Resolution 1984-141 I
r
r RESOLUTION 84 - ' l .,,r s r., rs np;.
''' a ' RELATING TO PETITION FDP0-84-V-8 FOR A G y ,��
r,
' VARIANCE FROM ,THE MINIMUM BASE FLOOD r gr .q..c , ti,'.
'r' 4,+c;1 ,,r,i ELEVATION,REQUIRED 'BY THE FLOOD DAM- ^.+�k' �d">s',� .
P �,i,ia4^ i AGE PREVENTION:.`•ORDINANCE
r
, kkritf v a �9-V2)� ti rf } r }tx :rrp
'rip t{ti4 .1 ` V a't�, rid
# 4 &b Ai � ry rK tid Ip* }' rY 3 '' h) �.
.w „?r ,�y WHEREAS, the petitioner. Arthur G. Davis��desires to build a'public ; �� a,
, r � �tl ���t fit
i '' V� ` pool bath ,at' 200, Cricket' Lake ,Drive (a `part,of Lot,x115,°,,Naples„Grove''6;� ` 74 � `,''+
311�7�da 9 yl
'ii r , and;Truck Co.'s Little Farms No. 2) and has requested a.Variance from,' hay 4 °,}, x '
' Y � a
4; '�; the Minimum Base Flood Elevation-�required.by.the Ord. No.:;79.621. and;'1 ii;r�,1 ; i f:',itii `-'r,., , •
p sr °Rtkfii`�,� k t3Fd} .' `
,, ,.,,$,A WHEREAS, the Board of Zoning Appeals has held.a public hearing x`'`,+ `4 °r
1' as required by law; has reviewed Petition FDPO-84-V-8 In accordance `� ' , t
y
t ,,r with Section, 18 (5), (6) and (7), and has, made a finding that the �� Q4,'`'1��r ig p,
, ranting of this x ,' fib �
granting petition complies with the intent and purpose of P�Av 1
;, �a,H +��9r
Ord. 79-62 as follows:
(5) The 2.51 reduction from the Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM)r, � '
4, , 10' National Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD) requirement to ,�I �1,,
' 7.5', NGVD is the minimum variance necessary, considering the ,•,14 , .
flood hazard, to afford relief. �?, •' ;u
i, (6) The variance 1s issued upon: 'i ,:
�
(a) A showing of good and sufficient cause based on review r,<; 't''
0' 11
of considerations contained in (7), following. ,�, <, 4 +'
(b) A determination that failure to grant the variance would .''.!:if
it
<,, result in exceptional hardship to the applicant. :'r�,
(c) A determination that the granting of a variance will not ,.;
•
result in increased flood heights, additional threats to ,,•F,'
i public safety, extraordinary public expense, create ` ri7 '
nuisances, cause fraud on or victimization of the public, ,t`
or conflict with existing local laws or ordinances. i#fu
(7) In passing upon this variance, the Board of Zoning Appeals ,4 ;`
has considered all technical evaluations provided to it, all „�'.
,,” - relevant factors, the standards specified in Ordinance � r,,1,�k ,'
p - 9 p , `1
, No. 79-62, especially those contained in Para'ra h 18 (7)(a-I) V4, r
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by'the Board of Zoning Appeals, i �^
that Petition FDPO-84-V-8 Is hereby 1t ,,.11,
y granted subject to the following ,+ ,,
conditions: , • �� � ,,�r,}',
k * /r 1' r A e 1 r7f�';8 � {i'P
1. The variance shall be for'the reduction of the Minimum Base Flood F`` °r?.%,
fif rt r
i, Elevation required by Ord. No. 79-62 from 10 feet NGVD to 7.5 r 3,
1 feet NGVD.
2. The Chief Administrative Official shall mail a copy �'
py of this Reaotu-
tion to the petitioner by registered return receipt and such mailin kiu1 s6,
' shall constitute compliance with Section 18, Paragraph (10) of` ; '' r,�`? . .
