... (1)>00" -f/) Uwoo....o ~~ctl~d~.9g'a.9Q) '=cN o ~ $: Q.l 0 Q) C .- en (l)..r:: O)"ro'- N .=o::_,,!' Cl,{) '- w"E:o :::J-.~ Ea=..... - _ro(flro"'6~o"OE-gQ.) '2 Q) a.(1J cnQ) ~ Cl...QJ- U).f? w......"'O ctl t5 E R.S; -5 "c IJ) .... E .2 Q) a. a3 ~"O co >'::J~ Q) 0 Vl2E 0..0 WCJ)....J g- o. g; c w -5 E ~ Q) ..c -,~:o . oi:S w CO D'l U) -...... '-._ .... Q) W :::I .- lI) "0 ro Q) o.~ 2 '- ro .... OJ u U CO (/) .- "m c ..r:: U u ~ 0 -5'S: ~ o.~ >. CL,Q u '- D'l Q) I CO ill c";;:: o E 0 OJ Q) :=:: (l) Q.'I .S: (/) _ u 0 ro N co a. ~ ~ :g.~ 6 (i) ":; 0)" &5 2 ~ > ..- ~-cll)..c: ro-E;"iij (1)"0 g E a..c"'D 0') en 2 a. >. _ ro "~ E <:( ro Cl> C) i:6 ~ q~~E~~~EE~g~~.~~mm ("") = ::l ro _ a...c "_ E .E ro c:: ::l 0 ~ro~~~a.OO~00c::(l)::la~ ..-()~enJ!!ro--,()~rouWIc.')~..- r-- " Q) g- o o '" o o N ~ (J) o o N ~ ~ ~ ~ :;; .c YO e o on $ rn "->- <D g o Q) on U ::l CD ro o " e o e E m OJ co e '" ::2: "' "' m :2; <l: I.l") N I.l") """ o ~ o ~ o N - to ~ - N ~ Q) - 'tl ) C o "" OJ U Q) >< W JJ <0 - Q) o Q) rJl <0 U Ul C .. E E o u ~ .5 Q.) ~~...., E_UlO'l......c.~W u:::l.... .ga;rog~""'.cOl ro(J)~ Q) l::::$:N :J~() o"E $ >.::1 (/)ctI. -oJ:: .-tt1Q).oU) c::U~~15 (/) ie'-g 00::-0 >.. oWw uW3..c:c::l .woO 5f~ egg Q; co >-i;;-g15..~ Q) c ~ ::l (J) ~"'C Q) O'l::l ~ 'w en ~ctI_J<:(_Q)fi:::l(/)u>o (ijOe:..g ><.3 E-occ.$ ctI~q, E E-ci-o'cm.3'(ti o.Q)ID_~ w2cQ)womCllE.o..::.:::ro..- -0- ctl :s~r.b t:.~ ctI::Q ~ ~u Q)"O...J uo........ Q) c 3:::1 0.-<:: -~ ~~ u_6 ~ ~(J) 800Wl() ~ .c OJ 0 ~ ...... >'.c Q)..::.::: W U co Q.) u.~ li- c~a.fi u(,) 0l;F cr::3! C ro"'O 0_ E E~ (/).So o-oNo d> ~ Q) 0 0 0 u[tj"'O("") ('\Ie L.. 0100......... Q.)cco co :::I E 0.0' ro 0 -::: ~ > ~ . cn<.9o-oot5qg~-~ 6 o >._ W c:i co 0 ctI 0 Q) >. 3 ..... ..J. g..c.!.Q 0 0..0 U ..... " ell g 32 J ro"'" > l() Q) l() en 0._ -0 co ;:zB~~:5~~ g.2.9~S: .. E o <.> - ::J o <1l 1il 0. E o U 0> o o f::J or ~ ~ -0 .. - .. is. E o u -0 .. ~ ':; '" .. 0:: 0> o o N :iE ~ ~ -0 .. " '" 'iij Ul <l: ~ '" .<;; '" " o '" 2 <ii 0.>, <.> Ul " Cl " <1l "5 <1l a:: '!;; -..II z-I.../ "'-_..&...&.. 1"'.....11 ..... I .1 '0 o ~ -g ,,!. (/) 0...... co ...... (/)-g~~~ ~~ ~>..!..g a3 .2'~ ~ :: a3 ~.3 I Q.l"CC g ~ ~ c 0 -0 'C s.... Q).2 c -0 - ro c a. :; ...., co co o'S .c Ul 0 0 ;tZ ~ Ul ..... (I)>q!iro~~CUwoD..o ~~ro30~-C'0..9Q) ::cN (5 ~ $: Q) 0 Q) c:.o (/) Q).c O)'(ij'c ~ ~ 0:: ~ C Lt) m Q) ....:0 :::I -;.5 ED.. _ _ro~ -62,o-o....-gm '18 Q) Cl..co ClQ) fIl Cl..Q)- rJ:l,E m......."'C ro t5 ~R.5fi.