The URL can be used to link to this page

PARAB Backup 11/16/1994 R Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (PARAB) Backup November i6 , 1994 - COLLIER COUNTY GOVERNMENT DIVISION OF PUBLIC SERVICES 3300 SANTA BARBARA BOULEVARD PARKS AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT NAPLES, FLORIDA 33999 (813)353-0404 A CERTIFIED BLUE CHIP COMMUNITY October 5, 1994 Mr. Kevin Litt 1670 Oaks Boulevard Naples, Florida 33999 Dear Kevin: We would like to invite you to make a presentation at the next Parks and Recreation Advisory Board meeting that is scheduled for October 26, 1994, 2:00 pm at the Frank E. Mackle, Jr. Community Park on Marco Island. Enclosed is a brochure and map, which - should help get you there. If you have any other questions regarding the meeting, please call 353-0404 . 4;;F: Steve Brinkman Parks and Recreation Director SB/bj/12414 cc: Commissioner Matthews Commissioner Saunders W. Neil Dorrill, County Manager Thomas W. 011iff, Public Services Administrator • %3a-a/AdiFoGGGBI` &tCG/a g/ntiuG.1.1GGt/Ze!`.1 L� Ll�'�: 3301 East Tamiami Trail • Naples, Florida 33962-4977 -hn C. Norris (813) 774-8097 • Fax(813) 774-3602 `-)• .*� strict 1 Michael J.Volpe District 2 September 30, 1994 Timothy J. Constantine District 3 Burt L. Saunders District 4 Bettye J. Matthews District 5 Mr. Kevin Litt 1670 Oaks Boulevard Naples, FL 33999 Dear Kevin: Thank you very much for your recent letter concerning skate boarders and rollerbladers in Collier County. I certainly share your belief - that a County facility at our community parks would be desirable for skate boarders and rollerbladers. I am taking the liberty of forwarding your letter to the Collier County Parks and Recreation Advisory Board for their review and consideration. As you know, I will be leaving the Board of County Commissioners on November 8, 1994 , and therefore will not be involved in the issues that you have raised in your letter. If I can be of any assistance to you in my capacity as Commissioner between now and then, please do not hesitate to ask. After that date, I will be opening a Legislative Office on the 3rd Floor of Building F at the Government Center and look forward to working with you in my capacity as State Representative from District 76. Again, thank you for your letter and if I can be of any further assistance, please do not hesitate to ask. Ver truly your , Burt L. Saunders Commissioner, District 4 BLS: sf cc: Tom 011iff, Public Services Administrator Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Members {' RECEIVED OCT 31994 1 PUBLIC SFPVIrt: Kevin Litt 1670 Oaks Blvd . Naples , FL 33999 September 22 , 1994 ( 813 ) 598-9666 Commissioner Saunders , I 'm an 18 year old Eagle Scout , a voter , and am currently enrolled at Edison Community Collage . I am writing because I am concerned about the problem of skate boarders and rollerbladers . They get in trouble for jumping off stairs and sliding on walls . Understandably they cause a problem for businesses and they deface buildings . As of now if a person is seen involved in these activities the police are called or the teens get yelled at by business owners . First this is a waste of time for the police and the yelling only causes bad feelings between the owner and the teen . To solve this problem I would like to propose that a part of a park be set aside for teens to skate in . I understand that the county doesn 't have billions of dollars to spend on building a park of this nature , but please keep in mind that the bigger and the better this place is the more people will go there instead of going to the streets . If ideas are needed for the out line of a park you may contact me and I will do my best to get some ideas to you . The building of this facility will not only keep more kids `rom bothering the businesses of Collier County , but also :gill give the --/ / ,/ / 4 a ,...' :1 ' :.....' ,,-- /40--'Lle._ '`,-1.',--A-,-... ..,-. /1 / / - /I, 3 - / ,a4 ` f: ' / -/ /C/ „,„,,.6.,<,._ 7Z. M E M O R A N D U M TO: Steve Brinkman, Parks and Recreation ector FROM: Sue Filson, Administrative Assista Board of County Commissioners RE: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board DATE: November 14 , 1994 As you know, we currently have 3 vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press release was issued requesting citizens interested in serving on this committee to submit a resume for consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review and recommendation as follows: J Diane M. Jacob 431 Palm Court Naples, FL 33963 JKimberly A. Kushman 900 8th Avenue S, #306 Naples, FL 33940 Leonard P. Reina J 316 3rd Avenue N Naples, FL 33940 Robert R. Hildreth j 2376 Pine Wood Circle Naples, FL 33942 James A. Davis 119 Wickliffe Drive • Naples, FL 33942 Joseph D. Zaks 4841 Shearwater Lane Naples, FL 33999 Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation of the advisory committee for appointment and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board' s consideration. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions, please call me at 774-8097 . Thank you for your attention to this matter. SF Attachments P. S. I am also attaching a copy of Resolution No. 94-136 establishing guidelines for receiving recommendations for appointment of members to advisory committees and auasi-1udicial boards. Diane M. Jacob 431 Palm Count RECEIVED Naples, FL 33963 813-.166-1887 NOV 1 4 1,94 aoird of County Commissioner November 10, 1994 Collier County Board of Commissioners Attn: Sue Filson 3301 E Tamiami Tr-Bldg F Naples, FL 33962 Re: Parks &Recreation Advisory Board Dear Sue: {� It is my understanding that there are openings on the above referenced advisory board on which I have an interest in serving. Enclosed is my resume which outlines my professional and volunteer work history since I moved to Naples in October, 1988. Because of my involvement with tennis and boating, I have some familiarity with most of Collier County's recreational facilities. As the county's population grows, the demand on these facilities will become greater and I would consider it both a challenge and a privilege to be involved in the planning process. Thank you for your consideration of my application. Should you need additional information, you may contact me at 597-4353 during business hours. Sincerely, atktik), Diane M. Jacob - Diane M. Jacob ( 431 Palm Count Naples, FL 33963 813-566-1887 11/10/94 Employment History 7/1/94 -Present Administrative Assistant, Charisma Chapel, Naples Duties include those of personal secretary to the Pastor as well as coordinator for all church activities; editing and publishing a monthly newsletter, etc. 9/1/82 - 6/30/94 Executive Director,American Subcontractors Association of Collier County,Naples Duties included coordinating a monthly membership dinner meeting; new member recruitment; production of a monthly newsletter; and providing a variety of member services. 4/1/89 - 5/31/92 Secretary, Naples Church of God, Naples Duties included those of personal secretary to the Pastor; all bookkeeping including accounts payable, payroll, and weekly deposit of offering and keeping record of individual giving; production of a weekly bulletin; etc. Volunteer Activities 1/1/91 - 8/31/94 Collier County Women's Tennis Association Served in various positions on Board of Directors of this 600- member organization which provides league tennis on public and private courts on a year-round basis. Duties included team assignments for each 7-week league; quarterly newsletter production; organization of 2 one-day tennis/lunch events per year. 1/1/93 - present Vanderbilt Beach Property Owners Association Serving as a director on the board; duties include attending monthly board meeting to review community issues and concerns; production of a monthly newsletter; helping coordinate a monthly membership meeting; maintenance of membership records, etc. Personal Married, no children, Age 45, excellent health Page 1 of 2 h . { Diane M. Jacob References Andrew DeLong, Pastor Kim Patrick Kobza, Esq. Charisma Chapel Treiser, Kobza& Volpe 621 Ridge Drive 4001 Tamiami Tr N- #330 Naples, FL 33963 Naples, FL 33940 597-4353 649-4900 Page 2 of 2 ECE VED arnett Barnett Bank of Naples arilt NOV , 796 Fifth Avenue South Post Office Box 413008 Naples, Florida 33941-3008 813/263-1303 Kimberly A. Kushman Fax 813/263-5544 Assistant Vice President Commercial Lending Group November 8, 1994 Ms. Sue Filson Administrative Assistant Board of County Commissioners 3301 U.S. 41 East Naples, FL 33962 Dear Ms. Filson: Enclosed please find my resume for consideration by the Board of County (. ^mmissioners for appointment to the Parks and Recreation Advisory ird. My background in the financial services industry for the past ten years well qualifies me to make a significant contribution to the Board. In addition to the business background, I have actively participated in a variety of community organizations, which have offered excellent experience for this position. Lastly, I am a twenty-one year resident of Collier County and have actively used the many services the parks and recreation system provides during that time. Thank you for this opportunity to serve the community. If you should have any questions, please contact me at 263-1303 . Sincerely, BARNETT BANK OF NAPLES Kimberly A. Kushman Assistant Vice President RESUME Kimberly A. Bushman November 8, 1994 EDUCATION Stetson University, Deland, Florida; B.B.A. Degree in Finance, May 1984. Naples High School, Graduation: June 1980. EXPERIENCE Assistant Vice President, Barnett Bank of Naples, Naples, Florida. Generating new commercial real estate banking relationships, as well as the maintenance and expansion of existing banking accounts. Total loan closings during the initial ten months of 1994 total $45 million. Managing a commercial real estate loan portfolio of $25 million. (March 1993-Present) Assistant Vice President, Sun Bank of Lee County, N.A. , Fort Myers, Florida. Servicing the financial needs of the Bank's private banking clientele and management of an $11 million commercial loan portfolio. Emphasis on business brokerage referrals and deposit generation. Production during the year exceeded 100% of established goals. The private banking department was housed with the trust department, creating an excellent referral network. (December 1991-March 1993) Assistant Vice President, Southeast Bank. N.A. , Naples, Florida. Managing commercial loan portfolio of $8 million. Emphasis on business development in the areas of small business lending, the professional market, coordination of municipality bids and SBA financing. Acting cash management coordinator for Collier County. Experience in letters of credit. (October 1986-December 1991) Credit Analyst, Southeast Bank, N.A. Naples, Florida. Analyst for Lee and Collier Counties analyzing a variety of businesses engaged in occupations including real estate development, retail furniture, restaurants, and medical facilities. Managed commercial loan portfolio and assisted in disbursements for real estate construction loans. (May 1985-October 1986) Corporate Credit Training Program, Southeast Bank, N.A. Miami, Florida. Training program to develop analytical skills through extensive post-college classroom work in finance and accounting. Further emphasis on case-studies selected from Southeast's current portfolio of diverse industries and loan facilities. (September 1984-May 1985) Resume of Kimberly A. Kushman November 8, 1994 PAST AND PRESENT COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT Youth Haven, Inc. - volunteer/member Friends of the Philharmonic - volunteer/member Coral Arts Society - member Women's Political Caucus - member Naples Society of Poets - member Naples Area Chamber of Commerce - Disaster Recovery Committee member Economic Development Council - Community Affairs Committee member Project Business Consultant, Junior Achievement. Three semesters of classroom instruction to eighth grade students teaching the fundamentals of business. Naples Central Rotary Club - Member; served on Board of Directors Collier County Historical Society - Member; served on Board of Directors Collier County Fine Arts Society member; served on Associate Board of Directors HEALTH Excellent health; regular exercise program; health and nutrition-oriented food plan; lifetime non-smoker. CONTACT LOCATIONS Kimberly A. Kushman 900 Eighth Avenue South, #306 Naples, FL 33940 Business phone: (813) 263-1303 Home phone: (813) 261-2174 Leonard P. Reina, P.A. Attorney at Law November 7, 1994 Ms . Sue Filson Administrative Assistant Board of County Commissioners Collier County Courthouse 3301 Tamiami Trail E. Naples, FL 33962 Re : Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Dear Ms . Filson: Please accept this as my application for appointment to fill the vacancy on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board to represent the Naples urban area. Enclosed please find my Resume. I am a resident and registered voter in Collier County and currently reside and conduct my law practice within the city limits . I have a strong interest in seeing Naples and Collier County remain a beautiful place in which to live and work, as well as to visit, and I believe that parks and recreational facilities are essential to accomplish that objective . Most great urban areas have one or more parks of world renown, such as Central Park in New York. I would appreciate being considered for this appointment and would be happy to furnish any additional information that you may need. Sincerely, Leonard P. Reina LPR:bh {��e Enclosure �� 3rd " " 359VO RECEIVED. NOV — $ =,9 a°; 4 500 5th Avenue South • Suite 502 • Naples, Florida 33940 • 813/263-2059 • Fax: 263-2069 LEONARD P. REINA LEONARD P. REINA, P.A. 500 Fifth Avenue S. , Suite 502 Naples, Florida 33940 (813) 263-2059 PERSONAL DATA: Age : 43 Wife : Andrea Clark Brown, Architect Health: Excellent EDUCATION: Doctor of Jurisprudence, (1980) South Texas College of Law. Master of Science in Management, (1976) FL International U. Bachelor of Science, (1973) Florida State University. LICENSES AND CERTIFICATIONS: State Certified Mediator (1991) State Certified Arbitrator (1990) Certified Hearing Officer/Special Master (1993) Federal Bar, Middle District of Florida (1989) Florida Bar No. 325716 (1981) Texas Bar No. 16754600 (1980) Florida Real Estate Broker No. 0130282 (1976) PRACTICE OF LAW: Areas of Practice : Civil & Criminal Litigation, Real Estate/Business/Contract Law (5/1/94 to Present) - Leonard P. Reina, P.A. (1992 - 6/1/94) - Shareholder, Forsyth, Brugger, Reina (1990-1991) - Shareholder, Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger (1986-89) - Associate, Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger (1980-86) - Sole practitioner, Houston, Texas RELATED EXPERIENCES : Adjunct Professor, Edison Community College and International College, Naples, FL Florida Real Estate Broker MEMBERSHIPS AND AFFILIATIONS: Florida Bar - Member Florida Trial Lawyers Assoc . Federal Bar Texas Bar American Bar American Mediation Association Collier County Bar: Director - 1992-95 Chairman, Library Committee Member Trial & Real Estate Sec . Naples Area Board of Realtors, Affiliate Member American Subcontractors Association: Member Government Affairs Committee Women' s Political Caucus Humane Society / one I - 1y o_m,missioners loo rly- Ito serve on advisor a �e By Daily News Staff _ SIX county c Collier County commissioners`are `J in looking for volunteers to serve on six ad- qualify vol - on visory committees that have, or will voters in Cc soon have,vacancies. - . ° The Black Affairs Advisory Commit- interest she ;",,t tee,the Golden Gate:Parkway Beautifi- Y cation Advisory Committee;the library tween minority'€ Advisory Board, the Citizens Advisory commission, Task Force, the Golden Gate:Commu- The Golden G ,t pity Center Advisory Committee and the cation Advisory ( ivy_ Parks and Recreation Advisory Board cancy, which reps e 5 all have open seats. ; 623.The five-men U Volunteers' - must be residents and the county come 4i registered voters in Collier County. Re- pertaining to the sumes and letters of interest should be to landscaPe Gol( ate- mailed by Nov. 12 to Sue Filson, admin- . tween Santa Ba ;are istrative assistant to the county commis- County Road 951. _ sion,3301 U.S.41 E.,Naples,33962.. The Library A The Black Affairs Advisory Commit- terms expiring on F't tee has three vacancies due to resigna- ing county commi tions. Two of the terms will expire in This five-memb tt June, 1995 and one term will expire in county eommissio June,1997.The nine-member committee budget of the 0 Vets identifies and evaluates problems unique System. 4 f■ to Collier County's African-American The Citizens ulation and reviews and recommends has two terms exf —' w ys to ensure open communication be- is available for a 1 E ALCM VED HILDRETH 2376 Pine Wood Circle OCT 2 0 1994 Naples, FL 33942 B (�v a b 2 - s7,01 --d/of County Cormissinners L//3/22)' 4J11/SO21( 02 /9%0(5 0 LZLC2E/9iion) (REVISED 8-24-93? PACKGROUND INFORMATION — BOB HILDRETH BORN: MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA. EDUCATION: UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI , CORAL GABLES. FL. B.A. DEGREE, COMMUNICATIONS, 1954. j''IILITARY: 3-1/2 YEARS U.S. NAVY. PACIFIC DUTY. QUEER: 12 YEARS. RADIO, TV. AND NEWSPAPER POSITIONS, FOLLOWED BY: 1957-1987 — SR. V.P. MARKETING. CORAL GABLES FEDERAL SAVINGS. ASSETS ON DATE OF RETIREMENT 2.5 BILLION. AWARDS— HONORS: CORAL GABLES CHAMBER OF COMMERCE — "ROBERT B. KNIGHT OUTSTANDING CITIZEN AWARD. " 1982 OMICRON DELTA KAPPA, NATIONAL HONORARY SOCIETY, TAPPED APRIL 5. 1987. IRON ARROW HONOR SOCIETY — UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI , TAPPED 1990 . PRESIDENT CORAL GABLES — CARTEGENA. COLUMBIA. SISTER CITY AFFILIATION. RECEIVED READERS DIGEST "BEST OVERALL PROGRAM AWARD. " 1966 — 1967 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTERS "BIG MIKE AWARD 1970 . BEST 30 SECOND RADIO COMMERCIAL "SOCIAL SECURITY" (JACK BENNY — BOB HILDRETH) HIGHEST CONSUMER RECOGNITION FOR "CHARLIE" TELEVISION COMMERCIALS 1974 BACKGROUND. BOB HILDRETH. PAGE 2 OFFICES HELD: CUR RENT. CORAL GABLES CITY COMMISSIONER-VICE MAYOR 1983 - 1993. DIRECTOR. FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS MARKETING ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA. 1970 - 1972. TRUSTEE. DOCTORS' HOSPITAL. 1971 - 78. DIRECTOR, MIAMI CHAPTER NATIONAL ACADEMY OF TELEVISION ARTS AND SCIENCES. 1978 - 1979. FOUNDING CHAIRMAN. CORAL GABLES COMMITTEE OF 21 . 1964-65. PRESIDENT AND DIRECTOR. CORAL GABLES CHAMBER OF COMMERCE. 