BCC Minutes 01/18/1983 R
NI~l.t, Florida, January 18, 19R3
LET IT BF. REMEMBERED, that the Board ot County Commlttlon.ra In
and tor the County of Collior, and aleo acting aa the Board of Zoning
~ppeal. and as the governing board(l) of Iuch special ~lltrlctt at have
been created according to law and havlnq conducted bUBlne.. h.reln, ~.t
on this date at ?,On A. M. in REGULAR SESSION In Building -P- of the
Courthou~e r.onplex 1n r.a~t Naplos, Flori~ð with the follow1n1 p.r~on.
pre..nt,
CfI^mMANr
VrCE C"AIRMANr
Mary-Prðncos Kruse
Daviti C. "rown
John A. rl8tor
Frederick J. Voss
C. C. -Red- Holland
ALSO PRESENT, Willi~m ,T. R.a~an, Clerk, Jðm.. C. CIle., Plical
Officer f.llnor ~. ~kinn~r, ~~puty Clerk, C. William Norman, County
Manaqer Burt L. Saunders, County Attorney, Terry Vlrta, Community
Developnent ~dmin!fttr~tor7 Lee L~yne, Plana rmplementntion ClrGctor,
Nell Cor r1 11 , Public ;.~rcty Administrator, I<nute lIartman, Public Work.
Admlnint.r~tor, Don~lrl Norton, Public ~.rvic'l ^dmlniltrator, r~w.rd
S~ith, Assistðnt County Manager, Nancy rara.llon, Adminiltratlv.
!'ecrt'tllry to the BOllrri [HIe! h'llll"m ","cNulty, r.her1t!'. !:'epllrtment.
b~~~ 073 rACt 395
Pig, 1
".. -- - ..- - - - -.-
..~. - - ~ _..& '- _..~.. ..- -- --...~ - --
~{.~ ~.'" c¡. '.:'
! ',,;~:. I~~, ~..' ~~.~:'~"~ '. "";,It;\",~ .o'}¡¡'_, "~
t.,,··
t~.¡',::'
. ~~~~
---- - --- - - - -- --- - -- ----~::ry~p. ~m - -------71
bC~~ 013 PAGe' 398 ; :f~i
·."~i~r t'
i-..
~.;¡¥f:'
':;:i~?
Tape 11
It.. 11
ACENDA - APPROVED WITH ADDITIONS
Commilaloner Rolland mov.d, ..conded by Comml..loner PS.tor and
carrl.d unanlmou8ly, that the ag.nd. be Ipproved wSth the tollovSng
addltlonar
1. Proclð~~tion for Mias Colllor County
2. Proclam^tion for ~rs. Johnson, Collier County Pair
J. IteM ~n1 re Justice Center Construction ~ðnaqor Secretarial
Po sit ion
Item .2
PROCLAMATION rOR MI~S DENIRE RAWS, MIS8 COLLIER COUNTY _ ADOPTED
CommIssioner Brown read the Procllmation tor Denll' Haw., MI..
Collier County, and moved, ..condeð by Commi..loner Pl.tor Ind carried
unani~ou.ly, that the Proclamation be adopted.
Pig- 2
~
~
,..
~
-
..
......_~,,,._,"-,,.,..~=.,-,,..
~~~-----------_.._-_.._-------------------~~,
",-"~",..,,,,,,,«,^""""''''-'.'''' <~
. .-.- -- - .-- --.- -_. ..- _. -~ .- -~ - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - -
It.. t 3
M~K CY13 f4Ci400
January 18, 1983
PROCLAMATION FOR MRS. JOHNSON, PRESIDENT, COLLIER COUNTY FAIR AND
EXPOSITION - ADOPTED
Co~II.loner VOl. r.ad the Procl.matlon for Mr.. AUdrey 30hn.on,
pr.sldent, Collier County Fair and Exposition, and moved, ..conded by
Comm18alon.r Plstor, and carried unanlmoualy, that the proclamation be
adopted.
PIg8 3
~
~
-
0<_ ..'_..~~..._.........._......, .'þ__
_...._-_.....".__......".._.~-
" ~
-----------------------------------------
It.1II . of
bO~K 013 FACt~02.
January 1", 19E13
,~ .
'-'
;.'
'.'
CARNIVAL PERMIT 83-2, RI PETITION C-S3-1C, SOUTH FLORIDA BLUEGRASS
ASSOCIATION, INC. - APPROVED
j~?
·t~¡
~:~
"4
~..
'¡.;
III
,~.~~,...,.~;,
'It
....
"
Plans Implementation Director Layne explained that Petition
C-e~-lC is ð request hy tho South Florldð Rluegraøs Al8ociatlon, Inc.
for a Carniv~l r~rmit to hold a AluegrasÐ Festival at Everg]ade8
Con8~rvatlon and !'portsman Club, Inc., on Februðry 11, 12 and 13, 1983,
add1nq thÞt the pfttit10ner has met all th8 requlr.mtnts an~ that tho
Ochop.. Fire Depart~ent has been notified and will be available and
.,.~
" ~
'-:1
<~
"
,j
th"t the Sheriff's Departmont haa aho been notified. She salð that '.
atat! recommendn ðpprov~l with the licenao !~~ to bo waived. Pespond- "
inq to Commissioner rJfttor, ~8. ~yn. laid thnt, this year, tax exompt
organizðtions, who will not have rides or concessions, have had the
Occupðtionðl license Ceo waived.
,
ó.',
Co~mla.ioner Rrovn ~ov.d, ..cond.d by Commlsslon.r Voss and
carried unanimou8ly, that Carnlvll p.rmit 83-2 for a Blue Orl..
F.stival, February 11, 12, and 13, 1983, be approved for the South
\
'.
~
,
Florida Blue9raaa ^ssoclatlon, Inc.
,..j
t
"
~"";1
!
