Loading...
Radio Road East MSTU Agenda 02/12/2014 Radio goad East s, le, Atoavut eommefte 32ei9 Ea¢t 7amau«i 714d Sucre W3 714,A144, 74 34112 MEETING AGENDA FEBRUARY 12, - I. CALL TO ORDER � ct H. ATTENDANCE III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: DECEMBER 11,2013 V. TRANSPORTATION SERVICES REPORT A. Budget Report—Caroline Soto B. Project Manager Report—Daryl Richard C. Landscape Architect Report—Dayna Frederick D. Landscape Maintenance Report—Affordable Landscaping,Inc. VI. OLD BUSINESS 1. Update on Status of Dead Plant Replacements 2. Update on Replacement of Beach Dune Sunflowers 3. Update on Status of Bus Stop relocation adjacent to "The Shores" 4. Update on Grant Applications VII. NEW BUSINESS VIII. COMMITTEE COMMENTS IX. PUBLIC COMMENTS X. ADJOURNMENT NEXT MEETING April 9, 2014—10:00 AM— Plantation Club House, 7773 Tara Court, Naples, FL 34104 December 11, 2013 walla goad Sue S.7 Zl. d care 3299£aat 7amiaoke?lad Suite 103 e, 6 ?taglea. 74 34112 MEETING MINUTES DECEMBER 11,2013 I. Call to Order The meeting was called to order by Mr. Johnson at 10:00am. Roll call was taken and a quorum was established. II. Attendance Members: Chairman Dale Johnson, Sue Chapin, Thomas Depouw, Renato Fernandez, Janice Bundy. County: Darryl Richard—Project Manager;Michelle Arnold, Director, ATM; Roger Dick, ATM Project Manager; Harry Sells, ATM Project Manager; Pam Lulich, ATM Landscape Operations. Others: Dayna Fendrick— Urban Green Studio, Albert Benarrock-Affordable Landscaping Service and Design; David Durrell—Juristaff. III. Approval of Agenda Ms. Chapin moved to approve the Agenda. Second by Mr. Fernandez. Carried unanimously S- 0. IV. Approval of Minutes: October 9,2013 Ms. Chapin moved to approve the minutes of the October 9, 2013 meeting as presented. Second by Mr. Depouw. Carried unanimously S- 0. V. Transportation Services Report A. Budget Report—Darryl Richard Mr. Richard provided the following documents for information purposes: • "Radio Road East MSTU Fund 166—December 11, 2013. " • "Radio Road East MSTU Loan Amortization Schedule. " • "Affordable Landscape Estimate Tracking. " He provided an overview of the financial status of the Fund noting: • There have been some unexpected expenditures for repairs expensed to line item 17 — Incidental Repairs. • The cost of the repairs has already exceeded the annual budgeted amount. 1 December 11, 2013 • The Beach Dune Sunflowers planted at the tips of the median have not provided the intended visual appearance and may need to be replaced. • There are approximately $30K of funds intended to be utilized to complete the final median easterly on Radio Road and $13K allocated to the Reserve for Contingency line item which may be utilized to offset FY14 expenses. Committee discussion occurred on the following items: • Concern carry-over funds from FY13 were utilized to offset projected expenses for FY14 and the practice cannot continue over the long term as the goal should be for