CAC Agenda 06/09/2016 Collier County, FL : June 9, 2016 Page 1 of 2
June 9, 2016
June 9, 2016
Meeting Agenda and Notice
COASTAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE (CAC)
THURSDAY, JUNE 9, 2016 - 1:00 P.M.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS CHAMBERS
THIRD FLOOR, COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER
3299 TAMIAMI TRAIL EAST, NAPLES
• Sunshine Law on Agenda Questions
• 2016 CAC MEETING DATES
I. Call to Order
II. Pledge of Allegiance
III. Roll Call
IV. Changes and Approval of Agenda
V. Public Comments
VI.Approval of CAC Minutes
1. May 12, 2016
VII. Staff Reports
1. Expanded Revenue Report
VIII. New Business
1. Modification to Physical Monitoring Plan
* CB&I Proposal/Work Order
2. Solicitation Committee Ratification of CB&I Qualification for 2016
*Final Ranking
** Request for Proposals
3. Sand Gift- Collier County Schools
IX. Old Business
1. Marco South Beach Renourishment
* PW Extension
* USACE Permit Modification
2. Control Beach Regrade
3. Hideaway Beach Sand placement-Marco Beach
4. Hideaway Beach Dredging
5. Collier Creek Dredging
6. Collier Creek Master Plan Modeling/Development
7. Doctors Pass Permit Modifications
8. Doctors Pass Erosion Control Structures
9. Biological Monitoring
http://www.colliergov.net/your-government/advisory-boards-and-authorities/coastal-advisor... 6/2/2016
Collier County, FL : June 9, 2016 Page 2 of 2
10. Cam Pass Beach Renoruishment- Permit Information
ii. Beach Renourishment 2016 Engineering
12. 5-Year Sand Placement Contract
13. Permit Extension for Wiggins pass-5-Years
14. Beach Renourishment Construction RFP
15. Interlocal Pelican Bay
X.Announcements
XI. Committee Member Discussion
XII. Next Meeting Date/Location
August 11, 2016 Government Center, 3rd Floor
XIII.Adjournment
All interested parties are invited to attend, and to register to speak and to submit their objections, if
any, in writing, to the board prior to the meeting if applicable.
For more information, please contact Gail D. Hambright at(239) 252-2966.
If you are a person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this
proceeding,you are entitled, at no cost to you, to the provision of certain assistance. Please contact the
Collier County Facilities Management Department located at 3301 East Tamiami Trail,Naples, FL
34112, (239) 252-8380.
Public comments will be limited to 3 minutes unless the Chairman grants permission for additional
time.
Collier County Ordinance No. 99-22 requires that all lobbyists shall,before engaging in any lobbying
activities (including,but not limited to, addressing the Board of County Commissioners)before the
Board of County Commissioners and its advisory boards, register with the Clerk to the Board at the
Board Minutes and Records Department.
http://www.colliergov.net/your-government/advisory-boards-and-authorities/coastal-advisor... 6/2/2016
CAC June 9,2016
VI-1 Approval of CAC Minutes
1 of 6
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE COLLIER COUNTY COASTAL
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Naples, Florida, May 12, 2016
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, the Collier County Coastal Advisory Committee, in and for
the County of Collier, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 1:00 P.M. in
REGULAR SESSION at Administrative Building "F", 3rd Floor, Collier County
Government Complex Naples, Florida with the following members present:
CHAIRMAN: John Sorey, III
VICE CHAIRMAN: Debbie Roddy
Ian Butler
Joseph A. Moreland
Nick Penniman (Excused)
Robert Brown
Steve Koziar
Thomas McCann
Jim Burke
ALSO PRESENT: Gary McAlpin, Director, Coastal Zone Management
Jeff Klatzkow, County Attorney
Gail Hambright, Accountant
Dr. Michael Bauer, City of Naples
CAC June 9,2016
VI-1 Approval of CAC Minutes
2 of 6
Any persons in need of the verbatim record of the meeting may request a copy of the video recording
from the Collier County Communications and Customer Relations Department or view online.
I. Call to Order
Mr. Sorey called the meeting to order at 1:00PM
II. Pledge of Allegiance
The Pledge of Allegiance was recited.
III. Roll Call
Roll call was taken and a quorum was established.
IV. Changes and Approval of Agenda
Mr. Sorey moved to approve the Agenda. Second by Mr. McCann. Carried unanimously 7—0.
V. Public Comments
None
VI. Approval of CAC Minutes
1. March 10,2016
Mr. McCann moved to approve the minutes of the March 10, 2016 as submitted. Second by Mr.
Burke. Carried unanimously 7—0.
Mr. Moreland arrived at 1:04pm
VII. Staff Reports
1. Expanded Revenue Report
The Committee reviewed the "Collier County Tourist Tax Revenue FY 16 TDC Revenue Report"
dated through April 30, 2016.
VIII. New Business
1. Appointment of Chair and Vice-Chairman
Mr. McAlpin presented the Executive Summary "Election of Chairman and Vice-Chairman"
dated May 12, 2016 for consideration.
Mr. McCann moved to nominate John Sorey,II as Chairman of the Coastal Advisory
Committee. Second by Mr. Sorey.
Mr. Burke moved to nominate Joseph Moreland as Chairman of the Coastal Advisory
Committee. Second by Mr. Sorey.
Mr. Roddy moved to nominate Robert Brown as Chairman of the Coastal Advisory Committee.
Second by Mr. Brown.
The Committee was polled on the nominations with Mr. Sorey receiving 4 votes, Mr. Moreland 2
votes and Mr. Brown 3 votes.
CAC June 9,2016
VI-1 Approval of CAC Minutes
3 of 6
Mr. Sorey was declared Chairman.
Mr. Sorey moved to nominate as Debbie Roddy as Vice Chairman of the Coastal Advisory
Committee. Second by Mr. Burke. Carried unanimously 8—0.
2. Summer Schedule
Mr. McAlpin presented the Executive Summary "Determine summer schedule for CAC
meetings"dated May 12, 2016 for consideration.
Mr. Sorey moved to cancel the regularly scheduled July 2016 CAC meeting. Second by Mr.
McCann. Carried unanimously 8—0.
3. CAC Appointment
* Backup Material
** City of Marco Island recommendation
Mr. McAlpin presented the Executive Summary"Review of CAC Applicants"dated May 12,
2016 for consideration.
Mr. McCann moved to recommend the Board of County Commissioners appoint Debbie Roddy
to the Coastal Advisory Committee. Second by Mr. Sorey. Carried unanimously 8—0.
4. ES for Grant Applications
* Grant Applications
** 10-Year Plan
*** City of Naples Agreement
Mr. McAlpin presented the Executive Summary "Recommendation to approve Category "A"
Tourist Development Council Grant applications from the City of Naples, the City of Marco Island
and Collier County for FY-2016-2017 in the amount of$10,999,000; authorize the Chairman to
sign Grant Agreements following County Attorney's approval; approve the 10 year capital
planning document for Fund 195-Beach Renourishment and Pass Maintenance and Fund 185
Program Management and Administration, and make a finding that these expenditures will
promote tourism" dated May 12, 2016 for consideration. He provided an overview of the
following Grant Requests:
1. Regulatory and Permit Compliance
Sea Turtle Protection Program—Collier County- $166,500
Beach Tilling—Collier County- $40,000
Physical Beach and Pass Monitoring—(Vanderbilt, Clam Pass Beach, Park Shore,Naples and
Marco South Beaches along with Wiggins, Doctors, Collier Creek and Caxambas Pass)—$165,000
Biological Monitoring(Vanderbilt, Clam Pass Beach, Park Shore,Naples and Marco South)—
$165,000
Shorebird Monitoring (Vanderbilt, Clam Pass Beach, Park Shore, Naples and Marco South)—
$28,000
SUB-TOTAL $564,500
He noted the requests are consistent with prior year approvals.
CAC June 9,2016
VI-1 Approval of CAC Minutes
4 of 6
2. Beach Renourishment Projects
Local Government Funding Request (LGFR)—$15,000
Vanderbilt Beach Engineering,NTP& Renourishment—$2,500,000
Park Shore Beach engineering, NTP& Renourishment—$1,500,000
Clam Pass Beach engineering, NTP&Renourishment—$1,250,000
Pelican Bay Beach engineering,NTP & Renourishment—$1,250,000
SUB-TOTAL $6,515,000
He noted the CAC has already recommended approval of the projects. The Pelican Bay Beach
renourishment costs are to be reimbursed to the County under the auspices of an interlocal
agreement at an amount not expected to exceed$400k(the$1.25M is a placeholder for the work).
3. Inlet Projects
Wiggins Pass Dredging/Monitoring - $750,000
Clam Pass Monitoring (Pelican Bay) - $20,000
Collier Creek Modeling Jetty Rework& Channel Training—$750,000
Doctors Pass Monitoring—$25,000
Erosion Control Structure Doctor's Pass—$1,000,000
SUB-TOTAL $2,545,000
4. Beach Maintenance
Beach Maintenance—Collier County/Marco Island—$190,000
Beach Maintenance—City of Naples—$175,000
Vegetation Repairs/Exotic Removal—County Wide—$75,000
SUB-TOTAL $440,000
5. Administration
185 Project Management and Administration $779,100
Tax Collector Fee's (2.5%) $155,400
SUB-TOTAL $934,500
He noted:
• The proposed projects, as necessary, will be returned for consideration to the CAC when
the individual contracts for the work have been developed.
• The item will be heard by the Tourist Development Council in May and the Board of
County Commissioners in June.
• A ten year capital plan has been provided for information purposes and he provided an
overview of the various items involved and the estimated costs.
• The Grant Requests total$10,999,000.
Mr. Brown moved to recommend the Board of County Commissioners approve Category "A"
Tourist Development Council Grant applications from the City of Naples, the City of Marco
Island and Collier County for FY-2016-2017 in the amount of$10,999,000; authorize the
Chairman to sign Grant Agreements following County Attorney's approval; approve the 10 year
capital planning document for Fund 195-Beach Renourishment and Pass Maintenance and
CAC June 9,2016
VI-1 Approval of CAC Minutes
5 of 6
Fund 185 Program Management and Administration, and hereby finds the expenditures
promote tourism. Second by Mr. McCann. Carried unanimously 8—0.
5. Draft Solicitation for Engineering to Renourish Beaches
Mr. McAlpin presented the Request for Proposal (RFP) "CCNA Solicitation 16-6629—2016
Beach Renourishment Design" for information purposes. He noted the construction costs are
estimated to be greater than $2M so the item is required to be bid out. Three responses have been
received by the County and they will be evaluated over the next few weeks to determine the most
qualified consultant to perform the work.
6. Draft Solicitation for 5-year Sand Supply Contract
Mr. McAlpin provided a copy of "Invitation to Bid, Solicitation: 16-6658—Sand Supply dated
05/10/2016" for information purposes. He noted 3 vendors have been approved to provide bids
for supplying sand to the County over the next 5 years for beach renourishment projects.
7. Collier Creek Modeling Scope of Work Write-up
Mr. McAlpin presented the document"Collier Creek Modeling Outline Collier County, Fl. " for
information purposes. He noted:
• The work is expected to commence in mid June following completion of the work at
Hideaway Beach.
• The dredging portion should be completed in approximately one week.
• The next phase of the project will be modeling of the area and a plan developed to reduce
the probability of sand accreting at the mouth of the Creek.
• A peer review will be undertaken when a plan has been developed.
• He will provide updates to the Committee as they become available.
8. Draft Beach Monitoring Report—2016
Mr. McAlpin provided the"Collier County Beach Nourishment Project 2016 One-Year Post
Construction Monitoring Summary May 2016" Prepared by Humiston & Moore Engineers for
information purposes. The report includes comparisons of beach templates from prior years back
to 2006 and will be utilized by Staff for planning purposes for future renourishment projects. The
recommendations in the report include the County continuing with the existing beach
renourishment projects as analysis indicates less sand is required to be placed over time in order to
maintain the required beach widths.
9. Draft Biological Monitoring RFP
Mr. McAlpin presented the Grant Funded Request for Proposal "16-6650 2016-2017 Hard
Bottom Monitoring" for information purposes. He noted there is not a requirement to bid out the
work given it is anticipated to be less than $200K, but Staff has chosen to sample the market to
determine the current costs associated with the activity. He will return the item to the Committee
with a proposed contract after the consultant has been selected.
10. Dredging Collier Creek Schedule
Mr. McAlpin provided the "Gator Dredging City of Marco Island Hideaway Beach Erosion
Project—Project Schedule 4-8-16" for information purposes. He noted mobilization for the
dredging should occur around June 17th
CAC June 9,2016
VI-1 Approval of CAC Minutes
6 of 6
11. Clam Pass Beach Renourishment
* Attachment No. 1
Mr. McAlpin presented the "Collier County Beach Renourishment 15 Year Permit—Permit
Modification Request to add Clam Pass Park" dated 2016 for information purposes. He noted the
proposal is to modify the existing Florida Department of Environmental Protection permit to
include Clam Pass Park in beach renourishment projects. One goal is to obtain permission to
utilize truck haul operations for renourishment of the area.
12. Peer Review-Beach Design
Mr. McAlpin presented the "2016 Project Nourishment Requirements Peer Review and Beach
Renourishment Design Methodology" dated April 2016 for information purposes.
IX. Old Business
None
X. Announcements
None
XI. Committee Member Discussion
None
XII. Next Meeting Date/Location
June 9,2016—Government Center,Administration Bldg. F,3rd Floor
There being no further business for the good of the County,the meeting was adjourned by order
of the chair at 2:20 P.M.
Collier County Coastal Advisory Committee
John Sorey, III Chairman
These minutes approved by the Board/Committee on as presented or as amended
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-1 New Business
1 of 1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve a work order with CB&I Coastal Planning & Engineering, Inc. to
provide professional engineering services for modifications to physical monitoring plans under
Contract No.15-6382 for time and material not to exceed $5,976, authorize the County Manager or
his designee to execute the work order,and make a finding that this item promotes tourism.
OBJECTIVE: To modify the physical monitoring plans for County Beaches and inlets.
CONSIDERATIONS: Currently there are physical monitoring plans for the County's beaches and inlets
that have varying survey requirements. Annual monitoring activities are dictated by these State approved
physical monitoring plans. The County seeks to modify the plans to align the monitoring survey dates
and to provide data on a timeline that is beneficial to the beach renourishment schedule.
This will allow the beach surveys that are performed in the January/February of each year to also be used
as the annual beach monitoring surveys that is required by FDEP permit. These surveys determine the
condition of the beaches and if beach renourishment is necessary later in the Fall of each year. Staff has
been successful in convincing FDEP to allow this to happen in the past however, FDEP is now requiring
this practice be formalized for it to continue into the future.
This permit modification request will include the Vanderbilt, Pelican Bay,Park Shore,Naples and Marco
Island beaches along with the Vanderbilt, Doctors Pass,Collier Creek, Caxambas Pass Inlets.
FISCAL IMPACT: Funding for the proposed work order is available in the amount of$5,976, in the
Tourist Development Tax Fund 195, Project No. 90536,County/Naples Beach. Funding for this work
order will not be requested for reimbursement from any grantor agency.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no impact to the Growth Management Plan related to
this action.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS: Staff is recommending approval of this item.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been approved as to form and legality and requires
majority vote for approval.—CMG
RECOMMENDATION: To approve a work order with CB&I Coastal Planning& Engineering, Inc. to
provide professional engineering services for modifications to physical monitoring plans under contract
No. 15-6382 for time and material not to exceed$5,976, authorize the County Manager or his designee to
execute the work order,and make a finding that this item promotes tourism.
Prepared By: J. Gary McAlpin, P.E., Coastal Zone Management, Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees
and Program Management Division,Growth Management Department
Attachments:
A. Proposal
B. Work Order
COLLIER COUNTY TOURIST DEVELOPMENT TAX REVENUE VII-1 SAC Sune 9,p
Vtaff Reports
1of18
FY 16 TDC Revenue Report __
31-May-2016
FY 16 Adopted FY 16 Current FY 16 YTD Var to FY 16 YTD
Description Fund Budget Forecast Forecast FY 16 YTD Actual Forecast
Beach Facilities 183 877,600 968,134 767,582 798,159 30,577
TDC Promotion 184 6,881,900 7,592;151 6,019,414 6,259,201 239,787
Non-County Museums 193 467,000 515,213 408,485 424,758 16,272
TDC Admin 194 2,277,800 2,512,909 1,992,352 2,071,719 79,366
Beach Renourishment 195 7,218,100 7,963,096 6,313,517 6,565,019 251,503
Disaster Recovery 196 - - 0 - -
County Museums 198 1,883,500 2,077,941 1,647,489 1,713,118 65,629
Gross Budget $19,606,900 $21,629,445 $17,148,839 $17,831,973 $683,134
Less 5%Rev Res (993,200),
Net Budget 18,612,700
Collections
%Budget %over FY 15 %over FY 14 %over FY 13
Month Actual FY 16 Cum YTD Collected to Date Collections Collections Collections
Oct 794,682 794,682 4.05% 16.04% 38.23% 26.57%
Nov 1,003,722 1,798,404 9.17% 3.93% 14.57% 36.67%
Dec 1,320,636 3,119,040 15.91% 7.00% 25.00% 37.68%
Jan 2,040,375 5,159,415 26.32% 4.65% 34.21% 59.85%
Feb 3,184,388 8,343,803 42.58% 6.42% 24.80% 54.77%
Mar 3,323,336 11,667,139 59.51% 7.00% 19.43% 38.67%
Apr 4,295,463 15,962,602 81.42% 0.37% 15.42% 30.05%
May 1,869,371 17,831,973 90.95% -8.80% -1.39% 27.73%
June 0 17,831,973 90.95% Na Na Na
July 0 17,831,973 90.95% n/a Na Na
Aug 0 17,831,973 90.95% n/a n/a n/a
Sept Q 17,831,973 90.95% Na Na n/a
Total 17,831,973 17,831,973 YTD 3.30% 19.04% 39.11%
Cuns4dIIIIIIE 241111.1
Budget Comparison
5 Yr History- Budgeted Budget to Actual
Month 5 Yr History-Cum Monthly Collections Actual Collections Variance Current Forecast
Oct 3.45% 3.45% 675,933 794,682 118,749 675,933
Nov 8.05% 4.60% 902,319 1,003,722 101,403 947,435
Dec 13.87% 5.82% 1,141,559 1,320,636 179,077 1,198,637
Jan 22.02% 8.15% 1,597,029 2,040,375 443,346 1,836,584
Feb 35.02% 13.00% 2,548,546 3,184,388 635,842 2,828,886
Mar 49.98% 14.97% 2,934,356 3,323,336 388,980 3,257,135
Apr 69.59% 19.61% 3,844,419 4,295,463 451,044 4,267,305
May 79.28% 9.69% 1,900,317 1,869,371 (30,946) 2,109,352
June 85.43% 6.14% 1,204,350 0 n/a 1,336,829
July 90.34% 4.92% 963,973 0 n/a 1,070,010
Aug 95.48% 5.13% 1,006,669 0 n/a 1,117,402
Sept 100.00% 4.52% 886,430 0 n/a 983,937
Total 100.0% 100.0% 19,605,900 17,831,973 2,287,495 21,629,445
Tourist Development Tax Collection Curve
.$5.0
1$4.5
$4.0 •
$3.5
$3.0 :---- 1 ..a.,w�,,,...,,..
