Agenda 08/26/2015 PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION
Municipal Service Taxing and Benefit Unit
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING AUGUST 26, 2015
THE CLAM BAY COMMITTEE OF THE PELICAN BAY SERVICES
DIVISION WILL MEET AT 12:45 PM ON WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 26 AT
THE COMMUNITY CENTER AT PELICAN BAY, LOCATED AT 8960
HAMMOCK OAK DRIVE, NAPLES, FLORIDA 34108.
AGENDA
The agenda includes, but is not limited:
1. Roll call
2. Agenda approval
3. Approval of 4/23/15 & 5/27/15 meeting minutes
4. Audience comments
5. Updates on the following:
a. USACE permit application
b. Hand-dug channel permit
c. Tidal gauges and software
d. Water quality data into STORET
e. Oyster recruitment stations
6. Copper in Clam Bay
7. TDC funding for bathymetric reports
8. FDEP permit modification
9. Annual aerial photo of Clam Bay
10.Clam Pass Park expanded parking
11.Seeking quotes/bids for Clam Bay monitoring and Clam Bay tree trimming and
exotic removal
12.Other
13.Adjournment
ANY PERSON WISHING TO SPEAK ON AN AGENDA ITEM WILL RECEIVE UP TO
THREE (3) MINUTES PER ITEM TO ADDRESS THE BOARD. THE BOARD WILL SOLICIT
PUBLIC COMMENTS ON SUBJECTS NOT ON THIS AGENDA AND ANY PERSON
WISHING TO SPEAK WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES. THE BOARD
ENCOURAGES YOU TO SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS IN WRITING IN ADVANCE OF THE
MEETING. ANY PERSON WHO DECIDES TO APPEAL A DECISION OF THIS BOARD
WILL NEED A RECORD OF THE PROCEEDING PERTAINING THERETO, AND
THEREFORE MAY NEED TO ENSURE THAT A VERBATIM RECORD IS MADE, WHICH
INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE APPEAL IS TO BE
BASED. IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY WHO NEEDS AN
ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING YOU ARE
ENTITLED TO THE PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PLEASE CONTACT THE
PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION AT (239) 597-1749. VISIT US AT
HTTP://PELICANBAYSERVICESDIVISION.NET.
8/24/2015 11:35 AM
CLAM BAY COMMITTEE
PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION
APRIL 23,2015
The Clam Bay Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division met on Thursday, April 23 at
3:00 p.m. at the Pelican Bay Services Division, located in the SunTrust Building, Suite 302, at
801 Laurel Oak Drive,Naples, Florida 34108. The following were in attendance:
Clam Bay Committee
Susan O'Brien, Chairman Tom Cravens
Joe Chicurel Ken Dawson
Pelican Bay Services Division Staff
Neil Dorrill, Administrator Mary McCaughtry, Operations Analyst
Marion Bolick, Operations Manager Lisa Jacob, Recording Secretary
Also Present
Mohamed Dabees, P.E., Ph.D., Humiston& Moore Engineers
Tim Hall, Turrell-Hall & Associates
Arielle Poulos, Turrell-Hall & Associates
Ted Raia, Resident
Linda Roth, Resident
Dave Trecker, Pelican Bay Services Division Board
APPROVED AGENDA (AS PRESENTED)
1. Roll call
2. Agenda approval
3. Approval of 9/24/14 meeting minutes
4. Audience comments
5. Updates on the following:
a. Adding oysters in Clam Bay
b. Kayak safety in Outer Clam Bay
c. Quotes for tidal gauges
d. WQ data into STORET
6. Clam Bay Monitoring
a. Work order for Turrell-Hall
b. Vendors selected via RFP
c. Change order for Turrell-Hall
d. Water quality analysis report
e. Water quality parameters for Clam Bay and berm sites
f. Quotes/bids for bathymetric surveys
7. USACE permit application
a. Management Plan submitted
1
Clam Bay Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division
April 23, 2015 Meeting Minutes
b. Public comments to date
8. FDEP permit application modification
a. Maximum dredge cut in Section A
b. 5 percent silt content
9. Other
10. Adjournment
ROLL CALL
All members were present and a quorum was established.
AGENDA APPROVAL
Mr. Cravens motioned, Dr. Chicurel seconded to approve the agenda as submitted.
The motion carried unanimously.
APPROVAL OF 9/24/14 MEETING MINUTES
Mr. Cravens motioned,Mr. Dawson seconded to approve the 9/24/14 minutes with
the following corrections: on Page 1, Mr. Dawson should be listed under"Also
Present" along with Dave Cook and Jim Hoppensteadt; on Page 2, in the March 18
meeting minutes,the second line should read, "motion makers and both results; in
the April 8 minutes, the starred last line should be "temetry"; on Page 3, at the top
of the page,the heading should read "May 14 Workshop Minutes" and Ted Raia,
Brad Cornell and Maura Krause should also be listed as Clam Bay Stakeholders;
in the 10th line from the top it was Dr. Dabees who suggested that Mr. Hall should
craft the language; on Page 4, near the bottom, the sentence beginning, "A letter of
modification" should then read. "to the permit for the flushing cuts for the new
sampling stations." Under Clam Bay Copper, the second line should read, "upper,
inner and outer Clam Bay"; on Page 5, at the top, after the words "measurements
taken", the words "several years ago" should be added and the word "upper"
should be changed to "inner" in that line; under Suggested edits for RFP, the
second line should read, "to include faunal and vegetative communities." The
motion then carried unanimously.
