The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 10/08/2013 Item # 8A 10/8/2013 8.A. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendaton to approve a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida providing for the establishment of a Conditional Use to allow therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling on property less than 20 acres in size within a Rural Agricultural zoning district pursuant to Subsections 2.03.01.A.1.c.19 and 2.03.01.A.1.c.24 of the Collier County Land Development Code. The subject property is located on the southwest corner of Goodlette-Frank Road and Center Street in Section 10,Township 49 South,Range 25 East, Collier County,Florida. [Petition CU-PL20110000719] OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) review staff findings and recommendations along with the recommendations of the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) regarding the above referenced petition and render a decision regarding the petition; and ensure the project is in harmony with all the applicable codes and regulations in order to ensure that the community's interests are maintained. CONSIDERATIONS: The Petitioner has applied for a Conditional Use as provided for in the Agricultural (A) zoning district to expand the currently approved therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling facility onto two additional parcels. The equestrian riding therapeutic program falls into Conditional Use nineteen (19), sport instructional schools and camps located on agriculturally zoned parcels less than 20 acres in size. Additionally the equestrian stabling facility is listed as Conditional Use twenty four (24). The development is currently operating with an approved Conditional Use, CU-Resolution 2000-63 (see attachment), which provides the same two conditional uses listed above however it is limited to lot 21. This petitioner is requesting that the two conditional uses be expanded to lots 20 and 19 (see attached). This equestrian center is located within a neighborhood generally containing both residential and agricultural uses with RSF-1 and Ag zoning districts. The purpose of this petition is to obtain a Conditional Use approval for the equestrian riding and stabling facility as allowed by the Conditional Use section of the Land Development Code (LDC): Conditional Use 19: Sports instructional schools and camps. Conditional Use 24: Agricultural activities on parcels less than 20 acres in size. i. Animal breeding, raising, training, stabling, or kenneling. FISCAL IMPACT: The Conditional Use by and of itself will have no fiscal impact on Collier County. There is no guarantee that the project, at build out, will maximize its authorized level of development. The County collects impact fees prior to the issuance of building permits to help offset the impacts of each new development on public facilities. These impact fees are used to fund projects identified in the Capital Improvement Element of the Growth Management Plan as needed to maintain adopted Level of Service (LOS) for public facilities. Additionally, in order to meet the requirements of concurrency management, the developer of every local development Packet Page-179- 10/8/2013 8.A. order approved by Collier County is required to pay a portion of the estimated Transportation Impact Fees associated with the project in accordance with Chapter 74 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. Other fees collected prior to issuance of a building permit include building permit review fees. Finally, additional revenue is generated by application of ad valorem tax rates, and that revenue is directly related to the value of the improvements. Please note that impact fees and taxes collected were not included in the criteria used by staff and the Planning Commission to analyze this petition. GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) IMPACT: Future Land Use Element(FLUE): Comprehensive Planning staff finds the proposed rezone consistent with the Future Land Use Element. A more detailed description of the GMP consistency is contained in the Staff Report. COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (CCPC) RECOMMENDATION: The CCPC heard petition CU-PL20110000719, Naples Equestrian Challenge on September 5, 2013, and by a vote of 6 to 0 recommended to forward this petition to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval subject to the following conditions of approval which state: 1. No office or business space rental to outside entities. 2. The additional uses on Lots 19 and 20 will not increase the number of program participants by more than 200 participants overall. 3. No participant programs are to be held on Sunday. 4. Special events shall be limited to 4 events per year and follow LDC 5.04.05 temporary event permitting requirements. 5. Maximum building height for principal structures on Lots 20 and 19 will be 25' zoned building height. 6. Ridge Drive setback for principal structures will be consistent with the existing principal structure on Lot 20. 7. Outside lighting shall be limited to low intensity bollards, and no exterior lighting is allowed except as necessary for security and safety. 8. Maximum number of stabled horses on Lots 19 and 20 will be 6 horses. 9. No amplified sound equipment or systems are allowed on Lots 19 and 20. 10. Adjacent to Ridge Drive on Lots 19 and 20 an LDC 4.06.02 Type C landscape buffer shall be provided and a Type B landscape buffer will be provided on Lot 19 between Lots 19 and 18. 11. Landscape buffers will be installed with first vertical construction. Packet Page-180- 10/8/2013 8.A. 12. Maximum parking spaces shall be 52 spaces. 13. The emergency gate on Ridge Drive will be constructed of solid decorative material. 14. Any metal roofing will be colored to remove glare. 15. The hours of operation for the facility will be 8:00 am to 8:00 pm. Occasional staff and volunteer training as well as board meetings may extend to 9:00 pm. To date, a number of letters of objection have been received. Therefore, this petition has been placed under Advertised Public Hearing agenda. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: Before you is a recommendation by the Planning Commission for approval of a conditional use authorizing therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling on property less than 20 acres within a Rural Agricultural zoning district. A conditional use is a use that is permitted in a particular zoning district subject to certain restrictions. All testimony given must be under oath. The attached report and recommendations of the Planning Commission are advisory only and are not binding on you. The Petitioner has the burden of demonstrating that the necessary requirements have been met, and you may question the Petitioner, or staff, in order to determine that the necessary criteria has been satisfied. In addition to meeting the necessary criteria, you may place such conditions and safeguards as you deem appropriate to allow the use, provided that there is competent, substantial evidence that these additional conditions and safeguards are necessary to promote the public health, safety, welfare, morals, order, comfort, convenience, appearance, or the general welfare of the neighborhood. As a further condition of approval of the conditional use, you may require that suitable areas for streets, public rights-of-way, schools, parks, and other public facilities be set aside, improved, and/or dedicated for public use, subject to appropriate impact fee credits. Approval or denial of the Petition is by Resolution. This item has been approved as to form and legality, and requires an affirmative vote of four for Board approval. (HFAC) RECOMMENDATION: Staff concurs with the recommendation of the CCPC and further recommends that the Board of Zoning Appeals approve the request for CU-PL20110000719, Naples Equestrian Challenge subject to the CCPC revisions as previously stated in the CCPC Recommendation section of this Executive Summary. Prepared by: Michael Sawyer,Project Manager Planning& Zoning Attachments: 1) Staff Report 2)Resolution 3)Application 4) Correspondence before CCPC 5) Correspondence after CCPC Packet Page-181- 10/8/2013 8.A. COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 8.8.A. Item Summary: This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Reccomendaton to approve a Resolution of the Board of Zoning Appeals of Collier County, Florida providing for the establishment of a Conditional Use to allow therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling on property less than 20 acres in size within a Rural Agricultural zoning district pursuant to Subsections 2.03.01.A.1.c.19 and 2.03.01.A.1.c.24 of the Collier County Land Development Code. The subject property is located on the southwest corner of Goodlette- Frank Road and Center Street in Section 10, Township 49 South, Range 25 East, Collier County, Florida. [Petition CU-PL20110000719] Meeting Date: 10/8/2013 Prepared By Name: SawyerMichael Title: Project Manager,Engineering&Environmental Servic 9/13/2013 10:41:01 AM Approved By Name: BellowsRay Title:Manager-Planning,Comprehensive Planning Date: 9/13/2013 3:20:26 PM Name: BosiMichael Title: Manager-Planning,Comprehensive Planning Date: 9/18/2013 3:38:06 PM Name: PuigJudy Title: Operations Analyst, GMD P&R Date: 9/18/2013 5:43:47 PM Name: PepinEmily Title:Assistant County Attorney, CAO Litigation Date: 9/24/2013 3:54:32 PM Packet Page-182- 10/8/2013 8.A. Name: MarcellaJeanne Title: Executive Secretary,Transportation Planning Date: 9/25/2013 8:00:38 AM Name: FinnEd Title: Senior Budget Analyst, OMB Date: 9/25/2013 11:44:07 AM Name: KlatzkowJeff Title: County Attorney Date: 9/26/2013 8:41:41 AM Name: OchsLeo Title: County Manager Date: 9/26/2013 1:49:50 PM Alow Packet Page-183- 10/8/2013 8.A. Co er STAFF REPORT TO: COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT GROWTH MANAGERMENT DIVISION,PLANNING AND REGULATION HEARING: SEPTEMBER 5, 2013 SUBJECT: PETITION CU-PL20110000719,NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE PROPERTY OWNER/AGENT: Owner(s): Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. 206 Ridge Drive Naples,Fl 34108 Agent: D. Wayne Arnold,AICP Q. Grady Minor and Associates,P.A. 3800 Via Del Rey Bonita Springs,FL 34134 REQUESTED ACTION: To have the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) consider an application for a Conditional Use pursuant to the Land Development Code (LDC) Section 2.03.01.A.1.c. of the Rural Agricultural Zoning District. The conditional use being requested is as follows: Number 19 and 24, to extend the existing therapeutic equestrian riding facility and stabling development onto two additional parcels that will total less than 20 acres in size. GEOGRAPHIC LOCATION: The subject 4.3± acre site is located at 182 and 194 Ridge Drive, on the east side of Ridge Drive, generally south and west of the intersection of Center Street and Goodlette Frank Road, Lots 19 and 20, Block I, in the Pine Ridge Subdivision, in Section 10, Township 49 South, Range 25 East, Folio Numbers 67185040009 and 67185080001. (See location map on the following page) CU-PL20110000719 Page 1 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised:8-12-13,8-14-13) Packet Page-184- 10/8/2013 8.A. a NO lit 1 411510"1►�o�.° ° ©©. 4�p a o lase©a©© ��©©ooa �o�© 1 ° IA LE ILI F s �© s LI Q o iliV Ili 1 —I INIIIIN � r V�c F Rkr a � 24 321,20•1 .. 3 .U.'3,13222 a•de 8 0a.. E ESW nae a•y 2 OdOa HNbaj_ < 3L1310000 '^ v ____,___ Z .3A120 aoaw 7 Z _ . . N 1110.. Willi # 1P,..,---it z „ . MI 416,10 2 ' TS N J 33S 01 ION ` N D U 4t ..,----a iv Z� avoa No1sONnn II O LNNGSTUN ROAD < WA H 5, A . g a�) _6aV1 NVORid S _ F ii i c .. 0 ° i -! 1 1 Ircail NI al - rIONEMTM. Is 1! .)0 i jun:JIB OcN'ol > ° °�g� ! avoaolnalaodaly aVOa�Nn,nd iN - NTp N ii• ' � and woa 3�a000 IIIM 8„M gi Ian r NNpyd 11133 �U9 . 1C N z 8" ¢ 75�a .�� - b 1 Tl'O1 0000 MNriId 31131a00'J N -- a i, NW �� 1k9.2U -mu.Iwrlwrl ft65'n) lMal 040(001. 11 18 its <C gi $i a In ill * w- - 3gn ��VINO 1VBN3OA f '0111A1111111 GULF OF MEXICO Pi Packet Page-185- 10/8/2013 8.A. J11 R.--! 3 a fli r NN LL (�TJj{ 65a z� C2 m Z .CM J (2 C mZa [ =O N2 W w z w SW UW3dOtld Nlltos O 0 r. I nl II N ;Kati==imilai==l•MiNi=rni=wlNENNl�wilMINlm�lim Ak Ul I M1Yd 3 oIM313NUO]lvntld ,_ W y I, I ! — d i rcu II - , rI 11 1I oy 1II1111w I ''11 Y N1Vd3MIae/3n1tlo31Vntld . > a '' 8 II H I r1 E —-1 OPL EMeEYENT ———— WLEASEMENT Q o W I I i� __ , W J 0 3€ I , L�— r } ik lS I Z • 22 II 1 III $ lo = I zw e° II i Igi I 1WE. a 1 RI— 11 �_ 2 el II 1 1t� r/ l,; (6 § BOrc, z I 'g I , 1 ._.. ` ¢=w . 3ON3i� W it I I ,,-5 oo des I I I i � a ll1 4' I I I 1 113N1 I. e s II 1 Il r- 1 I ti 1 , 81 II 11.E (-11 111 ( x 1I i3i 1 I I I - I It `. I I Nr,EN 1 ' C V IV' ...1 i II , I I� a y � �_ N I I h - r e---R^s a N 1, 1 I I I II II II ' ' iW ' + i It f g I *_ is ilh E. 133MS 31N32 ° — - —_ — — — — hi*8 _------- ' — --- \ / ^ (5 ----------- PHI I \ ri 11 111 it U 1 1 i II I I! II a J Q 0 du; • W z ,- zo >-w _ o� _ _ Q. o ce S < Packet Page-186- 10/8/2013 8.A. PURPOSE/DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT: The Petitioner has applied for a Conditional Use as provided for in the Agricultural (A) zoning district to expand the currently approved therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling facility onto two additional parcels. The equestrian riding therapeutic program falls into Conditional Use nineteen (19), sport instructional schools and camps located on agriculturally zoned parcels less than 20 acres in size. Additionally the equestrian stabling facility is listed as Conditional Use twenty four (24). The development is currently operating with an approved Conditional Use, CU-Resolution 2000-63 (see attachment), which provides the same two conditional uses listed above however it is limited to lot 21. This petitioner is requesting that the two conditional uses be expanded to lots 20 and 19 (see conceptual master plan on previous page). This area generally contains both residential and agricultural uses with RSF-1 and Ag zoning districts. According to the petitioners' application the mission of Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC) is to improve the lives of children and adults with special needs using therapeutic riding and equine-related programs. NEC was established in 1995 at its current location and has been an internationally accredited organization since 2000. In January of this year NEC initiated an equine-assisted program for retired military veterans suffering with post- traumatic stress disorder, traumatic brain injury, and amputation. Currently NEC operates within the limitations of the current conditional use approval which as noted above is limited to lot 21. Currently NEC operates at or near its capacity to meet the needs of its current participants. NEC also uses lot 20 but is limited to horse grazing purposes only. The applicant anticipates that the additional facilities proposed with this CU petition will serve approximately 200 additional children and adults. The facility expansion will allow the various programs noted in the application to operate more efficiently using the two separate riding arena/ring areas and central grazing/principal paddock area. SURROUNDING LAND USE & ZONING: North: Center Street ROW, then developed single family residence and stables, with a zoning designation of Agricultural, (A). East: Goodlette Frank Road ROW, then a developed parcel, with a zoning designation of PUD (Three Hundred Acre PUD). South: Developed single family residence, with a zoning designation of Agricultural (A). West: Ridge Drive ROW, then developed single-family residences, with a zoning designation of Residential Single Family(RSF-1). CU-PL201 1 000071 9 Page 4 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised:8-12-13,8-14-13) Packet Page -187- 10/8/2013 8.A. 4 t . Naples Equestrian Challenge .. I , �' ' Existing CU-Resolution 2000-63,lot 21 i` t� -.\:...,,.... .c., _ a , a a . �@ i Ia :tl ,/ a v �-_,i ,a,. s.a i la • �— -'h ''' - r,: i.- - '}fit ,.' i >k 1 -. { "CI 1 ar+' .~, Ate; .. irk ,. 4 .•1 I r .1,r rr tear �� Lot 20� ° , -+ ' 't m $$ -&� ire^ "" a { ` 1 Y �� Lot 19 -,� p� �� , �_ � �� 445c,, s ° w ''# 9. f l7 r''aiu.. � . yr t J i � '�t ss l �`' C �.. . +a t m .�.. L I.fib t s,,,;.„:::,,,,,''''.44, 6awCCUmv FramtlYA R �.NxZ GROWTH MANAGEMENT PLAN (GMP) CONSISTENCY: Future Land Use Element (FLUE): The subject property is designated Urban (Urban Mixed Use District, Urban Residential Subdistrict) on the Future Land Use Map of the Growth Management Plan. Relevant to this petition, the Urban designation allows agricultural activities as defined in the Land Development Code (LDC). Section 2.03.01.A.1.c of the LDC identifies the proposed uses as Conditional Uses within the Agricultural zoning district. Based on the above analysis, staff finds the request for Conditional Uses#19 and#24 of the Agricultural zoning district consistent with the Future Land Use Element of the Growth Management Plan. Transportation Element (TE): The Traffic Impact Statement (TIS) indicates that the adjacent roadway network has sufficient capacity to accommodate this project within the 5 year planning period. Therefore, the subject application can be found consistent with Policy 5.1 of the Transportation Element of the Growth Management Plan(GMP}. CU-PL20110000719 Page 5 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised:8-12-13, 8-14-13) Packet Page-188- 10/8/2013 8.A. Conservation and Coastal Management Element (CCME): Staff finds the project to be consistent with the Conservation & Coastal Management Element (CCME). This project was not required to go before the Environmental Advisory Council Board (EAC) as it does not meet the required criteria for review by the EAC as found in Division 23, Section 2- 1193 of the Collier County Code of Ordinances. ANALYSIS: Before any conditional use can be recommended to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA), the Planning Commission must make a finding that: 1) granting approval of the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest; 2) all specific requirements for the individual conditional use are met; and 3) satisfactory provisions have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable: 1. Section 2.03.01.A.1.c.3 of the LDC permits conditional uses in the Agricultural Zoning District. The requested use to expand the currently approved therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling facility onto two additional parcels is permitted as conditional uses in the Agricultural (A) Zoning District, subject to the standards and procedures established in section 10.08.00, Conditional Uses Procedures, of the LDC. 2. Consistency with the Land Development Code and the Growth Management Plan. As noted above, this proposal is consistent with the applicable provisions of the FLUE, the Transportation Element and the CCME Element; therefore the petition is consistent with the overall GMP. With the conditions of approval included by staff, the proposal may also be found consistent with all of the applicable provisions of the LDC. 3. Ingress and egress to the property and proposed structures thereon, with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe. As shown on the Master Concept Plan vehicular access to the site is provided on Center Street. With regard to traffic on public right-of-ways, Transportation Planning staff indicates that they have reviewed this petition and determined that there are no outstanding issues concerning vehicular access and traffic control. 4. The effect the Conditional Use would have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic or odor effects. The proposed therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling facility has been in operation on lot 21 for several years as discussed above. It is staffs opinion that the development will continue to address issues resulting from these operations as part of standard best practices procedures as currently observed. Noise and glare from these operations will not be greatly expanded from the current operations with staff recommended conditions of approval 1 and 2. Economic and odor effects should not be greater and relative to CU-PL20110000719 Page 6 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised:8-12-13,8-14-13) Packet Page-189- 10/8/2013 8.A. some of the allowable uses in this zoning district less than those possible in the agricultural district. Based on the current operation of this facility and the information provided by the applicant staff is of the opinion that the proposed project will not generate additional noise, odor or otherwise generate economic impact on the neighborhood. 5. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the district. As previously noted the site is surrounded by single family residential, agricultural and PUD zoned lands all of which are developed parcels Staff believes that with the recommended conditions and the limited operating hours proposed by the petitioner, the project will continue to be compatible with the neighborhood. Staff therefore believes that the propose Conditional Use to allow an expanded therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling facility may be deemed compatible with the neighboring properties. Furthermore, staff believes the recommended conditions of approval adequately protect the public's interest NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING (MM): Wayne Arnold, agent for the applicant opened the meeting at 5:35 p.m. and introduced himself and Sharon Umpenhour with Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A., Kim Minarich, Executive Director of Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC), Brian Dickerson, Attorney representing NEC and Michael Sawyer representing Collier County Growth Management. Six members from the public, as well as several employees of NEC and Board of Directors members of NEC were in attendance. A sign-in sheet was provided. Mr. Arnold began the information meeting by introducing the project and explaining where the project was in the Conditional Use process. Wayne then explained that the existing NEC facility had been previously approved through the Conditional Use process and the proposed expansion to include round riding arena, multi-purpose room and stables required a new Conditional Use. An aerial and site plan were displayed and the areas on the site plan were explained as to what would be where and how it would be utilized. Wayne discussed the existing and proposed relocation of the ingress/egress points in response to discussions with neighbors prior to the informational meeting. Kim Minarich took over the meeting and discussed the removal of an existing cottage to improve the ingress/egress point on Center Street making this the primary access to NEC. Kim explained that there could be an ingress/egress point on Ridge Drive but for emergency vehicle purposes only. Wayne asked Kim to please describe how the organization currently operates and what the proposed expansion would provide to the community and organization. Kim explained their mission statement and how the organization began and how the program has been utilized and expanded over the years. Kim also explained that NEC was an applicant for a HUD Grant and that there were requirements for the grant for the non-profit organization CU-PL20110000719 Page 7 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised:8-12-13,8-14-13) Packet Page-190- 10/8/2013 8.A. Kim explained how the different programs worked and why the need for the Conditional Use. Kim showed on the Site Plan what the existing and proposed buildings would be and how they would be utilized. The additional lot would be utilized for housing 4 additional horses, feed storage and a covered riding area and that the need for the additional lot is due to the increased attendance of the therapeutic riding and other equine assisted therapy programs. The main arena is at capacity and cannot accommodate the need for additional program times. One of the neighbors expressed their opposition to the expansion onto Lot 19 but wanted to clarify that they did not oppose the existing facility and its programs, or expanded programs on the 5± acres currently owned by NEC. Mr. Arnold concluded his presentation and asked for comments or questions from the meeting attendees. Generally, questions were asked on the following major topics, Mr. Arnold and Ms. Minarich responded to the questions generally as follows: 1. Buffers/landscaping The buffer would consist of plant materials per LDC requirements. Mr. Sawyer indicated the minimum buffer would be a 15 foot wide type B buffer along Ridge Drive which would include trees on 30 foot centers with a hedge. 2. Parking/traffic Ms. Minarich provided estimates of existing vehicle trips to the site based on the number of 30 minute riding sessions were provided daily and volunteers required for the program participants. Ms. Minarich indicated that the figures had been provided to Collier County based on a daily hourly estimate. The willingness to move the project access to Center Street was also reiterated. 3. Building size The proposed covered riding arena is a 75 foot diameter design with eave heights approximately 12 feet. The multi-purpose room is approximately 3,000 square feet. The stable area will be a 6-stall design of which 4 stalls are for horses and 2 will be used for feed and tack. 4. Project timeframe Ms. Minarich indicated that the proposed new facilities would be constructed once finances were available and suggested this would hopefully be in a 2 to 3 year time frame. 5. Facility operations CU-PL20110000719 Page 8 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised:8-12-13, 8-14-13) Packet Page-191- 10/8/2013 8.A. Ms. Minarich discussed in detail the grant application, which if awarded, would be used to acquire the subject property. Ms. Minarich also discussed NEC strategic planning and fundraising goals for the organization. Ms. Minarich explained the various riding programs offered at NEC and described how program needs have evolved to include a variety of equine related therapy. Mr. Arnold explained to the neighbors that they would be notified by mail of the hearing dates and that public hearing signs would also be posted on-site. Wayne then offered to provide any additional information if requested and to contact, Kim Minarich, Michael Sawyer or himself if anyone had further questions. The meeting was adjourned at approximately 6:40 p.m. COUNTY ATTORNEY OFFICE REVIEW: The County Attorney Office has reviewed the staff report for CU-PL201100000719 revised on August 14,2013. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Collier County Planning Commission (CCPC) forward Petition CU-PL20110000719 to the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) with a recommendation of approval, subject to the following conditions: 1. The riding ring structure on Lot 19 will not have amplified sound equipment or systems. 2. The hours of operation for the facility will be 8:00 am to 8:00 pm. Occasional staff and volunteer training as well as board meetings may extend to 9:00 pm. Special events may extend to 11:00 pm and follow LDC 5.04.05 Temporary Event requirements. Attachments: A. Draft Resolution. B. Conditional Use Resolution 2000-63. C. Correspondence. CU-PL20110000719 Page 9 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised:8-12-13,8-14-13) Packet Page-192- 10/8/2013 8.A. PREPARED BY: '4j4 . 8.S .13 L IC SAWYE r PROJECT MANAGER DATE PLANNING AND ONING DEPARTMENT REVIEWED BY: / , i . ' 13 RAYM D V. BELLOWS, ZONING MANAGER DATE PLANN G AND ZONING DEPARTMENT MICHAEL BOSI, AICP,DIRECTOR DATE PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT APPROVED BY: Alf !IP NICK CASALANGUIDA, ADMINISTRATOR DATE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION Tentatively scheduled for the October 8, 2013 Board of County Commissioners meeting. CU-PL20110000719 Page 10 of 10 NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CONDITIONAL USE July 29,2013(revised) Packet Page-193- 10/8/2013 8.A. RESOLUTION NO. 13- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CONDITIONAL USE TO ALLOW THERAPEUTIC EQUESTRIAN RIDING AND STABLING ON PROPERTY LESS THAN 20 ACRES IN SIZE WITHIN A RURAL AGRICULTURAL ZONING DISTRICT PURSUANT TO SUBSECTIONS 2.03.01.A.1.c.19 AND 2.03.01.A.1.c.24 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF GOODLETTE-FRANK ROAD AND CENTER STREET IN SECTION 10, TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. [PETITION CU- PL201.10000719] WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in.Chapter 67-1246, Laws of Florida, and Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has conferred on Collier County the power to establish, coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public; and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code (Ordinance No. 2004-41, as amended) which includes a Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among which is the granting of Conditional Uses; and WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals (Board), being the duly appointed and constituted planning board for the area hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of a Conditional Use to allow therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling on property less than 20 acres in size within a Rural Agricultural zoning district pursuant to Subsections 2.03.01.A.1.c.19 and 2.03.01.A.1.c.24 of the Collier County Land Development Code on the property hereinafter described, and the Collier County Planning Commission has made findings that the granting of the Conditional Use will not adversely affect the public interest and the specific requirements governing the Conditional Use have been met and that satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 10.08.00.D. of the Land Development Code; and WHEREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: Petition Number CU-PL20110000719 filed by D. Wayne Arnold of Q. Grady Minor & Associates, P.A. representing Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. with respect to the property hereinafter described in Exhibit "A", be and the same is hereby approved for a Conditional Use Naples Equestrian Challenge,Inc. 1 of 2 CU-PL201 10000719—Rev.9/09/13 Packet Page -194- 10/8/2013 8.A. to allow therapeutic equestrian riding and stabling on property less than 20 acres within a Rural Agricultural zoning district pursuant to Subsections 2.03.01.A.1.c.19 and 2.03.01.A.1.c.24 of the Collier County Land Development Code, in accordance with the Concepts al Site Plan described in Exhibit "B", and subject to the Conditions of Approval found in Exhibit "C". Exhibits "A", "B", and"C" are attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this Board. This Resolution adopted after motion, second, and super-majority vote this day of , 2013. ATTEST: BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA BY: BY: Deputy Clerk GEORGIA A. HILLER,ESQ. Chairwoman Approved as to form and legality: Emily R. Pepin EIZ? c11+\113 Assistant County Attorney Attachments: Exhibit A - Legal Description Exhibit B - Conceptual Site Plan Exhibit C—Conditions of Approval CP\13-CPS-01225\34 Naples Equestrian Challenge,Inc. 2 of 2 CU-PL20110000719—Rev.9/09/13 Packet Page -195- - - - - 10/8/2013 8.A. Exhibit A Legal Description ALL OF LOTS 19 & 20, BLOCK I, OF PINE RIDGE SUBDIVISION AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 3,PAGE 24 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA.BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: BEGIN AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF LOT 20, BLOCK I OF THE PINE RIDGE SUBDIVISION AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 3, PAGE 24 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA.THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID LOT 20, N 90°00' 00" E, A DISTANCE OF 478.94 FEET TO A POINT ON THE EAST LINE OF SAID BLOCK I; THENCE ALONG SAID EAST LINE S 01° 53' 23" W, A DISTANCE OF 400.22 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF LOT 19 OF SAID BLOCK 1; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH L1NE OF SAID LOT 19 N 90° 00' 00" W, A DISTANCE OF 465.74 FEET TO THE WEST LINE OF SAID BLOCK 1;THENCE ALONG SAID WEST LINE N 00°00'00"E,A DISTANCE OF 400.00 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 4.34 ACRES,MORE OR LESS. Packet Page -196- 10/8/2013 8.A. , 11 i b I x YW. a a ,. a N N at 6y s v Q m'z $� 6 mod FA ,'t1 w 2 N o 3111 Alb3bobd 1.111106 Z, U 11 tt III' 1,...1..3311=3�1 331..1..3.13 =13.3.13 =I....,..3.13..133E=1ss 1% 1 1 111 I II 1 (-- luwMIMI/ wuvnw f 1 w I II I II 1 a I III y 1 ICI � 'y I k 1 II1 p 1 II II j 'r lb T1a ,,� �' +la.:, 1 y a 1 III p 1� ig a '. �1" ak . `1 ' g III I p 1 k p 1 W f 11 w 1u II, I I ",- i x 1 > ky N II I I c1 f / a 'I f t y pI I o- _ ) II I I.I.I I � 1 I �� o— i nlw3wbclwwuvnw iv Y w yI I I ,I s — gFR EASEMENT - ----Fn EASEMENT_-.__"Sp - o I' I = 1s I Ia c ii I I I I g 1 I I c I1 I Ii �� o I� I i g..! o I I �7 J 1 ___�J p V't 0 •� - I I a I I I I 1 1 � p . .t 301/34 _I >, • - I' I f .e >� . r I " El, E II 1 I 'W I y I J1 I >s b 11 "3 k 1F1 l' 4 I- li y I ( # 01 )♦ o$E EF! II ( 1 5 k :0.414124,40196.44;. n ' ! I ! [ 5 I 1 °dam r: g R n I 1'� —� i _ I I � �a t p I ' ?V III I� A,— - € _ I I Ia II' II .I 1 1 i33elc r41 a�0 — ——— Ii ii --------------- -T - - - - - __ � € I ! I )1 UI it 1 II I J Q 0 x U 1 H . W 1 W_ I CL to 1 Dm di a1 Packet Page -197- 10/8/2013 8.A. CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR CU-PL20110000719 1. No office or business space rental to outside entities. 2. The additional uses on Lots 19 and 20 will not increase the number of program participants by more than 200 participants overall. 3. No participant programs are to be held on Sunday. 4. Special events shall be limited to 4 events per year and follow LDC 5.04.05 temporary event permitting requirements. 5. Maximum building height for principal structures on Lots 20 and 19 will be 25' zoned building height. 6. Ridge Drive setback for principal structures will be consistent with the existing principal structure on Lot 20. 7. Outside lighting shall be limited to low intensity bollards, and no exterior lighting is allowed except as necessary for security and safety. 8. Maximum number of stabled horses on Lots 19 and 20 will be 6 horses. 9. No amplified sound equipment or systems are allowed on Lots 19 and 20. 10. Adjacent to Ridge Drive on Lots 19 and 20 an LDC 4.06.02 Type C landscape buffer shall be provided and a Type B landscape buffer will be provided on Lot 19 between Lots 19 and 18. 11. Landscape buffers will be installed with first vertical construction. 12. Maximum parking spaces shall be 52 spaces. 13. The emergency gate on Ridge Drive will be constructed of solid decorative material. 14. Any metal roofing will be colored to remove glare. 15. The hours of operation for the facility will be 8:00 am to 8:00 pm. Occasional staff and volunteer training as well as board meetings may extend to 9:00 pm. EXHIBIT C CP\13-CPS-01225\32 Packet Page -198- 10/8/2013 8.A. _;24;2, GradyMinor • Civil Engineers • Land Surveyors • Planners • Landscape Architects May 7, 2013 Mr. Michael Sawyer Zoning and Land Development Review 2800 North Horseshoe Drive Naples, FL 34104 Re:Naples Equestrian Challenge Lots 19 and 20 Conditional Use Application Dear Mr. Sawyer: The enclosed application and exhibits included with this letter are in support of the proposed Naples Equestrian Challenge Lots 19 and 20 Conditional Use petition. The request is to permit Conditional Uses #19 and #24, consistent with the original approval for Lot 21 (CU Resolution Ill Number 2000-063) The property is located at 182 and 194 Ridge Drive on the southwest corner of Goodlette-Frank Road and Center Drive. The subject property is zoned A. The Naples Equestrian Challenge wishes to continue to offer therapeutic riding and equine programs to individuals with disabilities. Please feel free to contact me if you require any additional information. Sincerely, 'I isp D. Wayne Arnold,AICP Cc: Kim Minarich GradyMinor file Q.Grady°'Minor&Associates PA. 2 'x:239-947-0375 Q. y Ph. 39 947-11 F 3800 Via Del r EB 0005151 *LB 00 05151 • LC 26000266 Bonita Sprinbs,FL 34134 www.gradymmor.com Packet Pare-199- 10/8/2013 8.A. Coder Cin,ty COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE 411 GROWTH MANAGEMENT DMSIONI NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 PAX (239)252-6358 www.cofliergov-reef CONDITIONAL USE PETITION . PRE-APPEXCATION MEETING NOTES . _. . . • &z SU I TTJ AL,CFIECILYST • 0119 Date: )2-•I ! • Time: • as ilr.. Project Name: Ia :.l r" � ��tti I s�—. �raR; rit Project Addr/Location: 2.06 1741-1-,F.. t• Applicant Name: Phone: 6 �t • Firm: —' Current Zoning; Owner Name: . Owner Address:_ Phone: Meeting Attendees:(Attach Sign-in Sheet) NOTES: .? �SSv<S bsks-e _IAA . .41 /.i Awn: 6-72A • t j1tE? L.a C 'S - !+mot re;. ec' u s-e a -61'",, 6.14 • • Packet Page -200- 1 0/8/201 3 8.A. Cofer County • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION, NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX (239)252-8358 www.colliergov.net CONDITIONAL USE(CU)APPLICATION SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE:INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. REQUIREMENTS #OP REQUIRED NOT COPIES REQUIRED STANDARD REQUIREMENTS: Cover letter briefly explaining the project E Application (completed& signed) . 10 I download from websife for current form) ✓ *Additional set if located in the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle Redevelopment Area 1 Addressing Checklist signed by Addressing 1 t -- C.onceptuol Site Plan 24' X 36" plus(one 8 t/z X 11 copy) 1e" >�.- Copies of Warranty Deeds) 3 t. f Completed Owner/Agent Affidavits,Notarized 2 Environmental Impact Statement(EIS) *or exemption justification 2 "'�� • Digitalelectronic copy of EIS 2 r.------Aerial photographs (taken within The previous 12 months min.scaled 5 C - I"=200'),showing FLUCCS Codes,Legend,and project boundary Statement of utility provisions(with all required attachments&sketches) COeI 1 - ./ Traffic Impact Statement(TIS),or waiver _ 7 J/ Copy of Traffic Impact Statement MS) on CDROM 3 - Historical and Archeological Survey,or waiver 4 L..--- Copies of State and/or Federal Permits U-r'"-- Architectural Rendering of Proposed Structure(s) _ 4 L.— Electronic copy of all documents and plans (CAROM or Diskette) 1 f` Boundary Survey 3 i.e- Affordable Housing or Economic Development Council Projects: _ /....------- ❑ EDC"Fast Trade'must submit approved copy of official application ❑ Affordable Housing'Expedited"must submit copy of signed Certificate of Agreement. 2 e.-----` *If project includes an Affordable Housing component,you are required to schedule a -sting before the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee by contacting the Collier County Housing and Human Services Department at 239-252-2273. PLANNER MARK IF NEEDED TO BE ROUTED TO REVIEWERS BELOW: SCHOOL DISTRICT PARKS&REC-SID KITTILA SUPERVIOR OF ELECTIONS UTILITIES ENGINEERING••-ZAMIRA DELTORO 13AYSHORE/GATEWAY TRIANGLE REDEV-EXEC DM Communications Towers Only: MOSQUITO CONTROL COLLIER CO.AIRPORT AUTHORITY _ NAPLES AIRPORT AUTHORITY CITY OF NAPLES-ROBIN SINGER 41111 Commercial Mining Operations'Only: • GLENDA SMITH,IMPACT FEES-copy of application only,no review necessary ____1 Packet Page-201- 10/8/2013 8.A. w� C�' 7er County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE • GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION! NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX (239)252-6358 www.collieruov.net FEES: ® Pre-application Fee$500.00(Applications submitted 9 months or more after the date of the last pre-app meeting shall not be credited towards application fees and a new pre-application meeting will be required.) $4,000.00 Application Fee/$1500 if filed in conjunction with a rezone petition $150.00 Fire Code Review $300.00 Comprehensive Planning Consistency Review $925.00 Estimated Legal Advertising Fee-CCPC Meeting $500.00 Estimated Legal Advertising Fee- BCC Meeting (any over-or under-payment will be reconciled upon receipt of Invoice from Naples Daily News). C $2,500.00 EIS Review,if required O $1000.00 Listed or Protected Species survey review fee(when on EIS is not required) Transportation Fees,if required: $500.00 Methodology Review Fee,if required $750.00 Minor Study Review Fee, if required IN)01- ' :n•t &C.. [] $1,500.00 Major Study Review Fee,if required OTHER REQUIREMENTS: • • a n ' a_ Applicant/Agent Signature Date • Packet Page-202- 10/8/2013 8.A. Cow Ter County • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DMSIDNI NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX (239)252-8358 www.colliergov.net PUBLIC PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS LDC 10.03.05 F. Applicant must conduct at least one Neighborhood Informational Meeting (NIM) after initial staff review and comment on the application and before the Public Hearing is scheduled with the Planning Commission. Written notice of the meeting shall be sent to all property owners who are required to receive legal notification from the County pursuant to Section 10.03.05.8.8. Notification shall also be sent to property owners, condominium and civic associations whose members are impacted by the proposed land use change and who have formally requested the County to be notified. A copy of the list of all parties noticed, and the date, time, and location of the meeting, must be furnished to the Land Development Services Department and the Office of the Board of County Commissioners no less than ten (1 0) days prior to the scheduled date of the NIM. The applicant must make arrangements for the location of the meeting. The location must be reasonably convenient to those property owners who are required to receive notice and the facilities must be of sufficient size to accommodate expected attendance. The applicant must place an advertisement of the meeting in that portion of the newspaper where legal notices and dassified advertisements appear stating the purpose, location, time of the meeting and legible site location map of the property for which the zoning change is being requested. The display advertisement must be one-fourth page, in type ho smaller than 12 point and must be placed within a newspaper of general circulation in the County at least . seven (7) days prior to, but no sooner than five(5) days before, the NIM. The Collier County staff planner assigned to the project must attend the NIM and shall serve as the facilitator of The meeting; however, the applicant is expected to make a presentation of how it intends to develop the subject property. The applicant is required to audio or video tape the proceedings of the meeting and provide a copy to the Land Development Services Department. As a result of mandated meetings with the public, any commitments mode by the applicant shall be reduced to writing and mode a part of the record of the proceedings provided to the Land Development Services Department. These written commitments will be made a part of the staff report of the County's review and approval bodies and made a part of the consideration for inclusion in the conditions of approval. epee • Packet Page-203- 10/8/20138.A. Co Iker- County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE • GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION! NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.collieraov.net APPLICATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING FOR: CONDITIONAL USE , _ . • . - : . '.• . PETITION NO (PL) PROJECT NAME To be completed by staff DATE PROCESSED I NAME OF APPLICANT(S) Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. ADDRESS 206 Ridge Drive cry Naples STATE FL ZIP 34108 TELEPHONE# 239.596.2988 CELL# FAX# E-MAIL • NAME OF AGENT ft Wayne Arnold, AICP FIRM Q. Grady Minor and Associates, PA. ADDRESS 3800 Via Del Rey CITY Bonita Springs STATE FL ZIP 34134 TELEPHONE# 239.947.1144 CELL# FAX# 239.947.0375 E-MAIL wamold@gradyminor.com BE AWARE THAT COLLIER COUNTY HAS LOBBYIST REGULATIONS. GUIDE .siOi1;14gtII#1 Additi AND-..g,NSt.)13.:E4AAt YOU ARE IN COMPLIANCE WITH October 13,2010 Packet Page-204- 10/8/2013 8.A. C.,0*-T County • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net I. a ASSOCIATIONS Complete the following for all registered Association(s) that could be affected by this petition. Provide additional sheets if necessary. Information can be found on the Board of County Commissioner's website at http://www.colliergov.net/Index.aspx?page=774 NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: Pine Ridge Civic Association of Naples, Inc. MAILING ADDRESS 147 Caribbean Court CITY Naples STATE FL ZIP 34108 NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: Pine Ridge Civic Association of Naples, Inc. MAILING ADDRESS 155 Carica Road CITY Naples STATE FL ZIP 34108 NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP SNAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP NAME OF HOMEOWNER ASSOCIATION: MAILING ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP October 13,2010 Packet Page-205- 10/8/2013 8.A. Co r County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE • GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net DISCLOSURE-OF INTEREST JNFORMATION : . a. If the property is owned fee simple by an INDIVIDUAL, tenancy by the entirety, tenancy in common, or joint tenancy, list all parties with an ownership interest as well as the percentage of such interest. (Use additional sheets if necessary). % of Name and Address Ownership N.A. b. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and the percentage of stock owned by each. • % of Name and Address Ownership Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. (a not for profit corporation) 100% 206 Ridge Drive, Naples, FL 34108 D D Development LLC 100% 23159 Amgci Way Unit 302, Estero, FL 33928 Please see attached Exhibit 1 c. If the property is in the name of a TRUSTEE, list the beneficiaries of the trust with the percentage of interest. % of Name and Address Ownership N.A. • October 13,2010 Packet Page-206- 10/8/2013 8.A. Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. Conditional Use Exhibit I • Disclosure of Interest Information List Identifying Owner(s) and All Parties of Corporation and/or Trust B. If the property is owned by a CORPORATION, list the officers and stockholders and the percentage of stock owned by each. • Folio Number: 67185080001 Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. (a not for profit corporation) 206 Ridge Drive, Naples, Florida 34109 Officers/Stockholders Percentage of Stock Brigid Soldavini, Director 0% Kim Minarich, CEO, Executive Director 0% William Swartz, Vice President, Director 0% Kyle Christianson, President, Director 0% Cindy Bombard, Treasurer 0% 1111 • Folio Number. 67185040009 D. D. Development LLC 23159 Amgci Way Unit 302, Estero, Florida 33928 Officers/Stockholders Percentage of Stock Kenneth E. DeShetler, Manager 50% Susan E DeShetler, Manager 50% 4%4. Page 1 of 1 Packet Page-207- 10/8/2013 8.A. Colter er Co tty COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE • GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION! NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net d. If the property is in the name of a GENERAL or LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, list the name of the general and/or limited partners. % of Name and Address Ownership N.A. e. If there is a CONTRACT FOR PURCHASE, with an individual or individuals, a Corporation, Trustee, or a Partnership, list the names of the contract purchasers below, including the officers, stockholders, beneficiaries, or partners. of •Name and Address Ownership Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. 