Loading...
Agenda 12/21/1989 PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD AGENDA DECEMBER 21, 1989 • The Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meeting will be held Thursday, December 21, 1989 at 8 : 30 a.m. in the Parks and Recreation Administration Building, 3300 Santa Barbara Boulevard. I . Call to Order II . Approval of November 16, 1989 Minutes III . Old Business A. PARAB Guidelines• B. F. E. Mackle Community Park/Wilson, Miller, Barton, Soll and Peek, Inc. C. Proposed Linear Park - Golden Gate Parkway D. Beach Parking Permits E. Tigertail Beach per Mr. Kobza F. Action List IV. New Business I MINUTES - DECEMBER 21, 1989 PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD GOLDEN GATE COMMUNITY PARK ADMINISTRATION BUILDING 3300 SANTA BARBARA BOULEVARD, NAPLES, FLORIDA 33999 PRESENT: Chairman Scott McQuillin Vice Chairman Charles Stevens Kim Patrick Kobza, Esquire Mrs. Cherryle Thomas Mr. Gil Mueller ALSO PRESENT: Kevin O'Donnell, Public Services Administrator Cliff Crawford, Parks and Recreation Director Murdo Smith, Parks and Recreation Manager William Lorenz , Environmental Services Director James Burch, Chief Environmental Specialist Harry Huber, Technical Services Supervisor Michael Joity, DNR Representative, Beaches and Shores Concerned Residents of Marco Island Including Mr. and Mrs. Barozzi, Mr. Larry Basik, Mr. Dan Mahoney, Mr. Frank Blanchard, Mr. Dominic Maccarini I . Meeting called to order at 8 : 33 a.m. II . Minutes of special meeting ofDeccembeer. 12 , 19u89iapprovedoand sowell IEF as regular meeting of November and approved unanimously. III . Action List A. Bluebill Boat Ramp. Moving forward. Being reviewed by Real Property for property exchange. B. North Naples Community Park Baseball Field and parking lot approved. Playable in July. C. Willow Run on indefinite hold. D. Two tennis courts at NNCP will be finished within two weeks. E. Domesticated animals in parks resolution scheduled before BCC in January. F. Beach Parking Permit in Attorney's office pending legal review of accepting City parking permits because of State grant. IV. Old Business A. Linear park in Golden Gate discussed toand table anddesirable Mueller park site. Mr. Stevens made seconded. Approved unanimously. 4 0 DRAFT GUIDELINES COLLIER COUNTY PARKS AND RECREATION BOARD SEPTEMBER 1989 ARTICLE I - Membership Sec. 1 Pursuant to the authority of the Board of County Commissioners, Collier County, Florida, and as provided by Florida Statutes, the Collier County Parks and Recreation Advisory Board shall consist of five (5) members appointed in increments of two and three each by the Board of County Commissioners to serve for four years commencing on appropriate odd numbered years. Sec. 2 Members shall attend meetings regularly and serve as officers of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board to which they may be appointed. In accordance with Board of County Commissioners policy, if an advisory board member misses three (3) consecutive meetings without prior approval, he will be considered terminated from the advisory board. Replacements shall also be appointed in accordance with Board of County Commissioners policy. ARTICLE II - Officers Sec. 1 At the annual meeting (October) each year, the board members will select from among their number a Chairman and a Vice Chairman to take office at the next regular meeting and serve for one year, with eligibility for re-election. Sec. 2 The Chairman shall preside at all meetings, authorize calls for any special meetings and generally perform the duties of presiding officer. Sec. 3 The Chairman shall be empowered to call a special election to fill any officer vacancy. Sec. 4 The Vice Chairman shall serve in the absence of the Chairman. Sec. 5 The department staff shall keep a true and accurate account of all proceedings of regular board meetings and, on authorization by the Chairman, of any special meetings, shall have custody of the minutes and other records of the board and shall notify the Chairman when a vacancy occurs. ARTICLE III - Duties Sec. 1 Functions, powers and duties of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board shall be as follows: A. Act in an advisory capacity to the Board of County Commissioners in policy matters relating to Parks and Recreation affairs. B. To respond to citizen interests or inquiries relating to Parks and Recreation activities. C. To promote citizen awareness and encourage community understanding of the Parks and Recreation Department. D. Identify, study, evaluate and provide recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners on policy matters relating to Parks and Recreation. E. To accept policy study assignments from the Board of County Commissioners and present such recommendations to the Commission for action. ARTICLE IV - Parks and Recreation Director Sec. 1 The Parks and Recreation Director will have charge of the administration of the Department under the direction and approval of the Public Services Division Administrator. Sec. 2 The Director will assure the care of buildings and equipment, direction of the staff, quality of the department's services and operation of the Parks and Recreation department under the financial conditions set forth in the annual budget. ARTICLE V - Meetings Sec. 1 The regular meeting of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board shall be held at the call of the Chairman on the third Thursday of each month at the Parks and Recreation Administration Building, Golden Gate Community Park or other date and location approved by the board and properly advertised to the public. Sec. 2 The annual meeting shall be held immediately following the close of the regular meeting in October at the same place. Sec. 3 The Chairman may call special meetings when he deems it necessary, or shall call such meetings upon the written request of two board members for the transaction of only that business stated in the call . Sec. 4 All meetings of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board are held in conformance with the provisions of Chapter 286, Florida Statutes. Sec. 5 Three members shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of all business of the board. 1 Sec. 6 The order of business for regular meetings shall be: Call to Order Approval of Minutes Staff Report Communications Unfinished Business General Considerations Public Presentations Adjournment Sec. 7 Robert's Rules of Order, latest revised edition, shall govern the parliamentary procedure of the board in all situations not covered by these bylaws. ARTICLE VI - Guidelines Sec. 1 The board will annually review in October all guidelines in (ril; force. Sec. 2 Amendments to these guidelines may be proposed by majority vote at any meetings at which a quorum is present, provided the proposed amendments were stated in the call for the meeting. These guidelines and amendments thereto will take effect upon affirmation by the Board of County Commissioners. Date: Scott McQuillin, Chairman Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Collier County Naples, Florida Date: Burt L. Saunders, Chairman Board of County Commissioners Collier County Naples, Florida DRAFT4:) GUIDELINES COLLIER COUNTY PARKS AND RECREATION BOARD SEPTEMBER 1989 ARTICLE I - Membership Sec. 1 Pursuant to the authority of the Board of County Commissioners, Collier County, Florida, and as provided by Florida Statutes, the Collier County Parks and Recreation Advisory Board shall consist of five (5) members appointed in increments of two and three each by the Board of County Commissioners to serve for four years commencing on appropriate odd numbered years. Sec. 2 Members shall attend meetings regularly and serve as officers of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board to which they may be appointed. In accordance with Board of County Commissioners policy, if an advisory board member misses three (3) consecutive meetings without prior approval, he will be considered terminated from the advisory board. Replacements shall also be appointed in accordance with Board of County Commissioners policy. ARTICLE II - Officers Sec. 1 At the annual meeting (October) each year, the board members will select from among their number a Chairman and a Vice Chairman to take office at the next regular meeting and serve for one year, with eligibility for re-election. Sec. 2 The Chairman shall preside at all meetings, authorize calls for any special meetings and generally perform the duties of presiding officer. Sec. 3 The Chairman shall be empowered to call a special election to fill any officer vacancy. Sec. 4 The Vice Chairman shall serve in the absence of the Chairman. • Sec. 5 The department staff shall keep a true and accurate account of all proceedings of regular board meetings and, on authorization by the Chairman, of any special meetings, shall have custody of the minutes and other records of the board and shall notify the Chairman when a vacancy occurs. 