AUDIENCE COMMENTS
Ms. Linda Roth was concerned about the percentage of silt content in the permit
application.
UPDATES
ADDING OYSTERS IN CLAM BAY
Mr. Hall is consulting with an expert to determine the steps to move this project forward.
2
Clam Bay Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division
April 23, 2015 Meeting Minutes
KAYAK SAFETY IN OUTER CLAM BAY
Mr. Dorrill is awaiting a response from the County's Parks and Recreation Department.
QUOTES FOR TIDAL GAUGES
The County's Purchasing Department decided to put this item through the formal bidding
process as the vendor raised its price.
WATER QUALITY DATA INTO STORET
Data from the first quarter of 2015 is expected to be entered into STORET soon.
CLAM BAY MONITORING
WORK ORDER FOR TURRELL-HALL
Mr. Hall's contract has been extended, and a work order was authorized.
VENDORS SELECTED VIA RFP
The County selected five vendors to contract for environmental services including Clam
Bay monitoring.
CHANGE ORDER FOR TURRELL-HALL
This change order was authorized previously for the additional work Mr. Hall
is to do, which will include shore bird monitoring before and after a dredging event.
WQ ANALYSIS REPORTS/PARAMETERS FOR CLAM BAY & BERM SITES
Mr. Cravens motioned, Mr. Dawson seconded to recommend to the full Board that
testing on the berm sites would be for the parameters and times required by the
South Florida Water Management District permit. The motion carried
unanimously.
QUOTES/BIDS FOR BATHYMETRIC SURVEYS
A bathymetric survey of Clam Pass and the interconnecting waterway was done recently
at a cost of$8,500. Dr. Dabees explained the problems occurring within the Pass, and stressed
the need for the permits that will allow them to take action when it is necessary. The results of
the survey would be available by the next meeting.
USACE PERMIT APPLICATION
MANAGEMENT PLAN SUBMITTAL
Mr. Hall is scheduling a site visit with the appropriate agencies.
3
Clam Bay Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division
April 23, 2015 Meeting Minutes
PUBLIC COMMENTS TO DATE
The Army Corps of Engineers received some public comments and if the Corps
determines these comments are valid then they would submit a request for additional information
for which Mr. Hall would prepare a response.
Mr. Hall would advise the Army Corps of Engineers that the Management Plan recently
submitted per the BCC's direction is intended to be an integral part of the permit application.
FDEP PERMIT MODIFICATION APPLICATION
MAXIMUM DREDGE CUT IN SECTION A
Humiston and Moore Engineers submitted information to the FDEP that clarified the
maximum dredge cut of Section A.
5 PERCENT SILT CONTENT
The Committee discussed creating an internal document indicating the intent that when
sand is placed on the beach north and south of the Pass, it would contain no more than 5 percent
silt content; however,the permit modification application would not be changed.
ADJOURNMENT
Mr. Cravens motioned, Dr. Chicurel seconded to adjourn. The motion carried
unanimously and the meeting was adjourned at 4:30 p.m.
4
CLAM BAY COMMITTEE
PELICAN BAY SERVICES DIVISION
MAY 27,2015
The Clam Bay Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division met at 1:00 p.m. on Wednesday,
May 27, 2015, at the Pelican Bay Community Center, 8960 Hammock Oak Drive,Naples,
Florida. In attendance were:
Clam Bay Committee
Susan O'Brien, Chairman Bohdan Hirniak
Henry Bachman
Pelican Bay Services Division Staff
Neil Dorrill, Administrator Mary McCaughtry, Operations Analyst
Marion Bolick, Operations Manager Lisa Jacob, Recording Secretary
Also Present
Mohamed Dabees, P.E., Ph.D., Humiston and Moore Engineers
Tim Hall, Turrell-Hall & Associates
Kevin Carter,Dorrill Management Group
Joe Chicurel, Pelican Bay Services Division Board
Arielle Poulos, Turrell-Hall & Associates
Linda Roth, Pelican Bay resident
Dave Trecker, Pelican Bay Services Division Board
APPROVED AGENDA (AS AMENDED)
1. Pledge of Allegiance
2. Roll call
3. Agenda approval
4. Approval of 3/23/15, 2/24/15, 5/22/14 and 5/30//14 meeting minutes
5. Audience comments
6. Updates on the following:
a. USACE permit application
b. FDEP permit modification
c. Adding oysters to Clam Bay
d. Water quality data into STORET
e. STORET's successor: WIN
f. Tidal gauges
g. Exotic removal
7. Water quality
a. Parameters measured by County lab
b. Copper in Clam Bay
1
Clam Bay Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division
May 27,2015 Meeting Minutes
8. Monthly updates on tidal and copper data
9. Bathymetric surveys
10. Other
11. Adjournment
ROLL CALL
All members were present and a quorum was established.
AGENDA APPROVAL
Mr. Bachman motioned, Mr. Hirniak seconded to approve the agenda with the
addition of item 5G,Exotic removal. The motion carried unanimously.
