Immokalee MSTU Minutes 02/17/2016 JEnclosure 2
1
MINUTES
Meeting of the Joint Community Redevelopment Agency Advisory Committee, and the
Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee on February 17, 2016.
Immokalee Pioneer Museum at Roberts Ranch
1215 Roberts Avenue, Immokalee, FL
(239) 658-2466
A. Call to Order.
The meeting was called to order by Frank Nappo, CRA Chair and Cherryle Thomas
MSTU Chair at 8:48 AM.
B. Roll Call and Announcement of a Quorum.
Advisory Committee/EZDA Members Present:
Estil Null, Ski Olesky, Jim Wall, Martha Willimas, Cindy Lozano, Joseph Mucha,
Andrea Halman, and Frank Nappo.
Advisory Committee Members Absent/Excused:
Mike Facundo, and Julio Estremera.
MSTU Advisory Committee Members Present:
Cherryle Thomas, Lucy Ortiz, Bill Deyo, and Andrea Halman.
MSTU Advisory Committee Members Absent/Excused:
Norma Garcia.
Others Present: Dr. Beau Bradon, Michelle Mosca, Armando Yzaguirre, Bernardo
Barnhart, Daniel Gonzalez, Pam Brown, Corporal Patti Calderon, David Altomare, Lexi
Aupperlee, Mariela Romero, Hilda Garcia, and Carrie Williams.
Staff: Christie Betancourt and James Sainvilus.
C. Introductions. Chairman Frank Nappo introduced himself and welcomed all to the
meeting. All other board members present and members of the public introduced
themselves.
D. Announcements.
1. Meetings and Public Comment speaker slips
CRA staff reiterated the public 3 minute speaker slip policy. The board will give
more time if they feel it necessary.
2. CRA Annual Workshop April 5, 2016 at 1:00 pm @BCC Chambers
Dr. Frank Nappo reminded all about the CRA Annual Workshop and how important
it is for boards and Immokalee public to attend.
3. Immokalee Pioneer Museum – Hilda Garcia
Hilda Garcia introduced herself and gave a brief history on the Immokalee Pioneer
Museum at Robert’s Ranch. Ms. Garcia also discussed future projects at the
museum. She provided all in attendance a brochure with the history and hours of the
museum.
Board would like for the museum to be advertised and promoted more. They would
like to have local organizations and schools do scheduled tours at the museum. They
would also like for staff to look into the possibility of applying for TDC (Tourist
Development Council) funds to promote the Immokalee Pioneer Museum at
Robert’s Ranch.
Enclosure 2
2
4. The Immokalee Fire District
Chief Paul Anderson gave an update on the gaming compact revenue. He said that
he went to Tallahassee a couple weeks ago and requested that the Immokalee Fire
Control District get 24 percent of the gaming compact money and the Immokalee
MSTU taxing district get 20 percent of the gaming compact money. He also briefly
spoke about the straw ballot vote on the March Ballot.
E. Adoption of Agenda.
Staff presented agenda to the board for approval. Agenda was approved with no changes.
Action: Mr. Ski Oleksy made a motion for the CRA to adopt the Agenda. Ms. Andrea
Halman seconded the motion and it passed by unanimous vote. 8-0.
Action: Ms. Andrea Halman made a motion for the MSTU to adopt the Agenda. Mr.
Bill Deyo seconded the motion and it passed by unanimous vote. 4-0.
F. Communications.
1. Public Meeting Notice
2. Community Events
3. Immokalee Bulletin Articles
4. Naples Daily News Articles
CRA staff reviewed the communications folder with the boards. Staff passed around the
folder for all public to review.
G. Approval of Minutes.
1. Approval of Minutes for the Joint November 18, 2015 CRA/EZDA & MSTU
Advisory Committee Meeting. (Enclosure 1)
Action: Ms. Andrea Halman made a motion to approve the minutes for the Joint
November 18, 2015 CRA/EZDA & MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Ski Oleksy and the minutes were approved by unanimous vote. 8-0.
2. Approval of Minutes for the Joint December 16, 2015 CRA/EZDA & MSTU
Advisory Committee Meeting. (Enclosure 2)
Action: Ms. Andrea Halman made a motion to approve the minutes for the Joint
December 16, 2015 CRA/EZDA & MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting. The motion was
seconded by Mr. Ski Oleksy and the minutes were approved by unanimous vote. 8-0.
3. Approval of Minutes for the Joint January 20, 2016 CRA & MSTU Advisory
Committee Meeting. (Enclosure 3)
Carrie Williams would like for language in the January minutes section D.2. (page 6)
be corrected to say:
Public speaker Carrie Williams wanted to know why it isn’t is named Opportunity
Collier County not Opportunity Naples. Agricultural is struggling and we need other
ways for people to earn a living in Immokalee. We need economic develop ment in
Immokalee desperately.
