Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Agenda 06/20/2017
PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION Municipal Services Taxing & Benefit Unit NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING TUESDAY, JUNE 20, 2017 THE LANDSCAPE & SAFETY COMMITTEE OF THE PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION WILL MEET AT 10:15 AM ON JUNE 20 AT THE COMMUNITY CENTER AT PELICAN BAY, LOCATED AT 8960 HAMMOCK OAK DRIVE, NAPLES, FL 34108. AGENDA 1. Call to order 2. Pledge of allegiance 3. Agenda approval 4. Approval of 05/16/17 meeting minutes 5. Audience comments 6. Administrator's Report and Updates a. *Oak Lake Sanctuary noise abatement b. *LED bulb conversion c. *Gulf Park Drive median cut-through 7. *Right turn only onto US 41 at Gulf Park Drive 8. Pelican Bay sidewalks 9. Adjournment *indicates possible action item ANY PERSON WISHING TO SPEAK ON AN AGENDA ITEM WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES PER ITEM TO ADDRESS THE BOARD. THE BOARD WILL SOLICIT PUBLIC COMMENTS ON SUBJECTS NOT ON THIS AGENDA AND ANY PERSON WISHING TO SPEAK WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES. THE BOARD ENCOURAGES YOU TO SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS IN WRITING IN ADVANCE OF THE MEETING. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD IS MADE, WHICH INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY WHO NEEDS AN ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING YOU ARE ENTITLED TO THE PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PLEASE CONTACT THE PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION AT (239) 597-1749 OR VISIT PELICANBAYSERVICESDIVISION.NET. 6/14/2017 2:14 PM PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION LANDSCAPE & SAFETY COMMITTEE MEETING MAY 16,2017 The Landscape & Safety Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division met on Tuesday, May 16 at 10:15 a.m. at the Community Center at Pelican Bay, located at 8960 Hammock Oak Drive, Naples, Florida 34108. The following members attended. Landscape & Safety Committee Mike Shepherd Joe Chicurel, Chairman Scott Streckenbein (ex-officio) Tom Cravens Gary Ventress (absent) Bohdan Hirniak (absent) Pelican Bay Services Division Staff Mary McCaughtry, Operations Analyst Neil Dorrill, Administrator Lisa Jacob, Associate Project Manager Marion Bolick, Operations Manager Barbara Shea, Recording Secretary Also Present Thomas Folden, Collier County Sheriff's Office Trent Waterhouse, Pelican Bay Foundation APPROVED AGENDA (AS PRESENTED) 1. Call to order 2. Pledge of allegiance 3. Agenda approval 4. Approval of 04/18/17 meeting minutes 5. Audience comments 6. Administrator's Report and Updates a. *Conversion to LED bulbs on all remaining Pelican Bay streets b. Status of current phase of resodding on PB Blvd. and related cost 7. Pelican Bay sidewalk discussion and pedestrian/bicycle safety 8. Quality and cost of labor discussion 9. Oak Lake Sanctuary/Gulf Park Drive cut-through discussion 10. Vespo/Oak Lake Sanctuary noise issue 11. Chairman's comments 12. Committee member comments 13. Adjournment * indicates possible action item ROLL CALL Mr. Hirniak and Mr. Ventress were absent and a quorum was established 1 Pelican Bay Services Division Landscape & Safety Committee Meeting May 16,2017 AGENDA APPROVAL ir Mr. Cravens motioned, Mr. Shepherd seconded to approve the agenda as presented. The motion carried unanimously. APPROVAL OF 04/18/17 MEETING MINUTES Mr. Cravens motioned, Dr. Chicurel seconded to approve the 04/18/17 meeting minutes as presented. The motion carried unanimously. Mr. Cravens abstained as he was not present at the meeting. AUDIENCE COMMENTS Mr. Trent Waterhouse commented on the status of his coordination of the water tank paint color selection with Mr. Frank Laney, PBF and Mr. Robert Kaine, Collier County. Ms. Jacob reported that Mr. Dorrill will meet with Mr. Dan Rodriguez, Division Director of Collier County Public Utilities, to discuss this and other issues on June 5. ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT CONVERSION TO LED BULBS ON ALL REMAINING PB STREETS Mr. Dorrill reported on the completed LED bulb replacement project on Gulf Park Dr., and requested feedback from the committee on the level of light generated from the LED bulbs. He requested direction on proceeding with additional LED bulb replacement. Ms. McCaughtry reported that current PBSD street light reserves are approximately $900,000, and each year, additional funds of approximately $180,000—$200,000 are added. Ms. Jacob provided a spreadsheet of estimated costs to replace the remaining metal halide bulbs with LED bulbs, with two options for the 480V MH bulb replacement: (1) 80W LED at a cost of$50,775 or(2) 120W LED at a cost of$57,402. Mr. Trent Waterhouse commented on (1) the spread pattern being exactly the same for both the 80 watt LED bulbs and 120 watt LED bulbs, (2) the utility savings resulting from LED bulbs, and (3) LED bulbs being in compliance with"dark skies" guidelines. Mr. Cravens motioned, Mr. Shepherd seconded to recommend to the full PBSD Board to go ahead with the replacement of bulbs in all the fixtures. After discussion by the board, Mr. Cravens withdrew his motion, and Mr. Shepherd withdrew his second. Mr. Cravens commented on the current work underway by our lighting consultant who will ultimately provide recommendations on additional light poles and extension arms for the entire community. The committee agreed that it expects to vote on replacing all of the metal halide bulbs with LED bulbs, after reviewing the consultant's report next month. STATUS OF CURRENT PHASE OF RESODDING ON PB BLVD. AND RELATED COST Mr. Dorrill commented that the PBSD has replaced approximately 16,000 square feet (39 pallets) of sod, under our ongoing sod replacement project. PELICAN BAY SIDEWALK DISCUSSION AND PEDESTRIAN/BICYCLE SAFETY 2 Pelican Bay Services Division Landscape & Safety Committee Meeting May 16,2017 Dr. Chicurel commented on e-mails included in the agenda packet from residents expressing their concerns and experiences relating to unsafe poorly maintained PB sidewalks/pathways and bicyclist vs. pedestrian issues. He delineated two separate issues: (1) the physical nature, type, and condition of the pathways, and (2) bicyclist/pedestrian safety concerns. He commented on pathways being a major amenity to PB residents, and that new pathways must be safer and long lasting. Mr. Streckenbein commented on the possibility of accruing funds for pathway maintenance through a millage based assessment mechanism, in the same manner as our street lighting function is funded. Cpl. Folden, Collier County Sheriff's Office reported that there were no bicyclist/pedestrian accidents on PB streets in the last six months, and recalled one bicyclist/pedestrian incident on a PB pathway during the last year. He urged residents to report any bicyclist/pedestrian incidents to the Sheriff's Office. Mr. Trent Waterhouse commented on the PBF's current consideration of PBF security personnel patrolling the berm on bicycles. Mr. Dave Eskra commented on his accidental fall on a poorly maintained PB pathway resulting in three cracked ribs. Ms. Linda Harden commented on the poor condition and poor County maintenance/repairs of PB pathways. Mr. Dorrill