AUDIENCE COMMENTS
There were no comments received from the audience.
APPROVAL OF 3/23/15,2/24/15, 5/22/14 & 5/30/14 MINUTES
Mr. Bachman motioned. Mr. Hirniak seconded to approve the above listed minutes
as amended [in the agenda packet materials]. The motion carried unanimously.
USACE PERMIT APPLICATION UPDATE
Mr. Hall reported that the Army Corps of Engineers received public comments regarding
the permit application and a site visit would be scheduled with the Army Corps of Engineers,
Fish& Wildlife and National Marine Fisheries. If any of the public's comments or concerns
were validated during the site visit, the agencies would request additional information and Mr.
Hall would prepare the appropriate response.
FDEP PERMIT MODIFICATION
The FDEP permit modification application was submitted and is expected to be
authorized following the 90-day review period.
ADDING OYSTERS TO CLAM BAY
Mr. Bachman motioned,Mr. Hirniak seconded to recommend to the full Board
approval for the 15 oyster recruitment sites in Clam Bay at a total cost not to
exceed $1,500. The motion carried unanimously.
WATER QUALITY DATA INTO STORET/WIN
Mr. Hall explained the ongoing problems associated with STORET software and that
STORET would be replaced in 2017 by WIN software, which is web-based. Mr. Hall would
enter data from 2012 through the first quarter of 2015 into STORET and any data after the first
quarter of 2015 would be held and entered into WIN as soon as the software is available.
2
Clam Bay Committee of the Pelican Bay Services Division
May 27,2015 Meeting Minutes
TIDAL GAUGES
The tidal gauges were ordered and delivery is imminent. Installation of the gauges would
follow.
EXOTIC REMOVAL (ADD-ON)
The grant that Coastal Zone Management received to remove exotics was provided to the
Committee.
WATER QUALITY PARAMETERS MEASURED BY COUNTY LAB
Mr. Bachman moved, Mr. Hirniak seconded that a recommendation be made to
the full Board that the PBSD go back to the parameters and 12-month testing of
the berm sites to be consistent with the management plan. The motion carried
unanimously.
COPPER IN CLAM BAY
The Committee reviewed the April copper data done by Benchmark Labs.
MONTHLY UPDATES ON TIDAL AND COPPER DATA
The Chairman requested tidal and copper data be provided to the Committee on a
monthly basis and Mr. Dorrill would evaluate the possibility of providing this.
BATHYMETRIC SURVEY
Dr. Mohamed Dabees reviewed the results of the recent bathymetric survey.
OTHER
Dr. Trecker was interested in whether adequate samples were collected to account for
outlier parameters related to conductivity.
ADJOURNMENT
Mr. Bachman moved, Mr. Hirniak seconded to adjourn. The motion carried
unanimously and the meeting was adjourned at 2:20 p.m.
3
TURRELL, HALL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
MARINE&ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING
3584 Exchange Avenue, Suite B •Naples, Florida 34104-3732 • (239) 643-0166 • Fax (239) 643-6632
MEMORANDUM
TO: PBSD c/o Neil Dorril
FROM: Tim Hall
DATE: July 28, 2015
RE: Site visit with USACE and NMFS
Neil,
Arielle and I met with Mark Sramek and Brianne Mcguffie on the 23rd of July to conduct a site visit of the Pass and
waterway. Brianne is the project reviewer for the US Army Corps of Engineers and Mark is with the habitat
management division of the National Marine Fisheries Service. Jeff Howell for the Fish and Wildlife Service
cancelled and was not at the site visit.
We had an updated seagrass survey that we shared with the reviewers and they spent the most time in Section C and
at the throat of the Pass verifying that there were no submerged resources within the proposed dredge footprint and
generally reviewing the on-the-ground conditions. Both were satisfied with the descriptions that we had provided
and agreed with our assessments that there was little potential for any impacts to submerged resources. The
proposed buffers from the mangroves and seagrasses seemed to satisfy them. Both indicated at the end of the site
visit that they did not have any further questions and didn't see why the project could not go forward as proposed.
We will still need to coordinate further with FWS to make sure they have no questions but overall this site visit went
very well.
w e TURRELL, HALL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
MARINE & ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING
3584 Exchange Avenue, Suite B •Naples, Florida 34104-3732 • (239) 643-0166 • Fax (239) 643-6632
MEMORANDUM
TO: PBSD Clam Bay Committee do Neil Dorrill
FROM: Tim Hall
DATE: August 21, 2015
RE: August 26 Meeting updates
Neil,
Since I will have limited time at the upcoming meeting I thought it might be easier to provide a written
summary of the status of various projects so that my time on Wednesday could be used answering any questions
you or the Committee might have.
STORET
Data from 2012 through 2014 has been submitted to FDEP. As of today (August 21) we are waiting on their
acknowledgement that there are no more issues and files can be uploaded into the database. Data from January
through April 2015 will follow once we have the OK that current submittal has been uploaded. Data from May
on (when we switched from 5 to 9 monitoring stations in the Bays) will be held until new system (WIN) is in
place which will supposedly replace STORET.