1
$2.5
_
3$2.0 —,N.,.,.e.
$1.5 i.' .....w...�
$1.0 - ti=_c- .a
$0.5
$0.0
e O z o 4 '. F 4 3 ¢ ,n
f
1 I I 1 r
6/1/2016410 PM H:%evenue Reportalonthly Sales,and TDC Receipts.xv
c0 41 c0
0 0 4-
CA 0.0
O) re N
N
C CO
-'(I)
Q-
U>
a ON H H 00 m
N m N m 0 N
in m a H--H m 0)
Cn O ti) a Cl) H CO 01 Cn it) Cn co H1
H Fa in Tr u) �-I H ..7 0 Q o 44 o
H d0' E-r E4-H H m F H N
0 0 0 0 0 0 O H
W
Kt W W W W W W W
a cn m cn cn cn cn cn
00 0 0 0 0 0 0
?H
H
U 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
I'D I'D b h h h h
>1
OD
H
a
a n 6 n E b b E
*
Q 4 4,
H
H>4 a 4 H N >+ C0 m H
>+ N 4, ,, u) >4 t!) H >1 m >+ Ln >+ }r�, N
rn
CO N 4 HH i wq q a CO
E 4 W W 0 O� * co
* Cl) 41 4 4
H l0 H 0) ,-a H-1 H-1R CO i, m
CO CO GL' m RS a CY. H R; „ W a' N a' Cn W' C0
H W C' a 0 a In a 00 0 a s H a N U: a 4 a s
a N U Q H-4-1 E N fcl� N 0 N E EI 01
0 N
O Z E H H W U N O H a
'H * 0 * N * N * H * H * * C0
N lc
i 1.11
N
O m m H m cv
0 a) N N m
H m
a
CO H w u�) CO H w m cn 01 ' CO o Co w 000
a CO o W o W N W o W a W W m
.1 Ci.. co Cx o C*. Ct. m Cs, N W C34 a
O c0 N N C!) c0
O N 1 N H
�y `may H m
W u) ry rIDi < CO < .a-+ W U)) W Nm
C7 H r-j N r7 r7 N r7 m r7 f7 O
co m H to a
a a O O
H N
m CC) N m 00 CO
0 m U 00 U co 0 u) U N U U m
C0 CO ON W 0 W H W cn W N W W Co
H O co Q co O H Q 0) 0 a Q 0 o
o w a 0) N
N m N l0 m
\ H
H
O CO CO Cr 00 Op CV
CO O o > N H7 a > H H7 N C> r> N
O N O 0h 0 co 0 N 0 O N
O Z 01 Z N Z Z N z m Z Z m
O O CO O
m N a O
Q H
a N N 00 O in N
o H H H 0 H m E, N H 0 H H m
N U U) U o 0 a 0 m U a U U V)
m O H 0 co 0 0 in O m 0 0 a
Q m u] 0) ON
W N H rl N
CO
w CO
0 ow
N 0.0
Qj tx M
N
C N
-3Cn
U '-
Q —
U5
CO N Cl) m Cl) 0 Cl) 0 Cn m Cl) 0 Cn d' Cl) CO Cn Cn m
< 4 c a N a H a H H a a 01
r CO < o H H H CO H H H m H w H H Co H COm H in
H
0 0 a' 0 C 0 w O H 0 0 V' 0 N 0 0 rn
F H m H H H w F H H H Co H rn H H Co
H H m r
H H
H
W
O
4 a a a a a a a a a a
a W W W W W W W W W W
Cl) W Cl) cn co cn Cn Cl) Cl) Cl)
w
a
H
H
H a a a a a a a a a a
Z
h h h h h h h h h h
O
0
U
cil g4, n g 6 g g g g g
F b h . h h h h h h b b
*
O 4L
a x
W w r a U1 CO ryr in H
N >. r * >, co '>4 m iL >. m >. co 4 lc m>. m >. In > o >H >. r
H N \ 4 w * H W H Cn 0) w
>'H H H A Li) H * * H Co
Ha 0 * + H
W O H N 0 m E r 4 0) CO0
r CO N V x * m
> ZN CO Ea N NN H .---.C4 sr >N m Wa H Wrx co Oa co a CON w
Pc Ha m Oaco 0a o as in as o as w as m Ha U) c4 a, 4 a v
WH H24
QQ 7z. 0H.I) SWy m H Ln H N CO Z w 4 m Z H m
. O CA U CO N H U H m W in H 0 N
Cn
H £ Cn Cx 0 H d'
CO 4, d' $ N * * CO lc H x H I U) it m * * w
CP m r H m H N
>" sr O H CO m
HN m
0 W N N N N N sr Co
O CYl o CO w CO CO 01 m CO H 04 Ln CO 01 CO Co CO CO co
U W H W H W w W W W m W W W in W W W W m
44 H W N G. N Cz. CO G. N W W m W Co Cl Ci. a
CC CO m CO H U1 H CO
W H CO IN H
H H H m
a Z Z in
Z co
4 co
Ul N 00 H H Cn cr
H N H d' 0
H N
N d' N m CO Cn 0 0 CO
U CO U H U N U U1 U V' O In U [r U r U U m
CO W In W H W r W m W r W H W In W m W W W
H A A co A co A u) A co A O H A r A A o
O w Ul m sr N
N 0 H m
H H
H
O N N N N N N m N N
> m > CO > H > N > w > m > m > N > > N
W O 0 CO 0 a' 0 In O r 0 O r 0 rn 0 O r-
0 Zi Z CO Z W Z CO Z o Z Z co Z CO Z Z m
In N N CT O
co O
C:)
H
a H H m H C4 N N N rn H H CO In CO c
H F r H co F F co
m U U sr U r U r U U7 U O W U IT U U w
CO 0 O o 0 N O r O W 0 O r O m 0 0 C
0w COril CO CO m
CO
r
n N 00 t0 t0 00 N N N 0 00 er N
G 00 O er
N t0 t0 N t0 N N 00 N M
~ N N N N O N CO 01 et 1l1 1A O
co 0 W OF N n O Lai .-1 N Ol O M O N
o O . 14 in N O1 VI N 00 01 N N in u,
N N N N t0 01 IA N tf
N CL 0
W en en eel M enl en en eel ai V1 et C
Qj Q. Y V1 V! V! VF V! V! V! V! V1• V! V! ./1
N
C
7 N N N
NM 01 N
coO N ^ N- ON en
N
01 fel
Q— IL N ry CO
:11 4N , N
N N N N N an N an N N .-i*h H
t0
on �ri°i m N O1 NCV
00 N
''11 O
D N N .0 O N 00 01
.F°: O`
7 ny .--1nany .Y1y N ,o.:1
8 O N M
.1 u N ti Ol
N N VT N N an in V.I. N 14.
N
N
• b N M m M 0 N
e res m o s....-1 a
0
kfl CO
• m 00
Ncriryo N a ole
crlm o0
• N an N an an an an N VT VT p4
V!
01
a N * N a v.
N .ni N m t00
.....
0 m 0 0l N CO M n N t0 N
'0• ".:1
vi o? ,i•
IN ry ti ti ry
N M N M u .N4
CO
VI N N N N N N an N an N
✓)
0
N N o N n a n .n N 01
YI .m-1 01 CO O 0 N o o N .no 00
Q e d ry .moi R tvi G
CO 8 M M M m 8 8 v "t
N N N N N N CON N N N N a
~ M co
u 0
,,, m m 4.
m .c a CO
- ..-i a m 00 e
D E.
O Q N vt
N N h Nl. N `el."
N N
n
411.W
FT a
Z a M
Z n o o n o as m .0 o t0
x
O V N 2 O M M ..4 �0 00, N M
V �' Ot N l0 M of N O N
g35' ao a M
ce .n vl N .n .n n w
W N N N N N N N an an N t0
J N
J
O
uY o
ICO
li O W O .N0 o V N
1\Q 0 n
0 N .0• n o
C N' O O to 00 .O o N
vj
LL Si N VT In .Nn N h N N N awn CO
N O
i/!
0
C N n W W crl 03
00 Q O m ti)
Q N N n t0 N vMl O W N N 4
i .0a a .o o '0 d N
Z 73,-„; m N m ry �M m 4 H
Q V. h an V. .n H H v. M
V!
al
cc
1.
N
P.
- ri N el NmaN OnN- m n.il oN 1:f r7, .O 00
V N N ry Ory N N N
C N UT N N N N N N in VT VT N
V!
K g
m T QN Orn
n 4
N0 N N O -
m n m N n of .o N N N- o a
of v r ai a1
m aiLn
ni ti- TA oil .o o O
ZN VT N N N N N N N w N N
N N n n NN ne-1IR
W ONm
CO M CO O 01 01 ul u
N
G N
n • O O O CO9 to
O On U1 N N N V! VT N VT N N ,.{
✓1
cc
.0 n m N 0 7-.'•
N- .O0
N N M MO OOyO OOON
Q
QO 8 OO .i N Q
ON O NOO 0
ryLLO N
n .I .I 0 00m -, m a ,n m m
< 00 O1 In a a 00 N 01 N. t0 m
'- N 0 N m t000 0 N O1 4-1 01 m
I-0 Li/07 5 ai N N N 01 1l1 C .-I O 01 C iii
J CO C C e► N O1 0 m N C1 m
N 0.O ¢ -I N t0 .1 N N In O1 00 01 0
•IC cu
W m m ri ai m M m m' v a a
CD Ce u) W 4" 1" 1/0 1/0 {/P to VF 1/0 t? yr N
CD
C m
n m a a m nen
V m 0 o 0 o 1 m m n
W 0 O r N N 00 N N
Q h . O O m t0
0 1 n v N n o
N N
a
1n a m
:,?°-.
0 m r.;:6
c°1
m
N 0 N n 000 0 1m11 00'1 W to -1 V
W co' v 16 0 e '~
7 ry N .0 CN ry N
< N N H N
an in N in in N in to an in N
N
I.0
en ,ry o 10 N m m ID
al
�I m o 1'n0, °JN e m m II rt
ryN 0 N
1n
N
01 ..0 CO
00 n en en O cNn n N ,'31
N
01
Z CO O O JI 1n
ill O V !� O t0 N 00
ry N 9 8 N m 9 N
N N N m
N VF in N N N N N N Vf N
N
�}} CO
ID
0- O 1100 10 N 1Ni1 10 O O,1 CO N m
‘ern'''..
1011 N 1p M M cci
W
en 0 N
vNmi m m m 1n a g
h N N N an .n N In aro N C
N ▪ m m I
m m o 0 1121 nmol
2 m o 1Nn m 12v tri N .5 1c of crii N Lo N N N N H O ..m 03
n N
H H
Z tj o
m m 1n 1n N m n e N o r n
V a .o-i o r o 1u N o n 03
< ry o vri 8 1O m ry m o m m
CC f i " a w a o 1n r N 01
U.1 in N in in in in in in V1
J N
J
0
U YN
C O m m o m m 00 o PA m .1 cn M
? O W O N 1D 1LI p1 m O 0 ri
d. 00 N V sy0 O O ,
LL to V1 N in N N N N N in .n
/
N
01
C 2 0 1D .9 O a N N 8 co co
< O O O 1D m 00 N co O m •
7 01z co 0 O 01 00 a N a
< h h H 9 a8 1 8 N N a0 m N
in N
M1
V?
CC
00
2▪ .1 01 m m 01 v0 0 00 l0
if o N
U '0 Cr 1 m 00 (0 N N N V m N "'�
41
N
CN N N N in N N N in N N
H
C .q
1.1 CI' N01 10 o 00 10 N N
m N 01 N 00 00 N N
2' V N m Jn 1
N1 n O W r 0
F.1 rrl 2 co
0N N N ..o., N in 4.0f anf 0 N ,..j
N
N
''n N m '� n en 2 m o W
LO n m n N 'Onto co m m.4 tri
I ro o M
if
ri iri
co oft N
in
O N N in N 0 0 N N N N N ,.q
{A
10 N o0 01 o r1 a 1n 10
Li
W o 0 0 0 m m
ON N N N N 2N a ON ON N 2 Q
Q il 1 I W 1 N N a ~
. 8O O O N O O N N O O N O H
N N
Opp ƒ N
N §
§ 0 _ \ # ® ® # \ _ _
6ƒo $ # - - _ - 7
\k -
o ,— § G
} \ } } \ \ \ } \)§ a \|
/ - } } \ } \ \ } } }an \
E km cn
\ co
\ Tcril
VT _ Cli
_
to
o
cn
k \ $ :an . an _
§ \
o _ . an
®
E 2
2
o U ■ 3
IR \ _ _ ®cn ® i en
LY _
0
LP
ii.k \ \ } \\ } \\ } \ \ \
11/
§ to \ \{j \ } } \ \ } j
§ & &CC
la
& & 2 7 a a & a
ƒ Rm
/ \ _ a _ _ _ i 8 _ _
0 -
\ 8 8 )
! R \ \ 88 \ \ \ \ \ \ 0
Q 01 00 u1 1A N 'Cr a"I N N N N M
co CO aa-1 Of n N Obi N n N a O m in a
N lD kO Oi c n
Na 0 C 0c0 ,-I a'i sz 0 ,-1 N .-1 am-I ,-i
r Ci) Ce ; N VI. N i/4 Lf in in. Vn in in N
N
C W
U f w v^ a .FA m n
IlFY m a O Of Yt M
0.
0> G N N VM! N VI N VT ni N N N Kt
H
N
j 2 T N 00 N 0O m m O a
.r n o au m ce
00
Q N N N N W N N N N N 0.7
O
N
JI vaf 00 013.
m o vai n " 00 0 N
N m .. o ry m n O O
N N N N H N N ti N N ari
a
N
Vl oi au, nii
N • m NenoowroNm9O
01. on an all vn N N
H
r'Zi ti N ti a a o
al a .mi r,„
v aao m 8 o m ^�
N o 0 0cn "Li* o N
V• N VF N N VF V1 N uF N N
N
I—
I—.
c7 J m m Po ry m o m m .oi a N
yy C
F e. .n• m w.y m e
Q V Q N W VT N N N Vl N N V> N N
1 .
W
Z5
O W V N b N N 00 O 00 M 0 m ~i
U ) 0: N o 8 m o m 00
W < .2i :ti9 ti m 2 N 2 9 N N
W2 N Ul N N V, on N N V. N N N
J
J
0
V C mo nm m M 0 m N
co mn sr
03
a j
CO
NI N
LLI N N 1/.4H N N Vl N N VI. an N
W ill.
n 51n
m m n m n 00 .t4 min
N
tar US.
oai .4
Zv. min inmC. 00 w anY inN 0
Vl N N
N
C
N
LI' a O O1 Mm
co
MW N NM M 0
V Val N N N N N N N N N N r3:.
H
C
l CO
In N
00m8 a + n an
v o N0 0
n M Co CO
0N N inn lan tan N N avn an N N %.O
Z N
W O O
anN ona N n N m
0N 0 a nn a NOnl
tri ni
ui
O N lan Val H N N N h N N W N
OO 8 8 O M NOCOO O O ON O O .i O a
OO
LLO OOO ON8 ry
O F
•
a o N o In a I-I N In ay co N
4 rn a N N In N CO .-1 to N o
I N Al N CO N In t0 0 ID a' of tD
CD r co ° vi r .-i Le to vi o to to N vi g
co 0 N 0 ID CC 0 N N
N O.O a N a N CO N In CO .-I CO N N
W t0 n 1� V1 t0 t0 n 00 of N al 0e0
an ct CO y N N 4} Vf 4" 4.4 4A. VT 41 VT 4F 4"
0)
C co
7
a en
N n O a t0 CO N rt-....4 In
0 7 f .rv. N m `° Ne0
co N n 00
Q ry N m m m sr1i ry
',44 o o O1
co
U> ILI N N N H N N VT VT Val ni
inN
0
,n n .o 1O In a m .°14 m 8 m N
O 44 n o n .t .r o In n
m m co N m °' .41- m Ln
t0
m M a In
G VT to N VT N N N in in N nj
N
M
O M N N n O t0 of W n 0
JIW N o a W to ry N N
unl' DD N W N n O .-i D O
rn m m n m co
4"
t0
VT N N to N N to N N N l
N
M
co N a .7:. O to On Cii Oj. Wl. OOi M
RI tO A'
N O W M o N
a.2 iii a t" ecn n N a a uni too N
V> N N UT N VT VT VT VT e
N
O
a n ry W a •y
'I O o o n o m m Ln ry n o M
R I: vi ry tri tri m v o vi N a
Ln N
N tno tno in two inwN N two in told CO
40
I-
I- I..1
H b 8 co
p • V m tn2t 40
to In
N N
1
CC
a
0ZQryO< Mm toco rim y M VpDol0nC•-. N
h W N ^0 in VT N N N N UT N .-4V?0
Z W
0 V N M NLn
W N a J.
N N a
n - ry m o0 00 n a N
U Al a t1 MI' m vai of N m a
L.1 R n o o tan to n of
W N N N in N N N N VT VT N .My
J 4)
J
O
0 03
F1 o Ln
• a 8
r, to
n ri
o n• n
00 01,
Fa
o rviW N Nm NafnI:03 mo a ocvO
N
II. N N N N V1 N N N N
4/!
n a
> to a ry N 0 00
a N m a m N N N ° o
Q al o a o n m
oom a ni o "'
2 N a o
oao o
it.,
N
W1
C1 N a T V N N co.T .�-I N ISO
m ry to o n to ro
ILI
tto N ri ri vmi uni rl .Ni N a O1
V 8 N a M M a N M h N
0 N N N N N N N in in V1
N
a to
n to IN
0 O to of 0 co In
2 W o a a mat too Ct n W Ol M
ILI te m m 0 m m m N W CO
a
Z to W N N N N N ..co H N 0 •M
41
00
a N Ott m mN co to .-4
amm nn O m :i'.34 n o
o 8 M o r tri m In
m ry
go" N
Lo ryrn 2 FO
0 N to an in N in in N in in W.
N
a?
