The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 10/08/2013 Item #16A16 10/8/2013 16.A.16. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Recommendation to approve a Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida supporting the County's applications to Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) for Long Range Budget Plan Requests for Beach Renourishment Projects for Fiscal Year 2014-2015. This action maintains the County's eligibility for State Cost Share Funding for future renourishment projects. OBJECTIVE: To approve a Resolution supporting the County's applications to the FDEP for Long Range budget Plan Requests for Fiscal Year 2014-2015. CONSIDERATIONS: The Natural Resources Department continues to seek funding from FDEP to augment existing tourist taxes which have been budgeted for these projects. These requests, if approved by FDEP, will provide partial funding for Collier County projects consisting of (1) Collier County Beach Renourishment which includes the Naples Beaches, Vanderbilt Beach and Park Shore Beach; and (2) The South Marco Beach Renourishment Project and monitoring costs. A brief description of the projects is as follows: 1. The Collier County Beach Renourishment Projects (Naples Beaches, Vanderbilt Beach and Park Shore Beach) — This project will request state funding to replenish sand and restore the beach erosion conditions throughout the various beach shorelines areas including the FDEP required physical and biological monitoring. 2. The South Marco Beach Renourishment Project constructed in FY 2013-2014 and required monitoring costs. FISCAL IMPACT: Approval of this resolution is required as a condition of submittal to request long range State funding to renourish Collier County beaches and Inlet Monitoring. Tourist Development Tax funds are currently available and budgeted in Beach Renourishment Fund 195 to accomplish this work. State approval will lead to future state cost share participation on these projects through FDEP grant agreement and contract. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no impact to the Growth Management Plan related to this action. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been approved as to form and legality and requires majority vote for approval. —CMG RECOMMENDATION: Approve a resolution of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida supporting the County's applications to the FDEP for Long Range Budget Plan Requests for Fiscal Year 2014-2015. Prepared By: J. Gary McAlpin, P.E., Coastal Zone Management,Natural Resources Department Attachments: Resolution; Local Government Funding Request Packet Page -1516- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 16.16.A.16.A.16. Item Summary: Recommendation to approve a Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida supporting the County's applications to Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP)for Long Range Budget Plan Requests for Beach Renourishment Projects for Fiscal Year 2014-2015. Meeting Date: 10/8/2013 Prepared By Name: HambrightGail Title: Accountant,Coastal Zone Management 9/27/2013 10:44:08 AM Approved By Name: LorenzWilliam Title: Director-CDES Engineering Services,Comprehensive Date: 9/27/2013 12:16:00 PM Name: PuigJudy Title: Operations Analyst, GMD P&R Date: 9/27/2013 1:16:21 PM Name: LaPierreBarbara Title: Management/Budget Analyst,Transportation Administr Date: 9/27/2013 2:51:46 PM Name: McAlpinGary Title: Director-Coastal Management Programs,Coastal Zon Date: 9/27/2013 2:58:41 PM Name: KearnsAllison Date: 9/27/2013 3:51:42 PM Name: GreeneColleen Title:Assistant County Attorney,County Attorney Date: 9/27/2013 4:33:58 PM Packet Page-1517- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Name: MarcellaJeanne Title: Executive Secretary,Transportation Planning Date: 9/30/2013 8:30:15 AM Name: KlatzkowJeff Title: County Attorney Date: 9/30/2013 11:38:04 AM Name: IsacksonMark Title: Director-Corp Financial and Mgmt Svs,CMO Date: 9/30/2013 11:38:16 AM Name: OchsLeo Title: County Manager Date: 10/2/2013 11:56:13 AM Packet Page-1518- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FY 2014/15 Local Government Funding Request Beach Management Projects Project Name(Same as previous phase): Collier County Beach Nourishment Project Project Description: (Should be consistent year to year with annual updates. Include county, location with reference to range monuments, brief project history and upcoming activities.) The Collier County Beach Renourishment Project is located on the southwest Florida coastline in Collier County between Florida Department of Environmental Protection monuments R-22 to R- 30.5 (Vanderbilt Beach), R-43 to R-55 (Park Shore) and R-58A to R-79 (Naples Beach). The County requests funding consideration for the 2013/2014 The Collier County shoreline was nourished in 1995/1996 with approximately 1.2 million cubic yards and again in 2005/2006, using approximately 665,000 cubic yards of hydraulic fill. The main goal of the 2005/2006 project was to avoid environmental impacts such as hardbottom coverage and a design project life of six years. The borrow area (T1) was located approximately 33 miles north-northwest of Vanderbilt Beach and was chosen due to the coarser sand availability which avoids nearshore hardbottom coverage. A one acre artificial reef was constructed to satisfy permit mitigation requirements in 2006, but no impacts to the hardbottom have been observed. The performance of the beach in avoiding hardbottom coverage has exceeded permit expectations, and the results of 7 years of physical monitoring indicate that the beach can be widened without a significant increased risk of hardbottom impacts. The 2006 project was very successful, except downdrift of inlets thru the seventh year of the project life. The table below list the supplement fills projects that occurred during the period since the 2006 nourishment. There is additional sand in the next nourishment project to address the historic and future deficit down drift of the inlets. In addition, disposal practice at Doctors Pass has been modified. Table 1. Supplemental Fill by Truck haul and By Pass Volumes Doctors Pass Bypass to R58A to R59 except as noted 2009 36,000 cy disposed R60 to R62 2013 —36,000 cy disposed downdrift Clam Pass Bypassed South 2007 22,000 cy 2012 7,635 cy South of Clam Pass north of R47 2011 7,836 cy South of Doctors Pass R58A to R59 2010 2,650 cy 2011 22,293 cy 2012 10,700 cy at Naples Resort(R63) Vanderbilt Vicinity R-27 2012 12,000 cy Packet Page -1519- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Table 2. Fill volume and limits for each segment of the proposed renourishment project. ' ° Project Reach Project fps Design Pay Weight Limits Volume(c.y.) (ton) Project A Vanderbilt R-22+300 to R-22+300 to 60,000 90,000 R-30+500 R-25+500 Pelican Bay R-30+500 to 35,000 52,500 R-37 Project A Sub-total 95,000 142,500 Project B Park Shore R-43+500 to R-47+500 to 75,000 112,500 R-54+400 R-50 R-64+500 to Naples R-58A-480 to R-68+200, 80,000 120,000 R-79 R-72+600 to R-79 Project B Sub-total 155,000 232,500 Total 250,000 375,000 It is anticipated that the Collier County Beach Renourishment Project will go to construction in the fall of 2013. The FDEP has approved Collier County's request for a modification to the JCP Permit Number 0222355-001, and two contractors have been selected to perform the work. The 2013 project will be conducted using an upland sand source. The 2013 design volume is based on the quantity of sand needed to re-establish the design berm using the 2006 project design. The permit limits of the Vanderbilt project area are approximately R-22 to R-30.5, with fill being placed south of R-25 + 500. The permit limits of the Park Shore project area are approximately R-43+500 to R-54+400 with a gap between R-47+500 and R-50. The permit limits of the Naples Beach project area are approximately R-58A to R-79. There are two gaps at R-64+500 to R-68+200 and R-72+600 to R-79. The amount of fill needed to bring the historic project areas back to design standard is approximately 380,000 cubic yards based upon the 2013 monitoring survey, with some areas having a larger construction template compared to the 2006 design. Based on a tough dredging market, Collier County has decided to build a 215,000 cy truck haul project (250,000 cy with Pelican Bay) this year, followed by another project in a few years to complete the six year project. This year's County project will be supplemented by sand dredged from Doctors Pass and placed immediately south of the Pass through R-59. The equilibrium toe of fill will not encroach upon the hardbottom and will be landward of the 2006 permitted equilibrium toe of fill. Table 2 provides the fill limits and sand Packet Page-1520- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. volumes for each segment of the proposed renourishment project. Selected locations will have a berm built one foot higher to account for sea level rise. Pelican Bay reach is not eligible for funding from Collier County since it is private. It will be fully funded by the Pelican Bay Community. There was no intent to build this reach by the County, until the County decided to assist the Community in this manner. The Community will pay for all engineering, permitting and construction to build this segment. The Pelican Bay fill limits extend from approximately R-30.5 to R-37,where 35,000 cy will be placed. The 2013 design volume takes into account the impacts incurred from Tropical Storm Debby which passed through Collier County on June 25, 2012. The renourishment project will be constructed using an upland sand source. The project has three approved upland sand sources: Immokalee (Stewart), Witherspoon (Vulcan), and Lake Wales (Cemex), Immokalee was selected as the sole supplier based on price and distance. The construction window will be September 15 to May 31, which avoids peak sea turtle nesting season. Mobilization is targeted for mid- September. Approximately 165,000 will be funded by FEMA for impacts suffered by T.S. Fay and another 52,000 cy is being reviewed for T.S. Debby by FEMA. This application includes design request for reimbursement of the costs associated with the 2013 beach renourishment permitting and construction since it will be conducted prior to state funding disbursements. Additionally, this application includes annual physical beach monitoring and biological monitoring for the nearshore hardbottom. Packet Page-1521- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. BAREFOOT BEACH r• wr,Li w WIGGINS PASS �� TALLAHASSEE JACKSONVILLE DELNOR-WIGGIN - �)(.. PROJECT STATE PARK &' i NT$ LOCATION ORLANDO TAMPA ATLANTIC . OCEAN HENDRY CO. '0 BOLA V.= LEE RATON VANDERBILT CO. VANDERBILT / I BEACH 00 � GULF N 700000 ti,:i) OF ,J MEXICO '4 R_0 GULF MONROE CO. OF w MEXICO o a PELICAN , ■ PELICAN ° BAY BAY Cif` a PARK w • SHORE Rao CLAM PASS iii o , SR 8s N 880080 0 i N 880000 PARK SHORE .. DOLT SR 886 20' CONTOUR % �. \\ .w , NAPLES SR 856 NAPLES 111. N 880000 OM N 860000 Mel im SR 84 Ili LEGEND: \ o t I f PROJECT LIMITS LI PROPOSED FILL AREAS " GULF PELICAN BAY FILL AREA OF R70 FDEP MONUMENTS MEX/CO I 1. .0-T ROYAL , NOTES: GORDON PASS 90 1. COORDINATES ARE IN FEET BASED ON FLORIDA STATE o PLANE COORDINATE SYSTEM, q EAST ZONE,NORTH AMERICAN lS 0 4 000 8000 DATUM OF 1983(NAD83). m w o Imo[ J 2. FILL WIDTHS ARE NOT TO SCALE. a: k 1� -' GRAPHIC SCALE IN FT Figure 1. Location Map Use of Requested Program Funds: Funds requested for FY14/15 will be used for physical and environmental monitoring. Additionally, reimbursement for funds expended for the permitting, design and P&S and construction costs associated with the renourishment in FY 13/14 are requested in this application. Packet Page-1522- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Local Government Contact Table 3. Local Government Contact Name Title Email Gary McAlpin Manager,Coastal Zone Management GaryMcAlpin @colliergov.net Clint Perryman Project Manager,Coastal Zone ClintonPerryman @colliergov.net Management Address 1: 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Phone: 239-252-2966 Address 2: Naples,FL 34104 Fax: 239-252-2950 Mapping-Maps area provided as attachments. Maps should be to scale at a minimum of 1"=200' The Enclosed Mapping elements include: ❑ Project Boundary with Critically Eroded Shoreline ❑ Range Monuments ❑ Beach Access and Parking-Primary and Secondary, including access widths ❑ Public Lodging Establishments- locations and length of property boundaries along project shoreline or street frontage ❑ Comprehensive Plan/Current Land Use designations of Commercial and Recreational Facilities and associated property boundaries along the project shoreline Length of Project Boundary in Feet(total restored length) 38,956 ft. Vanderbilt Beach: Approximate Shoreline Length: 8,204 ft. Park Shore Segment: Approximate Shoreline Length: 11,412 ft. Naples Segment: Approximate Shoreline Length: 19,340 ft. Eligibility: Access Points and Public Lodging Establishments: Access Points and Public Lodging Establishments: See Attachment 1 for detailed listing and maps. Table 4. Cost Sharing Summary Total Eligible Commercial, Reach Recreational& Shoreline Length (ft.) Public Lodging Vanderbilt 7,451 2,656 Park Shore 3,940 987 Naples 18,410 2,220 Sub Total 29,801 5,863 Total Project Length 38,956 ft Eligible Shoreline 76.50% 15.05% State Cost Share% * 38.25% Licenses for the hotels are listed in Attachment 2 Packet Page-1523- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Schedule and Budget: (Include estimated phases for 10 years and estimated project costs for 5 years) Table 5. Schedule and Budget _ Year Proposed Description Total Method Estimated Federal State Cost Local Cost Cost Cost Share Share Share Design, Design Permitting,Bio. $350,000 $201,802 $56,686 $91,512 2013/2014* Monit.& Survey Nourishment& Construction Construction $11,100,000 $6,400,000 $1,797,750 $2,902,250 Serv. Phys,Biological, Monitoring Turtles,Birds $330,000 $0 $126,225 $203,775 2014/2015 Design JCP Permitting $110,000 $0 $42,075 $67,925 Phys,Biological, Monitoring Turtles,Birds $336,600 $0 $128,750 $207,851 2015/2016 Design P&S and Bidding $150,000 $0 $57,375 $92,625 Phys,Biological, Monitoring Turtles,Birds $343,332 $0 $131,324 $212,008 2016/2017 Nourishment& Construction Construction $12,614,000 $0 $4,824,855 $7,789,145 Serv. Phys,Biological, 2017/2018 Monitoring Turtles,Birds $350,199 $0 $133,951 $216,248 Post Phys, Monitoring Biological, Sea $357,203 $0 $136,630 $220,573 2018/2019 Turtles Design P&S and Bidding $150,000 $0 $57,375 $92,625 Phys,Biological, Monitoring Turtles,Birds 2019/2020 Nourishment& Construction Construction Serv. 2020/2021 Monitoring Phys,Biological, Turtles,Birds Phys,Biological, Monitoring Turtles,Birds 2021/2022 Design P&S and Bidding Monitoring Phys,Biological, Turtles,Birds 2022/2023 Nourishment& Construction Construction Serv. 2023/2024 Monitoring Phys,Biological, Turtles,Birds *Reimbursement of funds are requested from the 2013/2014FY Packet Page-1524- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Severity of erosion: Criterion will be calculated by the Department. Please provide narrative and any data that should be considered in addition to the Department's database. The Department previously stated that the average erosion rate in this area is 0.5 feet per year and provided Collier County with one point for this criterion(FDEP 2012). Threat to Upland Structures Criterion will be calculated by the Department. Please provide narrative and any data that should be considered in addition to the Department's database. In the 2013/2014 Local Government Funding Request Project Assessment the Department stated: The 25-year total combined total storm tide elevation for the project area is 9.9ft, NGVD (Dean/Chiu, 1989). (The Dean's high frequency equivalent erosion model, CCCL does not use the total combined total storm tide elevation developed for the CCCL program.) The length of developed property is approximately 28,000 feet. The length of property containing threatened structures is approximately 2,600 feet. The 5-year post- construction monitoring report with the July 2011 surveys identifies the hot spots within the project area, where the beach widths are narrower than the design beach widths. These areas are located between the following monuments: R-26.5 —R-27.5, R-51.5 —T- 54, R-58A — T-58.5 and T-62 — R-63.5. Structures threatened by the 25-year storm are approximately located between monuments: R-26 &R-26.5, R-52 &R-54, R-55 &R-56, and R-62 &R-64 (2008 aerial photos of the project area in ARCMAP were used to locate the structures. Shoreline lengths of developed property and property containing threatened structures were measured from the aerial photos.)Hence,the ranking score for threat to upland structures is one(1)points (FDEP 2012). Recreational and Economic Benefit: The percentage of linear footage of properties within the project boundaries zoned commercial, recreational, or Public Lodging Establishment, or the equivalent, in the current local government land use map 15.05% Availability of Federal Funds: Is the project Federally authorized by WRDA? No Provide date of authorization expiration. Does this project phase have a Federal Project Cooperative Agreement, or similar for the current phase? Provide a copy of the document. No Federal cost share percentage available for this project: NA Is this project funded through FEMA for storm repairs? Yes Vanderbilt, Park Shore, and Naples have FEMA Category G funds due to damage as a result of Tropical Storm Fay. This has been included within the 5-year estimated budget under the Federal Cost Share column at 75% of FEMA eligible cost. It is essential that construction be funded by the State in a timely manner, since Federal (FEMA) funds are time limited with restricted extension rules. Additionally, Collier County is working on securing FEMA funding for additional storms, such as T.S. Debby,which have impacted the shoreline in previous years. Packet Page-1525- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. A copy of the signed Project Worksheet is included with this application as Attachment 3. Local Sponsor Financial and Administrative Commitment Is funding for the project in the local sponsor's 10-year comprehensive financial plan? Yes Please provide copy or web link to the plan. http://www.coll i ergov.net/modules/showdocument.aspx?documents d=49023 Is funding provided through a source established by referendum? Yes Please provide a copy or web link to the referendum. A copy of the referendum that established the Collier County Tourist Development Tax is included with this application as Attachment 4. Is funding provided by a third party? No What is the percentage of total project costs provide by the third party? NA Please provide a copy of the cost sharing agreement. Quarterly Report Compliance: 12CO1: contract expires on 12/31/15 Quarter ending in Sept 2012: sent on 11-7-12 (2012 quarter 3) Quarter ending in Dec 2012: sent on 4-24-13 (2012 quarter 4) Quarter ending in March 2013: sent on 4-10-13 (2013 quarter 1) Quarter ending in June 2013: sent on 6-25-13 (2013 quarter 2) Are there active federal and state permits for the project? Yes Have local funds been secured for the project? Yes Explain: Local funding for the project will be obtained by Collier County through a Tourist Development Tax. This provides a dedicated long term funding source through a `bed tax'. Collier County levies a four(4%)percent Tourist Development Tax on all rental income received from accommodations rented for six months or less. The four-percent(4%)Tourist Development Tax revenue is allocated by the Tourist Development Plan approved by the Board of County Commissioners as follows: Fifty percent (50%) for beach park facilities and beach improvement, maintenance, renourishment, restoration and erosion control, including pass and inlet maintenance shoreline protection, enhancement, cleanup or restoration of inland lakes and rivers to which there is public access as these uses relate to the physical preservation of the beach, shoreline or inland lake or river. This funding source and dedication was approved by referendum. 13.4% for County owned or operated museums, to acquire, construct, extend, enlarge, remodel, repair, improve, maintain, operate or promote one or more county owned museums and for non- County owned museums that are owned and operated by not-for-profit organizations and open to the public. 36.6%for Advertising/Promoting and Special Events to bring tourism to Collier County. Packet Page-1526- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. In order to acquire state funding, a resolution from the local sponsor must be provided by the application deadline which declares: • Support from the Sponsor for the Proposed Project • Willingness to serve as the Local Sponsor • Ability to provide the full Local Cost Share • And the source of the funding Please provide copy of the resolution. The resolution is unchanged since last year and is included as Attachment 5. Previous State Commitment: Has the Department previously cost shared, reviewed, and approved a feasibility or design phase for this project? Yes Previous State Cost Share percentage 36.2% Will this project enhance or increase the longevity of a previously-constructed project?How? No The 2013/2014 project in combination with the 2016/2017 project will restore the shoreline to the design standards of the 2006 project, but it will be accomplished in two stages, 3 years apart. The 2013/2014 project has been designed economically, with the hot spot areas receiving the greatest amounts of fill. In addition, gaps are being left where no fill is needed, creating a savings. Will this project nourish a previously restored shoreline? (Full beach nourishment. Dune-only projects do not qualify.) Yes Project Performance: Nourishment Interval (Years): 7 years In the 2013/2014 Collier County Project Assessment, the Department stated that the August 2012 survey data of the project area indicates the locations of erosion hotspots where segments of the shoreline have eroded landward of the design shoreline: at Naples Beach (R-58A—R-60), at Park Shore beach (R-52 — R-53) and at Vanderbilt (R-27 — R-29). Between May 2006 and August 2012 surveys (approximately 6 years post-construction), 49% of the average shoreline width constructed remain. We can, therefore, assume the expected design life of the project(Permit No. 0222355-001-JC) of 6 years to be largely validated. (Collier County Beaches 2013-14 Renourishment Project Description With Engineering and Design Summary, November 2012 by CPE). Since the scheduled beach nourishment is in FY2013-2014, the ranking score for the project performance criteria is seven(7)points. Mitigation of Inlet Effects: Criterion is calculated by the Department. Please provide any supplemental information that may assist in determining if the project is located with the area of inlet influence and provides supplemental nourishment for an inlet that is not balancing its sediment budget as defined by the Inlet Management Plan or Strategic Beach Management Plan. Two inlets are located within the Collier County Project Area: Doctors Pass and Clam Pass. Both inlets are dredged periodically as described in their Inlet Management Plans, with the sand placed downdrift. This bypassing is not sufficient to mitigate for all of the Packet Page-1527- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. inlet effects, as demonstrated in the attached sediment budget from the Collier County Conceptual Renourishment Project Analysis (CPE 2011). By passing alone is not balancing the sediment budget. In this sediment budget, the bypassing rate was insufficient immediately downdrift of Clam Pass and Doctors Pass by 1,900 cy/yr and 10,400 cy/yr, respectively. This deficiency impacted the beaches further south, increasing the magnitude of this deficiency. Although the inlet maintenance dredging has largely achieved its primary goals (navigation and circulation), this activity has not addressed all of the downdrift impact. The 2013/2014 project is designed to address past and near term shortages in bypassing. The design of the 2013-2014 project is much larger south of these inlets for the sole purpose of establishing a design beach and creating a feeder beach sufficient to re-establish the alongshore transport rates for the Park Shore and Naples beaches shoreline. The modeling of these two reaches conducted by CPE in 2011, demonstrated the need for a healthy beach south of these passes to support successful beaches downdrift. The sand placement south of Doctors Pass will be is a volume of 37,000 between R-58A and R-59, which will be placed on top of approximately 36,000 cy dredged from Doctors Pass earlier this year. The target bypass volume at Doctors Pass is 10,000 cy/yr to the immediate south of the pass. This did not occur since 2006, since all bypassing was placed more than 0.5 miles south of the pass in 2005 and 2009. This placement will be corrected for this year's maintenance dredging, but does not mitigate for the missed bypassing. The proposed project will address the remaining deficit over and above what was placed south of the inlet in 2009-2011 for the past and thru the next projects life. The 2013-2014 nourishment will make up 100% of the deficit illustrated in the sediment budget thru the project life, which includes sand placed within the R58A to R59 region since 2007. The sand placement south of Clam Pass is a volume of 37,000 cy between R-44 and R- 47, an increase from 18,500 cy placed in 2006. This was later supplemented by a truck haul project. The 2006 re-analysis of Clam Pass Inlet Impacts (CPE 2006) found a need for additional bypassing of approximately 6,000 cy/yr. The proposed fill volume will address about 6 years of this deficit, with another 8,000 cy placed in 2011 brings the total to 45,000 cy out of a 10 year need of 60,000 cy. This is a percentage of 75.0%. The combined percentage is 85.5%. Packet Page-1528- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. '1,' ,i *1" i 0.3 0 • BARE'•• 'BERG DUNS A1.0 +5.3 7.