Agenda 03/08/2011 Item # 7A
.
.
.
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This item requires that ex pal1e disclosure be provided by Commission members. Shoul,d a hearing
be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. A Resolution of the Board of
Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida, relating to Petition Number V A~PL2010-739, for ft
variance from Land Development Code Section 5.03.06 E.6 to permit a reduced side yard (riparian)
setback from 7.5 feet to 0 feet on property located at 39 West Pelican Street in Section 31, Township
51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
OBJECTIVE:
To have the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) consider an application for a proposed Variance to
pennit a boat dock facility and ensure the project is in hannony with all the applicable codes and
regulations in order to ensure that the community's interests are maintained,
CONSIDERATIONS:
The .18:1: acre property has an existing single family home in Isle of Capri on a lot with
converging riparian lines into Pompano Bay. The petitioner proposes a wood finger boat dock to
facilitate one (1) vessel up to 17 feet in length. The proposed boat dock will be 3 feet wide and
153 feet long (as measured from the mean high water line (MHWL) and will total 374:J=: square
feet over water. This Variance petition is a companion application to a boat dock extension
petition for a proposed 133-foo1' extension to the maximum allowed 20-foot boat dock whic~ if
approved, would allow a 153-foot long dock.
The Conceptual Site Plan entitled "Schneller Dock - Proposed Walkway and Dock Layouf'
revised on September 1, 2010 and prepared by Turrell, Hall & Associates, IDC, illustrates the
location of the proposed boat dock and vessel. (See Site Plan included in the resolution and in
the Application),
According to infonnation provided by the applicant, the neighbors to the north (west) of the
subject site have existing, single boat docks that are approximately 215.feet long. The neighbor
directly to the 'east of the subject site does not have a boat dock.
The applicant has received a letter of no objection (included in the backup materials) from the
neighbor to the north. Staff also received a letter from the neighbor from the south stating that
there was a civil case (No.02-1743-CA) cancelling clain1s of purported riparian rights of the
subject lot, Lot 81. Staff has researched the allegation and the Collier COlU1ty Planning
Commission (CCPC) received testimony that has led to the conclusion that Lot 81 has riparian
rights.
FISCAL IMPACT:
Approval of this Variance petition would have no fiscal impact on Collier COlU1ty.
Packet Page -23-
.
.
.
-;.~
,.~"..,
3/8/2011 Item 7 .A.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) IMPACT:
Future Land Use Element (FLUE): The subject properties are located within the Urban
Residential Sub-district of the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the GMP. The GMP does not
address boat docks, it focuses on the greater issue of actual land use,
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES:
This Variance petition was not required to be presented to the Environmental Advisory Council
(EAC).
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION:
The CCPC heard petition VA-PL2010-739, Schneller Boat Dock on January 20,2011, and by a
vote of 9-0 recommended to forward this petition to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a
recommendation of approval.
Because the CCPC motion was unanimous and the letter claiming that the subject lot has no
riparian rights has been detennined and testified to be not true, this petition has been placed on
the Smllinary agenda.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS:
TIns matter has been reviewed by the County Attorney's Office and has been found legally
sufficient for Board action, A majority vote is required for approval. (STW)
RECOMMENDATION:
StaffreconIDlends that the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) approve the request for V A-PL20 1 0-
739, Schneller Boat Dock.
PREPARED BY:
Nancy Gundlach, AICP, Principal Planner
Depmtment of Zoning & Land Development Review
Attachments: 1) Staff Report
2) Application
3) Puente Letter
4) Resolution
Packet Page -24-
.
.
.
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 7.A.
Item Summary: This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission
members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. A
Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida, relating to Petition
Number VA-PL2010-739, for a variance from Land Development Code Section 5.03.06 E,6 to
permit a reduced side yard (riparian) setback from 7.5 feet to 0 feet on property located at 39
West Pelican Street in Section 31, Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida.
Meeting D~te: 3/8/2011
Prepared By
Name: GundlachNancy
Title: Planner, Principal, Comprehensive Planning
2/9/2011 4:42:49 PM
Approved By
Name: PuigJudy
Title: Operations Analyst, CDES
Date: 2/10/20113:15:53 PM
Name: LorenzWilliam
Title: Director - CDES Engineering Services, Comprehensive
Date: 2/10/201 15:33:10 PM
Name: BellowsRay
Title: Manager - Planning, Comprehensive Planning
Date: 2/11/201 14:06:00 PM
Name: MarcellaJeanne
Title: Executive Secretary, Transportation Planning
Date: 2/14/201 I 8:33:57 AM
Name: FederNorm
Title: Administrator - Growth Management Div,Transportati
Date: 2/15/2011 5:06:53 PM
Packet Page -25-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
. Name: WilliamsSteven
Title: Assistant County Attorney,County Attorney
Date: 2/18/2011 10:06:31 AM
Name: KlatzkowJeff
Title: County Attorney,
Date: 2/24/2011 2:30:17 PM
NatTIe: IsacksonMark
Title: Director-Corp Financial and Mgmt Svs,CMO
Date: 2/25/20113:02:12 PM
Name: IsacksonMark
Title: Director-Corp Financial and Mgmt Svs,CMO
Date: 2/25/20] ] 3:09:56 PM
.
.
Packet Page -26-
.
.
.
3/8/2011 Item l.A.
Co~T County
~~ -
STAFF REPORT
TO:
COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM:
DEPARTMENT OF LAND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
GROWrn MANAGEMENTDMSION, PLANNING AND
REGULATION
HEARING DATE: JANUARY 20,2011
SUBJECT:
PETmONVA-2010-739 SCHNELLER VARIANCE
COMPANION ITEM: BD-2008-AR-13142
PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT:
Owner:
Paul Schneller
39 West Pelican Street
Naples, FL 34113
Agent: Mr. Jeff Rogers
Turrell, Hall & Associates, Inc.
3548 Exchange Avenue
Naples, FL 34104
REQUESTED ACTION:
To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider an application for a
proposed variance from the required side yard riparian line setback of 7.5 feet for property with
less than 60 feet of water frontage to zero (0) feet as provided for in Section 5.03.06 E.6 of the
Land Development Code (LDC). The requested action (if approved) would allow a dock facility
at 0- foot from the riparian line.
GEOGRAPIDC LOCATION:
The subject property is located at 39 West Pelican Street, further described as Lot 81, Isles of
Capri No.1, Section 31, Township 51, South, Range 26 East, Collier County, Florida (See
location map onfollowing page)
PURPOSEIDESCRIPTION OF PROJECT:
The .18:f: acre property has an existing single family home in Isle of Capri on a lot with
converging riparian lines into Pompano Bay. The petitioner proposes a wood fInger boat dock to
facilitate one (1) vessel up to 17 feet in length. The proposed boat dock will be 3 feet wide and
VA-2010-739
12-21-10
D",..o 1 ^. 7
Packet Page -27-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
g .
iE
c.. a..
<
<.>
.... <(
0
rJ) ~
w
-'
!!!
~ ....
00
0 (/') (!)
:z I
< <
...
~ Z
0
Q.
-
Z
cz: 0
~ N
ii:
0
u
cz:
<
~
I
N~
"'";
~ ..,...,;
I- ~ C"):
....!
rn ~ 'I
I ~
< 0::,
.,. <(
'"
~ ,
~ CD
Q
Q
N
"""...- / E- ~.
-
'II:
Z
0
!::
I-
W
i~" ~ ll.i
.. I
..
a..
3 <(
~ :!! ~
Z
0
-
~ f-
<(
U
0
..J
II
Packet Page -28-
.
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
~ B s ~
~ Ii. ~ &rn w
~ 'olL II ff~ 1e
rn~CI)~ ~ w W
wui::.;!! N III ~ (!)
~~a~~ ~ o~ zffiw z
8:z:;rrl~ g E;~ ~ ~ ~ ~
::lQwa:a: c_z~
l1.b~:ro!l: olLftl~ll:
C)::lwUl<lLO--:.....o
~a:a:lLw<')~....t0
'=s;~o!3~z~~~
::~~U;b.:.iza:::C1
ffio~a:::l~ffi8:c:ilt
l1.a:ZNa:::ID<>;:)
~f(@xt;::::~~g
ILca:9a:ooa:c"....
www~wa:a:w .ILQ
a:.c;z:"'l-lI..ILI-OOlb
<zz~~zz~J1>:b
CI)~::CI)~QQ>~UlQ
C)ZOZwCl)CI)15:ii~o '"' ~ ~
~i=:Z:::~~~:r..a:w ..;..~~ l'l
~oO'JO 1-t-t-~5t: ~ ~ o! z'
~Z~i~~~8~o~ 0
C~I-<~l1.~::~>~ ~
~~<~~11.~~~~~> 0
~WC~Q.O~I-I-~a:.a: w
~~~~~~ggg~~~ 0
~o 00000000
b
C')
eI)...1
-...Iu..
::-u.
a:.~-
oc~
!!. ~-
~<t:=
11.~<
~J:W
~::!<
_wt::
::>...1
a:: 0 (3
~~if
w iii'
~zl-.!~
O~'Tc:i
IE!!: II >
~-!irlc.;
:ii ~
o
rti
11I11I
o>z
~O::l
a:.a:.w
c..C)C)
Will
x~z
Oa:.::l
a:C)1-
l1.z0
~~~
w
iiJZ '"
xz:::J",~
o::;~~c:i
lE::ffiu.::o:
~
~
a:l
o
Z
<(
a..
~
o
a..
W
l1.~C
~a:.;:
!!:_ofl
a:....~
l:)
'D
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
~
~
~
C)~
zo
-0
\ ~c
-u..
\ ffio
\10
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
w
~-~
~
t"
P:ID662 SCI1neDor Dod<I&lwgsIlJ662-Sa1NEUER DOCK-l'ERMIT.llwg
Packet Page -29-
~:
OW
w...J
NlE
~~
ZO
-ll.
::iE}-
Zz
Ww
WI-
~~
~t;
J:w
en...l
}-...1
0;:)
<u.
ll.W
~~
..
e..
WiLl
>w
00::
::iEu.
Wo
0::-
wb
~~
:::!e
3:w
enZ
0-
-~
I-z
0_
~~
...Ie
...Iz
:t<
..
I-
eI)
W
~
I-
W
W('I)
~~~
~en~
==Z...l
Cl<u..
Cl 0 .
<::Jf3
li;1W.,J
E-oll.ll.
_m<
l'I.l('l)Z
... ~ ~ ~
Z 8 t . 10
~~~~n:
iii~~~i:
II: ~ ;;; :i: III
g g Z
~
~
c :>: ..
w CD C u
~ ~ I!! ~
13 ~ ~ III
ceo !;
;t
o
o
o
C!
W
.J
.J
W
Z
I
()
(f)
r-
:J
o
~
~
t)
o
Q
Q
Z
c::(
>-
~
~
...J
~
Q
UJ
en
o
a.
o
~
a.
c.> ~::1 ~
:::: 0'; ~ ~
--~'3 i ....
CI:l ~_~
CL>o.~
~u:38.
-as ~.o
Oc:..!l.e
~~lii'
<a:Z:",
~8r:l'"
.........> .~~
-atE ~~
::I::~~~
_~ a> ~ 8.
~.a ~g
!-<E3 = ..= 0
""" u..c:;
.... ~...
E-< ~
"'8
"'8
!1
j
I
~
l
. 3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
153 feet long (as measured from the mean high water line (MHWL)) and will total 374:!: square .
feet over water. This variance petition is a companion application to a boat dock extension
petition for a proposed 133-foot extension to the maximum allowed 20-foot boat dock which, if
approved, would allow a 153-foot long dock.
The Conceptual Site Plan entitled "Schneller Dock - Proposed Walkway and Dock Layout"
revised on September 1, 2010 and prepared by Turrell, Hall & Associates, Inc. illustrates the
location of the proposed boat dock and vessel. (See Site Plan on previous page).
According to information provided by the applicant, the neighbors to the north (west) of the
subject site have existing, single boat docks that are approximately 215 feet long. The neighbor
directly to the east of the subject site does not have a boat dock.
In addition, the applicant has received a letter of no objection (attached) from the neighbor to the
north.
SURROUNDING LAND USE & WNING:
North:
Pompano Bay, a 1,152-foot waterway with a zoning designation of A-ST
East:
Single-family residence on Lot 80, with a zoning designation of RSF-4
South:
Pelican Street, then Marco Towers, with a zoning designation ofRMF-12
.
West:
Single-family residence on Lot 82, with a zoning designation of RSF-4
.
AERIAL
VA-201Q-739
12-16-10
Packet Page -30-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY:
The subject property is located in the Urban Mixed Use Residential land use classification on the
County's Future Land Use Map (FLUM). This land use category is designed to accommodate a
variety of residential uses including single family, multi-family, duplex, mobile home and
mixed-use projects. As previously noted, the subject petition seeks a variance for a single family
home that is located within a single-family subdivision, which is an authorized use in this land
use designation, therefore, the single family home use is consistent with the FLUM. The Growth
Management Plan CGMP) does not address individual variance requests; the Plan deals with the
larger issue of the actual use.
ANALYSIS:
Section 9.04.01 of the Land Development Code gives the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) the
authority to grant Variances. The Planning Commission is advisory to the BZA and utilizes the
provisions of Section 9.04.03 A. through H. (in bold font below), as general guidelines to assist
in making their recommendation of approval or denial. Staff has analyzed this petition -relative
to these provisions and offers the following responses:
.
a. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing, which are peculiar to the
location, size and characteristics of the land, structure or building involved?
Yes. The subject property has narrow pie shaped riparian lines with the narrowest piece
located where the proposed dock is to be located.
The intersection of the riparian lines restrict the mooring of the applicant's vessel. The
vessel will be located within the riparian rights of the applicant and in adequate water for
safe ingress/egress to Pompano Bay.
b. Are there special conditions and circumstances, which do not result from the action
of the applicant such as pre-existing conditions relative to the property, which are the
subject of the Variance request?
Yes. The existing water depths are too shallow within the pie shaped riparian lines to moor
a vessel within the required 7.5-foot riparian side yard setback.
c. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this zoning code work unnecessary
and undue hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties for the applicant?
Yes. The site conditions, mentioned above, make it difficult for the applicant to moor his
vessel.
..
d. Will the Variance, if granted, be the minimum Variance that will make possible the
reasonable use of the land, building or structure and which promote standards of
health, safety and welfare?
VA-2010-739
12-16-10
Packet Page -31-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
Yes. The proposed dock is reasonable while still allowing for safe access for the vessel to .
moor within the riparian area
e. Will granting the Variance confer on the applicant any special privilege that is denied
by these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning
district?
No. Most other neighboring properties moor two vessels. This property can only moor one
vessel. In addition, the applicant is requesting a fInger boat dock that is similar to the three
neighboring properties to the north.
f. Will granting the Variance be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of this
Land Development Code, and not be injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise-
detrimental to the public welfare? -
The proposed encroachment would have an impact mostly on the neighbor to the north.
However, the applicant has received a letter of no objection (attached) from the neighbor to
the north. In addition, the proposed dock will have no impact to navigation in the adjacent
bay.
g. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the
goals and objectives of the regulation such as natural preserves, lakes, golf courses,
etc. ?
.
Yes. There is a sandbar that is approximately 125 feet wide between the docking area and
then a mangrove island which pushes the location of the boat dock further into the water.
In addition, the proposed boat dock is located in Pompano Bay, which is an aquatic
preserve that does not allow dredging.
h. Will granting the Variance be consistent with the Growth Management Plan?
Approval of this variance will not affect or change the requirements of the Growth
Management Plan.
ENVIRONMENTAL ADVISORY COUNCIL fEAC) RECOMMENDATION:
This variance petition was not required to go before the EAC for review and approval.
COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW:
The County Attorney Office has reviewed the staff report VA-201O-AR-739, revised December
21,2010. - STW .
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) forward Petition V A-
201O-AR-739, Schneller Boat Dock to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a .
recommendation of approval.
VA-201D-739
12-21-10u
D~",,-~,,",f7
Packet Page -32-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
rPARED BY:
ladf\
A H,AICP,PRJNCIPALPLANNER
T OF LAND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
~ lB 2r'fO
DATE"
REVIEWED BY:
~ ';Y /~
RAYMOND V. BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER
DEPARTMENT OF LAND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
/ Z' z."Z.- {O
DATE
JfJt . ~rf J
LIAM D. LO' NZ J., P~E., DIRECTOR
.PARTMENT OF LAND DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
I 2.. . Z. -z.. - 'LO( (;)
DATE
APPROVED BY:
6);&z~
NICK CASALANGUIDA, DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
GROW1H MANAGEMENT DIVISION
/1. - 2'L- J 0
DATE
iV~u1 P ~
:MAR P. STRAIN, CHAIRMAN
I - [0 -- / (
DATE
Tentatively scheduled for the March 8, 2011 Board of County Commissioners Meeting
aaChments: A. Letter of no objection
B. Resolution
VA-2010-739
12-16-10
-
Packet Page -33-
3/8/2011 Item l.A.
LETTER OF NO OBJECTION
.
PROJECT SITE: SCHNELLER RESIDENCE
39 W Pelican Street
Naples, FL 34113
I hereby state that I am the owner of the adjacent upland riparian property located to the North. of the
proposed dock project at address referenced above. I understand that the subject project is proposing to
construct a dock within the required side yard setback from my property line as shown on the attached
exhibit. I do not object to the proposed dock project and agree to allow the project to be carried out within
the required side yard setback as shown.
Q~ .' /
y" __ II , "--';!.1t....~
. ~.::4~ /~ (J
//) .~
/- ,/~~-
~~~
Vgin~ signature of adjacent owner)
..
t7/:f)dt1n a fd., ~ 1 l- ~1' E.s
,::); h, }-.J\J(>J~.p ~
(printed name ot adjacent owner)
''''1 ,., ~.... v
J A-""w: ~"'1.:.1o
(Date signed)
.
VA-PL2010-739 rev:1
SCHNEUER VARIANCE
Date: 8/2/10
Due: 8/16/10
.
Atti P~cket Pag-e -34-
Co~T County
- ~-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
. COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLIERGOV.NET
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-6358
VARIANCE PETITION APPLICATION
(VARIANCE FROM SETBACK(s) REQUIRED FOR A PARTICULAR ZONING DISTRICT)
PROJECT NUMBER
PROJECT NAME
DATE PROCESSED
To be completed by staff
APPLICANT/AGENT INFORMATION
NAME OF APPLlCANT(S) PAUL SCHNELLER
ADDRESS 39 WEST PELICAN STREET NAPLES. Fl 34113
TELEPHONE # 239-394-0235 . CELL # 239-248-4357 FAX # _
E-MAIL ADDRESS:_
. NAME OF AGENT JEFF ROGERS
ADDRESS 3584 EXCHANGE AVENUE
TELEPHONE # 239-643-0166 CELL # _ FAX # 239-643-6632
E-MAIL ADDRESS:JEFF@TURREll-ASSOCIATES.COM
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
Legal Description of Subiect Property: _
Sedion/Township/Range WllU.22..e. Property 1.0.#: 52343040005
Subdivision: Isles of CODri Unill Lof: .Eli. Block: _
Metes & Bounds Description: _
Acreage: 0.18
Address of Subiec:t Property (If different from Petitioner's address): Same as above
BE AWARE THAT COlliER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE YOURSELF ACCORDINGLY
AND ENSURE THAT YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH THESE REGULATIONS.
.
Packet Page -35-
Co~T Cou.Kty
- ~ -
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLIERGOV.NET
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-6358
.
ASSOCIATIONS
Complete the following for all registered Association(s) that could be affected by this petition. Provide
additional sheets if necessary. Information can be found on the Board of County Commissioner's website at
http://www.collierQov.net/lndex.osox?oooe=n .4
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: ISLE OF CAPRI CIVIC ASSOCIATION
MAILING ADDRESS 338 CAPRI BLVD. CITY NAPLES STATE.E.l ZIP ~
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:_
MAILING ADDRESS _ CITY _ STATE _ ZIP _
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:_
MAILING ADDRESS _ CITY _ STATE _ ZIP ~
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOClATION:_
MAILING ADDRESS _ CITY _ STATE _ ZIP _
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:_
MAILING ADDRESS _ CITY _ STATE _ ZIP _
.
NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION:_
MAILING ADDRESS _ CITY _ STATE _ ZIP _
ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE
Zonin
N RSF-41 AI ST
5 RMF-16
E RSF-4
W RSF-4
Minimum Yard Reauirements for Subiec:f ProDertv:
Front: N/A
Side: U
Rear: N/A
Corner Lof:
Waterfront Lot:
Yes 0
Yes 181
No f8I
No 0
BE ADVISED THAT SECflON 10.03.05.B.3 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIRES AN APPLICANT TO
REMOVE THEIR PUBLIC HEARING SIGN (S) AFTER FINAL ACTION IS TAKEN BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY
COMMISSIONERS. BASeO ON THE BOARD'S FINAL ACTION ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE REMOVE ALL PUBLIC
HEARING ADVERTISING SIGN(S) IMMEOIA TEl Y.
.
Packet Page -36-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLIERGOV.NET
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-6358
NATURE OF PETITION
Provide a detailed explanation of the request including what strudures are existing and what is
proposed; the amount of encroachment proposed using numbers, i.e. reduce front setback from 25' to
18'; when property owner purchased property; when existing principal strudure was built (include
building permit number (5) if possible); why encroachment is necessary; how existing encroachment
came to be; etc.
For projeds authorized under LDC Sedion 9.04.02, provide detailed description of site alterations,
including any dredging and filling.
The procosed clan is to construct a 31 wide walkway with a terminal platform to facilitate the moorina of
a 17' skiff. The total overwater structure is accroximately 374 square feet that will be constructed out of
pressure treated wood and all dock ciles will be wrapped with pvc. Work will be done by barQe where
accessible and by foot usina a jettina system to hand clace clles within the shallow water area. The dock
will crotrude a distance of accroximately 153' feet from Mean Hiah Water CMHWlline into 0 waterway
that is accroximately 1.152 feet wide from MHW to MHW. DredQinQ is not beinQ crocosed for this
proiect.
Please note that staff and the Collier County Planning Commission shall be guided in their recommendation
. to the Board of zoning Appeals, and that the Board of zoning appeals shall be guided in its determination
to approve or deny a variance petition by the below listed criteria (1-8). (Please address these criteria
using additional pages if necessary.)
1. Are there special conditions and circumstances existing which are peculiar to the location, size and
characteristics of the land, structure, or building involved.
The existinQ water decths are too shallow for dockina a vessel and at a 153 foot crotrusion the
required side yard setbacks of 7.5' cannot be obtained because of the cie-shaped riprain lines.
2. Are there special conditions and circumstances which do not result from the action of the applicant such
as pre-existing conditions relative to the property which is the subject of the variance request.
See response to auestion one (1) above.
3. Will a literal interpretation of the provisions of this zoning code work unnecessary and undue
hardship on the applicant or create practical difficulties on the applicant.
Yes. the applicant can not have dock if no variance is aranted due to the unique riprain line situation.
4. Will the variance, if granted, be the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of
the land, building or structure and which promote standards of health, safety or welfare.
.5.
Yes
Will granting the variance requested confer on the petitioner any special privilege that is denied by
these zoning regulations to other lands, buildings, or structures in the same zoning district.
Yes. no setbacks can be provided for the procosed onsite dockina facility.
Packet Page -37-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES. FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252.2400 FAX (239) 252.6358
.
6. Will granting the variance be in harmony with the intent and purpose of this zoning code, and not be
injurious to the neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare.
Yes. it will be harmonious with the zonina code. Due to the existina docks north of the subiect's
prooerty with similar protrusion distances there will be no iniurv to the neiahborhood or detrimental to
public welfare.
.
.
Packet Page -38-
eo1lT County
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES. FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-6358
7. Are there natural conditions or physically induced conditions that ameliorate the goals and objectives
of the regulation such as natural preserves, lakes, golf course, etc.
Yes. the project site is located within an aquatic oreserve which is port of the Rookery Bay Snctuary,
which is why the applicant is orooosina a larae orotrusion over beina allowed to dredae.
8. Will granting the variance be consistent with the growth management plan.
Yes
9. Official Interpretations or Zonin9 Verific:ations: To your knowledge, has there been an official
interpretation or zoning verification rendered on this property within the last year? DYes I8] No
If so, please provide copies.