OYSTER RECRUITMENT
Oyster condos have been deployed for almost two months. We will be retrieving them in a couple of weeks in
association with the mangrove monitoring. Preliminary field review showed that we have had some recruitment
on stations south of the Pass though stations north of the Pass have not been checked yet.
BIOLOGICAL MONITORING
Seagrass surveys along the permit transects has been completed. Seagrass coverage this year was higher than
last year. New seagrass bed was also observed on shoal immediately south of the County Boardwalk. This
updated information was used during the agency site visit on July 23. Mangrove monitoring will be starting
Monday August 24. Shorebird monitoring to stay current for the anticipated permit and biological opinion
requirements is ongoing.
TIDAL GUAGES
Interim gauges are still deployed. Brackets for new gauges should be installed in Upper and Inner Clam Bay by
the Wednesday meeting. Issues with my foot have slowed me down a bit getting them deployed. I am still
shooting to have them all out by the end of the month.
COPPER SAMPLING
Data from June and July was submitted in tabular format on an aerial for review. June readings were very good
while July showed some increases in levels across the board, most likely due to heavy rain events pushing
remnant copper through the system from the development areas.
PERMITTING
The permit modification from FDEP was issued on August 11. The USACE and NMFS conducted a site visit
on July 23. At the end of the site visit both representatives indicated that they were satisfied the material and
exhibits we submitted were a good representation of the system and had no issues with the project proposal.
The USACE is still waiting on official position letters or requests for information from FWS and NMFS before
they can continue to process the permit review and issuance.
• -7, -- c.rirr:"'
. ■,, .', '
,.., .." .
Clam Bay Sampling Locations 2009
i-1%. " -,":, ",::*.t.:•.:,-, Clam Bay
. , ana,sa., ,7,:i'3.-::,4-4 •! .7",‘;,N. ' Sampling. Water Quality
piing L
Station La L __ 1.7`'"5
,,.'" go - --.-A,,,,,
.._
- -,.
,-,,-
- ,,....11. ,
../r-,
Clam Bay 181 49:nn- 8 26 14.618
-,°'.4'.4 =/-, Legend
.....
-------- "-- 986 26 14.277 Clam Bay 1 --,°'-.-i4,.;
Clam Bay 2 81 48-
'Clan,Iiii9-'..93.119- 65 26 13.969 , _ -,,:,-,i :13100;rf 0 Clam Bay, Water..,ffitu,:l:towyStations,
Clam Bay 41,8149.03126 13.636 ", ' '' ..,- r0,,,,,,,0-, -,,,,-.--- #.7
: ,.,., , - , ,,,,,,,. ..;:vit.;,..\__, 4 ' • .--'
Cl am Bay 5 8148.824 26 13.010 ,4 ' -4.:„,':, -.1A'!".:1.-9.-_,,,.,,* ,/ =t::'41e. *• fi 44,-,7.,r.:-.., 4'._"' I - ,
..4: ; ,. '. - ...t. T-VI: ,,.,
Clam Bay 6 .81.48t868 26 12.800 ,,,.., s,,.;,„„ ,,,,,..„...:,,,),,.ts,,-_,,..4.. _-_, .1.7,.. ......,_,.. : lif;:l ,...,.... ,,..,.. . i ,„ ..,,t,
Clam Bay 7 81 48.95..,26 12,682 tii: -4.3----! .- ''S'11":A: 41F;,■••'''' • t\;1'*.'f ' 4, lire ,
_.Nf.7.--- .-t.-.47.. - ,I.,..-ia,..i..,,,, -- , 'A 1 .. -$' -1..;
Clam Bay 8'131 48.766 26 12.659 7''17i. '" '''- -,; ",.4., .. :,,...::!;=1,,,,;;,.14 \ ;e7;:3-.,,,7:,,,:,•.1:::;,:etrot
Clam Bay 1:i81 48.586 26 12.654 Clam Bay 2 - - ‘%..t y1 .,,.:"... 1„..
.:' .1,-‘;!'t!.._,1.■•-i; ...>"'• t '` :4'.4..kt'''' - '- •'::*. '':, '*...-., , '.' i ...; ''.
'.
4-..--," -4 - i A■`'- -jig-f 1 *w( ..N
''.:1 ''' ' 1'.'` % Aft,:""*.f.:");;:"t • ll'Aeljt:i 4'r°471114-4}:ff',1 :f-tiET.;:
-- ' ,f,:, 4,-"-- ,-""` e;,.,-1 •;,,t, s-_,,,.., .Rvi 1 ...,:=7,.f'i
6.'
-t.
Nc.N. .1
r.-
f."
\, A :4-4'e_ '', f " '":-.1,-,- ..:1•.,..‘-,...aM*-.
,\ ..... ,,,. -4.„.. .,• ... tl.,..