Ord. No. 79-62 which reads as follows: �,,' .
s yl
z f ptirs ,
�
y i 1,, k ypn+yey � r r
drl iktlx?d 4, S 1i(.
y
Ili:a ?s c r r 7 ' lirig4k :e r rh 4
� '� )U.1 �� 1 ll 1 k r '+ 4kk�1+'fi)�p i "`741
r 1 0f�y'rt S, f , �'' is r , 1 4 +4,wf �} ::4'11./,';';';''': 4 i y4p 1+ f ,N ttxr
i J �,
1,0;.:"� } r i ' q 'o ' , h � d�}�t��l11'?�� fhrt f�z�
' 1 rwxr iQo11 ,()8`1,11 F 60 •; 9' b.�` hP;,0,V rrq 'iit4rA
tt sr 9rd' YjK'� 1' xf p w
4
'%�1,iii ,�
r t
1:
' 4#1,',4,,
j ti ti} 4 Y
��� 'Any applloaht, to 'whom a variance la;granted, , � �;,,'
,'shall'be'given writte ''notice,that when a ' ..,I4 "'io ,1,r r.,,
�,�{yryry��u Jq, 4 ,
ti b4 r, �.", � i, �; ,0 pal' r ;:,9,t 9 *Xiii;,,,.,44,:,,,,,i,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.,,,,,�'5 yi+ � elsm 1 7 r
' ' ` , rf, siYn
, ..ObO " r1►�(1.' a.,,, ,�,�'i E,.xtructure is pe� tted l:o ..b� bu ff fh.,. thy' ,`' << ,,.:}", .t:s s ,�Nt , � a, „
� � �,' ,y. . ['���lrt �� � t E_ t,t Y ..i S�F at d�''J�f^A� ,t? ,r �, r�r "„trJlS e ett � y PI,I;M;r �r1 J:,�� 4,��� r`� d �:p
,°.,,1 qtr, i,� 't1 ; f;lowast;habfitab ioo�'elevation.below h• `r!''' :4 r,i. Ir1,-,i,,,1„,,,,,,.i4,,,,,'..,,,,:,,,1,• Y � r Y4, s, �g�?��', lei ai ��ni ° r rcl.x r"t,�sr�i� �w „r+fh.t` � e� Y� �' r,, 11 i:M. .. Thy+,,,t S ri°'p it i <tl i,i a, ;.. Aj ,rr' � .. r i' ,'�. ,r ,, a t r .base`fi bod'.�reli�attor�'t '.the",itooa{s,,o.',�, iJ i14,1 rf ^�S Ytt rn.{,a PP c, t } �4,k k?1
y� �`� yt► � f f ood:,�insur ,�, �y� ��� ,„� silk:'' .:�
f.r;,p�} �rx X��'. �,��'��i d i� �;;$ X , 'i,'' S'n."d>1� S �fi`�'�'� i �'v vA!��:`f fie, ,l .y�py�„ tr;h'�+n r �{�q," � �^ �b� �°� .i.
``�e:,,: ;,.0' �A 1 4ii, t,, t,�, C ,did 's r' S„F.): ,.� i�d 1.1S '1, Y ,.::`3 ti{s,��.�h').r,12.!4Sk!.,,d,, i '1 t ,''.1 �,r{r r 1 r,
r„�i.?•i' Y ,1 'L i(d�1:4 �iztv,Y t.+ '3,1::a C.�t,,'!� � l bitit.c r �y, } '•. " , 'L�} 8"'C ` "�
�� f t�,�,� r ,e.,��t�{,.r , ,;, �,� z G�ilfitm��i�r�t� �it��,th�Y'1�1,�`.r�as���,��r�� ��yf� �'� +�' �''��ttrb�
' ,.,�p01 ,��i�51>°.i d= �`•.,�� p�i, h;(.::,�,.�yt„�t'VY'.fi'` ''r.; ys,;�y ,y.c, ,.v6 k1� d ..:+;q r ,��, {ef i �4NISIn, ��, �"�.' .. ,f
' t kii ."✓v�, a �'`" y 44, tfiy y, j 1 '� `,°( �(` y+iriti +. s r },�,y y rN , Y 1
,14''.'k''''''.4''''114.'.; � t, .4,1,,. ? ,iii. kl,0. y',4p)�}7'1' sl eiWI` .. ,r.-'';,11.1,7,*�4���,. 4,i+,l're# h �.A" 1 ,.4i'�� Ty �r,� Y , ,I+ ,
t�,'�f5s Y'N, ' }�i ( �, y` .�Si 1r16-�d�'it t 4 f. ,��. j}'4,1r4,.=., 1���,,i.:'7 fv, r�+,f�,xfg,.,rY.pi i'b�, ��.� a.,,.}. tq P., 3i4,, '`
p Y t a �t 1 �'�6�,�'Mi+ e a ,Y 7 s5 ey,� � 111 � �r , �,� �� � � l
�t v1 t i,1'lo6r + le gat o' aI 1� i p Y . ,5' t i
, 4,04 6"` �f�ya r A , S ./ it r ,, �" �k p t+'� �,t i' r �``,�4°d,fi•f i 34 t .'weft ,5.,l ,9„r a S t. , ±s� 'l"+ is !t 1't, ' 1 fl atr",u� �(, 4+!� ?a ,, p, ads± 13 "