PUBLIC PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS
NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMA liON MEETING
LOC Section 10.03.05 F.3.
. "Any applicant requesting variance approval or parking exemption approval must provide
documentation to the Zoning Department indicating that property owners within 150 feet of the
subject site have been advised of the extent and nature of the variance or parking exemption
requested within 30 days of receipt of a leHer indicating that the application is sufficient."
Applicant must submit a Property Owner Advisory Letter certifying that the property owners
within 150 feet of the subject site were notified. Letter must have property owners list attached.
Property owners list must be submitted at initial staff review and comment on the application and
before the Public Hearing is scheduled with the Collier County Planning Commission.
.
Packet Page -39-
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLIERGOV.NET
VARIANCE PETITION (VA) APPLICATION
SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252~2400 FAX (239) 252~6358
.
THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED
BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE
ACCEPTED.
REQUIREMENTS
#OF
COPIES
REQUIRED
NOT
REQUIRED
2
1
3
1
o
X
.
X
~
[gJ Pre-application Fee $500.00 (Applications submiHed 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app
meeting shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting will be required.)
Review Fees:
[gJ $2,000.00 Residential
o $5,000.00 Non-Residential
o $2,000.00 Sign Variance
o $100.00 Fire Review
D After- The-Fact Zoning/land Use Petitions 2x the normal petition fee
o $925.00 Estimated legal Advertising Fee - CCPC Meeting
o $500.00 Estimated Legal Advertising Fee - BCC Meeting
(any over- or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Daily News).
o $2,500.00 EIS Review
o $1,000.00 listed Species Survey (If EIS is not required)
OTHER REQUIREMENTS:
D_
o_
4~&.~
10 - :2.'1- /0
Date
Packet Page -40-
.
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
. DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COlLlERGOV.NET .
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252-2400 FAX (239) 252-6358
AFFIDAVIT
We/ .,R... \.. ~~ ~': sworn. dep... and "'Y flat we/I om/are /he 0""" of /he ....- """lbod he.... and
which is the subjed matter of the proposed hearing; that aI/the answers to the questions in this application, including the
disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter aHachecJ to and mode a part of this
application, are honeM and true to the best of our knowledge and belief. We/I understand that the information
requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer
generated or County Pf'inted shall not be altered. Public hearings wiJ/ not be advertised until this application is deemed
complete, and all requirecJ.information has been submitted. . J
-:s~~ ~~( ~'I'T(,ot(( U, U.J ( .J /-e.~;...~J
As property owner Well further authorize _ to ac!I.D"{;;J,./my representative in any matters regarding this Petition.--
~J~
Signature of Property Owner
Signature of Property Owner
~~~~~Uo-
T ypecJ or Printed Name of Owner
Typed or Printed Name of Owner
.
The foregoing instrument was ac:lcnowledged before me this 1t1{ day of ~ . 20 I () . by
~I,)\ ~... S Q.hf\e\\.o <' who is personally known to me or has produced C-M... R.LC.. '
as
identification.
State of Florida
County of Collier
ke~:.- Xl'\ V~ 11 S'5 e. ~f
(Print, Type, Dr Stamp Commissioned Name of Notary Public)
~'I~""
~ /:''Yfl :~ lEE Ll Rl1SSa1.
,~ ~~! :~ MY 00AtdlSsI0N, DO "",,,,,,,,
,,/"" .,.. """"""
~I ~i:~ ..t:.oJ:..~ '<uvol~lIvulRES: October 3D, 2013
~!I''';:'<'''' ,,~...... NoIa1y Public UnderwrileIS
.
Packet Page -41-
Property Owners List 3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
150 Feet of Subject Property
.
.
.
Packet Page -42-
~
o
M
~
:a'
<
<:)
.
-S
00
"
II)
';l
'+:
)<
0-
ell
tU
;:!
'~
5
--
!
II)
~
~
s
~
iU
ell
.~
a
0..
tU
....
~
"0
(,)
u:i
0..
l<I
:::
.::::
.....
~
.:::
.
.:
::l..
a
8
~
~
..
-
t
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.j
-
C
III
~
:5
is
.:
~ :5:0:
<{ I-ll.
~ eI)<{
1O'lr zu
O...J <{u.
0:::1 ~o
g~ uj~
~a: ~!l2
(O)w (O)c
N...J "0
IO...J Gl:o.
!:: ~ E~..-
- CIl'l:<o
.Q:r: ZUI-
Eu aamo
::lei) ...J
Za; !i~..-
,gEi!=~~~
OCllW"'GlZ
u.zmcn.J:::1
'')I.rI0}:
Q
Z
W
"
W '" '" l!.
... II C t:
~z= ~ ~
:e.. .. -; ..
t ~ ] ~
~ 4. Jl ~
iff
w
\l-
t:!.
g:
:::l
'"
:!
~
CO
:l
c
;::
So ~
o ;;
o :I
\I. 0
tIl Q
c ..
~ ~
:; Ci
III U
L..::,,^;
I ~;~~
~:;:.>
" ...D(:>-
r.."\. '-7/ ,,' "-
-.(;-' >.. ,! f." "'--
~(" .i)~'~'_;; .!f.....
'.. If"";'" ~'),
lJ::ij /~:~ -y,.;
..,&i i,.' " .~-' 0, >.'/
Il{?/~'{;, ' I~'i>"",! '},
~.l' ;l/;'...~ I';;~ 'J..~ :.' ".....
F' u....(. r " . ~,.
I ~'!" ~~:~~;.,_ l ;,\~!.; ;", ~ /31/
k. .,.:, (':.~""'~'~ -"'-.- ,'':.. ,f;"
.:~:.r.:,g,,:_',;,.,:.~_.,,~,' r..r!;!<.' :: .~: / .:.flY ,~
t"', ....:;-~._ ,,~;_"1(...{ <i..~:'r~'
, - ........., ,.'" I) ..,.. ."" ..,
t . .."",,~;~~ 9: '- ., C""I
.!" ~r-':d::;r;~'~;~~~~{
~'> ..4' ,. ~'~. I" iii:.,
, -"f ,- -.-. -
..., ~,.,.
J. _ ~-'
'4.~' . .-.- .- ~
i~:;..~:.fii~'';~;;:~.;.:.~~
i:~l
.~
t? ':fl
;~ _ ..~ ~:;:.4
CJ . -: r;~"~'
~1 r~:: ~
~~. ii.
ri: f
I ~,. ~
, '/"
'~)'7 ~ ~~
,:~'"'~' " hd
. .', 'I"::
,_' '; c:-
.' _~~[1'~f.t
r ~ ~n'l- ~I
y. ~ -;~.
fi- '
.~. c, ':~c':r';~~1t~~'
1-,t:,:i.fJ-'~fr-,--r,;
;'Iff';... '''~..'''Jf~ 1t:J,
. .2J' " ~
IJ~/~.. ~""'. f~ /... __
I" . '<r-+-' ,- ,-
I.Ilc"il' ..-..' .",,- I if-'
l:.&ii/~~~.~~~ \.:J..1l:i2~4~_ :~ ~"
Packet Page -43-
CD
iii
'C
.!!!
0.
.E
....
o
'C
Ql
en
'"
CD
~
Ql
en
.!!!
'E
~
~
o
c
e
.Q
~
.2
,!;
CD
<On;
'C
B
6..
:>
'C
c
'"
Ol
E
ac
0.2
"'1;i
UiQ;
~e.
CD.!!!
=.5
DIll)
c=
~o
~5f
:>
0..
;~
Ole
~ 'G)
EO;
E.t=
8~
",,,,
- 'C
;n0l
~:5
"'....
a..E
~-g
~:2
~2
00.
D:
~
C
::J
o
(.)
~
(5
(,)
CD
:5
~
~
;;;
en
.~
0.
~
~
;;;
0.
P
0::
:>.
c:
::J
o
(.)
~
(5
(.)
-.i
o
o
N
@
o
C'l
.....
\0
-
.....
v
..... w
U
:; 2
~ 5
0\ c:
tl'l ~ 0
> 0
" ..........
0 c: ............
..... W N<O
0 -' ...........
N -' co......
-' w co
c. 2 ~
I :J: (lJ
~ U III :::>
> V) 0 0
C'l
"-<
o
Property Record
~
Sketches I
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
\Y
Aerial
Trim Notices
~
[------- . ..---
Parcel No: 5234300000~. _i~
Current Ownership ~
".--- _.._--~ ------------
Property Address!~.z..~ELICAN ST W ______.________________
I
j'
L.
l___
Owner Namef COOPER, MITCHEL=& KARYN A '----'- ---- ---- ---"--'--'-'--- --------.---
._.~-~"'..._.."~_4.~:;:~,..-- _-..-:..__~~.-;_:.~_ r'.. -- "" ."
Addressesj 37 W PELICAN ST.... .._ _ ~__..~=~-=-~~__-,...~~. = ".==.,. ...:-_.=._-==....,.~==.-._.=_=_~ ~==--="' _~:_-= _,.=: "'_-=='.
City NAPLES J State FL : Zipji34113-4021
.--------- -..--... .-.--..-.-.----,,--- -...... --.-.--...-...------.-...._...__ __.1_.........____.._ _ ____ .._____. __
',----. '-Legal'IS~~~.~.~.c~RCNO~ LO!80,& ~-- ......-.... --.--.-....-.-............ ... ---. -"'''-- - ".... - ._..=..=~=.~~~_:~_.~~~~:
:: THAT PORTION LYING EL Y OF LOT I
! ____ .r ~!!JES~IN OR 37~_~~2~~.__._ .. ~~-::."-:...~~-=-~::~~:.-__~=::~:___.. ==:__=-:.~~._...~.~1
r--: S!.~tion~-C-T~w~ship-~-.,--. Rang;---- --'--A"Cf.eS-' ----..--.Map N'o. Ii Strap No. -- ---
L. ~~_.__..__~___..__._.___ 26 ___'___ o.!!_ _.__ .___ 683.!... __.:L. .__ ...._ 426~00.806B31_____
I
I Sub No.
L ./~ u~~ C~de
~-------.-- -......-----.----.-.---.. ...-- -",-----.---..--"-r--.-'I-----I. ---..-
426400 '. ISLE OF CAPRI UNIT 1 u~; MillaQe Area!! "~lJIi11aQe I: Total .! School
· . 1" ": SINGLE FANIIL~~-ESIDENTIA~_____.~_~j/ ,!.~1~3 -.!i.. ~~:2513 iI5.23~
I~s~~ hslndio~ for C~lc;Aalio~
J. __
2009 Final Tax Roll
(Subject to Change)
If all Values shown below equal 0 this
parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll
I Land Value I $ 385,560.00 II
(+) Improved Value $ 155,300.00 I
(=) Just Value $ 540,860.00
(-) SOH Exempt Value & Other Exemptions $ 389,472.00
(=) Assessed Value $ 151,388.00
(-) Homestead and other Exempt Value $ 50,000.00
(=) Taxable Value $101,388.00
I (=) School Taxable Value (Used for School Taxes) I $ 126,388.00 I
SOH = "Save Our Homes" exempt value due 10 cap on assessment increases.
Latest Sales History
Date I
06 /1993 I
II
/I
Book-Page
1837 -954
Amount
$ 0.00
~
The Infonnation is Updated Weekly.
ofl
.
.
.
Packet Page -44-
4/16/20109:25 AM
.
.
.
of!
Property Record
~
Sketches I
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
l.:V
Aerial
Trim Notices
" Current Ownership ~
r----. Parcel No.: 52342980005 -.:Ji-' Property Addressi[35 PEL~AN ST W '=~~_-===~~=='.=-===='=--=====
I Owner Name; PUENTe, RAFAEL F=&IDALIA--..------..-. -- ...--------. . .-. ..---- -.- .----.-.... .--- _u .-..---- ------ - -
[=--- ~d~~:l*i~.sii!~j~:...~:::~s.;~lE'::~:'~~.:::I:' '::"]"~ 'Ii01i:'i483:::':'.':::':::
r-----L;gai~ISLES OF CAPRI'N01-LOT79 ANO--- -.--------. '-'-'-"'.--... .---... '--. ....- - .-.-...-.-------.--.-.--.--.---
I ~:-t:.~~ :~~~:~ )1.~GN~.~i~F"L~ '-:-~-=---== - ~ ~.~-.=..=..=.~.---=-"'-~-=~ --'~.~'--' ---
1--__ 0_ .___________.__...__.__....._...._._____ .._..__..__..____!
C~~~ti'O~----:-, - . To';n-;;i1lp"-- -r-'" ..- -Ran"ge -'-'''''If .--. '--j,:;;es -...:...- ':. .. '-Map'N;;:' -....
L__~_____~._._._.~_~_.._ ._-.it_ ......._ _ _~~._.._.......~IL_.. .._O.~~ _..;:.. ~E3.~_~ ."
StraP. No.
428400 798831
'-'--.--- ----.--------.- 'r..----..-.-.----.--.. --. ....-.-.... .- ..-.- T....-...--... -.-..... "- ..--....-- "'- - .-.- -.... --.. ..._u
I . S~b N~: . ~ .. 426400 ;~ ISLE OF. CA'p~I~~I.T.1 . I!.j~~ MiII,a.ae Area;' J?;MU~a.~e: To~1 . .School
L__~~:Us~C~de - L_~_~_..JI~ACANTRESIDE~TIAL_______._ __J_....__.!.:~_._.;. 7.0123 L1~:~5~3 i .5,23~
~~ee rr:struclions for Cal~ulatio~ .._
2009 Final Tax Roll
(Subject to Change)
If all Values shown below equal 0 this
parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll
I Land Value I $ 137,700.00 II Date I
(+) Improved Value $ 0.00 I 05/1998 ,
(=)JustValue $137,700.00 I 05/1992 I
(-) SOH Exempt Value & Other Exemptions $ 0.00
(=) Assessed Value $ 137,700.00
(-) Homestead and other Exempt Value $ 0.00
(=) Taxable Value $ 137,700.00
I (=) School Taxable Value (Used for School Taxesll $ 137,700.00 I
SOH = "Save Our Homes" exempt value due to cap on assessment increases.
Latest Sales History
II
II
II
Book. Page
2422 -1227
1712 -2034
Amount
$0.00
$ 45,000.00
~
The lnfonnation is Updated Weekly.
Packet Page -45-
4/16/2010 9:25 AM
Property Record
Aerial
~
Sketches ,
~
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
'---
Trim Notices
~ Current Ownership i%j .
-----1----.--- --.- ----.----- -----.-.-.---.--- ---.----.
I Parcel No.i152342920003 ; _~!.operty Address; 33 PELlC~N STW___._.. "___
,----O;rier Nam~fHuFNAGEL. PAUL A ---.---..---.------.------
C-., . ::~dd-~~l~f:~~i.ICAN.ST;---~:--.-~ . - ~'s~~' FL' .--===~====~~=.=-=Zi~tii1-13~~~~1-.-~~"'-:.. -~=--=-=
L_____.__I____._____.___.____ ____._...____...._._ ___..____ _"__ .._ .____._._.__._______ ___
I Le.'~ :~~~!~~~~?~f,~~ :~-~==-~o=~~~~ ~-~== ==~~ ~~=-f~=~==-~:~~-=
_ ___ J~~ ~c;f, ~~~:..o~ t"g"~.~,,1p!",:"',,, ",~~P_ro..,,! ApJ!.:....!'~ff!E'~ _ _ _n__J
t.~~?e::~n--.- ~Jt~~~~~~===::=: ::.~~~~~~~~:~~:.::-:~~~::~}1~:~:_~~.~~~..~~~~.~6~~1~;:-'.jr:~~~:~:_-.~.::~~1f:;i~~~.==:~
----.----1'----------::--------.----.--- ...-.. ---- -..,. --- ...-- --,r'- -- .-..-- ---
I Sub No. II 426400 ! ISLE OF CAPRI UNIT 1 : ...:~ Millaae Areai. JJMillaae! Total ; School
,-:.=;..-::-.:-:=-=.:.=-=-L. :=~~===-==.~"':":':':.-:-_=_.~_=_=:"==:_ _. _ _~-=':=_=-=-=-.=..=-=~=
! ~ Use Code)1 1 ~ SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL . 91 11 7.0123. 12.2513 · 5.239
'-- .--- --. -- -"- --. ---- --- ------------.-- ---.-.. .-.--- .-. ---.-...A,..=-~~_===_==___==:.o.....,__~~,
i.See Instructions for Calculations
2009 Final Tax Roll
(Subject to Change)
If all Values shown below equal 0 this
parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll
Latest Sales History
Land Value $ 385,560.00
C+) Improved Value $ 177,830.00
(=) Just Value $ 563,390.00
C-) SOH Exempt Value & Other Exemptions $ 0.00
C=) Assessed Value $ 563,390.00
(-) Homestead and other Exempt Value $ 50,000.00
(=) Taxable Value $ 513,390.00
C=) School Taxable Value (Used for School Taxes) $ 538,390.00
SOH = "Save Our Homes" exempt value due to cap on assessment increases.
Date
01/2004
06/1991
Book - Page
3481 - 2179
1622 - 524
II
II
$ 0.00
$ 0.00
.
Amount
~llJi~
The Inf~rmalion is Updated Weekly.
.
of1
Packet Page -46-
4/16/20109:27 AM
.
.
.
of!
Property Record
.1
~
Sketches I
~
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
-
Aerial
Trim Notices
~
~
----" 1'---
!___ Parcel NO:i;~~34290000.7
Current Ownership ~
li.~._.!-rope~ Addres~'~~!EUCAN ST~~=:~_=_===-"-:===-====-~-=-=
..- -.-------1'---- - ------------. -...-.--- .--.-- ----.-.--. ----.--
! " ,....~~.~!.~!l.~~..I.~'.9~~~?~.~.~~~~.S!~~~ ~TN.RS ~~.. . _. . . . . .'. .
L_~ddressesl~6 SP!-_RROWBUSH RD ._____.__.____..____. __'_'_ _.____._____.._._..___._.._____.__.___ _. ________.
L_.._~~=~.E~[~!~A~ __.:_~~-.I~~~~_~~_-.~~~~~~..=.~~iat~:~y... -. ':.~~'-.-~:-:"":.- .~~.: .~ ~:~'.':-.'~.Zi;J;'i2~-1-~.~'~~~.- ~-~. .-"~: :~:.~:- :-:.
l=--=-__~ga'jll~~r:-~:~RI~o~. -.- '.' ~--~.. ..--_=~~_.=:_-~-_.._~.._:~~~.~~.~~~:~~_~~~~_ ;:=.:..=..~~===~~~
r--------'---.-----..--r---------.--- --.------ -. -------.--- -.- -'--'-'---'--- -- ---
r=- se::of!- -=1:=,!~~~ShiP --=,1=='-- ..-- ~ii!!~-'''=''=: =~~,.=--"~~:~-===~:==~"'~:~~~~~=+~==c- .426~O~:7 ~~'~2- .~:'-'-.
.._..___._______ "___'___'_ .___ .._ J......_..____..._..___...__._ . _._ _. ._._____..._ _..........___._..._ .__._...____.___..____..____.__
r-- --Sub~.-.-li ..- 4264oo....--...liisLEoi=-cAPRluNir-:j-..... .-.-..-- .
.._____.JL._ ._..__.___ .__. _.___..L_________.__..._..__.. .................... .._ ......
r-#-.-----1-. -_.- ".,-.--. ... ...~.il ~__.___._._.___.A......._._._.__A -- -. --..-. "- .-
t _.~: Use Code. L_._ _..__~_.__.... _ J ~l!..~!!:~~~!~!' .~'=~_~.T.~~~.1 ~.u.~~_
":'; Miiia'~eA'~~;i ":~Miil;~; r"To~i' -rS~~oI
.... '~'''''.'''~1'- .=-. -\~)I~~!=1~,!~~1~~t:~€[
;*See Instructions for Calculations
2009 Final Tax Roll
(Subject to Change)
If all Values shown below equal 0 this
parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll
Latest Sales History
Land Value $ 385,560.00
(+) Improved Value $ 100,853.00
~~~~ $~M~
(-) SOH Exempt Value & Other Exemptions $ 0.00
(=) Assessed Value $ 486,413.00
(-) Homestead and other Exempt Value $ 0.00
(=) Taxable Value $ 486,413.00
(=) School Taxable Value (Used for School Taxes) $ 486,413.00
SOH = "Save Our Homes" exempt value due to cap on assessment increases.
Date
09 / 2007
06/2001
10/1993
Book - Page
4282 -1605
2850 -1383
1871 -1462
Amount
$ 700,000.00
$ 470,000.00
$ 0.00
~!~
The Information is Updated Weekly.
Packet Page -47-
4/16/20109:28 AM
Property Record
Aerial
~
Sketches I
~
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
Trim Notices
~ Current Ownership i!j .
,__ _ Parcel N~'. 5234316~~.~~==_'~_~r-opertY Address; ~~~.!:~~~~IR~~~~.-~~~~=~~~~'=:=-~.'==-~:~=~ ~ .:==-=~__~
I Owner Nam;;' HUGHES JR, JAMES A=& ELEANOR D .--..--------.-....----- - ----- --....-------
I .. '_.....-Add;~;;;~r9iDOLPHittc-iii,- ...... .,,-.' ." -~--~.~==--=-'"==,,.===."--.-:r ==--=",==-=..--=
L___-Eityi~A~LES____L_____.__~ta~-.~~..._._. ___"." _ __ ...._.. ~EIL~~~~~..:40!~._______.____ __.
r - --L.;gal~_ ~_L.~~.~!. ~~~.~( N.O,1 ~!~4 &. ~'-.".~---,='-.~ --"~'~---'. -'-" ---.-.- . _.~~ ..... - ....... "._--==~~===:=~~~=~
i ~. T'::'ATPORTIONLYI_NGE~FLO!84._ ___._____ ___ __ __ ___.______. J
L-_.._[. TOMHWLl~~___._-- ._--~=---=-~: ----------.----~~=~~.=..J
i- Section -~~. T~~n.s.~ip -- . Ran.!il8 --~cms-"-'. Map No. Ii' ~trap No.
I~~____;~.._:__~ ._.~~.-:~".._. _H___ 3~_ __:.__ ____...~:~_~___ .... ._. _~.~~i" J. _.___..._~~640.0.~46B3!.._._.._ _....
I Sub No.
L: U~;C~de
--' -'..-'- --426400 -- ..... -'iSLE'oF'cAPRi"uNIT 1- -. -- - ...... . .... -. ." ".- Miii~q~ A~~il-O:';Miil;~~' If -.' T~t.;i- . -'11 -~'h~~i
1 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL . 91 ;1 7.0123 Ii 12.2513 il 5.239
._-~-___.___~_________.__.______________._.,._. __._.____.... ..__1. '.' ... . _. .
!.See Instructio'ns for .Calcul~iio~
2009 Final Tax Roll
(Subject to Change)
If all Values shown below equal 0 this
parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll
I Land Value I $ 377,910.00 II
(+) Improved Value $ 139,266.00 I
(=) Just Value $ 517,176.00
(-) SOH Exempt Value & Other Exemptions $ 370,260.00
(=)Assessed Value $146,916.00
(-) Homestead and other Exempt Value $ 50,000.00
(=) Taxable Value $ 96,916.00
I (=) School Taxable Value (Used for School Taxes) I $121,916.00 I
SOH = "Save Our Homes" exempt value due to cap on assessment increases.
Latest Sales History
Date I
02/1996 I
Book - Page
2144 - 2187
Amount
$ 0.00
.
am
The Information is Updated Weekly.
.
ofl
Packet Page -48-
4/16/20109:28 AM
.
.
.
ofl
Property Record
~
Sketches I
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
\.:.../
Aerial
Trim Notices
& Current Ownership ~
L __~arcei No.;~ 52~~iloo~?_~-=_...[=. .~!iE~~ ~~~~~X~~_~6,~!B~N.~~'~.~ .~-~~ ~~."- :._ ~ .":'.~:~-'~'.'.~'.:._: :_~.~-~:.~._:~ - ~.~:.:_.~..:~.~~~:.:_~
,--...- Owner Name 'HUGHES jR~AMES-A;-&'ELEANOiiD - .....---.....--..-. ...-... ..... --.. ..-..- --.-.... . - . '--'-"'-- -.- - ...--...-------
(.,....~.....Add;:e-;.~~~::-94DoCPHIN.cIR...~...... ..:g....... .........". .... ....,.... ..," .-
l.-.--- _ _. .
