The URL can be used to link to this page

Agenda 01/13/2015 Item #17C 1/13/2015 17.C: n EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve a Resolution designating property commonly known as Mar-Good Harbor Park, formerly the Mar- Good Resort Property, as a historically significant site, pursuant to the historic/archaeological preservation regulations as provided in Section 2.03.07.E of the Collier County.Land Development Code. The subject property is located in Goodland in Section 18, Township $2 South, Range 27 East,Collier County,Florida,consisting of 2.62 acres. [Petition HD-2006-AR-10679] OBJECTIVE: To have the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) consider an application to designate Mar-Good Harbor Park (Mar-Good Resort building, four cottages and the cistern) as locally historic pursuant to Section 2.03.07.E. of the Land Development Code.(LDC). CONSIDERATIONS: The BCC adopted Ordinance 91-102 establishing the Historical and Archaeological Preservation Ordinance. This Ordinance was enacted to protect, preserve and perpetuate Collier County's historic and archaeological sites, districts, structures, buildings and properties. The BCC may distinguish properties with architectural and/or hi$torical significance by designating them as local historic landmarks. The Collier County Parks and Recreation Department, on behalf of the BCC, has submitted an application to designate Mar-Good Harbor Park (Mar-Good Resort building, four cottages and the cistern)as a locally significant historic structure. The Collier County Historic and Archaeological Preservation Board (HAPB) reviewed and considered the application for historic designation of Mar-Good Harbor Park during their public meeting on February 19, 2014. At this meeting, HAPB voted 4-0 to forward petition HD-2006- AR-10679 to the BCC with a recommendation that Mar-Good Harbor Park;(Mar-Good Resort building, four cottages and the cistern) be officially designated as a local historically significant site and structures. The HAPB found that the subject structures qualify as a local significant historic structure pursuant to criteria"a" and "c" of the Designation Criteria as listed in the LDC Section 2.03.07.E.1 and as noted below: a. Association with distinctive elements of the cultural, social, ethnic, political, economic, scientific, religious, prehistoric and architectural history that have contributed to the pattern of history in the community, Collier County, the State of Florida, or the nation. c. Embodiment of the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, method or materials of construction, or that possess high artistic values, quality of design and craftsmanship, or that represent an individual architect or builder's prominence or contribution to the development of the County, the State of Florida, or the Nation. The Mar-Good Harbor Park site is a 2.5-acre parcel lying to the south of a dredged boat.basin in the north-central portion of Goodland Point. Goodland Point is an approximately 80-acre shell Packet Page-2423 1/13/2015 17.C. mound complex which has been previously altered. The shell mound complex dates as early as 400 A.D. and to as recent as 1400 A.D. for the prehistoric habitation of the parcel. Goodland was scraped, leveled and dredged in the mid-twentieth century. The Goodland community began in the late 1940s and remains one of the last rural fishing communities in Collier County and southern Florida. The Mar-Good Lodge, previously called the Mar-Good Resort building, now the Mar-Good Harbor Park Community/Interpretive Center,was constructed in 1949. It has served as the center of the Goodland community for over 60 years. It has functioned as a restaurant and fishing camp among other uses. It was also the location for the film"Captiva Island" (1994). Collier County purchased the site in 2005 with partial funding from the Florida Communities Trust. The Mar-Good Harbor Park was developed as a passive recreation area with the purpose of utilizing natural and cultural resources, providing non-motorized boat access to the water, serving as a neighborhood park,and providing educational opportunities. The requested designation is for six structures: the Mar-Good Resort building, four cottages, and the cistern. The historic/cultural significance of the resort building is described above. Three of the cottages were built in the 1920s (moved from Marco Island) and are rare examples of fish camp architecture; one was built on-site in the 1950s. The cistern was used to provide fresh water until municipal water arrived in the area in 1986. Building Code: Designated projects may be eligible for administrative variances or other forms of relief from building codes as follows: pm Repairs and alterations may be made without conformance to requirements of the Standard Building Code when the work has been issued a Certificate of Appropriateness . . . provided that: 1. The restored building will be no more hazardous than it was in its original condition, 2. Plans are sealed by a Florida registered architect or engineer, if required, 3. The Growth Management Division (GMD) Administrator has required the minimum necessary correction to be made before use, in the interest of public health, safety and welfare. Zoning Ordinance: Subject to the conditions contained in the LDC, a variance for any historically designated site or structure can be approved regarding setbacks, lot widths, depths, area requirements, and development regulations, open space and parking requirements and similar variances not related to a change in use of the property. Financial Assistance: Historically designated sites and structures are eligible for financial assistance set aside for historic preservation projects by the State of Florida or the federal government,provided they meet the requirements for those financial assistance programs. Certificates of Appropriateness: Such certificates are issued by the HAPB for designated sites before issuance of permits to alter, excavate, relocate, reconstruct or demolish; these are needed before the issuance of building,tree removal, or demolition permits. Packet Page-2424- 1/13/2015 17.C. FISCAL IMPACT: This petition by and of itself will not have a fiscal impact on Collier County. However, historic designated sites and structures are eligible to receive financial assistance set aside for historic preservation projects by the State of Florida and/or the federal government,provided it meets the requirements of those financial assistance programs. GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: The subject property is zoned Public Use—Goodland Zoning Overlay (P - GZO) and is in the Urban Coastal Fringe subdistrict as shown on the Future Land Use Map of the Growth Management Plan (GMP). The Land Development Regulations have been adopted to implement the GMP in order to ensure protection of historic resources. Policy 3.1:h of the Future Land Use Element provides protection of historically significant properties. LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: LDC Section 2.03.07.E.2.q. authorizes a property owner to petition for the historic designation of a specific site or building. The Board of County Commissioners is to consider "the preservation board's reports, findings, and recommendations, and upon consideration of the criteria and guidelines set forth in Section 2.03.07.E., the Board of County Commissioners shall approve, by resolution, or deny a petition for historic designation." The criteria and guidelines are set forth in full on page 1 of this Executive Summary. Should the Board elect to approve the designation, then this site will be added to the official listing of all history sites and properties throughout Collier County, which is coordinated through the Collier County Museum. This item is approved for legality. A majority vote is needed for Board approval.—HFAC HISTORICAL AND ARCHAEOLOGICAL PRESERVATION BOARD (HAPB) RECOMMENDATION: The HAPB heard this petition on February 19, 2014. At this meeting, HAPB voted 4-0 to forward petition HD-2006-AR-10679 to the BCC with a recommendation that Mar-Good Harbor Park (Mar-Good Resort building, four cottages and the cistern) be officially designated as a local historically significant site and structures. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the BCC approve the historic designation for Petition: HD-2006-AR-10679 Mar-Good Harbor Park (Mar-Good Resort building, four cottages and the cistern) as a local historically significant site and structures. Prepared By: Fred Reischl, AICP, Principal Planner,Planning & Zoning Department Attachments: 1. Resolution 2. Application 3. Archaeological Assessment—due to the size of the file, this report is available at: http://www.colliergov.net/ftp/AgendaJan1315/GrowthMgmt/Archeolo gical Assessment.pdf 4. Historic Assessment 5. HAPB Minutes 02-19-2014 Packet Page -2425- 1/13/2015 17.C. COLLIER COUNTY Board of County Commissioners Item Number: 17.17.C. Item Summary: This item requires that ex parte disclosure be provided by Commission members. Should a hearing be held on this item, all participants are required to be sworn in. Recommendation to approve a Resolution designating property commonly known as Mar-Good Harbor Park, formerly the Mar-Good Resort Property, as a historically significant site, pursuant to the historic/archaeological preservation regulations as provided in Section 2.03.07.E of the Collier County Land Development Code. The subject property is located in Goodland in Section 18, Township 52 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida, consisting of 2.62 acres. [Petition HD-2006-AR-10679] Meeting Date: 1/13/2015 Prepared By Name: ReischlFred Title: Planner,Principal, Operations and Regulatory Management 12/17/2014 10:45:41 AM Approved By Name: PuigJudy Title: Operations Analyst, Community Development&Environmental Services Date: 12/22/2014 2:10:16 PM Name: BellowsRay Title: Manager-Planning, Comprehensive Planning Date: 12/22/2014 5:1 5:32 PM Name: BosiMichael Title: Director-Planning and Zoning, Comprehensive Planning Date: 12/24/2014 10:36:52 AM Name: MarcellaJeanne Title: Executive Secretary, Transportation Planning Date: 12/29/2014 9:19:33 AM Name: AshtonHeidi Packet Page -2426- 1/13/2015 17.C. Title: Managing Assistant County Attorney,CAO Land Use/Transportation Date: 12/29/2014 9:19:41 AM Name: KlatzkowJeff Title: County Attorney, Date: 12/29/2014 2:02:15 PM Name: IsacksonMark Title: Director-Corp Financial and Mngmt Svs, Office of Management&Budget Date: 12/30/2014 8:20:38 AM Name: FinnEd Title: Management/Budget Analyst, Senior,Transportation Engineering&Construction Management Date: 12/31/2014 11:25:50 AM Name: OchsLeo Title: County Manager, County Managers Office Date: 1/6/2015 11:37:52 AM Packet Page-2427- 1/13/2015 17.C. .-. RESOLUTION NO. 15- A RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA DESIGNATING PROPERTY COMMONLY KNOWN AS MAR-GOOD HARBOR PARK, FORMERLY THE MAR-GOOD RESORT PROPERTY, AS A HISTORICALLY SIGNIFICANT SITE, PURSUANT TO THE HISTORIC/ARCHAELOGICAL PRESERVATION REGULATIONS AS PROVIDED IN SECTION 2.03.07.E OF THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE. THE SUBJECT PROPERTY IS LOCATED IN GOODLAND IN SECTION 18, TOWNSHIP 52 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, CONSISTING OF 2.62 ACRES. [PETITION HD-2006-AR-10679] WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County adopted Ordinance No. 91-70, the Historical/Archaeological Preservation Ordinance, on August 7, 1991 and subsequently incorporated this Ordinance into the Collier County Land Development Code; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County seeks to recognize the importance and significance of Collier County's historical heritage, and to this end has enacted regulations to protect, preserve and perpetuate Collier County's historic and archaeological sites, districts, structures, buildings and properties; and WHEREAS, Section 2.03.07.E of the Land Development Code, provides for official designation of particular sites as historically significant and provides regulations to maintain the historic character of officially designated properties; and WHEREAS, there are three cottages on the Mar-Good Harbor Park property that are rare examples of fish camp architecture and early 20th century accommodations for tourists in Florida; a fourth cottage was built in the 1950's; and WHEREAS, the Collier County Historical/Archaeological Preservation Board reviewed and considered the historic designation of the Mar-Good Harbor Park at a public meeting held for that purpose; and WHEREAS, on February 19, 2014, the Preservation Board voted to nominate the Mar- Good Resort building, four cottages and the cistern at the Mar-Good Park for official designation in recognition of the important role played by the structures; and WHEREAS, the Preservation Board hereby forwards said nomination to the Board of County Commissioners. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA that: [14-CPS-01400/1140770/1]31 1 of 2 Mar-Good Historic Designation Rev. 12/19/14 Packet Page -2428- 1/13/2015 17.C. In recognition of its important and significant place in the historical heritage of Collier County, the property commonly known as the Mar-Good Harbor Park, formerly known as at the Mar-Good Resort Property, legally described in Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein is hereby designated as an historic site. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Mar-Good Resort building, four cottages and the cistern at the Mar-Good Harbor Park, formerly known as Mar-Good Resort Property, shall hereafter be subject to the Historic/Archaeological Preservations Regulations of the Collier County Land Development Code as they pertain to historically designated property including all applicable incentives and restrictions. This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote this day of , 2015. ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA By: By: Deputy Clerk , Chairman Approved as to form and legality: Heidi Ashton-Cicko tip'` Managing Assistant County Attorney Attachment: Exhibit A—Legal Description [14-CPS-01400/1140770/1]31 2 of 2 Mar-Good Historic Designation Rev. 12/19/14 Packet Page -2429- i . 1/13/2015 17.C. OR: 3797 PG: 1773 EXHIBIT "A" 1 OF 4 LOTS 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, BLOCK 3, AMENDED AND ENLARGED PLAT OF GOODLAND HEIGHTS, ACCORDING TO PLAT IN.PLAT BOOK 1, PAGE 85, PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA; AND LOTS 4, 5, 6, 9, AND 10, PETTIT SUBDIVISION, ACCORDING TO PLAT IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 88, PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA; AND A CERTAIN PARCEL OR I":C{©�JR DED NORTH N PLAT BOOK 1, PAGE ND HEIGHTS - f DS OF COQ COUNTY, FLORIDA; PAGE 85, PUBLIC 1, NORTHWEST OF TRACT itF LAt p CONVEYS TO M. C. JOHNSON AS RECORDED IN DEEP .00K 7, AGE 57, ESTERLY OF PEI lIT _ SUBDIVISION, AS •EC*R= P.12.- .ti_ .pA , 'AGE 88, PUBLIC RECORDS OF CO LI" C* , *"I ,AV UTHERLY OF THE SOUTHERLY LINE * *' 'E IN S ID SUBDIVISION PROJECTED WESTE' �. TER AN;� OUT F THE EASTERLY AND SOUTHERLY SI�Q'R OF A PROPOSER C Zia~°f GOODLAND BAY AND EASTERLY OF T LINE BETW AND 11 OF BLOCK 3, GOODLAND HEIGHT DIVISION PROD, ti NORTHERLY, BEING MORE PARTICULARLY D ,G'�RifB Q AS FOLL W,S°'/ \[li. COMMENCING AT A CONCRETE-MONUM T WITH A 3/4" GALVANIZED IRON PIPE MARKING THE NORTHWESTERLY CORNER OF SAID PETTIT SUBDIVISION;THENCE SOUTH 22°58'30' EAST 30.0 FEET TO A CONCRETE MONUMENT MARKING THE NORTHWESTERLY CORNER OF LOT 1 OF SAID SUBDIVISION, THE POINT OF BEGINNING; THENCE CONTINUING SOUTH 22°58'30' EAST 221.88 FEET TO A CONCRETE MONUMENT WITH A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE; THENCE SOUTH 0°21'00" EAST 88.95 FEET TO A CONCRETE MONUMENT WITH A 3/4" GALVANIZED IRON PIPE; THENCE SOUTH 78°28'30' WEST 110.92 FEET TO A CONCRETE MONUMENT WITH A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE MARKING THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF LOT 9, BLOCK 3, GOODLAND HEIGHTS SUBDIVISION; THENCE NORTH 88°07'30' WEST 120.0 FEET TO AN IRON PIN MARKING THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF LOT 11, BLOCK 3, OF SAID SUBDIVISION; THENCE NORTH 1°52'30' EAST 34.79 FEET TO A 314' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE; THENCE CONTINUING NORTH 1°52'30' EAST 8.0 FEET TO A POINT ON THE SHORE OF A PROPOSED CANAL TO Packet Page -2430- . 1/13/2015 17.C. . OR: 3797 PG: 1774 EXHIBIT "A" 20F4 GOODLAND BAY; THENCE NORTH 88°54'20' EAST FOLLOWING THE SOUTHERLY SHORE OF SAID CANAL 114.66 FEET TO A POINT, SAID POINT BEING THE POINT OF CURVE OF A CURVE TO THE LEFT HAVING A RADIUS OF 60.0 FEET; THENCE FOLLOWING THE SOUTHERLY SHORE OF SAID CANAL ALONG A CURVE TO THE LEFT THROUGH A CENTRAL ANGLE OF 113°00' A DISTANCE OF 118.33 FEET TO THE POINT OF TANGENCY; THENCE NORTH 24°05'40'WEST FOLLOWING THE EASTERLY SHORE OF SAID CANAL 104.18 FEET TO A POINT, SAID POINT BEING THE POINT OF CURVE OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADIUS OF 61.38 FEET; THENCE FOLLOWING THE EASTERLY SHORE OF SAID CANAL ALONG A CURVE TO THE RIGHT THROUGH A CENTRAL ANGLE OF 18°30'20'A DISTANCE OF 19.82 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY;THENCE NORTH 5°35'20" WEST FOLLOWING THE EASTERLY 30 EAST 10 0 SAID CANAL 69.08 FEET TO A POINZs-T TO A 3/4' GALVANIZED ,R90 --1 T NUING SOUTH 88°07'30' EAST 16.4 FEET TO THE PAINT OF BEGIN1Jl L LYING AND BEING SITUATED IN GOVERN.MEt LOT 14, SECTION , TOWNSHIP 52 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, ALL E----M-ERJ1IAN, GO'ODLAND, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. ( f ....._ 1 A CERTAIN PARCEL � TRACT OF LAtP,/ LYING TH OF A TRACT CONVEYED TO MILTO JOHNSON AND " Cs''''P. P IN DEED BOOK 47, PAGE 411, PUBLIC R ** N S OF COLLIER e* , FLORIDA MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBE 'F*LLOWS• yt\l� COMMENCING AT A 4' X 4' CONCRETE MONUMENT WITH A 314' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE MARKING THE NORTHWESTERLY ERLY CORNER OF PEI ill SUBDIVISION AS RECORDED IN THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 88; THENCE NORTH 88°07'30' WEST 14.00 FEET TO A POINT ON THE EASTERLY SHORE OF A BRANCH CANAL FROM A CANAL TO GOODLAND BAY, SAID POINT BEING THE SOUTHWESTERLY CORNER OF TRACT CONVEYED TO DR. E.WAYNE LONG AND WALTER C. BURWICK RECORDED IN DEED BOOK 45, 324, SAID POINT BEING ALSO THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF THE LANDS HEREIN DESCRIBED; THENCE SOUTH 88°07'30' EAST 14.00 FEET TO A CONCRETE MONUMENT WITH A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE; THENCE SOUTH 22°58'30' EAST 30.00 FEET TO A CONCRETE MONUMENT WITH A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE, SAID POINT BEING THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF LOT 1 OF SAID PETTIT SUBDIVISION; THENCE NORTH 88°07'30' WEST 16.40 FEET TO A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE ON THE BANK OF SAID BRANCH CANAL; THENCE CONTINUING NORTH • Packet Page -2431- . 1/13/2015 17.C. JR; 3797 rc�; 1 X75 EXHIBIT "A" 30F4 88°07'30' WEST 10.00 FEET TO A POINT ON THE EASTERLY BOUNDARY OF SAID CANAL, SAID POINT BEING THE NORTHWESTERLY CORNER OF TRACT CONVEYED TO M. C. JOHNSON AND RECORDED IN DEED BOOK 47, PAGE 411; THENCE NORTH 5°35'20' WEST FOLLOWING THE EASTERLY BOUNDARY OF SAID BRANCH CANAL 16.97 FEET TO THE POINT OF CURVE OF A CURVE TO THE RIGHT HAVING A RADIUS OF 17.14 FEET; THENCE FOLLOWING SAID CURVE TO THE RIGHT ALONG SAID EASTERLY CANAL BOUNDARY AND THROUGH A CENTRAL ANGLE OF 36°19'10' 10.86 FEET TO A POINT OF TANGENCY, THE POINT OF BEGINNING, ALL LYING AND BEING SITUATE IN GOVERNMENT LOT 14, SECTION 18, TOWNSHIP 52 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, TALLAHASSEE MERIDIAN, GOODLAND, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. A CERTAIN PARCEL •- 'T'" •CT OF LAND L •G ORTH OF BLOCK 3, GOODLAND HEIGHT B �QN R��EN P�T�800K 1, PAGE 85 RECORDS OF LOLL R COU �-�^R ,� , I� \ SU DIVISION MORE AND EAST OF AP•Y - -, 141...1 PARTICULARLY DES, RI:E• A ' . L u - BEGINNING AT TH .C'", •RTHWEST COME OF�C T 14, BLOCK 3, GOODLAND HEIGHT�DIVISION; THEN N� )5°03'30' EAST 180.0 FEET TO A 3/4 GALV D IRON PIPE; Tfdl ONTINUING NORTH 85°03'30' EAST 52.91 FE -A CONCRt Qt IJMENT WITH A BRASS CAP; THENCE SOUTH 88°0'7 30"l = lr € AN IRON PIN MARKING THE NORTHEAST CORNER OF`-LCT. tL CK 3, OF SAID GOODLAND HEIGHTS SUBDIVISION; THENCE NORTH 1°52'30" EAST 34.79 FEET TO A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE; THENCE CONTINUING NORTH 1°52'30" EAST 8.0 FEET TO A POINT ON THE SHORE OF A PROPOSED CANAL TO GOODLAND BAY; THENCE SOUTH 88°54'20' WEST 107.89 FEET TO A POINT ON THE SOUTHERLY SHORE OF SAID CANAL, SAID POINT BEING NORTH 7°14' EAST 8.18 FEET FROM A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE, A REFERENCE POINT AND ALSO BEING NORTH 7°14' EAST 43.74 FEET FROM A 3/4'GALVANIZED IRON PIPE ON THE NORTHERLY BOUNDARY OF SAID GOODLAND HEIGHTS SUBDIVISION LAST AFORESAID PIPE HAVING HEREIN DESCRIBED AS BEING NORTH 85°03'30' EAST 180.0 FEET FROM THE POINT OF BEGINNING; THENCE NORTH 7°14' EAST FOLLOWING THE SHORE OF WESTERLY AND OF SAID PROPOSED CANAL 7.39 FEET; THENCE SOUTH 85°03'30' WEST 8.0 FEET TO A 3/4' GALVANIZED IRON PIPE; THENCE CONTINUING SOUTH 85°03'30' WEST 172.0 FEET TO A _ POINT ON THE EASTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY BOUNDARY OF PAPAYA STREET; THENCE SOUTH 7°14' EAST FOLLOWING THE EASTERLY RIGHT- Packet Page -2432- . 1/13/2015 17.C. ** JR: 3797 PG: 1776 XX EXHIBIT "A" 40F4 OF-WAY BOUNDARY OF SAID PAPAYA STREET 51.13 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING, ALL LYING AND BEING SITUATE IN GOVERNMENT LOT 14, SECTION 18, TOWNSHIP 52 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, TALLAHASSEE MERIDIAN, GOODLAND, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. AND BEGINNING AT A POINT MARKED BY A 3/4" GALVANIZED IRON PIPE ON THE NORTHERLY BOUNDARY OF GOODLAND HEIGHTS SUBDIVISION, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 1, PAGE 85, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, SAID POINT BEING THE INTERSECTION OF SAID NORTHERLY BOUNDARY AND THE WESTERLY BOUNDARY O P-FP SUBDIVISION, RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 2, PAGE 68, C201/1L I i FLORIDA; THENCE NORTH 22°58'30'WEST 126.35 FEEI 15W—GIN TERLY BOUND R OF SAID Pt I ii i SUBDNIyS O A CONCRETE, GALVANIZED IRON PIPE; IIE-NOI OO°21' ST 88.95 FEET TO A CONCRE!E MONUM NITH 31,' GA IZE� IRON PIPE; THENCE NORTH 78°28'30" T ` 4 iv^ o y� '''' E FONUMENT WITH A _ 3/4' GALVANIZED IP N" t�J°'I O HE THENCE SOUTH BOUNDARY OF SAID GO.94_: * . . SU ,DLVI 1.011, TH 88°07'30' EAST 157. • EET TO THE "•I 0 : GINNING, BEING SITUATE IN GOVERN .4 LOT 14, SECTTI4 8 NSHIP 52 SOUTH, RANGE 27 EAST, T• e •SSEE MERI r • C3•ODLAND, COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. 