VB MSTU Agenda 05/04/2017 Vassd a ofaf Osae& M.S.7.14.
Advisory Committee
I'pi
� 3299 East Tamiami Trail Suite 103
Naples, FL 34112
MAY 4, 2017 2:00 P.M.
Claussen Family Center at St.John's Church
625 111TH Ave.,Naples,FL
I. Call to order and Pledge of Allegiance
II. Attendance
Advisory committee Bruce Forman—Chairman(11/13/2019)
Bill Sjostrom—Vice Chairman(11/13/2020)
Mark Weber(11/13/2017)
Gabriella R. Miyamoto (11/13/2019)
William Harris(11/13/2020)
Staff Harry Sells—Project Manager
Landscape Robert Kindelan-CLM
III. Approval of agenda
IV. Approval of the minutes of April 6,2017
V. Landscape Report,Robert Kindelan,Commercial Land Maintenance
VI. Project Manager Report, Harry Sells
A. Budget report for 5/4/2017
B. General status of burial project
C. Sidewalks east and west side of Gulf Shore Drive
D. Widening Entrances to 14 finger streets off Vanderbilt Drive, Hole Montes Work
Order for$5,500.00
E. Mark Weber Term expires 11/13/2017
VII. Old Business
A. Landscape Design Connor Park,Update Harry Sells
Grubbing 42 feet $7,650,plus 62 feet $12,750,plus 62 feet $12,750
B. Landscape design of NW corner of Vanderbilt Drive and Bluebill
VIII. New Business
Possible new projects
A. Street Lights
B. Park Benches
C. Refurbishment of Vanderbilt Drive Landscape.
IX. Public comment
X. Adjourn
NEXT MEETING DATE: SEPT 7,2017
Claussen Family Center at St.John's Church
625 111TH Ave.,Naples,FL
2
Vassder8IOt Beach M.S.7.1I.
Advisory 00001001itf¢a
4114 i
3299 East Tamiarni Trail Suite 103
=�� Naples, FL 34112
MINUTES
APRIL 6,2017
I. CALL TO ORDER: Chairman Forman called the meeting to order at 2:00 P.M.
II. ATTENDANCE
Advisory Committee: Bruce Forman—Chairman
William Sjostrom—Vice Chair
Mark Weber
Gabriella R. Miyamoto
William Arell Harris
Staff: Harry Sells, Project Manager
Others: Dale Slabaugh, Dale A. Slabaugh &Associates
Robert Kindelan, Commercial Land Maintenance
Wendy Warren—Juristaff
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Mr. Sjostrom moved to approve the Agenda of the Vanderbilt Beach M.S.T.U. meeting as
amended.
Move: Item VII. - Old Business to Item VI.
Item VI. - Project Manager Report to Item VII.
Second by Mr. Harris. Carried unanimously 5- 0.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES MARCH 2,2017
Mr. Sjostrom moved to approve the minutes of the March 2, 2017 Vanderbilt Beach M.S.T.U.
meeting as presented. Second by Ms. Miyamoto. Carried unanimously 5- 0.
V. LANDSCAPE REPORT,ROBERT KINDELAN,COMMERCIAL LAND MAINTENANCE
Mr. Kindelan, Commercial Land Maintenance, reported on landscaping as follows:
• Landscaping maintenance is being performed as scheduled.
• Two nonfunctioning irrigation valves by Vanderbilt Drive and Oak Avenue were repaired.
• Plumbago plants were treated for Thrips.
1
VI. OLD BUSINESS
A. LANDSCAPE DESIGN CONNOR PARK,Dale Slabaugh
Grubbing 42 feet$7,650,plus 62 feet$12,750,plus 62 feet$12,750
Mr. Slabaugh distributed a conceptual landscape plan for the area of Connor Park between
Vanderbilt Drive and the beach access area noting:
• The goal is to create a"Gateway"to Vanderbilt Beach and enhance the water view.
• The southwest quadrant will be addressed first and the fence, serving safety and aesthetic
purposes, will extend approximately 180' past the walkway.
• Existing fixtures such as the Florida Power& Light(FPL)boxes and signs will be
integrated into the design.
During Committee discussion the following was noted:
• Mr. Slabaugh will forward photographs of the area to Mr. Sells for distribution to the
Committee.
• The plan will include replacement of the Clusia hedge with an alternate species.
• The location of the bank will be identified and areas of erosion investigated so the plan
may be revised to address any concerns.
• Mr. Sells will determine if the Water District would like to be involved in the project to
provide reuse water for irrigation.
• Potable water Irrigation is available in the area and a determination needs to be made on
the condition of the components and the entity responsible for the system in the area.
• Refurbishment of the Vanderbilt Beach Connor Park/Parks and Recreation monument
sign will be considered.
