VB MSTU Agenda 01/05/2017 VaNda,8i81 Saadi M.S.7./1.
Advisory Committee
3299 East Tamiami Trail Suite 103
*7 Naples,Naples, FL 34112
JANUARY 5, 2017 2:00 P.M.
Claussen Family Center at St.John's Church
625 111TH Ave.,Naples,FL
I. Call to order
II. Attendance
Advisory committee Bill Sjostrom—Vice Chairman(11/13/2020)
Bruce Forman(11/13/2019)
Mark Weber(11/13/2017)
Gabriella R. Miyamoto(11/13/2019)
William Harris(11/13/2020)
Staff Harry Sells—Project Manager
Landscape Robert Kindelan-CLM
Construction Ray Benza-Hole Montes
Dale Slabaugh, Landscape Architect
III. Approval of agenda
IV. Approval of the minutes of November 3, 2016
Meeting of December 1,2016 Canceled,Lack of Quorum.
V. Welcome to Bill Sjostrom and William Harris, newly nominated members
VI. Election of Officers
VII. Landscape Report,Robert Kindelan,Commercial Land Maintenance
VI Project Manager Report,Harry Sells
A. Budget report for 1/5/2017
B. General status of burial project
C. CenturyLink network by ElectriCom
D. Phase IV status.
E. Tree Removal Oak to Palm 7 trees
VII. Old Business
A. Landscape Design Connor Park,Dale Slabaugh
VIII. New Business
IX. Member Comment
X. Public comment
XI. Adjourn
NEXT MEETING DATE: FEBRUARY 2,2017
Claussen Family Center at St.John's Church
625 111TH Ave.,Naples,FL
Vaudar6ISt Saadi .htS.T.u.
IAdvisory Cosolsoiittaa
3299 East Tamiami Trail Suite 103
irNaples, FL 34112
MINUTES
NOVEMBER 3,2016
I. CALL TO ORDER: Mr. Forman called the meeting to order at 2:00 P.M.
II. ATTENDANCE
Advisory Committee: Charles Arthur—Chairman
William Sjostrom—Vice Chair(Excused)
Mark Weber
Bruce Forman
Gabriella R. Miyamoto
Staff: Harry Sells,Project Manager
Others: Robert Kindelan, Commercial Land Maintenance
Ray Benza,Hole Montes
Dale Slabaugh, Dale A. Slabaugh&Associates
Andy Solis, District 2 Commissioner Elect
William Arell Harris,Advisory Committee Applicant
Wendy Warren—Juristaff
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Mr. Forman moved to approve the Agenda subject to the following change:
Move: Item VII. - Old Business to Item VI.
Move Item VI. —Project Managers Report to Item VII.
Second by Ms. Miyamoto. Carried unanimously 3- 0.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OCTOBER 6,2016
Ms. Miyamoto moved to approve the minutes of the October 6, 2016 Vanderbilt Beach MSTU
meeting as presented Second by Mr. Weber. Carried unanimously 3- 0.
Mr. Arthur arrived and a quorum of four was achieved.
V. LANDSCAPE REPORT-ROBERT KINDELAN,COMMERCIAL LAND MAINTENANCE
Mr. Kindelan, Commercial Land Maintenance,reported on landscape maintenance noting:
• Brazilian Pepper south of Palm on Vanderbilt Drive has been cleaned out.
• The purchase order for fertilizer has been received; application date to be determined.
1
• Residential hedges should be trimmed to five feet in height to comply with Advisory Board
policy.
During Committee discussion the following was noted:
• Mr. Sells will submit a refurbishment request to Commercial Land Maintenance for
landscaping removed on private property during construction.
• A damaged bench was removed from the site at the Anchorage at Vanderbilt.
• The M.S.T.U. maintains hedges originally planted by homeowners before the M.S.T.U. was
established. All maintenance is within the County right of way and any code conformance
issues will be addressed now that construction is complete.