,\
"',
;~
';'(
')~~
!~:
,:;,:;
':~~
".~'
,}
. ~?
.
.'1
;r
..------.--- - .----
'aCJe 4
c:::ID
lIB
-
..............--.-- --- "-"('~" ..~.. -_.. .-..-.-...._!<r-.. ,.,_~__.,.,......._ _,., "
'".' ...~~.~".._..-. -.
Item t 5 eu:~ 01~ FAGc·...04
January IP, ]CI~"!
rINAL ACCEPTANCE OF WILLOUCHBY PLACE SUBDIVISION _ APPROVED, PUBLIC
WORKS ADMINISTRATOR AUTHORIZED TO RELEASE ONE-YEAR 10' MAINTENANCE
SECURITY (IRR!VOCABLr. LETTER OF CREDIT NO. Rl-~ 'ROM CITIZENS NATIONAL
BANK IN THE AHOUNT OF S~,023)
Public ~orkn ^dmJnlstrntor ~ðrtmðn stðtQ~ th^t the developer of
th~ Wlllouqhbì' Pl~CQ ~Uh~ivinion heø correct~d the Minor doflclencleø
in the development ~uring tho mnlntenance period on~ he r.co~mendeð
th~t Flnol Acceptance be npprovø~ for the project.
Commll.ioner Arown moved, mecond.d by Commi..loner Vo.. Ind
carried unanimously, that Final Acc.ptlnce of Willoughby Place Sub-
division be approved ðnd that the Public Workc Administrator be auth-
orized to re1eðAe the on~-year lOt ~alntenance Security (Irrevocabl.
Letter of Credit No. 81-9 from Citizen. National Bank in the amount ot
$(>,021'.
Item 'f,
FIVr.-YE~R SECONDAr.y ROAD rnOCnAM - APPROVEO ~ITH NO NEGOTIATIONS or
CHANCINr; L^TER
COmml~5!on~r ri~tor nnt~rl thnt ther~ WAR no ~~ntjon of E.~. 9~' In
the rxecutivc ~umm~ry rl~tr~ l/IJ/p) rC~ðrdin1 the rlv~-Yeðr necon~ary
Roa~ rrn~rð~, howQv~r, hr fl^ld hc felt th~t fður-lanlnq F.". a~) was
one of thr. 1I',0~t Inportnnt ¡ t.ems in the County and thnt h. would not
Ukr' to conr.dt IT'ðnpy until the S.fì. nfjJ '!I1Ittor Is øettlN', which h.
~nt¡cjplltQr. occurrin~ in th~ nftxt three months. Chðlr~an Kru8~ laid
th^t If there 1~ r. c~s~ of rrJoriticft, th~ proqr~m could bo chan9.d, to
which County M~n~~cr Normnn ønld th~t ~clly Rnðrl I. the lalt it.m for
whl~h funds will DP IIvn¡ln~l~ for threr. yoarn nn~ that any chAnge In
prioritics ~oul~ h~vc to ðCcur b~for~ th~t contract is let. Comml.-
paqe 5
.,- ....-... ... ...
~~~^~
..
.~-':""~If ..--..
-_._~
¡
.
i!!
January lQ, 19~3
aloner Piøtor said he felt that S.R. 951 11 more Important than Kelly
Ro ad.
Public Works 'Adminlstrator n.rtman said that 110m. of the qas tax
mon.y 11 budg.ted to fund s.veral bond. Ind that the mon.y tor thl.
proj.ct i. what i. ~nticipðt.d to b. l.ft bas.d on oxpens'l. He laid
the program has boen reviowed by the Fllcal Offlc.r.
Commis.ioner Brown moved, second.d by Comml..loner Rolland, and
carried ./1, with Commi.sioner Piator oPpos.d, that the Flv.-y.ar
Secondary Road Program be approved with no anticipation of change at a
later tille.
Pag' 8
b~~K CT73 PACt'-40S
\
:-----.--.----- --.-.... -. ----.-------------------
,"...,..""',".....,........,-,.
--...-....
. "-'"'''"'''"''''''''_'_n_'''~"_'''~'~'"'_<'_'''''
--- ------ -- -- -.- - ----- --- ---------------- ------......
'!.
Item t7
&J:J~ 073 PAGt,uZ.
January 18, 19~3
FINAL INTERLOCAL SERVICr. AGREEMENT FOR FIRE PROTECTION, GOLDEN GATE
FIR! CONTROL AND RESCUE DISTRICT - APPROVED
Public Safety Administrator Dorrl11 explalnod that the Executive
Summary dated 1/l3/8~ outlines the InterJocal Service Agreement for
firo protection in the r.old~n Cate Fire Control and nescue Ðlstrlct
which is ess~ntially the same ð9reement that the BCC approv.d Nove~ber
'3, 19A¿ and that provides nn initial payment to assist In estahlilhlng
the DIstrict in an a~ount not to exceed approximatoly $19,000.
Respondinq to Commissioner riltor, ~r. Oorr111 said that oxpenditur.s
will b~ mðd~ !n the name of the Golden Cate Flro and Rescue District
anri thllt thl' District wJ] 1 hav~ it! own bank account, addlnq th"t the
County 1n merely r~I~~urBinq the Diltrlct for leqltlmðte costa incurr.d
Cor the hen~fit o! th~ r1£trict each subaequent months and that payment
will be reculved and paid out to vondors prior to relmbur.ements being
madr by the County. lie sðJd thllt the contract state. that, ahould
expenditures exceed elth~r cash on hand In th~ fun~ or tho authorized
budget for this fiscal y~ar, the County will not be responsible. He
sðld he felt that the District ia aware of thil and that he has spoken
with the Chðlrm~n of the OJstrJct and the Fire Chief, adding that
-things will be very tight- this year.