T 5;------;-1,-;',4' -. . . .'--..71C1`.; ';
,„....a-ft.,.%_,;;* ,,..A...7....•;., ;. „:,•,:r-,3 1 I isi•04....',
-'';= -----' ' -4,,-,1 r ."'f)k.-- ..,„,,,,g', ....,•<,.1= .rA14", i kt,t14.'*)"
...:. ,...,-•'..-..,....::.::
PDEP test results • , ',.. ... '4„7',*k-'4"
2011 2012
i-;... :: :4-,-,1',:!:'''''ilii; . 4,11-'4.4%k ;--4::-":1474''',44; tt'''''.$. "-;',-4,,...3. ':..3:1.1
I #1 12.0 8.8
1 #3 5.7 1.1 - - ---.- .- --,..: 4„,„1f.,,„„,'_, .._ . , . .....,:-.-LA
-, -. , --., - ' r :-.,.. -,.:_,--------.--'
#6 1.6 1.0 --''----'" A
Clam Bay 4 ..: .,--..,'::-, .:-., -:-,. .,;, ,,,,,,....k,ct '-'. ,4e.gt,....:1,„:„Nc., .11,....f. , ••,,,,‘:,,
tt
.f.2.,*.-';', ,tte.'
- v y,-i, ,..,,A, ‘, .... ,
",. ('''' 443 ItAl■'-:+qt1-"'4,44,' ' 4 ''' A: , it,„,, .":41
1 , . .**
' i ,,,,24:Frte tl' ..'' - 1' ' d'''' l'6iti '• *,'1 '
1
. ' ' '',-. '''''', ' .f11■- '.. 'v* * -r:".01* - . ''',It '"' • Q's
Feb Apr May
#1 154 470 449
. '''''' - ''..'"1.-',3 'r'-''. 0-S-.• -i-44.?''-'i-"410.6.-1 .:0447.4 i;' - , .
. . 42..696 4. 491
#2 20.40 4.49 1,,,,-'
2.16 11.2 l ".. _ * - .,,l'*-4:-•41v, - tit,'0.1,..'-‘,.'"-'"air iji.,-, ..,,,,,
#3 1.12 3.39 1.24 .466 4.15 141":4 -' 1....,, clam Bay 5
#4 .577 .0646 1.37 3.08 • i.7..,,,,,,,,,, _ ,\. ,..,,.. ...r,,, ...„..,,,,,,,,,_:,, „...,,.,,,,, . .,,,,,,..„,.,,
.346 4.73 .272 .272 1.58 ' , 1 -,,,, - ,i. ;1•• ., t.-* --fr ,-,':', li-v,„, !LA, ',441,3.11 41‘eit,
#5
sa. ...- • , Zt ..--• :;.t.:::.1'' ' .. --•''' '$"*- •.. '* • '1"•••111/t, •r",''-•- •-t•
#6 .346 1.71 .272 .272 4.14 i z..A-s----.k .... , -.-7 I, ',...;Nit7ar>:.,:`,,,,, .t.1;
Clam Bay 6 -,,--: : k. ;. . . ''47- . .'...., .,i.----1-:,,
7.12 C.am
#7 .346 .942 .345 .272
#8
.346 1.69 .360 .272 3.28 .1
#9 .346 1.51 1.91 .272 1.53 Clam Bay 8 ;I'
Clam Bay 9 .
' : :'-" .4-0',.1A..; ,..
Impaired is greater than 3.7 ugh l Clam Bay
I
q7i
fC 1/4p O N O k !4 r'
M tf) N 5„
O r -1 O r mQl'c K Q U fiG a $a
V
CO ay x Q
0 al
et O CI
CO M FO M N N
E O O O M
V
x Q > l
fC �O N N O O
Qa d d
7,1; d N ay�"y
M O� O
G O O !`
c
mO N N O
d t� l� d
M N N N ri a
�y
E O r1 O O d �
ct O N N
M l� N N L Q
E O d O O c- z
F.
.iQx
w c`
JC•i U CO
,w
et' �o o O o �
fYt s. a o� �o ,: 4
c/-)
�o Q
W x U al
N t
Cr) CN1
U — < F
pfi
4,10 a ® - „to
)1
m ® '� 4t&*
o d'
cad o o .. CD �_
U 1 �
t4i 414
in
ft tsi N N M j •r�R
N \ \ S.
dlY'.'' F[ • t•
co
Tam ,-4 rA m - Ln io N oo rn
CO as to (13 CO CD CZ OS CO 113 CO CO CO m m CO CO CC) N
CM E E E E E E E E E
CO CO Co fo co Co co CO co Co
U U U U U O U U U t%
h , ,
m i, . , ii ,
i I , ,
z 1 kI I"(
ce :10
1
ict
2
V♦
Z
a
w
Ce
Cew
� 1
a
O
I
v 1 (11 Z la
O a
a it 1 1111 b. kik
z L
■
I i g
a
CO _ _1, _ : _ _ _LI_ _
O O O O O 0 O O O O O 0 O O O 0 O O O O O O O 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O
01 0 v1 O M O u1 0 u1 O M O In O to O M O V 1 0 In O In O to O iA 0 In O 111 O In O M 0 In O M O In 0
OCD C110f0003r.: r. LO kouiinnrnr MMNNria-tOCDaicn oi 001: N 'Ouo V1111CPnr MMNNaia-100
N N ri ri ri ri ri ri ri ri ri ri ri ri ri ei ei ri ri ei ri ei
0 l/Em
From: Mohamed Dabees [mailto:md @humistonandmoore.com]
Sent:Tuesday,August 11, 2015 4:16 PM
To: ResnickLisa
Cc: Neil Dorrill (neil @dmgfl.com);Tim Hall
Subject: RE: Please Review Specifications for Aerial Photography of Clam Bay
Hi Lisa,
We will also provide additional oblique aerials to cover the bay system later this month.