IX8 N O
mO .
LI
On 8 T '4 ry 8OO ON O N
Q
Q OOOO O ry m aO uO O O OO
tn O OoOO 0 O0 h
n on N N tD N N 0 N N IA M tO
co N co a In 00 00 Al Al cr In N t0 tD N N
'' I- N 0t0 N tD N N M N en O1 O
co N G.O 0 a DD It Y1 t0 t0 00 M N 00 N N
M N 0, Q IA N eT 00 00 AlM
N tT t IA N n Moo M 00 N N N 00 M
ai cca r6 a v N r eri a 10 ai .i I: P
j Y
7 U)
Q - m o'
a
V_ Wm N m Nno
iO r` of n ooto m OF p ,
trj
tOo
N
N N 4A N N F / N V 1
an
N
a 00
N a co 3G V W a N O .N4 CON
ry m n `XIm w 40 Ti'
a m o Oi 0i m U, Co. 0 N
a t N N N two N N N cn U 400 00
n
N
N
N N !n O W N
�I N O N N m n (0 co m a C
2.111
7,221,"
V O N N n O m Oi a1
N h co N VI N N N VNi N N
C.:
N
CO
ry m PA 00 to rn
00 8 o o.
4 en
of
Z e r g 4. of g v v rN
vs u. ti ti H i
0
V
C
W N
J W in N W N n tp vml W n M Ln
Q 2 iif a co O W N
H NN - NH _ N N N N
H
X u AR
F IA
W
iF 0 N LO
g a0n s N o Fi Na M
O W N N aNM
•
vvI N vN V 1.4 .til
M
~ Q W N
rIF W
O WaY
= m . mmMioo nm w QV O ,%`'
N MOn MNmT NLm o
cc 2 m o m n 00
LU 2 N
io N N N N N vI vI N VT N
J — an
J d
Z
o On > nm N m O Nro
0Qii T N vm 8."
m a o
M •
n
O mn mm 2 1. an m an N'^
m c
U N Ni
N¢ LL vN vI N 1.01 N 4.01. 4/1- 1.4
cC N
C
t/1 00
r.m.4 M
aDNV) ry NO 2 O RVC
Z Z O O O CO. N M O to
40. N N N Yr N v. N N N N 4a{
N
tD
0
vON M
0 A
m 1.11 n O u01 t0 O O N N 0 to
W 0 OO O0 O O V
Oy� O
CiN N N VVN
ti to vI N H
N
.-iN l
to
1 a b co Nco
co
On O 01
n nN
m m 4' vm 2 ' O00
O N 4./I `...2 v. N N H N N O DD
Z N N
N
N
m .ni a b CO m m m W m o0 CO N
O N m N N O n M N n W n M
G N N N N N N N H N N N u1
N
re
W O n W O O NN M MV
JN NO N N N N04 . ON N N N a
a OO O
ONO N O N OON Q
LLN O 0
n
~ O0 0 a 03 Oa N CA N 0 V01 vat N an
001
co co a N a N 01 1A N Na 10 a °° W
O O _, N P 00 N m CO M O a fa/1 O N
N G.O C m N N N N N m 111. m
O W v N 1n i/ 1/ 1/� 1R /n in. 1AN
W Q' O ›-
a)N
C /p
C
U`— f N N u00�r m
.:21.
`°
vT-I1-1
m Gi Lel
m
U` t -01. N .4 .n to VV in v1 N
ta
N
N
in n
D co
en
C7 .. r. `� nen o
vi N m a
D -tn. in N N N N V? VI N N
rn
7I r!-
o °' o eq n m 1-1 14 v a
N N N N VI N O
1R
jeetOa Nv nui0Nor.im o n$ ea o v n. ot0
In N N VN in.
N
N
L!
o n o m o
Q v01 b W b M O N W r.
rxr
^ VI
N N N V. V. to N .a/.
co
N N N
N
1-
V1 01
aa
H on
1p tO m O1 '^ o n ^' O f0
v m u+ a o �n o o .`_'. io m
O ~ Q O N .Nn N N .4. ci
N co N to Is
WWC +A
I- G
H
Z
O Q V D p m o N .di N
(J CQ o a m ti n .+ o m N n n a
2 tt v .4 vai a vi on- .n c6 , Oi
L N N N N N N to V. N to v1
W V?
J
J
0
Vit
a a m vni m m n co ry
on_ of
W N N N N N eyi H N N H N V. a
LL N
ge n
VI
O mN to
"'m n n •a m oLnj m
Z N VN. N '^ .nn H M
$ u, uti ut ti N
CC
t It
Nm a tnoi
Nf m o m m ii m
u % vN v, vs N N Nus n
N
O
cc
cc m
co2mco
O O1 Vf .mi b O
N n N pp I O
./. Vim'. nr1 (0
N N L. H t.6
N N V)en
%„1
2 N
c a
vm '" m o mm
on
v O N N N N N V. V. N
1/1
CL
WO n 0O 01 O
,-I N m oNf o
8 N OO O N O>, N JQ
Q O O NNLLOO 8 O ON O Ory N N N O
N
N
N
N N N O. a, N M VI
CO N CO 0 O N .a'-1 N Val 0 IA O Cl N 00 M
r a N o .c IC N a IC � Cl ti v
NN 0 n oa0 Obi 0�0 0 N N M LA CA a M
0) V! V. v V. .-I 4-I N N N N N .
pj ce ,_ V. VF 1 N N V! V. V.
0)
C co
7 W
co
N .mCp MU m o m
Q W O .Oi L O La .o' N N
U> N .. N N h N u N N L. N
N I.A.
N
N O N alN m n No u1m ory W m .
moi eno N a
V0 a. ti mo
aL. L. L. VN L. VL. N N
v.
N
E v Iii nn NI
o m o n n n '�
�I 0 N 00 M M O a (0 GO
N N N ff"11
N N N N N N N N N
N
m N M tD N M l0 N
Z :r1-11N m a
�I ryon-
m n , m vnai a v on n
N N N N N N N N N M
✓!
00
yl N m0 m cei
.4.. ke
N N 1La
N
in N
a T N O O O V P
en en
in
IA
L. rCiN Lam. L. tii
N L. AN/. V ~ •� .N1 GO
L. VT L. --
N
CO
J n m r,::, m n .�. .o N n W
e m N o ro m m o
I— aLn
m ry m m i0 Ncri m rt- t0
N L1 N N N N N L. N N N N VI
N
D_ Cl
O Z = oi .an .ni CO V. .0 O 1�
n ni m o .0 0 m N m 0n m ry t0
Z Q a 1-1
en' m a m a; m v g m
Z N N L. N L. Vf N N N Cr) L. N
O Z V.
U
re
103
W f go
6' w g co
aa au .mJ n ^� ro n j .iN
CO n m t0a. NNU N LL
74
0
ut L. N N N N N V. 'q
V.I.
.40
W n O 00 00 .an .moi N l0 0 al
n M
a O o 0 .O n m O V. N N
.O OLn •
no T ~cl Q I:
v al
u!
W
N Cl m m N o m m p
...co °w n .n n n o m
u ry .1 1O ry Mg m m °� M
WQ N L. N N N N N N N L. N V.
V.
C N
CO03 L0 en
V Oal CO,mV .i N b n W 00
ILI N N N N CO' .-I N N CO Cri m N
0 N L. N N N V. N 1A N L. N
Z V.
IX m n N
V M V N
ON O N M R Vf Off. T n V N
C ° ry °6 v Ot m o N
00 M M VI .D N
O N L. N N L. L. N N N L. N a
N
a0 n m a N ym m
41
Y O 0u 0 O ti -
.ii0
aO O .
8 8O O8 O 8 OV HLL N NN
G 0 in 01 CO O1 N an 10 O N O N
I- M 00 0 0 00 in in N M N N .-1
CO 000 g 00 01 V1 N N M 01 in 10 00
J
Oi N N 00 W 6 C 1!1 M N m N
O O m O en a en N M en in N a01
NO.O 0: N e4 N N N . . N N N N
Oi
a) f V! cJ N an N V! VF V1 in V! Vs IX N N
N
C 0
C/) LelC
N
mto w a .OO1V W m O mm
U > t h N N N H L. N to N t/} N
N
N m to m tD m M C n N
O e n m 3 .�-� m44.
? 01 cq-m N m ri
Q N H N +n N N tan N t/. M
V1
J2.I a N O m N a N
a vai o m
i'n' 14.' o °.° v o
K 10
V. N N a N N a N N a N
N
.71 Z m tp n a am N W coto
53
N N N N N N N N V1
H
co co a
Q t0 b N N O n W m it, O LiiN
fl ' M N N N N O m/. c/.
N L N in N
V!
_, a N to a to 0o m 10 m N
Q 2 o n m m m o oN m m o 00
I— ¢1 m m m a a v `" gq a m m
NYI V. Y. N N N N N N .n V. V. N
C a
>
0N
0 _ pan ti m ry n m 8 01
Z a a ry m N m to
Z ,9 Q O 8 N ry tJ 3 ry vi ,nV o a
Q co N H co ▪ V. N H V. co en
O (
U a
W 5 > in
J 0: o .. m ry o t0
J j tan m o o m o too ry m
O ce
m Npc
M Ncci
• N M M m O
U an N N an N N V. N N N V. M
LL
? .y b O a n O vaf N n pai a ^p
2 5 44ti ti r.., g l0
!Si ... N .n .n .n N vi .n .n N .n N
H
K
m N t003
m N t0 a m N N
l0 N W CO N N O O 3 .11
L.I Le V N N N N .n N N N N N a N
LW N V!
0
al n
f . 4rc
m O an m O r,a n m v
0 N a .n N .rvi. "'N .n N N n cl
tO a G
O N N a
2 V!
C 01
3On 8 8 O W W m m NO cD a m n co rN tri C
ON N V. to N N .n .n N .n N N
Q1p
OWO O
O PIO O▪ O Oa YN \O
Q
bO
Q N 8WO IOO . co t/ OVN O 8 OOO o
LL
< N.
CO v N 0 N o CO m N 0 rn
co r w o N o �e m ,s a m N
a °'
N d O a 00 4-1 T O t0 lO ,O N
N UIi O- N N O- N - N N N
O) Q' y N N v N N in N in an
N
C co
7co
¢ m n it e 00o
trl a n o
U 7 f mn M
_ co- Mgri V OiN NN m
U ` ko plOp
ro N N N N N VI. N N tel.VT nT vi
H
O0
j 0 m N b N 0 ..0 W ..0N
C .D 4 an OI rl N ft-; 0prn 1ter
Q .b l0 I . M N O n W n
Lel
N N VT N VT N N N N VT 00
N
00
it N
it °1n m --0 rym IA
meNNm itnimN m
N m N iiiran' NN N VT N VT N N ill V
te
V1
2.1 o 0 m m in
.-1 IA
ry rA
m 2 0 co 'f^ Ci m
"' ry m �' m m m mv �
8 .-I
N an. N N N .nn N in 4 N 00
N
al
N h N W .i M .i co N N b 00
y W 00 N .moi N iO W M .4 00 N
�I N m O O m O W O aO .nD a
u tl V t"
N N VT N N N N to . N N N
H
J
K Nc uio O: Nwo m or N to
O Q.a:
O
O
n
I— n �eoNN " mwN m N nN aI— ¢ n o VNryN V• N VT N VN N N N
ui
E2 N
M
W
O O = 8 O 2 Of O
cn
O �p n Nni to CM
n
.-1U o V0� nn „a a o aZ w f NNo r o
ONVT N tN VT N VT N VT NN0
Ce 0
W .+
ee n n
aom o n gi n N
J Q o N N o m .. No ati o cri tin oo 0 mti � o ry o b
U cn cn
LLVlVNvNv
tNi
VT N VT VT VT ty
N
i
.
Lcr
rn
o sr
m N om 0"'QN N a Nm aN ab ri
2 w a0sr N ,co na 0 H nv V
gi,
N v N N N 01
an
.xuiV `Ovn^uma mn� a.n Vr m ^ m N
f N
. c NO . N mOV1V rN n 8 b co N0 N N N N V> N N N
zli 06
AA
K 01
O 03 03O 01 W Jen inLO
O O Q• C 00 N M N 0N ~
0 `wnm O N mGo
N N N
na N Z VT N W VT N N m VTb
N
0
CC
N 0 n N N LO M � mm o it v i4 v e
ri
O v o � ,. o I,
aa ai is 171'
O N n 01 N N in N N in
N Ill a
N
te
W O . N m
7-1;
V0 8 o OO O O O O NO8O
oo
QyNO O 8 8 N8 O Fy O
LL O O N N N
Q a CO Kf1 rl M O In N n N M O
(O W 0 O1 C O^1 o m N m CO N 000 N n
J l0 lD N CO N l0 l0 mi lO O .-1 M
N 0_O 00 N Cr N N N CO CO CO CO N N
N VP - N in. N VT in. i/T Vf V?3. N
N
C .�•
Ce
U °° a m CA no °' `° ti a M
CA LI1 en
U > p N N N N in N N N CO
1.0 N H
1.0
NC N V• Wl0 nf
NNbn
CO
CO n O0 N fn
ti ry n j
V ddCDoY
N N N N N N
h
N
01
a m(31 d o
D Ocn
RI v m• 6
O. o
N In NVN VI. V! VT N
h
IN CA
1.1
ti o W .i d m at D m
O v a0 d e0 d
O : o; R o `,E.' 0
VI In N VI N N N V1 V. N
H
2E . m m m m m n m- N eOrl
Q n ti 01 r N ry .n. '^ m ti Ol
f m
N N VI CV N v! N N N N N N
I
I .
Vi 0
Ci J m m CO
W IN
'C''''.3
°' .mn m N
p[ d Of CO
E. O W O IN
..-i n O ry vi of01
O J Q Vt VI N VI . in L! N In N V1 N
I— a H
z F
z •ct Ul 111 IAb O V , 00 VN O N O N O COn
Q W 01' m N W m ti ,1 V1
CC N n .- N N N
W N . N in H N N . N N N
N
J
J
0
V m VMm 0 0.
a N O b N O- 0
CC N H n n
LL N N V! N VN VVI N in N N
N
C nm to aoN m m IT
r-1 m
Q O n am n LO 8 mO ClyO
0O O N 00 IN .moi .Ni m.47
Q to . . . VT . . an v V. Vt.
.1"
CC On
W md tO d N
OW N Vf N N VF Vf V! N N
N
act
00 LA 01 00 m .l D mO Nm IN
m0 g
0 N VI. N N la N N N N N N OS
Z
oo
h npj ti C oa LA p Nm •
te
temW o m d m n NrNN N N ON N N N N 1p
h
ry O O O - N MO m 9
YW O 9 O O - N
OOO O \ ry 4'4 a
OQ OO OO NO N Q
LL O F
n
ID w O 00
O O.-. zv N OOo
N NO 4/3 N ,I N N N ti1-1
W
H N V! an N N {R N N H
Oi Q ") a
N
C N
W
co en
V 7 fF no Li., Inti .Qoi m tO
.^. CO
U> 1 N an N N Nin N VT N N N
N
Itt17,
U - b M N N N N T
7 N N N N N N an N N N N
Q an
N
�I m C1`,1IN `.-°i N N m M
- N N t/QT N h N N N N N -
In
ZI PNaNw0.
~h 'r.1.' N
n N N coN N NO c.2.1 Nh
0Y1N
M1/>
tn
m a¢I a or
NLnN N a or
io m
N tn N N N O
N N VT o
I
in
Te 8,' m N fo m m 8
Q a o m o o o n m N ry o in
O CI. Q an N N an N tri N an an N an N Or
C in
0-
z =
D L21 i
01O m V m /aor O O ti • Mt0
Q mm M • Q C.
V O Q ^ NcCf N N N N an N N N N n
N
W Vf
J
J
O
U
a ry n
m N M
7 no e m c in
m ro N
W N N N N N N N N N N N ,I
LLan
N O
2 N VN�T R N b N Q M NLn
Nat
Q N VT N N N N N 4'9
N
C
i t71
O b p N ^ V N .moi m N
w Q '^• • 'a of
V N N N - N N N N N N P
c an
N.
ra
Lo Lo M V W n ,O ti N M
N an an in N In N N N N VMT fh
O H
Z
C
en N
m N m n'1 Ci'
N
01`.1
N lO
0 O r^I Q M u1 b N V7
G N N in N an N in N N N N R
0 VT
5J
Uy1 O O mO ClO
0N .+O mN Q Le)
1O it
C ONONOOO O m N• Nmo.i
Q
Ory O ti O HONNO NN N
T.
N
LOCO
O 0
N G_0
aj a)
ce
C cfl
—3(./)
0 3Q
0>
co o n a o w m o in a
n a a
oo a m N �o �o o
0 0o m M �n n oo
J o m vi vi en cn v o vi of cr
n No gl m m m on o 2 a ..
N an N N V) N N N t? N N
a �
m m m o
f e N
in an
h w
tiW
a
a — .n . ti
N
N
M
m
co
N m
-I h N ry n
N
QI V O <
N b •
N "q
7 CJ
O C = O N
} LL n N
Z J f of N NV V
W
O of H N h N N
Z N
V v,
ce
UJ f m
J b
O C�0 aN
.n .n .n .n
u y�
5
N
of vs a 5 5 5 �n v+ ti N N
C b
O b
✓ N H N N H H N N H an N
D N
m m m
o n n .n n n
2 N
O N N m IC
N
O m e
5 n
o .n 1
o v. N 01 .n .n .n m
0
m o a .,
> 0 0 o
LL n n n r ry 4 ry 4 4 ry n
00 in m O .-I in N 01 O 10 00 N
1' Val N 00 Cr; N N M 00 00 00 O Cr0
O7 01 CO= O N in co a 4. 00 N O O W Oi al. LT
O O O O N O1 01N N CO 000 of M co—
Lic
aj 4 -vs 1 1 V i~/1 N o N VT N N VNj
N
C_ w
W
n
V 4 01
m v N 0 r.
