Loading...
AHAC Agenda 10/07/2013 Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Agenda October 7 , 2013 FIL.iD n43 COLLIER COUNTY AFFOW6- AS" EHHOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE 2013 OCT -8 PM 12: 25 CLERK OF COURTS RY D� AGENDA Board of County Commission Chambers Collier County Government Center 3299 Tamiami Trail East, 3rd Floor Naples, Florida 34112 October 7, 2013 3:00 PM COMMITTEE MEMBERS Steve Hruby, AHAC Chairman Christian Davis, AHAC Vice- Chairman John Cowan, AHAC Committee Member Alan Hamisch, AHAC Committee Member Mark Strain, AHAC Committee Member Raymond Cabral, AHAC Committee Member Patricia Fortune, AHAC Committee Member Clyde C. Quinby, AHAC Committee Member Gerald Murphy, AHAC Committee Member Albert Batista, AHAC Committee Alternate COLLIER COUNTY STAFF Kim Grant, Director, Housing, Human and Veteran Services Elly Soto McKuen, Operations Analyst Priscilla Doria, SHIP Grant Coordinator NOTICE: ALL PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK ON ANY AGENDA ITEM MUST REGISTER PRIOR TO SPEAKING. ALL REGISTERED SPEAKERS WILL RECEIVE UP TO THREE (3) MINUTES UNLESS THE TIME IS ADJUSTED BY THE CHAIRMAN. DURING COMMITTEE DISCUSSION, COMMITTEE MEMBERS MAY ASK DIRECT QUESTIONS TO INDIVIDUALS. PLEASE WAIT TO BE RECOGNIZED BY THE CHAIRMAN, OBTAIN A MICROPHONE, AND STATE YOUR NAME AND AFFILIATION FOR THE RECORD BEFORE COMMENTING. ANY PERSON IN NEED OF A VERBATIM RECORD OF THE MEETING MAY REQUEST A COPY OF THE VIDEO RECORDING FROM THE COLLIER COUNTY COMMUNICATIONS AND CUSTOMER RELATIONS DEPARTMENT OR VIEW THE VIDEO ONLINE AT WWW.COLLIERGOV.NET. IF YOU ARE A PERSON WITH A DISABILITY WHO NEEDS ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THIS MEETING, YOU ARE ENTITLED, AT NO COST TO YOU, THE PROVISION OF CERTAIN ASSISTANCE. PLEASE CONTACT THE COLLIER COUNTY FACILITIES MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT. ASSISTED LISTENING DEVICES FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED ARE AVAILABLE IN THE COUNTY COMMISSIONER'S OFFICE. ,I- AHAC Meeting October 7, 2013 Item #3A 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. ROLL CALL OF COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND STAFF 3. AGENDA AND MINUTES A. Approval of today's agenda B. Approve Revised AHAC Minutes — August 19, 2013 C. Approve AHAC Minutes —September 9, 2013 4. INFORMATION ITEMS A. Affordable Housing Model —Staff B. Board of County Commission Workshop (October 1, 2013) - Staff C. PUBLIC COMMENT a. Persons wishing to speak must register prior to speaking. All registered speakers will receive up to three (3) minutes unless the time is adjusted by the Chairman. D. DISCUSSION ITEMS AND PRESENTATIONS E. STAFF AND COMMITTEE GENERAL COMMUNICATIONS F. ADJOURN a. Schedule for next meeting: November 4, 2013 AHAC Meeting October 7, 2013 Item #3B MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE REVISED MEETING August 19, 2013 Naples, Florida LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Affordable Housing Advisory Committee met on this date at 3:00 PM in REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building "F," P Floor, of the Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present: CHAIRMAN: Stephen Hruby Vice Chair: Christian Davis John Cowan Alan Hamish Patricia Fortune Gerald Murphy Mark Strain Excused: Raymond Cabral ALSO PRESENT: Kim Grant, Director — Housing, Human & Veteran Svcs. Elly McKuen — Operations Analyst Kristi Sonntag - Manager Federal/State Grants Priscilla Doria — SHIP Grant Coordinator August 19, 2013 1. CALL TO ORDER Chairman Stephen Hruby called the meeting to order at 3:00 PM and read the procedures to be observed during the meeting. 2. ROLL CALL — Commu TEE MEMBERS AND STAFF Roll Call was taken. A quorum was established; seven (7) voting members were present. 3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA AND MINUTES A. Agenda Additions: • Staff made additions of two (2) topics under Item 6 after packet was provided to AHAC as follows: • A. (Removed after agenda released and placed back on the Agenda) Jim Fields, developer of Solstice PUD Update • B. Lisa Oien, HHVS Grant Coordinator, DREF Re- Program John Cowan moved to approve the Agenda as amended. Second by Vice Chairman Christian Davis. Carried unanimously, 7— 0. B. Subcommittee Minutes — July 1, 2013 Chairman Hruby noted a copy of the Subcommittee Minutes had been provided to the AHAC members as an informational item. A vote was not required. C. AHAC Meeting Minutes — July 1, 2013 Gerald Murphy moved to approve the minutes of the July 1, 2013 meeting as submitted. Second by Patricia Fortune. Motion carried, 7 — 0. 4. INFORMATION ITEMS A. Committee Roles and Responsibilities Jennifer Belpedio — Assistant County Attorney gave a brief presentation on the AHAC roles and responsibilities per Statues and Ordinances. Kim Grant explained "the Board has the discretion, should they desire, to add additional duties for the Committee." She noted the AHSC is currently working on a model to help predict the need for affordable housing into this Community which is tied into Growth Management Plan and Housing Element and will require further clarification. Staff recommended Kim Grant and Chairman Hruby identifies some options that would be palatable to the Committee and Staff to be present to the Board. It was noted the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) scheduled a BCC Workshop in October to discuss Advisory Committees. The Staff requested to be on the BCC's October Workshop Agenda. B. DSAC Update Kim Grant gave an update on recommendation to amend the Development Services Advisory Committee (DSAC) Ordinance to identify a seat on the DSAC for an AHAC August 19, 2013 member. The next step will require Chairman Hruby and Kim Grant to go to next DSAC meeting on September 4, 2013 to seek their endorsement to change Ordinance. 5. PUBLIC COMMENT (None) 6. DISCUSSION ITEMS/PRESENTATIONS A. Jim Fields, Property owner and develop of Solstice PUD (formerly Cirrus Pointe) Update Jim Fields gave an update on the Solstice PUD; building homes people can afford and a brief history on Cirrus Pointe changed to Solstice. • Cirrus Pointe was approved with 108 residential market rate units. • Requested the Planning Commission to revise the PUD and Affordable Housing Agreement to accept 44 units @ 80% median income (previously approved) when the economy crashed. • A market study was done showing a need for 500 plus apartments. • Have support from everyone involved. • Nothing changed to former Cirrus Pointe and build 108 market rate units • Ready to pursue Cirrus Pointe Jim Fields responded to all questions from the Advisory Committee. Gerald Murphy summarized the final housing count of 108 units ranging from $260,000 to $340,000. Affordable level is at 10 -20 %. Jim Fields stated every unit will qualify for a percentage for affordable discount. Units are restricted to re- selling in affordable housing market rate. Vice Chairman Davis stated he would like to see another option. B. Lisa Oien, Housing, Human and Veteran Services (HHVS) Grant Coordinator, Disaster Recovery Enhancement Funds (DREF) Re- Program Lisa Oien gave a PowerPoint Presentation on Disaster Recovery Enhancement Funds (DREF) Grant #12DB- P5- 09- 21- 01 -K39. o Department of Economic Opportunity (DEO) approved a Citizen Advisory Task Force (CATF) Pursuant to Florida Statue 390.046(6). o DREF Disasters - Tropical Storm Fay - Hurricanes Ike and Gustav - Pass through funds from HUD (DEO) o The Flow of Disaster Funds • Eligible Activities • DREF Projects - Immokalee Stormwater Phase II - $2,084,514 - Farm Worker Village Hurricane Hardening - $832,519 - Esperanza Place, Immokalee - $35,000 for swale to protect housing. - Bromelia Place Generator - $300,000 August 19, 2013 Late 2012 - Bromelia Place sub - recipient notified HHYS they were not able to use funds. o Replacement of Bromelia Project - Advertised December 21, 2012 with a deadline of February 2, 2013. - Five (5) applications had been received. * George Washington/City of Naples was selected for Stormwater Improvements to George Washington Carver Apartments area, 869 LMI residents - $59,360. - Second Round Advertised June 18, 2013 with a deadline of July 15, 2013. - One (1) application received. * Hatcher's Preserve/Big Cypress Housing selected for Single Family Rental Construction, two (2) households - $240,640. Questions and Answers were taken. Kristi Sonntag explained the two (2) single family rentals in Hatcher's Preserve/Big Cypress Housing were built on a 99 year leased property. She interjected future plans included an additional fifteen (15) single family rental to be built that will remain affordable rentals for 20 years. C. Subcommittee Report on August 19, 2013 Meeting Patricia Fortune gave an update on the August meeting: • Subcommittee has been working with Jason Rummer, Operations Analyst with the Public Services Division. • Jason Rummer used housing data indexes, job opportunities, rental areas, vacancy rates and availability and affordable housing population to create statistics. • Jason Rummer will return to the September 9t' meeting with a determination of need and market and a way to project affordable housing future needs. • Affordable housing, needs, possible location for new rental housing, homeownership versus rental needs and what incentives could be provided were discussed. • Staff was requested to come back to the August meeting with an updated incentive formula to determine what factors should be considered when the market changes. • Report is scheduled to be available in January 2014. 