The URL can be used to link to this page

PARAB Agenda 02/24/1999 Ksand Recre , bO1!jht1i fl1rdYjsory Parks ' � acre 0 on Wednesday, February 24, 1989 2 :00 pm at East Naples Community Park 3500 Thomasson Drive Naples, Florida PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD AGENDA February 24, 1999 The Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meeting will be held Wednesday, February 24, 1999, 2:00 p.m. at East Naples Community Park, 3500 Thomasson Drive, Naples, Florida. I. CALL TO ORDER: II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG: III. INVOCATION: IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES,January 27, 1999 Meeting A 1-7 V. AWARD PRESENTATION: -Annie Pappalardo VI. NEW BUSINESS: a. Fitness Center Grand Opening March 1, 1999 b. Summer Camp Program VII.REQUESTS FOR DISCUSSION- SPECIFIC UPDATE ITEM VIII. OLD BUSINESS 1. Impact Fee Update 2. Regional Park Land Purchase Update 3. Park Projects Update IX. REPORTS/UPDATES: 1. Monthly Report (December) B 8 2. BCC Recap B 9 3. Adopt-A-Park Report B10 4. Parab Meeting Schedule BI1 X. ADJOURNMENT 1 PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD Minutes January 27, 1999 Vineyards Community Park 6237 Arbor Drive West, Naples, Florida PRESENT: Daphnie Bercher, Chairperson John Grice,Vice Chairperson Timothy Blackford Gil Mueller Lisa Barnett Edward "Ski" Olesky ABSENT: Murdo Smith, Recreation Manager Bill Shelburne,Parks Manager Karin English ALSO PRESENT: STAFF PRESENT: Marla Ramsey, Director Jacquie Hart, Secretary II John Dunnuck, Operations Coordinator Joseph Delate, Project Manager I. CALL TO ORDER: The meeting was called to order at 2:20 p.m. II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG IIL INVOCATION: by Jacquie Hart Iv. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: December 16, 1999 meeting. Motion by John Grice to approve September 16, 1998 minutes. Seconded by Tim Blackford. Passed 6/0. V. NEW BUSINESS/PRESENTATIONS a. Award Presentation - None b. Introduction Of New PARAB Member - Vice Chair Bercher welcomed Lisa Barnett to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. c. PARAB Officer Election - Mr. Tim Blackford nominated Daphnie Bercher as Chairwoman and John Grice as Vice Chairman. Motion by Tim Blackford to elect Ms. Daphnie Bercher as Chair and John Grice as Vice Chairman. Seconded by Gil Mueller. Passed 6/0. d. Skate Park Non Compete Clause: Ms. Ramsey stated that a request was made by the concessionaire to include a non-compete clause to her agreement. The County had given the City of Naples $15,000 for the improvement of their skate park. Ms. Rice attributes lost attendance to the City due to the improvements. The City of Naples skate park facility is free and the Sanctuary Park charges a fee. This clause will not allow the current concessionaire to have another agreement within Collier County but the concessionaire is allowed to manage other skate park at other counties or state. The clause will also prevent the county from funding non-county operated facilities any funding to any other skate park improvements except Collier County Parks and Recreation Skate Parks. The clause reads: "To Protect the County's investment in the subject Skateboard Park, for the duration of the Agreement, including renewal, neither the County nor the Concessionaire will invest in, contribute to, or perform any in-kind services to help support any other skateboard facility that is not operated by Collier County and it then appears that the other skate board facility could compete for any then existing or potential skaters of this Skate Board Facility." Motion by John Grice to support the Skate Park Clause. Seconded by Tim Blackford. Passed 6/0. e. Copeland Land Purchase for Playground - The Church has a land lease agreement with Collier County Parks and Recreation to allow the playground facility for 3 %2 years. Now the church is planning on building a Recreational building on the playground. The playground facility needs to find a new location. Ms. Ramsey stated that Impact Fees are not being used for Neighborhood Parks per County Policy. The Parks and Recreation are now directing impact fees funding to Regional Parks. The Parks and Recreation are looking at 3 pieces of property in the area but parcel #53 has 3 liens. Ms Ramsey contacted Michelle Arnold of Code Enforcement and she stated that the County could satisfy the loan with $6,820. Parcel #53 was the least expensive of the lots, but had more liens and assessment fees. Ms. 2 Ramsey stated that even if the land is donated, the liens still have to be satisfied. Mr. Mueller suggested that the Parks and Recreation staff consider lot #79. The gentlemen is a personal friend of his and he is willing to donate the 13 acres to the Parks and Recreation Department. Ms. Ramsey stated that the property is more wetland and the assessment fee is very high. Ms. Ramsey stated that the department could look into grant options but the main concern is to find funding to purchase the property. Chairwoman Bercher suggested that the Parks and Recreation Department meet with the church and discuss some other alternative on moving the playground equipment. Suggestions were made by PARAB that the Parks and Recreation Department purchase properties that have tax liens. Ms. Ramsey stated that it is not legal for the County to purchase properties at auction. f. Boat and Beach Access Report: The objective of the Beach Access and Boat Landing report is to recognize the increasing demand for water supported facilities and project viable opportunities to accommodate these needs. The current growth in Collier County impacts beach and boat access two ways. The increased seasonal and permanent population produces a greater demand on the existing facilities and reduces the amount of coastal region land available for future development. This summary examines the current inventory of beach access and boat launch facilities, current trends in the Level of Service, and future expansion opportunities for additional facilities. The table 1 inventory describes the physical characteristics of the existing boat launch and beach access facilities countywide including State and City facilities. Collier County currently has five (5) saltwater boat launch parks, one (1) fresh water boat launch park and seven (7) saltwater beach access parks located in the coastal zone of the County. As it stands today, beach access and boat launch parks are only measured under the Regional Park acreage element, thus beach parking spaces and boat ramp facilities are at the mercy of the regional park acreage element, which is currently satisfied by the Level of Service requirement for the next thirty (30) years, as all state lands were added to the measurement standard in 1990-1991. 3 Although the county population continues to grow, there are traditional and non-traditional opportunities to expand boat landing and beach access facilities through out the Collier County park systems. Bluebill Parcel -A 4.55 acre undeveloped land on Bluebill avenue owned by Collier county. Parcel has an appraised value of&1.5 million and a sale value of $3 million according to the Collier County Real Property Management. Beach Access Facilities -Use alternatives - 1. (A). Build a neighborhood park on the south side funded by a local MSTU district and construct 150 beach parking spaces on the north side of Bluebill Ave. Patrons would walk to Delnor-Wiggins State Park. (B). Trade Bluebill parcel for site near beach with increased parking opportunities. (C.) Sell Bluebill Avenue and utilize revenue to acquire parcels near beach access points. 2. Clam Pass Parking Expansion - Construct a parking garage above the existing 175 spaces parking lot. The cost of said project is estimated at $10,000 or space or roughly $1,750.000. the Registry Resort has expressed interest in the partnership for said project. 3. Bonita Beach Road Parcel 6 - A 1.5 acre undeveloped waterfront parcel owned by Klein Development Company. Although the property is vacant, it is zoned for single family homes with a conditional use to build a 9 unit development titled Spoonbill Cove. The value is appraised at $377,400 by the Real Property Management Department. This property could support approximately 30 beach parking spaces and patrons would utilize the Barefoot Beach Access. 4. Busing Options - As the County continues to grow and land becomes less available in the coastal region, there is an option to purchase or lease land outside of the coastal region and offer busing opportunities to beach access locations such as Vanderbilt Beach Access. 5. Ferry Access - Another creative idea is to purchase a small parcel with beach access near Wiggins pass and ferry people to the Barefoot Beach Preserve. Due to limited access, the South end of Barefoot Beach receives limited use. This option is a viable way to give patrons access to one of the County's more pristine beaches. 4 6. Vanderbilt Beach Subdivision - The 1.2 acre Block "C" is located along the north right-of-way on Vanderbilt Beach Road across from the beach parking lot adjacent to the Ritz Carlton. Although appraised for $870,000 from the property appraiser's office, the land recently sold for $2,000,000. Block"C" is zoned for commercial use. Boat Launch Facilities 1. US 41 Parcel #12 - Located off US 41 across from the Pewter Mug Restaurant is a two (2) acre parcel that has direct access to the Cocohatchee River. This parcel could support 2 boat ramps and 30 parking/trailer spaces. 2. Isle of Capri Parcel- There are several vacant parcels (Lots 546, 547, 548) with direct access to Tarpon Bay located on the Isle of Capri. These parcels could be utilized as a boat launch facility. 3. Lot East Of Bayview park - (two (2) are parcel east of Bayview Park. Zoned as Planned Development for residential, single family, The parcel is estimated to have an associated cost of $50,000/acre, but the owners would argue that the land is worth a greater value since it is waterfront property. The parcel could ideally support a 30 ft. ramp and 30 parking spaces. 