AHAC Subcommittee Agenda 05/06/2013 Affordable Housing
Advisory
Subcommittee
Agenda
May 6 , 2013
1Q �j�d y4S
411019
A
c� FRx of Py 3- 1?6
� r COURTS
COLLIER COUNTY --'t
AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY SUBCOMMITTEE``— ,t).,,
AGENDA
r�r
Collier County Government Center
3399 Tamiami Trail East, Suite 217
Naples, Florida 34112
May 6, 2013
1:00 PM
• Welcome
• Approval of minutes from the meeting of April 8, 2013
• Affordable Housing Incentive Strategies
• Other Items
• Next meeting will be June 3, 2013 at 1:00 p.m.
April 8, 2013
AHAC Subcommittee Summary Minutes
SUMMARY MINUTES OF THE COLLIER COUNTY
AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE
SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING
Apri18, 2013
12:00 pm to 3:00 pm
William F. Harmon Building
3299 E. Tamiami Trail East, Suite 303
Naples, Florida, 34112
Committee Members:
Steve Hruby, Chair
Gerald Murphy
Patricia Fortune
John Cowan
Public Attendee•
Dennis Oury
Carl Erickson
Marjorie Student- Sterling
Staff present:
Kimberley Grant, Interim Director; Housing, Human and Veteran Services
Elly Soto McKuen, Operations Analyst, Housing, Human and Veteran Services
Amy Patterson, Impact Fee and Economic Development Manager; Growth Management
Division
1. Call to Order -12:IS pm
Each person in attendance introduced themselves and provided their background, experience
and interest in affordable housing, including the public in attendance.
2. Overview of Meeting
Ms. Grant began the meeting by providing an overview of the subcommittee's focus. She
eviewed the handouts, explaining the charts by housing incomes. She also requested that the
Subcommittee take a few minutes to review the recently amended Housing Element from the
Cm- rrh a"a- in=--n nt ?ian Thnr: ara n r nihpr of nniirioc in the T3nncinn Flmmnnt t};�zt ..:;i
April 8, 2013
AHAC Subcommittee Summary Minutes
drive the subcommittee's focus to develop a method of indexing the housing demand for very -
low, low, moderate and affordable housing.
3. General Discussion
A number of subcommittee members discussed their previous and current experience with
affordable housing. Members focused on what worked, what did not work, and what some
of the unintended consequences were with local and state affordable housing decisions. Ms.
Fortune described the local housing market and the patterns of development over the next
couple of years.
Ms. Grant explained that the Housing Element details that by January 14, 2014, the
Subcommittee must establish a method of indexing the demand for affordable housing. She
also outlined the focus of the flowcharts, how the market drives the housing prices
compared to income levels. The charts could be used to show trends that the subcommittee,
the AHAC Committee and the County can use to develop and utilize incentives. The
incentives could be "turned on" and /or "turned off' given the demand or oversupply of the
market
4. Assignments
In preparation for the next meeting (May 6) and to determine what types of existing
information is currently available, the subcommittee members and County staff discussed
how to determine its next steps. A general discussion ensued to determine what
organizations, persons, departments, etc. would have information the subcommittee could
review. In addition, there was a general discussion regarding the potential of hiring an
outside firm to complete the housing index study and recommend incentives.
The following assignments were made by person:
Ms. Fortune: Metro Study contact
National Association of Housing Redevelopment Organization
National Association of Realtors
Information regarding homeownership vs. rental housing
Mr. Murphy: Locate Realty Association - price points for rental units and availability of
market rate vs. affordable rental units
Mr. Hruby: Urban Land Institute (ULI) - cost estimate for potential study
Ms. Grant: Florida Gulf Coast University, School of Real Estate - do they have a data
model (forecaster, demand /supply, etc)
Collier County Human Resources - Potential college interns to assist with
data collection and analysis
Ms. McKuen: Florida Housing Finance Corporation
University of Florida Shimberg Center
MacArthur Foundation - Yearly Child Well Being Study (related to affordable
housing /homelessness/homeownership)
2
5. Next Meeting- Monday, May 6,2013 1:00 - 3:00pm
6. Adjourn - 2:30 pm
April 8, 2013
AHAC Subcommittee Summary Minutes
COLLIER COUNTY AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVISORY SUB- COMMITTEE
Stephen Hruby, Chairman
The foregoing Minutes were approved by Board /Committee Chair on . 2013,
• "as submitted" [) OR "as amended" [_].
3
------------
go W pi hit hl Tim ia Voifilt
------------- --------------
Hub Hwfl&m &UiA
Lig it
flu
Abffi6fgi vio 200
8ghh4w
V16/26ij
i
----------- - - - - --- -- stibpdwA6jil§
------ ----- -- --
�iFi�Hih irk HU AIJUW
POWN with MOM
V16/26ij
i
i
Homeless Families
DOE definition includes "doubled up" families, due
to economic hardship and unaccompanied youth.
I
i 117 of the 1054 children identified as homeless
were unaccompanied youth.
The Collier County Public School count is a more
j accurate indicator of family homelessness. The
I+ DOE PIT data over the past five years shows us that
family homelessness is on the rise in Collier County.
I
Homeless Students
Collier County. Public Schools
�- -
-----------------------
1200
991 1054
1000 966
am
641
i 600
1 411
400
200
0
2009 2010 2011 2012 2011
Causes of Homelessness
What do you think is the primary event or
condition that led to your homelessness?
ly Employment /Financial
12K Housing Issues
Family Problems
Medical /Disability
Problems
Recent Immigration
5/6/2013
2
Solutions
Chronic Homelessness
• The most successful model for housing people
who experience chronic homelessness is
permanent supportive housing using a
Housing First approach. (Housing & Services)
• Research shows that permanent housing with
support services is cost effective, saving
communities thousands of dollars in the cost
of hospital stays, jail and other institutional
care.
Solutions
----- Fa-mily-Homelessness --- -------
• Studies show that families exiting
homelessness with rent assistance remain
stably housed over time.
• The hourly wage necessary for a family In
Naples to afford a 2BR at FMR Is $20.17
according to the National Low Income Housing
Coalition.
---- ------
HungeT&Hometcsss
Coalition
--
PIT data tells us that there's work to be done.
It will take a community wide commitment to
implement real solutions.
Our Ten-Year Plan to Prevent and End
Homelessness, "20.20 Vision" includes evidence
based strategies to prevent and end homelessness
for various sub-populations in Collier County
by the year 2020,
5/6/2013
3