L_ _~ Cityf N~!"L~~.___=_=L.~.~_.
-- ~=-=--===="~=-.~-=;,:==--.,,,=--=-==-==--===---====-.
State!i FL . '! Zip; 34113 -4016 ..
. __.._____._._.1........_.._._. . __._ . ""_._. _____'__._ ___...__
c--.. Le.~L~~:JE~~~:~~5~?;;~~ :=~;.~~~..=:.,~~;~~~:;_7~~.=.::.:=
,--- sectiOi1-..----,.ownsiiip.-il --.-. Range --1[-'-- -A~ie-;;- ...--. --l--'-Map-No.- -: ..---..--- Strap N(;. ---------
L~_.~31..~J ~~. 5;..~:__jL_.~'i6.... _~..-JI.____~~~__ _ ..}____6.~31..____;._.__.__~6400.856B3i._~.._.
- -.- --.-------1----.---.--.-.-..--.....-.--..- """.'--'-'-'--" .- .-------. --'--'-- -----.-
! Sub No. '. 426400 ,lISLE OF CAPRI UNIT 1 !;-'~ Mlllaae Area '::':Millaae: Total : School
I "':"lJ~~COd~' t .. I/VACANTRESIDENTIAL Ii .91"... 7.0123 ~ 12.2513' 5.239'
l .___.. ._.__.J _____________.___". .0.____ ..... ,_._. _ !.._ _..____.__.._.. ..
!~~:e ~tru:'io~ for ~al~alio_ns
2009 Final Tax Roll
(Subject to Change)
If all Values shown below equal 0 this
parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll
I Land Value i $ 377,910.00 II
(+) Improved Value $ 0.00
C=} Just Value $ 377,910.00
(-) SOH Exempt Value & Other Exemptions $ 0.00
(=) Assessed Value $ 377,910.00
C-) Homestead and other Exempt Value $ 0.00
(=) Taxable Value $ 377,910.00
I C=) School Taxable Value (Used for School Taxes) I $ 377,910.00 I
SOH = "Save Our Homes" exempt value due to cap on assessment increases.
Latest Sales History
Date I Book - Page 1/ Amount
05/1996 2178-1121 $0.00
01/1996 2139.1031 $ 49,300.00
01/1996 2139 -1030 I $0.00
12/1995 2127 -2109 $ 25,000.00
~
The Information is Updated Weekly.
Packet Page -49-
4/16/20109:29 AM
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
VARIANCE
PRE-APPLICATION NOTES .
.
.
Packet Page -50-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252.2400 FAX (239) 252.6358
VARIANCE PETITION
PRE-APPLICATION MEETING NOTES & SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST
D Dimensional
PL# pl-Z-010''' 13 q
Date: r;. 4-' ( 0 TIme: JJ 00 Assigned Planner: -A~y C."'$~
Project Name: C:;CtTl\..l~l..~ V~~
Project Ad~r/Location: '3Q W ~$\' ~~, ~ So ~
Applicant Name: j G..ff ~~ Phone:~t~ -01 ~
Firm:"\V~L-. ~ ... ~$oe.l~
,
Current Zoning: \2..<; F - ~
Owner Name: f-
Owner Address: ~c:r W~<;;r ~ St..r C1V...l g,~
. Meeting Attendees: (attach Sign In Sheet)
NOTES:
f;~ Co~: kb c!u'@~ i ~ JoJ'l ;l ~ ~ ~ 9- stIle -~!:J ~Sf'~,j-'r cAe2.
l1:A"'~f~""'rr"ttJ: f\jtJ c:9~:1'~c:.. T"I 0...... '
~\:)R~\'N<.=;.' ~R~~ 1-\EEr\.<::' \C) 9;2:C't\ ~b CF=
~C l N en" t'\l'~--:R.s
gIVU1,"JI?dVYlk I ~ Cho /.A/ (o/JS;jk-nu '-v/LOc Sec../-I'"..., S ..0$.6 C- r~j
5 .e;ru. 55 Ju.i., 1)YJ(nt':IfS. Y+ff}"C 41) / ~ 1/) .s U,6I7?I=!f- 0/7 tj?(/ wk-./
. 5 u/ve.. ~ ' h..k .~/-?? 1 1 /1 be ~=deJ "or /-"
· If telephone pre-application meeting is held, direct the petitioner to coordinate with Unda
concerning the requirement for the petitioner to send the notice letter to the surrounding
property owners or to give them that information that Linda typically provides them
.
8~s. "Blw C~
7\rJD ~
VA-PL2010-739 rev:l
SCHNELLER VARIANCE
Date: 8/2/10
Due: 8/16/10
Packet Page -51-
ec;rneT County
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT -.. "._..~'. - .. .- .
DEPT. OF ZONING & LAND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
WWW.COLLlERGOV.NET. .
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE - "-
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
(239) 252.2400 FAX (239) 252-6358
VARIANCE PETITION - (VA) APPLICATION
SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST
THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLlCAnON PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER
LISTED BELOW W /COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION.
NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBlTTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED.
#OF NOT
REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED
..completed Application (download from web site for current form) ~ X
( Completed Addressing Checklist, Signed by Addressing Department 1 ~
Conceptual Site Plan 24" x 36" and one 8 Y2 .. x 11 n copy [\g X'
Survey of property showing the enaoachment (measured in feet) 2 X
Owner/Agent Affidavit signed & notarized 1 >(
Deeds/legal's 3 X
Location map 1 ~
Aerial photographs (taken within the previous 12 months min. scaled 5 '^
1 "=200'), showing FLUCCS Codes, Legend, and project boundary
Electronic copy of all documents and plans (COROM or Diskette) 1 1(
Historical Surveyor waiver request 1 ~
Environmental Impact Statement (ElS) and digital/electronic copy of ~
EIS or exemption justification 3
Within 30 days after receipt of the first review comment letter. 1 X
provide Property Owner Advisory Letter and Certification
Project Narrative ~ X
:L ,.., de: to . . .
LJ ~ ...-t"1 UI ev.ew pa age KODln _U'l:r-', . , '-liT UI
-295 RIverside Circle, ~ples, rL 341 el ..
FEES:
(gl Pre-application Fee $500.00 (Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last
pre-app meeting shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting will
be required.)
Review Fees:
g $2000.00 Residential
\ 0 $5000.00 t4ulI-Rt::oidC::/llldl -
~ :\fter 'Fh~~r u~1 ZOIl;II~/l\ollld U:oc:: Pt:'liliuns 2x the normal petition fee-
~ $100.00 Fire Review
l8J $925.00 Estimated legal Advertising Fee - cepc Meeting
[gJ $500.00 Estimated legal Advertising Fee. BCC Meeting
{over- or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples.Daily News}.
ISl ? 1;oo.ee-- tIS Review --..
<bI $1 .000 ~It:d SpecIes Survey (if [!$-1s-not_re.quired)
OTHER REQUIREMENTS:
I[] $V\~M\, t>~ ~ (!,0l4? 1>~lts
llJ StAt?fV'\. \r Ou'~ CL.A1 M ~UO \f 1W~~( 1\tlO \Ncu..tDe, 1"li1tr IrrzMmJ .
D 8 V\P.-\r
\\\ {t \.U, S7+ tS" ~cS ~ ~ \~,
w ~
Packet Page -52-
.
.
.
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
ADDRESSING CHECKLIST
.
.
.
Packet Page -53-
COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT
ADDRESSING DEPARTMENT
(i)
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE
NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104
:7((,;"~~r.~~~~~~r~~J~~t;{I;;~~r~'bJ(;:fl::~1?;,~!;~~i~""1.JI ':lf~""~I:,W:':~ ';':':.. ~( :..:... ~::. ',' .:! i:; ;l:.~j:;;G"~~~~; f~i~'.,:.~ .~.~~l'\{i~~~~~~'~ 1~[:~l:'i,~j~I.:;; ~7::~;;~:;'I,:'lt~.~~~::~1
~;~:~~l::~j'~~~~r~f!:"~~.:;;~~~ l ~!~jtf(~~h~~.Ai:,;;;); r::;(.lt~!~~;l~.l(~~l :)~'-~;:'+'-"~::;':':'l', k:J:'~ :~:.. ~ L~;J r1 ~.~r~ ~r~:,:t.J'~:{r:'1:I,bi'I~4"r::~'\..:l~-:':} .1;fZ:f:~\ tfl'!~~'t" '~~/f ~~l:.~"; ~,'/: .r:t~,.,: ~ ~" ~ :r~,~
.
Please complete the follcming and f8)( 10 thB Addressinll Oepurtment 81 289-252-5724 or 5l,Ibmlt In person to ,he
Addl'99ting Departmenf at the aboYII address. Form must be sianed bY Addressina oersonnel rnior to Dre-mJoflcaUon
msetlna. DI-. allow a dav8 for Drocl!t..InQ.
Not an items will apply to every project. Items In bold type are requlred. Forms older than e months will require
additionat review and approval by the Adl!reseing Department .
PETITION TYPE (c:heck psfflion type b.low, complste B ssparate Addressing ChackliBt for esch Petition Type)
o BL (Blasting Pennlt)
o 80 (Boat Dock Ex1enBion)
o CamfvaflCircus Permit
o CU (Conditional Use)
o EX? (Excavation Permit)
o FP (Final Plat
o LLA (La! Line Adjustment)
o PNC (Pro}9Ct Name Chllnge)
o PPL (Plans & Plat Review)
o PSP (Preliminary Subcrrvisian Plat)
o PUO Rezone
o RZ (Standard Rezone)
o SOP (Site Developmsnt Plal'l)
o SOPA (SOP Amendment)
o SOPI (Insubstantial Change io BOP) .
o SIP (Site Improvement.Plan) . .
. 0 SIPI (Insubstantial Change to SIP)
o SNR (Street Name Cl1ange)
o SNC (Street Name ChangB - Unplatted)
o iDR (Transfer at Development Rights)
18l VA (VarlBnca)
o VRP (Vegetation Removal Permit)
o VRSFP (Vegetation Removal &: Site Fill Permit)
o OTHER
-..-
LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subject property or propertiaa (copy of Itmgthy description may be Ilttacl1ed)
ISLE OF CAPRI UNIT 1 LOT 81 ~ \ - S-l- z...Co
FOLIO (Property 10) NUMSER(.) of above (attach to, or Bsso::iBt9 with, legal d9scrfptJon If more than one)
152343040005
STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES (as appUClJbl9, If already assigned)
39 PELICAN STRE~ WEST
NAPLES, FL 34113
.
· . LOCAnON MAP mLlS! be attached showing exact locatIon of projectlsite in relation to nearest pubric road right-of-way
· SURVeY (copy . needed only for unplsnea properties)
PROPOSEO PROJECT NAME (If app/icsbl8)
SCHNELLER DOCK
PROPOSED STREET NAMES (If app(lcsbf9)
N/A
SITE DEVELOPMEt>lT F'LAN NUMBER (for existing projrN:tgfs/tes only)
SDPN/A - NlA or AR 1# 13142
Page 1 01 2
VA-PUOlO-739 rev:l
SCHNEllER VARIANCE
Date: 8/2/10
Due: 8/16/10
.
Packet Page -54-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
. ADDRESSING CHE:OKUST . PAGE TWO
.
-.. " --- . - .. "
ProJeet or devalopmmt names proposed for. or already appsarlng in, condominium documents (If appficatlon; indicate
whether proposed or elti$ting)
SCHNELLER DOCJ(
PIMI!le Chl!lck One: (gI Ch9CkUst Is to be Fued back
o Personally Picked Up
APPL8CANT NAME: JEFF ROGERS
PHONE 239-643-0166
FAX (239) 643-6632
Signature on Addressing Checklist does not constitute ProJect anctlor-Street Name approval and is
subject to funher review by the Addressing Department. -
-
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
Primllry Number 57- ~'+ 30 tf:Ob 0 5
Address Number
Addr... Number
Adctreu Number
· Approved t.r:J1~ (l/L.cta. f'Y)
~pd8ted by:
Oala:
l>ate:
4--Z-I-ID
IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST BE
UPDATED OR NEW FORM SUBMrrrED
G:\Currertl\A;!p1lcallL'ln Fonna'IArt:1l1JS8lnl1 ChllCldlBt r&v JunlJ08.CIo;
Page 2 of 2
.
Packet Page -55-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
CONCEPTUAL SITE PLAN
EXHffiITS .
.
.
Packet Page -56-
I-~ ~
Oil:
ww Z
;;;:n. 0
:>0
0g: en
w'
'0 I- wW
Oen
to w ll.:J
W o::Z
"I~ t') :JQ
~a rt!ll-.... ll.1-
~ll:l~ (!)o
W.... ~a:-l ~ z:J
~ t Cll-Li.. W ~~
~ Q en - z
<zf3 _en
~ ~z
~ ~~-l U 0::0
UIl. :JI- wO
...-< w:c Q..Q:
fI:lmz Q..(!) 0::0 o~
ll. 0- 0Li..
0) 1-0:: Li..o "<to
t') ..- WZ ~~ C:l~
:g .:JO 1O"<t
. 0 zen <Z . .
O~i=w enW 10'-
NCX)
~ ::imzen (!)1- zs:
m-O:J z~
o::l1:UO -I-
wll.o:c ~~ W
ri.l:J (3 zz "0
Z Z-lO<~ OW W:J
~81-~u W~ 01-
:J-
:J ~..- -l ..en I-CJ
uo~al~ f2WO i=z
,- :c Z ~o
0 ~~zi:21- 5i-~ -l -l
"'-0ll.f3 zO ^ ^
{) ~@~C3~ v v
z~~zz
rl ... 00
e L') L7i ~~
"i o::a::
IW Cl-:C~~
. . . I
-
..J
..J
0
0
en ~cO
w QuVrfi
...
n.
<
z
t
..
1,;5
I """'...
..",
~~
"Eu
I:
~
P,-..-y,ltwi.
-@
I .
I'
~
a..
(
2
~
-
Z
IiiiiI
t)
~
>
uo
;5
.q..Dr
,If ~ft j' ~
" ... ":' :I."
,to ..
~'1r. 03 oF ~I - -
y ':- ...'.....@
? !! ~
ll.'o,l'.:l...eri r!'Y'.i:'t
(.n.
a.:
$ .
I'
".
1.
E~""
..
3 :~
l-, ~-
'.
0(,.
.'-w;.~ .:
i
~>'"
q..., "id
~r.
~o.
C
tiE
ww
~n.
:>0
wit
(
CJ
-
ct:
o
...J
U.
u..
o
W
t-
(
~
C!J
1:4
,.J-::--.
.:l:~r-'1"'.
l/\'~.:J.'
~~-sJ':',.t::l:..e.,
~~:
'=,r~
~
.....
.
P:IllSG2 Sclln.lI.. Ooc:I:Id-ovsI0662-SCHNEu.ER DO::K-PERI.IIT.dwg
Packet Page -57-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
. ~, 9 CD
N
I
W
(!)
Z
~
-'
<(
-
0::
w
<(
~
Z
:J
o
o
III
~ ,:: iii
ZIU-,
~ !I! <S
... en en
ID~~~
:Z III
~~~~rL
~~:r~i:
a:~~~~
~
t-
~ ~
~ !!l ~
l:j M
8 Z
~:~a ~
!2S~ZO
13!",m w
ccoflUl
~
(J
o
o
~
w
-'
.J
W
Z
I
U
(fJ
a.
c:(
2
z
o
~
u
o
-J
c..> be) ~ ~
=~~ ~~
~_ I'
=~ ~ ~ ;:s
CI.)=....~'
1o-a 0 ("P') Ch
c:tSU.....:l~
.uc; ~..":'"'"'
ocL~i,
~ QJ r:::1.. :
= S ~ '
<::l z ~
~J~~;e,
= ~.5~
c:tS~~~,
::t:: ~ te Ch' .1
-u < ~
=- ~':':
O.~ c Co) ,
L..-". a C"2 c j
I;....c~ "5~
;::s "'" """'.1
E-c ~
....
""
""8
....e
!i
"g
ifj!
~j
.2
~
l3
~
Jl
~
o
z
f
::1E
o
D..
~
l-4 ~
~-~
C> ~
q-
~
~
~
~
C>
P:\OKZ _ DacIMooga\ll662../lCHNEllER llOCI(-PEIlMlT~
~
OJ
o
z
<(
a..
~
o
a..
\
\
\
~\
18 '\\
>~
z
~$C/J
t-a:::w
o<(Z
...J~:i
a:::
Co
N
..-
Packet Page -58-
v
co
I-
o
I-
en
W
:!:
I-
W
WM
.. 0:: ....
rI:l~'"
~en~
=Z..J
Q<Ll.
QO -
<::iffi
t;lW..J
E-<ll.ll.
...Ol<
rI:lMZ
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
~ ~ fj] :! ~
0:: i. I
m;.J 5:1 w
Wui::uj w ~.. (!)
fJ) U) '::;0 IlJ IlJ Z
2::le~g II: ~ ~ g
a:ZcwCl:::t ...."''''
::lQiila:Z IlJ
11.0UOio&l~
Cl::l:1i~":":Q
Za:~ t....m
gt;~~~~~
~~a:U,:Ea:CD
wO~;;:Q8:1t
~a:ZN><:::t
0~gx~~8
u..oa:fiNa:.....
WIIIWl1. oWIL:l;
~~~~!i~~
CI)~==CI)~ f3!: ..
Cl20z::~li:"" :J: ...
~5~~~~5~ E ~ ~ II'!
~czw~!z~~u~ Q ~ Q ~
t- tS Q ~ ~ ~!l! ~ 0' ...
f3m~~~~~~~ i I ~ ~ ~
E-<:rZ-'11._0::l::l ~.. u., 0
Qt-<<<t-l'-mCl) \J
zO ceooo .l.
U ~
o fu
o ~
t-
~ ~
lU ~
o
.J ~
.J ~
W 8
Z ~
I ~
() @
rn
t4 ~
~~~oCt/l
!5! ~ 0 li! Q.
~ ;!; ~ i
a:-:\ '"
c Z
~
c
z
:5
LL
o
C/J
W
a:::
U
<(
co
..-
ci
C/J
Z .
-CIJ
~CIJ
z~
o~
Uo
.....w
lX)a:::
bO
...J~
o
co
I-
o
....I
c.:.i co~ ~
.s".8 ::;; ~
~= ~~
~~;-
..... 0..., Ort,
=U-:l~
.0- ~":":"
o-aJri
~...o:::.
<5:Z:
- ":g
~.r; ~ c;
~>= .
c; &3 J.: ~
::z::~~~
~- G) ~ a
--- c DO.~
CU"5i iii g
f:::.,,1l,,;
::s.... ~ ""'
E--4. ~
. .... e
. ~ 8
'- "~
...
CX)
I-
o
....I
b
l')
~::lu.
::S-u.
0:3:-
oc~
~~f:,.
:5<....
ll.g<
-,J:w
~~~
_w!:::
::s>-'
0:0(3
~~iE
~
m"
o
z
~
~
o
a..
C)
'IQ
~
~_'? l\
~
t""
~
i
...
C)
P:106&2 S~ llacI<IlIwgI\0662.scHNElLER DllCK-PERlIIT.dog
Packet Page -59-
W
D..~c
~a:~
!!:<~
a: ~
~ 3j8{20t1It;miii7.~.
0;:011.. f!J'''' < ~
rn.;..I rn ~ ~ III W
WW::Suji!! N ~ ~ (!)
CI.lrnaz~ ~ o~ 2t;1iI Z
C::l...._x u:>a= ~...g (
8!zci:ilo 0 C!)~ .. ili CD a:
::lOwa:a: c zCl)
~~~~!l:~~~il!~
::lWCl.l<1I.. ~....o
!a:a:II..W"'zC!)....tf!J
....t.;woa:\l) :.0:;:1&1
~-zlbu:::l~~o=qi
Oa:";b::-a:::sJ.,
U~Ol::lJ:~HtcfQ:
a:ZNI!:::SID<>::t
a:OOox(/)......rnC!)0
LLwo .c.c-ZU
LLCa:....a:OOo:N.....
wwwil:wa:a:w .LLQ
a:crQ.I-LLLLI-Qorb
<zz<~zz;5,!!.>:;;
rnl!!::CI.la:QQ::>o::;rnj5
C!)ZOZWrnCl.lLLO::sl!!c
Z-:r::>::l::l a:Ul
~l-rnoo~a:J:::i::l1-
~~~l;51~~b~8~
cW~~rnl1.lI..==C!i>>
..w~C!iQ~..J..J;i!..J~g!
~mc_dro~~...<a:a:
f::::rz..JII..a:OOO~::l::l
0""< << 11.........1-.... (/)CI.l
zO 00000000
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
C!)~
~u
-0
~c
-u.
, mo
,ID
\
,
,
,
\
\
\
,
,
\
o
....~
eW
w...J
N!!!
-fn
~fn
ZO
-ll.
:E....
Zz
Ww
WI-
~~
~....
:d3
fn-'
....-'
02
~w
:E:I:
;-1-
.
e~
Ww
~w
:Eft
Wo
0:_
wb
~~
:::!e
3:w
fnZ
0-
-~
b~
~~
....Ie
....Iz
:c<
.
....
fn
W
3:
ti
Wr)
.. 0:: ....
{I.lF....
f'ifn~
C:W:Z....I
~<u.
QO -
-JI-fn
........Iw
llI;}W....I
E-cll.ll.
...Ol<
{I.lC')z
t4 r:j ~
z I ~ ~ III
ODe I
!!_ijijA.
~ r!o _ _ I
a:-~~~
~
~~!I ~
li~~ ~
:i l ii! 1I! will
CClU~
~ I-
a 5
o "~
(.) g
~ ~
W <t
.J ~
.J ~
-J
W ~
Z c
. w
I ~
() &
(/) If
-c.oNN
uc:.....:a
..s.~ ~ "i'
~"3C!!;s;
ra~;.-..
......OCWlO\
.~ ~ Ii ~
oS ..r=
~fij~'"
<~z
_~ e =i ~
~'>.~9
---.l = ::2 H)
"'a~ ..,,~
::::I::cldf;!~
~u <~
=e!.~ ~ 1
:3:::S~~
E- ~
~
one
....8
11
.a
j
f
:;:;
B
...
~ ;:; 3~8{201,,1It~m ~7.A.
w.:...J CI.l '" (!) It: ~ iD
CI.l~~wi! ~! l'\I
~::l~~~ ~ .~ w
~zo~x u o~ ~
~I-Qw~~ 0 E;~ Z
uol1. 0 zll)
(!)gZ:rll.li:.ILNiD).
~~wrn< OID.Q:
!:ti~~~~~~1g
::szw .::l....-x~1.U
~Oa:LJ.,b.:J~o:r1l:
~u~a:::l~c;g:::s(!)
a:gjZNa:~Wll.6lt
OILOXI- m<>;:)
ILO~O~~~~(!)Q
ww a:~OO zu
~o~Q.~lfa:ffiN.'"
rntfi;~~z~~~~~
C!l1->CI.la:oo~>>";"
z~oz ii)- >rnCD
_1-J:~~::lCl.lIL~WC
~oCl.lOoa:~O~Ii:O
~z~l-oI-I-F::S::lW
OW::lZW~~o::lO~
..,w ~ ~ C3 ~ 11. 11. ~ ~ U Q
f3lffi c c :::i 11. ...J ...J ...J C ~ ~
E-o:rz::llt~~~~:i>>
~~~o < 000 ~ ~ ~ ~,~
'"
o
C')' ."
rnc~f~'
:;'>11:.
O::>lll:
~cen
I-Z~
:55....
D..;:<
~:I:W
<::s!;(
~wl-"
::S>-
0::0=
wm~
I-<u.
""~__:t<,;~,,:.;,. -c.
':)0 - f'f" '.~
; ,: .,1-. LIe f,
.'" . I '
'i,..I0 wf:w t I
,....,....IW ~'."I> W~'-'..'.
,..:':c'tl! !!H 0 wt
.'. ....!:! en f"" :! 0:: f:
'..'" !_ rn'lw IL~..;..
