BCC Minutes 08/20/1985 R
';.1,.
&ill
., , ~. '. "'1-";~'~
. 4:' i\i4" .,~
~.", :'\..
~, f'I\~~
~ ,~' "'';,
~"1,..) :'
~-""'''''_~'_"'''''''.''''''_''''''-'''_''''''''h''''_''_'''''.'''''''~''''''''"-·'''-'';''''''-'.~''·''··-''';'__~'''___'''''''_'_M>£I.'''._'''___''''___,".'.f""....__~,~_"'''''''"._".....,''__.....''1_...'''~...............,___,......
~, ~, ". ';i:....p,:~(:.....,J~.......:~\.1,~¡tl¡~~til ~~¡...¡J:~.'..,.,
>~~::-.2~~~. :~- ':....~~~':.::;.\. >'~'~::~~,..~. ,..::4~~..'.~~~:'~~.__._-
;:II~,.
.~.,. 'f. ·o""./,,}
::.:~:...", .
~l'i'"J"~"""~
~.,;;>,.:' .,. ,"
.JS' .1.,,,.J'.' '. ~" .'+'"
. ~~Þ),.~<.., ./ ¡.:,' .
f "'~'1t I i~ ,,'
iii.1"'.: 'r!£"';"~\V:"', ., '
. ( .......' ~ .
... . ." :J>,'l' ·",~.fíi .,i' ''I ' ...'
I~~'. " ,1,,:h",''':'f¡.'·,
, t!l1l.U; .,1.': .' .
~,~ <A.. 1~~\ ¡" ~M ,\t, ...
A'MINDA' - APPROVID AI MODID
t:f,'
, "J>j"t. .."" .,'. ':..'., . .'
s·-1;·,tt:":':>~CCMlata.loner Piltot aove4, ..00n4.4 by Couil.loner a.... .nd ".'
~,,"d, ,_" "..1.·. "'. ,'. '-, . ...~:I,>
;t'..~· carrl.d anlnl.ou.ly, tbat tbe a9.n&1 be approved a. ..endedt '
~.,. .. Addition of Item 5C - pro.entation by rinanchl AcIvhor tor· .
~, selection of Underwriters - Added by County Manaqer.
J, b. Addition of Item 10C(l) - Recommendation for approval of the
Marco Island Community Park priority li.t of dev.lopm.nt -
Add.d by County Manaq.r
c. Addition of It.m IJC - Di.cussion of SW.dish Re.ource Recover~
Faciliti.. Tour - Added by County Man.ger.
d. Item 16D(3) d.leted by County Manager.
.. It.m 16A(2) moved to Item 13D for discu.sion by Commis.ioner
Ha....
f. ··Later in the me.ting, Item 16D(4) wa.'moved to Item 148 for
di.cu..ion by the County Manaqer.
. ~'~ . ":?f
ft:::I!I ---.--..
__ --';i::
. '.~
,":~:!¡'/..f..AU9U.t 20, 11185
ø,;;t~."
r~t,
'. f' '.. ~. , "', '. ",. . r'
~~.' '~,';t'o"\ M'é"~~ .
:..:,"'-!.:-...,:!¿:~...:,}
.; , . . ';]},;;.:€;~~.
,
.;t-'
Ite. t2 '
MINUTES OP AUGUST 6, 1985, REGULAR MIETING - APPROVED
Co..I..loner Plator .oved, .econded by Co..I..loner Goodnight and
carried unanl.ously, that the .inute. of AU9U.t 6, 1985, b. .pproved ..
pre.ented.
ne. . 3
WALTER -SIIAIDIOII- BOWILL, UTILITY DIVISIO. - RICOGNIZED AS EMPLOYII or
THE MONTH POR AUGUST, 1985
Commissioner Voss read a letter and presented it to Mr. Howell in
honor of being recognized as employe. of the month for August, 1985.
County MAnager Lusk .tated that due to the work that Mr. How.ll
did at the North Naples ..wer treatment plant, the County was able to
receive the additional 300,000 gallons of effluent.
Ite. ...
EMPLOYE I SIRVICI AWARDS PRESENTED (~)
Commission.r Voss pr.sent.d service awards to the following
.mpl oye. s z
Sam Rus.o - Engine.ring 10 years
Deniae Col.man - Agriculture 10 year.
Ite. '5
STAFF AUTBORIZ ED '1'0 PROCEED WITH ADVIR'I'ISIIIG FOR UIIDUWRITlR AJID TO
SBORT LIST SAID UNDIRWRITlRS TO 81 RITURHED TO TBI :JIQ\R]) RI '1'U MATIR ,
SINIR RIVlNUI RIPUNDIMO BONDS
County Manager Luak stated that at the meeting of Augu.t 13, 1985,
..',.
\"
aOOK OS'S PAr,t '457
Page 2
','-::'
" ;)
...................".~,--,""'--,-".."""""".._--,,',...,,"~'''"'' '''..,~,,-'".'._..,,--.-
~,-"'--
'/I
~t~:".-"
11".....
~~.~~:\
\~~::t>.
Il~08S~r,t~58,
: '!~~,é '"th.80ard ,.sk,e~ the commi tue", to come, back with a recommendation on
;;~;:(~.,l,.ctlo~/¿fUn4'rWr i teri, addiriil.J.thatbaalcallythe cOØlØli ttee'. "~~;" ~
I ''''~~reco.lÍlenð.tion.waa to 'foUO'lì.Cth. Ic2vlc. of the Unancial adv!ÎÒr.';·',
'>\~ìt~i~:M~~~:~,Þ.r .'wàqnul" pr~lId.nt· of Soúth...t:ern Municipal 80nd~'~"~ltat.ø~,,
.j.,.,=t. th..,purpos.·ofthe ...tin9 of the 'committ.. WII to ðeterlllin"~"~~~~"~'
........',,-...., .,:.....,. .' . . '- ", ., '.:.::·fI~·'·, .' .. .. ~ '." -'._''''1- ",:t~"(~
. *?"\":h.th.r:~tt wuit\ ''t.h.'CountY'1 but'lntei..t toproc..ð with. "'~~'::,,:L.:..:,:,~'~:
~:~~.tI.qOtiated 1118 or a competitive u18 and hia recommendation ia th~~'Æ,::t;,!..;,;
~,~,.... . the County proceed on a neqotiated lab bad. for .ev.ral reason.. ;:'He'!~,;" i
~;;;. 'Itated that the County ia talking about consolidating all the water and";'~ :
.:T,,'" i')t~,~.-
¡ ..w.r districts into one district, which is going to require a ~,~:
refunding of the outstanding debt, which ia very complicated at a.'; r:~
conq:¡etitive u18 because the iasut ha. to be sized beforehand. He . h>~'
""'''-'\
IItated that it is very difficult to size an issue beforehand and if the,.iS!;
'"",,,.
County waita until the laat moment on a .ealed bid baaia it ia hard to ,:.:_
determine what the interest rates are, the size of the bond i.sue and ..
the fact that the market is volatile. He .tated that on a negotiated
sale the County can pick and choose when they want to go into the
market. He stated that he is recommending that the ..lection committee
proceed with the advertising for an underwriter. He noted that the
rec~mmended time frame is that an advertisement be placed in the
newspapera next Tuesday with a response to be received on September 6,
1985. He stated that he is asking for c~nfirmation of the
recommendation. He stated after the committee receive. the propo.al.
from the underwriters they will begin the .election process and then
brin9 back a group of underwriters for review. He stated that after
the underwriters have been selected, then a price would be negotiated
for the bonda if they are sold. He noted that there are a number of
fees that can be negotiated.
Commissioner Pistor questioned if it is economically .ound for the
County to refinance the FmHA loans, to which Mr. Wagner stated that he
has not done a computer run to .ee if it is economically feasible,
adding that whether rate. g~ up or not, it would not cost anything to
consolidate the system. He stated that an analysis of the market will
be done to determine the savings, if any, that can be generated on tho
consoUdation.
Commissioner Piator stated that if it ia not 90in9 to coat
anything to refinance the $4 million, would Mr. Wagner put that in
writing? Mr. ~gner replied affirmatively.
Clerk Reagan questioned if it is possible to have a rated issue on
~
'.
J-"
..
., Auqust 20, 1985
,'1
Page 3
..
-
-
-"''"'. ,~""~.......",-..,-">~..-,,,, ""''','''-'..._..'''...,',''....''.~"'',...-..
.._".;.>""'....,,,;.\"""',.,.,-.""'-~""""-""~-""" --
"'<", '.,",;.>,;1': '''~;',;:if'''' ',U¡^ .:~.~}" 't'-
¡",'
. ':~~.;,::.:~'.;f~~~~..., ..~..
'.:.
'..,
GiiiI
iii
&I
, . ~
t.i,,:,;.~,,~.."
~Ù',""t--"t;i. \ ,
t~~:;'~~', ,'" :1', '. Auqult 20, 1985
'1;'~4.~"·'~' ;r", , ,'I.,,"',. .
~.;:.itr··¡1~an.c¡otiated ..ue;o! thh ,he instead of an insured hsu.?
9I~.,. " :.,.,.,~,'.;~~,>~;;.~, '~.,;··,.~M" t.,.~.' Waqn,. e, r 'r.,epì~ed ,atu rlllat,l~e,lY ,'adding that the county,' s "..€.~, rf;,
~~:an~h,!-..r.y~teÌII' h·mature eno\J9h so that an invutment <Jud. rat1~,?,~~
'1If:.~~1eoUld b~luceiv'd.' . ' '. .. '.:\' q~r~;1.i;:,~!
.~~;,.,.~', ¡ . > Clerk Reac;¡an stated that the County has always had insuud'1aSu,.,.
' 'and thty have not gone for an S&PtMting, but due to the faet¡that'~h.~
.' _',.' J'f¡.~
County is not sur. what she the refunding will be, the insurance '., '" ',¡
premiUll\ h going to COlt the County somethinc;¡, addinc;¡ that it will not ¡J;ív",~,1~
be a direct wash with the $22 million refunding issue. ,¿~..
Mr. Wagner stated that the insurance premium will coat on the new':"";~';;8
money, bu t on the re fund i ng money the County will be able to take that :ë'I..\f,¡\~
into calculation in Itructurinc;¡ the ..crow 10 that the insurance costs·· ":I;;~.
on the refunding alone should be a wash. "':"'$~:
" /.:' t ~j
Clerk Reagan stated that the County should be very cautious In how'"
much debt they are going to occur, adding that it is not for the sak.
of consolidating tho.e districts but for the sake of the debt service
in the County. He stated that the single largest increase in the
County in the past five years has been the debt service.
Commissioner Voss stated that this i8 not a direct debt on the
County as such.
Clerk Reagan stat~d that this is not a direct debt of the County,
but the Commission is ex-officio of the water sewer district, adding
that he is not concerned about the general fund. He atated that he has
the .ame responsibilities as the Commission to the users of that fund
and he does not feel that there is a separation there.