Mr. Sells advised the Committee that Commercial Land Maintenance's contract expires May
2017 and the service will go out to bid. He will prepare a "scope of work"which will include
mowing grass between the sidewalk and the street from north of Immokalee Road to the entrance
of the Dunes.
VI. OLD BUSINESS
A. LANDSCAPE DESIGN CONNER PARK—DALE SLABAUGH
Mr. Slab augh distributed a landscape plan for the entire length of the Conner Park area
noting:
• An inventory of the existing tree material was documented.
• Fox Tail Palms, Hong Kong Orchids and Royal Poinciana were introduced to the
scheme.
• The plan incorporates a coded list with the new specimens numerically designated.
• Mr. Sells advised the MSTU is responsible for replacement of plants in the curved
area of Conner Park bordered by Vanderbilt Drive and Bluebill Avenue which were
removed during construction.
During Committee discussion the following was noted:
• Conner Park, Parks and Recreation Division parcel, is not being irrigated-Mr. Sells
recommended the MSTU not assume responsibility for irrigation.
• The Parks and Recreation Department is receptive to the MSTU landscaping their
portion of Conner Park subject to design approval.
• Committee members expressed concern regarding a landscape investment in an area
owned and maintained by the Parks and Recreation Department.
• Drought tolerant plants and trees should be incorporated into the design.
• Conner Park and its sign define the entrance to Vanderbilt Beach and the community
benefits from beautification around the sign and in the area owned by the Parks and
Recreation Department.
• The Committee suggested the MSTU landscape to camouflage the utilities.
• Photos demonstrating the deteriorating condition of six benches, two of which have
been removed, in addition to a new design option,were distributed for review.
Commissioner Solis queried if park area in discussion is within the boundary of the MSTU;
Mr. Sells confirmed it is. The MSTU can design and landscape the area with the approval
of Parks and Recreation.
2
Mr. Slabaugh noted he has not developed a budget for the scheme presented which includes
the east side of Vanderbilt Drive and Conner Park. He shared with the Committee his
design proposal is conceptual and he is seeking direction from the Committee to further
develop the proposed scheme.
The Committee requested Mr. Sells research the amount of revenue generated from the
Beach parking lot and disposition of the funds and report his findings at the December
meeting.
Mr. Sells will investigate for presence of irrigation in the area housing the utilities and
report his findings at the December meeting.
Mr. Sells will provide quotes to remove overgrown plant material between the beach
access walkway and the water for the December meeting.
Mr. Sells estimates benches cost between $500-$600 to repair or purchase. He will
secure prices and style options for presentation at the December meeting.
VII. PROJECT MANAGER'S REPORT—HARRY SELLS
A. BUDGET REPORT for 11/3/2016
Mr. Sells provided an overview on the "Vanderbilt MSTU Budget Report on Fund 143"FY17
dated November 3, 2016 highlighting:
• Ad Valorem property taxes increased 8.66% FY17 to $1,192,800.
• Operating expense budgeted is $2,847,104.
• Most of the$1,164,321 in Commitments rolled over from FY16.
• Expenditures YTD total $226,377 leaving an available balance of$1,456,406.41.
• The purchase order balance for Holes Montes for$48,285 has to be increased by
$103,000.
• Estimated cash balance totals $2,751,128.03.
Mr. Forman motioned to approve an increase of$103,000.00 to the Hole Montes Inc.
purchase order. Second by Ms. Miyamoto. Carried unanimously 4—0.
B. COST OF AERIAL TO UNDERGROUND PROJECT
Mr. Sells distributed a financial analysis by street linear foot comparing the total cost of
Phase I versus Phases II and III to the Committee noting:
Phase I
• Total cost for Phase I for 1.801 miles was $3,093,881.46 or$1,717,868.66 per mile.
• Phase I encompassed Gulf Shore Drive,three finger streets and some commercial
properties.
• Florida Power& Light performed their services independently for Phase I.