~ CIJ.... E.E Q) Cl..a3 ffi-o m >, :=I.::t:. m 0 CIl ro E o...c III ~n.-J c.. c.. en m.c E co:::::::: -, O}"- VJ :=I coencm- ..c~..c,-c-oa>~m W :=I.Q'lCll-oCij m O~2";::: Co '- Ole) 1Il en.!!2 're c .c. t.) > m 0 :=I C C U c..(l) >,c..o-o '- Ol-g~ro-g"C'~ OEOOl(l):2(l)~.5en -e)~ctl N ro c..g>~:g.!!2 aID"> a>a3 e .> ..- ;: -g ro ..c co ~ '(i5 (l) -0 g E c....c -g O)(j)- c..>'- ctl,~ E<C ctl m O'lg_ 0-0 "'E ,,::J Em ..-uc CIl , m (l) .c. ..c ~ E.o "0 c.. '- .;:: ::0 (l) 0) M-:=Iro-c.. '_ESroc:=lo 'CEO";:,- ..co=- CO):=I 0" , ;:u e::(j)~ g-~U'~ g 8WIc.9 e::~ 1:: .!'e 0. c!: E o 0 ZO m o o N N ~ 0> o o N f1! ~ ~ ~ '" .<;; '" c o '" 2 <ii 0.>, " .Q 13 " ~ , " , 0 enO<;' <1lN~ Uo"- O"-~ N,,~ NO", ;;-o~ 02en ,:t:::o NE"" "'7...cN _::J~ ~ '" t--(tj o:::~> Que 0... ~~ WIll<1l <rW~ LUU.E rJl '" <{ '" c U.5~ Z-o<1l wiii5: [Lo.. Q"!!2 ~ g5 " 1il 0. E o U 0> o o N N ~ - ~ ~ 0> o o N N ~ ~ ~ ~ '" .<;; '" c o '" 2 <ii 0.>, " " "5 " <r '!;; 0> o 00 N N ~ ai<.> ",,- :.01,{) "'" "0. 0.'" ~~ ";; 0) ,,0> 0::0 -00 ~<;' en <1lNO ...J~ , l[)'-~ "<;f".E, O)-o~ ~~-2 J,-o'- <i"~~ ~"o. ~"'''' <Xl " 1il 0. E o U 0> o o N ;:n f::J ~ ~ 0> o o N ;:n ~ ~ ~ ~ '" .<;; '" " o '" 2 <ii 0.>, <1l g o U; OJ ::? iO ciS c (]) E (]) OJ ro c ro :::: if> if> <1l " <1l S " 0:: '!;; 2 <t: L{) N .r; ':'l: o ~ o ~ o N - CD ~ - N ~ (lJ ~ ro o c o :;:; :::J o (lJ >< w '" <Il ill o (lJ '" ro o U> 'E '" E E o o .g_ .92'E ;::OOC5ro:::l ..9:cucu-o LLQ.llIJ3::.QQ.l CSE>.o2:?-g cQ.lro~oQ)o .Ql ~ -g Q) ~ fFo en.E...... 0._ :J N Q)cE2{6oo.,.!. ..c: Q) 0 0.. CD' :;o';Q.l~::~ we Cii===-.::: c.Q a.l 3::'~ s: I.() ~~>'.Q>.c~ ~Q)~roQ)Q.lU) UfFoo-5Eo U;:l.....-Q.lWO CO(f).EcriID~"'t OctlQ)D.c_a.i 1.!)":':::(I);::s:Jju (")CtiroNal :..= O'l u c 0 oo...C""""_CC ~2.Q>oE.Q'lQ:; 95 (/)22 (/);5 N o..Q) ro Cl) Q.ll.... ..--(/)-5-0-0-52 '" " (; " :; o " a:; C. E o U 0) o o ~ ~ N ~ '0 '" a; a. E o o '0 '" ~ ':; 0' '" a:: 0> o o '" 03 '" N ~ '0 " " '" 'iij U> <l: ~ :;; .c en c o en 2 ro 0.>, " III " o ~ " ";; " a:: :;;; en ~Cil - "" '" " iI1~ "" .~ U Q) o e c ..c Cl..:, 3: C>Q) c.f: ct: g ro ~ " c " .c 0 ~ E "if) 0... e'~ ~- " l....Q.lu"'" 1?~u'<t "'''co$: :5g'.9J -"~ ;0:- s: ro ~ ..... (1)....-00) -3:gIDc75 c%.~ ~.9 " " " " iil a:: 0> o o ~ '" N ~ 0) o o '" 03 '" N ~ o :Q '" ~ ~ c c _~ c ~ " ";; " a: <Ii CO> en en '" '" III .8 ~ '" ~ ",en :.::: co :g~ > ~ c " "- .c S'" " " " " 5," "05 .~ ~2 ~~= Q)Q.l~ .0 " " ro.-=:: ~~~ ID Cl..-ci en E " '" 0 " " " c .ffi c. , - c c o 0 zu o ~ o '" N 03 o ~ o '" N 03 ~ o c %! " .c .'! .2 c Q " " 0. '" 0 ~ Q) ~ ..