CESM Backup 04/07/2017 CODE ENFORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE MEETING
BACKUP
DOCUMENTS
APRIL 7, 2016
HEARING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY SPECIAL MAGISTRATE
AGENDA
DATE: April 7,2017 at 9:00 A.M.
LOCATION: Collier County Government Center,3299 East Tamiami Trail,Building F,3rd Floor,Naples,Florida 34112
NOTE: ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WILL NEED A
RECORD OF THE PROCEEDINGS PERTAINING THERETO, AND THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A
VERBATIM RECORD OF TIIE PROCEEDINGS IS MADE,WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE
UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE BASED. NEITHER COLLIER COUNTY NOR THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE SHALL
BE RESPONSIBLE FOR PROVIDING THIS RECORD.
1. CALL TO ORDER—Special Magistrate Brenda Garretson presiding
A. Hearing rules and regulations
IL APPROVAL OF AGENDA
HI. APPROVAL OF MINUTES—March 3,2017
IV. MOTIONS
A. Motions for Continuance
B. Motions for Extension of Time
V. STIPULATIONS
VI. PUBLIC HEARINGS
A. Hearings
1. CASE NO: S0183103-CEEX20170003163
OWNER: ELIZABETH TREVINO
OFFICER: DEPUTY ALLEN
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAW&ORD.,SEC. 130-66(1)(H)
FIRE LANE
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: HOME DEPOT, 1651 AIRPORT RD,NAPLES
2. CASE NO: PR057433-CEEX20170004312
OWNER: RAY MCGARRY
OFFICER: PARK RANGER P.JONES
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAW&ORD.,SEC. 130-55
FAILED TO PAY PARKING FEE OR DISPLAY VALID PARKING PERMIT
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: VANDERBILT BEACH GARAGE,LEVEL 3,NAPLES
3. CASE NO: PR057776-CEEX20170004473
OWNER: MERRILEE VANKAMPEN
OFFICER: PARK RANGER W.MUILENBURG
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAW&ORD.,SEC. 130-55
EXPIRED BEACH PERMIT;BEACH AND LOT CLOSE AT SUNSET
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: BAREFOOT BEACH ACCESS,NAPLES
4. CASE NO: PU5144-CEEX20170004964
OWNER: TAYLOR MORRISON ESPLANADE NAPLES LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JOSE QUINTERO
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAWS&ORDINANCES 134-174 SECTION(N)
WATER HOSE CONNECTED TO THE BACK LEG OF THE BACKFLOW DEVICE
CROSSING SORRENO CT.
FOLIO NO: 31347557162
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 9066 SORRENO CT,NAPLES
5. CASE NO: PU5145-CEEX20170004967
OWNER: TAYLOR MORRISON ESPLANADE NAPLES LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JOSE QUINTERO
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAWS&ORDINANCES 134-174 SECTION(BXI)
WATER HOSE CONNECTED TO THE LEG OF BACKFLOW DEVICE CROSSING
SORRENO CT.CONTRACTOR CARRYING HOSE TO REAR PROPERTY OF 9067
SORRENO CT.
FOLIO NO: 31347557162
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 9066 SORRENO CT,NAPLES
6. CASE NO: PU5299-CEEX20170003150
OWNER: SHREE SIDDHIVINAYAK HOSPITALITY LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR ROBIN GOLDSBORO
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAWS&ORDINANCES 134-174 SECTION(N)
ILLEGAL CONNECTION TO THE SERVICE PORT ON TWO INCH RPZ.NO PERSON
SHALL CONNECT INTO ANY WATER OR SEWER LINE OWNED BY THE COUNTY
WITHOUT WRITTEN CONSENT.
FOLIO NO: 76885050157 •
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3837 TOLLGATE BLVD,NAPLES
2
7. CASE NO: PU5301-CEEX20170003151
OWNER: SHREE SIDDHIVINAYAK HOSPITALITY LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR ROBIN GOLDSBORO
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAWS&ORDINANCES 134-174 SECTION(9)
3/4 INCH BYPASS WAS REMOVED AND CONNECTION WAS ESTABLISHED BEFORE
THE METER TO THIS DEVICE.
FOLIO NO: 76885050157
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3837 TOLLGATE BLVD.NAPLES
8. CASE NO: PU5302-CEEX20170003153
OWNER: SHREE SIDDHIVINAYAK HOSPITALITY LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR ROBIN GOLDSBORO
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAWS&ORDINANCES 134-126 SECTION(A)(6)
FIRE BACKFLOW DEVICE,3/4 AND 4 INCH DEVICES ALTERED AND REMOVED TO
ESTABLISH WATER CONNECTION TO PRIVATELY OWNED FIRE BACKFLOW
DEVICES.
FOLIO NO: 76885050157
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3837 TOLLGATE BLVD,NAPLES
9. CASE NO: PU5142-CEEX20170003149
OWNER: CITY GATE SELF STORAGE LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JOSE QUINTERO
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAWS&ORDINANCES 134-174 SECTION(Q)
WATER HOSE CONNECTED TO COUNTY SIDE OF FIRE BACKFLOW DEVICE,
UNMETERED.NO FREE SERVICE.
FOLIO NO: 26095000264
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3807 WHITE LAKE BLVD,NAPLES
10. CASE NO: PU5325-CEEX20170003154
OWNER: CITY GATE SELF STORAGE LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JOSE QUINTERO
VIOLATIONS: CODE OF LAWS&ORDINANCES 134-126 SECTION(A)(6)
WATER HOSE CONNECTED TO COUNTY SIDE OF FIRE BACKFLOW DEVICE,NO
PROTECTION TO THE COUNTY WATER SYSTEM.
FOLIO NO: 26095000264
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 3807 WHITE LAKE BLVD,NAPLES
11. CASE NO: DAS21931-CEEX20170003964
OWNER: PABLO RAMIREZ
OFFICER: TAD BARTAREAU
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 14,ARTICLE II,
SECTION 14-34(IXB).DOG RUNNING AT LARGE.
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 600 VALLEY STREAM DRIVE,NAPLES
3
12. CASE NO: CEPM20150013681
OWNER: RICARDO DEJESUS AND KATHLEAN DEJESUS
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR STEVE ATHEY
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 22,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 22-228(1),SECTION 22-231(12)(I),AND SECTION 22-231(12XC). BROKEN
WINDOWS,ROOF IN DISREPAIR.
FOLIO NO: 1132520004
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 222 SWAIN STREET,NAPLES
13. CASE NO: CELU20170001152
OWNER: HERITAGE SQUARE REAL ESTATE LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JON HOAGBOON
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE 0441,AS AMENDED,SECTION
4.05.02(G)(L)(M).UNAUTHORIZED"STACKED"PARKING CONFIGURATION IN THE
DRIVE AISLES.
FOLIO NO: 152480002
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 13500 TAMIAMI TRAIL NORTH,NAPLES
14. CASE NO: CENA20160016736
OWNER: ALYCE ANN MATHIAS
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR PATRICK BALDWIN
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 54,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 54-185(A).WEEDS IN EXCESS OF 18 INCHES.
FOLIO NO: 56320001607
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 270 MADISON DRIVE,NAPLES
15. CASE NO: CELU20160019784
OWNER: MENDOZA BROS 5 LLC
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JONATHAN MUSSE
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 54,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 54-179,AND THE COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE 04-41,AS
AMENDED,SECTION 1.04.01(A)AND 2.02.03.ILLEGAL OUTSIDE STORAGE
CONSISTING OF BUT NOT LIMITED TO PILES OF DIRT,GRAVEL,PAVERS,
ALUMINUM,PIPES,ETC.
FOLIO NO: 00728400005
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 271 PRICE STREET,NAPLES
16. CASE NO: CEROW20160008193
OWNER: YASNIEL GONZALEZ ET AL
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR CRISTINA PEREZ
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 110,ARTICLE II,
DIVISION 1 GENERALLY,SECTION 110-31(A).DAMAGE TO GRASS AND USE OF THE
RIGHT OF WAY FOR VEHICLE ENTRY TO AND EXIT FROM THE PROPERTY
WITHOUT OBTAINING APPLICABLE COLLIER COUNTY RIGHT OF WAY PERMITS.
FOLIO NO: 36446880007
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 2801 TROPICANA BLVD,NAPLES
4
1
17. CASE NO: CESD20160017609
OWNER: MEDELSONNE GARRAUX AND ROSE G.GARRAUX GEROME
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR VICKI GIGUERE
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE 04-41,AS AMENDED,SECTION
10.02.06(B)(1)(A)AND SECTION 10.02.06(B)(1)(EXI).SHED ON THE PROPERTY
WITHOUT FIRST OBTAINING COLLIER COUNTY BUILDING PERMITS.
FOLIO NO: 77390004008
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 13463 COVENANT ROAD,NAPLES
18. CASE NO: CEROW20150020992
OWNER: MIGUEL GARCIA
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR TONY ASARO
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 110,ARTICLE II,
SECTION 110-31(A). DRIVEWAY INSTALLED WITHOUT OBTAINING A COLLIER
COUNTY RIGHT OF WAY PERMIT.
FOLIO NO: 37224880008
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 841 4TH STREET SE,NAPLES
19. CASE NO: CEEX20170002592
OWNER: JENNIFER DIPASCALE
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR DANIEL GROSS!
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 14,ARTICLE II,
SECTION 14-36.DANGEROUS DOG.
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 9047 THE LANE,NAPLES
B. Emergency Cases:
VII. NEW BUSINESS
A. Motions for Reduction/Abatement of Fines:
B. Motions for Imposition of Fines and Lien:
I. CASE NO: CEPM20160013889
OWNER: JP MORGAN MRTG TRUST
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR STEVE ATHEY
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 22,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 22-231(11),22-23 I(12)(C)(B),22-231(19). ROOF/SOFFIT IN DISREPAIR.
EXTERIOR SIDING OF STRUCTURE IN DISREPAIR.MOLD ON EXTERIOR SURFACE OF
STRUCTURE.NO ELECTRICITY IN DWELLING.
FOLIO NO: 36764920005
V IOLATION
ADDRESS: 3480 5 r"AVENUE SW,NAPLES
5
2. CASE NO: CEPM20160010488
OWNER: RONALD ABEL
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JOHN CONNETTA f
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 22,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 22-231(5),SECTION 22-231(11),SECTION 22-231(12XC),SECTION 22-
231(1.2)(N),SECTION 22-231(13),AND SECTION 22-231(15). POOL WATER IS GREEN IN
COLOR,SCREENS ON POOL CAGE ARE TORN/RIPPED,EXPOSED ELECTRICAL
WIRES,ROOF SOFFIT DAMAGE,KITCHEN APPLIANCES THAT DO NOT WORK AND
THERE ARE APPROXIMATELY NINE UNRELATED ADULTS LIVING IN THIS SINGLE
FAMILY HOME.
FOLIO NO: 35780080001
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 2172 41ST TERRACE SW,NAPLES
3. CASE NO: CEPM20160008116
OWNER: ALBERT HOUSTON SR.
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR JOE MUCHA
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 22,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 22-236. THE COLLIER COUNTY BUILDING OFFICIAL HAS FOUND THAT
THE MAIN STRUCTURE AND THE TWO ACCESSORY BUILDINGS ARE DANGEROUS
AND UNSUITABLE FOR THE SAFE OCCUPANCY OF ITS INTENDED PURPOSE.
IMMEDIATE REPAIRS,UP TO AND INCLUDING DEMOLITION OF THE STRUCTURES,
ARE REQUIRED.
FOLIO NO: 25631200005
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 216 S 4TH STREET,IMMOKALEE
4. CASE NO: CENA20160015273
OWNER: FLORIDA GULFCOAST HOLDINGS
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR TONY ASARO
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 54,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 54-179 AND 54-181.LIFTER AND DEBRIS CONSISTING OF WOOD,METAL,
PLASTIC,DISCARDED APPLIANCES,ETC.THROUGHOUT THE PROPERTY.
FOLIO NO: 01134800201
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 246 SINGLETARY STREET,COPELAND
{
5. CASE NO: CEV20160015274
OWNER: FLORIDA GULFCOAST HOLDINGS
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR TONY ASARO
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 130,ARTICLE III,
SECTION 130-95.UNLICENSED AND INOPERABLE VEHICLES ON THE PROPERTY.
FOLIO NO: 01134800201
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 246 SINGLETARY STREET,COPELAND
6
6. CASE NO: CENA20160018861
OWNER: LORRAINE BURGESS AND ADRIAN BURGESS
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR TONY ASARO
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 54,ARTICLE VI,
SECTION 54-179,54-181 AND 54-185(A).WEEDS OVER 18 INCHES AND LI I"1 ER ON THE
PROPERTY.
FOLIO NO: 1134805808
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 249 BROCKINGTON DRIVE,COPELAND
7. CASE NO: CEV20160018865
OWNER: RENEE A.WEEKS
OFFICER: INVESTIGATOR TONY ASARO
VIOLATIONS: COLLIER COUNTY CODE OF LAWS AND ORDINANCES,CHAPTER 130,ARTICLE III, •
SECTION 130-97(5)AND 130-96(A).COMMERCIAL AND RECREATIONAL VEHICLES
NOT PROPERLY STORED ON THE PROPERTY. •
FOLIO NO: 26088560009
VIOLATION
ADDRESS: 257 WORLEY STREET,CHOKOLOSKEE
VIII. OLD BUSINESS
A. Motions to Amend Previously Issued Order:
B. Motions to Rescind Previously Issued Order:
IX. CONSENT AGENDA
A. Request for Special Magistrate to Impose Nuisance Abatement Liens on Cases Referenced in Submitted Executive
Summary.
B. Request to Forward Cases to County Attorney's Office as Referenced in Submitted Executive Summary.
X. REPORTS
XI. NEXT MEETING DATE: May 5, 2017, at 9:00 A.M. located at the Collier County Government Center, 3299 East
Tamiami Trail,Building F,3rd Floor,Naples,Florida
XII. ADJOURNMENT
7
43 LA
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Collier County, Florida, Petitioner
Officer Jose Quintero
Vs. Public Utilities Department
Case No.:PU5144-CEEX20170004964
Taylor Morrison Esplanade Naples LLC , Respondent(s)
STIPULATION/AGREEMENT
COMES NOW, the undersigned, Taylor Morrison Esplanade Naples LLC , on behalf of herself/himself or
as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and
Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of the Citation in reference,
Case No. PU5144-CEEX20170004964 dated the 17th day of March , 2017.
In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Citation for which a hearing is
currently scheduled for April 7th 2017 to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement
process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein, the parties hereto
agrees as follows:
1) The violations noted in the referenced Citation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence.
2) The violations are that of Code of Laws Section(s) 134-174 N and are described
as illegal connection
THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall;
1) Pay operational costs in the amount of $50.00 incurred in the prosecution of this case.
2) Pay administrative fee of$5.00 incurred in the processing of this case.
3) Pay civil penalty of $ 500.00
4) Tota . ges are $ 555.00
espondent or Representative (Sign) Offic 's Signature
14%.50 Wif-t41.esN-2.
Respondent or Representative (Print) Officer's Printed Name
/ 02f•L 4 1 H
Representativ�Title Date
1/77/0
Date
REV 7/1/08
c-
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Collier County, Florida, Petitioner
Officer Jose Quintero
Vs. Public Utilities Department
Case No.:PU5144-CEEX20170004967
Taylor Morrison Esplanade Naples LLC , Respondent(s)
STIPULATION/AGREEMENT
COMES NOW, the undersigned, Taylor Morrison Esplanade Naples LLC , on behalf of herself/himself or
as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and
Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of the Citation in reference,
Case No. PU5144-CEEX20170004964 dated the 17th day of March , 2017.
In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Citation for which a hearing is
currently scheduled for April 7th 2017 to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement
process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein, the parties hereto
agrees as follows:
1) The violations noted in the referenced Citation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence.