commented on a previous PB plan (from a number of years ago) to widen pathways, but never implemented, due to resident concerns over tree removal. Mr. Dorrill reported that at his scheduled afternoon meeting with Commissioner Solis and Mr. Shepherd, he will discuss, (1) the possibility of the PBSD taking over responsibility for PB pathways, including possible funding mechanisms, and (2) other alternative solutions to the poorly maintained PB pathways, that may be suggested by Commissioner Solis. Dr. Chicurel concluded, "We have a problem, the sidewalks are inadequate, poorly maintained, dangerous, a safety issue, and the quality and kind of sidewalk is sorely lacking in substance." QUALITY AND COST OF LABOR DISCUSSION Mr. Shepherd commented on the recurring discussion of whether to (1) continue with our current labor model which includes temporary labor positions, or (2) transition the temporary labor positions to full time staff positions, and suggested that the PBSD come to a conclusion on this issue. Mr. Streckenbein suggested instituting an employee recognition policy, to include highlighting employees at PBSD board meetings. He commented on PBSD employee Pedro Montero who was cited in a resident's letter of appreciation, and suggested he be recognized at the June board meeting. Mr. Shepherd suggested that staff explore motivational training for PBSD employees. OAK LAKE SANCTUARY/GULF PARK DRIVE CUT-THROUGH DISCUSSION Mr. Dorrill reported that the County's safety committee will meet in nine days to prioritize proposed capital projects and identify likely years of County funding for these projects. Mr. Dorrill will provide the committee's ranking decision regarding our Gulf Park Drive median cut-through project at the June PBSD board meeting. 3 Pelican Bay Services Division Landscape & Safety Committee Meeting May 16, 2017 Mr. Dorrill also commented on the possibility of petitioning the state of Florida to make changes to traffic patterns at the intersection of Gulf Park Dr. and US 41, requiring approximate funding of$250,000. VESPO/OAK LAKE SANCTUARY NOISE ISSUE Mr. Dorrill commented that staff is in the process of obtaining a sketch and estimate for approximately 200 feet of berm for noise mitigation in the Oak Lake Sanctuary/US 41 area. CHAIRMAN'S COMMENTS None COMMITTEE MEMBER COMMENTS Mr. Shepherd suggested replacing the Collier County provided "reuse water is unsafe to drink" signs with more attractive signs. Mr. Shepherd commented on (1) a recent letter from a resident on Bobwhite Lane praising PBSD landscape workers, and (2) recent comments he has received verbally from Pelican Bay residents, praising and thanking the PBSD for all the recent community-wide landscaping improvements. ADJOURNMENT rhe meeting was adjourned at 11:45 a.m. Joe Chicurel, Chairman Minutes approved [ ] as presented OR [ ] as amended ON [ ] date 4 Agenda Item#6a Page 1 of 7 Shea Barbara Subject: FW: Berm fill estimates From: Tom Barber[mailto:tom.barber Labbinc.com] Sent: Monday,June 12, 2017 4:42 PM To: JacobLisa Cc: Jim Carr Subject: Berm fill estimates Lisa, please see information below: Dimensions: about 70'wide by 200' long Shu + I ice= # .: • Its a 3, Ii 1 Agenda Item#6a Page 2 of 7 { F X41 r i 3 Y ' t t ate IS.....:`p":..-.a k C Here is what existing to the South side c)as..tc. ,J,..,.kc, _. _. _ ._aCs' _ _ — - . _ /8 t t r 1 *. t 41 LA-6 4 t a And the north side: 2 Agenda Item#6a Page 3 of 7 t .04- .P of.,! c .k u?wii (13 1 ' So, I suggest something like we discussed with a berm which will split where a portion goes in from and the other behind and an access perpendicular to 41. Depending on whether you would like to add a wall to it or not you could vary the height from 4'to about 9',the estimate fill volumes are below: 6' in height @ a 6:1 slope would be 200 x(((36 x 6)/2)*2)=43,200 cf or 1,600 cv x 1.3 for loss and compaction= 2,080 cy @ $20/cy = $41,600 (cost is for fill material only; does not include installation) 9' in height @ a 4:1 slope would be 200 x(((36 x 9)/2)*2)=64,800 cf or 2,400 cv x 1.3 for loss and compaction =3,120 cy @ $20/cy = $62,400 (cost is for fill material only; does not include installation) And please keep in mind,we have not done any county or PUD code research, not sure if those slopes with landscaping would work or be permitted. Thanks, Tom Barber Agnoli, Barber,& Brundage Inc. 7400 Tamiami Tr. N.,Suite 200, Naples, FL 34108 Phone(239)597-3111 tom.barber@abbinc.com Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 3 Agenda Item#6a Page 4 of 7 MX/MA 0000°AGNOLI • (363A(3o ° B el�r�oporERARBER & cn0a©nl.1- og0000BRUNDAGE, INC. Professional Engineers,Planners&Surveyors 74011 Trail Mt Suite 200,Napkc,fi 34103 Ph.:(239)597-3111-Fax:(239)566-22113 June 9,2017 Via email to Lisa.Jacob@colliergov.net Lisa Jacob,Project Manager Collier County Pelican Bay Services Division 801 Laurel Oak Drive, Suite 302 Naples,FL 34108 Re: Pelican Bay Services Division US 41 Berm at Oak Lake Sanctuary Collier County Contract No. 13-6164 "County Wide Engineering Services" ABB PN 17-0083 Dear Ms. Jacob: At your request, Agnoli, Barber & Brundage, Inc. is pleased to submit this proposal to render professional services for engineering consulting services on the above-referenced project. Agnoli, Barber & Brundage, Inc., hereinafter referred to as ABB, proposes to provide Collier County the professional services outlined in Exhibit "A" attached. Since the basis of the contract is time and materials, a copy of our current Schedule B Rate Schedule is also included. This proposal is under the Terms and Conditions of the County Contract 13-6164. Work shall be completed within one hundred eighty(180)days from the date of the Notice to Proceed. We hope that this proposal satisfactorily responds to your request. Sincerely, AGNOLI, BARBER&BRUNDAGE, INC. Cd/k) Z- James A. Carr, P.E. Senior Vice President JAC/drr Attachments Page 1 of 4 K:\2017\17-0083 Pelican Bay US 41 Berm at Oak Lake Sanctuary\Correspondences\Proposal\Proposal.docx Agenda Item#6a Page 5 of 7 EXHIBIT"A" Estimated Project Budget Pelican Bay Services Division US 41 Berm at Oak Lake Sanctuary ABB PN 17-0083 June 9,2017 SCOPE OF SERVICES Agnoli, Barber& Brundage, Inc. (ABB) is pleased to submit this proposal to render professional engineering services. Pelican Bay Services Division (PBSD) is requesting a proposal from ABB for engineering and surveying for the design of a berm along US 41 in front of the Oak Lake Sanctuary for roughly 200 feet. The following is a description for the scope of services: 1. Survey Existing Conditions $2,700 F/F ABB proposes to cross section the existing area at approximately 20-foot intervals along the +/- 200-foot length. We estimate 10 sections over the entire distance. 2. Design and Construction Plans $6,000 F/F ABB will use the existing conditions cross sections to design berm. Conduct field visits as necessary. Review plans and comments from PBSD to coordinate final plans. Assist with construction bid documents. 3. South Florida Water Management District Permitting $5,000 F/F Coordinate with SFWMD staff on the design and permitting. Conduct field meeting with compliance staff. Address stormwater runoff from US 41 discharge. Apply for SFWMD Modification and respond to review RAI comments. 