'_.' ' I~ 0 .- u~~
"" oo::ll. d"'-~'
:".";""" .:; l.IW I-
",~,,'_::Z I-c; 1m 0 .
,<.:.:..;W ~il;,j...J ~ :
-.< ," rW 1-"'j...J
:,_.:'mx' ~o
:,~- ~;;i g;! ~": CI) ~
,', ,< CI) U <
/;'"ttlTIf~U U
. .-~:3;{~~):'~
ti,~-;
.
~'A'
"'<~~
. : '. ,\
.,' :,'\ ,., '.~.
'! '""'. ....*
. ..~-. .:
~~:}r
~'
I
r
,i>
f:~~:
,'_'" CD
c~
I'... ..'....-..
: -~;;{
"'I:,
ji-:.
"
,
.'
r-
.l
.,
-io.
,,:'
1.-
P:'4ll5l52 SdlnoIlar
~1D662-sawEUER
DCX:K-PERIoIIT -"'"II
Packet Page -60-
jj!:
~ :t'8/2011 Item 7.A.
Z I- -...'" Il
0~01.L fS Ul < N
rn.;...I rn g: ~ iii W
WW::Su};! N ~ ~ (!)
~~az~ ~ o~ i!Jj~ Z
l1.zl-:iX 0 ~~ i:riS (
a:oCw~ 0 (!)C/J .."'''' 0::
::l_wa:l1. c z).
ll.b~~lI.t:.l.Ltli!a:
CI:Jwrn< Oor:....O
ar:a:a:lLW('I)CI...t0
I=liiwoa:~~ '~l!
5!zfuu:::l..z~J::0
a:oa:....djg~lf:E~
WO!!aOl:J:I:ma.C!t
l1.a:ZN~==IIl<>::i
15~sxrn==:E!a~8
IL c a: 9 a: 0 c a: s... .....
wwwitWa:a:W"lILQ
~Hi~~~~~~7~~
rnW=:CI.la:OO>>rncs
Cl !Z 0 z W iiHi) l5 ~ ~ o. ~
~;::r==o>ii:r ..lrfil ~ : ~ i9
>oCl.lO I-I-I-==::l..., :::!!l ~ 8 I
~z:E~filOOe~8! z
cw::l<rna:a:==~ 0
_w~~Q~~~~~~~ ~
~ffic~~o~~~~c~~ w
~:rZ~lI.a:ooO_:J:J 0
01-< < <11. I-FI-I-CI.l CI.l
zO 00000000
cq
...
I
.
o
~
...
~
'It
o
,
W
ii1Z -
xZ~lDfJ
0:;"''''=0
If;:a:II.:O:
~:t:~iilci
;,El2 ~
II.
f2:
OW
w-l
N!!!
-en
~cn
ZO
-ll.
~I-
Zz
Ww
WI-
~~
~I-
:d3
cn-l
1--1
o~
<II.
ll.W
~J:
-l-
.
.
~
~
ID
~
~
m
o
z
~
:?E
o
c..
~
...
.
o
~
..,
N
'CD
~
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\cq
C)
'D
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
I:Ll
;,;.-." II
~
t'
co
"!
~
!
co
~
U>
~
ID
~
P:1D562 _.r llal:tIdwgs\D6ll2oSaiNEllER 1lClCKoI'ERMIT.dIIg
Packet Page -61-
0:
Ww
~w
~fE
Wo
0::_
wi-
mO
.....~
=0
~W
cnZ
0-
-j5
I-z
0_
~~
-10
""'z
:e<
.
I-
en
W
~
I-
W
W('I)
..0:::....
rlJF....
~cn~
=Z-I
~<II.
~o .
<::iffi
Iil1W-I
~a.ll.
_Ol<
(I.l('l)Z
d bO~ ~
...s,,a $;; ~
_"'3t~
fG~;-
.... 0 ~ 0\
.~ U Ii a
Us ~.-
oc:J1.:
u.:lUD.
u.:l='"
<ez
e =:g
~'S;: ~ Ci'
=;; &3 cE ~
::t::d/:l~6'"
__-cg ~ a
--c == 00."
g'c Iii 8
:3~~~
E--c ~
~
.,..,e
ro'\~
~
. oi
:Jl
I
j
!
tjtj~
z~~~1D
o ~ 0 D I
~6~~~
a:-~~~
~
~
Ci>t!
w CD ~ ..
i ~ ~ i
w ~ ii! I!
c C r.J ~
en
z
o
5
o
...J
o
W
en
C
Z
<(
en
J:
I-
c..
W
o
~
o
w
en
o
c..
o
0::
c..
~
U
o
o
rl
w
J
J
W
Z
I
U
(j)
.
~ Ii ~
~ ~ 0 Ii fS
CI.l ;..J CI.l ~ ~
W ui::s .. it N
~~o~(O) ~ ci~
l1.Z':"rrl~ g r;!3
a:oca:a: c zU)
::l_W 11. - >-
l1.b~~l1.li:.l.Loftl<<!a:
C)::lWCI.lc( --:"'0
~a:a:u.Iii(')C).....t;~
1=~~Oa:~~X==~
:E z W u:::l .. Z 0 :1: ~
a:Oa:..Jbg~a:~...
wU!am::l:rffl&cia:
D.a:ZNa:::sCllc(>::)
~~@><~::s::s~~8
u.Ca:~a:OOQ:N''''
~~~Il.~tEtE~clg,~
C(ZZ~~zz~:!l>" ',-
CI.l~==rna:QQ>:irnfg
~~o~w~~l5::S~i:i
-1-:1:>>00::a::1: ..O::w
==OCl.lO 1-1- ~::ll-
~~~!zfilfifi~~82i
co::l-<rnD.l1.500>>
..Wc(~Q~.j.j...J.j!!;UJ
~ffic.j~oi5i5i5~a:~
5F=~~~g:~~~i=~~
zO 00000000
t /~\r
... \( ..I ',.
.... ~ >-,. \0
Q )\ en-1J' ~
I- /' ,W 7L"
CJ >,.. i .
W 0 V ",
CQ 0:: 1/ '
.. Cl (
'//>~-t,( ;.
1---1(. ),
) f.\.
, 'I
'1/ \ '.,
',' .
~
1:4
J..
.~tLt~..
~..(~Xe~~ '-!)
~~
-'vr'
';::)
t"
hi
~
~
.W
!~
P:\D662 _.r DoekI<fw;s\0662-SCHNC...llER DCX:K-P!:RMIT.dwg
..-:;.,;.-"
::~.<
"., ;
. ~... J
:; :::::~:~
,'.~~';,,' .. ~..... j . ...)
h:~'_s:o')if ]L--. ,'. ~};o.'~..<
-.. . . :t:!'":~ , .'~ -"~"';J
i~~fi
-"~'..'-' ,.. I ~ ". j
~i)~~~:l; J ).:./?h
.~., 'f"'- /"" . ('
1~1;~~~3) :]~:rf.g
..~i
}\.<~
:5. )s':~J
," ....-,
__' "._>,.::L;
..\~. .~-<:,::-':\"'
I
-~
's)l.\{
I :,-..,. '.",
I \:>:.~::::~
';~~~;;:ccl~ia
;'?f;3;;:'::: I~
-j-; ~ i
I 0'1. C)',
<~U~~:
>1;C)~
"I"~
, '....
'-,' .. ~:
. I'~ ,
. ui '--'-.'
. - : k
---r-""---~"
'c:i~~:"; _ I" .
-'::'ci~.:) '.c;;...../,
. '--::.f..::..':>
\... ,,~' ".:. -- ...
-, I '.
c.
wtu
>w
00::
:!u..
Wo
0::-
wI-
mO
...JCIS u.
~c u.
~w 52
ooZ en
o- F-.
-~ ....
I-z
0_
~~
::Ie
:c~
.
0
1-:
CW
w~
NlE
-00
~oo
zo
-a.
~I-
Zz
Ww
~~ 0
WW
~~ N
.....
:J:W
oo~
I-~
o~
<u..
ll.W
~~
.
.
io
N
m
,
m
z
0 C!):2
~ ~o:: I
~ ~o
w zu..
rn ~g
O::ll.
W...J 0
1-< 0
Wz ....
c.. -
o:i!:
...JO::
enw
....1-
~~
i
)
,"""-y"
~.' ..
~ .(:'~;
',' ~ .
:;.::~~.::.~~:'
1 >' ~~%
)
)
) .,
, ....
,: .
'\
1
)
.\
)
)
,
a'
t>
Cl'"
,~ z:
.~ C'Ii;
101
s: 'j ::::'1
:J: \ ?j)
:! 'J ~'"
s:;
'1
'e
1:4.
"A-...
'> iffl>S!W~
.....~~ t:l~o:., ClI)
'~~i
<-'Y"
';::)
t""
I-
00
W
s:
1-,
W
WM
..0::....
~ 1-.....
f2oo~'
:~Z...J
'Q<u.
':"' ;:QQc6
9; <...JW
. r.1 W ...J
j;.cll.ll.
j;.cm<
rIJ('<)Z
q.
C>
Packet Page -62-
w
~ .. w
z Iii g
~ !l!
... en CD
~ ~ r/)
.. ...
~ ~ 10
e e Ii.
en '" '"
~ ~ ~ ~ i:
a: :b ~ r/)
0 C> z
::
~
..
t-' ~ i ...
..; UJ :! l'l
I
... -, '" z
0 >= .. 0
UI me.. ~
z ~ ~ g
Cl 0
II> ~ a: ~ W
w Ul
c c u -,
~
()
0
0 en
I
CO
~ 0
Z
<C
W ~
.J
..J
W
Z
I
(j
(f)
. bO C"">t N
o _ ~C""'\
..s::3 8 ~
"",~i;l ~;$
Q.;)C~_
......... 0 ~ 0\
c;2U~~'
.s-p:..",::,"
o~ ::f~
rn--=-
C"LJ~~
<5;0:;
_~ e =:i ~
.:: .S: ~ q
_____ = ::s ~
=UJ <t:l:'b
::::t=~ ~c;:-;
--c- ~ ~ a
a3.8 g.- 0
t::::C:J!]
=:E ~A.
E-< l:J
~
"'E
""8
~!
.~
~
'-I I I I .
~ 3~8{2011It~m 7.Ai
0;:0", _ I
rn....I rn <'/ s: iii W
Ww::s -i!! N IU ~ (!)
rnrno-zlU~ ~ -;s Z Iij Iii Z
~::ll-::::;X u~!t: III UJ g <(
c::ZcwO 0 Cl::) r: iJj en a:
::lQwc::g: c_z~
l1.t3UOl1. .IL<'/Wa:
(!l::la1m<li:O~..:o
~a:a:ILIi.i",(!)....t(!)
I=lii~oa:~~x~ll!
~ Z w u:::l .. Z 0 ~ (!)
a:Oa:....ibg~g:::s""
WU~Ol::lJ:ffia.cia:
l1.a:ZN:=:ElD<>~
a:oOCxc.o""""'CI.lClQ
ILwo "''''-zu
u.cc::...a:ooc::",''''
wWWQ:wa:a:w .u.q
a:c:J:Il....U.U.l-qOlb
<zz<~zz~:!!.>;;;;
CI.l~i1:rnc::QQ ~rni5
~~o~w~~gg5::S~i:i
- I- :J: :> >0 II: a::J: -. c:: w ~
~oCl.lO I-I-I-:E::ll- t-=
~z::s"'@ooQi:!8~
c~~5rn~g:::c5~~
ri.i~<C!i::::;~;i~<!...I>>
f;;iIWC...ll1.01-1-1-(Sa:a:
,..J:Z...Jl1.a:OOO_::l::J
ol-<<<l1.I-I-I-I-CI.lrn
;<!;O 00000000
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\;~,
t
"'-;-
o.
I"-w~fil:
o ...J'-l',> W
w I w
N!E.,Oa:
~(I) '~lL.
_(I) Wo
ZO 0::-
~e:~w5
Zz mx
Ifl ~i~ ~
m X ':5: w
wW'(I)Z
>1- 0-
.<(1) ,-~',
":l:W 15z
(I)::f .~<_
<~,;;.t> it,.,...J:E~
r--...-.if, Wt,',l...J 0:,:
':E :I:,.i< ~
.~ir t-": .
"f~~,
"'~'" .~
l~.;.~_.~",;..'_:,4~,'.~_i,...r.r,'1._!
,f'-~'-'Iv "
"~:;:_-'{~(, ~
;;
"-.
, :{
;;';'il:c'~ ;'--~"" ,
~"","",'.."'-
''''''''- --:.:"
"-." ..-
-~f
',.,';>- .
<...t~;:,:!.
$-.;..:~
P:\ll662 SehneIIet 1locl;1llwg.\D662-SCHNEUER llOCK-PERMIT.IIwg
Packet Page -63-
,~
~.~-': i
l
;
i
~,. .
;\'"
';;':.l~~;f-
.-.,.;>;l>,..i<"-.-
'''''!<"f'' .
-~.'~:a!ll
~'C~~~"P:~
,i'
II
~ ~
~ ~ .;
~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~
c 0
III
,..
III
I Q.
i:
Ul
z
;:
~
~ I i
Pi
I
Z
0>=" 0
~im2~
i3~~8 ~
C Q (.1 "")
~
U
o
o
~
W
J
..J
W
Z
I
()
(fJ
a..
~
2
CI.)
t)
o
::>
-J
u..
. be <"l .... '
~..E~{a
__~"i'
c-n- ~ ;; ~
Ba~O\'.!
.t':SU...J~
."......- ~-l
g.g :r~
~ iV g.~ 1
-< =z
~ .~
~.= ~~
---C>.~"
c:a &j J5 ~
=~~o::
--c- ~ ~ a
a3 -8 ~ M
:" t= d..z::::l 9:
:::s:::;a :.! s:;
F-< :;
co
:qg
<-!
~I
;;;
1~
J!
1
@
~
'iii
E
....
..
.~f
:/
, l
" ',j
./ J 1";
/\~,
",;,\///
/~/\/
'" //\ /,/ ,
./~/;'\'"
;'. ;'
, /~//,. '"
,. "'~ h
/ ;' ./ wa,:
"\;,;' '" !~
;' ;' \ I-
/ /,,// / ,. I
~ ;' ;'
;~;' / w-
, ;' )zJ-Zio~
'" O::i..: .
;' ;' '" lf~._~
/;' !i~iilc!
;';' ::E ~
;'- ;' I _
,I' ;'\;' I~"'/\
(/ .
/ \
/-
/
c::.
't>
~
~-~
~
~
~
a
c::.
P.IlllllI2-lloc:I<'tdIovI\Oell2.sc:tlNEllER~.&lwg
\~
~\
'2.
-~
Packet Page -64-
'%
~~
~
~
\
I lal I ",I I ~
~ 3L8/201} Item.? .A.;
z . Ii: .or <!!!
o ~ a.... 0'
CI.l.~ rn ~ ~;t Ii! W
ww::s.i!! ;J (!)
rnrt)~w~ ~ is zffilil z
~io~~~ g r;! !~~
::l_wa:a: c z
l1.bOO8: dL~lD~
C)::lffi~<li:o~":Q
~!:ffilLw~~":'tC!l
I::CI.lLLOa:"'Z~~lI!
::S~~U;i=.;iz~::sC!l
a:(J ..JOS~I1.....
~...S!211l~:r:WI1.0$
"'ZNI-::Sm<>_
~~SXl1l::E::ES!2~g
ILca:Sa:OOa:C\i....
wwwltwa:a:w .1L<;l
a:c:r I-LLIL....<;lOUl
<z;:z~~zz~,t>J:
U)~::U)a:OO>:>CI.l15
C) Z c z w ii5 c;; 13 ~ l!:! ..
~ j: :r :: ~ ~ ~:I: " It: ~
<~~~OCOOb~5;C
a:1II::l Wa:a:-~t":i
CjX:1- CI.ll1.l1.::c~~
..in<~:J~....I;i;i..J>>
~ W C ....I l1. 0 ~ ... ... cc( a: a:
i:::rZ....ll1.a:OOO_::l::l
ol-<<<l1.Fol-l-l-rnCl.l
zO 00000000
w
Z
:J
b
w
CI.l
z
I ~
\
\
....
en
w
;:
....
W
W('I)
.. a:: ....
fI.ll-....
~en~
ii:Z-I
~<u.
l:l CJ .
<-en
-1W
Iio1W-I
E-oD.ll.
Ul~~
~ ~ ~ ~
~ . . . 10
o;sijija:
iG~~-:r
a::;:~5'rIl
_ co l!: Z
~
I-
S~!i ~
c; .. 0
!It ~ c .. 1=
~f~i 0
~~u~ ~
~
U ~
o ~
o ~
C! ~
w ~
.J 0
.J ~
W @
Z ~
I ~
o ~
(f)
.bO<'I~
Qcc-a~
..s'J:: l;:; ~
__ "3 ~ :G!
C':'-:)DO_\Q
tu. s::..........
~ 0 (W'l0\
.$ U Ii a
0- ..
o~:f~
c-n ;3 c. '-
"'"'Sz
<( s:: \C
e '...
~._~o
__. > -9 .
-a&i rn~
:=ctd&!(;;'
-II) <~
=~.~ iti
...,. ofi .8
""1 .. "-
E--o loLl
. ~
I :q e
. ..
- .i
~
...
.
CERTIFIED SURVEY
.
.
Packet Page -65-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
>-
III
>
II:
::2 d
CIJ z
.. III- It
oa; iE
r:L~~l5~
~~O .
:IS a.... 0
U ::I
S ;I
U _.
III
a.
II)
...
m
~
...
w
w
c:
...
<II
~
::;
W
0-
m
...
l3
!<
8
e~
co
~~
~~
u~
w
a:
c:
::I
...
-3~ Z .a::
~o .0 0
>ziD!fi CD
=~E~= fi-
~=fl:;~ ~.
~~::t!!... ~
w~g!~ d
~:E5ul:!.~
;!~~~iZ 2
-.3=CQwrru1 W.
~1;;lUj!:le8~F!:S
I" >"'>~U~I"!l!
.~~~i~~~l5~
~!!So~~~~i
... ;!;1!:........."'lS
u "'Qticrz~~~
~~~g~~~
~0"'~~~"':E
~M~~~g~~
;'!2i=~~Sg~
l5~
"'-
:z:;oa:
__11:9
osg...
~~:l!?:
t5a.:oz
fd~~5
0:0:>0
"'0 0. a:
<mWW
...:1:3
:5:;:0
n.oU
"'~ ~. w~l1~g ~:.l~
~~ ~"'~"'... ~~s.~ ~S!'.
..: ~2 ~i;~= ~~~S~ g55
, z:!!l. "",!5~:li Ool'lujE htO
fa U1:c _z i!::._Q.ts Ezz:< d~iiJ
~ ~ i ~g ~;g~; ~~~~~ ~DIU
:8 ~; e~ to: Oat!~ ~~"'~ffi ~~~
~~-j; Q l;i1O !! ~~~ii .. ~.!Eg~ D_o
Z:;:~ -=~ -.~ e a::;!f~5!! w~l!F:g ~~f
~g~ ~~ ~ld ~ i~~~~f ~~a~i5 i~i
X~"Z: ~. -'-8 -C bgo~~a: ~"""'ffiO wi"'
il!ilj~ ;i ~~UI ~ Z~~a:o~ l5fi5ii:~ ~u~
i~i~'~ ~:i::!J !!lL~~~E o~~~= I~IZ:
~~~z .!i Q:O . ~~ao!!f ;Z:1D~O::t g.~
- ..J ~1- WC)o- 9 ::lEw~>-&a <cwO! !i:
~~L ~! I~l ~ ~~E5~~ i~;!:~i~ i2!
in o~ c<.. C IO-!P~.. S 1II1!!.... ~~....
~ a::z: ~~x t! !!~~~l!~:: i6~ ~~~
~ .:~~~!~ ::~~ 9 ~~~~~~ ~~!l~i :!E~
f s~ g~ ~
~!.:l ~~.. w ~ !5'
~;. ::~~~&9 a
...~ Ur ~ o~tH If:i 3
ZIl) 2~~ is: ~~ !!
~r: omfil ii;: z
~~ g~~ ~i ~
1ft; ~~~ 0 ~ m
;(Z ~:d;:: t;~ ~
rl~ t!~~ ~ wg 0
~~ ~2S ;;L!!ll!'~:l! ii
::JiC co!!( ~~!!!ID~g z:
~~ ;9~ ~~~~Ii! ~~
.fl~ ~~III C oLUI%L LQ
e:;:i ffii; 651e!!~~UI 5~
:tj5>- a..~iti 3>t:a:~~ :88
~o~ gz ~~~~~ g...
~~~ ~~ ~~~E~a':~Hi
.~; ~~ii ~tH:;;;u!e w~
=Ja; ~~~ ~:e=~:;!i~!
~<c O=D 2!mi5::JZ. =ii!:
~
lD
o
~
~
o
Q.
Cl
~!!l
8a:
~
. lUlU
~!;z
li!1r::i
D..0b
~~o _
~")i~~~
o -0
IE~ a.>
~J:;iil~
:!: ~
~ ~
S 0
15 ~
Ul ~
W 0
5 Q.
<
~
ci
Ul
~uj
~~
00::
tJo
=~
1-0
g~
z
:;S;CD
I-a:w
o~~
....-....
0::
b
'0"
n
.
0""
Ou
~g
w
fS
~
8
2
~
~
>
a:
:>
<II
9
w
ii:
'"
w 0
~o~~
.wUOD
c
z
w
C)
W
-l
\
\
\
~\
~\\!l:-
\ 01
\~~
:
...
.0
....
~~
.11::0
iL~
c5
.s
Ii
c:
'Si..
! ;$
::J~~
,,~3
t-~!
o~ :.
=l!!~
.. z
CS
1:
::I
o
U
i;~~~... ;:~~~ IS
-"~~2 ~~~ ..tu~~~i.i fl l5 ill
ilcJ>.. ~i!. 1il~lUm .ffi9~~!i 3
~~ ~ ~ :~3~Kli~!U ~ m~~~dJ 5
- 8 ~!r ~ D~:E~B.a::~Ullj;; U ID . C~U3dUl5:u
~ !iC!2 !!;!~.J''''z~i5-=x..~a~~.: ~x!>-~~
- ~ - 3I::....~. <w< _ u w.... 2=C.-..
--., -:J Il..I&I~uw...,z:tJW..... a:: >- O=-f5;:.=W'
g~e:. i~!::5E~::E~~~gfZ""f:E.:Ew~!i~:!
c~ ~~ eo ii! ~ ~ :I(~""O~~<D~ ~ 15 9~g:!ie~ .IO~
ffi~ ~ ~!E E" ~ 1;~~:;Q~:~i . ~ ~2gi-:~~B!
CJa::I~I. ~!"'a-~~~~I::J~O;. D..~n5~..f5~..
wi::E ~ i 5 ~ &Z-~WDL~ -'W 0 L o~;:::a::.~:lw.:i
..Jiit= i D ;! i~!i~~~~i5~fj It ~ ~1D:~il!:~~W
D D is Ii ~ X c~~8w~Q~:Jz!! Go gX:'::l:E~:iz~
~~zcg~~~wii~~~1!i8~;j Igr:;~r:~ .
~H ~ ~ i ~~h~~~3:t~ ~ = !~~~::l~gd
Ci:!Kui 5:ESZ:~Q.2i~8iill.~~UiIDU""~
~-:r~ G ~~fl9~r~~~_~~ t=~J:~~~~~~~
~ ~ 5~! f =~~~~~~C:~~~! ~~YdD~:~..
O.Ui~e.08~~~~~f3:eIOX. 1a~5G!~~~!~
~~
~ z
~5
:ioo
~c:~S
C:~S.S
~~ilG
g~85
Ii
en
.
a
.
u
~
NO
~CD
~...
~~
mco
.....0...
<>
ID
...
o
....
~D::'"
~,,"l'
~f~~
!i :"i1~
"l J
~flJ i I~ ~I
:r 52 me
loIl~n..
--
(dl.lXrS~~
_ 30D0.~t.lXl'i
~ -
o
:I:
lD
...
0_
ZID
:!b
ffi--
::E
~
o
.II::
...
~
lid.......
~
(dl.llT!l~l
N.IIll.lt.llllS
(dlol101lE
!; ~ N:iio,l;.ais
!;o
...~
l:I
~-
...