Conmis.loner Voss moved, ..cond.d by Co..i..loner Pi.tor Ind
carried unaniMously, that the Final rnt.rlocll Service Agr....nt for
fire protection, Golden Gate Fire Control and R..cu. Diatrict, be
approved.
P.g. 7
..--- - - .-- - -- -_ ._4--. __ ".__ ,._ . ~_~
-...- -_. -.. _.... - - .-- _. -. -~- - ,
,~
-"
f.!ig
..
ff:"~,"'~ ". ""..-.~."",~~,,, ~ ......',....,..
~~1"~"' Jl ~
W:",'":ttf-/t '~~~~\rt-f\" ,I~~''':-:J ~,,...L .!..,'io'~ ..,'J"¡+"f\~~"'.""'~
, ~:I
~"t\'
;>~1
.,..' ~,
,¡h..;
- - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - -- ...--- -----___-..1
, '.;~
f'." ,
'OJ
! ~~ '/
---.---------
~OJK 013 FA~t.t16
January Ie, 1993
Itell t8
BID .622, BUSH noe MOWER FOR PUBLIC WORJltS - AWARDED '1'0 CREEL FORD
TRACTOR, FORT MYERS, FLORICh IN THE AMOUNT or $2,495
Legal not1c~ having been puhll8h~ð in the Nðple. rally News on
Novemher 19, 198' as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication filed with
the Clftrk, hlds were t~kon (or Bid fr.22, for a Bush Aog mower for the
Depllrtment of Puhllc Works until ,,30 P.M. on Oecembar 15, 1902.
Commissioner Drown moved, aeconded by Comml..loner vo.. and
carrieð unðnimoualy, that ~id f622, for a Bush Hog Mower for the
Department or Public Works, be awarded to Creel Ford Tractor, Fort
Myers, Flcrlda, in the amount of 82,495, a. r.commended by the
Purchasing Director ft. being the lowest reaponsible bldd.r in the be.t
Interest of the County, and that the Chairman be authorlz.d to 81gn and
the Clerk to ðtteftt the resulting Igr"II.nt.
Item '9
ADVERTIS!M!NT or ORDINANCE 'OR FEBRUARY 22, 1983, RE BASIC GUIDELINES
or PERSONNEL ADMINISTRATION - ~PPROV!D, WORKSHOP ON PERSONNEL RULES AND
R£CULATION SET rOR JANUARY 25, 1983
Assistant County Manllqer Smith .xpl.ined that staff haa been
.n9~ged for Some time in revising the per.onnel rule. and r.qulltlonl
as outlined in the Executive ~umm.ry dated 1/14/A3.
Chðirmðn Yruse Raid that the holiday schedule of eleven fixed
holidays, the sn, tuition refund, .nd the runeral lellve ar. thr.e tt.n.
with which she has prohlems, noting that she like. the ldel 0: a
floating holiday and thllt ahe would rather see 100\ tuition retund.
~h. said thr~e days for (un.ral l.ave might cr.ate a problem.
Commissioner Voss laid h. t.lt that a lupervlaor should Ipprove
the (loatlng holidllY ðnrl he reque.ted that Itaf! look Into r.l.buralng
PIge 8
- - - - - - -.- - - ---- .... - .
,"'.~ ~"""'-'''''-'''",""_..,,,. _·.'~"P"'N~..' .'.
- - - -- -_.. - -- - -.. - - - .. - - - - - - - - - - --......--- --. --' ......'~
~..,....,
~
-
-
,,_i.:~·~:-r~···<),." ",~ "
~1iIII
..
"1'..-.,.....
January 18, 198:1
employees Cor unused sick leave. Comml."inn,.,. "n11 l",=, :...id that th.re
are two idua to the point ot r.lmb..'rstng sick leave, ðddlnq th.t a
person might come to work who ts no~ phyalcally ablø rather than lost
the tine.
- - - - - - - - - -- ~- -- -- _.- ..-. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -....
Aftor IS short t.liocussion, It wa. the consenSUB of the Commll-
.
',::;~
'P~
",('?>
,. .
.~ .
, or;,
n
,;
. ~~...
~ !~- ..
\,'"
, ;,1-
. ..~'
eionora that t.he Personnel ~ulos and Regulations be workshopped on
Jðnuary '5, 190J. Commllaloner Vo.. mov.d, I.cond.d by Commlø.loner
Pl.tor, and carried unanimously, that advertisement of the ordinance
for February 22, 19R3 re ba.ic quldellne. of Personnel Administration,
be approved.
Commi~slonor ßro~ said he would like the Personnel Department to
have IS øtronq part In ~evelopin9 the Rule. and nequlatlons.
Item 11 0
SECRETARY II FOR JUSTICE CENTER CONSTRUCTION MAN~GER _ EXEMPT FROM
HIR rNG f'R EEZE
County ~~nðq~r ~orm~n explained that there will be ~ vacancy on
.January :n, 1~/ 3 of " Secretary II tor the Justice Co"tl)r Confttruction
M~naqer ~nd he ðsked authorization to replðce th~t position.
Commissioner Pi.tor moved, .econded by Commls.lon.r Vo.s and
carried unanimously, that the S.cretary II position for the Justice
Center Construction Mðnagor be exempt from the hlrlnq tre.ze.
Itom III
'.':.
CHAIRMAN AUTHORIZED TO SIGN THE PROPOSCD LETTER OF RESPONSr TO
SECRETARY WAL~CE ORR Rt CETA OPERATION TO FACILITATE PROVISION or THI
JOB TRAINING PARTNtRSHIP ACT (JTPA)
Public Services ^dministrator Norton referred to the Ex.cutive
.:'t'
,~~
~~ :~~,
;. I'l
,'.j"
bO~K 01S rAGc-411
Summary dated 1/1?/R1 re~^rdlnq the Joh Tralnlnq rartnerBhlp Act
(JTrA), "dd!nq thðt the r.ET^ pro~ram will be replaced October 1, 19~3
paqe, 9
... '- ..- - ...- - _.~ -.... -- .. - -
--_.__._----------_.__..._-------~~~
...-.-,....... _...._~. ......-- .------...-.--...---,
"'__"'0.'>,.'·,
----- ----- -- -- - --- ------ -- - - ------ ------
~o~~ C113 fAI.~1a
by ~.~_w pro,ram presontly beln~ atructured ~t the r.tato levol.