••RK "�'� i I 6.• �►0c`" I" O LNOR- WIGGINS 0 6600 12000 16.6- 4.2 TATS PARK I *'S +5.1 GRAPHIC SCALE IN FT `__-5.,- 5.9 -10.5 t 4.7 V• DERBILT BEACH R30 1tv �I PELT*AN ■ BAY -2.1 6.8 R40 ...CLAM- 'S +0.8 f1 SR 896 GULF 1 Ill MEXICO 8 4 -6.6 • �l,HORE 15.0 I I .pASS 11.0 +4.0 0a SR 886 i +3.4 , 2.• -10.4 r t SR 856 `_-10� 7.5 o ! �o NAPLES +10.2 M SR 84 N 7.9 , :\ti (--) +7.2 \-.8 , � -,PORT ROYAL Yeti 0.7 \ p� S \ LITTORAL SAND TRANSPORT pN R90 -- MECHANICAL SAND TRANSPORT GORE \ KEEWAYDIN (DREDGING OR TRUCK PLACEMENT) \-04p ISLAND ALL VALUES IN CY./YR.x 1000 ,' Figure 2. Sediment Budget Map Use of Innovative Applications of existing technologies: Does the project address erosion in a method that is economically competitive with nourishment, that will not adversely affect the conservation of fish and wildlife, including endangered or Packet Page-1529- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. threatened species, or their habitats, and that is designed to demonstrate an innovative application Amok of existing technologies? The project has been modified to utilize the sand from Doctors Pass with placement adjacent to the inlet. This will assist in addressing future inlet related impacts in this region. To this end the applicant has secured both beach and inlet permit modifications and has produced an updated biological monitoring plan based on the placement adjacent to the inlet. When dredging prices became very high earlier this year, the County switched to an upland sand source, which saved approximately 40%over the dredger's bid. Has the project been documented to be effective and demonstrated technologies previously untried in the state? No innovative technology is proposed. Regionalization: Is this project being planned or constructed in cooperation with another local government to reduce contracting costs? Explain and attach a signed copy of the interlocal agreement between the two local sponsors. Collier County attempted to establish an interlocal agreement with The Town of Longboat Key however, funding and timing complications made it such that the execution of such an agreement was not possible this year. Significance: What is the volume of advanced nourishment lost since the last sand placement event of a beach restoration or nourishment project as measured landward of the Mean High Water Line? 189,221 cy The last placement event along Collier County occurred between February and May 2006. Based on surveys between November 2005 (pre-construction)and May 2006(post-construction) the beach nourishment project, prior to the 2013 placement, added 431,406 cy of material above the MHW line within the project area(R-22 to R-79). Comparing the May 2006(post-construction)survey with the 2013 survey, the project area(R-23 to R79)has lost 189,221 cy of material above the MHW line. The ratio of lost to placed is 43.86% Has the project eroded into the design template? Yes What is the proposed placement volume? 215,000 cubic yards will be placed as part of the 2013 nourishment. Packet Page-1530- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 1 Basis for Local Funding and Project Maps Packet Page -1531- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 1 FUNDING ELIGIBILITY COLLIER COUNTY BEACH RENOURISHMENT PROJECT Vanderbilt Beach and Pelican Bay Segment Project Boundary: Vanderbilt Beach: 300 ft. south of R-22 to 500 ft. south of R-30 Pelican Bay: 500 ft. south of R-30 to R-37(this reach is not part of the County project, but it is being added at the Pelican Bay Association's request at 100%of their cost. Approximate Shoreline Length: 8,204 ft. On-site Adjacent Total Public Access Spaces Spaces Spaces Delnor Wiggins State Recreation Area* 355 0 355 Vanderbilt Beach Road* 340 21 361 Qualifying Hotels Qualifying Shoreline Vanderbilt Shores' 550 ft. Bayshorest 297 ft. La Playa 360 ft. Vanderbilt Beach—Beach Cottages' 100 ft. Vanderbilt Beach Resot 100 ft. Ritz Carlton' 741 ft. Naples Trolley tours runs year-round in Collier County. The location of trolley stops is included with the project area maps in this application. The trolley stops at one hotel in the Vanderbilt Beach area(LaPlaya)which qualifies for 52.8 ft of eligibility each. The County has eight (8) public walkways between Delnor Wiggins State Park and Vanderbilt Beach Road, each with a bike rack. Walkways three (3) to six (6) listed below each have a four (4)station bike rack and in gaps not covered by parking&access or hotels. Vanderbilt Beach Public Walkways Walkway No. 1 @ R-29-340'with one four(4) station bike rack Walkway No. 2 @ R-27+200 (Seachase)with one four(4) station bike rack Walkway No. 3 @ R-26(LaPlaya) with one four(4) station bike rack Walkway No. 4 @ R-26-200'(Bayview)with one four(4) station bike rack Walkway No. 5 @ R-25+400 with one four(4)station bike rack Walkway No. 6 @ R-25 (Seabreeze)with one four(4)station bike rack Walkway No. 7 @ R-24 with one four(4)station bike rack Walkway No. 8 @ R-22+313 (DWSP)with one four(4)station bike rack Area determined to be publicly accessible Total Length Vanderbilt Beach Segment 7,451 ft. Packet Page-1532- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Area determined to be critically eroded R-22.3 to R-30.5 Percent eligible for State funding: 90.82% State eligibility incorporates the total project length(critical and non-critical)and eligibility only recognizes publicly accessible critically eroded shoreline. *Primary beach access contains a minimum of 100 parking spaces and public restrooms. f Overlap Packet Page-1533- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FUNDING ELIGIBILITY COLLIER COUNTY BEACH RENOURISHMENT PROJECT Park Shore Project Boundary: R-43 +500 to 400 ft. south of R-54 +400 Approximate Shoreline Length: 11,412 ft. On-site Parking Spaces Adjacent Total Public Access Metered Permit* Spaces Spaces Horizon Way 21 17 0 38 Vedado Way 25 14 6 39 Via Miramar 29 12 0 41 Seagate Drive(within .25 mile) 0 0 38 38 Clam Pass Park 0 172 0 172 Naples Trolley tours runs year-round in Collier County. The location of trolley stops is included with the project area maps in this application. Area determined to be critically eroded R-50.5 to 390' south of R-54+400 3,940 ft Total eligible shoreline length: 3,940 ft. Approximate Shoreline Length: 11,412 ft. Percent eligible for State funding: 34.53% State eligibility incorporates the total project length (critical and non-critical) and eligibility only recognizes publicly accessible critically eroded shoreline. *Permit spaces are available to residents and the general public for the same price. Atft Packet Page-1534- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FUNDING ELIGIBILITY COLLIER COUNTY BEACH RENOURISHMENT PROJECT Naples Segment Project Boundary: 1,050 ft. north of R-58 to R-79 Shoreline Length: 19,340 ft. On-site Spaces Adjacent Spaces Total Public Access Public Permit** Public Permit** Spaces Lowdermilk Park* 46 164 0 0 210 8th Avenue North 20 1 0 0 21 7th Avenue North 10 4 0 0 14 North Lake Avenue 19 20 0 0 39 Fill 6th Avenue North 5 5 0 0 10 5th Avenue North 0 0 0 0 0 4th Avenue North 11 4 0 0 15 3td Avenue North 10 4 0 0 14 2nd Avenue North 12 4 0 0 16 1St Avenue North 11 6 0 0 17 Central Drive 8 4 0 0 12 Pt Avenue South 5 12 0 0 17 2nd Avenue South 7 4 0 0 11 3`d Avenue South 8 6 0 0 14 4th Avenue South 8 7 0 0 15 5th Avenue South 34 0 20 0 54 6th Avenue South 4 8 0 0 12 7th Avenue South 7 9 0 0 16 8th Avenue South 6 5 0 0 11 9th Avenue South 11 4 0 0 15 Fill 10th Avenue South 9 35 0 0 44 11th Avenue South 8 5 0 0 13 Broad Avenue 49 22 0 0 71 12th Avenue South 25 8 0 0 33 Pier Parking Lot 81 0 0 0 81 13th Avenue South 31 13 0 0 44 14th Avenue South 16 14 0 0 30 15th Avenue South 10 7 0 0 17 16th Avenue South 16 14 0 0 30 17th Avenue South 7 3 0 0 10 18th Avenue South 12 13 0 0 25 19th Avenue South 0 0 0 0 0 215t Avenue South 0 0 0 21 21 *Primary beach access contains a minimum of 100 parking spaces and public restrooms **Permit spaces are available to residents and the general public for the same price Naples Trolley tours runs year-round in Collier County. The location of trolley stops is included with the project area maps in this application. Packet Page-1535- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Qualifying Hotels Qualifying Shoreline Edgewater Hotel 333 ft. Naples Golf and Beach Club 939 ft. Area determined to be publicly accessible Total Length 85 ft. north of R-58 to R-79 18,410 ft. Area determined to be critically eroded 85 ft. north of R-58 to R-79 Total eligible shoreline length: 18,410 ft. Total shoreline length: 19,340 ft. Percent eligible for State funding: 95.20% State eligibility incorporates the total project length(critical and non-critical)and eligibility only recognizes publicly accessible critically eroded shoreline. *Primary beach access contains a minimum of 100 parking spaces and public restrooms. Packet Page-1536- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. "Tit z r +, c� max a c z ill s , ..,c ..,.::::, ''''''? ',,,.. 4. , ,.,,„,. i .;, ., .--, ,,_iir,---1 - , i-lo a Z U m �v 1 [> std ,,— d cc 9 Q F. kat l;f < '' r ' a J 1- cif ■ 1 ' '.�r k r ,' ,.. Gu�FSNpaer"" c.� �°y; m t i „, w,g e^� ..c:ic,- .,,.. ,li,,,.oir5t..., . , . .,''''''' .11 figc-.., in , : 4k- '' t,t It, .,.. ' R H G Y 1 .''',;>„,7!�y tid .I3 F \ 1, = rr . - " tc�, .' �" CD ❑ O r� m u 000880' a 4 C o, c 3� y5 e.t v SYd - ''''''1",-,'' 0' #r 11 O f o� d S'� � ,� � '1;1.3 ti {1 1 Tt I m ? a,t , P",',.,4,..,,)x :;',.;;147.4,,t;,.6.• 1;2 a 11 2 + 'i "v a s '..- + - Yrri ,7 ,vim, r Pf yr +' t� ; ra^S ',,,,,-.',14`....44/."4!-'*"1y 1" $ '"'� 5..'`` ...,gam'd, : *te- .aerY"?ak�u.k '''.,‘"';'1,"„}—,,' 4. 'Y"T bd�f:. ",--M'z �f 1 t, i b ar51 4^ J1.� rFur � g ste t4 u ,� ''�i)bv$x i n • 1 e wbm .,r ,`-"'.7-.`...4-.?:,'",,,, to „�yy art ?ri f 1 y,t r r� %s. dy*.t, *FI's-7 T`', t S.r” 5 m 244-,,,k-,-,--;:- .- J3n+.w'+4r ,..+v.. x, l..bwe' Z.: d. ?�t3 m �� C N J £& A O N -,- .' r� a i �fi' ze `', m m a s.rx a k; ice. '` [ " .�' ' fi s-: ' ? °' d '''gz J', P s f,st,,3 : a m yFxa. 3' s )l� x r r xE' � e�Ri i 9 r_ -' '* � S w'ih5��Y G1 0 a ( k In ?d ^>t ,, -. 3cF �4` x131° ■ A� Y� a r f 0. 1 f0 N m a _ C 'O N 1 O O M N rc 1 LLNmc72 0 I PWa z� �r+ P G !e..y 4iy.„:„,t-.,...... a; O .. 1 o f ci m zl tr '$ % n,rt7fif'"' � �� I �—r m°�� m �} S '?i .s3 o n,�m m 1 r 1 t§.6mm� d .,wt ss 7 "°"9ca��,'iT,T,y Y 1 y m m a a d p e ,1-141.,,i 'c°' �," °E a �r I c v 1p 0 o>yr 0 [g p o 43. 1'Jt �y.i$d 1 k X, t 4-,,,„ `� .` .O O L 9 0 O 1+� i r�.x tit a+tr ' t,.' � i0 V m c U w . o- a o c"i ,n° I m c�inz°oa' `mc°c°) -..„ .a,,,,z,„.„,,..,„,,,,,...,, `!! O •- c' iti C i 2 -~ ! Z z Z L„ Packet Page -1537- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. c z LL rRI „ a a C w —� i1 1" A d s z ; ,, m 0 z < • S! C m y 5gP'ws Z 4 1 . •6' -nw `j' 0 cn= 2 8gri s O sa-4' J e d v < . ._... U J Q Y p . m A 1. k „t ww .fM,- , , ,f` %.-,,.1.i4-.-.'-,-;',1,,F4ti4 '-„{L fs K-N � 1' �(AS^.o �s y tomi . y' . ,,� L < t C4 d i - {f 'O . „ .; aee000 a � ? ��z a3x ” t r s' 7 wss nFs, a5 7 4 OC96; Q . sr? ' as r y �'� m`""�1 + `'+a .,.„,�rn� S �. t. s c E i" it z. 4 fex xm E;�3 -. 'YF -, 0 .s°.ry` ' ',: a5 _ ,`-:`V,A:€ tea.- --:::-1,,,,-.-,,,,,,,- �' . ..,„ y u W .4 ftr... m 5 $ �" ar , �� acr€� �-'s,„'' 4 cc', v r 2 ' I : F am � � w a- r a iS,r fit _ , , u ' ? , � .., -a -,:- m &»:fit,-5,x r c a. bait- ,-z.: .+�ry's °;•--,as ,.,' E 1?� ” ' '" �J ty ' r� e.r:;;F' t 7 n. J N p.s .,- . . 1384000. , 2,+-. .,F vc, . . —.. - �g, , a .. i UUO I O i I Nw C �O. z 1 I o OMN'-' x 1 I LiNpri2 �, ": c m d ry} ad Kb z- f w� n M'k 0 aEi ro f0 m , ,, Xs,' r>r $ �kc`13`. sue .- 0 a i "'rs t w, E• v,na a m '4 ,..•.p i is .1 i.17*Y r r °� I E o• o 1 0>W o a' oca-0c 23 , zi--,„,:"'' " m m co• E Q U g y u p 1 O o 2• O. C O o § X e -8 0Ocnzoa mNU O . cv ni I Z a "g _ Z Packet Page-1538- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Y W 1'1 - `' tt U K `1,iPSSJ x z LL }il:' V M I' V@ .+ W 4' ;31� a y w x t' G.1.0 E =zj_ t � 1 t �� W � 9R O g.fi x`tZa� S ...'. d Z �m�M^' = ao�c EI � L'Sdr G' n, , T • r j x r. O C tC6 a s _-st �t ,r. r y2 VJ, 1 NE yr, 4*. o y a S ?! 1 C L 3 t 10.1 0 Ok o=v. > ter, I ya A E1. U cc _ l ,� aV ; C 0 I.. 1.. °fr`3 .ir r • rw "r.''If of E .. .. co LL LL............:........ ............:....:._.�._...:.::..__:.....,:. ';._ a,..:.._._._..•..:._:::._--r-r. � 1 Z U I: - t4, r..v y , ..,.1a,,,,,,,I.,. ,...,..f,-•-. .,,,--,-..,, .. .4 1 c E'' rj F h . r . ? +� s t. �Z1 W n: 1 •i,'Sb^,I f 5.} -,..'4, if,P yy 1 R- '"� Y' i� - '•i%"k� A S,t2`�Il k1 ''S l' it Y Y.- ^' ''t'F � ,isr •� 'n wit$ "*,:47_!j� ,, ,y).11.---� V , ^Q k}.: �.'k f. 9 CiflS �• 31.E t u// '2rl i J 3,i t. n'vF E d co u d 1111 N rn uwac m n a c W* m E .C ob I C 15'0 L a 9 ` _,... 4: , 3r{ t . 1 ,+�r i / i 4 -y U u c U 14 ' N� i' 711 �'f a U o o L. 21� U..3i )y SSt i�lC m m E Q U w ar L ' R I SaQO=un� ' ryd L ' ' .. 0 ' I m cinzIIO 0cOO x o 0 N 7 . I Z 0 r Z Packet Page -1539- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. W z — U C Z LL .c c0 .v C F. c r :.,( ". CD'C E z tit Z o' m Wx. - c m W gQ�+ww Z +a at +. 7 0 to paogo. 2 U c� z�§4cex o- a x a 1111� `G � r z m ..L . '1'lllrntl� CI - ,. C J Q" 2 y fir' 1-,,,I. I _,- 1rY 0 ._ b :: : GULFS °, . t 4 r ty. o ti 1 U S,k'' ww IA " .: y. , 11 fit. ),,v..•-,..,„.'r'' OOOBBf.I i f N I d ,^ q i rii M V .a y 1 `u 'r C I o `° I 1 lt0 m d � d1 �. y rn E Y 1 „�'r •.�d o m m 1.1 _'rt' -r .: -:.: .. .. ... .. C Q W O r385o: .. .t, 2 i 11 E en'ak � * J g a r a f rt Y x F r [ Z, y, Mi l f L a, N H z ` o NO3 - a mu,¢ 'c,L t'' J„ � F ! ¢ gyp� „"' O W 2 a„ 7 1 t^ f14.-t ,...,',_,..44...4 t''..{- ` , , ...?„,4:„.,-, ti r6 U cy� .= � mo L c 5 r".4. }<rrpy y. i ',f,-A....„, { " ..,-- yk, ,, , ,o r • , ktt� r y` x, ? ?'4' i i * t ' m ` I I'D am i°>'c o E u■ >' >m D.L F.''' rti n te !rg' r 3 ,3 y r '4 ,r Y {,,,a C C a -C m a o. m fj M } a -S.,. , r ') 1 ' N m a y z i, L4 '� :.,� c.2 p n O•d ' •'7 F CD O O 7,c.2 Z 1. _ f �6{ ^ gg C— T A I O U d C.)CC)Z 0 a co NU 1, Packet Page -1540- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. cc ci LT 1 Ti 'f-I I ,11i gad W W Y e or al X 0 r= ', U c � Emma=,LL o Pr . •' mof Jas a. ';A� k tot V O Q ,, co m o k�-e ' x o ir -i" „ 1. .-* t p ., s$ S 1 4TI 4. a L GUL SHO.rwr IV a '.,y •_ 1.2 F (�. '1 o :Ft: I „• -H . ac .. -•<� TM'1,_,_ 4., w'0” t -. . 1' . •i s I co• d r Ei 071 co Q jjFa - P_' nt• ,;,;.,;#n `'' area^: 4 H O E M € .a p u1 398000 �.'. 4I. y�;�}�r •.''.t; qE'a C—Ti U W e?^'y '4'`L.'Y 1,r15't H• m U u_ 'r1/47'Pk i I[X * Z 11 L-n.Ai�t's. 'r'ksS 's� Y�;Y.,`,ti[, r: f•n:";� ', '' aP � �''. 1` ca, rt . „ .i .z',: •'yr f:, :.:..s.,, °: � ."..a � :;�.: - r % C;Trr. mrs�s.��tis. '��R2� - ..�+:.1+;s'y k:. f 7.y ��:.'�.-;.:.� � i,, ';}i . .•: ,-0a'Y.}' :i'1 '':n'`;'`;:::,.,`.... �f y�..�..L}•::,��`c%}•: :j�ali:^r,"5 .;.i r .aF .•� r �'�' "'��" 'd Ls'.�?!-,' .sue ,5; ::.. -�:. i"L;.:.r'.° 'ai F' 'y +c. - ,. �; �-..,... I_ Si W R lh• :L .'h ii i. 5 ti4..'-T:'a.:-.:`".!^ N ILI t 1 y 1 o 1 m co E m .fk:,1 a Q E v • 1 d LE 0 m aaio 1 . N F, t ;r I - .A ' 6 Y,mw r s f yr, t t m N ol II- M1 ! O O,-=“9 G ...w 8,_I y y Q c.),c f, i... - -- i ,r,u)„_,,.,,, ,,. „, .. . ....01,,,,- ...„4,,_ ., ,„....,, , ,, ... I' m E a. me d{I r P a_ o � 1,A 4.1, 7 S •4•L I r]i !T - iI c• o Q O > u-' ,, '' s U cEQ o ra, aw`; a N I - fr J H O W O f 2 C w? c O V O N C) V. X .. . ..:... ..':.4:..:.... I Z m, a Packet Page -1541- — 10/8/2013 16.A.16. L. �i '''..r.,:-.1-;... di d W • N• -a; .fin Y e ea L 2_ - St ,, fi"`9. .r ''y.:r' •j m 7V0 O! C7 Q m R e e. .-:: :d l4 °+ 111116:{ i 7. i. `.iw ...4•':'4.. .r ,p, ..rI' _ N c.1 C 7,,.q1_, �.', T. ,2• J �ojE.:' it I A4�� din+ = x.` CO roi Fit.U -. 4 "' 4 n, ! 1 ail c7.,,,--ill F ,iviiitift d '''','..'''<;......-'.1, 7g51:'4"':,„:::.... LuF 2.3 3 Y a i` J r. ' , 1,-,' �Y !I s it N : . m,Th R 4 ` E o e ` H w : ` "Y c• R W�� roc '.:.j.: Yi+ } u-•S :, '$':F:K...I, a,r . ^ a i 2 1 ,'.:q:.•:: .:..) • ...• ::...: :.'. " •-. ,..j4,15-,FAT.,:,'-7,1410.1;g2. • '.1.• ;.. ... 1i,-‘400t0....k .:M.:,,,- >• ,. - Lc...^.. fs x: •.. 7''''ti ....• c.i.>i'. :.. x.'.: ` o . fi m k R 11. V.$4 e Q E c�•I :H. �, 0 c I. ,•t`r l � �,.m135c N•4 { d O• .i CAF •� o f• csi '2 f .? N p f' ..� c:'^ir v NOM= 9500 4 t n1'..'. BE 4I N Q �' '25• .....x.• .q- W O U -,4' '�jY C �'k h�lY'i yMm' X"yy�'. 4•:. y ''-4 HiU1 V u.1 c�. c n� m 0 f, LL -. 7 id,�,�.,kiTt ��7,t s • F c e c o o O>7n i• '31 7 TZ :b .. m o c a v °U' ° .tea:•. " . .. . ..." •�}yV.a .d1A�.: .: r't - v_.' ,4:-...-.,,-..,.• N U U_ m m U y. v"I• .. . . ... " .. a O E O 9 r,. . E d Q 2 T y o.0 rte, $ ?3aa _ yaO i ° nz oN ari c° i s O ' w:4 r y o G e z o� ,'k o o �c _Z Packet Page-1542- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. w U C . Z 2 2 Z sl CL. m s a m w mag a 'o' �• ' ..T y y „,z g ae w w 8 i- " �m aapQgR: m � 0� O a O Z—x.cex o 8 FL zm a LL— y zs,_ m�` Jai O as a x r. a f J 4. F m • A: , '','..:' ': '' , d h 3 G ` ; 1 d.+Y 'fir N 4, N .' ; ''''''''''''''';:'17'f;,1;- ' ' \'' .It:J'C77. ' ' u �A C C c s^' LL 4 98e a� F r [ i a�a 000ese -a.. . aa 'L� `s.r :t c )''- I:..,,', ,_-:-;. ....'-'-!-";7, '.'t?''''-.7-;'.' '' -,,,„r;15"4t.,--.;;:'a 1 r f x'1'$1 i:°' y: 7: T 1 t. yr 4 '• U C S m 5 �'�N 'l�r *r ,�. rile a: i 4,!,:": �'� �,,y"fr il a. -L� '{- +µ`y°„--,1-7-47.,•-',';,,;•• ,.' _-�` F I w ? c2 O J '”} W ,n.k t...x r .' -''.-�,.a 5� ,,ern f "' : E ri m o a a e r '"� - �r u �, m ..„_-b,-,,. !'r13k 4 ,r".71 . j �n� �o a C+ O• .rl"4 ,fin �fi l�4 0cø - 9 ' a rt& �., . . N V U l0 C � mmEQ� O ° ' "5 a Q o�y ti, y_t d i 10/8/2013 16.A.16. N Z c 2 LL #v/ $ a C W — 3 t E z Z;•- r m d y za iex a �: ! 1 p a' O gum-iii. o s ti.., U m 4 � x k v i f ,y .1; n ji W J a 1 O U o w b @ C LL N O �` Y N ` Ii iv,5 In n t t x f � r _ [ ri , d ....w c .o W r a"¢ Sy u t U 1 5 ,0'1;2=. U 3 i 2 1..r kr' ;: 2 Y" O m m N U Q a 0 s C1) J 91 O C O M N C N rO ir._N 2 ri2 0 J 4 ak m . -wz � l ? O C O L i Pf S r m .. v t t O rn C r > r d } O L •fr• µ41, rn; X ',7,i UIqE .i _r," d l0 N L d f f �4."(,1 S .' - 1 w z n a E .;��• " s, � .P..-E,0 t ,O>U u � 60 !0 UI O a ,T,,:'"° y U U N G U N C � U O U d i IF Y 3 g N afV U ~ N Un Z. 2NU LI m 0 d 0 g Z Packet Page-1544 0 10/8/2013 16.A.16. N p -. y W • e r ; tg�r.�i •? C Z a L CO ++ e _ ,, .y.... 14iL E zra co o� z¢m "� �� * Z.dN w2Qeaw i r. v CU zz�`.-: o sue'° o 5<1 �t5, T-1-- U oa Q f 'rat ,! pal i k ^ : F i f Y`1 , ., 3 M N 1 .. LL jSR �i N ,01.‘,...t, O 1 m t. W to Il d' +Yp d C 4f C f w2 � 1 i t?s z3 e!,, # I y am ,:$ ° c y" _ •W E m W i c " 7 W' ,. ,,�t 111',7n,' '2::::',,,;;,,t7 I t Pr, fi 1 F"t r.J;=?, y. i [ , ' � au O d N T0• qi 4 -lky. D a .. -S.+ �• G t �, 7 n . -' .I o t d o 9 .r r f + a) c a+ m O Y, u o j3 rfr�'x„Y *kt 3 U[b Z 0 o_ W N U a, O w m O U 0 Z a g Packet Page-1545- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. U *411100131.744,, 4 0, ,:jir.! ` E 9. �„ z„,,.!!r..., a,= E zzz; 10/8/2013 16.A.16. N W U K s.'- 2 7 0 C Z LL ro s 4 iil u �y� www f � , .. ct1� c W Fa :w ' ,•. , � . m 16 m za=4s= o emu) wee-p„! Z 0A18 Sao.. . g� ..e �p'x •+ .: .zrn� , x, O a'6_; " ;;O'N'''''.." ' .o° Vt O 0,O z ai m:., v �• '`.a« w Y� U C L Z m a LL ? .r � ,.x . a;.Z,� 3 , wax I � � �� r.=. i Y 91 ,s }`r-?! .." ,i t �-' # is o.C " � .;, a'41 �.. : of J Q u ... il,..„,..: .,.„.::.%.,... .,. . .....x:::,,::.,:,„:,,. ..:...9.4...:‘,4 , ,,to. .., ,+..„ ,,.....,_:,.... ,. ...... i ,,,..,.„,,,,,.... ...,.., ___.„,.,......,__._, M it '-:':-;'''''..:'Llrf.-: :/1.4L,' ...":::,..;:ri;;;":: ' ').4**6;i,-'-'1.,'4`1',::.''.,,r-, ''>„0,.."`-'t. ."..:_;":.;':,::;`*'V:L''.;t:';''..'f'-`,:.,,'4.•.:),'':='"."-,;-.4 F, ' f ir Y Vi: �r i'' .• ' vv '' w 4 +lid' '�� ?;3 ' .taw* n::�., «.,,,,.,,aw• .:.ti. LL rN i A l f . ,�. y ,, 0 7 o Ir M_ _ —Q rr :::,:-.,7-,...,,,.;..,-- F:f C, o f I , aPl - tz :a1 O OMN ,�" r '.,„r ,{:.i fit- r y rn coo °'•-� ` ' w `r r x cUm0o oven • � is' -•& I m—11 o 0 0_Z. O o yy 3 ;'' rt. { W O w o m Ylv-z. m°v 1 0� a �� Z Packet Page -1547- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ,,,-,,,--„,..7,,,-....1.4- ,5-77,.„. -...,... w• a+ " te.+�_,''',, . ► GNLES a.aa ,s I n1i>% Y .. . a)N w o mo U C L U th '5,- a ;1,, ., ''/i P 1 '''''..il .\ ,'''" -. : -ge ,1:11., :. ..''' '' , . Ne. . if,.."..;',:.;1.,. ,. , .- .=... = F.,? ! _ .„..,„41, , t .,,.,,,.4,,,„.,,,,5.s .*.,\,,,,,.‘,,,r,„,..,.,,,,,,...:27,,.,.1::::1 :l':,, ,..,... ' \ ' !,,,;:...7 ...ri ,,, i.' 7174 k. i,, , t x �w1G .:,.r. 4_ ' ''' - . 1 N� fi ,, ' '� ' 1 LL i ` a ' ''e ''�,T" ' ' -`.3=' ° * `ut `ax`f i',,* �' ` . e 0 t 4 s t �'�,� r t y 4 s E E r a a d m q J :jC€ { r .. £ c o N N co CN I - --.1 m s� LE Z° e 0 .Y € -r� is t � m..r 4 ,'}-'d'`i ,4 a>5,, i ' Ii .m rn y v'_ a A m"' "'r` ^ ri 5'rw" t. - I -,> 1 dv4 a F 1 D ar{ U a ° m �,# m U c�Ti, U c.. y ° ,a co EQ ,7, U� t ∎ 'o U a. iK. . - N O UnZoa mc U w O N (..7 5 Packet Page-1548- w 0 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 7 71 dam c. W z 6 ULir ' tF r,{ trl CO I ? .. 4'.' O '� 4 s°;. ar i l*" ,;, ° �L'° c m 0 sa o.i g x 2 '" ds m m o<o 2 x .� ,►'1. ," I U CO L z 82.4 O -.1:::,'"'" anae aoHSa�q� g ins._ .;� .y; �� U O O. 0 �P' 'I jt I i 1 rte fs o t V l IL r_N w t - ,v lt. -ii 3J .. 44 r� '' 9! 1� a y -,,, r n x "" 1� I q y LT G ,k y{. `� N t ice.-.,',.. �e r `} � rs4 i! 2 I M1 / `0 YV r ry � * r j t ft ;,`,.. r x .' rr,N a ) A »f p -, 0` . �N i ti }� ,......,-7.-,,, t o yo- ` 4 a'S1�i"`s' Yda, ,,t, ,� 4 U W ,o.i .ff .D u y d 4:;. m y N q 72,-;g1-11 4 Q II " LLNm,± L "4,-4 j 2'sm '.`�....}'i y� yFt � r ; 3113 , ,.� y z m '' c G x o �c a4Y rv := o Eri'm- = , w l �.. w 5 w c a i'i� .r ,. b ,��, t,��W �� c.r�r-: ', �• t m a-r da�.+ �� d E o m a � ■ c'coo 10 0 E o�V7 0' a L a a o docaa c U' >' a �Um float, I �. y � U l0 F U N C W W O a U U O 9 O U O.� rtrt I, w-.. N—T,N 2 O U N gmo`m ncoo , U(nzOd wNU cog �� . : Z Packet Page-1549 10/8/2013 16.A.16. L N W 2 j C9 c Z LL a <1).c E z r; mmN Wa.e^„ Z _ = ma .n(3a€== 2 ° c 0 z—§gig ° Zm €LL— a 1,�cS, ,^ d Y C Q*- !,h n„'7�s x �F�dt c V p C et ea,. x _ J:.; UJa Q m { G, y i-pVfE &a "1 �4 a�1 0 „,.....