100% 206 Ridge Drive, Naples, FL 34108 3-23-2013 Date of Contract: f. If any contingency clause or contract terms involve additional parties, list all individuals or officers, if a corporation, partnership, or trust. Name and Address N.A. I October 13,2010 Packet Page-208- 10/8/2013 8.A. cfl6Y minty • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net g. Date subject property acquired 2001 and 2012 leased ❑ Term of lease yrs./mos. If, Petitioner has option to buy, indicate the following: Date of option: 3/23/2013 Date option terminates: , or Anticipated closing date: 9/30/2013 h. Should any changes of ownership or changes in contracts for purchase occur subsequent to the date of application, but prior to the date of the final public hearing, it is the responsibility of the applicant, or agent on his behalf, to submit a supplemental disclosure of interest form. PROPERTY LOCATION I . Detailed legal description of the property covered by the application: (If space is inadequate, attach on separate page.) If request involves change to more than one zoning district, include separate legal description for property involved in each district. Applicant shall submit four(4) copies of a recent survey (completed within the last six months, maximum 1" to 400' scale) if required to do so at the pre- application meeting. NOTE: The applicant is responsible for supplying the correct legal description. If questions arise concerning the legal description, an engineer's certification or sealed survey may be required. Section/Township/Range 10 /49 /25 Lot: 19&20 Block: I Subdivision: Pine Ridge Plat Book Page #: Property I.D.#: 67185040009 and 67185080001 Metes & Bounds Description: Pine Ridge Block I Lots 19 and 20 SIZE OF PROPERTY: ft X ft. =Total Sq. Ft. Acres 4.3+/ ADDRESS/GENERAL LOCATION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: 182 Ridge Drive and 194 Ridge Drive • • October 13,2010 Packet Page -209- 10/8/2013 8.A. Co en Caunty COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE • GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net ADJACENT ZONING A'NDLAND,USE Zoning Land Use N A Residential,Stables S A Residential E PUD Three Hundred Acre Goodlette Rd(church and residential) W RSF-1 Residential Does the owner of the subject property own property contiguous to the subject property? If so, give complete legal description of entire contiguous property. (If space is inadequate, attach on separate page). Section/Township/Range 10 /49 /25 Lot: 21 Block: I Subdivision: Pine Ridge Plat Book Page#: Property I.D. #: 67185120000 Metes & Bounds Description: Pine Ridge Block I Lot 21 CCONDITIONAL-USE REQUEST'DETAIL Type of Conditional Use: This application is requesting a conditional use allowed per LDC Section 2.04.03 of the A, Agricultural zoning district for ** see below (type of use). Present Use of the Property: Vacant Lot and Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. **Uses 19 and 24 of Section 2.03.01(A) (1) (c) of the Land Development Code, continued use of the existing therapeutic equestrian riding facility and stabling on parcels less than 20 acres in size. October 13,2010 Packet Page-210- 10/8/2013 8.A. Collier County • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION! NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net EVALUATION CRITERIA, „' Evaluation Criteria: Provide a narrative statement describing this request for conditional use. NOTE: Pursuant to Section 10.08.00. of the Collier County Land Development Code, staffs recommendation to the Planning Commission and the Planning Commission's recommendation to the Board of Zoning Appeals shall be based upon a finding that the granting of the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and that the specific requirements governing the individual conditional use, if any, have been met, and that further, satisfactory provision and arrangement have been made concerning the following matters, where applicable. Please provide detailed response to each of the criterion listed below. Specify how and why the request is consistent with each. (Attach additional pages as may be necessary). a. Describe how the project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan (include information on how the request is consistent with the applicable section or portions of the future land use element): See Exhibit 2 - Evaluation Criteria b. Describe the existing or planned means of ingress and egress to the property and proposed structure thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: See Exhibit 2 - Evaluation Criteria c. Describe the effect the conditional use will have on neighboring properties in relation to noise, glare, economic impact and odor: See Exhibit 2 - Evaluation Criteria d. Describe the site's and the proposed use's compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district: See Exhibit 2 - Evaluation Criteria e. Please provide any additional information which you may feel is relevant to this request. See Exhibit 2 - Evaluation Criteria • October 13,2010 Packet Page-211- 10/8/2013 8.A. Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. Conditional Use • Exhibit 2 Evaluation Criteria Provide a narrative statement describing this request for conditional use. The Naples Equestrian Challenge is under contract to acquire Lot 19 of Pine Ridge Subdivision, and owns Lots 20 and 21 of Pine Ridge Subdivision. A conditional use for sports and recreational facilities and stabling on less than 20 acres was approved in 2000 (CU Resolution 2000-063). The Naples Equestrian Challenge wishes to continue to offer therapeutic riding and equine programs to individuals with disabilities. This conditional use application requests the ability to provide these services on Lots 19 and 20, consistent with the original approval on Lot 21. A conceptual Master Plan identifying the existing and proposed improvements is included. The areas identified for indoor and outdoor uses have been labeled on the plans. a. Describe how the project is consistent with the Collier County Land Development Code and Growth Management Plan (include information on how the request is consistent with the applicable section or portions of the future land use element): The subject properties are zoned A, and per Section 2.03.01.A.1.c of the LDC, Agricultural activities on parcels less than 20 acres in size(animal breeding, raising, training, stabling, or kenneling) are permitted conditional uses (#24). Naples Equestrian Challenge also operates an instructional riding program and is requesting Conditional Use#19 consistent with their existing conditional use. The property is designated Urban Residential on the Future Land Use Map and the Future Land Use Element indicates that Agricultural activities on parcels less than 20 acres in size (animal breeding, raising, training, stabling, or kenneling) uses are permitted throughout the Urban area; therefore, the proposed uses are consistent with the Growth Management Plan. b. Describe the existing or planned means of ingress and egress to the property and proposed structure thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Ingress and egress to the overall site exists from Ridge Drive and Center Street. Access points to the properties are identified on the conceptual Site Plan. c. Describe the effect the conditional use will have on neighboring properties in relation to noise,glare, economic impact and odor: • Packet Page -212- 10/8/2013 8.A. • The uses should have no impact on neighboring properties. Naples Equestrian Challenge proposes to utilize Lots 19 and 20 for general office areas, additional horse stables, riding ring and training areas. The covered training arena and training room will be internally lighted and located toward Goodlette-Frank Road and away from the existing residence. Only outdoor security lighting will be utilized on the balance of the parcel. Buffers will be installed to LDC standards which should insure compatibility with nearby residences. d. Describe the sites and the proposed use's compatibility with adjacent properties and other properties in the district: The Naples Equestrian Challenge has been operating their therapeutic riding programs on the adjacent property for over 12 years and have developed a positive relationship with surrounding homeowners. Structures will be constructed to meet setbacks for the Agricultural Zoning District and outdoor activities will have operational hours consistent with those for the existing facilities. e. Please provide any additional information which you may feel is relevant to this request. Attached is additional information regarding the history of Naples Equestrian . • Challenge and descriptions of the various programs offered at the facility. • Packet Page-213- 10/8/2013 8.A. c, :r County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE • GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net Deed Restrictions: The County is legally precluded from enforcing deed restrictions, however, many communities have adopted such restrictions. You may wish to contact the civic or property owners association in the area for which this use is being requested in order to ascertain whether or not the request is affected by existing deed restrictions. Previous land use petitions on the subject property: To your knowledge, has a public hearing been held on this property within the last year? If so, what was the nature of that hearing? NO Official Interpretations or Zoning Verifications: To your knowledge, has there been an official interpretation or zoning verification rendered on this property within the last year? ❑ Yes ❑ No if so please provide copies. Additional Submittal requirements: In addition to this completed application, the following must be submitted in order for your application to be deemed sufficient, unless otherwise waived during the pre-application meeting. a. A copy of the pre-application meeting notes; b. Twenty (20) copies of a 24" x 36" conceptual site plan [and one reduced 8W x 11" copy of site plan], drawn to a maximum scale of 1 inch equals 400 feet, depicting the following [Additional copies of the plan may be requested upon completion of staff evaluation for distribution to the Board and various advisory boards such as the Environmental Advisory Board (EAB), or CCPC]; • all existing and proposed structures and the dimensions thereof, • provisions for existing and/or proposed ingress and egress (including pedestrian ingress and egress to the site and the structure(s) on site), • all existing and/or proposed parking and loading areas [include matrix indicating required and provided parking and loading, including required parking for the disabled], • locations of solid waste (refuse) containers and service function areas, • required yards, open space and preserve areas, • proposed locations for utilities (as well as location of existing utility services to the site), • proposed and/or existing landscaping and buffering as may be required by the County, • location of all signs and lighting including a narrative statement as to the type, character, and dimensions (such as height, area, etc.); October 13,2010 Packet Page-214- 10/8/2013 8.A. CoThIr County • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net c. An Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), as required by Section 3.8. of the Land Development Code (LDC). d. Whether or not an EIS is required, two copies of a recent aerial photograph, (taken within the previous twelve months), minimum scale of one inch equals 400 feet, shall be submitted. Said aerial shall identify plant and/or wildlife habitats and their boundaries. Such identification shall be consistent with Florida Department of Transportation Land Use Cover and Forms Classification System. e. Statement of utility provisions (with all required attachments and sketches); f. A Traffic Impact Statement(TIS), unless waived at the pre-application meeting. For TIS Guidelines and Procedures, please refer to the following link: http://www.colliergov.net/Index.aspx?page=566 . For additional questions, contact John Podczerwinky, 239-252-8192 g. A historical and archeological survey or waiver application if property is located within an area of historical or archaeological probability (as identified at pre-application meeting); h. Fees: Reference Pre-app notes for required fees and verify actual costs in current fee schedule i. Any additional requirements as may be applicable to specific conditional uses and identified during the pre-application meeting, including but not limited to any required state or federal permits. BE ADVISED THAT SECTION 10.03.05.B.3 OF THE LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIRES AN APPLICANT TO REMOVE THEIR PUBLIC HEARING SIGN (S) AFTER FINAL ACTION IS TAKEN BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. BASED ON THE BOARD'S FINAL ACTION ON THIS ITEM, PLEASE REMOVE ALL PUBLIC HEARING ADVERTISING SIGN(S)IMMEDIATELY. RECORDING OF DEVELOPER COMMITMENTS Within 30 days of adoption of the Ordinance, the owner or developer (specify name) at its expense shall record in the Public Records of Collier.County a Memorandum of Understanding of Developer Commitments or Notice of Developer Commitments that contains the legal description of the property that is the subject of the land use petition and contains each and every commitment of the owner or developer specified in the Ordinance. The Memorandum or Notice shall be in form acceptable to the County and shall comply with the recording requirements of Chapter 695, FS. A recorded copy of the _ 0 October 13,2010 Packet Page -215- 10/8/2013 8.A. Gar County COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE III GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 www.colliergov.net `' -' CONDITIONAL USE CCU)APPLICATION b SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST ,. . THIS COMPLETED CHECKLIST IS TO BE SUBMITTED WITH APPLICATION PACKET IN THE EXACT ORDER LISTED BELOW W/COVER SHEETS ATTACHED TO EACH SECTION. NOTE: INCOMPLETE SUMBITTALS WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. #OF NOT REQUIREMENTS COPIES REQUIRED REQUIRED STANDARD REQUIREMENTS: Cover letter briefly explaining the project Q o ❑ Application (completed &signed) (download from website for ❑ 0 ❑ current form) *Additional set if located in the Bayshore/Gateway Triangle ❑ SI Redevelopment Area) 1 Addressing Checklist signed by Addressing 1 SI ❑ Conceptual Site Plan 24"X 36" plus (one 8 1/2 X 11 copy) U p ❑ 411 Copies of Warranty Deed(s) 3 SI ❑ Completed Owner/Agent Affidavits, Notarized 1 19 ❑ Environmental Impact Statement(EIS), and digital/electronic ❑ si copy of EIS or exemption justification 3 Aerial photographs (taken within the previous 12 months min. 5 scaled 1"=200'), showing FLUCCS Codes, Legend, and project 0 ❑ boundary Statement of utility provisions (with all required attachments& I ❑ 0 sketches) Traffic Impact Statement(TIS), or waiver. For TIS guidelines & 7 ❑ is procedures, refer to http://www.colliergov.net/Index.aspx?page=566 Historical and Archeological Survey, or waiver 4 ❑ El Copies of State and/or Federal Permits ❑ ID Architectural Rendering of Proposed Structure(s) 4 ❑ 0 Electronic copy of all documents and plans (CDROM or 2 ❑ Diskette) Boundary Survey 3 IS ❑ Affordable Housing{or Economic Development Council Projects ❑ EDC"Fast Track" must submit approved copy of official 2 application ❑ ❑ Affordable Housing "Expedited"must submit copy of signed ` Certificate of Agreement. . .-. ,.'1410 October 13,2010 Packet Page -216- 10/8/2013 8.A. • Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use Additional Operational Background The mission of Naples Equestrian Challenge is to improve the lives of children and adults with special needs through therapeutic riding and other equine-related programs. Established in 1995 and located at the corner of Goodlette Road and Center Street in the Pine Ridge Estates neighborhood,NEC became a PATH-certified riding center(Professional Association of Therapeutic Horsemanship International, which is an international accrediting organization that has standardized the practices of therapeutic riding and equine-facilitated learning and psychotherapy activities)in 2000. In 2011, NEC achieved the coveted designation of a PATH International Premier Center. With the generous support of the community, NEC has expanded from serving four individuals in 1995 to 432 individuals in 2012. The majority of NEC's 432 participants suffer with autism spectrum disorder,attention deficit disorder(ADD)/attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder(ADHD),cerebral palsy, Down syndrome, multiple sclerosis, developmental delay, traumatic brain injury, post traumatic stress disorder(PTSD)and sensory integration disorder. Each year of its history, NEC has been successful in further expanding its equine-assisted activities and therapy programs to accommodate more participants. In 2012, NEC served 432 participants, who received 900 units of service (therapeutic riding, equine-facilitated learning and equine- facilitated psychotherapy sessions, outreach lessons and/or Summer Camp). By collaborating with • dagilte other non-profit organizations in Collier County(i.e., David Lawrence Center, PACE Center for Girls in Immokalee, Friends of Foster Children,Alzheimer's Support Network,Parkinson's Association of SW Florida) NEC successfully added several equine-facilitated learning and psychotherapy programs in 2012. In January 2013, NEC launched Operation Strides, an equine-assisted psychotherapy program for retired military veterans suffering with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), traumatic brain injury and/or amputation. Operation Strides is a fully-funded program (no fee for participants) as NEC was successful in raising the funds needed from private donors to cover the program's direct and indirect cost for approximately the next 2.5 years. According to the U.S.Department of Veteran Affairs,there are more than 32,000 military veterans living in Collier County. NEC is one of only 66 PATH-certified centers providing equine therapy services for veterans in the country. NEC currently is operating at capacity. In an effort to offer its equine-assisted activities and therapy programs to more Collier County citizens with special needs,the NEC Board of Directors is pursuing an opportunity to purchase the adjacent lot to the south of NEC's current location. This 2.15 acre parcel, located at 182 Ridge Drive,would provide NEC with the opportunity to increase its impact on the community. This additional land would enable NEC to conduct simultaneous programming resulting in more program hours; thus increasing the number of participants able to benefit from NEC equine-assisted activities and therapies,including NEC's Operation Strides program for military veterans. • Page 1 of 2 Packet Page -217- 10/8/2013 8.A. According to the data warehouse, more than 4,000 Collier County students have been screened, • evaluated and assigned an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) which calls for special accommodations due to a range of mental and physical disabilities from attention deficit disorder (ADD)to the most acute levels of cerebral palsy and Down syndrome. Among those 4,000 students, it is reasonable to assume that as many as 1,000,or 25%,would qualify for NEC services. In the last school year, NEC served 310 students,leaving a potential of 690 un- or under-served students that may benefit from NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapies. With the additional property located at 182 Ridge Drive, NEC is confident that with the extended facilities, approximately 200 additional children and adults will be served on this property per annum and for generations. NEC's preliminary build-out plan entails: • adding a six-stall barn to house potentially four (4) additional therapy horses, with a tack room,feed/hay storage as well as laundry facility; • a multi-purpose room to conduct meetings, trainings and small events (i.e., annual volunteer appreciation event); • a 75' diameter (just slightly larger than 20 meters) round covered riding arena to host equine facilitated learning and psychotherapy programs as well as therapeutic interactive vaulting for riders with special needs;and, • two additional turnout paddocks as well as a bridle path. Hours for use of the new facilities will be consistent with hours for the existing programming. NEC • typically conducts riding sessions between the hours of 8:00 AM and 8:00 PM. NEC on occasion may provide training to volunteers or conduct board meetings beyond their hours of 8:00 PM to approximately 9:00 PM. NEC does host special events throughout the year with these events ending at approximately 11:00 PM. Multi-purpose Room In addition to providing meeting space for volunteer orientations and trainings,the multi-purpose room provides NEC with the required meeting space to host PATH Instructor trainings. Currently, NEC is not able to host/conduct PATH instructor trainings due to its lack of adequate meeting space. As a PATH Premier Center and with the planned multi-purpose room, NEC would have the required infrastructure to host these trainings which provide revenue to the organization. Covered Round Riding Arena The 75 foot diameter covered round riding arena will provide a much needed additional riding facility where NEC will be able to conduct concurrent equine therapy sessions during normal operating hours. The location of the round riding arena was selected to provide adequate distance from the existing covered riding arena so as not to require a public address system. An amplified public address system is not required in a 75 foot diameter covered round riding arena, especially when kept an adequate distance from the existing riding arena that currently has a PA system that is used while conducting equine therapy sessions under it. The planned covered round riding arena will have lighting for evening sessions. However, the height of the arena sides and roof are low profile. Page 2 of 2 • Packet Page-218- 10/8/2013 8.A. ',NI. u. CVl) L: Ijrm Na. 151Q P. 1 ca>ruEf;<COUNTY GOVERNMENT GROWTH MANAGEMENT aMSIQt.v T.800 NORTH HORSES!04 DRIVE PLANNING AND REGULATION[ NAPLES,FLORIDA 34704 (239)252.2400 PAX (239)25.2-5724 U �_ W.CO GOV NET ,rape -}.-+.ip, r r,,. r��' ` '" �s • Please Complete the following and fax to the Operations Department at 239262-,724 or submit In person to the Addressing Department at The above address Form m application mead Iease a low 3 da s for rocess st be $iarl d by Addressing personnel prior to tyr®- Not all items wfti apply to every project. Items in bold type are required. FOLIO NUMBERS MUST BE PROVIDED. Forms older than 6 months will require additional review and approval by the Addressing Department, PETITION TYPE(Indicate type below, complete a separate Addressing Checklist for each Petition type) ❑ BL(Blasting Permit) ❑ BD( Dock Extension) 0. SDP(Site Development Plan) ❑ BD(Boat B aU Dock Permit. ❑ SDPA(Sat'Amendment) ® Cu Carnival/elms Use) . ❑ SDPI(Insubstantial Change to SDP) ❑ EXP(Excavation Permit)PP (Site Improvement Plan) ❑ PP(Final Plat SII'I(Insubstantial Change to SIP) LLA(Lot Line Adjustment) ❑ SNR(Street Name Change) • LLA (Ptayer,e Aare Change) ❑ SNC(Street Name Change—tin/aloft/xi) ❑ PPL(Plans&Plat Review) ❑ arlans of Development Rights) ❑ PSP(Preliminary Subdivision Plat) ❑ VA (Vegetat • ❑ PUD aazvne ❑ VRp{Vegetation Removal Permit) ❑ RU(Standard Rezone) ❑ VRSFP(Vegetation Removal&Site Fill Permi) ❑ OTHER. LEGAL DESCRIPTION of subject property or properties(copy of lengthy description may be attached) — Pine Ridge Block 1 Lots 19 and 20 FOLIO(Property ID)NUMBER(s)of above(attach to,or associate wrtft,legal description n ~ �~.�^ 87185040009 and 67185080001' irmoro then one) STREET ADDRESS or ADDRESSES(as applicable,Ye/ready assigned) 182 and 194 Ridge Drive ▪ LOCATION MAP must be attached showing exact location of project/site in ralatton to nearest public road right- of-way • SURV.EY(copy -needed only for tinplate('properties) PROPOSED PROJECT NAME(if applicable) PROPOSED STREET NAMES(ffapplicable) SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN NUMBER(forarkting projects/sitesonty) t $DP - or ,or PL • .11411F1-41.S . c �ri 'W= � !c Ark .,p-"•`,fit 1.1t Packet Page-219- 10/8/2013 8.A. p 4. /U13 2: 14PM No, 1510 P. 2 • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT MO NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION! NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)Z52-2400 FAX (239)252.5724 WWW.COLLIEROOV.NET Project or development names proposed for or already appearing in,condominium documents if application; indicate whether proposed or existing) • Please Check One: MI Checklist is to be Faxed back 0 Personally Picked lip APPLICANT NAME Sharon Urnpenhour PHONE 239.947.1144 F, •239.947.0375 • Signature on Addressing Checklist.does not constitute Project and/or:Street Name approval and is subject to further review by the Operations Department. • FOR STAFF USE ONLY FLN Number(Primary)._4,3 g Selo D D q Folio Number 2 rj() +__ + Folio Number Folio Number O - Approved by: 1./ wiz J 4/5-11:3 Updated by: Date: • IF OLDER THAN 6 MONTHS, FORM MUST I3E 11PDATMO OR NEW FORM SUBMITTED. Afici 4 8' 71, Packet Page-220- 10/8/2013 8.A. • Exhibit A Legal Description ALL OF LOTS 19 & 20, BLOCK I, OF PINE RIDGE SUBDIVISION AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 3,PAGE 24 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA.BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: BEGIN AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF LOT 20, BLOCK I OF THE PINE RIDGE SUBDIVISION AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 3, PAGE 24 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA. THENCE ALONG THE NORTH LINE OF SAID LOT 20, N 90°00' 00" E, A DISTANCE OF 478.94 FEET TO A POINT ON THE EAST LINE OF SAID BLOCK 1; THENCE ALONG SAID EAST LINE S 01° 53' 23" W, A DISTANCE OF 400.22 FEET TO THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF LOT 19 OF SAID BLOCK I; THENCE ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID LOT 19 N 90° 00' 00" W, A DISTANCE OF 465.74 FEET TO THE WEST LINE OF SAID BLOCK I; THENCE ALONG SAID WEST LINE N 00°00'00"E,A DISTANCE OF 400.00 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING CONTAINING 4.34 ACRES,MORE OR LESS. s • Packet Page-221- 10/8/2013 8.A. i .3g g 0 U 6 a m O Eel h gti ; yV i 9^ Rz <m mzm c F, o ma, ro O= I Z N 0 O 3V111.1adOYd- I Cr Cp U 1 " II II ;mmeII•tlmml�milmaso1�mimmiluals■••=lm�lsowilmomlm 1% I v1 1 HMI 31(IICB/]NItl0 HLYAYd u 1- I V 1 1 1 = 1 I a• II I I 1 ® 1 1 3 I 1 I Ix \\ d 1 p I 1 I t �'` ^� s 1 s = 1 11 1 I —1 i � H .1 e$a s� I I I I 1 — O 1 w lai 11 : S a� 11 I I s! _ '� g 1- 1 o Ent aI X _ I $ c III i �� ) 1111111 �/ 1 = as I 1 I 1 €1 d �' $ uve name 1 anroa sivnua / r I. w __58_ . ——— FPI.EASEMENT———1J a u§ I I I B © �' a�dx a_ 1 ; e °= I I �© 4 Ilk' I I rcm d I I I I = 1- I I 2 ° 21 I I 1 ' © I I Zw, �e U w U -'j -,_r, © w. I I p �� s� I 1 ! © ; �. - I I C ■ r 1 © Is. 30N3d ,T, 1 • I II 1 i I I rc _ fl i I i If II 11 `.s' , / 11' m / I CD { / 4 © . : I I ill II s i .10Y� _a' 2 d 1 _ I II I m a I� I E _ _ 1 II ! r w IfIII = .° 0 . . a.* I �� g N it �, vs. s 11 I , .,° :a II �� - it 0---2_ 3 s a �/ I i.�6'a y O __ I 8 i If i III I{ - - § r € �I II ,4 91 u 11 N II I� ge { IPA--II II I — usaaurdo -- — :-[ I II i ----------T --� T._-- .-sa y°-1 r----- __J l I l\\ % -- -- RrB I If I `h o I I :..-_II 1 I 1 G II U z 1 I 1 111 G J 1 °il Q m O, dm w }r z W_ Nw ft =x 3.0 D a 2 -'reK S =11 Packet Page-222- 2848611 OR: 2882 Pv1048z j013 8.a. UCOIDID in OFFICI11 UCO1D1 of COLLIII COMM, FL 01/21/2001 at 01:540 D1IGR 1. 1110C1, CLItt 001s 1!loll.io THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY: in in 0.51 10►4 James D.Vogel,Esq. DOC-.i1 13,3.10 •�. Fla.Bar No.0051373 lets; Vogel Law Office,P.A. IID11st TI?Ll Suite B,Midwest Title Bldg. 3936 Tamiami Trail North /ICI UP Naples,Florida 34 103 u (941)262-2211 z PREPARATION ONLY WITHOUT OPINION SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED THIS SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED is made this ...?/S{ day of August 2001, by . NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE CENTER,L.C.,a Florida limited liability company, 208 Ridge Drive.Naples,FL 34108,hereinafter called the GRANTOR, to NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE,INC.,a Florida non-profit corporation, PO Box 1353, Naples,FL 34106,hereinafter called the GRANTEE. (Wherever used herein the term"grantor" " 'ee 1 .1-440aclude all the parties to this instrument and the heirs, legal representatives and tgrri`t1Sl t v !s, and the successors and assigns of corporations). ,0) WITNESSETH: Thaythe to c sidera 'on of the sum of$10.00 and other valuable considerations, rec`etpt hereof t . ackn wledged, hereby grants, bargains, sells, aliens, remises, releases, cqnve +nfi _ , al that certain land situate in Collier County, Florida, viz Lot 20,Block I, PI DGE DGE SUBDIVISI t s ordia o the Plat recorded In Plat Book 3,Paged blic Records of - ey Coe ,Florida. Property I.D.: 6718508u i t _ SUBJECT TO all restrictions,reserve ments common to the subdivision,if any, zoning restrictions and prohibitions imposed by governmental authority,and taxes for the year 2001 not yet due and payable. TOGETHER WITH all the tenements,hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the same in fee simple forever. AND the grantor hereby covenants with said grantee that the grantor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple;that the grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey said land;that the grantor hereby fully warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons claiming by,through and under Grantor,but against none other. o vttJIIA.Pet I43 ED FNL • Packet Pare -223- "It OR: 2882 PG: `=0/8/2013 8.A. IN WITNESS WHEREOF,the said grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. Signed,sealed and delivered in our presence: Naples Equestrian Challenge Center,L.C. Wi . / a Florida Limited Liability Company (Si•, ,�1III . ,/� r ame fit . - By: Y 'f / area Conley,Manager (Sign) e /11,G&fCrit (Print Name Ci -- e. S,. STATE OF 7 ' � COUNTY O rtt • ) , The foregoing W 'ty was acknowledge be ore me this .,„'/ day of + j 200 ,. r+en ,i s Manag of Na lesEquestrian Challenge Center, .c.,el'tir7. rsonaljknow. . . p,•.• , • as identificafl n. 0 li '% 'i 1 7 1 ,v'- %'.___ ;CC-- IVOT �101�V t '�,1�.J O _+__j _�►M�S:oewoN.22.2001- -1E Cl. -} or Printed Name of Notary Commission No. My Commission Expires: ovn.m.01142,DEED FNL Packet Pa:e-224- 10/8/2013 8.A. Reta: 4264959 OR: 4430 PG: 0820 VOGEL LAif OFFICE RECORDED in the OFFICIAL RECORDS of COLLIER COURT!, FL 3936 TIKIAXI TR H lB 02/24/2009 at 03:5211 DWIGHT I. BUCK, CLERK RIC FEE 18.50 MAPLES FL 34103 COPIES 2.00 • LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT AFFIDAVIT NOW COMES Brigid D.Soldavini,as President of Naples Equestrian Challenge,Inc.,who being duly sworn, depose and say: 1. Naples Equestrian Challenge are the fee simple title holders to that property legally described as: Lot 21,Block I,Pine Ridge(Hereafter Lot"A') 2. Naples Equestrian Challenge are the fee simple title holders to that property legally described as: Lot 20,Block I,Pine Ridge(Hereafter Lot"B') 3. The parties desire to adjust a lot line and create two revised Lots,as depicted in the sketch and legal descriptions prepared by Bradley E.Stockham ,Florida Professional Land Surveyor#6390 attached hereto and made part hereof as Exhibit'1'. 4. Naples Equestrian Challenge,as the owner(s)of said Lot A hereby consents to the lot line adjustment in accordance with Section 10.02.02 B.8,LDC. 5. Naples Equestrian Challenge,as the ow - - • ..'d Lot B hereby consents to the lot line adjustment in accordance with Section 10.02,02 B.8, a R 6. Because the lot line adjus - - • result in two loV•eae, equivalent in size and having the minimum required road frontage a-d .• •age,the lot line adjustor-• me:is the standards of,and conforms to,the requirements of Section x.02. ..e Collier County L• d Development Code. 7. The property describe• her on is Zone• __,JAot 21)/• Lot 2• . d meets the intent of the Land Development Code,as amen.ed. 8. Furthermore, the lot I ne -• •tme t II of • =t' he 1‘0,,r •t: : • lop. nt rights or permitted density or intensity of use of the affecte. l.t. , .,4'vi. n,�•- q.... unit h= r :ling of new lots for resale or development within the meani $f, ection 10.02.02 B.8, C. 9. This Affidavit is being gl -TO want to Section 10.0 B : . tt oilier County Land Development Code. { 10. This Affidavit has been rev 't. d • ...�. Iy 6 _ _ . of the Development Services Department John - 'nf.T: ngineer of Collier ounty,Florida on the Z.41 Nay of . 20 y_ SIGNATURES OF OWNERS: Naples Equestrian Ch -• •e c. d D.Sold avini,President r STATE OF FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTY �i" Th foregoing'nstrument was acknowledged before me this 2'� day of ) -e f0 f .U.(' -�"` 204'1 ,by �,cQ .)0r.l�tv,�'. - GfGto /who have produced et_ fl•{'t�l Lim 1,`"'.,3{ t as identification a who did/did not take a(h�•oath. Notary Public My Commission Expires: Commission No. q3 p- NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OFPURIM Print Name: C '"••t Cinzia Bombard :Commission#DD793121 t Expires: JUNE 19,2012 • aONDEDTfliW 1rANr cEONDU GcO,n e. Packet Page-225- -- 10/8/2013 8.A. ***-OR: 4430 PG: vozi An- 0 p 3 N (t V t ji a �i 1Oi )= j 'n• 0 1, s • iitt. f 74 M „. 11 41 g ! Iti ill wgP, Ftyi ",,,,:-..,.. .-..-:_,,:...,......,..0.1..." ..istX1 ..i 8 ilg Ileib: ills Illg 'it x§lq 1 x yy !a.. d _ yyy f 1 w v X11 O zi;t x sg . t g 5 I 161/ Ili 5 41 i° 1/IlgIll 118 Ne - -- MO- - .tIM.p Pelf.00f N - og 3,4I fl woo ow 01901 wort-3urvoO - •- ..—" 'R .8Z'6LY M.ZZ.£S.10S i 1 1 Z'8 .LSZ w .10.191 g Aci 5i, .24,iiiimp I i iii N I1• ili •b . $ x 1 W t ��' 0O t I- X 4- "g �� `, }}W,, Sal Y N 0 62 8 4, p l y �► �_M w x 1.1 b �Z NY 0 io . y z O m I n n iv J N 2 n of Nib$ g Z 2—�z b o z y Q 0, 0 z vl a ��ta U WtnZ 3 8 0 cn 0 lj,J o V .00'SZZ .00.002 —] J A1 0 Lr rU0'SZi. 3,00.44.005 a I J La La L a. '4'7.0-1 0 U. Packet Page-226- INSTR 4755887 OR 4849 PG 693 RECORDED 10/25/2012 3:55 PM PAGES 2 10/8/2013 8.A. DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC @.70 $0.70 REC $18.50 III ,...:. . .•,.., PREPARED BY AND RETURN TO: Brian C.Layman,Attorney at Law Layman,D'Atri&Associates,LLC 301 FirstMerit Building 4481 Munson Street,NW Canton,OH 44718 Telephone: (330)493-8833 Facsimile: (330)493-1733 Website: www.lavmandarri.com Parcel Identification No.67185040009 (Space Above This Line For Recording Data] QUIT CLAIM DEED THIS QUIT CLAIM DEED, mad- _.rinc%- • .'s 2y day of September,2012,between Kenneth E. DeShetler as Trustee of P. I+r � 4.=.t t Living Revocable Trust dated May 5, 1998, ("Grantor"), whose post off - '• ss is 23159 .71. ' • . Unit #302, Estero, FL 33928 and D.D.Development, LLC, a Flo '•. t d liability company, ' . ee"),whose post office address is 23159 Amgci Way,Unit#302,Ester ,I'L 3.3928-________,F... WITNESSETH that te so.'/• c11 •r. •\_+. 71Teera,on •id for the sum $10.00 paid by • Grantee, the receipt of which is a•.. wle4 g d,,•o • h . ;else, re1e a and quitclaim unto the said Grantee and Grantee's succes ar5 t.. a for o. ,41 of ra_• ,Ftit ,and interest and claim which the said Grantor has in an-t• .e following •e b-• arc 14 land and improvements and appurtenances thereto in the Cdr •f Collier,State of F%sida, o • 4 Lot 19,Block I,Pine Ridg re-- 'vision,according to • B`%ok 3,Page 24,Public Records of Collier County F . ,r Ci?CJ Subject to (a) real property ad valorem - or 2000 and subsequent years; (b) zoning,building code and other use restrictions imposed by governmental authority, (c)outstanding oil, gas and mineral interests of record, if any; and(d) restrictions, reservations, and easements common to the subdivision, provided, however, that none of them shall prevent the use of the herein described real estate for residential purposes. Parcel Number: 67185040009 IN WITNESS WHEREOF,the said Grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above ' . n. Signed,s J d "elivered in our presence: / 1�_ / , / � '/ 'Kenneth E.DeShetler,Trustee of The Kenneth s. 11.\!�.� gib _• t E.DeShetler Living Revocable Trust dated May 5, t 4l.1 t/c 1Z 1948 • ""Grantor"and"Grantee"are used for singular or plural,as context requires. Page 1 of 2 Packet Page-227- *** OR 4849 PG 694 *** 10/8/2013 8.A. • STATE OF OHIO,COUNTY OF FRANKLIN: ss: The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 7A4 day of September, 2012, by Kenneth E. DeShetler, Trustee of The Kenneth E. DeShetler Living Revocable Trust dated May 5, 1998,who is [ 1 personally known or [___ has produced=. 'QaDy` '06,--.-5 1.%• f''ti as identification. I� 114* No , c,;State of P . R Cap. . .OS•ssio. 'xpires: i3/6(7-4 ri..--* ,,TAL&' .7,,, -.1,,!:. '--..1 P E r:. m Ex• i res 2t!„.,.,7; .uqu _` 1.16 { 4111 `i OF'0' :� F. ,-- P h, h Page 2 of2 Packet Page-228- 10/8/2013 8.A. C©uii r County • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION/ NAPLES,FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 WWW.coIiieraov.net AFFIDAVIT We/l, Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc.. being first duly sworn, depose and say that well am/are the owners of the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief. We/I understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted. As property owner Weil further authorize Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A. to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this Petition. - ....i, 110 %4Ul Vlt, Lcti/ C&`---__ Signature of Property Owner/Authorized Representative Kim Minarich as Executive Director of Naples Equestrian Challenge, inc. Typed or Printed Name of Owner 1 The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this g day , of ri , 2013, by 9 I)' \ ,1 i1,Cil1 . who is personally known to me or has produced as identification. 7 SA kAAI1NE Z (Signature of Notary Public)Y o,y�. , Notary Pub lic-State of Florida .... t ,p4 y1 ,,, My Comm.Expires Sep 27,2014 „,,,,v.1.,,,, Comanfssion#EE 30073 \C\ '+C . e (Print, Type, or Stamped Commissioned Name of Notary Public) • October 13,2010 . Packet Page -229- 10/8/2013 8.A. Corffer County • COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT 2800 NORTH HORSESHOE DRIVE GROWTH MANAGEMENT DIVISION( NAPLES, FLORIDA 34104 PLANNING AND REGULATION (239)252-2400 FAX(239)252-6358 WWW.coIiiergov.net AFFIDAVIT We/l, D. D. Development LLC being first duly sworn, depose and say that well am/are the owners of the property described herein and which is the subject matter of the proposed hearing; that all the answers to the questions in this application, including the disclosure of interest information, all sketches, data, and other supplementary matter attached to and made a part of this application, are honest and true to the best of our knowledge and belief, We/I understand that the information requested on this application must be complete and accurate and that the content of this form, whether computer generated or County printed shall not be altered. Public hearings will not be advertised until this application is deemed complete, and all required information has been submitted. As property owner Well further authorize Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. and Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A. to act as our/my representative in any matters regarding this Petition. dir • ign- ure of Property Owner/Authorized Representative E, b�S-4 e ✓ as Managing Member Typed or Printed Name of Owner The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this Cyaday of___ 2013, by\kN � 4 who is personally known to me or has produced C,2?1-k-. )--f -Z9' -das identification. (Th\M-7\'' moo`°Rr 'Vs MELISSA AMARTINEZ (Signature of Notary Public) _ Notary Public-.State of Florida ';4.7 My Comm.Expires Sep 27,2014.. • ;a:�' Commission#EE � C�C (Print, Type, or Stamped Commissioned Name of Notary Public) October 13,2010 Packet Page-230- 10/8/2013 8.A. c c s�•ts-ey ,. w N - ,..„.ji.ric 4 p"-' r. _777'i4-..' , f r µ i t • ii.*-7,,.:-...r,-;:s-J,_,,,vs,-i;---,41 ,...71., , .,,,,,,-: , -2,:i:...,!--., :-..-,,,. ,,,..-- ,;_:,..14-''''- -,4'-:-.--4;- .::• ' s r i4 w .F :7,..1-.;1,17., '':- ' _. , ` - 'LLB -C 3- , ° w : �` ` -s'!CENTER ST E a' a-.Ya&is .s+ , s 111 8 1 �Y o .,7--i.::-.;',.'4 � ;,a `�" '., „ -z x� W :4n "i ha.� T.., CL . lV 7• S a- ,i=e '.. r b ,2 5 O 7 It 2 4 to �.: ` 1891 .�. �o l } 1 t .r 2 _ y l fig,r• r �� s` ,. � w J 4, 2 +. 1 .AEI .n ft-,; a� 5 .�4 r ,9 ,;:-.,4,-..•,.,;!!-. .fir' • k- tJ;0 .-4 74n ter, ,' p r n+ z - ,. .' - 0�3'i... Y r ; er� • a 7,-1:--'-'..;:-. t O I � � �m 'f „ "� w^ •�"W p �. -e t, :=`,,:,:-'1'..,=.::a 't nK} .art �" ..,„%. io ~r �.r �� •` ., ��,`�� 11:1 �: �, t �' � `7 '"` �...` } , g SINGLE FAMILY HOMES ' r :-t `" ,...I,,,,i,,,,:::::::::_iii_.,. .. t.,....i..,,,I...:_,,,, .‘,.....c.:......,...it,T,,.L. .::-,',J.---r.. ..,-.---..--,7-,.a-f„,:.,„_-,....,;;;,,;,-41?-4,.-,,..;..:*::.;,,,_ .d c...,,... ,-,,.-4-.ti , : � �� " „ '"� x '�� r �� 4 ��Z'-n-+- t4 �. .' 2GG RADIUS a �m%a 7 •ti T s L' ,-.M LA t -.4 •,Y...Yam 'E '' ''.'^x `/ y y' 1 .4 "'� '� - `. ;-^.':- #3- r .. ...`«ac.,watt 4fc Viz.:'" .a:.: rr,�! a....± .c'.4fir __ i'... LEGEND Code Description Acreage± 111 Single Family Homes 2.1.5 0.09 '-- SUBJECT SITE 740 Disturbed Lands FLUCFCS LINE 1891 Stables(Horses) 2.10 NORTH TOTAL ACREAGE = 4.3-4t ac 0 100' 200' SCALE: 1" = 200' NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CFTAT.TENCE S Cr.dy Wmir a..d A'ret.tle:.P.n. GradyDlinor Y,, 5„ '„„ 3413' corromonus USE . Civil Fr sneers Laud Sw�r�rots Plannrav LanUstzpe Architects F KEGS MAP 'A60 `°° °°"` DATE AERIAL FLOWN — DECEMBER 2011 ""'a 410 P a yak:MO.15W oonims�aw.s 23.9947.1 l44 Rn'u.r;ra4J 1i..,.". r""A's"?9u.f a.4m0 sHE„t 7 of d G:?R0.!—PUUe.;M:µECLU—NAPLES EQJESft u Ch., 4GE\QRAWInu$f.UCFCS.oWG 4 24/20,3 a:50 Alt Packet Page-231- 10/8/2013 8.A. FLUCCS CODE AND VEGETATION INVENTORY • FLUCCS CODE (Description) Common Name Scientific Name Indicator Status 111 Single Family Home . 189 Horse Stables 740 Disturbed This area has been previously cleared. The vegetation present is either secondary herbaceous growth or exotic plants. Slash pine Pinus elliotti FACW Cp,O Cabbage palm Sabal palmetto FAC M,0 Banyan ficus Ficus benghalensis Exotic Cp,O Carrotwood Cupaniopsis anacardioides Exotic Cp,O Brazilian pepper Schinus terebinthifolius Exotic M,C Ear leaf acacia Acacia auriculiformis Exotic Cp,M,C Woman tongue Albizia lebbeck Exotic Cp,0 Mahogany Swietenia mahogany Upl Cp,0 laurel oak Quercus laurifolia FACW Cp,0 Live oak Quercus virginiana FACU Cp,0 • Broom sedge Andropogon virginicus FAC- G,0 Florida pusley Richardia scabra Exotic G,C Caesar weed Urena lobata FACU G,0 Virginia creeper Ampelopsis quinquefolia FAC G.0 Cat-briar Smilax spp. FAC G,0 Poison ivy Toxicodendron radicans FAC G,0 Grape vine Vitis rotundifolia FAC G,0 Whitehead broom Spermacoce verticillata FAC G,0 Beggers ticks Bidens alba FACW G.0 Rosary pea Abrus precatorius Exotic C, 0 Chocolate weed Melochia corchorifolia FAC G,0 Bahia grass Paspalum notatum UPL G,0 Ragweed Ambrosia artemisiifolia FACU G,0 Dog Fennel Eupatorium capillifolium FACU G,0 Guineagrass Panicum maximum FAC- G,0 Wild Pines Stiff-leaved Tillandsia fasiculata FDA/C IIIII Packet Page-232- 10/8/2013 8.A. • Surrounding Area 111 Single Family Homes 8144 County Road 8145 Road ABREVIATIONS— Canopy(Cp),Midstory(M), Ground Cover(G) Dominant(D),Common (C),Occasional(0) INDICATOR STATUS- Obligate(OBL),Facultative wet plants (FACW), Facultative plants (FAC),Upland(UPL) s • Packet Page -233- 10/8/2013 8.A. A brief Listed Species survey was recently performed at the property adjacent to Naples • Equestrian Challenge,206 Ridge Drive. Required to meet county review requirements its purpose is to identify and describe key habitats and report any listed species utilizing the site that would be at risk due to possible future development actions. This survey and report are based on fieldwork performed during April 2013. The project site is located just south of 206 Ridge Drive and consists of approximately 4.34 acres. The parcel is in Section 10, Township 49 and Range 25 in Collier County. The required survey for a Listed Species Survey calls for a survey covering 100%of the site,at prescribed transect distances per site acreage.This site was previously cleared and has no viable native habitat. As such this survey was very brief, all possible species of plants and animals listed by state and federal agencies were noted. WILDLIFE SPECIES OBSERVED Common Name Species Status Amphibian & Reptiles: Brown anole Anolis sagrei Birds: Dove-mourning Zenaida macroura Bluejay Cyanocitta cristata • As previously stated there is no native habitat on site.The site is vegetated with a variety of exotics. The site also has some structures and landscape. All these components have limited wildlife utilization.Any wildlife utilization is probably limited to common,urban adjusted wildlife. The only potential Listed Species issue was a documented Bald Eagle Nest about a mile north. This Bald Eagle nest is located north of Orange Blossom Road. This project is well beyond and protective zone of this nest. The surrounding area is also known to have an occasional Fox squirrel.Big Cypress Fox Squirrels are known in some of the neighboring areas however none were seen. The site also does not have any viable habitat for any listed species. Packet Page-234- 10/8/2013 8.A. Print Bald Eagle Nest Data Page 1 of 1 This report was generated using the bald eagle nest locator at • https://public.myfwc.cam/FWRI/EagleNests/nestlocator.aspx on 4/17/2013 1:43:26 PM. Search Entered: Within 0.5 miles of latitude 26.2378333333333 and longitude -81.7901666666667; All Search Results 1 record(s) were found; 1 record(s) are shown Bald Eagle Nest Map: P 3 —; 'nt;. 0-iir,�r iy = ��3 (1T-nit i1V Park 5..0 v ,1:11.-1:.w ca3,=5-:ad c?°111* -i • :r Fel can ems; T.. Pyre Pi.�;7e Y r.,a aR = . Y Prf. .... a .., .si;cur:d`.3ik C: — s Map data©2013 G000gie Bald Eagle Nest Data Search Results: Results per page: All N'':: Let Nest I Sec Last Last Town Ran - Gaz Act Act Act Act Act Dist. - ID County Latitude Longitude_ship -ge Page Known Sur- 08 09 10 11 12 (Mi) Sur- ter tion Active veyed A C0026 Collier 26 14.27 81 47.41 49S 25E 03 111 2010 2010 Y * Y * * 0.00 "Y"denotes an active nest "U"denotes a nest that was visited but status was undetermined "N" denotes an inactive nest *"denotes a nest that was not surveyed ""denotes an unobserved nest III https://public.myfwc.com/FWRI/EagleNe Packet Page-235- 4/17/2013 1018120138.A. • . • cOLLLER .ComPTT SOIL LEGEND ID REVISED 1/90 R. YAMATAKI . - _ . . .. . . • HYDRIC . . R 2 HOLOPAW FS, LIMESTONE SUBSTRATUM . • . . . H 3 - MALABAR.FS. • : H . . 4 . CHOBEE, LIMESTONE SUBSTRATUM AND DANIA MUCKS - - IMPRESSIONAL H - _ 6 RIVIERAi LIMESTONE SUBSTRATUM-COPELAND FS • 7 IMMOKALEE FS - 8 MYAKKA FS : 10 OLDSMAR FS, LIMESTONE_SUBSTRATUM. • ' • 11 NAT FS H 14 PINEDA FS, LIMESTONE suESTRATLIM • 15 POMELLO FS 16 -OLDSMAR FS - • . H 17 .BASINGER FS ' . H • 18 RIVIERA FS, -LIMESTONE SUBSTRATUM , . 