Loading...
Resolution 1991-258 RESOLUTION 91- I - . ,.-•,. `',-....-:A,•:.'i',..-.:4,,,,,.;,...,,liPtt..v,,,,V4,...,;.';',•:'•71'.:"-.-• .'' . 258 MARCH 19 ' 1991 •.,....-:,-, '..,:'''•-•-,•,,-,;ii,,,,:,_• '''';',...•'z',':,,,,,;',41V,'. .:;, ..::'•'.':".•, - '. ' q ;',:+!:`,?. .,,/,::,;i:''.:•:1`''''::..: ' -'' ' ' ' RELATING TO PETITION NO. PU-90-1 FOR PROVISIONAL USE OF PROPERTY HEREINAFTER DESCRIBED IN COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA. '''''..."-;:it';',P.',0•.`•2'4''''''_''''• '• . • ' •'‘'''' . .i.'-•,, ,:i.-!;:-.,,f,••-le,•*.••,'")... .;''','--•':',_,•;',...,'•'•;,: .- . • '-' ' •' .'.••:•,. WHEREAS, the Legislature of the State of Florida in Chapter •,,,,.".fige-,,,,;";;;zef,:=,,,,,,,,',',,,,.!•.,-;; ', , ' , ,.., 'Oirk•:Yi.:'-.;: ir.;: 7..'l246' Laws of Florida, and Chapter 125, Florida Statutes, has 11:if`'',;,-•:;•,.,,,•.',.•••:',:!••'•",',..;••-,:::•-•.-j,;',,,,:;.-...., conferred on Collier County the power to establish, coordinate `-''.:•-'41:•_,,ti..-•'6e'r...•,?:':',,,,,, ,•?,;;•••;::,,,.t. ,..,. ,• . . . enforce zoning and such business regulations as are .‘;',4•11•1'.1i::'(-'.., ,,,!,,,,,i,,•••:•:,-1,-•„:•?,,,,s:1,-.,;,_;.. , 41-,Vknecessary for the protection of the public; and '111.':ArPfl.:'-'.-:,:„::'''.-.':::--,- • WHEREAS, the County pursuant thereto has adopted a Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance establishing regulations for the ' '.'1,1'•,••?$'',-V,,i,•:',-;.- ''','-- '.'-,.- .-. . • - ,•........ zoning of particular geographic divisions of the County, among n V.,.Which is the granting of Provisional Uses; and . •••-y.,r2.,:',,Ail,•,..•,.„-,,,,,,•••,:,-,••:•••,,-,,• .,,.. - . - .•V''''''''''''''''":-•'• - ••• r WHEREAS the Collier County Planning Commission, being the ' . , • ,•:: . - • -is, r-..1.:::,- •-'., • -,- 4.w.,,,,, -.-.,, '., , • • duly . • ••• • • ').'1,,,''-' : ly appointed and constituted planning board for the ar ea Of*,..%:::::'.,•••-- .• ''''''''''''''':;•• ' hereby affected, has held a public hearing after notice as in said regulations made and provided, and has considered the advisability of Provisional Use "b" in an A-2 zone for earth . '''31:1'.1r;'''''''''''.'''''::: •::•''''''' ' • found . ' • ' .':: ' ' mining on the property hereinafter described, and has foun as a il;•1?lif':::::::::::::: matter of fact (Exhibit "A") that satisfactory provision and - _ , - - arrangement has been made concerning all applicable matters • . • ' , ,,, i'f',Iit.:,,S;•; ..;.'f,, ,,:f;,;,:;.,,.'',,);,',1,:i:,.''.,,..i.:., ' ., by said regulations and in accordance with Section ":-•,,4',. 7:',..W,;13aA. of the Zoning Regulations for the Collier County Planning • • -,,,,H, /.-,,,,-, iiii:•'•:,1,,,,,i-„,,,I;;I:'t1,:t',.:, , ,,. 4),:g-'-..i.:.i313-.-ion•, and c.''' ,;•'..,,-,:':'4'4°/.-=:,,,:,,;:;,•,'„....„„...,....„, .., 1.„.....,:,,,V,01"E., ,,,,--,',,i,','.,',-",',5,,,'-',-,,-.• . • ' .,.. ' : ,•:. ,,,, , ,,,:,-•:•,, -WHREAS, all interested parties have been given opportunity' : , l'.:i•P::: ::::::: :ci.,be heard by this Board in a public meeting assembled and the . •;•••:.: •.1",.,:i,'F•7'1...,:-, --;;., , , -,, : . : , ,,,,,,,,,,, Board having considered all matters presented. A . . .. ,- Y Now' THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, BY THE OF ZONING •' •.: ., .-'•':, '•-:.•-.•:,-:',,,„ • ',:t:',';''',,,f‘k„.••";Ii-i'•"•; :'•::•:,•';-;/".'.'