• A determination will be made on any signs that may be relocated.
• Home owners on Flamingo Avenue impacted by the removal of vegetation and
construction of the fence will provided a copy of the plan.
• Mr. Sells will determine the time line for removal of vegetation and plant material and
the project is intended to be approved prior to the summer MSTU recess.
Members requested Mr. Slabaugh provide a plan and budget estimate for Phase I of the
Vanderbilt Drive beach access area renovation for the May meeting.
VII. PROJECT MANAGER'S REPORT—HARRY SELLS
A. BUDGET REPORT for 4/6/2017
Mr. Sells provided an overview on the "Vanderbilt MSTU Budget Report on Fund 143"FY17
dated April 6, 2017 including distribution of the Adjusted Balance Sheet(Unaudited)FY17
highlighting:
• $1,076,977 of the FY17 property tax revenue budget of$1,192,800 has been collected.
• Current Operating Expense commitments total $645,684 and 2017 YTD expenditures
total $861,849.
• Uncommitted Operating Expense funds available are $1,339,571.87.
• ElectriCom will be submitting an invoice for final payment.
• Adjusted/Unaudited cash balance as of April 6, 2017 is $2,566,016.11.
2
B. BUDGET REPORT for FY18—Millage Rate 0.5 Mills
Mr. Sells recommended the millage rate for FY18 remain at 0.5000 noting it is the policy of
the Board of County Commissioners to establish a revenue neutral budget.
C. GENERAL STATUS OF BURIAL PROJECT
Mr. Sells updated the Committee on construction noting:
Phases II and III
• Comcast
o Overhead to Underground conversion installation is complete.
• Florida Power&Light
o Cable at two corners to be buried.
o Mr. Sells will meet with Florida Power&Light on April 7, 2017 to review the
switching orders and develop a work proposal for activation.
o Upon release of the switching order, MASTEC will mobilize with the timeframe to
convert the old network to the new network being six to seven months.
o Residents will be notified on power outages; anticipated to be minimal.
Phase IV
• The start and completion dates for the Vanderbilt Drive Pathway Project are contingent on
completion of the Collier County Greenway Project.
• Staff has submitted five design proposals to FPL and is waiting for a set of"buildable
plans" for Phase IV to proceed with the project.
• Two bridges associated with the Greenway project are being rebuilt requiring closure of
Vanderbilt Drive to Wiggins Pass Road.
• A bike path will be constructed on the west side of the street.
D. COMMERCIAL LAND CONTRACT EXTENSION TO JANUARY 8,2018
Mr. Sells notified the Committee that Commercial Land Maintenance's contract for grounds
maintenance expires July 8, 2017 and an extension has been requested until January 8, 2018 in
accordance with the Collier County Procurement Ordinance. The contract will go out for bid
in late summer.
Mr. Harris motioned to extend the landscape maintenance contract#13-6072, "Vanderbilt
Beach MSTU Roadway& Grounds Maintenance,"from July 8, 2017 to January 18, 2018.
Second by Ms. Miyamoto. Carried unanimously 5—0.
E. CENTURY LINK NETWORK BY ELECTRICOM—Change Order#1 correction. Addition of
$6000.00.
The Century Link network installation by ElectriCom is complete. The Advisory Committee
previously approved$350,000.00 for the ElectriCom equipment contract. An accounting review
of the Purchase Order issued for$347,012.55 identified an error in addition—the correct contract
amount is $353,012.55, a shortfall of$6,000.00. Change order#1 in the amount of$6,000.00
has been submitted for Committee approval.
Mr. Harris motioned to approve a Contract Modification for Contract#16-6647, Purchase
Order#4500171210,for Electricom, LLC for the Vanderbilt Utility Conversion Project in the
amount of$6,000.00. Second by Mr. Sjostrum. Carried unanimously 5—0.
3
F. HOLE MONTES CHANGE ORDER#6 ADDITIONAL$50,000.00
There are approximately six months of work remaining to activate the new FPL network and
remove the utility poles. Changes to Contract#13-6178 being requested are:
• Increase in"Consultant Detailed Observation" (CEI) services in the amount of
$40,000.00, new total $619,856.00, to cover the cost of services through the end of the
project.
• Increase in"Landscape Architect" services in the amount of$10,000.00, new total
$29,440.00, for investigating the landscape renovations on Vanderbilt Drive.
Mr. Sjostrum motioned to approve a Contract Modification for Contract#13-6178, Purchase
Order#4500152314,for Hole Montes,Inc.for the Vanderbilt Utility Conversion Project in
the amount of$50,000.00. Second by Mr. Harris. Carried unanimously 5—0.
G. MASTEC CO#3 ADDITIONAL$156,810.00
MasTec requests an extension for all contractual work to be completed for the following reasons:
• Delays to the Vanderbilt FPL utility conversion project.