■,. - ,.,/,,,,-.....-;c,,,,,,,,,„- , '--- A 1 -- -1 " jitc. HI aka ffi�i f fi Z _ :.ri. 1 fl N +�, ,' � . " GULFSHORt BLVD r..\e-jr, .yy F J .:— .10111 ..Jfd/ '','""Z,,- 'I 1 t � 00 p fly '`I �r - r}` ."..u)4r `f L 4 S Q r , ,N , Vd"t ,- ;-..,----,....'s-.. .rr. I O 1""•,', ' z` i `r`m µ`ti ,. s iA w ° $ a . gas," ° a g;#,.,,, .', „,' ,.j ,. , - - , . ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,44,, i Z A � � ��&5� � ter. wt h> i i a ,, 0 ? .y ' ;I P .s.,„0,,,-- sa. ..,..4 ar+Vt a,,, 0, . to �kP n#,& ., .,-v .- ,es *:s „.y,J'd�a„� aS ,`-,5:4` I d .I eaJy;nafoJ. 1 m U Q 1 - a' ii I c m II I I J _ o N f < a_ a Iv, 09999E c ,--..,A, I 1 O N N I LL N m M= s 1 ° o ,, iV' nrS L 7 e•fit ” 0 C I N 1,r,;1., L l0 ..P LY),I.r 3 x I n m ° m.H, a ew Ix m— E ° my d A 1 d C`O' O O y'° S 3, E-n O 6-_,g j i a' r ° 1 N U ch m c U m E m e `m a`> 3 t U 2, i m Q� +:x mEO � . Ed<;�ao.0 a O 0 I d Uinzod ,,,,,0 w O V p N c !X C5 C e —'- ; Z i Z Packet Page -1550- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. W ,4 fa C to 0) W cmN aec).KRa 2 o is_- 2 / o y m ova - 2 //' c4 ',:4 0 01 o z—8 g w,, '^.w` ae m K a�` r = Y ..ti J 1- t - s y a _ , S rt d [ II) U 1 ti ,t 4 : S! 1 h .., r .mss ffi' %-\o 4 ' •'3/4 ,,j.' 4.,'.., ri '''*. ' ';', • .1 ' ' ,00,--; •,•,• A- Y 1! t If,L .} i 11,....th 1 a, a 1 j p, ' o ..f �+-x T -9'x""5` ""+', n,,.• h +, t st a It.y a ,. o u - 7Y1 s Y * '1,1t''.: -� is , ,• r L; v 4 ..„3,..4, N\ 1 N ' ' '•,, 4 . , 0, BC� y j a • x7,11 - 1v :i', ; W yi7 ,,,,!'''''-et,., i N ,. „ #"u 2 ,' ' chi T A-ti 4 t 1. ',,,4 eC . tom' ”,• 4` U LL g `�. ct'Ma�� " ,y �3.( � ya7�=--t+x f.' ;.,9,,�Co-a,� T`° x�.TMt �5: a`x.,, t N'»9+ � 9 d„.�'r a .fs ..4., 0, 4, ;, t1 €r �g x JI ,, ! of C hs"`7 � , id I a I .3 H N U eeiv;oaf oJd I II ¢ 10 N 1 h m m I 1 'n ¢ I ii ET_ LL I I J _ 1 F x900000 00088E I 1 I o I 1 E. I 1 I I g N 1 1 I I>`N0 rig 0 ,.i" , 9 i.Y 4•` Sa 9th- ; M. k I 9 N 7 c y ' � $� fhY* { t � U' I a0) avHam ,,.' 1 m�' E mmcoom �' I e-- o °n m O e :,, I Gig o1 9 5E? u o a . 1 N o $ i c o .c m °� � `m 3c d � a I WCuE¢Oy o 1 oc`a¢o?.� 0-- N I o NL y_� . N U ° y o ell 7 oo i O O 0coZod co cv0 1, x a O -- CV r) In 1 Z Packet Page-1551- o 10/8/2013 16.A.16. WIL7. ' rN, 4. „'% Z 0 a c tit Li _ ' r_ B to GI Z>-. N _ � E m.cE ZZ ®, _,: of z a m 4..=c°4)u' wa_BW' °z :.; is O 01 0 z;,- iii 9t, o �, mu, U-m Z x fit, N re Y Q F J Rn Y1i '""`. 1 r JaF m' . .` �.• Y. O g. T-1 ' ' ,., ',` ., '---" " 't, := .,..? ' °-- ''''''-- - ''f,, = ''' ' :-=-,„" ' ''.! 140 ire 1. J a.B � o �� : • 3 1 x t ,o'd i . i m � E n I t s : 14 r , , _ ., fs� • Ii7t r • a W s`; `i , > 4�' � , e �`* �l-�t tx u, 4 7 ', rot +d s �} ',:" m v 0 m d 1 a m o I –_ o' 77 d I 1 00098C o 'eald;aafoid I N U�asa000 ry y a c O d O M N O I we oc E ' .1`n 9'3 4,+..,^:1, 1fl # = oadO"i A�. #ktYav :? c I ;il1 N 4' N N 3 C U 7 r22< ;,,,) ,%(-) W. E-6--.<15-6 ,,";c'1) z r o .2— .o 0 o. mc°U i ' h 0 UnZma' M. O j d z j y Z o Packet Page-1552- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. �. a ys ,; 1 c z LL a A l 40/....:7-*� 'min 4504Z_,-. 2 /4, 2 m os _,a A ‘ , . ,...-.3, td , ,,,,„_ , ,,,,.. .,, ,, ate.. ° III,.— . .4,, " , \..,, r . , ... . 1 \ ' ,LS r 3"r t« ,, . o4 1.--,...... 7.,". it ! w Grp„ * : r r„,,,,-,,,,,it,-,--4.„, „,....;,,. ....,„, °, t's�;°-�, �' �., �r 'fit ' y ` # . ' it 13) a. � y . 1, f � s ,,':-,,,,.. k / -ty,, . ,AiiiarAf,..r.$1.: 'y,}N %KK wl 14 C E g 'y 4t till N --;" ' ' ' \ 0--.11 li 'Os ..+;.; :,,.. : " ,-',' ..'.\A' -, ,..„--..ok' lt, t rn t tp � Y Q•;u �„ S a !n' Wily- ". y`, ;e J i r b. . F - -T# bt d 1. ,_, o k x"ty y 389D00 I y C N 4 1 o N m M= %:� 1_9r pia `` # �, ' U£+ , � , a- o L m'� w a a i g 15 1 1 ii � mE d m o oo'>C N cv0 av o oo camo a T.1 ..,;.:7,.-4-iE t I y oU° m0 mO U U 3 rn - I m sm ¢ i.2n w i 9 ar UCN N I dN 0 o o 1°, d c%NU o. C 1 1161 O l N(r w Z i U x P Z cp Z Packet Page-1553- 10/8/2013 16.A.16.it. Amok a 44. .,,,,,' - ,,,..r...--- ,„ ,,,,,, 4,,At , 1,, 4fi ° ! J!:Qfl m C„sly :1: ,..0,, , . ._,,,., .,.,,, .,,r , ,... m I gdLL<— r^, C J °. ''"Ir-€ r u, - , ,m E mo. z u .m m IX R a a X c —a �' .1* `' o Q I w - ue1 ;, 2, �t i 14: I 1 '44:::.010-::;';'' � *�,i k O f r a L,"1...1 y ` t n- R ; o � � P JYk ,1 M f S Q. •u at ray r „s,'k.. * I • rt�� U N °' E e Q E LL U d c —.E CD N II ice$ c II N z c O.O-. p O C-N O mNO2ri2 ' =,0E2—,.., = d1 II I ,4"O C T N-0 ,2 o 8-2 mp 2'1%,:. - +I w 1-0 1,?; o i I pOLII II a�yy 1 1 y 11 t R ^w U ,9p cU o c I Y tt � c' Y�(� k I o �E ' w�p d y � E¢m O V c 7) z i. :+" F p N Lwa.o = a, �ar I ,, m ` NU I 8 /)ZQ0- mI d — w Zr+a O �Z'og co Packet Page -1554- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. , v g ni c z 1` �s.. C V� K r-ui 0 d W 1�J� N L Z y " Y� 1 P m g E Z a i.s� ec6i — '. -^�.-.• z y ,.. , ,,,- 1,.. c m m pg. .- z A' <ffi_ �.. o',al t s Y -�",d ta. ,-d-�" ..� tv 5 m a 8‹ 4 F, II .,,,,,,,,,,,..t_...„..,...:....... ._% ..,,,_ , . . . , ,..t .. P 4:,..:41.4. .. 4-4'. *It '-.1 , ' .4'- ' \44,..4. "I`' -w W..,\,_ _ �p., a,,, Si o tih . . „,.. ._ , A„, ,,,,,„. f„...,,,,,w..,,,;,„c x=, , ,''r4` �.: r sn � 0000et,,,... ._, ,, ,,,,,,.::,..,,, :7, ,,,,,,,,,;:„...,;,,,,,,,:....::;5.,1,,,,,;.,ti:„,,,?.„1..4.7:,,,,,i,... ..a .,,.._.:,,.,., ,,,:, ,,, E,: ...,. d X 2c , „., r_ „ .LL LL d Q C ¢ O E ig to W O T d N 9 W O t p F— U 11 Q Z t ` C to iii to co Q o = c C J N f 1 � lC N N U'I C O z •� O O M N G < 1 11 N 0 c7 2 p ..,,,,,,< 5 7 c m I d� a y cio a° n U u x I SaU a v 2 g EoC 0 mo a m s U— C▪ 7 O m s O O V O W e�� N• E N N U L I o ` ° o w N om d coU° Z OI Y U t ¢° z O a 4O U • Ft fi X F _/ 2 —Z V Packet Page-1555- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. w ' r T '503c%p: 1 ki ,tia.,. -• . r •, O rn zo8es o l w wffff ra s s J Q Z a¢J 24 2 =v }i o n t y„„,„,"„; _.,- Pir � za a sr _ It ,.., rl,” 0� �,. wrM" ORE o k i ' 9 ..✓s,7" ^'r .-x GULF.„l ;,> Ta c",' '..,....;2■0**4 .'"".•;T' ' or,- t f -y�gy O _, a, q 41-4e E / 1 it @ .y '':'�i`K'99 -••'° s IS" 1 .,w /w -.it I w 20 ElO to . , 8Y xi 1 4' ;" ,i°:' t d s- d N= f c t „-.~ ..aF F- U u- g Y' r ' 4t*1 ,ate �' 2 o . I r G me l • ',..L:' � a c� y m c o o, 1 o d m I-390000 t,:',/fi ' = o m .o a i u o1w; L cu g 0 1 co N o (f O O M N vt ^ t r - l l ' V coI,a e y E` n °Hm a< o n a a s -:1;7,1,,, '3 O. 1Y a m maa dp~ co`` V x ^.+K. es<7 Z � -- mUr m °U O Ow- u °, , m g E• O g a V w, aaQ=o2U m N tl ° °� ` 9274-0,--7.5 f N om0OO ,.0I U)Z O 3 r 0 y O "� Z Packet Page-1556- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ! . 06 a w ry `+Y ray ,....-.6 tT, .. `" , m Q E c7 4.1 e� :,,n U d zm8dLL- 4 rI 4 � � t o c z g a Q. mow ' r q'• .., U c a m �� t1:1 i - _ . wi, ii, „05,1 .,., . .. . _ yam., *' �`: }' ' - '` '0^"%'S''`. •^` ' ,l,-r-.=,:c").:41..- + �n ' ' .f, .p'„t GULF SHORC BLVDy�,cPr,''� i. A , , 44, { M °- op---.-"`-:-. r ',1,..41.�n� J Pte, to o ii t.',.. . 4..., - • w, #^r 1 k f X cc? c i Y r. ` %m ,:u n - - : — "fit A ,,i(<" a� x VI t 'g 4 XzM dk' {, y:vn �'J x?'. l #":k rs..�s 0. M`^ r Pry c aCi . ra .+a '` s , i yx'u"'� E yk a �'SS / ; t., ,fie ' ' ' '' f °TMs' { 1. 9 ' o LL � N�s ai • a y� •� � o-�5' � c .U. W �, far ��,° U � EL C id a ro N N of 11 t1 U N ✓ �• ' E w a Q a_ ii v C 6,al c J ,� 0 N , .o C 0.. z 1 ti N to 2 0 L u yaotE yrn T a O A< '°" ' .t, ao>� i, a co�L c o0 0 n m oma7o -t I mU m cU rn"� N N N C 2 S -yaV w SE¢oU aN d i O« N a - 0 oo m = c o o w OWZOa Me4v G C —3 W U O it yy z Packet Page -1557- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. '6.`4ir �, ,.rte i� Y.)�'''''. M C Z ilh: J y, e LL, PO . ''kla . #r 'P' ..,""' c '[• '� 4 cam': U C Z etl O-t —lit tt, d)re a�z was° . U o a m 4 ' Y kt 3,p, ' Ate_ U o + of t iF SNORE 6LV0'C'Y="' '(a`-zu lit.. .� ,. 'ir-""fit : Gu� ' �tari` _ _'i 2 ,� -.. 4 �.,�..- 9�� r Q9 wt d TIT ' -. w�.# �,4 'it J , Yi'A °o �` —m $ pNj ! m a. `� Vv f a N N ',� v 2. It�.. 0 ,4, x a ,,,„4.....--.:?,,,,..,,,,,,,,',- `S« c °e , ,, ;r _'.- +: , ,,r--,-,----.., W,� tee P' r : k x ;��v k .e R rte 7 R t Y t, N U ¢ U 3, (I1 t0 U N Y 1 ! ,- d LL '' C 4 x i, l '-• = l N un s q OMN I O NOriS '1 Z = o _.�....' fr -_. I F r . -, ._. . ...., + I{! IIP g° E 1H 9 �; {2 v t't .y. . I C O L�d 9 QO UO ka # .�n l N U E am 2 U y o e< 3.� 3c N O 9 Nm O.O U w m' ' S n. N U dtnN ° N..` X90 o f°` Gf y Uo OI—ZDO aNU 0_y' 3i.de,_ wry.i-U O mm Z r Z _ Packet Page -1558- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. s '.., '''',!':,..1.11- g, N--47,, `d-' -r �R " ,.,'+1,•,m. ., , W � . , '° _ 1 F- '' a "am,",7, ' , ,f"'''":-.1-ii ''''tl.'25-1--. a �y , o g�w zcr8gw a - Ucm ^�ma LLz r r tia.- it, Y+� a �3 - 114,1 '-')T114 t . .5 ,lr. .404 J^ Q'. a wn- 1.F?SHOREaBLVD . �- N V.{ N fE 'rya !D fn �° � o ,(Or:'Nt CI) ' ' 41..%' 'lo I' t t0 '"""4"".v y .-+` ' •to A y .1 a ,,,:; ,.,94,,,,,,,,,,,,;.4.t„.„;., A• - p*.r.; ,z, OODLBE o E a, � �w2 6 '3r '� N1 5 A};' "' f ■ D 1 v W °�+a �e`x ��'our k' � F ��s.� "�� s - 0 -� �g f��.& k k'``��z �� t r£a -�`.. a:.�� ` 1 � 7 � ,'i ,,= U ti i W , rn c m a r s,4 • N tl, u °' em • m Ck q a 3 �• .0 I • J w, iw 'Y $ E N O M N O 0 c .$' , m L C n° E M cc E m�co =�y° £ ' E ° m c m u� � f i Y I y ° e o na m p �q} �* l C- Q O a Og�R^ y.yCyii z �(( a '� m E Q O ° °�'-_,,,,--.',1-,,,,: am Qo2'1am / z cyry N ° w F ° om.coJ N 0-,00_ ,,,,:: 00._ O N f" w.aa rao a Id u > H Z Packet Page-1559- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. z• r�?M 1 1'' a'. ..'"r� 2 dFSt '�;r ..rrr- m V d 2 Z: rn i, [- .j,,`'' ?. a r-;t .rte c. A ,� .4 w a�i of W n<.E,gv °z # y .. 6 !« s .w O li ,z u4,9 Sffi O ,• .„,,,,,4. ,, ,-,,..: . , ,,-,.k,--, 4 _ .. kris. .� �.'^a U 2 a8 a ..t U i:.. .,._-...:11 ._ you '' '' U O a lP a »,,, J Q ilftl-tiai 4-4.t-' ...-,...-;,:',/----?".. --_- ,:-`�` _F' k. � `` .'}� _, 1 4 u� 711 ` Y,g� ,� e R a. �.. t� F V pA y 1E „ R Guff 51 re Blvd. "",: F le t ?. ,w , 141 R �v timisrf 1.• ." a '•iiik,,4,014 o at ar. 04= *. •- mm 7 T�w n. .-. � va „,,,,5...;..,. . ., , it ,„„44/41 it -sail .1 "' 'xr� ,, � Q c ssa000 scat' it !. Pt 'k' _ U 4 � 7 th sic k 0 al i u. a F„ U t: lO d u 0] 0 U d Q ji �p a ii y E dr ro "' '�; 4 ir.1.b.. f0 N (� C N'12 i x 1^rEB LLN0ri2 0• � �', x� 'S `` x ' rr n 1 'moo `;'m cajE C y m , # iN` ,F.. —i Lto20--8 5. %U U l0 C U N '^ Gl .+n GHQ O?`Gl O_�' w °: N 1-3'U-.N N i X . _ O N fi ..lz,ea�...aa cth32 'z n Z Packet Page-1560- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ILI Ili Q m e IT C K Z 1; o L 6.'' ` a V>-g._ e'mo e i m � E zao ''s 0 t 9 r ' . ..13 o W '*s z d y ,, . II il -i, : « ,Y F< i tt gm.O1 Za.V8'iQ O c i ` � r . -a 4.:''� a a' w, J° w IS ,.., . , , _„,,...,. , . v.,,,, "V.*',Villh, N`P; ' '''' -7-,,,.. 1 F ti `dau' �:r �'a, ck .� a FC ° A r� m '' ry 4 �,,T ; r i� 1. fSI ' w� „� 4l j ':P S i 3x l''' —' f k ,.-G'elf SHOREBLVD yaw' °'F 1--;:--- c, q � Fr•j?a�.w" .4.--„,,,„„ ,-,t�� a.s �-�a �"�Y°`� ;,,q,. 4 t i.;r �"' y l= $'f ` 'L ro � !n t �f, •yam. ";_,, 1 r 1 a�i �. 3 tU41E' , "`f LL W[ ,4 r'U .'�ta:. 4, t� ! .. is mp lk ;a Fig Nor rn r ti Me r r"J •"`'`r'a$,�.moe'w4,. 4 W L c LU E'F ?r '• w."', ye �'{ § .F g W; t ^ $y k ,c ii � ,l'-',',,,,,;1";:`''46£2i@ id rn 0-"? '? k k3 tp .z �N ;h co 5.E ' fy' ,- Y CL o N N U u ii 0., d m m !p Z Q is . J i �> qt X #I o N o -No�2 ¢ . . era ' muxi{, Z r m 2_a R,m w c� E•/ ri m a `o W a a» w� N f i Ks z pY, St ,- * � °taco h3x $ F xr r om �aR+ ` " h _ 0 U _amm U N C ygOJ N Q g V Q w..aom ac a a mOU a al UiZN OC7 c 0 U°' O 1.- > x N 3 N -C Z C9 @ Packet Page -156 10/8/2013 16v .A.1 6z .rho, . .;% ,-3g...-, ? C t0 W p s^�. L ' sa•- o v e. „ w z a st a m v oQmfr°@ m , 4; 8 ` , ,-,m33 _ z in LL1 CQ,, }r 2 t4 >p kY Y d 4 ti ,,,,..1.._ ...,,,:, ".�.. „..„1,4 ( ter ." 4�. j - N.-At rr- iy a �.4c'we`°' Gult S Blvtl ,�q � _a-+ yr . " �'f_�v• q1, Y.'. L N 1 r dAVx u.�br..t- ^ q k .'i 1 ° tr. 111 a iy n V r .a1 y m n: ac X �, tr x i€tz c c 5_, s.: � t g k 1 O E E :f Yr F ,' r` t `e t!.,'r d r,, a'a',' ' a. m u w c, c RK 41 O _c m m m U N `, = LL lL Vie.,. CI) C g ry { 1 i — f S{ £w Z o 0 m a e M m m E.° E ° E w .us.,,a.uw.,,a..,.e... . 5,' ‘>'. = mc -F,� m r c.# C ti K A+4. # �y7 . o ;y . o2',gy k 8U °1 y °i . +wt m m E Q ° U w m a5j;, a C L o— N` N M a o 3 I .u, .a •,; :N .ao X.°z Z F u as Packet Page-1562- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. , s" [ t '�• ofty�`r. 2 Pill 2� �is G ar IH W��! r I `r ". i 7 'r�^�•5-+7 — 5.. 4 g—" - . . 7.0..E.:-...-F-n, ' ; I . . .1k_tahwr ,t,° 1 i ,.may,r� - sx p t .� f a V E Mi +. sK --u. j, , , � *� �A.-- GuH Sho e�'81 A +r c �� + .,,„ P` 3� , ,- N EU ti,-1, AY l�f�U .�,.�!� . o 50 f �; .,y a I . .v N �ooze;' o LL o '0." 21:73 t 111r* ixt SOW. .--,,t ' �{ y . $ .,..,........;,;,,,,A -.4. . ,.„ E'f T'"wa ,.R � P�3, y^ t7-ST ff ,� E W tl, . k , S :., VI!' ? , . 1 s k 4 +,-.#'"',-. i„ # k-„ , F F 3' s z-7t.;•. m"- 3 rk ,, {t W LL G t N Q U d O Z -'R 4 C�'4 m N- H I ¢II •N y a O C M 2 51 2 N m M IA 2 cu?al p 6 C W -o E° mcc .1� yamcoy _ :$ (urn— H o m a O d T rm n Le,y a a a.o n o m Fa II 0 . Le I m E rn o y 7 0 m C A O d II or CII L II O C i d r.) o_ c U 0 t y E p p U w-emu"f y�, y ' it . a Q a p.7 i.+ ' 1,,,,,;1,4,11,,,,,,,,,', F e k-"dir :x "a5=if Q -o N 3.c of-o,-TD� O- m mm 0 U i ew 'af'" Mom y UcZ9 o.o- 9, a d N M-^" u> -� � 0 .-s '3 r r�r`F N / 563-r G Packet page-1OU Z'^CC 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ..„, ,..,..,, 1St-I 11 rt 3 a1 7. VIIIIIT it y � 9 kI i r . . w y waQRa o Myy' .S�T'Y` U 0 2 2 m giiLL— t, 1 f 1sc r :100 ! t J to . tie i { ± f "-swim V e" 4 } M1. .A {¢` rA yam+ t� ..dra$r .,,s +a< ., .. \u-Y F 1 ,.-yjY f`.1 Ate,, '9�� Jf (NU sy ° ,ft9 -- 1-,-�-. . _ •G�If Shoi Blvd '.>. E _� ,y" ;14., ,,f ' v.'h 'N F 1,G N J 1a 4p. I�N o .��11 " a � � III' . s va° a� , ,.' et 0 sr 6 4 2. . r O E� ' ' s , m, <�` � n ' .1":„'',. I" ,,x,„,...---..5.-� ' ' t . Ozv r ` xt. 1LL W,n �d 2 -' .�'n h 1 if " r� ''1' ••-• ` n " Y a '� ' � .LL a" x'v��`.-4�S z 4.4F f ` , . 0 5 J ' ar'�a d s.rz- U 3 a f s a 1 A O COMN- Cl v W::, � °c F 3'i a t E a..e.H `a m E n N m`r' �y �: x '' .- - tr1 {{ , � .. omr py s r "- om ay r,,, t - y U v m m o w N w dQ o.7 a N i 10/8/2013 +► +t, k 1 6z .A .16LL w . µ r a i:. r d t . z ' o mm0 za= sm* m of w� a sv' A , ° z"� ,fi .ce * * LC Z a- ,.:.. . .: ,._...,„;;;,. . If o itror Mme a U i \" e+"•k~ 7 5 . . t dew t , I + 'Q i iy i r t F'4N'�� .fir 4{ j a. � *'' P... , , 114', ,-,,,-----Pmk, . ...- --.... ...„ -..-...-.---...,:.- --- . -ei.,:t ..,..,t. . '1.2v-',- '''''.-- '''''''':'-'7.-,:;.,.' ....--"'"' : ..',- , ,,,r3az000 �. ' * I . Ia ` ?-� g,�nPzee m '` £ ` -}- gymx" sa�` i a -2 sa tyr + I r[. „ a{ c.' E LI- +r1 w .., a I �: 1 i' w' ' : ''''. Z i W 0 co 5 a 06 y N U Q g.O"' , yt j y�}'y L C z , CO U N '° O Y.. Q' m vm I.„.:- . . ,. -_,,,, . ul f_ i m (Si y F . N 4• tiNpci2 K L O E M 7 m.c d a, ', , , ,_ v 1 +� Fx � a y� O O d y�O j" � -,2...; d KkL• (y.. V 1 j ,� ^x — O n� 4 r . 7,-147,3,°,--g' U U N C U y C 9,,k ' s- � ," " "'.. 4. t-mot,Y k l� "# � �A f U� t5;6 q^b �f . C O=y a ~M - y:�y ' a p O N O N ggS;li xr I /�Z2d mNU N � ciri d>O U x 0 S Z , Packet Page-1565- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 2 Hotel Licenses and Property Information Packet Page -1566- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Collier County Local Government Funding Request Property Name: Edgewater Beach Hotel and Club Property Address: 1901 Gulf Shore Boulevard North, Naples, FL 34102 License Number: HOT2100269 The referenced property has a total of 126 units,of which,126 are available to the public on a rental basis.Therefore,a total of 100%percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from the hotel website in August of 2013. Collier County Local Government Funding Request Property Name: Naples Beach &Golf Hotel Property Address: 851 Gulf Shore Boulevard North, Naples, FL 34102 License Number: HOT2100044 The referenced property has a total of 317 units,of which,317 are available to the public on a rental basis.Therefore,a total of 100%percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from the hotel website in August of 2013. Collier County Local Government Funding Request Property Name: LaPlaya Beach Resort Property Address: 9891 Gulf Shore Drive License Number: HOT2102616 The referenced property has a total of 189 units,of which, 189 are available to the public on a rental basis.Therefore,a total of 100%percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from the hotel website in August of 2013. Collier County Packet Page-1567- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Local Government Funding Request Property Name:Vanderbilt Beach Resort Property Address: 9256 Gulf Shore Drive, Naples, FL 34108 License Number:CND2100054 The referenced property has a total of 47 units,of which,47 are available to the public on a rental basis.Therefore,a total of 100%percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from the hotel website in August of 2013. Collier County Local Government Funding Request Property Name: Ritz-Carlton Property Address: 280 Vanderbilt Beach Rd, Naples, FL 34108 License Number: HOT2101047 The referenced property has a total of 450 units,of which,450 are available to the public on a rental basis.Therefore,a total of 100%percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from the hotel website in August of 2013. Collier County Local Government Funding Request Property Name:Vanderbilt Shores Rec Assn Inc. Property Address: 10701 Gulf Shore Drive, Naples, FL 33963 License Number: PR1M006385 The referenced property has a total of 28 units,of which,28 are available to the public on a rental basis.Therefore,a total of 100%percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from the property rental website in August of 2013. http://www.vanderbiltbeach.com/vanderbilt-shores.php Packet Page -1568- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Collier County Local Government Funding Request Property Name: Bayshores of Vanderbilt Beach Property Address: 10475 Gulf Shore Drive. Naples, FL 34108 License Number: PR1M007820 The referenced property has a total of 54 units,of which,8 are available to the public on a rental basis.Therefore,a total of 15%percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from Nancy Hainge, Office Manager in September 2013. Packet Page -1569- DBPR-PANTHERS RPN LLC; Doing Business As: EDGEWATER BEACH HOTE' ' T_.__ , _r, 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 9:01:02 AM 8/24/2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: PANTHERS RPN LLC (Primary Name) EDGEWATER BEACH HOTEL AND CLUB (DBA Name) Main Address: 1901 GULFSHORE BLVD N NAPLES Florida 34102 County: COLLIER License Mailing: 1901 GULFSHORE BLVD N NAPLES FL 34102 County: COLLIER LicenseLocation: 1904 GULFSHORE BLVD N NAPLES FL 34102 County: COLLIER License Information License Type: Hotel Rank: Hotel License Number: HOT2100269 Status: Current,Active Licensure Date: 12/20/2004 Expires: 12/01/2013 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective View Related License Information View License Complaint View Recent Inspections 1940 North Monroe Street.Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email: Customer Contact Center::Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395 The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395(.'Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change. https://www.myfloridalicense.com/Licens Packet Page -1570-d=4BC416781D74B3E7FB... 8/24/2013 DBPR- WATKINS H B & JONES E A; Doing Business As: PENT HOUSE HOTEL 10 n°�� ' ..r 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 9:02:24 AM 824/2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: WATKINS H B &)ONES E A (Primary Name) PENT HOUSE HOTEL (DBA Name) Main Address: 851 N GULF SHORE BLVD NAPLES Florida 339405332 County: COLLIER License Mailing: 851 N GULF SHORE BLVD NAPLES FL 34102 County: COLLIER LicenseLocation: 851 N GULF SHORE BLVD NAPLES FL 34102 County: COLLIER License Information License Type: Hotel Rank: Hotel License Number: HOT2100044 Status: Current,Active Licensure Date: 01/01/1901 Expires: 12/01/2013 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective View Related License Information View License Complaint View Recent Inspections 1940 North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email: Customer Contact Center::Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395( The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released In response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395V.'Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address If they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change. https:/lwww.myfloridalicense.com/Licensl Packet Page -1571-dmC9FFCC6AC3C665C935... 8/24/2013 DBPR- LA PLAYA LLC; Doing Business As: LA PLAYA RESORT, Hotel 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 9:04:24 AM 8/24/2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: LA PLAYA LLC (Primary Name) LA PLAYA RESORT (DBA Name) Main Address: 9891 GULF SHORE DR NAPLES Florida 34108 County: COLLIER License Mailing: 9891 GULFSHORE DR NAPLES FL 34108 County: COLLIER LicenseLocation: 9891 GULFSHORE DR NAPLES FL 34108 County: COLLIER License Information License Type: Hotel Rank: Hotel License Number: HOT2102616 Status: Current,Active Licensure Date: 01/30/2002 Expires: 12/01/2013 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective View Related License Information View License Complaint View Recent Inspections 1940 North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399 ::Email: Customer Contact Center :: Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395V The State of Florida is an AA/EE0 employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.if you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395.*Pursuant to Section 455.275{1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change. https://www.myfloridalicense.com/Licensc Packet Page-1572-3=C35DD7D743EC92D8F1... 8/24/2013 DBPR- VANDERBILT BEACH MOTEL; Doing Business As: VANDERBILT MOT*"10/8/2013 16.A.16. 9:05:24 AM 8/24/2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: VANDERBILT BEACH MOTEL(Primary Name) VANDERBILT MOTEL CONDO (DBA Name) Main Address: 9256 N GULFSHORE DR NAPLES Florida 34108 County: COLLIER License Mailing: 9256 N GULFSHORE DR NAPLES FL 34108 County: COLLIER LicenseLocation: 9256 N GULFSHORE DR NAPLES FL 34108 County: COLLIER License Information License Type: Vacation Rental - Condo Rank: Condo License Number: CND2100054 Status: Current,Active Licensure Date: 01/01/1901 Expires: 12/01/2013 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective Group 11/15/2002 View Related License Information View License Complaint View Recent Inspections 1940 North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email: Customer Contact Center::Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395 The State of Florida is an AAJEEO employer.Copyriqht 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395.`Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change. https://www.myfloridalicense.com/Licens Packet Page-1573- d=88C748F6EF238E311 BF... 8/24/2013 DBPR- RITZ-CARLTON HOTEL COMPANY LLC & CCRC; Doing Business As: PTT' "---- , ' 10/8/20101 3 16.A.16. 7:37:27 AM 8/25/2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: RITZ-CARLTON HOTEL COMPANY LLC & CCRC (Primary Name) RITZ CARLTON NAPLES (THE) (DBA Name) Main Address: 280 VANDERBILT BEACH ROAD NAPLES Florida 34108 County: COLLIER License Mailing: 280 VANDERBILT BEACH ROAD NAPLES FL 34108 County: COLLIER LicenseLocation: 280 VANDERBILT BCH RD NAPLES FL 34108 County: COLLIER License Information License Type: Hotel Rank: Hotel License Number: HOT2101047 Status: Current,Active Licensure Date: 01/01/1901 Expires: 12/01/2013 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective View Related License Information View License Complaint View Recent Inspections 1940 North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email: Customer Contact Center::Customer Contact Center: 850,487.1395V The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1345(g.'Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S. must provide the Department with an email address it they have one.The emails provided may be used far official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change. iirOFfk https://www.myfloridalicense.com/Licens Packet Page-1574-d=347876E1F8D253FCC8F... 8/25/2013 DBPR - VANDERBILT SHORES I, Condominium Project T1— _ 1 —r' 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 7:39:09 AM 8/2&2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: VANDERBILT SHORES I (Primary Name) (DBA Name) Main Address: 10701 GULF SHORE DRIVE NAPLES Florida 339632092 County: COLLIER License Mailing: License Location: License Information License Type: Condominium Project Rank: Condo Project License Number: PR1M006385 Status: Approved,Recorded Licensure Date: 07/19/1979 Expires: 01/01/2014 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective Multi 03/25/2011 View Related License Information View License Complaint View Additional Information 1940 North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email:Customer Contact Center:: Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395* The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records,If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395*."Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this cnange. https://www.myfloridalicense.com/Licens Packet Page-1575-d=584C169C4CEB571F826... 8/25/2013 DBPR-BAYSHORES OF VANDERBILT BEACH PH II, Condominium Project 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 7:39:50 AM 8/25/2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: BAYSHORES OF VANDERBILT BEACH PH II (Primary Name) (DBA Name) Main Address: 10475 GULFSHORE DR NAPLES Florida 339632034 County: COLLIER License Mailing: LicenseLocation: License Information License Type: Condominium Project Rank: Condo Project License Number: PR1M007820 Status: Approved,Recorded Licensure Date: 07/30/1979 Expires: 01/01/2014 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective ,. Multi View Related License Information View License Complaint View Additional Information 1940. North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399 :: Email:Customer Contact Center::Customer Contact Center: 850.487.1395V The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright 2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395.'Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address if they have one.The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee. However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change_ https://www.myfloridalicense.com/Licens Packet Page-1576-d=F2538501BE4D28EA15F... 8/25/2013 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 3 Corps of Engineers Study Authorization for Naples, Park Shore and Vanderbilt Beaches and Project Worksheet Packet Page-1577- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. From: Val Gelnovatch [mailto:vgelnovatch @tfgnet.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 04, 2012 12:25 PM To: WightDebbie; McAlpinGary Cc: Amanda Wood Subject: RE: Collier County and Marco Island Beach Collier County's WRDA 2007 authorization authorized the USACOE to undertake a reconnaissance study when it stated: "The Secretary shall conduct a study to determine the feasibility of carrying out a project for hurricane and storm damage reduction and flood damage reduction in the vicinity of Vanderbilt, Park Shore and Naples beaches,Collier County, Florida." Ever since then the USACOE needed to allocate $100k to undertake the recon study. We have worked with the delegation and USACOE on many different strategies to get USACOE to fund this recon study. Collier's delegation has requested funding to complete the reconnaissance study for more than several years. After several congressional cycles went by with the study unfunded,we met with USACOE at county offices in April of 2011, and subsequently submitted a request to Senator Nelson to authorize USACOE to be able to sign, upon completion, a USACOE-approved, County-funded study, and move it to the Feasibility phase. There has been no movement on WRDA since that submission 18 months ago (mostly due to the earmark moratorium hindering this highly-earmarked bill.) The Congress would like to move a WRDA bill now; however, the bill cannot contain anything that is project or location specific, since that would be considered an earmark. During the past two years the USACOE and the White House have not included funding in the President's budget for our recon study. Congress has not been prevented from earmarking funds for the project during this Congress, and the USACOE has not been able to include funds for the project in its Workplan because Congress will not allow appropriations to be used for new start projects. From: WightDebbie [mailto:DebbieWight @colliergov.net] Sent: Friday, August 31, 2012 4:19 PM To: McAlpinGary; Val Gelnovatch Cc: WightDebbie; Amanda Wood Subject: RE: Collier County and Marco Island Beach Importance: High Gary, Here are FY 11 and FY 12 briefs/requests for Beach Renourishment. Both also indicate we were authorized in 2007 in the Water Resources Development Act (WRDA). Val, You are probably gone for the long weekend. Please see Gary's request below. I put the attachments above for requests in FY 11 and FY 12. Do we have Packet Page-1578- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. anything in writing? We received the 2007 WRDA authorization for Beaches, then we have been working on getting the Recon. Thanks! Have a GREAT weekend, ladies. -Debbie From: McAlpinGary Sent: Friday,August 31, 2012 3:52 PM To: WightDebbie Subject: FW: Collier County and Marco Island Beach Debbie, Can I get some help with this on Tuesday? Steve needs confirmation that Collier was approved for a beach recon study and also proof that we have requested funding. From: Keehn, Stephen [mailto:Stephen.Keehn(&shawgro.com] Sent:Thursday, August 30, 2012 10:34 AM To: McAlpinGary Cc: Sharp, Nicole Subject: Collier County and Marco Island Beach Gary Do you have any letters or agreements from the Corps stating they are working on or towards a phase of a Corps project for you beaches? I need this for the LGFR etepluut Senior Coastal Engineer Coastal Planning& Engineering, Inc. Shaw Group Direct 561-361-3151 Office 561-391-8102 (fax 9116) Mobile 561-441-5499 stephen.keehn@shawgrp.com Packet Page-1579- Coder County 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Collier County Federal Legislative Agenda FY 2012 Appropriations 2011 Grants Funding Priorities Priority Targeted Potential Federal Resources 1-75/Everglades Boulevard Interchange Federal Transportation Appropriations $4 million for design Transportation Reauthorization Bill FHWA Grant Opportunities 1-75/Collier Boulevard/SR 84(Davis Boulevard) Federal Transportation Appropriations $4.5 million to update PD&E and begin design Transportation Reauthorization Bill FHWA Grant Opportunities Naples Bay Restoration Federal Energy and Water Appropriations (project authorized in 2007 Water Resources& Direct USACE Allocations Development Act) $450,000 for US Army Corps of Engineers study Beach Renourishment Federal Energy and Water Appropriations (project authorized in 2007 WRDA) Direct USACE Allocations $100,000 to fund engineering studies and permitting Vanderbilt Lagoon Federal Energy and Water Appropriations (project authorized in 2007 WRDA) Direct USACE Allocations $250,000 to study feasibility of environmental restoration Tri-County Water Interconnect Federal Energy and Water Appropriations (project authorized in 2007 WRDA) Direct USACE Allocations $5,000,000 for water interconnections with the cities EPA Grant Opportunities of Naples and Marco Island Collier Health Services Federal Health and Human Services Appropriations $500,000 for Assistance to Rural and Senior Health and Human Services Grant Opportunities Residents Ochopee EMS/Fire Station on 1-75 National Park Service Cooperative Agreement $3,000,000 for 3,000-square-foot facility with 2 bays DHS and DO1 Grant Opportunities $6,000,000 for Med Flight Aircraft DHS and DO1 Grant Opportunities Collier Area Transit Federal Transit Administration Grant Opportunities $6,000,000 for Radio Road Transit Site Development Transportation Reauthorization Bill As New Federal Funding Opportunities Arise During the Year,Additional Projects May be Identified Packet Page-1580- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Co er County gaK Collier County Beach Renourishment Congressional District: Representative Connie Mack Problem: Collier County Beaches are designated as critically eroded by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. Past renourishments have occurred within a 8-10 year cycle with the last renourishment occurring in 2005. Project Description and Status: A Reconnaissance Study is necessary for the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to determine a federal interest in the project. The purpose of the project is to renourish Collier County, Florida beaches to protect the upland structures, promote a healthy ecosystem and advance tourism within the county. Beaches that are in need of renourishment are Vanderbilt Beach, Park Shore Beach, Naples Beach and Marco Island Beach. The project received the following authorization in the Water Resources Development Act (WRDA) of 2007: SEC.4033. COLLIER COUNTY BEACHES, FLORIDA.The Secretary shall conduct a study to determine the feasibility of carrying out a project for hurricane and storm damage reduction and flood damage reduction in the vicinity of Vanderbilt, Park Shore,and Naples beaches,Collier County, Florida. Funding Needs and Budget: The County is seeking $100,000 in the USACE budget for the USACE to perform the Reconnaissance Study,generate a project management plan and a cost sharing agreement with the county. Federal Funding History: There is no history of federal funding for this project. For More Information: Debbie Wight, Collier County, (239)252-8113,debbiewight@colliergov.net Amanda Wood,The Ferguson Group, (202)261-3684, awood @tfgnet.com Val Gelnovatch,The Ferguson Group, (202)270-4074,vgelnovatch @tfgnet.com Packet Page-1581- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. U.S.DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY O.M.B.No.1660-0017 PROJECT WORKSHEET Expires October 31,2008 Public reporting burden for this form is estimated to average 90 minutes. Burden means time,effort and financial resources expended by persons to generate,maintain, disclose,or to provide information to us. You may send comments regarding the burden estimate or any aspect of the collection,including suggestions for reducing the burden to:Information Collection Management,U.S.Department of Homeland Security,Federal Emergency Management Agency,500 C Street,SW,Washington,DC 20472,Paperwork Reduction Project(OMB Control number 1660-0017).You are not required to respond to this collection information unless a valid OMB number appears in the upper right corner of this form. NOTE:Do not send your completed questionnaire to this address. DECLARATION NO. PW REF NO. DATE FIPS NO. CATEGORY NEMIS NO. FEMA 1785 DR FL JCCCOIG 11/19/08 021-99021-00 G APPLICANT WORK COMPLETED AS OF: Collier,County of DATE: PERCENT: 08/19/08 0% DAMAGED FACILITY COUNTY BEACHES:Vanderbilt/Park Shore/Naples Collier LOCATION LATITUDE LONGITUDE Naples/Naples Park/North Naples,FL (See Damage (See Damage Description') Description') Was this site previously damaged? a Yes C No C Unsure DAMAGE DESCRIPTION AND DIMENSIONS: As a result of high winds and surf associated with Tropical Storm(TS)Fay during the period August 18 and September 12,2008,the Applicant sustained significant beach erosion of 174,576 CY along three(3)sites totalling 38,789 LF(7.35 MI)of shoreline fronting on the cities of Naples, North Naples and Naples Park. The storm also destroyed stabilizing dune vegetation intermittently along—5,367 LF (1.02 MI)of shoreline. One multi-site PW is being written for work on beaches in the Naples area,as follows: SITE#1: Vanderbilt Beach-Lat:26.26287,Long:-81.82507 (Extending from R-22 to R-33,for a total distance of 11,526 LF or 2.18 MI) SITE#2: Park Shore Beach-Lat:26.19649,Long:-81.81578 (Extending from R-48 to R-55,for a total distance of 8,443 LF or 1.60 MI) SITE#3: Naples Beach-Lat:26.13177,Long:-81.80631 (Extending from R-58A to R-78,for a total distance of 18,820 LF or 3.56 MI) SCOPE OF WORK: DAMAGE DESCRIPTION AND DIMENSIONS(CONT'D): Total sand losses to all three beaches attributable to TS Fay are based upon a pre-storm survey(June 2007)and post-storm survey (September 2008)by Applicant's coastal engineer,Coastal Planning&Engineering(CPE), in their attached report,Collier County Beach Renourishment Project-Post TS Fay Storm Report,October 2008. CPE has determined that 174,576 CY of sand is needed to restore the beach to pre-storm conditions. The applicant is not participating in the"Pilot Program"in regards to this PW. SCOPE OF WORK: 1. One multi-site PW is being written for the Category G work on beaches in the Naples area because:(a)the subject sites are in close proximity to one another,(b)the nature of the repairs are identical among all three sites;and(c)the Applicant has indicated contracts will be executed to cover the sequential work items described below across all areas. Does the Scope of Work change the pre-disaster conditions at the site? C' Yes (e' No Special Considerations issues included? a Yes r No Is there insurance coverage on this facility? C Yes (I' No Hazard Mitigation proposal included? C Yes a No PROJECT COST ITEM CODE NARRATIVE QUANTITY UNIT UNIT PRICE COST 1 0 WORK TO BE COMPLETED 2 9001 DREDGE MOBILIZATION/DEMOBILIZATION 1 LS $4,800,000.00 $ 4,800,000.00 3 9001 SAND, DREDGE,PLACE AND GRADE 174576 CY $29.50 $ 5,149,992.00 4 9001 TRAWLING,SEA TURTLE 30 DAY $4,000.00 $ 120,000.00 ----6-----5 - 9001 TURBIDITY MONITORING 1 LS $53,000.00 $ 53,000.00 9001 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING 1 LS $50,000.00 $ 50,000.00 7 9001 CONSTRUCTION SURVEYS 2 EA $60,000.00 $ 120,000.00 8 9001 DUNE VEGETATION PLANTING(ALL AREAS) 53670 EA $0.55 $ 29,518.50 9 9001 DESIGN&ENGINEERING COSTS-Contract Estimate 1 LS $720,509.44 $ 720,509.44 SUBTOTAL FROM COST CONTINUATION PAGE(S) $ 360,254.72 TOTAL PROJECT COST $ 11,403,274.66 PREPARED BY: Joseph Chesler TITLE: Project Specialist-Coastal FEMA PAC: Donald Soegaard STATE PAC: Jorge Alpizar APPLICANT: Len Price DATE: PHONE: (239)252-3646 FEMA Form 90-91,FEB O6 REPLACES ALL PREVIOUS VERSIONS Packet Page-1582- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Page 1 of 1 FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY ADDITIONAL PROJECT COSTS DECLARATION NO. PW REF NO. DATE FIPS NO. CATEGORY NEMIS NO. FEMA J FL DR 1785 JCCCOIG 11/19/08 021-99021-00 APPLICANT COUNTY Collier,County of Collier PROJECT COSTS(CONTINUED) ITEM -CODE NARRATIVE QUANTITY UNIT UNIT PRICE COST 10 9901 PROJECT MANAGEMENT-SUBGRANTEE 1 LS $308,789.76 $ 308,789.76 —11 9901 DIRECT ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS-SUBGRANTEE I LS $51,464.96 $ 51,464.96 $ $ $ $ $ $ . _ $ $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ $ $ --r- $ ---- $ —-- $ --7-- TOTAL COSTS THIS PAGE $ 360,254.72 PREPARED BY; Joseph Chesler TITLE: Project Specialist-Coastal Revised Jan-07 Packet Page-1583- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Page 1 of 2 .,. FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY DAMAGE DESCRIPTION & SCOPE OF WORK DECLARATION NO. PW REF NO. DATE FIPS NO. CATEGORY NEMIS NO. FEMA 1 1785 DR I FL JCCCOIG 11/19/08 021-99021-00 G APPLICANT COUNTY Collier,County of Collier DAMAGE DESCRIPTION&SCOPE OF WORK(CONTINUED): 2. Various approaches to beach nourishment have routinely been used to maintain Applicants beaches since 1995. The Applicant has not gone longer than four years without renourishing their beaches by some means;either by inland truck haul or offshore dredging, including inlet bypassing. These events are listed in CPE's Post-TS Fay Report(see Table 1)and demonstrate an ongoing commitment to periodic beach maintenance activities. The latest federal participation in beach renourishment occurred following Hurricane Wilma in 2006(DR-1609-PW 2698Nanderbilt Beach,PW 2700/Naples Beach and PW 2704/Park Shore Beach). 3. The study area for the attached Post-TS Fay Report includes the full linear extents of all three of the subject beaches,except in one case. The Applicant has indicated that only 11,526 LF of 15,536 LF(74%)of Vanderbilt Beach(R-22 to R30)and the southern portion of Pelican Bay Beach(R-30 to R-33)will be included in the current renourishment project(see Post-TS Fav Report,Table 4)to restore the beach width to pre-storm conditions. The remainder of Pelican Bay Beach(R-34 and R-37)is not maintained by Applicant and public access is limited in that area. 4. CPE calculated the eligible sand loss by first measuring the reduction in beach width across the full extent of the subject beaches (243,094 CY). That value was reduced to account for the average beach erosion rate of 68,518 CY/yr established by CPE through monitoring shoreline dynamics between June 2007 and September 2008. The resultant volume over the project extents defined in#3, above is equilvalent to 174,576 CY(see attached tables, revised by Project Specialist from Post-TS Fav Report,Tables 4,5,6,7 and 8), which reflects the quantity of sand deemed eligible on this PW. [Cost Item#2] 5. These three beaches are to be restored to pre-storm conditions,as defined by as-built surveys of work the previous beach renourishment project in 2006/07 completed under Collier County Beach Renourishment Bid No.05-3584(May,2006,see Repetitive Loss). Work will consist of mobilizing offshore dredge equipment and pumping,placing and shaping-174,576 CY of beach-quality sand that meets approved geotechnical specifications(see Post-TS Fav Report,Table 3). The offshore borrow area for the approved sand is located approximately 33.1 miles northwest of Delnor-Wiggins State Park. Sand is to be placed and shaped per engineering specifications in the attached technical drawings to restore these beaches to pre-storm design elevations. Work will be conducted similar to approach used for the 2006/2007 renourishment project 6. The design standard for the previous 2006/07 renourishment project was set in the preliminary engineering report(CPE,2003)and is reflected in the attached engineering design drawings,dated September 15,2004. The design standards for Vanderbilt Beach,Park Shore Beach,and Naples Beach were 100,85,and 100 feet,respectively. The design standard is defined as an added beach width or total beach width(see attached Beach Renourishment Design Standard). Added beach width is measured from the pre-project Mean High Water(MHW)shoreline. Total beach width is measured from a fixed baseline set at an inland seawall,edge of vegetation,building line,or equivalent,and provides a measure of the total sandy beach area. Since the total beach width criterion uses a fixed baseline,the variability of the shoreline is accounted for in the design. Areas with sufficient beach widths require less attention,which allows the fill to be distributed to the more exposed and narrow beaches. This allows regions with relatively narrow beach widths to receive more fill than placing the same fill density everywhere. A total beach width standard was used to design the 2006 project. [Cost Item#2] 7. The Applicant's engineer(CPE)indicates the estimated mobilization/demobilization costs for the proposed dredging operation have increased over the previous 2006/07 renourishment project due to several factors:(a)the prospective offshore borrow area is approximately 33.1 miles northwest of Delnor-Wiggins State Park,creating several challenges to the contractor,(b)higher deisel fuel costs;(c)use of multiple booster pumps to cover the distance of transport;(d)multiple pipeline repositionings required;and(e) complicated permitting with narrowing environmental windows(i.e.,times when construction can occur without impacting sensitive species). Accordingly,the Applicants engineer(CPE)estimates mob/demob costs for all project sites to be$4,800,000. [Cost Item#1] 8. The prospective dredging contractor,Great Lakes Dredge&Dock(GLDD),would be required to use a trawler across the project site to locate sea turtle nests and to carefully remove any active nests from the project area prior to filling operations. Similarly,permits require turbidity monitoring during construction to control suspension of solids in the water column,and environmental monitors are needed throughout the project to eliminate impacts to sensitive species within the project area. CPE estimates the combined cost of these environmental protective measures to be$223,000. [Cost Items#3,4 and 5] 9.Pre-construction and post-construction surveys would also be conducted by CPE to confirm beginning site conditions prior to dredging,placement and grading(by GLDD)and to determine final placement quantities. These two surveys would be provided at a total cost of$120,000. [Cost Item#6] PREPARED BY: Joseph Chesler TITLE: Project Specialist-Coastal Revised Jan-07 Packet Page -1584- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Page 2 of 2 FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY DAMAGE DESCRIPTION & SCOPE OF WORK DECLARATION NO. PW REF NO. DATE FIPS NO. CATEGORY NEMIS NO. FEMA FL DR 1785 JCCCOIG 11/19/08 021-99021-00 G APPLICANT COUNTY Collier,County of Collier DAMAGE DESCRIPTION&SCOPE OF WORK(CONTINUED): 10. Applicant's representative(A. Madsen)has estimated that approximately 15%of the length of dune vegetation was destroyed and requires replanting to preserve the integrity of the protective dune system. Dune plants(Sea Oats,Uniola paniculata)would be replaced across—15%of the project area,or 5,367 LF(1.02 Mt)of beachfront. An attached price quote dated September 22,2008 from the Applicants plant contractor,EarthBalance,would provide labor and plant material to install 53,670 plants(@ 10 plants/LF). The contractor's bid specifies a unit cost of$0.55/plant,for an estimated total cost of$29,519. [Cost Item#7] 11. Design&Engineering Costs: Applicant's coastal engineer(CPE)would be eligible for costs directly related to the design, installation,monitoring and related services associated with the proposed work. A standard of 7.0%of the net eligible costs is allocated for relevant design and engineering costs for this large project in accordance with Public Assistance Guide.FEMA 322/June 2007,Figure 3,pg.58. [Cost Item#8] 12. Project Management-Subgrantee: Project management costs by the Applicant are applied to the project at the rate of 3.0%of the net eligible costs. [Cost Item#10] 13. Direct Administrative Costs-Subgrantee(SDAC): Direct administrative costs by the Applicant are applied to the project at the rate of 0.5%of the net eligible costs. [Cost Item#11] 14.Applicant's documentation of claimed costs for this project have been reviewed and found to be eligible,accurate and reasonable. 15.All records for this PW must be retained at the applicant's office for a period of at least five(5)years from the final closeout of their claim. 16. Upon completion,this site will be returned to it's original design,function and capacity within the original project footprint. The Applicant is responsible for obtaining all local,state and/or federal permits as they may apply to this project. PREPARED BY: Joseph Chesler I TITLE: Project Specialist-Coastal Revised Jan-07 Packet Page-1585- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. o 8 s 9 E a I �.- p g $x°��: - - a X10 as 1 g it i li gig_- D-R--er^ ali 11 g Hill f III >a, E N N g 2Ewr .c E A % i a a, V �!WR8 E 8 co 2 ii1 o ---v1151--v-R , S�§� � 1 R a E O 4 al m a k 1k a s a a a€ o55.55k%55o =j Eg 000�iov00000 ag �. ��-'+ 30E° 08i Io6So R .S 4°'7 1 7 ri N A 4 n ° U g'" 7 Y 4 7 T^ 7 4° 2S 1K C �^R$4aq.$e��a ' ' ,::r^ :°rn�°ry°S83^eiah“e 04 1 4 i 1 i` IR i3 s 4 7 ? R. W s ili SP 4=.74':^gnq w7 I t— t-1S4^4- ., 74,r;q� ^7474 T 77 5 1. SY.m T T rv.. °4°•.4q 9 g E 3 gil g d U47AX °-•174 R;T i ill iiE 311 :wg 1 ^ R - . LI o 4, ° ! o ' a ! 