0 P �� 7jj1 CITC Packet Page -2433- 1/13/2015 17.C. COLLIER COUNTY APPLCIATION FOR HISTORIC DESIGNATION (This is a petition to designate a Site,District,Structure,Building,or Property as historically significant Pursuant to Section 2.03.07.E of the Collier County Land Development Code). PETITION NO. H)- 'EO, i - /d6 79 DATE PETITION RECEIVED PRINCIPAL PLANNER FREZ) J EISG/IA (ABOVE 70 BE FILLED IN BY STAFF) OWNER'S NAME: Collier County Board of County Commissioners OWNER'S ADDRESS 3299 Tamiami Trail East Suite 303 Naples,Florida 34112-5746 TELEPHONE: 239-252-8097 PETITIONERS NAME: (if different from owner) Collier County Parks and Recreation (Nancy E.Olson, Region Manner)and Darren Clack,Chairperson Goodland Cottage Restoration Committee PETITIONERS ADDRESS: 15000 Livingston Road Naples, Florida 34109 Po 4vn 222 TELEPHONE: 239-252-4000 23cf- 394o77S LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: LOTS(S) BLOCK(S) UNIT SECTION 18 TWP 52S RANGE 27E (If legal description is lengthy,i.e.metes&bounds description,attach additional page). EXISTING LAND USE OF SUBJECT PROPERTY: Please provide a brief description of the existing and historical land use and structures nr the subject site and reference the attached designation criteria where applicable. (Attach additional page if necessary). EXISTING LAND USE: In 2005 Collier County purchased the 2.5 acre Margood Resort Property partially through grant funding from the Florida Communities Trust. The Margood Harbor Park was developed as a passive recreation area with a four part focus: to make the best use of the site's natural and cultural resources,to provide non-motorized vessel access to open waters,to serve as a neighborhood park,and to provide educational opportunities. Resource-based facilities on site indude Y.mile walking trail,2 picnic pavilions,children's playground,bocce ball court,kayak/canoe launch,horse shoes, badminton/volleyball court, and a community/interpretive center which houses objects from the Margood Resort building. Four(4)cottages and one(1)cistern located on the east side of Pettit Drive will be restored and used to interpret the history of the Goodland Community. Three(3)of the cottages were built in the 1920s(moved from the Kelly Gantt Fishing Camp on Marco Island to Goodland)and are rare examples of fish camp architecture and early examples of 20th century accommodations for tourists in Florida,and one(1)was built in the 1950s on the property. The cistern was used to provide fresh water to two(2)of the cottages until 1986 when municipal water arrived on the island. Packet Page -2434- 1/13/2015 17.C. HISTORIC LAND USE: The Margood Harbor Park site is a 2.5-acre parcel lying to the south of a dredged boat basin in the north central of Goodland Point. Goodland Point is an approximately 80-acre shell mound complex which has been altered. The shell mound complex dates as early as AD 400 and to as recently as AD 1400 for the prehistoric habitation of the parcel. The island was scraped,leveled,and dredged in the mid-20`"century. The Goodland community began in the late 1940s and remains one of the last rural fishing communities in Collier County and in south Florida. The earliest historical documentation of Goodland Point is on the Vignoles"Map of Florida"(1823)which refers to Goodland Point as"Fertile Lands." The name"Good Land"began appearing on maps by the 1870s. John Roberts (Goodland's first white settler)is credited with naming the place based on its characteristics. The Petit family was the next known permanent residents of the area and established a permanent homestead at Goodland Point by the late 1890s. Harry Pettit is credited with building the first road to link Goodland Point to State Road 92. in the late 1940s the Collier Development Company,owners of most of the land at nearby Caxambas Point(located on the southwest end of Marco Island)decided to relocate the residents of Caxambas to Goodland. The Mar-Good Lodge,previously called Margood Resort Building(now the community/interpretive center)had its origins in 1947 when Milton C(Rex)and Ruby Binks Johnson,professional balloonists and daredevils,retired to Goodland and purchased 38 pieces of property. They built the central Mar-Good Community structure in 1949 which they owned and operated until the 1970s. The Johnsons sold to Alex and Marge Tasetano who in 1986 sold the Mar-Good Property to Elhanon and Sandra Combs. The Mar-Good Resort has been the center of the community for over 60 years. It has functioned as a grocery store,restaurant,bait and tackle shop,move theatre,coin laundry,fishing camp,tourist lodge, trailer campground and the location for the 1994 movie,"Captiva island"starring Ernest Borgnine. Upon request C '4iier County Parks and Recrc, tior,can provide the following documents which contain extension detaii on the prehistory and history of the Goadiand and the park site: a An Archaeo oa rai Assc ssrraerlt of the Mor-Good Perrel o Robert S.Carr, M.S.;John G. Beriault,B.A.;John Crump,B.A. w Archaeological and Historical Conservancy, Inc • _. V11,0 ., r+c.:,t, Pori �4Ko 44,7rcanc • Par;amorican Consultants, /lc. o Tampa, Florida ADJACENT ZONING AND LAND USE: (Provide a brief description©f the surrounding land use and zoning designations.; The Margood Harbor Park, located on Pear Tree Avenue, and the adjacent cottage property, located on Pettit Drive, is zoned Conservation and Public. The property surrounding the site is residential. DESIGNATION CRITERIA: The Designation of Historical/Archaeological Sites, Structures, Districts, Buildings and Properties as "Historically Significant"is authorized by Section 2.03.07.E of the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC). The recommendation of the Historical and Archaeological Preservation Board and the decision of the Board of County Commissioners will be based on the below listed criteria. Provided a detailed Packet Page -2435- 1/13/2015 17.C. response, including any documentation or other resources,to each of the criteria,which is applicable to this petition. For consideration by the Board of County Commissioners,the petition need only meet one of the required criteria. However,a detailed response should be provided to any of the criteria, which appear relevant. 1. Association with distinctive elements of the cultural,social,ethnic,political,economic,scientific, religious, prehistoric and architectural history that have contributed to the pattern of history in the community,Collier County,the State of Florida or the nation;or 2. Association with the lives of persons significant in history;or 3. Embodiment of the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, method or materials of construction, or that possess high artistic values, quality of design and craftsmanship, or that represent an individual architect or builder's prominence or contribution to the development of the County,the State of Florida,or the nation;or 4. Location of historic or prehistoric activities such as habitation, religious, ceremonial, burial, fortification, etc. during a particular period of time, and may maintain a sufficient degree of environmental integrity to reflect a significant aspect of the relationship of the site's original occupants to the environment;or S. An historic or prehistoric site which has been severely disturbed but which may still allow useful and representative data to be recovered;or 6. Have yielded or are likely to yield information on local history or prehistory;or 7. Derive it's primary significance from architectural or artistic distinction of historical importance; or B. Is the birthplace or grave of an historical figure or is a cemetery which derives its primary significance from graves of persons of transcendent importance, from age, distinctive design features,or from association with historic events;or 9. A building or structure removed from its original location which is significant for architectural value, or is the sole surviving structure most importantly associated with an historic period, person or event;or € A property primarily commemorative in intent where design, age, tradition or symbolic value has invested it with its own historical significance;or 11. Area contains known archaeological sites that have not been assessed for significance but are likely to conform to the criteria for significance or areas where there is a high likelihood that unrecorded sites of potential significance are present based on prehistoric settlement patterns and existing topographic features;or 12. Are listed in the National Register or Historic Places. Packet Page -2436- 1/13/2015 17.0. _. ` f- r; ,„,_ /.7 / OWNER'S SIGNATUR DATE 1 .„„) .;-:-'1Z--, •.7 12./ /1 120 / 3 Altd /Z/1/0..// 497.3 PET 'TONER'S SIGNATURE DATE f different from owner) I Packet Page -2437- 1/13/2015 17.C. AN HISTORICAL ASSESSMENT OF BUILDINGS AT GOODLAND HARBOUR PARK IN COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA •,.... ......_ ... , „....„,— „,,•:,.:,/,,:„.4.7774.2.,-,,, ..,.. .„..7.45m,....,,.;•-ymx,;04''•,,;.',.., .-,: .„.; --7 v.4„,„ • , ,-r. • ,,,,,, ,... ..14..,i..,„.:,.•-ii.,,',•' •/-, _ ...1,.• , 4,; * 7:,:‘.•502,..,.,::"F:ze$' -• ..;•:•••••445+ ' ”,' ,.?,.. ,1 ,„.41;_i•-,,Y,417".e.-7,1r,r-52. ., .0' Z. ',..7": tic. ..--. var.,• .4.,,,rr,...y.t.:,_, Nr,TNAsire4.n,e).:, ..7 i-1•:.c.=-..7::::' -4iP'-'''fi%1":• e:,-•':1.:114-3s; '...411.1.',:'..;,'":*.:p,,;..:t. 4''s;., t1 4A,,j..0,','T N.4 1‘.'.t r.r-f..",-):',".:;-,.,.,,,`,,;,:.,'•-;..'.-,„i<'l 1.,4I-1.l' ,4s4.4„11„ Vn(r!5",r 1,s.,A;-'',,.•;r,A,4 1P4,,1 Pi04 4.. .,7',741:,:l' :--,' A 1'2,, '''', :%.!!'4”''' 747-L. , .41q;orLY,A-1,• 'f f9,.„. il,.:1,,,,!.1 7.,.,..,-,. 4.0....,:\ - ,,,;,-,,. ,,;,:,..,.,„:,.,..7.• ., , ,, i'. - ,,, ! .:.- liT Al,74:"?t`,,,4k. •*.,'-fc.lit f.4'4,-;:(‘`,,, . . , ,) Ar, .41" "'..<;;-...ar.....k‘e 7-7..eg.irft•:<,,,,',.,,4',...,..,;',,-.1 .4,1t ,..'•.),, ' , %', ....,4-.;.4...?,: „,..,) .-- , w....,.,....,..,4..,:-.. : ,,,. "., _-:- :' . ...1:i.'..'„s ''':'''`'. .t'..,‘,10,i,Ali.e.4::".,:.■..:i!T4:k_.,,,....,. .:440.4,,,g1,. .;I, "04,**_,;'; ,;(.....,-...t.--,.;;,...17,-.,?((i\s:4V:tile r, .g.--. ..a.......----;---t‘A',I,.‘— -.• '..,--:::•.,'.,::., .',.--':V.-:s/-■';gre :'., , '-.,.AV(3, m.•iitic .,,!f.:le;-';'4,14r,,n, lit-r'' .', t -..-`,,' ..-:,- :.;,,,,,.....,,V.trz,. •:,.,::':".:-Yi54.=.1:/4.•';%:.; ko. . . ,,,,•,,c . .. 4.1).Ac.,u;',,,..;',.-,2•,,,,..w.,,....,-, ,..,:-.;I,. -, ,.;,,,,,....4.'..;;•;:,...;.,I.7......,:i, ...t,..,,,,;,;,-, ..- .,,., ,lr,4,,,i, •A.;:;,..,,, .,.14,44k.y:4.4...,•„,-...•.::.; ..,:.'.:.::: .,-...",:•0 1.4.1 Eir•• ' - ,-',.A':''''''").?-7"\•P.,:.-trea•4.:V411- 1 ,11'1.) ',.,..,-w...,:s.-.4',.,:•,";.;'•eritt,...14.',.;/0,... ..",i,t' ,../-:4.,-..,.',,„':•')eic.`x __ .._•, ''. r'. ".7.1.-,',-. , , ' ". dX),..:.7'?':4;.:-K7r.i:.1 ‘..'4:41/),1;;(1y g-u), ,,,"..-. .9..:, ‘' - 14'sp4:7',' .......„1". ''''Ogro-•■•>&--,..4.' ' -.'''-' '''.,1W ..94'..--''''', , ,'','': '-'':.',•'.el.,...' -:1114y " ...,. ,, ■ ---,A...2z,-..-2,:::-,,..4- - 1,,,,rd---r--•••■,,,— ./ re',.•r ArI•r‘e .-* ,,,- r ',;,.: . i' ', '-'''',.,•—,--------•,'.:••-,..• .....'.'"r;“,'",,.. — ---.‘",••••• ,..yc %, '•, iv , ' , 4 E 4, -•.,••i,,, --,.,,. _._7.::::.0 ,,,.:— ''L',.'vw- .".-:.,w,;-,.. k,--4,.?.....;,- ...; A, •. .04, 1 ;', '+-4 ."-,‘,17,, ., -:,-4.12„,,,,,zi- '- ,---.,—..,z,“----0 4:7-,i,--,..",--• ,.... .. Ritri;1.'ir, ' '.... ,',T •f,,,, ;.\,.`z,.!' r.'°;,,, '.( 1,:,..1.: .'"?"1-' ,t..,7.1 it.7: 4!.. r..,...414R:V4',,,,,,', ' 44,,,,:.4,..:::,,zxisit.ib,.......-r-.......„,:‘,:,--: ., ,-,..:,,,i,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,„, ..,,.. -,--.-,-7--..„-,.) , • , --. Ti.f,' ; .. _ ,;',5ftriftlftt,Z4.:Pf.4:7,...0.f,ii 04.v.s4.. ,,,-.4..,:,mer, ti:c;;-:,?..,sicq,;:4,-,,:.i.- . r:'‘,,,,,,, "•-,,'c".~ . -------',,---—z;----%2`:--:-.--,/,~4 tf•laqPillt0.:1":11, 1.,IfiSr ':.!;;VAzigktftr.t.e'f'0;.4".:..,,-.:‘4v--;-:rn'-. ''.:"'''-',...,1-777,.. — • -- ,,,', ,i.:4-'',''''',\V'''',„r‘74;;;..., '1,11"Tif,.. ',-,::-V444",,I. .raitAticiVIV,..v..?;;.&-,,,I.`445,-Ft>1 .,-. , ,,"7:4(k.;••\.,-.70 '',..w;:*k ... ,! irri-.744/1111-1r1(fk.--6P."14'ce'Arr"-;5'4' *1.41.7M.'047.4.1"traehtrdlYdAbbillf-frwIA.4)4,.,,,■hd%;4'.*.$-,24,-.4,_41-re "'!:.I.X.A.Sydr.,,,:.,;h.:„.C.m..:7., all.':',4.•.,---..,,..).:1...„0,...-f 4 ei.J.4.,1"4 Aw. . . .. ., Prepared for: Collier County Parks and Recreation 3301 East Taman Trail, Bldg: H Naples, Florida 34112 Prepared by: Panamerican Consultants, Inc. f. 1 1 5910 Benjamin Center Dn've, Suite 120 Tampa, Florida 33634 ' I , , , , , , --- , HD-2006-AR-10679 August 2006 PROJECT#2004080030 DATE: 10/19/06 — MELISSA ZONE — Packet Page -2438- 1/13/2015 17.C. AN HISTORICAL ASSESSMENT OF BUILDINGS AT GOODLAND HARBOUR PARK IN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA Prepared for: Collier County Parks and Recreation 3301 East Tamiami Trail, Bldg. H Naples, Florida 34112 Prepared by: Panamerican Consultants, Inc. 5910 Benjamin Center Drive, Suite 120 Tampa, Florida 33634 813.884.6351 (phone) 813.884.5968 (fax) Jeanette Knowles Architectural Historian Lucy D. Jones Historian August 2006 Packet Page -2439- 1/13/2015 17.C. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction 1 Field Methods 3 Historic Overview 3 Goodland 5 Results 9 8CR948 Johnson-Combs Theater and Museum 10 8CR949 Laundry and Cistern 14 8CR950 Duplex Cottage 17 8CR951 MarGood Cottage #4 19 8CR952 MarGood Cottage #5 21 8CR953 MarGood Cottage #6 23 8CR954 MarGood Cottage #7 25 8CR955 MarGood Cottage #8 27 8CR956 World War II Cottage #9 29 8CR957 World War II Cottage #10 30 8CR958 World War ii Cottage #11 32 8CR959 Cistern for Cottages 8CR955-8CR958 and Laundromat 8CR960 34 8CR960 Laundromat/Shell Shop 36 Conclusions 37 References Cited 40 Appendix A: FMSF Forms ii Packet Page-2440- 1/13/2015 17.C. LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. General vicinity map of the Goodland Harbour Park project area, formerly MarGood Resort and RV Park, in Collier County, Florida. 2 Figure 2. Map of Marco Island with locations of Caxambas and Goodland (Waitley 1993:20). . . 4 Figure 3. Photographs of MarGood Park in the late 1950s. 8 Figure 4. Sketch of the location of MarGood Park historic resources. 9 Figure 5. Entrance to the grocery store area of 8CR948, the theater and museum , building, facing northeast. , 11` Figure 6. The north elevation of 8CR948 where Chuckle's Chickee Bar & Grill was located, facing south-southwest. 12 Figure 7. Side view of 8CR948, the west elevation, facing southeast. 12 Figure 8. Interior of the theater and museum, showing movie screen above original stage, facing north. 13 Figure 9. Museum collection in wall cabinets of 8CR948, facing northeast. . . 13 Figure 10. The north elevation of 8CR949, the laundry building and cistern, where Sharky's Bar & Grill , originally the community center, was located, facing south. 15 Figure 11. East elevation of 8CR949, with view of the second-story artist's studio, the cistern wall in the center, and laundry, restrooms, and showers on the - left-hand side, facing west. 16 Figure 12. View of the south elevation of 8CR949 where the restrooms and showers are located, and where the Laundromat was located on the right, facing north. 16 Figure 13. The cistern in 8CR949, with view of hole cut into second vault and floor laid after cistern was no longer used for water storage, facing west. 17 Figure 14. Entries to the duplex, 8CR950, facing southeast. 18 Figure 15. Side entry to 8CR950, facing northeast. 18 Figure 16. View of the rear elevation of 8CR950, showing closet for hot water tank, rafter tails, and hurricane shutters, facing south-southwest. 19 Figure 17. Façade of MarGood Cottage #4, 8CR951, showing asbestos shingles, concrete planters, and replacement awning windows, facing south. 20 Figure 18. West elevation of 8CR951, showing replacement and original windows, concrete-block piers, and metal roof, facing east-southeast. 21 Figure 19. The kitchen/dining/bedroom area of 8CR951, Cottage #4, facing southwest. 21 Figure 20. View of MarGood Cottage #5,'showing awning windows, asbestos shingles, and concrete planters beside porch, facing south. 22 - Figure 21. South elevation of 8CR952, with view of pier foundation, facing north, 22 Figure 22. The sun-porch, garage, and storage shed additions to 8CR953, and the central air-conditioning unit on the roof, facing southwest. 24 Figure 23. The southwest elevation of 8CR953, with view of the original orientation of the cottage to the southeast, asbestos shingles overlapping the original clapboard, and replacement awning windows, facing northeast. 24 Packet Page -2441- 1/13/2015 17.C. Figure 24. Interior view of Cottage #6 showing remodeled bedroom and closet area, facing east-southeast. 25 Figure 25. View of the carport and driveway in front of 8CR954, facing west- northwest. 26 Figure 26. Hurricane shutters over windows, rafter tails, and closet for hot water tank at 8CR954, facing southeast. . 26 Figure 27. Paneled walls of entry and living room in 8CR954, facing north. 27 Figure 28. View of the façade and north end of MarGood Cottage #8,8CR955, • facing east-southeast. Garage addition is on the southeast end of the structure. 28 Figure 29. The back of 8CR955, with view of metal roof, pier foundation and back porch, facing southwest. 28 Figure 30. 8CR956, with view of three-over-one window, clapboard exterior and small porch, facing southeast. 8CR960 is to the right. 29 Figure 31. View of the rear elevation of 8CR956 showing bathroom addition and closet for hot-water tank, facing north-northwest. 30 Figure 32. Shot-gun style Cottage #10, 8CR957, with view of main entry with braced roof over porch that has curved-pipe railings, facing northeast A hurricane shutter covers the front window. 31 Figure 33. Southeast elevation of 8CR957, with view of metal roof, clapboard exterior, and pier foundation, facing northwest. . 31 Figure 34. The façade of 8CR958, with view of 8CR957 in the background, facing east. 33 Figure 35. View of the.north elevation of 8CR958, showing the small size of the one-room structure, facing east-southeast. 33 Figure 36. The cistern, 8CR959, located between 8CR955 on the right and 8CR960 on the left, facing southeast. 35 Figure 37. The stuccoed, above-ground concrete-block wall of cistern 8CR959, facing northwest. 35 Figure 38. View of a laundry facility at MarGood that became a shell shop after municipal water was available in Goodland in 1986, facing east- southeast. 36 Figure 39. Southeast elevation of 8CR960, with view of asbestos shingles on . exterior, facing north. . 37 Figure 40. View of the porch-roof on Cottage #9, showing the rounded rafter tails, facing east. Cottages #10 and #11 have the same type of roof and rafter tails. 38 iv Packet Page-2442- 1/13/2015 17.C. INTRODUCTION Panamerican Consultants, Inc., Tampa, Florida, conducted an historical assessment survey of twelve buildings and one structure.located at MarGood Resort and RV Park (MarGood) in Collier County for Collier County Parks & Recreation, Naples, Florida. This investigation was • conducted in accordance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (PL 89-665)as amended in 1992,and 36 C.F.R.,Part 800: Protection of Historic Properties, and Chapter 267, Florida Statutes, Florida's Coastal Zone Management Program, and implementing state regulations. Field work for the project was conducted on June 22-23, 2006, by Jeanette Knowles, M.A.,Architectural.Historian. The.MarGood project area is located in Goodland on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the islands included in the Ten Thousand Islands that stretch along the Florida Gulf Coast • and are part of Everglades National Park. Goodland is on a point of land reaching out into the middle of Goodland Bay. An unincorporated community that welcomes winter visitors, Goodland has approximately 400 year-round residents. Until recently,MarGood was a boat marina and trailer park where visitors rented space for their personal trailer or recreational vehicle, or rented a cottage from the park proprietors. MarGood was a winter resort for more than fifty years, in operation every year between 1952 and 2005 (Figure 3). The project site is a 2.5-acre tract located in the southwest quarter of Section 18 of Township 52 South, Range 27 East on the Marco Island, Fla. 1973 USGS 7.5' topographic quadrangle (Figure 1). The project area is bounded by Pear Tree Avenue on the south, Papaya Drive on the west, Goodland Harbour on the north, and the loop of Pettit Drive on the east. With assistance from the Trust for Public Land and the Florida Communities Trust, Collier County purchased the 2.5-acre site in 2005. The Parks & Recreation Administration of Collier.County plans to develop the site as Goodland Harbour Park and plans to restore and adapt some of the existing features and structures for use in the new park. Twelve buildings and one structure associated with MarGood were recorded. Resource group 8CR947 was recorded to indicate the historical association of the thirteen properties (Figure 1). The properties include 8CR948, Johnson-Combs Theater and Museum; 8CR949, Laundry and Cistern; 8CR950, Duplex Cottage; 8CR951, MarGood Cottage #4; 8CR952, MarGood Cottage#5; 8CR953, MarGood Cottage #6; 8CR954, MarGood Cottage #7; 8CR955, MarGood Cottage #8; 8CR956, MarGood Cottage #9; 8CR957, MarGood Cottage#10; 8CR958, MarGood Cottage#11; 8CR959, Cistern for Cottages 8CR955-8CR958 and 8CR960; and 8CR960, Laundromat/Shell Shop. It is the opinion of Panamerican Consultants,Inc. —Tampa that all thirteen historic resources • are potentially eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places, and the resource group, 8CR947, is potentially eligible as a historic district. The twelve buildings and one structure are all identified as MarGood properties because they were all part of MarGood Cottages and Trailer Park/MarGood Resort and RV Park between 1952 and 2005. Some of the buildings will become a part of Goodland Harbour Park through adaptive use or historical interpretation. • 1 Packet Page -2443- 1/13/2015 17.C. 7es 1 isu�,¢1�' I# �.'�iP2"s-0b dGrC i li v :f ,2. N, + tt}.�fh J"')k`��t•.. ir, plu:�;'�,G^,.t•f'c�..,`r.`.trip=`,;,'� ',74:� .,rf R 141,F" 3 44-' jI r f�,, E ,r rj�f p ' t 141 4-':hi 4I . �4r, i� it t�r tf.. p k ',h 14 bx., t}a. r r✓j) j�t;" '_ r t Tlj i"Y'4 ��'t.A f t' �"!