• Collier County Utility Project Upgrades.
o Five conduits and the interior cable have been damaged.
o Cable will be tested and replaced if damaged.
o The utility contractor, Mitchell and Stark Construction, will be billed for the repair.
o Estimated cost for time and materials is $156,810.00
o Hart's Electric may be retained to perform the "drill"work for the conduit repair
versus Hole Montes.
o Change order requires approval by the Board of County Commissioners.
The Committee requested Mr. Sells obtain a letter from the County attorney confirming the utility
contractor, Mitchell and Stark Construction, will reimburse the Vanderbilt Beach M.S.T.U.for
the cost of repairs to damaged conduits and cable.
Mr. Harris motioned to approve a Contract Modification for Contract#15-6437,Purchase
Order#4500163308,for MasTec North America,Inc.for the Vanderbilt Utility Conversion
Project in the amount of$156,810.00. Second by Mr. Sjostrum. Carried unanimously 5—0.
Mr. Harris motioned to approve Hart's Electrical Inc.proposal dated April 6, 2017 for
Vanderbilt Utility Conversion Project repairs in the amount of$28,992.20. Second by Ms.
Miyamoto. Carried unanimously 5—0.
H. FIREBUSH HEDGE 495 PINE AND VANDERBILT DR.
Mr.Sells distributed a photograph of a homeowner's hedge and proposed the Advisory Committee
institute a hedge policy as follows:
• The M.S.T.U. will maintain hedges up to six feet originally planted by homeowners
before the MSTU was formed. The maintenance will apply to landscaping within the
County Right of Way.
• Single Family homeowners will be allowed to grow hedges up to ten feet in height
maintained at their expense to the standards of the "Operating Procedures Vanderbilt
Drive MSTU Landscape Maintenance on Vanderbilt Drive."
• An"Invitation to Bid"defining treatment of hedges will be issued.
4
During Committee discussion the following was noted:
• Mr. Sells will distribute a letter to twenty-eight single family homeowners notifying
them of the MSTU's hedge maintenance policy.
• The letter will include photographic examples of acceptable and unacceptable hedges.
• Residents will be advised the Advisory Committee is considering a landscape renovation
project for Vanderbilt Drive and the policy does not guarantee the hedges will be
permitted long term.
• A draft of the letter will be emailed to the Committee for review prior to distribution to
residents.
I. SIDEWALKS EAST AND WEST SIDE OF GULF SHORE DRIVE
Mr. Sells met with the Road and Bridge Department to discuss construction of a sidewalk on Gulf
Shore Drive resulting in the following:
• Road and Bridge wants to pave Gulf Shore Drive and install curbs.
• Road and Bridge would like to partner with the MSTU and the developer of a high rise
property to re-do the road and install curbing and sidewalks.
• A Request for Quote(RFQ)is prepared to go out for the sidewalk project;however Road
and Bridge has requested the MSTU delay distribution of the RFQ for thirty days pending a
resolution to their proposed project which would include a partnership of three entities
(Road and Bridge,the developer and the MSTU).
J. WIDENING ENTRANCES TO 14 FINGER STREETS OFF VANDERBILT DRIVE
HOLE MONTES WORK ORDER FOR$5,500.00
The Committee approved the funding for design at the March 2017 meeting. The Scope of Work Order
will be released and the design, if acceptable to Staff,will be presented to the Committee at the May
2017 meeting.
K. MEETING WITH PARKS AND RECREATION
Connor Park NW corner of Vanderbilt and Bluebill,Refurbishment Parking Islands
Mr. Sells is awaiting feedback on Mr. Slabaugh's conceptual landscape design presented to
Parks and Recreation.
VIII. NEW BUSINESS
Possible New Projects
Mr. Sells introduced concepts for future improvements to the Vanderbilt Beach MSTU for
Committee consideration including:
A. Connor Park refurbishment,partial to complete.
• Park refurbishment was addressed under Item VI A during Dale A. Slabaugh &
Associates presentation.
B. Street Lights
• The Committee discussed the need for street lights on Vanderbilt Drive to illuminate
the finger street signs.
C. Park Benches
• Benches will be considered for installation on completion of the County's utility
project.
D. Refurbishment of Vanderbilt Drive Landscape
• This project will be considered at a future date.
5
E. Landscape NW Corner Vanderbilt Drive,Bluebill
• Pavers could be an independent undertaking or incorporated into the Finger Street
improvement project.
IX. MEMBER COMMENT
Summer Meeting Schedule
The Committee agreed meetings will not be held in June, July and August 2017.
X. PUBLIC COMMENT
Collier County Utility
Members of the public expressed their concern with the project noting:
• Residents requested better communication and a schedule for project completion.