1! Z .�§g gx�8,1REPEEEeEFF Ea °a gl =i oggso g&f;o :l il "S °ffi I 1 1 1 1 iss Il ri!!� i i pia'a 1 1 R i rxa«x9aY!!!” g u ��inn!!!! 01 0l� iR49a21t4VV @ggcaelt r- 1029 aaaaaaaa a Cia Minn!!!! i a aaaaaaaaa 15i_il 1 1 c1 s a s Packet Page -1586- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Beach Renourishment Design Standard 10 TOTAL BEACH WIDTH DESIGN ADDED BEACH WIDTH DESIGN EXAMPLE DESIGN TEMPLATE 5 a- >>, P RE-CONSTRUCTION Z .;f PROFILE F- - - -- -MHW 1.11 0 EXISTING PROFILE O MJ L�L ADD D B. . H WIDTH REMAINING -5 4r TOTAL BEACH WIDTH REMAINING -10 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 NOTES: DISTANCE(FEET) 1.BASELINE SET AT SEAWALL,EDGE OF VEGETATION,OR EQUIVALENT The main objective of the 2006 renourishment project was to provide an enhanced recreational beach with secondary storm protection benefits. The design standard was set in the preliminary engineering report (CPE 2003). The design standards for Vanderbilt Beach, Park Shore Beach, and Naples Beach were 100, 85, and 100 feet. The design standard can be defined as an added beach width or total beach width as illustrated in the figure above. Added beach width is measured from the pre-project MHW shoreline. Total beach width is measured from a fixed baseline set at the seawall, edge of vegetation, building line, or equivalent, and provides a measure of the total sandy beach area. Since the total beach width criterion uses a fixed baseline, the variability of the shoreline is accounted for in the design. Areas with sufficient beach widths require less attention, which allows the fill to be distributed to the more exposed and narrow beaches. This allows regions with relatively narrow beach widths to receive more fill than placing the same fill density everywhere. A total beach width standard was used to design the 2006 project. The design width does not include advanced nourishment, which is part of the fill placed in 2006. The design width is the goal for the beach width remaining after 6 years, while the advanced nourishment is the expected normal losses. We account for the difference in the Post TS Fay storm report. Steve Keehn,P.E.,CPE,November 4,2008 Packet Page -1587- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Corporate Office 2579 N.Toledo Blade 34289 North 1.42 .78 34389 941.426.7878 941.426.8778 F'a�c www.earthbalance.com [ arthBalance© Price Quote PROJECT NAME: Collier County—Additional Sea Oat Installation ATTENTION: Mr.Allen Madsen Collier County—Coastal Zone Management Department 3300 Santa Barbara Blvd. Naples, Florida 34116 SCOPE OF SERVICES: EarthBalance°will supply, deliver, and install 60,500 Sea oat(Uniola paniculata)liners within the areas listed below for the beach restoration project located in Collier County, FL. All other contracts, change orders, and terms and conditions apply to this project. Areas Linear Feet Plants per Linear Foot Total Plants Total Cost $0.55/unit R1 to R1, +600ft 600 feet 10 Plants per LF 6,000 $3,300.00 R13 to R16 3,300 feet 10 Plants per LF 33,000 $18,150.00 R55 to R57, +400ft 2,150 feet 10 Plants per LF 21,500 $11,825.00 TOTAL COST $33,275.00 EarthBalance° will perform the services described above for a cost of $0.55 per unit, for an estimated total of$33,275.00(60,500 units). This quote shall remain valid for a period not to exceed thirty (30)days beyond the submittal date of September 22,2008. 6'4 weft- .3y 9S7,So QUOTED BY:Charles L. Kocur, Jr. Vice President EarthBalance® 2579 North Toledo Blade Blvd. North �,Port, FL 34289 \\NAS\PublicNorthport\ER\Projects\02 Active Projects\Collier County Sea Oats\Price Quote-Additional Sea Oats.doc Packet Page -1588- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY O.M.B.No.1660-0017 SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS Expires October 31,2008 DISASTER APPLICANT NAME PW REF NO. FIPS NO. DATE FL 1785 Collier,County of JCCCOIG 021-99021-00 11/19/08 1. Does the damaged facility or item of work have insurance and/or is it an insurable risk? (e.g.,buildings,equipment vehicles,etc.) C Yes C No C. Unsure 2. Is the damaged facility located within a floodplain or coastal high hazard area,or does it have an impact on a floodplain or wetland? (: Yes C No C Unsure Located in coastal areas covered by FIRM panels 12021C0581G,0393G,0391G,0387G and 0377G(see attachments) 3. Is the damaged facility or item of work located within or adjacent to a Coastal Barrier Resource System Unit or an Otherwise Protected Area? C Yes is No C Unsure 4. Will the proposed facility repairs/reconstruction change the pre-disaster condition? (e.g.,footprint material,location,capacty,use or function) C Yes t: No C Unsure 5. Does the applicant have a hazard mitigation proposal or would the applicant like technical assistance for a hazard proposal? C Yes N C• o C Unsure 6. Is the damaged facility on the National Register of Historic Places or the state historic listing? Is it older than 50 years? Are there more,similar buildings near the site? C Yes ( No C Unsure 7. Are there any pristine or undisturbed areas on,or near,the project site? Are there large tracts of forestland? C Yes (: No C Unsure 8. Are there any hazardous materials at or adjacent to the damaged facility and/or item of work? C Yes r No C Unsure 9. Are there any other environmentally or controversial issues associated with the damaged facility and/or item of work? 41- Yes C No C Unsure Sea turtle nesting area. PREPARED BY: Joseph Chesler FEMA Form 90-12D Revised Jan-07 Packet Page-1589- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. b .o a m a cc .:. ,-- c °m r 2 $ E LL c ILI c W E E m V -- E m m a m < Y o:L .E .9 > > 8. `o fn U o. w m m � 9 v O LL E z ° z z z 8 to a E ic d E yE E € 8 8 m co 6 V .5- m ° a 8. a p a O C 0 m do m 8 C u O° m N aa, Po 2 m O E 0 Q N E E E c c C O n� n o 2 2 2 8 8 0 o m o O O N 8 N m W W W(n H ti C Z O Cel O CD C3 CD CD CD CD O O O O O '�V' )!) Off) Qom) d op .(U ... O 0N) O pO O O O O O) 6f u- 7 O C) O O O O 0 It) O O O 0 p E 000_ co, 69 464 N N (ft O O yH t- a It, GH b9 U 69 to fR N 0 0 0 0 0 0 a a 0 co 03°- co H co H I- -- I- m 0 °) > 0 CC o c 0 0 - E o Q TA H m ¢ c >' U o of E v z 2 z 0 N F°- ., w 2 m H m m m m m m o N V z w 0 0 N u_ w U Q O 0 z a C o E a h $ r 0"c m m m m m m m m E Z 2 0 w W I- F- I- I- I- F- t- I-- m 0 -' F- CD 8 0 v W a 1 Wm o I— , _ s E o c 0a CO ° a) N o c 0 ca vg Y 0 p) a) . O E p C H c m v m o CD > o c O) E c v; C O 0 0) C 0 N 2 m C, c v o v o c d a) E v0) °) >, E 0 atf °) m O m 2 v a 0) CD N N 16 'n -> •'O N c v 0 0 V) 1- W d 0 0 c La- o) o)C C ii o al O o O m O o O j 0 N o aca C) ao C C 06 w 0a N0 0�} 005 N oz$ e c c m E 0 c o 0 ov o -o o c oa ° 06 0tf 0 a) _■ j Op09090 0p E 2 _ m o N c � c CO m� � mm ? a Z CD CD ¢ V m ma ` � ` m U mU ca CU U 0 o 4:1) .•-• ,- '0 0 m ,- J . m _ w W m W L LL o d O 2 O E O E 0 0 2 0 0 0 O (p0 �N N 8 e ¢ 0_ CD 000000 C.) 9UUVUV W 0 J - � Packet Page -1590- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY REPETITIVE LOSS STATEMENT APPLICANT PROJECT NO. FIPS NO. CATEGORY DISASTER Collier,County of JCCCOIG 021-99021-00 _ G FL I 1785 1. Has this project t site had previous damage? t: Yes t' No C' Unsure (tf the answer is NO,It is not necessary to address the remaining questions) 2. Did FEMA provide funding for the repair of this previous damage? t: Yes r No C Unsure (If the answer is NO,It is not necessary to address the remaining questions) 3. What is the date and cause of the previous damage? ❑ Fre Date(MM/DD/YY): 10/24/05 IS Flood ❑ Earthquake Tornado/Wind ❑ Hall/Rain • 4. Was mitigation approved in the previous disaster? C' Yes r No C` Unsure 5. Was the mitigation work completed prior to this disaster? C` Yes No C` Unsure 6. If known,provide the following information on the previous disaster: Disaster No: PW No: Version No: 1609-DR-FL Various 7. Comments: The initial Collier County Beach Restoraton Project was constructed in 1995/1996 to restore nearly six miles of critically eroded shoreline in the Naples area. This effort resulted in the placement of 1,172,650 CY of sand from offshore borrow areas on Vanderbilt Beach,Park Shore Beach and Naples Beach to provide storm protection and enhance shoreline recreational amenities. These beaches also received supplemental sand nourishment by truck haul between 1996 and 2002. The shoreline again sustained damage caused by Hurricanes Katrina and Wilma in 2005, resulting in severe erosion of sand and further restoration efforts,which was conducted in 2006/2007. Collier County received FEMA funding assistance to restore these same beaches under PW 2698 (Vanderbilt Beach)PW 2700(Naples Beach)PW 2704(Park Shore Beach), placing a total of 610,607*CY of sand, again from offshore borrow areas using a dredge. This work was completed in May 2006 and became the design basis for determining 2008 pre-storm conditions at these three locations. Total of 667,562 cy was placed,including 56,955 cy along Pelican Bay Beach(not-a-part) Revised Jan-07 Packet Page -1591- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. =.erkia „s diva N o q) 0 I • V .— w t W O J { 4 L � a` o ' yf, ,�1 i ;r 1i ■ 0 ;r f'` il-_ __ 9 11 .�- 1 r co 0 L Lf-ur-1 ,.., a '' ¶Ji 4+ °.6; c Q y Z a to i > G m W W a oo Q 0 l Iti Z C e— Q z E o 7—O oo- au - LU* 4 ; CI „_ 0 U F— o ;av _t � I c Z CC y z < is N ,-- a Z ILI 1.J w J — k.,..., °d 3 o O c. c Z ` zL w >� 4 tn 13-0503 ra. m 5 C) V co o m w o. M n L Ca �. L h . NCO LI W ODL p ry co c * 0� v. � � CO �� min W� m 0• uj� el...) U(�'1 N� L UIOnD�N UT Ulm W 6 to W o'a5 tii y. 'd N C a. WN N n. o p w Wt0 toLLJ y� a 7• 0 CDN ?0 ` 2 o , N m O N a m • O a cm -0 o a co U CL F- c Z m Q O Z � g a a a g Q.u. cis Packet Page-1592- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. . , co c m ■I •p i V tit 1, 7 ..J B C r� ��" (1 > is II r. { z ___- - -- - fl -It-ail-131V-i irl n ; j j� I ! I tea, _ Iw— ,' it I� �i Ii !'1 1 j ' ; }mo' _ Q ; 1I 1 1 ) 1 I r ! 1 i, ,1 v a ,., 'i I,L--11--IL' ;' '! j 1 TT: II ± I I', II Ii ' !' '� I, 1 ID i w r1 'I j 1 'I r i , i j ! r a jai I' ; i1 1 I j �± a 11 1, I 1 1 ( > . 8 xl 4C II ;` 1 Ii ��'1 � ;� - 1_< l 1 r tv ., o3 xal j 11 1 I I F '1 ;1 5' 1 j, j: , ( ;'.. � { tID 1 I r i, I I [C1 � ,1 ! I . r-4_....,..'o II IJ � I i I 1� i � � iI i' 'f I i i °° � 0p� ' '11� ; � I' d + : I if < I i1 > , j; i „ Q ''11 ' Z r,J 1 . 1 �1 t 1 !) 1t '1.+. 11 1' ' it 1 i I- Q. i 1 I 1 ,-tly..- I *" •7, 'l't"+ ( "". +" 1 3 1{ 'r�• C7.t I 1 + 1 1 `:i I r .0 tY LL •,I. 1 , -' ! _I'T 1 I C / h'P I 1. 11 t,I o o ,' I i, 1 i 1 1`-_,a_ (3 - 0 CP c� �f_anderblt I ,, 1 _ao N Z - Q Q d1 r 11 ti (. I, 11 1 MI tt ,�,� .1.1 -.-p�y U '.1 H, j! I'' "i. ,, I'i� 1`,I 1. I f -,. - .._ -., n. z i� X71 O a , w in U W 2 0 t3 ar r w if .14.15`k rc w -05 to u. N Cam O G Da ti0.U 1- m i v c'ul O = N a) ce - N a 0 'U o .1... m N >0 LIJ o C O Q U = � 4 � v Z V N o 0 d ��` n 01 U' o G ,_ ci, OV a H c z o U Z g a = v < t% o > Packet Page -1593- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. CO —� f=orest Lakes=Blvd 1 co .; o C /, a S'' "coif i ' t %JeFf!fU o , I - Z11 ___ a Goodlette-Frank Rd N Bnodlette-Frank:Rd w - _ _ _ a _ 14th St N= Q. ( I .. 1 - . - W I•_�i'-'1' (�W� ±i I 111 _• CI CL 7.,7-.=.2.7..:..7.:=1.6{ pl.I�l', I 01 I i �� ..- I I tl� �I!IIII � I 4)1 'a :TS '1 >- I, y '�11 147( I 1 ' 11; _ IFS I41_.� I L21tJ 1 i .C..- A j �'�O ar lL6 it �' O ,�-• 1 "O - ZJ it O 1 I i - 'l 1 > _ i r � j •f i 1— L' 1 ...11 f ' _-_ -t, N -... =: _rr iI I1 i ` i 1. I r , I 4 I iU Z ' I i1 . w I l I IX"t o a West Blv — I- ■l 1; earrr _ !L ;, Z d ( _ �r Y 1 LL, ,,W 11 t i S 1; aQ O l � , cU ' Imo._. v i� 0 a 0 �— 1 i -6, Z Z Q fl c _ V Q cc w J cu Guif-Shor Biud=N 0 c w [!a * a CI 7 N N .iJ CO L 6 In c N eD u to e Q7 m p b... O H 1 Q? 11 0 4f1 v. O � o EL O Q ! .Y a o ,� i W 2 G o yt o M O O r U N w co c. G1 poj s OD Z r C-/ as V O a V N Z U O 4 Z CO ' a. cn - , a d o Q. LL 0 cc Packet Page -1594- 1 1-1I—I -gym 10/8/2013 16.A.16. • 0 E •i.,,,:a ,----,, C7'''..."' 1-1 ' ' "--' . - . 1 ! d=1 . ' ! , z 1 ,: ., ; / CA,I,, ' '- -- .,; ZI", C„,) ;• . .., ...V. („3 ' • 'A.;, CO I,-:::... ,-_,:,7-}6:: :1 > I i".----- --r-•••-_-=----, -. .,..-4-.--. leH ''''', '-=•- •,,,, -cr --,,,1 i •, ,, .., i .' "'''''-''' ' Cr .":-.L•171)11 ,I ' a? fe.e.-----.---.:),1 h:::-_-_-:„041 :! :;-7:.,:„,',H ,t, w .(/ ---,1 ..-..:.$11117 .- ' r .-•• ,'1 .•--.-..-. • • t r,, I>/' / --. i! - 0 u..--- ,r.--,-.:,r .." ,...:.... q/ ' . , T=— Safdpip '--'S, I rI--— ii -------.,,,,---- .- a; fr it. I-- •, , / / ii r •1 :=Zii Ci < 5. ; .1 / ',. ■ i ,--- ; . 1;; / t' '' , ' i' .;. .. - 1----- / ,--- i f . . .-,.. ' ::::::=•:':---I 1 ,. L-:--_-. El l2 jf.:-k.f.- r,, --- ----,,r--0.— .0"C ,c,ok. %° - . ,I i't• - i' -tali! H 'i, ivl ...., . ', 11-::::-,:::: ri IL ,,-.:,,=:::,AIt ,, ':- - z 1,1_;,1___IL.,',„,..-,.„two ...,t, n A ,,,■, ...IL, Eir,qii....,si._.,„.-i,,, v. ,,, ,, ,,...______ 1, < il I,i- --L.;----:Th,',-- . .i; 1.7vg.t..b1-- /-%'.. .• C, li '.', 'i, 'I; ,,-;''' _. :' . nt f-- , ..gv- ,- .C.0---L---,1 Z a. atf,.,."7 1 It ,•p:.'----- "....-7, ' 1. ■1, .--'0:2...7.... --Tr- . I 1 i 1 !7---:::-::::, . — Lu .... 1: , ,.......,./I.— li"---±t tc).-..,.',-. ',' CO fetil.- L.,i'l I, '. . . 0 2 4.11IL , - _,,,,„, --) i ' ' ' '- ---''' 11 * l'---' 1 orri----Ln---; ' nr r....:.1 I. ,...si--- ___, I_ .:‘,..:-..----. 1; .: ..,..-...,_ --.'-,- :, ,. co , H . ,; ., 0 ia , 1■ !, ....,.. .L.:- gh'St) ', Aih St 5, -Ik- ,' ' ---J'------ ,-,--,, 1- ■,, II ■1 :: ,, ,., ',..L. , ..., 1,--2._.. ,,•••- -,:h cf.) ,..,•„,_ ,,,,,, , • o z z „----,1----I 1,, 0 •,__E•4,•„-_,:,...::::•, ,, -,..-.., , ....,..,..t.. .,,,,,....1._-,-- ,I tts 7 .. ,,...:'. . -..•,. ', . . < 11 1' 11 ..., c,-Slc-Q, 11 ----........i La--:.---':::',--,..---'r•-• ;; cs4 GO 0 17.---- -.:-_"-co " m o dii--$t.4.1-,5till I,..._t.,_.!. -,, .T--J, ', A.,..61 ,,__•et•._.._-,..,.-:,-_-•-.7.7..-m ------ ." _r.,i. .,• ,-,, ..,,,„.,...-- ...„. 0_ >- — CI )■ I I rl 11,-cit-24.----,,r,"...) ', 1' i; u.?,...,'1__.‘.'r_:,7-4-.:117.,-,------ 5 5 5 Gtifdon -Dr—---------t z ,...) 1— ,,„......:L,--,tz,:i4ilni-0..11 .1 ■,; i ! ■ -.n,--.....-2,' .-., --"§" 3. •,f .4C-...--4-,,... :-:::-"'-..-.. '—-1'.''- 'r '. 0 vt ilj '.*4. ' 1.4 Z Z. IC-° :---1,---"-.-'‘,4 ' ■I_ 1',--.' ,-- --.e:--,-1/4---- , 1,, ,, ., sr ,i __:, ....,,-,..---,;...• ,. cc(.9 (...) _4_,_„_- =_,---, " ,,, L._ --r, Q- --- if- , ., ..--• : W • E < LAIri ,____, —- H ?/, -.-2,,c1d-ot, .g. •• ..s, L , __,---- ...-L-to- - , -.-- cv s-- 5 -:::- -4---.4t ,, ',.. IL; .,...,1,:.- ::::: .-e-is ;'■ ',, .et Tr '1'7 '' 0 w ....i _.{ 4 ,4c ir, - ,i ,,, L...,..•...--f..-.:, :-.----,, .e ,,,, it ... -‘==x, _, '-,:_...1.•--c...4 T. ., 't■ . ?1 W .SE W i ■ 4. a Q. ' 7 VI VI CO 770' , . CO • c'e C t- 43 o .t. 0 z.4 0 de 0, cr au. Lu.5 43 II-I CO Cs.1 2 a 0 '''• , o ‘... lA Z.' >< gC Ca . .....,. 2 = 9 w 0 T- co C,) csi RI1- a) E . w a, CD co 0 ' . 0 CNI ,-. 0 CI a_ -a 1:- c ro 0 ''. < d . z = 0 z :..1 .. ›, 2 QC/) CI. .P2 0 <_II. 0 Packet Page -1595- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. co 0 O g U ,-�� $off GC CO E:; 4 C tlyY YikEg 2 Ith m� iu8 •u. 1I a8 5 o a i °- z M A 0y co Z z th11 o a a m w )., Wq I ;:o: 8t'1 ~Nag mtle >- M u. • W a IL La 2 ri: co E— M MI c OR o N V °D_ ID N O iii Of D N O p N 0 o> woo U 0 j 10/8/2013 16.A.16. co -03 0 sggs W Q . V1 2 LLiiilll WR CO 1" O i g f_. gg3ggE&E =p pN p$ d fW.. D 18 u O=5 8E £13 z m Coi i^ v p- . •Z x !Li 0 C ° 0 _ a? A w pier ! "�' �u m y� Z W 1 d^ W ? S oEi4 Ii '" tt W 0 ill qQ W z = a o z 2 B We �55 a °o U 6 'iii g a a, S Le o aI �, $ . .j.. 0 1111 �� till in!: z 0 e). ZZZ mp° Q NIP'- Ntrei >QZ .J-i ZZZ M W ,W,,.. W W O r of 0 2 o N.-- o - W w ' 4 -ry i P" r r ,,,r, .'gtt.r.",?.,..! v 1 �R i.. ty.'. r ..��wrgtTr ,`, Y Q .„ l.e«4sy ;, i' j,{',fi,-..d„;e�a ,irk.i; xia i'M a #5k�pg;,r } Z'c �'d T, ,Yrr`: 414:VWA g ? + 0. .,- �r E ,i ryWWW fi zti 6k� t a rs ss� ,A � Fg t {� 2Tke'e m�„,,-',4,..;!,;,.,42:0,,,,,rS Y{w�s"b± W Z e a .r F,,t.. �� rn,w<,. ” rr N a`�tom ' '5��,,,, � Z+ �"werx ". tit a;,, W r;.,,',w 4_,;.,,,, ,i,,,;::•14-'.-, , SWv :rL,.,,.ih t+ ar ca, '..*..o,',F 4 .1 "4z �r 'h�k ''F r P' rSa �,u-3 �,n, +;.s t d y h a r" � } x }1 ? e� , '^m w.y "1`} a',, .� ,,,i,„ N 1 '"o'f 1 ",'`5:f:1 k 44,VJ O, yyFjY.w r Ww A` 1 ^s-?x,�, nn., , W rx LL, s'a 'l,y� F r, coif'-t4" "- x ,t; W ;�jyy'�a �y.xr�1�',rMr'„^LC aw � , o� �4 ` �� ''1��.E '='a ' �, 'fi i � d. � �ph , , ew:^ n� ti'S r .,�.y, m bF. '. ,� Ls s a . � iy "G'Z..; t t,§.r w 'R'1'r,W-451---..'4A1 y }r.!'°1.Y Y t t t fi, x t'" 4.'"✓ fi',) w r2 tP �� as ,*. „,-^a y1k.,b aet �a y,,,4',Y` 'a kph 5,.ti. ,: C_ Wk s-"$ } ,>&h YtMI �/ k1 r w^FW't "'' 5x e 4� ii,l� '�a a �,-c3 r �s�.' iv n L f 'r ;.,,,,v -0 .v-,T"! - id 1`r„-/:;,.',,�^r,,,.SS,r'ii'.$ rt �,r,t, c1....f r r}. `i 1'''7t.'''' vSi,u.'/Lt1 s',A "' 'il 1,,-P3' ii4,4 t,,`,rr+. LCr _ J '" ,%k,+£^ ad�r , a"I�..Sr s rG 5 r 2 s w T Sgi q,.F', ,r$� b a r� f, 1 44 t: 3` z. a C Wes: a 1-4't' t yc 1 1`1" i f rr;, w,s 4 u x r is 42 , il t�zL ,4z ; ?',,;,-. t N .� w t }ZA,w+t ;i '�s�t k tt P. F v. uY s.',r 2u, n Ar 5 ° I W e �`�s 7�_ �m�.� �" 'n� r�'f" tr L + rs3'°,K'�1 w.,.0. � Gs.><i� `'ti jt�y"�w� " '�4 1}-}r i-, w .y��'� � w��sr;a�i x 1 W c q 7r4'.4" _ .t ,¢, ;.%' "v". ",' r P 7,r w k .V. a c tS :110 �.1 7'+ft `4 ,1 5T *L .a �,7... k -,,, ,N.r '1',",, '1 Fcv s.0 ,{ `3 n `,.. t.$ 'fptb `s d `.�y'� YYs�,��33"'' ir'Fw .�.s,e }, �3,'r-xt L �kT fr' ,px�c r i bhp ry r t°�;a.a et a,:� ,� � �' S 4' .T ' LL s h , ti ;,,f i z"to r .. y , e : 'y� � a#r . 3 . 0, x -. b'4., r�A.$, �:..y t ,t 'T e.� -t;� '. �i vcw "h 1,, , '�,t �s `ti ,..-. S ,s,"�, ' 'G"*p a sEii 4'a4"Y`'� 2s „,V, .� s. t ir' *'Y'd�a'i5'`r� et is c d� $ r t 4 "" f t Jt° �. � r �-P'"-��+7 ay,,g '` � -c' p'Xa34`� ♦ K � z' .""L'u t k Yeaa .r . kF e t r < r R,2 S a ,,, r Y,"', 4 41 »cti�uA. ti of srit -rt Y,,, u} My ^°..7ig ,k,;you-F, ACr r.i N .r r t'('y t t r --'V 4..0 at� f �` :h4 'r i' i a^s ^', .;,),,,44,,.:',„':%i r 4 $t c, F }ytss .rr'� -, s� N n y, -'k . �" 1y,1-,P,f`,,,,,, t7F'r 4,� �',,r s� +�5.,� � n t : 1yF 0,t +M + +�''"-T-q,,s -.,};s i, 4y r%Yg#t11'k�'��z� ‹i; r-'5,1 i' wL7,....+"! 4 s- gxr+h :-- k 4 a4 t' ,' a �.�� , ? �k ry li ' t GL",n l aF + ,, ,..-, :r 4� Cfv;` t a r✓d , vs r 1` a Y ' M P r $x 3� �s� c�,r` t ti v;~' �,S'* � h- P t f..r N ` S � .v "'` `ras �(�3,...{,+4r dr�r57 `' �y{ �,. tir v t wg a.�."v;�",..cy. .� ."7i 5 r '' .h' E . 1.T "'s t_,F '1 ' -a Lk s' ,,-..- m. ..ri r 4 5-..„:„,',-o.:> a;V C*rl yo'"' 't,^r stoZ irc' v r ..,tj1 �:.�t ,e.�.v � law' s.,ra � 'r'y�'i't� �,"�r ^,�'fY' s "'u' '�i _ _ �. �*.+."ke ^�a ��'}fi��it"aye ,y 1� v (,+,� � _ ,�, a �'k'�a a ,bliz n' piiti',,v' ^` 2,- '-{y� '$-r� R'J '1 "14'4--- N,['tiol N s.) b ; -7 'j% p'�`,j�c+'�i'!0l �-ii-V:-i °' ,�T {''1t c e,'kS.z t"' ,�t 'n,z^ f ;..4',"x 'ew a s sir t k i; ^' 'n r .: * ¢';y tot 'r4.g Y o-- +'#'..a y.. ...� �`� {^C�. y 't"Q "1i{�".i 'Z �rf'�l� SCn.'„ r°�x.. � t5t�`ar' ^r,'� ..� -.,vui�+.n'' .z�' `. `" cv. , o v-w.i A 4 ,1-qsv.+ r r .`�yts fy: t . i}'''c,'Y 'Nr ,,,, 'i i ', �E , 3, Se. y.3 ..�.,ry , ., s ;. . '` ' rl s L . ,.F,.r+ r - 3 k' c'.- ,. m" w,w Z. s- .To'lT, yy%!;a94+ 1'er i-�3r�' `v.,Y'+'y L' x�';'r'a l l�,?ru -.-I 1'' 144.' '"A `r P*'''L ' Vk C O z,,v, `.14 F`y^ r t" 1.14-w i `'' FY,f x'11�,� ' in;: -..: .'".,,vr v,fU"+Y7G.,ar„�s 0Sr7,r" z 44., .3 „ 1;,.t_,..ya J C? N1 m m � m e m O m r CD/ O O W Grn eQ Fa . U O V 05 (o QR W N 0311 n O N Wt W • 1 CC W o W Q d W;Q Q Z Q Z J 'Z 4 oa ZZZ ZZ Z LL Q O M O m O Z ai O e? Z N17a N^m NO a m 'e CO a. ' aa. Q u- CC Packet Page-1597- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. oT- O ■ U V -y t, \ �E_$ W E a H o v i m L Q g v ��q Z gp v5j d 0 1�W i 1 21 2 i Z = v < b e6 r C-•i m z f �W!+WW IJ- W h I [; u Z S i �� S * ✓✓ a O o "ter' LLi z t' § E W _ {V }b i Lc n. 9 , zaCI0 ° � ii; ae g , x H o� z ' fti W s i: i ; r' °4ii 8h j F im W 5 Oi g E Y 1 Di al f ft r E.B. e ° § $1 — sdsr a >- -t8e Z gg� . • W arr=r'i y,fi { r T' 'F T,k Y� -� �' ;{. '' ' ri _ y z w,:a� p't w t .:Kr y'"4 e,' ' �F c,u a F ^ .S'I p.„..s' r 4 t,,,,,,,,,,:.. .,!...,:.4,,,.,, { ,, t�, { ,� L9 yrW- l,:,„„ .k. .T F t r t� a° i.,� aR ,a; ��3 rb"b' , w, 0 M 17,17 fb°t9sd yryt : ti+4, ,v �b'''..'M_ y,a7vt'-r. -ai rw Pu,��t,: ''.rro >. r f ytier,5i'C '.,i�,T 4 t''f� '4r,>�i Q ' r �1F '�'k k°tt^'`5,i .J,� p -sGx._i3�'.J s �1` �x� f yFx ,G t u.. .,7r' r w'd ^.7' �+ H a:,S. �' aY J '4d ?g-g- Y. at , Lrt"i :n' t2?'IM 4,- $ '{isa �'"1 f' rr �.yf 'v' ' .J`�,I t ?yr At,',t M Z kr 1,r r. ,:•-•. ; vS,fi.t '''-'-''''''''''::-• .�; Yr Y !!,,.. �1 n �� ',41:1',::••'44,-'1•=j1','.c'r,,, Z- ''":4'1,'"'.. +.s a{�¢f..+;,;',14,' Nj, W Rvt.P '',•",..+ 4ier, t`rt t} 'to ' �v5 ,,..0 Yt r i 'a�'>,. , .i.. . v 1.Tr"f?kd y r a ,� ;C1"' LL' aa51: ° j1...',.c.1,-..7..'•'-' 1 ,. a , .?, a.�} „R.,,e, ., T' .5 s°�?.rtr, ',,vi„. .S t rr O W v n 7 F i }r Y'x'1" k y ry k k 7 1�3 t �d „..t.,..1. e' ° a M in :Yvb fa N '9', .,,,^,-:•,,,,,,.,:m-,•, ,i...`fir dfi t t,s �. 7K CY4 ..,i: F , ;e.4,T e /, ,kti aR iL zt r•t z 3 r yl r a s < v 9y1a3 A �° t Q C ,, n , {.3r avrl ��s#,W , v' - r f 4,�Q '' rsf J.:aa'�" 'r;ice',ti� 1 �s R t; W S to Z 'ft's sf `' a• 11ke.. 'F R' , `5 6th (' w_..i R v 'k ' :, ar a r ':"5� "i,. r ,✓ 7 V r=w �, < b(y t't ate Y X w x �1., t *3� tx4}�i A�. Q W i°, 1. w r vr'. °,i cam✓:. a,� i rf `,; ' w ti- 't'g',i,,P*al°ls t.' 1iia(341, t4srs q, .,�aMC#s:, } }5.3 x 4`ti S{r Uri +a y,,k ', ira ''3,;T V:'lt. �t�R ; 1,, t,"k t ryyr �yR''"k �&titf"r , 4 �' { §,� ?•'. *; Q V /�/ r t.., ,L; h. —4 ',V.:is'. _ t tJ,as `?r J a ;,�T_':,h4. a" ...0' .�hP,aF Y. r�5a� , A�'' f�". t;. LL• Z Ids t y,�ik-n'i ia'.'r f: 9,4h,,t\:, .`'L� Ss.?Y a^;._ a d',. . '1 iC f`Id•C 5 ��OFrr°T +1"1''`oai i'��l C.,.".�'� �4;,-4°.� } ti ..• W 5 °$ Y , s ,kn r cr �� nc r Rr �3 �',at fi ice,�'�S` 9i•,Lti`'��„-tr ..3 { „=fir i � s�� s .�^ }�.� > � x t C9 . d s "x w A T#.rc e,..rd+. { } }Z Y - r p ��FNR i .' :°no r y,,,6-`.4 +'4,#,"' a We Lt . '; %,-> it. ,;.x. i n 1,,,,tt .d>n'L„:, 's.} ,•0 1'a'7'r y-,,i' kRSrm alt,1. L i ,I, � ,'` 1, C ...,•^'iU wI .A{4 F -r s a >. x ma. 1 r ,y & W ,',1,-. w, v'T- ,. Y,iT, , 2 Sti ,, t,,. (C J".-.a 3 •a ski r5[ 1 i it i' ,.` '` 'I', - X17 fix °., `. a C'e q,. �' t ;,,�.. ry ,.. r y,i �i '4�t J :a.a , W ;°e`s�°k1n°51rt1i o- r a3F�srt d s4 y A�tJr M1� y pr° �kC r' `kr. .� i m r x� { 2.. vaart t ;,. l u,� <� r� $ �� f ec"5�.e,�a s1 r�r �i ♦C'; LL K k b, R r ,..,g Ka,ap ;vin i�w � is�t A' s` an. , .yt ''i, • w� ��'x '' ; -i Av y, b r2 i t w,.S '"ms! b!?° t a4 � F'., �5�,} F .:.. W rt.:;',...";;' r2`i ,,, ''' ' �a, -7 A. jZ ..'''.. rr 0 w 3, h1 • Nwc�� "�F� '.i 41is i ,Ts ,�r :."'r ti C r {;��y+,h , r ,y': r�- r da c u ' 4'r . r ,f� .-"a W .� 'rT fA� d (fin 7rrS �'k ^9k �, 5� r+. f , ,lkt A'+-Ai rr �0_ -j�s vr~R31�, W t ° Jt ,nr < ' G, ria S'3` �!r!' i � P.` .n '� a s(;sue ro'ff° 4, z ' ,is ?7 t TA{,-. d e. .v'-; # S ,gam '-. '�S#iy„t,t*'i ,Wr .r. ∎"' -- .- ,, ,r )tr,: art '` _, 9Y` {'i . } � t °ti+ :$ T.,.`'S dr "" . ,mum g »-� rrf A 9h� .'Sy A. Ga` sC n ` pE*14 h,� r' t.e:7 ' w+:' 4, , ` b ` w`3pkt♦u� t,'."` 4,;s;-A l4 '4t.Sct',{ YY�"� 4 w..+, a' � G ' s erw {s..'3'd p,1° n' :Y . x,-f 4j"@e�k4 ra�° r`>hsfi� `�."''t 7,43447 �F�'dH of x apt:ag.4. ° a ,-+� S+,c�& ✓J ,.l t,5 "t4.'E ' �sY'% ', 't,,,,3'`551.,� ti :',q , [ a.6 "c" bM,CS'4 ;' ! �,. a a r ,y.t nd b,,r'.4 [. P'e. 'fyK ,J(� .1 ;'r (J;„t",/',A�, Tt '9 1'1,14:�'w -�y{� c', ^,41 ...>it 8 t4 ,grv.,,x{' .a'4,,,,} ,c�,C , fir-- {¢ S!S5'r +w', '`4Y N 7t� i:4::H r t,,x.1..y J`..“'i. ,, "r.l tt. -PC rs� A<',,.„, o r t"`. 7 tt'�,. ,� 4s rr,C e J ib .,✓"a S� d - j'a 4 yr r s .�3ct ! � t y '�4+ s Yr��+�"Tr Y n�' w J h k T aaX'r e t r : f Ltt R 4. T r i, acb f' 'Y �,L s ar";"'# `-.' 'r'i a 3 ..",,-.';'r.1.1.:>. ,,��f f�'N'T$x „t`7jt et•Ua IV.,: y 1,- ,.z1#,,-;, -y,-..7p 4 .`.� +s kf:0#,,4, titiae ,r�,§ ,4-,';.4;;;#;#4- 4,-144, '• .',"' n L} s'-3`i, z1V 7,5, h {' x y .-, pY''',. +.„ 6„ - ? w `^ �-'k t ''i`'y r.t 1, .r ,.'-4- p, ,tf, i1rt4 t.,,,Aie -r Nlx .'t.'.•zZti '6 kie X2•• •F, w b.+3gc4..:S,.o1 � w2k3.y gvR S@y_ $ 33j %• 'Y4 f'� ,rEi1,. 7 uy r �� ,,e i &t 2a ,.' i P i-A . y 3 , 'f,,'1,..r, -1., .v W` °,„ .4- �r 3 ¢ `,°S.F�,`�j._.^P'wf ''�. (� 2,yTeC"1'-+-t -'.