- LO .... Ul Q) ..... 0 ..- co ro O..c Q.N ,.. a.. u -. s: ~..o g{qCOlC,) ::::"7 'V 0 .QlS2 c c: = ro..- c.. Vl"--"E me ..... ~U) Q.lN .....w:J a5~ oro.:;..-2Q.l"O"O.... ~:2-oQ.l..cQ)E>- L.()....O -O......-OQ.)t:: 1.Q-$OQ.lC>CIJ ~U.~ro::C6~OCl.. roE"'O(l)uU)Z(D I- Q.lUCO::ll:J::O 0:: c uu::a:5 V).-.- o.Qlocoo....(l)E~ a..f/.I_ >,o.ouo WwCEt-=o::Cl.. a:.cQ)OQ)~':;-CJ) ............. .... 0...0 > = (]) w,oO-oro-5:.... cn.scro....Q.)c .:5 <( c: 0 Q) c...o Q) 0 .- Uro"oo>'<1>_E..--s: .....C<ll.c=<llo..... zcn<llc.....~2~~ We) 0..0 ~ >.0..-..... D...e)~'-..QwcN5 OcoU'JEro:Sw.,..-u " a:; C. E o U o ~ o '" co 23 ~ o ~ o N 23 '" m :;; .c en c o en 2 ro 0.>, ~ " ";; " a: :;;; ....Jj L..L.j L..'-"..L..L 1"''-111 ..L I .r~. 00)0 <ll W ~g:: ro~o~ -g ~~jge)~~;3 D... CO~UUmO)oa> Cf) ON >,co 0.. 0:'::::: 5: c=t::o ~E "'E""'cO""- o C a.i Cf) a> N" .,- V5' :J 0.. ~ NocEt::.c.,..-a> -oU), , 0 o......_(j)wa>rol.() l.() ~ Ol.9 0..'0 o-of;-o"C~ ~oc"CU).....w we'co o c';;:'w ro c.......8...... (I) 0.,..- .,..- U) - e "0 w ~ '- ro o...u::: 0 1-~(l)O)o>::E (1)UCh.....W Ch.-OWOC.Q:Ju..... a:OIDro~u:::U03:~Ch.9~ a.Uro..... '-Ill 0 Wea. D...:J"'CIwro.EE>..9-Oo:J WCl)C'-e~ t::w;:;;;;ue 0::: 0 6 <ll .9> _ e ~::c :: ;:;;;; .Ql w.....u.~U'JO:::OttlCS:Ch CI)::O,,;O<DCCOc.Wwom <:(I-Cf) .cow -OEO" UO<llO......v;>.ID_ "--:J 1-:J.,..-"'OC(1).c=<lloo- Z C1"02wc.....::2~~ w ffi ~ NeD.. 0 :: >...9""- D... ro >.~ ~ ~ ,-,g <ll C N D.. OO..oN 0'lU'J..9 co:5w..- ~ " a:; C. E o U o o N co '" 23 ~ o o N co N o ~ ~ :;; .c en c o en 2 ro 0.>, ~ " ";; (!) a: :;;; " " . 'in '" " c " .cO' o (!) ..., ~ >,~ "0 c~ '" x a:~ 'O~o ,,~~ =0)0 '" 'N u<o' 0>'" o"'~ o A\~ 0> ""'~ 6 . U "'''- <Xl 0 ~ en " o en" ""-<!Ci5 ox" C"\l .- a. J,~:J NO C 6.c O'l .,..-D....(i) " a:; C. E o U o ~ o N co N o ~ o ~ o N co N 23 ~ :;; .c en C o '" 2 ro 0.>, <Ii U " c o Ol Cll .::2 6 m en "" :J :0 0: c Cll E " Ol '" c 111 :2i OJ) OJ) Cll ~ <l: L!) c:'! L!) :l: o ~ o ~ o N - CO ~ - N ~ Q) - 'tl J c o :;::; ~ t) Q) >< UJ JJ CIl a; o Q) Ul CIl U <II - l: Q) E E o t) en "'C Q.l ~ c: "'Oa5E.2 o-E~~cc2 N-,ropCOO....... 0>. s: - "" ......"Oro1:I:.8~2 ~ ffi.!:2 CO O)~~ OO::Q.l>'C_:J N .c ctI 'E = 0- 'E-ocnoS:Q.) ~ e"m '- <..) >,0::: o::l1lctlu)Q.lc ......-(/)~.--Eo CO C I 0.-0 'en l-u.,Cw=Q.lCO a::COcc-Q)"- 0=--' o Olctl_O c........ .... CO"iij 1;; ~ ~ w~:2..c(l)Q),-LO a:::"'O ."".c I Q)"- <lJ 00...... .!: I W .2: ;; .; c.." a3 (5 ;: ~(l)NCQ)..o~U ()~cbQ)~E,-"";;:; Za::';J~.9~..Q2 WOO"""UQ)Uro c.."'