Enclosure 2
3
Action: Ms. Andrea Halman made a motion to approve the minutes for the Joint
January 20, 2016 CRA & MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting with one correction on
D.2.(page 6). The motion was seconded by Mr. Ski Oleksy and the minutes were approved by
unanimous vote. 8-0.
Action: Ms. Lucy Ortiz made a motion to approve the minutes for the Joint January 20,
2016 CRA & MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting with one correction on D.2. (page6). The
motion was seconded by Ms. Andrea Halman and the minutes were approved by unanimous
vote. 4-0.
H. BCC Agenda Items for February 2016
1. Promise Zone Application (Enclosure 4)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 4 which is a resolution for the Collier County
Community Redevelopment Agency supporting the Rural Promise Zone Application
for Southwest Florida.
Action: Mr. Ski Oleksy made a motion to approve the Promise Zone application. The
motion was seconded by Ms. Andrea Halman and the motion was approved by unanimous
vote. 8-0.
I. BCC Agenda Item for March 2016
1. 2015 Annual Report
Staff will finalize the annual report and present it to the board at the March meeting.
Report will be on the consent agenda on March 22, 2016 BCC meeting. Staff asked
board what they would like to see on the cover of the report. After discussion board
would like for the Immokalee Pioneer Museum to be on the cover of the annual
report.
2. Advisory Board appointments
Staff provided board with an update on the vacant advisory board appointments.
3. Rural Area Opportunity – FHREDI (Enclosure 5)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 5 which is a an Executive Summary to approve
a Resolution expressing support for the continuation of the designation of the
Community of Immokalee as a Rural Area of Opportunity (RAO) within the Florida
Heartland Regional Economic Development Initiative, Inc. (FHREDI) Region. Staff
will provide final documents at the next meeting.
4. Collier County Community and Human Service Division FY 2016 - 2017.
Staff informed board that they will be applying for two grants. Staffs applied for the
grants last year but weren’t awarded them. The first grant is for Commercial Façade
Grant for $440,000 and the second grant is for $770,000 for Sidewalk and
Stormwater Drainage Project. Staff will be attending a Pre-Application meeting
today with Collier County Community and Human Services to discuss all the grant
requirements.
Danny Gonzalez wanted to know if there is any way that we can get local plaza
owners to fix their plazas. He said that some plazas in this community need major
improvements. What can we do to get the business owner to apply for this grant?
Staff said they will have to coordinate with the business owners to get them to apply
for the Commercial Façade Grant.
Chief Paul Anderson would like for staff to send grant guidelines by email as soon
as they are available.
Enclosure 2
4
J. Red Flag Items
1. New Market Road (Enclosure 6)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 6 which are pictures of the condition of New
Market Road and an email from county staff giving a timeline of repairs of New
Market Road. The road is set to be repaved in 2017 after the sidewalk project is
completed. It is set to start this summer.
***Due to time restraint we will be moving up Agenda item L.4.ii.
L. CRA New Business.
4. Commercial Façade Grant Applicants
ii. Lozano’s Restaurant
Staff provided board with Enclosure 10 which is a rendering of the improvement
for Lozano’s Restaurant. Staff announced that Danny Gonzalez and Sandy
Gonzalez are here today to request a Commercial Façade Grant for Lozano’s
Restaurant.
Mr. Gonzalez discussed the plans for the improvements that the Lozano family
would like to do on the restaurant. After a Q&A session board would like to
award Lozano’s Restaurant with a Façade Grant for $20,000.
Action: Mr. Ski Oleksy made a motion to award Lozano’s Restaurant for $20,000. Mr.
Frank Nappo and the motion was approved by unanimous vote. 8-0
***Staff went back to regular Agenda Item J.2. Lake Trafford.
2. Lake Trafford
Staff announced that Margaret Bishop is the Project Manager for the project.
i. Lake Trafford Seawall (Enclosure 7)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 7 which is a Project Management Plan for
Ann Olesky Park Erosion Control. Staff reviewed the project background
information, project budget and project schedule.
ii. Ann Olesky Park Pier Improvements (Enclosure 8)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 8 which is a Project Management Plan for
Ann Olesky Park pier repair. Staff reviewed the project background information,
project budget and project schedule.
3. Priority List for County Manager Leo Ochs.
Staff said that at the January 20th meeting County Manager Leo Ochs requested that
both boards provide him with a Priority List for Immokalee.
Staff will combine the priority list from the Operational Plan Workshop from the
CRA and the MSTU.
After discussion board would like for staff to have a workshop in March to come up
with a combined Top Priority list. Staff would like for list to be compiled by the
April BCC/CRA Workshop.
K. MSTU New Business
No new business items.
