Resolution 1984-140 �!
r g
r s a US PAG[� � RESOLUTION 84 � r" >
d,, a , � � " ' RELATING TO �PETIT,ION ,t=DPO 84-V 7. •a �f
3 ,. R'1l,V , � 5� r r
tt
fl ,� aai�y a{� f r FOR �A i 4
', '4'iR. w .4�'�a;`tzf f ,; , VARIANCE ,F,ROM .THE,,MINIMUM 'BASEL FL00Dt ��,,ti ` Y ��; 33 � zt,� � ,ri
y �;ra pt '" i ' '';4' ,�x;.EL Vid►'1"101 ,,REQUIREb�',BYE. THE t,PLOOD:DAM= �r "�ti}r 2�u ' ��.: rt„. °
�� �� 1' b ,' t,t ' ",, At E �PREV,tEyNTION ORDINANCE '' ORD. ;�t r't1,�=lti ,;� r � r t, ? ,
/r' y( r 4 '.1 k5' C ( NOS q, 4¢ i� M. g f D t f tl:
� � �) t r ,�F�� f �i,(,.r�, A ^ 79-6E) ,F ,w1 J try � ) � S d �f� ,� �b ��15 Ja�f�'f t l
„ ; ` S ? ,4�fivi:' ,"#..t ,, t i�' ,! r t,`! , P i,: i'f i,��',r�t,�P{ tF{y,.ail>✓ J, ' � �'.r , ,''" { �,r } in,:la )ytiyt� ; �:ji Ik°, 'ril•;'}i' , ,,
n
s ,J , N1 4 p',l}d 1}; r}y rFbt ,,, h,ror� ,t iiprif 6 fkl}t,! jYa t y , '', 5 rtY , d (�� ht ,
t ) , ,Yp' etqq�� fF. Si>+tii�}K ,• `��M �i;'r j:,A 7 d"1/ e .i 614X :;'ti<; r f Y,, ,v t� t,�� t' t 1 b 1 l)'S°y+ dir' ,`,1! ,�"ti ^��1
6 r r'ltx1,3 ' }'�t44FJ4£,!WHERE'$ the Y , iy to t r ,,. i,'4 s s 1' p l ��„ +i•f 't.�(
�, ,, .� �)�" �,�s�°n��}-»,�''�, , , ,, , , �at�tibner� -"h�IiChaet Sullivan de�eiras,to buihl�'a a�"n'�1� �h` � ��` � �
,,;� }� ytam ',home�,at `a 6$',6th°;Street West` (Lot';,19, ,Block''e• Littl'',.''',.,i.:6,'''''lck10w 4,,t , �'„,;� i9,
,) ) k� r' ,p� r{t..,',,,,,,,,,+,,.
'� �'� � ;��,�u����;�,��-�;��oh'' Subdivision, and has.'';req`uested '�a'� varlance �°from the Mint�rt�i�, �,
, P�t1xP�, u�P✓t' , rq j fi iP l ,
�'c `4 "'t "i''� 'r' ' Base Flood Elevation,required by'`'the Ord. No, 79-62; `antl 'eta'� �r�i� �, F '° ' t
b�',3 6 ,`' .'",-"'"'WHEREAS the Board of Zonlnp Appeals has' held�e public`heer'in'{0 �;f: t ,� ,�i ; tit','
� r, �� r � rtit ► , ,) „ 4
�; ;, i � .'yes required by law; .has Xreviewed Petition FDP,O 84�V 7 In accordallcs;','..�` +1 � , ';,
t>6 with Section 18 (5),, (6) and ,'(7) and has made ,a finding'' �`,°",' ^ ,,~�`
► that they � r
'� l� t ! , f .,,,,.d,,,..- . a .,, >, � .� (pone t, fb,, �aFp r{ 'h „µ
=„v ;�r,antng; of,..thi:. petition compiles . with: the .. intent `and p,,,,.Q,.,.',
rpose. oft �b �� �..
',);17.: i ,. Ord, 79.62 as follows: ' �� � r . , 6 �� , r•s + ,A, (5) The 4 ' reduction from the Flood insurance Rate Map (FIRM) .", `' Ss4 ;
`'' 13' National Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD) requirement to 9' ':',,:t'',0,41,',0,,,,;,!,,,1��
NGVD is the minimum variance necessary, considering the
flood hazard, to afford relief, es the adjoining home on the
west Is at an elevation of 7.69' NGVD and the adjoining home
r sP t
,A on the east is at 7.95' NGVD, the requested variance will put x, aij„ic't
„, ' the elevation of the petitioner's home approximately` 1' above, , ' , �''�„�,.
them.