1963-64. PAST PRESIDENT AND 30 YEAR-MEMBER CORAL GABLES ROTARY CLUB. PRESIDENT. CORAL GABLES WAR MEMORIAL • YOUTH CENTER 1979-81 . PRESIDENT. SOUTH FLORIDA F. I .M.A. CHAPTER NO. 2. 1973-74 CHAIRMAN. ORANGER BOWL INTERNATIONAL JUNIOR INVITATIONAL JUNIOR GOLF CHAMPIONSHIP. 1967 - 71 . CHAIRMAN. FLORIDA SAVINGS AND LOAN MARKETING COMMITTEE. 1975-78. TREASURER, SOUTH FLORIDA COMMITTEE FOR U.S. PROJECT HOPE. 1966-67. DIRECTOR. BIG BROTHERS OF GREATER MIAMI . 1970-71 . r. BACKGROUND. BOB HILDRETH. PAGE 3 MEMBERSHIPS: CURRENT: ORANGE BOWL COMMITTEE. MEMBER SINCE 1972. UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI HURRICANE CLUB. (COACHES CLUB) MIAMI TOUCHDOWN CLUB. PAST DIRECTOR. CORAL GABLES SISTER CITY PROGRAM. FORMER: ALPHA DELTA SIGMA ADVERTISING FRATERNITY. HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION OF SOUTH FLORIDA. FLORIDA COUNCIL OF INTERNATIONAL VISITORS. DOCTORS' HOSPITAL JOHN T. MACDONALD FOUNDATION. ADVERTISING FEDERATION OF GREATER MIAMI . NATIONAL ACADEMY OF TELEVISION ARTS AND SCIENCES. PERK S�L: RESIDENT OF CORAL GABLES sum 1950 .-/qqy MARRIED TO ISABELLE MARTIN HILDRETH SINCE 1952. THREE SONS, ROBERT III . CHRISTOPHER AND CARSON. 30 COASTAL ENGINEERING RECEIVED f CONSULTANTS ocT g 1994 11; INC. 8 r _of County Corraissiontrs Engineers • Scientists • Surveyors • Planners • Appraisers October 17, 1994 Mrs. Sue Filson Administrative Assistant Collier County Government Center 3301 Tamiami Trail, East Building "F" Naples, FL 33962 RE: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Dear Mrs. Filson: This letter is in response to the vacancy on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. I reside in Willoughby Acres which is located in District 5, and am licensed as an engineer in the State of Florida. As a resident of Collier County since 1984, and as a parent of two boys, ages 5 and 9, I am very interested in the future park and recreation needs of the County. Having worked with Collier and Lee Counties on numerous municipal park projects, I can bring both knowledge and professional experience to the Parks and Recreation Board. Attached please find my resume. If you have any questions or need additional information, I can be reached at 643-2324 during business hours, or after hours at my home phone, 597-9281. Very tr • :. -, COASTAL E I ERING Co SULTANTS, INC. if James £. Davis, P.E. Associate E .ineer Residence - 119 Wickliffe Drive Naples, FL 33942 Attachment - Resume JAD\ S. HORSESHOE DR. • NAPLES, FLORIDA 33942 • (813)643-2324 • =AX(813) 643-1143 r� NS JAMES A. DAVIS, P.E. Experience 1991 - Present Mr. Davis is head of the Civil Engineering Division at Coastal Engineering Consultants, Inc.with responsibility for land planning, rezoning and site engineering of planned unit developments, including commercial development, multi-family and single family residential projects. He has successfully negotiated and administered - municipal contracts for the development of environmentally sensitive coastal and river front projects. 1986 - 1991 As an Associate Engineer with Coastal Engineering Consultants, Inc., Mr. Davis was responsible for writing proposals, site planning, site design and engineering of utilities (using the Kentucky Pipe Program for water distribution and manifolded pump stations, roads, parking lots, drainage,and water management facilities), and design and permitting of projects requiring mitigation of ACOE jurisdictional wetlands. He was responsible for writing project specifications and contract documents, project construction scheduling and project management. 1985 - 1986 Mr. Davis,while with the Nielson Company,worked in highway and heavy industrial contracting, specifically in project estimating and management as related to the following types of projects: State and Federal highways, power plants, and wastewater treatment plants. Mr. Davis is experienced in calculating mass diagrams including free haul and overhaul. Additional experience includes the following: highway geometric design,traffic operations including progressive traffic signal timing, trip generation including linear regression and the gravity mode. Mr. Davis is knowledgeable in the area of computer programming. His computer background also involves working with the following software:Autocad,Timberland Accubid (job estimating software) and Earthwork (Quantity take-off software) and various surface water management programs. 1984 - 1985 Mr. Davis, working for Coastal Engineering Consultants, Inc., was involved in the design and management of civil projects in Southwest Florida, including the site development of the Marco Beach Hilton on Marco Island, Windstar and Crown Point West in Naples. Education B.S. Civil Engineering (Chi Epsilon) Colorado State University, Colorado, December, 1983 Professional Registration Engineering in Training - State of Colorado #12099, December, 1983 Professional Engineer - State of Florida #40090, August, 1988 '! Professional Affiliations I American Society of Civil Engineers - Officer from 1988 - 1993 r � KELLY, PRICE, SIKET & HEUERMAN • CHARTERED P:\t'1. K. I IEtER\I.-\N CHARLES\I. KELLY,JR. ATTORNEYS AT LAW TELEP'IONE BOARD CERTIFIED TAX LAWYER / BOARD CERTIFIED WILLS, ( (813)261-3453 MASTERS OFSLAW INS LAWYER ESTATE PLANNING GREY OAKS BUILDING R. SC0I-1'PRICE IN POINCIANA PROFESSIONAL PARK DONALD K. ROSS,JR. 264(1 GOLDEN GATE PARKWAY TELECOPIER MASTERS OF LAW IN TAXATION SUITE 315 (813)261-5711 ANDREW G.SIKET Y.O.BOX 8117 JOSEPH D. OF ZAKS LA OF MASTERS LA NAPLES, FLORIDA 33941-8117 W IN TAXATION ALSO ADMITTED IN OHIO October 10, 1994 < ALSO ADMITTED IN MAINE oe ALSO ADMITTED IN MASSACHUSETTS Ms. Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant Board of County Commissioners 3301 East Tamiami Trail • Naples, FL 33962-4977 Re: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Dear Ms. Filson: I am writing in response to your letter dated October 7, 1994, advising me that my term on the above-referenced advisory committee will expire on December 31, 1994. Please consider this letter as my notice that I am interested in continuing as a member of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. As such, I have enclosed a current copy of my resume. Please make certain that I am considered for reappointment to this board. Very truly yours, ose•h D. Zak JDZ/sa Enclosure cc: Steve Brinkman, Parks and Recreation Director C filsoa.lt JOSEPH D. ZAKS 4841 Shearwater Lane Longshore Lake Naples, Florida 33999 (813) 592-5140 EMPLOYMENT: Kelly, Price, Siket & Heuerman Naples, Florida Partner -The balance of the partners working for Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur left that firm in mid-March and joined my partner&me to form the current firm. There are six lawyers and twelve staff. The firm is a general practice law firm practicing in all virtually all areas of law, including: estate planning and trust and probate administration; real estate; civil litigation; corporate and business law;banking and bankruptcy and taxation. My partner and I,along with one paralegal and two secretaries, comprise the estate planning department of the firm. This department currently represents over four hundred clients. My current practice is concentrated in the area of sophisticated estate planning; estate and trust administration; probate; tax planning and compliance. I personally represent clients with estates ranging up to thirty million dollars. I currently serve as co-editor of the Naples Estate Planning Council articles appearing bi-weekly in the Naples Daily News and as co-chairman of the annual thirty page estate planning supplement appearing in the same newspaper. March 1993 to Present Kelly & Zaks, P.A. Naples, Florida Partner - Began a two lawyer, three employee partnership with the other member of the estate planning department of Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur. This practice concentrated in estate planning; estate and trust administration; probate and tax planning. Responsibilities include drafting and maintaining complex estate plans; as well as administering estate probate and administration of trusts. Over three hundred clients followed my partner and me from Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur, therefore the level of practice was virtually uninterrupted. February 1993 to March 1993 Porter, Wright, Morris & Arthur Naples, Florida Associate- Concentrated in estate planning; estate and trust administration; probate and tax planning. Responsibilities included drafting and maintaining complex estate plans; as well as administering estate probate and administration of trusts. Practice included preparation of tax returns and representing clients before the Internal Revenue Service. Gave presentations at seminars on estate planning and wrote numerous articles for publication in the Naples Daily News as well as for in-house publication. November 1991 to February 1993 Kaye, Fialkow, Richmond & Rothstein Boston, Massachusetts Associate- Concentrated in estate planning; federal and state tax; estate and trust administration;probate and corporate matters. Responsibilities included tax research and planning for a forty lawyer business, bankruptcy and banking law firm; drafting, implementing and maintaining hundreds of complex estate plans; as well as overseeing estate probate and administration of testamentary and inter vivos trusts. Additional responsibilities included: planning and implementation of corporate formations, mergers, liquidations and the drafting of a wide range of business documents. Accomplishments include computerizing tax planning and projections, trust administration and estate tax preparation; lecturing on tax,estate and business planning and writing articles for in-house publications. January, 1988 to July, 1991. Joseph D. Zaks, Resume 2 Touche Ross & Company Boston, Massachusetts Tax Consultant - Concentrated in individual, corporate and partnership taxation. Responsibilities included tax research and planning for a widely diverse client base. Additional duties included tax compliance and reporting on both federal and state levels. Accomplishments included the development and implementation of a personal financial management practice for the firm. August, 1985 to January, 1988 EDUCATION: Boston University School of Law Boston, Massachusetts LL.M., Taxation, May, 1989 J.D., May, 1985 Honors: Edward F. Hennessey Scholar-top 25% of class Activities: Moot Court Participant, First Year Student Advisor, Westlaw and Lexis Training. University of Massachusetts, College of Management Boston, Massachusetts B.S. summa cum laude, May, 1982 - Major: Private Financial Management Honors: Recipient, Mary B. Newman Award for Academic Excellence; Nominated, Harry S. Truman Scholarship for Commitment to Government Service; Nominated John F. Kennedy Award for Academic Achievement; Graduated First in Class. Activities: President, Pre-Law Society; Member, Finance and Accounting Academy; and Officer and Director, Alumni Association. BAR MEMBERSHIP: Admitted: Massachusetts Bar, December, 1985; U.S. District Court, District of Massachusetts, February, 1986; U.S. Supreme Court, June, 1990; Florida Bar, August, 1991; United States Tax Court, September, 1992. CIVIC ACTIVITIES: Volunteer, Collier County Assistant Public Guardian Program; Chairman, Collier County Parks and Recreation Advisory Board; Member, Naples Estate Planning Council, Co-editor bi-weekly column and Co-chairman annual supplement appearing in Naples Daily News;Member, Director Naples Kiwanis,Chairman,Blood Drive Committee,Advisor,Barron Collier Key Club;Member, St. John The Evangelist Building Committee; Former Member, Longshore Lake Homeowner Advisory Committee; Director, Longshore Lake Residents Association;Member,Naples Chamber of Commerce; Volunteer,Naples Special Olympics;Volunteer, Salvation Army. REFERENCES: Available upon request. t:,es RESOLUTION NO. 94-136 A RESOLUTION ADOPTING A FORMAL POLICY ESTABLISHING GUIDELINES FOR RECEIVING RECOMMENDATIONS FOR APPOINTMENT OF MEMBERS TO ADVISORY COMMITTEES AND - QUASI-JUDICIAL BOARDS. WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has established - various advisory boards and quasi-judicial boards to assist in various facets of county business and functions; and WHEREAS, members are appointed to the Various advisory committees and quasi-judicial boards by Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners; and WHEREAS, the Board wishes to establish a policy and set forth guidelines regarding the recommendation process for membership on advisory committees and quasi-judicial boards. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the following guidelines are hereby established for Board of County Commissioners receipt and acceptance of recommendations from the various advisory committees and quasi-judicial boards for appointment of members to such committees or boards: 1) Recommendations will be accepted by the Board of County Commissioners for appointments or reappointments for vacancies on advisory committees from the current membership of the committee. An advisory committee shall be allocated 41 days after notification from the Board office to submit in writing their recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners for the appointment or reappointment of members to such committPP- 2) The County Staff is to review and categorize the t applicants in areas of expertise and assure that the applicants • possess the minimum position requirements for the appointment zhev are seeking. 3) The following Boards are included in the category of • Quasi-Judicial Boards and no recommendations will be accepted or considered from such boards regarding appointments or reappointments for vacancies on such Boards: .a. Board of Building Adjustments and Appeals b. Collier County Code Enforcement Board c. Contractor's Licensing Board d. Public Vehicle Advisory Committee This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote. DATED: March 1, 1994 ' -ATTEST: /,; BOARD OF COUNTY Coo ISSIONERS DWIGHT E.. .BROCK, CLERK COLLIER Co - •, FLORIDA Iiipprli C0 N CHAIRMAN Approved-,as to form and legal?sufficiency: / .% ....... / Kenneth B. Cuyle- County Attorn-- i • , t%JG a,Pdo/C�JGtIGGe!-` CrJ6GG/G 4 CWGa/.�G.1.1GGL/?-eri C., �4. 3301 East Tamiami Trail • Naples, Florida 33962-4977 . 'In C. Norris (813) 774-8097 • Fax (813) 774-3602 C 4 strict 1 OUS. Michael J.Volpe District 2 Timothy J. Constantine October 3 , 1994 District 3 Burt L. Saunders District 4 Bettye J. Matthews District 5 Mr. Kevin Litt 1670 Oaks Boulevard Naples, Florida 33999 Dear Mr. Litt: Thank you very much for your letter of September 22 , 1994 . I agree with you wholeheartedly that skate boarders and rollerbladers need a place to do their thing. I have asked that the survey to Golden Gate residents for 1994/1995 include questions regarding the need for a skate board park. I am forwarding your letter to Mr. Tom 011iff our Public Services Administrator. I will seek his input on your suggestions. Thank you for your ideas and I especially thank you for wanting to become involved in improving leisure activities for our young people. If I can provide information or assistance in the future, please call me. Very trul `'. yours, \ _`� ettye J./ Matthews, Vice Chairman Commission r, District 5 BJM:cfd cc: Administrator Tom W. 011iff Public Services Division R_` I LU 1 41994 g l LIP,1 i I' 'S° F I S 1 s Kevin Litt 1670 Oaks Blvd . Naples , FL 33999 September 22 , 1994 ( 813 ) 598-9666 Commissioner Matthews , I 'm an 18 year old Eagle Scout , a voter , and am currently enrolled at Edison Community Collage . I am writing because I am concerned about the problem of skate boarders and rollerbladers . They get in trouble for jumping off stairs and sliding on walls . Understandably they cause a problem for businesses and they deface buildings . As of now if a person is seen involved in these activities the police are called or the teens get yelled at by business owners . First this is a waste of time for the police and the yelling only causes bad feelings between the owner and the teen . To solve this problem I would like to propose that a part of a park be set aside for teens to skate in . I understand that the county doesn 't have billions of dollars to spend on building a park of this nature , but please keep in mind that the bigger and the better this place is the more people will go there instead of going to the streets . I- ideas are needed for the out line of a park you may contact me and I will do my best to get some ideas to you . The building of this facility will not only keep more kids from bothering the businesses of Collier County , but also will give the y police less work and will make all of the above persons happ 'er . Thank you for your time . Kevin Litt r 1 C /V-i ( IMPORTANT MESSAGE FOR DATE i;; ; TIME/2:i1D en, TA B gok SAJ aer M Kam,- 4- OF c (jVCV.- '' ''"C) *r �0>1 PHONE J ?M 60"' ` �1 AREA CODE NUMBER EXTENSION CI FAX ❑ MOBILE AREA CODE NUMBER TIME TO CALL 1 , rize2f-te\64-Lo ,^ l''- -- TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL'/ ' CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CAUL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH 1M • b n ?7/2_6:1 +. RETURNED YOUR CALL I WILL FAX TO YOU 70 MESSAGE . r.... _ at,--- ...:4 f SIGNEDP� J TOPS 9 FORM 4009 LITHO IN U.S.A.4 f--)6) r'........-3 c-C-f-%- . g '''. , f 7 ,__._-?-, - e. k...". I -p cE- )..3, ,„\L )?:\ t_.., , ; 0 cam: r, ci.- . P T A r or. 4\ IN ..1k, r- ...., • c2. 5 W ' \' C ? ('''- . `2 - � U SHOWALTER Landscaping & Irrigation, Inc. 7399 MILL POND CIRCLE E. ` e NAPLES, FL 33942 ti•• bp; 4% (813) 598-4475 L:4 "ts<. 5/1/94 Mr . Tom 011iff Assistant to the County Manager County Manager 's Office 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, Fl 33962 Dear Mr . 011iff : With almost all of the vacant lots gone along the beach, there is no place for Hobie owners to get their boats to the beach, let alone store them. What would be the feasibility of the County providing a launch and storage site on Lely - Barefoot Beach? • A launch and storage site would offer many advantages to ' everyone. Namely, security, access, no problem with condo or property owners and provide a boating facility for Hobie • owners . All that would be required would be an access to back a trailer up to the beach to launch our boats and a place to store them. We don't need an expensive boat ramp or other facility because we never had one before. �`°• If this is possible, I would be willing to work along with you to accomplish this goal . Sincerely, ,�i� 54� �..