07/16/2013 Minutes 2013 Public Transit Ad
Hoc Advisory Committee
Minutes
July 16 , 2013
July 16, 2013
S O HE MEETING OF THE PUBLIC TRANSIT AD HOC
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Qy Naples, Florida, July 16, 2013
LET IT BE REMEMBERED, the Public Transit Ad Hoc Advisory Committee in and for
the County of Collier, having conducted business herein, met on this date at 3:00 P.M. in
REGULAR SESSION at Administrative Building "F ", Suite 501, Collier County
Government Complex Naples, Florida with the following members present:
Kimberley Bowers (Excused)
John DiMarco, III
W. James Klug, III (Excused)
Nancy Lascheid
Morton Rosenberg
Dylan Michael Vogel
Richard Duggan
Glen D. Harrell
(Vacancy)
ALSO PRESENT: Michelle Arnold, Director, ATM
Trinity Scott, Public Transit Manager
James Means, General Manager
Yousi Cardeso, Spencer Smith, Adam Amhad, Bill Gramer, Sarah
Layman, Milly Haylock, Stacy Renay, Deb Armstrong, Dan Armea
July 16, 2013
1. Call to Order
Ms. Arnold called the meeting to order at 3:OOPM.
2. Roll Call
Roll call was taken and a quorum was established.
3. Introduction of Attendees
The Attendees introduced themselves.
4. Approval of Agenda
11s. Lascheid moved to approve the Agenda. Second by Mr. Rosenberg. Carried unanimously 6 —
0.
S. Action Items
a. Election of Chairperson & Vice- Chairperson
Ms. Arnold provided the Executive Summary "Board Action Item SA Election of a Committee
Chairperson" for consideration.
Mr. Rosenberg nominated Glenn Harrell for Chairman of the Public TransitAd Hoc Advisory
Committee.
Nominations were closed.
Mr. Harrell was named Chairman of the Committee.
Mr. Vogel nominated himself for Vice Chairman of the Public TransitAd Hoc Advisory
Committee.
Nominations were closer!.
Mr. Vogel was named Vice Chairman of the Committee.
Mr. Harrell assumed the Chair
b. Review and Approve Bylaws
Ms. Arnold provided the Executive Summary "Committee Action Item SB Review and Endorse
Bylaws" for consideration.
Ms. Scott provided an overview of the "By Laws - Ad Hoc Collier County Public Transit Advisory
Committee.
Ms. Lascheid Moved to recommend the Board of County Commissioners approve the proposed
bylaws of the Ad Hoc Collier County Public Transit Advisory Committee. Second by Mr.
DiMarco. Carrier! unanimously G — 0.
c. Meeting Calendar
2
July 16, 2013
Ms. Scott provided the Executive Summary "Committee Action Item 5C Approval of Proposed
2013 Calendar" for consideration. The intent is for the Committee to meet monthly, the 3`d
Tuesday of the month at 3:00pm.
Mr. Rosenberg moved to approve the 2013 meeting schedule as proposer. Second by Mr.
DiMarco. Carried unanimously 6 — 0.
Reports and Presentations
a. Introduction to Transit
Ms. Arnold provided the Executive Summary "Reports & Presentations Item 6A Introduction to
Transit" for consideration. She presented a Slide show "Collier Area Transit — Introduction to
Transit." The following was highlighted:
• The program initiated in 1999 providing Paratransit service to County residents.
• Fixed route service began in 2001with 5 routes established.
• The service is provided by sub contract vendors.
• In 2007, a temporary transfer station was developed at Government Center site with a
permanent facility opened adjacent to the Government Center parking garage in July 2013.
• There are currently 10 Fixed routes with 23 vehicles equipped with handicap lifts or ramps.
• A fleet of 20 vehicles provides Paratransit service for ADA (Americans with Disabilities
Act) and TD ('Transportation Disadvantaged) clients.
• The program also provides emergency evacuation as needed when requested by the BCC.
• The program has a current budget of $9.362M and revenue sources include fare boxes, gas
tax receipts and State and Federal Grants.
Ridership increased 1,137% from 2001 to 2012.
• The Program utilizes an Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) which provides electronic
fare boxes, automated enunciation system, manifest information, automated vehicle
locators, etc.
b. Public Participation Plan
Ms. Scott provided the Executive Summary "Reports & Presentations Item 6B Public
Participation Plan " for consideration which included a copy of the "Collier Area Transit (CAT)
Public Participation Plan. " She reported the Plan will be considered as an action item at the next
meeting and requested Committee members to review the Plan and provide comments to Staff.
Following review by the Committee, the Plan will be forwarded to the Board of County
Commissioners for formal approval.
During Committee discussions, the following was highlighted:
• Consideration should be given to improving the visibility on the buses for notification of
events, meetings, issues, etc. as currently they are displayed in the front of the bus and
difficult for patrons to read.
• Consideration should be given to utilizing television or radio media to broadcast messages;
this is especially helpful for individuals who possess reading difficulties.
7. Member Comments
The following was highlighted:
July 16, 2013
• Consideration should be given to installing Braille strips on the posts at the new transfer
facility and bus stops so individuals with vision impairment may determine the loading
location for the various buses serving the routes.
• The system providing the brief pre recorded messages aired at the transfer facility or on
the buses should be enhanced to aid in educating the riders on upcoming events, service
changes, rules changes, etc.
• Consideration should be given to extending service until 10:00pm for employees and
patrons /clients of various facilities such as the hospitals or malls.
• Data should be collected and analyzed to aid in identifying the need for additional bus
stop locations.
• Consideration should be given to partnering with the tourism industry to increase
ridership, especially given the increasing number of foreign tourists who are accustomed
to utilizing public transportation.
Mr. Means reported if demand is demonstrated for additional routes or bus stop locations,
consideration would be given to adding stops or routes.
Staff reported, given the ITS, it is now much easier to garner statistics on the users of the system.
This information could assist in identifying if added service is required and /or how existing service
may be improved.
8. Public Comments
MiIly Haylock, Golden Gate Resident addressed the Committee and requested consideration be
given to expanding service in the Golden Gate Estates area.
Distribution Items
Trinity Scott reported the following items are provided to members for information purposes:
• 1Zesolution No. 50 crealing the Committee,
• Collier County Ordinance 2001— 55 establishing standards for County Advisory Boards.
• Government in the Sunshine from the Office of the County Attorney Jeffrey A. Klatzkow,
County Attorney.
Chairman Harrell noted, due to Sunshine Law requirements, a Committee members should not
discuss any business that may become before the Committee with another member. Emails should be
disseminated through the Staff liaison and members should reply only to the Staff' liaison with any
comments, not other members.
10. Next Meeting Date
August 20, 2013
There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned by
order of the chair at 4:30P.M.
Public Transit Ad Hoe Advisory Committee
July 16, 2013
arrell, Chairman
These minutes approved by the Board/Committee on AIUS—I—a�)QO13
as presented K or as amended
Committee Members
Mr. Glen D. Harrell —Chairman
Mr. Dylan Michael Vogel —Vice Chairman
Ms. Kimberley Bowers
Ms. Nancy Lasheid
Mr John DiMarco III
Mr. W. James Klug III
Mr. Morton Rosenberg
Mr. Richard Duggan