Enclosure 2
5
L. CRA New Business
1. James “Jimmy Garvin” The Movie (Enclosure 9)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 9 which is an email from Craig Kirby
regarding the Jimmy Garvin movie. Staff asked Immokalee Chamber of Commerce
president, Danny Gonzalez to speak about this project. Mr. Gonzalez said that on
January 30, 2016 a couple of community members met with Craig Kirby to discuss
the life and life achievements of Immokalee native Jimmy Garvin. He also said that
Mr. Garvin has a book out called Legacy of a Common Man: The Walk Was Uphill
and they want to make it into a movie. They want to call the movie
“IMMOKALEE”. He will be here in April for the Harvest Festival parade. He is
one of the marshals for the parade.
2. Advisory Board Members
i. Orientation
Staff said that they would like to review the new CRA bylaws with the advisory
board in April. Staff will provide all board members an orientation of the current
active board.
ii. Advisory Board vacancies
Staff provided board with an update on the advisory board vacancies. We have
10 appointed members right now. We have six applicants. We voted to appoint
four members who were Maria O’Neill, Bernardo Barnhart, Paul Anderson, and
Mariela Romero. Please give me clear direction as to what you would like to do.
After discussion board would like for the chair to send a letter to the board of
county commissioners requesting to appoint the four applicants the board has
already agreed to appoint.
Action: Mr. Frank Nappo would like to appoint the four applicants to the CRA Advisory
Board. The motion was seconded by Mr. Ski Olesky and the motion was approved by
unanimous vote. 8-0.
3. CRA staff vacancy
No update was given.
i. Sub-Committee
4. Commercial Façade Grant Applicants
i. Mr. 99 Cents Supermarket
Staff will reach out to Mr. 99 Center to see if they will be applying for a
Commercial Façade Grant.
M. MSTU Old Business
1. Contractors Report
i. Maintenance Reports – A& M (Enclosure 11)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 11 which is the maintenance report for the
month of January and half of February. Armando Yzaguirre provided board with
a maintenance update. He also reported that the new banners are up. He said that
some of the banner poles stands need to be repaired or replaced. Staff will work
with Armando to come up with a solution.
MSTU Board would like for staff to include pole maintenance to the new
maintenance contract.
Enclosure 2
6
Armando wanted to know about the landscape maintenance along the edge of the
grounds. Ms. Hilda Garcia spoke a little bit more about the area regarding the
land size which is 13.1 acres and about the clearing of the overgrown landscaping.
She said that they would like to install benches, umbrellas and picnic tables at the
ranch. Staff asked Hilda If they had every considered installing a bike path at the
ranch. After much discussion the boards would like for the MSTU Project
Manager to look into a partnership with the MSTU, the CRA, and the Immokalee
Pioneer Museum to improve and promote the area. Board would also like to see a
nice welcome sign along 15th Street. The current sign is in the entrance of the
ranch. Board would also like for Ms. Garcia to invite Ron Jamro to our next Joint
CRA/MSTU meeting. Mr. Danny Gonzalez would like to see if your supervisor
would consider allowing the Harvest Festival to be held at the ranch. Ms. Garcia
will also invite Mr. Jamro to the Immokalee Chamber of Commerce meeting.
ii. Landscape Architect – GWS
No report was given.
2. MSTU Budget Report
i. Current Budget (Enclosure 12)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 12 which is the current budget for MSTU
Fund 162 and 111 for review.
ii. Expenditure Report (Enclosure 13)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 13 which is an expense report for MSTU
Fund 162 and 111 for review.
3. MSTU Project Manager
i. Monument (Enclosure 14)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 14 which is the Project Manager report Staff
reviewed the report with board.
T
h
e
r
e
p
o
r
t
Enclosure 2
7
Mr. James Sainvilus said that the reason this item was brought back up from the
last meeting is because board requested for this item to be tabled until his return
from Military leave. He said that the monument item was requested by the board
as part of the MSTU Operational Workshop priority list.
After discussion board decided not to move forward with the reconstruction of the
monuments in Immokalee. Staff will do more research and will put this on hold
until the Main Street Improvements are completed.
Action: Ms. Lucy Ortiz made a motion to hold off on the monument improvements until
Main Street Improvements are completed. The motion was seconded by Ms. Andrea Halman
and the motion passed by unanimous vote. 4-0.
ii. Immokalee Banners
New banners have been installed.
iii. Sidewalk and Streetscape
A report was given by James Sainvilus MSTU Project Manager.
Enclosure 2
8
iv. Immokalee Main Street Improvements
MSTU Project Manager provided board with an update on the Main Street
Improvements project.
v. Lighting Report (Enclosure 15
Staff provided board with Enclosure 15 which is a maintenance report provided
by the county staff.
This report is for maintenance provided by county staff in January. Staff has requested
that this report be provided to them on a monthly basis.