�� Y?L r Post-d''routing request pad 7664 G1 BRAND SIDNEY H. SHOWALTER ROUTING - REQUEST Please I READ To 4_--? I I HANDLE I I APPROVE _ - / I FORWARD - `« '/' / I I RETURN I I KEEP OR DISCARD ' /,/J . I I REVIEW WITH ME Date From • s .SHOWALTER Landscaping & Irrigation, Inc. 7399 MILL POND CIRCLE E. { `-$0 NAPLES,FL 33942 1• (813) 598-4475 -4 liklirt:\ 5/1/94 ►_. _ Mr . Tom 011iff Assistant to the County Manager County Manager 's Office 3301 E. Tamiami Trail Naples, Fl 33962 Dear Mr . 0111ff: With almost all of the vacant lots gone along the beach, there is no place for Roble owners to get their boats to the beach, let alone store them. What would be the feasibility of the County providing a launch and storage site on Lely Barefoot Beach? • • A launch and storage site would offer many advantages to everyone. Namely, security, access, no problem with coado ... or property owners and provide a boating facility for Bobby owners . All that would be required would be an access to back a trailer up to the beach to launch our boats and a E: place to store them. We don't need an expensive boat ramp or other facility because we never had one before. If this is possible, I would be willing to work along with you to accomplish this goal. -127 Sincerely, SIDNEY B. SHOWALTER MAY 3 ;.3- • -• -"f ; ►►#161 `t f2s,o.'s) M E M O R A N D U M TO: Steve Brinkman, Parks and Recreation ector FROM: Sue Filson, Administrative Assista Board of County Commissioners RE: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board DATE: November 14, 1994 As you know, we currently have 3 vacancies on the above-referenced advisory committee. A press release was issued requesting citizens interested- in serving on this committee to submit a resume for consideration. I have attached the resumes received for your review - and recommendation as follows: Diane M. Jacob 431 Palm Court_ . Naples, FL 33963 Kimberly A. Kushman 900 8th Avenue S, #306 Naples, FL 33940 Leonard P. Reina , 316 3rd Avenue N �� Naples, FL 33940 } rn Robert R. Hildreth te' u 2376 Pine Wood Circle r ` Naples, FL 33942 CD James A. Davis - - _= 119 Wickliffe Drive • • Naples, FL 33942 T; _ • Joseph D. Zaks 4841 Shearwater Lane 74: Naples, FL 33999 Please let me know, in writing, the recommendation of the advisory committee for appointment and I will prepare an executive summary for the Board's consideration.. Please categorize the applicants in areas of expertise. If you have any questions, please call me at 774-8097. Thank you for your attention to this matter_` SF Attachments P.S. I am also attaching a copy of Resolution No. 94-136 establishing guidelines for receiving recommendations for appointment of members to advisory committees and Quasi-iudicial boards. , Diane M. Jacob 431 Palm Count RECEIVED NapLes, FL 33963 813-S66-1887 NOV 1 4 Board of County Commission^r; November 10, 1994 Collier County Board of Commissioners Attn: Sue Filson - 3301 E Tamiami Tr-Bldg F Naples,FL 33962 - Re: Parks&Recreation Advisory Board Dear Sue: It is my understanding that there are openings on the above referenced advisory board on M . which I have an interest in serving.Enclosed is my resume which outlines my professional -4,- and volunteer work history since I moved to Naples in October;I.988. ..__ Because of my involvement with tennis and boating,I have some familiarity with most of Collier County's recreational des. As the county's population grows,the demand on these facilities will become greater and I would consider it both a challenge and a privilege to be involved in the planning process. Thank you for your consideration of my application. Should you need additional information, you may contact me at 597-4353 during business hours. may, 2.??. Diane M. Jaco Diane M. Jacob 431 Palm Coact Naples, FL 33963 813-S66-1887 11/10/94 Employment History . - 7/1/94-Present Administrative Assistant, Charisma Chapel,Naples Duties include those of personal secretary to the Pastor as well as coordinator for all church activities; editing and publishing a monthly newsletter, etc. • • } 9/1/82-6/30/94 Executive Director,American Subcontractors Association of Collier County,Naples Duties included coordinating a monthly membership dinner meeting; new member recruitment;production of a monthly .• newsletter,and providing a variety of member services. • 4/1/89-5/31/92 Secretary,Naples Church of God Naples Duties included those of personal secretary to the Pastor,all �. bookkeeping including accounts payable, payroll, and weekly deposit of offering and keeping record of individual giving; production of a weekly bulletin;etc. Volunteer Activities 1/1/91 -8/31/94 Collier County Women's Tennis Association Served in various positions on Board of Directors of this 600- member organization which provides league tennis on public and private courts on a year-round basis. Duties included team • assignments for each 7-week league;quarterly newsletter production;organization of 2 one-day tennis/lunch events per year_ I/1/93-present Vanderbilt Beach Property Owners Association Serving as a director on the board;duties include attending monthly board meeting to review community issues and concerns; production of a monthly newsletter,helping coordinate a monthly membership meeting maintenance of membership records, etc. Persona[ Married, no children, Age 45, excellent health Page 1 of 2 • • • r Diane M. Jacob • References Andrew DeLong,Pastor run Patrick Kobza,Esq. Charisma Chapel Treiser,Kobza&Volpe 621 Ridge Drive •x,;4001 Tamiami Tr N-#330 Naples,FL 33963 -Naples,FL 33940 597-4353 649-4900 • • • pM - .!i.. • • .r."•�_ '�..x c'Pr ¢ -6 ..';:'^ -.a , • Page 2 of 2 • RECEIVED an Barnett Bank of Naples NOV 1 4 14c4 796 Fifth Avenue South Post Office Box 413008 ;,-,art .c'+,n:1 Co mis:ier-rs Naples, Florida 33941-3008 813/263-1303 Kimberly A. Kushman Fax 813/263-5544 Assistant Vice President Commercial Lending Group • November 8, 1994 Ms. Sue Filson Administrative Assistant Board of County Commissioners 3301 U.S. 41 East Naples, FL 33962 • Dear Ms. Filson: Enclosed please find my resume for consideration by the Board of County ommissioners for appointment to the Parks and Recreation Advisory lard My background in the financial services industry for the past ten years well qualifies me to make a significant contribution to the Board. In addition to the business background, I have actively participated in a • variety of community organizations, which have offered excellent experience for this position. Lastly, I am a twenty-one year resident of Collier County and have actively used the many services the parks and recreation system provides, during that time. Thank you for this opportunity to serve the community. If you should have any questions, please contact me at 263-1303. - Sincerely, BARNETT BANK OF NAPLES Kimberly A. Kushman Assistant Vice President • • RESUME •• Kimberly A. Bushman November 8, 1994 EDUCATION Stetson University, Deland, Florida; B.B.A. Degree in Finance, May 1984. Naples High School, Graduation: June 1980. EXPERIENCE Assistant Vice President, Barnett Bank of Naples, Naples, Florida. Generating new commercial real estate banking relationships, as well as the maintenance and expansion of existing banking accounts. Total loan closings during the initial ten months of 1994 total $45 million. Managing a commercial real estate loan portfolio of $25 million. (March 1993-Present) _ Assistant Vice President, Sun Bank of Lee County, N.A. , Fort Myers, Florida. Servicing the financial needs of the Bank's private banking clientele and management of an $11 million commercial loan portfolio. Emphasis on business brokerage referrals and deposit generation. Production during the year exceeded 100% of established goals. The private banking department was housed with the trust department, l creating an excellent referral network. (December 1991-March 1993) Assistant Vice President, Southeast Bank. N.A. , Naples, ° Florida. Managing commercial loan portfolio of $8 million_ Emphasis on business development in the areas of small business lending, the professional market, coordination of municipality bids and SBA financing. Acting cash management coordinator for Collier County. Experience in letters of credit. _ (October 1986-'December 1991) Credit Analyst, Southeast Bank, N.A. Naples, Florida. Analyst for Lee and Collier Counties analyzing a variety of businesses engaged in occupations including real estate development, retail furniture, restaurants, and medical facilities. Managed commercial loan _ - g portfolio and assisted in disbursements for real estate construction loans. (May 1985-October 1986) Corporate Credit Trainina Program, Southeast Bank, N.A. Miami, Florida. Training program to develop analytical skills through extensive post-college classroom work in finance and accounting. Further emphasis on case-studies selected from Southeast's current portfolio of diverse industries and loan facilities. (September 1984-May 1985) • , • Resume of Kimberly A. Kushman November 8, 1994 PAST AND PRESENT COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT Youth Haven, Inc. - volunteer/member Friends of the Philharmonic - volunteer/member Coral Arts Society - member Women's Political Caucus - member Naples Society of Poets - member Naples Area Chamber of Commerce - Disaster Recovery Committee member •f Economic Development Council - Community Affairs Committee member Project Business Consultant, Junior Achievement. Three semesters of classroom instruction to eighth grade students teaching the fundamentals of business. • Naples Central Rotary Club - Member; served on Board of Directors Collier County Historical Society - Member; served on Board of Directors Collier County Fine Arts Society - member; served on r, Associate Board of Directors REACTS Excellent health; regular exercise program; health and nutrition-oriented food plan; lifetime non-smoker. CONTACT LOCATIONS =Kimberly A_ Kushman 900 Eighth Avenue South, #306 Naples, FL 33940 Business phone: (813) 263-1303 Home phone: (813) 261-2174 Leonard P. Reina, P.A. Attorney at Law November 7, 1994 Ms. Sue Filson _ Administrative Assistant Board of County Commissioners Collier County Courthouse 3301 Tamiami Trail E. Naples, FL 33962 Re: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Dear Ms. Filson: Please accept this as my application for appointment to fill the vacancy on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board to represent the Naples urban area. Enclosed please find my Resume. I am a resident and registered voter_in Collier County and currently reside and conduct my law practice within the city limits. I have a strong interest in seeing Naples and Collier County remain a beautiful place in }r. which to live and work, as well as to visit, and I believe that parks and recreational facilities are essential to accomplish that objective_ Most great urban areas have one or more parks of world renown, such as Central Park in New York. I would appreciate being considered for this appointment and would be happy to furnish any additional information that you may need. Sincerely, ,t Leonard . Reinalti LPR:bh v-e Enclosure.. ,3/(y 31-1 " 33SVo RECEIVED NOV — 8 1994 c::- .GlJflL, 'I7V ISS 500 5th Avenue South • Suite 502 • Naples, Florida 33940 • 813/263-2059 • Fax: 263-2069 LEONARD P. REINA LEONARD P. REINA, P.A. 500 Fifth Avenue S. , Suite 502 Naples, Florida 33940 (813) 263-2059 PERSONAL DATA: Age : 43 Wife: Andrea Clark Brown, Architect Health: Excellent EDUCATION: Doctor of Jurisprudence, (1980) South Texas College of Law. Master of Science in Management, (1976) FL International U. Bachelor of Science, (1973) Florida State University. ;* LICENSES AND CERTIFICATIONS: State Certified Mediator (1991) State Certified Arbitrator (1990) Certified Hearing Officer/Special Master (1993) Federal Bar, Middle District of Florida (1989) Florida Bar No. 325716 (1981) Texas Bar No 16754600 (1980) Florida Real Estate Broker No. 0130282 (1976) PRACTICE OF LAW: Jv Areas of Practice: Civil & Criminal Litigation, Real Estate/Business/Contract Law (5/1/94 to Present) Leonard P. Reina, P.A. At, (1992 - 6/1/94) - Shareholder, Forsyth, Brugger, Reina (1990-1991) - Shareholder, Forsyth, Swaim & Brugger (1986-89) - Associate, Forsyth, Swalm & Brugger (1980-86) - Sole practitioner, Houston, Texas RELATED EXPERIENCES: Adjunct Professor, Edison Community College and International College, Naples, FL Florida Real Estate Broker � ; `MEMBERSHIPS AND AFFILIATIONS: Florida Bar - Member Florida Trial Lawyers Assoc. Federal Bar Texas Bar American Bar American Mediation Association Collier County Bar: Director - 1992-95 Chairman, Library Committee Member Trial & Real Estate Sec. Naples Area Board of Realtors,' Affiliate Member American Subcontractors Association: Member Government Affairs Committee Women' s Political Caucus Humane Society ( one - o _ tili= _, ommis-sioners IóO r ly -rho serve .on advisor . . ., :� -- Daily News Staff. . Six county i i . Collier County =are: - 11i VOIl1 _ i in: - lobbing for volunteers to serve on six ad= -1 ,p .visary committees .that have,_or 'will voter in.rx • f9 "soon have,vacancies. - :'-_ • -- • - • e The Black Affairs-Advisory - :interest ShC •B Commit ...10.3•,-7,---- the Golden Gate Parkway Beautifi- . :cation;Advisory-Committee;the.Lilirary :tween minority..f - .:Advisory Board, tfie-Citizens-Advisory commzssion-• • :.Task.:Force, the Golden'Gate Comma- . The Golden=G ,t _-:mty Center Advisory Committee and the cation Advisory C inn` . Parks':and Recreation Advisory Board cancy,which.rep] - . all have open seats. : •• - -- _. 623.The five-men e So `- . Volunteers-must be residents-and 'the ° � coin] c. 4 : registered voters in Collier:County. Re- pertainingto the _ mimes and letters of interest.`should be to Pe Gok 'mailed by Nov 12'to Sue FiLson,admen • tweea Santa Be de- assistant to the county commis- ' County Road 95L _ . sign,3301 U.S.41 E.,Naples,33962.. .. The Library A • The Black Affairs Advisory Commit- terms espning on r't tee has three vacancies due to resigns- ing county commi ilions. Two of the terms will expire in This fivemembe June, 1995 and one term will expire in qty commissiq June,1997.The nine-member committee budget of the 0 *Ins 'identifies and evaluates problems unique System 4 N to Collier County's African-American The atizens - tion and reviews and recommends has two terms exx - .¢ - _ ys to ensure open communication be- is_available for a z <_ • . `` • RECEIVED HILDRETH 2376 Pine Wood Circle OCT 2 0 1934 Naples,FL 33942 C1/3.) Z- dInfor County CO issloners Lf/3%?i 2Y ADV/SO21r 02 19/Ig/CC 2GC2e5 ilo/1/ (REVISED 8-24-03? $ACKGRO[JND INFORMATION - BOB HILDRETH BORN: MINNEAPOLIS. MINNESOTA. rDUCATION: UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI . CORAL GABLES. FL. B.A. DEGREE. COMMUNICATIONS. 1954. j1ILITflRY: 3-1/2 YEARS U.S. NAVY. PACIFIC DUTY. CCU: 12 YEARS. RADIO. TV. AND NEWSPAPER POSITIONS, FOLLOWED BY: • 1957-1987 - SR. V.P. MARKETING. CORAL GABLES FEDERAL SAVINGS. ASSETS OM DATE OF RETIREMENT 2.5 BILLION. AWARDS- HONORS: CORAL GABLES CHAMBER OF COMMERCE - "ROBERT B. KNIGHT OUTSTANDING CITIZEN AWARD." 1982 OMICRON DELTA KAPPA. NATIONAL HONORARY SOCIETY. TAPPED APRIL 5. 1987. IRON ARROW HONOR SOCIETY - UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI , TAPPED 1990 . PRESIDENT CORAL GABLES - CARTEGENA. COLUMBIA. SISrrk CITY AFFILIATION. RECEIVED READERS DIGEST "BEST OVERALL PROGRAM AWARD.' 1966 - 1967 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTERS "BIG MIKE AWARD 1970. BEST 30 SECOND RADIO COMMERCIAL 'SOCIAL SECURITY" (JACK BENNY - BOB HILDRETH) HIGHEST CONSUMER RECOGNITION FOR "CHARLIE" TELEVISION COMMERCIALS 1974 • BACKGROUND. BOB HILDRETH. PAGE 2 OFFICES HELD: CURRENT. CORAL GABLES CITY COMMISSIONER—VICE MAYOR 1983 — 1993. DIRECTOR. FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS MARKETING ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA. 1970 — 1972. TRUSTEE. DOCTORS' HOSPITAL_ 1971 — 78. DIRECTOR, MIAMI CHAPTER NATIONAL ACADEMY OF TELEVISION ARTS AND SCIENCES. 1978 — 1979. • FOUNDING CHAIRMAN. CORAL GABLES COMMITTEE OF 21 . 1964-65. PRESIDENT AND DIRECTOR_ CORAL GABLES CHAMBER OF COMMERCE. 1963-64. PAST PRESIDENT AND 30 YEAR—MEMBER CORAL GABLES ROTARY CLUB. r PRESIDENT. CORAL GABLES WAR MEMORIAL YOUTH CENTER 1979-81 . PRESIDENT. SOUTH FLORIDA F.I.M.A_ CHAPTER NO. 2. 1973-74 • CHAIRMAN. GRANGER BOWL INTERNATIONAL JUNIOR INVITATIONAL JUNIOR GOLF • CHAMPIONSHIP. 1967 — 71. ri. - CHAIRMAN. FLORIDA SAVINGS AND LOAN MARKETING COMMI'rrrr:. 197S-78_ TREASURER. SOUTH FLORIDA COMMITTEE FOR U.S. PROJECT HOPE. 1966-67. DIRECTOR. mg. BROTHERS OF GREATER ¢ � MIAMI . 1970-71 . _ n / - ( BACKGROUND. BOB HILDRETH. PAGE 3 MEMBERSHIPS: CURS RENT ORANGE BOWL COMMITTEE. MEMBER SINCE 1972. UNIVERSITY OF MIAMI HURRICANE CLUB. (COACHES CLUB) MIAMI TOUCHDOWN CLUB. PAST DIRECTOR. CORAL GABLES SISTER CITY PROGRAM. ,x FORMER: ALPHA DELTA SIGMA ADVERTISING FRATERNITY_ w ' HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION OF SOUTH • • FLORIDA. rr FLORIDA COUNCIL OF INTERNATIONAL c VISITORS. -.F., .-: DOCTORS' HOSPITAL JOHN T. MACDONALD `: : ,. . FOUNDATION a, ADVERTISING FEDERATION OF GREATER �.�. MIAMI. NATIONAL ACADEMY OF TELEVISION ARTS AND SCIENCES. - - PERSONAL: RESIDENT OF CORAL GABLES _ 1950-1161f 4' ' ,."`""""'"i"'''' '. : - MARRIED TO ISABELLE-MARTIN HILDRETH SINCE 1952. THREE SONS, ROBERT III. CHRISTOPHER AND CARSON. - 30 • COASTAL RECEIVED ENGINEERING RE .. CONSULTANTS act I $ 199k INC. _ �• r, of Count/ CC isSioner5 Engineers • Scientists • Surveyors • Planners • Appraisers October 17, 1994 Mrs. Sue Filson Administrative Assistant Collier County.Govemment Center 3301 Tamiami Trail, East Building "F" Naples, FL 33962 •- RE: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board • Dear Mrs. Filson: • This fetter is in response to the vacancy on the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. I reside in Willoughby Acres which is located in District 5, and am licensed as an engineer in the State of Florida As a resident of Collier County since 1984, and as a parent of two boys, ages 5 and 9, 1 am very interested in the future park and recreation needs of the County. Having worked with Collier and Lee Counties on numerous municipal park projects, I can bring both knowledge and professional experience to the Parks and Recreation Board. Attached please find my resume. If you have any questions or need additional information, I can be reached at 643-2324 during business hours, or after hours at my home phone, 597-9281. Very IN _.. - COASTAL 1 EKING C SULTANTS, INC. James . avis, P.E soaate neer Residence - 119 Wickliffe Drive Naples, FL 33942 Attachment - Resume OV' S. HORSESHOE DR. • NAPLES. FLORIDA 33942 • (813)643-2324 • =AX(813)643-1143 • JAMES A. DAVIS, P.E. Exoerience 1991 - Present Mr. Davis is head of the Civil Engineering Division at Coastal Engineering Consultants,Inc.with responsibility for land planning,rezoning and site engineering of planned unit developments,including commercial development,multi-family and single family residential projects. He has successfully negotiated and administered - . municipal contracts for the development of environmentally sensitive coastal and river front projects. 1986 - 1991 As an Associate Engineer with Coastal Engineering Consultants,Inc.,Mr. Davis was responsible for writing proposals, site planning, site design and engineering of utilities (using the Kentucky Pipe Program for water distribution and manifolded pump stations,roads.parking lots,drainage,and water management facilities),and design and permitting of projects requiring mitigation of ACOE jurisdictional wetlands. He was responsible for writing project specifications and contract documents, project construction scheduling and project management. 1985 - 1986 Mr.Davis,while with the Nielson Company,worked in highway and heavy industrial contracting, specifically in project estimating and management as related to the following types of projects: State and Federal highways, power plants, and wastewater treatment plants. Mr. Davis is experienced in calculating mass diagrams including free haul and overhaul. Additional experience includes the ,{ following:highway geometric design,traffic operations including progressive traffic \ signal timing, trip generation including linear regression and the gravity mode. • Mr. Davis is knowledgeable in the area of computer programming. His computer background also involves working with the following software:Autocad,Timberland Accubid Gob estimating software) and Earthwork (Quantity take-off software) and various surface water management programs. 1984-1985 Mr. Davis, working for Coastal Engineering Consultants, Inc., was involved in the design and management of civil projects in Southwest Florida, including the site development of the Marco Beach Hilton on Marco Island, Windstar and Crown Point West in Naples. Educatfotf _B.S.Civil Engineering (Chi Epsilon) Colorado State University, Colorado, December, 1983 • Professional Reaistration Engineering in Training - State of Colorado #12099, December, 1983 Professional Engineer-State of Florida #40090,August. 1988 Professional Affiliations American Society of Civil Engineers -Officer from 1988 - 1993 KELLY, PRICE, SIKET & HEUERMAN CHARTERED PAUL K.IIEUER\IAN CHARLES.I. KELLY.JR. ATTORNEYS AT LAW TELEPHONE sOARO conviED TAX UwrER BOARD CERTIFIED w'µ15. (813)261-3453 TRUSTS ANO MASTERS OF N ESTATE PLANNING GREY OAKS BUILDING R. SCOTT PRICE IN POINCIANA PROFESSIONAL PARK DONALD K. ROSS.JR. TELECOPIE R 2640 GOLDEN GATE PARKWAY MASTERS OF LAW IN TAXATION SI11TE 3115 (813)261-5711 ANDREW G.SIKET P.O.BOX 8117 JOSEPH D. /_MKS M NAPLES,FLORIDA 33941-8117 • ASTERS OF LAW TAXATION _,LSO,D •TTED IN October 10, 1994 OHIO 1•ALSO ADMITTED IN MAINE AA ALSO ADMITTED IN MASSACHUSETTS •• Ms. Sue Filson, Administrative Assistant - Board of County Commissioners • 3301 East Tamiami Trail - Naples, FL• • 33962-4977 Re: Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Dear Ms. Filson: I am writing in response to your letter dated October 7, 1994, advising me that my term on the above-referenced advisory committee will expire on December 31, 1994. Please consider this letter as my notice that I am interested in continuing as a member of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. As such, I have enclosed a current copy of my- resume- Please make certain that. I am considered for reappointment to this board. • V- truly yours, I - ose. ' . - JDZ/sa Enclosure cc: Steve Brinkman, Parks and Recreation Director c1iba..1< JOSEPH D. ZAKS 4841 Shearwater Lane Longshore Lake Naples, Florida 33999 (813) 592-5140 EMPLOYMENT: Kelly, Price, Siket & Heuerman Naples, Florida Partner-The balance of the partners working for Porter, Wright,Morris and Arthur left that firm in mid-March and joined my partner&me to form the current firm. There are six lawyers and twelve staff. The firm is a general practice law firm practicing in all virtually all areas of law, includinr estate planning and trust and probate administration; real estate; civil litigation; corporate and business law;banking and bankruptcy and taxation. My partner and I,along with one paralegal and two secretaries, comprise the estate planning department of the firm. This department currently represents over four hundred clients. My current- practice is concentrated in the area of sophisticated estate planning; estate and trust administration;probate; tax planning and compliance. I personally represent clients with estates ranging up to thirty million dollars. I currently serve as co-editor of the Naples Estate Planning Council articles appearing biweekly in the Naples Daily News and as co-rhairewn of the annual thirty page estate planning supplement appearing in the same newspaper. March 1993 to Present Kelly & Zaks,P.A. Naples, Florida _ .• Partner-Began a two lawyer, three employee partnership with the other member of the estate planning department of Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur. This practice crecentrated in estate planning; estate and trust administration; probate and ax planning. Responsibilities include drafting and maintaining complex estate plans; as well as administering estate probate and administration of trusts. Over three hundred clients followed my partner and me from Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur, therefore the level of practice was virtually uninterrupted. • February 1993 to March 1993 Porter, Wright, Morris &Arthur Naples, Florida Associate-Concentrated in estate punning;estate and trust administrating probate and tax pig.Responsibilities included drafting and maintaining complex estate plasm as well as administering estate probate and administration of trusts. Practice included preparation of tax returns and rspreseuting clients before the Internal Revenue Service. Gave presentations at seminars on estate planning and wrote numerous articles for publication in the Naples Daily News as well as for in-house publication. November 1991 to February 1993 Kaye, Fialkow, Richmond& Rothstein Boston, Massachusetts Associate-Concentrated in estate plannia&federal and state tax;estate and trust administration;probate and corporate matters. Responsibilities included tax rewards and planning for a forty lawyer business, bankruptcy and banking law firm; drafting, implementing and maintaining hundreds of complex estate plains as well as oveiseriog estate probate and administration of testamentary and inter vivos trusts. Additional responsibilities included:planning and implementation of corporate fors, mergers, liquidations and the drafting of a wide range of business documents. Accomplishments include computerising tax planning and projections,trust administration and estate tax preparation;lecturing on tax,estate and business planning and writing articles for is-house publications. January, 1988 to July, 1991. - Joseph D. Zaks, Resume 2 Touche Ross & Company Boston, Massachusetts Tax Consultant - Concentrated in individual, corporate and partnership taxation. Responsibilities included tax research and planning for a widely diverse client base. Additional duties included tax compliance and reporting on both federal and state levels. Accomplishments included the development and implementation of a personal financial management practice for the firm. August, 1985 to January, 1988 EDUCATION: - - Boston University School of Law Boston, Massachusetts LLM., Taxation, May, 1989 J.D May, 1985 Honors: Edward F.Hennessey Scholar-top 25%of class Activities: Moot Court'Participant, Fust Year Student Advisor,Westlaw and Loris Training. University of Massachusetts, College of Management Boston, Massachusetts B.S. summa cum laude, May, 1982 - Major. Private Financia1 Management Honors: Recipient, Mary B. Newman Award for Academic Excellence; Nominated, Harry S. Truman Scholarship for Commitment to Government Service;Nominated John F.Bemmedy Award for Academic Achievement;Graduated First in Class. Activities: President,Pre-Law Society;Member, Finance and Accounting Academy; and Officer and Director, Alumni Association. BAR MEMBERSHIP: Admitted:Maw Bar, December, 1985;U.S.District Court,District of Metts, February, 1986; U.S. Supreme Court,June, 1990; Florida Bar, August, 1991;United States Tax Court,September, 1992. CIVIC ACTIVITIES• — Volunteer,Collier County Anil' ant Public Guardian Program Chdrnau.Collier County Parka and Roneat on Advisory Board; Member,Naples Estate Planning Council,Co-ee&tor-bi-wee+idy column and Co-chairman.annual supplement appearing in Naples Drily News;Member,Director Naples Kiwanis,C7haitman,Blood Drive Committee,Advisor,Bacon Collier Key Club;Member, St. John The Evangelist Building Committer Farmer Mataber, Lengthens Lake Homeowner Advisory Committee~ Director, Lnagshore Lake-Residents Association;Member,Naples Chamber of Couwhrtoe;Volunteer,Naples Special Olympics;Volunteer, Salvation Army. REFERENCES: Available upon request. issoklbods 1 • v o b o . o C• o • C < < < < y a r h n 1 )0 1 y M s n 11 aZ < ` < e w w o 0 ■ w G 11 C H 0 0 m ^ A O) 10 N N O) — n^ CO a CS Cs •id Rd • Q Q z 10 H H g•4 0 o < a. < < < d o a. < < < A. < a. < a. a. < a. a. < a. A. < < < G. < < < -9 a a .... 110 id a. d < a. a. n. a. a. < a. < a. < < <id •n v .111= O. a. a. < O. < O. A a. < O. < O. a. a. O. < O. O. O. C. a. a. O. < O. < O. < a. < a. < " a a a 7 a. a. a. a. a. < a. ""i A. < A. < A. < A. < N n A. A. A. A. A. A. A. / A. < A. < O. O. < < r w >4 ag < A. < A. A. a. A. •0 A. < 0. < A. A. A. < < A. < C. O. < O. O. < < < A. < < < N` A. A. a. a. a. A. A. P. A. < a. < O. < O. O. • "11 O. A. 0. 0. 0. < O. 1 0. O. O. < n. < a. < W N W < O. 0. < 0. O. A. O. < O. O. < < A. < w k. < < ti ti � j Mx3 vv vJ 3x •...,v v C w 4•1 to 0 4-1 .0 0 .t at N v) ,... .7 4' 4' 4" .7 47 .7 N N 0 .7 .o N .t .7 a In L/) - 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ) ' 0 in a .t .O .t ■0 N .t C .t - .t .t . .t .t ■t Z 0. N ..4 to .t 0 0. O) n e) j z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I I I = .o In e•) in 1. .t .t r• r• 4-1 0- 0 P) a) el eh c%) er) n) , P. ■o Irvin in in r• 0. .n In .o P. en in In in in in � In .7 en .7 .0 r. en .O .O N V e7 Men e7 en en en p. x u m o ti • a) 0 1.4 a) 6 0 7 e0 .a d � y A � aH C 0 4-4 .-1 .0 At L+ a ) 0 . $.1 +a d a Cl) cC 1a e0 U yl •0 E • k a e0 C9 U a) a) W Pa ea V) $+ .-1 Z 1 ac y a $4 0 z tr w c� ti Z ►3 Cl) 0 Cl) • 1$1 CO 4'7 Ca e @0 • • 0 0 Wx m • JN) ,-4 • fz. .sL a0) 0 0 .4 0 4 A) Pa c) • a) tr rl > A) W a eX 0 it 0 w 4.) E 7E a3 q a) 0 0 0 aG C -4 •v e0 .0 a 4-1 •1 0 W .-1 e0 4-1 0 0 14 0 E+ 1.4 0 $4 0 •41 a) E .0 Z CO = ?4 'a4 Z P. N Cl) co CO W #•7 Z P. En E-4 ON o% .l N e+) .• in .O r- .--1 N eh .7 in ■o r` co \\ ( 11 ESTIMATED REVENUE AT PELICAN BAY COMMUNITY PARK Option 1. Operated as other Community Parks but construct a ball dispenser to determine who is the next person to use the court. Estimated Leagues $ 2, 000 Estimated Instruction 14 . 000 $16,000 Option 2. Full Operation by Contractor Services contracted out would be: Pro Shop $10,000 Instruction 20,000 Leagues 40,000 Open Play 30,000 Tournaments 10.000 $110,000 County 10% (11.000) $ 99,000** Option 3. Limited Operation by Contractor No charge for open play/reserve 4 courts for open play Services contracted out would be: Pro Shop $10,000 Instruction 20.000 $30,000 County 1% (3001 $29,700** County - 1% from Contractor - $ 300 Leagues 2.000 $2,300 In Option 2 and 3 the leagues currently conducted and co-sponsored by the County would change. In Option 2 all County leagues played at the Pelican Bay Community Park would pay the league fees to the contractor, thereby reducing the county tennis revenue by $2,000. In Option 3 the County would continue to maintain the current leagues. In both options the public, as well as the County maintained leagues, would be limited to play time on the courts with Option 2 being the most limited. ** Contractor would be responsible for maintenance of the courts. Estimated maintenance cost is $2,500/court/year x 8 courts = $20,000. This requirement would be more difficult in a limited operation like Option 3 and would either cause our payment to be much less or continue to maintain the courts ourselves. Dr Percy Mallison, Director State Lands Div, 9/24/94 Dept. of Environmental Protection cc:Kirby Green 3900 Commonwealth Blvd. John Norris Tallahassee, FL 32399-3000 COLLIER COUNTY-MARCO IS. -SAND DOLLAR IS. On 9/12/94, we requested you to exercise your fiduciary responsibility as Head of the State Lands Division- to notify the FL. Game & Fresh Water Fish Commission that CWA 88-1 is not currently a validly approved CWA and that they should promptly remove all signage and the grass that has grown since 1988. Attached to the 9/12 memo was a copy of the 12/15/87 notification from State Lands to the Game Commission which stated "--for this nesting season-" Clearly the Trustees authorized 1988 only. On 1 /15/88 Robt . Brantley, Game Commission issued his statement similar to the 12/15/87 memo, but with quite different verbage on the valid period for the CWA. We have found no legal basis for the Col . Brantley statement . Most importantly the Game Commission continues their signage. We believe that this difference is very important and must be settled. The resolution of this difference is very important to our current beach management plans. Do you believe that an administrative review process will be the necessary forum- or do you propose that we resolve this dispute in some other manner? Please respond promptly. Sincerely, 7 F. .Blanchard South Seas Condominiums 380 Seaview Ct. , Apt. 609 Marco Island, FL 33937 (813) 394-9587 FAX (813) 394-7224 _ DUO M Ail 1 11`∎r_c_ t"�Rt,yf Governor State of Florida JIM eta SMITH • Secretary of State ��•� DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES BOBBUTTERR'ORTH 'Attorney General At RV ° GERALD LEWIS Marjory Stoneman Duugla> Building; State Comptroller 3900 Commonwealth Boulevard BILL GUNTER _ Tallahassee. Florida 32399 State Treasurer TOM GARDNER DOYLE CONNER Executive Director Commissioner of Agriculture STATE OF FLORIDA • BETTY CASTOR C O U N T Y OF L E O N Commissioner of Education C E R T I F I C A T E PLEASE ADDRESS REPLY TO: I, Judy A. Brooks, do hereby certify that the Governor and Cabinet, sitting as the Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust Fund, met on December 15, • 1987 and approved the following Item 28 on the agenda for that date. Item 28 REQUEST: Approval for the Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission to post two sandbar/mangrove islands to prevent trespass during this year's bird nesting season. COUNTY/LOCATION: Statewide APPLICANT: Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission and the Division of State Lands CONSIDERATION: N/A STAFF REMARKS: The Florida Game and Fresh Water Fish Commission (GFWFC) is charged with the responsibility to post critical wildlife areas to minimize the adverse impact on wildlife due to man-caused disturbance or destruction. The areas are identified by GFWFC field biologists and a recommendation is made to the GFWFC to initiate rule making in order to manage public access during specific times of the year. Approval of the property owner (Trustees) is necessary for areas such as spoil islands, sandbars , mangrove islands, etc. , to be posted. Once approval is granted,.. the GFWFC staff must notify local governments, and go through rule making procedures (Rule 39-14, Florida Administrative Code) prior to seasonally posting the area in order to afford protection. The first area is a small mangrove island in the Myakka River: The island is a valuable rookery. The other area is a small , sandy island in Big Marco Pass which is also used by nesting birds. RECOMMEND APPROVAL IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of the Board of Trustees of the Internal Improvement Trust Fund this 15th day of December, A.D. 1987. a/4-7 /Q- J A..Br ks , Administrative Assist. D y ision of State Lands SEAL Department of Natural Resources "Working together to protect Florida's future" • y 1.• (. •l • '. .. .,.r ''EAa 8tv. •448 [ .:yi 4.v� E,r. �3 r"7414 t c � • 1,• .}• # 'r.. ° Ta •' + l 'l. �•V' \ fit.' l t • i C g 3 .4 • '4 o • • a • .• c A 4•4 C A P A £c F- A � Do w 1 O u St b m O ^ u D N ytNI ~ N C • ` LO • 'lii .a O L+tu p 0. S ON C x M ( 411.hr- el 4 1-4 Itt - — 4 H - r1 a8 V C W t..) +, ,.►dd • y w to 10 N C4 CI >I •G „• m a *41 ma U gF•{ u- + A O rC • A W* t► .d SC 4. P. C C m ea. Hh • i ~ O t I�r D s .0 u O � C p 1O ii. Si .0 0 .pC !m • % .'1 F c 4A• 0 I ' ! i 5M 0 EsOm fi ell .5 . N Ji S w k a d $ $.0 9 D .N 4 g t a . .oy 0 St 04 11 w C - �'— — a -w a.4.03 . .! w 8 - M . CO 44 • 0 4.• 4, [ 8 V N t i r T a� b I a W; w ai4O o .a to • 0 4 m b t!M C to te b v 4` O b em ue 0"' o S. a R a O w dy0\a u n d � A d y 4 y O S .0 ' R O N « ' m O u A y « Pd $ 0 L0O0 .. .4 C to 00 • 04 44 0 „ v. eel i t. A .a � a U p w ., a w W 0 .0 .4 i 3 , W 9 • • • • • . t'4 # 1. l k •-, '- v.,.fir, Ai , t' 1. k r t • • GAME PLAN RE : CWA/GOV - /CABS NET 1_ Preparing a 20-30 minute flip-chart presentation for Cabinet Aides 2 Letters of support from all beachfront properties in one bundle M. Mongiello T 2 is preparing. 3 Collier County Parks & Recreation Adv. Board 10/26/94 2 pm 4 John Norris- week of 10/24 Advice re Environmental Adv. Board Advice re Board of County Commissioners support CHART C '1 ) 1 988 Photo of Sand Dot 1 ar = s _ from Comments: No beach south of Tigertail County Park 1988 Taxable base of beachfront group-only= $680, 000, 000 Considerable debate was held over the question: 1- Should Sand Dollar Is. be maintained as an island, or 2- Should the intervening space be filled in. Sec. of State Jim Smith helped bridge the dispute by the insertion of Stipulation (9) wherein a channel between Sand Dollar Is . and the mainland be maintained . The DER refused to issue such a permit. We asked for a permit to fill in the lagoon and were denied. We have sought a compromise and have not found one. _ 2 -1311.'"472-‘'' -- _ y s sic f• .i 4 - -- yam — _ - _ _-sue.. r + #1 j - �`- _-- - ', I -= ,-s4_-, _ , '1f t{.., ,„, ..r �r t 1,... s , # +� , , i 1- " -*" i _,-__ __vitt,' -"'-'11-,01::-_,t.:_-1--_,- li mot" ; 1 _ _;:___,___ = J _,._ ,_.,...„ ,,_ _,...,.. . - -,,,,.-. -_-\,- . . ___: vi . _ _,. _ __ 3 . t ' . :-si ..- — JI -' -rix__-7'a #y li:N-_,s s ___- ,,:.. -_, „ . T _ _ ,..."-- -_-_Jr-e' ' --'.\II' ,'"" ;44; v .J r 10*-.' '- — •it Nc . ' • s s \\\ 4. , -- - ,fit ".- 1--t r E � _ - CHART C 1 9 9 4 PYio t o o if S arzd Do 1 1 a r I s f ro• i Comments : 1994 Taxable value of beachfront only $877, 000, 000 South Seas Club only $159,000, 000 ..1 ' .7,014, of, ' •ii ''1 , , ...., /7/ .1 g I I*V - • . ... • A 4 , iffiftrii„fl „, .. ..., -, , , „:„ , • ,, .! „, ,, , , . ..,..„ . . , e A , .,. '................ * ) / e , , . ' 4'-.L' li • 4.. ; 4", i . * e''''' ; \I, , '• , # , " *f e i.Ai ,.-,. , .: .:: 3 .N , _. . .., A, • • I l. 4.';' - * - ,:•• '* ? I ,f;••."-*.i' 14g ":"7• :\ 7:.....•,-4.: i : , - , : ,7,- . i • ti:- , . .- - -... . / ''.• r` ) 1 7 1 .,1., ' : -' i , ' 1 i•-,-'-,‘ 1. .' '-., - 1,„:...--„1:.'-i '. ,, ,,, i ; • ‘,1,' ' il ik- .,.-:, - ,, :': • r„- ," - .4:44 , ;"—.,.ii : i .', , • ,, 4:it t , ••-7:444:- . . i.:t ... . . •. IFiritriti64 '. - fil';itil ., 1-: • -P.FAP $6: A-,.i.•;-,, • ',. .•-•' • i : , 7 ' /•''''- • ''' 1''•'' ' ' ' :: 1• • ' ti:b 1.- ' f* ;''r4/- ' 1•••,. .7' •"! t' 4) illii „...: w.. , -t... "••' ,J.,- - •'.. : 'L.. - t., ' ; ,k,f:-.-'.7-.1 1 i').' -It/•e .- . I tt p,i . • :-..:1•• 1.,.',,,.. L'i ;, '.,,- . ., t . - 1 ',.4.----14 . 'f. , ,`: . ,; i .:1,....,i-?;,..-,-0.- '',..;: ",...‘.1.1.,s:' .--„I.''IL':Li- • '1 --.H ,- it' ' '- • .1.'1114 ,,*„1 ..I•11/4.- '1,-. .,..,..5,,r,,,i - / ..w• er vir- t. •• ", 1 ' / r l'• . I ',--;;•••••,'L:i,r-• - ',_''•.'. -, ; , • ''•‘/‘ 4."-•••31i. i ,‘ • . • `''• s1/2 r .,,,,,,, ..,t. .. . '4 '• 4, , ' f . ..-,,-:•:".•."-X.:.:'-- I:' ' ,- : t. : :! to Tri 1• . , . . . _ 1 i I . ,‘. . . . . - P , ,;• it/,rifir,,,,./,02 Alt-• :.,,„...., .. ,: :)...- ,1 ':,::-.7,e,L1:',',..--...,. -4-1,..• •:-... ,. ir. . i ! , -5. P-7.#;.1 `'''','•:,-.:1-!•1"'7::-I'.: '!'h• • •' t''.' ' ! 1":•",1•A '1'' 1 - ' : : , .., . . , ..I.-I:'',:': f5r4.''" 4' , , ',........ . . , ,..,_... .: :„, _. .. ,..,.: „ : 4,4z it_ AN- .... ,.. . _. ,(..dk . , .1, r.":.t.-;.,',1- .. .. 4--.AI ._ _ , „ , .. .''l. , _ i . L'--•"...a i '4'4- II .. ..„-r...--... . I.. `: ,,., - ''‘ r : . , '741 At,,,k . .. :-:.:Lly...--: 1,, - A. 1- • i „„„.,,,,,,, N.,,.:11 f'"41- . : . .. ,.....: .......: ...,....1._,. :, :1 : J ...4:4;..,141 ,..lv . ::: .„,...,., ,,A,..,.; :„ ...:1 . , ir , 1 ..' °L;1.%' --. ' . • i ! ! • .,!•i-2-!Th,-,::. - -1 ,' .. .- ... . - - - • -.,:-•:,:c ,;''' '''.'!'•'..-- '-'-i !!- -!. " . '-, 1 r'';•Ai 4.4.. t •:,.. ..2.,j! J-1 - -, . I, ,.....4:‘,::t-,.'7.•.:: I '. _•... it K.:-.44 m Pt" l. .. , • . . . . . : 1:,-,4.t " -- • \ XI' ;i:-,i'LL:;...,.1 ;• : . ,' $, . ! 14 ■%-- ,L .....„...- . ..„.,-,,, ''''''':::1'-'4.;;;.1:.1•';‘*':-,,,:,... A., - -,t1.,;.'..',..,.... ;,.. ',; , : I ‘:,,Lr=. • ,•,,, ; . ;11:ti ,, -. ,'• ,.; - . . . , • 161' -' • • ...„ ,P.til .. ' •).. . I fe..*-': 1".::',I',.':''' '1", .•-':'•-••• '.' 1$ I h -,,, .,..- -. h"-.-'7.!....0,h.....,.1 ;..•::.',.. :: f. - .h i . .:-.,...-)„,,,i•....- .:: , - .• .. - i I , I..= i &fa • :7' ... ..-- • 11 .••:':,;::1 t.1"-..: ' "--. 1.''`rs••;2.--'''..t•••• I I - •-•.•:%•:::: ';4•,..",: . 'h.-,..'.- -....-4: !,: . i h - -•:--- 117;:;7.",.-1::"."''‘'‘',./:•L;••;1,- ' : •I', - 1 7::: ,J. . ' .•',-si: i!,.•• . 74). • . .... „..4 • . , . . . iii.1...t-...{..... ;H.:I-. .., . .t. . H . ,i::, :.,, s _ ',7, ''' • "g0J ••.:':••/,i• .i:'`'',- V•-: I ' ' :h ; 1• --h•- '';''''' , $.•:4::17:.h,-.•'--h-•:". ,n4.-- "."t h:' 1, i . - I:•'--".'h , . ...•,-;... :7...".:',:4--, '„ :: - i _i...! : i. • 1)i-,1 4... .1 , .. , 14;,...-,... ..,_,,,, .,,,,,:- .: -_, i•- ,• .• ,... !..-2, - ... ,. ..,,;,..,„,!-4.-.-2., 1,..h.:.'-. •,--- . ..IL:. . ' . -. ,--..., ' ,.;.1,4- :•1•••;-.,1'•,- „'•• •'.- 1 -I 1 . ' • ,, ''...;•'-k i....::Z.,•; ;;Vii:.I:,cI,',1,.';',.-'''• ,'-'v I I '. . •f :-TA I I . . ',■• 11, •, ,, ,. • - ) -• .),,lip`..i.r••1„•,t'"kttc*'';',',.;•1"1-*',..i;•:1,,:';-k,**-•::„''''.1.J..•'. '',,-.::11 . • , '. •',1•,"-01' f' i tii• '14 •,‹.; i.. (L•fi'It.i.:44',"1-11-CiI';::::1.'.;-1:41,'"-;;,;,,-1 i,T,-.". 1.1'.:"L:1''..-- ,'Lt.-L.'''.:'.....^:4 . . ''L"t 1441.•-'.1"1 ";:t."-.',--...--•-,- . -. • • ...- ,, , , ,,.. '' Vkl ' •, ',,nr411'.. i'4"-47:441,./:::•..:1'.hh.4"i'-.4:;,--.,:::.1,'-"I-.- „.: .. ::.: -.-, ,,.1.-0,71• , • ...7'44-?..:•-414-.r.•;:•--I.,::-I.:'71--•,-:,II i•••••;•.':-•--:•7'1 -' •h-•'r: :'• • t . ...,,, '{,• . , . . . ;• .P'4.4i,::,:...'1';.; .:'1::: ..:•I.'' ...•:,.., --... ' ...'',:::'''k'::::: :Pili. \ 1 41,',',.:`:',.44;is1/4:,--:::411,..',1•':-;".''I---'': '••","--fi:'":.*-'''' t''•;:' ' :•::•` ' .. . -,.... -11 ' .7h').,:•.V h"'-' th.:':,-'*:41.•i'..Y•i4--;. th:71-••,...h-i::-.•:.-fI.7•:"--..':.-h•f--.7"-..li"--.7. . :"--.. - . 'i''''''' •-:•:':'!„,, :.'1•04LI•'7h,t;-'1•,:-•h,,:,,!: ••••,1: :: '.-":,:-:,,-:-"L'.....,....';•-...,,";:,.:1,',:-.--..:- ., -,- .. • !, ,..'..j',T,:-,74-Litg;:".0!--..1,1f. •T.:,:;',!..4...--,',-:"..J..,.:-.'',...f,,--,,-"•:_-7-',,,:;....,..:, . --. , --. k It ;-'..i,,a' ,, ,,,,,,,,‘.-44....„• lk.744''i.'''.:IL.:-.;,-4,-:',:'''L':'4.--:::::''''''''''''''''''''' . - . ' '''.-it—.''!:.ii,;,*:1114,,t1tii: l'•: ',=:-.:f.1-•...•,7;••••-'•..."-•••.;:-.--'...f.•,•,".- .:•:'*: •: : ' 7,4,1.'t,--.,:, ,,i,•.1.4.1'..c:-T-'4=:•::,4-',"."7..-,1.,.::t-,•=......,":_.:h,h."•-;,•:,-.:::.:".4,-..„,,, , ,. .: . : - . v.-.,t4.;:i4;:i.'-.::.',„,'•.':::T.:1;.Z;,:',, :•:-.f.:::.,.,,L-'"--.4,!:!$: • i : ''. -t-,' • -. :•,,'(4,rit',1;.th.t.h• "...."-. 7...",,,7.,.-_.:•7.:";.;::.t.-...: - ':••' • f'‘Ilth*V*-, ''4111;-q,,A.-fr.•-•••4!:'"-'?:"t-..)-t'L-.;";"'LkIr':"-:•:----.---''''. " .„.. ...,,t,..ri,..t..Vtit ,,,,\,,e.,-.,,,.....,....5.-.., • 4.. '-'.44,-',Plija•Vtig4lik''''''':' !,'.."..:`:',,--4-.."2.--.1..t•••-..!•. t 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 R a At :4' 21 it Vgy. it ''C tit,: ..if;..4.-...---'_,-• P-, ' ~F coiltit 'IF\144\ „%sii) . a f a as • Z f • ! a r r 1 \ - - .1 4. ft y i _ --. z - _ s f 4 - \ fit IP NO I I I I I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 i t 1 1 1 1 1 I I I I I I I I I 1n2 I 1 I I I I 1 1 1 I :1"'. .i/ f. t 91 -. -,. .. -....--- :"4„,,.. 1 f-c( -.--..-,N.,.......-., i JO , .- r. .....„,....., ....... _ „._ .:•_7......„...,......,-., :7 41 • . __ • :-1 tr--1---•.`" ---1--- " ■ . 1. , 1&„ ..• f nr•••• .1i ,i-- A.t.-3, F. P'*_. .*. • I . iiiiik: is,44,6 II\mikii.. _ . , . _ 4 4- i • i ..-_, .,..4. .44., . •,, ie. .. . I . ;Of: .* ' .1 ..,„All; • . ~ :cl 4 1*,,.... , ■ �'.T••af. fir. • • •. e I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I 1 1 1 1 CHART ( 3 ) TRUSTEE • S AP ET.ROVAL r GAME c 1%4 _ LEFT' LETTER = 1 2/ 1 5/8 7 , STATE LANDS DIV. TO FL GAME COM. Ft G1-1-1- LETTER : : 05/156 - Game Com. Ex.Dir. interpretation of 12/15/87 memo Several significant differences in wording need emphasis: TRUSTEE'S AUTHORIZATION: "--this nesting season--" GFC MEMO: "--annual nesting and entire year feeding and nesting--" The Game Commission has refused to discuss these differences On 11 /14/93, we got the Game Commission to agree that their geographic description was inadequate. We are here today to discuss their future plans . • CHART ( 4 PHOTO T I GERTA I L COUNTY P-4R K The manner in which Sand Dollar Island has been made to merge with the mainland is ruining the value of Tigertail County Park. The obvious goal of the Game Commission is to create a PASSIVE BIRD PARK . Obviously the utility of this park as a sandy bathing beach will be devastated. Tigertail used to be a prime beach park for the region of Southwest Florida. The State and County have long- range plans include the expansion of this park for park purposes . Bird watching is completely served by other areas in South west Florid whereas beach parks are few. We implore you to let a fully developed Marco Island continue to serve the TOURIST population. Florida derives a very large revenue from tourists . A bird watching park will greatly reduce this income stream. _ —- - .. IMIllr'• . ... j t - • 1 • : I • ' • i • . 1 . i •'. i"- I 4141 • AG . • s , • -.. , . r ' `.•..-:!‘;.4:, . .!•!..z; - '..--6.1.3,— 62 "%lki.• . e• , . *• Iry • •' • .... ..•,• •;+ M 7:" .-. ,t. ‘. ...- . . • • 1110* • 'goer . ... .... . `.. ■ A ' • / • . : . " .. OVA ••• ' •.4.' . e • ,i s •__,21- :• ..N, 'NIA • O. • f .: --'' , _ . r ..,•:5 :. ........—........: •-• ,,s,,,.. .. . . , . , .. . „,-,• , . :.,,,, ...4. . . - . . - .. ,t. I 1 : - . f—k, • ,. . :. , . . .• • i ..., t` , - • ... / 4 / : .. • • 4.. A.,11.1t:N ' ic. - , ....e• - . .. . -.. OP ... ! 410:4411 . ••■■ 4 p,• " s . , S' . 4." _ ....• _ . . 4101 • t - ../ tl .-. :0 • -4 a „ k. , -.i.---;<..\./..„,e.„.'. 14'; •%: It. -,dt,' ' _2-4.4C ; 1.6:s '''s." .: . I i • ti 7 . ,.• '•Oa.% .% _ • 1% ' I • 4 • • .• #0........__AI,.. . .4 4°• . cif r„4'. ‘ ai._.. . 3 , . . .. . , . . •.• ... .... . .■ , • I. ... ,'W.....,1.700.-.; . A • .• 'g ... •e. .NI. ' CI" . 14'%'.'"' .. . e. •.: ...;. .b4fr 4 • .; .. , •. r - ., ." Ai ,,t e' •- ./' -A . i , 1 _. -,.,,. ,„,......„...s. :. , . . - r* ..," .,-. .4 -rs- -• . . • .s.- 2 • \:.t" • . .,,>1;:*.ii,,,vt.11411, 1....., •• • Ik. ....: If •s. irs ', i...''— .--'...:. . N , . . ,r.p.16, • •....., , :-. -; , . ; . ..tti it !,;.- • . • , ,Ik •. l„ „,...„,sc.,:..f.r. • . : .,„• ,. .1,41."-. • ' -, • , •• • 4 \ V. ' . ?"'"-••IP ...•... '- k • --• • . 1. 'N ' 0' • • ; Pir 7 7..ii : ‘I' .. 4, - *Vi ' P • . - • **" 411 i; .'VI - • . k .1k-' - , • --I PR.W tj', • ., Nor.. ..-•••• . . ••■.1; ..0 .41.7,. 4 -1'6:- ii"."4:2 0 '4. .il.,:jiiiiiii7.• . -, , 11,77• • • i '-,.. . -4°.'"'"!‘rx-' - .Zi _ •i _ .-1.1-?1,i r.• '''' 'It..• '1141111C1<e-, 1 - .'"-ifCF-- ..-- diti• traL - ' • IP I / \* 4 Li. 11 • 41 ., . et . . 0. 0107 • 1.- -' r . ,..."X‘till 0 4.•s • - . IA°i1:4..7" '.-1. 4,;.• . • 1 ail,- • Y •off • till i , • v▪ ‘• Viii... /7. ;.:. 71,,..___,,,,z ___,... ‘ 6 isotk, -all ... ..:„.•._, ..„....ic,.....,:,_._.6.,..„ 7:•r' _,._ i.,..'`‘ ,...,.,-I "...," N --. , 1 '1 , 4.**6 s r___—.,?„.____ ,:x. its, ...v... ..4-.., --_ :,,,..7.. ,‘ ,,. 1 11141kr:r‘\ _ r_,,,, licit!, .&,..,,,,,t,- -- * .c-- , -, $ _,.._ ,__.. „......, - e. , __-... --. .-,-.,:- s--_,!:, -, - - ...,,.. -N. -=-.=al-,_., NI- -‘ „ ..„ __=ter r _._ __ f• *, t � i a . k •,, * . t '` !— ._ - _ _ _ a '-- -=7_-__ i _ _A1111110.,4 ` -r \lk- r !l c-t � 1f fi �c[ a'►trt-%°'ib 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 i 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 140 `1 COLLIER COUNTY PARK SYSTEM 5 YEAR MASTER PLAN Current Proposed Neighborhood 8 parks/34 acres 11 parks/39 acres (1 to 15 acres) Pinecrest, Lake Trafford, Farm Workers Village Community 14 parks/401 acres 15 parks/421 acres (15 to 50 acres) South Naples Community Park District 0 parks/0 acres 2 parks/200 acres (50 to 200 acres) Lake Avalon Park, Sports Complex Regional 12 parks/439 acres 16 parks/666 acres (200+ acres) New beach park, new marina, new boat ramp, new regional park School Sites 9 sites 13 sites Pinecrest, Bethune, Lake Trafford, new elementary * Upgrades and expands existing parks. * Upgrades and expands existing facilities at schools. 12752 Needed By 2,000 Facility Standard 250, 000 Pop. Value Proposed Cost Athletics/Sports Outdoor/Lighted Baseball 1/ 27,777 9 550,000 4 2,750,000 Softball 1/ 8,333 30 350, 000 8 4,200,000 Football/Soccer 1/ 12,500 20 350, 000 11 3,850,000 Basketball 1/ 12,500 20 30,000 9 270,000 Tennis 1/ 4,000 62 30,000 24 720,000 Racquetball 1/ 6,250 40 30,000 18 540,000 Sand Volley 1/ 12,500 20 12,500 14 175,000 Shuffleboard 1/ 8,333 30 12,500 13 162,500 Horseshoes 1/ 25,000 10 12,500 10 125,000 Bocci 1/ 25,000 10 12,500 10 125,000 Rollerblade 1/ 83,333 3 100,000 2 200,000 BMX 1/250,000 1 500,000 1 500,000 Skateboard 1/250,000 1 500, 000 1 500,000 Athletic Center 1/ 16,666 15 200,000 6 1,200,000 Covered Basketball 1/ 35,000 7 200,000 4 800,000 TOTAL 16,117,500 Recreation Complex Aquatic Complex 1/100,000 2.5 2.5 mil .5 1.25 million Rec. Complex 1/ 83,333 3 2.5 mil 1.5 4.5 million (Land) 1 .6 1 .6 million Sports Complex (Land) 1/250,000 1 2 mil 1 2 million Tennis Complex 1/ 83,333 3 500,000 1 500,000 Amphitheatre 1/250,000 1 1 mil 1 1 million Golf Course As Needed - - - - Community Center As Needed - 1 mil TOTAL 9,850,000 Page 2 Other Park Facilities Lighted Playgrounds 1/ 8,333 30 100,000 14 1.4 million Walk/Jog Trail (mile) 1/ 25,000 10 100,000 7 700, 000 Picnic Shelters 1/ 8,333 30 50, 000 16 800,000 Lake As Needed - 300, 000 1 300,000 Nature Trail (mile) As Needed - 50, 000 1 50, 000 Maint. Bldg. As Needed - 100,000 4 400, 000 Bicycle Trail (mile) As Needed - 100, 000 - - Specialty Use Area As Needed - 100,000 2 200,000 TOTAL 3,850,000 Beach and Water Marina 1/ 62,500 4 3.0 mil 1 3.0 million Boat Ramps 1/ 62,500 4 500,000 2 1.0 million Beach Park 1/ 50,000 5 5.5 mil 1 5.5 million Beach Access Parking 1/200 12.50 5,000 300 1.5 million Lake Avalon Development .5 million TOTAL 11,500,000 Existing Park Expansion Golden Gate Community Park 500,000 Veterans Park 1,000,000 East Naples Park 1,000,000 TOTAL 2,500,000 Page 3 School Sites Develop existing, expand existing, joint development of new. Bethune 150, 000 Pinecrest 150, 000 Highlands 250,000 Middle Schools New High School TOTAL 550,000 Libraries Try to develop all future parks and libraries so that they can share common facilities. New North Library New South Library/Manatee Site Other Park Acquisitions Neighborhood Community District Regional 200 acres 4,000,000 GRAND TOTAL $48,367,500 SB/cfd 000367 IMPACT FEES Community - $399 + Regional - $179 = 578 $578 generates 2 million $700 generates 2.5 million $800 generates 3.0 million $900 generates 3.5 million $1000 generates 4.0 million 000373 Each development of over 500 units must develop and maintain a neighborhood park based on the following: * 1 acre per 500 dwelling units * 2,500 dwelling units maximum service area * should be centrally located in development * facilities should include type/amount/quality/inspection ' ARMALAVAGE & LACROIX , INC . • HEAT ESTATE APPRAISERS. MARREI ANALYSIS&CONSULTANTS l October 18, 1993 Mr. Gerald Griffin, II President Signature Communities, Inc. 5551 Ridgewood Drive, Suite 203 Naples, Florida 33963 i Re: Avalon PUD Valuation Assignment No. 93-1828 $ Dear Mr. Griffin: In accordance with your request, I have personally inspected the above captioned site which is located along the south side of US-41 in unincorporated East Naples in Collier County,Florida. The subject property is referred to as the Lake Avalon Planned Unit Development in accordance with Ordinance No. 91-37 adopted by the Board of Collier County Commissioners on September 16, 1991. The subject property consists of approximately 126+/- acres of which 55+/- acres are classified as usable uplands. The subject property is currently zoned for a maximum of 376 dwelling units in accordance with the adopted PUD document. The subject property is legally identified as follows: A Portion of Section 13, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Containing 126+1-Acres Located Southwest of US-41 and Referred to as Avalon Lake PUD, Ordinance No. 91-37. The Subject Property Is Referred to as Tax Parcel No. 20, in Section 13, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, with a Tax Identification Folio No. of 392840004. Pursuant to your request, the purpose of my examination is to estimate the current market value of the unencumbered fee simple title to the property, in its "as is" condition,as currently zoned for 378 multi-family dwelling units, and to estimate the market value of the property assuming the site is designated as a low cost housing project with a total of 600 dwelling units. The effective date of appraisal is October 1, 1993, which was the date of physical property inspection and photographs. The valuation is subject to economic conditions and market performances prevailing as of the effective date of appraisal. This appraisal is specifically contingent on all comments and conditions set forth in this valuation. The scope of this appraisal included an inspection of the subject property, a survey of recent land sales within Collier and Lee Counties, a survey of general supply and demand trends affecting residential housing in Collier County, a review of the subject's zoning and potential uses, a review of the Master Land Use Plan for the property, and a cursory analysis of the subject property in comparison to the competing market environ. I interviewed land owners, real estate brokers, land use agencies, county personnel, and other knowledgeable sources regarding properties in this area. The 2375 L;araw Teak N.1?*. Su"E 210 M us fT ow%33940 813.649.4646 FA, 813.61.9.5972 Mr. Griffin Page 2 subject has been analyzed in relation to the market in which it exists, and to those properties with the most similar characteristics. Comparable properties were compared with subject based on location, size, potential use, density, physical characteristics, etc.. The subject has been valued on a price-per- unit basis, which is consistent with land sales of this type in the general marketplace. All sales information and listings were verified, and the subject's sales history was reviewed. The subject property is located along the south side of US-41 east, approximately 1/2 mile southeast of the intersection of Airport Road and US-41. The property consists of approximately 126 acres, of which 55+/- acres are classified as usable uplands. The balance of the property is a large man-made lake that serves as the central focal point for the future development, and other surrounding wetlands. The lake area consists of approximately 65 to 70 acres, and is a large symmetrical body of water that is currently utilized by local area ski clubs for recreational purposes. The central lake is an excellent amenity for the property. The Lake Avalon PUD allows 378 dwelling units with a minimum floor area of 750 square feet. Buildings can vary between two and three stories in height, and all sites will front directly along Lake Avalon. Development Standards and Regulations are classified as typical. Pursuant to your request, I have valued the property in accordance with the existing zoning and condition of the property, with an additional valuation of the property assuming it is designated for low cost affordable housing of up to 600 dwelling units. This appraisal is based on the assumption that the subject property is physically suitable for development of 378 multi-family dwelling units in accordance with the existing PUD, or 600 low cost affordable housing units as set forth herein. No representations are made that the subject property can physically accommodate density of this magnitude, nor that the zoning will be approved to allow this intensity of use. LAKE AVALON PUD VALUATION In the valuation of subject's existing zoning, numerous sale transactions were surveyed for the comparative analysis. Attached hereto is a land comparison chart utilizing five residential land sale transactions from the greater Naples area. The properties are located within about an eight mile radius of subject. The sales were analyzed on a price-per-unit basis, with no adjustment for date of sale. There is no quantifiable support for a time adjustment. Other adjustments are for property location, size, and physical characteristics. Since the subject property has benefit of the central lake amenity, sale properties not having this type of feature are adjusted to account for this superior characteristic. Sale No. 1 is the February 1988 sale of the Cypress Glen PUD along the north side of Pine Ridge Road about six miles north of subject. The 30+/-acre site sold for$1,848,000. The property was designated for 280 dwelling units indicating$6,600 per unit. The sale was adjusted downward by 10% for superior location, and upward by 10% for subject's superior physical characteristics. After adjustments, Sale No. I reflects $6,600 per unit. Comparable Sale No. 2 is the June 1988 sale of the Emerald Lakes PUD in North Naples about 7.5 miles northwest of subject. The property consists of 148 acres designated for 525 dwelling units and sold for approximately $3,595,000. The purchase price reflects $6,847 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 2 reflects $6,847 per unit. Sale No. 3 is the November 1988 sale of 40 acres in the Shadowood PUD. The property was designated for 228 dwelling units and sold for $1,475,000 or $6,469 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 3 reflects $7,116 per unit. Sale No. 4 is the September 1990 sale of 63 acres in the Sapphire Lakes PUD. The property sold for $1,738,000 and was designated for 316 units indicating $5,500 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 4 reflects $6,325 per unit. Sale No. 5 is the combined sale of the Piper's Grove property in North Naples about 8 miles north of subject. The purchase price is $2,289,000 and the Mr. Griffin Page 3 property was designated for 396 units reflecting $5,780 per unit. After adjustments, the sale reflects $5,780 per dwelling unit. Based on my analysis of subject in relation to the competing marketplace, it is my opinion the market value of the site is in the mid-range of adjusted values, or $6,500 per unit. The property value I is calculated as follows: 378 Units x $6,500 = $2,457,000 Rounded to: $2,500,000 LAKE AVALON PUD - AFFORDABLE HOUSING S1i'J In the valuation of subject as an affordable housing site, numerous rental apartment site transactions were analyzed for comparative purposes. Six of the sales have been summarized in the attached land comparison chart. Three of the sales are for conventional rental apartments, and three of the sales were for affordable low cost rental housing communities. Sales were adjusted for utilities, location,size, and physical characteristics. The adjustments are consistent with the valuation of subject as currently zoned. Sale No. 1 is the November 1988 sale of the Fountain View apartment site along Airport Road. The property was designated for a maximum of 456 dwelling units and sold for$5,931 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 1 reflects $5,338 per unit. Sale No. 2 is the April 1989 sale of a 30 acre affordable housing site located along Bayshore Drive about 1/2 mile south of subject. The property was designated for 184 dwelling units and sold for $5,163 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 2 reflects $4,905 per unit. Sale No. 3 is the April 1989 sale of the South Bay Plantation apartment site about six miles southeast of subject. The 240 unit site sold for $6,542 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 3 reflects $6,215 per unit. Sale No 4 is the June 1989 sale of the Waverly Place Apartments along Green Boulevard in Golden Gate. The 300 unit site sold for$6,695 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 4 reflects $6,361 per unit. Sale No. 5 is the June 1990 sale of the Arbour Lake affordable rental apartment site along Old US-41 about 12 miles northwest of subject. The 246 unit site sold for $5,040 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 5 reflects $5,292 per unit. Sale No. 6 is the October 1991 sale of the Saddlebrook affordable housing site about seven miles northeast of subject along Davis Boulevard. The 698 unit site sold for$5,007 per unit. After adjustments,this sale reflects$5,759 per unit. - Based on my analysis of subject as an affordable housing site in relation to the competing market, it is my opinion the probable value is $5,500 per unit. The value is calculated as follows: 600 Units x $5,500 = $3,300,000 • • Mr. Griffin c Page 4 The term market value is defined as: The most probable price which a property should bring in competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller, each acting prudently, knowledgeably and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in this definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby: a. buyer and seller are typically motivated; b. both parties are well informed or well advised, and each acting in what they consider his own best interest; c. a reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market; • d. payment is made in terms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto; and e. the price represents a normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale. The analysis and opinions in this letter are subject to the following premises, assumptions and limitations: This appraisal has considered all three approaches to value, if applicable. If any of the approaches is not applicable, then the omission of that particular approach will be justified Market data and reasoning supporting my analyses, conclusions and opinions have been retained in my files. The Market Data Approach to value has been utilized in the valuation of the subject land The Cost and Income Approaches to value are not applicable. This appraisal is in reduced letter form at your specific request. By virtue of reporting, this is a limited scope appraisal. A formal narrative appraisal can be prepared for your review at your request. Therefore, subject to the attached Limiting Conditions and Assumptions, and based on all contingent conditions and assumptions contained herein, it is my opinion and conclusion the probable market value of the unencumbered fee simple interest in the Lake Avalon PUD tract, in its current "as is" condition and designated for 378 dwelling units, and assuming the site is designated for an Affordable Housing community of up to 600 dwelling units,.as of October 1, 1993, is as follows: ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE OF LAKE AVALON PUD SITE IN ITS CURRENT "AS IS" CONDITION AND DESIGNATED FOR 378 UNITS AS OF OCTOBER 1, 1993 ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE OF LAKE AVALON PUD ASSUMING AFFORDABLE HOUSING USE OF 600 DWELLING $3,300,000 UNITS, AS OF OCTOBER 1, 1993 • Mr. Griffin Page 5 I hereby certify that I have no undisclosed interest in the subject property and my employment and compensation are not contingent upon my findings and valuation. The undersigned appraiser certifies, unless otherwise specified in this letter, that: the statements of fact contained in this report are true and correct. the reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions and are our personal, unbiased professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions. I have no present or prospective interest in the subject of this report and I have no personal interest or bias in respect to the parties involved. my compensation is not contingent on an action or event resulting from the analyses, opinions, or conclusions, in, or the use of, this report. - I, Richard L. Armalavage, MAI, have made a personal inspection of the property that is the subject of this report. - no one provided significant professional assistance to the persons signing this report. - my analyses, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has been prepared, in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, and the State of Florida for state-certified appraisers. - I certify that the use of this report is subject of the requirements of the Appraisal Institute relating to review by its duly authorized representatives. • The use of this report is subject to the requirements of the State of Florida relating to review by the Real Estate Appraisal subcommittee of the Florida Real Estate Commission. - I, Richard L. Annalavage, MAI, am currently certified under the continuing education program of the Appraisal Institute. - 1, Richard L. Arrmalavage, MAI, am currently a State-Certified Real Estate Appraiser, in accordance with requirements setforth in Section 475.501 of the Florida Statutes. My State Certification No. is#0000962 II This certificate is in accordance with the Uniform Standards of Professional Atmraisal > nice Standard Rule 2-3, and with the Appraisal Institute, Supplemental Standards of Professional Practice. both effective January 1, 1989. "This appraisal assignment was not made, nor was the appraisal rendered on the basis of a requested minimum valuation,specific valuation,or an amount which would result in approval of a loan." • 4 Mr. Griffin Page 6 i If you have any questions or comments concerning the above, please do not hesitate to contact me. It has been a pleasure to be of service to you. Respectfully submitted, • • .,AVAGE &40. 0 • , INC. Ok/ AF‘ 01(.-,/ Richard L. Armalavage, MAI State-Certified General Appraiser, #0000962 RLA/jm • • • • • PERMITS ISSUED " ( 1994 - 1995 ) M 001105 -94 -95 Dave's Beach Chairs I - Charter Club ( Dave ) ( w - 394-4192 X202 ) Insurance Effective 07-20-94 Expires 07-20-95 M 001106 -94 -95 Dave's Beach Chairs II - Surf Club ( Dave ) ( w - 394-4192 X202 ) Insurance Effective 07-20-94 Expires 07-20-95 M 001107 -94 -95 Day Sports, Inc, - Hilton ( Keith or Kyle ) ( w - 642-5000 H - 642-5675 ) Insurance Effective 12-23-93 Expires 12-23-94 M001115 -94 -95 Hilton ( John ) ( w - 394-5000 X651.) Insurance Effective 06-01-94 Expires 06-01-95 . . N 001103 -94 -95 International Yachting Services of Naples - Ritz Carlton (John Schiebel ) ( w - 262-8411 ) Insurance Effective 06-14-94 Expires 06-14-95 M 001108 -94 -95 Marco Island Ski and Water Sports - Marriott ( Mark Barr) (w- 394-4344 ) Insurance Effective 07-07-94 Expires 07-07-95 M 001109 -94-95 Marriott Marco Island Resort - Marriott ( Chris ) ( w -642-2694 ) Insurance Effective 10-01-94 Expires 10-01-95 M 001110 -94-95 N.E.S. CORP. "RADISSON" (Todd ) ( w-394-4100 X2153) Insurance Effective 06-29-94 Expires 06-29-95 M 001111-94-95 Particular People Charters Sweet Liberty - Radisson ( Capt. Leonard ) ( w - 793-3525 ) Insurance Effective 11-26-93 Expires 11-26-94 • • '' M'(701113 -94 -95 Recreation Facilities of America - Tigertail ( Tony ) ( w - 642-8414 ) • Insurance Effective 10-01-94 Expires 10-01-95 N 001101 -94 -95 Registry Resort - Clampass Park ( Paul ) Insurance Effective 09-10-94 Expires 09-10-95 N 001102 -94 -95 Ritz Carlton of Naples - ( Dan Thoresen) (w - 598-3300 X6526 ) Insurance Effective 01-01-94 Expires 01-01-95 M 001116 -94 -95 Sailors Haven - Club Regency ( Cliff ) ( w - 394-8197 X5050 ) Insurance Effective 05-20-94 Expires 05-20-95 M 001112 -94 -95 Southern Journey Charters -Club Regency ( Capt. Hank ) ( w - 642-6992 ) Insurance Effective 10-07-94 Expires 10-07-95 M 001114 -94-95 Stops Marine - Radisson ( Capt. Pam ) ( w - 394-8000 ) Insurance Effective 07-31-94 Expires 07-31-95 M 001117 -94 -95 Sunwind Beach Service of Naples - Eagle s Nest ( John or Juile ) ( w - 394-4114 ) Insurance Effective 11-19-93 Expires 11-19-94 N 001104-94-95 Vanderbilt Beach Rentals - ( Bill Hanson ) (w-947-4460) Insurance Effective 07-15-94 Expires 07-15-95 • RESOLUTION NO. 94-136 A RESOLUTION ADOPTING A FORMAL POLICY ESTABLISHING GUIDELINES FOR RECEIVING RECOMMENDATIONS FOR APPOINTMENT OF MEMBERS TO ADVISORY COMMITTEES AND - QUASI-JUDICIAL BOARDS. WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners has established ' - various advisory boards and quasi-judicial boards to assist in ---• ' various facets of county business and functions; and WHEREAS, members are appointed to the Jarious advisory committees and quasi-judicial boards by Resolution of the Board of County Commissioners; and WHEREAS, the Board wishes to establish a policy and set forth - guidelines regarding the recommendation process for.membership on . advisory committees and quasi-judicial boards. • NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that the following • • • . • guidelines are hereby established for Board of County -. - Commissioners receipt and acceptance of recommendations from the •- :ti various advisory committees and quasi-judicial boards for _ ;n� ` appointment of members to such committees or boards: I) Recommendations will be accepted by the Board of County Commissioners for appointments or reappointments for vacancies-on advisory committees from the current membership of the committee_ An advisory committee shalirbe allocated 41 days after notification from the Board office to submit in writing their .recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners tar the or reappointment of members to such committee- 2) The County Staff is to review and categorize the i applicants in areas of expertise and assure that the applicants possess the minimum position requirements for the appointment nay are seeking. 3) The following Boards are included in tits category of Quasi-Judicial Boards and no recommendations will be accepted or considered from such boards regarding appointments or • reappointments for vacancies on such Boards: • .a. Board of Building Adjustments and Appeals b. Collier County Code Enforcement Board C. Contractor's Licensing Board d. Public Vehicle Advisory Committee This Resolution adopted after motion, second and majority vote. • DATED: March 1, 1994 4aVEST: BOARD OF COUNTY &is ISSIONERS -DWIGHT E-:.BROCIC, CLERK COLLIER • • • , FLORIDA •' _ .e . BY /. • • - I-MAN . - - "Aepioved-,as-to form and _ - . .- • . .- _ • • Kenneth B. Cuyl County Attorn --• - • - • • • • ARMALAVAGE & LACROIX , INC . REAI ESTATE APPRAISERS. MARKET ANALYSTS& CONSULTANTS I • October 18, 1993 Mr. Gerald Griffin, II President Signature Communities, Inc. 5551 Ridgewood Drive, Suite 203 Naples, Florida 33963 Re: Avalon PUD Valuation Assignment No. 93-1828 Dear Mr. Griffin: In accordance with your request, I have personally inspected the above captioned site which is located along the south side of US-41 in unincorporated East Naples in Collier County, Florida. The subject property is referred to as the Lake Avalon Planned Unit Development in accordance with Ordinance No. 91-37 adopted by the Board of Collier County Commissioners on September 16, 1991. The subject property consists of approximately 126+/- acres of which 55+/- acres are classified as usable uplands. The subject property is currently zoned for a maximum of 376 dwelling units in accordance with the adopted PUD document. The subject property is legally identified as follows: A Portion of Section 13, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, Containing 126+/-Acres Located Southwest of US-41 and Referred to as Avalon Lake PUD, Ordinance No. 91-37. The Subject Property Is Referred to as Tax Parcel No. 20, in Section 13, Township 50 South, Range 25 East, with a Tax Identification Folio No. of 392840004. Pursuant to your request, the purpose of my examination is to estimate the current market value of the unencumbered fee simple title to the property, in its "as is" condition,as currently zoned for 378 multi-family dwelling units, and to estimate the market value of the property assuming the site is designated as a low cost housing project with a total of 600 dwelling units. The effective date of appraisal is October I, 1993, which was the date of physical property inspection and photographs. The valuation is subject to economic conditions and market performances prevailing as of the effective date of appraisal. This appraisal is specifically contingent on all comments and conditions set forth in this valuation. The scope of this appraisal included an inspection of the subject property, a survey of recent land sales within Collier and Lee Counties, a survey of general supply and demand trends affecting residential housing in Collier County, a review of the subject's zoning and potential uses, a review of the Master Land Use Plan for the property, and a cursory analysis of the subject property in comparison to the competing market environ. I interviewed land owners, real estate brokers, land use agencies, county personnel, and other knowledgeable sources regarding properties in this area. The 2375 ttucsue Teak Mc=T" SUITE 210 Na us Ft Gans 33940 813-649-41346 Fe. ,913.649.5973 Mr. Griffin Page 2 subject has been analyzed in relation to the market in which it exists, and to those properties with the most similar characteristics. Comparable properties were compared with subject based on location, size, potential use, density, physical characteristics, etc.. The subject has been valued on a price-per- unit basis, which is consistent with land sales of this type in the general marketplace. All sales information and listings were verified, and the subject's sales history was reviewed. The subject property is located along the south side of US-41 east, approximately 1/2 mile southeast of the intersection of Airport Road and US-41. The property consists of approximately 126 acres, of which 55+/- acres are classified as usable uplands. The balance of the property is a large man-made lake that serves as the central focal point for the future development, and other surrounding wetlands. The lake area consists of approximately 65 to 70 acres, and is a large symmetrical body of water that is currently utilized by local area ski clubs for recreational purposes. The central lake is an excellent amenity for the property. The Lake Avalon PUD allows 378 dwelling units with a minimum floor area of 750 square feet. Buildings can vary between two and three stories in height, and all sites will front directly along Lake Avalon. Development Standards and Regulations are classified as typical. Pursuant to your request, I have valued the property in accordance with the existing zoning and condition of the property, with an additional valuation of the property assuming it is designated for low cost affordable housing of up to 600 dwelling units. This appraisal is based on the assumption that the subject property is physically suitable for development of 378 multi-family dwelling units in accordance with the existing PUD, or 600 low cost affordable housing units as set forth herein. No representations are made that the subject property can physically accommodate density of this magnitude, nor that the zoning will be approved to allow this intensity of use. LAKE AVALON PUD VALUATION In the valuation of subject's existing zoning, numerous sale transactions were surveyed for the comparative analysis. Attached hereto is a land comparison chart utilizing five residential land sale transactions from the greater Naples area. The properties are located within about an eight mile radius of subject. The sales were analyzed on a price-per-unit basis, with no adjustment for date of sale. There is no quantifiable support for a time adjustment. Other adjustments are for property location, size, and physical characteristics. Since the subject property has benefit of the central lake amenity, sale properties not having this type of feature are adjusted to account for this superior characteristic. Sale No. 1 is the February 1988 sale of the Cypress Glen PUD along the north side of Pine Ridge Road about six miles north of subject. The 30+/-acre site sold for$1,848,000. The property was designated for 280 dwelling units indicating$6,600 per unit. The sale was adjusted downward by 10% for superior location, and upward by 10% for subject's superior physical characteristics. After j adjustments, Sale No. 1 reflects $6,600 per unit. Comparable Sale No. 2 is the June 1988 sale of the Emerald Lakes PUD in North Naples about 7.5 miles northwest of subject. The property consists of 148 acres designated for 525 dwelling units and sold for approximately $3,595,000. The purchase price reflects $6,847 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 2 reflects $6,847 per unit. Sale No. 3 is the November 1988 sale of 40 acres in the Shadowood PUD. The property was designated for 228 dwelling units and sold for $1,475,000 or $6,469 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 3 reflects $7,116 per unit. Sale No. 4 is the September 1990 sale of 63 acres in the Sapphire Lakes PUD. The property sold for $1,738,000 and was designated for 316 units indicating $5,500 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 4 reflects $6,325 per unit. Sale No. 5 is the combined sale of the Piper's Grove property in North Naples about 8 miles north of subject. The purchase price is $2,289,000 and the Mr. Griffin Page 3 property was designated for 396 units reflecting $5,780 per unit. After adjustments, the sale reflects $5,780 per dwelling unit. Based on my analysis of subject in relation to the competing marketplace, it is my opinion the market value of the site is in the mid-range of adjusted values, or $6,500 per unit. The property value is calculated as follows: . I 378 Units x $6,500 = $2,457,000 Rounded to: $2,500,000 LAKE AVALON PUD - AFFORDABLE HOUSING SITE In the valuation of subject as an affordable housing site, numerous rental apartment site transactions were analyzed for comparative purposes. Six of the sales have been summarized in the attached land comparison chart. Three of the sales are for conventional rental apartments, and three of the sales were for affordable low cost rental housing communities. Sales were adjusted for utilities, location,size, and physical characteristics. The adjustments are consistent with the valuation of subject as currently zoned. `. Sale No. 1 is the November 1988 sale of the Fountain View apartment site along Airport Road. The property was designated for a maximum of 456 dwelling units and sold for$5,931 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 1 reflects $5,338 per unit. Sale No. 2 is the April 1989 sale of a 30 acre affordable housing site located along Bayshore Drive about 1/2 mile south of subject. The property was designated for 184 dwelling units and sold for $5,163 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 2 reflects $4,905 per unit. Sale No. 3 is the April 1989 sale of the South Bay Plantation apartment site about six miles southeast of subject. The 240 unit site sold for $6,542 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 3 reflects $6,215 per unit. Sale No 4 is the June 1989 sale of the Waverly Place Apartments • along Green Boulevard in Golden Gate. The 300 unit site sold for$6,695 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 4 reflects $6,361 per unit. Sale No. 5 is the June 1990 sale of the Arbour Lake affordable rental apartment site along Old US-41 about 12 miles northwest of subject. The 246 unit site sold for $5,040 per unit. After adjustments, Sale No. 5 reflects $5,292 per unit. Sale No. 6 is the October 1991 sale of the Saddlebrook affordable housing site about seven miles northeast of subject along Davis Boulevard. The 698 unit site sold for$5,007 per unit. After adjustments, this sale reflects$5,759 per unit. i Based on my analysis of subject as an affordable housing site in relation to the competing market, it is my opinion the probable value is $5,500 per unit. The value is calculated as follows: 600 Units x $5,500 = $3,300,000 • I Mr. Griffin Page 4 The term market value is defined as: The most probable price which a property should bring in competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller, each acting prudently, knowledgeably and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in this definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby: a. buyer and seller are typically motivated; b. both parties are well informed or well advised, and each acting in what they consider his own best interest; c. a reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market; • d. payment is made in terms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto; and e. the price represents a normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale. The analysis and opinions in this letter are subject to the following premises, assumptions and limitations: • This appraisal has considered all three approaches to value, if applicable. If any of the approaches is not applicable, then the omission of that particular approach will be justified Market data and reasoning supporting my analyses, conclusions and opinions have been retained in my files. The Market Data Approach to value has been utilized in the valuation of the subject land. The Cost and Income Approaches to value are not applicable. This appraisal is in reduced letter form at your specific request. By virtue of reporting, this is a limited scope appraisal. A formal narrative appraisal can be prepared for your review at your request. Therefore, subject to the attached Limiting Conditions and Assumptions, and based on all contingent conditions and assumptions contained herein, it is my opinion and conclusion the probable market value of the unencumbered fee simple interest in the Lake Avalon PUD tract, in its current as is" condition-and designated for 378 dwelling units, and assuming the site is designated for an Affordable Housing community of up to 600 dwelling units,AS of October 1, 1993, is as follows: ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE OF LAKE AVALON PUD SITE IN ITS CURRENT "AS IS" CONDITION AND DESIGNATED FOR 378 UNITS AS OF OCTOBER 1, 1993 $2,500,000 ESTIMATED MARKET VALUE OF LAKE AVALON PUD ASSUMING AFFORDABLE HOUSING USE OF 600 DWELLING UNITS, AS OF OCTOBER 1, 1993 $3,300,000 Mr. Griffin Page 5 I hereby certify that I have no undisclosed interest in the subject property and my employment and compensation are not contingent upon my findings and valuation. The undersigned appraiser certifies, unless otherwise specified in this letter, that: the statements of fact contained in this report are true and correct. the reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions and are our personal, unbiased professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions. I have no present or prospective interest in the subject of this report and I have no _ - personal interest or bias in respect to the parties involved. my compensation is not contingent on an action or event resulting from the analyses, opinions, or conclusions, in, or the use of, this report. I, Richard L. Armalavage, MAI, have made a personal inspection of the property that is the subject of this report. - no one provided significant professional assistance to the persons signing this report. - my analyses, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has been prepared, in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, and the State of Florida for state-certified appraisers. - I certify that the use of this report is subject of the requirements of the Appraisal Institute relating to review by its duly authorized representatives. The use of this report is subject to the requirements of the State of Florida relating to review by the Real Estate Appraisal subcommittee of the Florida Real Estate Commission. • I, Richard L. Armalavage, MAI, am currently certified under the continuing education program of the Appraisal Institute. - 1*, Richard L. Armalavage, MAI, am currently a State-Certified Real Estate Appraiser, in accordance with requirements setforth in Section 475.501 of the Florida Statutes. My State Certification No. is #0000962 This certificate is in accordance with the Uniform Standards of ProfessionaLA , 11 Practice Standard Rule 2-3, and with the Appraisal Institute, Suvolemental Standards of Professional Practice. both effective January 1, 1989. This appraisal assignment was not made, nor was the appraisal rendered on the basis of a requested minimum valuation,specific valuation,or an amount which would result in approval of a loan." • Mr. Griffin Page 6 If you have any questions or comments concerning the above, please do not hesitate to contact me. It has been a pleasure to be of service to you. Respectfully submitted, • • •.. VAGE & . e" • • , INC.• nr t •'chard L. Armalavage, MAI State-Certified General Appraiser, #0000962 RI-Arm • • I • • 0 e 0 e el at e e I CO CO t o ■0 O — N m I v ^ e 10 in el r. 1n 01 0% IO — e r1 10 N e N P. 0 — — - - 10 0 el c0 rl rl — rl 0 0 — r1 e 0 N• el ft AN r. — O 0 0 �— Ip a Cl; 1� N 0% e N N IO N in W 0 L1 >L e 0 e PI at e e l CP. 0 e e I0 a0 — N a0 1 e 0 In h 1� in OI 01 %0 a rl CO N e N 1. 0 — 10 0 rl a0 el rl Ml O O — rl e 0 1 — 1: — a0 0 cc �. %O 0 9 I: N 4 0% - e N N ■0 W in 0 i N r- a0 C c.73 TO- M I.. O CO O O -t CO 2 r O V CZ < C../ O yy1� M M m_ MI CO O O st CO M CO 1-- 0 O O O O CO O O O O s O 2 > W W J < O -. r W O O O O O O O O O • O Cl N CI O .t O O M O O r .0 2.. N N N W 0 O d O O CV O co co . m ' P. = N .- .- N l 1 N M O M= OC 0 N N 1 J O p M I.. = r O[ y 0. W g O pp�� C,,� .gyp} p, sr O� = M CO O r M M , O OL W �• r •t N - O▪ O W _ • cc $ K N K U. s It US 1 ►_- Co N CO a ti ti M M O N O. W Y -f M j 'O tat ' �O N M N .• N Y Y IN tc. IV N. N O 7- N K M pMM 0 N CV O W •1 Mf .O N O $ `t ... In f E N O '0 E S M b BOO 1� O v t� O N 0 a 0 M N - .- O .- 0 $ N N ,--!. g 43 p8 3 .OA N O Q O O. O O + r r A N r r 3 CO N O n N '0 F N M 4 N `O 7. C, O — 7 Y I.■ M 0. ✓ Y • O Y 1 1P in ro < s M O IN $ N • 0 N Ii ! 6 r C.1 . Y c, C • 8 S . N F s O w V r 4. • • y �� y< V N on W ... Z h. ' * y < I W N RECREATION SECTION MONTHLY REPORT OCTOBER 1994 I. COLLIER COUNTY IV. IMMOKALEE COMMUNITY PARK AQUATIC FACILITY Activity 46 Activity 97 Facility Users 4,310 Facility Users 18,734 Revenue 4,232 Revenue 3,737 Instructional 33 Instructional 320 Special Events _ 0 Special Events 0 Marketing 168 - ' II. EAST NAPLES V. VETERANS COMMUNITY PARK COMMUNITY PARK Activity 328 Activity 627 Facility Users 19,563 Facility Users 21,025 Revenue 3,482 Revenue 12,715 Instructional 129 Instructional 364 Special Events 0 Special Events 0 Marketing 122 Marketing 530 III. FRANK MACKLE VI. GOLDEN GATE COMMUNITY PARR COMMUNITY PARK Activity. 126 Activity 233 Facility Users 14,709 Facility Users 74,580 Revenue 4,463 Revenue 6,079 Instructional 38 Instructional 120 Special Events 0 Special Events 0 Marketing 184 Marketing 414 VII. SECTION HIGHLIGHTS 10462 ATHLETICS SECTION MONTHLY REPORT MONTH: OCTOBER, YEAR: 1994 I. ACTIVITY IV. INSTRUCTION HOURS Athletics 6 Hr. 80 (Tennis & Golf) Tennis 40 Hr. 46 Total ATHLETICS 178 II. FACILITY USERS V. GAMES GGCP 232 . ENCP 4 10,222 VETERANS 167 It GGCP ENCP VETPK Mens 35 & Over 405 Mens Softball 5197 5197 581 Marco Softball 540 Little League 2025 VI. SPECIAL EVENTS Babe Ruth League 810 360 Golf 72 Tennis (Youth) 56 52 20 0 Tennis (Adult) 20 48- 12 Golden Years Tennis 30 130 C.C.W.T.A. 160 128 96 128 VII. SECTION HIGHLIGHTS Soccer (NCA) Soccer(Opt. Club) 6480 (vineyards) Soccer(Naples Soccer)810 (vineyards) October 6 Marco 30 and Over Softball meeting October 8 Start Marco 30 and Over League Collier Youth Football 180 180 180 October 27 Adult Soccer League Meeting C.0 Flag Football .1980 1800 - Practices 570 525, Totals 10,222 9,241 376 8,352 III. REVENUE $ 45,032.30 • --- ... ..- ... .. av•�_ • -- ta:an:.. aaav r; AV. 311 3;� •.., i. 3 ' o collier County Racquet Center Monthly Report Month OCTOBER Year 1994 I. Activity 78 IV. Instruction Hours 41 . . II. Facility Users . V. Expenditures $ 1154.77 - Tennis 713 Chal Nite 21 652940 Resale 520.00 ':. RB 172 Leagues -- 540 .652910 Operation Equip. S . . Team Tennis 96 Wall . .. - 86 652990 Operation Supply S 544-7 - Ladies' Day 28 Men's Day 33 , 651110 Office Supply $ . Instruction 73 Sp Event 41 651910 Office Equip • S Tournament Roam Rental 646710 Off.Equip Repair S ' 647110 Printing 5 90_00 652210 Food S 654210 Dues/Memberships 4 . IIL Total Revenue $5550•25 - . VI- Section Highlights - TotaI Sakes $ 5371.00 1. Pall League Programs Continuing Total Tax $ 179.16 2. Pall Junior Bennis Program Continnlac 3. worsen'a Round Robin Riser and Men'a 3/27 TO 10/25 jbtONTH TOTAL - Round Robin fre=er reorganized for 1a12/Mintar sessions . :: Tennis $ 250.50 . $ - - 4. Patron's League Competitive Team Tennis begun: Women's 3.5 Teas -'-- NCH 5 285.00 - ' S, • ---- women's 4.0 Tees Fro SI OF $_ . Q._ - ' S, men's 3.5 Tama Instruction $ 95,-00 $ S Began assessing 6% Sales Tax- on Per tit $�29_ S.O0 S applicable fees 6. Developing 10th Annual-Turkey Classic Leagues S-112.49-- S• Tannin Tomtnasent SP- S -°° S M 7... Facility Roars expanded Town E ,�,.- s -. EqpiF t $ I-0 s tiffts S s. Boa= Rent S • s - l'Ax2 8917= '5157-53 s -. _ Vg. Special Events raac20890Z $ U.63 S • •l• 913 3°=. ?r.;. F. 1 u, .. w N ►-+ o `o ?e -i O r- 5 t r $ $ $ $ $ $ $ tr; $ t;7;1 . Pk; g II II I 11111189 glir3 r3) g $ $ $ $ • r g Em. g g5111g g g gE55 5 'fliv M113 is €31. 13 /31311113e t3 0 W : a c► cs f31 o+ E g ! . 81 C2 of fe E e 13 k3 c • rn i IllIlIlIllE 1. NNE P INVINNINIMIENNEMPFUNIF: 10111111111111711NINIPPRIlltg 1, c as 6s '� 1,1 . 1 I n 1111 C ; — w �+ N !„-,' N N N N N N N j ',, ro a vi en ... • t 8 8 m , H 1 i .., . to 1111 n . 4 i n 8 8 8 8 z. g 0 f 04 J 01 C2 -8 ° ).; • - r g g 0: - ? . 8 5. 4:7 - a . • . 8 El . g C _ n 8 t3 to r. a- -- - - i _ i :. o. C7 PV w w �JN tri . ..• ' j::' : g Ch g $ 8 Az i tri a eg • N, c t.CA a - n C. V .■ , E. - . .. ,. n ; i . GA C yo I V C; N y � : ! ! IIIIIIU ig N 4 ti 13 13 111111111111 at• li i -. . 1 g .r" 5 8 � , rrMac Ut le 1 i Gorden Gate Community Center Serving the Community of Gorden Gate Month Ortz0-4/4_, q41 _ Activity Level `; Facility Users 6,4Og X evenue3 9 3.z1. X,O Instructional flours Special Events Aa • // UIG'iLIGi1TS: /� . Qa . % . �,4"6"4- Ls 5 AU"I' . x4.. .41-0-1 -2 4afri7cyr-ez-c. 69 ray.are„er.., • 4701 Gorden gate Parkway •Goldcn Cate, Tlvrida 33999 • (813)455-2343 PARK RANGER PROGRAM MONTHLY REPORT October 1994 MONTH YEAR ADMINISTRATION: Routine Administration: added MARTA Einong to volunteer list. Participate in "Make a Difference Day". FIELD OPERATIONS: Routine patrol: work with Sheriff's Office weekend workers at Barefoot Beach: Animal Control: installed traffic counters at Vineyards and Pelican Bay: check and record traffic counts daily: open and close parks daily: care of mounted patrol horses: enforcement of County Ordinances: empty trash and clean restrooms daily: check and record water test at Clam Pass: perform maintenance on vehicles and eauioment: do monthly inspection on concessions. BEACH & EATER SITES CAR COUNT USERS* Beach Facilities bgnth Month Barefoot Beach Access 6,740 6,740 16,176 16,176 Barefoot Preserve 8,405 8,405 20,172 20,172 Clam Pass Park 6,596 6,596 15,830 15,830 Tigertail Beach 7,378 7,378 17,707 17,707 Vanderbilt Beach 7,353 7,353 17,647 17,647 No. Gulfshore Totals 36,472, 36,472 87,532 87,532 Boat Launch Facilities: (Traffic counters installed 2/11/93) Bayview Park 4,397 4,397 10,552 10,552 SR 951 3,128 3,128 7,507 7,507 Caxambas 4,969 4,969 11,925 11,925 Lake Trafford 3,572 3,572 8,572 8,572 Y .. Cocohatchee River Park 8,611 8,611 20,666 20,666 (installed 6/25/93) Totals 24,677 24,677 59,222 59,222 *Users - car count x 2.6 - changed to 2.4 an 6/1/93 PARR SITES VISITED PERSONAL CONTACTS INIELDUCCODUEMIMME Month 212 Month xra Mh 212 935 935 3,795 3,795 5 5 COTS: Exotic control - Rangers 697. Friends 125. Volunteer hours, 32. Begin training Ranger Rodriauez on mounted patrol. 5933/10/94 COLLIER COUNTY PARKS AND RECREATION PARK MAINTENANCE MONTHLY REPORT October , 19 94 Park Maintenance Operations: Continue all daily maintenance functions relating to all parks and waterfront facilities. All annual contracts and blanket purchase orders in place for FY 94-95. Resodding of the Lm okalee Middle School soccer field complete. (Patch work around goals and various parts of playing field). PARRS MAINTAINED # OF ACRES # OF SITES ETD . YTD School Sites 10.5 • 5 10.5 5 10.5 5 f Water Orientated* 438.5 12 438.5 12 438.5 12 Neighborhood Parks 38.7 12 38.7 12 38.7 12 Community Parks 257.3 10 257.3 10 257.3 10 = ' *Pelican Bay Community Park added 9/94. Gulf Coast Little 'segue transferred from Neighborhood Park to Community Park Special Projects: Description: Clam Pass boardwalk repair proiect started 10/24. 45 day comae- - - tion time, target date mid December. Tigertail turnaround proiect complete. Caxambas environmental clean up prolect preliminary investigative phase begun. County has applied to State for limited contamination ass..ssment. Pelican Bay Community Park Droiect complete. Gulf Coast Little League and Tony Rosbouoh Park oroiects Dark master planning begun. OCPM to process through work order procedures. Park Supervision: Master park meter for boat launch revenue at Cocohatchee bid received. Executive Summary prepared for Board approval. East Naples CP landscaping entrance plan developed and sent to Purchasing for bid advertise- went. Quarterly report developed and sent to State regarding Barefoot Beach- Mid Continent Electric developing plan for additional signage. 4050 '' • ' BUDGET PROJECT AMOUNT COMMENTS A. Aaron Lutz Park 110,000 Capital projects has given this project to a Project Engineer and design should be starting soon. Play structure ordered November 1993, $30,000. Delivered 2/3/94 and installed. Electrical plans submitted, fixtures ordered. Completion date late October, November 1995. Project currently out for competitive bid. BCC approved Bid on 9/27/94. B. Tony Rosbaugh Park 173,000 Phase II - began Master Plan to include parking, 2 new lighted softball fields and parking area and concession building. C. Tigertail Parking 261,000 Reconfiguration of existing parking lot - completion 12/31/93. Complete. Turnaround start date-Aegdst- Sept 19, 1994. Completion 10/15/94. Ongoing. D. Vanderbilt Beach Walkovers 100,000 Capital Projects will be permitting and designing these pedestrian walkways on N. Gulfshore Blvd. Permits obtained,. Project on hold due to legal concerns. 3 accesses to be constructed. No progress. E. Vineyards.Public Park _ 3,024,000 Bids were opened on December 15, 1993. The apparent Low bidder is Vanderbilt Bay Construction at a cost of approx. 2.5 million. BCC has approved Bid, construction has begun, lake excavation • completed. Work has begun on sports building, pavilions and • community center. Light poles for soccer fields currently being erected. Softball field lights delivered & should be erected by mid October November. f► Pelican Bay Public Park 250,000 Westinghouse is building the park. The $250,000 is County's ate. contribution to the lighting and play structures, etc. Completion of park estimated Summer 1994. Racquet ball courts constructed, tennis court constructed started. 6/28/94 play equipment installation started, paving work complete. Tennis courts 99% complete. Bcc approved acceptace of facility 9/27/94. Should be open early Oct. Maintenance to begin 9/27. Ribbon cutting ceremony 11/3/94. 3. Imokaler Recreation Center 2,700,000 The final plans are to be submitted to the County by 12/31/93. 12/29/93 final SDP submittal. Bid package submitted for Purchasing review 2/11/94. Out for Bid Late February 1994. Pre-bid 3/10/94, Bid opening 3/30/94. Bids received apparent low bidder D.E. Murphy. Will be preseted to BCC for approval. PARAB reviewed on 4/27/94. Recommendation to BCC 6/7/94. BCC rejected plans 6/7/94. Readdressed issue on 6/28/94. Approved plans for pool, slide, activity pool, and refurbishing locker rooms. Come beck in 60 days in regard to gym. Construction started last week of July. Executive Summary going to BCC on 9/6 for options on Rec Ctr. Pool construction - locker roam facility being cleared, pool well dug. BCC approved remodeling of the gym for approx $816,000 on 9/20/94. -1- BUDGET PROJECT AMOUNT COMMENTS N. Fresh Water Boat Launch in 300,000 Presented options to the BCC on 12/21/93. County Golden Gate Estates Attorney reviewing legal options. I. Golden Gate Community Center Expansion 1,500,000 On 12/14/93 BCC approved funding this project. Capital Projects is currently advertising for Request for Proposals for professional services to design facility. Tom Donegan has been selected the Project Manager. RFP submitted 1/20/94. Due back 2/11/94 for Arch. Professional. Barney Schmidt and Weaver awarded contract and design work has begun. Bid spec presented to County for review. Bid opened on 7/27/94. Bid awarded to Cristel and a price negotiated. Contract signed by contractor being processed by County. Cornerstone laying 11/10/94.. J. Golden Gate Estates Community Park 1,343,000 Agnoli, Barber L Brundage awarded contract. Meeting with School Board scheduled for 5/4/94 at Big Cypress. Public meeting held 5/11/94. Draft design reviewed by County. 2nd meeting with School Board staff 8/5/94. Reviewing option of difference entrance to park. Reviewing property for entrance. Executive Summary to BCC regarding entrance on 10/11/94. Y-e GGCT will purchase 5 acres of property. BCC denied purchase, pursue easement option. K. Gulf Coast Little League 76,000 Master plan being designed. Approx $76,000 available for conc. stand renovations, batting cages, sewer hook-up. L. South Naples Park 1,000,000 Department and Real Property are continuing to investigate potential property in the South Naples area for a community park site. Also looking at property in Naples Manor for a park. M. Light GGCP Football/soccer Field 60;000 Light existing football/soccer field at Golden Gate Community Park. OCPM has assigned a construction manager to this project. Obtaining bids for work. N. Athletic Fields: 1,674,000 Construction of athletic facilities throughout County. Presently looking at ENCP and Middle and Elementary school sites. i.e. Pine Ridge and East Naples Middle Schools. Met with principals to discuss proposed plan. School Board staff has agreed to the idea, will be presenting to BCC. BCC =_ approved 9/27/94. Going before School Board in Nov. 0.. Barefoot Mach Parking Lot 175,000 Additional 100 car parking lot in the State leased property. Topo developed. In stage of applying for State permit. Completion date 1/1/95. Waiting for State permits. Applica- tion sent. SDP in process. P. Bayview Park Parking Lot 7 Currently Real Property is discussing the possibility of leasing land from the Colliers to construct additional parking adjacent to Bayview. No progress. -2- • • v• BUDGET PROJECT AMOUNT COMMENTS O. Clam Pass Utilities L Boardwalk 495,000 Repairing boardwalk and running sewer service to bath house facilities. Capital Projects obtaining permits. Project to be completed by 10/1/94. Sent out for re-bid. New completion date late November. Bids received. Apparent low bid Vanderbilt Bay. Project start date 10/24/94 w/park to be closed until 11/15/94. R. Golden Gate Community Center Sewer Conn. 14,000 Connect Golden Gate Cce unity Center to Florida Cities sewer system. All permits and authorization from Florida Cities Water obtained. Will be coordinated with expansion project. Completed. • 10428 • • • i, r4 • tt. ORDINANCE NO. 93- AN ORDINANCE CONFIRMING THE CREATION OF THE PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD; PROVIDING FOR APPOINTMENT AND COMPOSITION; SETTING FORTH THE TERMS OF OFFICE; PROVIDING FOR REMOVAL FROM OFFICE, FAILURE TO ATTEND MEETINGS; PROVIDING FOR OFFICERS, QUORUM, RULES OF PROCEDURE; PROVIDING FOR REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES; SETTING FORTH THE FUNCTIONS, POWERS AND DUTIES OF THE ADVISORY BOARD; SETTING FORTH THE DUTIES OF THE PUBLIC SERVICES ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS DESIGNEE; PROVIDING A REVIEW PROCESS; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICT AND SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, Collier County Ordinance No. 86-41, as amended, sets forth the requirements for creating County Advisory Boards; and WHEREAS, the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board was created by the Board of County Commissioners in October, 1975; and WHEREAS, it is the desire of the Board of County Commissioners to confirm and ratify the establishment of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board and to formalize the structure and operation of the advisory board in accordance with the provisions of Collier County Ordinance No. 86-41, as amended. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA, that: SECTION ONE. Board Confirmation of the Creation of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. The creation and establishment of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board (hereinafter referred to as the "Board") is hereby confirmed and ratified. SECTION TWO. Appointment and Composition, A. The Board shall be composed of seven (7) members consisting of one (1) member from the Immokalee Community Park District, one (1) member from the Marco Island Community Park District and five (5) members from the Naples and Urban Area Community Park District. B. Members of the Board shall' be appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the Board of County Commissioners. Said members shall be permanent residents within the Community Park District that they represent, and all shall be electors of Collier County. 1 1 . C. Appointment of members to the Board shall be by resolution of the Board of County Commissioners, which resolution shall set forth the date of-appointment and the term of office. SECTION THREE. Terms of Office. The initial terms of office of the Board shall be as follows: A. Two (2) members will serve until December 31, 1993. B. Three (3) members will serve until December 31, 1994. C. Two (2) members will serve until December 31, 1995. Thereafter, each appointment or reappointment shall be for a term of four (4) years. A member of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Board may be reappointed by the Board of County Commissioners for one (1) successive term. However, other qualified applicants may be considered for any vacancy. Appointments to fill any vacancies on the Board shall be for the remainder of the unexpired term of office. SECTION FOUR. Removal From Office: Failure to Attend Meetings. A. Any member of the Board may be removed from office, with or without cause, by a majority vote of the Board of County Commissioners. B. In the event that any Board member is absent from two (2) consecutive Board meetings without a satisfactory excuse acceptable to the Board Chairman, the Board Chairman shall state such fact at the next regularly scheduled Board meeting and shall thereafter notify, in writing, the Public Services Administrator or his Designee of the Board member's failure to attend without satisfactory excuse. The Board of County Commissioners shall review the Board Chairman's notification at a County Commission meeting and shall declare the Board member's position to be vacant if the Commission concurs that the Board member was absent from two (2) consecutive Board meetings without a satisfactory excuse 2 • and shall promptly fill the vacant position. The Board member shall not serve at any meetings after his or her position is declared vacant. - C. If any member of the Board is absent for more than one-half of the Board's meetings in a given fiscal year, it shall be deemed that the member has tendered his resignation from such Board. The Board of County Commissioners shall as soon as practicable after such resignation, declare the position to be vacant and shall promptly act to fill the vacancy. The Board member shall not serve at any meetings after his position has been declared vacant by the Board of County Commissioners. D. A member of the Board shall be deemed absent from a meeting when he/she is not present during at least 75% of the meeting. SECTION FIVE. Officers: Ouorum: Rules of Procedure. A. Annually the membership of the Board shall elect a chairman and vice chairman from among the members. Officers' terms shall be for one (1) year, with eligibility for reelection. B. The presence of four (4) or more members shall constitute a quorum of the Board necessary to take action and transact business. In addition, an affirmative vote of three (3) or more members shall be necessary in order to take official action, regardless of whether four (4) or more members of the Board are present at the meeting. C. The Board shall, by majority vote of the entire membership, adopt rules of procedure for the transaction of business and shall keep a written record of meetings, resolutions, findings and determinations. Copies of all Board minutes, resolutions, reports, and exhibits shall be submitted to the Board of County Commissioners. SECTION SIX. Reimbursement of Expenses. Members of the Board shall serve without compensation, but shall be entitled to receive reimbursement for expenses reasonably 3 incurred in the performance of their duties upon prior approval of the Board of County Commissioners. SECTION SEVEN. Functions. Powers and Duties of the Board. The functions, powers and duties of the Board shall be as follows: A. To evaluate, consider and review the acquisition of park property. B. To consider and analyze the development of park and recreation facilities constructed on these park properties. C. To review and provide input on parks and recreation programs, classes and special events. D. To review and provide input on the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. E. , To solicit input from the public that may assist with the duties listed above. F. To provide recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners on issues relating to those duties specified above or other duties assigned by the Board of County Commissioners. G. The Board may adopt and amend "Guidelines" to govern their operation, subject to approval by the Board of County Commissioners. SECTION EIGHT. Duties of the Public Services Administrator or His Designee. The duties of the Public Services Administrator or his Designee shall be: A. To administer the activities of the Board in accordance with established policies of the Board of County Commissioners and guidelines adopted by the Board. B. To provide periodic written reports to the Board, the County Manager and the Board of County Commissioners on the activities of the Board. 4 C. Attend all Board meetings. SECTION NINE. Review Process. This Board shall be reviewed once every four (4) years commencing in 1996, in accordance with the procedures contained in Ordinance No. 86-41, as amended. SECTION TEN. Conflict and Severability. In the event this Ordinance conflicts with any other ordinance of Collier County or other applicable law, the more restrictive shall apply. If any phrase or portion of this Ordinance is held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion. ,SECTION ELEVEN. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall become effective upon receipt of notice from the Secretary of State that this Ordinance has been filed with the Secretary of State. PASSED AND DULY ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida, this day of 1993. ATTEST: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA BY: BURT L. SAUNDERS, CHAIRMAN Approved as to form and legal suffi iency: Dav d C. We l Assistant County . ttorney 5 10/11/94 12:07 1T3136579044 INN. HABITAT 12001 im CiCdI�/tom Darlene Koontz October 11 , 1994 Steve Brinkman Telephone call today from Rev. Filomena Poole re : EaaL Naples Community Park. Concerned over problems with ladies restroom facilities for physically challenged visitors . Specifically, the restroom door is too heavy; there is a "lip" in the door that makes it difficult to get a wheelchair into the room; there are no paper towels in the dispenser in the handicapped stall nor is there is trash dispenser. She also mentioned that it would be helpful if the handicapped parking spots were closer to the entrance, perhaps this can be done with the new landscaping. Also, someone has moved the bikerack into the path from the handicapped parking spot into Lhe building . She has offered to be a volunteer consultant with regard to more user friendly facilities for physically challenged persons, if you would like for her to do so. Rev. Filomena Poole 774-4526 Please call me should you have questions or need further information. Thanks for your help! "1 1 c5 -> 813 353 1002 N0.004 pg2 We04ow rwe ' V COMMUNITY SERVICES DEPARTMENT REGULAR MEETING COMMUNITY SERVICES BOARD RIVER PARK COMMUNITY CENTER 11TH STREET N. & 3RD AVENUE N. NAPLES, FLORIDA NOVEMBER 8, 1994 - 9:00 A.M. A EN A 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 3. OLD BUSINESS A. Master Planning Update 1. Cambier Park 2. City-wide Park Study B. Naples Landing 4. NEW BUSINESS 5. CORRESPONDENCE AND COMMUNICATI ON A. Naples Pier B. Anthony Park 6. ADJOURNMENT Normal action may M taken on any Ileaf discussod or with respect t m y matter od at Mk mooting will �� Any r Ponca who decide;to to•• say that 1•111.811•1 mode by this board tb au le map e which ch savers.rincludes Ar test mooNa say and evidence upon which the sod t. •bawd.t swan ons* b•d roaM or the mooapt;data 1 map a0 the City Clark's Ott1p at 4344701 with ngaa4 A/17 spots us daY Warr the 775 THIRTEENTH STREET,NORTH • NAPLES FLORIDA 33940 TEL:(813)434-4880 FAX:(813)287-5840 11/04/94 13:09 UTILITIES 4 813 353 1002 NO.004 901 TM TO: - NOTE e.<9(,&64.: QJIICo nNJQ.OF O" AGES .5�3-/o0Z INCLUDING THIS o TM FAX#: PHONE#: FAX#: c3 FLASH r1% (SUBJECT &Imo 0Sy • DATE MESSAGE • ❑PLEASE REPLY 0 NO REPLY NECESSARY SIGNED PLEASE INFORM US IMMEDIATELY IF YOU 00 NOT RECEIVE FACSIMILE IN FULL TOPS i FORM 14400 LITHO IN U.S.A. • • KELLY, PRICE, SIKET & HEUERMAN CHARTERED PAUL K.HEUERNIAN' CHARLES ni. KELLY,JR. ATTORNEYS AT LAW c'• • - 'TELEPHONE 'TELEPHONE BOARD CERTIFIED TAX LAWYER BOARD CERTIFIED WILLS, _ • n (K 13)26I_0453 TRUSTS AND ESTATES LAWYER • r�? MASTERS OF LAW IN ESTATE PLANNING GREY OAKS BUILDING ;?` -• _ IN POINCIANA PROFESSIONAL PARK -I l! DONALD K. ROSS,JR. 2640 GOLDEN GATE PARKWAY TELECOPIKK MASTERS OF LAW IN TAXATION SUITI-2 315 (813)261-5711 ANDREW G.SIKET t P.O.BOX 8117 JOSEPH D. ZAKS NAPLES, FLORIDA 33941-8117 • MASTERS OF LAW IN TAXATION ALSO ADMITTED IN OHIO t ALSO ADMITTED IN MAINE November 1, 1994 ..ALSO ADMITTED IN MASSACHUSETTS Lt. Victor Morales Naples Police Department 355 Goodlette Road North Naples, Florida Re: Sailboat docking on city shoreline Dear Lt. Morales: I am currently serving as the Chairman of the Collier County Parks and Recreation Advisory Board. In that capacity, I was requested to contact the City of Naples regarding their policy for storage of boats along the city shoreline. I contacted Mark Thornton, Director of Community Services, and he referred me to you. The reason I am writing to you is that I was contacted by a group of county residents who indicated that they had been unable to register their boats for storage on the Naples city beach since a new ordinance was enacted in 1993. Having reviewed the ordinance, Ordinance No. 93-6923, I find no criteria included therein which would establish to whom the available spaces are assigned. Would you please provide me with information regarding the procedure which is currently being used to assign the available spaces? _Specifically, I am interested in whether any procedure is in place which would allow a resident of Collier County living outside the city limits to obtain the right to dock their boat at one of the thirty-five (35) designated spaces. I would like to be able to respond to the citizens' inquiry in • Lt. Victor Morales 2 November 1, 1994 the near future. Therefore, I would ask you to respond at your earliest possible convenience. Thank you very much for your assistance. iiS: .ceerel ours, Jo 1. . JDZ/sa cc: Steve Brinkman Lmoral«jdz