Loading...
Backup Docs 10/08/2013 (CR) CHAPTER 2013-227 ///7/e,- Committee Substitute for lB Committee Substitute for Senate Bill No. 50 An act relating to public meetings; creating s. 286.0114, F.S.; defining"board or commission"; requiring that a member of the public be given a reasonable opportunity to be heard by a board or commission before it takes official action on a proposition; providing exceptions; establishing requirements for rules or policies adopted by the board or commission; providing that compliance with the requirements of this section is deemed to have occurred under certain circumstances; providing that a circuit court has jurisdiction to issue an injunction under certain circumstances; authorizing a court to assess reasonable attorney fees in actions filed against a board or commission; providing that an action taken by a board or commission which is found in violation of this section is not void; providing that the act fulfills an important state interest; providing an effective date. Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida: Section 1. Section 286.0114, Florida Statutes, is created to read: 286.0114 Public meetings; reasonable opportunity to be heard; attorney fees.— (1) For purposes of this section, "board or commission" means a board or commission of any state agency or authority or of any agency or authority of a county, municipal corporation, or political subdivision. (2) Members of the public shall be given a reasonable opportunity to be heard on a proposition before a board or commission. The opportunity to be heard need not occur at the same meeting at which the board or commission takes official action on the proposition if the opportunity occurs at a meeting that is during the decisionmaking process and is within reasonable proximity in time before the meeting at which the board or commission takes the official action. This section does not prohibit a board or commission from maintain- ing orderly conduct or proper decorum in a public meeting. The opportunity to be heard is subject to rules or policies adopted by the board or commission} as provided in subsection (4). (3) The requirements in subsection (2) do not apply to: (a) An official act that must be taken to deal with an emergolcy situation affecting the public health, welfare, or safety, if compliance with the requirements would cause an unreasonable delay in the ability of the board or commission to act; 1 CODING: Words strickcn are deletions; words underlined are additions. Ch. 2013-227 LAWS OF FLORIDA Ch. 2013-227 1B (b) An official act involving no more than a ministerial act, including, but not limited to, approval of minutes and ceremonial proclamations; (c) A meeting that is exempt from s. 286.011; or (d) A meeting during which the board or commission is acting in a quasi- judicial capacity. This paragraph does not affect the right of a person to be heard as otherwise provided by law. (4) Rules or policies of a board or commission which govern the opportunity to be heard are limited to those that: (a) Provide guidelines regarding the amount of time an individual has to address the board or commission; (b) Prescribe procedures for allowing representatives of groups or factions on a proposition to address the board or commission, rather than all members of such groups or factions, at meetings in which a large number of individuals wish to be heard; (c) Prescribe procedures or forms for an individual to use in order to inform the board or commission of a desire to be heard; to indicate his or her support, opposition, or neutrality on a proposition; and to indicate his or her desi• ation of a re•resentative to s•eak for him or her or his or her • ou• on a proposition if he or she so chooses; or (d) Designate a specified period of time for public comment. (5) If a board or commission adopts rules or policies in compliance with this section and follows such rules or policies when providing an opportunity for members of the public to be heard, the board or commission is deemed to be acting in compliance with this section. (6) A circuit court has jurisdiction to issue an injunction for the purpose of enforcing this section upon the filing of an application for such injunction by a citizen of this state. (7)(a) Whenever an action is filed against a board or commission to enforce this section, the court shall assess reasonable attorney fees against such board or commission if the court determines that the defendant to such action acted in violation of this section. The court may assess reasonable attorney fees against the individual filing such an action if the court finds that the action was filed in bad faith or was frivolous. This paragraph does not apply to a state attorney or his or her duly authorized assistants or an officer charged with enforcing this section. (b) Whenever a board or commission appeals a court order that has found the board or commission to have violated this section, and such order is affirmed, the court shall assess reasonable attorney fees for the appeal against such board or commission. 2 CODING: Words fitrickcn are deletions; words underlined are additions. Ch. 2013-227 LAWS OF FLORIDA Ch. 2013-227 1 B (8) An action taken by a board or commission which is found to be in violation of this section is not void as a result of that violation. Section 2. The Legislature finds that a proper and legitimate state purpose is served when members of the public have been given a reasonable opportunity to be heard on a proposition before a board or commission of a state agency or authority, or of an agency or authority of a county, municipal corporation, or political subdivision. Therefore, the Legislature determines and declares that this act fulfills an important state interest. Section 3. This act shall take effect October 1, 2013. Approved by the Governor June 28, 2013. Filed in Office Secretary of State June 28, 2013. 3 CODING: Words ctrickcn are deletions; words underlined are additions. !o` //3 c/lY) %e/Yl9l2/i"C�S gs C�/77 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-001 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). 6 La Peninsula Seawall MSBtJ Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 301, Folio#54500040008 A'C'/,oz/rT 4. ieb6(14-A Date Print Name Signature(required) • e!'i LJ ,4711k:522 ' A/d,1-1 5,. . L //.3 Mailing Address 2. 40€0 v/u &',/i/4-1242 Date Print Name Si nature(required) Mailing Address 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 16 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ACC 1 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 54500040008 I Site Adr. 301 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address BERNARD, ROBERT C=&MADELINE E 301 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES State I FL i Zip 134113-4036 Map No I Strap No j Section 1 Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 453400 3017B06 6 52 1 26 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 301 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School 1 Other Total Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page j Amount I Land Value i $01 05/28/99 ,2552-1172 I $280,000 j (+)Improved Value $343,000 09/01/86 I 1219-22 I $248,000 ) (_) Market Value $ 343,000 (-)SOW&other Exempt. I $0 I (=)Assessed Value $ 343,000 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $50,000 (=)Taxable Value $293,000 1 (=)School Taxable Value 1.. $ 318,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A . * Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-002 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 602, Folio#73605000047 1. 4 t ►5- •�{D/\, 9 '3 Print Name Signature(required) Date Lf I—roq ':r 1/1/Vl (n/otwoltf "NA s3/o 3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(regE Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 1 8 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ACC Page 1 of 1 6 A i Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary 1 Parcel No. 73605000047 Site Adr. 602 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address KETCHAM, MICHAEL D=&RETA J 301 CLIFTON AVE I.; City MINNEAPOLIS State MN Zip 155403-3266 Map No Strap No Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 629500 6027B06 6 52 26 I 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 602 JViillage Area 0 I 91 Mi Nage Rates 0 *Calculations 629500 - 600 Sub/Condo MINIU School Other I Total CONDOLA PENINSULA A M , 1 Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) 1 Date I Book-Page Amount Land Value $01 12/19/06 4156-3273 $0 (+)Improved Value $ 353,950 12/19/06 4156-3272 $ 139,300 (=) Market Value $ 353,950 05/09/02 3034-249 $0 08/30/01 2884-1244 $0 (-)SOW&other Exempt. $0 08/12/98 2450-1727 1 $0 (=)Assessed Value $353,950 03/05/98 J 2395-662 1 $ 350,000 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 07/25/95 2082-111 1 $ 390,000 I (=)Taxable Value $353,950 12/21/94 2013-1539 1 $0 (=)School Taxable Value $ 353,950 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraisencom/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 1k 6A , Re: your petition Page 2 of 8 Collier County Citizen Petition No.___219.1C County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/281201; (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An Individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185,Florida Statutes,applies to this petition,It Is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. My person violating the provisions of this section shall,upon conviction,be guilty of a misdemeanor of the brat degree,punishable as provided In Sections 775.082,775.083,or 775.084,' (Section 104.185 F:S .) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County,Florida: The undersigned R t hereby County the la Peninsula Seawall pai Replacemnt request unicipal Services Benefit istric (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri.These Improvements shall be paid for by special assessment Unposed upon each assessable unit,which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill In sufficient amount to meet the cosi of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. it is understood that the design,repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design,repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After Investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shell be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S.mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance j funding for the aforesaidd design,repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 641, Folio#73805000322 r.-----i A 55GG ,S 0.4• 0 I #' / —'�rl�Dater` PrintNemo at, . re(rag red) 4 5'/7 Are/a/V.51)//r& / //.1.1,6(_ -750,3 13(, M lnp Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) Data Melling Address 3. • slaaeture(requlrod) .• print Name - 1 D 'oiling Address R & P MANAGEMENT RECE1VH„) SEP 2 6 2013 Office of the County.,�,k0;,:;,;t MG R SEP ASS Action ACC http://webmail.eaiihlink.net/wam/printable jsp?msgid=3395&x=147164076 9/24/2013 6 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 73605000322 Site Adr. 641 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address ANDERSON,T RUSSELL 1641 LA PENINSULA BLVD City I NAPLES State FL Zip 34113-4043 Map No Strap No Section Township Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 629500 6417606 6 52 26 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 641 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo '629500 - 600 LA PENINSULA A School , Other Total 'CONDOMINIUM { Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM ( 5.69 ' 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page ' Amount Land Value $0 04/23/93 1818-1658 $0 (+)Improved Value $279,631; 08/01/88 j 1372-497 $ 220,000 (=) Market Value $279,631 SOH*&other Exempt. $ 23,499 (=)Assessed Value $256,132 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value $206,132 School Taxable Value $231,132 all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?Folio1D=73605000322 9/27/2013 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13.005 * , Ai/ County Managers determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). 6q La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/orr replacement upon County approval. Property Address 642, Folio#736 5000348 \\ 1. Oci cf` 2c'i3 Print Name Signature(requ red) Date K2 L4 IP%/V<NsrA-A LKLv0 AixtPc 3 t=L- 3t-e 3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) Date 6z.,/ LR P /Vf /VSOL /1 L0 AM '465 Q L 3`/// Mailing Address 3. Print Name Signature(required) Date RECEIVED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT SEP 1 1 2013 MGR ASST ACC Page 1 of 1 6 A,.w Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 73605000348 1 Site Adr. 1642 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address J THUVE TRS, HAKON=&KARI E THUVE REVOCABLE TRUST UTD 5/21/04 1642 LA PENINSULA BLVD City I NAPLES State I FL Zip 1 34113-4043 Map No ( Strap No j Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 l 629500 6427B06 I 6 1 52 j 26 1 0 Legal l 600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 642 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates O *Calculations 1629500 -600 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School Other l Total CONDOMINIUM 1 Use Code014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 i I 1 1 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount i I Land Value $Oi 05/28/04 3575-3265 I $0 -- - _-, � (+)Improved Value � $ 311,250 12/22/99 I 2624-717 I $ 360,000 1 I (=) Market Value ) $ 311,250 08/17/95 I 2090-1613 $ 360,000 12/21/94 I ,2013-1539 I $0 ! (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value f $311,250 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (_)Taxable Value I $ 311,250 (=)School Taxable Value I $ 311,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 .. ,. awn .. . . .. A 7, Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 006 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. it is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting P property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 401, Folio#33400000020 14-00 cag 1. Dtp/ �1�V.44.,o ne-6,n4/7t97 frdiz-gtsiSii/f) C!�� /1//3 Print Name Signature(required) Date (oZ,3 $-a)i /?f2vt)1C c 7 d1//7l V024 2,_.. Mailing Address FEC RI ED 2• aA Print Name Signature(required & P MANAGEMENT Date SEP162013 Mailing Address 3. MGR Print Name Signature(requires cc Date Mailing Address Page 1 of 1 t 6 A 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 133400000020 1 Site Adr. 401 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DFLP 120 S BROOK ST City 1 LOUISVILLE State KY Zip 140202-1202 Map No I Strap No j Section ! Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 302200 4017B06 1 6 1 52 26 1 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 401 Millage Area 0 191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200-400 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo 1 School Other Total CONDOMINIUM 1 Use Coded 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value $a 05/08/07 1 4225-1911 I $550,000 (+)Improved Value 1 $343,000 09/01/00 I 2717-1681 I $ 380,000 I 08/27/96 ( 2221-14.09 $405,000 1 (=) Market Value 1 $ 343,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value I $ 343,000 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt, $ 0 I (=)Taxable Value $343,000 1 (=) School Taxable Value 1 $343,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the f=inal Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes*exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Search Results Page 1 of 1 ' 6A Collier County Tax Collector 3291 Tamiami Trail East,Naples FL 34112 2012 Tax Roll Inquiry System Print this page I OWNER INFORMATION I PROPERTY INFORMATION 1 Name:JI_DFLP Parcel: 33400000020 Acre: .0 I Address:!120 S BROOK ST 401 LA PENINSULA BLVD NAPLES f Atanl(GIS Loc: lievir Address: Address:I @g 400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM Address:( I Legal: UNIT 401 l I Address:IJI.OUISVILLE,KY 40202-1202 [ Legal: Legal: VALUE/EXEMPTIONS TAX INFORMATION I PAY TERMS I PAYMENT INFO Market Value:I 343,000 County: 1289.30 Nov: 4144.01 Paid Dt: 11/08/2012 Taxable Value:)343,000 School St:11141.50 I Dec:14187.18 1 Recpt: 9308 Millage Coder 91 School loc:JJ771.06 I Jan:14230.35 I [ Mach:I 9 . Homested Ex:1 0 City Tax: 0.00 Feb: 4273.51 1 Paymt:I[4,144.01 Agricltr Ex:I 0 Dependt: 931.62 Mar: 4316.68 L Mort:10 Widow Ex: 0 Water: 116.28 Apr: .o STATUS INFO. Blind Ex: 0 Independ: 37.80 May: .0 Disabled: 0 1 Voter Appr:I 29.12 I Now Due:)0.00 Non Ad Va:1 N Veteran Es:10 I *Gross Tax: 4316.68 Installment: N Wholly Ex:110 Appr tee: .0 Deferred:)N I Civilian Ex:]0 Advertising: 0.00 Bankrupt: N TDA: 0 I COMMENTS I 1* New;Search; Back To Lis#; 'I 2003 Parcel Information J 2004 Parcel :Information 1 2005 Parcel.Information 1 2006 Parcel Information 2007 Parcel Information 1 2008 Parcel Information.1 2009 Parcel Information 1 2010 Parcel Information 2011 Parcel Information Last Updated: 09/27/2013 5:00pm http://colliertax.com/search/view.php?ID=391027579&page=l&tc=1&tax_year=2012 9/27/2013 6 A g v"1 LARD 0476571 Alison Lundergan Grimes Commonwealth of Kentucky KY Secretary of State Received and Filed Alison Lundergan Grimes, Secretary c 6/7/2012 8:37:52 AM Fee receipt: $15.00 Alison Lundergan Grimes Secretaiy of ate P.O.Box ox 11 50 Annual Report ARP 11 p Frankfort,KY 40602-1150 Online Filing (502)564-3490 http://www.sos.ky.gov Company: THE DULWORTH GROUP, LLC Company ID: 0476571 State of origin: Kentucky Formation date: 7/1/1999 12:00:00 AM Date filed: 6/7/2012 8:37:52 AM Fee: $15.00 Principal Office 120 SOUTH BROOK ST. LOUISVILLE,KY 40202 Registered Agent Name/Address JACK B.DULWORTH 120 S.BROOK ST. LOUISVILLE, KY 40202 Members/Managers Member JACK B DULWORTH 120 South Brook St. Member JOSEPH E DULWORTH 120 South Brook St. Member CHAN 0 MILTON 120 South Brook St. Signatures Signature Jack B. Dulworth Title Member Ro• 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-007 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design;repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon.County approval. Property Address 402, Folio#33400000046 1. � ' /� 'rint Name § nature(required) Date f GIV i'iJrlis I f PC/ Deni'er 11A ©vt '3e) Mailing Address 2. erk.2n� �1/. iediQr `Trusfe� /_ .�`�PP g4Ji Print Name Signa ure 4 (% uired) Date Cci9hiii pr, , 6npPe" /� ©,;1p13 RECEIVED Mailing Address 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 b 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR A�;t; Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 33400000046 I Site Adr. 1 402 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address FIEDLER TR,JACQUELINE K HERBERT W FIEDLER TR J K FIEDLER 2008 REV TRUST UTD 09/16/08 112 GRAND HILL DR City I DOVER State I MA I Zip 1 02030-1704 _.. Map No I Strap No Section ; Township I Range j Acres *Acreage 7806 I 302200 4027B06 6 1 1 52 1 26 I 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 402 Millage Area 0191 } Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1 302200 -400 LA PENINSULA A C i CONDOMINIUM 1 School ; Other Total Use Coded 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount 1 I Land Value $01 10/30/08 1 4404-1825 I $0 I (+)Improved Value $241,800 09/05/03 I 3389-406 I $ 385,000 $241,800, (=) Market Value 03/22/01 I 2794-2950 $255,000 SOH*&other Exempt. I 08/03/98 2447-780 t`? er xem p I (-) Homestead&other Exempt.! I $241,800 12/02/97 2367-2336 $0 P 11/08/96 2249-157 $ 3,015,500 $0 1 (=)Taxable Value I) $241,800 (=) School Taxable Value I $241,800 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH=-Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6q ;T• Collier County Citizen Petition No. '13-008 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 302, Folio#54500080000 j' 1. Print Name S/4/// re(required) Date a Pt,at wc0h ve erwodo MO- ointr Mailing Address e4 it) i141 / "hi/Z. Print Name 7 Signature(required) Date 0 / U/vl,wcx z Iii V /(J.£vrweeL/ r ' 0/• Mailing Address 3. R & P 11.4AN ENT Print Na Si ure(required) Date SEA' 1 6 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST Ann 6Fe1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 54500080000 I Site Adr. 1 302 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address LE BLANC, ROBERT J=&JEAN 18 CHERRY HILL CIR City METHUEN State f MA Zip 1 01844.2706 Map No. ! Strap No. i Section 1 Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 453400 3027B06 I 6 52 I 26 1 0 Legal I LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 302 Millage Area 0 191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM 1 School 1 Other I Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Saks are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page 1 Amount I I Land Value $01 10/01/86 1 1223-1515 1 $ 192,000 I 10-)Improved Value $241,8001 i (=) Market Value $241,8001 e (-)SOH*&other Exempt. I $01 I C (=)Assessed Value $ 241,800 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value 1 $241,800 j (=)School Taxable Value 1 $ 241,8001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 1 elf• Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-009 * R fiCCounty Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7129/20 (dt * 4NAGEMENT La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition SEP l 6 2013 An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. MGR To the the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petitittOdt'ls-tiril I for a person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any on violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 303, Folio#54500120009 �7 1. Cv+v.-Q--S 1 kL i J f p.S 4 .4 v! ZU(� Print Name / Signature(require ) Date Mailing Addre: D Print Name Signature(required) / Date IL/ KA �" g ( q ) Mailing Addre s 3. Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address fagi o g Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.154500120009 1 Site Adr. 303 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address PHILLIPS,JAMES=&ANITA 814 KING BAN DR i City I LEWISVILLE State 1 TX l Zip 75056.5714 Map No Strap No I Section I Township � Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3037B06 6 1 52 26 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 303 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM j School I Other 1 Total Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 f 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount G Land Value ! $0 05/20/04 3568-2226 $439,000 (4.)Improved Value I $228,800 10/03/02 1 3123-1795 I $ 322,000 i 1 I (=) Market Value $ 228,800 06/28/02 3063-897 ( $237,900 07/18/01 2861-1037 I $0 I (-)SOH"&other Exempt. $01 04/04/01 I 2800-2500 $212,500 ' (=)Assessed Value $228,800 i 08/03/98 I 2447-775 $0 1 (.) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 01/26/98 i 2383-123 ' $0 i i i (_)Taxable Value $228,8001 01/26/98 ' 2383-44 i $0 11/08/96 I 2249-157 ; $3,015,500 i (-)School Taxable Value I $228,800! � If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 i Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A 04 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93-010 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). it is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected.property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 304, Folio#54500160001 1. nil art I toi �ut-- �-- 77Ler m�) &A.1772_- 9/67/_3 Print Name U Signature(requir`eEi) Date £6 / 6.1/1 t1/KVL /&-4.)d /dap les FL 3 41 113 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) Date RECEIVED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMEN C 3. SYY 0 9 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASSN' ACC Page 1 of 16 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. '54500160001 1 Site Adr.1304 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address CARTER, MARILYN 304 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES i State 1 FL 1 Zip 134113-4036 Map No. 1 Strap No. i Section 1 Township 1 Range Acres *Acreage 7806 453400 3047806 6 52 1 26 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 304 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1 453400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM i School ! Other I Total ._.. . Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I f Land Value $0 07/18/08 4379-3450 $ 380,000 f ; (*)Improved Value I $259,631 1 10/20/06 j 4124-4070 f $0 1 (=) Market Value $259,631 10/07/05 3907-307 10/07 $702,000 i 09/01/05 3881-1803 $0 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. I $ 12,033 .._. � ` _ 01/09/04 1 3483-145 l $540,000 i (=)Assessed Value ; $ 247,598 11/01/86 1231-678 1 $ 160,000 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. ! $ 50,000 1 (_)Taxable Value $197,5981 (=) School Taxable Value $ 222,598 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 f i �.•t�1 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 012 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 404, Folio#33400000088 1. 1 .a (ai Print Name Signature(required) Date ( * ) civutvi - (- — I �2 Mailing A ress 2. RE( El\/ED Print Name Signature(required) Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address SEP 16 2013 3. Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date ACC Mailing Address """ Page o --,1,, Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 133400000088 1 Site Adr. 1404 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address COLA,CAROLE S 404 LA PENINSULA BLVD City I NAPLES State I FL Zip 134113-4038 Map No. I Strap No. I Section J Township Range j Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 302200 4047B06 6 52 26 ; 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 404 Millage Area 0191 I )Vlillage Rates 0 *Calculation* 1302200-400 LA PENINSULA A I CONDOMINIUM 1 1 !_ Sub./Condo School Other Total Use Code 0 14. CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) 1 g i .. I Land Value Date Book-Page Amount $Q 05/06/10 4569-2474 $0 j (+)Improved Value $ 259,631 12/19/00 2761-1665 $250,000 11/17/00 i 2744-3479 $0 ' (=)Market Value $259,631 I $0 I SOH*&other Exempt.2744-3477 $0 10/20/00 2734-2480 $ 245,000 I (=)Assessed Value $259,631 05/09/00 2673-1370 $0 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 01/26/98 2383-44 $0 ,. .... � I i (_)Taxable Value $259,631 11/08/96 2249-157 ; $3,015,500E i (=) School Taxable Value 1 $259,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-013 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 442, Folio#33400000460 `Print Name Signature(r uired) / Date /6 "2-2ic--GCJ� 9Z/0/ Mailing-Address 2. RE CE Print Name Signature(required) I V Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address SEP 1 2 3. zo13 Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date Mailing Address 6 A i Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.133400000460 1 Site Adr. 1442 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address GERARD, ROBERT=&CAROLYN 1516 FRONT ST City 1SAN DIEGO 1 State ICA Zip 192101-2919 Map No I Strap No 1 Section 1 Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 302200 4427806 1 6 I i 52 26 I 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 442 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1302200-400 LA PENINSULA A School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 -CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page 1 Amount I Land Value $0 I. 09/07/00 I 2718-2852 1 $270,000 1 (+)Improved Value $281,250 12/29/97 1 2375-360 I $0 (=) Market Value $281,250 11/08/96 I 2249-157 i $3,015,500 : (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 1 (=)Assessed Value $281,250 1 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 1 (=)Taxable Value $281,250 (=) School Taxable Value $281,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. • http://wvvw.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 ___ 6 A ...Ad Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-014 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/2912013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting 1 property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 443, Folio#33400000486 1. y� ‘e14 Aet w .vasb.aoe2 AtiL (� q .12. 13 Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address 2. 1 ^fob --I3 A PULIN NOS _ L rt,t t At.. A- Print Name ur (required) Date RECEIVED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 16 2Q13 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASST ACC 6 _ Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 33400000486 Site Adr.1 443 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address VASBINDER TR,JACQUELINE R JACQUELINE R VASBINDER TRUST UTD 06/05/06 1685 HARDIN LN City POWELL State I OH I Zip 43065-9646 Map No Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 302200 4437B06 6 ! 52 1 26 0 Legal 1 400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 443 Millage Area 0 191 j Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200 - 400 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo I School I Other Total CONDOMINIUM_ Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 1 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount Land Value $0 08/20/08 I 4387-1089 ! $0 (+)Improved Value I $281,250 10/18/00 2733-1373 I $ 280,000 , ! (=) Market Value $281,250 08/03/98 i 2447-781, I $0 I 12/02/97 2367 2288 I $0 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 11/26/97 I 236$-2081 $0 (=)Assessed Value $281,250 11/08/96 I 2249-157 j $3,015,500 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $281,250 (=)School Taxable Value $281,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6q , Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-016 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 202, Folio#78545000047 1' N& M.Tic,y lo,� /� ' 9-9-13 Print Name Signature requir Date /53 3 Coy6Jai 1Q,Trr I 01111`emtedoi h I ci Mailing Address 2. 0 WV C fry "- 9 "HT _I Print Name Si ture(required) Date 1533 Coetovo p 7^Qr Wt(t f ��� M EIVED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. ` 2013 Print Name Signature(required) ' Date MGR Mailing Address ASST_ ACC P. 6 ,, Page l of l Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178545000047 I Site Adr. 1202 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address 'TAYLOR,JOHN C=&NANCY M 1533 CORKWOOD TRL City WILLIAMSTON State Zip p i 48895-9111 Map No Strap No I Section ! Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 677800 2027B06 1 6 52 26 I 0 Legal 1 200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 202 ,Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations LONDOMINIUM 77800- 200 LA PENINSULA A I Sub./Condo I School Other Total i Use Code 0 14- CONDOMINIUM i 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date ; Book-Page I Amount 1 � Land Value i $0I 05/28/10 j 4573-523, I $235,000 ; (*)Improved Value $241,800 01/02/88 I 1321-387 I $ 195,000 (=) Market Value $241,800 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value 1 $241,8001 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value i $241,800; (=) School Taxable Value $241,8001 .... . ..... .. If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 ' A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 018 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 241, Folio#78545000403 j 1. Nei //j7 /���� .. r _� 9/74 Print Name J,� ignature(r uired) Date /o9 /� r�G�!02� D Cl/f/G//V'// .7'..// 0#, i.S d`5^ - Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required EC E IV ® Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP162013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR ASST Mailing Address ACC 6 i Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78545000403 I Site Adr. 241 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address I LEACH, DAVID A 1109 ASBURY RD City!CINCINNATI I State JOH Zip 145255-4601 Map No. I Strap No. 1 Section j Township Range Acres *Acreage 7806 i 677800 2417606 f 6 , 52 26 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 241 Miliage Area 0 191 I Miliage Rates 0 *CalculatiQps 677800 - 200 LA PENINSULA A I Sub./Condo CONDOMINIUM i School 1 Other Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page Amount I Land Value $p 02/02/12 4764-1791 $ 325,000 (+)Improved Value , $249,631+ 12/23/03 i 3470-750 L_ $341,500 l 11/13/01 2921-1820 $ 299,000 ° Market Value $249,631 04/08/96 I 2167-2350 j $ 128,000 { (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 12/01/87 1318-1329 I $ 160,000 I i (=)Assessed Value $249,631 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $249,631 ! (=)School Taxable Value I $249,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=Ia+penins.., 9/25/2013 ► 6 A . .." Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-019 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 242, Folio#78545000429 '. au ( 7k l« Print Name Signature(required) Date a 14.2 Zc Pen/ ,c-( I at j/i/GC Map lei FL It/ II ? Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(requirC Date t'/'E R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP002013 Print Name Signature(required)GR Date ASST Mailing Address ACC . 6 ,, Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178545000429 f Site Adr. 1242 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address 1GAULT,JAMES J ABBE R DROSSNER 242 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES , State f FL Zip 34113-4035 Map No 1 Strap No I Section 1 Township 1 Range j Acres *Acreage 7B06 677800 2427B06 1 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1 200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 242 Millage Area 0(91 ! Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 677800 - 200 LA PENINSULA A L Sub./Condo School I Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM , Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 i 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page ! Amount Land Value $01 01/23/04 1 3489-988 $420,000 1 (+)Improved Value $281,2501 01/01/88 1 1319-1141 1 $ 198,000 Market 1 l (-_) Mkt Value $281,2501 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $01 (_)Assessed Value f $281,250 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. i $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value $231,2501 (_)School Taxable Value $256,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-020 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 .(date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 243, Folio#78545000445 \. Print Name Signatu (required) Date `c).L.\')) _.n� �v � hlvck \ ∎orl,\-.L-- 3 1\1. Mailing Address �-- 2. �' X � PVC)- u2.0(k. �Q( t� DV-: Print Name Signature(required) Date RECEIVED Mailing Address R $c P MANAGEMENT 3. 5EP Q 9 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASS f ACC ------------'-- f Page 1 61 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78545000445 1 Site Adr. 1 243 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DAVIS,WENDY K PO BOX 783 � f ] City WESTFIELD CENTER State ION I Zip 144251 Map No 1 Strap No i Section Township I Range j Acres *Acreage 71306 677800 243 7806 6 i 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1 200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 243 Ntiliege Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 677800 -200 LA PENINSULA A School I Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 , 6.7427 I 12.4327 I j Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount i I Land Value ! $0 10/25/12 4854-3470 I $ 345,000 (+)Improved Value $281,250 02/17/05 3735-3020 $710,000 1 I i (=)Market Value I $281,250 01/05/04 3477-2990 $ 340,000 , 03/29/99 1 2528-1154 $0 I i (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 I 06/01/88 1356-1473 i $ 205,000 i ; (=)Assessed Value $ 281,2501 (-) Homestead at other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value $281,2501 I (=)School Taxable Value $ 281,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-021 County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 244, Folio#78545000461 r4/./1 4.per / ,,,C1 I 1/11 5 -,„4..„ada c eetf-p-Ptsy Print Name Signature(required) Date ad 6 - /11'6 Mailing Address 2. !� Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEA' t 6 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ACC 6A Page lof1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No 1 78545000461 f Site Adr. 1 244 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address ADAMS,JOHN H=&PATRICIA 2562 GRACIE LONE City I MACUNGIE 1 State I PA Zip 1 18062-9555 Map No f Strap No. ;Section Township j Range j Acres *Acreage 7806 ( 677800 2447806 ( 6 52 I 26 j 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 244 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 677800-200 LA PENINSULA A ! Sub./Condo School ; Other I Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 ( 12.4327 k! Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) e(Subject to Change) 9 Date f Book-Page f Amount I Land Value $0 1 12/01/87 I 1313-1194 j $ 175,000 I E (4.)Improved Value $249,631 (=)Market Value $249,631 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 ! (=)Assessed Value $249,631 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $249,631 (=)School Taxable Value f $249,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coll ierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-022 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 222, Folio#78545000283 1. 4_ -13 Print Name /� Signet-re(require, Date Z Z z A' Pg.0 a, . �// )0165 I r/ Mailing Address 2. 10-/3 Print ]-\/(96,-7/0/Z,- - �1' Print Name / �J S gnature(required Date Mailing Address d 3' & PMANAGEME T Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 16 2013 Mailing Address MGR ACC 6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.178545000283 1 Site Adr. 1222 LA PENINSULA BLVD �..... Name/Address FELDMAN, MARC S RONNIE KOENIG 2818 RITTENHOUSE ST NW I _ 1 City(WASHINGTON State�DC Zip 120015-1522 Map No Strap No ; Section 1 Township I Range ji Acres *Acreage 7606 677800 2227806 6 52 26 1 0 Legal 1 200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 222 Millage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 677800 - 200 LA PENINSULA A School 1 Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM , Use Code 0 4- CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date f Book-Page Amount I I Land Value $01 03/04/03 3231-383 i $369,000 1 1 (+)Improved Value $ 271,250! 03/03/95 2035-1803 $219,000 1 (=) Market Value 01/01/92 j 1682-1197 $0 $271,250 01/01/88 1321-396 { $185,000 1 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 ' (=)Assessed Value ! $ 271,250 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value $271,250 (=)School Taxable Value 1 $271,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A 4 wig Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-023 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 223, Folio#78545000296 1.T.1 hd •►—e (= 6Q,(NY)0. rcl r. � 7/V13 Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address 2. Print Name SignaturE E I\ /E JJ Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR _ Mailing Address ASST ACC 6 A Page 1 of I Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78545000296 1 Site Adr.1 223 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address BERNARD JR,THEODORE F 9 TAMARACK DR City I BRUNSWICK 1 State I ME Zip 104011-3474 Map No I Strap No 1 Section 1 Township ; Range � Acres *Acreage 7806 I 677800 2237B06 1 6 1 52 [ 26 1 . 0 EE I Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 223 Millage Area 0191 , Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677800 - 200 LA PENINSULAR { School Other Total CONDOMINIUM f Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 1 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page 1 Amount I Land Value $0' 09/17/01 1 ,2893-272 1 $0 r j (+)Improved Value $271,250 07/17/88 1 1365-411 1 $200,600 1 j (=) Market Value 1 $271,250 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 i (=)Assessed Value $271,250 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value ; $271,250 i (=)School Taxable Value 1 $271,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll `SOH='Save Our Homes-exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetaiI.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6a Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-024 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 224, Folio#78545000306 . -5 t BPD ti i c—:14-1/ MIS `t 13 Signature(requi d) at Print Name Ey Mailing Address 2. A /e 8447(D :Tffiv/v/vs `` —` cry/3 Print Name Signature(re. ' red mate -4//9 Mailing Address ric E 3. Print Name Signature(requireF & P MANAGEMENT Date SEP 12 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ..� Arr. it 6 ,.. . ..... Page 1 of Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178545000306 I Site Adr.1 224 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address!JENKINS, RICHARD D=&SHARON 113 THOMAS LEIGHTON BLVD City CUMBERLAND State 1 RI Zip 102864-2202 Map No Strap No Section i Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7806 677800 2247B06 f 6 1 52 26 I 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 224 i Millage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 1677800 - 200 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo(CONDOMINIUM I School Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 1... 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page i Amount Land Value $0 05/04/04 3554-4160 $ 375,000 . 239631 1 (+)Improved Value 239,6311 04/17/96 ,2171-2372 $0 (=) Market Value $239,6311 06/01/93 ; 1835-727 $0 03/01/91 1596-1584 $0 (SOH*8t other Exempt. $0 12/01/87 1313-536 $165,000 ; (=)Assessed Value $239,631; (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 1 (=)Taxable Value $ 239,631 (=)School Taxable Value $239,631 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coilierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 64 .2-671,0 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-028 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. - t It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 209, Folio#78545000160 1. AA 11_0- njia- MAN)Print Name Signature(required) ate IV/ /A tact M,ieSr .PT VAY1 t ',kl I/ ' )-- su n cz. /1-400W Mailing Address 2. :De&—A18- Frz6 ' �e 9-07-)o/3 Print Name Signature(required) Date yy.le /11 Mailing Address ECEIVED 3' R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SL," 162013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC Page f A Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78545000160 I Site Adr. 1 209 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address FUZE, MICHAEL=&IRENE . ............... ........ 209 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES State 1 FL Zip 1 34113-4034 Map No I Strap No ; Section j Township j Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 677800 209 7B06 6 i 52 26 I 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 209 Mille __ ll Miliage Area 0191 a Rates O *Calculations Millage 200 LA PENINSULA A E Sub./Condo School 1 Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM I Use Code 0 14-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 f 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page j Amount I ` Land Value $01 01/23/07 j 4172-3808 1 $475,000 j I 1 (+)Improved Value $ 223,800 03/10/04 3518-1760 I $ 387,500 (=) Market Value $223,8001 07/08/02 3067-3338 $280,000 ■ 07/08/97 2329-1475 $0 I (-)SOH*8z other Exempt. $0 09/18/95 2100-1501, I_ $260,000 j I (=)Assessed Value $ 223,800 09/01/95 j 2100-1499 , $0 ' (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 I (_)Taxable Value $223,800 (=)School Taxable Value $ 223,800 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 P. 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-030 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 211, Folio#78545000209 1. l 1 e h/Jvi"i{/ 4:: I/f/I L'i G f� ��r�tz 3 % tic `///o/3 Print Name Signature(required) Date tf r/A 6 Da. 1�,1i�;�rr , AV,- , c 7'71 7 o Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(requi®RRE C E l\ 1 E D Date R & P MANAGEMPNT Mailing Address 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR _ ASST_ Mailing Address ACC P. 6 A: Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78545000209 Site Adr. 1 211 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address WALTER JR, KENNETH E • ROBERT D WALTER KENNETH E WALTER SR 5 FAIRFIELD AVE City I LITTLE FALLS State j NJ Zip 07424-1251 Map No. 1 Strap No. Section j Township j Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 677800 2117806 6 '' 52 26 1 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 211 Miliage Area 0191 1 iViillage Rates 0 *Calculations 1677800- 200 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo ndo CONDOMINIUM School Other i Total - Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 l 6.7427 L . 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Safes are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page 1 Amount I Land Value $0 j 12/01/87 1 1318-2380 1 $205,000 1 i (+)Improved Value ( $228,800 (=) Market Value $228,800 (-)SOW&other Exempt. 11 $0 (=)Assessed Value $228,8001 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. E.... $0i (=)Taxable Value ; $228,8001 (=) School Taxable Value $228,80011 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH=°Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coIlierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-031 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 342, Folio#54500920005 1. 9-:- L-+ i..D ['.S .h 10 C._-t°�'� 1� n c� (ALL /)� ri�+ 9/,/,3 Print Name ^'j Signature(required) Date ?) 1:a L..,1 1 1-U 14(�. a�t- L . cr. I r //03.1 Mailing Address \I 2. Print Name Signature(requirecREC E I V Date R\\&��P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP092013 Print Name Signature(required).GR Date ASST Mailing Address ACC �""'- Page o6 A Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary IParcel No. 154500920005 � Site Adr.1342 LA PENINSULA BLVD , Name/Address I BIESENBERGER TR, ERNA ERNA L BIESENBERGER REV TRUST UTD 11/28/05 _ I 1342 LA PENINSULA BLVD 1 City NAPLES State �FL Zip 134113-4037 Map No, I Strap No, Section 1 Township j Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 453400 3427806 it 6 1 52 , 26 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 342 Millage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM 1 School I Other I Total Use Code014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount 1 I Land Value ( $0 12/08/05 3944-40 $0 1 i CO Improved Value $281,250 04/06/90 1518-1127 I $240.0001 I (=) Market Value $281,250 08/01/88 1370-2337 $0 II . .. 09/01/86 1229-1864 I $ 183,000 1 F (-)SOW&other Exempt. $45,521 i t (=)Assessed Value $235,729 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $50,500 (=)Taxable Value $ 185,2291 (=) School Taxable Value $ 210,229 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 It 6 .4 r won Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-032 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 343, Folio#54500960007 1. /e/LPr S, �yes 1 1671/22---- (..9q o9/�0/3 Print Name Signature(required) /Date 44r/ /64 1 3 5/// 3 Mailing Address 2. RECEIVED Print Name Signature(required) Date& P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address vw' 1 1 2013 3. Print Name Signature(required) ASR Date ACC Mailing Address Page 1 of Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. f 54500960007 ) Site Adr. +343 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address KEYES TR, HARRIET S HARRIET S KEYES DATED 03/07/03 100 BASIL CT • : City I FRANKLIN i State i TN Zip 137064-3209 Map No 1 Strap No ; Section 1 Township I Range 1 Acres *Acreage ' 7606 453400 3437606 6 { 52 1 26 i 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 343 Millage Area 0 91 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM I School f Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date L Book-Page Amount Land Value $0 03/13/03 3239"1225 I $0 I (+)Improved Value $281,250 08/16/89 I 1462-2323 $245,000 i i.... 04/01/88 1339-537 j $200,000 1 i (=) Market Value $281,250 1 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value I $281,250 ..... .................... ... (-) Homestead at other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value ( $281,250 (=)School Taxable Value 1 $281'2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coll ierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A .1 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93-033 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 344, Folio#54501000005 1. . -ti� rP14 i . &swi('R ` .� . (4. 9-6-43 P nt Name S1 nat re(required) Date 34-4-LA P an/I 3Th A BL-Kb WAPL!3 iLefm A X113 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) RECEIVED Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SFP Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR _ Mailing Address ACC Page 1o6 A Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 54501000005 I Site Adr. 1344 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address I BESWICK TR, STEPHEN N 1 1STEPHEN N BESWICK TRUST 1344 LA PENINSULA BLVD City j NAPLES State 1FL Zip 134113-4037 Map No 1 Strap No Section 1 Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3447B06 6 I 52 26 I 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 344 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School Other Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page Amount I Land Value $0 i 03/23/11 1 4665-1444 $ I (+)Improved Value $249,6311 03/02/09 1 4431-3495 $ 300,000 , (=) Market Value $249,631 10/01/86 1225-2241 $ 180,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $ 12,203 (=)Assessed Value $237,428 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,500 (=)Taxable Value $ 186,928 (=) School Taxable Value $211,928 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-034 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 643, Folio#73605000364 1. J—OCA_n n r Be- n � �2-�- - �� . Jo) .o/3 Print Name ignature(required) Date LaPer)insufz (9/vd. Nap/es) l=� ,dc/ 1 ( 3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signal`", tli�edlI Date R & p MANAG\I'EID EMENT Mailing Address 3. sEP 16 2013 Print Name Signa, icequlred) Date Asst -------_..:-. Mailing Address Page 1 of ' A Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 173605000364 I Site Adr. 1643 I.A PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address BEHNE,JOANNE M 643 LA PENINSULA BLVD City l NAPLES .., . . State 1 FL I Zip 1 34113-4043 Map No Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 , 629500 6437B06 6 52 I 26 I 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 643 Millage Area 0 191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 629500 - 600 LA PENINSULA A I School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 814 CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Am ount Land Value $0 12/31/09 4527-2022 $400,000 (4-)Improved Value $311,250 07/15/05 3845-2394 I $715,000 1 l (=) Market Value $311,250 01/30/01 2770-2734 $ 140,000 [ (-)SOH*&other Exempt. I $0 05/08/95 I 2056-1407 $225,000 I 12/21/94 1 2013-1539 I $0 I (=)Assessed Value $ 311,250) (-) Homestead&other Exempt. I $ 50,000 1 (=)Taxable Value ! $261,250 (=) School Taxable Value 1 $286,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Searc1i/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-036 County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 645, Folio#73605000403 1. r" in„ /1.1 s e.. L is Print Name Cgnature(required) Date 751 c,) 6.0/ F y h /0-ef i .3 95-7 Mailing Address 2. 6-y' /1//t e.S eS Print Name Sign 5s re(required) Date aQs 9 G q GtJ "1//1 1o,� 36 r 5(1'1(i-el Fl 3 3 75-7 Mailing Address 3. VEID E C E I R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date S :P 1 1 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC i Page 1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 73605000403 I Site Adr.1645 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address NIESEL, CHESTER A=&NANCY 2959 W GULF DR UNIT 304 . City I SANIBEL 1 State I FL p1 33957-5723 I zi Map No. 1 Strap No. ( Section I Township ( Range I Acres *Acreage 1 7B06 1 629500 6457B06 i 6 52 26 I 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 645 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 1629500- 600 LA PENINSULA A ' Sub./Condo School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014 CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page Amount i I Land Value ; $O 07/28/09 4477-2076 $352,000 (+)Improved Value $279,6311 09/13/05 J 3888-4145 $ 670,000 06/10/05 j 3818-3652 $0 (=) Market Value 1 _ $279,631 07/20/04 3609-1313 $ 580,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 02/04/00 1 2638-726 J $0 , (=)Assessed Value $ 279,631! 03/02/99 ,25 8-1578 $0 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 06/13/95 ,2068-169 $285,000 ' iI I (_)Taxable Value $279,631 12/21/94 ! 2013-1539 , $0 (=)School Taxable Value $279,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH='Save Our Homes°exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collier appraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 I. 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-037 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 624, Folio#73605000186 4 (CE-x-c(---iiiii5re:::g-Print Name Signature(required) Date ,33c, tca KeeLe_ Area ..7-5/a ie( -rL .3W Mailing Address / 2. • Print Name Signature(required) RECEIVED Date Mailing Address ' & P MANAGEMENT 3. Print Name Signature(required) SeP 2 202 Date MGR Mailing Address ACC Page 61 I 04 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. !73605000186 Site Adr. 624 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address KEAY TR,JAMES RALPH E SONNTAG IRR TRUST 336 SEABREEZE DR City MARCO ISLAND State 'FL Zip 34145-1827 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 629500 6247B06 6 52 26 0 Legal ;600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 624 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1629500 - 600 LA PENINSULA A School Other Total ;CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page Amount ' Land Value $ 0 06/08/05 ' 3815-3660 $1,270,000 (+)Improved Value $ 301,250 12/11/02 3172-1468 $440,000 (=) Market Value $ 301,250 04/26/95 2052-2322 $208,300 $0 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 301,250 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 301,250, (=) School Taxable Value $ 301,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=LA+PENI... 9/27/2013 ff Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13.039 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon Co rf y approval. Property Address 631, Folio#73605000225_,----- 1. ° ` -mac e V5R.`61a/✓x be116/ d'4Ph/, ��/79x J� - 2ti sre 9 y/� Print Name ature required) Date / s7_i ,� e„..u„ sPRi2 G 4 yis4s: _:- Mailing Address 2. RECEIVFD Print Name Signature(required)r., & P MANAGEMENT Date SEP 16 2013 Mailing Address 3. MGR Print Name Signature(require SS-r7- ` Date Mailing Address F. 6 A Page 1 of 1 I Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 73605000225 I Site Adr.1 631 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address KATHLEEN OBRIEN FOX TRUST 19573 N SHORE DR City SPRING LAKE State l MI Zip 49456-9107 Map No. I Strap No. Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7606 I 629500 6317806 ' 6 1 1 52 26 � 0 Legal 1 600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 631 Millage Area 0 91 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 629500- 600 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo 1 School Other I Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 1 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount Land Value $0 01/24/13 I _ 0 4912-1 $0 . _. (+)Improved Value $274,631 10/14/04 1 3660-3138 I $p (=)Market Value $274,631 07/27/00 2703-1546 I $285,000 10/07/91 i 1653-850 (._ $0 (-)SOH* at other Exempt. $0 09/01/88 j 1378-368 I $225,000 I (_)Assessed Value $274,631 1 (-) Homestead &other Exempt, I _ $0 1 I (_)Taxable Value $274,6311 I (=)School Taxable Value $274.631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=`Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.comlMain Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 ► 6A INSTR 4829405 OR 4912 PG 1 RECORDED 4/23/2013 5:48 PM PAGES 3 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC @.70 $0.70 REC $27.00 INOX $1.00 RECORD&RETURN TO: This instrument prepared without examination or legal opinion of title by: Laura E.Radle,Esq.(FL Bar No.77041) Vamum LLP P.O.Box 352 Grand Rapids,MI 49501 Property No.73605000225 Consideration:NONE The Grantors,HENRY A.F ,6 d.nLLIAM O'BRI F X,sole survivors of themselves and Kathleen O'Brien Fox,deceased,a ce ill c py whose •-_ ,edifice a is ecorded herewith,whose address is 1 19573 North Shore Drive,Spring L e, • .• n ' ' 6, o ey o the Grantee,Henry A.Fox,Jr., I Trustee of the Kathleen O'Brien ox ,r t ;• e o ,�`r , a a ended,and his successor,whose address is 19573 North Shore Driv ,S• in: L. �Vlikh._. i, 5•\th fo o ng described premises situated in Collier County,Florida: C Condominium Parcel: Unit • •'1,of 600 La Penin 'P -, • c ,tit, inium according to the plat thereof recorded in Condomin' at Book 31, Page I , , • mg further described in that certain Declaration of Condomin• iQr • ded in O.R. B B.• '1 , Pages 1984 through 2050,as amended, et seq., together with i �,•1 '�• r., ;t• ments to said Declaration and Condominium Plat as from time to time ,e ;anti nd together with an undivided interest or share in the common elements appurtenant thereto. All as recorded in the Public Records of Collier County. Subject to covenants,restrictions,casements of record and taxes for the current year. Together with all the tenements,hereditaments and appurtenances thereto belonging or in anywise appertaining. Being the same property described in the deed recorded in Official Records Book 3660,Pages 3138 and 3139,of the Public Records of Collier County,Florida. TRUST POWERS: Pursuant to F.S.§689.071,the Trustees of the Trust described above,including all successor Trustees,have full power and authority to protect,conserve,sell,lease,encumber,convey,transfer or otherwise manage and dispose of all or any portion of the property described above,without the consent or approval of any other party. Dated this 24th day of January,2013. ' 6 _ OR 4912 PG 2 WITNESSED: (/' .411 11, l,----.. 4 Witn ss 1 P,nt Name:/omas H.Bergh Henry A.Fox,Jr. C-62a---- 111110..112:: Witness 2 Pr dame: Ch MiI ayer STATE OF MICHIGAN ) ) COUNTY OF KENT ) The foregoing instrument was acknow e._- ' Vfct�r fy= ' 24th day of January 24,2013, by Henry A. Fox,Jr.wro,is personally kripwn to me or , • .a 4 erotica 1,1.4d o did not take an oath. ,.'r 1,:, •'� _ '—---- 'f"a fi to in ' o�% `-= I 6 A .,44t Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-040 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 632, Folio#73605000241 M r 4g 4 e/ Z RI=AP/to I r' ,-4e,e +0X01 Print Name Signature(required) Date 3 a X.4 P1vi vD /) 4P/C's /.4 36/1/3 -- Y3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) Date E c EIVED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMEN I 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ACT ACC Page loll Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 173605000241 Site Adr. 1632 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address PIERPAOLI, MICHAEL L=&CANDICE 632 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES State 1FL Zip 34113-4043 Map No Strap No Section ] Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 1 1 7B06 629500 6327B06 6 1 52 26 1 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 632 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub/Condo 1629500- 600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I. 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page Amount 1 I Land Value $ 1 05/05/88 1 1347-143 $275,000 1 (+)Improved Value $ 306,250 (=) Market Value $ 306,250 (-)SOH* &other Exempt. $45,062 (=)Assessed Value $ 261,188 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value $211,188 1 (=) School Taxable Value $236,1881 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-041 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 633, Folio#73605000267 1. ,p4-40-:-5 , . MI /I4 Gf s7 a fir. G! hr'e.° !n%/U/ Print Name Sig ature(required) Date Mailing Address 4-e� 2. Print Name Signature(required) RECEIVED E Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date ASSN Mailing Address ACC 1 6 P g lofl Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 173605000267 I Site Adr. 1633 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address KEAY TR,JAMES RALPH E SONNTAG IRR TRUST 336 SEABREEZE DR City 1 MARCO ISLAND State 1 FL Zip 34145-1827 Map No I Strap No. I Section ` Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 629500 6337B06 6 I 52 26 1 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 633 .11/tillage Area 0191 I Miliage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 629500 - 600 LA PENINSULA A I School Other Total CONDOMINIUM I Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount Land Value $0 06/08/05 3815-3660 $ 1,270,000 CO Improved Value I $ 336,250 04/04/03 3256-3448 ( $455,000 (=) Market Value $ 336,250 05/04/95 I 2055-2022 I $220,500 12/21/94 I 2013-1539 I $0 I f (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 336,250 t (-) Homestead&other Exempt. L. .... $0! 1 (=)Taxable Value $ 336,250 i.. (=) School Taxable Value I $ 336,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 .. 6 A .• Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-043 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineers estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 603, Folio#73605000063 1. Print Name iS gnature req i ed) to Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required I l Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 1 2 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASST ACC _. . _ ... • fi A 4 Page 1 of 1 , Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary 1 Parcel No. 73605000063 1 Site Adr. I 603 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address ROGERS TR,CELIA F CELIA F ROGERS REVOCABLE TRUST JOHN L ROTH TR 1JOHN L ROTH REVOCABLE TRUST 113500 NARROW LEAF CT City 1 CLARKSVILLE 1 State MD Zip 21029-1438 Map No I Strap No. 1 Section I Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 1 i I 1 7806 I 629500 6037B06 I 6 1 52 26 1 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 603 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 629500- 600 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo CONDOMINIUM School 1 Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Data J Book-Page Amount i Land Value $0 12/06/07 4309-1206 1 $° 1 CO Improved Value $ 353,950 07/17/07 4258-3239 $700,000 (=) Market Value $ 353,950 12/06/00 2751-1036 $425,000 * 06/09/95 2067-2247 $ 350,000 1 (-) SOH &other Exempt. $0 _ 12/21/94 2013-1539 I $0 (=)Assessed Value $353.950 (-)Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 353,9501 (=)School Taxable Value $ 353,9501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearchaecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-044 County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: - The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 604, Folio#73605000089 1. Print Name Signature(required) Date a>-\ 1 .a.,``�Q.i.wt 5 ck\a \ vc� --‘e,s5, V-L 3 1 t3 Mailing Address /, 2. / ,P!•./r/�` f l ` ., 6'C // l f�/0 -6201 Print Name t_.. . Signature(re t red) / Date 601/ il///e/iSel RECEIVED Mailing Address 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 6 2013 Date Mailing Address MGI< ASST • ACC 6 1 ' .0e1ofl 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary IParcel No. 173605000089 1 Site Adr.1604 LA PENINSULA BLVD ...... ..... ..................................._ Name/Address BECKLEY, LELAN G CHARLOTTE.1 BECKLEY 604 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES State FL I Zip 134113-4042 Map No Strap No Section 1 Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 629500 604 7B06 6 I 52 j 26 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 604 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1b29500- 600 LA PENINSULA A School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sates History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page I Amount 1 Land Value $01 07/07/11 1 4701-1584 1 $410,000 (+)Improved Value $353,9501 05/21/93 1 1819-1214 L $0 05/01/88 1 1343-613 1 $310,000 1 (=) Market Value $353,950 1(-)SOH*&other Exempt. 1 $01 1 (=)Assessed Value $353,9501 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. 1 $ 50.000 1 I (=)Taxable Value $303,9501 (=)School Taxable Value $ 328,9501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?Fu1)Address=la+penins... 9/25/2013 ' 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-045 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 605, Folio#73605000102 Print Name Signature(requireili Date 10 &. o•F W4-SG.; , g t-o�r N(1 o7 b 1 ( Mailing OA/ddress 2. e._-/XAV XrZi Mi&Print Nam Signaturdfibie5 ui red) E 1 V aTe /n/ „ :74 ;rpf/lUeVh 1 AVMle i4 ENT Mailing Address 3. SEP 16 2013 Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date ASST Mailing Address ACC , 6c, . Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. I 73605000102 Site Adr.I605 LA PENINSULA BLVD 1 Name/Address ARAGONA,GLENN=&CINDY 101 PRESIDENT RD City TWP WASHINTON State NJ I Zip 107676-5225 Map No Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 629500 605 7B06 6 52 26 I i 0 Legal 1600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 605 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculati•ns Sub/Condo 1629500 -MINIUM 600 LA PENINSULA A School Other Total CONDO Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page Amount I I Land Value $0 12/10/12 I 4867-1595 $0 II . ! 1 (+)Improved Value $289,631 01/16/89 I 1412-990 j $235,000 ; : (=) Market Value $289,631 01/27/89 I 1412-930 $235,000 il 1 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $289,631 [ (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $289,631 (=) School Taxable Value $289,6311 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=°Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraisencom/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. /3-046 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 621, Folio#73605000128 1. CLrs o1 (F//// Print Name . •nature(required) Date 9 7S- S'YLi)a-n iZ PekrsIr�� �2.� , O a 49 ZC,7 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature°IRE I / D Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SD 16 2013 Print Name Signature(required_) Date ASSN Mailing Address ACC P 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 73605000128 1 Site Adr. 621 LA PENINSULA BLVD I I Name/Address GRAMS, PHYLLIS A 9875 SYLVANIA PETERSBURG RD City OTTAWA LAKE State 1 MI I Zip 49267-8723 Map No Strap No Section j Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 I 629500 6217B06 6 ∎ 52 I 26 1 0 Legal 1 600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 621 Millage Area 0 91 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 629500- 600 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo I School Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Data Book-Page I Amount ! Land Value $0 12/18/02 I 3177-2754 $445,000 i (+)Improved Value $269,631 02/07/90 i 1503-1328 $0 (=) Market Value $269,631 08/01/88 I 1375-571 I $215,000 i (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 269,631 il (-) Homestead&other Exempt. i $0 I (=)Taxable Value $ 269,631 I (=)School Taxable Value $ 269,6311 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll `SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 I. 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 047 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 622, Folio#73605000144 1 �A7NE,ran. rc1r-,°, C�e%C�us�CC� 0//A Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required)R Ec El' J Date R & p MANAGFA4I=NT Mailing Address 3. S41° 20 2013 Print Name Signature(requiredMG R Date Mailing Address . . , 6 A age 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No 173605000144 1 Site Adr. 1622 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address WEEKS, CATHERINE M 115606 DUCK TRAIL LN L._ I City(APPLE VALLEY State 1 MN I Zip 155124-7835 Map No I Strap No ( Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 I 629500 6227B06 6 I 52 26 I 0 Legal 600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 622 JVlillage Area 40191 } Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 629500 - 600 LA PENINSULA A i Sub/Condo School 1 Other Total CONDOMINIUM I Use Coded 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page ( Amount I ; Land Value $0 02/01/08 L 4326-1047 $0 1 (+)Improved Value $301,250 01/30/08 i 4325-2357 $0 (_) Market Value $ 301,250 01/07/08 I 4318-1518 I $495,000 01/18/05 I 3717-1386 $0 1 1 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 I I (=)Assessed Value $301,250 01/18/05 3717-1381, � $0 � ( 01/18/05 3717-1379 j $0 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 05/21/88 1343-1371 F $265,000 I (=)Taxable Value I $301,2501 1 (=)School Taxable Value $ 301,2501 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coIlierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 t Collier County Citizen Petition No. /3- 048 * * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7129!2 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon 82n775.083, guilty of a 104.185 F�S) degree, punishable as provided in Sections To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). Peninsula It is understood that the purpose of this district reoshalllbe pad for by spe ial assessment Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. T hese improvements imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to to meet the cost'of said and improvements. It is p collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient a proposed osed that upon completion of the project and acceptance d off. by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project p It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project e shall will be determined upon the creation property owners. The estimate for the design, repair p of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. a public After investigation by the Alternative Transportation seesta c rtment and an shall be crest dVeEach affected property hearing steall be held to determine if the proposed assessment S. mail. owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Booardof Co ntyrCommissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement p • 1. . 5 , lc �— L Date Prinnt t Signature(required)Name /f // 614. (O 1 C L /` 11 14.? v[-e f 1 Al c-S—3 9 Mailing Address / / a_ - Date/3 Ate, Print Name Signet e(required) .— Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. - Print Name Signature(required) 2013 Date Mailing Address ASST ACC A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 73605000160 Site Adr. 623 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address VOSIKA,JOHN B=&JUDY A 623 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES State I F Zip 134113-4042 Map No Strap No I Section ; Township I Range I Acres *Acreage II II 7B06 629500 6237B06 6 l 52 26 I 0 Legal 1 600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 623 Millage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 629500-600 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4 CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount ; I Land Value $0 { 04/30/08 4354-3823 J $ 550,000 I ( (+)Improved Value $301,250 I I 09/20/01 2895-981 1 $455,000 I (=) Market Value I $301,250 04/06/95 2046-1741 $ 320,000 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 1 ' (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $a (=)Assessed Value $301,250 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $ 50,000 (m)Taxable Value $251,250 (=) School Taxable Value $276,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-050 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 424, Folio#33400000347 1. / / .10 Print Name gnature(required) Date 67/?4":17 y DA< bra T rvahL) Mailing Addr6ss 2. Print Name Signature(required'R E p�14�� Date ECE1V Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR_ Mailing Address ASST ACC P-• 6 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 133400000347 Site Adr.1424 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address !CRAIG H PILLATSCH TRUST 1322 N DIVISION ST I � City 1 CARTERVILLE State I IL ; Zip 162918-1272 Map No I Strap No ; Section I Township 1 Range j Acres *Acreage 7606 302200 424 7806 6 52 26 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 424 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200-400 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount I s Land Value $0 01/29/13 S 4890-3125 l $_0i (+)Improved Value $239,631 11/18/96 1 2251-1867 4 $ 280,000 1 I { (=) Market Value $239,631 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 I (=)Assessed Value $239,631 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0I (=)Taxable Value $239,631 (=) School Taxable Value $239,631 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=°Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 l6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-051 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 431, Folio#33400000363 Pervvy AAMs 9- c15- MTh LNIA me Signa ure(require ) Date D • -EN( L a g eJ e , Ft 3 c175 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(requirR E c I\ ® Date R R P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. EP2it 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR ASST Mailing Address ACC -°--• t 6 age 1 of 1 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 33400000363 1 Site Adr. 431 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address MILLS, PEGGY L PO BOX 835 City LABELLE State FL Zip 33975 Map No. j Strap No. j Section 1 Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7806 I 302200 431 7B06 6 1 52 26 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 431 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 1302200 400- LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo j School I Other Total (CONDOMINIUM � i l _. Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not ail Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) _1111 Date Book Page Amount I Land Value $0 09/07/12 48354726 $ 317,000 I (+)Improved Value ( $244,631 07/16/01 2860-1273 I $0 (=) Market Value I $244,631 01/12/01 2764-3352 $0.1 _1111. . . 11/20/00 j 2745-1819 I $255,000 1 "SOH* other Exempt. $0 10/20/00 ( 2734-2484 I $245,000 (=)Assessed Value I $244,631 05/09/00 j 2673-1373 I $0 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. I $01 01/26/98 I 2383-44 I $0 1 111.1 1 (_)Taxable Value _. j $244,6311 11/08/96 I 2249-157 j $ 3,015,500 1 (=) School Taxable Value $244,6311 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Pb A . 4 1 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13 i County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7J29�./2013(date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition articular issue one time. An individual may only sign this petition on this p "It is unlawful for any To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, person pe time. Any rson to knowingly sign a petition or petitions conv ct ona be guilty of atmasd meanor of the first violating the provisions of this section shall, upon de ree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) 9 To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: County Commissioners establish the La The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of Co y Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). Peninsula is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair paid for by special assessment It is Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These imp imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed mou amount to meet the residential co ti of said and a the collected on the Collier County tax bi{l in sufficient proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance aid off. by the MSBU, maintenance would 1 prop MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project hal will be det the cost upon the b ne citing propertY owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. public After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes omen d Department shall be can advertised dEach affected property hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed U S mail. owner shall be notified of the public hearing by The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board on Cou to County yrCommissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement p Prrnnnr*it Address 324. Folio#545nn880002 �� ( 3 1. 3 e u S (-A'�tr� i_.. - - �-" _ Date Print Name ignature(required) 4r1 0 If5-f--v. Ave, "J , le.t Pt— 3 I- I 1 C' Mailing Address pl 2. 1•A ich.cvl 1-e_ _ , rr- ',1 ... 4... Date Print Name Signature(requi =,,) 41? 0 15.w S vv N0- lrl -a 3= I i , Mailing Address Y It 3. Print Name Signature(required) Date SEPi02013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC tr:\-, Page 1 oel Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No 1 54500680002 Site Adr. 1 324 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address HERRERA,JESUS=&MICHELLE 324 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES 1 State I FL J Zip 134113-4037 Map No II Strap N_o. � Section II Township I Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7806 453400 3247606 6 ) 52 26 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 324 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School Other Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM ( 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value $01 11/20/06 I 4141-38 0 2 $495,00 i (+)Improved Value I $269,6311 05/28/99 2552-1188 i $220,000 (=) Market Value ( $269,631 05/18/92 I 1716-1391, j $ 217,500 04/01/87 1260-226 � $ 170,000 I (-}SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $269,631 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $269,6311 (=) School Taxable Value $ 269,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coll ierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Sar, 44 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-054 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7129/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition,"It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting 1 property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 331, Folio#54500720001 1. Zwrici moR/077- eaez i-1 1-7/ays Print1 Name Signature(required) Date 706 & X/id OZ 44 cll✓l- //;; ailing Address 2. IINET Mai&'orr �,f e . 