{ /V� CO W ` � Q c T ' a m CO N M N W<Ca q N d V N W y W H wv >5 >Z ZZZ oJLL OZM O N V Q wa Ori aNrD °�Q°- N , d 0 O Z. �ya Nom - N� � c3}° .1 >li J J J J a-I CO W QZ W W "'z ..� ,. hy Q a Z r � yo 0 Q p r'�f ° q U J o a a- m Q Packet Page -1598- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 1 - ;. ,' 9" 1 {7 &f� -$ Srra`'r'Y t '� 0, , , ....,k.14,' "Ii-i',,-:',-- , -r ' 7r f � '. F:. 'f,;)' 4� i h.'";','`14.,..;',.::,-:v, : Jr 3 QQ /� 0 $ A 1/ ' g' . M 0 4 �F a z �- •a r j m LL .i`,� 4m .: 3 fir'' v ! L W ti� dr,' u o ^4 tii . . cy5 ti. a 'r5"yA C N g A7 Q Y. a ha r>e S 4Y � 1 A 0 Ll fi, ' ' LL f7 t ! c u Yti 't c f e e' r 4` L•n A + w S >S '' ` r� � v a t F w 1 ' La Lii N U LU >- a z I- 0 0 cc I } 1 ;t , L to O r 7 tN ►mes. ., z ■ ° I +�*b 1 N v i6 r« aA- / cCq i kv� �si L i m `4,,,,...,- co c o �`: m ,E j m O Q ai ` ij m U N ' I€ } > 3 gq, > 3 Z5 s , ^, j hxr , N Q O f� 7 w ok x # L J Z Q ry t1 x �� - o —I—W o g t`.. Z N Q_u., Packet Page -1599- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. • IF 41r te, r j' k - L �r In y t -F S`J J-' i ��41() "� •''c, iJ Jr /' - - "t.., X.'11). +b 4t ,k '. y„ '] .it lam' o; ref i ■ , . 7 as �.• r ra IV m'' a .,-.c,31....: Z } l �•,r {v `f Ata r} W i 4 i A. y•ill re � r tea: tE I _ w, •4; .J" a t o 2 ILI kit z = W cr d 0 0. U' _ ._ -- 0 a . i (.T.- al W S i ye 'iv,: , ' i y Ci i. li �A i t c t . s t i y c I " }` $ ; ' [ as [s • qz N s s ,-1,,,f-'.IF., .:4,,,‘,.a N 4A,,,,... ( j+ L �I to c c fey m RC� Q 0 4 tyk4ti-, 4 o r. ��p fa +(tP w. CO V N ,,▪ ;. _ 4- 4'r- '.III mire d r S /°:4t Nei.: f ' V i 1 i ` 1.c 0 o i ,' � > 3 i siil j 3 a� m ^� ; �S r j 4 • Iw. p'1 ;.. Uaka i' W O I W - t J Z vi` 4 ~ Z 4+2'{ �" (n a cc a a Packet Page -1600- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 0 G 0 ,�"' y d o r y4U " o t� of j N� -�' .��' � . i7��v' •,+rA f!e l y• to •y v ,rtr„..,' ;it 0 -, r LL fJx ',f ,'t ' .0.8r*.'r4�o a Ce co sS "ter ` f-i',41,1 k s. Y a L co �•, F`` w ``�� C { , a 3 rg "f? a — o e w l i 1,,,' a. F r , 5 f. O LL a 0 Z ~ a et I W fi � � 1 1,,V'�'> f I 45 Aft 1 0 �A, C d llt rr " !, „',"4.''''':r t p c l to',14,--.'�`' ...,'4''. W j ',.. f ' r -'r8 =A1 Y- d 1 �V r. J1 w Ol 41'V 5V5.4s r.4..4 > _C .�&4 4'',' t y ti s 1” j LV ca « "`N: J' c a)z �� r t 0) . trLf O eo to ",t cc th • r. t ' ) z „-., .. . ,,,4 t”—-", -ZI U i rCO t W N_r ' L i F s% N i c o e Q f !T U N I � u m i , 1 " �l".0.1 4 ' . ,��a 3 C ° , N > Z M. 'I � o,h 66:1,, x t Ho x a Uz a Q,LL Packet Page -1601- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. CD CO swy fi � e' NN 1rh � W r .a fr ! la "0 x Of m C m a"" '' _ .p H { z U. ; E a 0-4,,i• f ,•- . c = Ili W r! °� o °; ter, Q 'S } 4 4 • , ` o �, ,<< 0 0 C1 a � ,'4 '" d +•' m m "f v�1 P r O-0 fO m do -r C1rri am . ir il au) n i } j. till :,,.�, Oa a I _D " F L W v , m 1 ,,q + 1414:.:1 s t c a. 7 m o E s, F , ' oo L'y, , RI u- tiDj W 4 °,p i .ze N Q. - `�., �t _ N d N O Nr W 2 O CO Z O 0 W "� :.yr;. :�" k� ',4'.7:-4,�..a • —._•._ �FJ'S"�7 •s 5 • Q 2 Q. # 4 ,r i YZ �1 ` U d w -44,,.• j i,�i c m r:; rn w k ��:"rcr" c a as 0 <A i T . n ul N A.! ';4 C a t Y 10; r Y ,[ O Y [ /', J �+ e m O N f E oa . �f . 2► 8 b- S , $• .4a?r f % > r m CD In ca, , --:61„:„..-:,,::.0 . , t:;,,R.,-,,, f.• ;* „''' 2 E O• W� [a u m. w ,O 7,',.; tr, , m • o � , w 1,';10 UZ ,r 44 v ti YYi o0 11 Y a CO CL C1- Q,LL Packet Page -1602- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. BACK UP INFO APPLICANT: Collier,County of DATE: 11/19/2008 FIPS #: 021-99021-00 PROD.# JCCCO1G BACKUP DOCUMENTATION DO NOT COPY / SCAN Packet Page-1603- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 4 Referendum establishing the Collier County Tourist Development Tax Packet Page -1604- FROM : ELECTIONS OFFICE Fw< NO. : 941-774-94E8 Jun. 09 20E 10/8/2013 16.A.16. j P12 Official Ballot GENERAL.ELECTION Collier County, Florida-November 3,1992 V ,'...+tiGiM, 5 tx„FI y t a.�'y 1101X04 •1.4.$ Q .1 ,LTYWID °r�+'31 LG FL.FIeENDJ.'f111T N�::f r Otis :...443041 ..L. /'::xii.#.?� riwge'". .....<..k:611 , .: :. . s,,.. *'614 REFERENDUM ELECTION TO APPROVE THE LEVY OF 2%TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX • I SHALL COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO,92-fa BE APPROVED TC L&VY,IMPOSE AND SET A TWO PERCENT TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX ON EACH DOLLAR OF THE TOTAL RENT CHARGED ON ANY LIVING QUARTERS OR ACCOMMODATIONS IN ANY HOTEL,MOTEL.RESORT,APARTMENT, ROOMING HOUSE,MOBILE HOME PARK,RECREATIONAL VEHICLE PARK,OR CONDOMINIUM FOR A TERM OF SIX MONTHS OR LESS FOR FINANCING BEACH RENOURISHMENT AND MAINTENANCE, AND TO PROMOTE AND ADVERTISE TOURISM? YES FOR THE TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX 219—90. NO AGAINST THE TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX 220- I STRAW BALLOT SHALL THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS VOTE TO LEVY AN ADDITIONAL CENT TO THE ORIGINAL TWO PERCENT TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX ON EACH DOLLAR OF THE RENT CHARGED ON ANY LIVING MATTERS OR ACCOMMODATIONS IN ANY HOTEL,MOTEL RESORT,APARTMENT. RODM;NGHCUSE,MOBILE HOME PARK,RECREATIONAL VEHICLE PARK.OR CONDOMINIUM FOR A TERM OF SIX MONTHS OR LESS IN ORDER TO PAY DEPT SERVICE ON BONDS ISSUED TO FINANGETHE CONSTRUCTION OF A PROFESSIONAL BASEBALL FRANCHISE FAO'Lire? YES 226-x► NO 227.41k COUNTYWIDE 4 Packet Page-1605- r ., .,s., 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 'a __,-- -_. )3 E"c;D"4 I.••( 167 • = I.a 12 C O) ‘i„,)- E , ,,,a, 00 _____:- g ,:.., 4 Pz lig lw Vilw---->- ° C.) 4) 50.1 *110 p' .__...___ -ia....> Em4 2 P, cc2 Q et1 .i,;; : W W )--4 ta 4:- ' = N., 7, C5 * ril . *1' 41) CU r.. • * : Li Q * Q al 0 ; • 7 iiil 0 Allek y . c/e2a/r-z7/7z,v . Packet Page-1606- • 10/8/2013 16.A.16.� � ` L =_ LL -. � x 0c. o - vs - cc ` O Q O L O .�G L y _0.3 H _ C) ' O CS C V co a L = o = z h - = ai u f]. O •L o E i. "� v 0 L. = 0 = = c 0 -3 v x O ° O 4 O L: C _0. E 0 V C C1 V .r s O .N C L CJ u 8 � L ti CJ ~� L C H ° a>1 > C L r0 �+ -•: F C C a _ C X = O C = t O a� u O i. c C , c3 U v y _ c > 3 i- Q =s O = E' = c o = 3 v = L o - )- Z u"- o o L': oF� G 0 H CZ -- aes• = E"' O v1 L O yy,, L" o co x J h o as �' P.:+ C 5 03 O d Q C L ` c co C . .. j - O, � No �. C-. o� C3. (, O .C. CS CV y to C! O L" J O, .- ° u ••••1 ai O L `� .u+ O G L E O O L '£. C L O Q c .V+ .r C x V L `.. > L Cn O t > co LV. = es c = c a) co a O O a C U a v1 .� O d O ir• as u as = -' R O H "a > y O O p C .yC O d 0 CS O O t L 0 O c0 r., c "0 Z R v = ? Z �; E+ Cn E- -. O L. 8 - es R C •• 3 ^��' V . L uti.. O d 0.1 p u CA � O A as V G � 6i CJ 0J .0 C U .0 r U .D � •.'II C... C3 C O u C CJ y C 3 .• E U` > o a _ ^ [ .c = 'o o— m cis E o t C _C C al O" as ^ u •O u 0, G 00 Lj d. ^Y C 0 0 .� + V H 0 Q � O .. O 7 CS . C d 'o O 7.3 tel 0 C O C • , H ..= - L U xx L X v q v> .3 V 'a > G.)O d O �' . . .� u •J Q . O`' .- 01 r. r p - C y O ' - 6. ¢1 .:. .=r 'O .) $ .y 7 03 ': c a O= C C a 0 O = V • 7 G o a = ° o C " 0 E u s o ° c•F . q C� '7 ' C Vq • c u 0 o CC y J 0 us .� V ...� so co cs ed u - C y Q G .+ h C. O o "O G u .- a+ Ste. Ho t a �, 3 -p C o ai as v H .` a o oC ,,_, Q co c = C.! r.' 1 O L- e� C . , E 0 e, 0. a! 'O = C 0 w N 'O c� O V t�� a0i 'p =� i as Lac E � _ $ � i, ° >,2 00,.0-.o ° .°. a � � 5i31 L _ u V 'v u " as w °4 'fl es ° `-.. & -' E .c e o u o. as _ s ea � y'� CaE .� E P. >- 3 ° E- ° L". acs Ua. >- .0 .a P8 ° 37- r vi vD t� 00 o; l - _ Z g .0 o c L. _. �, o -o �O = C ° o o ;D o •-o as it .O >> a) G c.. 40 -g E- = > y .o 8 = L ° U 5 Cam. e L O CS 2 $ [ c o b� °' p°°�' o °� = Z C o ° 3 6 r•-. t!) C cLO. O al U E o y 'v Nas aasi E L s 0 a> ..... o O. .0 V Cr) u ° vii n. y _°; n O a� F., .0^o c �' b� _"' -C -a'- = .� c E L •r•+ x v 0 ti- c u y� o o E 0 '� c vo7 N g o ° 3 � c O ° C a 0 v O y .D Z h > 0 C c� R L ° >L' Oa (°1 C Q Q v $ o = = o c c " 3 — 5 a e c �° .n ° a -p o H 5 c o s c ° x `X-' o o V �° u cn' 3 a^ v `n c E 1.'- O E c = k v c- cd -8 V t" at 0 o Cl s ►P- [.� u 0 9 ° -" _ ° v u § = 0 -•r "' ° .o = L:'vb�i v 3 y °' r,rti W CO O L 7 t0C a E O 'D C .. a� 60i •U •C y u - C" + u E 0 V o c a� .. J .r - L r 0 O Cl) ►_~ oa 8.. ar eS, 3 0 0 1v > e 30 ' . Ep v i, E $$q• c au .... -_ >' �+ O L O L t y ° U L a) .0 O O @ L O a 0. 3 5 o. 2 z fa 3 aQr� � a t _0 G.'5 3c.) E = ) a. 3 ` F. ■' N CP Packet Page-1607- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. • to .-- • 0 VI 411 A " 1 ' R, rII;tp cp to tU cD(ro as I m,ro cp c0 co co;co i• cp I n7 'T R,; if,, al• n a: o 1 LL'u. u. �'LL �1 Ll.l a a:a '4- �.o.. L� a. u- u- L .U..:�L,a•+L9 2- E i I ! i c •• : I I 0:',..t C)•O C) e-4-...le-,40!0 N -IN r CD C CCr'••'C,1 CO CO F-: O+U) to:I's N O) e. IW+Nir ti r)'U)!O,co.r'-. ; g;0 8'r �•�'.g cc■to N C';Cfl 0IO U) 0 N N t+'r),c0 — •-1O):0):t.f) m Z; t0{cII!c0;+- i[i to . "- 1.7i'Cl LO'(O O t. enla :en+riV O r)'r)iNico: O Q ?Q!� Nr) NN N ie-' e- r r' r, • C7 Q i I j � I • ' ) r-.'N. C)SN:r) co;Nie- IO O 0 c O Qs-i,- C iC, ( N.1L 1(1) i f�• r):co r).en'O O'!t:em i e-•r co LA 0 O) co i M O O �n cD C;cO ;I:' . VI il` O;tiM;UATt 1—:0') 010le- 0c° M Lt) O)' - v !r c 7 ti c") cD ; r U) O 0 r1+� co'r--:r r!�'Q C7.0 I�:N LO CD.Oi tL ■ N N r Cv , r- Nle-:e-!N�N r. r I I ; • I 1 I I !• ' � i • �W C:•�i ,• • LL - O 1 i I{ ! aA d 1 ' i V 0 5. ro i • - E i a) = Lo, i I v CL 1 0v'u . . 0 0 M Et w c' o f , ,T) 4, - a Z �: ? +� I NI �, y•N. ,7 ff. ED I _ .•c".)1 Q O i(/) 5 0 � o v > U Z: I �; (VO 71� I N. n' i Std) p^ xi: ` ' l 51 P re' 0 x x x '( O aLo c o o _ ` - to I`o: C E/ iW 1= o) cc 1- 1- o U C l o is 1 = 0 I o v c L.L. t ,.....--2 I LL i p O co■ V co. ;f-1 c W O. 4) c-• �1)1 C i o c i' O c 0 I t! 3"1 J 5 E:E F- .�1 .._.Z' c. u) 1 0 a' c '112c1._.,(07; 3 x x:0:p p;co i -i'U x ? >.!< la, fa to m E o, 0'� :9! fl co to: F- E:,_;1---: o c Y o:a,1� .E _ �.2-1 ;11 ; U �.�:ji a) C):.c? c; ro• Ito tu 0 U I c, c� ,c!> ? N c].iC)IC.d y: toiC�jN ° y � c � DI g, 1 d. �.i' 0) O'•,ai Q C N • • I1) a) '. 0-ii U), If 0' E'ralO-.to'O!Y .,-r4 ▪ L. lITa to �;l'� '� y p Ea w �i x. tam pp X `o ; o E o) Cn o, 0!O 6-;010 �'� `o; oo E10,1.- h-- LL fl. - c i 0 1.1_,�;•i I N aQ W 1- O+'7 C x it-- to a)i .-l Gi m I-: ', Q•.•e.�;� L c, 51.0 t4'U Ql z; z1 D • .c1 =01;.15113; Q CV , U,U 'U 0:o U!UIUiU U U!UiU UIUI� r'°'v: Qlw 01(7) :n 0 c : i � I0 C°' 'N N N of i ? '�' �!N� !CIO ; , CO t() O m;O! N' p (J et) to c c I 0 cT O mia) O O)'O j C7 CO:Ci? O' r`1 r` r`'� r� �, Q «�j j I , , , O)�CD 1071 , t t , 'Cl?, �� L`�t�I�i�I.�,I�: 0 T.; D. 1--- -- (.4i NI r! OI1 +C?;4, ^'^1L. 1'rir- -- ∎1r �-!- �! ap•10 .... , .r r;,"ir.r � r O)�Mir3 r.� rj� ri�1� e- r ch1�,� �'(Ji 0 i E` I ■ I . ! i ! I I i a) 0001141k, 1)0 t rBLd • PIat suyt osj :way £1:67.ED u 86n1g . Packet Page-1608-- �,:n• ,�.� - �,.� , £'£ 952-4 gcc co^ li,:CZt:? 96".-..C.'90 l££8£b9lti5 rRH :�q 3.0 S 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 5 Resolution Packet Page-1609- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. MEMORANDUM Date: September 18, 2012 To: Gail Hambright, Accountant Coastal Zone Management From: Teresa Cannon, Deputy Clerk Minutes & Records Department Re: Resolution 2012-160: Supporting Florida Beach Management Program 2013-2014 Funding Requests Attached, please find one (1) original of the document referenced above, (Item #11I) approved by the Board of County Commissioners on September 11, 2012.. If you have any questions, please call 252-8411. Thank you. Attachment Packet Page -1610- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. RESOLUTION NO. 12 - 1 60 A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA SUPPORTING THE COUNTY'S TWO "FLORIDA BEACH MANAGEMENT PROGRAM 2013/2014 FUNDING REQUESTS" TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION FOR LONG RANGE FUNDING REQUESTS FOR FISCAL YEARS 2013/2014, AGREEING TO SERVE AS THE LOCAL SPONSOR, AND COMMITTED TO PROVIDING THE REQUIRED LOCAL COST SHARE. WHEREAS, the Natural Resources Department, acting on behalf of the Collier County Board of County Commissioners, has prepared two Florida Beach Management Program 2013/2014 Funding Requests to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) for long range grant funding for Fiscal Years 2013-2014; and WHEREAS, the funding requests are to fund the following Collier County projects: (1) Collier County Beach Renourishment which includes the Naples Beaches, Vanderbilt Beach, Park Shore and Barefoot Beach, and (2) The South Marco Beach Renourishment Project required monitoring costs; and WHEREAS, the timely maintenance and restoration of these high quality and readily accessible public recreational beaches is critical to preserve their value and viability, and to provide a boost to both the environment and the economy of Collier County tourism, including hotels, restaurants and related commercial activities; and WHEREAS, the role of the County government in maintaining and restoring beaches is appropriate and crucial; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners supports these two funding requests and requests approval from the FDEP for each funding request for Fiscal Years 2013-2014; and Packet Page-1611- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners agrees to serve as the Local Sponsor; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners is able and committed to providing the required Local Cost Share; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has enacted the Tourist Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended, which commits funding to beach renourishment, beach maintenance and beach park facilities. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Board supports the two Florida Beach Management Program 2013/2014 Funding Requests prepared for submittal to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection for long range funding for Fiscal Years 2013-2014 and requests approval from the FDEP for each funding request. 1. The Board of County Commissioners is willing to serve as the Local Sponsor for the renourishment projects. The County's Natural Resources Department has the staff dedicated to provide Project Management and Administrative support. 2. The Board of County Commissioners is committed to providing the required Local Cost Share. The required funds have been committed through the Tourist Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended. Additional funds may become available through Federal funding sources. PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this / I."' day of �� e v-2012. Packet Page-1612- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. RO.—,i. ,. K, CLERK BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS , DWIGHT E. BC COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA NI, (.3;44t.a.Sc -7/ . s By: .. . ,i.,.... ... , ,Deptv Clerk FRED W. COYLE, CHAIRMAW f),,, Mtesl,as ta Mired* (Jig:Wore-0*--4 Approved as to form and Resolution No. 12 - 1 6 0 -•- sufficiency: Board Of County Commissioners Ri-) .-- Meeting Agenda 9-11-12, Item 16A17 1 1 '/ ,i-i, een M. Greene Assistant County Attorney 10-C2M-00070/8 3 Packet Page -1613-vimminummimm.......mmaummmm 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FY 2014/15 Local Government Funding Request Beach Management Projects Project Name(Same as previous phase): South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project Description: (Should be consistent year to year with annual updates. Include county, location with reference to range monuments, brief project history and upcoming activities.) This project includes the yearly physical beach monitoring, beach tilling, and turtle/shorebird monitoring. All the monitoring activities are required by the FDEP and USACE permits. Collier County placed approximately 77,800 cubic yards of beach compatible material in 2013 to restore approximately 2,300 feet along South Marco Island(400 feet south of R-146 to G-4). The beach fill was within the 2005 permitted project limits. The main goals of the project were to restore storm protection, natural resource habitats, and recreational beach areas to offset the storm damage caused by Tropical Storm Fay in 2008. Additionally, the structural repair of five existing erosion control structures was completed in 2013/14. The South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project is located on the southwest Florida coastline of Collier County between Florida Department of Environmental Protection monuments R-143 and beyond R-148 to the terminal groin. The project's borrow area is the 1997/2007 Caxambas Pass Borrow Area. A supplemental borrow area is the Cape Romano Shoal. Use of Requested Program Funds: Funds requested for FY14/15 will be used for environmental and physical monitoring of the 2012/2013 renourishment project as required by permits. Additionally, this funding request is for reimbursement for the 2012/13 nourishment project and reimbursement of the repair of the five existing erosion control structures. Local Government Contact Name Title Email Gary McAlpin Manager, Coastal Zone GaryMcAlpin @colliergov.net Management Clint Perryman Project Manager, Coastal Zone ClintonPerryman @colliergov.net Management Address 1: 2800 N. Horseshoe Drive Phone: 239-252-2966 Address 2: Naples, FL 34104 Fax: 239-252-2950 Mapping-Maps are provided as attachments. Maps should be to scale at a minimum of 1"=200' Enclosed mapping elements include: ❑ Project Boundary with Critically Eroded Shoreline ❑ Range Monuments ❑ Beach Access and Parking-Primary and Secondary, including access widths. ❑ Public Lodging Establishments- locations and length of property boundaries along project shoreline or street frontage. ❑ Comprehensive Plan/Current Land Use designations of Commercial and Recreational Facilities and associated property boundaries along the project shoreline. The project maps are included as Attachment 1. Packet Page-1614- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Length of Project Boundary in Feet(total restored length) 2,681 feet Eligibility: Access Points and Public Lodging Establishments: Location/Name Address R- Type of Width of Total No. Eligible Mon Access Access/ units units shoreline Frontage available without (ft) to Public overlap (ft) Swallow Cape R-148 Secondary 20 72 72 2,600 Avenue Marco Access Drive Cape Marco 1000 R-148 Lodging 1,473 683 683 Overlap Property Cape Owners Marco Drive Public Lodging Establishment documentation including proof of licensure are included with this application as Attachment 2. Schedule and Budget: (Include estimated phases for 10 years and estimated project costs for 5 years.) Total State Local Proposed Federal Year Method Description Estimated Cost Share Cost Cost Cost Share Share Monitoring Phys,Turtle $77,386 $0 $16,158 $61,228 2013/2014* Construction Renourishment $916,460 $687,345 $47,839 $181,276 Construction Erosion Control Structures $808,000 $0 $168,710 $639,290 2014/2015 Monitoring Phys,Turtle $80,000 $0 $16,704 $63,296 2015/2016 Monitoring Phys,Turtle $81,600 $0 $17,038 $64,562 Monitoring Phys,Turtle $83,232 $0 $17,379 $65,853 2016/2017 JCP Permit&Eng $90,000 $0 Design Rpt $18,792 $71,208 Monitoring Phys,Turtle $84,897 $0 $17,726 $67,170 2017/2018 Design P&S and Pre-Con $50,000 $0 $10,440 $39,560 2018/2019 Monitoring Phys,Turtle $86,595 $0 $18,081 $68,514 Construction Renourishment $1,032,083 $0 $215,499 $816,584 2019/2020 Monitoring Phys,Turtle $88,326 $0 $18,443 $69,884 2020/2021 Monitoring Phys,Turtle 2021/2022 Monitoring Phys,Turtle 2022/2023 Monitoring Phys,Turtle 2023/2024 Monitoring Phys,Turtle 2024/2025 Monitoring Phys,Turtle *Reimbursement of funds are requested from the 2013/2014FY Packet Page -1615- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Severity of erosion: Criterion will be calculated by the Department. Please provide narrative and any data that should be considered in addition to the Department's database. The project area's shoreline has been designated by FDEP as critically eroded. Using the January 2007 and February 2011 monitoring surveys,the MHW shoreline change was found to be eroding at an average rate of-7.2 feet per year. Threat to Upland Structures Criterion will be calculated by the Department. Please provide narrative and any data that should be considered in addition to the Department's database. N/A: Only awarded to new projects for shorelines that have not been restored. Recreational and Economic Benefit: The percentage of linear footage of properties within the project boundaries zoned commercial, recreational, or Public Lodging Establishment, or the equivalent, in the current local government land use map 54.96% Availability of Federal Funds: Is the project Federally authorized by WRDA? No Provide date of authorization expiration. NA Does this project phase have a Federal Project Cooperative Agreement, or similar for the current phase? Provide a copy of the document. No Federal cost share percentage available for this project: 75% Is this project funded through FEMA for storm repairs? Yes Provide a copy of the signed Project Worksheet. (Attachment 3) Marco Island Beach has FEMA Category G funds due to damage as a result of Tropical Storm Fay. This has been included within the 5-year estimated budget under the Federal Cost Share column at 75%of eligible cost. Local Sponsor Financial and Administrative Commitment Is funding for the project in the local sponsor's 10-year comprehensive financial plan? Yes Please provide copy or web link to the plan. http://www.colliemov.net/modules/show document.aspx?documentid=49023 Is funding provided through a source established by referendum? Yes The referendum is attached to this application as Attachment 4. Is funding provided by a third party? No What is the percentage of total project costs provide by the third party? NA Please provide a copy of the cost sharing agreement. Quarterly Report Compliance: 07CO1: contract expires on 12/31/14 Quarter ending in Sept 2012: sent on 10-3-12 (2012 quarter 3) Quarter ending in Dec 2012: sent on 4-24-13 (2012 quarter 4) Quarter ending in March 2013: sent on 4-24-13 (2013 quarter 1) Quarter ending in June 2013: sent on 6-25-13 (2013 quarter 2) Packet Page -1616- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Are there active federal and state permits for the project? Yes Have local funds been secured for the project? Yes Collier County has dedicated the majority of the Tourist Taxes to beach maintenance, including funding projects within Marco Island. The funding was approved by referendum (Attachment 4). In order to acquire state funding, a resolution from the local sponsor must be provided by the application deadline which declares: • Support from the Sponsor for the Proposed Project • Willingness to serve as the Local Sponsor • Ability to provide the full Local Cost Share • And the source of the funding Please provide copy of the resolution. The resolution is unchanged from last year and attached to this application as Attachment 5. Previous State Commitment: Has the Department previously cost shared,reviewed, and approved a feasibility or design phase for this project? Yes Previous State Cost Share percentage 20.88% Will this project enhance or increase the longevity of a previously-constructed project?How? Rehabilitation of the five erosion control structures will increase sand retention on the island, which will increase project life. Will this project nourish a previously restored shoreline? (Full beach nourishment. Dune-only projects do not qualify.) Yes Project Performance: Nourishment Interval (Years): 6 years Mitigation of Inlet Effects: Criterion is calculated by the Department. Please provide any supplemental information that may assist in determining if the project is located with the area of inlet influence and provides supplemental nourishment for an inlet that is not balancing its sediment budget as defined by the Inlet Management Plan or Strategic Beach Management Plan. The Marco Island project is nourished in synergy with maintaining Caxambas Pass for navigation. The type of project is widely practiced in North Carolina and New Jersey, and it is economical and reduces cumulative environmental impacts. This practice meets the objective of the Strategic Beach Management Plan. This project returns sand eroded from the beach to the beach for 100%sustainability. Packet Page -1617- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Use of Innovative Applications of existing technologies: Does the project address erosion in a method that is economically competitive with nourishment, that will not adversely affect the conservation of fish and wildlife, including endangered or threatened species, or their habitats, and that is designed to demonstrate an innovative application of existing technologies? Improvements to the combined breakwater and groin system at the south end of the project area were conducted to control sand being lost off the south end of the island. The reconstruction of these erosion control structures will increase project life. Has the project been documented to be effective and demonstrated technologies previously untried in the state? N/A Regionalization: Is this project being planned or constructed in cooperation with another local government to reduce contracting costs?Explain and attach a signed copy of the interlocal agreement between the two local sponsors. This is a joint Collier County and Marco Island project. Significance: The last placement event along South Marco occurred between March and April 2013. Since the project is less than one year old,the calculation was performed using the August 23, 2012 survey. Based on surveys between October 2006 (pre-construction)and January 2007(post-construction) the beach nourishment project,prior to the 2013 placement, added approximately 27,800 cy of material above the MHW line within the project area(R-146 to G-4). Comparing the January 2007(post-construction) survey with the August 2012 survey,the project area(R-146 to G-4)has lost approximately 16,400 cy of material above the MHW line. This represents a loss of 58.57%of the placement volume. Has the project eroded into the design template? Yes What is the proposed placement volume? 