January IP, l~A~
no
said that th~ Gtðt~ is reque.tln~ that the rountieø ~Iv. ~uld.lin.. anð
that Some altcrni'ltives h...vo boon studiec1 in Collier County's case. ftf!
said that h~ talk~~ with ~ Stato official req~rdlno th~ possibility
th~t Collier County becomr a Sorvlco ~rlfv~ry ^re~, however, that
person sðld thp StÞtc Is looking tor an Dre~ closer to tho populfttlon
of 7.00,00n ðn~ would probahly not approve thet de.lgn~tlon for Colllor
(I,
·;·h·
:'''~'i ).,
¡*.,
'~~i'
~. J,.
County.
Commlønlonl'r Holland rnoveð, leconc1eð by Comml.8ionor rlator and
carried unanimously, that the Chairman be authorized to sign the
proposed l~tter of r~sponse to a.crotary ~~llace Orr re CETA op.ration
to facilitat~ provision of the Job Training Partnership Act CJTPA).
Item .12
ACENDA pnrcf.S ^~ PROPOSr.n - APpnOVtD
CommissIoner Hollftnc1 moved, seconded by Commis.loner Brown, and
carried unanimously, that the Aqenda prlc.s, al outlln.d In the
Executive Summary dated l/12/83 and let out b.low b. approved.
Packal1. -^"
I°J:l"-I~A.
$'in
(Ñ7endll on 1 }')
PlIckftof' "r"
~1'~
(Aq~nda ~ £xQcutiv~ Summar i..)
Packagc' "r"
t22t'
(A~endD , ^11 backup m~t.rlal)
- -- - -- - -'" -. - ...~- --... . - -"
~
..
........._~.._,,--_....._..,. -,.,~,.~,. -~, .......-- ,~
......' .......'"....."
...,~..,.---"
_,..~o',______.,.
~,
' ,
~;
It."
·ft
.,.
If
.!
'\1¡~
,:4,
- - - - - - - - - - -.. -- -- -- - - - - - - - - ~a:u~ry ~s ~ ~9~3- - - - - - - - ~ ~~;tJf
" /.f~·
'l¡'iK
It.m 113 '~~~~~!
,.i~;:',~. ~:'
. ¡ ~:'''N'
ROUTINE BILLS - APPROVED FOR P~YM!NT ,"0i~,1
purauant to Re.olution 81-150, the t~l1owing ch.cks were hIlU.d"'¡,.,,
,"/
, ~.!¡. ~
through J"nuary 14, 19B3, In payment of routine bills":~~;;;
CHECK DESCRIPTION CHECK NOS. AMOUNT;
Voucher Checks
C\131;~
91771
<!t2,320,dI;A.3S
~ 225,72n.49
Regular Payroll Checks
5~9n7 - 5941"
Ite~. 114 through t17
BUDGET AMtNDMENTS 83-212 THROUGH 83-215 - ADOPTED AS DESCRIBED IN TftE
AMOUNT SHOWN
Co~mls.loner Brown moved, seconded by Commlasloner Rolland and
carried unani~ously, that Budget Am.nðments 83-212 through 83-215, be
adopted ~a described in the amount ahown.
Budget Amendment R)-7.12r
to provide (undo for statutory salary
an~ related benefit incre~se ot Guper-
visor of Elections (Coneral) In the
amount of ~3,O~~.
Budget Amendment ß3-213.
re transfer of funda froM r.~uldr
salarfoa to provirl~ tor ~xpenditurel for
two tel~phoneft and the purcha.. of a
typewriter for newly dey.lope~ Water
~anag.ment n.pt. (W~ter ~anQgom.nt -
Op.ratlnq) In the ~mount o( S2,SOn.
BUdget Amondment A)-214r
to provide funds for Clerk's r~cordlng
fee. tor de.ds, easr-menta, etc. (County
Water 5ervlco) In the amount of ~1,nOO.
rð ~mendment of Fleot Management budget
to purchase a hasø radio tor the repair
shop at the County narn (Flo.t Manage-
ment) in the amount of SU4.
Budget Amendment 83-7.15r
"
b~~~ 013 PAI.c~
'aql
...__..._----.._-.__.~-- --.- ....- -
,
_ ._ _. _ _ _ __ .._ _ _ _ ....._ _ _ _ _ _ .._ _ _ __ _~.:',;:r
--...__.._--~. --- -......----.--....-.-... ,-~
_._----------------------_._-----~¡~
&O~K m PAGt'-424
'18
DISCUSSION OF C~RROLL PROPERTY ON SHELL ISLAND ROAD, SPEAKERS HEARD
CONSIDERED AS AN ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL TO MR. VIRTA'S DECISION.
COMMUNITY DtVF.LOPMENT DIRECTOR DIRECTED TO GIVE MR. CARROLL THE PERMIT
~T THIS MEETING
January 10, 19F!3
Commisnioner VOGS said that he asked that a ~IScuD81on of the
Carroll property on Shell Island Road ho plftced on the a,endQ b.cause
he WðS curiouR as to when the two houses were going to be built.
Mr. Ernie Cørroll explained that he intends to conatruct the
houses when h~ is rin~nclð]ly able. Relponding to Commissioner VOI8,
Mr. Carroll said that ðmplp opportunity hal been afford.d the persons
with who~ neqotJatJons hnve been conduct.d regðr~ing his offer to make
an even trade of propvrty and to help .elect a site. Ho said that hiA
ownership of the rror~rty ha~ never been commercial and that, should
waterfront property b~ found ot equal value, ho would be interest.d In
a trarlf'.