9-1l-A013 Print Name Signatur (required) Date -7o106 J4LA N PUler JJi6LJ/V 01 46048A., Mailing Address KECEIVED 3' R & P MANAGFJVIFNT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 16 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST Ann Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 54500720001 Site Adr. 331 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address MARRIOTT, LARRY C=&JANET L 7068 CALABRIA PL ► City DUBUN I State J OH Zip 143016-6107 Map No Strap No 1 Section ; Township i Range 1 Acres *Acreage I 7B06 453400 3317B06 ; 6 52 ; 26 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 331 Miliage Area 0 191 Millage Rates o *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM ! School 1 Other _ Total Use Code 014 CONDOMINIUM 5.69 i 6.7427 12.4327 I 1 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) j .. Date 1 Book-Page j Amount I i Land Value $01 12/30/11 1 4755-1325 $230,000 (+)Improved Value $244,631 $0 03/22/96 j 2161-1066 f �. (=) Market Value $244,631 01/01/90 1497-971 I $0 10/01/86 j 1225-2232 j $ 145,000 (`) SOH*&other Exempt. I $0 (=)Assessed Value 1 $244,631 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 244,6311 (=) School Taxable Value j $ 244,631; If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 t 6 , . A 71 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-055 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon C.Lnt- appro - . Property Address 332, Folio#54500760003 g/Ciffritth 1. �/I/ 4 Dat'Ed ( , �� /_ /i Print Name Signatu = (r, ed) /Oat &au' sNiAev 8/) '. fJapk5 1 / 3W/3 Mailing Address 1 2. Print Name Signature(required) RE NE Date Mailing Address R & P MANAG EMEMT 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR ASST_ -- Mailing Address ACC r gabi 1 oft • Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 54500760003 , Site Adr. 1332 LA PENINSULA BLVD ....................._ . ..................._. _... ..... Name/Address VANDEELEN, HENRY R=&JANICE E 332 LA PENINSULA BLVD UNIT 332 City I NAPLES State I FL Zip 134113-4037 Map No Strap No I Section ! Township I Range I Acres *Acreage J 7B06 453400 332 7606 6 I 52 I 26 I 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 332 Millage Area tit 91 ( Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM ! School I Other 1 Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 f 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount ; ' Land Value I $p 05/19/00 I 2677-2060 I $266,000 � I Improved Value (+) m p _ _ $276.2501.1 09/19/86 I 1215-1966 I $173,000 (_) Market Value $276,2501 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $01 (=)Assessed Value $276,250 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 j (=)Taxable Value $226,2501 1 (=) School Taxable Value $251,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 ' 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-056 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners, hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 333, Folio#54500800002 1. yo ng. 5 c 7/,f7/2 o/3 Print Name Signature(require.) Date C q- 1 ,�s C arv�a�-, gpant' 0ar1c, MI Li- 8 3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) Date E I\ /E® Mailing Address K & P MANAGEMENT 3. EP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASS I ACC 6 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser ........................... Property Summary Parcel No. 154500800002 1 Site Adr. 1333 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address CHUNG,YONG S=&M ELISA RIEW 1564 KINGS CARRIAGE RD ....................... .............. City 1 GRAND BLANC State 1 MI Zip 148439-8628 Map No Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7606 453400 3337806 i 6 1 52 26 I 0 Legal LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 333 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School 1 Other 1 Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12A327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page ' Amount 1 I Land Value i $p 07/23/02 3077-2624 $ 365,000 1 ` CO Improved Value $276,250 0 06/01/87 1274-445 ; $ 195,000 1 $ 276,250 09/01/86 j 1218-2397 $ 173,000 ' (=) Market Value f 1 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 1 (=)Assessed Value F $ 276,250 (-) Homestead&other Exempt, 1 $0 (=)Taxable Value $276,2501 (=) School Taxable Value $ 276,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-057 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax .bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 334, Folio#54500840004 Print Name Signature(require Date Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(requir D to Mailing Address y '! 3. .:.. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 1 8 ?013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC r 6 ii e1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 54500840004 ! Site Adr. 1 334 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address TAYLOR,TODD N=&STACEY L 334 LA PENINSULA BLVD UNIT 334 City NAPLES ; State(FL I Zip 134113-4037 Map No Strap No I Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3347B06 6 1 52 i 26 I 0 Legal (LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 334 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School 1 Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value $01 05/04/05 J 3790-972 $ 625,500 i p (+)Improved Value $244,631 05/04/05 3790-964 $0 , 07/26/04 3612-3334 0 i (=) Market Value $244,631 i (-)SOH*&other Exempt. i $ 12,288 09/01/86 f 1218-2401 $ 165,000 1 _ (=)Assessed Value $232,343 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. 1 $50,000 (=)Taxable Value $ 182,343; (=) School Taxable Value $207,343; If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-058 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on_ 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 341, Folio#54500880006 1. Jai?tsnJc ► LQA1 R • Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(requir CEN I D Date R & PMCa ANAGEM Mailing Address �P f 2��3 3. Print Name Signature(require%G Date ASST Mailing Address ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary 1 Parcel No 54500880006 Site Adr. 1341 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address WATERS,FRANCIS J=&ERIKA J 341 LA PENINSULA BLVD UNIT 341 City INAPLES State 1FL Zip 134113 Map No Strap No Section j Township Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3417B06 6 52 26 1 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 341 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School Other J Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 j 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I Land Value $0 • 10/08/10 4616-2582 $236,000 (+)Improved Value $249,631 07/26/01 2866-346 J $ 155,000 (=) Market Value $ 249,631 08/11/94 I 1975-1928 $ 155,000 08/01/89 1460-1665 I $ 190,000 (") SOH*&other Exempt. $ 12,203 01/01/87 1246-528 $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 237,428 • 10/01/86 1225-2224 $ 155,000 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $50,0001• (=)Taxable Value $ 187,428! (=) School Taxable Value $212,4281 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A ' Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-060 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 312, Folio#54500480008 Print Name / Signature(requiredd)) Date 3 W //ac _ xl,/d/P7p/a' ( o6oS" Mailing Address Print Name / r ignature(required) Date //v/./ire xe/o,6h/ CIS- /60-RECEIVED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. Print Name Signature(required) aT 1 7 2013 Date MGR Mailing Address ASST ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 54500480008 Site Adr. 312 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DAQUILA,RONALD=&SHARON 38 WALLACE WAY i I City �MIDDLEFIELD State CT Zip 06455.1295 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range _ Acres *Acreage 7806 453400 3127606 6 52 26 0 Legal LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 312 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School Other Total Use Code 0 14- CONDOMINIUM ! 5.69 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount Land Value $0 06/05/07 4239-33 $450,000 (+)Improved Value $241,800 09/01/05 3881-1797 $0 06/23/04 3592-718 $300,000 (=) Market Value $241,800 09/12/94 1984-278 $ 155,000 ; (') SOH*&other Exempt. $0 10/01/91 1659-100], $0 (=)Assessed Value $241,800'. 02/01/87 1247-2332 $0 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 02/01/87 1247-233], $0 (_)Taxable Value $ 241,800' (=) School Taxable Value $ 241,800 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=LA+PENI... 9/27/2013 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-061 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 213, Folio#78545000241 1, IAA I --'INKi ts�. L 9,/ 6/ -.c� I Print Name Signature(required) Date \.\)-2x /y 0 i p As'L') /Y7 A 0 2-. 1.c f 7 MiaU ress 2. �-' A � , tiS�.�.c<, (\. Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address RE C I V 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 19 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC _... Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178545000241 1 Site Adr. 1 213 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address!ZAMMER TR, LINDA RAUB !WILLIAM ZAMMER JR TR LINDA ROUB ZAMMER REV TRUST I 1 I UTD 07/25/02 PO BOX 1709 City 1 MASHPEE State 1 MA Zip 102649-1709 Map No 1 Strap No i Section 1 Township ; Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 1 677800 2137806 i 6 1 52 I 26 1 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 213 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 677800 - 200 LA PENINSULA A School I Other Total 'CONDOMINIUM ; Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM i 5.69 i 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount Land Value $01 02/13/04 3501-2168 0 1 I (.0 Improved Value $343,0001 06/04/99 1 ,2555-438 ; $ 245,000 1 ( 04/01/89 1434-810 I $280,000 1 i _( _) Market Value $343,0001 12/01/87 1 1315-638 I $265,000 1 I (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $01 (=)Assessed Value 1 $ 343,0001 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value j $343,0001 (=)School Taxable Value 1 L _ $ 343,000 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 # A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-062 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition,it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 313, Folio#54500520007 1. �orcri- <o MN 5 i a i ^ ,o�s GG�dxl T/40//:3 Print Name Sig ature (required) Date a! 3 I t /7 Wors.1( N•i pc.g. ?4. '9jn3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required)R E f` tl Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP 16 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR SST Mailing Address a p(' F 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No 54500520007 Site Adr. 1313 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address JOHNSTON TR, ROBERT L ROBERT L JOHNSON TRUST UTD 12/4/05 1 313 LA PENINSULA BLVD City I NAPLES State 1 FL 1 Zip 34113-4036 Map No Strap No j Section I Township Range I. Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 453400 3137806 , 6 1 52 I 26 0 • Legal I LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 313 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School Other Total Use Code It 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 I Latest Sales History 201.3 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page ( Amount Land Value $0 • 05/19/06 1 4040-1367 $.0 (+)Improved Value $373,000 12/18/00 ( ,2755-1830 $425,000 1 (=) Market Value . $373,000 12/29/94 2015-2044 i $258,000 R ' (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $ 19,899 09/01/86 1235-1958. .1. ... $248,000 ; i (_)Assessed Value I $353,101; (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,5001 (=)Taxable Value $302,601 (=)School Taxable Value 1 $327,6011 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 t6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-063 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person • violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 321, Folio#54500560009 1.17/M0-4 tJAA15 .52.1)55nz- ?fr4,g Print Name Signature(required) Date °7( 2A `JLrut1451 i+4 QLo'u t N ?QL-ES , FL- 3sit 3 Mailing Address 2. irX 3 Print Name ,Signature(required) Date 3 I 447E'Nht.)Sid4't 3Luz/ Ny4a..,5 , Mailing Address 3. R CE 1 V E E Print Name Signature(required) P MANAGEMENT Date SEP D 9 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST arr Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. �54500560009 I Site Adr. 1 321 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address RUSSELL,T HANS=&JOAN H 321 LA PENINSULA BLVD City l NAPLES State �FL I Zip 1 34113-4037 Map No I Strap No Section 1 Township I Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 453400 3217B06 6 j 52 I 26 1 0 1 ... Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 321 Millage Area 0191 l Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub/Condo 1 453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM I School I Other I Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) IDate I Book-Page Amount I Land Value $OI 09/01/86 I 1219-11 I $150,000 I CO Improved Value $ 239,631 (=) Market Value $239,631 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $ 12,373 I (=)Assessed Value $227,258 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,0001i i i (=)Taxable Value I $ 177,2581 (=)School Taxable Value $202,2581 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 p.6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-064 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 322, Folio#5450060868 ) 1 D `°4=4,„c f - � �-��' j 9-/:s Print Name Signature( quired) Date /50 t � d Spay' 1 Y'i f l c r: Mt( c( Mailing Address Ira 2. / F L! A --S14 IP i E /A/ /ili, C21: )/lik_,Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address 9-�P C E 3. N R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 12 2013 Mailing Address MGR t\cr 'Page 1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 54500600008 I Site Adr. 1 322 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address GEURIN, RONNIE=&SHIRLIE 1500 SPRING HILL CT City MURRAY I State 'KY f Zip 142071-9382 Map No I Strap No Section I Township 1 Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3227806 j 6 I 52 j 26 I 0 Legal LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 322 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates O *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM 1 School Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM l 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page ) Amount I Land Value I $0 10/07/11 4728-1056 I $340,000 ! (+)Improved Value $271,250 07/31/00 2704-1344 I $80,900 _ (_)Market Value $271,250 11/01/94 I 1999-2048 I $225,000 06/01/88 I 1357-410 $0 1 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 10/01/86 3 1223-1233 $ 183,000 I i (=)Assessed Value $271,2501 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. j $01 (=)Taxable Value $ 271,2501 (=)School Taxable Value $271,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetai l.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 P A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-066 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The uiiuersig e—cf pe ilbriers-►'rerebvrequest--fiat the t3oard of county Commissioners establish the -La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 323, Folio#54500640000 Print Name Signature(requ red) D to cam' jgP wir 5.t,J i_ A t 7/ -r4 3'i//3 Mailing Address 2. • Print Name Signature(required)R E E I V E D Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP 16 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 54500640000 I Site Adr. 1 323 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address ANDERSEN TR, RICHARD H _ 1 1 RALPH REHKAMP '323 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES State 1 FL I Zip 34113-4037 Map No Strap No Section 1 Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 323 7B06 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal I LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 323 Millage Area 0191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations f Sub./Condo 453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM � School 1 Other Total Use Code 0 4- CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount Land Value 12/17/04 $0 2/17/04 1 3713-916 I $0 . _ (t)Improved Value $ 301,250 06/05/04 3580-3158 $ 585,000 01/10/01 2763-2167 $ 355,000 I- (=) Market Value $ 301,250 ... I (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 07/06/94 1964-2167 J $0 i 06/01/91 I 1626-26 $220,000 ( (_)Assessed Value $ 301,250 , 09/01/86 ( 1215-1962 I $170,000 , 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $50,000 j (=)Taxable Value $251,250 I (=)School Taxable Value $ 276,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-067 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/2912013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 433, Folio#33400000402 1. i\LL OUrLe ems' cry Print Name Signature(required) Date L( S G Ltv . ant c-cd., -t. 37 can Mailing Address 2. �%dr �. k 00 7,, Print Name Signature(required) Date r,A4re, L A/ LEr, /7-/C1 Mailing Address LCE I V> nn 3. R �rL & P MANArEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date S==; 1 1 2013 Mailing Address MGR ACC 6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No 1 33400000402 I Site Adr. 1 433 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address MOORE, CARL R=&ELLIOT G PO BOX 3028 City J BRISTOL 1 State ITN I Zip J 37625-3028 Map No 1 Strap No ( Section I Township J Range j Acres *Acreage 7606 I 302200 4337B06 I 6 ! 52 I 26 I 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 433 Millage Area 0 91 J Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200 -400 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School 1 Other I Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 l 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book Page Amount Land Value $0 09/26/00 2725-2531, I $280,000 I (+)Improved Value J $ 276,250 08/03/98 2447-776 ( $0 12/02/97 ! ,2367-2336 J $0 i I (=) Market Value I $276,250 12/02/97 2367-2290 J $0 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 11/08/96 2249-157 ) $3,015,500 G (=)Assessed Value J $276,250 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (_)Taxable Value $276,2501 E (=)School Taxable Value $ 276,2501 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=Ia+penins... 9/25/2013 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-068 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 434, Folio#33400000428 1' /1--1 3 rnmEt.A tiTi r��aa ate.. . Print Name Signature(required) Date a > w I A",�� b. �,.� , FL .3 ss Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address RECEIVED 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(require9EP 1 6 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR �cnnv PP"6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 133400000428 1 Site Adr. 1434 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address J HATTAWAY, GEORGE W=&PAMELA W 256 EAGLE DR City I DESTIN I State I FL I Zip 32550.4858 Map No Strap No 1 Section 1 Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 302200 4347B06 6 I 52 I 26 I 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 434 Mill;ge Area 0191 ( Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 302200 -400 LA PENINSULA A School ' Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 k. CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date � Book-Page Amount I Land Value $0 02/25/09 4431-351 $ 320,000 1 (+)Improved Value $244,631 10/02/07 4287-2886 $0 05/04/07 4224-1453 $0 1 (=)Market Value $244,631 ...07/29/05 3856-1162 ; $668,000 I (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 p 04/03/00 2658-1101 $280,000 1 (_)Assessed Value $244,631 12/29/97 2375-360 $0 � (-) Homestead&other Exempt, I $0 11/08/96 2249-157 $ 3,015,500 (=)Taxable Value ' $244,631 ! (=) School Taxable Value $244,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=`Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 P. 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-069 County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). it is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. it is understood-mat the aaa;y,,, ,,, �;, ^d�nr,..,rpiacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 441, Folin la//R I'/ //,, r7 / /1/-16// �` �t ski z�� / y/`l/2 a /3 Print Name Signature(requir ) Date `/�/l7 4 /'L/./ ii/.5"11.1/q /7,2 VD N/1!'/1J is • �Y/r Ma ing Address 2. RE� , Print Name Signature(required) E I !(r Date R & P MANAGEMENT :i Ic: nu'Mailing:Addressu;-: :o:::•�rfr ......... �..... ` i.�p., V 3. a t 2013 Print Name Signature(requiredJGR " Date ASST � "-� ACC Mailing Address Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 33400000444 Site Adr. 1441 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address HATTENBACH, HARRY A 441 LA PENINSULA BLVD City I NAPLES 1 State FL Zip 1 34113-4038 Map No I Strap No. Section j Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 { 302200 4417B06 I 6 i 52 26 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 441 Millage Area 0191 i Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200 -400 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School 1 Other I Total CONDOMINIUM J , Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 ( 12.4327 1 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount Land Value $0 06/04/01 2835-2278 $ 279,900 (+)Improved Value $249,631 06/04/01 212,500, 212 $2835-2275 I (=) Market Value $249,631 � 08/03/98 2447-774 $0 . _. 1 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $ 12,203 01/24/98 I 2383-243 I $0 01/26/98 I 2383-210 I. $0 (_)Assessed Value j $237,428 11/08/96 2249-157 I $3,015,500 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 1 (=)Taxable Value $187,428 (=) School Taxable Value , $212.428 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins.., 9/25/2013 • 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-073 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 421, Folio#33400000282 1. cti—G1 zAN Cac i2 :140 C ,Lc'L 11 i Print Name Signet (requi,-d) Date L1NV4 ,1 GOAD P. Go 6s \— o c. ) Mailing Address 2. C�l� rtd k`. E LE l? Print Name Signature(required) Date L. Girt %. \ r < � Mailing Address 1 '1` 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature require i) 7? 16 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ASST ----- ACr. °-----�, 'a 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 33400000282 Site Adr. 421 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address CAPRI REAL ESTATE PROP LLC 80 LINVALE RD City RINGOES State N1 Zip 08551-1411 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 302200 421 7806 6 52 26 0 Legal 400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 421 Millage Area 0 i 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo '302200- 400 LA PENINSULA A School Other Total fCONDOMINIUM Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount Land Value $0 02/14/13 4886-3889 $ 309,000 ; (+)Improved Value $239,631; 03/07/05 3746-2912 $ 625,000 05/11/00 2674-3229 $219,000 (=) Market Value $239,631; 11/01/99 2606-3151 $0 : (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 08/30/99 2586-1469 $0 (_)Assessed Value $239,631 09/22/98 2463-3449 $0 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0' 07/08/98 2438-1646 $6,200 (=)Taxable Value $239,631 03/25/96 2162-50 $ 315,000 (=) School Taxable Value $ 239,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes°exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coll ierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=LA+PENI... 9/27/2013 • 6 A Electronic Articles of Organization L13000011316 FILED 8:00 AM For January 23 2013 Florida Limited Liability Company Sec. Or State stoner Article I The name of the Limited Liability Company is: CAPRI REAL ESTATE PROPERTIES LLC Article II The street address of the principal office of the Limited Liability Company is: 421 LA PENINSULA BLVD 421 NAPLES, FL. 34113 The mailing address of the Limited Liability Company is: 80 LINVALE ROAD RINGOES, NJ. 08551 Article III The purpose for which this Limited Liability Company is organized is: ANY AND ALL LAWFUL BUSINESS. ` Article IV The name and Florida street address of the registered agent is: CLAYTON KEELER 421 LA PENINISULA 421 NAPLES, FL. 34113 Having been named as registered agent and to accept service of process for the above stated limited liability company at the place designated in this certificate, I hereby accept the appointment as registered agent and agree to act in this capacity. I further agree to comply with the provisions of all statutes relating to the proper and complete perfomiance of my duties, and I am familiar with and accept the obligations of my position as registered agent. Registered Agent Signature: CLAYTON KEELER 6A Article V L13000011316 The name and address of managing members/managers are: FILED 8:00 January 23 2013 Title: MGRM Sec. Of State 20 CLAYTON KEELER stoner 80 LINVALE ROAD RINGOES, NJ. 08551 Article VI The effective date for this Limited Liability Company shall be: 01/21/2013 Signature of member or an authorized representative of a member Electronic Signature; CLAYTON KEELER I am the member or authorized representative submitting these Articles of Organization and affirm that the facts stated herein are true. I am aware that false information submitted in a document to the Department of State constitutes a third degree felony as provided for in s.817.155, F.S. I understand the requirement to file an annual report between January 1st and May 1st in the calendar year following formation of the LLC and every year thereafter to maintain"active" status. 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-074 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 422, Folio#33400000305 1. .,61/oltj , �"C / ,� aeiht)/4ae/ ed--/ocar3 Print Name Signature(required) Date '&o2 P4/0/.i) s Ut4 ALt/2, l//4 391/3 Mailing Address 2. RECEIVED Print Name Signature(required) Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP 0 9 2013 Print Name Signature(required)MGR Date ASST Mailing Address Cr Page loft Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary iParcel No. 133400000305 Site Adr. 422 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address MEHL, DEVON B 422 LA PENINSULA BLVD#422 City NAPLES State I FL I Zip 34113-4038 Map No. Strap No. Section 1 Township 1 Range I Acres !Acreage 7B06 302200 422 7B06 6 52 j 26 I 0 I Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 422 Millage Area 0 191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1302200 -400 LA PENINSULA A 1 School Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 i 6.7427 1 12.4327 1 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value $01 05/29/13 4928-2867 $0 I CO Improved Value I $271,250 11/08/02 3156-321 $0 r 1 (=) Market Value $271,2501 08/04/00 2706-2212 $ 265,000 other Exempt. 08/03/98 2447-771, $0 1 (-)SOH*& $01 12/02/97 j 2367-2336 $0 1 (=)Assessed Value $271,2501 i 12/02/97 2367-2290 $0 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. j $ 50.000 11/08/96 249-157 I $ 3,015,500 I 1 (=)Taxable Value $221 2501 . (=) School Taxable Value $246,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=°Save Our Homes exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiseneom/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 t. A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-075 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall'at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 423, Folio#33400000321 Fv'e- Print Nanp ignatur (requi ed) Date 112 - �� /3 .. , 3 /�...3 � Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(req IVE ED Date Mailing Address & P MANAGEMENT 3. S .P192013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASST ACC 6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 33400000321 Site Adr. 1423 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address !JONES TR, EVELYN EVELYN F JONES LIVING TRUST UTD 10/15/99 423 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES State 1 FL ( Zip 134113-4038 Map No Strap No Section 1 Township I Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 302200 423 7B06 6 i 52 26 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 423 I JVlillage Area 0191 f Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200 - 400 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo l School I Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM 1.._ Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 I _ 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page 1 Amount Land Value $0 10/15/03 3422-1772 1 $0 1 1__ (+)Improved Value 1 _ $271,250 11/15/96 I 2251-360 $318,000 (=) Market Value $271,250 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $271,250 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. I $ 100,500 (=)Taxable Value $170,7501 ' (=) School Taxable Value $245,7501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 i• Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-077 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. it is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 406, Folio#33400000127 1. JidrtfleAS Sk1 ( UI) (aRKI>� 910 )3 Print Name Signature(required) Date 1c) LA -p U J D LA, N 1\P L, F[.r.. 3411P Mailing Address CY)Cir Mal nu 1"6- ortounaillt64.4 ) 11 16 Print Name Signature(required) Date Address RE C IVE Mailing 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 6 2013 Date Mailing Address MCA ASST _ . ACC Page .6 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 133400000127 1 Site Adr. 1406 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address SMITH,JAMES B ... ....................._...._._...... 406 LA PENINSULA BLVD ................... i.. City NAPLES 1 i 1 FL Zip 134113-4038 ......_._..._............. Map No. Strap No. I Section I Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 ' 302200 4067B06 I 6 I 52 26 I 0 1 I Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 406 , Mill•ge Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 302200 -400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School Otiter I Total Use Code 0 14-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount 1 I Land Value $0� 03/01/10 4542-2080 $ 500,000 1 (+)Improved Value $323,950 06/29/01 2850-3328 1 $420,000 I I 05/30/00 I 2680-1917 I $ 360,000 I (=)Market Value $ 323 950 08/09/96 2215-1933 1 $0 1 1 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. 1 $0J 08/09/96 2215-1920 ) $370,00.0 I f (=)Assessed Value $ 323,950 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 1 (=)Taxable Value $273,9501 (=) School Taxable Value j $298,950 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment Increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-078 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 407, Folio#33400000143 1. Dor PM /IA v�rS 0(/.c). e X - (,�.�2,3 Print Name _ a Si; SI nature require D to tie +0 Oef..30(0 -P /troa2 CT > fpm,ee 6N, t-)4a q 442,. Q : A • ♦ , ,, Mailing Address •111, 2. /r ( � fled (14 v P./''S �\ � -0, . /d(/ Signet.re(required) l Date Print Name g i q ) x a4 aLifteie. RECEIVED Mailing Address 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 6 2013 Date Mailing Address MGII ASST ACC I f., Page 1 of 1 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary • Parcel No. 1 33400000143 I Site Adr. 407 LA PENINSULA BLVD i Name/Address HAVERS, FREDERICK A MARY DARLENE HAVERS 6 TORONTO ST, SUITE 1402 ' ' I Foreign Mall City, Province 1BARRIE, ON 1 Country I CANADA I L4N 9R2 i I ' Code Map No. I Strap No. 1 Section 1 Township 1 Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 302200 407 7B06 6 I 52 26 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 407 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200-400 LA PENINSULA A I Sub./Condo School 1 Other 1 Total 1CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 -CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Saks are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page 1 Amount I i Land Value $0 12/14/10 4634-437 $295,000 I 1 (+) Improved Value $ 259,631 03/31/08 4343-3772 $0 I I (r4)Market Value $ 259,631 12/11/03 3461-927 $418,000 02/07/01 2774-2735 $ 335,000 : (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $ 0 02/08/00 1 2638-3149 I ' $265,000 1 : (=)Assessed Value $ 259,631 01/26/98 2383-44 f $0 1 : (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 . 11/08/96 2249-157 $3,015,500 1 ' , (.)Taxable Value $259,631 ( (=) School Taxable Value $ 259,6311 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH.'Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-079 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 ,(date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 221, Folio#78545000267 /14 lei *i L t- 4 Print Name Signature(required Date l=lorta&: Z-2-I Lrt re4.11%.swi lvcit IJef i c.s )<'L 3 r 13 I I �) i 7'( f'va2Q/,/g�� / c//n (1/RHO Mailing Address 2. i1r: t*nn [rca Leaon �c�- 9/6 l3 Print Name �) ,Signature(requi ed) ate ��o-tl,�+.3 "t t'I 4 6a_rrt,t'{"rMt/�t L Dr, P�tcL1 �j1-� 4 S3 8 s< Mailing Address EC E IV E D R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP102013 Mailing Address MGR_ ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178545000267 I Site Adr. 1221 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address _ . LEACH, MICHAEL D=&ANDREA M 174 BARRINGTON VILLAGE DR City I BEAVERCRK TWP i State 10H I Zip 145385-9126 Map No. 1 Strap No. ; Section I Township ; Range 1 Acres *Acreaae 7806 I 677800 2217B06 i 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 221 Millage Area 0 191 J Millage Rates 0 *Calculations School 677800 - 200 LA PENINSULA A j 1 Sub/Condo Other Total CONDOMINIUM I Use Code 0 4 CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) } 1 $0 1 Date I Book-Page � Amount i Land Value 05/05/08 4356-3155 $460,000 (+)Improved Value I $239,6311 11 08/09/04 3622-2.307 $ 595,000 1 11 (=) Market Value i $239,6311 10/02/02 3121-1496 $ 330,000 12/05/87 1311-2169 1 $ 150,000 IL ")SOH*&other Exempt. i $0 (=)Assessed Value $239,6311 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value $239,6311 (=)School Taxable Value $239,6311 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes-exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins.,. 9/25/2013 6 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-080 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 204, Folio#78545000089 1. wtI(la 7- 013 /r �" 7, Print Name Signature(required) Date cio'l L.a !rlinsi,tla i)dd, Iap(es IL 3t/113 Mailing Address 2. p�F1�1 een O I i G+nS ,.e_AC..UL.t,--) L t.(CiLQJ 9.-7- .20)3 Print Name Signature(required) Date aoq/ La Pe inscil/, tSlvot-, PJ11 P!es FL Mil 3 RECEIVED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 1 1 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address AS ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178545000089 I Site Adr. 1204 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address i BRUNS,WILLIAM T=&KATHLEEN C 1204 LA PENINSULA BLVD 1 City!NAPLES State I FL Zip 134113-4034 Map No. I Strap No. Section Township Range i Acres *Acreage ; t 7606 1 677800 2047B06 1 6 I 52 26 1 0 Legal 1 200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 204 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations -200 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo 1677800 School 1 Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 14-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) .......... Date Book-Page Amount 1 , Land Value $0 12/20/07 4313-4128 , , $475,000 i (+)Improved Value j $259,631 03/19/04 1 3524-2251 ] $400,000 1 12/01/87 1313-1214 I $160,000 j (=) Market Value ' $ 259,631` I (-) SOW&other Exempt. $ 12,033' (=)Assessed Value $247,598 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. � $50,000 (=)Taxable Value $ 197,598 (=)School Taxable Value $222,5981 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins,.. 9/25/2013 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93-081 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 205, Folio#78545000102 1. r� LID 1-,„, P, be /t- Print Name 'Signature(required) r Date A 1��f �7 ) e.� (2 O 4 4- C: C':v (<L/a/ 5 0-4.r{{L e A) ?' 3 3 6 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) RE/'y Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR_ Mailing Address ASST ACC 6A Page 1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78545000102 1 Site Adr. 1 205 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address WEGERSKI, MARY A C/O JOHN P WEGERSKI JR 64 WEBER RD City CENTRAL SQUARE State 1 NY Zip 113036-2108 Map No Strap No � Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 677800 2057806 6 52 26 i 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 205 Millage Area 0191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 677800 -200 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School Other I Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount � Land Value I $0 01/23/02 I 2968-757 I $0 I (+)Improved Value ; $ 323,950 12/01/81 I 1314-688 I $226,000 1 I (=) Market Value $323,950 (-) SOH* &other Exempt. $0 I (=)Assessed Value I $323,9501 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. 1 $0 i l (=)Taxable Value $ 323,950 I (=)School Taxable Value $ 323,9501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.corn/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 ` 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-083 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 207, Folio#78545000128 _ , / , 1. / .44/4/4— ce4re/51-rt/c1:7----- - Print Name gnature(required) - Date Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(requires E CE!\/ ED Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP162013 Print Name Signature(requir — Date IVIUR ASST Mailing Address Are- r6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78545000128 1 Site Adr. 1207 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address FERNANDEZ,ALEXANDER C/O AFC GROUP P A 1001 BRICKELL BAY DRIVE 130TH FL i i City 1 MIAMI State j FL f Zip 133131 Map No. f Strap No. 1 Section ! Township j Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7806 I 677800 2077606 1 6 ■ 52 26 i 0 Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 207 Millage Area 0 191 ! Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 1677800 - 200 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount , Land Value $01 ( $255,000 { (+)Improved Value i $259,631 I 10/13/09 4503-2084 $ 100 (=) Market Value II $259,631 04/04/02 3013-476 $285,000 1 , 12/01/87 I 1314-696 I $ 175,000 1 , (-)SOH*&other Exempt. I $01 (=)Assessed Value $259,6311 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $259,631 (=)School Taxable Value $259,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to capon assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail,htm1?Fu11Address=la+penins... 9/25/2013 • Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 084 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 305, Folio#54500200000 1. Qd LL-1 eittA C7 6 6 L /d-vtve_s_ IN 3 Print Name Signature(required) Date 3 05 LA ■ i`-4.1 , 10PDES I re_ X411 .3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature( RE c E IVED Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 1 0 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR ASST �. Mailing Address ACC �. 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 54500200000 Site Adr. 1 305 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address INGOGLIA,IGNATIUS=&ANNETTE 305 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES State FL i Zip 134113-4036 Map No 1 Strap No I Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3057B06 6 52 26 I 0 Legal I LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 305 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School I Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 j 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page j Amount i t Land Value $0 11/06/01 ( 2920-353 $0 I (+)Improved Value $ 323,950 06/09/99 2556-2483 i.._ $ 310,000 (=) Market Value $ 323,950 ...11/01/86 1...1229-2318 1 $222,000 I 1 (")SOH*&other Exempt. 1 _ $0 (=)Assessed Value J $ 323,950 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 i (=)Taxable Value $273,9501 (=)School Taxable Value $298,9501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 � 6 « Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-085 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 306, Folio#54500240002 Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address 2. -r-1-0 ( '77,/-7'9 Print Name ,� Signature(required) Date 44- Pvi���S u (q 61 v vV` `ems 3. Mailing Address RECEIVED Print Name Signature(required) R & P MANAGEMENTDate SEP 12 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC p 6 i,,, 1 Page 1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 154500240002 54500240002 I Site Adr. 1 306 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address NED B HORNBACK DEC OF TRUST 306 LA PENINSULA BLVD 4f City NAPLES State FL Zip 34113-4036 Map No i Strap No ( Section Township ; Range j Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3067B06 6 52 26 1 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 306 Millage Area 0 191 i Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM ( School 1 Other I Total Use Code O 4-CONDOMINIUM j 5.69 1 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date ( Book-Page I ._ Amount Land Value $0 i 202 04/11/11 4678-2029 $0 ... __. i (+)Improved Value $323,950 f_ _06/24/08 4372-4158 I $0 ff (_) Market Value $323,9501 09/01/86 1217-2X17 I $222,000 * p (-)SOH &other Exempt. $01 (=)Assessed Value $ 323,950 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 1 (=)Taxable Value $273,950' ' (=)School Taxable Value $298,950E If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll `SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-086 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 307, Folio#54500280004 1. Ni„. ?-1-,0 Print Name - SI nature(required) Date 7.3 / 7 a . ld• 7k —141.gnr' e610, ga h7) Mailing Address 2. `n CARry /l 9- 7- a 013 Print Name nature(require Date vi • .'• , -- 4 4 001'' _1 76 _ b1 Mailing Address V j' 3. R & PMANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) 00 09 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC 6 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 54500280004 I Site Adr. 1 307 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address CAREY TR, NICHOLAS G NICHOLAS G CAREY REV TRUST 'JESSIE M CAREY TR JESSIE M CAREY REV TRUST 1 307 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES � State 1 FL € Zip 134113-4036 7806 453400 3077606 Section � Township i Range 1 Acres *Acreage Map No. Strap No. _... p 1 P • ! 6 i 52 f 26 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 307 Millage Area 0 191 f Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM 1 School j Other Total �.._..... Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date J Book-Page J Amount i i Land Value $0 06/10/04 3583-3896 J $570,000 1 (+)Improved Value ! $259,6311 05/02/03 J 3281-527 J $ 360,000 1 i . . 09/01/86 J 1219-1973 01 ; (=) Market Value $ 259,631 09/01/86 f 1219-1964 $ 160,000 J (-)SOW&other Exempt. $01 (=)Assessed Value $259,631 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value $ 259,6311 (=) School Taxable Value I $259,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 087 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners harahu request that the Bnard of Cnunty ('.AmiecinnAr ee4 lioh 1h,. 1 • Peninsula Seawall Repalrn eprdudi1101111vIu1!MVO, ■7G1 VIVG0 UO11a netit m111 v1bUIU(ktse V iii vi Svlotiw. It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 308, Folio#54500320003 CS? Print Name / [ / Signature(required) / /( Date 30X GA f /!Y s(� L 14 /3Z, )r V i)r L, = �j r� r 3�-1 // 3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) RECEIVED— Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP092019 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR,_ ____._ .--- -°--�" Mailing Address ACC t 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 54500320003 I Site Adr. 1 308 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address COLETTA TR,JOSEPH JOSEPH COLETTA LIVING TRUST UTD 10/9/06 308 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES State I FL I Zip 134113-4036 Map No I Strap No Section I Township ( Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 453400 3087606 1 6 52 1 26 1 0 Legal ILA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 308 Millage Area 0191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM 1 School I Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date ( Book-Page Amount ' 1 Land Value $0 10/12/06 4121-177 $0 _. . -- - 1 (+)Improved Value $ 323,000 06/12/00 2685-867 j $ 353,000 I (=) Market Value $ 323,000 05/14/97 2313-1404 I $0 1 i 05/14/97 2313-1401 $0 11 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 09/01/86 I 1219-1853 $232,000 , (_)Assessed Value $ 323,000 I (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $50,000 j 1 (=)Taxable Value $273,0001 (=) School Taxable Value $298,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-088 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 309, Folio#54500360005 c 1. C et d I11 ii G%�� . i, � ,�t 2t9/2 Print Nam Signature(required) Date 309 L P ,'nstilg t/yeg Fi. 3)11/3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address IREc;E 1\/E 3. D Its R $ P MANAGFMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP092013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC II, 6 A Page l of l Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 154500360005 54500360005 1 Site Adr. 309 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address WITTERN,CARL H { (KUCHELWEG lA { I Country 1 GERMANY 1 City 1HAMBURG Foreign`adie D22605 Map No, I Strap No Section f Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7606 453400 3097B06 6 � 52 I 26 1 I 0 Legal I LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 309 Miliage Area Oa 91 ` Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1 453400- LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM School ' Other Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date i Book-Page j Amount J Land Value $0 03/21/91 1600-1952 j $ 175,000 ` i (+)Improved Value $223,8001 09/01/86 1219-7 $ 179,000 I (_) Market Value $223,800 � (-) SOH*&other Exempt. 3 $ 01 (=)Assessed Value f $223,800' (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 � (=)Taxable Value $223,8001 1 (=)School Taxable Value $223,8001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www,collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FuliAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-089 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. 11� It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 310, Folio#54500400004 1. 3- 0 t+7 w, cal IaHat-, /,'; ' Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required)RE RECEINIED Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address r, 3. 1 1 2013 Print Name Signature(requlred)MGR Date /ASST ACC ----- Mailing Address ____ — 3. 6 1,=. Page 1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. (54500400004 I Site Adr. 310 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address I CALLAHAN, ROBERT C=&JULIA W 126 WELLINGTON ST City BRISTOL i State ITN Zip 37620-2946 Map No Strap No Section ! Township ! Range , Acres *Acreage 7B06 453400 3107B06 6 52 26 j 0 Legal I LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 310 Millage Area.0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations i Sub./Condo 453400 - LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM i School I Other I Total f Use Code O 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 ) Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page ( Amount ' Land Value 1 $0 09/15/98 2461-1433 ( $225,000 i (+)Improved Value I $228,800 09/01/86 1219-3 I $179,000 (=) Market Value $228,800 1 ( ) SOH*&other Exempt. j $0 i (=)Assessed Value $228,800 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. , $0 (=)Taxable Value $228,800 I (=) School Taxable Value $228,800 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/R ecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 • 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 090 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 408, Folio#33400000169 1. -TO Me--‘1J'k 9// q/2_0 Print Name ignature(required) Date 6 Ni e . �-�. L GQe�r CF' (l. 3 3 3 0 g' Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) RECEIVEs ate Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 1 7 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ACC l 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 33400000169 I Site Adr. 408 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address � MELVIN,JOAN B 4206 NE 22ND AVE City I FORT LAUDERDALE State I FL I Zip 33308-5628 Map No. I Strap No. i Section 1 Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 302200 4087B06 6 I 52 I 26 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 408 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 302200 -400 LA PENINSULA A School Other i Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page i Amount Land Value $0 07/15/96 I 2205-2382 i $395,000 (+)Improved Value ( $ 323,950 E (=) Market Value $ 323,950 1 (-) SOW&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $323,9501 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $01 1 (=)Taxable Value $323,950 (=)School Taxable Value I $323,950 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment Increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 093 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 101, Folio#64660040006 1. 4 AA,A,`l '�• ��� � cl j(o l 13 Print Name Signature( qulred) Date 10 I L-e, Qr.N�wt�1� !`�lu i• IVcip(ei FL ?`( ( 1'3 Mailing Address 2. -)“Sa (ASy q�/D 3 Print Name / Signature(required) Date ZAd ear 1Pd Pat/65'i / Mailing Address R 6/ED 3. R & P MANA(FME IT Print Name Signature(required) Date >�-h I 6 2013 Mailing Address MGR Assf — --�-- ACC I 6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660040006 !, Site Adr. ;101 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DOCKERY,TIM 101 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES State FL Zip 34113-4032 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 J 5284001017806 6 52 26 0 __ Legal 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 101 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 528400- 100 LA PENINSULA A School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM ; 5.69 I 6.7427 ' 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount Land Value $0 03/26/10 4555-2519 $ 378,000 (+)Improved Value $ 343,000 07/26/00 2702-2478 $ 300,000 (=) Market Value $ 343,000 03/18/98 2399-1978 $ 219,900 01/06/98 i 2377-7 383 $0 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 05/21/97 ,2315-2019 $100 (=)Assessed Value $343,000; 09/15/95 2099-2219 $250,000 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $ 50,000 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 (_)Taxable Value $293,000 (=) School Taxable Value $ 318,000! If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coll ierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=LA+PENI... 9/27/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-094 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). it is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 102, Folio#64660080008 r g jl Print Name ._.-_.__._Slgnat re(required) Date 5 CfteLC. SL:c1I-.„ -r4 . 196o Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(require ECE1VED Date R & P MANAG MENT Mailing Address 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(require 3 Date ASST Mailing Address Page loll Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660080008 1 Site Adr. 1102 LA PENINSULA BLVD 1 i 1 Name/Address 1PILAT, STANLEY=&BONNIE ; 11 CREEK CT . . . . . . : .• City 1SHILLINGTON . ; State PA .' : Zip 119607-9554 1 . Map No. 1 Strap No. 1 Section 1 Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 1 ; 71306 1 528400 102 71306 1 6 . 52 1 26 ! 0 .• Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 102 . , . . i Millage Area 0191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub/Condo 1528400 - 100 LA CONDOMINIUM PENINSULA A 1 i School 1 Other Total 1 1 1 Use Code 014 - CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6,7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Saks are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) , . . ; Date Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value . : $01 • . i 12/14/12 4866-1297 $219,900 (+)Improved Value 1 $241,800 02/09/12 4766-2899 $ 100 (=) Market Value $241,800 02/24/10 4544-818 $ 100 • • • . , ' ..----.. . . .. . . .. . , (••) SOW&other Exempt. $01 09/17/03. 2893-2612 $285,000 I . . . 1 09/20/99 , 2593-1116 $202,500 1 (=)Assessed Value j $241,8001 09/01/87 ! 1292-1708 $ 185,000 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. , $0 (=)Taxable Value 1 $241,800 (=) School Taxable Value 1 $241,800 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. frap:HWWW.collierappraisencom/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 • Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93-099 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 541, Folio#324550 0322 1 I Ir1&recce,,& ` ?U q3 PrintAName Signatur (required) Date lvevietopr younr/bidii 9 /Mailing Address I 2. Print Name Signature(require E V E I V ID Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 16 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address AcBT ACC 6 gi,; ,, Page 1 of l Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 132455000322 1 Site Adr. 1541 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address FERIN,ANDREA 421 RIVERVIEW DR City YOUNGSTOWN State 1 NY Zip 114174-1376 Map No Strap No Section f Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7806 295600 5417B06 6 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 541 Millage Area 0 191 1 Jllliilage Rates 0 *Calculations ' 1295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo C School Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 6.7427 I_ 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I Land Value $01 10/13/09 4500-2887, I $325,000 (+)Improved Value 1 $249,6311 11/30/05 3938-1947 I $ 595,000 i 1 (=) Market Value $249,631 10/27/04 L3668-467 $530,000 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 10/27/99 2605-1794 $255,000 1 10/15/88 1387-1946 $ 195,000 I i (=)Assessed Value i $249,631 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $249,6311 1 (=)School Taxable Value $249,6311 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 100 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 542, Folio#32455000348 1. .494,0,44k0 vi,A3 Print Name �' n /Si•nature(required) / /Date Mailing Address CGL ( ce}q./1 I. me 1 Per? (7.0 e4--ems viroop��f Print Name Signature(required) Da ?3 did L Lc & t'- It . . . Mailing Address T 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) , 1 Date 0 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST Acc Page -o Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 32455000348 1 Site Adr. I 542 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address PROCACCIO TR,ANTHONY R LURITA PROCACCIO TR PROCACCIO LIVING TRUST UTD 5/10/06 8824 ROYAL SWAN LN City DARIEN State I IL I Zip 160561-8431 Map No. I Strap No. Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 71306 295600 5427806 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 542 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo i 295600- 500 LA PENINSULA A School 1 Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code O.14- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 I Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I Land Value $0 01/22/07 4172-222 $0 t(1-)Improved Value 1 $281,250 03/01/04 3510-1791 I $435,000 (=) Market Value $ 281,250 05/30/97 ,2318-601 $ 319,000 f 05/30/97 2318-595 I $0 OSOH*&other Exempt. $0 09/01/96 I 2215-2033 I $ 395,000 (=)Assessed Value $281,250 12/21/94 2013-1539 I $0 I I (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $01 I (=)Taxable Value $281,2501 (m)School Taxable Value 1 $281,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll ''SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. ht tp://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-101 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 543, Folio#32455000364 _ l© a Print Name ignat re(required) Date 3 ki iRe c Nsuc14- 8 IUAAL s 3 L( r ( 2 Mailing Address t n Print Name Signature(required) Date 51,3 t, en )n orALCD1,vD. t 1 ► Mailing Address � �® 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 6 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR_ ASST ACC 6 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 32455000364 1 Site Adr. 543 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address CRAIN,JAMES R=&SUSAN K 543 LA PENINSULA BLVD + I City NAPLES State I FL Zip 134113-4011 Map No Strap No 1 Section j Township I Range I Acres *Acreage I 7B06 295600 5437B06 6 I 52 26 1 0 Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 543 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo - 500 LA PENINSULA A School ! Other Total 1295600 CONDOMINIUM i i Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 R Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book Page I Amount Land Value $0 1 05/04/95 l 2055-2024 I $208,300 I (+)Improved Value $281,250 12/21/94 I ,2013-1539 I. . $0 ) i _ 1 (_) Market Value $281,250 (-)SOW&other Exempt. $4,128 (=)Assessed Value $277,122 (-) Homestead&other Exempt, j $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value J $227,122 (=)School Taxable Value $252,122 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SON='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?PullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 46 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-102 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on_ 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 544, Folio#32455000380 1. o .e .T CJA i k X-41-241 9ifr63 Print Name Signature(required) Date s�<</ L 4 //3.--4/74/si 41 t z /k99/ / , a U`))3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) RECEIVED Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP 2 3 2013 Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date ASST Mailing Address ACC \_. ..!. 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 32455000380 I Site Adr. 1 544 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address CARLETON, ROBERT H 544 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES 1 State 1 FL I Zip 134113-4011 Map No 1 Strap No 1 Section 1 Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7606 1 295600 5447B06 I 6 1 52 1 26 I 0 Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 544 Millage Area 0 191 } Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 295600- 500 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo CONDOMINIUM 1 School 1 Other Total Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 ( 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount I Land Value $0 08/20/02 3093-2283 1 $0 [ CO Improved Value $ 351,000 02/11/99 2511-2861 $415,000 (=) Market Value $351,000 07/31/96 I 2211-2234 $375,000 05/01/94 1 1948-2140 $340,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 09/01/88 1381-1308 $400,000 (_)Assessed Value $ 351,000 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value 1 $301,0001 (_) School Taxable Value $ 326,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *50H=`Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?Full Address=la+penins... 9/25/2013 �� 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 103 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 523, Folio#32455000209 1, '�'' �fttYl��. f� r%C _ C l = r l /13-k, . Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address / . ' / 2. Print Name Sig ature(required) bate Mailing Address / Ec 3. I R & P MANAGEMENT, Print Name Signature(required) c:' 162013 Mailing Address MGR ASST Arr. ', fr 6 iii\, Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary 1 Parcel No. 132455000209 1 Site Adr. 1523 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DOHER, ROBERT G=&ANNE H 523 LA PENINSULA BLVD#523 City 1 NAPLES ) State I FL 1 Zip 34113 Map No I Strap No I Section 1 Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7606 1 295600 523 7606 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 523 Millage Area 0191 1Vlillage Rates 0 *Calculations 295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School 1 Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page Amount I Land Value 1 $0 1 12/20/12 I 4877-1309 $ 250,000 I (+)Improved Value $ 271,2501 08/31/12 4832-1162 $ 176,000 (=) Market Value $ 271,250 05/04/06 I 4030-2706 $ 500,000 1 09/28/05 I 3899-677 $400,000 1 (')SOH*&other Exempt. $0 06/26/95 i ,2072-1650 $ 335,000 (=)Assessed Value $271,250 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 j (.) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 1 (=)Taxable Value I $271,250 (=)School Taxable Value , $271,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 104 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 524, Folio#32455000225 1. Aja/ler 2! e 0/26/3 Print Name Signature(required) Date 2. Mailing Address,` Print Name Signature(required) Date /74p4(5. /. . D,4,,77( gym/ '/7 Mailing Address CEIVED 3' R & P MANAGFMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date I62013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC ., ,. , „.... pi. 6i.;,\ ficl Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 32455000225 1 Site Adr.1524 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DUFRESNE,GERALD=&NANCY A 1162 HEIGHTS RD City LAKE ORION State MI Zip 148362-2422 Map No. 1 Strap No. Section Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 295600 5247B06 6 1 52 26 0 Legal 1500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 524 Mil lage Area 0 191 Mi llage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 - CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I Land Value $0 09/19/11 4720-1146 $ 300,000 (+)Improved Value $ 341,000 06/29/11 I 4698-370 1 $0 1 1 (=) Market Value $ 341,000 05/05/95 2056-461 $ 340,000 ; 12/21/94 2013-1539 I $r 0 I ( H*)SO &other Exempt. I $0 (=)Assessed Value $341,000 1 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $01 1 (=)Taxable Value $341,0001 (=) School Taxable Value $341,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser,com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-105 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7129/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 531, Folio#32455000241 1. it:4,161\ .561/ ene.(---c,A Rrint K 46/e -I , �g/turej(bquira)a 1 1�3 l J� �Q�1es iL 3 cii4 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(requirecE w El' !E D Date Mailing Address K & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 1 0 2013 • Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR — Mailing Address ASST, - ACC A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 132455000241 I' Site Adr.1531 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address SHADOW RIDGE PROPERTIES LLC 300 STAMFORD PL STE 201 City STAMFORD State I CT Zip 106902-6733 ; Map No. 1 Strap No. Section I Township 1 Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 295600 53171306 6 52 26 1 0 , Legal 1500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 531 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1295600 - 500 MINIUM 1 LA PENINSULA A School 1 Other Total CONDO Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page 1 Amount 1 Land Value $0 04/25/11 I 4675-1265 1 $0 1 +)Improved Value $244,631 06/07/10 1 4578-722 1 $14,400 1 (=) Market Value $244,631 12/27/88 I 1403-1260 I $175,000 1 I (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 ■ 1 (=)Assessed Value $244,631 -) Homestead&other Exempt. 1 $0 (=)Taxable Value $244,6311 1 1 (=) School Taxable Value $244,6311 ) If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=°Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraisencom/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 ' 0 6 , *** INSTR 4553349 OR 4675 PG 1265 RECORDED 4/26/2011 12:32 PM PAGES 1 *** DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA A DOC @.70 $0.70 REC $10.00 CONS $0.00 I THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY AND RETURN TO: Shadow Ridge Properties,LLC 300 First Stanford Place,Suite 201 Stamford,CT 06902 Parcel ID Number:32455000241 SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE FOR RECORDING DATA This WARRANTY DEED,made this 25th day of April,2011,by JACK E.ROBINSON,a single man,whose address is 1344 Monarch Circle,Naples,FL 34116,hereinafter called the Grantor,to SHADOW RIDGE PROPERTIES,LLC,a Delaware limited liability company authorized to transact business in the State of Florida, whose address is 300 First Stamford Place,Suite 201,Stamford,CT 06902,hereinafter called the Grantee: (Wherever used herein the terms"Grantor"and"Grantee"include all the parties to this instrument and their heirs, legal representatives,successors and assigns). WITNESS ET H:That the Grantor,for and in consid n ion of the sum of$10.00 and other good and valuable consideration,the receipt and sufficiency of wive r ' , •w+i�edged,hereby grants,bargains,sells,aliens, remises,releases,conveys and transfers un oit ie aliih' .er\yin`'I nd situate in Collier County,Florida,viz: Unit No.531,500 LA PENINSULA 4 Ottl°minium,as recorded Ir^TCon minium Plat Book 31,at Page 69, of the Public Records of Collier C my Rtorhhr,taggker ni , the pr. rat interest in the Common Elements and Common Property of the Co do 1 niu • Li I d Corn 1 on Ele en appurtenant thereto,more particularly delineated and iden fie' I 1•t 1,„„t efe at o 1;o n • of 00 LA PENINSULA,a Condominium,as recorded in O fici R 1 s r 1 - % 4,‘, P∎u.s 67 hro gh 1476,and as amended,of the Public Records of Collier C nntt).F1' al •3 'enin'r 1a it o I va d,Naples,FL 34113. TOGETHER,with all the tenemen cditaments and appurt , ces ere 4 onging or in anywise appertaining. TO HAVE AND TO HOLD,the sant'. simple forever. e9 The Grantor hereby covenants with said r e hat.tan r-i tt{ iuJI seized of said land in fee simple;that the Grantor has good right and lawful author $self dFor�t j and,and hereby warrants the title to said land and will defend the same against the lawful c tns•ofIitl-pettsb""ns whomsoever;and that said land is free and clear of all encumbrances except restrictions and easements common to the subdivision and ad valorem real estate taxes for the current year. IN WITNESS WHEREOF,the said Grantor has hereunto set his hand and seal the day and year first above written. Signed,sealed and delivered In our presence: JACK E.ROBINSON P ', t Name: 44-1//e,c /6•t/DE LU dr k E.Robinson - 1 'rint Name:Se_4Jvt timaUrW..5 STATE OF CONNECTICUT COUNTY OF FAIRFIELD The foregoing instrument was acknowledged'before me this 25th day of April,2011,by Jack E.Robinson,who is personally known to me. :.```rh J.Fail f:.,, h . : `•t-- - - •:... "'�': rs///. /%- /. ,r� �y.I! RAF,tl , ' ..{?�Ivi1-%NO 1Af)•.'Si: s.": . ':tIBd?W1041 .,.?' • n^� . . r., .NotaryPubttc-Conneclicul My Commission Expires .nU C LIC. October 31,2014 • i • Commercial Recording Division 6PaA 1 of 1 Business Inquiry _�- HOME 'HELP Business Details Business Name: SHADOW RIDGE Citizenship/State Foreign/DE PROPERTIES,LLC Inc: Business ID: 1015762 Last Report Filed 2013 Year: PO BOX 112315, NAPLES, FL, Foreign Limited Liability Business Address: 34108 Business Type: Company Mailing Address: PO BOX 112315, NAPLES, FL, Business Status: Active 34108 Date Inc/Registration: Sep 17,2010 Name in State of SHADOW RIDGE INC: PROPERTIES, LLC Commence Business Sep 20,2010 Date: p Principals Details Name/Title Business Address Residence Address JACK E. ROBINSON 243 TRESSER BOULEVARD, 243 TRESSER BOULEVARD, SUITE 1700, MANAGING MEMBER SUITE 1700, STAMFORD,CT, STAMFORD,CT, 06901 06901 Agent Summary Agent Name JACK E.ROBINSON Agent Business 300 FIRST STAMFORD PLACE, STE 201,STAMFORD, CT,06902 Address Agent Residence 300 FIRST STAMFORD PLACE,STE 201,STAMFORD,CT,06902 Address OTHER ADDRESSES: Back View Filing History ! View Name History View Shares 1 http://www.concord-sots.ct.gov/CONCORD/Publicinquiry?eid=9744&businesslD=1015762 9/27/2013 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 106 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 532, Folio#32455000267 7)2/zo Print Name Sig ur (Pqui a ate -513 P&)1 ,Adid 67- 5i0d- it/13 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) R E C E I \/E D Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. r.°.3 „L.; x.0,1 ^�, 3 Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date ASST Mailing Address ACC 6 Aagelofl Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 32455000267 I Site Adr. 1 532 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address LOZIER, RITA JO FUGATE HARRIS 532 LA PENINSULA BLVD tE City J NAPLES I State 1 FL I Zip 134113-4011 Map No. I Strap No. 1 Section 1 Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 295600 532 7B06 1 6 I 52 26 I 0 Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 532 Millage Area 11191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 295600- 500 LA PENINSULA A 1 Sub./Condo CONDOMINIUM School ! Other Total Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 f 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value $0 09/19/11 4720-3240 $425,000 I (+)Improved Value $276,250 09/04/07 4277-3483 I $425,000 i 1 (=) Market Value $276,250 05/ 24/02 3043-2334 I $400,000 01 06/17/99 2559-2127 I $0 I (")SOH*&other Exempt. $0 07/27/95 ( 2083-134 I $ 300,000 I 1 (=)Assessed Value l $276,2501 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. I $ 50,5001 1 (=)Taxable Value $225,750 I (=)School Taxable Value $250,750 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93-107 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida_ The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 533, Folio#32455000283 1. 61,e...6_Print Name gnatur )` i d) Date 1/20Cpc.4fr(la L h—‘L-C,_ . st....,5rs..,49 _/. 0,t // z.4•0 Mailin g Add ess Print Name Signature(required) Date P E2I iM- RC() vs p Mailing Address 3. R & P _ 111 MANAGEMFNT Print Name Signature(required) Date ` ' 162013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC -- Ofr 4'7 P^:.a. 1 of1 • Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 32455000283 I Site Adr 1 533 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address FREY,GREGORY L BARBARA J FRENCH FREY PO BOX 821 City MARCO ISLAND I State 1FL Zip 1 34146 Map No. Strap No. I Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 295600 5337806 6 52 26 0 Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 533 Millage Area 0191 MVlillage Rates O *Calculations Sub./Condo 1295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A i CONDOMINIUM School Other Total � _.... Use Coded 4 CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount 1 Land Value $O I 03/23/98 2401-628 I $ 225,000 I 1 (+)Improved Value I $ 276,250 08/05/96 j 2213-2164 I $347,000 (=) Market Value I $ 276,250 07/21/95 1 2081-1318 I $0 07/19/95 I 2081-1316 , $ 310,000 i (-) SOW&other Exempt. $0 (_)Assessed Value I $276,250 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt, $0 { (=)Taxable Value $276,2501 (=)School Taxable Value $276,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 . 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 108 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 534, Folio#32455000306 1. /1 Se r 07013 Print Name S ature(required) Date iv ljv 5 v�)4 vozes 37// ,Y r -F Mailing Address H"1274 be-A JA Iv< Sterc j 3eff ..7e)1 3 Print Name ture(req i d) U� Date S3 /.4- kitim s 0Z4 IVArLe5 t7 .3W/3 Mailing Address 3. RECEIVED` Print Name Signature(required) R & P MANAGEMENT Date Mailing Address $' 1 2013 MGR A n� Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.132455000306 I. Site Adr. 1 534 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address SIEFF,JOHN P=&JANE L 534 LA PENINSULA BLVD i City I NAPLES 1 State I FL I Zip 134113-4011 Map No I Strap No 1 Section j Township I Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 295600 5347B06 1 6 ; 52 1 26 0 Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 534 Millage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 1295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page , Amount I Land Value I $01 07/13/95 1 2078-1487 I $ 360,000 I - ; (+)Improved Value $346,0001 12/21/94 j 2013-1539 I $0 j (=) Market Value $ 346,0001 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 II _. (=)Assessed Value i $ 346,000 ................ (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $ 50,000 1 (=)Taxable Value $296,0001 (=)School Taxable Value $321,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins.., 9/25/2013 ' 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-109 '` County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 141, Folio#64660880004 1. /4-0-6/6;--4. f' -2_ /�7 4,L /4/2e/$ Print Na r► ` •to • 4red ' ) Date 333 d'c'/4 1/d.ir�' o ,6-0ra? Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(require RECEIVED Date Mailing Address R (5--P MANAGEMENT 3. Print Name Signature(required) EP 2 213 Date MGR Mailing Address ACC P 6 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660880004 I Site Adr. 1141 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address f PALAGIEWICZ, DAVID T I JERRY PALAGIEWICZ f 333 60TH CT City WILLOWBROOK ! State I IL Zip 160527-1905 Map No. Strap No. Section i Township j Range ! Acres *Acreage 7B06 528400 1417B06 6 1 52 I 26 1 0 Legal 1 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 141 Millage Area 0 191 f Millage Rates 0 *Calculations - I00 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo 1528400 School ? Other Total CONDOMINIUM i Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page � Amount I Land Value $01 11/26/07 4305-1026 $330,000 j (+)Improved Value I $249,6311 05/07/07 1 4225-1546 $0 i 3 ... 05/30/02 j 3046-209 j $ 365,000 (=) Market Value $249,631 03/05/90 I 1509-2136 j $0 1 , (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 10/01/87 1302-1339 $ 155,000 '; ! (_)Assessed Value $249,631; (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value ! $249,631 (=)School Taxable Value $249,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 110 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. • It is understood that the design, repair andlor replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 142, Folio#64660920003 1. e � ) C- /lJ /vim? /,/ Print Name Signature/(requ e Date '�' 339 / ,f C/4.1 67- /�i� j'/Gi`0(1//`l) fi Mailin Address 2. ' ` ,1A71 d. e01J` �l) f) ti ?/ ,L 113 Print Name Si r(ature(requir /pate 11(73.36/ (AV-ad' ..d- lia140 C'z`, PEernerz4 f, 66/7�- Mailing Address 3. I\/ L R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 12 2013 Mailing Address MGR, A PO OP n. i �J PPage 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No, f 64660920003 1 Site Adr. 1142 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address JACOBS, KENNETH J=&ROXANA J 149339 QUAIL RUN CT City 1 PLYMOUTH j State I MI I Zip I 48170-3266 Map No. � Strap No. ! Section Township Range j Acres *Acreage 1 7806 � 528400 142 7806 6 52 26 � 0 Legal 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 142 Millage Area 0 191 ; Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 1528400- 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM Sub./Condo School I Other Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 t 11 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date . Book-Page ! Amount it 1 Land Value $0 04/02/13 4908-988 ! $ 348,000 1 (+)Improved Value I $311,250 09/12/03 3395-2429 1 $415,000 ' _ i I I 1 , (=) Market Value $311,250; 06/08/01 2839-534 1 $260,000 I { 09/00/87 1296-1411, $ 190,000 11 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 311,2501 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 311,250 (=) School Taxable Value $ 311,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-111 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 143, Folio#64660960005 1. Do i As / , Print Name S nat re(r uired) Date cl (13(b9 A /. /102-- lip o &d(L N lay ailing Address / 2. row rt . F" o R t ti(,C( /(( . 0/3 Print Name 4R_ Signature req fired) Date B ra,() 1 Mailing Address ,_ 3. & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 6 2013 Date MGR Mailing Address ASST, ACC I. 6PElOf 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 164660960005 � Site Adr.1143 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address 'FLORIO, DOMINIC=&RONA 197 BROADVIEW AVE i i _. City 1 NEW ROCHELLE State 1 NY 1 Zip 110804-4114 Map No. 1 Strap No. Section 1 Township ; Range 1 Acres *Acreage 1 7B06 1 528400 143 71306 6 1 52 , 26 0 Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 143 Millage Area 0191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 1528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A 1 Sub./Condo CONDOMINIUM School G Other I Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 1 N Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Data Book-Page Amount 1 1 Land Value $01 02/28/13 1 4894-108 j $307,000 ■ (+)Improved Value $281,2501 07/05/11 4699-1626 1 $ 310,000 (_) Market Value $281,2501 01/26/00 2634-1385 I $0 11/18/99 ; 2612-2124 I $0 IN SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 281,250 _..01/01/88 j 1322-350 � $0 (—} 10/01/87 1 1299-960 $ 190,000 1 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $01 (_)Taxable Value $281,250; (=)School Taxable Value 1 $281,2501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://wvw.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 '. 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-114 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 505, Folio#32455000102 1. 1--,VVA%j g■ Af"7' �. /-cir-9-t-e)1 . '`/ .cam�) 7 Print Name ignature(required) Date 1-0f— %4 ,re/v/AY,( 4 B'vv /(/ .z f � //‹' Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) f RECEIVE Ere R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP172013 Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date AS Mailing Address ACC -- i '' A i Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. i 32455000102 1 Site Adr.1 505 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address BONTHUIS TR, ELINOR A TAD 1-22-97 ITF E A BONTHUIS 6299 SPRINGMONT DR City HUDSONVILLE I State I MI Zip 149426-8704 Map No. Strap No. ; Section j Township 1 Range I Acres *Acreage I 7806 295600 5057B06 I 6 52 26 0 , Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 505 Millage Area 0191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations School 1 Sub./Condo 295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A 1 1 Other Total !CONDOMINIUM � � Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM + 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 f Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page ! Amount I Land Value $0 03/03/99 2518-2868 J $340,000 1 Improved Value 1 (+)Im r p__ $323,950 10/08/96 2236-2168 I $0 i 09/10/96 ; 2226-1515 I I I (=)Market Value i $ 323,9501 08/09/96 2215-1850 $ 385,000 1( ')SOH*&other Exempt. $01 ......... ......... 12/21/94 2013-1539 , $0 I (=)Assessed Value $323,950 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value I $323,950 i (=)School Taxable Value $323,9501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 , 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-116 * ! Y ED County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/�Q R & P MANAGEMENT La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition SEP 16 2013 An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. - To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this pets• -`tt-is-untawfutforany person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue ! i an-one-timer-Any-person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty • - isdemeanor of the first • degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment districtshali be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 507, Folio#32455000144 1. N J d bCYYL-710 1 //gito4 9 -/.3 Print Name n /f var.g • ure(required) Date 50 7 Ca.Pen;r si de,. 6/vd • • ' J //i.3 Mailing Address Print Name / Sig ure(required) Date 50-1 Po ►yt 5%.4.