q1 ,, (6), The variance is Issued upon:
` ', (a) A showing of good and sufficient cause based on review ;� , 1A
of considerations contained in (7), following. ps
>6�:
y, { (b) A determination that failure to grant the variance would ”
'�, ' result In exceptional hardship to the applicant. ^',,^r,
t : ' (c) A determination that the granting of a variance will ,riot �istr,� 3 '
result In increased flood heights, additional,.threats`,to , "i
,, , public safety, extraordinary '
y, public expense, create „ !
nuisances, cause fraud on or victimization of the public, °}t`r "
P ► ,fidi,
p or conflict with existing focal laws or ordinances. q ^ ,;
t (7) In passing upon this variance, the Board of Zoning. Appeals
has considered all technical evaluations provided to it, ally ,.!
,� relevant factors, the standards specified in Ordinance � `
„ No. 79.62, especially those contained in Paragraph 18 (7) ,t,"°` �a
P 1
r t fprr a,�9',f'ti,i 4:p ,h
NOW, THEREFORE, BE aIT, RESOLVED by the Board of Zoning Appeals', ,>> r ' ;; 4 ,� ,'r,t
��, ''' that Petition FDPO-84-V-7 'is hereby granted subject to the followiri `�9 �` '�.
conditions: '',I,,
� �;. ,a� . yr I xC7�t�NaF4">ya §u�d��
t ;, t 1'. The variance shall be for the reduction of the Minimum Base Fladd,14,, , � �tt, }
o
" , ;,,' r4 j Elevation required by Ord Na. r , ''” ,� ,
Iii'y"�'� ' L Y 79 62 fr_.1m 1o.;.feet NGVD. ,.4 S�}eat°`'„,i tik� ' f� t :
., ' rrY t11 0,�t151 n {ii , NGVD f 4 t '' , • ', i4 A ',A,,, t t '° r r ,
tN', at �t u'r' �, q a ,!,NI'' ) t:ir i∎li r u 0 i, 'ku 1 1;, i � "r ',2
:i '`�' �; ` liii,Chief Administrative Official :shall mall,4,4.;cop y o �'� ' srt � ` . ) I
fir, „
%� n � 4 `r;•it4 tIot RO'tthe'' etftionet'': �, n� , t r, s'�,ntM; 1,ht , ;.a�fi' r ,, ;Y,-)'',.�
;,� `r, f Q'E)� y,'4°11,1k 4 ,,, +,';%,,,4t� 0. p t k, ,.: gams,. rid,return,rt,.iie,lpi44,4,,i' iii ',rt, -,
d�` 6;,..:'ti.., ,d �ANet, )!t.. . t h a,. , , 'L..R :�,, , h,..v, r t t 4„:i r ” 1,,6,, 1 i,,4)4, C .i t tai 0 i A-A , t V
s, ,ur ri ' , � , <' 1 s ilir onatltut dam li �41:,
i 4 " t �, tip �� p eoe � ►�ti,?�Serf�o �, fsaeg 'ap, � a • �� ',
�k�,+s�r���' '�, t�t�'a�,s„a � t �,f...;, �Arw �:ylV �iI 4L ;�9 ktlip'} +„�•�' ,� ij� �'1r �;, �, i}a. 1 4 �n'7+�n+`i�;;T t6 i. �� S'��,�� t.�. ��Ck"'�tk� 1 r ,,�
F}U It td, - 16.1-1.r ;x �}'v .,�,Ti.1v' 7 Id 1� Ji.: ',rRi �ti d"«TCi,l ti�l::4/;ii l' t°,`; t c tJ 1r d,.. P4 a4)?t 't 6 ' � a
,
+`-'� ,�a,'t '�A �£3�C°�i,.r'`. Dt r`,u 'n r�yti4f)y,.rr,tt �I teb 1� rp'�°, # it11,5044,,,?3,;e0,,,,',N�, .� iM t 7�r ,. �, �{`^� �;��,'�i"" j'p�l,r"�.i .,:�#�'. �P� c�f�t 'eti t� C