2) The violations are that of Code of Laws Section(s) 134-174 (B)(1) and are described
as crossing property lines .
THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall;
1) Pay operational costs in the amount of$50.00 incurred in the prosecution of this case.
2) Pay administrative fee of $5.00 incurred in the processing of this case.
3) Pay civil penalty of$ 500.00 .
4) Total Cftargl
es are $ 555.00 .
�.J O3
Respondent or Representative (Sign) Offic 's Signature
S'tit((--/ API-E.-44:k_ _O 05 .� `sit,0 AQ Iu
Respondent or Representative (Print) Officer's Printed Name
i-t't-)
Representative itle Date
L( (11 0
Date
REV 7/1/08
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Collier County, Florida, Petitioner
Officer Robin Goldsboro
Vs. Solid & Hazardous Waste Department
Case No.:PU5299-CEEX20170003150
Shree Siddhivinayak Hospitality LLC, Respondent(s)
STIPULATION/AGREEMENT
COMES NOW, the undersigned, '1,-- c,orv"t-x
Q -- , on behalf of herself/himself or Shree
Siddhivinayak Hospitality LLC, as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and
Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of the Citation in reference, Case No. PU5299-
CEEX20170003150, dated the 17th day of February, 2017.
In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Citation for which a hearing is
currently scheduled for 4/7/2017, to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process;
and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein, the parties hereto agrees as
follows:
1) The violations noted in the referenced Citation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence.
2) The violations are that of Code of Laws Section(s) PU 134-174 (n) and are described as
Unlawful Connection.
THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall;
1) Pay operational costs in the amount of$50.00 incurred in the prosecution of this case.
2) Pay administrative fee of$5.00 incurred in the processing of this case.
3) Pay civil penalty of$ 500.00.
4) Total Charges are $555.00.
Respondent or Representative (Sign) Officer's Signature
c.,r\ri �� Robin L. Goldsboro
Respondent or Representative (Print) Officer's Printed Name
4/7/2017
Representative Title Date
u{ 11 1 (1
Date
REV 7/1/08
Vt
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Collier County, Florida, Petitioner
Officer Robin Goldsboro
Vs. Solid & Hazardous Waste Department
Case No.:PU5301-CEEX20170003151
Shree Siddhivinayak Hospitality LLC, Respondent(s)
STIPULATION/AGREEMENT
COMES NOW, the undersigned, 1- 1nr PotAJ , on behalf of herself/himself or Shree
Siddhivinayak Hospitality LLC, as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and
Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of the Citation in reference, Case No. PU5301-
CEEX20170003151, dated the 17th day of February, 2017.
In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Citation for which a hearing is
currently scheduled for 4/7/2017, to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process;
and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein, the parties hereto agrees as
follows:
1) The violations noted in the referenced Citation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence.
2) The violations are that of Code of Laws Section(s) PU 134-174 (q) and are described as No
Free Service.
THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall;
1) Pay operational costs in the amount of$50.00 incurred in the prosecution of this case.
2) Pay administrative fee of$5.00 incurred in the processing of this case.
3) Pay civil penalty of$ 500.00.
4) Total Charges are $555.00.
77
Respondent or Representative (Sign) Officer's Signature
PctRobin L. Goldsboro
Respondent or Representative (Print) Officer's Printed Name
Com i 4/7/2017
Representative Title Date
u1 111
Date
REV 7/1/08
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Collier County, Florida, Petitioner
Officer Robin Goldsboro
Vs. Solid & Hazardous Waste Department
Case No.:PU5302-CEEX20170003153
Shree Siddhivinayak Hospitality LLC, Respondent(s)
STIPULATION/AGREEMENT
COMES NOW, the undersigned, ,- ei�� ' ( ' , on behalf of herself/himself or Shree
Siddhivinayak Hospitality LLC, as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and
Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of the Citation in reference, Case No. PU5302-
CEEX20170003153, dated the 17th day of February, 2017.
In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Citation for which a hearing is
currently scheduled for 4/7/2017, to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process;
and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein, the parties hereto agrees as
follows:
1) The violations noted in the referenced Citation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence.
2) The violations are that of Code of Laws Section(s) PU 134-126 (a) 6 and are described as
Program Responsibilities.
THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall;
1) Pay operational costs in the amount of$50.00 incurred in the prosecution of this case.
2) Pay administrative fee of$5.00 incurred in the processing of this case.
3) Pay civil penalty of$ 500.00.
4) Total Charges are $555.00.
Respondent or Representative (Sign) Officer's Signature
Robin L. Goldsboro
Respondent or Representative (Print) Officer's Printed Name
0 w 4/7/2017
Representative Title Date
u � � 1i7
Date
REV 7/1/08
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Collier County, Florida
Petitioner,
VS. Case No. CEROW20160008193
Yasniel Gonzalez et al.
Respondent(s),
STIPULATION/AGREEMENT
COMES NOW, the undersigned, `last11Q1 Cton2Ltle2_ , on behalf of himself or
as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and Agreement with Collier County as to the
resolution of Notices of Violation in reference (case) number CEROW20160008193 dated the 7th day of June,
2016.
In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for which
a hearing is currently scheduled for LA -1-- 19- ; to promote efficiency in the administration of the code
enforcement process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the
parties hereto agree as follows:
1) The violations noted in the referenced Notice of Violation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence.
Damage to grass and use of the right-of-way for vehicle entry to and exit from the
property without obtaining applicable Collier County right-of-way permit(s)
THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall;
1) Pay operational costs in the amount of $ ( ES-.25- incurred in the prosecution of this case
within 30 days of this hearing.
2) Abate all violations by: Ceasing the use of any unpermitted Right-Of-Way access AND Obtain
all required Collier County Right-Of-Way permit(s) to permit the additional access OR to re-store
the Collier County Right-Of-Way to a permitted state, obtain all inspections through final
approval, within (a0 days of this hearing or a fine of $25O .°O per day will be imposed
until the violation is abated.
3) Respondent must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of abatement of the violation and
request the Investigator perform a site inspection to confirm compliance.
(24 hours notice shall be by phone or fax and made during the workweek. If the violation is abated 24 hours prior to a Saturday,Sunday or legal holiday,then the
notification must be made on the next day that is not a Saturday,Sunday or legal holiday.)
4) That if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may abate the violation using any method
to bring the violation into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County Sheriff's Office
to enforce the provisions of this agreement and all costs of abatement shall be assessed to the property
owner.
ll ' (
Respofident or Representative (sign) Cristina Perez, Supervisor
for Michael Ossorio, Director
Code Enforcement Division
Respondent oepresentative (print Date
7 .- 29 - l0
Date
REV 3-29-16
aialkillnr3r0011F1
CODE ENFORCEMENT - COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA
Office of the Special Magistrate
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, Case: CEEX20170002592
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, Plaintiff,
vs.
JENNIFER DIPASCALE, Respondent(s)
NOTICE OF HEARING
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that Pursuant to Section 162.06 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and Collier County
Ordinance No. 07-44, as amended, you are hereby ordered to appear at a public hearing before the Office of
the Special Magistrate on the following date, time, and place for the violation below:
DATE: 04/07/2017
TIME: 11:00 AM
PLACE: 3299 Tamiami Trail East Building F, Naples, FL 34112
VIOLATION: Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances, Chapter 14, Article H, Section 14-
36, Dangerous dog.
LOCATION OF VIOLATION: 9047 The Lane, Naples
SERVED: JENNIFER DIPASCALE, Respondent
Daniel Grossi, Issuing Officer
RESPONDENTS ARE REQUIRED TO APPEAR AT 10:30 AM FOR A PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE.
HEARING TO BEGIN AT 11:00 AM.
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that the alleged violator may produce any and all documents, witnesses
and/or evidence to be relied upon for the testimony given at the hearing. Documents will consist of the original
and three copies. Alleged violators have the right to be represented by an attorney.
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that Requests for Continuances will not be considered if not received by
the Secretary to the Office of the Special Magistrate at least five (5) business days prior to the date set for the
hearing.
IT IS FURTHER ADVISED that Ordinance.No. 07-44, as amended, be reviewed prior to your attendance at the
hearing to include emphasis on Section Eight relating to the appeal process.
Kerry Adams
COLLIER COUNTY CODE ENFORCEMENT
28Q0 North Horseshoe Drive
Naples, Florida 34104
(239) 252-2496 Telephone
IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY W-O NEEDS ANY ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE I'N THIS PROCEEDING,YOU ARE ENTITLED,AT NO COST TO YOU,TO THE
PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE, PLEASE CONTACT THE COLLIER COUNTY FACILITIES MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT LOCATED AT 3301 EAST TAMIAMI TRAIL,NAPLES FLORIDA
34112(239)774-8800;ASSISTED LISTENING DEVICES FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABLE IN THE COUNTY COMMISSIONERS'OFFICE
NOTIFICACION:Esta audiencia sera conducida en el idioma'ogles.Servicios the traduccion no saran disponibles en la audiencia y usted sera responsable de proveer su propio traductor,pare un major
entendimiento con las comunicaciones de este evento.For favor traiga su propio traductor.
Aveiisman—Tout odisyon yo fet an angle.Nou pan gin moun you fe tradiksyon.Si ou pa pale angle tanpri vini avek yon intepret you pale you-ou.
O fl 1.
sci 2_
JENNIFER DIPASCALE
9047 The Lane
Naples, FL 34109
2/1/17
Collier County DAS
7610 Davis Blvd
Naples, FL 34104
To Whom it May Concern:
This letter is my formal notice in writing that I would like to appeal your intention of labeling my
dog, Nala, a dangerous dog. I am requesting a hearing to settle this matter. Please advise me
of the times available. I can be reached at 239-919-2786.
Sincerely,
C eic, Cal
ennifer Dipascaie
000 ?
1- •''b'
....--.., , ,
_
-; 1 ".,•‘ '
/•••
/
.. / .
.•
..„,- ...,„..
..,„., .. .....,,,,,,,.
•
f ' ' fillip
0..
• , ' 0 ; ., ,
'.. : 4
00, ,
...,
....7
• . .
„,
.,.
. ... •
,.,.. /
, ..
,
. .... .. . ..,
•-4 t - ,
t `
_ .........,.... .- .
__
, _. •; 0 0
•
... ... .
.- .
.._
.. _.
•, . • . .
•
, •
. •:*!.. . t.t•
. . ..
.. - ' •,,,. I. •
. .- • -
-. . - • •-e" ' .
-• , . .
. •go, " .
- - •., .,
. -
- - .
go.,
!/_.......
Y s, Y/,/ IV-
,,, Pii,it.3
� II,
1 4}fj
•
iii
41
,I1 tr
s.
•
It , .. -
s
... _
. . . '•
',',-,';,„.....••. ,',,-.,,,,,_ ''
•,-
.-,-"Ji,;...)--... --'7,., . ''-r. ' '-•'',--''',-;'..•.1/4',•NTli'-''`-'-',':-.., '...•• ' '''--,'
. -..........1.::-':',''''''''.'''''''",., ..- '• '''''.1-.-;.''',". -'--.. ,i`...-', .''''',...'i...,,.,':::...'--:.::''
N
,.-.4",.:::..•-,-
-. '. ..ir------- v- -. .,-.•
,
.,i.•.:,,
., --, , _.•,,,.„.„-e,..--
, ,,‘,.„...
. . .„..
..,.
..,,
.. .
. .
..r''..:
,...„,01.---- \ ,,,, Ili, ,,.„ ._,„„„,, .,,,...::.'•
: I ',''',., ,. -',,,A4,,,,,-,'','.,, .,' '..'",„di.'1''',#j':- '' '',-.' pool \., ,•74%. •,-: :::,:.,'_. t.-I'-•.- -
[ 'ig,.T..1-i....41.,..'2,;,:-..•':..- '' '10":' . \! ' \ ''',. '..i----:-' ''-••::•:. -
:k.
,
- ,
, ,
. ' :.-,;• :„.':. ' ,(4, .,
,,, ,,
.. ,
' ' ..-, ',,,',,, • •--';40.3-,.: .';,.',,, ,.,,i„,:§1-,,,,,
. . , 1 ; ,
.. .
-
.. .. .„ . . ...
...„.„ ., .. . . .
. . .. .
.'
.. . . .... ,,
.. . . .
. .
,_ ..
,. .
sirlikl, -',J;;'..1 ' ':'i4,s‘
. ,
-N,,, ' ,"4-i-,,,'";.,:-.,-„::::H.,•,, .'
. . .
. .
t . -; •,, 1 ."`,,'-'-•- li
.
1 ,,
1
;,,,...',1
Ar_ .,.. ... _ ,.
ii
iiisa i I
.. .
i -
lr '
111
„ . 1
.•,.-.,„. -,... ..,-,4,...:. ' ,
I • ' :,,
• '
. .
. ,
... .
. ' .: .- ' 4 --- • -f . .. . ., ,
,,J, -
.4,..c. , ,
P .
,4%
1
, .,..
.,.
l'
,
, • It ,\
,
skill 1
4 . 1
..„
. ,
... .4
4,4640L, _
• .. .,
dimit4r
got.„
.„.,
Cala / 4011111101rieL
/ .440
a
110 ,
ail. '''., , i'
1
1
•
li
f.
f
, i / I
J r
_,, ., rii‘,..,. ....:1-Hi, :1617'..1-*"1:':''''' ' '' '..71" I:: ''i'_'-*'f::'1
fi.1 t
' -. "- ,, .. '..,. _
, ......, , ...
, . . ...,... .. ...4„...
_ ., 0 . . - .-14-
• 'k..‘,"‘ 'F
t
a
yl
krfil
. .
,
.?001 . . ,„ ,.
a
0
• ° • 4 i!
• ,4 i ' 6.:
1112111
1� !
.,
4 4 . -
r ',.46 ,
lir
�. `.` �r.- ,_. -ate ' `'
'..111/.17401/11..4/17 i
'74:°141.1°1'111:- / ...-.4.. IF/ rf 4. § •
3toor:/ 4741, A ,a '.,' ' I 1 , '
,r ,. i4i M
.0:1°11s44
1..m 4Y4i � . V.??",,, ./‘� � � ,
4.,,A-%.:
. ♦ c • v �
!
!• 1t iV-:A,�• ,` Vii. "t
'1
` •
,•'rte—�F ,� _ , f i
♦ - i ..
7
' t 1,1
2 •"*.:: r 1
•
. ,_ p r ,,.
4 =.. l Q v _ _
I 1 f
1 1111
in
la
411,41
Y.
1. e Z' ;•;
E.
.I. •
40 # '
Ilk 7'ilir *1 i' . Ihillillvit.
(tAiii,
a I.t
4..-:-.-4{. . lio.....i, # -4, .,,-. , A.
... "
at;ti 21.,,-=ate ,Pi.
4 d
w,r i
► .M 3 y
y
z ,
Ar.441
tf r ?. 4• 4
1 irt. •tt
• II% ' :',c‘" u •- ''.4.S. ‘,. i' I ', i Ili
1r i
•
11":
l` ss b. f. µ'
del
..t
• .
...,.....4, .., ,,... •_., . , • , ;.
tIt,
4^ ,
t 4 A
_ ,
(Ar"P",v--.-.--\ •• ,--• -i''''' ' -"•• • \- : .' ill • , . 4 i. -1),:',01,''''-,141PX ',' ..,--r ,
'N; \' • --. - .)) .•- , 4 '--‘,.-g:..-r,, -.-7..,::• . V•-,
i it,t�y �7
+illIN
1
.¢tl� , ,.''
.
i ..
s
,�s% a ...,•,.„..-.0... ,t,
,r- . .!. ,. ....... • ,, 4::..,.. :4,.
._ _, _ .. :.
Tom. ..
..,.. .:. ... ,,,..,
. , ..,4, . ,. , .
, -•• •---;'-':: 1'
• .' il I 4I!r •t•
41, :,\
‘%, - th _....._ 4 s
r �, yyy
1110%�_�` ,r q' iiI y
� ,.�, fit :!.