Mohamed
From: ResnickLisa [mailto:LResnick @colliergov.net]
Sent: Tuesday,August 11, 2015 4:06 PM
To: Mohamed Dabees
Cc: Neil Dorrill (neil @dmgfl.com);Tim Hall
Subject: RE: Please Review Specifications for Aerial Photography of Clam Bay
Mohamed,
I understand that you discussed this with Neil,agreed with Tim's explanation below, and plan to proceed
accordingly. As a result,we will not be ordering scale-rectified aerials.
Thanks,
Lisa
From:Tim Hall [mailto:Tim @turrell-associates.com]
Sent:Tuesday,August 11, 2015 1:35 PM
To: ResnickLisa; Mohamed Dabees PhD., P.E.
Cc: Neil Dorrill (neil @dmgfl.com)
Subject: RE: Please Review Specifications for Aerial Photography of Clam Bay
I think that covers the request if we decide to keep producing the large aerials. As you know,last year we did not
fly this aerial as a result of the confusion from Kyle leaving and Marion coming on board. We instead utilized the
Collier County aerial photography(which is now being flown every year though in January instead of July)along
with some oblique aerials from July that we also had available. If the PBSD Board is agreeable with utilizing the
existing County aerials and flying the entire system obliquely,then I believe we should request a permit
modification to the hand-dug channel operations permit to allow for that instead of the large rectified aerial that
has been required and flown for the past 15 years or so. If we can get DEP to approve,that should save the Board
around$4,000 to$5,000 per year.
Regards,
Tim Hall
Turrell, Hall &Associates, Inc.
Marine& Environmental Consulting
3584 Exchange Ave.
Naples, FL. 34104-3732
Phone: (239)643-0166
Fax: (239) 643-6632
Web: www.turrell-associates.com
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS TRANSMISSION IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE USE OF THE
INDIVIDUAL OR ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS ADDRESSED AND MAY CONTAIN INFORMATION THAT IS
PRIVILEGED,CONFIDENTIAL, WORK PRODUCT AND/OR EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE UNDER APPLICABLE
LAW. IF THE READER OF THIS MESSAGE IS NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT(OR THE EMPLOYEE OR AGENT
RESPONSIBLE FOR DELIVERING IT TO THE INTENDED RECIPIENT),YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED THAT ANY
DISSEMINATION,DISTRIBUTION OR COPYING OF THIS COMMUNICATION IS PROHIBITED. IF YOU HAVE
RECEIVED THIS COMMUNICATION IN ERROR,PLEASE NOTIFY US BY TELEPHONING US(COLLECT)AND
RETURN THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE TO US AT THE ADDRESS ABOVE AT OUR EXPENSE.
From: ResnickLisa [mailto:LResnick@colliergov.net)
Sent: Monday,August 10,2015 4:56 PM
To:Tim Hall<Tim @turrell-associates.com>; Mohamed Dabees PhD., P.E.<md @humistonandmoore.com>
Cc: Neil Dorrill(neil @dmgfl.com)<neil @dmgfl.com>
Subject: Please Review Specifications for Aerial Photography of Clam Bay
Tim&Mohamed,
According to Special Condition 13 a of the FDEP Clam Bay Channel Maintenance permit 11-0128463-
005:
13. Biological Monitoring
a. The permittee shall provide flight dated aerial photography of the Clam Bay ecosystem
annually. The aerials shall be taken in July of each year and submitted to the Department annually
for the duration of the permit.The aerials must be color,vertical aerial photographs,controlled
and rectified at a scale appropriate for post-production digitalization and a scale sufficient to
delineate differing habitat zones and dominant species within each zone. The flight line shall
include all of the Clam Bay Natural Resource Protection Area and the nearshore zone to at least
400 feet offshore(from the mean high water line);
So that we can obtain quotes from vendors, please review this proposed scope of work and let me know if
it fits the requirements.
Proposed Scope of Work for Clam Bay Aerial Photography
Please provide quote to obtain color and F.C.I.R. aerial photography of the Clam Bay Natural Resource
Protection Area, Collier County Florida suitable for 1' =200' scale enlargements.
1. Provide one copy of digital image files; and
2. Provide three(3) 1'=200' scale controlled color enlargements; and
3. Provide three(3) 1'=200' scale controlled F.C.I.R. enlargements
Thanks,
Lisa
Lisa Jacob,MSM
Pelican Bay Services Division
Municipal Services Taxing&Benefit Unit
Collier County Government
801 Laurel Oak Drive,Suite 302
Naples,FL 34108
(239)597-1749 office
(239)438-5239 mobile
(239)597-4502 fax
Iresnickacolliergov.net
r,.
.JQ x�. a,, , Lu
z c°ti�� . .
o o 0� U m j o
cd mCa o vi y► Z ,4,
•
vCs
Ce
XI;V :fir . .`° ,• '. �'
fa ,... N y
L.
2 i mot' ,--i a
t o '.
m
,‘, .
m
CO C "4
E
:
SCHEDULE B: RATE SCHEDULE CB&I Coastal Planning
RFP 15-6397
"Environmental & Biological Studies"
Title Standard Hourly
Rate
Principal $215.00
Project Principal $200.00
Project Manager $145.00
Ecologist $95.00
Permitting $130.00
Senior Scientist $420.00
Scientist $95.00
Enivironmental Technician $80.00
GIS Analyst $90.00
AutoCad $85.00
Expert Witness $200.00
Administrative Assistant/Clerical $65.00
This list is not intended to be all-inclusive. Hourly rate fees for other categories of
professional, support and other services shall be mutually negotiated by the County and
firm on a project by project basis as needed.
B-1
SCHEDULE B: RATE SCHEDULE Earth Tech Environmental
RFP 15-6397
"Environmental & Biological Studies"
Title Standard Hourly
Rate
Principal $120.00
Project Principal $120.00
Project Manager $105.00
Ecologist $80.00
Permitting $105.00
Senior Scientist $105.00
Scientist $80.00
Enivironmental Technician $65.00
GIS Analyst $65.00
AutoCad $65.00
Expert Witness $150.00
Administrative Assistant/Clerical $45.00
This list is not intended to be all-inclusive. Hourly rate fees for other categories of
professional, support and other services shall be mutually negotiated by the County and
firm on a project by project basis as needed.
B-1 flt
SCHEDULE B: RATE SCHEDULE Kevin Erwin Consulting
RFP 15-6397
"Environmental & Biological Studies"
Title Standard Hourly
Rate
Principal $125.00
Project Principal $100.00
Project Manager $95.00
Ecologist $80.00
Permitting $75.00
Senior Scientist $95.00
Scientist $80.00
Enivironmental Technician $40.00
GIS Analyst $60.00
AutoCad $50.00
Expert Witness $125.00
Administrative Assistant/Clerical $40.00
This list is not intended to be all-inclusive. Hourly rate fees for other categories of
professional, support and other services shall be mutually negotiated by the County and
firm on a project by project basis as needed.
B-1
SCHEDULE B: RATE SCHEDULE
Passarella * Assoc .
RFP 15-6397
"Environmental & Biological Studies"
Title Standard Hourly
Rate
Principal _ $190.00
Project Principal $170.00
Project Manager $115.00
Ecologist $85.00
Permitting $105.00
Senior Scientist $105.00
Scientist $85.00
Enivironmental Technician $65.00
GIS Analyst $70.00
AutoCad $65.00
Expert Witness $160.00
Administrative Assistant/Clerical $52.00
This list is not intended to be all-inclusive. Hourly rate fees for other categories of
professional, support and other services shall be mutually negotiated by the County and
firm on a project by project basis as needed.
0 B-1 J
SCHEDULE B: RATE SCHEDULE on THA Contract
RFP 15-6397
"Environmental & Biological Studies"
Title Standard Hourly
Rate
Principal $175.00
Project Principal $175.00
Project Manager $125.00
Ecologist $95.00
Permitting $130.00
Senior Scientist $125.00
Scientist $95.00
Enivironmental Technician _ $65.00
GIS Analyst $90.00
AutoCad $80.00
Expert Witness $220.00
Administrative Assistant/Clerical $60.00
This list is not intended to be all-inclusive. Hourly rate fees for other categories of
professional, support and other services shall be mutually negotiated by the County and
firm on a project by project basis as needed.
B-1
Exhibit B— Price Schedule Earth Balance
Position Hourly Rate
Professional staff(i.e. degreed $85 Per Hour
biologist or arborist)
Project Manager $105 Per Hour
Crew leader/supervisor $62 Per Hour
Herbicide applicator $28 Per Hour
Chain saw operator $32 Per Hour
Other laborer $28 Per Hour
This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Fees for other services and categories, including
equipment and materials, shall be mutually negotiated by the County and the Contractor as
needed for the Work.
Page -13-
Exhibit B—Price Schedule Earth Tech
Position Hourly Rate
Professional staff(i.e. degreed $95 Per Hour
biologist or arborist)
Project Manager $85 Per Hour
Crew leader/supervisor $65 Per Hour
Herbicide applicator $35 Per Hour
Chain saw operator $35 Per Hour
Other laborer $30 Per Hour
This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Fees for other services and categories, including
equipment and materials, shall be mutually negotiated by the County and the Contractor as
needed for the Work.
Page c
9
Exhibit B— Price Schedule Environmental Restoration
Position Hourly Rate
Professional staff(i.e. degreed $34 Per Hour
biologist or arborist)
Project Manager $25 Per Hour
Crew leader/supervisor $20 Per Hour
Herbicide applicator $14 Per Hour
Chain saw operator $14 Per Hour
Other laborer $10.50 Per Hour
This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Fees for other services and categories, including
equipment and materials, shall be mutually negotiated by the County and the Contractor as
needed for the Work.
Page -13- cao
1
Exhibit B - Price Schedule Kevin Erwin Consulting
Position Hourly Rate
Professional staff(i.e. degreed $90 Per Hour
biologist or arborist)
Project Manager $90 Per Hour
Crew leader/supervisor $55 Per Hour
Herbicide applicator $30 Per Hour
Chain saw operator $30 Per Hour
Other laborer $25 Per Hour
This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Fees for other services and categories, including
equipment and materials, shall be mutually negotiated by the County and the Contractor as
needed for the Work.