4:) ARTICLE III - Duties Sec. 1 Functions, powers and duties of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board shall be as follows: A. Act in an advisory capacity to the Board of County Commissioners in policy matters relating to Parks and Recreation affairs. B. To respond to citizen interests or inquiries relating to Parks and Recreation activities. C. To promote citizen awareness and encourage community understanding of the Parks and Recreation Department. D. Identify, study, evaluate and provide recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners on policy matters relating to Parks and Recreation. E. To accept policy study assignments from the Board of County Commissioners and present such recommendations to the Commission for action. ARTICLE IV - Parks and Recreation Director IL Sec. 1 The Parks and Recreation Director will have charge of the administration of the Department under the direction and approval of the Public Services Division Administrator. Sec. 2 The Director will assure the care of buildings and equipment, direction of the staff, quality of the department's services and operation of the Parks and Recreation department under the financial conditions set forth in the annual budget. ARTICLE V - Meetings Sec. 1 The regular meeting of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board shall be held at the call of the Chairman on the third Thursday of each month at the Parks and Recreation Administration Building, Golden Gate Community Park or other date and location approved by the board and properly advertised to the public. Sec. 2 The annual meeting shall be held immediately following the close of the regular meeting in October at the same place. Sec. 3 The Chairman may call special meetings when he deems it necessary, or shall call such meetings upon the written request of two board members for the transaction of only that business stated in the call. t IC: Sec. 4 All meetings of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board are held in conformance with the provisions of Chapter 286, Florida Statutes. Sec. 5 Three members shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of all business of the board. Sec. 6 The order of business for regular meetings shall be: Call to Order Approval of Minutes Staff Report • Communications Unfinished Business General Considerations Public Presentations Adjournment Sec. 7 Robert's Rules of Order, latest revised edition, shall govern the parliamentary procedure of the board in all situations not covered by these bylaws. ARTICLE VI - Guidelines Sec. 1 The board will annually review in October all guidelines in t.-4' force. Sec. 2 Amendments to these guidelines may be proposed by majority vote at any meetings at which a quorum is present, provided the proposed amendments were stated in the call for the meeting. These guidelines and amendments thereto will take effect upon affirmation by the Board of County Commissioners. Date: Scott McQuillin, Chairman Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Collier County Naples, Florida Date: Burt L. Saunders, Chairman Board of County Commissioners Collier County Naples, Florida 11/0 .5-44/n//3 koe DE/int /llF?E co _Is L4-7,/A, 1=1., 33 9 3 7 /z/z./J 8? /6 eAe she's, Z 4,-, ,t ezat v co,v e 52,L3670 R/30(47 T; S'7/i-7-46 0,- T 662 74-7L 08 9-e,V, ,9' 'c 7/' 11/H-7 /7 &ice/ /4- -oiJC-� m Zz--74e/4-Tl� 7h r P, 7 (1 erbe. ;heed- ti /t14-7 ge// c l,✓ Gou4ii tL No,e fy o, A/64Z p,✓ TW 6 i LA CoRs7 77M7 h & lig/ c oq -o ow APow7il, a 2 fJo Ai07 y.006e-s74„/a ivh1,1-is C47v.✓©T /33 . o Ai& 4 7 Gth2-7-4.L 3 /a. °o ma M7 /}ai is Loci-72:7 (- of 3 /V g-x7 7o Tis,--& ed?'-e-/-/ fav Njo,e o 'w a um I W D(4L-.0 /�PP+C L�1/i�c, CA f}'�✓y7y�"16 LI 0-1.4 C'-/-N a v n� LI'< X Lm CO 70 21-0.L 77(62 74,4_ 50 �i y /7 (J ea Q V 27 s the), `1owes �eiLy, S vt 141,11/62: /1414A-e 3 3 LA t.4 NIL • "Ja t ;i.' x.o i. 4 4 . t 1 I ' *"......, ) ..„ A s \ 1 i d Cl - 1 "%.,, 1 _ 41 , ',4( ......_ f„. _IA _.., tv?..)-3,,,,, a 1 4 Tic 11 i ,, . „....., ), I -,.. ,I ., r. ri: . > ..... ... 41,/ 1 ,... ..,,' -,c N, ,.1/7°Are/ psi Catfa, Corrairo 1e,. • ; i L Com`- 7 11,t)-) 011 GLA-(-40-1,4-do rte; *4ZL-c)U-/ LLe_e„,e1r:AAL(A)-4:1D01-e —i-- ji--c; 4 texJ. 7,JD, cLk, .,L4, Htuiliilvi ' 1 ', 4ifill .:: rtil i ill\ ,j,Jiri ^o — 11%5 I G igflri ., g w O`< �� N rn �.r " STALLINGS, Ph.D. ��1'* g F. (FRAN) Specialist m :TI � Environmental Protection o▪ � E° z 9 Cl) The Conservancy X63.0223 2 1450 Merrihue Drive (813) C" Naples. Florida 33942 o• z 0 ( r.,) w w' N O) W O N W 1 Th)1 i'M C. 'filaCCCAr - TO— € /11/C., (0 ct/ct i ik./ , 1/40 Secofietja 4//0.5___ /n, 661_41 "t l�� CcT.G� �j}���� • 6�1--�X.JA3- -7 t , 1 c,...„. , Cc >T4.i C. ... Ul'7 O[ -V uC, . Is/ I ,, .. A-6aes- s 4 v �L. \ a 4:) MEMORANDUM . • • DATE: 14 November 1989 TO: Ron Lee, Senior Planner FROM: Kevin O'Donnell, Public Services Administratorj2) ,. RE: Proposed Linear Park/Golden Gate Parkway Pertaining to your memo of October 24th, I have reviewed the ' potential park area. Please be advised that within the Growth Management Plan the Parks and Recreation Department is not anticipating adding further to its neighborhood park inventory. Due to the acreage in question (20) the area ycu referenced falls into that classification. There is also concern that since the park site splits Golden Gate Parkway, a rather busy road and it is only 125 ft. deep, it is rather limiting as to what type of facilities could be safely secured in the park site. The area could be developed with some park benches, exercise stands and possibly a jogging trail, although I would be reluctant to see the trail on the two parcels connected because that would require runners transversing Golden Gate Parkway. ;.� I am prepared to offer a few suggestions on how the County can proceed on this parcel. 1. I will present it to the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board for some feedback as to their desires at their November 16th meeting. 2 . I will ask my staff in Parks and Recreation to site plan certain facilities such as those enumerated above within the confines of the area and estimate the cost. 3 . If the County was to proceed in acquiring this site, acquisition and maintenance of the facility as a neighborhood park could be deemed -'-444n"" appropriate expense for the special Municipal Taxing District already in existence. In essence, the group most affected and being able to enjoy the k s benefits of a neighborhood park would be paying for its maintenance and upkeePp • particularlyduetits shape :.and size constraints it ,; does 'not . eadily afford itself :to much 'County-wide use. N' ,. ""'• Ve. !l • . N — Raa . Should you have any questions, feel free to contact my office. KO'D/cros cc: Cliff Crawford, Parks & Recreation Director v 3 • • - ri rr 2r aas' i" ;, 4'ae wz �! • ,,,• r .Msa,+ ,.r3r,amwfr #a§�, Vis ` ;,, +..atbt to z ,,z t'tw,tip#'swti n.0104Y .,e74 +As�.J' gr^ AAi* w"� ,pc�'nv ^. , ,..ri.'ee" .,:. s s. .. ..,. .,..: «iir,•. w+r:5:..' �+"".. ;r,'WYp +.. ,,,wa �.M, ti te - "� " " .. : ,=•�em^- � d °' ^ . '1,.,'4:-',;.:.''';,;(3/4,,s-.,..1:-. i 1 + „ r -�i ,. r ''..':':e'„ ,....,-,,,..71,-,..