Agenda 10/10/2017 Item #11G10/10/2017
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to direct the County Manager to deny the request for refunds for the permitting
fees paid by two wildlands fire victims, totaling $4,772.27, from the General Fund.
OBJECTIVE: To direct the County Manager to deny the request for refunds for the permitting fees paid
by two wildlands fire victims, totaling $4,772.27, from the General Fund.
CONSIDERATIONS: During the Board of County Commissioners (Board) meeting on September 26,
2017, agenda item 6A under the public petition, the Board directed the County Manager to bring back an
agenda item for consideration regarding the refund of permitting fees paid by two wildlands fire victims.
The properties involved in the public petition are as follows:
Laurence and Peggy Le Buff
5000 Le Buff Road, Naples, FL 34106
Square Footage: (Existing Home) 971 sq. ft.
Square Footage: (Replacement Home) 1,718 sq. ft.
Permit Number: PRBD20170729575
Total permitting fees paid $2,395.42
Jim Kurth
4895 Le Buff Road, Naples, FL 34106
Square Footage: (Existing Home) 1,902 sq. ft.
Square Footage: (Replacement Home) 2,619 sq. ft.
Permit Number: PRBD20170729583
Total permitting fees paid $2,376.85
The subject properties are included in the attached Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement Case Mast er
Report 17-912, which includes property descriptions and comments on fire damage. The report confirms
that the above listed properties, along with various out buildings, a boat and trailer and small vehicles (all-
terrain vehicle, golf cart and 2 wheeled trailers) were completely consumed by the wildlands fire. Staff is
unaware of insurance coverages or claims for either of the properties.
Fees collected for building and development permits are utilized to fund the full cost of operation for the
majority of the Growth Management Department, Development Services element. Fees collected for
permitting and inspection services performed are considered to be non-refundable. A decision to approve
this request would set precedence for future refund requests, which could include large projects, such as
the YMCA project which incurred major fire damage and the permitting fees totaling $182,991.99. Future
approvals of this nature could result in significant costs to the taxpayers of Collier County.
FISCAL IMPACT: The fiscal impact consists of permitting fees, totaling $4,772.27, which will be
refunded from the General Fund. However, the precedence of this request may have potentially large
fiscal repercussions for the County’s General Fund.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management plan impact associated with
this action.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney, raises no legal
issue, and requires majority vote for approval. -JAK
10/10/2017
RECOMMENDATION: To direct the County Manager to deny the request for refunds for the
permitting fees paid by two wildlands fire victims, totaling $4,772.27, from the General Fund.
Prepared by: Stephanie Amann, Manager, Financial and Operational Support, Operations and
Regulatory Management Division
Caroline Cilek, Manager, Building Plan Review and Inspection Division
Richard Long, Director, Building Plan Review and Inspection Division
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. 17-912_CasePDF_73281647 (PDF)
10/10/2017
COLLIER COUNTY
Board of County Commissioners
Item Number: 11.G
Doc ID: 3862
Item Summary: Recommendation to direct the County Manager to deny the request for refunds
for the permitting fees paid by two wildlands fire victims, totaling $4,772.27, from the General Fund.
(James French, Deputy Department Head, Growth Management Department)
Meeting Date: 10/10/2017
Prepared by:
Title: Manager - LDC – Building Plan Review & Inspections
Name: Caroline Cilek
10/02/2017 5:00 PM
Submitted by:
Title: Director - Building Plans Review & Inspections – Building Plan Review & Inspections
Name: Richard Long
10/02/2017 5:00 PM
Approved By:
Review:
Building Plan Review & Inspections Judy Puig Additional Reviewer Skipped 10/03/2017 3:35 PM
Growth Management Department Judy Puig Level 1 Reviewer Completed 10/03/2017 3:38 PM
Growth Management Department James French Deputy Department Head Review Completed 10/03/2017 3:39 PM
Growth Management Department Thaddeus Cohen Department Head Review Completed 10/03/2017 3:44 PM
County Attorney's Office Jeffrey A. Klatzkow Level 3 County Attorney's Office Review Completed 10/03/2017 4:18 PM
Office of Management and Budget Valerie Fleming Level 3 OMB Gatekeeper Review Completed 10/03/2017 4:49 PM
Budget and Management Office Mark Isackson Additional Reviewer Completed 10/03/2017 4:55 PM
County Manager's Office Leo E. Ochs Level 4 County Manager Review Completed 10/04/2017 12:16 PM
Board of County Commissioners MaryJo Brock Meeting Pending 10/10/2017 9:00 AM
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementCase Master Report 17-912Date Initiated 03/08/2017
Primary InformationDepartment:Department of Agriculture and Consumer Serv.Division:Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement - AgLawBureau:Bureau of Investigative ServicesRegion:Investigative Region 7Lead LEO:Feiner, Tara Inv. (Investigative Region 7 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Type Of Case:Fire RelatedCase Sub Type:IncendiaryCase Description:Lee Williams Rd. FireTotal Time:51:30