Coaml..loner Hasse .oved, .econded by Co..lssioner PI.tor and
carried unanl.ou.ly, that Staff be authorized to proce.d with the
advertising for the underwriters and to shortlist the underwriter. to
be returned to the B~ard re the Water' Sewer Revenue Refunding Bonds.
Ite. IS
ORDIKA»CI 85-44 RI PETITION PDA-85-6C, VIKIS , ASSOCIATIS, AMEWDIaG
PARK SHORI PUD TO ALLOW FOR LOW-RISI RISIDENTIAL STRUCTURES _ ADOPTED
Legal notice having been published in the Naples Daily News on
July 19, 1985, as evidenced by Affidavit of PUblication filed with the
Clerk, public hearing was opened to consider Petition PDA-85-6C filed
by Vines' As.ociate., repre.enting Park Shore, to amend the Park Shore
PUD to allow for low-rise residential structuro..
Zoning and Planning Director Pettrow stated that this is a request
to amend the Park Shore PUD for low-rise residential structures and
, '
ïõ; 08'8 'At:! ~59
paqe ..
, '.,
r~
~
~
.---..---
~:/.'~;"
,C:" 04~~í " '-< ~'. "
.... ,.~}~;::..;:,~.,:
~!'-,.".' :~ t:;'~~;;Î "
',\. ,.
.,'
~
~;.;
'<f';',
':~~::~~f,~¡, ',':t;þ.:'. :
'~f!K:~~~:~~~.~~" " . )f:" 1',~:~l.,';).'U9ust 20,1985\ '(~:~.~ir
·'rtlated devdopaaent .Undardl. ' He noted, that the .ubj.ct property lIii,.
~'o'C~t.d;"lk'ûn1t. 2 årid 50! Párksh';;r.~ northo~'Horhon way/'andáõut,'1i
.:~t.,¡..r,,';.-;:,~-!t~;j~;'';;'''-'· "":'f<. . \,' .,.. .. ,~',' ;-, ( .~ ";' ':': ' "-; , '. ..~,~:-.. ·\-'t.-:~
~~ol s~a9.te brlve along Gulf Shore Blýd. He .tated that the p.tltlo~~~¿
~" /·rh Ptó~oa1n9 to amerid the Park Shore pun docl.III.nt to include clust.i>'<"...
·t:·~lri9l.~"aml1Y or two-family r..identÍa1 fot Lot 126 only. HI not.~,,:.r.. :~~'/", "'
>,'that it 11 pre..ntly zoned PUD with condominlt.1'11. located to the north ',~ ,,'ú~,
, :... ..,~'¡o.-¡' \
,and south and to the east are I1nqle family dwel1inq units, adcHng that·:'t·~;.
the propo.ed amendment to the PUD document i. in compliance with the
. Comprehensive Plan. He stated that the amended document has been
provided with changes coverin9 clusterin9, setback provi.ions, and
d.nsity, and changes will apply to Lot '26 only. He noted that three
letter. were received in opposition and two letters in favor, adding
that Staff and the Plannin9 Commission recommend approval providing
that the documents are in order.
Mr. William Vines stated that this is necessary language
modification to accommodate a proposed change in the traditional
pattern of Park Shore beachfront lots. He stated that to date
everything on the beach has been elevated apartments and on Lot '26, a
development proposal has been prepared for a small number of low-ris.
cluster villa-type units. He noted that the existing PUD document did
not contemplate that kind of development and therefore, language change
is necessary to accommodato that. He stated that among other things,
the detailed site plans for any low-rise cluster development like this
will be submitted to staff and have to go through the County's
development plan review process where it will be subjected to the
normal test to make sure of adequacy between separation of buildings,
landscapin9, open space and all the other aspects of the plan review
process.
Commissioner Pistor questioned if this would reduce the density,
to which Mr. Vines replied affirmatively, adding that there could be
around 154 units built and only 28 are proposed so there is a major
density reduction. He stated that one of the requirements of the
Planning Commission is that density reduction ~n Lot '26 may not be
transferred to other areas.
Mr. O. J. Schuessler, 4001 Gulf Shore Blvd. No. stated that the
agenda does not indicate that this development is limited to Lot '26.
Mr. Pettrow stated that the amended PUD document states that it will be
limited to Lot '26.
Mr. Vines stated that the petition was filed and during the course
pag e 5
,.
l1li
..
a=
--~,~ '~''''',","...".,_.""-,, .",~"..--'~...,..~''',",- '" ..."","' ,,..,, ' .,
_'...____ 1111
1,.~ ,.
, .".'''''t.
,1.
" ~"-
'., .
......"----- " ...-..
, I. ,'.,
IiiI
I
~ -.-" .-.
....... ..--
,~"'... ,
'.~~:\, , 20, 1985
i!~~,:jO'f proe..s there wu language mOdlUC:::::~~ He noted that the
~W~':I.Ir\~ertlon of 11mitatlons of L·tt '26 and the prohibition of den~lty , . '.~' \
~~,~·.tan.fer is'a part of the language chang. that has taken place trom th~
;~~;-·,:;,;tim. the' petition waa originally fUed untU today. He stated that i~~"
/;;'1';\'; 11 in the modHhd petition. ,,;~t
~0ì Commissioner Voss stated that the PUD document state. that
individual lots within Block 12 may be developed to a hlghor or lower!,
density than 25 units per acre, so long as the total dwølling units
developed on Lots 1 through 29, Block 12, does not exceed 25 units per
acre and provided, hO'",ever, that in the event that clustered low-rise
dwelling units are developed on Lot '26, the unused density on Lot '26
may not be transferred elsewhere.
Commissioner Pistor stated that according to the wording there is
still a possibility that the petitioner could revert back to the
original zoning. Mr. Vines stated that this is true, adding that the
base language provides that density can be transferred, but with the
proposal for Lot '26, the density transfer is eliminated. But, if for
some rwason the low-rise development fails, then it is subject to the
basic rules.
Co..i..loner Holl.nd aoved, .econded by Co..i..ionor Pi.tor and
carried un.nl.ously, that the pUblic h.aring be clo..d.
Comai..ioner Holl.nd aoved, .econded by Co..i..ioner pi.tor and
carried un.ni.ously, that the Ordinance .. nuabered and entitled below
be adopted and entered into Ordinance Book Ho. 21.
ORDUIAHCI 85-44
AM ORDIIlAllCE AKDIDIHG ORDIHAllCE 78-29, TBE PLAIIIIID UIIIT
DIVBLOPMEMT DOCUNIHT POR PARK SBORI UNITS 2 , 5, BY AMIHDING
SICTIOII l.c., GENERAL DISCRIPTION OF PROJICT. AMIHDING IV b.
LOTS 1 THROUGH 29, BLOCK 12, PROVIDING AN IFFICTIVE DATI.
Ite. . 7
ORDINANCI 85-45 RI P!TITIOH R-85-l2C, Q. GRADY MINOR' ASSOC., AGIH'r
POR AllTON STEINIR, IT AL, RI RIZOHING FROM A-2 TO PUD POR -RIGENT PARK-
LOCATID SOUTH O~ IMMOKALEI RD. AND lAST or AIRPORT RD~ - ADOPTID
Legal notice having been published in the Naples Daily News on
July 19, 1~S5, AS evidenced by Affidavit of Publication filed with the
Clerk, public hearin9 was ~pened to consider petition R-S5-l2C, filed
by Q. Grady Minor' Associates, Agent for Anton Steiner, Erich Faes,
and Roland Stierli, requesting rezoning from A-2 to PUD for Regent Park
which i8 to be located south of Immokaleo Road and east of Airport
Road.
tODK 08B I'AGl461
Page 6
~~.'"
--"....._,........',.,"_._""~,...,'~.."'''___",'','"'"...",o>
',~e,"~'"'.,,'·_"',._"____...._""..,_"
--
,,\. ...'
'Ir-:.,.,.
,.ì,,·~
''''':-
~;i~·
f!~'. ! ~ I' '
~~ ø¡;:! ..~, '
~"':'" ' .
fft~~~' : :,'
i " ,~~)'K' 088ni462 AUgust 20, 1985 , 't. '."
¡¡~,~:'~ .r\~, zoning~nCl ,Pl~nning ..~~r~fto.~~~~~ttr~w .uted that this P.tiUoft;~:wa,~':.;::::t
'·"~,pr".nteCl",ln Jµne .ncLwu ðenl.d; adding that It II now being rehear~.Jf"~··
';~', ~',' ,'... "'" ",',', , >,,' -.~
4t'\.Í'Ioted that th.· orlginll1 PUD document hu b..n chang.d to connruct,~::',
.'::<'~'''Ï'',>:., .'. . " ,;~..t'.¡f'~'P'
,'466unlt. instead ,of 469 which ",ill b. 121 single family and '345 ,,,,;';~;""
;J:':~~Ùl";hml1Y units. He not.d that the minimum floor u.a h.. b..n ~~~{~
~r',:~~ub~tanthl1Y incn...d and other minor chang.. have been incorporât'ð~~::~?~~I'> '
~~: ,.H. not.d that Staff and the Planning Commhsion r.comm.nd approval with' .~:,
';~. the .m.ndm.nts. H. stat.d that th.re wre no letters of opposition , ,"A,
~~~: received this time. . " .;~
'ì~. Attorney George Vega stated that there was some opposition last ":"'~
tim., adding that since that time there wu s.veral basic chang.s m.d. 't.,~~
and there has been a meeting with Four Seasons and everyone is now 'in~::¡'.
approval. He stated that the lot sizes have been increased with the ~~
average lot being 80 feet wide and 130 faet in depth. He noted that
the floor space for single family was incr.a,ed from 1,200 square f.et
to 1,600 square feet and the multi-family from 750 to 1,000 square
f.et. He reported that the density has been decreased and there is no
objection that he is aware of.
Tape 12
'. ;. ,;""~:r'"
"""':"""':
........ ~,
,'....~.,. ,f.,...
f " ....~i:;t". .,~~~, 5--,"\'''' ''1,
, ' -¡., .' .we , .
., ;;'" , .
L" ,
~J
Co..l..ion.r Pl.tor .ov.d, .econd.d by Com.l..lon.r Holland an4
carried unanl.oualy, th.t the public he.rlngb. clo..d.