--,7-.T.,-,,,:.,;,,,,,:-v -0v4. 4°'-* --.1-- r; 4 s,, r , .r .'ems"C� � �* r 4 2i' �,,„, , ”;sF ', • k T. �'..,y roa ,„.0 Ito,„ow 34,44- e4-`aYt�.r rr s - N mow4Lr _- _..' b ..' .J• `R ha• .v. --. ! ` . ,4444 , _. r._ . ,. uaey�Say..i.sXa•aXeg.. .a,/.•n�5}"4 aa4 la ..u+e+• .R.. �..M.y .P'iaaaC.a v` xY' :..fitat 'a.a'j t +•�P V'W T.zgq'laabY '•w a ,.,Ylitx.. ..1 ” .L.:4+t7+ + ,.r,„„„„4 a^%t,3a+4va uri,.i.4 m. aAi + a ' Y 'M ( 4 , : } SYt -S 'T ArZ4t i { i v-:tW t. l Si {x S '. n-" +i. F 1 •n ...: -.e ""�,yogE+a *zrwa ...-�.. , .-�«�s,w _s-,,,,(,1 ,-. "'�M�l`-"mak*rte nax+,n . >r �u, MEMORANDUM DATE: 21 November 1989 TO: Neil Dorrill, County Manager Richard Shanahan, County Commissioner FROM: Kevin O'Donnell Public Services Administrator RE: Memo dated November 15, 1989 T Mr. Mueller's comments to Commissioner Shanahan are an accurate reflection of what PARAB has been considering relative to the beach parking charges. Attached is an Executive Summary that I have prepared as a result of PARAB's recent recommendation (November 16th) . However; in a conversation that I had with John Yonkosky, Finance Director, and Dave Weigel, Assistant County Attorney, they brought up that the recently approved contract for the State Grant the County is receiving for Beach Renourishment precludes discrimination at beach facilities. As a result there is a major legal concern relative to our ability to implement the PARAB recommendation dealing with honoring the City of Naples Beach Parking Permit. I requested that the County Attorney's Office review the matter and advise me accordingly. In the interim stautus quo will be maintained and the City of Naples Beach Parking Permit will not be accepted at Vanderbilt, Clam Pass and Tigertail. Should you have any further questions, please advise. KO'D/cms cc: 9liff Crawford, Director of Parks and Recreation arks and Recreation Advisory Board ... L,� ,', _4,41(. 6 4fe- a1+.c. ALi. , /9"et af to A.T.- r 4:) MEMO RANDUM- I 3 DATE: 21 November 1989 TO : Bill Loren: , Environmental Services Administrator FROM: _Kevin O'Donnell, Public Services Administrator r RE: Tigertail Beach I recently received a formal complaint from the food concessionaire on Tigertail Beach Park regarding the encroachment of the vegetation. Specifically, the concessionaire wants the County to "put back" the beach as it was in 1987 since he maintains this is the County's contractural obligation. Although I am not concerned 0 about the merits of the case the concessionaire raises as to the County's contractual obligation it is systematic of the problems at the beach. My staff has advised that several years ago the former concessionaire and Parks and Recreation were prevented from raking the areas and removing the vegetation. It is also my understanding my staff has not done any planting of the vegetation at Tigertail. -m.. . , Did your staff do the planting or know who did? zm� How can the Marriott and residential beach on Marco continue to rake and keep the beach free of vegetation but Tigertail is different? I would like to discuss this matter with you shortly and prior to the 12/21/89 PARAB meeting which you have been asked to attend. Your prompt attention to the matter is most appreciated. KO'D/cros cc: /Cliff Crawford, Parks & Recreation Director Bob Legler, Beach and Water Supervisor { v Nr iMO RAND UM DATE: 21 November 1989 TO: Ken Cuyler, County Attorney FROM: Kevin O'Donnell, Public Services Administrator 0 RE: Concessionaire Complaint - Tigertail Attached is a copy of a complaint along with pictures from the County's food/beverage concessionaire at Tigertail Beach Park. The concessionaire refers to' several provisions of the contract he feels the County has not legally fulfilled. Although I feel the complaints are without merit based upon the natural evolutionary changes occuring at the Park, please advise my office of the County's legal obligation under the Concession Agreement. I (:) " Attached are the pictures the concessionaire refers to in his .. letter. Please return when done. Your prompt attention in this matter is most appreciated. - i ....... KO'D/cms cc: Neil Dorrill, County Manager rt --Cliff Crawford, Parks & Recreation Director } , , Robert Legler, Beach and Water Supervisor -- --4-÷7.17-,4-; . - 4 i . r.� aka '1".":7" 741".—i,..;,,,,,- , 4 a : al ' f The Hungry Tiger 5342 Caldwell St. IP , • Naples F1. -33962 i November 15, 1989 Mr. Kevin O'Donnell Public Services Administrator7e Collier County, Florida Dear Kevin: Due to increased complaints from the Public and the continued deterioration of Tiger Tail Beach, The Hungry Tiger request that Collier County take immediate action to restore the Beach area to the condition it was accepted at the on set of our Food and Beverage Service Agreement. Had the County provided maintance along the Shoreline as is done at most Beach Front facilities ie. Marco Residents Beach, Marriott Hotel, and as was once done at Tiger Tail Beach (periodic raking and draging) the present condition would not exist. I L. We would like to point out several points of our Contract that cover this subject: (1) SCOPE. I b. FACILITIES. The County shall provide to the Concessionaire the use of the following • facilities and space: 1. The area known as Tigertail Beach--- (5) MAINTENANCE. The County agrees to provide the assigned facilities in their "as is" condition and to perform necessary exterior maintenance on the facilities assigned to the Concessionaire (9) IMPROVEMENTS; UTILITIES. The Concessionaire accepts the facilities and space provided in this Agreement in their present condition, We expect the County to fulfill their legal obligations and take whatever < ,, measures are necessary to return the area to acceptable levels, as exhibited by the enclosed photos. ,,, Sin erel , Managing President -- cc: Cliff Crawford, Parks & Recreation Director .,_ Public Services Div. 1_1(.1re_41(7;r<2.,.a,4.-c.--al,41-..9/ 0 ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION MEMORANDUM TO: Kevin O'Donnell, Public, Services Administrator • ,;,,.1:' ,-4- ._ .FROM: __.: William D. Lorenz Jr. , P.E. , Administrator Environmental Services Division I � DATE: 11-Dec-1989 SUBJECT: Assessment and Recommendations for Tigertail Beach 'a The purpose of this memo is to provide you with information and recommendations for addressing the problems at Tigertail Park. Background and History_ In August 1982 , Collier County submitted an Erosion Control Fund application to the DNR Division of Beaches and Shores. This application requested State support for the Collier County Dune Restoration and Protection Program. The program was designed to 1 ‘, , undertake, at selected County beach parks, those projects necessary to ensure the protection and where necessary, the restoration of the coastal strand and dune communities. A . specific program was submitted which included the revegetation of coastal strand communities, the reconstruction and replanting of damaged dune lines, the thinning or complete removal of Australian pines, the construction of elevated dune crosswalks and surficial walkways, the erection of pedestrian traffic control fences in areas of heavy impact, and the placement of pedestrian control signs. A On February 19, 1985, the Governor and Cabinet, sitting as head of the Department of Natural Resources of the State of Florida, approved Contract Number