20 - FT DRDMHANI) .WLLABAR:.Alcia-.FS ---' . . . . . • - . ' 21 BOCA FS - - . . . - - R 22 'CROBEE, WINDER AND GATOR' SOrLs, DEPRESSIONAL H 23 HOLOPAW AND OKEELAWTA SOILS IMPRESSIONAL - _ - H 25 BOCA, RIVIERA, LIMESTONE SUBSTRATUM AND . • COPELAND FS DEPRESSIONAL H 27 HOLOPAW FS . . H . 28 PINEDA AND RIvIERA FS . - 29 WABASSO FS - 1111 H 31 HILOLO LIMESTONE SUBSTRATUM, JUPITER AND - - MARGATE SOILS _ 32 URBAN LAND - • • 33 URBAN LAND HOLOPAW BASINGER COMPLEX • 34 URBAN LAND IMMOKALEE-OLDSMAR LIMESTONE • ' SUBSTRATUM COMPLEX 35 URBAN LAND AQUENTS COMPLEX ORGANIC SUBSTRATUM . • 36 UECRTHENTS SHAPED 37 TUSCAWILLA. Fs. 38 URBAN' LAND MATLAcRA LIMESTONE SUBSTRATUM • BOCA COMPT,Rx . - . 39 SATELLITE FS . • H 40 DUPE IN AND WULFERT MUCKS . : 41 URBAN LAND SATELLITE COMPLEX - - . . _.7---:::--1.f::,* .-: • :- 42 CANAVERAL BEACHES ASSOCIATION . .s. H 43 WINDER, RIVIERA-; LIMESTONE SUB6TRATUMr-AND':.. . - . - -. CHOBEE SOILS DEPRESSIONAL - 45. PAOLA FS (1-8 percent slopes) H 48 PENNSUCCO SOIL ( niTra prairie) - 49 HALLANDALE AND BOCA FS (slough) - - R 50 OCHOPEE FSL, PRAIRIE (marl) ,•.:::-.:---..-: H 51 OCHOPEE FSL . ...., . H 52 KESSON MUCK FREQUENTLY FLOODED 53 ESTERO AND PECKISH SOILS FREQIIENTZ;YFLOODED 54 JUPITER BOCA. COMPL-Rx ,.. . H ' - ' :-' 56 BASINGER FS, OCCASIONATJ,Y--FLOODED - - II . Packet Page -236- 1 820 8.A. Page 0/1 a/r 1 1 3 „ 8 f - ',z1`i T_� . r � x -v r t. fi T y ate'; - - ':(4,'`-.�� +:�' T s �E �-1',4,-` . T, r i a x= `i �_ .',' "* 4 ,-,.s. , a:r .. 3� u-i :i )..-z-,._-,,,, :-A`. a:” :..r ��.; a •ti z ,F', ua•. i . -,,F..--,,,V P' s " • ter ' rx a m z 3 _ _mot F ,� a , L �- ' E, ' . C ^' .UADAN LAND -,,,.. ..IPLLX„,,::;:4.,.:::,'.,:7,A,.r ` x,- uZ ALCC•.OL9 `'1 n T :q Y w` v-. ar x' 4 { '. .. t i.. • lP :: > j �r L. 1 3', - - In3-y MAR,L ST O..N„SU TDSTRATM C P.1-LC r x ,- ro x!t URDAN LAND- O r.L ! ..+ ..4 a {_ i 7 u rR i�.-44,7-074i'''',,.-ii.:' '' y x n a v � 1 ! x--x r r• yv w k - - ter( ''� ,+ - r --..c i .r -�y+'-',i .'- ” `� �' ,�„� E� .. � .gyp-3�y�a Ill t:,t. ,I.,-,....,...„ ... .. .. _.,. __,---....-...,� ° `r' ry-i 1 tl. u..- .n4_3ur j .w ' -.,. . .. ,it aJC� .._wit -- 3 ., i ..- ... ._. F �: '.`_.....4. •...'.:.'a�',. ' -r....t., -=ids • -'ry69 htfp://www.coIlierappraiser.eom/webmap,Packet Page-237-2_sde03114529676177974 jpg 4/16/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. Naples Equestrian Challenge • Traffic Assessment The Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC) provides equine assisted activity and therapy programs for special needs children and adults at their Pine Ridge location. In the past year NEC served more than 400 participants. Program participants are assisted by staff and volunteers of the NEC during each of their one-half hour riding sessions. Estimates provided by NEC staff indicate that the peak number of hourly vehicular trips entering and exiting the site is approximately 18 trips. Attached is a spreadsheet prepared by NEC breaking down the vehicular trips on an hourly basis for the existing facility. NEC is seeking conditional use approval for two properties, one of which has been owned by NEC and currently serves as pasture and paddock areas for the facility. Lot 19 (182 Ridge Drive) which is included in the pending conditional use application is proposed to have additional riding, stabling and volunteer training facilities constructed upon approval of the conditional use. The new riding arena, barn and training room is approximately 6,600 square feet and will allow a few additional sessions to be conducted concurrent with existing programs; however,it is anticipated that a minor increase in the daily traffic will occur. The conceptual plan prepared for the conditional use application depicts the proposed site improvements,including the addition of parking at the 182 Ridge Drive property. The additional parking may or may not be improved with asphalt, and its primary purpose is to serve participants using the small arena, special events,or during volunteer training. In converting the visitor trips estimated by NEC staff to vehicle trips. We have used the average visitor trips during the PM peak hours and multiplied that number by two to achieve to determine the total entering and exiting vehicle trips. Based on the square footage of the enclosed buildings, we can determine a vehicle trip per square foot figure, which can be applied to the proposed site improvements. Existing PM peak hour average 18 vehicle trips 18/10,000 square feet building area= 1.8 trips/1000 s.f. Estimated vehicle trips for new improvements 6,600±square feet building area/1000=6.6 6.6 x 1.8= 11.88 (12)peak hour trips Due to scheduling for volunteers and program participants, the new additional estimate of peak hour trips is likely greater than actual trips anticipated; however, the PM peak hour is a low volume figure and will have no impact on the County's road network. • Packet Page -238- 10/8/2013 8.A. • .i 'i A N ti D 1-hi 1F n.N N.}V ,+1 C It .- .p L y. 3 7'ar l$��r ▪�. vl CO r-. C n CO 00 Co CO N F H CO CO Co CO CO N LC) 4A IP LO LO tO ▪ .-1 .-1 eel N ,-I ,-I O.- m cy Z. 0 m F hN N N N N N m in d 777 Q t k 1' C 44 Q )41•p0 m 1 �,`� i 1- aY t 'S"1'-4 0 CO CO 4 N �5.�. w_c0 Co lb.. y H d ry 4 1 t 4:1 i# ,2' , 4Y• 1:1,'"f r ; . Q u j a O m _ # 4 .tti C :G d t. ,1 t d- 4 4.tR tD .-t• D I.± ° t t a. °^ m co —∎ n -- CO N O O I— .-1 Co co CO co to to o a o .-1 0 . m m m m r` m m m CO CO 0 H m 9 > a T. d^ m a T m =w to to tO tO to tO t0 t0 to (0 N N m N L R n "O$ ia N _I o w n d - n .- Q ro ao -t_ rn t �a a-/ a-4 O O 1 t .m A-. n '3 N y ti;' C :!L Y'!'%' of to i0 In t0''.-tO▪ .O-tO}N N al an t�,�_ .�v___i0 z .tO▪ _t0,. L n e-1 .-41 .-1 ." v v v co Co CO CO co c n m v O- a Q V p n o Ln v j Cl. m H w C to to O C V a' LC) t0 tO N o 10 N 75 U r LU _ a _ to ...€ 01 cJ Q In 0 g H n O-i.� ;n Y 'I� � CO W-ei N o �.tO.- O ti"� m CA4 W O y K1 to k c a0 CO'yt� t,▪ m rrtt�� m.:m- N ea m `m t. ;; n a-t V ,a C Q V 'mot„ L • 0 0 CO O 4 * y 0-.,a r as .0 o_ y C 0 L U al i m _ 4 • _, C 0 0 ,t-- --- p F C cc .1 W m - m m 0 .--I 0 0. n p. 0. p. n 0. n = cc Z LL. F-' Co al ti .-1 Z a-1 N m V (0 to N co 1- I- Packet Page-239- : .x. .,. 10/8/2013 8.A. ,/,-eic',„,,,e,,,,,,,,..\ - . :,',.„. ...„-:J..,..,,,, cs) .., : I. Q \ —u_„ -y y r N_, COLLIER COUNTY WAIVER.APPLICATION FRONT THE REQUIRED HISTORICAL AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL:SURVEY AND ASSESSMENT DA 1E SUBMITTED: PLANNER: Melissa Zone, Principal Planner PETITION NUMBER ASSOCIATED WITH THE WAIVER: (To Be Completed By Zoning and Land Development Review Staff) PROJECT NAME:Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use LOCATION: (Common Description) 182 and 194 Ridge Drive • SUMMARY OF WAIVER REQUEST: Naples Equestrian Challenge intends to construct additional horse stables and riding facilities on these two lots. The lots have been previously developed with modern single family homes. Naples Equestrian Challenge requests a waiver from conducting an archeological assessment due to the prior development which has occurred on-site. No excavation activities are proposed at this time. Naples Equestrian Challenge understands that any discovery on-site must comply with LDC Section 2.03.07E. (Properties located within an area of Historical and Archaeological Probability but with a low potential for historical/archaeolog,cal sites may petition the Community Development & Environmental Services Administrator County Manager or designee to waive the requirement for a Historical/Archaeological Survey and Assessment. Once the waiver application has been submitted, it shall be reviewed and acted upon within five (5) working days. The waiver request shall adequately demonstrate that the area has low potential for historical/archaeological sites.) • Historic PrescrvatiorrForms/rcv.06/05;08 1 Packet Page -240- 10/8/2013 8.A. • SECTION ONE:APPLICANT AND PROPERTY OWNERSHIP DATA A. Name of applicant(s)(if other than property owner, state relationship such as option holder, contract purchaser,lessee,trustee, etc.):Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. Mailing Address:206 Ridge Drive, Naples,Florida 34108 Phone:239.596.2988 FAX: E-Mail:laninarich@naplesequestrianchallenge.org B. Name of agent(s)for applicant, if any: D. Wayne Arnold,AICP Mailing Address: Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A.,3800 Via Del Rey, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134 Phone: 239.947.1144 FAX: 239.947.0375 E-Mail: warnold(@,. adyminor.com C. Name of owner(s)of property: Same as Applicant Mailing Address: S Phone: ( ) FAX: E-Mail• Note: If names in answers to A and/or B are different than name in C,notarized letter(s) of authorization from property owner(C) must be attached. SECTION TWO: SUBJECT PROPERTY DATA(Attach copy of the plat book page (obtainable from Clerk's Office at the original scale)with subject property clearly marked.) A. Legal description of subject property. Answer only 1 or 2, as applicable. 1. Within platted subdivision,recorded in official Plat Books of Collier County. Subdivision Name: Pine Ridge Plat Book 3 Page 24 Unit Block 1 Lot 19 and 20 Section 10 Township 49 S Range 25 E 2. If not in platted subdivision, a complete legal description must be attached which is sufficiently detailed so as to locate said property on County maps or aerial photographs. The legal description must include the Section, Township • and Range. If the applicant includes multiple contiguous parcels, the legal Preservation/Forms/rev 06/05/08 2 Packet Page-241- 10/8/2013 8.A. description may describe the perimeter boundary of the total area, and need not describe each individual parcel,except where different zoning requests are made on individual parcels. A boundary sketch is also required. Collier County has the right to reject any legal description,which is not sufficiently detailed so as to locale said property, and may require a certified survey or boundary sketch to be submitted. B. Property dimensions: Area: square feet, or 4.3± acres Width along roadway: 400±feet(Ridge Drive) Depth: 472±feet C. Present use of property: Riding facility and single family residences D. Present zoning classification: A,Agricultural SECTION THREE: WAIVER CRITERIA Note: This provision is to cover instances in which it is obvious that any archaeological or historic resource that may have existed has been destroyed. Examples would be evidence that a major building has been constructed on the site or that an area has been excavated. A. Waiver Request Justification. 1. Interpretation of Aerial Photograph Photo shows existing structures and riding facilities. 2. Historical Land Use Description: Lot 19 previously had a single family home constructed. Lots 20 and 21 contain single family homes,riding facilities and stables. 3. Land, cover, formation and vegetation description: improved properties within platted Pine Ridge subdivision. All 3 parcels have been disturbed_ 4. Other: No excavation activities are proposed for the site. None of the structures are historic in nature and improvements have been constructed between mid 1970's through present. B. The County Manager or designee may deny a waiver, grant the waiver, or grant the waiver with conditions. He shall be authorized to require examination of the site by an accredited archaeologist where deemed appropriate. The applicant shall bear the cost of such evaluation by an independent accredited archaeologist. The decision of 411 Historic Pracrvation/Forms/rcv.06105/08 3 Packet Page -242- 10/8/2013 8.A. • the County Manager or designee regarding the waiver request shall be provided to the applicant in writing. In the event of a denial of the waiver request, written notice shall be provided stating the reasons for such denial. Any party aggrieved by a decision of the County Manager or designee regarding a waiver request may appeal to the Preservation Board. Any party aggrieved by a decision of the Preservation Board regarding a waiver request may appeal that decision to the Board of County Commissioners. SECTION FOUR: CERTIFICATION A. The applicant shall be responsible for the accuracy and completeness of this application. Any time delays or additional expenses necessitated due to the submittal of inaccurate or incomplete information shall be the responsibility of the applicant. B. All information submitted with the application becomes a part of the public record and shall be a permanent part of the file. C. All attachments and exhibits submitted shall be of a size that will fit or conveniently fold to fit into a legal size(8 %2"x 14")folder. Signature of Applicant or Agent D. Wayne Arnold,AICP Printed Name of Applicant or Agent -TO BE COMPLETED BY THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DIVISION- SECTION FIVE:NOTICE OF DECISION The County Manager or designee has made the following determination: ❑ Approved on: By: ❑ Approved with Conditions on: By: (see attached) ❑ Denied on: By: (see attached) • r ,. Historic Preservat:on/Formslrer.06/05:08 4 Packet Page -243- 10/8/2013 8.A. �- - ''s.'�Asa �' .., C ,t ' :-f -r+f i '''.,s. 'r,a x'- •wr s I' .,Y ,fit • ,�. ..4,r. ,: i x. , -) s_r _ � clr . e 4 F t f n_aa`m...4 x1^7 .+vr St. .,-s�� . v 2 CENTER STREET t :. �`'!„* Ex �. "';. r ,.,__4,, :::,;_,K......-2,-,-,_=-Ntt.-1,? - ti w _ ''' -r -- is I q'7 s r I �;: 111 ;_ k #P' 7i.. `w x� y f : tQ t '' r tt' lY '' ',f } L, STAB 1 . I ,It ( S ,�, .Lay z-/a"4`S„i^u'2 w 'Mi f � Q�v�'',.1/2,g� ..,1 r.•( y VV V JI '\ Y `#s ' i @..I Ct; W 111 . 4 ,7 '421(45.2.-. - 4' .. ';: _ s.. W 'r ,� s5 l E O a`'YF''t '• Y ,! 1 891 `5+:--tom '1,.-5-T,. o�, I x s �' t � .r 1 t�- 11 7 i' t7.-..z. ++ rr .hn -,�..I .} ..r CIE s."' i'z� rte-, .W it S i `-3.' �i �. .. 'L_,;ui c;;: ,�? `u' Q 1 k ;S , g 0 ' 1:4..,..,,:.____:." c y !f! :" �« w ' I { i,. l'j 'flr � , s V -,'.`}�r�:� 3 �: rWy,.6.x .t„p'J-'.3 �I _-."J 4. M 1 Y '_'F I ^J' f,.0 ..ter -;.;_, ,N,ti ��a, �" S,� fi r� :t I y ' ,-'a Y} Y {�"'°f"d4a, h _ -114:,' 1 _ y 4� . Y I f r t "^' - _v :« _. 1:1-1:,-..:::::',::':::-..:::‘-2.f,=' e �, �; € •• f,',=_y .I r� I SINGLE FAMILY HO y y� e ¢ x'. . x MES : t- f Y �. -r ja- k .� ',i. ` bra T k t '�- ' I r-t> ,. ''1&'a I , i� t n '1 .7.44,i,';'-j::. ` a 5.3, yy' _ rte'."'°°``,.^ a.r= •L. ''ec. "-c,.Z'e.. ,. 1" i.7`"' :7, ':t r ` �� r �R9A 200 RADIUS c °�u� s, a �� a1 '' } ti zr y� y;Y. t: =:,,3r,,,., 3.3. °,'� J r ^� �i.}a �n 1 LEGEND Code Description Acreage t �I��,a�r-- SUBJECT SITE AA- 111 Sinote Family Homes 0.09 740 Disturbed Lands 2.15 FLUCFCS LI/JE 1891 Stables(Ho rses) 2.10 h'0R TN TOTAL ACREAGE 4.34±ac limini a 00 2OO SCALE: 1" = 200' GradyMinor Gnalgl0mv na Mw mn.l•. NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE "'"2'_ 0"800 Y1+nd Was "u^ ^.IS.M.,. � a CONDITIONAL USE ... III CUdI Engineers Land Surveyors Planners Landscape architects FLUCFCS MAP rax w>. un.rAml,.�uo�'sl c�araara nmz,s. � � DATE AERIAL FLOWN — DECEMBER 2011 11°II BanI piu v 239.9fi9�144 wrn•.led..IfFuur rum Fod.hlg to 239.090A880 3555? 1 OP I 4 RRW- M4O\Y"` -HA lE5 E. , CtNLLENGE 390-:ti\rWC�SDYIG 2/2003 9:90 WI Packet Page 244 10/8/20 1 3 8.A. Print Map Page 1 of 1 +rte' %# _ - - A - � ;'1-'''.z''� k.�' ' 1.,-.7.: -,- a� r fi�,� may ' �,., t ; V -„. .::-.a,''. 2fy r r .a_' .1.!- a .r xi= v,,..• >.._ 1`94ia ,,...,'.:,-----'--;',4.--, .: '3 y-f ti+ S - 74',k- �,s„4.-. sk�..SE-,;,,,,:.',,,,,_.t.::rie,--:.•••=r ,x' r'{'r Kc+ �s �,.ti;yu� .€� � a � s � ,rs ..� r ,k• rK, MAP LEG y.a. xc... .t j'� _ n r2 w�s`T. �C, x _'i« ,. st,- t,i Names. 'r � ''a i. s. _F< ti t i' •W wr �' D 1"afcef9: -g ,� _ i. 3 )�-t"- $ �,fie. i ,3 cu Mai ans �� *n s � r" x# � k J - per- ,� p... �4 .� AerJa73 148 5 ) P a ,3 L . ..y_ r T 7' t .4_,;,: r.,' f $iftlding fD4Spf1i7S9 r� ri 1'�, r x,rw r y 1-1.-"e,' � ` Ca7Jfa Coontp t, .. "'ruS. 4 a -�,h�S��.-..; 41 r; e�. Y z }C d�`F' • -"54,' ct.:,1 a .--- 4c- "^`v' .F C•t,fi.rr ..`l' ,�_ �.r yard „-..;:� as X ▪ }�;-., ?• a-- ' -5r �}x n w..S F t ,r z -"t - r - ..„.s.:-7,5_,-_-,i: ;yam 4 s, }� WM1 �"`s gy! .,y a'' 7Y i� se ' r Ys 1�� 3� 3 �-a ,-.t.---,,....y. �ry'��.� ",yi,�,. ;�', C "�S L c('� — .0,�� . �d,^'i f• T l�li1 d A, r?5 ✓' � A 4.: • T s 'a C° ..r FG3 ;wx�;� .._ ��.: aT fC'xww ''- 5 4c ,..i zY 1 IT n s •. -> "a�", f•••- '4z+ { a,� a3_ l "may il"^ 3. a tt • C 2006,Collier County Property Appraiser.Vd rte the Collier County Property Appraiser is committed to providing the most axurate and up-to date irdormation,no warranties expressed or implisd are provided for the data herein,its use,or its interpretation. O bttpi/www.collierappraiser.com/webmap/mappris Packet Page 245-=LANDSCAPE&paper=LETTER... 5/24/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. 1s. k III pU¢¢ W 6 Z m 7 W c a� WE � `4 W 2 0O aA z a i F' O w F id En NS' E1 Z in I b O 3wl.3 WOW Ad0b2 GC 1 0 N R 5 n :111111.11♦al=a lat•Ia=11•altralMMlaNIIlIIMM1lt•00IlralMIalti N N II e y N p \ i a N I N p 1 p N I §, N N 1 f? II U _ W }1:<,. Liyi c F- 4i fl O : 3 au p p I a- < !4,'" i I '1 =3 w1 II z` j \7► 1 o - 12 8 i 11 p EN 1 -"� "E"`- -TJ 2 ',2; n II .,i _—__ �.» __ _-J 1 11111 111 ig ' R= II N i ( 1 g a i _ �u o - N7 11 !FA . wS ^ I .—J ..._D�K 1J� ' Srg 1 ), 111L °1 • p B !� � t � aay 1a� •* eh._ 1.4 0 o0 II II .,u , a �J Q I i '1= t $ Il € i ' a s e N i ° L- N w 5in1 Pf° — , I n_ a I 1,119111:.;:::1.0 .8 O N N N II S S I i I i l I I b u W I j t • N -,-,�---- - __ -tip Ji \`--- 5 p .1.221:112.. � - # (--\\ r i______________, 1 1 f 2 i 1 4 N I( II N I I N if u p i Q„ (n r �m a <a ° W o >-1- = W_ 2,w S =x . O.a 1m o S nice • Packet Page-246- 10/8/2013 8.A. CFMINVIGNIDAIEP Dfl.W.V46 M..WEER A--.----.../21E71 Zo.---C...... ........"'...''..".-..- ..-■,...-.---.........■- -- — • — — — .. . 0 . • I . .:: .-• ,.. .. , • - , I i•'.-'• ei.: i .t= . -- ,,•;,, 'I ! tz-.1: Rw...11 ' :a.:, •••• ,,....: ....,. i * ::... m.......• „' ' .'L —. r....... Pi. r•I J. '1 -fr. ii. -,-,e II:: NEI ' , .,` ,,.,. I, STREET .. .: ;•''' .• -3 ow . • IT z• re i'-; i _, .. ,,,-; .)::-.14. i t : p . = • :._,. ;311 t-ri . • , 'e• .et, el tit i • • ...r.E., ,r.-st . • „e . ' ..••'. - . '• ..%... -. 1 V.err: rtitg -• I -ill 1111; :1 75 ';" '. . . „. _-.• : .Ni; 1 1.1 • ; • - E r. 'I r, I-:: ,,-•.-7::i'' 'I. .7. ' ''' ' '"• •Its I J ..4' 6 - , s .........1.-- (.- ; i I ,-.v.. -ft--?; ....7' . \ • ,,,,,+'' ' ,nimit i _ ./,. ,., :,:,;,, • .. .. ..,. .., _ ,.:'-;: ,.- Ai-7,' ;--;.=,":. ..'• :air? . 11 fri !gi ..-.„/„. • ,. .-•,.. . 4110 k'.: :cl: Ril f: 91 '41 \lki 'E.; .!!E,F , •; •,..,, I snit- - •-• . , ,11111111 • _ • E: if F illrall '!f!1 if. 1 .1=1111111116.■ -': ''... .t/ 5 : - i...i .iiii10: g -t, EFr 'is., - '---:\j-,••••97.----. .. - 1'1' - ,1 ., ;III ;! :'• t . • gill . , , i .• F.rittr• ?„...-:, .. -, !.. • 7.4 .'.• =Ott f,' '+' , - ..., •41&,0"6° ' ..gaiglitt-• .--,- . / L.3• ml ' . ...,.-- - . -. . s.--z.r. ... . : : •-• r•- / . i -. .3 r :ai-ir ° -1 .!....r.'-t-• 11P- moviii_. - ....... .„...- 1 .1. . ...,.‘ ,..,•,.,. _ , , I .. 7 .7,•,.. .3,,t,, -. .., WI . -... '-': ' i #....-Ni1 i ,..., ....,::_„5„--1,•-1--,.----_-- - 1 . ---, - • cn ,-d ..., t 1 ni 0 ,---t St.'..V•- --.,...r 4, Z .. . I . • . 0 -'. - z 1 ' j.4.• f'4. .7,-Z 2 ril affsmagaz.,-,,ci•-•.,,' I i- li.tli az :.aithilenliWill,..e.::: *. . 77 allWiriMaP.:.,4., -•:-'1::Zi• ., , 44140,:.iii ,..i ** , '''...l i '. 7•:7 . ri G z Cn ''''....4 , - .e.r; :r' . r_ „...) r : . :5-- t::j • „. .F. . 1'; .I..'g! ; ;f 2. 3 f;tEt.g 3 i= , IIIEEEIMI ,..t...:,y ''''' ,t- • ;-1 t• z, ,s=t - Et. i -, .•• _...,...ft. c,, ..- . rri . .., . ,.r, . ...., a . ,p ,1-y ic\: .. .; 1 -" - ii ii i i it it it ti ii ii Et:C; I ,,j IP l■• ''''',-.. scts !•;'' 71,`. ,.:- .-. f." li'"1.1:-.:.i ii 1.1 F.:::U.1:1.i.i.i r...--1'. : f - I -t.:.,r-71;-,-.. k : :; ...F i . Eq.!: i Vp.`111,i"•.'F o. 0 i: . i,, . , __ I E Z 4.- --'2 .- ' r=4:.:::,.,1,3.ki."."--;;;:k.7.f.',...;:"-.!...-'•--3..'11.--=.."-t; ' 1r...A al.:- ..,_ ,rp • . ...- ■ ,• Packet Page -247- 10/8/2013 8.A. ATLANTIC COAST LINE RAILROAD(GTji L£TTE-FRANK ROAD? SKETCH OF SURVEY I Alli0 S.OJ•5208'11 200.13'[P) ,A1 S0J51'Oe'W. 200.2 1•00 SiA NO ID �•^ Y FENCE 1 ON PROPERTY LINE - SPY IM — IN a 0 25' 50' 75' 100' 264' b t Ze tv 47.9' W STOLE ^u a.9' L1 O LEGEND F.C.M.A FOUND 4'ROUND CONCRETE MONUMENT F.C.P.® FOUND 1/2'COPPER PIPE I F.1.R. O FOUND 5/B'IRON ROD ILL • SET.0/B'IRON ROO B&B l8 3241 F.P.K.G FOUND PARKER KAOLIN NAIL WOOD POWER POLE Q 'TELEPHONE BOK lif ,— LIT WIRE g OR. OFF1CJAL RECORD BOCK O.H.P. OVERHEAD POWER py FE CENIERUNE p'4 V {MI MEASURED a (P) PLAT C I I O n. t H LOT 20 W a= ,. LOT 19 h g LOT 18 EXISTING RESIDENCE p : ' LIGHT N,m EXISTING RESIDENCE (NOT LOCATED) ° R AXE S z (NOT LOCATED, 7 c4 Y M to • FENCE 4 FENCE• x � • 1I I-. eI i CO o W Z 1 CU) NO m 0.00•00'00£ 42500 () 424.90'(N If 1 N00•D0'00'E.200.000,,CP) 199.88'00 LEI24. .7'K00'OO'DO E.638.9?'0')638.82':H) 5/8'FLR. :• 01.00-00"11-G_I1RF94P•!P1 104914,'CH10,". _— ,f h LB043 BARINI.'BASIS Yl' st ____________N_____ _____. )1 (6O' RIGHT-OF-WAY) - c ASPHALT RIDGE DRIVE I CEPTTJED TO: NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE DAVID B.BRUNS, PLE JlEALL PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: CertIFICnte Number.4520 LOT 19,BLOCK I, PINE RIDGE, A SUBDIVISION ACCORDING DATE OF SURVEY■APRIL 8,2013 TO THE PLAT THEREOF, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 3,PAGE 24 OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA. NOT VALID WITHOUT THE SIGNATURE AND THE ORIGINAL RAISED ,VOTES, SEAL OF A FLORIDA LICENSED SURVEYOR AND MAPPER. J 1.) BEARINGS SHOWN HEREON REFER TO AN ASSUMED BEARING ON THE /�/� EASTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY OF RIDGE DRIVE AS BEING N.00'110'00'E. (.;;;;D'NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE 2J THIS PROPERTY IS SUBJECT TO EASEMENTS,RESERVATIONS OR RESTRICTIONS OF RECORD. BOUNDARY 0 3.) DIMENSIONS SHOWN HEREON ARE IN FEET AND DECIMALS THEREOF. SURVEY 4J THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN FLOOD ZONE X DATED 5/16/12. SCALE. 0412 1nwvN Ic oso I REE Iez 1' 50' Da& D.B.B. PAS., 15 5.)IMPROVEMENTS OTHER THAN THOSE SHOWN HAVE NOT BEEN LOCATED. • FILE NO 6,)LEGAL DESCRIPTION SUPPLIED BY CLIENT. 33444414, UP' artUrlabo, S y,,,,,,,l,9r & 5,/,,,,,,,,,,,i, AGG"IPRLI9BI 1072 501,, .d...,....00.1d, °Et�t0t1i \\`\ .K0AL., SIL,41. 94102 (95!)_261 - 5965 3L.:L Xw,..rir.,.11 7a 1010 I Packet Page -248- 10/8/2013 8.A. 0Ma'100-bl-C V,3n8ns\Nrd d315V{N\(tL) 291N33 NMa1s3n03 s3ldVN\s1.oZ A3nans-s1.33ro8 d\s p N Cc,.. Cl to{-C Z �� 5.� • < WNOWW_WOIa. 0�3 = •. -1fi �: NW p� OKN JZY ZZUy° WN f'-/IW Fp U O_ -` L�� WC 6o. Q 6 H Op°W O �j \Y � p0 UOF-l-01- Z =W WW2C]N ors' im-J<omoZS Fa. �«w �w H Qti gi. �1i w Q <w 0rip0R 'n 0 cZ z <" wW6' 1 ozw° ° �a tla • u» - JZn,b �i ?I-�OpW�p W �mm o U OJ N O 4°-,a U O m Z~O< vo � NOy{A m co 6_9 O .ri�02 WN3 CW9w 0C W mO L.A.co,_ O2 47 v Wo a).-� woo NQ� 2C'".G C ¢ >- N Lu CC'-'0 ~O hZt1--Z0 i1 N° ZO>>1=llW ZZU< 1+_06a*awC.°OU °¢�h�<w Z -DAY ZO 0 �mpp 1y� 6 ✓� to Vi p N - 11J °mu^Qrnhw,„., ` Ufl1W Q: �_ °gym �sa��° ="ooZZ�Od� 0 °-W' a 0>0 F=O ( o� e'_'=c y� 1J s c W°”<=v+r a N 0 In U m LL L- Z O 0m0J tt.a.T0�W1YXWO „„,0 1O dCWJ..O O �O IIJ NCJJ� �' TZ Q til NN `OI�G C5 8Xz W W W UWU=t=oo ~ Wtn x�')II.tl^�lO >- I .ZI,.,0 KUyy..< �W�O U .�Z.��OSWtQfnN ZZ°� �vO �aU co x..dce WN-,W_'�'�W$ h Z.....a o '00 11 WOF r- I�I4--.l+ zLu W OYC �O�O�NJ W O =6 y.wv,R v3 � O� =ZO w OZ- Oo JOO E- N 4n O 2 O 2W I-U 01�°mm -g g,c5 ��?. 2 w �' UOY°OW r�aK °� C[O ° C�Tao Oi°H�zt...y,,N2 Z ~ 2-=m-WZ O �� Or � <6S.m mt=/IOZOO-OWm U z W°dgSC°U �� ZWK z Z m O 0 WO 0 c..4 rj En tL U 1` r- 0 U =°w W • a O ¢ti"r `r3 D a 0 ¢o ^ 0 0 C Eo°J c p '08 >{NV .d 31 Il1a000 r 9 '° o r III m° " N m K.C.00� Mx£ 1G�°�J Ow 1=6.,'., 200.14' (p) c" m 200.73' (P) m ° U = al t. G CO ^ C ro g 0 as a 0 0 w 6 0 G. 0- 0 co L N. =V C 0. Eri 0 O (O p� C g g Y- •CJ N - dY ti V Y ^0 m 0h O 0 0 m � O mJ O o O in-. C G rr m o 0 o Q CD o .n a Z 0 �+ c o O s O ...r., c5 r Z r • t; r rn !�Y N g CV "01 r4 r2 g; ft < u 200.00' (P) 200.00' (P) o m N00°00'00"E 400.00' m o 0 (30 M .09) CL 3Ala s 30a1d O O U - ° III } ..._ A - 1 g 1' 0 6 a W = 0 v -, 0 o LL 1n Packet Page -249- 10/8/2013 8.A. 13 A 1 • RESOLUTION 2000- 63 A RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A THERAPEUTIC EQUESTRIAN RIDING FACILITY CONDITIONAL USES 19 AND 24 IN THE "A" ZONING DISTRICT PURSUANT TO SECTION 2.2.2.3 OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE FOR PROPERTY LOCATED IN SECTION 10, TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH,RANGE 25 EAST,COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA. WHEREAS,the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter 67-1246,Laws of Florida,and Chapter 125,Florida Statutes,has conferred on Collier County the power to establish,coordinate and enforce zoning and such business regulations as are necessary for the protection of the public;and WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Land Development Code(Ordinance No. 91-102) which includes a Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regulations for the zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County,among which is the granting of Conditional Uses;and • WHEREAS, the Collier County Planning Commission, being the duly appointed and constituted planning board for the area hereby affected,has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided,and has considered the advisability of Conditional Uses 19 and 24 of Section 2.22.3 in an"A"Zone for a therapeutic equestrian riding facility on the property hereinafter described,and has found as a matter of fact(Exhibit"A")that satisfactory provision and an-angement have been made concerning all applicable matters required by said regulations and in accordance with Subsection 2.7.4.4 of the Land Development Code for the Collier County Planning Commission;and WHEREAS,all interested parties have been given opportunity to be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled and the Board having considered all matters presented. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS of Collier County,Florida that: -1- • Packet Page -250- 10/8/2013 8.A. 13A 1 The petition filed by Karen Blackwell representing Naples Equestrian Challenge Center, L. C. with respect to the property hereinafter described as: Lot 21,Block 1,Pine Ridge subdivision as recorded in Plat Book 3, Page 24, of the Official Records of Collier County be and the same is hereby approved for Conditional Uses 19 and 24 of Section 22.2.3 of the`A"Zoning District for a therapeutic equestrian riding facility in accordance with the Conceptual Master Plan (Exhibit"B")and subject to the following conditions: Exhibit"C"which is attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution be recorded in the minutes of this Board. This Resolution adopted after motion,second and majority vote. Done this D day of- i4 ,2000. BOARD OF ZON2IC')APPEALS COT.!.TFR COUNTY,FLORIDA • TIM THY J. �DNS�CHAIRMAN All S± .: ._ DWIGHT E.BROCK,Clerk Dc- Attest .as to Ctafrtt '; S}�$ltidforni and Legil,Spfficiency:• Maori M.Scuderi Assistant County Attorney • -2- Packet Page-251- 10/8/2013 8.A. 13 /\ 1 FINDING OF FACT BY COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION FOR A CONDITIONAL USE PETITION FOR CU-99-30 The following facts are found: 1. Sections 2.2.2 .3 .10 and 2.2.2.3.19 and 2.2.2 .3 .24 of the Land Development Code authorized the conditional use. 2. Granting the conditional use will not adversely affect the public interest and will not adversely affect other property or uses in the same district or neighborhood because of: A. Consistency with the Land Development Code and Growth Management Plzr : Yes t/ No B. Ingress and egress to property and proposed structures thereon with particular reference to automotive and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe: Adequate ingress & egess Yes ✓ No C. Affects neighboring properties in relation to noise, glary./economic or odor effects: i/ No affect or Affect mitigated by Affect cannot be mitigated D. Compatibility with adjacent properties and other property in the distric . Compatible use hin district Yes j No Based on the above findings, this conditional use shou , with stipulations, (copy attached) 414INKIMINE.04 re ommend for approval U2. DATE: /00 MEMBER• • VICE-CHAI rJ.k—mm ING OF FAR LWI mmic11-90.30 Exhibit "A" • Packet Page-252- Pilli°11...6 --- 1 0/8/2013 8.A. 1 RIDGE DRIVE [13-11V-1 1 60' RIGHT OF WAY f WWI. 223.00. r I. o i y N a —^ yn rn a cn o e x Z r 8 x • o IEiijil• V s A V j O _ 1 .. (`j n-z z 1 j, ;; _—) .. i Hi sor•� .. vs rs � .. C000LE7E-FRANK ROAD aa(PL2g aogED1120/1a 6bGJbdga6` lMidlef E- . I CONCEPTUAL MAS)Cf3 PLAN _._. •M t-4 i eat igclgaSgMINXIIIIIIIMEEIUIIIIIIIIEISM6gmematzgagst=lk x-. ---"t-='r—— Exhibit "B" fx ,•: mss= Packet Page -253- __ 10/8/2013 8.A. 13A11 CU-99-30 1. Pursuant to Section 2.2.25.8.1 of the Land Development Code, if,during the course of site clearing, excavation or other construction activity, an historic or archaeological artifact is found, all development within the minimum area necessary to protect the discovery shall be immediately stopped and the Collier County Code Enforcement Department shall be contacted. 2. An exotic vegetation removal, monitoring, and maintenance plan for the site, with emphasis on areas of retained native vegetation, shall be submitted to the Planning Services Director for review and approval,prior to Site Development Plan approval. 3. An application for Site Development Plan approval shall be submitted to the Planning Services Director within 60 days of approval of this Resolution. 4. This approval is for a therapeutic equestrian riding facility only. Any other use that is not permitted by right shall require approval of another Conditional Use. • EXHIBIT"C" • Packet Page -254- 1 0/8/2013 8.A. Crl4INISIG MRABER DPAWNG NUMBER Ar-1,,,:s5,N2RER ZT—Ti.HER ...--...........-.............. ...........-,...........,........ .,...............- • • .. , .. • . 1., . .. _ a OP" ..,I2.,. ......• ,.:2;.,,, "I ir'..: .....M... ■.,f. P-11 i P. iql I ..... :" = .w. es I •' . NORTH STREET k , ..1;, i Ts IR : • i E i ni I ..: i ,Il 221 rrl CT)•:. I es sZ. .es I 311 i':'11 u 2 • _ - ••••"0- . : 1:. rA '''-'• ' ''' - 11 ihit'• t 1 / il . .:,.. vir,..... ...=, ..m,.,,...„ , .4,„i„,,,in,:,„.:, '.2. ,, . rap 2. •il o .722.AV-..nr.•• )..2 l'....- . '.. ,, e.m , ... , .- _er'''X `,,,,,, "'s ..,, .•••r2i:. . . ..‘11 . • I I : Ter...,.2 ,...; s. ! : it Z ■ ."4,117;: r ‘-. ''.."0 '...* ': •El T!f.t. -.1 )2.-- . 4''. .411 • .. ...., :Arf, 1= til Pi f:itil 4118,;,! • ri ;i: tia i ail IN I=t'l ' :-tl 11';(-Mill . • ... . . 1* grillear ls 4 1 - 1 1.1!Hili ' MOE , 1. .i.' • 1,4 eiii;i:ei 21':' t . Illirr1110k0,7.- ._ , a ,:, - , "- -- — •1• Iliiti ;,, =-',1 = ., • . t 4,1f ' ii '(-:pt ;•141-: g r" i - - E .....i .,,,,,. . . • :-. I: :3 i !:-.iya; ■-• , . . — • ,....1...;:.:-... - ... N zt _ a /• E-2.'S M :2■2 • ; Z. ' . 18161406.• .. .. 0... ' .,... .• • r 1 glut F, lz 6 :4,. :'-1- ••• 2 j 12: ■ 1 i•ri5.1 ' - - .1 -....,.. f ' ri . ... - I.r.. 7 c; ■--1 - • 0 ...,, . =0 › ;71 IPINON11111Val 77it P...i <marsinaminr m.',.;1,.... m .12, ; '-' ' 7- 0 a gi :t;str- ...-: ,- I ;" 'T.' • .. 7 .:, g rl y , ,.., All t •.: I , 7.--n: ' il 1 r J f • ....... INF ...' 2ii.i; . F; • osaisaka--"wig..„, & ,-. - ,'e„l'..,f ,z ::., .22.i.,, .., . . ,,, / c, ,.. : •• 2 ;T•• ' l -!-: '',-: E ICJ :.(11 --. ' Cro i. :-. ?i!ii‘ :-::3 '''''-'‘k" — ti, - f•• ... Z il :, - ..e.":""''). ... ... rn rri _ .-f.. ,.,,,,,. ,.r. '.'1 .2.2,1 S T A.E_S__1__:__ _ -17' -— ..\ ..-,... . --...' " 0,,•7,'„et ii i i ii if if if il i! ii lr, E 4$••• f- /: ;1',“,:ti Z.,, a Zi:" i.i:ii:i.I-il q ii: iii f 0 i *•! .F.; Vil. ....; il id 1 1 It It 11.IL It II 1.1.N - ,......... Vali {C vie. 1 _ ,,,...., ,...„ 7....,,..„,, . . •.: t., zaz.V 1 .':... - .7.., Packet Page-255- .....„.,.,...,.. ___..... 10/8/2013 8.A. Mission&History I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 1 of 2 Mission&History Mission & History Speakers'Bureau The mission of Naples Equestrian Challenge is to improve the lives of 7 Meet Our Staff children and adults with special needs through therapeutic riding and Meet Our Horses other equine-related programs. Community Council Naples Equestrian Challenge(NEC) is a therapeutic horseback riding center Board of Directors which began in 1995 as a satellite of the Special Equestrians therapeutic Annual Report and Financials riding center in Fort Myers, FL. The NEC satellite group began with four volunteers,four children with disabilities and two borrowed horses on a borrowed field. In 1997, NEC incorporated as a separate nonprofit organization. In 2001, NEC became a United Way member agency, and in 2003, NEC became a beneficiary of Naples Children and Education Foundation,founders of the Naples Winter Wine Festival.With the generous support of the community, NEC has expanded from serving four individuals in 1995 to serving more than 375 individuals in 2012. • In 2000, NEC became a PATH-Certified therapeutic riding center. PATH (Professional Association of Therapeutic Horsemanship International), is an international accrediting organization which has standardized the practices of equine-assisted activities and therapies. In 2011, NEC was awarded the prestigious"Premier Center"status by PATH International. NEC operates on a 5-acre site which is home to a herd of ten very special horses. The site includes a covered riding arena,which was generously funded by the Naples Children and Education Foundation in 2006. The arena helps protect our riders and volunteers from the rain and the brutal heat of the summer sun. Today, NEC is serving approximately 375 individuals per year through its various programs,which include therapeutic riding for individuals with disabilities, Equine-Facilitated Learning and Equine-Facilitated Psychotherapy programs as well as summer inclusion camps and outreach programs. Participants range in age from 2 to 87 years old.The therapeutic riding programs offered at NEC foster growth and confidence, empowering riders living with cerebral palsy, Down's syndrome,ADHD, autism spectrum, traumatic brain injury, multiple sclerosis, stroke survivors and developmental • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/abt Packet Page-256-ry/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. Mission&History I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 2 of 2 delay. Equine-Facilitated Learning and Equine-Facilitated Psychotherapy • program participants include children and adults with a wide range of emotional, learning and developmental challenges as well as behavioral disorders. Click here for the NEC: Fact Sheet Click here for the NEC: Brochure CLICK ON THE LOGO'S BELOW FOR MORE INFORMATION: PATH 4.aY.WmavMls.e.^ United" of Collier County. NCEF + F C;t1.EJhT c:tV • Home•About Us•Our Programs•Our Stones•Get Involved•Contact Us•Privacy Policy•Sitemap {„),,,•_ Cfp), EGG • \P� 2011 Naples Equestrian Challenge.All Rights Reserved Terms of Use!(239)596 2988 1 info @naplesequestrianchaltenge.org 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 • . http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/Packet Page 257 story/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. The Mission The mission of Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC) is to improve the _ lives of children and adults with special needs through therapeutic riding SAVE _ III and other equine-related programs. ,��d� k „ f The Programs ' NEC offers weekly therapeutic riding lessons for children and adults ` -x:4 with special needs. Each lesson is typically 30 minutes in duration. �.. Weekly riding lessons include exercises and games on horseback, tai- s; 7s'. bored to students' individual needs and designed to help them advance :t - a `3* ' their abilities.NEC also offers summer horse camp opportunities in an •,.-. inclusion model for children with and without disabilities. x � ''`-' Equine-facilitated learning and psychotherapy also are provided at NEC y _, ..7–.1,,,, t t each month.These lessons are primarily taught from the ground,but may ,r — ''s include some riding.Program activities are designed for groups ranging i w i y; '� from 4-40 participants. .---=',-'4 i4t lili. Riders - '4 NEC served more than 375 participants in 2011 ranging in age from 2d— "' , _ "`; 80 years old. The special needs of our weekly riders typically include ADHD,aphasia, autism spectrum disorder,cerebral palsy,developmaen- -.....:__,_,,,_..s,,„-,.;: ;`- s tal delay, Down's syndrome, Parkinson's, multiple sclerosis, shaken 1 baby syndrome,stroke survivors and traumatic brain injury.As of Sep- " tember 2012, 120 special equestrians ride with us weeldy and another 1c 114 individuals participate in our equine-facilitated learning and psycho- ---" III`` ' '1 therapy programs. rt r.`u � - ". ` fix. , srde-:em-.a Benefits _; �-.':°z_ e z t Equine therapy offers excellent benefits... it relaxes muscles,increases �:� �,, T � joint mobility,strengthens and improves posture,balance and coordina- k s tion. It also develops self-confidence, concentration, trust and self- - l• discipline...and horses provide a unique source of love and reassurance r F for our special students! - -- L � Operating Costs&Budget � NEC subsidizes most of the cost of riding and other equine-related ac- 0 tivities. We charge therapeutic riders a nominal fee of$10 per 30- k''''' _ minute riding lesson. �, - Naples Equestrian Challenge's operating budget for FY 2012 is a $576,000.This budget reflects continued program growth_ The operat- R:' rte"¢ �cw, r. ing budget does not include capital expenses (major repairs & pus- `�� ' ; ':4;11::. chases). Over 450 active volunteers and the generosity of the local bust- a t `- 1i'' ;` -1 i, ness community helps NEC stretch our operating budget dollars further with in kind'donations of goods and services. M# � , ` .- _t 4 s°'* United Way Member Agency , I _---1 NEC became a Member Agency of United Way of Collier County m ,y, v. January 2001_ This year's grant helped with administrative staff salaries, , allowing us to continue the program's expansion. .k.e h Outreach and Collaboration --_ NEC collaborates with many other local non-profit organisations to con- n �. j duct outreach and ongoing programming, including but not limited to ,c a� _ Y Youth Haven,Big Brothers&Big Sisters of SWFL,Eden Florida,Light- r , --4° f house of Collier County, PACE Center for Girls, Shelter for Abused �� 0 ik k _ �. Women and Children,Parkinson's Association of SWFL,MS Center of �""' � P + SWFL,Friends of Foster Children,National Affiance for Mental Health It ." and with New Beginnings&Beacon of Collier County Public Schools. t ' -.�y �, '' . ;f k Contact Information r ,., _" fit",.- ��,, " -.. � �l 1 `tom w —- Naples Equestrian Challenge,Inc. `- EA v,w.s .-?.. W....7 "F 206 Ridge Drive,Naples,FL 34108 ; 7 """"'"° 1 _S�-`� , Tel 239-596-2988/Fax:239-514-2908 s www.napleseouestrianchallenge.or¢ 6 " i:' Email: -_ infona..napleseouestrianchallenge.org 410 Packet Page-258- 10/8/2013 8.A. • i �,CSy_i r� '.J a 4fi— d 2� /V V .P.14:-.P711:0..S k %0; 5 h a 6, • �h i 2013 NEC SUMMER-HORS'- , HI P-CAMP. SUMMER CAMP SCHEDULE Morning Camps 8:3oam-1.:oopm NEC Summer Camp activities June 10—June 14 (Ages so&Over) consists of Riding,Horse Care, June s7—June 22 (Ages 9&Under) Horsemanship,Grooming, Tacking June June 28 and Daily Arts and Craft Activity z4— (Ages so&Over) July 8-July 12 (Ages9&Under) July 25—July 29 (Ages so&Over) We Accept Campers Ages July 22—July 26 (Ages 9&Under) July 29—Auguste (Ages so&Over) 4 through 18. The • SUMMER CAMP FEES* Camper-to-Counselor Morning Camps ratio is 2:1. Full Rate: $300.00 Discounted Rate*:$200.00 *Discount for Children with Special Needs/Multi-Child/Multi-Week Advanced Riding and Horsemanship Camp** Rate:ss6o for the 7-week afternoon session (Wednesday afternoons only) **Requires Instructor approval Contact Missy Saracino,Program Director,for more information. 239-596-2988 or MissySaracino @NaplesEquestrianChallenge_org, 1 i . REGISTRATION DEADLINE:: MAY IA,` o3. ` ` Z f f �. ' j r ii,ti `` +��tff �+ 1,- , `. .i 'J S `t,� »1555444. } 1 . P t / 1 l4 t, r� ., �, ,Ys 1 ,fir, ,�1 >� Jj///vsk e E ! It s' R WI.' 4 :te - ` 1'�" x ,a ar i t ID 4� -1-7 te x �: 'a ? FAtee,Q.moe t t w g% 0 .4,. Packet Page-259- 10/8/2013 8.A. - - •• - - \i‘ge..-- .- : ._ _ -- _--__,--_ _4 . '..-AL.. ,..._,1,1,,,,,,,,,i....i"7:-.5- - .-V'''-'`...-' ''.,. . .*ea . -,,—,- . . .,---,3 ; .., .... '- .- . ‘,..,\- -,.----..--. -.::.; .:.-.'. .. -:: 1.. ,‘,./967,r_k . IN--7..,‘„ri,--,-..,4. %.,-.J.-.„-„,---------t---:,1i, :',.._--.,,;-. ..... .. p.„„4.:.- -....:. .- .. ',. Lc).;.:' . ,.. .--....; .' ,. .., -..-. . . -.., . ---.-.-iiN , , (Le. ,, _.-_--T 3- *. l' -1'.. * -0,-._ .z. gi Tt=4„0:- ,,, –. . _ 113 - - i,,,, o ' '� -� app � �7_`A- ' y� � a �t ^�_ 40 — , L=. ... .. ' .--- :,-: .1.),)-- ,. .....,. ,.--,...: . 4, - i:i- ,714 : .. ti44.- . --..,- _,.1.._.-:.=,-,--.E., '.:.0,.. ,---..,-7-:::4,41:_, ... - .t..., ... i.) _.,.: . z .. . . .. 4 ... .,....__...,.. ._. • ./ . 1„;."...... :;.... , ._... v_i.., . ` yam^"" M_ � 7; ,'. • 3 cu >,V W fry ` L LG C O l4 U O h J7U c0 N >, a) `U ° L o m o E O ._ , N n E Q U _ m .. ca v ° a. W (4), to N O as a,......1 E a J , cu N Z Y N ` Q o .B o �c1 c C 3 o R To p o o O U p � � a � n N o, m o t h a, i t O c CD I go z C t 1 0 1 a 0. as U U� RS N 1P1!Z O > p ❑,- cr o C' a O i w s I w ,..,.=� a 00 ❑❑ w M� O a2 Y 0) ° 0C` - an 0 � ¢O o � wCC Z p l f . ❑ � �.41 � Zo 000� 0 w a)} x , o o o w d cri i?Al.; i `o m m c 2 -o `o . c �. ..ay +=. O 'a 2 L L 2. p X" EV mil) -O o Li an a) r �'�J Oc �1?JM - :. 'C-.o'p i ,L�,� [- a) a 5 fu o.�C"o a•• `l .ti 0.- y i. m u m L 3 A m ur o ti a o m c n m > a>i t ti 0 o w ° a C7 m is U > -O N n C p, v 3 LI' bite) '° r Q t = t=- cw `comE .o r"' 11. m c 1--.".°12"-4,i'-9=.• C'c 'm aµ� a ..ca.) L cm as.w o •�, `� ®t�9 1, m N p -G m c w as fU O) U _° fi N Q m .. -.a) c A) i p .d 1L -,Z -( ,m C o N o o c a) c- -0 0 s~ s d v yn H o O0 a tJ • a) a4- .�{. t— -0•� c_E� E y 6 m 5 w CY C ° C W c I -Vf V � 4)79. °'�" o pa-U c'-0 E Q) O ..O � 3 O � � O � C,� '9- 1 �.p iI 1s (� _a7�WIiiflj- ( r L• E maw c ip o lL m N v m .., wd fa c c a`' °�y .c? n- 1011 m ° 2 m f vmc� � em: 16V E� m�0, 0— o Qn- U o p.0 F.* am =to mad ° 5 t0 o O)"' O r L 6sm p C c 02 03 ca L a) .a] N d '4.' � _O , d .)-„:.5.. ® :fl 0.A) L .. a Q .( ,_C.a C ill_ __c C ` C L M U r 1 (... V a' E as t;,. .�. ;� c >� -- .0 N s $ 1= 7 a)'a t— V) ..■ 4 W -° .:e pm p'C-SA y /9 a)H- N m m0 ,s 1---' 0.1 To] °1m z E) ' 1'�L az ° N a O v' ` C U O 4 a`V .� O O -2C C D t'S N N fay'C C C u 03 r W m 3 a)?5 a) a m Est }y d r t- D a.. c - s ?' a N'a .L-. O N >•N [�( `l .A =,•,' {} l6 "O..s. Ya.'� ,a' U fa w m C 0 > a1 -C Est = :1,15 II){II U..p N �a°� °v �� m � P _zom; ur� aymu9r° W z o 2 2 2-= 2 a) o c Packet Page-260- 10/8/2013 8.A. > oy_ �, r.,71 p-'`� $ 111(.1-1.1i,(i it!'d' s- - - s E' r, ,d•- C1. L1 . .' 2C1 c m o 2 a) 2=ai '; , w n} b 7: � :`y a)2 O L.. C N a 7.,_ -�� y. L y •p . L =t-, ti ti V �{� 0 3 Y p 7 L t - ? s `AFP 1 \ Vii U N m c U O C i' •tag' -»ia--^ slit s Ct _ ,} y al 3 v m - xi ,car �`w t.� �r -:a�.t °�.. 'r Y� a(6 O N O C a _ Yr :>„ PC TTh�y . .re':-:` 1 '~' m S :° a N o . s r + �1 .pert, „..-4-=',..4i.,-=..;=.71 , i.'��”' L .2 -i4 a O R C On. '�"k''7 cu m..-reit 414 ' '4":: 1:4;;:‘ } ' '''''''''' '''-'.';F:t15::7, -,11;AI ;''..',,'.4..,Z.Z../.,.,t,717,C1:..;!1,. ilii a E g (g. „,--3 tts i _ n �y T 8 N Q C U- ,-°�3 k � "'' Q] 1 41r• , *. c c,_, t° t y 41# o� f � F yg Z v s o m Y m ran �. •{. u� 0 5 ell :� ., ._,•_,..1.. `4 1 'J r iiG..-; 7 2 t L^11� _ 5 ssue§�. , 4��11aaa• ti. U � �. [.y u-- - ., ,�� *t 4,1 tt x F gi $ay fl T.>, x,,:1 ' :'� V v.4 i_ ., f - -<i., *p., old t a l '�`�.:w.., _._e x: ." } Q m a- 7'] '�S � ,-r t ,_ hTl i-,s P u i_ ,r�' t G.� y:� , 9Y .�.. m '{ - v O. m— -A•.,..,.. -em �r ur .a •.. .� - C y,- }a' _ x''s .-''''`7 21, sa ce 0 O .t ^ = �y- + 1 j -s,44 3 F z:" 7 .. iR g awl i. w L _ n -k N �.. ,`�► 7.. ia$ ti.-. w N , >a cf,t;-x v x3F r /q }®Y �' : C7 siC. J.,�+e .yam t at '` ,G1 'J .,,,,. "_s... -D .-, e,.,,.. l0.14 - ,�.i:PAr u R6 Q c O y•'c ` v �kaEr wT.._�:.-... `..`,.; e,A ' , r 0-4- s ;O a.�, o°u fio c=,-,1 D t0 3 r y Z p) t� C�7i km s za p m: � o€ -z C) Ct 4r N N L_ m d o U o ,,wru,.. ' a 'xc c �� a cy an p C .. Z i o • ° E._• a) - N `m m -°-' c w a) ▪ aim cs y.,.m U o d m a_ S: . - y m m 3 'm > >o m Z N c E'" m: -e. , ° as m 6 v a fip > m 0_ ? N fl U m 0 '`r �,w `E`i n, 4i:: .c,,,„ r a� ,p a aJ o v L c Li E a .� C e o aJ a m w 0�4� m x m u] Q � � ,�. C �{ ..ca)� a N n m > > omaJ of• rt m r rm,� _.`,—os p p y - -. .,�''-. -. r:' m a) c a� O m v Z m ''-' c'a U a N L ,,��'o�,� o��o: n. n5 a� m a o •x�3 � .3i , t m U - ^ (� m '° S •m v E °:_c W 8 m7� cz ." ar m m"-,a m i E,- e N v` vy !rte c C Q N . o Z Q a N m o >. -,> a >y,..' .> 4 3 ' ,v ^ N_ a) N a N NCO C a N C N CO o © y2 o o gO ur, s� w *.. - - p N N a `n a) C) a.= —a -7 � , a ci a 1 : � c � v a co' mma�lacmwxm m r• o a c 5 `- m x ym oui' a am m m o a`m crr o ° m ,+'r b t: * .473.4 v o o.'ao` v o. m w m '� w is m ..t . :w, W t a� m e c n -- o p a m• _ _�O z a � a a t 3 .,O a3 . '.0 a - :1-1' It r m C L TT�� mom'. t O a) i c a a m v o Tm a` a) {N 6 N O @ L:G a, a -;, • 1 a r •P1 ,F„, _ v oC) N O Q C .a Li12 " s -•N itr. v _ N-- ° -',A, .-� -°1 .c EO R � N = m ,:03 m .p CN °'m U � :lA O - d. -� U to O -c.c.:,-a L'v c ; 7-..... '` 'N 07 O) q a 4 " .m C p�� s p a) :o` N H ,� ?2' 1 p L a a a s Qa m:� � =a R K" R' m a) ' 17') _ c? _. z °O Packet Page-261- 10/8/2013 8.A. Therapeutic Riding I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 1 of 3 Therapeutic Riding Therapeutic Riding EFL&EFP NEC offers therapeutic riding lessons for children and adults with special Summer Camps needs. Each lesson includes exercises and games while on horseback, OPERATION STRIDES tailored to the rider's individual needs and designed to help with improvements with their abilities. Outreach&Collaboration Collaborative Partnerships Because the movement of a horse mimics the movement of a human's walk, riders experience this movement in their own bodies and receive physical, sensory, and neurological stimulation.This translates to stronger muscles, better balance and coordination, and,just as importantly, increased self- confidence and self-esteem. What is "therapeutic riding"? Because the movement of a horse mimics the movement of a human's walk, • riders experience this movement in their own bodies and receive physical, sensory, and neurological stimulation. This translates to stronger muscles, better balance and coordination, and,just as importantly, increased self- confidence and self-esteem. How does someone enroll in a therapeutic riding program? At NEC, our process is thorough:When an inquiry is received,the required forms are either downloaded from our web site or we send out an application package that includes medical forms, release forms,and information about our program. When we receive the forms back,we schedule an assessment and an evaluation ride. This is done by a member of our team of PATH Certified Riding instructors, often with the assistance of a licensed Physical Therapist. There is a one-time, non-refundable$30.00 fee for the rider evaluation. Not everyone who applies or is evaluated, is accepted into the program. Sometimes there are reasons why we cannot accept a rider(or a rider does not want to enroll after all), and we follow PATH guidelines in making these decisions. • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/ow tti Packet Page 262 c-riding/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. Therapeutic Riding I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 2 of 3 Once accepted, an appropriate class and time for weekly lessons is chosen. • If we do not have an opening in the appropriate class,the rider is placed on a waiting list until an opening becomes available.We make every effort to accept riders into our program as quickly as possible. How can I get the forms to sign up? Click on the links below or you can also send an email to missysaracino @naplesequestrianchallenge.org What happens after the Initial Evaluation? After the initial evaluation, goals are set for the rider for the current Session. These may include physical, cognitive, and/or behavioral goals.An appropriate method of mounting and dismounting are described and put in the rider's chart,together with any special instructions for sidewalkers. Suggestions for appropriate horses and tack are also included.This information is then used by our instructors to design lesson plans and objectives for each lesson.At the end of the Session, a Progress Report is generated and each rider is reassessed to determine which goals have been met, and to set new goals for the next Riding Session. When are lessons? We currently offer lessons on Mondays (3:30-6:45pm), Wednesdays 41) (4:30-6:00pm), Thursdays (9-11:OOam and 4:15-7:OOpm), and Saturdays (7:30am-12noon)during Winter, Spring and Fall.The summer season is a shortened schedule for general sessions but Summer Camp sessions are available. In August and on certain Holiday's there is no riding. To better identify our riders by age and ability level,we have assigned all of our therapeutic riders to teams,with names such as Palominos,Appaloosas, Thoroughbreds, Mustangs, and Clydesdales. We hope this will be a fun way for riders to identify themselves and build camaraderie within the teams. Click on this link to view our schedule: NEC Program Groups are decided bases on the following criteria: Mounting,Verbal Skills, Physical Skills,Ability to Process,Adaptive Equipment,Sidewalkers needed, Leaders required, Grooming and tacking and age. How much does it cost? Riders sign up for a Session which is composed of 6-8 weeks of group riding • lessons ($10 per 30 minute group riding lesson weekly).The cost of an eight- http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/Packet Page -263..)eutic-riding/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. Therapeutic Riding!Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 3 of 3 week Session is therefore a total of$80; riding fees must be paid in advance of each Session. • NEC Participant Packet 2013 Annual Physician Referral Form z ©2011 Naples Equestrian Challenge.All Rights Reserved Terms of Use (239)596 2988 info lnaplesequestrianchallenge.org 206'Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 • • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/our Packet Page 264-tic-riding/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. OPERATION STRIDES I Naples Equesli.ian Challenge Page 1 of 3 • ke511610/ Therapeutic Riding OPERATION STRIDES EFL&EFP Summer Camps 04:1E-P- L s �t �' OPERATION STRIDES ®P E R A ! ION Outreach&Collaboration ~ . � Collaborative Partnerships _ _.._......_ _....._: STRIDES ft'C6t1r tan to',ti1,Tib 17�, • a �5 -Miss, , NEC's Operation Strides is an Equine-Facilitated Psychotherapy(EFP) program with a curriculum geared toward adult veterans from the Afghanistan/lraq/Gulf Wars suffering from PTSD,TBI and amputation. EFP, which is increasingly being used to treat war veterans suffering from PTSD, incorporates horses experientially for emotional growth and learning. EFP is a collaborative effort between a psychotherapist and an equine specialist working with participants and horses to address treatment goals. During an EFP session,the participants learn about themselves and others while participating in activities with horses, and then processing (or discussing) • feelings, behaviors and patterns. In EFP,the interaction with horses helps military veterans to gain self-understanding and emotional growth. http://www_naplesequestrianchallenge_org/c Packet Page-265-, for-heroes/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. OPERATION STRIDES I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 2 of 3 Participants in NEC's Operation Strides program engage in non-riding and riding activities. Initially,the participants are involved in ground(non-riding) activities involving the horses at liberty in the arena(non-tethered, roaming freely)which requires the participant or group to apply certain skills: non- verbal communication, assertiveness, leadership,teamwork, confidence and observation of the equines are several examples,to complete an exercise. Exercises can be as simple as giving a participant a halter and letting him/her figure out how to approach the horse and put the halter on the horse. In addition,Operation Strides participants engage in riding sessions to experience and develop the skills needed to communicate and work with the horse from the saddle—a more dominant position. EFP offers military veterans a safe environment in which to work through issues such as: • Confidence, self-esteem and assertiveness ■ Trust and compassion • Sharpening of senses and self-awareness • Verbal and non-verbal communication skills and social skills • Self concept, goal setting and motivation • Fear, anxiety and self-doubt • Anger and impulses • Physical fitness and body movement • PATH Intl. Equine Services for Heroes PATH INTERNATIONAL • &raseSenirajorHrm. "Appreciating the power of the horse to change lives is our goal,"said Professional Association of Therapeutic Horsemanship International (PATH Intl.)Past President Dr. Paul Spiers, and PATH Intl.wants to provide positive change for these very special lives. Our service personnel have fought to preserve our freedom,and,for many, at a very dear cost.We must be certain that if our wounded service personnel and veterans need and want this kind of help,they will get the best PATH Intl. has to offer." PATH Intl. Equine Services for Heroes Mission PATH Intl. Equine Services for Heroes assists military veterans through services provided by PATH Intl. members and by providing leadership and guidance for equine assisted activities and therapies. • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/oui packet Page-266-r-heroes/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. OPERATION STRIDES I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 3 of 3 To accomplish this mission,PATH Intl.centers connect with Department of • Veterans Affairs Medical Centers and Clinics, as well as individual veterans. Veterans of any age can benefit from the program and by being involved with equines. szt z 2011 Naples Equestrian Challenge.All Rights Reserved Terms of Use/(239)596 29881 infolnaplesequestrianchallenge.org 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 • • • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/i Packet Page-267-'-for-heroes/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. Outreach& Collaboration j Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 1 of 2 c_ e5i o,77 • • z Therapeutic Riding Outreach &Collaboration EFL&EFP NEC collaborates with many other local non-profit organizations to provide Summer Camps the benefits of equine-assisted therapies. Some of these organizations OPERATION STRIDES include: Outreach&Collaboration Big Brothers&Big Sisters of SWFL Collaborative Partnerships Eden Florida Lighthouse of Collier County Deaf Kids Club Shelter for Abused Women and Children Parkinson's Association of SWFL 111 MS Center of SWFL National Alliance for Mental Health NewBeginnings Middle School • Beacon High School of Collier County Public Schools Youth Haven Friends of Foster Children PACE Center for Girls David Lawrence Center Alzheimer's Support Network • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/oui Packet Page -268--programs/ 4/5/2013 10/8/2013 8.A. Outreach& Collaboration I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 2 of 2 • In addition to our Inclusion Camps,we also offer"Outreach Camps"to groups of children from Youth Haven, David Lawrence Center, Boys&Girls Club of • Naples, St Matthew's House and Foster Care Council. Many of these • campers have never been close to a horse and their initial reaction is often, "big, scary, and smelly"! However, during the course of the camp, each child learns how to behave around these large, gentle animals, learning new skills and forming a relationship with the horses. EhC� z o 2011 Naples Equestrian Challenge.All Rights Reserved Terms of Use (239)596 2988 infoQnaplesequeshianchallenge.org 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 • • • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/I ' . rch-programs/ 4/5/2013 Packet Page-269- 10/8/2013 8.A. Collaborative Partnerships I Naples Equestrian Challenge Page 1 of 1. ,c e5 Iofc '4.5 • '-f94 411 61.. ) ., , _,rii,,-\ ...ch z (t, • (... Collaborative Partnerships •` -, • Therapeutic Riding P EFL&EFP We are proud to have collaborated with the following groups on specialized Summer Camps summer camps: OPERATION STRIDES *Special Olympics Outreach&Collaboration Collaborative Partnerships *EDEN Florida *Therapeutic Integration Services in Naples *Florida Gulf Coast University Occupational Therapy Students Outreach&'Collaborations �• --_ 3 y D irs In addition toots therapeuticnding,?TEC collaborates-rim III several other local uorrprnnt organizatipus to provide otters mwithfne manybeoefirs ceEguineFacihrtcd Learning and Psychos eiapy;Piogi-•ras - 2.1,,,NG S EE It?'-`7, youth)fCcvM E:'W tR 2QQC � lc.'. � , ..-/ CFit._RE M ,,,,,,,===y- ;g N fir% uvxa� �; p ace , Home•About Us•Our Programs•Our Stories•Get Involved•Contact Us•Privacy Policy•Sitemap 014 Z J m C 2011 Naples Equestrian Challenge.All Rights Reserved Terms of Use I(239)596 2988 I info @napiesequestrianchallenge.org 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 • http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/ow Packet Page-270 ative-partnerships/ 4/5/2013 10/8/201 3 8.A. • October 08,2008 Mr.Brad Stockham,PSM WilsonMiller _________ -- - 3200.Bailey.Lane,_Suite 200 Naples,FL. 34105 Re: Engineering Review—Lot Line Adjustments • LLA-AR 13776,NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE Dear Mr. Stockham: This is in response to your letter dated 9/22/2008 with attached original lot line adjustment affidavit regarding the above referenced property. We have reviewed the affidavit submitted and find it to be in compliance with the provisions of Section • 3.2.4.8 of the Land Development Code. Attached please find the original affidavit which has been . acknowledged by this office. This document must be recorded in the public records of the County. A copy of the recorded document must be submitted to Engineering Review immediately after it is recorded and to the Building Review and Permitting Department with the building permits for the properties in question. Furthermore, please be advised that (if not previously recorded) you must also record a Quit—Claim Deed in the Public Records of Collier County in order to complete the lot line adjustment. If you have any questions regarding any of the above,please do not hesitate to contact this office. Sincerely, John R.Houldsworth Senior Engineer Attachment(original affidavit) cc: Peggy Jarrell,Addressing 11111 Packet Page -271- 10/8/2013 8.A. Rata: 4264959 OR: 4430 PG: 0820 VOGEL LAW OFFICE RECORDED in the OFFICIAL RECORDS of COLLIER COUEfl, FL 3936 TAIIIAitI TR N III 02/24/2009 at 03:52P1f DWIGHT I. HOCK, CLHRI REC FEE 18.50 RULES FL 31103 COPIES 2.00 LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT AFFIDAVIT • NOW COMES Brigid D.Soldavini,as President of Naples Equestrian Challenge,Inc.,who being duly sworn, depose and say: 1. Naples Equestrian Challenge are the fee simple title holders to that property legally described as: Lot 21,Block I,Pine Ridge(Hereafter Lot"A") 2. Naples Equestrian Challenge are the fee simple title holders to that property legally described as: Lot 20,Block I,Pine Ridge(Hereafter Lot"B') 3. The parties desire to adjust a lot line and create two revised Lots,as depicted in the sketch and legal descriptions prepared by Bradley E.Stockham ,Florida Professional Land Surveyor#6390 attached hereto and made part hereof as Exhibit'1". 4. Naples Equestrian Challenge,as the owner(s)of said Lot A hereby consents to the lot line adjustment in accordance with Section 10.02.02 B.8,LDC. 5. Naples Equestrian Challenge,as the ow - 'd Lot B hereby consents to the lot line adjustment in accordance with Section 10.02.02 B.8, a R COty 6. Because the lot line adjus .e' result in two lots 'e ... equivalent in size and having the minimum required road frontage a d •r=age,the lot line adjustm-. me is the standards of,and conforms to,the requirements of Section +.02.s n . • .e Collier County L d D velopment Code. 7. The property describe• her:on is Zone. -. of 21 /- Lot 21 d meets the intent of the Land Development Code,as a men•ed. • 8. Furthermore, the lot I ne =u tme II of a =; he - _lop nt rights or permitted density or , intensity of use of the affects. I. • .4m �,t•> :•••.. unit..• h.. �r ting of new lots for resale or • development within the meani gf ection 10.02.02 B.8, •••7;C. 9. This Affidavit's being gi -- p uant to Section 10.0."B : • t6)'oilier County Land Development Code. 10. This Affidavit has been rev Wit • -.. . - . �.- At _ 1�• of the Development Services Department John - ••..Gs. •- ti ngineer of Collier County,Florida on the Lit day of f,l✓i . ,20d'– SIGNATURES OF OWNERS: Naples Equestrian Chy.. •e c. :r": d D:Soldavini,President STATE OF FLORIDA COLLIER COUNTY � " Th foregoing nstrument was acknowledged before me this J K 41-day of ! •ie-i 0 rtA4-(7-- 206 ti ,by ,c (Aftd,n'. - CL who have produced f`L bY`,J Lc-) t,c-4 c,.e v as identification and who did/did not take ah oath. Notary Public My Commission Expires: Commission No. 1) 93►2-f NOTARYFISLIC.STATEOFFLORIDA Print Name: C In 2.• , • Cinzia Bombard Commission#DD793121 -'` &pi= JUNE 19,2012 BONDED raRo ATUNIICBONDUWCO,INC. - Packet Page -272- 10/8/2013 8.A. N PR: 4430 ru; voci •••••• ,sd 4V 24 ad 1:2 1 Ir ate td : It - .- .j. • .f v ie , dill - - §° > 1 RI o E24 4° if" 114. EP; 4 II / i 1 '3.0 x °I Aix! !!! dt •gii il' . : 34! it i g A It m 5 1 1- 111 q 1 :!1 'ili ti14'.,•:! i:141Agg :Ail - :a ;`18 ri ". sp": ' Iri jib. ,.., :fg !MI -a rli ia aggN Fli X_E1 lag "---.; X Sig l' 1 ] r dill! Ali/1g 7 - - _ _ - ........, •_ •• • ac x+ru r,axe n:id acw --yula ov - ---- S i 1 •9Z•6II, M.ZZ.CS.IOS .LZ•9SZ .t0'19l 1 . i I N N 5 fe. iiiim i •R 11 1. o �r a 1 b - el b . _ � f z z '1„,:� b • B Z to ,S : c$ ...;-.. c0 ti i . Jr I • n ;41 ct-., 1 ,.. - kc o �M >e 13� . w 26i YN W1 zt- w s I o JCt.co PI O rL b' `\ o 0 N Y N 7 Sg 1 M h V Z to n N z M hA;_N tit O OO'SZ>• 3.00.00AOS 2 0 J J LI J - - G+�J0 u7R!.Of-j 3vPA 3.7011 -' - - - Z ' o N Za.�U Packet Page-273- - 10/8/2013 8.A. Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use • Petition CU-PL2011-0719 Neighborhood Information Meeting July 15, 2013, 5:30 p.m. Wayne Arnold, agent for the applicant opened the meeting at 5:35 p.m. and introduced himself and Sharon Umpenhour with Q. Grady Minor and Associates, P.A., Kim Minarich, Executive Director of Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC), Brian Dickerson, Attorney representing NEC and Michael Sawyer representing Collier County Growth Management. Six members from the public, as well as several employees of NEC and Board of Directors members of NEC were in attendance. A sign-in sheet was provided. Mr. Arnold began the information meeting by introducing the project and explaining where the project was in the Conditional Use process. Wayne then explained that the existing NEC facility had been previously approved through the Conditional Use process and the proposed expansion to include round riding arena, multi-purpose room and stables required a new Conditional Use. An aerial and site plan were displayed and the areas on the site plan were explained as to what would be where and how it would be utilized. Wayne discussed the existing and proposed relocation of the ingress/egress points in response to discussions with neighbors prior to the informational meeting. Kim Minarich 1111 took over the meeting and discussed the removal of an existing cottage to improve the ingress/egress point on Center Street making this the primary access to NEC. Kim explained that there could be an ingress/egress point on Ridge Drive but for emergency vehicle purposes only. Wayne asked Kim to please describe how the organization currently operates and what the proposed expansion would provide to the community and organization. Kim explained their mission statement and how the organization began and how the program has been utilized and expanded over the years. Kim also explained that NEC was an applicant for a HUD Grant and that there were requirements for the grant for the non- profit organization Kim explained how the different programs worked and why the need for the Conditional Use. Kim showed on the Site Plan what the existing and proposed buildings would be and how they would be utilized. The additional lot would be utilized for housing 4 additional horses, feed storage and a covered riding area and that the need for the additional lot is due to the increased attendance of the therapeutic riding and other equine assisted therapy programs. The main arena is at capacity and cannot accommodate the need for additional program times. One of the neighbors expressed their opposition to the expansion onto Lot 19 but wanted to clarify that they did not oppose the existing facility and its programs, or expanded programs on the 5±acres currently owned by NEC. Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use,Petition CU-PL2011-0719 Page 1 of 2 Packet Page-274- 10/8/2013 8.A. • Mr. Arnold concluded his presentation and asked for comments or questions from the meeting attendees. Generally, questions were asked on the following major topics, Mr. Arnold and Ms.Minarich responded to the questions generally as follows: 1. Buffers/landscaping The buffer would consist of plant materials per LDC requirements. Mr. Sawyer indicated the minimum buffer would be a 15 foot wide type B buffer along Ridge Drive which would include trees on 30 foot centers with a hedge. 2. Parking/traffic Ms. Minarich provided estimates of existing vehicle trips to the site based on the number of 30 minute riding sessions were provided daily and volunteers required for the program participants. Ms. Minarich indicated that the figures had been provided to Collier County based on a daily hourly estimate. The willingness to move the project access to Center Street was also reiterated. 3. Building size The proposed covered riding arena is a 75 foot diameter design with eave heights approximately 12 feet. The multi-purpose room is approximately • 3,000 square feet. The stable area will be a 6-stall design of which 4 stalls are for horses and 2 will be used for feed and tack. 4. Project timeframe Ms. Minarich indicated that the proposed new facilities would be constructed once finances were available and suggested this would hopefully be in a 2 to 3 year time frame. 5. Facility operations Ms. Minarich discussed in detail the grant application, which if awarded, would be used to acquire the subject property. Ms. Minarich also discussed NEC strategic planning and fundraising goals for the organization. Ms. Minarich explained the various riding programs offered at NEC and described how program needs have evolved to include a variety of equine related therapy. Mr. Arnold explained to the neighbors that they would be notified by mail of the hearing dates and that public hearing signs would also be posted on-site. Wayne then offered to provide any additional information if requested and to contact, Kim Minarich, Michael Sawyer or himself if anyone had further questions. The meeting was adjourned at approximately 6:40 p.m. Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use,Petition CU-PL2011-0719 Page 2 of 2 Packet Page -275- 10/8/2013 8.A. SIGN POSTING INSTRUCTIONS (Section 10.03.00,COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE(LDC) A zoning sign(s)must be posted by the petitioner or the petitioner's agent on the parcel for a minimum of fifteen(15)calendar days in advance of the first public hearing and said sign(s)must be maintained by the petitioner or the petitioner's agent through the Board of County Commissioners;Hearing. Below are general guidelines for signs,however these guidelines should not be construed to supercede any requirement of the LDC. For specific sign requirements, please refer to Section 10.03.00 of the LDC. 1. The sign(s) must be erected in full view of the public,not more than five (5)feet from the nearest street right-of-way or easement. 2. The signs)must be securely affixed by nails,staples,or other means to a wood frame or to a wood panel and then fastened securely to a post,or other structure. The sign may not be affixed to a tree or other foliage. 3. The petitioner or the petitioner's agent must maintain the sign(s)in place,and readable condition until the requested action has been heard and a final decision rendered. If the sign(s)is destroyed, lost,or rendered unreadable,the petitioner or the petitioner's agent must replace the sign(s NOTE:. AFTER THE SIGN HAS BEEN POSTED, THIS AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING NOTICE SHOULD BE RETURNED NO LATER THAN TEN (10) WORKING DAYS BEFORE THE FIRST HEARING DATE TO THE ASSIGNED PLANNER. AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING NOTICE STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER y� / ', BEFORE THE UNDERSIGNED AUTHORITY,PERSONALLY APPEARED -,t V\A t"t t t GCy c-�' I WHO ON OATH SAYS THAT HE/SHE HAS POSTED PROPER NOTICE.AS REQUIRED BY SECTION 10.03.00 OF THE • COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE ON THE PARCEL COVERED IN PETITION NUMBER -- PL2 tiaoo 6Z tq ibit ' ZOC, 9.161q,e__ tevkire SIGNATURE OF APPLICANT OR AGENT STREET OR P.O.BOX OPciele fr J 34 i D` NAME(TYPED OR PRINTED) CITY,STATE ZIP STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF COLLIER r The foregoing instrument was sworn to and subscribed before me this day of "f (,( , 20¢3 by personally to me or who produced as identification and who did/did not take an oath. Signature of Notary Public ,Q FPY `'8 MELISSA MAR i INEZ Notary Public-State of Ronda _ a fi` o-My Lamm.Expires Sep 27,201 C \ \t\ IY 1`0 Commission#EE 30073 Printed Name of Notary Public My Commission Expires: ' • (Stamp with serial number). C:1 Users'kminarich'AppDatattocaI\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\C165J1EU'AFFIDAVIT AND SIGN POSTING INSTRUCTIONS 5-2-05.doc Packet Page-276- „ ....._,„_-_,,,:;-.:r1.'-.,..,;:..;,--.1,1:_:'.71:- '-'7-"I't.,'-,;-,,I.: *„;_-'4'''.,„--...,,,,,,;tt,,,2",,::*:::"1:e. ,'?:,,,:k--;.:,;',,”:,';, . '.,'' .;,.4:-:,:-'1.;;;P-;;47: -:..:- :':- /2013 8.A, „0...,,a4' 0 10/8/2013 8.A. Joseph&Hon. Caroline Martino 179 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 July 25, 2013 Naples Equestrian Challenge Board of Directors do Mrs. Kim Minarich, Executive Director Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 Dear Kim: Thank you for hosting the Neighborhood Information Meeting of July 15th 2013. This letter is an attempt to document"what we heard" at the meeting and to clarify our position and thoughts regarding NEC's application for the pending Conditional Use permit. One of the primary reasons for this letter is to provide NEC the opportunity to clarify any items that we may have misheard or misunderstood so that all interested parties are working with the same data points.Apologies in advance if some of the letter is a bit stilted but my note taking is not as proficient as it used to be as I hopefully approach retirement age! Meeting introductory remarks (Wayne Arnold) 206 Ridge Drive CU permit approved in 2000. 2013 Plans call for: 194 Ridge Drive-CU so NEC can use sensory riding trail already in place. Looking to locate increase in overall parking on 194 Ridge Drive. 182 Ridge Drive—CU and covered riding round pen(75' diameter,with 5' high boarded sides and roof 12' at eaves),3.000 sa. ft.(!!) `multi-purpose' training room& 6 stall stable(4 horses, 1 tack& 1 feed room)&paddocks on 182 Ridge Drive. No PA system in round pen;will have lights, but"low profile" (not as high as current arena). Following completed so far: filed application for CU on 194 Ridge Drive(Lot 20)& 182 Ridge Drive (Lot 19), received initial comment letter from Collier County, sent sufficiency letter back addressing minor comments at this point. Process :Neighborhood Information Meeting(completed July 15th). : Planning Commission hearing(est. September) : Board of County Commissioner's hearing(est. early October). Packet Page -278- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25, 2013 Page 2 N.B. The initial draft rendering we were using as a baseline had already changed by the date of the NIM. Pending Action Item: We are formally requesting a copy of the most recent version of the NEC Master Plan drawings, and to be kept abreast of any changes to within 1 work week of any changes. NEC's need: NEC has grown the program from just therapeutic riding,to also include equine facilitated learning& equine facilitated psychotherapy. At the current time, still have `horse power' (horse capacity), but have maxed out scheduling time under the current arena. Over the past 18 months NEC has grown from 170 therapeutic riding participants to 450 therapeutic riding,EFPs and EFLs participants served per year. In order to add programs,need a second, smaller, facility to run concurrent programming and would like to add `interactive vaulting' (another PATH approved equine therapy, need round pen for that)—not resource intensive - 1 horse for 5 students(therapeutic riding is 1 horse for 1 student). There will be a training room for some volunteer training, summer camp, and also be used for PATH instructor training as a destination(income source). Additional reason for expansion beyond the riding facility is protect turn out space which is at maximum capacity by NEC's current formula. NEC's current growth projection is that the program will serve an additional 200 participants for an estimated end target audience of approximately 650 to 700 clients a year. Pending Action Item: We are formally requesting a copy of NEC's current Strategic Plan. Per Kim, this was adopted by NEC's Board of Directors in January 2013. Funding: NEC submitted grant request for County Development Block Grant(CDBG). Essentially HUD Funds—Federal -> State->dispersed to Counties. This funding cycle,NEC was advised that "reprogrammable dollars"were available but with a very short application cycle time. NEC would qualify as their growth is intended to serve a larger target audience and that is the link to funding of the property purchase. NEC submitted application to purchase 182 Ridge Drive,received conditional approval, spoke to Mr.DeShetler(current owner), appraisal completed($520,000); HUD will fund appraised value only. Differences between appraised value &purchase price—donors have already agreed to loan NEC the money. Have contract now with Mr. DeShetler subject to conditional use permit approval and funding secured through CGBD. Packet Page-279- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25, 2013 Page 3 CGBD funding will be subject to a successful approval process anticipated to be finalized in the County Commissioners (October)review of application&all qualifications. If no CGBD funding then NEC will not pursue the purchase of 182 Ridge Drive.NEC has to complete all contingencies (CU approval, grant approval etc.)and close on property by Oct 30, 2013. If CGBD funding granted,NEC will be audited by local office of HUD each year(20 year audit trail)to make sure they meet HUD requirement that 51%of all program participants are income qualified based on HUD recommendations. More than 51%of NEC participants do qualify to HUD's range. HUD's income requirements are for all program participants and not just those that would utilize facilities at 182 Ridge Drive. CGBD grant application is public information filed with County's Housing Department(Housing&Veterans' Affairs division). Action Item Pending: At meeting on July 15th 2013,Joseph requested and Kim agreed to provide him a copy of CGDB/HUD grant application. Estimated costs and progress: NEC has agreed a price for 182 Ridge Drive with the current owner Mr. DeShetler (total not stated in meeting)but has not yet estimated cost of"verticals"(buildings), infrastructure and all other capital expense related requirements. If NEC's purchase of 182 Ridge Drive is successful, NEC will then go through a more detailed budgeting exercise. The intent is to start a Capital Campaign to fund the project. The additional increase to the ongoing operating budget was not discussed. Training center& infrastructure costs to be determined. NEC has a lot of things they'd like to do with A/V in the training room but may not be able to do it at the onset e.g. "may not be able to have acoustical walls". At this point the budget is in very preliminary planning stages. After County approves a Conditional Use permit, construction must commence within 5 years (used to be 3 years) 5 years allows for permitting hurdles. Per Kim, if all went perfectly: complete purchase end October, launch Capital Campaign early 2014(may take 1.5 years), possibly start e.g. round pen before fully funded. Estimate 3-3.5 years to completion. The increased target audience to be served by NEC's expansion plan cannot be served until certain parts of the construction are complete. Additional 6 stalls,round pen etc. It was stated that there is nowhere else in Collier County the anticipated new clients can get assistance; so it could be between 18 to 40 months before any service to additional participants could be rendered. Our understanding is that NEC Board Member, Dr. Virgina Condello owns a boarding stable of some repute. It is also our understanding that Dr. Condello is a board certified psychiatrist and, at NEC, has provided equine facilitated psychotherapy for veterans or other clients diagnosed with PTSD or similar challenges. This client segment is a significant part of the audience NEC is reaching out to work with in their growth program -and an admirable cause of which we are very supportive. Packet Page-280- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25,2013 Page 4 When queried why satellite programs could not be a part of NEC (conduct these therapeutic service on another property)we were informed that NEC had completed assessments/surveys to determine where current&potential riders/participants are located in Collier County. Not clarified whether satellite programs would be a viable option. Action Item Pending: At meeting on July 15th 2013,Joseph requested and Brian Dickerson (Board Member) agreed to provide a copy of the satellite assessment noted above. Our position: As already stated,we are very supportive of NEC activities and have been for the past 15 years. As a family the Martino's have given donations of time, materials and cash of circa$1 million. In addition, Caroline was instrumental in fundraising efforts which helped raise millions of dollars for NEC during her 10 year tenure as a volunteer with combined roles of President& Executive Director. With this in mind,the following will outline our thoughts on best to worst case scenarios as it relates to NEC's growth and expansion plans: Best Case: NEC stays within the current 5 acres and redesigns the complete landscape, building etc.to have an optimal operating program that blends in with the Pine Ridge neighborhood. NEC makes a business case for all the CU exceptions it needs to add additional horses, stabling etc. as well as constraining some of the"perfect ratios"of land to horse etc. it currently enjoys. Our estimation(personal and not substantiated) is that NEC will have to make a$2 million plus capital investment to realize the growth plans as currently expressed. We firmly believe that redesigning/re-optimizing the existing space (in collaboration with Pine Ridge Residents)will be the most fruitful and supported outcome for NEC, its current and future clients as well as sustaining a welcomed and integral role in the Pine Ridge Community. We also believe (personal opinion)that this re-optimization of the current 5 acres can be accomplished for far less money than is estimated(personal opinion)to complete the project as currently envisioned. Next best case:NEC receives approval to acquire the property at 182 Ridge Drive and redesigns the current plans for the existing property and proposed acquisition to achieve the envisioned growth, but making the 182 Ridge Drive just paddocks with no permanent structures. Obviously, this is a better `option 2' for the Martino's and the Kalb's than it would be for the Wesnofske's. However, for all three families, and for other Pine Ridge residents, the anticipated and also the exponential future increase in traffic in and out of Pine Ridge Estates will continue to be an obstacle to us `getting behind' this option. Worst case:NEC receives approval for its currently envisioned expansion plans. Packet Page -281- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25,2013 Page 5 Detailed concerns and objections: Currently NEC acts as a landlord for 2 buildings;208 Ridge Drive and 194 Ridge Drive collecting approximately $2K per month, equaling $24K per annum (estimated not substantiated). The cost to service the leases (i.e.property taxes, general maintenance,repairs etc) does not seem to add much"profit"as a contribution to operational expenses. It does however seem to add a certain additional burden on staff time to properly service the tenancies. The square footage occupied by these 2 buildings is approximately: 3,000 sq. ft.total which could be dedicated to NEC's expansion program instead of recreating the same footprint on an additional piece of property. The property tax revenue generated for the county by the lease of these two building is approximately$2.1K per annum. If there were no tenants,NEC could claim 100%property tax exemption on both properties. Opinion—back to best case: it does not appear(on the surface)that leasing the buildings (208 Ridge Drive and 194 Ridge Drive), servicing them and paying taxes serves to make any meaningful contribution to annual operating expenses. Topically, it would seem that eliminating these two buildings and adding the additional acreage to enhance the current 5 acre design could be a more meaningful solution without the need for further land acquisition in order to achieve reasonable additional growth of the program and meet NEC's stated objectives. Access: The most recent plan (amended from the original which we were presented with prior to the meeting) calls for: • Maintaining the driveway from Ridge Drive into the house/office at 206 Ridge Drive • Eliminate the driveway from Ridge Drive into the house at 194 Ridge Drive • No driveway from Ridge Drive into 182 Ridge Drive • Elimination of the major ingress/egress entrance being used through the"shell rock driveway"at 194 Ridge Drive. This assumes the Guest House(208 Ridge Drive) is demolished and the Center Street access (2 way traffic)will be implemented as approved in the CU permit of 2000. The use of the shell rock driveway for the past few years has been a violation of the current approved Conditional Use permit. However,EMS requires secondary ingress/egress, so the shell rock driveway at 194 Ridge Drive will remain, but with a solid gate incorporated into the boundary ficus hedge. We agree and support that this shell rock driveway be abandoned as the "informal"major ingress/egress, but maintained and approved as an emergency ingress/egress and provide ad hoc access for major events or suppliers with major equipment needs. Although NEC has verbally agreed that the access will be changed back to Center Street,there was no committed time frame as to when compliance with the existing CU will happen,or if the change is independent of the success of the pending CU application. This correction/change was to be discussed at the Board Meeting Tuesday,July 16th. Packet Page -282- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25, 2013 Page 6 Action Item Pending: Following the NEC Board Meeting on July 16th,we are formally requesting to be advised of the plan and proposed timeline for access to be changed back to Center Street. Landscaping/buffer: Mark Sawyer, Senior Planner, Collier County Department of Zoning and Land Development Review advised the closest code that would apply for NEC as a `community facility' would be for a`B"buffer—a series of trees and 5'hedge,the buffer required to be 15' wide, and normally a variety of plantings through the area. Grass and paddocks would"count"as a variety in the buffer zone. NEC is planning a`nice, thick ficus hedge' along fence line on 206, 194 and 182, and on Center Street too. (Our opinion) The current plantings, especially the existing ficus hedge, seem unlikely to ever develop as envisioned. Without adequate maintenance, irrigation and fertilizer this buffer screening can never hope to be adequate. Parking: We have significant concerns about parking. Our"best case"solution would be that all parking be moved to the Goodlette Frank Road side of property. Appreciating that this solution is not a preferred one by NEC,we suggest that parking planned around the house at 194 Ridge Drive is switched with paddocks around the main house/office at 206 Ridge Drive. It was noted that the structure(house) at 194 Ridge Drive is now, and for the future, designated as a residence/office building,and that any removal of same would not automatically provide for additional parking without seeking a separate CU permit. Parking space to horse ratio: This is a controversial topic and we will attempt to illustrate our concerns with the best data available. Action Item Request Pending: If NEC has better documented data on parking space to horse ratios,we request that they share this written information so that we can review and adjust our suppositions. Parking Space (`PS')to Horse Ratio: As exists today: Parking spaces 32 -#of Horses 10 PS->Horse Ratio 3.20 Prior to NIM: Parking spaces 73-#of Horses 14 PS->Horse Ratio 5.21 Overall a 128%increase in Parking Spaces *NIM Revision: Parking spaces 45,but this total excludes handicapped parking. * We have an objection to increased parking on a ratio basis. The increased growth and new target clients of NEC's expansion are stated to be less impactful to the organization so the Parking Space ->Horse ratio should reduce not increase. Packet Page -283- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25, 2013 Page 7 NEC Assumptions: Parking spaces 52—45 standard and 7 handicapped parking spaces (handicapped parking spaces not included in ratio which would make the ratio 3.72). This was not clear in the meeting so apologies if we misheard the intent. **Our Proposed ratio: Parking spaces 40-#of Horses 14 PS->Horse Ratio 2.80 ** Includes all handicapped spaces and does not allow for further expansion of additional parking should the office/residence structure currently on 194 Ridge Drive be demolished at some future point in time. All above assumptions on parking include full time staff, clients,volunteers,vendors etc. As an illustration,half of the Mission Square plaza(from Dunkin' Donuts to Noodles Restaurant) supports five (5)commercial businesses that generate individual income as well as tax revenue for the county and has only 100 parking spaces to service commercial client needs (including 2 food service establishments!) Traffic: Concern over increase in traffic in general: special concern about waiting to get out onto Goodlette Frank Road either way, but most especially turning North onto Goodlette Frank Road, and additional traffic in Pine Ridge Estates residential neighborhood. At the meeting,Kim informed us of the following data: A. Collier County looks at trips (in&out equal 2 trips) during `peak times'. B. NEC `peak times' are in line with Collier County `peak times'. Collier County is e.g.4-6pm, and NEC is `after school'.For NEC, total of around 30 cars during `peak times' on Monday, Wednesday and Thursday afternoons, so approx. 60 trips during this time including volunteers &staff. During day, some EFL&EFP 6 or 8 participants"so we don't have a whole lot of traffic out of here during the day time". Saturday traffic not mentioned. C. County measures trips on Goodlette Frank Road, and this is considered `low traffic generator'. Per Wayne, so far the County doesn't project a problem. *Our estimates based on NEC's schedule posted on the web site for 3 NEC peak times/days : Monday afternoon between 3:30-6:45pm —80 trips Thursday afternoon between 4:15-7:OOpm — 72 trips Saturday between 7:30am &12:30pm —100 trips *Calculated results and experiential data, does not reflect complete schedule and summer camp programs, new EFL, EFP, normal staff and vendor traffic, or other current and anticipated therapeutic programs. Packet Page -284- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25,2013 Page 8 We would be very supportive of data based traffic information from the County but on an "actuals" based property level. We would welcome a traffic tube counter program over an averaged time period that can be extrapolated to represent actual annual traffic patterns that include both high and low seasons. Unfortunately due the constrained time frames of the current NEC grant application process,and this being low season, such a program run at present(say now until October 30th)would not yield relevant results. Abstractions from Goodlette Frank Road traffic patterns are not relevant unless a traffic correlation to local streets is presented and proven. Concern: What are the projected traffic implications once NEC is running concurrent programs in the arena and round pen on the proposed additional property? (Our opinion) Saturday morning is peak time'in any residential neighborhood, and current 100 +/-additional trips presents a substantial additional `burden'on NEC's neighbors—the residents of Pine Ridge. Pine Ridge has only 2 access points on the East boundary of the neighborhood: ingress/egress on Carica Road North(south-only egress on to Goodlette Frank Road)and ingress &egress on Center Street(north&south on to Goodlette Frank Road). The North/South ingress/egress on Center Street does not have a traffic light. Increased volume of traffic would be the data point to install a traffic light—and Pine Ridge residents have historically been vocal in their opposition to installing a traffic light at this intersection. NEC participants: The following questions were posed with the following responses: Resident in Pine Ridge with some NEC affiliation as a: Board Members= 1 Staff=unknown/unanswered? Volunteers=unknown/unanswered? Clients=unknown/unanswered? Catastrophic circumstances: What would happen to the properties should NEC declare bankruptcy or cease to be able to operate as currently structured? The opinion proffered by NEC was that a bankruptcy judge would dispose of the debts and properties as per the then-current rule of law subject to zoning restrictions. (Assumption/Implication-Properties would still have Conditional Use for therapeutic riding and could be assumed by another non-profit or for-profit operator for therapeutic riding only, or would revert to Residential Agricultural use). Financial Observations: The Martino's purport that there are future financial impacts to themselves personally,to other families in the immediate vicinity,as well as an overall negative "halo effect" impact to the Pine Ridge Estates neighborhood property values based on NEC's current expansion plans. Wayne Arnold commented that elected officials understand the need for non-profits in the County and try and balance the charitable need served and the property tax revenue loss to the County. Packet Page-285- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25, 2013 Page 9 Market Values &Tax Implications: Following is an illustration of the current Collier County assessed taxable market value for residences including and immediately surrounding NEC properties, compiled by the Martino's from information provided on the Collier County Property Appraiser's website. Property Address Owner Acreage Market Value Taxable Value 2012 Taxes Homestead 221 Center Street Harr 1.61 646,695 596,659 7,103.18 Y 209 Ridge Drive Pappenfuss 3.32 4,072,783 4,022,783 46,917.22 Y 193 Ridge Drive Wesnofske 1.53 499,520 449,520 5,355.00 Y 179 Ridge Drive Martino 1.61 678,298 628,298 7,454.66 Y 215 Caribbean Road Kalb 1.6 2,014,789 1,964,789 23,075.18 Y 198 Caribbean Road Fletcher/MacMaster 1.99 710,952 334,742 4,320.76 Y Sub Total 94,226.00 235 Center Street Duff/Pine Ridge Farm 2.8 916,800 550,887 6,459.90 Ag. 206 Ridge Drive Naples Equestrian Challenge 2.48 858,137 0 333.1 N 194 Ridge Drive Naples Equestrian Challenge 2.18 587,621 146,905 1,800.37 N 182 Ridge Drive DeshetlerTrust 2.15 513,143 513,143 5,944.83 N 170 Ridge Drive Ramsden/Madden 2.12 608,651 558,651 6,513.51 Y 158 Ridge Drive Herter 2.08 603,706 284,834 3,612.73 Y 146 Ridge Drive Cox 2.06 1,535,472 1,485,472 16,996.56 Y Sub Total 41,661.00 Grand Total 135,887.00 As illustrated above,once NEC ceases to be a landlord and they secure 100%tax exemption on their property,the County tax reduction at this point is only $2,100 per annum and with the acquisition of 182 Ridge Drive a further$6,000 reduction for a total of approximately$8,100. Even extrapolating this to 20 years $160,000 revenue loss for the County does not seem unreasonable. As previously stated,we believe that NEC should cease being landlords and re-optimize the acreage they currently operate on, and not seek additional land acquisition in Pine Ridge. Our concern is not the property tax revenue loss, but rather how the market value of properties are affected,pointing to a more dramatic issue for certain families and with a `knock-on' effect for the County also. Collier County Market Value Property Address Owner Acreage 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 221 Center Street Harr 1.61 769,766 834,607 1,387,900 1446,160 968,099 791,780 696,873 647,633 646,695 209 Ridge Drive Pappenfuss 3.32 558,031 1,333,011 6,238,020 6,623,877 5,446,903 4,581,023 4,058,022 4,107,732 4,072,783 193 Ridge Drive Wesnofske 1.53 572778 662,717 1447,614 1,195,240 756,656 614,234 545420 499,520 499,520 179 Ridge Drive Martino . 1.61 806,934 875,870 1,439,117 1,498,377 1,011,579 829,508 728,887 679,427 678,298 215 Caribbean Road Kalb 1.60 614,152 659,943 1,153,622 1,040,000 600,000 480,000 432,000 2,014,789 2,014,789 198 Caribbean Road Fletcher/MacMaster 1.99 859,798 929,309 1,596,958 1,663,315 1,079,522 872,621 771,886 711,262 710,952 235CenterStreet Duff/Pine Ridge Farm 2.8 851,337 892,908 1,272,179 1,365,983 1,373,648 1,127,051 992493 918,947 916,800 206 Ridge Drive Naples Equestrian Chall. 