\c> .)1,t o F 1 3,1 ( 15 Mailing Address 3. Print Name Sigo ure( e wired) Date Mailing Address Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 132455000144 1 Site Adr. 1507 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DONATO,JEFF HEIDI MAYERHOFER 1507 LA PENINSULA BLVD City`NAPLES I State FL Zip 134113-4013 Map No I Strap No Section Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 295600 5077B06 6 52 26 0 Legal 1500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 507 Millage Area 0 191 i Millage Rates 0 *Calculations - 500 LA PENINSULA A �ONDOMINIUM Sub./Cando 1295600 School Other Total Use Coded 14-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page Amount i Land Value 1 $OI 04/03/03 I 3256-2055 I $ 510,000 I (+)Improved Value $ 341,000 06/09/95 j 2067-1965 ; $405,800 { __ (=) Market Value I $341,0001 12/21/94 2013-1539 I $0 I (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $ 85,733 (=)Assessed Value 1 $255,267 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value i $205,267 (=)School Taxable Value $230,267 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.corn/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 117 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 124, Folio#64660680000 T Of 7" _/ 2) 4ky11Imo. 7ki Print Name Signature(required) Date /17/)c e/& ;4V / // ,7/e-� : 3 V/13 Mailing Address / 2. Print Name Signature(required}EC E I V Date R & P MANAGEMENT 3. Mailing Address i 2013 Print Name Signature(requiredAGR Date ASST ACC Mailing Address lr 6 • • Page 1ofl 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660680000 ; Site Adr. 124 LA PENINSULA BLVD 1 Name/Address I MARILYN E FLYNN TRUST 1 124 LA PENINSULA BLVD APT 124 I i i r City NAPLES State 1 FL f• Zip 3 34113-4033 • • Map No. 1 Strap No. f Section 1 Township 1 Range 1 Acres *Acreage • 7B06 I 528400 124 7B06 6 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 124 Millage Area 0191 1 j tillage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A School ' Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM .__ Use Coded 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 i 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll ' (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page ; Amount 1 Land Value $01 •08/28/12 I 4836-3543 $ 152,750 ". 1 I (+)Improved Value $239,6311 01/05/09 kk 4430-135 $0 : E _ k I �I i (_)Market Value $239,631 09/03/98 2457-3069 i $0 1 10/01/87 I 1303-583 $ 155,000 1 ' (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $ 12,373 (=)Assessed Value i $ 227,2581 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $ 50,000; (=)Taxable Value 1 $177,258. (=)School Taxable Value 1 $202,258; If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-118 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing,shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 131, Folio#64660720009 1. 1 A, ahll/344 S.-(-)X. tar- e+-0-Print Name ignature =quired) I ate // z&geit/45-6(k ./3/W , i0fie5 /, 3f/43 Mailing Address 2. en u.5 1,, , { Print Name Signature(required) Date /`g 1 - Mailing Address R 3' R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Si 1 2013 Date • Mailing Address MUR ASST ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 64660720009 ; Site Adr. 1 131 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address SCHMIDT,WILLIAM C&SUSAN M 1131 LA PENINSULA BLVD 0 G I � City NAPLES 1 State I FL Zip 134113-4033 Map No i 0 Strap No 1 Section E Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 528400 1317806 1 6 52 26 0 0 Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 131 Nlillage Area 0191 E Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 528400- 100 LA PENINSULA A 1 Sub./Condo School 1 Other Total CONDOMINIUM t Use Code 0 14.-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 1 P Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value $0 09/21/06 4109-2857 $470,000 ; 1 (+)Improved Value $244,631 04/25/91 1610-2019 f $ 181,000 i 0 09/01/87 ; (=) Market Value $244,6311 1296-662 $ 140,000 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. F $ 12,288} '._..._. (=)Assessed Value $232,3431 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,0001 (m)Taxable Value s $ 182,3431 (=)School Taxable Value s $207,3431 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 119 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 132, Folio#64660760001 1. 66e)e-r- W/16,ry f--g -43 Print Name Sign.ture(required) Date A.32 Lt PejVi,v /4 ��d _ ,„ P/ 3 /3 Mailing Address 2. P _ . AYE_ g- 3 Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address. RECEIVED 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(requiredSEP(required) EP 1 2 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ,e ASST ACr Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660760001 I Site Adr.1 132 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address 1 WILCOX, ROBERT T=&PATRICIA A 1132 LA PENINSULA BLVD 1 I _ City f NAPLES ; State !FL Zip 134113-4033 t Map No. I Strap No. I Section Township 6 52 Range 26 ' Acres *Acreage 7606 1 528400 1327B06 � 0 Legal 1 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 132 ; Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations I 5284D000 - 100 LA PENINSULA A ` I_ Sub./Condo School ( Other Total ,CONDOMINIUM I Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I i Land Value f $0 12/17/03 I 3466-789 ; $0 I i (+)Improved Value $ 276,2501 I 03/14/02 2999-210 $0 04/23/98 2412-978 0 1 (_) Market Value $276,250) -- (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $47,387i 04/18/96 I ,2172-1405 $245,000 i i . 06/01/92 1727-2151 j $0 ; (=)Assessed Value $228,863' 10/01/87 1300-850 j $ 170,000 l (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value $178,8631 (=) School Taxable Value $ 203,863 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll `SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 ' 6 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-120 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 133, Folio#64660800000 1. Print Name Signature(required) Date 9647 4'4rc=RWel04) 'rig'9, 4'cwt/ �.e via" i'r?.h cm2 a6a Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) i� Date • 267 derv-e-e wevcze_) 770e s' 'R Air" Mailing Address 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 6 2013 Date MGR Mailing Address SS1 ASST ACC ' 6 k1 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 164660800000 ! Site Adr. 1133 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address I FEELEY,THOMAS DENNIS I BONNIE DAWN FEELEY . _. 7667 WATERWOOD TRL City GLEN BURNIE State IMD � Zip 121060-8444 Map No. ! Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Acreage 7606 �._... 528400 133 7606 . 6 52 26 0 Legal i 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 133 Millage Area 0 191 j Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo i 528400- 100 LA PENINSULA A School Other , Total ! ! �._ Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 I Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date f Book-Page � Amount Land Value $01 03/28/13 4903-1431 $319,000 (+)Improved Value € $276,2501 09/12/11 ; 4779-813 i $0 ! _ . 1 04/10/02 3015-3061 i $400,000 1 (=) Market Value $276,250 I 03/04/91 1 1596-1452 $0 i . (-) SOW&other Exempt. $01 07/01/88 1364-467 $ 190,000 j 1 (_)Assessed Value $ 276,2501 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value 1 $276,2501 (=) School Taxable Value $276,250' If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93-121 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. it is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is indcrttvod-that-u,o design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 521, Folio#32455000160 1. F-1 (_ ), �n l} . 24? 4)t—L- _ _to (3 Print Name Signature(required) • Date Mailing Address fECE \/ED 2. ED Print Name Signature(required) �' MANAGEMENT Date sEP 16 2013 'Mailing Address• 3. MGR Print Name Signature(required) Date ACC Mailing Address Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 32455000160 I Site Adr. i 521 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address LOTH, ERIC B=&ROSEMARIE A 55 RALEIGH TAVERN LN i i4 City NORTH ANDOVER State 1 MA Zip 1 01845-5625 Map No Strap No Section I Township Range j Acres *Acreage 7B06 295600 5217B06 6 52 I . 26 1 0 Legal 1 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 521 Millage Area a(91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School I Other � Total CONDOMINIUM . Use Coded 4- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) I Date I Book-Page I Amount I I Land Value $0 I 07/22/02 I 3076-1957 ; $ 332,000 j 1 (+)Improved Value $ 239,631 I 12/27/88 I 1403-1237 I $175,000 I 1 (=) Market Value $239.631 1 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 239,631 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. I $0 (=)Taxable Value $239,6311 � (_)School Taxable Value $239,6311 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=°Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 t- 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-122 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 522, Folio#32455000186 Print Name T 6N✓ - 5 gnature�(fr', Date Mailing Address 2. 191--,7ng (_y uInn C1.1ta_tJe-- t, - ` , / Print Na�� ^w � Signature(required) RECEIVED Date Mailing Address 3. & P MANAGCMM1jT • CEP 1 9 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASS I ACC e1of1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 132455000186 I Site Adr. 1522 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address QUINN, MICHAEL J=&ALANA 5 8580 MAJORCA IN City NAPLES I State 1 FL Zip 1 34114-6435 Map No Strap No Section Township s Range { Acres *Acreage 7B06 295600 5227606 6 1 52 26 I 0 Legal 500 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 522 Millage Area 0 91 i Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo School Other Total 295600 - 500 LA PENINSULA A I f CONDOMINIUM... ( I Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date i Book-Page l Amount I I Land Value $ 07/26/95 i 2082-2342 $ 335,000 I 1(+)Improved Value I $271,2501 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0_i (=)Market Value $271,250I (-) SOH*Be other Exempt. $0 (_)Assessed Value $271,250 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $271,250 (=) School Taxable Value $271,250 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH=''Save Our Homes*exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser,com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?Ful lAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 f 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-123 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "lt is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 134, Folio#64660840002 6)(„2„,„v �c\e. i∎nt6+ e *poi 3 Print Name Signature(required) Date (06.'15 5t v e-4- f)i 0+ l-r -� ens, -a) 4L(0 3 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) RE C E I\ / D Date M R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR ASST Mailing Address ACC i. r ' r, Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 64660840002 I Site Adr.1 134 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address BIXLER TR,SARAH R SARAH E BIXLER TRUST DATED 03/28/00 10645 SUNSET POINT LN • City FISH ERS I State 1 IN Zip i 46037-7803 •Map No Strap No ; Section 1 Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7606 528400 1347B06 6 i 52 26 i 0 Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 134 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A School I Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 + 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) i Date . Book-Page ' Amount I ; Land Value $0 12/04/02 3166 4069 $ 352,500 l..- , (+)Improved Value $244,631 i 09/16/93 1865-1481 I $0 06/01/92 1722-1252 $0 } (=) Market Value ( $244,6311 10/01/87 I 1303-2188 $ 170,000 . (-)SOH*&other Exempt. I $01 ■ (_)Assessed Value ? $244,631 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value { $244,631 • (=) School Taxable Value $244,631 1 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetailltml?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-124 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 110, Folio#64660400002 1. r kOtt3 /l' Print Name t`Signature(required) Date Mailing Address Print Name Signature(required) ate 19 2 D 1\1111„ flu4-,TC-W, t (0 FtEe Mailing Address CP1VE 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) $ P 1 9 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC � �. (d Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 164660400002 1 Site Adr. 1110 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address ROWS JR, RICHARD C=&DIANE.1 17192 LOCKE RD City}MILLINGTON j State ITN Zip 38053-6922 Map No i Strap No I Section I Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 j 528400 1107806 6 52 26 0 Legal 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 110 Millage Area 0 91 i Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo ; School Other f Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Safes are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Pagel Amount H Land Value $0' 08/23/95 1 2092-1516 $210,000 l (+)Improved Value I $228,800 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 11 (=) Market Value $228.8001 . ........... (-) SOH*&other Exempt. ! $0 (=)Assessed Value $228,800 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value f $228,8001 (=)School Taxable Value j $228,8001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?PuIlAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 0 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-125 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 111, Folio#64660440004 1. AU. 40/ 6,2,A, �� ` 94.-Z19J3 Print Name Signature(required) v Date 32.2.o 4'o/t, /N#/L,P/Aii ST. .�4/v,4,to Ov is .r11/ '/L z o? Mailing Address 2. RECEIVED Print Name Signature(required) R & P MANAGEMENT Date Mailing Address SEP 12 2013 3. M(R Print Name Signature(required) ASST Date ACC Mailing Address i\ Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660440004 ? Site Adr. 111 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address 1 LANGDON,GREGORY W i (ALLEN E&GREGORY W LANGDON 15220 N MERIDIAN ST � f City INDIANAPOLIS State`IN I Zip 1 46208.2652 Map No f Strap No 1 Section ' Township ' Range i Acres *Acreage 7806 528400 1117606 6 52 26 i 0 Legal 1 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 111 Millage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations i 528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo I School I Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page I Amount I Land Value 1 $01 i : 07/26/95 i 2082-2357 $250,000 (+)Improved Value I $228,800, 12/21/94 1 2013-1539 $0 1 (=) Market Value $228,8001 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $01 i (=)Assessed Value $228,8001 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value $228,800 (_)School Taxable Value $22s,soo, If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. httpl/www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la-l-penins... 9/25/2013 P6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-127 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 113, Folio#64660520005 1. � &.I-Iu r 74& Print Name Signature re red) 060 Aik(fray � C4/4101- a 4032. Mailing Address LatlittiA S . 64 Print Name Ig ature(required) Date I MD 1- 136-6t116-1( tOrtak blind 6 11. Mailing Address lir tw 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) S P 1 6 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 64660520005 i Site Adr. 1113 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address HUNT, DAVID B=&LAUREN S 12866 HORSEFERRY RD City CARMEL State 1IN 1 Zip 146032-7266 Map No. I Strap No. 1 Section 1 Township ! Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 i 528400 1137B06 6 52 , 26 0 1 Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 113 Millage Area 0191 ' Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo School Other 1 Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014 CONDOMINIUM f 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page ' Amount 1 , Land Value 1 _ $0 04/16/10 4559-700 $450,000 1 , (+)Improved Value $ 343,0001 04/17/03 3267-3327 $445,000 1 i (_) Market Value f $343,000 j 03/04/99 2519-1710 ! $ 257,500 i 09/01/87 1294-1230 $ 250,000 1 i (-)SOH*&other Exempt. L.. $01 (=)Assessed Value $ 343,000; (-) Homestead at other Exempt. $01 (=)Taxable Value $ 343,0001 (=) School Taxable Value $ 343,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-128 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 121, Folio#64660560007 1. Print Name Signature(required) �Dat� lad La) t on&yz&c. k, 6 ` . (b. 3 /13 Mailing Address 2. .11 r 11 3 f-dpe 06v4.:a4t 1/d2,pa (?-?-/3 Print Name '`. Signature(required) Date �� l // Mailing Address `* ► ' 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SE° 12 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR Assr -�-- ACC '. 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 64660560007 Site Adr. 1 121 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address STAPE, LEONARD=&HARRIET 100 LA PENINSULA BLVD#121 !� City 1 NAPLES State FL Zip 134113-4032 Map No I Strap No Section , Township Range j Acres *Acreage 7B06 5284001217B06 • 6 52 26 0 •Legal 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 121 Millage Area O 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 528400- 100 LA PENINSULA A ff Sub./Condo School f Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page Amount 1 Land Value $01 ( 03/11/02 1 X996.1340 0 i (+)Improved Value I $239,631; 06/07/01 1 2838-2520 $270,000 (=) Market Value I $239,631 1 10/00/87 1300-86Z $ 145,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $ 12,3731 (=)Assessed Value $227,2581 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $50,000' (_)Taxable Value $ 177,258; (=)School Taxable Value $202,258;. If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FuilAddress=la+penins,.. 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93-130 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 104, Folio#64660160009 1. 1/14 1 d r'4 i c0 V 1, €—R.{J r E 9/7/20/3 Print Name Signature(required) Date 6 S+D h \fa,'lei G-+, t, Greer SG 2.1650 Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) f ® Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3' SEP 1 1 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR ASST Mailing Address ACC it' 6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. (64660160009 1 Site Adr. 1104 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address MILDRED F SOUTHERN REV TRUST 6 STONE VALLEY CT City J GREER State SC E Zip 1 29650- 3265 Map No. Strap No. Section ! Township Range Acres *Acreage 7606 528400 104 7806 6 52 26 0 ' I Legal 1 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 104 Millage Area 0191 ! Millage Rates o *Calculations 528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo , School Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) .._...._.............._ . Date I Book-Page I Amount Land Value $0 f 05/01/12 4797-3316 j $0 (+)Improved Value I $ 259,631; 05/17/12 4797-3313 $0 _ . i (_) Market Value I $259,631 11/01/87 ; 1306-1019 $ 155,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $259,6311 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 I (=)Taxable Value $259,631 (=)School Taxable Value $259,631; If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 l_ , Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 131 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County appro al. Property Address 105, Folio#64660200008 1. I hoip -/3,e/in�L&- 4) . ,�,,,0 . . 9 �� Print Name Signature(re ui :. --'f~ Da.-t ilie2_ . /2, 3 ii, ilir Mailing`Address r&k.)40.5(1/4/ 2. Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 17 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ASS1 ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 164660200008 Site Adr. 1 105 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address I JENNINGS, CHARLES W=&CAROL 1 105 LA PENINSULA BLVD ! � I City NAPLES State 1 FL j Zip 34113-4032 Map No Strap No Section Township ; Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 528400 1057806 6 52 26 0 Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 105 Millage Area 0 191 Jylillage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1528400- 100 LA PENINSULA A 1 I_ School Other Total 'CONDOMINIUM I ; Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount ' ! Land Value $0' 03/16/99 2523-3199 ; $290,000 j (+)Improved Value $ 353,950 02/01/88 1 1330-285 $218.000 (=) Market Value $ 353,9501 (-) SOH*&other Exempt, $01 (=)Assessed Value $ 353,950; (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,0001 (=)Taxable Value $ 303,950; (=)School Taxable Value $ 328,950; If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.coll ierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.htmi?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 t6 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 132 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 106, Folio#64660240000 1. IANiI t Q /7i�7 �' „1%3 Print Name / Sig ature(rl 6�ifed) /Date /D 6 ,.60 �cy�.ys'�•.sy ' vo �/1i ,l S / � 5'//,3 Mailing Address 2. �� _ c-Aa. A/7(t Name ejcl, Signature(required) Date eP4/ . x,AP (kak el II; I Mailing Address 3. R 8c F' MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 6 an Date MGR Mailing Address ASST ACC k- 6 Q, Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660240000 I Site Adr. 1 106 LA PENINSULA BLVD .................. Name/Address HOGG, RONALD J VIRGINIA HOGG 106 LA PENINSULA BLVD City NAPLES I State I FL i Zip 34113-4032 Map No ) Strap No. Section , Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 71306 52840010671306 6 52 26 0 Legal 1 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 106 Millage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A School ! Other Total CONDOMINIUM Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 ! 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I Land Value $p' 12/17/02 i 3193-1276 i $0 i 1 (+)Improved Value $ 323,9501 12/17/02 J 3193-1274 $0 (=) Market Value $323,950 02/06/02 2976-3437 ( $0 02/06/02 1 2976-3435 $0 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $01 02/06/02 2976-3421 $0 ' (=)Assessed Value $ 323,950f 02/06/02 1 2976-3419 i $0 � (-) Homestead&other Exempt. € $ 50,0001 09/05/01 1 2887-1700 i I$404,900 $273,9501 l _ _ (=)Taxable Value 08/19/99 j 2583-1434 I $ 302,000 1 j 10/01/87 j 1299-948 $218,000 (=)School Taxable Value i $298,950' If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 ..� OA Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-133 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 107, Folio#64660280002 1. 'cos,aU. Al« 1�,.�.7�b rs ►. `�1�f 13 Print Name Signatu (required) Date Mailing Address 2. s--) o Ct'nne, yob on a at 9 f q f 13 Print Name , Signatures.uired) Date aN10 UIs4.-er RoV 410e tits MI L/$ 3®9 Mailing Address RE 3. E i V i Print Name Signature(required) R & P MANAGEMEi fate SFP 12 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST Or ( Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 64660280002 I Site Adr. !107 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address'JACOBSON, RONALD L=&JOANNE B 112410 ULSTER RD 1 City I ROCHESTER HILLS State 'MI j Zip 148309-2041 Map No. Strap No. Section i Township Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 E 528400 1077B06 6 52 26 0 Legal 1 100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 107 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Cando ;CONDOMINIUM School Other j Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page j Amount I Land Value j $0 07/23/10 4589-990 I $325,000 (+)Improved Value $259,631 07/09/01 2855-3438 $ 285,000 05/14/99 I 2546-3340 $ 250,00.0 (-?Market Value i $259,631 01/01/91 1587-778 ! $0 f (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 04/01/88 1343-1353 $ 185,000 (=)Assessed Value $259,6311 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $259,631 (=)School Taxable Value $259,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www,collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.htm1?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 134 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. ++! It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 108, Folio#64660320001 _ /4_ /3 Print Name ignature(required) Date /2-0a7 ,5 e_a_ � <� � c �4J � /� '/ ? iy Mailing Addres 2. Print Name Signature( eq red) Date / 7 44(14/4q /tchre5-�� 6;7- ti/E' l '1/l Mailing Address f, per,I 3. Print Name Signature(required)R & P MAI��C'�M�' ' Date SEP 16 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASSr Acc '°' ` I Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 64660320001 Site Adr. �108 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address PARRISH,JEAN E 12027 SYCAMORE LAKES CT o.. City!FORT WAYNE State 'IN Zip 146814-9019 Map No. ( Strap No. , . 1 , , Section Township Range 1 Acres *Acreage 71306 1 528400 10871306 6 52 26 0 Legal 1100 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 108 Millage Area 0!91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations '528400 - 100 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo CONDOMINIUM ; School Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Data Book-Page Amount Land Value I ount j �_ $ 05/12/06 j 4036.2086 1 $750,000 (+)Improved Value J $ 323,0001 04/07/04 I 3536-3507 $600,000 (=)Market Value j $323,000 10/21/94 i 1996-88 i $ 325,000 I i ............ 09/01/87 , 1295-823 , $ 225,000 (')SOH*&other Exempt. $01 (_)Assessed Value $323,0001 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0; (=)Taxable Value $ 323,000 (=) School Taxable Value $ 323,000; If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH=''Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 1 3-136 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 402, Folio#78539000684 1. —� - ►�rAIl G/ 1/ [3 Print Name ` -I n•t e(required) Date s .7—elAelif oJ , vowt64- �-/o Y Mailing Address /14, 2. A J - ) / Print Name 'gnature(required) Date %SR o _ -' �.'/(1x,0,.4:‘L t /9D r Mailing Address 3. C I\/I1D R & P MANACIEASENT Print Name Signature(required) ate SEP 12 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC ,�"- .�- ( T ° h Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 78539000684 Site Adr. 1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD vc-I'v\-- tACIA Name/Address TIMLIN, FRANK M=&NEENAH M 7520 INDIAN PIPE CT City COLUMBIA State 1MD Zip 121046-2459 Map No I Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 1 I 1 7806 I 677560 4027806 6 1 52 26 i 1 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 402 Millage Area 0191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT 1 School I Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 1 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sates are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount Land Value 1 $0 02/01/10 4533-1555 I $ 595,000 1 (+)Improved Value $520,010 01/07/04 3479-3046 I $ 965,000 (=) Market Value $520,010 12/05/02 3168-1280 I $ 690,000 I (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 520,010 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 520,010 1 (=)School Taxable Value $ 520,010 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 137 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 403, Folio#78539000707 1. Es Li c A. . ttut3Ei _ 5eprolf3Ee- t0 ta01 3 Print Name S gnature(r quired) Date SuYt+Pt=U)tESEtJk)E(Z 3, c't0It-4S Nit,F-r) lbcyz AN Mailing Address DR-: 190 LIR? NLYk)SuLPr iJl.VIJ., A,tNtT LIb3 NR1 t-Cs/ FL 3q(13 1,f S4 PTIWNOM tate(required) Date Mailing Address RECEIVED R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SEP 1 7 2013 Date Mailing Address MC7K ASST ACC , A ft of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178539000707 1 Site Adr.1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD un'tk 40.1 Name/Address 1HUBER, LESLIE A 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD APT 403 City 1 NAPLES 1 State I FL Zip 134113-4040 Map No. I Strap No. I Section I Township 1 Range I Acres *Acreage 7606 1 677560 4037B06 ( 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 403 Millage Area 0191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub/Condo 1677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT 1 School Other 1 Total 1...._. Use Code 014..`CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date 1 Book-Page I Am ount I Land Value $0 07/29/08 I 4382-1199 $980,000 1 (+)Improved Value $585,750 10/07/05 I 3906-2564 I $ 1,192,000 1 (=)Market Value $585,750 I (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 LI (_)Assessed Value $ 585,750 I (-) Homestead&other Exempt. 1 $ 50,000 I (=)Taxable Value $ 535,750 il (=)School Taxable Value $ 560,750 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 r 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-138 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, 'It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 404, C12 Folio#78539000723, 78539000244 (gt4AblqS VAIF4f-ta\(4, Print Name Signatur (re red) Date 147-7 r\-j17�t 44 Mailing Address 1kECE1VED 2. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SE?? 16 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address - „ k 6 •t Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 78539000723 Site Adr. 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address R RICHARD BURKHOLDER R/L TRUST C M BURKHOLDER R/L TRUST PO BOX 1477 City IHARTVILLE State OH Zip 44632-1477 Map No. Strap No. Section Township Range Acres *Acreage 7B06 677560 404 7B06 6 52 26 0 Legal ;TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 404 Millage Area 0 91 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo i 677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School Other Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 I Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount Land Value $0 12/14/12 4879-782 $737,500 (+)Improved Value $ 585,750 07/21/03 3346-2756 $0 (=)Market Value $ 585,750 11/25/02 3160-2349 $827,000 • (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 585,750 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $585,750 • (=)School Taxable Value $ 585,750 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraisencom/Main Search/Re cordDetail.html?FullAddress=LA+PENI... 9/27/2013 6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178539000244 1 Site Adr.1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address R RICHARD BURKHOLDER R/LTRUST . ......................... . . .................................................... C M BURKHOLDER R/L/TRUST PO BOX 1477 . ........_.... ... ........ ..................... .... ... . ..........._...__..... City 1 HARTVILLE State 10H 1 Zip 144632-1477 Map No. I Strap No. j Section I Township i Range I Acres *Acreage 1 7B06 677560 C12 7B06 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1 TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM CABANA 12 Miliege Area 0 191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations ' Sub./Condo 1677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT 1 School 1 Other 1 Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 1 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Saes are listed due to Confidentiality) _ (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page j Amount j Land Value 1 $0 12/14/12 ' 4879-782 $737,500 (+)Improved Value I $ 30,000 11/25/02 I 3160-2375 $75,000 1 1 (=) Market Value $ 30,000 (-)SOH* &other Exempt. L $0 I (=)Assessed Value $ 30,0001 ■ (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $01 I (=)Taxable Value $30,000 (=)School Taxable Value $30,000 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 06 Collier County Citizen Petition No. /3-142 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/2912013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose'of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 303, Folio#78539000587 1. at-on Dn a Print Name Signature(required) Date ehras. one Aucso si G b 1 Z Mailing Address / 2. Steal EA) i',t1. (24 irie/,v4 4.11� .N.S i , ed. 9/9/ Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address RECEIVED 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date, 6 013 Date SE Mailing Address MGR ASST 6A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178539000587 I Site Adr. 1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address CAVANAUGH,STEPHEN W SHARON K CAVANAUGH 409 CHRIS IN City j_NOBLESVILLE I State I IN Zip 146062-8897 Map No Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 677560 303 7B06 6 I 52 I 26 I 0 Legal `TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 303 Millage Area 0 91 i Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT I School I Other Total Use Code 014 CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount Land Value 1 $0 09/28/12 4844-3922 $472,000 (+)Improved Value I $575,750 11/09/04 3675-3458 $ 1,200,000 (=)Market Value $ 575,750 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 I (=)Assessed Value $ 575,750 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. I $0 (=)Taxable Value $575,750 (_)School Taxable Value $575,750 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 taikm.,6 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 143 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon C unty approval. r7) Property Address 304, Folio#78539000600 ! ) ,,• ;f, / • 1. 6'0 L 13 ?(..) J �.) q 1 , Print Name Signature(eq fired) Date ."--0 (" 2)J11}"K 1)1Vc k 3741 Mailing Address 2. l_l li/�,¢ �div R C e rL) _ (9- ,` Lti q/1/.3 Print Name IgnatGre(equired) Date 760 1.4 PEN/A/6'4414 t// A/4/'LL_. / J/11/3 Mailing Address fE C I 3. Print Name Signature(required) & Jv+ N GEMENT Date SEP 16 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST • 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. J 78539000600 j Site Adr.i 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address WILLIAM P RUSSO TRUST 3180 CANYON OAKS TRL City MILFORD j State I MI I Zip 48380-3958 Map No Strap No I Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 677560 3047606 6 I 52 1 26 , 0 Legal 1 TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 304 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub/Condo 1 677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School Other 1 Total Use Coded 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Amount Land Value $0 05/27/11 . . 4711-1859 $0 - .. { (+)Improved Value $575,750 05/26/10 4570 2056 $ 600,000 ..... (=) Market Value $575,750 03/29/10 4554-3197 I $ 100 12/11/02 ( 3172-1945 I $980,000 I_(-) SOH*&other Exempt. 0 1 (=)Assessed Value $ 575,750 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 575,750 (=) School Taxable Value $575,750 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 1 3-144 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7129/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address L 'cxe 305, Folio#78539000626 k � 1 S to Print Name Signature(required) Date '2D0 �Q��n�n��-�0. (6\,vc). 30� des � 3 t Mailing Address 2. .6-r,- . nvvie.441 . ?li r/i 3 Print Name Si ature(required) Date 70-t. LA- 4,6-/\!/,J t1O- vim go S Aro4-6-v i Mailing Address RECEIVED 3. R & P MANACEMFN Print Name Signature(required) 9 Uate S."2 1 9 2013 Mailing Address MGR ACC _ "0 a �r a /I Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 78539000626 Site Adr. 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address HERCHE,VICKIE L GRAEME MURRAY 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD APT 305 City NAPLES I State I FL Zip 1 34113-4040 Map No. I Strap No. I Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 677560 305 7B06 I 6 I 52 26 I 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 305 1Vlillage Area 0 191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1 677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT I School 1 Other I Total Use Coded 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 j Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) I (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount Land Value I $0 I 04/26/13 I 4919-1436 I $0 I (+)Improved Value $510,010 03/23/12 I 4780 -845 I $ 610, 000 11/27/02 I 3163-217 I $670,000 I _ .(=) Market Value $ 510,010 I (-) SOW&other Exempt. $0 I (-)Assessed Value j $ 510,010, I i (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0I I (=)Taxable Value $510,0101 I (=)School Taxable Value I $510,010 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SON="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetaiI.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6 44 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 93- 145 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 306, Folio#78539000642 1. RAn1k C , 1?ice��rvl ,- a(� 4 0, 9• Print Name Signature(required) Date /52/s- 64 L e. /--/M�egsuri 411/ c?*•r,2 — Mailing Address J 2. /- Print Name Si,nature(required) Date ,?SZP 6r€.1 etA 'INanci9/1-671 Al/ Ali _ — Mailing Address RE 3. C E I'►V/' Print Name Signature(required) - jg SEP 12 2013 Mailing Address MGR Pagel A Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 1 78539000642 I Site Adr. 1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address F C&L L DRESSMAN REV TRUST 12568 FOREST CITY DR City 1 HENDERSON State I NV Zip 189052-6951 Map No 1 Strap No Section Township 1 Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 677560 306 7806 6 52 j 26 I 0 Legal ITWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 306 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT I School I Other I Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sates are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount I Land Value I $0 03/18/13 ( 4899-1552 I $680,000 (})Improved Value I $ 547,410 11/25/08 4409-3637 $780,000 (=) Market Value $ 547,410 04/24/07 4218-2567 I $0 03/14/07 4197-62 $ 12,921,800 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 547,410 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 1 (_)Taxable Value $ 547,410 (_)School Taxable Value ( $ 547,4101 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll "SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 iv 6 A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 146 County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) "ie Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: fhe undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 401, Folio#78539000668 1. 1X1/ .�e 2.Ala/. /1 �/ �� orox,Print Name nature(re iDate '/4 7/' G.a)9P id 4/ S1? I✓7 /9,02_ M. ng •dress 2. e, � / ��s! Print Name Signature(required) / Date dA ��� � �t �/� f� //c/ /01 RE C E IV D Mailing Address 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) SE!' 1 ti 1013 Date Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC ��� 6 ,4 Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 78539000668 i Site Adr. 1 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address I MEGILL,WAYNE 2 HUNTRISE LN City WEST CHESTER State IPA I Zip 1 19382-8565 Map No I Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 L, 677560 4017B06 6 I 52 I 26 I 0. . ! 1 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 401 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations i Sub./Condo 677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School I Other I Total Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Safes are fisted due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount Land Value $0 05/17/04 I 3565-316 I $ 950,000 (+)Improved Value $607,410 03/17/03 I 3241-1166 I $868,200 (_) Market Value $607,410 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $607,410 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 I (=)Taxable Value $607,410 f (_)School Taxable Value $607,410 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/MainSearch/RecordDetail.h#ml?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-147 * 5 A County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 202, Folio#78539000448 1. Pi Po (LT?N 6A ' 3 Print Name Signature(required) Date d/ vrE1A ' / �F S Mailing Address C Print Name Signature(required) Date 'DO &,1/ X02, 1UAA 's TA , 'J 3 Mailing Address 3. RE RECEIVED Print Name Signature(required) R & P MANAGEMENT Date Mailing Address 092013 MGR ASST 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 78539000448 I Site Adr.1 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address I PORTINGA, DEAN R 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD APT 202 .......................................... City NAPLES I State I FL ( Zip 1 34113-4040 Map No Strap No I Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 677560 2027B06 I 6 i 52 I 26 I 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 202 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub/Condo 1 677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School I Other I Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Safes History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page 1 Amount I I Land Value I $0 05/17/06 4038-4153 I $0 (+)Improved Value 1 $ 500,010 12/06/02 3169 2533 I $ 745,000 I I (=) Market Value $ 500,010 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $500,010 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. I $50,000 (=)Taxable Value $450,010 (=)School Taxable Value f $475,0101 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Say 1' r>> Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 152 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shalt solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. • After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 101, Folio#78539000367 Print Name Signature(required) Date 6-/l f eez 7// ro�,J 12 76 Mailing Address 2. 0 „ p , Da t• re4y -e r3 . Print Arne Signature(required) Date 67/.c /./ 7 11 r (A-) 3 I Ud j Y .4)210 f /-1/ c%' 0, Mailing Address E C I V D 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 1 6 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC 6 A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178539000367 Site Adr.1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD - l Name/Address PEARSE TR, BRENDA DIANE BRENDA D PEARSE REV TRUST UTD 9/7/06 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD APT 101 City!NAPLES State I FL 1 Zip 1 34113-4040 Map No Strap No I Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 677560 1017B06 I 6 52 i 26 I 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 101 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677560 TWIN DOLPHINS I AT f School 1 Other j Total Use Code 0 j 4 CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sates are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount Land Value I $0 09/25/06 I 4111-1395 I $0 (+)Improved Value I $557,410 04/05/06 1 4011 3176 I $1,300,000 (_) Market Value $557,410 12/31/02 I..3187-2336 I $ 786,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $557,410 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. f $0 (=)Taxable Value $557,410 .......................... . (=)School Taxable Value $557,410 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH='Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 l 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-156 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 201, Folio#78539000422 1. L«4 n4 hilby d Print Name Signature(required) Date ?f"7< `49 tc �/ Mailing Address ! 2. g �-- ` 'Zeit t: 71. 712- Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailin Add ss WED 3. RECEp & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(requiC iP 2 3 2013 Date Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC It Page 1 k A Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary IParcel No. 178539000422 I Site Adr. 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address TADYCH,KEVIN L=&LISA M CARL&CORINNE THIESEN PO BOX 40 City I HAZELHURST State 1 WI I Zip 154531 Map No ! Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 1 677560 2017B06.__ 6 1 52 I 26 1 0. . .. . Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 201 MIliege Area 6191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School 1 Other I Total Use Coded 14-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount Land Value $0 02/25/05 1 3741-1722 I $0 (+)Improved Value $587,410 01/20/05 I 3719-1082 I $ 1,015,000 I (=) Market Value ( $587,410 03/19/03 3242-1009 l $827,700 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value ; $587,410 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 1 (=)Taxable Value $ 587,410 1 (=) School Taxable Value $587,4101 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http:I/www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-157 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address PH 2, C13 Folio#78539001049, 78539000260 1. H YEA yvtcj- rt 11 b h '3 Print Name Signature(required) Date 14 4 171 14u iyc HILL� t �I43 ) 63D) -7 Mailing Address 2. q /po //3 Print Name Sign (required)d ,,��Date'14 14.-4N04 ik/1N ROL ju,..ctxt. E. IN t .VW VA, f" C_ rizt Mailing Address e �E 3. } ID R & P MANAGEMENV Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 16 2013 Mailing Address s , 6 A Page loll 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary IParcel No. 78539000260 Site Adr. 1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DJN FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 494 HUNTERS HILL TRL City COLGATE 1 State I WI I Zip 153017-9543 i Map No Strap No I Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 677560 C 1371306 1 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM CABANA 13 Millage Area 0191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo I 677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School 1 Other I Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM j 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 p Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount . I Land Value $0 1 12/21/05 39524206 $0 r (+)Improved Value $ 30,000 05/08/03 j 3286-2097 $75,000 I (=) Market Value $ 30,000 03/17/03 3241-1067 $0 11/26/02 3161-2233 $ 75,000 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $30,000 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $30,000 I (=) School Taxable Value $30,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraisencom/MainSearch/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 _ . .- . - _6 4. , __ ________ ___ _ . lc < 3754732 OR: 3952 PG: 1206 • `�, RECORDED in OFFICIAL RECORDS of COLLIER COUNTY, FL 12/21/2005 at 12:26PN DWIGHT B. BROCK, CLERK RIC FEE 18.50 This instrument was prepared DOC-.70 .70 by and should be returned to: Retn:EYPRESS/UPS Bradley.1. Kalscheur, Esq. CHICAGO TITLE INSURAICB CO Michael Best&Friedrich LLP 5447 NBLLIE DAVIS LI 100 E. Wisconsin Avenue,Suite 3300 TAMPA FL 33634 5251 Milwaukee, WI 53202-4108 Tax Folio No. 78539000260 �r"-r mop op MAO. Ne , WARRANTY DEED 6447 Tampa.l`..��� THIS WARRANTY DEED made as of the 1s` day of April, 2005, by THE NIMMER 1 FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP No. 1, a Wisconsin limited partnership, of 494 Hunters Hills Trail, Colgate, Wisconsin 53 7,- - -inafter called the Grantor, and DJN Family Limited Partnership, a Wisconsin�1�t 4411 ', of 494 Hunters Hills Trail, Colgate, Wisconsin 53017,hereinafter cal ie • aiii ee .--- 1, WITNESSETH,tha sat, G , for . I in co sidera''on of the sum of ten and 00/100's ($10.00)Dollars and other ood 1 • -y l r ,°I . ' '.ai• Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee, the receipt where f i• h reb a ' o - !-1, :r. too, bargained and sold to the Grantee and Grantee's hei . . e' • - j dive! • o 'h-If interest in the following described land located in the\d my of Collier, Stat-',.f Fl•rid.V- it: 7# -'� a Cabana No. 13, TWIN 12/` I S I, a condo, i ogether with the pro rata interest 1 in the Common Elements •d pp 1,Q•, ; l'•= of the Condominium and Limited Common Elements appurtenant he -•`a +• .e-•.rticularly delineated and identified in the 1 Declaration of Condominium of TWIN DOLPHINS I, a condominium, recorded in O.R. I Book 3151,at page 885, et seq., of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, and as amended. SUBJECT to all the terms and conditions contained in the Declaration of Condominium of TWIN DOLPHINS I, a Condominium, and the Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws of TWIN I DOLPHINS I CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., and all amendments thereto filed of record. SUBJECT ALSO to all the terms and conditions contained in the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions of LA PENINSULA recorded at O.R. Book 1213, Page 770, as I amended in O.R. Book 1352, Page 1307, Public Records of Collier County, Florida, and the 1 Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws of the Club at La Peninsula and all amendments thereto Ifiled of record. 4... 6 A *** 011: 3952 PG: 1207 *** SUBJECT ALSO to taxes for the year 2005 and subsequent years, restrictions, reservations and easements of record,and zoning ordinances of Collier County,Florida. And the Grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land, and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. Signed,sealed and delivered in the presence of: The Nimmer Family Limited Partnership No. 1 e/lir _R (1 10 off Iwo. i.AA u/.`.._ Witness Title: a 'artner C. T eA,1714 ► State � t of Wisconsin r" ) " � )ss. County of t f L�ftu�tc.•ec-- ) j Personal came before me this � f / , 2005, Do�,aQ H.?'fty -e.r' as G n Gvtera� s4}+�•.- of The Nimmer Fain' Limited Partnership No. 1, to me known to be the person who executed the foregoing instrument and a • •wle•: • - � ,�-�AF��, • f otary Public, State of iscQnsin • \ aie • My Commission • ,,'s• ail�ieIssSmot$A119s2I1.1 ......... • -2- P1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178539001049 I Site Mr. 1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DIN FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP 494 HUNTERS HILL TRL ... ................. ...... . City 1 COLGATE 1 State 1 WI I Zip 1 53017-9543 Map No I Strap No I Section I I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 677560 PH 27B06 6 1 52 1 26 1 0 Legal 1 TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM PENTHOUSE 2 Millage Area O 91 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 677560 TWIN DOLPHINS I AT 1 School Other 1 Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount I Land Value $01 12/21/05 3952-1204 l $0 (+)Improved Value 1 $995,470 05/08/03 3286-2096 I $ 1,900,000 (=)Market Value $995,470 I (--)SOW&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value 1 $995,470 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $995,470 (=) School Taxable Value $995,470 if all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 116 A 3754731 OR: 3952 PG: 1204 lg RECORDED in OFFICIAL RECORDS of COLLIER COUNTY, FL 12/21/2005 at 12:26PN DNIGHT H. FROCK, CLERK REC FEB 18.50 This instrument was prepared DOC-.70 .70 by and should be returned to: Reta:BXPRESS/UPS Bradley J.Kalscheur,Esq. CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE CO Michael Best& Friedrich LLP 5447 NELLIE DAVIS LN 100 E. Wisconsin Avenue,Suite 3300 TANPA FL 33634 5251 Milwaukee, WI 53202-4108 Tax Folio No. 78539001049 RETURN TO Chicago rule Insurance CO. 5447 NeWe Da' .Lane WARRANTY DEED I Tampa,Florida 33634 THIS WARRANTY DEED made as of the 1't day of April, 2005, by THE NIMMER FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP No. 1, a Wisconsin limited partnership, of 494 Hunters Hills Trail, Colgate, Wisconsin 53 - einafter called the Grantor, and DJN Family Limited Partnership, a Wisconsin t a�h •, of 494 Hunters Hills Trail, Colgate, Wisconsin 53017,hereinafter cal e e rake.—`''- �, i WITNESSETH,tha sal• 0 : for . • in o sideraf on •f the sum of ten and 00/100's ($10.00)Dollars and other od 1 : • .o-1'1- • rr• aid Grantor in hand paid by said Grantee, the receipt where f i- h eb a o I-. -., Ir te•, bargained and sold to the Grantee and Grantee's hei o . r:• • Idivi k• o e&h.If interest in the following described land located in the fed ty of Col ier,Stet ,f Flo •d it: 'C5\ 1 \ , (5) Unit No. PH-2, TWIN ' • S I, a condo r. ogether with the pro rata interest r in the Common Elements +■ f3, • , • �• of the Condominium and Limited Common Elements appurtenant her•4-401.: • particularly delineated and identified in the Declaration of Condominium of TWIN DOLPHINS I, a condominium, recorded in O.R. Book 3151,at page 885,et seq., of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, and as amended. TOGETHER WITH parking spaces 11 & 12, and Storage Locker No. 6, which are appurtenant to the aforesaid unit as Limited Common Elements. 1 SUBJECT to all the terms and conditions contained in the Declaration of Condominium of TWIN DOLPHINS I, a Condominium, and the Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws of TWIN I DOLPHINS I CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC., and all amendments thereto filed of record. SUBJECT ALSO to all the terms and conditions contained in the Declaration of Covenants, . Conditions and Restrictions of LA PENINSULA recorded at O.R. Book 1213, Page 770, as amended in O.R. Book 1352, Page 1307, Public Records of Collier County, Florida, and the _ _ 6A - *** 011: 3952 PG: 1205 *f Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws of the Club at La Peninsula and all amendments thereto filed of record. SUBJECT ALSO to taxes for the year 2005 and subsequent years, restrictions, reservations and easements of record,and zoning ordinances of Collier County,Florida. And the Grantor does hereby fully warrant the title to said land,and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the said Grantor has signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. Signed,sealed and delivered in the presence of: The Nimmer Family Limited Partnership No. 1 \. R Co& By: Lt .1►Ikft A * Alig 1 KO1�i'.f•r N Nagle: I 1 J yu► z2 Witness Tide. General Pa ner A State of Wisconsin V )ss. °,, County of I - ) �Q Person came before me this , 2005, as ^�e� of The Nimmer Fami y Limite. Partnership No. 1, to me known to be the person who executed the foregoing instrumen and .. ow -':-• e. 404-_ Notary Public,' • ''•,"c ry c,Sta�t�e_of WiWi�onsin •3 \OTAIr�,•�'� My Commission es: tS tw►. TiklientaW�.�4i003IW1196180.1 -2- ' bA Collier County Citizen Petition No. /3-160 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 603, Folio#78539000943 .\•...Pr■AO-9-11/ 1-a6t3 1 Print Name Signature(required) Date c.,R 15 t�q.,� � i�� I� a,�1 S VA ' 3 Mailing Address f\ I 16 / /��/ cl-- ) --ao Print Name Signature(required) �/ Date Mailing Address RECEIVED 3. R & P MANAGEMENT Print Name Signature(required) Date SEP 1 1 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC �'� �' L ge l of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178539000943 Site Adr. 1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address ANGELL, WILLIAM G 6825 DAVIS BLVD#242 City I NAPLES 1 State I FL Zip 134104-5326 Map No I Strap No j Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 677560 603 7606 j 6 I 52 26 1 0 Legal ITWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 603 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School 1 Other I Total i Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 I 6.7427 1 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sates are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page I Amount I Land Value $0 12/22/03 3469-1449 j $..0 I (+)Improved Value $762,330 1 _ 11/20/02 3157-2434 I $1.305.000 i (=) Market Value $762,330 i (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $762,330 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $50,0001 ( (=)Taxable Value $ 712,330 I (=) School Taxable Value $ 737,330 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 . 6q Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-161 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7129/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "it is unlawful for.any person to knowingly sigma petitioneor petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is wide'bt�uu that me purpose hub aisUUI" iA .�,.,:_. ,��,,,. .,.r�....o the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 604, Folio#78539000969 1. >4�y AfEisol Print Name Signature(required) Date 7i) LA ? //i/,u,4` '-ti) Alf PCF3 fc 3411/ Mailing Address 2. Print Name Signature(required) FEE I 1 I E D Date R & P MANAGEMENT Mailing Address �'") 1 3. 2013 Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date ASST Mailing Address ACC Page 6 �f 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary [ 1 [J Parcel No. 1 78539000469 Site Adr. 1 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address DIROCCO TR, PENNY S PENNY S DIROCCO TRUST DATED 04/03/95 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD APT 604 .. ........................................... City I NAPLES State 1 FL Zip 134113-4041 Map No Strap No Section 1 Township I Range 1 Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 677560 604 7B06 6 1 52 I 26 0 Legal 1 TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 604 Millage Area 0191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School Other Total Use Coded 4- CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427J12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page 1 Amount j Land Value $0 12/18/02 3177-3167 1 $ 1,089,700 , i CO Improved Value $762,330 (=) Market Value $762,330 1 (-)SOW&other Exempt. I $0 (=)Assessed Value 1 $762,3301 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000 (=)Taxable Value i $712,330, (=)School Taxable Value $737,3301 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH='Save Our Homes-exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 MOLE1,1f8110 Department of Health•Vital Statistics (STATE FILE AMBER) STATE OF FLORIDA MARRIAGE RECORD *** 3866092 OR: 4065 PG: 3993 *>r* TYPE UPPER CASE USE BLACK INK RBCORDID in OFFICIAL RICORDI of COLLIII COUNTY, FL USE This liosns•not valid unlass seal of Clerk, 07/05/2006 at I2:I2FM ORION! I. BROCI, CLIRL Circuit or County Court,appears thereon. RIC III 10.00 Rota: DBNNIS DAVID NILSOM PICK OF 06-0088MAR (APPLICATION NUMBER) , APPLICATION TO MARRY 1.GROOM'S NAME(First,Middle,LasU 2.DATE OF BIRTH(Month.Day.Year) DENNIS DAVID NELSON AprIl 14,1941 U.RESIDENCE-CITY,TOWN,OR LOCATION 3b.000NTY So.STATE 4.BIRTHPLACE(Stall or Foreign Country) BIG PINE KEY MONROE FLORIDA CALIFORNIA 5s.BRIDE'S NAME(First,Mlddl•,Lull 5b.MAIDEN SURNAME(N different) B.DATE OF BIRTH(Month,Day,mar) PENNY $ E DIROCCO WATSCHKE November 06,1947 7a.RESIDENCE-CITY,TOWN,OR LOCATION 7b.COUNTY B.7c.STATE BIRTHPLACE(State or Foreign Country) NAPLES I COLLIER FLORIDA MINNESOTA II• ' • THE APPLICANTS•NAME. NTH ;1 n h.•• .•• LFOR HERSELF.STATE THAT THE It6ORMAT)ONPROVIDED'1°0"•,, THIS REC IS OF ,• .., D BELIEF.THAT NO LEGAL OBJECTION TO THE MARRIAGE '-•"^ns NOR y .C'T1 L;y r". OA •••••¢E i�' �,yv TOUSANDL(EREBYlIPPLY FOR LICENSE TOMARRY. . •, C n-1,.• ; 6=%` .. il. AJ .a- - tf� 006 BE D -I P. f ■ 1 7 OF OFFICIAL "-'-04 1 12.SIGN •F OF ICIAL(U,•.in Ink) C'• DEPUTY CLERK iiiihb�� ;.r... III '.4 '' • 1 Ag 1 ' '' ��I' / ; 1t BEO ND< ORN TO BEF RE YE ON(DATE)•' . i :4. f---.. • �i.N.�4l �.c..� .�1 200: ....• r'. 15.TTI1.E OF OF Al.I `/ tin/ .� okz r[.?x,7: nr t e• Gk • _ • • •��,.�` DEPUTY CLERK w � vI r , ..,l,,,,,, 11. rAr ., 'i,,� LICENB •i.'.i- ��. AUTHORQATIONAND i R£BYGNENTOANY PERSON'1■ .�1„'•;;I! BY THE LAWS OFTHE STATE OF FLORIDA TOPERFORM ••'•.� AMARRIAOECEREMONY � TEOFFLORIDAANDTOSOLEMNN , IAGEOF THE ABOVE NAMED PERSONS.THIS LICENSE MUST ••, •• BE USED ON•..a R THE EFFEC tLi!. • ..•., •d BEFORE THE ,_4_;_..!,x..H IN . ATE• FLORIDA IN ORDER O:_.:zL•.:.• D..•V. . fi.COUNTY ISSUING LICENSE •I. ttCENSE:•Q b1 18a.DATE UCENSE EFFECTIVE IS.EXPIRATION DATE ? ; COLLIER ;2�t. v May 14,2006 July 09,2006 • ..S • 264.SIGNATURE Oj1000RT CLERK OR JUDGE 20b.TITLE BY O.C. • `4 Al : O., e"' t� DEPUTY CLERK 120o. JL • CERTIFICATE OF MARRIAGE • . �t ... -• .t 1. • ►, : .4 L. i. ...•l1 -. E:t•..,-..• ,:,•. .1 : r. • : ,. ', ..;:4.,. .. .r••.:•... ,dl. 1.. ..n •. I, 'i .I •, ..;t... „,.„%„,.„% 21.DATE OF MARRIAGE(Month,Day,War) 22.CITY.TOWN.OR LOCATION OF MARRIAGE 1 UV N€ Z / Z o0 6 NA/04 `S_ FG 23s.SIGNATU OF PERSON PERFORM! CEREMONY(Use black Ink) 23c.ADDRE88(Of person performing ceremony) SEAL ■ ' �V- 97�"W. 7.,e.O.ys CR. i 4s,ec., /SS. ,4 I s•ld j•- 23b.NAME D TITLE OF PERSON PER RISING CEREMONY 24.81. ••E OF WITNESS •CEA NY Wu sok Ink) (Or notary stamp) • i3Rue.4r Are FCDG i - . 4%1 ��J,�� 2&S•'f'; ,4 ES= O CER 0 (Use black Ink) •I64CCd !UQ-3-.3Yl't•'# Al Clicetr.' , t. 6A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-166 County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 503, Folio#78539000820 1. CAna.AC'S - q/c1/4 0/3 Print Name _ Signature(required) Date 1 t 13.. t �t C�tiZ 5 COCA e()t,r.V ��t v. } .>1 n::.\c( 'y 2, vu =-jet ' = c c�� 9"/1671,W.1„/ Print Name Signature(required) ' Date RECEI ED Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. S",;,? 16 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address MGR -- ASST ACC b A Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary - 1 Parcel No. 178539000820 Site Adr.1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address LANEY, CHARLES E=&ROSEMARY 1912 PATTONS WAY City SEVIERVILLE State ITN Zip 137876-6589 Map No Strap No I Section I Township + Range I Acres *Acreage 7806 677560 5037B06 I 6 52 I 26 0 Legal )TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 503 Miliage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT I School Other Total Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount I f Land Value $j 08/25/04 I 3631-3324 I $ 1,012,000 (+)Improved Value $595,7501 12/19/02 I 3178-3410 I $847,000 (=)Market Value $595,750 (-)SOW&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 595,750 (-) Homestead&other Exempt, $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 595,750 1 (=)School Taxable Value $ 595,7501 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 /. Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-168 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 505, Folio#78539000862 1. 0,F-)>r ve t_.•/ t)1 LAu-1e.6,17 1 a1 t ?(- Opact� jJ l C. i1 to t c_- 9 -9.- /J' Print Name Signatur (required 0 Date Mailing Address 2. RECEIVED Print Name Signature(required) R & P MANAGEMENT Date Mailing Address SEP 1 2 2013 3. MGR Print Name Signature(required) ASST Date ACC Mailing Address Pa g e 1 ok A Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 78539000862 I Site Adr. 1 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address LACHENMAYER,BEVERLY M 1253 CULLIGAN LN City I MENDOTA HEIGHTS State 1 MN I Zip 1 55118-4151 Map No I Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 ( 677560 5057B06 6 1 52 ! 26 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 505 Millage Area 0191 1 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS 1 AT I School I Other I Total Use Code 014- CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page 1 Amount I Land Value $01 08/19/04 3628 2806 $890,000 � (+)Improved Value $ 530,010 12/10/02 3171-2568 I $ 785,000 1 (_) Market Value $ 530,010 1 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 O Assessed Value I $530,010 i (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 1 (_)Taxable Value $530,010 (=)School Taxable Value 1 $530,0101 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-170 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 601, C4 Folio#78539000901, 78539000082 1. ce„� PS"e /�f� l�''�4 Print Name Sig ure required) Date P9 sy /Pj r 3o 3a141 ,6fe/ F7 3.3961 Mai ing Address 2. tic es-e I Print Name( Sig ure(required) Date 9 9' Sef, oe/ Ft 3 14 Mailing Address LCE VED 3. R d Print Name Signature(required) e F213 I 1 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC 6 Page 1 of Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No 78539000901 Site Adr. 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address NIESEL TR,NANCY S CHESTER A NIESEL TR 2959 W GULF DR UNIT 304 City i SANIBEL State I FL Zip 133957-5723 Map No Strap No { Section I Township i Range i Acres *Acreage 7806 I 677560 6017B06 I 6 I 52 I 26 1 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 601. Millage Area 0191 1 Miliage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub/Condo 1 677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT I School l Other Total Use Code 014-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 6.7427 l 12,4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date I Book-Page I Amount Land Value $0 12/22/08 4415-941 $0 (+)Improved Value $657,410 12/31/02 i 3187-2337 $860,000 (=) Market Value $657,410 Market (-) SOW&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $657,410 r (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (_)Taxable Value $657,410 (=) School Taxable Value $ 657,410 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main_Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A Page 1 of I Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178539000082 Site Adr. J 700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address NIESEL TR, NANCY S CHESTER A NIESEL TR 2959 W GULF DR UNIT 304 City SANIBEL State 1 FL Zip 133957-5723 Map No. J Strap No. Section Township I Range j Acres *Acreage 7B06 f 677560 C 47806 ; 6 1 52 j 26 j 0 Legal TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM CABANA 4 Millage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 677560-TWIN DOLPHINS I AT School 1 Other Total Use Code 0 4-CONDOMINIUM 5.69 + 6.7427 l 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) [ Date J Book-Page J Amount I Land Value $0 12/22/08 14415-939 $0 I (+)Improved Value $ 30,000 12/31/02 i 3187-2338 1 $ 75,000 (=) Market Value $ 30,000 (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 (=)Assessed Value $ 30,000 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 30,000 (=)School Taxable Value $ 30,0001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll `SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to capon assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-173 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected do the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address PH 4, Folio#78539001081 1. rJoq,k/ 17- i ;YN N 44 c • i 9/A //-3 Print Name Signature(required) l / Date /;3 42 ,gain) 6144 41,i4 7f4 fl1PN, FL- 3-sii Mailing Address 2. VEPrint Name Signature(required) Date R & P MANAGEMENT' Mailing Address CEP 16 2013 3. Print Name Signature(required) MGR Date ASST ACC, Mailing Address 4aAlof 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel Na. 1 78539001081 I Site Adr.1700 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address JOHNSTON&JOHNSTON PH4 LLC 313 LA PENINSULA BLVD City 1 NAPLES State I FL Zip 1 34113-4036 Map No 1 Strap No Section 1 Township ! Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 I 677560 PH4 7B06 I 6 f 52 26 I 0 Legal I TWIN DOLPHINS I AT LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM PENTHOUSE 4 Millage Area 0 91 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations Sub./Condo 1 677560 -TWIN DOLPHINS I AT I School Other I Total Use Code I4-CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 I 6.7427 I... 12.4327 I I Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount f Land Value $01 05/13/13 4922-1118 $852,500 1 CO Improved Value I $895,4701 04/29/03 3276-1353 $1,300,000 (=) Market Value $895,4701 (-)SOH*&other Exempt. $01 1 (=)Assessed Value $895,4701 1 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. ` $0 (=)Taxable Value $895,470 (=)School Taxable Value $895,470 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH='Save Our Homes'exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 Detail by Entity Name Page 1 of 2 FLORIDA DF,PAR'1'MFN'1' OF . DIVISION OF CORPORATIONS lfll�j/ Detail by Entity Name Florida Limited Liability Company JOHNSTON &JOHNSTON PH 4, LLC Filing Information Document Number L13000068863 FEI/EIN Number NONE Date Filed 05/09/2013 State FL Status ACTIVE Principal Address 313 LA PENINSULA BLVD. NAPLES, FL 34113 Mailing Address 313 LA PENINSULA BLVD. NAPLES, FL 34113 Registered Agent Name&Address DENTI, KEVIN A, ESQ. KEVIN A. DENTI, P.A. 2180 IMMOKALEE RD, STE. #316 NAPLES, FL 34110 Manager/Member Detail NONE Annual Reports No Annual Reports Filed Document images No images are available for this filing. http://search.sunbiz.org/Inquiry/CorporationSearch/SearchResultDetai l/EntityName/flal-11.,. 9/27/2013 1 . 6 DurhamTim From: Kevin Denti[kdenti @dentilaw.com) Sent: Friday, September 27, 2013 10:13 AM To: DurhamTim Subject: RE: Johnston&Johnston PH4 Yes he is. Thank you, KAD. Kevin A. Denti, Esquire Kevin A. Denti, P.A. 2180 Immokalee Road-Suite#316 Naples, Florida 34110 (239) 260-8111 (Phone) (239)260-8112(Facsimile) kdentiCdentilaw.com From: DurhamTim [mailto:TimDurhamC&colliergov.net] Sent: Friday, September 27, 2013 9:38 AM To: Kevin Denti Subject: Johnston &Johnston PH4 Hi Kevin. I am in the process of verifying signatures on a petition impacting properties on La Peninsula Blvd. The owner of parcel number 78539001081 is listed by the Property Appraiser as Johnston&Johnston PH4,LLC. Mr. Robert L.Johnson of 313 La Peninsula Blvd.signed a petition for the above-referenced property. Is he authorized to do so? (I imagine he is.) Thanks, �n4e �ua�am111 "111 Executive Manager of Corporate Business Operations for Collier County,Florida Website:www.colliergov.net E-mail: timdurhamPcolliergov,net Phone: (239)252-8383 Perfection Is not attainable,but if we chase perfection we can catch excellence.--Vince Lombardi Under Florida Law,a-mall addresses are public records.If you do not want your e-mail address released In response to a public records request,do not send electronic mail to this entity.Instead,contact this office by telephone or in writing. 1 ÔA Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-176 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, it is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District (Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 601, Folio#73605000021 1. Print Name Signature(required) Date Arr.x,49 yy .L�.�,.,lr .2b0&." 4)ie/ e).9f 010 Mailing ACddress 2. Print Name Signature(required) RE c E ` 'E Date Mailing Address R & P MANAGEMENT 3. SEP 12 2013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR Mailing Address ACC Page 1 of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No.1 73605000021 Site Adr. 1 601 LA PENINSULA BLVD I j Name/Address !PELICAN LANDING LLC 600 LA PENINSULA BLVD#601 City I NAPLES State FL Zip 134113-4042 Map No ! Strap No ! Section I Township Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 629500 6017806 6 52 26 0 Legal 1 600 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 601 Niillage Area 0191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 629500- 600 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo 1 School 1 Other Total CONDOMINIUM 3 Use Code O 4-CONDOMINIUM I 5.69 I 6.7427 I . 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I Land Value _ } $0 05/16/11 4684-1738 $ 375,000 ' 1 (+)Improved Value $289,631! 07/01/08 4374-2060 $0 i I i (=) Market Value $289,631 07/01/08 4374-2058 $0 07/01/08 I 4374-2055 $0 I (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $0 06/14/00 2686-2764 $ 325,000 1 (=)Assessed Value $289,631 08/01/96 2217-202 j $0 (-) Homestead &other Exempt. $0 01/11/95 2114-1608 i $0 1 (_)Taxable Value $289,631 07/20/95 j 2080-1779 $255,900 12/21/94 2013-1539 $0 l ! (=) School Taxable Value $ 289,631 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.corn/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress—la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A A.fate of Nttir Alinpohtxe Filed 2013 ANNUAL REPORT Date Filed:03/28/2013 1 The following information shall be given as of January 1 Business ID:848502 . � , , .F. proceeding the due date Pursuant to RSA 304-C:80. REPORT DUE BY April 1 2013 William M.Gardner t t ANNUAL REPORTS RECEIVED AFTER THE DUE DATE Secretary of State p2 WILL BE ASSESSED A LATE FEE. PELICAN LANDING LLC '"r ADDRESS OF PRINCIPAL OFFICE: 130 CENTRAL AVE 130 CENTRAL AVE DOVER,NH 03820 DOVER,NH 03820 ENTITY TYPE: LLC 4! ,r BUSINESS ID: 649502 -: REGISTERED AGENT AND OFFICE: l'k* H STATE OF DOMICILE: NEWHAMPSIRE " BREEN,BETSY 7 GERRYS LANE OWN REAL ESTATE DOVER,NH 03820 ,e., If changing the mailing or principal office address,please check the appropriate box and fill In the necessary information. 12:-, ❑ The new mailing address The new principal office address PO Box is acceptable. ```_J MANAGERS MEMBERS NAME AND BUSINESS ADDRESS(P.O.BOX ACCEPTABLE). NAME AND BUSINESS ADDRESS(P.O.BOX ACCEPTABLE). sr LIST AT LEAST ONE MANAGER BELOW OR MEMBER ON RLGBT A MUST LIST AT LEAST ONE MEMBER BELOW IF NO MANAGERS B MANA. Kristen Hopkins NAME cm STREET 130 Central Avenue STREET 'r' CITY/STATE/ZIP Dover Nh 03820 CITY/STATE/ZIP p;: NAME _ NAME STREET STREET ' CITY/STATE/ZIP CITY/STATE/ZIP NAME NAME • STREET STREET `'?' ` CITY/STATE/ZIP CITY/STATE/ZIP `' NAME NAME STREET STREET CITY/STATE/ZIP CITY/STATE/ZIP NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF ADDITIONAL MANAGERS/MENIBERS ARE ATTACHED To be signed by the manager,if no manager,must be signed by a member. I,the undersigned,do hereby certify that the statements on this report are true to the best of my information,knowledge and belief. tit Sign here: Kristen Hopkins Please print name and title of signer: Kristen Hopkins / MANAGER NAME TITLE =!_ FEE DUE: $100.00 E-MAIL ADDRESS(OPTIONAL): 11111. 11111 I 11111111 I I 11111111 III 064950220131003 WHEN THIS FORM IS ACCEPTED BY THE SECRETARY OF STATE,BY LAW IT WILL BECOME A PUBLIC DOCUMENT AND ALL INFORMATION PROVIDED IS SUBJECT TO PUBLIC DISCLOSURE REQUIRED INFORMATION MUST BE COMPLETE OR THE REGISTRATION REPORT WILL BE REJECTED MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO SECRETARY OF STATE RETURN COMPLETED REPORT AND PAYMENT'TO: New Hampshire Department of State,Annual Reports,107 N.Main St.,Room 204,Concord,NH 03301 6 • 6f4 u Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13- 177 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 203, Folio#78545000063 1. R 1l7 1/i<)' 13 P int Name _ S nature(req fired) Date L_Pc f {lay ill ] val /.(d f 'Y/" -, M ling Address [t 2. Print Name Signature(required E C I\ Date (R & P MANACEMENT Mailing Address 3. . SEP182013 Print Name Signature(required) Date MGR ASST Mailing Address ACC 5 A Page l of 1 Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 178545000063 1 Site Adr. 1203 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address LA PENINSULA#203 LAND TRUST 203 LA PENINSULA BLVD#203 I II j- City 1 NAPLES i State I FL j Zip 134113-4034 Map No. I Strap No. ; Section ± Township 1 Range j Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 677800 2037806 j _ _ 6 52 1 26 i Legal 1200 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 203 1'4/linage Area 0 191 Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 677800- 200 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo CONDOMINIUM School 1 Other 1 Total Use Code 0 4- CONDOMINIUM 5.69 1 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Sales are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page ' Amount I Land Value $0 02/27/12 { 4770-232 { $0 1 (+)Improved Value $ 228,800 01/26/12 . 4764-238 $0 i (=) Market Value i $228,800 10/29/10 4620-2170 l $0 i 1 1 05/12/10 4584-1792 $282,500 I (-)SOH*&other Exempt. j $0 1 .... � 10/27/00 f 2736-3009 $250,000 ( (=)Assessed Value $228,8001 I _ 01/29/99 2507-1068 $0 } 1 (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $ 50,000; 01/29/99 1 25074066 ; $0 I 1 (_)Taxable Value $ 178,8001 05/01/88 1346-1577 $ 182,000 i 1 (=) School Taxable Value j $203,8001 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll *SOH="Save Our Homes"exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail.html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 6A INSTR 4663906 OR 4770 PG 232 RECORDED 3/2/2012 8:56 AM PAGES 2 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC @.70 $0.70 REC $18.50 INDX $1.00 I • THIS INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY: RONALD S. WEBSTER 979 N. COLLIER BLVD. MARCO ISLAND, FL 34145 PARCEL NO: 78545000063 SPECIAL WARRANTY DEED This indenture, Made this Z7/ day of , 2012 by ROBERT H. WHITE, an unmarried man and MARJORIE . TESSIER, an unmarried woman as Grantor*, whose address is 203 La Peninsula Boulevard #203, Naples, FL 34113 and ROBERT H. WHITE and MARJORIE L. TESSIER as Trustees, or their successors in trust, under the La Peninsula #203 Land Trust dated- k •vember 3, 2010 and any amendments thereto confer • t•G-101, 0 rustee with full power and authority to protec ®Q• erve a - ell, lease or encumber, or otherwis Co anage and di- .• : of the real property in accordance with F or' .- - ute 689.0 ' (1 as Grantees*, whose address is 203 La Po i su ': - ,•u -va • #203 Naples, FL 34113. 1 1 WITNESSETH, Th= e .n., •i f• nd \ n c4sideration of the sum of ten dollars $ . o'd .i'd •' =r •- . = considerations, to them in hand paid b % antee, the re,. ip Ap eof is hereby acknowledged, has gr. ..d, bargaine• -a d 4) d to grantee, their heirs and assigns for,ld the followin• Sd:cribed land, situated, and being in r,► ' -r Coin , -• ida, to wit: o .ominium, According to the Unit No. 203, 200 La Peninsu sue- g Declaration of Condominium as recorded in official records Book 1309, Pages 1559 through 1626, inclusive, and the amendments thereto and according to the plat thereof and according to the plat thereof, recorded in condominium plat book 30, page 83, and any amendments thereto, of the public records of Collier County, Florida. And Grantors do hereby fully warrant the title to the land and will defend the same against the lawful claims of all persons whomsoever. _ Subject to restrictions and easements common to the subdivision, if any, and taxes for the year 2012 and subsequent years. t: 6 A *** OR 4770 PG 233 *** • • 1 *"Grantor" and "Grantee" are used for singular or plural, as context requires. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, grantor has hereunto set grantor's hand and seal the date first above written. ilty/d41/ itnes.' # sign name `i0bert H. White / ' dr , ,� • Witness #1 print n. le �!� �tirik ..�Al.;_41/,_ , rA ,fitness+#2 sign nam_ }�� .V r9fir . Tessier • YL itness 2 print name 116 clAtC State of /`—/19/'/G' ' -- County of 0//fie/'- {, The oregoin instrument was acknowledged before me this 27/h day of , 2012 by ROBERT H. WHITE _ d MARJORIE L. TESSIER who are ersonally known to me. My Commission Expires: f 14 /eel Seal Nstary P odic o►'r iii Notary Pudbal Stale of Florida MaryAAdams • My Commission D0943896 ?o,pov Expires 12/1812013 t 6 ii� Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-178 County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). I It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 208, Folio#78545000144 ctio 1. .12)01,06d4t 4 Liik-uid ...