I~~
ae
~-
Packet Page -66-
,...~u..."",.
3/8/2011 Item 7 .A.
CD
...~'"
81D'"
~8~
~z~
gwz
.."'w
;!~if
.
.s .l! 3
'" "'...
:;:g~
:I;::;~
:;:;:;
S"S"S"
.., ..,..,
~t!~
.
,oJ
I-
w
~ j;[
I- ::i
C/) w~
zoo.
~~~
::::i @.~
~ ~
..J -
o
.
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
al
o
'Z
<(
a...
~
o
a..
:!
X
a
z
<C
-oJ
U.
0
en
w
c::
.. 0
<(
co
T"" ~
0 :I
00 x
N =
Z . ~ x
W -00 .~ ., * :l
j5C1) X ~ x
(!) z~ m * :I
~ 0 X :J
Oc:: ~ x
Z ~
Uo .,
~ x ~ ~
T""w ~
COo::: ~
1-0 0
g~ Q.
W
-oJ
<(
. ~
I-~~)
.r.rIrI
-"
o
C'\I
"
-
T""
Packet Page -67-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
LETTER OF NO OBJECTION
.
.
.
Packet Page -68-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
LETTER OF NO OBJECTION
PROJECT SITE: SCHNELLER RESIDENCE
39 W Pelican Street
Naples, FL 34113
I hereby state that I am the owner of the adjacent upland riparian property located to the North. of the
. proposed dock project at address referenced above. I understand that the subject project is proposing to
construct a dock within the required side yard setback from my property line as shown on the attached
exhibit. I do not object to the proposed dock project and agree to allow the project to be carried out within
the required side yard setback as shown.
-<-- . /
,..." e' # "
r /., -" ~C.",,''''/~t..........
~>. ..::...~.:::.,,.z.. v 't (j
.'- , ,
.' j' ." .' ..-;
,~ ~/ "7
. . . .,' ,;' ~/ /~.." .
/ ..;/. " ,!!~::-' --
.!.9t(~iI ~ignature of adjacent owner)
~.
J It" ,c",:,* .2..~.<....;~
(Date signed)
,.-, i ( . t . ":" "
t' .f ey...\'rL (.\ if>.-- r-tr-'!. !;", t:f c.....
t
......-.... I'
"J i -"" 1- .i,.'14' '"
(Printed name 0 adjacent owner)
.
Packet Page -69-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
AERIAL FLUCCS
.
.
.
Packet Page -70-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
~ Ii: == 2-~ ~
~ . 0 ~ N
rn ~ CI.l ~ ill W
m ui::s . i!! III ~ ~ w" (!)
o~o~.., .~ zw Z
0. zl-::::i X ~!li ~:r g 01:
a:ocw~ CliO ~:.., Jr
~-~a:11. . z).
bZOo. .ftlil:!a:
Cl::lW:I:C(Ii:........o
~a:a:CI.lw..,~tc"
!:t;~~a:~;.(::~
::!:zwu:~;i..O:I:c"
~oa:.o a:::s...
worn....l::l 11.....
l1.a:z~a:~~~s
~fr@xt;::!:!{l~8
lLOa:lj!a:Oa:-.'"
w~~l1.l:!!e:I:!!~l!5~
~zz~~z~I>;;:
rn~::CI.la:Q ::iffics
Cl z 0 z W CI.l l!5 ::!: I- ..
~j::r::>0~:I: ..a:fil
","oli)O .... ::!:::l""
· ~z~~fillj!g~8i:li
OWI-C(CI.ll1.::ct?:;>
"m~i:lig~~Ci!c>~
~WC....ll1.01-....~a:a:
r-i=~Ci!~g:~~F~~
eo ^^^^o^^
'" vvvv vv
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
~~~~~"
...~ ~.
:i' i'" ~~, '.
'"' .0"1 1'-"'
:~:fiJ~;
\~Jii,..,I~
r~'-;.~'-'::~'~'f~.
;J,,,,;: ,
,
"'!~'t.i.._
~.
.<....~
\: .:~ ,~j
,~i~
:<~~'i,~
f',
'f
~ .
f''! ,~..
~'..
,,~;,;)t,
.;.r .
.~ .~
.,;ir;~
/It"),. ,
. :J."~;.(:-',l'-;:C'" ,f:~~'
: " ' , ~.;~; :lIi~~:'
.."
'"
,~{/:);
't'~.
P:\DIlS2 SchnoIler ~\Dl562 - SCHNEllER IXlCK.lMg
Packet Page -71-
'if
~
U
o
,~ 0
r!
w
..J
\ ..J
,~ W
Z
I
U
(/)
,..~ C,"
JIll
':l~;;o'/
i
.[
:l~~'~'~
,ild'..t~"'f ..(
,I
~:;J
Jf' J OJ
"
,~
.i
t
. tJ.I)C"'IN
~.~~~
~'3c!~
~[g~~
..... C f"P'10l
.;s! U ~ a.
Os -..
g ::L~ .E
",-,0lIe.
<~z
_~ 8 ::l ~ ~,
-Q..... .!! =
-. E; ea ~
c;~ ""'\2;
=dg~~
~u <~
~.e ~~.
i::: :a l;l g
=::S "5 if:
~ ~
....
co:>
.....s
......8
j
g
~.
!l
]
~
~ ~
iii l\l
~ ::
lZ: ,;,
o
aJ
..
10
~ ~ n.
I
aJ
Z
~
~ ~ ..
..; '" ~ l;j tlf
....w_! z
~;md O~
~ ~ i'5 z
~~ri~ ~
a..
<C
:2
en
U
U
:J
...J
LL
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
SUBMERGED RESOURCE SURVEY
.
.
.
. Packet Page -72-
TuRRELL, HALL & ASSOCIAY~~,li~c:.A.
MARINE & ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING
': ~M ~,
r~;;F~. Vj..:.:;...:.-
. 3584 Exchange Avenue, Suite B . Naples, Florida 34104-3732. (239) 643-0166. Fax (239) 643-6632
SITE:
DATE OF SURVEY:
WEATHER:
TIDE:
VISmILITY:
PERSONNEL:
Submerged Resource Survey
Schneller: Section 31, Township 51 S,
Range 26 E
May 12,2010: 10:00 a.m.
830, Sunny, Wind 10-15 E
LOW 6:40 A.M., 0.9 MLLW, HIGH 12:24 P.M., +2.4 MLLW
approximately l' - l' .5"
Jeff Rogers
1.0 Purpose and Scope.
Turrell, Hall & Associates performed a submerged resource survey for the site referenced above on May 12, 2010.
The survey was requested by Collier County staff. The Schneller residence is located in Isles of Capri, Florida. The
project site is more specifically located in Section 31, Township 51 South, 26 East ofthe Naples, Florida, United
States Geological Survey 7.5-minute series quadrangle map. The proposed docking facility as shown on the
attached exhibits is a fixed wooden finger dock to facilitate the mooring of one vessel up to 17' in length, protruding
.roximatelY 142' from the MHWL.
The objective of the submerged resource survey is to identify and assess potential impacts to the existing submerged
resources by the proposed project. The survey provided onsite environmental information to help determine if the
proposed project would impact any existing submerged resources and if so would assist in reconfiguring the
proposed in order to minimize any impacts. The general scope of work performed at the site is summarized below.
· Turrell, Hall & Associates personnel conducted a site visit and snorkeled/walked transects within the
proposed project basin and verified the location of any submerged resources.
· Turrell, Hall & Associates personnel identified submerged resources at the site, estimated the % of
coverage, and delineated the approximate limits of any submerged resources observed.
· Turrell, Hall & Associates personnel delineated limits via a handheld GPS (Garmin Model 76csx).
2.0 Submerged Resource Survey Methodology
J effRogers, Biologist of Turrell, Hall & Associates performed the submerged resource survey during an incoming
tide with high tide being at 12:24 P.M. The submerged resources were evaluated using snorkel equipment where
accessible and walked the remaining area where lower water levels exist all within the proposed dock footprint.
The entire project area was evaluated systematically, setting up a series of transects approximately every ten feet
~>ughout the length of the entire shoreline and o~t waterward beyond the proposed docking facility and boat.
.sects were laid from each property line running northwest and southeast all within the entire impact area. This
IS the area that will be impacted with construction and normal ingress/egress of the proposed vessels utilizing the
docking facility. A visual estimation of percent cover for submerged resources was made for each transect. I
Packet Page -73-
snorkeled and walked these transects, compiled notes, and located the limits of any submerL 3/8/20 111te m 7.A.
aerial drawing, that is attached for your review.
3.0 Findings . .
Surface water conditions at the time of the submerged resource survey were calm. There was an incoming tide that
was encountered during the survey with high tide registered at 12:24 P.M. (+2.4 MLL W) on this date. The substrate
found at the site ranged from a silt sand or sand with small amounts of shell debris that ranged from the mangrove
fringe line out past the distances of the proposed impact area. It is estimated that 95% of the area is covered with the
silt sand with about 5% shell debris.
The submerged resource survey at the site yielded few findings. Green alga (Coulexpa sertularioides) was observed,
along with a few Florida Fighting Conchs (Strombus alatus), and a Banded tulip snail (Fasciolaria hunteria).
Barnacles were in the immediate area growing on the mangrove roots along the shoreline and on the piles of the
adjacent property dock. Few fish were also observed sporadically throughout the deeper transects that were
cencentrated around the adjacent dock were shelter is provided. Since there are no seagrasses and no oysters that
were observed, it is our opinion that the project will have little to no negative effect on the surrounding marine
ecosystem.
Mangrove Shoreline
.~.;..
.",",-,:"
f' .. )
L_~__~_ .
P. Cqo<. 'n::...~-".>".'. -,-
'~t'~'~:;''.;,::''t:, .:,:
. .' . ..:. ..~ -'-' ....~ . : ~ .-' . '- - .'..'. ;.
,-', .
. " . -' -.- .
" '
L.
~'~;;,;:'
. . ..~,.
.#.-' '-.
"
I
Banded tulip snail
.
Mangrove Shoreline
Florida fighting conch
.
Packet Page -74-
\\c/
/ "
/.
"/\/,,,/"
,,/\ /<
/. _x/
", / /
<~:/\" "
/, /
",./\ /// /
/>>)(//,~ ~::J
1-<
/ ()U
/ ~ Wli:
, / ~~
) / , ~~
/ / \ I-
/ /,,// / ' I
, / /
/~/ / W-
/ ~.z"'~
" 0::::; . .
/ / / lf~~~
/ / ~~u:lci
/ / ~ ~
/. / / .
/ / / /
/~i/ \
/ \
J 0
/
\~
\'1a-
~
o~
%
":>1-~\
~
't;.o;
t:>
""
14 t-.
~~~,~ ~
~~x:g~o:., ~ ' ~
~JP.;$;~ 'f tl
T':~
~ ~'?
\
P;\0662 SchnoU., 00cl<1<l_1Oe62 - SCHN"..LLER OOCK.<Mg
Packet Page -75-
!. I~I I~I I I
~ 3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
o :;: v ;i!: a: < N
CI.l;.JCI.l s: I
Wui::E.'<t !IJ Iii W
tI) CI.l W 1:; .:s::; (!)
f2::lf2~)( ~ll: ~ Iii ~ z
a::Zoulo Cli;j m w < (
::lQwa::!!= .z). ~ililil a:
11.1-()0~ N-
ClUZ:z:l1.li:olt)"!ll:
z::lWCI.l< ,,":~o
F~ffilLw~--:~!B
I-tI)lLoa::~X~ll:
~ZWu.:~~o:r(!)
a::oa: ,u~a:::E1-
W()~;::l:z:R:c:ill:
11. a::zNa:::E<>:::l
Oa::oox!n..,CI.l(!)O
ILw ..::-ztJ
u.oa:~a:Oa:- . r-.
WWWl1.I-WILa::W"!U.9
a:o:z: 1-00cc
<zz~~z~'!!>:b
tI)~~l/)a:Q ~fflo
~~O~W~~::EI-C:i
~1-i15o~!l::r::;!5w...: ~ '" ..
~~::El-filb~~8~ t!!l ~:g l'l
ow::lZrna:~< Z
..w~~50a.~..J~~~ 0
~l/) ~::::; <<->> ~
~wO..Ja.OI-I-~a:a: ~
~::I:Z..Jl1.a:OOF::l::l w
ol-<<<a.1-1- CI.ltl) ~
zoo 0 0 0 000
W
Z
::::;
t)
W
en
Z
p
\
\
I-
en
III
$:
I-
III
Ill'"
..~~
~I-~
wen",
C:Z-'
Q<l:1L
Q () -
<:JIB
~1ll..J
r-.c..c..
....Cl<l:
tt:lMZ
Ii N III
l:I)ul~ ..
~ 8 ~ 0 III
U)rj~C;rl.
~~~~i:
a:-";"ob~
:: 0 z
~
o
~
g ~ c u
~ ~ ~ ~
ffi ~ ~ '"
C C tJ Q
Y-
O
o
o
C(
lU
.J
.J
W
Z
I
U
f.IJ
C/)
r-
()
ill
C/)
Z
c:::(
ex::
r-
ill
o
ex::
::l
o
U)
w
~
o
ill
(9
a::
ill
2
ro
::l
C/)
"O:>N'"
o 53 ....,.... '
~.- ~~
~=ct~
~~:;;-
...... c ~~
-:= ~ Ei a
Os -i<
g ~ .[~
<~z '
c -\,0'
di?3 .=> ~ 1;
- 'S'
-a &3 ~~
~<P.l~~
---c- C1) C> ~
ai oS "" c;
..... := a ~ .
::s~~c::'
E- ~
~
f' ~ ~
.'~ -./. ~
~f "1;
; ,t'
@
~
..:..: .
';;;
JS
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
DEP PERMIT
.
.
.
Packet Page -76-
Florida Department of
Environmental Protection
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
'-IIClIII'" """ I..,.,
Governor
----
-~
South District Office
P.O. Box 2549
Ft. Myers. Florida 33902-2549
JeiT KlJttkamp
Lt. Governor
i\.licbel W. Sole
Seacl:l"v
November 3, 2007
Paul Schneller
c/O Turrell, Hall & Associates, Inc.
Jeff Rogers
3584 Exchange Ave., Suite B
Naples, FL 34104
Re: Collier County - ERP
File No. 11-0283215-001
Dear Paul Schneller:
Thank you for your application to construct a 374 square foot single-family dock. with-in Pompano
ey, Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve, adjacent to 39 West~elican St., Class.IT Waters, Section 31,
wnship 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County. This type of activity may require authorization
for construction and operation of the project (regulatory authorization), unless otherwise exempt
by statute or rule, authorization to use state-oWned submerged l~ds (proprietary authorization),
and federal authorization for works in waters of the United States through the State Programmatic
General Permit (SPGP) program. Your request has been reviewed for all three authorizations. The
authorizations you have been granted are listed below. Please read each section carefully. Your
project MAY NOT have qualified for all three authorizations. If your project did not qualify for
one or more of the authorizations, then that specific section will advise you how to obtain it. You
may NOT commence your project without all three authorizations. If you change the project
from what you submitted, the authorization(s) granted may no longer be valid at the time of
commencement of the project. Please contact us prior to beginning your project if you wish to
make any changes.
SPGP (FEDERAL) REVIEW -NOT APPROVED
Your project has been reviewed for compliance with State Programmatic General Permit (SPGP)
IV effective September 1, 2006. Your proposed activity as outlined on the attached drawings is
NOT in compliance with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) State Programmatic General
Permit (SPGP). A copy of your notice also has been sent to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
eACOE) for review. The USACOE may require a separate permit.
.~\.1ore Protc:ction. Le_....s Process.'
fliI Packet Page -77-
Applicant: Paul Schneller
Application No.: 11-0283215-001
Page 2 of3
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
Failure to obtain this authorization prior to construction could subject you to enforcement
action by that agency. For further information, you should contact the USACOE at 239-334-1975.
Authority for review - an agreement with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers entitled
"Coordination Agreement between the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers a acksonville District) and
the Florida Department of Environmental Protection State Programmatic General Permit, Section
10 of the Rivers and Harbor Act of 1899 and Section 404 of the Clean Water Act." .
REGULATORY REVIEW - APPROVED
Based on the information you sent to us, we have determined that your project is exempt from'the
need for an Envi.ronmental Resource Permit (ERP). You must comply with the criteria and
limiting conditions in accordance with Section 10E-4.051(3)(b), Florida Administrative Code.
. .
PROPRIETARY REVIEW - APPROVED
Your project occurs on state-owned; submerged land and will require authorization from the
Department to use these lands. for private purposes. The Department has reviewed yo~ project as .
described above and on the attached documents and/or drawings, and as long as the work
performed is located within the boundaries as described and is consistent with the terms and
'conditions therein, we find your project qualifies for a consent to use state-owned submerged
lands. This consent is conditioned upon acceptance of and compliance with the attached General
Consent Conditions.
This notice constitutes final agency action and is subject to the provisions of Chapter 120, F.S.
Chapter 120, F.S. does not apply to the SPGP review.
.
Packet Page -78-
Applicant: Paul Schneller
Application No.: 11-0283215-001
Page 3 of3
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
If you have any questions, please contact Tim Schwan at the letterhead address, by telephone at
(239) 332-6975 extension 193 or by email atTim.Schwan@dep.state.fl.us. When referring to this
project, please reference the file number listed above.
Sincerely,
?/~-
Tim Schwan
Environmental Specialist
Submerged Lands and
Environmental Resource Program
TS/rnac
Enclosure~:
Rights of Affected Parties
Notice of Determination of Exemption
. State Lands General Consent Conditions
.:
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Fort Myers,- Log # 10704
Bureau of Public Lands Adm:ipistration
.
Packet Page -79-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
RIGHTS OF AFFECTED PARTIES
To; Paul Schneller
Date: November 3, 2007
File No. 11-0283215-001
.
This letter acknowledges that the proposed activity is exempt from ERP permitting requirements under
Section 10E-4.051(3)(b), Florida Administrative Code. This determination is final and effective on the date
filed with the Oerk of the Department unless a sufficient petition for an administrative hearing is timely
filed under Sections 120.569 and 120.57 of the Florida Statutes as provided below. If a sufficient petition for
an administrative hearing is timely filed, this determination automatically becomes only proposed agency
action subject to the result of the administrative review process. Therefore, on the filing of a timely and
sufficient petition, this action will not be final and effective until further order of the Department. The
procedures for petitioning for a hearing are set forth in the attached notice.
This determination is based on the information you provided the Department and the Statutes and Rules in
effect when the application was submitted and is effective oriIy for the specific activity proposed. This
determination shall automatically expire if site conditions materially change or the governing statutes or
roles are amended. In addition, any substantial modifications in your plans should be submitted to the'
Department for review, as changes may result in a permit being required. In any event, this determination
shall expire after one year.
Be advised that your neighbors and other parties who may be substantially affected by the proposed
activity allowed under this determination of exemption have a right to request an administrative hearing on
the Department's decision that the proposed activity qualifies for this exemption. Because the
administrative hearing process is designed to re-determine fipal agency action on the application, the filing
of a petition for an administrative hearing may result in a final determination that the proposed. activity is .
not authorized under the exemption established under Section lOE-4.051(3)(b), Florida Administrative
Code.
The Department will not publish notice of this determination. Publication of this notice by you is optional
and is not required for you to proceed. However, in the event that an administrative hearing is held and
the Department's determination is reversed, proceeding with the proposed activity before the time period
for requesting an administrative hearing has expired would mean that the activity was conducted without
the required permit.
.
Packet Page -80-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
The Department of Environmental Protection gives notice that the 374 square foot dock with-in Pompano
Bay, Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve, adjacent to 39 West Pelican Street, Class IT Waters, in Section 31,
Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Collier County has been determined to be exempt from requirements to
obtain an Environmental Resource Permit and consent to use sovereign submerged lands.
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
NOTICE OF DETERMINATION OF EXEMPTION
A person whose substantial interests are affected by the Department's action may petition for an
administrative proceeding (hearing) under Sections 120.569 and 120.57 of the Florida Statutes. The petition
must contain the information set forth below and must be filed (received by the clerk) in the Office of
General Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida
32399-3000.
Mediation is not available.
If a timely and sufficient petition for an administrative hearing is filed, other pc::rsons whose substantial
interests will be affected by the outcome of the administrative process have the right to petition to intervene
in the proceeding. Intervention will be permitted only at the discretion of the presiding officer upon the
filing of a motion in compliance with Rule 28-106.205 of the Florida Administrative Code.
In accordance with Rule 62-110.106(3), petitions for an administrative hearing must be filed within ~1 days
of publication of the notice or receipt of written notice, whichever occurs first. Under Rule 62-110.106(4) of
the Florida Administrative Code, a person whQse substantial interests are affected by the Department's
Ation may also request an extension of time to file a petition for an administrative hearing. The
~epartnlent may, for good cause shown, grant the request f9r an extension of time. Requests for extension
of time must be filed with the Office of Gener~ Counsel of the Department at 3900 Commonwealth
BoUlevard, Mail Station 35, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-3000 prior to the applicable deadline. A timely
request for extension of time shall toll the running of the time period for filing a petition until the request is
acted upon. Upon motion by the requesting party showing that the failure to file a request for an extension
of time before the deadline was the result of excusable neglect, the Department may also grant the
requested extension of time.
The petitioner shall mail a copy of the petition to the applicant at the address indicated above at the time of
filing. The failure of any person to file a petition for an administrative hearing within the appropriate time
period shall constitute a waiver of that right.
A petition that disputes the material acts on which the Department's action is based must contain the
following information:
(a) The name and address of each agency affected and each agency's file or identification number, if
known;
(b) The name, address and telephone number of the petitioner; the naine, address and telephone
number of the petitioner's representative, if any, which shall be the address for service purposes during the
course of the proceeding; and an explanation of how the petitioner's substantial interests are or will be
affected by the agency determination; .
. A statement of when and how the petitioner received notice of the agency decision;
A statement of all disputed issues of material fact. H there are none, the petition must so indicate;
(e) A concise statement of the ultimate facts alleged, including the specific facts the petitioner contends
warrant reversal or modification of the agency's proposed action;
Packet Page -81-
3/8/2011Itelll 7.A.
(f) A statement of the specific Rules or Statutes that the petitioner contends require reversal or
modification of the agency's proposed action; and .
(g) A statement of the relief sought by the petitioner, stating precisely the action that the petitioner
wishes the agency to take with respect to the agency's proposed action.
A petition that does not dispute the material facts on which the Department's action is based shall state that
no such facts are in dispute and otherwise shall contain the same information as set forth above, as required
by Rule 28-106.301.
Under Sections 120.569(2)(c) and (d) of the Florida Statutes, a petition for administrative hearing shall be
dismissed by the agency if the petition does not substantially comply with the above requirements or is
untimely filed.
Complete copies of all documents relating to this determination of exemption are available for public
inspection during normal business hours, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.rn., Monday through Friday, at. Deparbnent of
Environmental Protection, South District Office, 2295 Victoria Avenue, Fort Myers, FL 33901.
.
.
Packet Page -82-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
SUBMERGED LANDS AND ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES PROGRAM
GENERAL CONSENT CONDITIONS FOR AUTHORIZATIONS
Project No: 11-0283215-001
Chapter 18-21.004(7), F.A.C., provides that all authorizations granted by rule or in writing under Rule 18-
21.005, F.A.C., except those for aquaculture activities and geophysical testing, shall be subject to the general
conditions as set forth in paragraphs (a) through (i) below. The general conditions shall be part of all
authorizations under this chapter, shall be binding upon the grantee, and shall be enforceable under
Chapter 253 or Chapter 258, Part II, F.5. Chapter 18-21.004(7), F.A.C., General Conditions for
Authorizations:
(a) Authorizations are valid only for the specified activity or use. Any unauthorized deviation from the
specified activity or use and the conditions for undertaking that activity or use shall constitute a violation.
Violation of the authorization shall result in suspension or revocation of the grantee's use of the sovereignty
submerged land unless cured to the satisf~ction of the Board.
(b) AuthoriZations convey no title to sovereignty submerged land or water column, nor do they constitute
recognition or acknowledgment of any other person's title t<? such land or water.
(c) Authorizations may be modified, suspended or revoked in accordance with their terms or the remedies
provided in Sections 253.04 and 258.46, F.S., or Chapter 18-14, F.A.C. .
e> Structures or activities shall be constructed and used to avoid or minimize adverse impacts to
sovereignty s~bmerged lands and resources.
