Immokalee MSTU Minutes 04/20/2016 JEnclosure 2
1
MINUTES
Meeting of the Joint Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Committee, and the
Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee on April 20, 2016.
Immokalee Library
417 North 1st Street, Immokalee, FL
(239) 657-2882
A. Call to Order.
The meeting was called to order by Frank Nappo, CRA Chair and Cherryle Thomas
MSTU Chair at 8:30 AM.
B. Roll Call and Announcement of a Quorum.
Advisory Committee/EZDA Members Present:
Mike Facundo, Estil Null, Ski Olesky, Andrea Halman, and Frank Nappo.
Advisory Committee Members Absent/Excused:
Joseph Mucha, Cindy Lozano, Martha Williams, Jim Wall, and Julio Estremera.
MSTU Advisory Committee Members Present:
Cherryle Thomas, Lucy Ortiz, Bill Deyo, and Andrea Halman.
MSTU Advisory Committee Members Absent/Excused:
Norma Garcia.
Others Present: Bessie Reyna, David Wheeler, Derell Burr, David Jones, Michelle
Arnold, Mariela Romero, Everett Loukonen, Randy Cash, Richard Tindell, Patti
Calderon, Silvia Puente, Vanessa Bielema, Danny Gonzalez, Steven Lopez, Juan Serna
Herrera, Armando Yzaguirre, Paul Anderson, Pam Brown, Jack Johnson, Trinity Scott,
Jonas Marvelous, Amanda Townsend, Michele, Mosca, Lorraine Lantz, Fred N. Thomas,
Corine Williams, Maria Garcia Pizarro, Mike Sheffield, Omar Deleon, Beth Brainard,
and Joann Ramey.
Staff: Christie Betancourt and James Sainvilus.
C. Introductions. Chairman Frank Nappo introduced himself and welcomed all to the
meeting. All other board members present and members of the public introduced
themselves.
D. Announcements.
1. Meetings and Public Comment speaker slips
CRA staff reiterated the public 3 minute speaker slip policy. The board will give
more time if they feel it necessary.
2. Communications and Customer Services Division - Mike Sheffield and Maria Garcia
Pizarro.
Mr. Sheffield and Ms. Garcia Pizarro introduced themselves and provided the board
and public with an overview of what they do for the county. They also provided
board and public with their contact information.
CRA Chair Dr. Frank Nappo would like to see if it’s possible to have access to
public meetings housed at Horseshoe Drive and at the Main Campus. We would
want to be able to interact in the meeting as it is going on maybe by phone hook up,
web or by facebook. Mr. Sheffield said that they would look into the possibility of
having the set up. Pam Brown, Jonas Marvelous, Fred Thomas also provided
comments to Mr. Sheffield.
Enclosure 2
2
3. Immokalee Branch Library – Amanda Townsend
Amanda Townsend from Collier County Public Services Division discussed with the
board the concerns regarding the Immokalee Branch Library Saturday hours and the
literacy program.
Dr. Frank Nappo provided board and public with a brief history of the communities
concerns. He said that the board would like to have a meeting with library staff to
include the Immokalee Chamber of Commerce, the Rotary Club, the Immokalee
Civic Association, the Immokalee CRA, and the Immokalee MSTU to talk about
what kind of programs we would like to see and what months are better than others.
It doesn’t have to be a 12 month operation what we would like to do is discuss what
the community wants and needs are.
Ms. Townsend would like to offer three ideas 1.) Our new library director has new
and exciting ideas and is very much interested in seeing libraries being reenvision ed.
2.) As an in-between solution we can start to have these dialogs and the community
center is also opened on Saturdays. 3.) In the fall the library system will be doing
comprehensive community assessments and going out and doing focus groups all
over the county.
Mr. Fred Thomas reiterated how important it is to have the library opened on the
weekends. He suggested that if it’s a budget issue we should try to use volunteers to
staff the weekend hours.
MSTU Chair Cherryle Thomas also commented on the importance of literacy
programs for children of all ages.
Mr. Null and Patti Calderon also provided comments to Ms. Townsend.