Co..l..ioner Pi.tor .oved, .econd.d by co.-i.sioner Holl.nd .nd
~.rried unaniaoualy, that the Ordinance .. nuaber.d .nd entitl.d b.low
b. adopted .nd entered into Ordinance Book No. 21, .ubject to ...nd..nt
of tb. PUD documents
ORDINAIICE 85-45
AN ORDINANCE AMINDING ORDINANCE 82-2 THI COMPRIBINSIVI ZONINO
REGULATIONS lOR TBE UNINCORPORATED AREA OF COLLIER COUVTY,
FLORIDA U MIlfDllIO Tal 10111110 ATLAS .....P .UMBER 48-25-7 It
CBANGIMG TBI lONING CLASSIFICATION OF TBI BERlIN DESCRIBID
RIAL PROPERTY FROM A-2 TO -PUO- PLANNED UNIT DIVlLOPMINT FOR
PROPIRn KNOWN AS -REGDT PARK- LOCATID ON TBI SOUTH SIDE or
DAVID C. BROWN HIGHWAY AND 1/2 MILl EAST OF AIRPORT ROAD IN
SICTIOH 25, 'I'OWNSBIP 48 SOUTO, RANGI 25 EAST, AIID PROVIDING
AN EFFECTIVI DATE.
Ite. 18
RBSOLUTION 85-175 RI PETITION FDPO-85-V-4, ILENE STAIILEY, REQUESTING A
VARIAMCI FROM TBE MINIMUM FLOOD ILEVATION AT 5437 BARDIE ST., NAPLIS
MANOR - ADOPTED
Legal notice having been pUblished in the Naplea Daily News on
August 4, 1985, as evidenc.d by Affidavit of PUblication filed with the
Clerk, public hearing was opened to consider Petition FDPO-85-V-4,
Page 7
-=:I
-
-
"';'..'...''".,.,..-',_..,.____""_.,....._O;¡'~__""'...."'",,>'A_,,';.""'".,,,,:'"'_,,_,..,..""_"___..,~;',"""._,___""'_""_-_i""_""".'"......'''_'",."_""".",__.~,_~"__,~"'",~",,,,,,'",""_'"''''
, ~JI!'!l(¡'" :.,,",'" ' . ,'~,. "III""'I_~M"" '..', '. .
''';';''':':''W~I!'J:.'.I!'!''t~JI!ìG;'··7.....:,}-'1!l-{::'·~ ,~,' .. ""'~';C""~':'''''' '!," "'.'::,:~, ,..,.. ':¡;;>,.,;;iÞ¡;?~
~~~:':;,'·:~~.~'f~£~~~~~f-~~-;-;::~;;~'·~;;;,,: '," t:~~~'::..~~~ ~~- ~ ,\~: -., _ ~~~~.'f
.œ,.."ft... .,'f:.\....'. 't,,· ,"",t.,.., '''4Þ.t1 '_~'f4.,'f , ~'t-. "i:,..,..,-·'!t'~~M~' - <"'1. ~ '~ 'if> ~,. . r·,;;,.',t.:.-';-¿
'\',\.,.. ",~.!}~.~j(.,;?,~\,;~;"",: . "<,' "','1,;""" . ...;i¡'?!J~!:i:,;:~·!,:' ," ,'''' ':.''')~,''1i
~Y:1\~~'~ ..~, ~ . J .:t,.,. 'I, " , ,) ~'< V ~,. ~~ ,";::,"1i
~~~i~'~~.;~'b~::~'f,';.:' ~~ .,"',-,..{".' "'¡": _~.·:1~~~:
""~;"'f1t,tNi'''''t4j.'. '.,*~' t. ~J ~;.-;·i.;:)I¡'.,.,.~:""; I 1. "":!'f(.J'!!'.
t'.- ,'""~4. "'..":.~ ,~" ( ,( I" r, . . :' i "
r ,~""';.;' -/ ¡\::;¡'.I¡: ÞJff"b : J .' F ~ ¡ '~ " t ~l.,iI)¡...r ('f- "',j, t:¡:~ ...: ", ~ ,.~~-.o:
.~.;J;'",. ':f~.¡;' ". ,. ,,/ '~'<. , ~ ,J,. . ,.., .,'4. ~,...\i(·~R,:' l '''''t''''- "". ~,).."~.~/
. ',. 'it' ¡" '" ' ,"" ·"'...:.::wltt,,,, "'. ,. M' ". ' rff ".:!,
,'f :,,,,"'.¡>oi 1",I!'f1'; c:',1tJta:_, '~, IJ'~"'" . ' ~~ ..... jjIW;'i;,\',.....Au¡¡,UÎt:~ 20' II,; 198 5 ¿ ..., '.' ';... þ",<;'J!þi(. ',~ "\
~'J!.~-:".Þ' ..... ," "'t ..t-F "'~"'ri~'i"...." ,/, ~ ...".¡,¡
~ti~~~:~m;í~:~~1~;~~~~~.x;~:::~:~:1:n~~:"~~:~~:'~;~~l~'"..'"
, . op'H.f'iÍÎ~'i1b¡éš·~'h"5431rHi'r~ìí":Ît~ht? t:ot,' '27; Block '13,' Na~pf...
~'::(~';:~d:;1" t:õ·' 1 ;,;¡,/I,b' ~i '1"" ... '.'. ~' '1;~,:' '...."k!j~' '" ¡; , 1'.~. ,''íi~' I<i:r/.,f'"
"t.^ g t n I:IÚ ... V ."on., ",' , '. ,,', 'r.
':f,:\;;f:tôn":t\g'~n4 PlÎnning '01 r.cto~ "p~ttrow' atat.ð, that MIl.' st.a~1e)t~·!{·
:s,:tequ..Ùng' 'approval of approx 'Imateiy"'3·' trorit'the'!åln 1iii:.Î1l 'tioò·d;'.~,;"':).t...;,~.~
':':':"'levatlon reqùirement, adding that at the Ume of constrúction~,"{~·:.
~·,.:,.:':\'appuentlY the benchmark thatwu' utilized wi. lncotr:ec't" and thë"t'H'jt¡,.",.
,'" ..~., '.¡, , . .-' '.'".\'~ :)"'.' '~~;1~
;.'~:;.. floor was, therefore, poured about 3- below the minimum flood aleva-,'
¥{' Hon.· He stated that under Section 18, (7) (a-m) of the flood damaqt':
prevention ordinance, thera is authorization to approve this type of
petition.
Mr. Lincoln Stanley stated that the person that laid the house
for him made a mistake ot 3- and he is asking tor approval ot this
r eque.t.
Co..iaaioner Piator aoved, .econded by Couiaaloner Holland and
carrie4 unani.ously, that the publio hearing b. clo.ed.
Co..i..loner Pi.tor aove4, .econ4e4 by Co__is.loner Goodnight an4
carried unan1aously, that Re.olution 85-175 re Petition rDPO-85-V-4,
Ilene Stanley, reque.ting a variance fro. tbe .Inlau. fl~o4 elevation
at 5437 Hardee Street, Naple. Manor, be adopted.
am 088 PAr.t 463
Page 8,
'''''__''_''''''"¡",__~,'_',~,JI'_'''''''''''>;>''_Ol-t,,W~''.~_''''''';'_''''''_-'f"',...._'"_,_...._~''''..,'''''',,...''''''''''...._..,_.,'''.','''''''',.....;;','''''','''»<",+'""""""",,,,",",~.',.~,,;,,,,,",_,,,,,,,M""""'"'"
, __'".-,-¡."tr: {~' . ,,~...~,~ '·k,~..,..t~? 1,~~ !
~'.
.... ','
!fl.: <:" - :tt.,',,<.l~~ft'o'·'
'..' "'-'~'~'f'lirïliiiJ';""'"
..""
.....,
.,-...,"""
~1 ,.' ,f': V:
.,
t,i' ;;.,.
",: ~.
'¡!~~"~466 _"".at '0, 198.
~7..-l·:J"~" "h IJ~
. ,~RÎÎÔï.vrlo. 85-176 R& PI'I'I'1'I011 PU-85-loe:, MARCO IBUdID 'IRI COII'I'ROL
~r~DIS'l'RIC'I' RIQUISTIIIG PROVISIONAL USI or 'I'BI RSP-4 DIS'l'RIC'I' FOR A rIRI
.," < ITA'I'ION LOCATID ON MANGO AVlNUI, GOODLAHD BIIOBTS - ADOPTED
"'!
""., .
Zoning and Planning Director Pettrow stated that the Marco Island
rire Control District Is requesting a provisIonal use under the RSP-4
zoning distrIct for a fire station for property located on Mango Avenue
in Goodland Hei~hts. He stated that Staff and the Planning Commission
are recommendIng approval subject to stipulations which cover
environmental concerns, historIcal archaeologIcal concerns, and the
drainage plans to be submitted. He stated that he has received no
adverse correspondence on this petIti~n.
Chief Jackson of Marco Island FIre Control DistrIct stated that
other sItes were researched and none of them were acceptable except for
this one. He stated that the maIn reason that a statIon Is needed is
due to the response time, adding that the people in Goodland raised
$18,000 for this piece of property. he stated that the station would
be manned wIth volunteers and they plan to build a two story statIon
wIth the engines housed on the first floor.
CommunIty Development Administrator MullIns stated that there are
some diffIculities with the flood elevation for thIs sIte, adding that
there will hav. to be substantial fillIng done on the site as the fire
engines cannot be h~used below the flood elevation.
Chief J4ckson stated that they are planning t~ bring in fill for
the fire station.
Couis.ioner Pistor .oved, .econded by Co.-issioner Ba... and
carried unani.ously, that Resolution 85-176 re Petition PU-8S-l0C,
Marco Island rlr. Control District r.questlng provisional us. of the
asr-4 district for a fir. statIon located on Mango Avenue, Goodland
Beights be adopted subject to stipulation. contained in the rindinc¡ of
Pact and the Petitioner'. agreement.
Page 9
..
-
-
"1 __,,'g.._-<i.
-"--"-"'--'-"-''''''''''--';--'"--_.~-"
""",,-,,-,,".,_.~----;--
.". ..',.":',; ,·1,·~ ,~:);,.." .~~;~;
¡¡¡¡
.,'''..'...''\ôt''~,' . '"';""~,' :.
'.' ,..~,_:~:t.,,',' '- ';-,",
.~.. ..;:,'f'O,1',oo".,:,..,;::.'.. t'¥t/;'('
" ·:;tl\l<
_J
,J" .'
I, L
"",'{',
'. ·J\'fIiJ/Î
:. ";'I~';~:;;1:2;"i;' 7' ;~.~.j ", ,; ¡::;a
'Ìt~ì~~~!t~Fr' · ": ." "~~?~.. 2~., 1985, ;:;,~:;;,.€~~' ;"
~ ~~tt' 1i('\a!-..,,, þø(H....., "'t'\" '''- <'~·.r~/I' "";~"';;:,.;
, :,~'.nIn,*' .v-a5-14C, RUTB rnLD, RIQUIS"IMa PROVISIONAL UBI wE- or '1'1Ii::.>'
;,.;.\,,\,..,-1 DIS'l'RIC'I' rOR A CHILD CARl CENTIR rOR PROPIRTY LOCAUD AT 114 ,:,..~¡~';,
~~\,:','CAR!I.INI ROAD - DINUD ' ~~.';
t:,~P;~ 'Zoning and Planning Director 'ettrow stated, that this petidon >T.:,~~,
*::1" tor Provisional u.. ·e- of the r..idential dngh family zoning. ,.i;~£;,
¡r,v" " ,'.