(e) Construction, use, or operation of the structure or activity shall not adversely affect any species which is
endangered, threatened or of special concern, as listed in Rules 68A-27.003, 68A-27.004, and 68A-27.005,
F.A.C.
(f) Structures or activities shall not unreasonably interfere with riparian rights. When a court of competent
jurisdiction determines that riparian rights have been unlawfully affected, the structure or activity shall be
modified in accordance with the court's decision.
(g) Structures or activities shall not create a navigational hazard.
(h) Structures shall be maintained in a functional condition and shall be repaired or removed if they become
dilapidated to such an extent that they are no longer functional. This shall not be construed to prohibit the
repair or replacement subject to the provisions of Rule 18-21.005, F.A.c., within one year, of a structure
damaged in a discrete event such as a storm, flood, accident, or fire.
(i) Structures or activities shall be constructed, operated, and maintained solely for water
dependent purposes, or for non-water dependent activities authorized under paragraph 18- 21.004(1)(f),
F.A.C., or any other applicable law.
.
Packet Page -83-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
GENERAL CONDITIONS FOR FEDERAL AUTHORIZATION FOR SPGP IV
1. The time limit for completing the work authorized ends on July 24, 2011.
.
2. You must maintain the activity authorized by this permit in good condition and in conformance with the
terms and conditions of this permit. You are not relieved of this requirement if you abandon the permitted
activity, although you may make a good faith transfer to a third party in compliance with General
Condition 4 below. Should you wish to cease to maintain the authorized activity or should you desire to
abandon it without a good faith transfer, you must obtain a modification. of this permit from this office,
which may require restoration of the area.
3. H you discover any previously unknown historic or archeological remains while accomplishing the
activity authorized by this permit, you must immediately notify this office of what you have found'. We
will initiate the Federal and State coordination required to determine if the remains warrant a recovery
effort or if the ~ite is eligible for listing in the National Itegister of Historic Places.
4. H you sell the property associated with this permit, you must obtain the signature and mailing address of
the new owner in the space provided below and forward a copy of the permit to this office to validate the
transfer of this authorization. .
5. H a conditioned water quality certification has been issued for your project, you must comply with the '
conditions specified in the certification as spec;ial conditions'to this permit.
6. You must allow representatives from this office to ~pect the authorized activity at any time deemed
necessary to ensure that it is being or has been accomplished in accordance with the terms, and conditions of .
your permit.
further information:
1. Limits of this authorization:
a. This permit does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, State or local authorizations required by
law.
b. This permit does not grant any property rights or exclusive privileges.
c. This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others.
d. This permit does not authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal projects.
2. Limits of Federal Liability. In issuing this permit, the Federal Government does not assume any liability
for the following:
a. Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of other permitted or unpermitted activities
or from natural causes. .
b. Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of current or fu~e activities undertaken .
by or on behalf of the United States in the public interest.
c. Damages to persons, property, or to other permitted or unpermitted activities or structures caused by
the activity authorized by this permit.
Packet Page -84-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
d. Design or construction deficiencies associated with the permitted work.
e. Damage claims associated with any future modification, suspension, or revocation of this permit.
3. Reliance on Applicant's Data: The determination of this office that issuance of this permit is not contrary
to the public interest was made in reliance on the information you provided.
4. Reevaluation of Permit Decision: This office may reevaluate its decision on this permit at any time the
circumstances warrant. Circumstances that could require a reevaluation include, but are not limited to, the
following:
a. You fail to comply with the terms and 'conditions of this permit.
b. The information provided by you in support of your permit application proves to have been false,
incomplete, or inacctIrate (see 3 above).
c. Significant new information surfaces which this office did not ~onsider in reaching the original public
interest decision.
5. Such a reevaluation may result in a determination that it is appropriate to use the suspension,
modification, and revocation procedures contained in 33 CPR 325.7 or enforcement procedures such as
those contained in 33 CFR 326.4 and 326.5. The referenced enforcement procedUres pro~de for the issuance
C?f an administrative order requiring you comply With the terms and conditions of your permit and for the
~tiation of legal action where apptopriate. You will be required to pay for any corrective measures
~dered by this office, and if you fail to comply with such directive, this office may in certain situations
(such as those specified in 33 CPR 209.170) acco~plish the corrective measures by contract or otherwise and
bill you for the cost.
6. When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time the property is
transferred, the terms and conditions of this permit will continue to be binding on the new owner(s) of the
property. To validate the transfer of this permit and the associated liabilities associated with compliance
with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign and date below and mail to Department of
Environmental Protection, South District Office, P.O. Box 2549, Fort Myers, FL 33902-2549.
(TRANSFEREE-SIGNATURE)
(DATE)
(NAME-PRINTED)
(ADDRESS)
".
Packet Page -85-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
COE PERMIT
.
.
.
Packet Page -86-
REPLY TO
ATTENTION OF
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
JACKSONVILLE DISTRICT CORPS OF ENGINEERS
FORT MYERS REGULATORY OFFICE
1520 ROYAL PALM SQUARE BLVD., SUITE 310
FORT MYERS, FLORIDA 33919
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
Regulatory Division
Fort Myers Section
SAJ-2007 -05861 (MOD-LBO)
MODIFICATION 1
SEP 2 4 2009
Mr. Paul Schneller
39 W. Pelican Street
Naples, Florida 34113
COpy
Dear Mr. Schneller:
Reference is made to correspondence submitted on your behalf by Turrell, Hall, &
Associates, Inc., requesting a modification to your Department of the Anny permit number
SAJ-2007-5861 (LP-LBD). The pennit was issued to you on 19 March 2008, and involved the
construction of a finger pier for use by kayaks or canoes. The project is located within
Pompano Bay, in Section 31, Township 51 South, Range 26 East, Isle of Capri, Collier
County, Florida.
.
Your request is to authorize mooring of a 17-foot flats vessel at the finger pier. No
changes are proposed to the finger pier. The Corps of Engineers has reviewed your request
and has determined that the impacts of the proposed change on navigation and the
environment are insignificant. The pennit is hereby modified in accordance with your
request dated 14 September 2009.
No changes other than those annotated are allowed by this document. All other
conditions of the original DA permit SAJ-2007 -5861 (LP-LBD) including any required
mitigation, remain unchanged and in full force and effect. You should attach a copy of this
letter and all other modifications to the original DA permit.
If you have any questions concerning this letter or Department of the Army permit
requirements please contact Lauren Diaz at either the letterhead address, via electronic
mail at Lauren.B.Diaz@usace.army.mil, or by telephone at 239-334-1975 extension 31.
BY AUTHORITY OF THE SECRETARY OF THE ARMY:
~~ 1Jf, t ~~
VvA
Alfred A. Pantano, Jr.
Colonel, U.S. Anny
District Engineer
. Copies Furnished: .
Turrell. Hall, and Associates Inc.
CESAJ-RD-PE
Packet Page -87-
(.
c
-
It
o
.J
U.
U.
o
W
f-
~
rJJ
3/8/2011Ite~"" 7.A.
gc>z w
..... III
III
.
W
Cl
Z
~~~: ~~~~~ . ~ '."
~rl~~llJl
~~~f:;"'~;;~git~:,..
It 1~.:"i~:~Jt.
'0 - .,.... '.:.-;J ......~.
. '::t~~l;t~~~~:~
~~}~t..~;: ;, . ". ~~ '. ~~ .. ~ ...,
~...' . . ~, ''"Jk;)0t
. .' :{4.. . .ft. ".
.:, ;~$~}I~'~~
'':;--=:~;;..:'; ~
. ....
0.
~
~
-
z
-
o
-
>
5~
ww
-,a.
mo
:;'rr:
"'a.
-"
ffi{
~ ,
>-
.w
lll::
I
\
\.
\
\
\-
\,
1:4
~-~
~
/
I
/
.,/
/
.'
'"
.. CD
f-~
oa:
ww
;a a.
:;,0
",5:
rJJ ~co
~ oW 01'
<
z
-~....
Packet Page -88-
.: .
~.;. : .
.J;- .~".... . '.
~~"~.,: ........
~
t-
en
W
.. 3: l")
tI.lt-.....
f2w~
c=Wl")
QO::...J
Qti~
<zffj
r:<l<(...J
~Uc...
--<(
tI.lulz
c...
0)
l")
~
Z
:J
o
o
tt:
W
-
.J
-I
o
()
5~
ww .
;a a.
:;,0
"'5:
~
en
2
()
::it-
W:c
D..C)
...... ~ii
~ 1Ll~
~ci~[/)
~~t=jjj
...Jm2[/)
l%l_O::J
0::0::00
wc...o:r:
..-<z -
tI.l::lU<2
ZOO .<(
Eut-g2
U~ ;:-~ ;;! uJ
OO)"'D..
r:<l.....zi!1-
=t:on.en
QX::><!;!
l;:lW::>O.>
Zt-ocizz
- 00
::;eL5--
==...!.:c!;.!;.
Q I . . .
~
2
o
en
W .
enW
oen
c...::J
0::2
::JQ
. c... t-
C)U
z::J
-0::
I:t-
_en
::!z
0::0
wU
c...o::
0::0
Ou..
u..o
WW
0::0
<2
enW
C)t-
z~
~5
<z
O:::w
00::
~Im~
~:I:Z
01-<(
zO
-I
~
~
w
<
~
z
::>
o
o
w
"0
W::J
Ot-
::J-
t-C)
i=z
<(0
...J...J
^ ^
V V
iii
~ ,:.: ail
z w.....
. ~ !J! ~
..... ItJ II>
oM
'<to
&,,~
10'<7"
. .
10 .....
NCD
z3:
Ql
... ...
z 8 III
0 :l ~ ~ Q.
Uj
:> ~ z z i:
w
a: ffl
~
~
,.: ~ ~ ..
~ CI) III
... OD Z
.... .., o c
Ci >= .. 0
w m C '0 ~
tJ I t!! g 0
Uj~~m W
l!/ 5 s;J ffl
~
()
0
0
rt a..
<(
~
W z
0 .
..J f-
..J <(
()
W 0
....J
Z
I
()
(fJ
. bD N,....
~3~~
"'-l~i s~
.BE1~~
.5! U Ii a.
Os -"
~aJ!J!
"'-la~
<=:z:""
~'~i~
cati3 ~~
~~~6:'
-C)<~
~'5 ~i
s:s ~t:
e;...c ..,.
:::. :q .~
'" ~
-.
J
T
B
.
..
Ji
.
>-
<(
m
o
z
~
:2
o
a..
.
~
"'.'" "
~
.
._- o..d<\PERJ.IITS\d-.;s\soI B-""ll
~
~
~
~
~
~
Q
~
o
z
<(
a..
:2
o
a..
..
~
...
C:PJ
z
V<:U,)
COi:!w
~<Z
00.-
..J_....J
0::
\
\
\
~
.~ \
~\\\
\"!
..
"t
(c
N
.....
0..-
05 ..
00
3:0
V
CD
f-
o
Packet Page -89-
?-
m
~
f-
W
Wro)
rijg:;:
I3m;:;
C:::Z...J
Q~u..
Q () .
<:J~
WW-I
~a.c..
_Ol~
rt}ro)Z
1..1 1%1 I I
> 3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
-I 0::::: wVJ m
~. C!i' < III
ffi.~ ~ ill rb
cnW;:!' W ~'::" Cl
o(f.)OW' ;:,> Z w ~ ~
1J..:;'f-~~ It: ~!I! ~
lrZOulCl ;:) ~ U) U)
:;,OWlrZ CIJ
IJ..j::Uo-N).
ClU~:r"!Il')Q:
Z::':lii!rt}+,,":O
i=1=wu..lI~fB
_(f.)u..o~XIl:
~~~U:~~CJ
wurt}.J _11....
1J..a:::-mOc..$
a::: ZN><...
O~OXCl(f.)O
lLo~O~ir~...
WWWlr"!WlL9
<a:o:r~9f-O(Q
zz<n~>"'i
(f.)w:> :::>~U)
C,!)1-;>(f.)...Iu.. c ...
Z~o~~o c,.: ~
;:;I-:r> lr . <;t"';j
>o(f.)O~:r::l1:!:! ::: Ill'" 8
~z~I-~15o< ~ co Z
ow::lz<;:;uo B > B 0
lrf-<c>>> Will w .. ~
u/w <; < ~ ...I W W ~ ~ I- i r
f2ffio~a:o~~ii:ii: Hi ~ ~!l! ~
!-ci=~<...I<IJ.._O::l::l c c u ~ 1IJ
o f-f-(f.)(f.)
zO 00000 ~
() Cf}
o ~
o ~
?-
ft ~
w ~
.:.J 0
;::
.J 0
w 8
z ~
I t;
U G)
(f)
1IJ
~ 8 iD
u;'l'~~A.
~ ~ Z f
a:- III
I
~
Cl
z
:5
u..
o
U,)
W
0::
U
<(
co
.....
o
CI)
z .
-U,)
~CI)
Zw
o....J
00::
o
.....w
COo::
""'0
g:2
o
co
f-
o
..J
-bONN
~~~~
...= t~
gj~;-
.....8"'""0'\
.5! Iil 8.
Us ..
Oc::lJfJ!
~"'liii"
-< ~ z
~ ...,
~. ~~
= 1:1 'e~
1:lS~"";:b
::t::~!l6=:'
... <....
- II) ..~
-~ DC"
~~j!
::t
~~
.s
.~
i
~
..-
co
f-
o
..J
:::;
E
c::
1-\ \
b <\ \
(') 0
!!2::1~ \ \
~~~ \ \
0011. \ \
~~~ \ \
ii~< \ ~
-l :t ~ \' ...
<::E< \ V
~~!::
::EO::!
ffim~
1-<11.
..
"".
E:4 \:-.
~.~ ~
I:> ~
'" ti
~
:;::>
t"-
I:>
Sd1noIotDack~_~
M
to
>-
<C
m
o
Z
<C
a.
~
o
a.
\
\
\
\..
~
~\
1i,
'a,'
~t
\
~ 1L3/8/~01~ It~m l.A.
is,o r5 11. ~ N
ffi.~ ~ ~~ ill W
w::! -;!: ::!' Cl
l3~O~M ci ~tij~ Z
c..:JI--X >!l: \2 W < <
!5i5culfi (!)~ .. ill ~ It.
t1.i=~~t1. N~).
(!)uz:z:t1."':101X11t:
z:JWrn<~""""O
i= j: ffi 11. ~ le --: ~it lB
/::rn11.O ...X It:
~ Z W u: 2 .. 0 C1J
lrolrJ5~Ir::E,-
WO~ :Jsc..'1l:
t1.1r-CI>Ir:I:t1.c::i
Ir ZNI-::E<>
o~@xw::!!!a~8
~clr9lrOIr- . p..
www...WlrwC.!u.Cjl
Irc:z:R:!c~I-QOCl)
<zz<:1:z~,g,>";"
rnl!:!;:rnlrQ ~ffi8
~~~~!t!~15~!ri:i.. ~ ...
~brnoo~:Z:::E:J~ ~!!l i i If!
C~~~~~fi~E8~ Z
I-<W t1.:o..... > > Q
_w~<u~~~cww ~
~ffic~~o~~<c~~~ g
~:I:Z~c..lrOO~:J:J m
ol-<<<c..I-I-~rnrn
zO 0000000
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
.\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
Packet Page -90-
o
1-:
OW
w-l
N~
-CI)
~CI)
zo
-a..
:EI-
Zz
Ww
WI-
mx
WW
>1-
<CI)
:tw
(1)....J
I-....J
u::J
<11.
a..W
:E:t:
;-1-
.
0.
W.
>w
OW
::Efl:
Wu
0::-
wI-
mO
X
....JW
::!o
~w
l/)Z
Uct
-I-
I-z
0_
x<
W:E
....Jo
....Jz
f<
I-
CI)
W
~
tii
WM
.. 0:: ....
Cl)t-....
~CI)~
=:Z-I
c<u..
CU .
- en
<....Jw
C:JW-I
~n..a..
_me::(
rn""Z
101 1.,1 I I
III
Z CD ~ iD
~~~~rL
~ ;j; ~ :I: i:
a: ... CI)
Z
~
~
fii ~ is ..
~ ~ ~ ~
ffi ~ l:! '"
o 0 U ~
~
()
o
o
~
W
..J
..J
W
Z
I
()
(/)
~
::>
o
~
~
()
o
C:l
o
Z
.<C
>-
~
~
_J.
~
'0
UJ
Cf)
o
a.
o
cr.
a..
.
d CD~ ~
.sJ!l~~
u:.- ~ ~ ~
oo~~
=t.)~:::l
.os ~ ~
~C~.!!
-< lil:i :!
.~
~. ~C?
==.~ "'....
=!:Q ." ~
:::I::~!t5;'
-0 <:::l
= 53 ~'::'
~'l;;J ] g
;:t ~ ... Ii:
E- ~
::b
. .... i1!
:~ r-a tt
":~. n
< 1
I
j
.
~
I iiil I ~I I I
i ~/8/2911-'te_m ~.A.
l/) ~ l/) ~ w W
wui~."'" ~::z Cl
~l/)owl:; '$ ~'::w Z
ll..;:)I-~X ~Il: lZlffJ;;t. <:
a:ZouJo C):::l ~:I: ~ ~
;:)Qw a: a: zit) rn
ll..I-OOll.. N-)..
t!lOZ:I:ll..~IO"!1l:
z;:)wl/)':":u.~+O
j:::~ffiu.wl!3,,":lIm
!:::l/)u.oa:~X~1l:
~ z w u: i:? ..0 :I: <!l
a:oa: 'os!a:~,-
worn-'::l:>a. _
a.a:-Cla::ra.O!5
a:OZNI-:E<c>
ou.@Xl/):E!!2~8
u.oa:Oa:Oa:_ = r-.
wwwg:l=!fEw"!u.~
a:O:I:a.<e 1-00'"
< Z Z < 3= Z ~ ,I >- ";"
rnl=!~l/)a:Q ~ffi:g ....
Clzzozwrnou.~I-" <;>
~~~~~~:r:;!5@ :i ~ ~ ;;;
~Z:EI-OOb::lO< ...:!!l c Z
Ow::lzwa:>~UC 0 0
a:1-<l/)ll..;>....>->- w _
U/W < < 0 0 -' ...J C W W Z 0 I-
e~~j~~gg~~~ ~ ~ ~
bl-<<<:ll..l-l-l-tI)l/) C .,
zO 0000000
. -"-' '.;..-
'~<~'*.~;;~~<"~:'" ~:;,: ,-;:., .
ub.Q~~
..s'E~~1
~;;....
.-A' ~_ ;!;
.8o~~
;; _~ U ii a.
'; Us -i;i'
~ ~ = .9 l,:"
'i<~~
~gtx:i~
. ....-( .?; ..~ 9
; "'2 r::s ": i
=~~~
~Q)<~,
:::::~ ~",::"I
~';:::l ~ g
iiI ~ c
::E ~ .:=
~ ~
~ ....
co
;~, ~ ~
~
]
]
@
e
.,
'1nOIIor DockIPERMITSIdwgs\se!_8dog
Packet Page -91-
~
(j
o
o
0::
w
-'
.J
W
Z
I
()
en
z :g
o c
iii ~
~ ~
a:
UJ
..
III
~ ~ ;
J:
Ol
~
o
I-
-l
<:{
a::
w
<::(
T
l-
S
o
w
Cf)
-0
0...
o
a::
0...
.~
=
I~LI~I l I _
~ 3/8/2011IteITI 7.A.
Ul ~ iii ~ I
Wui~,;:! ~ ~ ~
UlUlOW~ .!S! <t~ z
~::l....~x ~Q: ~ w <( <
lrt5ouJ~ C)~ ~ ili 1il II:
K1=~~D. N~)..
C!lUZJ:D.!i:'IO"!!t:
Z::lWUl< ~~o
1=l=ffiu.til~-:i'iffl
!:::UllL.Olr~X~!t:
:;z~u.:~.;;oJ:CJ
0:0 .,jUS[:;'"
WU!!2Cl::lJ:D.o'Q::
D.a::ZNa:::;<>:::J
~f2@xt;:;!!2~8
lL.0 a:: 9 a::0a::_ . ....
www~wa::W"!lL.q
0:0:x:It!;(Ll..1-90CD
<zz<~z~,g.>-,,;-
rJ)~~rJ)a::Q ~f3~
C!lz Z 0 Z W rJ) 0lL. :; I- ..
_-J:~>::l a:: 0
~6rJ)00g:J::E::l~
~z~!z@~g~8~
Ojg....<rJ)D.~~>->-
..w<<uo-'-' UJUJ
~Ul O::iD.<<-,>>
[:;;lwo...JD.o........<oa::lr
!-:I:Z-JD.O:OO ::l::l
ot-<<<D.....t-i=UlUl
~ 0 0 0 0 000 0
"!
~
10
~
ID
CD ~
c:i
m
~-
...
rei:
o
N
..
N
"i
..r
N
'CD
~
'" ~
.."
ID
"i
l:4 ~
~-~ ~
'" ~
"" '"
ti ID
'l<;; ".i
:::> !;
I:"-
z SchnoIlor DocklPERMrrs~_8.d"'!l
>-
<(
OJ
o
Z
<(
a..
~
o
a..
~
,/
'"
Packet Page -92-
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
0
1-: o.
OW W'
w....J >w
N~ OW
-en :Eft
~en Wu
zo 0::-
-0.. wI-
:EI- IDO
Zz X
Ww ....JW
WI- ::::!o
IDx S:w
wW en~
>1- u<(
<(en -I-
:I:W I-z
en....J 0_
I-....J x<(
t') u::J W:E
~ <(LL. ....Jo
o..W ....Jz
... :E:I: :"<(
Nt') -l- .
.~t'ot: :
""Z
\
"\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\"!
'"
'<t
I-
en
ill
s:
I-
W
W""
.. a:: ..-
UJI-r-
f2en~
=:Z-I
Q<(LL.
Q U -
<::i~
~W....J
, 0.. 0..
t:cn<X:
cn..,Z
Il)
".i
.
"
-bDM~
Q == ro"')~
..s::= ~ ~
~"3 ~ ~
~~.~
~ 0 1T"l0\
dU....:l~
-as ~..'":':
O:=fS~
gs IU -a~
<: gj z
a:j::i5
c:td .~ ~ 9
:==:= =....
dtxJ=~
::Z::~~5:'
-0 <~
= r-:l ;, '::'
0.>.;;;;; ~ .,
~ ~ -j
~:E~...
Eo-< ....
~~
!
'I
"l'
=g
.a
~
2
:it ~
ljj ....~ ~ ~
z z
~ ~
a:
~.
...
lD
I
D.
i
t/J
Z
~
o
I-
, ~ ...
..... q!j lW)
...: U) .... CM ,
f-~OOz
o
i=
o
w
Ul
g ~ c u
S i ~ g
ffj ~ ~ l!l
ccu-,
:l
()
o
o
~
l!J
.J
.J
W
Z
I
()
U)
U)
Z
o
~
<C
o
o
_-I
o
Ul
(()
o
Z
<C
Cl)
,
r-
0..
UJ
o
~
o
UJ
U)
o
0..
o
O~
0_
.
.
E
=
a '.0 ci
rIJ ~ rIJ ~
muj~uj;! ~
O~OZM ci:S
ll..zl-::;x >!5
~ofilw~ ClCll
ll..i=ugjll.. N~).
ClUZXo..l-lO"lll:
Z:JWcn~u.",:+O
-a::ffiU.WIO~IIl.!l
1-U.0a::~>(~li!
WU:~.:iO:I:l.!l
~..i(}~lE~...
ll..(}~Cl:J:I:ll..cill:
a::a::Z"'~~<(>:;'
O~Oxcn~cn(!)O
Wo ""'-ZtJ
ll.CH!:a::a::On:- . ,..
~wwll.~a:w"!U.9 I
oXll.< 1-90'" '
~mZ<(~~~?!>-d;\
(!)!Z~~ffiU;u....d3~ ,\
~-:I:~>:JO~I-o
~bcnOO~:I:~!5~
1 ~z~l-0015::l0<
. OW::lZWOCS<(I-UO
n:1-<1/)ll.;;> >>..' -"
../W < <( U 0 ...I ...I 0 IJJ W ,-<"
till/) 0:30..<<...1>> y.