f� N Y� tv „ ,Y' i 1�c,',�, ,, a � r� , � , � t.�� "�i�,. b t !:. t � re„"t i:„
R r in a "M, , ) +. I,i -!H r 5i:,; YFJ a` - • q,�Y 0 , t
, . ? 1(; 1"he�'�rantin�,rofs''• •• '' arlin .4,, a�. been'„°�pr'edt,Cate� rinot alt 4 1,� , s ;
,,,'�4ir,',i°,0e, zf ,)4w�•`h,a 'tn46 ' N;'''''''''4':lt >.«p r ("4{ ,fY ,t1,., ",r,< �:`� i ,<:i✓ yl'',,'I'(al , x ti,t+-;1r f, '' trf� .;•
,,,�'r �, r;'� ii.? 'the'-engtnering 1 data ,,ands information prov do°d' by".; h. i�i��Itib NMn r r Icliki , ::'
A•i„Y b k1 r t 'h,7,t t,s, a 'y ,'
+<L<` r,,"v YI.;,p, girt/ ,and gah review ti'o#; same wtt -F , , ' r �t 1,4 ,tl,Y , 1 .
1,pp i< f h respsct�>tbrtha oonsideratiohs",tre uir ;.,.A fi�„� �„•F‘4''''''I''':'''''°'41 1''' ', l ffl '0, apt 7 i `S i ,k y ,t, yd pn� s,r l,� Nye t, a i w
f ,/,a b the ,Ord Noy.,+, r ,t4i �" aN "{4 i,a sty,qyu ,t, 5 ' t d > Y14 r 4 ,I'd r' ,,�d y
,0, 0'�",,} ,,s, y 79 aci ,Q T., ,, ,: Y f6'„� � t; ,r: 41..„ 0nf g��� i,:
fi � biµ t �t t r
1 J t, J a , < y t An k i f p,
� a;; , d,i tt "w r Y � `,The "rantin of this, ,r • � , , �, t ' °%
. "� '''; ,1 i g g ar!rtance by the hoard`of, Zoning Appeal.; w+ � �
" `� t doe not make or tmpiy'any"assurenoes,"that` t subject�propert� < ,e, �'�'''01,14 `?
,
t>
• b Y�� ,�� lY {Yi l ' „
,S rp � or aLl'uCLUree are not !t era ,g .� r '�, pm# fit �{' ' '
�+ ubject,to flood damagesi�','!" '' ?�i ,,V 6,ifH t� .$ 7+ , �w y i ` `
a �,Y, Further, the ; {,
+� �'" granting of this �varian�e' shall not create aiabii•:, ,< �s YrY; t�,�,
� ity on the part �of Collier County or by any officer`.or employees ' �`> ,` ;� ' ,
Ott thereof for any flood damages that result from reliance 'on this ti st �Ylrf
� Y ;it'�� , variance or any administrative decision lawfully,made;thereunder.a.r , r�` � 7
t "'
r `r In accepting this :variance, the petitlonar"'assumesall resp�n•'; '� � `■
�" sibility for any property damage resulting from its appitoation: ,q �l'f Y
;�: Commissioner Holland motioned, seconded by ' Commissioner �: 'r` '
i'' + �`
`fit ' Pistor for the adoption of this Resolution, Upon call for ' ,, ;
u F the vote, the motion carried. `
r Its 1t/0
°� ,," ' BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS '`'�+ ' ``
; DATE: .Tuiv 24, 19$4 COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA �"�Y tf
N''' f AT?6Swq gy. /ate"' t.,
•
���WbLiA►�n � � ` N, K , CHAIRMAN ; ' 440''.ir
i
:: a F'yh,g
iY � f
Y Y r f�,Nk .+
i _•�, Y,, YY ,_ y
4 FY
r
.b
w 1e ,,i!iYC�f 9 .t O�'e'{i'', i}, �54"4{,:,y.,,Y4;`` i y." .k,•f �%{,�.,� ,4 " ,`,:; 1�' ai, ,g7:44',;r1 t K h'�� ',�.».�;.'i4!I t.._' `y 1 ,,, v t a a i. r
i e;ia.t N:`
ri s
'+t
s:
i
a' �F
,' * , l� 4 4 '0,,,,,,,14-,,,:..,,,,,,,,,,,r 3 h'4,',',.,'1,-,',.`,,,I,,)-,',..,','.