Tape '2
Respondinq to Com~issioner Piltor, COmmunity ~velopm.nt Admlnl-
strntor Virta stated that the property owner could build one unit per
(ive acres of ownershJp, ðdrlJng that County approval Js for develoPMenl
in ·ST· and thnt any further developm.nt beyond the roadway would
require further ·ST- ðpproval. Mr. Carroll said that the property il
legally ðeDcribed as ~o land acrel and that the ar.a upon which the
houses would be built is approximately 3 acr.a.
Commissioner Brown moved, .econd.d by Co~I..lon.r Holllnd, thlt
the road permit be granted. County Manager Norman said that he was not
sure that a motion to qrðnt the road permit WIB appropriate. Chlirmln
~rUB. ~.k.ð it tho road permit has be.n grant.d to which Mr. Vlrta
responded negatively.
. ., .; ,~."
- --. - -.....-----.-- ----.-- --------..............
~'l
1&
-
),~'#,~;t:,'~, . '.. 'r...... .._'"','~.~ ~ "
". ~ - - - - .- - - - ~- - --- - - -. --. - - - - - -. - - - - - -- - - --.. --..
January Ie, \!)n~
The following persons spoke In oppoBltlon to the roftd parrnlt.
Mr. T. II. Balow, National Audubon Socl.ty
Dr. ¡(ri. Thoemke ;nookery Bay Sanctuary
Mr. aernie VQkel, The Conservancy
····Com~i..ioner Holland l.ft the room at 9.45 A.M. .nd r.turned
at 9r48 A.M.....
Commissioner Voss Baid that h. Iympathiz~d with the qoall of the
conservationists to porservp. the area, however, the Board cannot
arbitrarily deny ð person the use of hi. land because that nmounts to
confiscation. County ^ttorney Saunderl advls.d that, ~t thil point,
there has been enou1h testimony from the speakers 80 that the Commls-
nloners could consider th~ Individuals as filing an appeal to the
/1ftciaion of the df'pðrtmont that illluftd the pormlt. FIe 8"id that the
Commisnloners would have to base their d.clslon regarding d.nying the
permIt not only on the information proYlde~ by the appellantø but on
tho information provided by thf' department, addlnq the tact that the
orn ~nrl Corps of Enqineerft h~ve !ssuod pormits. ~e pointed out that,
10nerally ~peðklnq, when th~ nr.n Issues permits in areas that are
.'qulItic prel'or\lofl or IHOllS within Outstandln1 florida Water., the
aqulltic prosorve rules "nd tho rule. and re~ul.tion. dealing with
Outstanding Floridð Waterø are ~.nerally considered hy the DER, adding
that there is no evidence that this rlld occur, but that he felt that
tho Commlssioner~ can infer that nccurreð by the fact th"t the permit
was Issued hy tho T'.'F:R. fIe slIid that if the Commissioners teel thore 1.
not enough evidenco to concludf" th"t there would be Ion'1 term
onvironmental rle~r3dðtion of the area the appeal can be ð.ni.~ and tho
permit Issued.
"Ip. . 3
CommiRsioner Orown 8ð1d ho ~id not approve of the County
Attorney's advice, ðd~inq that, it a qroup wantl the land, th.y should
b.rt~r for it leqally ~nd in " manner which i. r..pectabl. and that
0'13 ~ACt'Ø
biJJ~
PIg8 1~ ,..r::.,ç'
. ..~";t"/~'r{
.- ~-..- - - - - - - - - - - - - -.... ---'..,~'.:"",..~..
¡
'.:ì~¡fJo
, :¡'\~[,i·.
.~~i~
" (,.~P';t
. ',;,~~t;
.",~;.;~~(~,,~ I>
, '.""
ri··~""'_ _ _ _ _ __ __.. _ _... _.. _.,
,~~.:~,;
- ..-~.. -- --
.~~~~..,~~:\\ .,{~:, ...~/ ,,\,"~'~:1.'tt
,),,,,' '
''''I.'! If 'fI'''' I"
----_ __ ø_ ____ ..'___.________._._.__._ .~.
Ô~J~
CY13 PACt'~6
-- -- - -- - -- - - - - _ _ _ ~1~
~)"
,·It;
January In, ]n~~
would h~ the only way h~ would approve or It. Aospondinq to Comml~-
sloner 1101111 nd , ....r. Yo k e 1 Bille:' thllt neqotllltiona h""/C? hf'on 901ng on
since: carly 19r1 IInc1 that when the apprltl!'1l115 came:! in, the vðluc of thð
property ch:lnqcrJ. ~I r . t:o rmnn 1101 1 rl thnt, bt'CðU!lC ~t^t(t funds tire to h..
usctd for the purchðs~ or the property, the lan~ hðd to he npprðlsed.
Comrllaslonr.r 11011an1 lId" hI:' W,1f not in r",v(')r or i!('nyil'l~ the øt)oplc tht'
USC' of the lanrl an~ h~ t1id not lik~ thr f~ct th...t th~ nituotlon haß
heen held up ~~ lonq. Chnirmrn rrucct ø...l~ nh~ c1i~ not ~~ree thðt thC'
,
,
m"ttcr hc!on":; he-fort' tht, Dec.
r,~:q:ondln'1 Lo C';')!!',¡dsr.1onpr "oø~" P1r. ("',,::-rol1 ~ð1~ thl'tt he lntp.n"r,
to huiH the' rOð~' !rr\"'O~iðtO]Y to ('Jilin acc.Sf" to tht uplant1 whfch he
wants to LJS('. fin fõ"l(' t.hllt hI' hllf, r('spClnde" to roll th(' or<:1"nlzlItionr.