annual expenses to equal annual revenue. • The feasibility of deferring construction of the final phase for approximately 2 additional years and utilize a portion of the funds for the existing project until expenditures have stabilized and have the areas maintain the appearance originally intended. Grant Applications Staff reported there may be opportunities for Grant funds for roadway beautification and consideration should be given to submitting applications seeking those funds. The Committee determined Ms. Chapin will coordinate preparation of the applications and submit to Staff for dissemination to the other Committee members for review and comment. B. Project Manager Report—Darryl Richard Addressed under item V.A. C. Landscape Architect Report—Dayna Frederick Dayna Fend rick,Urban Green Studio provided the"Landscape Architects Field Report —Field Report No. 3" and "Landscape Architects Field Report—Field Report No. 4"for information purposes. She outlined the results of the field visits including the action taken to correct any issues. The Committee requested Staff to submit the Landscape Architect Field Reports to the members for their review as soon as they are completed by the vendor or on a monthly basis. Beach Dune Sunflower Replacement—Tips of Medians Staff submitted the document"Radio Road East MSTU Beach Dune Sunflower Replacement Estimated Cost for Various Options" for consideration. The document included a photograph of an area landscaped with Asian Jasmine and Bromeliads. Committee discussion occurred on the options. Ms. Chapin moved to replace the Beach Dune Sunflowers in the tips of the medians with Asian Jasmine and Bromeliads in a format similar to the photograph referenced above. Staff to obtain price estimates on the costs and timeline necessary to complete the work and submit the proposal to members for comment via email. Second by Mr. Depouw. 2 December 11, 2013 Mr. Depouw amended the motion to include the original motion and to include adding Bromeliads to the two existing medians currently planted with only Asian Jasmine in the area of the Plantation to improve the visual appearance of those areas. Second by Chairman Johnson. Carried unanimously 5—0. D. Landscape Maintenance Report—Affordable Landscaping Service Al Bennarock of Affordable Landscaping Service provided an overview of recent maintenance activities. Replacement of Dead Plants Staff reported they are in the process of reviewing the status of any dead plants and related warranties. They will be coordinating with the consultants and original contractors to develop recommendations on a course of action. Staff will provide the recommendations to the Committee for their review. The Committee noted this activity should occur as soon as possible. Goal of the MSTU regarding existing work completed vs. initiating new work in the final Phase Committee discussion occurred whether the goal of the MSTU should be to utilize existing funds to construct the final