4. Immokalee Code Enforcement staff
Code Enforcement staff introduced themselves and gave board brief updates on their
coverage areas and community involvement. Steven Lopez and Juan Serna Herrera
provided their contact information and the main number (239-252-2440) for
complaints.
MSTU Chair Ms. Cherryle Thomas would like to go on the record requesting
assistant for a citizen in Immokalee whose property has been used as a dumping site
for tires. They have about 50 tires that need to be removed. Code sta ff said they
would look into helping the property owner.
Mr. Marvin Courtright wanted to know if code enforcement had any responsibility
or authority at the Immokalee Airport. Mr. Courtright has security concerns for the
Immokalee Airport. Code staff said they don’t have any security responsibility for
the airport maybe the sheriff’s department does.
E. Adoption of Agenda.
Staff presented agenda to the board for approval. Agenda was approved as presented.
Action: No action was taken by the CRA due to a lack of quorum.
Action: Mr. Lucy Ortiz made a motion for the MSTU to adopt the Agenda. Mr. Bill
Deyo seconded the motion and it passed by unanimous vote. 4-0.
F. Communications.
1. Public Meeting Notice
2. Community Events
3. Articles
Enclosure 2
3
CRA staff reviewed the communications folder with the boards. Staff passed around
the folder for all public to review.
G. Approval of Minutes.
1. Approval of Minutes for the Joint March 16, 2016 CRA & MSTU Advisory
Committee Meeting. (Enclosure 1)
Action: CRA March 16, 2016 minutes were tabled due to no quorum present.
Action: Ms. Lucy Ortiz made a motion to approve the minutes for the Joint March 16,
2016 CRA/EZDA & MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting. The motion was seconded by Ms.
Andrea Halman and the minutes were approved by unanimous vote. 4-0.
H. BCC Agenda Items approved March 2016
1. 2015 Annual Report
Staff reported that the 2015 Annual Report was approved by the board in March.
2. Collier County Community and Human Services Division FY 2016-2017 grant
application
Staff also reported that the two CDBG grants that staff requested after the fact
permission to apply for were also approved.
I. BCC Agenda Item for April 2016
1. Lozano’s Restaurant – Commercial Façade Grant (Enclosure 2)
Staff provided board with a copy of Enclosure 2 which is an executive summary
requesting that the CRA approve the application and recipient agreement for the
Immokalee CRA Commercial Façade Improvements Grant Program for
reimbursement of $20,000 for façade improvements to Lozano’s Restaurant located
at 405 New Market Road. This item will go before the board on April 26, 2016.
Staff informed the board that the complete package was in the communications
folder. Staff also showed all present a color rendering of the before and after of
what Lozano’s will look like.
Danny Gonzalez from the Immokalee Chamber of Commerce and employee of
Lozano’s Restaurant has concerns about how New Market Road looks. He said that
a lot of cars are being sold from private properties. He also said that one particular
property owner is using his property as a used car lot. Mr. Gonzalez said that he also
called Family Dollar corporate office on the landscaping on New Market road. The
property needs to be maintained. He also has concerns on New Market Road
business that have pallets that are a fire hazard.
Code Enforcement said they just received the case on the cars being sold on New
Market road yesterday and they have scheduled a site visit.
J. Red Flag Items.
K. MSTU New Business
1. FDOT Presentation – David Jones – Immokalee Main Street Improvement Project
(Enclosure 3)
FDOT staff introduced themselves.
James Sainvilus gave a brief history on the Main Street Improvement Project and the
Pedestrian Safety Study.