Case StatusCase Status:CLOSEDCase Status Date:03/20/2017Case Referral Code:ForestryDisposition Code:CLOSED EXCEPTIONALLYDisposition Date:03/20/2017Dissemination:Closed Case
03/28/2017 16:47:57 Page 1 of 1
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Primary InformationDescription:Lee Williams Road FireOccurrence From:03/05/2017 14:02Occurrence To:03/20/2017 12:00Source Of Info:DOFSource Reliability:COMPLETELY RELIABLEDissemination Code:Recommend Case ClosureContent Evaluation:POSSIBLY TRUEReporting LEO:Feiner, Tara Inv. (Investigative Region 7 / Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement)Mileage:880Approval Status:ApprovedApproved Date:03/20/2017Approved By:Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)
Agency Reference NumbersAgency Case/File NumberCaloosahatchee Forestry Center 2017-17-0088Caloosahatchee Forestry Center Lee Williams Road Fire (11)
SynopsisLee Williams Road Fire Investigation Complete.Caloosahatchee Forestry Center Lee Williams Road Fire (11)Incident 2017-17-0088, 7230 Acres in total.
Address #1 - LOCATION OF EVENT #1 - 1015 Snake RdPrimary InformationAddress:1015 Snake Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Address #2 - LOCATION OF EVENT #2 - 1501 Snake RdPrimary InformationAddress:1501 Snake Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Address #3 - LOCATION OF EVENT #3 - 4980 Lebuff RdPrimary InformationAddress:4980 Lebuff Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:this was a 3 bedroom, two bath residence prior to the fire that consumed it
Comments:This is a residence that was consumed by a wild lands fire. There were multiple vehicles (go cart, trailer, golf car andbicycles burned up also.
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 1 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Address #4 - LOCATION OF EVENT #4 - 5000 Lebuff RdPrimary InformationAddress:5000 Lebuff Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:this was a two bedroom, two bath frame home prior to the fire consuming itComments:This was a frame house that was built in 1968 and was uninsured
Address #5 - LOCATION OF EVENT #5 - 5700 Lee Williams RdPrimary InformationAddress:5700 Lee Williams Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Address #6 - LOCATION OF EVENT #6 - 5721 Lee Williams RDPrimary InformationAddress:5721 Lee Williams RD, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
SubjectsRelationship Name Bio DOBHome Address Huber, Janneke (-) (PERSON)54 yr. old, WHITE, FEMALE 04/05/1962Home Address Wilkins, Weston R. (PERSON)59 yr. old, WHITE, MALE 12/19/1957
Address #7 - LOCATION OF EVENT #7 - 985 Snake RdPrimary InformationAddress:985 Snake Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Address #8 - Victim's Address #1 - 4895 Le Buffs RdPrimary InformationAddress:4895 Le Buffs Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:Fire Scene
SubjectsRelationship Name Bio DOBHome Address Kurth, Jim (PERSON)WHITE, MALE ---
Address #9 - Victim's Address #2 - 5180 Benfield RdPrimary InformationAddress:5180 Benfield Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:Fire scene
SubjectsRelationship Name Bio DOBHome Address Waldeck, Todd (PERSON)56 yr. old, WHITE, MALE 02/25/1961
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 2 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Subject #1 - Assisting Agency #1 - Florida Forest Service, Caloosahatchee F.C.Primary InformationSubject Name:Florida Forest Service, Caloosahatchee F.C.Record Type:AGENCYJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:Assisting Agency of
AddressesRelationship AddressBusiness Address 10941 Palm Beach Blvd Division of Forestry, Ft. Myers, FLORIDA 33905 , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressBUSINESS(239) 690-3500 (BUSINESS)FAX (239) 690-3504 ()
Subject #2 - Lead Agency #1 - Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementPrimary InformationSubject Name:Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementRecord Type:AGENCYJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:Lead Agency of
Business DescriptionBusiness Type:GOVERNMENT/PUBLIC BLDGState Organized:FL
AddressesRelationship AddressBusiness Address 2005 Apalachee Parkway Terry Rhodes, Tallahassee, FLORIDA 32399 , United States of AmericaBusiness Address 2005 Apalachee Parkway, Suite 222 Terry Lee Rhodes, Tallahassee, FLORIDA 32399 , United States ofAmericaBusiness Address 2005 Apalachee Pkwy #121 Terry Rhodes Building, Tallahassee, FLORIDA 32301 , United States ofAmerica
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressBUSINESS(800) 342-5869 (BUSINESS)BUSINESS (850) 245-1300 (BUSINESS)
VehiclesRelationship Tag #VIN #VehicleDescriptionOWNERACS 28172 1FTPX14V66NB57808 2006 FORD F-150 (WHITE) - AUTOMOBILEOWNERACS111084T1SK13E0SU6428721995 TOYOTA Camry (GREEN) - AUTOMOBILEOWNERACS28379---2007 FORD - AUTOMOBILE
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 3 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Subject #2 - Lead Agency #1 - Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement - ContinuedVehicles - ContinuedRelationship Tag #VIN #VehicleDescriptionOWNERW60HPH---6 TOYOTA Avalon - AUTOMOBILE
Alias InformationAliasAgLawHeadquartersOALE
Subject #3 - DOF Pilot #1 - Gilham, Kenneth A.Primary InformationSubject Name:Gilham, Kenneth A.Record Type:Government OfficialBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:DOF Pilot of