��Jri � �G e>* JyJ 7F'W art i .. ac" �'+`e.''"P j S .g ; ;c;)/ r .Sc� )T �r L, � 1. _a a • r� •ak �. 'k '° •' s. „fi'.i2 .fir. yt-rr, cd�; ti Nti 11.,..;,‘ c .•.f,.': 6 -.•C r •.ryt ; ? cn /. . #, ry A• rYyaY+d} A '�,syr 'JS}J '` d �.}• � ii Q • -s t r.44`t-,"`i}t,i'" F N�m+c. _; �t•�' _. ) f, k' 8 . s�v ,. ` z D r rr,r B A Y • . ' .r s� d ate' cc:} ,5 ', f,'�{`. G'O O D L A t,i A ? �+'�. 7x�t'�++•�:�f�,.�,Y'k'."kY+?^' f i� i ,4.u' 4}"jµ�' l r R• J,- •• •-• - Akl' •••'4.1.104,Aka. l' . • ' . • . ' ''..L.:../..-". r '4 .,q,5\4 s: —Ikk,.(tr...‘. '..` . •' -- , • "-"Veol.,..4-6.,, 1;,. ' "140k^ 1,V/14ifi' 1;1';4,graiiii. '1. tyj ) � s ,, . " t kr.wfts' t ,,�, `,gib. ,� 'k.��yxiu ,j r,y�,: r „K f ii.- Ct� :i � e' k 1 r �t r.:}�+ ,/,�� "p�,� S� }f�� wit F ;+ : t rc i 111 Y '' , A' to.N` { S � P 'vs.fa ,tF !^% Qtir,.'{ •• k ,ts }eeS45< } N•Iu W J,' ffffff FF s:U.G t( A. .71:4...0'' 4t 'sr.fit t•µ - {. r�: °P�` , i'� Y F 3 .wk y s" Fly r. A . '1" z of • •ii ' }'�.nr: t e t ,.. .. , c t 'u 2 4. i t,•"4,..,•t '! -... •1• �, ';,:!.41;i0 'Sr 1� Nth LL -'au}}} , vgr9 ant p'Wa • � ]t.. , /Si {A '1.4' F \\ \\^`41st}('•,{f,�, ,,,.;.fit yv ''��,,,F�yyy:t' r.k1,..: i ty :,�. ' ,,t,..4.,,,•_,-.; \ ,p t ,, M1' v -it•,. •e' -. �f} VP.`,A?�.i'ir.',,' 1- '• 424/1: v'a. 'a trL a •ycrt )t a "YLg .... (.,-,•‘;'‘.%l,je\. ~i4'`d'!{s J1 .�4,•'n;,: �. sR, ti. 9'$ , *,. , ; k:� .7 i .,- . ' � C7 • t `'• er- 441.t t6 x' .,,,,4 t th ggF 0. tt4 r t . 0, %i « ' If' .: � kRf. � y V ty 4 +.. d ,,., 2 n Jrlk .t t ` ; . . 9l•�:, , 4 e 7 t � � h S 1t1 c ur 1..4 0 . y y f.ti . • 1 *� ..: ' . a . y, - • ro c,,w•y. 'l S 1,v� ,4 a ti P L '. : ), a w-41: t ' n ": + yF.Y r r! ,41,111,' '4 d . ,f � 9 ^15 t U" i . Kr 1 f ,4y '2 r�t , � „ A, •N Goodiand Harbour Park Collier County, Florida Legend: 'r:•":: Township 52 South,Range 27 East ,; { ^tM{ f Base 8CR947 map: Marco Island,Fla.1973 •7, ' USGS 7.5'topographic quadrangle • 0 02 0.4 0.6 0.8 Miles • . Figure 1. General vicinity map of the Goodland Harbour Park project area,formerly MarGood Resort and RV Park, in Collier County, Florida. 2 Packet Page -2444- 1/13/2015 17.C. FIELD METHODS Jeanette Knowles, Architectural Historian, and Amanda Townsend, Operations Analyst for Collier County Parks & Recreation, conducted pedestrian surveys of MarGood during the afternoon of June 22 and the morning of June 23, 2006. Jeanette Knowles recorded the structures located at MarGood immediately afterward. Prior to the field visit, Collier County Parks &Recreation provided a plan of the property with all structures color-coded according to whether they were to be removed or kept for• the future park, "Goodland Harbour Park." They also provided an aerial photograph of the project area with the standing structures identified by a separate color, the access road indicated, and floating docks hi-lighted. By the time of the field visit, all mobile homes and trailers had been removed from the site. During the field survey, all structures within the Area of Potential Effect (APE) were recorded and photographed using with a color digital camera and a 35mm camera with black and white film. At least four views were taken of each structure, with additional photographs taken. as necessary to document particular features of each structure. While some structures were photographed on the interior, others were locked and could not be entered. Digital photographs were also taken of the general project setting. Notes were taken concerning the condition of each structure, use of historic and non-historic construction materials, and architectural plan. A handheld GPS unit (with 10-foot accuracy) was used to record the Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM) coordinates for each structure, typically while standing in•the middle of the front elevation. Structure locations were mapped on a topographic map of the project area. Local informants include Tommie (Kirk) Moss, Kappy (Stephens) Kirk, Jackie (Bianchi) Kranz, Cecelia Weeks, Elhanon Combs, Sandra Combs, Sandra Arnold, David Southall, Betsy Perdichizzi, William Perdichizzi,William Ludlow, Marie Ludlow, and Marion Nicolay. Jeanette Knowles, Architectural Historian, spoke to these informants on several occasions concerning the history of the project area. HISTORIC OVERVIEW Historically, there were three settlements on Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands in southwest Florida: Marco on the north end of the island, Caxambas on the south end, and Goodland on the east, next to the bridge over Goodland Bay (Figure 2). W.T. Collier and his son W.D. "Captain Bill" Collier were the preeminent early settlers of Marco. W.T. Collier came to Marco Island in the 1870s and grew cabbage for a Key West market. His son had a boat service, among other ventures, and was to be the guiding genius of Marco Island until the early 1920s. 1n1908,Bill Collier invented a new motorized clam-dredging machine that sped clam harvesting (Davis 1998). The E. S. Burnham Packing Company, a clam factory extablished at Caxambas in 1904, was subsequently guaranteed years of work. A second clam factory was started in Marco in 1911 by the J.H. Doxsee family. That cannery stayed in operation until 1947, while the cannery at Caxambas closed in 1929 (Tebeau 1966). 3 Packet Page-2445- 1/13/2015 17.C. • North Marco inn . Marco Village Factory o o Marco • Bay o Pass Old Railroad Embankment $CIII6 1 ( Mh. 953 0 Marco Maroc River To US 41 Highlands a } Railroad • Turnaround' Gull of Me ka SR 92 . J Roberts SR 92 vrpg.. • Bay Badlekl. 3 • ()resent Bay +.�! B - n. Bond, V Indian Hill Goodland Air Force w f ` 41w,,eights Hotel V Tracking ° f �t (Ruins) -- Station / V i Caxambas of Burnham m Pass \\ CaxaSito mbas Factory(Ruins)Cla Tan Thousand blends Figure 2. Map of Marco Island with locations of Caxambas and Goodland (Waitley 1993:20). Bill Collier began developing the town of Marco, but sold most of his land to Barron Collier in 1922. In the late 1920s, the Atlantic Coast Line (ACL) Railroad reached Marco Island. Also in the 1920s,the San Marco Corporation of New York put together rather grandiose plans to develop the entire island as Collier City, with highway and railroad access. Collier owned most of the island, except for some parcels at Caxambas and Goodland. Much of this • property Barron Collier bought from the Louisville & Nashville Railroad, which had gotten the land from the state in exchange for track laid elsewhere. Issues of legal claim to,coastal land and inaccurate nineteenth-century surveys delayed Collier's plans to develop Marco Island. Anticipating eventual growth, however, Barron Collier built an electric plant on Marco Island. When the Florida real estate boom ended in the late 1920s, Collier's plans and the electric plant were abandoned(Tebeau 1966). The first settlers at Caxambas arrived in the 1870s. Most prominent were James Madison Barfield and his wife Tommie Camilla Stephens Barfield. James Barfield was a vegetable farmer, selling his produce to the Key West and New York markets. Among the exotic fruits he grew was pineapple(Waitley 1993). Another prominent early settler of Caxambas was Frederick Ludlow who married W.D. Collier's daughter Emma. Ludlow ran a pineapple plantation at Caxambas. The Barfields ran a general store and the post office, and gradually turned their home into a hotel known as "Heights Hotel" (Tebeau 1966): In 1904, the Barfields gave some land to the E.S. Burnham Packing Company, which operated a clam cannery there until 1929. The local economy became focused on commercial fishing, and the cannery built housing for its workers. In addition to the cannery and housing for workers, Caxambas had a large frame building that 4 Packet Page-2446- -- 1/13/2015 17.C. served as a school, church, Sunday school, movie theater, and stage where tap dancing lessons .. were sometimes taught (Weeks, personal communication 2006). According to Tebeau (1966:157), "The old schoolhouse at Caxambas became for a brief time a movie house, the only one the island ever had until M.C. Johnson began to operate one at Goodland in 1952." Tommie Barfield was very actively involved in the promotion and development of Marco ' Island, and worked with Barron Collier to create Collier County. It was at Tommie Barfield's urging that in 1912 a ferry completed a crucial connection between Naples and Marco Island: In 1936, a bridge was approved for construction over Goodland Bay as a Public Works • Administration project. • Using a swing span that had been part of a bridge over the Caloosahatchee River at Fort Myers, the bridge was officially opened in 1938 (Tebeau 1966). Although the E.S. Burnham Cannery closed in 1929, Doxsee's cannery in Marco stayed open until 1947. In its later years, the cannery struggled with the effects of over fishing. After the Doxsee cannery closed, the ACL railroad stopped running trains to Marco (Davis 1998). During World War II, the Army Air Force built a base near Naples for a submarine patrol and for training pilots. This facility, with two 4,000-foot runways, was an auxiliary field for Buckingham Army Airfield near Fort Myers. Marco Island was used as a bombing and gunnery range. After the war ended, the airfield became the Naples Airport (First National Bank 1981; Freitus and Freitus 1998:14-15). The Barron Collier Company never developed Marco Island, and in 1964 sold 10,000 acres (including the 6,700-acre island) to the Deltona Corporation (Waitley 1993). At the time, the island's population was less than 600. The Deltona Corporation, founded and owned.by Elliott, Robert, and Frank Mackie, had recently worked on major developments in Deland and Daytona Beach. The development was called "Deltona" after its location, and General Development Corporation soon changed its name to "Deltona." As General Development Corporation in the 1950s, the Mackle brothers had developed Key Biscayne and Cape Coral (Antonini et al. 2002; First National Bank 1981). The Deltona Corporation embarked on a 15-year plan that completely changed the character and appearance of Marco Island, changing sparsely populated fishing communities into manicured high-end resort communities. Deltona's development plans required extensive dredge-and-fill operations, and led to extensive controversy over U.S. Army Corps of Engineers' permits. Ultimately, part of the island was developed, and part was not. Goodland, where the land was privately owned, remained apart from the new development(Antonini et al. 2002). GOODLAND The first settler on the eastern corner of Marco Island was John Roberts. Roberts named his homestead "Good Land Point," referring to its suitability for vegetable farming and fruit trees. In 1887, John and his wife Margaret, along with John Graham and Wellington Payne, formed the Tropical Fruit and Vegetable Company. In the 1890s, the company's land was sold to Samuel Alexander Pettit, who farmed the land as well. Pettit also sold shell from a large prehistoric midden as road material. Samuel Pettit's son Harry used some of this shell to build a, road from Goodland to State Road 92 after the bridge to Marco Island was opened in 1938 (Tebeau 1966). The shell mound also supplied base material for State Road 92 on the other side 5 Packet Page -2447- 1/13/2015 17.C. of Goodland Bay where the road led to Royal Palm Hammock on the Tarniami Trail (Highway 41). According to information provided in Pilots, Pinballs, and Poliltics, a private military • contractor excavated shell from the Goodland area during World War II. The shell was used as a base material for two auxiliary airstrips to the Buckingham Army Airfield near Fort Myers. The shell was loaded onto trucks at Goodland and driven to Naples over the new Goodland Bay Bridge. From there, it was trucked north on Highway 92 to the Tamiami Trail, then west to Naples (Fessenden, 2003). In 1949, Goodland had a tremendous growth spurt when the Barron Collier Company moved most of the houses (about 20 buildings) from Caxambas to Goodland. Before this, many people had been living in their houses in Caxambas on Collier-owned land. The rent was so minimal that it was often not collected (Weeks, personal communication 2006). Wanting to clear the land in Caxambas for development, Collier offered to pay the expense of having a professional house-mover from Fort Myers take the houses to Goodland if the residents agreed to buy a lot in Goodland from the Collier Company (Tebeau 1966; Waitley 1993; Weeks and.. Ludlow, personal communications 2006). Families accepted the offer and all the houses were moved to Goodland, with only one ending up on a lot that would eventually become part of. MarGood. At that time, Goodland's only history was that of the Calusa Indians creating the shell mounds and the Pettit family farming most of the area,including the shell middens. A forty-acre shell mound near Goodland Bay had been used as a place to plant vegetables and fruit trees by earlier settlers like John Roberts (Tebeau 1966). Farmed later by the Pettit family, the land continued to be used for fruit tree orchards, citrus groves, and vegetable fields. About 50 years after they began, the Pettit family stopped farming and subdivided their land into "Pettit Subdivision" in 1947 (Collier County Plat Book 2, Page 88) and "Goodland Heights" in 1949 (Collier County Plat Book 1,Page 82). At that time, they sold lots to people who wanted to - build a house in Goodland or move one from Caxambas. Several houses are still standing in Goodland that were moved from Caxambas, while others have burned down or been razed (Weeks, personal communication 2006). The MarGood Resort, RV Park, Cottages, and Marina were on land once owned by the Pettit family. In 1949, Cecelia Whidden Weeks and her husband bought a lot on the south side of Pear Tree Avenue. They wanted to keep the house in which they were living in Caxambas, so. the heirs of Barron Collier, the owners of almost all of Marco Island, gave them the house and had it moved to Goodland. The lot on Pear Tree Avenue that the Weekses bought was across the street from where MarGood would develop in the early 1950s. In 1949, the lots in MarGood were still full of avocado and sugar apple trees, with a few small agricultural buildings among them. To the northeast, a few hundred yards away, was a small cottage where Rex and Ruby Johnson lived (8CR953). Only one house from Caxambas was moved to the MarGood property: Mrs. Cora Leo, a school teacher, bought a lot on the north side of Pear Tree Avenue in front of Cecelia Weeks' house. She had her Caxambas house moved to that lot, but as the house was old and in poor condition, it was torn down a few years later (Weeks, personal communication 2006). • 6 Packet Page -2448- 1/13/2015 17.C. Rex (Milton C.) and Ruby Johnson may have owned some of the MarGood land by 1950, but they certainly owned most of it by 1952 (Weeks, personal communication 2006). Rex and Ruby married in the early 1900s. Together, they formed an act that took them up and down the east coast. In the performance, Rex operated a hot-air balloon while Ruby performed an acrobatic act on a trapeze suspended under the balloon.The climax to the performance was Ruby jumping from the balloon-basket with a parachute (Greene 2004). When the weather turned cold,Rex and Ruby headed to Marco Island near the southern tip of Florida. Before she moved to Goodland in 1949, Cecelia Weeks remembers the Johnsons coming to Caxambas during the winter. They brought a few rides from the carnival that was part of their show in the north, such as cars that went around on a track (Weeks, personal communication 2006). Seeing a retirement opportunity, the Johnsons began buying lots in Goodland where they built themselves a cottage (8CR953). Their vision was to provide accommodations for other winter visitors to Goodland. By 1952, the Johnsons had established MarGood Cottages and Trailer Park and had constructed the two-story concrete-block building (8CR948) as a rental office and a movie theater. They quickly built the cistern (8CR949) to provide water for their trailer park customers, and built a duplex (8CR950) where two or three families could stay. The Johnsons soon built Cottages #4, #5, #6, and #7 and later acquired 8CR955, Cottage #8 and its associated cistern. This cottage had been built as a winter residence by George and Betty Culty who had purchased a lot in Pettit Subdivision around 1950. In the late 1950s, a fish camp in Marco called Kelly Gantts Fish House &Cottages was sold. Rex and Ruby bought three of the cottages (8CR956, 8CR957, and 8CR958) and moved them to MarGood. 8CR960 was built by the Johnsons as a laundry facility but converted to a shell shop when municipal water was available and the cistern was no longer needed (Weeks, Ludlow personal communications 2006). Although Rex and Ruby maintained a home.in New Jersey, they always returned to Florida for the winter. Caring about the people in Goodland, Rex and Ruby always gave a wonderful Christmas present to every child in town (Weeks, personal communication 2006). In the 1950s, five small cottages were moved from Miami to Goodland. Bill and Edna O'Connell purchased them through someone they knew in the construction business in Miami. The cottages were put on lots at the end of Pear Tree Avenue near the water (Marco Channel); one of the cottages next to Stan's on Harbor Place recently burned (Stop n.d.). No cottages from -. Miami were ever placed at MarGood(Combs and Ludlow, personal communications 2006). In 1986, Elhanon and Sandra Combs bought MarGood Resort and RV Park from Marjorie Tasetano. Marjorie, Ruby Johnson's closest friend, inherited the property from Ruby who was a widow without children when she recorded her will in 1982. In,2005, the Combses sold the property to Collier County for use as a waterfront park (Naples News, December 1, 2004, "County Approves $2.5 Million Purchase of Margood Resort"; Marco Island Sun-Times, February 2, 2006, "Digging up the Past in Goodland"; Warranty Deed 3610955). 7 Packet Page-2449- 1/13/2015 17.C. " kt Tai>� {� uY s ,, ,,',A. 1'.1,6,:k... {s cry fz�J .��t`�' I I'• 1,,1 a ) 't ,i ,y 7 g..kir 7a�,. 4 1:,,Tx' 5.✓� nk;f��C' t y ` ` C 'u" ,s�,' rs rllr •rid 4 i4 3?rh�� 2 4' r''t,}tr'', l e r + h t 1r „M r, i44".,441>00%.`7% 8 �y' ' S-`yr,.1. ,� x Mel *4:c . a�a i`r'iT1(�atis .i0f u9 °!fir > . .-i ll'igg fe. s0 ..j�tt,,��At e ”1,?,,,,:.1,4,44,,.:,.x ' �`'`r'f LF"'",*• �r i i 9 n r :sw-1S`by f i ¢ti y-::`:V/.c !y I v3.R. 7 •.__ x.;' r e". 4•:. �xN;3$J fA13 rf7�PtyJe S i4 d fps _ t ,.�y tom.• s'''::,.9i:':;--.:..,: ' ' u w ri cn` ,- I�t 41r6. c...a 44,':',;,.,,447.:4 s + Y nt yi(. j 3 r pl :i ��4L� a++w ll '''!,,,,,,,,,4'7'''''''w,ixtssy"� 1 4 "rc95,�ir. / �i`;.,,. � _ ��d &ix+f 0i •Y ?�-J Lrdvlti�a4;F w;��t L ff�'�j ♦Ft�w�'W+�•f ')S�F a c. t'•' �'"' Ya• r 44I,es'�,E?'t #.. M Y'4t''s "Y 5 , . 4' c. n,` 'r i x G i ' S y !1 # c .r < fl '' ak L,n iINC'. A�..77 d ;��y N r.(tta � " uP�r'( �1y' '- 1tJ *' ' xq. , �t vi * F� 3r41-,kNn �,,-11-,ylf Ayie''1 3�yjrr 4ty('9 #)s ),,,„,°'` .,7 f, .@,l..,, 'S ,z t.,- a i ff y to a e�° ru.4 wo i k40 • y�if„, 13,, yt 5r S. 1S A r,.o- /sr i '$Mit-dgT' �. °4'YztL xM° v 'rtCxn , • , �'1r� 8Is q 3 �I �. `*i'tf' dri 444-,; n h s n Gfr'05 .0,.....:49,40.:;44-f—`z --'1,^'}'S 4' sY 1 5 '''''''P�. i, F .. f{., .�a' 1- r }'' : 40, 4, ...i. m.414k+' G,t.G 1.��"4�,1$,� 4$3 21' t, 7, y5 .n}s. 5 `'r r)'a.,, `!�. .... . )f�. dx.}rk;.s'¢p�',,.. ?:�; 1F RR�,k•�..�..7M'�r, .trEqu eu,A" ,3_ J Fisi;t.. .. • • • ` LyA • y ^ ,� • ' 1•_ '. '�""""�'""" Mfr`.•3f ', ue : syri h I Jw, -4.,.;-:.:.-..- r v. T s , 1 - b � l 3 r haf * WF ls 1yr s .. % Si'c ..(„ -'"' I 4 LrV „4 7/.r s . ,, ^ c ;,_ - fi� j G' FBr� ,di k iy{" inky✓t r�� a. ,' tA.,.�,at Ny�, .. p - 9 y h.7Mh' .i��l FK t rl 43 Lt e' 5 r F{ "m � °.4,Q t'4 4.;; 1 n u F ei 8 • • • 41'40,is rPS p-bm.7J 'z'bs1,�-�3* r".•' `00AL.Yisis�a•Y±Li{f:. a9%i''''a'; .,. Itt t)k +t 'A'.., ,,,...o... v. . .-' Ra•r�!1fl 1 '� _ ., ajt .rtoia:ir tx r r x i S m u �.. v7 r,e 1x+*.x r 1 'f 3 re- 1,.S s4 t i7 ' ''"1(� .,,rw•m •ly,:o 6 frift J i 4:::: 1,4:4 4r{ . r s3' 7,x 4o.'a : & a4 x 3 51 a,,f4" �ysa 1 'i t�! ,�,�6 s�, v f p�f � Z AcF y >; a A r >f,,. rntiTi �',yr' ..i5y a r A ^.7 , Y'A�xs F : G G ti r gI��1 • 4i,--, lLr' •,rr e x r i did'°t�4' v't. '41 #'4i ),,4.�R: l fir 1 k.g% i$ /i t C44 1 SM1�,: 1�+i� /p,.Y�r ti 3'Li ,, ,0fj'.^-M1! !I'M y 44)�! Sr�fo,- /i, ! ?.' t ,.,3 1qida 4, ,r.i3'n' f 10 .@�1,,,,,l'+ r t a 4 e4fr.�.1,t f-,.*e.4,r svfr -.. +ar .. r i trc r u 3;•-9r Cti ik s i t?`w' " �~ :1 „q✓s;4 -y k1, A,',.'s',i'a'y`rM�e� � r __w3)_° Z�.�aW..lt rtn H�'�1rA �� r�.. r...• ,, asp .��'�`�rpv A ykM 19 f G�� r�' __MCI 1 PS 'u fr ` .fin. 3 ".emu ~ a .. , , Yr4 i .�1� "--4.-: Ij LJrI-- t - t. t .,crn .n. :. '._; r » a i� 1 .tt-, 5 'x.14 1•• Figure 3. Photographs of MarGood Park in the late 1950s. 8 Packet Page -2450- - 1/13/2015 17.C. RESULTS Twelve structures and one building were documented during the historical assessment of MarGood Resort and RV Park. MarGood will be developed as a public park by the Collier County __ Parks and Recreation Administration, and the new park will be Goodland Harbour Park. All thirteen historic resources were considered potentially eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. Collier County plans to restore and use some of them in the new park. All thirteen resources have been included in Resource Group 8CR947 (Figure 1). The structures and their locations are show in Figure 4 below. • mobile home park ^O L , -o Goodland Gr'3 1 13 Harbour ------ O, a'y Q concrete boat ramp m post 4 \ \ 3 office paved road Int NI r. t 11i Pear Tree Avenue --.. Legend: Goodland Harbour Park Collier County,Florida 1 8CR948 ■ 8CR954 0 50 100 8CR949 8CR955 3 meters u BCR950 8CR956 ■ RCR951 10. 