• Heron Avenue is not navigable and should not be the "staging"area for the project.
• The soil is emanating an odor.
• Dirt presence is overwhelming.
Finger Street Entrance Widening
• Residents expressed support for widening of the streets including enhancements such as
paver crosswalks and street sign illumination.
• Dead end street signs should identified as "no outlet" or similar verbiage.
Conduit Damage
• Staff noted the MSTU will be reimbursed for damage cause by the utility project
contractor.
Meeting Agenda
• Staff noted the Agendas are published on the County web site prior to the meeting date.
Underground Infra Structure
• The underground infrastructure allows roads to be paved.
• Cables and switches in the vaults are waterproof; vaults not necessarily.
• The MSTU will maintain the vaults short term; FPL will maintain the vaults on turnover.
Traffic Lanes and Signage
• A bicycle lane is not incorporated on Vanderbilt Drive by the finger streets.
• Illumination standards for new street signs will be researched.
• Staff will review replacement of orange traffic signs.
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by
order of the Chair at 4:10 P.M.
VANDERBILT BEACH MSTU ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Bruce Forman, Chairman
The minutes approved by the Board/Committee on , 2017
"as submitted" [ ] OR "as amended" [ ].
6
NEXT MEETING DATE: MAY 4,2017 2:00 P.M.
"CLAUSSEN FAMILY CENTER"AT ST.JOHN'S CHURCH
625 111TH AVENUE,NAPLES,FLORIDA
7
VANDERBILT MSTU
FUND 143
May 4,2017
Vendor hem PO# Budget Commitments Expenditures Total
1 CUR AD VALOREM TAX $ (1,192,800.00) $ - $ (1,114,901.32) $ (77,898.68)
2 DEL AD VALOREM $ - $ - $ - $ -
3 OVERNIGHT INTEREST $ - $ - $ (1,984.88) $ 1,984.88
4 INVESTMENT INTEREST $ (2,000.00) $ - $ (10,259.96) $ 8,259.96
5 INTEREST TAX COLLECTOR $ - $ - $ (70.70) $ 70.70
6 REVENUE STRUCTURE $ (1,194,800.00) $ - $ (1,127,216.86) $ (67,583.14)
7 TRANSFERS FROM PROP APP $ - $ - $ - $ -
8 TRANSFERS FROM TAX COLL $ - $ - $ - $ -
9 CARRY FORWARD GEN $ (960,500.00) $ - $ - $ (960,500.00)
10 CARRY FOR OF ENCUMB AMT $ (882,004.94) $ - $ - $ (882,004.94)
11 NEG 5%EST REV $ 59,800.00 $ - $ - $ 59,800.00
12 TRANSFERS 8,CONTRIB $ (1,782,704.94) $ - $ - $ (1,782,704.94)
13 TOTAL REVENUE $ (2,977,504.94) $ - $ (1,127,216.86) $ (1,850,288.08)
14 ENGINEERING FEES DESIGN Hole,Montes&Assoc. Preliminary Design-finger streets TBD $ - $ 5,500.00 $ - $ (5,500.00)
15 SURVEYING FEES RWA,Inc Surveying 4500166989 $ 18,112.00 $ 10,112.00 $ - $ 8,000.00
16 INDIRECT COST Collier County Indirect Cost Direct Pay $ 26,100.00 $ 26,100.00 $ -
Florida Land Maintenance 4500171726 $ 5,565.38 $ 5,534.62
Signature Tree Care 4500175060 $ 3,375.00 $ -
17 LANDSCAPE INCIDENTALS $ 100,000.00 $ 8,940.38 $ 5,534.62 $ 85,525.00
Florida Land Maintenance Ground Maint 4500171726 $ 47,706.00 $ 21,294.00
Electricom,LLC Utility Conversion 4500171210 $ 40,766.49 $ 312,246.06
Hole Montes CEI Utility Conversion 4500152314 $ 179,760.20 $ 91,376.95
Mastec North America,Inc. FPL Util.Aerial to Underground Cony 4500163308 $ 553,005.72 $ 116,100.18
Harts Electric Install new power 4500166205 $ 6,971.47 $ 8,948.53
Cable Wiring Specialist Comcast Underground 4500165508 $ - $ 270,970.05
Locate Holdings Inc. Locate services for buried utilities 4500175418 $ 3,000.00 $ -
18 OTHER CONTRACTUAL $ 2,647,992.94 $ 831,209.88 $ 820,935.77 $ 995,847.29