77,800 cubic yards was placed as part of the 2013 nourishment Packet Page -1618- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 1 Project Maps Packet Page -1619- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. E ,-- gyp..� � re i $- 'a4 44,airy ° f{2i �Z qg V.-7-t- 1= , -4--441., ‘..-fisi ..- , i ,f., :* Li LT_t }v ' ` �� /° y .. m z z 1 uv .1w• • O `28dww z kt. ** (*If ''''''''1"41 , j: '''L' 1 i S'�Wii _` f ✓ 's - 1 d i•. L c G Z m tt LL is 41 Z U $ 'W awtxLb t �t'a. i a y S a_\ � , d R' w J Q N d 1� y -�.� fir J i.. r `x , GO�EtE 6WD m .za+,a,.'°,"a^�,"., na V m r m �3tx ie+ '> SOUTN �':^-"^°-'i+"1O' a F 1. ".ice ti, � =1�i p,rte pm 1 Y M -II r �xi R z7l � 1 �µ t: Sr qt } it 1 � a. 'j 'r, t { '*4),,, ♦ :t .'`. 1 sus J"ayf,`�,d'.r cY � } }" t ft o d y at R ki ii W ♦' _ D •,5. t* U W a `i'.- ``� � • Z 4 W { yr 1'vf"r. st it f E n}} ,°'F� { o i . ' f lO O Ni W . 1 O O M N O I .p r"t �_ G, 1 c c . 0,4 "' 'L`1srt I �iDm9°LyE ,,t& fEr�*we a^ i ;ca.�.,. !•t, t a(`o n d-0`m .,.M'90 dip C O n O D rt E p G d'O G 1" O *MMrit:.0 td 44 " ° O L2, U O G NI N 7 `°� pp d m E Q y ° w U --2—.52Z-0—=O U a'N N i O o--C ao-- K N o�° o m o c o o pCi N U�Z D d co Z —= Packet Page-1620- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. u i ff ' 4i z n' L E Z z�-NL w e � K tt \ i3 LL r':5,--7,1 �$ kW t U r d R t ' - .b J y I , ... . , _._ — _c-, 42' 0 m` #�, ' t a 7 U 4 1 ; r r � ,p N s '1' ,*p,�:� �. t g�i q 3• . s h F 5 v 7 k , L. .: , i.t i'-';',,,,° •a' iti 1'- � ,-, I _ p$ "' ii,4 4. pu, + po 1` 1§, ir . If.Pell- s •+a'Y .spa .1 ] s+p ?� s a _ t r fax �" o a nN* ki LL r k•4..r.F = t u I _ ,, -0 C Z 4 wiryy P w a _"z '�r. .s; q tiY a7 U d E E o ■ U cu c J N F CO N u ti N C.�O N M1 `p pM N... 92 i a>-N�M 2 ■ R` a Y, 4 M 'I' EWZ =� 'F. ggt ? a tti� 7{ �H :�'v {p o E r c mL° ' �y '''-'•':4 aq Z , r `$�q 1 o m m�a c al & t kT 't I mi.�tma! E r d ti 7£ nco o a 'wa'° a° �-� i 4 x m E ,,,c,_ d� oas I ry f _____ Rc� p6_ m_CV I cn0ca ooN u L O p mocaccaU' ° NU U m C(� !H C `m_mEQ_0O • ° „� op CaQ a) QU 30; N °3-35' 00- °'`om�co• ° w C N Z NU E co Z Packet Page-1621- o 10/8/2013 16.A.16. gs —.tr 71•T, v . z §+;.F..R Li I- ' .... en W Z 3 � �I .it i ,_ -. , H . ;,LL U r "e r`ry?.;r: U z oI. � g Q F P .'4,.''''''''7.- . � ..�+ ".r'�we+ _ c a L'2 f #' C O0 ¢ . I- a .,9/,\18:-63i1,710.;, ??;;;;• fi 4 et y l A , • - r U r V �"'.J l�w rat f , 4 °" - ,, � L --� �.t 8.-,,- Tr ''.1g, YR..,t � 1�.; 1 d h d y 1 as r7. c s'a r , °S°3 r ' s k m. ' e .-'r° > .S , Y c • ' O o Cy .' U k �f f s a` LL m a) E ▪■ i Lo N N Nu▪i O O[7 N ¢ mNo2c,S I '• yr�,, _sue• y �Q Z'= , I W Z m r. O O C4 c Lu -owr3577ozE ,15 o y, m LOE rna av dp I rc) �a«o0- o>5 c m 1 I CO U v m 0� j 2 `y `y pr � O t w i i°E �Ga"', 000sta-I � R� Eao a61 "E.<"-c)-7);' ''“,r) NU O . )»„ ` a ti W2 I 15 r N M Z —Z Packet Page-1622- 0 10/8/2013 16.A.16. un..�w, • A = z LL ' ', r > W ,� '. ''..4..,', � ��k�. 99 r;r� . m L E z i� e ....._,./ T .}a . v - 1'�1 Tom' ,id.. r ' d '. m d z Q m g o m ,',i'...—.7 f:--, S ' a T m U) w a�� a z e ". 8 O 2 Rm - kitik g s d O C O - I- x m_..,• r OMIBOOH OOS v q;.;'^7 q R i }� ,� - ter .. �,ir �. �. @ .� s .,y. �'000'n . t 'Li tit ;- �,�n ,. .° °. r8lfd9. ii ter„ .; °o co d .Fn- S +I .. . ..., J..rFc.4f:- . l"`Y- sfN,w. C O ti k m e. ,,,,g '- -!: `' £ab � : x . 2 a g' ' an 'r ,- r-+ f _✓ ; „' 10'' Z f rn C Y W Q, N N ' Q U A N U m m y o E E a• Q E m 'c s o J N — 1 I Hi!! 0 I z 0 Q U 5 iii=#' 4iR I W Z m a' ., �'�_ P.tsO 'y '► O I c u10i d•z. 'c,'J A ' t$ ,;a 7 , y.," jt 1 0 Mme'm c a' �,� C7 a.s. � 'n.n 't `� e. - g,'m`O 2_.E.• m i ,rte -ar.,',',€ 1 m °' E `° o m a aai �' z�E1 ievav�i°} 'sx�S 6 I C II Q°a N 32,0 u LI ,..�'"nv 1 N U U R c U N c w,, 000sw� mmda ou ° _ E_ME v, I a Q °_� a U O.8 1 °-'"'avr- d K o N o�° o m o c o 0 U� °a I m Ucn ZOamNU r O r N M Z 2 Packet Page-1623- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 0, } L. i , ? tr';'1_74-:;;-• .P r " C W+ 2 LL a ; t0 — L CO bhi:'...a''' '-r-',:',,,,,;',:.: 'I:fit \ '''' ' ' .:J1 r 61 to Z V c E zm adg 2U,m {, n 01 Ol'67 ElQn 1 pc a'..4 ' :.;.::, M 4 ,` l O sr•,',••,, *.. • ,...„ ;� i` 000L 1.9- $ fig: 'c rs P .. c--.:: _ ,o � o LL O F o�p m s t II • CI LL } ° E EL k, Y r "�r �t, V• Lu U- O tl E td 00091.4- B • N Q o c EN s ._ - ... f 0 co N 0 a 3. ti C C 1 ENCCri2 t v 2u).62--e-,%-02. a i -? �' U o m c U '°c� P y cI)i rrig s'ai^$S w 00091.4-, 16 m E Q ° zo o z p.�Tf mav,o=o f N o vaa c wU 0U C)O N O U Z,. X O,.% C7 Packet Page -1624- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 2 Hotel Licenses and Property Information Packet Page-1625- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Collier County—South Marco Local Government Funding Request Property Name:Cape Marco Property Address: 970 Cape Marco Dr. Marco Island, FL 34145 License Number: PR1G025964 The referenced property has a total of 683 units, of which, 683 are available, at the owner's discretion, to rent to the public. Therefore, a total of 100% percent of the property is available on a rental basis. The above information was obtained from the Rob Hart, Manager in August of 2013. Packet Page -1626- DBPR- BELIZE AT CAPE MARCO,A CONDO, Condominium Project Page 1 of 1 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 11:22:04 AM 8/29/2013 Licensee Details Licensee Information Name: BELIZE AT CAPE MARCO, A CONDO (Primary Name) (DBA Name) Main Address: 970 CAPE MARCO DRIVE MARCO ISLAND Florida 33937 County: COLLIER License Mailing: LicenseLocation: License Information License Type: Condominium Project Rank: Condo Project License Number: PR1G025964 Status: Approved,Recorded Licensure Date: 07/03/2001 Expires: 01/01/2014 Special Qualifications Qualification Effective Group View Related License Information View License Complaint View Additional Information 1940 North Monroe Street,Tallahassee FL 32399:: Email:Customer Contact Center :: Customer Contact Center:850,487,1395 The State of Florida is an AA/EEO employer.Copyright.2007-2010 State of Florida.Privacy Statement Under Florida law,email addresses are public records.If you do not want your email address released in response to a public-records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact the office by phone or by traditional mail.If you have any questions,please contact 850.487.1395.*Pursuant to Section 455.275(1),Florida Statutes,effective October 1,2012,licensees licensed under Chapter 455,F.S.must provide the Department with an email address It they have one,The emails provided may be used for official communication with the licensee, However email addresses are public record.If you do not wish to supply a personal address,please provide the Department with an email address which can be made available to the public.Please see our Chapter 455 page to determine if you are affected by this change. https://www.myfloridalicense.com/Licen:Packet Page -1627-id=73449A1C4E8DAE4A3B... 8/29/2013 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 3 Project Worksheet Packet Page-1628- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. U.S.DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY O.M.B.No.1660-0017 PROJECT WORKSHEET Expires October 31,2006 Pubic reporting burden for this form is estimated to average 90 minutes. Burden means time,effort and financial resources expended by persons to generate,maintain, disclose,or to provide information to us. You may send comments regarding the burden estimate or any aspect of the collection,including suggestions for reducing the burden to:Information Collection Management,U.S.Department of Homeland Security,Federal Emergency Management Agency,500 C Street,SW,Washington,DC 20472,Paperwork Reduction Project(OMB Control number 1660-0017).You are not required to respond to this collection information unless a valid OMB number appears in the upper right corner of this form. NOTE:Do not send your completed questionnaire to this address. DECLARATION NO. PW REF NO. DATE FIPS NO. CATEGORY NEMIS NO. FEMA 1785 DR FL JCCCO2G 11/19/08 021-99021-00 G APPLICANT WORK COMPLETED AS OF: DATE: PERCENT: Collier,County of 08/19/08 0% DAMAGED FACILITY COUNTY South Marco Island Beach Collier LOCATION LATITUDE LONGITUDE Marco Island,City of 25.91051 -81.82507 Was this site previously damaged? r` Yes C No C Unsure DAMAGE DESCRIPTION AND DIMENSIONS: The applicant is not participating in the"Pilot Program"in regards to this PW. As a result of high winds and surf associated with Tropical Storm(TS)Fay during the period August 18 and September 12,2008, Applicant sustained significant beach erosion of sand. Applicant's estimate of beach sand loss is 76,728 CY(cubic yards)along 4,383 linear feet(LF)(0.83 MI)of shoreline within the City of Marco Island is based upon a pre-storm survey(June 2007)and post-storm survey (September 2008)by Applicant's coastal engineer,Humiston&Moore, Inc.(H&M),in their attached report,South Marco Island Beach Renourishment Project-Post TS Fay Impact Evaluation,November 2008. The significant beach erosion occurred along the portion of Marco Island Beach maintained by Applicant between DEP monuments R-144 and R148,at the southwestern tip of Marco Island and adjacent to Caxambas Pass. TS Fay made landfall along the Florida Gulf coast on August 19,2008 less than two miles south of the subject beach. SCOPE OF WORK: 1. Applicant intends to competitively bid contracts to replace 76,728 CY of sand by dredging a Florida DEP approved offshore source and pumping sand back onto the beach. The sand will be pumped to design grades and elevations and shall meet all specifications for beach-quality as required. The initial offshore source of suitable sand has been from Caxambas Pass,immediately south of the subject beach. A sufficient quantity of suitable sand is not expected to be available from this source;therefore the Applicant is seeking permit authority to dredge sand and transport the material from Cape Romano 15.0 MI further south. H&M and Applicant estimate this extra distance and required onshore pumping and handling will increase previous costs for dredge mobilization/demobilization cost to approximately$700,000 and will increase the unit cost for reclaimed sand to$20.00/CY. [Cost Items#2 and 3] 2. H&M estimates the average width of the project fill zone for placing sand and grading is 100 LF,for a total land area for construction of 10.06 AC(4,383 LF X 100 LF). Using cost estimates from the 2007 project,H&M estimates the cost for placing and grading the sand along the shoreline to be$1,591.35.AC,or$16,008.98. [Cost Item#4] Does the Scope of Work change the pre-disaster conditions at the site? r Yes a No Special Considerations issues included? t: Yes r No Is there insurance coverage on this facility? C Yes ( No Hazard Mitigation proposal included? r Yes (% No PROJECT COST ITEM CODE NARRATIVE QUANTITY UNIT UNIT PRICE COST 1 0 WORK TO BE COMPLETED 2 9001 DREDGE MOBILIZATION/DEMOBILIZATION-Estimate 1 LS $700,000.00 $ 700,000.00 3 9001 SAND,DREDGE-Contract Estimate 76728_CY $20.00$ 1,534,560.00 4 9001 SAND,PLACE AND GRADE- Contract Estimate 10.06 AC _ $1,591.35 $ 16,008.98 5 9001 TURBIDITY MONITORING 1 LS $15,913.50$ _15,913.50_ 6 9001 ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING _ _ _ 1 LS $26,522.50 $ 2_6,522.50 7 9001 _CONSTRUCTION SURVEYS 3 EA $15,913.50 $ 47,740.50 _8 9001 CONSTRUCTION MONITORING 1 LS $53,045.00 $ 53,045.00 9 9001 .GEOTECHNICAL STUDY 1 LS $50,000.00 $ 50,000.00 SUBTOTAL FROM COST CONTINUATION PAGE(S) $ 378,787.52 /► TOTAL PROJECT COST $ 2,822,578.01 PREPARED BY: Joseph Chesler Oi yt�' TITLE: Project Specialist-Coastal FEMA PAC: Don Soegaard STATE PAC:Jorge Alpizar APPLICANT: Len Price DATE: PHONE: (239)252-3646 FEIM Form 9041,FEB 06 REPLACES NI PREVIOUS VERSIONS Packet Page -1629- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Page 1 of 1 FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY ADDITIONAL PROJECT COSTS DECLARATION NO. PW REF NO. DATE FIPS NO. CATEGORY NEMIS NO. FEMA I FL I DR 1 1785 JCCCO2G 11!19108 021-99021-00 G APPLICANT COUN Collier,County of Collier PROJECT COSTS(CONTINUED) ITEM CODE NARRATIVE QUANTITY UNIT UNIT PRICE COST 10 9001 DESIGN&ENGINEERING COSTS-Contract Estimate 1 LS $293,254.86 $ 293,254.86 11 9901 PROJECT MANAGEMENT-SUBGRANTEE 1 LS $73,313.71 $ 73,313.71 12 9901 DIRECT ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS_SUBGRANTEE —_—_ 1— LS — $12,218.95 $ 12,218.95 ------- --- — -- -- --- $ $ -_ $ $ $ - $ $ $ $ — ----- ------- ------ ------------- ------------------------ ----------- ---------- — ----------------- ------- ---- --- --------- -------------- -- — ------------- -- — $ - TOTAL COSTS THIS PAGE $ 378,787.52 PREPARED BY: Joseph Chesler TITLE: Project Specialist-Coastal Raviaad Jan-07 Packet Page-1630- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Page 1 of 1 FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY DAMAGE DESCRIPTION & SCOPE OF WORK DECLARATION NO. PW REF NO. DATE FIPS NO. CATEGORY NEMIS NO. FEMA 1785 DR FL JCCCO2G 11/19/08 021-99021-00 G APPLICANT COUNTY Collier,County of Collier DAMAGE DESCRIPTION&SCOPE OF WORK(CONTINUED): 3. Applicant has used various approaches to beach nourishment to maintain their beaches since 1991. At that time,the entire beach was renourished(from R-135 to R-139 and R-143 to R-148)with 575,000 CY of dredged sand. In 1996,a segmented rock breakwaterwas constructed to add additional stability to the restored beach and to reduce further sand loss in Caxambas Pass. Approximately 60,000 CY of sand was placed on the subject beach area(from R-144 to G-1)in 1997 via dredge from Caxambas Pass. An additional 20,000 CY of truck-haul sand from upland sources was added to the subject beach at various times between 1998 and 1999. Most recently,in 2007,Applicant completed the South Marco Island Beach Nourishment Project,which deposited approximately 176,000 CY of sand over the project area in the wake of Hurricane Wilma(FEMA-1609-DR-FL),although only 55,000 CY of fill was deemed FEMA-eligible as a result of that storm event(PW 6733). 4. H&M calculated the eligible sand loss by first measuring the reduction in beach width across the full extent of the subject beaches (76,728 CY). H&M has studied the relative stability of the subject beach from 1991 to present and presents their findings in their engineering report,Post TS Fay Impact Evaluation. That report finds that without the referenced rock breakwater in place,the normally beach erosion rate would be approximately 34,000 CY annually. H&M's analysis finds the background losses(i.e.,beach erosion rate) along the subject beach has been negligible since construction of the breakwater and concludes that the approximate erosion of 76,728 CY of sand represents the actual storm losses from TS Fay. 5. The dredging contractor would be required to use a trawler across the project site to locate sea turtle nests and to carefully remove any active nests from the project area prior to filling operations. Similarly,permits require turbidity monitoring during construction to control suspension of solids in the water column,and environmental monitors are needed throughout the project to eliminate impacts to sensitive species within the project area. H&M and Applicant estimates the combined cost of these environmental protective measures to be$42,436. [Cost Items#5 and 6] 6. Pre-construction,construction monitoring and post-construction surveys would also be conducted by H&M to confirm beginning site conditions prior to dredging,sand placement and grading progress and to determine final placement quantities. These three surveys would be provided at a total cost of$47,740.50.Construction monitoring will be provide by the dredging contractor for an estimated cost of$53,045. [Cost Items#7 and 8] 7. Geotechnical studies estimated to cost$50,000 are required for permitting purposes and to confirm Applicant's offshore borrow site suitability for placement on the beach. [Cost Item#9] 8. Design&Engineering Costs: Applicant's coastal engineer(H&M)would be eligible for costs directly related to the design,installation, monitoring and related services associated with the proposed work. A standard of 12.0%of the net eligible costs is allocated for relevant design,engineering and associated administrative costs for this large project in accordance with Public Assistance Guide,FEMA 322/June 2007,Figure 3,pg.58. [Cost Item#10] 9. Project Management-Subgrantee: Project management costs by the Applicant are applied to the project at the rate of 3.0%of the net eligible costs. [Cost Item#11] 10. Direct Administrative Costs-Subgrantee(SDAC): Direct administrative costs by the Applicant are applied to the project at the rate of 0.5%of the net eligible costs. [Cost Item#12] 11.Applicant's documentation of claimed costs for this project have been reviewed and found to be eligible,accurate and reasonable. 12.All records for this PW must be retained at the applicant's office for a period of at least five(5)years from the final closeout of their claim. 13.Upon completion,this site will be returned to it's original design,function and capacity within the original project footprint. The Applicant is responsible for obtaining all local,state and/or federal permits as they may apply to this project 14. Copies of the following list of permits pertaining to this project are included herein: a. USACE Permit SAJ-2005-2726(IP-MN),issued 01/11/2006; b. USFWS Biological Opinion(Service Log#4-1-04-TR-11752),issued 11/14/2005; c. FDEP Joint Coastal Permit#0235209-01-JC,issued 12/22/2005. PREPARED BY: Joseph Chesler TITLE: Project Specialist-Coastal Revised Jan-07 Packet Page-1631- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 0 N a co 0 $lg ; o 0 e0 a fA co co a. N 0000 viri U m + + + + + is- co N v v a v v F- co o 3 .. a 3 3 N N W m F G CO 'NC pO CO O O O "3 al 2 Ili Os V N ti pn R Np Np NCp N z Z O 0 T 7 h 8 a S & C. & oL ll I, W ,s7 7 7 7 -p7 g w 7 N mN N N n CO .0 !!!.n/A0 a ti $ I m m m m m m m m m m W U E q 05 a E E E E E O Z N e W H )E 'N 'N N N N Q m .G m m m m m m 2 W i.. o cc) m g m L m CO i i 1 i i VC C WI- 0 41-0 14 h w o el I n s W 5 E E c c o '2 W N O N .M... i..• v v ti. C W CO CO CO OJ CO 0 0 Q I J 0 c ° w` U w w` w w` w w r ui v.. O co g g g g g g g 8 8 `i ...S. O O CO 0 0 0 O O CO C) N 5 O O O) O O U) O O d P) LO eh f�! Ili U.'LL W O 0 CO `Cr S O VA CO CO CO .1 AV, W O �'' CO O e7 co" 1C) t0 I� c7 O L) N ce w �� d N N fV N N N I m o: CO g fA fA w fR tR /9 a r4 r9 0 IQ U 1- O ¢ 160 • co tuil O CO C 00 ° ° ° 0 O CD 0 0in 0 "C 0 0 h N h O O 1 ° i ° o � � rnfrn � o= z c _co C Cl) FW - Es )9 > r■69 69 64 69 d4 69 CD Cti CU •• Z co „t O N O " r CO u-J O N <_ ti) 0 �.i taa V. m I S Q 0 o C CO M CD L ft, F m _1 CD Z ~ V w IS o m 1 of 114 = F e — v fm co o , �) .., rn °) v) v) CO v7 CO e �` L- N C.1 fp f0 ca co co , ¢ ai ' J U Q J J J J J I e O CL Ca W W 11 In 0 U 4 I I � U • I� a H ILJ LL_ E u. ▪ W CO fp U U N to CD CO CO eel: Z r n 0 r r C7 r r N. W Z O O 0) O) O) fp- O `- LL t- `' r g W N g O I 1 d 0 C O it of 6 i� o 0 0 e iccr of o >, o °• Q d 0 CD h aD f 'Q C o •C 3 0 0 go h m W d d d d d �I- O w Q M v U = v p n 9Iw it ththatht c m o a o v m 0 ,0 m2 0 c m I Eat c m in o) - a ,G 'a re p o ci) u 0) c c I E- , I 0 m ' U20w.v ( w < g... a Packet Page -1632- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. Collier County PW#JCCCO2G South Marco Island Beach Preliminary Bid — Geotechnical Study Preliminary opinion of geotechnical costs for Tropical Storm Fay on South Marco Island Item Number Unit Unit Price Cost Mob 1 LS 9,550 9,550 Vibracores 15 Cores 1,400 21,000 Core Processing 15 Each 175 2,625 GSD analysis 50 Sample 60 3,000 Carbonate analysis 50 Sample 84 4,200 Compatibility analysis/permitting 1 LS 7,475 7,475 Standby 1 Day 2,150 2,150 50,000 Prepared by Athena Technologies, Inc. 3700 Rosewood Drive Columbia, South Carolina 29205 www.athenatech no loci ies.com (803)790-4483 11/21/2008 Packet Page-1633- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY O.M.B.No.1660-0017 SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS Expires October 31,2008 DISASTER APPLICANT NAME PW REF NO. FIPS NO. DATE FL I 1785 Collier,County of JCCCO2G 021-99021-00 11/19/08 1. Does the damaged facility or item of work have insurance and/or is it an insurable risk? (e.g.,buildings,equipment vehicles,etc.) f Yes r No G Unsure 2. Is the damaged facility located within a floodplain or coastal high hazard area,or does it have an impact on a floodplain or wetland? (:Yes C No C Unsure Located in coastal areas covered by FIRM panels 12021 C0B11 G(see attachment),Zone A or V 3. Is the damaged facility or item of work located within or adjacent to a Coastal Barrier Resource System Unit or an Otherwise Protected Area? C Yes T No C Unsure 4. Will the proposed facility repairs/reconstruction change the pre-disaster condition? (e.g.,footprint material,location,capacity,use or function) C Yes r No C Unsure 5. Does the applicant have a hazard mitigation proposal or would the applicant like technical assistance for a hazard proposal? C Yes ( No C Unsure 6. Is the damaged facility on the National Register of Historic Places or the state historic listing? Is it older than 50 years? Are there more,similar buildings near the site? C Yes is No C Unsure 7. Are there any pristine or undisturbed areas on,or near,the project site? Are there large tracts of forestland? C Yes (: No C Unsure 8. Are there any hazardous materials at or adjacent to the damaged facility and/or item of work? C Yes is' No C Unsure 9. Are there any other environmentally or controversial issues associated with the damaged facility and/or item of work? Fes. a Yes C No C Unsure Sea turtle nesting area. PREPARED BY: IJOSeph Chester FEMA Form 90-120 Revised Jan-07 Packet Page-1634- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. a re Is' °n = m W e- 2 g 8 c c c W co_ c E L L a o a co a e 'a 5 T J pt_ E E o 2 0 LL E 3 e € € € Z c ° m m Ti � ° c ° C o u 8.42 o _w 0 p 8e. — a 9` S� a $ qq ° C m°o m aci m u c m Z'I3 2 b N o Lo pn a).- C b o 4 Re ° N O W W W U) P- 0 di N p CD a) 0)O O 0 to u U 0 0 0 oA p E o o ai ri cV o o )ti g v iri LL a) j 0 � O 0) t[) t 0 8 N O p „— 0 O U) ,0 CO t��• O M m N 1� y Ts 0 Q 03 EA N? cA co Cs 0 ur, Ea Eft E m w co m co co m co co [o m m co o win m O= o F- F- I- I- F- I- I- F- F- U m « . W C O o Q N F- c } 4 0 0 m E re U F- LL 1=ii 15 z ..