- , - �l 1,j Print Name ignature(required) lDate - .; ‘41}ZI / VA t (4- 4 3 Mailing Address 2. RECE \/ED Print Name Signature(required) MEN Date R & P MANAGE Mailing Address SEF i 6 2013 3. Print Name Signature(required) �SS Date Mailing Address 6A INSTR 4512167 OR 4639 PG 1109 RECORDED 1/4/2011 11:19 AM PAGES 2 DWIGHT E. BROCK, CLERK OF THE CIRCUIT COURT, COLLIER COUNTY FLORIDA DOC @.70 $0.70 REC $18.50 INDX $2.00 CONS $10.00 TRUSTEE'S DEED THE GRANTOR: RUSSELL E. HAMMOND, not individually, but as successor Trustee of the RONALD B. AND NANCY C. HAMMOND FLORIDA RESIDENCE TRUST U/A/D 11 '/'- s- ea h Certificate of Ronald D. Hammond, -c i1 d-. e as this Deed),whose authority is Al_ orth on the Ce c. of Trust Existence and Authority recorded at the same It e a this Deed, WHOSE ADDRESS IS: 9 .. I_; Ca vile ' I i!a • ::3 , CONVEYS AND WARRA • ., . "•M 7" ; •7 BARBARA H.LUDLOW, TO THE GRANTEE: not individual'lik s ,- t stees of the RONALD B. ' 'o. individual' T •V) 12/09/86,as amended, WHOSE ADDRESS IS: `II' • LOak— -0(C.,, - iI'e, ti 48838, An undivided one-half(1/2) interest in the real estate situated in Collier County, Florida, more fully described as follows: Unit No. 208, 200 LA PENINSULA, a Condominium, as recorded in condominium Plat Book 30,at Page 83,of the Public Records of Collier County, Florida, together with the prorata interest in the common elements and common property of the Condominium and limited common elements appurtenant thereto, more particularly delineated and identified in the Declaration of Condominium of 200 LA Peninsula,a Condominium, as recorded in Official Records Book. 1308, Pages 1559 through 1626, and as amended of the Public Records of Collier County,Florida, together with all improvements, fixtures, easements, hereditaments, and appurtenances associated with the real estate("Property"),and subject to easements,restrictions,interests,and reservations of record;taxes and assessments not yet due and payable. *** OR 4639 PG 1110 *** 6 A The Grantor covenants that the Grantor has good right and lawful authority to sell and convey the property and Grantor warrants the title to the property for any acts of Grantor and will defend the title against the lawful claims of all persons claiming by, through, or under Grantor, but • against no other persons. • The Grantor has not established domicile in Florida. This Deed is given for Ten Dollars ($10.00) and other valuable consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged. This Deed is dated I z f ,2010. - R'USSEL -E. HAMMOND, not individually, but as successor Trustee of the –• • ALD B. AND NANCY C. .Q��i,K C T' ►,', 4 D, 11/FLORIDA RESIDENCE d(11 &tit . _. _. &..441.11LI i 1..—___. itness#1 Signatu e 1710)451.3),-ili v,;�4'j)r 7, '_Ti I Witness#1 Legibly Prin ed iii -i/ II— i�:'.ly Printed Name STATE OF u' ,`�_6 :� ) �O )ss: ,S COUNTY OF It,,., , la T ciik- ,..- The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this 24 ' NJ._ , 2010, by RUSSELL E. HAMMOND, not individually, but as successor Trustee of the RONALD B. AND NANCY C. HAMMOND FLORIDA RESIDENCE TRUST U/A/D 11/29/95, who is personally known to me or who has produceddriwk 1ieense. as identification. 4,t 2 Ced460 9 Notary public,State of VA ,County of Meath" My commission expires: 11etsrhny 3,2 4 Acting in the County of PREPARED BY AND RETURN TO: JENNIFER L.REMONDINO(0031151) WARNER NORCROSS&JUDD LLP 85 East Eighth Street,Suite 310 f.t' k,;'ti Holland,MI 49423 ; *I. psi`'; Telephone: (61 G)396-9800 s�:'4,-4,1e` �s'I-7c-4•N Fax: (616}396-3656 -r Z, r'.O T/.h y 0.{ :: c--.< '. 4371865•I l.n a t.!c a '1 41,.4).. ill. ' t." A Collier County Citizen Petition No. 13-179 * County Manager's determination of sufficiency on 7/29/2013 (date). La Peninsula Seawall MSBU Petition An individual may only sign this petition on this particular issue one time. To the extent that Section 104.185, Florida Statutes, applies to this petition, "It is unlawful for any person to knowingly sign a petition or petitions for a particular issue more than one time. Any person violating the provisions of this section shall, upon conviction, be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in Sections 775.082, 775.083, or 775.084," (Section 104.185 F.S.) To the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County, Florida: The undersigned petitioners hereby request that the Board of County Commissioners establish the La Peninsula Seawall Repair/Replacement Municipal Services Benefit District(Benefit Unit or MSBU). It is understood that the purpose of this district is to repair and/or replace the seawall at La Peninsula Condominiums located on the Isles of Capri. These improvements shall be paid for by special assessment imposed upon each assessable unit, which is proposed to include each residential unit and each cabana unit, collected on the Collier County tax bill in sufficient amount to meet the cost of said improvements. It is proposed that upon completion of the project and acceptance by the MSBU, maintenance would be the MSBU's responsibility until any financing for the project is paid off. It is understood that the design, repair and/or replacement project shall solely be at the cost of the benefiting property owners. The estimate for the design, repair and/or replacement will be determined upon the creation of the MSBU and professional engineer's estimates. After investigation by the Alternative Transportation Modes Department and an advertised notice, a public hearing shall be held to determine if the proposed assessment district shall be created. Each affected property owner shall be notified of the public hearing by U.S. mail. The undersigned petitioners hereby also request that the Board of County Commissioners provide advance funding for the aforesaid design, repair and/or replacement upon County approval. Property Address 410, Folio#33400000208 1. DE-V to `DE e- (it Att �I tom`' � �n,,�,• r r� Print Name Signature(required) Date ;)/. 91 PC-f,to003 U 7 100,- -,1 i eIs ffi fs' , 011 Mailing Address L{ 2. J Print Name Signature(required) Date Mailing Address / \/1 3' R & P MANAGFMFNT Print Name Signature(required) Date SE? 16 2013 Mailing Address MGR ASST ACC � �"" ,6„t. A , Collier County Property Appraiser Property Summary Parcel No. 133400000208 I Site Adr. (410 LA PENINSULA BLVD Name/Address PENINSULA LLC LA 2029 BIRCHWOOD WAY i 1 { City]BLOOMFIELD HILLS State I MI Zip 48302-1601 Map No I Strap No Section I Township I Range I Acres *Acreage 7B06 1 302200 410 7806 6 : 52 1 26 0 Legal 1400 LA PENINSULA A CONDOMINIUM UNIT 410 jVlillage Area 0191 I Millage Rates 0 *Calculations 302200- 400 LA PENINSULA A Sub./Condo I School E Other I Total CONDOMINIUM I Use Code 0 4- CONDOMINIUM 1 5.69 I 6.7427 I 12.4327 Latest Sales History 2013 Preliminary Tax Roll (Not all Safes are listed due to Confidentiality) (Subject to Change) Date Book-Page Amount I i Land Value $0 10/02/12 ' 4850-1571 $0 I i (+)Improved Value $228,800 07/22/11 4704-1843 I $ 270,000 I i (=) Market Value $228,8001 07/20/04 3609-2796 $ 395,000 I 1 _ 10/28/03 I 3431-2351 $0 I I (-) SOH*&other Exempt. $01 05/17/96 I 2184-1818 I $ 260,000 f ■ (=)Assessed Value $ 228,800 , (-) Homestead&other Exempt. $0 (=)Taxable Value $ 228,8001 (_) School Taxable Value $ 228,800 If all Values shown above equal 0 this parcel was created after the Final Tax Roll 'SOH='Save Our Homes”exempt value due to cap on assessment increases. http://www.collierappraiser.com/Main Search/RecordDetail,html?FullAddress=la+penins... 9/25/2013 q 2013 FLORIDA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY ANNUAL REPORT FILED DOCUMENT#L12000127338 Feb 04, 2013 Entity Name: LA PENINSULA, LLC Secretary of State Current Principal Place of Business: 2029 BIRCHWOOD WAY BLOOMFIELD HILLS, MI 48302 Current Mailing Address: 2029 BIRCHWOOD WAY BLOOMFIELD HILLS, MI 48302 FEI Number:46-1220567 Certificate of Status Desired: No Name and Address of Current Registered Agent: NRAI SERVICES,INC. 515 E.PARK AVE. TALLAHASSEE,FL 32301 US The above named entity submits this statement for the purpose of changing its registered office or registered agent,or both,In the State of Florida. SIGNATURE: Electronic Signature of Registered Agent Date Manager/Member Detail Detail : Title MGR Name MAHAJAN,RAKA Address 2029 BIRCHWOOD WAY City-State-Zip: BLOOMFIELD HILLS MI 48302 t hereby certify that the information indicated on this report or suppiementalreport is tam and accurate and that my electronic signature shall have the same legal effect as if made under call);that tam a managing member or manager of the limited liability company or the receiver or trustee empowered to execute this report as required by Chapter 606 Florida Statutes;and that my name appears above,or on en attachment withal other like empowered. SIGNATURE:RAKA MAHAJAN MANAGER 02/04/2013 Electronic Signature of Signing Manager/Member Detail Date Cud _--cu,.,...".......L t_s,- ` To to 7 . Collier County Commissioners' Oil Meeting Speech 10/08 Unless the Collier County Commission passes and enforces local ordinances, Hughes is free under current law (and these issued permits) to employ any of the newer drilling processes known as "slick water, high pressure, high volume, horizontal fracking." Horizontal directional drilling poses far greater risk to health and environment than vertical drilling. Consider this, in order to do what they do, the Bush administration had to exempt the industry from key provisions of seven federal environmental laws: the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, the Safe Drinking Water Act, the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act and the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act. Exempt means unaccountable. The federal authorities won't regulate; the state authorities won't do it, either. Recklessly the oil industry is invited to regulate itself! The industry hype promoting drilling the Everglades does not realistically show the very real impacts of this type of energy development. New extraction processes are not "perfectly safe" and not "clean" at all! And it is certainly not the same drilling that's been done "safely" for more than 60 years, as we've been told to believe. Hughes is free under current law to employ the newer process and technology without applying for any new permits, in fact, without telling us that they're doing it. The recently permitted well effectively begins the industrialization of our treasured Everglades' environment. If colliers insist on exploring and extracting the tight oil in Sunniland we will pay a price that is much more than we can afford. Collier County's industrialization runs rampant when we permit oil drilling. The concomitant fresh water contamination, air quality and health issues, road destruction, erosion, illegal dumping, landowner rights abuses, and quality of life issues associated with extracting the oil beneath us are staggering! The long term environmental and health impacts for humans, flora and fauna have not been adequately assessed ahead of this rush to drill. John P. Dwyer, Ph.D. 1 7 You County Commissioners have the power to protect us where the effete regulators have failed. Please take a brave stand and do not gamble away our most precious paradise. We need strong county ordinances, strictly enforced. Air Pollution For those of us who have lived here for decades well know, along with those of us who have driven with open eyes through the area of the dark ghosts of pine trees pointing their dark fingers at the heavens can guess, that the Golden Gate and Everglades "brush fires" of uncontrollable violence of the past will rush through, wind-driven for miles, during the dry season. Some years we are lucky. Some not. Some fires are started by careless people's campfires, cigarettes, some by perverse attempts to build rain clouds in a very dry sky. Some are started by freak dry season lightning strikes. But to have at each well site a gas flare! If you've ever lived in oil country, as I have and meditated upon its ordinary ten-foot/lame roaring upward, have observed how the flare periodically and suddenly expands and becomes more violent. To place such a thing in Golden Gate or in Big Cypress or in any other part of the Everglades is insane. The 2013 Florida Statutes 403.072 Pollution Prevention Act.—Sections 403.072-403.074 may be cited as the "Pollution Prevention Act." D, E, F, G 403.021 Pollution of air and waters of South Florida is a menace to public health and welfare, creates a public nuisance, and is harmful to wildlife, fish and other aquatic life. Such oil drilling pollution impairs domestic, agricultural and recreational uses of air and water. John P. Dwyer, Ph.D. 2 7 Because it is the declared public policy of Florida to achieve and maintain levels of air quality as will protect human health and safety as well as prevent injury to plant and animal life, we subscribe to fostering the comfort and convenience of the people and want to facilitate the enjoyment of the natural attractions of this state. Furthermore the legislature has declared that citizens should be afforded protection from the dangers inherent in the release of toxic or hazardous vapors, gases, or volatile liquids into the environment. Oil drilling in Naples is antithetical to each of these elements our legislators' statutes have affirmed. First is the release of hazardous air pollutants, including deadly hydrogen sulfide as well as sulfur dioxide created when the well flare combusts this and other gasses brought to the surface by drilling. Moreover, the 24/7 three-month use of three 1,000 horsepower diesel engines on site will produce levels of pollutants and noise that will disturb if not destroy our natural flora and fauna. This is not to mention the hundreds of diesel trucks bringing in the rig and associated materials for pad, road, pipes, chemicals, storage tanks, and temporary housing on the unimproved dirt road smoking the whole neighborhood with thick dust. Second, the oil and gas industry cannot be exempted from pollution regulations that prohibit such lethal and carcinogenic compounds as benzene, toluene, methane, sulphur dioxide, and polycyclic hydrocarbons. These substances, even when flared, are going to interact with atmospheric gases to form ground-level ozone, carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and deposits of hazardous particulate matter and other gases inimical to the famed salubriousness of South Florida's air and the cleansing effects of our famed sheet water flow. John P. Dwyer, Ph.D. 3 ' 7 The statute specifically prohibits "new wetland impacts." Simply designating a parcel or a field as for "agricultural use" does not stop the natural annual rise of the water table nor diminish the considerable volume of sheet flow during an especially good rainy season like this one. A two foot berm around the well cannot prevent fluid migration when the water level exceeds two feet (as in September it nearly always does) and the flow rushes over the berms and back into the surrounding wetlands. Third, 403.021 provides that no wastes be discharged into any state waters without first being given the degree of treatment necessary to protect the beneficial uses of such water. The over 700 different chemicals used in drilling are extremely dangerous to humans and other life forms and are concentrated in the constantly recycled drilling fluids euphemistically referred to as "brine" and the chemically coated "filings" that sift down to the bottom of the holding pools. Without local ordinances that strictly comply with state statutes, drilling even more wells in the Sunniland Trend will adversely affect human, animal, plant, and aquatic life that flourish here. 60 % of all US oil and gas wells used fracking while horizontally drilling. There must be an absolute prohibition from drilling companies' use of various acids and the many trade-secret chemicals so inimical to the health and welfare of local forms of life. These fluids and filings must be constantly monitored by true chemists (now in very short supply) who will frequently test for all specifically-prohibited compounds, and who will make their results easily accessible to the public so that the nearly universal corporate tendency to ignore regulations is suppressed. The supposed 800 tests of water per day by Collier authorities are not focused on the trade secret chemicals of the drillers and so produce results that we cannot trust. John P. Dwyer, Ph.D. 4 7 .01 For example, when we test for arsenic, we cannot see the strontium or anything else. All we can see are various concentrations of arsenic. The "final" injection of these many lethal fluids and particles into the boulder zone does not in any way guarantee their exclusion from migration upward and outward into our precious state waters. Such vile pollution of our now pure state waters and air is a careless and morally repugnant destruction of our rapidly depleting natural resources. Discharging well drilling wastes into the state's pure water, discharging well drilling gases into our now clean and pure air and causing deadly precipitants to fall into our sheet flow where it will be consumed by thirsty wildlife and filter down into our shallow household water wells is criminal. What these permits have done is authorize new land disturbance, new wetland impacts, new air pollution as well as promote the presumption of innocence that drilling companies will not use acidification or hydraulic fracturing. Each of these grievous consequences is prohibited by 403.021. Water Pollution 403.0625/863 403.0625 Environmental laboratory certification; water quality tests conducted by a certified laboratory To assure the acceptable quality, reliability, and validity of testing results, the department and the Department of Health shall jointly establish criteria for certification of laboratories that perform analyses of environmental samples that are not covered by the provisions in s. 403.863. John P. Dwyer, Ph.D. 5 7 .4 403.863 State public water supply laboratory certification program.— (1) The department and the Department of Health shall jointly develop a state program, and the Department of Health shall adopt rules for the evaluation and certification of all laboratories, other than the principal state laboratory, which perform or make application to perform analyses pursuant to the Florida Safe Drinking Water Act or which conduct a water analysis business. Such joint development shall be funded in part through the use of a portion of the State Public Water Systems Supervision Program grants received by the department from the Federal Government in order to implement the federal act. Last week's homework assignment for you was to read Michael Klare's �p book along with Richard Heinberg's. I also sent you each a web page 63, �--t .ducting pictures of typical oil rigs, engines, trucks and tanks to let you know what to expect on 24th Avenue S.E. and to give you an idea what our Desoto Blvd. children and parents are threatened with--even if nothing goes wrong. Do you really have the heart to allow this to happen? We need you to acknowledge that you have the right and the jurisdiction to say what the Colliers and their drillers are going to do with our land use. When the stewards of Paradise, Adam and Eve were about to be tempted, angels came to predict the temptation and prophesy what would happen in the future if they succumbed. Our local stewards are no better than Adam and Eve. Please, listen to the right voices. Don't just allow the stewards to exercise their free will. We've seen what happened last time. John P. Dwyer, Ph.D. 6 MORRIS DEPEW ENGINEERS•PLANNERS•SURVEYORS LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS #LC26000330 Traffic Accident Analysis— Corkscrew Road Excavation, DCI2006-00026 Introduction This traffic accident analysis was undertaken to determine whether the number of heavy trucks(dump trucks,cement mixers,etc.)traveling on Alico Road and Corkscrew Road in southeast Lee County make the roadways less safe than other roadways in Lee County, and if the trucks negatively impact public health, safety and welfare.To gain a better overview of the County roadway network in general, data was gathered from the Lee County DOT and GIS. Additionally, reference is made to the Lee County Comprehensive Plan (Lee Plan). Tracy Burrows (A Survey of Zoning Definitions. Planning Advisory Service, 1989; p. 33) defines an arterial road is one which is interregional in nature,conveying traffic between towns, boroughs, and other urban centers. Efficient movement is the primary function of arterial roads, hence, private access and frontage should be controlled and limited to high-volume generators of vehicle trips.Arterials provide direct, relatively high speed service for longer trips and large traffic volumes. Mobility is emphasized, and access is often limited.Arterial roads typically carry higher traffic volumes and a wider variety of traffic types at higher speeds than collector or local roadways. Corkscrew Road is a two lane road and is classified as an arterial on Map 3B of the Lee Plan map series, and is also designated as a Second Order Facility on the Collier County Metropolitan Planning Organization on the Collier-Lee Bi-County Transportation Network(Highways Component) map dated March 5, 2007. Background Policy 7.1.3 of the Lee Plan requires that'industrial land uses must be located in areas appropriate to their special needs and constraints, including but not limited to, considerations of....access by truck, air, deep water and rail...' Policy 7.1.9 states that'industrial development will not be permitted if it allows industrial traffic to travel through predominantly residential areas.' Because the Corkscrew Road Excavation project is accessed solely by an arterial roadway,which by definition is designed to carry high volumes of traffic at higher speeds, it is fair to state that the truck trips traveling to and from the operation will not travel through predominantly residential neighborhoods. The limited residential neighborhoods/residential uses in the Southeast Lee County area are typically accessed by privately- owned local roadways, most of which are unpaved and characteristic of the rural, agricultural development in the area. There is a heavy concentration of dump trucks and concrete batch plants in this part of the County because this location is where a great deal of the limerock resources exists—it also occurs in the northeast and northwest portions of Lee County. However,Southeast Lee County has historically been the main source of limerock in the region. The area is sparsely populated compared to the rest of the County, and there are large agricultural uses in the area. The relative lack of population in the area has provided some justification in the past for allowing excavation activities to be located in this area; Lee County has indicated that it would preserve this area from incursions by urban uses. Due to the rural nature of the area,there are only two major roadways serving the area: Alico Road and Corkscrew Road. ` 7 Accident Analysis A review of the 2005 and 2006 crash reports revealed that the vast majority of accidents in Lee County occur at the intersections of 1-75 and US 41,the County's major north-south corridors. 2005 Lee County Worst Intersections for Crashes 1 1-75 &Corkscrew Road 2 US 41&Cypress Lake Dr/Daniels 3 1-75 &Daniels Pkwy 4 US 41&Gladiolus/Six Mile 5 1-75&Colonial Blvd 6 US 41&College Pkwy/Woodland 7 Del Prado &Veterans 8 1-75&Alico Road 9 SR 82 &Colonial/Lee 10 1-75&Bonita Beach Road 11 Colonial Blvd &Ortiz/Six Mile Cypress 12 US 41& Pondella Rd 13 US 41 & Pine Island Rd 14 US 41& Hancock Bridge Pkwy 15 Gladiolus Dr. &Summerlin 16 Daniels Pkwy&Six Mile Cypress 17 US 41 & Bonita Beach Rd 18 Old US 41&Terry St. 19 1-75&Palm Beach Blvd. 20 Colonial Blvd & Metro Pkwy 21 US 41&Colonial Blvd 22 US 41&Alico Road 23 College Pkwy&Summerlin Rd 24 US 41& Boyscout/Fowler 25 College Pkwy&Winkler Those intersections in the chart above in boldface font indicate interstate exchanges. Lee County DOT data rated the 2005 data by number of crashes; six of the 25 involved 1-75 and 10 of the 25 involved US 41 (not Old US 41). In 2005, 64%of the most dangerous intersections involved 1-75 or US 41. Lee County DOT revised their reporting methods somewhat for 2006, rating the intersections by crash rate rather than by sheer number of incidents. This methodology took into consideration the volume of traffic and calculated an accident rate, revealing the following intersections as the 25 most dangerous for 2006: 2 I P a g e Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 ' 7 2006 Lee County Worst Intersections for Crashes 1 SR 82&Gunnery Road 2 College Pkwy& McGregor 3 Corkscrew Rd & Ben Hill Griffin 4 US 41 & Pondella 5 Buckingham &Cemetary 6 Lee Blvd &Gunnery Rd 7 Corkscrew Rd &Three Oaks Pkwy 8 1-75 &Corkscrew Rd 9 US 41& Daniels/Cypress Lake 10 SR 82 &Colonial Blvd 11 US 41&Gladiolus/Six Mile 12 Del Prado&Veterans Pkwy 13 US 41&College/Woodland 14 SR 82 &Gateway Blvd. 15 US 41&Pine Island Rd 16 Colonial Blvd. &Ortiz/Six Mile 17 US 41&Alico Rd 18 Pine Island Rd &Woodward Ave 19 Ortiz Ave& Ballard Rd 20 McGregor Blvd &Summerlin 21 Cypress Lake&Summerlin 22 Metro Pkwy&Crystal 23 Cypress Lake & McGregor 24 US 41& Bonita Beach Rd 25 Colonial Blvd &Summerlin The list of 2005 and 2006 most dangerous intersections were then cross-referenced, revealing the locations of the most dangerous intersections for the two year period. Because the methodologies for the 2005 list varied from the 2006 list, all 1-75 intersections were disregarded, and only arterial and collector intersections were evaluated. This time frame was specifically analyzed, as it was during this time the traffic volumes were the highest,and local construction was at its peak. The following intersections were than ranked on a scale of 1 to 10, 1 having the highest incidence of accidents. 2005 2006 rank rank US 41&Pondella 7 1 US 41&Daniels/Cypress Lake 1 2 US 41&Gladiolus/Six Mile 2 3 SR 82&Colonial Blvd 5 4 Del Prado&Veterans Pkwy 4 5 US 41&College/Woodland 3 6 3IPage Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 $ 7 ' ` US 41&Pine Island Rd 8 7 Colonial Blvd.&Ortiz/Six Mile 6 8 US 41&Alico Rd 10 9 US 41&Bonita Beach Rd 9 10 US 41 intersections are among the most dangerous in Lee County; US 41 intersections ranked the top four most dangerous intersections for both 2005 and 2006. Note that the intersection of US 41 &Alico Road rated 10th for 2005 and 9th for 2006, and that US 41 & Bonita Beach Road was rated 9th in 2005 and 10th in 2006. Attention is directed at these two intersections due to their proximity to mining operations, as it should be noted that 1-75 is the preferred route by heavy truck operators to travel north or south. However, both of these interchanges have substantial commercial and retail development near the interchanges as well. Composition of Traffic on Alico and Corkscrew Roads Lee County DOT prepared a memo for a zoning case near the Alico Road corridor, and in it, stated that "large trucks comprised the majority of traffic on Alico Road.The majority of large trucks on Alico Road appear to be dump trucks traveling to and from mining uses." The Lee County Truck Impact Evaluation report prepared for Lee County by David Douglas Associates, Inc. supports this assertion. This is due, in part,to the fact that: 1)the Alico Road corridor is the historical mining corridor in Lee County, as this is where the resource exists; 2)the nearest access to 1-75 is via the Alico Road interchange; and 3) zoning conditions for mines along Corkscrew Road often required that trucks utilize the Alico Road to access I- 75 rather than Corkscrew Road. 2008 Average%of Trucks for Alico&Corkscrew Roads 3 -month Roadway Link Feb. March April avg. Alico Rd E of Ben Hill Griffin 52.93% 54.20% 55.94% 54.36% Alico Rd W of Green Meadow Rd 54.52% 51.25% 56.46% 54.08% Alico Rd N of Corkscrew 43.09% 38.47% 48.13% 43.23% Corkscrew Rd E of Ben Hill Griffin 10.34% 11.15% 10.09% 10.53% Corkscrew Rd W of Alico 23.88% 21.20% 24.41% 23.16% Corkscrew Rd W of County Line Rd 12.08% 12.97% 17.22% 14.09% Source: Lee County Truck Impact Evaluation(July 2008) Crashes on Alico and Corkscrew Roads Realizing that up to an average of 54 percent of traffic on Alico Road and up to 23 percent of traffic on Corkscrew Road is comprised of large trucks, an analysis of the percentage of accidents involving large trucks was undertaken. 2004-2006 When all accident reports from the 2004-2006 for the area east of 1-75 on Alico and Corkscrew Roads were reviewed, 189 accidents were found, 22.7 percent of which involved a heavy truck. This data indicates that one was less likely to be involved in an incident involving a heavy truck (i.e., dump truck or cement mixer)than to be involved in a single vehicle accident or an accident involving another passenger vehicle. This is significant when viewed in light County Staff's 4 P a g e Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 $ 7 assertion that the "large trucks comprised the majority of traffic on Alico Road." If±50 percent of the traffic on Alico Road is comprised of heavy trucks, one could assume that up to 50 percent of the number of accidents would involve heavy trucks. However, only 25 percent of the accidents on the roadway involved heavy trucks; statistically, heavy trucks were less likely to be involved in a crash than were passenger vehicles. Of those accidents which did involve heavy trucks,41 percent involved a passenger vehicle, 37 percent were single vehicle incidents, and 22 percent involved more than one heavy truck. Simple laws of physics would have one conclude that accidents involving heavy trucks and passenger vehicles should result in a higher number of injury or fatal accidents. Interestingly, only nine out of 33 (27%) accidents involving heavy trucks resulted in injuries or possible injuries. In comparison, 22 out of 77 (28%) accidents not involving heavy trucks resulted in injury, and in addition to those accidents with injuries,three out of 77 accidents not involving heavy trucks were fatal. There were no fatal accidents in which a heavy truck was involved during this time frame. The number of accidents involving heavy trucks which resulted in either injuries or fatalities on Corkscrew and Alico Roads is considerably lower than the state-wide average. Accidents with Injuries (2004-2006) 60 50 40 - i 30 C , 20 10 0 �__ 1111111111 111W No,None, N/A Non-incapacitating Possible Yes Fatality •Accidents with no Heavy Truck •Accidents with Heavy Truck Source: Florida Traffic Crash Reports for Corkscrew Road 2004-2006 State-wide data indicates that the 1 percent of passenger vehicle accidents result in fatalities in both 2005 and 2006, but 67-69 percent of passenger vehicle accidents resulted in injuries. By comparison, 2- 3 percent of accidents involving medium, heavy or tractor trucks resulted in fatalities, but only 58-59 percent of those accidents resulted in injuries. State-wide,the percentage of accidents involving large trucks which result in injury or fatality is nearly identical to that of buses, and very similar to that of accidents which involve recreational vehicles(RVs). 5IPage Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 7 State-wide Injuries and Fatalities Crash Data by vehicle type(2005-2006) Injuries Fatalities 2006 2005 2005 2006 Auto, passenger van, light truck 67% 69% 1% 1% Medium, heavy, or tractor-truck 58% 59% 2% 3% RV 52% 56% 3% 3% Bus 54% 58% 1% 1% Bike, moped, motorcycle 90% 91% 5% 4% Other, unknown 70% 68% 1% 1% Source: Traffic Crash Statistics Report 2005,Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles When individual intersections are analyzed to determine the number of accidents involving passenger vehicles and heavy trucks, every intersection had a higher incidence of automobile accidents than heavy truck accidents with the exception of Alico Road &Airport Haul Road and Alico Road &the entrance at Florida Rock. The intersection with the highest number of accidents is Corkscrew Road and Ben Hill Griffin where 90 percent of the accidents did not involve a heavy truck. At the intersection of Alico Road and Ben Hill Griffin (where upwards of 50 percent of the traffic is heavy truck traffic), only eight of 20 accidents east of the intersection involved heavy trucks. Thus, in 2004—2006,one was no more likely to be involved in a traffic accident involving a dump truck or cement mixer than one was to be involved in an accident with a regular passenger vehicle. __----------------- 2004-2008 Crash Data by Vehicle Type Other,none, unknown Q u Medium-Heavy truck •Corkscrew -c Ol •Alico Passenger vehicle 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Crashes Source: CDMS Crash Data Summary Report,Corkscrew Road 2004-2008(Lee County DOT) CDMS Crash Data Summary Report,Alico Road 2004-2008(Lee County DOT) Wage Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 Accidents within 2600' of Intersection (2004-06) Corkscrew&Wildcat Run I Corkscrew&Stoneybrook Corkscrew&Bella Terra ■ Corkscrew&Miromar Corkscrew&Ben Hill Griffin Alico&Treeline is With Heavy Trucks Alico&Mallard j II Passenger Vehicle Only Alico&Florida Rock Alico&Devore i Alico&Corkscrew Alico& Ben Hill Griffin Alico&Airport Haul Road 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 2007-2008 Corkscrew Road Lee County DOT traffic accident data reveals no major incidence of accidents involving heavy trucks such as cement mixers or dump trucks from 2007—2008 on Corkscrew Road. During this time period there was one fatality on the Corkscrew Road which involved a single automobile. Analysis of the At Fault Vehicle Crash distribution indicates that of the four incidents involving heavy trucks: • no citations of aggressive driving listed as a contributing factor • lane departure was listed as a contributing factor in two cases • there were no associated fatalities • there was one injury By contrast, of the accidents involving passenger vehicles (automobile, pickup truck, passenger van): • there were three instances of aggressive driving • lane departure was listed as a contributing factor in 21 cases • there was one fatality • there were 15 injuries Looking only at data retrieved from accident reports during the 2007-2008 timeframe, 35 accidents occurred, only two of which involved heavy trucks. Of those two accidents,the first 7 I P a g e Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 one involved the driver of a passenger vehicle who was at fault(he swerved into the truck driver's lane), and the other involved two dump trucks where one rear-ended the other and there were no injuries. Five of the 35 accidents involved alcohol,one involved an ATV and two involved animals. Out of all 35 reports, 30 of the accidents were single-vehicle. The data indicate that during this time period, motorists on Corkscrew Road or Alico Road were more likely to be involved in a single-vehicle crash than a crash involving a heavy truck, and more likely to be involved in an accident as a result of an animal than to be involved in an accident involving a dump truck. This data analysis is consistent with testimony given by another traffic expert regarding the incidences of traffic accidents on Corkscrew Road between 2003 and 2006. At the Estero IPD hearing testimony he stated that of 153 accidents on Corkscrew Road between Westwind Mine and 1-75, passenger cars accounted for 85 percent of the accidents while trucks accounted for 15 percent. (Banks,Transcript 15, pages 117-118 of Estero IPD, DC12006-00007). Accident Analysis: Corkscrew Road 2007-2008 Dump truck Type of Accident involved Percent Total Percent Alcohol involved 0 of 35 0.00% 5 of 35 14.28% Animal involved 0 of 35 0.00% 2 of 35 5.71% ATV involved 0 of 35 0.00% 1 of 35 2.86% Fatality 0 of 35 0.00% 1 of 35 2.86% Dump truck involved 2 of 35 5.71% 2 of 35 5.71% Injuries 0 of 35 0.00% 8 of 35 22.86% Wet road condition 0 of 35 0.00% 4 of 35 11.43% Night/dusk/dawn 0 of 35 0.00% 18 of 35 51.43% Ran in ditch/culvert 0 of 35 0.00% 14 of 35 40.00% Rear-end collision 1 of 35 2.86% 3 of 35 8.57% Single Vehicle Accident 0 of 35 0.00% 30 of 35 85.71% Two Vehicle Accident 2 of 35 5.71% 5 of 35 14.28% An analysis of accidents occurring within 2000' of an intersection along Corkscrew Road during 2007-2008 reveals that passenger vehicles are more likely to be involved in an accident at an intersection than is a heavy truck. Of the six intersections reviewed, only two of 29 intersection accidents(6 percent) involved a heavy truck. Fatalities Lee County DOT created a map which indicates the number of fatalities on Lee County roadways from 2002—2004. Consistent with the data regarding the volume of traffic and high incidence of accidents, I- 75 and US 41 were ranked as most deadly,followed by SR 82,SR 78 and SR 80. 1-75 and US 41 are the major north-south corridors in the county, and SR 82,SR 78 and SR 80 are the major east-west corridors with high traffic volumes. All of these roadways are classified as arterials,with the exception being 1-75 which is an interstate. 8IPage Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 b. 7 r 2002-2004 Lee County Roadway Fatalities Roadway From To #fatalities 1-75 Charlotte County line Collier Co. line 31 US 41 Charlotte County line Collier Co. line 13 SR 82 US 41 Hendry Co. line 12 SR 78 Stringfellow Road Alva Bridge 12 SR 80 US 41 Hendry Co. line 11 Veterans/Colonial Pkwy Cape Coral Pkwy SR 82 8 McGregor Blvd US 41 Shell Point Blvd. 8 Summerlin Road Colonial Blvd Pine Ridge 4 Corkscrew Road US 41 Hendry Co. line 2 Treeline Blvd. Daniels Pkwy Corkscrew Rd 1 Alico Road US 41 Corkscrew Rd 1 Source: Lee County Fatal Crashes 2002-2004(Lee County DOT) Further analysis was undertaken to determine the ratio of the number traffic fatalities to the roadway length. 1-75 again was rated at the top with 0.92 fatalities per mile,followed by Veterans Parkway/Colonial Boulevard second with 0.73 fatalities per mile, and McGregor Boulevard third with 0.62 fatalities per mile. By comparison,one fatal accident occurred on Alico Road and two fatal accidents occurred on Corkscrew Road during the same time period, resulting in an incidence of 0.09 and 0.13 fatalities per mile, respectively. Alico and Corkscrew Roads have fewer fatalities per mile than does McGregor Boulevard or Summerlin Road. Fatalities per mile 1.00 0.90 --- i 0.80 0.70 0.60 0.50 0.40 { 0.30 7 0.20 t — — —4—Fatalities per mile 0.10 t 0.00 .G_ 9IPage Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 .., 7 i . A review of crash data from Lee County DOT reveals that from 2004-2008 there were four fatalities along Alico and Corkscrew Roads,three of which were at or near the intersection of Corkscrew and Alico Road. In five years of reporting(part of which coincides with the time when the construction industry was at its peak)on a roadway on which by all accounts the majority the traffic is comprised of heavy trucks,the number of fatalities as a result of heavy trucks is zero (which is below the state average [percentage] for accidents involving heavy trucks). However,four fatal crashes did involve passenger vehicles. Furthermore,from 2004-2008, a higher percentage of passenger vehicles was cited as being the at-fault vehicle in a crash than was medium or heavy trucks. Alico Road Crashes- Corkscrew Road Crashes - At Fault Vehicle Type At Fault Vehicle Type Other, 2004-2008 II 2004-2008 none, unknown Other, 17% none, lim, C M-•ium- unknown 11 II i Source: CDMS Crash Data Summary Report,Corkscrew Road 2004-2008(Lee County DOT) CDMS Crash Data Summary Report,Alico Road 2004-2008(Lee County DOT) State statistics In order to provide additional supporting evidence of the data provided by local crash reports, data from the Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles website' was also analyzed. This data revealed County- wide crash data, and indicated that in 2006, passenger cars,vans and light trucks comprised 89.6%of all crashes state-wide. Bicycles, motorcycles, mopeds,ATVs,trains, low speed vehicles, 'other or unknown', and RVs made up 5.6%of the total accidents. Buses made up less than 1%of all crashes. According to the state statistics, in Lee County the average number of annual total accidents from 2002- 2006 was 29,293. Of those accidents,an average of 9.44%involved commercial motor vehicles(CMV), and 2.6%involved fatalities. Only 0.25%of all of the fatality accidents involved a CMV. (A CMV is defined as having a GVW of 26,001 lbs or more, designed to transport more than 15 persons, or transports hazardous materials.) By comparison, again 22.7%of the accidents east of 1-75 on Corkscrew or Alico Roads involved a heavy truck. And while this number is more than double the average number of accidents involving heavy trucks on a county-wide basis, it is important to keep in perspective the fact that Alico and Corkscrew Roads are unique in that nearly 30-50%of the traffic on these facilities consists of heavy trucks. 10 IPage Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 7 State-wide, in 2006 the number of light trucks listed on the contributing causes of accidents was invariably higher than for medium, heavy or tractor trailer trucks. Light trucks were involved with more accidents than were the heavier trucks combined (light trucks= 69,729; medium, heavy and tractor trucks= 15,317). According to the Florida traffic crash report, 'light trucks' are pickup trucks or trucks with 2 or 4 rear tires, medium trucks have 4 rear tires,and heavy trucks have 2 or more rear axles. In addition, careless driving was listed as the contributing cause of 71,866 accidents state-wide. Of those, 15,072 were attributed to light trucks,which is more than 5 times the number of medium, heavy and tractor trucks combined (2,966 total combined). In general, a similar trend is seen for all contributing causes of all the accidents from 2004-2006. Below are additional interesting facts from the state's traffic data: • In 2006, motorcycles were involved in almost twice as many accidents state-wide than were medium or heavy trucks. (9,259 motorcycles, 5,150 medium trucks, 5,189 heavy trucks). • In 2005, passenger vehicles(cars, light trucks and vans) accounted for 88%of the total number of vehicles involved in fatal crashes state-wide. Medium trucks and heavy trucks accounted for 3%and 4%, respectively. Tractor-trailer trucks also accounted for 4%of the total. • In Lee County, CMV-related crashes ranged from 8.18%-10.66%during the five year time frame. Less than one-half of one percent(0.5%)of all crashes resulting in a fatality involved a CMV. (Note: none of the accidents on Corkscrew or Alico Roads east of 1-75 involved a fatality from 2004—2008). Lee County Crash Statistics 2002-2006 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 Lee County-Total Crashes 5634 5963 5834 6237 5625 5 year fatality history 71 121 108 150 121 Percentage 1.26% 2.03% 1.85% 2.41% 2.15% 5 year injury history 5096 5571 5240 5686 4698 Percentage 90.45% 93.43% 89.82% 91.17% 83.52% 5 year CMV related crash history 461 528 537 665 573 Percentage 8.18% 8.85% 9.20% 10.66% 10.19% 5 year CMV related fatality history 11 13 12 23 13 Percentage 0.20% 0.22% 0.21% 0.37% 0.23% 5 year injury history 5096 5571 5240 5686 4698 5 year CMV related injury history 392 468 474 650 414 Percentage 7.69% 8.40% 9.05% 11.43% 8.81% Source: Traffic Crash Statistics Report 2006,Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles 11 I P a g e Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 t ; 7 a 2006 Florida Crash Data, Contributing Causes # Medium #Heavy #Truck Total # Light trucks truck truck tractor Careless driving 71886 15072 986 1013 967 Failed/Yield ROW 33705 5920 344 257 195 Improper backing 2804 607 114 147 78 Improper lane change 6026 964 132 189 254 Improper turn 6290 1078 103 117 129 Alcohol-under influence 7629 2035 62 10 4 Drugs-under influence 770 187 5 1 7 Alcohol &drugs-under 1266 326 6 1 1 influence Followed too closely 7736 1569 114 105 71 Disregarded traffic signal 1386 1360 90 72 45 Exceeded safe speed limit 5252 1051 41 58 72 Exceeded stated speed limit 3252 604 26 23 15 Disregarded stop sign 1977 401 55 79 52 Failed to maintain 1031 204 8 15 12 equipment Improper passing 1670 394 12 17 18 Drove left of center 1561 286 9 10 4 Obstructing traffic 504 94 10 14 16 Improper load 228 105 28 24 29 Disregard other traffic 664 123 9 4 6 control Driving wrong side/way 1088 143 10 6 2 Fleeing police 519 93 1 0 0 Vehicle modified 29 7 1 0 0 Driver distraction 1851 405 27 13 11 All other 30423 5203 455 493 451 Source: Tables 25,Traffic Crash Statistics Report 2006, Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles Conclusion The incidence of accidents involving dump trucks/cement mixers and passenger vehicles is proportionately lower than the number of accidents involving two passenger vehicles. Both Alico Road and Corkscrew Roads which are heavily utilized by dump trucks and cement mixer trucks have lower rates of fatality accidents than Summerlin Road, Colonial Boulevard, and McGregor Boulevard, and also have a fatality rate of crashes involving heavy trucks of zero; the state average of accidents involving heavy trucks was 1% in 2005 and 2006. Vehicle crashes on Corkscrew Road are more likely to not involve a heavy truck than to involve a heavy truck. More accidents occurred at Corkscrew Road and Miromar Mall (which is presumably mostly passenger vehicle traffic)than occurred at the intersection of Alico Road and Ben Hill Griffin where the majority of traffic is heavy trucks. 12 I P a g e Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 Crashes Involving Heavy Trucks(2004-2006) Corkscrew &Alico State County Roads 2004 20443 537 10 %of accidents with injuries 88.30% 88.30% 20.00% %of accidents with fatalities 2.28% 2.23% 0.00% 2005 22804 665 16 %of accidents with injuries 84.30% 97.70% 6.30% %of accidents with fatalities 2.35% 3.46% 0.00% 2006 20774 573 17 %of accidents with injuries 81.55% 72.23% 35.29% %of accidents with fatalities 2.10% 2.27% 0.00% Sources: Traffic Crash Statistics Report 2005,Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles and Lee County accident reports This analysis concludes that the number of heavy trucks traveling on local roadways does not result in an increase in the rate of injury or fatal accidents. Despite the perception that heavy trucks such as dump trucks make the area roadways more dangerous,empirical data simply does not support this assumption. Utilizing state data and the County's accident reports, less than 3 percent of all accidents in Lee County involving heavy trucks occur on Alico and Corkscrew Roads. Further, when compared to state and county crash accident incidents overall, Corkscrew and Alico Roads have considerably better safety records. Attachments A. Map- Lee County Fatal Crashes 2002-2004 B. Map—Lee County 2005 Traffic Crashes C. CDMS Crash Data Summary, Corkscrew Road 2004-2008 D. CDMS Crash Data Summary,Alico Road 2004-2008 http://www.flhsmv.gov/reports/crash facts.html 13 IPage Corkscrew Road Excavation(MDA 05161) May 11,2009 7 .... SONNEttiOCR OFFICE OF THE HEARING EXAMINER, LEE COUNTY, FLORIDA HEARING EXAMINER RECOMMENDATION voLumE RECOMMENDATION for DCI2006-00026 RESOURCE CONSERVATION HOLDINGS, LLC, in reference to CORKSCREW EXCAVATION , � OFFICE OF THE HEARING EXAMINER, LEE COUNTY FLORIDA HEARING EXAMINER RECOMMENDATION HEARING DATES: MAY 27, 2009, MAY 28, 2009, MAY 29, 2009, JUNE 4, 2009, JUNE 5, 2009, AUGUST 19, 2009 AUGUST 20, 2009,AUGUST 21, 2009, AUGUST 26, 2009 SEPTEMBER 25, 2009, SEPTEMBER 29, 2009, SEPTEMBER 30, 2009, OCTOBER 2, 2009, OCTOBER 6, 2009, OCTOBER 7, 2009 OCTOBER 13, 2009, OCTOBER 14, 2009, OCTOBER 20, 2009, OCTOBER 27, 2009, OCTOBER 30, 2009 , NOVEMBER 3, 2009, NOVEMBER 6, 2009 • SITE VISIT: OCTOBER 12, 2009(BLASTING DEMONSTRATION), NOVEMBER 5, 2009 WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS: AUGUST 7, 2009; AUGUST 14, 2009, NOVEMBER 13, 2009 AND NOVEMBER 20, 2009 I. APPLICATION: This matter came before the Lee County Hearing Examiner as an Application for a Rezoning Y 9 pp 9 to an Industrial Planned Development(IPD)pursuant to Lee County Land Development Code (LDC). Filed by RESOURCE CONSERVATION HOLDINGS, LLC, 1700 Corkscrew Road, Estero, Florida 33928 (Applicant/Owner); MORRIS DEPEW ASSOCIATES, INC., c/o DAVID DEPEW, 2914 Cleveland Avenue, Fort Myers, Florida 33901; HOPPING, GREEN&SAMS, Go GARY SAMS,ESQUIRE and SUSAN STEPHENS,ESQUIRE, 123 South Calhoun Street, Tallahassee, Florida 32301; CDM, INC., do KIRK MARTIN, 12501 World Plaza Lane, Fort Myers, Florida 33907; W. DEXTER BENDER & ASSOCIATES, do PAUL OWEN, 2052 Virginia Avenue, Fort Myers, Florida 33901; DRAPER TECHNOLOGIES, c/o PETER PELLERITO, 17595 S. Tamiami Trail, Suite 102, Fort Myers, Florida 33908 (Agents). Request is to rezone 1,365.5± acres from Agricultural (AG-2) to Industrial Planned Development (IPD) to allow the use of an Excavation, mining operation (Construction Materials Mining Operation)with a proposed depth of 110 feet below the wet season water table AND sod farming. Dewatering is not proposed. The proposed use will, if permitted. allow blasting activities. The Applicant has also requested approval of a General Mining Permit. The subject property is located at 16871, 17501, 18701 and 18901 Corkscrew Road,SE Lee County Planning Community, Sections 23 and 24, Township 46 South, Range 26 East, and Section 19, Township 46 South, Range 27 East, Lee County, Florida (District#5). II, STAFF REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION: DENIAL The Department of Community Development Staff Report was prepared by Alvin Block. The Staff Report is incorporated herein by this reference. Case DCI2006-00026 07-Apr-10 - 7 III. RECOMMENDATION OF HEARING EXAMINER: The undersigned Lee County Hearing Examiner recommends that the Lee County Board of County Commissioners APPROVE the Applicant's request for a rezoning from AG-2 to IPD to allow the use of an Excavation, mining operation with a proposed depth of 110 feet below the wet season water table for the real estate described in Section IX. Legal Description WITH THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS: A. CONDITIONS: Conditions to this recommendation are contained in the Appendix attached hereto, which is incorporated herein by reference. B. DEVIATIONS: NONE IV. HEARING EXAMINER DISCUSSION: SYNOPSIS This is a request to rezone a 1,365.5-acre parcel of land, located on Corkscrew Road, from an Agricultural (AG-2)zoning district to an Industrial Planned Development(IPD). Approval of this application will result in the development of a lime rock or aggregate mine. At the end of the mining activity, a 770-acre lake will have been created with a maximum depth of 110 feet. Additional accessory uses are also requested, which include administrative offices, stone, glass and clay products, Groups II and III, repair and maintenance facilities. A hearing was conducted on the request before the undersigned Hearing Examiner, in accordance with an Order issued by Circuit Judge Joseph C. Fuller, dated February 12, 2009. Testimony was taken over a period of 22 days, spread over seven months. The final arguments took place on November 6, 2009. The record comprises approximately 5,000 pages of testimony and argument, including testimony from approximately 36 expert witnesses, 59 members of the public that spoke before this Hearing Examiner, and eight others submitted comments without testifying. Approximately, 228 exhibits are part of the record, as well as, six separate memorandums of law, and responses thereto. Based on the testimony of those witnesses, the exhibits entered into evidence, legal memorandums and the arguments of the Attorneys for the County Staff,Applicant, members of the public and other interested parties,the Hearing Examiner found that a preponderance of the evidence required him to recommend to the Lee County Board of County Commissioners, that the Applicant's request to rezone the subject property should be approved, with conditions. Introduction This is a request to rezone a 1,365.5+1-acre parcel of land, located at 16871, 17501,18701, and 18901 Corkscrew Road, from an Agricultural (AG-2) zoning district to an Industrial Planned Development(IPD). The property has a frontage of 10,439 feet on the north side Case DCI2006-00026 Page 2 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 of Corkscrew Road. It is approximately 6.5 miles east of Interstate 75, and 1.5 miles east of the intersection of Corkscrew and Alico roads. It is also 2.5 miles west of the existing WestWind Mine, which was approved for mining uses in 2001, and 3.5 miles west of what was the proposed Estero Industrial Planned Development Mine,which was denied for mine uses, in 2006. The Schwab 640 Mine, a proposed Industrial Planned Development, is directly south of the property, and was denied for mine uses, in 2001. The subject property is comprised of 91.3 percent uplands(1,247.5 acres), and 8.7 percent wetlands(118 acres). It is within both the Density Reduction/Ground Water (DR/GR) Resources and Wetlands Future Land Use Plan Designations,' and the Southeast Lee County Planning Community.' It is currently being used for cattle grazing and sod farming. Approval of this application will result in the development of a lime rock or aggregate mine. At the end of the mining activity, a 770-acre lake will have been created, with a maximum depth of 110 feet. Additional accessory uses are also requested, to include administrative offices, stone, glass and clay products, Groups II and III, repair and maintenance facilities. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 1.4.5: The Density Reduction/Groundwater Resource(DR/GR)areas include upland areas that provide substantial recharge to aquifers most suitable for future wellfield development.These areas also are the most favorable locations for physical withdrawal of water from those aquifers.Only minimal public facilities exist or are programmed.Land uses in these areas must be compatible with maintaining surface and groundwater levels at their historic levels.Permitted land uses include agriculture, natural resource extraction and related facilities, conservation uses, publicly-owned gun range facilities, private recreation facilities,and residential uses at a maximum density of one dwelling unit per ten acres(1 du/10 acres). Individual residential parcels may contain up to two acres of Wetlands without losing the right to have a dwelling unit, provided that no alterations are made to those wetland areas. Private Recreational Facilities may be permitted in accordance with the site locational requirements and design standards, as further defined in Goal 16. No Private recreational facilities may occur within the DR/GR land use category without a rezoning to an appropriate planned development zoning category,and compliance with the Private Recreation Facilities performance standards,contained in Goal 16 of the Lee Plan. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Objective 1.5: WETLANDS.Designate on the Future Land Use Map those lands that are identified as Wetlands in accordance with F.S. 373.019(17)through the use of the unified state delineation methodology described in FAC Chapter 17-340,as ratified and amended in F.S.373.4211. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 1.5.1: Permitted land uses in Wetlands consist of very low density residential uses and recreational uses that will not adversely affect the ecological functions of wetlands.All development in Wetlands must be consistent with Goal 114 of this plan. The maximum density is one dwelling unit per twenty acres(1 du/20 acre)except as otherwise provided in Table 1(a) and Chapter XIII of this plan. 2 Lee County Comprehensive Plan,Vision Statement,Section 18: Southeast Lee County-As the name implies,this Community Is located in the southeast area of Lee County.South of SR 82,north of Bonita Beach Road,east of 1-75(excluding areas in the San Carlos Park/Island Park/Estero Corkscrew Road and Gateway/Southwest Florida International Airport Communities)and west of the county line.With the exception of a few Public Facilities,the entire community is designated as Density Reduction/Groundwater Resource,Conservation Lands(both upland and wetlands),and Wetlands on the Future Land Use Map.This"community"consists of mining operations,agricultural uses,and very large lot residential home sites.The one exception is the Citrus Park Community. This community is not expected to change in character through the year 2030. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 3 of 70 07-Apr-10- toi The authority and function of the Lee County Hearing Examiner's Office, with respect to zoning matters, is set out in Lee County Land Development Code Section 34-145(d).3 3 Lee County Land Development Code Section 34.145(d): (d)Zoning matters. • (1) Functions. Regarding zoning matters, the hearing examiner has the following prescribed duties and responsibilities: a. Prepare recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners for changes or amendments relating to the boundaries of the various zoning districts or to the regulations applicable to those districts. b. Make recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners on applications relating to the following: 1. Rezonings, including developments of county impact, planned unit developments and planned developments, and any accompanying request to use TDR or affordable housing bonus density. 2.Developments of regional impact and Florida Quality Developments approval,which may or may not include a request for rezoning. 3.Special exceptions that meet the criteria for a development of county impact,as set forth in section 34-203(b). 4.Other special exceptions and variances which are submitted simultaneously with and are heard in conjunction with a rezoning. 5.Variances from any county ordinance which specifies that variances from the ordinance may only be granted by the Board of County Commissioners. 8.Applications to increase density above the Lee Plan standard density range through the use of affordable housing bonus density units. 7.Reinstatements of master concept plans for planned developments. 8.Applications for mine excavation development planned approval under chapter 12. c.Certain amendments to development of regional impact development orders do not require a public hearing. After staff review and recommendation, proposed amendments of this type will proceed directly to the Board of County Commissioners and will be scheduled on the administrative agenda of a regular weekly meeting,The board will vote on the following types of amendments based upon the recommendation of staff without review by the hearing examiner: 1.Amendments that incorporate the terms of a settlement agreement designed to resolve pending administrative litigation or judicial proceedings;or 2.Any amendment contemplated under F.S.§380.06(19)(e)2. (2)Considerations.In preparing his recommendation on any matter,the hearing examiner must consider the criteria set forth in subsection(c)(2)of this section as well as the following,if applicable: a.Whether there exists an error or ambiguity which must be corrected; b.Whether urban services,as defined in the Lee Plan,are,or will be,available and adequate to serve a proposed land use change,when reviewing a proposed change to a future urban area category;and c.Whether a proposed change is intended to rectify errors on the official zoning map. d. Whether the level of access and traffic flow(i.e. median openings, turning movements etc.) is sufficient to support the proposed development intensity. e. If the hearing concerns a mine excavation planned development,whether the request meets the criteria and standards set forth in chapter 12. (3)Findings.Before preparing his recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners on a rezoning,the hearing examiner must find that: a. The applicant has proved entitlement to the rezoning or special exception by demonstrating compliance with the Lee Plan, this land development code, and any other applicable code or Case DCI2006-00026 Page 4 of 70 07-Apr-10- • 7 . � The subject site is bordered on the north by a parcel owned by Lee County,which is subject to a conservation easement, and is identified, on the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, as the Airport Mitigation Overlay Area. East of the property is a large parcel, known as the T E & T Mitigation Area, which is actually owned by the South Florida Water Management District, and leased for use as a mitigation bank. Directly, south of the subject parcel is Corkscrew Road, across from which are four separate parcels. The first of these parcels, located on the eastern portion,is the Schwab 640 Mine,an Industrial Planned Development (IPD). West of that are numerous lots, in the Agricultural zoning districts, known as the 6L Farm's Development. This area consists of large lots,which are agriculturally zoned, and used primarily for residential purposes. They are accessed from a common road, heading south from Corkscrew Road. Further west,along Corkscrew Road, is a parcel comprising a Private Recreational Facilities Planned Development(PRFPD). On the western side of the subject property's southern border is a large parcel comprising an Agricultural Zoning District (AG-2), Finally, due west of the subject property are a number of large lots, commonly referred to as the Burgundy Farms Subdivision,which are all in Agricultural Zoning Districts, regulation:and b.The request will meet or exceed all performance and locational standards set forth for the potential uses allowed by the request;and. c.The request,including the use of TDR or affordable housing bonus density units,is consistent with the densities, intensities and general uses set forth in the Lee Plan;and d.The request is compatible with existing or planned uses in the surrounding area;and e.Approval of the request will not place an undue burden upon existing transportation or planned infrastructure facilities and will be served by streets with the capacity to carry traffic generated by the development;and f.Where applicable,the request will not adversely affect environmentally critical areas and natural resources. g. In the case of a planned development rezoning or mine excavation planned development, the decision of the hearing examiner must also be supported by the formal findings required by sections 34-377(a)(2)and(4). h.Where the change proposed is within a future urban area category,the hearing examiner must also find that urban services,as defined in the Lee Plan,are,or will be,available and adequate to serve the proposed land use. (4)Authority. a.The hearing examiner serves in an advisory capacity to the Board of County Commissioners with respect to zoning matters as set forth in subsection(d)(1)of this section,and in such capacity,may not make final determinations. b.The hearing examiner may not recommend the approval of a rezoning,and the Board of County Commissioners may not approve a rezoning, other than the request published in the newspaper pursuant to section 34-238(b),unless the zoning district proposed by the hearing examiner is more restrictive and permitted within the land use classification set forth in the Lee Plan. c.In reaching his recommendations,the hearing examiner has the authority to recommend conditions and requirements to be attached to any request for a special exception or variance included under subsection(d)(1)b.3.,4.or 5.of this section. (5)Decisions. All decisions of the hearing examiner concerning zoning matters under this subsection(d)will be in the form of a recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners. Only a participant or his representative will be afforded the right to address the Board of County Commissioners. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 5 of 70 07-Apr-10- t., and used as single-family residential sites. Some of these lots are developed,while others are not. They are accessed from the private unpaved Burgundy Farms Road, which leads north from Corkscrew Road. The Applicant's property is a rectangular shaped parcel, with the exception of another, smaller, rectangular parcel,which extends into the subject property, in a northerly direction, from Corkscrew Road. That parcel is owned by Lee County, purchased as a 20/20 conservation acquisition. There is also an easement along the southern property line, to Lee County Utilities, wherein six water wells are located. The Applicant's Master Concept Plan, as originally submitted for consideration, consists of four pages, which are attached hereto as Exhibit B. Please note, this is not the Master Concept Plan that is recommend for approval by this Hearing Examiner. The Master Concept Plan being recommended by the Hearing Examiner is attached hereto as Exhibit C. It was developed by the Applicant during the course of the hearing. The latter plan depicts the 770 acre lake, which will be the result of the proposed excavation. The Typical Lakes Section reflects a 110 foot deep lake. From the top of of the bank of the lake, the slope is 6:1 to 4 feet, below the dry season water table, and 2:1 from four feet to twenty feet below the dry season water table, then vertical to the lake's maximum depth. The plan represents that the mining will take place in five phases, over an estimated time frame of twenty years. or more, Phase 1, or the first area to be mined, is in the western quarter of the property. Phase 2 comprises the west-central portion of property. Phase 3 is the east-central portion. Phase 4 is on the eastern portion of parcel. An area described as Phase 5 depicts the administrative office, concrete batch plant, asphalt batch plant, aggregate piles, loading and distribution areas on 120 acres. That phase may also be the last phase mined. Phase 5 contains the entrance to the property from Corkscrew Road. No other access points are depicted on the Master Concept Plan.The plan represents that the phases will be mined sequentially,and new phases will not be excavated until the prior phase has been completed. Preserve areas are located along the eastern, western and northern boundaries of the property, constituting buffers between adjacent parcels. A 50-foot-wide, 8-foot-tall,vegetative buffer will front along Corkscrew Road(south property line). Wetland and upland restoration buffers are proposed along the other three property lines. Minimum excavation setbacks are 910 feet from the west property line(adjoining the Burgundy Farms area), 2,100 feet from the east property line, 500 feet from the north property line and 400 feet from the southern or Corkscrew Road boundary line. An extensive reclamation plan is also proposed. A cross section of a proposed hydriodic barrier(subject of later discussion) is also depicted on the Master Concept Plan. This application is unusually, for a number or reasons. It comes before the Hearing Examiner with a "judicial history." The Applicant previously filed a lawsuit against Lee County. Resource Conservation Holdings, LLC, a Florida Limited Liability Company vs. Lee County, Florida, et., al., Case Number 08CA—18477, Circuit Court of the Twentieth Judicial Circuit In and For Lee County, Florida. A copy of the Final Judgment therein is attached hereto as Exhibit D. In that lawsuit,the Applicant requested the issuance of a mandamus against the County, requiring them to bring this matter forthwith, for hearing, before the Hearing Examiner. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 6 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 The application commencing this matter was originally filed on March 21, 2006, and requested approval of a dirt mine. In 2007,the Applicant made a decision, with the consent of the County Staff, to amend its request for a limerock, or aggregate, mine to a depth of no lower than 110 feet. Both types of mines are permitted within an Industrial Planned Development. The amended application was submitted to the Department of Community Development, on June 20, 2007. In September 2007, County Staff and the Board of County Commissioners began an effort to amend the Lee County Comprehensive Plan. From September 18, 2007 through December 4, 2007, the Court found that a de facto moratorium was in effect, at the Board of County Commissioner's direction, mandating that the Development Staff not process any mining applications. That Court ultimately concluded that the Board actions were improper, in that, no public notice was given of the proposed action, and no proposed moratorium language, for the public to review, was provided. The Development Staff did continue to process the subject application, for a short period of time. On October 2, 2007, the Staff accepted a full submission from the Applicant, responding to a Staff Request for Additional • Information. Pursuant to Lee County Land Development Code Section 34-373 (d)(1), the Development Staff had 15 days to respond,in writing,to the submittal.That ordinance further provides, that the failure to respond within the 15-day period will result in the application being "deemed sufficient." The 15-day response period expired on October 23, 2007, with no response from Staff. The Court concluded that the application had, by operation of law, been"deemed sufficient." It further noted that the term, "deemed sufficient," is not a substantive finding, either approving the application, or recommending approval. It is, however, a procedural step, which means enough information has been submitted to allow the application to be heard, and reviewed,by the Hearing Examiner.The Court did not recognize the de facto moratorium by the Board of County Commissioners, and granted the mandamus.The Court ordered that the application was to proceed forthwith for hearing before the Hearing Examiner, and ultimately the Lee County Board of County Commissioners,for action in accordance with the provisions of the Lee County Comprehensive Plan and the Lee County Land Development Code, that were applicable to the subject property on the date of the filing of the initial application. Any future amendments to those ordinances are not applicable, or to be applied to, the subject application. The matter was originally assigned to Diana Parker, Chief Hearing Examiner. However, on May 21, 2009, the Applicant filed a Motion to Recuse Diana Parker from hearing this matter. See Exhibit E hereto. The basis for this request was"a well-founded belief that Ms. Parker has developed a pre-determined conclusion against any mining operation on Corkscrew Road, in the vicinity of the RCH property." The Lee County Attorney's Office filed a memorandum opposing the Motion to Recuse. Ms. Parker held a hearing, on said motion, on May 26,2009. The law that governs a recusal contains a rather low threshold. Basically, the hearing officer must avoid the suggestion of impropriety. It need not be proven that a conflict, bias or basis actually exist; it merely is sufficient to suggest the same. While denying any pre-determined conclusion, or bias, on her part, Ms. Parker did recuse herself from hearing this matter, in order to avoid the suggestion of any such impropriety. The case then proceeded before the undersigned Hearing Examiner. In compliance with Circuit Judge Joseph C. Fuller's Order of February 12, 2009, Exhibit D, the hearings commenced, on May 27, 2009. Thereafter, testimony was taken during 22 Case DC12006-00026 Page 7 of 70 07-Apr-1 0 - 7 1 days,spread over seven months. The final arguments took place on November 6 2009.The record comprises approximately 5,000 pages of testimony and argument,including testimony from approximately 36 expert witnesses, 59 members of the public spoke before this Hearing Examiner,and eight others submitted comments without testifying. Approximately, 228 exhibits are part of the record, as well as six separate memorandums of law, and responses thereto. The purpose in reciting these statistics is to suggest that no other matter before this office has ever had such an in-depth, exhaustive, and comprehensive review or examination. Applicant's Case Testimony began with the Applicant's expert in land planning, David Depew.4 Dr. Depew PhD., whose expertise is well known to the Hearing Examiner, County Staff, and the County Attorney,testified regarding the Applicant's development plans, as basically outlined above. The other significant portion of his presentation related to the application's consistency with State Statutes and Lee County Ordinances. The discussion commenced with compatibility issues, within the County's Future Land Use Map. Dr. Depew asserted that certain future land use categories are more intensive than others,and that others are designed to preserve current uses and character. This includes the rural communities, which were created to "promote design approaches for maintenance of rural character." In other words, areas designed to remain permanently rural in character. Likewise, the Lee County Comprehensive Plan enumerates which areas are intend to be developed, by specifying uses, and in what areas development, or expansion, uses can occur. The subject property is located in the Density Reduction/Ground Water Resource Land Use Category (DR/GR). That land-use category specifically authorizes agricultural, mining or natural resource extraction, conservation, gun range, and recreational uses. The mining or natural resource extraction use is not limited to the DG/GR Land Use. It is also authorized in Industrial Land Use areas. Dr. Depew testified the reason that mining or natural resource extraction was placed in the DR/GR, was simply that it was the area in which limestone is located, and that limestone mining has been occurring in that area for at least the last 40 years. The definition of the DR/GR Land Use is contained in the Mission Statement of the Lee County Comprehensive Plan. It is Mr. Depew's opinion that the reason for placing it there, was to put the public on notice that if you are moving to that area,or are acquiring land there, or for that matter any portion of Lee County, the Mission Statement will inform you of the kinds of activities that you should expect to be permitted within the respective land use. Consequently,anyone acquiring property in the DG/GR is on notice that mining activities may occur, within any part of that designated area. The definitions of some future land uses, in the Vision Statement are actually very limited, as compared to others. For example Buckingham and Pine Island, two separate communities, have definitions that indicate that they are predominantly agricultural communities and are to be maintained in a rural setting. For example,the definition of Pine Island indicates that"it will continue to be a place where people,nature, and agriculture exist in harmony, a place that is not very different from what it is today." The purpose of the Lee 4 Hearing Transcript, May 27,2009,pp. 13-63. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 8 of 70 07-Apr-10- • County Comprehensive Plan is to protect these communities from urban sprawl, and development of strip malls and other similar intense uses. The desire is to maintain those communities as viable and productive agricultural areas. The definition of the DR/GR contains no such restriction. Indeed, it is the position of Dr. Depew that nothing is permanently restricted in that area. The language describing the DR/GR talks about agricultural uses and large lot home sites.There is nothing in the definition that permanently - maintains existing uses. It simply lists as basic and allowable uses, mining, agricultural, and large lot residential homes. There is nothing in the definition that indicates that this area is (� to be maintained in its current condition. Goal 10, and Policy 10.1.4, of the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, indicate that mining activities are permissible in areas indicated on the future land-use map, in rural open lands, or the DR/GR. The latter is only one, of the three land-use areas, that permit mines. He continued by describing the existing, and closed, mines in the DR/GR. Exhibit F, attached hereto,depicts all of the prior and current mining operations within the DR/GR. The purpose, of reviewing these mine locations, is to indicate that mining activities are a currently accepted activity in this area. The testimony went on to discuss the Applicant's request in terms of area to actually be mined, set aside for wetland, preserves, buffers and other uses. I am not going to be dwelling on those figures in this immediate discussion. On several occasions during the hearing, the Applicant amended the request. This was generally done in response to comments from County Staff, neighboring property owners and Hearing Examiner statements. The end result are the conditions and description of the project,as set out in this recommendation, and the recommended Master Concept Plan, Exhibit C hereto. The Applicant's next witness was Mr.Kirk Martins The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit G. Mr. Martin is a hydrologist and Vice President of Camp, Dresser and McKee, Inc. (CDM) He performs groundwater assessments and modeling for his company,and their clients. He has previously testified in this venue, and was recognized as an expert witness in ground water hydrology,geology, and groundwater modeling. Sixty percent of his practice involves providing services to governmental agencies, including Lee County, and the remainder to private entities. At the beginning of his testimony, Dawn Perry-Lehnert, Assistant County Attorney,raised an objection to his testifying,based on what she perceived as a conflict of interest. Specifically, Mr. Martin has been employed by Lee County, on several occasions, and has provided expert opinions regarding hydrological issues in the DR/GR. Mr. Martin was involved in the creation of the Integrated Water Master Plan for Lee County. Ms. Lehnert informed the Hearing Examiner, that at the present time, there is litigation, before the Division of Administrative Hearings, that dealt specifically with the subject matter of this case, and some of those issues directly relate to what Mr. Martin was going to testify about. Mr. Martin denied any involvement in the litigation, and indicated he did not know that the subject matter of his testimony was related to it. This Hearing Examiner made a determination that it would be more appropriate to deal with the conflict issue by allowing the County to file a Motion to Strike his testimony.This would allow the examination of Mr.Martin 5 Hearing Transcript,May 27,2009, pp.63-145. Hearing Transcript,May 28,2009, pp.52-73. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 9 of 70 07-Apr-10- k ki to continue, and the County could then file their motion and any supporting documentation of a conflict. If the Hearing Examiner found a basis for the County's request, Mr. Martin's testimony would be stricken from consideration herein. The County Attorney later withdrew the assertion of a conflict of interest and the matter was not further discussed. The examination of Mr. Martin continued, and his PowerPoint Presentation was introduced as Hearing Exhibit Number 32. The witness indicated that there are a number of possible environmental impacts that had to be reviewed, prior to any development of the property. He noted there is a wetland area to the north of the property,that is part of the Southwest Florida International Airport Mitigation Bank. There is also a private mitigation bank, on property owned by the South Florida Water Management District,to the east of the subject property. Additionally, public water supply well fields, operated by Lee County Utilities, are on the southern portion of the subject site. Mr. Martin gave a general overview of Florida's hydrology. He indicated that there was a difference in the rock formations located in South Florida, from the rock formations in the northern part of the state. Generally, in Lee County, it is typical to find approximately 15 feet of sand overlying approximately 20 to 30 feet of rock, then below that a clay confining bed, and finally an area that is known as the Sandstone Aquifer. This is the aquifer that provides drinking water for County residents. This cross-section exists over approximately 80 percent of Lee County. However, in the area of the DR/GR, that cross-section changes. In this area you find 15 to 20 feet of sand, underneath there is up to 100, or more, feet of limestone. The limestone is coarse, hard and very desirable by mining interests,developers,and the Florida Department of Transportation. It is also important for water uses. That is why so many of the Lee County's well fields exist in the area. Mr. Martin indicated that there is a conception that mining lowers water levels, but that this is an overly broad statement.Mining levels can lower water levels,but don't necessarily have to, if preventive measures are provided. One assumption is that evaporation,from the lakes or borrow pits resulting from excavation, causes greater evaporation of water. There are compensating actions occurring when you develop a mine. Prior to mining, loss of water is occasioned directly by soils or puddles, or transpiration of plants. There is also significant water runoff on agricultural lands. This is estimated at approximately 40 inches per year. The post mining lakes are estimated to lose approximately 34 to 35 inches of water from evaporation, with no runoff. The net recharge to the groundwater reserves is approximately one inch prior to mining, and five inches after mining. This translates to an improvement to the groundwater recharge, after mining. The subject property loses approximately 13 inches of water per year, due to runoff, as a result of the extensive drainage system, running in a north-south direction. There are five or six such culverts on the site, measuring 30 feet across and up to 6 feet deep. The proposed berm around the property provides for permanent containment of storm water, up to the 100-year storm scenario. He concluded that the post mining scenario has a higher annual groundwater recharge and higher overall water level, due to the elimination of surface water runoff. Further, that Lee j Case DCI2006-00026 Page 10 of 70 07-Apr-10 - '. County Utilities,the Green Meadows and Corkscrew well fields,include wells adjacent to the mine lakes, with a long history of no water quantity or water quality problems.' There is one rather unusual condition that exists on the subject site. The water levels on the northeastern portion of this site are around 24 feet NGVD, and drop to 18 feet NGVD on the southwestern portion of the property. Those differences in water level are caused by the material (rock) in the ground that causes a friction, which in turn causes the water to move more slowly, and hence the slope. If you remove the material, the friction is removed, and the water will seek its own level. Essentially, lying flat along the project. That may cause the potential to lower groundwater levels to the neighboring properties,to the north and east,that is the mitigation banks. Mr. Martin's firm, including Mike Schultz (whose testimony will be discussed later) reviewed the geology and concluded that the construction of a grout curtain would be the most cost effective, and most technically effective, method to prevent any such off-site impacts. A grout curtain is not meant to be a barrier to water flow, or to stop water flow. It is designed to be an impediment to flow. The curtain will re-create the friction that occurred prior to excavation of limestone. The process consists of drilling a line of holes, between the excavation and property boundary, every 15 to 20 feet, and pumping in a cement grout solution, under pressure. This is the same solution put into the County's public supply wells in the area. The grout spreads out from the holes, and fills in voids, holes and crevasses, within the limestone rock. This is a limited blockage of the water flow. If the water level drops on the subject site, this will not affect off-site levels. This is an adaptive and flexible technology. The Applicant can increase the density, or number, of holes to create more of a blockage, or lessen the holes to increase flow. A more detailed review of this methodology is presented in the discussion of Mike Schultz's testimony. The Hearing Examiner should point out, at this time, that the use of the grout curtain was modified by the Applicant, as will be discussed later in this review. This technology is controlled by the Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan (AMP). This Plan proposes to monitor on-site wells, as well as off-site wells, and ground water level monitoring stations. Mr. Martin described a three tier action plan. Monitoring water levels, will determine if and when remedial action is required. If such action is required, the grout curtain will be designed, and constructed, to respond appropriately. All monitoring data will be reported to Lee County and the South Florida Water Management District, as a requirement of the Plan. The Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan has already been approved by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. I am not discussing the specifics of the Plan, proposed by Mr. Martin, at this time, because,during the pendency of the hearing, modification to the same was proposed by the Applicant, based on concerns expressed by the County Staff. The Amended Adaptive Management Plan is included within the conditions to this recommendation. For purposes of this recommendation, I think it appropriate to review, in detail the final version of that Plan. In any event,the original Plan, as approved by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection(Applicant's Hearing Exhibit 32), is the one initially presented to the County. The one that is the actual subject of this recommendation is more restrictive, than the original submission, and, therefore, would most likely be approved by that agency. 6 Hearing Transcript,May 27,2009,at Page 79. Case DC12006-00026 Page 11 of 70 07-Apr-10- At this point in time, cross examination of Mr. Martin was commenced. Examination of Applicant witnesses was unusual, as was the cross examination of most witnesses in this proceeding, in the sense of the number of Staff members asking questions of witnesses. In other cases before this Hearing Examiner,one,maybe two,members of the Staff would have questions of a witness; in this case, upwards of six Staff Members sought to question a witness. Since a great portion of the cross examination was repetitive,and sought clarifications of Mr. Martin's testimony, I will discuss the more salient portions. Mr. Martin did confirm the development of the mine in five stages. That, according to the Adaptive Management Plan, the second phase would not proceed, until the monitoring of Phase 1 had be completed,to the satisfaction of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. This scenario would continue for each additional phase. Surface water, up to the 100-year storm level,would be retained on-site. Water moving through the groundwater system is not constricted from getting off-site. He confirmed that lakes,similar to those proposed in this development,have a positive effect, in terms of attenuation of drawdowns, to the nearby water supply wells. The Applicant's next expert witness was Michael S. Schultz,'of Camp, Dresser and McKee, Inc., in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Since, Mr Schultz has never testified in this forum, his curriculum vitae is attached as Exhibit H hereto. He was accepted as an expert in geotechnical engineering. Mr. Schultz does not specialize in grout curtains, rather in all the major forms of barrier walls,slurry walls,cut-off walls,sheet piles walls, and ground freezing. Mr. Schultz first described the grout curtain proposed for this site. It is a series of holes in a line, or multiple lines, drilled to a depth of approximately 110 feet, through the limestone, and tapping into the clay, or confining, layer beneath it. Following drilling, grout is injected into the holes, under pressure. The pressure is greater than the stresses in the ground,with the result that the grout opens up fractures or holes in the rock, and the grout fills it. Grout is a substance made of water, cement, and sometimes bentonite, with a strength that is approximately 10 percent of concrete. Its chemical nature has no adverse environment impacts. Exhibit I depicts this process. The depth(into the rock)of the infill depends on the permeability of the rock, the in-ground stresses, and the viscosity or fluidity of the grout mix. The grout curtain will only be placed on the east, north and west sides of the site. There is no need for it on the southern boundary, because it is the lower side of the property. Additionally,there is a desire not to impact the County wells in that location.The grout curtain will be installed after the completion of each mining phase. Mining will commence in Phase I, on the west portion of the site, with the result that the curtain, if needed, will be installed at the end of mining in that phase. Prior to the actual grouting,water pressure tests are conducted at various levels,to measure the ground response, or how much water the ground is taking. That gives the operator an estimate of the ground permeability, and thereby the amount and mixture of grout that is appropriate for the hole. Initially, it is anticipated that the holes will be 15 feet apart. However, a determination, of higher or lower than anticipated permeability may change the spacing. Additionally, more grout holes or, a second or third line of grout holes can be • prepared at alternate spacing, to further decrease permeability. If it is determined, that the ' Hearing Transcript,May 27,2009,pp.35-106 Hearing Transcript,May 28,2008,pp.4-52 Case DC12006-00026 Page 12 of 70 07-Apr-10- grouting is too impermeable,it is possible to fracture portions of the grouting to increase flow. The Adaptive Management Plan requires the monitoring of wells on the site, as well as off- site, to determine any off-site changes to groundwater levels. Based on those results, the permeability created by the grout curtain can be adjusted. Grout curtains are not a new concept, they were first employed in 1802, and have remained an generally accepted engineering application since that time. Upon cross examination, Mr. Schultz explained that the grout, proposed for the current site, would have a setting time of four to six hours. Grout curtains may be affected by chemical reactions over years and thereby deteriorate, but that is unlikely in the current location given the chemical of the rock structure. When questioned whether the mining activity,and/or on- site blasting, would affect the curtain, his response was that the charges used for that purpose are controlled and directional. Further, monitoring of the site would detect any such changes to the grout curtain. He also indicated, that during the drilling for the grout curtain, core samples are taken, rather than the operators looking at the grout and water to determine the intrinsic permeability. Other engineering and scientific issues were discussed with members of Staff, but none appeared to give rise to any negative effects of the grout curtain. Ryan Shute,8 of Morris - Depew Associates, a registered professional engineer, appeared as the Applicant's expert in surface water management and engineering issues related to surface water management. His testimony was related to the potential of diverting surface water from north of the subject site, to the Burgundy Farms community, west of the subject property. Mr. Shute testified that the Applicant's site is an agricultural field, with ditches running from north/south, and a small number also running east/west. None of the ditches are connected to any off-site drainage. Water flow in the area is generally from the northeast to southwest. There are existing berms that divert water from the north, to the properties to the west, that is the Burgundy Farms community. This is the historic flow of surface water, for decades, or at least since the property has been used for agricultural purposes. It precedes the development of the Burgundy Farms area. There is a control mechanism with a flash water riser, a small weir, on the south side of the site. The proposed site, as permitted by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, is going to have a perimeter berm set 100 feet back,to allow a vegetative upland buffer, from the north property line. Additionally, there will be a vegetative upland restoration planting along the western property line. The west side of the site has the lowest elevation. Surface water from the north will continue to be deflected around the subject site to the Burgundy Farms area, that is the current historic flow pattern. The site will not add to the flooding problems of that community, because it will retain all of the subject property's surface water, on-site. Cross examination of the witness did not reveal any remarkable issues. Mr. Paul Kirby Owen9, of W. Dexter Bender Associates, was declared to be the Applicant's expert in wetlands ecology, wildlife biology and marine ecology. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit J. Mr. Owens evaluated the site for listed species and assisted 8 Hearing Transcript, May 28,2009,pp.73-107 9 Hearing Transcript, May 28,2009,pp.73-107 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 13 of 70 07-Apr-10- 1.? in the design of the Indigenous Management Plan, Exhibit K attached hereto. Ninety-two (92) percent of the site is actively managed, with improved pastures, that historically has been grazed by cattle and the periodic harvesting of sod. He noted the berm and ditch system, described by the previous witness. Native vegetation association consist of upland flatwoods and cypress wetlands on the east and west property line. Remnant islolated cypress wetlands are located within the improved pasture,in the interior of the site. The ditch network surrounding this area has substantially altered the historic hydrology of the wetlands. The mid-story of remnant cypress areas was dominated by exotic species, prior to recent treatments. The ground cover has been impacted by the cattle, and is now dominated by invasive species. There are no significant natural resources on the site,which contains 80.7 acres of wetlands, 28.8 acres of wetland agricultural ditches and 15 acres of other surface water upland-cut agricultural ditches and cattle ponds. Additionally,a protected species survey was conducted by Passarella and Associates in the year 2000, and by Brown Collins in 2004. A limited caracara nesting survey was performed by W. Dexter Bender and Associates in 2007. Those surveys documented the opportunistic use of the overall property by the Big Cypress Fox Squirrels, Florida Burrowing Owls,several species of wading birds, Audubon's Crested Caracara and an Alligator. Only the Florida Burrowing Owl and the Big Cypress Fox Squirrel were nesting on the property. The implementation of the Management Plans will ensure that this project does not affect a listed species. No Florida Panther or Bears have been observed on this site, Nor is there panther or bear habit located on the site. The proposed development provides for the enhancement of 73.3 acres of indigenous upland and wetland habitats and the restoration of 114 acres of uplands. A total of 187.3 acres of native habitat will be placed under a conservation easement and permanently protected. The goal of the Indigenous Vegetation Management Plan will be implemented to enhance the existing wetlands and uplands, by exotic species control, and to restore native uplands and wetlands, by native plantings along the perimeter of the site. This will provide a buffer between the excavations and the conservation lands to the northeast and residences to the west. The project, upon completion, will produce 99.34 kilograms of forage fish biomass for the wood strock population. Forage fish biomass is the weight of fish, on a per acre basis, in a particular wetland, based on hydrology. The Applicant is incorporating a wading bird littoral shelf drawdown berm into the lake's littoral shelf. The drawdown berm traps fish in it,when water is drawn down during the dry season. This provides the optimum feeding condition for wood storks and other wading birds. Commenting on the Florida Panther and Black Bears,the witness indicated that it is unlikely that such animals would be struck by vehicles operating from the mine. There is a large mammal wildlife undercrossing, constructed west of the subject site, and is the only nearby area with natural vegetation. The animals are funneled into this crossing (under the roadway) by a fence, along the right of way. Cross examination of this witness did not produce any unusual issues worthy of comment. Case DC12006-00026 Page 14 of 70 07-Apr-10- Larry Sewell10,of Sarasota, Florida testified as the Applicant's expert in real estate appraisal, and in particular to Lee County, Florida. Mr. Sewell was tasked with studying the impact of rock mining, or mining activities, on the value of adjoining residential real estate. A secondary review was made to determine whether mining, or mining activities, was sufficiently incompatible to discourage residential real estate development. The witness discussed his interviews with individuals who reside, manage or broker properties within the DR/GR and in close proximity to mining operations. Those interviews revealed common complaints related to truck traffic, lighting, and blasting activities. He interviewed individuals, from residential areas, within and outside of Lee County. He concluded that there is a uniform market resistence to the presence of mines. Just like there is a resistence to electrical transmissions facilities or locations next to an interstate highway. However, that resistence does not mean that there are not buyers for residences in these locations. To the contrary,the witness testified that the proximity to a mine does not diminish the fair market value of the property, rather the buyer pool is lessened. Again, cross E. examination did not result in any conflicting issues, with the witness's testimony. Ted Treesh", of TR Transportation Consultants, testified as the Applicant's expert in transportation planning, and the author of the Traffic Impact Statement,submitted to County Staff in support of this application. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit L. That study was updated and the update issued immediately prior to Mr.Treesh's testimony. The original study was based on a 108 million cubic yard year, that is the estimated actual tonnage removed from the subject site. The new study accurately reflects the proper 91,295.082 cubic yards of material. In computing the usage of the site,Mr.Treesh assumed the actual operation of the mining operation and the operation of four batch plants. There may be a concrete block plant,substituting for the batch plant,but the block plant generates less trips. Therefore, the four batch plants would represent the maximum potential trip production. The result is that the facility could produce a maximum of 1,309 one-way truck trips per day. The subject application requests 1.200 two-way,or 2,400 one-way truck trips per day, onto Corkscrew Road. This is also based on a 15-year useful life of the mine. The application indicates a 20-year, or longer, useful life for the mine. It also presumes that the mine will operate 52 weeks per year. A typical truck can haul15 cubic yards of material. Taking the above assumptions into account, Mr. Treesh then determined what effect this increase in traffic will have on Corkscrew Road. The Highway Capacity Manual's methodologies requires that a factor of 1.7 be applied to truck trips this takes into account the difference in characteristics between trucks and passenger vehicles. In simpler language, one truck trip is the equivalent of 1.7 passenger vehicle trips. The usage was computed based on traffic for the year 2011 (the year following opening of the mine). The study concludes that there would be a Level of Service"B,"on Corkscrew Road,east of the project entrance to the Lee County line; a Level of Service"C,"on Corkscrew Road,west of the project entrance to the intersection with Alico Road; and a Level of Service "8," on Corkscrew Road, west of the Alico Road intersection. The adopted Level of Service for Corkscrew Road, pursuant to the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, is Level of Service"E." The result is that, even with the Applicant's maximum use of the reviewed road segments, 10 Hearing Transcript, May 29,2009, pp.3-37 Hearing Transcript,May 29,2009,pp.38-70. Case DC12006-00026 Page 15 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 those roadways will be within the acceptable levels prescribed by Lee County Ordinances. Applicant's most recent Traffic Impact Statement is attached hereto as Exhibit M. A similar study was undertaken,using the Link-Specific Service Volumes(created based on factors imputed into Florida Department of Transportation software). This study produced similar results to that discussed above, excepting that Corkscrew Road,east of Alico to the entrance of the site, operates at a Level of Service "D." This is still within the adopted acceptable level of service standard for Corkscrew Road. There was discussion of changing computations to assume that there would be less than anticipated use of Alico Road to connect to Interstate 75. In re-computing the above analysis, using this new assumption, the Level of Service for the various segments of the roadways are B, C or D. These are still within the acceptable standards, as defined by Lee County Ordinances. Mr.Treesh testified that,in order to further reduce traffic impacts,the Applicant has proposed financing the following road improvements (these improvements are contained within the recommended conditions of this recommendation): 1. Construct a left turn and deceleration lane,east bound,on Corkscrew Road, into the site's entrance. 2. Construct an acceleration lane on the north side of Corkscrew Road, at the site entrance, to merge truck into east bound traffic. 3. Construct a left turn and deceleration lane, east bound, on Corkscrew Road, into Burgundy Farms Road. 4. Construct a left turn and deceleration lane, east bound, on Corkscrew Road, into Alico Road. 5. Construct a right turn and deceleration lane, west bound, on Corkscrew Road, into Alico Road. Mr. Treesh also confirmed that the Lee County Department of Transportation classifies Corkscrew Road, at the subject site, as an arterial roadway. That is a road that is primarily designed to accommodate longer distance trips,higher speed of travel,and higher volumes of travel. Lee County Land Development Code,at Section 10.1,defines; "Arterial, means a street primarily intended to carry large volume of through traffic connecting a major activity center to other major traffic generators. Access to abutting properties is a secondary function." Mr.Treesh refined the classification of this roadway as a"rural arterial roadway." There are other conditions that have been recommended by the Applicant, that deal with traffic issues. They will be discussed later in this recommendation, as part of the discussion of conditions. The Applicant then called upon Jeffrey Straw,12 of Geosonics, Incorporated. His resume is attached hereto as Exhibit N. The witness was determined to be a seismologist, and an expert in the field of blasting vibrations and associated issues. Mr Straw described the blasting process to be employed at the subject site. Initially,after removal of the overburden, the surface is leveled, and the mine operator and explosives company set out a pattern for blast hole drilling. In this case, the initial cut, that is the key cut, would run north/south 12 Hearing Transcript,May 29,2009,pp.71 -179. Case DC12006-00026 Page 16 of 70 07-Apr-10- 1 7 .j. through the area designed as Phase I. They would drill to a specific depth, insert a cardboard tube, place a soup can sized vessel with a booster, which also contains the blasting cap, which is on the bottom of the hole, and then fill it with bulk emulsion. It is eventually detonated. The detonation is actually part of a series of approximately 24 holes that are detonated nearly simultaneously. The gas pressure created by the explosion fragments the rock, and it is removed by a dragline. The blasting will reoccur after each section of rock is removed, gradually expanding the excavation or lake. Ninety-five (95) • percent of the blast energy is absorbed by the rock. The remaining energy moves out from the blast area, in the form of vibration. The operator has the ability to direct blast energy away from adjacent residential areas. However, this does not totally eliminate all vibrations from encroaching into the residential areas. Mr. Straw has been involved in the blasting industry, in Lee County, for several decades. The industry is within the regulatory jurisdiction of the State Fire Marshal's Office, pursuant to Chapter 69-A of the Florida Statutes. Therefore, this Hearing Examiner cannot recommend, and the Board of County Commissioner cannot usurp, the authority of that agency which has exclusive jurisdiction over blasting activities within the State of Florida. Dr. Depew was recalled as a witness13, and began his second presentation by reviewing aerial photographs of the DR/GR. These photographs were taken in 1966, 1980, 1990, 1998, 2005, and 2008, (See EXHIBIT 0 through T attached hereto). These pictures clearly depict the expansion of mine development within this area of Lee County. It also depicts the development of the subject site as an agricultural property. Finally, it reflects the residential development within the DR/GR. The significance of that is that residential development, while not extensive,occurs more or less simultaneous with development of mining interests. Some of the mines were converted to residential uses, after mining had ceased. Dr. Depew then turned his attention to the individual mines and the conditions incident to their approval. He began with the Westwind Mine(DCI2000-00057),east of the subject site by several miles, and also on Corkscrew Road, which was approved for the processing of sand and rock (to a depth of 50 feet), and for a horticultural incinerator. It has a 31-year approved use, with no blasting, operations are allowed for 12 hours, six days a week, and a 4 to 1 slope(steeper than the subject application). The Staff and Hearing Examiner found the application was compatible with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan and the Lee County Land Development Code. Further, that the application was consistent with the densities, intensities, performance and locational standards of those ordinances. Finally, it was compatible with existing or planned uses in the surrounding area. Mr.Depew cited additional similarities between that case and the current application. This witness' testimony continued in similar fashion, taking up the approvals of the West Lakes Mine, University Lakes Mine, Bell Road Mine, Bonita Grande Excavation, Southwest Florida Rock. There was discussion of compatibility issues, traffic, distance to residential uses,densities,intensities,water quality issues,bank slopes and their similarity to the current application I am intentionally just giving a short synopsis of this discussion because this application should be reviewed based on the facts and conditions of the subject property,not 13 Hearing Transcript,June 4,2009,pp.5-180. Hearing Transcript,June 5,2009,pp.3-114. Hearing Transcript,August 19,2009,pp.6-69. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 17 of 70 07-Apr-10 - t 7 ' { what happened in other cases, at other times. Mr. Depew also spent some time on describing the history of this case, and how it arrived before the Hearing Examiner. The witness then went on to discuss Applicant's Hearing Exhibit 19,which are their proposed conditions. The Applicant had submitted proposed conditions, as part of their °24-hour letter,"which is a response to the Staff Report. One of the unusual actions by Staff, in this case, was the absence of a submission of any proposed conditions on their part. In every other case heard by this Hearing Examiner, in a case where Staff has recommend denial, they still submit recommended conditions in the event that the Hearing Examiner and/or the Board of County Commissioners decides that the request should be approved. No conditions were submitted by Staff. Consequently, the Applicant took it upon themselves to present their own set of conditions. This was done by attachment to their 24-hour letter,and the later Applicant Hearing Exhibit 19. These two sets of conditions are different. The Applicant, in response to the comments of County Staff and Hearing Examiner, made modifications to the conditions to be more in line with the comments. Exhibit 19 is not the final version of the recommended conditions. Rather than discuss these conditions,and then later changes or amends them,the Hearing Examiner will,at this stage, ignore the proposed conditions. A detailed discussion of the final version of conditions will be discussed later in this commentary. This discussion, of one set of conditions, will avoid confusion and misunderstanding by everyone. However,the Hearing Examiner will make the comment that Applicant's recommended conditions are based on conditions applied to other approved mines, conditions that are unique to this application, and others that are designed to limit the impact of the mine to neighboring properties. The conditions are indeed more restrictive and costly than any others previously imposed on a mining operation. • Dr. Depew's next area of discussion was the Applicant's compliance with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan and, more specifically the compatibility and consistency with that ordinance. This review was a restatement of the his finding contained in his Land Use Study, Applicant's Hearing Exhibit 19,attached hereto as Exhibit U. The witness was of the opinion that the subject request was consistent with the provisions of the Lee County Comprehensive Plan cited in that exhibit. This witness was also qualified as an expert in Statistical Traffic Accident Analysis,and in that capacity he testified regarding his Traffic Analysis,Applicant's Hearing Exhibit 32, attached hereto as Exhibit V. That study concluded; despite the increased traffic volumes and additional operating mining activities in the vicinity, the safety record of heavy trucks on Corkscrew Road has improved since 2000. When Alico Road crash data is reviewed, only 30% of all crashes involved a heavy truck, despite the fact that over 50% of the traffic on the roadway is comprised on heavy trucks. The report indicates that truck traffic,generated by mining operations,is less prone to serious accidents, when compared to passenger vehicles. Case DC12006-00026 Page 18 of 70 07-Apr-10 - • A The Applicant's next witness was Thomas M. Missimer, PH.D.14, who was qualified as an expert in geology, hydrogeology and water quality. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit W. Dr. Missimer was hired by the Applicant, because Kurt Martin, and CDM,was no longer serving as their engineer. He had reviewed the latter company's grout wall recommendation. The same was re-categorized as an"hydrologic barrier." The grout curtain is recommended for the porous limestone layers on the subject site. However,the first or top layer of material on-site is sand. His recommendation is to provide a slurry wall through the sand or top layer, and then grout curtain through the limestone, and into the confining layer, which consists of clay. Mining is limited to 110 feet, or to the confining layer, whichever is shallower. Dr. Missimer testified that the grout curtain will only work well in the porous limestone layer; it does not work in the sandy top layer. The slurry wall is unlike the grout curtain, which is created by injecting a substance into a hole, bored in the rock, at predetermined spacings. The slurry wall is a bentonite mixture poured into a trench, dug in the surface layer. As the name implies, it creates a wall through that layer. This wall provides rigidity, so there in no movement of water through the sand. The grout curtain and slurry wall are used together to form the hydrologic barrier that the Applicant proposes to restrict or retard, but not eliminate, groundwater flow. Ninety-five (95) percent of the water flow is through the limestone layer, so that restricting the flow through the top layer is not particularly significant. Cross examination of Dr. Missimer was performed by the County Attorney, three Staff members of the Department of Community Development Staff, and Thomas Hart, Esq., representing members of the public. During that examination, the witness described the Applicant's use of modeling, monitoring and their Adaptive Management Plan. The final version of the latter document is attached hereto as Exhibit X. That Plan was amended during the course of these hearings. Basically,the Applicant will monitor historic,current and future data, from on-site and off-site wells,to determine baseline levels and current levels of groundwater. This data is used to create models of groundwater levels,during yearly cycles. The Adaptive Management Plan provides the flexibility to determine spacing or changes in the grout curtain, so that water levels are maintained at the levels that were determined for the period before development occurred. The hydrologic barrier will be constructed along the northern property boundary, as well as on the eastern and western sides, as is determined necessary. No barrier is provided,along the southern boundary. This is the location of the easement for Lee County Utilities wells. There will be no attempt to interfere with water flow to those wells. It should be noted that this barrier will be retained permanently on the subject site.The data collected from on-site, and off-site wells, (the latter owned by other entities) will be provided to the Department of Community Development, as well as other State agencies. Dr. Missimer presented model runs to the County. Since this constituted new material not previously reviewed by them, Staff requested a continuance, of the cross examination period, which was granted. Dr. Missimer was recalled on October 20, 2009, for further examination regarding the model runs. I will discuss that testimony now, for the sake of continuity. 14 Hearing Transcript,August 19,2009, pp.69-155. Case DC12006-00026 Page 19 of 70 07-Apr-10 - h k Prior to cross examination Dr. Missimer discussed the Adaptive Management Plan. He amended the Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan,along with his associates Dr.Coulibaly and Dr. Guo. Their plan was produced with a computer program, known as MODFLOW. Dr. Guo is the author of the SEAWAT Code used in one of the MODFLOW modules. Dr. Missimert5 explained that their Adaptive Management Plan was designed based on five layers. The use of this number of layers provides for a complicated computer model,but the characteristics,including permeability,of each layer can be different. This allows the modeler to use difference values, leading to a more accurate model. The South Florida Water Management District,the Danish Hydraulics Institute and the U.S.Army, in previous models for this county, have all treated the Surficial Aquifer as a single layer. The data imputed into these models come from wells throughout the DR/GR, and specifically wells located in the mitigation areas, county well sites,wells drilled by the Applicant, and others. Those wells,or data collection points, cover all points of the compass,within a circle that is at minimum three miles, from the subject site. After the model is constructed,the data is imputed,and the model is calibrated. You calibrate the model by changing cell types until you produce water levels that are close to the measured water levels in the field. The entire process is geared to creating a model that can minic real world conditions. The more information that is imputed into the model, the more accurate the model will become. Dr. Missimer describes this work as dealing in two worlds; The modeling world and the real world. The entire purpose of creating this model is for its application to the Adaptive Management Plan (AMP). This guides the use of the hydrologic barrier. Its name implies that this is not a fixed operation manual. Rather, it is more off an agreement to review data and possibly modify or prescribe changes to the hydrologic barrier. A number of questions, that were propounded to the witness,were deferred to Dr. Coulibaly. Dr. Coulibaly, a member of Dr. Missimers' company, provided a good deal of input into the preparation of the AMP. He testified later in these proceedings. The cross examination, by Lonnie Howard, was directed to the data that was placed in the Applicant's model, and from where that data was obtained. This examination disclosed disagreement, between Mr. Howard and Dr. Missimer,as to issues in the modeling effort, but did not appear to disclose any fatal deficiencies. Dr. Missimer was also questioned by Dr. Samuel Lee, regarding the Tier 1 system employed In the AMP. There are five such tiers, within the AMP. There was agreement that there was confusion in the meaning and application of this plan. Staff's Case The Staff began its case with Alvin "Chip" Blockt6, of the Department of Community Development. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit Y. Mr. Block prepared 15 Hearing Transcript,October 7,2009,pp.211-261. 16 Hearing Transcript,August 19,2009,pp 231 -246. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 20 of 70 07-Apr-10- • the Staff Report for this matter. He was declared to be an expert in Land Use and Planning, especially as it relates to Lee County. Mr. Block's testimony was unusual, in that he provided the Hearing Examiner only with a chronological history of the case. He gave no testimony regarding the consistency of the application to the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, or compliance with the Lee County Land Development Code. Rather than review this history, which is basically irrelevant to the issues of the recommendation, the Hearing Examiner - would refer the reader to the factual history set out in the Court Order attached hereto as Exhibit D. There was no significant cross examination of Mr. Block. Staffs next witness was Andrew Getch,17 from the Lee County Department of Transportation, who was recognized as an expert in transportation engineering and transportation planning. Mr. Getch testified that the Applicant's total number of truck trips, through the life time of the project, was probably low, based on his calculation of the amount of fill and limestone to be removed from the site. This may or may not be correct. The proposed acreage to be mined was actually reduced during the course of the hearings, and after Mr. Getch's testimony. That made his, and the Applicant's,calculation of total trips throughout the life of the project, inaccurate. He also represented that the use of Corkscrew Road, as proposed, between the project entrance and Alico Road,would lead to the eventual deterioration of the road surface, and it failing in terms of structural integrity. He did say that, based on the Applicant's Traffic Impact Statement, there will be an acceptable level of service, at all times, on the subject roadway. Finally, in regard to the Applicant's proposed conditions, specifically, those requirements placed upon truck driver's serving the site, the witness believed that they are unenforceable, as a practical matter. The next witness produced by the County Staff was Dr. Glenn J. Rix,18 a Professor at the Georgia Institute of Technology, who was determined to be an expert in blast vibration, ground vibrations, human response to vibrations and soil dynamics. Mr. Rix's resume is attached as Exhibit Z. He outlined the principles governing the blasting process, how to characterize ground-borne and airborne vibration,the different types of seismic waves, and the effect on structures that these waves have. Prof. Rix discussed U.S. Bureau of Mines, Report of Investigation 8507,which derives itself from a study at an howitzer range in Texas. He concluded that blasting is a complex process, involving ground-bourne vibrations, air- bourne vibrations, and the response of structures and human perception. It is difficult to make predictions about the impact of blasting on structures and humans, that is why monitoring is important in the field. Maintaining peak particle velocities of less than .5 inches per second reduces the likelihood of threshold structural damage, but does not preclude it. Humans perceive ground-borne and air-borne vibrations at levels significantly lower than those that cause threshold structural damage and human annoyance. Dr. Rix's comments were generalizations and not specific to the subject site. He had not visited the Applicant's site, nor had he performed any testing at the site. Florida regulations provide that the maximum peak particle velocity allowed is .5 inches per second at any structure. This is the same acceptable level adopted in the above cited U.S. Bureau of Mines Report. The Applicant has agreed to be contractually bound,to a peak particle velocity limit of.35 inches per second. This is within the range that Dr. Rix deemed acceptable. 17 Hearing Transcript,August 20, 2009 pp.3-101. 18 Hearing Transcript,August 21,2009,pp.3-56. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 21 of 70 07-Apr-10- r I ; The Staff next called Harry A. Campbell18 the Chief Traffic Engineer and Manager of the Traffic Section of the Lee County Department of Transportation. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit AA Mr. Campbell was declared to be an expert in the fields of traffic engineering, traffic operations, traffic studies and traffic data analysis. The witness gave an overview of the various segments of Corkscrew Road. He also discussed the testimony of Dr. Depew, whose conclusions he disagreed with because he believed that comparable corridors have to be used to provide a proper comparison. He made the conclusion that as the number of trucks increase,the exposure increases and therefore the number of crashes involving trucks will increase.' He also noted that the Applicant's requested number of trips, i.e. 2,400 round trips, actually doubles the number of trucks currently using the subject segment of Corkscrew Road. The other problem is when a loaded dump truck needs to turn, it takes 3.5 times as long as a passenger vehicle, and that will cause delays along the roadway. Trucks take longer to break, or slow down, and longer to accelerate. Eighty percent of fatal accidents involve medium to heavy trucks, on non interstate highways. He drew the conclusion that an increase in large trucks may(emphasis added) increase traffic operational and safety problems." Further, the absence of improvements to mitigate the impacts caused by that magnitude of truck traffic, it will be less safe." The witness also indicated that there is no Federal, State or County standards that exist, which determine how many trucks, on a given class of road, is excessive. He believes that given the current condition of Corkscrew Road,and improvements proposed by the Applicant, that the requested amount of truck trips will very likely result in the public experiencing additional delays, as a result of trucks accelerating from exiting the site, and slowing down to enter the same. He concluded that the Applicant's request results in unacceptable levels of truck traffic. Upon further questioning from the Hearing Examiner, the witness could not define what constituted an acceptable level of truck traffic. Nor did the Department of Transportation attempt to determine what an acceptable level of truck traffic should be. When pressed on the issue of a number between one truck trip per day,and 2,400 truck trips, perday,he commented,that up to 10 new trips perday would not be noticeable by the public. Roland Qttolinni,20 Director of Lee County Division of Natural Resources, a Registered Professional Engineer, was the Staffs next witness. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit BB. He was declared to be an expert witness, in the field of water resource management and surface water management. Mr. Ottolinni provided an overview of what his department's duties involve,and how they respond to applications similar to this request. He noted that in eastern areas of Lee County,the topography generally falls off a the rate of one foot per mile. However, at the subject site this fall is 4.5 feet per mile. The northeast corner of the site has a elevation of 27 feet NGVD,to the southwest the elevation is 18.9 feet. NGVD,or a 8.1 foot drop across the property. Groundwater generally follows the drop of the land, and the steeper the drop,the more dramatic the effect will be on the groundwater level. The concern is that creating a lake, on the subject property, will cause a reduction in the groundwater level in the mitigation areas directly north and east of the Applicant's property, 19 Hearing Transcript,August 26,2009,pp.8-113. 20 Hearing Transcript,September 25,2009,pp.3-82. Hearing Transcript,September 29,2009,pp.99-109. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 22 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 F and the water wells of private landowners. He did not voice an opinion whether the Applicant's proposed hydrologic barrier would correct this problem. The witness then discussed the other area of concern to him that is the surface water flow. The property is currently used for agricultural purposes, and has a berm that surrounds the site. However, in a number of areas, generally along the northern boundary, there are breaches of of the barrier.These breaches allow surface water to flow onto the subject site. The Applicant proposes construction of new berms, totally surrounding the site, which will block all water to the site, and send it to the west of the property, exacerbating the flooding along Burgundy Farms Road. It may also affect the mitigation area to the north by further stacking water on that property. Finally, it may impact the wetlands on the subject site, and the wetlands on the County's property, described herein as the "finger parcel," by denying those areas the flow they are currently receiving. On cross examination, it was noted that the witness testified that the existing berms could be repaired and returned to their original condition. The witness could not identify if the berms were originally on the property. Further, that he based his comments on the condition of the property, not from personal inspections, but from information, or statements, from other members of his Staff. Staff s next witness was Dr. Samuel Lee,21 with the Lee County Natural Resources Division. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit CC. He was determined to be an expert in the professional engineering fields of surface water and groundwater modeling, management, design, hydrology and hydraulics. Dr. Lee's function, with respect to this project, is not to review the hydraulic barrier design, a field in which he is not a expert; but, rather, review the hydraulic analysis,either by modeling or review of actual data. After which he determines the possible areas of concern to the natural resources of the area. He found that, based on the Applicant's submissions,the detail of the hydraulic barrier implementation are currently unknown, or at least at the time of his initial testimony. The witness also commented on the defects of the Adaptive Management Plan submitted by the Applicant. I am omitting a discussion of those defects, because the Plan was revised during the course of the hearing,and I think it would be appropriate to review only the final version.The original version was to be implemented in four phases, and Dr. Lee had concerns over the implementation process. The phasing of the Plan was modified in the final version. Likewise, there were concerns expressed regarding the determination or formalization of baseline data; this was also modified later.The undersigned found that Dr. Lee's initial testimony appeared to say that he could not recommend the implementation of the hydraulic barrier, or the Adaptive Management Plan, because he lacked data, to be supplied by the Applicant, to render an opinion. The second part of Dr. Lee's testimony was on groundwater modeling. First, he reviewed what that term encompassed, and the various software, code selections, data and other preparation that goes into creation of a computer model. The purpose of the model is to mimic what is happening in the field. Remember,this is a groundwater model. One cannot just visit the site and determine what is happening underground. Dr. Lee believes he found numerous inconsistencies, errors and other problems with the Applicant's model, with the 21 Hearing Transcript,September 25,2009,pp.83-196. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 23 of 70 07-Apr-10- i7 result that it could not be accepted as a decision making tool. The Applicant, as discussed .17 later,"reinvented the wheel,' and submitted a modified model. i The next Staff witness was Tony Pellicer22, Operations Manager in the County Division of Natural Resources. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit DD. He was declared to be an expert in the fields of water quality, surface water monitoring, storm water permitting and chemical constituency issues. After an overview of the functions of his division,the witness discussed the problems with respect to the proposed monitoring. Based on his understanding of the Adaptive Management Plan, it uses on-site goals versus off-site goals, at least in the initial stages. The project baselines were determined without comparison or correlation to off-site water levels. He went on the give examples of why that information is critical for monitoring. Again, the Adaptive Management Plan was later amended in the hearing process. Mr. Pellicer also discussed water quality. He showed photographs of other mine sites, depicting stains and spill areas. The Hearing Examiner specifically finds what happens at other sites is irrelevant to the subject application. He discussed algae blooms that occurred at other sites, and the proximity of this site to County wells. His discussion dealt with issues that may be occurring at any other mine in Lee County. The witnesses testimony, regarding other mine sites, is speculative and not relevant to the subject application. Aaron Martin,23 from the Lee County Community Development, was declared an expert in environmental sciences,as it pertains to the Lee County Comprehensive Plan.The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit EE. He testified regarding two issues, setbacks and environmental impacts, on the site and adjacent preserves. He indicated that stockpiling of materials could occur adjacent to upland communities,and this could result in excessive dust and breaches into the reserve. He then discussed what could occur to the vegetative community, as a result of a change in the hydro-period. Basically, the vegetation could become stressed and die or become susceptible to disease and parasites. Since the witness is not an expert in hydro-periods, he could not testify as to whether this would occur. He did voice concern with the tier process of the Adaptive Management Plan. This tiered response was modified in that Plan, after the witnesss testimony. Finally, he mentioned the absence of a monitoring protocol for the vegetative communities. The monitoring conditions of the FDEP permit require monitoring of exotics and restoration plants. In his summation, he concluded that the project is inconsistent with a number of Lee County Comprehensive Plan Goals and Policies, but did not provide any factual basis for these conclusions. Becky Sweigert,24 a Principal Environmental Planner, with Lee County, was declared to be an expert in wildlife ecology. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit FF. Ms. Sweigert found inconsistencies,with various policies of the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, based on a lack of information, regarding protection measures for the burrowing owl and caracara, and lack of a proper littoral shelf. Additionally, the parcel is within the secondary 22 Hearing Transcript,September 29,2009,pp.4-98. 23 Hearing Transcript,September 30,2009,pp.3-29. 24 Hearing Transcript,September 30,2009, pp.29-80. Case DC12006-00026 Page 24 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 Otto zones for black bear and Florida panther, as determined by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. This witness provided a Power Point slide that depicted panther positions, based on telemetry data. See Exhibit GG attached hereto. This data positions collared panthers and has been collected over a 20 year time frame. The data does not depict a single panther position on the subject site. it does provide a clear depiction that the panthers are moving through the mitigation banks and the conservation areas. There have been two panthers killed, by motor vehicles,in 2006 and 2007, in proximity to the subject property. Ms. Sweigert commented that there have been no additional panther fatalities, since the Lee County Department of Transportation extended fencing along these road corridors. Susie Derheimer,25 of the Department of Environmental Sciences, was presented and qualified as an expert in the field of environmental planning, as it relates to the Lee County Land Development Code. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit HH. She testified that the application does not comply with the open space requirement of Section 10- 415(a) of the Lee County Land Development Code. The witness went on with her calculations; however, since her testimony, the size of the subject lake was amended by the Applicant, making those calculations not applicable. She then discussed the neighboring flowway, that flows northeast to the southwest, and is contained in the mitigation and conservation areas. The subject site was, at one time, part of this system. However, since commencement of its agricultural uses,decades ago, its berms removed it from the flowway. Staffs next witness was Matthew Noble26 who was declared to be an expert in the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, the Lee County Land Development Code and transportation planning. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit II. Mr. Noble began with an overview of the DR/GR, including photographs of the area. He also attempted to play a sound tape of a blast at a nearby mine. This was objected to by the Applicant, on the grounds that the witness was not an expert in sound or acoustical engineering. The Hearing Examiner sustained that objection. Rather than listen to the tape, the Hearing Examiner agreed to visit a mine, within the DR/GR, to actually witness a detonation. Mr. Noble then went on to describe the Corkscrew Road area as a community of rural character; incorporating the residential areas along Burgundy Farms Road, Six L Farms Road, Carter Road Loop and even the Wildcat Run Subdivision. He described the County - Store, on Corkscrew Road, as a community hub. The witness also described the dangers of truck traffic, noise, dust and light pollution that he believed would emanate from the proposed site. His next comments related to a history of prior mine applications in this area. He then started to summarize the testimony of other Staff witnesses. The next area of testimony was a review of aerial photographs of the property, commencing in 1944. The witness pointed out the flowway in this area of the County, which is known as the Flint Pen Strand. This is the flowway that the subject parcel was originally located in. The photographs clearly depict the development of the site as an agricultural parcel, and the placement of ditches and berms within the site. He claims that the photographs depict the 25 Hearing Transcript,September 30,2009,pp.81 -150. 26 Hearing Transcript,September 30,2009,pp. 151 -175. Hearing Transcript,October 3,2009,pp.4-182. Hearing Transcript,October 6,2009,pp.6-297. . i Case DC12006-00026 Page 25 of 70 07-Apr-10- 07 remnant flowway on the site. He also suggested that the approval of this application will preclude any flowway restoration or habitat restoration. He also claims that there is water flow through the property, by way of breaks in the breaches in the north berm. This break takes water that would otherwise drain through Burgundy Farms Road, and lets it flow south through the subject site to Corkscrew Road. In support of this assertion, Mr.Noble presented a short video,depicting an un-scientific demonstration of water flow,and grass floating on top of it. There was a presentation on what road segments would receive the traffic from the subject site. He also discussed the increase in truck traffic,the neighbors'fear of these vehicles,and the provisions of the Lee Plan that they are inconsistent with. Finally, Mr. Noble discussed the potential danger to wildlife caused by the project. Like a good deal of his testimony, he relied on the testimony of other members of the Staff, for support of his position. On his second day of testimony, Mr. Noble took the hearing on a photographic tour of Alico Road and Corkscrew Road. This testimony concluded the County's initial presentation. The County called William F. Spikowski27 as an expert in land planning. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit JJ. This testimony was actually taken out of order, on October 13, 2009 to be specific. It is included in this portion of the discussion of the County's case, to maintain continuity in the presentation. The witness discussed three issues. First, the amount of land that was needed for mining. Second, the amount of land that is currently approved for mining uses. Third, how much additional land is needed for mining. He described the uses for rock in residential, commercial and road construction. He indicated that this need for rock is both within and with out Lee County. One-half of the state's rock supply comes from Miami-Dade County. This is because the rail system on that side of the state is very good for transportation of the product in a northerly direction. Mr.Spikowski then focused on the method he employed in determining the future rock needs. Based on that calculation he concluded that we needed an additional 821 arces of mining to meet demands through the year of 2030. On cross examination the witness acknowledged that he was not familiar with recent limitations on mining activity in Hernando County, or of a recent Court decision concerning Miami-Dade mines. When questioned about the Strategic Aggregates Review Task Force Report, he admitted to using parts of the report in his presentation. He commented that the report dealt with statewide issues, and was not a local prospective, and that it contained findings that were "appallingly wrong." Cross examination went into the specifics of rock quality, limitations on production to remain below DRI Thresholds,road building plans, and other issues that were not taken into account in Mr.Spikowski's direct testimony. Basically,he made calculations by concluding that future growth in the next 20 years will be the same as in the past. This is a most unscientific.study. 27 Hearing Transcript,October 13,2009,pp.53-140. Case DC12006-00026 Page 26 of 70 07-Apr-10 - Applicant's Rebuttal The Applicant's first rebuttal witness was Frank J. Lucca,28 who was recognized as an expert In blast engineering. His resume is attached as Exhibit LL. He is the owner of Terra Dinamica LLC, which are active in the explosives business. Mr. Lucca was also the author of a study, commissioned by the Board of County Commissioners (Contract Number 2983, CN 04-17), to determine if land development blasting can be done without damage or other detrimental impacts to residences,other structures,public utilities,or groundwater resources, given the geology of Lee County. That study was reported in June of 2005, and comprises Applicant's Hearing Exhibit 87. The executive study comprises Applicant's Hearing Exhibit 86. Mr Lucca concluded, in his study, that peak particle velocities between 0.3 and 0.5 are extremely conservative to any type of blasting within the County. Blasts within that range should have no adverse impact on structures, or anything else. Unlike the County's expert on blasting,this witness actually visited the subject site and reviewed the Applicant's blasting plan. He expressed the opinion that it was a conservative plan and that the potential for blast damage, within the subject area, is nonexistent at the levels set out in the application. This includes the grout wall proposed by the Applicant. Likewise there is no potential for damage to County infrastructure(i.e.wells)along Corkscrew Road. In cross examination the witness did admit that residents will feel the shaking or vibrations from the blast, and it could cause pictures on a wall to move or fall. Donald Alexander Bruce29 was the Applicant's expert witness in hydraulic barriers. Mr. Bruce's resume is attached hereto as Exhibit MM. The witness teaches on a regular basis at the Colorado School of Mines,the National Highway Institute,and short courses for various Departments of Transportation, as well as at trade shows, seminars and workshops, all throughout the United States. He began his testimony describing this has worked on grout curtains for Lake Okeechobee. In regard to the case at hand, he has examined the final version of the Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan. He described the site as wide open with no overhead restrictions and the rock is not exceptionally difficult to grout, or to drill in. He classified the project, from a technological point of view, as a very simple straightforward hydraulic barrier. The hydraulic gradient is very,very light. The parameters that Dr. Missimer has modeled can be achieved in the ground and can be satisfied quite readily. The gradient is the difference between the elevation of the groundwater on the upstream side of the barrier, or the outside, and the inside. Basically, the difference in the water table on either side of the barrier. While the experts debate the modeling, the gradient is no more than 10 feet. In other projects that the witness is familiar with, that gradient may be 10 or 20 times that number. The witness also discussed the useful life of the barrier. In South Africa, grout curtains are installed in underground mines, with very acidic conditions, and their useful life is in excess of 10,000 years. There is nothing in the soil or rock of the subject site that would deteriorate the barrier. The witness concluded that the grout curtain would become part of the geology 28 Hearing Transcript, October 7, 2009, pp.51 -90. 29 Hearing Transcript,October 7,2009, 9 P pp.91 -210. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 27 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 of the site in perpetuity.He concurred with the prior witness that blasting would also not affect the curtain. Working in shafts under the Harlem River, in New York City, blasting is conducted within 30 or 40 feet of barriers, without ill effect. The product used for these curtains is bentonite, sodium montmorillonite clay, which occurs naturally and would have no detrimental environmental issues. Finally, he discussed the methods for moditying the barrier, if flow actually needed to be increased. This can be done by several methods. First, use a backhoe to create notches in the slurry wall on top of the barrier. He discussed the use of a testing process, creating a dewatered box on-site to measure the effectiveness of the system. This test would determine the residual permeability of the barrier. The witness concluded that the hydraulic barrier would be able to be constructed in an environmentally friendly fashion and do exactly what it is supposed to do. On October 13,2009,Applicant produced Richard Friday,30 the Chief Financial Officer for the Applicant. As a witness, Mr.Friday testified regarding the demonstration blast that had taken place the day before October 12, 2009. The blast, actually a series of approximately 26 blasts,was not to exceed.35 peak particles per second, measured at one thousand feet from the detonation site. The purpose of the blast, requested by the Hearing Examiner, was to determine the noise it generated. It was not to be a scientific test for any issue relevant to vibrations. The Hearing Examiner notes that the noise level was not significantly high, and would question if it could actually be heard from within a structure at the 1,000 yard distance. A vibration, or movement of the ground, was also noted. What effect that may have within a structure is unknown. Mr. Friday testified that the test blast was representative of a typical blast, at the existing Younquist Mine. That the blast was in the top 96 percent, in terms of seismographic results, of their blasts, and that the noise that eminated from the blast was typical. Mr. Friday also testified that the Peak Particle Velocity, measured 1.975 feet from the blast, was 0.13. Ryan Shute,31 a Registered Professional Engineer,with Morris DepewAssociates,was again called as an Applicant's expert in surface water engineering. He testified that, based on Lee County Aerial Photographs, the subject site's use as an agricultural site began in 1968. Additionally, there were agricultural uses on the property, to the north of the Applicant's parcel, known as the Port Authority property. These all had the effect of diverting surface water flow to the west. By 1972, the berm system, on the Applicant's property was in place. The was no wetlands present on the subject site and the agricultural portion of the Port Authority property. Basically,there was no surface water flow, because the water flow was fully restricted by the berm system. In the late 1990's, the Port Authority removed the agricultural configuration of its property, and returned that area to a preserve, similar to its state in 1968. The Applicant's property is untouched. The surface water flow through the preserve area was returned to its northeast to southwest direction, but not across the subject property. The witness also described an Environmental Resources Permit issued to the Port Authority that allowed it to place fill(from airport construction) on one 20-acre site, and another 30 to 40 acre site, to a height of six 30 Hearing Transcript, October 13,2009, pp. 34-52. S1 Hearing Transcript,October 13,2009,pp. 112-140. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 28 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 feet, immediately north of the Applicant's property, in essence further restricting water flow onto the latter property. This fill has the effect of channeling water flow onto property adjacent to, and west of, the Applicant's property. This testimony refutes the assertion by Staff witnesses that there is ground flow on the subject site through breaches in its berm area. Any flow on the Applicant's property arises from solely on site sources, channeled through agricultural ditches on the site. He also indicated the presence of a flow through the Burgundy Farms community,specifically through ditches that drain into the Corkscrew Road ditch. The witness concluded with the opinion that the north perimeter berm, proposed by the Applicant, will not impact the Burgundy Farms area for flooding. Ted Treesh32 was recalled by the Applicant, as an expert in transportation planning. He confirmed the posted speed limit, on Corkscrew Road, between Alico Road and the Lee County line, as 55 MPH in the daylight, and 45 MPH at night. Following which he reviewed the Applicant's proposed amended road improvements, those contained in the conditions presented in the appendix to this recommendation. Mr. Treesh then took the traffic safety formula supplied by Mr. Campbell, of the Lee County Department of Transportation, and applied the same to two segments of Corkscrew Road, that is Ben Hill Griffin to Alico Road, and Alico Road to the Lee County Line. Since, Mr. Campbell's formula was based on 100 million miles traveled, Mr. Treesh modified the equation, for lower volume levels, to one �. million miles. This simply moved the decimal point. Mr.Treesh concluded that the accident rate does not have a direct correlation to any increases in traffic. The Staff, from the County Department of Transportation, objected to the use of this formula in this location, because of the low amount of data available for the location. The Hearing Examiner notes that the formula was the one proposed by Staff's witness, Mr. Campbell. Dr. David Depew33 was then recalled. He first testified regarding the change in Staffs position, from prior applications, regarding consistency with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan. Specifically, he asserted that, because blasting activities are now regulated by the State Fire Marshal, the Staff cannot support a recommendation of approval with blasting as a permitted use, because the County has no control over the activity. He then gave his history of submission through the County. Commenting on other Staff witnesses, he disagrees with the assertion that this area of Corkscrew Road is a rural community, having • its center at the Community Store. This is compounded by the fact that mining already exists in that future land use, and in an area of the County with the absolute lowest density. Dr. Missimer's testimony revealed differences between experts opinion of the Applicant's modeling,with respect to data imputed into it,determination of basis line figures and selection of monitoring sites. His cross examination was lengthy, and, while revealing professional disagreements, it did not reflect that the concept of the AMP was unsound. Dr. Thomas M. Missimer appeared before this Hearing Examiner on two additional occasions.` I will deal with those sessions collectively in one discussion. Dr. Missimer was not employed for the purpose of designing or constructing the hydrologic barrier The witness 32 Hearing Transcript, October 14,2009,pp.4-30. 33 Hearing Transcript,October 14,2009,pp.31 -140. 34 Hearing Transcript, October 20,2009,pp.6-218. Hearing Transcript,October 27,2009,pp.30 -280. Case DC12006-00026 Page 29 of 70 07-Apr-10- began his testimony by characterizing the differences between his modeling efforts,and the Adaptive Management Plan (AMP). The purpose of the AMP is to manage groundwater levels at the Applicant's site, using a combination of modeling to predict water levels. Modeling is the vehicle used to predict those water levels. This is accomplished by monitoring well sites,on-site and off-site,to collect and evaluate real data and input the same into the model. The model takes this data, along with other information, including the ground's hydraulic conductivity, and water recharge. This will result in the actual design of the hydriodic barrier, and any temporary or permanent measures, to properly recreate the proper resistence to groundwater. The AMP is designed to be flexible to allow adaptation and changes in the future. It is implicit that the effectiveness of the barrier will be determined at its time of construction, as well as in the future, and modifications (if any) implemented. Dr. Missimer described, in detail, his understanding of the barrier's construction. Then he turned his attention to the AMP. This plan is less of a plan, but more of a flexible guide of when to respond to inputted data, to maintain ground water at appropriate levels. This is intended to be a tiered system. Meaning that at predetermined events,i.e. completion of mining in Phase 1, the model will govern the design and placement of the barrier. Cross- examination reflected professional disagreement in the Plan and monitoring. The Hearing Examiner reviewed this as actually a healthy environment. It appears clear that there is genuine disagreement between the experts, but it did not rise to the suggestion that the Plan, the Model, or the Barrier, would not work. Rather, that Dr. Missimer, as well as his associates, later appeared to take the comments of Staff to heart, and employed the same in the second version of the AMP. This Hearing Examiner has avoided specific review of the testimony of all of Dr. Missimer's sessions, because of their extreme scientific detail, and the fact that the AMP itself was reviewed, thereby negating concerns brought to light in Dr. Missimer's cross examination. The next rebuttal witness was Jeffrey Straw35,who had previously testified in this proceeding. He reviewed the State Fire Marshal's Office from 2002 through 2007, and determined that 24 complaints were filed, for blasts within the "Corkscrew Road Area.". Those complaints were investigated, by that office, however, no violations were charged against any mine operators. There were 17,502 blasts within that area, during the calendar years of 2006 through 2008. Some mines decreased the number of holes per blast,therefore,creating the necessity for more blasts. The reason,for this was to reduce the impacts to nearby property owners. The witness testified to complaints on mines, at locations other than the subject property. Since the subject site is undeveloped, it has no complaints filed against it. The purpose of the testimony from this witness, presumably, was to dispel the assertion of extensive damage from blasting, at other mine sites. On October 30, 2009, Dr. David Depew36 was recalled for the final time. This time to specifically discuss the application for a mining operations permit process. The witness was questioned about various provisions of the Lee County Land Development Code. The basic 35 Hearing Transcript, October 27,2009, pp.9-30. 36 Hearing Transcript,October 30,2009,pp. 12-54. Case DC12006-00026 Page 30 of 70 07-Apr-10- purpose of which was to identify which issues are material to the rezoning process,and what issues are more appropriately left for review by Staff during the development order process. The Applicant's position is that certain issues raised by Staff should not be the subject of a zoning hearing. Rather, the same is to be reviewed during the development order process. This was directed to the examination of Dr. Missimer and his associates, regarding their Adaptive Management Plan. Cross examination commenced regarding what issues are appropriate for review by the Hearing Examiner, and Board of County Commissioners, and which should be subject solely to Staff review. Dr. Kapo Coulibaly37 was the Applicant's next witness. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit NN. He was recognized as an expert in the field of hydrology and associated computer modeling. Dr. Colibaly, along with Dr. Missimer and Weixing Guo, created the model used in the Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan. A fair amount of the questions tendered to Dr. Missimer, during his examination, were deferred to Dr. Colibaly because of his deep involvement in the creation of this model. Interestingly,at the beginning of his questioning,the witness acknowledged that the critique of Mr.Howard,relating to water storage in the lake, was probably correct, and that he had inadvertently placed a higher storage in the lake. He adjusted the model accordingly. He also commented that this oversight probably had very small impact on off-site calculations. He was then cross examined on various aspects of his modeling efforts. Some of these questions,posed by Mr. Howard,were enlightening,in that it showed the use of values,that were out of normal range, and why the witness employed the same. Dr. Colibaly was then cross examined by Dr. Lee, in what i can only describe as a disagreement in methodology, understood only by the witness, and his examiner, but no one else present. This underlines the concern that this is not the forum to reviewed, make a decision on these technical issues. That is what development order review is about. This will be discussed later in this presentation. Staff's Rebuttal Harry Campbell returned as a witness,"first to rebut the assertion,that the County could limit the use of Corkscrew Road,west of Alico Road to interstate 75,by placing weight restrictions on that segment. He testified that Section 316,555, of the Florida Statutes,gives the County the authority to apply weight limits, under certain conditions, but none of those conditions exist with respect to this application. He went on to critique Mr. Treesh's determination of crash rates. He concluded with the statement,"But predicting what crashes are going to be in the future is going to be extremely difficult because there are so many variables affecting this. it could be higher, it could be slightly lower. To say what the crashes might be in the future is very speculative."" Chip Block also testified again.40 This time to introduce documents into the record and to provide a more detailed history of the case. With emphasis on when certain information was 37 Hearing Transcript,October 30,2009,pp.55-179. 3e Hearing Transcript, November 3,2009,pp.4-20. 39 Hearing Transcript,November 3,2009,page 17,lines 19 through 22. 40 Hearing Transcript,November 3,2009,pp.21 -38. Case DCi2006-00026 Page 31 of 70 07-Apr-10- requested of the Applicant. This was done because the Applicant changed their request from a dirt mine, to a limerock mine, which requires additional information. Becky Sweigert returned for the purpose of updating telemetry data, regarding the Florida panther.41 Lee E. Werst, Jr., of the Natural Resources Division, appeared as an expert in well field protection, well water permitting and groundwater resource management.42 Mr. Werst placed into evidence, or had judicial notice taken of, a number of county ordinances and well field approvals that prohibit mining or excavation within a 500-foot radius of an existing well head. The Applicant's Master Concept Plan, in all versions,clearly depicted that excavation was outside that prohibited area. This is testimony about a non-issue,since all parties clearly understand the county ordinance. Dr. Samuel Lee returned for his final presentation.43 He began by discussing USGS Guidelines,and the fact that the Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan did not comport with those guidelines. He also commented on the fact that a water budget was not included in the model, and that the model had other deficiencies. Matt Noble44 concluded Staffs rebuttal by a historical review of prior mining cases, and rezonings within the DR/GR. Actions in other cases, and testimony therein, really has no probative value to the current application. The Hearing Examiner repeatedly asserted that his obligation was to make a recommendation on the evidence and testimony as it relates to this request. Testimony, findings and comments in older cases violate the Applicant's right to due process, because they have no way to cross examine that material. Mr. Noble then went on to comment on the testimony of other witnesses that testified in this matter. He reiterated County Staffs position on water draw-downs,buffer, noise,truck traffic, residential quality of life and the issue of where new mines are needed. His examination was interrupted to have Brad Browning, an expert in environmental planning,testify that,on October 26,2009 at 9:45 A.M., he witnessed a Florida panther crossing Corkscrew Road,just west of the Alico Road intersection. Mr. Noble then suggesteds that the application was inconsistent with Policy 5.1.5, Objective 77.3, and Policies 77.3.2 and 77.3.3 of the Lee County Comprehensive Plan and various other sections of the Lee County Land Development Code. • The Public and Third Party Interests: Generally, every hearing day, at approximately 4:00 P.M., testimony from Staff and the Applicant ceased, and the proceeding was opened up for public testimony and submission of evidence. Consequently, this input continued throughout the hearing process. The 41 Hearing Transcript,November 3,2009,pp.39-38. 42 Hearin g Transcript,t,November 3,2009, pp.51 -58. 43 Hearing Transcript,November 3,2009,pp.59-96. 