19 ELECTRICITY FPL Electricity 4700002986 $ 200.00 $ 33.63 $ 66.37 $ 100.00
20 WATER AND SEWER Collier County Util. Water&Sewer 4700002980 $ 30,000.00 $ 6,715.79 $ 23,284.21 $ -
21 RENT LAND Vanderbilt Real Estate Holdings Parking Lease 4700002870 $ 2,500.00 $ 2,400.00 $ 4,800.00 $ (4,700.00)
22 RENT EQUIPMENT J.M.Todd Copier Lease(shared) 4500171793 $ 300.00 $ - $ 133.06 $ 166.94
23 INSURANCE GENERAL Collier County Insurance General Direct Pay $ 600.00 $ 150.00 $ 450.00 $ -
Florida Irrigation Supply Irrigation Parts 4500164397 $ 6,299.27 $ 1,200.73
Florida Irrigation Supply Irrigation Parts 4500171647 $ - $ (16.31)
24 SPRINKLER SYSTEM MAIN $ 10,000.00 $ 6,29927 $ 1,184.42 $ 2,516.31
25 MULCH Forestry Resource Mulch 4500171658 $ 4,000.00 $ 4,412.64 $ 27.84 $ (440.48)
26 LICENCES AND PERMITS Collier County Permits Direct Pay $ 2,000.00 $ - $ 2,000.00 $ -
27 CLERKS RECORDING FEES Clerk of Courts Recording Fees Direct Pay $ 300.00 $ - $ - $ 300.00
28 LEGAL ADVERTISEMENTS $ 400.00 $ 400.00
29 OTHER MISCELLANEOUS Juristaff,Inc Transcriptionist Serv. 4500171659 $ 2,000.00 $ 633.18 $ 1,166.82 $ 200.00
30 OFFICE SUPPLIES Staples Advantage Office Supplies 4500171792 $ 300.00 $ 172.38 $ 27.62 $ 100.00
31 COPYING CHARGES JM Todd Monthly CPC(shared) 4500171800 $ 300.00 $ 132.90 $ 167.10 $ -
32 FERT HERB CHEM $ 1,800.00 $ 3,307.50 $ - $ (1,507.50)
Matulay's Cont Green Fence Cloth&Cable Ties Visa $ - $ 409.15
The Flag Store Display Flag Pole for Public Mtgs Visa $ - $ 36.55
33 OTHER OPER SUPPLIES $ - $ - $ 445.70 $ (445.70)
34 OTHER TRAINING $ 200.00 $ - $ - $ 200.00
35 OPERATING EXPENSE $ 2,847,104.94 $ 880,019.55 $ 886,323.53 $ 1,080,761.86
36 TRANS TO 111 UNINCOR $ 91,500.00 $ - $ 91,500.00 $ -
37 Budget Trans from Appraiser $ 9,500.00 $ - $ 6,917.94 $ 2,582.06
38 Budget Trans from Tax Collector $ 29,400.00 $ - $ 22,548.02 $ 6,851.98
39 TRANSFERS $ 130,400.00 $ - $ 120,965.96 $ 9,434.04
40 TOTAL BUDGET $ 2,977,504.94 $ 880,019.55 $ 1,007,289.49 $ 1,090,195.90
2588,487,415 FY 10 Final Taxable Value
2,005,897,752 FY 11 Final Taxable Value Total Available Balance $ 1,090,195.90
1.910,384,837 FY 12 Final Taxable Value Plus Commited And Not Spent $ 880,019.55
1,904,053,751 FY 13 July 1 Taxable Value
1.945.640.839 FY 14 July 1 Taxable Value
2,044,186,286 FY 15 July 1 Taxable Value I Estimated Cash $ 1,970,215.45
2,195,715,846 FY16 July 1 Taxable Value
2,386.591189 FY 17 July 1 Taxable Value
Estimated Cash Less
8.65% Adj.1610 17 Uncollected Ad Valorem Taxes $ 1,892,316.77
FY17 FY18
Millage 0.5000 0.5000 Mlllage Cap=.5000 I Actual Cash
Extension 1,192,788 1,097,858
Property Tax Limitation Impact
FY 17 Gross Taxable Value 2,385,592,169
Minus.New Const.Annex. 5,449,987
Plus:Amendment#1 TV Component 0
Adj.Taxable Value 2,380,142,182
Prior year FY16 Levy(Proceeds) 1,097,858 1,022,093 DR 422 Levy
Rolled Back Rate (lees Amend.One) 0.4613
91%of Rolled Back Rate 0.4197
From:CasalanguidaNick<NickCasalanguida@colliergov.net>
Date:April 24, 2017 at 5:10:50 PM EDT
To:CarnellSteve<SteveCarnell@colliergov.net>,YilmazGeorge<GeorgeYilmaz@colliergov.net>
Cc: GoodnerAngela<AngelaGoodner@colliergov.net>, OchsLeo<LeoOchs@colliergov.net>,
WilligGeoffrey<GeoffrevWillig@colliergov.net>
Subject:Vanderbilt Projects
Team,
We have briefed Commissioner Solis on the current status of the Vanderbilt projects and our tentative
plans.