phase of the project as planned; or defer landscaping it until the existing medians have achieved the visual appearance originally intended. It was noted there are no residential developments fronting the final median to be landscaped, and it would be prudent to ensure the existing areas are completed as intended. The Committee determined to focus available resources on completing the existing areas as originally intended before initiating a new phase. VI. Old Business 1. Update on Radio Road/Madison Park Traffic Signal Mr. Richards reported the Transportation Planning Department will be undertaking a new traffic study to determine if a signal is warranted. VII. New Business Ms. Arnold reported Staff the County will be relocating the existing CAT bus stop near"The Shores,"to a location closer to Santa Barbara road in an effort to improve pedestrian access to the stop. VIII. Committee Comments None IX. Public Comments Speaker Leslie Lilien addressed the Committee noting, as a resident she is impressed with the MSTU's actions and decisions. She noted there may be no residential development adjacent to the final 3 December 11, 2013 median to be landscape, but it is the"entryway"to the MSTU and the work should be completed as soon as funds are available. Being no further business to come before the Committee, the meeting was adjourned by the Chair at 12:10P.M. RADIO ROAD EAST MSTU ADVISORY COMMITTEE Dale Johnson,Chairman The Minutes were approved by the Committee on , as presented , or as amended . The Next Meeting is February 12, 2014-10:00AM Plantation Club House 7773 Tara Court, Naples, FL 34104 4 Radio Road East MSTU FUND 166 February 12,2014 Vendor Item P0# Budget Commitments Expenditures Total 1 CUR AD VALOREM TAX $ (83,200.00) $ - $ (71,994.11) $ (11,205.89) 2 FIFTH THIRD 0/N INTEREST $ - $ - $ (4.87) $ 4.87 3 INVESTMENT INTEREST $ - $ - $ (152.69) $ 152.69 4 REVENUE STRUCTURE $ (83,200.00) $ - $ (72,151.67) $ (11,048.33)'';';'; 5 TRANSFERS FROM FRCP APP $ - $ - $ - $ - 6 TRANSFERS FROM TAX COLL $ - $ - $ - $ - 7 CARRY FORWARD GEN $ (53,100.00) $ - $ - $ (53,100.00) 8 NEG5%EST REV $ 4,200.00 $ - $ - $ 4,200.00 9 TRANSFERS&CONTRIB $ (48,900.00) $ - $ - $ (48,900.00) TOTAL REVENUE $ ,(132,100A0) $ - $ (72,151,67) $ (59,948.33) 11 ENG FEES OTHER Urban Green Studio Landscape Architect Serv. 45-147566 $ 11,500.00 $ 7,245.00 $ 4,290.00 $ (35.00) 12 INDIRECT COST REIMBURS Collier County Indirect Cost Direct Pay $ 1,100.00 $ - $ 550.00 $ 550.00 13 LANDSCAPE NCIDENTALS Affordable Landscapng Incidentals 45-147258 $ - 5 2.225.00 $ 275.00 $ (2,500.00) Affordable Landscaping Grounds Mainenance 45-147258 $ 23,409 92 $ 6,977.87 Urban Green Studio Landscape Architect Serv. 45-147566 $ - $ 2,465.00 14 OTHER CONTRACTUAL $ 70,000.00 $ 23,469 92 $ 9,442.87 $ 37,087.21 16 ELECTRICITY FPL Electricity 47-001724 $ 1,000.00 $ 3X.177 $ 179.03 $ 500.00 16 RENT EQUIPMENT J.M.Todd Shared Copier Lease 45-147422 $ - 5 .23 06 $ - $ (133.06) 17 INSURANCE GENERAL Collier County Insurance General Direct Pay $ 300.00 5 - $ 75.00 $ 225.00 Florida Irrigation Irrigation Parts 45-147372 $ 644.0; $ 555.93 Hannula Landscaping Repair to Imp.System 45-148531 .1 147 50 $ 437.50 Naples Elec.Motor Works Run Multi Conductor Wire 45-148472 - $ 495.72 Naples Elec,Motor Works Repair Pump System 45.148135 - $ 1,27665 18 SPRINKLER SYSTEM MAINT $ 1,500.00 $ 701 57 $ 2.765.9; $ (2,057.37)'. 19 MULCH Forestry Resources Mulch 45-147139 $ - 5 500.00 $ - $ (500.00) 20 OTHER MISCELLANEOUS Juristaff Inc Secretarial Services 45-147139 $ 1,800.00 $ 1.300 00 $ 200.00 $ 300.00 21 OFFICE SUPPUES Staples Office Supplies 45-147413 $ 200.00 $ 100.00 $ - $ 100.00 22 COPYING CHARGES J.M.Todd Copier CPC 45-147480 $ - $ $ 100.00 $ (100.00) Diamond Fertilizer Fertilizer 45-148252 $ 15.20 $ 184.80 Florikan Fertilizer 45-147396 $ - 01 20.00 $ 1,980.00 23 FERT HERB CHEM $ 2,000.00 $ 35.20 $ 2,164 50 $ (200.00) 24 OPERATING EXPENSE $ 88,400.00 $ 36,120.72 $ 20,042.50 $ 33,236,78 25 REIMBURSEIiENT FOR STAFF SUPPORT $ 24,200.00 $ - $ - $ 24,200.00 26 Budget Trans from Appraiser $ 3,000.00 $ - $ 372.74 $ 2,627.26 27 Budget Trans from Tax Collector $ 2,200.00 $ - $ 1,555.18 $ 644.82 28 TRANSFERS $ 29,400.00 $ - $ 1,927.92 $ 27,472.08 29 RESERVES FOR CON11NGENCIES $ 13,300.00 $ - $ - $ 13,300.00 'rr: 30 RESERVES $ 13,300.00 $ - $ - $ 13,300.00 31 TOTAL BUDGET $ 132,100.00 f $ 36;120.72 $ 21,970.42 $ 74,008.86 Total Available Balance $ 74,008.86 0 FY 10 Final Taxable Value Plus Commited And Not Spent $ 36,120.72 348,180,488 FY 11 Final Tangle value 337.298,857 339525.637 FY t 3 F,....T....,.v.,.. I Estimated Cash $ 110,129,58 I.;: 360,794,734 626%A„..13,.14 I Estimated Cash Less Missing Income $ 98,923,69 I FY 14 FY 13 Millage 0.2306 0.2401 Maximum 4.5000 Extension 83.199 81,520 P,.,...,T..L.,,...,.,,I,..... f Y-4.,.....I.... V..... 360.794,734 M...,,, N...C., A...,.. 7.314 7B2 P,..:A.....,..../1 TV C ,,. 0 351479.952 31.520 R.,,..e...R...(,...A,.....O ) 92306 0.2099 /1,//— ;, i i - Q8 O i o \ 0 ® a 1 g 1 \ li Iii ; t, s:°:' I ' 'F I i � il as OE ® ®OS I i qk 11 $3 ^1 - -V 6N f I* 11 o z o 1 '� II l 4, $ i. o — Zt X14 � s � Ij1'+, jl 1 � z ? o p o �� � � �A I �i vii I 14 1 i" i "' •l / k 1111 `.:. Kli 11 S D _ #-(4- \ !-A---m. i 4 _ 711 _ .,z vol. 0 4,_41101 .; . i- IT- / I III . _ `, li 1 C q's 6' I \ ° 1 ‘lij R i I 1-' T i . A 4, 10,.. , , 2,0 l 1 li -t... a 1 I 117 i iiI \ Ii;a (14, iii: t� ri ye� =;.s E';-. 1 le e .I°_ � I ; a 4.. 11111IIIII 3;11 F= � I 1 1 `� 1 i I Illi1' '111,1 111 11 11 4 . F b! --tsl. L. .1. , , j t_____ZI IL flf ; 1 i N-) -- - i14si 4111 _`VIII' 5f i VI t I l j ----- I f , og .`Q I —I� ""�4. 1 ---I i8 21:11_4... i l i .d -- z' I .1; I �z - �. _)/ m i 3 4®� 1 f I If S a oo z i r i= Q s O n m 1 { , ; Os ®o ® ®o e � , I I �1 iiiii Yr lo I Am � S < O I �� 11 r m K z . gl 3 ii 4 4,. 1, __ , , , lc-4 ' :.. ' . , 1 1 �•, I /c I iii, �oi� , a 3 i 0 ' i 0 • cr) i 1 1\ g * ;II '4 II I g ill ,. • iI 1 I l !I ',o ! I ��ai� n i .g. 1 4 ,. 7 ;$ r :1 ' .. I ; 3 i . . ,o i 0, gp 1 1 1 1 1 e .../ --f i • ' II '4\ .• 1 ED \` Y o i.i \ 0, , t] i i�11/0 I! 11 f i ,1 ilie il vi 1, . , _,,, s _,s 186E a _„let �_�� ::sy , +- i l e a} 1 �lllf °� Fly 1 1; 1 1 i ---, ! 0 N — 3 1 I i i 1/'u 11111 j'1fl f 1 111 !j `i OC -0m -j_ ■i I c I I � O --- : 1 - e SEE 9HEE..03 i t a 1 I' 1 p` it I ■ I O 1 ® p ©O 1 °° 11 q lit 1 ,,' i 6)°0 -e 7-0 ,zk , \ g ii 7, O li ° I ;uiiiij1 °0 1i 1 ;- ,t Av it .g� "\ I 1 I m f,l`� g #•s� � 6`.4 V1 I - '7 I' ` a \ I I 1 .aa. G n:�' i m _' ° z . o , .0 0 1;y� . 11 o -4‘. ?CI,, 6. i i.. Y D 3 I O F (�- o ml c 1 by 0 il II "OT Zx , lit ,., ,\ ii. , ,, ,,, , - ; 3 i G., Ts ii c l Im ,4 .1 I I \ I, I ' 31 t-1.-'4- •-rt. csa H ..k, „, . ,_____4, -ca. 110 .....„ ......, F- i A 11 k 1 V '''' t H , ° A S S a 01 1 1 °I* rt'. I g1 °$c.) .ice Z I , o ,k,,,,a,,,_ tr te.,__ Z O I iii, go. 33,' -' 8p3ai rrs1 SppHBp 1;7:3c:asa �.s jp°° ,,s "- 1 11 I " h- -- ilit► 'VI 11 Mil , 1' 1 II vi . 1 F I 1 tp S ,a S� 8pi+ { till! e 3f, - ' ' - -- \iii i i '11111 i 1 ill il i 1 -q=• T1:'pp 0 `e- i i D 1 To i l �,:: I i i I 1 .. ea ' i qr.'. I ® ., rn 9 ® I \] i 1 3a ° ! UQ Q�V I % .IN. IiI 51 .ii,,, o .T-R '�O� m Pi 11 0 _ f 1 __1 F S, , 6., if. -: S a , ill II?"1,.� azatt t1\ � � 7P ^ `� CS p I I �- !I..- S1 4 A __, A � 0 t IS\ 4 s, f ,..., - 1 ..„) 1 , 1 ' r-.,E • Te. ' .-3 =* j i II i' liiira S �a a� � a S C a 11;g 1 § I I , € a ■ o I A' m > I < S Iii y z T .1>. �1►'I ill . ,' I 0 -;;* G, ,,,. 7 7 i,-'4 .1- -- c, o =-, \ 4 _ , ..._._ ,.„.. , , l© ,- , .--. c-, 14 1 N U v " D ' ) 1 I t ��.�� 1 I pm� t 2 sNv t ), I 1' 1ill -, I k •-.114 ,te_, LI:1,-i ; i I , , I i-ig m � .o 1 °; N- 1 i 11 o z p , e11 m i 1 ; T Rl q i 1 F*t ig lh ! it I1II 11 s1 t 1 '5 1 r.' 1 L z I� A=-- w `I; i I('! :11111' thU 111 Z I j ��©�1,'0`, ��j t/// 7 �, z "t7 m C ++;ID F ' Rl V i u_;.II 1. 10° 1 ''� a J,6 v,, 7; 1 ' j I\i I. ht\17Sa.*".-Pl.I 12 I '... 1 I 0/0 lit. ...... 1 1 r vl , , 6 ir.) 1 i m - S 2 Go (9(9 oc,0 I , , _,4 \ n ' 1 g Q ®� cep g1,.� d I I HH€s m Q A i i. - -Ii - _., tik ii P • , \Eicjlo 1 . t ,.5, , -7,-- " ,\. • _ o • ,c 70) tZ 1 i l I 3 0 • o :- I p 1 j " i1 1 ,� ' 1 1 !=vhsvoiii: ,A1. 1 I t(' ,. v- > �g N N - �':y' a 1 I ' 1• I ■1 I ti ti 1 i� G , ` I c �-- I � tri il *A. � I 2., i , ZS 4n__ 1 \IN z - . Zr iii '''il b ' ., , iiiii';f e 5eeeee �;:tr '' 'i • r II 1 �t R i f 1 i X11" I I * Gin., ' ~? qrD 11`11! !1111,1• Oral! Ii' ill 1_,. T„,, t 't il'! s �M I� Ii If: ' a ; m �_ r— i t I i 11 � ci ' 1 I m - z 1 I ' ' I---�+ --�--- i cn I' i v eF via. UJ o ------i-1'ii--t`— 1 w.ouvE '�T� -- },• a I ;1 I • �` lI I • ,� ; � zE a I ,$ 1 , ,1 l i 11 = "W • ® 1 iii g mA to .®e . R!:1 E ii! i l ;i i I _ ,� m llF Bill !• s •® • 1 I 42 I, _, , p 5- y b o � 1 $ s 111 3 g~ �`Z. 3. >5 !may 1 *Z 1,1, k;vg •,1��'• k.:. N\ CSI t‘..ig? ej 431 1 li g3 - 8: ›-3 ; 1 milt& 0 F. - &i )'. -- 4 0 • 0 . -di* - i Zriig I J i its i , . I -- , j '. 1 - - �� gl. I I i7 1 -.....co—'- I II z j J f �I I i1 1. , s - Z 1 II / ';, X. P 3 1 1 1 c, 1 IR 1 . -t 1 , , fl it ,� 11 ( I 1 I W1 _ GN 753 fN 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ; 1 l i 1 i 0 '---)A j iN G; � , c 1 a 6 � V' d z I I I I I S 1 1 1 Z 1 1 1 j 3 ii I I I I I rn 111 1 1> 1 pl., ' 1 ii 11'11111111j 1a I 1 N '�E11t .iiiIEMill ;pIEt! 1� T_ 111 11'1 1I1111 1 11! �i I �) 'ITT (i' --- 11 1 ' I 1 9 , I I h _- _- —_— _ I ), I - j /II i I _o - - IN v A n o w N N .1- F:,.. O Z .i n N W 4 W N c 0 E ° ra Q Eo 3 Y m w ,5 m ce a o m .a v L o `o c h0 II I`O U W 0 N w E ry 0 0 o O o 0 0 o vi W 'F-' p] P H fR to to W to IPr V1 W V. M W V. V1 °o o °o, o °o °o °o N o C N N N N .-I N O rV a E D VI- W fh VY art Vf fR Y+ M tPr J Q u� u� u� ug ug w w w m m g 0 d w� o .-.1 CO^ rn o ii f l N co co co w a) is E_ 3 m v 3 r o H ,n ; ; c v C LOn c O U E 0 10 N V _ra IN W u C CL N O O O E O U N N jj m O' R Cr Na :Cr x n C •N C W a a a a n a E. O O U m i) O) O, 01 O< In 0, O+ .-■ N n U N 1 0 o`- « O N 4 C L C 0 ra 0 ti y L 2 C N N o E o N N O U C ll t `E °E Ti ra . ✓ v u w A Z t -8 E 2 "' C ? ,, o L o E a O m o E IL U v v p n 1= . c m 0 a, m o m Q Z m n 0 ai m c 75 ,o 0 B - C o -C Q N « E OI N r0 o @ m y a 1L C Z S O N E n y m 1-' .v U ¢ f u 0.F y ? w 0 t m j T W v E V1 = c O 0 ro C O 0 10 -o d RI u . m Z C Q O _ 0 .Q 'N m C C ` O Q ^ S ° c u 'v E N t v C 3 tn w °' v V -6 1p 3 E. n s t Q E n '° o �i c A 0 m " g E .� E in n m .i� E 0 (0 0 my c Q o 0 W m a ,� g ro Q U rn > > o o+ « (0 o v m _0 V' d p E E E $ g E H E E .0 o c w ' 2 O O . H r0 Z L L L C w E w 'L'' O w0 L 0 n O N F- y r f' z Q ¢ ¢ z z 0_0 C f a0i m °�{ �' ai ; ap p w V) m 2 • Z U W 2 T _ 2 O E. r=r 'o % tL ~ 'O'X C L 2 a g C = QQ1 .QQ� 4 M �0 IL N d _ W t t W V C V C Z , C j 0- N -a., < o E °Q m° � mmmmmmm > H LL Zuu0 m <S < C '- W Z .c m U S 0 C 0 « m = IA w 0 S N ro 0 Z . i' 0 . V it 0 u u Q c a 0 'rJ Z a 0 0 J ° Z 5 Y m 0 f x en : Estimate Affordable Landscaping Date Estimate# Service and Design. LLC Pest Control and Tree Service 1/28/2014 2014456 658 Bald Eagle Dr. Marco Island, Fl 34145 ,,t Phone: 239.389.1468 Fax: 239.389.1434 Email:Landscapinggalsmarco.com SERVICES ADDRESS BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COLLIER COUNTY RADIO RD EAST CLEARK'S FINANCE DEPARTMENT MSTU ROADWAY LANDSCAPE MAINT. ATTN ACCOUNTS PAYABLE CONTRACT#13-6090,po#4500144489 3299 TAMIAMI TRAIL E.STE 700 NAPLES,FL 34112-5749 Quality services at an Affordable Price P.O.No. Terms Job Location REP Builder 4500144489 Due on receipt 055 Qty Description BEACH DUNE SUNFLORWER&BROMELIAD REPLACEMENT RADIO ROAD EAST 18 ORANGE BROMELIAD **ITEM#47 70 AMPA BROMELIAD**ITEM#47 55 MEXICANA ALBO BROMELIAD **ITEM#47 1 IMPERIAL BROMELIAD **ITEM#48 128 GAZPACHO BROMELIAD **ITEM#50 78 SUNKISS BROMELIAD **ITEM#48 42 PORTEA BROMELIAD **ITEM#48 2,011 ASIAN JASMINE#1 **ITEM#62 867 APPLICATION COUNTY MULCH**MATERIAL PROVIDED BY COUNTY "ITEM#67 56 LABOR DIG OUT DUNE SUNFLOWER **ITEM#16 Thank you.We appreciate your business Total $18,562.91 Signature