C2722 for the erosion control project known as the Collier County Tigertail Revegetation Project in the amount of $114,789. On March 5, 1985, the Board of County i Commissioners passed a resolution approving an agreement for the ;.s1 erosion control project known at the Collier Tigertail Revegetation Project and authorizing the Chairman of the Board to ' execute DNR Contract Number C2722 on behalf of Collier County. Limited dune construction was planned at the major existing access to Tigertail Beach. Extensive revegetation and control of :.i Australian pine proliferation was envisioned for the remainder of the site. In anticipation of expanded parking and increasing -1- popularity of this site, six (6) crosswalks (530 feet total) and 1, 170 feet of dune protective feeder walkways were planned for the site. Australian pine removal on this site was considered essential to dune restoration and preservation for the future. Final site plan outlining the proposed work was approved by County Engineer, Thomas Kuck and the County contacted the private firm Environmental Services Unlimited to complete the dune restoration and Australian Pine removal program. County staff certified the project complete on December 4, 1985. $; Problem Assessment Marco Island is a "beach ridge" barrier island made up of many .� hundred of years of beach ridge migration. Sand Dollar Island is the latest evidence of this migration and is naturally moving towards Tigertail Beach. Coastal hammock species and red mangroves now thriving on the once barren Tigertail Beach front are also evidence of the natural succession of this area. If this beach system follows typical successional events it is not expected to return to the sandy beach it once was, and Sand Dollar Island will take its place as the Tigertail sandy beach. Many species of native vegetation have migrated seaward, probably due to the lack of wave and normal beach activity. This past summer fewer beach visitors to the area has allowed much ' vegetation to continue this seaward migration. On October 25, 19.89 , Environmental Services staff made a preliminary visit to Tigertail Beach to assess the current status of vegetation. Attachment A contains the results of the survey showing a mixture of coastal hammock, coastal dune, scrub, and mangrove/marsh vegetation growing together on Tigertail Beach. The vegetation is quite extensive and there have been many complaints that it affects the recreational aspect of Tigertail Beach. The increased vegetation from both natural and planted sources has decreased the area of clean beach. Most of the new vegetation, however, is from natural colonization and not from the dune restoration project. As the system changes we would also expect a natural change in the quality water landward of Sand Dollar Island. Environmental 4 Services is of monitoring the water to determine if or when the water quality changes. The first monthly report is provided as i Attachment B to this memo. The decrease in white sandy beach has concerned many people who ' !I expect the park facility to concentrate on this recreational character. The public's expectation of the recreational opportunities of this area can not be completely met because of the natural dynamic processes of this coastal system. Some s4 maintenance activities may be permitted by state agencies, 2 however, a return to a large sandy beach will not be expected, IDgiven the dynamics of natural system and state prohibition of removing beach and dune vegetation (Attachment C) . In summary, the natural coastal processes associated with the formation of Sand Dollar Island has allowed a variety of native vegetative species to colonize the beach. Most of this vegetation has developed naturally and is not associated with the County's prior restoration project. This natural loss of white sandy beach, however, is in conflict with the public's expectation of Tigertail's recreational opportunities. Other valid recreational opportunities, however, are provided because of the uniqueness of this system. Recommendations 0 The Recreation and Open Space Element of the Growth Management Plan identifies eleven (11) recreational principles (Attachment D) . Items 5 and 9 provide guidance relating public facilities with their location and environment. Because of the dynamic nature of costal processes, the County should recognize that its coastal parks are subject to change also. Given this understanding, the County should anticipate these potential changes and incorporate them in coastal park design and management. This will help ensure that facilities are "designed and constructed for appropriateness in the area where they are to 0 be located" and "should represent a positive example of designing energy use and concern for the people and the environment. " In short, we should strive to keep our park facilities in harmony with nature rather than force nature to comply with our present use of current park facilities. Rather than viewing the natural processes at Tigertail as being a deterioration of the facility, we should emphasize the associated positive environmental benefits of stabilizing the shoreline and providing more varied natural habitat for wildlife. Indeed, we should take this opportunity to show the public that Tigertail Beach is unique in that it maintains a natural, healthy and 1 undeveloped status. The formation of Sand Dollar Island (a new barrier island) enhances its uniqueness and provides increased aesthetic, recreation, and storm protection benefits for the citizens of Collier County and landward property owners. The conservation and Coastal Management Element of the Growth Management Plan provides many objectives and policies regarding barrier islands (Attachment E) . One of the trends and issues identified in the Recreation and !? Open Space Element is the lack of open space and a need for natural areas. As this area becomes increasingly naturalized, the County could provide additional recreational and educational opportunities that take advantage of the natural benefits of the 4 w.: area. At the same time, the County should also strive to offer areas where the public can enjoy more conventional recreational opportunities. Implementation Plan A goal for Tigertail Beach and other coastal recreational areas should be to provide a wide range of recreational opportunities • that are in harmony with the ever changing natural coastal system. Three objectives specific to Tigertail Beach present themselves. In the short-term, the County should take positive steps to ensure that the public can enjoy beach recreation at the park. In the long-term, the County should evaluate alternatives to take advantage of public enjoyment of the unique and interesting natural areas presently forming. A third objective is to provide the public with on-site information about the unique character of the site, its environmental benefits and general coastal processes. 