7. COMMENTS -- STAFF /COMIlVII ME MEMBERS Kim Grant noted Chairman Hruby and Clyde Quinby, Committee Member terms expire on October 1, 2013. She urged them to reapply for positions on the Advisory Committee online if that is their intention. Mark Strain questioned if the Subcommittee was doing the AHAC responsibilities. Chairman Hruby explained the benefits the Subcommittee provided. Mark Strain voiced concerns on duplication of efforts and not seeing data and documentation available to Subcommittee. Kim Grant indicated the Subcommittee was created to make recommendations on only one topic; recommendation for a model. August 19, 2013 Chairman Hruby suggested holding the regular AHAC meeting at 3:00 pm and not holding the Subcommittee meeting. Mark Strain moved to adjourn the AHAC meeting. Second by Alan Hamisch. Motion carried, 7 -0. NEXT MEETINGS: Regular Meeting: September 9, 2013 Location: BCC Chambers, 3'd Floor, Administrative Building "F" There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned at 4:00 PM by order of the Chairman. COLLIER COUNTY AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY ComwrTEE Stephen Hruby, Chairman The foregoing Minutes were approved by Committee Chair on , 2013, 'as submitted' " OR "as amended" ". AHAC Meeting October 7, 2013 Item #3C 1VIINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY CONQvUTTEE MEETING September 9, 2013 Naples, Florida LET IT BE REMEMBERED that the Collier County Affordable Housing Advisory Committee met on this date at 3:00 PM in REGULAR SESSION in Administrative Building "F," 3rd Floor, of the Government Complex, Naples, Florida, with the following Members present: CHAIRMAN: Stephen Hruby Vice Chair: Christian Davis Raymond Cabral John Cowan Patricia Fortune Gerald Murphy Clyde Quinby Jr. Mark Strain Excused: Alan Hamish ALSO PRESENT: Kim Grant, Director — Housing, Human & Veteran Svcs. Elly Soto McKuen — Operations Analyst Jason Rummer — Public Services Division: Operations Analyst September 9, 2013 1. CALL TO ORDER Chairman Stephen Hruby called the meeting to order at 3:00 PM and read the procedures to be observed during the meeting. 2. ROLL CALL — COMMITTEE MEMBERS AND STAFF Roll Call was taken. A quorum was established; seven (6) voting members were present. 3. APPROVAL OF AGENDA AND MINUTES A. Agenda John Cowan moved to approve the Agenda as presented Second by Clyde Quinby Jr. Motion carried unanimously, 7— 0. B. Subcommittee Minutes — August 19, 2013 The Subcommittee Minutes for meeting held on August 19, 2013 were provided as an informational item. A vote was not required. C. AHAC Meeting Minutes — August 19, 2013 Chairman Hruby called for a motion to approve the August 19, 2013 minutes. Mark Strain commented he did not believe he made two (2) motions as reflected under 3. AHAC Meeting Minutes — July 1, 2013 (page 2) and 7. Comments — Staff /Committee Members (page S) Item was tabled and will be addressed at October meeting. (Transcriber will research both items.) Patricia Fortune arrived at 3:08 PM 4. INFORMATION ITEMS A. Affordable Housing Model Kim Grant explained the AHAC, Subcommittee and Staff have been working on a model to help predict the need for affordable housing into this Community which is tied into Growth Management Plan and Housing Element. The presentation model is not a finished product. The presentation is designed to convey information and to bring the Advisory Board through a thought process. Staff provided a copy of the Collier County Growth Management Plan and City of Naples Comprehensive Plan — Housing Element prepared by Collier County Planning and Zoning Department Comprehensive Planning Section for the Collier County Board of County Commissioners and Naples City Council, adopted October, 1997. Gerald Murphy arrived at 3:11 PM September 9, 2013 Jason Rummer gave a slide presentation which outlined an Affordable Housing Model — Working Draft (prepared for the Collier County Board of Commissioners and Affordable Housing Advisory Committee) dated September 2013 for discussion and input. • Where is Collier County today with affordable housing • Who needs affordable housing • What are the demand needs FY 2014/2015 Objectives: The presentation of this model is to meet Goal 1 and Objective 1 as set in the Collier County Growth Management Plan and the City of Naples Comprehensive Plan Amendment by Ordinance No. 2013 -10 on January 8, 2013. Policies 1. 1, 1. 2, and 1.3: By January 14, 2014, the Department of Housing, Human and Veteran Services shall establish a method of "Indexing the demand, the availability and to project future need for very low, low, moderate and affordable workforce housing Informational Sources: - National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) and Wells Fargo - Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC) - Federal Bank of Atlanta, Foreclosure - Response.org - Florida Housing Financing Corp / The University of Florida (Schimberg Reporting) - ApartmentRatings.com - HUD - Florida Agency for Workforce Innovation, 2012 - Occupational Employment Statistics Florida - Department of Revenue, 2012 Final Roll Year Logic Flow for Model Development: • Current State — study demographics and determine key factors in establishing a demand and projection model • Discern Need and Goals of Model — what is and who needs affordable housing. Stratify by owned and rental constituencies • Develop Projection Model — determine key factors and planning assumptions, sources for current data and project demand by creating baseline for future planning Important Data: - 32 out of 70 census tracts in Collier County show - Average Median Income (AMI) — Naples/Marco for a four (4) person is currently at $65,700 - The AMI of the census tracts above decreased 9.7 % in 2013 from 2012 - 2013 - 2nd quarter, the average median sales price per housing unit in Collier County was $245,000 with a 28.2 % share of homes that are affordable for median income - 10.2% of Collier County households are statistically below the poverty line September 9, 2013 Elements of the Model. • Key factors — average median income, population growth, affordability of available rental and owned units and number of persons per household/housing unit • Environmental factors — job growth, interest rates and price points of housing units and apartments All questions were addressed by Staff. Discussion was made on the Affordable Housing Model Draft and Staff will provide the following to the Advisory Board prior to October 7, 2013 meeting: • Current presentation version • Resources • Will incorporate specific general comments made during workshop to bring back to Advisory Board. 5. PUBLIC COMMENT (None) 6. DISCUSSION ITEMS/PRESENTATIONS A. Approval of the reappointment of Mr. Quinby and Mr. Hruby to the AHAC Staff provided Advisory Board Applications received from Mr. Quinby and Mr. Hruby. Gerald Murphy moved to recommend both Mr. Quinby and Mr. Hruby applications be submitted to the Board of County Commissioners for approval. Second by John Cowan. Motion carried unanimously, 8 -0. 