8CR957 8CR952 11 8CR958 © 8CR953 12 8CR959 ;:-_-_-1 chain link fence ■ 8CR960 Figure 4. Sketch of the location of MarGood Park historic resources. _._ 9 Packet Page -2451- • 1/13/2015 17.C. 8CR948 Johnson-Combs Theater and Museum 8CR948 is located on Pear Tree Avenue within MarGood Resort and RV Park (Figure 4). A two-story, rectangular, masonry vernacular structure, it was built in 1952 by Rex (Milton C.) and Ruby Johnson as an office for MarGood Cottages and Trailer Park (MarGood) and as a movie theater (Figure 8). This was the first movie theater in Goodland, but not the first in Collier County. In the 1920s, movies were shown in the Caxambas community building (Tebeau 1966;Weeks, personal communication 2006). Open to both the community of Goodland and the trailer park, movies were shown in 8CR948 through the 1990s (Combs, personal communication 2006). With a stage in place, there was an occasional live play. Because the building was so large, Rex Johnson also used it for boat storage. Rex had expected to see growth in Goodland and commercial'opportunities for himself with a ready building. That, however, did not happen (Weeks, Moss, Combs, personal communication 2006). When Elhanon. and Sandra Combs bought MarGood in 1986, they cleared the building of cars and boats and turned it into a store, restaurant, dining room, and theater for live plays and music. They started the museum collection from items given to them by visitors and from things they collected in other places (Figure 9). Articles left in the building by the Johnsons were old pots and pans from some of the cottages, and newspaper articles (Combs, personal communication 2006). The Johnsons never had a collection of memorabilia or museum pieces (Ludlow,personal communication 2006). A concrete-block building, 8CR948 has a stucco exterior,a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, assumed-concrete-footers, and a poured concrete slab 'floor. The few windows in the building are casement, single hung one-over-one, and fixed plate glass. All windows have metal sashes and frames. The main entry on Pear Tree Avenue is a single commercial glass door within a protective booth. In recent years, this entry led into a small grocery store, grill, and dining area within the museum (Figure 5). A double commercial door leading into the dining area and museum is located on the side of the building on the east elevation. A private door on the north elevation where Chuckle's Chickee Bar and Grill was once located leads into the building. Double delivery or service doors are located on the west and south elevations, and a single wood door is located on the north elevation. The service door on the west elevation may have been used as an entry and exit when movies were shown (Figure 7). The concrete porch at the rear of the building (north elevation) has been altered to create an open bar.and grill area with a thatched roof, wooden seats and benches, and an elevated wooden seating area at Chuckle's Chickee Bar and Grill (Figure 6). Under the thatched roof is a wooden bar with a gable roof and a large wooden vent. An old photograph (Figure 3, center) shows that this area was originally a restroom-addition to 8CR948 for visitors who arrived with a trailer or who rented one of the cottages that had no indoor plumbing (Combs, personal communication 2006). . Concrete and wooden walks and ramps are all around the building except for on the west side. 8CR948 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the.NRHP under Criterion A—a property,associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR948 was constructed as a facility to serve the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers. Those needs included places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and water, and water and electricity. Rainwater from the roof of 8CR948 filled an adjacent cistern. Water from 10 . Packet Page -2452- 1/13/2015 17.C. • the cistern met the need for water at MarGood until at least 1986 (Combs, personal communication 2006). As a movie theater with a stage, 8CR948 provided entertainment for tourists staying at MarGood or living in Goodland from the 1950s to the late 1990s. The display of memorabilia in 8CR948 was collected by Elhanon and Sandy Combs who gave it to Collier County when Collier County purchased the property in 2005. The collection includes old photographs of Goodland and MarGood, shells fashioned into tools by the Indians who created the middens, an American flag with 34 stars, and hundreds of unusual T-shirts nailed inside the gable roof. One of those T-shirts is autographed by actor Ernest Borgnine who made a movie (Captiva Island) in Goodland in 1994. The museum was an attraction for a relatively isolated tourist park and met a need for entertainment other than boating and fishing. The building demonstrates how tourism developed in the far reaches of Florida through the creation of cottage rentals and trailer parks offering the basic necessities of shelter, electricity, public restrooms and showers, parking areas, boat-launch areas, and entertainment. Collier County plans to restore and use 8CR948 as an interpretive center and a community museum where the collection of historical memorabilia will be displayed. . .,,':,'?.51'.'441:.•,;'4,1,2v..2', I;)1%° ' i a 'L ip:r�: :5 f7: i 4 ' ', n ,'y$' F S ',h.:::; ' r . -4,-,tv„, lk � 1) ' c 4 i -,r a ,.a r r 7s r , c .3 z r l,; "2 Sr i-,ti r cp s r ;, ti i,, rh5+. I c: a •r+t ,r�!�,�Y,��',y .�>1 v nu)�j4r� 'z}!i"�t,"^l xG i'��t'F'�ty��v�cr „#::'1,4 i i :. t '' lxati ypA ra ,ill dY 4 4 ^!rx't Le ., <'.y I Sj2.� S�J 'H d..0 t �. Y i1 0 1}1.: aw r .t j r(,at ' q�€".r 4 / 99. fYa t 9 t �r L .,iav i ,4,44,fMe uA r z;. iYY t t u's`a vx'.--'�X0 r ma r° »t1.tj.,� 1 i k"%.:”.k y 10.4' �" .■J t ,,..v'!�,,,4.4. i�'�a u` ,4.,,,J,, ;r 4.,%fw A�.,'r44 ,r ni P� 4 .�S.v.i 1/ a , i r^aF � .�Jy tAt�,S !rt ��3 : "..:,,,,,,,,,,-16,,,,,,„.,-,,r G i i%3 f Cw :' r.'el'f'N VIN r Yi a x x,�t) ,,N t' 'L4l,,,l m' ; ; ! 1sx} n [ 1[4 fp s ?.. i JJ�,hk 7,r3 ! - ? ,1 ,4Y'`'.wt't �% ,rtfYr} 4�*yf r t .. t L.. J/1, ! c:4 �. J ahyr rr.ric, '.i:".•-;'; ri 1 is { • Figure 5. Entrance to the grocery store area of 8CR948,the theater and museum building, facing northeast. r� 11 Packet Page -2453- 1/13/2015 17.C. ,.,-c., „ , - .,,tp„,101., T'(.-/ .,....._ '. ,' i'll":1 ‘ I4'114e'i,■.. el `,-. — , 41 - . Al lierl• ,--, sh-- .. , 41( I,\ • i :3 , I; ---...., ,,,,,I•if -• 0 •-"S• 41.4 ti •4,.. , 1'1 k .g '''&`":1 N•vi - :-kk' Ii;.:3 ' , li ....: zt,ati,1,..t.,,,..:-'., :--,.: , ,•'.., ,.,,p); ' sii 4 IrI" i\V,P.• Sf.`:-.-`"-•"or.':.•.... - —- - .."`"... . •rs ..,.. . ...,Q1AA4.. :,•, ','/ .2,:t e * •...s" .-•-,,,;• ! • 4-ely. 401 q....,,,,,,, „ .,... .,e ., ....„' • . ..., .., ,,, ,A, .,—,, 1,...A.„..,,m,t 't.' . f I' ..ai '-:`..e-;'...... 04i.},..,.., •': ,„,..-:-"1,1 9,.,Peigliv ",-, .itcz: -,',)k. /'''• N.' A ... _ •t„,,,, Al. t . ,,,,,,,•••,-.,,,,•,, _ _......_.__ , -,,,-0,,,,,,40).,fr. ,•,..•piii..,,,I „ -w 0- 444,1Nli.14.- i Air,.._ . 1. _ 4...cic..it _...„..fi...; mi f,I.....-1,, d,Ilik.. ., 7.ill if i kit r,1.,W•• .., ,.... ', ''''' P.. „, ..... I •Y :-.• 1. ",. - : • 4 3`-‘1,; • * .- '- •,7.78-z--M: ,. .. -,..... . . ... , i* ' , .4s1 .e.,..,- - -13g. t4:,1,- •„..,,.. . • •,...... .,_-.1...,, .„..,, .... r.,... .• . ---.47, 1 ma„;. • 1. ir.- ',..._ lb ,. . ; -•-• Is..I• ...---""-•••-•-••.••••.-:, ....."'•••"'"'÷"*.: -A.1111I-71-1!a 1 - '‘ .A.' .1, ,1 I I% •-, si.• I - :, ' ,i s , t s,,, .01 . ,. ,..,-' 4''Y'.' .. - 7,7 ly:11/V.,..” '• 11 i • • • ' : .. ,• r....„., ,,: • ' •„,01, 1•1‘..?•• 2.,,•%,-,• 1.Ref. .,, •• ,m1,i , . , . 4.. -...1,.....4.-..,.; . .. ;,; .., . . ...,..:,,.,-.4...--,,- 7',1.-z--5:'-,--.'.--;....c.,..,-4,--.:,ftiary,, 1,loti-t, • ,.,,.,,,,,-,-,-,,i;„ ,„, ,,,:. ,,,,, . .- ....--,.--- . ,. ....,,,. ,,..„,.1k.,..a.-.- . .- ' i.t.--Ail.,•,1 -- 0.-- ,,- ...,-..f. g, '. . •• ..,',..'•,-,." .?"P.::",:`,,,,t‘,":4•,,, U.-' ;•• •-.A..4,,,, 0.•,,,,••,. . • . .... .,..,,,,,,,,..- ...• ,. . .. : •••• • • . „ / ,,.., ., .• ,..... ,,,, ., :, , ,.,••••,, ... , ,• . - .., • .. ..A:,•fri•-•• ," ' ."•• ••."., ..• •44vAtt•-,:.. mu, <,,,,..,,___- •• ,•• ,or:-43 , . ,••4:„. . ."''„::.S.04;1,V,,, „. ..,,,,•. /. ••••14:.,^"'•"-•'•-•'•.--7.16,e.,•••••-••• •:..•••,t-' "-...r*■•:;,, ...,,,,, • . ;„,...e.A.-....,... . .-,........ •......• ....x ,.•^,,z,..,,k -.•••'-i,..• •-:.'*----4•4t ,1 •••%••%"0-4.r..ti i ,a.. . • •• •4- . • ....;`,.4.3....: .• - ..: .:.„1:.--,-•,,,,;:A ,4, A...",','; V-"...." .-,11..,. vp,fg:•..14.. ..k.--,',.'t ., .: •-..'. _..'.',,W,P,,,,r,-4,-;:,,..,,,......n._,;.:„.,,,,'".---7.!•?,• • . "T.,-...-.'...V. ;V•I'P'"', 'IA v.o.,v.-, ,-,owler:mq,' '1d.ii , 9.".;-,-,-..--- . t -,-,-,,- ,..-- '',------.F.A•e,y--,'-'.--, .. .,-....... , :.....-:'.a—.,,,,,,,A40- ,_-0.,0,,,.)m.41.,.",,,,..., . ....,--,,,,..;.?,,,..17-4-...„..,,-;.?„,..•,,,cts•,,t.. ,- ..,, ,,-7, ..,:-,:..A.Ir,.. ,—•.- -- . ,-- ` . • where Ch • 6. The north elevation south- southwest. Figure . vation of 8CR948 w Chuckle's Chickee Bar&Grill was located, facing south- , --,,,...141.!3.:.,--,,,•,... • ,$fv,..,:iv 4, ,, ' •'''''',,w,`7,..7.11i,.....,' •''''''41Hil,':i9+,e nigr.,,...,414co.,,,t41-.,-,,,,..„._ . _..,,..,,..1.._ , .4 --we th. ■ .e 6.440 a .4/tyr..,,,,,,ve,..", ,,,, .1, ,,,,,,,,, •e".c.4.,0.(N•'-,.:,•0•-",,,-.3•••4+• ,4 1.-4247III: e,/t.....,4•NI,kr„,,,I.:,.,, ?5.;_•pp,,..., *,',047:704,14.!•;.,,,',M;411,4,, Aola.,,,, ,15M li."4q-'1:1•Ett"...1,. .-„,:, `.irr,,;,;.414144.1-$6•!"I4?"4,'',1itil'/C91.4%.$,,,,•f.,-c',"I; ilk''.'"iI'it""I*,.'40;.,,, „ 11'.4.4V414,,,,■..,„., *14 ''...,.. .1,. -04 4..k, , ,,,,,.,,., , ,..,0, ,,A FL., , ,,I.i• V,t, . , .... ,... . ... •-„t., r416'4k12•Il'7'4001,10- '+*1 i g;14.1W•TAWI.0‘21'441,e'"cc, i.-"4"&"0"ipto :li‘illl'i•",-,745e). .•."' 't 03,.t,' 'IV' 411( i traitti4 .1*-- ..111514,•?'14.',IV)15..,'''',,,,..T.4.1.4,Ni;li,thn,Fire,s,' -i. SAPH:1414,,,,,,,.01,Af'.2.:e.Ps'-,,i',',f,,,,,31141,7-;.; '-•-•"•".'/''',..'•'''' ?:-.•.".4-.4%",;;.. .- " 41.•." -.4t.t441 +, 1'4...7)/,'•S'',4.••11""^MIhNlag,-"7..'11• : ' ','ACM,I ,&s7(4.,,S,,,,VI.I.,0,74,4,..•I:j••,,•,f,•,..<'• . •,=7• •7 ,-,•-..; - . ,, ,',7.,,..,;:i4,..71„,:,7,115;A-4).;,,k Rh„.4 R..0.3,4,,t-,, ' },,,,t,o, pyll',... -"P.'-`q-kv*,..1.1'.;?•••A 1,.,:-.4.. .1%...n. . ; • •...%.** aNIVI'i:i'igle,`..,..i.Y.;:lisv....V Za,?-4,144.440,4:,h - -4:':,1•7341,04, 01,4•.-M3,1119-wrr;;...•,.. ,.. ,-.1..z.:.:••••;rf..• • ..:;...--..., ••,..,,,..., .0i, ,ItA5i4444g.744,01,,,A41 '•. Ill',,r41 1-`;',Pitt,e;Ft,4'.?,' ,,-`.-- • i. •• • *,-..'....,-',. :N.WYktft 14,iit,IN,„„).411,7,tz:•:"'"-'7, -.104'4,,:`4, ,;..frW-'I, -'.' ,•, 14.-.. - ,-.:-. -' itiV,,,,,,} '-' ::•,•,..W^A.I.N4,-4,4,1494,49•441:Aye;'`;,,,,4,II;....;•...j../, •.\ '+`..iti 4 .0-e,..t;I:i, •'4-1-44.7,,,f'71041:-,1)-,,kt.,•.-`p..%7I,I.-,,i zok;., ,.,., , .2..4,,,I•1.,••••%{;4'44\7 WIIkfe..14,...,"04A-S7.4:;.4,.•?..?•7•1'.1."-':'., .".. ••""'I,;W..44,4•40'.',,••• re,:„,,,,,,t6r44,4:-4,,,,..1...e.,„ . ;I . ".•‘4."-1..-:,-", , $•••".I./IV..':/‘3'-.”'.'./'' • 1. P?'•''''.,';it,' I '"I•'I", ••.. -'••• •- ' , 4,••• .• , - ,'.11•'- • .4,.. I- ., . „, ,. ,.',:•.- •••••." . . "'II , - •• ' ‘ '.`' . • • , • , - • . . . '••"% _ -• :-".". • .- ' . _ • .- • Figure 7. Side view of 8CR948,the west elevation,facing southeast. ...---, 12 Packet Page-2454- 1/13/2015 17.C. ., w • }'. • r :1 : ' t > i •• :i ` X C . I ir FjA" LG Figure 8. Interior of the theater and museum, showing movie screen above original stage, facing north. :'r ' N+µi4M. l�� -51.,,,,,%-41.' �a , 1,. •' . ,.crw a •+w" 4- R.,.mil!C Y'..,1=',F1,-t-1:.'"^. I• 1 J ; t r 1 A,4f Y s 1 1. of 4, f 111 �.. 1 t •1 '. c f ry t ! s 1 i,. * ■ r e !�—.. " i : 1• e x` "6 . .mml. QpQpS r 1 i:� .........--\ 4"'IF/441AL --: : .0 .' V.4.4,4•'14-1t1 .4 rw3N•4.4 k a.3os�: r tax s AIM riv i rep i 1�S { , Figure 9. Museum collection in wall cabinets of 8CR948,facing northeast. 13 Packet Page-2455- 1/13/2015 17.C. r-- 8CR949 Laundry and Cistern 8CR949 is located within MarGood.Resort and RV Park on the east side of 8CR948 (Figure 4). A two-story, rectangular, concrete and frame structure, it was built in 1952 as a cistern for the new trailer park. Initially, the cistern consisted of two concrete vaults below ground, with extended walls that allowed for additional water storage, and a gable roof (Figure 13). The roof of the above-ground masonry building was covered with rolled roofing. With no public source of water, the resort provided water for its visitors by collecting it in cisterns. Rain was collected from the roof of the two-story museum/theater building just a few feet away and from the roof of the cistern itself. Water was directed into the windowless cistern through pipes. When there,was no rain, water was delivered by truck from Naples and stored in the cistern. Below ground, 8CR949 was a two-room, concrete-block vault with a stucco finish. Earthen ' berms banked the walls on the outside, keeping the water cool and preventing rapid evaporation. MarGood had two other cisterns for water collection at that time. A water tank near some of the cottages held water collected from the cottage roofs. An old photograph shows pipes running into a cistern below the water tank. When lifted into the tank, the water had pressure to run into the cottages or other buildings. Another cistern was located by a cluster of four cottages on the east side of Pettit Drive. When a public source of water became available in Goodland in 1986, 8CR949 was drained, a floor laid, doors cut, and the rooms above were converted to storage space (Combs, personal communication 2006). Every home in Goodland from the earliest time of occupancy to 1986 relied on water collected in cisterns built next to the houses or under them (Weeks, personal communication 2006; Florida Keys 2006). Artesian wells were also used in some places in Goodland. After the cistern was drained and altered, the building was enlarged to include an outdoor laundry facility, public restrooms, and showers (Figure 12). Eventually, a cook-shack for weekend seafood dinners was added to the southwest corner, an open studio where an artist/sign- painter worked was added as a second story, and the north elevation was enclosed and screened as a community center. In 2002, the screened porch became Sharky's Bar & Grill (Figure 10).. The porch area of 8CR949 has a shed roof, wood panels on the exterior, a concrete-block foundation, concrete-slab floor, wooden beam ceiling, and a four-light awning window on the west elevation. Sliding glass doors lead into one of the rooms above the old cistern and a steel spiral staircase in the adjacent room leads down into the cistern recently used for storage. The gable roof of the art studio is covered with sheet metal panels and the exterior of the building, except for Sharky's, is covered with vinyl siding (Figure 11). An exterior staircase on the west elevation leads to the art studio. Rope has been nailed around window openings in Sharky's and on the open art studio to suggest a marine motif. An elevated wooden walkway leads to the laundry and restrooms. The above and below-ground cistern, because it remains in place and is relatively intact, is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history—and Criterion C—design and construction. The structure that was added around and above the cistern, including Sharky's Bar & Grill, the second-story art studio, and the laundry facility with adjacent restrooms, is not considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP as 14 Packet Page -2456- 1/13/2015 17.C. • none of these added areas have architectural merit or significant historical associations. They are also less than fifty years old. As a means of collecting water to sustain a tourist park, and as an example of the way water was collected in Florida, especially in the southern region, the cistern demonstrates how small communities in Florida survived and how tourism was able to grow in the absence of a municipal water system. Field investigations revealed that the original two- room cistern exists, and its above-ground walls are in place. Collier County plans,to preserve and restore the cistern for the new park—Goodland Harbour Park—and provide historical interpretation for visitors. Parts of 8CR949 not associated with the cistern may be demolished so that the cistern will be an excellent example of a Florida water-collection system. N. {a\ „ a !" Yes+ � y'i�; ry�st Y1 �f T1° F ` �` q `7 j' 1r ilrw � • +11.0 S \ 'e fill )4 ;t / {�'�r/ v' 11110:;-; ` r � l�i t •1(Ir 411• �r ffr rN • /� + l S� t r l f - tf ai' t a f f k �,`•`tii� ("'� ff i a rr3 �5a1a't3` d�h9i�d3 fraT54s� � .+Y l {0, •r,J{,t,},f, a S}� 1 ,4 ' � diTj , k�'• • r fiffli?N.:4k1 ,s a • ' 11/ 111 4 : + „. r ,r't) 1i tY �� r 4{ s' ✓i 1.0 i r Ur 9A rp t •r,N /(,f, 1q,,,k's• tw :ry� t A , il ` i '` '.jr {Jl � • f \ s J 1 ' .S.. x "'+�. 7.C!AMtw�'�.`�'•T , �`4� i+Y�w.cF. �s�a riy,�Sn '" r+tr3^{,rK a+^r""£:.�N9{ ^+'�'t'r `'°' t = n f y�` ••.'�'•,?: r • r ? ' r� t T htl. '': r ^'- r •+i`rt ti} �xF • fiar f + S ✓+ { erw r A' � • t .In , Figure 10. The north elevation of 8CR949,the laundry building and cistern, where Sharky's Bar&Grill, originally the community center,was located,facing south. 15 Packet Page -2457- 1/13/2015 17.C. _.. - , 1- 1 . +13nf . • • f1:',j0'w' ti 1 i •,„),•/-;:-••• 1 , +�'�..„ wti+ 1 t Ps q g 7 •'''4etP.Mik 3" r IY ' y it Tti r w ,y,tY n�� F1 1 , ,„ fw ltiiq "'NISI , ,t . , Figure 11. East elevation of 8CR949,with view of the second-story artist's studio,the cistern wall in the center, and laundry, restrooms, and showers on the left-hand side, facing west. ' + y i �1� }r: j� f dk3t..41,_,t t i 1 a r} 13+- t s t 4.,-. r t l i,.,Itil/ I a t lt A . f t} t-1 - . r r �. 'kik;•y • '{ ± Y k�. 1 ■ ' ,��' :,c l ltl '+ + ti I •\ l l+ kl ` t r •. . .. . " 1 '. 4k1 .,41.;i _•;.... `s do i ti el''+. .,.i.;,. t Y,....,'N'.`,..tac:xr1. �,q, ' 1 r IiI.,.'� ��,y i `iC. F.,:.., ' -,,,'JIt9 v w ..•% >• t •fit. •t.. S. ,,a. t .' -,,., 4't w Lw.i- x...acr"'F}I.,,,, tf' ,c. -, �Se��a t a 'f'. ,^ ,,14.11 a.tr. Y , •y�3 , cG Ac f �Y"11:f t,p-i �'".5 A j5 as�ck �'f v f Yom• t =7 1 7 � "fr' ltat t r 4. � lair"'y . t v_k , t ea'� r n +•I`« « d rd�i St ;;` a r� ` 'Yai>+ta' 04 i .xa -C ��.��++r` , . .ii ;7, r `` } srte` i....4 tar to e!ri t t}�', �t"r`1'' ' df�r x t � 4 Y N't Y'Y' n q .� "ivek t :�r ° '1 t0' . i'0.i,t--. t 4 �n*( lr2R? Sx��L`1,f""� 70 �r �a "tom^ t' Figure 12. View of the south elevation of 8CR949 where the restrooms and showers are located, and where the Laundromat was located on the right, facing north. 16 Packet Page -2458- 1/13/2015 17.C. r,e�si �er x�lit-4 : • -�a .:.,... ..r.. .„ tf;A"I .77.14w' Ali.MA1yhf ar warsaar-rY.a. "".S° '1 1,^t*r"4 3 Figure 13. The cistern in 8CR949, with view of hole cut into second vault and floor laid after cistern was no longer used for water storage, facing west. 8CR950 Duplex Cottage 8CR950 is located on the east side of MarGood, bordering Pear Tree Avenue and Pettit Drive (Figure 4). The double cottage was constructed by Rex and Ruby Johnson on site in the early 1950s (Weeks and Ludlow, personal communications 2006). A one-story, frame vernacular structure, 8CR950 has a concrete-block pier foundation, a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, and asbestos shingles on the exterior. The main entries are two half jalousie doors on the west elevation (Figure 14). A third entry on the south elevation has two lights in the top portion (Figure 15). A small shed roof is over each door, and each door is entered from a small concrete porch with curved pipe railings. Windows are two and three-light awning in metal sashes, although the bottom light in the three-light windows has been removed for air- conditioning units. Many of the windows have hurricane shutters above them and rafter tails are visible under the east and west elevation eaves (Figure 16). 8CR950 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR950 was constructed as a component of a recreational facility serving the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and water, and water and electricity. Collier County.Parks & Recreation plans on using 8CR950 as office space for various local, non-profit, or county organizations. 17 Packet Page-2459- _. . , 1/13/2015 17.C. . • ...... .. • „....., • • .•-:-..•...-..,,,....,. . 1,,,,,14t.:.,..._.,,,...„..„,...,,,A..„•korp.,1,.,„,..,• . r.,.. ..,.......:•f:::,:y..,,,,..,,,,...,._,..rls r.:,..„-- -.,•?.,,,.--0,s,...•d,....,:::-.,..1, . ..........:-,, , ,,...,. %.. --..• ,..:",:,... .,,,.., .., .:,-.......-.,,,,,,,,,,,..e,,,,..4,......,•"..,-,4-;..4N ,.7.,../t.'.1'./. -• ------p,......:4•,.?;r•';:_•••i•'3.iit...51-...':..•... :-.'- ..'''''' '':''".' u, ...,.. . • ' "." t -•,."4..-.,..,,-...,. .,-.....-- • ' .,':-,',7,.",','.:,:a.,:i:.7.,',...•.kj..,,k0.:zi•,...,...f.,,i-T....:*.:..,..". • ,:, ....1.;„%•.;...,,_•-,:.,„.....„.e.ift;•!:':1 •:‘,.:•-r...:-..4..:1•.'.::."Fr ''-'-.', . . .. . ''''....• ..tar-VPV.. :g•;•1.4 ... ..„<*„.,:.,.,...... ''''''r..• '..rie '-%•.- tc,Y7-414:1f1V k1'e4.'•-t."4 -..... ''.'•'.'. ..., ' ..'..4;,,:‘.4..,,,..-:.••::•••Vi..N.I.,.*.N.•f•-••. Z... 4 ..‘2:7;'. ...."..'- . '." d'At,'r,• , ". pt:4. :4f-/.4 .1•:••I':'..,..,;•••':::ili ', ...4.4.,,:r.s„...,..t..: '.h... 1 -.: 'j,:.•:,..;•.:'.:...:* ,:',"'•••':•.,• • "r.: L''.f.," •,:l.;,,,4 •rot.,.....; ;...... • . v.., . • .....,•-•y •'',•;....'•'•.:•`i';'.•'':';:•'-•,•A..k. .7,..,.., .. . . • ...Te'.':::',75;'' -*.;.:•.-.;.i',,,..2 .;,.?.';,.... •q- ■0:. ,N;.;:ii.....,,''. 4''''....,.. 1 ...„._-------,,,.,,..:,• " '.:.' ".::':''..:.,':', • ..;1.-:-:,..,:..::\.:••,.:,1.37.- 4. i ;,-......,•A,...;;;,,,•,,••;•,•:,•.;s3:•-.-,,:•L-•,,..::z.-!N ;.•,.,....-•:,1/4-;—..,--......,.-.,,,.. .1:4.. ..:a...-,....;,..:1 ..- .' • • ',:..,• , • :!t•fv!......:(--2,,, ‘e't, -•..., c.N.I.::.;;!.,"',-"...'''''''..,',1:',--...'Z'.,:',.........:..".•-.-"........-2,.., ""-,.. ,-.......,,.....:. '. . ,". •4=', I'V '',' •.! ;-,,:...,:f•p:,'r;:.;.'•::.•-.■*:.,-,-.•:•• .•-7.",-.•'•• .••..• ,: '. •:...',:::..--.: ., .. . • .•."-..,:-•-iir.••-•77....--.:,:•!.... ,t,..-J....' .... .....?f,:„.::::::::•r,fi,,,,..c.:::::-.,.,,:, :..1.. .... .. . o- .• .. . • 4 „ .- , .• .: ..- . -....-.. • • • • • . • • . • .• .. ' ••(.. • .... •..•:,.; ,.,.. . • .., e •- • • i . ■ .... •.:.• ',:,:i•4:.ii":•ii..4)'N',..-4,.,„4,4*-'■4440M1,7'.'4.'"Yq.,"4' •'.4!,'!,.<'.;':::'6•1.-,.,:i:,•i /,`,..•I:/•'';., ' •..,. -. ',... . '. •' '''' - ••■•,.:-.....:1.';14.4"7'1410iittriliPi4440'.4.6''''''';'' .'"•,//,•••1.1.//''',-51'1'.5.,•••:::,'..64,•'::,..:,; •::::',-.!:‘,.;?:•\''''i-;'•••':: .. .".•';',„..,,. " ..., ,;:.,•?•', 44'''tirj,'!;:g.lit,i;Okif..ts.0,.#...i.'.114;7•‘3.:47,Yt':10. /14,.., (/•("4.1,1•::?,;;'?;4.;:',... .........;:;.......i.f.:"..1 r.i. ::::.1:':',...i''Z''''.;:i';4 Ai'..:7".;;':...‘..(1k3:::W1*."4;1'..'&4 4 g..''''.:';...'' ::...:'::;Z'''';'IPi.141?167i11414:filitl ..7g..4..'..:q,7141,?*;:),LVIZ•7';.'!..;.7..*:;?..i,^ '...;111'.441:8'::',::,iii.k. S:21..;!..,.1i.....1"i,..*.:.... .;;:r1.0'il.T!'i:.:Z4;;:.*'..■ift k.I.M.f..1,P,:45414..1.:.'....:7:?1::,„411...,;,44,, ; /7 ;.:V:1 i,V...7°:11:7.::i;04.6147r:S411*,.426.101:q:: :.;..:•'. 4:i::.C5",:',...,k17.....ci,..'l'‘..C.1,.? ;40114.,*.4‘;44.V...4,* ' ',.l 4/./ fr.r.'!......W:r..7;:';'n".;■:.1, .t.'r,...I.!'.,...,r I..;VT'I,W1:4 f....74.44 i:;?., ; i.if.Yf,trFre'''1• A .- .I/''::;.;:A ..4.-:.:,:.,,..,,..,..,,,...:•.; 3,=;- ff 7 fli;:zi.1?"-livq.47,-74-10,0go# • .— ....,:,„ : ': tli.P;*C::',Y,.:;r,Alte*;r;.9;:;T'e.i.;;;::.ld:fi:;ej:ggi2,4:i.t-;.y::t,+j • • ' ' .':.: ...' ..