4. Oak Lake Sanctuary Swale (If Necessary) $2,500 F/F Revise existing swale at east end to provide erosion control and connection to the US 41 discharge. If twin pipes are proposed under the berm, there will need to be pipe end treatment for erosion and grade modifications to maintain flows to the swale. No FDOT permit is anticipated nor is any FDOT permitting included. 5. Survey As-Built $ 1,600 F/F Survey locate berm. Page 2 of 4 102017\1 7-0083 Pelican Bay US 41 Berm at Oak Lake Sanctuary\Correspondences\Proposal\Proposal.docx Agenda Item#6a Page 6 of 7 6. Construction Services $3,430 F/F Provide construction observation and assistance during construction: • Attend one pre-construction meeting on site. • Provide assistance to answer questions and coordinate during construction. • Construction observation to the extent necessary to certify to owner/agencies. • Provide as-built record drawings. TOTAL $21,230 F/F F/F=Fixed Fee T/M = Time and Materials. Billing will be based on actual time and materials expended in accordance with our rate schedule. Budgets given will not be exceeded without prior authorization. Reimbursables $200 (Est.) Reimbursable expenses include expenses for blueprinting, copying services, database searches, color graphics,overnight express delivery service, long distance telephone calls,the cost of public meeting signs, noticing the public meeting by mail and by newspaper advertisement, and mailing lists from Collier County Property Appraiser's Office Page 3 of 4 K:\2017\17-0083 Pelican Bay US 41 Berm at Oak Lake Sanctuary\Correspondences\Proposal\Proposal.docx Agenda Item#6a Page 7 of 7 SCHEDULE B RATE SCHEDULE Personnel Category Standard Hourly Rate Principal $206.00 Senior Project Manager $172.00 Project Manager $147.00 Senior Engineer $157.00 Engineer $123.00 Senior Inspector $96.00 Inspector $76.00 Senior Planner $139.00 Planner $110.00 Senior Designer $114.00 Designer $94.00 Environmental Specialist $109.00 Senior Environmental Specialist $134.00 Scientist/Geologist $93.00 Senior Scientist/Geologist $118.00 Marine Biologist/Hydrogeologist $110.00 Senior Marine Biologist/Hydrogeologist $138.00 Senior GIS Specialist $139.00 GIS Specialist $102.00 Clerical/Administrative $62.00 Senior Technician $85.00 Technician $72.00 Surveyor and Mapper $120.00 CADD Technician $81.00 Survey Crew—2 man $130.00 Survey Crew—3 man $161.00 Survey Crew—4 man $189.00 Senior Architect $154.00 Architect $121.00 This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Hourly rates for other categories of professional, support and other services shall be mutually negotiated by Collier County and firm on a project by project basis as needed. Page 4 of 4 K\2017\17-0083 Pelican Bay US 41 Berm at Oak Lake Sanctuary\Correspondences\Proposal\Proposal.docx Agenda Item#6b Page 1 of 2 SheaBarbara Subject: FW: Street Lighting Study From: Thomas E, Mollis [mailto:tehollisOembargmall.comj Sent:Tuesday,June 06, 2017 3:16 PM To:JacobLisa Cc: Jim Carr Subject: Street Lighting Study Lisa, On May 31St , I made an onsite inspection of the street lighting system in Pelican Bay Service District. I arrived at 8:15 pm and reviewed the new installation on Ridgewood Drive. While I was reviewing the installation the street lights were energized and I was able to see the new LED fixtures in operation. I then proceeded to the intersection of US 41 and Pelican Bay Boulevard. I review each of the intersection and crossovers along Pelican Bay Boulevard from south to north. Each of the intersection and crossover appeared to be well lit by street lighting poles located at the intersections. I noticed 8 fixture not working while making this review. I felt that I could have made a list of the outages by noting which intersection/development entrance, and then thought how much easier it would be if each pole was marked with an identifying number tag. I then reviewed the following intersection roadway to Pelican Bay Boulevard: Myra Janco Daniels Blvd., Crayton Rd., Gulf Park Dr., North Pointe Dr., and Hammock Oak Dr.And then review all the other roadways included within the Pelican Bay Service District. I completed my review at 10:00 pm. ' My review did find several locations need tree trimming, but many of them were noted on our previous report. I saw no location that could not be improved with additional tree trimming. Sincerely yours, Thomas E. Hollis, P. E. Hollis Engineering Consultants, Inc. 16900 Colony Lakes Blvd. Fort Myers, FL 33908 Phone: (239)481-2385 Cell: (239)560-6541 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. Agenda Item#6b Page 2 of 2 Estimated Cost to Replace Metal Halide Bulbs with LED Bulbs on ail Remaining Pelican Bay Streets MH Bulbs Already Replaced with LED Bulbs No. Description Location 38 480V 250W MH to SOW LED Gulf Park Dr(from US 41 to Pelican Bay Blvd) 2 480V 250W MH to 87W LED Pelican Bay Blvd at Gulf Park Dr 1 480V400W MR to 120W LED Gulf Park Dr at Green Tree Dr 1 480V400W MR to 120W LED Pelican Bay Blvd at Ridgewood Dr 1 240V 100W MR to 30W LED Ridgewood Dr at Pelican Bay Blvd 1 240V 100W MH to 30W LED Pelican Bay Blvd at Glenview PI crosswalk REMAINING 480V MH BULBS Remaining 480V MH Bulbs to be Replaced with LED Bulbs and Estimated Costs OPTION 1 No. Description Unit Price Extended Price ' 241 480V 250W MH to 80W LED $ 179 $ 43,139 Shipping 7% $ 12.53 $ 3,020 $ 46,159 with 10%Contingency $ 4,616 $ 50,775 Total • OPTION 2 No. Description Unit Price Extended Price 241 480V 250 W MH to 120W LED $ 204 $ 49,164 Shipping 7% $ 14 $ 3,441 $ 52,605 with 10%Contingency $ 5,261 $ 57,402 Total REMAINING 240V MH BULBS Remaining 240V MH Bulbs to be Replaced with LED Bulbs and Estimated Costs No. Description Unit Price Extended Price 179 240V 100W MH to 30W LED $ 71 $ 12,673 Shipping 7% $ 5 $ 887 $ 13,560 with 10%Contingency $ 1,356 $ 14,916 Total Rev 5/12/17 Agenda Item#6b-1 Page 1 of 5 Pelican Bay Services District-Street Lighting Poles Street Address Pole Numi Notes Picture# Pelican Bay Boulevard Al No issues 9151255 Pelican Bay Boulevard A2 No issues 9151256 Pelican Bay Boulevard A3 No issues 9151257 Pelican Bay Boulevard A4 No issues 9151258 Pelican Bay Boulevard A5 No issues 9151259 Pelican Bay Boulevard A6 No issues 9151260 Pelican Bay Boulevard A7 No issues 9151261 Pelican Bay Boulevard A8 No issues 9151262 Pelican Bay Boulevard A9 No issues 9151263 Pelican Bay Boulevard A10 No issues 9151264 Pelican Bay Boulevard All Sable palm 9.7'west Sable palm 9.7'east Light fixture is unobstructed 9151265 Pelican Bay Boulevard Al2 No issues 9151266 Pelican Bay Boulevard A13 Sable palm 5.6'northwest Light fixture is unobstructed 9161267 Pelican Bay Boulevard A14 No issues 9151268 Pelican Bay Boulevard A15 Sable palm 10'southwest. Light fixture is unobstructed 9151269 Pelican Bay Boulevard A16 Sable palm 4.2'southwest 9151270 Pelican Bay Boulevard A17 No issues 9151271 Pelican Bay Boulevard A18 Sable palm 11.4'north Light fixture is unobstructed 9151272 Pelican Bay Boulevard A19 No issues 9151273 Pelican Bay Boulevard A20 No issues 9151274 Pelican Bay Boulevard A21 No issues 9151275 Pelican Bay Boulevard A22 No issues 9151276 Pelican Bay Boulevard A23 Sable palm 11'northeast 9151277 Pelican Bay Boulevard A24 Sable palm 11.4'northeast 9151278 Pelican Bay Boulevard A25 No issues 9151279 Pelican Bay Boulevard A26 No issues 9151280 