7. COMMENTS — STAFF /COMMITTEE MEMBERS John Cowan moved to adjourn the AHAC meeting. Second by Gerald Murphy. Motion carried unanimously, 8 -0. NEXT MEETINGS: Regular Meeting: October 7, 2013 Location: BCC Chambers, 3rd Floor, Administrative Building "F" There being no further business for the good of the County, the meeting was adjourned at 4:40 PM by order of the Chairman. COLLIER COUNTY AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMIVIITTEE September 9, 2013 Stephen Hruby, Chairman The foregoing Minutes were approved by Committee Chair on "as submitted" U OR "as amended" U. , 2013, B O n C O z D z H z C rD Q) 7 rD Q O 1 r--t D n 40 o = 0� n O O V). D O L >CL � o O O G 3 n3 3 tn' . o N3 0 O rt CD CD -1 W (D 4 O on 3 A t w w ;o as A � J � N ? W QQ• c� c� --h 0 1 'h 0 0- CD 0 c— Lo :K O^ V WC a � -0 0 0 � o o rt co Ln > _0 • 0 V) �� 3 _0 rlr Lo � z 0 c� � c� c� c� --h 0 1 'h 0 0- CD 0 c— Lo :K O^ V WC a � -0 w 9 O o j'� �• Z3 —� _. cry• to aj o 3 C �(D 3 LO000a,0 �ooa� � (D < rt -I LO o CD r-r CD ca.zCD <.rt cD � 0- rD o 3 w o ai n i.. G) O o• o !} VI S O ' cD LO F" rt CD N cD (D F" �„ cli :3 w i Lo m JI owl*" • • • • 0 3 au-p 0 Ln (D CD (D CU 0 0 CU -1 (D 1 Ul Ln JI owl*" • • • 0 au-p 0 X (D CD (D CU 0 CD CU -1 (D Ul -0 D V) a :3 CD C O ( JI owl*" Im 4 C� D n (O n _ o o D Ul _0 (7 N •� CD O � rt C- rt - i voo O �rn -°Ln 3 �-► c oo ?i cn CD .� rt 3 3 rr' rt CD r- CD o CD rt ° aj- (DD rn o• rt y , o O Z3 —1 o 3 rt � O� c� t a r rr Some M OU at ..N IV 0 rt I ®■. VMS ixlz�� �f �4; 11 -4 Zft C) �n cD � y0 w O O cp-- 00 = O D ,.R� ai 0 0 � n 0- (D V) O 0 D H H w� o� 0 Ln 3 o (D 00 LO O-7 O c- 070 O U) N O l..Q 0 , a a { ,a tFt �a t z -- CU 0-)70 `n rD (D I V) 0 0 1 D o ZT 0) O (7 � O V/ / rD 7 S Z' o U) 0- D D H , a a { ,a tFt �a t n 0 3 Q r-t rD r-r J V cu Ln O 3 rt n O � •�•! (D rD 0 m O c(DD :r N Q. n i 0 S0 G = Q. m LO 0 E n 0 3 Q r-t rD r-r J V cu Ln O 3 rt i O ��3 i J p ' rt O I O rt -n rt [D rt _0 CD (D- CU rfi r*' {. U)� ' rn F l< rt CD t0'` rn CD r f"r � 3 1 C c 3 r� V n' c� H < iV L ml `Q 1 6 ~, CD LU (1 C LO (D D 3 rt = o"� rD 0 O M D m -CD D Q n K ° (� c � Qo Cv �o o D w O D 1 6 ~, CD LU (1 C LO (D D O rt = O rD 0 3 M 3m m 1 6 ~, CD '." (1 =y0 � o rto D O V) = 3 U � M o rD r) CO (D n�rn -CD D n K ° (� c � Qo Q �o o CD .., O O N p C ova 1 6 ~, CD '." � o rto D ( o < = rn tV =oo �- < I I CD r) CO (D n�rn -CD D n K ° (� c .. m cn Q �o o { U'�.. N p C ova H , wort _0 rt O F`3 U) � OD ':;� Q. n 0 r=r -. ° _ o C: o acv FD � 3-0 0 L cm CD cD ° -h - z 0'-0D_ 0 �`o (D CL 35' Wo m n ' (D C rt � � � C:) C: V) Q 0 LC) 0- 0 0) -1 FIT on —1 w cD Drt0 n `�' Lo o 3 C c- r 0 CD �. (D - o • • • all . . ..... N G) -0 0 o -o ::E C: 0 D (n 00 O C n W o H r..r '•� ■ O C: (D 0� O O rD 3 V D_. -n w _ cr 0 rt -� 1-1 r' cD rt 'I cn D mcn =o _ < X c r+ -h . . CD �• n (D —s (A rtoo o -� _ M —n — CD -S ('D Cu tQ c, cn, o �' p –h CD Q to CD -h o on M r', CD D rn V C _ m r rt 0 h CD 3 10 c Dv o CD (n 00 O C n W o C) Q ■ O C: (D 0� O (D -M 3 Q D_. -n w _ 0 rt a 3 �Ul) (D�� rt - = O p ZT D 3 5. —h O -cs _. V) 0) m 0) M .. _ -i �D a �� �!��_ rn M _ [i r.i. �D — • . rt Q) cD - r+ f CD Q. (o � _ CD O C CD O C �D (!i X _ CU o '�' -�, _ :� 1 3 C O (i 3 _ G' �1 �} C F 0 rt o CD *pp O (D Q, Q o � 21i� �a 2002 2m] 2 0 | 2007 � | 2«0 tj u $ � | | � i | 2■„ g = CL 0 _ . ]. $ , | 7 2 JC «� | Ic Q. k k � i§ 2 7# E � 2§ = o _ _ ©E ' m z __ _ — $_ $ 2w22 #g/ 22 IA 2 o CL E § ƒ ; s&§ 2 Z _ 99 J at ca ri r to 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 r4� i 010 q1 1 2010 q2 iuiu€j I� 2DID Q4 it Q1 i 2011 Q2 2011 2011 q4 3012 € 1 i 2 D 0: B 2oI2A3 B 2012 q4 2013 q1 1 CM 013 q: LA 0 00 u � u ul rn 2 � �' v► to -L% L� v w LA. hJ fit n, _ ff 0 Im C3 0 C3 �} ' a IOC ig x r Ln u rp ' H -n Lri CU rt O O tQ Ln LO CD < n rat o- �C7 LO m � Ln CAD � 3 <. Q CD cn CD CD CD D r-r (n (7 0 o�3 �w rr-r M 0. CAD Ln rrt :3 1 to i AC GLqq DI i� a LVA t I 0 1 � D u p � � O (D ,1 ' H O rn� o nU-) � � o rn � �• X c0 p 3 -n cu cu rr - n O -n LVA t I 0 ~ O u n � � r-t (D ,1 ' H O rn� o nU-) 0- �rn(D X 3 -n cu N p' n W -a z CD � 1 3 ZT O" O CD ►V p -p o m O 1 Ul &T Y " ' - 3 -6 Fn - 0 0 3 (=D R (D C: w m cn CD Er CD (n r-.1- x m w 0- 0 (D rT 0 a � of ..e V MEIN lop r dab r _ r I U3 m �OO. •rt cnoQ0O -h .capD,� =oo'oo3i��'�' �co�tCp�< �ac_r�c,�cn�- rUp�Nrtc��� m-ernm �O70rt3D��= mom pN:r Df�DL'�3��ZfD'r� (<D•�C Q .5 rt Z m Q d f�D fCD•� rr Fj C. (N to Q O. fl) m�++ V1 fD to 0 Z C fD rt to fD O N d tD rr w p M 7 c = O m In m 6' O m M O VI 3 � VI N N C M Q Q O c"t' (� C7 O �+ O m A rF N fD � N O � o CD • Ul W ` L!1 (TD Q I-� � aq � °? N LO (DD T 00 r� Ln O CD N C W r N I-, 2 CD C7 _0 O V) O O rr Ul _0 c 'a N Q am" O cF' O F" N \ in X C v v L!1 O 3 :3 V V . Q < r�-r Q O V) D rt uQ r rt N O r W Z; C: T T N 3 0- m C� (D uO, (D 0.1 V :3 O O U) O (D z N O O 0 N 0 N O 6' O M O VI 3 � VI N N Q O � � A rF N Ul ` L!1 N I-� V 4 UOi 00 Ln O O I-, 2 CD O l > V) O Ul V 'a N Q fD Ln LOO in C O fD O 3 � N N O ` 4 O 2 CD O l > V) O O 'a Q fD O O 3 � �?"� sr�x »�.� ... _ ..�. � k�...z� __ __ N s } O CD -n < p D y. cD ° n :3 CD Q- — ::3 7;t: -) cD o U < t H n cu } 0 N CD ZT � CJJ -� � 1 (D (D 00 00 0 ' @ 6 N I o 0 W i i (D O O rt O zT o D (D D o 0 0 ' ET ET 0 0 ,� LAJ to Oo �' CD = � r-t o -1 Q) (D U) Q _ . 0 (11 C: Q -< 7 fi —h V o r-'r D ° -� L 1 CD C 6 N� 0 0 Lo _ _0 0 N o r- ~' �o L CaMD) LTI(D Q N �7 CD r uj o (D in Nj 0 F-L 0 0 m CF) Rool N 0 F" LA) m w W LA) m W c rD =Oj Cl) rD 0 N Lo 0 -r C) rr 77 rD 3 O rr--r (D (D D o ET 0 w rt O TI L 77 ODD (0 ( (D C) rt O ,fit. C Q� CD D0 �o D ID 0 0 Q o fD LO _ 0 N cn r(D LO c z 0) (D 0 CD 0_ U) N 7l C) r F-L _ LQ O c L D LO CD C) 0 c N �d �=C: D 0 _. O rn 0 _. 0 (D n m3--Q) < W. 0- J n �. 0 a w (n (n m m m =rtrt3 0zT 0� n BCD — U, \ O (D —h O n o n O � � 3 C: m• c� 0 r n� rt r-t ZT zT :3 0m (n n (D 0 FD n zT 0 O 0 C: 1 Z3 (, jj rt r. O� < O o z �0 0 _0 7 -P (D Lrl rV11 \ h rt n r- t 0 C D rt: Z3 V) 0L O U) D u > 1-- Z3 oa) Q N a) Q CT Z � 0� VI CD N O O zF-L (D w 0:K . T r-t 0L 0 z; S �r 1 1 Y U 2co �M W0; ;01< 201, z 0,; ,-0g 0 k k $ .0 0 0 0 2 R 2ff 1-n R f \ rD rL } 2 k `4 g | E G | ; Y Z 0 too O �v A A 1f mw .10cz { r C d K 4 0 3 WtcW v 3'X93 O a ear d as 1`40-3 2 tin rt(A dOvl�A �p-mowM ? 3 0 i u + w I—1 « W -PN r 0) -! 00 CO O O w O w � • w O O O O O O O O O O CO 0 O�o0 QO '7Co /700 V r1 � NCO X04' � OC, c�s�.t` c Co 00 Cori or �� 0r .off �o // ICY, rcb� , � s � d �s� o s� . r � (,ems NC o� �b o/, ,/ or Ar0 IeK `s'C X". or /700 /1`ao��Or o� ob I—1 N W -PN Ul 0) -! 00 CO O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O (I.) 0 Z O 3 d rr H • I i r 1 r • • CD rt V) 0 (D J 0 . OJ (D I V) (-) 0 r- (D r-r (D Q. —lh 0 1 —I (D D rt n � n � 9 0 O 1 w fto z Z) pit (D 0. L—i 0 (D (D UO) •A 0 w O 0. L—i 0 0 —h 0 (D (D 0 =3 rt r V) _0 2L rD 0 D 70 Lr) c =3 r ET o V) rt 0 0 0 -0 rZ D QU rnrt- lO rD rt 0 0 :3 ZT rt (D (D UO) •A CACA Lfl IN IN a 11) C3- M k_11 32" -ra EV IV I -u 7-1 sk LZI ITS LJ r_-1 * LU I LLM U. Ajj -n Fb =r =r M M 0 arm Rd,* pm LAJ -ILIR- '6 A.rA LJLJ M O M Ate O 'AM' 32" -ra ;L IV I -u sk LZI ITS r_-1 * LU I LLM Urn %Ar IL mi Fb =r =r M 0 arm pm '6 En r iii M- e. lf r--' W ow. 1 r% -1 Fss LAJ -OA r%.J 4.0 q-"- tz rw --A bra M O M Ate O 'AM' ITS %A I %Ar IL pm �A s iii e. lf r--' C62 %;.7 1 Fss M O M Ate O 'AM' v rn = O O _0 C: 0- T. O ° C: cD LO rD (D 1 OJ :7 ° �- O O O =�0 O O -O O _0 3 ca. _. �cli 3 O O rt T. Cl) O O D D 0- ^ co rD , Qj cli (D ci x rD ^ C Lo cD O LO n rt C: _0 O 0-0 u m O n (D Q) rt rn U) cD LO 0 v rn = �O �X. -0 c� Lo 0L� O O o O D -O O _0 CDC �cli 3 cl) O rt , Cl) O O D D 0- rD , (D ci x LO ^ �: k-C> --r- =M= O r-..v Z-F-I F-- O 4C=30 lm- i czz> o k-C> --r- =M= O r-..v Z-F-I F-- 4C=30 lm- i czz> t. Viii G�l 5-1 --ir- C=> F--.> CID CZZ> CDC> CZ=> CD<> CY 9=2" t. Viii G�l 5-1 --ir- C=> F--.> CID CZZ> CDC> CZ=> CD<> CY t. Viii G�l 5-1 --ir- C=> F--.> CID CZZ> COO t. Viii G�l 5-1 K:=7 CID CZZ> 9=2— t. Viii G�l 5-1 0 v 0 c LA Z3. Ln GO 0 v v 2 0 C fD yJ CD C) O .v . O rr ty O 1 IZ D) cr fD _ O a UQ N z CD fD Q. M !Z N O W 00 Cn W 'N -v O N 00 00 00 Ln N n f7 00 Um W0 O fD O O — 0 0 0 0 Z ,�-�- = 'N -v 0') N 00 00 00 Ln N n f7 Oo N in 00 O fD O cn N (f7 c Z ,�-�- N N r_*. S fD C rD V W V 0 N fD OHO = = a 4�::- O — _ =m ED w V O� rr V) �. = 'N -v r r p O 00 00 00 Ln N v N Oo N in 00 O fD O C) m (f7 00 ,�-�- N N r_*. S fD C O V f2 = 'N O -V r r p O 00 00 00 Ln N N lD 3 � r-+ O p Q O :E N 00 m = 'N O -V r r fD O = :;u O p -0 :E N 00 m V N N P rD aQ r_*. 0 C O V v Oo 0 Q fD = = S= W -0 — _ =m ED w V 00 rr V) �. CL CU CU CU rr O Q o -+, o rD ova = 'N O -V O O :;u O to cr :E N 00 m V N rD aQ r_*. 0 ED v O CL Q Q \ Q 3 v O O w cD CL CU CU CU rr O Q o o' rD fD O Cn rD Z:5 �< N r-r 3: W C:;- fD x C sZ O !7D C., fD = m O -V X cu O O 3 M' 3 rD aQ r_*. fD ED v O CL 3 v O O w cD CL CU CU CU Q o o' O O �< 3: x < O !7D C., fD CD -0 fD < O fu 0` CU (D N O `-� p X. [<D N CD O -0 (I =5 rr C: W. a � -% O } fD �rr aq 0 =r i N i. 0o rD p CD 3 II O O CrQ rr fD n C V rr O rfl Q rr rr O O 'a C O fD IS O O .