3
Phase II and III
• Total cost for Phases II and III for 5.904 miles was $6,569,026.00 or$1,127,141.53 per
mile.
• Florida Power& Light granted the MSTU a 25%credit for assuming responsibility for
installation of electrical conversion services in Phases I, II, and III.
C. GENERAL STATUS OF BURIAL PROJECT
Mr. Sells updated the Committee on construction Phases II and III noting:
• CWSI(Comcast)was completed October 28, 2016 and service has gone live.
• Electrical Conversion
o A Switching Order for Florida Power&Light to activate power has been written but
not released by FPL.
o Ms.Arnold and Mr. Sells met with John Lehr, statewide coordinator of all Florida
conversions, to review status of switching order activation.
o Hole Montes provided a survey and stamped set of engineer prints to FPL.
o FPL requires additional information to process the switching order and activate the
conversion.
Committee members volunteered to meet with John Lehr of FPL to discuss expediting
processing the "switching order."
D. CENTURY LINK NETWORK BY ELECTRICOM
The Century Link network installation by Electricom has commenced with an estimated
completion time of four months.
E. COMCAST NETWORK BY CWSI
The Comcast network by CWSI was completed October 28, 2016 and service has gone live.
F. PHASE IV STATUS
Mr. Sells recapped the status of Phase IV Construction from Bluebill Avenue north to Wiggins
Pass Road. The start and completion dates for the Vanderbilt Drive Pathway Project have not
been finalized.
Staff has submitted four design proposals to FPL over a two years period and is waiting for a set
of"buildable plans" for Phase IV to proceed with the project.
Collier County is scheduled to begin construction on the first"Greenway Project"bridge the
week ending November 12, 2016. It is estimated construction will shut down traffic north of
Bluebill Avenue for ten to fourteen months.
During Committee discussion the following was noted:
• MSTU construction for Phase IV should follow behind the County project.
• The MSTU should consider allowing Florida Power& Light to perform their services for
Phase IV independently, similar to the methodology utilized in Phase I, and coordinate
the project with Comcast and Century Link.
4
VIII. NEW BUSINESS
A. Recommendation for New Member William Arell Harris
Mr. Sells distributed Mr. Harris's application for the vacant position on the Vanderbilt Beach
Advisory M.S.T.U. Committee for review.
Mr. Harris presented his background to the Committee noting he has been in a management
position for The Dunes for thirteen years and is currently responsible for seven buildings,the
Coach homes and the restaurant. He expressed his interest in becoming a member.
Mr.Arthur moved to recommend the Board of County Commissioners appoint Mr. Harris to
the Vanderbilt Beach M.S.T.U. Advisory Committee. Second by Mr. Forman. Carried
unanimously 4- 0.
IX. MEMBER COMMENT
None
X. PUBLIC COMMENT
None
There being no further business for the good of the County,the meeting was adjourned by
order of the Chair at 3:48 P.M.
VANDERBILT BEACH MSTU ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Charles Arthur, Chairman
The minutes approved by the Board/Committee on , 2016
"as submitted" [ ] OR "as amended" [ ].
NEXT MEETING DATE: DECEMBER 1,2016 2:00 P.M.
"CLAUSSEN FAMILY CENTER"AT ST.JOHN'S CHURCH
625 111TH AVENUE,NAPLES,FLORIDA
5
044.1a';K
P2;-:14'‘•
Board of Collier County Commissioners
Donna Fiala Andy Solis,Esq. Burt L8aunders Penny Taylor Wiliam L McDaniel,Jr.
District 1 District 2 District 3 District 4 District 5
December 13, 2016
William A. Harris
280B Grande Way
Naples, FL 34110
Subject: Vanderbilt Beach Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee
Dear Mr. Harris:
While convened in regular session on the above date, the Board of County Commissioners
voted to appoint you to a term on the above-referenced advisory board. Your term will expire
on November 13,2020 or at such time as the Board re-appoints you or appoints your successor.