Staff provided board with Enclosure 3 which was the powerpoint presentation
provided by Florida Department of Transportation. FDOT staff said that the design
for this project will begin this year. Construction will start in the beginning of FY
2019. FDOT staff conducted a brief presentation to the board.
Enclosure 2
4
Scope of Project
Traffic signals at N 3rd Street and N 7th Street
New highway lighting through the corridor
New crosswalk at N 2nd Street
Pedestrian channelization in the median
ADA, signing, and pavement marking upgrades
N 3rd Street Existing Midblock
1,390 crossings over eight hours
Intersection ranked 3rd on the High Pedestrian Crash List
Recommendation: Install a traffic signal
N 7th Street Intersection
441 crossings over eight hours
Students using area to cross SR 29
High number of bike/ped crashes
Enclosure 2
5
Recommendation: Install a traffic signal and remove midblock to the east of the
intersection
N 2nd Street Intersection
326 crossings at intersection and 343 crossings midblock between N 2nd Street
and N 3rd Street
Recommendation: Install a midblock crossing with RRFB
Pam Brown had a concern with a light being put at the designated areas. Flashing
lights are possibly a good idea. She also said that we need to educate the people here
in Immokalee.
Patti Calderon had concerns with the signs currently on Main Street and with the
traffic signals being proposed for Main Street. She wanted to know why are we
willing to put two more traffic lights on Main Street and can’t put one at the
intersection of Westclox and SR29.
Dr. Frank Nappo also voiced his concern on the intersection of Westclox and State
Road 29.
Enclosure 2
6
After much discussion between the board, CRA staff, FDOT staff, and the public
board will meet and coordinate with
L. CRA New Business
1. Naples Pathways – Beth Brainard (Time Certain 10:00 AM)
Beth Brainard introduced herself and briefly gave a background on what the Naples
Pathways Coalition does. Ms. Brainard said that they are an advocacy group that
works for safe bikeable walkable communities. The Naples Pathways Coalition
group works throughout Collier County and advocates and educates the people about
bike, pedestrian, and motorist safety. She said they have almost 400 members and
can reach over 2,000 people who are interested in these issues. Ms. Brainard said
that their group in here to help you.
Ms. Brainard held a Q&A session with all present and provided their website
information www.Pathwayscoalition.org.
Dr Frank Nappo would like to see a board member or a public citizen from
Immokalee join and attend the Naples Pathways Coalition. He also said that on May
4, 2016 at noon he would be touring Ms. Brainard the areas of concern for
Immokalee.
Ms. Brainard said that she would like to invite all to a Pathways Coalition meeting
being held on Monday, May 2, 2016 at 6:00 PM at South Street Café in Naples. The
purpose of the meeting is to identify the problems for Bike Ped safety in Collier
County.
2. Immokalee Accelerator – Dr. Goodman
Dr. Goodman was not present.
3. Transportation Planning TIGER FY2016 Grant – Growing Connections to Create
Mobility Opportunities in Immokalee (Enclosure 4)
CRA Chair Frank Nappo asked Trinity Scott to discuss Lake Trafford Road before
she began her presentation of the TIGER Grant. She said Lake Trafford Road and
the bollard situation there is a big difficult problem to fix. What our department has
been talking about is that their needs to be an interim solution and a long term
solution to address the safety concerns. Our long term solution is we need to get a
pond site and pipe in drainage ditches so we can put proper shoulders and sidewalks
on that roadway and that’s money and also getting through the permitting issues.
Our operations folks have come out and they have come up with an option that
would be to remove temporary curbing with the bollards and to put in a 9 inch
concrete curb in addition they would look at trying to pave an addition two feet on
the north side of Lake Trafford Road. She said that she is currently working with the
school to see if this is something they are okay with.
Ms. Scott also briefly discussed the New Market road sidewalk project and the
possibility of a vacancy of the Pathways Advisory Committee (PAC). She said it
would be good if we had someone from Immokalee on the board.
Staff provided board with Enclosure 4 which is an overview of the TIGER Grant.
This project is designed to grow the existing pedestrian network by providing new
facilities to accommodate bicyclists and pedestrians where none currently exist. By
expanding the small network of pedestrian and bicycle routes it will more than
double the number of current facilities in the area and provide enhanced options for
transportation to education, jobs, and other essential services for residents of
Immokalee.
Enclosure 2
7
Enclosure 2
8
i. Letter of Support (Enclosure 5)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 5 which are draft letters of support to be
included in the TIGER grant. Both the CRA and MSTU chair signed the letters.