who hl'lvr \oJrittt:'n tc ~in oPPo!1inq the roðc1 onet cxploincc! thlJt, lit th"
timC' hc ~irr:t I'Ipµlic-: lor the porrllt, h", contllcter! Mr. DilJ Oherhelml'n,
of thr Collier County Conservancy, and asked hln to Come to the prop-
orty ~o h~ coulrl t~JI h1~ ~~ðctly whðt h~ int~n~ed to rlo with th~ l~n~
ðn~ thðt ~r. Ohcrhc]m~n brouqht !ernl~ Yokol and ~rls Thom.mke with
him. Hr. c~1~ th~t a ßtðte~~nt r.~nrdlng hi~ Intention of puttln~ a
road through to !1ðln ðCcftSII to the hlqhland to hullð two homes Wit,
printed on the permit npplicatlon. Ho tðld th"t several monthc aao h~
told Attorney Ji~ ~rlaht, or the DNR, that If something wal not done by
~QPtemb(!r l~r.', tIe w/)s qoin". to utllizI' the property. HI!! reVleWf!'c1 thf'
backgrounrl of Invcr.tiqatin~ several pi~ceD of limilnr proporty [or ~
p08sibl~ tr~rlc ~nrl sal~ thllt tho mont practicel piocr w^~ foun~ to also
h~ in the Dcqul~ltlon are~.
~r. CðrrolJ rcnrl 0 l~ttcr fro~ Governor Craham addressed to Mr.
Chnrlen Lee, vice President of tho Florida Audubon Society, in which
the Governor rr.frrred to the Corps or F.nqtnef'rs pfllrmit issued to Mr.
Carroll for ~ pro;ect which con.18t~ or ð S2S foot Ðccesa rond from
Pit., to 1 f
- . . .~.""
!T.'-'-J
..
-
"\. .
.A¡~~."
--- - ----...-- - - -- -- --- - -------.-.--- ----,----------------.'
,
January 1~, lQR~
Shell Inland noðd to ~ 1.5 acres upland hammock near Henderlon r.r..k.
iLott~r not received for the record). Mr. Carroll said that the
Covernor's lottor oxplalned that the proj.ct, a. proposed, would have
Minimal ðdvor~. envlronm~ntal impact, that the road would be r31..ð nne
Loot, that five 12 Inch culverts would be Installed to enlure normal
w~ter flow thðt npproximlltoly l/lOth acro of mangroves ~lon~ tho road
would be romovedr that on July l~, l~Rn, tho nER issued a Notice of
Intent, that no r"quests were received for lIn Administrative "'taring
and the road permit w~s lø.ued ~uqu.t r., 1~qn from the OER. ~r.
Carroll said th~t r.ovcrnor r.raham's letter explained that, by Letter of
Undorfttandln~, tho D~n ðctØ (or the stato rogardinq Corpo pormlttlnQ
applic~tlon5 nnM th~t ~n öb1ection to the ~pplicatlon by the r.ovornor
would have the e!{~ct o! nullifying tho State Corps' .~re~ment on
nredq~ nnrl Pill Permlttln~, that the Covernor strongly supported the
Rookery ~ay rstuðrln~ Sanctuary and that he had ur~ed expeditlou. and
complete ~c~uln1tlon of the r.anctuary, but that he felt it would be
patontly unfair to Mr. Carroll for tho State to issue him a permit and
then ohjt'C"t to hl~ rl'c('lpt of ð Corps pormlt, IInd that, hy r.'oPy of hi.
lettor, he W~8 ð5klnq the nNR to giv. consltieratlon to a land change
with ~r. Cðrroll.
The followin~ perRons spoko In opposition to tho road permit.
rr. Arm~nd ~. Opponhelmer, Collier County ~udubon ~oclety
r..,t Ware
,John R. Oppc.>nh"lmcr, Collier County Audubon ;lOchty, Collier
County N~ture Conservancy
Charlotte '.-!('stMon, LClIgue ol Women Votf'rs of Collier County
Curt Machot
qespondinq to Commlßsioner Brown, ~r. Carroll said his fa.l1y haa
owned the property since rebruary 13, 1980.
Tape '4
Mr. Saundors reitornted that the BCC coul~ con.ider the sp.lker.'
testimony ~s nn ^ppenl to t.he Board of an Administrative Decision, Ind
b()J~ 0?3 rACc,.t2'1
Pag e 15
..~~..:...:.
""-~-
,
--- ---- - ------- -----------.- -------- --- ----
BO~K
07~ fACc,.t28
January 18, 19"3
F
that it may be appropri~te for the Commllsionorl to conalder whether
they accept this as Dn ~ppeal, adding that, if the Board does accept
the testimony as an Appeal, they woul~ then havo to mako a decision .s
whether to issue or deny tho road permit. Ch~irman KrUB8 noted that
q
there was a motion on the floor which had not been removed, and Mr.
;f
1.:,-
'i
Norman said that the ßOðr~ had to first i~entify tho ~ctlons of the
peopla who ha~ appeared before the ~oard as appe~ling the Administra-
tive Oecision and th~t, it the Board decides it does constitute an
appeal, since th~rc 18 no potltion or legal ðocument, the Board can act
on the ap~eðl. Rp~~o~din~ to Commis.loner ristor, ~r. Saun~er. said
thðt this woul~ not hr conßlðereð an ðppeal of a zoning type. Commls-
sloner lIollllnd s...ltj h~ t.ic1 not .ee how thla itom could be considered an
appeal ~hcn Comminaioner Voss waft the one who requesteð that the Item
be placed on the ð~rnda. Commissioner Voss and Chairman Kruae laid
they did not think it was an appeal elthor. ~r. Norman said that the
ðltcrnative is that, If an app.al i. filed within 30 days, the Aoard
would hAVC to 90 throuqh the subject again.