•-•••::;'.":.;.- igt,i,,..c.;i:::;:',':;;•....I.V.',1":■74A7.Sti' "44:t.:,:;.;;.......,,:e,tA8,40.04i,,,z7:21.,..A.pr,.:0:1,t,;:;•.1p,.izoii . . ...- ik".-: -il::■4.4A'''-ikir'IPOPZIVIP;';?:,'17:4P.thiiiici,i44.V.,:. .....A. _._ .,., •.. . 410,4,0;„4.7,41.1fotiviorpt.....iloct,._*01,:twtwru.,..4..,:g.4%,4e..,q4.;:.,,./... ....,„„,„. ...,...:„, .,„,..,.,„:.;a6.. ,5„„,..,1,,,,„; ..,,,„.....„..,„„..4,,4„.„4, ,•:'.;?,,V.S.-.:th...,P;.1.,?al,:.,,,••,,,•—•••,:kn•Yir'' • . 1•-• • •'• .:..4w,„;,•;-,.., ...iz,I.A•,•4,j(0'.pir•,..•:.f,!:.--.,:ird '..,-.:-:.,,:,-.;u4.,-1/4•...-5....,...q,T,'..r,".1.,.,tql...1.••'‘...:. ,-,0' inc.V.Ov.. ..., '. .,..........., .,. . • Figure 14. Entries to the duplex, 8CR950,facing southeast. -----, -.,—. , i'IFF4-: •:'• , . • . 771'1-..,..,'•,',•,'-'-...,:r ''.......;,,!, , .... •. ,„....p. ..,,.•.,.r ,--:... -,. . . ,y, -, .•- -.,...* ,..... . .,,,, ,,, .. ...:....„,, ,,, ••• . ., . .. • . , .,. .. .. ,,,' ••,p . ' ... ....,^•",-TP-7.4.71''.,,,,,,Ac.3.W:',..,,',',',,i''.'.' ;'..' -.1.1„ . • ' ii'.';'i',..,'4....i: . -,-''''''.:7.7":"•:.'"'.',...,,,, i.: ;i■i.:;*'::.,,,eif. .',4'.''.:...i.'4-x,.1 ..' ' 4 Yr.. ---,re.... „,......i.„,..,:„......,........„... ...,..„..„.....„,',..,-, -.„..z,::,::,,,I.',..,At:ilitiii,,10;•;4911,----5.4•. .,-:•.•::•.•:•-.•.:•:••-••e.„.... • - ••• •d•ylv...... - ... • . • ,,-,;••:;::::',,,• ••••--..., ...„..:.•:; -1;:;•/2•44.0.VW-4?0 At."0.• ••..d.tn:;:,...:-:,•:..,....-.-'.....",. • . .:- •••,.:,:• a ff, ..„,• • — ...e.'••-•..,..•;,;.:,.;;;,:soi6i,;;,•70.',.-',A*'.-r-lka...04;Y4,°...,, -1. '...h-...--laiiV.k.i1::T•i•:.•••'.. - .Y7' , ...5•: :.'.....\'•:f.,'A•1 •'0*.'.1-.AC.;, .41-•.-fra•tt,*11#•4-1--•'77=.-•=1-'-'"•"--% "•i'g'.-•,', ,...'• ',. '''4 ..'-' ...7 • --'',4.,•114•.,t.4,,,,,,0„•0. ,.., .f,.4,vg.,, .''‘.)N,.411.,... ',.`• '1,. ' ,.......,44'-t.„.t. ‘. ,.,",1? - ....-,1• .,.: ...16,7*•044:14 i,+4.,:''y '%'' ., OA. k.. •- , ._- . ;. • . ...•:,."..::.:C+'''.. .""• ::::Wie.„,..,,N,Tpitt#1.prieit'.,40'''e...-47::i..• ! •' '''''' •.'" ' • .; '.... :O."; ,i%'','i",:".-14t:1": ),I.Y4i4VAVt:;?,' Xi.e''r,v,;,-,0"4,14..., ,,:-..,....,...-.: • -.': ,.4.L.,,z'. ' --' • , ...:', 1•••.- • 0,0'.0.'„,‘,01';.?;,,e;i::`,:•-•':',eN,P,'.1.02.14';',',''.•:.'41,10t,',:t ' • — -. '; -''' ' 4.''' . Ns: •••• Oilet:;.4 ...'.•:, . ..*,'!,..■'',.,...Y;,Witl' ::,:,1 , ' . ..,.. h,„,.,.k).0.1„ u•,,,,, ,,A, -...--4-..--,-.-.....:..*:-.F.,•=22.5,.., JO ..,„„. „tt, ;;‘, vt,w4;cor • ..u Lk e. . •. ■Okalil ;;.•4' .- e"''i." ''' 'I' ,i,..;;;;Wo • 11:41v... ' • '' .11114: a..:• "4i•IN •%.:.:4'.t,Zt.'.. .....H!.',.•;'1.1,Ifi.4:-,..',0 .,-0,;;,, ,.141 • ....mgy.:. ?/-.4,17,'.../,:•?;,:,;:r1.4,113,:„Or fl'4 1-----_,........*.Al figgl 0,41.0,,, ,. ....,-„, . ,. . ,, ,,„.....i.:..-14.....„...-.;,,. .. ,,,,,4, ,,. r • •.....4,41. .. . ........ . . ..,, . ..._ V.Ial gl,r•fvkl,,.; . ' .. 10 :. i"- ,..... i:"'.. I:. .0t4,4 „..- ' " V, - k ;;;;;„IT,.,;yt= ,..,oxp :oor, .--, 4- •• •. ,A ..i""a•"%-i."''.5'ct l'''14Vid .7t-*7:77pq---:,.--.,-------,,,,,,,..,40.4e. '• ":.;:;::::,..2::: ,.... .-.1 . .A -. :) 104;43:1 .' FI 0 P•7'.44W-,4',,i4:43-:0:44..11,.ttV, .IVO 1 -7''',..s .".,-- • ', '. . 'he;.1::„...:::. r ,,,,•„;,..40.,•ic:,.0.,A:g4twA04...1.40.a..; •„,4i,tpc,;:eio,•sisq.3.1.1.,;&:.4,g4 ,,,,....,.... . . ,. 0,....'-:;...!:•••!...:1/ 1•%,. "*-1.•••, .it-4't 0.:';: ' .;'.l'.'...! ,_.. .,)••4•4:i1F e,.-z40,7i.t..,.140Weifeli'41..;,t,okR,•0:440-twpr..0,4.f.p. ':',.'''!;:';g.e'gkii, gigur4V4.,i,-,k,...40%nliigit:gig t,,A-.-•,-....,..:..-4 us i ..,..;,,„ .,.„., . . ., . •-:Votrribt_„„fORAMCPAVALi..V.WVIX:V!..SO4'''''' • .. . ,., ...• ' ' '(.75."''MY•Xf*P4PY:06.43/3V.6.;,..*.;;:titi'4.“"'"'" •• ••• . .7... . • .0.0:::":$14' t..1' .•i : 41,\'' Ar • ... . ..u••49,0?,,I,k,'' '''''',4''''''" • . " • .. :.. 44..•■•..41' ••••••14'.,./:7. ''''."-,0...":'r .,— • . A"t4„...oi.ilf . . . - . .;4' .•' ,;...-: ', , .•,,•3,.•i-"*.,.:4'A'•-"' • . . • - . 5:— „ , ,.-.; 4./oat.. .- •••• : 1."- • • •i:-..',--•-•-t• • • • .:., % .. • . ., . ...1:‘, . . . , . .. . , . , . :. • • 1 ,.... • , • Figure 15. Side entry to 8CR950,facing northeast: • . . ..._ 18 Packet Page -2460- • . • 1/13/2015 17.C. A 14 \; ll it'4 /egg •i �4,�' Y tl ti •!•11 Fddd ,14.4 1 Figure 16. View of the rear elevation of 8CR950, showing closet for hot water tank, rafter tails, and hurricane shutters, facing south-southwest. 8CR951 MarGood Cottage #4 8CR951 is located on the east side of MarGood near Pettit Drive (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by Rex and Ruby Johnson on site in the early 1950s (Ludlow and Weeks, personal communication 2006). 8CR951 has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, an asbestos shingle exterior, and a concrete-block pier foundation (Figure 17). Windows are two and four-light awning in metal sashes that appear to be replacements for original one-over-one, double hung wood sash windows. Two of the original windows remain in the kitchen (Figure 18). The main entry is an off-center jalousie door with a shed roof over a concrete porch with curved-pipe railings. There are metal vents in the gables, a single hurricane shutter over one window, concrete planters on either side of the front porch., and rafter tails on the east and west elevations. The kitchen and dining area often doubled as the bedroom in small cottages such as this one (Figure 19). 8CR951 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the – NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR951 was constructed as a component of a recreational facility serving the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing places to stay, places to park 19 Packet Page -2461- 1/13/2015 17.C. ^ trailers, entertainment, access to boats and water, and water and electricity. Collier County Parks &Recreation plans to adapt 8CR951 as a park shelter. •,;•,.4.4•:••.;k- ,<. Yl ` r t ! i_ !et:). 1 r r?,/` I Jr 1 4ttrhgi, Sd.s�'4 rr 5W e w ,A.f,r n s `�,� { ?Sp y a !4•s , >,yr !i. i t[s <.L .4 t,,441 i[t,,n f 1'0,Ve e tr f''n, Ji 1?, t;j4 1,,, , 3 ) < i' '5.,.;:'g•-',:;*. I ' 'G 1v3J,., y Y ti .•.,,:',6t,�IT p,;'h�t' L:i".107" ,4»,'tf ( r ;!x`" ,r t', `•a4-',''.'"•.'"•"'•••••••'`''''''1-( rrs'-'1. h�(C in-b ''�'...° 4YPy• �<k. ��wC,1 ix µ3 fyy,y G Y�i,. (( 7 -Z t i „y. r �w < � Y * 1 r 7r ;rl55 �. {(q 6. x' tig tt''�� LriZ' h: `0, r 4" t v x ^... vt+f 15 n d'4�1' I 4,41.6At x'^41 a l , ! r � �tf'� riS 1 c> ;f.r SH'�vs,fitr<S,.-s'!"''sit ,�;, ^�s 1 wid[ y�< ' G/' < rs�<t[`�1M� ,F3rf f }z dry OO�'1 r gl ^!.' t :?.* iw. 1; r� 1.11'k/>.�+.Q U "'Sf'��//h� s,t' ,S .3f 1 f1`''{': 'r' „.,,,k-, a: +x: �w Oyu 4.,V,V3'+� r hi fIj —Ai, r tad r!'))aK # •,, t ix , q*i�jtl lftD90;. lie $ .lam ,�r�k��4 v ? t4 k '4 '''''''---'-'''''''''''''"'"-"I' Al K ''z� { ,L :19'y d j dy .� < a ,} 4p.f _ y G. .iw h r�x d .,A 1)2,- ,T M 7 1rf `9,0= • i' i F s• AW 1V ,ltd'4 r ',441'; s �Ys�{ L , .._.: ;a 3 I 'j ' vvg t jS'€}„,:�f;k„�., yn 'Y.,, .�--.4',;rY4 i a r.,ri^. :""Gra 'T : 4x4'__ <St. a tr .' H 9 Figure 17. Façade of MarGood Cottage#4, 8CR951,showing asbestos shingles,concrete planters, and replacement awning windows, facing south. ..."..4.-,-= ... ,fix w: %h„c 1. t .t,. 4,4� y,sue,R■f ql, t v C y ,•ei • �∎'z••.i^A.,r11 . �a`t aP t xl r 9 01,:y ?'f S,,a,PRA 7 ;. X'4'3 y < J , "GAY ---":111P' r 1 Yi'}csb0,41 rsr,`"F`'9•yi.” f ., [ 'ah{ J'ty`E.g.t"r 5tr fr 1" 7-.ii r � ' ,' Y �4s C l » r , - F 'x �er • y t-F.--,-...,---i_:,, Six-.'fit 1v` .' m""�try” 1 • " tr?, vim "{9• ,a,r . '' �;,y r a.....-« , ,< ,1. r.., Tr t .r'r at-�^"`.,- .ter e r r v. , '3" ''.;1';''' rrh` r.,Ja:r r.;.,,,'",,;,,,,,.: 4 ', .'re N., f.: 1t" ,G.Q "C?.+"rtty;_ s,. .-,i,,,',....,4,..:, yn i''e .F p` i terse`' f ..e. r :n r 5X3. ., "r_PiF.re.3 a na t v-T 4` S"+ ,,-. s47. s; .?.4 `` t._,.i•._. L .s...,1.r�_,.4:7,1_...x. ri. .:._.-,: iw'. zza,,'t.,•r E.A..�'x -.;',..F.y..-: +".a.l .r',, 5__.....f._ .._._.. 20 Packet Page-2462- 1/13/2015 17.C. Figure 18. West elevation of 8CR951, showing replacement and original windows, concrete-block piers,. and metal roof,facing east-southeast. ..M1 )Jr ._1 n #k, . ry t.xr r if{x17:1 i; z's?M?'I +J>t 1 f4 'y`}`�t iA)"xj 47 !C3 l� t y.� �i•{({ /�y f,Y �jy,�,1`y`��,,;� 1� �� {`� Fnr 3�ir 1 'Iir -^ S"swnY� . ) 1ll S f' YC , X44,/.fr A-'YJ ai'G"3:.Y *,.,,�(,,rN��SY i 1' I f ...:.v'hi! J) r'1� 'kuN J . 7 . ;K ,. � f }y:c^ntr l t4.' d hk , ..,q u l.t. t v , s cri x+• 1 l yr x;7,w.::ftik):::�.. o^� �� ' 'C 1 t�r,t 5 r �xt� 9 t'-.e'�S'n 7 Y t.F w �� '�'i g.q-. �) �� -+v x Fity •A u• i3'" ,tie r� et t` A ".' r ry � 7 AF 1' f�r ��) { J„�� „�,!„�,.�� A"J�i" r 4 r , •'t</ � ,+,)�1�j�5' t, ,. y7 Pf 7 tv�• 1 .,,',,,,,,0 it M +`,�',4 k ^42 ! S 1aa, .p"i^��,r.. .m Li--v'3 r r,.2 a.:f , 1t' ;pp-�9'r5, ;-r'Yl•�'"'�i'�I'p 44 r t, ,4,`s Mrs •41:;,, tia,eml. +.'1^RF�1 } _ ' "`�f�;+h axx # r F •A { 41}r 'fi t{ {i4 s ; °C ,, 1 �ht `� t Y Q< 7 u . 7r.�r cs %,$,,,,d)J a% J ti.,W,,i '7.Ore. ` rt �_xi.l~m`•rL ... ,.at-'6'; ✓ ,exA v .d ' 3`k7+"c'Yr . ge;,.a,,t ,- ,rvi i,_C , �7��'r� , ' te 4 J4714 I57-14.-,:b._ F, +$ , .„.Afi tip e ri.4-, 4 i. :r 3� ', .§; :Vati fa�TR'i J v+ 't!�'{{ i4 r Y4' s; T� . , ` rJ`x ifl 4 A {f 14;1(.1: 4+?''1,Psge+4y.W, S �I >rra d r j1 r' _r,•T"'r < ..ftis= k �"f4'SK� ,+d'.'�) w�p�3d5`1`,_ '£ r�. h'"�'`��v f, 1. P�.'"5i '_r+.°. t'T i�' 4d c t4s',, .""+..-•'.F;. X '�',L� 7. n�5t"*',it i� 4, r� rf 40,,,,,°' , on5,F t-i x *I x 5 ,I,T�, t •��5 .. ,.w r f t ST b 7?��re j� r $j �r Y'p ` 1. )t,�,ifi��til 1vL ..n^ .•^' J�i�LI t ,� A �� y fc f f�!1 ar `�6u' S.t t h K1�r � . 4 k 17, t,:f� .,aor' w+�. can It/r 's'4 v— r yr n�dx�N'taar�y rfoa g� , p'�IXr 7 NA t rid J° r i a F 'lF�,�r• •rn.r..5 IG" A 'tz � br{i}ef�f ,w 4 T ...:1.7::::::--'1:-.. ve '� Figure 19. The kitchen/dining/bedroom area of 8CR951, Cottage#4,facing southwest. -- 8CR952 MarGood Cottage #5 8CR951 is located on the east side of MarGood near Pettit Drive (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by Rex and Ruby Johnson on site in the early 1950s (Ludlow and Weeks, personal communication 2006). The cottage has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, an asbestos shingle exterior, and a concrete-block pier foundation (Figure - 21). Windows are two-light awning in metal sashes that may be replacements for earlier windows. The main entry is a centered jalousie door with a shed roof over a concrete porch with curved-pipe railings (Figure 20). There are metal vents in the gables, a single hurricane shutter over one window, concrete planters on either side of the front porch, and rafter tails on the east and west elevations. A hot-water tank is located in an exterior closet on the west elevation. 8CR952 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR952 was constructed as a component of a recreational facility serving the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and ,.---, -- 21 Packet Page -2463- 1/13/2015 17.C. . . ....... water, and water and electricity. Collier County Parks & Recreation plans to adapt 8CR952 as a . park shelter. .r;Np., ., .:,...? . .,:,, ..,,.. ,.: ..,... , . .. ..:,.. .. . .. , , ,.. , .. .:,,,,..!;,,;; -.5.45.::,,,::f..f.:Fros," .,,,-,::.. ••1 1,...,••,. •-;..“,. •, , ., t.t.1,•:•.',..' '. n.,..' ,.,• ,„. :' ',.....r-..,;;;,,,:o1,•Wir:7;.,.,1;$1.A/ty t..`,.;,'"..,a,e,,,re•ki....1.:,:,...4.4'..,',OW.,,F.•:.;.':„'•v'•,,•.i.,..,`..;.■ . '',W,,',444:•Wz+Vi.F. i,':>',,TV•;•.:',.;;;:. rs'..!,: ,%. :--." '. ' S'■...‘'‘..:if, •;•,..;.":,:':;: 1 •,,;',1*:■?: tik.;:$444.,‘;(4.,4,,Z Aigiiit:AbA"••:-.24A;i;•-1;•.;:;i.:Z.: •;01`....q;.::;:-'::.!,'•'.7;).• .../.-•';‘,":`,.11';':1:54:::::.:;3'.Z;,''''.--;•::1•;,.:•''... .Z.i':4!:,t.T...'150„1"frelitAtfil,' .. P.1.41491441.1:11.1V;;-•'4: :::;;'4i,40 :ii.T./2: ' q:?1;43PfilAkiritk441i-*Wg.p.•"?'-, 0, ...„1,,,,,,v,,,,c,,..A„,,,,..:n.,...Ay....;:i„:41:74.:.,,,:•:::,,,,,,,...„: •- -...,,....„t„.1„.„,,,.../.:„.,,,,,,o,.,,,,,709.1., 6.1.*,,-00...,,,,,A,.....• ,- -40,41446.4..,,-.4.4,,;,..1.,..r..z.2,7,7:,,v;-.,,,....N.:,;.;rop•-- --•••• • • 4, 4.4,4i..f,m,,4,-,A..4,7.,„ ,,,,....,„ r,. ,1110,,,T044.4.,,,;;;,..1:;; ..1,-. -..;;•,,,,,....,4.1.4...-4, ,s.-y.f.f,R.?. :• . 2..t. • .,....v..tb.s,..41tdow,,,sn.l.:...,. . .A.g.:',.,. •.'f." ' •, kt,'i: r 0 'r'74 — •).14' '`'-'' l'-'le-'W.A.A.Z " ' 4 . 14t' ') 4.,.;„ i, '''44'.1".:'$,S;ri•:.,',17t:: :'-.1r,•:.-1.„:„xte.4.,,:6:1,i70,1.e.,A14,1:1::!::::;,)' :„ 10,40.0.- „-,--,....,....,-;,..,!1„.......".,,,,,, IV'0.";91, : te,t■• - A, `, ,i,z. ,r,, 7..,( .. ... N.-,■`i.' . "''''."..9ggr..i'ig^it •051' '..C:141,W.% V.' ..■• : .rift.. ...--,4 -'..,..••. ••• ., ...- .t...,,,r...nr..../.,,,—....i.c,„ ,. q ,,,c,',.., , VA.tilitrr'+'.1".1., „....f. - Igildro-rri.rs'm...••znaw r ,c#10tAn. . _ 2.F.ZAtEA,41, . • .• 1.1,.7•PW• . , I ipmfol 1 i.ei #31 4 __Ai ... ...,„: .. ... . ...,:,, ••,::. itr'..I -:, . F, ..;.`,';'',11 1"h, li:It .11..... 1F44...v.••/,..#.1 ...t-rt..X,,.. •,, ' ,-., ''A•:'SV •#'4.. , tAki•44.".114'.••■.ii•?'•,-‘11 4,(71 4 lif•Nit, '4,,y1:20Vt.,•:,, •t•;;;;5k....ltd • A ..• --,', ' .. ,, ...t../„,„1_,.,.,1, , , ,,,,,,,,,•,,,,i4yr,.., ■,4 ,,' ..,••'-',,,,. '" ;• -‘,• ,;": , . .. tl•:,tb,..4V,'.1,4•WW,e_life : Vinliiin?.',1 WIgt.;i4,01,7.piii4t.',P'tVi 1Z(.14' .t.,..z,;••• --,.. ,•,;•,z .,,,v41.:. 'argavi,:r.,„ ' ••. , ' ./.,ik% "' 4+ ••It.1... ...417*',:a."S..41‘,'''1....41e-IRfev ,. ....''../'''".911.:':::311---'8e1461 '); • '•,•.,,%,•-',...-','• A,t,','", ''..i ,4,4..4Y,' i.. ,t-,..,j."4.1:',F+iglz,„.„,"•:., • ''',..•.;•:•-.--,;.....,t',„ry• ,,,• „,.. , ..:.•::.4`.dip?!1,i.••.,..... , a...;•- ....,,,,,,,, ft.„,...,44,,,,„..,.,,,, I., ..z, ._,_„„,;--;, -.:.,..,-.... • ‘": ..d .;•••,'s N'..=:. •, ,. s ', !.''.trf••i#.#:,'....,•:‘,#/".'"*! ' . ' • . ..• ...4.40,44; - #''''''S'' '• •#,'•:.i. '#'''''... M.W••#.•V.....1,•'•44.01.% ••••■••.;:,-;'''••• -•-••:.7..-.•..'„,-.-:•e.,-,,.--•-,4,„/... '''794 — •• •,, •.-' '.1'' ....:'.'•%'1 V"'A41,1'..''').:;,, '.-..:IR. .:--.....••4-;:e.t, :1 •:•-• ••' •' . '''•t''.g::' .•:.,-.• .14 ....0.4:..:-•....4t.:...4:::::ar,:t.'1:1"-r- ,--•> •;'•• .C.,..:"r•,,.:41.;:::•••‘; r;,,,I,....:, ■.,...';'. '' ..;.-.,.;;;;1).',",;',,.....,,....,'.„,"...',.:,..s. ." ..,..,,:, ,, ' . .... ,--:'. .•.,. .."..70,.,14.;.1.,,.....,: : 2.:*,...;.!•:4.4;l':..;40,:•••• — • ,-.,..-.:r.::•:'.'::,; ! ''''' • .'. ••;,..; t,.',.A .•-,..- - - ,--:-.. ...:.. • , . .. • . ...•,:•••.. .;....,..;.1,.,... --........ ,•..::•':,..••...•• . ..4.,,, •,. . ,,.....,0.-,......,-.;.....!....,...- •...;Y a,..••..,..,.'.„.,,,...,.'1...:...•t.•....,-.:,*,..V,.t..,.,..,'..,...1,„,-.1 / -• ' , 17.....";•:•41:'''''''.•,,,•••"'•0•41.^:''••■•'.''''' Figure 20. View of MarGood Cottage#5,showing awning windows, asbestos shingles, and concrete planters beside porch, facing south. , IpArn -;'';74)* Wfl'',???•;,?):;;7i1,r5rn'f,Y7.*iwM; n ,,,t s A14..i'nn, le.','.';' 1,.: '';',i''.•`A",td;"•;`,/•■••`,' ■r.i,,:--',,-,::elti -M,,IMP4,04--f':r ..:;,..t.k-,.. 't.s.;,‘•; .41."-•,:-., Ir•-....;',,,•••,;,,,vA- _ -- ' ■it.--•,..44•PrOet.5,44A h: •...........!t' 4.,.s....." ''.;.:.e., •, t„., :,-,,,, ,•fil.;,..,.c,•,,Ir,„, ',..‘";M:,"7"0.a..''';4';•"- '''•:••'t.• :It i.'.; . . ' . ' , ;4'.7;0•A ' . ','A'''''4'2 t','•`1d .' ' 4.1.f.., ..21... , ,.' -, ,::,,,.......,.;:r.■::',,,.r.'•, 4.'..;)+ -k.•..:1,....,,,;., ,,,.... -.1"'t• • . `;'.74;.::`,,k,;,,st...; *--;.' '..'':'-.:••:•":44,1c.g., n '-1 4 ' 4 •••'•r',:..-•:'''',.-• •4:::iii•;'..",4 -, ';'-...; •••,;•'s .•-.1`..''''..• ---4`.f. ;4.*4,„4;€„*.,:l':4:.. • •,•...s 7...,..,...;•.-- ., ... .-•.......:„...,..-..„,..0-..- ....R.!, ...",.,;.4„...,?,..,. ...:.•,- A. .... •.4•,• ,:;#.•,5,1"''''' - • .'::1,:a.',42V"... :•,:,..,.' '''''',44.4•14.•\,,,. •■••'''.'•. ';,....;:•:•,9:49•A....."...Z.11:1#:',.d...',;::,:l'_.1 •.P4.17,6•:,.. MIV.„..4.0.C''';.• .,,#-.4.;•4•A'--. • '''.1".1::'4'4••••:■'.'"•#•'W■1474#$:•.04,4.4K,II.,..■•,..; ,. .. .....7,.,ZO"' ...• .,..,•••,•157.as'A.',‘'O';':'''''.1j.:.:P1974r IV:M4#41`.1,!..:4,°:: ...'•I.••'•:,•:,,ki.,., , •..-;,..4iiht ., •••,. ' P.4,-",.. _,,'.'..,,,,,,,,'11.1 • - , ,..."..".,t,, .4:,,.'," ip.,'>.I0.,,,,....1,i;,,I,14.,,•01,-. 1,,,.1.4,21.,. ,' ' 44#1.,.44k ' • -,••••'' .-deg •:47#1WA,P11.1.°'' . ,.-•,•4.7,. ...t#IM,:0,110*''''... •:,rti■,..MAIII,,Igge'",e,k,/,1,4,,if.',%.1.... ,,'1•,‘•.•,640.•,`/i . "" :,..a.o.t.: ''.#•••t4Crr''",••' keeVilki,11, •!;.SW 4'1.40.i.*Vt",,'07.•.ti.19,"}),e,,,NY,Q,54,,'•,?,,,,,,,,,,.'. !,4-;,7„1"."-lPf);.',-,t-v;,;,•.' •,:'-.• ' '14..4,;:rAtItitiVirtAteo:''',.;.':53.....:„.-:.,1;F:,27-4.)46i7ijo;Wker-1,17-f ifeitiltgyftqr,,,-.'.' •-'''''.. - '•••.:...:. ' :.,,,:1;,4:,,,,,.•••• ,453,i,„,,,f•,4,4,10.,,,A,Ilitatevip;:,1,k..131.4-44,4----------.Ii,.,64if.,;),,,Rnr.... .„--,..0.,glogi-v",t,17.44,141411,-)tv.4•tkfitalvklf:: "'',, 'i,-,- '014:41.W41.44$11:i'4.41.gde"q . •"':itaii:';61 fle;ifirOIZA:$4414xellq -'•7.„...,.; ; -,)!ZoZ, ;pi";" , - • '''',,A.'w4V.$18.1,,fibirtti.,5,144 ',••• , 41\.,: -'-')"- \ , N ,',1•111i.Are..79g):***WedtPliEt . . , i,.,„,74;.,..„.0i-1,71.2,4,1...e•-,614 '',"ikrort,i,ii,10*-14:?„,W;,;;;,.)54, 1.1),W*. - - ..„,ti,mA.„,;,i)„..!i,.;-•41.2,1,,,,V,,,N . 12,'` ' V.q. R4440,0 k-4„.;)."' '-'. . ' -*VA lie",',,V.i ftltalikyln%1) • ''''''.$1.C`‘."7 ..7.,-,"•-•: 7M4r,*.if&-PA.4jklii.4"1"" • '''''''"Z"::•'"' :. * --A7-41.40 Yr.17.V411:•gair,41't. i:. . ':rt.-V.i.••'''••1.1t•AMr-iP4'.1•A'AA'AX,.,tet:(444 4 -:.:.....•);:k(41•47:7-......t1.,:=41.;:-tOu'll'gAil*API..60 '.,"-.1:-: ;.• ,...41:).:-.;•-...-cE:T.;:*4,„,f,- vefogv.-107-. .q.,,q,wiwk*:,;..w...4zt,.?;41.4.atz.4-.1•!..::...6&,,,..*",.:,.,. ;.-..1.vy,=..„• : '4.....,...:,:,. _ ., 1.,.?..,g.,;.;:mi.......A,•:f4,-,,..5art,1„.f,..^.-,,h,/,&,t4F1,49,,,444,.,,nf,..4,4;,1,44400,sliw.,34-,•4•Jolgg4,04.1111100.t.c,•:, •,:.::.,.;•;. ••,4;.•••:%;2.......71,...:.(,.:1:•.L.:7:''z.:,..,0,24.,-:,,4.-4...,,,14,4,41-•,•wa...ger041,4,1,417,040:015A91.4.kisrt.i•ipk,004,,..•r, 34,41,4‘0,40:%•:::$N.;>:,•.:,.;..1 A i •3,:gr.,4•••4,•;‘,5a‘e.,.:c,••,:;2.,8>T•44::.;•....m,±01R.:,fit,5;‘8.41,•17;44,44•;(0•141,1.,x,',:ct.:Aile"0.6.004,..svvik 4.15..,q14,*,... ..N42$1•/..),.•Ah,:•%.•::.:.• •.4., 1--,,..4...,,;:,-,,.:...4.„'..:-•4•...«-..r-.hi':-..,-.44Y,.1,0-0-'4 d'Ark.e-ni,;•';:146:41,VA-401.h.4.4 c0••,;4;14•2410a0 ',..V.*P".1.*;••Is'"'"\'..ss.'•'Z I'' ''',1-‘::-.'i s.....:'.•:•:::.,....2 v;;Q:',.',..;.:-?::?....re,.:•::!-:,0:1-::19-1 r.v..., •,...:WW-'44.4117,0r,1...,i,59"4ta,,-,,,",..rit3 ..../;,-,:.....•...m A N,-;!,-;-,..., "'J.'', .i. ' ';''-',-''.','::-,:••:.:'...•._:,..2112:.e.'..'..,.:4•".. ::•flgal..;. :31;?:P.Ct01.;A.1*-4,0:V%tki-5sR4M.Pl'IMub ''''`"-'-'''''''''s''' ' ''' ; _...,,,,.::::-,-,.... ..,.: . .., -.;.-,..',,•,;,....:7,;.,''..e-, •1:...4-.'A,FI'S.,:::` ,::::,-,10.:§4i,14.14.1.40A,t4"t'IllptilfiliRb 4 ..!..;:,,.:....., . , -.._....... -:---,....... . , ._ ..........-....,,..,:.,..,:.......s......:..:::.,k-s.......:,-,-----Z z:--•1:V.4116'1-104ZNIAlar-f`' '' '17r .. •-:,- ,r ' ,": ' ,I...' -. ---•„; ),:.- ---.• ..,• ..-..;11:•;k1.0', ' r,-,..1,07 -," _,-) , ",--:::x':'4.-.7"..*„:,:vNt„- , • , ...:„ ' . •-,:•::4-4.:t-i-.k,..-„,...f,„4,..,;,-.....„.:7„;;.„:-.1.,,,.„.2...-....,a_4.47.„:„:;;.; ,,,„,„,, ,,,_,,,,..... ,,,...„. „ . ,,,, .,g„.i. • ,. ;‘,',T.I.,.:.-e,..,;.-v..,;.-..,..4....,,f-4m0501, .;=:set,,, , ••-1.-...,' ,. .1::,:;,„„,,•::;97-A,,,,,q,,,,,„„!..t , --,---„,...,.1, FA.-7.,.., „04,14!k ..14'''1•#rk•-••••',"4.#44.43tql.c.46,14,..#4.'Z.,,•40..kAW'r?,`'1: -.,•••i•W''''-4111,..i#10'.7..0.1.W.r'7'r 41t. • 1. •:' ''% ' --'rt.-4 '5 t,•11•te,•j.•`;;..,..;;;.-4r....4',1...4*':$7.1tit.•.k.• - ki:70.1.0..,,..r.-;,..,Atz.t . •,,,...-q)s.....„.g-,‘„:::,..;...,-,...n-,,,;;,,,pe._4..,,,?.;...wt...,,F.,n... •:. .... ,......-, ., .I . 4..- '• ..— , ,.e:','..'..:„.,.-44...i; 'fiA,:-lk."1,42.*.T,'4i,,..'4%•,.'.5‘-lryi:-,-;:-..'),,,,,,, ,,,44.gotit vo*Ar,4'..,,*,,,.., '4'•,...,'..-.;‘, '.-1.N$ •::•.;.q,....‘,_ ..-,'L',1•:..1 '„.4.194•4;3•1510.14. 4.,4" ,4",pit,-4;:i.-•,,,•:_'.0..,4."-...'•,-•se.-- ..1.„41' --tb.)-•:„,,:•,: i .;..,„ ,,.4,7'..:,..><4..,„.-..,,.•2 0,,,,,,, :1:'••••-..--.7.., ..,...41.-tr1/40, ti•144,3:4-0,-Ai'.,_.,-...,or..,,,,,,....,.,.'4'.'t..-•\.,... 1,4,y,-•'.'1.41:•:414.":";.+.7 1,24-ki4:,(41111Aitves.–ip',..a.:" '4,4*.,k-QmtK:iel. Lk,-).--:k.,...,1,ii.ti..... 't)1.,...c.: --iiK, ::?-ro...-2,... -, -- ••:;:h:::..a'.1:toz.444,444.-,... 1,;41,....e...4.--....‘,.., Figure 21. South elevation of 8CR952, with view of pier foundation,facing north. -- 22 Packet Page -2464- 1/13/2015 17.C. 8CR953 MarGood Cottage #6 8CR953 is located on the east side of MarGood between Pettit Drive and Goodland Harbour (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by Rex and Ruby Johnson on site in the late 1940s and was their first home (Ludlow, personal communication 2006). Later, 8CR953 became the "cat house" for Ruby's cats. Ruby then moved into Cottage #7 (8CR954) and Rex stayed in the theater building. 8CR953 has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, clapboard and asbestos shingles on the exterior, and a concrete-block pier foundation. Windows are two-light awning in metal sashes. Originally similar in plan to MarGood Cottages #4 and #5, 8CR953 has been altered with the addition of a full-length sun- porch along the northeast elevation and a garage and storage shed on the northwest end (Figure 22). The jalousie door into the sun-porch is now the main entry. In front of the sun-porch is a concrete porch with three steps and curved-pipe railings. The southwest elevation has both clapboard and asbestos shingles on its exterior (Figure 23); and a wooden gable vent remains above the original main entry on the southeast elevation. The opposing gable is hidden by an'air-. conditioning unit. Hurricane shutters cover several windows, concrete planters are on either side of the front porch, and rafter tails are visible on southwest and northeast elevations. The walls,. ceilings, and floors in this cottage have been modernized (Figure 24). 8CR953 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR953 was constructed as a component of a recreational facility serving the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the -- Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing . places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and water, and water and electricity. 23 Packet Page -2465- 1/13/2015 17.C.v.'-1' .vim >'teF PR .`�,...m 1 hH W 7 yC,I.1ka''S*">ii4-e•�",,,,'t c FP ) \-,E7''�yy�Es ,,,��yyy��,y, t„,,,o,',15..',.r'Y;;Atii .P.I dt, `:'� ..,...,4,..” 'ar{ l rt t 7'.x 11 t r\.i+t A •• T'g 1••'_r Y 1.:1,r' ti rjCT`..."Yi • , W., s.4i t'0I'OPN y. 'i'+\`c g4Pi''��d l'e.t 4{ - 't. a i ,' Li., jNu; l'a4 \ 1 s� iii-,t. lt` 'g-ile fih \C x+l }., .,•}4 t91,1 ,;,f)'t; t:i:.,i /rt ;i. .,..,.''.a::4;''.7.,k' ,. �t r ' t•4/041444p,..„•:',,,,, 1f r 1).4,- t �t w '1 TM ti p-=r•. `l -.. /R 1 .