,'' t z Y, r"t >t F a k , . J 141',14,',;'''',',':,.,:,,,,',,,`,, t P U' iY n i r Isi� I41y $ c F' a,,.� , , ;rt'IN 74 , C tit , ' s 4,,.' d t4 r F, n�A a ii q '11., Y+d � P r'R tlr� ,,,-,',•:,.;, , id' A tli:i r il.t.')1 � f .. '"' 1 ais ' , ' ,' t( r 4� i ,i 4, % , mN}) 3gk S t t r lt n, dt ,6Pg4+�' ° s`�a d h¢ 1 .k ii .f91. ? , 1F *t r J .t, 7 r ��74ii, � , a ,• %/02-,),01,';',91,2:2'2:',2;2:::'i. „t � 21 R 4 4r ,, ; alt :,, y , i l � a 1 9 rf r t,, r 7�a�i2 t� �„04 1 ll�iS t i, ,it i ,,,,122,','',','.)';',;',',„.2,',',....;;,,,,,, ,i",1 s n .2 ;, ..e,4 a,2 k . 6 ' a. '� p 7 ;,1-� ,1`^i M1 ,,,,,2,,,,„,2;,,, ,,,,„,,,,;2:2 v , r , i U ( Ca,,4 �t,,,k 41,,,,,„,,,r i A F)e i�� 3 Hti ) '� f, � S. .'�e i „,y � qA,1: , , , r ti,,,' i4 ;7 } 4 1 t t; � ,,1 0�,wry ,ir � ' ; , � 1app t1' l,�1 P�" -s" t Y ' � 7 Y j ,>� a r 14 t '{.t 4,. o4 Yl�t l',..'',),o , 4 ' "�„ „,Y �6� j �r ,,",,,',1,!, "0 i.i a n S 4 ,7,L4 rj1,',2,� krt h. .�,3i� ' :i�S.," i+ c�'i{p°44.1 µ0 r t�, t , ,y �r .}/s gg 65. � fir* �s� �i a4f lCj,r x 4��p; Y4�A a , � lol.�!��� ;�,,I 4,Js a� , �i�,b 4' ,4keApt „Ni���� �< �,rt 5.,,,� o>r j a�4 �}4 M w d,�,c t;:i•',,,,;',,,:,,,,," u}x�;$ti F;' 4i+� .i (4 ,�iy{„ �,,+a41>1 l s,. i1�r�„ c + . di F r`�4 ��a��?�, ,:'4,... ,. " ��ni �d � t 4 '"it 4 � , H �Y3 k 4 C'�Y n I>` � ', h rt� � t���1 ,,�+;. +' ' , 4,Ayik,ft " 4 t i,J,;v y �t " ",jP ri 41 "� ,l�0 l , �Cyr, q ay, ,��t , s 'b aiF ,hF rrz 1 "S i/R , il;jx'f 1 : ,i,,1r 4 V{,tt,,yyt '1, �e,�pW, , i ` fi s,�t} t ' ,tA � � �i� r S i ; r #�S e p �rx e 4 )i, r s 1"� ��k� 1 a� �,,,t t',,p � t 1 �,{v�� ���at i 0� a Q�%�5 . r t � ,„.4 a , � ,,p 4'',a n + r,:„:01 t ," kq,„S r,F4 t�F .r t,� ��: � ..) nf. `.atA"Vk:' �4ii:,;. M ta° t : a i ,�'4 x t({ tt v ,i „ 1% l � , 4�•
� "' ! a , r ' t. ,,,,;v,fy . ,it i,i,' 4Fp t ,fi" `1i r '''. , t b i,I a' ryq 4 ',,+..+ , tn e „. t, `t ;4s;a. s�7 ',P ,,,,, ,y,,, r, ,. ,a d �