Respond!n~ to Chairman ~rufte, Mr. Virta said that the letter
lssuin() thc road pcrmlt was Rignf'd on January 13, 19P.3 and was not sent
becl'luse tho item WlIS placed on the a9~nda, adding th II t , .1 far all he
was concerned, the road permit has been is.ued !rom the County.
Respond in9 to Commissioner Voss' question of whether he would be
- - --- .-. ..- ,- _4. . _ _'0.
willing to gIve those persons neqotiatinq with him ð couple of more
months, Mr. Carroll 5ðie! that he had agreed to delay aft.r d.lay Ind
thðt If 80meonr. came up with. concrete proposal he might consider It.
Co~mi8sioner Voss moved, s.conded by Commissioner Pl.tor and
carried 4/1, with Commi.sloner Rolland opposed, that co..ent. fro.
the speckers which were h.ard be considered .. In Ad.lnl.trltlve Appeal
to the decision of Mr. Vlrta.
. ,
Pft9. 1~
--.....
,
~
~.
~
-
't....,^.~~......
. .....---.-....-.......,.........-..
,',1~.._,'-:~,·....,
.," 'j .
""""_..~\~.~
~,,'1 '.;..:, .:' I,..I~I:J.I'.;·;;,.'
". ;', '~: .. , I./'. ',:>. ,.' '...i ,t'..'foI,
"'W"
- -- - "- .- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - -
January lA, HI'"
.
Responding to Commlui,oner Brown, Mr. Saunders said that thh
action will concludo the subj.ct and that the ordinance provldøø for a
30 day period to appeal to tho BCC, and that his advice wal the he~t
way to keep the itcm from coming back before tho ace. He said that
there was no way to prevent the Ipp.llanta from qoln~ to Circuit Court
if they 80 ~.Dir~.
Commissioner Holland ~oved, ..conded by Commlllloner Brown and
carried 4/1, with Commissioner VOla oppo.ed, that Mr. Virta be dlr.ct.d
to issue the road permit In hand to Mr. Carroll following the vote.
***·*RF.CESSI 10,35 A.M.
RECONVENEDr 10r48 A.M......
Ite~ 119
COUNTY M^NAGER NORMAN AND PUBLIC SAFETY ADMINISTRATOR DORRILL AUTHOR-
IZ!D TO ATTEND EMERCENCY MANAGEMENT TRAINING MEETING J~NUARY 23-2~,
1983
: ¡'"." 1'4., fI', ·.,~,~'¡.,,:"r;:;.:<
, .
Commissioner PIstor said h. reqrettod that he had to ~o to
Tnllah~ss~e I~st w~ek and Wð. not pr~sent for the voto reg~rdinq the
County Mlln~anr'9 and PUblic ~atety ^dministrator's attendance to an
F.merqency ~~n~qcmcnt Training me.tlna, January '3-?~, 19ß3, ad~lng that
he fecls that the County noe~a a certain amount or good loadership In
the event of ,1n omp.rl']ency. lie laid he felt that the County hal be.n
honorcd to be selected ðG one of a fow to attend the M.etin~.
Commissioner Plstor moved, seconded by Commi..loner Vo.., thlt County
Manager Norman ðnd Public s.rety Ad.lnlltrator Corrlll b. allow.d to
attend the Emerqency Management Training meeting Janulry 23-26, 1983.
CommIssioner IIolland øaid that he had strong heling. th'lt the
Civil Defcnse Dlroctor ~nd the Director of tho ~S are the two p'r~o~'
who would bp callnd on first and toromost to carry the me..ag. to the
general public !n the event of an emerryency and that, It thoa. two
people had been 8ugqestert for th.. meetlnq, ho would have had a dl Her-
ont foellnq. He requested that a workahop pertaininq to the dutle. of
b:"K ens 'ACcø
"ql 1"1
','
_.~'-_._"'_._..."",-",
~o~~ 013 fÁCr:~O
--- -- - _.- - -. - - - - - _. - - - - - - - - - - -- -- - - - - - -------- -..
January 10, 1~03
the Public Safety Director and exp.ndltures b. held.
Mr. Norman said hr understand. that the sponsorc asked that the
only people to he conßldere~ for att.nd~nce be the Administrative
Officer an~ the person under hl~ involved in the program.
Upon call for the question, the motion carri.d 4/1, with Commi.-
sloner Rolland oppo.ed.
Commi~sioner Hollan~ said that h. woul~ ask for the ntorementioneð
workshop at ð later tim~.
Itell .20
CHAIRMAN AUTHORIZeD TO SIGN CERTIFICATES or CORRECTION TO THE TAX ROLLS
AS PRESENTED BY TAr. PROPERTY ~PPRAISER'S OFFICE
Commissioner plator moved, .econd.d by Comml..lon.r vo.. and
carriod unanimously, that the Chairllan be authorlz.d to 119n the
following Certificates of Correction to the tax roll. as pr...nted by
the Property Appral.er's nfflcel
1982
TANGIBLE PE~AL PROPERTY
NUMBr.R
DATE
-
19r.'-23C1-'3"
J/lO/A3 - 1/13/R3
.!!.!.2.
593 - /)0:1
11/5/~'- - 12/2~/Ø2
ill!
59!:>, !'?i - 1\06
ll/5/R' - )2/29/82
1982
-
314, ~7r" ~~7 - 453
12/15/82 - l/ll/A3
Itell 121
EXTRA GAIN TIME FOR INMATES NUMBERS 40224, 40867, 39014, 40130, 25876,
33093 AND 3673(, - APPROVED
Commissioner pi.tor mov.d, ..conded by Co~i..loner Brown and
carried unanillously, that the Extrl Gain Ti.. for !n~at.. Nu~b.r.
, "
Paqe 1"·
.....
~
---'
II!iJ
..
,""~
"~1f! "
(/~lt~~~~¡)~II,
Sh.rlft'. Department, b. approved.
