Loading...
BCC Minutes 12/04/1990 R Naples, Florida, December 4, 1990 i~LET IT BE REMEMBERED, that the Board of County Commissioners in .~._for the County of Collier, and also acting as the Board of Zoning ,Sale and as the governing board(s) of such special districts as ~h&Ve been created according to /aw and having conducted business : ,:. in, met on this date at 9:00 A.M. in RE(~ILAR SESSION in Building of the Government Complex, East Naples, Florida, with the g members present: CHAIRMAN: VICE-CHAIRMAN: 'ALSO PRESENT: Max A. Hasse, Jr. Michael J. Volpe Richard S. Shanahan Burr L. Saundere Anne Goodntght James C. Giles, Clerk; John Yonkosky, Finance ~DArector; Wanda Arright and Annette Guevtn, Deputy Clerks; Netl Dorrill, County Manager; Ron McLemore Assistant County Manager; Tom Olliff, Assistant to the County Manager; Ken Cuyler, County Attorney; '~ed Relschl, Environmental Inspector; John MadaJewski, Project Review Services Manager; Harry Huber, Technical Services Supervisor; Ken Baglnskt, Planning Services Manager; Frank Brutt, Community ~lopment Services Administrator; Sue FI/son, Administrative to the Board; and Deputy Byron Tomlinson, Sheriff's Office. Page AOEn'DA -~ CSA~aZS Shan~han ~ovsd, ssconded by Conlssionsr Goodntght c~'T~edunan~usly, that the Agsnda and Consent Agsnda be with the following changes: Add item 9Al, Recommendation to approve for recording the final plats of "Mission Village Unit One and Unit Two", at Staff's request. Add item 9A2, Recommendation to grant preliminary acceptance of the roadway, drainage, water and sewer improvements for ;i the final plat of "Willoughby Pines" at Staff's request '3. Add item 9AS, Water and sewer facilities acceptance for Willoughby Pines, at Staff's request. ~**..i;4.·.... Add item 9A4, Water facilities acceptance for CaS Bank, at · Staff's request. 57./.'..,.. Continue item 8C until December 1!, 1990, Gary Kluckhuhn *i~: representing Del's, at Staff's request. · : Continue item 8E until December ~1, 1990, Gao=ge Vega, Jr. ~.i~ .' representing Lely Resort-Classics Golf Course - preliminary /' .' work authorizat ~,. Continue Item 14B3 until December 11, 1990, Review of the Glaze Management Study and recommendation for Implementation of organizational improvements to the Transportation Services Division, at Staff's request. Continue item 14H?, Bid award for the Pelican Bay Improvement D/strict for right-of-way maintenance, due to receiving bid protest. Request that item llD4 be heard at the end of the Regular Agenda, Recommendatlon to adopt the attached resolution authorizing the issuance of Collier County Special Obligation Revenue Bonds, Series 1990 awarding the bonds to Merrill L~ch & Co., pursuant to a Bond Placement Agreement, and approving the Private Placement Memorandum, at Petitioner's request. OF F~E~ULAR BCC ME~TING OF OCTOBER 16, 1990 - APPROVED AS ~hanahan ~n~ed, esconded by Co~ss~onsr Goodn~ght ~,a~T~ed unanimously, to appr~e the ~C Minute8 of the of OC~O~r 16, 1990. ~CO~IZED ~ ~O~E OF ~E ~ FOR 1990 stoner Hasse recognized Gary S. Arnold, Emergency Services as Employee of the Year for 1990. He congratulated and pre- Mr. Arnold with a plaque and a $250 cash award. December 4, 1990 DESIGNATING DECEMBER 7, 1990, AS ART LEAGUE OF MARCO ~ner Shanahan presented to Kathy Madison, Diane Bostick, Sheller, Dr. Maxine Bennett, and Sa11¥ Blanchard the Proclamation B~gnating December ?, 1990 as Art League of Marco Island Day. Is~onel- Shanahan ~oved, seconded by Commissioner (~oodn~ght led una~t~l¥, to proclstm Friday, December ?, 1990, ss Art of M~co Isl&nd Day. 09 Page 3 December 4, 1990 NO. 90-580 RE PETITION CCSL-90-?, HARRY HUBER, OFFICE OF PltOJ~CTS OF COLLIER COUNTY, REPRESENTING COLLIER COUNTY !CO~ZSSIONERS REQUESTING A COASTAL CONSTRUCTION SETBACK LINE VARIANCE TO PERMIT BEACH NOURISHMENT OF MARCO ISLAND BEACH - ADOPTED Legal notice having been published in the Naples Daily News on 'November 18, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication filed with Clerk, public hearing was opened to consider Petition CCSL-90-? by Harry Huber, Office of Capita/ Projects, representing the of County Commissioners of Collier County, requesting a variance the Coastal Construction Setback Line as required by Ordinance .19 to allow: The addition of 1.18 mi/lion cubic yards of material offshore borrow areas to 2.6 miles of beach on Marco Island · eaward. . . of the CCSL; the construction of two rock/stone groins on Island seaward of the CCSL; the construction of twenty-two walkovers on Marco Is/and seaward of the CCSL; and re- of dunes affected by these activities seaward of the GCSL; ~.iocated ~n Sections 19 and 20, Township 52 South, Range 26 East. Environmental Inspector Reischl stated that this project involves impact to wildlife and native vegetation, but the long term ~s environmentally neutral or beneficial. He related that It&fi recommends the petition be approved subject to the fo/lowing ~s: exotic plant removal w~thin the project limits; appli- Cable Federal, State, and Local permits are obtained; project shall place after October 31 and before April 1; dune walkovers shall with DNR standards; and at least 1.32 acres of wetland shall be ~n the Rookery Bay Aquatic Preserve as mitigation for impacted response to Commissioner Volpe, Mr. Reischl clarified that the ie presently being done is on the Hideaway Beach side and is seaward of the CCSL. 3ing Commissioner Shanahan's comments, Mr. Reiechl confirmed the st~pulations requested are already included in all the and State permits. Page 4 December 4, 1990 iMr[ Relech! disclosed that the funding for the project is being generated by the Beachfront Taxing District on Marco IeZand. .' ..jCmm~lealoner Shanah~n ~oved, ascended by Con~ealoner aoodnight .~.~. c~riedunan~ou~ly, that the ~bllc hearing ~ closed. ~[:~ C~So8~F 8h~ ~v~, seconded ~ Conlsoloner Go~ght ~- c~A~~A~iF, t~t PetAtAon CCSL-90-7 ~ approved, there~ .ir Page December 4, 1990 NO. 90-581 RE PETITION SNP-89-15, GLEN CAUDILL OF ANCHOR '~l~q~tl~G, REPI~ESEIITING SHRE~SBURYASSOCIATES, REQUESTING EXTENSION 0F~UBDMSIONMASTER P~AN FOR CASA DEL SOL PUD - ADOPTED Legal notice having been published tn the Naples Daily News on ~'November 18, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication filed with Clerk, public hearing was opened to consider Petition SMP-89-15 by Glen E. Caudtll of Anchor Engineering representing Shrewsbury J, requesting an extension of the Subdivision Master Plan ;royal of one year to October 24, 1991, which ts located on the West ~tde of C.R. 951, 3/4 mile North of Rattlesnake Hammock Road, In 15, Township 50 South, Range 26 East. MadaJewskt, Project Review Services Manager, stated that the ,Jeer petition ts to request an extension to the allowable timeframe the Subdivision Master Plan Approval for the Casa Del So/ project :ated on the west side of C.R. 951, north of Rattlesnake Hammock He explained that the subdivision regulations have a provision allows a subdivision master plan to be in effect for a period of year and the ability for the Board to consider and approve exten- to that timeframe. After being notified by the County Mr. [ewskt reported, the applicant sent written notice requesting an ~tenston. He explained that due to the long lead time tn obtaining necessary permits, Staff recommends approval of the extension. ]~!Mr.. MadaJewski confirmed Commissioner Shanahan's comment that the and fill permits from the Corps ts taking longer than what was ~ated. n response to Commissioner Volpe, Mr. MadaJewsk! affirmed that the 'from the petitioner was received prior to the due date, but it 30 days to be scheduled on the Board of County ~ers' agenda due to the advertising time required and holt- MadaJewskl advised that there have been no construction docu- approvals for this project. ::~'Ccl~ieetone~ Sh~nahan move4, seconded by Co,missioner Goodntght December 4, 1990 r,~z-z-%ed unam~.~ou.~¥, 1:hat the i;mblic ha~ng be cloeed. Cme.htseioner Sh~,nahan ~oved, aeconded by Co~-:la. ionar Goodnight: carried unanimoualy, that PetitAon ~fP-89-15 he approved, thereby Reeolution 90-581. Page 7 .1:3 ::. '~.? December 4, 1990 ~ OF ~ ~W~/ZO~ DI~CTOR*B DECISION ~T ~:'~ OF ~ Z~ O~Iff~CS IS TO ~S~ICT ~ LOCATIOW OF IST~LZS~S ~ ~~ ~SE IS TO SELL ~COHOLXC B~GES ~ILE ~L~NG ~A~ ~OSE ~I~ USE IS ~ S~E OF FOOD TO L~ATE WI~iN 500 ~ OF ~ EST~LIS~S SELLIN~ ~COHOLIC BE~ES FOR ON-SITE O~ION - ZONIN~ DECISION ~LD ~ ST~ TO D~LOP ~UA~E TO ' . Legal notice having been published tn the Naples Daily News on NOVember 18, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication filed with public hearing was opened to consider Petition A-90-§, bY James L. Karl and Associates, requesting an administrative of the Planning/Zoning Director's decision that the intention .Ordinance is to rustrict the location of establishments whose ie to sell alcoholic beverages while al/oWing ~taurante whose primary use is the Sale of food, to locate within iof other establishments se/ling alcoholic beverages for on- Frank. Brutt, Communi=¥ Development Services Administrator, stated the subject pet~tion is requested to decide if the Planning and Zoning Director's interpretation of the Zoning Ordinance relative to · :spacing between restaurants, nightclubs, etc. serving alcoholic ., t9 correct, He explained that the Zoning Director has made nterpretation that the Ordinance states and ~t is the intention of Ordinance to allow restaurants serving alcoholic beverages of the alcoholic sales is less than ~0~ to be within 500 feet of other, but the Ordinance also requires the spacing of factlit~es, ~nightclubs, bars, etc., that derives more than §0~ of its revs- 'alcoholic sales to be more than 500 feet apart. Mr. Brutt the zoning codes have been reviewed, and it is recom- the Board of Zoning Appeals support the decision made by P.X~ing/Zoning Director. .the petitioner, stated that the issue is not the 500 rather the interpretation of the exemption provided in D of Section 8.il of the Zoning Ordinance. He explained Page 8 December 4, 1990 ation of the exemption from the County was requested cause s client of hie ie looking to open a lounge where the revenue be less than §l~ from the sale of food. He remarked that a was received from the Zoning D~rector which stated, "It is my ~retation =hat the intention of this Ordinance, 'while allowing :taura~ts whose primary use is in the sale of food to locate within ,.:'is tO.restrict the location of establishments whose primary .:it ie to sell alcoholic beverages." He pointed out that the .is if that restaurant is w~thin 500 feet and ts a restaurant derives 51~ or more of its revenue from the sale of food then the should be exempt. He suggested that the "use" of each establish- be the focus and make sure that there is no use within 500 feet Lyes 51~ of its revenue from the sale of alcohol. '.'::County Attorney Cu¥1er described the Issues as Mr. Karl is terprettng the exemption to exclude the restaurant use from the of the Ordinan,=e as opposed to which establishment comes FirSt as in the case of an existing church and a lounge not being to locate within 500 feet, however, a church can be located 500 feet of an existing lounge. ~Commtssioner Saundere commented that it does not make sense that a that can receive 49~ of its sales In alcohol ts allowed to fithin 500 feet of a lounge, but a lounge cannot be located 500 feet of a restaurant. ounty Attorney Cuyler noted that his interpretation of the ordi- that no consumption on premises in establishment will be 500 feet, however, the Board has determined that if you are ~'tmarll¥i~,...~. a restaurant and your sale of alcohol is only ancillary then al/owed an exemption and can locate within 500 feet. Conissioner Volpe questioned if Mr. Karl's interpretation is to ~ou~ge or bar to locate within 500 feet of another to which Kar~ responded no. eeponee to Commies~oner Shanahan, Mr Brutt stated that in his would take an amendment to the Zontng Ordinance to clarify Page 9 December 4, 1990 to be achieved here. this morning. Commissioner ~ncurred. Karl suggested that a clarification to Subsection one of 8.11D be provided to state that the exemption be applied to both the establishment and the adjacent establishment. :[:In response to Commissioner Hasse, County Attorney Cuyler read th* ordinallce the explanation of 500 feet, "that the distance of fleet shall be measured as the shortest distance between the lot on the existing establishment is located and the lot on which the beverages are sold to the public, except that establishments in shopping centers shall be measured to the outer wall of the ishment. Mr. Cuyler added that there is provided a minimum .t...ax!ce variance where if a person meets certain criteria, they can for the variance. ~o~.ge ~el~er, representing Collier Co.t2 Civic Federation, ~tated~ that nothing should be done to ~eaken the ordinance and there be a control on the dtst~ces between businesses dtspensln~ ,~Ce~/ealo~er Shanahan ~r~ed, ~econdad b~ Co--iaaloner Saunders ~ ~~ly, t~t the ~bltc hearing ~ closed. response to Commissioner Volpe's ~est~on regarding zoning, Ken B~ginskl of Pl~nln~ Services Department stated ~here are certain crt- described under the zoning section which a property ts evaluated Bagtneki pointed out that there is a waiver request applica- where under certain circumstances the applicant can request a and use those circumstances to Justify the request before the '.of County Commissioners. ion~r Saunders commented that he does not feel that this -applies to this ordinance. loner Shanahan stated that if Mr. Bagtnski is correct and e,i~ an existing remedy that addressee the problem then the ordi- should be left as Page 10 December 4, 1990 ::County Attorney Cuyler pointed out that there ara two issues pre- are, Mr. Bagtnski~s interpretation and the variance item. explained that the variance item applies to Section 1lA1 which deals With schools, churches, public parks, and playgrounds. Commissioner Volpe suggested more discretion tn the area of a Waiver. He noted that he does not want to see a proliferation of bars ..,~, 'es, however, there needs to flexibility for 'unique response to Commissioner Hasse~s question on who monitors the of alcohol and food sales from an establishment, Mr. Karl that it is regulated by the license that the State issues and La'written into the ordinance that zoning can require an establish- to file ftnancials. ~fl County Attorney Cu¥1er explained that what is being asked is that ~eStaurants be removed from the equation and on1¥ have the 500 foot :~on between place, that derive their primary source of revenue the sale of alcoholic beverages. He stated that the Board can either uphold the Zoning Director's interpretation and do nothing else r/uphold the interpretation and direct staff to review the ordinance gee or overturn the Zoning Director's decision. Sal~dere left the ~eettng at this tine. Commissioner Goodnight voiced her concerns regarding the fact that ~_- is not a §00 foot separation between a restaurant that sells and a restaurant that sells alcohol which makes the ordinance it~nt and recommends That the ordinance be changed to make it It. Com~utoner Shanahan moved, seconded by Commissioner Volpe and $/1 (¢o~ateetoner Goodntght opposed and Co--tsetoner Saunders out of the roo~), to uphold the decision of the Zoning Director. ~C0~utoner S&unders returned to the meeting et this tine. ..' ,Co~teetoner Sh~n~h~n ~3ved, seconded by Commissioner Volpe and unln~u~l¥, to direct staff to develop l~nguage that would proble~ regarding exeeq~ttorm and waiver provisions. 24 Page December 4, 1990 ~0~ A-90-6, KARKN A OR.NOWSKX REPRKSKNTIN~ DEBBIK SKRZYB'SKX, :~ANAPPEAL OF THE PLANNING/ZONIN0 DIRECTOR'S DECISION THAT ' TH~ ~ ON LOTS 13 AND 14, BLOCK 4, GOODLAND HEIOHTS SUBDIVISION, i~. HAV~ LO~T TI~IR NON-CONFORMING USE STATUS - ZONING DIRECTOR'S DECISION ~; Legal notice having been published in the Naples Daily News on ~November 18, 1990, as evidenced by Affidavit of Publication fi/ed with Clerk, public hearing was opened to consider Petition A-90-6, :filed by Eaten A. Ornowskl of Frost and Jacobs, representing an appeal ~f."t.he Planning/Zoning Director*s decision that the uses on Lots 13 Block 4, Goodland Heights Subdivision, have lost their non- ng use status. . '.. Brutt, Community Development Services Administrator, stated the subject petition Is requesting an appeal of the g Director's decision regarding the uses on Lots 13 and "~Blo. Ck 4, in ~oodland Heights Subdivision He explained that tn .... .~-of 1989, notice of violation of the "Housing Code" was served on i,i~ :subject properties and pictures were provided for the record g the buildings state of disrepair. He advised that a building permit was obtained in September of 1989 to do structural Work on one of the units but in November, 1989, the second notice of n of the "Housing Code" was served He informed that the ~l~ca~t dJ.d apply for building permits to do more structural , however, the necessary information requested was not supplied .the applicant and no building permit was issued. He pointed out w~th no repairs being done the houses have continued to Lte, have been vacated, and must be removed. i:'.Mr. Brutt clarified that because the structures have been vacant .-.~... period of time, they no longer comply with the requirement ri°n-conforming section of the Ordinance which would allow ~':. . the structures under the non-conforming status. He epe- that because of the zoning of the property, the two lots can be for the construction of two single-family houses, one on each lot He requested that the Board support the Zoning Dire.ctor*s dect- Page 12 December 4, 1990 response to Commissioner Haese, Mr. Brutt explained that the ~g area of these lots consists of boat trailers being parked lot to the east and a single family homes are located on the Sides. :Z~,:' : loner Shanahan questioned if there is not some provision i~coUld be made so that more than two but a limited number of unite be built that would meet all the current zoning requirements. ,iL~otnted out that 11.1 of the Zoning Ordinance provides such a use says, "equally or more appropriate to the district than the ng non-conforming use, and that the relationship of the struc- to surrounding properties is such that adverse effect on occu- and neighboring properties will not be greater than if the existing non-conforming use ts continued." He related that the desire petitioner is to tear down the existing structures and rep/ace 'with new houses whJe~ would be to the benefit of the community. Mr. Brutt reported that the houses have been vacant for approxima- s~x months. .Colmtsstoner Volpe noted that the subject house is in the coastal hazard area and the plan ts to d~rect population away from this He added that the properties are on septic systems and are y small. ~'Commisetoner Shanahan reiterated that he Is asking if there ts not ~romise that can be made where more than two houses but less ~f~ve houses could be built which would provide for quality, housing on Goodland. Ornowsk~ of Frost & Jacobs, representing the petitioner, s background sum_~ar¥ of the discussions with Dick Clark of )ltance Services. Ms. Ornowskl stated that Mr. Clark has agreed 'the summar~ except for number 5. Ornowskt disagreed with the comment that no document8 were when the second and third permits were requested. She that building appraisals, est/mates of repairs, 8nd site 28 Page 13 ,~ , ..... December ~, ~990 an~:were submitted to the Building Permit Department and not to the ,liancs Services Department or Zoning. She explained that her Lent's contractor had three meetings with Mr. Ron Hedges of the Permit Department, and at that time there was a disagreement whether the 50~ threshold had been surpassed. Ne. Ornowskt noted that she feels that there ts some compromise available within the Zoning Ordinance such as under 6.10D and 6.15 anticipate structural alterations as well as under 11.1. ii,flirt, regards to discontinuance of use of the property, Ms. Ornowski out that the law states that discontinuance or an involuntary CesSation of work to bring repairs Into compliance and tn this case a Bllildtng Code Ordinance does constitute a voluntary discontinuance of 'on the part of the petitioner. She affirmed that her client did to abandon these properties, but rather wanted to repair bring the property up to standard. 5. Ns. Ornowsk! related that the plans of the petitioner are to ,air or replace five cottages to the degree fitting of the Good/and area and be tn compliance with the building code, but resume the non- ng use status. She commented that these houses would be housing and a petition has been signed by the neighbors and s people alike approving of Ms. Skrzynaki's plans. In answer to Commissioner Volpe, Ms. Ornowski explained that the are for rental use and the zoning is for single family residen- e, therefore, this property has a non-conforming use as well as rmlng building. ~ommtsStoner Hasse questioned how long Ms. Skrzynskt has owned :property and how long it has been in this disrepair. Ms. the petitioner, stated that originally she was sited for such as a piece of siding needing to be replaced, wiring Ang to be fixed, and mostly cosmetic items in nature. She ,l&ined that she requested to completely refurbish the houses and building code division concurred; however, with the time necessary .pull permits and the summer rains doing further deterioration of Page 14 December 4, 1990 the property no longer had the no'-conforming use status. pointed out If she had gone ahead and did the patchwork required .not tried to fix the houses up properly, then she would not have today with loosing her non-conforming use status. Ruth Edens, Director of the Goodland Civic Association, presented ~titt°n by the residences of Goodland upholding the zoning for two ..~one on each lot. Dick Clark, Code Enforcement Supervisor, stated that the non- ~f°rming use issue is due to the initiative of Compliance Services enforce the minimum housing code. He explained that because the ' ~le were required to move out and did so for more than 90 days, violates the non-conforming use status which constitutes the loss status. He informed that now the structures are unsafe and needs to be done. response to Commissioner Volpe, County Attorney Cuy]er stated are limitatioh~ to the amount of work that can be done with :ructurss under the non-conforming use status. He explained that the general intent of the non-conforming provision is that eventually the will fall into disrepair and will be replaced with con- ~g:?tructures. He noted that with the new provisions in the however, there is the ability to repair and expand the under the non-conforming use status. Mr. Brutt explained that Sections 6.13 and 6.14 of the ordinance ~hib'it repairs of non-conforming structures when the cost exceeds the current assessed value of the structure. He specified that .the second set of building permits were requested, the petitioner what the current assessed value of the structure was so it be determined whether or not these repairs were tn access of however, the information was never provided. Dr Hasse stated that the deterioration he noted in the could not have happened in only two months time, and com- appears that a lot more than 20~ of repairs are needed. 000 ,, 28 Page December 4, 1990 Ornowski pointed out the violations are clearly stated in the '~er from Compliance Services dated June 26, 1989. She indicated the ordinance would have permitted replacement at the time the were first brought in. She alleged that the circumstances ld be considered using the provisions within the ordinance. [¥Com~issioner Volpe noted that this is a use that is inconsistent the County's Growth Management Plan and ts in support of the of the Zoning Director. sioner Hasse questioned what the assessed valued is of one houses. Hs. Ornowskt replied that the land value is approxtma- $45,000 and the five houses are assessed at $16,O00 total. Carl Edens, owner of adjoining subject property, stated that the have been in a state of disrepair for some time and the rents seem to be tn the affordable housing range, and asked that the of the Zoning Director be upheld. George Keller, President of Collier County Civic Federation, spoke support of upholding the Zoning Director's decision due to the fact these houses are in such disrepair and have been for some time. ~Ms. 0rnowskt recounted that the request is for the application of :.~the ordinance provides in 6.10 revised and 11.1. She pointed out the rents fall in the definition of affordable housing. .In response to Commissioner Saunders, County Attorney Cuyler :ated that if the Board finds that there was a discontinuance of use an,inappropriate amount of time which it appears that there was, he is An support of the staff's recommendation to uphold the Director's decision. C, eeeal~A~ne~ Volpe e~n~ed, ~econded by Co~missloner Shanahan and ~ly, that the public hearlng be closed. · Ce~e~/~ioner Volpe ~ov~d, seconded by Comissioner S~unders and c~t-~ted 4/1 (Co~aissioner Sh~u~ahan opposed), that the interpretation L-ulingby the Planning/Zoning Director be upheld. ~:~,$e$ ltec~m: 10:45 A.M. - Reconvened: 10:55 A.M. at which : t~ Deputy Clark ~uevtn replaced Deputy Clerk Arright .e~ Page 16 December 4, 1990 Till It~JSKUM Iq~(~STIJKI RKIMBURSKMKNT FOR KXFI:NSKS OF THK Chris Lombardo, President of The Friends of the Collier County thanked the Board for its support of the Indian Days Festival ~was very successful with more than 18,000 in attendance, repre- ~ng more than a 50~ increase over 1989. He requested reimbur- of the $24,569 spent by The Friends of the Museum over the of the F~stival. He said part of that cost was $15,000 aseo- with the installation of permanent overhead lighting in the grounds, as well as permanent ampage systems for electrical to handle the of variety vendors and exhibits. He listed other expenditures, concluding that the funds utilized have a majority of the resources of The Friends of the Museum. He ed reimbursement from Collier County contingency funds, ting the County reimburse itself from bed tax revenues. Commissioner Saunder~ asked how the revenues generated from the were used? ~!Mr. Lombardo replied the only revenues were generated from the posters, which totaled $1,351.25. He said that amount has been spent in the continuation of the work on the Children's ieCovery Cottage. answer to Commissioner Shanahan, Mr. LomUardo replied that the $24,569, The Friends spent $5,000 for a permanent sound and approximately $7,000 on various other expenses. Commissioner Volpe commented the Board has recently completed et hearings, and this request was not included. He said he is with The Friends asking for money from contingency funds purpose, after-the-fact. M~. Lombardo explained that during the budgeting process, The were not certain where they stood in terms of the bed tax, ..made a difference in how to approach the County or whether to the.County at all. He indicated his feeling that this is not so much for County funds, but for bed tax funds. Page 17 December 4, 1990 Volpe remarked that a council will be appointed to applications for bed tax funds, and the Board should not act on ad hoc basis outside the recommendations of that council to ~rtate those funds, ~i¢ommtssioner Saunders asksd what the status is regarding the bed :.and what happens if the County loses the law suit? County Cuyler replied that the case has gone through the trial level currently at the appellate level. He said the County has taken to keep those funds secure until the appeal is over and if is unsuccessful, the Court will determine what to do with money already collected. Commissioner Shanahan asked if the Board has the authority to ear- from contingency funds with the possibility of refunding it bed tax is defended successfully in court, to which County tf Cuyler replied in the affirmative. Commissioner Shanahan the Board to suppor~ the Museum. .. Coemtseloner Shanahan ~oved, seconded by Co~mieetoner Ooodntght to ~~ $24,569 to ~e ~ten~ of the ~s~ out of conttngen~ wi~ ~ ~11 ~erst~tng t~t the ~d will ask the T=tst itviso~/ Coattt# to reimburse the County when ~nd if t~ Co~tsstoner Volpe indicated he cannot support the motion, stating ~this re,est ts approved, the Board will be inundated with requests other people tn very similar circumstances. He added The Friends the ~useu~ will continue to have the opportunity to apply for bed .-funds if they become available. leorge Keller, President of the Collier County Civic Federation, there are many organizations in the County that are doing because they want to, and they do not come in after-the-fact ..ask the Board to pay for them. He concluded the Board should set :edent at this meeting that these type of requests will not be Commissioner Volpe asked Mr. Lombardo what the $24,569 was ortgi- 31 Page 18 December 4, 1990 bUdgeted for? Mr. Lombards responded that money was raised by !:Friends of the Museum and will be returned to the County in the of the Childrens' Discovery Cottage. He stated The Friends have ~n Improving the Museum for the past eight years, and in the past years have raised over $500,000, built the museum and taken care grounds. i:In answer to Commissioner Hasse, Mr. Lombards stated that the ~itiVal has been paid for, however, they do not have the ability to forward with any other project. He said the Children's Discovery will be left in an incomplete construction state because the were expended for the Indian Days Festival. Hasse commented it is very difficult for him to vote for The Friends of the Museum, however, he supports .Ssioner Volpe's view that this proposal is after-the-fact, and ..County does not yet have the funds from the source being 'Charlotte Westman, representing the League of Women Voters of er County, stated this request has an element of good faith. She :ated her support for the petition. 'Commissioner Saunders stated that, in his opinion, this is not a JtAon of good faith. He said all Board members have supported the however, the Tourist Development Council is Just now in the :ess'of being established to review requests for funds for all of categories of uses under the Tourist Development Tax, if when those dollars become available. He stated it would be highly ~riate for the Board to begin discussions with any organization funding cultural events as part of that expenditure until a is presented by the Council. He added relative to using money the contingenc~f fund, those dollars are for unexpected expen- 'es that are absolutely necessary, and if the County experiences a [cane during the next season, funds may not be available to con- with it if the contingency fund is raided now. ~ioner Volpe asked if money has been allocated in Non-CIE Page 19 December 4, 1990 that may be used for improvement of the Museum? Manager Dorrill answered in the affirmative, stating there than average chance that additional Non-CIE one mill fund will be possible for the Museum project. ~0mmisstoner Volpe stated he wanted to make that point, because he want the impression left that the County is not doing for the Museum. He said the County has been working hand in With The Friends of the Museum to complete that project. emphasized that the greatest support The Friends have =ei~ed throughout the project has been from the County and this of County Commissioners. He said the fact that they have ',mplished what they have is due primarily because of that support. :ated his appreciation, and also that he understands that a against this request is not a vote against the Museum. :ommissioner Volpe m,~ntioned if this request is not approved, The Friends will still have the opportunity to go back to the Tourist ~loPment Council and make the same application for reimbursement. .Call for the question, the ~otton failed 2/3 (Com~isstoners e~ud Volpe opposed. ) :ounty Attorney Cuyler pointed out that if a Notice of Appeal is the bed tax funds will become available within 30 days. ~PR~NTING THE C09~KINITY IMPROVEMENT COMMITTEE OFT HE IM~L~-PIk~E ~ ~IATI~ ~STI~ WA~ OF TI~IN~ ~S - County Manager Dorrtll explained this is a routine request for a [ver of tipping fees in conjunction with a neighborhood clean-up Isioner Hasse stated his concern that the applicant is not · to petition the Board on his own behalf. ,.Manager Dorrill advised the Board that he communicated )licant by letter, Informing him that he was scheduled to this meeting. He commented that were it not for the fact the clean-up is scheduled for December 8th, he would recommend Page 20 Co~a~tt# of th~ Naplee Park Area Association for a waiver ~D for their nei~hborhood cle~n-up on Deceaber 8, 1990. P~ RE APPEAL OF BUILDING OFFICIAL'S DECISION - ~ OF ~PPROVED WITH CONDITIONS Frank Brutt, Community Development Administrator, explained that ~Palmer is appealing the suspension of his building permit ia(single family dwelling unit on Marco Island. He stated that due ; :~. ! i .. · .illness and ultimate death of the applicant's wife, delays in resulted in the expiration of his building permit. He cared complaints were filed because there had ~een no activity ~ng place, and the applicant was advised when re-issued a building rmit'on March 30, 1990, that construction must continue in a proper [on and that at least 60~ of the project must be completed within ~onths. As a result of no activity taking place on the site that time, he said, the building permit~ was suspended. [~iDlck Clark, Code Enforcement Supervisor, related that this has anon-going problem for over two and one-half years. He stated very unsightly and is a danger to children. He said Staff :opposed to the construction if' it.is carried out in a serious He suggested that if the permit is re-issued, that it be con- tioned to require the structure be constructed by a licensed that it be completed within six months and a Certificate be obtained within that six month period. He added Staff tuesting a notarized copy of the loan commitment letter to construction be furnished to Customer Services at the time of resurrection of the permit. He concluded that Staff would like to iisi:ithe applicant as much as possible, however, concerns of the who have been exposed to this lengthy problem must also be 000 PAG i 3A Page 21 December 4, ~990 xer Saunders asked Hr. Palmer if he. was agreeable to the imposed by Staff, to which ha replied tn the affirmative. 0mts~lm~er Saundera ~oved, seconded by Co~aisstoner Shan~han to .Is/Id/rig lmrmlt with the above condltton~. Hr. Clark requested the Board add a further stipulation that !ing each two months, one third of the construction must be '~fileted, and failure to do so will nullify the building permit. Hr, Palmer indicated his agreement to the added stipulation. S~md~rs amended the ~otion to reflect the added con- s~c~ by Commissioner Shanahan and carried unanimously. ~glkl* FLAT~ OF II~OEALEE HABIT&T FOR HUMANITY, INC. ("NISSION VILLAGZ · ~ ON~ AND UNIT TWO=) - APPROVED WITH STIPULATIONS ... Oommiutoner Saunders ~oved, seconded by Coutsatoner Shanahan and o~z~ied un~n/mousl¥, that the Final Plata of Im~okalee Habitat for Inc., ("#tsaton Village Unit One and Unit Two") b~ approved mtipui,~lons -- &ccept the Irrevocable Letter of Credit as security to :f*'(guarantee completion of the subdivision improvements. the recording of the Final Plats of lmmokalee '; -Habitat for Humanity, Inc., ("Mission Village Unit One and Unit Two"). 3. Authorize the Chairman to execute the construction and main- tenance a~reement. no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the required Improvements have received preliminary acceptance. Page 22 December 4, 1990 iliB:~)r-UTIOII 90-582 GR&NTZII'G PREL~~ ACC~PTANCZ OF ~ ROAI~AY, ~.;'D'R&IN&G~, M&/~R i,R'D SEM~R ZNIVR~S FOR /qrE FINAL PLAT OF ~:~ ~' ~ PzN~s" - AIX)PTED ~FITH STIPULATIORS Co~mtmsloner Saundere ~oved, seconded by Co,missioner Shanahan and ~c~t~d ~n~ni~ously, that Resolution 90-582 b~ adopted granting prelL- ~ept~nc~ o£ th~ ro~bmy, drain&ge, w~ter and m~r t~prove- the F.~l Plat of '#tlloughby Pines', with the following · Accept the Maintenance and Escrow Agreement as security for maintenance of the infrastructure until the Board of County Co~tssioners grants final acceptance of all improvements. Authorize the Chairman to execute the Maintenance Agreement for Preliminary Acceptance. Preliminary acceptance of improvements will not become effec- tive until water and sewer facilities have been conveyed to Collier County Water-Sewer District. 13' Page 23 .... .r;.... December 4, 1990 FACILITIES FOR NILLOUGRBY PINES - &CCEPTED WITH Shanahan ~wed, seconded b~ Co~teeloner aoodn~ght C~Tted unamt~m~l¥, to accept the water and sewer facilities for Piz~e with the following stipulations: The water facilities to serve the project cannot be placed Into service and no Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued until the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation fur- nishes a letter authorizing placement of the sewer system into service and approving the water distribution system for service, and; Bacteriological testing has met the County's requirements, .The Fire Flow requirements of the project have been satisfied, and the Fire District furnishes a letter accepting the fire hydrant for ownership and maintenance. OR Book ~ Pages ~~'~ C & S BANE - ACCILTT~DWITH STIPULATIONS ~ ~C~, seco~dt~ t~Z Co~islionlr Sa~u3~rs ~ ~~ly, to acc~t t~ ~ter facilitie~ for C & r¸ -following stipulations: The water facilities to serve the project cannot be placed into service and no Certificate of Occupancy shall be issued until the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation fur- nishes a letter approvin~ the water distribution system for service. Bacteriological testing has met the County's requirements. The Fire Flow requirements of the project have been satisfied, and the Fire District furnishes a letter accepting the fire hydrant for ownership and maintenance. ook /j"£3 ages ;. trl'Tl~ ~ D'~'I~'~LOP'~:P.~ OF THE PALMETTO RIDGE SUBDM$ION FOI~ ~01 OF THE WILLOUGHBY ACRES STORM DRAINAGE SYSTEM - dter Carter, Transportation Director, presented a request by :;:for the developer to revise his site plan to construct a portion ,,storm drain improvement for Palmetto Ridge Subdivision in the Acres Improvement District. He said the proposed agreement December 4, 1990 commitments by the developer to install the drainage struc- :es/and pipe, and address any utility confl~'cts that may come about lng construction. He reported the County wtll commit to provide , valued at approximately $20,000. He mentioned that the Summary Incorrectly statss funding will be from Fund 325. this project will actually be paid from Fund ill, the :orporated ~eneral Fund, and will be a reimbursable loan out of Acres Drainage Improvement District for the pipe only. Shanahan ~d, ~ecoaded b~ Co~issioner Volpe and m~an~u~u~ly, to mpprov~ an m~ree~ent with thru developers of l~'~J,~tto P..id~e ~v~s~ for p~t~a~ co~ct~ of ~ 52 90-41 AND 90-45 - ADOPTED ~~ Shanahan ~nmd, seconded !~ Co,missioner Goodntght ~z~ied m~ntm~ml¥, that Budget A~md~ent. 90-41 And 90-45 be OF ~ r/~TERNAL SERVICE FUND TO FINANCE THE CO~ OF John Yonkosky, Finance Direc~or, explained ~his As a recommen- by ~he Clerk of Courts for direc~ion ffrom the Board to Lsh ~ ~nternal service f~d tn order to partially a~locate char~es n~ paid by the ~eneral t~ayer to the users that are by ad valorem t~es. He reported this will result In $1~,000 in savin~s. C0~issi0ner Volpe asked if departments have not budgeted for this wi~ f~ds come from their contin~ency funds? ~Clerk G~les angered tn the affirmative, advising that presently 'departments are charged for postage only, and this will tack on a ge to cover the operating expense ~d attempt to divert the from ad valorem t~es to user fees and other sources. He said is spread out through many departments and there will not be a ~eat impact for any one department. He stated the only ~estton to establish this fund now or wait ~other year. an~er to Co~t~ M~ager Dorrtll, Clerk Giles replied this effective January 1, 1991. to.f~ce t~ c~te of ~rating ~ co~'e inte~l LEADKRSHIP SCHOOL INVOICE - APPROVED TO BE PAID FROM BUDGET Mr, Yonkosky 8tared this item deals with an outstanding Invoice Naples Leadership School. He explained a contract with North Page 26 December 4, 1990 Outward Bound School was sl~ned by the former director of the Naples Leadership School Department. He reported the total was for $5,400 of which all but $900 has been paid by the D~rectors of the Naples Leadership School, who is requesting ii'County pay the remaining portion. Gerr~ Olmsted, Court Administrator, explained that this program not been budgeted for FY 9! He stated that because of miscom- the former director sent an entire class to the North Outward Bound School without notifying the Board of ~ectors. He said, as a result, the Board paid $4,500 which is all had, and is requesting the Board of County Commissioners pay the $900. He indicated the funds were designated in last year's Mr. Yonkosk¥ explained that since this program is not part of the for this fiscal year, there are no longer designated funds to this invoice. He said it can be paid through the Court atton budget or appropriated from contingency funds, however, not a budgeted item. Mr..Olmsted pointed out that if the funds to pay this invoice come oma. this year~s C~rt Administration budget, he may be back before ~Board of Cowry Co~ss~onere In the coming months re~estlng Co~s8toner Saunders asked if the County Is obligated to pay for b~ll? Mr. Yonkosky responded th~s is a function that the Naples .p School as a non-profit entity has paid for in prior years. that although a former County employee s~ed the contract, he };not believe the County ts legall~ obligated to pay these expen- ~et~.tonoz* Sm~n~Sorfs moved, oeconded b~ Con~ooLo~= Vol~ ~ ~ly, t~ the 0000 ~ paid ~r~ tho ~ Ol C~ COLLrn COUFfY ~ crrIzE~s & s0u~maN ~ATI0m~L BA~K ADVISORY sm~v~czs -~lrr~D TO ~_A_~_~/Z~o Page 27 presented an agreemen~ between Southern National Ba~ (C~S) for financial advtsor~ ser- reco~ended Board approval. M~ager Dorrtll mentioned there has been a coordlnatton ~tween hts office and tha~ of the Clerk of Courts on this Re said this ts historically a management agreement and since not had the opportunity to review it, he requested this be for one week. S~underm moved, ~econded b~ Coma~e~toner S~ to ~~ ~ ~t~ to the ~t~ of ~c~r 11, 1990. Co~tes~oner Volpe asked for ~ expl~atton of certain port,one of to which Cowry Attorney ~yler replied that he will a report for the next meeting. T__~?. ISSUANCE OF COLLIER COUNTY ~P~CIAL H~V~NUE BONDS AND AWARDING THE BONDS TO M~RRILL LYNCH & CO. ,Ron McLemore, Assistant County Manager, reported.this Involves the of the Gargtulo property and the necessary funds to ~ the ground level parking facility. He said the Intent was tng. to the Board the actual bond resolution and bond purchase · He Indicated, however, the current Interest rate Is 7~, County stays tn the market place for a few more days, that be lower. He asked that this item be continued for one ;an~ also requested to extend the scheduled closing date on the ~;to December 2~, ~9~0. f?i]~"~'' With ¢&S, agreed with Mr.,McLemore and advised the [nue this Item. '.~cLemore added that the representative for the Gargiulo pro- aGTeed to extend the closing date. Volpe Indicated hie belief that the Count~ ts £ng 'too much money, stating there ts already $500,000 currently '~ the Non-CIE element of the Growth Hanagement 62' Pags 28 December 4, 1990 me improvements. He questioned if this entire expense can be paid the one mill capital improvement levy, i.e., pay cash? · McLemore orated the County does not have the $3.81 million would be necessary to do that. ~In answer to Commissioner Volpe, County Manager Dorrill replied entire amount is not available because of other projects, the c~ntral library, the agriculture facility building and )letton of the Health Department. !;"-~mio~e~ 8~unders moved, seconded tr~ Co~iaaioner S~ ~nd unanimously, to continue this item to the ~eeting of December ~ DIR:~CT~D TO &FFLY FOR A VARI&NC~ R~t~DIIltt TR~ SIGN Commissioner Goodntght explained that the Naples Area Chamber of has recently moved and, because of the County's Sign idinance, their existing sign ts now too large for their new quar- She requested the Board allow the Chamber to move their old the new location. Oatee, Executive Vice President of the Naples Area Chamber Co.merce, stated the sign would be placed in front of the building ;Xt'has been in the past. ~ommtsstoner Volpe mentioned that, to his knowledge, there is no tn the Sign Ordinance to allow for an exemption. He also %ated that aesthetics are a consideration in terms of size and loca- of the sign. He related that the Chamber of Commerce represents community, and Collier County Is requiring all the mem- of the Chamber to comply with the Sign Ordinance. He remarked re may be a number of businesses in that membership who could similar hardship argument. He concluded he has difficulty sup- 'this for exemption. Saunders commented there is also a variance procedure be followed. Page 29 ~:%":~' .... : December 4, 1990 Goodnight advised that the reason she requested this em be on the agenda is because the Board has a/ready allowed a simi- )t/on with the gver~lades boat tour ~L:Commtsstoner Volpe asserted that the difference between both is, vandalism was the cause of the boat tour sign needing to ~laced. C0mmtsstoner Shanahan communicated his desire that the Chamber .all°wed. · to keep the identity they have established over many years the current sign, and his hope that there is a procedure that 'a/low them to do that. In ~nswer to Commissioner Volpe, County Attorney Cuyler responded .in accordance with the normal variance t~e procedure, there .ill, have to be some showing of hardship to allow a non-conforming John WIlver, Customer Service Supervisor, stated that the Chamber not have the requir,,~ frontage for a free standing ground sign. the Sign Ordinance allows a variance for a 12-foot community board for charitable organizations, however, he ts not cer- if the variance procedure is appropriate to an exempt sign. Commissioner Volpe commented that the Chamber's sign is 18 square WIlver stated that the Chamber must apply for a variance, Staff will have a problem using an existing sign as a ,.dshtp, or granting a special privilege that would not be granted to ~ltcants. s advised that the Chamber of Commerce is attempting to sign in time for the seasonal onslot of visitors. He what the procedure will be to r~turn to the Board? BrUtt, Community Development Administrator, stated the ~tance procedure requires review by the CCPC prior to being placed a. Board of County Commissioners agenda. Mr. Wtlver advised that the Chamber may erect the 18-foot sign for as a wall sign, because they are allowed 20~ of the wall it 64 Page 30 December 4, 1990 ~'"the consensus that the.'.Ch~ber of Co~erce apply for a erect their st~. .. ~ ~ FI~ ~T OF "~IR P~ - ~ AcCept the construction, maintenance and escrow agreement as security to ~uarantee completion of the subdivision improve- ments. 2;~ :' Authorize the recording of the Final Plat of "Montclatr ,;:,,.~ ~:: Park". Authorize the Chairman to execute the construction, main- tenance and escrow agreement. .4. That no Certificates of Occupancy be granted until the '" required Improvements have received preliminary acceptance. That preliminary acceptance of Embassy Woods Golf and County Club at Bretonrs Park Phase Two be granted prior to prelimi- i:ii':narF acceptance of the improvements within this plat. 6,¸ Authorize the Clerk of the Circuit Court to make proper nota- tion of this action upon the previous plat. See Pages 74- 90--814 PROVIDI~ FOR ASSUSMENT OF LI~N FOR THH COST OF PO~ZIC ON LOT 78 RONALD R. B~LL See Pages 90-8S8 FROVIDIN~ FOR ASSESSMENT OF LIEN FOR TH~ COST OF O~PUBLIC NUISANCI~ ON LOT 22, BLOCK'103, OF MARCO BEACH UNIT TI~, ~ N~IANN, PA, R~GISTEREDA~IIT FOR DIMARCO ~ DIMARCO, See Pages~~~_~__~ FI~OVIDIIG FOR A~S~MENT OF LIEN FOR THE COST OF NUISANCE ON LOT 21, BLOCK 153, GOLDEN ~ATE, UNIT ' See Pages~ o~ ,~' ~ 90-88T FI~OVIDING ~ ASSP~SMElqT OF LIEN FOR THE COST OF ~ZC ~S~ ~ L~ 4, 5 ~ 6, BL~ 14, GOL~ · 2 ~D R. ~~ ~~S V~I~ ~ See Pages December 4, 1990 90--588 PROVIDING FOR ASSZSSl~NT OF LIEN FOR THE COST OF OF PUBLIC NUISANCE ON LOT 12, BLOCK 268, UNIT 7 PART, GOLDEN 90-599 FROVIDING FOR ASSESSMENT OF LIEN FOR THE COST OF PUBLXC NUISANCE ON LOT 37, BLOCK 81, GOLDEN GAT~ UNIT NO. :~;~?,,~;~1~ ~, JR., REGISTERED AGEF~ FOR 3. #. 3. I'~irEBTM~ITS, See Pages ff '~'" 0(~ (~ PttOVIDING FOR ASSESSMENT OF LIEN FOR THE COST OF PUBL'rc NUIS*A~ICE ON LOT 38, BLOCK 81, GOLDEN G&TE UNIT NO. Tlt'UPI&.NO, JR., REGISTERED ,AGENT FOR 3. #. 3. .*'JO~EPH THOPIANO, JR., REG!ST~R~D A~EIIT FOR 3. W. 3. See Pages 90-591 PROVIDING FOR A~SESSM~NT 0Y LIEN FOR THE COST 0F OF P~BZ, ZC NUISANCE ON ~ 39, B~*'81, GOLD~ ~ ~T NO. I~S~, See Pages ~O--592 PROVIDING FOR ASSESSM~IIT OF LIEN FOR THE COST 0F · ~lO ~S~ ON ~ I~ ~. ~IXO, C/0 ~ a. ~SINO · O-SgS FROVIDING FOR ASSESSMENT OF LIEN FOR TI~ COST 0F FO~ZC NUISANCE ON LOT 21, BLOCK 209, UNIT 6, PART l, &. PrlITERr JR. AND MAR~ 3. PINT~t See Pages 90-594 FROVIDXNG FOR AS~SI~NT OF LIEN FOR TH~ COST OF ffO~XO ~IO*XSA,I~ ON ~ 8, ~ 4 OF MARCO BE~CH UNIT SeePages FACXLITXES ACC~f~D FOR IMPERIAL PLAZA - I~ITH water facL1Lttee to serve the project cannot be placed ~tnto service and no Certificate of Occupancy'shall be /ssued ' Page 32 mm= 'ttr~n ~ 'iYlorida , EnvAronmemtal: RegUlation fur- ,e~e:~a ~ le~er au~hor~zAng::~he:: placemen~ o~ the "sewer ~ AnCo ee~ice ~d 'apPr~ing the wa~er dis~ri~ion' 8ys~em ~or ~,'r ~- ~ac~eriological ~es~tng ha~ me~ ~he Co~'~ re~iremen~s. ~e ~Are ~low retirements o~ ~he proJec~ have been aa~ia~Aed, ~d ~he ~ire Dis~rAc~ ~urnishes a ~e~er accep~Ang ' '~he ~ire h~dran~ ~or o~erahip and maintenance. ~:.~:~:. TO EIr/'ECTJLW I']ITERF~IDTRMISI~]tBET~EEIC0~I~I~XTY C[,~l~ OF COUR'I~ - IN '1"1~ ~ OF ~12,423 AND PURCKASK RKt~K~SXTXON' AFPIK)VKD FOR BLOCK II~SOLOTX01'90-595 ACCNPTX]~Fi"V~ (5) D~gDSWXTHOUTNA.'~ANTYI~ON F~Oi"~l~f~~ Ill $~CTZONS 22, 27, 33 & 34, TO~II'SHXP 47 i~I'A'I~','~ 29 ~.AST; A]ID SECTZOII'S 3, 4, 9, 10, 15 & 16, ~IP 48 :~OUTH, RABqJE 29 EAST, COLLXKR COUNTY, FLORIDA, FOR PARCKT.,S DONATKD BY FROPKItTYOWIXRS TO COLLIER COUNTY FOR THE CAMP ICKAIS ROAD See Pages /~ ~" ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~R S~CXFIC CO~ITI0~ I~LVXRG OF S.R. 951 ~ZN P~L 240~ ~GLK ~KK D~0~ a4o IZ,2~'S DXS~II~ ZIXTIATXV~ APPI, ICATION, AM:EIDI'I~ TO ADDX'T~O~' (FF ~6,785 11 FOlqD 223, C0~f ~ 155979 67 Page 33 c~ntJ~uld to 12/la/90 JLRD AI4~IDI4~IT A(FR.~IEI"IT~ WI:TH COWSO~P., TOMI~IID & ~ ASSOC.; VICTOR 3. ~e~~ 30t 1991 TO ~ FOR ~ lm~C]~,Sl L'q'D D~,~ 0]' ~ lq3R ~ D~RZN~ ~ 90/"91 (R.~]I'E~AL OF BZD NO. 89-1501) TO ~0'$ SOD XM TI~ AMOUNT--S2 & ?.a .~a~:ll~ 111 TI~ ~ OF ~4St545 ': 1990 T~X ROT, Z, ,~!. ',~, 990.*;41 9. o~42 )-38 L990~40 .990-43 Date 11/20/90 v',-~ ,,~ : December 4, 2990 ~ ~ I~IMAT~ NO~. 59596, ~5841, ~59210, 66208, A62380, A62685 A40220 ,following miscellaneous correspondence was filed and/or to the various departments as indicated below: Letter dated 11/21/90 to BCC from James C. Giles, Clerk of Court, re public hearing on 12/18/90 re Wayne C. Ashley requesting to vacate, renounce and disc/aim the right, of the County and the Public to a 20t alley for the purpose of constructing a service station driveway. Filed. David Lawrence Mental Health Center, Inc., Report in Accordance with the Office of Management and Budget Circular A-110 for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 1990, from Coopers & Lybrand. Filed. David Lawrence Mental Health Center, Inc., Financial .Statements, together with Report of Independent Accountants Ji:'.?i .for June 30, 1990 and 1989, from Coopers & Lybrand. Filed. Department of Community Affair. Florida Small Cities Community Development Block Grant Program, Economic Development Category - Phases II and III: Notice of Funding Availability. C~ptes to Neil Dorrill, Russell Shreeve, and flied. Letter dated 11/19/90 to Chairman, BCC, from Jon M. Iglehart, Environmental Specialist, Department of Environmental Regulation, re Collier County - WRR, File No. 111890495, application for dredge and fill activities by Halstatt Partnership. Copies to Harry Huber, Nell Dorrtll, Frank Brutt, and flied. Letter dated 11/26/90 to Chairman, BCC, from 3on M. Iglehart, Environmental Specialist, Department of Environmental Regulation, re Collier County - WRR, .File No. 111892795, application for mangrove alteration activities by Collier Development Corp. Copies to Frank Brutt, Nell Dorrt11, Bill Lorenz, and filed. Memo dated 11/15/90 to BCC from W. Warren Mulhertn, Chief Internal Auditor, Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services, re Findings Regarding Compliance with Professional Standards Based Upon a Review of the Independent Audit Report for: Audit Period: September 30, 1989; CPA Firm: Coopers & Lybrand; Audit Number: 89L526H. Copies to John Yonkosky, Budget, and flied. ~' ~Ne~o dated 11/15/90 to BCC and Nell Dorrtll from Jane ;:!Polkowski, M.D., P.P.H., HRS Public Health Unit Director, re St. Louis Encephalitis Update. Letter dated 11/19/90 to BCC from Tony D. McNeal, Engineer, Bureau of Coastal Engineering and Regulation, Department of Natural Resources, re Request for Public Comment; File Number: CO-300; Applicant: Curt J. and Carol 3. Richter. Copies to Neil DorrIll, Harry Hub.r, Frank Brutt, and filed. Dated 11/10/90 from the Division of Administrative Hearings, re Development Order 90-1 issued by the BCC for The Regency Page 35 December 4, 1990 · Village of Naples Development of Regional Impact: Department of Com~unity Affairs8 Notice of Voluntary Dismissal. Copy to .~f.'. Nail Dorri11, and filed. Letter dated 11/14/90 to Chairman Hasse from Robert L. .Patton, Controller, Collier County Tax Collector's Office, re distribution of Current Ad Valorem Tax after Tax Collector's · commissions. Copies to John Yonkosk¥, Budget, and filed. Letter dated 11/20/90 to Chairman Hasse from Robert L. .... Patton, Controller, Collier County Tax CollectorSs Office, re ~i]'~';:dtstrtbutton of Current Ad Valorem Tax after Tax Collector's :~i~.commtsstons. Copies to John Yonkosky, Budget, and filed. ;la.<? Notices of Public Meetings and Public Hearings from the Land Acquisition Advisory Council. Copies to Nail Dorrt11, Frank Brutt, Bill Lorenz, and filed. · Land and Water Adjudicatory Commission re Development Order 90-1 issued by the BCG for The Regency Village of Naples Development of Regional Impact: Department of Community Affairs' Notice of Voluntary Dismissal, dated 11/16/90. Copy to Nail Dorrill, and filed. ~15'. Ntnutes Received and Filed: Ochopee Fire Control District Advisory Board Meeting Minutes of 10/1/90. Golden Gat= Estates Citizens Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes of 9/21/90. 16;:.<i~Nottce to Owner dated 11/15/90 to Collier County from Robert [~.~'::.:~ L. Johnston, agent for CES Industries, Inc., d/b/a Consl. :: glectrlc Supp, under an order gfven by BCC re FTM 20119-01 ~: Emergency Services, Golden Gate Parkway, for miscellaneous .<' electrical supplies and equipment. Copies to John Yonkosky, Steve Carnal1, and filed. i~?;-:/ Notice to Owner dated 1~/21/90 to D.N. H~ggtns, Inc., and BCC from Griffith Paving, under an order given by Perez-Nar, Inc., for Collier County South Service Area, W.W. Transmissions Facilities (Water Pump Stations 3.01, 3.03 and 3.08} for limerock and asphalt. Copies to Steve Carnell, John Yonkosk¥, and filed. Notice to Owner dated 11/21/90 to Better Roads, Inc., and BCC from Linder Industrial Machinery Go., under an order given by T & S Utilities, Inc., for CR 951 4 Laning (Junction 23rd Ave. to Golden Gate Blvd.), Project #65063, Bid #89-1§08, for rental equipment. Copies to Steve Carnell, John Yonkosky, and flied. :: Notice to Owner dated 11/20/90 to Gr~at Monument Construction Co. and BCC from R. Waterfteld, agent for Patent Scaffolding Co., under an order given by Great Monument Construction Co. for 831 7th St. SW, Naples, a/k/a/ Water Booster Pumping Station, Project #90412, for scaffolding and related materials. Copies to John Yonkosky, Steve Carnal1, and ~::~.'~.' : 9~90 i:ilNOt~ce t° Owner dated 11/ to BCC from Donald L. Brinley/Builders Trade Services, Inc., under an order given by Chats Landscaping for St. Andrew's Road "South Collier :: .'Waste Water Treatment Project", E PA # CI 2059?020, for .. m~ecellaneous irrigat~on materials. Copies to John Yonkosk¥, /.~.,~.... Steve Carne11, and f~lad. ~ ~'.¢? 7~ Page 36 · .,~ ..:' December 4, 1990 NotiCe to Owner dated 11/21/90 to BCe from Ms. Burma Starkey, ,,~,pagentfor Dick's Dr~wall,~Inc., under an order given by Rutledge & Sons, Inc., for Health Services Bldg, HRS Bldg ' .M NSC Sob #: D3986 & SBA Ent Naples, FL 125026, for metal stud framing, drywall and stucco with all related items. Copies to Steve Carnell, John Yonkosk¥, and filed. Notice of Service Hearing Before the Public Service Commission to Southern States Utilities, Inc., Deltona Utilities, Inc., the Office of Public Counsel and All Other Interested Persons re Docket No. 900329-WS: Application for ~i~:f. a Rate Increase; Issued: 11/14/90. Copies to Neil Dorrill, ~, . Mike Arnold, and filed. ;23,: .. Notice of Hearing Before the Public Service Commission to ,:~ · Florida Power & Light Company and All Other Interested Persons re Docket No. 900796-EI: Petition for Inclusion of Sharer Unit No. 4 Purchase in Rate Base, Including an Acquisition Adjustment of Florida Power & Light Company; Issued: 11/14/90. Copies to Net1 Dorrtll, Mike Arnold, and filed· '/Notice.of Nearing BefOre the Public Service Commission to Florida UtilitieS'Corporation, the Office of Public ~; ,Counse! ~nd All Other Interested Persons re Docket No. 900329-WS= Application for a Rate Increase; Issued: 11/20/90. Copies to Mike Arnold, Nell Dorrill, and filed. Notice of Cancellation of Commission Hearing to All Parties and Ail Other Interested Persons re Docket No. 890486-TL: Petition by Cttlz~ns of Florida to Compel Compliance with Rule 25-14.003, Florida Administrative Code, by United Telephone Company of Florida Regarding Calculation of and Netho~ of Refunding 1988 Tax Savings; Issued: 11/21/90. Copies to Mike Arnold, Nail Dorrtll, and flied. "~here being no further business for the Good of the County, the lng was adjourned by Order of the Chair -,. Time: 12:25 P.M. the Board on or aa corrected Page 37