Please begin to move forward on option 4 where we continue with the water/sewer/drainage work
while readjusting the MSTU electrical schedule to follow immediately behind.This will be done with the
understanding that the increased costs to the MSTU will be absorbed by the utility because it is the least
cost path for both parties.The first explanation of this concept will be presented this Thursday to the
MSTU. Please provide his office a copy of the agenda and a bullet point explanation of the approach
being presented with the estimated schedule update.
Recognizing that we will have an evening community meeting in May, please prepare an outreach plan
using variable message boards and potentially mailings or door notices to make sure we reach out to as
many people as possible. Also, please contact Angela in his office so she can notice through their
contacts.At this meeting, he would like a detailed schedule presented that includes estimated
completions dates by phase and a paving schedule.This should also include an update to the MSTU
project.
Going forward, he suggested a mechanism to send regular updates about the project through
community notices and/or quarterly meetings. These items will be included to the upcoming taskers
after you have a chance to review and finalize the plan.
Thank you,
Nick Casalanguida
Collier County, Deputy Manager
NickCasalanguida@Colliergov.net
239-252-8383
�rc�l�;r�rew4y
ITEM NO.: DATE RECEIVED:
FILE NO.:
ROUTED TO:
DO NOT WRITE ABOVE THIS SPACE(Orig.9/89;Rev.6/97)
REQUEST FOR LEGAL SERVICES
(Please type or print)
Date: 4/7/2017 To: Office of the County Attorney,Attn: Scott Teach
From: Harry E. Sells Project Manager
(Name) (Title)
Public Services PTNE
(Division) (Department)
Telephone#(Very Important): 239-252-4980 Cell 239-821-6909
Re: Request for opinion on responsibility of excavation contractor to pay for damages
done to other buried utilities while burying sewer and water lines for Collier county.
(Subject)
BACKGROUND OF REQUEST/PROBLEM:
(Describe problem and give background information-be specific,concise,and articulate.)
CC Utilities has contracted Mitchel and Stark to replace water,sewer,and storm sewer lines in Vanderbilt Beach. The
construction is being done in the same area that the VB MSTU has buried FPL power lines that will be activated some
time this year. Mitchel amd Stan has not been potholing, are not properly utilizing locations services, are digging
without location marks and are reporting damage after the fact and covering the damage before it can be reviewed by the
owner(MSTU project manager).
(Are there documents or other information needed to review this matter? If yes,attach and reference this information.)
This item has/has not been previously submitted.
(If previously submitted provide County Attorney's Office File No.)NO
ACTION REQUESTED:
(Be very specific. Identify exactly what you need in the way of legal services.)
The Vanderbilt Beach Advisory Board have requested a statement from the CAO adising
that generally when damage is done under the conditions listed above, the contractor is
libel for the cost of repair. Scott Teach provided an opinion on this in a meeting with
Purchasing approximately one month ago.
OTHER COMMENTS:
cc: Michelle Arnold, Steve Carnell
(iLrequests must be copied to your appropriate Division Head or Constitutional Officer.)
C Qj
V u) Y N N O V1
c co q) a CoN
E c L'i 2 a) " a) 2 a, c o y v 2
io 0 E TLA E TLA 7 E a E T LA
0 E -p E -0 +' 0 .0 a+ 0 Y N a) O 0 d y
7 T a)vl 0 .G a) L a) a.) -a L aN`) -0 LN :2 5 a) 0 v a) L
C U a j O u u O. 7 O O. 7 O C d a) N
c .0 0 a) ca n E 7 W co a n m 2 a7S L w >
0
o o ° v E o01 ° 0 0 9 v c o o
c o c v o o c oa c c a o ._ c C
£ c E o c s a o c o c u o co a) O c
on v o o ,, o o o0
E $ .v O L m Ou a a O t 0a L O w 'o L
O a) -c -c a) - v 'O L ). .0 c 0) iTs
y o c o E c '0 -D C o E c o E c " y -0 o E c
C c •o v m c - 1O -0 a) -0 a) " c a) - v a)
o c a C .0 0 c V 0. C .0 a C C a) a) O C C L
p a! o a 3 p a) ax O a, 3 O co a CO .0 u o )o 3
0 0 0
`
O o v O 0
N F o
a) N . a) V Cra 2
HOo t C OC0 C C N apc
0N E C EY CU U H m
a) 4.• C U
A cu � CU , a+ ?