4. Moss Family Property (Copeland) - The Moss family has indicated to staff a willingness to lease there 4 +/ - acre property for a period of 20 years at no cost. The parcel is located just north of Stan's Restaurant in Copeland. After the terms of the agreement expire, the family will re- examine the use of the land. IX. Old Business a. FAA - Ms. Ramsey stated that Mr. McMannus could not get the Coast Guard to commit and he was also having problems with the liability insurance for the event. b. Boat Show - Mr. John Good decided to continue his boat show at the Airport. c. Impact Fee Study Result: A report was distributed to PARAB showing four different options. The Parks and Recreation Department will present four (4) park impact fee rate study option to the Board of County Commissioners on February 9, 1999. Option 1. The costs have been updated to reflect the current (1998) cost per acre or type of facility. The calculations also include standards and 5 costs for new facilities (i.e. beach parking spaces, roller hockey, and skate parks), which were not included in the 1991 rate study. Option 2. The calculations are based on the current (1998) level of service standard for all types of land and facilities including beach parking spaces, roller hockey and skate parks. Option 3 The calculations are base on the same level of service standards option 2 except for the exclusion of beach access regional park land. Option 4 Utilize calculations of option 3 but use TDC funds for beach related expansion Motion by Tim Blackford to recommend Option #2. Seconded by John Grice. Passed 6/0. d. Regional Park Land Purchase Update - The Board of County Commissioners approved 175 acres be purchased 1 mile south of Immokalee Road for the North Naples Regional Park Project. The estimated cost for project is approximately $14.7 million. The facility will also include the new Parks and Recreation Administration Office. Staff has been directed to do two (2) appraisals, an environmental audit and an assessment. (a draft plan of the North Naples Regional Park was distributed) Dog Park- Ms. Barnett inquired if the Parks and Recreation Department has any plans for a Dog Park. Ms. Barnett suggested the North Naples Regional Park since it is in the planning stage it would be a good idea to designate an area of that park for dogs. e. Park Projects Update - Sugden Regional Park gazebo is being worked on. Also preparing the paving which will be complete next week. Golden Gate Fitness Center project is nearing completion. Concrete sidewalk is being poured today. Fitness equipment will be arriving on the February 8, 1999, and install on February 9th. A walk through will be done on February 12, 1999. Grand opening is tentatively schedule for March 1st, 1999. South Regional Park is four (4) weeks behind schedule because of the dewatering. 6 X. Monthly Report f. November Monthly Report -No discussion g. BCC Recap - Golden Gate Pool Concession: - Staff presented an executive summary to award a concession agreement for the Golden Gate Pool. A report was presented before the Board of County Commissioners showing the results of the proposed MSTU for Neighborhood Park in Golden Gate -staff to redraft. h. PARAB Meeting Schedule - Next meeting is scheduled at East Naples Community Park, February 24, 1999. i. Adopt-A-Park Report - Ms. Karin was supposed to give a report was unable to attend the meeting because she is terminally ill with cancer. Jacquie send a card to Karin English on behalf of the Parks and Recreation Board. Ms. Barnett suggested that she would adopt Bayview Park and Mr. John Grice will adopt South Naples Regional Park since Karin English is out sick. VIII.ADJOURNMENT Motion by Tim Blackford to adjourn. Seconded by Vice Chairman John Grice. Meeting adjourned at 4:00 P.M.. Passed 6/0. 7 mG. - mcom cn cp 0D c > co ) cOGc- W D cZmm _ 0000m0 > H > m "C00 fC � � p f G� G� G� G� x DD ".mzD a.. cD C) x '< ZC� mOCCD -axi mm -1r_ s. 00) io m H0 .L-I -I ,.jalm0D < mz7) o -IrK73m -< mn00 ''°° > O -1m - -1 = Om -i = Km m -Im = mvm 0 > m > z ZmD, � C `D D -DID * o�ooDzc � wm00 bOZZrrmKKD73 -Dpn '< Cnzr= Oz r mo (I) 1- Krm > mcnX � rcncnDmm � n nn � mcn a' O u) = O m ")' gym O n x m ,,,,i.-ri � D m � m A m m O O m m y 7J D D 0 • OPi Q up s ' .Z1 ,pori CD• Fi; " 0 O as ; 5 a0, ': cn". s00 W - A k ) N CT O O i A co 0 co O -1 0 CI -11 CD > mai tea- -I C� 1 ^ C) " \+ 0 ( - D r o z m V -{ N .Z7 N' a u `gy NO v O> Co .O C -4o CD CO -4 Co cn O C) W 6) CO Co) O` OO W O C) CP W N C) 01 O CA 0 Z 0 2 Z Ni, i .i i i ;(DNiN i Ni CO, co W iNi i A -G -< ) A O C) v W ' O co A N N i A O O O CP O N O co N A 'V 73 Z In 4 i i N PA Cri Co Co --.1 Co 0 ` CD m D Ni . N O O i CD O co CO CP A Cr' co N CO ilia' (P O C) co co N O co A O 71 2 -0 2 .. 1 CS) CT A Co Co 0) IC: O Oa) co A N CD co Cn •CO -, A O N -I O -. CT CA O O O Z m 4 D '� D C kW, GJ, i CNO A CO CAI) N CCO N N c0 CA c0 CO Co Co O-4 N O 0 m r 0 NiN CoW A C) NiN VrK CD' i A CP co (� i v v v i C) Cfl -4W iaN CW CPiOCDW 4, -4 � CDo -4 -, C,) iWa) 4, - co D -1 7J W 01 - 0) i o) Co O' o Ni i CO 0) -I A O co 01 (P CO -4 cn 0) cn -I A Na 2 -< m CD O Ni -I V 01 O W` O O CO i CP -I Ni O W 0) CP C) N Co O Ni C) Co 0) O W CC C) m m m gY r: x 0 D OA , E m m " ,p i i ' i Ni 00Co W i v Co A S ,a CO Z Co 01 Cn i n 0) � 4 Co 401 N3 sCooA Co I D aW NJ N m -CO COCOi -co -, -Co O Ni CO 00 W i 0Z7 0m .W: Ni Ni Cn 01 -4 i _ N A A 00 0) Ni W h -4 v C) Ni -.I A O O 0) i 71 to coOW O O A O O i O V 0 AZO` CP O A N 01 N CP A O O N O - .D u: , > -I IP0AN --. W W i N o'.: co -.I i i A W -0. O) W Ni -0. A CO C) Ni CP z ""' 'V U1 CT co C) N 1 V -' N N CP Co CO `.0 A A CA Ui N CO O CD CO Ni - Z 3 .N W N CP i O O'01 03 N W CP -4 C) O N i O CO A O -4 W i Oo cco _, c. Ni. Ni O Ni W W co i O -4 00 CP CA A ',1: Co co -4 co -4 -4 co W O ICP; N' C) i C) -1. Co N i O O O i CP Cb O -I k.,1. CA V Cn N CO O CO CA N O (P O co _ ej E C) co ',Sod i i _, C a V v i A W i A Ni W Co N ..C,' CO A i W W V 0 CP A co . C Ca CP CO O co "co Ni C)) (O Ni i O W N ? Ni O o O IV O 6) CO A Oo A A CD Cn co _a 01 01 Ni' CO Ni .-c 01 0) CO D) 0) A 01 ^4 -- A 0) CP - J --, A C)0 -, A 2 Ni: CP O C. i CO 41, O O CO O CP 01' CO -4 i 0 A W CO co: A -I co CP O �1 O Cn O co W m Z • -1 70 W Ni. i Cb Co Ni. . W W i N Ni Ni i co 'I m < i _, (O N UC'. W i CO. co N CD CA CD A CP; A V Co O (fl V O N A -.I o D Z 0i. Oo Co Co CP -4 Co -CO C))'. -J co Ni Ni -4 i A O CA. Na O O -1 Ni co co N O A 70 C - -I: -4 O - ' co -4 O: O CO co CO - CO co Ni " Co Ni i i -4 A -, O A CO • cP o :41. A o o cP o rn W co i �l O 0o i W CA . C) co Cn Cn A co CA o 0 0 0 co m (0 .C.io N. i cly i CP i iP Co CCo (fl i W -i Co -,1 01 Co CP = 'U t r4 C)) CW -4 a) '+1 V .1(4 W -4 O 0) CO W CP Ni Co N.) O Ni C)0 A co O A - -1 I.).$ (n C}) C) O C i Co C3) O CO CO W Ni (31 CP V -4 O) CP CO -4 N 0) O O 0 (P O co: O CO .{ O O A 0 0 CO N O co O co CP A ca co A A CD (O W CP O V O -.I 4 77 M N :Ri i -� N i .CO v i zo 1,3 ,R. Ni - ` A N co A J CP i ,Co. CP co N co co v -4 C)) co A XI 'Ia.: W --1 703 A -co WI -1 A le O Cn i (P W O i N In - -> -co -co _, O) -co O '.I CO < L7)': W CP a) (P Ni K)` Ni O O; A -4 CO co A 01 CD C)) Cb A co co CP CO al 0) l03.. UC O v CO a) CP' O O i O A , CP co -.I O i O co co CP AuC) -4; N A CP CT CP CO Co O Co O CD W C (B) 8 BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS PARKS AND RECREATION RECAPS: February 2/9/99 8C1 Beach Access &Boat Launch Report 2/9/99 8C2 Impact Fee Study Report 2/9/99 8C3 Modify language of GG Neighborhood Park MSTU survey 2/23/99 16C2 Acquire outlying parcels located north of landfill to utilize for recreational purposes. 2/23/99 16C3 Authorize the purchase of playground equipment for Cocohatchee Park. (B) 9 To: Marla Ramsey DirE r Department of Parks & Recreation From: Mary Ellen Donner, Recreation Supervisor Date: Jan. 5, 1999 Re: Pool & Fitness Revenue Report FY YTD FY YTD FY YTD 96/97 96/97 97/98 97/98 OCTOBER Pool $3,509. $3,509. $6,924. $6,924. $10,486. $10,486. Fitness $5,567. $5,567. $10,503. $10,503. $11,299. $11,299. Totals . $9,076. $9,076. $17,427. $17,427. $21,785. $21,785. NOVEMBER Pool $3,122. $6,631. $4,107. $11,031. $6,229. $16,715. Fitness$3,912. $9,479. $8,663. $19,166. $9,139. $20,438. Totals $7,034. $16,110. $12,770. $30,197. $15,368. $37,153. DECEMBER Pool $3,889. $10,520. $5,067. $15,587. $5,485. $22,200. Fitness $4,342. $13,821. $8,473. $22,294. $7,410. $27,848. Totals $8,231. $24,341. $13,540. $37,881. $12,895. $50,048. JANUARY Pool $6,291. $16,811. $4,508. $20,095. Fitness$14,867. $28,688. $13,856. $36,150. Totals $21,158. $45,499. $18,364. $56,245. FEBRUARY Pool $8,254. $25,065. $9,531. $29,626. Fitness $8,191. $36,879. $10,219. $46,369. Totals $16,445. $61,944. $19,750. $75,995. MARCH Pool $18,771. $43,836. $13,263. $42,889. Fitness $5,396. $42,275. $10,123. $56,492. Totals $24,167. $86,111. $23,386. $99,381. APRIL Pool $13,784. $57,620. $24,130. $67,019. Fitness $6,978. $49,253. $6,444. $62,936 Totals $20,762. $106,873. $30,574. $129,955. Adjustment from actual revenue + 5,855. $135,810 MAY Pool $26,016. $83,636. $24,226. $91,755. Fitness $6,919. $56,172. $6,399. $74,680. Totals $32,935. $139,808. $30,625. $166,435. JUNE Pool $35,210. $118,846. $40,087. $131,842. Fitness $8,077. $64,249. $7,973. $82,653. Totals $43,287. $183,095. $48,060. $214,495. JULY Pool $26,017. $144,863. $26,995. $158,837. Fitness $6,290. $70,539. $6,717. $89,370. Totals $32,307. $215,402. $33,712 $248,207. AUGUST Pool $19,617. $164,480. $19,117. $177,954. Fitness $7,697. $85,877. $6,027. $95,397. Totals$27,314. $242,716. $25,144. $273,351. SEPT Pool $11,366. $175,846. $9,735. $187,689. Fitness $7,641. $85,877. $8,699. $104,096. Totals$19,007. $261,723. $18,434. $291,785. PAR4NGER MONTHLY REPORT / MONTH: December YEAR: 1998 VEHICLES VISITORS MONTH YTD MONTH YTD BAREFOOT BEACH ACCESS: 2,044 12,623 4,095 30,293 BAREFOOT BEACH PRESERVE: 9,095 21,975 21,828 52,740 VANDERBILT BEACH: 8,950 19,711 21,480 47,306 CLAM PASS PARK: 5,308 18,947 12,739 45,472 NORTH GULFSHORE ACCESS: 980 3,903 2,352 11,719 TIGERTAIL BEACH 8,416 28,137 20,199 67,529 MARCO SOUTH ACCESS: 1,810 4,873 4,344 11,695 SUGDEN REGIONAL PARK: 3,564 11,630 8,553 27,911 COCOHATCHEE RIVER PARK: 4,212 14,716 10,108 35,317 BAYVIEW PARK: 5,540 19,287 13,296 46,288 951 BOAT RAMP: 1,719 4,964 4,125 11,912 CAXAMBAS PARK: 2,964 7,653 7,113 18,366 PELICAN BAY PARK: 2,650 6,743 6,360 16,232 LAKE TRAFFORD PARK: 4,210 10,320 10,104 24,767 PERSONAL CONTACTS SITE VISITS INTERPRETIVE PROGRAMS MONTH YTD MONTH YTD MONTH YTD 8,971 25,637 811 2,284 8 18 PARTICIPANTS MONTH YTD 139 189 PARKING CITATIONS WRITTEN WARNINGS VERBAL WARNINGS MONTH YTD MONTH YTD MONTH YTD 39 121 64 183 341 829 VIOLATION CITATIONS COURT APPEARANCES MOUNTED PATROL HOURS MONTH YTD MONTH YTD MONTH YTD 2 37.5 66.75 EXOTIC VEGETATION REMOVED: MONTH YTD BRAZILIAN PEPPER: 218 228 AUSTRALIAN PINE: 31 46 OTHER: VOLUNTEER HOURS: MONTH YTD RANGERS: 58 202 BBCH P FRIENDS: 472 TTBCH FRIENDS: 10 30 SRP FRIENDS: 5 23 O 1'HER: REVENUE MONTH YTD BEACH PARKING: BOAT TRAILER PARKING: CONCESSION: COMMENTS: ADOPT- A- PARK REPORT The Adopt-A-Park Report is provided by the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. Each PARAB member visits their adopted parks and gives a detailed report of the parks condition. The purpose of this report is to help Parks and Recreation Department to continually improve in maintaining park facilities. Tim Blackford a. Vineyards Community cPark 1Vport on 3/24/99 b. Clam Toss Community Bark, c. Cocohatchee River Talk Edward"Skin OCesky: a. Immokalee Community Bark Report on 4/28/99 b. Immokalee creation/Aquatic Dapfinie c3ercher:: a. Veterans Community Park Report on 5/26/99 b. Golden gate Community Center c. 91a.KA. Masse Jr., Community ( ark, Gil Mueller:: a. 2igertail Beach Report on 6/23/99 b. South Marco (Park John Grice: a. East Naples Community Bart Report on 2/24/99 b. Sugden Regional Bark e. South Naples Community (Park Karin English: a. Report on 2/24/99 Lisa Barnett: a. golden gate Community Bark Report on 2/24/99 b. Lely Barefoot Beach c. Bayview Community(Park (B) 10 r. „0-4, cPC74c 145 ( 4cN Q cif c v4�(10 , (74- vcIcsoceybOv4ce, MEETING SCHEDULE 2:00 p.m. DATE LOCATION 1. January 27, 1999 Vineyards Community Park,6231 Arbor Drive West 2. February 24, 1999 East Naples Community Park,3500 Thomasson Drive 3. March 24, 1999 Golden Gate Community Center,4701 Golden Gate Parkway 4. April 28, 1999 Immokalee Sports Complex,505 Escambia 5. May 26, 1999 Veterans Community Park, 1900 Immokalee Road 6. June 23, 1999 Max Hasse Jr. Community Park, Golden Gate Boulevard 7. July 28, 1999 TBA 8. August 25, 1999 TBA 9. October 27, 1999 TBA 10. November 17, 1999 TBA 11. December 15, 1999 TBA NOTE: Meeting dates could be changed due to holidays observed. PARAB members will be notified 2 weeks prior to meeting date in the event of a change. PARAB meets every 4th Wednesday of each month. ** MEANS A DATE OR A LOCATION HAS BEEN CHANGED. (B) 11 • z (,3 -0703 co Departinent of Collier County Parks and Recreation 4 3300 Santa Barbara Boulevard Parks •• Naples, F7urid.124116 R�eaho • To: • From: • 6INC- 8210+¢1 jtiAlitikaDate: 211rf Number o(Pages: ()nduding cover) Phone: (941)353-0404 Fax: (941)353-IOOZ AA A 1oAlDivid kc, t. Ct ._• - " 44t t Nl /'t. ...416631 _PAL ,t turf 114. Lc } Jutia .6,ozviiiAa utti4f- yikt .441A1211 _Aga al._ Axial- d•14.04,, y.ea LA_Ltm YL... S YG II ecid i rJ J t1 lid' 1 f _:l t atf _., ttpy (cl dr) watt ycal Ha I h a • • • 'E•J 2 CT US' TO BE ME BEST" e eoikeJe / U 3301 East Tamiami Trail•Naples, Florida 34112-4977 John C. Norris (941)774-8097•Fax(941)774-3602 District 1 James D.Carter,Ph.D. January 13, 1999 . District 2 Timothy J. Constantine District 3 Pamela S.Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Berry District 5 Ms. Lisa H. Barnett 1105 Royal Palm Drive Naples, FL 34103 Subject: P.'ks and Recreation Advisory Board -� Dear • A hi ;e: While convened in regular session on January 12, 1999, the Board of County Commissioners voted to appoint you as a regular member on the above-referenced advisory committee. Your appointment will expire on December 31, 2002, or at such time as the Board re-appoints you or appoints your successor. . As with any advisory group, the primary purpose is to assist and advise the Board of County Commissioners. By law, however, the ultimate decisions rest with the Commission. At times, the Commission's decisions may not reflect the recommendation of the advisory group because many facts must be taken into consideration. By copy of this letter, we are requesting Marla Ramsey, Parks and Recreation Director, to provide you with any additional information you will need as a member of this committee. On behalf of the Board of County Commissioners, I wish to extend our appreciation to you for your willingness to serve the residents of Collier County as a member of this advisory board. Very t • ours, Or/ ela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman Commissioner, District 4 PSM:sf RECEIVED cc: Marla Ramsey, Parks and Recreation Director JAN 15 1999 1 1 L........ t PARKS ;13ECR ^+T:� # Aialcdo/-62dh:py-x 4 0 'leo, 3301 East Tamiami Trail•Naples, Florida 34112-4977 John C. Norris (941)774-8097•Fax(941)774-3602 District 1 ' James D.Carter,Ph.D. District 2 Timothy J. Constantine January13, 1999 District 3 Pamela S.Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Berry District 5 Mr. Edward R. Olesky 6001 Lake Trafford Road Immokalee, FL 34142 Subject: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Dear Mr. Olesky: While convened in regular session on January 12, 1999, the Board of County Commissioners voted to re-appoint you to a 4-year term on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. Your new term will expire on December 31, 2002, or at such time as the Board re-appoints you or appoints your successor. On behalf of the Board of County Commissioners, I wish to extend our appreciation for your willingness to continue serving the residents of Collier County as a member of this advisory • committee. If I can ever be of service to you during your term, please do not hesitate to contact me. Very truly"yo s, P ela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman Commissioner, District 4 PSM:sf EIVED cc: Marla Ramsey, Parks and Recreation Director REC PARKS&RECREA iot4 vVt7,,,,,dedo;en, -Vfi�GV/(/!/ -co/m/m6ato42P/iGS „A-17p,, Sl, 3301 East Tamiami Trail•Naples, Florida 34112-4977 • 941774-8097x 774-3602 X � John C. Norris � � •Fa941� � District 1 James D.Carter,Ph.D. District 2 Timothy J. Constantine 3 January 13, 1999 District Pamela S.Mac'Kie District 4 Barbara B. Berry District 5 Ms. Karin E. English 3823 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 421 Naples, FL 34112 Subject P. ks and Recreation Advisory Board Dear I.. r/_ ' While convened in regular session on January 12, 1999, the Board of County Commissioners voted to re-appoint you to a 4-year term on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. Your new term will expire on December 31, 2002, or at such time as the Board re-appoints you or appoints your successor. On behalf of the Board of County Commissioners, I wish to extend our appreciation for your willingness to continue serving the residents of Collier County as a member of this advisory committee. If I can ever be of service to you during your term, please do not hesitate to contact me. Very trul yours, P. ela S. Mac'Kie, Chairwoman Commissioner, District 4 PSM:sf cc: Marla Ramsey, Parks and Recreation DirectorRECEIVED • v JAN 15ISA PARKS s RECREATION EATIO,N To Naples Engraving, Attn: Mr. Grant Leitch Field Purchase Order: #853114 Phone: (941) 262-4449 Fax: (941) 263-4011 Lisa H. Barnett Parks & Recreation Advisory Board Please make name plate for the above mentioned name also make name plate with wine/burgundy background. Thank You!! If you have any questions, please call Jacquie at 353-0404. Also when name plates are ready for PICK UP please call. PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD AGENDA January 27, 1999 The Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meeting will be held Wednesday, January 27, 1999, 2:00 p.m. at Vineyards Community Park, 6231 Arbor Drive West, Naples, Florida. I. CALL TO ORDER: II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG: III.INVOCATION: IV.APPROVAL OF MINUTES,December 16, 1998 Meeting A 1-5 V. AWARD PRESENTATION: -None vI. Introduction of New PARAB Member-Lisa Barnett VII.NEW BUSINESS: a. PARAB Officer Election b. Skate Park Non Compete Clause B 6 c. Copeland Land Purchase for Playground B 7-10 d. Boat and Beach Access Report (will be distributed at meeting) VII.REQUESTS FOR DISCUSSION- SPECIFIC UPDATE ITEM VIII.OLD BUSINESS 1. FAA- 2. Impact Fee Study Results Cii 3. Regional Park Land Purchase Update 4. Park Projects Update IX. REPORTS/UPDATES: 5. Monthly Report(November) D12 6. BCC Recap D13 7. Adopt-A-Park Report D14 8. Parab Meeting Schedule D15 9. Parab Member Listing D16 X. ADJOURNMENT 1 FIRST AMENDMENT TO SKATEBOARD PARK CONCESSION AGREEMENT This document amends the Skateboard Park Concession Agreement ("Agreement") of August 26, 1997,between Collier County and Sparrow Ventures, Inc.. The following paragraph is added to the Agreement: To protect the County's investment in the subject Skateboard Park, for the duration of the Agreement, including renewal,neither the County nor the Concessionaire will invest in, contribute to, or perform any in-kind services to help support any other skateboard facility that is not operated by Collier County and it then appears that the other skate board facility could compete for any then existing or potential skaters of this Skate Board Facility. Except as expressly amended, the Agreement remains unchanged. Dated: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY,FLORIDA ATTEST: DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK By: BY: Deputy Clerk , CHAIRMAN Approved as to form and SPARROW VENTURES, INC. legal sufficiency �.- By: Linda Rice, President Thomas C. Palmer Assistant County Attorney WITNESS: Print name WITNESS: Print name (B) 6 tK � MEMORANDUM TO: MURDO SMITH, OPERATIONS MANAGER =<-- PARKS &RECREATION DEPARTMENT FROM: Wilma Iverson, Senior Specialist Real Property Management Department DATE: September 1, 1998 RE: Copeland Property Per your request, I have researched properties in the Copeland area for a neighborhood park that Parks and Recreation could equip and maintain. I have highlighted a map to assist you in locating each property. Charloff: tax parcel 77 - (highlighted in yellow) This property is owned by Arthur Charloff, who was granted the property in 1985. Mr. Charloff lost the original deed and was not able to record the document in the Public Records of Collier County. He is willing to sell the property and would like for Collier County to make an offer. The County's cost would be minimum since there are no liens on the property. I spoke with the Owner of Record, Douglas McGoon, Jr. He is willing to convey the property to Mr. Charloff to clear title. Fisher: tax parcel 53 - (highlighted in pink) Mr. Harold Fischer purchased property by Tax Deed. He owes approximately$11,000 + for assessments, tax certificates etc. A quiet title action would need to be processed through the court system to receive a clear title. Bird-tax parcel 101 - (highlighted in green) Mr. Hubert Bird purchased the property in 1989. According to Gary Harrison, Code Enforcement, Mr. Bird died. There are approximately$1,500 in assessments due on this property. We would need to contact a representative of Mr. Bird, if available, to find out the status of this property. (B) 7 Rusitzky- tax parcel 79 - (highlighted in orange) Louis Rusitzky has approximately 12 acres of property in Copeland. He owes approximately $12,400.00 in assessments. A quiet title action would have to be processed through the court system to clear title. Tax Parcel 32 & 49 (highlighted in blue) is owned by Copeland Baptist Church. This property is leased by Collier County for the purpose of installing playground equipment to be placed upon. This lease expires 9/24/99,but provided for two (2) one (1)year renewals. According to Mr. Yonkosky, Director,Department of Revenue, the Board of County Commissioners, may waive some of the assessments, or at least not charge the 12%interest on the principal. It is my understanding any Property Tax/Tax Certificate and Solid Waste (trash pickup fees) must be paid, but perhaps we could reduce some of the liens owed on the properties. If a quiet title action has to be processed through the court system, the County Attorney's Office is able to process the paperwork for that procedure. This procedure would cost$300 to $600. If you need further assistance with this project or if you have questions,please contact me at 774-8991. Thank you. (B) 8 0 . >. w •t.. l Q F IV ! V 1 411 ,e` M �► r f1lilM 10. ! v � • Ee yrs- l''''' ,t, u I?i— uo J 111 1 ! ❑ I H r. ..7*, . riJ r O � • 1- tk id s•�/C rt mg M4, T;.,,:i. (.. , ..., i ET- A LI.J.' 1 , n ;#:-. 4 -1 ti ® — t. Al A El, .1:-.3, (..., n ...L--- t. al _.:...,._____. . -4 ,-, . .., ,.. -- z ____, ?..,4,,, gi,.. n. e- 1'1 •:3 $. .Ell -4[2 -: a) Nk r.ii. 31 « Z °.. - 1 . Yom` 'Z a y `� j ,. 2 -t 4.1 ..r- t1 lam-- _._, Z . '. Li ° T.' Lil E!--.z ... ,,c.1 _ . ... 1 -ti-- i-cri 7 i.is �in ' x ft rn l=1 ~ M © w-.© ' 1...................1 ��`' Al „t 4. .0 y s �- . D ..�c 4,tA ar1 j . �C � r �i C y/r'L-_S f 0�I. 'C"L'M • 111 rT? ,: T i • � Y w 4(2..7 .. ,,......:4"."1:--... .,::',4',* �. y .,,,� _3 ,kms •. .,„..44,,,,,,,,..t.„..._,_ 1 ` �` ° t ..._,_ h r' t a 6. • 0d ' V''..,4Y `---..,._,..,1,..L., (`� v r tC , / `z .r_ s Q .`. z MEMORANDUM DATE: January 15, 1999 TO: Marla Ramsey, Parks and Recreation Director FROM: Jacquie Hart, Secretary II RE: Parcel #53 Hi Marla, Michelle Arnold called and this is the information she gave me. There are 3 liens on Parcel #53 since 1994. Loan #1 a. Principal $245.00 b. Total owed $377.06 including interest Loan #2 a. Principal $325.00 b. Total owed $510.00 Loan #3 a. Principal $ 5,650.00 b. Total owed $10,172.82 Michelle said the county would satisfy the loan with $6,220.00. (B) 10 .. , III a ,01 0 CO C.0. 0 CO 6) 63 C 0 0 CO 'Ca' < < -1 CO CO Z 0 CO CO CD < < -o 5.• F. 0 G') 0 0 -n m > -n I =1 m .,C; 0 0 C 7:/ -," 0 )00. > 'C > 03 5 C 0 en CO > C 0 0 0 0 0 > ', 7 > > z > 03 CO 0 3< -C X Z c) m 0 C '' P -0 X CO m HE 0 CI) M 0 03 () H -4 CD rT1 0 > < _-44 0 0ni- 0 — -iiTmlxcf) -,0Thn _-i _< m2o000> 1HZ 09 ?C 0-1•-••1 -Z> ,;•L;i F = mum - > ) _ _ _ :-.-1 Z O W MP Cn C > 0-I > I:13 F x > = s-21 r- ,,,0 03 m m cn -1 71 - > mmcn0 -050mr- w I0 o) o I i- FK mX0w73 . . '' w , > 0 z ° O = H m < 0 _< r- Om m 0 0, 0 -1 › -0 '''' -0 3 7J X -;s1 Wo M M O z cn > X F -*, CD q w'r ;:, -1) ,,,0 ,---- , o j , , t! o . , '„,o.',' 4, co — — n.) o cn -, 4, rs, o 4, o co a al co r.4 PM I W iikop Cl) ,.,..„ ,.. -..-...,--i-•; ....d. . > 4..},.. x o -4 0 I- 1.; 1— th ---. 0.) 1,- CO 0 N3 C) 0 /.... N.3 -4 C° 7:1M co Z „ -I O CO 0 ,;%'‘, - g 0 0 z z C (3) — N.) 0 — N3 03 -1 -1 -. N.) 01 01 -.L -, N.) - E x -o. cri 4t. co ca A 0) C3 N.) 0) CO N3 03 -A CO N.3 -A ...., (71 01 CD -P. NJ A -4 0) --1 X z > ..‹ > -01 ---403 bcocn (0 01 co a0N3 -4 - CO 03 A CO bo co a) co 03 03 A CD -I M xi XI 'Tti 0) -4 CO 01 01 CD (.11 A V CD CO CO ,1 NJ A 03 (.71 C.3 -4 03 -.. CO CD 01 -1 ..., 03 03 N3 03 CD (0 ',1' CD 0 cr) a) CO -4 (0 --4 A a) co 4, -.1 -40) no co co a o a o -< rn x > > 13 CI) •:,:&.*.A X 0 0 > CO a) --, - _, -< F. 73 Z OD co N.3 -, 03 'Il; N.3 A -1. 03 03 N.3 --1 0 -1 ....> -, 0) CO CD -4 a -4 -4 CO CD -, N3 (n th --4 co --4 -4 N3 C) (31 0) N.) CD (C) -A CD 01 -s. CD (D 0) 0 ...< rs.) iso a lo co co co co b ---4 a c.) -.4 o-) a) co r,4 -,r -o 4, op -, 4, X 4, c 03 CD CO 0 01 CO -, N.) 03 (31 01 -. Ca --. CD (0 0 (31 0.3 CD -- A Cli CD CD iv mco 0.) -4 N 3 0 0) N-1 0) 0) 0 0 CO -1. CT 03 N3 CO -3 4, N.) N3 -1. 0.) N) 01 CD ^4 0 03 0 CD 13 m 0 _73 33 Z Xj 0 w Om X < > N.) "4 n) -, 4, 4, -, -....1 N) Ca .p X- > 0) ....1. Cri -4 01 CT. CD 4t. CO 03 CO A A -, "4 -). Co V (31 ID V N...) Ca 0) -, CO X CO Z M N) oa -, -.4 0 a) r.) N (0 4, ro cn th 03 -, L'il) 0 -A In -, o) CD A CD - co X 0 n) co --, 4, o, cn co a co 01 .1X6 -A 6) c=, A -> 03 CO 0 0 N.3 CD --.4 N) -A 0 03 01 CD a) -- 01 0 0 0 0) tn. CO 0 0 C3 -4 0 0 -.4 N3 0 0 0) -1 CD 00 -4 0 CO N3 0 N) 0 1t4:. 0.0).... 03 n4 - r,‘. -‘ ,v, - . . - - N.) IV -, CO 0 CD N..) -, 4, CD .s -‹ N3 0 -I Ca CD 0 -4 0 CD ' (13 N.) ,1 0) A NI -.. pi - cr, co 0) 0) o-. 4, o 0) co 0m1:1 > CD co lo -co o N) co co :p. 4 co In co la 141 4, c;. 6 -ca co a) 03 In -.4 -.4 CD mCO 0 0 -A 0) 01 N..) -,. CD CD CO 0 (D 0) -1 "4 0) -, -s. 0) 0 N.) CO 03 -.4 0 n) 11.3 0) CO CO 01 C31 .CD (31 C) 0) 0A CD CO -1 N) -1 -.4 0 -P. CO -A NJ N.) 0 03 0 CO Z -I C) C X E x -CD 10' to - al (0 -1 m to N) N.) N.) NJ 03 -1 A ^4 03 -, -, NJ CO 0) 0) A Co i z C.)1 V - 0 co 0, 1..) -4 16, (o 4, -, -.. - a) n.) iv coiv co - -, 4, 1.4 Iv co -I CD NI 0 0) A 0) V .424, N3 CO N.) N.) CO CD --.1 "4 0) CO -4 0 01 CD 03 03 N3 -1 N) a) cp a : ; o3 4, 0- a o 4, 00) %lc cr) cr) co o N.3 01 --.1 CD - (0 0) 03 Ca A -4 O 0 0 cD 0 Co 0 -‹ m X X M -< < ...., .... ...a. N3 _, A N.) r.)N.) - .- m,, >. r..) -i 0,3 --. 03 N.3 --, W. N3 -, V'.. C31 -.. N3 0) cn co •-, 4, -.. N) -.. -4 (n o a, a) co 00 Z _ ca N) cOCD ) -4 co N3 CD 4, --,1 iv co 4, -.1 N3 co 0 -, --4 a -, n.) 4, b V 0) 01 C IN3 Ca CD --, 4, CD 03 01 "iCD A NJ 0 03 CT 01 03 4, Cri CO O 01 CD CO C..) CD -, N.) CD m al 0 0 .tu, CO CD -4 a o 6) CD - ',(O A 4, 0) CD 4, 0 IV Ca 01 0) A CO 03 1\3 CD CD O 0 CD 0 "4 0) . . -0 co ,..., _, _.‘ -ot -40 .-t 3 N3 7 " ci o 50.; -'. ^) '. 5-n crt cr) al co NJ Co ---4 A. 0 = 7J N.) 1\3 ,CC1 1\3 CD (0 0) 1.4 ,,arn -th co th -, CD -LCD b ---o a) co r..) (1 a) a) - b .n. co (71 01 0) CO 01 0 co -, torf, o -, a) 4, --o -, -, co -n, O 0 CO r.) A a) (31 a 4, ,•,,-< cr) o o a) no --,i (,) o o CD C) CO ')1/1//t A A (0 0 0) 03 4, 03 03 CP th na ^4 CD A Ca a o ^4 0 n) --4 ,.. . _ > X 0 •,,3,,, co _ N) ..,,,,; i-z-;. „su C) -, - -- , , n.) - a 4 ,,,Ig a, _‘ Ca N3 -. 0) N.) -> Ca 1\3 61 CO 4, 0) CD -- 01 a) CO 0 -, (31 CD .< ,.. ',1 V ,1 tr, a) co -4, b 4, 4, a) 03 -. 03 1\3 -, 00 ^4 4.1 03 10 03 th r..) -, th b co co -1 -004,t co co 5.;-. „1 co --• ..... o o a) co --, co ca CD N3 0) -, 4, N3 -‘ -, 03 Co a) N) 0) (31 01 CO.._0 a ; co OD ,--\ 0 0 --.1 a 4, o a) -.1 cn a CO o co co - "4 a o --.. V 0) a) CO a -, a iv a) Q (D) 12 do" mak BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS PARKS AND RECREATION RECAPS: December/January 12/15/98 16C1 Award the purchase of maintenance equipment to John Deere in the amount of$56,000 1/12/99 8C1 Report on results of Proposed MSTU for neighborhood Park in Golden Gate. Staff to redraw boundaries. 1/12/99 16C1 Extend agreement another 6 months with Henderson, Young & Co. for impact fee study. 1/13/99 #3 Legislation Delegation: Amend statute to give BCC local rule. 1/26/99 8C1 Award the purchase of 175 +/- acres for a regional park. 1/26/99 16C4 Approve an agreement with the Gulf Coast Skimmers for completion of grandstand facility 1/26/99 16C5 Award a concession agreement for the Golden Gate Pool. (D) 13 w w+rrl110 AbOPT A- PARK REPORT The Adopt-A-Park Report is provided by the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. Each PARAB member visits their adopted parks and gives a detailed report of the parks condition. The purpose of this report is to help Parks and Recreation Department to continually improve in maintaining park facilities. Tim cB(acI ford: a. Vineyards Community cPark Report on 3/24/99 b. Clam Bass Community Bark c. Cocohatcfiee River Bark Edward"Skin Ofesky: a. Immokatee Community cPark Report on 4/28/99 b. Immokalee Vcreation/Aquatic Dapfinie <3erciter:: a. Veterans Community Park, ljeport on 5/26/99 b. golden gate Community Center c. 911a. A. Masse Jr., Community Tark Gil- a. Tigertai(Beach Completed 11/18/98 b. South Marco 'Park John Grice: a. East Naples Community ParkReport on 12/16/98 b. Sugden 1R gional Bark Karin English: a. Bayview Community Bark Report on 1/27/99 6. South Naples Community Park, Lisa Garnett: a. golden Gate Community Bark Report on 2/24/99 b. Lely Barefoot each (D) 14 C cP74' X6 l/ c ► ce C 'ZOVV ' 1( ociey botAce,� MEETING SCHEDULE 2:00 p.m. DATE LOCATION 1. January 27, 1999 Vineyards Community Park,6231 Arbor Drive West 2. February 24, 1999 East Naples Community Park,3500 Thomasson Drive 3. March 24, 1999 Golden Gate Community Center,4701 Golden Gate Parkway 4. April 28, 1999 Immokalee Sports Complex,505 Escambia 5. May 26, 1999 Veterans Community Park, 1900 Immokalee Road 6. June 23, 1999 Max Hasse Jr. Community Park, Golden Gate Boulevard 7. July 28, 1999 TBA 8. August 25, 1999 TBA 9. October 27, 1999 TBA 10. November 17, 1999 TBA 11.December 15, 1999 TBA NOTE: Meeting dates could be changed due to holidays observed. PARAB members will be notified 2 weeks prior to meeting date in the event of a change. PARAB meets every 4th Wednesday of each month. ** MEANS A DATE OR A LOCATION HAS BEEN CHANGED. (D) 15 C PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD IMMOKALEE DISTRICT (1). Edward"Ski"Olesky Term Expires 6001 Lake Trafford Road 1/12/99 - 12/31/02 Immokalee,Florida 34142 (residence)(941)657-2401 Fax:658-2401 MARCO ISLAND DISTRICT (1). Mr.Gil Mueller Term Expires 541 Blackmore Court 1/1/95 - 12/31/99 Marco Island,Florida 34145 (residence) (941) 394-9444 URBAN DISTRICT (1). Ms.Lisa H.Barnett Term Expires 4001 Tamiami Trail N. Suite 300 1/12/99 - 12/31/02 Naples,Florida 34103 (residence)(941) 643-9703 (work) 649-4900 (Fax) 649-0823 (2). Karin E.English Term Expires 3823 Tamiami Trail East,#421 1/12/99 - 12/31/02 Naples,Florida 34112 (residence) (941)643-9606 Fax: 348-1483 (3). Mr.Timothy M.Blackford Term Expires 276 Madison Avenue/Wk.Addr: 2403 Trade Centerway 1/1/97 - 12/31/01 Naples,Florida 34110 Naples,Florida 34019 (residence) (941) 566-9121 (work) 513-9300 (Pager)436-9549 (Fax) 513-9300 (4). Mr.John Grice Term Expires 326 Charlemagne Boulevard,I204 1/1/97 - 12/31/01 Naples,Florida 34112 (residence) (941) 774-5517 (Fax) 793-2414 (5). Ms.Daphnie Bercher Term Expires 3375 Timberwood Circle/P.O.Box 1072,Naples, FL 34106 8/26/97 - 12/31/99 Naples,FL 34105 (Wk Add)Cummings&Lockwood 3001 Tamiami Trail 4t`Floor,Naples,Florida 34103 (residence)(941)262-1686 or (work)649-3108 Fax 263-0703 (D) 16 ramsey_m From: hart) Sent: Friday,January 15, 1999 3:14 PM To: ramsey_m Subject: Michelle Arnold Hi Marla, Michelle Arnold called and this is the information she gave me. There are 3 liens on Parcel#53 (1994) Loan#1 1. Principal $245.00 2. Total owed $377.06 including interest Loan#2 1. Principal $325.00 Total owed $510.00 Loan#3 1. Principal $5,650 owed $10,172.82 Michelle said the county would satisfy the loan with $6,220.00. If you have any questions please e-mail or dial my extension#221. Or call Michelle Arnold for further detail information. Page 1 9 TREISER, KOBZA & VOLPE, CHTD. ATTORNEYS AT LAW Lisa H.Barnett Richard Shapack of Thomas A.Collins,ll o The Northern Trust Building of Counsel Fitzgerald A.Frater+o 4001 Tamiami Trail North Catherine E.Kidon Kim Patrick Kobza o Suite 330 0 Also admitted in Michigan p Stanley J.Lieberfarb Naples, Florida 34103 +Also admitted in New York C.Richard Mancini Telephone (941) 649-4900 0 Also admitted in Kentucky Andrew H.Reiss o Also admitted in New Jersey Richard M.Treiser Fax (941) 649-0823 t Board Certified Tax Attorney Christopher T.Vernon Internet Address: Michael J.Volpe+ www.tkvnaples.com January 22, 1999 Collier County Parks and Recreation att: Jackie Hart 3300 Santa Barbara Boulevard Naples, Florida 34116 Dear Jackie: Per our telephone conversation of last week, I have enclosed a picture of myself for publication in Leisure Lines. Please let me know if you need any additional information. I look forward to meeting you and working with you. Thank you. Very t ly yours, Lisa Barnett . RECEIVED JA7N 2 5 1999 ^' s a�RECREATION 4, 0 0 401116* boo ;_, ,,,4 , 4 4111111111111111114 February 9, 1999 Study Prepared by Department of Parks and Recreation 3300 Santa Barbara Blvd. Naples, Florida 34116 1 INTRODUCTION The objective of the Beach Access and Boat Landing report is to recognize the increasing demand for water supported facilities and project viable opportunities to accommodate these needs. The current growth in Collier County impacts beach and boat access two ways. The increased seasonal and permanent population produces a greater demand on the existing facilities and reduces the amount of coastal region land available for future development. This summary will examine the current inventory of beach access and boat launch facilities, current trends in the Level of Service, and future expansion opportunities for additional facilities. This study is an update to a 1995 report prepared by Jeff Moore, a landscape architect for the parks and recreation department. INVENTORY The Table 1 inventory describes the physical characteristics of the existing boat launch and beach access facilities countywide including State and City facilities. Collier County currently has five (5) saltwater boat launch parks, one (1) fresh water boat launch park and seven(7) saltwater beach access parks located in the coastal zone of the County. Highlighted among the characteristics are comparisons with beach parking spaces, boat ramps, car parking!trailer spaces, and active beach front miles [Table 2]. LEVEL OF SERVICE The park system Level of Service as adopted by the 1991 impact fee study and the Open Space element of the Growth Management Plan is currently measured by three (3) categories: regional park acres, community park acres, and facilities. As it stands today, beach access and boat launch parks are only measured under the regional park acreage element; thus beach parking spaces and boat ramp facilities are at the mercy of the regional park acreage element,which is currently satisfied by the LOS requirement for the next thirty years, as all State lands were added to the measurement standard in 1990- 1991. (See [Table 3] for the Level of Service element for Regional Park Acres.) The County standards do not show any demand for additional beach parking spaces or boat launch facilities even though the seasonal and permanent population continues to grow and the current facilities continue to fill to capacity. Once more, there is no immediate revenue source for new facilities without impact fee support. Many of these issues are being addressed in the current impact fee study update. Staff is first of all proposing the elimination of State lands as a consideration of the Regional Park LOS. As indicated by Table 4, the gap between the LOS standard and regional park acres without state lands has been closed considerably with the addition of Sugden Regional Park and the recent Board action to acquire a 175 acres for a new regional park in North Naples. The purchase of additional regional park land also permits staff to meet the facility LOS standards. Staff cannot construct new facilities on State owned preserve lands. Secondly staff is proposing a separate standard for beach and boat ramp acreage. The 1991 adopted LOS for regional park land is at a $15,000 / acre cost of land acreage. This figure is too low when considering beach and water accessible land. The consulting firm of Henderson, Young, and Company created a proposed acreage standard based on the property appraisers taxable value of current beach and boat launch parks. Additionally, a facility standard for boat ramps and beach parking spaces is being proposed based on the current population and existing facilities. FUTURE OPTIONS Although the County population continues to grow, there are traditional and non- traditional opportunities to expand boat landing and beach access facilities through out the Collier County Park system. Beach Access Facilities 1. Bluebill Parcel — A 4.55 acre undeveloped land on Bluebill Avenue owned by Collier County. Parcel has an appraised value of$1.5 million and a sale value of $3 million according to the Collier County Real Property Management. Use Alternatives A. Build a neighborhood park on the south side funded by a local MSTU district and construct 150 beach parking spaces on the north side of Bluebill Ave. Patrons would walk to Delnor-Wiggins State Park B. Trade Bluebill parcel for site near beach with increased parking opportunities. C. Sell Bluebill Avenue and utilize revenue to acquire parcels near beach access points. 2. Clam Pass Parking Expansion- Construct a parking garage above the existing 175 space parking lot. The cost of said project is estimated at $10,000 / space or roughly $1,750,000. The Registry Resort has expressed interest in a partnership for said project. 3. Bonita Beach Road Parcel 6 - A 1.5 acre undeveloped waterfront parcel owned by Klein Development Company. Although the property is vacant, it is zoned for single family homes with a conditional use to build a 9 unit development titled Spoonbill Cove. The value is appraised at $377,400 by the Real Property Management Department. This property could support approximately 30 beach parking spaces and patrons would utilize the Barefoot Beach Access. 4. Busing Options - As the County continues to grow and land becomes less available in the coastal region, there is an option to purchase or lease land outside of the coastal region and offer busing opportunities to beach access locations such as Vanderbilt Beach Access. C 5. Ferry Access - Another creative idea is to purchase a small parcel with beach access near Wiggins Pass and ferry people to the Barefoot Beach Preserve. Due to limited access, the south end of Barefoot Beach receives limited use. This option is a viable way to give patrons access to one of the County's more pristine beaches. 6. Vanderbilt Beach Subdivision - The 1.2 acre Block "C" is located along the north right-of-way on Vanderbilt Beach Road across from the beach parking lot adjacent to the Ritz Carlton. Although appraised for $870,000 from the property appraiser's office, the land recently sold for $2,000,000. Block "C" is zoned for commercial use. BOAT LAUNCH FACILITIES 1. US 41 Parcel#12 - Located off US 41 across from the Pewter Mug Restaurant is a two (2) acre parcel that has direct access to the Cocohatchee River. The parcel is for sale for $225,000 by the Collier Development Corporation. This parcel could support 2 boat ramps and 30 parking/trailer spaces. 2. Isle of Capri Parcel-There are several vacant parcels (Lots 546,547,548) with direct access to Tarpon Bay located on the Isle of Capri. These parcels could be utilized as a boat launch facility. The vacant lots across the street (Lots 485,486) could be utilized as the car / trailer parking area. If all the lots were purchased, this facility could support a large boat ramp facility. According to the Real Property Management Department,the estimated cost of these parcels ranges from $9.93 / sq. foot for water front and $4.50 sq. foot for the parking area. 3. Lot East of Bayview Park- Two(2) acre parcel east of Bayview Park. Zoned as Planned Development(PD)for residential, single family. The parcel is estimated to have an associated cost of $50,000 / acre, but the owners would argue that the land is worth a greater value since it is waterfront property. There are also environmental issues (mangroves) with the property that would have to be mitigated. The parcel could ideally support a 30 ft. ramp and 30 parking spaces. 4. Moss Family Property (Copeland)—The Moss family has indicated to staff a willingness to lease their 4 +/- acre property for a period of 20 years at no cost. The County would be responsible for clearing the area and building the boat ramp. The vegetation is a mix of Brazilian pepper and mangroves thus permitting could present a challenge. The parcel is located just north of Stan's Restaurant in Copeland. After the terms of the agreement expire,the family will re-examine the use of the land. Location Map „..,,,,,,,,,.,,,, A.6 -- , ,,,,,,,,,- , - Ates € „ sacwr ,� RO " L 4a Parcel 6 r, • t Ra. ! MT 17 . Bluebill Park �, Fva •4mrc�ckc�xa. Sau .f %,1+tttEa ‘a x+ Asa St '"• u%Fxt% ,t . ^•., t•ixFtES�aSdan ingot '4,1 s R�. --t-(')\ gyp „ i r 1,5Block"C„ '',4',,,r, Cr 894 %c*fc�e Ha. } 04'4 _ 41 . ' rxr.E. Z Rye t e 4 s1 i . t;• ,, .,. : It',it7 - -`StEden�ftlld pa,..y , , i CC a %e ,e ', a�a s a' �' ''. e:eotak..a. _ �1 l+dra $ E e5 C;T i;11$1!„3( Ff tAIRSDA E %e' 1 r�;� t NAFIES i EAST g Bavview Expansion ---- '" ,c r �sav 1 , l .- '� 8 I � LELY ' L EtER,,,w,&5 Isle of Capri — — r i..�. ...., ... ,_ — 1,. ,° ,eco itiU AN7 Boat Ramp � ��', .',urrc4 �,� ;. � ,�,.. ;.L y BAY ' ' IA 4 .. ` 111171\ ,� a.an k - -„` ', . : `' -- Moss Boat Ramp I Beach Access & Boat Launch Facility Inventory Table 1 k ! I!'h'f 1i1A IY'iN,�4i1!nl 4'1!1 I;LPI 1'it � I hrit?✓!,11t11..101114,i!:f?'f1:i IA!i f 4'44471 NW�li LkLGirn!i4iit'Ihllj!I�r,!!;I i 1„!j � ' :' ! 1 4i'r',v.R 1i Itt ::14Y l4li;1111I4„ I! y ! ,I ! 16'';-”,r i Nf,,;,;.". 1 1 ! Ii i`1iliiiholigip,iFIYxLi�:",M,:IiiiidiI'.iiiill IIIip!i'Irjln 1'I' Mi•11111 1!!'!l i!IN:1',fNf I,;ll Ii1� +I L.ii t. i .!4..1 .i!!!L:ILa,,.,,a 131 t,'w1 Aillil.ln;!I I,!.i �! I ! i , If 1 ! r 9 t ' . .x.1,!;1,.3,nl aA:,, :1(11,1 NI NI 1..1-.I { 1 II.I Lx,11,1 C!„”. {;r4!r {„' J 1 I .:ned,r�d4'y.. r1 ,4 '! t!' 1' 11 ix; !,1 ..I"IA{ ,. :: ur 1,x,1 I{ .r.i,,.,.,... , .f.,,. I .r..V,l �•r 1': hi .,,I' ..,�x.,. 111'{1 1111.. .::n, ..L. :Iv rvv .!.I.. ...i 0,a. I .f,., .,:k..,.,..^. ,41¢0:�t ,., ,MM.. ,I ,nu 3::r.. ii .,..1:. ':I.1, .9 I„L..I...... x:'I. ,:,:E d �•hi},I 11,11. .n.. ..h.. `..I! '' IM,. 3, 1111. :5`I'io-.,:0ri!7fr x3::Y.Y.,3J.y,!,r�:A' i.l.o-, .r.,.... :;eN... ,.,19r r. 1111.� .1.. !:^.if"!`:, 313;!. :A.h'. ,h7:x :7f,. ':.1. :k:Aa. ..i.1, i .. .b.:.f 1 M ..4 .,Y:-i 1 311NikA <'iih. 'airy=>r eii:. i:o,a..,. I!ilia,r. :!II.I 111,1. y.a.,„ ,.f.r...,.!, !.I .,!. :1!' a. 1 I,: !!t{!i1F:_4175r!3%' ,!.,I{.. ,1....: : 1a';,r .,YI,. ..1 it°-� `iil:t%:...r S -..3.,,�. :11 .Y..'.x,l, :1 c...> 111"1'"! I d.!.. �,^,.. 1i3fb.iry .1 1:111 r !f.,111 !. ,tr• i!lil(:iii!<ilpili i., [i!!jif...:.A ., 1,.43: f..!i. 1 ..Ix:4 Ur!,�: .10,,,11'14¢I LbL.�1L......!... :4Y. a.!L,{ a:'fGf l. .i x:1:4' ..t..:. .I...... , .Ants,},f' ..n.,d:.. 1, ...,4. ,.n.x;A.,.,.;z,3!k:•: :.4.:. ..I,. .,i l.., . L,,. 4r.,' . 1. r. I.r .4!i!.1,... ,x'x,..!,. -.L.w n,f Nle,en.,.o-,.n!ia „n., , ir01 Alt f I :^:11 x!<. y1 1 r:l.. :.!:i 4..rr ,...: ::::: 13.1....,.r:.: „, .!.:' �r.^'::, :. .YI.:1 �7i;7„ ...f.:.,I„N.. 1i!n1:3!!;i''! . I. '!I .1 h1.I ,:.n.3.n,Y"::!. ..Y.... ..LrN:!!:a;.a.a:1,r:wr,.,,ni;i;:;!'t n:::aa.J�!X" .xv 1..l r. fur., ,.I: !f.I .:.ih! .i. ;'e:l^: il...:.0 h! 1111.. .PM•I - I .i,.!� h. ,I. i ,..I.3 !r::i<Xr:iailn;lL"",.•!•..r::f:kf%-� :,i. ?.q!;:::S.Yi.',' ;7.,, ;,aN. ''i',ii1Yi'"x c i!S iiN!!!AN, ..�. , .I.1 i!w:i ..,,.1,.,.. k�;!, 1111.. 111:1 r..: �...., uanx !!;.0i.,,.;a10.0...1 ,.,. . : „!.. 11,1 .. -.::eN!v:l 01,.19an3:. ,.,..,:...,.!,":::¢>:n r..1!!1.31.. 4FC.. .,.I.x .I,,, ,:rl!:1xi:"i:'i.. 114:.1,. I. ,,I 3R.i'91f ',r. 1.3,: ..! ,u::k1,!.' ,:i.,a. ':r xXllx'-+ !:a kt '!:� ,I:::aa,::r:,.. •.3. I ',:,x:rY:4 �.!.ki,i3: ,:NJ 1,: ,i "t .:ar :::Aa.;.lwvi:'I,.,A...:::1 ,Jo-.. ..1...1.1,11 :, ,1, .(;... ..I ...6., „.,.::^1:,. �f'.!!5rui%;rkf-a x111,.. !.. ., !!A!!I•!!'s.,, :X117. :31:,,1111 1 .I P, I!:v0fr:.71¢`11 ` ,I.,., .:d::... 4•s,!.. I...n I In' i.,A.gg ,A „1,., 1� r^�r'r .xU, v,,,.y "xa!,y. i,IU .1 ',!nk!'::t CI lif° .JNI^3 7i!11N!ri+'� at-!,a:r,. , ��5!Ei'i!E%r r!! n3nn X '�„ 1:n's ui'"I�'" .k : 1': ,.b 1 7111...:.. {r ' (J....,0v;:v vi 11'11 A.x a�. ..fl v4., ! ;i,l!i,1i!in;1;1:'r.....,.... t,..:.� ..!L3 � ..I..L rill 4. I ,..1,,,10111111;11,11i0 ,d.f,,.3. lilhriil: � ! 114.1. ,,:.!.. ..y i,:% 1 ..E, 1111 ,7111 .a!: ,h.• ,it, '-�i'm^' ,%!. :, .t. .5..,.. .L. n• A"'lf 1,i 9':. ng:illN rN!} Y,,. '•i, I r,1, n'I'S' ;', 177,,1 I :,1 I t{ N 'k!'!Nr:e ..I ,.f .x i' ',ra, !•h .N'iY.'r! '.4..rl ,". f !A:w :,I id44a-�: n.!,Uh xa,,;1, I!ik!' '7'111 lan!�. 1 t ,11..,+ f. a , !!4 E�•: :.41, '.1.1. i:k!.:i ! :.Ar. f u. .b !h'. n.l r:'. p! ::,,!x I x111 f'N+ ..1!' A,...I E.11,1.. .11r'Y i� , ! 'i;!!1 h rA.11 "!,'1!. 3:1.1'. ,.n.4 i,r, ... ' !'ii,,.Jn.,.. �:'0111.. ..3.{...,,, � .7'� ...1+:'i:34.J�?;7117., ,.t 4: ...L.,>:.•-,.: '..7 fn!f� , f,.x •:n� , ! ,, , ,f. I! 'i:. !n'!.1 .,011i10,1"1.n!' ..I.n. IaN :,. ,: .� ..,:,.. >.r'.r. �,,. „t. 3;1111 II 111,1.. .:1,.i.. , 1. .. (,. 111 I : . 1v, , it I .v..",..Lrur ,t ,.. I : ,4, :, f.l,l :aNI i �h , 11 - 1 . .,.,.....x...:A. .,^!,0aa.:,f."......-' ,. ,. 1:: t. ,I ! , ., r. t 111::1; :.r,Y.lw..r.L.,...,..,�, N.....!r.,r.......:. 1,...,7A-, ,,:.,a::::..:..r. ` ..A.. ,.� li..'t 11 1w 1111 v,.,.1i. ..Nni,l 1;111..LN, I. ...1.. I L!iY, .,N L.I �. .,. .,... ., ,.' r! ,:., .w 4.,..,.1.4 1111 r A f I wl�.:..:.:i.r.....-. E 1.411 �i ,. .. L-1111.. ,�. 1114.¢. I � �1.443ii. ..E J., I. 1:1,11. 11 JI I'..� .1.:,.x,,� .:!'., NNI 31., "Y.:.,::;:r:ru:.^00w�o' i3!!!"'I'" -.., 1..1.1,111.. :1:111, ��,��.,7.,::.::::r,,'r„A..:,..,.,a';,,�n.,.,.:,.r;:::,. . ::.::..!,....... .:..!.,i,::l..... ,1111 ,.I: ,,1111,... ,.. :1:111.:.,,,. 1. :.: 4., ,.1..,.....,...1, Ax,l!+:=7Yi3lf:! ¢u:1fi1G` Y. t7k::::., ..,h.:t14`i'x nap. aFduh'.A:E';tixiF`in!rn r;I:Xl:in:: ..1 ,141x. !3!:3ti;!:.,•,y: .sl"a!';:3N!'y'1dAb'a'.1::+.!,;1.r .I,. ..A, ;::.41,4!!, �.'!1. .::.:::nn.0•...^:: .Yyv ' 4,.1,111 .Akk I: , ,i ..r.. 141.7 .^lai ,;G:a: ni.,lnx..t.! N:r. ,..,,: ,'J. :1,:x:'::i,1,.::kN,i3;x'!'131 n 3::,rfi!1:!i'.f.: .l. .N...: S"!if1 1:,.771: .!, .,,il''!Y 11:7..7.^1.;,:,Y;:rYr:;3^+1;i 001, ,:,,P:.. i:;,NH!!G5% ,,:igrriir.:L.., ..!. !i=11:1.;1?ir7 �nv;l'r:!: .55X! .I..,,I 11.7..::X,h ';!,,:!:, ;,..4;1', 11x1.., ...:..,...-. 8'r!biYFni!G!<m:�!i`thiv .I o-..!re.. . 11!1.: 1.... ,E!:!:, 11 i. ,a•. ..,,.^.,^„rrr::w.A. Ir 1,:.�h:n' 'J:al. ii:!1!Gr.: P.!: :v!1't l!Y..> n°xvi';x,.,^!in!x;x' :xnl. '.!11 r :!I v:.l.n'%eN.!�3., 3::.17:: :i!,�,:.:::.::.::::.a! �.. I„ .I..:.n I!;taliri ,..,9 3"ra. ..fdr. ^ifjii!i!:::. "F”: >5!ils8i 1111. ..1.w.:,! .:1.i!;x14,1 4. .xn'3:k1: r .4 Ali..,.illiM::,:::!x.A3k.',1111, ,,, iltig, .vb:.0:0, ' ! t ,.f.:JP!!;.a!:,. :i.,. ,n.!riFF';icaR, .I,Ir y. .I.. :::,.;x, ,!N'!.:. .,.1 s^a� !! ..9. 11r1�=�a!irai�l„ .,3, ..fr.. ,. 1� xl........., ,t YGJx7'3. �,{� .Y yvx:J 1 :nbt Vl,.. i.,. .I. .1.,...:-,u.,.a, .1.1.1¢ ,'4'1,! r.l 117 e:rl,t'r!1ii3:.,. „117,.1,.:0:, N.. ,1111 ..,, �,t. ` nkil!.:' t..... "!nlll.,,, .!.hl..^':. ''NN ,,L:..,......1,.rt:!!:k 4' ln,7wnxy,,,;a;!,:r ,-:Ixa;' te.:.:. 7111 ,1:,. .a..f 4.i ,W.1.:..,! .,:7.„11..,.t. .,I.:.., :l." t, ?�:,,,nn:_:• 11011 1111.. L..I ..{Lx.: .7;1'7.1"i` .0 .;•.� m ..1...f :.1.v A[1i:Y'P! ..1 01,1.. in .,, v43!iVilr:. .7.. ..vJ ,i 33".1..0., I ! iii`1111X1 !. :in !.I ,.1...,!t-:..1,- ..1 3[ a?�=hili .:.4., ,4v . Ln 1,,rv'1:!'' 1 1 •1111. 1^x.1: ,:.r,. ..I.. rlitV!rn^•a'!%tY%'r x v X 370 .1,.3.a •.!1':::n,,. 'a,:L,..,. .q i ,1,i!:o-r',. a I,v..3: ..I.I IEs.:r. 1. 3!:IY;:3'. h...s.^!.+„'3!:1at s7:!t •b..1 .L,.......1 ..i,wia?:.. kwvalu .:1.,3 'r!,”! I,.v..,.- :,,4, �7X1:1;:LO. I r riY r I !l It!:k'! "1n•v 111 i ..9 n.h.-h.., .b:.:n.:x,,!v,':x' Yl r7 a, 3:'N .1,1.:: 7bss! .Ar.... f^,,.:. u.,:�. i,.....: ..1 4LIn!A. !!!ir1!;;;J, „L: �,1 !.,1'--,M.. 7;;`I :!Y!n,t I: 17.X1 v!r :k.: uv ld!...k:.,a n'_',:�x! ..I.J ..1.^ :Y.E :U,r�; I i. ..n ENi!1'n�n:'. !:ii!:. ,.iil�.. 1^W 1111... ::..n!:r:,, ,.... 1:. .igili 4 4N^.: iNe .,:Ga.:,.:.v....v,:!. , .l::a:. ,1.1.71 i .1.. u'rl: .. ..1.7., .1!iw:. ,^,.I i°`ir ,,,¢1111..I1 :.:ih...hv.,.1!' 'r1,t:;.a, :.Nuv 1. 7111..tl.^ hnn rl:. : .t.:` .^1111.:. r.4 ..I...1 1:11%!!, 11111.'",4•, ,..7, T%'h:t 1111.. ..A,'.7. ,r,h,:; 1'f..,.:,:1,111,. "t.3,:.'i. ..L..i. ..4.1: ..h..;;s ...n�:71.7 %{ry :..rl o-.l.k:!I,... .^,:141:11!1 :I,. 1,:':7. :,,.1.1:r.. 'i!,a 7.f:n:NaS>.,::.Y.... fi, ,a.;..r:.a I„ i+„ f ..I 111:1. ..!,,,..:: i1. .:3..... r r., at..:,,, ,.:.:: I .1,..J::;k;,:,:. 71:11,.,: r, !:f4:1,,xa!::;.:,.:,.^:.:::::x::ra:.,d .Yl, r:.s,. o-7s vl .,I,.., :N,1 ,:.. �rf!i�:,,'.,.. ,.( .^,1,1:1:1:: I !..,!.b!.,.:,,1,111.1.. . 14. �:7h's� .L... ..1 .,!!3.1..."",EN11N!5f ,,7axV. I... dL, `:;.!x'7'.:.N A.a.s :..1 .:l.l :1:111,. ,!Y !:. .:f .,il:i ' 3.1. In:itY!4i!ni !,.u...:,:r,i:;,':k'rV!,x:;axa'a„ax::i'•;%x.7!,.,. ..I, ,.L' :y 116;7'7!%: L, h..4 %;yr.,..,...r:::: !::!!it:'i:f .:., ' la. :l kr! 'x:A.V:.r':A:i!rk!:r::t .:i•! ,.rAn.,.,....., %:7::7•::::11,,.7F'i'G37: I. 11,11 :.4:.......a:4!,:;....,. 11,{.1,1111 ...111 1!X41,,,:,.'k,r::..v ..,A, ...1.1... 1::x4.0,.:,,.,.::: 1...1n..':.. 1X11:,,:.1......:1':1,:1: ..I!:ms!. :..,.. :F7.:..,, ..4,,.,.."•5x{„ a ...to-..,. 1i77::iP :k.k%if!i:i3k3:3kN3s'i!'kr:7x':4!.: cr.N „I. .,i .i..,1:^:... ,I S:::P,•^,,.kv :17,;11;!711,7"!7C!7k:J”: !.L . ..I. ..1 ,,:4111%;t'y!,NiXXiiri![ .,,. .1 rel:: .3.1,.-.1 :.J 1.. s .:. d.1.: ,!1':.:!. 'NEI r7:.,..n !.,::1„LAn 0n0„u, ;315;'1 L'I'r7” �rnl !013.i,:1..::, ..,!I:% 14:. ! J'"'L•,. n 1!, 151.1!1„• 7•'lilia �:U,w O,,,., },r ..L .Isn7 :.In..v,!:.. ,,.,. 1711! .L'iYr .1.:.... .1 ,(: �Nt!niX 39111^.1; .,I.. .1.. . :'..�... 4..^i! ..I. .:I?Y!nrr�!!! ..3. x51,4`, ..IA Inds719ii:k!:n! .,!. .,.l... !0.:!.:. .!! .1!:1�n ..{., .7.11::.'1,. ,.N'! ;G•1� ',n,-d:",.:: .11.1. '1,, `!?h..:.. x,:111... ..,1^,.. n.l 7117:,.:v.7;7,3:3:k: iii! .,.7. :r..x:111.-: J,. r::id.. ,.r J' 1....!.... .: 1,i:31i.w,s4• :.if.k7,...3 - ,:;:11�ihiiL., ,, 71 Lbr.:.. .A.,.., .LM, :..'4i7!x 11. .fa h. rX,":,..:..: 1ar3!Ia7"rf'!57: , { 114,4 ..X311, ,1,111.: ..I,ru,:x:x .,'+.,:,A,.7x.,;,': .,.1. .,.:1. ,.t.J.'., I'0h3,, 4�I;,;.v.., • f...l:. 4111..... ::,,r. ,:.,I .f:..... . .7:1,111 ..:r..:. :.. ..rr,,.,.;:.. .,::s'114!:..{. ,... 1111 �'�i Y r .31. 3!Nr17;,J:.,• 77.!11.1. iyi:l�.1, .,!an,... t,.::..:... 7:11171 is ..3.. i,us.:. , L,::N941!lr,i; ..1..,,. .1:4,.II .i LII Ia:dF'i:! 3'3! . 'rf!S'w., ..i.., 1,,1111 ,h;,;0. .,:L7a.....! rn1.": :!!45x! 'x.J,:. ..., naL.,. ..�- ,!nXw::,:::::7,:,a:x-..,:.^: IJ, ..II, ..,.sb7k, s.1' .ly:a:3:3a:,.::., 111,1 ,.n,.r. ...,A..77nm.l!1i ... 111,1,'..!.,.:7:.7 an!,,,a......."::.:,...,....n.7.7,.,.:;..,.i.: ::,.,:.1111.. 1111 ,1111.::. i,i.l, .. .I L. ,:,n,,:a:;nrx'nkY•a N';iriaNlNNES`!5:_ax!: ............. ...I... 1111..: ..........V 1111 1111.. ........ r 1111.. ..1. :1 11,1.,.:-ar x:,5„ ,,,, 1. ........ ,1...9 .,Inikiij3!Xnx 4gnk::::A%'• .yI..s.. ... :.. .,..,.1717..1 .v -I:I........:......":....v, .,., 1111. v.. 111.:,..:1111 v.. .....7. .......,..7,.^„ ...:!. 1.:...... ..:. •,..111..., .. A ri'Yi,4.1.1... ,1.- ..I.:..:.:v ^I,.; 11,11 11! ''1 11,.1...11::...,.....:..,,. ......... .i 1.,..... I .,1:.:.7:do:!v r",.... !1.::!n. ' 7:77:I... Jyl! !,.:I.1.,::;:,!i:I:,:.: :.,.:::::3...kN:':,,. ...::w".,.,1111: . ......,11.,1::.!.I ,0," ::k xr J.:x; n:.. ,o-n.n:..0. ,:.1,x0,: § .::. ! '131rxSE :Y,. x1::1..........:........ Barefoot Beach Access 100 0.5 5 1 x Barefoot Beach Preserve 356 1 342 3 x x x x x Vanderbilt Beach 150 1 5 1 x x x x Clam Pass Beach 175 1 35 1 x x x x x North Gulf Shore 25 0.5 1 1 Tigertail Beach 210 1 40 1 x x x x x x South Marco Beach 70 1 1 1 ` � �1, 4 ,x444444 ' 4 �:_ k. ,.^ < �. _ p x x City of Naples Beach Access 1048 42% 6 46% 35 x x x x x Delnor-Wiggins Rec. Area 370 15% 1 8% 6 x x x x x L;!f'xikx:,:ix:3:Y:a:,:01! !;:.;:1,:x;:1:i:ir:; d:l :i:3:,:i:r::X!:iri::ra.::y:,:0..: 111,'1:.. :..1 ::P:fki;77716i:kl;xxs:Xrns13!:w:i%Xn:nru<:a::!,ak :.�. J, ri-.tx: !4'71'117 x:. '351'3:!. •!!!ik:tx 7:1:1i:!:7,:::7ii5! ,.,§.Y .!a.•a,xxxmar 71:7rx:a::!x^� 1x,1,..,4!i.a:n.,:.. •7!uaJ,:: !'.:51,1.. ::a:1:!:r,::Y:�::k3:!':::,x,:3'1:, ;7'x:ay.r .1 .^.!,,. 1'31:31,1,"i,ki:!'i"!:'. ..1.,..... ,.I..1,.,! ,! �„xi' 111,1 ,h:! :.r " r4;r:: `;i�.x . l i:b!'b!:N'::9k k.7..:.. rl nJa:$%311`7; :4,n.;..: ,^.:1,'!1•,.7!0,0x,0 7: 1701,. 11617'✓ 1 I.,.,91J?'117X1 n ,3 .I ..4... 703.7:x1.,:.,.." r!,a `,'1;111 Iii., .:,. .L.7 :-d!Ih . 77,:X.7. 1:111 ...I1ir1;r;.., 'x ! 1111 7kla,. 11:19 7r,k!!iA^ :.fl, •t4liiif9,3!::,v .7071 4171 ..fs...,:1,1 ..I: 11,77.. ..z,aui�i:Y,."nr .,:„,, ..I,a.,.:N,,... ..1 �. 777:1 ..L,.. ! [i 3`11.i!!.. 1,.7.17 ,:4:x30 :,:.4'1iiNir:,.4,. , N!: !,,, 5174,1 1,3.,. y.l. .1.7113::lr yi :r%... ' ,1..1. ...1 1'11..07:;:.:{,.r. .:t..... 7.,:1... 1IA.,: :3:1, '714:7: ..N.r ,!Y I ' :..41,, ,3.e!,;,, 'J!i17b. .r:51'G ..!.x'^.:.:' ..t ,1.L IY.. �r::G.^1111,. ,-r4:,:re s3.,i:r.t ....I... 117::., Y:;!': s..,., ..:i4^t n. .1. ”11.71411! 4l : �3! I!. 'n'r6' -.,A�1, k I':,, ,.;4'1,"�1 117'6, I .,,.1.;a.,:n:.,.NA:1 pli,1:;9! ,4.: ii„. ,"1.. .Ix,. Jr 41111':i ..�' ,! I :,1.:ffr x1.11 �!!.N , 1 r1. .,,A:... , r..T.r„,., 0 11,x0. If:7.f 711. :.P. .1:. aY„ '::.,1.•nf. rlf.a. 'r..3 .1151 19, .1:1"' Y,r1 I... 1, � v.l.ln."A,s'•, :Ixr' M7I,�. f' vt ,9•1!1 I.'ii lAr .PL,4311 I. ,1 A 6.x "11 h' r.!. -,1. � I, k!. ."'1!11:,I l:s':r! r f .1 ,. ..4 iN t ..I1 ..I .n'. :.7,. sX;'I:' .,!It" .!h. 37:4 r: .,a3,. 1'sN! s I. f 7.n •J1,. 3i,;n'r r f. ,..f.1 111!1. ..I 1! 1 1: ''i.. :!a, a,5...I N1�. 1„11 11 � :,,. I1,. 7!71:4 1-.. L. �::...N,!:, •..I:. I x114!.i h:;Y1f...14,1 .p'•.n�,1 ! 1 i:3 1•'777: h.1.. ,.,. i'i!!X!�;:�I''F''1 riw3 l.r 1., r:.l' I IM' .:ix: 41:. 'N LI77 ! �,. ryy� y,f!IXi lin ir�i d x�. 13. n3:.L: IJ.�44.: :.,I .'.I II,. .1 1 I .!,':1041;;,:0115 L 4 ,:,!so- "e4. I�9 ;,117,4 I�I"� e P'.. ,.IIil 7!,i LI 1 N 1111.1. 3!1.3.:1 ' I,I 1 I ..N r.Y.l 4'!111'1:Jf,i' N5!wlli'GI.i 1 Ik 1,1. 1X77 11x!11. ..�� ,,,1,.1. f 1 .,.741tt! ,1 1171 I r'I I li. a.. ixA'.ik'.'.., �I df"�.w:ul h,3�hlx7.ln,!f�1111..I r,7.. ,.{' y.�'�I!1b ��r:. .1 1 W.i , x14 1111: ! f.. I�!I!I:: rI I tillli i:.l o j„:Y. ' iillil..i! IrTpdr.� ..t}!.111110.i ,i,,O,i ..L x !.f.:: .1 r .,1'f II ,'!I' rtylpp , "i, ''!! ,.. �U rr. 1 3 r ,..h.,lt. .I IJ!'.t.+v ..f..:, I..�.r. N; ,�r.:"� ':rl!a .4 U!!4 i I. a,f1,7.4H !. ..h{; !aX1 , Y3,. „i .Ilan,�q•. .f -s:,. '.4 �t 111 �vl r 1.1 !1, 1 I I I. 1711.. '7 ...:�,:. .Nny1, y :oi%�. h7n LI. .,f4i� NtY a, ,If 1n�Y!,A11 X41 �.r.nr.n.11. .111.!11� ..ILpp''L� :,�.: �I , .,1 ��. :J,. ^'':1:!III•:..:y�>�' h. .rn .,. 'til „kAN I � I , .I.1,1G:11 r II�:.G.. ..t .,J,�::!,.1:.1.L.., .1147 ,1 UI Ox��Px 11 `jj i '7';1':1x1 1 1.11 n. , �,' 4 wq'. f{I 1 ::i „4, 1:1.. I. ,4.-11§ 1I. .a.. 1:, :17.01, da 7iN' it 1,711, !ti! L.b:f1.w.5 f '., 1„,,..011,1NiI .A15 A.:'7 '.n, 1�t' I” !, ,.. !:tl I'1.% ^aA'1'!7�3.7 7 E N!A.Y'1,71,4 .JL 111.1. !oil,�i.: , �..k.: ,!6Y` I.,I :,x771! 1,an., x77!ix,: '1. .h 1.b.: .'an kr1NXf!;:.:fl ..l h.: .t..... 1�1•.1•,"u�. ai:i!�!:7 ...r r N ( PXI 4dW .3� 7111.,.if4 xr,,r,.1 hry 1tt3,fG'1::1 9: I:.Ir.,. �: .:I: ..At^ I. ..m'r I f...a 6,;431 Ir. t:..'f .I. vry.;r .1... !' :I ii.., , 411! ,a0 I.. 4 k ,,.,Yr.!.I a,,b) ::• .B irilio 1.. , : hu, i f., ,r .,f..4, nn7 II x ,11.'74 i-:r,In(� 1+X71 �aii..��!�4 t!,,., ,,,tlLlnf x111!?.,;171x'71.d, .AIV:.... .1.7 .» „, t7'E16a ..r I :N7 ..1 �1x. y li::,, .,IaXa:`5!G 4.t 1.4: .:.i. ..M t.l!:n .ya�I :�. h...... .n,li',a!i'N-,. ,.J., ..h,l ,.1 ,:u.. .x i. 3 , ,. .F n!:. .•.t 6 IY!�' rf'.n ..I, ,.11,4 fl x11.•.7 .114'11.. !!r'n.,.....iYl.... ..i.. .:.i:. tN1! C: � Y: I1. N,..t,�l It.i r`4 6,1,1;,1,!. .,I i.'h: E.. ,,,.t.. :7::11x 14.7.,7.";r,4 ..al !4J 4,.i PI 7x3, ,.n.,. !. ..LN. .'4111,,,,1 J!;7::n 1'4:1x. .0111 l7x n 5. ul,ll;n1 !::,h „x.,17x7....w!,y1 ,,:x11 , L..A... W4.. ,177 ..�: ,r ..I. _:hl.:, "f: I t 1 .r...,. :3.. a31:1:r1k7 »431:7.7 , 4,1x7.. .3:.Id. 1. :1 .!„ f..,t^�'., : .,1117... 57'31, 11„ ,!.�, :I,4.: 'a'li'.:an.!E;1� ..i 1 b .1 1 ht;:.. ...I,,. �:. r 11 .5,,.,;411 ,:.�., .1.4;,!N o-,:1 ' :I. .1.! • ,II 1'777:•.x':. ..NI iX7:� rl. 7'3 ,A f. .1 i..., i,4 14x.,:,,,:. n,.1 i .,, '�117�1„ -� � a ., 1,11.1� !,n.. .0•.,,.,, ,a':,3o.., 1., �..,rl f^I l:u k 4 Y:.. ..3 :11.,,.... If. .r.:';1 ..h4::. ,I.r ,,,11..., �� 1,t r o-!s :1: �:4 3 i ..14 -.Y,I 1 I �Ah.. 0! yy 71!1115 1.::,: .,!.,] ,�X G1^1'111 f: r::7!110- :.4,1 .x1!11..! .�::! rL.x 1 el � L. 1. .. r It 6r.., 4 't.7., 1:.1,. ..�... '::1f.�,�' .,Irl'!7Y.-.,L:.f 7.., xn.. 1 ,.L ,u!1 ..i .X. 1� a3.1 .1.141,,.. I 1 ,..f n. Irl ..1 .!...9.., :1i. ..17.! 11.7.1;,::..,1^.. .771,..,. x,1 . .1.., ..711 .:X: .....,!. 7..,}rhrw`a 1 :,;,x;;,7,1 1111..,.3P,1 ...,..,1:.N.L...:.,..... ,,:X1.1....1. 1.1. 7.� 1 Ir 4.. N: .3 .,., f1„. f..d�..1, L. 1:1... ,1:: : 1 .. ,. ,,.r 7 I ,... , .,,,,. 7r7 1.,1....:..7 I. :,. . ,:,:,,:,:xx:,.11:,:dar,,;.r!,:t3:a•„1,,.1, I :%.:, ,3... .,1,I ti ,0 liy a:.1. .ti 7 !r ...x.:i:kLa.:, x''il lb ..L. .!! ..�,!!!,.SI .., 17.71 lr ,I,;1113,"!. 111,1,.,,.. , ...1.,..,.., ,.II,.. ,1 .,::vi..: t.s: , i... .I I. I„!, .4!::.t .,NI I. !!1. .77 b,-,.,. ,r,. ...L..; ,4:47:1-:r,xr-„r.. 1::x:,1; .:xx .17 p I, II,. .1�4n1. .,N! ,f., ...�.r..t h.:, .,.L.7n ..J' 1., i.: �IL::..,, P11141111110310101101 t .91. .I!.... .::1:1:11 X'n” :.n II'' .f i :.01 0111 ..n.. �k..: !,A.!:.70} t Aa'': 1�. ,I 11.1'.:. 7'.3,n. :91E977 11 , ::'Pa^i7 ,I , Nr0 '�#Ui:x:xx's! '.'11. !:1. . .:LAI.. ..,1. ,na,!s :,;1.:7,71: , ,.�..1 ':A<,7 r,:l. lir l!,1. : �!,... !r,NrAn1r':1":• n.4x�•"�: ,01,1,,,1101:,.,..1,110,1„..,+.411111 I'N1iir5i:a xxr. 1 ,.L , I 11 r ei7hEin'::33,�y'.0 i, ..fr;i t..i .,!.. 1x1.1: :7..,. Aiax;aN,. r .nl.. '! 1:1 :!ky:x117P 7n,.. !, 1:.'.,s1t.1,1n1G 3'S Il,rrn -.ill n7i'6 (il'. I4! . .Iv.1 1 A,4 !In. 7!X41.. ,v �.4 !X! .I 1111! :'71. I.'1-... '}1:'1011,1ii:5,..�1.. x111.. !ifLl7aiq'r.s.-.:a , I .,.: ..4, ,5.51, !u:G1 ii'a wLl!7,:!7e....: A.I 1 .,I. .,.t.. ranar'�:: .,t.. ..f!'..�r :.1.:..7 1 t. •1,1:,11,b1:xx... h,.x N.:xE.a .I I A� !11.1. I., .!.t.. ..r....!., ,,, .,LI .rr.157� .i1,.a1....i. ,i. -f�' !,r ..I. :r,i!- 77L.,97,w 11,11 !:,t.. :x11, .7 'in':., t.J...,. : 1d 11�1 :I: ::�:, 71,11.} ,.5..:. ,:,:4!::4:•,1::::7 x.: : % I „I"...a ithf: .:nG. ...Lf .t,; 71:x7!, J. .. .,.. N, :! 7,11.1 ,rE'3-1,1,1:1 ..1,...7 'Y,.1 I I Ln ,.i t 3. ,.f.!.3 I .! :'!!Y'!' t N 'i1 ..i.� ..111.:1 1.X7" +.,i,. .I ,1.3%:7'777.-..1. 7 b.. .If.,N ..71' MI1111A ,71,4. 1,nx... :,7x r7P'ri' ...� f�!!..1 I,:, ff a.. .!I':7 ,:1:n,,..:;'... 137'4 ...I t I t L., v.... ..{.:.:, ,r yr n1r:N7!";''a!:,... J r 1'1;'1;1 Win:r,ai:n:: . 1.1,'. .1 ..L. ,.,..,344:,. !.ill ...1!: ,,1'1' :fSn,, a::... : ,f.1... :Ji� ,.I 7,::a.7r.h . 1 ,4 .1 ..,.� 4 n 111,1.. F. 11a 111131'11„ A pi4.0 ."Yr,:, k%i1..- x713 ,.n:.:x..,., it i^f! 1111 ..n7` ,:al. 14.. I,..:k3 i .,,a.,uP ba!: 117.::..:7,::-' ,.J!a.:::r.:1L:.,1 ,::1.: !..,11,1 1 15.X tl: „I. :1 atil,ll:. f.. NI.r.:::..{....,d:. :!� 1.1... A .4.,71 ^.4..,. 14:4 �L. .I 4.. ln'.'. '.A !ar 7,.,1 ,:1 ..,4. ..i.. .!.f..:.!5i„ inft :,.(.:. 11:11 ,.41. 7i. :.1::x,.17 if V. :r11'in!E:,!.L.1:1. itr+ [ s,.l,!9:f:.,:. r:,.: Jr C,. ,..I., :7;FIX2 13X'.... !1139,. :.P ny 1. r::.l;., ,.1., L. "14^ .4 .,A'.�... Pk': A,!!.f..I :.J.a, .13.':, 1 .:1 x171 „r ..1. :.!! 1:4.1` II,,�� 'I ..1 ,.x:ar7rA. , .L .rf 5 i,1 ,:L, .,,I.,IN 7-.i, I:,,,1. :p� 1.t ;4. 17!7i sn a. f ��IIn7::P Ix!”: 1,1,11 '•f :.r. ..!. .,1.. !.I I ;,,, J 1 1,. ,1..1.0, .!,d„ 1.7... ,,., °i;; n5r!J,� f.:.3 I lr,, , 'tl 7,1 ,1!x1,7:: ::,� ..1. 1111! !n I: '•:xl:'! ..alk ! I. 111;.1, I t::,Gx,:,:7:k'•, 7.1.,., ;:1,.5. ::..;�-• i.. H . 1 .'f l�., An.kn!:::,,..,+.{. 1,..i_. .17 177X,. ..,40; 1x11 eis,x,3w �.I.I IGI , JI.1v..1.7.i .:.r , ..4 A..1:1:1n'tP"111 ..1..'.1, x;;31,1,7 I..,r 4' ,.Y rt':":..:,:,,.r.::., y i 4 7 •1..1..1. !.. I f. w11,:x., ,11111 r.f'Y''" 11. ...,.1 7,4,X11 :.�., 11141 .X^?';i' Y7'::,. .�I t . 5 a ,i l r, :1n. ,In,.,::a:.. .;111.'1 � 4! •;1;711. ,.I. ::.bk..:m A'w"31 , 1,...1.'!ir .rltA 1... ..E: .h. '1111... 171. 111.1. ':nn.. .,n.:•. 5x.1!1%ki�,.7ii7 p�! iwf.a..,l,f,..:,. .,1. .5., 3£'I. 171.1 ,41,7 I..r ,1.! '!6,.., ?.�l:c.. ,x1'7.:1.. 4%G,J,.,.,.. .;�..... .I .11 ,14,44,,..1:,,,,,is•:...:., .1,11n.1. :f.::1::!1r:;;:4lr"'r%1`�.,7i A ,.. :t ,71.1 11Il 1i .,.A., !.,., „I ”.:114!.., .,A nr. �.:n::;!,.,,. 11.71 , I ..,.171:•1••,... .I I ,rix!,,:7 ..11. �r1."5:.. 3.1:f ,1111.:!„. . .. Inr„ l','n; ,,3. !:71 .U1. 1 :T,'3:9ya::..,,, ,i;�7':FI3F'37!L r: ...1.I:. 1 ,.f7147 ;r•4'!:;AN 1:t1:1........ 11,1,..1:; 7!,x7 r ..L.. n:f. .1. „f.. :77,„:9::.�' ,;,1,11 54 , .7 011,1.. .,.I:^! ,.31.-A Lr:7� ,...N1!i' .1 1 V.1 ..i 1x:1'!. .1,. A'!,,,.:..:A!' ..1..,..- ..I. d , Ixel!i1 7 .. .1.. 1111!:-.,v i.4.. %3%44n!i.,» i .':,5;i'" 0M I 1x1 .! 11,h g.:N;i;xJ!:;::.r:.7,5�." z.:1.. I .I.!^,..... "n{33kn',,,.- '?ilii 1, '!k 1111: tx, il, 17x:: '1.1 E,.IW1 .1.!: ”'J .,N..,1..: [n 7x71 .n7, p Iii17.a'. �.!.i, it 11 ,,,1111:, 4:.1. ,.I 3q,1:41 ' !1;'['71'11 .5.774:, .17....� ..I, :,r+.lA.r.r. 11::4:x+ Iw:...17 �1x!7., 1, I. ..IA.. .7rlM1 ..1 = 1..1. �71 s! ::�3,"::r>•:` aA''3% ..1 ,,..1, !x71!: :.,. :f n" 3112X1. a.i!"::. .,.I .Ji',' M 47:1, I }I:n ,..3,.:.,..:,.:. ...�:' ..M'a ,,11.1,. . LI.., , ,1,b a1 ,.,12§1; ,1 I'r 'N y,l ..1 Y..f... ,,il:iv, .,.. .:.4s:,� A11. 1 17 t:: 11,1,,1 , .7:11 3 x w'; 71'^ ..,:1;r .:nxx:!!w 0011.... ..1:5:i211b. 1 1;3 li, " 14 Iv"n:L...., !n{.A N.'I:' .•a.u!. ..131'7 1174 it N,.J.71 nllirj,�1Y11�"Nt 17:::. !4131 x '.1.. :1: .I, .3� 11;'14...i r�r333 1..X.74:i .1.7,.", 7,3 11:!.7....,..:1x7. 6^ � 1 ,1 r'1i4� L.. v.l, 11;��. i'1111. ! I 4:11117; !3,,: .,Lv:. �,.1'11:79,.17E 17%3P:0,. 'iI eal.. : 3: t1 ..7,. 1 x71 Jf., i,� %1:j7AY:7:a4.eis 1911 !4!x!4 ! i.. .:I� .1 N r.. 1. x.9., x,.3.NL:f.^, .h i. .I. �G.:rr`;; 3 ,r ,:I.� i,...I 4 >! '!{1171 .,.1 1 ��., 1,11,,1.,, ,r... ':'�..:!`!i;2 a !..s. .I 1..,7 is�r it 1, x!1117": L. ( N.6,..:. ,1,14%`:! ,ti7k71iEa,,,'`iir11'si;1i1r7i. 1r^;! .:?, L.n.,..4111 ..n..i...- ..t .1,., ,1;1'1 1 'x'I .:.4 .IIID 111,,7... '';�...,,i7. 7a... ,11x1. .:,, 'n7P--•..� .,:' ,1,,A, ! :I„ .N. 1x11. ..!I .7147,. 1,1:A'a^:. '^'3x1!'17 �... 11,1 1111.r,•,,,,,:' .:r F:,. "f1,,: na,a ..! J 3,. 't .I. i'a 4".. ,A... o-7177... :I; 'Xx':.. 