On behalf of the Board of County Commissioners, I wish to extend ourappreciation for your
willingness to serve the residents of Collier County as a member of this advisory committee. If I
can ever be of service to you during your term,please do not hesitate to contact me.
Best regards,
411,146, jet;ideo
Commissioner Donna Fiala
Chairwoman, District 1
DF/wr
cc: Harry Sells
Tessie Sillery
3299 Tamismi Ind East Suite 303•Naples,Florida 34112-5746.2 252-9097•FAX 239.252-3602
VANDERBILT MSTU
FUND 143
January 5,2017
Vendor kern PO# Budget Commitments Expenditures Total
1 CUR AD VALOREM TAX $ (1,192,800.00) $ - $ (627,880.54) $ (564,919.46)
2 DEL AD VALOREM $ - $ - $ - $ -
3 OVERNIGHT INTEREST $ - $ - $ (280.54) $ 280.54
4 INVESTMENT INTEREST $ (2,000.00) $ - $ (1,290.49) $ (709.51)
5 INTEREST TAX COLLECTOR $ - $ - $ -
6 REVENUE STRUCTURE $ (1,194,800.00) $ - $ (629,451.57) $ (565,348.43)
7 TRANSFERS FROM PROP APP $ - $ - $ - $ -
8 TRANSFERS FROM TM COLL $ - $ - $ - $ -
9 CARRY FORWARD GEN $ (960,500.00) $ - $ - $ (960,500.00)
10 CARRY FOR OF ENCUMB AMT $ (882,004.94) $ - $ - $ (882,004.94)
11 NEG 5%EST REV $ 59,800.00 $ - $ - $ 59,800.00
12 TRANSFERS&CONTRIB $ (1,782,704.94) $ - $ - $ (1,782,704.94)
13 TOTAL REVENUE $ (2,977,504.94) $ - $ (629,451.57) $ (2,348,053.37)
14 SURVEYING FEES RWA,Inc Surveying 4500166989 $ 18,112.00 $ 10,112.00 $ - $ 8,000.00
15 INDIRECT COST Collier County Indirect Cost Direct Pay $ 26,100.00 $ 13,050.00 $ 13,050.00 $ -
16 LANDSCAPE INCIDENTALS Florida Land Maintenance 4500171726 $ 100,000.00 $ 9,350.00 $ 1,750.00 $ 88,900.00
Florida Land Maintenance Ground Maint 4500171726 $ 60,916.00 $ 8,084.00
Electricom,LLC Utility Conversion 4500171210 $ 347,012.55 $ -
Hole Montes CEI Utility Conversion 4500152314 $ 140,884.75 $ 30,252.40
Mastec North America,Inc. FPL Util.Aerial to Underground Cony 4500163308 $ 510,295.89 $ -
•
Harts Electric Install new power 4500166205 $ 13,220.00 $ -
Cable Wiring Specialist Comcast Underground 4500165508 $ - $ 270,970.05
18 OTHER CONTRACTUAL $ 2,647,992.94 $ 1,072,329.19 $ 309,306.45 $ 1,266,357.30
19 ELECTRICITY FPL Electricity 4700002986 $ 200.00 $ 83.64 $ 16.36 $ 100.00
20 WATER AND SEWER Collier County Util. Water&Sewer 4700002980 $ 30,000.00 $ 24,641.41 $ 5,358.59 $ -
21 RENT LAND Vanderbilt Real Estate Holdings Parking Lease 4700002870 $ 2,500.00 $ 5,400.00 $ 1,800.00 $ (4,700.00)
22 RENT EQUIPMENT J.M.Todd Copier Lease(shared) 4500171793 $ 300.00 $ - $ 133.06 $ 166.94
23 INSURANCE GENERAL Collier County Insurance General Direct Pay $ 600.00 $ 600.00 $ - $ -
Florida Irrigation Supply Irrigation Parts 4500164397 $ 7,187.63 $ 312.37