O c 0 ,;_< ..a. ' Ow .?-
1)
T
yc � =
aOv8 = ra a, w0 V G
1-3 4 Y , = ) 7 O Y (O
a, O 00 - O0 0 _ i
o Ci) -a T C ) V T 0 N to C v 'O
ca c;.., V CC -0
O oi V >' LC 9
U
O1
c f0 a) 7) p •O fo a) N
H To :c ' "O
Tc 0)
7 C y YC . Y O cCt
.2C N G 8 c E NO6 CcO i'='. Co C CCa 0 o o voa o 0
2 O a a) z O a
a) 2 .J o_ < 0 O a w
T >
j T
._ Ia
0 =as T 7•o arD aL7 7 a) F- F- 'O ,n T
a) - 'O -O to a+
Wil .47'
M v E a) 3
c .a c c c c Y N o 3
0 0
C13 0 N ^�a ED Y N O Q oa
Y a) a/ T a .fl .7 - N 7
Q RI .- Cl.; a) C C E N C a .j 'C 'O
> Tc,C O O U O > > o a, = ' m
Vm-. O '3
J w w 0 Y O N
o 3 Y 3 ` 3 LL o •Ev v
0 =a o 0 0 0 0 0 o m
2 c ¢ 3 ¢ 3 Q 0 2 2 ¢ o 2 c v
0
1-
0o w
o
cn
aN o N o O o
y N
C a) >. > N
E c ,n 2 2 2
•� W
itl
t• o
i+ * 01 0) o
m O)
0 N c-1 cy o N m
O
o ra ra O ON a., ON N
7.: T 7
U E
E ,= a p u
7 Q u
Q c
N O
W V
a)
N 7. O
> > a O
• - 4
a •7 j G) u
a
a) 3 u u o c
w O v Q m
o > _c m Y E to
a c a aa o O
y o a` E 3 _
> o o v a `u a;
C 7 _ to - 2 U '� -O -0
O Y ,o M Ql L C 0 >
v ra 0
i p2
N ~O -O Ni O a
a r. 3 E o y amu n 'mi v '47'
.0 D O T C a) O c
a) ,~i, -0 a v 0 cv - m ) -0 aa)
v
N Cl.; aJ w T 0. '0 8 N 3 w
v a) - CL a0 O u y
.; > > 7 T a) C C
4J a) p - ca c T T a)
O O W +' as O
c as -
W > a) > C a) c Oa a! � U y
c Y V Y N a) . -pcu a)
Tv-- > > Y > "a E. Ei73 ,'''c'
a
N E V, a{ E 0 3
0 a
a) ¢ Q 3 ¢ o uo 2 c `o a
N a)
c v v E
.2 � ,,
0 .-I N m V 7
a
0 c Q
-ill
f+-?!�: ';
* �h !f ! 4i?5e t 41J
t�• 47,6„rt`r. 4, "" .' '.A•' 'ate L} i
,, , 1 . -:- , At va Ai! : . k = I- - i-: t..... .,0, _,..; „/ ...:,----7- i. Iwli
44,1
■ N' I r ' fix rr :II,.
.. '. M 9 Y iod,.' 3, 1 c
1 1—• 4 ',. tt. i * It C f . 1.,.,' , f..... f.'1 11111X4,4 id& •=0 ,,tS.1/0" g.•
''' *.,6.4'.1.66r. : ;:.. 4 I . . 4 •- t* .4. r„, i.i.o. f !,-10 it,,,.,r,....2...„.„4 „__„,„.,,..#
0
r��
N .
trot �:
o li
R'
f
s
t fi
t . r" r; Oh 4
a
441h ‘it IF
y'etht T4:11 W 4
Vii' ;, . ■,,A' 4+ 0
d
2
+� q g_ ,,,,fir �* 411
J� lt. � S , t +s7 M1„{ it,et sem ... g'. , i �y ' Rj •'
ga
r .' + t #°' 9 �. - r?. r!�' > }+ s151, 'c.,,y ...fi t- i :�s4� °' e"
��(, 16a5. tt 1 � � �� �!,' si ^�< � .,� �,• burr a��� 7. �'
�` (._ ;1 .,•et{1114,4101 .. sl T E- ,r'="4', aR ,
•�, -' lor • i .` 1, s e 7 { f s=x - [¢
.� . ril ,#; x 3 "firf'#ih,a L asoq�
:;, ,,,,,
�". ��. Hr 1114.
r it � (y�� �" r#.:` 1,
e ! 1 ! w e, e X fit(' .4 !
"� ^M- `ar 4 � ms's
.. tr v . -;.'t-A4*'t
F' F '�$s � V � " , S:+ oj of i
! ;Sif.k •i ..' 16116 %
x
ll
•
,,.r
by@:)a
r f z
c c °
••.1N4u p 2 y °
O` j C O a
N o v E
04u
v3
.. � rr
c n x Y N
E
g oQZ Y v s E
E 3 ° a
y 3 mo mo N 2' 8 lk
2"4:.' c - > v o ( '
= t i3 2 ° m °. 3
0 0
3 a c .` c .ami 3 E
C
liw U u u ..
s
V '- c i s o a > >
I
s Y N > E w u
4Z w 3 w 3 ri
a v
- :"4";-. ' rl. . ,,, '7.f.,i`- .:',A 1 • - pr-,717! mevk;
t y�pL "pa
H
V1 > it - - {*vim- '
- , . - ••,,..li ,
51t 1 11 ;r?r #4,:- .,.