::;l": 4istrict for a child care center at 114 Caribbean Road. He stated
a petition was submitted in December, 1984, and it was recommended
approval at that time, but due to the opposition regarding noise,
traffic and a deed restriction setting a precedent, the Board denied
the petition. He noted that in June, 1985, Ms. Field submitted a
petition indicating that her child care center would not set a pre-
cedent and requested that her petition be reheard, which was approved
by the Board. He stated that it is now before the Board again for
approval, adding that Staff and all county agencie. recommend approval
subject to the conditions in the Executive Summary. He noted that
there were five petitions with SO signatures against the petition and
11 letters against it wIth 3 letters being proponents of this
provisional uae.
Ms. Field stated that she does not wish to harm Pine Ridge Civic
Aasociation or Naples, adding that each cas. sh~uld be taken ..parately
and judgeð on its own merit and she doea not believe that this
provisional use would set a precedent. She indicated that she has lots
of grounds for the children to play on so that there is not going to be
excesaive noise, adding that she only "'ants to have 8 children. She
indicated that she is willing to have in her deed restrictions that
this home will not be sold as anything but a private home. She stated
that this would help her financially and she ia asking for approval of
this provisional use.
Attorney Cardillo, representing the Pine Ridge Civic As.ociation,
stated that this is a question of exceeding the normal five children as
being an improper use of the property and the Pine Ridge Civic
Aasociation believes that it ia. He stated that the Board previously
voted this matter down and he i. requesting that the Commission be
consistent and vote the matter down again.
Rev. ~pes stated that he does not feel that statements regarding
noi.e and traffic are fair, adding that Ma. Field i. providing a
service by caring for children at this nursery .chool. He stated that
if he felt it was detrimental to the pine Ridge Civic Association or
Page 10
-
..
-
___w""'......
- _'ø__..._,...-,,.,....,----
,$ .: r -"t" ._~: \,~ ~
i<l~";'~~~~ , , ..
,-,' ~~' -.., -- .-, -- .. .~
-....---
;",\',
·~~ò-.,~"
I~". ,,'. August 20, 1985 ..
~~'}~~e' ue~ in which he BY", he would Þe oppoud to It. He .tated' th.t~~'
, '~'~;~,~e'CSo.~not ~e~~ t~~t this' ~chool would. ut a preceðent In anywa~~,. 'f,'.,,:.f~~
'( ',:1" \:'."."~. Mr~'Thomà.' Ru..ell, Director of pine Ridge civic A..ociatlon,J,;~:~';:
. "~,,<,, .tated~ that the Pine Ridc;e c1vic A.sociatlon h against this " ,
~\. provbionlll use. He stated that they would Uke to keep the ar.. .. it
!.;' II and he is ..king that this petition be denied.
~~'~ "ape . 3
';i;~:,:, '
"
Mr.. El1e.n Sharp .poke In opposition to the petition. Ms.
Vanette Shillin stated that it i. her house that receive. the noi.e
from the children a. well as the annoyance of the additional traffic.
She presented a petition that was circulated in the pine Ridge Area
with 87 nam.. that indicated It was felt that a day care op.ration
would affect the atmosphere of the area, create ðdditi~nal noi.e and
reduce the property valu...
Commissioner Voss stated that he has had several letters from
people in Pine Ridge on this matter, adding that he feel. that the
wishe. of the people of Pine Ridge have to be taken into c~nsideration.
Commi.sioner Has.e stated that he visited M.. Field'a h~ua.,
adding that it is maintained as well as any other home and better than
.ome of them. He stated that she is to be commended on what ahe i.
doing, but it i. difficult to go against the zoning that is there to
protect the residential area of the community.
Commissioner Holland stated that he has read the recommendation
from the Staff and CAPC numerous times, lookod at the area, ha. heard
mentioned many times about not allowing spot zoning, and there i. not
one place in Pine Ridge that the zoning has been changed and with this
thoU9ht in mind, he has to go along with the people of Pine Ridge and
deny the provi.ional u.e.
Co..i..ion.r H.... .oyed, ..conded by co..i..ion.r Bolland and
carried un.ni.ously, th.t P.tition PU-85-14C, Ruth Fi.ld, requ..ting
provi.lonal u.. -E- of the RSF-l district for a child c.re center for
property locat.d at 114 C.ribb.an Road b. denied.
..... Rece..1 10110 A."~ - Reconvenedl 10120 A~". .....
It.. III
COUIITY AftOlUln DIR.IC'l'&D '1'0 WORK WITH JIB. PERBIDA/SOUTB WEST FLORIDA
RBGIOIllAL aROUIID TRAIISPORTATIOH ASSOC. REGARDING ORDIHMlCB 83-50 (TAXI
CABS) MID BRING A REPORT BACK TO THE BOARD IH 3 to 4 WIlKS
Ms. Marq.ret Per.ida of South We.t Florida Rlqional GrQund
Transportation Association stated that this ofqanization was for~.d
;O~K 08'8 PAGr4 73
paq. 11
."."~,._";'~"",,,,_OII'"
;..r',.
, ~~, .. :'.
¡¡¡¡¡,,:'.,
~
¡¡¡)
;~;
'Jo.".
'~¡;<, no'O '171 AU9u.t 20, 1985
,. UOO PAtt 'i 'i." .
~r:(ftC.~tlY to protect and upgrade th. quality' and prohsa1onaUII1'II of
:'::,::,,:CJr9urid transportation ,operation. within the County of Collier and
".~~/;.f~~t,iY.~,n9>areu. She referred to the packet of information the .'r.,;
~~,~C~..l.~lon~r. wer. given and Ordinance 83-50, noting that und.r S.ctlon"
,\':;:'i'è~'~':"~'at(;.~' th.rt .hould b. Inurt.cS that extra pa...nger. .hou1db. ' ~"'>';:". ,..."..0
~;' ,"òharqed $1.00 per puunqer rath.r than $.25 III the preunt ordinance"· 1:.:..~t.i.:;~I,' ..'
atate.. She stated that after two years of workin9 with this Ordl- ,~:~..."
. . ".~,
'nance, they have found out what 11 practical and what is not practical, "':':';:ii
which i. why the proposed change. have been pr.unted.~~~,'
:'."'i':'
Commissioner Voss questioned if MI. pereida was aware that the,·"
insurance rates are going up very high, to which Ms. pereida stated
that they have already gone up for her company over 200\.
Commissioner Pistor que.tioned what i. meant by the statement that
says that permits should b. is.ued to individuals immediately under the
parent companie. name?
Ms. pereida stated that this means that the permit should be
issued in the individuals name as well as the hiring company's name.
She stated that individuals were issued temporary permits until they
could be checked out and it was a way of contacting that individual
again because the hiring company's name was on the p.rmit. She
indicated that it used to be done this way, noting that this would give
the County some recourse if they checked into someone and found out
that they were not desirable and did not meet the qualifications. She
stated that the County could come back to the Company at that point and
let thdm know that the individual did not meet the standards, and in
turn if the company had to let someone go, the owner could come back to
the County and indicate that the person was fired.
Commissioner Voss stated that this needs to be referred to the
legal department for them to go over the proposal.
County Attorney Saunders stated that he could look at the proposal
and have an informal report to the ~oard concerning the affecta of the
recommended chang.s to the taxicab ordinance.
Commissioner Holland stated that the name of the company was with
the individual that applied for the pormit and they had to have a
chauffeurs license in order to qualify for that. He stated that if an
individual is working for a company and they are terminated and the
County has no control, that person can create a problem for the company
if that permit ia not pulled.
County Attorney Saunders stated that he is reviewing the ordinance
Page 12
..
-
-
"'... ~..''''~ .,.. 'I"
~_..._,._-"'
.._",_~,_"_""_,,,,,,~~. "'~""_""h,_'~__'~'__""
~;:..:.;;::~. _~: :::~ ~. ·)"r:
--,.,~
--
....',
',..'
~L.~;~" þ , ' "
i:~r,. '"C, , . Aue¡ult 20, 15185
:~~~~r~;~'î( look at the r.comm.nded chanc¡es and h. v111 bring
'b:JSack' to' the aoàrdòn the matter.
~'.'~.' Pe re1da Itat.d that Ih. would like to have .om. input int.o
,~:~:'·ch.nc¡.. b.for* they au pr...nt.d to the Commi..ion. , . >I
~:',¡~.·~:f Mr. Jo. Cuuon .tated that h. concurs with the remark. macSe by'
~_,,;:~ì Pluid a.'
Mr. Cary Maxwell ~a.tro, pre.id.nt of the South We.t Ree¡ional
Ground Tran.portation As.ociation, .tated that this ore¡anization va.
formed as an internal governine¡ type organization .0 that member. will
have to adhere to the proper licenses, permits, etc. in order to give
Collier County the best in transportation po..ible. He noted that he
i. providine¡ Colli.r County with excellent .ervice all y.ar lone¡ and
then durine¡ the ....on, people com. in m.ke the profits and then leave
and he would like b.tter control over permits and licenses.
Mr. Ocy Richardson stated that since 1981 insurance rate., tire.,
Ind e¡Isoline have e¡one up, as well as the price of the automobiles. n,
stated that the rates ne.d to be increased so that they can continu. to
.erve Collier County and the public.
Commissioner vo.s stated that there i. merit to what has been said
and he hopes that the County Attorney and the taxicab people can get
toe¡.ther and come back with an equitable solution.
Mr. Tom Olliff, Fleet Manae¡ement Director, .tated that in June h.
approached the Commi.sioners and recommended that Ordinance 83-50 be
revised, adding that h. has b..n working on it with Assistant County
Attorney Anderson. He stated that the ordinance should be back before
tho Board within 3 to 4 weeks.
Commissioner Holland questioned if it is possible for an
individual coming in for a permit to be directed to someone under the
Board instead of the Tax Collector, to which County Attorney Saunders
stated that the ordinance could be structured in that fashion.
"I'ape ...
It.. 112
CœSUL"I'IIIG DmI)I&BRIIIG SIRVICES MRIIMan' 8&"I'W11II BOLB, MOnIS, AJII)
ASSOCIA'I'IS, INC. AIID COLLIIR COUII"I'Y POR '1'81 )lOR"I'B NAPLES ROADWAY JtSTU
1M 'I'B& AMOUNT or $75,982.00 - ADOPTED
Public Services Administrator Kuck stated that this is a
recommendation to approve the consulting engineering agreement with
Hole, Montes' As.ociates, Inc. for the preliminary engineerin9 de.19n
for the North Naple. Roadway MSTU. He noted that on March 19, 1985,
the Board adopted Ordinance 85-13 creating the North Naple. Roadway
UOK 088 PAGr 475
Pa9. 13
....'_ ,.-___ <"II 11___..,·....."'""_·"__·...._'___""~· .,..""