=r O' -< f'1 f�D CrQ O _r N CD C 1 i Y 0 •v 7�Pg Y $ F Y a YW it - sz �� o o • 0 CD 1 s ` • L / C 1 i Y 0 •v 7�Pg Y $ F Y a w H 0. n• ry- O '1 Ln • [ 1 - sz �� o o 0 CD s ` L / w H 0. n• ry- O '1 Ln • [ 1 o 0 L / Q E� O (n t r rT ' �• O O. r l �N � w H 0. n• ry- O '1 Ln • [ 1 AHAC Meeting October 7, 2013 Item #4B Coer County AHAC Alternative Model /Index Chart and Information October 2, 2013 Comer County Alternative Model /Index Chart and Information October 2, 2013 Table of Contents Model - Part 1- "Right Now" Model................................................................... ............................... I Appendixand Definitions ............................................. ..............................2 Model Elements and Source Data 1. 2012 Average Median Income ..................................... ..............................4 11-fistoricaI Average Median Income ............................... ..............................5 2.Population Growth ................................................... ..............................6 3.Median Home Price ................................................. ..............................7 4. Housing Opportunity Index ....................................... .............................11 S.Interest Rates ........................................................ .............................12 6.Number of Persons per Household ............................... .............................16 7.Job Growth .......................................................... .............................17 Model — Part 2 — Projections Slides....................................................... ............................... .. 20 Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council Information ...........................25 Co en County Model Part 1 "Right Now" a w 3 E E 0 0 : °c o a t� 0 0 ~ w c m oN c> u n= ti � ip W 4i r m y C u v — F u L _ c m — — s S y L < N Ul L d ono vo m > aS ".ora a � c o 22 E E � 7 u U Q n m N N a N R u C E S to S c N E m a f o��3m a LL Sp w o 6+ T = tE u c i a n o w u m o u- � m v ¢ m O -E t 9 � � O l7 c o N = 3 o o 0 a m ry m � } v Q a o a o O z a 0 Isom N alsoC � ■`[ ate. I _ a c o N = 3 o o 0 a m ry m � } v Q Collier County -Public Service Division — HHVS Department —AHAC Committee September 25, 2013 Appendix Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC) was established on March 10, 1979, pursuant to title X of the Financial Institutions Regulatory and Interest Rate Control Act of 1978 (FIRA), Public Law 95 -630. In 1989, title XI of the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA) established The Appraisal Subcommittee (ASC) within the Examination Council. The Council is a formal interagency body empowered to prescribe uniform principles, standards, and report forms for the federal examination of financial institutions by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (FRB), the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA), the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and to make recommendations to promote uniformity in the supervision of financial institutions. To encourage the application of uniform examination principles and standards by the state and federal supervisory authorities, the Council established, in accordance with the requirement of the statute, an advisory State Liaison Committee composed of five representatives of state supervisory agencies. In accordance with the Financial Services Regulatory Relief Act of 2006, a representative state regulator was added as a voting member of the Council in October 2006. The Council is responsible for developing uniform reporting systems for federally supervised financial institutions, their holding companies, and the nonfinancial institution subsidiaries of those institutions and holding companies. It conducts schools for examiners employed by the five federal member agencies represented on the Council and makes those schools available to employees of state agencies that supervise financial institutions. The Council was given additional statutory responsibilities by section 340 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1980 to facilitate public access to data that depository institutions must disclose under the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act of 1975 (HMDA) and the aggregation of annual HMDA data, by census tract, for each metropolitan statistical area (MSA). National Association of Home Builders /Wells Fargo Housing Opportunity Index (HOI) - NAHB is a trade association that helps promotes the policies that make housing a national priority and that all Americans have access to safe, decent and affordable housing, whether they choose to buy a home or rent. The NAHB /Wells Fargo Housing Opportunity Index (HOI) is a measure of the percentage of homes sold in a given area that are affordable to families earning the area's median income during a specific quarter. Prices of new and existing homes sold are collected from actual court records by Core Logic, a data and analytics company. Mortgage financing conditions incorporate interest rates on fixed- and adjustable -rate loans reported by the Federal Housing Finance Agency. The NAHB /Wells Fargo HOI is strictly the product of NAHB Economics, and is not seen or influenced by any outside party prior to being released to the public. Federal Bank of Atlanta -The Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta is part of the central bank of the United States. The Federal Reserve System —the Fed, as it is often called consists of twelve Reserve Banks located around the country and the Board of Governors in Washington, D.C. The Atlanta Fed territory covers the Sixth Federal Reserve District, which includes Alabama, Florida, and Georgia, and portions of Louisiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee. The Atlanta Fed and the other Reserve Banks play an important part in all three of the Fed's functions: monetary policy, bank supervision and regulation, and the operation of a nationwide payment system. In its monetary policy role, the Bank seeks to keep prices stable and economic growth at its maximum sustainable rate. The Bank's Board of Directors drawn from the business community, banks, and labor and consumer organizations makes recommendations every two weeks on the level of the discount rate, which is the rate at which the Bank lends to commercial banks. The Atlanta Fed's Supervision and Regulation staff seek to promote the safety and soundness of the banking system, foster stability in financial markets, ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations, and encourage banking institutions to responsibly meet the financial needs of their communities. Through its six branch offices, the Atlanta Fed provides cash to banks, savings and loans, and other depository institutions; transfers money electronically through the FedWire funds transfer system and automated clearinghouse; and clears millions of checks every day. The Federal Bank of Atlanta is a decentralized central bank and public policy institution and been in existence for over ninety years. Foresclosure- Response.org - is an online guide to foreclosure prevention and neighborhood stabilization developed and maintained by the Center for Housing Policy, the Local Initiatives Support Corporation (LISC), and the Urban Institute. The site 1,2-- Collier County -Public Service Division — HHVS Department — AHAC Committee September 25, 2013 includes easily accessible information on abroad range of state and local policy solutions, as well as tools to create customized data reports and maps and participate in interactive online discussions. The Foreclosure - Response.org is not the definitive word on state and local housing responses to the mortgage foreclosure crisis, but rather as a framework for organizing the knowledge and experience of policymakers and practitioners from around the country. Florida Housing Finance Corporation - Florida Housing was created by the Florida Legislature more than 25 years ago to help Floridians obtain safe, decent affordable housing that might otherwise be unavailable to them. Florida Housing administers the bulk of affordable housing resources available at the state level and works with local governments, non - profits, elected officials and others to affordable housing in Florida's communities. All of Florida Housing's state funds are appropriated through the Trust Funds created by the Sadowski Act and commonly