0 > t m o en m N vO - m v00f
VI on N on N N VT N lf1
N V1
,' a 00 O N
7 ,a-i COa0 0 ti n NLO N N
0 00 .ill NN vm1 01t0 .00 N
4 V1 V1 V1 N N V1 N N VI N N
V1
01 Ol 03 t0 M vl vl
7-I'
0y F.P. co
m ap •V-. 8 m vi N 8 Of
-I , N m m m m Lan tO .y
MI
N on N on N N N on N on in
N
o n it, m to CO 0 to o .n CO
it o a m CI m v u^'i a oi .�-� N
.100 N n a m v e .l`^i n .�.1
N VI N N V> V• N N N N tf1
01
N1 01 m y rn
V1N
0
N O O 2 O In
QN
r ^ o N of .N- v vi
m m "y .n.. on.
YJ N N �' N N N N N N N N 1.q
I--
I—
I— 01
til
o1 .-1
mIlO m O m
ni0c 00 a CO
OOzn tuUo o o .nm G
Q o m ryn•
.il MI am mO h N .4
f VI N VI N N H N O N
J
w
D c. n 00 III Of N N ol
O 0 00 °' 0 S 9 8 00 mCI
o a+ m
VCe o
ec . Ti v ry
to vi vi
W tall N N in N N W tA N M N
J N
J
0
Li ,/1
4 00 l00 v .0-i v0i o m mN
- v .° O
o
o 00 0i o 01 o 00 enl a0 N
el N m m N a n M
W N V1 N N N N N N N O .-0
V. V1
N
4o
01
N 0 vat 0 N N 0001 0 C- O' 0p C
0 03 vi 01 00 O vi m N
2 O 0 N 0n. H no N O rl CO
N N to N N N V1 N N ear
i/1
W O
0 o a m Cr
o
03 •
1.1 Ln
.mil n0 m o m .tDi o ry m n
MI Uin CO i.i3 0
N tl, N N V1 N V1 N N V1 all
N
m 00
m M m `(0 00 n 0 N N
00 m o m n Ln
N- CO 01 fW
0 . 10 m .0 to ni
> N a u1 m a m a ul ul au ten 01
O N N Vf N N VI N VI N lfl
Z V1
m N N NN N CO M51 n 01 nPO N n W
Ill
t ti N ON N , 00 t, a in b CO
O N H N N V1 N N N VI V1 V1 CO
N
a 8 n 00 01 0 M a N 30
W O :r
O O N .y
a ON ON ry N N O O O N- N
O \ N O.1 Q
MQ vlO n O1 .- N O OO O 0OO O0 ~aO N ~
n.
a LA CON00 m m v IOn N N e N IA
I- N Io LO N to N N IA a-1 penpp 01 a
M N O) Cr ISA ami O61 00 M 00 M t0
N
N- 00 O M N N. M 00 en 00 a-I N N 00 rl
CO aN M N N M et us.
C) N N O^
O) Q' 6 ri N ti N ati a-1 a-I a-1 N .-I N
0) ! N V! N N N V! V! N V! VT N V).
C 07
7
U a— m CO N n N m N m o N 000
6.
m to N o+ n N O
0> to
V N W
cri
N O V N N
v1 <D N m to l0 to Ooo
N N N N N N N N VR N tD
N
ta{ co
00
c. N▪ N N 0 a M 1. N N N l0
O l0 t O I� Oi tT o 00 co' O to a
J Q n n n rn
to n n W ami Oni 00
a N N N N N N N N N N N
W N
CC
J N
LL JI N O N 01
0 M N en
N co m CO
a 10
W rail a O W W n toil 01 011 N 01
J n N N m N t0 N co en OI tn
W N N N N N N N N N N N
Z N
M
X CO
C a N N n N m a m in O)
a I N ol
o N to t0 to .an O a 41
Cl j a ri N N N O Ti Vtri
N
• LA m ro n N v'w m o4 -t a
O in N in N N in N N N aA )
I
W
J N
O N UNf .,i N .Oi N N N 0) N min
C QI O N Ol 0.I.
t0 R N triOl a1 0
2 O o n Al N V1 M l0 O1 a to
to to to N m men a m o ro N
QN N N N N N N N N N N a^.1
N
W 03
LA H N N n N t0 N N N N CO 00
Z J n0 m m 0 m to O N a ID a 6.
C ~ W no-
.-1
l0 tp n N .-i at ari N
J 6 a O N O t0 W O N n at a
0 W Q a to n O (N m n N N N
N N i N N i. N N r6. a a M
J0 N N N N N N N N N N N M
N
~ J
O Q W N
I— i—
OI
O N
m n ti N d' N N m T
0 Q v m m M m ti a a to co m
V I Q V m n in N tri m W IA'
N N
CC Y N m m Ai a1 O O M N
m CO
W C. N N N N H N N N N• N in N
=Ia 'NA
J
Q > > co 01 N W al m 0 0 CO N
rc N m 0N in N N o a to .01-i N 00
Ci 4D > m N N r.
m ri
n o o n v1 arvi ti 0
O
Q m n Co of tO t0 t0 at o .n a a-1
CC ILI
LL N 14
N N N 34
N N N in N AI
N N L.A.
0. N
2
V o o N N iN N N N ttoo n 03
N
N n m n to N a N m M
O oo t6 o R of o6 tri o cc o a
M 2 o O N .N-1 O O oN N vrvi aai O T
Z N N N N N N N N N N N a-
2 N
Q c. a0
in
Z W m .-1 N co a al a1 O co M IA
Q m n o N N O O N N N LA..
V• V m N O CO QN t011N a N o N le Ar O N
F C N N V01 in N N AA Vcn LA ILIm1 H N O
z N N
W
C
C
C
N
I:0 ILI or oo
Q m N tp N N N On 0. a O nm co o Ln en N 01 n M
tri
Q to
N O rri
oi W ri N a N 01 nal n t0 00 OO
O N LO to t0 M t0 sr:; n co N 00
2 N N in N in in in in N in N
N
N
IX N W M N CO N a to to to O ti N 4A
m ,n4.
y a t0 0o al co m W m Oo t0
O t6 N ai a t R a a a M
^' V v1 M V V .N/1 to trill 00
LOO n in
C N N N N N N N N N N N LA
N
4N co O
y1 O r N m a N LO
N
QO O OO O O O O O O O O)- N N N N N N N \ Al N
\ OuQO O O pp O - N0 M O 1 O
O ONN O O O O 1—
T.,
—, N N
N N N 01 N N N
CAC June 9,2018
VIII-1 New Business
1 of
CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc.
2481 NW Boca Raton Blvd.
1 c
Boca Raton, FL 33431
�j Tel: +1 561 391 8102
Fax: +1 561 391 9116
www.CBI.com
May 11, 2016
Gary McAlpin
Director
Collier County Coastal Zone Management
2800 N. Horseshoe Drive
Naples, FL 34104
Re: Modifications to Physical Monitoring Plans (Contract No. 15-6382 "Grant Funded
Professional Services for Coastal Zone")
Dear Gary:
This scope of work details the tasks necessary for CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc. (CB&I) to
assist the County in modifying the physical monitoring plans for the County's beaches and inlets.
Currently there are physical monitoring plans for the County's beaches and inlets that have varying survey
requirements. Annual monitoring activities are dictated by these State approved physical monitoring
plans. The County seeks to modify the plans to align the monitoring survey dates and to provide data on
a timeline that is beneficial to the beach renourishment schedule.
CB&I will review the existing physical monitoring plans for the County's beaches and inlets and propose
modifications to meet the County's goals. Through conference calls CB&I will coordinate with the Florida
Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) in gaining acceptance of the proposed modifications.
The modified physical monitoring plans will be submitted to the agencies for approval and incorporation
into existing permits.
Included as Attachments are the Fee Proposal (Exhibit A), and the Rate Schedule (Exhibit B). These
services will be performed on a time and materials basis not to exceed $5,976.00 under the terms and
conditions of Contract No. 15-6382 between Collier County and CB&I dated June 9, 2015. Barring any
unforeseen circumstances work will be completed within 180 days of receiving the notice to proceed.
Very truly yours,
Thomas P. Pierro, P.E., D.CE.
Director
CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc.
Cc: Steve Keehn, P.E., CB&I
Tara Brenner, P.G., CB&I
Confidentiality Statement
The information contained in this proposal is confidential commercial information and shall not be disclosed,except for evaluation purposes,provided that if
a contract is awarded to CB&I Environmental&Infrastructure,Inc,as a result of or in connection with the submission of this proposal,the requester shall
have the right to use or disclose the data to the extent provided in the contract. This restriction does not limit the requestor's right to use or disclose any
technical data obtained from another source without restriction.
d
_ w
R
y c c° (Q co Cr)i
co0 � do I SEs
O N O V E
N N N 'a
m
a
a)
S
U Z tS ,2 ea _
U= O 3:I C o C
E- N
5 L a H 0 t O N N N N
7 c co O 7 D s' _ ER ER
a` y
a)
c
w
N_
217' a)
O o W 00 ,-
0 0 = Efl 1—
'E. m to
N
i
d w
A ro
N
U) N NLii
CC d S Ea cr)
C
O co g
J
U. a c
m
Q Ci) a a
V) c w
O L -, o
a !' V C
O
w
Q arc O. to 7 .4. Et E
H W V o' N 0 A 2 EH CO d
00 IL. 'y V 'c 2
2 to T `m , Cl)
W Q a pco c
ii .�+ U
C
1L
II II II o
m
2 r N cr) =O 03 U O LL
co o
W �=' to �p Q> a
m
g
ai
I-
0
H
J
(a Q
c a/
co W
O. F.
al Q
c
o 06
E c Li/
0 To
R V
H y
.o
0
co
c
0
Y
A
V
F
12
So
G
r
CAC June 9,2018
VIII-1 New Business
3 of 5
SCHEDULE B
RATE SCHEDULE
Title Rate
Principal $207.00
Senior Project Manager $173.00
Project Manager $148.00
Senior Engineer $158.00
Engineer $124.00
Senior Inspector $97.00
Inspector $77.00
Senior Planner $140.00
Planner $111.00
Senior Designer $115.00
Designer $95.00
Environmental Specialist $110.00
Senior Environmental Specialist $135.00
Scientist/Geologist $94.00
Senior Scientist/Geologist $119.00
Marine Biologist/Hydrogeologist $111.00
Senior Marine Biologist/Hydrogeologist $139.00
Senior GIS Specialist $146.00
GIS Specialist $103.00
Clerical/Administrative $63.00
Senior Technician $86.00
Technician $73.00
Surveyor and Mapper $121.00
CAD Technician mm $82.00
Survey Crew- 2 man $136.00
Survey Crew - 3 man $172.00
Survey Crew-4 man $205.00
Senior Architect $155.00
Architect $122.00
This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Hourly rates for other categories of professional, support and
other services shall be mutually negotiated by Collier County and firm on a project by project basis as
needed.
B-1
CAC June 9,2018
VIII-1 New Business
4 of 5
WORK ORDER/PURCHASE ORDER
Contract 15-6382 "Grant Funded Professional Services for Coastal Zone"
Contract Expiration Date: June 8, 2016
This Work Order is for professional Engineering Services for work known as: Modifications to
Physical Monitoring Plans
Project Name: City/County Physical Beach & Pass Monitoring
Project No: 195-90536
The work is specified in the proposal dated May 11, 2016 which is attached hereto and made a part of
this Work Order. In accordance with Terms and Conditions of the Agreement referenced above, this
Work Order/Purchase Order is assigned to: CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc.
Scope of Work: As detailed in the attached proposal and the following:
* Task I Modifications to Physical Monitoring Plans
Schedule of Work: Complete work within 180 days from the date of the Notice to Proceed which is
accompanying this Work Order. The Consultant agrees that any Work Order that extends beyond the
expiration date of Agreement No. 15-6382 will survive and remain subject to the terms and
conditions of that Agreement until the completion or termination of this Work Order.
Compensation: In accordance with the Agreement referenced above, the County will compensate the
Firm in accordance with following method(s): ❑Negotiated Lump Sum (NLS) ['Lump Sum Plus
Reimbursable Costs (LS+RC) Time & Material (T&M) (established hourly rate — Schedule B) ❑
Cost Plus Fixed Fee (CPFF), (define which method will be used for which tasks) as provided in the
attached proposal.
Task I $5,976.00 (T&M)
TOTAL FEE $5,976.00 (T&M)
PREPARED BY:
Gary McAlpin, P.E., CZM Manager Date
APPROVED BY:
Amy Patterson, Division Director Date
APPROVED BY:
David S. Wilkison, Department Head Date
By the signature below, the Firm (including employees, officers and/or agents) certifies, and hereby
discloses, that, to the best of their knowledge and belief, all relevant facts concerning past, present, or
currently planned interest or activity (financial, contractual, organizational, or otherwise) which
Page 1 of 2
CAC June 9,2018
VIII-1 New Business
5 of 5
relates to the proposed work; and bear on whether the Firm has a potential conflict have been fully
disclosed.
Additionally, the Firm agrees to notify the Procurement Director, in writing within 48 hours of
learning of any actual or potential conflict of interest that arises during the Work Order and/or project
duration.
ACCEPTED BY: CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc.
Thomas P. Pierro, P.E. Director, CBI Date
Page 2 of 2
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
1 of 2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve the ranked list of design professionals pursuant to RFP No. 16-6629,
"2016 Beach Renourishment," and authorize staff to negotiate a contract with the top ranked firm
CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc. for subsequent Board approval, or, if contract
negotiations are not successful with CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure,Inc.,then to authorize
staff to commence contract negotiations with the second ranked proposer, Environmental Science
Associates,and make a finding that this item promotes tourism.
OBJECTIVE: To obtain professional engineering services for the 2016 beach renourishment of the
Vanderbilt, Pelican Bay,and Park Shore Beaches.
CONSIDERATIONS: Engineering services (as described below) are required to obtain a Notice to
Proceed (NTP) authorization from Florida Department of Protection/United States Army Corps of
Engineers (FDEP/USACE)to conduct a truck haul beach renourishment project within Collier County in
the Fall of 2016 utilizing the existing 15-year Joint Coastal Permit (JCP) for Collier County's beach
renourishment program.
The physical beach surveys conducted in January/February 2016 indicated that the Vanderbilt Beach,
Park Shore Beach and parts of the Pelican Bay Beach need renourishment in 2016. The beach width
measurements and three years of advanced renourishment placement indicated that these beaches will
require the following:
• Vanderbilt Beach(R22-R30)—Approximately 30,000 CY's(cubic yards)of renourishment;
• Park Shore Beach(R44-R53)will require 25,000 CY's to 30,000 CY's of renourishment;
• Pelican Bay Beach will require approximately 10,000 CY's of renourishment.
Based on this analysis, The Board of County Commissioners (Board) approved a 2016 Renourishment
Program to be built after November 1, 2016 using truck haul construction and either off road vehicle
transport on the beach or sand fluidization and pipeline transport. The sand fluidization and pipeline
transport placement approach is being considered to enhance public safety and will be bid as an option.
Stated quantities will be adjusted prior to construction during the pre-construction survey that the
contractor performs.
The scope of work the engineering consultant is required to perform is as follows:
1. Analyze recent survey data on existing beach for actual beach conditions and make
recommendations;
2. Develop, plan, design, specifications, Construction Drawings, NTP documentation, bid package
and other related services as required to engineer the project utilizing a truck haul renourishment;
3. Complete application for and obtain a FDEP NTP to accomplish this work;
4. Estimate of most probable costs;
5. Bid Package generation;
6. Evaluation and Recommendation of bidders;
7. Coordinate as needed to complete this project;
8. Certify the project at completion;
9. Time is of the essence. Engineering must be accomplished to allow beach renourishment to begin
on 11/1/2016 and be complete by 1/1/2017.
The Sudgen Park lake shoreline will also be renourished with approximately 10,000 CY of beach quality
sand in the sailboat launch area,the main park beach and the water ski beach/stands area. No engineering,
design or permitting is required for this work but coordination during construction is anticipated.
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
2 of 2
The area south of Doctors Pass and the Naples Beaches are not part of this solicitation and will not be
renourished in 2016.
The Pelican Bay Services Division will reimburse Collier County to renourish their beach. No sand will
be placed on the Pelican Bay Beaches without an executed Memorandum of Understanding (MOU)
outlining the terms and conditions of the Pelican Bay beach renourishment.
A Request for Proposal (RFP)was solicited in order for the project's design to be in compliance with the
applicable Consultants' Competitive Negotiations Act (CCNA) requirements. On April 6, 2016 RFP No.
16-6629, "2016 Beach Renourishment," was posted. One thousand three hundred and ninety-four(1,394)
notices were sent out and forty two(42) firms downloaded full document packages. Three (3) responsive
proposals were received on April 26,2016. On May 17, 2016, a selection committee short-listed the three
(3)firms based on an evaluation of their technical proposals. The selection committee ranked the firms as
shown below:
Name of Firm Final Ranking
CB&I Environmental &Infrastructure, Inc. 1
Environmental Science Associates 2
Coastal Systems International 3
The top firm, CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc., is sufficiently familiar with the scope of this
project and is qualified with similar experience in Collier County. Staff recommends approval of the final
ranking and requests authorization to commence contract negotiations with CB&I Environmental &
Infrastructure, Inc. for this work. This is in compliance with CCNA policies and procedures. If contract
negotiations are not successful with CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc., then staff is seeking
authorization to commence contract negotiations with the second ranked proposer Environmental Science
Associates with the objective of bringing an acceptable negotiated contract back to the Board for
approval.
FISCAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact at this time. Once negotiations are completed and
approved, funding is available in Fund 195 Renourishment Reserves for this project. Funding for this
contract will not be requested for reimbursement from any grantor agency.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There are no growth management impact associated with this
Executive Summary.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney, is approved as to
form and legality,and requires majority vote for approval. -JAK
RECOMMENDATION: To approve the ranked list of design professionals pursuant to RFP No. 16-
6629,"2016 Beach Renourishment",authorize staff to negotiate a contract with the top ranked firm CB&I
Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc., for subsequent Board approval, or, if contract negotiations are not
successful with CB&I Environmental & Infrastructure, Inc., then authorize staff to commence contract
negotiations with the second ranked proposer, Environmental Science Associates, and make a finding that
this item promotes tourism.
Prepared By: J. Gary McAlpin, P.E., Coastal Zone Management, Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees
and Program Management Division,Growth Management Department
Attachments:
1. Request for Proposal
2. Final Ranking
O O O
0 co O coO
c O O O
a N M
3 Wim+?l`lhfr4;
U Z
Q N
U
1
E�Yi i'pi 'p4.+ '�+ k {fd (b
11-11 I
Uir
S ,I Ti.1!1 r)i 4 d 44 1 P9i4iij
01110'Ip r"' E '' f€�gglli
1111! :,,,..,,i
g dk.3Ti J ��{ p_
'v��;y�.�ivi.4if�?�.:��.,y<�v�<Yv�,:A'PF." y�.,11 51�F�.,.
Liqi
l,v�,! E d PPP"'9 j �v S!k 3
M4lfMh� I�) { 4 fE 4 �4},. fY :
i4gif s1'dE °.1E E iiita 1��l
$.111111111 .
s$.JoINl9ga+:3cf!�' � � +.Ei
'toll �
+NiE19�IyRi��ifw'Nikj `' s��r
1110I41.."1.11
1.P. i itt. 1rtiggljs {k4,.."
d10I41.fl �I j�kll,7+} 1i�l i{ �4 1-1 1
I
iiil f.Intr.....r-.4-..4.,.i4,,;11,.:11.01,11
i
+4f k E a t h s.. 741,41v W ��
ii
W
iii
E En
I1+ +q?! NSI!3F91�: E!3
idliith.
H
T Fr'yEx:e.! h4 ppii =i ° '.d€ 1;61 4�!,11�E1if 11.11. tidal!f.f f91 Ft1�11IE.1{,11.d ' }i, ,,,ivi :ice!i`iw y` Si ri E:pdtpi �'iki�9l�',i{ ,� '`!," ' Fpp".�d€lki+..fp fME 1�!`":IP3 1 T1Pyi.LI l ,-,i0
Q
91§�+!44 tl Ei EB : ' 'J!!'
d j:11111 ."� {iv'1 c��iyug '{�EI
a IE��l{P @Co ,0`ijG€@[a L1 i E`i 4116,,10I�11., 1 €� faE�d�illib$€j4i x+A ry. +--' , Nfn C litiliNEMB.. qa�E diPpdlP N O Set ..f;€M fd4 °�� C /Q i;g yd1tEt€1^4 1&,1 fk1'#k1V31 d�1�,a>F 1....% C i
v .:;.ig?p1pi1f..E i. 114 dr 1; ..{—t .: W V
LL 4 i Ei k 7- Y �. N
a)
• V ,,,,„,„,„„„,„,„,„,.„KI linf l;4 0 lf, s#r�l,.i d ,g 4' /1C` () (1) �4O
��::{{ N 4Q " 1$3�df yj4 E -110
f�4'" �;*lilaS4- W V J LL
3 l'{' (6 `,9-
t0 fii19 r '' ..a �� ''" O C u) C
t. ri
r d x rii�°y p�'i z :�IE S 11 C (n E
N I.T �7{{"� �a W CO (6 __I
N
e. a d1h41 .-ti
1 Tom.+�diiTm Jj p`d fi 1:,,,p,•:,: .,k',TMh 1 db.°2 •� f¢— U
�g LL _ -T'�me,Ekelaj Hhil[11Evi d k di�If i, W C O O OL
R th ::s..°:1,1!„,,110116gl1,f H 4 lEdE1laa U W U W
.4 li..111111111111111.0111
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
1 of 37
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
In accordance with Florida Statute 287.055, Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act.
Colter County
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
COLLIER COUNTY
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
CCNA Solicitation
16-6629 — 2016 Beach Renourishment Design
Adam Northrup, Procurement Strategist
(239) 252-6098(Telephone)
(239) 252-6302(Fax)
adamnorthrup@colliergov.net(Email)
This proposal solicitation document is prepared in a Microsoft Word format. Any alterations to this
document made by the Consultant may be grounds for rejection of proposal, cancellation of any
subsequent award, or any other legal remedies available to the Collier County Government.
IV
r,
ProoaanentSomas Drvesion•3327 Tarrearni Trail East•Naples,Florida 34112-4901•239-252$407•www.cdliergov.riet/proctrementservices
CCNA(Revision 01202016)
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
2 of 37
Table of Contents
LEGAL NOTICE 3
EXHIBIT I: SCOPE OF WORK, SPECIFICATIONS AND RESPONSE FORMAT 4
EXHIBIT II: GENERAL RFP INSTRUCTIONS 11
EXHIBIT III: COLLIER COUNTY PURCHASE ORDER TERMS AND CONDITIONS 16
EXHIBIT IV: ADDITIONAL TERMS AND CONDITIONS FOR RFP 20
ATTACHMENT 1: CONSULTANT'S NON-RESPONSE STATEMENT 28
ATTACHMENT 2: CONSULTANT CHECK LIST 29
ATTACHMENT 3: CONFLICT OF INTEREST AFFIDAVIT 30
ATTACHMENT 4: CONSULTANT DECLARATION STATEMENT 31
ATTACHMENT 5: IMMIGRATION AFFIDAVIT CERTIFICATION 33
ATTACHMENT 6: CONSULTANT SUBSTITUTE W—9 34
ATTACHMENT 7: INSURANCE AND BONDING REQUIREMENTS 35
ATTACHMENT 8: REFERENCE QUESTIONNAIRE 37
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
2
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
3 of 37
Cotter County
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
Legal Notice
Pursuant to approval by the County Manager, Sealed Proposals to provide Design Services
will be received until 3:00PM, Naples local time, on 04/26/2016 at the Collier County
Government, Purchasing Department, 3327 Tamiami Trail E, Naples, FL 34112.
CCNA Solicitation
16-6629— 2016 Beach Renourishment Design
Services to be provided may include, but not be limited to the following: Engineering Design Services
for the 2016 Beach Renourishment Project.
® A pre-proposal conference is not applicable for this solicitation.
All statements should be made upon the official proposal form which must be obtained only on
the Collier County Purchasing Department Online Bidding System website:
www.colliergov.net/bid.
Collier County does not discriminate based on age, race, color, sex, religion, national origin,
disability or marital status.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA,
BY: /S/ Joanne Markiewicz
Director, Procurement Services Division
This Public Notice was posted on the Collier County Purchasing Department website:
www.colliergov.net/purchasinq and in the Lobby of Purchasing Building "G", Collier County
Government Center on 04/06/2016.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
3
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
4 of 37
Exhibit I: Scope of Work, Specifications and Response Format
As requested by the Collier County Natural Resources Division (hereinafter, the "Division or
Department"), the Collier County Board of County Commissioners Procurement Services
Division (hereinafter, "County") has issued this Request for Proposal (hereinafter, "RFP") with
the intent of obtaining proposals from interested and qualified Consultants in accordance with
the terms, conditions and specifications stated or attached. The Consultant, at a minimum,
must achieve the requirements of the Specifications or Scope of Work stated.
The results of this solicitation may be used by other County departments once awarded
according to the Board of County Commissioners Purchasing Policy.
Brief Description of Purchase
The Board of County Commissioners of Collier County is seeking qualified firms capable of
providing engineering services as required to obtain a Notice to Proceed (NTP) authorization
from FDEP/USACE to conduct a truck haul beach renourishment project within Collier County in
the Fall 2016 utilizing the existing 15 year Joint Coastal Permit (JCP) for Collier County's beach
renourishment program.
Time is of the essence. Renourishment activities must begin on 11/1/2016 and be complete by
1/1/2017.
Detailed Scope of Work
The physical beach surveys conducted in January/February 2016 indicated that the Vanderbilt
Beach, Park Shore Beach and parts of the Pelican Bay Beach need renourishment in 2016.
The beach width measurements and three years of advanced renourishment placement was
included in the calculations and indicate these beaches will require the following:
• Vanderbilt Beach (R22-R30) —Approximately 30,000 CY's (cubic yards) of
renourishment;
• Park Shore Beach (R44-R53) will require 25,000 CY's to 30,000 CY's of renourishment;
• Pelican Bay Beach will require approximately 34,000 CY's of renourishment.
Based on this analysis, staff is recommending that the County proceed for planning purposes
with a project to be built after November 1, 2016 using truck haul construction and either off
road vehicle transport on the beach or sand fluidization and pipeline transport. The sand
fluidization and pipeline transport placement approach is being considered to enhance public
safety and will be bid as an option. Stated quantities will be used for planning and bidding
purposes and will be adjusted prior to construction during the pre-construction survey that the
contractor performs.
The awarded firm will perform the following:
1. Analyze recent survey data on existing beach for actual beach conditions and make
recommendations
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
4
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
5 of 37
2. Develop, plan, design, specifications, Construction Drawings, NTP documentation, bid
package and other related services as required to engineer the project utilizing a truck
haul renourishment
3. Complete application for and obtain a FDEP NTP to accomplish this work
4. Estimate of most probable costs
5. Bid Package generation
6. Evaluation and Recommendation of bidders
7. Coordinate as needed to complete this project.
8. Certify the project at completion
Background Information
The Sudgen Park lake shoreline will be renourished with 10,000 CY of beach quality sand in the
sailboat launch area, the main park beach and the water ski beach/stands area. No engineering,
design or permitting is required for this work but coordination during construction is anticipated.
The area south of Doctors Pass will be renourished when Doctors Pass is dredged when the
installation of the Erosion Control Structures is complete. These quantities have been confirmed
by an independent Peer Review consultation. No renourishment is recommended for the
Naples Beach (R58- R79).
Preliminary discussions with the Beach Committee Chairman of the for the Pelican Bay
Services Division indicated that a more realistic renourishment quantity that the Services
Division is willing to compensate the County for would be approximately 7,500 CY's to 10,000
CY's. No sand will be placed on the Pelican Bay Beaches without an executed Memorandum of
Understanding (MOU) outlining the terms and conditions of the Pelican Bay beach
renourishment.
Term of Contract
The contract term, if an award(s) is/are made is intended to be for current needs.
Prices shall remain firm for the full term of this contract.
Surcharges will not be accepted in conjunction with this contract, and such charges should
be incorporated into the pricing structure.
Projected Solicitation Timetable
The following projected timetable should be used as a working guide for planning purposes
only. The County reserves the right to adjust this timetable as required during the course of
the RFP process.
Event Date
Issue Solicitation Notice 04/06/2016
Last Date for Receipt of Written Questions 04/21/2016; 3:00PM
Solicitation Deadline Date and Time 04/26/2016; 3:00PM
Anticipated Evaluation of Submittals May 2016
Anticipated Completion of Contract Negotiations May 2016
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
5
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
6 of 37
Anticipated Board of County Commissioner's Contract June 2016
Approval Date
Response Format
The Consultant understands and agrees to abide by all of the RFP specifications,
provisions, terms and conditions of same, and all ordinances and policies of Collier County.
The Consultant further agrees that if the contract is awarded the work will be performed in
accordance with the provisions, terms and conditions of the contract.
To facilitate the fair evaluation and comparison of proposals, all proposals must conform to
the guidelines set forth in this RFP.
Any portions of the proposal that do not comply with these guidelines must be so noted and
explained in the Acceptance of Conditions section of the proposal. However, any proposal
that contains such variances may be considered non-responsive.
Proposals should be prepared simply and economically, providing a straightforward concise
description of the Consultant's approach and ability to meet the County's needs, as stated in
the RFP. All proposals should be presented as described in the RFP in PDF or Microsoft
Word format with Tabs clearly marked. If applicable, the utilization of recycled paper for
proposal submission is strongly encouraged.
The items listed below are to be submitted with each proposal and submitted in the order
shown. Each section should be clearly labeled, with pages numbered and separated by
tabs. Failure by a Consultant to include all listed items may result in the rejection of its
proposal.
1. Tab I, Cover Letter/ Management Summary
In this tab, include:
• Provide a cover letter, signed by an authorized officer of the firm, indicating the
underlying philosophy of the firm in providing the services stated herein.
• Include the name(s), telephone number(s) and email(s) of the authorized contact
person(s) concerning proposal. Submission of a signed Proposal is Consultant's
certification that the Consultant will accept any awards as a result of this RFP.
2. Tab II, Business Plan (20 Points)
In this tab, include:
• Describe how your firm will meet the specific needs of the County.
• Describe how your firm plans to take on this contract while balancing work from
other clients.
• Demonstrate the fiscal stability of your company.
• Detailed plan of approach (including major tasks and sub-tasks).
• Detailed time line for completion of the project.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
6
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
7 of 37
• Include with the Business Plan or as an attachment, a copy of a report as an
example of work product. This should be for one of the projects listed as a
reference.
3. Tab III, Firm Credentials and Experience (30 Points)
In this tab, include:
• Provide a "not to exceed" two page "Firm Credential and Experience" narrative
that identifies and highlights the firms credentials and experience relative to JCP
multi-year beach renourishment permitting, success and cost effectiveness.
• Provide information that documents Consultant's and subcontractors'
qualifications to produce the required deliverables, including abilities, capacity,
skill, and financial strength, and number of years of experience in providing the
required services.
• Complete the following form, titled "Firm Experience" and include with your
submittal for this tab.
***Remainder of this page intentionally left blank***
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
7
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
8 of 37
Tab III — Firm Experience
Name of Firm:
1. Identify the number of years the firm has provided engineering or
architectural services to the public sector(under the same name
and/or the same principle owners). (number of years)
2. Identify the number of"industry awards and/or recognitions"that
the firm has received from peer group (i.e. American Council of
Engineering Companies, American Institute of Architects,
National Society of Professional Engineers, etc.) in the past five (number of awards)
(5) years (1/1/2010 - 12/31/2014).
3. Identify the number of licensed engineering or architectural
professionals who hold offices in engineering professional
organization (i.e. American Council of Engineering Companies, (number of office
National Society of Professional Engineers, etc.). holders)
4. Identify the firm's number of"published articles" in professional
engineering or architectural journals that the firm has been
recognized for in the past five (5) years (1/1/2010— 12/31/2014) (number of
published articles)
5. Identify the number of licensed engineers or architects in the firm
who have at least four (4) years of engineering experience.
(number of license
engineers > 4 yrs)
6. Identify the total number of Collier County projects in the past
five (5) years (1/1/2010— 12/31/2014) where the firm has been
the lead consultant. (number of"lead"
Collier County
• Provide a list of those projects, the year, and projects)
the Collier County project manager.
7. Identify the total number of Collier County projects in the past
five (5) years (1/1/2010— 12/31/2014) where the firm has been a
sub-consultant. (number of
"subcontractor"
• Provide a list of those projects, the year, and Collier County
the Collier County project manager. projects)
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
8
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
9 of 37
4. Tab IV, Discipline Experience and Specialized Expertise of Team Members (20 Points)
In this tab, include:
• Description of the proposed contract team and the role to be played by each
member of the proposed team.
• Describe the various team members' successful experience in working with one
another on previous projects.
• Provide the resumes of key individual and qualifying experience relative to major
beach renourishment JCP permitting that are available resources and assigned
to this project. Include details of unique benefits that the firm offers on this
project.
• Attach resumes of any sub-consultants. If sub-consultants are being utilized,
letters of intent from stated sub-consultants must be included with proposal
submission.
• Provide a list of projects that includes sufficient detailed description and outlines
the firms experience in JCP multi-year beach renourishment permitting, success
and cost effectiveness. Include start date, end date, original budget, final project
cost and number of change orders.
5. Tab V, References—5 Completed and Returned (10 Points)
In order for the Consultant to be awarded any points for this tab, the County requests
that the Consultant submits five (5) completed reference forms from clients whose
projects are of a similar nature to this solicitation as a part of their proposal. The County
will only use the methodology calculations for the first five (5) references (only)
submitted by the Consultant in their proposal.
Prior to the Selection Committee reviewing proposals, the following methodology will be
applied to each Consultant's information provided in this area:
• The County will total each of the Consultant's five reference questionnaires and
create a ranking from highest number of points to lowest number of points.
References marked with an N/A (or similar notation will be given the score of
zero (0)). Consultants who do not turn in reference forms will be counted as zero
(0).
• The greatest number of points allowed in this criterion will be awarded to the
Consultant who has the highest score.
• The next highest Consultant's number of points will be divided by the highest
Consultant's points which will then be multiplied by criteria points to determine
the Consultant's points awarded. Each subsequent Consultant's point score will
be calculated in the same manner.
• Points awarded will be extended to the whole number per Microsoft Excel.
For illustrative purposes only, see chart for an example of how these points would be
distributed among the five proposers.
Consultant Name Consultant Total Points Awarded
Reference Score
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
9
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
10 of 37
Consultant ABC 445 10
Consultant DEF 435 9.8
Consultant CHI 425 9.6
Consultant JKL 385 8.7
Consultant MNO 385 8.7
Consultant PQR 250 5.6
Note:Sample chart reflects a 20 point reference criterion.
The points awarded by Consultant will be distributed to the Selection Committee prior to
their evaluation of the proposals. The Selection Committee will review the Consultant's
proposal to ensure consistency and completion of all tasks in the RFP, and review the
Points Awarded per Consultant. The Selection Committee may, at their sole discretion,
contact references, and/or modify the reference points assigned after a thorough review
of the proposal and prior to final ranking by the final Selection Committee.
6. Tab VI, Availability and Responsiveness (20 Points)
Provide a "not to exceed" two (2) pane "Firm Availability and Responsiveness" narrative
that identifies demonstrated responsiveness to County's needs and availability of
resources.
Firms will be awarded points for demonstrating the ability to take on and successfully
complete this project with demonstrated knowledge of FDEP, FWC and Army Corps of
Engineers requirements.
7. Tab VII, Acceptance of Conditions
Indicate any exceptions to the general terms and conditions of the RFP, and to
insurance requirements or any other requirements listed in the RFP. If no exceptions are
indicated in this tabbed section, it will be understood that no exceptions to these
documents will be considered after the award, or if applicable, during negotiations.
Exceptions taken by a Consultant may result in evaluation point deduction(s) and/or
exclusion of proposal for Selection Committee consideration, depending on the extent of
the exception(s). Such determination shall be at the sole discretion of the County and
Selection Committee.
8. Tab VIII, Required Form Submittals
• Attachment 2: Consultant Checklist
• Attachment 3: Conflict of Interest Affidavit
• Attachment 4: Consultant Declaration Form'
• Attachment 5: Immigration Affidavit and company's E-Verify profile page and
memorandum of understanding
• Attachment 6: Consultant Substitute W9
• Attachment 7: Insurance Requirements
• Attachment 8: Reference Questionnaire
• Other: Licenses, Certifications, etc.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
10
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
11 of 37
Exhibit II: General RFP Instructions
1. Questions
Direct questions related to this RFP to the Collier County Purchasing Department Online
Bidding System website: www.colliergov.net/bid.
Consultants must clearly understand that the only official answer or position of the County
will be the one stated on the Collier County Purchasing Department Online Bidding System
website. For general questions, please call the referenced Procurement Strategist noted on
the cover page.
2. Pre-Proposal Conference
The purpose of the pre-proposal conference is to allow an open forum for discussion and
questioning with County staff regarding the RFP with all prospective Consultants having an
equal opportunity to hear and participate. Oral questions will receive oral responses, neither
of which will be official, nor become part of the RFP. Only written responses to written
questions will be considered official, and will be included as part of the RFP as an
addendum.
All prospective Consultants are strongly encouraged to attend, as, this will usually be the
only pre-proposal conference for this solicitation. If this pre-proposal conference is denoted
as "mandatory", prospective Consultants must be present in order to submit a proposal
response.
3. Compliance with the RFP
Proposals must be in strict compliance with this RFP. Failure to comply with all provisions of
the RFP may result in disqualification.
4. Ambiguity, Conflict, or Other Errors in the RFP
It is the sole responsibility of the Consultant if the Consultant discovers any ambiguity,
conflict, discrepancy, omission or other error in the RFP, to immediately notify the
Procurement Strategist, noted herein, of such error in writing and request modification or
clarification of the document prior to submitting the proposal. The Procurement Strategist will
make modifications by issuing a written revision and will give written notice to all parties who
have received this RFP from the Purchasing Department.
5. Proposal, Presentation, and Protest Costs
The County will not be liable in any way for any costs incurred by any Consultant in the
preparation of its proposal in response to this RFP, nor for the presentation of its proposal
and/or participation in any discussions, negotiations, or, if applicable, any protest
procedures.
6. Delivery of Proposals
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
11
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
12 of 37
All proposals are to be delivered before 3:00pm, Naples local time, on or before 05/06/2016
to:
Collier County Government
Purchasing Department
3327 Tamiami Trail E
Naples FL 34112
Attn: Adam Northrup, Procurement Strategist
The County does not bear the responsibility for proposals delivered to the Purchasing
Department past the stated date and/or time indicated, or to an incorrect address by
Consultant's personnel or by the Consultant's outside carrier. However, the Procurement
Director, or designee, reserves the right to accept proposals received after the posted close
time under the following conditions:
• The tardy submission of the proposal is due to the following circumstances, which
may include but not be limited to: late delivery by commercial carrier such as Fed Ex,
UPS or courier where delivery was scheduled before the deadline.
• The acceptance of said proposal does not afford any competing firm an unfair
advantage in the selection process.
Consultants must submit one (1) paper copy clearly labeled "Master," and six (6)
compact disks (CD's)with one copy of the proposal on each CD in Word, Excel or
PDF. List the Solicitation Number and Title on the outside of the box or envelope.
7. Validity of Proposals
No proposal can be withdrawn after it is filed unless the Consultant makes their request in
writing to the County prior to the time set for the closing of Proposals. All proposals shall be
valid for a period of one hundred eighty (180) days from the submission date to
accommodate evaluation and selection process.
8. Method of Source Selection
The County is using the Competitive Sealed Proposals methodology of source selection for
this procurement, as authorized by Ordinance Number 2013-69 establishing and adopting
the Collier County Purchasing Policy.
If the County receives proposals from less than three (3) firms, the Procurement Director
shall review all the facts and determine if it is in the best interest of the County to solicit
additional proposals or request that the Selection Committee rank order the received
proposals.
The County may, as it deems necessary, conduct discussions with qualified Consultants
determined to be in contention for being selected for award for the purpose of clarification to
assure full understanding of, and responsiveness to solicitation requirements.
9. Evaluation of Proposals
Collier County will evaluate and select these Services in accordance with Florida Statute 287.055,
Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
12
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
13 of 37
The County's procedure for selecting is as follows:
1. The County Manager or designee shall appoint a selection committee to review all
proposals submitted.
2. The Request for Proposal is issued.
3. Subsequent to the receipt closing date for the proposals, the Procurement
professional will review the proposals received and verify each proposal to determine
if it minimally responds to the requirements of the published RFP.
4. Selection committee meetings will be open to the public and the Procurement
professional will publicly post prior notice of such meeting(s) in the lobby of the
Purchasing Building and on the County's Procurement Services Internet site.
5. Prior to the first meeting (Organization Meeting) of the selection committee, the
Procurement professional will post a notice announcing the date, time and place of
the meeting at least three (3) working days prior to the meeting. At the initial
organization meeting, the selection committee members will receive instructions, the
submitted proposals, and establish the next selection committee meeting date and
time. After the first meeting, the Procurement professional will publically announce
all subsequent committee meeting dates and times. The subsequent meeting dates
and times will be posted with at least one (1) day advanced notice.
6. Selection committee members will independently review and score each proposal
based on the evaluation criteria stated in the request for proposal using the Individual
Selection Committee Score and Rank Form and prepare comments for discussion at
the next meeting. The Individual Selection Committee Score and Rank Form is
merely a tool to assist the selection committee member in their review of the
proposals.
7. At the scheduled selection meeting, the members will present their independent
findings/conclusions/comments based on their reading and interpretation of the
materials presented to each other, and may ask questions of one another. At the
conclusion of that discussion, members of the public will be offered an opportunity
(not to exceed three (3) minutes) to provide comments.
8. At the conclusion of public comments (provided for in number 7), the selection
committee members will individually rank order each proposer. Collier County
selection committee members may consider all the material submitted by the
Proposer and other information Collier County may obtain to determine whether the
Proposer is capable of and has a history of successfully completing projects of this
type, including, without limitation, additional information Collier County may request,
clarification of proposer information, public comments, and/or additional credit
information.
9. Once the individual ranking has been completed, the Procurement professional will
direct selection committee members to read their individual ranking publically. The
Procurement professional will record individual rankings on the Final Ranking Sheet
which will mathematically compile into an overall selection committee rank of
proposers.
10. In any of the selection committee meeting deliberations, by consensus, members
may request to invite proposers in to clarify their proposals, ask for additional
information, present materials, interview, ask questions, etc. The members may
consider any and all information obtained through this method in formulating their
individual ranking and subsequent selection committee overall ranking and final
ranking.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
13
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
14 of 37
11. The selection committee's overall rank of firms in order of preference (from highest
beginning with a rank of one (1) to the lowest) will be discussed and reviewed by the
Procurement Strategist. By final consensus, and having used all information
presented (proposal, presentation, references, etc.), the selection committee
members will create a final ranking and staff will subsequently enter into
negotiations. Award of the contract is dependent upon the successful and full
execution of a mutually agreed contract, pending the final approval by the Board of
County Commissioners.
The County reserves the right to withdraw this RFP at any time and for any reason, and
to issue such clarifications, modifications, addendums, and/or amendments as it may
deem appropriate, including, but not limited, to requesting supplemental proposal
information.
Receipt of a proposal by the County or a submission of a proposal to the County offers
no rights upon the Consultant nor obligates the County in any manner.
Acceptance of the proposal does not guarantee issuance of any other governmental
approvals. Proposals which include provisions requiring the granting of zoning variances
may not be considered.
10. References
The County reserves the right to contact any and all references submitted as a result of this
solicitation.
11. Proposal Selection Committee and Evaluation Factors
The County Manager or designee will appoint a Selection Committee to review all proposals
submitted. The factors to be considered in the evaluation of proposal responses are listed
below.
Tab II, Business Plan 20
Tab III, Firm Credentials and Experience 30
Tab IV, Discipline Experience and Specialized Expertise of Team 20
Tab V, References 10
Tab VI, Availability and Responsiveness 20
TOTAL 100 Points
Tie Breaker: In the event of a tie, both in individual scoring and in final ranking, the firm
with the lowest paid dollars by Collier County to the Consultant (as obtained from the
County's financial system) within the last five (5) years will receive the higher individual
ranking. This information will be based on information provided by the Consultant, subject
to verification at the County's option. If there is a multiple firm tie in either individual scoring
or final ranking, the firm with the lowest volume of work shall receive the higher ranking, the
firm with the next lowest volume of work shall receive the next highest ranking and so on.
12. Acceptance or Rejection of Proposals
The right is reserved by the County to waive any irregularities in any proposal, to reject any
or all proposals, to re-solicit for proposals, if desired, and upon recommendation and
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
14
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
15 of 37
justification by Collier County to accept the proposal which in the judgment of the County is
deemed the most advantageous for the public and Collier County.
Any proposal which is incomplete, conditional, obscure or which contains irregularities of
any kind, may be cause for rejection. In the event of default of the successful Consultant, or
their refusal to enter into the Collier County contract, the County reserves the right to accept
the proposal of any other Consultant or to re-advertise using the same or revised
documentation, at its sole discretion.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
15
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
16 of 37
Exhibit Ill: Collier County Purchase Order Terms and Conditions
1. Offer regulations. Risk of loss of any goods
This offer is subject to cancellation by the sold hereunder shall transfer to the
COUNTY without notice if not accepted by COUNTY at the time and place of
VENDOR within fourteen (14) days of delivery; provided that risk of loss prior
issuance. to actual receipt of the goods by the
COUNTY nonetheless remain with
2. Acceptance and Confirmation VENDOR.
This Purchase Order (including all b) No charges will be paid by the COUNTY
documents attached to or referenced for packing, crating or cartage unless
therein) constitutes the entire agreement otherwise specifically stated in this
between the parties, unless otherwise Purchase Order. Unless otherwise
specifically noted by the COUNTY on the provided in Purchase Order, no invoices
face of this Purchase Order. Each delivery shall be issued nor payments made
of goods and/or services received by the prior to delivery. Unless freight and
COUNTY from VENDOR shall be deemed to other charges are itemized, any
be upon the terms and conditions contained discount will be taken on the full amount
in this Purchase Order. of invoice.
c) All shipments of goods scheduled on the
No additional terms may be added and same day via the same route must be
Purchase Order may not be changed except consolidated. Each shipping container
by written instrument executed by the must be consecutively numbered and
COUNTY. VENDOR is deemed to be on marked to show this Purchase Order
notice that the COUNTY objects to any number. The container and Purchase
additional or different terms and conditions Order numbers must be indicated on bill
contained in any acknowledgment, invoice of lading. Packing slips must show
or other communication from VENDOR, Purchase Order number and must be
notwithstanding the COUNTY'S acceptance included on each package of less than
or payment for any delivery of goods and/or container load (LCL) shipments and/or
services, or any similar act by VENDOR. with each car load of equipment. The
COUNTY reserves the right to refuse or
3. Inspection return any shipment or equipment at
All goods and/or services delivered VENDOR'S expense that is not marked
hereunder shall be received subject to the with Purchase Order numbers.
COUNTY'S inspection and approval and VENDOR agrees to declare to the
payment therefore shall not constitute carrier the value of any shipment made
acceptance. All payments are subject to under this Purchase Order and the full
adjustment for shortage or rejection. All invoice value of such shipment.
defective or nonconforming goods will be d) All invoices must contain the Purchase
returned pursuant to VENDOR'S instruction Order number and any other specific
at VENDOR'S expense. information as identified on the
Purchase Order. Discounts of prompt
To the extent that a purchase order requires payment will be computed from the date
a series of performances by VENDOR, the of receipt of goods or from date of
COUNTY prospectively reserves the right to receipt of invoices, whichever is later.
cancel the entire remainder of the Purchase Payment will be made upon receipt of a
Order if goods and/or services provided proper invoice and in compliance with
early in the term of the Purchase Order are Chapter 218, Fla. Stats., otherwise
non-conforming or otherwise rejected by the known as the "Local Government
COUNTY. Prompt Payment Act," and, pursuant to
4. Shipping and Invoices the Board of County Commissioners
a) All goods are FOB destination and must Purchasing Policy.
be suitably packed and prepared to
secure the lowest transportation rates 5. Time Is Of the Essence
and to comply with all carrier
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
16
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
17 of 37
Time for delivery of goods or performance of the Occupational Health and Safety Act, the
services under this Purchase Order is of the Federal Transportation Act and the Fair
essence. Failure of VENDOR to meet Labor Standards Act, as well as any law or
delivery schedules or deliver within a regulation noted on the face of the Purchase
reasonable time, as interpreted by the Order.
COUNTY in its sole judgment, shall entitle
the COUNTY to seek all remedies available 9. Advertising
to it at law or in equity. VENDOR agrees to No VENDOR providing goods and services
reimburse the COUNTY for any expenses to the COUNTY shall advertise the fact that
incurred in enforcing its rights. VENDOR it has contracted with the COUNTY for
further agrees that undiscovered delivery of goods and/or services, or appropriate or
nonconforming goods and/or services is not make use of the COUNTY'S name or other
a waiver of the COUNTY'S right to insist identifying marks or property without the
upon further compliance with all prior written consent of the COUNTY'S
specifications. Purchasing Department.
6. Changes 10. Indemnification
The COUNTY may at any time and by VENDOR shall indemnify and hold harmless
written notice make changes to drawings the COUNTY from any and all claims,
and specifications, shipping instructions, including claims of negligence, costs and
quantities and delivery schedules within the expenses, including but not limited to
general scope of this Purchase Order. attorneys' fees, arising from, caused by or
Should any such change increase or related to the injury or death of any person
decrease the cost of, or the time required for (including but not limited to employees and
performance of the Purchase Order, an agents of VENDOR in the performance of
equitable adjustment in the price and/or their duties or otherwise), or damage to
delivery schedule will be negotiated by the property (including property of the COUNTY
COUNTY and VENDOR. Notwithstanding or other persons), which arise out of or are
the foregoing, VENDOR has an affirmative incident to the goods and/or services to be
obligation to give notice if the changes will provided hereunder.
decrease costs. Any claims for adjustment
by VENDOR must be made within thirty (30) 11. Warranty of Non-Infringement
days from the date the change is ordered or VENDOR represents and warrants that all
within such additional period of time as may goods sold or services performed under this
be agreed upon by the parties. Purchase Order are: a) in compliance with
applicable laws; b) do not infringe any
7. Warranties patent, trademark, copyright or trade secret;
VENDOR expressly warrants that the goods and c) do not constitute unfair competition.
and/or services covered by this Purchase
Order will conform to the specifications, VENDOR shall indemnify and hold harmless
drawings, samples or other descriptions the COUNTY from and against any and all
furnished or specified by the COUNTY, and claims, including claims of negligence, costs
will be of satisfactory material and quality and expense, including but not limited to
production, free from defects and sufficient attorneys' fees, which arise from any claim,
for the purpose intended. Goods shall be suit or proceeding alleging that the
delivered free from any security interest or COUNTY'S use of the goods and/or
other lien, encumbrance or claim of any third services provided under this Purchase Order
party. These warranties shall survive are inconsistent with VENDOR'S
inspection, acceptance, passage of title and representations and warranties in section 11
payment by the COUNTY. (a).
8. Statutory Conformity If any claim which arises from VENDOR'S
Goods and services provided pursuant to breach of section 11 (a) has occurred, or is
this Purchase Order, and their production likely to occur, VENDOR may, at the
and transportation shall conform to all COUNTY'S option, procure for the COUNTY
applicable laws, including but not limited to the right to continue using the goods or
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
17
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
18 of 37
services, or replace or modify the goods or this Purchase Order, VENDOR shall
services so that they become non-infringing, immediately give notice thereof, including all
(without any material degradation in relevant information with respects to what
performance, quality, functionality or steps VENDOR is taking to complete
additional cost to the COUNTY). delivery of the goods and/or services to the
COUNTY.
12. Insurance Requirements
The VENDOR, at its sole expense, shall 15. Assignment
provide commercial insurance of such type VENDOR may not assign this Purchase
and with such terms and limits as may be Order, nor any money due or to become due
reasonably associated with the Purchase without the prior written consent of the
Order. Providing and maintaining adequate COUNTY. Any assignment made without
insurance coverage is a material obligation such consent shall be deemed void.
of the VENDOR. All insurance policies shall
be executed through insurers authorized or 16. Taxes
eligible to write policies in the State of Goods and services procured subject to this
Florida. Purchase Order are exempt from Florida
sales and use tax on real property, transient
13. Compliance with Laws rental property rented, tangible personal
In fulfilling the terms of this Purchase Order, purchased or rented, or services purchased
VENDOR agrees that it will comply with all (Florida Statutes, Chapter 212), and from
federal, state, and local laws, rules, codes, federal excise tax.
and ordinances that are applicable to the
conduct of its business. By way of non- 17. Annual Appropriations
exhaustive example, this shall include the The COUNTY'S performance and obligation
American with Disabilities Act and all to pay under this Purchase Order shall be
prohibitions against discrimination on the contingent upon an annual appropriation of
basis of race, religion, sex creed, national funds.
origin, handicap, marital status, or veterans'
status. Further, VENDOR acknowledges 18. Termination
and without exception or stipulation shall be This Purchase Order may be terminated at
fully responsible for complying with the any time by the COUNTY upon 30 days
provisions of the Immigration Reform and prior written notice to the VENDOR. This
Control Act of 1986 as located at 8 U.S.C. Purchase Order may be terminated
1324, et seq. and regulations relating immediately by the COUNTY for breach by
thereto, as either may be amended. Failure VENDOR of the terms and conditions of this
by the awarded firm(s) to comply with the Purchase Order, provided that COUNTY has
laws referenced herein shall constitute a provided VENDOR with notice of such
breach of the award agreement and the breach and VENDOR has failed to cure
County shall have the discretion to within 10 days of receipt of such notice.
unilaterally terminate said agreement
immediately. Any breach of this provision 19. General
may be regarded by the COUNTY as a a) This Purchase Order shall be governed
material and substantial breach of the by the laws of the State of Florida. The
contract arising from this Purchase Order. venue for any action brought to
specifically enforce any of the terms and
14. Force Majeure conditions of this Purchase Order shall
Neither the COUNTY nor VENDOR shall be be the Twentieth Judicial Circuit in and
responsible for any delay or failure in for Collier County, Florida
performance resulting from any cause b) Failure of the COUNTY to act
beyond their control, including, but without immediately in response to a breach of
limitation to war, strikes, civil disturbances this Purchase Order by VENDOR shall
and acts of nature. When VENDOR has not constitute a waiver of breach.
knowledge of any actual or potential force Waiver of the COUNTY by any default
majeure or other conditions which will delay by VENDOR hereunder shall not be
or threatens to delay timely performance of
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
18
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
19 of 37
deemed a waiver of any subsequent Expenses for Public Officers, employees
default by VENDOR. and authorized persons.
c) All notices under this Purchase Order e) In the event of any conflict between or
shall be sent to the respective among the terms of any Contract
addresses on the face page by certified Documents related to this Purchase
mail, return receipt requested, by Order, the terms of the Contract
overnight courier service, or by personal Documents shall take precedence over
delivery and will be deemed effective the terms of the Purchase Order. To the
upon receipt. Postage, delivery and extent any terms and /or conditions of
other charges shall be paid by the this Purchase Order duplicate or overlap
sender. A party may change its address the Terms and Conditions of the
for notice by written notice complying Contract Documents, the provisions of
with the requirements of this section. the Terms and/or Conditions that are
d) The Vendor agrees to reimbursement of most favorable to the County and/or
any travel expenses that may be provide the greatest protection to the
associated with this Purchase Order in County shall govern.
accordance with Florida Statute Chapter
112.061, Per Diem and Travel
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
19
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
20 of 37
Exhibit IV: Additional Terms and Conditions for RFP
1. Insurance and Bonding Requirements
The Consultant shall at its own expense, carry and maintain insurance coverage from responsible
companies duly authorized to do business in the State of Florida as set forth in the Insurance and
Bonding attachment of this solicitation. The Consultant shall procure and maintain property insurance
upon the entire project, if required, to the full insurable value of the scope of work.