_..,'''''~,--~--'.,~-.---''-
. "~'_~~~~~"it;. ~~~!)}....,;
"'j;:r:-:Ji~,("",,'I;~·:.',.J:('-~___~<"~"·'I'¡.'¡~~·" 'r v -.. ;,...
:~;~~~r::~I~'~:"::::)' ";:"\ ;~' :è'" "," ':. "~f¥.i
~¡~ ..'."?"t."',., 1"\," .", ,.AUtjUlt 20, 1985,,:,:, , '," .' ,11" ,
,1$~J~n"'·.18',\1;85J! th.::~rðff~~·e:?i4pf~li/'~~'t..:,; ,Áa:~O~Î.~
',~tr~1;f~~::~:1:;~z:~~~:::~'·i:6:~f~~:~~~!~r;;1.~:1~,~r~:~ ,
~1ÏS.Õn~~developeð . 'prel1ld nary engin.ering',lcòþeo,!workjJrògtäia ~,~hh¡
·;·(;1t;¡Mo~t'.. . Aa.ocht.. buedonabudg'.t allocat1ð~'\ot·..'pp·rðièIÌÌl'.t.;lY
", ,0",. ' '" , ,~" " , ' 'I' ' , .-, .,' "'..! ,",.,', ,'"pi) ";
. \',1.~~'òòol, 'He ItateeS that throu;¡h 'conf.renc"".nd/pr'ic'.n'90tia:I~~};:,t~~
....10n. held on August 1, and Augult 8, a bilateral, a9ren.nt;."..:"~·' ,r~"
;)~r.i~h~d "h~rebY the fir. would provide the foUoI.ting ""r"1e~·.'toÌ';:¡~':~;.
,~~~r~' .-' .- '-', ' . . , ' " ' , " ',' . ';; ,
~;X~'~UII 'of'$7S,982.001 proj.ct lurveying and riqhta-of-way def1n!! ~
<,t10n; eltablhhment of three corridor alternativ.., environmental
/.
. ...~;'.Iaeallll.nt and mappinq, prelimina ry traffic and roadway engin..ring
¡~:.. '
':",~' phnl' preliminary probable construction coat .Itimatoa, report on,
~~¡;" financing alternativ.., and apportionm.nt/a....am.nt'report. H. .tat.d
,~; )i.¡..'.". ' ,
-l~t. that hil recommendation is that the Board approve the final recomm.nded '
engineering contract and authorize the Chairman to execute the appro-
priate agr.ement by and between Collier County and Ho1., M~ntel ,
Associatea, Inc.
Co..i..toner Piltor .oved, ..conded by Co..i..lon.r S.... an4
carrl.d unanl.ou.ly, that the conlultlng .ngin.ering .ervloe. .gr....nt
betwe.n aol., Ronte. , Allociat.., Inc. and Colll.r County for the
Morth Maple. Roadway M8TU in the aaount of $75,982.00 b. approved.
~,"'.
..
~""
'W'; ,
('oil .
..~~,
....,1:.
...,~
;:~,
:,~"
~.,' .
~:,,:.,
~~.'
;~,:'~.,
....j
"',"__..~,,~,.._""",_,_"'"_,~,_..___._"'.......',"'þ,~Wi..;'_,'_.,_,_~.....,_,_1111<,."..Ø1...~"*._IJ",__'".. ""''''I;_'''-''''''''~·'.'--''''''''''''''''''''''''''''·''''''''''''''''''''''-'·'
<'e,,"·,~''''"'''"''''·'''''·'''''__''''_~~__·"_·
';1< _01 >,. "'¡- "" ,
.....'~: .. <~ .;~~ ¥",.~
1&1
IiiiII
..
II.
~~:"'~" , "Augult'20,1985 ;,1" r,',!":,,.t.
'~'It...i:"'i"" _": ., -:,',,~~w~
,t~~'~'¿~~Rì~In LII'I' roR 'l'B1 MARCO ,II~D~OMM~ln PARK - APPROVID WI'1'8nl,:" ,.~;-jf~!
.}';':>5,OOOIQUARI'fOOT MULTI-PURPOSI 8UILDIIIQ ÞD 8IDS TO II LIT OM ALL.,<",,:~~'_
~;,"""I" PRIORITY ITEMS ' ,,',> , " " .. , ".. "
,.~- ""~~ ...:.', ,;.' .:~.
PUbUcSetvicu Admlnhtrator Norton stated that two weeks ago,~, ..,:..~~~~-" ,- ,
the Board'sent the Ha rco Ial and Haster Plan back to the pa rks ,'':~r't'-:
~ ''''1''-1' """ .
Recreation Advisory Board to ask them to prioritize the Hat of items ".:'!t3Ìt
"':~':'>M'~'
to be placed in the community park. He stated that there were three
stipulations which were to leave the community center on the Master
Plan, leave the drainage ditch unfilled, and to attempt to salvage as
much square footage as possible for the multi-purpose indoor facility.
He stated that the recommendation is that the Board approve the pri-
ority list as shown in the Executive Summary and ,that Willlon, Miller,
Barton, 5011 & Peek, Inc. be authorized to proceed with preparation of
the bid specifications.
Commissioner Pistor stated that the Board approved the Master Plan
without any changes, adding that it was not stated to attempt to
salvage as much square f~~tage as possible in the multi-purpose indoor
facility. He stated that he w~uld have asked that such a condition not
be includ...d because a building under 5,000 square feet is nt,)t worth
spending money on as it would not be large enough.
Mr. Tom Peek of Wilson, Miller, Barton, 5011 & Peek, Inc. stated
that two weeks ago, he told the Board that it was his recommendatit,)n
that the building be a minimum of 5,000 square feet as that is an
appropriate size to deal with. He stated that in the deliberations
with the Marco Island community groups and the Parks & Recreation
Advisory Board, th~y were concerned about getting the broadest number
of user facilities for the people and they elected to recommend the
3,500 square foot facility.
Mr. Thomas Kalbfus, representing the Marco Island Taxpayers
Association, stated that the money available should b. spent for those
facilities that would be used by the most people, adding that the plan
recommended is based on having something of everything. He noted that
the mUlti-purpose building of 5,000 square feet is the most useable
facility and that the $75,000 maintenance facility is not necessary for
the maintenance of the park site, adding that the maintenance facility
would be funded through tho CapItal Improvement Fund. He stated that
grading and grassing of the area should be done as soon as possible and
that the means of irrigation by wells should be explored for the park
aOOK 088 PACt 503
Page 15
, .
--,_., "---.-
---..-,,-....,''''''...-'-............".'.'.' .-,
" ........'~.._._---
."
.J "
.)......,..,..,..,,-'
~.../~.
;~:;, .
"'w',
;;ë( :,',ôlÍlt OB'8rAGt504. Auguat 20, 1985
~~::~,à1te~ He noted that the Taxpayers AaÍl'oc:1ation 11 ..king that the
,'- '~,' ....' ",_.', n..~!." ' ~
' ' ~','y:"d..tgn for a 5,000 aquare foot building be authorized, and that bid. b. ,.".it:~'
~;~'?pr'paredand that no other funds be c:ommi tted until the actull coat of
'~"i:'.' 5~OOO .quare foot building 11 determined. He atated that the choice
'&;ì¡<;~; i< 11, between a 5,000 aquare foot building that w1l1 be uaeful to a large
:~), 'nUftber of people or a variety of improvementa that wi11 be uaefu1 to a
''''~''''
small number of people. He atated that another iaaue ia whether Marco
Ialand should be required to fund a County maintenance facility or
whether thia should be funded from County-wide Capital Improvement
budgeU.
Ma. Brangaccio stated that the maintenance area in all the
community parks is being paid out of the bond money. She noted that
the ~ster Plan doe. have a 5,000 square foot multi-purpose facility,
adding that the estimated cost i. $375,000 and if this is done, the
items on the Executive Summary dated August 20, 1985, could be built
through Item 7.
Commissioner Voss stated that if the multi-purpose building ia
built on pilings and there was a covered recreation area under it, this
would eliminate the need for the other covered recreation area.
Mr. Peek stated that there were two different uses for tho..
covered areas, adding that the intent of r3ising the building would
provide 8 feet of clearance under it for shuffleboard or other such
activities. He noted that the covered area that is identified as a
separate item is one that could be used for volleyball and basketball.
He stated that he thinks that the construction of the maintenance
buildings on ~rco Island is appropr late as all the other parks wll.l
have basically the same type of maintenance area.
Mr. Burton, member of the Parks & Recreation Advisory Board,
stated that the mUlti-purpose building is on the ~ster Plan as a 5,000
square foot bUilding, adding that the reason that 3,500 square feet is
being recommended at this time is because they are trying to get more
activities included in the park. He stated that the Parks & Recreation
Advisory Board did not want to take the position of excluding any of
the item. in favor of a 5,000 square foot building, but the 5,000
.quare foot building may be less expensive to build at this time then
add on later. He stated that it i5 the decision of the Board whether
to exclude some of the items and go with a 5,000 square foot building
or build a 3,500 square foot building with more recreational items.
Commissioner Pistor stated that he thought the Master Plan was
Page 16
c:::J
..
-
~.~!II"-
1'___"""'~
--",....---
-.;:,) "'i?~(~'~?" ,:,."i":,.:"~'~~'#~~':'~~: '~';~>1';"i"
Ij¡¡1
,-::i
:;:
:~}:;,:,,;S~
~fiSi.~.,~':-, , " AugUlt 20, 1985 . ,¡,,~;>:';~t~:
;~:'~prov.i ~tth theS,OOO aquarefoot facUity anð that the rest of ~t~.'::[.);'~
~'~~~~~,~,'tìñìa 'Wt'r.' to go ðut for bid and th.n buUd what can ,b' buUt w1th' ~h"'r~~!¡
4,:~\f~11.bl"~.on.y.,. , . ..~'!.'.. "j;4rt
~';:I:;;"i'+j~::'\'.:;:~:Mr., .Bl1rton.stated that he haa no problem with approving t~. MI'~~~~
~~\i;<~:'Pl.n with the 5,000 square foot bulldln<) and puttin<) the prioritized, ,{~l:;¡:>
~.:·~:,1'ltema out for bid.
~,~'
':.", Commissioner vo.s question.d what is going to be done about
irrigation, to which Mr. Peek stated that the water in the lake has
b.en test.d and it haa b.en determin.d that the water quality cannot b.
used for irrigation. He stated that at this time, the park will have
to b. irrigated out of the potable water system.
Commiesion.r Voee etat.d that if Bahia gr~ss is us.d inst.ad of
B.rmuda 9rass, it would not have to be irrigat.d.
Mr. Pe.k indicated that the Bahia 9rass would turn brown, but the
plants are goin9 to nead irrigation and it is going to b. expensiv..