Florida Irrigation Supply Irrigation Parts 4500171647 $ • $ (16.31)
24 SPRINKLER SYSTEM MAIN $ 10,000.00 $ 7,187.63 $ 296.06 $ 2,516.31
25 MULCH Forestry Resource Mulch 4500171658 $ 4,000.00 $ 4,412.64 $ 27.84 $ (440.48)
26 LICENCES AND PERMITS Collier County Permits Direct Pay $ 2,000.00 $ - $ - $ 2,000.00
27 CLERKS RECORDING FEES Clerk of Courts Recording Fees Direct Pay $ 300.00 $ - $ - $ 300.00
28 LEGAL ADVERTISEMENTS $ 400.00 $ 400.00
29 OTHER MISCELLANEOUS Juristaff,Inc Transcriptionist Serv. 4500171659 $ 2,000.00 $ 1,315.81 $ 484.19 $ 200.00
30 OFFICE SUPPLIES Staples Advantage Office Supplies 4500171792 $ 300.00 $ 200.00 $ - $ 100,00
31 COPYING CHARGES JM Todd Monthly CPC(shared) 4500171800 $ 300.00 $ 223.79 $ 76.21 $ 0.00
32 FERT HERB CHEM $ 1,800.00 $ 3,307.50 $ - $ (1,507.50)
33 OTHER OPER SUPPLIES Matulays Cont Green Fence Cloth&Cable Ties Visa $ - $ - $ 409.15 $ (409.15)
34 OTHER TRAINING $ 200.00 $ - $ - $ 200.00
35 OPERATING EXPENSE $ 2,847,104.94 $ 1.152,213.61 $ 332,707.91 $ 1,362,183.42
36 TRANS TO 111 UNINCOR $ 91,500.00 $ - $ - $ 91,500.00
37 Budget Trans from Appraiser $ 9,500.00 $ - $ 2,305.98 $ 7,194.02
38 Budget Trans from Tax Collector $ 29,400.00 $ - $ 12,807.61 $ 16,592.39
39 TRANSFERS $ 130,400.00 $ - $ 15,113.59 $ 115,286.41
40 TOTAL BUDGET $ 2,977,504.94 $ 1,152,213.61 $ 347,821.50 $ 1,477,469.83
2,068,487,415 FY 10 Final Taxable Value
2,005,897,752 FY 11 Final Taxable Value Total Available Balance $ 1,477,469.83
1,910,384,837 FY 12 Final Taxable Value Plus Commited And Not Spent $ 1,152,213.61
1,904,053,761 FY 13 July 1 Taxable Value
1,945,640,639 FY 14 July 1 Taxable Value
2,044,186,286 FY 15 July 1 Taxable Value I Estimated Cash $ 2,629,683.44 I
2,195,715,846 FY 16 July 1 Taxable Value
2,396,592,139 FY 17 July 1 Taxable Value
Estimated Cash Less
8.85% Adj.16 to 17 Uncollected Ad Valorem Taxes $ 2,064,763.98
FY17 FY18
Millage 0.5000 0.5000 MIllage Cap=.5000 I Actual Cash
Extension 1,192,795 1,097,858
Property"ax Limitation Impact
FY 17 Gross Taxable Value 2,385,592,169
Minus:New Const.Annex. 5,449,987
Plus:Amendment 81 TV Component 0
Adj.Taxable Value 2,380,142,182
Prior year FY16 Levy(Proceeds) 1,097,858 1,022,093 DR 422 Levy
Rolled Back Rate (less Amend.One) 0.4613
91%of Rolled Back Rate 0.4197
II1I ; §
, E o
L2 „ 2 .-
j ,7 ,, 2 (t ;
! R , ' ®
i i . \S )a
4 74
\ \\\� \� �\,� \\\\/\LeA�� \\�}”' \
82 2
\ § \\� \ Ti \ \\ �� \
\ - g \
§
. ! § # '0
® : }
k ) $ ( \ \ } ! ! § } \ e ®
§ a \ \ '2; � ) l : 22 / ) ! ) { % z / \
: § , � g2
- $ . § + » = > ; , , 2a9E « $ r
! ! 7 ! ) } j : : � , l ± l = » » » ! . , lira
I I E
, z H . f,
ncn u o «
n .