Page -13-
Exhibit B—Price Schedule Peninsula Improvement
Position Hourly Rate
Professional staff(i.e. degreed $125 Per Hour
biologist or arborist)
Project Manager $75 Per Hour
Crew leader/supervisor $40 Per Hour
Herbicide applicator $20 Per Hour
Chain saw operator $20 Per Hour
Other laborer $16 Per Hour
This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Fees for other services and categories, including
equipment and materials, shall be mutually negotiated by the County and the Contractor as
needed for the Work.
Page -13- c`'°'
Exhibit B- Price Schedule Sandhill Environmental
Position Hourly Rate
Professional staff(i.e. degreed $75 Per Hour
biologist or arborist)
Project Manager $75 Per Hour
Crew leader/supervisor $50 Per Hour
Herbicide applicator $50 Per Hour
Chain saw operator $35 Per Hour
Other laborer $30 Per Hour
This list is not intended to be all inclusive. Fees for other services and categories, including
equipment and materials, shall be mutually negotiated by the County and the Contractor as
needed for the Work.
Page -13-
From: McCaughtryMary
Sent: Wednesday, August 26, 2015 2:45 PM
To: Neil Dorrill
Cc: BolickMarion; ResnickLisa
Subject: FW: Functions, Powers, Duties of PBSD Board
As part of today's Clam Bay Meeting, that was a publicly noticed meeting this was discussed.
Mary
From: naplessusan(arcn.com [mailto:naplessusan(arcn.com]
Sent: Wednesday, August 26, 2015 2:20 PM
To: McCaughtryMary
Subject: Fwd: Functions, Powers, Duties of PBSD Board
Hi Mary,
Per your request.
Susan
From: lor3lor3@aol.com
To: naplessusan c(Drcn.com, djtreckeryahoo.com, napleskendawson(a�aol.com,
jchicurel(a�gmail.com, "h bachman" <h.bachman@ieee.orq>, bphirniakaol.com,
bushpjworkgmail.com, sstreckenbein(c�yahoo.com, nfn16799 @naples.net
Sent: Wednesday, August 26, 2015 11:20:32 AM
Subject: Functions, Powers, Duties of PBSD Board
Dear PBSD Board Members,
The Board of Pelican Bay Municipal Services Taxing and Benefit Unit (PB MSTBU)
is the entity recognized by the Collier County Government to represent the Pelican Bay
Community. You are granted much power and responsibility via multiple Ordinances,
together with the Letters of Agreement/Understanding, negotiated by concerned PB
leaders and the Board of County Commissioners. In the best interest of the Community,
the Board must preserve and retain the powers and rights of the PB MSTBU. Do
not allow others to diminish them.
The Functions, Powers and Duties of the PBSD Board are listed in Ordinances 2002-
27, 2006-05, 2013-19, 2013-61.
The Amended Memorandum of Letter of Agreement/Understanding for the BCC and the
County Manager with the PB MSTBU Board is a component of the above Ordinances.
It clearly defines the authority and responsibility of the PBSD Board. It states that:
1. The Functions, Powers and Duties of the PBSD Board are listed in the Ordinances.
2. The BCC shall accept the direction of the PBSD Board in its policy decisions relating
to the PB MSTBU, to the maximum extent allowed by law, unless and except when
there is some overriding governmental reason to do otherwise.
3. All ultimate policy making powers are reserved unto the BCC, sitting as ex-officio
Board of the PB MSTBU pursuant to Florida Law. (That's the reason some decisions
made by the PBSD Board require BCC approval)
4. The County Manager shall accept the direction of the PB MSTBU Board in its
exercise of decision and control of the day to day operations, to the maximum extent
allowed by law, unless and except when there is some overriding governmental reasons
to do otherwise.
5. All ultimate administrative and ministerial powers related to the operations of PB
MSTBU are retained by the County Manager, under the policy direction of the BCC,
sitting as the ex-officio Board of the PB MSTBU.
The salaries of the PBSD Administrator and staff are paid by the PB MSTBU. Their duty
is to implement the decisions made by the PBSD Board (some decisions require BCC
approval, e.g., annual budget, Clam Pass). The Administrator is wrong in saying that the
Board cannot make decisions, and that it is only an advisory committee to the BCC,
intimating it is the same as the Coastal Advisory Committee, Parks and Recreations
Advisory Committee, Library Advisory Committee, etc.
The PBSD Administrator is a liaison between the PBSD Board and the County
Manager. He is to report periodically to the County Manager on the activities of the PB
MSTBU. "Report to" does not mean "answer to"; he answers to the PB MSTBU Board
who hires him and pays his salary. His contract is with the PB MSTBU. The PBSD
Administrator, hired by the PBSD Board, has no decision making authority. He cannot
represent the Board without the Board's direction.
PBSD Board members must publically refute the PBSD Administrator whenever he
makes the assertion that "PBSD is only an advisory committee to the BCC without
authority of decision making."
Pelican Bay Blvd. is a County Road, all County citizens especially those residing in the
neighborhoods of the road have the right to be involved in the reconstruction of the road
and median.
Thank you for your kind attention.
Sincerely,
Linda Roth
Montenero