CommJ~sioner plator stated that wh.n bids are let, both Bermuda
grass and Bahia grass could be included.
Co..i..ioner Pi.tor .oved, .econded by Co.-i..ioner Goodnt9ht and
carried unant.ou.ly, that the priority list for the Marco I.land
Coaaunity Park be approved with the 5,000 .quare foot .ulti-purpo.e
indoor facility and that Wi1eon, Miller, Barton, Soll , P..k, Inc.
proceed with the bid specifications to l.t the bid. a. aQon .. po..lbl.
on all priority it....
n.. 114
RISOLUTIOM 85-177 COMCIIUIING THB COMSTRUCTIOM or PAIUtIMG FACILITIES AT
CLAM PASS PARK - ADOPTED
County Attorney Saunders stated that this item was put on the
agenda at the request of the Seaqate Property Owners Association,
addin9 that this resolution guarantee. the A.sociation that when and if
a parkin? lot i. built to service the access with Clam Pas. Park, that
members of the Seaqate Property OWners Association will have the
opportunity to review the plans and specifications of the parkin<) lot
to make sur. that certain concerns they have are addressed In t~.
construction of the parking lot. He stated that the resoluti~n do.s
provide that, although the As.oclation may comment on the plans and
specifications, the final decision will rest with the County Manager as
to actual design and construction.
Commission.r Voss questioned if the County Manager wanted to
accept that responsibility, to which County Manager Lusk replied
lOOK 088I'Af,£ 505
Pa9' 17
---
'\ \;, ,~'~
',~; f
....',
j¡....... ..
~}..,~'i·":
~\ '
~~\-~
~i::".:~";.i ;:":~;~í<,;:~', ".' ',: .,'ì';,C:,';
~~":~';ifJ(.~:,.,;,(£.¡}¡~, , , "",,",r,¡.""k ,I...·
""V·'·"1.: niì· "ì":'·....i.;'I.""~'.', ,~;,' ,", :.:,:~;o;;.,.,.¡:, ~"""U9U.t' 20,' 1985
""~:t . """"'~n~"" ", '..... . ... "
I:"~ I, "., ,.!iV4~\"'~':'::"" ,'. ,~1\~,1 :~;\ '\, I., "
" :~~V¡Lô'u~ou~i~~;' ~epr..e~d~cPt~~:;~.9a'te' Property owner. i'''' ~,,';~[;,f.;
4'·"'~:r.f ·...'Q',:f~~f;,,'..'<' :', ~ _ ,.', ' " , , ~"",, "~
""',lo9Ia,,lon lltatecf-thUthey .ar.ple'",ed that the ,Board 18 con.iðettng
. th.~~·~~PO'< .ìtcSr..óludon. ~.' .""./, ',' ~..,:.~'~
",,-~:,t:"~'~'~:~,í~~,_',_;.,. .' _ . f .t ';.' ..~-;~¡..
:f..... .5~'';;...'l':,.';,d{I.,:'" (' " ..I", . (~,"':...
~,' ,!t~. ".¡'$.'.!...,~.... ,:\
·;~Ü.;~MI. ."Boulton ,Itated that in March, Ihe talked with the curUnt'>
:'1'1'."",'1/ ,~ " .
,,:¡~.hff·.bout ,the plans, adeUn; .that they recognized the need for '.ollle.,,~.,.;',
~).." type of protection inSugate and' IU99uted that they would wor~ on a;!~';~':J::>
j",,"::' cooperative bash with Pelican Bay and the Registry Hotel to get a' "
t.t"compromise plan that would protect the homunext to the parking lòt. ~
~,"." She noted that the IU99utionl that were made by staff was that the
,'-'''
parking lot be moved a. far north al pos.ible, that a wall be built on
the Saa9ate line and that there be heavy landscaping to the north of .
the wall. She stated that she is reques~ing that the resolution be
adopted.
County Att~rney Saunders stated that the items that were discussed
consisted of some fencing between the parking lot. r.nd the canal acro..
the way from the homes in the Seagate property owners area. He stated
that he did not want any confusion between a wall and a fence. He
noted that the landscaping was discus..d with the possibility of havl~9
a 10-15 foot wide landscape buffer and h. did not want any confusion
between a buffer area and heavy landscaping.
Co..i..loner Piltor .oved, ..conded by Coamillloner Goodn1Vht and
carried unan1.ouIly, that Re.olutlon 85-177 concerning the construction
of parking facilltl.s at Cla. pa.. Park be _dopted.
1; '. ~
" .
Page 18
~'\.:
~t,1
~~~
~,:;.
;~;S '
~'"
~""";'
,"',
fiT
11m
..
..
,. ';""~:
--,",,'",,-,,-,--'.
_,_*""_~.-.-.,.,...__o___..'"~,"'~__o_...
.i~-.~". ,~. ,,'~~;~~~;{~::'~";~;'I:<~;\':"';."'" ':\, :";";'.)~~~¡:;7j~·"~">;
i'. ',."... . ' ,';,:¡ '".",',....
, " , ' ,.t)'~~~ "~:;~,'~,:' .~; '. .. ",'t ' ..
'. ',~ ") .,..,..". , ',. t '~'.,..
~. " ~'''',.'''''', ·"':''?''~'"I:~~··' ....",',.¡' ,;-'1-
;'"';:;.~ ")~'~>;.~¡~,:;.~.
jd, ,{t, , "
," ,." ',.,' .w. ...~ ,",f t
.)',-", "..: " ~..... . ~..r. \ ~
.'......,'-.1 ''''''''''«~);,l:~~ 'J.',,~ .' ;,. r',I
~ ,¡} ~"'i ..... ':~',~~;;< ,r "1",,"', ;f ',. . . ",
...fie', .,,~..,Ä " g .,'¡':' Au...u.t 20, 1985
. ;~...~, .- ";,. 088 ;ACt 50 ' ;:'¡, .;' ," "l"
:'In. .. " ' , . .' s~ . '"
".. ~"ä~~'~\r';bíNô' Ì'ORn':Pri~~èY 0' BOA~if7Wt"'.~RD iJ'O'ŠDP~R,.
'" D',UGAL-:ÞlraSI'O' ,BOARD MIKIIRB, MAtiAGEMIM'f STAfr IdID LIGAL &'fAn ''''"'
'ADOPTID~~~COUNTYATTORMIY DtRICTID TO DRAFT RISOLUTtOM INTO ORDIMAMCI'
,..,;~~. ';h;;:?~tÎ~ort'i~y;såund.ra stat.d thAt it has bun the pOl1êi·'~l:t~...
,'.,: '~":". ~ ,~...f!. ,r ' , " " , ,_, .. ' " '..', ),
,:'8o'¡i4.'toprotect the management .tAffand the m.mb.rs of th. Comllll..tori?'t:~
:~:~~::"w1t:h rupect to being sued individually for damag.. or other typ.. òf' )~~:,~;:\'
r," ':'''''';'.." ' , ' ."" :~'~'.
~';;ì, hgal action. be1n9 taken aga1n.t incHvidual staff ..em'beu and Comlllh:",,~,i,:
~', .''0 ' ' ~'Sl,~"
~,¡.;,;"' .ton.rs. He atated that th.r. waa aome concern a. to wh.ther the ,", ~ ",\
~~""'\'
~~' policy ha4 been formalIzed, therefor. a resolution wa. drafted to
~¡t. formalize the policy which indicat.. that certain ataff memb.r. Ihted
in S.ction 1 of the Resolution as well a. the Board of County Commi.-
.loner. are to b. protected in terms of having repre.entation and to b.
indemnified in the event that th.re are claims filed a9ainat them for
activit1.es arising out of their elllp10yment. He stat.d that the resolu-
tion specifically state. that if there is any willful wrongdoing on the
part of the individual that this r.so1ution will not protect them.
Co..i..lon.r Ha... aov.d, ..cond.d by Co.-i..ion.r Pi.tor and
carrl.d unanlaoualy, that a..olutlon 85-178 ..ttlng forth the polley of
tbe Board vith r.gard to the .upport and l.gal d.f.n.. of Board
..aber., ..anag..ent .taff and l.gal .taff b. adopt.d.
co..l..lon.r vo.. .tat.d that a r..olutlon 1. ea.l1y change4 and
h~ f.el. for futur. purpo.e., thl. r..olutlon .hou14 b. advertl.ed and
adopt.d a. an ordinanc.. It va. the c¡.n.ral con..n.u. that the County
Attorn.y pr.par. .uch an ordinanc..
", !
, ~ '
; "
"'>:.
, ,"):~~~',
";:íf'~,,'~
'';~J:, -
" ,~'
',n~
"";¡/Ç¡'
,F:
...;4-'~
::,i£6
.".~
':;;$1.'
"~
" ';"/:,'
""""""1:
';';$Jt
>':~i~~
"J¡,
~i'.:.'
; ~J";.,~, t
Page
.' \ ' .
'.~' " ..~/,".
..
..
..
_1__,,___'_.'·__'<I'ta__,
,_.,_,__,_..,,,,,__~,..,,,,,,,....~-,-,,..,:,,,,,,;,,,," ",,,,,",,,,,,,,,",~,,,,,,,,,,,,..,,,,..,,,,.._o<~
, ,
..
........'
~,
.,'
'..'"
IIiiiI
-
',.
'1i
'1','
;~~,,;,,~,
t¡,.,··"
'~..~~.. .U
.i.t ' ..
./~:,,(:fROU1'I"1 BILLS - APPROVED rOR PAYNIN'!'
1fr;'<~>'~"fPur;suant to Ruolution 81-150, the following checks were Issued
~;~<...~. t.'hr'~~h'Friday, Auq'ust 16, 1985, in paym~nt of routine MUss
'...t~::', 'CHECK DESCRIPTION CHECK NOS'. AMOUNT
'f~,">,· -
'i.:' Vendor 132085 - 132290 $996,894.59
'~t;"
'\.
AU9I.:St: 20, 1985
. Ite. 117
BUDGIT AMENDMENTS 85-385/386, 85-388, AND 85-390/391 - ADOP'!'ED
Coui..lon.r pi.tor .ov.d, ..cond.d by Co..i..ion.r H.... and
carried unani.ou.ly, that Budg.t Amend..nt. 85-385/386, 85-388, and
85-390/391 be adopted.
It.. 118
COMMISSIOIIIRS PUTOR, BASSE, AIID GOODlfIGBT SILICTED '1'0 SIRVE 011 TBI
PROPERTY APPRAISAL ADJUSTMENT BOARD
Co..ission.r Holland aov.d, seconded by Co.-i..lon.r Vo.. and
carrl.d unani.ou.ly, that Co.-i..ioner. Pistor, H.... and Goodnight be
..lected to .erv. on the Property Appraiaal Adjuataent ao.rd.