1. Short-term maintenance of existing beach areas The County should develop and implement a plan to maintain current beach areas where stabilizing vegetation is absent. The possibility exists for the DNR to permit minimal raking of the beach. There are several regulations, however, protecting stabilizing vegetation. Specific steps include: ♦ Identifying areas to maintain as unvegetated sandy beach reserving as much desirable native vegetation as possible; ♦ Applying to DNR Beaches and Shores for a permit to allow raking; ♦ Applying to Collier County Development Services for a vehicle on the beach permit; ♦ Identifying ingress and egress points if vehicular equipment is to be used. 2 . Long-term development of other recreational opportunities Providing new and different recreational opportunities at Tigertail that take advantage of the changing natural coastal system would be a positive step in placing the park facility in harmony with its surrounding environment. Boardwalks and other paths through the naturalized areas would appeal to many people as a relaxing form of passive recreation. Access to part of the newly formed Sand Dollar Island would provide the beach-minded public an interesting location to "lay their blankets". • Sud ... .. , wr 4E) A conceptual plan for the area has been advanced (Attachment F) . Boardwalks are shown in the naturalizing area and to Sand Dollar Island itself. Prior to any commitment to a conceptual plan, however, the County should determine the State's regulatory requirements and conduct a feasibility analysis. Specific steps should include: ♦ Identifying State regulatory constraints; ♦ Receiving input from appropriate advisory boards; ' ; ♦ Developing a conceptual plan, including costs and evaluating engineering and financial feasibility; =tl a .' ♦ Identifying funding mechanism , j 41i ♦ Obtaining approval from the Board of County Commissioners 3 . Public Information Providing the public with appropriate educational and informational materials regarding the value and workings of our natural environment is a continuing process. Well-placed plaques and displays should show how coastal barriers protect our sensitive shorelines. Identification of stabilizing native vegetative and wildlife should demonstrate the importance of these natural resources. A display of aerial photographs showing how Marco Island has been evolving would demonstrate this ever changing and dynamic coastal processes. Specific activities to accomplish this objective would include: ♦ Identifying funding sources to implement a program; ki ♦ Establishing specific educational objectives that can be met with on-site passive displays; 1 ♦ Developing a public information plan for subsequent implementation. Summary and Conclusion 44 Native vegetation is colonizing the sandy beach area at Tigertail Beach in response to the natural, coastal processes. These l0 processes have formed and changed Marco Island, and will continue 4. to operate in the same way in the future. Although there are many environmental benefits to these processes, existing _ recreational opportunities are being changed. These changing conditions, however, present additional varied recreational opportunities. -5- . ikr , . r It is proposed that we develop flexible management plans to allow 4 V recreational opportunities that are in harmony with the ever-changing coastal environment. The concept is applicable for Tigertail Park and the County's other coastal parks. The County should therefore expect changes in the character of its coastal parks and be prepared to match recreational opportunities consistent with the natural changes. 1 Regarding Tigertail Park, the County should immediately identify ; areas where white sandy beaches can be maintained and implement '_ an appropriate maintenance plan, establish a flexible long-range plan to offer other recreational opportunities consistent with y the ever-changing environmental conditions, and begin developing an information program to educate the public about the changing conditions and their respective environmental benefits at Tigertail Park. This approach is consistent with recommendations of the County Growth Management Plan's Recreation and Open Space Element and Conservation and Coastal Management Element. WDL:pc Attachments 1 4;1-1...,'lis:,CI .' c: Neil Dorrill, County Manager aril kCrawford,° :PaTksancRecreaton Director Jim Burch, Chief Environmental Specialist Maura Kraus, Environmental Specialist II Environmental Services File r • • • ., 3 _6 . , , . _. ... . ,t - - ,} tri,. 17 ATTAommaNT A J . TIGERTAIL BEACH PRELIMINARY VEGETATION LIST Distichlis spicata - saltgrass Momordica charantia - balsam apple i . 4 Sonchus spp. - sow thistle Cyperus odoratus - flat sedge Chamaesyce blodgettii - spurge 1 Sesuvium portulacastrum - sea purslane Eupatorium capillifolium - dog fennel Rhizophoria mangle - red mangrove .♦ Uniola paniculata - sea oats • Scaevola plumieri - inkberry ♦ . Baccharis spp. - saitbush Solidago spp. - goldenrod Ipomoea pes-caprae - railroad vine Ipomoea stolonifera - beach morning glory • Chloris petrea - fingergrass i a Helianthus debilis - dune sunflower , I Iva imbricata - beach elder Cenchrus spp. - sandspurs I ' Cyperus spp. - sedges 1 Casuarina litorea - Australian pine j Coccoloba uvifera - sea grape • ' Spartina patens - salt meadow 1 cordgrass ♦ Protected species . . ow y. • ?u ATTAQNT B COLLIER COUNTY ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES DIVISION POLLUTION CONTROL DEPARTNXNT MONTHLY PROGRESS REPORT FOR NOVEMBER 1989 SAND DOLLAR ISLAND MONITORING PROGRAM SPECIAL PROJECT 90-01 PREPARED 9Y ^`^ STEPHEN A. GRABS, M.S. ffi viRONNXNTAL SPECIALIST II e UES WALKER, H.S. POLLUTION CONTROL TECHNICIAN 5 DECEMBER 1989 DRAFT • • 1-{ a )71', ,om{ °�'''!',+l# Kr "v'�'„ t"rs(e s�'q "}l xk'.F.v11 .r S• ,F '4 �-� '"^< a , 4 A Y r • `y k • y9�a x u� i 2 1'* �. ! '.r Y y ..."S. a a-s... }" '+ y!"^'.I !` �'.,,,.. • t.� 'Y 3� fi' ,'' pf ,fG�i i _ C INTRODUCTION Concern has been raised regarding the effects of proposed beach renourishment i activities at Tigertail Beach (;Marco Island) on hydrographic conditions in the '1 Hideaway BeachiTigertail 3each/Sand Dollar Island area. Of particular concern ';f are what effects. if any. the putative closure of Sand Dollar Island and 4 subsequent formation of a lagoon between Tigertail Beach and Sand Dollar _stand -r111 have to 'paler qua_- r _ondi=_ons--sneC_ :.all7 those related to _:ntac: :scree :on. w ".'�OnLZ_�7 sampling of surface water quality in :115 area was initiated by the t Collier County Pollution Control Department in October 1989 to monitor selected water quality parameters. Those parameters Included temperature. c_ssciTed axyce.. sal=ty. .onauctance pH and fecal Coliform and Decal l 3L_3.*JtOCOCC: ?a Cr@r:3. ".'he 3:'_rob-O-?OQ-C3� data will be Compared with Florida Je a_tment ._ ln':=tnment3_ ?eau_at:On bac:ar:ol:g::a_ standards for ::ass -- Recrea :tri. --raters :ia Idmz stzac:-e -oce 5. ' . _CmDar_3cns :.. :a"=_ ria__-_ _ond_::Ons e:-- be _made t er ::me and _e-_ :- -e_n r'+ - ±n• 'Sand Solla= and •'3ea:.7.n T:Ce::a__ 3eac^ _::es. 5utp_ement:ag :ae -eater r. a_:t_ hon:tor:ng w_-1 be a quarterly sed:nent ?. ,ana_7S:S program. he _:C s of th_s *_program element well be to monitor and H Compare the or»an:_ :once::. androgen Su-_:1e :oncentrat:On and Tart:--e size g of tae sed:_an:s :-ler bc:: t:ne and space IGil-_ ?S. 3each. . "5 : _ _ e=t tae .....,_an ;:-- be tne --ec -tn 7_ blol:g:Ca_ samples of :he beam..: :a:mora. nese samples '4111 also be _"• willbe arih:'.'ed Ind act analyzed. If needed. :hese samples can be analyzed at a future date to evaluate what changes. if any have occurred in the il benthos as a consequence of Changes in the orientation and size of Sand Dollar Island. `. This progress summarizes the results of the November 1939 sampling event. METHODS 11, Water quality samples were collected from two stations along the coast of Sand i Dollar Island and at two stations off Tigertail Beach. The actual station locations were selected randomly within designated areas and can vary from month to month . Comparisons will be made between Gulf (Sand Dollar Island) and Beach (Tigertail Beach) sites (Figure 1) . At each station samples were i collected from water of approximately 1-meter in depth. n:.t,P HS K.',':'''''\' 1 MMMIIIIM • 0 .!e'_ereeaS _me :c cf 7:1=d:2712.72. d_ssol 'ed ;x:1 en. JIT, salio: and canduc=3nc3 ••dere :. San. :::... 