-T. •• \ .` ' ,N 1 t { - ;,� ,!‹ . ! . . ,.'4•,,,,,f.6•1 ..'....:•:::: x P t \ I O'i 4 5 j ' N Il . • .d • : - ' -_. ' µ' i --1 1 r hr f ; / a7 e m : il ,„„) , s 4 r ..: -".-.•.:,.. -, ••• '..s'. . r'•:...• ? . 6'i� d- ' •• y R ei ; k/ \ 1ei,;:w 3rjti , r a • Figure 22. The sun-porch, garage, and storage shed additions to 8CR953, and the central air- conditioning unit on the roof, facing southwest. r1!!s .,'k'+> ti,+ ..t.'- 1 . f. 4t -' M SC si r" i fa y "' A'4J "53 YH fit v \ w Lr. ? ,,,v.,,,,,...: '. 'M'7 • 1 4^ .5 .: ," n\, 4 .i ce n�F•'r` rl y .. .e'i, • l xas •14.9 -,..-''''-';'&4':'-7.1,',' i µ f,,e ;� y!�•t♦ ';:0,,!:t j t.�F\ r \ srC n,,I ',;,:.q. i�'�Ka.X,G..4 !ti ti ii to .�j4 ✓,+ s •. ;� t�� '��a' l �js•"'° t• r W —,,,e >Y..4u w 1. tr O C4 f tsi 4 # '11 A Hir 7 x A669 ABBY 4 ;V641 ,FR' Tsr a- t ip' C k'`" r! i N z 7 !P 59 t r '$� 0 J i 5 a h.• At., ``., C.141-,54.... �xt_tr6 n f. 'ate+ s,r,.- affi r ,Cta L-•z'xr+�J'�.� Sr(t' .f r� 3 r.�.:"'Y2"a�'� c�+z f F c'v� • {s r.. . sv�iCi�yGSII/+n«n a h 7 s a :lW44-41,P,41 '), o wns�A:�T�'sX�'!^^ms1t�, 4 1,1 of r' 14.111 {t 4, ° if f.c ;1 t i£t 44't n:Avow 1 r-.1. -tsw . gn a i ..... r f ,,.• r.� t ''r�7P.rht \ R� t A'd... °l. L ., �` e r�r ` Ctw}a era '-'� � ,, .' -,,.,i., ,,.... .m`DYVh p,, 7 ' '- F,:. 'f a..fir/f`', °j:'z'.v�:51 #G.''�•'7"'I a'� s N G X ter '2'sy' ,';e. Figure 23. The southwest elevation of 8CR953, with view of the original orientation of the cottage to the — southeast, asbestos shingles overlapping the original clapboard, and replacement awning windows, facing northeast. - 24 Packet Page -2466- 1/131201517.C. rii,,, a } . ,.„�y i ,4/ ��( 0�"�t S yLL � "7 � t1aJ } ,J-,ii.,, i r o s v ,,,t 444 ,t ,t priiP � $ �SX A� � r 9 �t 3 o 5 t, —, ! t ; } r w 1a� ;, Fk �f Y ° w . r'tm , ��' ` YF�sy4 ry�fNt AGY L r c. c, 0;etr:02-0^ " $o f-4:4kt I Y J Yx N i r . ; r,Jau . t,l 4N a ' � t S ,• '. ,., io. r i! u 1 c 4 1 •° ,`i i _ tJYd •t t�.t. G. j.r J r. tyf„ ? ,} u aj T . h41( - 1-55, i l 4'1 :'i°.� Rf r r�,t C C (t}k N Irt.,4,, 1 r- H'' ,..41,:.44 J f7ty r:fJI;',,,, ,y}� kma4� fi , y � 4A 1 V.1 ,k X° _ 4,4 ii : tx U �7 /1? . l ';:- t e ` �4Nh-t % .-1 r � s ^"t r r - �r � } l • f Td v r t �F ( `' S l� J 'i t x M ,a , Figure 24. Interior view of Cottage#6 showing remodeled bedroom and closet area,facing east- southeast. 8CR954 MarGood Cottage#7 8CR954 is located on the east side of MarGood between Pettit Drive and Goodland Harbour with an address of 325 Pettit Drive (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by Rex and Ruby Johnson on site in the early 1950s (Ludlow, personal communication 2006). Ruby Johnson moved into this cottage in the 1960s. The cottage has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, asbestos shingles on the exterior, and a concrete- --_- block pier foundation. Windows are two-light awning in metal sashes. Similar in plan to MarGood Cottages #4 and #5, the main entry is on the northeast elevation in front of a carport over a concrete driveway (Figure 25). The doors on this cottage, however, are not jalousie but are wood with two lights in the top portion. In front of the main entry is a concrete porch with three steps and curved-pipe railings. Metal vents are in the gables, hurricane shutters cover several windows, concrete planters are on either side of the front porch, and rafter tails are -- visible on the southeast and northwest elevations (Figure 26). Several cottages in MarGood had some custom interior remodeling done, such as the paneling in these rooms (Figure 27). 8CR954 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR954 was constructed as a component of a recreational facility serving the needs of an emerging Florida tourism'that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and ..... water, and water and electricity. __ 25 Packet Page -2467- 1/13/2015 17.C. . ,... • . • • ..__ ,1::•;•..t....‘„:... . ..1,.... ,:.- .„..,?... •••••.:1,.. . rozimintik,0,..„.•, • :•••,...„....-....,„. ...-...,..„, ....,, ,....,, .. ..• ,,,, ow .0' Itytelt-„,,,4 ..p„...,,,,,,,...,,,...,,,,,,,•.., •...,,,-......••.,,,,c•.., ••,1„.. 1 ,Or''1'4 4:>.`''4?"'.",' .'!‘r.,:L•10,,,.."..10, '4•". 'AiitcW,...erl. ..V.i,,..1•444.:,04.7;A:•44.1V 'r t".. ;' 4, ' •"",'A' 'tr(L. ..,:s1TA ?,■...'4N,1."1,::•■•• '-■•1:05lielii,t 4r•rhf :_'Ar CrOVe,Sftilige•Arrine.lee. . - ,..,'.1"..,.,,,,...r..• 1,....tr- ',.• . (4.5-;,:.::...A--v4/444,R;h, •',0.-rli:r....it FIF r.:,,,`.',1,i ,.ell,Pliftrir.:,--'• .....- .."- -: • -7- ..... • ,,,:,.,5;,-.:•,•os.,„,.,,,,v .J.,,,r tp-4,•kr ,p-.p. .. ...,..414. •-. ,,,,— - - . ;,c7R,it,,,pi,o•v-,..ka,.0,7..,ovv.,c, 11 iigttr,::, 0;:.,f1,t'.1, t' ', .. , ...",. .'-... ''..'"-'1-•,:;$`- 114A4.1,11r. ,1.104.406" 'v 40:4041,,:.c9i -It, .4.,,,,,,' 04.4.4,-..•• .,' „ .....-..,...-fr- „,,oit.1;‘,..0,,,„,,A.,..,,,.;)„,..*...v.,,,,,.4 us,,:,:,,,....,•4iith.gry,,piti,„ ,,....,-4,4.,•,,.-.41.1V0.4'.'r,•,;::'',:-.6' •-••.".••E::*”- Vii:%...V,:4"4"i;t■IA.,1:.',41•?..01kittl'•,.*tails'AzI,trAstgpkeityi■ A,-,,v-t!,:zyc,,,::?;,... s.1 ,.,. .,_;,,..,- ',',...%;•.•''':--gli.• •,Pt 4;'';,14,•i.:.,p-::,":-,',110.'•!•,71"4 -3,4•4'',-90. 1.,;`41t■IN'-:-'''-'' '-'4,-.,:41. -'. :ta'-:... •-• • •j•••.?,-;11,,`‘,1,:rif:..t...-1„4,•:`..1,7,-,,.:,'2'1tc143,4:1•?..,,,71,p,,•,...,,t,-1,5,4,;A:.•-• ...,.t.,,..„ -,,,,---;- . . ,....._ .. ..-.7'--,„7,,iLl..-•... ',..i,',•,.-...,..(i,.•!A?'..,,;;,`!,,,'...-....c;,,:.,,-,,:,-,'.•,.,:•:...-_.•.;--,.,-' -,-;: ... • ; ... • • .••:•••i L'''.'-. '''''..".••• ••••':-.:i:.•••'::::.:••••••,..1..•-'-- -• ,„.. P'''''' ,s-':i- . rs!..c1.01:3•11. • •. . ...', : •.-••1- '• -AN k -‘,,. Pr i,„ f .v.7.,-..e, -. , •,i.-4 4 , . • , . ,- t(,.,,, • ,,,,, „,, •..., e. . • . •.• •' ',...:••• -•,,,..i.,',..ill ,i, .. •. ..1 ,,,,,:,.• e. 6., A li ' • '•• ,..... 1 . ' .1::*'..!' ...:;,:. 4''.,',i,-;;fg.:-::',....,,,i- ...,.;.17 • ' p 1,:-..,.. . . - : • : . 1 •':::::';‘ •:•---,:••;c:is•-•,-ii;if.‘,. .•;,-,!,2,,...;•-•:.:-.:•• •••!..-,..'. 1. '., ,, .,-,.;, ..,. . • P ,4 :A - • ,;•.;‘,..kiiiityl:.?:,t,,4!.:Olt,. -1, ...•:..„:..t:•.. '....„'.....:.• ..:. . . .. • • ' • J4,1,1 i , i , ,-.•• • . . I . •-t 7..;•.,;;P: .• • : - 4_,.7t.•,,,,,.; :.-4.•.- ...,....--:,. .::::::::.•........ ...-'. i 1 V,, ..1-''':./- '',:f.',--.::,,,1:-.:,•,',m.'"'„,k0,..---,,- .,' .....c...:.,-1-',:;..-,:.. - - ! z : ; It f_.._ ,... , Aw, ,,,,h..,„r .., .:.:. • . . , t. - ...e,....;.. i. .:c.d.:s.,-.-„,,,i,,,Ft. • . ,. . -._,. • , - ,...„,, „..,,,...,_. .;„7. 4-!--v4 • • .:.. • •. • • . j i? . j- • • k • •----1--0,•••••,--="1.4,.......--:;-,-_, ...., . . ., .• ,,I, ..:„ ... ...,:,:•:...;:•-:;t:::.-•••,1,'-‘:,•:.,,, . •,..-_•--:. . -_,-.• • ., A:I: ,-..;:9.-!;?,-...:2.;.Vv- --,,,,,-.9 :,- -1 --4--•• .- ‘ ••,-,:f •. - v - itle-;:,;%,-...-„,-.4...11)::-;-.I.,?:..,,,,),‘,4?,„•,...4-,:-.,4,74.,-,,,,,....:„:-..•...,,....-..„. - -..-:,-,„.- .. ,• - : -• i• i ••••,' -1-.1:•-•"..irptt..4.-.;,:••--,..,:.11,,,yee,-..i.-,--1-mt,-,.--4,,,ziv--..: ...::::-,4f•-v...."-•.•,:-5y. ; .--.-.,-• :-..:,-.7........ ., - 1:: ....-.. . .'"". I ...... k ...e.2;A:',...441g: ..Z.P41:41V,V.V.:1,,,,,e.:,,i4ti:g`:::;,,it:"g::',;,;"?... ..,...q,':•,14.:.::...ft,,: -:',-Z5`.,,,, —....,,,,.',,,,,-, :-.•..',',".,,„..;'....,,,,r;,,,,- ,.'••,, ' ' ,,tec.'' .,41. r...,.....t"1" . (.4., '..''',,,r4'.',7,4,1 ' ,, - .,,1/2 . ..■,...:::- •-tvr...-t,ii...•,.,!..!..:,..,',..,.3-1).,,I,:x.,.,:„.,,,, .-,,....-,1,,,;-zs.4:-crm ,t , ,:„:,,,,f. --!:•%''•';',-<'- '4 '-'''1:2•,'*A-'4•,!,.:;,'74i. ...: ../:-5-74-i*p.,...0•-•..15-1,;•:-•,%,1.1f":,:•:-1.',;11.?t,..v.-;-r,:,-;:i tA17:,-4-f::;•F.1,0.-..73/.tph,•-. • • -ii-.1.-f-As!%,,-.1,, i.;:;:r.,-9-n-.- -,.;-.:,.e.',44,-/.4.4,,ity. 40-.0:::i,;,41.;i.‘'Rzrui.4,,-...:-,r_...,:::-,...7,01....rt-,.vi •,' ,q,••-.Aillk,- -;.,...„..L.:•:5-. .. -.•••:•••••• :•'s•-:,,,?:.k.•.-.2s,):-,,,...^.(;iY,At,-;.ft...v.,„:‘,47,ip:a1,,,,fiiI,.. tifiktrtii.,.q.*,:...,:vr..-.."A.:,:,,,,,,......1e,.z.:.,op '.. ,;70,41,;.e. ,,•-„,....,,, •.- • - . .,,,,:,.:.,./....s.,..$,-:-.,...4.....,.,,,4;vfie,,...wi•-,:::,4‘,..-i,-;.,.44-x.:,:,,9,.,:......4,1.1,,,ii,„ ,,,,,,,,.....„:„.--:.:4.6,..,,,,,;,...N.1-4.,,,,,...,....,.,.„0 .te,,,,, ,-:. . " . ,-,.--.1,---;14: ,.--,,-.44.,-:.,.,/...-,,.-..r....,,,.,,,,‘.....,...-6„ -..,...„.:,.„:,....:7.4„,,. -;,,,7-..--.41,...2,.......h • .,,4;,-t.,,ve%. •, -. "------r-1,---1,-..;:siz,v,5-7,...,x.N,AAR",,k4.--..,,,-,,,:z...,....,...,0-,.„-,.,.:,..,--i .,....„1,-..-••I.- - •-- .'--1, -'14N`,'''''i''''''''0•)`;M-,-''..-7,'''',"',”,i, i's•%,t...1L141.,1,4.m•A„,1,-,„1.J, ... 1 '' '' ' •''‘.'1,1,..:,t,...•..,:".......-•;:i; •••■•;',.?"..t.-‘v......-,,..t..-...:,.,..1 .7,,,.. . -7.-- Figure 25. View of the carport and driveway in front of 8CR954,facing west-northwest. • -ir .:,-4:1:::-.A0!•-:.'''",":'-:' '.';',••7•."F.?,';'," ' ' --:;;;(---- INtrill),-.114..%.f.:z..;.-••' .,,,..,,„, ,.., 44.,,.7 ,s,fib" .„_..1.A. i'to ..-',, --..,..: %;,.'4.1."-:,-.1,',.,. •'.,. ,•,.'''x' .,.......:7.--;,"1-‘ ' ..se,,,,f,,,,,,•,3:,•• ,.,j,r... .`- ..:;,•!.,l'".',. ....-4.-i2,',:-‘,..,..:.::',I. re,, !,..;,)ij,',)d.'''''!'•41404ic,:'..Vi4;:-. ,Ifi;'•it;'. ,-.1ta.,.. •,,:;.,4 /.',;'`i--.. ....:z,•-,.,,,. -. ...-..k,.....:...4-4:1 0-.... •,4 r..;,,s,t,..5-q. vi,'`.1 4- ii,__:.;1:-',"•''.'..t■Ii.c.-,..,4'WY.-!•• -- 1.- ; -,,i,.., ...g.„v::.:.,,..,-);,::::-:,•..,... ..r.7,::::. - ,•,.:......,....: i.-' " ''''' *4'1 ;4.y'' ' ''*'il- .• I) Ip',.•.,',-,t,-- ,r,':. 'Ai,- ,-.2.:-,:-.., - 1,,`.- •.:.;,.....;......',;.!•.4; •,k."-.---:.- 'i-'.•.'ItAtk.4.•ti4...1.'. •'*--4-.'• '...C.'''q' ' - ";•.:;::-tlf:1%;•ii. :1104'.1: ' ' .-1.. ' ;•1''''.‘. ."'-'•• AP . ....4.1.:-'4;f:i,Y...!.'4.°4. 1 1,:11.1.4,1 Wi 4. .....,, ' ' .L.,';',-4ft.:•:A).--,. ,'''L■ :.17.,: ,VtiaPfr,;:1'1.,'::' '''-':',','.:',?,;•';7,,..,.. ., '1.01,'. 1.,-,,,,y.e::::.,:i.:.:;.:'.i0.":!„..;••;01 1(i...i,•,;;•42.:',,,If.xfir . ..."-.7.•-•:•"::7.4•7..q■:„.. .• 1'/1 7 • -..... 1 14' a • • ...•.......,--..r.-:',. .: od i.liiiilwrivo:0 ' •, , .. -,..,'.-...'..,.....‘.,.:i .... '-.-,..,71:47", - ,,,s14044 . . ...- .,- - . , .-1....7.:' •,',4 ..''.:;.',....:. t....,• ...ti...:"..,:`.,.. ...,700.0.7. I ,.,. :(VA, ;ket:' :....,..- •%........,::1,•'''•;1,54 • ''. '1.”..hiri.t... Ari=',. • ' 4.:4„ ,0'...1,;.;.„,..11'.,,Ft.q.P,lose:- „...,..".r,, „ i,.iiip..,1.- i, . ' :,-.;....:7.,77,,,,.„.„,,,., .... ..„... ,. ;:-..."4,,,.; 7 ,.:,i:.-;.::•,. , .0024 `,,,,hTi 7,4,,,...... , . ,,liet„,,, , . .., ,...„:„..,,,,,,i -,- ..., .s:.;:i4,.:....,. ...... ...1 ,.. „..vi,...:.:,:,.,,,,,... s. :.;.6*,T';?:;;;Rril i: ../1:7% ..,■-orr'", -,,W.::--.'•.- ',.:....---1-,:' - ., ;-: .ficztl.,■., ' ;,,,,,.:.:''-.A..q.',1:-..,V,,,,,,:,,":-,i , , 14 V',-,!'''''' . ,V 1;" ft.:- '-%4,:,,,,o, . •• '•••:;'.-',-,. .,•,•_:•:,-,•:1„;•,.., titottc. • ', ,'.:*••4:-'' #1.14, • i`''-',',.. ',;:1,' • ...' t'sr.f,''''';•1 .• '''.i'd -+'j,i iZ,';'14';',*,t,'.'. .-..' : ,,,*..,.'5, i ,..„..„....k.,,,,i,.. ly, 1,e, , 4 ,.,:,.• ,., i . .;r a,,t;,ns ,- .I..1%,. .'1 1,-,,,, ,`•;,,t- 'r..2.......,,,.. ..-'1'....-f'.:-';',..-1-•'`-% ';'?",:',i.' -; - .......,, t;s,4".:.,'';,',.:'' .•-i•-'•',. : '•' t•••'-'rn' ' ' '' --qi.A.,,i ..;1'. ,,,p4,1 ',,.,,,,„1.,• -,.."...'r, 7,,..,,:-.-.3.--z.;,- ?-e. .,-,...:44:;..--;-,.,,,,, I, '..,.., ..:-.....,.,..,..:, . • .:!,1,.-(k. '..:... g:OA .Vii'...'...:.:T..;:,:::.`;-;:,•:•,::,•-fi.:'.:;:;.,,..a. .-.-a .".,-*---— • .-:•';'.,'.'e'':''...--'•-.'.'- '•'1.?',,''.t1•i.A7l/24•'4ti ii.7-ia,..-.....11'•i4w-,.43,,.:.°.:.-‘*''4.;• m.4',-''':.:•l.i l•;4I.•,'s1••-,,,-,.—,"..9.',,•:„1 viiI.4"vMs.t1e.4)t,.f:re.,,.',p..4.,w:4,•••t.0iAws F..,.Y,,,..:1;.•n:.4,•..(.•4:,!;,.'.....'.•.-••.•.,......,...:...-:•..;.•-'•.I. 1,.1,•,,,fr.7.tt.V,oPrtyi.si4•&met..,J;stY-,1-,tqi,,.-.„1.,4'.gk3„i.l..,,,.iy,,,,,m,r,go,,.,..h.-s.,.•g•4,i■i-t'•.,..:r..t.v.1.,o-;t,.e,..1 g7-4p,..i,g.J..•;f...'..-..•'••t1-..,.-:,,t,'..,,.:,•. 1h- lm .-..:.,1:-.-;'1.,-,-•,'.,,.,,......t...,41 s,,.l.,.e,.i,,,P`,-i'.,',,;...;;/,,_.„.4:C;,,.::..z,:.:,,;'••::i:#ila,:..•,-;,,‘,.,-,I.',.„.$•.A,...,,&•.,,4,,.;,,,,-;&';,-,',•.„•,'s.-,'.•.•-.,..• •.••,:--. ••-6.t.• •■••••go ....•..:•••..,w••••:1•••0",,,-;.';,•••;;,,;_ii-4%.••••' ' • • ,.... .....,„. :„..:-..;;;;;■#;':..Y.:444..4...••4W,:',..:,...1;.:i3k- .:1•;;;.:,,g•i':•;:i•504.4t4iFV,411. ,,.■,:••:::"•••••):A,.."4.1:11'^'IPH,-.i!...1,f.;• . ,„. 7.:..., .t it . ;,....t...14:10-'•4,•-t'rliAti7-.:Sirp:•;,?';'•:.•••:4;&•,•••#.744,14•4',-4,A*P1.41 V!,;•,•;,.:I.,•;.•o.,,,,.',O',., ,,',•:'1,4 14.,14,t,•.•... •--e•...yz:.:'. i .It ,..-;.;•,::•;4•":"P!ZrAOP•stAt•-..,..4.V.7%"••4tr,".•.- 7.4'•'i'lr4t>'?,(4fc/VAY311.0.klvit'iWO14ts.4.ri-•.. .....14,,rsti,At171•, :721,,,,...s,' .':'-..• .._-,1•••%',...'•••,••, Vi'.%. :•• :'•,'.'.••••,'.1,;,-..?:!,,•;: ift4p,o'bs,k.,..i.S.7,;:q?...,.-1: .;;•:',L14.:,,,,!:•,;•,,•1•1.4.,sik,'•74.1•■,p,,,os„,„.7•,,,,,tvy•.S.ip,p,:•:• ,•',Vpi.,,,,Ai,o,'+:,,^ • ., '..'.-''''•*. ' '144,=',......cr'•.::. •;'".',...,4:.••••:•*.i.t....Y.PA•0•:■• ••••.'0'...:•:::•1. ..i.,ki.e;.:.41:4•Vig..,R416,1409Ng.'.03%'•gr•-.1;.' '..-^c,.-q.,,s,4.rz•-WO::„”..4,0- '.. .'s-;•..4;,,-.'1)-` .i,,.Kir-",,-,,,.'.j .:,-..."..i. .!..:.-''''...'4:...,..t.; .,z,..7-..,g,''..:::r-i.r.i?..-.--,..1z,.,.",;...?:';m4'..f...:41.4;a:?A'.'''''',I•'WeL.5-.) .-: 't'..'-' '-- ' • . ''.'.;-..,,- , • - • .. %,.,:, ,. I, . . . ' . ' . ':...'.,.4.-.•...'":',.; ''r,: -, ' ' •.4,.....i.,,... .:1-....-;.. ,--, .••400';''''''''::',.,,, .--.."•••- ' . .• - .,- . . , mi.,,T.m.,,,,r.,4,...n#..,;,,,.0".. :'''''',. -- -----i.,,,,.....K-fTro-4,,,,.,„! - ,',........, ... i..•'! .---1/`' • ---.... Figure 26. Hurricane shutters over windows, rafter tails, and closet for hot water tank at 8CR954,facing southeast. 26 • • ........ Packet Page-2468- • • 1/13/2015 17.C. • y rf ii+ 1)04P '41 J �•` t1��,- c ti � - .: - I •q 1 L 7 L ' j rg i t.•�r Y .331, .69 ; H r; _ � I � �i,�Ii ' 4 �� a . �55 In' I Vf ' � 171 r5 ..1I Ih(! (.i4'k/ i l.5 _. #.Z.•F,■ Fl it , ' • a 5 Figure 27. Paneled walls of entry and living room in 8CR954,facing north. 8CR955 MarGood Cottage #8 8CR955 is located on the east side of Pettit Drive (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by George and Betty Culty on site in the early 1950s (Ludlow, personal communication 2006). Later, the cottage was acquired by Rex and Ruby Johnson. The cottage has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, asbestos shingles on the exterior, and a concrete-block pier foundation. If there are rafter tails, they are hidden by gutters. Windows are two, three, and four-light awning in metal sashes (Figure 28). Because a garage has been attached to the southeast elevation where the main entry may have been originally, the main entry is now on the southwest elevation, which is not a gable end as in MarGood Cottages #4, #5, and#7. The garage floor is dirt. The main entry is a screened wooden door sheltered by a bracketed gable roof. The concrete front porch has wrought iron railings. Unlike most of the other cottages in MarGood, 8CR955 has a back door where there is also a concrete porch (Figure 29). 8CR955 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR955, not long after it was privately built, became a component of a recreational facility serving the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island,the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and water, and water and electricity. 27 Packet Page -2469- 1/13/2015 17.C. J ,f_44..,:",,,„.,.:;.'.!..,_—,".;,I 17 )7/ •00`;......1.:•,7.1^,f4``y • ••:•.''mil... M yo; nay Gt'' -a : "w �G ./ >-1�.:* c''''.1.'7""4..*- 4:- -7.' ti le- ` , : : J4 ' i � .:"A:',.., ) ri�� 5 r � � / nh a •,• L �� , t✓ t✓M ti tr,•,.1 V 2 ` t rte. ... r / org2¢�t r x ��.� m s :,,i• �4 11. tL E 1 a„�Cr !,..;.-,..,k;,, ,..1...�7 9)f�h^1� p.,,N r��pv`r yam+��i;Hi L1,r4f f! mz p ',{> ''t Cgj'31 ap,'FLgir'� x mLm'.7t ,T a hJh1,,r f `1N IR ngT4U1Nn f ? 94 : .F'^�-1j :,.td' t1 i 1.� � i i� i't�rrrns�cbd t s�.kwrPE�ia f 1sx�.i r` - y�r a t �”s�d. " 'cgF,�'b"� .� ��"{ ��•"4TIa ��aY�?}j ��^'�!!;•�I�d 11"7iri�r� !'" �" `7�, i/If y,80' �" f, x e ' i �� .r (p `1 :�ort"i�l fi1.t1 y M1r"�,',..l.d -q tl ;:i f t Yx1i r . P i��yw� .„ i, : 5.,`"iy' -a.a�..e,....n�r '`" ,.f . V WW-- Figure 28. Vi ew of t he façade and north end of MarGood Cottage #8, 8CR955,facing east-southeast. Garage addition is on the southeast end of the structure. y{,, fc '- J. x t+a r i;x;i"i,,,'' i '`.t ✓/_i',-'''r /'5 Ji Fi'i. 'i c 1 r , ,�i i� ,L'e.,. -.-., e 11Y•,.1,e 4 5` u A.A' 'axiik T„Fr !wa" Z ,P p 7.,m r S n Jr^8 y v.an)) 7 1 ? j 1 v P. a ✓r i y .rikl,Le + cam ) 4y�,�,c,: y.1 4%„,,,rt 7 r�.•f �....,,.�,.,o:.,.,,:., sM ? ,,y,,, krC`,?�,.4{,�•1 'Ir t 1 tS�er^r /•.4`,�( !'tat,44,,4' ,\v.'k � y�e �4• 1 Py �. PZ� 1.,r, z....„.....,,-, ?�gi s '• �a7 i - *�' - ,�'6.` S,i 41 6 : 1 t 4S,r• -�s1V•:...7.1:.: ,• `�/s�7'""•1 - 44,,,, %4,.r 151 .•y.w! 1 a�"• ., l hv'M1Nn . e.r> SSrd7 z t 4.44 x�F `7c ✓i/t re at w Y t !',..ea , a."7 tN4 �t� �t,�il5 rf "'A(', +Ir ;a7�T ryvtr ' 1iy` '; a+r8,F/� s w ''u� {a 4v ei7n ..- * 4,� t4, .9 .•.a.. . •^ ! .�i,; i if off d 1- —. 't i ''tii"�S7. ,It,,y 3 I f' v" � r s t F' a 1 4A V 'i•4i T..ii b �i9'' IV r7•�) L T ' w•I x 1 P ✓ r ,C, L Figure 29. The back of 8CR955, with view of metal roof, pier foundation and back porch, facing southwest. 28 Packet Page -2470- 1/13/2015 17.C. 8CR956 MarGood Cottage #9 8CR956 is located on the east side of Pettit Drive, where it is grouped with two other cottages of similar style and construction (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by Kelly Gantt for his fish camp at Marco on Marco Island in the 1920s. In the late 1950s, the fish camp closed and the cottage was bought by Rex and Ruby Johnson and moved to MarGood (Ludlow, personal communication 2006). A shotgun-style cottage, 8CR956 has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, a clapboard exterior, and a concrete-pier foundation (Figure 30). The piers do not appear to be manufactured, but look as though they were made on site. Windows are three-over-one, double-hung in wood sashes on three sides of the house; wood-sash casement windows are at the back of the house where changes have been made. The main entry is a screened wooden door reached from a small concrete porch. The porch has pipe railings and a braced shed roof with decorative rafter tails and asphalt shingles. A bathroom has been added to the rear of the one-room cottage, and a hot-water tank has been housed in a separate closet outside (Figure 31). Hurricane shutters protect the rear windows only. 8CR956 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criteria A and C. As part of an early-twentieth-century fish camp, 8CR956 represents basic accommodations provided for recreational fishermen by people in south Florida hoping to increase their income through tourism. 8CR956 demonstrates the importance of recreation and tourism in Florida at a time when travel to remote areas of the state was difficult and services were few. Although it was moved from its original location, the cottage was always used for the purposes of recreation and tourism. 8CR956 is also potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion C. While the structure is not outstanding architecturally, its one-room, shotgun style is scarce in Florida. Collier County plans to restore 8CR956 and interpret it historically for the visiting public. t�',"ix�� i;a f"W S°tai tM �,, viN, r t+e t, '` y,y `' i ? t tV , {'. t <�4k;, .5', i.SAJP4 r, �Y" G1?G.' .'�aa.t a�i;y t o ~ tY. ' •"F i. . r� JS x yet./°: 'r a v"� . Shy n 4 . .. W.a 1%, t t.' A .19 t;t"t, ji - 3 r ' - $' i r . T ref 111,P,1 t 4... 2'i 1 t' � t LL to u) r0.0 _� i -- } ... ?r 4 L ii RAy :£ t - . ,5,1 MV ...-14:.,-.e. fi.--tr+..n,,•t.�•.... �1 U ' l l r t r -,-,A.-.--;1.-- � ,P R 1 Y i"j :%:::-0'.',e++ :sl -" -tit �, Y t ? 5w I- ` ,.,t a t'4 `r ° s a . ..,.... s i-Mt..1 mY'.ui'3`w p vi.l§Si`.ain:n ._.....u.__.3 .ieh2r. L Figure 30. 8CR956,with view of three-over-one window, clapboard exterior and small porch,facing southeast. 8CR960 is to the right. -- 29 Packet Page -2471- 1/13/2015 17.C. �'- .I f 4,s,'Ya M,{7,„„ ,_ f ,i�,.-. wy,+tit'., , ' x= , '' { i d j rata ,1{ ( i•O' ., i,.. "��'S ,4 4 ,4 ,M .a t,.„,,' is '' '—f, �.n t 'l^'� •r i if .tR�t"St' �\,, spy,, ��,� r 7 e w i $ ,,k�V. ' iii 4 >Ikmf ..,,, �{r,.(x'XAS r4 T \r .�� 441 4 ,; 1. ,2 � } I T '' i \::—. ry L�{ ';'t2 1 S•f� o":f11 v ",,.a�-rtr tr 3 rr �� ,f b��}}L��,- \'10,14r,7'"' ' .. -i`�a II 5�i i 1 y , r� �" 1 a�r: -,,,,;.=,--' < ,-,?tii ' ,::.A.. .?*. n"ikix 't k r A�txF�PSlu I Ne r - f � I ,KI r {i l �£" a'w^d,F�' •� .r— � { �,LJ "�Y �,',,�t `j�c.Mu1 ` r' �n�g ( F t l.i C�?#Pr Y aan _., 1 I!g i !1(1 Y .V r,,, lI,,"H,•. ,, ,y5_-, A a4" ,.it ,,,.2. tikls ,,;- ciK9f4t`; ', -xi, # r: i rlhWig/A t Y'+�i }t M1 f ,^t.i u{t' %'�A5�"�'' :I S S,4(_,ay.s, fif l { „ y rY y r ?f�xii 1r ri t t— a � GSr�ux ' t'u� rl s a r ,iy ,--:- G. Asa, '�2`•'.r..�$�.rt.�tit:1.�'^ul re t r `'-,— � '� 3 r d,�4 l ; 3 1 "�l��i x3� F'�Y��IT,r�j`p�9 A";�,s�jl�;�1{,1f,p� .tlr a•?"�{7j a r�'�'].�A,W.NYr'�tfi'.7wWat"e�.s`y` '�` > � t rl` „ S A'.�C� °rAi�yi140-5 t `-'.�" f µ i aRAS� , ff i ;��.•i Olt .00�.h r r' i fir;.., 6. t r 1 r.r t`0ii 7. cdg -,t ';,:r,'fir a U f '1 '7 1 r r''''': SF 'r �4;$; 1.� . I a 1.t:1(, f Ir/r �. VSwL S y i c wz :xtzt uc ca-, +,:1 . _.. ;... ~ . hr'.:..,..^.:::-,..„,,-/. . J. Figure 31. View of the rear elevation of 8CR956 showing bathroom addition and closet for hot-water tank, facing north-northwest. 8CR957 MarGood Cottage #10 8CR957 is located on the east side of Pettit Drive, where it is grouped with two other cottages of similar style and construction (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by Kelly Gantt for his fish camp at Marco on Marco Island in the 1920s. In the late 1950s, the fish camp closed and the cottage was bought by Rex and Ruby Johnson and moved to MarGood (Ludlow, personal communication 2006). A shotgun-style cottage, 8CR957 has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, a clapboard exterior, and a preformed- concrete-pier foundation (Figure 32). The piers do not appear to be manufactured, but look as __. though they were made on site. Windows are three-over-one, double-hung in wood sashes on three sides of the house(Figure 33);jalousie windows are at the back and on the north elevation. The main entry is a screened wooden door reached from a small concrete porch. The porch has pipe railings and a braced shed roof with decorative rafter tails and asphalt shingles. This cottage has a side door and concrete porch on the northwest elevation. A bathroom has been added to the rear of the one-room cottage, and a hot-water tank has been housed in a separate .. closet outside. Hurricane shutters protect the front and rear windows only. 8CR957 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criteria A and C. - As part of an early-twentieth-century fish camp, 8CR957 represents basic accommodations provided for recreational fishermen by people in south Florida hoping to increase their income through tourism. 