•;::':„';','('•'•:',:'•••-•-• '• - • BOARD G 4iiliLs of Collier County, Florida that the petition filed by %;,-.41,1,,,•,;',,,•:..,:',.-'••,-;.•-.-',,,,,.:•..•,,,,..:.i .. . _ . .. - ... , • Wil1iam, C. ,McAnly of William C. MoAnly & Associates, -X•4'lg,,;-,;,_;;:-,•_;r:::,.;:,;; •,..•:r..•,..; - .• , , , , •,,,, ,,,, ,,:•,. .,;,,,t P.i.4representing College Properties of Southwest Florida, Inc. ,,•- :, ,,• -• -•,:,7,,,,,, • ■•••:':g,i4P-..,-,‘••'•:-,4'.f.,•:i:.;;,,-,;.:,-•',,.•:,•••,•-• ,' ' - • • ' , • . ' . - „•,• -‘:•:,,.;.'•,'.f;"•'' ,, ,,;,..•., , - . 14ith''•:respect to the property hereinafter described as: -. . • ,, ,,,,,, ,.,, ...H,•!,.a l'-ik,'"*`4;13!-ii:,.:',•-!P*:‘,......-4.;'"•:1';':••-•••;•• ---•9 . . , ..„ . . . . .. .- -,, Exhibit- "B" which is attached hereto and incorporated • _ : ' . ' ,. ,..::::•:1: rw •,' ••,..;,:::,:y7Atti,„::,:...,,,,,--.,tric ,14,'',,,,,. i by reference here n i':,-,•' '''4-.4',,,,:.,..-...: •;:,..,,,i.,,,..,',..,, ,,,,..,,,,‘,„„, . . . . ... . , . ..,,..„ ...1r,,:,-,.*•,,,?,,,,,,;,,,,,,,,,,,fg.,,,,,,,,..:,....., ,,,,,,,,,,„,-;,..,,,:',:':,,.1,,,,,:,;.,-_ ,' . ' GOO 1, 00 PAGE . ''X''''':,'''q;%''',:,,,-,f•-,:.,,,,,,.,,,.. :.',,:,,, ...i , , ;,•,::::.).:..-.: ,64-'''".'''''''''''' ''''''''" '' MARCH 19 1991", , �u s°'x f �. T � F,b }nd'the same is hereby approved for Provisional Use "b" of tlitiA, 2 'zoning district. for earth.mining subject to the ;11 .. i+following conditions: n ,- x �i; . r :. , ai'� � }j 5 `,t f �p`.,, y ` xhibit "C" which is attached hereto and incorporated a� , , ka ' a'`w A$ s ah' by reference herein.� 2 ° 1 `' BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution. be recorded in 'O4� the.,minutes.of this Board. ,�4�, G ra, Commissioner Saunders offered the e, i "�s" 'y r, 4 ,� ; { g _ foregoing Resolution and moved for its adoption, seconded by yi �a" fi ,Commissioner Shanahan and upon roll call, the vote r,,,r ' { : ,, xi trys 1,� !" r rut h ' '„9;� r AYES. , Commissioner Saunders, Commissioner Shanahan, Commissioner Hasse, , ",.,° §� ,'',,�=1./ `And Commissioner Goodnight '' �` ,NAYS: Commissioner Volpe E 9 Yy�• .y ' : f'tISENTFAND NOT VOTING .fl ',;: � .2.,„•,,', k T r .,, d(4,0 ,:p ABSTNTION: •none this 19th day of March , 1991. /� A X f aka J _ yr g % aY JET fi �p $,, �,t.,,H, BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS � » ' " + � COLLIER COUNTY, 'FLORIDA � ti ( �� BY:Pte, =a g P ,i .. PATRICIA ANNE,GOOD GH , C,,iAIRPERSON y ''r>aE$�{C. GILES', CLERK { n,,4/O i i (/�,Ow/�/ ✓ � o ED, AS• TO ORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY: ]jAY�j a%'' +�' rt#, �'' . `� A6.6t. Ctj')IL.4AFAA , I li t a��ra ' , OR N, . STUDENT• 1) �� 'k �SI.,STANT COUNTY ATTORNEY , �` o- y y f,,rr w ,f "F ' xx u l pit ,F.•1:'"::,,,J,•1 0.ti , 0 1 RESOLUTION „ 6 i n )2471 , r, • r t,, ‘MIIIMMEMMse ■ MARCH 19, 1991 ,,,i, r, , : ,,,,,,,v,,,,ti:iii*vi,:44;,i,t,i4,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,i,,,,,:,,,:;,,,,,,,,,.,,,,,,,, . . '- '', ,c P t,,,,,/,,, ' FINDING OF FACT BY . :'« ,• COLLIER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION -. T!,�- FOR '} }, A PROVISIONAL USE PETITION �z g 1 FOR 3 ;,-,441,r.,,‘..,,,,:,-,,,.4,..