Pelican Bay Boulevard A27 No issues 9151281 Pelican Bay Boulevard A28 No issues 9151282 Pelican Bay Boulevard A29 Sable palm 9.6'south Light fixture is unobstructed 9151283 Pelican Bay Boulevard A30 Sable palm 9.1'northeast 9151284 Pelican Bay Boulevard A31 Canopy of oak tree to the north is withn 4'of the light fixture 9151285 Pelican Bay Boulevard A32 No issues 9151286 Pelican Bay Boulevard A33 No issues 9151287 Pelican Bay Boulevard A34 No issues 9151288 Pelican Bay Boulevard A35 Sable palm 9'north 9151289 Pelican Bay Boulevard A36 Sable palm 8.2'northeast 9151290 Pelican Bay Boulevard A37 No issues 9151291 Pelican Bay Boulevard A38 Sable palm 7.6'northwest Light fixture is unobstructed 9151292 Pelican Bay Boulevard A39 No issues 9151293 Pelican Bay Boulevard A40 No issues 9151294 Pelican Bay Boulevard A41 Sable palm 12.4'northwest 9151295 Pelican Bay Boulevard A42 No issues 9151296 Pelican Bay Boulevard A43 No issues 9151297 Pelican Bay Boulevard A44 No issues 9151298 Pelican Bay Boulevard A45 No issues 9151299 Pelican Bay Boulevard A46 Nearby oak canopy is encroaching on the light pole and fixture 9151300 Pelican Bay Boulevard A47 Sable palm 10.8'north. Light fixture is unobstructed 9151301 Pelican Bay Boulevard A48 Sable palm 8.2'north Sable palm 10.2'east 9151302 Pelican Bay Boulevard A49 No issues 9151303 Pelican Bay Boulevard A50 Sable palm 11.3'north Light fixture is unobstructed 9151304 Pelican Bay Boulevard A51 No issues 9151305 Agenda Item#6b-1 Page 2 of 5 Pelican Bay Boulevard A52 No issues 9151306 Pelican Bay Boulevard A53 Oak 10.3'northwest Canopy of oaks is within 2'of the light fixture 9151307 Pelican Bay Boulevard A54 Sable palm 10.5'south Light fixture is unobstructed 9151308 Pelican Bay Boulevard A55 No issues 9151309 Pelican Bay Boulevard A56 Branch of a nearby oak is hanging over the light fixture 9151310 Pelican Bay Boulevard A57 Sable palm 10.2'south Light fixture is unobstructed 9151311 Pelican Bay Boulevard A58 No issues 9151312 Pelican Bay Boulevard A59 No issues 9151313 Pelican Bay Boulevard A60 Sable palm 9.1'south Sable palm 10.3' 9151314 Pelican Bay Boulevard A61 No issues 9151315 Pelican Bay Boulevard A62 No issues 9151316 Pelican Bay Boulevard A63 No issues 9151317 Pelican Bay Boulevard A64 No issues 9151318 Pelican Bay Boulevard A65 No issues 9151319 Pelican Bay Boulevard A66 Royal palm 9.5'north Branches hanging close to light fixture 9151320 Pelican Bay Boulevard A67 Branches of an unknown type of tree are encroaching on the pole&fixture 9151321 Pelican Bay Boulevard A68 Branches of a nearby oak tree are encroaching on the light fixture 9151322 Pelican Bay Boulevard A69 No issues 9151323 Pelican Bay Boulevard A70 Sable palm 9.6'west Light fixture is unobstructed 9151324 Pelican Bay Boulevard A71 No issues 9151325 Pelican Bay Boulevard A72 Sable palm 10'west Sable palm 7.8'east Branches blocking light fixture 9151326 Pelican Bay Boulevard A73 No issues 9151327 Pelican Bay Boulevard A74 Canopy of a nearby oak is within 4'of the light fixture 9151328 Pelican Bay Boulevard A75 No issues 9151329 Pelican Bay Boulevard A76 No issues 9151330 Pelican Bay Boulevard A77 No issues 9151331 Pelican Bay Boulevard A78 Canopy of nearby oaks is encroaching on the light fixture 9151332 Pelican Bay Boulevard A79 No issues 9151333 Pelican Bay Boulevard A80 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9151334 Pelican Bay Boulevard A81 Sable palm 12'west 9151335 Pelican Bay Boulevard A82 No issues 9151336 Pelican Bay Boulevard A83 No issues 9151337 Pelican Bay Boulevard A84 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the fixture 9151338 Laurel Oak Drive B1 Laurel Oak Drive B2 Laurel Oak Drive B3 Laurel Oak Drive B4 Ridgewood Drive Cl Sable palm 6.3'southwest,Sable palm 8.5'northwest,light obstructed 9211416 Ridgewood Drive C2 Canopy of a nearby tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9211417 Ridgewood Drive C3 No issues 9211418 Ridgewood Drive C4 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching 9211419 Ridgewood Drive C5 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroachmg 9211420 Ridgewood Drive C6 Sable palm 5.8'northwest,Sable palm 7.4'north,light fixture is obstructed 9211421 Ridgewood Drive C6B Sable palm 6.7'south,light fixture is obstructed 9211422 Ridgewood Drive C7 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroachmg on the light fixture 9211423 Ridgewood Drive C8 No issues 9211424 Ridgewood Drive C9 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroachng on the light fixture 9211425 Ridgewood Drive C10 Canopy of a nearby tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9211426 Ridgewood Drive C11 No issues 9211427 Ridgewood Drive C12 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9211428 Ridgewood Drive C13 No issues 9211429 Ridgewood Drive C14 Canopy of a nearby tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9211430 Ridgewood Drive C15 No issues 9211431 Ridgewood Drive C16 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9211432 Ridgewood Drive C17 No issues 9211433 Agenda Item#6b-1 Page 3 of 5 Ridgewood Drive C18 No issues 9211434 Ridgewood Drive C19 Canopy of a nearby tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9211435 Ridgewood Drive C20 Pine tree 12.0'northwest, Branches are within 2'of the light fixture 9211436 Ridgewood Drive C21 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9211437 Ridgewood Drive C22 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9211438 Ridgewood Drive C23 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9211439 Ridgewood Drive C24 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9211440 Ridgewood Drive C25 Canopy of a nearby mahogany is encroaching on the light fixture 9211441 Ridgewood Drive C26 Sable palm 3.5'southwest,Sable palm 9.1'south, 9211442 West Boulevard K1 Sable palm 11.0'north,Sable palm 5'south 9211406 West Boulevard K2 No issues 9211407 West Boulevard K3 Sable palm 8.3'north 9211408 West Boulevard K4 Sable palm 5'north,Sable palm 6.3'south,light is obstructed 9211409 West Boulevard K5 Light fixture is blocked by the canopy of nearby trees 9211410 West Boulevard K6 Oak tree 10.6'north,Oak tree 7.8'south,light partly obstructed 9211411 West Boulevard K7 Sable palm 6.9'northwest,Sable palm 11.6'north 9211412 West Boulevard K8 Sable palm 9.3'southwest 9211413 West Boulevard K9 Canopy of nearby oaks is within 5'of the light fixture 9211414 West Boulevard K10 No issues 9211415 Crayton Road L1 No issues 9211395 Crayton Road L2 Sable palm 11.2'northeast Light fixture is unobstructed 9211396 Crayton Road L3 No issues 9211397 Crayton Road L4 Sable palm 10.8'northeast,Sable palm 10.6'east,Sable palm 7.9'southeast 9211398 Crayton Road L5 No issues 9211399 Crayton Road L6 No issues 9211400 Crayton Road L7 No issues 9211401 Crayton Road L8 Sable palm 8.7'north,Sable palm 4.2'east,Sable palm 6.5'southeast 9211402 Crayton Road L9 No issues 9211403 Crayton Road L10 Branches of a nearby oak are encroaching on the pole 9211404 Crayton Road L11 Sable palm 8.8'southwest,Sable palm 5'southeast,light obstructed 9211405 Gulf Park Drive M1 No issues 9211375 Gulf Park Drive M2 Canopy of nearby tree is within 6'of the light fixture 9211376 Gulf Park Drive M3 No issues 9211377 Gulf Park Drive M4 No issues 9211378 Gulf Park Drive M5 No issues 9211379 