• 7 �I.
-11\-:f* . 4j�` ' � r Y , 4 .� ';�
,...., .
___
v �'C
_ ___ .
- ....,
;,,,..
, • ., .
nilsic I
J^ � _ � _ i �
1
\&h..
v v?if �
.:, .
\ to ......
1 (( •
_ Y S
44
,IT,
, + '• •. {
fr% 'Sn r rt
t.
, { .Styy • -
4
COLLIER COUNTY DOMESTIC ANIMAL SERVICES
SUFFICIENT CAUSE TO CLASSIFY DOG AS "DANGEROUS"
PURSUANT TO COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE
CHAPTER 14 ARTICLE II SECTION 14-36 AND/OR
CHAPTER 767 FLORIDA STATUTES
1/27/17
Jennifer Dipascale (054862)
9047 The Lane
Naples,FL, 34109
"Nala"(189259) Blue, S/F, American Staffordshire, 3y
This letter is your written notice that Collier County Domestic Animal Services (CCDAS)has
determined that there exists sufficient cause to make the initial determination that your dog,
"Nala",as described above, is a"Dangerous Dog"pursuant to Collier County Ordinance Chapter
14, Article II, Section 14-36 and/or Chapter 767, Florida Statutes based on the following
findings:
(3) Has, when unprovoked, chased or approached a person upon the streets, sidewalks, or any
public grounds in a menacing fashion or apparent attitude of attack, provided that such actions
are attested to in a sworn statement by one or more persons and dutifully investigated by the
appropriate authority.
Pursuant to Collier County Ordinance Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36 and/or Subsection
767.12(1)(c), to appeal this initial determination,your written request MUST be sent to CCDAS
(Attn: Officer Grossi) not later than seven (7) calendar days from the day that you receive this
letter.
If you request this hearing, the hearing will be held as soon as possible, but not later than twenty-
one (21) calendar days and not sooner than five (5) days after the day that CCDAS receives your
written request for a hearing. If you request a hearing, be sure to provide CCDAS a telephone
number where you can be reached on weekdays between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. in order for CCDAS
to conveniently notify you of the date, time, and place of the hearing. A letter notifying you of
the same will also;be sent to you. If you have a preference for a specific date and time, (or dates
and times that will be most convenient for you) you may request such dates and times in your
written request for the hearing. CCDAS will make our best effort to accommodate your request.
However, CCDAS cannot guatantee that your-hearing will be scheduled on the date(s) and
time(s) as you requested. This hearing may only be rescheduled by written agreement approved
by both parties.
If you do not request a hearing within seven (7) days from the date of your receipt of this letter,
this initial determination will become a final determination that your dog is a"dangerous dog"as
determined by CCDAS.
0003
If a final determination is made that this dog is a "dangerous dog" you will be required by law to
immediately take several actions with regard to this dog. These obligations include registering
this dog as a "dangerous dog" with CCDAS and are specified in Collier County Chapter 14,
Article II, Section 14-36 and/or Chapter 767 Florida Statutes. Additional obligations are
specified in Chapter 14 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances.
If your dog is impounded throughout this process, you will be required to pay for all costs
incurred for the care of the dog. You must pay all costs in full before your dog will be released to
you. Please note CCDAS will not hold- your dog indefinitely. Failure to comply with all
requirements of this letter, Florida Law, and County ordinance will ultimately result in your
forfeiture of ownership of your dog.
If you have any questions, or require additional information, you may contact CCDAS at (239)
252-7387 and ask,to spear • i Officer Grossi.
Signed by: ( 1,r--
Officer
1Offcer Grossi
Animal Control Officer
Collier County Domestic Animal Services
7610 Davis Blvd
Naples, FL 34104
(239) 252-7387
0004
Timeline of events
® On April 30, 2015, two dogs, Bently and Nala (A189259) aggressively approached Mara Marzano
as she was walking her dog in the roadway. This was investigated under DAS activity number
A15-009567 and a sworn statement was received.
® On January 25, 2016, Bently was off property and approached Chad Stine. Bently was not
aggressive. Nala then approached in an aggressive manner and attacked his dog. This was
investigated under DAS activity number A16-000491 and a sworn statement was received.
• On August 16, 2016, Gloria Laverde was walking dogs in the roadway when Nala ran off property
and attacked the dog. This was investigated under DAS activity number A16-004356 and a
sworn statement was received.
0005
ZI
‘3.-\\-*
i -
9.
ads _ <
...*i.\.
f
a-' W 0
C- \
c-
un
\t lit
.., \
V .,d A 1 �,
s.,,, P "ria
cra \-
c....
a;
C3 r
\ •-
V rn y
r
.?4' c'1'
w
`-'1 r 0 1)
7
ao� \
2 ks y
4
:c4-.. , \
%
i c w
tkM 41� N d �� \
O e O
0C)GU
0
O o
0
erre
Cot ier County
Public Services Division
Domestic Animal Services
Dangerous Dog Investigation Acknowledgement
I, ,i Ci n i (( Dy of C„v/,G, the owner or caretaker of / /A have received notice
that:
o This dog is under investigation as a dangerous dog
- Chi/DAS has found sufficient cause to declare this dog dangerous
o CCDAS has determined that this dog should be impounded
❑ I must take action to reclaim my dog,or surrender my dog to CCDAS
tether DD �j �! C0.f7`at)
DD Ord r .i 4- t e
• and acknowledge receipt of such said documentation (copy attached)on l �
C
I date.
1
I understand that if I fail to respond to CCDAS's request(s) and/or fail to cooperate with the investigation, I may forfeit
ownership rights to my dog.
t
1J � � i
Signatur
1r1n I .�v Ct\J `( /
_
• Print Name
4,1.1'111.0,-
ry/ � 22"-e/111.‘
., . 3 7
Investigator's Signature ID#
Person ID PO .111 I?6.1.
Animal ID 4-171 - Th
Activity Address q()Li 7 4_0...Az.
COLLIER COUNTY
is
ACtliFiZAL
DorresticAnimal Services •7610 Davis Blvd.•Naples,Florida 34104•239-252-PETS(7387) •www.collierpets.com
0007
Collier County Domestic Animal Services
APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATE OF REGISTRATION OF DANGEROUS DOG
In accordance with Collier County Ordinance Chapter 14, Article II, Sec. 14-36 as amended and
Florida State Statute Chapter 767, I hereby apply for a "Certificate of Registration" for a dog
that has been declared to be a dangerous dog.
Dog Owner's Name:
Address where dog is located:
Dog's Name: Breed:
Gender: Weight: Color:
I have included Three Hundred Dollars ($300.00) registration fee and:
A. Attached is a true copy of a current certificate of rabies vaccination, for this clog, issued by
on the day
of , 20
B. I hereby certify that there is posted a warning sign at each entry point to the premises
where this dog is located for a total of signs. Each of these signs is a clearly visible
warning sign that informs both children and adults that a dangerous dog is present at the
premises. These signs shall remain continuously posted at each such entry point. A color
photograph clearly showing the front of these signs is attached. Each sign is 18 inches wide and
is 12 inches from top to bottom. (DAS will provide signs for the initial registration)
C. I hereby certify that this dog has been permanently identified as a dangerous dog. The form
of this permanent identification is by electronic implantation. A copy of the receipt for this
permanent identification is attached to this application.
D. A current, color, photograph of dog is attached.
E. A receipt, or other written proof, that the dog has been spayed or neutered by a licensed
veterinarian. If there is a medical or other reason that the dog cannot be spayed or neutered, the
owner will provide the reason in writing signed by a Collier County licensed veterinarian.
F. I acknowledge that the dog will be identified by name and address on the Collier County
animal services website.
G. I understand that the Certificate of Registration must be renewed each year, at least 10
calendar days prior to the expiration date of the Initial Certificate.
1
0008
H. I understand that I must comply with ALL regulations stated within Collier County Animal
Control Ordinance Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36 and Florida State Statute 767, as it
relates to Declared Dangerous Dogs.
Signature of Owner:
Printed or typed name of Owner:
Date:
Telephone number of Owner:
E-mail address of Owner:
Facsimile phone number of Owner:
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY:
This dog was declared to be dangerous by CCDAS on:
Application received by Domestic Animal Services on
Application is approved by:
Application is disapproved for the following reasons:
2
0009
Chapter 14 Article II
Sec. 14-36. Dangerous dogs;definitions and procedures.
1. Definitions.
A. Dangerous dog means any dog that according to the records of the appropriate authority:
(1) Has aggressively bitten, attacked, or endangered or has inflicted severe injury on a human being on public or
private property;
(2) Has more than once severely injured or killed a domestic animal while off the owner's property;
(3) Has,when unprovoked, chased or approached a person upon the streets,sidewalks, or any public grounds in
a menacing fashion or apparent attitude of attack, provided that such actions are attested to in a sworn
statement by one or more persons and dutifully investigated by the appropriate authority.
B. Unprovoked means that the victim who has been conducting himself or herself peacefully and lawfully has been
bitten or chased in a menacing fashion or attacked by a dog.
C.Severe injury means any physical injury that results in broken bones, multiple bites, or disfiguring lacerations requiring
sutures or reconstructive surgery.
D. Investigation is conducted by animal services. Animal services must interview the dog's owner when possible and may
require a sworn affidavit from any person desiring to have a dog classified as dangerous.
E. Proper enclosure means that,while on the owner's property,the dog can be securely confined indoors or in a securely
enclosed and locked pen or structure, suitable to prevent the entry of young children and designed to prevent the
animal from escaping.Such a pen or structure shall be structurally sound, made of materials impervious to moisture,
have secure sides and a secure top to prevent the dog from escaping over, under, or through the structure, and shall
also provide protection from injury and the elements.The square footage of a proper enclosure used as a primary
means of confinement for a dog must be equal to or greater than the length of the animal from the tip of the nose to
the base of the tail, doubled, then squared, and divided by 144. For example, a dog measuring 30 inches from the tip of
the nose to the base of the tail will require a 25 square foot enclosure(30 x 2= 60;60 x 60=3,600;3,600/144=25).The
height of the enclosure shall be equal to or greater than the length of the animal from the tip of the nose to the base of
the tail multiplied by 1.5.
2. Procedure.
A.The Director shall investigate reported incidents involving any dog that may be dangerous and shall, if possible,
interview the owner and require a sworn affidavit from any person, including any animal control officer or enforcement
officer,desiring to have a dog classified as dangerous. Any animal that is the subject of a dangerous dog investigation,
and is not impounded with animal services, shall be humanely and safely confined by the owner in a securely fenced or
enclosed area pending the outcome of the investigation and resolution of any hearings related to the dangerous dog
• classification.The address of where the animal resides shall be provided to animal services. No dog that is the subject of
a dangerous dog investigation may be relocated or ownership transferred pending the outcome of an investigation or
any hearings related to the determination of a dangerous dog classification. In the event that a dog is to be destroyed,
the dog shall rrot be relocated or ownership transferred.
B. Animal services may impound any dog under investigation if the owner is unable or unwilling to securely confine the
dog during the investigation. Upon written notice from animal services,the owner must allow access to the dog for the
purposes of impoundment. If the dog is impounded during this time,the owner is responsible for all costs related to
impoundment unless the owner ultimately prevails and the dog is not declared dangerous.
C.A dog shall not be declared dangerous if the threat, injury, or damage was sustained by a person who, at the time,
was unlawfully on the property or,while lawfully on the property,was tormenting, abusing, or assaulting the dog or its
owner or a family member. No dog may be declared dangerous if the dog was protecting or defending a human being
within the immediate vicinity of the dog from an unjustified attack or assault.
D. If the Director,or his or her designee, makes an initial determination that a dog is dangerous, based on the initial
investigation, the County shall provide written notification of that determination to the owner of the dog. Notice shall
be by certified mail, by certified hand delivery, by service pursuant to F.S.ch.48, or as otherwise authorized by Florida
Statute.The Director's initial determination shall automatically become final unless the dog's owner,within seven
calendar days after receipt of the notice,files a written request for a hearing to challenge the Director's initial
determination.The written request must be submitted to animal services. If the dog's owner files a timely written
request for a challenge hearing, the effective date of the determination shall be the date of the final decision of the
Special Magistrate.
E.Any owner of a dog that is initially declared dangerous by the Director may appeal that decision to the Code
Enforcement Special Magistrate.This hearing shall be held as soon as possible, but not more than 21 calendar days and
0010
no sooner than 5 days after receipt of request from the owner.The hearing may only be continued by agreement of
both parties.
F. If the Special Magistrate's determination is to uphold the dangerous dog classification,animal services shall provide
written notification to the owner as required above.The dog owner may file a written request for a hearing in county
court to appeal the classification within ten (10) business days after receiving notice.This request for hearing must be
filed with the county court, and a copy provided to animal services within the time provided. Any such appeal shall not
be a hearing de novo, but shall be limited to appellate review of the record created before the Special Magistrate.
3. Registration of dangerous dog and fees.
A. Registration of dangerous dog. Not later than 14 calendar days after the final effective date, as specified above,that
the dog is determined to be a dangerous dog,the dog's owner must file a complete written standard form application
with animal services to be issued a certificate of registration for the dangerous dog.The application/administration fee
for each certificate shall be$300.00 annually.A complete application for the initial certificate of registration shall
include: (i)the filing fee and late fees, if any; (ii)a color photograph of dog and a signed acknowledgement form that the
dog will be identified by name and address on the Collier County Animal Services website; (iii) a receipt or other written
proof that the dog has been permanently identified (via tattoo or microchip); (iv) a current certificate of vaccination for
the dog; and (v) a receipt or other written proof that the dog has been spayed or neutered by a licensed veterinarian. If
there is a medical or other reason that the dog cannot be spayed or neutered,the owner will provide the reason in
writing signed by a Collier County licensed veterinarian.
B.Within ten days of receipt of a complete application, animal services will make a site visit to ensure provision of a
proper enclosure, and posting of the premises with a clearly visible warning sign at all entry points that informs both
children and adults of the presence of a dangerous dog on the property.Animal services will provide the required signs.
Upon completion of a successful site visit, animal services will issue the requested initial certificate.The duration of each
certificate is 365 days.There shall be a late fee of$10.00 per day,for each day that the certificate is not issued.
C.Annual renewal of certificate of registration. A standard renewal application must be filed annually at least ten
calendar days prior to the date that the respective certificate is to expire. A complete application for a renewal
certificate shall include the$300.00 renewal/administrative fee, a then current color photograph of each dangerous dog
sign posted at the premises where the dangerous dog resides, and a current certificate of vaccination.
D. Failure to re-register.There shall be a late fee of$10.00 for each day that a complete renewal application is not filed.
Animal services may impound any dog whose owner has: (i)filed to re-apply for registration 30 days past the expiration
of the certification; or(ii)failed to successfully complete re-registration 45 days past the expiration of the certification.
Upon written notice from animal services,the owner must allow access to the dog for the purposes of impoundment.
The owner is responsible for all costs related to impoundment. Failure to successfully re-register the dog after 30 days of
impoundment will result in forfeiture of ownership of the dog.Animal services may dispose of such an impounded dog,
in a humane manner, at the expense of the owner.
4.Subsequent handling of dangerous dogs.
A.The owner shall immediately notify animal services when a dog that has been classified as dangerous:
(1) Is loose or unconfined;
(2) Has bitten a human being or attacked another animal; and/or
(3) Is sold,given away, or dies.
Prior to a dangerous dog being sold or given away,the owner shall provide the name, address, and telephone
number of the new owner to animal services.The new owner must comply with all the requirements of this
Ordinance.The owner is required to notify the appropriate animal services authority if the dog is moved out of
jurisdiction.
B. It is unlawful for the owner of a dangerous dog to permit the dog to be outside a proper enclosure unless the dog is
muzzled and restrained by a suitable leash of dependable strength and under the control of a competent person. Unless
prohibited by the dog's physical make-up, as in brachycephalic breeds, the muzzle must be of a cage-style that will not
interfere with the dog's vision, will allow the dog to pant and drink, but will prevent it from biting a person or animal.