-: 0 .2 F-- 0 F' Co 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 "3 Zco c ' , m m a) m co co Fm- co co °`o T w o V m u. al w L m O e 0 'A 0 V m z g ° C9 F.. 0 co 0.. z U w ooV > � W co (0 m (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 m ° z w W F- F- F- F- F- F- F- F- f- = 0 J 0 w CQC N W C O r- a) c ° o a Co N 0 5 c' a m:n m .o o .0 co m c _ _v v o co 0) > O C O c �, 0 c o C. O in o m "C 0 m O O m o E 0 7 C T 5. N f0 C N 0 E N O m 0 C C c 0 E N E ai o o 8 w E 0 c � E � b c co � 0 m 0 m c 2 2 c�3 c m CO O a) U O W co 0) a T30 I) U 1) •v a7 o 0 a F' c 0 0 C7 CI 03 0 o 2 o 2 3 2 = ci Z co O C Ci C) 0 E c C dj c p 0 -p m N 5) d m C 0 0 0 o o C > 2 .c C m p 05 cO o od -- m m 0 V O N 20 N co 0 l0 N - _°- n J m W 7 m 7 _ •U) 3 s CL ..- d 0 m m m 0 m = m = m _. > j m C c S CD Q,C) F- F- F- - F- F- X `o = o` Q a4) = `0 .0 J ct Packet Page-1635- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY REPETITIVE LOSS STATEMENT APPLICANT PROJECT NO. FIPS NO. CATEGORY DISASTER Collier,County of JCCCO2G 021-99021-00 G FL I 1785 1. Has this project/site had previous damage? !: Yes r No r Unsure (If the answer is NO,It is not necessary to address the remaining questions) 2. Did FEMA provide funding for the repair of this previous damage? r: Yes C No r Unsure (If the answer is NO,It is not necessary to address the remaining questions) 3. What is the date and cause of the previous damage? ❑ Fire Date(MM/DDIYY): 10/24/05 0 Flood ❑ Earthquake El Tornado/Wind ❑ Hall/Rain 4. Was mitigation approved in the previous disaster? r Yes t: No r Unsure 5. Was the mitigation work completed prior to this disaster? r Yes r= No r" Unsure 6. If known,provide the following information on the previous disaster: Disaster No: PW No: Version No: 1609-DR-FL 6,733 7. Comments: The initial Collier County Beach Restoraton Project was constructed in 1995/1996 to restore this critically eroded shoreline on South Marco Island. This effort resulted in the placement of 575,000 CY of sand from a nearby offshore borrow area to provide storm protection and enhance shoreline recreational amenities. Approximately 60,000 CY of sand was placed on the subject beach area (from R-144 to G-1)in 1997 via dredge from Caxambas Pass. An additional 20,000 CY of truck-haul sand from upland sources was added to the subject beach at various times between 1998 and 1999. Most recently,in 2007,Applicant completed the South Marco Island Beach Nourishment Project,which deposited approximately 176,000 CY of sand over the project area in the wake of Hurricane Wilma(FEMA-1609-DR-FL). Despite the construction of a segmented rock breakwater in 1996,the shoreline sustained further erosion damage caused by Hurricanes Katrina and Wilma in 2005,resulting in severe erosion of sand and further restoration efforts,which was conducted in 2006/2007. Collier County received FEMA funding assistance to restore this same beach under PW 6733,where FEMA paid for placing a total of 55,000 CY of sand a from Caxambas Pass. This work was completed in May 2006 and became the design basis for determining 2008 pre-storm conditions at this location. 'Revosed Jan4o7 Packet Page-1636- • 10/8/2013 16.A.16. L+ err V _d t O . i O: 1' } El _ r N— ee { 1 I ice: �� IL 3? ' .�, Z '6°- m•` r , LLI :Q' / a Q I 'i- ' 'V 3 Sy . O G.' v r � �j. 1 ai } ;• 3 . 4 ., � W . Jjl J r t• s v• r�1 :-.4, I i• 3 >- i 3 1 - 3 Q � (�(f� U -� Jr' W z Z a ., 1 M W r, ff u- a ; w ,ff 0 Q _ �-�N w M LA � f+ , 0 nom. U r r1, 11 a- '.. G N 0 Wa Ff BEY r 0,e ,` r s a F- w V •Y / �aa cue v Q Q w J _ t, - -o ,,4r, a ro O i e> ai W raQ >`-E- cap O ILI ' Z m i °o o tr • y co y � v ui N! o Z o o a+ 0 o .0 ON to N 7 C? r p •c V c ‹ d � a O Z U, Z i 9 c a �- iis IL Rc'e° Packet Page-1637- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. r ,, 40 C O ! d 1+ rr U J -1f-- r '�. 3Lt ._ ,. t {t !/-1"-c•---.7"7 ` I i r ( l r 4 J I r i' r V b S I i I I, + ';,,rk N '- ,, 1 ,, ( I { s to ,.,. 6 � i r ,�i 7I .. tl iZ9 ; =� s�i5. ) i rr ., .,==,'" ^ —, 1 Q ;er ' a jf 1�+� '1 ibi 4 : ,��.J-_ -4'- t ',,,,i t 2 1.67_ a- t {�j� i y '"' \'':",":"I'e,\ — ,,r �} :�� Lt eat �r ,_� rr i I , ,, nt I ! t r U„,` ,,xh Yr Jill 1 ;1,._,..,,,-:... 1� lift n �. + :.:- - t�L-------, , i I +[1 L I+ ,f 1,, ,� t, :i, 4 1 �)t _ ,:• --'1 I vy ( tif' ti I uJ ,.„.<,4�y . Y � r'” t: t J QG =` �'�1� x'11` 2 r ' ) �G"T }`� ,, fi`'...��, '1'.:+ `_, , ii « � d (� 19all4 u. { 03 W Z vr . I r U =' "- ��--MfCi � - V-. a in W J Lr% le-- .r• {n LL w 0 4 LO IA ut I o o LL t � r 1 — •JL "r r w A�. .a N VI G N O G ,( 6 = q E a a' r r.} U. o z v. a U o 0 6 N CO CO Q 0 ^q Z a a m a G w a Q u. n re Packet Page-1638- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. 0 :N O +j " y V 6, ..:,:,!-.1;32 'T '" , "1 w 6' 4�1 .v f .: p +15. "'r4 "K r }�4Y- '+8'I r�, - xP' Rr 'r�c r - d - S xNra k .D ■x „ - < . Y' }6 rk f b, r ,n au, Fri r'a't Z '-$ y,1 , 4 4 a",�`•� tM !,?;P� W •{7, k, s + „'„..4, ,: v .yqf t` a ,�,q ►lit,,` t a'$?:. ;�r + r i : 'i .J”, „9:,T',/{' Ili MI 1”. . 44 a.` 's' ; '� w h' 'h.s� ,4',i.,,',, 1,^i 1 L'''' '"Y" i4 � " L °�' 9 rp� it ,•4•°10,1,'''f dY ( d fi4 sfa l ^ �. • �' d R + .:r m'3 f t + t � ;• ��.a"'w . '' �:, t.7,;, ,:w4 't a .4*i.,�,''3r �, t ,�fit: a✓^ y ' . 4,.�,;x .' ti. 4q�„ -,44 4` ., r-.." "'�a 43a F'`s'1 r }`�,�' S 1 .s(` " ' s y, ,"" -+i.^ra "00e.Y. :',,,'""4-4'''.i"4.i ,7 d�. a 1,r v .. f", ' '? . ate. tt43. . c� A4 a� �r � �f,.�$t ,t,. at �'*��.�r.�;}a,�,��3 ,r Via, y.. v„t e nr° F w i.".'7, +F.ia"7'"'IR`,..-Ar. 4r; . J• �s s z ' - M A `yL" ,t„.,,,:,, d "* 1t`^_ O Q _ rA Li, lic " ` • 4 f A}L� IR W C a Q 0. z O r z w Q ix w Js.. x O w Wes. t"tn 4` '` ff �''� 34.11,41 m _ 4 , W. V Z.. o T ' --.ma7.': a s I a�� 01 n . Li L3 a .e wo •4. y� /'mil. t ,e,.e F.F+^ f M. ^Y C3- �. J Z na. a r Packet Page-1639- 10/8/2013 16.A.16.• 0 � .° i ' 'mss E w at i _j. '�fps p n1 «" W 11 zo �.~. g lil t.i.{[� Q$1 II a t z A E € e'14 b d A z O c Z0 o €:s 4 _ 0 in. O¢. ~ W ir Jj f Ihi ill a iii vow P ' ESE I � o ;511 e_Q � < s )r S -i x S rJ Y N 1 s 1k i y t-ti zr z 3 iy pG ad -x;p Y i r: d L s e n F f' Lt. 0 r F o Z b i r ? b a d W W v K . a' s�'Y ty ?= �` s 6 p a n xd d : w d � fi3 f I ': yu 'Z 5P�1 . r. Av a°� 1 Y Z v 1 qqiy £ , .. 0.l n 1 r C r SCw i� ST S Yi , r � b Q W 6 1 tfT� w in ., W 2 ce Ce tt a f i ,, L` ,, r �'}ek 7 t e y ylri ht..+ d 9 ,. r r -�'°� rdY"i2 t f` ' E-i Y e n` sn ''1:� r i t t } .�a ?'r Lt. sf �Ea � r ,q.SFr Y '` "'. w Y l � }y 4a4 to � r ,,'Y etn 1 L t. r ...,f? eY '9 E J;N- , il M �'svn s c L he n 1 h J c>' LLI d, ... '` % 1 is ..,A-x tfFror�btt JY, a': �q "(` tY' .Fr N k-r y c a4'��}s4' t4�' YT • U1 "� 3 . 4 N 'iG tj l . a r t,. Y ,ri i'l rr", -i Cl.ir ¢ lu f {'1. .• s s t f(+r .*r ti -}4i2 rf e ,1 ° i s.. 1 3, '1t Lt r r .s b .:x x , y% i. '.• f a,.'7ti�f ty 4' `,t 4'":•',r. T. +, r t./ s 2 t.' L f rF w i fs � s b.yr L ? 1 C . rF }t��srya4'. V' '. + v�t.$f� ':- f t. `' �n i '3 .+,a ' r,j; yo- � s" � ,r :-� s r` i , '^ a ,k ! ,� -c . d!'. �,v yr',.,', .,�.... x+4�u:s.,c. f^fry. *..2''. .;L r r`i a 'v. !�� ,' I aY - >rot:,,•',,rx7,,7. rm, .P;}.n7' t .w J:, m t R^ ' f c'* ?,:°i- x fir` F: ,uol :.` g LT ..3'Z i e N ; ;.--� J WQ • N� w J7 Z o Wa oo W• Q �LL Q C ¢ WO ea o. r- / $ C.)... C"4: DLL 0 w •�' Of LL a 2 L Qf Wz a 3s • V..0 , z ,z o o Q O < ■f■ 4 • Packet Page -1640- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ) ,Lxt L C OD p �!� n N,ar �45C Lf .i.-•:„. � �t Ol y4 t., h ,y 1r8.. d • V, U f 4Y i Xe r (� 1 e4 a + '-4' Sit k ' t.. r ti 7 Iii -Ce LLI .N 1 3 r 0.' k'.0. f" .,,,,,,,..„,:f.,,,.,.:,„.,,,.....„....,;4• - > as�4�r + 1.4:',45 9 -;.• Q I` 'i`�{.6# ��, Q a a ff rM i tY �r fib,; N x 72.,,,:,;:7:1.,p,-.'-v-0..* z : rind �;� l' i4# ^W$x'J' "- f 4 o° 'i ..., �'''''.17;/".74.;'''.1,4,` a k p1fA� a , ±x Z J r- 1 al 7r�3 { fa " � pax ti i r m ,{g M k . i k o� � p�kr a c v C O i a3c ,, c+ :.t Y l0 f ., " � N, x O O `V a 3 iw C ; 3 �CD Q. N 7 '',• 8 coo a.W I O W Q V. Lu Q N zF— a �. � , .•. ill rr.V•r• + ,.. '- k ,r : i. • hi. dye t4 R t x yi r w a Yi ` } bawy O ''''4171.''' aF h c. V 1Pr< cn 1 t f�? 43 'n rgQf o,yr!, - o O ti a " F–' . v ` �,�it� m iP� �4 Z' . 04 M ;� W N m CO A µ hy O N a d -- 'H g i4 a ; 06— } ;' `, '>i . qZ " '' l"+ i g O 9 V ''''4":14":.4.-''''....."' r$S vi a d < LL Packet Page-1641- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. • N #,:,r .; y�'�`rM FP -1-.m,y ,,,,s,,,, 1... (.) , , „ „....... . .. ... .. Lw t . >• Z0 wl i 77 a ,,k¢.'y,s'i l t� , k Y CO• � hF ` r'15�,�.# � z''f"1 N a t .z a o k��u �, .r • V'n '.r,,,,,,,,,,,, �`'fi"r ate,,.'rTF� t R cii a. O rt , e C 1'41'7,1' Y r� .a �r 4 '00 as 0 6 CO w ha CO Z r� v3d ii: L -, '� A as 0 Ad 00 Lx i yyFx x (p g u.1 V- 0 ly p t„a v” 0 t O I LL I N w >— 0 C L z H 0 T w QJ F k i r H L( 'A,p ■ LL aN, x mY”rywtV" ( a71H[I y" a d �) x+114 . - t'. Orr h F -- �� O r -. 2; ,,� '. N J e r ix� Y m I- 0,.., - '' v ,om 3.3„e-a..3/3 `t„ + ' r e CO Z 3e - + C O■ Gs Z C °' 'tp! ii. � ' i}, K t l,E G, � CO c C 3Y, r t t U 66 k iA O Q e r fi x 3 ,""';'‘-t. " C hA'''''t 5 °a N O - .fi t 5► 4.'0 -' ca R } .t :,';'„01,,,,,,N.1, � �� t p G ��x a b t h � u Y,rr ,m Of V 3 v r: .' 4,,s;&,, ,y V r O 1'd ° n ilLeP h 3 raN GS c - vv >o co. 3 d' 't�w � `w E Z ,Q a Z a a .QLL Packet Page-1642- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. BACK UP INFO APPLICANT Collier,County of DATE:. 11/19/2008 FIPS#: 021-99021-00 PROJ.# JCCCO2G BACKUP DOCUMENTATION DO NOT COPY / SCAN Packet Page -1643- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 4 Referendum establishing the Collier County Tourist Development Tax eAPt Packet Page-1644- FROM : ELECTIONS OFFICE FAX NO. : 941-774-9468 Jun. H9 WC 10/8/2013 16.A.16. P12 Official Ballot GENERAL ELECTION Collier County,Florida-November 3, 1992 f�a ,e: I I+,Ir.yr t ' ., e ;y C.` ;1614 ‘,.;'::***'''''",t/41. w 1 T �WIDE" F E�D g „ id .:1�' "1"7"7,7; .e ' 4 REFERENDUM ELECTION TO APPROVE THE LEVY OF 2%TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX SHALL COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE NO.92-00 BE APPROVED TO LEVY,IMPOSE AND SET A TWO PERCENT TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX ON EACH DOLLAR OF THE TOTAL RENT CHARGED ON ANY LIVING QUARTERS OR ACCOMMODATIONS IN ANY HOTEL MOTEL,RESORT,APARTMENT, ROOMING HOUSE,MOBILE HOME PARK,RECREATIONAL VEHICLE PARK,OR CONDOMINIUM FOR A ItriM OF SIX MONTHS OR LESS FOR FINANCING BEACH RENOURISHMENTAND MAINTENANCE, AND TO PROMOTE AND ADVERTISE TOURISM? YES FOR THE TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX 219- I NO AGAINST THE TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX 220- I STRAW BALLOT SHALL THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS VOTE TO LEVY AN ADDITIONAL CENT TO THE OR'GINALTWO PERCENT TOURISTDEVELOPMENTTAX ON EACH DOLLAR OF THE RENT CHARGED ON ANY LIVING DUARTERS OR ACCOMMODATIONS IN ANY HOTEL,MOTEL RESORT,APARTMENT, ROOMNGHCUSE,MOBILE HOME PARK,RECREATIONAL VEHICLE PARK,OR OCNDOMINIUM FOR A TERM OF SIX MONTHS OR LESS IN ORDER TO PAY DEBT SERVICE ON BONDS ISSUED TO FINANCE THE GONSIKUCTION OF A PROFESSIONAL BASEBALL FRANCHISE FAC'LITY? YES 226 NO 227 COUNTYWIDE 1 . Packet Page -1645- I V 10/8/2013 16.A.16. N - � _ Q 170. ��II: 0 ---.... p., 4 A T�, (At11 ----. 0 ,_ 6 r N 0 4? ,.0.- ._....--: &. re- Ea* SI ; C/C4 47%. ,......_ , ;wig( tte- = 2 ,,,,, ..., Moi,„_ 0, 411) 41) rill 0 * : 13 Q ei,ic * * Glit ii. O ) . 0 Z a • Jaw Vce?uiy,77ff iv Packet Page-1646- E � � c N � � o L �. '. - - .t, 10/8/2013 16.A.16. C .- C Q• O N Q c3 L O O ..% ..0 E ° �. ca O to �, as _ _ y, a, C C u ^~ L N ° c'-: C U ° O E a. C y C U E t y c c = v - > 0 4 O L. C L c,. E 0 v C R s = t -v - y In O. z L. ° CE if n " •C O p y O C>> C C Y '.'•1 u E a, U � E as ' o E-y C)> ZL o o L=.1 Y. C a, y r. a -o O Uom ,. o C C C U ca C + O CD V E E 'O -t- o G c •--1 O a L O + O U y j ON o as � O O O O co)H U O L sn 1"--) �. c.. O, a O _ _ x ^ L `O. . L Cn O a; •— > c, V a�L C C:. C co C C U ^p o "' a� 'fl A O O Q E as CA C3. O " a`�j .0 t] C ... V G CA E V ,.,P O E ". — ca y aj ej U n• C w L "c . = 0.-l. O U L 0 .a G-. CA • C C ^p 'O -C yO a) 0 .= 0 0 L. y O 0 y = C Z R U R P-. Z E 1 .O E-.1 � O t. .= CJ : a: R O .-r J C � U w e ,8 .. — U 0 .. ai � O C3 y '� L. C° w y 67• ....w V . a) U ai C C 0 U R L O O = u _ a 1 E u = R t.. O .o CO •0 .0 C 3 .0 o 'o i _ a E o n U a) c 0 u E Ys y > E O co E L C o g 0. u L O C E ' R 1 et ._ y 0 c ,v oQLn c c 0 u o c , o o > cs � � ›. o 3_ N U v, - v o -' y .0 O ti. v E° u u > p Py °L .t' ° • O-E = a O .�� 0 C C It q u V U r C "C vC eil � ee L. 2C � F ai : - E -0 � C ^O O 0 O CC Q u C .� 7 C °o o o c C .o L o v u a E 7 � v a O U O . .1 2,- p C u .. . C � p O C - 2. C O O C > O _ M C U -O t... .0 0 . in O c. o u V ..i h pp d d u . �V = QC3o Ot— a) s_ bsiia tn O o v V t= C3 eo L 5 ° l-" . ri J a O C o " ri r a, n c-o b E to r. 8 E c, a. d FL,* ff °L a C • et a: ` : R U r CD A ca .. ca C � P._ 4.1 V p L > a) U 3 --' op fl. 0 rui, 3 ea ea ^ e) U a.) C R OE c 8 y U E °� c ` _. co.. aE E 3 •v >- 3u E-• ° °- ae O . >- .0 32 P 8 ° 3ia r C - 0 E y a> a et 4 -- O G ..• w L 2 CO U O 4' ° L 0 i V2 g •c . C . y O -v d c C • G D 0 z E-' > Q C a ° =°. >' a E °c. e e-• C t..... g 5 z ° ° °U o -• C ai E R u p E" ° a ° -C � o °W E c CD °- cu* 8 e v E • r ' _ 0 y � s Q ° a as C CIA C. • i -9 d 0.) -.. o . L- 0. L. o 'el = CA c L ° v c ° E cd 7 ° N °Li ° ° >' o 0 p i el) 0. L > O O u .�. en w u O >, y a 'J• L-2. x, a, o p o u O y -° ' t > C U C U o L = .G u ^a V O u y O O a) n U E v "C+ 7 E E —2 s. u g y — cs O .. H J (� ° $ ° o E R o ; 8 c -°- E c y 2 o t _ E "2 -R-� ° °' 8 .... [z c o .8s• E". c 2 = E ■,mac a t o V e° u ¢ c > d v ` a. �- u R a•C ,�. .J p C C x rJ L. x «s CI .6 V t'' c4 "" a: '7 -c C.0 0 o cn 4L' — k O G ff��•... a+ y O v, U R E'3 s. .0 -- 0. U t E c3 `o a oop cc 3 C 0 —`°,o a°, a c C c C 4 .0 c F°., 3 y ) W o a € �' E c C a Ems.. nn. C ° oo H _ R v G .... ca R i M 7 U a, �O •� O, 0 0 a, C co U L C °� E 'O GA 0-'• y C� 0 >, >, R 3 o R ca a, i > E c ' p o E c v _ L. 'S E c=d O O "' g E c.4... z E .° 3 2Ar3a = 0.. 3 � E oV a. 3 : E-° o ^ N ri C Packet Page -1647- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. II' - -.T : --• y , l ! ; U W d Ql a) . o a)i tU. a) a)! a)�a) a)• ai• N /A •a U) CI U) U)' U) .v. U)•y!U) Q�i . I.QiI :0. n n C '" a oI 1L li!k ti;�!ue ala!a a:a li a:a;a a_'tilu`a L,tL.'('- alc i' E ' . ! ! I = • ' I : 1 O 0 0 ?7 Q•J�I�!1C!O,r N rIN r m!O C CC n'c4 tD (D' I-: • O+6C) Dir..- N O)•C tx):N.1..- t� C.) LA!O op.I�;QItf-!i08'.,:O Oi'7 cy,'-.2 R H N' Q:CO au10 LA 0 lf,1N;I!-'C7ItO ..- r1O,O:LA: I - (.7IV CO'CD O U) CV; M!t7!- O t'7.'t71%--; > 0. ;�!C N CT) NN N Ir' T- :r- rl rt i C7. ! •I i !C') t�'r� M:Nit'') co Nie-{O 0 0 CD O "- .- r) c.l (') !I UD rn, ; !ti ')!CD t");tr):0 O.v-!NIe-:r 0 Lf) O 0104!co T!n;t` nit.)im • O �fM.O N. CV O C0 Oi LL ■ ' r es, Nlr;r,CV.N r. r I ■ I - _ . W '- •Ich I y Q: • 0_ I Is o i c, " -- . • I 1 ■ • • 0 Ltd a) a i • • W p I� D E i Ii :- W ■ N !0 i� CI'D ,VI , • ''O [L ,F 0 ' O N W_ N p l . v' a_ MS O p. . U -1 O - C; y O Q 2+ >; O y I 0 V y � t4. y, i2 c0 Q7!'-'= xl >. 0 IW: > es co - O!.N .- _ COI ; > •� c °'� 92I c. W 1— w c, I_ i- ' 0 °• =1 °' 03 I 3: � `' `pl '� a, 'c L'1_ t;.� I !03 `_ i x zy m, y.C? 'cn co t.. _ v! o p Q i i • ) ( -o =IC x to •n '5 IL.. N 9 _ IE, cpl1,„_1 ...I I � i_ - a), y co. :it I c x at; Cr 7 C c r0; a o' � o■A, 'vol,g x x: :°;°•v I �i0 ca al I W m = o' c!- �I O �.'C:_ia).y:.0 =•1-:F- O C, ".: p1 Ita v «1 co Ls of I 3,0' s,:> > N CL a)!a:d y,to,aDI N o N . - c N. O' j f CD cn a� I � I ,cn'�? f ed I w a ' _z(-)'-a."'" !: o x f c3 cs y. � c F S:w �; � x o! -N C/) q v m; ! o! I �' rf0 C1U wI i > 0 CO L 00 E. � e e1of o;h- -D d '? CO 41) t4"sf y a) 6 w ni E ci , aii m 0 0 M NNe � ;;Q = :C ig. � v a 3, 7j O m L)00i_Oj ci; S Q rr!� ,-:r.,1 L HI �1 J m GI pI 1- C �' I CO> I U;V 'U'U;U U`UIUIU!U C.)?U(U 010!~ F--'t!, Q W U1t4 :); 0 c jCDC°� :N N (N 0I ' I !v ' C'J 0 0I I :' 0 O • c� 0 �`� O O O O DO:W!O �;O:N'O.O,tD CD CO In.CIa ,�{ 2i j te n! i OiCaIt�IJ1I � ,� t i ;�1, C!t.I�i�l�:t�: o T.; as• L[) Cp•M M 6.6 .4. tzJ . C7,N, �••T i ti41,- (N t_7 to In `7 i m 0: ' • !c= :`NITTr'T ,I r '— .=1 11:� 7. :1�'c*;,�I� ft' CO 1J i r Clr;rM.r0 ''.1 r- Ch rlf� rM; 1 !.., . . I ( • t_. .) 1 a) .0011W cc t 10 1•etd • paysuen osj :we.j EL:62110 u 86MR . Packet Page -1648-.. a,LI in .„n..,.s,,, ,m,.n,.n E,E e ea ao^ F;c?1:? 96 c•BO IEEBE�9L176 TnH :Aq 1L es 10/8/2013 16.A.16. ATTACHMENT 5 Resolution Packet Page-1649- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. MEMORANDUM Date: September 18, 2012 To: Gail Hambright, Accountant Coastal Zone Management From: Teresa Cannon, Deputy Clerk Minutes & Records Department Re: Resolution 2012-160: Supporting Florida Beach Management Program 2013-2014 Funding Requests Attached, please find one (1) original of the document referenced above, (Item #11I) approved by the Board of County Commissioners on September 11, 2012.. If you have any questions, please call 252-8411. Thank you. Attachment Packet Page -1650- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. RESOLUTION NO. 12 - 160 A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA SUPPORTING THE COUNTY'S TWO "FLORIDA BEACH MANAGEMENT PROGRAM 2013/2014 FUNDING REQUESTS" TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION FOR LONG RANGE FUNDING REQUESTS FOR FISCAL YEARS 2013/2014, AGREEING TO SERVE AS THE LOCAL SPONSOR, AND COMMITTED TO PROVIDING THE REQUIRED LOCAL COST SHARE. WHEREAS, the Natural Resources Department, acting on behalf of the Collier County Board of County Commissioners, has prepared two Florida Beach Management Program 2013/2014 Funding Requests to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) for long range grant funding for Fiscal Years 2013-2014; and WHEREAS, the funding requests are to fund the following Collier County projects: (1) Collier County Beach Renourishment which includes the Naples Beaches, Vanderbilt Beach, Park Shore and Barefoot Beach, and (2) The South Marco Beach Renourishment Project required monitoring costs; and WHEREAS, the timely maintenance and restoration of these high quality and readily accessible public recreational beaches is critical to preserve their value and viability, and to provide a boost to both the environment and the economy of Collier County tourism, including hotels, restaurants and related commercial activities; and WHEREAS, the role of the County government in maintaining and restoring beaches is appropriate and crucial; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners supports these two funding requests and requests approval from the FDEP for each funding request for Fiscal Years 2013-2014; and Packet Page-1651- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners agrees to serve as the Local Sponsor; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners is able and committed to providing the required Local Cost Share; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has enacted the Tourist Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended, which commits funding to beach renourishment, beach maintenance and beach park facilities. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Board supports the two Florida Beach Management Program 2013/2014 Funding Requests prepared for submittal to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection for long range funding for Fiscal Years 2013-2014 and requests approval from the FDEP for each funding request. 1. The Board of County Commissioners is willing to serve as the Local Sponsor for the renourishment projects. The County's Natural Resources Department has the staff dedicated to provide Project Management and Administrative support. 2. The Board of County Commissioners is committed to providing the required Local Cost Share. The required funds have been committed through the Tourist Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended. Additional funds may become available through Federal funding sources. PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this t I day of r _ � r2012. Packet Page-1652- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. , BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGHT E.,BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA , , 1 . ,........." . . „ .., (3a/tit joitc: 7.11-LL W C-v-cA g.1-til --- By: ,DepiktY Clerk , FRED W. COYLE, CHAIRMAN-' Attest:as to craw*** g\ , . . fitglistort ..oe.4 Resolution No. 12 - 1 60 Approved as to form and -•- sufficiency: Board Of County Commissioners , Meeting Agenda 9-11-12, Item 16A17 0-,Imii ,4foc),(L-L, • een M. Greene ' Assistant County Attorney 1 O-CZM-00070/8 3 r Packet Page-1653-NI■11110111■1.1101111MII 10/8/2013 16.A.16. RESOLUTION NO. 13 - A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA SUPPORTING THE COUNTY'S TWO "FLORIDA BEACH MANAGEMENT PROGRAM 2014/2015 FUNDING REQUESTS" TO THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION FOR LONG RANGE FUNDING REQUESTS FOR FISCAL YEARS 2014/2015, AGREEING TO SERVE AS THE LOCAL SPONSOR, SUPPORT PROPOSED PROJECT ACTIVITIES AND COMMITTED TO PROVIDING THE REQUIRED LOCAL COST SHARE. WHEREAS, the Natural Resources Department, acting on behalf of the Collier County Board of County Commissioners, has prepared two Florida Beach Management Program 2014/2015 Funding Requests to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) for long range grant funding for Fiscal Years 2014-2015; and WHEREAS, the funding requests are to fund the following Collier County projects: (1) Collier County Beach Renourishment which includes the Naples Beaches, Vanderbilt Beach, Park Shore, and (2) the South Marco Beach Renourishment Project required monitoring costs; and WHEREAS, the timely maintenance and restoration of these high quality and readily accessible public recreational beaches is critical to preserve their value and viability, and to provide a boost to both the environment and the economy of Collier County tourism, including hotels, restaurants and related commercial activities; and WHEREAS, the role of the County government in maintaining and restoring beaches is appropriate and crucial; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners supports these two funding requests and requests approval from the FDEP for each funding request for Fiscal Years 2014-2015; and Packet Page-1654- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners agrees to serve as the Local Sponsor; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners is able and committed to providing the required Local Cost Share; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners agrees to support proposed project activities; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has enacted the Tourist Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended, which commits funding to beach renourishment, beach maintenance and beach park facilities. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the Board supports the two Florida Beach Management Program 2014/2015 Funding Requests prepared for submittal to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection for long range funding for Fiscal Years 2014/2015 and requests approval from the FDEP for each funding request. 1. The Board of County Commissioners is willing to serve as the Local Sponsor and support the renourishment projects. The County's Natural Resources Department has the staff dedicated to provide Project Management and Administrative support. 2. The Board of County Commissioners is committed to providing the required Local Cost Share. The required funds have been committed through the Tourist Development Tax Ordinance No. 92-60, as amended. Additional funds may become available through Federal funding sources. 2 Packet Page-1655- 10/8/2013 16.A.16. PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this day of , 2013. ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA By: Deputy Clerk Georgia A. Hiller, Esq., Chairwoman Approved as to form and �le ality: 'Colleen M. Greene Assistant County Attorney 04.0031;5328 3 Packet Page-1656-