SubjectsRelationship Name Bio DOBEMPLOYERFlorida Forest Service, Caloosahatchee F.C.(AGENCY)---
Subject #4 - DOF Ranger #1 - Fischer, BobPrimary InformationSubject Name:Fischer, BobRecord Type:Government OfficialBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:DOF Ranger of
Subject #5 - DOF Ranger #2 - Garcia, FrankPrimary InformationSubject Name:Garcia, FrankRecord Type:Government OfficialBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:DOF Ranger of
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 4 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Subject #6 - DOF Ranger #3 - Nicoletti, MarkPrimary InformationSubject Name:Nicoletti, MarkRecord Type:Government OfficialBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:DOF Ranger of
Subject #7 - PROPERTY OWNER #1 - Cure, DonPrimary InformationSubject Name:Cure, DonRecord Type:PERSONBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressHome Address 1501 Snake Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 404-2518 (CELLULAR)
Subject #8 - PROPERTY OWNER #2 - House, HughPrimary InformationSubject Name:House, HughRecord Type:PERSONBio:UNKNOWN, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressIncident Location 5700 Lee Williams Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 253-3223 (CELLULAR)
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 5 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Subject #9 - PROPERTY OWNER #3 - Kurth, JimPrimary InformationSubject Name:Kurth, JimRecord Type:PERSONBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressHome Address 4895 Le Buffs Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 293-0305 (CELLULAR)
Subject #10 - PROPERTY OWNER #4 - Valdes, Luis GPrimary InformationSubject Name:Valdes, Luis GRecord Type:PERSONBio:HISPANIC, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressHome Address 1015 Snake Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (786) 366-0717 (CELLULAR)
Subject #11 - PROPERTY OWNER #5 - Waldeck, ToddPrimary InformationSubject Name:Waldeck, ToddRecord Type:PERSONBio:56 yr. old, WHITE, MALEBirth Date:02/25/1961Juvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 6 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Subject #11 - PROPERTY OWNER #5 - Waldeck, Todd - ContinuedAddressesRelationshipAddressHome Address 5180 Benfield Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 398-0131 (CELLULAR)
Subject #12 - PROPERTY OWNER #6 - Welkins, WesPrimary InformationSubject Name:Welkins, WesRecord Type:PERSONBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressHome Address 5721 Lee Williams RD, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 353-2157 (CELLULAR)
Subject #13 - PROPERTY OWNER #7 - Wood, WaynePrimary InformationSubject Name:Wood, WayneRecord Type:PERSONBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressHome Address 985 Snake Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 455-7462 (CELLULAR)
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 7 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Subject #14 - VICTIM #1 - Harrison, DrewPrimary InformationSubject Name:Harrison, DrewRecord Type:PERSONBio:60 yr. old, WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:VICTIM of
Subject #15 - VICTIM #2 - LeBuff, LaurencePrimary InformationSubject Name:LeBuff, LaurenceRecord Type:PERSONBio:73 yr. old, WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:VICTIM of
Personal InformationUS Citizen:Yes
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressHOME(239) 457-1950 (RESIDENTIAL)
IdentificationsID Type Number State Country As Of Date Fictitious CommentDrivers License L110524444420 FLORIDA United States ofAmerica ---No ---
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationshipNumber/E-AddressLISTED ON DOCUMENT (239) 348-7557 (BUSINESS)
Property #1 - 1015 Snake RoadPrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:TrailerDescription:1015 Snake RoadQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 8 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Property #2 - 985 Snake RoadPrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:PLANTS/CITRUSDescription:985 Snake RoadQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
Property #3 - 985 Snake Road/BBQ GrillPrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:MISCELLANEOUSDescription:985 Snake Road/BBQ GrillQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
Property #4 - 985 Snake Road/Hot TubPrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:MISCELLANEOUSDescription:985 Snake Road/Hot TubQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
Property #5 - 5700 Lee Williams Road/Wire FencePrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:MISCELLANEOUSDescription:5700 Lee Williams Road/Wire FenceQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
Property #6 - 5000 LeBuff RoadPrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:STRUCTURE
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 9 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Property #6 - 5000 LeBuff Road - ContinuedPrimary Information - ContinuedDescription:5000 LeBuff RoadQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
