06/09/2015 (CR) '-t
'9 /
d
A 0
V
nk 4 4V..1 .
a g'
e) e
tc. 7 vl
..~.... 2 .......#
XI CD � a m a
3 cQ
0�
-ID 0 -
C \ m
co 1I a)CL
r a
0 _
D = o m � 0 :°. A �
0 COQ 51 KTm = 3
�0 2 (7 M " 1'C - z
zcn cnmc
cmnz 0 0M G '�- o
E cn00 --1 mz � L •
rn m -I 0 m = 1
0
M- O6 xi R 1
0 zm m Ozz 1;4
m g m cn > m V_
O -o - ^ m � z
O
xi
0roo .W� � i- 0
O 0 D = W o CO
z C e.zo -iz D CD
Oc -I mO w -n=
O � m 0DD Q ° ^"'
M Do (/n r 0 Cn 7D -0 CL
o m a w
-1 O m D Cl)cn =
pz,
m '-- - O � c o c cp
n c < -i—
O ao C o
-1 ccnnK 23 0c00
1'=17 n z ~�� 0 '11
Q
I-' CD p O oOZ '�.�
m rill- E > co D 4a ma
O mW Z mzm � n
Z 00 U) ODr .
Z Z m z 7i
� m O 20
cn- r- -I D � al °o O Z
1 CO m 1� 2 D -..-4 ND 7 � ' l
Dm > p :1 .-
MI cj D Q z mo
D m mO o mm L
33 cn 0
° � MI 03
M O * p ooTi r-
xi m0 p = cn ,
z- < z (%) moot'73
r mm z 0p r
a oz r moo
ra
xp o D z co
r c ° —1 -1o9<0
- m 2 cET)
DJ m z --i
cn 0 -<
z 2
0 >
73
CD co m D
-
al a a CO a•`n Ca CD
CD a M
0
v
,1∎ CO
o _ ,,
-0 = 0 rn � o r° �. �--�-
D = M r o ° m UP'
N.
0 03m Km = = l
m G_ -zi � oc� V z
C, Z (q rn ui m pc
O mZ v omz I n 0
▪ v O 1 0 m ° 0 •
U
M• "' -I -1 CDO °
rn Oz ml m0D
v z °m rn GZz
-n r ° m cn > m O -0 ° ^• m �0 Z
O nD - � Wo CO
Z m Z = -< °w
—1 0 ° _1 mow Q -n O
M o K rn c, D D 12 o -.
= -n cn r- � cn m -v
o -n a
p m D cn
W = �° O z -i rn CI ci _�am
r = m op m 0m ° (7
M mm -G �- m • 3
-1 020 O mz °m •
O �o C c,
m 00 0 > zo v,.
✓ cn o O ° c, Z .. O
m m z E D W D °
m m � -Ian n �•
p = � Z mzm v
,1 p r --I CC/ --I
—1 o g• fA ° E
_ =10• 3Za = Kcn
I:- * m v zoo
- F- 1
Z > c O v
N
n
1 m "O rn C) ° IV l
D D ,�
1- C
Z 70 ,�►
m 0 ° =
C o � m � � c
Cn
v o0 \m o * v mi
p = mxi m rn p = =
s Dm - m
-Z1 m fZ f� m W p D
D -o -1 r■
r mm 0 = D
n pz r mmo
77 gD ' - zm °
-r< Em = � a -a,-
m -�i
c5 C') -<
z =
o a
33
CD Xl ID 2
-a
iii 3 a CO
m co CD
CD
-ti 0 a.
CP-
c C 5 ` CD
D v, c� '. 0)
-p = 0 m r' O m {1\
D 5 � r Oco m o
m 273 M � m0 - Z
C7 z cn
m cnp 0 zZZ 0
-i 0 m ' � 1
rn m -1 -I � 2 � �!
0 zm m FAD >
m R1 z
TI 1-- 0 M U, Dm
o -0 --I m - z
33 O
O � Corp
s. � m m * W fv Ca
Z -n Z = -< °w
2 OC mOw a. m
M 0 � m 0 > > Q o Eon
a ° O 73 < > a CD
CO = 70 0 � —im 5 ■_�
m mm no c
-1 O _= --� a
� -0 0 m2W ( 3
0 C •
-•1 ci3O 00c � =
X m -pi C7 DJ z0 i.11 0
r- U, 0 D 0 0 2. ..
m m Z m D co D °a mCi
0 � W Z mzN V/ `�
-n O m —1 co -1 Oo
1 O
-- C7 Cl) O r '
'
,m OZ = D oa m ° zo ,
F a p cO ff
,cn r- -1 37 m °
m DV CDI 177 CI, . cD mDm -4 n r U,
O JJ ,
> oJD To mcnp 1
M 0 * °v 0O
xi >rTi< z rn m Cl) p D
C� = D DOS
D D
1— mm Z 0rr-
m pz -< mm ° -�
o D z 0 co
1"' C < -I --I O -<
- m 2 c - 91
�(m Z �DO
cn 0 -< v.
z 2
G) D o
MP r a
A
Cti
v
i,.
m Z D
- a CO
N Si! = CD
W c 5
F7_ co CO
C7 al c� rl■
-o = 0 m ro "4. •p.
D = m 1" 003Fri C ,
m `—" -' m c el Z
0 Zc cnmc
O MZ 0 pmZ � . , t
II
1 O r 0
M• m -Zi �oDO
Srn0 (m = zI
om Po (--v z m � zz /r_ o m - zc—im /O 0-0 0-1 m -< z c: .r
= r 0
o UM
Z T Z = coo
6) C0w
--1 m n c_
m , u) P- 0 C Q O C .
n ° „ -n o « N
= O a =im =•
co m m - 0 m Z 0
M --n n -< O�� m 3
—I 0 -o O f= ZW 3 3
-IcDC
XJ 0c0 ,-1
rn ° p C) JDzo R7 O
✓ cnp O 0Pz r«
rn � z M 11� z 4 13
m -n n
-a c m = gym .� 0
O 0M IT —Z�i Wpo
-1 O n 0
-1=.
_ - O D = c°n o�
M z z• Z t):1
i >
`a z v ° -
D 2
o r -I
-I D
co 0) N m 0
.0 m >
-
m O �° O
V) � cn D m2C
m o : 0 00m
v
m m p m p = cA
rn _
Z < Z V) p n' •
-1 m0 Cl) mp _,
0 = o O DDD
r mm Z al co �;
a oz r Koo
mm0
op m z
..
-
c 5 C7 -<
z Z
6) D
73
CD C) m D
- 3 g. CQ
�
R. CO CD
CD
-v O v =
E_-_ D cc) co 0)
n 73 _ -u _
r m0 m 1- ° CD
a 55 E: r" per O O
0 C O M KTDD m 3
m � -I m - O � -
0 z () � rnOc Z
cmnz 0 omz O
- � � 0 mG)
M m - -1 C =
m OZ rn xi mG) D
0 zom m Ozz �j
rn r0 m Conn
O 0o w m -< z ■
o CO
Z � � Z = -WGc°.�
z O c -� z v, CD
= Oc -I mOcu n
rn � m 2 > > o
n n'n � < > us \ a
co = = O gm '' n _�
M
r m � mz
MI o n O
-1 C)O -o O = zo
O 70 = C m n co m
-1 ct XJ 0 c 0 - " I
rn ° O C) 30zo Co
r cnp O o6) z c-0
_oc m = gym " 0
O 0 � _I Apo 6.
-n-1 On > Co
_ � O D = R- cn
in O _ Z omz
D � m 0 z ° p
zD � OO
r- -i o grt
�rn 0V mT NI CDD ■
m m v.
(A!) om D mmOc �\ _
in o * 0 00070
m =O _Di -1 .
- Dm m gym =
Z mz V) o
Z\
-1 m O m O —D
�
C) _ 0 nor Al
r
mm
Z 2.:1 o
r
M Dz r mm °
m -n8c
Do m z �
cn C) -<
z 2 ^
0 D
73
m W 2
a = CO
-< o CD P. CO
CD
-0 -< 000 m C _ _°
W c -< 0 = -`D-
r
0 D 0 Z
r m � r ni0 ..
55 K < 70 C •
C) 07 M -=1 0
M C„ -zi =1 � a Z
M -- z
(7)
O mz D zm 0 0
''0 � -I O c0 •
r -0z O o '
—I cnz 2 p °w
0 ZM M Co
m 1- 0 177 -' D
▪ 00 C 0 >
rco 0 —I K
-Im m DCm
00 z� ^CO
O -, Z CC g CD
—1 0 Jo _1 —I 0 , 0 c
C , co 0.
-I
Huu 3
a OM
--1 0 -0 O Z Z m
O K0 C0o
—I cn � 2m -i °A 6 —I
IT 7 °1 O y m U
r- c p
z 01 > 'V
m � ? Mc z —.
m m MD:Ino ° n
-0 C M 0 CD
O XOw °
Z0O
2 00n A" m00-
ITl z � Z -0 —zi C1 (�
D m DD -< Cr -
* -1om z a O 5. _�
xi
M mz � =
rCDDD —1 --I
m mm O 0 > a
C DJ z D r
m r
mCn 0 = D CD 0
33 DOm m mC
Z < z V) 0 cn
--I m 0 Cn c n -
n mm O 30 >
r
m pz z =I
p )6> -< =� W
2 - = m
-rG � m 2 = 0
m m m
CT) 0 1- m
mz
D xy
2 00
-a
z
_ �
m
L
D C7 N a) 2
3 a CO
-< O N R c=• CD
M CD
C .c - ro m
c: n Zz CO ;
m -1 O .=-«:a 75 K r < 7C1 ° s 3
C7 = Z =iz ° ►
ITI cn -i -1 U, n p
0 zn m -- n `'1 Z
� z 0 2 0
E u) o —I Pz •
-1 O c o
-1 cn m = 0 °o
z w Q
v z ° m cw
-n r- m -I >
71 00 � o3OD
1m or- m
m D C m
O C7 n 7o z ^n
Z � m Z0 � 0 0 �al
-� 0 ° _1 -1oo a =
0. 12: CL
—I 00 -no DD3 tcn n CD
D. = � Oo80 �n o
m � 1- � o � z CD �D
-� p -"'v OZZm
O � Co CcOo a
-1 cn a0 m -1 ° rs "'I
m -n -1 nym° „ �• O
rr17 m z w o z ...13
° Z ∎.
-n m g 2Do0 0
—I - m �mj ° o
rno oW Z00V
z �
Zlo -Ap
� m 0D
m -a m m
"' o
PC
O DD
D z Zr r
m o * 0 20
'0 DOm m m --G
Z < z V) 0 ;
M 0 Cn Fr) -I
0 _ 0 CO m =
I- m m Z Jo >
D O Z 1"' r
r- 0 0 -I _ m
-< � m 2 = 0
DJ m mm
0 0 pm
0 0
n
II o
-
Z
-I
M
CD MI CD m 2 )211
ills 3 Et CO
`D• D CD
O =v
P 0.
n D,
70 = 0 -o L �.
= o m r0 - CD
Tx = � r OO � m C
0 mm KLH _
m ELI- --:, moo
0 mz 0 c'-' mz ? 0 l• Q
E BOO -�1 zz � Z. r r- •
m m � Oi mom D �� ✓
rn Oz = PR 6) f
0 zm 177 Ozz d
-n r- 0 I Tm vi D m
M = m E * miv
O c7D °o--ioo Ca
Z � m Z = -< w
� C Z W
C
CD
-I = -� = O l n
= ° cn m 0cn 0- o
m m rcn m -0
r- = m = Om ° ul c pup
m -n -1 -� -1-. m 3 cro
—1 O -'v 0 mzo
C
-I u) 0 M 0 0 _'
M Omp� C') Dizo Q
r cn p O 0 0 z
o
m r Z M m Z 0• -U
-T-1 -m0c rn = gym (� `�
0 W Z mOo
M ,?:3 r -I O -{ o
o0 CO � .a
m o � Z O =-1 D
a
C1 K* m 0 zoo
Z c
t/) 1- --I --i O °o -�
cocas = mD � -. =
m m m D O K) C
m � m p ° mm -)
D m = n Fr: 0) O p r
M 0 * p OOm Cv
73 Dmm m c' m = I (
Z < z Cl) oo3D
—1 m0 U) MO -I
0 mm O D � 1 n Cr
Z al 10
a Oz mm0 W
71 gD z0v,
c < —1 -� O7
-< � m = pct, -Q
Jo m z _i
n 0 -<
z =
O D ✓7
= V
r
Mi CD CD CD D
3 CO
Fe. • CD
CD o=
O - 0.
a-r, CD cf) CZ
C7 = , -v Ni\-
- m0 m - p - rF
D = � - Omm5•
C) Dom 'S KT33 2 c a
m cn --II —1 � OC7
'Ti C7) 33 Z zv, p, m c
E cno zZ � >." '\ 0•
r- 1" - O o a -7<-1
�n •_ •■.
z 4i -�
-m-1 mm = � zo
o pOz �, v
0 z m 0zz
-n r- o m "cnDm
D3 m00 F,-; r6 os
- r- co r O
= m m * mo
Z c - °� m Z 7,=1
w
G ° _ z= › w
� l "
= O m m Q- o
M Do U) P-- 0Cn
N -p Q.
03 Dom 0 0mo 1 n
m m71 -I- ! 3
—1 0 -o O = z 4. k. 3
O CO o cQ
-I
opo _
m ° p o oZ0 g 0
_ 1
m � z M � co z v .0
5.
0 m N
O Mr._ Z moo
(n O Jo r
°=
O D K cn
m 0 z 0 =1a ilik
z � mz
a FZ D c0NO O i
Cl) 1- -I - — ,
m -4. . =
-0 mm ^' nom n
m m O o ;° m r
o o > m - o
�' O 0 z
m p2 p Opm
.0 ._ ,._.,= 33 ,13 _1 (1)33 o _1 (
_rim ...,- D m m w m =
z < z V) opoD
-1 -m-1 D O -I
.. c.) = 00 > 1. ,?.._
1— m m
Z � or
m oz r moo
-C m = c c7
DJ
m z -
F.15 C) -<
z =
O D
ml
CD so 2
- 0 3 a CQ
CD `" CD
-< CD v =
O = `>. Cu t2
v� co a)
n ° .-I c xi o m
-0 = o m .-o•p
O Wm � Tm =
rn cn -I o o
zn 0 m cnFo
m ° 0 zzM cp � C .
-0 -1
m -1 7JJ `rn � c, 0_ _
rn Zz a7 mOD � -. Y(`,
D m m ° zz t',
1 r ° m U) D0
a7 ° ° w -< z ,. ,
E =, m WON
O n D = =1 oo °o
Z � m Z = -< w
-I G) C = ZCa Q i =
= c "'4 m °- :Z o
rn � � � C) �
a ° ° T1 K CA a
03 = O � -jm c)
Mill -► - z
-X0200 =z ° 33
� O
O K0 mc � =
= 0 - D °- =
m -n -I DJ Z ° .• O
° G) - 6
MI
-1 � c rn = gym i` n
O oW Z W0
_ Cn ° .4'
--1 OOn D _
_ ° D 0 -=1 > •, .
rn z � Z mz L �!
°v - zvvc ° °
I
0(f) r --I = -_ a N�DD Z ..
I- cf) O m m omm r
° ca m U' p 1l
.,--
I
ci) p rc
M 0 = Dom -P
xi < Z
Z C/) ° W D j.
-1 m ° C/) m ° .
- mm z film
F �_,
r11.1 a bz r K m m I 0o
° D
c < --1 O -< ;
- <m = c �
DD m -I
v) 0 -<
z =
73 i t
C
C�
Add On Item 16F3
June 9,2015
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Recommendation to suspend contracts with BQ Concrete LLC., pending completion of
the County Manager's internal review of this contractor and subsequent presentation of a
report to the Board.
OBJECTIVE: To protect the interests of the taxpayers.
CONSIDERATIONS: On May 26th, 2013, Item 11B, the County Manager informed the Board
that he was conducting an internal review of worked performed by BQ Concrete LLC.
BQ Concrete LLC, currently has three (3) active contracts that have been awarded by the Board
of County Commissioners:
• Contract 14-6197 Hammerhead and Designated Driveway Construction
• Contract 12-5974 R Concrete Driveway, Sidewalk, Curbs and Slab Install and Repair
• Award 12-5823 Maintenance & Minor Repairs
The County Manager requests that these contracts be suspended pending completion of the
County Manager's internal review of this contractor and subsequent presentation of a report to
the Board.
FISCAL IMPACT: There is no fiscal impact at this time.
GROWTH MANAGEMENT IMPACT: There is no growth management impact associated with
this Executive Summary.
LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS: This item has been reviewed by the County Attorney. Section 29
of the County's Purchasing Ordinance (Ord. No. 2013-69) provides in relevant part as follows:
"The County Manager may suspend and/or debar vendors, contractors, consultants and other
interested and affected persons from active participation in obtaining County contracts upon
approval of the Board. The purpose of any such action shall be to protect the County's interests
and the integrity of the County's contracting process.
The Purchasing Director shall have the authority to recommend to the Board the suspension of
a contractor, subcontractor or person from consideration for award of contracts if there appears
to be a reasonable basis for debarment as set forth herein."
Accordingly, this item is approved as to form and legality and requires majority vote for
approval. -JAK
RECOMMENDATION: That the Board of Collier County Commissioners suspends contracts to
BQ Concrete LLC pending completion of the County Manager's internal review of this contractor
and subsequent presentation of a report to the Board.
Prepared by: Joanne Markiewicz, Director, Procurement Services Division