}+R U,,#`tt.:n a t'o�i k,,,,,s,r a'„,, F r4.s,, ,! 6'A tr.,t',!';ily;'.ti'q,,, ' h:)�`!Fr + f � ",,6`v4 l �',t t,, 9M',/,, ,, �r`5 cf., 1'Y'4'e 7 ,r,vp Y,}'3 ;�.. � 7 rr tit t �ser}!� „ x` �� ii,w��+�� r.$ F' � y�b� w��<7����tur•a § :x, f, t,� rt :M ..4t;� :k4 1, ,g'I ,r,� ,, ' ?ti+l/,,.r, r rl fhivtr V ,.} a,t�i �., �7"4V,tJ tY7i ' .?r 0 at r tl r1>}� of ,.py.1,tt9',yP ;'p4'r a l 4� W7j d',�,;,� i � x,.,tr r` ,.. •�. � ,},�t+,°�tK s�1..}d "4p�"''��' �i of Io1;N,i�e<td ).�?"N t�y.,ty 2�4, *d a t, rrt 4 F14'�.i� `�'�.' �btiihh +4, l� ',ti.t. Ylk�t„ '} 7 a( ,,,t,
e �':f M�kh'',io',,'i. y,�t„I4:. A'�iYy4 }�.'$Z , „) t,"4 V 41 .ti . , �3.,r,l;..S J ca��tr,s .:41 �' r , ,14r,lt (t e tr: ;' ft :i
i , {� 1a Y, 01a,r eiP ;0,,e0-110,'1:, a �1`V i �i1 ' .-; P,;;; > �',';, �, 6 t:# ,t;& t r
itiA.:1';',''''':::''.'''1/4.'31;t:4,ry 1`'t0 k l` -;? .''.i9:"+ fn 9A.47'.-tl ;'#;. SU5 , }t, ,rr, t6li`� 16f� ��x'3 t ''B t..i t :'1!lit��ia�xA441 1
P , , {s, :, A�x�fata.g-4k1'it'k t,,, ltr f'rf�u' 4; ' ''') s gr,4.P �""' `- SvT Ct ✓ .,'- tiW d f ,.
•
",;,.:?;,at §�; titn 4"' ?',,'44, " 4h, .. ,';;,v','"111;.,us ��� , X41 F �Cr ,�1k , gV , t z y ,■„ ,� i i9— - +?^k�p�.�u''q"jq"U,C ,�n „i Mj42 r 9ti 'i'b ".:4,..3?''''",' `S st ,.r
9i'
k* '' it
�I4P',, Any=applicant to Whom a •variance is granted, ,' ; t t,
v 'R1 s r ;A a , 9 '� c
fb;.',..1' i d rr k .I!!b,' �4
,�t;h,3x,,�� � ,s<hatl �i�e given written notice that;�whan a ' �k,",�s,4E�A�: ryry„��;;r R�
k ` I4:f,yw= ,4 , ;structure, is,permitted to be built w th d .,
ii ` a' ',:',./.';','''.:'.';'. i, the
'"r�'.1n 'M17�q�:tr d'' :J', fr i tF' ' °i,a :r:'.4'4'. �a,.ry p � � , t ,� i y r s 4i.:•I+ A y' I t�,' J4�'!i'�rh 'I� ^9.
4 , s�lr �4, >:�. ,� , t;.lowest abltabie�,fior• elevation below';;thrE,E,f�; <' 4' , , ,°'"rrr; , �>,•I an ..�: 1.,,I ,fs t #- t , (a ,;,;',":1••,+••."4+!.;.),'e-i",,',4.,:•:::,,,,a ,,, ,, ! ,,. �; 1 ,4k 4. ".s�1
kt
• , :r+ ",,t?, , ,, , +." base flobd,ee ator��the cost�tf flood incur a ,j ,l�c i ,,, a ,.�` 'Y�,� ':' ,
�,,,1$y X4vt 0�t §r� ,11,",. f f7 ,tr i "'Y �' ' - ', t, i. '.,,';,'..,,",,,,:,,,,..,;:',:',1,: A+k �' I s pp
� 1�.��! � �ft t ibi.k�8 �d °. i r � �+ ,t t '�' � k f f7 l;� �� �' ..$:�n �. t'9
}. :( IA , , , �, ,i ,�� ' ,, ,;ante„will be,ncotnmensurate with;the icreasd `';`f'4 '%,q :'' ,� 'S� 7:
M 1 f' 'r, ` „, risk resulting from. the reduced; lowest'habitable 'ti4'a ;k411''''';0'' Fw Iu r
'�{ fi?• Yy, '47,',i','.`,'
''^ t{1 'J 1,� ,,[ ! �pu��k ,,1 { t S.` f { ■i ,,,, f A a
y5IA i 9 I k,,°�”`1,A t , , �i� 7 s� if1�1':elevatldn.l,��f,,,,; r 1',� t ,,'+ ,r ay , t Srt ty,1Y .„ .'4 �P..