1 I I �ev = f $ t"..1i = v y.n
i n
NjN f m m ' ,I3 ° .y f 'i a Zi
I ^ILL i 23 cu
1.4‘, 8 _
A
G 0 00 0 0 00 e 0 N 0 m 0 0 m 0 n o 0 0 N 0 a o o v o o 2
0 0 o cc cc v vi ro o m o .n o 0 o n vi m of ro
~ oN m N m ry `� m .n N e o �n n
m vii N N
N o ai o Zvi m ti , 2 ry m o ro v e '. H n n M
a m a v^i ao .n
w 00
VpI '4 ne e O O O
M
M
o O I� o o O v n
LL N N
Oi vi M .y a0 O 00 n N
~
V O O O
N N
0v0 O O mti o 5;
O O O O O o m O O N
ON O
m a O rmi 0 mR �00 � mO O .n On 0
e Y. N
F:'
Cl V0 tn )n N n 1NLL tNN N N
N _
g! 000 M
C 0 C
2O N
Y Oi W L',.°4 a n n
0 0 0 8 v
0 o ro
m 0 e e
`o
LL - N
n
a 8 e
O W9 b
N T
V o LL N Cl M M
C O n
O
8 ' O O A
O
0 S O
O N
H
2
D
ON
Y
-p M
W u m
b
N
W
M
s O
O} e ri
0
0 N
O
}
00
V _ V
� ON �
J Y v a V C « N v Y m
— i° yE a � c E'g «O _ Vu O C! E _
o _
a
a° 0) E c v -a vx>z 0 a tW F.
w 3 < p.,,0 '00° _
E., u u u o LL LL i x z d a r- LL
w v -
r
v v - y
m m 'o
a 2 8 F a`
Signature Tree Care Office: (239) 348-1330
Signaturetreecare.comgee. .411
- , 15275 Collier BIvd.St.201-276
info(a signaturetreecare.com i14 Naples, FL 34119 Fax:
PROPOSAL Page 1
Proposal#: 6938
Clerk's Finance Dept Home: Proposal Date: 12/19/2016
CCBCC Office: 239-252-5871 Customer#: 1491
3299 Tamiami Trail East SalesRep: Ian
Suite 700
Naples, FL 34112 Type: G
Terms in Days: 0
Job Site: 4 County
Transportation Phonel
Naples, FL 34104
Item# Quantity Description of Services Item Amount
1 3 Trees& Palms 190.00
Radio Road East of Santa Barbara,
1 dead Royal Palm -cut stump low, no grinding
1 almost dead small Buccaneer Palm
1 almost dead Pigeon Plum
Removal of tree, debris and stump. Grinding stump below grade, leave chips in stump hole.
Not responsible for unmarked underground lines or irrigation lines going through or near stump.
Any repairs or installations for irrigation at a time and material rate.
2 7 Hardwood 3,375.00
Vanderbilt Drive Between Palm and Pine
6-Carrot Wood Trees 1675/stumps 525
1- Ficus or Banyan tree 900/stumps 275
Removal of tree, debris and stump. Grinding stump below grade, leave chips in stump hole.
Not responsible for unmarked underground lines or irrigation lines going through or near stump.
Any repairs or installations for irrigation at a time and material rate.
All methods accomplished thru ANSI Z133.1 Specs. in compliance with Collier County code and industry standards.
Not responsible for underground sprinkler lines.
Please sign proposal&return to schedule work order. If any questions or changes to
work order, address in writing/email.
Proposal Total: $3,565.00
Required Deposit: 0.00
Authorized: Date: