PARAB Minutes 11/18/1998 PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
Minutes
November 18, 1998
Golden Gate Administration Office
3300 Santa Barbara Boulevard, Naples, Florida
PRESENT: Joseph Zaks, Chairperson
Daphnie Bercher, Vice Chairperson
Timothy Blackford
Gil Mueller
John Grice
Edward "Ski" Olesky
ABSENT: Karin English
Murdo Smith,Recreation Manager
John Dunnuck, Operations Coordinator
ALSO PRESENT: Marla Ramsey,Director
Jacquie Hart, Secretary II
Joseph Delate, Project Manager
L CALL TO ORDER: The meeting was called to order at 2:15 p.m.
II. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG
ILL INVOCATION: by John Grice
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: October 27, 1998 meeting.
Motion by John Grice to approve September 16, 1998 minutes.
Seconded by Timothy Blackford. Passed 6/0.
V. NEW BUSINESS/PRESENTATIONS
a. Award Presentation - The award presentation was postponed to the
next meeting.
b. FAA - The Federal Aeronautic Association would like to utilize the
amphitheater at Sugden Regional Park to teach people how to use a life
jacket in case of a plane crash and how to be rescued from the water.
They will use their own volunteers to show the demonstration at the park.
No representative from the association was present to make a presentation.
Previously, Ms. Ramsey told the FAA that the project would have to be
presented to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board for a
recommendation. Ms. Ramsey also stated that the FAA requests a waiver
of$800 fee. Ms. Ramsey stated that any type of fee waiving would have to
go before the Board of Collier County Commissioners for approval.
c. Ordinance 93-81 Change - The current ordinance that dictates the
make-up of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board requires there be a
representative from the Immokalee area and one from Marco Island, with
the remainder of the committee members represented by the Naples and
Urban area. Staff has submitted an executive summary requesting that
Ordinance 93-81 be amended as follows: delete the seat from within the
Marco Island Park District and increase the number of seats within the
Naples and Urban area Park District from five(5) to six (6). This executive
summary is scheduled for the Board of Collier County Commissioners
meeting.
Mr. Mueller stated that the City of Marco Island still pays the County for
3 park facilities. Mr. Mueller stated the people of Marco Island should
have representation at County level.
Mr. Blackford stated that this ordinance does not prohibit people from
Marco Island from being on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board.
Mr. Mueller stated that there were 7 facilities on Marco Island which he
represented. Now there are only (3) facilities even though it is less, the
necessity for representation from Marco Island still exists.
Mr. Blackford stated that currently there is a commissioner who represents
Marco Island as well as part of Naples and that's not to say that someone
from Marco Island could not run for a commissioner's seat.
Chairman Zaks inquired if there is a separate Marco Island Taxing District
as it relates to parks.
Chairman Zaks stated that if the original reason for creating the Marco
Island and Immokalee district was because of physically separated in
distance from the rest of the area, then Marco Island becoming a City
should not change the ordinance. Chairman Zaks stated that he was the
Immokalee representative when he originally came on the Parks and
Recreation Board.
Motion by John Grice to accept Ordinance 93-81 as written.
Seconded by Tim Blackford. Four (4) for the motion; John Grice,
2
Tim Blackford, Daphne Bercher & Edward "Ski" Olesky; two (2 )
opposed; Chairman Joe Zaks & Gil Mueller. Passed 4/2.
Mr. Mueller would like to serve out his term before he steps down.
Ms. Ramsey stated that if the Board of County Commissioners approves
the amended ordinance, Mr. Mueller may have to reapply for the parks
board position.
Mr. Mueller stated that he would prefer to serve the end of his term
(12/31/99), which will complete 12 years of service to the parks board.
d. Monthly Report Proposal - Ms. Ramsey would like to simplify the
monthly report. The proposal is to cut these reports to just three by
deleting one page to the Recreation Section. The second page of the
report would be used to report the number of programs and number of
participants.
Elimination of this reporting saves an estimated 16 staff hours per month.
The staff hours estimate is based on an average of 2 hours per facility in
compiling and reporting these statistics. Additional staff hours are needed
at the Administration Office for putting the five page report together.
The Parks and Recreation Advisory Board recommends that the Beach &
Water Revenue sheet remain, because it is the biggest source of revenue.
The sheet should include month to date and year to date revenue all on one
sheet.
Mr. Blackford explained that the user information and revenue on every
park will or should show previous month, current month, prior year, and
year to date.
Mr. Grice inquired if there was a way to show the expenses or the budget
for Parks and Recreation.
Ms. Ramsey stated that the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board would
have to wait 2 months to get a copy of the budget showing the
expenditure. This report is provided by the Finance Department. The
budget report is not a simple report to read because each park has their
own cost center and budget but Ms. Ramsey stated she would look into an
alternative summary report.
e. Beach Parking Sticker - Chairman Zaks inquired if anyone gave any
thought to computerizing the beach sticker application process.
3
Ms. Ramsey stated that the forms will be eliminated when the new stickers
are being issued in January 1, 1999. Ms. Ramsey also stated it would be a
waste of time to input the information in the computer.
f. Introduction of New Employee - Ms. Ramsey introduced Mr. Joe
Delate, Project Manager for the Parks and Recreation Department. Joe
will be working with all construction projects. Ms. Ramsey stated the
position is new for the Parks and Recreation Department which was a
lateral move for Joe Delate from Public Works Engineering Department.
Mr. Delate is working on the expansion of the Golden Gate Fitness Center.
The contractors are now working on the interior of the building and the
project is moving very rapidly. The project is on schedule for mid-February
completion date.
Mr. Delate stated that he was working on two other projects, South Naples
Community Park and Sugden Regional Park. The Board of County
Commissioners approved a contract to W.G. Mills for South Naples
Community Park. A start date for the project is December 1, 1998 and
completion date is June 1, 1999.
The next project is Sugden Regional Park. A gazebo will be built along the
side of the dock. The project will begin pending Board of County
Commissioner's approval. Mr. Delate stated that staff is finishing a small
pond and botanical garden at the front entrance as well. The project is
funded through a donation from the Sugdens.
IX. Old Business
a. Impact Fee Policy Status - Mr. Blackford inquired when the Impact
Fee Study is going before the Board of County Commissioners for
approval.
Ms. Ramsey stated that she has to meet with the County Administrator
Robert Fernandez and the Planning Department prior to the study going to
the Board of County Commissioner.
X. Monthly Report
b. October Monthly Report -No Discussion
c. BCC Recap - No discussion
d. PARAB Meeting Schedule - Next meeting is scheduled at Veterans
Community Park.
4
imuriiimuoimmoor
e. Adopt-A-Park Report - Mr. Mueller commended the Marco
Y.M.C.A. for doing a good job.
Mr. Mueller stated that he does not think anyone will ever do a better job
as Dennis Gulley did.
The Racquet Center is moving along pretty good. The new City Park
Board has some new ideas and Mr. Mueller is also a member of the board.
Tigertail Beach is looking good. Mr. Mueller stated that the signs are up
but it will not help if tourists do not read English.
Ms. Ramsey stated that more signs will be installed and buoys will be
dropped into the water. The reason why the buoys were not there was
because the department has to put 400 pound weights on the bottom of
them. The department does not have the equipment to handle that kind of
weight.
VIII.ADJOURNMENT
Motion by Chairman Zaks to adjourn. Meeting adjourned at 3:30
P.M.. Passed 6/0.
5