8CR957 demonstrates the importance of recreation and tourism in Florida at a -- time when travel to remote areas of the state was difficult and services were few. Although it was moved from its original location, the cottage was always used for the purposes of recreation and tourism. 8CR957 is also potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion C. While the structure is not outstanding architecturally, its one-room, shotgun style is scarce in 30 Packet Page-2472- 1/13/2015 17.C. • Florida. Collier County plans to restore 8CR957 and interpret it historically for the visiting public. -••,:i. _.-1,.., ?,,,,r7;•.; x �jt(F • \ .w t.siL' - . r•Y fLi1,.d„f F}��r P r 1.c ^ f • •, _ 2�a t ! t t s3 s%.s 10 ...",:.A1. V,' ° ,r tip• �s.' Sri fJ. + �.-• 1,4...64 sq ,y * .` * w r aM'4! v :,1.:_� f 1 tf S nif'• _' ✓ r I: , ! n'",.1'1, 1 .7y':it s, a x I, ,; , , • d t " 3 - 2 r ,1 N r 6 r ••. ._. .. , . ' ._A'.rt . ?,.e&:.. Figure 32. Shot-gun style Cottage#10, 8CR957, with view of main entry with braced roof over porch that has curved-pipe railings,facing northeast. A hurricane shutter covers the front window. .rat LJ r,4,4"..'v°11* 4 F e'J .4'L� 1 Vii,' 4"^ k �. ti i• /.0,t�:�/a x 11'4;;, 4,,e.:4 4, t _.,.r„,,,,,.41.: y . ,KU r it as ek (z _ '.M`•s#' 7.'�//r P r 3 ��Jryy)l,r �r s, ,t ar t^•r tv,,S s y , . ) .'�,. .r.1.-.024:2.‘",1—'4,.....1-- A b S s +.` i r. "rt'-t1 f Wir�qe':$ • •1 V-..:!...:•:.,..:;'..' ; ifRi , �c� ▪ r Pr,r f.. r>ti II s I 3 .r'z ?., ',..::;,;17.'4"°1 -• 1;. + "1,,, ..i • t t r '. ro 1If 1`i f +f[, Ystnti /' r 6 !i ` y YT i 1 ' f' i r tFr, ; t• mot" ..1, p.ASt't y+ ,�" "$'3tirz ^.r;;,. -?m' x6a Cvib' 3.44.ta,,2&.5.41 M' .ky ry.. tt'Sff f ..c tia r a4r ,Peb a"4 4".$t6�'c .- k1Al ,r. .1•ilarr_re ▪ S+e nrai y..14., 4 ! .m••),,..,1"'aq.N I.-&cx' ...dAs'yv 1 . r..," ...... r~ °.�w u Ju- .HI`PP`O..+1t . rk'JS.ti 1 a,1.. .41. �i 5 3 i.,�(4iifp,�gt,..�. ( .s _ ....5'777.1". >P/' r75 -. r_. 14i@r'er Yrty yit.'Wg. b+i<1 XX .r.., '+•'*,14t .�;J,.:. .�. ':- ` 1-��..._:.. :'Aj . .. �.. 1 t ' •T'• .. • • Figure 33. Southeast elevation of 8CR957, with view of metal roof, clapboard exterior, and pier foundation, facing northwest. 31 Packet Page -2473- 1/13/2015 17.C. 8CR958 MarGood Cottage#11 8CR958 is located on the east side of Pettit Drive, where it is grouped with two other cottages of similar style and construction (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular cottage, it was constructed by Kelly Gantt for his fish camp at Marco on Marco Island in the 1920s. In the • late 1950s, the fish camp closed and the cottage was bought by Rex and Ruby Johnson and moved to MarGood (Ludlow, personal communication 2006). A shotgun-style cottage, 8CR958 has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels, a clapboard exterior (Figures 34 and 35), and a pre-formed-concrete-pier foundation. The piers do not appear to be manufactured, but look as though they were made on site. Windows are three-over-one, double-hung in wood sashes on three sides of the house; the rear windows are hidden from view by hurricane shutters. The main entry is a screened wooden door reached from a small concrete porch. The porch has pipe railings and a braced shed roof with decorative rafter tails and asphalt shingles (Figure 34). A bathroom has been added to the rear of the one-room cottage, and a hot water-tank has been housed in a separate closet outside. 8CR958 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criteria A and C. As part of an early-twentieth-century fish camp, 8CR958 represents basic accommodations provided for,recreational fishermen by people in south Florida hoping to increase their income through tourism. 8CR958 demonstrates the importance of recreation and tourism in Florida at a time when travel to remote areas of the state was difficult and services were few. Although it was moved from its original location, the cottage was always used for the purposes of recreation and. tourism. 8CR958 is also potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion C. While the structure is not outstanding architecturally, its one-room, shotgun style is scarce in Florida. Collier County plans to restore 8CR958 and interpret it historically for the visiting public. 32 Packet Page -2474- 1/13/2015 17.C. — a+Iwo%.;,,,"'el.,..... . f k °L',Y""`'e I' iJ 'S » fir. : , L :2- .e+ t «. t �. ♦ N Is H jp✓ 4I y_ , .t t Vi' F.b +.. 4 :'1.� A. i• `1 —,..-;...---Y,...;h .„:1.1/'..•s' , J'. �'„ yl4t�. 1 ..i ; -., r :-..i '•'•C - .:t'r/.r' ti- 9 ''till �• ;.- ,. ,,.; ,,.a,, '1 to >. 'i ! t, a .-,' *:---.Qa%:y s' '.> , �.s `' A* : W.^+l r 'S+ } 4 r ,,, 3G } . i. a l/ ,. `x/` 4 l Tt nl, Jr 4'.ay1N. t .‘:-.;.:1',...i. -.1&,1%,44,:P;'. • " f.'. •�:a ,_ ( 1 »•• " fat' , - ` 3• -.....n./41474" -.,.‘44,4"4` : 1.411111,14;e 1.i: 1 r, -.•'�s''r ., t a •J � to _ ; 'F. ..._. L'1 1 I .I '..1-„1...-.11774: 1;A --%„..„,,„.,, ,1.fy, `� y � �t i .; �a 1 L.r" '`"..—''`t`#r� E k 'T' & kC at l,4 "‹,a jtva +r"j rs n kf e ., +4 t;-•:Nxf "j�l r S tAx I j :td'.k'., > .. . . ya�?x „ Y r!vrrlx £ „m`�... fit` rf :N�: ,s b :•a ' c ...r.:r .c. i.-2,..$.LEw..u: !,, ¢ ' 1',, e' _< Sxi T Figure 34. The façade of 8CR958, with view of 8CR957 in the background, facing east. �. �j.' /� �.fl r ,n �, --� '1 ,yp�?r/'1��t 1p �i• �jyu"?7�', 'P[ X11 _ /� 7:r'. WSJ `Fy • dL,,1wW�+.: ! aY -,-Ti`.'. P "'i ~ r}`��.? f,v.1 f+ i ,d,�, F>> ',„∎ • ._tA,.,a v- tF ail : r p u {t 0. ,}a t -' E+ y.Ilit 1. R ' ^Y y}ak.R t Y Its '- ier, JS T I.' ik.-ri•d ki„ "u. w 'r;. t+ "'AF h'f'+•"i ��(< „I.,. J'��M'.:"'�1 ., It G w r ,41'n'.1 4,yu SV '.-y f ,. ��,,'y`�iFr ]'. , s(,*•rit'�'t 1 w•d,f st ,.Ny,�r al5yy +1,.ti■ ''A,. $� � � .♦ 5 /::f�,trl ` � �'�` h Ir �rbilerigire:V>t,:■C'�J�,J;i.'4r^�!'!C'E ..,,,,14'• t`�r ,N;:<,,4 ��' ' e� ?rk 1•,i°j } ,u 1 tv.m 1_,.ei ,r 1 ,, 'i • _y�,r�t ft is ' � ,�� af „ iriN �k : (��3 , t.a;t a t, .,. I-,q a t $ ...4 ,. ..4 Jam {^ .. r4i, ,in MV:1`1 M ,l]e1''''..` , rJyA a> t_ 1 �41rr •,'•- %.1.-....'...'i > r J r st7. .r., ?MA'�'�i1`h i u•.'1 d %„s^. :.•< I( I "✓ 1.1.., 3 i�Yypr�'"•i��ik 31t 7 '''''''''''.444 a•.•.•;� 141,� , ,I.,.:,.:..1-..-r.:44-,,te ,n _3�.i ' t yy 7,1 ::age4.: .V, V z sl %'' ",;.$ 31 1 - -- . W rrT fyr.s ,,. �` i--. $3x +.;to 'i'"€r� :,','�.,4",•$•,4I 1 ''i, r .. t Af-.. ' .if-_..ie.... _-ic,(f v�p 4e•rest✓,,�C7 kM1y, � s Ld , 4,; --f S S µ ,. .'I }�' '. --,; l 15 41 2 / 4} S I { 551; / tJ ry � t :r "• ,:14•7:::yj -,-�. 3 .C�l�y.•r '� .: y,,.,, u 3 fd ls�,� 3 f r S• •!Y it i 1 yJ ty�"J. J 1 .i..-.r ><l': ,y+y't'r"{�A��9( lpd s+ 3�� Sf' �� ",`Vs .A},f S if 1`'68EFi 1 --. ""7-, , -Wry +s a'1+7,° r,tnrvK Y�F �tt,�w ,',a', J� : � rz77:1'e• a v '+a. -,,......''.•" a � 'rit+�,/ ur i. S`i'tiy pp•r 1 t �J A \ g ±.....r,`,IIEI"..,7,4 ' t I i P��✓+$iil,,,v, • :�. s � •t'"P-r kT+//.`�'�"tt,��„vµ+:'� ,rruSr^'fir}•.n„/s.,i .� 01 41t 4��'��y9, -� '� :":':..j...:;, !..::,-: a.7^{. Y✓S : .� �. J.3.•, ..,. ,.'T.',fYSn X. 11;t "tN e i V+Fjya y...` + > ,'K.. ., _""� t a. .`L' "� d,...,•, f s$urw r r Y1)~S• Y -'n^^".Y. , �IF>.' - (v,.•,-..1,7,-,'.0...,;,,„r ry 4-0.• �'t�u�' 1•. - J q My t 4P f `{fi, ii a Figure 35. View of the north elevation of 8CR958, showing the small size of the one-room structure, facing east southeast. 33 Packet Page -2475- 1/13/2015 17.C. 8CR959 Cistern for Cottages 8CR955-8CR958 and Laundromat 8CR960 8CR959 is located on the east side of Pettit Drive between 8CR955 and 8CR960 (Figure 4). A cistern, it has a below-ground concrete vault for the collection of water and above-ground , concrete-block walls that have been covered with stucco (Figures 36 and 37). A flat roof is on top of the cistern and there are holes for water pipes in the southeast and northwest elevations (Figure 36).. The building next to the cistern, on its northeast elevation, was at one time a Laundromat for MarGood Park. The cistern was constructed originally, however, to serve a privately built and owned cottage on its southwest elevation, 8CR955 (Ludlow, personal communication 2006). Later, the cistern provided water for the MarGood Laundromat and the surrounding cottages until municipal water arrived in Goodland in 1986. After that, 8CR959 was no longer used as a laundry facility, the cottages had bathrooms added, and the cistern was not needed. The above and below-ground cistern, because it remains in place and is relatively intact, is considered.potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history—and Criterion C—design and construction. As a means of collecting water to sustain a tourist park, and as an example of the way water was collected in Florida, especially in the southern region, the cistern demonstrates how small communities in Florida survived and how tourism was able to grow in the absence of a municipal water system. Collier County plans to preserve and restore the cistern for the new park—Goodland Harbour. Park—and provide historical interpretation for visitors. • 34 Packet Page -2476- _ 1/13/2015 17.C. i - --vf IJ.1 • 1 „, :•,:-N /j ', Z.,,, •'Cli,'1"...P1,...4.-v-. -• ■,:r.: ." \• ' , ,. . . . .• ,...,:;•.,..1',••,,.• .r:••ifl"" fp' ,.:-• . -it: ,%-,-;,-..-"....- ..t. , ',-• .,. ,,,e- - - - ,,,._-'1 ,7:'''''''',...?4.7.,4,,, '::;•-.Y.:...si.417.-_-.11 ,;Al,'lit vi.•'1.. \,,t7:;N.? i....-.. , ,. •_ ,, . ' ' ' ''''',.:1; I'''AV:;.'■4:)''....''Y....,''''‘'tN.4.: ; .-',....f. atlIN.L1 t. „. ,-,... :1, 1 *?-:- ,,............,,,Nx.. 1),,,...0,' ,,. ,i , If:.1.' '.ic -...v.,:V li,r,' ,'1,1■::;•' .,.■: (R;.. '': 1•'".`.... - 1,.91.4i •......-, , ••. ',?I`C. .i:ob "dir . ,,t,, ;,./..,* ;,,,, .... ‘ ‘,.- 4.5..tr:- . ' i '411,4,.;."--:;../21,i'L',',.40r e..?',411.1.r.;.:0■14,=: ..;.; ".,-,N,,,,..1 '? -,-' '.:”;,,:: •..1‘;.'": 141:' ••'',1 ik:. c4pArtiqx i.,As,If':1!: ,I--...4111.4.'.'t-*,1.)?; - • .,lt, d. -. , , ..--If i, -il> ,-■:,.•, ,. '7'.,., ..,,...--V 1,,,..vr,--,;kr.,1. . .',. 1...:;" . •;1, :•i 0, , .Ii.,,,,',•,'-• ,..-.ti..I-S,!M.''..-1:■:'1%.:1,1";I: 444 "1,44:1,••';*,:•In- I,. - ,•::7:1, N.--...4401e...,:: ,•..c,g T:ri:;,t::,:t,Ai ..i.-..<!-••:----.AtJr,,,P..4',4,;,•iii'1,•,,r.,•i-i'is• • Alt ' .'i ' N ,.,„„;;;;,,,,,,,.-.. .:::t-,•,,,i.,....r.;•,i;;,- .. • ...:_,..,-.1•.: „„,t....0.:•,..;„J•q 4 4,r..4 ';.:' . ...-4.,',( .7'2.......,.... , * . 4"1....;141 :::?"'....'4; ::,*•.'.t •,:47'.',"1,(.41,7'•••`' •:,,:', `...,."...7%.,-,•,-,:•:',,,...k.....-I-,.":,.•....,1 . '.... ., • e, _. r6.' t ,...' • -4 ', '.11‘;' 'r 1,'I 1'''''' i.P1 ,... ..• '''0.•'" -'.'','''',_,7,•,.:,:.L.,1..,.. ,....-.,... —......44,,,, 1-,,,,....* ' , ..... _.... .,..._,. . „.....,..__ ,„ ....,,,..:...... 4.-..,,,,x;. ,----1"..,r- .„.„, ,-;;;;;;;,irt,t.;-•,:v.:1,sZt-::,;,,,,-,..e.,"...1 •ir,,g,,...:.."'"'• , , ' :' . : " ','''';`,t44.-,!, " ` .,r1•4,1,,,, -. ,.,..„,..,,,....4.1r:sT.P• v•-tF,t.,••7•.',..t...:..•rj-4:•....-"--;.°*-:: „.apton-.7 ' • . . -,:. tairt13...t:;:.cilfat.4:;•.:!......0::-....1;i:.;t7c.:: •; • • 'z '-1 .'-1011...te't'-‘1.1ti.4%:#1.1^41.'•, .: ,,.,r1r 5,rt. ft,k.. V=.47■.,.k.d.:,;:,1:44.11-::1;triz.h.::":.:. ': , . ' -1...... :1.12?ef.).;:v.e.46,40.,...k....11giita;;A**•'444.m..egirt.',•::::44_tdp,„,..----:i.g.'0,11.17.4-c. .Alt ;e:::,...:-. ........1 .,•• , ..' .1:41(;i.',7'';''..:: :E:f:....!....,It l''..'I .,t,:'4.. 1:AP. -ttIe`t`.....'-:;;;;:-...'74.1,,,*-tiii0.3,.:'.;','";:' :.- '' ''...;: ''..,,,,,, tfi . _ '4",... h' VI:: f-I-:1.11`'.'4,4' ,,11'..•;;;; 1.7.f''.4%4;1.',.'; Wit,g11e41..'gr V*, : T.A.,,'.'-':':''..i; . ,:.',....V.Ok ' • i) .. ''' ir''' '.t'l cili...P1- A -0 :N4,,' ,".,\VV't?..7'1i:,4`.;::',4'411",' ,Li;:i.:,---•. . ;',:,4%..;ifia., . 4..;':..-,, 6'''.'•4';'''•!"'.7, Tiatill.,it...L.:v.' l'IX,''''- rf,-',*1 :i.J...:4,..-.. ,. L...i.-',.0A p.*4\-s.t.:P.:.::ti:4A4*I si.'.-g,•i:V::,i•l.•;.,.! 0,...,..:.,e......f;.k:,. k1T-,.. .,::',v....1..a,,,-.Y,7',1-,.-......-'4.A 4,,t.,„.,:..!.-...-..,1..--::,:.:,.--,.,:;';,.,,:-.,...;...•?.;:.,.-....:.-v,.-.......,,..•--:4-;4.......-.,0.4.,.t;:4:•-..I!-F-;..,,.•::.:.'::,'-.'.-'.-'...:''s,---‘,-..•.-.-•..:s ..,2.:.1.j..,,.,i-:.. - ,... ..frii-41U1,1 ,-,ili,,„Ii$' ri.'1',7;01.4:•-4'- e.c4,74:1°A.W. •-•-.-'6..,•::,,iz.,..:1;;;1.--...,.p,,e47:-.i.-,i,:. ..,., _. ,. ...?,:. :,.•,.,, . fi .,::',.;44. ;.4^:4--,.e.m.',.-,,,,,....'.:t‘-.,41.,,:.. ..44.,,,-A....444.,' •,--....-•:-.:-.',-..‹,..., (...,.. -.-2'....::-.....r.:,"ri.....14...-e. ..'' ,,t..:,,kf 1 ........,..,....-..4',-;z14.f-g04.N14. :.,..1::"...;:„.tm:;.F.,,,,,431- •-;..r:. , ...., - . ".:.!.....!,,;‘, , :.,...„,... •, k.....' - , '--.2r• ' . ••,.:or•:,zii;:?•••';---:' , ,•. ... .,.. ,.., •,ck•.■t). ,,. ,t ti.; 444tt,tisst$-. . ts-OtYkr.,*-...:.v - . . !i•f.' '4•A4;■1"it=i4t,V=31:1 ieLe;X-i>s+44, I'ilCA:p ..._. 10,?vzo,1',O..r i44:.v-t--b..-4.-,r2..4.•--.M A.Y.,..,,4J-.'.;a...::.4V.pi.1.h.v--,.0.c•t'a-••-•.i5.i,,4'4::,•ZK,.4 i4.■p,g,0.‘-.,',,:i.;.t1,,fri.ii./.r.'"i?*ii..,S.,rn,'',1.‘j•-At,,.,-.,.-';,.a-7w/,'N,;i%k.•t,-•,,.`-,-•e.,-.:,..e:,'.o;1.,r:4,,,-{"4t'.3F.,i,:A.,.;.$1,.f,.1".-.,ct,'k.:,,•,N„.„',,„,1,i..fk',t.:''-.,.4.iiAt'..isi,t i-'4•*-k-,-g‘4.7.0 it,1„VPi•:t.t4,,..4-A;i.”,m,4:0>,i,.,.1i1i„,i S..'.'..•.''.!-e.-'','.T4•t;j.,7c„:tr.1..:,-!V:.:„*°-4'l,"-,,,,.--1,`„P','=,,.'.",o1-:-i,i7'.,.X,■,:l”,,ck,,i,'4,..i-,..7K,et„i.Z'2.IV.;.,.:..%.1':",,■,,-.1k-"•-,v.!,`.,..`.-r.-.•-J,-'„•.'t.e.‘!,.0,...-,.;f.4:,•.:*';..4.,V4.•,„,.-',..,”;i..i,,.1'.1f:e.--,,r,,i•,...:n.:.'...,.,,'-:-',:,::.',/:'-'-•-,.,',.T4,1-...,....4.".....;..,.-;:•,.:!...v:,•:"...fr'.-,„:.l-f.,.' .,'..,h:.:.7..'...tr...:.:!:.!.1:,•A,?,.••....-,.,,-,•'s.-...,•.:....t.!•...1-..:'i';...,;•1x.;'.-,-1.,.•:.,. , ' :. .,.,V...:,.'.. .:.:'.--:'.'••'•,'... .a-•-.•j s'.i•,.-•im'1.1..,',..*..,.,•i.-w.:„z..•.4",;.6x,f.'°q-..4.:`.'„,,i.,,.,..,,.‘7....!4'..4--,”.-•,:......e..z,-. i * . 1 , '; „ ' ..,_x,.w.4••.).4.:—,.,•m ...,'.,i., • ••• .... ., Figure 36. The cistern, 8CR959, located betwseoeunth8eCaRst9.55 on the right and 8CR960 on...the,,...,.;,1;:t, facing - •-.•7 ,.• \ I,•• ••- , . &E"2,- ,4.4.4.,,,,' A., ''.I' ' .....4,..1",•:'...;,,,;? ..14 Il. :. . airi-..,.; r. ;. P.Ofg,4.4,.:411,%141. - 1.. ,• , t--- ,,,..., '' ' .-,,,,,,%; 1,04,s V...1 ,',,,„ 4':i'''.-"s,','-''' ...*...-.'''." .' ,____71•Ar.: '.."-. 5,1 fi., =Iv:Il.ii;:iiT,Piev.'. >., \A ..,..-.4..„,,.zi.m., -.,..%.... '41;*.r . "-- -,-•71' t . -.1. .•1I ..,.. : ,I..-,,,P,.;,,fi..- Vr;,.. '' i,•,. ,.,,,;‘.41.i. .g!,-.6,),...:7,....-.4%:..s, i-- ,,.,,•,, ... .c.t,,, '..- 14-,,:. ,...-.4;, ... 1. .... r I • ';., ' 'r.`s'.:.'I:t.:":V,,_. ;,•.Air.0.., Ili /i',I1,.. '‘;;; ' 6i.tc...:„..f.tv, ,t,;.<"''. .....1-'.‘.,,-.._ .,,-$::f 4 ezr;:..v,i,„.,..., , 1 , ,. .ig04,7-rfti priol.4':' t f, / O'' . -I'''qz 14-- ' tt ' 4 I\• ).'1)-' "iirfr"tk '-• : Y-"""'S f,' '':"." - '-•!.. 4,,P,Ae.t. i f-.,• ,,,.. .,. ...-: ,.-•:::..,- ;..:,,,tit,lA ...,,;:s... , .,.....,)4',,,(';"..:,..'',..11::',::`:•-••,,l'.'riir ''',.41y..II.4'4'thil...1: 47 -,.,t Iii f t N :,..;;;,.4.," .i...,.4. 1;,,,7.., .....,....,..- f X./Ali'ic 1••: :::.::':lif,..11 itA4.111.if,,\1■:1411"Vig; 4'...07/60 ..;'i:4i.;;AA 1442` v\‘‘'Nk•ii6\-SZI'l I,:(■:.,' 11',' 11'. iii:•.:...;2'..:11t.P.,;;;:.:1"11,1'It.Mtg:''...;d.i.C..C?:'..7.::';:7ii'#*. .:t 1,:'...''.:•...:V ti:\'‘Vi %.'-', -:'C''NI:^:' i', . ikk '‘AV 1.•::'•••:.1?.-.i..''....,4 4 V#4 f!t,...::''''...1'..;ik\'1"....''-'..-'''v\'''Av.'-\..-...-''',..../f 1.'V/.-' . .-..' "tsc';'---.41-i',.':4. i..-.%:','..;,,'‘:,...,.';''.,9:`.....s'it'it."....'1' ".'' k ..,...4 1 if.;i- ..r,,,,,,,,, ;,-...?.:•47:( v t,'CMri1",t e 4-t i i r,sNt$i.fef..;;;,:;..:,: 1'"-.l,'c..`/..,.••-.:':'i.;.f.'\..,.'::;:.-,....,,..'1:.:.;:".'.,.;,.:..4-:;'.'?-..'.`'.-..-,..7.:';.i''.:' 11 , IA •-41;...!.•:'!%........•.';:,,'fr','.:',.'I•t•l,.i A:-if,-V,1V,•%4.,-':3',AI,-Vkl-',.k 11.',7.4..,:fiP;\,..1:*-7.Z.71**'.•W'1:,,'4-fqt.1.::•;,4'.91,,,,.,'1,.'''f.k i'.9,T..'I.. ?,..4:.•-.;.2: i'PI :"• ••••:%tt. 'Y'j..1:A..,''',7,..;?..?1„ e.24: /...... : ••‘,..'C.,..:''''''i%'..1,.7tk4&iil. - •''.2 C:.•;1...•:1'1,:e.t.e''',A,:,•e;if It,: •pilik,s..kY ..,'4'.:' rf, ',•'..-,.;:?....:glAit," ..--, ' -,12...---,.. ;-........,.;',4bv. .... , . .,, ,,..,,dil,•..!:-,:.-_,-. „...-,.,..gi.,',:;:z..i. / ..:.: .....• Yr")4,45.4.1V,-444 t,Al tAWAS;(‘''.*:•1*.l..'t i:'i';'.:1 • ',4.4. ;•;:!. .' •''...II - ■,.'.4 . . . . :',',,,,-? '''''.,W,''''.,1:f,f4413'.*' f,A.,t,: .gt;:,41:14.04,143--%•.t..• •-..,:,•,:?:', _ •• . : . .".'Z'' '-4'1,I0".1[1N'''•1 kAIPVZ'''..1:'•'.. :•.115:'''' 0' r '. .''" `. '...' '.'''IL,41,55.':''-.4p.IMPt,5.41.9f0,4,V411::''AP.W.,,, Ago!, tg.', i'.'•'.' ,, r: ' . ,'L..: • oz, ,•;:r, - .'7.;'4-q.'fxat'i4r,h4,..t';,,..';--'244..1,,w4 .1-4,im. '', .,:..,•-z,.,::.. -..,...-..-,,,,,... .., . .....t.1:44„,..,,,,i;ki. -..te ';,,,i ,,,,,,,:,tia,.,''...,,:', ,........ -;,,iti-4-54.2;,.,. ,,,;04,1•-;-.. ,•-:.,,:.',..,,.'4,,...A .....f .-,.-: -4..gt:F.,.,Frp..o-1-- -4: ;...-,.. 4,V.. , ,:-.:,,ti,-(-1, -,44-4,`4.:,'''%1`'. .'^A ,?;/I-444'.4'.. ...,:::,10,'■,f, , ,4.. :' . `'.--,,Li4;t4:•,-*4%; * A?:.'"x '1"44`;. ,).,'''',,i,L '''"411CA""4,f,.:,.+.'..i 1-.1`*,,'- 0. • 41. 7"t'--s-. r'4'ir '.:- '''' ,N.,;".. ;,•4•,-,i4,!,4,:,,,1104.','T .i...ft.. . .-fg.:)•;....'',',....-f.:= _ ,.....;., .,..4.,;,,,,,A.- -„ ,.,...,..';.',ItitUe".;■,... -*C1:r.,tele.,1, .1/.0.',.,. 11.,.-D-,-.5....,- .• . ,-,..-.. .:. i,,,, ..,, ,,,..-5i. .. .., ,...„..... , ii--\,',. .: ....,. .. ,:- .- -...... ..,.- .,..,i... -, .-..•'.'' . ' •r;_, -1.:2-.A.S--16,144. ..'..;•.:•._.•. ....,,-;.."' "" - '1:' "", '.2 : /Ai;,./,'i.'",.09. 1_1,.,..::,1.1.=...e.5,.?'-;:-:-,,"•;;,i.".4... ):7-7e4g.*.tiff-fi?...,,„*,.i..2..z'":::t.t..*4:-y::-..,..!'4.7,..;;Z:,,. • ...:`, '..-'''' -.- ,' i!..• ' ,.-yi,, .--,i""." •.7,....;;.4...:-.,..:',..s..... ifir,-....:-..t. ,,,,,, .,1:a.......t.,,,r, .•t......e.....,..1._,..,,,,--....,. , , ., ...,,,. -,.....,!A 7-r 1 -..._... ....—,e, ..",,,,,-...!'4,,,, g,,,::"...:1--..a&.•217,-• ..*:.,.....r. .-.r" ,-".:41. '' ,.„,..:. ..,...,..., . .,--_ .4",-,••,-, • .,•,'.,.. -- •... . '„,''•'..:.4'4,,:k4 4,....Ir'"-''."-i..',-...2!,..9'."--Artr,-:-,r"..0.74',11''- :,...,,,,:e • .•.,.•,',.1/4-;,,..-,•i''''. ^ -,-'- -.-:.--,-",....--•=..7f677'," *q"' _ ..■ ..— ..14.'.k.i*'''';'"5'/441',”.1.-.--":"'''.,.% ,''--""-- 'Ili`14 ..':-4‘.-1:4ii,P' .„' -..t'skl•• It'7',..‘54,-,Yik.:. ..,,-,;,,:-.1„ ,. .. -- P"-••■ ":,,',',.., 4k,:•,',60-• -,42.-',,I;4-..1.*:7.5.14-,.-"•,--",,: .If`-..1- ',.'5°",z"-, ---'..". '''' ,, ..:•:!':'.-2;Sio 4.,:ri,,,-.••:.•,..,..._... , , .__. air ..... Figure 37. The stuccoed, above-ground concrete-block wall of cistern 8CR959, facing northwest. 35_ . Packet Page -2477- 1/13/2015 17.C. 8CR960 Laundromat/Shell Shop 8CR960 is located on the east side of Pettit Drive between 8CR959 and 8CR956 (Figure 4). A one-story, frame vernacular structure, it was built in the early 1950s as a laundry facility for visitors staying at MarGood.. The structure has a gable roof covered with sheet metal panels and asbestos shingles on the exterior (Figure 39). A window is on the northwest and northeast. elevations, but they have been boarded over (Figure 38). A door is on the southwest elevation, but it, too, is covered by a board. In the 1990s, 8CR960 was converted from a Laundromat to a shell shop. A MarGood resident, an artist and sign-painter, had a collection of shells and other interesting items in this building. The building was open to the public (Combs, personal communication 2006). 8CR960 is considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A—a property associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history. 8CR960 was constructed as a component of a recreational facility serving the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. Located on a boat basin on the edge of the Gulf-Coast Everglades, and situated on the eastern side of Marco Island, the largest of the Ten Thousand Islands, MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and water, and water and electricity. .a, .!i' i'l�. } j J` 71° M`0,4‘22 r4o e , :rvtnH r T � r `.�� tit f■ .� t .r'^tRP� t _ •ate 1 }. f Yrt y. �j f �c Y, • �t1. I' ',kS, ei.."'. r; '1 \1 r :447::;•.\''''V ^'k1j a. /•`'. �.__.. j i Y> dtt'„ t s AY* . A r a a fi' p �t a tsa jftppa ✓tel�� r"�t !\\ .;t ! n;�y s i�7k•�bxu l�9+1 1 1 rt1 •••4 E t -'a• �( t i.—.-. °IIR SY �fl-t; ,t(`1.w otj I �CIr n ;'[ j1 t� �! .•,,4100mt' keC17h':.'2 •f t F f ,tiw 'n, ' \`Lttrxta 1 Y s f'.. t `t.'./ it ! .n i }, • -- • - 4� 4 fn.^,�+'•"Y - F s .tit �� w'%'�' iN..`° '� . j' f cr9%al^ t•r .uy.�t`9y+ ', a�- �- u.. i `trkc5,tys' t„ r-1''ec f,y y 4 •.5°'+^ i d"' t u-:.f-Jv�! .d'k,b s 3t.. t •v �,�*i `•v iis "'+r1tit;S'4 Nf+/s. i'teyr<'� �rn� t.i �.'l 7C+... ^3«• tti -{ 0 5.- r fs ?4Lr le -4a�.ri! ;g_'" 3x. S.7' a.• s11 �i -\P..r.•rS .iC J s "'�S • ¢ w: fir/ ,p� qsk"y` J ix .< 1 \nS < • t2r kL,`Y. e•.nfrr ,� ii.r4P +n! 114..n i a OPOS ��`�.iw`s't?• . °f- '+t r•• N( FL.1i tit "'tPa� 't � "t " �', t a ray ai"'+, f x \o f.T otsi }f �+ri r 3c n.. v�4'4v.t, tp`✓:'"'*.tt :r s l� r .6 :\•, ,� it"�i4c,,♦ \..t, -' �•1dr•#-1.4.-+'. 0?,0 3 1:• >t:,.s.`.1`1�' ''r t w�t{'ly ,�r`T 1 ft-ni "•rf `i •T'1 r t • *"r:'I,r ' T / � !�" At �,S , t $♦ �`�.. £• d& "ty ^rs � ys yY!--{{Ir r 1 r s! f r 1 r*( 4 e _ _... -_. Figure 38. View of a laundry facility at MarGood that became a shell shop after municipal water was available in Goodland in 1986,facing east-southeast. 36 Packet Page-2478- 1/13/2015 17.C. -- -, �ti� rye r 4 `- ate. ,, L -.-4, �v7.f ■■ ti b` : `41 r MAl .O .-Q:': 1-13 x o ,f "+r• t r a f :t ! s ,,, S '�'�'s7,'S� � � }99 r.this ul"� .R > l'�'�w ? t � 1 � t t :" .... ;$.7 '1,:- • F i'{[ n u (a Ay 16 ! ,k Y -{Y�YS. YcNt•i,41; : Y V r r ill 1., e nn,i,At e k3 k) gr �� 1 t �a tit' z a a ,4 ',,-^D-`a y, y r , ri a t rM�,:; 1 1 �`"�,, mmi.VV+r1a1 sq Vl ire ,.r S Y 11d, a a EG t 4 'rri. , 0•'1r ) IAi tiirAj 6 n a v lm e. i@ ntt YN' ( `.t, 1. ff/ ,,,�t s., 1. tr,r t I r i '�'` l U`5 'i ft-f#1�i,N�S,r/s.1 Js 46.4. .e , va a1.0. _'.'�.16�. 5� L +� Y3Fii iK7el,'� ��¢y 4 r ' 1. ''�''i+ �ty"11.�7�-'}"�, �: � �y'-7' �1's l 7 C J - 1 w, ,e L'rx,l 1 !N ! m'1^'L y t '°��;�s i 1 r tA�� 3$0 3',r sf�' .i! •', r r•$�s 4e 'YR4- ...tlN>"�wH.:, � "�.t ��l�. YreF R -ritli 4 ha 4rtiA y'�� t�tIv� e—g:40,�a„t�. ye�t.>? m v ,*,,,,,V�ftk 4 t f k S a., r. r •, t,T 0°r a F' + r t 3 't y N t'd„., } T k 1� a�n 'n. R 4 1 f d t” A� �,}. � a, .,j:,cnrrY..' •�.9'T Pig 'Mi'uk7'�a� I�s+�x �1 L'rr .s �^`�M`s..?t.�. fi5.`!7'!4 fl�'r�@ � .1 .,L� iaFT"Yr.`Ri "' , t,�, �kc a,nfigy'' d {j?2 an�j a+I� '!�'^` g� fr nSstS'y}xtr &iii '"s,�!Rfh ��( 'la_ w l �c y' r-Al'.3"a,nY 0,4, r`u„ ,c„`Gh� ' iV is iki..t 1+,x - . -t.n k s rt r y� b t P' 7 d jX Ns xt m ✓�, ^ ,.. 