Property #7 - 5180 Benfield RoadPrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:STRUCTUREDescription:5180 Benfield RoadQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
Property #8 - 4895 LeBuff RoadPrimary InformationProperty Class:DamagedProperty Type:STRUCTUREDescription:4895 LeBuff RoadQuantity:1Submitted To:NoneCollected Date/Time:03/08/2017 15:54
OfficersLEOHochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Hopkins, Daniel Inv. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Kohler, Mark Edward Inv. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Raulerson, T. G. Lt. (Investigative Region 4 / Regulatory Investigative Section)
Record Status InformationRecord Origination Operator:Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Record Origination Date:03/08/2017 15:54Last Update Operator:Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Last Update Date:03/20/2017 13:53
Reporting LEO Date Supervisor DateFeiner, Tara Inv. (Investigative Region 7 /Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement)3/28/2017 Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6/ Regulatory Investigative Section)3/28/2017
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 10 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative 17-912Report Date: 03/08/2017
Narrative begins on the following page.
03/28/2017 16:47:58 Page 11 of 14
Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement
Investigator Feiner #2702
Case: 17-912
Investigative Report: Florida Forest Service
Lee Williams Road Fire (11)
Incident: 2017-17-0088
On 03/06/2017, at approximately 1730hrs, I was contacted about a large wildland fire located
within the Picayune Strand State Forest in Collier County Florida. The Florida Forest Service
assigned incident number 2017-17-0088 and named it Lee Williams Road (11).
A review of the weather conditions reported by the Florida Forest Service revealed that on
March 5, 2017, the winds at the Caloosahatchee Forestry Office were from the ENE at 18mph,
the temperature was 77 degrees Fahrenheit with a relative humidity of 38%. Fire Readiness
was at a Level 2. The acreage of the fire at initial contact by FFS was 33 acres. Wind conditions
and dry fuels quickly increased the size to several hundred acres. On 03/12/2017, the total
acreage of the fire was 7,230 acres.
Investigation
On 03/07/2017, I arrived at the scene. An incident command center had been established at
8075 Lely Cultural Parkway, Naples, Florida. I contacted the Florida Forest Service to inform
them of my presence and to advise that I would be the primary Investigator on the case. I was
briefed on the incident by FFS Park Ranger, William Muirhead. I followed Ranger Muirhed to
the suspected origin area, located at 5700 Lee Williams Rd., Naples, FL 34117. I then exited my
vehicle and began my investigation by walking the perimeter of the possible origin area.
Fire indicators and weather conditions revealed that the fire moved in a west-southwest
direction. An examination of charring, protection and foliage freeze in the burned area led to
the possible area of origin of the fire appearing to be located on the property. The head fire
moved west from this location, jumped Lee Williams Road, and continued moving west. The
fire burned down a barbed wire fence on the property as it moved west and crossed a
chain-link fence to the south. Strong winds at the time of the fire aided in the fire moving and
spreading quickly. Charring was evident on most of the trees up to at least 20 ft. or more,
indicating that the fire grew in strength from the area of origin. No ignition sources,
accelerants, or evidence of arson was located at the scene. There was no lightning reported in
the area on the date of the fire and the fire was not near a railway. A power pole was located
just outside the burned area, but it was not damaged.
The evident charring and protection on the palm and pine trees in the area, foliage freeze and
evident backing fire indicate that area of origin is in the northeastern area of the burned area
on the property.
On 03/08/2017, Lts. Hochuli and Raulerson met me at the fire scene and conducted an origin
and cause investigation. Their findings were also consistent with my original findings which is a
probable origin area on the northeastern side of the property located at 5700 Lee Williams
Road. A search of the area of origin area was again conducted, but no ignition sources could
be located.
On 03/10/2017, FFS Rangers Fischer, Garcia and Nicoletti accompanied Lt. Hochuli and I to the
area of origin. They were the first rangers to respond to the fire. Ranger Garcia stated that the
area to the south of the area of origin was already burned when he arrived on scene, however,
the property at 5700 Lee Williams Rd. was fully involved. The Rangers further advised the
same south area on the property in question had burned about a year prior and may not have
had much fuel, making it burn more quickly. Ranger Garcia began his suppression efforts by
cutting a line around the burning area which included the property at 5700 and to the south of
the property. He then began cutting a line from Lee Williams Rd. to the west beginning just
north of the 5700 Lee Williams Rd. property gate. The rangers stated that fire was burning at a
high rate when they arrived and had already crossed Lee Williams Rd. to the west and was
moving at a high rate of speed.