***Due to time constraints Michelle Arnold, Director of Transit and Neighborhood was
moved up on the agenda she was going to speak under citizen’s comments.
Ms. Arnold introduced herself and she also introduced her Senior Planner Omar Deleon.
Mr. Deleon discussed some of the efforts that they are working on with public transit.
He said that they want to improve the look of the bus stops. We want to make it clear
and helpful to the community.
An initiative we are trying to do with CAT in Immokalee is we want to find ways to
better connect with the community. We would like to set up a meeting to look at a map
of Immokalee to see what areas of this community need to be serviced.
M. MSTU Old Business
1. Contractors Report
i. Maintenance Reports – A& M
Armando Yzaguirre with A&M Property Maintenance provided board with a
presentation of lawn maintenance for the beautification area. Mr. Yzaguirre said
if you want to do anything with Main Street while you are waiting for the Main
Street Improvement Project you will need to get the irrigation fixed and that will
cost you about $8,000.
***Due to time all items were tabled to the next meeting.
2. MSTU Project Manager
3. Adopt – A – Road Program – update
MSTU
N. CRA Old Business
1. CRA Annual Workshop – April 5, 2016 – update
2. Land Development Coe Amendments
i. Email from Richard Henderlong – LDC Amendment – 5.05.08 Architectural &
Site Design Standards – CCPC hearing (Enclosure 6)
ii. Section 5.05.08 – Architectural and Site Design Standards (Enclosure 7)
iii. Cross Reference to Section 5.05.08 (Enclosure 8)
3. CRA & MSTU Operational Plan Workshop dates
4. Immokalee Stormwater Master Plan – update
5. Priority List for County Manager Leo Ochs (Enclosure 9)
i. CAC March 28, 2016 Meeting – update
ii. MPO April 8, 2016 Meeting – update
6. Immokalee Pioneer Museum – update
7. Advisory Board Members
i. Orientation
ii. Advisory Board vacancies – update
iii. Orientation
Enclosure 2
9
8. CRA staff vacancy – update
9. CRA Project Manager Report
i. Commercial Façade Grant Applicants –update
ii. Sweat Equity Grant Applications
10. Code Enforcement – update
Mr. Steven Lopez gave report under announcements.
11. Other Agencies
i. Immokalee Chamber of Commerce – update
Mr. Danny Gonzalez announced that the Harvest Festival Event and the 5K run
that will be held on April 23, 2016.
ii. SWFWDB – update
iii. Housing – update
iv. Law/Fire Enforcement
v. IFAS Extension
O. Citizen Comments:
Pam Brown wanted to inform the board and the public meeting held last Monday
regarding the Habitat Conservation Plan for Collier County. She would like for the
residents of Immokalee to comment. She also said that our master plan is fourth in line to
be reviewed.
P. Next Meeting Date: CRA & the Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU will meet
on May 18, 2016 at 8:30 AM at the Immokalee Library
Q. Adjournment: The meeting adjourned at 12:00 PM
Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU
---)111))
Immokalee
Certification of Minutes Approval Form
Prepared by: Approved by:
(At'? 2 a
Christie Betancourt,Interim Operations Manager Cherryle Th, as, Chair
MSTU Liaison
These Minutes for the April 20, 2016 Joint CRA & MSTU Advisory Committee were
approved by the MSTU Advisory Committee on May 18,2016 as presented.
* The next MSTU Advisory Committee meeting will be held June 22, 2016 at 8:30A.M. at the
Immokalee CRA office located at 750 South 5th Street,Immokalee, FL., 34142.
All meetings will be publicly noticed in the W. Harmon Turner Building (Building F),posted at the Immokalee
Public Library and provided to the County Public Information Department for distribution. Please call James
Sainvilus; Immokalee CRA, at 239-867-0026 for additional information. In accordance with the American with
Disabilities Act, persons needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact Christie
Betancourt, Administrative Assistant, at least 48 hours before the meeting. The public should be advised that
members of the MSTU Lighting and Beautification Advisory Committee may also be members of other Boards and
Committees. In this regard,matters coming before the Advisory Committee may come before one or more of the
referenced Board and Committees from time to time.