known as the State Housing Initiatives Partnership (SHIP) program. University of Florida Shimberg Center for Housing Studies -The Shimberg Center conducts research into housing policy and planning, with a special focus on housing affordability for Florida residents. Shimberg provides data and applied research to state agencies, local planners, the housing industry, non - profits, and others involved in shaping housing policy in Florida. Their current research focuses on documenting housing market conditions and affordable housing needs in Florida's counties; cities and neighborhoods; preserving Florida's affordable rental housing; linking affordable housing with land use and transportation decisions through GIS modeling; and supporting the development of energy efficient and healthy homes. The Center also produces the Florida Housing Data Clearinghouse which provides public access to data on housing needs and supply for Florida's cities and counties. Florida Agency for Workforce Innovation - The Florida Department of Economic Opportunity promotes economic opportunities for all Floridians through successful workforce, community, and economic development strategies. Definitions Affordable Unit — any housing unit at market rate, subsidized, or public housing unit for which a household at a given income limit, expressed as a percentage of AMI would pay no more than 40 percent of income for gross rent (HUD, National Low Income Housing Coalition and states use a 30% percent of income affordability threshold). These include apartments, condominiums for rent, or single family homes for rent. Gross rent includes contract rent for the units plus utilities. References to rent below include utility costs. For instance, if a 4- person household earns 60% of AMI is $36,000 per year income, an affordable unit would be one whose monthly rent equaled no more than $1,200 ($36,000/12 x.40). Housing Opportunity Index -The share of homes sold in that area that would have been affordable to a family earning the local median income, based on standard mortgage underwriting criteria. Therefore, there are really two major components -- income and housing cost. NAPLES FL. FY 2013 MEDIAN FAMILY HUD INCOME GUIDELINES EFFECTIVE December 11, 2012 2e P. AV r4r->AN 1 h1coN1 e FY i Inccomom e Limit Area Median Income FY 2013 Income Limit Category 1 Person 2 Person 3 Person 4 Person 5 Person 6 Person 7 Person 8 Person Extremely Low (30 %) Income $14,550 $16,600 $18,700 $20,750 $22,450 $24,100 $25,750 $27,400 Limits Naples- Marco Island FL MSA $65,700 Very Low (50 %) Income Limits $24,250 $27,700 $31,150 $34,600 $37,400 $40,150 $42,950 $45,700 Low (80 %) Income $38,750 $44,300 $49,850 $55,350 $59,800 $64,250 $68,650 $73,100 Limits FAIR MARKET RENTS 2013 FOR EXISTING HOUSING Naples, FL MSA (Collier County) Effective November 13. 2012 0 B 1BR I 2BR 1 3 B 1 4 B 724 833 1 1,038 1 1,356 1 1,669 FAIR MARKET RENTS 2012 FOR EXISTING HOUSING Naples, FL MSA (Collier County) Effective Sent. 22.2011 L 0 D 1BR 1 2 B 3 B 1 4 B 813 932 1 1,049 1,304 1 1,357 2013 Income Guidelines & FMRdoc n g Q. g .2 !�2 Iq IR .1 11 11 S. g I c; 6 p !I mM1 .9 R —'..o — 32 0 41 1 IS BE I ol M. ml I 28 N ml 2 ci �d I 6 6 c� N 1. 11 d i g 2 2 6 j @ g ci .1 11 16 4, .1 IS I 1 1. R Iv 14 P 4 S. A I a em g IS ci vm o g S. a' mm md�� nm m ®g m� m me�� ^ego sz x IE 2r 'E 10 IE ;B ;Ex 2 A 2- FOIP(JL,PMO C-jw L4T kA 6. o rc.) ID Cl) r- r CD (3) C141 ce) 'o N Vito 0 N N. 0 Lo O) cql io 00 ;co M UI)l — co CD 01 0 e o I o e C� 0 " co o l I U CD LO, ol Ci c%i C) 0 U- C) Ln V 0 C) c';N co V Co C'! E - 0) ci cd (n E :3 0 r IM .0 ca LO CD 10 co 0 Lolo 0 E '0 C) co v w 00 i C> C> 0 0 0 0 �Olm —0 C N N'04 CIJ C14 Z O I O( O O O '� > 0 > 0 > O'b > > 0 A :3 0 U) CD LO 0 cm cl 0 (D (D 010 -04 CN C> m 40 c E ix 0 C-4 C-4 cv C*J C14 0 0 a a o u 0 0 (D i .1 75 -61 ! o° F 0 0 A 2- FOIP(JL,PMO C-jw L4T kA 6. 3 M�vl �- N* JS N N m o N Y v to col, v Q Y m w Q 5 U O i 0 0 C M N O a O c v 0 0 ur O N 00' c R O C •� '° ~ V d C w 0 t4 N m M u G .�'-� `m L = lffl In ¢ z v to C C v c m �CfCf �CfC1 =�CfC m� }o ej00 ej °oo CU —°'oo O -° o� o aw w O N N 0 0 N N 0 0 N N C O O = N N O Z m 2 O v .; Lr gozb r so Lb t [o tib Lo £b Lo zb Lo Lb go tib go £b go zb go-Lb So tb So £b Y So zb .o N � N ^^ So Lb o to 0 0 O 11% 0 O 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 d- M M N I*- -o'-3 M al o m tA.1 00 o a LL� o v a w c :3 M i o m 0-0 o a Q o c ai x 3 c °o ° aj CL O O V y m Lr� E o o m m 0 a Q) O O •� M co =l t0 v in i4 C M N N 3 Z aJ Q �+ M -O N c c ra c m M M m dd m14inn = rl n c R° m0 w } -O m N O (n a m N 4) _ y m M m N O -OO CJ - v 'O O al 7 Q aJ O O 01 O O a ��i N Z m N .�''.. f2i O I aJ 2� £b uoz -�b OIOZ Lb Looz tib 666 £b 666 zb 666 ieb 8661 £b g66L Lb ib66L w m; £b £66L 0 N 0 o ry 0 0 0 o vi 0 M E 41 ? 0 ca m` E „✓ o� aci ~ L o Y O n �. Q e 4 7 irk C O O Q s c ry ro � m m rJ ='yam a z N p 2 N d ax p p a o 0 a o a a p N. O 4A O G 1rt r M. (1 rl E it O Z a0. UOz WZ G ooz gooz !ooz 190oz ;ooz tooz Eaoz zoo. ►ooz 0 O O O ol 6 N !2 CY 0 8 , am omT, - z 0 memg ci IQ Sl .1 Wl .1 ol am IN BE S. I cl �m I 1 19 7 1 u. PD 90 V) I - . I - I . I 1� �2 t2 d 2 g 6 �2 Cx rye e c� 6 T. EIE m 0 x O_g 2 0 4 c6 gym S. gi 6 Iq t2 140 S. m 'I O m ^ QN ^ v O ^ ^ N Q m ^ N oI CJ m ^ N o, of amn N om^ N of am ^ N of of 0 of a N m ^oi o, of O u N OI m N I O m OI n u n of 2 N m u Qi a m r Oa e m m Di e m m a e m r I O v m oe o, o mm o, a m o mm a -- W a h m - m m a v M. F � e v n m v w h v m m y S. m e r S. m m m o R. m mm m m r m m ^ mm N rm m m26 m� N ry m N R�� N Sivm�� N v m v v m m v Q �r J �g Z�7 a vo nrri ^.- SO � n m r m rn m gi n m m m ^ mPON m � R6 �lj N4ev S. m m N rmy� gmm a � _ n p c E n E c n a �a0R �ao�¢ ;ho c ado _._. YrLi y)'iT`��C,1 I�1rS7 j lFfl )+, �f:l.i-`• .it� `' _ ,_ �`�az. _i Three Month Trends: --a- 30 -Year FRM =- 4 15 -Year FRh1 1YearARM -ar -511 ARM 4.75 -- - -- - - - -- - -- -- 4 -50 - - -- - - - -- -- 425 4.00 3.75 - - - -. _ _. _CcpyrW42013Klortgage- X.Corn - - - - -- 325 - - -- - - -- - -- 3.00 - - - _- __._ - 2-75 .. _ ------ - - - - -- 250 Cl N M M M t'R W M M M M 0 M M M M M M M {'• ` ti r T T T T r r C ` ;z C 4�l Ci7 [� M co N Ql to M O to M O 117 ti7 11'7 (L7 O cD ID M1 M1 M1 M1 Q 4 4 q q Q7 O (j1 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ( Obtaining Permission to Reproduce ) One Year Trends: 4.75 4.50 --w- 3D -Year FRM + 15 -Ye2r FRM _- 425 1•YearRRPAInitial Interest Rate - -- -- - - - - -- - - - -- 4.00 �- 511 ARM: Initial Interest Rate ---� -- 1 Yr & 5(1 ARMS Fully- Indexed Rate 3.75 -_.� - - -- - - - -- - - -- - 3.50 —_ — - - -- - - - - - -- 3.25 Copyright 2013 Mortgage -X.Ccm 2.75 2-50 N_ N N N N N N t'i ro t9 ra t`f c7 n M [°1 ci C7 Pl C! c7 M M M M M q C� Cp G yr M1 T C 4 T! T LO GI a CO Q V M1 T tr1 pa N to O M OJ O O r T N N 3" N M M M C C UJ M 1D O r� M1 M M© O O D O O O O Q O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 One year trends of mortgage rates. 30 -Year FRM, 15 -Year FP.M. Sr1 ARPd, 1 -Year ARM ' Fully- Indexed Rate = Index (1 -year CMM + margin (assuming a 2.75% margin) (obtaining Permission to Reproduce) Add 1Y.iSchcrt +c vctir v.el5iic' (chd<h +- :rc'cr HTM-L ccdc) Three Year Trends: I' 8.00 7.50 6.00 5,50 5.00 4.50 4.00 3.50 3,00 250 M k -T! � M 31 71 J!- 7, 3:• M 3� M M > M � M > M CP 0 = 0 C n C a C 0 C' C 0 M C 19 17 IT n 7 7 CTR v T 9 tq 7 19 _'9 '9 7 1? 9- 19 CT 19 IF 19 IT '9 7 19 IF 'LP r_ C 1 7 10 0 0 z cz. p r 2 p pow C'006000000�;8==r� b 6 �b R 0 w W C' U1 • 0 Co " - (..) , c 10 n C' __j I a e., Q t" Obtaining Permission to Reproduce Add !hiS chcr! IC VCLr (Ji6 f,erL -Lr ccd.:,t .*5 5.50 --a— 30-Year FRIVI 15-Year FRI'd 1 -Year ARM., Initial Interest Rate 1 Year ARM: Fully-indexed Rate 5.00 4.50 Copyright 2013 Mortgage-Xcom 4.00 3.M50 3-00 2_5D — — — — — — - — — — — ;E CO 01 M Co to M ;a: 20 43 Q a N �-! - Q z Z: — ;L- iq i2 a Fq Z 0 0 8 N G N M in w I.- Three year trends of mortgage rates: 30-Year FIRM, 15-Year FRM. 1-Year ARNI Fully-Indexed Rate = index (1 -year CM-0 + margin (assuming a 2,75% margin) Obtaining Permission to Reproduce I Add 'O'o s chcr i to v c:Lr -bcb si t=1. icb,J, hcri: *cr HTAIL code! Historical Graphs For Mortgage Rates: Long-Term Trends 30-Year FRM, 15-Year FIRM, 1 -Year ARM Rates, 1992 - 2012: 15 14,150 � 15.00 4. 00 2.50 0 0 C', C, rs. co co ca a -Z c o o 6 6 a o 6 6. (Obtaining Permission to Reproduce 30-Year FRM Rates 1971 - 2012: 30-Year FRM, 15-Year FRM Rates 1984 - 2012: -�k-S —_— I Year AM I D i-- F� Ahff Obtaining Permission to Reproduce National Average Contract Mortgage Rate, 1963 - 2012: W, ISM 14.00 13.00 12.00 11.00 10.00 9.00 8.