�.r: ,. tra� � L ',� r^t,( , f,+�;Y !� i ail � i 1�{ a) Sj��� i� ,F t��f�, �� �� t ,, ,F
« 14 r,'4'., . , Th . granting'.;of this"wariince,:has been` predicated;pr`incipall ot17��'" V.4.14");4,',4,',/,',,,,,`",,‘,
' `!+ '
'- " , t� , a the engineering; data and 'provided by .�a�14,4 �«
� 74��n�ti ' I p y the p�etlt�ona��s � � ` , ��' �p:� ,
• •,v a „ .and a •review of same ,with respect to the considerations re uiredAx ,
1. , ''^ " ' by�the Ord. No• 79-82: q , !, v`h�ph 7'. ,,4 �' .•y,^" i The granting of this variance by the Board of, Zonin A ealalr`, ',i�';A i ' ia`"
does not make or imply any assurances that the subject property>!:,..,;',-,1;1"..';',;,44�10,400",?'
1 p p /
�5.
, 'i :'' or structures are not subject to flood damages. « ,r.;
, d Further the granting'.of this variance shall not'create gq
tk
+� Ity on the part of Collier .County or by any officer or employee' rr, }c.•
,. thereof for any flood damages that result from reliance on this :'�, ;ra1, ,z1. "
� variance or any administrative decision lawfully made thereunder✓ '>,,'` � ;
petitioner p `
In accepting this variance, the etitioner assumes all res on ' ` �'
sibilit for any r .
Y y property damage resulting from its application. ,","q , t'
Commissioner
Holland motioned, seconded by Commissioner ` % ' ,
`� ' ' Voss for the adoption of this Resolution. Upon call for,;, �',
. the vote, the motion carried. ' ,: tt',
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS '4 ` �
,, . DATE: July 24, 1984 ,a ��
COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA ''; , t�y � '; ,
yWAyTTEST: BY � � r,r `,�._
1.414, iAM,• ,1 E eAN, RK �/ AN•��\ �k`
(:� � {'Ii�,
S • ,.: - e r
Y y
` , { 44 ,(0' t f�„� '''-
97 ' IAy�v�d s�Ti4 `
. +.ti}p,, I M "r` dr r '
",' "' ; I'1 12M �`tK' '
e‘,4.a y 1`i,!S ti -x',i t 6. f. pu yt �ti '",4 '4�,�1� y >
"t 4 ,�4 1�:,i,r , , y ',� 1 t.'3 VFl �iR ''.'7 , p�F4��:1� p@. t,
n \4 Vy� M } g i ," U +i$'d rN t
F a a (�W A4'''',1"‘r e „� i Fs fi,�u ,,'/,( k1'4a 3'41i � ),1 ]■
P , #�°�yJt pk b � A its 4 "
j� }+lY z.y,.",pg$, 'f.:...'''.,i' ,i.,a,. v i. ? , ! K;'dSln t I.� 4 y .,•.,.
,y,ZI r s 1 r �, x 4 Y +
t,, r ��4 <�?; Pliag/65oX ,,�s u� s 41. , , s
:,.4`;�`, t} �„Planning Dept, w ' � ��, `''n" $
4 q b'a� �ti� ,�1i r n , , ,( � � , ,! I q'� t i ✓/�� �5 �(3P �
� d)'1� 1�:�� ,r�4 S q� y S f t , ':,i 4�,r p,�:47,J L ' ,� ,�l�gy.���� �w��,��ly nj ,.
tiar"jQ )i r 'd 4 ,i7 ,! t. v;PJ7KK, z r :,I , , r r + , r r to, M 4'
, ���,++�Y s 9..i �,;�,{�f' � r , � ," ���r�'w ( ,"r �+ , � , �� I €r r�'f rk�d'� �,¢¢�� � t�{4i a}+l�9 r
,, ''lry$1 i r:,'''''''',''!,;:'''.
� , ! { '' ( irh tY'' r 7� 1(x.1, dqq,�,y 7 , PS
t� 1 ,}l,,e l <{f, 5t G,,., it , L�.t. ! , .I ', , S" i,i X1h4�{Ii ij � , ,P.y fi�l� , d
C , t� ,r ¢,, e ,, a � i1 t , i , ,:SH,�� � � 1 r 1, rf, t i 4 1 S,x i i ', i`�b �,�t 1, W i0O Y r s , ,%�y-4 ' C Y I "r� r( 4' y t 4r <'6iY4 Id :,r t,Ao x6o:o. - .u,'� t ���� � p� �,r a ,� c ,t', n yt P d � , ',a T d �4 �7 ,a, i ,� , s h A1I <J��'� i r ;7 f , PI {it + r U 6 1S,! 4;;T��y ,,,:,, §i,69 ; i ,,, ,,j e� li,1,,,„4 n„i,r r { 'it' , ,,r r, I c,Y '. r�. ° � �? 7 � 0 , I , nl �, t P f� 1,4,,,t,';''
�1�i�!J Sat ,4.
e'
,�o-a�' �
A