Gulf Park Drive M6 No issues 9211380 Gulf Park Drive M7 No issues 9211381 Gulf Park Drive M8 No issues 9211382 Gulf Park Drive M9 No issues 9211383 Gulf Park Drive M10 Canopy of nearby tree has the light fixture covered 9211384 Gulf Park Drive M11 No issues 9211385 Gulf Park Drive M12 No issues 9211386 Gulf Park Drive M13 No issues 9211387 Gulf Park Drive M14 No issues 9211388 Gulf Park Drive M15 Sable palm 10.8'west Light fixture is unobstructed 9211389 Gulf Park Drive M16 Canopy of nearby trees have the light fixture covered 9211390 Gulf Park Drive M17 No issues 9211391 Gulf Park Drive M18 No issues 9211392 Gulf Park Drive M19 Sable palm 11.3'east, Sable palm 9.3°southeast 9211393 Gulf Park Drive M20 No Issues 9211394 Green Tree Drive N1 Sable palm 11.0'northwest Light fixture is unobstructed 9231443 Green Tree Drive N2 No issues 9231444 Green Tree Drive N3 Light fixture is complety blocked by 2 large oak trees nearby 9231445 Green Tree Drive N4 Oak tree 11.7'northwest,canopy is encroaching on the light fixture 9231446 i Green Tree Drive N5 Canopy of nearby oak tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9231447 Agenda Item#6b-1 Page 4 of 5 Green Tree Drive N6 No issues 9231448 Green Tree Drive N7 Oak tree 9.7'north,canopy is encroaching on the light fixture 9231449 Green Tree Drive N8 Canopy of nearby oaks is encroaching on the light fixture 9231450 Green Tree Drive N9 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231451 Green Tree Drive N10 There is not a light pole numbered N10 on the map Green Tree Drive N11 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231452 Green Tree Drive N12 No issues 9231453 Green Tree Drive N13 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231454 Green Tree Drive N14 No issues 9231455 Green Tree Drive N15 No issues 9231456 Green Tree Drive N16 No issues 9231457 Green Tree Drive N17 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231458 Green Tree Drive N18 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231459 Green Tree Drive N19 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231460 Green Tree Drive N20 Sable palm 7.7'north,branches are touching the light fixture 9231461 Green Tree Drive N21 Sable palm 10.4'S,Sable palm 4'SW,Sable palm 5.4'N,light obstructed 9231462 Green Tree Drive N22 No issues 9231463 Green Tree Drive N23 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231464 Green Tree Drive N24 No issues 9231465 Green Tree Drive N25 No issues 9231466 Green Tree Drive N26 Oak tree 9.2'northwest,canopy is over the top of the light fixture 9231467 Green Tree Drive N27 Canopy of nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231468 Green Tree Drive N28 Sable palm 7.5'E,Sable 5.2'NE,Sable 9.2'NW,Sable 10.2'SW 9231469 Oakmont Parkway V1 No issues 9161339 Oakmont Parkway V2 No issues 9161340 Oakmont Parkway V3 No issues 9161341 Oakmont Parkway V4 No issues 9161342 Oakmont Parkway V5 No issues 9161343 Oakmont Parkway V6 Unknown type of tree 9.2'southwest Canopy of tree is within 2'of the light 9161344 Oakmont Parkway V7 Oak tree 12.5'south Fixture is completly blocked by the canopy of the oak 9161345 Oakmont Parkway V8 Pine tree 9.2'south 9161346 Oakmont Parkway V9 Sable palm 5.4'SW,Oak 10.2'NW,Sable palm 10.8'NW 9161347 Oakmont Parkway V10 Sable palm 8.2'northeast,Pine 8.8'southeast 9161348 Oakmont Parkway V11 Oak tree 10.8'NW Canopy is encroaching on the light fixture 9161349 Oakmont Parkway V12 Oak tree 11.8'N Canopy is encroaching on the light fixture 9161350 Oakmont Parkway V13 Pine 9.2'east,Unknown tree 12.0'northeast,Pine 12.3'north 9161351 Oakmont Parkway V14 Pine tree 9.3'northwest 9161352 Oakmont Parkway V15 Canopy of nearby oak tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9161353 Oakmont Parkway V16 Maple tree 9.0'northeast, Canopy of nearby trees has fixture covered 9161354 Oakmont Parkway V17 Oak 9.0'west,Pine 6.8'north,Canopy has the fixture covered 9161355 Oakmont Parkway V18 No issues 9161356 Oakmont Parkway V19 Oak tree 7.0'south,Canopy has the fixture covered 9161357 Oakmont Parkway V20 Tabebuia tree 9.0'west 9161358 Oakmont Parkway V21 Pine tree 8.0'NE,Pine tree 11.5'east,Canopy covering fixture 9161359 Oakmont Parkway V22 Sable palm 8.7'NE,Oak tree 3.7'SE,Canopy is within 2'of the fixture 9161360 Oakmont Parkway V23 Oak 8.0'SW,Oak 5.3'W,Oak 12.5'NW,Canopy covering fixture 9161361 Oakmont Parkway V24 Sable palm 6.7'northeast,Sable palm 7.9'southeast 9161362 Oakmont Parkway V25 Canopy of nearby oak tree is within 2'of the light fixture 9161363 Oakmont Parkway V26 Sable palm 10.5'south,Canopy is within 3'of the light fixture 9161364 Oakmont Parkway V27 Tabebuia tree 11.3'west,branches are touching the pole 9161365 Oakmont Parkway V28 Canopy of nearby oak tree has the light fixture blocked 9161366 Oakmont Parkway V29 Canopy of nearby oak tree has the light fixture blocked 9161367 Oakmont Parkway V30 Sable palm 6.2'SW,Sable palm 5.9'NE,Sable palm 12.0'N 9161368 Oakmont Parkway V31 Sable palm 8.7'south,Branches are touching the light fixture 9161369 Oakmont Parkway V32 Cabbage palm 11.8'north,Cabbage palm 5.7'north 9161370 Agenda Item#6b-1 Page 5 of 5 Oakmont Parkway V33 Sable palm 4.0'south,Sable palm 8.6'south,Branches blocking the fixture 9161371 Oakmont Parkway V34 Cabbage palm 1.5'west,Cabbage palm 2.7'northwest,fixture blocked 9161372 Oakmont Parkway V35 Unknown type of tree 8.0'southeast,branches encroaching on pole 9161373 Oakmont Parkway V36 Branches from a nearby Ficus tree are encroaching on the light fixture 9161374 North Point Drive AL1 Sable palm 11.0'north 9231479 North Point Drive AL2 No issues 9231480 North Point Drive AL3 Unknown type of tree 10.7'east,branches encroaching on the pole 9231481 North Point Drive AL4 Oak tree 11.6'SE,canopy encroaching on the light fixture 9231482 North Point Drive AL5 Canopy of a nearby oak is encroaching on the light fixture 9231483 North Point Drive AL6 Sable palm 10.0'east,branches of nearby oak are encroaching on the light 9231484 North Point Drive AL7 Tabebuia tree 10.3'east,canopy of nearby oak are encroaching on the light 9231485 North Point Drive AL8 Canopy of a nearby Gumbo Limbo tree are within 3'of the light fixture 9231486 North Point Drive AL9 Canopy of a nearby oak tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9231487 North Point Drive AL10 No issues 9231488 North Point Drive AL11 No issues 9231489 Hammock Oak Drive AM1 No issues 9231470 Hammock Oak Drive AM2 Sable palm 10.5'south 9231471 Hammock Oak Drive AM3 Canopy of nearby oak tree is encroaching on the light fixture 9231472 Hammock Oak Drive AM4 No issues 9231473 Hammock Oak Drive AM5 Sable palm 9.5'S,Sable pal 8.7'SW,Sable palm 3.4'NW,Sable 11'NW 9231474 Hammock Oak Drive AM6 Branches of nearby trees are encroaching on the light fixture 9231475 Hammock Oak Drive AM7 Branches of nearby trees are encroaching on the light fixture 9231476 Hammock Oak Drive AM8 No issues 9231477 Hammock Oak Drive AM9 Sable palm 11.0'south 9231478 Agenda Item#6b-3 Page 1 of 1 Signature Tree Care Office: (239)348-1330 Signaturetreecare.com 15275 Collier BIvd.St.201-276 info(a.signaturetreecare.com Naples, FL 34119 Fax: PROPOSAL Pagel Proposal#: 6962 Pelican Bay Services Home: Proposal Date: 1/13/2017 6200 Watergate Way Office: 239-597-2265 Customer#: 1849 Naples, FL 34108 SalesRep: Ian Type: G Terms in Days: 0 Item# Quantity Description of Services Item Amount 1 119 Trees& Palms each 115.00 13,685.00 Locations: Per document list submitted by email from Pelican Bay Services. Pricing includes all MOT including arrowboards. Pricing includes an ISA certified arborist on site at all times. Pruning to increase the footprint or casting of light. The spread of light emanates at a 56 degree angle from the light fixture. The branches and fronds below the line of angle will be either removed, thinned or reduced so as not to disfigure the trees. This will accomplish a greater good when trying to maximize light foot print. As well any larger understory plantings that are impeding the cast of light would be addressed as this is a lighting issue and not solely a clearance issue of the light pole. All trees pruned in accordance with ANSI A300 Standards for Pruning Practices, ISA standards and Collier county codes for proper pruning. All methods accomplished thru ANSI Z133.1 Specs. in compliance with Collier County code and industry standards. Not responsible for underground sprinkler lines. Please sign proposal&return to schedule work order. If any questions or changes to work order, address in writing/email. Proposal Total: $13,685.00 Required Deposit: 0.00 Authorized: Date: .: AFF:: aV , L6 Sl1 =>_,x Uc P' :. . Vi , ` L 2 ' 'V KY' ,. .,. , .. , . ,:. . , , _,. „,..,, ,...., „.,,,..,.,,,,.. „...,v„.1...,„,.,„.: # r zt` tut' r ....„..„.„...., ., . ... ..„.„ ,..; Ft J3 _ 2 ,. ..„. „,„„, ,„..„,„ . , ....., ,..., .,..,,, ,.„ . .,,, ., , .„4„„...: ..,..„...„.„ rip-, 7-f,„: 11, g 1 .k.,4011 ,, ;:- .. .7., ". ' ,,,- -. ,,,,,: ,,,,-„. i r `e& N-' <a w ae�+ R7 . L > z x t ,__, H • n cL CL a t., .L k i ray x k ra Q W a€ ....= idlikommollirritIV, li .4ii,liv ii , itt '.-- CL U") } ' • -,,,,t11' ,..,.,'...,4,.:4,,,,'...[ " m ' .4 z �/ . LL yN - 2 t E'. ,.,,,,:,...'-:,'-''''''-,',..-''' ,-:-L'iL. '. . ,.., -:),..? ,' =. t -,,„,...„,,,,,, , '• Ilk .„.41e1 . : 1 .: s ' ,44,4* 4 ,,,,. t. , 11 .. .. ,. ',, 4 . ' ei= *?4'.: 14Itek #' 1....1 " .. !, ', ,, , . . ., , ',,0 -, 1, , z °, 7•.. ..: { . , ,..„,„ ,t. ,:,.„v . ... . , -. _.,.„ . : , "0"f om •4, b4 } k. U. * . H E N OOOOOO O O O O O O 0 a U co O OO O O O O O O0 O O O O O OO OO O O O O OO C a O O O O O O� 7 O� M O O On M M 01 H 69 b4 69 fH b4 V3 69 69 69 b4 b4 _ 69 _ M Q 69 HH J Q H 0 HH 0 O O O O O O O O O H L U O O O O O O O p 00 O O O O CI H O O O O O O6 • ON O ON O O O� o d z s 6 64 64 669 69 d H c a) m L OS H r O 0 Z ,O M 00 oc - J L c d al Z wO p H a) V U 0 rn cn cn cnrn a ao ....4 . a a w cn cn cn -] x m 0 Y, C Z O L > a O co 2 ct o Q c 2 z R cD d E W Q dC 0 a o °c 0 _o 0 L o. m a q o > ¢ y .4 Ww I- Q + W W W c6 v O U CL o W H a J U 00 w a! U Zr) CD Z H w w v `o d Fw O z . = — w w F" > o H Z WW o ,4 a n , U p H U (7") C7 U CC W W W Z w N o C7 0 w • m ¢ C z O a4 W Oh =4 U cG W c E O ¢ H a z o z Q m ¢ U w Ca U g w ¢ 0 w w U z z -p N z ¢ W w Q ¢ Q Q H 0 0 0 0 o a ra u o H o > = o 2 Q z tali n o c a Oa ,4 z , U H aw, z z z z .Z a o u Ix w H o ,) ou < c ou cn .> CO m Z C N zv - N M V v, ,ON m O, O N M V W v d a> H 73 n 17 EL CD a ,..,,•,--,,17,.. .4,,.,-, ...,,,:,,,,. , i „,.. „, 40 I, Ib Sn : t ' +''',44-,l.,-.--.-...,--,."-.-•..:,:.--r---',-L:.'2,1*.t.,-"•••"'''.".-•'• —'::::':.::17:-::-.--1.1.: „z :i _ �� 'dry 6 w, - i•''' ..,.....4ftr.t::c;-..:..7;i'',1-.:-0,.,,:...,".4e1„..: 1,,,1"7,-,-,4P.I.;--,',., ' 2 ' .!..:,..,±.",„'''--;:A •:. :,.-1.:--.,-.•--%...-1C''',. ::.,ollft-„,.... .-::..iv7,::4r...,..7-•.:•.. : ,::,:-,,,it-:-...-,..17.z.,,„ 40;01.0,1 ::..- ' -•.'•-'4'' ''''''--:"liez."1"7"4-;'::.1'.;::':.---''.4:1 "--I'll"' • • '''' t.' :' •""4:`4'-',i.-"i'4'..,1-:--.:'-'-' "-----X 7-:,:i;,;--Altti.•!':---:-,:•-:- .:.4i96-tK:t:94tilgr4- 5:- - :.4W11.11444t,.:, t„ *-4-.-'-•• .:14.--' •' :::::i*':•••"•-, ,-;-.;•:$4,:-:'" '! .4' ::: '---.;.,,- '.' .E I. • '''-' •!! :-'j• -.:ii.,:'--- . -" ..-',1,,A.I.••„.„:----,,.,,:''' ..:i!,17-,117:14,19,%0-,..,.„_. 4 pliA 471. m 3 • 0,--.'. :;,-,--.1:,:',!'s:'•.;441.-''''-:.-- -- -': ,.. - _ :14(44.-,,.;', 1 i ','''., s ':::::i--.:::.-.4..,...:-.i7.4. 1014;.:4"-----;:...'il,I0.,,.:.:-iii",44:.: ,AH-----'='--_- 44=1 -l_n : itt I 2 0, F 44 # r Vit W i5g.::!!.:0,,,.:,,,...1.r.i...t-...... -•,..-,,,,-.,•,,,:•:':'.,i.....-..-i. 3.....,.....iii..,::.-..:. ,-; -••4,,,..i:.: :.1...:'-'•.:.-1.,-- .:;,:.''''!'...!":Lifilm,,,,..:..:-- I.:,:. --:,:,,,.,:„..,'''.,.-:::-1.:'....:':',.::.::,...-...- -- ,,,...1.!::,''''.i.',.....x.,4i-'1,1s*:,i''I'''''','-C''':...i.i.„,.i.7.1''''',.'.igti:,...,:-.'...1.,:.,1,17...:.'...,,,,,'....:..,.„,..','.....*.....4e',:'-'_.'.'4,1,.:„:...0''''1,,It:.,..-..,,,...7,,,,I...,..::,..::':::,-- g.„ :::.'' 0,..:,....J±,,,:,::,.a:;::::,:;::.:::: ::, ::,. _.4. _... ., :,,...„.:„!_,.,,:„.,,.,.....:,,,,;_:...„1::::.._,_,:.: :::::.;..... Iii1:.),.. : ,..,.. .._,•,::,_..:....:.zt„...,,:,.4::. ..„..:,__4; v,,t,,i. •,;,-4. -..-,,,.,-”'' • ..,„',5i,..ii:4"i- -.':-..- - '°- _ k- • bv�e 'mo -44•;'14!'''• 3 _...,._,, ,.„:,.„..,:.,..., i„.•:„.. .„.„,„.„,__:,•,...„.,____,•„. •_•.:. ::,::: ,...:„. ,.,...• ..., .. „....,....„..„„:„•,%,q,„:„:„.........,,....„.........„..E. ,,...„.„,. .. ..... I . ,,•;.,„....,..„:„:„.„.., •,, ...„.....,%,...,„„......... ....,%.,,,..,,...,. :. . .......... , .,....„,„.."...,,,,,..,....„. ,..,„,,,,,,,,,,,„,..„,„ , . ,, +f „:„.„,....„,....„,..„.„,..„,...„,,,,,,,..,„„.4.....„,....„,,,,,,,„„,...„..„.„..„..,„,,,,,,,.....,„..t.:::.......,,,,,,..„. .•• , %........,..,,,,„.„,..,.,,. ,: ....:...:,..„.„.....„...,.....„,....,,.„..,„...„..,„%,..,,:,.„.„:„...,• iii,•;1 lifEg•-7 .... „, '.,.....• '•4•;7'.•••:•--•-:•„..„:„.0::•.,:::,•-;:_-.-'-.:::--: ..," , 1,..,..,,,v., •,..-,- ..',. „...,,.„.;...4 ,kiitii.. .t_.......,„?,-_„,,„,„,..5 , _.„,:„.„:„.„,„4t,....:„.: 004,., ,0.,v, .... . ----- - "....... ,...: t , 1:,„......il... : ,1., .,..i,t,.,.,.. ,-__...,.,„:,..4. __.:_...... .,,..:r _.„-- , t ivi ... 1 :. . . _....._ .t,•••,: m. ....,.„.,„,0„,t".04.0,;, i 1-....1,Rt .:III ..,„ -"I,,,14••,,II•11:: . 11,..1, \ \ ',,,„:11111•. '..1. I:1:-: 11.1"114:'1,-,:111.-.• 1•••, ••• ..::1:11I111Y:.• V4."- '' 71'11411,::,, ..,:., -..''.1': 111 I\ 1 :.Ittr; ,,,..";...,:::...,":....,..:' ... „..•.... 1.4,,,. ii••...::.,,',.....,448:.,..-,.;.";...1,I,:::::.,...::,:•,1":I;::,..-.1...7•:,1-.::::,1,.:,':•,,.•,..0'.1....•' . . . ir P,i,.,•• :. � k, aQ M- , =oa a H En O OoOO O OOCO o. 0. • MO O O O O 0 N O 00 O O O O a OOOOOOO7 00 N 00 O O O M QO S S O O O h M 00 �n O O Vl M N T 69 64 N M V M CO 0,- E-, Gni fA 69 69 69 69 69 69 69 69 69 N3 69 49 , H J H 0 H HH C.P0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Q O O O O O O O O O C O 0 O O — O O O O O H O O O O O O 91! 60-9 N 60N9 O M W 0 6699 bM9 699 6Al Tr 699 6699 69 69 69 69 d 1 C S I— S o ,- Q00 N N N W It Cep, H o p V C) - cn cn cn cn cn >» Cl) >. >. Z w En cA C a a a a .