<lf � r*. The following facts are found: firA } l• Section 7.9 b.3)(b) of the Zoning Ordinance '44 "' authorized the prov siona1 use. ,,',',,'N,;,„, 2. Granting the provisional use will not adversely affect the public* interest and will not adversely affect '' } Property or uses in the same district other s ' f.. because of: or neighborhood , A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan: Complies with Comprehensive Plan f 1� Yes y No `1..' B. Ingress ress and egress to property and proposed w structures thereon with automotive and particular reference to traffic flow and control, andeaccess inncaseeofe, ��' " fire or catastrophe: sP Adequate ingt ess & egress nw Yes No ''' Affects neighboring properties in relation to , glare, economic or odor effects: ' .. No affect or Affect mitigated by Affect cannot be mitigated D. General compatibility with adjacent 1, properties and fi other property in the district: itti;:' Compatible use within district Yes V No fih —_-- r,, i Based on the above findings, this provisional use should, .1 with stipulations y recommended,for approval attached) (sk� o�t) "be '�,,, DATE:2 7 9 > CHAIRMAN: _ J' ;, , �� / Stt"�mya'i' Zf t ra a' +;�4,3"ly�^ � ,. '- t Rrfl..19r .;�I ,. .'�� �� � � �.sa Jir Yy5 . INDING OF PACT CRAIR MAN _ A 1p ':f :I y0yt„ -,r Y h f 1 S,', {� }� of �i ',..,',..Y.,',-1,,,v(,0„1,,,°1',1<'.3 ' 1 -� , ��''1A1ryY a -�C r wi PI )4 ! 5 fy 1C+ i j .�,,dY'ri 1 K^s .. ^`` , Exhibit "A" , ;.• • i ® COO PAGE 102 , ( ° «a- i G Co h : ` `f w h ✓ ! % ` Ai vf' � -f,, ■ ,a 4 e t <,,,,,;y!!',..1.: ,. ;.4!,,d `{+ c rr V',:,1]` '. MARCH 19, 1991 ' i" �1 f , F i'tio� '4-'1'::::'''''';',."' COLLEGE PROPERTIES OF SOUTHWEST FLORIDA, INC. . : . "SANDERS' PIT"• k},1 f,� '' LEGAL DESCRIPTIONS OF PROPERTY r < -,, `0 The following are the legal descriptions of the parcels of M ;- • land which comprise the property included under this • a' provisional use application and excavation permit 'k'" ,x� modification. 2+r^ 1 var ;. ,, OR Book 1313 - Page 2053: The Northwest 1/4 of the Southeast ' 1/4, less the North 1/2 of the Northwest 1/4 of the " `{ Northwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 20, "1' Township 50 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, . f� Florida; + ill ' b1F• OR Book 1376 - Page 800: The East 1/2 of the East 1/2 of the ,4 „ Southeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 20, Town- wr ship 50 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida; ,h ' OR Book 1389 - Page 0072: The North 1/2 of the Northwest 1/4 r= r of the Northwest 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section .20, $ ; Township 50 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, f � `,� Florida; ■ ,i t, „,: OR Book 1440 - Page 0602: The Southwest 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 20, Township 50 South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida; OR Book 1440 - Page 0603: The Northwest 1/4 of the Northeast ,' x 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 20, Township 50 l ` South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida; 9 'n OR Book 1440 - Page 0604: The Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of the Southeast 1/4 of Section 20, Township 50 ::, ' , , South, Range 27 East, Collier County, Florida; :j r �, ,g I' 000 PAGE EXHIBIT "13" *,' ■ � MARCH 19, 1991 < , . l i t f- ' {t .:,,,k0,', a , k J l Pert is � + � er�G i rf ,` p ev" k :ler a A' AGREEMENT #` b I g William C. McAnly of William C. McAnly and Associates, !,-, P.A., as owner or authorized agent for Petition PU- 90-1, agree � ' r to. the following stipulations requested by the Collier County . ,4 ° Planning Commission in their public hearing on February 7, <_ 1991. ,wk, :, a., The excavation shall be limited to a bottom elevation of . Q° T -20.5 feet NGVD. All disturbed areas proposed for lake '? } ` excavation shall be excavated to a minimum elevation of 0.0 feet NGVD. " �� , b. Off-site removal of material shall be subject to "Standard tea' Conditions" imposed by the Transportation Services in ' ' document dated (5/24/88 co �,iY (copy attached) . +`" c. No dewatering will be allowed as stated on the water tip : quality monitoring program report. 