2.48 574,442 596,978 876,138 1,251,489 1210,511 989,392 872,009 859,493 858,137 194 Ridge Drive Naples Equestrian Chall• 2.18 524,001 537,1.22 773,895 835,814 821,478 660,624 597,511 587,701 587,621 182 Ridge Drive DeshetlerTrust 2.15 444,127 448,200 674,425 732,465 727,716 584,175 523,635 513,552 513,143 170 Ridge Drive Ramsden/Madden 2.12 528,834 545,810 813,163 878,216 860,172 695,187 618,260 608,685 608,651 158 Ridge Drive Herter 2.08 524,949 542,361 807,188 871,523 852,895 689,623 613,066 603,706 603,706 146 Ridge Drive Cox 2.06 1,552,997 1,699,872 2,085,604 2196,251 2,043,355 1,703,285 1,568,302 1,547,252 1,535,472 • Packet Page -286- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25, 2013 Page 10 The line items highlighted in the table above show the change in Collier County Market Value assessments for two properties in the immediate vicinity of Naples Equestrian Challenge's current property. The property at 209 Ridge Drive was purchased in 2004,built on in 2005 and the contiguous lot was purchased and combined into one address for a total of 3.32 acres. Over a 12 month time period(2005 to 2006),the market value of the combined properties encompassing 209 Ridge Drive increased from $1,333,011 to $6,238,020. As another illustration,the Collier County assessed market value of 215 Caribbean Road increased from $432,000 in 2010 to $2,014,789 in 2011 after the Kalb family had completed construction of their new home. We expect to be able to provide further examples of our premise that a `new build' on an existing Pine Ridge lot can significantly enhance the market value of not only the actual lot,but the properties in the surrounding area. This affects not only the property owners themselves, but also ultimately Collier County's `bottom line' for taxable value. Summary Opinion: Best case—NEC grows program with its current acreage and redesigns a Master Plan to accommodate same and does not expand by purchasing any additional land in Pine Ridge. Main ingress/egress is moved back to Center Street before the end of 2013. Appropriate landscaping that meets and is planted and maintained to best or better than County standards,with special regard to immediate neighbors and their view. Ratio of Parking Spaces to horses reduced to 2.80 including all handicapped spaces,maximum parking spaces of 40. Reduce scope of planned training building from 3,000 sq. ft.to 1,800 sq. ft. No additional Public Address systems (arena already has PA system installed); sound and lighting respectful of the neighbors' right to peaceful enjoyment of their homes and neighborhood. Worst case-NEC receives approval for its currently envisioned expansion plans. Summary of Pending Action Items and/or Requests: Can we have the items requested by 31 July, if not please advise a date. Copies by email should be fine. • 1. Pending Action Item: We are formally requesting a copy the most recent version of the NEC Master Plan drawings and to be kept abreast of any changes to within 1 work week of any changes. 2. Pending Action Item: We are formally requesting a copy of NEC's current Strategic Plan. Per Kim,this was adopted by NEC's Board of Directors in January 2013. Packet Page -287- 10/8/2013 8.A. July 25,2013 Page 11 3. Action Item Pending: At the meeting on July 15th 2013,Joseph requested and Kim agreed to provide him a copy of CGDB/HUD grant application. 4. Action Item Pending: At the meeting on July 15th 2013,Joseph requested and Brian Dickerson (Board Member) agreed to provide a copy of the satellite assessment noted above. 5. Action Item Pending: Following the NEC Board Meeting on July 16th,we are formally requesting to be advised of the plan and proposed timeline for access to be changed back to Center Street. 6. Action Item Request Pending: If NEC has better documented data on parking space to horse ratios,we request that they share this written information so that we can review and adjust our suppositions. Sincerely, Joseph &Hon. Caroline Martino 4 ` t r"J cc: Michael Sawyer,ASLA,APA Senior Planner Collier County Department of Zoning and Land Development Review 2800 North Horseshoe Drive,Naples,FL 34104 Michael Sawveracolliergov.net D. Wayne Arnold, AICP Q. Grady Minor and Associates,P.A. warno ld@grad vminor.com Kalb family, 215 Caribbean Road Wesnofske family, 193 Ridge Drive Pine Ridge Civic Association Packet Page -288- 10/8/2013 8.A. Joseph&Hon. Caroline Martino g • 179 Ridge Drive a4 ..°, Naples,FL 34108 July 31,2013 Naples Equestrian Challenge Board of Directors c/o Mrs. Kim Minarich, Executive Director Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. 206 Ridge Drive Naples, FL 34108 Dear Kim, Thank you very much for your prompt response to the various requests and queries posed after the NIM of July 15th and our feedback letter of July 25`h. It is apparent that gaining transparency and a normalization of information and data is a difficult and tedious process. We do appreciate yours and NEC's most recent efforts to gain transparency on a contentious issue so all parties can be confident of the data to support their individual yet opposed opinions. I am outlining a status of items requested and the current status as I understand it. I would appreciate your review and updated status by return email of either a target date when open requests can be fulfilled, or if the request will not be fulfilled for some reason. I am also including responses to questions in the JULY 25m response document that were embedded but not called out which NEC responded to.. 1. Pending Action Item: We are formally requesting a copy the most recent version of the NEC Master Plan drawings and to be kept abreast of any changes to within 1 work week of any changes. Current Status—July 30, 2013—Satisfied; received most current Site Plan(rev3)-Parking Revision. Attached Site Plan (rev3)-Parking Revisi 2. Pending Action Item: We are formally requesting a copy of NEC's current Strategic Plan. Per Kim, this was adopted by NEC's Board of Directors in January 2013. Open Request—Status TBA 3. Action Item Pending: At the meeting on July 15th 2013,Joseph requested and Kim agreed to provide him a copy of CGDB /HUD grant application. Current Status—July 30, 2013 - Satisfied; received application and related attachments /exhibits as noted in application. 4. Action Item Pending: At the meeting on July 15th 2013,Joseph requested and Brian Dickerson (Board Member) agreed to provide a copy of the satellite assessment noted above. Open Request—Status TBA Packet Page -289- 10/8/2013 8.A. 5. Action Item Pending: Following the NEC Board Meeting on July 16th,we are formally requesting to be advised of the plan and proposed timeline for access to be changed back to Center Street. Open Request—Status TBA 6. Action Item Request Pending: If NEC has better documented data on parking space to horse ratios, we request that they share this written information so that we can review and adjust our suppositions. Current Status—July 30,2013—Satisfied; received most current Site Plan(rev3)-Parking Revision and confirmation of intended parking spaces. Total 52 NEC Horse to Attached Parking Ratio 30 jul I wanted to respond to your question posed on page 8 "NEC Participants"of your letter reference below. NEC currently has the following associations/affiliations with 66 residents in Pine Ridge: Board Members = 1 Staff= 0 Volunteers= 10 Donors= 50 Participants = 1 Summer Horsemanship Camper=4 Current Status—July 30,2013—Satisfied; received above response, no definitive relational/correlated data. Attached Extrapolation NEC Resdiential Affiliations.pdf With thanks in advance for your continued co-operation. Kind regards, Joseph Martino Packet Page -290- 10/8/2013 8.A. cC LU W LU W LU O = Q Q Q Q Q m Z at a lt� d cc as .• N. 0 M1• M1. M1• M1. I— M1. i- = M1• = 7 (6 O N s o M 'O L O m w i N• CC C = O O d N L- 'p OA O LiJ = i N Z LL C N DD CC CE d = N .--I O O� .-1 e7 N N N CC Vl O y.. 11 W z CJ a n to i II N In = u ry L 2 ° a N 0. v u c o ;u E `m = L E ra 0 m V) > 0 a V) Packet Page-291- 10/8/2013 8.A. U ot = c 0 0 .. 0 0 0 Y 01 e-1 1.0 M co N co C ■i' a-4 UCu • Lo U S L N CO G) -0 U N lD U) LO lA C 113 C M D it ( O. N O ty b M I� tv U (.0 01 N (p C O. O O .-I ---I 0 (.0 • N N N to co O C M I1') M cf N (▪C C a) N O C M N M Ln LD 0 coG▪) U a m N N O C CI d- by 0 --I r-I ei e-I r-I c S co 0. M M +�. O m O M (b Ni e 4 N r-I p ^ 0 N O U (N N U L 0 \ N \ > N > N C) G) C C O (6 ns Cl. a a) c▪ rs °: 0- ✓ y .0 v) in U .a° � > -C z °' CO a) z Packet Page -292- 10/8/2013 8.A. RE Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th a From: Joseph Martino [josephvmartino @comcast.net] Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 12:41 AM To: 'Kim Minarich' Cc: SawyerMichael ; 'Wayne Arnold AICP' ; 'Alison Kalb' ; kevkalb @aol .com; 'Elaine & vince Wesnofske' ; 'Allan Jones' ; 'Caroline Martino' Subject: RE: Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th Attachments: NEC NIM Status jul 30 2013 b.doc; NEC Horse to Parking Ratio 30 jul 2013.pdf; NEC Resdiential Affiliations.pdf; Site Plan (rev3)-Parking Revision.pdf Dear Kim, Please see attached file. Hopefully the formats will be compatible, if not please advise and I will use best efforts to ensure a compatible format for ongoing information exchange. I have attached the referenced embedded .pdfs that are in the word doc as separate files in case they will not open from within the word doc. Kind regards, Joseph Martino original message From: Kim Minarich [mailto:kminarich @naplesequestrianchallenge.org] Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 5:00 PM To: Joseph Martino Cc: michaelsawyer @colliergov.net; 'Wayne Arnold AICP' ; 'Alison Kalb' ; kevkalb @aol .com; 'Elaine & vince Wesnofske' ; 'Allan Jones' ; 'Caroline Martino' Subject: RE: Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th Hello Joseph & Caroline, RE: NEC's CDBG Grant Application Attachments The following "Resumes, Pay Scales and Job Descriptions of all NEC employees are attached for your review. This email and its attachments completes the forward of all CDBG Grant Application attachments as requested. If you should have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Best regards, Kim Minarich Executive Director Page 1 Packet Page-293- 10/8/2013 8.A. Re Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th From: Kim Minarich [kminarich @naplesequestrianchal1enge.org] Sent: Wednesday, July 31, 2013 6:28 AM To: Joseph Martino Cc: SawyerMichael ; Wayne Arnold AICP; Alison Kalb; kevkalb @aol .com; Elaine & Vince wesnofske; Allan Jones; Caroline Martino Subject: Re: Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th Hello Joseph, I am able to read all files. we are set up to read word and Excel docs as all as PDFs. Thank you, Kim sent from my iPad On Jul 31, 2013, at 12:40 AM, "Joseph Martino" <josephvmartino @comcast.net> wrote: > Dear Kim, >• Please see attached file. Hopefully the formats will be compatible, > if not please advise and i will use best efforts to ensure a > compatible format for ongoing information exchange. I have attached > the referenced embedded .pdfs that are in the word doc as separate > files in case they will not open from within the word doc. >• Kind regards, >• Joseph Martino original Message > From: Kim Minarich [mailto:kminarich @naplesequestrianchallenge.org] > Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2013 5:00 PM > To: Joseph Martino > Cc: michaelsawyer @colliergov.net; 'Wayne Arnold AICP' ; 'Alison Kalb' ; > kevkalb @aol .com; 'Elaine & Vince wesnofske' ; 'Allan Jones' ; 'Caroline > Martino' > Subject: RE: Naples Equestrian challenge NIM July 15th >• Hello Joseph & Caroline, >• RE: NEC's CDBG Grant Application Attachments >• The following "Resumes, Pay scales and Job Descriptions of all NEC > employees are attached for your review. > This email and its attachments completes the forward of all CDBG Grant > Application attachments as requested. >• If you should have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. >• Best regards, > Kim Minarich > Executive Director > <NEC NIM Status jul 30 2013 b.doc> > <NEC Horse to Parking Ratio 30 jul 2013.pdf> <NEC Resdiential > Affiliations.pdf> <Site Plan (rev3)-Parking Revision.pdf> Page 1 Packet Page-294- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Kim Minarich [kminarich @naplesequestrianchallenge.org] Sent: Wednesday,August 14, 2013 9:08 AM To: Caroline Martino Cc: SawyerMichael; Joseph Martino;Wayne Arnold AICP;Alison Kalb; kevkalb @aol.com Kalb; Elaine&Vince Wesnofske; Allan Jones Subject: RE: Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th Follow Up Flag: Follow up Due By: Wednesday,August 21, 2013 5:00 PM Flag Status: Flagged Dear Joseph& Caroline, Again,thank you for your time and interest in NEC's current Conditional Use Application. However,the only relevant issues to address at this time are those germane to CU permit review and approval process. To that end,NEC has provided you with various documents/data you have requested;those that are public record and some that are not. More importantly,NEC has provided these documents directly to you as a convenience, saving you the time and effort necessary to file a public record request with the county. You will receive notification directly from the county regarding the Collier County Planning Commission meeting date as well as the Board of County Commission meeting date at which NEC's CU Application will be reviewed and voted upon. Best regards, Kim Minarich Executive Director NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 T: 239.596.2988 F: 239.514.2908 w new.NaplesEquestrianChallenge.onz Mark your calendars now for NEC's 8th Annual Bootstrap Boogie Barn Dance to be held Saturday, November 9, 2013. Please click on the link below to learn more about the event, event sponsorships and buy your tickets! http://www.naplesequestrianchal.lenge.org/news-events/2013-boot-strap-boogie-barn-dance/ Confidentiality Notice:This E-mail message,including any attachment,is for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review,use,disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient,please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message. 1 Packet Page-295- 10/8/2013 8.A. From: Caroline Martino [mailto:carolinemartino @comcast.net] Sent: Wednesday, August 14, 2013 6:43 AM To: Kim Minarich Cc: michaelsawyer @colliergov.net; Joseph Martino; Wayne Arnold AICP; Alison Kalb; kevkalb©aol.com Kalb; Elaine& Vince Wesnofske; Allan Jones Subject: Re: Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th Kim, I am following up on the items requested during the NIM of July 15. Can you provide a date as too when I can expect to receive the 4 remaining open items? It would be most beneficial to receive these items soon so they can be reviewed prior to the PRCA meeting of August 27th. All parties having the same data will make for a more transparent and efficient communications process. Thanking you in advance. 1. COMPLETE: We are formally requesting a copy the most recent version of the NEC Master Plan drawings and to be kept abreast of any changes to within 1 work week of any changes. 2. OPEN: Pending Action Item: We are formally requesting a copy of NEC's current Strategic Plan. Per Kim, this was adopted by NEC's Board of Directors in January 2013. 3. COMPLETE: At the meeting on July 15th 2013, Joseph requested and Kim agreed to provide him a copy of CGDB /HUD grant application. 4. OPEN: Action Item Pending: At the meeting on July 15°1 2013, Joseph requested and Brian Dickerson (Board Member) agreed to provide a copy of the satellite assessment noted above. 5. OPEN: Action Item Pending: Following the NEC Board Meeting on July 16th,we are formally requesting to be advised of the plan and proposed timeline for access to be changed back to Center Street. 6. OPEN: Action Item Request Pending: If NEC has better documented data on parking space to horse ratios, we request that they share this written information so that we can review and adjust our suppositions. Krgds, Joseph Martino On Jul 27, 2013, at 10:33 PM, Joseph Martino <josephvmartino@comcast.net>wrote: Dear Kim, Thank you for so quickly fulfilling 2 of the 6 requested items in our letter of July 25th. (Received July 25th-copy of HUD Grant application and the revised Site Plan) The attachments referenced in the HUD grant were not included in the file you forwarded. To insure that there is transparency and we are all working with the same data can you also send the attachments so we can review the 2 Packet Page-296- 10/8/2013 8.A. complete application. Looking forward to receiving this and actions to the other remaining 4 requests. I made some observations and comments on the attached site plan regarding parking and recalculated all the various parking related ratios. So as to be working with the same data points as NEC can you review the following numbers and confirm or correct as appropriate? Parking Space to Horse Ratio Horses PS Ratio Total Parking % Increase Standard Spaces HC Spaces SS to HC Parking Ratio Current Source Date 10 32 3.20 27 5 19% 1st Site Plan 3 Packet Page-297- 10/8/2013 8.A. Rev 1 7/2013 14 73 5.21 128% 66 7 11% NIM Verbal Plan 7/15/2013 14 52 3.71 63% 45 7 16% Revised Site Plan Rev 2 7/2013 14 63 4.50 97% 56 7 4 Packet Page -298- 10/8/2013 8.A. 13% Neighbor Expression 7/15/2013 14 40 2.86 25% 35 5 14% Thank you in advance for your prompt response. Joseph Martino From: Caroline Martino [mailto:carolinemartino @comcast.net] Sent: Thursday, July 25, 2013 3:12 PM To: Kim Boyd Minarich APR Cc:michaelsawyer@colliergov.net; Wayne Arnold AICP;Alison Kalb; kevkalb@aol.com; Elaine &Vince Wesnofske; Allan Jones; Joseph Martino Subject:Naples Equestrian Challenge NIM July 15th Dear Kim please see attached letter following Naples Equestrian Challenge's Neighborhood Information Meeting on July 15th. Kind regards 5 Packet Page-299- 10/8/2013 8.A. Hon. Caroline Martino Tel: (239) 594 8875 Fax: (239) 594 8528 Cell: (239) 404 6718 carolinemartino @comcast.net<mailto:carolinemartinona,comcast.net> 6 Packet Page -300- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Friday,August 30, 2013 12:04 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Thanks, • Mewk. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-maiL address released in response to a public records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Joseph Martino [mailto:joseohvmartino(lcomcast.net] Sent: Friday, August 30, 2013 11:31 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Mr. Strain: My name is Joseph Martino, and I live at 179 Ridge Drive, Naples, 34108 in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. While I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-301- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:12 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mork. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: ewdos @aol.com [mailto:ewdos @aol.com] Sent: Saturday,August 31, 2013 10:33 AM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; philbrougharm @colliergov.net; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein @colliergov.net; pmidnev @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: My name is Elaine Wesnofske and I live at 193 Ridge Drive in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. While I admire the wonderful service that NEC provides, I feel that the proposed expansion to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not at all compatible with our Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I respectfully ask that this conditional use petition be denied. Thank you for your consideration in this regard. Elaine Wesnofske Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-302- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:12 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: vwdos @aol.com [mailto:vwdos @aol.coml Sent: Saturday,August 31, 2013 10:46 AM To: Strain Mark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners, My name is Vincent Wesnofske and I live at 193 Ridge Drive in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. Regarding the Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval that will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013, I wish to request that this approval be denied. i so admire the wonderful service that NEC provides. However, I feel that the proposed expansion to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with our Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. Thank you for your service and your time in reading my objection to this expansion. Vincent Wesnofske Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -303- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:13 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Patricia Milford [mailto:schubeyaembargmail.coml Sent: Saturday, August 31, 2013 3:56 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymkleinCacolliergov.net; pmidnevcollieroov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Collier County Planning Commissioners: Our names are Patricia Milford and Robert Schubring and we own property at 1175 Pine Ridge Road in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5,2013. We are unable to attend that public hearing but we hope you will consider this email in our absence. We support the NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be APPROVED. Thank you. Patricia Milford and Robert Schubring Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -304- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:23 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. M a,irk. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Marni Chur [mailto:marnichur @vahoo.com1 Sent: Sunday, September 01, 2013 3:58 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein @colliergov.net; pmidnev @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: Pineridge Civic Civic Association Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 • Dear Planning Commisioners: 'P ` Our names are Marni and Neil Chur of 700 Myrtle Road in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. We are aware that the Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on Septemmber 5, 3012. We will not be ably to attend that public hearing, but we hope that you will consider this email in our absence. The NEC provides an admirable service, however, we believe that the NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank your for your time and consideration in this matter. Please do not hesitate to contact us is you have any further questions. Marni and Neil Chur Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -305- 1 0/8/201 3 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:23 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Petition CU -PL 20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. M ark, 239.252.4446 Under Florida LOW, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From:JAMES MADSEN [mailto:themadsens@embaramail.com] Sent: Sunday, September 01, 2013 4:52 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Petition CU - PL 20110000719 Dear Planning Commisioners, We are James and Sandra Madsen and live at 435 Gordonia Road in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5,2012. We are unable to attend that public hearing,because we both work for the Collier County Public Schools with ESE children. Our life work verifies that we appreciate the good service that NEC provides, but their proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I hope you will consider this e-mail since we are unable to attend the meeting. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you, James& Sandra Madsen Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -306- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:24 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark, 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Ironduke36 @comcast.net[mailto:Ironduke36Cacomcast.net] Sent: Sunday, September 01, 2013 6:08 PM To: StrainMark Cc: pineridgenaples(alhotmail.com Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: My name is Donald Dyer, and I live at 458 Ridge Drive in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5th, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence. While I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Sincerely, Donald Dyer Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-307- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:28 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark, 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your a-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Kevin Kalb [mailto:kevkalb @aol.com] Sent: Monday, September 02, 2013 7:51 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Commissioner: My name is Kevin Kalb, and I live at 215 Caribbean Rd. in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. Although my wife Alison and I will attend the public hearing on Thursday, September 5th, I am also writing to formally request that the Conditional Use Permit request for NEC be denied. We respect and support the laudable services that NEC provides. However, we feel strongly that NEC's planned expansion from its current 2.5 acres,to nearly 7 acres, and expansion from its original mission of serving roughly 32 participants,to serving a planned 632 participants,is incompatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I appreciate your consideration of our concerns regarding this petition. Thank you. Kevin Kalb (239) 254-7640 - Office (239) 580-8287 - Mobile kevkalb(a�aol.com Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-308- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:28 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Kent Hasen [mailto:drhasen @drhasen.coml Sent: Monday, September 02, 2013 8:49 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein@colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: pineridgenaples(ahotmail.com Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 JI- AESTHETIC -t ;. PLASTIC ak&•- SURGERY NAPLES _ Kent V Hasen, M.D. Dear Planning Commissioners: My wife and I (Kent and Dellene Hasen) live at 100 North Street in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challege's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. We are unable to attend that public hearing, but we hope you will consider this email in our absence. While we appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is our belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Sincerely, 1 Packet Page -309- 10/8/2013 8.A. Ck- (72/(27/ 4081 lamiarni Trail North 6203.N plus.FL 34103 1 PH(23 )11S2-5€-.02 FX(239)247-9278 wwu.Dctiasen.com LfJ Tube If you are a patient in need of timely assistance, please call the office at the phone number listed above since this email address may not be checked for days at a time. NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY: This message and any included attachments are intended only for the addressee. The information contained in this message is confidential and may constitute proprietary or non-public information under international, federal, or state laws, including the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 and related regulations. Unauthorized forwarding, printing, copying, distribution, or use of such information is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you are not the addressee, please promptly delete this message and notify the sender of the delivery error by e-mail. Thank you. ****************************************************************************************************************** Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-310- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03,2013 7:25 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma-rk, 239252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: calhoun1943©aol.com [mailto:calhoun1943©aol.com] Sent: Monday, September 02, 2013 9:12 AM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein©colliergov.net; pmidney(acolliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge petition CU-PL20110000719 Gentlemen: I am writing this e mail on behalf of my husband John Cardillo and myself, Linda Cardillo.We live in Pine Ridge at 395 Ridge Drive where we have been residents for almost 40 years. This property is approximately 1/4 mile from - , the equestrian center. Neither my husband or I can attend the meeting on Thursday. We are both very supportive of the efforts of the center for their expansion. They have been excellent neighbors and their mission is to be admired. We have never experienced any impact from refuse, traffic, or noise and feel that what they are asking is indeed compatible with the neighborhood as Pine Ridge was developed as horse country. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Linda Cardillo 395 Ridge Drive Naples 597-8577 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -311- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:29 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NaplesEquestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, a-mail addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records 'request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: susanff@comcast.net [mailto:susanff@comcast.net] Sent: Monday, September 02, 2013 10:16 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein@colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc:pineridgenaples@hotmail.com Subject: NaplesEquestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: Our names are Yale and Susan Freeman and we live at 153 West Street in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. We are unable to attend that public hearing, but we hope you will consider this email in our absence. While we appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is our belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. Our specific concerns are as follows: 1) The expansion of NEC is analogous to a historical Bed & Breakfast which was grandfathered in, expanding to a Hampton Inn; while a concession may have been made for a historical B&B, a further concession for a Hampton Inn would be inappropriate . 2) Every Request for Conditional Use Approval granted sets a precedent and makes the next Request for Conditional Use Approval more likely to succeed, thereby circumventing the intent of zoning. The erosion of our residential community could continue until such time as commercial uses will be permitted. 3) Although we commend NEC's worthy new goal of serving the needs of individuals with drug addiction, schizophrenia, PTSD, etc., we believe this far exceeds the original purpose of the conditional use initially granted. 4) By accepting federal HUD money, an organization loses its local philanthropic mission and local control. Governmental regulations must be complied with. 1 Packet Page-312- 10/8/2013 8.A. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. • Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-313- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:27 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge-CU-PL 20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma-►-k, 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-mail addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Richard Grant [mailto:rgrant(agfpac.com] Sent: Monday, September 02, 2013 12:09 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; KleinBarry; 'pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: 'pineridgenaples @hotmail.com' Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge-CU-PL 20110000719 Members of the Planning Commission: My wife and I have resided in Pine Ridge at 158 Caribbean Road for 34 years. My office is located in Pelican Bay. A previous commitment may prevent me from attending the meeting on September 5.So I am sending this email to express our concern with and, regrettably,our opposition to the above petition. Pine Ridge is a unique place to be sure. It is today surrounded by six lane roads which presents some challenges to the lots that are on its perimeter. But the lots are large and can be buffered.Those on the east side, abutting Goodlette Road,are, in the main, much larger than most,and are still zoned for agricultural uses. That the Naples Equestrian Challenge does good works is not the question or the issue. The issue is its impact on the residential Pine Ridge neighborhood that it adjoins. It's expansion, however well designed it might be,will increase those impacts, many of which are negative: noise, night time lighting,traffic etc. The proposed conditional use is not sought because of the needs of the existing operation, but apparently because of a planned expansion of the NEC programs that requires more land for the expanded operations. In my opinion that does not justify the proposed conditional use when considering that a conditional use already exists for its existing uses. The logical effect permitting the conditional use could lead to future requests for expansion.While perhaps it might not set pure legal precedent the approval of one conditional use could make it more difficult politically to deny subsequent requests. If NEC wants to expand its programs and services it really should locate some other land in an appropriate area to carry those activities on. They should not be expanded in a residential area-even one whose underlying zoning may be uniquely agricultural.And were there to be justification for the proposed conditional use it should not be separated, or disconnected, from the present approved conditional use, but rather they should both be joined as one single request so that the entirety of the uses, existing and new,can be regulated as one single matter. Richard C.Grant I Board Certified Real Estate Attorney (239)514-1000 1 Packet Page-314- 10/8/2013 8.A. GRANT Grant Fridkin Pearson,P.A. FRIDKIN r 5551 Ridgewood Drive,Suite 501.Naples.FL 34108 PEARSON Tel(239)514-1000 I Fax(239)514-0377 ATITANrys AND rgrant @gfpac.com I www.gfpac.com GOLr E.EL MC AT LAW The preceding email message may have information that is confidential,may be protected by the attorney/client or other applicable privileges,and may constitute nonpublic information. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient,you are hereby notified that any dissemination,forwarding,or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please notify the sender immediately by email or by calling(239)514-1000 and delete the original message. Thank you Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your a-mall address released In response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page -315- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:25 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition#CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, a-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a pubL-Lc records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Donna Connolly [mailto:ddondonnaaol.com] Sent: Monday, September 02, 2013 11:36 AM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidnev@icollieraov.net; RosenMike; pineridgenaolesClhotmail.com Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition # CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: We are Don and Donna Connolly and live at 197 Eugenia Drive in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrain Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. We are uanble to attend that public hearing, but we hope you will consider this email in our absence. While we appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is our belief that NEC's proposal to expeand to nearly 7 acres and approxiately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single family residential neighborhood. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Don & Donna Connolly 197 Eugenia Drive Naples, FL 34108-2929 239 592 1038 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-316- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 7:27 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Pine Ridge and the NEC approval process Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma--k. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address reLeased in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Barbara W. Miller [mailto:barw(amsn.com] Sent: Monday, September 02, 2013 12:25 PM To: StrainMark; pmidneycolliergov.net; RosenMike; barrvmklein@ colliergov.net; HomiakKaren; philbroghamCacolliergov.net; EbertDiane Subject: Pine Ridge and the NEC approval process September 2nd, 2013 Dear Collier County Planning Commissioners, We live in the quiet, residential Pine Ridge neighborhood and are unable to attend the Planning Commission meeting on September 5th, 2013. The Naples Equestrian Challenge expansion and conditional use approval is on the agenda for this meeting. The Naples Equestrian Challenge at its current location provides a wonderful service to our community. But having it extend into areas not zoned for its activities is not so wonderful for the residential community of Pine Ridge. 52 parking spaces, extended hours and services, more traffic, more noise and the deterioration of residential properties is not the neighborhood where we purchased and built our home. We are against the creeping of non-residential concerns that require special zoning consideration for any lot in our neighborhood. We are against the conditional use approval for NEC. Wes and Barbara Miller 14 Ridge Drive Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -317- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 8:55 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Conditional Use Permit for NEC Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-maiL address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Pam [mailto:oam6173©gmail.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 8:54 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Conditional Use Permit for NEC Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past five years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC?s equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants (member of my family). There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC?s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to (me/my family) and to our community. Thank you, Sincerely, Pamala Plenge 295 3rd. St 1 Packet Page-318- 10/8/2013 8.A. Bonita Springs, Fl 34134 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. • 2 Packet Page -319- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:26 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as -:you would any such correspondence. Mark.: sto 239.252.4446 Ya Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Lynna Scofield [mailto:lynna.scofieldPgmail.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 8:58 AM To: StrainMark Subject: NEC Hello Mark- We won't be able to attend the Thursday meeting - but definitely wanted to express our support for the mission and service of the Naples Equestrian Challenge program. It holds high standards for service and safety and as can be verified by testimonies of families who are served,NEC is making an essential investment in the lives of child and adult riders. I absolutely support their mission and would encourage approval of their zoning requests. I have often thought that is it wonderful that it sits within a residential neighborhood, hardly appearing to be more than just another quiet, well- kept property. I'm sure that future entry/exit/parking will be tailored to bring the least disruption to the Pine Ridge community. Holly and Gracie have volunteered with NEC - as a parent, I appreciate a safe venue for volunteer service for my children. The training, supervision and opportunity for service that they have received from NEC are a valuable part of their development as responsible, caring young people. Please feel free to contact me for any further information. Thanks very much, Lynna Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-320- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:27 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Attachments: nec.doc Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: theplay36 5comcast.net [mailto:theplay36 @comcast.net] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 9:11 AM To: StrainMark Cc: Missysaracino @naplesequestrianchallencie.orq Subject: NEC Please see attached Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -321- 10/8/2013 8.A. W.T.F Inventory Systems 333 Washington st Suite 431 Boston Mass 02108 617-227-6833 9/03/2013 280 South Collier blvd #1201 Marco Island Fl 33145 Dear Planning Commission Committee Member; I am writing is support of the NEC expansion and Conditional Use Permit. I have been involved with a program in Mass which has the same guidelines and the NEC in Naples. I have seen the benefit to the kids, and adults of the programs they use in the programs they apply. I flew down to Naples last week to specifically meet with the people at NEC and sign up as a volunteer for the 6 months I winter in Florida. I hope that gives you some impression of the importance I feel for this program, and strongly urge you folks to vote yes on these well needed permits . Thank You for your time, Sincerely, Mark Robinson Packet Page-322- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:27 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Rebecca Taylor [mailto:b2ltavlorCa�cmail.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:00 AM To: RosenMike; pmidnev©colliergov.net; barrvmdlein(acolliergov.net; HomiakKaren; BroughamPhil; EbertDiane; StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Members of the CCPC: I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 4 years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. These kids and their parentsgain so much benefit from the program, and many would not thrive without it. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Rebecca Taylor Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. Packet Page-323- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:28 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: F1N: Naples Equestrine Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Original Message From: Brande [mailto:brandeshelton(Eyahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:17 AM To: StrainMark; BroughamPhil Subject: Naples Equestrine Challenge Dear members of CCPC: My name is Brande Shelton and I have an almost five year old son that is autistic and he rides his favorite horse Pick A Spot at Naples Equestrian Challenge. Chaden has been through one riding season and a week of summer camp at NEC this year! Chaden is engaged in his therapeutic horseback riding! The staff and volunteers are absolutely wonderful with these children. My son gains so much from his 30 minute session weekly. We live in NW Cape Coral and we drive about an hour for these sessions. There are not many therapeutic recreational options out there for special needs young children. NEC is an asset to its community and these children can thrive on additional sensory therapies that they can utilize on the Sensory Trail! Please approve the conditional use permit for NEC! Sincerely, Brande Shelton 205 NW 24th Place Cape Coral, FL 33993 Phone: 239-738-0173 Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -324- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:36 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW:YES-NEC's Expansion and Conditional Use Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Marl. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: tjohnsoncpa @comcast.net [mailto:tjohnsoncpa @comcast.netl Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:32 AM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @colliergov.net; pmidnev @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: Missy Saracino- NEC Subject: YES- NEC's Expansion and Conditional Use Permit Dear Members of the CCPC: We are a family of a participant in the Naples Equestrian Challenge - Equine Therapy Programs. Our daughter has been riding for the past 9 years at NEC. Our family has personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. Our daughter, Kendra Johnson, walks because of NEC! Kendra began the NEC program back in October 2004 in her walker. She was 3 years old and not yet walking. Many told us Kendra may never be able to walk. However, we still brought Kendra to ride anyway, even if only to enjoy the horses. Please understand, riding the horses was not viewed as therapy to Kendra but as fun! NEC is a huge part of who Kendra is today!! Kendra will begin another year of riding at NEC this Thursday at 6pm. 1 Packet Page-325- 10/8/2013 8.A. We encourage all of you to come watch her and others ride...tosee for yourselves just what NEC is to all its participants. The Naples Equestrian Challenge has also given sibling like Rebecca a rare opportunity to be with her sister. In the riding summer camps, Rebecca has enjoyed riding with her little sister. This is a program allowing typical siblings to experience riding horses with their disabled or in Kendra's case ABLED sibling. We BELIEVE...NO WE KNOW...it is NEC that KENDRA IS WALKING TODAY.'! Families(like ours) with children of special needs...really need NEC to expand and grow. We would hope all of you as MEMBERS of the CCPC will come to be enlightened at the benefits NEC provides to our community. There are so MANY MORE children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. It is a wonderful program! It is a place for our families and our children to grow, experience and succeed in life. We are confident this expansion will be the same for so many more families in our community! We plead with all of you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. Thank you in advance for your consideration and help. Respectfully, Ken, Tonya, Rebecca...and especially Kendra Johnson Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-326- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:37 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC conditional use permit application on lots 182 & 194 Ridge Drive Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail, addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: terry m moser [mailto:terrymmoser(ayahoo.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 10:36 AM To: StrainMark Cc: Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdleinCalcolliergov.net; pmidney(8colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC conditional use permit application on lots 182 & 194 Ridge Drive Members of the CCPC I am a resident of Collier County and have been a volunteer for NEC for over five years and therefore have personally seen the WONDERS of the NEC equine therapy programs. It would be a great dis-service not to allow the expansion of there services to the residents of Collier County. These programs help the special need children and adults of Collier County in a way that can not be found anywhere else in S. W. Florida !! I urge you to APPROVE the NEC conditional use permit vote scheduled for 9/5/2013. Thank You, Terry M. Moser Naples, Fl Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-327- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 12:01 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Conditional Use Permit Attachments: NEC show 2013 850.JPG; NEC show 2013 832.JPG Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma-k. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Stacie Wiesenbaugh [mailto:rrflorida @embarcmail.coml Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 11:51 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Conditional Use Permit Dear Mr. Strain, Member of the CCPC: Since 2005, my family and I have been a part of the Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC)family. My husband, John Buck, and I each volunteer, advocate and most importantly are parents of rider, Riley Buck, age eleven. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants and my own family. Activities and organizations who accept and nurture a child as involved as my own are rare and should be treasured. They also provide an amazing opportunity for those with time and energy to give to participate and see the return on their investment simply in smiles. There are many more children and adults with special needs in the local community that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. I have attached photo's of Riley from the horse show last spring I hope that you will see how amazing these moments are in Riley's life. Please feel free to speak with me personally at 239 495-0350. Thank you, Stacie Wiesenbaugh Stacie Wiesenbaugh Independent Consultant#18425803 Arbonne International, www.arbonne.corn 239-495-0350 Riley's Smile: www.RileysSmile.corn The Shark Tooth Guy on Facebook 1 Packet Page-328- 10/8/2013 8.A. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in wilting. 2 Packet Page-329- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 12:20 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Attachments: Additional Opertational Background.pdf Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Marks 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: c.angelica.perezc gmail.com [mailto:c.angelica.perezc gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 12:19 PM To: BroughamPhil; StrainMark; Ebert Diane; HomiakKaren Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Members of the CCPC: , I am Carmen Angel Perez, LPN. I am a supporter and volunteer with the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for two years . I have personally seen the many benefits NEC' s equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its numerous participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC' s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to for me and to our community. This program unites all people and enriches the lives of everyone who participates . Please support this vital program and the riders. Thank you. Respectfully, Carmen Angel Perez, Licensed Practical Nurse Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-330- 10/8/2013 8.A. Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use Additional Operational Background The mission of Naples Equestrian Challenge is to improve the lives of children and adults with special needs through therapeutic riding and other equine-related programs. Established in 1995 and located at the corner of Goodlette Road and Center Street in the Pine Ridge Estates neighborhood,NEC became a PATH-certified riding center(Professional Association of Therapeutic Horsemanship International, which is an international accrediting organization that has standardized the practices of therapeutic riding and equine-facilitated learning and psychotherapy activities)in 2000. In 2011, NEC achieved the coveted designation of a PATH International Premier Center. With the generous support of the community, NEC has expanded from serving four individuals in 1995 to 432 individuals in 2012. The majority of NEC's 432 participants suffer with autism spectrum disorder,attention deficit disorder(ADD)/attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder(ADHD),cerebral palsy, .Down syndrome, multiple sclerosis, developmental delay, traumatic brain injury, post traumatic stress disorder(PTSD)and sensory integration disorder. Each year of its history, NEC has been successful in further expanding its equine-assisted activities and therapy programs to accommodate more participants. In 2012, NEC served 432 participants, who received 900 units of service (therapeutic riding, equine-facilitated learning and equine- facilitated psychotherapy sessions,outreach lessons and/or Summer Camp). By collaborating with other non-profit organizations in Collier County(i.e.,David Lawrence Center,PACE Center for Girls in Immokalee,Friends of Foster Children,Alzheimer's Support Network,Parkinson's Association of SW Florida) NEC successfully added several equine-facilitated learning and psychotherapy programs in 2012. In January 2013, NEC launched Operation Strides, an equine-assisted psychotherapy program for retired military veterans suffering with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), traumatic brain injury and/or amputation. Operation Strides is a fully-funded program (no fee for participants) as NEC was successful in raising the funds needed from private donors to cover the program's direct and indirect cost for approximately the next 2.5 years. According to the U.S.Department of Veteran Affairs,there are more than 32,000 military veterans living in Collier County. NEC is one of only 66 PATH-certified centers providing equine therapy services for veterans in the country. NEC currently is operating at capacity. In an effort to offer its equine-assisted activities and therapy programs to more Collier County citizens with special needs,the NEC Board of Directors is pursuing an opportunity to purchase the adjacent lot to the south of NEC's current location. This 2.15 acre parcel, located at 182 Ridge Drive,would provide NEC with the opportunity to increase its impact on the community. This additional land would enable NEC to conduct simultaneous programming resulting in more program hours; thus increasing the number of participants able to benefit from NEC equine-assisted activities and therapies,including NEC's Operation Strides program for military veterans. Page 1 of 2 Packet Page -331- 10/8/2013 8.A. According to the data warehouse, more than 4,000 Collier County students have been screened, evaluated and assigned an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) which calls for special accommodations due to a range of mental and physical disabilities from attention deficit disorder (ADD)to the most acute levels of cerebral palsy and Down syndrome. Among those 4,000 students, it is reasonable to assume that as many as 1,000,or 25%,would qualify for NEC services. In the last school year,NEC served 310 students,leaving a potential of 690 un-or under-served students that may benefit from NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapies. With the additional property located at 182 Ridge Drive, NEC is confident that with the extended facilities, approximately 200 additional children and adults will be served on this property per annum and for generations. NEC's preliminary build-out plan entails: • adding a six-stall barn to house potentially four (4) additional therapy horses, with a tack room,feed/hay storage as well as laundry facility; • a multi-purpose room to conduct meetings, trainings and small events (i.e., annual volunteer appreciation event); • a 75' diameter (just slightly larger than 20 meters) round covered riding arena to host equine facilitated learning and psychotherapy programs as well as therapeutic interactive vaulting for riders with special needs;and, • two additional turnout paddocks as well as a bridle path. Hours for use of the new facilities will be consistent with hours for the existing programming. NEC typically conducts riding sessions between the hours of 8:00 AM and 8:00 PM. NEC on occasion may provide training to volunteers or conduct board meetings beyond their hours of 8:00 PM to approximately 9:00 PM. NEC does host special events throughout the year with these events ending at approximately 11:00 PM. Multi-purpose Room In addition to providing meeting space for volunteer orientations and trainings,the multi-purpose room provides NEC with the required meeting space to host PATH Instructor trainings. Currently, NEC is not able to host/conduct PATH instructor trainings due to its lack of adequate meeting space. As a PATH Premier Center and with the planned multi-purpose room, NEC would have the required infrastructure to host these trainings which provide revenue to the organization. Covered Round Riding Arena The 75 foot diameter covered round riding arena will provide a much needed additional riding facility where NEC will be able to conduct concurrent equine therapy sessions during normal operating hours. The location of the round riding arena was selected to provide adequate distance from the existing covered riding arena so as not to require a public address system. An amplified public address system is not required in a 75 foot diameter covered round riding arena,especially when kept an adequate distance from the existing riding arena that currently has a PA system that is used while conducting equine therapy sessions under it. The planned covered round riding arena will have lighting for evening sessions. However, the height of the arena sides and roof are low profile. Page 2 of 2 Packet Page-332- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 12:44 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Griffin, Robin [mailto:Robin.Griffin @marsh.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 12:43 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; philbrougham @colliergov.ne; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Good morning to you, the members of the Collier County Planning Commission, My twelve year old daughter Marissa has been a rider and volunteer at Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC) for the past several months. Marissa was diagnosed with Clinical Depression and ADHD when she was nine. At the age of ten she had a severe reaction to her medications and began pulling out her hair. All her waist length golden hair was gone in a matter of months. Imagine watching your child tear out clumps of her hair and not be able to stop herself. After this, we decided to remove Marissa from all medication and attempt a more Holistic approach to her healing. We spent months traveling back and forth to St Petersburg for intensive therapy and treatment and were able to reverse the hair pulling and I am happy to say Marissa now has grown back her hair. Her therapist recommended continued treatment for her depression and anxiety to prevent the Trichotillomania from reoccurring and suggested Equine Therapy. We were introduced to NEC's therapy program this year through her care provider at the David Lawrence center and began an 8 week program. I can not tell you what an amazing transformation I saw in my daughter over the course of those few weeks. It brings tears to my eyes every time I think of how much pain and suffering my young one as endured due to her illness. NEC has given her back a life worth living. The Therapy and volunteering has given her self confidence, a sense of purpose, socialization skills and the ability to bond with and care for an animal 4 times her size. The relationships and experiences she has had at NEC are unmatched by any program we have participated in. While you consider allowing NEC to obtain a conditional use permit in order to expand the treatments and opportunities they can provide to their clients- please keep in mind the children and adults like Marissa. I can understand the neighboring property owner's concerns for the value of their land- but please think about the value of the many lives NEC has touched, and saved, through their programs. As a community we need to invest in the well being of our citizens and our children. Property can be bought and sold- but people are the real investment that make our community worth being a part of. If you have not visited the NEC campus I highly recommend taking a tour. The facility itself is impeccably maintained and aesthetically pleasing. I can only imagine the expansion will be as clean and well manicured as the existing land and buildings. Take a look for yourself- watch a lesson. The joy and 1 Packet Page-333- 10/8/2013 8.A. compassion you will feel knowing this amazing facility is a part of our town will make you proud to be a Neapolitan. I wish you all the best in your endeavor to make the right choice for our community. I know it will be made with compassion, thoughtful consideration and intelligent review of all the information presented. Regards, Robin Griffin Robin Griffin I Insurance Assistant Marsh I Private Client Services 5811 Pelican Bay Blvd. Suite 101 Naples, FL 34108 Direct Dial 239-597-0431 I Fax 239-597-0464 robin.grifiin(a�marsh.com I Marsh USA Inc I www.marsh.com In California d/b/a Marsh Risk & Insurance Services I CA License # 0437153 ********************************************************************** This e-mail transmission and any attachments that accompany it may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise exempt from disclosure under applicable law and is intended solely for the use of the individual(s)to whom it was intended to be addressed. If you have received this e-mail by mistake, or you are not the intended recipient, any disclosure, dissemination, distribution, copying or other use or retention of this communication or its substance is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error,please immediately reply to the author via e-mail that you received this message by mistake and also permanently delete the original and all copies of this e-mail and any attachments from your computer. Thank you. ********************************************************************** Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page -334- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 12:59 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark, 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are public records. If you do not want your a-mail address reLeased in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Barrie C Fitz-Gerald, Ph.D. [mail to:bfitzgera ld©barringersystems.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 12:57 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymkleinCa�colliergov.net; pmidney©colliergov.net; mkerosen©colliergov.net Cc: pineridgenaplesAhotmail.com Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Our names are Dr. Barrie and Nilsa Fitz-Gerald along with our 2 children and their puppy Alli.....We reside in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood...just steps away from the above captioned at 254 Ridge Drive. Many years ago...NEC did petition us to allow their "use" to be allowed in our neighborhood. Initially, it was to be a "small" operation. Well, it has grown considerably...and now they are projecting the operation to grow "exponentially" . Under the current operation...we see cars parked along the streets for varying events...this poses to be a "huge" (to quote a local Kia advertisement) problem. Are they kidding...632 PARTICIPANTS a year. No that's not correct...are they suggesting that these folks will only attend 1 day...lf we allow 632 participants a year...we are looking at 632 potential participants each week or month....AND TO GROW BY 30% (and for what period...there will be no end) Think about this....632 participants...even if for just one day they show up all at one time....ARE YOU KIDDING?!! WE BELIEVE THEY HAVE GONE BEYOND THEIR ORIGINAL FOCUS AT THE PRESENT TIME....AND HEREBY RECOMMEND THAT THE `CONDITIONAL' USE PETITION BE DENIED. THIS IS NOT A "COMMERCIAL AREA"...and we believe although shrouded in a "non-profit" cloak is "QUASI-COMMERCIAL". If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck....it's a duck. 1 Packet Page -335- 10/8/2013 8.A. Respectfully submitted, Ba 'ie aa►a'MAW fitz—O"ah' gdippyie `6' Perag 6 eHealth Visioneering www.eHealthVisioneerinq.com CODESMART UNIVERSITY Relate, Individualize, Strategize, Maximize (Aiiscripts, Cisco, McKesson and Microsoft Certified) 0: 239.514.7777 Fax: 239.514.7779 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-336- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 1:09 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: ASAP Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Dagmayis Martinez [mailto:mayi7502(a dmail.com) Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 1:09 PM To: StrainMark Subject: ASAP Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer/participant for/in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC?s equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants (member of my family). There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC?s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to (me/my family) and to our community. Thank you, Dagmayis Martinez Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -337- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 2:05 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Marl/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Kristyn Stetson [mailto:kstetsonOstetson.edu] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 1:48 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Mr. Strain, I am a volunteer at Naples Equestrian Challenge and have been for the past eight years. I started as a volunteer at the age of twelve and am now a sophomore in college. Even though I am away at school I come back and volunteer whenever I am home on break and this summer I did more than 370 hours there. Over the years I have seen ample benefits from NEC's programs for the participants and the volunteers. I have seen children who are in a wheelchair learn to walk, I have seen non-verbal children say their first words and so much more. I worked with one girl who couldn't sit up on the horse and was supported with boppy pillows sit up for the first time after weeks of trying. The smile on her was priceless as she looked around at everyone who was cheering for her. Every time I am at NEC I see miracles happen big and small. I have personally benefited as a volunteer from NEC. Though volunteering at NEC I found my passion for special needs children and am currently studying to become an elementary ESE teacher with plans on coming back to Collier County to teach.There are so many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that can benefit from NEC and you can help us provide this vital therapy. I strongly urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application. I cannot say enough good things about this program, unless you want a whole essay. Naples Equestrian Challenge has been such an amazing opportunity and is a tremendous asset to me and the whole community. Thank you for your time. Kristyn Stetson "Kristyn Stetson's, Stetson University !Elementary Education Bonner Leader, Stetson Bonner Program Bonner Ambassador, Stetson Bonner Program 1 Packet Page-338- 10/8/2013 8.A. FOCUS leader, FOCUS orientation Vice President/ Co-founder Stetson Coalition for Sustainable Student Health kstetson @stetson.edu I (239)272-9411 Campus Box 6972 Under Florida Law,a-mall addresses are public records.if you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page -339- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 2:06 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use Permit for 194 and 182 Ridge Drive, Naples, FL Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mai-k/ 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-mail addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Dixon Yun [mailto:dixonyun @gmail.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 1:58 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @colliergov.net;pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: Missy Saracino; kimminarich @naolesequestrianchallenge.org Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use Permit for 194 and 182 Ridge Drive, Naples, FL September 3, 2013 Dear Members of the Collier County Planning Commission: For more than a year I have been, and will continue to be, an enthusiastic and experienced volunteer at the Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC) equine therapy program. I have witnessed the unique beneficial effect horses can have on individuals with physical and emotional disabilities. Do the NEC programs serve and have a positive and inclusive impact on the local and surrounding communities? Through direct experience participating in the NEC Equine-Facilitated Psychotherapy and Equine Facilitated Learning sessions, I have worked with Alzheimer's and Parkinson's patients,At-risk girls at the PACE Center, Friends of Foster Children and others. These programs are progressive and adapt to the needs of the target groups; so we can see that the specialized application of therapies is virtually universal when considering human needs and response. Participants and their families are unabashed in expressing their gratitude,when words often cannot adequately convey the sense of empowerment and satisfaction they achieve. Activities are growing to include Operation Strides for veterans with PTSD and brain injuries and Collier Lighthouse for the visually impaired. It is evident that there are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. 1 Packet Page-340- 10/8/2013 8.A. Trained administrators,psychologists and horse specialists are devoted to thoughtfully designing, constructing and operating a practical and effective facility. Taken together with the efforts of eager volunteers, tangible outcomes are all but assured. I also have knowledge of the Carlisle Academy for Integrative Equine Therapy and Sports and Ever After Mustang Rescue in Maine further reinforcing my endorsement of the mission of the NEC. I regret that I cannot attend the September 5th hearing,but urge you to approve NEC's application for the Conditional Use Permits before you. In my absence,this letter can be read at the meeting to state my support for the NEC. If any concerns are expressed that could delay the swift approval of the application,I am available for further discussion that might facilitate any solutions necessary to move this worthy project forward. Truly yours, Dixon Yun Volunteer Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-341- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 2:33 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: CCPC Meeting/September 5 for NEC Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Original Message From: Jeanne Zagursky [mailto:ieannezae50email.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 2:32 PM To: StrainMark Subject: CCPC Meeting / September 5 for NEC > Dear Member of the CCPC: > I am aware that there is a CCPC meeting on September 5 for discussion around the approval of Naples Equestrian Challenge's Conditional Use Permit application. I will not be able to the attend the meeting this Wednesday since I am out of town but I wanted to let you know that I am in full support of approving the permit application for NEC. > I am a volunteer for NEC's equine therapy programs and have been for the past 2 1/2 years. I have personally seen the many amazing benefits of NEC's equine assisted activities and therapy programs provided to all its participants. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. NEC offers a wonderful program and they are tremendous asset to me and our community. > Thank you for your time. > Sincerely, Jeanne Zagursky Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -342- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 2:47 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: naples equestrian challenge, petition cu-p120110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your a-mail address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: eileenfletcherfll comcast.net [mailto:eileenfletcherfl©comcast.neti Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 2:34 PM To: StrainMark Subject: naples equestrian challenge, petition cu-pI20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: Our names are William F MacMaster and Eileen M. Fletcher and we live at 198 Caribbean Rd. in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. We are unable to attend that public hearing, but we hope you will consider this email in our absence. While we appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is our belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you, Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -343- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 3:09 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-mail addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-mail. address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Richard Yovanovich [mailto:ryovanovich1961Ca>gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 3:08 PM To: pineridgenaples(ahotmail.com Cc: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Mr. Pytlik My wife and I have lived in Pine Ridge with our two children sincel 998. We have watched the Naples Equestrian Challenge grow and improve its facilities and services. We believe the Naples Equestrian Challenge has excellent facilities and has been a responsible community member. Naples Equestrian Challenge is located at one of the primary entrances to the Pine Ridge Community. I drive by it at least two times every day. The existing facilities are attractive and provide a nice entrance to the Community. We believe the planned expansion of the Naples Equestrian Challenge facilities will be an excellent addition to the Pine Ridge community. We have received unsolicited correspondence from residents opposing the planned project. The opponents have called the Naples Equestrian Challenge a commercial use and are requesting denial on that basis. The Naples Equestrian Challenge is not a commercial use and any attempt to classify it as such is merely a scare tactic. We know several people who have been served by Naples Equestrian Challenge. The Naples Equestrian Challenge provides a much needed service to the residents of Collier County and in no way negatively impacts the Pine Ridge community. We fully support the proposed plans and encourage the Pine Ridge Civic Association to support the proposed plans as well. Sincerely, Rich Yovanovich 1 Packet Page-344- 10/8/2013 8.A. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-345- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Tuesday, September 03,2013 3:18 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Support NEC Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: mcguirekristi @aol.com [mailto:mcguirekristi aol.comi Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 3:18 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Support NEC Dear Mr. Strain, I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past six years. I have personally witnessed the many benefits NEC has provided for equine-assisted activities and therapy programs to the participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve the NEC Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. With appreciation for your support and approval of the Conditional Use Permit for the Naples Equestrian Challenge, Kristi McGuire Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-346- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:09 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Expansion and Conditional Use Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mcwk. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, a-maiL addresses are public records. If you do not want your a-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Ray Beaudry [mailto:rwbeaudry(&gmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 4:14 PM To: StrainMark Subject: NEC Expansion and Conditional Use Permit Dear Mr. Chairman I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 2 years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Gloria M. Beaudry VOLUNTEER 5013 Ventura Court Naples,Florida 34109 239-325-9300 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-347- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:09 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Leigh [mailto:QlMorris @comcast.net] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 4:44 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymlein @coliierciov.net; Dmidney©colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge We have been involved with NEC for over 12 years as a participant and volunteer.This organization has my wife, Nancy with MS condition. It has increased her mobility and muscle control. I have worked with the participants as a Volunteer for over 4 years and have seen marked improvement in a number of clients. Previously I volunteered around the property doing miscellaneous job. All monies raised are used for the clients with minimal staff and I believe around 500 volunteers help the operation There are many special needs children and adults who benefit from these programs. I urge you to approve NEC Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to my wife and the other clients and to the community. We appreciate your thoughtful consideration Thank you, Leigh and Nancy Morris Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-348- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:10 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Conditional Use Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-maiL address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Sandra Hotchkiss [mailto:bomobears @gmail.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 5:02 PM To StrainMark Subject: NEC Conditional Use Permit I am a volunteer at the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past year. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's activities and therapy programs provide to children with special needs, Parkinson patients, adults with memory loss and veterans suffering with PTS. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application that is before you. This program is one of a kind, a unique program in Collier County and a tremendous asset to our community. Before retiring to Florida, I worked in a mental health hospital at Yale University New Haven, Connecticut and witnessed first hand the benefit of animal therapy for the mentally challenged. Again,please approve this application. Thank you from a NEC volunteer and a Florida resident. Sandra Hotchkiss Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-349- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:10 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challange Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Wally [mailto:wallaced0001@ gmail.com] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 5:26 PM To: Wally Dow Subject: Naples Equestrian Challange Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: Our names are Wallace Dow and Shirley Dow, and we live at 193 Center St in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challange's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013.We are unable to attend that public meeting, but we hope you will consider this email in our absence.While we appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is our belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood.We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank You. Sincerely, Mr and Mrs Wallace A. Dow Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. • 1 Packet Page -350- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:10 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Subject Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: anna burns [mailto:meganann.laura(agmail.coml Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 5:47 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning commissioner Mark Strain Chairman Our names are Richard and Anna Burris and we live at 337 West street in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing,but I hope you will consider this email in my absence. While I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to exspand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Mr. & Mrs. Burns Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-351- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:11 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: We support the expansion of the Naples Equestrian Center Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Dina Sewell &Michael F. Finkel [mailto:sewfin @comcast.net] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 6:02 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymkleinCahcolliergov.net; pmidneyPcolliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: We support the expansion of the Naples Equestrian Center Dear Commissioners, We have lived in Pine Ridge since 1999.The NEC is a beautiful campus, and the work they do is extremely beneficial. I am a neurologist, and my patients who have been at the NEC programs have always been extremely positive.When an individual is limited in his or her ability to walk or to move around unassisted,the experience of riding the large horse is very positive. I have been told that the NEC wants to expand services to individuals with Parkinson Disease and dementia. I believe that these programs will be very beneficial to adults with those conditions, and I will tell my patients of the opportunities. I do not consider this Not For Profit organization to be a commercial establishment We have reviewed the plans for the expansion,and they appear to be thoughtfully designed to match the ambience of Pine Ridge.We have been puzzled by the objection to this expansion by some of the neighbors who live close to the proposed expansion. Horses and their structures are elegant,and, like some of the other near neighbors,we cannot see that property values would be affected.There is already another horse property directly north of the NEC on Center Street. There have been concerns about an increase in traffic.When one considers how a client would approach the NEC, it is only logical that they would enter and leave via Center Street as accessed by Goodlette-Frank Road.There is no logical reason to enter from one of the few entrances to Pine Ridge. Please approve the expansion. If you have doubts or concerns, please visit the site and see for yourself. Yours sincerely, Michael F. Finkel MD 241 Carica Road 1 Packet Page -352- 10/8/2013 8.A. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-353- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:11 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mcu-k. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Sue Timmins (mailto:timmins05 @comcast.net] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 8:58 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmkleinCa�colliergov.net; pmidnev @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: pineridgenapleshotmail.com Subject: Re: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: My name is Susan Timmins,and I live at 76 Caribbean Rd in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. I have lived at this residence for 16 years. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5,2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence. While I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. Living on one of the main entrances into Pine Ridge,our neighborhood roads are busy with fast moving cut through traffic. Approval of the this petition will further burden our roads and create safety hazards. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Susan Timmins Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -354- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:11 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Expansion Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark' 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Art Canfield [mailto:ajc9425 @comcast.net] Sent:Tuesday, September 03, 2013 9:43 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @coliiergov.net Subject: NEC Expansion Dear members of the CCPC, We are residents of Pine Ridge Estates (423 Ridge Ct.) and we would like to express our support for NEC'S expansion and Conditional Use Permit. There are many children and adults in Collier County with special needs and we believe it is our moral obligation as residents of the county to assist them in any way that we are able. Naples Equestrian Challenge has proven themselves to be a good neighbor by keeping the Horse Farm clean and well kept. Equine therapy is a complimentary therapy that stimulates the entire body of the patient and has been proven to benefit the person physically, psychologically, educationally, and socially. As a community we would like to think it would be a privilege to be a part of helping those who have been born less fortunate than we are. As members you have an awesome responsibility in making these tough decisions, I am hopeful that you will consider allowing this expansion. Sincerely, Arthur and Kathleen Canfield 1 Packet Page -355- 10/8/2013 8.A. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-356- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:12 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC's expansion and Conditional Use Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: William Kane [mailto:kanelandis(agmail.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2013 9:54 PM To: StrainMark Subject: NEC's expansion and Conditional Use Permit Dear Member of the CCPC: Our daughter is a participant in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 7 yrs years. We have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants especialy our daughter Vanessa. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our family and to our community. Please do not let public sentiment decide what is best for our children and others who would benefit greatly from this provision. Thank you, Bill and Sue Kane Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-357- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:12 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Original Message From: Lea Haven [mailto:leahavenQanaplesequestrianchallenge.org] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 5:48 AM To: StrainMark Subject: NEC Dear Member of the CCPC: I started out as a volunteer with NEC 12 years ago to be with the horses. Working with the children pulled me in so far that I went and became certified as an instructor and have been teaching for the past 10 years. I have had some of the same riders over this period and know first hand how this program helps. I would love to see NEC acquire this property which has been a dream of ours and be able to expand the program and service many more people. I also have been doing the veterans program for NEC and have so many stories to share that I could be here all day about how it has helped these men and women who so proudly served out country. I urge you to approve NEC?s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Lea Haven PATH Certified Instructor / Equine Specialist Mark your calendars now for NEC's 8th Annual Bootstrap Boogie Barn Dance to be held Saturday, November 9, 2013. Please click on the link below to learn more about the event, event sponsorships and buy your tickets! http://www.naplesequestrianchallenge.org/news-events/2013-boot-strap-boogie-barn-dance/ Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-358- 1 0/8/201 3 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:46 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Original Message From: Robert Daun [mailto:rdaun30(acomcast.net] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:45 AM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymkleinlcolliergov.net; pmidney(acolliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 My Name is Robert Daun, and for thirty-one years have lived at 29 Ridge Drive in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. To the best of my knowledge, the Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence. While I commend the Naples Equestrian Challenge for the good work they have done over the past several years, I do not believe that their wish to add two residential lots to their original conditional use approval is in the best interests of the remaining Pine Ridge subdivision homeowners. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Robert Daun Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-359- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 10:11 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge conditional use permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Mbodzenski [mailto:dmbodzenskaaol.coml Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 8:11 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge conditional use permit Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy program. I have personally seen the many benefits NECs equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NECs Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Dr. Michelle Bodzenski, PT, DPT Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -360- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04,2013 10:12 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma-3ek. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Norman Dery [mailto:drdery@embargmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 8:23 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Chairman Strain, I am a volunteer and Board member at the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 5 years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC?s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to (me/my family) and to our community. Thank you. Bonny L. Eads, O.D. 60-10th St. N. Naples, Florida 34102 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -361- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 10:14 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, PETITION CU-PL20110000719 Attachments: Equestrial Challenge 1.doc Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Arnold DeHart [mailto:7100deh@ gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 9:03 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, PE i 1 i ION CU-PL20110000719 To: Chairman Mark Strain Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal We,Arnold and Wilma DeHart,live at 7000 Trail Blvd. in Pine Ridge residential community. It is our understanding that Naples Challenge's expansion and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. We plan to be at the meeting to express our disapproval of the proposal, but in the event we are unable to attend that public meeting we hope you will consider this Email in our absence. We attended the meeting when Naples Equestrian Challenge first proposed obtaining a conditional use for their limited program to have equine-facilitated therapy for children having special needs. Since then they have expanded their program far beyond the original concept. Now,they are seeking to expand the program to further degrade the residential character of our neighborhood. The attached copy of the resolution of the PRCA Board members clearly expresses the determination of the Board, with active support of the residents, to maintain the residential character of our neighborhood. Since the requested expansion would detract from the residential character of our neighborhood, we strongly recommend that your board deny their request. Sincerely, Signed: Arnold DeHart 1 Packet Page -362- 10/8/2013 8.A. Wilma DeHart Enc: PRCA Board of Directors Resolution Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-363- 10/8/2013 8.A. Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal We,Arnold and Wilma DeHart, live at 7000 Trail Blvd. in Pine Ridge residential community. It is our understanding that Naples Challenge's expansion and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. We plan to be at the meeting to express our disapproval of the proposal,but in the event we are unable to attend that public meeting we hope you will consider this Email in our absence. We attended the meeting when Naples Equestrian Challenge first proposed obtaining a conditional use for their limited program to have equine-facilitated therapy for children having special needs. Since then they have expanded their program far beyond the original concept. Now,they are seeking to expand the program to further degrade the residential character of our neighborhood. The attached copy of the resolution of the PRCA Board members clearly expresses the determination of the Board, with active support of the residents, to maintain the residential character of our neighborhood. Since the requested expansion would detract from the residential character of our neighborhood, we strongly recommend that your board deny their request. Sincerely, Signed: Arnold DeHart Wilma Deflart Enc: PRCA Board of Directors Resolution Packet Page-364- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 10:18 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Conditional Use Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma-r-k' 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send eLectronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Linda Detzel [mailto:dressagebootsCacomcast.net] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 9:47 AM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; philbroughham5colliergov.net; HomiakKaren; KleinBarry; pmidnev(acolliergov.net; RosenMike; Missy Saracino Subject: Conditional Use Permit Ask Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past S years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. By allowing the Conditional Use Permit, NEC will be able to expand the number of special needs children and adults they can serve. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Linda Detzel 3980 Loblolly Bay Dr. Naples Fl 34114 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-365- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 10:18 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send eLectronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Gary Gilchrist [mailto:gary.gilchrist2 @amail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 9:29 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Please support the NEC s expansion and the Conditional Use Permit. This is needed to meet the individual needs of the adults and children in the program. This program has continued to make a difference in the lives of many people. Also, the program has continued to grow each year. Gary Gilchrist 4300 Belair Lane Naples Florida Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-366- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04,2013 10:18 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Petition CU-PL201100000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mai-Icy 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address reLeased in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: adinorcia @comcast.net[mailto:adinorcia @comcast.netl Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 9:50 AM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein @colliergov.net; pmidnev @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: pineridgenaples @hotmail.com; tdinorcia Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Petition CU-PL201100000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: My husband and I own property at 143 Caribbean Court in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on Sept. 5, 2013. We are unable to attend that public hearing, but we hope you will consider this email in our absence. While we appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is our belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. My husband and I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Regards, Brenda K. Di Norcia Anthony Di Norcia Jr. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -367- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:16 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Expansion Attachments: NEC.jpg; PRCA Resolution.doc Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma--k. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Peter Pytlik rmailto:peter @warehouseservices.netl Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 10:28 AM To: StrainMark Cc: Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; KleinBarry; Paul Midney; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Expansion Dear Mark; Please review the attached documents before your planning meeting tomorrow. We feel they will assist you in making a decision on the NEC plans to expand. Thank you in advance, Peter Pytlik, President Pine Ridge Civic Association Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-368- 10/8/2013 8.A. s�` PINE RIDGE CIVIC ASSOCIATION :. a ri„p -t,� vow OF NAPLES, Inc. IMAGO& '. , P.O. BOX 770307 CD NAPLES, FL 34107-0307 To: Mark Strain, Chairman From: Pine Ridge Civic Association Date: September 3, 2013 RE: Naples Equestrian Challenge(NEC) Expansion Plans The Board of Directors of Pine Ridge Civic Association (PRCA) have considered the proposed expansion plan of NEC. We have evaluated their request in comparison to our 1) Covenants and Restrictions, 2) By-Laws, 3) Resolution of October 8, 1996, and public opinion. Although the existing operation of NEC conforms(but not entirely)to the conditional use permit and is pleasing to most in the area,the expansion does not comply with the resolution of October 8, 1996. It can be considered a nuisance in violation of our Covenants and Restrictions and does not improve the residential nature of Pine Ridge. For these reasons we cannot support the expansion plan as presented, and urge you to deny the request. Sincerely, Board of Directors Pine Ridge Civic Association Packet Page-369- 10/8/2013 8.A. Resolution of the Board of Directors of The Pine Ridge Civic Association, Inc. WHEREAS, Pine Ridge Subdivision (original) was planed in 1954; Pine Ridge Extension was platted in 1957, and Pine Ridge Second Extension was platted in 1971. The three plats make up what is commonly known as "the Pine Ridge Subdivision." All three units were developed by Collier Development Corporation. WHEREAS, Collier Development Corporation created a master plan for the entire subdivision with specific uses designated in specific locations. Since planned unit development(PUD) zoning was not available at the time of platting, Collier Development Corporation used deed restrictions to insure the integrity of the master plan. WHEREAS, changing the deed restrictions to permit uses not originally intended will alter the character of and have a negative impact on the master plan of the Pine Ridge Subdivision. WHEREAS, the Pine Ridge Civic Association, Inc. ("the Association")is a voluntary association of property owners in the Pine Ridge Subdivision whose purpose is to promote and maintain the unique character of the Pine Ridge Subdivision as a community, to protect its property values, and to enforce applicable deed restrictions that encumber property within the Pine Ridge Subdivision. WHEREAS, the Board of Directors of the Association is charged with addressing and giving leadership on issues that face the members of the Association. WHEREAS, the Board of Directors of the Association believes that it has a responsibility to adopt a policy concerning proposals that might be made to modify the zoning and applicable deed restrictions concerning different parts of the Pine Ridge Subdivision. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that it is the policy of the Board of Directors to support the continuation of the single family residential character and usage of all those lots in the Pine Ridge Subdivision that are not now zoned for commercial or multi-family uses; and the Board will not support efforts to make changes by modifying zoning or the applicable Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions unless (i) it is shown by compelling circumstances that the continuation of residential usage is no longer feasible and that other uses are not injurious to adjoining property, and (ii) that by an appropriate vote of lot owners there is a stated desire to amend the applicable Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions. Adopted by the Board of Directors of the Pine Ridge Civic Association, Inc.,this 8th day of October, 1996. Yes Chris Lombardo,President Yes Arnold DeHart,Past Pres. Yes Sally Barker, Vice Pres. Absent Connie Buck,Director Yes Sue Bracy,Secretary Yes Rebecca Fisher,Director Yes Paul Steinmetz, Treasurer Absent Jim Quigley,Director Copied from original by A. 0. DeHart 1/29/08 Packet Page-370- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:17 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-mail addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: agalbut @aol.com [mailto:agalbut @aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 10:32 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian CU-PL20110000719 Having been a long time resident of Pine Ridge residential community, I must advise against Naples Equestrian's expansion plans. It doesn't make sense to double or triple it's footprint and go to 50+parking spaces for a marginal (.?30%)increase in their capacity. Their neighbors feel this would be too impactful on them and I agree. I would support their neighbors in approving a scaled down expansion, as an acceptable compromise. Thank you. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -371- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:17 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Approval Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From:Janet McClellan [ma ilto:janeti59(agmail.coml Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 10:39 AM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmdlein(acolliergov.net; Dmidnev@collieraov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC Approval Hello, Our son has been in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy program for the past 8 years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide for Joshua as well as other participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to my family and to our community. Thank you so much, Janet McClellan Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-372- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:17 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Support for the Naples Equestrian Challenge special permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mw-k. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Jeanne Jeanguenat[mailto:iieanauenat3185amail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:01 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Support for the Naples Equestrian Challenge special permit .1 am the grandparent of a child who is active in the Naples Equestrian Challenge program and have been attending his practices for the last four years. I have certainly seen the progress he and his friends have made. But above all else, seeing the satisfaction when they achieve a new challenge and their joy in participating in the programs certainly shows the worth of this endeavor. Please vote for this special permit and thank you for your consideration. A concerned Grandmother, Jeanne E. Jeanguenat Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -373- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:17 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark: 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, a-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-maiL address reLeased in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: Brynburke [mailto:brvnburkeamail.coml Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:22 AM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is an amazing program and a tremendous asset to our community. Come by sometime to observe the various programs&I'm sure you'll walk away wanting to make it available to as many individuals as possible! Thank you for your support! Please, don't hesitate to call me with any questions or concerns. My cell number is 703-593-0067 Bryn M. Burke 721 Ninth St. South,Unit 4 Naples, FL 34102 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -374- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:18 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Original Message From: Anita Johnson [mailto:afinaplesPamac.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:07 AM To: StrainMark; dianneebertOcolliergov.net; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein(ac olliergov.net; pmidneyPcolliergov.net; RosenMike; pineridgenaplesPhotmail.com Subject: NEC, Petition CU-PL20110000719 My name is Anita Johnson, and I live at 775 Cassena Road in the Pine Ridge neighborhood. I request that you deny the NEC petition. It would not be a vote against helping children but a vote in support of zoning laws. NEC's first approval in our neighborhood was for a small operation. Let's keep it that way. I will not be able to attend the hearing but hope you keep me, and my desire to keep this area residential, in mind. Thank you. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-375- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:55 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Attachments: CCE09052013_00000.pdf Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Vin DePasquale Emailto:vdepasqualeCa dockcraytoncove.com] Sent:Thursday, September 05, 2013 11:50 AM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein@colliergov.net; pmidnev@coliieroov.net; RosenMike Cc:pineridgenaplesPhotmail.com Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 The attachment is a request for conditional use petition CU-PL20110000719 be denied. — Vin DePasquale Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-376- 10/8/2013 8.A. E-mail addresses for the Collier County Planning Commissioners: Mark Strain, Chairman markstrain@colliergov.net Diane K. Ebert dianeebert ac colliereov.net Philip E. Brougham philbrougham@colliereov.net Karen Homiak karenhomiakPcolliergov.net Barry M. Klein barrymklein@colliergov.net Paul Midney pmidney@colliereov.net Mike Rosen mikerosen@colliergov.net " Email address for the Pine Ridge Civic Association: pineridgenaplesPhotmail.com If you wish to register your opposition to the impact on our neighborhood, please send an email to the Planning Commissioners and to the Pine Ridge Civic Association. We have provided suggested language for your consideration below. Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: My name is Vin DePasquale, and I live at 56 Center Street in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence. While I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Packet Page-377- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:55 AM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Expansion and Conditional Use Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma irks 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, a-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your a-maiL address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Jenn Barrett f mailto:jbarrett0505Ca�amail.coml Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 11:54 AM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein@ colliergov,net; pmidneyiacolliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC Expansion and Conditional Use Permit Dear Member of the CCPC: My brother has Down Syndrome and has been a participant in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs for the past 8 years. I have also had the pleasure of volunteering as a side walker and attending various NEC programs and competitions over the past several years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. NEC's program has not only improved my brother's balance and coordination, but also his confidence. It has been so encouraging to witness similar progress with other participants as well. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. By introducing additional challenges, such as the Sensory Trail, riders would certainly have the opportunity to grow, develop, and be encouraged. Also depending on the rider's special needs, one therapy may be more beneficial than another. The Conditional Use Permit would open up additional therapies to many individuals in need. For those homeowners who are opposed, I would invite them to come watch the practices, shows, and interaction among participants. The value NEC provides is undeniable. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It truly is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our family and our community. Thank you for your consideration, Jennifer Barrett Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -378- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 12:22 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: naples equestrian challenge, petition cu-p120010000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. MoArk' 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Scott Tuttle [mailto:ScottCa>tuttleinsure.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 12:07 PM To: StrainMark; diannebert(a>collieraov.net; BroughamPhil; RosenMike; pmidney(&colliergov.net; barrymkleinla�colliergov.net; HomiakKaren; pineridgenapleshotmail.com Cc: brooke.r.simpson(a>us.pwc.com Subject: naples equestrian challenge, petition cu-p120010000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: My name is Scott Tuttle, and I own a home at 6832 Trail Blvd in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5,2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence.While I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it my belief that NEC'S proposal to expand to nearly double their current size and increase capacity to 632 participants per year is not conducive to a residential neighborhood.This expansion will increase traffic through our neighborhood. It is my understanding that the parking lot alone will be increased 62%from its current size to 52 parking spaces and I believe is just too much commercialization for the Pine Ridge neighborhood. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied Thank you Scott Tuttle Tuttle Insurance Group 19 New Haven Rd (Rt 67) Seymour, CT.06483 203 888 4373 203 888 5207(fax) www.tuttleinsure.com Like us on Facebook! 1 Packet Page-379- 10/8/2013 8.A. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-380- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 12:23 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge petition-Support the expansion Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. MoArk. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Heather Tice [mailto:heatherticedfnbofgc.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 12:10 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge petition - Support the expansion I am a long time Pine Ridge neighborhood resident and a parent of a special needs child who rode at Naples Equestrian Challenge for three years. I passionately and whole heartedly support the expansion and conditional use permit for the NEC. I understand what a huge impact this organization has on families with special needs children (and adults). If they are able to expand to help serve more people who need the service,then I am on board with that expansion. Our neighborhood has always had a special character to it. From the two barns to the neighbors with goats,we have a unique charm that made me fall in love with the neighborhood. I would never want to change that. I am very disheartened that a small handful of neighbors are trying to get the permit rejected. I am especially disappointed that the Hon.Caroline Martino,who headed NEC for so many years, would try to turn the neighborhood against the NEC. Because of that, I have decided to become more vocal in my support of the NEC expansion. I,for one,will not be swayed and stand firm in my support of Naples Equestrian Challenge and ask that you approve their conditional use permit. Thanks, Heather Tice Heather J. Tice A.V.P. - Director of Marketing First National Bank of the Gulf Coast 3560 Kraft Road Naples, FL 34105 1 Packet Page-381- 10/8/2013 8.A. Phone: 239-325-3750 Please consider the environment before printing this email. This e-mail and any files transmitted with it are the property of First National Bank of the Gulf Coast, and/or its affiliates, are confidential, privileged and are intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom this e-mail is addressed. If you are not one of the named recipient(s)or otherwise have reason to believe that you have received this message in error, please notify the sender at 239-348-8000 and delete this message immediately from your computer. Any other use, retention, dissemination forwarding, printing or copying of this e-mail is strictly prohibited. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page -382- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:16 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian chalenge,petition cu-pI20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by teLephone or in writing. From: mshari3686©aol.com [mailto:mshari3686©aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 12:37 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian chalenge,petition cu-p120110000719 Dear planning Commissioners: My name is Maliheh Zakikhani and I live at 6562 Trail blvd.in Pine Ridge residential neighborhood it is my Understanding that Naples equestrian challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the planning commission on September 5, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence.while I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides,it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine single-family residential neighborhood .1 respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you Sincerely malihe zakikhani Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -383- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:16 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: ajf522 [mailto:aif522Ca>hotmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 12:49 PM To: StrainMark Subject: NEC Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer, and my daughter is a participant at the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 5 years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants, and my daughter in particular. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to my family and to our community. Thank you, Amanda Ferguson Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE Smartphone Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -384- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:17 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Conditional Use Permit App Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark' 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Lauren Glase Imailto:laurenglaseohotographv(avahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 12:56 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein(acolliergov.net; pmidnevdcollierdov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC Conditional Use Permit App Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 2 years. 1 have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Lauren Glase laurenglasephotographyCa yahoo.com www.laurenolasephotography.com www.laurenglasephotoq raphv.com/bloq Become a Fan on Facebook! www.facebook.com/Iaurenglasephotography 1 Packet Page-385- 10/8/2013 8.A. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-386- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:17 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Original Message From: dlh4360embargmail.com [mailto:dlh436Pembargmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:05 PM To: StrainMark Cc: EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymkleinPcolliergov.net; pmidney(Ecolliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-P120110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: My name is Diane Heald, and I live at 436 West Street in the Pine Ridge RESIDENTIAL neighborhood. It is my understanding that NEC's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this e-mail in my absence. While I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is NOT compatible with the Pine Ridge single- family residential neighborhood. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Sent from my iPad Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-387- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:17 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: NEC Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Original Message From: Cindy [mailto:cmcdonough1140gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:17 PM To: StrainMark Subject: NEC Permit Please approve the conditional use permit for Naples Equestrian Challenge. I have been a volunteer there for two years & they are a great addition to the community. Their expertise is helping our most challenged & vulnerable children and adults is well known. They have minimal impact on the surrounding community and run a clean, quiet and well-organized riding center. A community is judged by how it treats its most vulnerable citizens & NEC should be encouraged for its services and contribution to the entire Naples community. Therefore, your approval shows respect for NEC's continuing efforts to serve our community and it is most requested. Thank you. Life is hard-be good to yourself and others-Cindy. Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -388- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:18 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Eqestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Hi. Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. M cu-k' 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Emma, David [mailto:demma @hightoweradvisors.coml Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:20 PM To: StrainMark Cc: pineridgenaples @hotmail.com Subject: Naples Eqestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners, My name is David Emma, and I live at 193 Eugenia Dr in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence. While I appreciate and the admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I respectfully request the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you, David A. Emma, CFP®, CRPC® Masterson, Emma &Associates "Providing Personalized Guidance for Sound Financial Decisions" Managing Director, Partner HighTower 5150 N Tamiami Trail Suite 402 Naples Fl 34103 (o) 239.330.3041 (c)401.225.3938 CO 239.236-1610 DEmma@hightoweradvisors.com www.hightoweradvisors.com/masterson-emma Securities offered thru HighTower Securities,LLC-Member FINRA/SIPC/MSRB-HighTower Advisors, LLC is an SEC registered investment adviser-200 W Madison St.25th Floor, Chicago, IL,60606-312.962.3800.Trades and other time-sensitive information should not be sent via email or left on voicemail.Always speak with a live person for trades. 1 Packet Page-389- 10/8/2013 8.A. The information contained in this email is confidential and intended for the named recipient(s)only. If you are not an intended recipient of this email please notify the sender immediately and delete your copy from your system.You must not read,copy,distribute or take any further action in reliance on it. Email is not a secure method of communication. E-mail messages may contain computer viruses or other defects, may not be accurately or completely replicated on other systems, or may be intercepted, deleted or interfered with without the knowledge of the sender or the intended recipient. HighTower makes no warranties in relation to these matters and will not, to the extent permitted by law,accept responsibility or liability for(a)the accuracy or completeness of,or(b)the presence of any virus, worm or similar malicious or disabling code in,this message or any attachment(s)to it. Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. • 2 Packet Page-390- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:18 PM To: SawyerMichael Attachments: NEC Conditional Use Permit; NEC's expansion; Support for NEC's Conditional Use Permit Application; Permit for Naples Equestrian Challenge; NEC expansion and Conditional Use Permit; Naples equestrian ; NEC Conditional Use Permit; Naples Equestrian Challenge; Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -391- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Sarah Beaumont[sarah @naplesluxuryhomes.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:35 PM To: StrainMark; dianeebert @colliergove.net; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Cc: Missy Saracino Subject: NEC Conditional Use Permit Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 2 years. 1 have been involved with horses for over 24 years and have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve the NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you(please see attached). It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Sarah J. Beaumont Campbell & Prebish,LLC Real Estate Professionals 792 Broad Avenue South Naples, FL 34102 Office: (239) 213.0800 Mobile: (239) 825.8674 Email: sarah @,naplesluxuryhomes.com www.naplesluxuryhomes.com ******Confidentiality Statement****** If you are not the intended recipient of this transmission,please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message as it may contain privileged and confidential information.Any information contained in this e-mail is not warranted or represented to be accurate or complete and should not be relied upon as such for any reason. Nothing in this email shall be deemed to create a binding contract to purchase/sell real estate. The sender of this email does not have the authority to bind a buyer or seller to a contract via written or verbal communications including,but not limited to, email communications. 1 Packet Page-392- 10/8/2013 8.A. .-.t:,M .......tI.., it 1 I , 1 f i y S ,; _ I *^+.� a I � I� 1 3 J �� ti ::aaa� sll� Wit; � � e 1 it � �: ! _ S t r ..��; ice , 1 I iI!,1q e 4 LQT 21 j 't� � �� .••�`° � � L0Tt9 1 .�, +Ema 1 ,' rr-- wI .dar7; iaYw 7111: .ii10.,+1rt.ikvirN w wr rnc. :fi.cr �a? HUMPHREY•ROW, �C1�ady1rlialo( ill'E k.c n ,1 c c IS NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE x 2 Packet Page -393- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Sue Lottridge susielott aol.com Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:44 PM To: StrainMark Subject: NEC expansion and Conditional Use Permit Dear Mr. Strain, Chairman,Collier County Planning Commission I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 13 years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs have provided to its participants. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is such a wonderful program for all of us involved and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Sincerely, Sue Lottridge 1 Packet Page-394- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: judycrousedesign@aol.com Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:38 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @collergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC's expansion Dear Member of the CCPC, I am a volunteer at Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy program and have been for over eight years. I have personally witnessed so many positive results and benefits that the participants(and their families) have received by being involved with NEC. Benefits range from improved cognition, muscle coordination, speech and social attributes. There is also a sense of community and belonging that many of the participants and their families have been able to achieve due to this extraordinary program. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application so that many more children and adults with disabilities can be serviced so that their lives can continue to improve. Thank you for your time and consideration. Best, Judy Crouse 1 Packet Page -395- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Emily Buersmeyer[ndgirl1997 @yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:41 PM To: StrainMark; diannnbert@colliergov.net; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Permit for Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer for the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past two years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to me and to our community. I am sixteen years old and I call NEC my second home because NEC is like a family volunteers, riders, and their families included. NEC not only teaches lessons to their riders but also to their young volunteers like myself. NEC has changed my life because I get to see how much the riders get out of their lessons every week. I work with one rider can now sit up on his own and feed himself all because of his lessons at NEC. With these permits NEC will have more lessons for some amazing new riders and change their lives forever. Thank you, Emily Buersmeyer 1 Packet Page-396- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Amy Melson[amilu @comcast.net] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 1:43 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; philbrougam @colliergov.net; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; mikerose@colliergov.net Subject: Naples equestrian Attachments: photo.PNG; ATT00001.txt Dear CCPC members, Please support the NEC expansion and continual use permit. In doing so you will continue to allow my son Benjamin all the benefits of therapeutic horseback riding in a center that would benefit all of collier and surrounding counties. Thanking you in advance for your support. Amy Melson 1 Packet Page-397- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:19 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under FLorida Law, e-maiL addresses are pubLic records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a pubLic records request, do not send eLectronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Sheila Abraham [mailto:saabraham1 gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:05 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein @colliergov.net; pmidneyacolliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy program and have been for the past year. I have worked in healthcare (primarily psychiatry and psychology)for over 20 years and I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC?s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Sincerely, Sheila A. Abraham Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-398- 1 0/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Colin Gordon [cgordon827 @gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:38 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; karenhoniak @colliergov.net; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC's Conditional Use Permit Dear Member of the CCPC, My wife and I have been volunteers at the Naples Equestrian Challenge for more than six years and in that time we have seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted and therapy programs provide to all of its participants. We have also witnessed the benefits to the participants expand and improve as NEC has grown in that time. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. We urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. The permit will enable NEC to reach out and provide many new programs and benefits to current and future participants. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to the community in Collier County. Thank you, Neil and Ellen Gordon 1 Packet Page -399- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Rita Torok[ritike78 @yahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:45 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a participant in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past two years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants my daughter Vanessa. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. l urge you to approve NEC"s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to my family and to our community. Thank you, Rita Torok 1 Packet Page-400- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Kim Minarich [kminarich @naplesequestrianchallenge.org] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 2:48 PM To: Wayne Arnold; StrainMark Subject: Fwd: PRCA RESPONSE TO NEC See response from pine ridge member below. Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "calhoun1943@aol.com" <calhoun1943(a,aol.com> Date: September 4, 2013, 2:46:00 PM EDT To: "pineridgenaples @hotmail.com" <pineridgenaples@hotmail.com>, "rrcervelli @yahoo.corn" <rrcervelliayahoo.com>, "susan@thebrackenteam.com" <susan@thebrackenteam.com>, "bed2585(aIhotmail.com" <bed2585 @hotmail.corn>, "tvensel@gmail.corn" <tvensel(ZZgmail.com>, "roadrunner333(a @ mail.com" <roadrunner333( gmail.com>, "georgesutcliffena,hotmail.com" <georgesutcliffe @hotmail.com>, "libbvcooleyl @aol.com" <libbycooleyl(&,aol.com>, "ypapenfuss @hotmail.corn" <ypapenfuss(a�hotmail.com>, "kaufman02(@comcast.net" <kaufman02@comcast.net>, "don @dgarrettconstruction.com" <don a,dgarrettconstruction.com>, "di emmancomcast.net" <di emmacomcast.net>, "ginsberg.joan @gmail.corn" <ginsbergjoanna,smail.com>, "info@postures.com" <info@postures.com>, "dml @thelivingstonfirm.com" <dmlathelivingstonfirm.com>, "imaginegiftstore@aol.com" <imagineaiftstore @aol.com>, "1ayhnbuild-ddci.com" <jayh@build-ddci.com>, "brougraff@gmail.com" <brougraff @gmail.com>, "moreschnick1 @comcast.net" <moreschnickl(&comcast.net>, "mamk72@comcast.net" <mamk72 @comcast.net>, "mjeannekopp @aol.corn" <mjeannekopp(a�aol.com>, "iswaltbillig @embargmail.com" <Iswaltbillig @embargmail.com>, "treeplateau@earthlink.net" <treeplateau(a�earthlink.net>, "jmathew@thestrategyco.com" <jmathew(a)thestrategyco.com>, "phdhmn@gmail.com" <phdhmnna,gmail.com>, "meaganh@wkmj.co" <meaganhna,wkm .co>, "meschunko@hotmail.com" <meschunko @hotm ail.com>, "danka ahrabi c`,r yahoo.corn" <danka ahrabi @yahoo.com>, "girardin@comcast.riet" <girardin@comcast.net>, "iaybarrvcolinn gmail.com" <jaybarrvcolin,@amail.com>, "j ulianjjaviermd@aol.com" <julianjjaviermd@aol.com>, "gemini23us @vahoo.com" <gemini23usayahoo.com>, "sallyleachl(&gmail.com" <sallyleachl@gmail.com>, "naplesbuys @aol.com" <naplesbuys(a,,aol.com>, "margotkaufmar acomcast.net" <margotkaufman@comcast.net>, "courtbracken(a�hotmail.com" <courtbracken @hotmail.com>, "sscliftonsaaol.com" <sscliftons @aol.com>, "weissdev@@aol.com" <weissdev@aol.com>, "ottokopfs(a.aol.com" <ottokopfs@aol.com>, "ashlevtunkle@vahoo.com" <ashlevtunkle(a,vahoo.com>, "ellieloving@aol.com" <ellielovinuaaol.com>, "donnatavlor412(aiaol.com" <donnataylor412@aol.com>, "mmpenamdr&,,yahoo.com" <mmpenamd(cr�,yahoo.com>, "myriamcolson @msn.com" <myriamcolson@msn.com>, "gwoods@lawfirmnaples.com" <gwoodsalawfirmnaples.com>, "j onespacks1 na,yahoo.com" <jonespacks1(a�vahoo.com>, "hkw7147agmail.com" <hkw7147@gniail.com>, "chris(a,bensencapital.com" <chri s@bensencapi tal.corn>, "gnewl @me.corn" <gnewl @me.com>, "j eanglen@centurylink.net" <jeanglen@centurvlink.net>, "clademan@hahnlaw.com" <clademan@hahnlaw.com>, "Iklane I(a,aol.com" <lklane1(a aol.com>, "schahwan tvgnaples.com" <schahwan(aitvgnaples.com>, "susan.slater0(aigmail.com" 1 Packet Page-401- 10/8/2013 8.A. <susan.slater0@gmail.com>, "jillianssmitha54gmail.com" <iillianssmithaa,gmail.com>, "ibsereno @aol.com" <ibserenoe,aol.com>, "ksdeshet2@aol.com" <ksdeshet2(a,aol.com>, "Jason t lewis @yahoo.com" <Jason t lewis@vahoo.com>, "adavishasson @gmail.com" <adavishasson@gmail.com>, "kjoynn,pgicommercial.com" <kjoyna pgicommercial.com>, "prettytulipa,,aol.com" <prettytulip@aol.com>, "michele @hogan.org" <michelea,hogan.org>, "pjj@naplesmarina.com" <pii(a,naplesmarina.com>, "ricochet312 @gmail.com" <ricochet312@,gmail.com>, "scott@tuttleinsure.com" <scott@tuttleinsure.com>, "ckelly @flinttrust.com" <ckelly @flinttrust.com>, "garyhazz@aol.com" <garyhazz(2 aol.com>, "thumperdoc@gmail.com" <thumperdoc@,gmail.com>, "moorcbm@aol.com" <moorcbm @aol.com>, "ms @msadesign.com" <msaa msadesign.com>, "myhouseofpaineOa,comcast.net" <myhouseofpainecomcast.net>, "den2335 @aol.com" <den2335Oaaol.com>, "iwaltzer@comcast.net" <jwaltzer@comcast.net>, "ndavenport3Oa,gmail.com" <ndavenport3 @mail.com>, "ielong@naples.net" <jelong @naples.net>, "adrian.visanyahoo.com" <adrian.visanOa,yahoo.com>, "myovanovalgcu.edu" <myovanov @fgcu.edu>, "suebApremiermail.net" <sueb(a,premiermail.net>, "fxrp @embargmai 1.com" <fxrp @embargmail.corn>, "msr21062(&,comcast.net" <msr21062(a,comcast.net>, "karntnerl @comcast.net" <karntnerla,comcast.net>, "barw@msn.com" <barw(cr�,msn.com>, "mlyooper @aol.com" <mlvooperOa aol.com>, "shellvbeaOa webtv.com" <shellvbea @webtv.com>, "maria9959@mac.com" <maria9959Oa,mac.com>, "alisonkalb @aol.com" <alisonkalb(a�aol.com>, "anti gen(a,bnnorth.net" <antigen @bnnorth.net>, "nickhalecolor@comcast.net" <nickhalecolor@comcast.net>, "brendabranda @gmail.com" <brendabranda @gmail.com>, "rictalford@a,earthlink.net" <rictalford @earthlink.net>, "brendabrendaa,gmail.coin" <brendabrenda @gmail.com>, "7100deha,gmail.com" <7100deh @gmail.com>, "mk1wwnaol.corn" <mklww@..aol.com>, "mschalfin @aol.com" <mschalfin @aol.com>, "ewdos`,aol.com" <ewdose,aol.com>, "ampeep123@aol.corn" <ampeep123@,aol.com>, "pesa23@aol.com" <pesa23@aol.com>, "tunana,turrell- associates.com" <tuna @turrell-associates.com>, "dabbys5@aol.com" <dabbys5(a�aol.com>, "mindadonovan@comcast.net" <mindadonovan(ct�,comcast.net>, "kppytlik@aol.com" <kppytlik @aol.com>, "garywgrant @nail.com" <garvwgrant@gmail.com>, "tedbill@pelicanacres.com" <tedbillrib,pelicanacres.com>, "pest8888 @comcast.net" <pest8888 @comcast.net>, "clarkdjensen @aol.com" <clarkdjensen(aaol.com>, "lambertdelong @yahoo.com" <lambertdelongayahoo.com>, "dgoodman5l(a,,comcast.net" <dgoodman51 @comcast.net>, "noreenbawn8(ahotmail.com" <noreenbawn8 @hotmail.com>, "wdkeith@ckblaw.com" <wdkeith @ckblaw.com>, "dzviblemanAohnrwood.com" <dzvibleman(a johnrwood.com>, "alberto(anewarchitectura.com" <alberto @newarchitectura.com>, "mccontinoegmail.com" <mccontino @gmail.com>, • "nfn01995 @naples.net" <nfn01995@naples.net>, "kimconnors8100,comcast.net" <kimconnors810Ocomcast.net>, "georgedburt@aol.com" <georgedburt@aol.com>, "tompeek @aol.com" <tompeek @aol.com>, "merrittlisak @aol.corn" <merrittlisak@aol.com>, "vicmolter(c�aol.com" <vicmolter @aol.com>, "sstarmaneaol.com" <sstarman@aol.corn>, "floridaseller @gmail.com" <floridaseller@gmail.com>, "peter@warehouseservices.net" <peter@warehouseservices.net>, "cm1b422@,aol.com" <cm1b422 @aol.com>, "rl egrant(a,comcast.net" <rl egrantOa,comcast.net>, "samiller34 @aol.com" <sami11er34a,aol.com>, "dhei11954 @aol.com" <dhei11954(a aol.com>, Kim Minarich <kminaricha,naplesequestrianchallenge.org>, "lr1850 @aol.com" <Ir1850@aol.com>, "reainacpena@gmail.com" <reginacpenaOa,gmail.com>, "parjimjan @comcast.net" <parjimjan(a�com cast.net>, "pjones146702(&,comcast.net" <piones146702(abcomcast.net>, "robert@investorattorneys.com" <robert@,investorattorneys.com>, "rachie62654@aol.com" <rachie62654 @aol.com>, "harriette.nollerncovenantnaples.com" <harriette.noller(c,covenantnaples.com>, "slandreevl @comcast.net" 2 Packet Page -402- 1 0/8/201 3 8.A. <slandreevl @comcast.net>, "ddondonna@aol.com" <ddondonnanaol.com>, "marianneluchl@gmail.com" <marianneluchl@amail.com>, '1 irons 17@comcast.net" <j irons 17@comcast.net>, "marnichur@yahoo.corn" <marnichur@vahoo.com>, "sajbacc@comcast.net" <sajbacc@comcast.net>, "jmtiernev3ngmail.com" <jmtiernev3@gmail.com>, "susanff@comcast.net" <susanff@comcast.net>, "dlhirs a,embargmail.com" <dlhirs @embargmail.com>, "goldprod2 @aol.com" <goldprod2@aol.com>, "arbitrage@comcast.net" <arbitrage @comcast.net>, "ssusangal@aol.com" <ssusanga1 aol.com>, "hbgator(a.aol.com" <hbgator @aol.com>, "georgek(a,osuproperties.com" <georgekna,osuproperties.com>, "dash2@mindspring.com" <dash2@mindspring.com>, "mkande105@comcast.net" <mkande105 @comcast.net>, "bebelennon@aol.com" <bebelennon@aol.com>, "cheffy6(a,aol.com" <cheffy6@aol.com>, "ironduke36 @comcast.net" <ironduke36 @comcast.net>, "dbraverman @me.com" <dbraverman@me.com>, "marvlvnnhill@comcast.net" <marvlynnhill(a,comcast.net>, "cbcarpentry@mindspring.com" <cbcarpentry@mindspring.com>, "timmins05@comcast.net" <timmins05@comcast.net>, "prougraff@aol.com" <prougraff@aol.com>, "amegan20 @nmail.com" <amegan20 s,gmail.com>, "sallvleach(n,comcast.net" <sallyleach @comcast.net>, "danielcbetz@aol.com" <danielcbetz@aol.com>, "mscire@comcast.net" <mscire@comcast.net>, "coastcommercial @comcast.net" <coastcommercial@comcast.net>, "wpearsonnagfpac.com" <wpearson(a,gfpac.com>, "evensel@,gmail.com" <evensel(a,gmail.com>, "j ennydamelio@comcast.net" <jennydamelio @comcast.net>, "carolinemartino@comcast.net" <carolinemartino@comcast.net>, "rebeccamfisher @vahoo.com" <rebeccamfisher @yahoo.com>, "susan@thedevitos.com" <susan @thedevitos.com>, "sewfin@comcast.net" <sewfin@comcast.net>, "ukoo12 @aol.com" <ukoo12(a,aol.com>, "bcpecaro gmail.com" <bcpecaro @gmail.com>, "vindepasquale @.comcast.net" <vindepasquale@comcast.net>, "iwvnn@sunshineace.com" <jwynn @sunshineace.com>, "ihillis@pobox.com" <jhillis@pobox.com>, "bmaulsby@proscan.com" <bmaulsby@proscan.com>, "tmoran0@comcast.net" <tmoran0 @.comcast.net>, "wdearbornl(a,comcast.net" <wdearbornl @comcast.net>, "rvnals @comcast.net" <rynals@comcast.net>, "j oemolter(a,gmail.com" <joemolter@gmail.com>, "edpackard33(ciiaol.com" <edpackard3 3 @aol.com>, "julieprice @comcast.net" <j uliepri ce@comcast.net>, "agalbut@aol.com" <agalbut@aol.com>, "rdaun30 comcast.net" <rdaun30@comcast.net>, "pbaradine@comcast.net" <pbaradine @comcast.net>, "oldhamolde@aol.com" <oldhamolde@aol.com>, "caribbean149na,aol.com" <caribbean149a.aol.com>, "lmbundy @embargmail.corn" <1mbundy(a)embargmail.com>, "rlrbm @msn.com" <rlrbm@,msn.com>, "pinelake2(a,earthlink.net" <pinelake2@earthlink.net>, "cindydreyfuss@,gmail.com" <cindvdreyfuss(a)gmail.com>, "rachelnoca@comcast.net" <rachelnoca @comcast.net>, "mvettes@msn.com" <mvettes@msn.com>, "classiccarslou@yahoo.com" <classiccarslou @yahoo.com>, "ed 1948@comcast.net" <ed1948@comcast.net>, "mgatzl @aol.com" <mgatzl aol.com>, "njbrissonamindspring.corn" <njbrisson(umindspring.com>, "beaumonthouse@embargmail.com" <beaumonthouse @embargmail.com>, "dougartlsense.com" <doug@rtlsense.com>, "fredheald@embargmail.com" <fredhealdaembargmail.com>, "cpa6fam @comcast.net" <cpa6fama,comcast.net>, "alien fami1y03(a>comcast.net" <alien familv03@comcast.net>, "henkmorelisse@comcast.net" <henkmorelisse(a,comcast.net>, "viacaribe @vahoo.com" <viacaribe@vahoo.com>, "eschmieding(a)embargmail.corn" <eschmieding(dembargmail.com>, "michellegray@embargmail.com" <michellegray(aembargmail.com>, "meleamon(a4gmail.com" <meleamon @gmail.com>, "garvbladich 1@embargmail.com" <garybladichl(a,embargmail.com>, "sallylappin(a,comcast.net" <sallvlappinna,comcast.net>, "Iranaples 1@aol.com" <lranaples 1 aol.com> Subject: Re: PRCA RESPONSE TO NEC 3 Packet Page -403- 10/8/2013 8.A. If you have"dual sympathies"why did you take a position at all?You might have been better off abstaining. Original Message--- From: Pineridge Civic Association <pineridgenaples(a�hotmail.com> To: rrcervelli<rrcervelliayahoo.com>; susan <susanathebrackenteam.com>; bed2585 <bed2585@hotmail.com>;tvensel<tvensek amail.com>; roadrunner333 <roadrunner333Ca.gmail.com>; georgesutciiffe<georgesutcliffe a(�hotmail.com>; libbycooleyl <libbvcoolevl na aol.com>; ypapenfuss <voapenfuss(a hotmail.com>; kaufman02 <kaufman02(a?comcast.net>; don <don(a�dgarrettconstruction.com>; djemma<diemmaa,comcast.net>; ginsberg.joan <oinsbero.ioan(a�gmail.com>; info <infoapostures.com>; dml <dmla.thelivingstonfirm.com>; imaginegiftstore<imaginegiftstorea,aol.com>;jayh <iavha,build-ddci.com>; brougraff <brougraffagmail.corn>; moreschnickl <moreschnickl a(,comcast.net>; mamk72 <mamk72acomcast.net>; mjeannekopp <mieannekoon aol.com>;jswaltbillig <jswaltbillig(&embaromail.com>; treeplateau <treeplateau(a�earthlink.net>;jmathew <jmathew cr thestrategvco.com>; phdhmn <phdhmnagmail.com>; meaganh <meaganh(a�wkmi.co>; meschunko <meschunko(a,hotrnail.com>; danka_ahrabi<danka ahrabiavahoo.com>; girardin <girardinacomcast.net>;jaybarrycolin <iavbarrvcolinagmail.com>;julianjjaviermd <iulianiiaviermdeaol.com>; gemini23us <gemini23us(a�yahoo.com>; sallyleach1 <sallvleach1 @gmail.com>; naplesbuys <naplesbuvsa,aol.com>; margotkaufman <margotkaufman(c�comcast.net>; courtbracken <courtbracken(a hotmail.com>; sscliftons <sscliftonsaaol.com>;weissdev<weissdevaaol.com>; ottokopfs<ottokopfsaaol.com>; ashleytunkle <ashleytunkle(ayahoo.com>; ellieloving <ellielovinc aaol.com>; donnataylor412 <donnatavlor412(a.aol.com>; mmpenamd <mmoenamd( vahoo.com>; myriamcolson <myriamcolson(cD_msn.com>; gwoods<owoods(a lawfirmnaples.com>;jonespacksl <ionespacksl(a�yahoo.com>; hkw7147 <hkw7147(a.gmail.com>; chris<chrisabensencarital.com>; gnewl <gnewlame.com>;jeanglen <jeanglen c(D,centurylink.net>; clademan <clademan(a?hahnlaw.com>; Iklanel <Iklanel(a�aol.com>; schahwan <schahwannatvgnaples.com>; susan.slater0 <susan.slater04gmail.com>;jillianssmith <iillianssmithAgmail.com>;jbsereno <ibsereno a(�aol.com>; ksdeshet2 <ksdeshet2aaol.com>;jason_t_lewis<iason t lewis(a�yahoo.com>; adavishasson <adavishasson(a)gmail.com>; kjoy<kioy(c�pgicommercial.com>; prettytulip <prettvtulip(a�aol.com>; michele<michele(a�hooan.orq>; pjj <pii(�naplesmarina.com>; ricochet312 <ricochet312(agmail.com>; scott<scotttuttleinsure.com>; ckelly<ckelly(a flinttrust.com>; garyhazz<garvhazz(a�aol.com>; thumperdoc<thumperdoc(a gmail.com>; moorcbm <moorcbm anaol.com>; ms<ms(a)msadesign.com>; myhouseofpaine<mvhouseofpaine(o)comcast.net?; calhoun1943 <calhoun1943(a,aol.com>; den2335 <den2335aol.com>;jwaltzer<jwaltzer(a)comcast.net>; ndavenport3 <ndavenport3qmail.com>;jelong <ielonq a(�naples.net>; adrian.visan <adrian.visanvahoo.com>; myovanov<myovanovafgcu.edu>; sueb<suebna premiermail.net>;fxrp<fxrpaembargmail.com>; msr21062 <msr21062(a�comcast.net>; karntnerl <karntner1acomcast.net>; barw<barw a(�msn.com>; mlyooper<mlyooper(c�aol.com>; shellybea <shellvbeawebtv.com>; maria9959 <maria9959( mac.com>; alisonkalb <alisonkalb(c�aol.com>; antigen <antigen(a bnnorth.net>; nickhalecolor<nickhalecolor(c�comcast.net>; brendabranda <brendabranda(a�Qmail.com>; rictalford <rictalford(a�earthlink.net>; brendabrenda <brendabrenda(a�gmail.com>; 7100deh <7100deh(a�omail.com>; mklww<mklwweaol.com>; mschalfin <mschalfin(c aol.com>;ewdos <ewdosaol.com>; ampeep123 <ampeep123(aaol.com>; pesa23 <pesa23(a�aol.com>; tuna<tunaaturreil-associates.com>; dabbys5 <dabbys5(a�aol.com>; mindadonovan <mindadonovancomcast.net>; kppytlik<kppvtlikc aol.com>; garywgrant<oarywgrantagmail.com>; tedbill <tedbill(�pelicanacres.corn>; pest8888 <pest8888(a comcast.net>; clarkdjensen <clarkdiensena,aol.com>; Iambertdelong <Iambertdelonqayahoo.com>; dgoodman5l <dgoodman51Acomcast.net>; noreenbawn8 <noreenbawn8(o�hotmail.com>; wdkeith <wdkeith(a�ckblaw.com>; dzvibleman <dzvibleman(a�iohnrwood.com>; alberto <alberto(a�newarchitectura.com>; mccontino <mccontino(cr�gmail.com>; nfn01995 <nfn01995(c�naples.net>; kimconnors810 <kimconnors810(c�comcast.net>; georgedburt <georgedburtt aol.com>; tompeek<tompeek(a�aol.com>; merrittlisak<merrittlisak(a,aol.com>; vicmolter <vicmolteraaol.com>; sstarman <sstarman(a�aol.com>; floridaseller<floridaseller(a�gmail.corn>; peter <peter(a�warehouseservices.net>; cm1b422 <cmlb422(cr�aol.com>; rlegrant<rlegrant( comcast.net>; samiller34 <samiller34aaol.com>; dhei11954 <dhei11954( aol.com>; kminarich <kminarich(a�naplesequestrianchallenge.org>; Ir1850 <Irl850t7o,aol.com>; reginacpena <reginacpena(a�gmail.com>; parjimjan<parjimian(ccomcast.net>; pjones146702 <pjonesI46702 aacomcast.net>; robert<robertainvestorattorneys.corn>; rachie62654 <rachie62654(a7aol.com>; harriette.noller<harriette.nolleracovenantnaples.com>; slandreevl 4 Packet Page-404- 10/8/2013 8.A. <slandreevl(a.comcast.net>; ddondonna<ddondonnaCa?aol.com>; marianneluch1 <marianneluch1(a7gmail.com>;jirons17 <jironsl7acomcast.net>; marnichur <marnichur(c�vahoo.com>; sajbacc<saibaccacomcast.net>;jmtierney3 <jmtiernev3agmail.com>; susanff<susanffoacomcast.net>; dlhirs <dlhirs(a�embaramaii.com>; goldprod2 <goidprod2aaol.com>; arbitrage<arbitrage(c comcast.net>; ssusangal <ssusangal(a�aol.com>; hbgator <hbgator(a,aol.com>; georgek <georgek(c�z osuprooerties.com>; dash2<dash2(a�mindsprinq.com>; mkandel05 <mkandel05acomcast.net>; bebelennon <bebelennona,aol.com>; cheffy6<cheffv6Ca.aol.com>; ironduke36 <ironduke36 a(.comcast.net>; dbraverman <dbravermaname.com>; marylynnhill <marvIvnnhill(a�comcast.net>; cbcarpentry <cbcarpentrv(a.mindsprinq.com>; timmins05 <timmins05(a�comcast.net>; prougraff<prougraff(a aol.corn>; amegan20 <amegan20(a)gmail.com>; sallyleach <sallyleach(a�comcast.net>; danielcbetz<danielcbetzc aol.com>; mscire <mscire(a?comcast.net>; coastcommercial <coastcommercial comcast.net>; wpearson <wpearson(a)gfpac.com>; evensel<evensel(a,gmail.com>;jennydamelio <jennvdamelio(a�comcast.net>; carolinemartino <carolinemartinona comcast.net>; rebeccamfisher<rebeccamfisher(a�vahoo.com>; susan <susan(a7thedevitos.com>; sewfin <sewfinacomcast.net>; ukool2 <ukool2aaol.com>; bcpecaro <bcr ecaroagmail.com>; vindepasquale<vindepasquale oc comcast.net>;jwynn <jwvnnc1 sunshineace.com>;jhillis <jhillisapobox.com>; bmaulsby<bmaulsbv(a�proscan.com>; tmoran0 <tmoran0(c�comcast.net>; wdearbornl <wdearborn1acomcast.net>; rynals<rynals(a�comcast.net>; joemolter<ioemolter(agmail.corn>; edpackard33 <edoackard33 ct7r.aol.com>;julieprice <iulieprice(a�comcast.net>; agalbut<agalbutaaol.com>; rdaun30 <rdaun30(a�comcast.net>; pbaradine <pbaradinena.comcast.net>; oldhamolde <oldhamoldeaaol.com>; caribbean149 <caribbean149 cCD.aol.com>; Imbundy <Imbundvaembargmail.com>; rlrbm <rlrbmamsn.com>; pinelake2 <pinelake2(a,earthlink.net>; cindydreyfuss <cindydrevfuss(a,gmail.com>; rachelnoca <rachelnoca(a�comcast.net>; mvettes <mvettesamsn.com>; classiccarslou <classiccarslou(a.vahoo.com>; ed1948 <ed1948(cilcomcast.net>; mgatzl <mgatz1aaol.com>; njbrisson <nibrissonamindsprinq.com>; beaumonthouse <beaumonthouse aembargmail.com>; doug <doug(a,rtIsense.com>; fredheald <fredheald(cr�embaramail.com>; cpa6fam<cpa6fam(a�comcast.net>; allen_family03 <alien familv03(a�comcast.net>; henkmorelisse<henkmorelisse(c�comcast.net>; viacaribe <viacaribe avahoo.com>; eschmieding <eschmiedinci embargmail.com>; michellegray <michellegrav(a embargmail.com>; meleamon <meleamon(kgmail.com>; garybiadich1 <garybladichI aaembargmail.com>; sallylappin <salivlappin(a comcast.net>; Iranaples1 <Iranaples1(a,aol.com> Sent: Wed, Sep 4, 2013 11:43 am Subject PRCA RESPONSE TO NEC Dear Fellow Residents; In an effort to keep you informed I have attached the 2 documents which explain the PRCA stance on the NEC request to expand. We understand both sides of the issue and have"dual sympathies". However, we are governed by Covenants, Restrictions, By-Laws and Resolutions that cannot be ignored. We hope you appreciate the time, effort, consideration and deliberation that took place before reaching this conclusion. Peter Pytlik, President Pine Ridge Civic Association 5 Packet Page-405- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:39 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Permit Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Stacy Hamburg [mailto:bizeemomCacomcast.net] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:25 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Permit Dear Chairman Strain; Our daughter, Jaclyn, is a rider with the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy program. She has been riding since she was 23 months old. The movement (gait) of a horse is the reason her Physical therapist suggested equine therapy to help her learn to walk. She began taking her first steps the month after she began equine therapy. Her speech and communication skills have also been positively impacted through this program. Jaclyn is now 10 years old and making wonderful gains in her development. We have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. A sensory trail riding experience will be an incredible addition to the therapy programs. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset for individuals in Collier County with therapeutic needs. Thank you, Stacy and Mike Hamburg Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page-406- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:39 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use Permit Application Importance: High Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-maiL addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address reLeased in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From:Tony Felice [mailto:afelice023Ca earthlink.net] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:28 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; karenhomiak@collilergov.net; barrymklein@ colliergov.net; pmidnevOcolliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Conditional Use Permit Application Importance: High Dear member of the CPCC: I have personally experienced the many benefits of the NEC equine therapy program. In the fall of 2012 I suffered a serious accident which left me without the use of my left hand and arm in addition to various other injuries. My hand therapist in Naples suggested the NEC program at the end of February, and I was accepted. Through their patience, guidance and encouragement, I regained my balance, confidence, and the use of my limbs. I am truly indebted to the NEC. There are many more children and adults who could benefit from this important therapy. That includes the returning veterans who have a program of their own at NEC. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application which is before you. The proposal doesn't even begin to approximate a commercial venture. It is a healing center, a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to me as well as our community. Sincerely, Fee4 9e- 'e€ee Mary Beth Gorke-Felice 2290 Carrington Court, #204 1 Packet Page -407- 10/8/2013 8.A. Naples, FL 34109 860/974-9836 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-408- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Pat Kurzenberger[pkurzen @me.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:41 PM To: StrainMark Cc: Missy Saracino Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge permet Dear Mr. Strain, I am a Naples resident and a volunteer at the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past ten years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Thank you, Patricia Kurzenberger 1 Packet Page -409- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Eric Lemboris[eric @vantagesearchgroup.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:50 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past 11 years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community. Sincerely, Eric Lemboris President Vantage Search Group,Inc. 239-596-7373 Tel 239-236-0755 Fax Member-National Association of Physician Recruiters Member-National Coalition of Healthcare Recruiters 30/9-ANTAGE SEARCH GROUP HAMS/WIDE HEALTHCARE RECRU[i MEt T "20 years of quality healthcare recruitment" • 1 Packet Page -410- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Emily Glass[eaglass5998 @eagle.fgcu.edu] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:08 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past two years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to (me/my family) and to our community. I am particularly proud to be a part of this organization as I would like to make this my career one day. Thank you, Emily Glass 1 Packet Page -411- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Kim Minarich [kminarich @naplesequestrianchallenge.org] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:49 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: FW: Supporting the Conditional Use Permit Dear CCPC Members, I am forwarding the email below on behalf of Ms.Canfield. Thank you for your consideration, Kim Kim Minarich Executive Director NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 T: 239.596.2988 F: 239.514.2908 www.NaplesEquestrianChallenge.org Mark your calendars now for NEC's 8th Annual Bootstrap Boogie Barn Dance to be held Saturday, November 9, 2013. Please click on the link below to learn more about the event, event sponsorships and buy your tickets! http://www.naplesequestrianchallen ge.ora/news-events/2013-boot-strap-boouiie-barn-dance/ Confidentiality Notice:This E-mail message,including any attachment,is for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review,use,disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient,please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message. From: Loretta Canfield [mailto:locanfield(ayahoo.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:20 PM To: Kim Minarich Subject: Supporting the Conditional Use Permit Mrs. Minarich, I am a resident in Pine Ride. I am absolutely in support of the Conditional Use Permit for NEC and expanding the facilities as well as enriching the neighborhood. Over the past five years I have watched the program grow without cause for concern in parking or traffic. The beauty of the Pine Ridge neighborhood, in part, is the equestrian presence and variety in homes and its unique individuality. Napes Equestrian Challenge is an organization that brings so much good to the community and helps so many children and adults, the thought of it not being able to expand and help others is a shame. If NEC 1 Packet Page-412- 10/8/2013 8.A. can not benefit from the Conditional Use Permit, and continue to grow and assist the community, what will become of it? The proposed site and expansion clearly has taken into consideration the parking and architectural landscaping design to incorporate the facility and keep within the Pine Ridge beauty. Pine Ridge does indeed have beautiful homes and well manicured lawns. It also has run down and unsightly homes with stained facades and unkempt lawns. The Conditional Use Permit will allow NEC to grow and enhance a small area of the community and bring a much needed and used organization, with only the best intentions and programs, to a desirable area of the neighborhood. With the Conditional Use Permit the NEC facility can maintain its high level of performance while still keeping within a desirable size to assist participants including the community. I have received and read the letter that was sent to the owners in Pine Ridge. It was both disheartening and unfortunate that a few who are suddenly concerned with the structure and growth of NEC would lash out with such harshness and unnecessary bitterness. It is most unfortunate to see a few in the community have such animosity from such a positive enriching venture. I am in favor of the Conditional Use Permit. Loretta Canfield I 2 Packet Page-413- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Wilma Proctor[wilmahpr @me.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 3:55 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Mr Strain I am a volunteer and contributor for Naples Equestrian Challenge equine Therapy program and have been for the past 12 years. I have personally seen the many benefits of NEC Equine assisted Therapy program provided to it's participants. There are many More children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to our community Dick and Wilma Proctor 8665 Bay Colony Dr Naples, Fl 34108 Sent from my iPad 1 Packet Page-414- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Marlene Foord jdfoord @embargmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:10 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Support for NEC's expansion and Conditional Use Permit Dear Mr. Strain, We have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. Our family friend,Jaclyn Hamburg,has benefitted greatly from equine therapies. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. A sensory trail riding experience will be a positive experience for riders. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset for individuals in Collier County with therapeutic needs. Thank you in advance, Marlene and Dominic Foord 1 Packet Page -415- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:38 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mark/ 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Tiffany [mailto:tiffanvCaisonl.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:30 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymkleinecolliergov.net; pmidnev@colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Member of the CCPC: I have proudly served on the Board of Directors for the Naples Equestrian Challenge for the past 2 years. I am fortunate to have experienced the benefits that NEC's activities and therapy programs provide to its participants and this community. Collier County is a wonderful place to raise a family and I am proud to call it home. I was born and raised here, left for college, started a family and knew exactly where I wanted to raise my children. I am blessed to have two beautiful,healthy girls but as I watch the families and participants of NEC's programs it is very apparent that not every family is as fortunate as mine. Being connected to NEC has opened my eyes to the limitations that Collier County has to offer to persons with disabilities. I have spoken with many young couples that question their ability to live in Collier County due to the lack of funding and support for their disabled children.Not allowing NEC to expand and offer more support and love to those in need would simply be a tragedy. There are many children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help but we need more space. I hope you strongly consider to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. This is a vital program for this community and receives excellent recognition that helps Collier County grow in its success. "Choog¢Building Char-beta over Building Walth."Donna Maefiinn Tk a vt,R, g ffany Lehman Owner/Agent 1 Packet Page-416- 10/8/2013 8.A. Insurance Source of Naples, Inc. a Division of Crosslet Insurance Services 3765 Airport Road North Suite 201 Naples,FL 34105 (239)325-3030 phone (239)325-3033 fax www.isonl.com Like us on facebookl Your Source for Protection Home,Auto, Commercial,Life,Health and Long Term Care CONFIDENTIALITY NOTE: The information contained in this e-mail is legally privileged and confidential and is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above and for the legitimate business purpose of Insurance Source of Naples,Inc. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient,you are hereby notified that any dissemination,distribution or copy of this e-mail is strictly prohibited.If you have received this e-mail in error,please immediately notify us by return e-mail. Coverage cannot be bound or altered via an email message. Proud Representative of ISEKURITY. �� ..» S2 ; -w TRAVELERSI Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page -417- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: StrainMark Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:48 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Mork. 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-maiL addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From: Jay Hillis [mailto:ustax @embaramail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:42 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein @colliergov.net; pmidnev@colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Members of the Collier County Planning Commission: I would like to write in support of the NEC(Naples Equestrian Challenge)conditional use permit. The daughter of our friends has been greatly helped by the therapeutic benefits of their program and the expansion of the facility will allow more beneficiaries to participate and also allow enhanced benefits to the current special needs children and adults. Thank you for taking the time to read this. czoa(0o.04d1' Enrolled Agent Accredited Tax Advisor Accredited Business Accountant QuickBooks Certified ProAdvisor US Tax Accounting, Inc. 869-B 97th Avenue North Naples, FL 34108 239 597-7009 Phone 239 597-7460 Fax Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 Packet Page -418- 10/8/2013 8.A. • _ .,. . i 7 i = > I. • 1 11 % tt 1 ) r') • - . III t .....- . i • .i : a . C 4.,..--, ..-- '' ''tc -- -- . - - .:•.1......._ • — . '" 1,—..... . i.•;...3 it 7 q s-.? "*S"):::- • • il-::: 174 1 1P...- 17%•' ';'' . •,A, rl...' .-" 7--7. . • ,• od • i--= 131 ,c_.%\iii. ''':;••••'" 4 c' '''‘'' ,,,.. -). 4. • -0--. --_. '6- • . __ . - • . -- :., .: r.f•. . - i -6 o . • , ;,.,' 5 0,•:: - TZI .C.7, 411 -7- -. .t . 1 -:,-) •,-,w-.---t•.'..-;1;;,,,,-.i, •g 0 : . * 4 * Packet Page -419- 10/8/2013 8.A. E-mail addresses for the Collier County Planning Commissioners: c a 1- Mark Strain, Chairman markstrainPcolliergov.net ;= -" ,l:, Diane K. Ebert dianeebert(�colliergov.net Philip E. Brougham philbrougham(Ecolliergov.net \ P . - Karen Homiak karenhomiak@colliergov.net ! , -p -,. Barry M. Klein barrymklein@colliergov.net 1 '' p ry ra c Paul Midney pmidney@colliergov.net 1 rte, ozi Mike Rosen mikerosen(a�colliergov.net -, .. ' Email address for the Pine Ridge Civic Association: pineridgenaples@hotmail.com If you wish to register your opsicili to the impact on our neighborhood, please send an email to the Planning Commissioners and to the Pine Ridge Civic Association. We have provided suggested language for your consideration below. Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissio rs: chi/ Sort.LLe ':0-L. 6 , C My name s , and I live at faddressl in the Pine Ridge g residential neigh.Mod. It is my understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. I am unable to attend that public hearing, but I hope you will consider this email in my absence. W i e I appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is my belief that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. I respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. Packet Page-420- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Charlotte Newell jcharlotte.newell @yale.edu] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 5:19 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Expansion Dear Mr. Strain, I am a volunteer and the sister of a rider at Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs. My brother has been riding for the past six years, and I have been volunteering for just as many. I have personally seen the countless benefits of NEC's therapy in both my brother and all of his friends who take part in the organization. From this therapy,my brother, who has Down Syndrome,has improved his core muscle tone, speech, and most importantly,his confidence. It is so important that children and adults with special needs have access to this life-changing therapy. So much good will be done and so many more people will be reached if the planned expansion is allowed to go forth. I strongly, strongly urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is the most amazing place I have ever been given the chance to spend my time and the difference that it has made in mine,my family's,my brother's,his friends' lives, and to the community is insurmountable. Thank you, Charlotte Newell Yale Class of 2016 1 Packet Page -421- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: clarke @alzsupport.org Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:53 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge-Sep 5th Hearing Importance: High Dear Mr. Strain, I am writing in support of Naples Equestrian Challenge in general, and in support of the application for the conditional use permit for 194 and 182 Ridge Drive. Over the course of the last year, Naples Equestrian Challenge has partnered with us, The Alzheimer's Support Network, to establish a therapy program for individuals with Alzheimer's disease or related dementia. The results have been remarkable. The staff and volunteers at Naples Equestrian Challenge are superb. Currently, the program is restricted to a covered riding area. While much can achieved in such a setting, what they have proposed could offer so much more. In partnership with the Naples Botanical Gardens, we have developed a "sensory tour" for Alzheimer's patients. Being able to stroll through botanical gardens on special guided tours has provided moments of peace and tranquility that last through out the day. Likewise, the use of the additional lots for riding trails would no doubt expand the tools available to the Naples Equestrian staff, and enhance the experience of the patients in the program. I strongly support their request. The Alzheimer's Support Network has been serving Collier County families free of charge for the past 31 years. It is my pleasure to be of service to you and Commission in any way possible. If you have issues or concerns, or if you have ideas on how we can better service the community, please contact me directly. Best Regards, Clarke Clarke Pollard Executive Director Alzheimer's Support Network 660 Tamiami Tr.N., Suite 21 Naples,FL 34102 (239)262-8388 www.alzsupport.org Original Message Subject: We need your help and support! From: Missy Saracino <Missysaracino @naplesequestrianchallenge.org> 1 Packet Page-422- 10/8/2013 8.A. Date: Wed, September 04, 2013 12:47 pm To: Good Afternoon, If you have not already and you have the time, please send an email. They are being counted and the numbers do matter. Letters need to be sent by the end of the business day today. We hope to see you tomorrow morning at 9am. Wearing an NEC shirt is recommended. Having a large group of NEC supporters at the meeting can definitely be in our favor. Dear NEC Family, NEC has an extraordinary opportunity to expand its equine-assisted activities and therapy programs, but we need your help and support! NEC was successful in receiving a Collier Development Building Grant in the amount of$520,000 for the purchase of the property immediately to the south of our current site. The grant funds of $520,000 are equal to the appraised value of this lot. NEC has entered into a sales contract with the property owner for the purchase price of $650,000 and have secured an additional $130,000 bridge loan from a very generous supporter and donor to make up the difference from the appraised value to the purchase price. The sales contract has two contingencies: 1) that NEC is successful in obtaining the grant funds equal to the appraised value of the property, or $520,000; and 2) NEC is successful in obtaining a Conditional Use Permit from the County for 182 Ridge Drive (the lot under contract). NEC is required to have a Conditional Use Permit so that it may conduct its equine-assisted activities and therapy programs on that property. NEC currently has a Conditional Use Permit on 206 Ridge Drive. This is the property we conduct our programs on now where the office, arena and barn are located. Some of you may know that a few years back, we built a Sensory Trail around the paddocks to the south of the arena. These paddocks and sensory trail are located on 194 Ridge Drive, which NEC purchased several years ago. However, we have never been able to use the Sensory Trail for our riders because NEC does not have a Conditional Use Permit for 194 Ridge Drive. NEC is permitted to have horses on this property but not able to conduct therapy lessons, etc. Therefore, NEC has filed an application for a Conditional Use Permit for both 194 and 182 Ridge Drive, which will be reviewed and voted on by the Collier County Planning Commission on Thursday, September 5 at 9am. Several Pine Ridge Estate homeowners, particularly those with homes directly across Ridge Drive from NEC, are adamantly opposed to NEC expanding to the lot to the south and are actively campaigning against the approval of the Conditional Use Permit. Their voices will be heard at the upcoming Collier County Planning Commission meeting. HERE IS HOW YOU CAN HELP! 1. Attend the CCPC this Thursday, Sept. 5 at 9am meeting will be held at the Board of County Commission Chamber, Collier County Government Center, Administration Building, 3`d Floor, 3299 Tamiami Trail East. Just your attendance shows your support, but you may also wish to speak in support of NEC as well. A short comment expressing your support will be very helpful. Or if you are not able to attend the meeting, you can? 2 Packet Page -423- 10/8/2013 8.A. 2. Send the following email, which you may take great liberty in editing to make it personal to you, to the following members of the Collier County Planning Commission: a. Mark Strain, Chairman markstrain@icolliergov.net b. Diane K. Ebert dianeebert(lcolliergov.net c. Philip E. Brougham Dhilbrougharn(lcolliergov.net d. Karen Homiak karenhomiak(lcolliergov.net e. Barry M. Klein barrymklein(acolliergov.net f. Paul Midney pmidneyc colliergov.net g. Mike Rosen mikerosen(lcolliergov.net Please send an email to express your support for NEC's expansion and Conditional Use Permit to each of the above members of the CCPC no later than Wednesday evening. Here is a suggested email for your consideration and personalization: Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer/participant for/in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past years. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine- assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants (member of my family). There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC?s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to (me/my family) and to our community. Thank you, (Signed) I have attached a copy of NEC proposed site plan as well as a description of NEC, its growth, its programs and collaborations along with the proposed uses of the new facilities. If you should have any questions, or need additional information, please do not hesitate to contact me at any time. All of us at NEC truly appreciate you and any assistance you can provide to help us grow and expand our services. Many, many thanks, Kim Minarich Executive Director NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE 206 Ridge Drive Naples,FL 34108 T:239.596.2988 F:23 9.514.2908 www.NaplesEqu estrianChall enge.ora Mark your calendars now for NEC?s 8th Annual Bootstrap Boogie Barn Dance to be held Saturday, November 9, 2013. Please click on the link below to learn more about the event, event sponsorships and buy your tickets! http:/hwww.napieseonestrianeha llen2e.orginews-events/2013-b©ot-strap-boogie-barn-dance/ 3 Packet Page-424- 1 0/8/201 3 8.A. Confidentiality Notice: This E-mail message,including any attachment,is for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review,use,disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient,please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message. Thank you, Missy Melissa Saracino Program Director Naples Equestrian Challenge 206 Ridge Drive Naples, Florida 34108 Tel: + 1 239 596 2988 Fax: + 1 239 514 2908 missysaracinoC a�napleseauestrianchallenge.orq www.naplesequestrianchallencte.orq wwvv.facebook.com/NaplesEquestrianChallenge Mark your calendars now for NEC's 8th Annual Bootstrap Boogie Barn Dance to be held Saturday, November 9, 2013. Please click on the link below to learn more about the event, event sponsorships and buy your tickets! http://www.napleseaues reanchallenge.orp/news-events/2013-boo - strap-boogie-barn-Glance/ Confidentiality Notice:This E-mail message,including any attachment,is for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use,disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient,please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message. 4 Packet Page-425- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Jan Hillis Uan @ustaxacc.comi Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:51 PM To: StrainMark Subject: NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CENTER Dear Member of the CCPC; We have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. Our family friend, Jaclyn Hamburg, has benefitted greatly from equine therapies. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Permit application before you. A sensory trail riding experience will be a positive experience for riders. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset for individuals in Collier County with therapeutic needs. Janis Hillis 1 Packet Page -426- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Carol and Hans Muller[handcmuller @msn.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 5:04 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymdlein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Members of the Collier County Planning Commission Ladies and Gentlemen: My husband, Hans Muller, and I, Carol Muller have been volunteers with the Naples Equestrian Challenge for a total of 22 years. Hans began volunteering in 2000 and I began in 2004. During this time,we have seen many children and adults with special needs improve both physically and mentally while having enjoyed bonding with the horses in the programs. It has been a rewarding experience for both of us. The programs are well managed and the facilities and horses are exceptionally maintained. There are many people with special needs in Collier County that could be helped by NEC and the vital therapy programs available. We urge you to approve NEC's Conditional Use Application before you on September 5. Thank you, Hans and Carol Muller 1128 12th Avenue North Naples, Florida 34102 • 1 Packet Page-427- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Jenny Sutton [jenny @suttonco.org] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 4:53 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge I have been a supporter of the Naples Equestrian Challenge for many years. The benefits their equine-assisted programs provide are truly spectacular. Please approve their request for Conditional Use Permits and assure not only the future of their service to our community, but the NEC's ability to increase benefits to those that really do thrive from their programs. Sincerely; Jenny W. Sutton 1 Packet Page-428- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Bob Hardy[rahardyjr @gmail.com] '` -` Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 5:25 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge Dear Mr Strain; The purpose of this letter is to ask for your support for the Naples Equestrian Challenge's (NEC) expansion and Conditional Use Permit. The NEC's many programs have significantly benefitted hundreds of special-needs children and adults. They have recently implemented a special program to assist the rehabilitation of returning veterans who have been wounded in combat. Speaking as a disabled veteran of the VietNam conflict,I can assure you that any support we can give these brave soldiers' return to a productive life inures to the benefit of both the individual and the community. Because The Naples Equestrian Challenge is providing such an admirable and inspiring service to our community I urge you to approve the expansion and Conditional Use Permit. Thank you for your kind attention, Robert A. Hardy LtCol USAF (ret) 1 Packet Page -429- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Abigail Morton [amorton54 @gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 6:48 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: NEC Dear Member of the CCPC: I am a volunteer/participant for/in the Naples Equestrian Challenge equine therapy programs and have been for the past year. I have personally seen the many benefits NEC's equine-assisted activities and therapy programs provide to its participants. There are many more children and adults with special needs in Collier County that NEC can help by providing this vital therapy. I urge,you to approve NEC?s Conditional Use Permit application before you. It is a wonderful program and a tremendous asset to myself and several families, and to our community. Thank you, Abigail Morton 1 Packet Page -430- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Curtis L Stephens[curtislstephens @aol.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:05 PM To: StrainMark Subject: Conditional use permit-NEC My name is Curt Stephens. I live at 1263 28th ave N in Naples. I have been volunteering at NEC for about 7 years in both the equine riding activities and in the maintenance and repair of the facility itself. I'm sure others have indicated the many benefits of this program to residents of our area. I hope also that you have been made aware of the excellent condition of our existing facilities. We have made use of extensive landscaping, irrigation from well water and regularly scheduled landscape and yard maintenance, regular mowing and up to date repair and maintenance of our buildings,houses and barns. This is in strong contrast to the appearance of empty lots in the area. I would like to address any concerns about increase traffic, increased noise and increases in lights that might result from the proposed use. First, in terms of increased traffic. Our classes are organized into 30 minute rides with about 15 minutes for mounting/dismounting and take place at sessions that last 3or 4 hours. The horses are rested on at least two days a week. Classes have on average 3-4 riders. A 30 % or 40% increase in riders would only mean 1 or 2 more riders per class. Even with increased need for volunteers, there would be only a very modest increase in traffic. In terms of increased noise. This equine activity is a very low noise program. Horses do not respond well to sharp or loud noises. Students are taught and encouraged to ride quietly. There are no bands, loud cheering etc. None of the equipment utilized generates noise. Noise in this area is the result of loud cars, motorcycles, trucks,etc on Goodlette Frank, Centre and Ridge roads. In terms of increased lights. It is my understanding that the intended use involves housing, training and some increase in areas used for trail rides. These are low elevation activities and are not stadium or additional large arenas and therefore only require small incremental increases in lightning. In addition, the lot in question has a large number of very large trees that would provide significant shielding of any increased lights. In summary, I would strongly recommend and ask that the conditional use change be granted. I believe this change will enhance Naples in general, the Pine Ridge area in particular and would eliminate yet another unsightly undeveloped lot. NEC will continue to be a good neighbor and provide a most vital service to so many of our residents. Regards, Curt Stephens Sent from my iPad 1 Packet Page -431- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Cindy Bombard [CBombard @swfl-cpa.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 6:00 PM To: StrainMark; Ebert Diane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymklein @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; RosenMike Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge-In favor of Expansion Attachments: BCC.docx Dear BCC, Please review my attached letter in favor of approving the Conditional Use permit for Naples equestrian Challenge. Regards, Cindy Bombard, CPA President/Owner *r Bombard Cent Wiled Publ c Accountant The office will be dosed September 19, 2013 through September 27, 2013. Your trusted accounting solutions partner 27499 Riverview Center Blvd., Suite 224 Bonita Springs, FL 34134 Office: 239-596-2677 Fax: 239-244-8291 www.swfl-cpa.com This notice is required by IRS Circular 230, which regulates written communications about federal tax matters between tax advisors and their clients.To the extent the preceding correspondence and or any attachment is a written tax advice communication, it is not a full "covered opinion."Accordingly,this advice is not intended and cannot be used for the purpose of avoiding penalties that may be imposed by the IRS. This message (including any attachments) may contain confidential client information.The information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. If you are not the addressee or the employee or agent responsible to deliver this email to its intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any review, use, dissemination, distribution, disclosure,copying or taking of any action in reliance on the contents of this information is strictly prohibited. 1 Packet Page -432- 10/8/2013 8.A. September 4,2013 Board of County Commissioners 3299 Tamiami Trail East Naples, FL 34109 Dear Board of County Commissioner, My name is Cindy Bombard and I have been involved with Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC)for almost 20 years; as a parent of a participant, Board member and volunteer. I first heard about NEC through my pediatrician in 1995,when my daughter was diagnosed with cerebral palsy. I thank God every day for the doctor that told me about NEC. My daughter started riding at NEC when she was 18 months old;she was barely crawling at that time.Within months she started standing on her own,taking steps and eventually walking on her own. The"therapy"continued to help her with balance, speech,fine and gross motor skills.The best part about it was that she didn't think it was therapy. It was fun and the fact that she could do what so many other kids her age couldn't do, made her feel like she was on top of the world.She could not ride a bike, but she could ride a horse!These are just some of the physical benefits that come with equine therapy. There are no words to describe the emotional benefits such as confidence,self-esteem and sense of accomplishment that NEC provided to my daughter.She was a participant at NEC until she turned 16 years old.She loves horses and still rides today. NEC gave her a lifelong passion for horses and riding. I have served on the Board as Secretary for over 10 years with many different Board members, including with Caroline Martino,former President/Executive Director of NEC. Over the years,various Boards discussed acquiring the adjacent property at 182 Ridge Drive.This should not be a surprise to the Martino's. I would also like to add that the Martino's chose to buy their home on Ridge Drive when Caroline Martino was President of NEC.She saw,first-hand,the benefits and the need in our community and helped it grow until she was asked to resign.The Martino's seem to be leading the campaign against NEC's expansion,which makes me feel like there are issues beyond property values behind their passionate opposition.They were once equally as passionate about NEC, its mission and its growth! NEC has a great mission and serves many individuals in need in the community. NEC has always considered the residents of Pine Ridge and will continue to do so. It would be an injustice to deny the Conditional Use Permit request. I ask you to consider all other facts and recommend a favorable decision for NEC and the participants it serves. I thank you in advance for taking the time to read my letter. Respectfully, eindg J3andee id Packet Page -433- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: vwrecycler @gmail.com Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 6:56 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; philbroughham @colliergov.net; HomiakKaren; barrymklien @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; milerosen @colliergov.net Subject: Petition CU-PL20110000719 Douglas and Carlotta Rubel Residents and property owners at 41 Caribbean Rd. 34108. Respectfully request That the Naples equestrian challenge conditional use petition be denied. Thank you PEACE TO YOU 1 Packet Page -434- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: Tompeek @aol.com Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 7:56 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrymkiein @colliergov.net; RosenMike; pmidney @colliergov.net Cc: pineridgenaples @hotmail.corn Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Dear Planning Commissioners: Our names are Tom and Nora Peek, and we live at 90 East Avenue in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood. It is our understanding that Naples Equestrian Challenge's expansion proposal and request for conditional use approval will be presented to the Planning Commission on September 5, 2013. We are unable to attend the public hearing, but we hope you will consider this email in our absence. While we appreciate and admire the good service that NEC provides, it is our opinion that NEC's proposal to expand to nearly 7 acres and approximately 632 participants per year is not compatible with the Pine Ridge single-family residential neighborhood. We respectfully request that the conditional use petition be denied. Thank you. 1 Packet Page -435- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMichael From: vwrecycler @gmail.com Sent: Wednesday, September 04, 2013 6:56 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; philbroughham @colliergov.net; HomiakKaren; barrymklien @colliergov.net; pmidney @colliergov.net; milerosen @colliergov.net Subject: Petition CU-PL20110000719 Douglas and Carlotta Rubel Residents and property owners at 41 Caribbean Rd. 34108. Respectfully request That the Naples equestrian challenge conditional use petition be denied. Thank you PEACE TO YOU 1 Packet Page -436- 10/8/2013 8.A. SawyerMic hael From: StrainMark Sent: Thursday, September 05, 2013 5:02 PM To: SawyerMichael Subject: FW: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Importance: High Hi Mike. Here is a letter I just received on an upcoming agenda item that you are the planner on. Please distribute as you would any such correspondence. Ma s-k, 239.252.4446 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-maiL address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic maiL to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. From Barrie C Fitz-Gerald, Ph.D. [mailto:bfitzgerald(a�barringersystems.com1 Sent:Thursday, September 05, 2013 5:00 PM To: StrainMark; EbertDiane; BroughamPhil; HomiakKaren; barrvmklein(acolliergov.net; prnidney(lcolliergov.net; mkerosen(a�colliergov.net Cc: pineridgenaplesna hotmail.com `u Subject: RE: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Importance: High Another issue...is that we already have another stable on the other side of Center..just drove by off of Goodlette...this is a mess right now without any extensions. Many cars in the NEC...BUT About 30 cars in the other stable north of NEC....THIS IS CRAZY....AND THEY WANT MORE... -1 61..0? From: Barrie C Fitz-Gerald, Ph.D. i mailto:bfitzgerald @barringersystems.com) Sent:09/03/2013 12:57 PM To: 'markstrain @colliergov.net'; 'dianeebert@colliergov.net'; 'philbrougham @colliergov.net'; 'karenhomiak @colliergov.net'; 'barrymklein @colliergov.net'; 'pmidney @colliergov.net'; 'mkerosen @colliergov.net' Cc: 'pineridgenaples @hotmail.com' Subject: Naples Equestrian Challenge, Petition CU-PL20110000719 Our names are Dr. Barrie and Nilsa Fitz-Gerald along with our 2 children and their puppy Alli We reside in the Pine Ridge residential neighborhood...just steps away from the above captioned at 254 Ridge Drive. Many years ago...NEC did petition us to allow their "use" to be allowed in our neighborhood. Initially, it was to be a "small" operation. Well, it has grown considerably...and now they are projecting the operation to grow "exponentially" . 1 Packet Page -437- 10/8/2013 8.A. Under the current operation...we see cars parked along the streets for varying events...this poses to be a "huge" (to quote a local Kia advertisement) problem. Are they kidding...632 PARTICIPANTS a year. No that's not correct...are they suggesting that these folks will only attend 1 day...lf we allow 632 participants a year...we are looking at 632 potential participants each week or month....AND TO GROW BY 30% (and for what period...there will be no end) Think about this....632 participants...even if for just one day they show up all at one time....ARE YOU KIDDING?!! WE BELIEVE THEY HAVE GONE BEYOND THEIR ORIGINAL FOCUS AT THE PRESENT TIME....AND HEREBY RECOMMEND THAT THE `CONDITIONAL' USE PETITION BE DENIED. THIS IS NOT A "COMMERCIAL AREA"...and we believe although shrouded in a "non-profit" cloak is "QUASI-COMMERCIAL". If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck....it's a duck. Respectfully submitted, Barrtie aura'Min /tz--04 ah graxxze c6N,g _pexedet eHealth Visioneering www.eHealthVisioneering.com CODESMART UNIVERSITY Relate, Individualize, Strategize, Maximize (Aliscripts, Cisco, McKesson and Microsoft Certified) 0: 239.514.7777 Fax: 239.514.7779 Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 Packet Page-438- 10/8/2013 8.A. 26D )) Wednesday, September 18,2013 1) NAPLES DAILY NEWS • • NOTICE OF MEETING NOTICE OF MEETING NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A RESOLUTION Notice is hereby given that the Board of County Commissioners, as the Board of r • Zoning Appeals, of Collier County will hold a public hearing on Tuesday,October 8, 2013, in the Boardroom, Third Floor, Administration Building, Collier County Government Center, 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, Florida. The meeting will begin at 9:00 A.M.The title of the proposed resolution is as follows: A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS OF COLLIER COUNTY, m FLORIDA, PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CONDITIONAL USE TO s ALLOW THERAPEUTIC EQUESTRIAN RIDING AND STABLING ON PROPERTY LESS THAN 20 ACRES IN SIZE WITHIN A RURAL AGRICULTURAL ZONING DISTRICT s PURSUANT TO SUBSECTIONS 2.03.01.A.1.C.19 AND 2.03.01.A.1.C.24 OF THE f COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED ON THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF GOODLETTE-FRANK ROAD AND CENTER STREET IN SECTION 10, TOWNSHIP 49 SOUTH, RANGE 25 EAST,COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA. (PETITION CU-PL20110000719) A copy of the proposed Resolution is on file and available for public inspection in the Collier County Clerk's Office, 4th floor, Administration Building, Suite 401, Naples,Florida. NOTE: All Persons wishing to speak on any agenda item must register with the County Administrator prior to presentation of the agenda item to be addressed. Individual speakers will be limited to 3 minutes on any item. _The selection of an individual to speak on behalf of an organization or group is encouraged. If recognized by the Chair, a spokesperson for a group or organization may be allotted 10 minutes to speak on an item. Persons wishing to have written or graphic materials included.in the Board agenda packets must submit said material a minimum of 3 weeks prior to the respective public hearing. In any case, written materials intended to be considered by the '? Board shall be submitted to the appropriate County staff a minimum of seven days Asto prior to the public hearing. All material used in presentations before the Board will become a permanent part of the record. ' • Any person who decides to appeal a decision of the Board will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefore, may need-to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. - If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the Collier County Facilities Management Department, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Building W, Naples, Florida 34112, (239)252-8380. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the County Commissioners'Office. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA • GEORGIA A.HILLER,ESQ.,CHAIRWOMAN DWIGHT E.BROCK,CLERK By: Teresa Cannon,Deputy Clerk (SEAL) No.2000491 Sentemher 18.2013 • Packet Page -439- •