- a a w a y d 0 a O c Z etiO I. I IT 4:C0 0 IX 0. a Z a ca L. U >= !6 {) UO N Y.. W Q o-. ... W.» D (� + V 0 W 7K F 8 z 4 w V. • 4 x ' w z 'H W o 0 Oa 0 W WW O ] ��" W z •[L�' � N E r� W (W7 z� Q p: V y ¢ 0 w z ¢ ¢ ¢ ¢ w 0 o ° d • 5 o o .a w o 44 _ q y nPI� O W a LQ U a a 0 C7 ZO C.3 a CO U �a a w o V) c� a U CO >O •c m 0 0 2 Z N M V V) sO N 00 O� O N M C CO .CO a0i H acro. • U S 41/Tarmarni Trail Agenda Item#7 2 Page 2 of FDDT and Lely Res Boulevard Intersection Improvements FPID:433415-1-52-01 r CONSTRUCTION PROJECT The Florida Department of Transportation is constructing the median modification at the US 41/Tamiami Trail and Lely Resort Boulevard intersection by replacing the temporary curb and poles with concrete curbs and islands. PROJECT SCHEDULE O Construction is expected to start April 3,2017. O Construction should end late Spring/early Summer 2017,weather permitting. O Construction crews will be working during the daytime and nighttime. O Lane closures are anticipated during the day and nighttime hours;however,no lane closures will occur during the peak hours of 6 a.m.to 9 a.m. and 4 p.m.to 7 p.m. O Please be alert for construction crews. PROJECT COST Estimated cost for engineering design, materials/equipment,and construction is$465,000. RSR •:........------ - if I 4 4 PROJECT CONTRACTOR&ENGINEERS " Ajax Paving Industries of Florida,LLC Wantman Group - 3 ' '-ti,.,,,,L, '-i,1-,,,,7,;,--?• .''''4, . "- ,, - A-.1,P5';f:'':.,t,;',--.V.,:7-!''''.:: , 't 9 ; „:, ., .-,1-.4,°,----- ^te : x a '� •m:.s� f + �, �� t A ;� � �� "� 1 �au �; � '' y, � Il S 1� TAI' IIAI' II TRA ; baU> 1: S ! t" tnai + o, .^wr a::',",,!;.:4:. � ar # -1 g 41),, .t."''', # �I[ riF' ii Agenda Item #7-1 SheaBarbara Page 1 of 5 Subject: FW: Right Turn on 41 Agenda Item 7 Attachments: Turn 1-1.jpg; Turn 4-1.jpg;Turn 5-1.jpg; Turn 7-1.jpg From: Mike Shepherd [mailto:mikeshepherdpaCo>gmail.com] Sent:Thursday,June 15, 2017 5:42 PM To: NeilDorrill; McCaughtryMary; JacobLisa Subject: Right Turn on 41 Mary, Please send a copy of this to Joe as a one way. Thanks, Mike Neil, I think we might be over thinking our plan for making the Gulf Park to US41 a right turn only exit. Here is my thinking, for you to dispute.... Gulf Park is a county road and not subject to FDOT as far as changes are concerned. If we wanted to do nothing but restripe the left lane of Gulf Park approaching US 41 from the west, only county approval would be needed. I have attached a similar arrangement which exists for the north exit from the Riverchase Shopping Center(better known as the home of the north Starbucks) onto northbound US 41. The lanes were obviously original configured when a left turn onto US 41 was possible (before the median structures were built). Now, the intersection only allows a right turn. The only work required to make the intersection conform to the right-turn mentality... stripe the left lane with a converging geometry and add a "no left turn" sign I can't imagine a total cost of more than a few thousand. Can we try the Riverchase solution and see what happens? Leave US41 untouched.... let the sheriff ticket any goofball who tries to turn left anyway. Mike Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 • k + r 3e _ - , .., .-, ..4,... -...' . 7.4 f,,,.,•41'.---..-.-,..--- ..., t ' -•.---4:44i, . LL 1 ` gyp ` ,'. —.; ; ' T ! ,,,. .4; '-".•-•,,Tr.::'*! ,' -..•:,i-,L:'-':, . -.-1,.„. 4?-4 - • ''.1'' ',1-111.-- 'N-•'-'•: ;',*„4?3,4i.i--tilli';';--...- .„.2.''---,-,-;„1.4:ii; : . , : . • ., -:4.- , .. Niiii;:5,-,":.••, 4-- -8**‘-Pf1-74;35":: ---:;'-''-;'''''''-' '•Cti-,:i -' �V s. Y :#r • 71 • ' edm" -y i. > .3 : k- . _{ ---krws.,•. , g '~3 _ x - #" 40'..._-1' !.Yr-- arl-4t ` e y €' �#'`!F 04 r.s., err 111" i ai ma { � � r .i:u * r r a Aar' ±`' # e#,• �y.i _g S. g ti ' yx. } • ,i '«,fir . ., • fit; L, 1 '' ,# ''4 6'> s- - --V �'1:4, 1-" :*7"•-• t �. '1. '`� 1` 'f rs. t 5+ g i 4 s g- r-Y(p, 4� b, 4 ay ijit .P t is . . "` :„. • •,.„. lto Ir {;11 • .....,.,•,.„..,. : �W , ...,._.•::,.:.„..w...• •,•,....,;A,•-,;,,,:..74.77--7--,M.,..,,,- ,,,„....,-,.-i-,••• .:,--,••.7.-,--,-.--;77,.-'--7,7-7:,77--,7„--i:-„ :- -zetg',4, :iN „,1,A.,-**itg • • ems: • ' • N•' ,4e arab a 1 1 _ ' �a x, 44a,, , .:. : .. '. " 1 3 I) L.,41100,00id '"', , s3 �; 1 I } ate %'+'''''+--- " ,� S i .. ; 1 i ,zd "' • „.F�t ‘ "-o4 �`: ra ( ''#� 'A £d G , ' i" S .�� fi. � t:-Y �Li1 y , litill% s ti .,,,iti °�;� µmsm �a g ,S''.e: ' i : : , i '4': ''''''' 1 417r .,. ,.,„.,..—,4141,.4- ,..„...,„,,., /-- ,-,;;-.1., ,:. ,,,t 1......0.:,, , ,- .i._ /-,,. -, t . a i 1 .., -. ,. 'N M - 1, — `',.,'-',.-.,7,,iyi.4 I -7,,, ) _,,... ,,,,,,. „ . r' „, 44'..-.. g 4 __ ., ,,, ,,,.„ ,,, ,,,. _ 5....,,,. ,.-.4 g!.. , „,.,,i. Fl 1 I dg aLrii.e � fig ',w ; 'nW —,1 1 4 s , - -,... - - . „I-,, ,,,,,,?1 .4.,........ -...,,.- --..'4'4 '' . r-1:•4'.'" "-, -,,-7' ,it,Ptit-', '''' ' '''2'3iF-- le u4 lei yw]' : i. Mic 4'. '-'7.7r''; gi4' --1 '- '-'-'471i'f t l',:iiirICSE„,-:: „, ".', '''%'',..-.,-;'''' - '+f .4 a ° .Y ''' "::.4....;c. � Sty ''' * \'.:.' *'rile4rhA'AtA :",';IA, ,' l'._,,'-,,. '-- -,;,-„,:n • '.� Pt' tM's r s tos •mak `,� t 4. III �� Sw nrpt [�a 'f -tea, '' v ', ''... ' -.k\. . . it.,. -`,. :. , . , ES-• t. It � l , --s;'-1,-:" ' ' '-:':- ''' "- '- ', .51.4-' i.t ' , '' f ygpq s a�l .it. 1G'",. 1f . ..41.—...t.;!' n y y,i �a.../ �yy , 'fit . Yyi ke 9'x-. fi :tr ' , .i. t:' ' ' ; t /, '' '1...'1"-'. -,-f %.; .. ; s $` _ 1 t k pa tom�.. ' tg"P . c- t 4 - 4 LL t i ,it _ r. �M� 7.---7� � v. IL.1G[ 10.......71t i t t!' s .iN,t Page 5 of r s°¢ � . ' fi" �'':' a,,f.`j - " xr? a i C 6 ' se� 7. ''��5'as"..n. N: ,t \,a,y3 ' 4 '1a - i � ' A t s -illa ft.`NI :.. E �� ---v a�tZ-:7.2,_'w. - i[':kr r34 ng yz [i., ,-,-;,'• a✓ eke " =7..R"'.,-... i. *i s yk m� 1. j ( '. $ a"\ `\ h`ef I 44\qq 444444444f4474!;474'44:44 i , - \-„"AD'44-4;1,44\ , "-..,-,,-,.., ,, , .it,N tAu' ' `�te �. h vp}J?`44 : is l Agenda Item#8 Page 1 of 2 JaccibLisa AMEMBIfilleallW From: Jim Carr ljim.carr@abbinc.com] Sent: Wednesday, May 17, 2017 12:08 PM To: JacobLisa Cc: Joe Chicurel; SheaBarbara Subject: RE: Sidewalk or Pathway? Attachments: Collier County, FL Land Development Code Sidewalk, Pathway requirements.pdf Lisa, This might be more than you need, but here are some definitions,and attached is section from the Collier County Land Development Code (LDC): SIDEWALK Chapter 8 of the FDOT Plans and Preparation Manual Volume 1. 8.3.1 Sidewalks: "Sidewalks are walkways parallel to the roadway and designed for use by pedestrians. Generally, sidewalks should be constructed along both sides of arterial roadways that are not provided with shoulders" The min width of sidewalk is 5'on both curb and gutter and flush shoulder roadways, with a minimum separation from back of curb of 2'. If the sidewalk is adjacent to the curb the minimum width is 6'. Grades shall allow adequate drainage but maintain ADA requirements. A clear 1' wide graded area with 1:6 max slope shall be provided, and edge drops off should be avoided. Collier County Land Development Code: Sidewalk: That portion of a right-of-way or cross or crosswalk, paved or otherwise surfaced, intended for pedestrian use and bicycle use. (See Chapters 4 and 10). Sidewalks must be 5' wide and provided with dedicated public or private right of way or internal access. Construction material consist of a minimum 4" concrete for non-county maintained roads and 6" minimum for country maintained roads, both constructed over compacted subgrade. Sidewalks can also be paver brick over 4" thick compacted limerock base w/paver sand per manufacture specs. PATHWAY Chapter 8 of the FDOT Plans and Preparation Manual Volume 1. 