The owner may exercise the dog in a securely fenced or enclosed area that does not have a top, without a muzzle or a
leash, if the dog remains within his or her sight and only members of the immediate household or person 18 years of age
or older are allowed in the enclosure when the dog is present. When being transported, such dogs must be safely and
securely restrained within a vehicle.
C. Hunting dogs are exempt from the provisions of this act when engaged in any legal hunt or training procedure. Dogs
engaged in training or exhibiting in legal sports such as obedience trials, conformation shows,field trials,
hunting/retrieving trials, and herding trials are exempt from the provisions of this act when engaged in any legal
procedures. However, such dogs at all other times in all other respects shall be subject to this and local laws. Dogs that
have beenclassified as dangerous shall not be used for hunting purposes.
0011
D.This section does not apply to dogs used by law enforcement officials for law enforcement work.
5.Attack or bite by dangerous dog.
A. If a dog that has previously been declared dangerous attacks or bites a person or a domestic animal without
provocation,the owner is guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in F.S. ch. 775,and subject
to imposition of a fine not to exceed $500.00. In addition, the dangerous dog shall be immediately confiscated by animal
services, placed in quarantine, if necessary, for the proper length of time,or impounded and held for ten business days
after the owner is given proper written notification, and thereafter destroyed in an expeditious and humane manner.
This ten-day time period shall allow the owner to request a hearing as outlined above in this section.The owner shall be
responsible for payment of all boarding costs and other fees as may be required to humanely and safely keep the animal
during any appeal procedure.
B. If a dog that has not been declared dangerous attacks and causes severe injury to or death of any human,the dog
shall be immediately confiscated by animal services, placed in quarantine, if necessary,for the proper length of time or
held for ten business days after the owner is given proper written notification, and thereafter destroyed in an
expeditious and humane manner.This ten-day time period shall allow the owner to request a hearing under this
Ordinance, above.The owner shall be responsible for payment of all boarding costs and other fees as may be required
to humanely and safely keep the animal during any appeal procedure. In addition, if the owner of the dog had prior
knowledge of the dog's dangerous propensities, yet demonstrated a reckless disregard for such propensities under the
circumstances,the owner of the dog is guilty of a misdemeanor of the second degree, punishable as provided in F.S. ch.
775, and subject to imposition of a fine not to exceed$500.00.
C. If a dog that has previously been declared dangerous attacks and causes severe injury to or death of any human, the
owner is guilty of a felony of the third degree, punishable as provided in F.S. ch. 775. In addition,the dog shall be
immediately confiscated by animal services, placed in quarantine, if necessary, for the proper length of time or held for
ten business days after the owner is given proper written notification, and thereafter destroyed in an expeditious and
humane manner.This ten-day time period shall allow the owner to request a hearing under this section. The owner shall
be responsible for payment of all boarding costs and other fees as may be required to humanely and safely keep the
animal during any appeal procedure.
D. If the owner files a written appeal under this section, the dog must be held and may not be destroyed while the
appeal is pending.
E. If a dog attacks or bites a person who is engaged in or attempting to engage in a criminal activity at the time of the
attack,the owner is not guilty of any crime specified under this section.
6. Violations.
A. Failure to comply with any provision of this section may result in a fine not to exceed $500.00 and impoundment of
the subject dog. Upon written notice from animal services,the owner must allow access to the dog for the purposes of
impoundment. The owner is responsible for all costs related to impoundment.
B. Failure to cure any violation of this section within 30 days of impoundment of the subject dog will result in forfeiture
of ownership of the dog.Animal services may dispose of such an impounded dog, in a humane manner at the expense of
the owner.
C. Upon second occurrence of a violation of this section, failure to cure within ten days of impoundment of the subject
dog will result in forfeiture of ownership of the dog.Animal services may dispose of such an impounded dog, in a
humane manner at the expense of the owner.
(Ord. No. 2013-33, § 11)
00 . 2
Activity Report with Photos
Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type:
A15-009567-1 STRAY/AGGRS 04/30/15 09:08 PM A8HRS 2 DOG
Activity Address: Geo Code: Jurisdiction:
9047 THE LN , NAPLES 2 COLLIER
Activity Comment:
2 AGGRESSIVE DOGS RAL CALLER MERRA 404-1314
Owner Information:
Caller Information:
SHERIFF POLICE, (239) 252-9300 JENNIFER DIPASCALE, (239) 919-2786
3319 TAMIAMI TRL E , NAPLES FL 34112 9047 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109
P000211 P054862
Animal Information:
A189259 - NALA- SPAYED, BLUE, AMERICAN STAFF
Officer: Call Taker: Result Codes:
P999129 WALKER SHANNON 1 RPRT 5 MC 2 DAFF 1 AFDR
Dispatch Date: Working Date: Complete Date: Response Time:
04/30/15 09:10 PM 04/30/15 09:14 PM 04/30/15 10:26 PM 00:06
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0013
Memo:
04/30/2015 4/30/15
Upon arrival I was able to make contact with caller Mara Marzano and three deputies on scene. Mara
explained to me that she was walking her three dogs (Golden Retriever, German Shepherd and a Rat
Terrier) on leashes. As she approached 9047 The Ln, she noticed a Pit Bull that lives at the residence
on property, off leash and barking. She began to turn around and walk in the opposite direction. The
dog came off property following behind her and a second Pit Bull appeared. The second Pit Bull ran
towards them and attacked her Rat Terrier. "Blaze" slipped his collar and ran away; currently
missing. Mara is unsure if he is injured at this time. Missing dog report sent out to staff.
There are two other neighbors that were witnesses to the dogs being off property. I gave Mara -
affidavits to pass along to the witnesses. Mara filled out an affidavit from the Sheriffs Department
and a Deputy notarized the statement. Affidavit will be placed in the affidavit box tomorrow.
I was able to make contact with Heather Dipascale at the residence of 9047 The Lane. The owner
Jennifer was not present during my visit. Heather advised that she was unaware that the dogs were
out and mentioned that the painters must have left the gate open. I did explain to Heather the
importance of properly confining the dogs, as this is the second complaint regarding the same
violations. I also informed Heather that citations can and may be issued in regards to this particular
incident based on the affidavits that we receive. Both dogs are current with county license and rabies
vaccination.
I spoke to the Deputies on seen that advised once they arrived the dogs were witnessed off leash
but back on property.
129/SW
04/30/2015 4/30/15
Copy of sworn statement, filled out by caller Mara Marzano, provided from CCSO. As per CCACO,
more than one affidavit (on an affidavit of complaint form) is required from more than one residence
in reference to and proving that a violation occured for citations to be issued; citations pending the
receipt of DAS affidavits.
Statement has been scanned and attached to activity; filed.
125/KL
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0014
Photos:
A'-5-CL t5tr'a
Cest.in,ShantS
SVVC) STATEMENTtar lat-OfteCtatt
,
-s. wane,.Ne.t S 11‘77
6"-s- ,-- or.n---
sr
worton ss B3__>= . rt-rlia_F,cnt._�. l. Ste.L _.Tf
ss
vets.,rn edtl�..,r w rn.e.ne.as and ars that en oh. 3 L _daror -.Dr�_-_ so
...o.•
b .nod .
ae.,,..r.sort.or F,nrid...hat t-_�t.c.-o -.�✓ -- ----_.
• c7L_Gr". rYir�a _c. .- ti._,��,,,,,,� i-i.�.�..��. cam- -O-it-.< ._._.—._a a_ /G
•J-�e..�-��,.__.a...i_Y__-.�a o-fes_ -./�
sTi. OF F�iol3ro.t,. �-Kocarrt A -.-thls /vaJL•%D��/`�
COVNTY OR ( =L : __...Sw mai subs r b.tl baa thls.�tlay eI yl�p�
f Sa-Ll... . 7�.-'Y ;�r Svc s -__..
a, nsilY A^^wM1n O.a.n.Trn.es,dane,R<,.e./ •.Soso- • .� orw.
nducnd 1
•
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0015
Collier County Sheriff's Office
3319 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, FL 34112-4901 I.•`?`_
SWORN STATEMENT - Vie`1, 4)
STATE OF FLORIDA '+'',yr"e
-VS- tC Report No. 5 1 1 9 3( >
Name-7)16. y A- ! / ` A. (-Z~Q In 0 Date of Birth
Telephone a3 d 5 -) -
Home Address - T1-1---7
Work Address
3/ S c--- -7-2t.-0144:--.)-11.4:1-{- Sk '( L Telephone
E-Mail Address
who, being duly sworn, deposes and says that on the day of tA p('i ) A.D., 20 /
in ___( 49 ) ) 1 - County, State of Florida, that h- IE / -
T/411-A-C_ • ' ' Ise 1 i .._ .,W./ / l
I+ I Ea . , 1 ti. . .div.� ,,a/A!- . !J .6->�/S / -I --c
�/
?'.4' I I ?4- (a 1, IC LealyeZ A, .. A •--"C •--4--1A) L7711‘. _ti) I I evc---cn ON-E-- -- ,,A_. 0 • ''./ ...., • 1 __
i
G _,b-)4 (f)/ -4- .t_ it i Vt ;\ 'c : c_1.l _L.. _Cr l r
ZkAet. otti-21-€-t-1- _ 3 Z/2_,AZ-te- (VAA-e_4_2A4\-&- „..,_ „A/o' _
.- CV-At Go//q, ) - _ ,,Q z • air/Lt.. 7D _,..s,e -- j-x4.,, (---2924/md.___
a
c-i--LA--Ttfo �6 ��,�►- .s . a A � 7 'F LORIDA,
COUNTY OF `---0 L4 --,-.1.---(7_1"-- , Sworn to and subscribed before me this3 day of yU-JJ
?` => L___ ,20 / , by Lk a of pe n mak at en bol .
My Commission Expires: r ' r 12 o
.ignature,of perso makin Statement
I 1 % "25�
7Sig`ersonally Known OR
atu a of ar'i]II'ric"Per F.S.S.117.10"-State of Florida
i- Produced Identification,Type of ldentificati.nt/
Form#P164-REV.09/10
006
Collier County Domestic Animal Services
7610 Davis Blvd., Naples, FL 34104 / 239-252-7387
Statement or Affidavit of Complaint Form
Generally, violations of the Collier County Domestic Animal Services Ordinance do not occur when
an Animal Services Officer is present. For an Officer or Domestic Animal Services to take action
regarding a violation, either the Officer or two residents MUST witness the incident(s).
This Affidavit of Complaint or Statement, when completed by a witness provides the documentation
necessary for an action to be taken. It establishes probable cause for an Officer to believe that a
violation took place, and the nature of the violation. This Statement form is essential for Animal
Services to pursue further action in reference to the violations you have described. For Animal
Services to efficiently respond to your needs, we ask that you print, review and carefully complete
this Statement to the best of your knowledge, and return it to Domestic Animal Services within ten
(10) days of the incident.
62
Complaint No: p (' - C
Tell us about YOU!
This portion is to be completed by you, and about you. We need to know your full name, address,
and various other information. Please print neatly or type, and review the completed form to
ensure that all information is included and correct.
Last Name: f V'i I 7-a no First Name: f''4g MI ft)
Street Address: f l Lr O <h'_ L -/x
City: r\I 4)ka State: f Zip:
Home Telephone: 0 Work Telephone: ,� (•:,
Tell us about the animal owner
We need you to record as much information about the animal owner as you know. Don't guess, be
certain. If there is some information that you do not know, simply write "unknown". The
information most needed is the animal owner's address. If you are uncertain about the owner's
information, or if the animal even has an owner, speak with your neighbors to be sure.
rr�� / P
Last Name: pi i .` = �� First Name: ) �� (, �l '1 MI
� t
Street Address: 1 (Tr-. I l' rIC
City: State: Zip:
Home Telephone: Work Telephone:
When is the owner normally home: L- do n i+ Kiii O ()1
Where did you obtain this information?
1 •
00 '7
What does the animal look like?
To take action, Animal Services needs tb be as certain as possible that we are dealing with the
correct animal(s). Please record as much and as accurate a description of each animal as possible.
Only list animals that were involved in the specific incident you are completing this Statement for.
Here are some basic rules:
• Breed is for species as well as the animal's specific breed
• Color: Indicate the dominant color first, then all the other colors
Breed(s) - Color(s) ,Sex Name
.
(-20 tic, KI r�cY oP pif I VY 'dL�
'r (; )as 1)t,L-P a (t -:, l C ' "I , elf, n (.( ,s itri -t :;�.� cl CLP`
* If you are uncertain about the breed of the animal. The animal control officer may be able to assist you with determining
the breed based on your description.
When and where did it happen?
This is where you tell your story. Please fill in all blanks with EXACT time, date, and location,
based on what YOU observed. Without this information, Animal Services cannot pursue further
action. Here are some examples:
Location: In street in front of 1212 Smith St.
In my back yard at 2121 Smith St. -
Time: 1:30 p.m.
+ � i f--i_r, !
Location of Incident: r1 a 1 �c 0( y- 1Y�•=!GIS (t �'1 4-h: a' 1{lIYq
EXACT Date of Incident: - EXACT Time of Incident �f� t"-"'`'� C/ilm �-- DA
a.m./p.m. CO
I l.'
Tell us what happened. Y t � C�r^ �tkv
In this section you will write a brief story of what happened, based on the information you gave
about WHEN and WHERE it happened, and what YOU observed. Only write about the most
recent occurrence. Previous occurrences are not relevant. DO NOT write about hearsay or other
conflicts there have been with the animal owner. Hearsay is what you have heard from other
people, not what you have observed, and is generally not admissible in court. Please print clearly
or type.
9 `
t'�;� I,�, �i, f t'T J�.� a J-'%,� �1�- 4‘)_ /; rJ\. ��J� i J i i,P'
tj-?L. O 0(.��'�Jy.� ! `' rr l i r' ,'%V� . .- !':t.-E al 1 w Th't 4.,t J�i
J /
- A) - i . 0(-��(� (i✓05� trn 4' (-- P�� C? /, s 2 0�
, I J
l r viJCS: y �, �. � ,
,i)--r_s _7 .. , II
E A (t- 1, 1-Alkt2.k 1(A/LI IL. 40 ' I
--14-c-- ..„./
1 i J u U
2
008
•
) iJj OA .11
7! //' jtg,-(
ii, /k .4-etprpr:Q- /PAX fuviii CoI
.1v }-1_,,a, A.--t4A--1- hitta 30D31 clic5c
, '
A. SCA �. , 714,411,1{_+ am - ) -� J,AN
A 7 /3 L t''
11(2722/Lkal--) - 0/\_ / ,5f.L c/ iA, efio
, trIltJi-r0)1-1
e4 A_- U ,- L/ l' 4
L2
Le,c E'er
t)d--[1*--/ Y r 17t-d-
Aeb . e)._, 1--3Pytr:
111,,,6' ti t A A . . L��(� �' c)-9 _(2 t i.Lrf ?)^!3
trYs 71L/ _2?
"Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Complaint and the
fads stated i it are tru A"
11:1 ik ALA 471 r>l b
Signature of Affiant ( ) Date
Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this 9 t day of lk'` , 20 ,
by IA Cx,-t C-. t' \ ekt- /L C r\-0 , who is [l ersonaliy known to me, or
12 Has. roduced as identification.
& \r‘
Signat&re of Notary, State of Florida Notary Stamp
E.JO• N
Notary's name (printed) ;F ' <; H SON
Commission#EE 828405
Expires October 10,2016
i _ ...`••` Sbec d Trru Troy Fal inIAPAx 6:0-3,!5-7019
100 L) qt
Commission Expires
0019
Activity Report with Photos
Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type:
A16-000491-1 INV/BITE ANIM 01/25/16 01:33 PM A8HRS 1 DOG
Activity Address: - Geo Code: Jurisdiction:
9215 THE LN , NAPLES 2 COLLIER
Activity Comment:
DOG ON DOG 1-25-16 CCSO CALLED IT IN
Owner Information:
Caller Information:
CHAD STINE, (850) 502-9946 JENNIFER DIPASCALE, (239) 919-2786
9215 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109 9047 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109
P128677 P054862
Officer: Call Taker: Result Codes:
P999114 ZEITLER TADB 3 MC 1 RPRT 3 NTC
Dispatch Date: Working Date: Complete Date: Response Time:
01/26/16 10:59 AM 01/26/16 02:30 PM 01/26/16 04:27 PM 1D 00:57
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0020
Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type:
A16-000491-2 INV/BITE ANIM 01/31/16 12:00 AM A8HRS 1 DOG
Activity Address: Geo Code: Jurisdiction:
9215 THE LN , NAPLES 2 COLLIER
Activity Comment:
DOG ON DOG 1-25-16 CCSO CALLED IT IN. CHECK ON STATUS OF AFFIDAVITS IF NOT REC
Owner Information:
Caller Information:
CHAD STINE, (850) 502-9946 JENNIFER DIPASCALE, (239) 919-2786
9215 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109 9047 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109
P128677 P054862
Officer: Call Taker: Result Codes:
P999136 BYRNES Kurt 1 RPRT 1 COMP
Dispatch Date: Working Date: Complete Date: Response Time:
01/31/16 08:12 AM 01/31/16 04:08 PM 01/31/16 04:08 PM 16:08
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0 () 2.
Memo:
01/25/2016 01/25/16 I recieved a call from Mara Marzano with the county attouney's office. She called in a
complaint about the dogs from 9047 The Ln attacking her leashed dog on 04/30/15 See
A15-009567. She said the dogs also attacked another dog that belongs to her neighbor that lives
across the street from her. She said that attack was not reported to DAS. Mara is very upset that this
dog has now attacked for the third time. She wants to know what is going to be done about this
dog. She wants the officer to contact her at her work number 252-8236 or on her cell phone
404-1314. 102/NE
01/26/2016 1-26-16
I called and spoke with Chad on the phone. He stated that he was walking his dog when 2 dogs from
9047 came off property and attacked his dog. His dog was able to get away and out run the
attacking dogs. He stated that he is aware of other incidence involving the dogs from this address.
I explained to him about the affidavids and that it takes 2 as per our county ordinance to be able to
issue citations. I also told him that I would drop some by to him at his home. He was not there but
his rnither would be.
Affidavids will be reveiwed as per county ordinace once they are received.
Mr Steine did take his dog to the vet and will provide the pictures and vet report.
I spoke with the dogs owner, Jennifer. She was aware of the incident and stated that one of her
neighbors is'out to get her and she and that neighbor do not speak because of a past dispute.
Jennifer stated that her step daughter had come home and opened the door and the dogs ran out.
She stated that they can contain the dogs its just when they have visitors that they have problems.
She stated that she has put a call into a fence guy and was awaiting his call to come give her a
quote on a fence for her property.She is unaware why her dog would act like this, that her dogs are
sweet. She asked me several time to meet them. I declined at this time.
I took the oportunity to explain to her the process of declaring a dog dangerous, she was concerned
that we would take her dog.I explained to her that we would not remove her dog unless the dog had
beeen declared and it attacked someone again.
I issued NTC for licenses for both dogs and Rabies vaccination for one.
While typing this I received a call from Pam Cunningham ,432-312-7011, she stated that her nanny
witnessed the issued form 1-25-16. She stated that she will get with Mr Stine to let him know. She
will have her nenny fill out an affidavid and get by to our office. She wanted to know if we took the
dogs, I explained to her that we are not in the possition to remove someones property at this time.
She was concerned as to how long the whole process takes , I explained to her that it will take some
time to get through the whole process.114
01/28/2016 1/28/16 - Affidavit received from Mra Marzano. She stated her dogs were attacked by 2 RAL dogs in
May 2015. She also stated Mr. Stine's dog was attacked on 1/25/16 but does not state that she
witnessed the attack.
138/DG
01/29/2016 1/29/16 - Affidavit received from victim dog owner, Chad Stine. He stated he was walking his dog
on lead when it was attacked by a gray Pitt Bull mix. He stated his dog was able to escape and ran
home with the Pitt mix chasing the entire way. Statement, photos, and vet bill attached to activity.
138/DG
01/31/2016 According to memo affadavit received.
GB/136
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0022
Photos:
Collier County OOm60tic Animal Srarvice.
..........•M...N.p oar PL 21e2o./x210-21021-721..
- St.C.m.nt or affld.yts of Cempl.lnt roan
Coneraliern mei S.M..oOmco or r I Collier
r Dem A into action
ntoebino a y a anon.e. .r Ora Officer or tee ratio.[.I+VST w ..:Annual
i.e.mne•eit f ca... .am or..t.m.nl,
rerocressess e W M Laken. ,l. ..alto 1 an Censor to believe,that a
violation Sof
opllace and Mesnor. .0 Meli•Mors. v,Statement f
MOM.. v bet.f your.newl.d0.•o 0e, o Oer...areview Ammo. .mlc ours tan
liolsaar.of the.Incident. vett
�roll.'ll.t
n Ile_000yw / POI ice- re.co/-f r6 237y
Tag me TOL"
if.w.m.rpoeie d..b or Wtys.7 adnr.d.
. ry.°n.L'omPr
l::a fom le
emu Oraall Information l•incite..and correct.
treat Nemo. 8-1-1ne.- Nem.. C,1,,......1 Ia. ILt. .
-- al...t wddr.... q 21 S T he- P L-rt.
cry, rs.1`d-E'Ia., st.te. _ F L_ 2101 3-4/09
Herm Telephone,(4So)S0y—CtgY6 Work Telephone L 3") 3c -4rs6y
Toll u•about ^ ra•'T
Wes need _ d Isanimal
m. . h ••you new a .b.
Certain- n, serum Information ou, a 't know,
w :er,.irr � :d..nr:
hoee n . . tb .D •ur. n
Information.or If C .Tal n nes an owners 4 e your oor•ba .
tarot Hamel Un{bylot.ln .mal Ur,!/-1/1.tXVr i t UN�.r+rn
atra.0 Ada a. 4 O q., Tho-- Pt-''1. L. -,01 3':/a q -
ow, i dii eS al.l.l F
mama Tall.hen•l yin k' PN M___ p .r . U✓l�toul✓1
when I.Ma owner nermaby nem., uyt h�.ko ag.ragdfc...xS
�jrD�
Whir.ma yo.I ebt.n.this Infe.n..•mn Tll,ts a w 1-a.r'e -4t a-`�-f o ,mow.. -
y -Prolyl d Poli L-4.-t-4.7 t2
6 4e y�-{t.... S
c.
Photos:
. .the. .ltilt: `is.fy.Ce• In
_
cermet lvrut •InctYo
axnt . terl ....that mow cane dos.,Min Ma
Oget mas Meese record
in OW..MCa•nao completing hSterwfo
I
N eed
. nate ae'a.ne aemin.nt rho ret,Me s allllthhe eche. N
i Moro e tq.p Ihdlea p t solar n !obit
I
L
....of.1 Color(.) Sorel_- am.
I
- 1 (r-Lrhmb r-19-4.1...1 `-_\\..c- :- - rL i y. - -
z..„,..,=.7...............==..... ......n.n........n n..,momma ern...n.t.or w mm0 ye.,MY.w...wnma
I.
and who..aIt
v
h tell your.tory. P n 1 Slimes with!SACT time,
auetloWMtti
VC.. Wtchothea Inbonol
rmtle ,MM...SOM...Canur
Caron.Pe.. lush..
on. Here a Marna
iuruen, e w taro o.rd.t•tai•mtu st
_tion...Incidents-�aLtitAk- si\ Oyitl rF�ttf�9097 dAise-,�.Ly
!SACT Pato of fneldentl / Z /b oser,r Tower or tnci.f-nt r f S m.�
T.N u•W ..hap nnnea.
1ntnl a will write••brief.tory of w eao .
etl n tM
putVMS!. N
.end waR• lc w ober
...Ted. Only wriInfte b natant
.M01...o CaM a Mit A NOT writ.slam.t other
csonflict•theme Sieve been with ye
::?1,414.1::.nor w Mb.noon
000 .end 1^ N Lod O in se pr no•.1.1.1.
S
I
� e• -r SP P G., ......e.
ave "' t_` :"..e.
! ' , �a� p
I' eR- wt, ..:.-4t-..., 1.q,.c,w-cs atro.,.lct I IS fail
1/1[7�S k-_ an y 'ar f,xcic.1 "F--{fo- r,titc,D�-4,-a-- 1.-�.--(-
j p(o T GM1otG-a Nn.ttl rt,/OJ-"-IT-�'o 4 -3'�+¢-rt r:V ew9 /r+Y ROY? -�✓I:.t,/Y� w..+c4
6r.rinl-L Tars -1F_2.t7tY, INP c1D -'t�i � _q.+.lP/ E.2Cc,...,
-4's n..c-- jw--t.-TT..._ d 2 n.a..D7 `(l cr7 Ow as cel-.✓_..,„...
MA-s-v.v..a..r-, •R-Aor .....b0.-/- IS a...-o .�1 5 y hQ.tL✓TL ,„
0.yta tjv.......4-L...Y --i. S¢Go...l.l d2oa/wdi p-7-1-b..//
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0023
Collier County Domestic Animal Services
7610 Davis Blvd., Naples, FL 34104 / 239-252-7387
Statement or Affidavit of.Complaint Form
Generally, violations of the Collier County Domestic Animal Services Ordinance do not occur when
an Animal Services Officer is present. For an Officer or Domestic Animal Services to take action
regarding a violation, either the Officer or two residents MUST witness the incident(s).
This Affidavit of Complaint or Statement, when completed by a witness provides the documentation
necessary for an action to be.taken. It establishes probable cause for an Officer to believe that a
violation took place, and the nature of the violation. This Statement form is essential for Animal
Services to pursue further action in reference to the violations you have described. For Animal
Services to efficiently respond to your needs, we ask that you print, review and carefully complete
this Statement to the best of your knowledge, and return it to Domestic Animal Services within ten
(10) days of the incident.
Pt 11,- 000 '41 ( Yol C Q(` - t4,6
Complaint No:
Tell us about YOU!
This portion is to be completed by you, and about you. We need to know your full name, address,
and various other information. Please print neatly or type, and review the completed form to
ensure that all information is included and correct.
Last Name: 64 I Re-' First Name: C ° `-C14 MI a"�'
Street Address: 99--1-5- T Lil,
City: I" ck-P `-e-_3 State: C Zip: J t / 0 q
Home Telephone: (SY-0)507.----Ct911117 Work Telephone'�239 3DLf
Tell us about the animal owner
We need you to record as much information about the animal owner as you know. Don't guess, be
certain. If there is some information that you do not know, simply write "unknown". The
information most needed is the animal owner's address. If you are uncertain about the owner's
information, or if the animal even has an owner, speak with your neighbors to be sure.
Last Name: U14. --11o())✓1 First Name: U11 -YIOC MI t]1/1 kr1 ow,--)
Street Address: 0 7 t lel ,
City: N 4 Dt€ 5 State: / Zip: 3(-4/0
Home Telephone: U OC.- \ Work Telephone: I.) 1,1_C--V QC-&)
When is the owner normally home: h --Yt.oC30d'1 ,L 1746 f S klGekooto at-45
Where did you obtain this information? �..�.5 IS W I� t`�- at V
0 e�li ot'el a. -i��-� port-ce, i12r
- rZ �
- ;
D � �
$ — 1b `- —►�,- c ` ,�5 I
0 0 2 4 cjefrg5 .,ck-vior�lee0y
j
What does the animal look like?
To take action, Animal Services needs to be as certain as possible that we are dealing with the .
correct animal(s). Please record as much and as accurate a description of each animal as possible.
Only list animals that were involved in the specific incident you are completing this Statement for.
Here are some basic rules:
• Breed is for species as well as the animal's specific breed
• Color: Indicate the dominant color first, then all the other colors
Breed(s) Color(s) Sex Name.
1(4 r t-K>IX lacz- 62.1,11 _gc$g
1910-741 (1,no\ve
r+- bol a ( Cob , . v
* If you are uncertain about the breed of the animal. The animal control officer may be able to assist you with determining
the breed based on your description.
When and where did it happen?
This is where you tell your story. Please fill in all blanks with EXACT time, date, and location,
based on what YOU observed. Without this information, Animal Services cannot pursue further
action. Here are some examples:
Location: In street in front of 1212 Smith St.
In my back yard at 2121 Smith St.
Time: 1:30 p.m. C�
Location of Incident:a I VB S 1 G( S�! l O ( 7 of ve`Oc.
` a
EXACT Date of Incident: l/Z-51I ' EXACT Time of Incl ent I . I a.m., '.
�'
Tell us what happened.
In this section you will write a brief story of what happened, based on the information you gave
about WHEN and WHERE it happened, and what YOU observed. Only write about the most
recent occurrence. Previous occurrences are not relevant. DO NOT write about hearsay or other
conflicts there have been with the animal owner. Hearsay is what you have heard from other
people, not w t you have observed, and is genera ly noLadinissible in court. PI ase print clear) /�
or type. ViAp q. 1 6- a- � P S GKv . •' i0 rt)
•- �
Chq.ST
T w t 1::1rwr tit lectik Lb-1+1'N a. 1,xrA.a sS °soy►1-ct M,
r
Rp Lue_, own:x;(424 evui 01T- —1 iv— Pc.4
AO C N .V i Or—a dr`lue,w' 'oto:
r
L;lirt l�� 4 ° �a oT .• - 047 cuAday\ck r,e)r-vvy LAAA p /
r 5 f‘ ki-41A4 4c7 sueerKoJ lc 4(2, wo cet(L_Lte,),
*0 IA - • I 4-() k7L1)11. t\Q,{
0025
1 QJIA CSS tori c 0 - 0 iT„s1)1 (
ljtia_ci-e-r) . v d M-G,4 PyU.-- 0 ' r to n p cc\-ki-A..
tx)q5 (�rl ` p,/ c ►.v ads os -Cm (lam, i U .74,e-4.e-d&cv
` 1<40-- — ti *-Row- 4c-, •A-
t) %-tV\ )-,moo 4 .� 41 - - OP r iI jAkid7 4)/4 )2-akfrld
V) u vl.(t 2-—� C,OR 42.2s1 f."'i ' 1 • 1 t a+"
e- O C'
f f; r r. .. / f.
1) [ow_ ,,, ,.
•
fl
L. 5 (4,{ v , ,,...1--i. _.. -.4, '-IIP - iilihdi. -- .
o . .-
ry 10,0, Cka_5-d, [A-1 nik, --g r ftk:z.)7-- '
1 0 AJLIL/e-S k%-{
h oAP-- IAA, iI °t. ( I of uJ ko-)7
40:0 A ./t. okr CR 1 .____ , •Goo0 ds .-- 1--kp o. bisire>.- 0,,e
LOaA---- 1)*.c- 'iW--c)o\it cz,irvw- dor d-9rti--‘o1/4-al tp,t-__- I , e___
1 I is 4 k-A5 Vk -C -b f() _ a- ' i i 5 , iter U 4,9L9)
"Under penalties of perjury, I declare tAat y.e read the f reg ing Afr t.Dk . .hint an - I
facts stat-• in it ;re true. (91A., C.
/401111r_dik
4 .41....--,....r n)\-r-0--5 (-''ri gwe_f-/ ttqf /764-7,9/1 c•- --.--VrOD---1Signa ure of rfriant Date
Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this ;-9g day of 5,+-V,A-tZil , 20 1/p ,
by ' OA- S YIUE f , who is ❑ personally known to me, or
0 as .roduced -' 1' ?\VE.�' L1CfL25& as identification.