3>',,,,.:� r x gg$�y ,Nri ,P•� ^�, 4',8,4 �i oilS ito I t a,f !i 'M phi s! � .l'`'a•�Gro 4'Va1{ '}t f v I�GZ r#'�� l.11.. !1 b�TA�^IJ�'!`<'� j° • 1h t q ;M.', < W 14 C r t,A,A,S i is q h' 1 A gift „I s i N „,� r F'�$4 JN �f�l�.1ti�4!; 's'X3>r� s M� � � s t r "5i'�., s,7,�'X+.','$.�'" F; y 7��J� a��1w'p.+,31 7"'�,t irke'Ir �> a xi s M ?w t t, ,.„!1,44'5∎VI � a} q 7�"did { Y ti I t S�`b•`y,^sn71�a-c•F +�h 9 �"� r k,.,IS -0 !.k „h� sue'': °1 1 1 tx ' 4 4 H t'J ;1 l , - r 't V;;14.1.41:,!.`a'4r a r:t r 5r�!7' `-•:-..'",".•,`',,Y 4.,4 yJa 1. 'r �i o.,.', �yV�y+�. T 1 ,.t ',��(�f'',�}�t1+�, ,or ,Y- y t } of J>r' b.Fl 9k'ry{,l V YA�!',ry',.tW.4s1��i� '7 ,J,�1�' �.i y i,h. 'S, +ra.+s >f YJrcifSittvi 'x''s d , n: t•• Ttl u�i Y0Zikeg 4 3' •r5” tt'fit.r, d� ,sap ••• } .1' ,t.\ ^I .s r I .' F14 0I �dry � "ys w >j�l a .�..r ,.f .„.'NS � c�� .`4' H 'TT_4 5,,V 1 ' \ } `.Yr 3p,�.1�5.".i• ''c.f` ;:-' 'a'l,. _ 'ro,r� . :1'1..Ok ."S !t".t.J • k`.l.�i�i"+r �+.+. •1�fir!.. �✓1 ..,. ...�.• .c:.«.�_�iLLn 1ti-,+�' ";f1:.,?_....-'- Figure 39. Southeast elevation of 8CR960, with view of asbestos shingles on exterior, facing north. CONCLUSIONS MarGood Resort and RV Park, originally named MarGood Cottages and Trailer Park, operated between the approximate years of 1952 and 2005. The trailer park is located in the ._.. small fishing village of Goodland in the eastern part of Marco Island. Before 1949, there were few houses in Goodland (Tebeau 1966). A bridge connecting Marco Island and Goodland to the mainland was in place by 1938, but Goodland remained without a municipal water system until 1986. In spite of the lack of amenities, tourists and winter visitors willingly traveled to Goodland where fishing around Marco Island was great (Rhodes 1912). While some people towed a trailer, others needed accommodations upon arrival. Visitors also required water, - restrooms, and showers. Although there were two other places where people could stay in Goodland (Pink House Motel and Marco Lodge), MarGood remained the only place where tourists could park a trailer, and later, an RV. In 2005, the owner of MarGood sold the property to Collier County. The county plans to restore some of the remaining structures at MarGood and adapt them to new uses in the park depending on their condition and historic significance. The new park will be called Goodland Harbour Park. The structures have been documented by PCI as MarGood structures and buildings since that was their identification when they were in use. Adaptive use of some MarGood structures is feasible. All of the MarGood structures are - considered potentially eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion A. Three cottages-8CR956, 8CR957, and 8CR 958—were constructed in the 1920s as part of a fish camp at Marco on Marco Island. When the fish camp closed in the late 1950s, the cottages were purchased by the owners of MarGood at the time (Rex and Ruby Johnson) and 37 Packet Page-2479- 1/13/2015 17.C. moved to the trailer park. The origin of the cottages is confirmed through a primary source (Ludlow, personal communication 2006) and through architecture. The absence of bathrooms in the area and the decorative rafter tails on the porch roof (Figure 40) suggest that these three cottages were not constructed by any branch of the military as housing for a dredging or other crew (Nolte, personal communication 2006). ' a> 3x*$E'T�� 1 14 1V rilA I E� �'i h � ¢yix 9 4 1 1 R #�a I' ,r Figure 40. View of the porch-roof on Cottage#9, showing the rounded rafter tails,facing east. Cottages #10 and #11 have the same type of roof and rafter tails. Because they are rare examples of fish camp architecture and are examples of early- twentieth-century accommodations for tourists, PCI considers these cottages potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criteria A and C. Although they were moved from their original location on Marco Island, they remained on Marco Island and continued to be used as cottages for tourists. The cottages have also retained architectural integrity in spite of added bathrooms. The bathrooms could be removed to further enhance the association of the cottages with Florida Gulf Coast fishing in the Ten Thousand Islands in the early twentieth century. Removal of the bathrooms would also reveal the cottages' function as basic shelters. Collier County plans to restore these cottages and use them for historic interpretation. The two cisterns, because they are in place and are intact, and because cisterns were necessary for the growth and survival of any remote tourist park in southern Florida during the first half of the twentieth century at least, are considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criteria A and C. Collier County plans to restore these cisterns and use them for historic interpretation. All other structures within MarGood, including the cottages and theater- . museum building, are also considered potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP. As individual structures, they are part of a property that is associated with events that made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of tourism and recreation in this country. The structures were all built to serve the needs of an emerging Florida tourism that was interested in boating and fishing. MarGood tried to meet the basic needs of its winter customers by providing places to stay, places to park trailers, entertainment, access to boats and water, and potable water and electricity. The individual structures demonstrate how tourism developed in the far reaches of Florida through the creation of tourist parks offering the basic necessities of shelter, public 38 Packet Page -2480- 1/13/2015 17.C. • restrooms and showers, parking areas, boat-launch areas, and entertainment. Collier County. ^ plans to restore the theater-museum building for public use and historic interpretation, and to adapt several of the cottages to new uses in Goodland Harbour Park. The FMSF historic structure forms and the FMSF survey log sheet are located in Appendix A. �_. 39 Packet Page -2481- 1/13/2015 17.C. REFERENCES CITED Antonini, Gustavo A., David A. Fann, and Paul Roat 2002 A Historical Geography of Southwest Florida Waterways. Volume Two: Placida Harbor to Marco Island. Florida Sea Grant and the West Coast Inland Navigation District,Venice, Florida. Bruno,Betty n.d: A Journey Back in Time: The Historical Move of Homes and Families from Caxambas. http:www.goodland.com/history.htm, accessed June 16,2006. • Collier County 1947 Pettit Subdivision. Clerk of the Circuit Court Plat Book 2, Page 88. 1949 Goodland Heights. Clerk of the Circuit Court Plat Book 1, Page 82. Davis, Arnie Gimon 1998 Recollections of Environmental Change in the Ten Thousand Islands, Florida Bay and the Everglades: The Oral History and Social Issues of User Groups in Southwest Florida and the Everglades. Unpublished internship report, Rosenstiel School of Marine and Atmospheric Science, Division of Marine Affairs and Policy, University of . Miami, Coral Gables, Florida. Fessenden, Nancy B. 2003 Pilots, Pinballs, and Politics: A History of the Naples Airport. Trafford Publishing, Canada. First National Bank&Trust Company of Naples 1981 Naples-Marco Island: An Illustrated History. Moran Publishing Corporation, Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Freitus, Joseph, and Anne Freitus 1998 Florida: The War Years, 1938-1945. Wind Canyon Publishing, Inc., Niceville, Florida. Greene,Evangelyne 2004 The Goodland Life: Museum at MarGood Resort Makes.History Come Alive. http://naplesnews.com/npdn/ma features/article.html, accessed June 16, 2006. Rhodes, Harrison Garfield 1912 Guide to Florida for Tourists, Sportsmen and Settlers. Dodd, Mead and Company, New York. Stop, Pam n.d. Colonization of Goodland. http://www.goodlandfla.com/history.html. Accessed June 16, 2006. 40 Packet Page -2482- 1/13/2015 17.C. Tebeau, Charlton W. •-� 1966 Florida's Last Frontier: The History of Collier County. University of Miami Press, Coral Gables,Florida. Waitley, Douglas 1993 The Last Paradise: the Building of Marco Island. The Pickering Press, Inc., Coconut Grove, Florida. Warranty Deed 2005 Indenture between Elhanon Combs and Sandra S. Combs and The Trust for Public Land, Recorded May 5, 2005. Instrument#3610955, Order Book 3791, Page 1888. Local Informants Mrs. Tommie (Kirk) Moss, former Goodland post-mistress, Goodland, personal communication July 7 and July 25, 2006. Mrs. Kappy(Stephens) Kirk, former Goodland post-mistress, Goodland, personal communication July 25,2006. Ms. Jackie (Bianchi) Kranz, owner/operator Pink House Motel, Goodland, personal - communication July 24, 2006. Cecelia Weeks, former Caxambas resident and current Goodland resident, personal communication July 7, 11, 13,25, 31, 2006. Sandra Arnold, Collier County Museum, Veteran Services — Oral History World War II Veterans, Naples,personal communication July 25, 2006 Elhanon Combs, former owner/operator MarGood Resort and RV Park, Naples, personal communication July 25-26, 2006. Sandra Combs, former owner/operator MarGood Resort and RV Park, Naples, personal communication July 25, 2006 David Southall, Curator of Education, Collier County Museum,Naples, personal communication July 31, 2006. Betsy Perdichizzi, Marco Island, Historian,personal communication July 31, 2006. William Perdichizzi, Marco Island,personal communication August 1, 2006. William Ludlow, former Goodland resident 1949-1971, Fort Myers, personal communication July 31, 2006. 41 Packet Page-2483- 1/13/2015 17.C. Marie Ludlow, former Goodland resident 1949-1971 and MarGood employee 1955-1971, Fort Myers,personal communication July 31, 2006. Marion Nicolay, volunteer, Marco Island Historical Society, personal communication August 2, 2006. Non-Local Informants Kelly Nolte, Senior Architectural Historian and Military Specialist, Panamerican Consultants, Inc., Mobile, Alabama,personal communication July 31, 2006. 42 Packet Page -2484- 1/13/2015 17.C. February 19,2014 MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY HISTORICAL/ARCHAEOLOGICAL PRESERVATION BOARD Naples, Florida, February 19, 2014 LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Collier County Historical/ Archaeological Preservation Board in and for the County of Collier, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 9:15 A.M. in REGULAR SESSION at the Collier County Growth Management Division —Planning and Regulation, Conference Room 4610, 2800 North Horseshoe Drive, Naples, Florida with the following members present: CHAIRMAN: William Dempsey (excused) VICE CHAIRMAN: Matthew Betz Patricia Huff(via teleconference) Sharon Kenny Rich Taylor (excused) Craig Woodward (via teleconference) ALSO PRESENT: Ray Bellows, Planning Manager, Zoning Services Fred Reischl, Zoning Services Elizabeth Perdichizzi Nancy Olson, Parks and Recreation Packet Page-2485- 1/13/2015 17.C. February 19,2014 I. Roll+C'a 1 tiendance: The meeting was called to order by Vice Chairman Matthew Betz at 9:18 A.M. Craig Woodward and Patricia Huff requested attendance via teleconference call. A quorum was present. (Elizabeth Perdichizzi participated in the discussions but, did not vote. Her application for the At-large position on the Board had been accepted but not formally voted upon by the BCC. However, she was heartily welcomed back by the remaining HAPB members.) H. Addenda to the Agenda: REMOVE: Under Old Business - C. Horse Creek Estates Historic Designation Update ADD: Under Old Business -E. Mamie Street Issue III. Approval of the Agenda Sharon Kenny moved to approve the Agenda to include the Addenda items noted above. Second by Elizabeth Perdichizzi. Carried unanimously, 4-0. (Elizabeth then withdrew her second, since she was not yet allowed to vote.) Second was by Matthew Betz and carried unanimously, 4-0. IV. Approval of Minutes: November 20, 2013 Craig Woodward moved to approve the Minutes of November 20, 2013, as presented. Second by Patricia Huff. Carried unanimously, 4-0. V. Old Business: A. Vote to fill the HAPB At-large Vacancy Ray Bellows announced Elizabeth Perdichi77i's application was accepted and a formal vote by the HAPB to move it forward to the BCC was the next step. Sharon Kenny moved to nominate Elizabeth Perdichizzi to fill the At-large position on the HistoricaUArchaeological Preservation Board; and, to recommend her acceptance by the BCC Second by Matthew Betz. Carried unanimously, 4-0. B. Margood County Park Historic Designation Revised Application Ray Bellows provided copies of the revised application for Historic Designation for Margood County Park, signed by the County Manager and by Nancy Olson, representing Collier County Parks and Recreation Division, authorizing staff to move forward with the Historic Designation process. Ray Bellows explained the application contents to the conference callers. The HAPB reviewed the application which included restoration of the four cottages and the cistern located on the east side of Petit Drive in Goodland. Sharon Kenny moved to accept the application, as written;and, to enthusiastically move forward the Margood Park Historic Designation application to the Board of County Commissioners for approvaL Second by Matthew Betz. Carried unanimously, 4-0. 2 Packet Page -2486- 1/13/2015 17.C. February 19,2014 C. Horse Creek Estates Designation Update(removed from the Agenda under II) D. Revisions to the Historic Guide Ray Bellows stated the revised legend Patty Huff had sent, changed some of the wording for the site names to reflect how it was shown in the table of contents. The adjustments had been sent to Tim Billings to finalize the map. It will then be sent back to Patty Huff to finalize the Historic Guide project. Patty Huff asked for any other corrections, and there were non. She expressed concern that the funding for the Guide may run out and she had hoped the Guide would be available to the public before the end of the tourist season. She expected five to ten thousand copies would be needed. Ray Bellows responded the funds were there and he will expedite the remaining changes. Fred Reischl noted a technical issue had arisen, in that the vote and condition had not been stated for allowing Craig Woodward and Patricia Huff to participate by phone; and needed HAPB approval. Sharon Kenny moved to approve the attendance of Craig Woodward and Patricia Huff via telephone conference call due to extraordinary circumstances. Second by Matthew Betz. Carried unanimously, 4-0. E. Mamie Street Update Ray Bellows reported the vacation of Mamie Street had been denied by the Board of County Commissioners. He had received notice that Florida Grove was preparing to move forward with finalizing all of their open permits that had been put on hold through the court settlement proceedings. They included: a. renovation of the duplex to make it habitable b. vegetation removal c. work on the seawall Patty Huff asked about what vegetation was to be removed and did that not come under ground disturbance; and, was the road designated historic. Ray Bellows responded the County would not support historic designation of a County maintained road that had been completely redone. Also, the County would not be in favor of any hindrance to future road maintenance for the health and safety of the public. Matthew Betz was concerned about ground disturbance as the whole Island was in an archaeologically sensitive area and work should be monitored by a certified archaeologist. Ray Bellows responded the duplex was not historic. He would have to pull the permit to see what was proposed as far as vegetation removal. (Permits are not brought before-the HAPB) He said a survey and assessment study was done and Florida Grove must abide by its requirements. He will check to see if monitoring was a requirement. The HAPB could make a motion, and he will relay it to the proper party, that the Preservation Board recommends monitoring by a certified archaeologist of any further vegetation removal or ground disturbance as part of the requirements before the permit is closed out. 3 Packet Page -2487- 1/13/2015 17.C. February 19,2014 Matthew Betz moved to recommend to the BCC that the Building Department have a professional archaeologist on site if any earthmoving activity at the Florida Groves' 318 Mamie Street building site takes place;to include the duplex and vegetation removal. Second by Sharon Kenny. Carried unanimously, 4-0. VI. New Business—Handout of Phase 1 Cultural Resource Assessment of the RMC Enclave MPUD Parcel. Fred Reischl distributed, and will e-mail to those HAPB members not present, copies of the Phase 1 Cultural Resource Assessment of the RMC-Enclave MPUD Parcel which will be acted upon at the next HAPB meeting. This will give everyone time to review it prior to the meeting. VII. Public Comments: Elizabeth Perdichizzi asked to comment on: a. One of the local businesses of Marco Island, Sunshine Ace Hardware was focusing on the History of the Island and had requested of her several old photos of the history of the Island which they reproduced all across the top of the store. An artist painted area scenes portraying Caxambas, Marco and Goodland for their ribbon cutting opening and festivities on February 22nd b. Two sold-out presentations of The Presidents Wives to support the Auditorium at the Marco Island Museum. c. Tonight's SWAFAS meeting at which the speaker will talk on The Spanish Ships, their 500 year history in Florida waters, and recent underwater archaeologist's discoveries, as part of a series, at the Bonita Springs Community Center. d. Lee County's discovery that one of their lakes is a sink hole. SWAFAS had petitioned Lee County to purchase the property; whish is part of the County's drinking water system and covers 20 acres. She noted HAPB may be interested in the petition due to discoveries which may be made there. VIII. Board Member Announcements Craig Woodward announced: February 28, 2014—The movie "Wind Across the Everglades"will be shown at the Community Church Fellowship Hall in Everglades City. Reservations needed. Sharon Kenny asked if anyone knew of the movie about the Everglades being shot, in which Dolores Sorey and Clyde Butcher would play a part. Craig Woodward responded the gentleman speaking before the movie on the 28th, (Bud Schulberg), was planning a movie about the Everglades andit may be that one. Craig Woodward further announced: Tuesday, February 25th at 7:00pm in Rose Auditorium- a free talk by Bob Stone of Gainesville on Florida's Cattle Ranching Tuesday,March 4th at 7:00pm a presentation by Dr. Francis on Florida- Rethinking Early History-what happened with the Spanish after Ponce deLeon. Patty Huff announced: Saturday,March 8th at 10:00am, a walking tour of Historic Chokoloskee- 4 Packet Page-2488- 1/13/2015 17.C. February 19,2014 to iclude Smallwood store,the Calusa Indians,the Mound and two cemeteries. Local families will participate in the narrative. It will be a fundraiser for, and sponsored by, the Everglades Historical Society. The next scheduled meeting will be on Wednesday March 19,2014 in Room #610 Collier County Development Services Division,2800 N. Horseshoe Drive. Sharon Kenny moved to adjourn the meeting. Second by Matthew Betz. Carried unanimously, 4-0. There being no further business for the good of the County,the meeting was adjourned by order of the chair at 9:53 A.M. HISTORICAL/ARCHAEOLOGICAL PRESERVATION BOARD r-- z e4 hairs nau,Mat-thew-Beta, 1 iS�tn-� These meeting notes approved by the Board/Committee on 2119 icf. as presented ,1.- or as amended 5 Packet Page -2489- 1/13/2015 17.C. • • 26D )) Wednesday, Decemb; r24,2014 )) NAPLES DAILY NEWS • I NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF INTENT TO CONSIDER A RESOLUTION Notice is hereby given that on Tuesday, January 13, 2015,•in the Board of County Commissioners Meeting Room, Third Floor, Collier Government Center, 3299 East Tamiami Trail, Naples FL., the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) will consider • the enactment of a County Resolution. The meeting will commence at 9:00 A.M. The title of the proposed Resolution is as follows: , The purpose of the hearing is to consider: A Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida designating property commonly known as Mar-Good harbor Park, formerly the Mar-Good Resort Property, as a historically significant site, pursuant to the historic/archaeological preservation regulations as provided in Section 2.03.07.E of the Collier County Land Development Code. The,subject property is located in Goodland in Section 18,Township 52 South,Range 27 East,Collier County,Florida, consisting of 2.62 acres. [Petition HD-2006-AR-106791 A copy of the proposed Resolution is on file with the Clerk to the Board and is available for inspection. All interested parties are invited to attend and be heard. NOTE: All persons wishing to speak on any agenda item must register with the County manager prior to presentation of the agenda item to be addressed. Individual speakers will be limited to 5 minutes on any item. The selection of any individual to speak on behalf of an organization or group is encouraged. If recognized by the Chairman, a spokesperson for a group or organization may be allotted 10 minutes to speak on an item. Persons wishing to have written or graphic materials included in the Board agenda packets must submit said material a minimum of 3 weeks prior to the respective public hearing. In any case, written materials intended to be considered by the Board shall be submitted to the appropriate County staff a minimum of seven days prior to the public hearing. All materials used in presentations before the Board will become a permanent part of the record. Any person who decides to appeal any decision of the Board will need a record of the proceedings pertaining thereto and therefdre, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based. If you are a,person with a disability.who needs any accommodation in order to' participate in this proceeding, you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the.Collier County Facilities Management Department, located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Suite#101, Naples, FL 34112-5356, (239) 252-8380, at least two days prior to the meeting. Assisted listening devices for the hearing impaired are available in the Board of County Commissioners Office. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA TOM HENNING CHAIRMAN DWIGHT E.BROCK,CLERK • By: Teresa Cannon Deputy Clerk(SEAL) December 24.2014 No.2043119 Packet Page -2490-