44 Hearing Transcript,November 6,2009,pp.21 -110. Case DC12006-00026 Page 32 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 I undersigned has decided to review and discuss that testimony and submissions, at one time, rather than chronologically. The public participation, in this hearing, was extensive. It included residents from the nearby communities of Burgundy Farms and 6-L Farms. Those individuals voiced concern and opposition to the project, based on increased truck traffic and related safety issues, blasting impacts, especially vibrations and its impact to their property, noise from traffic and plant operations, lighting and dust issues. These residents may well feel impacts, from the Applicant's mining operations, on a daily basis. There were other individuals,from locations further to the west, who expressed concern mainly with the increase in truck traffic, along Corkscrew Road, especially, west of the Alico Road Intersection. That area has higher residential densities, and commercial zoning district, along Corkscrew Road. The residents do not have any faith that the traffic conditions proposed by the Applicant will decrease truck traffic. Finally, there is a segment of the public that believes that the subject proposal will have environmental impacts. Those impacts include negatively impacting the Florida panther, wading bird populations, and others. There were several individuals,who were qualified as expert witnesses, in various fields, who also testified. It should be noted that some of them were paid for their presentations, by members of the public or other interested parties. Kim Trebatoski45, a senior ecologist with Kevin L. Irwin, Consulting Ecologist, testified on behalf of the interests of EarthMark Southwest Mitigation Bank, owner of the 632.4-acre Corkscrew Mitigation Bank, located on the east side of the subject property. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit 00.She was recognized as an expert in environmental planning, including the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, and wetlands ecology. A large portion of her client's mitigation bank (257.7 acres) is comprised of hydric pine wetands, which has a short hydro-period. Much of the time that wetland is in inundated, in saturated soil,with periodic fluctuation of a few inches, above the soil during rain events. She asserted that a change in surface groundwater of.1 to .2 feet could reduce the hydro-period of the hydric pine flatwood by 50 percent. She then discussed the elevation of her client's property, in relation to the Applicant's. She believed, but had no other proof, that the Applicant's grout curtain was risky. This comment was well beyond her expertise. She also expressed a belief that the Applicant's proposal was not consistent with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan. Sometime following Ms.Trebatoski's testimony,EarthMark,through there Attorney,withdrew any opposition to the Applicant's Request. This appeared to be in exchange for the Applicant's increasing the size of the lake setback on the eastern property line,to 2,100 feet. That being the case,the Hearing Examiner is disregarding Ms.Trebatoski's testimony,since her client appears to be of the position that the increased setback eliminates any impacts to their property. Michael Roeder", Director of Planning at Knott, Consoer, Ebelini, Hart & Swett, P.A., appeared as a witness, on behalf of Bill Lyteli, Kathy Lytell, and the Wildcat Run Homeowner's Association. He was declared to be an expert in zoning and land use matters. Mr. Roeder indicated his testimony was limited to compatibility issues to the nearby residential uses. He made one significant initial point. That is the residents west of the 45 Hearing Transcript,August 19, 2009, pp 245-286. 46 Hearing Transcript,August 20,2009,pp. 102-230. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 33 of 70 07-Apr-10 - f M Corkscrew/Alico intersection have one major issue,traffic,and specifically dump trucks. That roadway segment passes through relatively extensive residential and commercial development. The residents east of that intersection have the same issue, but a variety of additional issues that affect their quality of life;specifically, noise, blasting damage, dust and air qualify, light pollution,and visual pollution. That road segment passes through residential areas of very low density and with agricultural zoning districts, similar zoning districts with large scale agricultural uses, and other mines. Mr. Roeder believes there is a distinct difference between these two areas. He also believes that the Board of County Commissioners' decision in the Schwab Materials and the Estero Group applications are dispositive of the issue of the compatibility of mines in this area. The Hearing Examiner is of the opinion that all applications must be reviewed independently of other submissions,and a recommendation made based on the facts and law of each submission. The witness continued on with examples of what facts, in his opinion, constituted inconsistency with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan. Jason Lauritsen47 testified on behalf of this the Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary,where he is a an Assistant Director. The witnesses resume is attached hereto as Exhibit PP. Mr.Lauritsen was qualified as an expert in wood storks and wood stork ecology. The witness took the hearing on a narrative of the history of the property, and review of the wetlands lost during its development as an agricultural site. The wetlands are used by wood stocks during the winter months. He described in detail wood stock activity at the Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary. He then reviewed wood stork activity at the Applicant's site, and found foraging events on an interior agricultural ditch and similar activity in a ditch right next to the subject site. He discussed the littoral shelf to be constructed on the banks of the proposed lake, and the fact that if would not concentrate the fish or food, in an area accessible to the wood stock. This problem was eliminated in the final and recommended version of the Master Concept Plan. Ellen Lindbled,48 Director of Planning and Environmental Compliance, Lee County Port Authority.After questioning it was determined that she was not giving testimony as an expert, in any field. Her testimony was accepted as an employee of the Lee County Port Authority. She commenced by giving an overview of the airport's mitigation park. That is the property located directly north of the Applicant's site. She did not voice specific objections to the Applicant's request. She left that to other representatives of the Port Authority. Lonnie Howard,49 of Johnson Engineering, testified on behalf of, their client,the Lee County Port Authority. He was qualified as an expert in groundwater hydraulics, groundwater hydrology, groundwater modeling plans, surface water hydrology, surface water hydraulics, surface water monitoring plans,as it relates to hydrology(not water quality),hydraulic barrier design and analysis associate with excavations. He testified that they had developed their own groundwater model flow, and made simulations by phase, with and without a grout 47 Hearing Transcript,August 26,2009,pp.126-166. 48 Hearing Transcript,September 29,2009,pp.110-123. 49 Hearing Transcript,September 29,2009,pp.124-211 • Case DCI2006-00026 Page 34 of 70 07-Apr-10 - • curtain. They reviewed the initial Adaptive Management Plan. He concluded that the excavation will reduce groundwater recharge by approximately two inches. He disagreed severely with CDM's determination of recharge or discharge and with the Applicant's model. Mr. Howard, as well as Dr. Lee, had serious criticisms of the data used to produce the Applicant's models. Rather than trying to summarize this individual's very detailed testimony, I commend the reader to specifically review his testimony in detail. The witness ended his testimony with the conclusion that, as proposed, the application does maintain surface and groundwater, at their historic level. Church Roberts,' of Johnson Engineering, was qualified as a expert in the fields of environmental permitting, ecological monitoring, mitigation design, land management oversight, and flora and fauna surveys and management plans. The witness was responsible for the design and permitting of the Port Authority's mitigation park.After a general overview of the park, Mr. Roberts proceeded to review the wells and groundwater monitoring that occurs on the site. He then turned his attention to a description of the current state of the mitigation park, especially near the Applicant's property, and what effects changes in the hydroperiod would have on it. He framed these effects in terms of the changes that were discussed in Mr. Howard's testimony. James Blythe Hodge,5t member of Earthmark Southwest Florida, which is the corporate owner of the mitigation bank, east of the subject parcel. He is also the project manager for Earthmark, in the operation of this wetland mitigation bank. He is an attorney and was not testifying as an expert in any field. Rather, he discussed the history of his mitigation bank, its ownership, function and remedies he may have in the event of unintended impacts from the Applicant's project. In reality, he was establishing a background of the project. He also indicated that he would be presenting testimony from his experts in hydrologics and ecology, at a later date. Those witnesses were scheduled for testimony, The appearances were continued, and it was later confirmed, that they had withdrawn Earthmark's objection to the Applicant's project. This was in consideration of a set back of 2,100 feet from the east property line to the proposed lake. There is a more specific agreement between the parties, but its terms are not relevant to this proceeding, and the same was not disclosed or requested to be disclosed. No further testimony was received by representatives of Earthmark Southwest Florida. Ed Carlson,52 Director of the Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary,testified on behalf of that entity, which is located approximately two to three miles south of the subject site. Mr. Carlson has done field work for the Sanctuary, prior to that, for 10 years with the Audubon's research department. The witness describes himself as the guy who drives into the swamp, places well pipes without heavy equipment, and develops shallow groundwater wells used for monitoring purposes. His knowledge is based on personal work experience, as opposed to a formal education, in those areas. He was not qualified as an expert witness. He explained 50 Hearing Transcript, September 29,2009,pp.212-233. 51 Hearing Transcript,October 7,2009, 9 pp.263-275. 52 Hearing Transcript,October 13,2009,pp. 141 -149 Case DC12006-00026 Page 35 of 70 07-Apr-10- { • that, within the Sanctuary, and below the surface layer, are the shell beds which are extremely permeable, forcing water to flow much quicker, than in any other layer. His concern was that, if the lake was excavated, and a shelf bed was exposed by the lake,water would run extremely fast through the shell bed. This may adversely effect the water levels in the Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary. Upon questioning, Mr. Carlson acknowledged that he did not know,or could prove,that there were any such shell beds connecting the subject site to his Sanctuary. Since, neither the Applicant's, Staffs, or third party witnesses raised or discussed this phenomena, it has been discounted by the Hearing Examiner. No proof was proffered to the Hearing Examiner that shell beds posed a concern at the subject site. Recommended Conditions: Incorporated in this Hearing Examiner's Recommendation of approval are the conditions to the recommendation, set out in the Appendix hereto. County Staff deviated from their usual procedure of submitting a proposed set of conditions for adoption by the Hearing Examiner, in the event that the Hearing Examiner would take a position contrary to Staff's i. recommendation. No proposed conditions were initially submitted by Staff. During the course of the hearing,this Hearing Examiner invited Staff to submit proposed conditions. The Staff responded with conditions that were, in essence, a restatement of requirements contained in the amendments to the Lee County Land Development Code, adopted after submission of the application herein. That action clearly contradicts the express requirements contained in Judge Fuller's Order of February 12, 2009, Exhibit D attached hereto. Consequently, this Hearing Examiner determined that he could not recommend any of Staffs recommended conditions. The Applicant provided the Hearing Examiner with a set of conditions. These were amended during the course of the hearing to incorporate requirements that responded to comments by County Staff, and issues identified by the Hearing Examiner. The final version, of the Applicant's suggested conditions, was further modified by this Hearing Examiner. The Applicant's conditions were, in part, taken from conditions that had already been imposed upon existing, approved mine operations within Lee County, and other provisions are new and apply exclusively to the Applicant's project. The conditions, along with their exhibits and attachments, are extensive and comprise the entirety of the Appendix to this recommendation, contained in Volume 2 of this recommendation. Some of these conditions require comment by the Hearing Examiner. Condition 1.A. requires the Mine Operator to develop, and maintain, a website for activities, and information, related to the operation of the mine site. It provides the public with links to the official sites for State and County Offices,and information on the current dates and times of actual excavation and blasting, informs the public of a method to notify the operator of unsafe or discourteous truck operation. It also provides online copies of monitoring reports, that the mine operator is required to provide to State and County Offices. This section of the conditions requires the Applicant to provide the public,and especially local residents,with up to date information in regard to its day to day mining activity. , Condition I, B. contains the conditions requiring the Mine Operator to comply with the Adaptive Management Plans, and mitigation and reclamation efforts. It requires monitoring Case DC12006-00026 Page 36 of 70 07-Apr-10- !, after cessation of mining activities to assure the integrity of the hydraulic barrier. Bonding is a requirement to ensure funds are available for remedial action. Finally, the County is granted access for inspection of the barrier areas. Condition I, C. requires, as part of the Mine Operator's website,that up to eight cameras are �. on-site to view mine operations, on a realtime basis. In regard to these conditions, the Hearing Examiner finds that they will provide the County Staff and the public with information concerning the current operation of the mine, assurance that the lake created by the mining activity will not cause any long term impacts, and a blasting schedule. Condition II provides for mine and accessory uses. The Applicant will be allowed to continue sod farming and cattle grazing (agricultural uses), until that phase of the site is converted to mining operations. Condition III contains the dimensional limitations of the site. Please note that there is a 500- foot setback from the Lee County Well Easement on the south side of the site. Mining is limited to a depth of 110 feet, or to the confining layer, whichever is the shallowest. The Applicant has modified the excavation bank slopes from their original submission. It is designed to provide an area for wading bird activity on the edges of the lake. Additionally, the setback from the east property line(the border with the mitigation bank located on South Florida Water Management District property) has been extended to 2,100 feet. This was accomplished by negotiation with the mitigation bank. It is beneficial to the Applicant's site • in two ways. First, since it is on the eastern portion of the property, the additional setback will reduce the difference in elevation between the northeastern and southwestern portions of the site. This in-turn should reduce the potential of the off-site impact of reduced water levels in the neighboring mitigation bank. Second,it increases the amount of open space on the site. Condition IV, A, 1, contains the hours of operation. It should be noted that 24-hour operations are authorized,if required, by a contract with a federal, state or local government, or agency thereof. Notice of such around the clock operation must be posted on the Mine Operator's website 48-hours, prior to such operation. Blasting is always limited to the hours of 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM and drag line operations are always prohibited between 11:00 PM and 6:00 AM. Condition IV, B. deals with traffic. The Mine Operator is limited to 2,400 round trips, within a calendar day. In order to reduce the impact on the other users of Corkscrew Road, improvements will be made to the Alico/Corkscrew intersection, the Corkscrew/Burgundy Farms Road intersection, and Corkscrew Road, at the entrance to the subject site. These improvements will be funded by the Applicant. The Mine Operator will fund additional road patrols, by the appropriate law enforcement agencies, in the "Corkscrew Road Corridor," defined as Corkscrew Road, from Alico Road to the entrance of the Westwind/Corkscrew Mine. Additionally, the Applicant proposed Safe Driver Contract Requirements for the hauling companies and independent drivers that will be hauling product from the site. Essentially, in addition to the usual penalties for traffic infractions, drivers will have additional restrictions Case DCI2006-00026 Page 37 of 70 07-Apr-10- I7 placed on them, i.e. banning the drivers from hauling from the subject site and mandating attendance at driver improvement courses, for traffic infractions within the Corkscrew Corridor. Driver training courses will be required for all drivers and hauling companies. Signage will be provided to direct drivers to use Alico Road, when coming and leaving the subject site. The Applicant does, and will, not oppose the reduction of speed limits (along Corkscrew Road), and weight restrictions on Corkscrew Road, between Alico Road and Ben Hill Griffin Parkway. Condition IV, C. contains the environmental conditions. They require a minimum of 187.3 acres of indigenous preservation and restoration,a significant buffer along Corkscrew Road, and 3.6 acres of littoral shelf for wading birds. Wildlife monitoring, exotic removal and a final restoration plan, submitted at the local development order stage, are also required. Condition IV, E. contains the Groundwater Conditions that apply to the site. Dewatering is not approved for this venture. Private wells,within one mile of the subject site, will have the opportunity to be tested, at no charge to the owners, prior to the commencement of the first phase of mining. Additionally, free inspections may be had upon completion of new well construction, and the sale of a home, where the well was not inspected. The entire point of this inspection is to determine if any damage has been caused to a well by the Operator's blasting activity. If that does occur,the property owner's damage will be repaired by the Mine Operator. Detailed conditions are also supplied regarding the proposed hydraulic barrier. Basically, construction and maintenance of the barrier will be controlled by the Lee Adaptive Management Plan. That plan is more specific and restrictive than the original Adaptive Management Plan that was presented to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. The barrier must also be in compliance with the Environmental Resources Permit, issued by that agency. Most significant is the requirement, that prior to local development order, a revised calibrated hydrologic model, using accumulated field data, will be provided. This provides the County Staff the opportunity to provide input into the specifics of this model. The parameters and considerations to be employed in developing this model are specifically set out in the condition. This condition also specifies the monitoring and reporting requirements imposed on the Applicant,as well as the standards for determining baseline water levels.There are additional requirements for hydraulic barrier performance tests, sequencing of construction and groundwater quality and quantity monitoring. Condition IV, F. contains the blasting conditions. Of note, the Hearing Examiner has added language clarifying that the reduction of peak particle velocity to .35 inches per second, is a contractual element of this condition, and the same may be enforced by an action in Circuit Court. Bonding is a requirement of blasting , as well as a public notice of blasting times. • Case DC12006-00026 Page 38 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 i • Standard of Review and Burden of Proof Given the unique background of this case, this Hearing Examiner feels compelled to review the principles of law that apply to this recommendation. This is a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, requiring that my findings and recommendation must be adduced from competent,substantial testimony and other evidence presented with scrupulous adherence to procedural due process. The Quasi-Judicial Proceeding is borne out of the Florida Supreme Court Case of Board of County Commissioners of Brevard County v. Snyder, 627 So.2d 469 (Fla. 1993). In that decision,the Court separated the functions of comprehensive rezonings(comprehensive plan amendments),from the rezoning of smaller parcels. They concluded that the comprehensive rezonings of large areas affect a large portion of the public and are policy matters. Therefore, they are legislative in nature and subject to a"fairly debatable"standard of review. Rezoning applications, on the other hand, are applications of that policy, and have an impact on a limited number of people or property owners. The decisions are subject to strict scrutiny and a substantial evidence standard, and are thereby more judicial or "quasi-judicial" in their nature. This requires that a recommendation to the Board of County Commissioners must be based on facts adduced from competent and substantial evidence, with scrupulous adherence to procedural due process. The Supreme Court, in quasi judicial proceedings, places the burden of proof on the landowner to demonstrate that the use, to which it seeks to rezone, is consistent with the comprehensive plan. There is no presumption as to the consistency of the use. However, once the landowner proves that the use is consistent, with the comprehensive plan, the burden shifts to the County to demonstrate that maintaining the existing zoning classification accomplishes a legitimate public purpose. The Court also held, if the Board of County Commissioners denies this application, and if that decision is appealed to Circuit Court, the Board will be required to show that there was competent and substantial evidence presented to it, to support its ruling. Hearing Examiner Findings: Residential Compatibility Issues The first issue, that must be reviewed, is the compatibility between the Applicant's request for a mining use and the nearby residential areas. There are two such areas in relative close proximity to the Applicant's property, the Burgundy Farms Road and the 6L Farms Road Subdivisions. The Staff basically contends that mining and residential uses are per se incompatible, relying on the assertion that blasting, truck traffic, dust and noise make residential uses near mine sites,unrealistic. At first blush, one might agree with this position, but the testimony and evidence do not support that position. Staff has not provided any definitive proof that that is actually the case. The only actual expert testimony on the subject came from the Applicant's witnesses, Larry Sewell and Dr. David Depew. They presented evidence that there has been residential growth in the DR/GR, at the same time that mines were being created. The fact that mines are in the area does Case DCI2006-00026 Page 39 of 70 07-Apr-10- 1 � H � not seem to have hafted residential construction. Granted that residential expansion is not larger,but the DR/GR,with its density restrictions,does not contemplate or welcome massive residential expansion. Mr. Sewell indicated that the pool of prospective purchasers, for residential property in the DR/GR, is less than other areas, but it is in line with the number of residences, and home sites, located there. Staff provided nothing to rebut this testimony. There was a substantial amount of testimony from individuals, who either live near the Applicant's property, or close to other mines. They complained about truck traffic, blasting, noise and dust, all of which does negatively, to some degree, impact them. None of the complaints, however,rose to the level of stating that those activities were driving prospective purchasers, or existing residents, from the area. The Hearing Examiner also notes,and the testimony reflects,that the subject parcel is within the Southeast Planning Community, an area of 82,500 acres, and 435 dwelling units. That constitutes the lowest density of any area in Lee County. Natural resource extraction is a specifically authorized use in this future land use area, which is consistent with the concept of locating such use in a very low density location and away from denser areas of the County. This use was contemplated at the time the language was placed in the definition of the DR/GR, which can only be construed as meaning that the authors intended that the use would be acceptable in the future. This Hearing Examiner can only conclude that the Applicant's request is compatible with the existing low density residential community. This may not be acceptable to the relatively small number of residents who live near the proposed project. Nevertheless, the Lee County Comprehensive Plan clearly puts property owners, and future property owners, on notice of the activities that may be lawful within the DR/GR. Traffic Compatibility Issues The issue that drew the most opposition, or comment, from the public, was that of the increase in truck traffic from the site. The Applicant has requested a condition limiting the site to 2,400 daily round trips, or 4,800 one-way trips, of dump trucks. These trucks may be accessing the site around the clock, based on the Applicant's contractual obligations. There is no question that this is a significant increase in activity on Corkscrew Road. The Applicant has included proposed conditions that would route incoming and outgoing trucks, from the site, east on Corkscrew Road to Alico Road northwest and onto Interstate 75, or other roadways. The purpose of that condition is to limit the truck traffic on the sections of Corkscrew Road, west of Alico. How successful the Applicant will be in the compliance and enforcement of these conditions remains to be seen. Based on the testimony before this Hearing Examiner,it is clear,that,even with this proposed increase in traffic,the Level of Service for the segment of Corkscrew Road,from the entrance to Applicant's project, to Alico Road will be at an acceptable level. The Applicant's Traffic Impact Study, which has been confirmed by the Lee County Department of Transportation, treated each truck as though it were 1.7 passenger vehicles. That is the only standard imposed by Lee County Ordinances. The County Staffs opposition to the truck issue is a belief that it will increase traffic accidents, funnel traffic into a residential area, increase road congestion, and increase road wear. The Case DCI2006-00026 Page 40 of 70 • 07-Apr-10- - i Applicant asserts it has met the only County standard imposed upon them, that is an acceptable Level of Service at the commencement of operations. The testimony clearly indicated that road use will increase by as much as 4,800 single truck trips, or 2,400 round trips, per day. After consideration of that number of trips, experts from both the County Staff and the Applicant, agree that an acceptable level of service will exist on Corkscrew Road. The Applicant has asserted that once an acceptable level of service has been proven, no further examination of the issue is appropriate. They rely on the case of Debes vs. City of Key West, 690 So.2d 700, 701-702 (Fla. 3d DCA 1997) as their authority for this position. In that case, the Court held that, "Because it is virtually self-evident that, by its very nature, all commercial uses create 'more traffic' than non-commercial ones, it is equally obvious that local government cannot justify a denial of a particular commercial use on this ground. To hold otherwise would mean, as it apparently did in the proceedings before the Commission, that the protectable rights of any owner may be arbitrarily destroyed. This is not and we will not let it be, the law." County Staff also took the position that truck traffic will increase accidents along this segment. This is a speculative statement. Their traffic expert, Mr. Campbell, produced a formula used in the prediction of traffic accidents. He did not apply the formula to the subject site. Rather, he made mention of an increased safety risk without reliance on any data, or other evidence to support the same. In his testimony, he could not recall the posted speed limit on the subject segment, or if there was a different limit after dark. In short, there is no serious definitive evidence supporting the assertion that the Applicant's request would result ✓ in increased traffic accidents. This Hearing Examiner agrees with the Applicant that once an acceptable level of service is proven,the issue becomes moot. All development,be it industrial,commercial or residential, implicitly implies an increase in traffic. To deny a use,just because it results in an increase in traffic, would allow all development to be denied. The real concern, to the undersigned, is that there has been no readily ascertainable standard set forth to determine when truck traffic becomes unacceptable or simply not safe. The Staff did come with a formula for determining the"potential"for future truck accidents. However,intuitively it stands to reason, when traffic increases,accidents increase. That is not the test that can be employed here. In order to deny the Applicant his requested use, and lawful enjoyment of the property, this Hearing Examiner believes that a readily ascertainable,and scientifically supported,standard must be the basis for determining the limitation of truck traffic any segment of roadway. No such standard has be proffered, nor has is it been suggested that such a standard even exists. The County Staff has also asserted that approval of this request would be inconsistent with Lee Comprehensive Plan Policy 7.1.9.53 This assertion is totally misplaced. All parties have agreed that this segment of Corkscrew Road is a arterial roadway, which is defined as a Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 7.1.9: Industrial Development will not be permitted if it allows industrial traffic to travel through predominantly residential areas. Case DC12006-00026 Page 41 of 70 07-Apr-10- 1 2 .; * street primarily intended to carry large volumes of through traffic connecting major activity centers to other major traffic generators. Access to abutting properties is a secondary function."54 Lee County's Traffic Safety expert indicated that this application would double truck traffic on Corkscrew Road, and that there were already 2,000 round trip truck trips on that roadway. This area currently has large amounts of commercial trucks through it daily. Corkscrew Road has another mine and large agricultural operations on it. Those operations place dump trucks and tractor-trailer vehicles on this roadway, carrying dirt, rock and agricultural products. Most of the residential properties are located on local roads, accessed from Corkscrew Road. The reality is that this segment of Corkscrew Road is a mixed use area, with residential uses comprising only a part of the total activity. It is also clear that Corkscrew Road is fulfilling its purpose as an arterial roadway, and that it is intended for the uses contemplated by the Applicant. This Hearing Examiner finds that the increase in truck traffic, over the existing and similar traffic,does not raise a new compatibility issue. There is currently extensive dump truck and agricultural truck traffic on the roadway. The Applicant's proposal increases truck traffic, it does not create a new truck corridor. That use already exists. Those types of vehicles already extensively employ Corkscrew Road, between Alico Road and the Lee County line,. Compatibility with Blasting The Applicant has requested permission to use blasting incident to its mining operation. The mining of limestone cannot take place without the use of explosives. The Florida Legislature has divested counties from the regulation of blasting activities. The Applicant has come forwarded and agreed to be contractually limited in its blasting activities, in such a way as to produce no more than a peak particle velocity of 0.35 inches per second,when measured at a distance of 1,000 feet from the blast site. This agreement to treat, as a contractually obligated provision, which will be capable of enforcement in Circuit Court. County Staff has taken the position that it cannot be treated as a contractual obligation,because the State Fire Marshal has exclusive jurisdiction over blasting activities. The Hearing Examiner called for legal briefs to support these various positions;however,there appears to be no case law that is dispositive of the issue. The Hearing Examiner is of the opinion that if the Applicant agrees to have it treated as a contractual limitation, that the same will be enforceable in the Courts of this State. It is a limitation that they have consented to, in consideration,for the requested rezoning. It does not deprive the State Fire Marshal of its oversight authority. The limitation is more restrictive than the current state law. There was testimony from neighbors regarding the vibrations they were experiencing from blasts from other existing mines. There was no testimony that they exceeded the current limitations imposed by the State of Florida. The testimony on the subject, from the County's expert, Mr. Glenn Rix, and from the Applicant's expert, Frank Luccia, reflect agreement that blasts,at the maximum levels,set out in the conditions hereto,would not create any threshold structural damage, and would be within an acceptable range of vibration. It should also be noted that the conditions herein also contain provisions to determine if damages are occurring, or have occurred, to wells at residential homes sites. They are also intended to remedy any such damage, at the Applicant's expense. 54 Lee County Land Development Code Sectionl 0-1,Street Subsection(3)a. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 42 of 70 07-Apr-10- The Hearing Examiner finds that the current residents of this area of Lee County,are already experiencing blasting activities and knew that the same could be expected to occur in the area of Lee County. The Applicant's blasting for mine extraction purposes is not incompatible with other neighboring land uses and is, in fact, compatible with current blasting activities from other sites within the DR/GR. It is also the opinion of the Hearing Examiner, that the limitation of blasting levels, does not constitute"contract zoning." The Hydrological Barrier The hydrologic barrier, and accompanying Adaptive Management Plan, was the source of considerable expert testimony and review. There are two parts to the physical barrier. The slurry wall,which is the top portion of the barrier. It is, as the name implies, a wall of a slurry substance that is placed in the top layer of earth on the site. The wall is placed immediately on top of the limestone layer to the surface of the land. Below this wall is the grout curtain, which are bored holes, filled under pressure with grout, that resist the underground water flow. That wall extends from the top of the limestone layer to several feet into the confining layer. The County Staffs actual position with respect to this hydrologic barrier is vague. They appear to be opposed to it. However, the testimony of their witnesses, and questions of Applicant's witnesses, reveal that, in reality, they know little about the process. This is not a new engineering process, and has been used for over a century, with successful results. The testimony from all of the Applicant's experts,who are eminently qualified in the planning and design of these structures, is that the proposed hydrologic barrier, if adjusted and modified by procedures set forth in the Adaptive Management Plan, will provide the necessary restrictions to ground flow, in order to prevent off-ste impacts. This is not contested by the County Staff. They produced no experts who testified regarding hydrologic barrier technology.That omission does not appear to be accidental. In fact,the reality of the matter is that Staff has admitted that the hydrologic barrier will work, provided the Adaptive Management Plan is properly finessed. The Proposed Adaptive Management Plans, yes there are two, provides for a monitoring system measuring ground flow based upon the input or data, from monitoring wells, in and near the subject property. The use of the term "adaptive" means that the Plan can be modified based upon the data inputed to the system. This is where the disagreement exists between the experts. The Hearing Examiner sat through hours of testimony on the Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan. The parties differ in issues dealing with modeling input, selection of data sites, and other scientific issues beyond the understanding, or the expertise, of this Hearing Examiner, and frankly most other individuals in the hearing room. The Adaptive Management Plan is a document designed to be "adaptive" and subject to modification by experts in that field, as more data and information is received. The sources for the data are clearly in place. The specific issues dealing with "tweaking"the Plan should not be taken up in this proceeding. They are issues that would be most effectively reviewed during the development order process. They certainly are not severe enough to constitute an impediment to approval of this rezoning request, nor should the same be a basis for denying the Applicant its request. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 43 of 70 07-Apr-10- t i. Surface Water Flow The subject site, at all material times hereto, and for several decades, has been developed and used for agricultural purposes. It has a berm along its perimeter to restrict surface water flow, on to the subject site,from the Flint Pen Strand. That flowway runs from the northeast to the southwest, and essentially around the northern boundary of the property. The Applicant's property was once within the boundaries of that flowway. It is not now and has not been part of the flowway for decades. Within the subject site are a series of agricultural drainage canals. Staff has tried to convince the Hearing Examiner that part of the water from the flowway crosses the Applicant's property, through breaks in the north part of the berm. This is without any real evidence of any significant water flow. The Staff produced aerial photographs, and pictures,of grass flowing in the water of these ditches, near the breaches, but no definitive scientific proof of any surface water flow from the flowway. The purpose of proving this water flows through the site, is to assume that the new berm system, proposed by the Applicant, would direct additional water to the Burgundy Farms residential area. The clear and convincing testimony from the Applicant's experts supports the position that the development of the Applicant's property, as proposed, will not create any additional surface water issues to that residential area. They may continue to have flooding, but that is simply because they chose to develop the residential area within the confines of a flowway. Surface water flow should not be changed to any degree by the Applicant's project. Environmental Factors The County Staff and public have all contended that the subject property will have serious detrimental environmental impacts. This property is developed and used as an agricultural site. Any large wetland areas were removed decades ago. This property is on the edge of the Flint Pen Strand Flowway,which is inhabited by the Florida Panther, and other protected species. Telemetry data from collars on the Florida Panther, imposed on an aerial photograph, Exhibit V attached hereto, clearly reflects that, while the panthers roam the nearby slough,there is no use of the Applicant's property. This agricultural site is clearly not panther habitat. There is no significant use of the Applicant's site by any endangered or monitored species. Strategic Mining One of the County Staffs arguments in opposition to the subject application is that current existing and approved mines will provide sufficient quantities of limestone,for all uses, in the foreseeable future. In support of this argument, detailed testimony was provided by William A. Spikowski. Staff has not cited any authority for the proposition that a rezoning can be denied because adequate sources of a product are available elsewhere. Likewise, the Hearing Examiner has found no provision of the Lee County Ordinances to support such a position, especially with regard to a product that has regional implications. Reliance on such a criteria might invite preemption by the legislature. Since, the Hearing Examiner is without authority to consider such issue, it will not be further discussed. In prior decisions from this office, both Hearing Examiners have rejected the assertion that proliferation, of any use is an appropriate basis for denial of a rezoning, or conditions to a rezoning. This Hearing Examiner will maintain that position with regard to this recommendation. Case DC12006-00026 Page 44 of 70 07-Apr-10- ' 1 7 Consistency with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan This Hearing Examiner, based on the evidence and testimony before him, makes the following findings regarding the proposed projects consistency with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan(Lee Plan). The Lee Plan's Vision Statement recognizes the existence of mining operations in that community. It also recognizes that the community is not anticipated to change, and mining operations are expected to continue operations,within the area, through at least 2030. The request is therefore consistent with Lee County Comprehensive Plan, Vision Statement, Section 18. (See Footnote 2) Material excavation is a permitted use within the DR/GR. The Applicant has proposed safeguards to maintain surface and groundwater levels,at historic levels,making the request consistent with Policy 1.4.5 of the Lee Plan. (See Footnote 1) The proposed restoration, preservation and enhancement of the wetlands and uplands, in conjunction with the Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan, will maintain the ecological functions of the wetlands in the vicinity of the proposed uses. The project will add value to wildlife by creating a larger vegetated buffer between the wetland mitigation lands, to the north and east. The Applicant will also eradicate nuisance and exotic species and provide a conservation easement for their perpetual protection. This is consistent with Policy 1.5.1 of the Lee Plan. (See Footnote 1) Adequate buffering is provided on the site to mitigate impacts to adjacent property owners from noise, dust and light. There is substantial indigenous vegetation restoration to provide visual buffers. No odors will emanate from the site. Required best management practices, complying with all appropriate Federal and state statutes, will be employed at the project. Applicant's Adaptive Management Plan will provide protection from adverse water quality and quantity, throughout development and after termination of mining operations. There is one access point to the subject site. The Applicant's Traffic Impact Statement indicates an acceptable level of service,along Corkscrew Road,during the pendency of mining activities. There is no substantive evidence before the Hearing Examiner that Corkscrew Road is significantly more dangerous, as a result of this request. Police,fire and EMS services are available and adequate to serve this site. This resource, Limerock, is vital to the local and state economy and infrastructure. This Hearing Examiner finds the Applicant's request consistent with Lee County Comprehensive Plan Goals 7, 37 and 39, Objective 7.1, and Policies 7.1.1, 7.1.2, 7.1.3, 7.1.10, 39.1.1 and 39.1.5.55 55 Lee County Comprehensive Plan Goal 7: INDUSTRIAL LAND USES.To promote opportunities for well-planned industrial development at suitable locations within the county. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Objective 7.1: All development approvals for industrial land uses must be consistent with the following policies,the general standards under Goal 11,and other provisions of this plan. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 7.1.1: In addition to the standards required herein, the following factors apply to industrial rezoning and development order applications: 1.The development must comply with local,state,and federal air,water,and noise pollution standards. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 45 of 70 07-Apr-10- Ahk 2. When located next to residential areas, industry must not generate noise levels incompatible with the residential development. 3.Bulk storage or production of toxic,explosive,or hazardous materials will not be permitted near residential areas. 4. Contamination of ground or surface water will not be permitted. 5.Applications for industrial development will be reviewed and evaluated as to: a. air emissions(rezoning and development orders); b. impact and effect on environmental and natural resources(rezoning and development orders); c.effect on neighbors and surrounding land use(rezoning); d. impacts on water quality and water needs(rezoning and development orders); e.drainage system(development orders); 1.employment characteristics(rezoning); g.fire and safety(rezoning and development orders); h.noise and odor(rezoning and development orders); i. buffering and screening(planned development rezoning and development orders); j. impacts on transportation facilities and access points(rezoning and development orders); k.access to rail,major thoroughfares,air,and,if applicable,water(rezoning and development orders); I.utility needs(rezoning and development orders);and m.sewage collection and treatment(rezoning and development orders). Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 7.1.2: Industrial developments requiring rezoning and meeting Development of County Impact (DCI) thresholds must be developed as Planned Developments designed to arrange uses as an integrated and cohesive unit in order to: 1.promote compatibility and screening; 2. reduce dependence on the automobile; 3. promote pedestrian movement within the development; 4. utilize joint parking,access and loading facilities; 5.avoid negative impacts on surrounding land uses and traffic circulation; 6. protect natural resources;and 7. provide necessary facilities and services where they are inadequate to serve the proposed use. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 7.1.3: Industrial land uses must be located in areas appropriate to their special needs and constraints,including,but not limited to, considerations of: topography; choice and flexibility in site selection; access by truck, air, deep water, and rail; commuter access from home-to-work trips; and utilities; greenbelt and other amenities; air and water quality considerations;proximity to supportive and related land uses;and compatibility with neighboring uses. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 7.1.10: All county actions relating to industrial land uses must be consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the Economic element of this Plan. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Goal 37: LEVEL OF SERVICE STANDARDS.Establish and maintain specified levels of service on state and county roads within unincorporated Lee County and the roads the county maintains within the municipalities,including those level of service standards adopted by Rule by the Florida Department of Transportation for Florida Intrastate Highway System(FINS) facilities. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Goal 39: DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS.Maintain clear,concise,and enforceable development regulations that fully address on-site and off-site development impacts and protect and preserve public transportation facilities. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 39.1.1: • New development must: Case DCI2006-00026 Page 46 of 70 07-Apr-10- ` 7 it Natural resource extraction is a specifically identified use within the DR/GR. The Applicant has provided methods to insure that natural resource extraction activities minimize or eliminate adverse effect on the surrounding properties and natural resources. The Applicant • has provided an environmental assessment report addressing potential impacts, and demonstrating the methodologies that will be employed to avoid or reduce those impacts. The Florida Department of Environmental Protection has reviewed those submissions, and has issued the permits required to undertake this activity. A careful review of the Applicant's most recent Master Concept Plan indicates that they have. This application is consistent with Lee County Comprehensive Plan Goal 10, Objective 10.1 and Policies 5.1.5,10.1.1, 10.1.2, 10.1.3 and 10.1.5. •Have adequate on-site parking. •Have access to the existing or planned public road system except where other public policy would prevent such access. •Fund all private access and intersection work and mitigate all site-related impacts on the 'l public road system;this mitigation is not eligible for credit against impact fees. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 39.1.5: The Land Development Code will continue to require appropriate landscaping for developments abutting arterial and collector roads. 56 Lee County Comprehensive Plan Goal 10: NATURAL RESOURCE EXTRACTION.To protect areas containing identified natural resources from incompatible urban development, while insuring that natural resource extraction operations minimize or eliminate adverse effects on surrounding land use and natural resources. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Objective 10.1: Designate through the rezoning process sufficient lands suitable for providing fill material,limerock,and other natural resource extraction materials to meet the county's needs and to export to other communities,while providing adequate protection for the county's natural resources. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 5.1.5: Protect existing and future residential areas from any encroachment of uses that are potentially destructive to the character and integrity of the residential environment. Requests for conventional rezonings will be denied in the event that the buffers provided in Chapter 10 of the Land Development Code are not adequate to address potentially incompatible uses in a satisfactory manner.If such uses are proposed in the form of a planned development or special exception and generally applicable development regulations are deemed to be inadequate,conditions will be attached to minimize or eliminate the potential impacts or,where no adequate conditions can be devised,the application will be denied altogether.The Land Development Code will continue to require appropriate buffers for new developments. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 10.1.1: Natural resource extraction operations intending to withdraw groundwater for any purpose must provide a monitoring system to measure groundwater impacts. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 10.1.2: Applications for natural resource extraction permits for new or expanding areas must include an environmental assessment.The assessment will include(but not be limited to)consideration of air emissions,impact on environmental and natural resources,effect on nearby land uses,degradation of water quality,depletion of water quantity,drainage, fire and safety, noise, odor,visual impacts,transportation including access roads, sewage disposal,and solid waste Case DC12006-00026 Page 47 of 70 07-Apr-10- This Hearing Examiner did not find the Applicant's request inconsistent with or not in compliance with any other provision of the Lee County Comprehensive Plan or the Lee County Land Development Code. The undersigned Hearing Examiner finds that the requested rezoning, meet the criteria necessary for approval, including consistency with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan and Lee County Land Development Code. The new zoning district, as conditioned, is compatible with neighboring properties. Consequently,this Hearing Examiner recommends approval of rezoning the subject parcel to an Industrial Planned Development (IPD) subject to the conditions and deviations set forth herein. In compliance with Section 3.1 of Lee County Administrative Code AC-2-6,the undersigned Hearing Examiner conducted a site visit to the subject real property prior to issuing this recommendation. V. FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS: Based upon the Staff Report, the testimony and exhibits presented in connection with this matter, the undersigned Hearing Examiner makes the following findings and conclusions: A. That the Applicant has proven entitlement to the rezoning by demonstrating compliance with the Lee County Comprehensive Plan, the Lee County Land Development Code, and any other applicable code or regulation. B. That the request will meet or exceed all performance and locational standards set forth for the potential uses allowed by the request. C. That the request is consistent with the densities, intensities and general uses set forth in the Lee County Comprehensive Plan. disposal. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 10.1.3: Applications for natural resource extraction permits for new or expanding sites must include a reclamation plan which provides assurance of implementation. Reclamation plans in or near important groundwater resource areas must be designed to minimize the possibility of contamination of the groundwater during mining and after completion of the reclamation. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 10.1.4: Natural resource extraction activities (and industrial uses which are ancillary tonatural resource extraction)may be permitted in areas indicated on the Future Land Use Map as Rural,Open Lands,and Density Reduction/Groundwater Resources,provided they have adequate fire protection,transportation facilities,wastewater treatment and water supply, - and provided further that they have no significant adverse effects such as dust and noise on surrounding land uses and natural resources. In order to reduce transport costs and minimize wear on the county's roadways,the extraction and transport of fill material may also be permitted as an interim use in the Future Urban Areas provided that the above requirements are met;however,special restrictions may also be applied to protect other land uses.These determinations will be made during the rezoning process. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Policy 10.1.5: Lee County will support efforts by government,community leaders,and the extractive industry owners and businesses to seek incentives that will help to facilitate the connection of natural resource extraction borrow lake excavations into a system of interconnected lakes and flowways that will enhance wildlife habitat values,provide for human recreation, educational and other appropriate uses,and/or strengthen community environmental benefits. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 48 of 70 07-Apr-10- Or 7 • D. That the request is compatible with existing or planned uses in the surrounding area.. E. That approval of the request will not place an undue burden upon existing transportation or planned infrastructure facilities and will be served by streets with the capacity to carry traffic generated by the development. F. That, where applicable, the request will not adversely affect environmentally critical areas and natural resources. G. That the proposed use or mix of uses is appropriate at the subject location. H. That the recommended conditions to the concept plan and other applicable regulations provide sufficient safeguard to the public interest. I. That the recommended conditions are reasonably related to the impacts on the public interest created by or expected from the proposed development. VI. LIST OF EXHIBITS: STAFF'S EXHIBITS 1. Resume of Alvin H. Block III, AICP, Senior Planner of Department of Community Development 2. PowerPoint Presentation consisting of Corkscrew Excavation Case Chronology ( CD ) ( Hard Copy) 3. Excerpts of Application 4. Resume of Andrew Getch, Lee County Department of Transportation 5. Excerpts from U.S. Transportation Department, Highway Capacity Manual 2000 6. Excerpts from Lee County Concurrency Report 2008 7. Excerpts from Traffic Count Report 2008, prepared by Lee County Department of Transportation, dated February 2009 8. Excerpts from Commercial Motor Vehicle Manual, prepared by Florida Department of Transportation 9. PowerPoint Presentation, prepared by Lee County Department of Transportation ( Hard Copy) 10. Resume of Dr. Glenn J. Rix, Georgia Institute of Technology 11. Power Point Presentation of Ground Vibrations and Human Annoyance from Blasting, prepared by Glenn J. Rix, Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology (Hard Copy) (color) Case DC12006-00026 Page 49 of 70 07-Apr-10- ` 7 12. Resume of Harry A. Campbell, P.E., P.T.O.E., Lee County Department of Transportation 13. Professional Opinion- Crash Analysis, prepared by Harry A. Campbell, Lee County Department of Transportation 14. Large Truck Crash Facts 2006, dated January 2008 and prepared by The Analysis Division, Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration 15. Lee County Truck Impact Evaluation, prepared by David Douglas Associates, Inc., dated July 2008 16. Comprehensive Truck Size,Volumes I, II, I II and IV, prepared by the U.S.Department of Transportation 17. PowerPoint Presentation, prepared by Harry Campbell, including a comparison between Alico and Corkscrew Roads 18. Roland Ottolini Resume, Division Director of Lee County Natural Resources Management 19. PowerPoint Presentation, provided by Roland Ottolini, consisting of Lee County Division of Natural Resources role and responsibilities and overview of Corkscrew Excavation Mine Site and Vicinity (color) (28 pages) (2 sided) (8 1/2"x11") 20. Samuel B. Lee resume, Engineering Manager of Lee County Natural Resources Division 21. PowerPoint Presentation, regarding the Hydraulic Barrier and the Adaptive Management Plan, prepared by Samuel B. Lee (color) (23 pages) (8 1/2"x11") 22. PowerPoint Presentation, consisting of Groundwater Model, prepared by Samuel B. Lee (color) (14 pages) (8 1/2"x11") 23. L. A. (Tony) Pellicer Biographical information 24. PowerPoint Presentation consisting of Monitoring Plan for Hydrologic and Water Quality, prepared by L.A. Pellicer, Lee County Natural Resources Division(11 pages) [color] 25. Monitoring Well L-1995 Historic Baseline and New Baseline Chart (color) and Lee County Water Quality Monitoring- General Plan, prepared by Lee County Natural Resources 26. Lee County Port Authority Overview PowerPoint Presentation, prepared by Lee County Port Authority (color) [14 pages] 27. Lonnie V. Howard, P.E. Resume, Professional Engineer Case DCI2006-00026 Page 50 of 70 07-Apr-10- { 28. PowerPoint Presentation consisting of Hydrological Assessment of Corkscrew Excavation, prepared by Johnson Engineering 29. Churchill Roberts Resume, Director of the Environmental Team at Johnson Engineering 30 Environmental Analysis PowerPoint Presentation,Proposed Corkscrew Mine and the Airport Mitigation Park, prepared by Johnson Engineering (color) 31. Aaron Martin Resume, Environmental Planner, Lee County Division of Environmental Sciences • 32. PowerPoint Presentation consisting of Setbacks and Preserve Protection, prepared by Aaron Martin 33. Rebecca Sweigert Resume, Principal Environmental Planner, Lee County Division of Environmental Sciences 34. Wildlife PowerPoint Presentation consisting of Protected Species Location Maps, prepared by Rebecca Sweigert, Lee County Division of Environmental Sciences (39 pages) [color] 35. Suzanne Derheimer Resume, Environmental Planner, Lee County Division of Environmental Sciences 36. Open Space, Indigenous Preservation, Reclamation, & Buffering PowerPoint Presentation, prepared by Susie Derheimer, Lee County Division of Environmental Sciences (color) [101 pages] 37. Matthew A. Noble Resume, Senior Planner, Lee County Department of Community Development, Division of Planning 38. Matthew A. Noble Updated Resume, Principal Planner, Lee County Department of Community Development, Division of Planning 39. PowerPoint Presentation consisting of aerial perspective pictures,Off-site impacts of mining, a brief community history,Corkscrew Excavation Lee Plan Staff Consistency Analysis Staff Report, prepared by Matthew A. Noble, Principal Planner, Lee County Department of Community Development (115 pages) [color] 40. Strategic Mining consisting of a report on mining in Lee County, prepared by Lee County Division of Planning, dated September 30, 2002 41. Character and Landscape PowerPoint Presentation, dated October 6, 2009, consisting of Alico Road Landscape Photos taken on October 5, 2009 42. BOCC Minute, dated September 5, 2008 43. HEX Recommendation for DCI2000-00057, case heard on March 15, 2001 Case DC12006-00026 Page 51 of 70 07-Apr-10- 44. CD consisting of Fort Myers Mine#2 45. Ground Water Resource Protection Study,prepared by Henigar&Ray,dated July 28, 1993 46. Future Land Use Map, Lee Plan Map 1, Page 1 (color) (11"x17") 47. Mean Monthly Rainfall 48. Scott M. Gilbertson Letter in reference to Alico Road Existing Functional Classification, Director of The Department of Transportation, dated October 19,2007 49. William M. Spikowski Resume 50. Spikowski PowerPoint Presentation consisting of charts and aerial maps 51. Test Sites for Hydraulic Conductivity Values Used in Schlumberger Model aerial map and Excel Spread Sheet, prepared by Johnson Engineering, dated October 19,2009 52. Dr. Missimer's Hand Drawn Diagram (24"x36") 53. Dr. Coulibay data submitted to Dr. Lee in a CD • 54. The Impact of Mining on Water Quality and Water Quantity in the DR/GR, prepared by Thomas M. Missimer and Robert G. Maliva 55. Composite consisting of Technical Memorandum Groundwater Modeling Results Old Corkscrew Golf Club, prepared by Missimer International, Inc., dated July 24, 2000 56. Technical Memorandum to Lee County Port Authority in reference to Johnson Engineering, Inc's review of the additional modeling information submitted regarding potential impacts to the Lee County Port Authority Airport Mitigation Park, prepared by Lonnie Howard, dated October 1, 2009 57. Speed Zoning for Highways, Roads, and Streets in Florida Report, prepared by Florida Department of Transportation, 1997 Edition 58. Composite consisting of Letters to Mr. David W. Depew from the Department of Community Development in reference to the zoning application, and Letters in response from David W. Depew to the Department of Community Development. 59. Aerial Map consisting of GPS on Panthers 60. Close up Panther Point Map 61. Aerial Map consisting of 24 Hour Telemetry Data • 62. Lee E. West Jr. Resume, Lee County Natural Resources Division Case DC12006-00026 Page 52 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 63. Rebuttal on RCH Ground-Water Flow Model Based on ASTM & USGS Guidelines, prepared by Sam Lee, dated by November 3, 2009 64. USGS Guidelines for Evaluating Ground- Water Flow Models Report, prepared by Thomas E. Reily and Arlen W. Harbaugh 65. Unites States Department of the Interior Memorandum in reference to Groundwater Modeling Guidance for Mining Activities, dated April 21, 2008 66. Request for Appeal of Zoning Board Decision 85-5-8, appeal submitted May 30, 1985 67. Dump Truck Traffic Generation 68. Minutes for May 21, 1985 A and May 28,1985 ZB, in reference to 85-5-8 DCI 69. Summary Report for 85-5-8 DCI 70. Minutes July 8, 1985 in reference to 85-5-8 71. Master Concept Plan from 85-5-8, revised May 9, 1990 72. Resume of Bradley Browning, Senior Environmental Planner, Lee County Division of Environmental Sciences 73. Bradley Browning Affidavit, consisting of observing a Panther crossing Corkscrew Road on October 26, 2009, affidavit dated November 5, 2009 74. Composite consisting of Corkscrew Road and Alico Road School Bus Stops Map and List 75. Proposed Changes in Lee Plan Policies 76. Staff Basis for Proposed Conditions 77. Aggregate Certified for FDOT, Production Report for July 2007 to July 2009,prepared by Florida Department of Transportation 78. Composite consisting of Approved Aggregate Products from Mines or Terminals Report and Maps 79. Staff Comments on Applicant's November 3, 2009 Revised Conditions 80. Article from Florida Department of Health in reference to Groundwater Risks Résumés of Lee County Staff are on file with the Hearing Examiner's Office and are incorporated herein. Case DCI2006-00026 Page 53 of 70 07-Apr-10- . 7 APPLICANT'S EXHIBITS 1. Composite Aerial Photographs of Subject with Wells, dated 2005-2008 (color) (11"x17") (2 pages) 2. Lee County Comprehensive Plan Excerpts 3. Lee County Future Land Use Map, generated December 2007 (color) (11"x17") 4. Southeast Lee County DRGR Future Land Use Map, generated December 2007 (Color) (11"x17") 5. Lee County Planning Communities Map 16,generated January 2008(color)(11"x17") 6. Chart of Buffer Zones in LDC regarding Noxious Uses 7. 2005 Aerial Photograph, Strategic Mining Map Overlay-Active & Approved Mines, prepared by Morris Depew, dated April 6, 2009 (color) (11"x17") 8. Composite consisting of Mining History as follows: '8A. -Westwinds Mine-Corkscrew Mining Ventures 1) Lee County Development Services Division Staff Report for DCI2000-00057 & DCI2002-00066 cases 2)Hearing Examiner Recommendation for Case 99-04-035.06S 01.01,heard on June 23, 1999 and Hearing Examiner Recommendation for DCI2000-00057, heard on March 15, 2001 3) Board of County Commissioners Resolution#Z-01-016 8B.- University Westlakes Mine 1) Lee County Development Services Division Staff Report for DCI2002-00075 2)Hearing Examiner Recommendation for DCI2000-00079, heard on November 21, 2001 and DC12002-00075, heard on June 4, 2003 3) Board of County Commissioners Resolutions#Z-00-039,#Z-01-043 and #Z-03- 36 8C.- Bell Road Mine 1) Lee County Development Services Division Staff Report for DCI2003-00077 2) Hearing Examiner Recommendation for DCI2003-00077, heard on July 8, 2004 3) Board of County Commissioners Resolution#Z-04-047 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 54 of 70 07-Apr-10 - 8D.- Bonita Grande Mine-Hubschman 1) Lee County Development Services Division Staff Reports for DCI2001-00065 and 98-01-237.03Z 01.01 cases 2) Hearing Examiner Recommendations for 98-01-237.03Z 01.01 and DCI2001- 00065 cases 3) Board of County Commissioners Resolutions#Z-02-047, Z-87-199 and Z-98-071 8E.- Estero IPD 1) Lee County Development Services Division Staff Report for DC12006-00007 2) Hearing Examiner Recommendation for DCI2006-00007 3) Board of County Commissioners Resolution#Z-06-097 8F.- Schwab 640 1) Lee County Development Services Division Staff Report for DCI2001-00002, Revised Staff Report dated February 11, 2002 and Staff Report for 89-8-8-3DCI 2) Hearing Examiner Recommendation for DCI2001-00002 3) Board of County Commissioner Resolutions #Z-01-046, Z-89-081, # Z-89-81 A and#ZAB-85-105 8G.- Southwest Florida Rock LLC 1) Lee County Development Services Division Staff Report for DCI2001-00055 2) Hearing Examiner Recommendation for DCI2001-00055 3) Board of County Commissioners Resolution#Z-02-053 9. Lee County Land Development Code- Definition of Residential District 10. Summary and copies of Newspaper Articles 10A. DVD consisting of Management and Planning Meeting on April 7, 2009 and DRGR Meeting on August 1, 2009, audio files 11. Burgundy Farms Road Aerial Photograph and Data (11"x17") (color) 12. Bella Terra Aerial Photograph and Data (color) (11"x17") 13. Section 21, 22, 27, 28, 33&34, Township 46, Range 27-Lazy D Ranch Road Aerial Photograph and Data (11"x17") (color) Case DC12006-00026 Page 55 of 70 07-Apr-10- I7 14. Section 3,4,5,9&10,Township 46, Range 26-Devore Lane and Mallard Lane Aerial Photograph and Data (color) (11"x17") 15. Sections 26, 27, 34&35, Township 45, Range 27-Bell Road Mine Aerial Photograph and Data (11"x17") (color) 16. Venice Minerals Mine Aerial Photograph & Data (11"x17") (color) 17. Land Development Code document regarding Noise Zone Overlays 18. Lee County Development,Chapter 34,Text Highlighting Compatibility of Residential & Mining Uses 19. Land Use Analysis prepared by Morris Depew Associates, Inc. 20. Master Concept Plan prepared by Morris Depew, dated April 21, 2009 (11"x17") 21. Photographs of Berm on North Property and Line of RCH; Eastern Quadrant (2 photos) (color) (1 page 8112"x11") 22. MD PowerPoint Presentation (color) 23. Environmental Resource Permit No. 266397-001, issued February 27, 2009 24. South Florida Water Management Water Use Permit No. 36-06874-W, issued December 2, 2008 25. Resource Conservation Holdings, LLC., Final Judgment- Sufficiency Suit 26. Lee County v. Resource Conservation Holdings, LLC., Order of Taking- Condemnation Suit 27. Motion to Relinquish, Division of Administrative Hearings Case No. 08-6480 28. County's Response to Motion to Relinquish in District Water Use Permit Case, Division of Administrative Hearing Case No. 08-6480 29. Court Order Denying Motion to Relinquish in Water Use Permit Case, Division of Administrative Hearing Case No. 08-6480 30. E. Larry Sewell, Real Estate Appraiser& Consultant, curriculum vitae 31. W. Kirk Martin, P.G., Vice President, Camp Dresser& McKee Inc., curriculum vitae 32. Adaptive Management Plan, prepared by Brad D. Cook, P.G., Project Geologist, Camp Dresser& McKee Inc., dated August 2007 32A. CDM PowerPoint Presentation Case DCI2006-00026 Page 56 of 70 07-Apr-10- f7 33. Michael S. Schultz, Senior Vice President, CDM, curriculum vitae 34. Table of Grout Curtains (11"x17") 35. Intentionally Left Blank 36. Paul K. Owen, Principal Ecologist, curriculum vitae 37. Lee County Indigenous Area Management Plan, prepared by W. Dexter Bender & Associates, dated May 22, 2009 38. Jeffrey A. Straw, Consultant in Vibration and Acoustics, Vice President & Area Manager, GeoSonics Inc, curriculum vitae ' f 39. Blasting Plan, dated May 8, 2009, prepared by Jeffrey A. Straw, Vice President & Area Manager, GeoSonics, Inc. 40. Ted B. Treesh, President of Transportation Consultants, Inc., resume 41. Traffic Impact Analysis, prepared by TR Transportation Consultants, Inc., updated April 27, 2009 42. Traffic Accident Analysis, prepared by Morris Depew Associates, Inc 43. Patrolling Agreement with Lee County's Sheriff's Office 44. Intentionally Left Blank 45. Bonita Grande Mine and Bell Villa Data 46. Six LS Farm Road Aerial Photograph&Data, Sections 25&31,Township 46, Range 26 and Section 30& 31, township 46, Range 27 (color) (11"x17") 47A. Limerock Sample-soft rock with little porosity 478. Limerock Sample-hard rock with porosity 47C. Limerock Sample-hard rock with little porosity 48. Boundary and Topographic Survey, prepared by Morris- Depew Associates, Inc., dated March 20, 2006 (11"X17") 49. Corkscrew Excavation HEX Presentation by Paul Owen 50. Corkscrew Excavation Trip Calculations 51. Removal of Material from Site,Analysis consisting of Traffic Study Assumptions and Proposed Mining Plan Case DCI2006-00026 Page 57 of 70 07-Apr-10- . . 52. Corkscrew Mine Entrance Road- Dedicated Left Turn Lane and Acceleration Lane Proposal, prepared by Draper Technologies, LLC (11"x17") 53. Corkscrew Mine Intersection Improvements - Dedicated Left Turn on to Burgundy Farms Road Proposal, prepared by Draper Technologies, LLC (11"x17") 54. Corkscrew Mine Intersection Improvements- Dedicated Right and Left Turn Lane, improvements to Intersection of Alico Road and Corkscrew Road,prepared by Draper Technologies, LLC(11"x7") 55. Memorandum to Hearing Examiner regarding submitted documents and denial,dated May 19, 2009 56. Composite of Historical Aerial photographs, prepared by Morris-Depew Associates, Inc, dated May 22, 2009 (11"x17") 57. Revised Applicant Conditions 58. Surrounding Residential Aerial Photograph, prepared by Morris-Depew Associates, Inc., dated May 22, 2009 (color) (11"x17") 59 Applicant's Proposed Conditions- Final, revised August 5, 2009 and Proposed Conditions, dated July 14, 2009 [post hearing submittal] 60. Composite consisting of Mining and Excavation Plan,Master Concept Plan,prepared by Morris-Depew Associates, Inc.,dated April 21, 2009 and revised August 4,2009 ( 11"X17") and Master Concept Plan with Aerial, dated April 21, 2009 (11"x17") (color) 61. PowerPoint Presentation consisting of Revised Conditions Comparison, dated 8/19/2009 (hard copy) (color) 62. Comparison of Applicant's Proposed Conditions, Exhibit 57 vs. Exhibit 59, dated June 4, 2009 and revised conditions dated August 5, 2009 63. Two Letters from Florida Department of Environmental Protection, dated July 20, 2009 in reference to permits to operate the Concrete Batching Plant and Nonmetallic Mineral Processing Plants facilities 64. Conceptual Model and 3D representation of the conceptual model, prepared by Schlumberger Water Services USA, Inc. 65. Thomas M. Missimer, Ph.D., P.G., Vice President of Schlumberger Water Services USA Inc., Curriculum Vitae 66. Groundwater Modeling to Assess the Effects of a Hydraulic Barrier on Impacts of the RCH Mine and an Assessment of the Impacts on Lee County Utilities Water-Table Aquifer Production Wells, prepared by Schlumberger Water Services USA, Inc. Case DC12006-00026 Page 58 of 70 07-Apr-10- 7 67. RCH Mine Model Files, prepared by Dr. Missimer (CD) 68. Resume of Michael E. Roeder 69. Structure Response and Damage Produced by Ground Vibration from Surface Mine Blasting • 70. DCI2006-00026 Staff Report, dated May 12, 2009 71. Memorandum from Dawn Perry Lehnert, Assistant County Attorney to HEX, dated August 14, 2009 (2 pages) 72. Memorandum from Dawn Perry Lehnert, Assistant County Attorney to HEX, dated August 7, 2009 73. BOCC Resolution ZAB-86-62 74. BOCC Resolution Z-89-055 75. BOC Resolution Z-89-081 76. Proposed Lee Plan Amendments for Southeast Lee County,prepared by Dover,Kohl & Partners, dated May 2009 77. Staff Report for DCI2000-00057 Westwind, dated March15, 2001 78. BOCC Resolution Z-01-016 79. BOCC Resolution Z-00-039 80. Administrative Amendment ADD2000-00217 81. Southeast Lee County DRGR Well Field Protection Zones Map (color) (11"x17") 82. Panther Habitat Map (color) (11'x17") 83. Species Richness Map, consisting of Strategic Habitat and Conservation Areas important to flora,fauna and natural communities,determined by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation (color) (11"x17") 84. Southeast Lee County DRGR Major Flowways Maps (color) (11'x17") 85. Frank J. Lucca Curriculum Vitae, TerraDinamica L.L.0 86. Terra Dinamica Executive Summary, Lee County Blasting Study, prepared by Terra Dinamica LLC., dated June 2005 87. Lee County Blasting Study, prepared by Terra Dinamica LLC, dated June 2005 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 59 of 70 07-Apr-10 - { 88. Lee County Ordinance No. 06-07 89. Dr. Donald Alexander Bruce Resume, Director of Soldata, Inc 90. Dr. Bruce Diagram (Handwritten) [24"x36"] 91. Dr. Bruce Second Diagram ( Handwritten) [24"x36"] 92. Weixing Guo, Ph. D. P. G. Resume, Senior Hydrogeologist, Schlumberger Water Services, USA 93. Kapo Coulibaly, PhD. Resume, Hydrogeologist III, c/o Schlumberger Water Services 94. Dr. Meismer PowerPoint Presentation 95. Seismic Results, dated October 12, 2009 96. Seismic Results ( second location ), dated October 12, 2009 97. Prospects for Southeast Lee County, report prepared by Dover, Kohl & Partners, dated July 2008 98. Surface Water Rebuttal Presentation consisting of Aerial Photos and Graphs,dated October 2009 (34 pages) [color] [CD and Hard Copy] 99. Revised Boundary and Topographic Survey, prepared by Morris-Depew Associates, Inc., revised October 5, 2009 (11"x17") [14 pages] 100. Intersection Improvements Map, prepared by Draper Technology, LLC (11"x17") [4 pages] [color] 101. Power Point Presentation consisting of four(4)photographs of Corkscrew Road and Alico Road looking North at Corkscrew Road, Crash Analyses, professional opinion by Harry Campbell, Lee County Department of Transportation and graphs consisting of Accidents Rate and 2011 Projected Accidents 102. Surrounding Residential after 2001 Aerial Map, prepared by Morris- Depew Associates, dated October 13, 2009 (11"x17") [color] 103. BOCC Minutes, dated September 11, 2007 104. Composite Exhibit consisting of Memorandum from DCD to BOCC and Meeting Transcript from September 18, 2007 105. Toward a Greener Lee, Effective Planning Alternatives for Rural Lee County, prepared by Spikowski Planning Associates, dated November 15, 2007 106. Strategic Aggregates Review Task Force Final Report, dated February 1, 2008 Case DC12006-00026 Page 60 of 70 07-Apr-10- 107. Lee County Density Reduction/Groundwater Resource,Ad Hoc Steering Committee Report, dated July 30, 2008 108. Proposed Lee Plan Amendments for Southeast Lee County, dated May 2009, prepared by Dover, Kohl &Partners { 109. Staff Analysis and Recommendations for Comprehensive Plan Amendment, dated June 12, 2009 110. Paul 0' Connor Memorandum to Local Planning Agency in reference to DR/GR Amendments, dated July 17, 2009 111. Natural Resource Strategies for Southeast Lee County, prepared by Dover, Kohl & Partners, dated July 2009 112. Time line consisting of DR/GR Actions and RCH Application (5 pages) 113. Memorandum from Dawn E. Perry- Lehnert to Hearing Examiner, dated August 7, 2009 and Summary of Comments on Corkscrew Excavation Memo to HEX 114. Prospects for South East Lee County 115. Corkscrew Road Area Blasting Totals 2006-2008 (11"x17") 116. Aerial Map of Blast Complaints (11"x17") [color] 117. Complaints of Blast Effects including Residents List and copies of the Requests made for Investigation • 118. Lee Adaptive Management Plan-Corkscrew Excavation, prepared by M. Missimer, dated October 27, 2009 119. Composite Dr.Missimer's Grout Curtain Illustrations[Handwritten](4pages)[24"x36"] 120. Double-Mass Curves, prepared by James K. Searcy and Clayton H. Hardison 121. Composite consisting of Memorandum from Lonnie V. Howard,Johnson Engineering to Mr. Terrance 0. Bengtsson, Senior Hydrologist at South Florida Water Management District,in reference to Water Use Application Number 010511-7,dated September 30, 2002 122. Corkscrew Excavation Monitoring Well, Piezometer, and Staff Gauge locations map and Six(6) PZ3 Groundwater Hydrographs with different dates, prepared by CDM 123. Lee County Case Review Checklist 124. Chart consisting of Difference Between High Storativity and Low Storativity in the Lake Case DC12006-00026 Page 61 of 70 07-Apr-10- f 125. Indemnification and Hold Harmless Agreement Resource Conservation Holdings,LLC and Earthmark Southwest Florida Mitigation, LLC, dated October 30, 2009. 