1, .11x1!'''"ii:{: I.!n"3N1!n:, t.. .:a4^� ..f... .:! .I , ,�xr'" :!'71,......7.7 i. �. ...n' .01 .1..1....1,:, ..L: 1111.. ..:1x s•... ,!' .I, l'1�'.rk ^ 1411: .n f f. 1111,.A'.'•17 .I r: ..71! 7,x'1.1, x,6” 3 x 4: I :..k. .�;al.r. I7:i,. 11 7n1 t "An.l il. ..N.IkI �i4'1E': ...rl.i.G:1r,n 'iii...,w ,.t,.. ,I, .in An; 0,71'1 .7X'11 r' N. !, 7 1 11;,,11 .Nf�1'1 11.7. :ii f :x:71 'f 2r.,:,.,.,.,7.r.1111: r!i 117 I!:1 ;.41!, f. 111 ...4,7, 4.. h 1.1719,X. 111111r:111111$1 !I f.7. ,., :;4111 .,'N!N&a, ..11, :1,1.N :lar. ,! !::h tl, 'J 119. . ..1. ,-I:' � s .xi'.7.xnwi", 3.,,:,,:!,.1. r 1114., 11,x1.a 012;'2 1 %7v ..1f, 7� 71'11 ..I.iih ..I I., .r: 17" 1 !'llrl . '' 1.' :i,:,�, Whir• .i,. a... ,�L' n.1 112'15''' 4I..I. �•1,: r 41111.1_4,H ..} FL:: i::!% "+41..1 7i-, ..17 ',rii r 11111911111011,11 1.7 �J r.� !: ? ! ::t�;r Nf. n7317,,.., x .,1 r'L4A, h a'!I ,LL' i.,,:1 :..I.. ..14 .1i 1.7 f. I�'7....vll .1 N.MI�n.41. ."i, . I. ( !t:A iltt i'I .I •4('!::1, ,..17, I• .I I ::s 112 2r' +n r1` 'w..d. .I :.s:!pI � ;!411., ,i,. f'i. I I.,4 nirr.1 I 1'1• L' II 11,1,1, 117:t. A'I, !,N7 r. .t.. :1..... :,N1, � ,.Ili. If .4 ,X? t. f I 7,.,:nx:4.b, ..'N.„, r. ,,.. 1111 � .7i':” 11.. ,,. 1.IfnhS iii: :Gr1%..x 't5'r.Iirn';. ..,1-, 4!111111 P1 i! ,.4� , 1 ,�!, 1714'. .,! .�...1. L..1. x,�:•,.,- ...!.m M.1, .. I f l!, .. 1111 1 .III I L 1 5 fin ,.1 .'n!.. I. .. N�:!246.. m�7I :' .�,71h:n .I!' ..,:h.,. ,.�i.l , 1 :f .�r . . f7, ..,I. 'iiF.•,,.1 ! 1' � 1, !7.1.1 I 1 . . ,v71rW .:,3!1, ..,17. 1. ,::1..... Ai!:Ekr I , i 4, .: `X, ..t. 1,r.,.. 'X•I ,N:r .111x.- L.. .!.I. ..l.r: ,.. :;34!,: ::nn1;;'t . ,.. ! ,1,111 ! 11,1::,...,r:W,,:k::r'.... : 1 I', 11 J. •I 1111.. 1 II III � :.117. ,1i,.. .1.I, A, i. , „If, 1111 1.X47.. .L"4,.k.:�,. .i.: Lt :., I., ,.rx.n..,,.. ...1., '7111.=,' k.{.,." 117.7;:!i::n...f I,II qty �.. :,,,:1! 24.1... ... ....,f,.P.. I.. J..:.: ,1:„ ,.,� ..4. I,1 Ifl l II. 1.A.,,: ..Iv I .1.. 1 , :.411, 1111. f :aEG3!i ..N..... ,�.. ., 17x1 i .,4 :7r...,.. '16 '1k.•, .,,{,5J° :1'r 1.1 ..1.,.. .:: ..1,.7.1 i,. �i ! 3E 1:1.1,:. n!:1 1” 1- �1 ...L. .,,II 144'713 LA!., A,4 al"1!1:+. . .L.. ...... :,:§ 79,..11� 'r:1 Lx C`.': th^r3rn+. :f f, .I. 1111.".,,. ,7f, IL.. : J. ,.A9x-,. ..n.:.. ,71 ,..i,•: 333 .` ''Jt... 1,,111 ' i !!1, »'rt^s7:n 1111," r'1 �. .i :0Lw' 1111: 'I.I.,, 1 ,1:, 111'7 !,1,Y..1, 77:64,n !..h.. !.1 ,t,n.l,., .1. I ::n,n1 ...�' ..a .1 3X!9 I ,4i,. ,u W.:r ,1.;.,,X7,:.1, ,,:! I f7N. I!, 13;11., 5:r„ 4.!.. 111;1... 11111,Li. .s.:: .! a'!1.,.... aal +:In!!r,.,: I!7 .1. 1{ F, , Rol 4 .IJ�s19;if'i . 1!, yy .f.,, .!'177 11'14!,. .:1",". ,11:4,1..,, 1F,<,1. ..II:. .11. of.. 9.1:!:, .1N., 1 i.. .1 1 111,1: a .�": 1' 1..: .1..1.. ,.N.._.. .'4. 7.4 ,vnt.. . 1 n!;f.�i:1 4,11. !'!'i"n 1, „xl,. 1n.. n 1!,..,, .11,1. '4i..,-„ 1..: ,4 .1.,. i.x 1111.7111... i 1111 7 0!11!:7 I,. ,�1.>. I" !n1!,::., .L,.!1'X10: ,a:L... x:@a9 1:!3::xa!; !!N ,a YIL„:,, ..1:!I .,14, !., ::II ,x11'3:Y1'%v:41x "MI OP... 111 a.: ..IA.:.a:.y J ,f ax: ':I,in. :a7 1., 4 a,7 .N.. 1!......I. .,!,,. :L::r':;,:71,'.7 1,.t n 4 r.. 'i:,a 1':" it , !., 4.� ... 111..'4,. :0,xx , ...I An 1 1 .,41 1 Lr,:1.112":. ..!1' �1 � ,11!!1%1..1. ..,a, !7f.x. ..1 441• .0 .3,11,11 x!:U,�;..1., � .11'7.:1 I G I'N'.,8,. ,'i•,r h. .. .,I fra.,"-.,y. ,LI,4 ! n....Yr: ..II .I .1......... ..., ....t ..L,...,.,,1111,.,. L....J ..L.d: ..JI':, .3. .,.. n�,i7:.7,M ..4..t. .yr A:r. '�1:1:..7 ..f,.N! 1..7! ..k.1111 ,I .{' 4 a!:1L x111 „Lx. f It ...I k' 11,, r a�ax'G+.n.,1,111. f:.,a x,!. 1::1 .:1..1 :.A..a:.,.. I i .'„ X 1., . kb. 'i 1'1111140W� 11 f 9' !f� .5 9' :ayI F7 3:. 7i:1,'r, 1: a ,X. 14. x,n r 7 I- II99'' 1,11.81 71'7 .I. ..i I ,.3,, � .:A 1171 e �,. 17x1y' , I A :IKK el I .h N..Y. .1,,k, in:.:. •5N'9'!x1,1 !I.G.7:1,,7 '1...�:: 1fn.1 ..1..7.7 a, :;:f1,: X... .I 's'L. .,I' T1 .n... ' x.,� 1 v l x., Ilif' :"11!rx .1 w .L.4 x141 1 11. .1 Y ..I..,. 12;£71.: ,Y!. 7�1 . ..t:n. .Ania4 A,I. ,t. 1'5.1• MINNi:.., .,.:ua ,i - -:,w7. .�•1!7n;: ...d,. 177:0: aw1..171 , .i.fe,'.M::, :�Y .n1,7 .:.1. !IN:1114,1:d.: .r.. 1.. 1,-n 1. ..i.. 1 ,:,,,.-,.,{ ,.f,I r '.t..!.., Irl.. x1,11^w, r! ,„1:,,.7.r:, ,I !....�'.. .I,! ,,1x11,. ��7X11 1:11. h..da .I, -•i'... ,r:! it L. 11 ,.1, I.. H! r.117,1 ar'I i, ,„I,. ! :,I. ,.I.. 11,11,:rA.,.:1:. 4!�!,: iq., 5.i ,.,E.A'XN;,.: a l w'.aA'1 11'X!1 - :.t.-. r,.I.1,x ,1.77 I. ..1. i ,1 ,.t. 471X. Y 1 � .1.:, ,9 I,.x ::,:1, :!i J,..x.a.5...: ..1 f I. .10.1, n a`!ifll"N ..J..1 vrl' 7!3�i!':r1! �. i I ..:n.. p "s7p 7 r!uxxx "i I:: 111:¢,x, .:1s:xi. ,I ,.:y.. 1.7 !2.,..;. 01,11;, ,1. 1.1771. ,n',,1r7.Aa.a : .1 .4.. :174,,. 1 �1 ,.I.. .I.1� x,nl �j1q� I �n:1;..:, .L..,::^111 J In!i .I 7 1111 A ..1.. 1 ILrS'1��3 nt;i,1. 'vi , II., J!�}'i: i„In:3r::ri..I '1:71'13 VIM] 1 ..17 I %nv4.. xyl1 �1r,„1(1. '1'41,7 .17 1 �7 li.„L,1 .nl•, t.. ..4 11:,,,..,,,11.,„11,:j.„.!..i4 '1rX.L1..„ I.'1. i XI::: ...L. ii:,!4.:. ,.Lb ^'17,'11 1. .ff 1 , :L_ r:,..,-:, !Yr.:o- al ,:' 1' 5 .!. qii r1Y1i4 A 117 I. .x41. N+, r.'' a, 4 nw..f ,.i;. !tl It� Illf �.fr'' . `I•!'!'�N f ,1. a, ,A91 x�..,.r. :x99x..4.9. 7e' 1.1.1 L'.4 ! 'r'1. .'1 �..r,. ..1:1,.,. i 1 17 .1 ! 1111. I:: r1 1111 .!. ,.!. ,1111 ,:f 1. 111.1. .iw, 1111. 1,.. .111.,I , 1 � I L1!I •i 54!1 ..L I.I.1.1...! 1 !I .1,11 '10 '":,t +4 �.: .LiA7f,...� , 'N., a 14� ii,1111,, . . ..J,.: .., f..1 r. .4. ,.I YI.L,,!n� A I r. A1.7 !I!s' 0,fi 4! .11.1,, ,1111': yy ,�. ':A!:'Xa3rJG13's.a;! !I,n."•., 9n1111,I ,.117:. 4 1 r , 45'!: ..1 L.'.;:'E!4.....x1,4.11 A.. 7i: ..3( , N 1 f ...i. 1•n.,r7;,!.„ 01. ..!r.. 1.,..., 77.1.7 1..1 .I.. ...�:' ..I.. .:7 4 0v,!.3.rfr k: ^.!. -.I,1 1114 .I f .11,..! 7.,1... L.0:...v ..i ..3 1 I. f,.111 L..�... 111.;..1.. :,..1..: t111,X. ' 11 ,•11..... .1...1..11 Iv19.lrr,A„ r .71. I:n.a'!!17",.., x":14 [ 7'11 �. I'-. ,.1:!+31:.,.,V :", ,119., 11... .1.,.f! .4.,. ,n., ..1 ,If;1:y!:.. .J...r.P 7,1,.7-'x :.:14. ..I�. !:r:l'. .1. ! L!'Y. ,.:r7.11., II�'. 11n,. 1U..ins41, :'rxA!!irx-4":':;:;x:.:�l,•,:79 1111„ : 1711 7.11 t� ,":: ,.J:1, 1411. r!, ..,�,.,� 1717'X„ .R 1, (, ..,nl 1.1.1'1: .A.. h, a,,, ,.,sf..r. 1111!,^:, n,: I. :,.n..., 1,X1:7:7 ntn.: r:l i.:.,:,r , ,±'tll.. ,,J!7.:! r.:,1!.-,1,1 •'�. .i' ,d”- ,rill 771"71 u:. � .:.11,1,:., r , Ji1f.7... 1111 15';11. 12:9:7, i.....,,1.. 2::11:,, 1.. .A.,. •:n!a.. ..3Ga. ..x11 1111:1!11x9' .i3'�t. ,.h".in ;i:�,,. ,,,. . !!•14 ,x111 !11..1x 1 1x17 ,1 ,.P... 7,1:!11.. vA'i;n1:17!911.7 i!ann x.. 111 I,n .1.1J.. 1, f<g22.r ...f 1i;lA ..11...1 1,1.1.. !,i.i...,.,x^,,......:!;17N�s; .I ,r`�. ,,1.. 4n.P. ..1.1.,.7:., ,.E, f,� ".1 . 1 0'9 :rl:o- l 1 n771:7,• .�.v x 1 .6 :1:1.1 1.,:. 11,.X!:71., .71. ,..�. f ;,,;41;!rE:l i. :,1,.41.,,: ..it... . .,..J.L1.,.^^ ..:C.. "'1 i. �,i..f.7 'i.l ..u.. 17An !i 11272! ! yy is}1:,:,1 .i... ..I,f... '47.11:.r' 1.. 1 x111. .Y ,.1.1111:£x:;:J, iln,r::v. 331,17,„ ,:".,.,!;x.:1:7s,,.,l,,::111Ln':ir5!!,1?:3110 v:L„�, .1,.. 1.1.,,,1 N9ri� j i t p �::,;, ...,..w..r',:::3,;r � ..,l is 11„4 �0 3 4.,.:,... ..1 79747 7,,f I 4.. 11';7, 1,..^'111,, .i. I,.. 1 i 1.4157: 7,.:41,.11!:7,7..7,......17..1 ,,. ,Jk:r: a 3'. 1!11'wi;.'1!777,n'!^"n n ..1.. 44 :11- 3.: ,1 I. 1111, 1,N.. .:77,7: �i:11.7 ,.,1..,. !3:40:!wx �y� ,:I, v.7G,: ,.1.1 1,4x4:,1 71!11 ji :::.r:. �r.i,,. 7144 : 6.4! .IIID .11:0-. 1.. 1 :7'X11..1!. A. .111 .. :.11. , ,,,� ..I,' ..A„.3.,1111:.. .:X...,. 5'111: ^[!14! ,:!f... 11, rA .17,I,: v .1,.1 1.,.7 ,1711!1':1, , ..I I;'1, 1in'l l'1 .i .1.1 ,.r I •'1 f..n v ,n. ...1...: .X100:,' 11111 I,. �.1..,.., ....1 Iv. 1711.. ..N .f:....,I'1 000 .,.1....0,. : ,7,I,4n415':XX!1!`n. 1 ,,� I .11' ..7�4.n!.,..,,:, !'nl.... 71.77 ..V' ,:!��N,r,: i,1.... „f ' I 1111 !;:ill:. i ,.ix:,:,::: i..... ,.,.L:... f 1.,...I.... ,., 110.. .J ,f I..: ,r :4. , n•i ei 1;.76:'P;.!. 141X`1:. 17. ,.1..1.1. a.l .17.1111;1:. :I I... !:I:',. 11.£0:x,,. ...1.-.,.0::77.x:. 31,731a m .73!17:x11!.:.01111 ....I ,r.. . ;,;.:::: 7..P. .t. . ..1,f,::.:::7:1111. ;1.19"4 1.1;. .?7,..! ia7x1;1:::, AL E:f::% ,.'!N.. ...I.. .,,,!77::n,I,:x,1R?1,:,r..:..,I:: nl..,.., ,,:I.. ... 1111 ..I.11,.....4,. .L:,1.,,7 J!">'.�::;. 1111 7¢1;;,:7'7X; .i{... ..i. ,nXi.rrG 4, ...L........ 111.. A:1....,1 .1, ,.!,1.11, ..I.,. 1 :,,:.s.......:! .. ......,. ..N, 1.71. ..4, 4.!....7 x1111:.: 1111. 11,7.... 17.31 1....1. ,x171,rA - 1111- a!'rux.A: 1111. ,i .,:1.,.;::.,1.1 1...:........,,:. 1111:fL1ri II' ns';9n1,, I.. ,.9'...;. , ! 1114.. :'r4 4 �:111:1:.....: ,...x1!1x77!�7�1 1 .i .4!.,.. 7.1:,:::77,,.. . ,,,...1';41::1::,!7.^^!.. .i,,.,.,.: I., .:,a ,:f.,.,:..x:.,,,...J;ii9!1;4Y;;,:f:;; , 1111..: .,.,..".!'.:Pxi .!. :1t11f3!!1:`. ,..f.,:.,: 1iii;i:l:r7,7t.':rx,.:,:,,.. .1..:!'rli:” 1111,., .,.:A Id77 , 1.. A,h;r::l':1'i,r:�l..1.,.,:!::::::% ..V:•:::!'rl:., 1111.. ..111 I.17 ,1,•�il11ix3:w 7.,,,..1...,,.,. :7x1!.:.bx!d!,I 1:kl:rr'�'fiv:u;:r,x u0rx:Ili!iX;q:11114!S!111n1i:!n!1:711XX4 M!!!1:aa,J„1xyn:ax!{.x1., ,..,A•.,..,1,,,. ., " ',... ::77 .,.1,111 111 !i;4411f:.1,,:t,,,.,.7„l,ia1!,1!:3!,1:.. 1111 1111... Cocohatchee River Park 4 58 62 7.2 $3 x x x 20 x x Bayview Park 1 16 26 4.2 $3 x x SR 951 Boat Launch 2 17 0.5 Caxambus Park 2 54 4.2 $3 x x x x Chokoloskee Boat Ramp 1 15 0.5 Lake Trafford (Fresh water) 1 8 2.3 x ` County Totals' 11 61%, 168 65% 88 18.9 , Naples Landing 3 17% 35 14% 12 2 $.25/hr X X X Collier-Seminole State Park 2 11% 25 10% $5 Delnor-Wiggins Rec. Area 2 12% 30 12% 200 $2 x x r >; _.. ..& State Totals- 7 90 12 202 Comparisons of Facilities Table 2 Boat Launch Percentages Beach Parking Spaces 15:111 ®CCityountyof Naples Totals t,r ®County Totals43% • � Rc7 ■City Totals r 5 Beach Access ❑Delnor i Ins BoatlTrailer Spaces Beach Front Miles 8% ®■County Totals S �� in Totals City of Naples , ' Beach Access 00 M m co Zg g I- w ra af - I- J a _, O Ce (0 Cw w w 0 0 0 Q Q Q Y Y Y a a a a a a III 1 io nd� O ",,,,,,,-.:.,,,,,,4:_;,;:1,511.!,,, �z F co io O i :.,,,,,,..v:, 0' da . N 'motor em s* O il .,...,, , ,,,,., .' N ':::::::":111'''',:,,:',7.,:r L. Cd ,'_''1,.',r1'','',1:,_''''.1,L',:l'‘,: II CD - r .. La j a) Fr k i aY . - a) a) r ) ,,, .-,',,,,-.,',,-;:"-„F-4...;liti:,-,-,-.,:,-,.-, '.- O) .' Q) t GAY O O OO O OO OOOOOOMNO O O O O O f+O OO N OO OO O O O O O O 00I O O O O O O t) M NO O O OOO00 I-- (0 a6.8Jayd' M N N NN N 0 9 v a) M z F- z u_ O W u) a W U Ir w CL W t Y Q a LU ce J UQ QQ Z W a aCC I § '‘.• c rn N m CD to N � C CDN Z .x D c Z a `m m o 0-in c Y O a t p m O a v Ll N n� i •I rn , (� 1 , a a) / O r A in Ls) C)) A' c- , A CO A CD C7) r 4 CO CO .l.- 0 O in O In O in O In O in O In O to O In O LO O Cn N O 10 N O I,- to N O I'-- 1.0 N O N O CO 00 00 I-- r- CD CO CO CO LO to Cn Cn 'Cr d' d' abeamv