Radio Road Beautification MSTU Agenda 10/14/2013 Radio Road Beautification M.S.T.U.
Advisory Committee
3299 East Tamiami Trail Suite 103
Naples Florida 34112
III OCTOBER 14,2013
AGENDA [ ,gTQ TIE
I. CALL TO ORDER DEC 31 2013
II. ATTENDANCE By
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: September 9,2013
V. BUDGET REPORT
'VI. LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE REPORT—ROBERT KINDELAN, CLM
VII. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT'S REPORT—SCOTT WINDHAM
VIII. PROJECT MANAGER'S REPORT
A.
I.X. OLD BUSINESS
X. NEW BUSINESS
A. Reschedule November Meeting Date(Veterans' Day Holiday)
XI. COMMITTEE MEMBER COMMENTS
XII. PUBLIC COMMENTS
NEXT MEETING: NOVEMBER 11,2013 — 3:00 PM
Berkshire Lakes Master Association Clubhouse
495 Belville Boulevard,Naples,FL 34105
Radio Road Beautification M.S.T.U.
Advisory Committee
4 0: 3299 East Tamiami Trail Suite 103
Naples Florida 34112
September 9, 2013
DEC 31 20,J
MINUTES Li
By
I. CALL TO ORDER
The meeting was called to order by Chairman Dale Lewis at 3:04 PM.
A quorum was established. Three voting members were present.
II. ATTENDANCE:
Members: Dale Lewis, Chairman
Helen Carella,John Weber
(Vacancy)
Excused: Fred Rogers
County: Darryl Richard—MSTU Project Manager
Harry Sells—MSTU Project Manager
Others: Scott Windham—Windham Studio, Inc.
Robert Kindelan—CLM
Al Benarroch—Affordable Landscaping Service &Design, LLC
(Anne Iacuzzo—JuriStaff)
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Addition:
• Item VIII.— "Project Manager's Report"
o Under"A." Review Quotes: Add—"Rich King Project Quote"
John Weber moved to approve the Agenda as amended. Chairman Dale Lewis offered a
Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously,3—0.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: June 17,2013
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to approve the Minutes of the June 17,2013 meeting as
submitted. John Weber offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 3—0.
V. BUDGET
(Report attached: "Radio Road MSTU Fund 158, dated September 9, 2013")
• Current Ad Valorem Tax: $ 308,200.00 (anticipated)
September 9,2013
• Received to date: $ 296,387.06
• To be Collected: $ 11,812.94
• Operating Expenses: $ 200,000.00 (Line Item 33)
• Open Purchase Orders: $ 39,287.83
• Spent to date: $ 127,784.71
• Operating Funds Available: $ 32,727.46
• Improvements General/Capital: $ 350,300.00 (Line Items 34 and 35)
• Reserves(for contingency): $ 3,200.00
• Total Budget(Available funds): $ 387,758.99
Darryl Richard suggested the Members consider setting aside additional reserves for a
Hurricane Contingency Fund. In the event of a hurricane,while insurance does pay for
most costs,there will still be miscellaneous issues which may not be covered.
John Weber stated Countryside has a larger Reserve fund.
Darryl Richard noted the millage rate will be considered during the next Budget cycle.
He stated the cap is .5000 in the budget and the current rate is 0.3185.
Chairman Lewis stated his concern was encumbering funds that could be used for other
projects and noted additional work is to be done on Devonshire.
Darryl Richard stated the County Planners reminded him that there is undeveloped
commercial outparcel/grassy knoll on Devonshire Road(next to Walgreens). He noted
the shrubs may be in the Right-of-Way;they should be removed and replaced with a
Calusa Hedge as a buffer. Utilities were also a consideration.
Chairman Lewis asked Scott Windham for recommendations.
Scott Windham stated the area will require irrigation. If the shrubs are in the R-O-W it
must not interfere with the sidewalk.
John Weber asked about a cut-through for walkers.
Darryl Richard stated the R-O-W should be staked or surveyed as a first step. There will
be demolition to remove old roots and healthy soil installed. Also to be considered is the use
of different plantings that are shade tolerant.
Action Item: Darryl Richard will prepare an estimate of basic costs.
John Weber moved to approve utilizing the original SDP drawings to obtain a quote
for a survey of the area.
Scott Windham raised a question of liability concerning a pedestrian cut through. If the
businesses in the plaza were not receptive,walkers could be"dumped"into a loading
dock area, for example. He suggested developing an actual pathway that leads to the
marked crosswalk by First Watch. If people cut through elsewhere,they will do so on
their own.
(It was noted that the Motion did not receive a second.)
Consensus: Scott Windham will provide an overview of the project at the next meeting.
2
September 9,2013
Scott Windham pointed out pavers were more attractive than plain concrete for the
vehicle pads; it was a more esthetic look.
Darryl Richard stated the Bonness quote included additional compacted limerock
for the base which complies with F-DOT standards. The total amount of the quote is
$9,573.10. He supported the choice of pavers.
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to accept and approve the proposal submitted by
Bonness,Inc., not to exceed$9,573.10.
Discussion ensued. Chairman Lewis also supported installing pavers.
Helen Carella offered a Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously,3—0.
Darryl Richard confirmed the work will not begin until after the rainy season is over
and new Purchase Order will not be cut until after October 1's.
B. Review of Quotes: Rich King Greenway Entry Project
• Quotes were submitted by Leo Jr. Landscape, Hannula Landscape, and
Commercial Land.
• The lowest bid was submitted by Leo,Jr. at$9,756.95.
• Leo,Jr. has not worked for the County previously.
• Scott Windham noted the difference was in the area of labor—Leo Jr. may
have underestimated the cost.
Scott Windham pointed out it was a relatively small project and a good test to evaluate
the vendor's capabilities.
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to accept and approve the proposal submitted by Leo
Jr. Landscape.,not to exceed$9,756.95. John Weber offered a Second in support
of the motion. Carried unanimously,3—0.
Darryl Richard confirmed the Purchase Order will not be cut until after October 1st
IX. OLD BUSINESS
(None)
X. NEW BUSINESS
A. Meeting: Change of Time
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to approve changing the meeting time from 2:00 PM
to 3:00 PM for all future meetings. Helen Carella offered a Second in support of
the motion. Carried unanimously,3—0.
XI. COMMITTEE MEMBER COMMENTS
(None)
4
September 9,2013
XII. PUBLIC COMMENTS
(None)
NEXT MEETING: October 14,2013 at 3:00 PM
Berkshire Lakes Master Association Clubhouse
495 Belville Boulevard,Naples,FL 34105
There being no further business to come before the Committee,the public meeting
was concluded at 4:15 PM.
RADIO ROAD BEAUTIFICATION MSTU
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
$ I I
DALE LEWIS,CHAIRMAN zit
The Minutes were approved by the Committee Chair on 1-et• �1— ,2013
"as submitted" IXl OR "as amended" ( 1.
5
Radio Road Beautification M.S.T.U.
'✓ Advisory Committee
3299 East Tamiami Trail Suite 103
Naples Florida 34112
September 9, 2013
SUMMARY: MINUTES AND MOTIONS
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Addition:
• Item VIII. — "Project Manager's Report"
o Under"A." Review Quotes: Add—"Rich King Project Quote"
John Weber moved to approve the Agenda as amended. Chairman Dale Lewis offered a
Second in support of the motion. Carried unanimously, 3—0.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: June 17, 2013
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to approve the Minutes of the June 17, 2013 meeting as
submitted. John Weber offered a Second in support of the motion.
Carried unanimously, 3—0.
V. BUDGET
Darryl Richard stated the County Planners reminded him that there is undeveloped
commercial outparcel/grassy knoll on Devonshire Road (next to Walgreens).
Action Item: Darryl Richard will prepare an estimate of basic costs.
John Weber moved to approve utilizing the original SDP drawings to obtain a quote
for a survey of the area.
(It was noted that the Motion did not receive a second.)
Scott Windham raised a question of liability concerning a pedestrian cut through. He
suggested developing an actual pathway that leads to the marked crosswalk by First
Watch. If people cut through elsewhere, they will do so on their own.
Consensus: Scott Windham will provide an overview of the project at the next meeting.
VII. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT'S REPORT—SCOTT WINDHAM,WSI
Darryl Richard stated Scott Windham had submitted a proposal for Maintenance
Consulting Services at a total cost of$19,790.00.
September 9,2013
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to accept and approve the proposal submitted by Windham
Studio, Inc. Landscape Architecture for maintenance consulting services, not to exceed
$19,790.00. John Weber offered a Second in support of the Motion.
Carried unanimously, 3—0.
Chairman Lewis thanked the vendors (WSI, CLM, and Affordable Landscape) for their
work during the year.
VIII. PROJECT MANAGER'S REPORT
A. Review of Quotes—Vehicle Pad Installation:
• 40 vendors were contacted but only 2 proposals were submitted
• Bonness, Inc. was the lowest bidder
Scott Windham pointed out pavers were more attractive than plain concrete for the
vehicle pads; it was a more esthetic look.
Darryl Richard stated the Bonness quote included additional compacted limerock
for the base which complies with F-DOT standards. The total amount of the quote is
$9,573.10. He supported the choice of pavers.
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to accept and approve the proposal submitted by
Bonness, Inc., not to exceed$9,573.10. Helen Carella offered a Second in support
of the motion. Carried unanimously, 3—0.
Darryl Richard confirmed the work will not begin until after the rainy season is over
and new Purchase Order will not be cut until after October 1St
B. Review of Quotes: Rich King Greenway Entry Project
• Quotes were submitted by Leo Jr. Landscape, Hannula Landscape, and
Commercial Land.
• The lowest bid was submitted by Leo, Jr. at $9,756.95.
Scott Windham pointed out it was a relatively small project and a good test to evaluate
the vendor's capabilities.
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to accept and approve the proposal submitted by Leo
Jr. Landscape., not to exceed$9,756.95. John Weber offered a Second in support
of the motion. Carried unanimously, 3—0.
X. NEW BUSINESS
A. Meeting: Change of Time
Chairman Dale Lewis moved to approve changing the meeting time from 2:00 PM
to 3:00 PM for all future meetings. Helen Carella offered a Second in support of
the motion. Carried unanimously, 3—0.
2
CO CO CO CO 43 CO A3 3 NN0 CO CO V O C11 A CO CO 0 CD CO V 14 14 14 113 14 CA CJ A W N -1 O CO CO V CA N A CO N O CO CC' V O) A A W N i
-I M A -I CO CO -i -1 0 O 7100 orCgcn - M m -00 2W mm -1 -1zo --1 -1 M - - moo
OI y cm i) P. c 0P. 4" v -° m 73 00T1 ICm - zDmCn = z - 7300 -1 07) -' -' < mm -mj1- X
D m m z G) G) z z > � F 2m m > z0z Hm ° -1mncmi � mm r0 � -< W � zm -1 � DpD
m < < ,N*+ -I -mi co -1 DoG -I r zm A cn2 m � mA
x m m m -1 -11'10 rm z m 0cn - � ccn m0OROc� mOD -z053.3 mm mmmm .Zml .Zm1 m --�'Im ? < <
V N -n 73 OE C 0 O "0 � � � cn0 TJDD
m O 0 > D to Cm G) = -p 0R<1D � m -om � G) zmo � zz mN -I , 00tnDHDzprr
O z z 1z X m D � m7D � � 0E5 -< � xZo 00Zg 73 < - 73X - Zx �
Z
n z cn CO c CH m 11 w 0m C7) m � zz � � o -� mmmn < A � ccyo ? -1mm
to z 0 D. 0 � z m Co � W O0g E � � C) .-01X W m0 � � m ZO � moE
m m
m or ( o �' u' z mD � = W mm Ho _1(i) __i
0
G7
Z n O r I -1 xl m m -1 -0 X
0 -0
0 -1 z 0 m A x
M m z m z
m
ER ER En ER En En EA En ER EA ER EA -CO En EA En En En En En En En En EA En En EA EA En En ER ER En En En EA EA EA En EA En En
D
CO
c 3
fD
I N (fl aW N N W W 7. -1 N V -4 C.1 - W O O
N CO W O V N CO 03 . A N 0 A > - 0 W -1 0 A O C11 CO N N 0 0) CO 00 N
W W A V V .. CO-co N O W A O O O O O V W O O In W 0 0 - 0 (T A N O N a
O o O O O O O O O O O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O
O O O O 0 O O O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 , O , O O O , O O O O O O O , O 0
O O b o b O O O O O O O bb O O O O O O O b O O O 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O
O O 0 O 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 00 0000000 0 000 0 0 0000 0 0 O
ER ER En ER En EA ER En ER En Efl E9 En En EA En En EA EA En En En EA En En En En En En IER En En En En En 69 En En EA EA En
0
3
3
� -I - CO 0) - i
O !O O W N CJ1 0 3
W CO W W 0 N N 0 C0 CD
00 O 0 00 O O co O O 7•0 i i i N c N , 0 , , 00 , 0 0 , , 00 i , , , , , , , i i i H
ER ER En ER En En ER EA ER En EA En En En En to En En En EA En EA EA En En En EA En EA En ER En En EA EA En EA En En En EA En
M
X
W To
I a� .
C
c
v
A A A
ER ER -CO ER EA En ER En ER En ER En En En En EA En En En En En EA En En En En En En En En jEn En En Efl En EA EA En En En EA En
NW W W W 0 V N CO N 01 A 0 _, 0 0 V CO . C N N 0
N W W A V V A A N O W i. O O O O O V W W CJ) W V O O <. A N O N 0 0 D
W co O O 0 O 0 0 0 CA O) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 -100 0 0 COO OD CA 0 0 CIO 0 0 v
▪ 0 0 0 0 O O O CO CO -1 O 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O W co O co W O 0 O
W b O b O 0 O O COO W 0 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O ' W O O ' O O (71 61 O O ' CT O ' O ' ' O 1"r
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (Jt CO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CA 0 0 O 0 A A 0 0 A O O O
O
a T1
Ca 0 r CD C L L = O m m Ti m m W (� N
.D O O -. 5 O1 c): 13 0 0 0 0 O Z O
C 7
c m -I1w CD r0x0 0. CD D pt E m co
CO r• 0. n n ,� O r y <
v ? n n y 1. = cc > > N 00 E
rn C1- .__,,D3 O
3 Q0 = c K o — CO
Z
Ca -
m 0 me a C
o co 'o
CD
o
11 m
,„co i'n <->:-I m K
N E, ! CD
N .W H 4 t l0
M yy
a• 3 I' x 3 2x -O O co 0 A co W N•
o co I D) 0 - c< ' V C_°. m A H H -lH _'I _I H -IH1 '1 -I 13
Q
CD a; 0 7 C co co w° 0) W 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 000) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0 CO
W Oi < g, 5 (CD CO 10 0) °D v 0 0 00 00000 0000 0 #
0 CO co 0 0
ID N I CD 0 i N N co Co W
.Z1 a
d
m v -< j j o D �i oonom � mr � -
-° - - m r c ci o O O o o c o CD cc io CI A ` T (D t :00
CO (-, C- S N W ",
C_ _
_ W Ca`c '< m 0) 0 r C C CO lD 0 0 `•Z ca O S
X H 1 -1 -� 7 D m N c c co O N
o rn
3 co O T co N S Q ? W
0 FO Cn 7 N z ` `< CO CO cD cD
3.�" 0 4, - N N N N Co C= (..< ,-
O N A C C CO N (D 0 CD N 0 CD 0 3
7 tD a W CCD CCD CCD CO CD o O- co
0. 0 p G.
co O
,n. .'.: N 7 D1
O o CD
0 to
W O
r 3
OD, In EA En En EA En En En En En En En-co En (A
W O W - CD
CO (0 0
W A V 00 N O CO CO (9 V 0 0)
W A N V 0 0 W 4, N V V O co 0) CJ) 7
0 O 0 CD N O 0 CO 01 0 N N -4 -.
N 4) 0 0 co co O O) O O CO W
Co -• 'co in N CO V O CD Co , , O " 6 1
(0D N CO CP 0 0 O CWJ) 0) 0 0 0 0 0 (h 0 -
= ER EA EA EA EA En En EA En EA in in in En
D
0 >
CD C)
f) C
'O O)
II 0
N 10
p . , , , , 1 1 , 1 , , , , , Q
0
iii
� JI
PROJECTS STATUS REPORT
To: Radio Road MSTU Advisory Committee
CC Darryl Richard, Pamela Lulich Collier County ATM
From: Scott Windham
Date: October 14, 2013
RE: Radio Road MSTU Projects Status Report
MSTU Committee and Staff:
The following is a status report of the on going refurbishment projects.
RICH KING GREENWAY ENTRANCE (FPL Application):
• County will schedule construction upon receipt of board approval of bid.
DEVONSHIRE EAST ROW REFURBISHMENT STATUS:
• WSI and staff have researched available ROW and have found that the existing
Viburnum hedge on the south /east side of the sidewalk is within the ROW or
right on the line depending on location. WSI and staff recommend pursuing a 5'
landscape easement with the shopping center owner in order to plant a new
Clusia hedge along the back of the ROW line while leaving 2-3 ft for Asian
jasmine between the hedge and back of sidewalk.
• WSI will then prepare a concept plan and budget estimate for the area.
Please email or call me if you have any questions.
Thanks,
Scott Windham, ASLA
Landscape Architect LA000-1516
Windham Studio,Inc.,Landscape Architecture,LC 26000365
P.O.Box 1239,Bonita Springs,Florida 34133 Phone: (239)390-1936
Fax: (239)390-1937 Email: scott@windhamstudio.com
www.windhamstudio.com
1