) /0 /ill
,i) I
Signature a- Notary, State of Florid Notary Stamp
�FLLLA MoLoo-A LI __
Notary's name (printed)
-4,,,,,..,;\:, K&LLY�3.f ULCAl1Y
k Notary Public,State o. Florida
;. i Commlesior$FF 61178
ON f \--7 I rj I�i -7 �`Y comm.expires NOV. 17,2017
Commission Expires
3
0020
^yl ]l orzda Vete/ na/y 9220 Estero Park Commons Blvd.,Suite 117
,k Estero,Florida 33928
Referral Center Phone: (239)992-8873
Fan: (239)9sZ-0884
t 24-Haar Emergency and Critical Care www-fivrc.com
,v .fes
Emergency Discharge Letter for "Spike"
Patient Information:
Client Information: "Spike"(#29122)
Chad Stine(#24330) canine,Boxer
9215 The La Tan/White,male neutered
Naples,FL 34109 DOB:7/25/201 1
(850)502-9946
Monday,January 25,2016
Letter to:Harborside Animal Clinic
Seen By:Rhaysa Feliciano, DVM
On 1/25/2016, "Spike" Stine was presented for dog attack.The following is a summary of the visit:
Presenting Complaint:
dos attack
History:
Spike it s y/o MN Dor that Is presenting for dog fight wounds. About one hour ago he was being walked in his
neighborhood when he was attacked by two dogs. There are multiple lacerations on his right rear legs, side and by
his shoulder blade.Historically, Spike is healthy and not on any medications other than flea and heartworm
prevention monthly.He has been eating and drinking well and not having any vomiting, diarrhea,coughing or
sneezing.
Medications : monthly flea/hwp
Diet: Purina One
TPR:
Temperature: 101.3, Pulse: 100/strong,Respiration: pant, MM: pink, CRT: pink
Weight: 37.104 kg, 81.80 lb, 1.11 m2
Physical Exam:
Appearance:BAR, euhydrated, BCS 7/9
Eyes: no ocular discharge OU, normal pupil size/symmetry OU
Ears: clean ears AU
Nose:no nasal discharge
Oral Cavity: mild dental calculus,no masses/lesions noted
Heart/Lungs: no murmurs/arrhythmias ausculted pulse quality strong/synchronous,mm=pinlJmoist, ert<2sec,
normal bronchovesicular sounds in all quadrants
Abdomen: soft abdomen on palpation,no pain response elicited, no masses/organomegaly noted
Urogenital:M/N,no genital discharge noted
Musculoskeletal:adequate/symmetric muscle mass,normal gait, full Ortho exam not performed
Neurological: intact cranial nerves,appropriate mentation, normal proprioception x4
Skin:Localized small hive-like area on right side of trunk. 2 penetrating wounds(bite wounds)
on the right dorsal
0097
• neck; superficial skin abrasions on the right and left side of the chest;mild swelling,penetrating wound (bite
wound)and multiple superficial skin wounds on RPL over popliteal LN area
Lymph Nodes; normal size/consistency of palpable nodes
Assessment:
Bite wounds
Skin laceration(non penetrating)
Localized hive-like raised areas
R/Os: deep pyoderma vs dermatitis vs other
Treatments:
Clipped wounds _
Cleaned with chlorhexidine scrub
Flushed with sterile saline
Medications Dispensed:
CLAVAMOX 375mg #28
Give 1 tablet(s)every 12 hours until gone.
Refills:0
KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN!!!
CLAVAMOX 125mg #28
Give 1 tablet(s)every 12 hours until gone.
Refills:0
KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN!!!
CARPROFEN-GENERIC 75MG TABLETS #10
Give 1 tablet(s)every 12 hours until gone.
Refills:0
KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN!!!
Recommendations:
Spike presented to FVRC for evaluation of multiple bites after being attacked by a dog earlier today. Upon
physical examination we noticed that he had multiple superficial and penetrating wounds on his neck,sides, and
right back leg.The bite wounds appear to be superficial in nature with no deep pockets observed during
examination. We also observed what appeared to be hives on a small part of his skin(not generalized), this could
be caused by a deep pyoderma(skin infection) or a localized dermatitis. If these do not go away I recommend you
have them reevaluated by his regular veterinarian or a veterinary dermatologist.
Although Spike's wounds may appear minor on the surface,there can be severe secondary soft tissue crushing
injuries, vessel compromise with associated local ischemia(loss of vascular supply to tissues),tearing of
underlying structures, contamination of deeper tissues and deep wounds that may involve body cavities. Dog bite
wounds are contaminated not only with hair and debris that was on your pet's body at the site of puncture but also
the bacteria present in the mouth of the other dog. There is risk for abscess formation, skin necrosis,and drains or
surgery may be required.
Spike's``rounds should only be cleaned with a warm wet clean towel,washcloth or dry gauze. Do not apply
hydrogen peroxide, antiseptics or any other topical products on his wound as these will interfere with wound
healing and could lead to complications such as deep wound infection.
Home care:
1. Please check Spike's wounds twice daily. If you notice any excessive redness,swelling, or discharge-
especially if discolored and/or malodorous, please contact your family veterinarian if available, otherwise call or
return to FLVRC.
0098
2.Please administer Spike's medications as directed below:
-Carprofen 75mg tabs: Give 1 tablet by mouth every 12 hours for 5 days as needed for pain.
This is a Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drug(?NSAID?) given for pain relief. This medication can
sometimes cause stomach upset, and in rare cases, it can cause liver or kidney problems. If your pet vomits,has
diarrhea, or stops eating while taking Meloxicam, STOP the medication and contact a veterinarian. DO NOT
substitute any over-the-counter medications without consulting a veterinarian. DO NOT give prednisone or other
steroids while your pet is taking carprofen. It is very important that this medication be dosed accurately. Please
ask if you have any questions regarding dosing.
** You may begin this medication when you get home.
-Clavamox 375mg tabs: Give 1 tablet by mouth every 12 hours for 14 days.
-Clavamox 125mg tabs: Give 1 tablet by mouth every 12 hours for 14 days.
This is an antibiotic. It can occasionally cause GI upset(Ioss of appetite, vomiting, or diarrhea). If this occurs,try
giving the medication with a small meal. If problems persist,please call us or your family veterinarian. It is
important that antibiotics be given as directed. Give the ENTIRE course of medication, even if your pet appears to
be better.
''* You may begin this medication when you get home.
3. As long as Spike is doing well(wound continues to heal,resolution of bruising and swelling, good appetite and
good energy level),please plan on following up with your family veterinarian by the end of the week. However, if
at any time you become concerned that he is not doing well and your family veterinarian is unavailable, please feel
free to call or return to FVRC.
4. In the next couple of days you can apply warm compresses on the injured area every 6 hours. To make a warm
compress you may place a damp cloth in the microwave for 10 seconds or so and then place it in a plastic bag.
Please ensure that it is not too hot. If it is too hot for your skin then it will be too hot for Spike.
5. Due to the location of Spike's wounds, we did not place an e-collar.Please make sure that Spike is not licking or
scratching at his wounds.
Activity:
1. STRICT REST for the next 2 weeks is VERY important.This means absolutely no running,jumping, stairs, or
playing with other animals.
?. Watch for signs of a worsening condition such as depression, lethargy,weakness, vomiting, diarrhea, difficulty
breathing, or any other concerning sign(s). Please call if any of these are noticed.You may need to return to
Florida Veterinary Referral Center or see your regular veterinarian as soon as possible.
Diet:
Normal diet. Provide plenty of fresh water and encourage to drink.
If you have any questions regarding" pike", please feel free to contact me personally.
Sinc ,
ay a Fell o,DVM
CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE*EMERGENCY MEDICINE e INTERNAL MEDICINE o ONCOLOGY \".•
fTh�
SURGERY/NEUROSURGERY a NEUROLOGY*RADIOLOGY =RADIOIODINE 1-131a,?;'7,.
0099
Dear fellow residents of The Lane,
On the afternoon of Monday, January 25th I was walking my boxer, Spike, on his
leash as many of you have seen me do almost daily since moving to The Lane. As my
dog and I reached the far end of the neighborhood, a large dark brown/black dog came
sprinting towards us growling and snarling from the driveway of 9047 The Lane. The
dogs sniffed each other and the unleashed dog seemed to be calming down as it
discovered Spike is very friendly and never aggressive as most of you who've met him
have already discovered. I was about to continue our walk back to our house when a
large, grey pit bull came sprinting towards us from the driveway of 9047, leapt at Spike
and both dogs began an attack on my dog. I was unable to stop these dogs as they
were all moving very quickly. I let go of my leash and Spike was able shake free of the
powerful jaws of the pit bull and started sprinting home. The pit bull gave chase for
about a quarter mile but Spike was able to outrun him. Once I got Spike home, I
immediately called 911 and filed a police report. Spike obtained multiple bite wounds to
his neck and back leg but is doing well on anti-inflammatory medications and antibiotics
to prevent infection after a trip to the veterinary hospital. A smaller, less athletic dog
wouldn't have been as lucky.
The reason I'm writing this letter is to prevent anyone from walking their dogs or
children down to the end of the street and running into a similar situation. Only 2
houses down there were 2 toddlers playing in their front yard while this attack was
occurring. I have also talked to at least 2 other dog owners who have had their small
dogs attacked by these dogs in a similar manner but were lucky enough to have
neighbors or lawn care workers around to chase the dogs away with rakes and brooms.
I encourage anyone who has had one of these experiences to contact the homeowner's
association and Domestic Animal Services. Our homeowner's association is doing
everything under their legal power by sending warning letters to correct this behavior
but the owners obviously are not taking this serious enough. I am not trying to cause
any conflict but I couldn't live with myself if someone's pet or child were seriously injured
or killed because people didn't know there were dangerous dogs who consistently get
out of their yards and harm other dogs. We have a unique, beautiful neighborhood
which is the envy of many other neighborhoods in Naples. Being attacked by dogs
should not be something we should have to be concerned with. I appreciate all of your
attention and hope this matter can be solved before any more animals are hurt and
before any children are injured, maimed or killed. If you don't have children or pets or
never walk down to the end of The Lane you may think this doesn't affect you.
However, if the local news finds out about this, our property values will suffer in the
short term. My family loves this neighborhood and is in it for the long haul. Feel free to
contact me with any questions or suggestions on how to solve this problem.
Sincerely, -
Chad Stine, MD
0030
Florida Veterinary Referral Center
9220 Estero Park Commons, Suite 7 - Estero, FL 33928 •
Tel: 239-992-8878 Fax: 239-992-0884
www.flvrc.com
INVOICE
- Client Information Patient Information
• Chad Stine "Spike"
9215 The Ln Boxer, male neutered
Naples, FL 34109 - Weight: 81.800 ibs, 37.104 kgs
Invoice Number: 108100 Date: 1/25/2016
x c 1
� yi .:y�_s � .,y" � ,y. e � m L.
.P:PIW :a4 Doctor IDescriptton F� 4 W41:7�, .,K0 . Quantity x GHarge
1/25/2016 1 CONSULT, EMERGENCY EXAM 1.00 96.50
1/25/2016 74 CLAVAMOX 375mg 28.00 117.15
1/25/2016 74 CLAVAMOX 125mg 28.00 55.17
1/25/2016 74 CARPROFEN -GENERIC 75MG TABLETS 10.00 16.49
1/25/2016 74 READY FOR DISCHARGE 1.00 0.00 -
1/25/2016 74 Payment-American Express 1.00 285.31
Previous Balance: 0.00
Subtotal: 285.31
Sales.Tax: 0.00
• - Payments: 285.31
Discounts: 0.00
Ending Balance: 0.00
Current:. 0.00 Over 30: 0.00 Over 60: 0.00 Over 90: 0.00 Over 120:
0.00
Spike's next appointment is at am / pm.
Thank you for trusting us with your pet's care. If you have any questions or concerns, please give our
office a call any time.
1/25/2016
0031 •
Activity Report with Photos
Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type:
A16-004356-1 INV/BITE ANIM 08/16/16 12:31 PM A8HRS 1 DOG
Activity Address: Geo Code: Jurisdiction:
9047 THE LN , NAPLES 2 COLLIER
Activity Comment:
SIG 31 BRN PIT BUL ATTACKED THE CALLERS 8 YEAR OLD LEASHED MALTESE NAMED TRIXIE
Owner Information:
Caller Information:
DOROTHY KRAMER, (239) 248-6090 JENNIFER DIPASCALE, (239) 919-2786
9126 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109 9047 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109
P130149 P054862
Animal Information:
A189259 - NALA - SPAYED, BLUE, AMERICAN STAFF
Officer: Call Taker: Result Codes:
P999101 KUBICSEK NICK 2 MC 1 RPRT
Dispatch Date: Working Date: Complete Date: Response Time:
08/17/16 07:11 AM 08/17/16 11:25 AM 08/17/16 12:09 PM 22:54
0
0
Print Date: 10/7/2016
Activity Number: Activity Type: Activity Date: Priority: Total Animals: Animal Type:
A16-004356-2 ASSIST/PUBLIC 08/16/16 12:31 PM A8HRS 1 DOG
Activity Address: Geo Code: Jurisdiction:
9126 THE LN , NAPLES 2 COLLIER
Activity Comment:
MEET WITH CALLER AND THEIR DOG WALKER
Caller Information:
DOROTHY KRAMER, (239) 248-6090
9126 THE LN , NAPLES FL 34109
P130149
Officer: Call Taker: Result Codes:
P999101 KUBICSEK NICK 2 MC 1 RPRT
Dispatch Date: Working Date: Complete Date: Response Time:
08/17/16 07:11 AM 08/17/16 11:25 AM 08/17/16 12:10 PM 22:54
O fl v Print Date: 10/7/2016
V
Memo:
08/16/2016 08/16/16 At around 12:15 pm today an employee of the dog owner named Gloria Laverge was
walking thier leahsed maltese and their leashed Havnese on the side walk near the end of the
street. The sig 31 brown pit bull ran out of its owners yard and attacked the maltese. Gloria told me
that she did not see anyone from 9047 The Ln during or after the attack. She said when the attack
happend she reached down and picked up the maltese and ran back to the dog owners home.
Dorothy Kramer said thet her husband is currently on the way to Old Naples Vet with their injured
dog. She said the dog suffered two bites to the right and was bleeding. Dorothy also said that they
knew this dog had a history of aggression, so they never walked their dog near the dog owners end
off the street. She said she was recently told that the HOA had made them get rid of the brown pit
bull and that was the only reason why their dogs were being walked on that end of the street.
102/NE
08/16/2016 8/16/16 15:05
Caller, victim dog owner, Dorothy Kramer, called to update that her dog has to have surgery, and
will need to go under anesthesia, because she sustained a deep puncture from the incident. Ms.
Kramer also stated that the HOA has gotten their lawyer involved because the attacking dog owner's
have gotten "their last warning".
125/KL
08/17/2016 08/17/16 11:56:
Met with dog owner Dorothy and she showed me the pictures of the attack and will e-mail them to
me, I left affidavits for her dog walker to fill out.
Went to the attacking dog owners home and talked to Joe the husband of the dog owner and he
said his dog were not outside yesterday and that he was not at home and he keeps them crated
when he is not home, he showed me the dog and I tried to take a picture and it was blurred the dog
would not stay still, went over DD protocal if this turns into a DD investigation.
101/BK
08/24/2016 8/24/16 - Affidavits received from witness, Gloria Laverde and dog owners, Dorothy and Reto
Kramer.
Ms. Laverde stated she was out for a walk with the Kramer's dogs, "Missy" and "Trixie" when a
brown pit bull type dog approached and attacked "Trixie". She was able to separate the dogs and
the pit bull ran back to its home. Ms. Laverde took both dogs back home and informed the Kramers
about the incident.
Mr. and Mrs. Kramer did not witness the incident, but stated Ms. Laverde came back from the walk
with "Trixie" in her arms and informed them she had been attacked while out on-a walk. "Trixie"
was taken to the vet for treatment.