~WO..Jll..OI-I-<(a:a: .\
~:I:Z...lo..a:OOO::l:J .
Ot-<<<ll.t-t-i=rlJl/) \
zO 0000000 \. \
~.
.....-
o.
W.
>W
OW
~ff:
Wu
It:-
wI-
mO
X
...IW
::!o
~W
enZ
u::i:
i=~
0_
X<l:
W::!
....10
...IZ
="<l:
"
o
1-"
.
OW
W-l
N!E
-en
;;en
zo
-0.
::!I-
Zz
Ww
WI-
alX
WW
>1-
<(en
IW
en....l
1-....1
0::1
<(u.
ll..W
~I
.1-
.
fl./
.I.
~j
'of
~i
~)
~'.!:>
i-- /~A/.
v"
~,
.
.
.....
~- ,.::-..e:"-'~"'"
'............ l........_...--
'"
2 ScI1n.11e< DockIPEIU.IITSdwgs_ B d-.g
{
~,
...J~
<(It:
ZO
-u.
~1-
a::<(
W...I
1-0.
(:)
N
......
~
o
o
o
~
W
J
J
W
Z
I
U
(f)
Cl~
~a::: I
~o
zu.
-~
::!...I
a::Cl..
W...I (:)
1-<( ci
Wz ......
Cl..-
o~ L
-lit:
enw
,....1-
~~
'e
-bQNN
u~........
.s3:!:;:;~
::l~'"
=~ a -~ ~
C1.>o""'-
~t..)r"l~
--_ Ii ~
U as -l:i
55 ~ -!'"'
<~z
~.5l ~ ~
= ~'3:5:
C'::S t:tl "" ;:;
:::C:cIdrts
_- C) ~ E
O'~ iM
S~~~
E-< I::l
;:::!;
:q~
~
og
:I.
::.
E
@
~
\
.(
)
'"
"
~:~
\.
'~
,"
\
.
Packet Page -93-
o
.,..
10
~ 4-
Z I
III
Z
~
o
I-
~ .,..
~ ~ (I)
o ~ Z
o
g
W
III
en
I
CD
o
z
~
~
I
<:(
CJ)
z
o
I-
o
ill
CJ)
.~
..:
Upland Property Survey
& Legal Description
Packet Page -94-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
.
.
.
.
.
~J..u.o,,"'~..:I ~'u. """TV'" .,\.'" ,,,- ..
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
CER TIFICA TE
Upon application of MITCHEL COOPER and KARYN A. COOPER,
husband and wife, whose address is 37 West Pelican Street, Naples, Florida 34113, and
pursuant to Section 92.16 and sub-section 253.l2(9), Florida Statutes, the undersigned,
on behalf of the BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE INTERNAL IMPROVEMENT
TRUST FUND OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA, pursuant to Rule 18-21.019, Florida
Administrative Code, hereby certifies that the boundary separating the lands of private
ownership from the adjacent state owned sovereignty lands on July 1, 1975, is described
as follows:
DESCRIPTION
.
THE WATERWARD BOUNDARY LINE AS IT EXISTED AS OF JULY l, 1975
LYING EASTERLY OF LOT 80, ISLES OF CAPRI NO.1 IN SECTION 31, TWP. 5 t
S., RGE. 26 E., COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, .
BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS'FOLLOWS:
COMMENCE AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF LOT 80, AS SHOWN ON THE
PLAT OF ISLES OF CAPRI, UNIT 1, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF, AS
RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 3, PAGE 41, OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA; THENCE NORTH 00041 '00" EAST, AWNG THE
WEST LINE OF LOT 80, 115.00 FEET TO THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF LOT 80;
THENCE NORTH 55050'Ol" EAST FOR l51.0 FEET, FOR A POINT OF
BEGINNING; THENCE ALONG THE WATER BOUNDARY LINE OF JULY 1, 1975,
SOUTH 52003'34" EAST FOR 27.86 FEET! TO THE POINT OF TERMINATION,
S~ poi;NT LYING NORTH 48018'25" EASTj 103.0 FEET, OF THE NORTHEAST
CORNER OF SAID LOT 80.
"
The above legal description was prepared by Eric D. Kurtz, Florida Professional
Surveyor and Mapper No. 4163.
NOTE: (1) This certificate is issued without a title examination of all tidally influenced
land or tidally influenced islands bordering or being on sovereignty land, which have
been permanently extended, filled, added to existing lands, or created before July l,
1975, by fill, lying landward of the above described waterward boundary line, and the
Board of Trustees of the Intern.a! Improvement Trust Fund of the State of Florida may not
have any right, title or interest'"jn any of these lands. (2) The Board of Trustees of the
Internal Impx:ovement Trust Fund of the State of Flo!ida has not determined or verified
the riparian ~ghts lines of the applicant's privately owned uplands. (3) This certificate
does not c.onstitute a detennination by the Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement
Trust F~~bf tl,te' .s1:at~ c,lfFlorida, that the app1.i~t OWn$"~~ filled area' that exten.ds from
~pp~i~~t~:s l~ils'.~at ~ '~ediatt?lY ~pl~n~'o~'~~ :~~'o/ea; . ..' :
Packet Page -95-
_~l&''''
=-........,.
.. ... ....
....cns:s
=..=,.
.. I:""
_.....E:"
....aalt
c.a.n
=:u>8
::;;..c;;:
""
~=
~n
-0
=::=:
--
.... C'
:: .... ~
.... c:r ~
I>> .... -..:II
.... If -..:II
:oc:n
.. .. ~
=:5~
=50
~.... ::r::J
-= ..
iln
-<<1 0 c....:t
:-! ~
as 0 CJ'I
,. .... .;::a.
o
nn
~~~
n ~ Ci':)
t:--.. ..
.""
C:Cn~
gc:n
=...-
:c t.n
...
0:'4
::
n
==
-
-
-
....
C>
lrusrees .NO. ~V't/'t\..1',,,,,,')-.ll}
3/8/2011 Item 7 .A.
In Witness Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and have caused to be affixed hereto
the official seal of the Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust Fund of the
State of Florida at its office in Tallahassee, Leon County, Florida, this 2./?( day of
~,:!,2AEZY ..2005. . . .
, ., ;, ..
. . .:'.: '(SEAl;,) r,..
'./ . Board ofTf}lStees of the
. '! Intern.at IIi1Pr~vement Trust
: FUI;l.dofthe State of Florida
BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE
INTERNAL IMPROVEMENT tRUST
FUND OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA
('~~ l f. fL'l<1f;:-
(Typed or Printed N e of Witness)
By:
Te E. Wi . ....on,
Bureau of ey and Mapping
Division of State Lands
State of Florida Department of
Environmental Protection
as agent for and on behalf of the Board
of Trustees of the Internal Improvement
Trust Fund of the State of Florida
"J" ~ .~. .-
':'W'tJ1'- :, '~
: ;: ' '1. e~~
'. I .}
'.
,
/tJJ~UJ
wItness ()
ko6/n H~K
(Typed or Printed Name of Witness)
.
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF LEON
. The fQregoing instrument was acknowledged ~fore me this f2 { '7{ day of
t:"taSve4rL1 . 2005, by Terry E. Wilkinson, Chief, Bureau of Survo/ and Mapping,
Division of tate Lands, Department of EnvlI'Onmental Protection, as agent for and on behalf of
the Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trost Fund of the State of Florida. He is
personally known to me or has produced a driver's license as identification.
~~,\,~
L~ G..~.WUb'
'~Y.~4:.~ .
~(d cP:~.f 3o';~
;::~t~ .~\.
:: & 0 ~.
;;*:4 z -.._QtI..(I.*E
~~. ~ tOO372323 ~
~~. ~.",. It
~~;~-~~
~ ~..... ~.,.~
~IIII';;;="'~
APPROVED As TO FORM
& LEGALITY
State~oriDa~ K
Notary Public
(Typed, Printed or Stamped Name of Notary)
Commission No1J]) "3 72 ~2:;'
.
~.~
My Commission Expires:NoJ. 3'1 ~f3
Packet Page -96-
00
~
00
JI t!1
~
.., . liS
s
.
00 If
g
;:;::::
-_:.. dl
".,." &UP "
Itr
.1 I
i. . I
[i]
I
;1
I
I
-+-
__~_ 'IITt:.....-:J ;
(--,&~ ----{
I
I
Packet Page -97-
..
5 ~
~
2
III" I
Jil
I~
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
January 16, 2011
.
Nancy Gundlach., AICP
Collier County
Growth Management Division
Planning & Regulation
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
Subject
Response to Request for 133-foot dock at 39 West Pelican Street - Lot 81
Isles of Capri # 1 - BD-2008-AR-13142 (NG).
Dear Ms. Gundlach:
This letter is to advise you that my wife and I are the legal owners of Lot # 79 Isles of Capri # 1, and
want to let you know that the subject request for a dock extension does not appear to comply with
the decision of arbitrator Charles T. Carlton and final judgment execu~ed on August 2, 2005 by Circuit
Court Judge Daniel R. Monaco ( Case No. 02-1743-CA ) cancelling claims of purported claims of
riparian rights of all Defendants, including subject Lot 81.
I also want to state that this civil case ( No. 02-1743-CA) cancelled my lot's (# 79) and that of all
defendants (including subject Lot # 81 ) designated riparian rights as delineated on a survey by Trigo .
& Associate , and if the subject request for the 133 -foot dock is granted, it will not only conflicts
with the above described court's decision, but it will also impede and adversely affect my rights as legal
owner of lot # 79 and tax payer to have access to Pompano Bay.
I request that Collier County carefully review the legal responsibilities, and implications of Case No.
02-1743-CA, before considering this request, and as a Collier County tax payer request that you
advise me in writing of your decision .
Sincerely,
~~~::::)
l ~I - ______
-' ;
. .-
Rafael F. Puente
8230 N W 165 Terrace
Miami Lakes, FI. 33016
Cc: Collier County Government
Office of the County Attorney
3299 Tamiami Trail E. Suite 202
Naples, FI. 34112-5746
.
Packet Page -98-
-+-
~IJ
II --
I '"'f
.. '"'
. ~
[iJ
III
5 ~
~
m R
'I t!1
~
.., . I!;
s
[i]
;;"?=
- - :1..-
J1IIVU IUD II
Ii
I-
~
Ib
Ala:'
I
. ,
I
;1
I
/
_' I
___ "4:~
(;~~~ ---~
I
I
[i]
Packet Page -97-
il." I
~I
f I
~~
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
January 16, 2011
.
Nancy Gundlach -' AICP
Collier County
Growth Management Division
Planning & Regulation
2800 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
Subject
Response to Request for 133-foot dock at 39 West Pelican Street - Lot 81
Isles of Capri # 1 - BD-2008-AR-13142 (NG).
Dear Ms. Gundlach:
This letter is to advise you that my wife and I are the legal owners of Lot # 79 Isles of Capri # 1, and
want to let you know that the subject request for a dock extension does not appear to comply with
the decision of arbitrator Charles T. Carlton and final judgment execu~ed on August 2, 2005 by Circuit
Court Judge Daniel R. Monaco ( Case No. 02-1743-CA ) cancelling claims of purported claims of
riparian rights of all Defendants, including subject Lot 81.
I also want to state that this civil case ( No. 02-1743-CA) cancelled my lot's (# 79) and that of all
defendants (including subject Lot # 81 ) designated riparian rights as delineated on a survey by Trigo .
& Associate , and if the subject request for the 133 -foot dock is granted, it will not only conflicts
with the above described court's decision, but it will also impede and adversely affect my rights as legal
owner of lot # 79 and tax payer to have access to Pompano Bay.
I request that Collier County carefully review the legal responsibilities, and implications of Case No.
02-1743-CA, before considering this request, and as a Collier County tax payer request that you
advise me in writing of your decision .
Sincerely,
~--}
--:;-/
-- -L_<;;:~
/ j' - ...-/
/ ;
Rafael F. Puente
8230 N W 165 Terrace
Miami Lakes, FI. 33016
Cc: Collier County Government
Office of the County Attorney
3299 Tamiami Trail E. Suite 202
Naples, FI. 34112-5746
.
Packet Page -98-
.
.
.
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
Paul Hufuagel
33 W. Pelican Street
Naples, FL 34113
Nancy Gundlach
Collier County Development
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
-Naples, FL34104
Subj: Petition No. BD-2008-AR-13142, Schneller Dock Extension
Dear Nancy:
I am writing to confirm our conversation of 02/16/20 11 concerning the subject petition.
Listed below please find my comments:
1. The site map is incorrect A large plot of land lies between the plotted lots and the bay.
2. This land is not accreted. court records and photos from the 1950's show the contour of
the land has not changed.
3. Mr. & Mrs. James Hughes (their letter of support for the petition is in your file)
constructed the first dock extension over the land in question approximately 8 years ago.
4. Initially the Hughes attempted to gain possession of the land by means of adverse
possession. Apparently they did not complete the process because there is no record of
them having obtain Quiet Tittle.
5. In lieu of Quiet Tittle, the county record show Mr & Mrs Hughes apparently devised a
different tactic.
6. :Mrs. Eleanor Hughes used her maiden name which was Eleanor DaSilva to represent the
owner of the land with riparian rights and under that identity quit claim the property to
herself and her husband. To the best of my knowledge DaSilva had no property rights.
7. After Hughes was successful, at least two other lot owners built docks apparently
crossing land to which they had no deeds. Another land owner (lot 79 ) Puentes,
attempted to have a dock approved in 2005, that was stopped when the circuit court
ruled that none of this property owners had water front property or riparian rights.
8. All of this data is a matter of Collier County Public Record as a result of my quiet tittle
Packet Page -99-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
action for lot 78 in 2005.
9. The Trigo Survey was directed by Mr. run Hughes. Mr. Trigo testified in Circuit Court
that he was directed how to apportion the land by Jim Hughes.
10. Mr Puentes letter to Collier County and the Collier County attorney dated 01/16/2011 is
correct. The courts have denied riparian rights to all the lot owners adjacent to and North
of the subject lot 81.
11. It appears to me that the docks built across this land are in violation.
If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to call me.
Respectfully yours,
~IA -, r~O
pauIHufn~{f'-
Packet Page -100-
.
.
.
I
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
RESOLUTlONNO.2011-_
A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, RELATING TO PETITION
NUMBER VA-PL2010-739, FOR A VARIANCE FROM LAND
DEVELOPMENT CODE SECTION 5.03.06 E.6 TO PERMIT A
REDUCED SIDE YARD (RIPARIAN) SETBACK FROM 7.5
FEET TO 0 FEET ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 39 WEST
PELICAN STREET IN SECTION 31, TOWNSHIP 51 SOUTH,
RANGE 26 EAST TN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.
[COMP ANION TO BD-2008-AR-13142]
WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has
conferreq. on all counties in Florida the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and
such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and
WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (LDC)
(Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which establishes regulations for the zoning of particular
geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of variances; and
.
WHEREAS, the Collier County Board of Zoning Appeals has held a public bearing after
notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of a variance
from Section 5.03.06 E.6 of the Land Development Code to permit a reduced side yard (riparian)
setback from 7.5 feet to 0 feet, as sho'WTI on the attached Exhibit IIA", in the RSF-4 Zoning
District for property hereinafter described, and has found as a matter of fact that satisfactory
provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said
regulations and in accordance with Section 9.04.00 of the Zoning Regulations of said Land
Development Code for the unincorporated area of Collier County; and
\\/HEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board
in public meeting assembled, and the Board having considered all matters presented.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that:
Petition Number VA-PL2010-739 filed by Jeff Rogers of Turrell, Hall and Associates,
Inc. with respect to propert'j hereinafter described as:
Lot 81, Isles of Capri No. I, as recorded in Plat Book 3, Page 41,
of the Public Records of Collier County. Florida, together with that
portion of Pompano Bay lying upland of the 1.6' contour
contiguous with said Lot 81 as delineated on a survey by A. Trigo
& Associates, which is defined by a line extending from said mean
high water line and a line extending fTOm the northeast corner of
said Lot 81 in a direction of North 55 50'01" east to said mean
.
Schneller Variance I VA-PL2010-739
Rev. 2103f1 I
lof2
f
Packet Page -101-
I
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
high water line delineating the approximate limits of Riparian
Rights
Folio #: 52343040005
be and the same hereby is approved for a variance to permit a reduced side (riparian) setback
from 7.5 feet to 0 feet as shown on the attached Exhibit "A", in the RSF-4 Zoning District.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this
Board.
This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote this
, 2011.
day of
ATTEST:
D~GHTE.BROCK,CLERK
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
By:
By:
. Deputy Clerk
FRED W. COYLE, Chairman
.
Approved as to form
and legal sufficiency:
Steven T. Williams
Assistant County Attorney ~1~1 \\
Attachment: Exhibit A - Conceptual Site Plan
CP\ IO-CPS-O 1 049\3 5
Schneller Variance I V A-PL20 10-739
Rev. 2/08111
20f2
.
Packet Page -102-
.
<
c
...
~
o
.J
U.
<:
D-
r:
(
J
~ {.4/ i '1l :
(' - ~
~ ,~~
mft
ii: t
~
l::
u.
o
!q
..t~\.~
~~~'
~
I
~
U!~i
~gf
n~1
Ii!
::s
~
:e
~...~~.....,
.~Scr.~__~~______..
Packet Page -103-
?-
m
"I~ ~
;tii;,
-WI')
l$e:it
-CIJ
~zaj'
... cot w
i=u.....
-::is.
llllW z
u..
OJ
t')
I~
15
'in>
U
rt:j
w'
it
r~$,
1..J~
iol
tal
I-~
~5
ii'!'"
::>g
me..
-
UJ
Z
<:
o
::;1-
If~
~it
.,.... WZ
:g .::>0
.Qzcn
O~Ew
~macn
ll.liEc::>
lrn 0
w-o:!:
li)!::; ~ ~ z
~15 o. C5
t: ~~ ~ J
t.i!C;:!i ffi ~
~I"'" -I-
~!;;t5it(l'j
~X~<:Ul
t:iUl50CJ~
?lg~65
::110 i7! ~ -.
"I~ = 50S
0'1, I. .
.J
(
-
0=
lLI
<(
~
Z
::J
o
o
~
Z
o
ffiuj
~~
a::Z
;:,Q
u..i-
og
~/!;:
I-cn
-2
::fa
150
tl..c:
a:: 0
au.
lL.Q
W!!::
<2:
I1.lw
Gl-
z~
~13
~:z
~~
~,~ fE.
~r-<
~~
~ ~ !:!
~ 12 2 to
m~iJij ~
o ~ ~ :J:
~--CtGJ
8 ~ z
5
to
be.,
'<t'O
fg~
~q ;-
('o/m
z!;
~ ~~;;
:;~t! '
. ,. ~
iii~~fi
I ~ ~ ~ >>l
~
U
o
o
r! ~
W a
.J ~
.J 0
ill 9
Z
I
o
{!J
<(
I-
OJ
:r:
><
LlJ
ti1
to 0
o;:ll
=='!::
...-{!I
-z
!<a
-' ....J
(; 0
. bl.I~N
o=~~
..s.- '"' :f
0i~",
05"'1-~
-E! U ;:;! a
8~ Jf ~
<:0'3 U "'- ,
=-~
<::!3 ....'.
~!S:="" :
. 4i:..s~~
~..e,g~
::r::~r!~
- <a
::::l. '3 f" j
~..::i _
t::.E!.!
~~J1CM
~ ti\ ;;h
/.. -- ~
d~: \ No ~ .
"..,,-",<-- ="..'
r \.'.-i,~,/ r'~ I
'-1U ;. ,
/.... = i
I'.,~..., '. I\i -. <
\/'f'
A.. , 11.
i: ...~"..
>! 3/8/2011 Item 7 A
;..f i a,-. ..
~;:: I J!
I~~~~ lu I
i~e!~~5 ..
t;~m~t-m ~ III
i~!i!~~~i. I. ~! ~" ~
~ ~ !i2 m i" I ~ 6 ~. z ~
g::aZC'l a:; ~.- jj;
it~filX ~ it z
!~!11~~~ ~
~iol1l~~ffi~
~2S~:i~!~ ~ It I. ;;
aUl~~~~8! ~11i" ~
~I~;~i~~!! ~ II ~ ~
zO 00000 ~
O 00.
J:
o 11:
Cl e
It ~
rll. m
L!.s z
.J ~
.J @.
lU 8
Z ~
I t:i
o ril
rJ)
~
~
~
D.
\~
"\
\\
\\
\\
\\ Cl
\ ~~ 11 ~ CD
~~\1J l~
~~
>'t{~i
({i'~ :71:1
"'<tl...
~~
, \~ ...~
, \1 'i ...i., ~~~~
~,D~\ ~~ili
\ ~ \~~N .
. \'oq ~ <t .- ~ I-i~
~ \p. \:}'i'":.,)d
..... ),~, ~~:.'f,. .\ II~!
~" \~ Z..~.' i.).
~~ ;:\\'~"" ~ ;; ....;.\~ I~!!!~'
, ''''c. '? \ c;~. "-=. lil/:' q
a~ ~ \\':....1 ~{ ~ ~yi ill
8 co"" fsd'd'- .
== ~.,'!.\~:... . '\~;;! ~/ "',,::
. \'~.. -!o;:~ .'.. . ,.
~ \Yj7" 'i oj ~ ""
<: \ \~ _ ~ '\.. i~lI/
&:n \ ' ::1-" lil
o ' '.. ;j . . oj 'i.. :;j :{ ;;
:l! \\{ W:.~:j -'I
a.; . " ~ oj ~".
i!l '" Z ('\\."", · . '1.,.'1 '1'1'1
Q. co5cn _ \<~.~ ~ ~ V'
6 ~ ~ d \ \; ~ ~'~ ~.
..J~...J ~ \ },.:::,' \~-~.
/ -<~~ ~\ '!
~h ~~ ~\~~." \
_d~:: :::i . \
~ \\
c
S
U:t
N
~
\
\ .
\ -t
\ t
\~
'\
\
\
J ~
I
1, I
'. \
(.') 1-:
I.:) i <.!
~ ....,'..
I~:'l
5~
~8
'"
~
f-
a
P"IlE' ~
Ooot.~
DOOC~~
Packet Page -104-
8
....
9
dt\l).....C"C
.s -3 ~!f
~~~:t
-;;8;S;C;;-
"gJi JIi i
~g ...
<::;5
~.5 lZi ~
~:=.uo
~~~i'
s.-;~1[:
"i)'5i ;...
~~J~
{:::~\ :b
d~' -t(q ~
,..,.'1 ;;
....:'.' ~~,:;J
~~~/ i ..~
..'t'" I II:'
TO. ,~
,\ r", ~
\. f '\ t;"
~I ~
",,1. ."'.
f'",-..c::" j
"'.. ~
<<i
I-
o
-J
~~
~I ~~~~ .~.:;;,!'.I.~
'~;~'.J.",'; ~4' .\ ,....
r.JJj...1"ft .. I --,~;:
I ~ j~
... ,,_ .lli
~~-.rO:d(I~~
fSF..;.:.mI:O:X'~..l!!liIQ
.
, \
\ .,~~ \.
'""~"
\'I~;o'!.~ 'II
\ ~;:,
\\?\ \
V~~
....'" ,
,\:\ .
\ '\\~ '
, '~~',
',,~~ \
. \.
",%. ~
\. ''\ V ~~~
\, ~ \. ~I~ ~~II
, ~~~.\. \ Iffa:~
\ ,\ \. llll
\ ,~. 'V
\ (~ X/ x~~ -
\ ~~r; o~~~~
\ ~J' \. 1f~1I:;t:i
I~' ~:r~u1~
, 'Kq.... \. . .-l:i~ ~
\ \. \',;'?l. ~ II.
/".--.,....~. \ .... \,~. I \.
V"~
.. I '?ft... '\
\.( ~~, \. ~!
<~1;.. \ ~ '_E:boff
J 'i~'.i. , .... ~
'<;:..
/ \ ~, ~
"~~ ~
\ ~~~,
~~:{~;, t.~
y.~~ 'i;~t~ a: \.
, \~ 'tt-\..
,fJ.. .."').
\ ~.i::",.
- .;~\.
\. ';;.
\.