Interviews and Damage Assessment
On 03/07/2017, Inv. Feiner interviewed Wayne Wood.,residing at 985 Snake Rd.Naples, FL
34117, Tel (239) 455-7462 relative to the wildfire damage he sustained. Mr. Wood
stated that his hot tub and barbeque grill was completely lost due to the fire. He was not home
at the time of the fire. Inv. Feiner walked the property obtained and observed the following:
Inv. Feiner walked the property obtained and observed the following:
1.Hot Tub) on the property destroyed $5000.00
2.Barbeque Grill Area $2000.00
3.Foliage $1000.00
On 03/07/2017, Inv. Feiner interviewed Luis G. Valdes Jr.,via telephone, Tel (786) 366-0717,
relative to the wildfire damage he sustained on his property located at 1015 Snake Rd.Naples,
FL34117. Mr. Valdez stated that his trailer was completely lost due to the fire. He also advised
that the trailer is empty and no one resides inside of it. He was not home at the time of the
fire. Inv. Feiner walked the property obtained and observed the following:
1. Empty (Mobile) on the property destroyed, estimated damage $5,000.00.
On 03/08/1017, Inv. Feiner interviewed Don Cure, residing at 1501 Snake Rd., Naples, FL
34117, Tel (239) 404-2518 relative to the wildfire damage he sustained. Cure stated that he
called 911 Emergency Dispatch to report the fire. On 03/05/2017. He did not see anyone in
the area and did not know how the fire started. He sustained no property damage.
On 03/10/1017, Inv. Feiner interviewed Wes Welkins residing at 5721 Lee Williams Road,
Naples, FL 34117, Tel (786) 366-0717 relative to the wildfire damage he sustained. Mr. Welkins
stated he sustained no property damage due to the fire. Welkins stated that he had trouble
with his neighbor Don Cure in the past and is suspicious Cure started the fire. Welkins did
admit however that he has no evidence.
On 03/14/1017, Inv. Feiner contacted Hugh House, the property owner of 5700 Lee Williams
Road, Naples, FL 34117, Tel (239) 253-3223 relative to the wildfire damage he sustained. Mr.
House stated he was not interested in continuing the conversation because he was not
interested at all. An inspection of the property showed approximately 50yds of barbed wire
fence and poles destroyed. Damage estimated at $1,000.00.
On 3/9/2017, Investigators Hopkins and Kohler were assigned to conduct damage assessments
and scene documentation of additional damage incurred by the wild fire. For further details
regarding their damage assessments, see attached supplemental reports
Conclusions
No ignition sources were found in or around the area of origin of the fire. There was no
lightning reported in the area on 03/05/2017, and the area of origin is not near any railroad
tracks. There is one powerline pole next to the burned area, but it was undamaged. No
witnesses to the fire starting have been located and no persons were observed in the area on
the date of the fire. However, human causes cannot be ruled out. High winds, dry conditions
and plentiful fuel caused the fire to burn quickly and move rapidly from east to west-southwest
and jump several lines established by the FFS. An investigation of the fire scene, burn
indicators and weather conditions conclude that the area of origin of the fire is most likely
located on the northeastern side near the driveway and gate area located at 5700 Lee Williams
Rd., Naples, FL 34117, map coordinates Lat 26’ 7’ 47”, Lon 81; 34; 51”. This is a vacant lot
owned by Hugh House. The cause of this fire is undetermined.
Case Closed.
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/1Report Date: 03/09/2017
Primary InformationDescription:update of case informationOccurrence From:03/05/2017 00:00Occurrence To:03/09/2017 00:00Source Of Info:on sceneSource Reliability:CAN NOT BE JUDGEDDissemination Code:Case ContinuationReporting LEO:Kohler, Mark Edward Inv. (Investigative Region 6 / Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement)Mileage:100Approval Status:ApprovedApproved Date:03/20/2017Approved By:Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)
Agency Reference NumbersAgency Case/File NumberFlorida Forest Service, Caloosahatchee F.C.2017-17-0088
SynopsisA wild lands fire that began on Sunday (3-5-2017) and burned it's way to this location. The building and the barn at 5000 LeBuff Roadwere a total loss. A tractor was also burned up along with a small barn. The house at 4980 LeBuff Road was totally consumed by thefire along with a number of small vehicles (atv, golf car and a 2 wheeled trailer). Photos were taken of both locations. 5000 LeBuff(owned by Laurence LeBuff) was uninsured. It is unknown at this time if the owner of 4980 LeBuff (Drew Harrison) was insured. Mr.LeBuff stated that he believes his loss is around $500,000.00 He further added that he has been a resident here since 1968 and all ofhis memorabilia was lost in the fire and he only managed to save his pickup truck.