The County and the Consultant waive against each other and the County's separate Consultants,
Contractors, Design Consultant, Subcontractors agents and employees of each and all of them, all
damages covered by property insurance provided herein, except such rights as they may have to the
proceeds of such insurance. The Consultant and County shall, where appropriate, require similar
waivers of subrogation from the County's separate Consultants, Design Consultants and Subcontractors
and shall require each of them to include similar waivers in their contracts.
Collier County shall be responsible for purchasing and maintaining, its own liability insurance.
Certificates issued as a result of the award of this solicitation must identify "For any and all work
performed on behalf of Collier County."
The General Liability Policy provided by Consultant to meet the requirements of this solicitation shall
name Collier County, Florida, as an additional insured as to the operations of Consultant under this
solicitation and shall contain a severability of interests provisions.
Collier County Board of County Commissioners shall be named as the Certificate Holder. The
Certificates of Insurance must state the Contract Number, or Project Number, or specific Project
description, or must read: For any and all work performed on behalf of Collier County.The "Certificate
Holder" should read as follows:
Collier County
Board of County Commissioners
Naples, Florida
The amounts and types of insurance coverage shall conform to the minimum requirements set forth in
Insurance and Bonding attachment, with the use of Insurance Services Office (ISO) forms and
endorsements or their equivalents. If Consultant has any self-insured retentions or deductibles under
any of the below listed minimum required coverage, Consultant must identify on the Certificate of
Insurance the nature and amount of such self- insured retentions or deductibles and provide satisfactory
evidence of financial responsibility for such obligations. All self-insured retentions or deductibles will be
Consultant's sole responsibility.
Coverage(s) shall be maintained without interruption from the date of commencement of the Work until
the date of completion and acceptance of the scope of work by the County or as specified in this
solicitation, whichever is longer.
The Consultant and/or its insurance carrier shall provide 30 days written notice to the County of policy
cancellation or non-renewal on the part of the insurance carrier or the Consultant. The Consultant shall
also notify the County, in a like manner, within twenty-four (24) hours after receipt, of any notices of
expiration, cancellation, non-renewal or material change in coverage or limits received by Consultant
from its insurer and nothing contained herein shall relieve Consultant of this requirement to provide
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
20
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
21 of 37
notice. In the event of a reduction in the aggregate limit of any policy to be provided by Consultant
hereunder, Consultant shall immediately take steps to have the aggregate limit reinstated to the full
extent permitted under such policy.
Should at any time the Consultant not maintain the insurance coverage(s) required herein, the County
may terminate the Agreement or at its sole discretion shall be authorized to purchase such coverage(s)
and charge the Consultant for such coverage(s) purchased. If Consultant fails to reimburse the County
for such costs within thirty (30) days after demand, the County has the right to offset these costs from any
amount due Consultant under this Agreement or any other agreement between the County and
Consultant. The County shall be under no obligation to purchase such insurance, nor shall it be
responsible for the coverage(s) purchased or the insurance company or companies used. The decision
of the County to purchase such insurance coverage(s) shall in no way be construed to be a waiver of any
of its rights under the Contract Documents.
If the initial or any subsequently issued Certificate of Insurance expires prior to the completion of the
scope of work, the Consultant shall furnish to the County renewal or replacement Certificate(s) of
Insurance not later than ten (10) calendar days after the expiration date on the certificate. Failure of the
Consultant to provide the County with such renewal certificate(s) shall be considered justification for the
County to terminate any and all contracts.
2. Offer Extended to Other Governmental Entities
Collier County encourages and agrees to the successful Consultant extending the pricing, terms and
conditions of this solicitation or resultant contract to other governmental entities at the discretion of the
successful Consultant.
3. Additional Items and/or Services
Additional items and / or services may be added to the resultant contract, or purchase order, in
compliance with the Purchasing Policy.
4. County's Right to Inspect
The County or its authorized Agent shall have the right to inspect the Consultant's facilities/project site
during and after each work assignment the Consultant is performing.
5. Vendor Performance Evaluation
The County has implemented a Vendor Performance Evaluation System for all contracts awarded in
excess of $25,000. To this end, vendors will be evaluated on their performance upon
completion/termination of this Agreement.
6. Additional Terms and Conditions of Contract
Collier County has developed standard contracts/agreements, approved by the Board of County
Commissioners (BCC). The selected Consultant shall be required to sign a standard Collier County
contract within twenty one (21) days of Notice of Selection for Award.
The resultant contract(s) may include purchase or work orders issued under one, or any combination of
price methodologies by the County's project manager:
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
21
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
22 of 37
Lump Sum (Fixed Price): a firm fixed total price offering for a project; the risks are transferred from
the County to the contractor; and, as a business practice there are no hourly or material invoices
presented, rather, the contractor must perform to the satisfaction of the County's project manager
before payment for the fixed price contract is authorized.
Time and Materials: the County agrees to pay the contractor for the amount of labor time spent by
the contractor's employees and subcontractors to perform the work (number of hours times hourly
rate), and for materials and equipment used in the project (cost of materials plus the contractor's mark
up). This methodology is generally used in projects in which it is not possible to accurately estimate
the size of the project, or when it is expected that the project requirements would most likely change.
As a general business practice, these contracts include back-up documentation of costs; invoices
would include number of hours worked and billing rate by position (and not company (or
subcontractor) timekeeping or payroll records), material or equipment invoices, and other
reimbursable documentation for the project.
Unit Price: the County agrees to pay a firm total fixed price (inclusive of all costs, including labor,
materials, equipment, overhead, etc.) for a repetitive product or service delivered (i.e. installation
price per ton, delivery price per package or carton, etc.). The invoice must identify the unit price and
the number of units received (no contractor inventory or cost verification required).
The County reserves the right to include in any contract document such terms and conditions, as it
deems necessary for the proper protection of the rights of Collier County. A sample copy of this contract
is available upon request. The County will not be obligated to sign any contracts, maintenance and/or
service agreements or other documents provided by the Consultant.
The County's project manager, shall coordinate with the Vendor / Contractor the return of any surplus
assets, including materials, supplies, and equipment associated with the scope or work.
7. Public Records Compliance
The Vendor/Contractor agrees to comply with the Florida Public Records Law Chapter 119 (including
specifically those contractual requirements at F.S. § 119.0701(2) (a)-(d) and (3)), ordinances, codes,
rules, regulations and requirements of any governmental agencies.
8. Payment Method
Payments are made in accordance with the Local Government Prompt Payment Act, Chapter 218,
Florida Statutes. Vendor's invoices must include:
• Purchase Order Number
• Description and quantities of the goods or services provided per instructions on the County's
purchase order or contract.
Invoices shall be sent to:
Board of County Commissioners
Clerk's Finance Department
ATTN: Accounts Payable
3299 Tamiami Trail E Ste 700
Naples FL 34112
Or emailed to: bccapclerk(a.collierclerk.com.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
22
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
23 of 37
Collier County, in its sole discretion, will determine the method of payment for goods and/or services as
part of this agreement.
Payment methods include:
• Traditional — payment by check, wire transfer or other cash equivalent.
• Standard — payment by purchasing card. Collier County's Purchasing Card Program is supported by
standard bank credit suppliers (i.e. VISA and MasterCard), and as such, is cognizant of the Rules for
VISA Merchants and MasterCard Merchant Rules.
The County may not accept any additional surcharges (credit card transaction fees) as a result of using
the County's credit card for transactions relating to this solicitation. The County will entertain bids clearly
stating pricing for standard payment methods. An additional separate discounted price for traditional
payments may be provided at the initial bid submittal if it is clearly marked as an "Additional Cash
Discount."
Upon execution of the Contract and completion of each month's work, payment requests may be
submitted to the Project Manager on a monthly basis by the Contractor for services rendered for that
prior month. Services beyond sixty (60) days from current monthly invoice will not be considered for
payment without prior approval from the Project manager. All invoices should be submitted within the
fiscal year the work was performed. (County's fiscal year is October 1 - September 30.) Invoices
submitted after the close of the fiscal year will not be accepted (or processed for payment) unless
specifically authorized by the Project Manager.
Payments will be made for articles and/or services furnished, delivered, and accepted, upon receipt and
approval of invoices submitted on the date of services or within six (6) months after completion of
contract. Any untimely submission of invoices beyond the specified deadline period is subject to non-
payment under the legal doctrine of "laches" as untimely submitted. Time shall be deemed of the
essence with respect to the timely submission of invoices under this agreement.
In instances where the successful contractor may owe debts (including, but not limited to taxes or other
fees) to Collier County and the contractor has not satisfied nor made arrangement to satisfy these debts,
the County reserves the right to off-set the amount owed to the County by applying the amount owed to
the vendor or contractor for services performed of for materials delivered in association with a contract.
Invoices shall not reflect sales tax. After review and approval, the invoice will be transmitted to the
Finance Division for payment. Payment will be made upon receipt of proper invoice and in compliance
with Chapter 218 Florida Statutes, otherwise known as the "Local Government Prompt Payment Act."
Collier County reserves the right to withhold and/or reduce an appropriate amount of any payment for
work not performed or for unsatisfactory performance of Contractual requirements.
9. Environmental Health and Safety
All Consultants and Sub Consultants performing service for Collier County are required and shall comply
with all Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), State and County Safety and
Occupational Health Standards and any other applicable rules and regulations. Consultants and Sub
Consultants shall be responsible for the safety of their employees and any unsafe acts or conditions that
may cause injury or damage to any persons or property within and around the work site. All firewall
penetrations must be protected in order to meet Fire Codes.
Collier County Government has authorized OSHA representatives to enter any Collier County facility,
property and/or right-of-way for the purpose of inspection of any Consultant's work operations. This
provision is non-negotiable by any department and/or Consultant.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
23
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
24 of 37
All new electrical installations shall incorporate NFPA 70E Short Circuit Protective Device Coordination
and Arc Flash Studies where relevant as determined by the engineer.
All electrical installations shall be labeled with appropriate NFPA 70E arch flash boundary and PPE
Protective labels.
10. Licenses
The Consultant is required to possess the correct Business Tax Receipt, professional license, and any
other authorizations necessary to carry out and perform the work required by the project pursuant to all
applicable Federal, State and Local Law, Statute, Ordinances, and rules and regulations of any kind.
Additionally, copies of the required licenses must be submitted with the proposal response
indicating that the entity proposing, as well as the team assigned to the County account, is
properly licensed to perform the activities or work included in the contract documents. Failure on
the part of any Consultant to submit the required documentation may be grounds to deem
Consultant non-responsive. A Consultant, with an office within Collier County is also required to have
an occupational license.
All State Certified contractors who may need to pull Collier County permits or call in inspections must
complete a Collier County Contractor License registration form and submit the required fee. After
registering the license/registration will need to be renewed thereafter to remain "active" in Collier County
If you have questions regarding professional licenses contact the Contractor Licensing, Community
Development and Environmental Services at (239) 252-2431, 252-2432 or 252-2909. Questions
regarding required occupational licenses, please contact the Tax Collector's Office at (239) 252-2477.
11. Survivability
Bids (ITBs/RFPs): The Consultant/Contractor/Vendor agrees that any Work Order/Purchase Order that
extends beyond the expiration date of Solicitation 16-6629 resultant of this solicitation will survive and
remain subject to the terms and conditions of that Agreement until the completion or termination of any
Work Order/Purchase Order.
12. Principals/Collusion
By submission of this Proposal the undersigned, as Consultant, does declare that the only person or
persons interested in this Proposal as principal or principals is/are named therein and that no person
other than therein mentioned has any interest in this Proposal or in the contract to be entered into; that
this Proposal is made without connection with any person, company or parties making a Proposal, and
that it is in all respects fair and in good faith without collusion or fraud.
13. Relation of County
It is the intent of the parties hereto that the Consultant shall be legally considered an independent
Consultant, and that neither the Consultant nor their employees shall, under any circumstances, be
considered employees or agents of the County, and that the County shall be at no time legally
responsible for any negligence on the part of said Consultant, their employees or agents, resulting in
either bodily or personal injury or property damage to any individual, firm, or corporation.
14. Termination
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
24
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
25 of 37
Should the Consultant be found to have failed to perform his services in a manner satisfactory to the
County, the County may terminate this Agreement immediately for cause; further the County may
terminate this Agreement for convenience with a thirty (30) day written notice. The County shall be sole
judge of non-performance.
15. Lobbying
All firms are hereby placed on NOTICE that the Board of County Commissioners does not wish to be
lobbied, either individually or collectively about a project for which a firm has submitted a Proposal.
Firms and their agents are not to contact members of the County Commission for such purposes as
meeting or introduction, luncheons, dinners, etc. During the process, from Proposal closing to final
Board approval, no firm or their agent shall contact any other employee of Collier County in reference to
this Proposal, with the exception of the Procurement Director or his designee(s). Failure to abide by this
provision may serve as grounds for disqualification for award of this contract to the firm.
16. Certificate of Authority to Conduct Business in the State of Florida (Florida Statute 607.1501)
In order to be considered for award, firms must be registered with the Florida Department of State
Divisions of Corporations in accordance with the requirements of Florida Statute 607.1501 and provide a
certificate of authority (www.sunbiz.orq/search.html) prior to execution of a contract. A copy of the
document may be submitted with the solicitation response and the document number shall be identified.
Firms who do not provide the certificate of authority at the time of response shall be required to provide
same within five (5) days upon notification of selection for award. If the firm cannot provide the document
within the referenced timeframe, the County reserves the right to award to another firm.
17. Single Proposal
Each Consultant must submit, with their proposal, the required forms included in this RFP. Only one
proposal from a legal entity as a primary will be considered. A legal entity that submits a proposal as a
primary or as part of a partnership or joint venture submitting as primary may not then act as a sub-
consultant to any other firm submitting under the same RFP. If a legal entity is not submitting as a
primary or as part of a partnership or joint venture as a primary, that legal entity may act as a sub-
consultant to any other firm or firms submitting under the same RFP. All submittals in violation of this
requirement will be deemed non-responsive and rejected from further consideration.
18. Protest Procedures
Any prospective vendor/proposer who desires to protest any aspect(s) or provision(s) of the solicitation
(including the form of the solicitation documents or procedures) shall file their protest with the
Procurement Director prior to the time of the bid opening strictly in accordance with the County's then
current purchasing ordinance and policies.
The Board of County Commissioners will make award of contract in public session. Award
recommendations will be posted outside the offices of the Purchasing Department on Wednesdays and
Thursdays. Any actual or prospective respondent who desires to formally protest the recommended
contract award must file a notice of intent to protest with the Procurement Director within two (2) calendar
days (excluding weekends and County holidays) of the date that the recommended award is posted.
Upon filing of said notice, the protesting party will have five (5) days to file a formal protest and will be
given instructions as to the form and content requirements of the formal protest. A copy of the "Protest
Policy" is available at the office of the Procurement Director.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
25
Non
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
26 of 37
19. Public Entity Crime
A person or affiliate who has been placed on the convicted Consultant list following a conviction for a
public entity crime may not submit a bid, proposal, or reply on a contract to provide any goods or services
to a public entity; may not submit a bid, proposal, or reply on a contract with a public entity for the
construction or repair of a public building or public work; may not submit bids, proposals, or replies on
leases of real property to a public entity; may not be awarded or perform work as a contractor, supplier,
subcontractor, or consultant under a contract with any public entity; and may not transact business with
any public entity in excess of the threshold amount provided in s. 287.017 for CATEGORY TWO for a
period of 36 months following the date of being placed on the convicted Consultant list.
20. Security and Background Checks
If required, Consultant / Vendor / Contractor / Proposer shall be responsible for the costs of providing
background checks by the Collier County Facilities Management Department, and drug testing for all
employees that shall provide services to the County under this Agreement. This may include, but not be
limited to, checking federal, state and local law enforcement records, including a state and FBI fingerprint
check, credit reports, education, residence and employment verifications and other related records.
Contractor shall be required to maintain records on each employee and make them available to the
County for at least four(4) years.
21. Conflict of Interest
Consultant shall complete the Conflict of Interest Affidavit included as an attachment to this RFP
document. Disclosure of any potential or actual conflict of interest is subject to County staff review and
does not in and of itself disqualify a firm from consideration. These disclosures are intended to identify
and or preclude conflict of interest situations during contract selection and execution.
22. Prohibition of Gifts to County Employees
No organization or individual shall offer or give, either directly or indirectly, any favor, gift, loan, fee,
service or other item of value to any County employee, as set forth in Chapter 112, Part III, Florida
Statutes, the current Collier County Ethics Ordinance and County Administrative Procedure 5311.
Violation of this provision may result in one or more of the following consequences: a. Prohibition by the
individual, firm, and/or any employee of the firm from contact with County staff for a specified period of
time; b. Prohibition by the individual and/or firm from doing business with the County for a specified
period of time, including but not limited to: submitting bids, RFP, and/or quotes; and, c. immediate
termination of any contract held by the individual and/or firm for cause.