0 - d. All provisions of Collier County Ordinance No. 88-26 shall °`,'� be adhered to. However, staff shall have administrative o '.1, authority to approve minor changes to the excavation. DF4 , , e. Copy of South Florida Water Management District qk'f construction/operation permit or early work permit shall { t be provided prior to excavation permit approval. ' f. Monitoring of water quality shall be performed in accordance with the Water Quality Monitoring Program Report prepared by William C. McAnly & Associates, P.A. : 4 g. An additional bond in the amount needed to restore the a: off-site property along the northern boundary shall be T "" provided. Restoration will include total filling to natural grade and re-vegetation in a manner similar to ,5 surrounding areas. s. ; e h. A monthly report shall be provided to Project Review Services indicating the status of the discussion with the , owners of the property along the northern border. If the r4,'. problem is not resolved by January 1992, the project shall , be brought to Water Management Advisory board (or it's "�;;. successor Board) for discussion. . ',, 1,r s Mi, 3 Exhibit "C" -1 f � G A y OOO PAGE�O4 � Arl aAr4t ytqa x 1if lr `r = la� , t4 MARCH 19, 1991 }• ,i 70• yy .Sao u M N , I¢V,1 r wf r . f„v' 's a t a F a u i. ' This project is recommended for provisional use approval f , only, and does not absolve the applicant from complying• . .: with all environmental ordinances in effect at the time of ,, final development order approvals or from supplying 'a necessary information as required for any subsequent '' approval (i.e. , wildlife surveys, etc.) . In the event of ,,. disagreement between applicant and Project Review Services . ''A.. staff as to environmental stipulations, the Environmental „;' Advisory Council or its successor body shall make :, recommendations to the Board of County Commissioners as a >' part of the effected approval process. j. Documentation that the ten (10) acres (3 parcels) in the . Fakahatchee area owned by College Properties of Southwest i! Florida, Inc. , have been deeded to and accepted by the ° State of Florida, Department of Natural Resources, Bureau �, of Land Acquisitions, shall be submitted to Project ;, Review Services prior to the issuance of an excavation permit. ' F'' k. . . All conditions stipulated by Collier County Compliance liance .,, Services as a consequence of any past or present x violations including any unresolved tree removal ,k • violations shall be satisfied' prior to the issuance of an 9 d, ?fi.