3ur:ace waters and near bottom waters. Three replicate water samples were collected, in sterile bottles, for analysis of fecal coliform and fecal sr.eptococci bacteria. These samples were packaged 11 and stored on ice sufficient to maintain a temperature of four (4) degrees 4 centigrade. The samples were then shipped via common carrier to Thornton Laboratories in Tampa where they were then analyzed by Standard Methods (American Public 3ealth Association 1985) . See Appendix A for an explanation 1 of these parameters. L. RESULTS (TUBLE 1) AND DISCUSSION 4 WATER TEMPERATURE measurements were similar between the two sites. DISSOLVED JX?azJ levels were only slightly higher (7.5 mg/1) at the Beach site than at the Gulf site . .3 ac/l). CONDUCTIVITY and LIL=V:=.' :e�e_s were slightly higher at the Beach site than at the Gulf site. pH -values were somewhat higher at the Beach site. ?EC= CCL:FOR:f BAC: =A counts ranged from <3-23 MPN/100-ml at the Gulf site and from <3 to 9 `CPN/100-m1 at the Beach site. The detection limit for this • test is 3 MP'V/100-n1. F2ER microbiological standards for Crass III waters require that no singe grab sample exceed 300 :CPN/100-ml. For further comparison. more stringent conditions exist for Class II waters (Shellfish j Propagation or 3ar7esting; (Fac 17-3.1110)) . Class II standards for fecal coliform bacteria include a median value not exceeding 14 MPN/100-ml. For the six samples collected at the Gulf and Beach sites the median values are 4 and <3 MPN/100-21 respectively. ''' FECAL STREPTOCOCCI levels ranged from <3 to 11 at the Beach site with all Gulf samples falling below detection limits. 4 :9 REFERENCES l''''' AMERICANPUBLIC EXILTB 1SSOCIITIOI. 1985. Standard Ne tbods For the Examination . of Water and Wastewater. IPU. Cincinnati. - "" a,ts •ct . v ° Allik I T BLS 1. SUMMARY OF PHYSICOCxIC31L IND MICROBIOLOGICAL PARA!! !RS. SAND DOLLAR ISLAND MONITORING PROGRAM: NOVIMBER 1989. • •` PIRINESER GULF I ICSAU (BINGE) SEAN (BINGE) TEMPERATURE (C) 25 (-) 25.5 (25-26) DISSOLVED OXYGEN (MG/L) 7.0 (-) 7.5 (7.2-7.8) 4 CONDUCTANCE (uMHOSI Y) 54535 52224 SALINITY (PPT) 35.2 (34-36.5) 32.8 (32.0-34.0) PH 8.7 (8.5-9.2) 9.4 (9_2-9.6) 4 FECAL COLIFORM (2fPN/:00-1L)' 3 (<3-23) <3 (<3-9) FECAL STREPTOCOCCI (1711/100— L)■ <3 (—) <3 (<3-11) a geometric mean of six replicates. d 446111V • 6 1 • , i s„ . I' (:l 5 1 • 5•• ` • V • : •• M18_ �f L {j"r. {-� ,7r.. a.-,- R• ... `-.M' 61.#;;;:•-•.#6. ' 1t 4y• t.' 1 • ti . • `''r'Px .*'" a,,-}`.��i,� s,..r.,"••••24:_•"1. ;5r~'y ,1rS e4:. 0-1.••• �F•-iti ..�r -. �,,1Zr.,•P r ••.� .#1.p.� •+ . 'J' r.� ••i`.d9,' 'i „,,,'F ei ►' ''..t y�dy,. °I ..i� a';"' M . .� „F. >q+ .. o� goi. tC.eta •r�• w� .4fi° .n.,ik ;e'tr." q.,.p�ti,.• ,II'•; W . �e�„...'":•...r1:1; :4 s; ' . , • fir' ^s ., %t+- In.--;'"', , 'y' T '4+ ' "� `�'' • "?t-.' -.l'14�, �•1�•�'lr. r- 'Syt fl/. .1 i, ”.a.1 `..-•-.! j ;.•4 �. mow: .. E t-i...1°JI° ;• :.. •?'�"t ..ac-u'wry��.�f?,, '�; r,[,../...•,.. WY r °; • J - ♦ ��.- .. '.. 's . - .6'' ..' �.. j,: 3.4.411 ., 1 "' ,, q fit f 1•• •}.+w•c '' i�tr� I. +�� • {() t:, ..:;'41....,..4 ,,F..;.47.;......:•"—. r.. .Y s..tr..a s + f 1/:4, r ^i} +1l ' d.. :.� ' r ,:::1,Y;� . r. it.°t }: .Y ���-� p � S��,+ ,;...f. 1 lrti,t •�� -ice�Y;1 t7" r b �t i` 1.,fit `MI5,...., ° J - .. ° •x -: ► ••' 4\r, ,:.C.;;;;,.•..,,4'1^ moi? ri�.. {'. ,�i !':1 '"„ •. +!.A .v�T.' t 37 '' F. ... v �y��.� `..' l sub. , s • 1, i .' yr";.•k x t `• tc i ��.� r"s tr' ! - 10-c. x•' S.� ir. '-'- ;,•,a. 'S�_r+S• S t., �. •• •�' ... . • .. • ^�l�t' t_�^�1� !M Virg'•_ 4• � 'r' � "P�ga!+'.+.1� ,!'!';c rf�a.•Vit' .., r � �..a. ...° 17.--------s APPLIDI: A. DEFINITION OF VAT!R QUALITY PARAMETERS INCLUDED IN THE SAND DOLLAR ISLAND MONITORING PROGRAM. =PE/ 'URE: is a measure of the hotness or coldness of the water in degrees Celsius (C) : 0 C is the temperature at which deionized water changes state from liquid to solid and 100 C is the temperature at which deionired water changes state from liquid to gas. DISJOL7ED OXYGEN: is .he neasure of the concentration of oxygen dissolved in . ' water. The Florida Administrative Code (17-3.121 (12) ) indicates that in Class III marine waters. the concentration "shall not average <5 mg/liter in a 24- A hour period and shall never be less than 4 mg/liter." Dissolved oxygen varies naturally with temperature. Colder water is able to hold more dissolved ox_Igen than is warmer water. SAL_::::'. _s 7te measure .t iota_ sc__ds :n -.lamer a2 er all :anccna:es ''iave been :pn"eT_ad 72 .x_ies. :__ Promiie and _:Q=:e na-e Peen replaced Py ctl^ _7e and all organic n=_ na_er has been ox-4- - d APHA 1985) . The FAC does notspecify any standards for marine waters. Th.... marine waters typically 11:Ar have salinity values near 35 ppt. y CONDUC'.".LNC.F: is a measure of :he ability of an aqueous solution to carry an electric current and depends upon the quantity and type of ions and dissolved solids in that water as well as its temperature. The Florida Administrative Code (FAC) does not specify any standards for marine waters. ad: is a measure of the concentration of hydrogen ions in a solution over a range of 0-14 pH units: values >7 are indicative of alkaline conditions and 1 i values <7 are indicative of acidic conditions. The FAC indicates that the 1 general criterion for surface waters (FAC 17-3.061(1) ) is that pH "shall not ' vary more than one unit above or below natural background provided that the pH is not lowered to less than 6 units or raised above 8.5." :1_ 11 FECAL COL.FORM BACTERIA: the Most Probable Number per 100-m1 (MPN/100-ml) of coliform bacteria from the faces of warm-blooded animals is widely used to evaluate pollution of seawater, bathing areas, wastewaters, etc. FAC 17- 3.121(5) indicates that, for Class III waters, the fecal coliform count, based 1:4 upon at least tan samples. "shall not exceed a monthly average of 200/100-m1 11 of sample. nor exceed 400/100-ml of sample in 10% of the samples, nor exceed 800/100-ml on any one day..." FECAL STREPTOCOCCI BACTERIA: are considered to be indicators of fecal "', `' 4 • pollution (APHA 1985) . The ratio of Fecal Coliform:Fecal Streptococci counts , i-4� � , may provide information of possible sources of fecal contamination. For :". '!. .f,, example, ratios )4.1 are considered to represent contamination by human wastes ..M <� , '� . • • and ratios (0.7 represent nonhuman contamination (APRA 1985) . For this ratio sem; :•' • ' to be properly applied. fecal streptococci counts must be )100 MPN/100-ml. .74 , x , ... , i • Fj; I. � v 44 i •• 72 I Z C jth LTJ C— z • C C73 • ... Z Z \\.• =4.< 4 .... ,_ v, = , ... -7+• = 7. 6 d x � = • O 0 Jd� C / 6 = 0/6 • fi�• ". < • _J Q c • QZ E » 1 ci n ..c gg r i#t' • O 0 C.1C Cil C I '' R Q Cil 4C = = CZ CA Ls.! (r) , `• .T..ti '•. ✓ t• • .i . ...= 4. ..i 1111.1 S''!1 ~. � s40 VI • , - ++. .,' .1... mss J . tiO ,y .� "7' 4 ./ ,�,y .. INV Xi • • S '• ` xiv! '. �t . .wr7—++,utgk !. �r•� e " • _`�„� Y•1�M..;w. ♦ ' '` a•yHr xdr � ' - "'t , 4', •- .1 r 1.l•.M r , .:27.1.1.......m•w. ... ATTACHMENT C aJ Sea oats which cover the majority of Tigertail Beach and Sand Dollar Island are protected by Florida Law. The following is an excerpt from the Florida Statues; Y "370.041 Harvesting of sea oats and sea grapes prohibited; possession prima facie evidence of violation. - (1) The purpose of .this section is to protect the beaches and shores of the state from erosion by preserving natural vegetative cover to bind the f sand. :t (2) It is unlawful for any purpose to cut, harvest, 4 remove, or eradicate any of the grass commonly known as sea oats or Uniola paniculata and - Coccolobis uvifera commonly known assea grapes from any public land or from any private land' without consent of the owner of such land or person having lawful possession thereof. Possession of either Uniola paniculata or Coccolobis uvifera by other than the owner of such land shall constitute prima facie evidence of violation of this section. However, licensed, certified nurserymen who grow any of the native plants listed in this section (01. -, • from seeds or by vegetative propagation are specifically permitted to sell these commercial grown plants and shall not be in violation of this section of the law if they do so, as it is the intent of the law to preserve and encourage the growth of these native plants which are rapidly disappearing from the state. History - s. l,ch.65-458 ; s.l,ch.67-150; s.280, ch. • 71-136; s. l,ch.71-153 ; s. l,ch.73-258; s. 16,ch.85-234 . " DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION (DER) 1 17-27.010 Policy and Intent. 