......roUOU"O o ~ 6.f; llJ .!:: OJ g- Q) E o " :; o " a:; C. E o u o ~ o N co N 25 ~ 'C Q) Qj Q. E o t) 'C Q) ~ ':; '" Q) ll: o ~ o N co ~ - ~ ~ 'C Q) l: C> .;;; Ul <l: ~ i; .c '" " o '" 2 rn 0.;., " Ul Q) Cl " " .;; " a:: '!;; E ~ o 0 ~- - " Ul" 2 a:; .gJ", 0.= :~ " .c t .2 ui l: .c 00 o""~ Z ;.,0 O"ON o~~ ~a::"7 , ~N "'O~ "' ;., " 0) all::: 00>. ~"o OaJ~ N 0.0 chEN ~rnU ",!"S:W ~UlO 1:: .!ll C. C: E o 0 ZU o ~ o N co ~ ~ ~ o ~ o N co ~ - ~ ~ ~ i; .c '" to o i" 2 rn 0.;" to .Q 1:3 " 0. 2(1) rn- "00 g-(/) II) oOrn f-f-t 000 I I 0. n..a..~ o'E == ......02 ::::;:}O>o .!a enO...... :> == CD 0 Q):J(J)N ::::>cocb CIJ>u I ~wQ)~ co..c"O u "':::: Co 0_ .::::::ctlu"" o 0,-0 -6 ..- 0 C (l) ~oroU) M -a~ ~ Nco03g ......_ctl.... " a:; C. E o U o ~ o N iO N ~ o ~ o N ?; N ~ ~ i; .c '" to o '" 2 rn 0.;., "' Q) OJ 1:3 0: " >::" ~ C " 0 Cl.::::: " rn Ul1:: "0 " .!!1 E 0." 8 g ~"O o-g .9t5 " "m 6- ~ [l2 c~ ""0 C/) '>0 00~ C;O=~ c;J~~ <9'2~ N~N ~rJJ~ " a:; C. E o U o ~ o N iO N ~ o ~ o N iO N ~ ~ i; .c '" to o '" 2 rn 0.;., " " s " a:: '!;; ...II'-'-I'"V.L..L 1'-'-111 .....,.". :::uo ~ ~ ro rnE~~}1l ~ .9 .~ :J 0 '- Q.l ~ '- co IDa.. - 0lQ)..g.c-C O(j) cu~E..oc~ro::- o Q) Q) >._ W O'O"(i}t9O -0 i;: X 'E ~ g'-ro a5"S: -g c; ~r.nQ)5c.c'c ~Q.lroN oC-5uO......Q.lC:=:t::M u.cc .-vroo(/) I Coal:;:;...... ~:;::::Q.lON "''''' E.!: Q) '- 0 00..::.:: 0....... co>. 1-n..Q)OQ)ro~D 5:-gN C Q)..QEJ:;; ~E=\::; 1.0 ..... C>J:;; a. _ co ~ & ctI 'u; - ~ a>.:: 5: ID Co N c>__"Oa>3;2c>"O ......~C;:;:Q.)O>Ol .".w , O'l'- '-"ro 0'- Q) U) U) 0'lU) O'l U Q) ~ U) U) U) 'E- NroQ):::l'_J:;;a.Q)ro~ NU:::::lCO-o_OJ:;;U ..Q ..... c:r 0..:: C - - Q) Q) ~ OO~E(/)O-Oo-o-g~ O~cro~"C2c8uo NOO~ Q.l(/)o ~- , .- en Q.l "C Q):;:;; Q) 0 >. '7E'-=: u.2:::lroJ:;;"5"O NpID Q)!E U O-U-J:;; ro ..... ..::: 0.. -5 0 .c ~ 0 '0 a. ~ 1:: .!ll C. C: E o 0 zu o ~ o N ?; N ~ o ~ o N t::: N ~ ~ i; .c '" to o '" 2 rn 0.;., l: o t5 " 0. 0> to '5 to " Il. o N t::: ~ i; .c '" to o '" 2 rn 0.;., to o 13 " 0. <II ~ c Q) E E 0 t) 0 - '" C ::l 0 E ..: 'C Q) ti .. ~ ~ 0 t) 0> 'C 0 0 Q) N ~ t::: Q) 'E co W "0 .. " ::l " n; '" u; !!! > 0 z c .2 15. ." " .. Q) C to .2 n; '0 E :> i; o ~ " '" -= o ill 01 U " co 06 c (1) E " 01 ro to ro :2 '" '" m -'I L..L.I.L.V..I,...l" IL.'