Staff also wanted to inform the board that two new traffic lights are slated to be
installed on 3rd Street and 7th Street. This was warranted because of the Pedestrian
Safety Study that was done by AIM Engineering.
Enclosure 2
9
Pam Brown said that is too many lights in such a short distance you can’t even
accelerate and then you have to stop again. We need to get someone from the state to
come to our meetings to discuss this further.
James will follow up with FDOT to let them know the concerns the board and public
are having. We wanted lighted crosswalks not traffic lights.
N. CRA Old Business
1. Adopt –A – Road Program – update
No update was given.
2. LDC Amendment – Enclosure 16)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 16 which is the Executive Summary and backup
documentation for BCC Agenda Item 12/8/2015 authorizing staff to process an
amendment in the 2015 Land Development Code Cycle 2 to amend LDC Section
2.03.07 G.5. Immokalee Main Street Overlay Sub-District that will allow prohibitive
uses to become eligible conditional uses within the Immokalee Main Street Overlay
Sub-District (MSOSD) boundary to incentivize commercial development. Caroline
Cilek and staff will present new documentation at the next board meeting and they
are requesting this advisory board to review and approve.
3. Promise Zone Application – update
Staff provided board with an update.
4. Historical Marker for Jane Brown Graveyard – update
Staff asked Ms. Pam Brown to provide an update on the graveyard. Ms. Brown said
that she is working with the county to apply for a historical designation.
5. CRA Budget Report
i. Current Budget (Enclosure 17)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 17 which is the CRA/MSTU budget section
that was adopted by the Board of County Commissioners for FY2015-2016.
6. CRA Project Manager Report
i. Immokalee Stormwater Projects
Michele Mosca from the Stormwater planning staff said they are working directly
with CRA staff to identify smaller projects in Immokalee. Our primary objective
is to complete the Immokalee Stormwater Plan update that was originally paid by a
consultant (AIM Engineering) hired by the CRA. This will take about 5 months.
We have two engineers in house looking at it.
We also talked about about purchasing pond sites that were identified in the
Stormwater Master Plan. We have been in discussions with the Williams family
and we received correspondence from the family yesterday for the site that's
immediately west of arrowhead. We will continue the discussions on that property
with the Williams family.
We have about $200,000 so we're looking to see if we can partner up with other
organizations and looking for other grant opportunities. We know a huge concern
to the community is Lake Trafford Road and we are working with transportation
staff to try to identify some funding sources. Michele also announced that an
inventory is being done for all the pipes within the Immokalee community.
Enclosure 2
10
7. Code Enforcement – update
i. Flea Market (Enclosure 18)
Staff provided board with Enclosure 18 which an update regarding the Flea
Market owned by David Esquivel owner of La Soriana. Staff announced that Mr.
Esquivel is going to have a Pre-Application meeting with the county on February
24th. We are hoping someone from code can attend.
Mr. Joseph Mucha provided board with an update on the Flea Market. He also
provided board with an update on McCrory’s.
The CRA chair will be drafting a letter to send to county staff regarding the flea
markets in Immokalee.
8. Immokalee Chamber of Commerce – update
Danny Gonzalez informed the board that the chamber has a new office located at
Null’s Notary office.
9. SWFWDB – update
No update was given.
10. Housing – update
No update was given.
11. Law/Fire Enforcement – update
No update was given.
12. IFAS Extension
No updates were given.
O. Citizen Comments:
No Comments.
P. Next Meeting Date: CRA & the Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU will meet
on March 16, 2016 at 8:30 AM at the Immokalee Pepper Ranch Preserve
Q. Adjournment: The meeting adjourned at 11:55 AM
Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU
j")
Imr c kalee
Certification of Minutes Approval Form
Prepared by: Approved by:
C4ic . Y1 t /t� Nit-ogiS
James Sainvilus Cherryle T` omas, Chair
MSTU Liaison
These Minutes for the February 17, 2016 Joint CRA & MSTU Advisory Committee were
approved by the MSTU Advisory Committee on March 16,2016 as presented.
* The next MSTU Advisory Committee meeting will be held April 27, 2016 at 8:30A.M. at the
Immokalee CRA office located at 750 South 5th Street, Immokalee, FL., 34142.
All meetings will be publicly noticed in the W. Harmon Turner Building (Building F), posted at the lmmokalee
Public Library and provided to the County Public Information Department for distribution. Please call James
Sainvilus, Immokalee CRA, at 239-867-0026 for additional information. In accordance with the American with
Disabilities Act, persons needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact Christie
Betancourt, Administrative Assistant, at least 48 hours before the meeting. The public should be advised that
members of the MSTU Lighting and Beautification Advisory Committee may also be members of other Boards and
Committees. In this regard,matters coming before the Advisory Committee may come before one or more of the
referenced Board and Committees from time to time.