Address #1 - LOCATION OF EVENT #1 - 4980 Lebuff RdPrimary InformationAddress:4980 Lebuff Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:this was a 3 bedroom, two bath residence prior to the fire that consumed it
Comments:This is a residence that was consumed by a wild lands fire. There were multiple vehicles (go cart, trailer, golf car andbicycles burned up also.
Address #2 - LOCATION OF EVENT #2 - 5000 Lebuff RdPrimary InformationAddress:5000 Lebuff Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:this was a two bedroom, two bath frame home prior to the fire consuming itComments:This was a frame house that was built in 1968 and was uninsured
Subject #1 - VICTIM #1 - Harrison, DrewPrimary InformationSubject Name:Harrison, DrewRecord Type:PERSON
03/28/2017 16:48:00 Page 1 of 4
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/1Report Date: 03/09/2017
Subject #1 - VICTIM #1 - Harrison, Drew - ContinuedPrimary Information - ContinuedBio:60 yr. old, WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:VICTIM of
Subject #2 - VICTIM #2 - LeBuff, LaurencePrimary InformationSubject Name:LeBuff, LaurenceRecord Type:PERSONBio:73 yr. old, WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:VICTIM of
Personal InformationUS Citizen:Yes
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressHOME(239) 457-1950 (RESIDENTIAL)
IdentificationsID Type Number State Country As Of Date Fictitious CommentDrivers License L110524444420 FLORIDA United States ofAmerica ---No ---
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationshipNumber/E-AddressSUBJECT'S TELEPHONE (239) 457-1950 (RESIDENTIAL)
Record Status InformationRecord Origination Operator:Kohler, Mark Edward Inv. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Record Origination Date:03/09/2017 14:14Last Update Operator:Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Last Update Date:03/20/2017 10:24
Reporting LEO Date Supervisor DateKohler, Mark Edward Inv. (InvestigativeRegion 6 / Office of Agricultural LawEnforcement)3/28/2017 Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6/ Regulatory Investigative Section)3/28/2017
03/28/2017 16:48:00 Page 2 of 4
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/1Report Date: 03/09/2017
Narrative begins on the following page.
03/28/2017 16:48:00 Page 3 of 4
Aciss 17-912/1
03/09/2017
Investigator Mark E. Kohler
Narrative
Wildland fire in Collier County, FL.
I was assigned this incident by Lt. Hochuli at 9:00am on 3-9-2017. Upon arrival at the
Collier County EOC at 10:00am of the same date, I was met by a representative of
Forestry and advised that the burned dwellings were located on LeBuff Road.
I responded to LeBuff Road and located the first burned up house at 4980 LeBuff
Road. There were no people at the scene. I walked around the burned area and took
photos of the buildings and the burned vehicles. The photos are attached to this report.
Estimated loss is $215,000.00.
I then responded to 5000 LeBuff Road (next door) and was met by Mr. Laurence
LeBuff, the owner of 5000 LeBuff Road. Mr. LeBuff advised that he had evacuated the
premises on Sunday and when he came back on Wednesday, the fire had destroyed
his house and barn. He went on to say that he was uninsured. Mr. LeBuff stated that his
neighbor at 4980 LeBuff was named Drew Harrison but did not know Harrison’s date of
birth, telephone number or current whereabouts. I took photos of the fire scene and
attached same to this report. Estimated loss is $500,000.00.
On 9-20-2017, I completed a photo log and entered same into this report.
