Loading...
CESM Backup Docs 12/05/2014 Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Backup December 5 , 2014 .t l BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Collier County, Florida Petitioner, vs. Case No. CESD20140013416 Robert Rivers JR & Leah Marie Rivers Respondent(s), STIPULATION/AGREEMENT 'Robotic 4- Ri Jejcj S r COMES NOW, the undersigned,Lech, , on behalf of himself or as representative for Respondent and enters into this Stipulation and Agreement with Collier County as to the resolution of Notices of Violation in reference (case) number CESD20140013416 dated the 5th day of August, 2014. In consideration of the disposition and resolution of the matters outlined in said Notice(s) of Violation for which a hearing is currently scheduled for 12-\s w"( ; to promote efficiency in the administration of the code enforcement process; and to obtain a quick and expeditious resolution of the matters outlined therein the parties hereto agree as follows: 1) The violations noted in the referenced Notice of Violation are accurate and I stipulate to their existence. Horse stable built without first obtaining all required Collier County Building Permits THEREFORE, it is agreed between the parties that the Respondent shall; 1) Pay operational costs in the amount of $//q 2y incurred in the prosecution of this case within 30 days of this hearing. 2) Abate all violations by: Obtaining all required Collier County Building Permit(s) or Demolition Permit, inspectins, and Certificate of Completion/Occupancy within/40 days of this hearing or a fine of $250 per day will be imposed until the violation is abated. 3) Respondent must notify Code Enforcement within 24 hours of abatement of the violation and request the Investigator perform a site inspection to confirm compliance. (24 hours notice shall be by phone or fax and made during the workweek. If the violation is abated 24 hours prior to a Saturday.Sunday or legal holiday,then the notification must be made on the next day that is not a Saturday,Sunday or legal holiday 4) That if the Respondent fails to abate the violation the County may abate the violation using any method to bring the violation into compliance and may use the assistance of the Collier County Sheriff's Office to enforce the provisions of this agreement and all costs of abatement shall be assessed to the property ownee espondent or Representative (sign) Fait Jeff fight, Director Code Enforcement Department /Z �5� 5 /2 is /`i Respondent or Representative (print) Date /ays 7y Date / REV 12/30/13 , _,..„._c_,I.,..,c,._1 .);.,,,,r).,,,:_irel ..,,,A.,,,:,„.7,,,,,,,:2_._0...,,i,,,., ,,::.,/,,,,t1,,,t..1,,:,. 00.. :I, '1.„_,,,'F.0.11'.37-- ',I' :: . z: , :. 4...`,...:14 ' ti - ,, i.„Villg-:. .' ■ y R y t '. FIT_j. :',',../ 1, i .�• i. • ' r }♦. . r.y . , • i J .i 4. 1.1 s T f s u `* a ark , . 1 . ..:.;:•• .,,,;, /, .. . d' • mow_ ;, vii , � � f J 4 � ilm o N 00 m 4 v-I 1.71.. 0 1 giffj r, CL o CO N Z 2 ,,------ __ ci. c , - W J U Q c� `j i: .— . - O .: , ,L, ,,, ,„. ..., „ , •_ = .,,, ,... _(:) ,,... _ ._ _c i „,s , ,. X 11) w 0r4 N �� k 1'4.. 3 'k a l':'.: •fi g Ks 0 �•_ 4''. 1r . N M 00 J ° ` �� 0, , 4 .. .,„ .. ..__.... . " ....„, O 1 r v . 0 0:31)(1) .1,;'..4:71: 7'1_1,-- --i,' t. , i '''."' -:'' ' Ill .—. ' iF :.:-,i i . , 1, '.', ,,,,;,' ,,.. ''''' ,'','''...,,,f.„°,7.- ' li ' 0 CO NI Z '--, 2 cu ..‘, .-, .„..:. ,H.:, : .:___0.. c : Iii co . . h , , , ..... ........ , .,... ., . . ,M mimml N.- r. ID mC �O •41. NX LU 11) 0 '' -.w.u..0...,tix.s.,�..m�ygyy'• ....:...........damn,.W, hx^iY''',L,. ....,,,,,,,:: N , - ■ a a ' ' .' 'ir f,,,', , I 1,..,,,,,,. .. . „.. .... . . , , , ,p { t 4N; A Y .. ^5 ! ,--„, .. rs . . . .,,,r,....„... .4.. .,:'4 , ''',4 i s $ '' ,,I :4141ii,41:'' ' „3., .,,a I tik t . It f, i . / . .. : ) • ',7,'t'''' '11.--, ,'"if-''''i,e ''„,"1 --,... ..1,:-Ji.,,!1-,--', --, '.f .' ,-,',7 , ' n F] r 7 - 2013 .., . . , • ... 4, . . , . ..... <1 ....., .2. fr 1 ft- 432:1E.1=====iiata, U 11 Oft la 2014 A .• .• . 4111111111111111 . lit ....,*,- '—...------ s, i r 1 ,. Or • fl 023,21,==a4=3.D. ...... tutt .., I ,, . ? ',. as pf 4f.. `-y r , , 7 , 4,' if; `'f.' . ‘ , i 44$2,...,:- : ,... , , , , , . 4# , ..,,, ' :' 1N< a _ ilhi , , IT r- i y � f , - t . ___ 4. 1 ..1-'Nit. 1.3 r i , ... ..„ _ � e 1 ..,:„....‘ .. _ .... i z- 1' . J.41, f,,. ... . . . ... • Z. k 1,11P *1111.111M6661.6.""1 ill i 1.,i; .._ . n iii J+�...r. -.. . ' , ';. art #p».r " i"ie as�d ^M* t. t w f *Mn i •I 4.i R ti*Sr4,4'...., iii;ni: " 'w..q..r L. - r. ,may GzV 2 0 1 Li 001'1 0 - . _ r 1. • r X', ,' '∎Wii it i `.".."'"••••• ■ • v i PilI ',,r--,t--::::44t✓ � js 1 '#.�, � ,� yk*s sr . �a J ffi� � ° f . f a 4 � T i ..a i ,441044014041041 ,,,,, : lh:k°4 r 08/ 19/ 2014 14 : 41 Illikimammila ■ -,' , 1 : . „'-' 1 1 i 1 - . . . ___ ..........., .. ._ •-.- ,„,„, ------------- -, '`..,.... -°"............. ......44,- ._ 1,:,,,ts__ -,,,F-I "'""""'"'"""". ...........o.................."n- _ . _ ____, ,,, ----.. ....., ,,,-. ... . • 7' -..__. ,... . I - -•'-- 4 . 10/27/2014 13 : 09 ., ...., .... .. .... . , .._ . , -,---- ... ,.: . - 1 xf fi r - r` c o /17- w., ( e , is ' 1 iY �j a '' — a 1 ', , p . if . :,,, ?„1 ,11000 Ar _,,,..,,,,_ ,'''' : ,,,,„-...": 2. ',"titt, '.1- 1 #iff, ' R n _ • + t .. fir. { I F ' .Y 4,..# !q uy t r . ' r - ., r x p f} \1 .C. 5 -r,„!;-,..;•t..... Cam" ¢ •. .4 e Y ` a a ,,�° r t *--..;-17'-- 7 • S 'O ia .) ) Li (--q ' 1 ∎- 12-cc(-1 I A f 1 y 4 f 4, all flit Ala 1 61dr *I a..7" , t 4. ,k �M ' 0 Nii ,-,„,Y, - •40,. ..---„,."' ; hir 'al 7c4„- ' iki, : . Il e 1 1 4 , 4 a . ' r b E ,^. a A n ' or < y 1 x .e a , . E . • v': a W a� yy,,. •r 6 ir 111411* * r 1 44 'Mk ft R iii as ..._ �� + x ': • o ,000 lo o . oo R k 4 g ar t ; r L. ti I, , • 1 1 ■ Md .„ ." t^r. yen p # g. . \ „ .. n a _ § t° " k t. . ei n F _ � ..„-/ ....'"-' 11114.1"*"*"'m / 1 . " • - -- ;,',t,,,.1,74,-,i,,,,,,,,,_ ,,,,,,,,, _:,.,,...'',..'..,e,,,1::;....,..:,!tt.",C7-_- I .-tt..,',.- r. 1,1 -0 7 lot !,,r.:,,:,,, ---... ,„,,,,,,, , , ,... N,.. .;4 tir rr ..:. _it„.„0„,..„ ,. - - ' - _ -.. ..:::,..,_:,,,,,ei , , r �� ; "'- .. —'—''''' igik „ ,, . .. .., ., , . ,',,.-.,. ,,,N \ . r' { n n@ . 4 ,. , ,r • 1* ., 4 a g x f . r 8 ,,...''.../ 411111111 , iR I " Alliti4' ''''' '''''' '- .+ 1' :it illi a x . x j ,_ ,„ '— - -. I. ir Itr'' , ., , , , , c „ . g . , Ito it ,:: ,' '',,,,. 1 i 'I- it a 4 tor 3 IA 1 , . S ,, ';#4 .-de , I,...ilti.1.1111,.._.,._,;.,...,:,:,_,„7,:.„..„,,,._., j__:,,,7::,,,:.,::"...,......'..'; , iy ft.. 1 ,. Nei. °",--:1,4*'''''''. k te it -ft I, � k � �� � � d � � � � � Per , L a �( '. �y'tea P 01 pt - . '; .-.. S Y M � ! _ : , n mod. rh 'a F:. h ' p T` LynchKyra From: WalkerShannon ,nt: Monday, November 17, 2014 10:50 AM LynchKyra Subject: FW: Appeal of initial determination of Peanut and Brutus Horn as dangerous dogs From: Mike Horn [iumikeclu @aol.com] Sent: Monday, November 17, 2014 10:27 AM To: WalkerShannon Cc: ilene2314(aaol.com Subject: Appeal of initial determination of Peanut and Brutus Horn as dangerous dogs Shannon: Per your instructions, we wish to appeal the initial determination that our Frenchies, Peanut & Brutus, are "dangerous dogs". We await your further instructions as to what we need to do next. Thanks for your help in this matter. Best wishes, Mike & Ilene Horn Buttonbush Lane aples, FL 34108 239-860-1606 or 239-404-2533 (our cell phones) iumikeclu(gaol.com<mailto:iumikeclu(aaol.com> or ilene2314(Gaol.com<mailto:ilene23140aol.com> Under Florida Law, e-mail addresses are public records. If you do not want your e-mail address released in response to a public records request, do not send electronic mail to this entity. Instead, contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 COLLIER COUNTY DOMESTIC ANIMAL SERVICES SUFFICIENT CAUSE TO CLASSIFY DOG AS "DANGEROUS" PURSUANT TO COLLIER COUNTY ORDINANCE CHAPTER 14 ARTICLE II SECTION 14-36 AND/OR CHAPTER 767 FLORIDA STATUTES November 14th, 2014 Ilene Horn(P003043) 823 Buttonbush Ln Naples, FL 34108 , "Brutus" (A164218) red male, French Bulldog, two years old. This letter is your written notice that Collier County Domestic Animal Services (CCDAS)has determined that there exists sufficient cause to make the initial determination that your dog, "Brutus", as described above, is a"Dangerous Dog" pursuant to Collier County Ordinance Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36 and/or Chapter 767, Florida Statutes based on the following findings: 1) On 0 •e,44th, 2014 Has aggressively bitten, attacked, or endangered or has inflicted :-vere ink + en a human being on public or private property. Pursuant to Collier County dfdinance Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36 and/or Subsection 767.12(1)(c), to appeal this initial determination, your written request MUST be sent to CCDAS (Attn: Walker)not later than seven (7) calendar days from the day that you receive this letter. If you request this hearing,the hearing will be held as soon as possible, but not later than twenty- one (21) calendar days and not sooner than five (5) days after the day that CCDAS receives your written request for a hearing. If you request a hearing, be sure to provide CCDAS a telephone number where you can be reached on weekdays between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. in order for CCDAS to conveniently notify you of the date, time, and place of the hearing. A letter notifying you of the same will also be sent to you. If you have a preference for a specific date and time, (or dates and times that will be most convenient for you) you may request such dates and times in your written request for the hearing. CCDAS will make our best effort to accommodate your request. However, CCDAS cannot guarantee that your hearing will be scheduled on the date(s) and time(s) as you requested. This hearing may only be rescheduled by written agreement approved by both parties. If you do not request a hearing within seven (7) days from the date of your receipt of this letter, this initial determination will become a final determination that your dog is a"dangerous dog" as determined by CCDAS. If a final determination is made that this dog is a"dangerous dog" you will be required by law to immediately take several actions with regard to this dog. These obligations include registering fi this dog as a "dangerous dog" with CCDAS and are specified in Collier County Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36 and/or Chapter 767 Florida Statutes. Additional obligations are specified in Chapter 14 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinances. If your dog is impounded throughout this process, you will be required to pay for all costs incurred for the care of the dog. You must pay all costs in full before your dog will be released to you. Please note CCDAS will not hold your dog indefinitely. Failure to comply with all requirements of this letter, Florida Law, and County ordinance will ultimately result in your forfeiture of ownership of your dog. If you have any questions, or require additional information, you may contact CCDAS at (239) 252-7387 and ask to,speak with Officer Wacker. /z- fOKA __ Signed by: • Officer Shannon Walker Animal Control Officer Collier County Domestic Animal Services 7610 Davis Blvd Naples, FL 34104 (239)252-7387 NOTICE THAT DOG IS UNDER INVESTIGATION AS BEING A DANGEROUS DOG—NO IMPOUNDING THIS NOTICE IMPOSES MANDATORY OBLIGATIONS UPON YOU IF YOU ARE THE OWNER OR CARETAKER OF THIS DOG November 6, 2014 To: Ilene Horn(P003043) 823 Buttonbush Ln Naples, FL 34108 This Notice is to inform you that the following dog is currently under investigation by Collier County Domestic Animal Services ("CCDAS") as possibly being a "dangerous dog" as specified in Collier County Ordinance Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36. "Peanut" (A164219) fawn male, French Bulldog two years old and "Brutus" (A164218) red male, French Bulldog,two years old. CCDAS has sufficient evidence to believe that this dog has acted in such a manner as to be investigated as a "dangerous dog" by applying the criteria specified in Collier County Ordinance Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36. CCDAS believes that you are the owner or caretaker of this dog. If you are not the owner or caretaker of this dog, please contact CCDAS Officer Walker (239) 252-7387. CCDAS has not currently impounded this dog. Per Collier County Ordinance Chapter 14, Article II, Section 14-36, mandates that you are required to humanely and safely confine this dog in a securely fenced or enclosed area pending the outcome of the investigation and resolution of any hearing related to the dangerous dog classification. During this time frame: (1) the dog shall not be relocated from where it normally resides and (2) ownership of this dog shall not be transferred. After the investigation, CCDAS shall make an initial determination as to whether or not the dog is a dangerous dog. CCDAS will inform you in writing of its initial determination. If the initial determination is that there is not sufficient cause that the dog is in fact a dangerous dog, the investigation will be closed and the dog may be relocated and its ownership may be transferred. If the initial determination is that there is sufficient cause to make the initial determination that the dog is a dangerous dog, you are entitled to request a hearing to appeal the determination within seven (7) days after your receipt of that notice. If you do not request a hearing in the time specified, the initial determination will become a final determination that the dog is a dangerous dog. You will be notified in writing of the final determination. If the final determination is that the dog is a dangerous dog, you will be required to take several actions with regard to the dog including registering the dog as a dangerous dog with CCDAS. These obligations are specified in Chapter 14 of the Collier County Code of Laws and Ordinance. Failure to comply with these obligations may result in fines and may ultimately result in your requirement to forfeit ownership of your dog. If you fail to respond to CCDAS' request and letters and fail to cooperate in the investigation, you may forfeit your ownership rights to your dog. If you have any questions or require additional information, you may contact CCDAS (239) 252-7387 and ask to speak with Officer Walker. DATE: ii 4 A` Signed by: A i I Aga.; A.; Printed Name: /1• .�14f?e WORA Collier County Domestic Animal Services 7610 Davis Blvd. Naples, FL 34104 239-252-7387 Go -ter County Public Services Division Domestic Animal Services Dangerous Dog Investigation Acknowledgement --� ( / I, 71Pt'e 1 j , the owner or caretaker of IthAtiOatd have received notice that: (:)1-his dog is under investigation as a dangerous dog ❑ CCDAS has found sufficient cause to declare this dog dangerous ❑ CCDAS has determined that this dog should be impounded ❑ I must take action to reclaim my dog, or surrender my dog to CCDAS ❑ Other and acknowledge receipt of such said documentation (copy attached) on lowernlar (-es 2461`4iate. I understand that if I fail to respond to CCDAS's request(s) and/or fail to cooperate with the investigation, I may forfeit ownership rights to my dog. •ignature /4 . Lene AKA, Print N. e ` / Inv ::tor's Signature ID# Person ID _\VII2 A� 'o2"e� 21 Activity Address �- COWER COUNTY 400), 1° DOMESTIC hil"ULI sERERVICE5 CES` Domestic Animal Services •7610 Davis Blvd.•Naples,Florida 34104.239-252-PETS(7387) •www.collierpets.com Co Tee C®-4.14ty Public Services Division Domestic Animal Services Dangerous Dog Investigation Acknowledgement I, ` \o2_4-_ , the owner or caretaker of Ow have,11 have received notice that: ❑This dog is under investigation as a dangerous dog XCCDAS has found sufficient cause to declare this dog dangerous ❑ CCDAS has determined that this dog should be impounded ❑ I must take action to reclaim my dog, or surrender my dog to CCDAS XOthere'`l,FF1C_t r L art CC:12-114 or "1�o g , TKa ne_oi rt..431..tiz, and acknowledge receipt of such said documentation (copy attached) on /(//4/21/1 date. I understand that if I fail to respond to CCDAS's request(s) and/or fail to cooperate with the investigation, I may forfeit ownershi. rights to my do:. Al '/ *44 0' A, r Signature 411 GAZ 4 &zL (- W°'31/ Print ALAIL / 21 Investiga;r's Signature ID# Person ID Pc O_a3 Animal IDIAItA'-tom Activity Address flILA-("D"5--)• c atiS »tom► COWER COUNTY , 2i L 21 i 4 i 8 C�'l p.a ly DOMESTIC 4 SE RV.I CES DomesficAnimal Services •7610 Davis Blvd.•Naples,Florida 34104.239-252-PETS(7387) •www.collierpets.com Memo: 10/15/2014 10.15.14 I was able to make contact with victim Mary Walsh via phone. Mary advised that she was going into the Horn Family issurance place of business with her leashed dog. From previous visits she was aware that the family usually brings their dogs to work, so she figured she bring her dog along. As she was walking in both dogs came runnig toward her dog and actual bit him on the neck and tail (both minor puncture wounds). As Mary was trying to pick up her dog, both "Peanut" and "Brutus" started attacking Mary and latched on to both her arms. Mary recieved multiple puncture wounds to both arms. No sutures of stiches required. The owner Ilene did take Mary to the Urgent Care on Livingston where she recieved antiobiotic and wound care. I did make contact with dog owner at her of business. Both the dogs were at home. I went over the quarantine rules with the owner. This the second incident involving her dogs. I drove to the owners home, saw both dogs in the window and placed on quarantine. I did make contact with the victim Mary a second time and advised that the dogs was placed on quarantine. I did inform her that this is the second incident involving the dogs. Mary is willing to fill out an affidavit. Her arms are completely wrapped and she does not feel comfortable taking the bandages off to take pictures. I will drop off an affidavit to Mary as she is she does not have an email. She will also attach the vet report to the affidavit. 129/SW 10/18/2014 10.18.14 Unable to make contact with anyone at the residence. Left an affidavit and my card taped to the door. 129/SW 10/20/2014 10/20/14 Affidavit received from caller/victim Mary Walsh regarding the incident that occured. Responding officer to contact Ms Walsh &see if she wants to pursue the possibility for a Dangerous Dog investigation; if she does, photographs of the injuries and medical records are required for both herself& her dog, to determine if the injuries meet the definition. Responding officer to also provide affidavits to attacking dog owner Ilene Horn regarding the incident, photograph & attach pictures to AIDs of both attacking dogs. 125/KL 10/24/2014 10/24/14 12:14 Arrived at 823 Buttonbush Ln. to release both "PEANUT" (A164219) & "BRUTUS" (A164218) from home quarantine. I did not make contact with the homeowner/dog owner but was able to visibly see both dogs in the front window of the residence alive and well. Both dogs released from quarantine. I posted a notice of the quarantine release along with an affidavit asper 125/KL. I made contact with Victim Mary Walsh via phone to notify her of the dogs quarantine release and that both dogs were alive and well. Ms. Walsh and I discussed the possibility of a Dangerous Dog Investigation and she does in fact want for us to pursue the investigation. I explained of her the process and what information we would need. She advised that she would be going to the doctor again for a follow up in a couple days. She was driving at the time I called and asked if i would call her back and leave a voicemail with the information we required, and she would be sure to get it back to us as soon as possible. 132/]Bosch Print Date: 11/17/2014 11/01/2014 11/01/14 09:15 I made contact with Mary Walsh (P064716) who advised that she had all her medical records together, but unfortunately she did not have any photos. She stated the wounds all close to being healed up now. She stated she was going to bring the medical records by the shelter today. I provided Ms. Walsh with the Activity # and advised her to notify the front desk staff that she was providing us with the records in reference to a Dangerous Dog Investigation (DDI) and if front desk staff had any questions to provide them the activity # as reference. 132/JBosch 11/01/14 11:25 Ms Walsh brought her medical records in and I have pictures of the injuries. The wounds are healed and there is just pink marks on the skin. I will attach the pictures on sunday, November 2nd, 2014. I put the medical records in 132/ JB mailbox. 110/AM 11/06/2014 11/6/14 1315 We arrived at the office to create and gather all the proper forms for the Dangerous Dog investigation. Upon completion of this we left for the Michael Horn Insurance Company where Mrs. Ilene Horn was working. We arrived at Michael Horn Insurance Co. We made contact with Ilene Horn who was with a client. We waited for her to finish with her client. We spoke with her face to face and her husband Michael over the phone. We presented them with the Chapter 14-36 Dangerous Dog Ordinance, copies of the notification of investigation, Dangerous Dog Applications for each dog. Mrs. Horn agreed to sign the paperwork and we educated her on the process of investigation and what it means if the dogs were declared dangerous. We discussed with her that she has a right to contest any findings that her dogs are dangerous and have a hearing in front of a magistrate. 133/mg 11/13/2014 11/13/14 1308 We called Mr. and Mrs. Horn. They were confused about the affidavit and did not fill it out. The will fill it out and get it notarized then fax it in. Fax number to 125 fax machine. 133/MG Print Date: 11/17/2014 11/13/2014 11/13/14 Affidavit received from alleged attacking dog owner Michael Horn regarding the incident that occured. Also received vet report from victim dog "Ardi" Walsh. All documents have been scanned &attached to this activity; filed. DD pending direction from CCAO. *Note: Message received from CCSO Records Bereau: CCSO Report 14-011462 is for an incident that occured prior to that report & has nothing to do with a dog park incident. No additional information found. 125/KL 11/13/2014 11/13/14 Made contact with Assistant County Attorney Kevin Noelle regarding this case; Mr. Noelle believes that both "Peanut" & "Brutus" do qualify as a Dangerous Dog as per: Chapter 14 Article II Sec. 14-36. Dangerous dogs; definitions and procedures. 1. Definitions. A. Dangerous dog means any dog that according to the records of the appropriate authority: (1) Has aggressively bitten, attacked, or endangered or has inflicted severe injury on a human being on public or private property With the direction of Mr Noelle and the wish to proceed from victim Mary Walsh, both "Peanut" and "Brutus" are going to be declared Dangerous at this time. Activity re-sequenced to deliver Sufficient Cause Letters, Acknowledgement notice, and a copy of the Dangerous Dog Ordinance. If an appeal is not submitted with Seven calendar days of receipt of the letter, the declaration will stand and both "Peanut" & "Brutus" are subject to all Dangerous Dog registration and procedures. 125/KL 11/14/2014 11/14/14 1900 We arrived at 823 Buttonbush to meet with Mr. and Mrs. Horn about the declaration of their dogs as dangerous. We educated them on the process, provided paperwork and the letter with highlighted sections related to their dogs and this situation. Mr. Horn was given the number to the DAS office in order to contact supervisor Kyra Lynch on Monday 11/17/14 if he had additional concerns. 133/mg Print Date: 11/17/2014 dota • " ''T Collier County Domestic Animal Services 7610 Davis Blvd., Naples, FL 34104 / 239-252-7387 Statement or Affidavit of.Complaint Form Generally, violations of the Collier County Domestic Animal Services Ordinance do not occur when an Animal Services Officer is present. For an Officer or Domestic Animal Services to take action regarding a violation, either the Officer or two residents MUST witness the incident(s). This Affidavit of Complaint or Statement, when completed by a witness provides the documentation necessary for an action to be taken. It establishes probable cause for an Officer to believe that a violation took place, and the nature of the violation. This Statement form is essential for Animal Services to pursue further action in reference to the violations you have described. For Animal Services to efficiently respond to your needs, we ask that you print, review and carefully complete this Statement to the best of your knowledge, and return it to Domestic Animal Services within ten (10) days of the incident. Complaint No: I -03552 Tell us about YOU! This portion is to be completed by you, and about you. We need to know your full name, address, and various other information. Please print neatly or type, and review the completed form to ensure that all information is included and correct. Last Name: wa h First Name: I'4 14144r MI e • Street Address: ,3,304, igterapaorttliork. oki c ka City: p State:, Zip: 3410 3 /���, p Qbrr 51•IILIQ p Tele hone: Work Telephone: Tell us about the animal owner We need you to record as much information about the animal owner as you know. Don't guess, be certain. If there is some information that you do not know, simply write "unknown". The information most needed is the animal owner's address. If you are uncertain about the owner's information, or if the animal even has an owner, speak with your neighbors to be sure. Last Name: ttOrn First Name: t 1 e MI Street Address: 60100 Altraimi. Gait S' L4t#e 3 City: State: ?, Zip: 34 i Home Telepho e: Work Telephone: 3q• When is the owner normally home: Mer walk Where did you obtain this information? jortliftrailliet fôcty IftM( COW° °GM 'r )5 IQ WV 1 Atiett tiIIK' 4 ` What does the animal look like? To take action, Animal Services needs to be as certain as possible that we are dealing with the correct animal(s). Please record as much and as accurate a description of each animal as possible. Only list animals that were involved in the specific incident you are completing this Statement for. Here are some basic rules: • Breed is for species as well as the animal's specific breed • Color: Indicate the dominant color first, then all the other colors Breed(s) Color(s) Sex Name. 4oiUPa li fill * If you are uncertain about the breed of the animal. The animal control officer may be able to assist you with determining the breed based on your description. When and where did it happen? This is where you tell your story. Please fill in all blanks with EXACT time, date, and location, based on what YOU observed. Without this information, Animal Services cannot pursue further action. Here are some examples: Location: In street in front of 1212 Smith St. In my back yard at 2121 Smith St. Time: 1:30 p.m. 00. Location of Incident: ____at ej 16_ 11;/t9jilji.iiilipl A g'a Wet:114 EXACT Date of Incident: /0144 EXACT Time of Incidezt a. p.m. Tell us what happened. a• AV In this section you will write a brief story of what happened, based on the information you gave about WHEN and WHERE it happened, and what YOU observed. Only write about the most recent occurrence. Previous occurrences are not relevant. DO NOT write about hearsay or other conflicts there have been with the animal owner. Hearsay is what you have heard from other people, not what you have observed, and is generally not admissible in court. Please print clearly or type. i I �'' • ' ill∎ w WA. L 1.1 .1 . • A • lI • ` . is _ 6Kle n / door & ►0 P • 1 /A. 6 4 r;. . • • ' I ' r ,r., 6 0 rs • .► f', I, `� . =t �r �' ' a ' iiv /.; ' ;L, '.. a /_ *' ® itelturei "Y1 • i 4 0 AiP � 11, It < ,l'1, Y' I ` I '� 0-'- :;ii i' :, ice; $ , / , '., '.ate ._.... ., I Ole' ' – :' - : i . I %xis .�", *, , _ Ifiej 2,\: 4-; -,,P4 P 0 5 ' '.' , "-* -— (424111 rA 4pri . tEsap laileil AO' Wi ' v / r - "f-rtv willikte Oh& fir7C- wrd - 1.• , ' ...' K kii - , , ( wieI 1i ; f` , a ."Under penalties of perjury, I de Leovill,04100 e that I have read the foregoing Affidavit C. vie aint and the facts stated in it are true." � . I ure o A rant Date Sworn to (or affirmed) and subscribed before me this 7-0 day of COO$W Z. , 20N , by Nktk 0- i`'-S , who is Mpersonally known to me, or 0 Has produced as identification. '70LA,L9 -3\9,‘,0,1 . Signature of Notary, State of Florida Notary Stamp VA a(-07-L} lA F Notary's name (printed) o� Y"� Notary public State of Florida a Rachel Jones *, m� My Commission EE 202718 -,cFa� Expires 05/29/2016 Commission xpires 3 6 9el w-tt--F—T -r•":ve, e d '4'. , 0 neef to --) ,,,,- ",,,,,,o,, „ ,- , -..rob ......„...,../.. 4t. low WI-WU ,41.'"',# 4, 4#60, oige,ce .4 I-, ,i . 1 +1. .,..- I Loy „),,,,,,., 64 ' 4 ' 444P, in udeo al ..„,,,,„„„,,,,:,,,.. ' w' ..,..g2o 1 ,,,,, f a 3ry4,-'•,u do-ti As N „it I #w , , „,„4111 Q10101 : i., , ,, ,ti 4 , , .,,r _ ., %, 4 S F 1P, � 4 .ed tepl /..1 ,. : . ,,: tiark it adir,t ,,,..,,it, in <of ,,-,„ , , , ,. , e. 40, , , 4 .'e , pi tli Cr/ve4it ,i,/ . : itts Nov 13 15 04:02p Mike Horn Family Ins. 239-597-1696 p.1 - Collier County Domestic Animal Services 7610 Davis Blvd., Naples, FL 34104 / 239-530-7387 Statement or Affidavit of Complaint Form Generally, violations of the Collier County Domestic Animal Services Ordinance do not occur when an Animal Services Officer is present. For an Officer or Domestic Animal Services to take action regarding a violation, either the Officer or two residents MUST witness the incident(s). This Affidavit of Complaint or Statement, when completed by a witness provides the documentation.rietessary forTan-action to-be taken. -It establishes probable cause for- - - - -- -- an Officer to believe that a violation took place, and the nature of the violation. This Statement form is essential for Animal Services to pursue further action in reference to the violations you have described. For Animal Services to efficiently respond to your needs, we ask that you print, review and carefully complete this Statement to the best of your knowledge, and return it to Domestic Animal Services within ten (10) days of the incident. Complaint No: /-((/wiry 4/ 414 -©05-75 2 Tell us about YOU! This portion is to be completed by you, and about you. We need to know your full name, address, and various other information. Please print neatly or type, and review the compl ted form to ensure that all information is included and correct. Last Name: 4'2� First Name: /�'r l C44P�L MI • Street Address: 6:2-3 3.1..c 77-eirciat.5"4 4A-A1‘.. City: j State: /4eC .�4'(0?— Zip: Home Telephone: (2.30)&6 /S46"-Work Telephone: (-2 3) --41' //‘ 1 Tell us about the animal owner We need you to record as much information about the animal owner as you know. Don't guess, be certain. If there is some information that you do not know, simply write "unknown". The information most needed is the animal owner's address. If you are uncertain about the owner's information, or if the animal even has an owner, speak with your neighbors to be sure. ,f Last Narne: � First Name: �G� C//,fcL MI /C Street Address: g2 3 cd.✓frfi% 444/- City: /v4PL S State: JrZ-- Zip: 341G?4,e Home Telephone: (�37)�(4_ (t4'A Work Telephone: (23r)597 /4-91r When is the owner normally home? ` / r 6 : 3.d Where did you obtain this information? G I J� ��'; 1 Wnz -- ,.. r e-a- .. , '= �- W / je , 1 Nov 13 15 04:02p Mike Horn Family Ins. 239-597-1696 p.3 v What does the animal look like? To take action, Animal Services needs to be ascertain as possible that we are dealing with the correct an"irnai(s). Please record as much and as accurate a description of each animal as possible. Only fist animals that were involved in the specific incident you are completiliy this Statement tor. Here's some basic rules: • Breed is for species as well as the animal's specific breed • Color: Indicate the dominant color first, then all the other colors Bre�c j,I Color S Jame Al 7• * If you are uncertain about the breed of the animal. The animal control.officer may be able to assist you with determining the breed based on ycur description. When and where did it happen? This is where you tell your story. Please fill in all blanks with EXACT time, date, and location, based on what YOU observed. Without this information, Animal Services cannot pursue further action. Here's some examples: Location: In street in front of 1212 Smith St. In my back yard at 2121 Jones St. or Time: 1:30 p.m. Location of Incident: �L� 4wt ~ h'( .---r/its, G gle g EXACT Date of Incident: /0//4//i EXACT Time of Incident: 2: a?: en 4 Tell us what happened. In this section you will write a brief story of what happened, based on the information you gave about WHEN and WHERE it happened, and what YOU observed. Only write about the most recent occurrence. Previous occurrences are not relevant. DO NOT write about hearsay or other conflicts there have been with the animal owner. Hearsay is what you have heard from other people, not what you have observed,.and is generally not admissible in court. Please print clearly or type. Be sure to sign the form in front of an Animal Services Officer. .!..- - "-•• 41 ' 46.....41 '...-- ...dr • - • —........._—...,... .., ,_ ..r - ' - . ••.'Ifj- / �' • r` / '' rid, j / ' 7 / ,- , 4/,:ad - 4]%► L=,_„ ..A?( _4 _ ,�,.4: - , - / i r��%> 1f , a�1�rLt i �I�' i _. ' / fir.:�.,m±. ,. �`.t/ AL��� ! i.. 71 2 Nov 13 15 04:03p Mike Horn Family Ins. 239-597-1696 p.5 1 ;ad I/ 71 . �al� /� 1a..I../��d_ i ■ / —f / LLB. Idt.�. / /� r_ � / =.. `_, sue._ / ,l _ / !/' • L Air • i. ..� � .,���,. ice. Y` "Under penalties of perjury,, declare that I have read the foregoing Affidavit of Compl- /and • ad in it are true." • Signature of Affian Date IV (c iPS'L y e / sT I OF f=Lo Lic�R Coun� OF CoLL.er. Printed Name of Affiant Sin.r,B-A.__ 1 + )11-4 f Animal Control Officer Date i_ f) 1dlneL F. 14-o RA) Case Number: p JQyl Known-I0 -iiN/ 0,6,,t,t16- 1.,,_) N. tLe,n2 44 RA) * filYMANS 411648 ,, , EXPIRES:March 23,201 'E"arWe landed Mu kilo Wiry swwci Memo: 03/03/2014 Location of Problem Goodlette Frank Road / Riverside Dog Park Police Report: # 14-011462 Nature of Complaint Dog attack and multiple people bit by these dogs. Animal Type/Description Two french bulldogs Color tan Sex at least 1 male ? on the other one Owner Name Ilene Horn Address 823 Buttonbush Ln E-mail Address Brudd53 @gmail.com Print Date: 11/17/2014 03/04/2014 3.4.14 Unable to make contact with the dog owner at the residence. I did see both French Bull dogs in the window. I left a notice on the garage door requesting contact. I was also unable to make contact with the caller to get a better understanding of the situation. I left a voicemail requesting contact. 129/SW 1100 I received a call back from the victim. Barbara informed me that the owners two dogs attacked one dog in the park. One dog was holding on to another dogs tail. A friend smacked the dog to get it off of the other dog and it went after Barbara. She does not know which dog bit her (attacking dogs "Brutus" or "Peanut"). She did not go to the hospital but says that the bite was pretty severe. She also does not know the date of the incident but says that it happen a week ago. She filed a report because she feels that the owner was arrogant and showed back up to the dog park and did not apologize for the incident. According to Barabar the lady whose dog got attacked receieved severe injuries. She said that the lady never reported the incident, she does not know her name and she has not come back to the dog park since the incident. Barbara's dog was not injured. Barbara was bitten on the right forearm. She does not have the information for the other person that was bitten by the dog. She will email me pictures of the injuries and contact the police dept for an exact date and time. 129/SW 03/05/2014 3.5.14 I was able to make contact with the dig owner Ilene. Ilene told me that the dog "Lucy" was barking and creating a ruckus, drawing many of the dogs to her including "Brutus". A woman (assuming Barbara) leaned down and picked up "Lucy" and "Brutus" did bite "Lucy" on the tail as she was being picked up. Another woman smakced "Brutus" and he went flying. Ilene told me that she did not see "Brutus" bite anyone, but it is possible with all the commotion going on that she missed it. Ilene believed that her dogs are not aggressive. However, I did point out to her that if she blantantly admitted that her dog bit another dog, that does show signs of aggression. Illene told me that she does not ever plan on going back to that dog park (Veterans). I placed/released both dogs from quarantine (Brutus and Peanut) , as Barbara was unsure of which dog bit her. I did receive pictures of the injury. There was one puncture wound. I did notify the victim, via a voicemail about the quarantine release. 129/SW Print Date: 11/17/2014 y,. Dec 02 2014 11:02AM HP Fax page 2 ST. FRANCIS ANIMAL CLINIC, PA 5380 Tamiami Trail NAPLES,FLORIDA 34108 (239)597-3108 Phone (239)597-4180 Fax Jeffrey Rj■oble,DNA. Damien Lin,v.M.D December 2,2014 Re:"Brutus and Peanut"Horn Owners: Mike and llene Horn • To Whom It May Concern: In our 2 /2 years of experience with"Brutus"and"Peanut"at St Francis Animal Clinic;we have never seen any signs of aggression problems or dangerous dog behavior exhibited by either animal. Their behavior has been typical of most dogs in the veterinary clinic setting.They have always been easy to handle for the purpose of physical exam and treatment, and are certainly very friendly. Sine- i ly; Je e:,7 ,• - 'VM Damien Lin, VMD AO • 11 0 I I P 11-29-2014 To Whom This May Concern, My name is Manny Lopez, I am the co-owner of Celebrity Dog Training. I have been a professional dog training instructor for over 25 years, and I have personally trained thousands of dogs, of many different breeds. Celebrity Dog Training originated in the Miami area back in the 1980's, and we moved our operation to the SW Florida area back in 1991. I am writing this letter on behalf of Mike and Ilene Horn, who are the owners of 2 French Bulldogs, Peanut and Brutus. They were enrolled into our training program in June of 2012, and they are currently 2 and a half years old. They completed our program successfully, and did well in training. What I observed is they do like to play rough, but never aggressively. I have never seen any real aggression from either Peanut or Brutus. Sincerely, Manny Lopez,Training Director Celebrity Dog Training PETSMART 2255 Pine Ridge Road Naples, Florida 34109 239-598-9889 November 20, 2014 Re: Ilene and Mike Horn 823 Buttonbush Lane Naples, Florida 34105 To Whom It May Concern: This is to certify that canines own by Mr.& Mrs. Horn, Peanut and Brutus, both French Bull Dogs are in the process of undergoing a series of obedience classes, currently taught by me at PetSmart in Naples. Also, Mr. & Mrs. Horn are undergoing these obedience classes as well so that they understand their dogs behavior and can learn to take control. I have to date, not witnessed any dangerous behavior. I can be reached at (561) 284-4949 for further questions. j --7z7'49". 7//77. - Kenneth P/Schwartz CGC, CGCA, ThD, PTSD Evaluator, Trainer ..di 4-41 ,, il 4.,a) 8 . r CU v) 4..1 E a a) cu L a. pi > •= C ao 43)(,,,T, ..,...., _. c al . =MIN — L. CD +J .Fi = 75 =MS 7:L Si i. 4 („) cn a) E u 4_• < 4"--- o W a Lu as j \v---.' _ni.-- t.)40b 0 8 CL. '1-P E a) .1 s , o d tj - V C0 m m 22 iii= 0 0 CA • MINIM C eil) 4Mj CL Q) a) L J U ,-„,) c_s;-; ,..... _ ,,, , „ , 1 ~ 1 � e .i, ‘.1/4- +a O a) 4 o E = a) «3 a) c L O �- i ot IN > •_ CV 4-las 0- a) 0 c is • ■... 4.s 1- a) 4.1 'a —,,,, -a. (id il: 4 u ,,, E ° 4.j 1D 0 812 T B o 10 t n_ cb 'IL2 ak 4. "e". cu 0 w cid �� v(ill° 0EL 'v o as (1) WV •— CU & CKS I— cu V o ~ N C171111 0 =mom-1 Q , L cc c� Q) r U „,, '\\ 11 '� r St Francis Animal Clinic Patient Chart Printed:09-03-14 at 11:03a i CLIENT INFORMATION Name Mrs.Ilene Horn (813) Address 823 Buttonbush Ln Naples, FL 34108 PATIENT INFORMATION Name Brutus Species Canine Sex Male, Neutered Breed French Bulldog Birthday 04-10-12 Age 2Y ID 985121008611232 Rabies 021404-14 Color Red Weight 0.00 lbs Reminded 07-11-13 Codes • MEDICAL HISTORY-Vaccination View Date By Code Description Oty(Variance) 08-05-14 JRN 1030 Tag-Collier County 05-15-14 DCL 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 10-28-13 SFA 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 08-03-13 JRN 1030 Tag-Collier County 2047 Rabies Canine 3 Yr,#021404-14 ID:020726-13 Serial:S285356G Expires:02/18/14 Type:K Mfg:PFIZE Admin:SC 2013 DAPP 3 Yr.Booster 04-26-13 DCL 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 07-31-12 JRN 1030 Tag-Collier County 2045 Rabies-Puppy,#020361-12 ID:020361-12 Serial:S175169A Expires:05/07/13 Type: K Mfg:PFIZE Admin..SC 2010 DAPP 1 Yr Booster • 07-10-12 JRN 2006 Corona 1 Yr 800ster 2011 DAPP Puppy 06-19-12 JRN 2005 Corona-Puppy 1st 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 2011 DAPP Puppy;05-29-12 "*- 2011 DAPP Puppy F' ' 4 C!l>tC7�s� O 2001 Bordetella 1st Vac. s 14.) itiLAer J�I ► 9 i5 /((f, BO* it a6ed vv I �.-�•� . ,,,� a,. I _ St. Francis Animal Clinic . Patien Ohart Printed: 09-03-14 at 1 1:02a CLIENT INFORMATION • Name Mrs. Ilene Horn(813) Address 823 Buttonbush Ln Naples, FL 34108 PATIENT INFORMATION Name Peanut Species Canine Sex Male,Neutered Breed French Bulldog Birthday 04-10-12 Age 2y ID 985121008240098 Rabies 021405-14 Color Fawn Weight 0.00 lbs Reminded 07-11-13 Codes MEDICAL HISTORY-Vaccination View Date By Code Description Qty(Variance) 08-05-14 JRN 1030 Tag -Collier County 05-15-14 DCL 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 10.28-13 SFA 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 08-03-13 JRN 2047 Rabies Canine 3 Yr,#021405-14 ID: 020727-13 Serial: S285356G Expires:02118/14 Type:K Mfg:PFIZE Admih:SC 2013 DAPP 3 Yr. Booster 1030 Tag-Collier County 0426-13 DCL 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 07-31-12 JRN 1030 Tag-Collier County 2045 Rabies-Puppy,#020362-12 ID:020362-12 Serial:S175169A Expires:05/07/13 Type: K Mfg:PFIZE Admin:SC 2010 DAPP 1 Yr Booster 07-10-12 JRN 2006 Corona 1 Yr Booster 2011 DAPP Puppy is 06-19-12 JRN 2005 Corona- Puppy 1st 2002 Bordetella 1 Yr Booster 2011 DAPP Puppy 05-29-12 **" 2011 DAPP Puppy. 2001 Bordetella 1st Vac. • ii li is z abed xed dH NVEV:6 171-0Z CO daS /A /Vii /A /A / /A /1 AJ\ /A ( /A /VI, iAr\ . /i 1, r. i♦ . /\ /A / , ..< K ‘< a a Za 'r ' � �, a l ;< Y Y -J 2 �< a < oa to _ p (V s = J 2 I J Ye� a ,C +� i O W O F a J a N .6 d N a ,,� Y Y J E 3� Z Z a Z Z (/1 (A 7 K oi ,i u. J^ 1 O O N O T C3 re Y `'• -� W c'> oo Z o) a) 7 to cx — :I cL a O Ov O O NN 7 W 7 =O }N J U a N N m N 3` Y�� W�� lid o Q Ho I (neY Jre I I re u_ 1-u_ I m g` ,I Z U „ - W 0 Y 0 . >, M Q Y a E f k ! > O \< x 0 C a 'S E i sC = U Y m cjf v Y d -J rA r; '� ` z z Y = ix 3 ;"c z � � � m o ao a) K W o fno u) - Z ° N a iC a N V 7 Z O 0 L. Cl Z � o aov .L- :< ZLO rea) N- - (N Nm � - YN LL � 0)) . 0)Cr) W (0 t m a x* W ° co M V Y ^ � V 0 Q a) / _ a) Z a OZ JZ0 F.• ,z I .• I o CO time N K 00 5 , t • Ii w > tr) 03 N c..) `- .a . Z' U • Z 0 0 =• (:,tla Y Y x K O Z d J O �`' E Ii W ...- = cp' d Q L co O 2 O p U O O N o m ' K u_ co ,K : ,.....j � O ui _ � w g W \ `' l z wN CC 4� d L Q Qo0 E N Z Q O D ..° Q ii Gl i.., i "'�.. o m ,moo wti VV • U O V i W L .z -8 d � Z> WZu_ 0mw J � _ - \fi t/ , , , , , , , , ,,, / A, „ „ , AIS/ 1/ )lV/ ViA / v/ ‘iA/ 1, klAI ll NIA/ A./ A/.A/ V/ AfV/ / t/ :/ . ∎! ViA/ , / h/ S , "- u 7s, 7 R l'w ;/■ vR ( / 7 R /Y !/ i s v i v // /✓ %-, V v\ I V rY r\� fX> Rr> v� v, iV� s Y�-r}- lv ./.1 Ir� /V\ V\ V: f-\. N.' Y ' V V V \ , _ f, f� I1 !\ r i K ., K z ;< ?,',"- : o o Y _ Y 2! ... J r Q CO CA p d N d .5 Y >\'. il Z Z d Z Z N fA 7 fY m L .fit LL co I V Q� J� y CO > >. ■ X 9 Ce O Q CO o ce h W > >,, Z W yo oo co o N 0 O p CO iL.. r K N W V Qrn N CO v Wb o K h Oo t--. O c W � Q p 0 V� M r �m r Q� Z � co , U O g N ° > W OU �U .?d cc Y Y O' U)> I �Z ! O4.j CAZ4E MI mZ I NCC .J CC CC Li. I-U- I O i CO 1 1 I I . op U Y o :' > ZO Q �4 Y � t co Q N 0 Q _ 0 E Y Y a _I y - Q a2f LO >� Z Z = 3 , "� L. O Z.CT a 0 Y O O QL I' ;.< �" O fn O cn to cp e- Z ---K a N Y Z LlO z CCD N N d M t w : C K Y N LL d' QOM) 0 V c0 a O # L I',. ,, :/ SL. Z ^L Z D Z 1t J Z '1 m �' L Co Y Q was* Q - ...1 a z i g c 2.'‹ 0o cv 1 °'co jr I r"� 0 L!) I < M o if >- U Z c O ° \. fn i To w l 2 Z Z W Z re O. Z \ g C m O Qo ° E -"as Y W t� Q U o 0 � i; j..b v ° `Nt J 2m O a) z ti- -"cvs * < ._.] ,,"e,'> Z D s inn rr 4‘41011) 12 "IMICIIIr JF° w ^ '" Co W`d >` .<ill r \ • .i \r \rii ∎ \i \/ +/ Sr \ \/ \/ \/ Si i\i\i\,i\/ \ / i\/ r / \ fil \ I \/ i/ .\! \i / \ I \ f"\/ i/ \ i \ \ i\i\, , \ . n. ,.. .ti. ....-- A A A X X i� .P: X., , A ,r4 . n X A 1,„ ^ A x .X X '.: M.A n. K. l� n. F: r. A S ��K�NF 111111 111111111111111111111 AMERICAN 8051 Arco Corporate Drive *A r� KENNEL CLUBS Suite 100 `,b ,5. Raleigh, NC 27617-3390 www.akc.org July 19, 2012 ILENE HORN 823 BUTTONBUSH LN NAPLES, FL 34108-3428 Congratulations on your new French Bulldog and welcome to the world of purebred dogs. Your AKC registration dollars support numerous AKC efforts to benefit dogs and dog owners. By registering your dog with the AKC,you supported valuable programs such as Canine Search-and-Rescue,the AKC Canine Health Foundation, the AKC Kennel Inspection Program, public education, canine legislation, and DNA parentage verification. AKC registration provides wonderful opportunities for every purebred dog lover. The AKC Canine Good Citizen®program is an outstanding way to train your dog in basic obedience, valuable for every family. In addition, many dog owners enjoy the thrill of participating in AKC activities, shows and trials throughout the country. I invite you and your dog to get involved with the AKC! Since your French Bulldog is a newly registered purebred dog, the AKC has arranged a Complimentary 60-Day Trial AKCsM Pet Healthcare Plan*for your new puppy—at no cost to you—but you must call PetPartners at 1-866-725-2747 or go online to www.akcphp.com to activate your plan and get details about this wonderful benefit.The cost of veterinary treatment has increased dramatically in recent years and the AKC Pet Healthcare Plan helps you pay your vet bills if your pet has an accident or is ill. Please note, if you ordered multiple items at the time of registration, they will be mailed separately and should arrive shortly. These include the AKC Certified Pedigree, the Dog Care and Training video, Family Dog magazine, and the AKC collar tag. If you did not order a Pedigree, you still have the opportunity to do so.An order form is provided on the back of this letter. All of us want to be responsible dog owners. To help,the AKC offers a wealth of information at www.akc.org. Our site lists national and local dog clubs and AKC Canine Good Citizen®evaluators. Please visit us online and on Facebook and Twitter. If we can be of further service to, please contact us by phone at 919-233-9767 or by email at info @akc.org. Sincerely, Dennis B. Sprung //�� President and Chief Executive Officer 'The 60-Day Trial Plan is provided by the master policy issued to the Association of American Pet Owners.Activation required.Administered by PetPartners,Inc.Underwritten by Markel Insurance Company,4600 Cox Road,Glen Allen,VA 23060.Not available in all states and only available to US residents.Eligibility restrictions apply.Contact PetPartners,Inc.for terms and conditions.Must be activated within 28 days of AKC Certificate Issued date.Visit www.akcphp.com/trial or call toll free at 1-866-725-2747. Please separate below and keep for your records. �i •v..y ip..seww wsos•.�/r sews wv./1,1.5. A 1i7 E R I C A N KENNEL CLUB i.W2//J%IVL,W..d.4.4 S/J//, ../W Ja/S/✓,/1/I.I/N//LA NAME NUMBER PEANUT DONICA HORN NP31671110 R BREED SEX i�y KEN, FRENCH BULLDOG MALE s�;cP tr�ti R co FAWN &WHITE,WHITE MARKINGS DATE OF BIRTH is .1 �" APRIL 10,2012 * * t< ,k" SIRE x MORENO DISSEL h4;°NDED,`8'..--f �` NP16780502 11-08 AKC DNA#V585602 AMERICAN ,, ,+ DAM R PRECIOSA NP23510303 08-12 KENNEL CLLIB® � N BREEDER N R DANIEL G MORENO CERTIFICATE ISSUED JULY 19, 2012 " OWNER This certificate invalidates all previous certificates issued. k If a date appears after the name and number of the k R sire and dam,it indicates the issue of the Stud Book ILENE HORN Register in which the sire or dam is published. ` 823 BUTTONBUSH LN For Transfer Instructions,see back of Certificate. k ,, NAPLES, FL 34108-3428 This Certificate issued with the right to correct or t revoke by the American Kennel Club. io 412W" REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE a � NF 1111111 11111 11111 11111 liii liii c AMERICAN 8051 Arco Corporate Drive 61Ki, * KENNEL CLUB® Suite 100 ��NDEO peep Raleigh, NC 27617-3390 www.akc.org July 19, 2012 ILENE HORN 823 BUTTONBUSH LN NAPLES, FL 34108-3428 Congratulations on your new French Bulldog and welcome to the world of purebred dogs. Your AKC registration dollars support numerous AKC efforts to benefit dogs and dog owners. By registering your dog with the AKC, you supported valuable programs such as Canine Search-and-Rescue,the AKC Canine Health Foundation,the AKC Kennel Inspection Program, public education, canine legislation, and DNA parentage verification. AKC registration provides wonderful opportunities for every purebred dog lover. The AKC Canine Good Citizen®program is an outstanding way to train your dog in basic obedience, valuable for every family. In addition, many dog owners enjoy the thrill of participating in AKC activities, shows and trials throughout the country. I invite you and your dog to get involved with the AKC! Since your French Bulldog is a newly registered purebred dog,the AKC has arranged a Complimentary 60-Day Trial AKCSM Pet Healthcare Plan*for your new puppy—at no cost to you—but you must call PetPartners at 1-866-725-2747 or go online to www.akcphp.com to activate your plan and get details about this wonderful benefit. The cost of veterinary treatment has increased dramatically in recent years and the AKC Pet Healthcare Plan helps you pay your vet bills if your pet has an accident or is ill. Please note, if you ordered multiple items at the time of registration,they will be mailed separately and should arrive shortly. These include the AKC Certified Pedigree,the Dog Care and Training video, Family Dog magazine, and the AKC collar tag. If you did not order a Pedigree, you still have the opportunity to do so.An order form is provided on the back of this letter. All of us want to be responsible dog owners. To help, the AKC offers a wealth of information at www.akc.org. Our site lists national and local dog clubs and AKC Canine Good Citizen®evaluators. Please visit us online and on Facebook and Twitter. If we can be of further service to, please contact us by phone at 919-233-9767 or by email at info @akc.org. Sincerely, atd.f.i9 0.44411".. Dennis B. Sprung President and Chief Executive Officer *The 60-Day Trial Plan is provided by the master policy issued to the Association of American Pet Owners.Activation required.Administered by PetPartners,Inc.Underwritten by Markel Insurance Company,4600 Cox Road,Glen Allen,VA 23060.Not available in all states and only available to US residents.Eligibility restrictions apply.Contact PetPartners,Inc.for terms and conditions.Must be activated within 28 days of AKC Certificate Issued date.Visit www.akcphp.corMrial or call toll free at 1-866-725-2747. Please separate below and keep for your records. - .„, . ..se,.,.��,1,r,11111”W��.,.,.�,5.,ITA�,-W AMERICAN KENNEL CLUB .I N✓,,,../S/3/i5/5/.,,,,f/r/a+�/✓',...S..../I, a k NAME NUMBER k BRUTUS DONICA HORN NP31671113 k BREED SEX - h, FRENCH BULLDOG MALE --c., KEyt<, 1 `k COLOR FAWN,WHITE MARKINGS DATE OF BIRTH f iI APRIL 10, 2012 SIRE ',* *J MORENO DISSEL a',';o Meer" NP16780502 11-08 AKC DNA#V585602 DAM AMERICAN PRECIOSA KENNEL CLUB° NP23510303 08-12 BREEDER °r DANIEL G MORENO CERTIFICATE ISSUED JULY 19, 2012 OWNER This certificate invalidates all previous certificates issued. k If a date appears after the name and number of the sire and dam,it indicates the issue of the Stud Book ILENE HORN 823 BUTTONBUSH LN NAPLES, FL 34108-3428 Register in which the sire or dam is published. N For Transfer Instructions,see back of Certificate. This Certificate issued with the right to correct or revoke by the American Kennel Club. N R REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE- a c P ` b , '• re s '-q - oilA _.,„, m+fib n a_s-. � 5 . ta ,4� x . , f: . ti i •xi a C t aN' I • , ,-,,,,,, , ' - . ,,,,A,'''• .11 ., i.„-_-_, ...i...i....._;:.,.,_,;„„7.-...;,..,.,..,:z.:_:. .„ , . ...,...,„,........ „ .....,,, ..,,,I,,,,..;it.i., ,_,, ,-,;_ . , 1,„,., ,,,,,-,„•„:„,.:„.1.„.14_,.•..,s._1.7:1-451,05:_:„. ,::,-„•-. , .,.........,„ . .., ,. , ,:.,,,,,,,..„.:„. :„:!„.•,,,,..0„.„,,.„.., ...,,,,.„.,...45,41, .:„. ,., ,.•,, . ...„ .,.,.. .... , . ., _.. ,„-„,•-,,,,,.,.. -,, , iit eil„..i:11.4-4,4„.:_ ,:.-„,&.,c,..t.t..•_.,- :-•- _ ?.,•„*.•.,,,,-,,,, , , ..,,.:?,,,;.,,....„.. -.• . -,, ,;-.._,":4,, rel,. 1.ipt4itifa.,-- ,,,,:.__:;:i,..: •. -,:::v:.:-: ''-- --•.:::-. _ .,--::,!:,....i-41 i I: i;:',,,,:',,.:. i-.'•-,-;.:t.,ii-.--.--1,:ir4t.ti...,---.- ..e2,-- - -, - : i:.j.,,,,,',.L-.,. ,••04A:t..1.14 '. -. „..,.,44-ti',i, If I.1-,--,_,-,__:3-iog;'•',..,,.,.:•: ,„. - *7_ ..''. .._,',' •• 4 471-- . '''''.'-' --: ,,:-.- ...,,irtme4----,6•:-::- - . •-• -•-: • - i---- 1*-1-' • i.11,,,- ,- , -.;;,-• ,* 'lit J.' • . .._.,_. r „„. g .".." , . „.,..„. I .,,_ ...„.... ,.....„.. „...,p... ....,, -..., tji- ..• ff..'4 , 'l'_ —=.,,, -''--:.;••'-';;°'1!--..-'- . - = , IA . - '... ltA,, - --'-', • , „ . . ar „:--, •,i-, , 41.2.44P:":2'r,•:`,”. ' ,-,, -,* ,:!!!'• -*--'''•Y,. , •vvrA*-0.1, ',.•,-.:,:',,r. ,,, ' ''-irk 4 '-:- ' ' - • ' . .„401.-:," ' "----7.' '.:',. ;,,,. ..—_. _ 'r.,-••=,:,.•• •!, -,--, , ..: 1.- ' =t- t- • ' .,., , - . .... . ....„ „. . 4— ' ' ' •' ',-",-t.-?.:*;,--.: — .,. .._, ;:.'. "::•!." ......-.,.,_2,..-.T . ., i ,-,:,,-z,-, . . - -' -•.,.,..,„. ,.„„,... ;_-- -'-i't,--' 40111111111 .,. 14,.. . 1-, -,.. '....--A-k-_-...4,-- _ .._. ,. . . , .. . _.., .,,....::::T-,-*-:5---p--,-...._.:-•-.:•.;.-:: '-;:,:r.04..if:4.'''''' '',i''''.:- . _,,.., . ,,, : T-Tr4„,,,..,T, .• • ° :;%.„. ,,,„ 1_,T. PIV„..: . ..., ° - •:T. , ....._ , a ' a -a - 40. , „„,. ., .,,'",a',',...: 1,-•-, ,�,..p �' vs. "I ci 0 0 ' 2 ,P. -..._ jt.‘ . -'AtOilitlg.'' . p `16 _' t� � ---- �``t,_ _ � q st d i e `\c * 'ice. i k t .. a A a a I, • • . k N. st4 r,. i A 11 aY i' }.." gyp, i.. .., , , ,, , ,,, 4 , ,..„ ,,,... ,... ., ..„. ,... ....,i .. , ,,, „„ E r * d - �� W.„00 ..' ' o 4f� a it% '- \ 1 ,yak Nt •d 4. g , _„t„ 4, i I Ai'''. y y . . _ .. ,...... . . ..„ . . . 4- 1 .1■• •• IlY■ -,-. I .. .. ...... , - ,..4^....... Al ,,--..... , --,"'--- --- . - . ,-,---- - -• - -- ... , - 41*•....1 ., . - ------ .. ' _ __. .. ,._ te,...,- . - ..._-. , ._......_ . ..., ... ., ..... __ __....,... . ....... .. , . .. • ... „.........._ .._ ur . .. .... . .. ..__ .. ._ , _. r-- -.. ._ .. . CD . .._ _ •-..- C\i . ..,...... . - -r•-,,..,?-' N., --....._ ........ -......_ - ....,.-,...,r- M ..._......----,,,,,..L.__ - — • ....___.._,... --. - ...,„„, , \'\•.„,- --_,-. . - - - • \ , . • . ,. _ . , . . CD. . \., tkl , . : \.‘, t -.•:,,., - -,-,-:., . .. . . p.,.. ,..., , IL. de,. A.4•I` ,s \It,. ''‘ ,, *'.,' . •It.- ,,' ' '. . 1, ' ,4 ir;'• ' IV ' ' ..,p. ; s- . . `-. . . 'Jr yr ' - _.. -. ....... . , n 40 --..... ... ....,. , . , .c..... ' . , ... .,..' ..?... , I :* ... 4. ' , t. 0 mt. , •,-*4. ••:, '......- 1. - 4. - ik... ',Pt'•/ ' ''447*- ''', ki _..),i.....,.:: _. • '7,7 .1, le.' -.ifigair,,,-i „ler' :-.., -.' :•..-.4, • 0 , I' # ,-. .1* • -4t . , ,...., .... ;.+■, . . , .•- - ,..... ,... ,. t , . • • s illi•- 1. ... ,.... - .,--, .., .:4... , . , . , , . AP,..,---,,---t '- ,. .11! . ...--.-.--..„ — ' .111. ,... r II..--: ,.......-# ---- . : ... _ _ . ... 1%,,,.... 41,...... A ?„..,. . :'-fillit`,,•,' mt„ ...i :., , ,- —„• - - ,.. - - . , . . , --',a,_ -.. ' #. ."-+• I.- 1!, t t . ...., --...... f i 0 lop..... ......,,,,214....—...... . '• .•*, i ' - -% `t.*` ......0*--- ---- •-;.„ \ ,.s . ,1 - , ' ,...., -,,,.....- ',..... -....... -, —--........., 0' *4' • -,, '*., ' — "."- '1.• ° , --,•••• -0,1% .plor i •,,-"'‘,..- 4.-- ,..) - lt. ,..., '''_'N . . 2., - -- , .-_,..V., '-' --'41411111■1. 4 ..," , i ' , * LI.L. i o 411111116Z. * *. itzza '` ' . gIIIPIIIII ' - - _ 1111111141114"..lip . _ ..--• : '.- .a,,,, - . , . .... .-.. MM.- ... t 4 I 4111510101% *,, , ; . 4-• e'r.----7: , i, ; 'a • 4 L ,....... . ....- __it_ .. ,... - . ,., ...!,, , `.., ■ "Ik' _ , • ... ...JR If ' $.." . ., -- ,.. - j 0 t ,. --‘1'.'t .., 4 . % ,\, , # f A* - j-''*• ' , '....#1; -_ _ - -- 4.. , _ _ ,,,,..., -. ,- '' . ..1 it ost4 . ' - t . . ..• ... 11 i.. - . • . - ' /.. .- . 111'(•. ° 0 -ir I . ,. 4 44 t #1, ,1 At A- 1, , ..., ..• 44' 'It ' .'-' • ' '''<* 4. \. ' • "8 VI, . Iti -..... . \,,,;.. ...:,---z--- , . , „. *I' Atint ' - ., ' * ..■ /02' . , fr . 5 • • , \ **. - i' 7 • - - Or lir **V - I ,' -- • ) 41" ' .\ , ,.., ^ ....a ,- .... +. lifts . `• .4.• - , ..071111( , It.,„4,0 , • . . *-,..,,,. ' _ *1* . - „ 1 . '4*'41:4i4, 411* T. . ; '4' ■ . t,'"e4 .. .,, , -- - ., . . . f. i I r . '. P' I-' ,,,,W, . . 1 .s. ,� i R w • t ! II • « Via e ' .� x .r 1 /. C 'r .# ' f' ' F 1. . ' it1 `. r�� .:` d _ 8 aye. k�j _ £. . '. :AAA 4: 5,i',., 5. / , •, y < v ro i,? tea. fl ��, ' vY ° s ' �� a > v� d ' : .. - . 1---'-''''' '-''...'',.\■• _. ,,. . re • „,.'r'— #- ✓ a 7 At.' +� 4 . . k , wy• t y �� w . s *- a . CT e11r ,, .- Y L N 40,-?ti - 'cr.- ' 1 • , ♦ z« y Ry 4 <It' ,ter:..,4, , , 3 ,,,.. i _.,,, i, _ R ! F T�fi ms` µi - i _ . ' : '''' i \ \ t .. . - ,{ • •Nato, iris .01 L A , >_ as '.. v ■■ \ r Y ._ s - \ , _ i...., i___,..t x -F /Y ' 4 ib , , ' x /O y t ° . ., :".11:4411"*.'"" .0• r ( . �,Oa j - ",° •i4. •_ r�'�c r ,— ,. 7'771147A.pow :, • .4,,.... ..• 6. /MONIMM. .- V .. - **7 # , '•', ..% -• 4, , ;,,,• . - ..'.,. ... .: .....1::, Jr.,.- ..,_ .. :„..,...„ .. .,... ... ... ... to- , ....., .,•••,' •rja—' ' ' - A t 4 .4 "7•10/1,, .i,fr• ":,•,1" „,,. '• ,,r,.„....--, illt ' ..,., .-,!••,,A,;,,,,i'',,,,, -'7.,-,,, I-I-•- ,. ,..- ,',47't,-' •''"--,T2r,i.-?"44-1t7 i.,',.."""-,441,,,," ' -4..- -..i .j.„-,• .I.'''.';- .--.:..',',,,,"‘, c-•-sa., i'-'. '(.. ' ...... - . ' •: ., ,'....„? •,'.. . ' ..) 14, „,,,,„„: ,' •-•„,,,„. , - , •,-,. . ,• • : 4..-11,10...,. • ' ,• ..- - ti,•,:r.lik CV).,... C\J lot. .,j• . . • ... ---. --, ..... . , , . ..i. t ''',f,„,f.i,i7'••••#.4;57-'1"--t;-'27"' . • ' ' : ' ,. . -', -C ). , ) , t . .-. . .. . .,.•.- • „-- ,'",-..... t. . : 1 . .011100.Nt.. . . , -,t-•...1.t_74 ,.. ... '•1 • " I • • . - . - , r....0 rorf:%••,:t .., • , ... • „ , ..... .. , .... - 1. i• 1 ., ', IN,;.;. , 't• '' `f ,4'.• '.'s , ., ,. • i‘' _ .-. ( - _3111.-...• - '',•-rAtit' ''''' -.' '' ' ' i es ` .: . S • *' ' 1, , •L„. , A • Xt"• { \ - -• a 1 k • "'4*-,:•.,'s; , 2,-.'1;.;.. ... „.. • ,„ . • .,. 1 . • . . .,.$ 1 '-'''.',;41'''•-41.,'",,' , = • r , , , . , a • = =. . . , tr•••=.4 i • ,_ . , 11 • * . - .....-- • r„ •• lite4-4, 1 7, : •-.,,' , ..., •-. t... . . ," it,11.4 _ill i' ''''',.'4::7 '.'-',..7:'•'.:','-'7"',...-'.-•" -:. .— .., .i. -,,,..: ., - .-*.,,,,:..,,,,-,,,. -,,•.;.• t• s..... .-e-,,..„.„... . . . . .. ,,.. ,_ ... ' ,': '''*- ...2,. ,,,-.....1..',• '-',''-;:t';- $ .,. ... , . ... ' . 's _ / • - .• e ' .* - a, • ,... " ,,, r • .w . - -,,,..--•„„eir—==:•"'"- _ .., .17iOZ/Z/Zi °dr'6S66SL9£8179cSLL£OOPs 17 1OZ Jatii0D/Indino/duuigann/uzoa•.xasreaddeaaiiioa•nnnnnn//:d11u• ate MM o ;j. - - . 0 4 -. �a _ ? '' i i MP M e r a • ». ' a 0 I ,. r' 1 Jo1a nd o ......-- __, °a . :, � 0 , ..- ....', - .;:,,,,J..-:.. ......-- . , . ..., i< , .... „:„. ,.,.„,,,...„.,..._ F i . ,. i+ 9 Y. 8 0 ,,„ ,.. . , . . . - 4' ' -' N\ kik*. V µ,yM c a ?..1") .- r I ,.. ` - _.--- • i" °Q! H It +_ y Inc:F _ , '1 '°o.Y.__ t ' 1 .. F hv;,, ` L. vr r [Y1 t N a 4 .1 \ e W ,r� �.E�* v - 0' ' Y.„. 1:=:::Asi :,... ... T �. ` t ,g.. .....„ . ,./...1---7 ::, . .. - y ,. ... ,: ciwif ,,,,......,. . ., % „„,.. ..:„.,, ,, ..., , 'vat Frye ' , s 's . ,,.v,s s 4 ,, y , . k Or ' r ,,,. M 41•101■10.■ r w a. P ,, it t y` j f`�r y, R �lf� �� 3, V 11 ', • ! —+rte ,u r 11, # e�yy. i , , Y ', a • ' ". r4164 At .f,..- ?iv,—.e. .. ' • r '.l1 -- ft • «, * - y 1 3 y 0 4 k' 4*, a l• } r * . ti ., ! °< it Ittilig A y :, a .,t R fo. f 1 . . . -, # .. ..ct .'4, 11- ' ' 44,..A. 4 ' ' ,R ,. w, a r t p ' 4 tt... . i . t ., " fad Cr %._fiti. t ii Api,,, - - .;; . .., _„;r c;• 1 p�e.`' s N ( ,› 1 a7 !0 .. i / %ilk.. T ti i . 1I. p; ti, s \ ''''-'t ' i t i. . f , • C C; F .•&LL. C ' ♦ .x5 r , C3 N ,:h • f- C r p., , . , ) ' �.�` `r. R w ifkl ` ,� :�_ . � .off 4.,,..„„. ....,_„ ..„ „ „.„,,„..., ..., IP ' , ,.. "'Se". :,..***",..;74** ,4„. 4,;,... ,,,,1/4-- `fR� ,., . tit , z+sF M+/" , , �� � � fY.`� } 4! a �1 '4 YS ' "ate v A` • _ t/y, T*ZA - ti; -.-'1i,4 ra ,A'I !. a,,, .^i `� j . yt °4� y� W ¢ '°'"" 'Vii. "t , * '',., '''''.--'4 41' - - -4-4 . .- ,.., . ,,..,- „4-1,-.77. . -- 5i w• q -ry 9•t �: i y= ' o f =j..- 1° *"..A.. .�4 Yx, a rAP �, �"�' w s fi '4,,� u Nt. ' „� ,. 5 #, .1:0..1. . •; r % . ,, . : i ), - . : - � s T. ;, < ..{ , .. N.4t i'` 'y.,f, t 4. .. y,'A. . ' :* ! �, c ,t S k; r " tee+/ #4-, „,,, Q if It .s �:J • z z 4'0V - ON.. ., re. , , r • { x- I' ■ Illb A. •, i V !.` ; . .fit , i. "� 4 j y . i "� t �• OF I 'C [ Nt Ilik ‘4 t -A.,'"...: . 1-* .', . c: "'„`N :-,,,,--.. " ! / "„"F//' -1. - .• 1^ '444 mg , 4 ,,,,,-. i -i ta * x� 1C16 r % . , .1"...17,. „T. Ni....4'‘ik ...,11-- , , d. ;, t1} ,trt t ! 6r yR. } F s • i : ',1,.,,.,'N.,,,,,„: '' ;';', ':...i:, 14,. . 1 ,,,..st,. if,r,, ,, ,i, , .,# 4111:,,,. I , ': :'N; ;''' .:,,,t.'ff '''' ' '#.#''';',:, r9 f 4......,' # g, . . 4 74.4i444k 4. 1 , I ' '• *1'1 . .; 1 " . - - 0)' ... ' • ' ,Ar ' .‘ , IV' fr. ..... * . . : . '.0-'',‘'''''',7 ;ilk` ... .., - '' •. f '.' '..-i"Is'..1;.1t'" 4Ir .•„. . . • , e ' 4.1'''' I 't - e. * :-'. , '-0,-,.' ' Y,1',',..',' .. '-'''.,,:' *-•.:,,V- -`.4. - * „,., 4...i ... . -f '''' 01 # eihopr\ak ,,,,,,‘ ( lib 4 ! ,, I C i ..r.„1 411111.1 I Pd IIIIINIg _„,...., 1 IIIM4 I : ... ...... t . 111.110.„.--1111"- ilk I , • ". _- , ' .4 r 'Ilkf. a .. • ... , ..•' . , " • ' • ... . • .. - --, lit ...,. -.4f,s ....,- --- - ,,,,P , ..., - - ., .::,,,, lei iiii i.„ ...:., ,„,,,..z.,,i, . : ,n _ .., • ... - ...-- ,...., „,,... ,., .,, - ,... • ... I, - . ,,. ..„.„ ,.# • , .4� 1 g • ,, ' tO Ate. :,*:''' ` 0 , i ', .. I *,..' :.,.. r, 1,,,°,-, °II"' 4 A 1,0-4'''" ' _)i„:71. ,I,"?,, * :P.--'''' Ar 'l'--a**-,- - i. ',..:.';''1:: , * 1 ''. ft... * :,,,.4.6, ,..4hk-A. .z.la..4... ....:, ':.„.... to \11: ff' "11;ot i A,*A:tva‘`` 1 40 1 A i .. „t ,, ."..,. ' t �► + 1i+. ► Ii v , = / „ s f"-. • @, q) a' - „° _ �t ttliY n � y.� w l "1 % w 4,� t w . ..a..- , . ..- tit'''.� � '! � fl "� ar�,yr ` ' . ,# °i-Ms dam w r ,' a 44 48i l.4 ;r *rife ;al 0 °641 . a + • , ` a t w kW:'•�1 Ls` �z , 4 ° � _r may K4e � a,# .. — ^ v •�ilt,...„.. . !. A � 4' t ! r Y "� y� "�A 5 . It. ...# 4.rt 1 J n . . � �' 1L.= i- .+�"',�,e i �; ! g y� r�y y�' 1.`*' r� � ,I. .. . 4 r.... 4 *. s i � ' ce# a r` _ ak M i xf ° y w,r y ► ,q . . .. .414 .; IF!w 00, ir 4 i ' r°-t471.- t'''''''' 4 „I. ..4r- ----4,"-., 44 ...: - " 4"*" 4 . '.4'i..'', .. illib ', 9f .: - ,-. ..,'-,,t,...,- f , . .'40,17'., ,;,,' .t.', *,,..' -. ,,,,, ,ic,.. ,4, - - w Agt,,,r,„ 1;...„.. *, ,.. ' r.... , . , *{# `. ;� ]Lim r. "3 ' ' a i. k .. 4` •.,¢ &. Tk,.. a ;� + '1' tee., . r: `,;f. " °, ' + ' w . . oh-3 441 ti i t M • rrir a f, 4. ,„.\-, i. i ,ems' '''' .i.7,41*'11:1''''','.i''''...',-,,'.: ''' '4":'. ''''' ' ''''.f.' ' N r , 3 .. s j i ,,,: _ � v .... _yam I " � II'. € . i . - . --AL:--'3'-'1''''''s' ' ,11 , ,,,,,, 4 a --,-,..,4 ....__...„,tioilioillt 1‘.._ , • x -Q _ ti w 0. , N.'- ;" * *'"''',- r44%,, t. , ..„:„ -- ,,,,,, °''' ::''‘':°:----ft, ,°‘-‘t. . ,i1.,4,� � I .tea : � 4, .„..v , , , ,.1: - : , , ,, . _.-- --':.,,,,.... „,,,,,,.,...._ L ,,,,.. „,,,....,e• ,,,, 7%. ,‘,..,:„.%7".4....„,,.... ,,,, 4. . , .. . 'if, , --...../ \,.., , . , .• ' r . / t ' , ;• Idiot , : / ... , — . , , . , ,, , ,ft ''',:4!'il',, 4 ' ' \---4 ,,. - L . , .,,, ., . ..:, ‘ ‘ ...`.,' ''' , ■ 4:' ll''. ' \ ' ' -11 / .,'41 -, 1 s ' 47, /rw-- --„,,,ist. • *. ,...-, --.=,..(- ..--1 -.' i-jilt- „‘'' CI >vr' ‘ . • z„,..... . ... _.0,,.. ........ .., . ,,, .......... Ow •- ..._ ' kr 1 ' ) CY, ' ..=,-....... =' C 4 , . . I — st lk 11 411.114, 114 ....-..., . . ' — 4411..4)111111fr 44 if 411 1 ,... • V^ tt I . i s 0 . , —_ .,,,, , , lft• ,. . i 41' - 1 •"4-4. • ''''' .”" , , , Ai. N. • v t, J. ,.; ,...-44;•:- ..„ , .k.k '44,... " 44 ,.. . , . ...,.: ... % ,,,, ,.,t, • -. -'- 7!.4. , v -4 ....1....„. „.. ., . ..... .....„ .0„,....,-;,„ ... .... . ,.. 4 orrii; W' ih■ , '. .. 14 4 - 7 ir ''',,. ' . ' .,. ;Ps it ,,tiik,4414,1"‘'41k. .. 4 14,.' I: • r g i t*, ' » F • .; rr'. �m �' '. '7, e. 3 � ',ti' ,.s s i.'' / rt 1/4'1"..".10eY-" ,44j -.-.--,. . , ....-4"Cst s, e: * ..--7,---4 -0,,,- 1. , - i t L ft - •e'i.;, p` �` . X `, ` "l tipi ' �C { am .h its .N"- .r x s ,„ ' f , '¢ a 1 , w,i ' 4 .. 1 i rN` t c AL. . "' ' F ,r e ' s ' 3r . /fir .-„ki.4„,-, ., -..:1,,, ,,_,, , /1„ �o+� 1. i+ ! Al. 4 0y� �� g F+ ) ipe � .m". t' # e: y �.rn `� C0 A F .R. � # y � + � tZ,. ##m E s � � • z r+rtI t .f � t p s? � . *�� � . t sue'g ,. m 4,4;r44-4. r , " *" '... 4� ir �n£� �'r� a*r y . e ,i� � p ."rm 11---, x. f , " ^at +ra'∎ :* r 0 r 1 , ,, F„ t a h aF' F < ; t p f j d y« - g# ' . er y {r 4 !y'' + + '` 4y .� #. , em f r m 4 .4 .. t F«fi ,. ` +' 0. !I F t ht p r'rW .. ' t f'' •� w"�rz . *"A s r m F 4., - e f fq,.t'+ _ •M ` i • t f A" x � ` "i: �,:, ' a t'r '°' " ,:y 6"•^its, r ') ! >� »° # . • o tom:" . Y om it /�1 - rt ., r r J r4 . 11#F s. , n f v to 1 047,e4// rr n"sr, J. �r ,i, {r ,t . +„ "0..7, # ,,e).1.. ., # r § i 0.m# 's y *: fin, - r r� i M k.,. r- r , �'" t 4� m tom# i m k'r a �,si .3., , „ t.'N ma ^F yy, tai y y f S 4 4 , L4 ,r Y+ E F : r � 6 :%L LL ■ • ;,'' ‘ ' •. i, 4, 4,, , A r 0 I , y � • , , % 4 , R ,!►- # r- �+ O N . I I / ' I N '44 -' ' fli , ‘, '",, , ,, . ,, P,4 rl 4 , ,,,,./„i,.„,-.41 : c % ,,, ,,,,,,,,, „. „ . . , ,,,. .....„ _ ' , • 4> —, . ,,,•,, ,. , -.„..ip._•,,,,, , . .., , . ,,,, . . t.,,,•. i . .. �' 4 /dirt �► 4111 �k; tf,y° ! , l r i': • Jj 3 �r.', ' i , .. , '. t y . _.,- A. ',.. , , ., ,,,,%ti . , , ::.,-_. .4.L ' s.:,-...„:„. •,. , 4>, . 11 :., .:,,, 4,,, • , ,•,• ,•, ,..,„, , . .t ..1,,... -_,0% ,, .. 4b-./..ti At AV fir' 4 I ' 01‘;',>',.."0t • 1. ,4. /� ; rr . ./s' `ay' Z� : A , , ate • �"^ ,+ / r x _ p. w , _ may. ;' y n „tt i .,,,,,., , , ,, -:, "• r 1 .. _ _ ._ ..`_ [ w ' - - N "- : ; t F . „ •r,� N p w ' r; .. _ -s_ � te. m ' 41 ' , .c. ,.. ^` T F .. r " y n .4 Wk F '" err. �� �^ „, `,i ,e+ � -- wit. x "�°•a '�' ': ' V ' � µ M " . .14 .0.,,,.; ... iii, ..411„. , At :is r .,. ... �° q s 'rr # ,lib r it �r tea. I" Jon r" " yy a .;. M. Y y n