23. Immigration Law Affidavit Certification
Statutes and executive orders require employers to abide by the immigration laws of the United States
and to employ only individuals who are eligible to work in the United States.
The Employment Eligibility Verification System (E-Verify) operated by the Department of Homeland
Security (DHS) in partnership with the Social Security Administration (SSA), provides an Internet-based
means of verifying employment eligibility of workers in the United States; it is not a substitute for any
other employment eligibility verification requirements. The program will be used for Collier County formal
Invitations to Bid (ITB) and Request for Proposals (RFP) including professional services and construction
services.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
26
d i. eromitilMINI11111111111111mo
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
27 of 37
Exceptions to the program:
• Commodity based procurement where no services are provided.
• Where the requirement for the affidavit is waived by the Board of County Commissioners
Consultants / Bidders are required to enroll in the E-Verify program, and provide acceptable evidence of
their enrollment, at the time of the submission of the Consultant's/bidder's proposal. Acceptable
evidence consists of a copy of the properly completed E-Verify Company Profile page or a copy of the
fully executed E-Verify Memorandum of Understanding for the company. Consultants are also required
to provide the Collier County Purchasing Department an executed affidavit certifying they shall comply
with the E-Verify Program. The affidavit is attached to the solicitation documents. If the
Bidder/Consultant does not comply with providing the acceptable E-Verify evidence and the
executed affidavit the bidder's/ Consultant's proposal may be deemed non-responsive.
Additionally, Consultants shall require all subcontracted Consultants to use the E-Verify system for all
purchases not covered under the "Exceptions to the program" clause above.
For additional information regarding the Employment Eligibility Verification System (E-Verify) program
visit the following website: http://www.dhs.qov/E-Verifv. It shall be the Consultant's responsibility to
familiarize themselves with all rules and regulations governing this program.
Consultant acknowledges, and without exception or stipulation, any firm(s) receiving an award shall be
fully responsible for complying with the provisions of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 as
located at 8 U.S.C. 1324, et seq. and regulations relating thereto, as either may be amended and with the
provisions contained within this affidavit. Failure by the awarded firm(s) to comply with the laws
referenced herein or the provisions of this affidavit shall constitute a breach of the award agreement and
the County shall have the discretion to unilaterally terminate said agreement immediately.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
27
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
28 of 37
Colter County
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
Attachment 1: Consultant's Non-Response Statement
The sole intent of the Collier County Purchasing Department is to issue solicitations that are clear, concise
and openly competitive. Therefore, we are interested in ascertaining reasons for prospective Consultants not
wishing to respond to this solicitation. If your firm is not responding to this RFP, please indicate the
reason(s) by checking the item(s) listed below and return this form via email or fax, noted on the cover page,
or mail to Collier County Government, Purchasing Department, 3327 Tamiami Trail E, Naples, FL 34112.
We are not responding to CCNA Solicitation 16-6629 —2016 Beach Renourishment Design for the
following reason(s):
❑ Services requested not available through our company.
❑ Our firm could not meet specifications/scope of work.
❑ Specifications/scope of work not clearly understood or applicable (too vague, rigid, etc.)
❑ Project is too small.
❑ Insufficient time allowed for preparation of response.
❑ Incorrect address used. Please correct mailing address:
❑ Other reason(s):
Name of Firm:
Address:
City, State, Zip:
Telephone:
Email:
Representative Signature:
Representative Name: Date
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
28
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
29 of 37
Colter county
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Di r.sion
Attachment 2: Consultant Check List
IMPORTANT: THIS SHEET MUST BE SIGNED. Please read carefully, sign in the spaces indicated and
return with your Proposal.
Consultant should check off each of the following items as the necessary action is completed:
❑ The Proposal has been signed.
❑ All applicable forms have been signed and included, along with licenses to complete the requirements
of the project.
❑ Any addenda have been signed and included.
❑ The mailing envelope has been addressed to:
Collier County Government
Purchasing Department
3327 Tamiami Trail E
Naples FL 34112
Attn: Adam Northrup, Procurement Strategist
CCNA Solicitation: 16-6629 —2016 Beach Renourishment Design
❑ The mailing envelope must be sealed and marked with Proposal Number, Proposal Title and Due
Date.
❑ The Proposal will be mailed or delivered in time to be received no later than the specified due date
and time. (Otherwise Proposal cannot be considered.)
❑ If submitting a manual bid, include any addenda (initialed and dated noting understanding and
receipt). If submitting bid electronically, bidder will need to download all related documents
on www.colliergov.net/bid. The system will date and time stamp when the addendum files
were downloaded.
ALL COURIER-DELIVERED PROPOSALS MUST HAVE THE RFP NUMBER AND TITLE ON THE
OUTSIDE OF THE COURIER PACKET
Name of Firm:
Address:
City, State, Zip:
Telephone:
Email:
Representative Signature:
1
Representative Name: Date
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
29
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
30 of 37
,er county
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
Attachment 3: Conflict of Interest Affidavit
By the signature below, the firm (employees, officers and/or agents) certifies, and hereby discloses, that, to
the best of their knowledge and belief, all relevant facts concerning past, present, or currently planned
interest or activity (financial, contractual, organizational, or otherwise) which relates to the proposed work;
and bear on whether the firm (employees, officers and/or agents) has a possible conflict have been fully
disclosed.
Additionally, the firm (employees, officers and/or agents) agrees to immediately notify in writing the
Procurement Director, or designee, if any actual or potential conflict of interest arises during the contract
and/or project duration.
Firm:
Signature and Date:
Print Name
Title of Signatory
State of
County of
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this day of
20
by , who is personally known to me to be the
for the Firm, OR who produced the following identification
Notary Public
My Commission Expires
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
30
lionimmormonnailmmin
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
31 of 37
CoiiL7er County
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
Attachment 4: Consultant Declaration Statement
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
Collier County Government Complex
Naples, Florida 34112
RE: CCNA Solicitation: 16-6629—2016 Beach Renourishment Design
Dear Commissioners:
The undersigned, as Consultant declares that this proposal is made without connection or arrangement with
any other person and this proposal is in every respect fair and made in good faith, without collusion or fraud.
The Consultant agrees, if this proposal is accepted, to execute a Collier County document for the purpose of
establishing a formal contractual relationship between the firm and Collier County, for the performance of all
requirements to which the proposal pertains. The Consultant states that the proposal is based upon the
proposal documents listed by the above referenced CCNA Solicitation.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, WE have hereunto subscribed our names on this day of
200 in the County of , in the State of
Firm's Legal Name:
Address:
City, State, Zip Code:
Florida Certificate of
Authority Document
Number
Federal Tax
Identification Number
CCR # or CAGE
Code
Telephone:
FAX:
Signature by:
(Typed and written)
Title:
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
31
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
32 of 37
Additional Contact Information
Send payments to:
(required if different from above) Company name used as payee
Contact name:
Title:
Address:
City, State,ZIP
Telephone:
FAX:
Email:
Office servicing Collier
County to place orders
(required if different from above)
Contact name:
Title:
Address:
City, State,ZIP
Telephone:
Email:
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
32
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
33 of 37
Cot er coHhty
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
Attachment 5: Immigration Affidavit Certification
CCNA Solicitation: 16-6629—2016 Beach Renourishment Design
This Affidavit is required and should be signed, notarized by an authorized principal of the firm and submitted with
formal Invitations to Bid (ITB's)and Request for Proposals (RFP) submittals. Further, Consultants/ Bidders are
required to enroll in the E-Verify program, and provide acceptable evidence of their enrollment, at the time of
the submission of the Consultant's/bidder's proposal. Acceptable evidence consists of a copy of the properly
completed E-Verify Company Profile page or a copy of the fully executed E-Verify Memorandum of
Understanding for the company. Failure to include this Affidavit and acceptable evidence of enrollment in the
E-Verify program may deem the Consultant/Bidder's proposal as non-responsive.
Collier County will not intentionally award County contracts to any Consultant who knowingly employs unauthorized
alien workers, constituting a violation of the employment provision contained in 8 U.S.C. Section 1324 a(e) Section
274A(e) of the Immigration and Nationality Act ("INA").
Collier County may consider the employment by any Consultant of unauthorized aliens a violation of Section 274A (e) of
the INA. Such Violation by the recipient of the Employment Provisions contained in Section 274A(e) of the INA shall be
grounds for unilateral termination of the contract by Collier County.
Consultant attests that they are fully compliant with all applicable immigration laws (specifically to the 1986 Immigration
Act and subsequent Amendment(s)) and agrees to comply with the provisions of the Memorandum of Understanding
with E-Verify and to provide proof of enrollment in The Employment Eligibility Verification System (E-Verify), operated by
the Department of Homeland Security in partnership with the Social Security Administration at the time of submission of
the Consultant's/Bidder's proposal.
Company Name
Print Name Title
Signature Date
State of
County of
20
The foregoing instrument was signed and acknowledged before me this day of
by
who has produced as identification.
(Print or Type Name) (Type of Identification and Number)
Notary Public Signature
Printed Name of Notary Public
Notary Commission Number/Expiration
The signee of this Affidavit guarantees, as evidenced by the sworn affidavit required herein, the truth and accuracy of
this affidavit to interrogatories hereinafter made.
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
33
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
34 of 37
Caber County
Administrative Servs Department
Procuromcnt Servces C,v,sion
Attachment 6: Consultant Substitute W—9
Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification
In accordance with the Internal Revenue Service regulations, Collier County is required to collect the following
information for tax reporting purposes from individuals and companies who do business with the County (including
social security numbers if used by the individual or company for tax reporting purposes). Florida Statute
119.071(5) require that the county notify you in writing of the reason for collecting this information, which will be
used for no other purpose than herein stated. Please complete all information that applies to your business and
return with your quote or proposal.
1. General Information (provide all information)
Taxpayer Name
(as shown on income tax return)
Business Name
(if different from taxpayer name)
Address City
State Zip
Telephone FAX Email
Order Information Remit/Payment Information
Address Address
City State Zip City State Zip
FAX FAX
Email Email
2. Company Status (check only one)
Individual/Sole Proprietor Corporation _Partnership
_Tax Exempt (Federal income tax-exempt entity _Limited Liability Company
under Internal Revenue Service guidelines IRC
501 (c)3) Enter the tax classification
(D=Disregarded Entity, C=Corporation, P=Partnership)
3. Taxpayer Identification Number(for tax reporting purposes only)
Federal Tax Identification Number(TIN)
(Consultants who do not have a TIN, will be required to provide a social security number prior to an award).
4. Sign and Date Form: Certification: Under penalties of perjury, I certify that the information shown on this form is correct to
my knowledge.
Signature Date
Title Phone Number
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
34
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
35 of 37
ler County
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
Attachment 7: Insurance and Bonding Requirements
Insurance/Bond Type Required Limits
1. ®Worker's Statutory Limits of Florida Statutes, Chapter 440 and all Federal Government
Compensation Statutory Limits and Requirements
2. ® Employer's Liability $100,000 single limit per occurrence
3. ® Commercial General Bodily Injury and Property Damage
Liability(Occurrence Form)
patterned after the current $T,000,000 single limit per occurrence, $2,000,000 aggregate for Bodily Injury
ISO form Liability and Property Damage Liability. This shall include Premises and
Operations; Independent Contractors; Products and Completed Operations
and Contractual Liability.
4. ® Indemnification To the maximum extent permitted by Florida law, the
Contractor/Vendor/Consultant shall indemnify and hold harmless Collier
County, its officers and employees from any and all liabilities, damages,
losses and costs, including, but not limited to, reasonable attorneys'fees and
paralegals'fees, to the extent caused by the negligence, recklessness, or
intentionally wrongful conduct of the Contractor/Vendor/Consultant or anyone
employed or utilized by the Contractor/Vendor/Consultant in the performance
of this Agreement.
4. ®Automobile Liability $ 1,000 Each Occurrence; Bodily Injury& Property Damage,
Owned/Non-owned/Hired; Automobile Included
5. ❑ Other insurance as D Watercraft $ Per Occurrence
noted:
❑ United States Longshoreman's and Harborworker's Act coverage shall be
maintained where applicable to the completion of the work.
$ Per Occurrence
❑ Maritime Coverage(Jones Act) shall be maintained where applicable to
the completion of the work.
$ Per Occurrence
❑Aircraft Liability coverage shall be carried in limits of not less than
$5,000,000 each occurrence if applicable to the completion of the Services
under this Agreement.
$ Per Occurrence
❑ Pollution $ Per Occurrence
® Professional Liability $1,000,000 per claim and in
the aggregate
• $1,000,000 per claim and in the aggregate
• $2,000,000 per claim and in the aggregate
❑ Project Professional Liability $ Per Occurrence
❑Valuable Papers Insurance $ Per Occurrence
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
35
CAC June 9,2016
❑ Employee Dishonesty/Crime $ PeVOONAPEIRAPiess
Including Employee Theft, Funds Transfer Fraud, Include a Joint 11.63)61337
Payee endorsement naming Collier County.
6. ❑ Bid bond Shall be submitted with proposal response in the form of certified funds,
cashiers' check or an irrevocable letter of credit, a cash bond posted with the
County Clerk, or proposal bond in a sum equal to 5%of the cost proposal. All
checks shall be made payable to the Collier County Board of County
Commissioners on a bank or trust company located in the State of Florida and
insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
7. 0 Performance and For projects in excess of$200,000, bonds shall be submitted with the
Payment Bonds executed contract by Proposers receiving award, and written for 100% of the
Contract award amount, the cost borne by the Proposer receiving an award.
The Performance and Payment Bonds shall be underwritten by a surety
authorized to do business in the State of Florida and otherwise acceptable to
Owner; provided, however, the surety shall be rated as"A-" or better as to
general policy holders rating and Class V or higher rating as to financial size
category and the amount required shall not exceed 5% of the reported policy
holders' surplus, all as reported in the most current Best Key Rating Guide,
published by A.M. Best Company, Inc. of 75 Fulton Street, New York, New
York 10038.
8. ® Consultant shall ensure that all subcontractors comply with the same insurance requirements that he is
required to meet. The same Consultant shall provide County with certificates of insurance meeting the
required insurance provisions.
9. ® Collier County must be named as "ADDITIONAL INSURED" on the Insurance Certificate for Commercial
General Liability where required.
10. ® The Certificate Holder shall be named as Collier County Board of County Commissioners, OR, Board of
County Commissioners in Collier County, OR Collier County Government, OR Collier County. The
Certificates of Insurance must state the Contract Number, or Project Number, or specific Project description,
or must read: For any and all work performed on behalf of Collier County.
11. ® Thirty (30) Days Cancellation Notice required.
RLC 4/1/2016
Consultant's Insurance Statement
We understand the insurance requirements of these specifications and that the evidence of insurability may be
required within five (5) days of the award of this solicitation.
Name of Firm Date
Consultant
Signature
Print Name
Insurance Agency
Agent Name Telephone Number
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
36
4
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-2 New Business
Colter ter.County37 of 37
Administrative Services Department
Procurement Services Division
Attachment 8: Reference Questionnaire
Solicitation: 16-6629— 2016 Beach Renourishment Design
Reference Questionnaire for:
(Name of Company Requesting Reference Information)
i
g (Name of Individuals Requesting Reference Information)
Name: Company:
(Evaluator completing reference questionnaire) (Evaluator's Company completing reference)
Email: FAX: Telephone:
Collier County is implementing a process that collects reference information on firms and their key personnel to be used in
the selection of firms to perform this project. The Name of the Company listed in the Subject above has listed you as a
client for which they have previously performed work. Please complete the survey. Please rate each criteria to the best of
your knowledge on a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 representing that you were very satisifed (and would hire the firm/individual
again)and 1 representing that you were very unsatisfied (and would never hire the firm/indivdival again). If you do not
have sufficient knowledge of past performance in a particular area, leave it blank and the item or form will be scored "0."
Project Description: Completion Date:
Project Budget: Project Number of Days:
Item Citeria Score
1 Ability to manage the project costs (minimize change orders to scope).
2 Ability to maintain project schedule (complete on-time or early).
4
3 Quality of work.
4 Quality of consultative advice provided on the project.
5 Professionalism and ability to manage personnel.
i 6 Project administration (completed documents, final invoice, final product turnover;
invoices; manuals or going forward documentation, etc.)
7 Ability to verbally communicate and document information clearly and succinctly.
8 Abiltity to manage risks and unexpected project circumstances.
9 Ability to follow contract documents, policies, procedures, rules, regulations, etc.
10 Overall comfort level with hiring the company in the future(customer satisfaction).
TOTAL SCORE OF ALL ITEMS
11 Please FAX this completed survey to: By
RFP CCNA Template_01202016 16-6629
_1 37
CAC June 9,2016
VIII-3 New Business
1 of 1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to approve the donation of approximately 13,000 cubic yards(CY's)of sand from
the Collier County School Board over the next five (5) years to be used as needed within Collier
County.
OBJECTIVE: To approve the donation of approximately 13,000 CY's of sand from the Collier County
School Board to be use at various venues within Collier County such as rebuilding of Sugden Park Lake
beach, Parks and Recreation ball fields or landfill cover.
CONSIDERATIONS: Collier County staff was approached by the Collier County School Board
representatives with the possibility of a sand donation from various public school playgrounds. The
complete donation would be over the next five (5) years and consist of uniform quality sand that is
essentially free of organics. The sand is being replaced to avoid playground falling injuries. Collier
County staff has inspected the sand and has verified its condition. The School Board will remove,
transport and stockpile the sand to designated locations within the county, within reason. The sand will
be donated"as-is". Collier will not incur any expenses as a result of this donation.
This material has a variety of uses within the County. Originally, it was considered for beach
renourishment. However, after review of the material, staff determined that the sand could be better used
for the rebuilding of Sugden Park lake beach, or for Parks and Recreation ball fields or landfill cover.
FISCAL IMPACT: Sand from the Collier County School Board will be donated to the BCC over an
approximate period of five years. The estimated value of the donation is over$1,000, however, it will be
utilized for maintenance activities throughout the county and is not considered a capital asset. As such,
there is no fiscal impact associated with this action.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no impact to the Growth Management Plan related to
this action.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney, is approved as to
form and legality,and requires majority vote for approval. -JAK
RECOMMENDATION: Recommendation to approve the donation of approximately 13,000 cubic yards
(CY's) of sand from the Collier County School Board over the next five (5) years to be used as needed
within Collier County.
Prepared By: J. Gary McAlpin, P.E., Coastal Zone Management, Capital Project Planning, Impact Fees
and Program Management Division,Growth Management Department