-'III ..1,.1 .r-\. ~ 2 ~ <l: L{) N L{) :t: 0 ~ " 0 g ~ '5 0 " N 0 - U <D ~ - N ~ Q) ~ ell 0 c :2 :::l >> () '" Q) Cl >< a; w " u: " u " .!!! a. E 0 u :; VI " <>: " 0 VI '" " (J) <>: co := 0 ai OJ u ::; aJ c. U) C (J) ell ~ E Q) (J) 0 ;:: en ro Q) c ro U) ~ ell U on on m 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. RESOLUTION NO. II-_ RELATING TO PETITION NUMBER SV-2006-AR-9400 FOR AN AFTER-THE-FACT SIGN VARIANCE FOR THE SWAMP BUGGY RACES/FLORIDA SPORTS PARK. THE SIGN VARIANCE REQUESTED IS TO ALLOW AN EXISTING NON-CONFORMING, OFF-I'REMISES DIRECTIONAL SIGN TO REMAIN AT ITS EXISTING LOCATION UNTIL THE RATTLESNAKE- HAMMOCK/COLLIER BOULEVARD BRIDGE IS EXPANDED OR AN ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER ALLOWS THE SIGN TO BE MOVED ONTO THEIR PROPERTY. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF COLLIER BOULEVARD AND RATTLESNAKE-HAMMOCK ROAD ON )'ROI'ERTY HEREINAFTER DESCRIBED IN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter] 25, Florida Statutes, has conferred on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 04-41) which establishes regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of variances; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided. and has considered the advisability of an after-the-fact sign variance to allow an existing, non-conforming off-premises directional sign (hereinafter referred to as the "Sign") to remain at its existing location until the Rattlesnake- Hammock/Collier Boulevard bridge is expanded or an adjaccnt propcrty owner allows the Si!,'ll to be moved onto their property. The Sign is located on the southeast corner of Collier Boulevard and Rattlesnake-Hammock Road, as shown on a site plan attached as Exhibit "A." The BZA has found as a matter of fact that satisfactory provision and arrangemcnt have bcen made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Section 9.04.00 of the Zoning Regulations of said Land Developmcnt Code for the unincorporated area of Collicr County; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given the oPPOliunity to be heard by this Board in public meeting assembled and the Board having considercd all matters presented. NOW. THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that Petition SV-2006-AR-9400 regarding the property hereinafter describcd as: Parcel ] 7 of Section 14, Township 50 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida, Swamp Buggy Sign Variance / SV-2006-AR.9400 Rev. 02!16iJ I I of 2 Packet Page -1346- 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. be and the same is hereby approved for an after-the-fact sib'11 variance extension for the Swamp Buggy Races/Florida Sports Park. The sign may remain at its existing location as sho\\'I1 on Exhibit "A" until the earlier of the two following events: I. The Rattlesnake-Hammock/Collier Boulevard bridge is expanded; 2. The adjacent propel1y owner allows the sign to be relocated on their property. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution relating to Petition Number SV- 2006-AR-9400, Swamp Buggy Sign Variance, be recorded in the minutes of this Board. This Resolution adopted afier motion, second and majority vote. Done this day of .2011. ATTEST: DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY. FLORIDA By: By: FRED W. COYLE, Chairman , Deputy Clerk Approved as to form and legal suiliciency: Steven T. \Villiams ~..,) Assistant County Attorney 5 ;;/171, ( Attachment: Exhibit A - Sign Variance Exhibit CP\06-CPS-()()" 83\ I 0 Swamp Buggy Sign Varianc.:e:, SV-:?006~AR~9.;.jOO Rev. 02/16/1 1 201'2 Packet Page -1347- v. .:LI8.IHXa f--- OJ I X W w U Z <( cr: <( > z C) Ul ~_T w.n Or-- ~'''1'" ,,- Vi i GID ifj'..c-: "- "-'" 011 c.> O~ "..l-W !" 10:: l~o , "" 11Ilo I- 1",0:: I~ , j5 / .,. --/ -':: /...- I,() / - -------:;;.~ ':, ) ,~""~" ii '\'" ,. ~ ~o~ ;)~- ~ , ,., I ~l }. t ...1.'...'" \\~~ "J't}. ,("\I ~t~- 'C'O:J t"\I "dO") '" 20"3 --- ::::~ '---. -0 '\ -----~---_...-/ d"O) ____________.~.22_ ___ > 8jtt ii5lj c.c ~fll "' " u:: ,,"" 0"- 0;<11 0>- -'U:: "-0 "- <11 io .ri tD en 0- :: II => ' O::J (Y...J Ow.J 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. I z ~ 8 o ;:: Ii · w "- w i- u z " <; 0: " " ~ ~ > 0 r..), z io C> Vi ~ ! . K >- 0 Ei :;; I X vi W 0:: w w U I Z >- 0 <t 0:: 0: '" <t > -' ...J Z 0 C> c- Vi ~ " g 0 ~ ,w ~- '0 w '~~~ lVNlfJ ClNI1SIXJ ";6 O\fOCJ ),_NilOO .. "I!'O'J 'a'e... "C'l '- ~Il~ l~:: ~ C __ i ~" ~ ~ o ~ !.~~~ he$ ~!g ln~ ii I .rilt" ~]~ <J ;. =-0"" ~~-l I-<..l~ Io"""'~~ ""z.~ """,,804 "I" :- ::- s-!~ ... \ \ \ I I '.m~ /---------------------- 11:0' ~ o ./ ~ :: w"" / ~ ' "0 I , . _ .1 _ Z 0::: / :: ! ;: i::; <i ~ 0 1 Vl ~ 'e t;: wu ~&r,. ---10 ... ~ 1=::> <::> 0::<( J: " ..'" 11 ~ ~ ~ Packet Page -1348- ...1" "I~ "110, z . . ~ . w 3 3 3/22/2011 Item 17.A. 24D . Wednesday, March 2, 2011 · Naples DaDy News NonCE OFINTENTTO CONSIDER RESOLUTION Notice is hereby given that the Board of County Commissioners, as the Board of Zoning Appeals. of Collier County will hold a public hearing on Tuesday, March 22, 2011, in the Boardroom, 3rd Floor, Administration Building, Collier County Govern- ment Center, 3299 East Tamiami Trail, Naples. Florida. The meeting will begin at 9:00 A.M. The title of the proposed resolution