8.6 Shared Use Paths: "Shared use paths are typically facilities on exclusive rights of way and with minimal cross flow of motor vehicles. They are almost always used by pedestrians,joggers, in-line skaters, bicyclists, and in some cases equestrians. However, the bicycle's operating characteristics will dictate the design of shared use paths. The criteria in this section apply to paved shared use paths" Typically, 10'14' wide depending on use and variety of users(bicyclist, pedestrians,joggers, skaters). ADA Requirements shall be met regarding sloping and ramps etc... 4-foot lateral offset to obstruction shall be maintained, as well as 2 feet wide, 1:6 max slope adjacent to both sides. Collier County Land Development Code: Pathway: A defined corridor for the primary use of non-motorized travel. All pathways shall be designed in accordance with the most current FDOT Bicycle Facilities Planning and Design Handbook as it pertains to shared use pathways. Pathways Construction material consist of a minimum 4" concrete for non-county maintained roads and 6" minimum for county maintained roads, both constructed over compacted subgrade. Or Pathways can be Asphalt at a minimum of 6 inches stabilized subgrade (LBR 40), 6 inches compacted limerock base, and 1.5 inches Type S-Ill asphaltic concrete. • Agenda Item#8 Page 2 of 2 James A. Carr, P.E. Agnoli, Barber& Brundage, Inc. 7400 Trail Boulevard, Suite 200 Naples, FL 34108 239.597.3111 ext 215 239.566.2203 fax Original Message From: JacobLisa [mailto:LisaJacob@colliergov.net] Sent: Tuesday, May 16, 2017 11:43 AM To: Jim Carr<iim.carra4abbinc.com> Cc: Joe Chicurel <jchicurelggmail.com>; SheaBarbara <BarbaraShea@colliergov.net> Subject: Sidewalk or Pathway? Hello Jim, The landscape and safety committee wants to know what the difference is between a "sidewalk" and a "pathway". Would you please help answer this question? Thanks, Lisa Sent from my iPhone Under Florida Law,e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 2 1 Agenda Item#8 Agnoli, Barber& Brundage, Inc Page 1 of 1 Engineer's Preliminary Opinion of Probable Cost June 15, 2017 PN: 16-0108 (fka 11-0043) PELICAN BAY BOULEVARD PATHWAY(10/06/2011 Plans) WESTSIDE-THE COMMONS TO NORTH TRAM STATION A. CROSSWALK CONSTRUCTION Item No. Description Unit Quantity Unit Total Cost Cost 1 MOBILIZATION LS 1 $40,000.00 $40,000.00 2 MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC LS 1 $15,000.00 $15,000.00 3 DEMOLITION-ASPHALT PATHWAY SY 3,262 $3.50 $11,417.00 4 DEMOLITION-CLEARING AND GRUBBING(SHRUBS,SOD,MISC.) LS 1 $2,500.00 $2,500.00 5 DEMOLITION-CURB LF 104 $6.00 $624.00 6 DEMOLITION-CONCRETE SIDEWALK SY 20 $25.00 $500.00 7 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL OAK EA 8 $1,700.00 $13,600.00 8 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL SABAL EA 2 $600.00 $1,200.00 9 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL ORCHID EA 2 $800.00 $1,600.00 10 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL MAHOGANY EA 3 $1,300.00 $3,900.00 11 ADA COMPLIANT DETECTABLE WARNINGS EA 30 $250.00 $7,500.00 12 PAVERS-REMOVE&RE-INSTALL W/NEW BORDERS AT CROSSWALKS SY 220 $105.00 $23,100.00 13 CONCRETE-6"THICK(PATHWAY) SY 5,131 $44.00 $225,764.00 14 CONCRETE-2'VALLEY GUTTER LF 89 $20.00 $1,780.00 15 CONCRETE-6"THICK SIDEWALK SY 36 $44.00 $1,584.00 16 REGULATORY SIGNAGE-DECORATIVE POST(RELOCATE EXISTING SIGNS) EA 2 $400.00 $800.00 17 REGULATORY SIGNAGE-R1-1 EA 2 $300.00 $600.00 18 THERMOPLASTIC STRIPING,STD,WHITE,SOLID-6"WIDTH LF 820 $3.00 $2,460.00 19 THERMOPLASTIC STRIPING,STD,WHITE,SOLID-24"WIDTH LF 62 $12.00 $744.00 20 ALUMINUM RAILING LF 70 $90.00 $6,300.00 21 LANDSCAPE-RELOCATE EXSTING IRRIGATION LS 1 $2,750.00 $2,750.00 22 LANDSCAPE-RESTORE EXISTING SHRUBS,GRASSES,MULCH LS 1 $3,300.00 $3,300.00 23 LANDSCAPE-RESTORE SOD LS 1 $5,500.00 $5,500.00 24 ADJUST ELECTRIC HANDHOLE TOP TO GRADE EA 2 $1,000.00 $2,000.00 25 ADJUST IRRIGATION VALVE BOX TO GRADE EA 2 $250.00 $500.00 26 TEMPORARY SILT FENCE LF 6,300 $1.50 $9,450.00 27 BIO-BARRIER ROOT CONTROL EA 46 $400.00 $18,400.00 TOTAL $402,873.00 10%CONTINGENCY $40,287.30 PROJECT TOTAL $443,160.30 Agnoli, Barber& Brundage, Inc Engineer's Preliminary Opinion of Probable Cost June 15, 2017 PN: 16-0108 (fka 11-0043) PELICAN BAY BOULEVARD PATHWAY(10/06/2011 Plans) WESTSIDE -THE COMMONS TO NORTH TRAM STATION A. CROSSWALK CONSTRUCTION Item No. Description Unit Quantity Unit Total Cost Cost 1 MOBILIZATION LS 1 $28,000.00 $28,000.00 2 MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC LS 1 $15,000.00 $15,000.00 3 DEMOLITION-ASPHALT(MILL 3/4"LAYER) SY 3,262 $10.00 $32,620.00 4 DEMOLITION-CLEARING AND GRUBBING(SHRUBS,SOD,MISC.) LS 1 $2,500.00 $2,500.00 5 DEMOLITION-CURB LF 104 $6.00 $624.00 6 DEMOLITION-CONCRETE SIDEWALK SY 20 $25.00 $500.00 7 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL OAK EA 8 $1,700.00 $13,600.00 8 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL SABAL EA 2 $600.00 $1,200.00 9 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL ORCHID EA 2 $800.00 $1,600.00 10 DEMOLITION-TREE REMOVAL MAHOGANY EA 3 $1,300.00 $3,900.00 II ADA COMPLIANT DETECTABLE WARNINGS EA 30 $250.00 $7,500.00 12 PAVERS-REMOVE&RE-INSTALL W/NEW BORDERS AT CROSSWALKS SY 220 $105.00 $23,100.00 13 12"STABILIZED SUBGRADE LBR-100 SY 1,828 $10.00 $18,280.00 14 6"LIMEROCK LBR-40 SY 1,828 $10.00 $18,280.00 15 ASPHALT-1.5"TYPES(PATHWAY) SY 5,131 $12.00 $61,572.00 16 CONCRETE-2'VALLEY GUTTER LF 89 $20.00 $1,780.00 17 CONCRETE-6"THICK SIDEWALK SY 36 $44.00 $1,584.00 18 ,REGULATORY SIGNAGE-DECORATIVE POST(RELOCATE EXISTING SIGNS) EA 2 $400.00 $800.00 19 REGULATORY SIGNAGE-Rl-1 EA 2 $300.00 $600.00 20 THERMOPLASTIC STRIPING,STD,WHITE,SOLID-6"WIDTH LF 820 $3.00 $2,460.00 21 THERMOPLASTIC STRIPING,STD,WHITE,SOLID-24"WIDTH LF 62 $12.00 $744.00 22 ALUMINUM RAILING LF 70 $90.00 $6,300.00 23 LANDSCAPE-RELOCATE EXSTING IRRIGATION LS 1 $2,750.00 $2,750.00 _ 24 LANDSCAPE-RESTORE EXISTING SHRUBS,GRASSES,MULCH LS 1 $3,300.00 $3,300.00 25 LANDSCAPE-RESTORE SOD LS I $5,500.00 $5,500.00 26 ADJUST ELECTRIC HANDHOLE TOP TO GRADE EA 2 $1,000.00 $2,000.00 27 ADJUST IRRIGATION VALVE BOX TO GRADE EA 2 $250.00 $500.00 _ 28 TEMPORARY SILT FENCE LF 6,300 $1.50 $9,450.00 29 BIO-BARRIER ROOT CONTROL EA 46 $400.00 $18,400.00 TOTAL $284,444.00 10%CONTINGENCY $28,444.40 PROJECT TOTAL $312,888.40 Gwen Rasiwala From: JacobLisa <LisaJacob@colliergov.net> Sent: Tuesday, June 20, 2017 9:57 AM To: Gwen Rasiwala Subject: Fwd: Gulf park Dr. Would you please print 15 copies of this email?Thanks, Lisa Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Ken Dawson <napleskendawson@aol.com<mailto:napleskendawson@aol.com>> Date:June 20, 2017 at 08:48:10 EDT To:JacobLisa Jacob<lisajacob@colliergov.net<mailto:lisajacob@colliergov.net>> Subject: Fwd: Gulf park Dr. Straw Pole 18 are not in favor of he No Left Turn . 3 neutral O for Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From:J and R REED<reedmtn@yahoo.com<mailto:reedmtn@yahoo.com>> Date:June 14, 2017 at 12:01:28 PM EDT To: "napleskendawson@aol.com<mailto:napleskendawson@aol.com>" <napleskendawson@aol.com<mailto:napleskendawson@aol.com>> Subject: Gulf park Dr. Reply-To: "reedmtn@yahoo.com<mailto:reedmtn@yahoo.com>" <reedmtn@yahoo.com<mailto:reedmtn@yahoo.com>> Ken, We are strongly OPPOSED to ANY change in Gulf Park Drive. There is no valid reason for any adjustment to turning and we oppose a turn around on the roadway. Blessings, Jeff& Rita Reed St. Maarten 703 Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1