•00 7.00 6.00 5.00 Nelonal Average Contract 1'•ior tgage Rata 4 Copyright r?/ 2012 Nortgage- X:.com } *5 4.00 . o. o,ono.oho.o+o:o.o.ono+ono.o:uw' coq+ o: o+ e•` p+` c •.`a+o—••i�o`m�n.c•w�o�`c�0000" 00 a.rnrno� c*•.i•.iv-1J.t.J�J�-- J�Jmc; c;rnam c• ;c: �a+u.ow.o,ammuc9 �.c••� o.±•oSo 6 CJ •G 1110+`+1 OD 0Orh+U .0 N0+ -J0 LL�Orf•) W a. (n Q +'-J CU +D Orfv)CJ d•CJI G+^.1 O)+OO rf.) ).F. 111T'+1 CO 4� P3 )5 GJ M c0 oN G T N C T d V �p C c a j c x o O � N d D. 0 O N p07,S© "s F F-P, HO t-DS i � w n m O Z � N L W d 0 Z In c N v y O d Y > c a c w y � v E w o x E E n m? v p E o Z L d w a c E L E 2° 3° c u a � � , v c > v L Z = - p 0 O CO 3 o z 2° 9° . 9 * �° c •C n a L p w w= O O e a w O ° vl % >: ¢ I� i N In C C Z Z 7 M 0/ d an 00 O N a-i N W W � O N N O O M N t� L d N d N 2 N Ol 41 Q! d O! O/ a a a a a a O ip Q N •„� lD p Z O O O O O O U rr ¢ 2 2 p07,S© "s F F-P, HO t-DS i � w n m O Z � N L W d 0 Z In c N v y O d Y > c a c w y � v E w o x E E n m? v p E o Z L d w a c E L E ri I& 2° 3° 2° , o °�° 3E dP 3° 2° 9° 9 9 * �° e X A° e °* e 02 °R O IA tD 01 I� O Q M H 00 O N a-i M 00 O D1 N N O O M W t� I\ Q Ol lD Q ri lD Q 0a1 ko n co M C lD Omo co I� n Om1 n lMD tQ0 W Ol n m� N b N N V M VNl C a m N LA M 00 r lD t\ Q W Vl O O W Ol lD V1 U'1 Q VI N r, Vl ri H t` w M M N M M tD lD Ol W N Q I� Q L m N VI m tD N O H Q N 1D m lD to Q ri 1p m m to I� d •p y N f� N Q ce Ilk (� N N t(1 O m r�i lD ll l/1 M l0 lD N I� Ol ri o M QI 01 M 1A 0p H U1 O E C O N lD Q Q Vm1 lOD M Q I(1 Ln Q M Q w d d' IQA l�D O V) Q V1 ll1 M Q N r�•1 N N M N Y C V W ` F i/f VT to Vf iA iA N vA N V1 V} lA iA iA N a/' V} V? N Vl N V1 N VT N th W i/1 V? VY i? � d m a 2 ` 2 M N M lD l!1 Q D1 M M lPl l0 lD O N k-R Vl N Ol M V1 Ln O In lD D1 G7 Q m n In N G d M N N N N N M M M M m m N N N N N N ,-1 N N M N N N '-I lD Q to l0 lD Q O O a � O L d LN lmfl n a0 N a0 M O lD l0 N Q O Q W M CO m t0 O Q p 1p r-I N 1� lD N n N Q r-1 M 00 'i ri W O O Q N Q r•1 ry m <n O lD V1 N Q Ol 01 O O N 1� Ol O] O N 3 M Ol 00 O V1 1f1 N al n W l0 lD I- N Q N Ol M O\ O Ol M p 3 z U Q t0 01 N lD M m W lD Q N In t(� N M N Q CO O W N Q W O W m W m N lD M N ri O O Ol I� O"t Q O N N .--I Ol N N lD Q n O Q lD D1 lD O N f\ 1 ` I"• � G N ri O N N V n N Ol M I, M r-1 00 1p lD N N Ol Vl to N m c O lD 1, lD Vl M M N N M O M N tY1 Q N N Q N M N O N N i� N N Vt N W Q lD N M l0 Ol u1 lD Q a w U U O1 O ri O ri O ri N M O In O ry Q vi tD .-i N N V N Q ui N O e-I r-I r-I N O ri 0 0 0 0 0 0 on O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C A � I� ri H .-1 N N H M '-I a N Q ri Q N a .-+ Q N Q .-� Q .-� V1 r-I vl N tD .-1 l0 N l0 ri tD ri lD N ID 0 .-� 0 o c-1 c 0 ,-i 0 o rt .-i r••1 .--I ri .•i N N N N N M N M ci Q .-1 H ri I& 0 c rL m G O Q C m' E n m O 0 a a m Wa c � e c m a c m z° m c a F U y m N m O a « N . m m IUD O � L m c � � ma m G .L. L L U - U J Q N c a �7. g 0 o r P r o N m o N r r N O N n ' � n •- 0 N N h m m r m n m N < P n O O M N O O O O O O 7 O N G O C � r h 00 O N Q Q N P 00 A n 7 1 - m a o r m m ro ^ n Q m o c m m P P ty A N r r S �a N N m A Q N N m A m m W �JWW O �5 a m IE a L A N C $10 O 9 Y O G N E y « to E m W a Y E m J c V m IL C7 C J m m a m m o L V m N n t O. a E u m �•`• _$ .�. U U O LL E I9 J A rL m 6 C m N N 2 Z 0 Q a a .m+ G O C O am a a' N 1- F- R m } d m c « C R � L y U « c 0 'd C A V ' w, 7 O � LL R C fn 7 0 =- w E �+ W 7 n a w < 3 N Q V C •. O O1 N R R O VJ Z m Nm f'NM M I,r? V 10101 V 0 0 0 N N r r,T 7 O1,Yl O W r (V N 1n00� a-NM r ��r� -Q �(j N N r r r Nf7 (V 00 N O <I; N OR u0 n V 0 RQCON I, mrm O)mr r W m O O .-- c i w N V' 4 M N (O N N r O Qi � r N (0 � N o c.—.9 j r 0 `7 N r • O MmN 7 NN rmN cl In r rM N V mr ey mr - NN mNN o rr6ro4ocirc?0000 oo�oo iod0000000 n ? � q V: C'1{r Nr Nr- N"ci ] q u1 N chm q V: f, r 10 M O 10 OD R N 6 '7 N N O r Q) r V' N O C] O N cV [] O r v u] r T r (p O (V 7 O `o M V h O O M 1 c D h 0 0 0 0 N M 1 A m m N N N m r O) m Q r m c 0 r M O N mM I�p)c�m l0 mm O O M O m010 i6M N Ov- c0 a N No] N Mc07 0071-- m vMOMm1� mmCr Q1-0O)O r=-, MO M c�m10M 01Nr 10 Mr0 R 10r rCn0 rmM r m I� c0 co l<7 r r r r r m 0 Q O mmM c01� mN N QQ7 mRMr cOr MrmQ1 f�N Q) M1�7 mm O m m 6 ui Ih t0 cV m m .6 m V 10 1� 1q N Ih co. l`7 � m In M .. m m m m w Q O- O m N V M O M f� 0) co m i0 N 7 m N Q7 N m N O M 10 V 1DM M Nrm m NMO N.- -t0Mr0 V' l0rr p)Or w ct—N 1� 1� m LLi r r r r r r a N m 1010MOM N r cO Nf� Q r10 c0 O) mRO� M(0 c�mmNNrcO MN E M m N O m 0 c0 g O N 'C m 1q r r m m N� m 1A O v IV O N ee�� I�c0 m Om O) W N NQMOMm O v e� N7m NON mN 10 to m MMN m1�10MONrtOM O< 10rr Of ON m lhOr NIA � co m 1ri u O 0 h D N d o d w 9 d G N Q c m c p�p N G 2 W d C A V Q 6 m R �c+2v•` -' n Z o E m dennRmenQ T J V 0 d u to R' '0 N o C O •O N C G w C Q V O m C M t d C m L A R d G LL $ u E 5° m G o a ?: to d !' `0 c w W y o e "m y d E «d p «<G c p lo O O o m H 7 ,.R, m b V C N y o m c C o �°5o Cm .°- :cd�AOmSVimcSo cEEE� _ C1 c 0 9 d d y tF' .d. 'a O C7 O 2 G R C •V A" N C d �` R C R 'Yp d o-2 Ve >> n g E p o `° • >- a`awn�O-jo ayi ~Q- mew °- mmeo;,t'G°wE o'�C7U�'- ovn v Z LL aq N 7 3 a V w d t m R E G R q O E V 7 R yy u 'd6 �' V c N Z' to p Q Z m> W C' C R C w a 9 d L V m 0 lL N J h� cLL y0. �Q W 2•_QQt.� N0.F LL d W J OF- n d a u1 4V-I E m a . U - m m M c s m E O E W J -,5-6 S y U � u�m N C mr n a n J O O 0 E 0 d U W . O O � � m O m c m mp ra ss oLL V7 �` 7 ni v a � m Ma �� Coder County Model Part 2 Projections C:� C=4 C) KZPI ilo to all 1=31 fn I-N Ln "15 767 lj -4 RTC LU aj t3L* 6- CD i C- :rj <r, cl LO—= -n *!31 CN cm 10 vj CN k-,p J. U. -A Oj Lin cn Ln cf-I T-4 V) Lou di LL- < Loll L, --4 ct -4 C-4 �u 0 di :'INK q c): L- on C� , IF , mnm'' V) lu ub LLJ Kw cy') 13J C= 0-1 Ln aj Lft lei rye I�rps�[ 2D M Cl) ZI L p I i U? 4--) M Cl) ZI 1 E U) 0 C) Lm 0 DL LL Q) 0- o (1) O U Q) ) o > r- x Q) U7 �o O �O _ O O Q ._ ® -0 p ® ra ra` { N O 0) Q) Q o 'Q Q Q'O XCl' W a p �I M Cl) ZI -%= a CDO CL)l CX3 9=L- CDP 1-7 r-v,a C--j CDO CX3 9=L- 1-7 r-v,a CDC) r- KC== C--j ----- <DC) C--j C-d"ll C-4 CDO c:10 9=L- CDC) r- KC== C--j ----- <DC) C-d"ll C-4 L-f--j <:3-lj CD<D C-73, L-r--) 7-2, CDO c:10 9=L- L-f--j <:3-lj CD<D C-73, L-r--) 7-2, LO f f i 1 i s f 'F fiitf l rrl Ir4 ql i - \ft N Y f- i`IfJfkL }/ i =� O ! -0 M Q.; O 4J Q) Ln N 1 ° o to-- c c f a I .►- a�i v rn D Ln C C N `-1 Ln xz x ! I a r' a oo u o ° _.__. O f OI El - -- 4-- i p 0 N N + ° M 00 r- M . D t a° L � � UD SU L O L ti M Il i ° oN I / T I to (� .1--f c CQ N O O l ..�. rII ca N Ln N 1 .-F X ++I ! I email ! N M Ol z � N bn It el- s Q-I I `! w i Q. O is Q. 0 to ®� O COI tail � i Y ��+ p N N � j O Ln G1 i m 4J I I 30 pOp � O O L L Q: OI ° L N 00 O O� tD 41 of j X ' -{--- . O O I T O G +J rl O d O 0 to i w a i ry � w cu ++ y+ r I k I I u ^ N tD I o '. O uj a. c6 f6 'O ~ U, O E Q Q c O' O 4 I I m i a j i N o \ D m Z I; , I O O d ! '� fo f4 I Gl ! 2 OA " � Ln 00 c 2' LL L O I CL: O' O M Ln a as li!M. Q. Y� i w CI) NMI , l to trt r6FJ: �1; it L �.. N � u 'r : llr�l `I�D�j'���+ � i \�..4 �J �s a •� P Fk _. • ru fill x f : o4W t I L AIy� rmn c I c 0 W RYy° fpr jfxrt V p 5� 1s .1 til x1 "N "M 1 �l __ ==1 4�f 0 E 0 `c L A O E J LL V z � h eq Q ISJ a CL ?o e p 0 U -0 W W 0 LL h Q r O y N � C it i� QA.N tOD W H m r N r' r Ov N O P �i N N YW'J N 2 EE G 9 E E a 9 n o u LL� m M [O Q r n del m m O M n m O of M r YJ Q P W W O M Q M O r W Q P O m W W Q N P W Q W M 14 in r v W � r ci in r m 1� M r W ^ m M ^ V W O N P W M ' 4() — M O P W N M ] o O O O O o O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O y ] O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ° � � O O O O O r J n r n r n n n n n n r r r r n r r r r t r o m m- o in m- m is - m m m m m co m m— m- w m m m o- m- m m— � z G V O n O O m W m m m P m O O m P W P N P c-� M f7 O m d d 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o w Z Z Z z Z Z Z Z Z Z z Z z Z z Z z z Z Z z z z z z z N n n a a n a a n _ o N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 7 N r r N O d a W J W r 9 f9 fA O N � N {M 69 f9 !9 ✓3 di M fA fA fH fA IA M f9 63 fA fA b! fA fR N1 � � t Q r ► P N M n n W cli P m W m m W P M O to 9 f9 (A 69 69 N f9 t9 N 69 63 H fA b3 fA f9 fA NT b3 � M W 69 69 d3 � d3 ] o O O O O o O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O y ] O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ° � � O O O O O r J n r n r n n n n n n r r r r n r r r r t r o m m- o in m- m is - m m m m m co m m— m- w m m m o- m- m m— � z G V O n O O m W m m m P m O O m P W P N P c-� M f7 O m d d 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o w Z Z Z z Z Z Z Z Z Z z Z z Z z Z z z Z Z z z z z z z N n n a a n a a n _ o N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 7 N r r N O d a W w F C M p W N N N N N O M m r W OQi O M r N O u2 N m d d W h d O P O N N O N n N P rn r rn r .M- W M 3 N r N N Wi N .