----------------------------------------~
January 1~, 1903
40224, 40067, 39014, 40130, 2581~, 33093 and 3~13~, al requelted by the
Item '22
DUPLICATE TAX SALE CERTIFICATE NUMBER 3889 TO CEORGI WAINSCOTT
TRUSTEE/DEBORAH WAINSCOTT, DUE TO LOSS - APPROVED
Co~mllsion.r Pistor mov.d, ..cond.d by Commls.lon.r Brown and
carried unanimously, that the Duplicate Tax Sal. C.rtlflcate NUmber
38ß9 to Ceorq8 Wainscott Tru.tee/Deborah Walnlcott, b. approv.d due to
10...
b\JJK 013 PACi431
to'C
--~--- - -- ---- --- -_._------------,}~,¡~\;"
, , " ".,.,1
: ~'.~\,~,~~,~:\:~',/
;,,'Vt":,','">;'
",
.......- -- - - - ~- - -- -
-------------
--------
January 1f', 19~3
IU. 123
LAKE TRAFFORD MEMORIAL GARDEWS CEMETERY OlIOS NO. 328 AND 32' _
ACCEPTED 'OR RECORDATION
Pur8u~nt to action of the Board January 1n, lQ7A, wherein the
Chairman w~s authorized to .19n variou. d.ed. to Lake Trafford Memorial
Carden. Cemetery lots as the ne.d arts.., Deeds No. '2~ and 329 were
accepted for rocordation.
bO'~ 0'73 'ACt'..uS
.."..~,,,.,-'".._~._._.__._---
.¡'-~
I..I:~~~
. -,:,? .\
-----------------------------------_____~t
't!. .
"'. ;.!.
. ..'~.~ :"t
Itell '24
MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE - FILED AND/OR REFERRED
BU~~ 013 fACc~
January lR, lQS3
There beln~ no objection, the Chair directed the following
corrospondence be filed and or referred tu the various departm.nts IS
indicated I
]. Lotter, d~ted 12/20/a" from Attorney Donald A. Pickworth,
representing Shop and Co, Inc. requesting delðY in hearing
rlate until further notice on ri9ht-of-way permit r.quest
numhpr P2-7P~1. xc ~r. Norman and ~r. Saun~era. Filed.
2. Lotter, rl~ted 12/14/A'-, from Maureen ~icolli, Leonard Newman
~~ency, Inc., transmitting ð Certlflcðte of Insurance
recr.ived for Avatar f101dlnq8, Inc., r:ulf Communlcfttlons, Inc.
Ii/h/" r.olrlen Cate ~erican Cablevlsion Services. xc ~r.
Nornan. rilflrl.
3. Lotter, rlated 1/3/~" from M~evft Reddin, Executive Director,
^reð ^~ency on Aqln9, enclosing first seMi-annu~1 monitoring
vi~it rr.port (or ColJier County Community Cnre for the
fldcrly. Fileli.
4. Momorftnrlum, dftted 1/3/Q3, from Sheriff Aubrey Rogors trans-
nittinq firftt Ouarterly Report - Sheriff's Confiscation Trust
rund, rl~cl.ll Year lQP'-P3. Filed.
~. P.i~ Corkscrew Island Plre Control and Rescue District
FInancial Statements al of f;eptember :to, 19P2. rUed.
(,. Letter, datod I/10/R~, from ^lycia C. Pryor, Controll.r,
~rw~~, flnclosing C.rtifl.d Co~y of the l~ql-A' Audit Report
of the South Florida Water Manag.ment District and Comments
~nd a copy o( the R.commendations on rnt.rnal Accounting
Control as of September 30, l~a'. Filed.
7. Copy of letter, dated J'/30/P" trom Chris And.rson, Collier
County Forester, to Mr. Vlrta reporting on actlvlti.. durlnq
December, 1982. Filed.
9. following [)cpartmental Reports received and fU.d r
1. Cr1^ ~onthly Rtatu. Report as of Dec.mber 31, 1982.
2. Solid ~ðste Division Monthly Activity Reports for
Octöbcr, Novomb~r and December, 19~2.
n. Copy of letter, dated December 11, 198~, trom Wl1~.r c.
~rown, requestin9 that Burton "oad b. delet.d Crom the
resolution cre.tln9 pav1n9 a.....m.nt di.trict for ~oconut
Cr~ek. xc ~r. Norman and Mr. Hartman. Fll.d.
'age 21
¡
-....- - - - - -- - - - - - ....- -.... - -'- -- - - - - --- .:.:J.!....~
c=J
..
-"
.- "...~..... '-.--. -- --." .
i.~-. - - -- - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - -J.n:-ary~ ~ ~ 98; - - - - - -..;;'~:
~:,;..
Ii!:"',', ' 10. Copy of followln'] Minutes r.c.lv.d and fU.da
.~~; . 1. Ochopu f'ire Control Dl.trlct Advisory COlllmltt..,
~};II¡,.. 2. Gold.n Cate Community Center Mvhory Comllltttee,
/1 ' 11/30/Q 2.
3. Iales of Capri Fire Control District A1vlsory
Committee, 1l/1/R, nnd 12/~/a2.
.
.
.
.
There boing no furthnr busin'IB to come before tho Board of County
Commiaalonors, the meeting a~1ourne~ at 101~5 A.M. by ordor of the
Chc1ir.
eOARÐ Of' COUNTY COMMI~RIO~r.RC/
80~RD OF ZONINC ^PPF.ALS/EX
OPf'ICIO GOVERNING AOARD(O) OF
SPECIAL ÐrSTRrCTS UNDF.R ITR
CON~OL .
ATTEST.
WILL'I^~ OJ.
~~þ
--::"'
Thesu '!\inuteø
the RCC on
~lII-"""d./? /?,J a.
corrected
.
"
prosentet2
or a.
DJJ~ m fAct4S'l
\
.M.J.,-..~
- ---_...~.~.- ,...-......