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/2Report Date: 03/09/2017
Primary InformationDescription:Damage AssessmentOccurrence From:03/04/2017 00:00Occurrence To:03/07/2017 00:00Source Of Info:InvestigatorSource Reliability:COMPLETELY RELIABLEDissemination Code:Case ContinuationContent Evaluation:CONFIRMEDReporting LEO:Hopkins, Daniel Inv. (Investigative Region 6 / Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement)Mileage:100Approval Status:ApprovedApproved Date:03/20/2017Approved By:Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)
Agency Reference NumbersAgency Case/File NumberFlorida Forest Service, Caloosahatchee F.C.2017-17-0088
SynopsisAssist with Damage Assessment
Address #1 - Victim's Address #1 - 4895 Le Buffs RdPrimary InformationAddress:4895 Le Buffs Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:Fire Scene
SubjectsRelationship Name Bio DOBHome Address Kurth, Jim (PERSON)WHITE, MALE ---
Address #2 - Victim's Address #2 - 5180 Benfield RdPrimary InformationAddress:5180 Benfield Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of AmericaDescription:Fire scene
SubjectsRelationship Name Bio DOBHome Address Waideck, Todd (PERSON)56 yr. old, WHITE, MALE 02/25/1961
Subject #1 - PROPERTY OWNER #1 - Kurth, JimPrimary InformationSubject Name:Kurth, Jim
03/28/2017 16:48:02 Page 1 of 4
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/2Report Date: 03/09/2017
Subject #1 - PROPERTY OWNER #1 - Kurth, Jim - ContinuedPrimary Information - ContinuedRecord Type:PERSONBio:WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressHome Address 4895 Le Buffs Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 293-0305 (CELLULAR)
Subject #2 - PROPERTY OWNER #2 - Waldeck, ToddPrimary InformationSubject Name:Waldeck, ToddRecord Type:PERSONBio:56 yr. old, WHITE, MALEBirth Date:02/25/1961Juvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:PROPERTY OWNER of
AddressesRelationship AddressHome Address 5180 Benfield Rd, Naples, FLORIDA , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressCELLULAR PHONE (239) 398-0131 (CELLULAR)
Subject #3 - WITNESS #1 - LeBuff, LaurencePrimary InformationSubject Name:LeBuff, LaurenceRecord Type:PERSONBio:73 yr. old, WHITE, MALEJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:WITNESS of
03/28/2017 16:48:02 Page 2 of 4
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/2Report Date: 03/09/2017
Subject #3 - WITNESS #1 - LeBuff, Laurence - ContinuedPersonal InformationUS Citizen:Yes
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressHOME(239) 457-1950 (RESIDENTIAL)
IdentificationsID Type Number State Country As Of Date Fictitious CommentDrivers License L110524444420 FLORIDA United States ofAmerica ---No ---
Record Status InformationRecord Origination Operator:Hopkins, Daniel Inv. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Record Origination Date:03/09/2017 14:44Last Update Operator:Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Last Update Date:03/20/2017 08:48
Reporting LEO Date Supervisor DateHopkins, Daniel Inv. (Investigative Region6 / Office of Agricultural LawEnforcement)3/28/2017 Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6/ Regulatory Investigative Section)3/28/2017
Narrative begins on the following page.
03/28/2017 16:48:02 Page 3 of 4
17-912/2
March 9, 2017
Hopkins, Daniel Inv. OALE
This is a case of a Wild Land Fire in an area of Collier County Florida with several
destroyed homes and property. Investigator Hopkins was assigned to assist in the
damage assessment of the properties in the Le Buff Road and Benfield Road area.
5180 Benfield Road, Naples, Florida; The home, which had been a stilt home, was
destroyed as were property surrounding the home including a 1987 Chevrolet Pickup
Truck. The property owner was present at the scene and is Todd Waldeck, W/M DOB
02/25/1961. The scene was documented using digital photography and those photos
are attached to this report. Total property loss is estimated at $200,000.00.
4895 Le Buff Road, Naples, Florida; The home, a two-story home, was destroyed as
was a Boat and trailer adjacent to the home and two out buildings. According to the
neighbor across the street, Laurence Le Buff, the owner at 4895 might be a Jim Kurth.
The scene was documented by digital photographs which have been attached to this
report. Total property loss is estimated at $215,000.00.
This case is ongoing.