44!
o
'r
e ', ;-**,',:::,,!t•.'
1-�
2 ,
JV _ wy 1 3
J
z
---46,‘_
r
. '
Z a5 _
O �-
W ___ .i... �.c. .. ';v' .. ..tit �,�,
w i n $
c
Z d v u o, o v o
d
2o $ o ¢' 9 i s
W y oVC m
W 2 0 c o Iii 0 o q m
P ° .y _ a c o'o
0 3 3 N Nau`�
w u
m m a
oo to
g +
,5',
O
'O ° t
N
Oy
c aCN ° d WN Cc > > _ > >c o .. a am 5. _oa ° co9 c ° a a
yt.' x xc -. m v >
o 0 t` N
w o 0 0 0
N N ry
0 u W co .
N
+ ry m O
tiN
c
`°, L o
na
•
m' ac3aa z a Lmm a T u° a ve> a Ya-' v o" o N0o m CO `1 QO 3 -o N J V, W0yL a a a a «•i, m a C O aay t+ 73 1.N "2 ,,_ NC ' E « 1111" :171' g a `o a« 5 avo « o0c3 jm t p V + IAA
; m31
L 9 o . av aO 1 'J'.c «cz cF — roonm E « vco « Y o' w r o Ec v \ u.Gy OL S O « O "O C a Uc ; .-8
Q OOEa « Cw a o a V a o 3 ;
Z. 2 12-• Nk
wa ta V « v anvVaa co o ° m c o a - c co 4 0v 3 « L L _ y, cA 9 9 N
14,
i 41
c o . E ? ,o c $ v c o r, Y g q E E = lh E '^ 4; t-',,
'C n
8 3 g v m 2 v A r` v 3 v .moo °u I c N v
�Ntlw'4,,;
,
� ti ay? Y1+`a -"a t
V1
"tip t
# ' .. Jr;;A `ems.J: ,.'.
TT dY 1
C�j� P l
it
"kill",
4-�� �; L \ tti;:,
�R . . ,k Z b ,,, I .. .. �+ . ri.
N 'Vr,
y4.- 4 «, J
1.' m
2 2 m C N mLLx
aTa>• -O = .a a OO ," w6 M N C Nw _ 3v
.67
a " w v o$
a m a
ro
N b
O+1
a vaJ aa aJa a aC 0ma mm m
c
E E
IT.
iLf
P. n
0 0 0 0
N
O
N
N N M M
N p n W
`o
a
d
m
a
d
r., c o Ld � o
0 L 9 c F , N
-5E. _ Y -2 W t N
0..„20..„23 a v \.
«
d d -,,r,,, d
1 o a ''' r,1 o
q x a H c m 0
=2.z _ ck E t m a L ? c x 2 c
m m v V- y y d N 4 L°n
.t28 a N `o m ' ,S .3.'-
E o o °1 Lii m v 3 a' -,1 4 0
% u
9 c E o,,E n` 0s o
01 » v 3 my u E ; 'S�(\ov
E E d ° ° E i=m n« a a v
t
-.-
u° c o 3 u 5 v p
`,
L x1
7,{
't ir
JAe
ti' ,vr r-
r
�--`ram+ } ". �J i
i it _71 f r d ;° , .-rp
:, r
d `o
c ti
c j
d
w s ai
a s o
o � c
a .2 a
f,
10
.2_, O
a
8
W d
N d
d
J
C
>r
a a
L •3
1 O c
C . j
d
a0
C_ I.
E N
a
rna
n
N
O
0N O
MN
01
I 114.
e
a
..
s
,:;ii.
11
,-,i ,,,,,' ,,,, = - ' - 4,
' -,
.'
._ ..... . , . _
t ....„,.,,.... ....„... , , ,., .
, __. , .
,, . -.:7,.:17 ,::,,..",.,,. , ,L, ,'_=,.,,,,•_,,,, „.--.,i. i
vy�, I l
_ ,:,,_.,.,,...r•.•-c ,...„,er,_, r .: N
R
p ,
y
Wil.
Aa
I III
0 S.. '. ' 4abe, .... si
I R tilia'' ... ..
....
. .. , ,
L.
■
k
t s
,--,' -
0 ,
,
•
. ,
,..
_
:
. ‘
11111"1"
II
i
-
.
I
rimmli
- - IF
L
ii- i . ,
api: