Immokalee Beautification MSTU Minutes 09/26/2012 Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU
inn raoko lee BY
Certification of Minutes Approval Form
Prep by: Approved by:
//, 00 4,6-yucks
1.../
Penny P• lippi,Execut/flo irector C erryle Thom. ,Chairman
Immo e Lighting and :eautification MSTU Liaison
These Minutes for the September 26, 2012, MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting were
approved by the MSTU Advisory Committee on October 24,2012 as presented.
* The next MSTU Advisory Committee meeting will be held November 14, 2012 at 8:30A.M. at
the Southwest FL Works conference room located at 750 South 5ih Street, Immokalee, FL.,
34142.
All meetings will be publicly noticed in the W.Harmon Turner Building (Building F), posted at the Immokalee
Public Library and provided to the County Public Information Department for distribution.Please call Jeffrey Nagle,
Immokalee MSTU Project Manager,at 239467-4121 for additional information. In accordance with the American
with Disabilities Act,persons needing assistance to participate in any of these proceedings should contact Christie
Betancourt, Administrative Assistant, at least 48 hours before the meeting. The public should be advised that
members of the MSTU Lighting and Beautification Advisory Committee may also be members of other Boards and
Committees. In this regard,matters coming before the Advisory Committee may come before one or more of the
referenced Board and Committees from time to time.
Fiala D`/
Hiller
Henning fi Misc. Comes:
Coyle ✓•
Colette Date:
Item
Copies to:
Immokalee
Hondo m the 71 v cevvy
Minutes Enclosure 2
Immokalee Lighting and Beautification MSTU Advisory Committee Meeting
September 26,2012
A. Call to Order. The meeting was called to order by Cherryle Thomas at 10:10 a.m.
B. Roll Call and Announcement of a Quorum.
Advisory Committee Members Present:
Cherryle Thomas and Bill Deyo
Advisory Committee Member Absent/Excused:
Lucy Ortiz, Andrea Halman and Norma Ramirez
Action: A NO quorum was announced.
Others Present: Richard Tindell, John Rebise, Robert Kindelan, Fred Thomas Jr., Carrie
Williams, and Cristina Perez
Staff: Jeffrey Nagle, Penny Phillippi, Brad Muckel, Christie Betancourt, and Marie
Capita.
C. Introductions. John Ribes was introduced as the Principal in Charge of JRL Studios.
D. Announcements: Mr. Thomas announced that he is an active member of the
Citizens Advisory Committee (CAC) and stated that the CAC and the
Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) will be having a joint meeting next
month (October 4th) and will discuss placing a bus depot across from the
Seminole Casino which would be good for tourism. Mr. Thomas added that the
Casino planning to build a $495 million dollar hotel and that a strip mall near the
potential bus depot would also be a good idea. Ms. Thomas stated that she has
spoken to the Guadalupe Center and was informed that the property purchase cost
for that parcel will probably be below$750,000.
E. Adoption of the Agenda.
No Action Taken: (Quorum not present)
F. Communications.
o Mr. Nagle passed around the Communications Folder which contained the
following: Notice of MSTU Public Meeting.
• Coastal Cleanup Power Point presentation
• Copy of 0$ Extension for JRL landscape architectural
consulting services, extension until 10/22/12.
G. Approval of the Minutes.
No Action Taken: (Quorum not present)
H. Old Business.
a. Budget Report.
Mr. Nagle reported on the current budget, provided Purchase Order and
Expenditures Reports to the Committee. Mr. Nagle stated that Gloria
Herrera from the ATM/MSTU department in Naples will assist him with
Immokalee CRA 2012/MSTU Master File/Agendas/October 2012/September Minutes
1
Immokalee
Fbrido i+tho 21u renwry
the new FY2013 Fund 111 PO's and that it was his understanding that
adding a 10% increase to the new PO's to be processed is typical.
Ms. Thomas asked about the newly installed temporary curbing and
"white sticks" along Lake Trafford Road, indicating that the MSTU
offered to install rails in that location last year, but heard no more about it.
Mr. Nagle and Mr. Nagle stated that it was his understanding that the work
was being done with FDOT funding, possibly Safe Routes to School
program.
Ms. Thomas stated that she had contacted Choice Environmental to ask
about cleaning up the remnants of the vacated homeless person at the
McCrory store frontage along Main. Jim Wheatly was offered as the
Choice contact person to speak with. The reports were accepted by
consensus.
b. Code Enforcement Report.
Ms. Perez from Code Enforcement announced a clean up on School Drive
and Delaware was conducted on September 8th and that Weldon Walker of
Code Enforcement assisted with the MSTU/KCB Coastal Cleanup on
September 15th. A good amount of volunteers turned out for that event.
On October 8th a meeting will be held at the Community Care Facility to
create a list of abandoned structures in the community in coordination
with the Sheriff's office.
On October 12th there will be a construction debris removal Task Force
meeting in Immokalee.
c. Project Manager (PM) Report - Mr. Nagle reviewed the MSTU Project
Managers report with the Committee.
i. Carson Road sidewalk project — Mr. Nagle stated the bid
preparation is in progress and the project is on schedule.
ii. Main Street Improvement project - The Committee Members were
informed that at the last project design meeting, attended by JRL,
Rick Arico (FDOT), and RWA surveyor, FDOT had requested that
all the ramps along Main Street be designed to comply with FDOT
accessible standards. In order to meet the FDOT ramp design
criteria many of the ramps and curbs reconstruction will extend
beyond the Main Street R.O.W. and into the County R.O.W.,
requiring additional project scope, additional project costs, and
additional County R.O.W. permitting. Nagle reviewed a letter from
JRL, received by email on 9/23/12, indicating what JRL
determined will be needed to revise the plans per FDOT requests at
the last project meeting. Mr. Ribes (JRL) stated that what Mr.
Arico is asking for is not an official FDOT request and suggested
that the MSTU formally submit the 100% plans for the project to
FDOT for review and comment. The MSTU committee members
present directed Mr. Nagle to formally submit the 100% plans for
the project to FDOT for review and comment.
Immokalee CRA 2012/MSTU Master File/Agendas/October 2012/September Minutes
2
Immokalee
Ms. Thomas asked if someone from FDOT could attend the next
MSTU meeting to discuss the project. It was recommended that
Trinity Scott be contacted to attend that meeting.
Mr. Thomas indicated that perhaps the plans for Main Street
Improvements could be presented at the County CAC and TAC
advisory meetings with a request to those committees that the plan
be passed thru FDOT as currently designed.
Ms. Thomas stated that the existing planters along Main Street.
Mr. Tindell indicated that the planters were in the sight lines of the
project.
Mr. Nagle noted that the JRL contract for this project will expire
on October 31, 2012 and that an extension will have to be
requested until FDOT comments are provided and the MSTU can
determine how to proceed with the plans.
iii. Street Lighting—Mr. Nagle informed the Committee that there had
been no new light pole knock downs since the last MSTU meeting.
He is waiting on the light pole manufacture (Lumec)to provide the
standard blue color light pole costs to the supplier so the MSTU
can receive an updated light pole replacement cost estimate from
the contractor.
iv. Holiday Decoration - The Committee was informed that Southern
Signal investigated the existing light poles along Main Street to
determine if the electrical outlets were energized and it was
determined that the lights from 9th Street north to New Market
Road did not have electric to the existing sockets. Mr. Nagle
reviewed the Southern Signal estimate for; 1) wiring up the needed
26 light poles receiving decorations, 2) installing the 40
decorations including mounting brackets, and 3) removal of
decorations after the Holiday season.
Ms. Thomas indicated that she thought that the original light pole
contract called for the electric outlets on the poles from 9th to New
Market Road to be wired. The MSTU members present also
directed Mr. Nagle to proceed to have the contractor wire up the
necessary (26) light pole electric outlets. Staff was instructed to
research the original light pole installation contract.
Ms. Thomas added that it is the Committees direction that Mr.
Nagle place the order for the 40 Lighted Angel decorations and
hope for the best (regarding the FDOT General Use permit
approval). Ms. Thomas asked what decorations will be provided
along 1st Street from Carver to Main where there are no electric
outlets on the existing light poles
Ms. Thomas recommended that Mr. Nagle coordinate the garland
wrapping with Trimmers. Mr. Kindelan (CLM) indicated that he
has the existing cornucopia banners and that they were worn and
Immokalee CRA 2012/MSTU Master File/Agendas/October 2012/September Minutes
3
Immokalee
Fonda m H.71 sr c.nk.y
tattered. He will look through them to determine how many he has
and which needed to be replaced with new ones. Ms. Thomas
inquired about the Holiday banner change out stating that the
Committee would like to buy new "cornucopia" banners. Mr.
Nagle was instructed to review the condition and quantity of the
existing cornucopia banners after January to determine a new
order. Ms. Thomas indicated that the Holiday banners and new
lighted angel decorations should be installed on 11/1/12 (1st Wed.
of November) and removed on 1/6/12. Mr. Kindelan made note of
the dates.
v. Ninth Street Sidewalk replacement—The Committee was informed
that the project was on hold until the required County R.O.W
permit can be completed and submitted for approval. Mr. Nagle
anticipates completing the permit application after completing the
Holiday decoration coordination.
d. Contractor Reports.
Maintenance Report - Mr. Kindelan reviewed his report. CLM
anticipates an application of mulch in November and
recommended that the MSTU rollover the fertilizer and mulch
supplier contracts with the County.
CLM has reviewed the existing condition of the damaged planters
along Main Street, as directed at the August MSTU meeting and
recommended that two of the planters be removed since they are
severely damaged and would require significant work and cost to
repair. Mr. Kindelan added that he thinks that there is a concrete
slab under the planters and that it is possible that the planters drain
by way of the gutter inlets/grates. CLM was instructed to remove
the two planters.
Mr. Kindelan stated that the two gateway entrance signs at New
Market and SR 29 and at 1St Street and the Casino had been
cleaned and bricks re-pointed.
CLM indicated that they had previously submitted a quote for plant
replacement at the Sheriff's office and will resubmit that estimate
to the Immokalee MSTU for review.
A discussion of which fund CLM's fertilizer and mulch costs are
taken from. Mr. Kindelan indicated that fertilizer and mulch has
always come out of fund 111. Ms. Bentencourt indicated that since
the CRA has managed fund 162 the fertilizer and mulch costs have
been charged to fund 162.
ii. Landscape Architect Report - Mr. Tindell from JRL reported that
the declining Acacia tree described in last months report still exists
in the New Market/SR 29 triangle median and should be removed.
He indicated that the Main Street trash receptacle doors reamain
open after collection and appear to be getting worse. Mr. Tindell
Immokalee CRA 2012/MSTU Master File/Agendas/October 2012/September Minutes
4
Immokalee
iii. indicated that the stump of a recently removed Crape Myrtle tree in
the median of 1st Street and should be dug out. CLM stated that the
stump will be removed this week. Mr. Tindell questioned CLM on
the status of the dying Crown-Of-Thorns in the median on 1st
Street. Mr. Nagle indicated that CLM has provided an estimate for
the removal of the dead plant and the removal and replacement of
the soil in the median. Mr. Nagle indicated that he will need to
prepare an alternate planting design for that area before CLM can
provide a complete cost estimate. Mr. Tindell recommended that
CLM perform a severe trimming of the Bougainvillea hedges in
the medians in October. CLM agreed. JRL further recommended
that the White Fountain Grass in the medians should be cut back
again (recently trimmed back in August). Mr. Nagle indicated to
the Committee that he will coordinate with CLM to replace the
dead Crown-Of-Thorns plants in the 1st Street median, where
needed.
e. Community Redevelopment Agency Report.
i. Storm water Project — Mr. Muckel informed the Committee that
the Storm Water project is on schedule and will be completed by
November 7th. The next phase of the storm water project will
consist of a roadway overlay on Boston, Colorado, and Delaware
Avenues to be bid next week for construction in November
through January.
Mr. Deyo stated that he was concerned about the sidewalk on
Colorado Avenue. Muckel responded indicating that particular
section of roadway is privately owned by the residents fronting on
it.
Mr. Muckel stated that a new $2 mil. DREF grant for the
construction of a stormwater improvements project at Immokalee
Drive will be going out to bid. He added that the Big Cypress
Basin Board has programmed their budget for funding $200,000 of
this projects cost.
ii. Crosswalk Project — Mr. Muckel indicated that the selected
contractor for this project was AIM Engineering and initial project
cost came in high. He is currently working on negotiating a lower
cost of the study phase of the project with the engineer. Mr.
Muckel informed the Committee that the project funding had to be
returned and recommended that the MSTU partner with the CRA
to fund the study phase of the project. He will bring the cost of the
study back before the Committee for further discussion at the next
meeting.
iii. Facade Grant update — Mr. Muckel stated that there are currently
two building currently working under the grant, Minors Market
and the Haitian Restaurant.
Immokalee CRA 2012/MSTU Master File/Agendas/October 2012/September Minutes
5
}
Immokalee
i6rda iI.71 a wruwy
iv. 1st Street Plaza RFQ update—Mr. Muckel informed the Committee
that David Corbin Architect was selected for the project. The
project design contract and will go before the Board of County
Commissioners for approval on November 13th.
I. New Business.
a. Selection of a landscape architectural consultant: Mr. Nagle suggested that
selection of a County approved firm to provide MSTU consulting services be
postponed until the next meeting to allow the MSTU Committee members
time to review the short listed firms submittals before making their selection.
No Action Taken: (Quorum not present)
b. Review of number of street sweepings in the current maintenance contract:
Mr. Nagle explained that under the current contract for FY 2012 there were 31
street sweepings budgeted. However, there were actually 39 sweepings
performed at one per week. A review of the current maintenance contract
identifies a total of 52 sweeping or 1 per month. Nagle requested if the
Committee wanted to see 52 sweepings per year (1 per week) or would they
prefer an alternative number of sweepings per year. Ms. Thomas stated that 1
sweeping per week for a total of 52 sweepings per year is the direction of the
Committee.
J. Citizen Comments.
a. None
K. Next Meeting Date.
Regular Meeting October 24, 2012 at 10:00 AM.
H. Adjournment. The meeting adjourned at 11:45 a.m.
Immokalee CRA 2012/MSTU Master File/Agendas/October 2012/September Minutes
6