126. National Pollution Distribution, dated October 6, 2009 127. Management&Planning Committee Agenda in reference to Restricting Truck Traffic on Corkscrew Road 128. Composite consisting of Applicant's Proposed Conditions Revised as of November 3, 2009 129. PowerPoint Presentation, prepared by S. William Moore, Esq. Résumés of Applicant's consultants are on file with the Hearing Examiner's Office and are incorporated herein. PUBLIC'S EXHIBITS Payton's Exhibit: 1. Florida Wildlife Federation Presentation by Nancy A. Payton, dated May 29, 2009 Eslick Exhibit: 1. How many rocks does Lee County Need?document,testimony by Donald F. Eslick, dated September 5, 2008 Trebatoski Exhibits: 1. Resume of Trebatoski, Senior Ecologist, Kevin L. Erwin Consulting Ecologist, Inc. 2. Environmental Resource/Mitigation Bank Permit from Department of Environmental Protection, dated June 4, 2004 3. Letter from the Department of the Army, dated July 22, 2004 and Notice of Authorization 4. Letter from the Department of Environmental Protection dated November 8, 2006 regarding Permit Modifications 5. Composite consisting of Corkscrew Regional Mitigation Bank Photo Index and Photos (9 Photos) (81/2"x11") (color) Roeder Exhibits: 1. Copy of Hearing Examiner's Decision for Case 96-02-319.06S 02.01,dated February 17, 1998 Case DC12006-00026 Page 62 of 70 07-Apr-10- #. 2. Chronology of Corkscrew Road Mining Approvals, prepared by Mike Roeder, dated July 17, 2007 and revised August 19, 2008. Lauritsen Exhibit: 1. Resume of Jason Lauritsen , Assistant Director of Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary Schmidt Exhibit 1. Peggy Apgar Schmidt's PowerPoint Presentation consisting on Mine Impacts Cornell Exhibit 1. Audubon Society Presentation, consisting of Lee DRGR Natural Resources 2009 Report graph, slides from presentation given by Dr. Mike Duever at Corkscrew Swamp Sanctuary in April 2006, presented by Brad Cornell, Southwest Florida Policy Associate. Lytell Exhibits 1. Photograph of channeling on Corkscrew Road (8 Y2'x 11") [color] 2. 2 Photographs consisting of Trucks Traffic on Alico Road and Corkscrew Road(8 1/2' x 11") (color) 3. Photograph of Traffic (8 '/z" x 11") (color) Hill Exhibit 1. PowerPoint Presentation consisting on Corkscrew Rural Community including pictures (CD) (19 pages) [color] Carlson Exhibit 1. Photograph Hart Exhibit 1. Composite consisting of Policies and previous testimonies from Corkscrew Transcripts VII. PRESENTATION SUMMARY: See Official Court Reporter Transcripts VIII. OTHER PARTICIPANTS AND SUBMITTALS: Case DCI2006-00026 Page 63 of 70 07-Apr-10- f � 1 }• ADDITIONAL APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVES: 1. Dr. Donald Alexander Bruce, 161 Bittersweet Circle, Venetia, Pennsylvania 15367 2. Kapo Coulibaly,do Schlumberger Water Services, 1567 Hayley Lane, Suite 202,Fort Myers, Florida 33907 3. Richard Friday, do Youngquist Brothers, 15401 Alico Road, Fort Myers, Florida 4. Jamie Goble, do Brigham Moore LLP, 3277 Fruitville Road, Unit E, Sarasota, Florida 34237 5. Weixing Guo, Ph., D. P. G., do Schlumberger Water Services, 1567 Hayley Lane, Suite 202, Fort Myers, Florida 33907 6. Jodi Joseph,c/o Morris Depew Associates, Inc., 2914 Cleveland Avenue, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 7. Frank J. Lucca, do Terra Dinamica, LLC., 5 Meadow Brook Road, Granby, Connecticut 06035 8. Thomas M. Missimer, do Schlumberger Water Services USA, Inc., 1567 Hayley Lane, Suite 202, Fort Myers, Florida 33907 9. S.W. Moore,do Brigham Moore, LLP, 3277 Fruitville Road, Unit E,Sarasota, Florida 34237 :10.. Gregory S. Rix, do Brigham Moore, LLP, 3277 Fruitiville Road, Unit E, Sarasota, Florida 34237 11. Mike Schultz, do CDM, 50 Hamphire Street, Cambridge, MA 02139 12. Kim Sewell, do Brigham Moore LLP, 3277 Fruitville Road, Unit E, Sarasota, Florida 34237 13. Larry Sewell,do Sewell Valentich Tillis,3277 Fruitville Road, Unit F,Sarasota Florida 34237 14. Ryan Shute, do Morris Depew Associates, Inc., 2914 Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 • 15. Jeff Straw, do Geo Sonics, Inc., 4313 Southwest 64th Avenue, Davie, Florida 33314 16. Ted Treesh, do TR Transportation Consultants, 13881 Plantation Road, Fort Myers, Florida 33913 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 64 of 70 07-Apr-10- t ADDITIONAL COUNTY STAFF: 1. Brad Browning, Lee County Environmental Sciences, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 2. Harry Campbell, Lee County Department of Transportation, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 3. Susie Derheimer, Lee County Environmental Sciences, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 4. Andy Getch, Lee County Department of Transportation, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 5. Bill Homer, Lee County Port Authority, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 6. Sam Lee, Lee County Division of Natural Resources, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 7. Ellen Lindblad, Lee County Port Authority, P. O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 8 Aaron Martin, Lee County Environmental Science, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 9. Anura Karuna - Muni, Lee County Natural Resources, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 10. Matthew Noble, Division of Planning, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 11. Roland Ottolini, Lee County Division of Natural Resources, P.O.Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 12. Tony Pellicer, Lee County Division of Natural Resources, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 13. Dawn Perry-Lehnert,Assistant County Attorney, P. O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902-0398 14. Dr. Glenn J. Rix, Georgia Institute of Technology,790 Atlantic Drive,Atlanta,Georgia 30332 15. Becky Sweigert, , Lee County Environmental Sciences, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 16. Lee Werst, Lee County Division of Natural Resources, P.O. Box 398, Fort Myers, Florida 33902 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 65 of 70 07-Apr-10- . . PUBLIC PARTICIPATION: A. THE FOLLOWING PERSONS TESTIFIED OR SUBMITTED EVIDENCE FOR THE RECORD AT THE HEARING (SEE SECTION VII.): For: NONE Against: 1. Mary Abramson, 20800 Corkscrew Road, Estero, Florida 33928 2. Bella Altura, 20875 Torre Del Lago Street, Estero, Florida 33928 3. Burton Altura, 20875 Torre Del Lago Street, Estero, Florida 33928 4. Eugene Atchison, 18423 Fuchsia Road Street, Fort Myers, Florida 33967 5. Kathleen Banks, 19920 Barletta Lane#1421, Estero, Florida 33928 6. Nicholas Batos, 9165 Hollow Pine Drive, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 7. Judith Beach, 23058 Grassy Pine Drive, Estero, Florida 33928 8. Theophil A. Begansky Jr., 23736 Stonyriver Place, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 9. David Bowser, 20601 Country Creek Drive, Unit 3315, Estero, Florida 33928 10. Ed Carlson, c/o Corskcrew Swamp Sanctuary, 375 Sanctuary Road West, Naples, Florida 34120 11. Brad Cornell, do Collier County Audubon Society, 1020 8th Avenue South, Suite#2, Naples, Florida 34102 12. Anne Cramer, 3521 Tasselflower Court, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134 13. Gregg Cross, 18401 Glades Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33988 14. Anthony Davis, 19430 Burgundy Farms Road, Estero, Florida 33928 15. Beverly Davis, 19430 Burgundy Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 16. Philip W. Douglas, 10304 Cape Roman Road, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 17. John Duder, 23650 Via Veneto, Apartment 502, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134 18. Marilyn Edwards, 9240 Spring Run Boulevard, Estero, Florida 34135 19. Donald G. Ernst, 20562 Candlewood Hollow, Estero, Florida 33928 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 66 of 70 07-Apr-10 - 20. Donald F.Eslick, c/o Estero Council of Community Leaders, 23650 Via Veneto#604, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134 21. Angie Finau, 19200 Burgundy Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 22. John Fraioli, 5651 Harborage Drive, Fort Myers, Florida 33908 23. Teresa Fraioli, 5651 Harborage Drive, Fort Myers, Florida 33908 24. Thomas B. Hart, do Knott, Consoer, Ebelini, Hart&Swett, P.A., 1625 Hendry Street, Third Floor, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 25. Sharon Hickox, 19641 Burgandy Farms Road, Estero, Florida 33928 26. Janice Hill, 20731 Corkscrew Road, Estero, Florid a 33928 27. James B. Hodge, 5151 Collins Avenue, Suite 834, Miami Beach, Florida 33140 28. Lonnie Howard, 2122 Johnson Street, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 29. Mike Joyce, 17350 Corkscrew Road, Estero, Florida 33928 30. Stewart Katz, 20411 Wildcat Run Drive, Estero, Florida 33928 31. Jason Lauritsen, 2896 Orange Grove Trail, Naples, Florida 34120 32. Bill Lytell, 18251 Glades Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 33. Cathy Lytell, 18251 Glades Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 34. Jim Lytell, 18301 Glades Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 35. Beverly MacNellis, 22819 Forest Ridge Drive, Estero, Florida 33928 36. Rick Marini, 20557 Torre Del Lago, Estero, Florida 33928 37. Jack Meeker, 23701 Copperleaf Boulevard, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 38. Sandy Mitsos, 21071 Six L's Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 39. Neal E. Noethlich, 20225 Wildcat Run Drive, Estero, Florida 33928 40. Thomas O'Dea, 23195 Foxberry Lane, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 41. Nancy Payton,c/o Florida Wildlife Federation,2590 Golden Gate Parkway,Suite 105, Naples, Florida 34105 42. Ray Pothier, 21034 Oxbow Bend, Estero, Florida 33928 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 67 of 70 07-Apr-10- 43. Arvo Rahe, 19050 Corkscrew Estates Court, Estero, Florida 33928 44. Ronald Reichert, 20950 Rivers Ford, Estero, Florida 33928 45. William F. Ribble Jr., 89$1 Bonita Beach Road, Suite#525, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 46. Church Roberts, 2122 Johnson Street, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 47. Alan Rodak, 4108 Dahoon Holly Ct, Bonita Springs, Florida 34134 48. Mike Roeder, c/o Knott, Consoer, Ebelini, Hart & Swett, P.A., 1625 Hendry Street, Third Floor, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 49. Theresa Rohrman, 19090 Burgundy Farms Road, Estero, Florida 33928 50. Donald A. Rowe, 9136 Willow Walk, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 51. Peggy Apgar Schmidt, 5640 Mackaboy Court, Fort Myers, Florida 33905 52. Richard Semon, 18251 Three B Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 53. Vincent Silvestri, 20450 Ardore Lane, Estero, Florida 33928 54. William F. Spikowski, do Spikowski Planning Associates, 55. Jean Stanley, 13795 Cleto, Estero, Florida 33928 56. Linda Tam, 20152 Larino Loop, Estero, Florida 33928 57. Kim Trebatoski, 2077 Bayside Parkway, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 58. David A. Urich, do Responsible Growth Management Coalition, 3919 McKinley Avenue, Fort Myers, Florida 33901 59. Amiel Villani, 17600 Corkscrew Road, Estero, Florida 33928 General: B. THE FOLLOWING PERSONS SUBMITTED A LETTER/COMMENT CARD, OR OTHERWISE REQUESTED A COPY OF THE HEARING EXAMINER RECOMMENDATION: For: NONE Against: 1. Jay Bolt, 20570 Torre Del Lago Street, Estero, Florida 33928 2.. Kevin Hill, 20731 Corkscrew Road, Estero, Florida 33928 Case DC12006-00026 Page 68 of 70 07-Apr-10- oh? 3.. Jon Leighton, 18201 Three B Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 4. Katie Leighton, 18201 Three B Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 5. Don Leroy, 20049 Buttermero Court, Estero, Florida 33928 6. Kim Rahe, 19050 Corkscrew Estates Court, Estero, Florida 33928 7. Arlene Rutstein, 23833 Cape Monaco Road, Bonita Springs, Florida 34135 8. Julia Semon, 18251 Three B Farm Road, Estero, Florida 33928 General: 1. Anthony J. Cotter, 301 East Pine Street, Suite 1400, P.O. BOX 3068 Orlando, Florida 32802 2. Mrs. A. E. Tongue, 15481 Copra Lane, Fort Myers, Florida 33908 3. Charlie Whitehead, do ckwhitehead( bonitanews.com IX. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: See Exhibit A (scanned legal description). X. UNAUTHORIZED COMMUNICATIONS: Unauthorized communications shall include any direct or indirect communication in any form, whether written, verbal or graphic, with the Hearing Examiner, or the Hearing Examiner's staff, any individual County Commissioner or their executive assistant, by any person outside of a public hearing and not on the record concerning substantive issues in any proposed or pending matter relating to appeals, variances, rezonings, special exceptions, or any other matter assigned by statute, ordinance or administrative code to the Hearing Examiner for decision or recommendation. . . . [Lee County Administrative Code AC-2-5] No person shall knowingly have or attempt to initiate an unauthorized communication with the Hearing Examiner or any county commissioner [or their staff]. . . . [Lee County Land Development Code Section 34-52(a)(1), emphasis added] Any person who knowingly makes or attempts to initiate an unauthorized communication . . [may] be subject to civil or criminal penalties which may include: [Section 34-52(b)(1), emphasis added] Revocation,suspension or amendment of any permit variance,special exception or rezoning granted as a result of the Hearing Examiner action which is the subject of the unauthorized communication. [Lee County Land Development Code Section 34-52(b)(1)b.2.]; OR Case DCI2006-00026 Page 69 of 70 07-Apr-10- . 0.47 A fine not exceeding $500.00 per offense, by imprisonment in the county jail for a term not exceeding 60 days, or by both such fine and imprisonment. [Lee County Land Development Code Section 1-5(c)] XI. HEARING BEFORE LEE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS: A. This recommendation is made this 7w day of April 2010. Notice or copies will be forwarded to the offices of the Lee County Board of County Commissioners. B. The original file and documents used at the hearing will remain in the care and custody of the Department of Community Development. The documents are available for examination and copying by all interested parties during normal business hours. C. The Board of County Commissioners will hold a hearing at which they will consider the record made before the Hearing Examiner. The Department of Community Development will send written notice to all hearing participants of the date of this hearing before the Board of County Commissioners. Only participants, or their representatives, will be allowed to address the Board. The content of all statements by persons addressing the Board shall be strictly limited to the correctness of Findings of Fact or Conclusions of Law contained in the recommendation, or to allege the discovery of relevant new evidence which was not known by the speaker at the time of the earlier hearing before the Hearing Examiner and not otherwise disclosed in the record. D. The original file containing the original documents used in the hearing before the Hearing Examiner will be brought by the Staff to the hearing before the Board of County Commissioners. Any or all of the documents in the file are available on request at any time to any County Commissioner. XII. COPIES OF TESTIMONY AND TRANSCRIPTS: A verbatim transcript of the testimony presente#a he hearing can be purchased from the court reporting service under contract to a H:aring Examiner's Office. The original documents and file in connection with thisiiatter • e located at the Lee 's unty Departm--t of Community Development, 1500 roe Ste, , Fort Myers, Fiorida. /" Alarm RIC"b, RD A. GESC 'DT LEE COUNTY HEA" G EXAMINER 1500 Monroe Stree -uite 218 Post Office Box 398 Fort Myers, Florida 33902-0398 Telephone: 239/533-8100 Facsimile: 239/485-8406 Case DCI2006-00026 Page 70 of 70 07-Apr-10- Ci� o1g/j3 ..l=am a A �i 11 � Please use this version of my email with a new citation. Thanks. / klatzk-o Colleen M. Greene Assistant County Attorney (239)252-8490 Fax(239) 252-6300 From: GreeneColleen Sent: Monday, October 07, 2013 10:39 AM To: KlatzkowJeff Subject: Naples Equestrian (8A October 8, 2013)Voting Conflict Inquiry Jeff, Commissioner Hiller asked this Office to review the Naples Equestrian Zoning Petition scheduled for Tuesday, October 8,2013 (Item 8A)to determine whether any potential or perceived conflict of interest may exist regarding her vote on this item. As we discussed,there is no statutory conflict of interest and in my opinion no apparent conflict of interest exists either. Commissioner Hiller lives in the Pine Ridge Community in close proximity to the Naples Equestrian location also within the Pine Ridge Community. Although there may be close proximity between the Commissioner and the Petitioner's location,this alone does not create a statutory conflict. The prohibition on voting conflicts is found in Section 112.3143(3)(a),Fla. Stat.,and provides: "No county, municipal,or other local public officer shall vote in an official capacity upon any measure which would inure to his or her special private gain or loss;which he or she knows would inure to the special private gain or loss of any principal by whom he or she is retained or to the parent organization or subsidiary of a corporate principal by which he or she is retained,other than an agency as defined in s. 112.312(2);or which he or she knows would inure to the special private gain or loss of a relative or business associate of the public officer. Such public officer shall,prior to the vote being taken,publicly state to the assembly the nature of the officer's interest in the matter from which he or she is abstaining from voting and,within 15 days after the vote occurs,disclose the nature of his or her interest as a public record in a memorandum filed with the person responsible for recording the minutes of the meeting,who shall incorporate the memorandum in the minutes." This statute was amended in July 2013 to specifically define a special private gain or loss. The amendment provides: Section 112.3143(d)"Special private gain or loss"means an economic benefit or harm that would inure to the officer,his or her relative,business associate,or principal,unless the measure affects a class that includes the officer,his or her relative,business associate,or principal, in which case,at least the following factors must be considered when determining whether a special private gain or loss exists: 1.The size of the class affected by the vote. 2.The nature of the interests involved. 3.The degree to which the interests of all members of the class are affected by the vote. 4.The degree to which the officer,his or her relative,business associate,or principal receives a greater benefit or harm when compared to other members of the class. The degree to which there is uncertainty at the time of the vote as to whether there would be any economic 8A benefit or harm to the public officer,his or her relative,business associate,or principal and, if so,the nature or degree of the economic benefit or harm must also be considered. Commissioner Hiller will receive no economic benefit or harm as a result of the Naples Equestrian Zoning Petition. Commissioner Hiller's home is one of many in the Pine Ridge Community and any benefit or harm to her property value is remote and speculative as there is no information as to how the Naples Esquestrian expansion may impact the community. Further any benefit or harm is not"special"to Commissioner Hiller but will impact the community as a whole. Therefore based on the size of the class that may receive a benefit or harm,there is no special gain or loss to Commissioner Hiller that would prevent her from voting on this item. Thank you. Colleen M. Greene Assistant County Attorney (239)252-8490 Fax(239)252-6300 Jeff, Commissioner Hiller asked this Office to review the Naples Equestrian Zoning Petition scheduled for Tuesday, October 8,2013 (Item 8A)to determine whether any potential or perceived conflict of interest may exist regarding her vote on this item. As we discussed,there is no statutory conflict of interest and in my opinion no apparent conflict of interest exists either. Commissioner Hiller lives in the Pine Ridge Community in close proximity to the Naples Equestrian location also within the Pine Ridge Community. Although there may be close proximity between the Commissioner and the Petitioner's location,this alone does not create a statutory conflict. The prohibition on voting conflicts is found in Section 112.3143(2)(a),Fla. Stat.,and provides: "[A] state public officer may not vote on any matter that the officer knows would inure to his or her special private gain or loss." There is no special private gain or loss to Commissioner Hiller in voting on this item. This statute was amended in July 2013 to specifically define a special private gain or loss. The amendment provides: Section 112.3143(d)"Special private gain or loss"means an economic benefit or harm that would inure to the officer,his or her relative,business associate,or principal,unless the measure affects a class that includes the officer,his or her relative,business associate,or principal, in which case,at least the following factors must be considered when determining whether a special private gain or loss exists: 1.The size of the class affected by the vote. 2.The nature of the interests involved. 3.The degree to which the interests of all members of the class are affected by the vote. 4.The degree to which the officer,his or her relative,business associate,or principal receives a greater benefit or harm when compared to other members of the class. The degree to which there is uncertainty at the time of the vote as to whether there would be any economic JMB TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING, INC. 'le, gli TRAFFIC/TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING & PLANNING SERVICES 84 TRAFFIC IMPACT EVALUATION of the NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE October 4,2013 Prepared by: JMB TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING, INC. 761 2 1sT STREET NW NAPLES, FLORIDA 341 20 (239) 919-2767 CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATION NO. 27830 (PROJECT No. 1 3091 3) f , /0-4 _ 2013 JAME =ANKS, P.E. DATE■ FLORir EG. No. 43860 JMB TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING, INC. 8Ai TRAFFIC/TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING & PLANNING SERVICES NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE October 4, 2013 Existing Operation and Proposed Expansion Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC)is a non-profit equine-assisted therapy facility that provides services to children and adults with special needs. The equestrian facility is located on the southwest corner of Center Street and Goodlette-Frank Road, within Collier County, Florida. NEC's programs consist of individuals obtaining therapeutic benefits by participating in equestrian-oriented activities. The participants are closely supervised by no less than one (1) or as many as three (3) volunteers per rider, depending on their age and/or specific needs. Because of the strict supervision requirements, all sessions are provided on a "scheduled appointment" basis only. Currently,the facility can accommodate no more than four(4)participants at a time and each therapeutic riding session is for a period of approximately 30 minutes, except for some children and adult equine-facilitated learning or psychotherapy sessions which vary from one to two hours long. During the longer sessions,there are no other concurrent riding events. NEC begins its first class at approximately 8:00 AM and currently ends the day between 6:30 PM and 8:00 PM. NEC is proposing to expand its facility by constructing an additional riding arena, barn and training room contiguous to the south of the existing grounds. At various times of the day,there will be concurrent classes at both the existing and new riding arenas. Existing and Future Traffic Conditions In order to quantify the volume of existing background traffic on the adjacent streets and trips currently generated by NEC, traffic counts were conducted during the highest peak demand periods (i.e., between 8 & 9AM and 4 & 6 PM). The traffic counts were obtained at NEC's site accesses and at the intersection of Center Street & Goodlette-Frank Road. Because the traffic counts were obtained during the month of October, a seasonal adjustment of 1.15 was applied to the data to reflect peak season traffic volumes. The traffic count data is attached. In addition to obtaining the traffic data, JMB conducted field observations of the traffic conditions/operations on Center Street, Goodlette-Frank Road and Ridge Drive. Based upon the data collected at NEC's site accesses, JMB determined that the findings and conclusions contained in the NEC Traffic Assessment Report, which was prepared by others and deemed acceptable to Collier County, were correct. As previously estimated, NEC currently has an averaged peak traffic demand of approximately 18 entering trips during the PM peak hours. JMB found the total two-way trips to be 26 vph. Note,the project's two-way trip determinations reflect an average peak demand,which is subject to reasonable fluctuations. 761 21 ST STREET NW, NAPLES, FLORIDA 341 20 PHONE: (239) 919-2767 JMB TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING, INC. 8 A Furthermore, JMB's evaluation and observations of the existing traffic conditions supports the following conclusions: Center Street Center Street is a two-lane local road that has a peak season peak hour two-way traffic demand of approximately 270 vph. The current demand is less than 25% of the road's carrying capacity. Based upon the demand vs. capacity(v/c ratio = 0.25), it was concluded that Center Street operates at a level of service LOS A. Ridge Drive Ridge Drive is a two-lane local road that has a peak season peak hour two-way traffic demand of 175 vph, which is less than 15%of the road's carrying capacity. Its v/c ratio = 0.15 which supports the findings that the road operates at LOS A. Center Street/Ridge Drive Intersection This intersection is a four-way stop controlled intersection with a total peak season peak hour four-way approach volume of less than 600 vph, which is less than 35% of the intersection's carrying capacity. As determined, this intersection functions at a v/c ratio = 35%which is LOS A. Center Street/Goodlette-Frank Road This intersection is a "T" configuration and the north/south approaches (Goodlette-Frank Road)is under free-flow conditions. The north/south approaches have three through lanes/direction, there is a northbound-to-westbound left turn lane and a southbound-to- westbound right turn lane,and the eastbound approach has a separate left and right turn lane. The intersection has all the turn lane provisions necessary to accommodate the traffic demands and no further improvements to the intersection are warranted. As determined,the turning movement volumes are relatively low at this intersection and JMB estimates that the side street approach operates at LOS C and better and LOS B or better for the north/south approaches. Future Traffic Conditions As previously mentioned,NEC is proposing to expand its capabilities by constructing an additional riding arena. At various times of the day, there will be concurrent classes on both the existing and new riding arenas. To be conservative, JMB analyzed the increase in traffic impact assuming that the most significant impact will occur during the PM peak hour. During the PM peak hours, the new arena will typically be used for riding sessions consisting of six-to-nine(6-to-9)riders and three(3) supervisors. The duration of the PM sessions at the new arena are expected to be one hour or more and will start around 5:00 PM and end sometime after 6:00 PM. Therefore,the expected net new PM peak hour trips generated between 4 & 6 PM will be more weighted towards ingress trips and will average no more than 15 two-way trips during normal use. The estimated net new trips reflect an average peak demand,which is subject to reasonable fluctuations. JMB TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING, INC. 8 A The estimated net new trips represent 5.6% of the existing background traffic on Center Street and less than 1.5% of Center Streets carrying capacity. The impact of the net new trips generated by the proposed expansion will be negligible and will not degrade the operation or level of service of Center Street, Ridge Drive, or Goodlette-Frank Road, or their respective intersections. More specifically, all roadways and intersections will continue to operate at acceptable levels of service, regardless of the net new trips generated by NEC. As part of NEC's efforts to minimize its impact on the adjacent road network, the site's primary access will be relocated on Center Street concurrent with the completion of the proposed changes.It should be noted that JMB does not find this necessary because the adjacent roads and intersections have a substantial surplus of capacity to accommodate NEC's net new trips regardless of whether or not the site maintains access to Ridge Drive. The access on Center Street will be located approximately 320'to the west of Goodlette-Frank Road, which places it at an appropriate distance from the intersection of Center/Goodlette-Frank as well as Center/Ridge Drive. The proposed access location exceeds the County's minimum intersection separation criteria and will ensure that there are no turning movement conflicts with the two adjacent intersections. Conclusion As determined by JMB,the trips associated with the proposed additional therapy riding arena will be less than 1.5% of Center Streets carrying capacity, and all roadways and intersections within proximity of NEC will continue to operate at acceptable levels of service, which have been described below: Road or Intersection Level of Service Center Street A Ridge Drive A Goodlette-Frank Road A Center St/Goodlette Frank C Center St/Ridge Drive A The relocation of the project's primary access on Center Street will be strategically located to ensure that there are no turning movement conflicts with either the intersection of Center/Goodlette-Frank or Center/Ridge Drive and the proposed location exceeds the County's minimum intersection separation criteria. The volume of traffic entering/exiting the site's access on Center Street will not appreciably affect east/west traffic flow nor create any undesirable traffic issues. Naples Equestrian Challenge Trip Count Date of Survey: October 3,2013 Start Time Enter Exit 7:00 AM 0 0 7:15 AM 0 0 7:30 AM 0 0 7:45 AM 0 0 8:00 AM 0 0 8:15 AM 2 0 8:30 AM 4 1 8:45 AM 6 0 9:00 AM Stop Count at 9 AM Start Time 4:00 PM 0 0 4:15 PM 4 5 4:30 PM 3 4:45 PM 1 2 5:00 PM 5 0 5:15 PM 5 3 5:30 PM 3 1 5:45 PM 3 6 6:00 PM Stop Count at 6 PM INTERSECTION TURNING MOVEMENT COUNTS 8 A Intersection: Center Street @ Goodlette Frank Road Date of Count: 10/3/2013 Thursday Eastbound Westbound Northbound Southbound Total All AM Period L T R L T R L T R L T R Apprch's 7:30-7:45 0 0 21 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 8 33 7:45-8:00 2 0 15 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 5 25 8:00-8:15 2 0 19 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 4 28 8:15-8:30 6 0 16 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 0 18 48 8:30-8:45 5 0 25 0 0 0 18 0 0 0 0 14 62 8:45-9:00 8 0 22 0 0 0 19 0 0 0 0 12 61 AM Totals 23 0 118 55 0 0 0 0 61 257 Approach% 16.3% 0.0% 83.7% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% %/Lane 8.9% 0.0% 45.9% 21.4% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 23.7% %/Inter. 54.9% 0.0% 21.4% 23.7% Eastbound Westbound Northbound Southbound PM Period L T R L T R L T R L T R 4:00-4:15 18 0 16 0 0 0 20 0 0 0 0 10 64 4:15-4:30 10 0 15 0 0 0 20 0 0 0 0 11 56 4:30-4:45 15 0 24 0 0 0 16 0 0 0 0 6 61 4:45-5:00 8 0 11 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 9 37 5:00-5:15 11 0 11 0 0 0 11 0 0 0 0 13 46 5:15-5:30 21 0 19 0 0 0 19 0 0 0 0 8 67 5:30-5:45 13 0 16 0 0 0 20 0 0 0 0 14 63 5:45-6:00 11 0 14 0 0 0 22 0 0 0 0 12 59 PM Totals 107 0 126 0 0 0 137 0 0 0 0 83 453 Approach% 45.9% 0.0% 54.1% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 100.0% %/Lane 23.6% 0.0% 27.8% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 30.2% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 18.3% %/Inter. 51.4% 0.0% 30.2% 18.3% PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Eastbound Westbound Northbound Southbound L T R L T R L T R L T R AM Period 8:00-9:00 10 0 71 0 0 0 18 0 0 0 0 35 134 PM Period 5:00-6:00 56 0 60 0 0 0 72 0 0 0 0 47 235 CenterGoodlette-1 Intersection: Center Street @ Goodlette Frank Road Date of Count: 10/3/2013 8 A 2013 PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENT VOLUMES Eastbound I Westbound I Northbound I Southbound I L T R I L T B i b T Bib T R I AM Period I 10 0 71 1 0 0 0 1 18 0 0 1 0 0 35 I I I I i I PM Period I 56 0 60 I 0 0 0 I 72 0 0 I 0 0 47 I 2013 PEAK SEASON PEAK HOUR TURNING MOVEMENTS Seasonal Adj Seasonal Adjustment Factor= 1.15 1 Eastbound 1 Westbound 1 Northbound 1 Southbound I 1 L T R I L T R I L T B i b T R I AM Period I 12 0 82 1 0 0 0 1 21 0 0 1 0 0 40 I I I I I I PM Period I 64 0 69 1 0 0 0 1 83 0 0 1 0 0 54 I CenterGoodlette-2 Intersection: Center Street @ Goodlette Frank Road 8 A A A 40 I 54 I I I I I I 12 I 64 V V 40 0 0 54 0 0 I I I I I I I I I I I I < V -------> <_____ V _ > A A A A 61 12 -I I -0 0 137 64-I I -_0 0 > 2013 AM PEAK HOUR < ----0 0----> 2013 PM PEAK HOUR < --•0 ----> > > 93 82-I I ----0 0 133 69-I I -0 V V V V < - n > < - A -------> I I I I I I I I I I I I 21 0 0 83 0 0 A A 82 I 69 .1 I I I I I 21 I 83 V V CenterGoodlette- 3 ` 8A Naples Equestrian Challenge Traffic Assessment The Naples Equestrian Challenge (NEC)provides equine assisted activity and therapy programs for special needs children and adults at their Pine Ridge location. In the past year NEC served more than 400 participants. Program participants are assisted by staff and volunteers of the NEC during each of their one-half hour riding sessions. Estimates provided by NEC staff indicate that the peak number of hourly vehicular trips entering and exiting the site is approximately 18 trips. Attached is a spreadsheet prepared by NEC breaking down the vehicular trips on an hourly basis for the existing facility. NEC is seeking conditional use approval for two properties, one of which has been owned by NEC and currently serves as pasture and paddock areas for the facility. Lot 19 (182 Ridge Drive) which is included in the pending conditional use application is proposed to have additional riding, stabling and volunteer training facilities constructed upon approval of the conditional use. The new riding arena, barn and training room is approximately 6,600 square feet and will allow a few additional sessions to be conducted concurrent with existing programs; however,it is anticipated that a minor increase in the daily traffic will occur. The conceptual plan prepared for the conditional use application depicts the proposed site improvements, including the addition of parking at the 182 Ridge Drive property. The additional parking may or may not be improved with asphalt, and its primary purpose is to serve participants using the small arena,special events, or during volunteer training. In converting the visitor trips estimated by NEC staff to vehicle trips. We have used the average visitor trips during the PM peak hours and multiplied that number by two to achieve to determine the total entering and exiting vehicle trips. Based on the square footage of the enclosed buildings, we can determine a vehicle trip per square foot figure, which can be applied to the proposed site improvements. Existing PM peak hour average 18 vehicle trips 18/10,000 square feet building area= 1.8 trips/1000 s.f. Estimated vehicle trips for new improvements 6,600±square feet building area/1000=6.6 6.6 x 1.8= 11.88 (12)peak hour trips Due to scheduling for volunteers and program participants, the new additional estimate of peak hour trips is likely greater than actual trips anticipated; however, the PM peak hour is a low volume figure and will have no impact on the County's road network. 8A . :,„,,,.„,,,,,::::„..:,::„.. c 10 a. u Z 1 a co eo DO co Co .0 .-1 co co Co co co Y .-( .-1 e-1 ci .-I a--I C u3 0:1 Q a II 0 n R F Q ..- N N c.1 N N N V) .�- /6 O n O o m m t_ } n u 'Cl li LL v �t t y tp tD r+ a10+ vt H O es, d' � O. O n O^L0 rl n M CO <� -1 C) S" ei CO 00 tD O 'i CO tD tD O � TO M In Cn M N to f'n1 fn CO co L = N ci ei r-1 1 s-1 ,...1 .4 Qul Q V O to K m >- a n3 _ tD �D lD tD lD tD tD tD tD ID N N N F N L Y H a. N. R n p u W Y f0 N Iii! C lD tD t0 tD lD lD iD N N Cl) 4.11,. ..-.,..,.---: N O. Cr tp tp O tD 0 Co O •_ _ m L F. M nr V Q Cr Co Co CO CO ns c to > ° Y Q V M O n W CL t6 N II F w Cr t0 tD tD Cr Cr Sa to tD (.4 D E r 07 y H _c N �_ y W A- O O'er :_ ^.N T00 0o c° O Cr - N to O rl i.OO 00 00 00 O u 00 CO t� 1� .-i e�-1 .-4-4 10 V• X V- V O 00 O W 16 to 'z'V_ .4- Cr tD ID.:CD C'tD 5---;-!)4=,„.....D tD N 7 O z w m mo °+ °°c as ananfl to rz c0 ai 'i a-1 Z N N =,,,E°-Cr +11 LD n CO H H BA • " , " Grant#-.13-12-UC-12-00196 CFDAJCSFA#-14.218 Subrecipient—Naples Equestrian Challenge,Inc. DUNS ft-029483800 - FETI -20-3571795 FY END-1-31-13 Monitoring End-9-30-2033 AGREEMENT BETWEEN COLLIER COUNTY AND NAPLES EQUESTRIAN CHALLENGE THIS AGREEMENT is made and entered into this 14th day of May 2013, by and between Collier County, a political subdivision of the State of Florida, ("COUNTY') having its principal address as 3339 E. Tamiami Trail, Naples FL 34112, and the "Naples Equestrian Challenge", a private not-for-profit corporation existing under the laws of the State of Florida, having its principal office at 206 Ridge Drive, Naples, FL 34108, WHEREAS, the COUNTY is an entitlement County of the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) grant program Community Development Block Grant Program funds and the COUNTY expects to continue to receive entitlement funds from these grant programs to operate the COUNTY's housing and community development activities; and WHEREAS, pursuant to the aforesaid agreement, COUNTY is undertaking certain activities to primarily benefit low and moderate income persons and neighborhoods and to alternatively use Community Development Block Grant (CDAG) funds for: slum or blight treatment or for an urgent community need; to improve the quality of life in Collier County by providing infrastructure improvements, public facilities, and other activities which are related to neighborhood/community improvements; to improve the condition of life for persons who require physical access or other services that meet their individual needs; and to provide for long range community improvements by assessing current conditions and planning long range improvement programs as described in the Consolidated Plan submission; and WHEREAS, each year, the COUNTY prepares a One-Year Action Plan detailing how it intends to allocate funds received from HUD to conduct eligible activities for the benefit of low and moderate-income residents; and WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners of Collier County approved various Collier County Consolidated Plans and Annual Action Plans for the CDBG Program; and WHEREAS, in accordance with HUD regulations and the Collier County Consolidated Plan concerning the preparation of various Annual Action Plans, the County advertised a substantial amendment on March 14, 2013 with a 30-day citizen comment period from March 14, 2013 through April 15,2013; and WHEREAS, on May 14, 2013 the COUNTY approved substantial amendments to various year's Annual Action Plans providing CDBG funds in the amount of S520,000 to thc Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. for Property Acquisition located at 182 Ridge Drive, Naples, FL 34108; and Nrtplo Lquctirian ChAllongo,Inc. CDBG(CDS 11-08) Property Acqukition Page 1 of 26 t NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual benefits contained hcrcin, it is agreed by the Parties as follows: I. SCOPE OF SERVICES The SUKK£C|P(ENT xho||, in a satisfactory and proper manner and consistent with any standards required as a condition of providing CUOG funds, as determined by Collier County Housing, Human and Vdcrun Services (IIHVS), perform the tasks necessary to conduct the pruarumnudiued as follows: The FY 2012'2013 Annual Action Plan identified and approved this project to Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. for the following: Project Component: Acquire property located at 182 Ridge Drive, Naples FL, Parcel 07185040009. 8pcuiDoaUy' improvements identified for funding are outlined in the budget in Section III. All activities funded with CD8G funds must meet one of the CU8(3 program's National Objectives: benefit low- and moderate-income persons; aid in the prevention or elimination of slums or blight; or meet community development needs having a particular urgency, as defined in 24 CFR 570.208 |�. TIME OF PERFORMANCE Services of the SUBRECIPIENT shall start on the 14th day of May, 2013 and end on the 31st day of October, 2013. The term of this Agreement and the provisions herein may be extended by amendment to cover any additional lime period during which the SUI3RECIP[EN'I' remains in control of Cl)BG funds or othcr (`|]8G assets. including program income, ||L AGREEMENT AMOUNT The COUNTY agrees to make available FIVE HUNDRED AND TWENTY THOUSAND DOLLARS (8520,800) for the use by the Sl]BREC|P|ENT[or PROPERTY ACQIJISFL'ION during the Term of the '\grcccncn/ (hereinafter, the o|orea\u\nd amount including, without limitation, any additional amounts included thereto as a result of a subsequent amendment(s) to the Agreement, shall be referred to as the 1unJi) The SUBREOPlENl' project hudgc\ xhuUhcux follows: r---- -- -- Line Item Description CDBG , Funds ! Lyroperty Acquisition located at 182 Ridge Drive, Naples R. S520,000 TOTAL S520,000 `-'—_ .__ Modifications to the "Budget and Scope" may only be made if approved in advance. Budgeted fund shifts between cost categories and activities shall not be more than 10% and does not signify a change in scope, lund shifts that exceed |0% o[u cost category 'aodactivity shall he made with board approval. xop/,° /4"/*"^nchox,ouc nxm.uDS 0^8/ /m,,^rxwu"°o.m Page 2o|26 - - ' ' All improvements specified in Section I. Scope of Services shall be performed hv OUBREC(P)ENT employees, or shall be put out to com h ' vc bidding under a procedure acceptable to the COUNTY and Federal requirements. The SU8K[C|P|ENT shall enter into contract for improvements with the lowest, responsive and qualified bidder. Contract administration shall be handled by the SUBRECIPIENT and m"nihond by HHVS. which shall have access to all records and dwcunnen/s nc|u��'(n the project. Thc County shall reimburse the SU8REC\|`l[NT for the performance of this Agreenient upon completion or partial completion ofthe work tasks as accepted and approved by IIFIVS pursuant to the submittal of quarterly progress reports. Invoiees for work performed arc required every month. If no work has been performed during that mon|h, or i/'the SUBR[C/P|[NT is not yet prepared to send the required h4okup, a SO invoice will be required. Explanations will be required if two consecutive months of SO invoices are submitted. Payments shall be made to the SU8N[[}M[NTwhco requested as work progresses but, not more frequently than once per month. Final invoices arc due no later than 90 days after the end of the agreement. Work performed during the term t, th pl'ograni hut not invoiced within 90 days without written exception from the Grant Coordinator will not be reimbursed, No y'me will be made until approved byRRVS for grant cnm�ixncc�dudhu��� to any and all applicable }ocu[ state cx Federal requirements Payment will be made upon �receipt o[nnr000dy cump|c�Jinvoice and in compliance with §Z1870` Hm6da8 | , u\hcrvvsuknovneothe"Locu| properly Government Prompt Payment /\c,." The following table details the project deliverables and payment schedule. - - -- Property Acquisition Reimburse for allowable expenses for property acquisition. Supporting documentation including hut not limited to closing documents,appraisal,survey and HUD settlement statement must be submitted for reimbursement A minimum of 200 low ai-H-d N/A moderate income persons per year as evidenced by submission of the Exhibit D quarterly until 2033 Income qualification N/A activities for pmlctpants / who iU6eLx�| persons;°/ 51%of persons served must fall fall utorbelow 80% of ' AK4i } n,*�mry� As evidenced by N/A annual yrupcnyappraiser records and property insurance | _ mxmu/4uc^",i`challenge /"e rmx/.cn^ um` ,°p*v »w^'`"=" Pxur3u[26 - ' 8 A \v. NOTICES Notices required by this Agreement shall be in writing and delivered via mail (postage prepaid), commercial courier, or personal delivery or sent by facsimile or other electronic means. Any notice delivered or sent as aforesaid shall be effective on the date of delivery or sending. All notices and other written communications under this Agreement shall be addressed to the individuals in the capacities indicated below, unless otherwise modilied by subsequent written notice. COLLIER COUNTY ATTENTION: Sandra Marrero, Grant Coordinator }]39ETomiumi Trail, Suite 2i | Naples, Florida 34112 (239)252'2399 sandrvmp,/eno@cnUitrgnv.uci SU8KEOP|EN7 ATTENlION: Kim Minarich, Executive Director Naples Equestrian Challenge ZO6 Ridge Drive >)op|cx. Fi]4|08 (239)590'2988 kminmieh�naploequomhancha|lengo.urg V. ADDITIONAL CONDITIONS AND COMPENSATION The parties acknowledge that the Funds originate from CDBG grant funds from HUD and must be implemented in lull compliance with all of HUD's rules and regulations and any agreement between COUNTY and HUD governing CUB(] funds pertaining to this Agreement. In the event oI'curtailment or non-production of said federal funds, the financial sources necessary to continue to pay the SUBRECIPIENT all or any portions of the funds will not be available. In that event, the COUNTY may terminate this Agreement, which termination shall be effective as of the date that it is determined by the County Manager or designee, in his-her sole discretion and judgment. that the Funds are no longer available, In the event of such termination, the SO8Q[( U`{[NTugrccz that it will not, look k), nor seek to hold the COCNT`/, nor any individual member of the County Commissioners and /or County Administration, personally liable for the performance of (Na Agreement, and the COUNTY shall he released from any further liability to GD8RF[lP{ENT under the terms of'this Agreement. VI. GENERAL, CONDITIONS � S[U(0HTRACTS No part of this Agreement may be assigned or subcontracted without the written consent of the C0[NTY, which consent, if given at oU, shall be at the COUNTY's sole discretion and judgment. H GENERAL COMPLIANCE The SU8RE[U`UENT agrees to comply with the requirements of Title 24 of the Code of Federal Rcgu|u(ionx. Part 570 (the U.8. Housing and Urban Development regulations concerning Community Naples L4"awiu^Challenge. Inc. omo(MS 17-0x) /,'rul> xw«/,'l'"` Page 4 of 26 • 8A Development Block Grains (CDBG)) including subpart K of these regulations, except that (1) the SUBRECIPIENT does not assume the recipient's environmental responsibilities described in 24 CFR 570.604 and (2) the SUBRECIPIENT does not assume the recipient's responsibility fur initiating the review process under the provisions of 24 CFR Part 52, The SUBRECEPIENT also agrees to comply with all other applicable Federal, state and local laws, regulations, and policies governing the funds provided under this contract. The SUBRECIPIENT further agrees to utilize funds available under this Agreement to supplement rather than supplant funds otherwise available. C. INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR Nothing contained in this Agreement is intended to, or shall be construed in any manner, as creating or establishing the relationship of employer/employee between the parties. The SUBRECIPIENT shall at all times remain an "independent contractor" with respect to the services to be performed under this Agreement. Unless otherwise provided by the Scope of Services, the Grantee shall be exempt from payment of all Unemployment Compensation, FICA, retirement, life and/or medical insurance and Workers' Compensation Insurance, as the SUBR EC IF I F.:NT is art independent contractor. D. AM END MENTS The COUNTY or SUBRECIPIENT may amend this Agreement at any time provided that such amendments make specific reference to this Agreement, and are executed in writing, signed by a duly authorized representative of each organization, and approved by the Grantee's governing body. Such amendments shall not invalidate this Agreement, nor relieve or release the Grantee or SUBRECIPIENT from its obligations under this Agreement. No amendments to this agreement will be granted ninety (90) days prior to end date of this agreement. The COUNTY may, in its discretion, amend this Agreement to conform with Federal, state or local governmental guidelines, policies and available funding amounts, or for other reasons. If such amendments result in a change in the funding, the scope of services, or schedule of the activities to be undertaken as part of this Agreement, such modifications will be incorporated only by written amendment signed by both Grantee and Si BRECIPIENT. Expiration of Agreement: It'the SUBRECIPIENT does not complete the project within the time period. the COUNTY Manager or designee may grant a cumulative time extension of no more than 180 days and modify any subsequent project work plans to reflect the extension. The request must be submitted no later than ninety (90) days prior to end date of this agreement. E. INDEMNIFICATION To the maximum extent penuitted by Florida law, the SUBRECIPIENT shall indemnify and hold harmless Collier County, its officers, agents and employees from any and all claims, liabilities, damages, losses, costs, and causes of action which may arise out of art act, omission, including, but not limited to, reasonable attorneys' fees and paralegals' fees, to the extent caused by the negligence, recklessness, or intentionally wrongful conduct of the SUBRECIPIENT or any of its agents, officers, servants, employees, contractors, patrons, guests, clients, licensees, invitees, or any persons acting under the direction, control, or supervision of the SUBRECIPIENT in the performance of' this Agreement. This indemnification obligation shall not be construed to negate, abridge or reduce any other rights or remedies which otherwise may be available to an indemnified party or person described in this paragraph. The SUBRECIPIENT shall pay all claims and losses of Naplcs 411 Chailvi , Inc (1)13G(CDS I \L-Lmskion Page 5 of 26 C'Ict) 8A an\ nature whatsoever in connection therewith and shall defend all suits in the name of the COUNTY and shall pay all costs (including attorney's fees) and judgments which may issue thereon. This Indemnification shall survive the termination and/or expiration of this Agreement. This section does not pertain to any incident arising from the sole negligence of Collier County. The foregoing indemnification shall not constitute a waiver of sovereign immunity beyond the limits set forth in Section 768.28, Florida Statutes. GRANTEE RECOGNITION/SPONSORSHIPS The SUBRECIPIENT agrees that all notices, informational pamphlets, press releases, advertisements, descriptions of the sponsorships of the Program, research reports and similar public notices prepared and released by the SUBRECIPIENT for, on behalf of, and/or about the Program shall include the statement: "FINANCED 13Y U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT (HUD) AND COLLIER COUNTY HOUSING, HUMAN AND VETERAN SERVICES DEPARTMENT" and shall appear in the same size letters or type as he name of the SUBRECIPIENT, This design concept is intended to disseminate key information regarding the development team as well as Equal Housing Opportunity to the general public. Construction signs shall comply with applicable COUNTY codes, G. TERMINATION In accordance with 24 C'FR 85,43, the Grantee may suspend or terminate this Agreement if the SUBRECIPIENT materially fails to comply with any terms of this Agreement, which include (hut are not limited to). the following; I. Failure to comply with any of the rules, regulations or provisions referred to herein, or such statutes, regulations, executive orders, and HUD guidelines, policies or directives as may become applicable at any lime; 2. Failure, for any reason, of the SUBRECIPIENT to fulfill in a timely and proper manner its obligations under this Agreement; 3, ineffective or improper use of funds provided under this Agreement; or 4. Submission by the SUBRECIPIENT to the Grantee reports that are incorrect or incomplete in any material respect. In accordance with 24 CFR, 85.44, this Agreement may also be terminated for convenience by either the Grantee or the SUBRECIPIENT, in whole or in part, by setting forth the reasons for such termination, the enective date, and, in the case of partial termination, the portion to he terminated. However, if in the case of a partial termination, the Grantee determines that the remaining portion of the award will not accomplish the purpose for which the award was made, the Grantee may terminate the award in its entirety, Naalo ClthIlenge. CD/Ili(('1)5 13-0t0 1'11)pol. AcquLsition Page 6 of 26 8 A VII. REVERSION OF ASSETS In the event of a termination of this Agreement or upon expiration of the Agreement and in addition to any and all other remedies available (o the COUNTY (whether under this Agreement or at law or in equity) the SUBRECIPIENT shall immediately transfer k/ the COUNTY any funds on hand at the time of termination (or cNprmion) und any accounts receivable attributable to (heusco[CDBU funds. The COUNTY's receipt of any funds on hand at the lime ol termination shall not waive dhcCOUNTY`s right (nor excuse suBRE;cEIPIENT's obligation) to recoup all or any portion of the funds, as the COUNTY may deem necessary. Any real property under the 3UBREC|P|ENT'xcnnuoi that was acquired or improved in whole or in pun `viih CDBG funds (including CDBG funds provided to the SUBRECIPIENT in the form of a loan) in excess o[52i0O0 as outlined in 24 [FR 570.505 must either: a. Be used ko mcc\ one of the national objectives in 24 CFR 570208 (formerly section 570.901) until live (5) years after expiration of the term of this Agreement or for such longer period of time as determined to he appropriate by the COUNTY and as memorialized by the COUNTY and the SUBRECIPIENT in an amendment to this Agreement or such instrument as the COUNTY at its discretion determines appropriate; or h. If not used in accordance with the above subsection (a) the SUBRECIPIENT shall pay to the COUNTY an amount equal Wtbccunrnlnnzrkc( value of the property less any portion of the value attributable to expenditures of non-CDBG funds for the acquisition of or improvements to, the property. No payment is required after the period of time specified in subsection (a). Tide to equipment acquired by SUBRECIPIENT shall vest with the SUBRECIPIENT, xuhiect10 the conditions outlined in24CFR 84.34. Title losupplies other expendable property shall vest with the SUBRECIPIENT upon acquisition subject to the conditions outlined in 24 CFR 84.35. VIII. INSURANCE SUBRECIPIENT shall not commence any work and/or services pursuant to this Agreement until all insurance required under |his Section and outlined in Exhibit -A" has been obtained, and uTcd, at all times during its performance. IX. ADMINISTRATIVE REQUIREMENTS � EXAMINATION OF RECORDS The SUBRECIPIENT shall maintain suflicient records in accordance with 24 CFR 570.502 and 570.506 to determine compliance with the requirements of this Agreement, the CDBG Program and all other applicable laws and regulations. This documentation shall include, but not be limited to, the following: H. DOCUMENTATION AND R[I0RDKE2P|NG All records required by CDR( , � All rqons, plans, surveys, information, documents, maps, books, records and other data Naples/:Al 'w="c^u/mp: x/c (1:1)110(COS 13- 8) Aq"°.o.". Page 7 of 26 tGiv- ' 8A procedures developed, prepared, assembled, or completed by the SUBRECIPIENT for the purpose of this Agreement shall be made available to the COUNTY by the SUBRECIPIENT at any time upon request by the COUNTY or HHVS. Materials identified in the previous sentence shall be in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, procedures and practices, which sufficiently and properly' reflect all revenues and expenditures of funds provided directly or indirectly by this Agreement, including matching funds and Program Income. These records shall he maintained to the extent of such detail as will properly reflect all net costs, direct and indirect labor, materials, equipment, supplies and services, and other costs and expenses of whatever nature for which reimbursement is claimed under the provisions of this Agreement. 3, Upon completion of all work contemplated under this Agreement copies of all documents and records relating to this Agreement shall be surrendered to HI IN'S if requested. In any event the SUBRECIPIENT shall keep all documents and records in an orderly fashion in a readily accessible, permanent and secured location for four (4) years after expiration of this Agreement with the following exception: it'any litigation, claim or audit is started before the expiration date of the Cour (4) year period, the records will be maintained until all litigation, claim or audit findings involving the records are resolved. The COUNTY shall be informed in writing if an agency ceases to exist after closeout of this Agreement of the address where the records are to be kept as outlined in 24 ('FR 85.42, 4, The SUBRLCIPIENT shall maintain records showing compliance with the Davis-Bacon Law, including tiles containing contractor payrolls, employee interviews, Davis-Bacon wage rates,and administrative cross-referencing. SUBRECIPIENT shall maintain records showing contractor compliance with the Contract Work Hours and Work Safety Law. Similarly, the SUBRECIPIENT shall maintain records showing compliance with federal purchasing requirements and with other federal requirements for grant implementation. 5. The SUBRECIPIENT will he responsible for the creation and maintenance of income eligible tiles on clients served and documentation that all households are eligible under HUD Income Guidelines. The SUBRECIPIENT agrees that IIHVS shall be the final arbiter on the SUBRECIPIENT's compliance. 6. The SUBRECIPIENT shall document how the National Objective(s) as defined in 24 CFR 570.208 and the eligibility requirement(s) under which funding has been received, have been met. These also include special requirements such as necessary and appropriate determinations as defined in 24 CFR 570.209, income certification, and written Agreements with beneficiaries, where applicable. C. REPORTS AND EVALUATIONS (MONITORING) Reimbursement may be contingent on the timely receipt of complete and accurate reports required by this Aureement, and on the resolution of monitoring findings identified pursuant to this Agreement as deemed necessary by the County Manager or designee. During the term, SUBRECIPIENT shall submit quarterly progress reports to the COUNTY on the 15111 day of January, April, July and October respectively for the prior quarter period end. As part of the report submitted in October, the SUBRECIPIENT also agrees to include, a comprehensive final report covering the agreed-upon Program objectives, activities and expenditures and including, but not limited to, performance data rocstri:an C'hallcngc. Inc. CDIil I ICDS 13-0) Proud) ALquisiiion Page 8 of 26 CP), 'IA On client feedback with respect to the goals and objectives set forth in Exhibit "D". Exhibit "D" contains an example reporting form to he used in fulfillment of this requirement. Other reporting requirements may be required by the County Manager or their designee in the event of Program changes; the need for additional information or documentation arises; and/or legislative amendments are enacted. Reports and/or requested documentation not received by the due date shall be considered delinquent and may be cause for default and termination of this Agreement. During the term, SUBRECIPIENT shall submit an annual audit monitoring report (Exhibit E) to the COUNTY no later than 180 days after the SUBRECIPIENT's fiscal year end. The SUBRECIPIENT agrees that HHVS will carry out no less than one (1) annual on-site monitoring visit and evaluation activities as determined necessary. At the COUNTY's discretion, a desk top review of the activities may be conducted in lieu of an on-site visit. The continuation of this Agreement is dependent upon satisfactory evaluations. The SUBRFCIPIENT shall, upon the request of IIHVS, submit information and status reports required by HI1VS or HUD to enable I IH VS to evaluate said progress and to allow for completion of reports required. The SUI3RECIPIENT shall allow 141-1VS or HUD to monitor the SUBRECIPIENT on site. Such site visits may be scheduled or unscheduled as determined by l{UVS or HUD. D. ADDITIONAL HOUSING, HUMAN AND VETERAN SERVICES, COUNTY, AND HUD R EQU I RE MENTS The SUBRECIPIENT agrees to utilize funds available under this Agreement to supplement rather than supplant funds otherwise available for specified activities. U. PURCHASING All purchasing for services and goods, including capital equipment, shall be made by purchase order or by a written contract and in conformity with the thresholds of Collier County Purchasing Policy, Purchasing Threshold Policy Dollar Range ($) Quotes Under S3K 1 Written Quote Above $3K to $10K 3 Written Quotes Above $10K to 550K 3 Written Quotes Request for Proposal (REP) Above $50K Invitation for Bid (IFB) F. AUDITS AND INSPECTIONS At any time during normal business hours and as often as the COUNTY (and/or its representatives) may deem necessary, the SUBRECIPIENT shall make available all records, documentation and any other data relating to all matters covered by the Agreement Ibr review, inspection or audit. G. PROGRAM-GENERATED INCOME Any "Program Income" (as such term is defined under applicable Federal regulations) gained from any activity of the SUBRECIPIENT funded by CDBG funds shall he reported to the COUNTY, utilized by the SUBRECIPIENT and shall be in compliance with 24 CER 570,504(c) in the operation of the Program. Napics FLitwstriaii Chullenge, C1)0C;(CDs 13-08) l'■oporly Acquisitim Pane 9 of 26 ' 8A GRANT CLOSEOUT PROCEDURES SUBRFCIPIENT's obligation to the COUNTY shall not end until all closeout requirements are completed. Activities during this closeout period shall include, but not be limited to: making final payments, disposing of program assets (including the return of all unused materials, equipment, unspent cash advances, program income balances, and receivable accounts to the COUNTY), and determining the custodianship of records. In addition to the records retention outlined in Section X.B.3, the SUBRECIPIENT shall comply with Section 119.021 Florida Statutes regarding records maintenance, preservation and retention. X, OTHER PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS A, OPPORTUNITIES FOR RESIDENTS AND CiVIL COMPLIANCE The SUBRECIPIENT agrees that no person shall be excluded from the benefits of, or be subjected to, discrimination under any activity can'ied out by the performance of this Agreement on the basis of race, color, disability, national origin, religion, age, familial status, or sex. Upon receipt of evidence of such discrimination, he COUNry shall have the right to terminate this Agreement. To the greatest extent feasible, lower-income residents of the project areas shall be given opportunities for training and employment; and to the greatest feasible extent eligible business concerns located in or owned in substantial part by persons residing in the project areas shall be awarded contracts in connection with the project. The SUBRECIPIENT shall comply with Section 3 of the Housing and Community Development Act of I 968. 13. OPPORTUNITIES FOR SMALL AND MINORITY/WOMEN-OWNED BUSINESS ENTERPRISES The SUBRECIPIENT will use its best efforts to afford small businesses, minority business enterprises, and women's business enterprises the maximum practicable opportunity to participate in the performance of this contract. As used in this contract, thc terms -small business" means a business that meets the criteria set forth in section 3(a) of the Small Business Act, as amended (15 U.S.C. 632), and "minority and women's business enterprise" means a business at least fifty-one (51) percent owned and controlled by minority group members or women. For the purpose of this definition, ''minority group members" are Afro-Americans, Spanish-speaking, Spanish surnamed or Spanish-heritage Americans, Asian-Americans, and American Indians. The SUBRECIPIENT may rely on written representations by businesses regarding their status as minority and female business enterprises in lieu of an independent investigation. C. PROGRAM BENEFICIARIES At least filly-one percent (51%) of the beneficiaries of a project funded through this Agreement must be low- and moderate- income persons. If the project is located in an entitlement city, as defined by HUD, or serves beneficiaries countywide, more than thirty percent (30%) of the beneficiaries directly assisted under this Agreement must reside in unincorporated Collier County or in municipalities participating in the County's Urban County Qualification Program. onakliyc. iDaG(CON 13-08} propcny AL'quinon Page 10 of 26 8 A O. AFHR\4AT/VE ACTION PLAN The SU8KE[IP1RNT agrees that it shall he committed to carry out pursuant to the COUNTY's specifications an Affirmative Action Program in keeping with the principles as provided in President's Executive Order 11246 of September 24, 1966. The COUNTY shall provide Affirmative Action guidelines to No SlJFIREC|P|ENTtu assist in the KnnnWmion of such program. The SOBR[ClPlENTshmU| submit a plan for un Affirmative Action Program for approval prior to the award ot findS. F. CONFLICT OF INTEREST The SURH[C|P(ENTooYrnunts that no person under its employ who presently exer ises any functions or responsibilities' in connection with the Project, has any personal financial interest, direct or indirect, in the |` jcei areas or any parcels iherein, which would conflict in any manner or degree with the performance of this Agreement and that no person having any conflict of interest shall be employed by or subcontracted by the SUB|<FC/P|ENT. The 8UBRLECiP|GNT covenants that it will comply with all provisions of 24 CFR 570611 -Conflict of Interest". and the State and County statutes, regulations, ordinance or resolutions governing coniliets at interest, Any possible conflict of interest on the part of the SUBRECIPIENT or its employees shall be disclosed in vThng to MIN'S provided, however, that this paragraph shall be interpreted in such a manner so as not to unreasonably impede the statutory requirement that maximum opportunity be provided for employment of and participation ot low and moderate-income residents of the p 'eg1ur&e( area. XL CONDITIONS FOR RELIGIOUS ORGANIZATIONS CDBG funds may be used by reli ioux organizations or on property owned by religious organizations only in accordance with requirements set in Section 24 CFR 570.2000). The SUBREC|PlENTuhoU comply with First Amendment ChurchISwte principles as follows: a. It will nut discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment on the basis of religion and will not limit employment or give preference in employment to persons on the basis olreligion h. It will not discriminate against any person applying for public services on the basis of religion and will not limit such services or give preference to persons on the basis of reli c. It will retain its independence from Federal, State and local governments and may continue to carry out its mission, including the definition, practice and expression of its religious beliefs, provided that. it does not use direct CDBG funds to support any inherently religious activities, such as worship, religious instruction or proselytizing d. The funds shall not be used for the ucquiaition, construction or rehabilitation of structures to the extent that those structures are used for inherently religious activities, Where a structure is used for both eligible and inherently religious activities, CDBG funds may not exceed the cost of those portions of the acquisition, construction or rehabilitation that are attributable to eligible activities in accordance with the cog accounting requirements applicable to CDBG funds in this part. Sanouuriex, chapels, or other rooms that uCMG funded religious congregation uses as its principal place ol'worship. however, are ineligible for C[)BG funded improvements. SEVERABILITY Should any provision of'the Agreement be determined to he unenforceable or invx|id, such a determination shall not affect the validity or enforceability at'any other section or pai thereof `"n* C»ux,"ue. o�px.,/ox 13-N/ rwp*,A*vi`x Page | l o[26 , `? 8A IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Sub recipient and the County,have each, respectively, by an authorized person or agent, hereunder set their hands and seals on this 14th day of May. 2013. A VI EST: BOARD OF C U NI T C ,MMISSIONERS OF DWIGHT E:-13ROCK, CLERK COLLIER CO TN rlY, , •RIDA 1 . By: " y ‘ GEORGIA A:HIT ER, ESQ., CHAIRWOMAN Sig -'11 '0 ... ., . .„, Dated: :10 1-0t 3 (. '.,AL) ,________4________ Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. le/j44 / a■--- _ By: Kim Minarich Kim Minarich,Executive Director Subrecipient Name and Title Approved as to form and legal sufficiency: N Jennifer 1. White, Assistant County Attorney' P)-) ■/' 'C) Naples l Auestrian Challenge.Inc. CD13(i(CDS 13-08) Prop;r1) Acquysition Page 12 of 26 8 A EXHIBIT"A" INSURANCE REQUIREMENTS The SDBR[C{PlENT shall furnish to Collier County, c/o Housing, Human and Veteran Services Department, 3339 E. Tamiami Trail. Suite 2 1, Naples, Florida 34112, Certificate(s) of Insurance evidencing insurance coverage that meets the requireiiieiits as outlined below: |. Workers' Compensation as required by Chapter 440, Florida S/u/ules. � Commercial General Liability including products and completed operations insurance in the amount o[$|.O0O1 0 per occurrence and 52,000.000 aggregate. Collier County must he shown as an additional insured with respect to this coverage, 3. Automobile Liability Insurance covering all owned, non-owned and hired vehicles used in connection with this contract in an amount not less than $1,000,000 combined single limit for combined Bodily Injury and Property Damage. Collier County shall be named as an additional insured. [Ls|uN STAGE OFAPPLICABLE) In addition to the insurance required in 1 — 3 above, a Certificate of Insurance must he provided as follows: 4 Professional Liability Insurance in the name of the SUBRECIPIENT or the licensed design prohsxionml employed by the SO@QEC{P|2NT in an amount not less than $1,000,000 per uccormzc/$l'00O.0U0 aggregate providing for all sums which the 3UBREC|P|ENT and/or the design professional shall become legally obligated to pay as damages for claims arising out of the services pedinncJ by ihc 6UBRFC|P|[NT or any person employed by the S\)8K[Uy|ENT in connection with this contract. This insurance shall be maintained for a period of two (2) years alter the certificate of Occupancy is issued. Collier County shall be named as an additional insured. Ll �\TuM.l}nN Pt(AS'.(ft API'I_lC'AIThF.) In addition to the insurance required in | — 4 above, the SUBRECIPEINT shall provide or cause its Subcontractors {u provide original certificates indicating the following types of insurance coverage prior to any construct ion: 5. Completed Value Builder's Risk Insurance on an All Risk" basis in an amount not less than one hundred (100%) percent of'the insurable value ol'the building(s) or structure(s). The policy shall be in the name of Collier County and the SUBREC\PlENT. 6, In accordance with the requirements of the Flood Disaster Protection Act of 1973 (42 U.S.C. 4001), the Suhrecipient shall assure thut for activities located in an area identified by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) us having special Hood hazards, flood insurance under the National Flood Insurance Program is obtained and maintained as a condition of financial assistance for acquisition or construction purposes (including rehabilitation). Naples/*^,mio'cxm*ne" /.c (.o1i6 mn /3.0m/ r"pert:, »w"'�/""' Page |3u[26 '`r «` 8 A UftWtx}i»N/NI8wAu*wExTP||+sE(IF APPLICABLE) /\/ter the Construction Phase is completed and occupancy begins, the following insurance must be kept in force throughout the duration of the loan and/or contract: 7. Workers' Compensation as required by Chapter 440, /Ynri/oS&x8aes. 8. Commercial 6one:u| Liability including products and completed operations insurance in the amount o[S|.000,008 per occurrence and $2/000,000 aggregate. Collier County must be shown as an additional insured with respect |u this coverage, 9. Automobile Liability Insurance covering all ov/nc6, non-owned and hired vehicles used in connection with this contract in an amount not less that $1,000,000 combined single limit h.r combined Bodily Injury and Property Damage. Collier County as an additional insured. 10, Property Insurance coverage on an "All Risk" basis in an amount not less than one hundred (100%) of the replacement cost of the pnoperiy. Collier County must be shown as a Loss payee with respect to this coverage } \. Flood Insurance coverage kn those properties found to be within a flood hazard zone for the full replacement values of the structure(s) or the maximum amount of coverage available through the National Hood Insurance Program (N}lP). The policy must show Collier County as a Loss Puyec /\]].M.A. / iptreStnmmn)ienmc_/^c rum;mos^m/ rmou` ^qui*"m Page |4o[20 ` k ` 8A EXHIBIT"Tr COLLIER COUNTY HOUSING, HUMAN AND VETERAN SERVICES REQUEST FOR PAYMENT SECTION I: REQUEST FOR PAYMENT Sub recipient Name: Na- les E uestrian Challenge, Inc, Sub recipient Address: 206 Ridge Drive, Naples, FL 34108 Project Name: Property Acquisition Project No: CDS I 3-08 Payment Request # Dollar Amount Requested: $ SECTION II: STATUS OF FUNDS 1. Grant Amount Awarded $520,000 2. Sum of Past Claims Paid on this Account $ 3, Total Grant Amount Awarded Less Sum Of Past Claims Paid on this Account 4. Amount 01 Previous Unpaid Requests S 5. Amount 01 Today's Request S 6. Current Grunt Balance (initial Grant Amount Awarded Less Sum of all requests) I certify that this request for payment has been drawn in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Agreement between the COUNTY and us, as the SUBRECIPIENT. I also certify that the amount of the Request for Payment is not in excess of current needs. Signature Date Title Authorizinv, Grant Coordinator Supervisor _ (approval authority under$14,999) Dept Director (approval required 515,000 and above) Napft!si.qucskri:10 cono LnS Irriv AcclaNition Page 15 0126 Q.\,2) 8 A EXHIBIT "C" RELEASE AND AFPIDAVIl' FORM CONSTRUCTION ONLY 0c SUDRE[ lMCNTcrdiGcs For itself and its contractors that all charges for labor, materials, supplies, lands, licenses and other expenses for which COUNTY might be sued or for which a lien or a demand against any payment bond might be |l)*d, have been satisfied and paid. This document is in compliance with Florida Statutes Chapter 713,02 Part I — VVmivcrorRdcuy: o[Licoy This Release and Affidavit is given in connection with the S(JB8ECl9|2NT'x (mnnrNy/finu|) Request |brPmYmcnL Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc. Witness: BY: 13T: DS: ExecobYeDirecuo DATE: Print name and tiie STA ll OF COUNTY OF _ The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day o[ . 20__, by as of A Choose Not-For-Profit, or Corporation or Municipality on behalf of Choose NoAFor'Pro|it. Corporation or Municipality . fie/She is personally known to mu OR has produced as identification and who did (did riot) take an oath. My Commission Expires: (Signature) Name: (Lcvihh/ Phrdod) (AFFIX OFFICIAL SEAL) Notary Public, State of: Commission No,: Naples ovmu/ripCxxiuoe^Inc, cuu(/(Cn* 12-08) Properly»*w."*m Page 16 o[26 8 A EXJIIBIT;'D" Ql1ARTERL\' PROGRESS REPORT Sub-recipients.Please fill in the following shaded areas of the report Agency Name: Naples Equestrian Challenge,Inc. Date: Project Title: Property Acquisition Alternate Program Contact: Kim Minarich Contact; Telephone Number: 238-586-2888 :❑ E3 4 0 O 'REPORT FOR QUARTER ENDING:(check one that applies to the corresponding grant period}: 7131113 10131/13 Please take note: Eacn quarterly report needs to include cumulative data beginning from the start of the agreement date of May M.2013 Please list the outcome goai(s}from your approved application&sub-recipient agreement and indicate your progress In meeting those 1 goals since May 14,2013. A Outcome Goals: list the outcome geal(s)from your approved application i sub recipient agreement. Outcome 1:Close ort Property#t7-31-13 t Outcome 7:Serve a minimum of 200 low and moderate Income persona peryear'for the next 20 years ` . Outcome 3: Outcome 4: ° Outcome S; Outcome 6: k Outcome 7; B.Goal Progress:indicate the progress to date in riesling each outcome goal. Outcome 1: ,fir Is this project still in compliance with the original project schedule?if more than 2 months behind schedule,must submits new#tmeltne 2. for approval. \,rplry l-yut' Ui,ui t:hallcng,% /Ilk', ('I)Ici (t'US I3-ORl Page� i i t [ �U i''opertT ACC(in"^iil'ir ' 8A o ves If no,expIair. 3. Since May 14,2013,of the persons assisted,how many,,„ now have new access lcontinuing)to this service or benefit? 0 b. now has improveo access to this service or benefit? 0 now receive a . se•vice or benefit that is no longer substandard? 0 TOTAL; 0 4, What funding sources are applied for this period/program year? S $ Section 108 Loan GLaranlee HOPWA S S Other Consolidated Plan Funds - CDF3G Other Federal Funds - E SG $ . . State(Local Funds HOME - Total Entitlement S Total Other Funds Funds Nitplch Ftestriati (t.:1)S .3-08) Ifroperi, f‘t:quiNitIon Page 18 of 26 8A EXHIBIT"D" QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT 5. what tiM total number of UNDUPLICATED cleats served this quarter ItapptktbI.7 1 a, Tot&No et w..1011 low ans a erred 0 iota/No re remade servoct.noir 18 0 tr. total No er aout metes le..,,ery 0 Tote No i mate,senterf under 10 0 TOTAL 0 TOTAL: 0 c Tutor No 1 reor,tera 0 1Q,,14.4 41 t,,a4:1 newt oi haus eecid 0 6. •What Is the total number of UNDUPLICATED clients served since October 'optical:0e? a, Total rs..