Co..l.aion.r Pi.tor .oved, .econd.d by Co.-i..ion.r H.... and
carried un.ni.oualy, that tb. Ad.ini.tr.tiv. A.alatant to tb. Board be
authoriz.d to contact the School Board for two repr...nt.tive. for the
Property Apprai.al Adjuata.nt ao.rd.
It.. 119
RBSOLUTIOII 85-179 APPOIII'1'IIIG, REAPPOINTING OR CONFIRMING APPOINTMEIIT or
MEMBIRS TO THI COLLIER COUNTY CODI ENFORCEMENT BOARD - ADOPTED
Administrative Assistant Israelson stated that the resolution in
the backup material is incorrect in that it states that Mr. Ford .hall
b. appointed to a three-year term in the cateqory of -Businessman-
which ahould read that Mr. Ford shall be appointed to the remainin9
two-years of a thr.e~year term In the cate90ry of -Busineasman-.
Co..i..ioner Piator .ov.d, ..cond.d by Co.-Ia.ion.r Bolland and
carri.d unani.oualy, that R..olution 85-179 appointing, r..ppolntlng or
conflr.lng appointa.nt of .e.b.ra to the Colli.r County Cod. Inforc.-
..nt Board be adopt.d.
'001(
08'8 par;~ 511
Page 20
17' . r:rr.. ".
. -----""""-".,..'-"
. ....._-"'-,,----,-"".*..,.._~~--,.
.... .¥~;~. ,t
¡þ. ',<~:\, .' ::··:.~'~~~''Pf'1 :-ì:;ì~'
,~:'
~~.'('.;'I'
. í.':088·~Ar.t514
. te.UO",,:..I:
. -;:'trlf~"-;. J':~'__:~ -,:(. ' . . , ' "
CáMKIISIOMKR PllTOR ~D COUXTY MANAGER LUSK SELKCTID TO CO OM THE
"::8WKDIIB RISOURCI RICOVERY rAC1LITUS TOUR AIID PRISIMT A fULL RIPOR'!'.' ',~;,-~.
. tUPOM RETUIUUNC _ APPROVED ,~ "'1\~~,...
.. "'shtant County Manager Dorrlll stated that thh item 18 a ,.I: :~:.,,;;¡
) l~·t''¡¡.~
recommendation to allow two county participants to travel to Sweden to . .': ~~'~~
visit the resource recovery tacility. He stated that a tinal deci8ion ,~~,
and reservations cannot be changed after August 28, 1985, which i8 WhY"'~;;:S;
"'.;~,:,
this item is being presented at this meeting. He noted that Dr. ,,~:
Stokes, who is working on a retainer to the County, haa coordinated an
opportunity to participate with the Swedish Export C~uncil, in con-
junction with the American Public Power Association, a tour of resource
recovery waste-to-energy facilities in Sweden. He stated that the
program is being heavily subsidized by the Swedish Export Council, as
well as ~he Power Generating Association to allow represen-
tatives trom our country to look at the two types of prevailing tech-
nologies in the field today, which is the circulating fluid beds as
well as mass burn technology. He stated that the trip will depart from
New York on September 14, 1985, and will return to New York on
September 22, 1985. He stated that all arrangements are being made by
the Export Council and the trip subsidy will be shared by both
participants and the two sponsoring agencies. He stated that the total
cost to Collier County from New York woul~ be $1,300 per person which
includes all transportation, all meals, all lodging and all per diem
cost associated with the one week tour. He stated that this w~uld
provide the County with 8n opportunity to see both of the prevailing
technologies without any particular influence by or over the trip based
on a manufacturer. He noted that it is Dr. Stokes' recommendation that
the Chairman of the Soard and the County Manager participate in this
tour. He stated that Dr. Stokes did not have any particular interest
in going.
Commissioner Voss indicated that he did not have any desire to
attend. Commissioner Pistor indicated that he would be willing to go
t.
','
,I" .
Auquat 20, 1985
on the tour.
Commissioner Hasse stated that he feels that Mr. Kuck, the County
Engineer should participate in such a tour.
County Manager Lusk stated that within the next two months thø
Board will be voting on committing the County to approximately 20 years
at a cost of $50 million and it may be the most important issue this
paqe 21
II!:C3
11::1
-
"..~_..."".._-----,",
.--...""",.,,'0;,. "'_..,_~"......,.'.,_.....-.-_,,__.__
.;'''~' ,~,., "....~..:'~"\
'~ "
;..~,I<~. ~,':':'.',:' "', '\'I::,?:~f./1'~
..
1&1
~
-f: ~
t
.~.Jj~-""~
~"
~~,',~;',t",
~_:,:~~~'; .~'
ii~ril" - :¡~\~"!
, , ~~,~]',~~ård will decide this
,·~'l.ast one Commluloner
,\,., .', ' .
. . ,¡?:it!hh country but there is not a fluidiz.d bed which may cut the coat In "::r~l;:,"
~t~,:" half. He noted that 80me member of the Commission should see this type' ".",
~~, ,
,.",. at operation.
~"
,,' AaI1.tant County Manager Dorrill stated that there are no
circulating fluid bed r.s~urce recovery plant. in the United State..
Commissioner Holland stated that this County will be the first to
try this process and it seems .tranqe that somethinq i. beinq
recommended that has never been tried in this country.
County Manaqer Lusk stated that if it is a process that really
work., it would be the be.t thing for this County, but somebody needS
to be sure that it really works.
Commissioner Voss stated that Commissioner Pistor has indicated
that he woul~ be willing to go with the County Manager and that upon
their return, there should be a written report presented to the
Commissioners.
Co..i..io~er VO.. .oved, .econded by Co..l..lon.r Goodnlqht and
carried 3/2, (Co.-i..ion.r. B.... .nd Bo11.nd oppo..d) that
Co..l..ion.r PI.tor and County Man.g.r Lu.k r.pr...nt the County on the
Swedi.h Re.ource Recovery ~.ci1itie. Tour .nd pre.ent . full written
report to the Co..l.alonera upon their r.turn.
Assistant C~unty Manager D¢rrill stated that he will confirm the
arrangements and the only additional cost to the County will be
transportation between Naples and New York, adding that he is assuming
that the motion includes that. He noted that the trip originate. in
Hew York and the cost associated with that was in the memo presented to
the Commissioners.
August 20, 1985
year. He noted that it ia important that at
attend, adding that there ia maas burning in
Ite. 121
PITITION TR-84-14C, ARMOHD MASTANDREA, REQUESTING PIHAL 3 MONTH
TEMPORARY RESIDENCE PERMIT FOR PROPERTY AT 481 LOGAN BLVD. - DENIED
Commissioner Hasse stated that there has been very little progress
made on this construction site.
Community Development Administrator Mullins stated that the
trailer has been at this site for a period of one year, adding that
there was an error on staff's part. She noted that July, 1984, they
were given their six month permit and did not have their buildin;
permit until February, 1985. She not.d that there was an inspection
for a temporary pole and they also received a three month extension
aDD« 088 PA(.{ 515
Pa",_ 22
"
.iii"~ .... ,,'. ;, ,,"',
,;'
~.~,,~ ;:~ ~';,~~~ "·i¡Ç,f,,.*,,:..:it
. ~'
,~~ ,~.~, ">,' ""R Augu.t 20, 1985 ' :::, ,~;,.:~~~~~;I:
;¿~.I.MfJarf~~f¡'av. ...pl... In ...y..... ...t.. <hat thay .... n.t1f1.d'~;~t
~~:1"-i:on.;,;1lln.,..121 1985, that their trall.r permit would .xpire on July 19,,.f~:""P';
. )9íf5'~.~u..Sh.;noted ·that on July 22, 1985, thap.t1t1on.r calli' In "for. :>~'...:'"
~~ka'tif1nàlthU' 'month ut.ndon. She Indlcattdthatthe ·onîY·.j'thln9 ?~',
". '~t.thát,^h.. b..n don. h .om. hnd clearinCJ and .0111. f1111nCJ of the ait,r~'Y;!i!;,~..
L~:t-~,~" , ., ' ' ,"' ,~~¡"~:,.¡,,~~. '."
¡ ,"'. She .tat.d that there h a ..ptic and w11 .ytelll but th.n has been no <'...,'
)I..,.t
offici.l In.p.ction. noted.
co..i..ton.r H.... aovad, ..oond.d by Cout..lon.r PI.tor, ~at
P.tlt,ton TR-84-l4C, Araond Ma.tandraa, requ..tln9 the ..eond and final
thr.. aontb t..porary r..td.nee per.it for property at 481 Loc¡an
Boul.vard be d.ni.d.
Mr. Joe Grimm of Golden Gate Estate. stated that in July, 1984,
the petitioner had permi.sion from the Board to obtain. tr.iler p.rlllit
and did .0 without obtaining a building permit. He nQted that in
February, 1985, the petitioner app.ared before the Board and .tat.d
that h. was re~dy to pour the foundation and had obtained a building
p~rmit the previous day. He reported that prior to May, 1984, he had
obtained telephone service. He indicated that he installed a driveway
and culv.rt without any permit. He noted that the only inspection mad.
was for temporary power. H. stated that in February, 1985, the Board
granted the petitioner a 6 month extension, and it s.ems clear that the
p.titioner does not intend to build a reaidence and he ia aSking that
the Bo.rd deny the petition.
Upon c.ll for th. que.tion, the ~tion carri.d unani.ou.ly~
It.. 122
RESOLUTION 85-180 ALTERING BOUNDARIIS 1M PRECIMCTS WITHI. TBI COUNTY -
ADOPTED
Commissioner Voss stated that Superviaor of Elections Morgan haa
a.ked that a resolution be adopted in order to adjust precinct line. to
reflect annexations in the City of Naples done October, 1984, and July,
19&5, and adjust one line for better delineation in preparation for the
Cenaus.
Co..i..ion.r H.... .ovad, ..cond.d by COllale.ion.r Pi.tor and
carried un.ni.ou.ly, that R..olution 85-180 alt.ring boundaria. in
pr.cinct. within the County be adopt.d.
Page 23
I.I:CI
m:s
-
"'~_,___,___,,uu
-,.....,._-,<>~-'.">' "'.~ "",."".._..,._'''"-,~_._-,,,'~',-...--..''''"''-
'~f'"·
~,:~
:~'-
~'-' /,'
~ ,,., ..,'." ''''',''
~L, , lOoK\'riS8:p~G~;522
,:í¡:'~ It.. 123
~~.:,' aUILDII1G -B- 'J'() BAVI ASBISTOS RIMOVlD 1M LUU or BUILDUIQ -A- rORAII
~{:" ADDITIC»IAL CBARGI OF $50,500 BY W. '1'. STEPH!NS CONSTRUCTI0M - APPROVED
~"
,-,,{:'
·~'K
.",",.,
,/"
August 20, 1985
Commissioner Voss stated that this is in reference to the a.bestos
and indicated that instead of removing the asbestos in Building wAw at
this time, it is being requested to remove the as~estos in Building wBw
which is the Health Department. He n?ted that they would be moved into
Building WAW temporarily.