1 • (1) The department finds that: (a) Three species of mangroves border more than half ' 'i • of Florida's peninsular shoreline; (b) This natural mangrove vegetation protects the shoreline against erosion resulting from relentless coastal dynamics; V. # • (c) Each species of mangrove provides habitat for a diverse community of plants and animals, including endangered species such as bald eagles, brown pelicans, and ospreys; (d) Mangroves play a fundamental role in estuarine nutrition by producing concentrations of organic matter which are utilized by marine organisms within the estuarine food web; • (e) Over 90 percent of Florida's commercial fish ;t species are dependent upon the nursery function of these dynamic estuaries; (f) These mangrove estuaries provide a dependable winter resting ground for a host of species of migratory birds; (2) It is the intent of this rule to protect mangroves and their vital role in the economy and ecology of the state by establishing a procedure for evaluating and minimizing the impacts of proposed mangrove alteration, while allowing waterfront homeowners to selectively trim mangroves in order to enjoy the benefits of riparian ownership. Specific Authority: 403 . 021, 403 .061, 403.933, F.S. Law Implemented: 403 . 021, 403 . 061, 403.933, F.S. History: New 5-21-85. 17-27.030 Prohibitions. Unless exempted pursuant to Rule 17-27.060, no person shall alter, allow, or cause to be altered any mangrove in jurisdictional waters .; without first obtaining a permit therefore from the • department in accordance with this rule or a general permit adopted by Rule 17-4.720, F.A.C. • • ;:• •. .. L • y e . a .Y • • , ' '`� - ., NITACHMENTD 0 II . RECREATION PLANNING PRINCIPALS There are several principles of parks and recreation planning that have been developed . These planning principles are integral to ensure the success of the planning process and to ensure that a quality standard is part of the process . They are : 1 . Public parks and other recreation facilities should be situated in an equitable manner so that all citizens . have the opportunity to enjoy them . i 2. All people should have the access to recreation activities • and facilities regardless of interest , sex , income , . cultural background or physical handicap . 3 . Property should be acquired to the actual need and ability of the County to develop in order to insure for adequate parks and recreation opportunities in the future . 4 . Lands acquired for public recreation services should be dedicated in perpetuity for public recreational use only . 0 . 5. Public park: and recreational facilities should be designed and constructed for appropriateness and attractiveness in the areas where they are to be located . 6 . Properties and facilities should be adaptable for future requirements . ., 7. Citizens should be involved in the planning process . 8� The local , re4fonal and state plans should be integrated . 9. Parks and recreation facilities should make the most 1 efficient use of the land and should be designed and managed to provide for the convenience , health , safety , welfare and A pleasure of intended users ; and should represent a positive example of design , energy use and concern for the people and the environment . -i 10. Parks and recreation facilities should not be limited to daylight use only . Illumination allows more effective utilization of the parks thereby increasing efficiency. The lighting system should be planned to encourage active participation rather than passive observation . 11 . The planning and design process should provide a rational basis for community action in order to improve leisure opportunities . RO-I I-3 4 . ATT cHMENT E ZIW GOAL 6 , iThe County shall identify, protect, conserve and appropriately use its native vegetative communities and wildlife habitat. 1 GOAL 11 ij i ; The County shall protect, conserve, manage, and appropriately use Ii its Coastal Barriers including shorelines, beaches and dunes and will plan for, and where appropriate, will restrict activities where such activities will damage or destroy coastal resources. OBJECTIVE 11.3 Until the Coastal Barrier and Beach System Management :- Plan is adopted (Objective 11. 6) , undeveloped coastal barriers shall be maintained predominantly in their natural state and their natural function $shal]�i be ,. protected, maintained and enhanced. 11.3.2 Any development activities on an undeveloped coastal barrier must be compatible with protection of the natural form and function of the coastal barrier system. lir 11.3.7 Participate in and encourage regional and state programs E to acquire naturally functioning, undeveloped coastal barrier systems to insure the preservation of their natural function. ` 11.3. 9 Native vegetation on undeveloped coastal barriers should be preserved. To the extent that native vegetation is . lost during land development activities and the remaining native vegetation can be supplemented without damaging or degrading its natural function, any native vegetation .1i lost during construction shall be replaced by I;; supplementing with compatible native vegetation on site. ,! All exotic vegetation shall be removed and replaced with sti i', native vegetation where appropriate. ,. I OBJECTIVE s E 11.4 Until the Coaf;tal Barrier and Beach System Management 1. Plan is adopted (Objective 11. 6) , protect developed 1. coastal barriers and developed shorelines by establishing mechanisms or projects which limit the effects of development and which help in the restoration of the natural functions of coastal barriers and affected beaches and dunes. aimmummor 4 POLICIES 11.4.1 Promote environmentally acceptable and economically feasible restoration of the developed coastal barriers and the urban beach and dune systems. 11.4.3 Prohibit activities which would result in man induced shoreline erosion beyond the natural beach erosion cycle or that would deteriorate the beach and dune system. 11.4.5 Initiate and support beach and dune restoration and preservation programs where appropriate. 11.4.8 Construction seaward of the Coastal Construction Control Line will be allowed for public access and protection and restoration of beach resources. Construction seaward of the Coastal Construction Control Line ihallthotttlieWs interfere with sea turtle nesting, will utilize native vegetation for dune stabilization, will maintain the natural beach profile, will minimize interference with natural beach dynamics, and where appropriate will restore the historical dunes and will vegetate with native vegetation. • 11.5 For undeveloped shorelines, provide improved opportunities for recreational. , educational, scientific, and esthetic enjoyment of coastal resources by protecting Beaches and dunes and by utilizing or where necessary ,2s establishing construction standards which will minimize the impact of manmade structures on the beach and dune systems. POLICY 11.5.i Recreation that is compatible with the natural functions of beaches and dunes is the highest and best land use. 11.5.3 Prohibit activities which would result in man induced • shoreline erosion beyond the natural beach erosion cycle or that would deteriorate the beach dune system. I 11.5.7 Regulate activities so that they will not threaten the. stability of the dunes or the beach itself. 4 11.5.11 Construction activities shall not interfere with the sea turtle nesting, shall preserve or replace any native vegetation on the site, and shall maintain the natural .� . g beach profile and minimize interference with the natural beach dynamics and function. • . ATTACHMENT F . i i i 7"-. O . /7 P S• \- , ••::,,,,:,:,:,,,,,,:,:,::.:,:•:.:.,,:„„„„„„:::::::::::::.:.:.::::::::::::.:.:,::::::::.::::::::::,::::::::::::::.:.:.::::::::::.:.::::::::::::.: .•••:•••••:••:::::„....••••:•••••••••.:,•••••:•:•:••••„:„:„............„.:.:.:.:....:.:.:.:.:.„.:....................................................................:................................::•:•:.::::::::.......:::::::.:.:.:.:.::::::::.:,.::::::::....:.:.:::::::.....::::::...:::::::::..........::::::.::::::::::...::::::::::...::::::::...::::::::::„..:. ) \ , :...:.:::•::„:.,..,:::::::::,•:::„,„,,,,,,•:,,,,,:.::.::.:.,:,„:::.::,„.•••„•:„„•:,.„:„.:,„,„„•:„„•:„„,„„„,„•:„„.„.„.„.„:„:•::•::::„„,„.„,„•:„,„„:•:::.:,:•:,„„.„.:•:„.:„,„„,::.:•::„„,,,:,:,:,:„,„•:„:..::::-.-:•:::::::„.::9::::ti.:::::::::,::::,:::.:::::1:1:::::::::::::::::::::•..,,,,--.,:::.,::::::::::-.:,,,,,:-..:•:::::::::::::.:,.::•••:::.:•:.:•:•:.:.:::•:::::•:.:•:::.:•::::::::::::::...::„.:•::•:.:•:::::::..:::::.:..„.•:.:•••:.:•:.:•::::::::::.:•:.,.:•.:•:.:„.•:::.:::.::::.:::::„.„.•:.::...:.:•:....:.........„.„....:.....:.....,::..„...:,:„...„..„.....,,: I .,....---. --:::ii.iaai.I:•pii.mmo,::,::.:::.:::,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,:•:,,,,,,„„„„„,•:,•„•:„„„„„:.:::.„.::„•:„„„:.„„„„::.....--- . , .:: :::::::: :::::::::::::::::: ::::•:::::: :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::,::::„,.••••••••-•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••..........................„........„........:.:.,„,. _:•:„:„:„.•:::::::::•::•::•:••:,•:::•„„„„,:„.„„:„.•:,„.„„„„„„„„„„„,„„•:•:„,„„,,,,,,,,,,•:::,„:„:.„,,„„„„„,:::.::„„„„:„„,„::„„„„:„.:;,„,„„:„,.:.„„„„„„: \r N :::.:.:::ii*.:::.::::::::....::•,..„ , .P t14 : S O S Q G ••• • • i E..��. i G / FLUSHING CHANNEL EL \ ' M : • : eciaaS BMERGE_ �SHOAL AREA N SAND DOLLAR ISLAND N *: .i;•?i!illi::•.. c.- Nc.. •*::;::i.iA:.::i•::::::. :.:.•:*:iiii:•::::i:if:::.::::::i•:?:i:. AP PX. MHW \ -......;i:i.,.:.e.....tigiii.iiffiRM:..• • . APPX. —4' > .0 --- • NGVD \ ••••:':::.::::&,, \ 'a • /0i:7 FLUSHING CHANNEL \ • J \ .. BOARDWALK TO "'' SAND DOLLAR ISLAND \ \: : : I . . Ry . j . • ,. . , •,, • ... <, - 1>Ai1; 11_10-89 F� • ' 1GO 1 -1000' 5. CONCEPT 2 PLAN FOR MAINTAINING ,W?!!'. ''. FLUSHING BEHIND SAND DOLLAR ISLAND fET 002 RELICT b89.311 COASTAL. :� ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, INC. FILE b � . ••1.• . i L.. Q 's-✓ I I ys 7i —.r- 1/7 1 I I\ e� 44. 1-: w to 9 77v.44 div r! /yam x3 NN\NN TN NN NW) d • 0 Decemner Its, 19d9 A. x total of 3509 8q. rt. would be acheived by this expansion and would represent an 80x increase in capacity. Ls. Three existing windows on the present wall could be moved to the new .ast wall. Also the existing single door could be used to conform with fir regulations. 0. tresent toilet facilities; air conditioning; and parking spaces would be adequate and in compliance with building codes. L. A sliding collapsible partition may be added at any given location to allow multiple use of the meeting rooms. ra. An additional 1567 sq. ft. at approximately 560.00 per sq. ft. or $94.000. would be well within the budget limitations. Respectfully, G. C. klueller 4UL COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DIVISION OF PUBLIC SERVICES 3300 SANTA BARBARA BOULEVARD PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FL 33999 (813) 353-0404 A CERTIFIED BLUE CHIP COMMUNITY ii A December 28, 1989 Ms. Maura Kraus Pollution Control Technician Collier County Capital Projects 3321 Tamiami Trail Naples, Florida 33962 Dear Ms. Kraus: We wish to thank you for taking time out from your busy schedule, especially during the holiday season, to share your expertise. Your joining with us at the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meeting of December 21, 1989 was most thoughtful and generous. Thank you! Hope your holiday's were happy ones. Very truly yours, e.-4,1";/1 ,lez.l'it44."-js.'/I , Clifford T. Crawford Parks and Recreation Director 1981/cfd —...--2:, 2t WfBW .. 9+' war,'.. k<{ '4 ,:'—'1';' , 8f L ve. 7111111111 COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT Allow DIVISION OF PUBLIC SERVICES 3300 SANTA BARBARA BOULEVARD PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FL 33999 (813) 353-0404 A CERTIF D BLUE Ciiii'COLNfl.j CITY December 28, 1989 Mr. William Lorenz Administrator Collier County Environmental Services 3321 Tamiami Trail Naples, Florida 33962 Dear Mr. Lorenz : We wish to thank you for taking time out from your busy schedule, especially during the holiday season, to share your expertise. Your joining with us at the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meeting of December 21, 1989 was most informative for us all and I'm sure answered many questions and fears of those concerned residents of Marco Island that were present. Thank you! Hope your holiday's were happy ones. Very truly yours, Clifford T. Crawford Parks and Recreation Director 1981/cfd �\ T COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DIVISION OF PUBLIC SERVICES 3300 SANTA BARBARA BOULEVARD PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FL 33999 (813) 353-0404 A CERTIFIED BLUE CHIP CO,12'b1UNITY December 28, 1989 Mr. Harry Huber Technical Services Supervisor Collier County Capital Projects 3321 Tamiami Trail Naples, Florida 33962 Dear Mr. Huber: We wish to thank you for taking time out from your busy schedule, especially during the holiday season, to share your expertise. Your joining with us at the Parks and Recreation `_ Advisory Board meeting of December 21, 1989 was most informative for us all and I'm sure answered many questions and fears of those concerned residents of Marco Island that were present. Thank you! Hope your holiday's were happy ones. Very truly yours, Clifford T. Crawford Parks and Recreation Director 1981/cfd , e) 0-- ' COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DIVISION OF PUBLIC SERVICES 3300 SANTA BARBARA BOULEVARD PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FL 33999 (813) 353-0404 A CERT'ED BLUE CIDP COIIlVIL'N'IT1 i December 28, 1989 Mr. James Burch Chief Environmental Specialist Collier County Natural Resources 3321 Tamiami Trail Naples, Florida 33962 Dear Mr. Burch: We wish to thank you for taking time out from your busy schedule, especially during the holiday season, to share your expertise. Your joining with us at the Parks and Recreation ID' Advisory Board meeting of December 21, 1989 was most in-formative for us all and I'm sure answered many questions and fears of those concerned residents of Marco Island that were present. Thank you! Hope your holiday's were happy ones. Very truly yours, /i_ it-`fee:-,_�t, Clifford T. Crawford Parks and Recreation Director 1981/cfd I i iiiw,__, COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DIVISION OF PUBLIC SERVICES 3300 SANTA BARBARA BOULEVARD PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FL 33999 (813) 353-0404 A CERTIFIED BLUE CHIP COMMUNITY ii December 28, 1989 Dr. E. F. Stallings Environmental Protection Specialist The Conservancy 1450 Merrihue Drive Naples, Florida 33942 Dear Dr. Stallings: We wish to thank you for taking time out from your busy schedule, especially during the holiday season, to share your expertise. Your joining with us at the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meeting of December 21, 1989 was most °ar►' informative for us all and I'm sure answered many questions and fears of those concerned residents of Marco Island that were present. Thank you! Hope your holiday's were happy ones. Very truly yours, t+°CCc t Clifford T. Crawford Parks and Recreation Director 1981/cfd i 5