` excavation permit. �' 1. If the resolution of the incursion onto and excavation on a . the adjacent property to the north includes the filling and grading of said area (approximately 200/ x 2,000') , the petitioner shall re-vegetate the area with native , PA.:' species representative of the p p previous habitat. All three r-., - strata shall be planted. -4K,',.: ' � tl$ m. + Petitioner shall submit a littoral zone planting plan, to”•• ° '° ° Project Review Services for review and approval prior to: r',� excavation permit issuance. ` • n. . The Planning Services Manager may approve minor changes in { ` the location, siting, or height of buildings, structures, <:` and improvements authorized by the provisional use. Vr Expansion of the uses identified and approved within this x Provisional Use application, or major changes to the site r.,;;° plan submitted as part of this application, shall require '` the .submittal of a new provisional use application, and l�<, shall comply with all applicable County Ordinances in 02,k. effect at the time of submittal, including Section 10.5, i 'a; Site Development Plan Review and Approval, of the Collier County Zoning Ordinance No. 82-2. � r y 000 PA�r 105 ' kr -2- .: 144 iA'. i�x f' ti«t� / h dl .6.j 7.,+w a �s # "JY MARCH 19, 1991 + Y 1 , 1 +e -, . h a��7xn�,F'#N y3� /� t w� v �. pp Y: 'l fi pp}3SN "Cq+ 4�i t o , SY Y iN jar .y'C'4n At '�, i i;�p PE TION OR AGENT s + '` SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME' THIS `7"k.1‘, DAY OF I Lam . 1991. 5; � f NOTAR .... ..... .... •.... . .. ... .., V4t' '+i 1 . s rQTIt1Y PUQLSC STATE OF FLOAIDA NT COKKISSIOM EXP. APR T1#I'd�L ! " s'i r�� SEAL p0110t0 iKRU GIKEAAL ICS.L't0. a .'' Y. et MY COMMISSION EXPIRES ( 4.,...... 4/ ' rt k4 f n u [ f R I, 7 ' REPRESENTATIVE FOR CC 5.- SWORN TO AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS LJ DAY ...V._ ...rykci.., .f,', OF.. . 1991. 0 ci.,...c ...„,.1„...,...„, , , '+ NOTARY �, SEAL y% r°,fi Ml MOTs^Y PUOLTC STATE OF Pl01IDA £�s AMY,COMMISSION EXPIRES: #ST A e5a r• te32 � � r K" C 7x'f t L6'•a "' v} }tai'',.,;',/,:/)...,./1'4.,,,, 8J%tlEU I$U 6iatA�i. l*S. HAD. f * '�,y, 90-]. AGREEMENT SHEET k u y '�' YP } k ( �Y Y , r iu 000 r 106 ` 4 k �� u .3M 1. d ,# (Y�i �P . :,',,,$,,,,, t � t m MARCH 19, 1991 or 1,+ p4 k y r if 54 4t :x y a� . j 41 i 4 COLLIER COUNTY TRANSPORTATION SERVICES "STANDARD. CONDITIONS. EXCAVATION PERMIT APPLICATIONS INVOLVING , OFF-SITE REMOVAL OF MATERIAL ' The intent of these "Standard Conditions" are to provide excavation permit applicants a summary of conditions. which may affect their projects and which should be taken into consideration during all stages of project development: �.. . 1 . Haul routes between an excavation site and an arterial road shall be private with property owner(s) approval or be a public ' collector road built to standards applicable to handle the �;�` resulting. truck traffic. Where residential areas front ,": collector roads, appropriate turn lanes, buffer and bikepath shall be required as minimal site improvements and if recommended for approval, shall be so with the condition that ,!3, the Transportation Services Administration reserves the right to suspend or prohibit off-site removal of excavated material ; should such removal create a hazardous road condition or substantially deteriorate a road condition; such action by the � h : Transportation Services Administration shall be subject to ..T; appeal before the Board of County Commissioners. ., 2. Haul routes utilizing public roads shall be subject to road : maintenance and road repair or an appropriate fair share by the 014:4 permittee in accordance with Excavation Ordinance No. 88-26 and fV, Right-of-Way Ordinance No. 82-91. 