is as follows: RElATING TO PETITION NUMBER SV.2006-AR-9400 FOR AN AFTER-THE-FACT SIGN VARIANCE FOR THE SWAMP BUGGY RACESJFLORIDA SPORTS PARK. THE SIGN VARI- ANCE REQUESTED IS TO ALLOW AN EXISTING NON-CONFORMING, OFF.PREMISES DIRECTIONAL SIGN TO REMAIN AT ITS EXISTING LOCATION UNTIL THE RATILE- SNAKE-HAMMOCK/COLLIER BOULEVARD BRIDGE IS EXPANDED OR AN ADJACENT PROPERTY OWNER ALLOWS THE SIGN TO BE MOVED ONTO THEIR PROPERTY. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF COLLIER BOULE- VARD AND RATTLESNAKE-HAMMOCK ROAD ON PROPERTY HEREINAFTER OE- seR/BED IN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. Copies of the proposed Resolution are on file with the Clerk to the Board and are available for inspection. All interested parties are invited to attend and be heard. , NOTE: All Persons wishing to. speak on any agenda item must register with the County Administrator prior to presentation of the agenda item to be addressed. Individual speakers will be limited to 3 minutes on any item. The selection of an in- dividual to speak on behalf of an organization or group is encouraged. If recog. nized by the Chair, a spokesperson for a group or organization may be allotted to minutes to speak on an item. . Persons wishing to have written or graphic materials included in the Board agenda. packets must submit said material a minimum of 3 weeks prior to the respective. public hearing. In any case, written materials Intended to be considered by the Board shall be submitted to the appropriate County staff a minimum of seven days prior to the puolk heanng. All material used in presentations before the Board will become a permanent part ofthe record. Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the Board will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evi- dence upon which the appeal is based, If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to pa'r. tiClpate in this proceeding; you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Depart- ment, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Building W, Naples, Florida 34112, (239) 252.8380. Assisted listening devices for the heatlng impaired are available in the County Commissioners' Office. BOARD Of COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA FRED COYLE, CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E. BROCK. CLERK -,,~'.~i.~1 ,:..... ."''''';' ,:;:~- ~f::' By: Teresa Polaski, Deputy Clerk (SEAL) M;mh") lOtt No1RQOQtO Nn1R'IM10 Packet Page -1349-