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/3Report Date: 03/17/2017
Primary InformationDescription:Assisted with Lee Williams Fire 2017-17-0088Occurrence From:03/08/2017 00:00Occurrence To:03/08/2017 00:00Source Reliability:COMPLETELY RELIABLEDissemination Code:Case ContinuationContent Evaluation:CONFIRMEDReporting LEO:Raulerson, T. G. Lt. (Investigative Region 4 / Office of Agricultural Law Enforcement)Mileage:292Approval Status:ApprovedApproved Date:03/28/2017Approved By:Whitman, Michael Capt. (Bureau of Investigative Services / FDACS/OALE)
Agency Reference NumbersAgency Case/File NumberFlorida Forest Service 2017-17-0088
SynopsisAssistance with origin and cause of the Lee Williams Road fire FMIS 2017-17-0088
Address #1 - LOCATION OCCURED #1 - 5700 Lee Williams RdPrimary InformationAddress:5700 Lee Williams Rd, Naples, FLORIDA 34117 , United States of America
Subject #1 - Reporting Agency #1 - Florida Forest Service, Caloosahatchee F.C.Primary InformationSubject Name:Florida Forest Service, Caloosahatchee F.C.Record Type:AGENCYJuvenile:No
Relationship InformationRelated Offense:Reporting Agency of
AddressesRelationship AddressBusiness Address 10941 Palm Beach Blvd Division of Forestry, Ft. Myers, FLORIDA 33905 , United States of America
Telephones / E-AddressesRelationship Number/E-AddressBUSINESS(239) 690-3500 (BUSINESS)FAX (239) 690-3504 ()
03/28/2017 16:48:03 Page 1 of 4
Office of Agricultural Law EnforcementInvestigative Supplement 17-912/3Report Date: 03/17/2017
OfficersLEOFeiner, Tara Inv. (Investigative Region 7 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Hochuli, Daniel Lt. (Investigative Region 6 / Regulatory Investigative Section)
Record Status InformationRecord Origination Operator:Raulerson, T. G. Lt. (Investigative Region 4 / Regulatory Investigative Section)Record Origination Date:03/17/2017 10:32Last Update Operator:Whitman, Michael Capt. (Bureau of Investigative Services / FDACS/OALE)Last Update Date:03/28/2017 16:10
Reporting LEO Date Supervisor DateRaulerson, T. G. Lt. (Investigative Region4 / Office of Agricultural LawEnforcement)3/28/2017 Whitman, Michael Capt. (Bureau ofInvestigative Services / FDACS/OALE)3/28/2017
Narrative begins on the following page.
03/28/2017 16:48:03 Page 2 of 4
Case # 17-912/3
Lt. Thomas Raulerson
Lee Williams Road Fire
On 3/8/2017 I was requested by my chain of command to assist Inv. Feiner with a fire origin and cause
investigation in Collier County. The fire occurred in or around the Picayune Strand State Forest and was
assigned Florida Forest Service (FFS) number 2017-17-0088. The address for the origin of the fire was
relayed to me as 5700 Lee Williams Rd. Naples, FL.
On the same date at approximately 11:00 am I arrived at 5700 Lee Williams Rd. I approached the area
from the south on Lee Williams Road and stopped at the edge of the burned area. There I met with Inv.
Feiner and Lt. Hochuli. We discussed the facts and circumstances related to the fire and weather
conditions on 3/5/2017, the date of the fire. FFS reported that at the time the fire was reported the
winds were out of the ENE at 18mph and the relative humidity was 38%. A check of the Florida
Automated Weather Network historical data showed that the ENE winds with speeds ranging from 17
to 27 mph were present for most of the day on 3/5/2017.
From Lee Williams Road I looked east and was able to observe approximately a third of an acre that had
burned. This area was bordered on the west by Lee Williams Road. The south side property was
bordered by a chain link fence and power line that paralleled the property line. The east side of the
burned area was bordered by unburned vegetation. On the north side of the fire was a path/driveway
for entering and exiting the property from Lee Williams Road. The entrance from Lee Williams to the
property was gated. During Fire suppression activities FFS firefighters had cut in a plow line around the
entire burned area at 5700 Lee Williams Road.
I entered the burned area from Lee Williams along the south side of the burn. As I walked to the east I
observed burn patterns, charring and freezing that would indicate I was in the area of a flanking fire. As I
continued to the east I observed the power pole, carrying the powerline, was well clear of the burned
area to the east and showed no signs of damage or arcing. As I proceeded, I began to turn to the north
transitioning to the heel of the fire. All indicators showed this to be an area of backing fire. I continued
around the fire and as I approached the driveway on the north side of the fire the indicators again
revealed a flanking fire. As I followed the driveway toward Lee Williams road, I entered an area were
the intensity of the fire was very low.
I conducted a closer examination of this area. This area had a thick layer of pine needles that burned
only on the top layer of needles. If the ground in this area was disturbed it revealed unburned fuel. This
burned area was outside of the line cut in by FFS. I followed it north for approximately 20 feet to the
center of the driveway. On the driveway was a spot approximately 18 inches in diameter, where the
debris on the ground was almost completely consumed. This spot was about 15 feet from the entrance
gate to the property. When standing on the north side of the driveway, behind the burned area there
appears to be a “V” pattern that burned to the south to the area of the main fire. I was able to
determine that this area is in the area of origin but it is unclear if this area burned before or after the
plow line was cut in by FFS personnel. This area of origin is consistent with a low intensity fire that
burned from this area of origin to the South, 20 to 30 feet, until finding sufficient fuel to flare up and
have the prevailing ENE winds cause the fire to spot over Lee Williams Road. After spotting over the
road the fire created a head fire that continued to burn to the WSW.
A thorough search of the origin area was conducted and no evidence of an ignition source was located.
Based on investigative findings, equipment use, normal human activity nor intentional lighting of the
fire can be ruled out as a cause of this fire. Therefore, the cause of this fire is undetermined