County Manager Lusk stated that Building wAw has only a total of
7,000 square feet that needs asbestos removed from it, adding that the
Health Department has 12,000 square feet of asbestos to be removed. He
stated that this is the cause of the additional $50,500. He noted that
the reason that Building "A" is not being done at this time is that it
is too incover\ent for the Judges, so when that building is remodeled,
it will be done then.
In answer to C~mmiRR1oner Holland regarding the standards of the
asbestos in these buildings, ASsistant County Manager Dorri1l stated
that none of the airborne particle samples exceed levels that would
force the County to remove it, but it was the consensus that there was
a situation that was deteriorating which is why there has been an
asbestos program for two years.
County Attorney Saunders stated that under federal law the
asbestos has to be removed either when their is a major renovation or
when the building is torn down, but at some point in time, regardless
of the condition of the asbestos, it has to be removed.
Co.-i..ioner Pistor moved, seconded by CODDi.sioner Goodnight and
carried unani.ously, that Building wB- have the asbe.to. removed in
lieu of Building -A for an additional charge of $50,500 by W. '1'.
Stephens Construction.
***** CODDissioner Pistor moved, .econded by Commi.sioner Goodniqht
and carried unanimously, that the following it.m. under the
con.ent agenda be adopted and/or approveda *...*
Ita. 124
PETITIOH TR-85-4C, GEORG! CORZINE, JR. FIRST 3 MONTH TEMPORARY
RESIDENCE PERMIT IXTE~SION ON THE N 165', TRACT 103, UNIT 7, GOLDEN
GATE ESTATES
Ite. 125
BID 1867 POR MEDIAH CURB COHSTRUCTION FOR GOLDEN GATE PARKWAY - AWARDID
TO H. W. BEADDOIN , SONS, IN THI AMOUNT or $36,709.50
Page 24
a:::I
..
..
. ,~.'. '''t',;,¡.;::·;'~~·:.r.'?,__:.-:J?''6~+.',
.'!\è':'Ö'o' J". <.J""'~;~'~"<.~~~_iii#{,.~"',,,,,,
--,.----'""'"-',, ...'...--.,.,'"'..",,-,----"';
"~,--"""","",..',."','---""'_...---'-
'Auqust20, 1985
~' " ,: Leqa1' notice havinq been pUbliihed in the Napl.. Daily Ne"S on ' ¡, "
~r::~'~:âU1Y, ~3, 1'985, .1 evidenced by Affidavit of Publication fUed with th.;t~:.;
, ~~~f ,,"¡Clerk, bid. were received for conltructlon ot m.cHan curbs for Golden ,', ;~
~:..:-' '."Oat. Parkway until 2130 P. M. Auqust 7, 1985.
~%~"IÌ 126' ,
. t;';', 'BID 1842, LAIID CLIARING MID OPEII-BURIIING or RIGHTS-or-WAY PROM SArrA
[;.. BARBARA BOULEVARD IXTIHSION TO DAVIS BOULEVARD - MfARDID '1'0 HARPIR
., BROTHERS, INC. IN THE AMOUNT or $22,600
Legal notice having been published in the Naple. Daily Ne"s on
Jun. 26, 1985, and July 3, 1985, as evidencdd by Affidavit of
Publication filed with the Clerk, bids were received for lend clearinq
and open-burning of rights-of~way from Santa Barbara Boulevard
Extension to Davis Boulevard until 2:30 P.M. August 1, 1985.
Ite. 127
LA~B TRAFFORD MEMORIAL GARDENS CEMETERY DEED NO. 429
See Page ...s :1.t.
',...
," ., f~,'~'~:_~'·~""'" ~'.~
,....
'"," ~,
" ,
·'r~
IIiIi¡¡
~
It.. US
AUTBORIZATIOII TO ADVERTISI MID RICIIVE PROPOSALS FOR IHGIIIIIRING
SERVICIS FOR FOUR LANB ROADWAY DESIGN SIGMINTS OF RAT'l'LISIIAKI BAKMOCK
ROAD, RADIO ROAD, AND C.R. 951. SELECTION COMMITTEE APPROVED
Selection Committee: Neil Dorrill
Tom Kuck
George Archibald
It.. 129
MISCELLANEOUS CORRESPONDENCE - rILED AND/OR REFERRED
There being no objection, the Chair directed that the following
correspondence be filed and/or r~ferred to the various departments as
indicated belowl
1. Letter dated July 31, 1985, from DER re amendment to Section
17-4.245, Florida Administrative Code (F.A.C.), concerning
requirements or secondary standards for installations
dicharging to Class G-ll ground water. xc: Mr. Dorril1,
Filed.
2. Letter dated August 2, 1985, from DER and notification of form
application (Fi1ea Nos. 111069075, 111071985 and 111073475),
dredge and fill permits. xc: Ms. Mullins; Dr. Proffitt,
Filed.
3. Memorandum dated 7/30/85 from Fiscal Officer Giles to
Utilities Administrator Crandall regarding financial
statements for period ended 6/30/85. Filed.
am 088 PAG! 523
Pag. 25
1'"'IiII'__IOiI>.-
If .",._~_"'__..~......"'-''',~-'~.
_..""___,....,,"~.....,_"._...,h~ '___""""."'''"~''___
~.~f::;'·~~:~~·~:f~~. ",~'
'áE'S~"';'\> ~<':, "'~. ,
~.,:"'~'(' . .\', .,
;"~~~'\1~"'/;',~~;:: ',.,,;
, ·~::'pª~~~~t.~2,4 . ",:"," "~U~U.t 20, 1985 ...: ~
·;"r··..~~~.{~,l....~'rnnsmtttal' dated .818/85 from HUD"ofhtimate of total ,';'1~, .,,~<
~¿":";.t.< ;,required annual c:o.ntoribuUon. ,from u.s. Daft of Housin,9,',.'}1·~,~
:~~~:(:"::;,,~::>~rban Development.,' XC"" Ms.. .W1l11amsonl Pled. . <:"" ',,;:,
:'J'~J(~1_', " ,~¡' . ,c ' ',','" . " " ' , .. ,...;';"~':~'
'{~;¡;ki'ÌS'. 'i',' N<)t:1ce dated. 8/7/85 from KaunK. MacFarland, Florida Lànd an
4;':i:->t ,'Water AdjudicatorY Commladon,:of l,nforma1conf~renc., ,,:; :.~;',¡. '
'\'Í:-~'"'' : u;'rdin; l)eve1opunt Order lid.' 1'5-2, Vineyard. and ',. '·:t.r~
~:, ":,;.í.~,;,~' Development Order No. 85-3, Le1y. XCS Ms. Branqacclo', MI.<~;'¡~
"':~l~~:."'~,~,~'~'. " ·Mullins, r11ed. - ¡,';t.:~·".,
,*,',~\.\;'·.,~,i:" 6. Notice dated 8/12/85 frolll aeorge L. Varnadoe, P.A., re;atdh!9'<,::.:......
r-~¡. . Development Order No. 85-2, Vineyards reque.Un; motion, for .n,,~:·~,~~i.·,'~·.,'
~,i¡.;: extension of time to respond to petition for appeal. XCI MI.:t'\1<:\~
~ Brangaccio, Ms. Mullin., rlled.,>:;,~
~1:,. 7. Hi nut.. received of Ci ty of Napl.s meeting of 7/17/85. FUed. 'r'"~,':~~
" ""~
':~~¡"
8. Minutes received of EMSAC meet1nq of 7/10/85 and aqenda for,.~
me.tinq of 8/14/85. Filed. ,~~,
9. Minutes received of Parka. Recrution Advhory Board meet1ngj:'::i
of 7/18/85 and aqenda for 8/15/85. Fl1.d.....:;::;:~
10. :<:1
.,~,
."~':~
.'~
'~\
"1f,
,,;¡.
.'.,'~
"..> ',:" , :!I'.~ê\~<!"~' "1~ '
(: ,., ~: >:.....~.," I,,~:~~~~:"\·!'t;;r. <" ,:
;."
>/'1,,'"
Letter dated 7/31/85 from Edwin J. Putzell, Jr., vice
Chairn,.1n, Biq Cypress Basin Board, enclosing 1985-1990 five
year plan for Big Cypress Basin, SFWMD. . FUed.
Ite. 130
CONTRACT WITH E. W. SIVER . ASSOCIATES, INC. rOR RISK MAHAG~EKT
CONSULTING SERVICES
S.. pag.. SJ.7 -S.3()
Ite. 131
BUDGET AMENDMENT INCRIASING FLIIT MAKAGIMENT'S FUlL RIVINUES AND
EXPENDITURES $136,000.
Ite. 132
.' TRACT -1-, MARCO BBACa UNIT SEVIN, APPROVED FOR THI LOC"TIOM OF THE
MARCO ISLAND BRANCH OF THE COLLIER COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY
lIES
..
-
...,.--_.._-"~, -----..--'""--............"'."'..
1'1__lall "IIV' ..."'_ot.....__,.._...._____"·'..""····...·.._,"·""'..._·_..-.'"'
<,"~",",.......'-"-----.-
,~.'~.~~':... ~: .~~' .;,:~',.~~~,~' .1!;
..
, ~~,,;,,:.~,,"':':~<~.
, ."~~,,~,~-r~(;,~.,~~,~~i:~··,;
'11:""
.....'..
.....
''''':''f,'
..
,. "L
..
'.,,'.' ~"
,,!,,-t>
<,.
..
..
r "
'.... 't f, ,~:~ ::'" : '~',!¡ ,.
, "'"Augun, 20, .1985
,,-' ~u. '\.;::/' \; 'f It ~ t"lñ
,.,:.,. ~ ".' <,; ",~ .', , .
\'....,
of the County,
"'. .;' ~ '".
the Chair -Time. llISSA.M.
BOARD or COUNTY COMMISSIONERS/
BOARD or ZONING APPEALS/EX '
orrICIO QûVER~ING BOARD(S) or
SPECIAL DISTRICTS UNDER ITS
CONTROL
.f/.C¿Hf YO", CHAIMA'
" ¡'¡t,
"
.á·
-.i"
,¡
CLERK
- ¿J..C-. .
:Oard on ~../~ /PI-
or as corrected
IDDK 088 PAr.! 525
.I',~ .;.
P89- 27,.
"
,---,.., , ,'"' "",_",~.._,_",.,~..,»~,<"",,,,,",",,~;_,,,,,,,...",,",_""''''''~_"",...",.,.",___~,__"~,_______._,_,>\,,,,,.__..,.,,,,,,______'"""....-.."o>'~,,"'",._""""....,....'<>.-".'." _"'~"',....",ho'=,";>";"~.".,,_,,_,__",·,~....."~_...,·,,....."',,+'....~,,$~-