4,■ 4 ;rjt ,_ 3. Off-site removal of excavated material shall be subject to . ., Ordinance No. 85-55 (Road Impact Ordinance) . A traffic and road impact analysis shall be made by the County to determine ,.. the effects that off-site removal of excavated material will r have on the road system within the excavation project's zone of influence. If appropriate, road impact fees in accordance with Ordinance No. 85-55 shall be paid prior to the issuance of an excavation permit. ve,3 4 The Transportation Services Administration reserves the right to establish emergency weight limits on public roadways affected by the off-site removal of excavated material; the ' procedure for establishment of weight limits shall be the , presentation of an applicable resolution before the Board of County Commissioners. Should weight limits be instituted, the permittee shall be responsible to implement measure to assure • that all heavy truck loadings leaving the permit's property 1!,. conform to the applicable weight restriction. 5. The Excavation Performance Guarantee shall apply to excavation ' Y operations and also the maintenance/repair of public roads in accordance with current ordinances and applicable permit stipulations. 9�.�. ® COO 107 PAGE � d 'G+1A N st!`1 I +?Y` Y i' .z N•Nt;K<�.ia r r•..y • A‘ n• 4.! 4. ,y n °• �� �� s t,• act e ( v `14.:4',.,-''t.04 y C, .,m 4(.,„,,,,, k 0 ' ydµ t . i' o ,..., ,,,,,,,"',;$'1,,'4,1'1,4'..'1'.-'''', . . MARCH 19,, 1991 ',, ti r f* � r ty t p y{�.1�' yY( � -,-?;‘,/,,?,,,,t, a+ry�. k r�' � a e ti '� � t. r , na, dN .. s „, 2,,,,,,!,,,,i,,,r, N ' 6. Based on soil boring information per Ordinance No. 88-26, a , . blasting permit may be appropriate. Should a blasting permit 44f 'i' application be submitted and should residential areas exist r,. � 4 within one mile of the excavation site, the County reserves the 4 .., 1k right to deny a blasting permit based on concerns for off-site t' „ impacts from blasting at an excavation site. Should a blasting x`i; fr}r, permit be considered and approved, the minimum conditions of ?;- ' approval in•addition to conditions per Ordinance 88-12 are as follows: ' �, A. Structure inventory/monitoring and applicable : property owner release as required by the County ' . ";, Engineer. B. Security bond applicable to private ' property damage )1r4,',”' acceptable to the County. , a,; : C. Control of size/depth/number of charges per blast by the County Engineer. k D The right of the County to suspend and/or revoke ';..'.1,;''' '''' ':' . blasting permit authority should be determined that blasting activities are creating unacceptable ` - off-site conditions either in terms of private ' property damage and/or related physical effects of �• 4 ' , blasting operations. 4 i '1f, �' 7. No excavation permit shall be issued until receipt of a '4.1''': release from. the Transportation Services Administration #,f applicable to proper mitigation of off-site impacts, , ` meeting of applicable provisions of Ordinance No. 82-91, '%t1pr Ordinance No. 85-55, and Ordinance No. 88-12. i ns r ,., r f Ai 7;' ,0x r doc. "2636 94 ' v; , Refer,ence to letter of 5/24/88 ,��'� s' r 'r Revised 3/90 . ,,,",,4,A,,,' , ,� ¢ ' SRS/mh to J�/y Y &S '...'"1,,,,,O. 'µNt t r . l''',,,,,,47 .,,i4,'',..41.,''‘,;;;,' zt k„�t , x1 ,1 .:, , �,, 4 � t 1 t tn� $�I e \ v ,, .° '4, , i c t fray th.. a° 'x ” i ix A z a d h Si1ii 4 y rrr +f" ,rt" '' a r., : yf ! 0Co PAGE l ag , 3 „7-..„ gzr :: 'it•Vo4Wi'21 :.ttb.'45,. '''1tp. •rAK” 7! xry7. :4 ..1.{ --.-1—.7'.:*.='. _.—.N :.:.tea..e r...R. —..:—r•rM"..M1' .'t . 1...