•ecct oi adult lamed'served 0 boa:nsetres 01'ornate,seed under 18 0 0. /old r.yrntor 0'acL.Smalen eyed 0 Total to/CL.,,of males twee,'.daor 18 TOTAL; C TOTAL: 0 c 'olor d wound 0 104a1 No et weal,rnac of noLcanoC 0 Conve le EITHER hue mion OT OR se,L9mprele queen:An 075 f:;.,./program lay senile Vents le caw ma*el that rated MO Presumed Senoto t&evades Corn n waster,P8 4 any chant rri your anag ran.apes ro No alio a Naavnec fienel catelsory 00 NOT COMPLETE BOTH QUESTION 7 AND 8, 7. [PRESUMED BENEFICIARY QATk r ,OTHER RENEFIDIARY DATA.INDOME RANGE la/locate the!welt:to...get el LINIIVELICALErt Indicate the total number 0=1 thlinitELEAIELP persons persona starved Coco October 1 Atm tall Into served since October 1 who Ian Into emit Moored each presumcd benefit category ;Pro ',fa, category Me IOW shook'eq■tal the total rt.qt.asenn 14): ar03,7 ecirN tolNln queSlon 88;t. Report., Report as. O AnesoO r../tvdcon Letrosney raw income(9-2014/ O e40neless Raison 0 LI.', 6,oUtn(31.50%) O Halwrea Soccses, 0 Pkoloyee hconto(51 BC.A; O Persons 3-19.4,10; 0 Abttne Nocle•elf IrcOme t'7IIVA7 O fOol,Parsons O Valeta C C re ancolyr Ideesatry O P"10 Chsat.ed Art Ars C °Me,Yrs en (01ALt ssss TOTAL C 9, !Racial 8.Ethnic Data. 101appiutble) Please Indicate how many UNDUPLICATED client.served since October tell Into each race category.In addition to each race category, please Indicate how many persons In each recap category Consider therratIves Hispanic (Total Race column should equal the total cell) RACE ETHNICITY Winta ol whom r sae many we Hamm 7 0,AC,,1ainCan Aine,c4, 0 0 tawhom Co,n a-ry Fee Htsporic 7 AS 8, 0 0 cr wrcan now eletly are raaggrua 7 A inc.' dO iateNtolni rtc=sre 0 0 •dr whom how merry are llISpaldCT NalW0(i3,.,1,11n;01Nr PaCek.latency 0 0 el wtip/r,!ow frary lirsparo7 lOw,' 0 niNas tor Mantis IL Wore 0 r`rea n/whom,hay many wet siSpddc"I • 0q cow Amerman OW In 0 0 .01 wham,how:nary we H.spATeCT IN :nda-vNasha reather 4 eleostAloc w,Ar 0 0 of whore nC.e.Many a'a Moue*, Dm.,Wan.roc,o1 0 0. tenon now marry we H4parrer 011ve C 0 ctl*nor,row many ara ParaCT TOTAL 0 _0 TOTAL HISPANIC NAT2 Spnalde duWernr—TYwis represents your&echoes: I tet signature rt4tIchlrian (1)13(i(CDS 13-07i) Ii I)Tifl \ \oplicition Page 19 of 26 EXHIBIT '`E" ANNUAL AUDIT MONITORING REPORT OMB Circular A-133 Audits of States, Local Govennmnnts, and requires the Collier Coun�yHoua . Housing, Hurnanand Veterans Services OopaMnnentiomonkor our sub recipients nf federal wvvurdu and determine whether they have met the audit requirements of the circular and whether they are in compliance with federal laws and regulations. Accordingly, we are requiring that you check one of the foUPwing, provide all appropriate documentation regarding your organization's compliance with the audit i_requirements, sign and date this form. I Sub recipient Fiscal Year Name Naples Equestrian Challenge, Inc . Period Total State Financial Assistance Expended during � Total Federal completed Financial--'Fiscal Year sancaExpwndaddvhng---st ndvcomo�hedF�oo| Yeor F--' completed Check Appropriate Boxes i---' ' -- - - We have exceeded the $500,000 federal/state expenditure threshold for our fiscal year ending as indicated above and have completed our Circular A-i 33 audit. A copy of the audit report and management letter is attached. I We exceeded the $500,000 federal/state expenditure threshold for our fiscal year ending as ( indicated above and expect to complete our Circular A-i 33 audit by . Within [] 30 days of completion of the A-133 audit, we will provide a copy of the audit report and management letter, We are not subject to the requirements of OMB Circular A-133 because we: O Did not exceed the $500,000 federal/state expenditure threshold for the fiscal year indicated above O Are a for-profit organization Are exempt for other reasons-explain An audited financial statement io attached and ifapp|ioab|w the applicable, management letter. (If findin9s were nptwd, please enclose a copy of the responses and corrective action plan.) Certification Statement I certify hereby ' Signature --- -- - � Date annmandTidm �_____ N=/ NHu,priu/cx*uo»+ Inc. � oHo(COS /,-0«} op,:rt■ Page 20 of 26 8 A EXHIBIT "F" LOCAL AND FEDERAL RULES,REGULATIONS AND LAWS l. 24 CFR 570. as amended - The regulations governing the expenditure of Community Development Block Grain (OD8G) funds. 2, 24 CFR 5V - The regulations prescribing the Environmental Review procedure, 3. Section 104(b) and Section 109 of Title 1 of the ||nuningund Community Development Act oF 1974 as amended 4. Ink VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 as amended, Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of'1968 as amended 5. 24 CFR 570.601 Subpart K - The regulations issued pursuant to Executive Order 11863 which prohibits d iscrim mat ion and promotes equal opportunity in housing. 6. Executive Order 11246 ("Equal Employment Opportunity"), as amended by Executive Orders 11375 and 12086 ' which establishes hiring goals for minorities and women on projects assisted with federal funds and as supplemented in Department of Labor regulations. 7. Title VII o[the 1968 Civil Rights Act as amended by the Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1972, 42 DSC § 2000e, et. seq. The SUBRECIPIENT will, in all solicitations or advertisements for employees placed by or on behalf of the SUBRECIPIENT, state that it is an Equal Opportunity or Affirmative Action employer, B. 24 CFR 135 Regulations outlining requirements of Section 3 of the Housi and Urban Development Act or 1968. as amended. Compliance with the rn 'isions of Section 3 of the HUD Act ofl0O8. as amendcd, and as implemented by the regulations set forth in 24 CFR 135, and all applicable niles and orders issued hereunder prior to the execution of this contract, shall be a condition of the Federal financial assistance provided under this contract and binding upon the COUNTY, the SUBRF,ClP|ENT and any of the 5UQKEUP|ENl`s Sub-recipients and subcontractors. Failure, to fulfill these requirements shall subject the COUNTY, ients and subcontractors, their SUCCCSSON rind assigns. to those sanctions specified by the Agreement through which Federal assistance is provided. ]he SCBR[[|P|EMT certifies and agrees that no contractual or other disability exists that would pi'event compliance wiih these requirements. The SU8KE[1P1ENT further agrees to comply with these "Section 3" requirements and to include the Following language in all subcontracts executed under this Agreement: ~De work to be performed under this Agreement is a project assisted under a program providing direct Federal financial assistance from HUD and is subject to the requirements of Section 3 of the Housing and Urban Development Act of 1908, as amended (12 U.S.C. 1701). Section 3 requires that to the greatest extent feasible opportunities for training and employment be given to low- and very low-income residents of the pi'ojecl urcu` ond \hotcortmxts [brwnrk in connection with the project omu(oxsn'm) "^v*'° Awu.=^.w Page Z| o[26 8 A be awarded to business concerns that provide economic opportunities for low- and very low-income persons residing in the metropolitan area in which the project is located." The SUGR|lCU`(EN'[ further agrees N ensure that opportunities t'or training and employment arising in connection with a housing rehabilitation (including reduction and abatement of lead-based paint hazards), housing ums(ruchon, or other public construction project are given to low- and very low- income persons residing within the metropolitan area in which Une CDIIC} Oundcd project is located; where feasible, priority should be given to low- and very low-income persons within the service area of the project or the neighborhood in which the project is located, and to low- and very low-income participants in other HUD programs; and award contracts for work undertaken in connection with a housing rehabilitation (including reduction and abatement of lead-based paint hazards), housing construction, or other public construction project to business concerns that provide economic opportunities for low- and very low-income persons residing within the metropolitan area in which the LD8G'0u/vdcd project is located; where feasible, priority should he given to business concerns that provide economic opportunities to low- and very lox-income residents within the service area or the neighborhood in which the project is located, and to low- and very low-income participants in other ULD programs, The SUBREC|MENT certifies and agrees that no contractual or other legal incapacity exists that xmuid p'e 'ent compliance with these requirements. V Age Discrimination Act of 1975, Executive Order 11063, and Executive Order 11246 as amended by [xecu(ircOn]cn } 1]75, 11478' 12107 and 12086. 10. Contract Work Hours and Safety Standards Act, 40 DS[ 327'332. | |. Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, 29 USC 776(b) (5)` 24 CFR 570.014 Subpart K. 12. The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 13. Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970, as amended. 14, 29 [[N Parts 3 and 5 - Regulations which prescribe the payment of pr vuUi wages and the use of apprentices and trainees on federally assisted projects as mandated by the Davis-Bacon Act. HUD Form 4()10 must be included in all construction contracts funded by CDBG. (See 42 USC 276a and 24 CFR |D.\ |(c)). |i [sccutive Order 11914 - Prohibits discrimination with respect to the handicapped in hzeroUy assisted projects. |o, Cxecutive Order 11625 and U.S. Department of' housing and Urban Development Circular Letter 79'45 - hic)i prescribes goal percentages for participation of minority businesses in Community Development Block Grant Contracts. 17, The SUBR[OP|[NT agrees to comply with the non-discrimination in employment and contracting opportunities laws, regulations, and executive orders referenced in 24 CFR 570.607, as revised by Executive Order 13279, [he apulieahlc non-discrimination provisions in Section 109 of the HCDA are still applicable, mv/op4"cwioo,xo//uv, Inc. D136 (COS o/w) /�o°nrx*pi,x.m, Page Z2uf26 8 A )8. Public Law )U0-43O ' the Fair Housing Amendments Act o[ }988, |V. 24 CFR 84 - Uniform Administrative Requirements for Grants and Agreements with Institutions of Higher Education, Hospitals and Other Non-Prolit Organizations and specified by the tbl lowing subsections: • Subpart A - General: • Subpart 8 - Pre-Award Requirements, except for 84.12, Forms kn /\pp|ying for Federal Assistance; • Subpart C- Post-Award Requirements, except for: o Section 8422. Payment Requirements- Grantees shall follow the standards or 85.20(h)(7) and 85,21 in making piyments to SUBRECIPIENTs; o Section 84.23. Cost Sharing and Matching; o Section 84,24. Program Income - in lieu o[ 8424 CC)8U SUBR.E[l91ENTs shall follow 570.504; o Section 84.25, Revision ol'Budget and Program Plans; o Section 84.32, Real Property - In lieu of 84.32. CDDO SUBRECIPIENTs shall follow 570.50�� . o Section 84.34(g), Equipment In lieu of the disposition provisions o184.34(g) the following applies: " In all cases in which equipment is sold, the proceeds shall be program income (pro- m(cd to reflect the extent to which C[}BO funds were used to acquire the equipment): and • Equipment not needed by the 3UQQEC/9|ENT for CTl8G activities shall be transferred to the recipient for the CD8(} program or shall be retained after compensating the recipient; o Section 84.35, Supplies and other Expendable Property o Section 84.51(h). (c), (d), (e). (1) and (h), Monitoring and Reporting Program Performance; o Section 84.52, Financial Reporting; o Section 84.53(b), Retention and Access Requirements for Records. Section 84.53(6) applies with the following exceptions: • The retention period referenced in 84.53(b) perta ning to individual CDBG activities shall be Four years; and • The retention period starts from the date of submission of the annual performance and evaluation report, as prescribed in 24 CFR 91.520, in which the specific activity is reported on for the final time rather than from the date of submission of' the final expenditure report For the award; o Section 84.61, Termination - In lieu of the provisions o[ 84.6), [D8G SDBRGC|PlENTs shall comply with 570,503(b)(7); and ° Stihpart U -. After-the-Award Requirements -except for 84.7!, Closeout Procedures 20. 24 CFR 85 - Administrative Requirements for Grants and Agreements to State and Local Governments shall be followed for sul recipients that arc 8ovcnxnenix| entities. 21. Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 as located at 8 USC 1324, et seq. and regulations relating thereto. Failure by the SUBREC11IENT to comply with the laws referenced herein shall constitute a breach of this agreement, and the County shall have the discretion to unilaterally terminate this agreement immediately. Nan/~`4v~^'iowcho/mg: Inc, nmo\'osn^«> ,"+u,xulmw.m Page 2] o[26 8 A 22. Prohibition Of Gitis [o County Employees - No organization or individual shall offeror give, ci(hcrdirec |y o/ indirectly, any favor, gift, loan, ice, service or other item of value to any County eniployce, as set forth in Chapter 112. Part UL Florida Statutes, Collier County Ethics Ordinance No. 2004'05, as amended, and County Administrative Procedure 5311. 23. Order of Precedence - In the event of any conflict between or among the {cnns of any of the Contract i)ocmocmx. the terms of the Agreement shall take precedence over the terms of all other Contract Documents. except the terms of any Supplemental Conditions shall take precedence over the Agreement. To the extent any conflict in the terms of the Contract Documents cannot be resolved by application of the Supplemental Condkions, if any or the Agreement, the conflict shall be resolved by imposing the more strict or costly obligation under the Contract Documents UOfl the Contractor at Owner's discretion. 24, Dispute Resolution - Prior m the initiation of any action or proceeding permitted by this Agreement to resolve disputes between the parties, the parties shall make a good faith effort to resolve any such disputes by negotiation. Any situations when negotiations, litigation and/or mediation shall be attended by representatives of SUBRECIHENT with full decision-making authority and by COUNTY'S staff person who would make the presentation of any settlement reached during negotiations to COUNTY for approval. Failing resolution, and prior to the commencement of depositions in any litigation between the parties arising our of this Agreement, the parties shall attempt to resolve the dispute Mediation before an agreed-upon Circuit Court Mediator certified by the State of Florida. Should either party fail to submit to mediation as required hereunder, the other party may obtain a court order requiring mediation under § 44.102. Florida Stature`. The litigation arising out of this Agreement shall be Collier County, Florida, if in state court and the US District Court, 20* Judicial Court of Florida, Kin federal court. BY ENTERING INTO TU|5 AGREEMENT, COLLIER COUNTY AND 'ME, SUBRC[%P|ENT EXPRESSLY WAIVE ANY RIGHTS EITHER PARTY MAY HAVE TO A TRIAL BY JURY OF ANY CIVIL LITIGATION RELATED N. OR ARISING OUT OF, THIS AGREEMENT. 25. 'ftc SUBRECIP[ENT agrees to comply with the following requirements: a. Clean Air Act' 41 USC 7401. e/xr4. b. Federal Water Pollution Control Act, 33 USC \25}' c/ �c4, axamended, 26, In accordance with the requirements of the Flood Disaster Protection Act of 1973 (42 USC 4002 and 24 CFK 570.605 Subpart K), the SU8R£C)P1ENTxhaU assure that for activities located in an area identified by FEMA as having special flood huzunJy, flood insurance under the National Flood Insurance Program is obtained and maintained, If appropriate, a letter of map amendment (LOMA) inay be obtained from FEMA, which would satisfy this requirement and/or reduce the cost of said flood insurance. 27, The 8UBKb( |P)6NT agrees that any construction or rehabilitation of residentia structures with assistance provided under this contract shall be subject to HUD Lead-Based Paint Poisoning Prevention Act found at 24 (.FR 570.608. Subpart K. 28, [hcSU8KEC|P(£NT *grccy to comply with the Historic Preservation requirements set forth in the National ||imnric Preservation Act o( )966. uo amended (|6U.S.C. 47O) and the procedures set forth in 36 CFR Part 800. Advisory Council on Historic Preservation Procedures for Protection of Historic Pnoperticx, insofar as hev apply to the performance of'this agreement. cxxx,np Inc u)m�/Cm n-ox/ ,wpo^/^o/"ki/~. Page 24 of 26 BA In general. this requires concurrence from the State Historic Preservation Officer for all rehabilitation and demolition of historic properties that are fifty years old or older or that are included on a federal, state or local historic property list. 29. The SUBRECIPIENT must certify that it will provide drug-free workplaces in accordance with the Drug- Free WorkpInce Act of 1988 (41 USC 701), 30, Hie SUBRECIPIENT certifies that neither it, nor its principals, is presently debarred, suspended, proposed for debarment, declared ineligible, or voluntarily excluded from participation in this transaction by any Federal Department or agency; and, that the SUBRECIPIENT shall not knowingly enter into any lower tier contract. or other covered transaction, with a person who is similarly debarred or suspended from participating in this covered transaction as outlined in 24 CFR 570.609, Subpart K. 31 The suBREciptENT agrees to comply with the following OMB Circulars whichever is applicable, and agrees to adhere to the accounting principles and procedures required therein, utilize adequate internal controls, and maintain necessary source documentation for all costs incurred, States, local governments,and Indian Tribes follow: • A-87 for Cost Principles • A-102 for Administrative Requirements Educational Institutions(even if part of a State or local government) IblI • A-21 for Cost Principles • A-11 0 for Administrative Requirements Non-Profit Organizations follow. • A-122 for Cost Principles • A-110 for Administrative Requirements 32„Audits shall be conducted annually and shall he submitted to the COUNTY one hundred eighty (180) days after the end of the SUBRECWIENT's fiscal year. The SUBRECIPIENT shall comply with the requirements and standards of ()MR A-I 33, Audits of States. Local Governments, and Non-Profit Organizations. If this Agreement is closed out prior to the receipt of an audit report, the COUNTY reserves the right to recover any disallowed costs identified in an audit after such closeout. 33, Any real property acquired by the SUBRECIPIENT for the purpose of carrying on the projects stated herein, and approved by the COUNTY in accordance with the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970 and 49 CFR 24.101, shall be subject to the provisions of CDBG including, but not limited to, the provisions on use and disposition of property. Any real property within the SUBRECIPIENT control, which is acquired or improved in whole or part with CDBG funds in excess of 525,000, must adhere to the CDBG Regulations at 24 CFR 570.505. 34. As provided in § 287.133, Honda Statutes by entering into this Agreement or performing any work in furtherance hereof, the SUBRECIPIENT certifies that it, its affiliates, suppliers, subcontractors and consultants who will perform hereunder, have not been placed on the convicted vendor list maintained by the State of Florida Department of Management Services within the 36 months immediately preceding the date hereof, This notice is required by § 287.133 (3) (a), Florida Statutes. 35, No Federal appropriated funds have been paid or will be paid, by or on behalf of'the undersigned, to any person for influencing or attempting to influence an officer or employee of any agency, a Member of Congress, an officer or employee of Congress, or an employee of a Member of Congress in connection with N.Lpk:s t'hallenge, Inc. ("DM;(('I)ti l'r,norty Aajoiition Page 25 of 26 . ` 8 A the awarding of any Federal contract, the making u[any Federal grant, the making of any Federal loan, the entering into of any cooperative agreement, and the extension, conbnuu6on, renewal, amendment, or modification of any Federal contract, grant, loan, or cooperative agreement. any funds other than Federal appropriated funds have been paid or will be paid to any person for inlluenciug 0) attempting to ioOuroceonofficc/ nremp|oycuo[unya8cncy, uMcmbcro[Congrcux, on officer or employee of Congress, or an employee of a Member of Congress in connection with this Federal contract, grant, loan, or cooperative agreement, the undersigned shall complete and submit Standard Form'iI,L "Disclosure Form to Report Lobbying," in accordance with its instructions. The undersigned shall require that the language of this certification be included in the award documents for all sub-awards at all tiers (including subcontracts, yuh'grun1s, contracts under grants, loans, and cooperative agreements) and that all SU0RECU`lENT3 shall certify and disclose accordingly. ]h. Travel reimbursement will be based on the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) per diem rates in effect at the time of travel 37 Any rule or regulation determined to he applicable by HUD. 38. Florida Statutes 7il2O, Part 1, Construction Liens ). Florida Statutes. 119.02 I Records Retention w:F/uku*t,:wCo^|mne' omo(Coy 13'08) '*p^,A^puow Page 26o[26 / ,^ * ``/ cAL ioto3 // D JMB TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING, INC. y? JurileS TRAFFIC/TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING & PLANNING SERVICES 1/145 MEMORANDUM October 7, 2013 ID To: Board of County Commissioners From: James M. Banks, P.E. RE: Safety Considerations on Corkscrew Road & Sand Delivery/Dump trucks Dear Commissioners: I am aware that the Board of Collier County(BCC) is reviewing the issue of Sand Trucks traveling on Corkscrew Road, and that Lee County Government has provided some information that supports their request that an alternate route be used. As you know,part of their submitted data or claims have to do with safety issues along Corkscrew Road. With respect to Lee's request that safety issues be made a part of your deliberations, I don't believe that the BCC has been provided a complete assessment of the issues regarding dump truck-related crashes. Once the BCC is provided with a breakdown of the dump truck crash events (see items 1 thru 6 below),then an informed decision can be made. If such an effort was made to disclose all the facts to the BCC,then I suspect you will find that the evidence proves that the use of Corkscrew Road will not create a heightened safety issue, or that somehow other roads of similar status and condition are (for some unexplained reason) safer for truck travel. My firm conducted a review of the crash reports along Corkscrew Road between the years 2003 thru 2006 and found that "trucks" were involved in a low percentage of crashes and "dump trucks" even less. The type of dump truck crashes varied, but can be summarized as: a.) single truck crashes, b.)truck-truck, and c.)truck-passenger car crashes. The truck-passenger crashes also included "passenger car at-fault" accidents. There were no recorded school bus-truck crashes,no truck-pedestrian crashes, and no fatalities related to trucks, during that period. It is my opinion that the BCC has not been provided with all the factual evidence needed to make a decision related to truck safety. That is, without establishing the frequency of dump truck at-fault crashes vs. other types of crashes along Corkscrew Road, no fact- based conclusion can be reached. I believe the BCC must be provided the following additional information for consideration: 1IP .� , JMB TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING, INC. 110 1. Average daily volume of dump trucks and the total average daily traffic (ADT) for the past 3 to 5 years along Corkscrew Road(between I-75 and S.R. 82). For 2 thru 5 below, use the same 3 to 5 years and road segment as above 2. Total number of recorded crashes (all vehicle types) along Corkscrew Road. 3. Total number of crashes that involved a dump truck(do not include non-dump trucks in this stat as the issue specifically pertains to dump trucks). 4. Total number of dump truck crashes that involved a passenger car or pedestrian. 5. Total number of dump truck w/passenger car crashes where the truck driver was cited "At-Fault". 6. Description, location and severity of each dump truck crash. Also for your consideration,the conclusions of the Morris-Depew Traffic Safety Analysis are consistent with my firm's previous findings. My regards, Jim 2IPaae /0/g//--- ,', 1/D Staff Recommendations for Collier County Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Wells 1 1 D Purpose The purpose of this White Paper is to respond to direction given by the Board of County Commissioners on September 24, 2013 in relation to the proposed Oil Exploration and Production Wells located on east of 24th Ave SE. Recommendations in the Executive Summary, Item 1OF were: To have staff prepared to respond to citizen inquiries related to the anticipated issuance of an Oil Exploration Permit for operations adjacent to Golden Gate Estates by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. Preparation should include but not be limited to a review of permit stipulations and safety elements, evaluation of potential impacts to County infrastructure, and, most importantly, evaluation of needed preparation to insure adequate disaster readiness and coordination of emergency management and first responder agencies. Further directing staff to bring an assessment and recommendation back to the BCC at the October 8, 2013 board meeting, (or the first board meeting following DEP action)for possible BCC action. Transportation Considerations Access to this site from 24th Ave SE was the subject of a Right of Way Permit (PRROW2013020264201) issued to Collier Land Holdings on 08-29-2013. The Permit was issued for Residential Construction to install a lime rock driveway at the end of 24th Ave SE. Road and Bridge Maintenance has videotaped 24th Ave SE East of Desoto Blvd. It is in good condition at present. During and after the period that equipment is brought in through this road, County staff will review conditions and require the Drilling Company to grade the road if conditions warrant. Planning and Zoning Considerations Both the Growth Management Plan (GMP) and the Land Development Code (LDC) are specific to where Oil Wells and Oil Field Development are permitted within the various GMP districts and LDC zoning districts, the below two tables summarizes the districts that oil wells are permitted and the process an application needs to satisfy to gain approval. From review of the list, one can see that in certain districts an application for an oil well is required to go through an administrative process, which requires the submittal of a Site Development Plan, to gain approval. Within other districts, an oil well is required to go through the conditional use process, which requires a public hearing to gain approval. The GMP is specific in that any application for an oil well is not reviewed at the local level from an environmental perspective. Policy 1.1.6 of the Conservation and Coastal Management Element states, "In those areas of Collier County where oil extraction and related processing is an allowable use, such use is subject to applicable state and federal oil and gas permits and Collier County non-environmental site development plan review procedures." Essentially this review is done by the FDEP and duplicative reviews are not encouraged by the GMP. The specifics of the criteria that a new oil well must satisfy from a land use perspective is regulated currently by the GMP and the LDC and if the Board directs, staff could initiate changes to both of these Staff Recommendations for Collier County 1 1 £) Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Wells documents to either increase or decrease the regulatory requirements for the establishment of a new oil well. For example, the Dan Hughes application for the exploration oil well near the Estates is currently required to submit a Site Improvement Plan to gain approval, but if the Board directed, the regulations could be increased to mandate that a conditional use application is required for any new exploration well or a conditional use is required for any new exploration wells within a specified distance from a residential structure. These two potential changes are provided to demonstrate the latitude the Board has regarding the types of changes that could be directed to new facilities. Because the application for a Site Improvement Plan has already been approved for the Hughes' site, any changes to process would not affect the exploration well near the Estates, but the change would regulate all future facilities. Staff could find no provisions within Florida administrative law or Florida State Statutes that prevents a locality from regulating the appropriate placement and procedures related to new oil wells in the County. Oil &Gas Drilling GMP FLUM DESIGNATION (FLUE) * Urban* Oil extraction and related processing * Conservation Oil extraction and related processing. Where practicable, directional-drilling techniques and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized to minimize impacts to native habitats. Agricultural/Rural Oil extraction and related processing RLSA Oil extraction and related processing RLSA Oil and gas field development and production(CU) RFMUD Receiving Lands Oil extraction and related processing RFMUD Neutral Lands Oil extraction and related processing RFMUD Sending Lands- no Oil and gas exploration. Where practicable, directional-drilling TDR severance techniques and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized to minimize impacts to native habitats. RFMUD Sending Lands- Oil extraction and related processing after TDR severance Estates no allowance * IAMP&GGAMP are silent to oil& gas drilling ** some specific Districts and Subdistricts may not allow the use Staff Recommendations for Collier County 111) Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Wells Oil &Gas Drilling LDC ZONING DISTRICTS A by right-Oil and gas exploration subject to state drilling permits and Collier County SDP. A CU -Oil and gas field development and production subject to state field development permits CU -Oil and gas extraction CON by right-Oil and gas exploration, subject to applicable state drilling permits and Collier County non-environmental SDP review. Directional-drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats, where determined to be practicable.etc.,etc. CON CU -Oil and gas field development and production, subject to federal and state field development permits and Collier County non-environmental SDP review. Directional-drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats,where determined to be practicable. etc., etc. RFMUO Receiving Lands by right-Oil and gas exploration, subject to applicable state and federal drilling permits and Collier County non- environmental SDP review. Directional-drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats,where determined to be practicable. etc., etc. RFMUO Receiving Lands CU -Oil and gas field development and production, subject to state field development permits and Collier County non- environmental SDP review. Directional-drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats,where determined to be practicable. etc., etc. RFMUO Neutral Lands by right-Oil and gas exploration, subject to applicable state and federal drilling permits and Collier County non- environmental SDP review. Directional-drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats,where determined to be practicable. etc.,etc. RFMUO Neutral Lands CU -Oil and gas field development and production, subject to applicable state and federal field development permits and Collier County non-environmental SDP review. Directional- drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats, where determined to be practicable. etc.,etc. Staff Recommendations for Collier County 1 10 Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Wells RFMUO Sending Lands-with or by right-Oil and gas exploration, subject to applicable state without TDR severance and federal drilling permits and Collier County non- environmental SDP review. Directional-drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats,where determined to be practicable. etc., etc. RFMUO Sending Lands-with or CU -Oil and gas field development and production, subject to without TDR severance applicable state and federal field development permits and Collier County non-environmental SDP review. Directional- drilling and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in order to minimize impacts to native habitats,where determined to be practicable. etc.,etc. RLSAO by right-Oil and gas exploration subject to state drilling permits and Collier County SDP. Directional-drilling techniques and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in FSAs and HSAs. etc., etc. RLSAO CU -Oil and gas field development and production subject to state field development permits. Directional-drilling techniques and/or previously cleared or disturbed areas shall be utilized in FSAs and HSAs. etc.,etc. Water Resource and Aquifer Protection Recommendations County staff has performed a cursory review of the proposed permits for UIC permit 22-5, Oil Well 22- 3H and SWDW1354. As best as staff can determine, the proposed permits appear to be issued in compliance with State Rules. However, there could be a variety of enhancements that would provide a better degree of protection to County residents and our water resources. Accordingly, the applicant could consider the following additional protective measures: 1. Require that that all exploratory and production oil and gas wells using a class II injection well follow the Criteria and Standards for Class I Wells outlined in F.A.C. Rule 62-528.400 through 62-528.460 which would include a dual zone monitoring well, continuous injection and annulus pressure monitoring, well specific testing for water quality, establishment of the base of the underground source of drinking water and more stringent well abandonment criteria. (F.A.0 Rule 62-528 allows for an exemption to the class I Injection Well permitting, design, and monitoring standards for oil and gas injection wells. Oil and gas injection wells are permitted through this exemption under 62C-26-62C-30. A dual zone monitoring well is not required for Oil and Gas class II injection wells. Other permitting, design, abandonment and monitoring standards for oil and gas injection wells are not as stringent as similar Class I municipal injection wells permitted in Collier County.) 2. Require secondary containment for all on site hazardous and petroleum products and all hazardous and petroleum wastes to include: Staff Recommendations for Collier County 1 D 1 Ill Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Wells • Petroleum fuel tanks • Non refined crude oil tanks • Hazardous waste • Petroleum contact water • Petroleum piping,fixtures and valves • Hazardous or petroleum greases, lubricants and solvents (Requirement would provide an acceptable industry standard practice to assure aquifer protection.) 3. Require annual site inspections for petroleum production wells and 24 hour notice scheduled inspections during active drilling operations to assure compliance with all secondary containment requirements. (Assures annual compliance with multiple inspections as needed during oil well construction.) 4. Require that all releases to the soil or surface water that contain salt water, drilling muds, industrial wastewater, hazardous and petroleum products or hazardous and petroleum wastes in volumes greater than 50 gallons be reported to the Collier County Pollution Control Section. (Current FDEP spill reporting requirement at oil and gas facilities for volumes greater than 250 gallons. Current County requirements in Wellfield Protection zones require reporting of 50 gallons or more.) 5. Require all systems handling drilling mud fluid and salt water storage be designed to contain any leaks or spills on site. (Provides a greater assurance of pond performance and reduces high level berm failure.) 6. Require all oil and gas exploration and production wells to submit a basic surficial aquifer groundwater monitoring plan per FDEP Rule 62-520.600 with a minimum of three wells (background, intermediate and compliance) with a semiannual sampling cycle for industry related indicator parameters. Further require a dual zone monitoring well to detect fluid movement. (Provides early detection of any impacts to groundwater and assure site compliance with State water quality standards.) 7. Require continuous hydrogen sulfide (H2S) monitors at the site perimeter similar to what is currently installed at all five of the County utility facilities (landfill, sewer & water treatment facilities). Establish a perimeter H2S compliance standard of 1 ppm for oil and gas exploration and production wells that are in close proximity or adjacent to other developments to control offensive H2S odors. (May already be an early warning safety requirement.) 8. Require facilities to create and maintain a spill prevention plan that takes into account releases or spills smaller than 50 gallons. (Requirement would provide an acceptable industry standard practice to assure aquifer protection.) 9. Request a protocol from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection and the South Florida Water Management District that copies Collier County with all application packages for future oil and gas exploration, production and class II injection wells. This could also include invitations to pre application meetings and any other permit related correspondence, additional submittals or meetings. Staff Recommendations for Collier County 1 1 D Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Wells (This helps to assure the County has ample time and understanding of upcoming oil and gas wells and their proposed locations). 10. Request that the Florida Department of Environmental Protect reestablish the Big Cypress Swamp Advisory Committee to review and recommend construction design standards for future oil and gas exploration, production and injection wells.The committee could be comprised of oil industry, State regulatory, Collier County and local citizen and provide an independent assessment of well design standards to assure environmental protection.Some topics of review could consist of: • Well casing thickness and material • Formation cement performance testing requirements • Pretreatment requirements for other waste streams directed into injection well • Site tests to establish the bottom of the Underground Source of Drinking Water (USDW) and identification of formation confining units supported by core samples. • Well logging requirements • Mechanical Integrity testing requirements • Requirement of a dual zone monitoring well to detect fluid movement (Provides reasonable assurance that design standards, construction materials, and geophysical testing applied to other similar industry wells are evaluated for use in oil and gas exploration,production and injection wells. This is established under F.A.C. Rule 62-377.42) _ N � n ' 1 D o, -0 K = o- � OCD IC) CD 73 N o., N _ H -' y 01 N A a 0) O• -1 CDD O vOi M.. 0 co 0 al '-r fD 0 0 W rr O N ,N,f N N �. -I O � 0 a Q - 0 O N rr 0 (D▪ N < _. 0'00 r0'f < C !39 O m m of vpi u, < a in m m 3 v+ 0 rr C m o Q m -h 0. 0 : 3 rn o 3 m ,-+ m m m 0:-;v � n •-+ CD a0 rD-4, c CD f `< E CL n m 011 rl•Cu 3 = n v' d 0 n m -1+ a G) n -a '* rD Cu 0 7" -, r a_ o Q ° 3 a m o O o rD w c - < ? m - ci, v j 0 n (D fD o_ 0 n '' m ,•.' < (D v' fD m CU• (<D o q ca m _° = 0 fp = < ° r' o < m f D o n Q n0 "' o `� m Q- = in v 7 °•° c •o = m o 5. T7 • m N m C 0 vs (D "a m y 7 07 (D 3 r+ G) D Q (D C N O 'r p S S .0 p n Q o n, j N O 0 Poi (D_*. O 000 (D .-. N c 7 V) 7 n 0 m 3 m 0 ° o o g a _' 3 a. o_ o CL — n r: m 41 A'� d _ �o N C' O S v' O (D m [D d4 N a) m o 00 N w N• ,„ fD p (D 0 n p *. m rD rt. 3 m N R. n' '� CL . n CU...5 d m a0 CD m St o- rf ,',/' VI ,..4,2:F K (D 01 p o -n '0-r m (D N m O (D ,z O n' CD '� _ v, `^ u) 5 O (vD = m Doi CD v of O D n -0 (�D m 'a N v -a O n 713 O 'O O H m ,-r 0. (D• n -0 0• o. 'Nr W n o) O4 v' ,dr 0 `t v 1:1) g EMI rt. O ` Q 0 i° m a O v '* v ' m 7 0 0_ o n =' C rD ' o _ o = m n ...... o_ • ,,rD N -, o' -, p 'a ,-r v 7.1: 0 ..< N Z 3 < 0 .< (D (D (D p co 0 y' C m o n y' N 0 (1)i t^ 3 v y O N N " a (D of m 3 0 C j o Q - o ' N v O GO C < ni a y C o v_, = oa 0 0 Q H O ° s=r ,N-r 0 co CV N CD '�• N S O N (D o. 0 CD o_ 0 -p r. -s to D * -s an n O n v' C - n ro n D co zo "CS us v N d 0 -a LA (D a O O N O 3 O C ii' CU H ° Q „G n' P O 0 N o�' o C N a '� ,0* ,Nr Q C D o O `^ nai 5. 0a 0 m 0)3 < Poi ' en °'a na. m Q a° o a- rt nr o Z m o D o ° °' fl" o CU 3 > = o ( a St a c ° . M v 00 s Do - o a a C H Q fD (p v' - -s O O' — N I ■ rt m O ''F CO of O °' 0. 0) N DJ 1--) a. CN 0 v, s c'D a� 0, u a a) , D °�- 3 d n > .• O F). cm ° m -1 v CD — as co 3 a co .< p p n n cD C a• C a .s �, m e• m 0 in a, m. m 3 ti 7, °- N a r�D m -Z '* � m 3 n m O co O n ail n * K -s — am = a- 3 N (D '+ .v n 0- 0 v' * cn -a n a, 0- n 0 0 c m m C a, 4 _ o m � C a, a- -a v O ,-r -a 3 n s a, - O s O 3 _. CD rD C D s a m y ar a3i N c�D `^ N N n' cni -. r�r fD O rr fD . O v < cna a) m• C a. ,a-r O A H' 7 3 "a rDD m O chic m ? -a K a" O_ f�D cpic 0 rD 0 03! (-D -0 O ani [D xr FE, ) Q. O O 3 N a --n 3 ai c^ fD m cn' a, -. O fD n•a = -. s a, 3 m rt v `n• m (Dm. . 3 p. m D m o < ' c n� -a Q 3 aaa al d m Cr ? a°a m 'O^ 3 m 0 o 0 0 a, 3 `" 0 n -, n m tD C n m m 3 C H m :^ a m 0 - - fD O �' a O x a; O am ..< ,-r 0 = O '* m C CCD r, fD -, < fD Q O N fD z p 7 o a P• ° o 00 m x °1 a' D a) O N 0 v N ° Ov N O 'a m < a< - . a, 3 I ✓ 3 O CD lD„ -a O D H H Ill(D I CL CS 7-, + - O -tim m o O0 < m °' m < m 3 0, d ”' n 3 x, c mn � m, a- 7+ "0 C - D 3 CD 0) m m s— cu 3 3 12, m m N % c cm '+ a E. cm, o •< v n d' s aaa 0 '••. n Q a, a' cn ,a+ —h a¢, (D frD 'G m m .< _,, o O , z CL v, o V m -s 3 O r• 70 a, T N 0 O •O ", N V1 73 fD O �' A n H O� a. a, <. a a) N OL, a tD O M 'p (D N O N fD •••— �, O O G1 D 2, m 0 3 ,* s = aa, co . 0 fD -• x ..< . 7 O n O a 3• 0 m a� d m r. s v cm _ O n a. c" 0 * a' n CYQ c? N 3 CD m. -0 a O C '< rD' m 0 (D (mp a S C C ,may 7 . N r+ Q H CD p �, •Q o N• O co 0. .0 I - -0 m. a) 't 0 N 0i O• C -. -, a, ' . . .9 3 .7 g a as x 0) N 07 NJ a ,... 0 A * 110 -. 7 O 3 Q Q N co D (D p O 0, co CD (D V, fD -h m v N p O c 3 v -.s = fD -I's o fD •t -' m (D '< 3 • < Q VI rt < m v) C 3 C, Cl fD V' 'a O' iU fD 0 k = rt QQ v O 3 (/' rt oo o °o D oo o m s o o as o 0 (D n " — ,--« 3 as o Fa cn c cn ro., r* „ n o- -a -h m m 0 3 = 3 c Cu n v, -, m ,-+ O _c. c Q, fD fo -s ( -, 3 C, 3 E. c O r° fD N p O -, v ,DD N m y v, t) N rt �CD C et 0 fD fD N O O fD , 7 cu N fD * DU -• r* N v 3 O -0^ 0. Q, OtQ f , O v1 ND T fT' N fD n' 0 Q � •t 0 S < - N T fD = N -• 0 N = O LA 0 3 3 0 Q O fD D m N• N 0 7 rM O C! — < C,1 p. j =f' lD V'Ct. r�„ 3 O - fD O, N < 0 Q- cu Q in C `co r a t CCD 0 (D (D rt _- N O O 5 = fD O Q N _n < Q N O rte,. 3 3 �3• N fD m fD = 0• Q. V' {mA 3 N ri• CU 01 0 O v O n , = d n 3 Q fD 3 -* (D o fD _ -a n - -n 0 n n fD 0.•< Q. ,°t a, v s c O < = < = c °' m N• rt rD O rD o' O O vOi `-" v CD 0) 0) fD rD a n: cr . -6 4 < v 3 s r, f-D 2 o. c - s < a) co to N co -, fD n N o , N °° [D fD = fD < 9 ry or/ O O O < Q p fD v 0 -a fD Q 7 O fD `"-Y Q, ° fD Cu 3 -1 c 0o v, O rD * O o :^ 7 N a ,-�'� Q ?! 3 H G to 3 n C co � po �• n, < fD Q 0.v n Fl 5' rD o o m ..< -0 to v ,,, r* 0 — v+ O o m RI ao -s o W 3 O O Q, O -0 rD-� fD n, RI v Q, rat ah rD S n, O CPI al. O' n A n f D .-4- n N el• E f Uq n, rr d4 = N N m Q- 7 fD N m S - CD 'a co K D G ,•' O o c O CO C ,. c m D . a -• D -, fD N fD ,-I. 's fD Q, o o O rt n ? S O C 0 fD C, O =. N - N O o - C, c Q S o h fD ri, 0.= "O C fD cm OS ,- w D N • rt n C, Q O_ f S 3 .-1. --- .-cro( c � -, Q� Oo -< Z ,a O N (1) p 73 < " a •-1- 0) rt fD o n n: 3 v o. o. c n fD f' o m oa fD m o rt LS a -, � n c, Z H F °: ° o, m C, ° 3 rt = • cn O n - j fD V) o Q rf-.' fl- Q (D 17 n v' = 70 O , 01 :. O Q V) C Q• N A- O O. C'•r Q - -1 Yl• < •O 3 r 2 O fD - rr a N 0 -a O• CD OQ rt co N fi,t CD Q) co Q) W Q. VI 0‘) lt co4:1 1 D 0 C ° _ N O N v N 3N a N 74 -h i O a _ N fD , ° f•f. 3 fD fD O co C o fD m n• fD . -1 3 o. -' s? 0 �- -< ° 0 aa)• fD 3 a0 a S fD 0 -s A -h a = O =t1 fD ,..r Cl. y fD ; m C n" '+ ao a in O fD fD S fD fD T oO. a ° D 'O fD 3 72, N 7 ni Ufl a N n 074 N N z- ,-I. fD O f ,< Q -< a - " ONc Cr" 7 -0 `,r a fD O O � N C O Cr 3 3 N QfD "( " rN Q ) rr .v CU T a0 N T r) a) S a) • CU - Q r) S fD * 7 T 00 _. a) 3 .< < 0 a) ° O o rn 0 -< v) o 0 ° (eD N a) a s ,-h 3 Q o N fD F.; .< A -0 0 a _+ -. ,M 3 fl. (OD N "- M o 3 O0 as N * 0' O faD 3 Om a o 3 c- iv oa fD fD 0.)o -. 7' O. 0 a v) n '.O^ o an) 3 ' o p °: 3 f-D (OD n 3. -, 0 o ,,. a a) d s - N o a N a) fD C S D N O- o < a) N C 0 (D < a)ri. ° G S N N 3 CD NI N N 0 �,' fD f7 ,-r C a fD 7 N c -a C O v, f1 a) o (Cn N H X rr N Q O. B (�D N -, a) c -) N N 3 G) 13 0 ET N < ,n-r rD fD o O fD O O 3 a '' N c O-r 7 p 3 a4 T 0 ri. 3 7• ao s ) ,N-r N O� a—* chi, v am. '� - A fD O N O• O O O N C fD O ° N 3 -). C N fD a — f7 rr N 0 N fD a) NI �• O '' ° N S fD N N ...4 H N )-M a) a) m 0 ''* f') O- v+ ''* cu T a) a Q O r d O N n ,N-r Q d CA < (�D O Q fD 0 N fD fD -0 N H a) �• 0 o Q C fD m o Nrt -.; L o) C > I 3 a0 O �• 0 7 CL ,)•r a0 ° n < K ,-r 0 a0 fD r) fl- -0 Q' fD re fl. fO a n 'C O fD fD O fD t/) O 0, fD C cu 0 �_ rf Q 0 - O 0• e-r O N N d C a0 N Q N fD O O O n N 0 7C Q CD DJ N Q C a) v 3 N Om N p 0 O 3 a) !n N N 3 rD fD v • - C ,-r = _, v N a c m a) fD c _ M fD fD!n -4 3 aai a Q• i3- f7D -0 fD Cl. ffD -• O. - a00 CU. 7 '< v)• O 00 co ,.r fp :^ f) = co -, 3 fD CD O fD v O 1 a a) 0 0- 0 vii ° rT c 3 o r+ n CDD N Cl- aoo `�^ H p N 3 ru _ a- N -h v o ° * fD - =. T O 0 Q O Om a � C- a) a0 O I. O. �n O- - a4 -, N 'O r) p 3 S C 0. -1 ' G) is 7 a) DM o N v 0 ' H -+, N T• a c° � a4 ,...m--' <n 00 m 307 fD S G -a O _ax Dm rD o in 'Y 3 o O Q-3 D O * ,a C ' fD a O -t T � m n co o n a O N * O 3 O Om ". O 0 O < f " N fy: o °f 7 v a N ' 3 f 0 -PO <c a) 0 a N '4 o , N N cu N " N aCfD 0 0 -1 d O a -' a) fD C O C CO C C- ni f Ov -0 fD � 4) v `j O N fD (n vi O O CD < N d Q- a �, D O r N ,-r sr-D v D ..< D -. 0 N Q v a ,-r O- a fD H C a a0 3 a fD CL iii 3 h O fD C a -2. to fD (D rr ,-r f"D ,=r a) a) a) fD 0. ° N fD a a0 CCDD O �. a 00 ° f'f' M- ,M •< 0 O a) -° 0_ Q- N N Q' o N fD O S Q_ 3 fD c a ° VI 3 0 a) N 13 a) O - N C = 0 e' 0- .. flak 3 fs = a) N a) a 110 ag CD 3 CD co N D,- r.. • rt 0 CD m ,rt 0r = 0 N c o, co v s n m co 73 CD F.O c CU M m -p �' 4 0 in rD cr , 0 m 5_ m 3 3 N < 3, 0, 00 01:1 O „F 3 r+ o d 0 3 r, 0, N -I 0 (n 'p "O Q i-� O 3 n o c * r, c . 3 . 3- ? 3' ,.,,-1 o 0 , 00 n v 3 3- 3 3 („ 3 c a m ° m D 2. 3 Fi' -0 v Cr m oO1a 3 C. °c = m m 72 N. rC ° - v (e -r rD ", .4 v, n 3 = - a) a t0 c Q lO m , O O n N Q ..< e) S d w 3 r-D -a rDD 0 F-' Cr ~' 3 Q• 3 -I r3•r O7 o cu 3 o'a a s - a 3 O O _,, ' n ° ro v, G) o o s D co 3 ,rt rap) m m n 3' v c 3 A cu rD m 3 Fg r+ _,' = m• 3 3 3 r+ y '< O Q' o (^ O ,n ,n a O Ft N m m H O Q m LA O m CD < ( (CD m O m rD ° 1 Q in S v' v '� m CL 3• n • ''* O� d r r p O 3 O 3 3 S. °� n K < m 3 c 3 0 al �+ 3 ° rCD - ( -" 3 �' o 0- M .� x 3' -" m D a) V, 3 N 01 0) -i 01 'a Q 0) N FP 0 v m V+ • K 3' m • g 3 O c m .4. •G O. 0 -• .< r�D a ON rD °" (^ "• 3- C 3' 3. S O Q rp' N n m y 3 ,� -a fro ,•+ cn y Oi m alp o • 3 C n v m O 3 ;• v c : rr,' o < a 2 I G Q O� m 0 v . rD N C 00 3 C w - O O) H rm3, O O O LA rt o' a) ,rt 3 C 3' Al Cr rCD C) c 3' m r3D -< j ;' °- 3 3 3 (D v -< � 0 4 3 'a m 3 (n 3 n, (n r+ " 1 0 3 O O -0 0 0, v 3 m m QrD O, 3 Q O �• m Q c O N 0q '*O m - 0 n . n y 5 3 3 0 < Q °- H v d rr a, H m �, m en 3 m— o q m .< c m v o 3- m e fl. 3 O fl. v, .-1. 'O <7,' C V -‘. '. > m -O * ro • 11, ,N•' (M E m c v, 3 rD a * 0 �, 0, * 00 O m gp c g 13 0 i A- c 6 rD -o 9 o rD n, n�i fl'. as -' ° -a fl v fm 'a o go, 3 0 O 3 rC v,' 5 O _3 .nT (D '0 3 n9i - m O 7' 3 O c 3 ,-,. '< 0, 1 O 2 O 3• rD v 0- < 3 S N a 7 <• 3 - -0 a o0 M 3 - rD W °- ,°.'• 7 rD N. N (2C CD C CD w .- .. 0 m C -1 3 O f D C cm 3 = m 0) =' = rD o r, W („ o cN, ;Y i '* o n m c ° °' ,� a o0 m = °' 3 C 3 (D o c m o, m rr 3 rD Q n, c a-, 3 v p ,N* p 2 v ,n N j Q C O a. a) v,' O Q m m A d n 3 0 3 N 3 0 Q• c 3 Q (D to 7r m < Q. Q °. O Q O Q. N CD D Q O' c-3' = to rp rD -, N .a E H �5 W 0, O n S p ,•* ..= D 0 O ^':N LA FL),. _ -a -o 71. a C - 0 0~, Q O =• DJ X = 7717 I •1 = O K Is tv 2 m N D) a. cri oo CD v v O v v -, '* v+ * = ne D el < DJ xi cn � v) m s m m y D .,4 • 0) ,o ° -a c n -tea m Z _ ,,, CU m a c m m c m Q n O m v, _ v = co 514 3 v - n' o ,n* o") vm) Q m o c Q_ ("D Q 7 N v W O N o '* a A a) m S (mD • v) v' = a- S m X 3 c N < z_ C ti' m m �'Ill 70. n 0 m rD fp .< O N 0 m m (ND O /-* v+ v "O N m c No c 7' c O .. = 3 ° m s 0° °�' a •- ° m ,c 3 = o, Q oN c °- ov -0 m 0 *3 = S gir-L) = � 0— p 3 5 m 'a m S ° = < 3 O n 3 (D F O D S O O 00 (0 Q "a Q fND (�D N (D O v+ N 3 O 0) -I Q 0) 0) n• r) -I 3 K rt N' (ED (-3 (D to _• N Q- o Q <_ O N Q m — 0 v a O n v VI O U0 v — = O 00 A fl- v+, v) y O (o -na ca. a 0 a) m n m O- N m n' O' N -1 7 f3D I � N = c S C 5 v v m C - v,, ''* 3 f0 As m. 00 VI v) rt ri r .-r m 3 ,� •< v N n) N -h 21 co (D 3 O p a fD o .a O -1 v) 3 . C N C' C ((DD C - m 0 41 5 (D v rr a) O a n rr N Q '+ v, 3• O m D a=i v, 3 N et O D) 0) r, W "a n m m ,-• , 0) (D ' O_ n 0 .- o- r n ". 0) m DJ 3 7 a) "a m O_ 0) Q (D -0 O' 0) A 0- O. 3 0A) 3 H G) — D 0 y,.' D) 0 c E. 7+ 3 a 0 '� �' -°a Q n om) oo 74 3 (D Q v " O 3 ,t a n N m (,D O °+ a c j c O a (rD O j •c o (�D = ° '*: �; 3 - C 3 E_ o m c ° o - - .° n ° Q C 3 m• a ' c am •< o O o fl o P °° ° a � n— n N (D m � fD� a O a s o (D m (Dm rt m °) m o °)• �_ n a v a Q g d °a co s 5 .=-I. vii O rr N C N ,..r 0 O 0 0. N "6 n C (0 S Q- y, ut Q O m-s fD (D m m m m (D 8 0) (1 (� E (0�) 0) T (0 0) P c o 3 3 < c < m c ( n ,,,,-0 H O 3 -a �• 3 -* co cD O, c fD ° m (7 3 ^ v) o n) °am O m noo -S Q a d z m Q 7 (D n m — m vm ' v) O C = O O (D C O' :-r to 7 n r (0D m n' O y a C 0" O o �, — 3 * vt •m 3 a ° - a 0 co vu v+ m N D) Cr O1 O D) C O -, v Z r Cu 3 O C . C ' a' r D) (p (D r a I a) N 0) EL 01 W 8D11D N t' O 4t0 0 (D 3 C m O0 (rD Ort -0 n 0 S O v D O O < a) N 00 (D r+ H r) < (rD c < ,,,, c �f D„ 0 3 . o ��Dn 3 O c c, n CD Di co 3 < a ((DD c CU o - rt m o n' 0_ m o 0 N O 0 S C N O N -7 O D ' O N o 3 �` (D •� -, 0) (D to (D O n = 7 w 3 (D' o (D •D fD -) 0 n) o O a Q r2 c 00 �. (D .. rn+ to 'fir n n C H, C rt. 0 O' a. o ? O (D o ( -„ C (D -n 3 rf c n • O c c ,� O = -' m 0 3 0 O te o v G O N(D r+ 0" to fD S • r+ Q to 3 (D O ( n0 .<< (o 3 B v _ a a m` � a ft, (13< 2 O (D Ls.,3 y �• C _ N O) to t = < A. n N -' (n '* •,.) O ' O (D aN 3 (D 0a o o •< -I (D C y (D ti) o Q o f to O a en 3 n (D 0 � f7D n N -ti N /1) 04 3 — N " Cr 0- n N O cu -i 0 a a' T (D CT "0 m O c N c -„ (D 3 O O r O n c 0" (D 0 CD LA to 7 �+ S n -a in a Cl a 0 'Q) A (�D �, H O �G < m v_ o N 0" to � m S v o =• 0 _• N Cu 0 e m N C G 0) 0 3 Q D o Q N n o fl- = O = 3 r+ (D cr (D a 3 N (D cn O (� 3 ,+ -_') a (D n) (D (D n o (D O O r+ '< N to 0) O 0 F fop 'O)r rrt* Q a �' O (D s c r+ 3 m n) d v N o 7" a m -. v n 0 r~ = 3 Dta f'^D • o c On K ((0 - CD -O N 0 O N -° 3 (A o 4/ • 3 r+ O 0) (D c c _? 3 twit - a 'i a r3r Q = m ° m to r+ r (D 0) O 3 N rr wo O (D o m m 3 3 °) - O m o '+ 0" v O D N '* cD 0 �• C H VI a) (D a O n (D . N rr+ n I-r GI to 3 7 CD v EU MI m 3 c Cr C m D o m 0 * v o co ono m y a A •_«' `(CD '0-r A N DO '0 O < N rD -5 tn. O N O -) m to • of O 0'q v (D CD v r+ a °) f7 c rf °) �' r+ 3 A Et w• G. 3 rh. 7 ,, v 3 CL: a cu n c ,°'+. 3' (U°D o C 'rt•+ '< O = o < 3 ° a a N N uta 0 fD = 7 O n s' C ea. 3 3 's c CD 3 -, 0- G ° 3 0 ,G H < p � C+ to 3 cu a y N (D 7" o S 3 C O 3 3 0 o •0 (D (D c _+; a 0 .-p o (D 0 - N' O CPI '* a 5 •■ !n a N N fD a -0 * ? v' fD 0q O '} = 3 (D O o' 5 v' to O to l�D K CL CS -. O a CD w o =,•, o Q ° Q ° D Q) 0 ° Cu n G 7 73 o -0 o C 3 ° v't 0. m c' (D a - C '+ 3 ° 0 3 3 CD '* o O " n• -° 3 -, o n m m p wm, p o 3 3 FEI• - o n 7 7 n n) " 0 n -n, (D a 0q Z a ° IV to m a o (I 3 0. �, rt co m 0 °" y 3 (D c o t0 it O to o to r<4. 7 Q 'rt-r O N Ort 3 in'r to • '+ N 12 C1 O N N 0O O O N O O O O • DJ O .4 G) O 0) - -I C) - a a a t -• t _ t _ i - t v m m g C CU N C) a 9" Ui 071 i1D -I n '* rD 3 5 13 ; g n 0 `^ = 'r = 01 0 ° NO DJ CD •` 0 -• N -f r� cr N h n C '..r 01 0 '*. <. d 0 O N• '+ r� ,* O c CO Vi 0 r. n `' ,rt ,rt -� co rD O S '•! 0- v S 0. V A CD O -I O rD es- rp rD d 3 0 t) 0 r�D S N fD fll 3 O rD rNj (D O� N 01 (D C -1+ M a < .1 m 0) r+ OA — rr d 1 ‘,„2 D ••< 0 y, cn p1 s 71 „Mt. rp 00, � O O- O6" o rD ,n-r '"h r7 0 O cm � o n a' = rfD c - * 7 f O i K - Do 0 cu 3 00 Q N H TI 0 O� 0 '° ° c -1 ,. fD � o rD c <, o rD = O< z 0 7 -O'+, O (1 a rr 00 r)' O q 0 a 0 y Q 7 N Q rr 0 rr O aU , 3 A 1 0 '•F = N Q DI n Q O < O W rt ° Orc1 CD 3 -I 0 . rp . a N `< 0m < co O n o N rnp ,� ? < all E. 0C1 N O 001 N rD O 0) r?. N T .i O� S O N -0 c fD �G D CL° O• O ° a) �' N fl) N rD, y rD .a n G<l ' a S y -, rZ v Q _ v+ CD N 0 Cr O v Q < < m. ci 3 3 ,°1„ v H A 3 ° o s a)i m ° c v°o v, '^ rr ro d 0 < G1 el. _, 3 0,) 3 = rD rp c m 5 0 01 (D 3 A °+. 0 3 v rp rip 3 0 � 3 3 Q ° o 2+ m 3 3. c 0 N -1-, -„ i q CO 0 m D o) � v 0) O < rp v+ a 3' -r i h v 0 O O 3' G7 , fl. UQ O N H' n c rop a O N rD N 0 C 0 -0 6 ,, ? v n O 0 vN-i• 01 CD 0 cn O O * �+ Q v+ O c n O o o Er: = Q — _p. s o r) 3 - ° r) co C m 3 v,, Q = 10 c_ r-'p rD 0.. y '"! ,� Q.. O (,D 0 3 c. n < .0-r 0 0 O rD < a 3 O C O C -) n N cn re 01 N O 3 0 ° N O O (Dm. �' �A H 0-0 ma O n _t y, in -0 0- n 0 co a 0 0 = o 0) N ' 0 c rD O< 0 rte'. Z O < v O CO .•*s vi Q A- Q O '< r) — fD o Cr 7 co 7 N o O CT rip N A y 71 rD Q. t. 0. 0 G. H rD S Cl. S N N N S 7 • (D (D rD 76 1".•3 O 40i D n (7D M C S 4 c 0 N =' ,. C 3• o< co rD < o 3 CD 0) '< 7 ' O 'a m 3 °' Q ri 3 f3) 0 n rD j r+ oa c ri a rD Q O2. v 3' 01 n o v f D 0) ro a. v+ ? P. N o = m ro x13 x 10 10 1 12 5 c» 7 DJ N O o N O 0 N O m O O =. N 01 O N DJ O• N 01 (-p 0• < = ' < — 1 < = m .7 2IV O z x 01 , r 07 „Z 0- O O ' 0 ' _ ' 0) gy a cD 3 m r cD r y 3 r m 3 O n' cr' 2 m 3 -I -I 00 O. e E m 0 c D .c 0 0 3 k fD \ \ c 0 o c -' F m n§ Ri cu o « _ 0 c 0 0) / 3' en 0 0 7 ) � E CD o . fp eL 7 - = % 3 EEm ' . « 2 . j 0 Fel ® } _ a) n £ E 0 7 C 7 < 0 7 0 0 7 0 E / 0 2 - $ 3- e u, ] m § 3 c ] v, _ C a r n _, n c c ) \ / k \ m / / 7 / _ c- . J f O. CD � _ = X E / CD - 04 0 / ° ® � \ CD - 0 7 C n = m % \ R E 0_ — c . ] CD vi o ) 0 = 0 n ( ® 0 c- / U e m O / / c 2 - 2 $ g 2 E - E n % o § c E + § ¢ 2 ) a) f G 2 K \ - IL _. V/ 0 V/ ° \ > CU 5 \ 3 \ on ° q 0 7 ] / D 0) o ] — 1 0 CL ƒ 9 / Q§ 0 = 0 < / 7 7 $ a, 0 fp v) - V g 2 - E / = \ F. \ / 2 — c $ / % \ a 2 .< a) 0 J 7 v, E 0) 0 ■ 0 = a, eL o e, 2 / 0 n c 3 - Wi n ] ° n c CD 7 ƒ ƒ CD £ cu ° - f 0 0 / CD Z 0 CI a o - - CL= 7" - = -• E a) f in e c (/) m w \ % 3 ,-1. « I � I 0 N C § k ,Z Ia co r" a g 2 I OJ a up w o = o x z a 3 a ol m n 3r- I '° 3 rn rn 'fl ncnn p 2 > 3 n -< v,� rr' m rn 0 z 3D � 3 rn m /"� ° C ~ -mien rt w n r rn 3rm m Z° m 3 ° o � -r v M n o � CO � 0 a z r a rn � z m m a o oTo G' 171 m � z � m "a zrrr' c O m a v N rnDO rt 2 rn rn � rn � . i rn m O m ( zz 5 A m "� v 3 mxD70 ft \ �rnw o m -I GI z i -t ---� rn rn di z 2 O m "� v xi 3 ..� Hrn zn I 0 m HG) 3 Z � Dz 1��1 3 ° rn � z D -1 = � � P \ r I O O � zm X m rte, C_ mi Z --I * z z a m rncco oo i-- - ci A m Oo m m 0 n W t'� � cn _,, m m 3 rnzW �•• a w mW °w -P w 70 D V rn CO v t ,..., Ln rn C ACD� D '� '� m 3 rn � w \�,, rn 4 m O < rn v - r z � n � H = � z r -CI Oa3 Tt) m z < m r° _\• .< O rnz -1 3 ,� °-n . u m O� > 0 °› -� ° u z a v o ,. v m v 5 C 0 O v c()Dc0 rn v 0 O 0 no n ° o �� .. a Dc0 m Z O -iz n -I � � f3 rn6) i, n n z co m m co corns _1 3 rn� z , CO -Zj o ' = \ 3 to ° o O 2 X 171 03 CO 2to o z 3 -Ip 3 o Q, al 0 v z � - ' - -1 CL n a ° Q ° �y �D o a xi � 3z ° i�' a v z � � ° m = 3 m moo ° `; H a � 3z o -0 D. O zHs) �, 1xi rP O m Nrn ° cep ` :� ° � D ,_a c� 'v 0 °z �O � �' M m O 0 rn l,� Lay 1O v rn D,. c CD ° xm`O , xi 7o n0X " 2 O pzrn A., m O � om0 rn m 2 m G� (n Y:, n -I 'J 0 Cn r n a 'a �T C > H -I D. = Z ° zr�n n W 2 -.? --I FA 3 rn -I 2 71D � .-1 rn - co� ` (I) rn rn V N > 0p 03 -ni = 71XDD O To o m =pi OT CO !-,\ 'G N > pr0 t O 7p O CO a z 7v m CD m °c "'i _ 73 M ■ 1 iii 'v ncnn 0 1 0 m a G) m 3 D 0r a m m /1 3r. r 3 m m /1 A r- r- 3 m A ,_.., 3 r at m Z 4 m 3rrn c► m Z H m .� �- rn p N A -< v' oo m O Z A O c(i) RI ap a Z rm 3 C oT0 '* A rn 3 C o " o el =t v rn O v -a •a 7, c 7 m > � rnz 3 RI > m m 7rn ' 3 m rn N � zp M � 0 m m N gc o CT 1 v 3 rnDx r��,' it m v 3 rnD0 rt ► m ni p m � '-' z m 0 m ( '-' z = m 0 12 3 v -1m> 3 v rn � D ' 0 0 ,...'s- z m ITO q 1-1 0 0..� = � � O Z -I 2 _, _< O Z m r N 2 m • 2 I r N m = W o I ^ = o° °w a w rn W W n a w n r W n - N W u nc1 w r r z w "' SAD R1 z 7AD R1 m Z D > m T D w -I C 0 � Z m 0 3 < rn p -I m0 rn � � 5 m rnmm m p p^ oo G — `/ m p Dz � o `/ 2 > z � ub v O v a c ° r- 0 7°o v c ° po 70 Dcx rn (n Dc m .•. ( A H0 m A �„� G � � � A p Hzz �, Z Hzz =. -1 3 rn� z = 3 rn� n mm co 3 m Z co 3 0 w0 O � Zo ,�M,. a a -° � rt lV 7a0 > 3 � 0 = 70 2 3 � o co p r ul Cm 73 > c3z O G a c > O 1< 0 70 m1 ° 0 0 'ran r7.11 rt 0 rn rn c� .. vi rn c� n ......• I.,.' 3 -1 D ° o H 3 -1 D ° o n . 0 z -1 2 j0 rim -p 0 Z - O f'i' ° o n) a al CD 7o a /� I-i N LC l V F.I N �C v �' v 70D -p C O rnD p 3 70 C2 C2 m n °° - Ei 3 -- 70 n0xi -, o p o ��O it o ( 0 n� cn -•1 cn cn � z / •a 2 0 ° zrn M m 2 ° zrn cD C < D --1 --1 �• C ,< > _ _ �. W - m m mpOD A m rn0D / o -I A zDr- ..I A zDrr r m I 71 7� 2 to W r cn Co N ° Or C N N p CO O 2 •p Z eW -n oo 'G 2 0TA Go 2 °c -w-I co m Z � a. zcn �. c v 0 310 ,a > m m 0100 � a GI m iv m mom m m Z n 3� m c� m 2 �. -< („ ; to v -< N to v 2 o FE a , O cn / a 1•11 O C m n rt w G7 O C 0 rn n a O TO 72 rnrnz to r-ter" a "0 > rn � z (� m -I >tn -m-I r � z � '� m -m1 r �' z N m m 1-+ - O O = = rn m N G) 0 = --1 rn m �3i 23 � o C m C} .0 m W rn v rn � z .. • n f; -- & 75 "0 70zn H 0O 7zrn 1■1 O O m .. 0 \ Z -' D z CJ r m m H000p0 `�� /—�1 m m = moo �V l l w a .. rnww a �• rnoo v r el 00 ., n ,� u, 017 m � G) D rn m 3 rn G) rr 1 m 1- z C D D C r Z D I I XI m C 0 D �l O O C z G m p C z rn = � O '� Hp m rn m rn m 7o p^ 0Go a `� m m O, W a `'� v p > z � C v -< > z -< a C 000 m '' a C ° r0 rn U) 0 -Dio0 n -Dios (� n --I 0 z .Z.' 3 rn z n Z 3 rnoz )1 n m Z O -C-IN J c3D m Z 0cN c3D M UM o U � Oc) 'o-�. CD O U - z -°A PP: CD o v > 3 --1 0 1C ,= XI > 3 -I o tC 73 > c O I D C3z O >-e--- - �' O m � rn � ` ;� p m WI 0 c=D A :: 0 z -I 99 :1 7o p 3 0 z -I 0 °o �` r n 70 !H-P N v D -- c v D E.O rn .� .ET 3 73 xi o x, rn 0 xi O S O u) a 0 v it O O N v, .a rn _ w 0 z rn A C -rG D -i -I En 1 -1 -1 = 3WD W �m ' l * ta = 3 A m rn p D 0 m rn p D O A \ 1 illp RI = rn > 0 0 g 0 2 p 7103 z 70 -91 69 4 1a = of m CH co M zv) a z � Q.LC a X 4 0 o rt , n'v n0 = no CCD a GG) m onDOn m 3 � � �° 3 �" m n 3rr 3 m m eN n .< u, W m v z n .< �, m 0 m v H O c � Tn rt r O a � Tn = a Z 3 > zoo �, v rn 3 a zoc = t ri v rn r-,., z 1.e m a r � z � 3' m (n -m-1 r f) rn � 3 m m CA v 3 x > x et 1' r rn v .5 rny73 71 1 r (�, rn m G� 0 o O m (\ m ..1 GI O m .1\ o 73 0 (73 I-1 94 j 73 m -IzD c=D 3 _1 rn '_' n .. C 1 Xi 3 rn n - 73 O 0 z rn H o o j° z rn 1■1 Z -1 * Dz Z -.1 � Dz 2 = _ O _ = _ ,- O C n 2 a rnoo , n a rn °° ( n Oro I- ~ w % 1 ��j � � W m 3 � � D V rn m 3 X � D _ � rn rn Z T. Dcn V m Z � Dcn "V OP-1 -C-1 0g3 -C�I o m < rn X m < rn m so ^ co 0 `� m -4 D^ QJ 0 `� a o ° p o p 0 0 ° n o v a C r ni n 0 A N n -i 0 0 A O H z rn O z cn 2 3 rnzz n. -1 3 m. z tD r. O Vf xz5 , rt CD o 0 7° zp rt fD ° • a > ° o 41 0 > 3 � o V m Z 3 � o raj Ip cz c C � z s O -I o fD 0)-1 1 o 3 3 M M M �\ 114 -1 D o o n H D -p O z -i o x r' ' 1-1 O z -1 v 73 r* N a °O % fD xa °O N CD{Q�Q v p D N c v 70 D 4, c 0.-1 m o7, rn -I m � ,°� rn % y.� 0 0 o (0 U) 1 0 0 (/ U) = 0 ° zrn cD = O ° zrn CD r � � � ► n m � � � n C -< A --1 --1 ai a ,< > _ _ A ai O0 --I-I n > • co -i rn D rn m au. rn --I la = ran -{ n-I = � oD � `" -n-I = -zID � X" 2 61 o -WG f7 OTC m l' '\) = -I C -I C� � = n a z `" a a zV' a m m 0 rt 0 rt /7 r#3/ n = n x z > 3 n 3 1 0 '�Da� 3 m m /1 O O 0 3 m G) m /a m 3 r rn (D m Z N 3 -< c~n CI m Nr m z C (f) F79 rt N 0 r 3 c 6 M e r -~I 0 rn 'ry rn OXzz m r' 3 > 13 73 MI a ZOc m rn m H m m rn c�i) rn Z 1.12 v 3 rn m M _ 0O c. rn m '� Z O ea v 3 rn D 0 rr r v 3 rnD � r; m F rn p m rA ~ z = m ! m G rn n ~ z 0 0/�` m X v -IC) z �l XI 3 rn � z n - C�' x O O niZrn Fy .4 n _' I•14 2 _ ADZ z z = * zo p o cs W Z = = _ I- ° -I -< . 0 .> m m HI O o /� m 70 -IOo G, T \ rnW � l ) .. rnmo •0 G CI r " nw � z W c r 70 n IT1 n p g rn rn z 7� D cn \, m Z � D � w5 j > 4 m 093 C -I 0 D O (n --� z m O < m r m m rn 0 I Orn rn ,� Z0 m X O co^ 0 O CU (11 `, DZ `/ _ E. a u v 0 XZ 0 v -< > Z � °v a C DC � rn z N � 0 � n t u) n -Dio0 m �-. z 3 = ZD g 1-1 0 Z 3 rnyz n m m co co 3 La = m co corn fD > CO -I > H \ r, fD M 0 (1) � zp m Z pCN cD � O 2 ZOO rt X z 3 -I 0 (p > 0 ° 0o U 0 0 zr- `n Cu o v z � "' -a 0 73 H3z ° a 71 > c3z O Q' O m � rn � :: 3 -I ADo :: '3v p oo \ooi t g fir .o 0 zOo x ri• C > 7O D`� _ ,�., > ry ' `• 73 v frn) O p rn0�p T ..I m � � rn 72 m � � rn -� 0 o �� 4* ch 0 �� N cn 41: m Z 0zr�rt n m � zrnm r..<t D -I -I Z C = rn r a () CU 3 C -G D -I -I a 0 * Ca 'I 11 l' V n m0D O m 3 -I n Dr m O > O _ --1 � to�n 0 CIA N ° O = C1 Z 0 71 OD Z 7o OTW 1 f = n ~ rn cc � C r0 m � � fD m a T) v rt. X -C rr I 1^ V 3D0 m > rn m /'\ m -< 3rrn y m G 13 G p .5. mn � . a r C ° O m rnrnz m 4 3 m N � � p rn T 3 rn � 0 _rt m xi D --I-I D xi 3 -1 rn ,._, n p O � zm H -1 x � � o — Z m ♦m rn � _ n W �.. n ,., w r co 6-)- rn 1-1 x M z r(�� C OCrn ) 73 0 _ � 0 m p 0_- a v v � z < °. Ill C D c x m (A n Ho � n O � zz to -1 3 rn9) z c co - ° -C10 v ‘12 O 0 ozo O v z 3 � ° O > c 3 D 0 1< 0. 0 m mH0 S s. � N � 3 -1 DDo - 0 z --1 0 1 a pOV — I FDP 3 O cn o �� --1 v) v, ,_, A -a o m 0 0zrn CD r -mv � � n co -I T D ro m zpD O "1 2 -1Drr- M E- W a 03 = i..� p O S. Z 70 O W I.. a O Cr) C C Z v' a - v C 'fl o = 0 f7°D z a 3 'v ncnn zr- r 3 Z �` n zD0 'a CD a rn m /1 m ,� m C ,.., 'Q m -< ,rr- m t m ZO m ,_, rn O � rn a n 0 O00On rt a G1 0 C Wn rt al F-Ny 3 a zoc 0 rn 3 a z00 v rn mrn � ,� z d 3 -a-I 'v rn � z m a rn � rn � m (n -mI r ,c�nrr, � 3 m (/� � � O rt q rn m N FO a <_ rn D 3 x > xi _*, r- r 0 3 7iD7o r m -a m6) ° o V m m `♦ � � ° o f m O m z 3 O m z z --.._. O 0 xi Drn O 1E4 O 0 Uzm — ` Fowl Z = O '� Z rnWw 0 lY vv m m iO °o - ,v —I a W � , E t o a ,, rWW n m 3 7° � D W m m 3 i-i mG) M -1 C 0g3 m Z TD ›17 Xil m m rnrno m0 W = � 0 ) r = O Wcnp = O co � prn m n^ oo !\ `/ m p O W ra a r D O � n -� p ` D '< 7° n 1- 1 0 0. a c ° r ° X a °c 0 � 0 70 � n -Dl o 0 U) `" A (I) n -DI 0 0 (I) .. 0 .� z cn -( O – ' ' o) n .i 3 rn� z n� Z 3 rnFz �. .. n al a 3 m m ix 6•1'� \ ` 3 (Q rn m DJ N 3 W -I p 1./V h W --1 D H " fD mt LID 73 z ,_, (� m = m z z -1 0 to p -Clzz = : Di G > czz O Cii 0 ill m10 fD 7o rn � 0 cnrn0N fD ... 1.1 O m rnN (D 0 o-H W x rt w 0 z-I • • 7 rt N �° > �D O p m0, (il c ai 3 O 0 mD - I c 70 7, 0 0 m y.� 70 7o n 070 "e_1 m 3 O U) 0 m 0 Z W 4* 0 cn o m`0 rr = 0 � ~ r f�D = 0 0270 'Q 0zrn fD m m� G� cn n m Z rn � � n C 1 D -I --1 (� D --I --I �. m m � � � 2 �-IrnD i rn x. Iii - 0 0 3 m a 0 r W O W -Z T Mt 0 n z n� W = O -< CU m zc" o, a zv) a v 4 o CD 010 a rn 0100 cD > 0 m n 3Dr 3 m m n 3rr ? 3 m m .v m .< r rn m m Z -'-r m -< r rA r i t m 0 O O En cc' = K- > a r 0 O -, rnn p a Gam) r c o „ o c o „ o = ITI a z2c m C m a z0c .' m 0 m m 7rnz co\ 3 rn m m 7' rnz c\- -1 m -I r- 'v -I r- " m rn C 3 rnD ° -�,:,' ) -I m C 3 rn D ° E ' 117 C -1 MG) ,--, O m -n -1 6-) G) o R rn 0 3 0 -I G, n gi C � Giz �,-I n z 7 H z I• I Z = � zo - ) "3 (�' 2 2 _ 1zo i4 Z mm ,- ry �" �' ) rn m s r r" / t Emol = COo0O N -IOC a w rn � � n a w rn � o n co � n ,...,, cn c.,, r- r- CO rzw Va I r- rzw m 2 � D � nil m - � yvDi m 023 --I C 0 3 '� O -I z O -1 z -n rrnn p U .n rn1-1p 2 O ocnp 2 O ocnp a m F Dz � 0 s rn '< Dz � 0 \./ a C prn- O 72 n C 0rn- O 73 ch n D c 0 rn ^ n D c 0 m ^ ,.., O � oz En n ,,,, O -I oz n �' 2 =s -I 3 m� z n -I 3 rn� z A n 2 m Con rD 2 m Coon z O0 -I D --I r" 3 p0 -I > -"I N �! to 0 n o � U� to �O > 0041 c� CD p = lit p2 3r_ corr 0 p 2 3Ocon cfl O > c > 0 c .-i O > c3 > 0 r 4 CL imi itt cu 15 0 z -I 9 f" 7o rli 'v 0 z -I °o .. i �° > p I 2-1 CD xi p O N al O 0 X > _p I = O 0 70 > , '� _ CD 70 C n p\ V ' ai 3 72 p n o fli m�° opm o � � - O U) 0U)73 m y.� 0 (A p (rn A /) v� �'F -I cn .a -I cn .a 2 0 0zrn CD 2 0 pzrn c�n. c '< > _ _ �' c '< > _ _ ,\ °' m 2 3rn � ) m RI m CO 2 3rn � (�,co -1 n zDr o _./ -' n z > p O-, \ 2 : 7, r 7� 2 -lxi r 7C + CU �a.4 p0 Z m 1 o0 [? p OTC [? OT -WG 'a m o � ov 00 2 0 � p0 C rt C " V n cn n ODO CD 3 0 m /1 3D � 'a a > m eiN 3 -0 m m A 3 � ,r� m 3 m A p ( vow 8 m y Z r A O c�i� rn � m a Z 3 ~ rnn G) 0 c .-.. Tn _r A r py a z A O � m p rn a rn Oz m a rn r- m mmz to g 3 r":: m � rn � 3 -I m iri `J 20 m U. H m () rn F � n0 rt q m p 3 � Ox A —I p 3 rnDo ,-r rn O 3 rnnz ? �� X 3 -I � 5n '' mm O O , zm �i co 1.x.1 O O Drn 11� . 2 < > 2 <,� .� Z z -, z z T . z S m m -I 0b 0) 77J W m m -IOo Imml y w rn , w -) (_! n a w rn . W n co n ,,, ,n 0 ? r `'' 1- z w L F.rn V" rn N 7OD N 7o � D 2 D (I) 0 m r. Z D (f) �1 m- C O D - 9 O a 3 O T rn D �' I— rn -n rn 2 � r rn 70 0 ° �- XI o co r� a G u v 0 ° � o V "'C a p 7 O ° n0 `� C r o r- ' A -D-IC5 ° U' �! ^ N A Ho ° `9 ( A m Z 3 = zD ` Z 3 = � D n. z 3 rn� z J n -I 3 m, z � � = m CO n = m co 0o n im (q cD m 03 -I 0c-Im -` . c3D W -4 DH NO 0 M (Q I:, N 0z5-p. g.fD CD 0 a 0 () U' , ` J CD 0 D 3 � ° ∎ 0 z z � � \r) o a c > 0O v' 4 CL o > c3z 0 rn � ° �- ID 0 m m � ° Z tf1� m 3 m `nrn �, cD ?''S. 3 -I v' oO ^I ) rim 0 z 0 o0 iv\ H . 0 z -1 0 rim 'v CD > pOK �' m > °oN > � . O 0 XD -p ?t) c 0 p rnp-r' c 73 O U 73 n A (�1 0 0 ,p ( 1 (T cn ° m tD m Z zrn r� �. n. (D n.La _ 11 rn D r' 1 CO _ E MI -D-I J (1)3 cc,PI) m 30D `^) O T A m rnOD ) O Co >. N ° r- Z M Co 1 0 O O 5 71 O co 0 O CO "TI CO G7 n � J C, n � 'a = O (7) - W m O cn C H c c o 70 x. z cn a a a to = fD 0 m v OD rt I -0 0 = 0 7 z > 3 - ncnn _ A Dr a m m 0 = 0 CD a > m 3rr- ter-+ 3 Z -mi ma n 3r � z z m m `-I m v `"� m '-'` rn v p C � Tn rt G) AO O c�n00n _ a G � rn r° zrn -o t° m a RI > z ° o-I m 1 a -m�i r z "� `-� "1 m in m v m -G - -1 rn V m m N 0 _r -I w , z o rt 1 w -n 3 � GI ° o m _ r17 v 3 moo o ti rn D 0 p c" ZI = O TO O m ujzz = 3 rrn :? O 1 v -I G� z ,-mss, O O XZn ZK op 1 3 '� xzn m z --1 * zz X11 i ~ z -1 * Dz r Z -1 = t < O ?° Z = z O r = 70 = rN r` ' = 70 = � • ►� �� m m -I Oo m rn m -IOo -1 = WO �' m = WO I n a w m co w A —I ,3 m W L, • r- 1-1- zw n r aao n .4 � 0 r W rn -i ai O 9 3 U (' -n C -1 D D 0 m C rr (� -1 m O ran �., X IP Fs p , m m m 0 F 'n -n = � zp 0 oomm z' '� O oocrnnp m a = 0 0 � � � °v u v o >z � aaa u 5 C r- 2 7v 5 C o n o n � � p m a ,-. Dc71 m ^ z 0 Hzz to 0. N 0 -IOZ m n .i 3 rn� z 2 n z 3 = � D n 2 n > -1 3 rn, Z cp M -1 > c► o W -zi ° moo r 3 CD N (p 0 a p 0 5 _r l D p cn Z p 1 rt /1� = a a O CD v 0 3 r Ln N -I C 0 0 3 r � C 73 x.0 z � 0 70 -1 6 = .-±-. I- 0 1 a 3 O Doc, rt 0 -1 ,-1 ° o � :.°. zHc' m ("-`1 .p 0 z -1 °o r H rim v 0oN CD ( 73 > °ON m CD O 73 v m p∎ (A 3 C W DO� C B -1 m ,-,r1 20rn �� porn �)' 0 cn X rn r0 tt 0 m 7v m�O +� -1 o � CC Z �'F � 0 cn C I �'F m z m � cmii "0 m Z ozrn U -�IrnD pCp -I m m mOD o �m m CO 3 i� _ H70F W m" n -z-1oD IA m - pro 64 �m N 0 O 1� _ Z 72 0W 0 '1. al 0w V GI n -< Q, 11 CO s m 00 TA C :•= Ov C 0 Fr (� rt 1 0 / 0 = 0 m D > m 'o n = n 2 > 3 n 31- rr- 3 m m 3D °r -0 > re m m -< !_' m m p N m 3 1-- c� m Z ..1 ma A 0 Cr) CD O tri a Z r n r761 cys C Z r 3 C ° 00 =* p GI 0 C OHO �; a 0 rn m > ( rnz m 3 --I-� v x rnmz m C Z _al �>w cn Z -p • m (in m m cn r, 'v �' m V� 0 3 7v > � A r- M m Fri ;' ) 0 ro_r n m ,.., rn � p 5. n m C Z XD 70 rr n r rn 3 0 rn . n 73 73 0 -1 C) - \ � z (� 3 � z ►� Z = * zz° ^^' � Z z � Dz Z m rn _ a •` pp0 o m = moo Q n W rn ,D Li) 4 l ) r. rn o w m 3 rn6D Jp rn m Z rzw rn m Z 7CDcn (r. ;- r N � D � rn O < m C 3 - I Oa ( 73 ,O (r) m m _, < rn , rn Q a, r = o a m rn � O co m � -I X co rnrn= Dm G � `S m `/ a m r D C rn C x Z 3 = D c4 2 0 „� z z V) 0 n. -I 3 r"� z 11 cD -I 3 r=n� z (D n 0 (� Xzo° fD CO "I > H a > ° O5 .1 = 0 cn � zo _r CD h = = t o a p0 � ° C z --I O \ cQ �0 Z 3 -I O \ m = rnmp O p a O —I Drn o .' i1 O m F,- n ° rn � , Ti C. %I ry .� (� Q 0 z -10 is" 3 -I Dpo H • 0 pON ��' C'fl a oO ° CD L O p m 0. 1 C 3 - O C x D � c p cmn 73 rn�0 n C� m Oxrn r• U ° O n m Z rnm � n zrn Gol m m 3co -D1 * . y = �Olr=nH p rn H kil � IS - '� _ .—zjDr ey A A z ° r G7 a r- u, W = 71 x r N O � O m N ° O _0 Z - OT co ti 'v Z ,wp O CO G1 n � n -< n oV) LI a. m ZV)tri C o CD X UM c 0 °0�1 rt. /. / ncnn 3 �° 0 = 0 m z > 3 o = o z a a m /'\ D r a rn rn /1 D � '0 3 m m A 3rr 3 2 z r '-' m m z �-� wiri A -C N W ul m n z r A O c�'r� °0 �' M a Z r 0 v)3 C .6 _n - N rn 3 C OTO A rn -I 0 a zoc v m , mrnz .. 3 m , '- m � mz . ■' 3 -a -I -1 r cn m 'I 'I r- ;' z m m N O rt rn G7 0 rn rn D ° - m m rn A m r. 0 m G) 1--1 0 — ma O m 6-) G) = 3 0 rn � z ' 3 0 ,(7.), 11 0 0 � Dz n ' Z z ADZ 7 - c ~ 7z, z-I = , o -I = 1 o �o pO Z—I m m HOo m m -IOo - w ..1 ^ril rn co O n w rn W ° n W u 0 - W W r ~ w '�" m 3 rn z` nil m 3 m , rn 70 r C --IDD m C -ADD m [[�� ((�� -I Oaz -I Oaz m < rn m cn z 11 _ Wes ° a _ xi O^ ° a o -c �z � 0 --F= ° o 0z0 ° a C ° r m C D C X m I. A -DI 0 0 A A H ° '"�--^cn n -I 3 rn , z n -I 3 m z n m z o CO m m m CO CO m 0o -I D -I 1 a to co •_rn 73> .. a) up O �' _?g -I =�; �D a a ° o ° a) CD O 0 zGtn -1 0 O 0 zr � X > c3z O �' o a � 3z o �. 3 -I v' oo `� F.y 3 -1 Fill :� xi a ° O ' tC i�-i O 00 XD°� C 700 0 nD �, y _1 m no , ', -1 m 0 � m -e 0 rn 0 �� � 4* �O rn o �'C _1* -1 �' = O X 'C 'hip rn Z ozrn rn z rnzrn n to r- G7 Cy) _ of en "I rnD '4 . `W -i --IIrrnn > �J La X -� = -i _Ill ©-CI 2 z D -I A Z D r- O ��. -� -1 1-I- = 7C 1rn N � � Z m a 05 0 rn W C7 pi OC N = CO rn W C 4 m v co fp 7 , " I -a ncnn 73 z > 3 '° 0 = 0 z > 3 O = O m > G) m n Dr > O m n 3r- ~ 3 m ^� n 3 � ~ z n 0 (�j m 0 Z �' n .< (N!) v� m m > Z 3 C OOO rt v rn O C OT0O : -i 0 r a z c 3 a zOc m 0 m m vvv)) m -< 1 3 m m m vr) rmn 3 m m rrr ' z o -��i-,1 rn m ~ 7 o Lit " \ _1 III 0 3 x > r* r 0 3 rn D 0 rt r O m G) ~' z 0 m el 17 m0 m ~ zz = m IV 3 0 rn � z -- (d 3 rn � z '` �� O 0 � zrn 9) �"� 0 0 � zm ■ H z -1 * Dz ,' ) Z z -I � Dz m m = 0c• r - � = 03o a mom (;' l ] > w m � u., \ CI W ~ w 1 " Gr0 " rnzw r rn m 1.4 � D (D/) I"' 1.4 � D � rn O = < rn �. r O = z = O co o 2 O co m a u m O.. a 0 O on � o 0 O ono 00 `/ a C D c m - C D c m N n -Io0 w A M 0 --I - � cn n z 3 = zD -I' z 3 = zD -t 3 m� z n -, 3 m � z n = m sown �' c� = m vowrn,, m co -zj D -1rg a 2 m LO GO -•1 DcIN a 0 � z °o rD 0 Xz °o rt CD pz 3O ° m 0 p � O (n i 0 z _ � -i C. 70 a cz ,› ° o 3z ° a DI xi y cD w O m ,,,-1 r� rn - Z CU ° O m - 3 -1 > 0 3 -I D ° NO �p 0 z -I o 'v 0 z -I oV p rim re rim?° > p O N � . (e �° a °K) N (D CD ii)O m D -p E. - O p m 3 xi 73 nom 3 xi 73 nix , m O , m . -e -I m O m O � Xr r° 0 ( p �� -I (n (n 1--1 .a `�.�. -I U) i- .a X Z m [ M rn Z ° zrn �`�,, cD faiC - 6 -< D -I - Li = 3mH �, W � m -Dj C 111 m Li m m W c A- ,.. N ° p = M m ° 0 =cn Z 70 O W 32 Z 70 'tea C) n -‹ GI n -< CH z c -I m C a m c a v) a c 0 0 rP / .v 0 = 0 CD Z 6) m .° O = � z a 3 A 3r- 3 z ,mi n A 3Dr 'a > m m /'� rn .� �� rn rn p m Zorn (D rn Z N O C � Tn N O O � rnn a C) r m rn - z 0 go 3 > Ts — OrnmOz m a III, ,rnl r � rn � 'fl m rn m mrn � --I m m �-1 � cO m N '� � O �'' 3 rn � 0 _t m rn p N � Dp r rn 3 0 rn — n • 3 'r4 n rn — z Xma I -I = - Z z = � DO Z 73 = z r-, m rnWw 1 '� '�►. m = Woo a w 1 ` a rnWW ... nzw D r— co n � W r r r 2. m 3 m 6-) rn m 3 rn 6 �' 1-1 x 1-1 70 rn C ADD cn ` > m C —IDD �- o m O < z 70 m o < rn N 70 rn m rn N ° r OO ( rn o r m -< D2vo � m -< D2 � p a 0 O 73 n0 p ° O 73 n -� p a C r2 73 a C ° r0 70 " p _1oz � n Ao moo -� - z z n' z = z ..I 3 m� z 0- -i 3 m � z n_ M m CO 3 m m co con IP O rn ta a o - •s °a s ° o -? et z � H -:I Q. D z V`. ,a c3D ° a a c � z ° .o �INNI EU ° Z ::3 M cnMo M 0 rn � v Ii I D o • 3 -I D ° o n 'v 0 o ° co c-7-N •p 0 ZHC) �o > CD o N p m0 0 mDO , O 0-. D 75 X Ox V,_ , m n ° m z O m , rn (1) rn�O 7:1 2 O ° rn it) 2 O ° zrn L f:17 cD m Z rn n rn G) cn ( m C . D -1 —I U) -r1 D —I --I �,-4"-- 1 03 m m zcoH * � 2 3rn � \ rn D O m m rn oo Luk) A O A O D A z r -s 71Dr-- X. ` A zXr ' ‘-'' 2 r�n I 2 :�r M 04 a O 1.4 73 O oo N O 0 CO Zm 0 'a Z 70 rn co 'C 2 O vi . - Go 2 O v) Q Go a zN C m z � a 7 c p p rt p r, rt f is- s. -v ncn z > 3 ■ n 7o �° oso z >61 m 3 0100 'a x GI m n A 3 � � 3 m m /'� r r -e 3 m 3 r rn cD m �„� z '� ,� '� -<A �W � m y G r C � rnn r � rnn O C O -n O =* -~1 v 3 x z00c 3 m v ITI 73 rn ° z In 6 3 I- m xrnz iii 3 m m m � rn � m (n .mI m vrn � C r M (n _ 'v -I z CD �-- �..�1-4 0 3 rye rte- rn p rn � 0 rt a. C ...1 rn m ~ z = m (� O m G) 1--1 o EDI 7vz3 -a r773zrn -' z O ► � N O l � Z z z = = F< 0 `' �_ Z= O i m m o m m '6 �• m - 011 + = o C n W _ o a w rn W� Y r n rzw ° Irrii Go .. ncn r rn � r Z 7SD ( m z TD t rri C --I D 73- m 0i- 0 m _, < z 1 V O vi z r „ = � 0 �, r -n m rn � p m0 rn rnrn -I 0 co GI p `/ m 70 O, p ii x `� � z � 0 0 O 00n0 ° a\ m cxn C DCo EA f m 0 � oz 0; m n -1 0 _1 o z cn L, z = z n 3 = � D 3 m � z k .i 3 rn- z CA = m CO w n m m = m co co / 3 m z 0Crn UQ 3 (Q CO -I DH18 V ' CDD 0 - > ZO m �. rrr �! Vf 0 z 4 • = 0 -P - C > > 3 -I0 `_ x 2 3Oo W ,P 5' rrimm 0 z � 0 0 c > O it, O � C{ 3 z Di o 7x0 --I -I 00 = v" CD O m m r p :i O m cnrnN M AP' . `� 3 -I Dpo =•` 1_i Fig� 0 z -I ° ► X r'i" - x poo (D rim ii 3 m 0 -I m 0 , m 0 cmn � rn�0 C/1 70 m co - v) v) 7o c�°D = O 0 '— RCD I pzrn n m � GIcn V -�ti m r. D -I -I r J -< > __1 _, „7, C ,,,,I x 2 = u = -�-I rn D .- z -I m m rn W D r 0 n n z 0 . O -I n 11P A- _ H � r vii CO X 0 co x pr o ITI 1-1 m 7p O � - Z OW 'G z -n 03 GI n -‹ Ui I7 n -< W I 0 cn co 1 0 _ C --I = G rt 0 �;. r* //' 0 CO 'a o = no Z 3 A 010 II 3 m m owN on IS 3Dr -a 3 rn m n rn �� rn y m 0 �'�,, 'Q� m zF ii m z 7 AO O � rnn = a g r �. 3 C OOp '= 0 rn rnrnz 1, 3 D > I\ "0 > rnrnz IQ �a j3 r In � z � 1-1 "0 rn m I-1 G� p rt. (J rn .� p C rn O 3 rn D0 r_r m p rn � zZ a m X 0 --I G) D -ae O 73 O m v, zz a 3 -I m'--' n 3 0 rn � z p O 70zrn [::- to 1'44. O O Pa zrn ' ,: H z * zz -� Z z -, � Dz s'':' Z = X _ � ° F< --� = � O r n W ., fl a w '- w 00 .� (� � w r • m w x �D rn� r rn �� m TDB r Z (Dv) \ v�1 � �-I O � 3 ‘,..1, C Oa3 't a O m = < z 0 O-� ` z �. o r ° r' d rn rn �rn m 70 0.. rn a `,� CO O co if1)1 m D^ oo 0 O pnp 0 a C on0 m . U) n Hot 70 m t � 0 (A n O A Z 3 = D `:fin Z 3 = � D \ n = m no 03 a ••� 3 rn. z cD m Z O c hi 3 (Q m pi W -1 D --Im a y � O °A = XI Z 3H ° cfl 7v Z 3 -I 6 a um = 0 a C 3 D p .< ' 70 a C3z p �' C m N � � M-a tii O rn o a cu 3 O zoo - M.! O m .. 1 3 -1 > oo H p0 � a 11 -a O z -1oV C\. 7 e • ~ o 70 D c �, a °P N - m CD O rn W 0 7� D ..0. c nom - 0 � � rn 0 m per`, cn it p m 7, m y.• _1 v) cn 'o -I v) � � . m Z � zrn O ozrn n • U) D -I -1 of rn -rC D -I -I W -< -7-1 rn D ---_ rn m 300 -1 * � -I n 71 Dr rn 1 -1 n zDr" m ~ m oo S ul 1•4 OW 'a m ° a0 Z Tp CZ 70 O W 'a 0 ril 1:13 rn I o � a � c a C el' 1 v rp 1 // / A.° 0 = 0 c�D y GI m 'o n = n 72 z > 3 Dr 3 m m n 0 = 00 -a > m m _31- '-' M m z n 3r_ m z -1 n '< cn ° Z m "< ' in v, v Z r 3 C 000 g. -I p rn O C 0T0 = ~-I p rn 74 mmz m "A ' 3 -al '° > m !TAz u2 3 M m cn m -i _1 m V) m m \ m V -I N cnz C ni v 3 � � � 2 nil m r 'J � O rt O ~ z ! „ rn v ~I g1ao G p` m V ) 0 m z z rt 3 ° rn � z 72 v � 0z 1') X 0 O � ZZrnn G 1� 70zrnn r �A H s = z .< -° n 0 c - 1 _, = � ._ P N —� m m -IOo (4 m pa -lb ,) Q n m Cry r.2 CO v r) � o G -S r > _< o . -I I 03 z. '� r► r w rn m - rn m z � D � lb > r z 7� DN 1. � �}} 0 O 3 m O C rn cti �' = � o r' O cn inzz r g' co [-in) a C. D C > 0 mil- m -< Dz � '- v v a C Dcxi 'r m 0 C ° E0 e- (I) n --I 0 0 �' cn vai n v 0 o m z 0 = zD u' - 0 -Izz '11 v� -1 3 m. Z c� —I 3 rn� z z n rn = m CO Con Z CO 0c "1 d 3 m 0crn 0 3 0 � Zo rt can 7oz °p cD CD �o z 3 -I6 = � a � 3D o ��' � ° ° z � � C -� � O m rn � o Z C a) O � � o Z M DI cnrnN C 1 ..� 0 m Fri cD N •• 3 -I > °o H 3 -1 > 0 o n . �, H �° 0 off " cD 'v 0 op ° � V r > N [D > N C m p p mo? a __ 0 0 rn0- __ O of 0 cn c cn 1* O U o A �� = o v) v) 70 77) -0 - 0 tn cn cn '-' ''nn ,�� -a � GZjcrni� r° m Z rrn � j V` n 702 = U D --I -I 0 ( f PI C m 3vrno � C u = 3rn =D-I r __... n G0 = 71 xr , n ZDr Sc m ITI I-1 a o 70 %� (A O „!� a o (q 0 C) n -< GI n ti 0 ov) a- Q- m oc�n (f a z i ID 0 w 0 � I cn n 3 n 310 'a 3 m m n 3DO .a 3 m m m -( �rrnm m C '�' I m 3r � m � ma rn Z 3 C O -np 0 rn O � � rnn a 61 m m m M ;°, z 10 a 3 ->-1 3 > � 0cO r v m --1 F rn -1 m v 3 rnD ° rt ■r m v 3 > ° '* ■ R1 O m u, ' D = m T m � zz = m O m O � zrn H 3 0 � zn " I k Z � zz h �` Z o O Drn `) H z = z -co -7 -1 z -�� � o 1 \. 2 IT! m zW °o ICI m iii -IOo '� y m rnW F�l + -1 rnc ° el W .. � zw CO n � � 1'TI G) R1 z. (� I. Z ' > ( �' > i.4 73 > D d J cc�� "i z � D > C 0 (T1 m OGrn C�i 0g3 .1 = � o O ti) -I 1z m p� � G \� 7p O � � a fN \� D '< > :< v m .< D^ o° /� v N. C/ a C Dc2 rn D C er_ oO e �. th A --I O ca n t n D KJ 0 \ ( n O z cn ,,,, --1 o , 2 3 rnFz n Z 3 = zD i n� = m WCO n -I 3 rn� z n 00 -Z-I Dom ^' ai m Z co 3 o ° zo rt CD o > I a tin 72 D s moo > > o O _p= 5 2 D D ii .� O m rn o g r� CDD p > c1 3 z k �. 3 -1 D m CD -4 " H 0 m (rn„ rn ° CDD Q : 'o n0 = n0 7 z > 3 -a ncnn n 3 � � �a > rn m /', 3DO > m m /", rn ,< N rr, m 0 N '� m 3!- rn m z w I tri A C � Tn 3 r- AO � co n = y c) m O Mt 'ry rn OrnOz is 3 -lI > > rnXIo m '� .... a m m xi m m m 3 m CA m I- `Jzp rt m w � z � m m 3 x° 00 rr �� rn c) 0 r -I rn ,,,,� rn D r 0 3 D x = r m -1 G) ~ . p m ," � n � 0 m �. .v 1 O m rA zz a 'CP 0 m ( zz a 0 3 0 rn � z :. \ -. 73 D rn0Z -as t 73 O 0 7o zrn c. ��-1 0 0 Xzrn -',� CO 1 1 � _ quo c( Z ? _ -< o � � aN Z = 70 = rry ( c 0 '� = m = r iv 4 C 0 m m HOo ba m m HOo m = WO _ /� el -I 000 n � cn �' l ) a w rnW � cc- p `,.! m 3 " �W m 3 rn � w Ir rn r - x > v rn Z1 -9-I 0 � 3 m z D � Xi -n r=n N o rn 0 -1 0 X x Om ° -, › 0 . 5.,. ,s, v) . › .... v o � n -� o o o 73 D m ...., m C pry 7� �. C pro [1 DCp (1 m to DC � m .� 5 O --I oz CI 1-1 0 , 0 0 CA n z N ' 2 z n' -I 3 rn � z n -I 3 rnPz m z 0 c m 3 m Z � c rn '� 3 00 -I D o M pp ...1 DHNo fD 0 0 pzo "C\ O cA Xzp M CD Pa z z � o to '� 73 > z � o tO p > cz > O ..4 C' > ezD O ^, O m crnno � :: Fy O m � rnK, ` � 3 0 z -loo .. 71 3 0 Dp °o :: > op " n M a z°PN T---) M O 0 m0 -p _ 0 MDp,m-I m porn C 70 m pox 3 0 cn o v�0 4 U) o V�0 -I m Z mGj � S n m Z � � N n C -rG D -I -I l \ c --G D -I --1 �� Li 2 -1Ir=nD '� W '4 -1IrnD M m mOD P O0 �/ m �2 rn °0 > CO H xr Q _ 7, Dr to �J m 1 p0 V' 0 CO a or _' N O Z �0 O CO .a Z 70 O W ea m Oc -I c m Oc --I-I c a z v' a, a z cn a m - m 0 rt 0 r+ ■ -a o = o m Z a 3 n 3I- 1 -° 3 m m /1 m 3rrn m m p N n O v) 1 fD a Z GI C 6 m n0 rt w 3 > z0c =' -I ° rn Ti - xirnz �\ 3 m ern . rn v 3 > � + I rn O m G") 1-1 = m 10 70 ° ---I (zD 3 Xi -1 rn1" n X Z Z 0 � o 1 z m rn -I O -M �► y a ^ n1 co w n W Wi n � e.,, 1* Imm m 3 � � > \� Fill m Z T D O -In' 73 'n = m-- xi 0„ k x:. p.. .... ?2i c 0 m ^ n � � Vf ►.. n Z Ell 0 3 = cz) D o, ' -i 3 rn- z i N. M = m W W n 0 Ea m 2gzco Il► \ CD O =z .` t v � CL p > -ci3D O L .- z 3 -m-I `nmo c) `� H 0 zH9 73 rl• o a ° ON to fD O G rn 00- a7 3 -I m x m N O O 4* '.� o w .a = O czrrrt cD rn Z mG-) � n c ,< > _ _ �. m cn m 3rH --I = z5 � i Oo a I Z Z p OT 'a 0 Ci) n -< \ = O (7) co r" zv a a O Pp 3D r- 12 > m m n n 3 r '-' cp m Z mcp m W ; C a z r o oC � Tn �) 111 3 > zoo = n re a � �" j° rnz 3 m m• 3 x n ° at c� R1 rn N g1 0 0 C ~ rn 0 13 o m vjzz = 1 3 o -I n z n -r -I mzm 3 ? � 1�1 Z -I * D z 1?-1 -`� Z 2 � O n m m I co C) N el > ., mWw r 1- w uJ 111 m rn , r Z XD � C 3 Xi -I OC O rn � z m -n ° mS c., = 0 co r(1)1 --1 a N `/ v > z � C °v M• c ° moo �o C A Z 1-4 o --� z -' 3 = 6, D _ n -I m z CO Ul 3 -� N - CD U2 ° -Q X) > z ° 0 to = O 0 ' ' L- u'i ci- o rn � o s 0 ra o rn m CD .' 0 zo ° 1 as ii■i r* -0 3 73 a ° N 1p 7o m � 7°°vrn W ° `C H•L (!1 I 'C m Z rnzrn n G� tn - -c) al C W -I -II r=n > Li I 3 oo —I n-1 n z > r Sco >i -I 1- 7C m > ° 0 0 Z mmW I O rii a co m viD eV_ 0 = 0 m a 3 _ 010 2 cai m n D r 2 m N r m al m 2 N 15 n -< w ( m v Z 0 co HTn c a f"' 0 c 0a0 r.rn 3 Op0 l-+ M 3 p0 -I 0 > z a z c m m mmz to m > > m m ( m '� - 3 m -I r � z � v m (n -I r , z m � m o 3 rnyX rt rn v N mD0 - rn m m , oz = m p m nzz = Az-m o 73 0 � 0 � r� v -�I � D 54 X o z -I 0 _ Drn ^^ \ �`� FNI 0 0 < Drn c; ~ 2 _ � � 1` 2 2 = = -< 0 `,-5 2 mq m m r N m m 0 6 m --� 0 o m --I O o Wrnw ° I �1 n a ^ mw � rn 3 rnzw \ Tim F rnzw r■ -1 c HcD� D w ) rn z � D � 0 m o a m tt J % -m-1 m O rn Xi 'n = z 0 = " z r 2 T w rn &11) GI \ -I 0 w rn (12) M �� h1 1.:<13 `� r-1 w v -( D 0 .� D v a c on v ° o 0pO co 70 a C r 7v 73 cn n -Dino cros tn n -Dion u --I 3 r=nc) z N 0 el -1 3 rn� z = n co = n _ C Xio 0 -z-I D -cm m Z at 3 3 00 -I D -I �► tD tel oa x08 ro a ° o -- = mD 2 3 -I �p rxl z 3 � 0 to .= v z F1 = v 0 z c a c1z o \ -+ C x a c3D o - .0 D DJ o m Nrn0 . ■ . O m rnrn o S 3 1 Doo `� 3 'i D ° o F�1 'v 0 zHo H v 0 zHIo Xi a o,p " 73 rim > o o --1-- c� (tit o v � DNp '� �D " v XD � _ (D 3 -I m O � rn .� m O , m Fri r0 o V) 7' rnA 2 O � c�n � N 1 Vf -I � � � s. cA it 0zrn C m 0 ozrn c�n C F v G) cn n rn v G) cn n -< D --I -I a� c > = = 1 Li = 3rn -DI W = 3rn _1 �` m w 1 -T -n-I n zp � o n zOI fi- ° ° c \ - ° o O z o � Z T w 12 c) o o U�N 1 c a � m a 0. 0 xi v' � °� w