\
?:i ti:3/~/2011Item 7 A
~ ~ d tt is II!! -,OJ II' .
ffiwli CD ~ i' ... :! ~
uniJ~n lili !
~~m:iU~i~tQ
'~8;;~~j~ii
It!15-l!l~im!l .....
iffil~i~~;~J. -tii
;lduH~U I ~
~J;:;J:5~%;:)O::l~Q ..
i~i~~~~S~8~ Br,!I~
_Iw~~~o~~~~> S Ii. z.
~J~~~i~~~g~1 1~~~1
2:0 OOOOO^I=Cl1lr.l ~a5~1I
vOO ~ l-
t) 5
o S
o a
o
C! ~
w ~
.J ~
.J ~
ill ~
3:
Z m
T en
_ 0
U &
00 g:
Q till........,
,.a's S ~
"3...s: -
~- ~ S: ~
l!:f Q ;r. 0;:-
.$U-.l.~
g:i ... ;:
~If~
~.lS =l:8
~~!;
::::~ ~~
-- 8 < ~
en I e's ;. f'.
U! =- A ..
:: .c=:~ Ji~'
I ~ :,;.f', ...
w"'~ IX'
_. W. ;1 fe' \ ~ ~
~IE :;;. \"~,iIT :-::,. ~
;:i ~ .~.~ I .~
Qi< tL. !....If; i J.
~.g u) (1: /-~.F
~Iw u:. I. "'.1 ,,~,,;,
~~~ E ~:~ .-i i.
.,Ea:. <; Jl "'.
<:>:I!l") Z ,/,:, ,~ ~!j:!'
".~ Jj~
. .\
~
10
III
;::ll!
~~-
oo.~
~:z"'
S~f::
ll.~<
~~~
:f~~
~~~
~~~~
15~>
::iil~
~
a:l
o
Z
c::C
I!l.
2
o
a
o
t-: 0
o.~ ~5.J
~tD OW
:E iii ~ c::
Z (1) H:! IL.
:i~ w~
zl- mO
wZ ~x
wIU ~w
mC -a
wW :=w
>1- U)~
<OJ 0<:
:t:Uf -....
(t}::1 O:Z
~~ l/j~
.a.:W -Ie
~j!: i~
\.
\.
\
\
\.
\
\
\
\
\
\
'~\
\
\ i5
\ ~8
\. I~
\
\
\
\
\
\.
\
,
...
\
\
\
Packet Page -105-
#I
,(
~_ _:\-..... ,~'~ "c.. '^':'
., <41- .~~ ' ~ ',~ ,e;.. '~~.-~~
~'''l . #'. ...",_ ._~
\;1*
\
"
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
i . g Ii I~ ~-; w
mui~ ~ ~ il
~~~~" ~~. I,~
!55rn~g ~!!~ ~.. ~
~glilt:~~~~
~I q.gp8ior:tm Ilj!f CPl
ja:~~~~~i~ ~~~::-I)
II! ell J g ~ C) ~ '.~ ~ ~ ij ij ~
~~~~~~l!!~~~ &! ~ ~ ~ I
::;ra;im~i~~~~ ~
i~ !O(~~!~ s
zii~l~ ~o~mfii ~ ~ ..
lii3~ii~18~ ~ ~ ~ i i
I3lffl!!~~3~~~~~ ! I ~ ~ ~
5~c.<~a.g~~i=o:lrt.l B_5~.
1, >:.0 000000 00 :t
..,:~ ,I (J
-. -.,.r~ ' 0
...J
o ~
~ ~
W ~!
.J Q
..J ~
W ~
Z ~
I
~ U
(fJ
k ,i
ifrt
~Q~
~~~
ZL..J<
~I~
~.~~
m~~
'..l~: '~I..'..;:~ ~.~'.'.:'.
.0 ~ ,w ..
- =>
.~ 0 ~
l~ en :~:i u.(
.:~ ~.!K!f2.-,
~~I' 51
:ifi!i!.I~~; ,
-;~8f I~g
'~u.lt;I)~
.<~ 0<
.:rffi t:~
(/)... 0 :;;(
"01-5 .~~
Ll.. '..1
~ W .-1 C
~ :;: :,l~ z<
_!- "'I....
:
U
ii
,,-,
,; ~ ..-~;,
.~;
,'-
n-
j..,..
~. \.
.....:
.:.
"
Iii
D
II!
In
uj-
~
I>:'llID5<>I_-"'llilDCH!Ie.l.ER~_
Packet Page -106-
.
~
\ \.
\ \ ~ <'f
\ ~~ -<i "t
~.,. 'f \ .
\ "f\. ~ ~
\,,?~ \~~ ~ III
~ "! "f,,;ji' 'i
~ 1.'\ Ifl
, .~ .1:
~~~ ""'I
.,. ~~
. "":~\. ~'\~ q
.,~ ~
III \ , ,r-:
~ "'.e~",?\.. '=l
" 9 ...
; "'\0 ~!M~!S
-, \ .-~~,... ~=!"?q
~ \~.q~ ~~. l~~~
'<?~l
:i ~. .~.. '\ ~
. v_~~
<'f <'t:~q
q C C?,,~.,
":~~.J ~~~ .
dt 9~ a' ~ SF II:: W
~ '\\~!\~~.~ ~~~~ ~~~
d ~t..... ~.}.'?' <"l ~~g
\~ ~\~ ,~ ~c::
~ \~ ~~~ , ~
. Q \;:" .
'II; " ~.i< :L.Jr<....
C> ~1;".^
' ck' \?#,$ ::
~ "? 'Ill ~~ \.
II) ~ ~ tft~... sf
ci ~ ..\. c:t~i
~ - ~~ '.:;;<#'{;1':l I or; ,'J
~.ci ~1)"I;~.... "
' V\ ....(~'~i~~ ~ 'Q ~:ii
"} ~t~..'\~ C) .~~!'
'lI; :31ii!". N \. N c:: Q
~ -;j .~~ \.-
~e;.~q ~'- :J
.L ~.... ,~~~ ~~ .
..: "=, '" :.r;%" ~ '1i~ ;S
.,! '-l;;.;:, , .t~C') 1l~
,~ (~~... ~N ....;
~ .... \~i.. ~ f~~~..' ~ tq
N" <,!,,,:.,,,,. "t Cl
. ~, ~ - \2~~ wi-
~ .,;~ :.f~ -.: .
. :oJ ~ "'.~
.\ N ~.:"~
. ~"':;.;
~.. ~ ~.
~ ": \. '
,
;
l
.t
I
~
.1
i
i
!R
~-~
~
~
~1TI..,:.
[i1.' I
~i
~'1
;.;.'....Ii~
.'~i
J fr. :r
16
~]U
JI
ii1~ -
~:f.::I b~
::It..: .
'm. q
!i~&m~
""'If S
~
m.
o
z
<(
0..
:a:
o
a..
CD
"i
\
\
\
\
\
\
'"
~
loB
~
t~,..wQs.....~~~..=>~ro~~..Dic;
Packet Page -107-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
~ Ii ~ i
~ . d u. !
l5ul; : ~
m!~~fiJ ~ IS
~~fil~g g ~~
f;g!Ei~It~~~!
z p:: ~ .. ,r) C!I .... t CI
~liiw~~~~x~""
~8!~~~i~g=
=a:zw~~rll~i5
~~M~il~!~~~
!~i!~~~~lmi
C!I~o!l:lfial!Q~~~~
a:~~5~~~ij;:i~;:;
~Z:E~O 56:J <:
!w~ ~ [~! Q
"Iw~~_~;!;!~ ~~
~~o~lt~b....~g~~
o...~;d2o..l-g~l=lt)lD
;r:O oo~ooooo
eq
, ~
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
efu
Q...l
~!!!
~a,)
z~
-Q..
:eF-
Zz
Ww
l&~
~F-
<(I)
:rw
17)::1
bE
~w
~it
.
.
~~
~u.
ld~
111"-
~~
..J
-0
S:W
mZ
~~
o~
@~
..1.0
~~
.
,
,
,
\
\
\
\
\.
\
\
\'"
~
1
I
;...
tl}
ill
.".
>
l0-
W
tll <')
..~J.~ :::
~':"".~~,
t.:Slmi"-,;
..J Z I
ZI<ii:
~.Q uj
<t~~
:iJ.:f.l-
. '-10. ~
...O'J<'::
Ch (0) Z
j Q iil III
-~ S)
N
CI lit
~ ti iii III
!~~ ~
ftll/ II)
~ ":'1'= ...
i 10
Q <> !
~~ij
0. - - ...
-~~ l!:
~
}-
l-' ! I ...
,.: "
,.:" z
~5 g " 0
i:
~f ~ ~ ~
! ~ III
~ en
z
(j 0
f-
a <
CJ
0
C ..J
0
W
~ (f)
0
ill z
<(
.J C{) !
r
f :-
0... ,
-= l.!.!
W 0
Z ~
0
- ill
I CI)
-
() 0
a..
0
UJ ~
~
d 9P~""
.s'= ~!
~= 6 or
C'-I~_\D
o -""=""~
~8 ~;5
.~_ E.....;.
g.;:1 ~i;1
~~ ~ ~""-
<r' I::: ::<:
:.....:: ,
~~.t; ~ ~
=E:~~J
: ::!i~ "'>~
=~ ~~t
<"'! .
i --::- g ... el.f:.
IP'- ~Mf.
o.5! :,dl '
!e~ J1""J
I ~ .fil\~ :
..., .... .
.t;O; ... t!
.~:!_~l ~!
f <-..;'.."..",' ;:;.- .~. '
v',; J ;'"
-a~' 'r.:i I~~
.. ,L .. ~
~l~k~~,~, rg'~
f' ';...~ f. ",It. ~_1
I. 'h I "'~:"
V il '
I /:~.:, ~
,...,-...... E
t' '-'l ",;
~ Ii i
muJ~ ~ i f
~~o~... x g!i
~~~~~ ~ ~~
l!)gffiiZ~ri&~:~
E~ffi~a!:1i;~;
mS~j~~~~~~
Il.a:ra~a:~~~g~
t5f2~1~~:i!ll~8
~Iffi. ffia:~ffi~,~~
~ x !C:~~<~o...
~ ~~~~~~....ffi~
~i~~~lt~~~~m
~w~~~~~~~8~
~Iffi ~ is ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ ~
5~~~~:fggg;::ii
zoo 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 C .\.-.-
rf ^.~.'\
\ rfl.....j" ,<:"" .,
\ \~" l>/'~.
\: f ~ ....
, '. (
, I.
\ \.
<. ,---', \.: "
z \r \1 \0. \
o r. (-'\.ci '. '
~. .J. \~. ..l'.fili-. .::~.. .'......
~( - '" .~~ ~-'.:,
W --\" --~ .-,
co ~,('. -_.".,.
~ /' t -~ ~_ . "-
i/~~{ :-0" ,"-'
/' ~\ !' -: . '.-
",'~. " /. ) .--"
_ - "r'.l~ -
i )\-~._--
.)~/ \\) :-'\l~.: ..'-
I 1) Y-.,..',
! .tv \. ',', b
, ,r, <-, \ \ .0
,~~. d. ..",--, ... _
..' , \ _ ) f~ .:~.-; . __,.:;;'ot~ '":" f
\ '-. 1 ,!I .:'. ..
'\. ". i' ..:' --
(~~\~~\~- ,..:-' -.--
\ I ,'" -. . =..
i,L~ tt~~\ ~~~ ..
1 r"-~. '\ .. \ i..::"\ _~7~':;- -~
-".'oJ f'
~
~
~~~
~.{$X~"?'"
~~.
~
...
I ~ <'J-
~
a
I
~__~,Gf~.doc!
/:<.l ti I
~.., ., '.~
~!.~
';"
.;"~',
'(' o.
) ~m
~~
wS
~~
:::!o
:=w
'\ ~~
'< ~I-'
I ~~
~ UJ::!!i
~, ~ ~~
:;--:z::...-. ~~;;:i
''''' . ;..:<....~
- ' ~. i 12 t
"'-.. ' @~-'
:~ '1!,'~~ ~ ~
-a.
. U ::Elz
f:~ !~
~ffi
~=1
0;:)
",I.l..
c..W
~:t:
:-t-
<
( i
"
,~
t
'\
"
'\;
(,
tQ
ri:r
z
o
i:::
0'
W
(F:I
.;
:'111,,;;
_ ......... 4.~ ~t',
'.-.:-t
;
. t
\ ~.: ~.
"'~ "C.
) ,;~
1_','.
. .~..~
t~~ :}
f~~ ~
'OJ' .l
~-..~- i"~
lff~~
f--' ~s
, .:.... f
i' ci:
fO:;:!
. >-'J.,
...~~.~
_ J
. <:> "
I.,..:.!.
" ::; \
~ ~ -\
p'.~~
I ~:----~
fi .,
f': :.
"
I.
~-
'd"~
-
io
...;
I
....
ll'I
.
"7
i ~ ~" g
;1 ~~ ~
:t
o
o
o ~
C! ~
w ~
.J Cl)
.J ti
W [)
Z ~
-
.I-
o
(f)
.
,~
o~
Za:
1=0
<;.I..
z-
15
....<::
wz
0.-
0:=
.....ll:';
COJl..!
~....
~!<
,
"
..:.. u,,<~.~- ~........ .... .....
_.~
I
I
b
=i
-
0,,' 0;
) >~
~ '<, en,
z (, Z(
., ",,1
~\c:n
~ )~}
.... ,;...1)
~ ,::oi
j' ~l
" )
'_'::-...:. -~~~. :..:-\ ....
t~l
; "~!.'.'
.,J'
~.
"~
;1
.
.:;-
.bD~~
g..a ~ g;
--~ .
- ....
~~~:t
_5;;;;;:-
. caw.$:;
.u c; r;:: ~
~sJf~
=~it
-< l:l :z:
e aj':f
c:l;d.,... SrI e:
== i: .::; ~.
~t.Lic.:~.
l"=-~ ~~
P'5 if ~ '
t:: .;;:; .., .i:
IC~~'~:
~ .;)!\;:J;
l. \~ g
~i; '....,. ~
'" ; 1- "V
~! i' J ~
...~:l' [ ~
1-- ' ..
~. . ....~. ~.' i
';/ '\l~'
~: ..:
...\.... 'i;.
~--.or......_ if
/_'''' '....~ LI.J' ,
'e
\
i
Q
F-
er.
UJ
s:
f-
LU
wM
m!;r:;,=
U'il- v
.'. t ~ 1ft} ..,
J ri =~it
.1 "l' SUm
........'. S!", ~:J 111
,', .. r_~ w..J
." '. ... D. C.
. " ~ <:
;1 ~- ~~z
Packet Page -108-
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
~~~~n. i,. ~ Ii ~I~ 210 ! ~
:;;;z_~m~.~~_w ffiwi ~ .~ . *
"'" ~~ I11lnO~IJ3.'" .~~~ %
:i .,wl:) ~~:;iil@ g i! f~ ~ ~ ~
ffi~.~~ ~h~~~t:'~~~~
m~l~ffi ~~m:w~g~~~g
w~ z EI7l ot::,...~x ~
l~n.. B;< ~~liIu:i=.:I~O <<!I
I~m r=o~ wt)~~g~g~~ll:
...J ~< Cl.c:i(-la:~II2<:i;:S
rz IU~~ ~flg~Ii;~:i!!!2:8
w~;~QIo wfiHfi~~~f~~is~
~ & ~.. !l~~~~zz~t~..
II) !:CI)c::OO>:>r11:g
CJ ozw5l1Sl:':i~I1I~
. .'. " "1 ~ .. i ~ i) ~ ~ x .- ~ ~
.r'.. ~~~~~~f~~8~
.-.......~~.............i.;.'. if.i....5..~..'.~ ~IU U iu ~ d I
~:;~~~zo 00000000
.bC:~N
g..a ~ e
.:i:~~~,
,t!.s 0 ~Ei
; .S u ~ d. r.
l~ g:g [If ~
gs.. 5 -aL ~
<E:!i
6=~
~.l:l ~>o!
-:;..~ .
j~: "J~i
-~ -:;&,
== ""
~. ;i 81
t::.:sl ... ~ I
e.oe:Jj"-j
.. /~\~
~( .~ FJ
1>- . '1
~.'{l'{(rl
tJ.:_,-.t ~
\, ......\, g:
V / ":;'i'!b I
)'f ~
.- ,: ~
.;'1';' flt,.~ J: I
.'.'
i~
"t~.;
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
Jli~,.. .
'I' . .' f.:J.J.J '.:.1 I'I~!!'J'~
. ,) I <',":').
' ..,.;,.,."..; !,. .
'.' '. ;::,(~..,~, 1~;1 ~~='l ~,.;r
I'~">~?"W~~ .1 l.- ~f~ti~. ~
';,r ,. "; 't:i c~lI''t!~ 'j~.i
:-;,l..,., f';g~, ~!d~.., ~tl:Jf@ !!~
j:..... ...\~..t'. ..... ~;t~.;~$.~.. ~ "J'i.I.~.'.;:.R...".~....~1 ~!'I.j.;,':'~I~ <!If.-::';
:' "~~'< ~ ~)~!!Vu ffi 11~~I~ b t
!. ii .~~~~\ . t.\1. ~.;'.:;'.'.~ Q I.~.I.::J.. ..... a
i =~~il 1:1;1).. ~;!'."':~j'.'. .!il.fi~I.' m
~Ii _'" I~,r 'r mi'
. ;"1 ~ II ," .
l . ill Gilt;; .
rf~ 17{ Q.LJC l~"'~~~ fOJ>.
1- ~~; a1iS
t ~o
~;i ::;I
.!.J
,;,->
~-'";:
I! ~...
" ,.,,','," ',.,' .. . ~ . ;
...:_w-
Packet Page -109-
tl I:i e
-z~";;' <l
Q-2<i
. f;l ~ ~ -
i:i::~ :t
'" ... 9' III
., l'J i
~
.."
..,l'!
i~":
:i ~u;;
,.,:l~!z
1IIIII
~
o
o
o
~ ~
W ~
.J g
~:;:)
-! ...J
UJ u..
7
-
I
o
(fJ
__:4
/< ,
/ ;/x\(//
" '"
,/ //\/
". "'" /
/'\J/
/ /-\//\,
~"'" . \/ ,//
/~~ /y ~ ;J
" /' t~
/ w~
,/ ,/"'" Ii;
/X///\' " It-
/ ./ ,/
",. ./ ,/ -
~ \ /,/ ~~I:!~
./ ./ ~.;q
" /~./ H:~iil~
". /' <; ~
;' ,/ ,/
/- /' I .
,/ ~/ / //\
,/ 1/
/'
/' J' ~
/ \.& ~~
~ ~\
\
-~
\
~. r
~ i,li;
_'t:!
~~
~ " ...~ s, I ~
I :; &j
~ IE; ,
\
~.dov
~-~
Packet Page -110-
3/8/2011Ite!n ~ .A.
~ It: ~ ~ II I ~ ~
o ~ li! J... ~
1~;li ~ u I H ~
~1I!lhl';!!'N < _I.. ·
ee~~~~iill ~: ~J ~
~~;~~nl~5 ~; ~Ii i
Q, ~ ~ N ;= ... CD i 8 ~'iS
ffi~ffi~i~lm1~; ~
!~i!~~~~~~: ~..
~~~~~!~a:~~~!i ~ 'I ~ i i
~2""'~wg~\:,",....Q ii ~ ~ ~ ~
iil~ ~ g ~ g~, ~! ~ i I II ~ ~ ~
F=~i~l~r::ggF~m V
fio ~ooooooo ~
o ~
(,)
o ~
z
C ~
i-:-
~ ~
III ~
.J g
.J ~
UJ @
Z ffi
I ~
o 55
(f)
w
~
fa
en
z
..... :s
,z ;::
; 1:.l If j
~ l
' -f f
I
l
I
.
\
1 -ac'l"'J.,....
. g'En~ ~
{-""5 ~....
, ~[1 ;~~
-~ ~ t::?-
U!""'l ,.: ~
~ ~ .!d.,':
~..') ~ -;j7
<:;:: :~
2, ~~
~.- 1~O
- ~ :1~ ~
!! -a;:;.) ~; ~ ;
'., ~<"., ;.'-' eo I
,-:.-~~;aj
=.5 i-.J ~r
I' ;- E:~ +~
fa .:::I..o!. oZi -
::: r-,?:D; ;: f' ~
I {jjf \... i;' f
" ~I~i r~[/ t'j'
~1~ i ..:;:.~ .:~\ i
-I'"~ - ~ " < '.. "".
Q::! en ~ ~.': I ~~:.
I <',I.... ill I . ,... 1:
, ~I!g: r. y~ ~.
Ii .....,.,~ ~, t
f ~1"'J" j.. ....
.
\
\
3/8/2011 Item 7.A.
.
.
Z2D " ~ednesda,. February 16. 2oi1 . ,Naples Dd, N~WB
::;~~:-::'~-;~~::~'::::~~~'''-:~:::~"7.;=~~~''=.~-::~=:~:::;''::::;:.~:~~=:=::::::=:.=:::;:::;====-:=.==~=
.
NOTICE OFPUBUC HEARING TO CONSIDER RESOLUTION
., . .
Notice ,is hereby given that the Board of County Commissioners, as the Bo~rd 'of
Zoning Appeals,. o'f Collier County will hold a public hearing on Tuesday, March 8,
2011, in the Boardroom,' 3rd Floor, AdministratiEln, Building, Collier Coun~ Govern-
ment Center, 3299 Tamiaml,Trail East, Naples, Florida. The meeting will begin at
9;00 A.M. The title ~f the proposed resolution is as ~~lIows: ' .
A RESOLUTION' dF THE BoARD OF ZONING AP'PEALS Of., COLLIER CdUNTY, FLORI-
DA" RELATING TO PETlTlON NUMBER VA-PI.,2010-739, FOR A VARIANCE FROM
LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE SECTION 5.03.06 '.' " : . .." '. .. .
E.5 TO PERMIT A REDUCED SIDE YARD (RIPARIAN) SETBACK FROM, " . ' ,
7.5 FEET TO.O FEET ON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 39 WEST PELICAN STREET IN SEC-
TION '31, TOWNSHIP 51 SOutH, ,RANGE 26 EAST IN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA.!C-
OMPANION TO BD-2008-AR-13142] . .,.. . , .
. " . . '. -.'
f!. copy' of the proposed Resolution is on file with the Clerk to' the Board and ,is'
available for inspection. All i!lterested parties ar.e invited to attend and be he,ard. ' ,..-
NOTe: All Persons Wi,shing'to speak on any agenda item must register with 'th~
County Administrator prior to presentation of the ag~nda item to be. addressed. In:
dividual speakers will be limited to 3 minutes on any item. The selection of an indi-
vidu,aJ to sp.eak on behalf of an' organization or group is encouraged. If recognized
by,the Chair, a spokesperson for a group or organi~ation may be allotted 10 min-
utes to speak on,cln,jtem.
Persons wishing' to' have written or graphic materials includ'ed in the 'Board 'agenda .
packets must submit said material a .minimum of 3 weeks prior to'the,respective
public hearing. In any case. written materials' intended to be considered ,by the
Board shall be submitted to the appropriate County staff a minimum of seven da~
prior to the public hearing. All 'material used in presentations before the Board Will
become a permanent part ofthe reco~d. ' , ~," , 'l
Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the Board ~i11 need a rec~i-d' of'the
proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need to ensure that a verbatim
record of,.the proceedings Is. made, which record includes the testimony and evl-
. :: dence upon ~hich the appeal is based.' , ' , ,', -': .,' .
.. . . . .. .... . . . .- .
If you are a person with disability ,who needs' any accommodation' in order to, par-
t,iclpate in thiS proceeding, you are 'entitled, at no cost to you, ~o\ 'the provision 9f
certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Depart-
ment,' located at 3335 TamiamiTrail East, Suite #101,' ,Naples; Florida,. 34112, '
(239)252-8380; Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in
the County,Commissio~ers' Office: , .' . "'''.. ' .
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS'
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
CqLlIER COUNTY. FLORIDA'
FREP COYLE., CHAIRMAN.
'~WI~HT (BROC~ CLERK
, By: 'Ann'Jerinejohri, Deputy Clerk
(SEA~) , '
"
. .
i
.
. ." ~
~ :
Fpbrlrarv 16' 201; .
, '
No1889201
.
Packet Page -111-