138/DG
0 0
3
4 Print Date: 10/7/2016
Photos:
Whet deem the.r.Pr" llS
look!Mane
. .vJs t
a(a). nww.d In u,e epeunc Inamn u.re cornw.t no Carl satpment for.
I
0 r�eoai(i)na nd c..lr C ae(/el.nant ce�or n e,:non ell the otnpr mN me
.�. __tom✓ii st IED.EtJ
:otzer or ow...nun.Tina rower.onnnag enc..env ern sou an b.-.
nn nen
Vernonend
where did eI heptagTh.Is where you tall your wtory. PI•oca ell in all hinnks with on,
• e .....e
E
bled on No at VOL( acevocl.mpleWithout the lnrermetlon,enlmalSorvlpec Cannot pursue further
ecklnLensensor
yen..
beefier.or tncldent: AC r.or roe .r-}rr.f rya =toy,'riot ion e,
exAer oew or Ineleene: /-#I+y/te a a;G EXACT nm.or modem /1:/
Taff us hat
In
uc w n0 will
a nor=tory a pop
puned, u tl 'he, u Poe.
toner
Oe. ry=e.
nplae ee mnhovepboon w the a m•I p what v erect rye�uao fronret
T"'%•'
o type, lm
et whet you ave ob .van.and I ro co
e noly not aemlbele In urt, Pleaseprint clocr y
l;/nr,'a s�.l L �i v�-e/no71-/ yti.• w.r14
r ilia a,s' A ; < a.nr- T;, /- fe.ff /6.-th A'
G/ .2-49.0 oc/sr
..-,�./I a 71-r<-n nfc f�a/c"..l7 ./ rr. 3 2e
0 G✓44i' f r. G/d'soP r•-d.rt. u t o-�/J„2 Gra Ir c' i n/ Ti }c/! S.
c4b1- •cs-lctA e Ana Ea'e 04,
4.4/O✓Y; Cc rto •S S'fl,f 7h' f
zi2
Photos:
r /<r a r hoe-0r ii,c,� s. iJs 7p.0
Ailis ✓c - /or•o -cam on /Yx
.)%.r A:,fl /'><m•n -?.kr�. - ..,..�us /-rtot i i J0LC
410 a -74o 1,4.vs< s L z- 1'( ;A, dP;4 k ji_.ten.
QTre
.-'Ci c,s Qr
c..49 j,r!' n,!1” %rmSe,r Aell 0-Y Sn,re.d7 TZ . /�<••�f
�l"y�._st vr/r p/dam -f. ( 7 :dk u ri 0 "74-,
7-r`an't elnany -A-rt'�r/ SI
,""e. 's. -,/ p �,e•. n 7/+te C n/c.
/c 00 et* 1`y. F d>C// 4+as rasa 7-/7irt i�c 1
//�7e_ 40c/-, -4e L� e.AP c. . /��r.r /4,r/te�e./.f/,
7‘ l'e TUC,n f <I is rre U/fc y
p.nyery,)a .pro c oft neo a road the toreoo n afro,sok or Complaint an t •
slag tel. r Amant Dote e
Sworn
red)n • b•erlbe
ud burore me this�l day ..4.2:91.0•..?
l•
mand
rlu .r who 0 parayknown to ee
pr. rr� r>G� R/c r.iL/•.>/a 7.!/L/I
tion.
Mire Olu6lN:Jerry, or Morloa Notary Sts =
S
na,"pJ S
Natery m (prl d) /
/7. 3c /5 "AZ =..
Gemmlvelon expires
)
•
Print Date: 10/7/2016
r-
0 0 3
Photos:
a 7 � /,de-;. o urn rV7,as
st o1 4e}rI on/ ince
o
7
4..ir] cvc/,E r-n T-�e �igIi 7-awoAds
e ! ,
iq/i L�i S W a. n G� D r-
z (-e-er .
�• <(,n...•[ >.,I� e' iay,•1.Jr L✓p/,Gr ri
f)a :ceea
s /eat' 4-4; f //ILeda /e:e
Jam/ �/-�r, 7'z•rra� r,., o.. •
•
Photos:
Colli or CountyMom esti C Animal Sort,ICC S
7610 Davis 011.4., rapl s, L /235-2s2.-73115>
Statement or Affl.evlt or Ce plalnc Porn,
Sorvicos -sr ea
OT occur
Generallyon ,Socha.,Olfl.sr Is present. n Un.cerllier County Ceornerrrecnor,Dom se.Aroma,Services ret tele acUun
rePartl n0 a vlolauon,nether the tar or two resident.mus-r w tnn�*rM mcicioc fa).v
This Allltlavlt of Cern...Int.Int er Statement.when eernnlate4 v come
ntecan
n o ry e t It c is hep nrubwb+s c s1.fa ud1,Www,r
Sweiateenervices r k pl ee,s This
t Y..Cm.tnorm Is o bv4'sl ter nnentol
nae A
Serve..isSwL to a n respond ter, t Come....n. 1 Services warren ten
s SL*recent t+ a bast e1 your knew) tl0•'.one return.r e
(10)caws of the Incltlanl
Complaint PIM
Ob Icbamaaletotl b pt, I Lf el we fnr•n.a
*neon,that oft infe•maoen li +ndv4ve area Cerract. V er ea. enc rat,ew .v cam e
Last loom.. r.ri a_ riot name. l•I.,.• ,
5traatAtl4ress.r;. i 1g I'
sure: a _ , --••:1 r•a -.._
dame TOloetctaI ,) J1•• rr . Werk Teleohenv: _ - .)14 -f•t
mal owner
We nose you to encore a o m
muce •re _ - ..,TM
write
certain.
etlenf therm m own.m 4 Is uo n nesru lorsernorroan cent you co L If V meencu ablauKnt the awn s
lnfern,rLlon,er if too animal vvon en vwne,speak with Vaur nvlOnbars[e W suer.
ova Nemo, _ ast Nam..
Coma Telrphona: _ work Telane.ona
When is the owner normally horn*.
Where dice you oetaln this Ineermstlen7 _-.. .. .. _-
•
•
Print Date: 10/7/2016
00 Or6
Photos:
What clava c Irlaa•
To t vales.•• u:oble a rid ouch tho
correct anima/Co).n
ae
Only 1involved In ma uraemic•melaena you are Complete..[Oa Stota.[om r.•r.
utoro soma(taste memo
•
is for
• Cole Int/Ilona no the dominant color forst_then aro rho armor co,e.v
sow Nano
•
Th cWhen
o ' Ery. ro
• emI•.arorma[lan. Xanmecsarv�eau canna rurrur fu nl•or
actlen. Hor ora•oma rxam Ioat
omat
TLocation or Incident a'r••m.J!, I. 1,r.- _!_.J I'.., 4r'l i rI(c 1<f le
Dote or,nceloro,r.Y I . Or f(. EXACT rima or lna.Can - .m.
Tan u what
In Emla• will w aaara
o•e w_ _ eOnly w vol i
about m say e
he moat
or(Yee.
her whet VOW horn au.e.,...a.and.•..Hare y ,ate aa.ore in cm., tido•:
Photos:
•
Collier county Domestic Anlmsl Services
Seto OOYI•slvs.,w ,et_ /sae-zal-4as7
OCOO•rfient or A/IL•vlt of Compbine Porn,
e:eon: ort.:nero m;oc: s:.r...: t.k ren
rao•rinIng a wereeen,row.,m.Officer or two•o..eonts MUST wrt the 1ncb.ntt.1.
•Com Olarnt or St ktomenc,w n Ofncer t
o Coolies.that a
k ia.,unfit• of tn.u Thu 1ST tarn utso rre
eI your knewr.ee.,anonto .r to oem..u.nn.m.I S.rwC.,w.cn.n Cert
(te) ur neons.
doy.of Cm.inc.eana.
Campl•1nt Nt A\C.-C70..'-t"'nS‘•
Tellu .bout TOIJI
This portion Is to Oe ep b pv vow.
onaneatly Or ryes. dine review the Complete. form to
snaur•that all ttnrermatlw Is innlue.0 and Correct• ec++
•
ut Nem.. '-cNoma:.-72.•,.o\h Nt a,,,___.
Street Synclracsi O tZ
ccv: .J.` \-" 2112: Vtl�/C.1
•
Moura Tolephen•. M n.v..._. ♦C. wen.T•I.ehun.. _
Tot.us ob... mol Owner
y [no animal owner as you know. Den,guano,ton
ew
t conll+ o ITrrf. eo he own 1
lnforrnaeen.or thin
enlm.l omen s on owner, w urn fib O er,to be worn,
Last Noma: ^i7.�es- .r r.. (" ♦.1st _�r•(2'/ NI
Street AO rscs �f.ti7 qtr r__`l,.,,VV ._,.
City: \+1 r. ,\c! . Stat..
Mon.Tal We.Tet •
when 1di cn•owner normally home.
wh.r.etd yew obtain thin tnlamtaaena :tet .._ U,,�.-_AV, o .
•
Photos:
•
wl..e a two. n.oL.ee.n the w.uuc.neuro ve...r.cem12l.nnb n..statem.na ror.
More
.rs a(,)n . Cyber./
a e.)�.nt carer ns•_.n.II thr eth.r Ne e. ._
•
•
Winer.o
M•r.:r:ote...masa. •theist m.+germ.nen.nntma s.rwt..t....tet 12 h.nner
rna
a.ecarlen of tncleentl,•a is�.� �'-.� ", tin mer Inpa��.
EXACT odic.et tnoe•nr. T b:%IC u<'t ere ACTn O•
Tell tae. ♦oeen ma inforrnmien you sone
nitiout WINK. one,
U absorb... Only weste nibeut cns mow
Mot. . dine lly a e12.•..ree, n diof barnIuo?
t whoa yee In<oyn. ole...aunt=...n.
er Hoa. • a t-�[ ._-.\[i._CV —" .., 1- \•_•t4 t _
1- ..k,r•..-t,�-.-1 \ ......_..tea , .a\-y__.
•
•
•
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0038
•
•
•
•
•
Photos:
•
�.�...,.� - ... c • • .,C.. r.,"
�..m _ A
c • -_�
•
.,,..7.y s.--.• —� �:s:sl _�-PN
•
•
v.nurv.f a.. woe re.oern
.n. e. v a.'„T i:.--e rn
.+ �i. of
aae.ara sow. n
a au.. eS/ / 1 G•
sio.,.•ura � oraF
._..
Data
.a'&o(or.^KYaaa)e rw�e ermaa eororo..a rw. oa
�vao v
.roa^'-z.,eor
DC- —
A.
rv.sraorW .e.
Notary Stamp
•
Try I! L¢mPOS
Notary
- - Irpt
J, E.,,/
�e o/ s
•
•
•
•
Print Date: 10/7/2016
0 039
Collier County Domestic Animal Services
7610 Davis Blvd., Naples, FL 34104 / 239-252-7387
Statement or Affidavit of Complaint Form
Generally, violations of the Collier County Domestic Animal Services Ordinance do not occur when
an Animal Services Officer is present. For an Officer or Domestic Animal Services to take action
regarding a violation, either the Officer or two residents MUST witness the incident(s).
This Affidavit of Complaint or Statement, when completed by a witness provides the documentation
necessary for an action to be taken. It establishes probable cause for an Officer to believe that a
violation took place, and the nature of the violation. This Statement form is essential for Animal
Services to pursue further action in reference to the violations you have described. For Animal
Services to efficiently respond to your needs, we ask that you print, review and carefully complete
this Statement to the best of your knowledge, and return it to Domestic Animal Services within ten
(10) days of the incident.
Complaint No: 41(47 ' �,s"
Tell us about YOU!
This portion is to be completed by you, and about you. We need to know your full name, address,
and various other information. Pleaseprint neatly or type, and review the completed form to
ensure that all information is included and correct.
Last Name. cr�JF � �� First Name: �. (C7 ✓/c� MI �t __
Street Address: C l�'�'l �} ( fJOi H
City: 1�t i:)) State: �'fr-1 Zip: 134/067Home Telephone: `1 J 73 ftp Work Telephone: r%ori °� — L(_? _c'0
Tell us about the animal owner
We need you to record as much information about the animal owner as you know. Don't guess, be
certain. If there is some information that you do not know, simply write "unknown". The
information most needed is the animal owner's address. If you are uncertain about the owner's
information, or if the animal even has an owner, speak with your neighbors to be sure.
Last Name: First Name: MI
Street Address:
City: State: Zip:
Home Telephone: Work Telephone:
When is the owner normally home:
Where did you obtain this information?
0040
What does the animal look like?
To take action, Animal Services needs to be as certain as possible that we are dealing with the
correct animal(s). Please record as much and as accurate a description of each animal as possible.
Only list animals that were involved in the specific incident you are completing this Statement for.
Here are some basic rules:
• Breed is for species as well as the animal's specific breed
• Color: Indicate the dominant color first, then all the other colors
Breed(s) Color(s) Sex Name
•
* If you are uncertain about the breed of the animal. The animal control officer may be able to assist you with determining
the breed based on your description.
When and where did it happen?
This is where you tell your story. Please fill in all blanks with EXACT time, date, and location,
based on what YOU observed. Without this information, Animal Services cannot pursue further
action. Here are some examples:
Location: In street in front of 1212 Smith St.
In my back yard at 2121 Smith St.
Time: 1:30 p.m.
4_ )1 -, � (� s
c,C- u s �,� J�YE p.)01--() ClOgl7 1z� 1-0/7e._1-0/7e._Location of Incident: On -.3c.(Jo�h,
EXACT Date of Incident:CV- IC0-IG)C EXACT Time of Incident 1-." 1,i a.m.jp J
Tell us what happened.
In this section you will write a brief story of what happened, based on the information you gave
about WHEN and WHERE it happened, and what YOU observed. Only write about the most
recent occurrence. Previous occurrences are not relevant. DO NOT write about hearsay or other
conflicts there have been with the animal owner. Hearsay is what you have heard from other
people, not what you have observed, and is generally not admissible in court. Please print clearly
or type.
CAJ. (_�6 v- ? � (-1 f `'ice 4Y Cl)11 C,f (A0 f S 1 16 6 C1-)24i t 'i X 1 L ci O
FC- c•1U _ F.,�I�SY Js U 10 Ib �rcavone..5i�. LVI1 ; i7 IQ, � ecar5 L�i (2:19
1
OW I ,/tyt( is cct ei Ib F �a �>��e uA'tO 15 S' ` C-errs DEcac)p - We
�LC 10_06.e. LI )10Ofl } ( VJ` CIO EUl r ugly ) C ►14 4U01ec] [O C
R u.)r1 Ci f)1 c s 6(11 e 6-1-Ye.e f .) (1,-)
�'1(� t�'1t Sic�QW i �� l
s �tl�. . � � �� �t5 � s;-lu� �y b1't1t�.;n f�t� ��I I cul
2
0041
•
oflt"h t.c ic1Y9e 6I,2E4 do") DCyG.5fl -3 t--a-ee7- (1 Jif e- k.C))71 P_
g047 -Hole tone , ov(j) -t Bo/ ycl c
11\)�e. I • WQQS Luc-4 ��)�`�y ��1u� y) Xl e , O)id �t-t�> 1-C'c1
It !
q �t L i ri 9 I Y i Y c''✓ .
r tYt�c c �� �-bu cIo �� �YiXi.e G� polti?�c vii Oke. lea��i
�
c7 eF - L-33ca� . ��s J c►� �a 5 i i1 t,i 11 y 904
(k no\ 1)0m 11e i «u1 (100 ±)*J otec 43fl \DC,\ "(.(•))11..C. •
J
YIet ' Loa e. wkd `51/1.( 67)-1
on r,� ��> f o>>La ,�� y (-,;-; m 3 '%o I i —0 -{ ru. n u
} i `
Ik w Y -0Y o 1,u, • .)I ,► 1 e 6 w�c. `1— L�c.1 J ; 1 Lci
46_ K.)uln ys 00(1::. Y 1X1 4o 1171.(i \Jct .
"Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Complaint and the
facts stated, in it are true." 1
/-'G2.64) - /C, ,.c,u,c .< . - O S 6 -- G
Signature of Affiant Date
Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this C9 day of '��15 , 20 1 �,
by 6/0/1-61 L-t i e i do , who is ❑ personally known to me, or
&pies prod Pt- 03)`73 (vOi7O as identification.
/(
( ' atu .Kotary, State of Florida Notary Stamp
622.trip
0s
7AUA CAMPOS
Notary's name (printed) ` .� NotaryPut lt ,state of Fbrda
'� Commissronb FF 232027
11;
i,{y comm.expires June 17,2019
June 17. ao j
Commission Expires
3
0042
Collier County Domestic Animal Services
7610 Davis Blvd., Naples, FL 34104 / 239-252-7387
Statement or Affidavit of Complaint Form
Generally, violations of the Collier County Domestic Animal Services Ordinance do not occur when
an Animal Services Officer is present. For an Officer or Domestic Animal Services to take action
regarding a violation, either the Officer or two residents MUST witness the incident(s).
This Affidavit of Complaint or Statement, when completed by a witness provides the documentation
necessary for an action to be taken. It establishes probable cause for an Officer to believe that a
violation took place, and the nature of the violation. This Statement form is essential for Animal
Services to pursue further action in reference to the violations you have described. For Animal
Services to efficiently respond to your needs, we ask that you print, review and carefully complete
this Statement to the best of your knowledge, and return it to Domestic Animal Services within ten
(10) days of the Incident.
Complaint No: , /r� --.0t0 '7 2 (�(3
Tell us about YOU!
This portion is to be completed by you, and about you. We need to know your full name, address,
and various other information. Please print neatly or type, and review the completed form to
ensure that all information is included and correct.
Last Name: ('CAin(' r First Name MI L.,
Street Address: qi,..i i he La el e
City: 4 1 t°.s State: /' L . Zip: c3 C-// 0 q
Home Telep one: C41_(((Telephone: . d U
Tell us about the animal owner
We need you to record as much information about the animal owner as you know. Don't guess, be
certain. If there is some information that you do not know, simply write "unknown". The
information most needed is the animal owner's address. If you are uncertain about the owner's
information, or,if theimal even has an owner, speak with your neighbors to be sure.
Last Name: < )f e_dt l e 5
First Name: <Tr 0 E' v MI
Street Address: goy l e L c ii
City: 1 )1 e S State: f Zip: pelf 0
Home Telep one: Work Telephone: �3 P .6'S P/Z7
4 l on e.1,.
Y
When is the owner normally home:
Where did you obtain this information? �l 3 ,I ) at t---0( U-C C�e //-1°
(4)C. ,:7 f z_C.?v oc�".S 4 7,,--
i
0 0 43
What does the animal look like?
To take action, Animal Services needs to be as certain as possible that we are dealing with the
correct animal(s). Please record as much and as accurate a description of each animal as possible.
Only list animals that were involved in the specific incident you are completing this Statement for.
Here are some basic rules:
Breed is for species as well as the animal's specific breed
• Color: Indicate the dominant color first, then all the other colors
Breed(s) Color(s) Sex Name
Jo, .1:- rD n
•
* If you are uncertain about the breed of the animal. The animal control officer may be able to assist you with determining
the breed based on your description.
When and where did it happen?
This is where you tell your story. Please fill in all blanks with EXACT time, date, and location,
based on what YOU observed. Without this information, Animal Services cannot pursue further
action. Here are some examples:
Location: In street in front of 1212 Smith St.
In my back yard at 2121 Smith St.
Time: 1:30 p.m.
Location of Incident: - F C(`D SS (1�f cP --(1):v -1061') [h� ( ad7�1 I �5 ,� - 37(
EXACT Date of Incident: All ip ;,- f EXACT Time of Incident Ie)":/-c a.m./
Tell us what happened.
In this section you will write a brief story of what happened, based on the information you gave
about WHEN and WHERE it happened, and what YOU observed. Only write about the most
recent occurrence. Previous occurrences are not relevant. DO NOT write about hearsay or other
conflicts there have been with the animal owner. Hearsay is what you have heard from other
people, not what you have observed, and is generally not admissible in court. Please print clearly
or type.
•
D v1 CA) S Me c 1 1 1 k 1 oil 4 1 vsr /642, cif 6, 4(
e r l (` tLe i n 4 T�(( (�7. vile._ howl (1)1' / � k r zje..?
( ovlc SPP 4l'00d , )0Thr ref t /r) i i rk S
i, q ht' vim/ e id Z-4 // r a/0 ri `S 517it
• 2
0044
hL , J; eiv
ler ,uf oire rw�i- / 72 (/ ! 5 Lf , a Of) < c-4-2111-;-' J74.
c--)r . Ail n e f n . / I-1 k 1 i a/70Q i 1- ['Ai j e)--s; 7 / /i X(
1,001) - ISI 4b t- /. M/fit/ ` Z',4 e7W 1
Aq S i /Zl tiD5e' 9,c- 1.)e iN,s- "'W /1, x(2 Sin e. ,700 Qom
i Cly o e r 00---1- 4 rms'e it- , ��/)e u-~e 4 r / /Lt P /1 _,e../_.),__
i�1 oi, - q ► f 0C6c --f-to, 4s. / e k--( J wee- 71d
1/Le 17 U St' 4 04) r( i LS I. 1(' /oYe (it l S C 7 --e�C 0 u r c-!I�i/`E
--r4 m :i r/ erns-lna //�7 .�/�i', a evol ,� b��=,f iiu _;fie/Ie
12,111( dtiLe ki),)(�1 d l(.0 e �rt`.. ^ l,A274-7/d fi 2) ,-s ,, p /✓U!/
-fir mirnf ti7 '4e k?Sr 4<1S Zi/i0 6e D0 t i6) (--47(.2e . A
I)e i 1601- -t7 ld os- l al— t o Pil A _f ire 6'Y)cD(Ae 1))/h f _.t
/ID n 1 v(14,4 q7L 9Dtr) e &i)ef AD Der, 44s 70r/i ��� cc)
Ant 1 o e -{-7-0 , b 7k e i-v.)ice %i-e U.)a at) 6),e(--- lr v�
4' �l>C —7
"Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Complaint and the
facts stated in it are true." Al1 1t1 // - Aa (1, -2.076
Signature f Affiant Date i
i
Sworn i (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this day of Alt/St , 20 /G',
by l)or1)-fh Li g r /Y1-e , who is Li personally known to me, or
( 'Has pro ced DL- 14/ -( J 6 7 7/E D as identification.
tgtur of etary, State of Florida Notary Stamp
/ail'Ct a/71 p 0 S .. _ . . __—_
Notary's name (printed) TAUACAMPOS
Notary Public,State of Florida
>
x.--n
E,, Commission#FF 232027
J&il e /7t c -C) / Cj arm., h!y comm.wires June 17,2019
Commission Expires 1
3
0045
U o r- d5 ko de l e fT 01 0 (J r i -/- r 41 k
7 , . .
ree p.0- o, e.A f s 4.-1-e' i 2 bi-e , ,,1 j,„1/re,,kv ,,--6.,,,,,
D A,..,ed.e, a9q K )--- e ri .iri 7`—zfcoa as
reg9Q1-e // ' W I C� e Civ s� /�e ��� �e fS ‘.c>q� n
f e J f #60// 11) 6),41-e, igi:WA 4 4: `i
U �ir f-- -
•
- Al 0--{ /4 / (4 r I-ce I 1 yl 4 ZUP//(c
/-a i--e,
(I (-f a 1 v 1 fb e r7 _/5 ,1 c e u/1 n -47 047
0) • i &-f"
/pi* &// ç ()e 6.- e-f v 11
? s /eAs4 ,c- /( /1'7,4_41 Aeie 2"4 >e Z44 e .
�i C Is 6610 3 4 ,'e ei) l m(; Z-//7 �' v ,�
7?''' ,? i S. zt)i / c
, I-)
ef a //3 1Lo 62 ,1 ,-eif)
//i
i i
,
j
i
00413
• • }
Collier County Domestic Animal Services
7610 Davis Blvd., Naples, FL 34104 / 239-252-7387
Statement or Affidavit of Complaint Form
Generally, violations of the Collier County Domestic Animal Services Ordinance do not occur when
an Animal Services Officer is present. For an Officer or Domestic Animal Services to take action
regarding a violation, either the Officer or two residents MUST witness the incident(s).
This Affidavit of Complaint or Statement, when completed by a witness provides the documentation
necessary for an action to be taken. It establishes probable cause for an Officer to believe that a
violation took place, and the nature of the violation. This Statement form is essential for Animal
Services to pursue further action in reference to the violations you have described. For Animal
Services to efficiently respond to your needs, we ask that you print, review and carefully complete
this Statement to the best of your knowledge, and return it to Domestic Animal Services within ten
(10) days of the incident.
Complaint No: A\ 6,- Oc 356
Tell us about YOU!
This portion is to be completed by you, and about you. We need to know your full name, address,
and various other information. Please print neatly or type, and review the completed form to
ensure that all information is included and correct.
Last Name: KC DC7 First Name: c---(2-0_,Vc> MI S
Street Address: ``—
City: � \�5 State: Zip: 0'1
Home Telephone: 23')2(g L--"D) l S Work Telephone:
Tell us about the animal owner
We need you to record as much information about the animal owner as you know. Don't guess, be
certain. If there is some information that you do not know, simply write "unknown". The
information most needed is the animal owner's address. If you are uncertain about the owner's
information, or if the animal even has an owner, speak with your neighbors to be sure.
Last Name: /1:7', e First Name: J o / MI
Street Address: C:\ e_
City: State: 1 Zip: 0 `-'1
Home Telephone: Work Telephone:
When is the owner normally home:
Where did you obtain this information? (_-�\rs \(,._.
0047
What does the animal look like?
To take action, Animal Services needs to be as certain as possible that we are dealing with the
correct animal(s). Please record as much and as accurate a description of each animal as possible.
Only list animals that were involved in the specific incident you are completing this Statement for.
Here are some basic-rules:
• Breed is for species as well as the animal's specific breed
• Color: Indicate the dominant color first, then all the other colors
Breed(s) Color(s) Sex Name
� k (.)\\
If you are uncertain about the breed of the animal. The animal control officer may be able to assist you with determining
the breed based on your description.
When and where did it happen?
This is where you tell your story. Please fill in all blanks with EXACT time, date, and location,
based on what YOU, observed. Without this information, Animal Services cannot pursue further
action. Here are some examples:
Location: In street in front of 1212 Smith St.
In my back yard at 2121 Smith St.
Time: 1:30 p.m.,
Location of Incident: Ac- tr ,-�S5 _A\r1< .1.,...c,r2v--e-\ "AOe--
EXACT Date of Incident: 5s14(; ) ( EXACT Time of Incident \-. '. \S a.m./p.m.
Tell us what happened.
In this section you will write a brief story of what happened, based on the information you gave
about WHEN and WHERE it happened, and what YOU observed. Only write about the most
recent occurrence. Previous occurrences are not relevant. DO NOT write about hearsay or other
conflicts there have been with the animal owner. Hearsay is what you have heard from other
people, not what you have observed, and is generally not admissible in court, Please print clearly
or type.
•
O Li< (7)0 –� �,�\�.�� C—tcik �� c om e_ \D -v_,- •
c)-\k C� \Si\� 55y Cvn c1 y ��
C� r >c �A\\ CSC �rL , ^��?G r},,\�� Gc�.1CS ?<<L
�1 n 8
r\ w\-1 C vL` c r�, (�cj�Cce 0--"Th C�
2ve_f G c)<\r,r, 1 C7VkC S�
- a Y1 G e_- Cmc C2,\
C C I k C-c-PCJ. S\''\
' , P/v"b if...oy S V c �r� G- c�� "N11 e_ cw cc-5
‘c'_ vo \.)a_
Ci�V 1 8 / .
"Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Complaint and the
facts stated in it are true."
/2-
Signature
2 Signature of Affiant // Date
Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this ti day of Aub" Uts.f , 20 ) ,
by jR.-ef U r J1 ' , who is n personally known to me, or
�tlas pr••- -d Pt- DLit g- USe...-1a-OG'-7c9 `tg v as identification.
•S - . - • rotary, State of Florida I Notary Stamp
Gt-1( (A- Ca('Yl7) 0-5 6 0
Notary's name (printed) y TALtACAMPOS
Notary Public,State of Florida
`�' Commissior,;r FF 232027
(J y l` ,� o/ /� w,; My comm.expires June 17,2019
Commission Expires - ,� `7
3
i0 4�
1
"".'"Z
"" 54t9-'','-'2`
ig '.L y .«
r. a
" Si .:r�Y' +�+". $ . iRf �,t �," 's' M ;r; . 04,
Y:ii 'S x,y fit, }3 -
f v
. itA.',---- - --.„_ - - ..- -- _' - -
ay Y ' $
i
11
'
i •
•
•
. i b
104k
1 i
•t
•
1F ;j
• i
u
{
.
•
0050
J� �E� ^y
•
•
•
lb
•
•
•
•
,.y •
•
6 ,�2 ' .T
' •
yid
,,r,
y'
S
7, ''..t'..;4 ..-' -..-X‘...''T.;';g...,,',.-''41*:,.'':".tt;' ' '
r-
4 #
a
q
d�
i
o t: ' „ 'yam >: .-/ xse _ ., ..,..t-':»!,',' i :aIT d i'6C S i 7 _; �'° 4t} �t �L. rot` 4 1 1jrs ..,,-;'':--A'
\ . 4
k
} i{S ./r--i' kE X6: ". & 1�
' '._
N
� i
0051rp
'`Alf,t_k°,1-•„7-p-4.-
• i
4-,-4
- 1
.' ' ...-....•.-4;:t.,:**"1141eimic.w`...'-•.'-';•• -••••,:-•44.-',1j•
., e, ,, ,... . ,..._... , i ..
. ...
, ; A •-1
'-4 -;-*1.4.•4*
' I
.i.
•
- ,
I ,
,.
'L •I
: •!.' .
, '•
'''. -,';'•4:'
.,... ...
...• *, i„.
.....„., :, .____ •
. !.
„ -
'..,*4-,• , '4;"'.:4
:.;ci
. •441' . ' - 1 '
;; , •44
' -.%
- F,..
- .•.4 I
•,41p.-- i •.., -1, _
._-::::r•11:. -7:,.. '_,•,4
,••,,1-1,,..,e,, 1:'•?' v:. '
r
...14‘)
. .-,
‘`..,....t,6-!,,, ,,•
,
4,04(wl"r: 7
- - T.,-,:,,,,,,- . - -• ,. - . - ,‘.-..'-.. ...iii '
-7••4,,-f''k-_,t4:•,---•ft,"_!'-- - - . - - - -- , -•-._ "• - , , _ .41k, 7A,,,gr, -
...
. ,
=
0
' • —"11110g1111,11011011-;','7
l''' .,,,,Z,,,...-,-,:.' , _ IP. , . ,,.•t:;.-`..,,
-..s
t•-;,;:i- 1,,. ',''P',:.:;.1,,$ :.'!:',.144';'N- " ' .
i •
1 '.- . -, _ , ,•-•,,.,,4-->-,,•-• -
'I- titi
E Ilil0f, ' 7' ' ' ''''''''''• '-'4*"..:'. l'
,,.. A..- '''v'r.,'*,,f,,V410k._ '••
;‘,,`.,.. • ,, .e 44,,:,,,t;,:u 4,-;,,,
1 ', ito70714./' ";' ' 0
:::::,,fv,..;:,al.;
,...i,„. , „,, '-:,17,.4...-•,:-.,.•- ty..
•
it-,*---,1•‘: • • it . , ,
. . _ .,
co