�- r d .Q- N W - - - 47 O O � m ' m cpU O Q V � N Q N - Q m - - m r W O d n N m P O N rn 0- Q N d C o �a m m o d W p n v n in m M N m o rMi ro m v, ya LL') d r d m N d Q d V N P n N p N N N d M P M N N j 1 I m r H �� d� ONi I d r P it] h V M� fpDI r� i[mi P Q h NJ M M1 N� p� 0 a h O N NO') W O 4 N d r N W O P m E - ? <'? 2 u O ? o m M m o W d m N E d r M N P - m d d- - d -- Q fa w fn en w f» vs u3 a - yy N O Y'f P m d d d W M N m m m N M d n c'! _ 111 � If O O O O o O O O O O 6 O O o O O O O p O p p` O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O r n r n r n r r r n n r r r n r r n r r r n N w m Z d M M r O NO d P N m M W N W d d Q O Q ' N R W y r V '6 O r O t� m W r M W O 01 N O O N m 'E o o ? Q P of - of of ro o M m of cv ci P n ri ai er m ai o a Q d m W � � o n r d n m °rn ro m W n d d rn m `o H m o o z Z Z z z Z Z Z Z z Z z z z Z z Z z Z z Z Z Z Z z Z Z z Z IM Na o � 7 Q m N F c a a a pa, J a a 9 a a a a 4 a m 9 a a a a a 7 > > v � a m U U N N N N N N N ' N N N N N e- N N N N N N N N N N N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O m IO a I U' N N ^ N ' N N r r r r r r r � � N r N r r r � N N 91 c lL 0 � M Nd O r NW O M M M m Q N Q M N m O r N M r O 0 d O P N r r W Q N m d Q N r O O W O M I� O d m N N N N OJ O O Q <O O L7 In O d O N t7 O O d W d M O m U N m r ^ Q r u'J m d Q m -- r O N r r r F" a E N OP r N m r _ N O P Q Q m P W LL d O Q <O U � LL M M'O E N W a E %o�1�fc;�y�Et O U ° a � U ; E u U � V xA « u - 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 R R R R 0 0 0 0 0 0 n r n r n r t� r r r r r r r r r r r r !9 fA F9 fA Y3 di fA f9 (A t9 t9 tl9 M l9 to f9 (9 W O m M P t(1 b C7 c7 N � O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O P O O V 0 J {p U LL N v C `o m d mn O P O d m d a E } -2:1 d `ol 0 0 0 0�0 0 0 o�o`0 0 0 of oJolo�o{a N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O P O O V 0 J {p U LL N v C `o m d mn O P O d m d a E } -2:1 So v- : 2013 FFIEC Census Report - Summary Census Population Information - - -' - '�` MSAIMD: 34940 - NAPLES -MARCO ISLAND, FL r i` cK� r�tu nsaiu:un State: 12 021 0001.01 1556 3.98 486 952 1494 62 1 7 11 32 11 12 021 0001.02 1473 5.84 537 740 1387 86 1 6 18 51 10 12 021 0002.00 1962 12.39 514 900 1719 243 10 23 27 158 25 12 021 0003.01 3057 5.20 905 1539 2898 159 3 22 6 98 30 12 021 0003.02 1474 6.51 448 743 1378 96 0 10 3 65 18 12 021 0004.01 2776 1.73 1054 1574 2728 48 1 14 4 20 9 12 021 0004.02 1602 1.44 511 875 1579 23 2 2 0 10 9 12 021 0005.00 1730 3.93 578 760 1662 68 0 20 1 33 14 12 021 0006.00 1311 6.10 440 678 1231 80 0 7 10 56 7 12 021 0007.00 1184 81.67 208 359 217 967 4 4 695 232 32 12 021 0101.02 5096 12.79 1386 2015 4444 652 1 69 24 519 39 12 021 0101.05 3952 18.04 1118 1981 3239 713 4 35 47 599 28 12 021 0101.06 4065 3.74 1335 2076 3913 152 5 22 15 93 17 12 021 0101.07 4023 13.90 1138 1534 3464 559 3 85 47 381 43 12 021 0101.08 2576 12.31 594 821 2259 317 7 17 11 273 9 12 021 0101.09 2096 1956 . 560 973 1686 410 5 16 21 346 20 12 021 0101.10 4262 29.19 1047 1828 3018 1244 9 69 81 1007 78 12 021 0102.05 2559 9.14 769 1097 2325 234 2 28 21 160 23 12 021 0102.08 3305 2.39 1239 1751 3226 79 1 20 5 44 9 12 021 0102.09 2138 4.54 619 928 2041 97 4 17 9 56 11 12 021 0102.10 3261 9.72 932 1920 2944 317 4 20 14 250 29 12 021 0102.11 1737 13.64 478 1058 1500 237 2 33 20 160 22 12 021 0102.12 5794 17.36 1388 2313 4788 1006 5 73 106 756 66 12 021 0102.13 4008 5.39 1190 1718 3792 216 2 26 41 128 21 12 021 0102.15 2939 1.74 976 1613 2888 51 0 28 2 20 1 12 021 0103.00 3968 30.19 850 1560 2770 1198 2 44 137 967 48 12 021 0104.01 3724 25.32 937 1556 2781 943 15 75 168 627 58 12 021 0104.05 11307 26.71 2488 3966 8287 3020 13 213 452 2241 101 12 021 0104.08 2966 22.45 696 899 2300 666 15 45 55 515 36 12 021 0104.10 8157 82.70 1474 2104 1411 6746 22 41 1335 5244 104 12 021 0104.11 6632 64.61 1396 1984 2347 4285 17 60 744 3398 66 12 021 0104.12 9212 34.38 2359 2783 6045 3167 21 113 358 2599 76 12 021 0104.13 6584 46.32 1544 1863 3534 3050 15 55 335 2574 71 12 021 0104.14 7623 37.78 1937 2243 4743 2880 16 79 228 2447 110 12 021 0104.15 14589 21.78 3600 4855 11412 3177 13 325 521 2154 164 12 021 0104.16 5883 10.37 1768 2372 5273 610 7 63 55 429 56 12 021 0104.17 5195 25.02 1313 2168 3895 1300 2 92 172 989 45 12 021 0104.18 4485 15.07 1389 1896 3809 676 2 91 83 463 37 12 021 0104.19 3160 75.60 612 940 771 2389 6 8 427 1925 23 12 021 010420 6012 78.91 1306 1660 1268 4744 16 42 1127 3456 103 12 021 0105.05 6764 42.78 1795 2621 3882 2902 2 161 789 1883 67 12 021 0105.06 5558 31.11 1696 2327 3829 1729 9 53 81 1541 45 Page 1 of 2 ITHI Page 2 01 2 AsiaM Other be( of NamHisp Tract American Hawailanl Black Hispanic Population soholds White Minority Indian Pacific Population Popuation Twaor PoPulation Population Population Islander More ._ .,PopuUtebn , fia�s 12 021 0105.07 4042 38.88 934 1557 2552 1490 4 55 3 1032 88 12 021 0105.08 4343 34.81 1112 1891 2831 1512 4 78 592 796 42 12 021 0105.09 5548 14.19 1524 2227 4761 787 14 40 219 459 55 12 021 0105.10 3560 5.20 1031 1767 3375 185 3 22 32 120 8 12 021 0109.01 2383 46.12 575 972 1284 1099 14 20 125 926 14 12 021 _0106.02 3223 32.92 864 ri 2162 1061 5 56 171 802 27 12 021 0106.04 3836 31.05 823 1531 2645 1191 5 29 326 795 36 12 021 0106.05 3112 31.33 972 41 18 2137 975 1 61 364 507 42 12 021 0106.06 2400 12.71 666 1281 2095 305 1 22 45 208 29 12 021 0107.01 4279 43.51 1069 1900 2417 1862 13 43 304 1444 58 12 021 0107.02 3240 44.66 959 1314 1793 1447 12 11 347 1037 40 12 021 0108.01 3451 11.39 952 1863 3058 393 3 39 121 208 22 12 021 0108.02 10208 67.40 2263 2914 3328 6880 18 47 1650 5071 94 12 021 0108.03 4062 31.27 1102 1731 2792 1270 14 34 248 952 22 12 021 0109.02 3544 14.70 1073 1555 3023 521 3 37 14 440 27 12 021 0109.03 4517 10.03 1690 2075 4064 453 7 52 28 327 39 12 021 0109.04 2021 9.01 626 1`032 1839 182 1 17 9 142 13 12 021 0109.05 3050 7.84 920 1178 2811 239 2 42 15 165 15 12 021 0110.01 1530 5.03 646 992 1453 77 0 17 4 53 3 12 021 0110.02 2018 4.08 564 811 1936 62 1 20 13 39 9 12 021 0111.02 7291 23.32 1932 2905 5591 1700 53 58 205 1328 56 12 021 011`0+3 2225 46.70 457 656 1186 1039 9 3 460 $53 14 12 021 011.05 2546 26.04 1007 1342 1883 663 6 14 133 489 21 12 021 0111.06 3022 32.53 656 972 2039 983 6 16 287 659 15 12 021 0112.01 7072 9.98 2182 3170 6366 706 1 105 66 456 58 12 021 0112.02 18805 44.58 3773 4498 10421 8384 46 265 1034 6745 294 12 021 0112.04 4807 98.29 454 699 82 4725 3 9 1308 3343 62 12 021 01.12.05 2664 99.25 412 600 20 2644 51 0 946 1536 111 12 021 01.-01 6369 94.57 794 1072 346 6023 11 5 828 5162 17 12 021 0113.02 5920 93.11 839 889 408 5512 11 5 818 4611 67 12 021 0114.00 4657 93.97 654 720 281 4376 18 5 527 3775 51 12 021 9900.00 0 0.00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Page 2 01 2 -�j L� ovv%(r�. C_e�JT ��aJ l�LJr� 2013. FFIEC Census Report - Summary Census Housing Information MSAIMD; 34940 - NAPLES -MARCO ISLAND, FL D )TAE• State: 12 -FLORIDA (FL)� FI nl firancu Ir .r .:cn5 12 021 ..vJ.V4 0002.00 i 1076 U14 986 26 40 528 403 212 12 021 0003.01 2727 1589 29 614 1345 602 286 12 021 0003.02 1059 815 36 656 948 194 12 021 0004.01 3543 164 22 1412 577 87 12 021 0004.02 2511 178 27 720 116 162 12 021 0005.00 1241 1241 21 737 38 155 12 021 0006.00 1097 747 23 519 737 23 12 021 0007.00 651 152 30 91 463 159 12 021 0101.02 3183 2851 17 1897 51 1814 268 118 12 021 0101.05 3531 1694 15 1520 995 461 12 021 0101.06 3679 1731 17 1674 1096 402 12 021 0101.07 2069 1401 23 1394 1037 140 12 021 0101.08 1482 1196 17 712 650 109 12 021 010109 1532 1111 27 666 12 021 0101.10 2220 2220 29 1123 583 307 12 021 0102.05 1468 1082 18 896 1123 705 12 021 0102.08 3572 1461 18 1628 665 201 12 021 0102.09 3305 518 17 846 909 123 12 021 0102.10 2429 1227 26 1385 332 82 12 021 0102.11 1805 269 25 752 894 535 12 021 0102.12 3164 1599 15 1525 179 306 12 021 0102.13 2996 1976 14 1443 1229 788 12 021 0102.15 3215 597 18 1459 1134 275 12 021 Q.03.00 2212 1514 33 926 322 154 12 021 0104.01 2018 1319 25 936 745 634 --92p- 12 021 0104.05 5725 3278 11 2315 792 1983 1651 12 021 0104.08 1066 1059 22 765 765 134 12 021 0104.10 2583 1556 25 642 628 1462 12 021 0104.11 2499 1903 24 1451 1239 533 12 021 0104.12 4102 3395 13 2330 2202 QF.3 12 .021 0104.13 2214 2214 13 1577 1577 286 12 021 0104.14 2650 2650 15 2078 2078 165 12 021 0104.15 6744 5676 8 3875 3777 980 12 021 0104.16 3745 2955 13 2175 1923 197 12 021 0104.17 3147 1841 14 1550 1108 618 12 021 0104.18 3010 2397 13 1524 1430 372 12 021 0104.19 1079 1079 20 621 621 319 12 021 0104.20 1847 1305 22 760 760 900 12 021 0105_05 3959 1847 13 1462 1017 1159 12 021 0105.06 3204 2484 15 2042 1766 285 Pagel of 2 12 021 0105.08 2888 1799 15 1332 1183 559 12 021 0105.09 4901 2187 13 1877 1262 350 12 021 0105.10 3399 1946 23 1555 1129 212 12 021 0106.01 1201 1048 28 500 500 472 12 021 0106.02 1878 1162 26 94 718 _298 12 021 0106.04 2476 1365 26 1189 744 342 12 021 0106.05 1777 1187 26 1127 823 . 221 12 021 0106.06 1781 1126 24 1189 843 92 12 021 0107.01 2764 2017 30 1113 970 787 12 021 0107.02 1877 1515 25 811 753 SM 12 021 0108.01 2776 1218 25 1609 1072 254 12 021 0108.02 4507 3369 13 2003 1935 911 12 021 0108.03 2907 2130 21 1538 1213 193 12 021 0109.02 2205 2023 20 1221 1177 334 12 021 0109.03 3459 2438 20 1910 1616 165 12 021 0109.04 2210 1127 23 811 518 221 12 021 0109.05 3351 1225 21 1082 646 96 12 021 0110.01 2111 539 23 917 324 75 12 021 0110.02 4455 79 23 737 44 74 12 021 0111.02 5595 4084 10 2170 1774 735 12 021 0111.03 1455 1361 22 ^ 722 704 134 12 021 0111.05 2488 1420 19 1151 996 191 12 021 0111.06 2439 1425 13 799 654 173 12 021 0112.01 5441 3682 11 2911 2304 259 12 021 0112.02 6413 6008 8 3943 3879 555 12 021 0112.04 1086 828 32 220_ 220 479 12 021 0112.05 959 846 32 42 42 558 12 021 0113.01 1643 1372 23 567 543 505_ 12 021 0113.02 1232 1157 20 629 622 260 12 021 0114.00 1090 991 26 405 405 315 12 021 9900.00 0 0 0 0 0 0 Page 2 of 2 Collier County Government Communication & Customer Relations 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 102 colliergov.net Naples, FL 34112 -5746 twitter.com /CollierPTO facebook.com /CollierGmv youtube.com /CollierCov September 25, 2013 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA MONDAY, October 7, 2013 3:00 P.M. Notice is hereby given that the Collier County Affordable Housing Advisory Committee will meet Monday, October 7, at 3:00 p.m. in the Board of County Commissioners chambers, third floor, Collier County Government Center, 3299 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, FL. The meeting will be broadcast live on Collier Television and via colliergov.net. About the public meeting: All interested parties are invited to attend, and to register to speak and to submit their objections, if any, in writing, to the board/committee prior to the meeting if applicable. All registered public speakers will be limited to three minutes unless permission for additional time is granted by the chairman. Collier County Ordinance No. 2004 -05 requires that all lobbyists shall, before engaging in any lobbying activities (including, but not limited to, addressing the Board of County Commissioners, an advisory board or quasi-judicial board), register with the Clerk to the Board at the Board Minutes and Records Department. Anyone who requires an auxiliary aid or service for effective communication, or other reasonable accommodations in order to participate in this proceeding, should contact the Collier County Facilities Management Department located at 3335 Tamiami Trail East, Naples, Florida 34112, or 239 - 252 -8380 as soon as possible, but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event. Such reasonable accommodations will be provided at no cost to the individual. For more information, call Barbetta Hutchinson at (239) 252 -4228. Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term Home Phone DateRe -appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term Mr. Christian Davis 642 -4455 1494 Trafalgar Lane 370 -1408 Naples, FL 34116 E -Mail. christian.davis @pnc.com District: 3 Category: Banking and Mortgage Mr. Stephen J. Hruby 430 -3005 1800 Gordon Drive 430 -8011 Naples, FL 34102 E -Mail: shruby @architectsunlimited.com District. 4 Category: Residential Home Bldg Industry Mr. Clyde C. Quinby 11426 Quail Village Way 594 -3055 Naples, FL 34119 E -Mail: poseygl @aol.com District: 3 Category: Real Estate Mr. Raymond Cabral 293 -8571 14767 Indigo Lakes Circle 348 -7759 Naples, FL 34119 E -Mail. rymond@naplespropertylist.com District: 3 Category: Represents Essential Services Personel Mr. Alan Hamisch 963 -4669 10036 Heather Lane, #1301 431 -5571 Naples, Fl 34119 E -Mail. alan@hamischlaw.com District. 1 Category: Advocate for Low Income Persons 09/15/09 10/01/12 3 Years 09/25/12 10101115 06/12/07 10/01/07 4 Months 9/24/13 10/1/16 3 Years 11/8/11 10/1/13 2 Years 9/24/13 10/1/16 5/22/12 10/1/14 2 Years 09/25/12 10/01/14 Wednesday, September 25, 2013 Page I of 4 2 Years Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Name Work Phone Appi'd Exp. Date Term Home Phone DateRe -appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term VACANT VACANT 00 /00 /00 00 /00 /00 3 Years TBD 00 /00 /00 10/1/14 Naples, FL E -Mail: tbd District. Category: Employers within jurisdiction Mr. Gerald F. Murphy 263 -3300 12/10/12 440 Spinnaker Drive 435 -7370 Naples, FL 34102 E -Mail. jerrymurphy2010 @gmail.com District. 4 Category: City of Naples Mark Strain 39) 398 -2102 4/9/13 3675 Third Ave. N.W. 39) 732 -9400 Naples, FL 34120 E -Mail: mpstrain @comcast.net District. 5 Category: Collier County Planning Commission VACANT VACANT 00 /00 /00 TBD Naples, FL E -Mail: TBD District: Category: Labor actively engaged in home building Mr. Albert Batista 39) 272 -9327 9/10/13 9853 Tamiami Trail North 39) 272 -9327 Naples, FL 34108 E -Mail: avbatista87 @yahoo.com District. 2 Category: Alternate Wednesday, September 25, 2013 Page 2 of 4 11/18/15 10/1/14 10/1/15 10/1/14 3 Years 2 years 1 Year Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term Home Phone DateRe -appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term Mr. John L. Cowan 09/03/08 09/02/11 3 Years 375 Kingstown Drive 649 -7363 8/17/11 9/2/14 Naples, FL 34102 E -Mail: jcowan2 @attglobal.net District: 4 Category: City of Naples -Not for Profit Ms. Patricia C. Fortune 877 -0102 03/08/11 10/1/12 3 Years 6769 Del Mar Terrace 272 -8494 09/25/12 10101115 Naples, FL 34105 E -Mail: pattifortune @gmail.com District. 3 Category: For - Profit Provider of Affordable Housing Wednesday, September 25, 1013 Page 3 of 4 Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Name Work Phone Appt'd Exp. Date Term Home Phone DateRe -appt 2ndExpDate 2nd Term This 11 member commission was created on July 23, 1991, by Ordinance No. 91 -65, to monitor the implementation of the Affordable Housing Task Force's Recommendations, and the goals, objectives, and policies of the Housing Elements of the County's Growth Management Plan and the City's Comprehensive Plan. Terms are 3 years. Amended by Ordinance No. 2005 -69: the BCC will appoint 8 members, including the alternate member, two of which must live in the Rural Area (East of Collier Boulevard), and one of those must be a resident of Immokalee. The City of Naples will appoint 2 members. On 12/14/04 the BCC adopted Ordinance 2004 -77 to add 1 Alternate member to be appointed by the BCC. The Alternate member shall serve in a voting capacity only when a regular member is absent from a meeting. On December 13, 2005, the BCC approved Ord. No. 2005 -69 changing the composition of the committee, 9 members and 1 alternate. The BCC will appoint 8 members, including the alternate (2 of which must live in the Rural Area (East of Collier Boulevard), and one of those must be a resident of Immokalee) and the City of Naples will appoint 2 members. On April 11, 2008 the BCC adopted Ord. No. 2008 -17 changing composition of committee; 11 members & 1 alternate; BCC will appoint 9 members plus alternate; City of Naples will appoint 2 members. Take stipulation (East of Collier Boulevard) out of ordinance. The commission shall be comprised of members from the following categories in connection with affordable housing: 1. Residential home building industry; 2. Banking or mortgage banking industry; 3. Areas of labor actively engaged in home building; 4. Advocate for low- income persons; 5. For - profit provider of affordable housing; 6. Not - for -profit provider of affordable housing; 7. Real Estate professional; 8. Local planning agency; 9. Citizen who resides within the jurisdiction of the local governing body making the appointments; 10. Citizen who represents employers within the jurisdiction; 11. Citizen who represents essential services personnel; and 12. Alternate NOTE: 1 member must be a resident from Immokalee FL STA T.- none Staff. Kim Grant, Housing & Human Services Director: 252 -8442 Wednesday, September 25, 2013 Page 4 of 4